Other meetings
· recording 2 hr 18 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
284 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Tells me we're good to go. We are good to go. Oh, perfect. Thank you so much. And thank you for your patience, Angie, and understanding as we put today's meeting agenda together. You're a rock star. There's pieces that are still coming in, I think. Well, you know, we're adaptive here. All right. Good morning. I will now call to order the regular meeting of the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments Joint Powers Authority for Friday.
0:29 August 14, 2020. Please, everyone, let's see, I'll make sure I do this right on the agenda. First item on our agenda is the Pledge of Allegiance. So please join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. Ready? I pledge allegiance to the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation under God.
0:58 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. And the next item on our agenda is roll call. Angie, could you please take the roll? Yes, ma'am. As Supervisor Corliss? Present. Supervisor Gardner? Here. Council Member Salcido? Here. Council Member Wentworth? Here. Supervisor Griffiths? Supervisor Totharo? Here.
1:31 Council Member Ellis. Here. And Council Member Schwartz. Here. Thanks so much. Great. So we have a quorum of six members. So we will, or seven. It's a quorum anyway. Somebody else do the math. Next item on the agenda is item four, public comment. Do we have any public comment this morning? Yes. Sorry, having some issues here. I did receive an email this morning from
2:04 Chelsea Taylor with MLTPA. If you'd like, I can read that into the record. Yes, please. It says, hello, my name is Chelsea Taylor. I am a project specialist for the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative and wanted to share a quick update. As a reminder, the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative is a grant-funded initiative by the Sierra Nevada Conservancy with Prop 68 funds. Excuse me.
2:30 The grant was awarded to the Town of Mammoth Lakes on behalf of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. One of the outcomes of the grant is to identify the will of the region as well as specific projects to tee up for grant funding down the road. The SRTI has three important tracks, the recreation stakeholder track, climate adaption and resilience, and connection to the Eastern Sierra visitor audience.
2:57 All of these tracks will produce project ideas as a part of this effort of the SRTI will work with partners to prioritize proposed projects and identify funding sources for them. Originally, the initiative was designed to convene members of the community, but in light of COVID-19, we have gone digital and are now collecting project ideas online. Please sign up at essrp.org to stay informed on the effort.
3:23 and to submit project ideas for how recreation and tourism can be more sustainable across the eastern Sierra region. Thanks very much for your time, and we look forward to hearing the community's ideas. Sincerely, Chelsea Taylor and the SRTI team. Great, thank you, and thank you, Chelsea, for the comments. So any other public comments? All right, then we will move on to item five, and good morning, Mr. Griffiths.
3:57 Moving on to, this should be quick, item five is approval of the minutes of the July 1st, 2020 special meeting. Those were included in the packet, so I'm sure all ESCOG members have reviewed them. Is there any discussion? Otherwise, I'd look for a motion to approve. I'll make a motion to approve. Second. All right, we have a motion by board member Salcedo, second by board member Totharo. Is there any further?
4:27 Board discussion or public comment? All right, let's please take the roll call vote. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Council Member Salcedo? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Tothero? Aye. Council Member Ellis? Yes. And Council Member Schwartz? Yes. And I see...
4:56 Supervisor Griffiths has joined us and your position on this? Yes, ma'am. Thank you. All right. The motion passes and we will move on to item six, which is discussion and approval of clerical services agreement between the ESCOG and, or sorry, between the ESCOG and the town of Mammoth Lakes. So clerical services, I would turn now to town manager Dan Holler. Good morning. Yeah, thank you, Stacey. And
5:26 The agreements on the agenda today, and start with this one, but prepared by Grace, and sorry, I'll put your last name, so the, from Inyo County, and I think Randolph is sitting in at this point, Marshall's sitting in right now for her and another meeting, but the clerical services agreement basically is based off of the budget that was prepared. We had allocated about $20,000 for that work. There's a draft agreement within the,
5:54 The agenda packet there, it's pretty straightforward. We've reviewed it by the town attorney, Andy Morris, is at one or two little minor edits and it's proposed to move forward. It's based on a monthly cost of $1,666, just under $20,000 if you do the math. And then that would be billed out probably quarterly and processed that way. As with the legal services agreement that we have within Yoak County, it does need to have approval from the
6:24 Town of Mammoth Lake still, but it's coming to ESCOG first. The recommendation would be to approve the agreement as presented, unless there's a particular question on the item or some of the work, we can take a look at that. On that, we've structured each of these agreements kind of as a fixed cost agreement versus trying to track hours and managing different, because different people are involved in the processes.
6:49 Same thing with the legal counsel one, it's set for that for basically what we believe to be an average of routine work that goes into these processes. We will be looking at that a little bit to make sure over time that it is reflective of the work done, but instead of doing a lot of, frankly, a lot of massive timekeeping, it was simpler to look at a rough average estimate in terms of time and look at a fixed cost agreement here. So what we did for
7:17 As I mentioned for the legal services agreement. So with that, I can answer questions related to it. The work would primarily, it's overseen by our clerk's office, primarily done by Angela. And if she's not here, then we have other staff who would fill in and be able to provide those services to make sure it continues to flow accordingly. And this last agenda was a good example of a busy week. So anyway.
7:45 If there's questions to it, there's a broader statement in the front of this. There was a number of administrative things that we needed to follow through on in setting up ESCOG and getting a lot of these agreements between the members to provide services was one of the key elements to move through administratively. And so we're continuing down that path. And I think after a couple of meetings here, those will all be in place. So with that, any questions or comments, be glad to address those.
8:14 Any other discussion with the board? All right. Any questions from the board? John, go ahead. A quick question, Dan. The agreement makes reference to an ESCOG executive director. Whether or not we have an executive director, if we have a contractual services person, I'm assuming that would cover that. Is that right? Yeah. So whatever that is, the idea there would be, you know, that coordination effort would be through whatever designations there.
8:43 For example, right now, it's been myself and members of the board, frankly, and the attorney's office doing that element. It is structured looking to the future. There would be an executive director, whether it's a contract or a firm or a employee, it would have that function. Okay, good. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Any other questions? All right. Then I would entertain a motion to approve.
9:20 I will move to approve the agreement as stated in the agenda. Second. All right. We have a motion by Board Member Gardner, second by Board Member Griffiths. Any further discussion or public comment on this item? Let's please take the vote. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Council Member Salcedo? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths?
9:55 Yeah. Supervisor Tothero? Aye. Council Member Ellis? Yes. And Council Member Schwartz? Yes. Thank you. All right. Motion passes and agreement approved. Next item is another agreement. Item seven is discussion and approval of the fiscal services agreement between the ESCOG and the County of Mono. And I don't...
10:22 Okay, Dan can cover this one too. We have budget workshops all week, so our finance director may be taking a well-deserved break from meetings this morning. Go ahead, Dan. If I may, it's the same prologue as the previous item related to agreements with the various member agencies to provide services. It was unknown we put this together regarding what the amount of fiscal work may be done.
10:52 We put in a budget, I think, of $5,000 for it. That's reflected here on the monthly rate of 416, just a hair under that. The agreement has been provided to county staff. We have not received comments back from legal counsel from the county, but it follows the same structure as the other ones. I would anticipate that there's no significant issues there, maybe a small change or something.
11:17 The other thing that the agreement does not do, this here really looks at the core elements of the ESCOG. It's like paying the member agencies that, or if you had an ED on or other staff, it'd be paying that process and kind of the basic stuff. If we were to get into a grant situation where we have a lot of processing and stuff, either we would need to build that into the cost of the grant or have a discussion if the agencies are going to support or pay for that additional cost, because my guess would be there would be additional
11:46 Impacts on the fiscal services side of that. But my recommendation would be to take that with each of those types of projects coming in and not try to guess on an amount on the front end that could, it's just an unknown number at that point. So the contract is set up really for the basic services for the fiscal side. Anticipation there, it's really a quarterly process. So not a lot of staff time hopefully involved, but again, we'll know more as we go forward.
12:16 And if we do end up with grants and other elements that require a substantial amount of work, we'd need to address those on a case-by-case basis and either amend the agreement or have it as part of the grant agreement for those fiscal services to be provided accordingly. Thank you. Any questions or comments from board members? Is it okay that Stacy is signing both sides of this contract? I had suggested that we ought to look at either...
