TransparentMammoth

Mammoth Lakes Recreation · 2020

Mammoth Lakes Recreation Special meeting

· recording 2 hr 25 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

291 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:03 Okay, we're good to go. Oh, thanks, Angie. All right, we're all here, so why don't I, I'm going to call this special meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board of Directors here August 11th, 2020 at, what do we got? 5.05 p.m. to order. Angie, why don't we do roll call to start with? Was that me? Yeah. Yeah, present.

0:36 Thank you. Board Member Wasserman. Mr. Wasserman. Okay, we've got some audio problems, but I can see him. Board Member Dugan. Thank you. Board Member Taft. Here. Board Member Ferney. Here. Board Member Schaubmeyer. Here. Secretary Bankson. Okay, I can see her treasurer page. Here. And President Albright. Here. Thank you. All right.

1:14 Start off with a thank you to all of you. I know everyone's life is maybe as crazy as it's ever been and that your dedication to make time to join us here on each one of these special meetings as we work through these issues is inspiring, commendable, all of the above. Good work, team.

1:38 We'll move into public comment. Angie, did we have anybody there in suite Z or emails come in? I have no one here and I have not received any emails at this point. If that was to change during the meeting and we have any public comment, by all means, please let me know and we can, I think it would be fine to

2:08 to interrupt us if that was the case. Thank you. A couple orders of housekeeping to start with and that was we had minutes from both our July 7th and regular scheduled meeting and then if I'm not mistaken that one was a regular meeting? Yeah. And then the special meeting on the 23rd you received in your board packet

2:38 minutes from those two meetings. I would entertain a motion on each one of those, probably individually, to approve those minutes. I will motion to approve, Secretary Bankson. Do I have a second on that? And let's focus on the July 7th one first. I think for clarity's sake, we should do one at a time. I'll second that.

3:15 I have Wasserman as a second. So that was Bankson and Wasserman as a second. Any discussion, comments? Very well captured. Seeing none. All right, cool. Why don't we do a roll call on that? Angie? Board members Hauser? Yes. Board member Wasserman? I have to abstain because I wasn't at the meeting.

3:47 Okay, you can go ahead and stand, but just going forward, please know that you can review the notes and you are allowed to vote on them if you choose to do so. I prefer to abstain since I wasn't there. Absolutely. Board Member Dugan? Yes. Board Member Taft? Yes. Board Member Ferney? Yes. Board Member Schaummeyer? Yes. Secretary Bankson? Yes. Treasurer Page? Yes. And President Albright?

4:19 Yes. Thank you. All right. So motion passes 8-0 with one abstention. And let's do the same for the special meeting, minutes on the special meeting from July 23rd. Motion and a second, please. Motion to approve. Miranda? I'll second. And that was Heather, I think.

4:53 With Eric Wasserman on the background. And any comments on that one? Questions, concerns? Seeing none, let's do a roll call, Angie. And we're going with Rhonda for the motion and Heather second? Yes. Thank you. Board Member Souser? Yes. Board Member Wasserman? Yes. Board Member Dugan? Yes. Board Member Taft? Yes. Board Member Ferney?

5:26 Yes. Board Member Schadmeyer, Secretary Bankson, and I did get a visual on Heather, Secretary Bankson. Yes. Treasury Page. Yes. And President Albright. Yes. Thank you. All right. And so that passes 9-0. Excellent. Thanks for getting us through our housekeeping really quickly.

6:00 Next up on our agenda is I'd like to do an update on our Town of Mammoth Lake contract negotiations. And we've met a few times since our last special meeting on the 23rd. And so wanted to keep the board abreast of those.

6:27 Proceedings. And I sent out, and I'm going to endeavor to share that document right now, testing my Zoom skills. And take a second, share screen. Well, actually, it's not the one I want, because that's the email. What I want is, okay, this is what I want, so.

7:14 We're going to go share screen, not email. Come on, Albright, you can do it. So to start off with, and Heather and I and Catherine will kind of tag team on some of these, but we have met, let's see, since our last meeting three times, Heather, I think? Yeah, I think since, what, since July 23rd? Yeah.

8:16 Everything is kind of fuzzy, but it's been two or three times. Yep. And so there's been further clarification on a couple of areas, and we've really used as a group two documents to kind of guide our discussion and kind of document it so that we can share it with you. And John Wentworth has been kind of our

8:45 our scribe keeping track of these things. And as we've worked through each of the different items, what we've come up with is some key agreements. And the first document, and the one that I have on the screen right now is the key agreements document. And where that started was with some of the original

9:13 MLR, Town of Mammoth Lakes contract documents and some of the things that at the organization's outset we were seeking to achieve. So we were either confirming and or adapting some of those. And what you'll see on this is within each area there are some key agreements.

9:39 And I got to say, I actually am just catching like right down here. I should move this because I'm going to edit. Well, I don't have editing capabilities right now. Where you see it says here, proposed key agreement on this third one. Actually, you can see down here, we actually agreed on Friday about that. And it turned yellow, which was

10:11 When we came to an agreement, it was supposed to also get this red lettering here, but, you know, little formatting things. So, as you can see throughout this document are all the areas that we have reached agreement with, with, you know, our associates, you know, with Bill and

10:35 John and with Dan and even Andy Morris are the town's legal advice as we've worked through these. And so, you know, what we've done is you can see these key agreements were just a starting place for us. And we'll kind of go through those rather quickly because what became more

11:05 pertinent to us is the second document that is the funding priorities, which will really become the foundation for, you know, our contract. And it may even have a little bit more legalese as Andy was involved more with the funding priorities. And so with the goal being that each one of these key agreements in yellow

11:33 that ideally where we're going to go next is these are all the concepts that would be in the contract but then the last part of our negotiation will be well with each one of these what is the what is the kind of the the time the build time for each one of those and coming up with the you know the the value of the contract and

12:02 So we still have more work to do, but we thought this was a great place to make sure we weren't going off track on, you know, what the deliverables and the foundation of the contract would be, what us as MLR would be focusing on to deliver to our partner's client at the town. And so why don't I go back? Heather, anything to add to that as kind of a starting point?

12:32 No, and I know it's been a process, and I know it's hard for people to kind of understand the different meanings, how this all came about, but that it's been a lot of conversations between all parties about expectations and what people are unhappy with and what people would like to do moving forward and a couple different changes. So I'd like any feedback that anybody has, and I know that people maybe wanted to see a finalized

13:00 I guess report at the end of this, but there's a process to everything as we all know in this world. And so we're in the middle of this process and we're getting down to the nitty gritty and there'll be a lot more at the same time we were doing an evaluation while we were doing this contract. And so we're trying to balance both things at the same time. So I just want everybody to kind of know that.

13:20 Any feedback would be greatly appreciated if you think that we're off on any aspect of this. I think one of the biggest things that is different on our contract is that, one, we obviously said we're going to keep the ED, we're going to keep the NGO aspect, but funding our ED is something that's different from before, and I think that's an important thing for people to notice. Great. Thank you. Heather, Catherine, anything you wanted to add as a

13:51 Primer, before we start getting into the details? No, I think you guys really did a nice job of laying it all out. Like I said, I worked with John to kind of transcribe everybody's feedback, including the board feedback from the last time we all met about this. So I think some of your key comments about, you know, funding sources and our future and our direction were really helpful in steering some of these ideas.

14:20 Thank you, guys. Yeah, exactly, Catherine, and that we've been kind of, you know, meeting with the town and then coming back to you, seeing you as the board of MLR, and this back and forth, though, laborious, maybe is the right term, is what we felt like was the best way to bring us all along on this.

14:48 kind of adventure and get to a place where we're comfortable with, you know, really building the foundation for a relationship well into the future. And maybe I'd say that as a last part, I have been impressed, you know, with John and Bill and the staff at the town, Dan and others, the desire to

15:17 You know, kind of hammer this out and find something that can be a foundation for us to continue to work well into the future. And maybe, you know, at the start, I wasn't so sure that was desired, but I have certainly been convinced of that otherwise. And as a as a to help us through this tonight, I know I see John joined us and Dan's on. So by all means.

15:46 If MLR board members have a question, comment or concern, those guys are here to help us kind of work through that. And, you know, so don't hesitate to, you know, ask for their, you know, their insights or feedback if something, because Heather and Catherine and I won't hesitate either because we've been working through this, but no.

16:14 You know, there's a lot of little details to try to work through. So like I said, you know, we started from this first document with partnerships, development of new products and services, innovation in existing programs, fundraising, leadership advocacy, implementation and management, organizational structure, and

16:43 I thought there was one more, and funding, you know, were the eight things that we, you know, from a historical perspective started with and found our key agreements. Rather than, you know, and I'll ask the board, you know, your opinion. I know we didn't get this to you until, you know, just yesterday, but maybe I'll start off with, rather than going through these line item by line item,

17:12 You know, I'll take them, and if there's any questions about each section, section one partnerships, any questions, comments, or concerns there, and we'll kind of do that with each one of them. I think that'll be probably the most expeditious way to work through this. And I think some are just going to be a raise your hand or speak up, or we're going to move on to the next one, eh? Yeah, exactly. I think that's right, Heather.

17:42 Just for clarity's sake, if I understand correctly, the idea here is to take these key agreements and eventually roll them into what's referred here and what was in the past referred to as either Exhibit A or B, a list of deliverables. Yes, and we've kind of called it funding priorities, but...

18:08 You know, and I'll, that's a great point of clarity that we need to nail. So maybe I'll, I'll go to Bill and, Bill and John, you know, that, that's exactly right. The funding priorities are the deliverables. Is that, am I off base? Go ahead, John. Craig, I can, David, that's exactly the, the idea. And the reason to have two documents for the MLR board.

18:39 The key agreements, starting with 2015, the legislation that enabled and made MLR possible with some changes and some advice going forward. And then a list of priorities for the town to fund, that the town desires to fund is the second document. And that becomes the baseline for an Exhibit A. It's important to note that we

19:06 In our discussions, we did not talk personalities. We talked positions. We talked capacity. We talked structure, architecture, if you will. And we did not talk about money in any specific meaningful way. We wanted to really get to a framework for a contract and an agreement. And so the MLR discussion and deliberation this evening is really on that framework.

19:34 Those priorities to fund. And if that, if this version or any modified version comes back to the town, the town would take that to the town council. Could maybe get to the town council meeting next week, if not in September. And then MLR and the town, depending on the outcomes of those two efforts, would sit down and memorialize all this into an agreement. Thanks.

20:02 And I think the other part is that through this process also, it's important that Dan and Bill and John are here, more so John and Bill, because at the end of the day, they're the ones who have to go back and then take this and sell it to the council. And that's why we need to make sure that we understand that maybe they don't understand all the intricacies of what we're going through. And we want to make sure that everything's very clear. And so it's something that they can go back and sell.