12:47 Somebody else here sign in or the Mono County have somebody else, but from a legal perspective, that didn't seem to be a red flag. So it's up to, it may look better if there's somebody else, but Stacey, I'll leave that up to you. Well, maybe Karen could sign it as vice chair. Yeah, and just to point out, or just to concur that it's not really a legal problem. Stacey's wearing two different hats, or board member Corliss, I should say, is wearing two different hats when she's signing it, but it does look a little weird, I agree.
13:16 So, yeah, it's not a legal problem, it's just a perception problem. So, not a problem, really. So, up to the board, if you'd rather have the vice chair sign, we can modify the agreement. Yeah, why don't we? So, we would just... I'm just asking Karen, I'm looking at her. ...to have the vice chair's signature on there. And then this will still, both of these agreements, this one will need to go to the county for approval. So, Chair Kortles here to be signing as Chair Kortles for the county. I'll sign, yeah.
13:50 Chair of the Board of Supervisors. Yeah. Supervisors. Karen, are you fine with that? I think Karen's the vice chair, right? Yeah, fine. No problem. Right. But just be getting whoever forget the right signatures on stuff, so. Then I will move that we approve the contract with the change of vice chair Schwartz signing on behalf of the Eastern Sierra Council of Government. I will second. Okay, let's see.
14:22 Cut a motion by Board Member Griffiths, second by Board Member Ellis. Any further board discussion or public comment on this item? All right, let's please take the vote. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Council Member Salcedo? Yes. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Supervisor Griffiths? Yes. Supervisor Tothero? Aye.
14:54 Council Member Ellis? Yes. Council Member Shorts? Yes. Thank you. All right, motion passes. Thank you all very much. We do have guests on this morning. You may have seen we have Holly Alpert and Rick Cattleman here for item 10. They're from the Inyo Mono Regional Water Management. So now I'm missing the last, is it group? Yep. Group program, something like that.
15:26 Okay. So I looked to the board. Would it be all right in order to honor our guest's time if we take item 10 now? And I will admit to you the reason I'm doing this too is because I would like to hear this presentation and I'm going to have to leave at about 9.15. So is that all right? And is that okay with staff? Just as long as Marshall doesn't have to be somewhere because his item would be pretty quick as well.
15:53 Oh, is that the, sorry, Marshall, is that the insurance item? I'm here for the whole meeting as much if it's necessary, but thanks for the consideration, and probably Grace will be able to substitute in here at some point when her court appearance is done. Okay. Well, let's go ahead. I always, when I'm chairing things, I always like to try to honor the guests ahead of...
16:21 Out of us since we're in the meeting anyway. So why don't we go ahead and take item 10 now. And this is just a discussion item, no action, but something I'm excited to hear more about. This is a presentation, as I said, from Holly Alpert and Rick Cattleman from the Inyo Mono Regional Water Management Group on the regional fire and forest capacity programs, potential opportunity for
16:49 California Fire Safe Council funded county or regional level fire prevention position. There's going to be a test on all of that and we're going to have to all draw out how it's related after the presentation. So good morning, Holly and Rick. And good morning to you all. Thank you. That was quite a mouthful.
17:18 I'll be speaking for the most part, but Holly will hopefully chime in here on occasion. And as many of you know us from the water work, but Holly and I have been working for the last few months on a Sierra Nevada Conservancy project that is called the Regional Forest and Fire Capacity Program. And it's part of the state's efforts to
17:47 Ultimately reduce risk of wildfires in primarily rural communities as well as the surrounding wildlands. And some of you we have talked to as part of this program, we did a series of interviews with regional stakeholders about needs in the area as far as increasing our local community's capacity to
18:16 deal with both the threat of fires and deal with the state bureaucracy and how to get funding to help with some of these things. And throughout that, we kept hearing almost all of the time for a real need to have a county more or less level coordinator to help out.
18:45 Our local fire safe councils, fire departments, the agencies, and help everybody talk to each other a lot better and coordinate their efforts. While completely independent of anything we were doing, we heard a rumor a month or so ago that the state has already been looking into this possibility and the legislature has appropriated some
19:13 $6 million, I believe, to be spread across the state, but to give each county who's interested, and some like San Francisco perhaps might not be, but that part of it remains to be seen as to whether all of the state's counties will participate or not. If not everybody does, then presumably the pot of money will be increased a little bit per county.
19:43 Anyway, the rumor that we heard initially through the California Fire Safe Council was that they would be acting as a contractor for Cal Fire, who is the keeper of these funds, and they will distribute these funds to each county that's interested. The counties then have
20:12 Apparently quite a bit of discretion in how the monies are to be allocated just in an administrative fashion to establish a coordinator position within their jurisdiction. Now, shortly after we heard this rumor, Supervisor Corliss through the RCRC received a
20:42 A one-page memo, which is part of your package that lays all this out in perhaps greater detail, and I'll refer you to that. The interesting thing here is that document was dated June 7th, and only saw the light of day in late July or early August. And a few of the details are slightly different than what we heard.
21:11 From the California Fire Safe Council. So some of this stuff may still be up in the air, but for the time being, since it's the only thing we've seen on paper, I would go with the details that are on that one pager in your packet. Now, in the forthcoming RCRC meeting, there may be some more updated information, which would be great.
21:40 But anyhow, the counties are going to be the recipients of this funding, and it does sound like a near sure thing. Nothing is ever absolutely for sure with the state of California, but we can hope that it's going to happen. Now, however, throughout our work, we kept hearing the need for regional coordination, and because
22:10 ESCOG exists. It seems that your organization is like the perfect home for one or more of these coordinator positions to make this a regional, at least two-county effort. There may be some opportunity to somehow involve Alpine County, but that's for a later discussion. But in the meantime, it just...
22:39 Seems obvious to everybody we've talked to that ESCOG would be the ideal home for these coordinator positions. And you folks being in government, you may also see that there could be some just administrative and financial benefits for housing.
23:06 a like a supervisorial position and one or more assistance within ESCOG rather than having two kind of equal level positions in each county just as a financial efficiency but definitely leave that up to you guys and at this point since we're not certain of all the details it is not 100% clear whether
23:35 There's even the, under the state guidelines, whatever they may be, since we haven't seen the fine details, you know, whether ESCOG could be the home. It, for a little bit, we know it, it seems likely, but, you know, it's not a certain thing. In the, you know, this program looks like it'll actually formally start just after the first of the year. And just,
24:04 In the meantime here, I will offer this, our services, this regional forest and fire capacity program to help out with interfacing with the California Fire Safe Council, you know, to get this thing rolling. Because we were kind of already doing this independently, we're in a position where we could help.
24:33 Our third colleague, Marlon, said, you know, we could help jumpstart this project if ESCOG is interested. So we'll just leave that offer on the table. And that really is all I had to say, because we're still in the dark on some of the finer details, which may become more clear after Supervisor Carlis meets with the RCRC.
25:03 Well, and thank you, Rick. I'll just add that right now I represent our region on the board of the Sierra Nevada Conservancy as Jeff did before me. And I know in my year and a half on that board, and I think Jeff did before me, I have really, I have, I've been trying as loud as I can. And as many of you know, I don't have an indoor voice. Letting them know that our region needs more capacity. So when this regional
25:31 Forest and Fire Capacity Program became available working with Sierra Nevada's Conservancy staff and Brittany Dyer from a group called American Forest. I think they really heard us and helped us get this, I'm going to, RFFCP is the acronym of it, sorry, another acronym, to get that going, to make sure our region was the recipient of funding and effort.
25:57 And then additionally, Brittany helped us secure, is Marlon an AmeriCorps member or Sierra Nevada Alliance? Anyway, to get- Sierra Corps, as they call them. Yeah, additional staffing to work with Rick and Holly on the RFFCP. So when this opportunity came up, all the elements are coming together. This is something that we've been working on.
26:26 So make sure the state knows we need this. We need this coordination. We need more projects over here. We need more funding. So today what we're looking for is, is there interest? So just, you know, is there consensus among this board to continue to pursue something like this? We did just have an RCRC meeting yesterday and Stacey Heaton, who's the staff member working on these issues, didn't have more information, but she knows.
26:54 Potentially interested in this. I think somebody needs to mute. Maybe Clint? And we have a Sierra Nevada Conservancy Board meeting coming up the first week, second week of September. So more information should be forthcoming. And by the way, the confusion about this is a great example of the problems we have in really increasing pace and scale of, you know.
27:24 Forest health projects in the state. Like, there's so many groups. Everybody's going like this. So, and I have also tried, you know, I think they're aware of that. But is there, so turning over to board discussion, is there interest, the question, is there interest? Mr. Wentworth. Yes, real quick, I, on behalf of the town of Mammoth Lakes, we are profoundly interested in this. We're dealing with a whole number of different fuels reductions projects.
27:51 Great work to be doing. The question always is, who is coordinating all this stuff? Edison, are you talking to SNC? Forest Service, are you talking to this person? And as you, you know, we always like to get haircuts, especially in August, but we just don't want to go maybe too close. These issues have also come up at the Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. I recently, there's a lot of discussion about fire and dealing with the regional approach to these issues.
28:20 I recently shared some information with Supervisor Kingsley, who had expressed real interest in, well, how come Inyo County can't get in the fuels reduction game and shared a bunch of stuff with him. But again, trying to deal with such a significant issue as this through all these sort of anecdotal channels is just not in anybody's interest. And I think bringing this into the ESCOG focused
28:47 With a known points of contacts are accountable for this, I think is really important, really critical. And it also goes for a way that we can then coordinate with the federal agencies because they're set up to have reliable points of contacts as well. And I think it's an excellent proposition. I look forward to the counties figuring all this out. But from the town's perspective, we're highly supportive. Yeah. Yeah, I'll say as a board member, I'm very interested.
29:17 Would also like to have a conversation with my fellow supervisors in Inyo and staff because Kelly Williams has been quite active in this. So I just would want to have that conversation with my staff and my fellow supervisors to make sure the regional approach fits into the structure of what we're currently doing. Yeah, I would say the same thing. I think it's a great idea.
29:53 Spoke up initially about, I think, ESCOG taking a regional approach. As we say, maybe too often, but wildfires don't stop at county boundaries. And I think we need an overall regional approach. We certainly need to discuss it with our own counties, certainly in Mono County. But we've got plenty to do. And as tempting as it is to get additional resources, the most important thing is to get the work done, not necessarily.
30:21 Have to have it within our own county boundaries. So I think if we can set this up under ESCOG, get the two positions, we'll be able to accomplish a lot and both counties will certainly thrive and benefit from this work. So I would support taking the regional approach and going back to our board in Mono and having that conversation. Yeah, and obviously anything, the timeline on this, as Rick said, is probably early next year. So there's certainly time.
30:51 To bring this back. And of course, the way we're set up, really any action is going to go back to each of our respective agencies. I support the concept. I think it's, you know, the more we can coordinate these things together, the better off we are. Details need to be worked out. One question I have is, since Inyo County and Mono County are rather large, it seems like the mitigation.
31:24 efforts would be different per county. Does that matter? I mean, if they can hear me. I can hear you. You're breaking up a little, Karen, but it looks like my internet kind of froze up a bit. Can you guys hear me now? Yes. I just, one thing I was wondering about was whether or not, since our counties are so large geographically,
31:58 And the mitigation efforts would be pretty variable. Does that, is that a consideration that we need to be concerned about? Is that something that the coordinator would handle? I just know that like fire prevention in one area, maybe like the city of Bishop is gonna be very different than the town of Mammoth Lakes. Yes, certainly the fuel types county to county are extremely different. I don't know that that,
32:31 Makes it any more complicated that means we shouldn't have a regional approach. Yeah, I would say a lot of this could just be grant management and administration, which I don't think it matters what fuel type it is to do that. Rick, the green fuel type. Yeah, because, you know, you think we have one comment, another, we, last year, about a year ago at the RCRC annual meeting,
32:57 Through Sierra Nevada Conservancy, I and a couple other supervisors convened a roundtable of counties looking to, you know, do this kind of work, just have a clearer process and get more done. And we had a representative from USDA Rural Development who looked at us and she's like, you know, why on earth do you have so many fire safe councils? It's like, well, because...
33:22 That's how they're set up, that every little neighborhood has its own fire safe council, and that's incredibly inefficient. So I think, you know, just looking at some kind of administrative support, and as John said, coordination could be really helpful, even though the projects would be different. And one other thing I would add is if we can find a way to get to some kind of biomass issues, to be able to coordinate that across the region.
33:51 That could be a very important thing to aggregate the feedstocks and the opportunities to actually maybe start getting some of that kind of stuff going. I guess the other thing too worth mentioning, as competition heats up, literally for these things, a regional approach is going to rise above everybody fighting in the trough. And so I think that we separate ourselves when we say we're coordinated, we're looking at it on a regional basis.
34:23 Go ahead and deal with everybody else fighting for their individual projects. We've got our act together and we're coming to you as a region. That separates us and not to mention it's a more effective approach. One thing that we have been hearing fairly consistently from agencies like CAL FIRE that disperse grants is that when you can bundle a bunch of projects.
34:54 Small projects together as a package. They tend to look favorably on that. So that's another advantage to a regional approach. To the other part of this, from my standpoint, and a little bit that I've been involved in a couple of fire safe councils, is that they do okay with their neighborhood and knowing what the neighborhood needs to do, but the administrative part of it and how to deal with the people above them is a struggle.
35:24 They're community members who have the best of intentions, but not always have the right background for the administrative part. So if we can provide from a regional standpoint, the administrative part of it, that's going to help them out considerably, I think. Yeah, that's an excellent point, Dan. I know that, and not just to go back to Mammoth a little bit, there's a, was it a million dollar grant, Stacey, that came for the S&C for the fuels reduction work in the Lakes Basin? It was landing in the hands of a nonprofit that
35:54 Barely had a bank account. And I think, you know, that disproportionate matching is something that this regional approach could really, really help out with a lot. And, you know, not burden these fire safe councils with the administrative work that can focus on finding grants, getting resources, getting things done, but we can bring the administrative stuff into a coherent, cohesive, single point of contact. Right. So it sounds like there is consensus.
36:25 Am I, if I'm reading it among board members, Rick, to at least keep our eye on as how this develops and potentially how's the, how's this position or positions if each county could get a court or one person, whatever it looks like to do that through ESCOG. So thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much. And I just want to add just of interest maybe to the town, but to everybody here on Tuesday, well, except the
37:00 My Inyo guys, because you guys will be in your own meeting, but on Tuesday morning, Janet Hatfield from Plumas Corporation will be giving a presentation. It's another name that I cannot remember, but its nickname is the Mammoth Donut. It's a 55,000 acre fuels reduction project proposed on Inyo National Forest lands around the town of Mammoth Lakes and in Mono and Madera counties, because it includes the Reds Meadow area.
37:29 So I think that, you know, that's something SNC has funded some pre-planning work on that project, but it's going to take so much coordination because it'll involve, you know, multiple areas and potentially multiple communities. So pretty exciting, but it's a good example of maybe why we need even more coordination. So thank you very much. Thank you all.
37:59 And Stacey, could you please pass along the invitation to the SNC meeting? I'd like to attend. Okay, yeah, it's the, I think September 10th is the date. And it was supposed to be in Shasta County, but obviously it's going to be here in Zoom, in Zoom land. So thanks very much. Any further comment or is there any public comment?
38:35 There's no one in Sweet Z and I have no public comments at this time. Then we will move and I'll check here. We of course have other esteemed guests with us today for item 13. Thanks, Rick. So I will, I look to the rest of the board. I'm going to leave here momentarily how you want to proceed, but we just completed item 10. So actually, Karen, I'll go ahead and turn the meeting over to you.
39:06 to run, and I'll be disappearing here shortly. And I'll leave it to you to decide where you want to go. Okay. Sounds good. Bye, Stacy. Internet connection is a little unstable. Can you guys hear me? You're coming across a little unstable, Karen. Can you guys hear me? It looks like my internet seems to be somewhat unstable. Karen, you're...
39:53 You're bouncing in and out if you wanted to assign this to a different board member. That's better. Sorry, my internet seems to be a little unstable. Karen? Karen, do you have a landline wireless phone near you? Sometimes that can make the internet's contact unstable. If you can unplug a telephone, if you have a wireless...
40:30 Telephone and move the receiver away, you may have a more stable connection. A handheld landline. Can you guys hear me now? Yes. Sorry. I'm going to call in. Okay. I'm going to make an executive decision as past chair to move on to the Sustainable Recreation Partnership Meeting, which I believe is what our guest.