20:33 Yeah, great point, Heather. Thank you. Bill, anything to add to that? No, just that we have not got into the nitty-gritty yet of the financing, and that this year, moving forward, is, you know, all going to sort of be up in the air until we know what's going on. And we understand that right now, because of COVID, because of the circumstances with the town and their fundings right now, we know that this is going to have to be revisited.

21:01 We'd had that conversation on some of the financials in January of 2021. And we're going to have some deliverables that we're going to have to come up with on our end. Is it okay that I put that all out there right now? Because that's the conversation we had. Yeah, thank you, Heather. Because, you know, I'm with Bill. I've been chomping at the bit to get to the numbers. And I appreciate that.

21:31 Before getting to there, you know, we got to be really clear on, you know, what we're trying to achieve and that the nitty gritty of the month of the dollars and cents, though important, shouldn't, shouldn't be our starting point, I think is maybe a way to put it. And, and so, but we still have some on both sides for both the town and for

22:00 MLR, you know, there's some financial realities there that will certainly need to, you know, be addressed on both sides. So with that, going through the key agreements, any question or comments on partnerships, I'll spare you me reading the screen for you.

22:35 Hearing none, how about development of new products and experiences? I like what it says there. This might be more directed for town council, but speaking of products and experiences, those new green street signs going up in town, I don't know if this would fall into that category, but that never made it by us. Personally, we have all these nice fancy signs and wayfinding for everything else, and putting those green street signs into town, I think, is just...

23:08 Not a good idea, but we could revisit that when that becomes something to talk about. Okay. Any other comments or thoughts on key agreement under development of new products and experiences? Greg, it's Rhonda. Yeah, Rhonda. I do have a question down in the third bullet point where it's...

23:39 I'm sorry, I'm reading from a Word document, so I may be out of line. It's actually, and now I see the funding mix for ESSRC would stay the same regarding Measure U and Gen Fund dollars. Can you define the Gen Fund dollars? Because this is referring to the support of Mono County actually hiring this position. So can you define those?

24:07 What you mean by Gen Fund dollars, is that Town of Mammoth Lakes, is that Mono County? With the Town of Mammoth Lakes, it's talking about the Town of Mammoth Lakes. His funding is a three-part funding. Dan can probably speak to it better, but it comes from Measure U, it comes from the Town of Mammoth Lakes General Fund, and it comes from the County's General Fund. Okay, so could we have the language identify all three? It's going to stay the same. Nothing's going to change on it.

24:37 And this is all inclusive of the car, the computer, the gas, everything, when I talk these numbers, benefits, salary, et cetera. 20K comes from the town general fund, 75 comes from Measure U, and 50 comes from the county. And from what I understand, none of that was going to change. Thank you. That was the understanding that has been, and if anything has changed, I'd love to hear otherwise, but that's how it was explained to us in our last meeting. But we all know everything's very...

25:11 fluid these days. So if anybody hears anything different, please let me know. That is the information that we provided to the county and they're in their budgeting processes right now. They wanted to confirm that as well. They're looking at other funding potentially for actually project on the groundwork that that would be in addition to the funding of the person in the core program support for that person. So I think it's maybe fair to say, Dan, that as

25:41 This will evolve as the three entities work through their respective, particularly the town and the county through their budgeting process, right? Correct. Yeah, we're waiting on the county at this point. There'll be a portion of this, obviously, that's already spent and out for the current process. My guess is I think they're going to complete their budget process in September, so this will probably be an October 1 transition date.

26:08 Have a new MOU between the town and the county for the funding structure. Okay. Great. Thank you for that detail. If no other product, questions on new products and experiences, we'll move on to innovation in existing programs. Any questions? I have a question or maybe just point of clarification on this one. I feel like I understand and appreciate the spirit behind it.

26:42 By Mammoth Trails, do we mean the existing Mammoth Trails group that meets annually in the library? And the second part of the question would be this piece about serving as a resource, providing localized technical knowledge, fostering trail-related stewardship. That doesn't, I think, as the next, I think that description doesn't match our existing Mammoth Trails meetings, so I'm just wondering kind of what the vision is for that. It seems like a neat idea. I assume that's different from our

27:13 MTC. I don't know, Dan, John, Bill, you guys want to clarify what your vision is on that one? Yeah, if I could just, that language, David, that's quoted in there, some of the Trail System Master Plan, which, you know, was written a while ago. It's a, it's, the purpose of having that in there is, it is a program identified in the town plan that's been funded through Measure R so far, but it's certainly, it's a baseline that could be expanded in,

27:43 to grow from. And I think it's important to point out the semantic confusion between Mammoth Trails, which is a confederation of user groups. It has a charter, it has a variety of different tools that could be used as a baseline to grow from, but this should not be confused with the Mammoth Trails Committee that deals with the allocation of Measure R funds for trail system projects. They're two completely different things. Yeah, and I understand that.

28:11 But I know, and you know, because I've been at it for a long time, but I think that from the public standpoint, that's confusing. Sure. And then I just, I wonder if somewhere in there, if when we, as this, as this evolves into a real deliverable, if we wouldn't want to call out a little more about, you know, doing public outreach and advocacy for the trails program. Just, I would just say that point, I think is a really good one.

28:38 And we just want to flesh it out so that, you know, whoever's charged with delivering that has a real solid understanding of what that deliverable means. Sure. That's good thinking, I think. And for me, just to add something in there, the original put in the trails master plan, there's an awful lot of groups from equestrian to ski joggers to snowmobilers to motorcycle groups that really haven't been included in that.

29:10 consortium of trail users that is, you know, brought together once a year, even though they've been invited. And I think they just need a little help to get there so that we have a solid group that is working together instead of at odds with each other. So that's just sort of a dream of mine going back, you know, the 40 plus years I've been dealing with land management issues. Yeah, I mean, I think that's a dream we all share. So let's try and articulate it specifically so everybody knows. Yeah.

29:42 That was my question as well. Did you identify any other organizations or groups because in this, because it's talking about existing programs and then it just brings out these two. So if there's others that you want to identify, it sounds like this would be the place. Excellent. All right, moving on to the fundraising number four. A little bit more where, you know.

30:17 The rubber meets the road. And frankly, where we've had our, as we've talked about many times within our board meetings, where we've had some of our struggles. And so any thoughts, questions, comments about that section? Craig, I just have one question. In the second bullet point, MLR is under no obligation to provide

30:51 Its own overhead costs. Does that include any staffing costs, including our ED? So I would jump in there for a second, Craig, because this is something that we have to figure out as our little meeting group because it's not in alignment with itself. That bullet point that you're under no obligation to provide its own overhead costs. Yet under item seven, the first bullet point.

31:25 That MLR will require, will require, recruit, hire, and fund its own executive director is sort of at a cross point to that. So that's something we all have to work on still. And if I could just speak to that, Tamara, this goes back to the policy document that the town council adopted, I believe, back in 2015 that we started from, where it was sort of built into MLR from the beginning that, well, this is nice and you guys are going to do great things, but

31:56 You have to go out there and in some vague way fund yourself. And that was never clearly defined. It wasn't a known thing. So I think that the group that was meeting wanted to get to clarity on that point and to say that moving forward, as we construct an agreement, the town will pay for the services it desires. And we'll figure out a way to do that just

32:22 Cleanly, efficiently, and directly. And we get to discussion about the ED and some town needs as well on this document. The lane for an executive director is clear and clean for MLR. I guess then my question is, what is included in MLRs under no obligation to provide its own overhead costs? What is included in overhead costs?

32:49 And that's when we get to discussions about contract and funding, whether MLR is setting up positions as being hourly, billable hourly is like a, you know, with a loaded cost or whether it's done on a salary basis, that gets into the technical minutia of how money's going to move. But I think we just wanted to take that kind of vagueness that was institutionalized at the beginning, just take that off the table, just not worry about that anymore.

33:18 And a little bit to say about this also is the discussion was is that, you know, we are a nonprofit. We're also an NGO. So in doing that, right, there are services that we house with the town. That's the Measure U and Measure R is the big part of it, right? So what is the value of that? And that's the part that we are sitting down to identify. What is the amount of time?

33:45 that it takes for us to execute the town's expectations to continue the funding, right? So what is that value? And that's what's being identified. And that's where there's going to be some harder discussions. But with the nonprofit aspect, most nonprofits raise their own funds, including that for the ED. So we kind of have this dual

34:13 And so I think we're trying to figure out how do we stay as the NGO and also have our independence. And we have been funded by the town in all aspects for now five or six years. And they're looking at the ROI. And if you look at some of our spreadsheets, we're like, okay, we can understand where there's maybe some

34:41 Things on both ends that should have been discussed sooner before now. I'll just be honest with that. But let's put this into a little bit more than nitty gritty. Let's get it. Let's actually put it down in black and white so that there's not so much vagueness. Does that help? Well, it does. And again, that's what I'm trying to clarify on the vagueness. What are we as an organization responsible for fundraising for? And what do we not have an obligation for fundraising for?

35:08 That's, again, being a bullet point of no obligation to provide overhead costs. Does that mean office space? Does that mean, you know, I'm not exactly sure what's included in overhead costs. You know, to some degree, you could say salary is not included in overhead costs. We're talking about brick and mortar or those types of things. That's for me to understand what's the clarity.

35:30 What would be overhead costs? And that would be using accounting services, using the, does that include Andy, does that include attorney services? Right, attorney services. Is that including the benefits for our ED being able to run through? Those are very strong conversations that I'm trying to get to too right now. Okay. And I totally agree.

35:55 And I think that these are the notes that we need from you guys. So the more input, the better. Okay. I really appreciate the question, Tamara. And I feel like having seen the evolution of this over the years, I can see where this is coming from. And I hope that as we get to a final product and we're looking at a contract language that we can clean it up to the point where we don't really have to say a lot of this stuff where it's really, you know, these are the services rendered, this is the cost.

36:25 And beyond that is up to MLR, what MLR wants to do as far as its operations or its leadership or its, you know, the logistics of delivering those services would be up to MLR. And as long as those services are delivered as per contract, then, you know, it's not, the town doesn't have to worry about how that's done. And that's what I don't want to make assumptions that we say, well, included in overhead costs is legal fees. You know, that can be pretty substantial.

36:54 If we didn't specify that that's something that the town should cover. So just I would want a little more clarity as to what we anticipate would be covered under that obligation. So just my two cents. We would like 10 cents. Everybody throw their two cents in place. Give me 18 cents. 18 cents worth. But I think I just want to highlight the point, David.

37:26 made because I think this is where we're trying to head is that if we can make it clear on the deliverables and what the cost to provide those deliverables and Tamara, I get your thing because all costs could be considered overhead costs. Right, right. What are we shoving in there? And then I don't want MLR to be responsible for things that we weren't prepared for. Yes.