41:38 Are here for, is that correct, John? Is that item 11? Actually, Jeff, it would be item 13 if we wanted to. Item 13. I'll move to item 13 and let you take over, Mr. Wentworth. Excellent. Thank you very much. If that's okay with everybody here at the ESCOG, we'll move on to that item. So we're very pleased to have a number of folks associated with the Innovative Finance for National Forest grant.
42:05 I'm going to put up a presentation. While I'm doing that, I'm going to introduce you to Laura Drescher, who will give a quick introduction for some of the folks on the line, and then Laura will take us through a brief presentation that I will share from my screen. So I'll put that presentation up now, and Laura, go ahead and tell us who we need to know. Great. Thanks, John. First of all, can everyone hear me okay?
42:35 Yes. Thumbs up or not. Awesome. So it's great to be here with you all. My name is Laura Drescher. I work for a firm called Quantified Ventures, and you'll hear more about us in a minute, but we're excited to be working with John and our partners at the Inyo National Forest on this project. We have a couple of other folks from the Innovative Finance for National Forest Grant Program here. So, John, if you advance to slide two, we can just go ahead and let...
43:00 Jeff and Spencer introduced ourselves and then my colleague Seth and I will talk more about our firm and what we're doing on the project. Great. Well, thanks everybody. It's good to be with you this morning. My name is Jeff Lerner. I'm a consultant with a group called the U.S. Endowment for Forestry and Communities. We're one of three partners in this brand new grant program called the Innovative Finance for National Forests program.
43:30 This is the first time that all three of us have worked together as a partnership, so it's kind of exciting for us, but it is a brand new program, and it's really trying to address big challenges associated with forest health and recreation using the power of finance, and the primary focus of the program has been on the national forest system, so places like the Inyo National Forest.
43:55 but also can be on adjacent lands and the different communities that intersect with those different national forest lands. We have just started making grants this year and those grants are for exploring, building, and applying finance tools to some of these larger scale projects like some of the campground work that needs to be upgraded in your area. And that's where John's group
44:22 MLTPA comes in, and they were one of our, among our, one of our first set of grant recipients, and their consultant partners, Quantified Ventures, and so I was going to turn it back over to, to, to Laura at this point, but, but before I do, Spencer, do you want to introduce yourself and, and give us a little perspective from NFF? Thanks, thanks, Jeff. Hi all, my name is Spencer Plot.
44:49 I'm with the National Forest Foundation and I'm the Conservation Finance Program Manager for National Forest Foundation. NFF is a congressionally chartered non-profit to be the Forest Service's basically non-profit partner and we serve to help develop and create public-private partnerships that facilitate restoration of our national forest lands.
45:18 So in this role, I serve as a technical support and also kind of looking at these projects really broadly to kind of learn the tools that all of our grantees are advancing and hopefully being able to bring those to bear on not only these projects but beyond these projects as well. So we are really trying to learn from this program.
45:46 Learn from all the innovation and ideas that our grantees are bringing forward and just really excited to be able to be a part of this process and want to say thanks to John for inviting us to this and really impressed with the work so far and can't wait to see what comes out of the work that QB and John and the Forest Service will be doing together.
46:13 Thanks, Spencer. So, John, if you advance to the next slide, and Seth, you can go ahead and introduce yourself and our firm, and then we'll talk about this specific project that we're here to just briefly introduce to you all today. Yeah, great. Thanks, Laura, and thanks for the IFNF team and John for giving us the opportunity to introduce ourselves. So my name is Seth Brown. I'm a director at Quantified Ventures.
46:41 We heard a lot about finance through this Innovative Finance for National Forests, and that's really our role and value-add in this project. We bring funding and financing to projects that address some sort of social, environmental, or health challenge across the country.
46:55 We work with local governments. We work with councils of governments. We work with organizations that have established joint powers authority. We work with nonprofits and large health insurance companies. But the theme and takeaway from our work is that we're trying to get beneficial projects funded. And the way in which we do that is by focusing on the outcomes that that project is supposed to achieve.
47:18 So if you have an environmental project, you're assessing and estimating and evaluating the environmental outcomes associated with that project. We put a dollar value on them and we talk about the cost savings or the cost that happens when you don't do this project in order as a tool to get that project funded. And we believe that that actually increases the likelihood of funding because you're able to pull people into the transaction or the funding stream that normally would be outside of it.
47:48 So by talking about how a farmer manages his land can actually affect downstream water utilities, if we can measure and evaluate that, we can connect those dots and work across the bridges to make that happen. So outcomes drive all the work that we do. We do work in four practice areas. We do work in urban and coastal resilience. That's helping cities adapt to the challenges associated with climate change, stormwater management, coastal resilience, things like that. We do work in...
48:17 Agriculture, that was that reference I just gave you of working with upstream farmers and implementing regenerative agricultural practices, looking at, you know, pollution reduction while also sequestering carbon, stacking those payments, coming up with creative strategies to really scale up more environmentally beneficial farming solutions. And then we do work with forestry and land use, which is why we're here today. We're a partner of the U.S. Forest Service. We have a few of these IFNF grants, which we're implementing with forests across the country.
48:45 Laura's going to go in greater detail about the work we're doing on the Inyo with John. And so we're excited about sharing our learnings as we go through this long process with you guys. And it's really nice to have a forward-thinking place that is actually...
49:01 Creating structures to solve issues of mutual concern that don't just sit at the local or county or federal level, but can be dealt with cross boundaries regardless of who the landowner is. And that's a lot of the kind of things that we think about. So it's exciting that you guys have this entity in place and we'll definitely be seeing you guys as a partner as we work through this. So from that, I mean, that is the overview of Quantified Ventures and some of the work we address. And I'll pass it to Laura as she talks about this specific work.
49:30 We're available and hopefully we'll be engaging with you guys, but I just wanted to make sure you know who I was, Seth Brown, and my email is on the end of this deck, which has been provided for you guys, and so looking forward to getting to know you guys. Thanks, Seth. John, if you want to move it to the next slide, I can talk about, so we're engaging you all, we're really just introducing ourselves at the beginning of this project. So we're just, we want you to know what we're working on. We don't have anything concrete to share with you all yet.
50:02 But we're kind of going to lay down a placeholder for, you know, when we do, we'd like to re-engage with this group. As Seth said, the projects that we work on often touch, you know, multiple players and multiple jurisdictions. And we're super excited that you all have a structure in place or that you're actively forming to help address some of those issues. So we see this Council of Governments as a key partner in this project.
50:30 So what is this project? What are we trying to do? The scope that we've defined in working with John at MLTPA and with the Inyo National Forest is that the campgrounds on the national forests do not meet current needs. And we've had conversations about different reasons for that in terms of layout, you know, what campers are driving to campgrounds, climate change is putting additional pressures. Now we have...
50:55 COVID-19 that's creating additional pressures, additional demand, and some different needs than in non-pandemic times. So we're looking to put together a business plan that addresses a lot of these things. And we're looking at doing that in a couple of different ways. So the first activity, we're going to work on this for about nine months to put together this business plan in conjunction with MLTPA and the National Forest.
51:24 And the first component, we'll look at the profitability of the current permits for those campgrounds. What does that permit structure look like? What campgrounds are generating revenue? What campgrounds have opportunity to generate more revenue? If these three things changed on the campground, that kind of thing. And there, we're really helping the national forest to
51:50 and form the next round of permitting that they're preparing for in next year. So how do we set up a structure that can, through the permitting process, incentivize some of these improvements that are needed and are not being incentivized right now through the current permit structure. But then we're going to bring in some of what Seth was talking about, about looking at other outcomes, other outcomes from projects.
52:18 And bringing in other stakeholders that in some way benefit from those projects and are not traditionally part of those transactions. So we're going to build that into the financing strategy, investments from the concessionaires with this outcomes-based financing that I'm talking about. So that'll require, of course, identifying which projects, identifying...
52:42 You know, who or what organizations are benefiting from that, bringing them to the table to talk about, you know, what a transaction could look like. And I think this would be a juncture that we would expect to engage or hope to engage with some of the members of this council of governments on. And then our final phase will be this implementation plan. So based on what we found in the profitability study.
53:09 What we've come up with partners for the financing strategy. We will come up with a plan for the National Forest to finance these components of this project. And I want to stress that that plan is really based on input from stakeholders, people on the ground.