37:56 As a board to say, hey, this cost falls under you. That wasn't under an overhead cost. And then all of a sudden we're responsible for, again, some, you know, legal fees or a salary or even, you know, an operating space. Those could come under and they could be quite substantial. They'd cut into our budget, so. And that the goal of making this clear is that that's how we have developed a stronger

38:26 Client, contractor relationship with the town. But then John was saying over to the side, we have MLR as an independent organization. When we want to go do things outside the realm of servicing these items, we have the freedom to do that, but we need to fund those things. And so it's how we're trying to get to the point where

38:54 We have a strong relationship that is very contractual with the town, but then keep our independence. And it's because through Bill and others in the town council, because of how we've had it set up in the past, which is, John and I had a little bit of this conversation at one point, which is

39:23 We're learning as we go. And by having it so broad, it's created the opportunity for people to feel like they don't know what value they're getting. And so this is our, in this 2.0, 3.0, whatever version of MLR we're at right now, as we update, we're getting clear so that we have less of that ambiguity that people can

39:53 Feel like that they're, they don't know where the money's going to or going for. And, you know, really trying to listen to our partners because, you know, that is their concerns. Now, they're listening to us that we want to be, have some independence and nimbleness that the town, you know, doesn't have or can't provide our organization. How do we get both those things?

40:23 I don't know. That's where I've made some sense of this. And I really appreciate your comment. That is not clear enough to get that objective. Right. It's at least not clear enough for me. Maybe it's clear for everybody else. But I think just defining it a little bit more so that we don't have that ambiguity moving forward would be helpful. Tamara, I totally agree. I think that...

40:55 The clearer this language is written, the better things will be in the long run. Okay, thank you. Okay, note taken. To reiterate Bill's point, you know, the mention later on about MLR, you know, again, there's sort of a prescriptive note about MLR hiring or recruiting or... So trying to, you know, extricate those...

41:25 Those management issues from the services to be delivered would be, I think, an important goal. Yes. Great. Any other comments, insights on that? Great. I'll move on to leadership and advocacy. It looks like anything there, maybe? Implementation and management. Yes, Rhonda. Hi.

42:25 I think it's just one word, but, oh, I lost my place. No, never mind. I have another question as we get further down, but that's fine. Thank you. Well, it makes me realize that, you know, again, there's a phrase here that seems like kind of legacy language and that has to do with all that we were just talking about, maintains the capacity and initiative. Again, that's sort of prescriptive language. It'd be cleaner.

43:11 Easier to understand if it just said, you know, MLR agrees to take advantage of opportunities as they arise or, you know, we could be much more specific in terms of what MLR should be looking to take advantage of. And then the maintaining the capacity part is, that's on us to make sure that happens. That makes any sense? Yeah. Minor point. Minor point, David, and this is,

43:43 to kind of share where I guess my concern or curiosity lies is as we said at the outset each one of these key agreements kind of leads to the funding priorities and then there is and we'll get to it when we get to the next document but how I envision it is that

44:11 Something like that has, what does it cost for us to take advantage of opportunities? That is like next to impossible to put a price tag on, it seems to me. And that's, those are the red flags we need to see because that's where we will create kind of animosity or

44:36 In between our groups, because we'll think we're taking advantage of an opportunity as it arrives, but the town's going, we have no interest in that, and those are the things we have to avoid. Yeah, I think that's exactly right, because when I read that and I hear, you know, hey, we should be, you know, jumping on every opportunity to write a grant that we can, and some of those grants will flow directly to the town to perform work, and some of those grants would.

45:04 would flow to MLR to fund operations. And, you know, how do you prescribe that on the front end in a contract so that everybody feels like, okay, you know, MLR is jumping on opportunities that benefit the greater good. Just, you know, again, the more specific we can be, the more we can put metrics to things, the better off we'll be in the end. Okay. Well, let's keep...

45:31 that in mind as we shift to the funding priorities because that's where it should have a finer point to it if that is indeed going to be the document we use to get rid of ambiguities. Organizational structure, any comments, thoughts there? We did quite a bit of

46:01 talk in this area, and I think as we outlined in our last update with you, you know, the town brought forward the idea of a chief recreation officer and a concept of them bringing on people that would fit another need that they have, but that, you know, we could potentially tie that to

46:31 assisting MLR. There's quite a discussion there, so I wouldn't be surprised if you guys have some questions about that. Is that what you're talking about in the second proposed agreement that starts town will make available to town employee? This whole paragraph means nothing. I don't understand what you're saying. I understand that there's

47:01 Exhibit A and exhibit B to be determined, but I don't understand what you're trying to say as far as the town employee. Can you describe that a little bit more? I might call on Mr. Wentworth to help us through that. Yeah, so Rhonda, this is a very important point because as we've all embarked on this

47:36 This commitment to MOR and to really getting our handle around outdoor recreation in Mammoth Lakes, we've learned a couple things over the last couple years. We've learned from the experience of the trails manager, who's originally intended to be an employee of a nonprofit, who it was determined it made a lot more sense for that employee to be an employee of the town. This means that when that position is talking with the Forest Service, it's speaking on behalf of the town.

48:04 That's proven to be very effective. I think the other thing that we've run into is the reality of prevailing wage law in the state of California. And I think from the town's perspective, from a structural point of view, in order for the town to really deliver on the infrastructure that is necessary to create a sustainable, a truly sustainable recreation program in the town of Mammoth Lakes.

48:31 The lead body for that effort needs to live within the town of Mammoth Lakes. For legal reasons, it needs to be, we need to be, we can't be implementing projects with someone who is not, who is exposed to prevailing wage law. We need to have a person who is fully covered by the laws of the state of California in that respect. We also need to have someone in a position who can leverage all the town's resources.

48:59 Public Works Department for bidding, the Planning Department for CEQA and planning and those kinds of things. And we also need to have someone who can operate on a peer-to-peer basis primarily with the Forest Service. Right now, all of that activity that I've just described comes directly at the town manager. There is nobody in between and there's nobody...

49:22 Arbitrating and guiding the implementation of those projects. We have several important plans on the books, the walk, bike, ride plan, trail system master plan, and town staff is currently undergoing an effort, which I think you heard about at the LTC meeting, to roll up all of those mobility plans into a more centralized document. We don't know exactly what that's going to look like, but all of the key infrastructure needs.

49:50 of the town and the community to be a truly sustainable, you know, outdoor recreation destination are going to be in those plans and in that infrastructure. And it's simply not possible to move forward and get those projects done without having capacity within the town to make that happen. So the idea would be for the town to hire someone into that position and that a certain number of hours would be available from that person.

50:19 to assist MLR with those items that are specifically going to be under contract for MLR to perform and deliver as part of the contract agreement with the town. Okay. So some of the things that you described, you had illuminated in other places within this contract. You talked about prevailing wage. You talked about some other things.

50:49 to condense what this position is, is a liaison between that's able to conduct business with other agencies? Is that how I understand that? Fundamentally, yes. Okay. It's just, and the reason for the confusion is,

51:12 It's very, there's a lot of legal term in here or set forth, but it didn't really describe what that position was. So that's where, so, and that, I think you could say it concise like you did, and it'd get more clarity to what it was because there were a couple of other places that you illuminated those particular things. So that's where I was confused about what it is. Thank you. Certainly apologize for that. This is a...

51:40 It's kind of a homemade document here a little bit. Oh, I totally understand. And some things are to be determined. Yes. But if it's more of a liaison that has to have a certain level of authority that currently is exercised by the town manager in between these other agencies as NGOs and other governmental, federal, or whatever agency, that wasn't coming through. So in the next go around, if that's...

52:08 Defining it, that would be helpful. Yeah, for sure. And I think also that other piece about the prevailing wage piece is very important. Yeah, and you do refer to it further on. And so maybe it's in a key, it may be in, oh, it's up above. Yes. No, it's the support that do not conflict with a prevailing wage. You already had in there, so.

52:37 No, that I had no way. That other was clear. But this large paragraph wasn't. Thank you. Yep. Yep. Great. Thanks. Good question, Rhonda. Any others in this section as we go down into the sub bullets of TAM will provide MLR with administrative support for public meetings. MLR provide support for

53:11 I found my word. What was your word? I found my word question. It pertains to

53:43 to the R funds and Measure U funds and it says MLR provides continuous support as the recommending body instead of for the recommending body. That's correct. As I think as recommending body for expenditures. Correct. And it's in the same thing in Measure U. Yeah. Got it. You make a good editor, Rhonda. I read a lot these days. We all are these days.

54:19 Only second to spending time on Zoom meetings. And then the last section was the funding. And any questions on that section? That was something we talked about quite a bit in our last meeting in the first draft of this document. It's just the recognition that the

54:54 Count-derived funds that are held in reserve are, you know, we agree that we should, you know, that those funds help support MLR operating here in the short term. No questions there? Well, so just for, again, for clarity's sake, I feel like I understand the spirit of it and I think it makes sense, but just considering that it has,

55:28 terminology like appropriate use. If there are restrictions, let's be specific about what those restrictions are. Does appropriate use mean in the service of the specific deliverables in this contract or any operations as the board sees fit? David, you're totally right on that. That is the gray area of the public funds aspect of

55:57 This is the 2.0 of the funds that we received, you know, like, we're like, we have the money in the bank right now of $100,000 plus. Well, those funds should have been used for X. Well, it was never really, like, clearly defined. And so we're asking for that clarity. Yeah. Good. Yes. And the town, the town is prepared to, when we get into the funding priorities, documents, and next steps, we're prepared to provide some consensus and direction. And we have some input on that, too, but we think it should be spent on, too.

56:27 Great. Thanks. Great. All right, guys. So that was the kind of foundational document that we worked with. And again, probably more conceptual, but then moving to the funding priorities, it started to, you know, get, let me just play with my screen a little bit here so I can read this. Is that, can I make that a little bigger for everybody?

56:58 Does that help? So then, you know, this is more the document that will then become where we, with each one of these key agreements, start to develop, what does it cost to provide this service to the town and becomes the foundation for the financial aspect of our contract? Is that a...

57:27 a fair way to introduce what this document is trying to achieve there, John? Yeah, I would just add that to look at this more probably sort of as a framework and to establish the things to be funded with the details and the nitty-gritty to be figured out because this, the idea would be that this

57:54 set of funding priorities that this kind of makes sense for the MLR board, we would take the same document or a modified document back to the town council. And if the town council agrees to it and MLR board has agreed to it, then we sit down and negotiate and form a contract from that. So whatever you guys want to do this evening, it's going to go back to the town council and the town council is going to...

58:21 I don't know if it's a similar exercise, but it's going to need to weigh in on this and get to a conceptual agreement on the things to fund. Yeah, so I'll try to reiterate that here is that our goal here is to go through this document and, you know, we sussed out some

58:45 Edits and some things that needed more clarity in the conceptual document. But this is where it really matters because this is the document that will go to the town council for their approval. And the next step in this process is getting us, our two organizations aligned on these funding priorities.

59:14 Let's start off with the first one, innovations in existing programs. Well, I would say just from my vantage, having gone through the former document and recognizing that this is really just a cut and paste of the high priority items from the first document, I'd say the comments all apply to these particular segments.

59:42 So I'm not sure there's a lot of sense in going through it again, item by item. But on number one, I would just reiterate, you know, this seems like, you know, really fundamental to the services provided. And it would be good to have a fairly specific articulation of what the town's vision for those existing programs is so that, again, whoever's implementing it can really follow that and understand.

1:00:12 what the goals are and what the vision is. Yeah, just, Craig, real quick, I hope you're taking notes there because I know meeting minutes may not capture all this, so we're all kind of taking notes on these. Yeah, I've got my notes too. Great, thank you. Perfect. David, let me ask this. Do you have a suggestion of how to provide greater clarity to that, you know, a potential edit that we would

1:00:47 Consider here and push on to the town council. It seems still rough enough that we're not really at this stage of wordsmithing. I'd certainly be happy when you get closer to it to take a glance and see if I can give some more specificity to it. Again, I feel like I get the vision. I really appreciate it. Bill and I have talked a lot about this. We've talked about it.

1:01:18 about this at a number of different levels, but the idea of MLR being that convening organization, that umbrella organization for different user groups in the outdoor recreation space, I think is a great concept and a great foundation for what MLR's work ought to be. I think it might get confused a little bit by the quote from the Trail System Master Plan, given that that's...

1:01:44 You know, an older document and kind of takes it off in a different tangent. I think, you know, if we can just contemporize that language and I think John and Bill have a really strong sense of what they think that should be and I trust you guys to come up with a paragraph that captures it a little better than this. That would be all I would say. Great. Thank you, David. Any other comments on innovation in existing programs?

1:02:15 I mean, I guess just to say, you know, having now been through, you know, some of our earlier kind of, you know, where we were struggling to side with, you know, whether or not certain deliverables had been delivered on, you know, now I think is a really good time to articulate that because there have been programs established, but some feel that those programs were within the scope of what MLR was founded to do and others feel like they aren't.

1:02:46 You know, really saying, you know, here's the, here are the programs that, that the town hopes MLR will do. And obviously if MLR wants to create programs outside of that, that's, that's, you know, it's well within its purview and it will fund those programs separately. And that's. And I think, David, you bring up a good point and it was this item at the top of the page that, you know, and, and one of the things I, I know we all.

1:03:16 in hindsight realize that we did not do enough of ongoing check-ins and monitoring of the final agreement as we go along and that checking in with our partners will really be key to not going too far afield with some of those opportunities.

1:03:45 that present themselves and knowing who's responsible, you know, when we're going to go do something independently that that's not blurred with what we're doing under this contract. So, cool. Moving on to organizational structure, you know, as David said, you know, a lot of this is just copy and paste, but, you know, trying to get it down to

1:04:15 You know, a narrower articulation. Anything in here? Just for the board's edification, this is literally a cut and paste. There's no change in language from the key agreements document. It's just these are the items to fund. So the language should be exactly the same. It's just these are the things we want to focus on for the contract. Okay. And that goes through

1:04:54 All of these key agreements and support the goal of trails committee funding support as the recommending body for expenditures on RNU. And there we go. So it's really narrowed it down to those couple items. Any questions about any of that?

1:05:27 that needs further clarification. If this is those three items of innovation and existing programs, ongoing structure and funding are the three primary bullets there. Is that enough for us to agree to send on to the town council?

1:05:57 for their purview and kind of the next step of the process. I would like to make one more point in here. I want to make sure that we are including the clarifications of what Mammoth Recreation does being municipal and that MLR is outside of municipal and that when we define those umbrellas.

1:06:28 I think MLR needs to be defined very strongly in its language so that it's understood by the town council because they're not sitting through hours of meetings, understand the definition of our role. And that's going to be recreation outside of municipal and arts and culture. That's a great point, Heather. And I would just add, you know, obviously I like the brevity of this document, but by the same token.

1:06:56 For the sake of this negotiation and for the council and the public's understanding, when it says continued support for the trails manager and the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, for example, what does that support mean? I mean, I have a pretty good sense of it as the trails committee chair, but I'm not sure that the public necessarily does or that the town council necessarily does. And obviously we don't need to have a voluminous.

1:07:22 Explanation of that, but I think a couple of good hard-hitting sentences that say, you know, this is what we mean by support, and this is what we mean by programs, and this is what we mean by recommending body. Agreed. I think just by nature, as you develop it, you become so intimately aware of what you're trying to say, that you say it in language that nobody understands.

1:07:53 As far as Measure U and Measure R, define what programs those are for, arts and culture. You take care of it right there. But after you get it, have somebody read it who doesn't exactly know all of the backstory, intimacies of the organization, does it make sense to them? And that's your test right there. Good feedback, Rhonda. And so,

1:08:26 You know, as I guess a point of order if what action do we need to take as a board? I would assume we're going to have a motion to pass on these funding priorities for the town council's consideration and that we would need

1:08:55 Motion and second and vote on that. Am I on the right track there? I think in all honesty, just I'm sorry to put this out there, but the deliverables and the overhead costs I think need to be defined a little bit clearer before I think we present them to the town council because I think that's going to come back to them as not completed. I'm sorry, am I throwing a wrench in this? No, I think it's a fair point. I think what would make sense

1:09:24 is to get the sense of the full MLR board with this document as presented, but then to add into a motion a follow-up meeting with the already appointed MLR committee that's met with the town council folks to then refine the language that would go to the council based on the consensus representing the interest of the MLR board. And that at that point becomes a semantic exercise to translate the things that are in here in a way that are consistent with the intent of the MLR board.

1:09:54 In a way that can become a sort of more actionable for the town council. I think that's a, that goes back to the checking in piece of this to make sure that we don't just take this language the way it is. There's going to be a translation for an agenda item, but to do that in consultation with the MLR committee that we've been working with so far, I think that would be really kind of a critical step. Yeah, Heather, this is going to come back to the council probably on the September 2nd council date.

1:10:25 So we will have several more meetings of our group. Okay. I was thinking about next week's meeting. I was like, oy vey. Okay. No. No. That was me being optimistic and ambitious. That was me panicking. Thank you. You'll have some heavy lifting to do. Yeah. Very, very much so. Yeah, Heather, that's great that you brought that up because, yeah, I was, I'm kind of struggling going, I, you know, it seems like there is.

1:10:53 There's not enough meat on this bone. If we need it, I would certainly be willing to make a motion to recommend that the negotiating committee proceed along these lines to clarify and I don't want to say finalize, but Well, let me suggest this.

1:11:25 We have a regularly scheduled meeting on the 1st would just tabling this item with the feedback we've gotten from you all go back to our committee and continue the work and then bring back a cleaned up version for our meeting on the 1st and then have the motion.

1:11:56 to pass it on to town council or is that getting too tight on the other side? I understand the spirit of that but I think the only timing issue will be is everything would have to be codified and released for council prior to that. It would have to be out on the 28th. So it doesn't really give town staff enough time to turn things around from the second. I would

1:12:26 Second and reiterate what David said. I think we've expressed our concerns and the clarity that needs to be established in the document and we've gone through it. So we would trust our committee to come up with a finalized version now that we've shared our concerns. And if it doesn't meet their needs, council is going to kick it back to us. Yeah, exactly. Yeah. There's going to have to be some hard realities and some hard deliverables attached to that. Right.

1:12:57 I think we've got our piece, and we've all got to put our input right here, and we trust you guys to put it together in a... Say it now, or forever hold your feet. Exactly, like, I said my piece, now you guys, I trust that you're going to put it in a hard format, so I don't need to see it again. That said, though, Heather, you alluded to, and others have alluded to the fact that those hard realities are going to be the financial pieces, and that would be the piece that...

1:13:26 The board would probably need to endorse before. Those are some true conversations that we have to have and I don't know if that's something that we can get into in a little while. Craig, I don't know if that's something we can bring up. Well, I'm thinking what Colin was just saying is that, you know, if and correct me if my timing is

1:13:55 is mistaken, but the MLR board gives the committee these marching orders that we just talked about, hey, a little bit more clarity to have those hard conversations. And, you know, we've got to send that off earlier, as Colin suggested to the town, knowing that that may come back, you know, with further, but further

1:14:26 Editing on their side. But I think we'll be a lot further down the road for our board to have some of our financial, you know, conversations at our September 1st meeting and that we could, you know, agendize the outcome of our committee's next couple meetings that get into those budget items and that, you know,

1:14:55 We can at least start addressing the financial side from MLRs of how we're progressing, knowing that, you know, it still has to be approved by town council, but, you know, we'll be working more in sync with town council, both considering the same stuff at the same time. Did that make some? I think that makes a lot of sense. And then, and furthermore, given the timing,

1:15:22 There's the potential. So if we have a chance to kind of, you know, to visit the semi-final draft that's already in the council packet by that point, there would be time for an MLR representative, probably one of you from the committee, to stand before council that Wednesday night and say, you know, here are a couple of the concerns that are still pending or, you know, we've...

1:15:48 Run this through the board and our board is generally seem supportive or whatever. Yeah, I think from a mechanic standpoint that that makes sense, David. And, you know, any other feedback on on using that as our timeline team? Yeah, I think that works really well. I think David put it fairly well. The council is going to get in their packet what the group works on.

1:16:15 Yes. And that's going to be their first opportunity to dive into it. And so any comments coming back from the group at that presentation would be appropriate for them then to make the decision. I like that. Yeah, and I would just advise that these key agreements, as rough as they are, these documents have gotten us to where we are this evening. And if this is something that the MLR board can support, that's great.

1:16:45 As we go forward, anticipate that this now starts getting translated into a town council agenda item or, you know, it's going to start going into a different type of a document, but certainly we're going to be using this as our guiding reference instead of principles going forward. And just keep that in mind as we go forward. It may start looking different, but we're going to be hanging on to this as the baseline, the foundation for what we do going forward.

1:17:13 Thanks to all you guys for putting in this effort. I'm sure it's not an easy thing to corral, but this is probably long overdue. Probably lack of clarity and communication is why we've arrived at this point. So it's good that we're finally starting to hash this stuff out. Thanks, Colin. Any other comments? I would just say, I would add Rhonda's wordsmith on the last bullet point before funding where...