53:31 It's not just us, you know, sitting in a room coming up with this strategy and we think these things could work. We're going to try and truth that with do stakeholders think this is viable and are stakeholders bought into this potential. So the purpose of today's conversation is really an introduction to allow for some later engagement, you know, probably when we're looking more at the financing strategy.
53:59 We've identified the improvements and we're ready to start talking about, you know, this is what we see on the permit side here. Maybe these are some gaps. Let's talk about, you know, what is the impact of these projects and how can we use that to inform a financing strategy? John, if you skip to the next slide and then I'll just ask if there were questions at the end. I'm not going to go over this timeline. This is just provided to you to show, you know, we're working on a
54:31 on a nine-month time frame, and we're anticipating to engage stakeholders, this group and other groups throughout that process as we learn more. John, if you skip to the next slide, I'll just highlight for you all a couple of next steps. I think I mentioned this in the last, just to hit it home. So we, Quantified Ventures, are working with
54:55 The National Forest and with MLTPA to first identify those campground improvements. What are we trying to finance? What's the scope? What's the cost? And then that will allow us to think more broadly about, well, how do those benefits, you know, or how do those projects, what other outcomes are possible from those projects?
55:18 The second next step that's listed here is to conduct that profitability study, and that will focus on concessionaires and the permit structure. We'll be working closely with the National Forest on that, but then we envision re-engaging this group on that financing strategy, which would be inclusive of concessionaire contributions, maybe looking as well at this outcomes-based financing that Seth mentioned, where we're bringing other partners to the table.
55:46 Based on benefits that they might receive from the projects that we're exploring. So we're working closely with MLTPA and the National Forest on all of this. I believe, John, that's my last slide. If you advance to the next one, we can confirm. Here's all our contact information. So you see we have a couple of folks from Quantified Ventures on the team. Nora and Adam represent the Inyo National Forest on our team. John's working closely with us. And Sherry, who's on the line, is with
56:16 Region 5 of the Forest Service. So if you have any questions, you can reach out to any of us after this meeting. But I also want to pause right now and see if there are any questions from what I just mentioned. Thanks very much, Laura. Any questions from the ESCOG? I know that Pancho Smith was going to be on the call. He's the Indian National Forest Supervisor, Acting Forest Supervisor.
56:44 They're dealing with some internal HR issues, I believe, and Nora's been involved in that. Sherry Reckler, you are with Region 5 of the Forest Service. Anything you want to add to any of this, or are you good? I'll take that as an affirmative. Okay, any ESCOG members, any questions? I am good. Sorry, I couldn't get myself off of mute. Okay, good. Thank you, Sherry. Jim, I think you're muted. Did you want to speak or no? No, I have one simple question, John.
57:23 Would this kind of project here also result in like increase in campgrounds? I know I'm listening to it as I'm trying to figure out what exactly it is. Would it result in an increase in campgrounds? Just because I know looking at ESSRP notes and stuff that being overrun and people just kind of camping everywhere, the demand is there, but we're not meeting. In fact, you know, in the past, Forest Service has actually, you know, closed.
57:51 Campgrounds, and now we're seeing the results of that. So is there that on the horizon of actually expanding campsites? Yeah, I don't want to speak for the National Forest, and I don't think we've gotten to the point yet where we're identifying specifically what we're doing on those campgrounds, but we have been discussing that increase in demand and how improvements or relocating campgrounds or possibly increasing capacity.
58:19 Could help address that demand issue. So I'm not going to promise that we're considering more, but it's definitely part of the conversation, that increased demand. Yeah, Laura, because I see that as being, and what Seth was talking about, the environmental concerns, being a driving factor. Do you manage it and put it into a spot, or do you have people just kind of doing whatever they want to do to the land, actually causing more environmental problems, or do you have an area where people can...
58:48 I guess follow examples and see how to do stuff right. I know in Jeff's notes on the ESSRP, there's a lot of people up here who this is their first time being out and they're just kind of figuring it out that why you can't dump this here. And so thank you. Laura, thank you for being here and for this presentation. That's really interesting. And I know you touched on this really briefly right at the beginning. Can you just quickly review?
59:15 The sources of funding that Quantified Ventures will be using, some of the examples of the funding. Examples of funding that we would be using to support these campground improvements, for example? Correct. Yeah, yeah. So one key piece is definitely going to be from the concessionaires and the permit structure. So we've worked in other projects where we've looked at, can you structure the permit in a way that
59:45 Through a longer horizon, incentivizes the permittee to contribute some money for capital improvements up front. So that's an example of something that we're looking at. We've also briefly touched on this concept of outcomes-based financing. We use that to bring in other folks who benefit from the projects and see if they might
1:00:10 be willing to contribute based on the value of the benefits that they receive. So, for example, we're looking in Colorado at a project to create a revolving fund for forest health treatments to mitigate wildfire risk. And we're looking there at an intergovernmental entity that would organize a collection of local beneficiaries or payers.
1:00:38 Who would contribute to repaying money from the fund based on their, you know, reduced risk of wildfire that they received from the treatments. So we don't yet have a sense here of what that translates to for the Inyo, but that gives you a sense of, you know, we would be identifying the projects with the Inyo and then thinking about, okay, what other groups or organizations or towns
1:01:07 Um, benefit from us doing these things, um, and what kind of a, um, you know, financing strategy can we put together that, that brings, brings the resources that we need to bear to solve the problem. Yeah, Linda, I want to add, there's two, two things to keep in mind. LADWP, um, as a huge multi-billion dollar public utility, there are models for this in Colorado.
1:01:33 The Denver Water Utilities has worked with upstream benefits to recreation, things like that. And also, I think I've shared with you all this document that just came out from USDA Rural Development, Recreation Economy, USDA Economic Development Resources for Rural Communities. We've talked a lot about USDA Rural Development, how they could possibly come in and be a partner to this. And, you know, the role for the ESCOG is kind of to be determined.
1:02:01 But the authority, the ESCOG now has, with the Joint Powers Authority, there may be opportunities to broker a lot of these financial opportunities that we're looking for quantified ventures with that business plan to bring to the table to figure out how to structure it. Pancho was, again, was going to be here this morning. We've had good conversations about the identification of the current spider web that exists in the Eastern Sierra of authorities between the Forest Service, the federal government, the counties with their authorities in the state.
1:02:31 And the challenge here really is to start getting all that stuff aligned, figured out, get it clean, simple, and straightforward so that we can identify sources of capital and financing to do these campground improvements initially, but then to migrate that into a whole series of other infrastructure improvements that will benefit the region. Okay, thank you. That's very helpful. I appreciate that. I'm very enthused about this possibility. I was involved in
1:03:02 Developing the original concessionaire program with the Forest Service 30-ish years ago. And it was because of the yo-yo that the Forest Service goes through with funding the recreation program and all of their programs. And so I think this will be a good step forward. My caution is that when we're looking at improvements, we need to make sure that we're looking at
1:03:27 Things that may actually reduce maintenance costs rather than just increasing them because funding is not stable. And so if we're increasing the amount of funding that whoever administers campgrounds is having to deal with, we may be putting them in a spot later that they're not able to deal with. So if we're looking at improvements, let's see if we can do things that reduce costs rather than increase costs.
1:03:56 Can I just add a comment to that too? Just so you guys can think about that is we're looking at these challenges and a lot of the scope and how we do our financial structure is what problem are we trying to solve? Yeah. And I wanted to bring up an example in Ohio, which is where we're looking at a large scale mountain biking trail system network as an economic development play.
1:04:17 The idea that you build this, you have new visitors come, you can capture some spending associated with those visitors, and then have an increase in the tax base from sales tax and hotel tax and a few other things. We were able to work with the local governments to establish a council of governments and increase their funding to that council based on the increase in taxes that they were receiving. But the problem isn't just how do I build a trail, which is a huge problem.
1:04:42 The other is the Forest Service and the local government don't want to trail if they don't have the funding to maintain it. And so how do we create a sustainable structure to not only, you know, I think when you think about these things of solving issues of mutual concern, maintenance is going to be something that is going to go forward. And so how you have the structure to make this done sustainably is the kind of problems that we're talking about in having funding streams that are there, not only to repay money that was borrowed potentially, but to have
1:05:11 The government structure and governance, whether it's an actual government or just an organization, to think about where money needs to be employed and what issues need to be deployed so that it's not just a one-off thing. It's something that can be sustainably there. So that'll be like the root of a lot of the work we're trying to do with y'all. Yes, good. Thank you. Any other questions for the group here? Well, great. Thank you very much. Laura, Seth, Jeff, Spencer, Sherry.