1:17:45 It's MLR shall provide continued support as the recommending body instead of four. But again, thanks. You guys, great work. I mean, there's a lot of work here and I appreciate the committee for getting as far as they have so far. Thanks. Hey, Catherine, any comments from you on, you know, you've been watching the sausage making. Any comments from you?

1:18:21 I know she has a sick one. Hey, sorry. Sorry, I just had to extract myself from a sleepy baby. But no, everything sounds great and next steps are perfect. We'll be ready to take everybody's feedback, I think, back into this. Okay, awesome. I feel really good. I just want to make sure everybody understands what we're talking about when we talk about.

1:18:49 Fundraising, needing to start making and bringing in our own money and understanding the aspect of funding our own ED and that process. I want to make sure that everybody understands that. And does anybody have any questions or any rebuttals against it? Or does anybody have any comments about it? Because that to me is a big difference from our contract before to now. I guess just one comment, question.

1:19:19 And it won't be answered now, but just something for you guys to continue to discuss is that, you know, you and Craig both have referenced that there's a certain amount of independence that comes with this, you know, with this self-funding piece. I think that's worth having some brass tacks discussions about with Andy Morris and Dan and the town. You know, what does that

1:19:46 shape up to me. And, you know, if we really get to a place where we can fund an executive director entirely independently of our service contract with the town, you know, does that, are we still held to the highest standards of the Brown Act for board meetings, for example, or only for public hearings on the deliverables that we're servicing? I think that's really important going into this with our eyes open in terms of

1:20:16 What we can raise money for. You know, I do think it's going to be very hard to raise money for operations if we don't have that kind of independence. So it's just something to kind of grapple with a little bit from a legal standpoint. Dan, do you have any input on that? Mr. Holler? I can put in on that a little. Dan would probably talk to Andy more than me. It is my understanding.

1:20:47 That if the organization accepts any tax dollars from the town outside of a regular contract, that the Brown Act has to continue. That's a state rule. Yeah. There's two factors to that that require the Brown Act to continue, and you can't bifurcate the organization's activities. The first one is the structure of the board. There's a council member that serves on it. That's appointed by the town council in that role.

1:21:17 relationship back to the town council. They serve as a full board member, then that is one test. The other is substantial funding from the town tax dollars. And there's a third element that ultimately gets in if it's there actually be an allocator assigned a duty or a role that would otherwise be accomplished by the town. So there's a couple different tests when you look at that element.

1:21:44 Under the structures proposed, I believe that the actions of MLR would continue to be subject to all of the current, whether it be the conflict of interest codes or the Brown Act or the other elements, the filing of Form 700, those types of issues would all still apply under the current discussion. So you're saying that if staff is covered by town funds, but the ED

1:22:14 Funds are raised. There's no way to, as you said, separate in any way. Yeah, the board can't bifurcate itself and say, in this instance, we're a Brown Act board, in this instance, we're not. We kind of read that here a while back. There's nothing that would prevent MLR from doing other things and working on items there, regardless of the, you know, outside of the, you know, the funding sources, raising their own thing, going out and doing different levels of work.

1:22:41 The only limit to that would be it'd be on its own dime, if you will. So there's no, you know, improper use of town dollars for those types of purposes. Sure, but if we're funding our ED, then he or she decides to do as they will. Yep. Yeah, they just can't, they still can't violate the Brown Act. They still can't violate, you know.

1:23:03 The FPPC rules on conflict of interest. Like the ED couldn't go, I'm going to go hire my spouse for $100,000 a year and have a direct conflict of interest in those types of elements or something. So there are some restraints, but it's fairly broad of what they can work on. Yes. Yeah, I would just recommend Craig and Heather and Catherine that you guys look into that and maybe we seek some external advice as well. I mean, I...

1:23:32 It's not that it's a problem, but I think we need to, again, have our eyes open as far as what our goals are internally aside from the services that we're moving toward agreeing on. Again, I think it's going to be very hard to have a professional executive director at any kind of competitive level working on anything but this and still have the constraints that we've been operating under.

1:24:01 I understand those constraints exist, but I also think that if we're going to get into the business of restructuring, maybe there's a chance here for us to restructure in such a way that we maintain public hearings for the pieces that are relevant to R&U, and if we're raising money outside of that, we need to look at what possibilities there are. Yeah, I hear that, David, and I think it's certainly a topic we should be talking about going forward.

1:24:29 And again, the ED can go out and raise money and do those things. It just, if the board is going to be engaged in that, if it's a majority of the board, that's an open meeting process. So you can't like have a closed session behind door comment discussion with the full board about creative solutions to go raise money or options or cutting deals with folks in a private setting.

1:24:51 No, I completely understand, and I've been digging into this. I understand the legal parameters. I also think that there are potentially some solutions, just, you know, having worked in the nonprofit sector for a long time now. It's, you know, there are, especially when you get into fundraising, it's really hard to do it in the setting of a Brown Act. And so, you know, just, again, for our board, just to...

1:25:18 Take responsibility for what that actually means in terms of our ability to deliver beyond the services that we're committing to deliver. I get that. It's great to set a little bit of a challenge there. For sure. And just based on that, I agree with what David said. It's much harder to raise funds for administrative things like salaries than to get a partnership to sponsor a project or an activity.

1:25:43 So looking at our finances, you know, and again, if we're saying an executive director is going to help us raise funds, how secure are we to pay an executive director's salary for the first six to 12 months while we have time to go out and raise funds? Very limited. Yeah. So that's a concern. That's something that we have to jump on right away, obviously. If we're going to be moving forward, we've got to be aware of these finances. Right. Let's see. So circling back to

1:26:24 Whether we need a motion or not for, let me see if I can take a crack. Craig, this is Dan. If you want, I mean, instead of trying to formulate a full-blown motion on it, if you have consensus of the full board from what we're hearing, and everybody's kind of confirmed up our consensus, this is the right forward, as this is not a final document, you know, something will need to come back to you. We can use that consensus, I believe, to move this forward. I didn't hear anybody in,

1:26:54 You know, what I would call opposition, more so clarification comments, you know, quite a few of those. But as far as anybody being opposed, unless there is, and I've missed it, they can speak up. But it sounds like you have a pretty solid consensus to move this forward with those areas as noted discussed for more clarification. That may be easier than trying to craft a formalized motion, but either way will work. Thank you. That's exactly what I was looking for.

1:27:24 and so you know with that you know consensus the committee will continue to work with representatives from the town to bring something back for the board's consideration on maybe a more final document on our

1:27:49 September 1st meeting, and that'll be agendized for us to maybe memorialize with a motion at that point. And Dan, before we all go, can you just give us, for the committee and the town folks here, an idea of the date by which you're going to need a document for the council packet? Yeah, there's three things going with the council.

1:28:18 The goal was to be done in September, so we have both meetings on the 2nd and on the 16th. I don't know at this point, we may have one special meeting in September, depending on some other factors with COVID. But if we were to do that, say shoot for the 16th, which is the second meeting, that agenda material would need to be ready no later than Wednesday the 9th of September.

1:28:46 So that would give us just, you know, a couple of weeks to work through that. Okay, does that sound kind of like a reasonable goal for everybody? Does that work for MLR if we're kind of shooting for the 16th? Yeah, very much so, because then, I mean, we can have a full-blown discussion at our September 1 meeting and, you know, come out of that with something that'll make it into their packet. I guess my question would be,

1:29:17 And maybe this is to our committee and our representatives from the town is with that Dan would be looking at August for something to be in the packet for the second. Yeah, we would be that agenda would be out on the 26th of August. So it's a little more.

1:29:46 tight to have something draft up. And then if you made any changes at your meeting on the first, then we would be dealing with one document, another document that's not completed. So I would much rather try to go in with a final document between the group of us. Okay. Versus one that has potential amendments coming out of the meeting on the first. Okay.

1:30:13 I think that's a better, otherwise you'd have to have one ready for you all. Also, I like on that 27th or 26th in order to get it into your packet to hit the first. Yeah, hit the first. So that pushes everything. And we have a council meeting next week. That agenda is going out Thursday. So, I mean, really you only got two weeks to...

1:30:38 kind of work through to get a draft agreement before the MLR board, then you would have, we would have a few more days to work through that, make any changes that would go to a council packet and be able to hash that through. And if there's just something that's significant that pops up, like I say, you may have to have another emergency meeting, if need be, special meeting to address those issues. If we don't get through it by the 1st. Okay. So I give this a little bit of time.

1:31:04 Yeah, I agree with that timeline. Any feedback about that from the board? It seems like the direction we should head, hearing nobody, we'll move in that direction with the consensus from the board to have something for them in their packet for the September 1st meeting. Be your September 1st meeting, be our September. All right, you guys, thanks. Yeah.

1:31:35 Excuse me, President Albright? I just want to make sure I've captured this right, and then I believe we also have, it looks like I may have just got an email with a public comment. But first, I just want to confirm there was consensus by the board to direct the ad hoc committee to continue their work with the town to amend the Toml funding priorities and key agreements and bring them back to the board of the regular September 1 board meeting for approval and recommendation at that time to bring

1:32:04 the documents forward to the town council for approval on September 16th. I think that summarized it nicely. Thank you, Angie. Great. And then let me just double check an email that just came in. Okay. She doesn't specifically say it's a public comment. I'm pretty sure it is, but I think before I read it into the record... Go ahead and just read it out, Angie. It's fine. Okay. This is from Sandy Hogan. It says, not sure why a town council member would be required...

1:32:43 to be on the board if this is a pure nonprofit organization having a contract with the town. There are other nonprofits that have had contacts with the town which do not have a town council member on it. Perhaps you should check with outside counsel on this. Excellent. And actually to maybe respond to that, I know Sandy had brought up and one of the things all we can discuss within our committee is

1:33:14 is within that structure whether potentially not an ad hoc but a ex-officio member of the MLR board was a town council person non-voting whether that could I know Sandy's brought that up before and that's something we'll definitely as a group look into so thank you Sandy for your comment. All right.

1:33:41 So moving on, let me stop sharing this screen. And how are we doing? Do we need a quick break or are we doing a keep plugging? I'm going to say thank you and adios. Plug away. Thank you all very much. Looking forward to our next round and looking forward to moving forward. Thanks a lot. Thanks, John, for all your work on this. Yeah, thank you all. All right. Excellent.

1:34:16 Keep plugging forward. And so next up, let me get back on track. So I asked Matt to, in light of all this, and to provide us with kind of one pagers, if you will, for what it would look like from a strategic planning standpoint,

1:34:46 If we continue to work with the town of Mammoth Lakes, but also if we don't end up renewing the contract beyond the extension here at the end of September, you know, what his view on what that would look like for us, it seemed like that was a missing part that the board would need to kind of further inform these decisions we have in front of us.

1:35:15 Ask Matt to provide us with a couple, and you've got those attachments in your packet, but I'll turn it over to Matt to kind of work through what those two different kind of visions, if you will, might look like with and without a contract with the town going forward for MLR. Matt?

1:35:47 Thanks, Greg. I'm going to try to share the screen here if I can, Angie. We're good. Let's see here. There you go. Let me just blow it up here. All right. So I think current is what we're basically talking about tonight, extending the contract with the town of Mammoth Lakes, focusing on the key deliverables.

1:36:34 that are associated with Measure R, Measure U, and Trails. So basically what we did is just kind of broke it up into key objectives, which is our programmatic buckets and then biz dev and fundraising. But under our current programmatic buckets for sustainable relationship, we would continue to work on stewardship, which includes our adopted trail program. We do this.

1:37:03 In conjunction with Mammoth Lakes Trail System, Mammoth Lakes Recreation operates front of house, Mammoth Lakes Trail System operates an overseas back of house. We would continue to do tangle-free waters. This one we do wholly on our own, but we are partnered with Mono County and other entities on this project. We would continue to do events like Gooch Patrol, which deals with pet waste, other cleanup events.

1:37:32 And then for advocacy, we would certainly continue to do our work on Keep Long Valley Green and then some of our public lands policy work. The one that really jumps out, I think, is our winter recreation planning. We want to be heavily involved in that, primarily trying to coalesce different user groups into taking part in this exercise so that we can get

1:38:01 All of the different representatives at the table so that there's not hopefully staving off a lot of controversy later as the winter rec policy shapes up. Administrative continuing to do our work with Mammoth Trails Committee providing that oversight for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System budget and some direction for Joel and his team. Moving over to community building.

1:38:31 We would still continue to do our Measure U grant program, the allocations program, and then oversee special projects. And then we would also do a limited amount of outreach and education, including leave no trace, some work on climate change, and then addressing some diversity inclusivity work and issues in town. Moving over to capital projects, I broke these up into three different kind of sub buckets.

1:39:01 The first one is MLR-led. These are projects that we do pretty much wholly on our own. I wouldn't say wholly because we have to work with partners, but we would run point on it. That would include work with the winter staging area, trying to get the winter staging area, certainly the one going in a shady rest, but also I know Matt Perulo is looking at some other areas along 395. And then we've talked about trying to do more work into

1:39:32 Establishing additional snow play areas and trying to enhance the existing one. And then we have a partnership bucket. This is stuff that we do in partnership with different entities in town. That would include the Lab Sharp enhancement project. We're working on that with Mammoth Lakes Trail System and the town of Mammoth Lakes and the U.S. Forest Service. Buckeye Hot Springs. Matt Perullo's working on this and that involves

1:40:01 SNC that involves representatives from the HD, I believe. And then the amenities program, which we do with the town of Mammoth Lakes, Parks and Rec, Stuart and his team over there. That basically is trying to get things like bike racks, bottle fill stations, benches. That program basically grew out of the bench program, which is at capacity. So there's a real opportunity to get other amenities in town that we...

1:40:30 Desperately need. I know that when our last mobility committee meeting last week, we talked a lot about bike racks and the need for bike racks, not just to facilitate the current need, but aspirationally, we know parking is a big challenge. And so if we could get more people, you know, up into the lake space and on their own bikes, you know, do we have enough bike racks up there? So all of those would fall into that program. And then we have programs that where we would just be the fundraising lead.

1:40:59 Meaning we would take in the money and then those would pass through. Those are things like working with our forest service partners to replace some of the plum toilets with vault toilets, continue doing bridges and other things where needed, trail amenities where needed, and of course trailheads. And then the last one would be business development and fundraising. Under fundraising, continuing to do work on appeals. We'd like to launch a monthly giving program.

1:41:28 I think now that we've got some of our big other programs out of the way, we're looking towards that to do a fall-time launch, and we think that would be a great way to build in solid income throughout the year, continuing our efforts to cultivate corporate and then move more into major gifting grants. Right now, we're doing a limited amount of work. Matt Perulo's working on some grants. Just got another one this week.

1:41:56 Kind of continuing that into a very limited function just because we've got a lot of other work specifically tied in with Measure R, Measure U. And then some programs. We do have money coming in from adopted trail and tank-free waters and the town of Mammoth Lakes amenities. And then partnerships, continues working on some strategic partnerships. Right now we're actually, we just moved one ahead of year. We had a partnership, kind of a verbal partnership with

1:42:24 LADWP, but because of the COVID situation and the inability to kind of conduct group efforts and group meetings, we're going to push that off a year, but when we can kind of get back and have a little bit more stability in that landscape, we'll renew those. And then we are talking right now with Patagonia and REI to do some partnerships in terms of in-market training in Southern California.

1:42:53 for people when they come up here, before they come up here. So it's one thing, I know that there's a lot of conversation right now to try to educate and people while they're on the landscape. We're hoping to try to be proactive and do that down in market. So all of those programmatic deliverables are tied to key performance indicators. I think what we're shooting for from sustainable recreation side is we'd like to have 80% sell-through on AAT. That's on the actual adoption side.

1:43:21 You know, the volunteer side, we're getting great response and continue to get great response. But we also, it's important that we get money in there to support those volunteer needs. So we'd like to see at least an 80% sell through on that. Same for Tangle Free Waters. We're getting ready to roll that out hopefully this week on Thursday perhaps. But we'd like to see 80% sell through. That one's kind of reversed right now. We did have the Mono County Fish and Wildlife Commission provide us a grant.

1:43:50 And then establish a

1:44:19 Winter Recreation Plan Working Group. That's something that we talked about earlier this year. And then again, it's been kind of difficult. We're not quite sure, you know, what the timing is on Forest Service side. We believe that it's still going to happen, but we just, we need to get some clarity in talking with them. But we have to be proactive, even if we're just reaching out to people now. And then of course, continuing with the MTC setting and meeting goals and trying to improve on that if we can.

1:44:49 Wherever possible. For community building, it's 100% reporting for Measure U grantees. And again, this is something that Kim's been really instrumental on is that the trackability of how our Measure U partners are performing. She's done just a fantastic job of putting in tools. And so I think what we want to do is make sure that we get 100% reporting on how those programs are developing. And then on the outset,

1:45:18 And on the outside and then finding out how they, on a recap, how they performed and how many folks they reached and use that as an effort for our allocations committee to evaluate our partners. I think one of the things that we struggle with is that, you know, since we brought on the multi-year funding, at what point do we try to phase out the existing partners so we have room for incoming partners?

1:45:48 And so I think that reporting is going to be critical function of that evaluation. And then the second thing is trying to leverage what I call one to two fundraising against Measure U dollars. So we have a significant amount of Measure U dollars that are going into the program, but we would ideally like to be able to bring outside money and to supplement that. So, you know, I'll use an example for Mono Arts Council. They do a very successful art and wine.

1:46:17 Program. And can we find a vineyard who maybe wants to support that? Will Gallo come in and start putting money in? And that way, what that does is if we get money from outside sources, then we can take some of that money that perhaps would have been channeled to these grantees, and then it frees it up to either bring in new grantees or expand them more robustly. On capital projects.

1:46:46 We're setting up a campaign page for the lab sharp enhancement. I think that's something that we want to not only get that page up, but we want to become more involved as advocates for the project because that's kind of a little bit more in our wheelhouse. I think MLTS is very qualified at doing the actual work and working with forest servers, but I think we need some assistance in front-facing components for this campaign.

1:47:14 And that's something where MLR can step up. And then I think working with Stuart to develop and launch the amenities program. And then moving finally into the business development and fundraising, you know, we want to try to do at least two appeals, which is something new we haven't done before just because we've been working to get to the area where we are now. We have a body of work behind us. We can do two appeals, you know, conservatively at 7K each. We could get a lot more than that, but I think that's...

1:47:42 I think the minimum that we need to do to make those efforts viable and try to get 100 people signed up for monthly giving throughout the year at $5 a month. $5 a month doesn't sound like much. It's basically a Starbucks coffee. When you think about it, $60 per person a year. That's usually well above what we get for most people. So if we could get 100 people selling us $5 a year, then...

1:48:11 That turns out to be a significant amount of money. And the better part is that monthly givers has been shown to actually give more than what they normally do. They're usually the first people that also respond to appeals. And then we also would like to establish two net new partnerships at a minimum of 5K. So we have existing partners, but we need to bring in net new every year for this organization to grow. And then underneath, we have just the people I've already mentioned that we partner with.

1:48:40 On sustainable recreation, it's MLTS, U.S. Forest Service, Mono County, a little bit with Town of Mammoth Lakes, but that usually comes indirectly through Mammoth Lakes Trail System. On community building, then we do work primarily with Town of Mammoth Lakes. We work a lot with Dan and Stu, Rob Patterson. On capital projects, we work with everybody. We work with Town of Mammoth Lakes staff, work with MLTS staff, we work with Mono County, we work with U.S. Forest Service.

1:49:07 And then on BizDev, you know, that's something that we do a little bit more in-house. So is there any question on this before I go to the next slide? Yeah, I think I have a question and a comment. One, thanks, Matt, for doing this. This is super helpful to lay this out like this. And it makes me realize, Craig, Heather, Catherine, as you proceed with negotiations with the town, arriving at...

1:49:39 A clean document like this to present to council would be super helpful so that, you know, again, we have a reference point so everyone can kind of say, ah, I see, you know, the key agreements all make sense, but laying it out in really crystal clear form like this, I mean, for example, where we have a key agreement that says support Mammoth Lakes Trail System, well, let's get a little bit more granular and let's say, you know, does, what is the relationship between the town and MLR?

1:50:08 for adopt a trail. You know, what's that financial breakdown? What's the pass-through? What's the cost of that? Same, you know, does the town have an interest in tangle-free waters? Is that part of the contract? Does the town have an interest in pooch patrol? Is that part of the contract? You know, just so that we're super clear, you know, what we feel like is supporting the trail system versus, you know, so the town shares those values and goals, I think is important. One thing that I,

1:50:38 A question for you, Matt. Trail hosts isn't on here. That's become a big hot point. Does MLR have a role in trail hosts? Right now, our only role with trail hosts is a grant that we received on the outset of that program through People for Bikes. I spoke with Joel Monday about, you know, how we can kind of close that grant out, and I think we're working to that next step.

1:51:08 As far as funding, it could be. I mean, we could try to add that to something that we do as a fundraising lead along like with bathroom bridges and trailheads. But in terms of management and designing that program, I think that's something that Joel and MLTS working with MLTPA have kind of taken leadership role on that. It seems to be working. I think for our efforts, we're trying to focus.