1:05:44 The introduction piece of this is real. I would anticipate that Quantified Ventures is going to be reaching out to each members of the ESCOG as stakeholders, and they're going to be seeking your specific advice and insights. So looking forward to that effort. Also for members of the ESCOG, every time you see MLTPA represented in the slide deck, imagine swapping that out with ESCOG.
1:06:09 You know, these are the kinds of projects that the ESCOG could very easily have been playing the role that MLTPA is playing going forward. We're happy to play that role for the moment, but this is all part of the kind of capacity building strategy and examples for the ESCOG going forward. So thank you all very much. Karen, I think you're back. It looks like your connection is stable and happy, so I'll certainly defer and bring this back to you. Thank you all very much. We'll see. I don't know. It seems iffy.
1:06:39 Yeah, it kind of does seem kind of iffy there. So in that case, I'm going to defer back to Mr. Griffiths. Jeff, do you want to point us to a next agenda item? Okay, I'm double computering here. Let's then go to item number eight, which is an update on liability insurance and request for a quote. Perfect, thank you.
1:07:14 And who is leading this? Which staff person is this town of Mammoth Lakes that was doing this? Yeah, if I can take the lead on it. Okay, great. I'm not sure who's sharing their screen, but we can drop that off. Oh, I'm sorry, yeah. I wasn't sure if that was. There you go. There we go, thanks. Yeah, the insurance element was one of the administrative work programs to look at liability insurance for the ESCOG members.
1:07:41 Again, out of Marshall's office working with Grace. They had reached out to their risk manager in Inyo County. They had reached out to Alliant, I believe, as the potential provider of insurance to do a quote-up. We've provided that information to the insurance agent to do the review on that. I think a number of us use Alliant for insurance purposes.
1:08:05 But we should be getting a quote back shortly. It'll take us some calls and follow-up and probably some additional detail information to be provided. The estimated cost is probably in the $5,000 range. Until we actually get a formal quote back, though, we won't know. It's pretty limited in scope, really focused on the liability components for the ESCOG. I think there's a vehicle insurance requirement in there. It seems like there's one other item that I'm not remembering now.
1:08:35 But Marshall's staff has been helping out, coordinate that through along with Daniel County Risk Manager. So we wanted to give you an update. If we get that quote back and it looks favorable and we get it squared up, it would come back to ESCOG at your next meeting for consideration at that point. I don't believe that has to go back to any of the other bodies. It would just be an ESCOG action. I'll refer to Marshall on the process for that. And yeah, I have nothing to add to that. That's my understanding. Okay.
1:09:06 Thanks, Marshall. And Grace, again, has been great, Marshall, from your office, helping coordinate this. So pass that. Thank you on. Thanks. So we just wanted to give an update on that as we try to narrow down the number of administrative items that were on the list to get done as the formation of the ESCOG goes forward. Also been looping Bob Gardner in this. He was kind of assigned or jumped into helping making sure this stuff happens. So, Bob, thank you.
1:09:36 Okay, thank you all for your work on that. Do we have any questions for staff? If not, we'll move on to item number nine, which is discussion regarding executive director recruitment for the ESCOG JPA, requests for qualifications and contract for services. Yeah, we can lead out on that as well and then open it up for questions for the board. The item here, discussion previously for executive director was to look at
1:10:09 There were three options initially looked at. One would be hiring somebody directly into the ESCOG that has some additional costs and challenges with it as an option. The other one was contracting with one of the existing agencies. None of us, I think, were able to really identify a staff person that would have that capacity to spend, you know, half time or better providing services for the ESCOG.
1:10:36 The other one was to look at an independent contractor. Reach out for a contract employee, so to speak, that's somebody who had the skills and abilities and then for ultimately for a fixed scope of work and contract dollar amount would be able to provide those executive level services for the ESCOG. The two elements here, one would be a sample.
1:11:01 Agreement for those types of services. The Inyo County one is presented here. I'd have to go back and look at whether or not it would stay with Inyo County as the contractor or if it would actually be used the same agreement but make it an ESCOG agreement. The formation documents provides the authority of ESCOG to enter into contracts and agreements. So that would be...
1:11:24 Yeah, it would be ESCOG. The Inyo is just an example of a standard contract. We'd modify it to be an ESCOG agreement. Okay, thank you, Marshall. Yeah, that was going to be my assumption, but I wanted to make sure. So you see the type of agreement. I think all the agencies have something very similar to this when they do professional service agreements. So it would lay out that component if there's questions on the items in the agreement.
1:11:53 Please feel free to bring those forward. I think the other question is making sure as we start to look at a request for qualifications that we put out, this could go to an individual or a firm to be able to provide the levels of service that the ESCOG is requesting. So it would go out accordingly. There's kind of a first cut and draft item here and really looking for
1:12:21 Directions, a lot of it on the qualifications. This is not a RFP or request for a proposal as it is, can we find a qualified individual or firm who can provide the level of executive services to ESCOG? And do we have the right scope of qualifications that we want to look at somebody coming in? Once you put this out, we get a response of one or more applicants.
1:12:49 There would be an interview process to go through and determine the best qualified, and then you would negotiate in terms of finance or cost and scope of service and payment for those services. The budget had a $25,000 allocation for this. It was kind of looking at a little over $4,000 a month on a six-month agreement. Again, that could be modified accordingly depending on timing and moving something forward.
1:13:16 But I think the first question for ESCOG would be the qualifications that you're looking for in this position to make sure that we can adequately, I'll say we, meaning the ESCOG board, if you have staff involved reviewing a list of potential applicants and do they meet those qualifications and then once you select a number one person, then sit down and look at, see if we can reach an agreement.
1:13:43 on the scope of services and financial arrangement. Yeah, Dan, Dan, if I could, and Karen and Jeff, whoever's kind of chairing the meeting, Supervisor Corliss, Jim Ellis and myself did some initial work as part of that kind of committee. We've worked closely with Grace to get these pieces together. And in the, it's,
1:14:14 I think Angie sent it out. There's a specific agenda item for number nine that roughly fills in what we're looking for. I can share the screen or just read out to you the basic things we're looking for from a contractual services person. And I'm hoping that the board can come to agreement that those sound sufficiently encompassing of what we're looking for and then provide direction back to
1:14:42 You know, board members and staff to clean up this, I guess it's an RFQ or solicitation for services, get it published, get it out there so that we can start getting, moving forward with a recruitment effort to bring someone in to help ESCOG and help, you know, a variety of different staffs are working on this to start, you know, getting someone in place to help us move forward with all these things. So,
1:15:08 Jeff, Karen, depending who's got the best internet connection, I can either read these things out loud or I can share the screen. Why don't you share your screen, John? Okay, I'll do that. So hopefully you all can see this. So it's... Can you zoom in one more time? Yeah, sure. Taking it to 100%. Is that legible there? Good. So I'll just go to the top of it. This is a draft of...
1:15:45 The document that would go out. There's some things we need to fill in, like who's going to be the contact person that we can, Jim and I instead. Dan? I had to do it. Dan, get a pair of these, why don't you? I know it might rupture the vanity a little bit, but they work pretty well. Yeah. It's a discrimination. I understand. I'm right there with you. Basic things, who the contact name would be and things like that.
1:16:15 But the services we're looking for are these things highlighted in yellow. We can take a moment to read these if you want to add anything to it or make any changes. Maybe just take a moment. We can take a look at it. And Dan, you can put your monofocal on there. So that's basically what we're looking for. I would think that we would want someone who has some experience dealing with public boards. Okay. Let's add that.
1:17:24 Hopefully you guys can hear me with my internet connection. Will this person have someone that they report to, or will it just be the board that they report to? As of now, they will be reporting to the board. And Karen, generally on that, you'd have that regular order where they would primarily report through the chair, vice chair, that process, and then the full board for decision-making authority or elements.
1:17:57 That overall direction. But as long as they're working under that scope of work and stuff, there's a high level of independence there because it's a contract position versus employee position. So I'd say, and Marshall can weigh in on making that distinction between employee versus contractor will be very important in terms of how their work goes in time. You can't really set other than, yes, you need to be here for board meetings and stuff of that nature for those elements.