1:51:38 Efforts where there are gaps, if you will. And so as I mentioned earlier, I think one of the places where we could play a big role is go down and try to do more outreach in market. And I think that not only helps to address some of the issues as people come up here that if we can educate them beforehand, but as we do more work in market and gain a little bit more presence, you know, we've always talked about trying to, if we really want to,

1:52:07 Succeed at fundraising. It has to be bigger than the town, right? The town is a pretty finite pie. And the more of a slice we try to get, usually that slice comes at the peril of another nonprofit. So it's kind of a steel share. But if we go down to Southern California, then we're carving out that new pie for us anyways. And so I think that this gives us a good opportunity.

1:52:34 Just try to set that table, which is something we've talked about and wanted to do all along. And then just thank you. Finally, you just heard all the conversation about what the town deliverables might look like. And obviously this scope is a lot bigger than what it looks like where that contract might go. Another piece that I'm not sure is on here is that...

1:53:02 You know, we were struggling with the language around it, but that umbrella, you know, serving as an umbrella for outdoor rec groups, where would that fit on this? Right now, you know, I'm not sure that we could fit it in. I mean, when we go to the next slide, I think you'll see that probably a bit more flushed out. Okay. Maybe community building. Yeah, I mean, it probably would land either in sustainable recreation or community building.

1:53:34 But again, I think right now, one of my concerns is just simple capacity that come November, December, and then certainly as we move into January, I lose a significant amount of Kim's time. And then with Matt moving on, for all this work, there's really going to be just two of us. And so we're going to run into bandwidth problems. I know this just because we...

1:54:01 We encountered some of them when it was just Emily and myself. And that was before we had programs up and running. So now it's just going to be, you know, there's a lot that we want to do. It's like, how do we get there? And so I think that the challenges, and this I will talk about in a minute as we move to the next slide, is that I think what we're looking at here is that in Mammoth Lakes Recreation, if we continue down the road,

1:54:31 with, you know, in our partnership with Town of Mammoth Lakes, which I think is important. There's a lot of important work that needs to be done. Our long-term strategic goal of being a, what I call true standalone nonprofit, and by means standalone, meaning that we're generating enough money where we can literally standalone and hire more employees and execute on more programs, that trajectory is going to be

1:54:59 Way more shallow than it would be if we were just kind of like off on our own. The challenge is though, off on our own is a big risk reward, right? So the reward's bigger, but the risk is bigger. The chances of us becoming insolvent, especially with the climate as it is right now, that's a legitimate and very real risk. Whereas here, the risk reward is lessened somewhat because the town is contributing money.

1:55:26 But our trajectory is going to be a lot more shallow just because we're working on a lot of programmatic needs that are perhaps less fundable, certainly maybe less sexy than we would be working on otherwise. I'm sorry, one more question, if you don't mind, just one last little quick thing. There are a couple programs on here like Buckeye Hot Springs that I'm curious if...

1:55:54 If we go the way things are leaning and Matt moves over to the county, what is MLR's role on the Buckeye Hot Springs? So because, and Matt Perulo, jump in if I get this wrong, because that grant went through Mammoth Lakes Recreation, we would still administer top line on that. But again, Matt retains, you know, all the oversight and supervision of that specific project. So that would be basically a pass through.

1:56:22 And so just as I think the work that he's doing right now with OHV and the latest grant he's got is going to be passed through. And so when we wrote Matt's original contract, we anticipated this, that MLR acting as the pass-through, we would take an administrative cut on that, and then the rest of it would just continue on through the agencies actually doing the lifting on that. And then of course, Matt, whether he's here or whether he's with the county, maintains his management role.

1:56:53 Thanks. Thanks, guys. Matt, the only comment I was going to make, first of all, thank you for putting this together. It's very clear and succinct. You know, I understand that right now this is really just an internal document, but if at some point this moves to a little bit more of a public-facing document, my only suggestion would be, and I understand kind of formatting perspective and trying to keep it to one page, we had to use a lot of shorthand.

1:57:21 Jargon and, you know, acronyms and that kind of stuff. But, you know, even as an MLR board member, it's a lot to sift through. So if it does transition to more of a public-facing document at some point, I would suggest, you know, either clarifying some of that stuff or putting together kind of a descriptions and key page, basically, that would attach to this. Yeah, good advice. Thank you, Colin. Okay, can we go to the next one?

1:57:55 All right. Can you guys see this one, the alternate? Is that on your screen? Still current. Okay. Let me try again. Now, do you see the alternate? Yes. Okay. So, this one would be if, you know, in another scenario, Mammoth Lakes Recreation separated itself from the town of Mammoth Lakes and went out on its own.

1:58:36 So the first thing I think to point out is that our mission would likely change. In the past, you know, our mission is to address and, you know, advocate and enhance for sustainable recreation, arts, culture, and mobility. And I think in order to be successful, we have to pare down our focus to one thing, and that thing is sustainable recreation.

1:59:06 We feel it's important to have those elements in our community. For us to be successful, I think we need to just focus on sustainable recreation. So this one-page strategic plan outlines that. So the key objectives, again, laid out in the same format with our programmatic buckets, moving over to sustainable recreation.

1:59:32 We're still working on adopted trails, still working on tank-free waters, still working on pooch patrol. We would probably expand our cleanup events, not just because it's kind of top of mind right now with everybody out there, but this is something that we've wanted to do anyways, is move up and address some needs in central and northern part of the county. And then as we go down to advocacy, you'll see that, especially under public lands policy, in addition to winter recreation,

2:00:02 Planning on the Inyo, we'd want to try to get involved in some other things that are affecting our public lands and forests here. Certainly NEP is a big one and ROPA is another one. And so I think that's something that David and I have talked about is can we perhaps take up a more prominent role? There seems to be a bit of a vacuum right now where there's just not a lot, I don't think there's any other entities right now that are really pushing on that. We're kind of relying on

2:00:31 The national organizations. And I think that, you know, here as the organization that is kind of that umbrella for all the different recreational users, certainly that would fall under our role. And it might certainly could be expanded beyond that, but these are just some examples. Moving over to community building, we break it out a little bit more. So in the past, what we've done just limited to diversity and inclusivity would be expanded out to JETI, which is Justice.

2:00:58 Equality, diversity, and inclusivity. One of the things that we want to focus out there is mobility. We have a pretty good system right now with ESTA, but I think we want to revisit that. One example that was passed on to me that was kind of eye-opening is that one of the challenges that we face as a community is that 51% of our population is Hispanic or Latino.

2:01:28 We don't really talk about them in a lot in terms of the recreation. Like, you know, I don't think in any really meeting other than recently during the COVID has there really been a lot of thought in terms of, you know, doing outreach to this portion of our community. And I think that's a shame. And I know that Stuart and his team do a really good, or really, you know, a lot of effort trying to build programs that do engage.

2:01:55 That portion of the community, one example obviously is the sports leagues and soccer, but you know, the buses don't drive up and drop off to the fields, right? So they get dropped off and you see moms working with their kids, walking with their kids hand in hand, all the way up to the fields and all the way back. And you know, some people may not say that's a long walk, but maybe for them it is. I think those are just kind of the things that we need to keep in mind is that, you know, are all the things that, all the decisions for everything from

2:02:23 Mobility to signage to everything else. Are those really optimized for 51% of our residents? And I think that's something that needs to be addressed, that MLR can be addressed as it pertains to recreation. Partnerships are another one. I think that we, you know, I've talked about for a long time trying to get a Latino outdoors chapter here. I think there's a lot of work that can be done, whether that's through for Latino or someone else.

2:02:51 But I think we need to establish those so that we, one, are speaking to this community with a credible voice, but two, give them a construct that they're going to feel welcome and familiar with. Moving down with outreach education, we want to do a lot more work into Leave No Trace. This is kind of one of the intersects where we do work, I'd say intersect maybe with the host department of doing some more outreach and more education with Leave No Trace.

2:03:20 Certainly want to get involved with climate change. I think that it's impossible to extricate. If you're going to champion sustainable recreation, it's impossible to extricate yourself from climate change. It is the biggest threat out there right now facing outdoor recreation. And then diversity and inclusivity. This is really a big topic right now within the industry. I think between the Latino community, the indigenous tribes, and some other stakeholders, I think that

2:03:50 There's a lot of room in our community to make some headway on this. And then converse or subsequent to that, I think there's a lot of opportunity for us to go out and get funding. I think all the things, I'll get to this when we get to business development, but all the things that we're putting here, I think have to be tied to funding. We can't just do them if they're going to be kind of out of pocket charitable efforts. They need to be tied to funding user groups. And this is something that you guys had talked to on the last slide.

2:04:17 We need to be much more proactive at reaching user groups. I could make a laundry list, but I just limited it to three. We really need to reach out, do a much better job of reaching out to OHV, OSV. That user group, I think, the face of it is changing, and I don't think people realize that they are, in some cases, very outspoken advocates of responsible use. They do have a big...

2:04:44 Kind of backing from industry and there's a lot of opportunity to do some funding in there. You know, Matt just got a great grant to address some of those needs. Fishing is another one and I haven't got it yet, but I asked Jeff Simpson up at the county. There was recently a report done where I think, you know, every 10 years the county does a report on what the activities report and the top one's always hiking.

2:05:10 And that's great. We do a lot of work towards hiking. But one of the interesting things was they did a comparison between what the fishing community brings into the community from an economic standpoint versus what the hikers do. And it was so out of balance. The fishing community spent a lot of money in this community. And we really don't do a lot of things to engage with them. And I think that's something that we absolutely need to do. Certainly, you know.

2:05:40 From an educational standpoint, we want to make sure that they are as low impact as all of our other user groups. But then we also need to figure out how we can address their needs. A big issue right now is the bacteria that's going through all of the hatcheries. And right now, I think we're down to one hatchery. And they're talking about, and I don't really understand this. This is a little bit beyond my understanding, but there's different.

2:06:05 And then I think the last one's, you know, kind of like coalesced a lot of them into human powered and trying to make sure that we stay connected.

2:06:35 With that community, I think that is the heart and soul of Mammoth Lakes. And how can we harness them to be real advocates as well? And then the last one is safety and training. You know, we have Eastern Sierra Avalanche Center, and they're part of our Measure U grant program. But, you know, what else can we do to promote safety? I mean, you know, we recently lost a experienced outdoor

2:07:04 Backcountry enthusiasts from Bishop. And we lost two climbers, very experienced climbers earlier this year on Red Mountain. So we know that going into backcountry can be dangerous. And, you know, is there anything that MLR can do to try to address that for the community? You know, work with the Avalanche Center to do more training. Maybe find some outside funding for that.

2:07:32 Can we do more stuff on weather predictions? More education on how can we support search and rescue? I think there's a lot of things that fall under safety that we could make some significant gains in. And then moving over to capital projects, again, the same format, MLR-led. We still want to work on winter staging areas. I think that's important. We're not going to give that up. Snowplay area is the same way. Labs and Sharp Project, Buckeye Hot Springs is going to continue.