1:18:26 There's a limited amount of oversight and restriction you place on a contractor other than what you actually have in the agreement and deliverables for them to work towards. Yeah, it's a tricky issue and I think we'll have to cross the bridge when we come to it about who the individual is and what other types of work or things they do, you know, and try to finesse the independent contractor distinction as best we can. Yeah, and that just for all of us, that relates to, is it AB5?
1:18:56 Marshall, the state legislation that now governs independent contractors? Yeah, there's that. But even before that, it's just, as you may know, one of those areas where, I mean, you can't just arbitrarily declare someone you hire to be an employee. I mean, sorry, to be an independent contractor. There's tests you have to run. And it's, you know, you see what side of the ledger, the more of the checks end up on.
1:19:25 I think there's obviously a desire here to make it a contractor-type position. So I think optimistically we'll find a way to do that. But it is a tricky issue legally. So like I said, I think probably just throw your net out there, see who you get. We'll look at where they're coming from, what other work or jobs or things they do, and how this job's going to be structured for them and try to keep it.
1:19:55 On the independent contractor side of the ledger so it passes all the different tests. Got it. Thank you. And that's why I said when you do put it out, it may be an individual or a firm. You could have a firm bid on it that have different people and different skill sets to hit the various options that you could have a team of people working on. Yeah. Well, that would be the cleanest as far as the independent contractor. And they'd have a person assigned to be kind of be the rep at the board meetings, but the delivery could be spread out.
1:20:24 Think of this as truly a request for qualifications from, you know, our community out there of people who may be able to provide that, be it an individual or a firm. Got it. So I'm hearing that we need to add an item in there, Jeff, whoever, whatever this is, has experienced dealing with public, with the boards of public agencies, we can certainly add that language. They have something on public funds accordingly.
1:20:54 They have that governmental relationships in the past. The grant management aspect may be an element that falls through some of this. We haven't, at staff level, we haven't sat down, I don't believe Ron or Clint Dryad really tried to walk through this from a staff perspective at this point. If you want us to do that, we could, I'm assuming, but really wanted to lay it out to the ESCOT board and say, you know, what skill set are you looking for?
1:21:28 Would it make sense for the first year to have them, the firm or the individual report to one of our administrative heads? It seems like given that we don't really know the scope of the work, I mean, we know it's very, like they're going to be kind of creating their job and we don't quite understand the workload and the workload could be a lot or a little given different.
1:21:57 Projects going on. But it seems like it would be hard to manage this without someone directly overseeing you. Unless this person gets paid really, really well and they've done it before. I don't know. You know, that does become one of those issues, though, where the more oversight and supervision they have, the more they look like an employee. So, you know, hopefully you get someone who's
1:22:26 Have an independent mind who works independently without that sort of supervision and who's comfortable working with direction from your board. You know, that's really the ideal situation and would work best as well for qualifying as an independent contractor. Karen, I know when we had this discussion with John and I and that was the thing, you know, for the money that we're putting at it, it's how much can you get? How much can you expect?
1:22:59 And there was some, you know, questions there of where can we, what kind of, not what kind of quality, but how much load can you put on here for the money that we're putting out? It's going to have to be kind of a fluid that this might change a year or two down the road when the funding sources also start to change. Yeah, it's very much little chickens, little eggs, and baby steps in the middle of all that, so.
1:23:27 I think we just got to jump in here and see how it goes and adjust as we need to as we learn more. But we got to get on with it. So let's get on with it. Yeah. So, Bob, in that spirit, I think what we're all hearing is please, you know, work with Grace. Jim, it's you, me, and Stacey a little bit working with Grace and whatever staff we got and add qualifications around.
1:23:56 Experience working with public boards and also experience dealing with public funds. Add that to these things we've got highlighted in yellow. If that's a pleasure of the board, we can certainly do that and then we'll work with Grace, some combination of Grace, Marshall and Dan to finalize the document, get it out there and we'll start recruiting. Yeah, John, I actually like that, those additions just because that kind of ensures that we...
1:24:24 That we don't run into problems down the road if they have at least that background. Yeah, for sure. That makes good sense. So, Jeff and or Karen, do we need a motion or how should we proceed on this one, do you think? I think we can take it from a staff level. I think you got direction to us to kind of clean this up. I'm assuming the three of you can take a look at it again as a subcommittee and then put it out on the street.
1:24:55 Okay, I know Jim and I are good for that. We will certainly speak for Stacey on that one as well. I'll defer to Ron and Clint if they want to, you know, provide comment or input into it as the other administrators here. I don't know if Bob was able to get on the call or not, Lawton, but if they want to walk through and add any additional insights. I'm fine with it. This is Ron. Okay, thank you, Ron. Okay, sounds like we have direction and...
1:25:28 If anybody wants to add anything, now's the opportunity. But if not, we will move on. Thank you so much for that work. It's exciting. And we will move on to item number 11, which is an update on the ESSRP, including partnership meetings on July 6th and August 3rd.
1:25:49 And review for future opportunities for ESCOG engagement and update on the status of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator in Mono County. And I assume that is you, Mr. Wentworth. Thank you, Mr. Griffith. Yeah, I'll wade into this. In the packet, sounds like Jim's had a chance to look at them or the meeting notes from the SSRP meetings. They continue to be productive, helpful, and they really continue to make sense for the region.
1:26:19 One thing I think is the ESCOG, we need to be mindful of Brown Act issues with the configuration of members from the ESCOG showing up on those meetings. And I think they are informational meetings at this point. So I would defer to and recommend to each ESCOG member individually, just running it through your Brown Act lens to make sure we're doing right by all that. No action is being taken. Information is being shared. And just see how that fits into your Brown Act stuff.
1:26:49 I will talk to a couple of things here and then we can just entertain any questions or things we need to deal with from the ESCOG. Can you unshare your screen? Oh yeah, of course. Or even better yet, can you share your screen with your notes? I will do that. I'm going to share my screen. I'll share a couple of things here. The first thing is I'll share this screen.
1:27:16 And I sent some communication out to the members of the people, the ESSRP on that email list this morning about a very significant and important development that was announced yesterday by Governor Newsom and President Trump's U.S. Forest Service. They have issued a joint federal initiative to reduce welfare risks, restore watersheds, protect habitat, biological diversity, and help the state meet its climate objectives through an MOU.
1:27:43 Which is called the Agreement for Shared Stewardship of California's Forests and Rangelands. This is a very, very important development. And I can share if I can put it in the chat or share it however needs to be shared. But the conversation we had this morning is the ESCOG around forest health, fuels reduction efforts and those kinds of things. This MOU is focused on that. But sustainable recreation is also very specific language in that MOU. And I can blow this up a little bit so that Dan can read it.
1:28:13 And the sustainable recreation language includes pursuing mission appropriate and sustainable recreation opportunities in ways that leverage resources and extend capacity through partnerships and alignment around a shared vision of access and diversity. The ESSRP is, you know, for all of us that are working on this thing is really, is cutting edge for the state of California. And we are the replicable model through that investment, through Prop 68 money,
1:28:43 We really have established a replicable model for the entire state of California and certainly nationally. So this was just announced yesterday. It's something that we all need to be being mindful of, but going forward, the relationship with the ESCOG to the ESSRP is something that we need to be mindful of and work on. It's going to take some legal insights, Marshall and everybody, to figure out how to take an information-sharing body and how do we...
1:29:11 Associate that with the ESCOG in a way that's appropriate. But this is something that we'd heard rumors about from our friends in the Forest Service, but it hit the street yesterday. So I can put these links into the chat and we can all take a look at that. But this is a very important development for all of us in the Eastern Sierra. Any questions on that one?
1:29:41 You know, hot off the presses. So I'll put this in the chat here in a second. And then what I'll do is I'll share the, I guess, the meeting notes. I can share that. Jeff, of the last meeting, the kinds of things that ESSRP is talking about, the kinds of work that's going on with all that. So I'll share that from the packet, from our ESCOG packet. Let me close that. And let me go back up here.
1:30:10 And these are the most meeting, and these are meeting, to be clear, these are meeting notes, they're not minutes. ESSRP, again, is basically an information sharing body. But you can see these are all the people that are participating in this. And the number of efforts, there was introduction to our friends from the Innovative Finance Group that you just met today. I think the value of having them on the agenda today is that they're very interested in the authority.