2:08:00 And then, of course, the fundraising leads on bathroom bridges and trailheads. So I'm not sure. That's probably going to be the one that changes the least. And then going over to business development, we still have the same structure in terms of donations grants. With the exception of grants, you're going to see that we're going after more private foundation. That's been added on there because we now have, you know, I think a little bit more time since we're pulling some of that time back from the R&U oversight.

2:08:29 And then we'll also want to go after some other government grants, whether those are USDA or what have you. There's a lot of money floating around in rural development right now. Then the last one is strategic partnerships. So again, going down the key performance indicators, same, you know, I think 80% sell through on AAT. The only thing that's different there is finish the Keep Long Valley Green documentary.

2:08:56 That's something that, you know, hasn't, Cape Long Valley Green, we kind of work on that when we have time, since it's outside of our primary funding source. We've got some money that came in through Annenberg, but I think what we want to do is, you know, this is something that we feel, once we get this documentary out, especially if we get the right person to narrate it, and we're talking to a few, could be a real big win for MLR in terms of getting us on the landscape, not just in the regional landscape, but...

2:09:25 You know, statewide, even nationally. I think there's a lot of opportunity here, which would, again, we could springboard into other giving opportunities. Over in community building, I think we specifically want to do six outreach events. And what I call an outreach event might be something like a movie, what we did last year with Dirt Magic, where we have a film and then we have a panel and we talk about, you know, talk about issues that

2:09:55 are appropriate to that film. We did the same thing with, David, what's the name of that movie that we did from your article? The other one with? Wild Force. Yes, Wild Force, sorry. And then the education ones would be more something where we actually are trying to get people together and do straight up education. How can we do, whether those are in market in Southern California or up here, how can we tell people to be better stewards of the land?

2:10:30 Educate on Leave No Trace practices. We want to establish a Jedi working group in town. So we want to try to get some stakeholders, you know, whether that's working with Agnes over at Eastern Sierra Conservation Corps and her contacts, perhaps working with Jolie down, you know, who represents a lot of interests of the native indigenous tribes and other folks trying to say, hey, what are, you know, the needs for

2:10:59 The diversity and inclusivity. I think what we want to try to stay away from is, I don't know if you guys had heard, but Altera just hired a person to oversee, I don't know if they hired him, he was already with the company, but they moved someone over to oversee their diversity and inclusivity. And he's a great guy. You know, I'm not going to say his name. He's a great guy. I've worked with him. He came from Aspen. Awesome dude, but he's an old white guy.

2:11:29 And I cannot think of a worse, you know, just from an optics standpoint, a worse place to kind of start from. And so from us, I think it's important that we have something that is actually representative of the groups that we want to service. And the same thing with OSV. I think we really need to work hard in our community to get OSV and bring them in so that the programs that we're working on actually address their needs and we're not speculating them. Moving over to capital projects.

2:11:57 I think that's pretty much all the same, except for, you know, we want to get that page done and hopefully that will be done in the next week or so. We want to get 100% fundraising for at least two capital projects. So that means whether that's a bathroom and a trailhead or a bridge and a snow play area, our goal for the next year is to get 100% funding for at least two projects. And then the last one is we want to get approval.

2:12:24 Forest Service approval for a winter staging area and get lined up to get that installed. And then going over to business development, those key performance indicators increase slightly. Instead of two, we want to do four appeals at 10K instead of 7K. We want to do 200 monthly giving, 200 people sign up for monthly giving instead of 100. And we want to do four net new partnerships instead of two.

2:12:52 So I think, you know, again, just trying to capitalize on our increased capacity to get more results. And then again, the partners is pretty much the same. So any questions? Anybody have any questions out there? Other than thank you, Matt, for that. I really appreciate it. It's very thoughtfully put out. Okay. No, I appreciate both scenarios because there's pros and cons with each. And you're articulating well. Great to see the enthusiasm for the projects, no matter what.

2:13:42 No matter which scenario they're on, it's great to see all of that and opportunities there makes the decision even harder. Matt, I do have a quick question for you. Obviously, this is a simplistic distillation, but basically the difference between the alternate and the current would be kind of narrowing our scope of focus.

2:14:11 And then kind of expanding our development and fundraising entity. You kind of clearly just pull out for us what would be the major difference in terms of the fundraising structure? How much more do you intend to raise in the alternate program? And is that basically dollar for dollar matching the loss of town revenue? Can you kind of just talk about the funding side of things a little bit?

2:14:42 Sure. I have draft budgets for these, but there's just so many variables, I thought it would be almost counterproductive to attach them to these. But basically, as I said before, we're looking to pursue opportunities where there's at least funding opportunities available. And so if we're doing, for example, advocacy work, we need to be looking at, okay, you know,

2:15:11 Is there anybody out there funding advocacy work? A little bit, not a whole lot, but, you know, certainly there's a lot more opportunity to do solicitations around those efforts. So, you know, I know that most of the national ones, that's kind of their bread and butter, right? For us, we would be doing it, but doing it a little bit more surgically, and we'd be going out and saying, hey, here's how these specific issues, so if NEPA rolls back, how's that going to affect us here in Eastern Sierra, right?

2:15:40 And trying to communicate those issues and pursue funding opportunities for that. Dollar for dollar, I couldn't tell you, but it's going to be additive because we're not doing anything on that right now. You know, again, this is something that David and I talked about and we'd love to do it. It's just finding the capacity to, you know, sit down and do it because it's not an easy lift per se, right? We have to do some homework. We got to build out pages. We got to, you know, make the...

2:16:09 Draft up the appeals and get it out. And once we kind of do the groundwork, then great, we can add to it. But it's just like building anything else, like building adopted trail of tank of free waters. It takes some work in the background. So I can't say dollar for dollar what it's going to gain or offset. I think other things probably might be a little bit easier, especially over on the business development side. You know, I think those are pretty clear. Like instead of doing.

2:16:36 You know, two appeals will have the ability to do four appeals. So you could conceivably double that money. And those appeals, you know, instead of bringing in $7,000, because we're out there trying to gain audience while we're doing all this, it may increase to $10,000 over $7,000. Same thing for monthly giving, we have just more resources and time to promote it, try to do work off bigger lists. I mean, that's one of the things right now is that, you know,

2:17:05 We've tried and we will get bigger lists as we move forward just through Adopt-A-Trail, Tango-Free Waters and a few other outreach events. But, you know, when I came in, I think our list was only like 400. And now it's, you know, it's coming up on, I think we have probably about 1,200, but we really need to be somewhere in the 10, 20,000 range to kind of hit these financial goals that to keep us, you know, keep growth in our future.

2:17:34 Just because the conversion rate is just low to begin with, and now with everybody kind of out of work or kind of holding on their discretionary income, it's going to be that much of a struggle. So, you know, I can't tell you exactly what it's going to be dollar for dollar, but it's going to give us, provide us more opportunities, I would say, to pursue than if we just worked with town. That's really what the big difference is, is creating more opportunities. Amen.

2:18:01 Putting this all together, and I do like the brevity of it. Question is, how fast can we turn on some of these fundraising opportunities and get cracking on them? Now, and like, you know, I would like to launch our first appeal, our first ever appeal, and now's a great time to do it. I mean, there's so much going on about all the challenges we are facing with trash and litter and, you know, people not observing the campfire restrictions.

2:18:30 There's a lot of issues that we need to address on that side, and people want to plug into that. So if they, you know, can donate to that, then we can put some money back into the host department or the host project or program. We can do some money on our side and get some of these outreach events that's, you know, listed in their community building going. We could do a lot more stuff. And so I think some of these, you know, as I said, I've been preparing for the last three years to get us where we are now.

2:18:57 And, you know, that's kind of the ironic thing of having these talks. And maybe it's good timing, maybe it's bad timing. But, you know, we're in a position right now to move forward on a lot of the things that I'm seeing in the, you know, the documents that Craig and Heather shared with us at the first part of this meeting. And I'm like, yeah, we're ready to do that. We're ready to do that. We're ready to do that. Great. Thanks, Matt. Any other comments or questions out there for Matt?

2:19:34 And I would echo the thank you there, Matt, because as we're working through this, you know, with the town, I thought it was really important that the board kind of understand because there's both are a possibility for us, you know, we don't know how this is all going to unfold either on our end or the town council end.

2:20:01 And so making sure we understand, you know, kind of the lay of the land as there's this potential fork in the road for us, I thought it was really important and for you to speak to, you know, what areas of opportunity and focus, you know, we may have before us would be helpful. So thanks. Let's see.

2:20:26 We will move on to, I think we have one more little housekeeping thing, which was before we move into our closed session, and that was, we have our schedule of our regular meetings for the coming year, and if I'm not mistaken, let me look at that, it is

2:20:54 And maybe Kim or Matt, you can speak to it. It's still the first, I can't find it now. You had the document in our packet. It was the first Tuesday of the odd months. Is that right? Yes. Yes. And so with that, do we...

2:21:18 Does the board have any problems or comments on that for a regular meeting schedule going into FY 2021? And I assume we need to approve that as our meeting schedule so that we can get that out to the public. This is not listed as an action item on the agenda. Yeah, I think it was more just getting the dates in front of everybody and reiterating the current schedule that has been set up in place. Okay, cool.

2:21:50 Information. All right. Any feedback from anyone or we can move on to our closed session and do the goal of that is our final review with our ED. And so if nothing else on the schedule, why don't we do this? I'm thinking.

2:22:15 You know, we're more than a couple hours in. Why don't we take five minutes to do bodily function breaks? Heather, or excuse me, Tamara sent us all the link to a separate Zoom and so that we can all log into that one in five minutes and then

2:22:41 And Tamara, did you also send that to Matt? Because he's going to be joining us as we go through that with him. I did not. I sent it to all the board, but I can forward it very easily. Yeah, if you could forward that to Matt. I have 728. How about at 735, we'll reconvene in this other Zoom. And then Angela, when we complete that.

2:23:09 We'll come back to you and report out from our, and all right, we, let's see, we entered, I wrote this down, we entered our closed session at 7.40 and it closed at 9.05 and no action taken.

2:23:48 740 to 905. You there? Yeah. We're all there? Perfect. And I don't have, where's my other page of the agenda? I think we all only had any board member updates? Seeing none. Going on to request for future agenda items? Seeing none. We will adjourn here at 907.

2:24:38 Thanks, team. Thank you. Thanks, everyone. Thanks, guys. Thanks, everybody. Thank you. Good work. Have a good night. Sleep tight. Thanks, Angie, for everything. No problem. Good job, Craig. All right. Talk later.