1:30:40 That the ESCOG is now put together through the Joint Powers Authority. And as they work on this business plan and put together a finance model, there may be a role for the ESCOG and all that through that authority. The Forest Service cannot consume money in a way that the ESCOG can. And imagine if we were to have constructive conversations with LADWP or USDA World Development. Those millions of dollars could flow through the ESCOG.
1:31:10 with the Forest Service as a contractor to do the kind of work that ultimately would be desired on federal public land. So these are, this is that spider web that Poncho was talking about, but these are the kinds of things, the institutions that we're all growing here, these are all the things we're working on. The other thing we touched on was the announcement of the Great American Outdoor Act. It's been a very big week for all of us in, for counties that are configured the way that they are.
1:31:38 with the kind of partnerships we have with the Forest Service and the National Park Service and those kinds of things. Great American Outdoor Act is a great big deal. We have requests into Poncho and the Forest Service to understand exactly what's going on with the call for projects that's coming out of Washington. We've heard rumors, well, you got to get your project ideas in within two weeks. We've also heard no, it's 60 to 90 days. We've also heard
1:32:05 Well, gee, the Forest Service, these are not just deferred maintenance projects from the Forest Service units. They're going to need representations of partnership to bolster and elevate those projects in Washington. And I'm setting up a call with Pancho. We'll get some information out to folks. We may need to have a special ESSRP meeting in the coming weeks once we get some direction from the HT and from the Indo-National Forest is exactly what that looks like. Also from the Park Service.
1:32:32 We may be able to provide letters of support from counties and towns and the ESSRP that can elevate those deferred maintenance projects and we'll keep you posted on that. So that's a pretty important thing. We talked about the trail host program, which has been pretty successful in Mammoth. I know that Mammoth electeds and Mono County electeds are talking about, is there some way that we could help with the partnership agreements we have in place between the town and the Forest Service?
1:33:01 If that could help Mono County with visitor centers and things like that, these are ongoing discussions happening in the back of the house. We touched on this idea about the metropolitan exodus, which I think is something very, which would be of real interest in Inyo County. I know you guys have talked a lot about not just bringing visitors here, but to start working on a population base. And with what COVID is doing, with digital 395, with air service coming in here, this is a perfect recipe.
1:33:29 for those kinds of economic development strategies. They're seeing a lot of that in Tahoe. I think we're going to be seeing a lot of that in the Eastern Sierra. These are opportunities coming our way that I think we really need to be talking about. And it's also very helpful to have the COVID conversations in the context of recreation. We are all seeing this overwhelming surge coming from our recreation audience, and it's very reassuring.
1:33:56 To know that it's not just happening in Inyo or Mono or Mammoth or Bishop. It's happening to all of us. And frankly, this is a statewide and a national phenomenon. And I think it puts a lot of these things in perspective that helps things like the EOCs, the public health officers, all the electeds put these things in a kind of perspective to be able to manage it well. Up until they are arranging visible public protests about visitation and tourism.
1:34:25 I can share that with the chat. I'll share that with you guys as well. I don't think we're quite there yet, but it's something to be mindful of and keep an eye on what's happening at the title. So people are protesting that there's too many tourists? Yes. And I will put something in the chat. Stacey Corliss shared this with me. It's a newspaper article. They're going to want the name of your firstborn and some other kind of creepy information.
1:34:53 But I will put that in the chat. You guys can take a look at it. But it's happening. And we had, you know, we all know that we had change.org petitions, got about 2,000 signatures in the region. It didn't seem to really go anywhere. You know, it was an actual request for formal action. But these kinds of things are out there. Through the SSRP, we can share these kinds of information as well. And that's been very useful. We did talk about
1:35:23 The entire Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative, you heard that public comment this morning. It is virtual now. So project submissions, there's a webpage for that. We'll be pushing out information to get your constituents, to get your organizations to submit project ideas for that. The climate change piece is going very well. We're happy to provide more detailed update on that. But I would like to get to the governance piece. Bob, we talked about the ESSRP and its governance alignment.
1:35:53 There's been some talk about moving from a non-funded challenge cost share agreement to moving to more of an MOU structure, which may make sense with the Park Service. That's an ongoing thing we're dealing with. And certainly the model that the state of California and Mr. Trump's, President Trump's Forest Service put together, that was an MOU. It was not anything more complicated than that. And that may be something as we go forward for the ESSRP and its relationship with the ESCOG.
1:36:20 that we maybe want to be thinking about some sort of MOU structure. So those are the basic things that we touched on. I think the highlight of the meeting is always are the updates from the individual partners, just what's happening in Alpine County, BLM, Caltrans, State Parks, City of Bishop, Humboldt-Toyabe, the Inyo County, some really great updates from Inyo County that was super helpful, and the Inyo National Forest.
1:36:47 It's just the opportunity for all of us to share information as to what's going on across the region. And a lot of very important and interesting things are popping up. One of the things coming up is the fact that the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator, a guy named Matt Perillo, that position may be moving to Mono County. I know it's part of the Mono County budget discussions, and we'll see how that gets voted on. The town is also working on some restructuring with Mammoth Lakes Recreation that we look forward to sharing with the ESCOG.
1:37:17 This goes out to this larger capacity for the ESCOG, ESSRP, where are these things going to live? This is back to that kind of spider web discussion. And how can we build these institutions as efficiently and to be as effective as possible? These are certainly things for future conversations with ESCOG and the ESSRP and all of our partners. I guess that's kind of it. Our next meeting with the partnership is September 14th.
1:37:43 Unless this Great American Outdoor Act says, hey, we should have some conversations before then based on the call for projects coming out of Washington for the Great American Outdoor Act. I'll stop sharing there for the moment and defer back to Jeff Griffiths and Chair Schwartz if there's any more information needed or any other questions answered. Go ahead, Dan. Yeah, my takeaway from that last meeting was the overwhelming concern that people expressed of
1:38:13 The numbers of people who are now visiting us in total numbers, but the percentage of those who had never been outdoor camping before and didn't have a clue what they were doing, and so they were doing fire, a lot of dispersed camping, dangerous fire activities, human waste, trash, all those things. After the meeting, I talked with Tawny at Visitor Center, and she...
1:38:42 was also concerned about that. I talked to Clint about the possibility of us allowing within our existing grant to the chamber to put additional information on beginning camping. And that I think is working. Tawny was going to coordinate with whomever in the Mono Northern part to make sure we have a consistent voice. The other part of that that I have not worked through, but
1:39:14 And I don't know how to work through, is that it seems to me that the model that's used for the trail host programs up in the Lake Basin is maybe what we can be doing to get out and about to have direct contact with a lot of the dispersed users that are new to this. And the struggle for me is that's probably the best done.
1:39:40 By the Forest Service, but how can they fund it with the lack of money they have? Is there any way that any of our groups can get money directly to them for salaries? I'm envisioning an army of temporary, relatively local employees who a few days a week go up and talk to people and educate on what's going on. The other out of the box possibility, and I don't know if it could be done quick enough.
1:40:10 is if the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Group could fund projects that the forest is already doing that would free their money up to be able to have them be able to get some temporary employees, that might work. Whether it can be quick enough to respond to this, I'm just definitely concerned that we're gonna have a or many forest fires that are gonna mess us up because of the...
1:40:37 Lack of understanding of what people have with fire. Dan, if I could on that, a couple things. First thing is I put all those links in the chat. I hope you guys can all see that. If not, we can send it out later another way. The model, Dan, I can talk with you more about this offline. The model we're using on the Mammoth Ranger District, which will cover part of Mono County, the agreement the town has with the Forest Service Trails Program, we can bring in temporary workers.
1:41:06 But then work with Forest Service guidance to do the kinds of things that we're talking about. I can send that out to you as well. I think we should look into the scalability of that, because frankly, that might be the most facile way to do this. And I think we can, we can, we're talking about that with Mono County around the visitor center up there, if there's some way to use the authorities already in place to scale it up. And I think we can report back to that group to see if that might work.
1:41:31 On the messaging thing, I'm very glad you brought that up because the town is now actively talking with Mammoth Resorts. We're trying to get ready for winter. And we're part of that is bringing together like Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Resorts, the town and others about consistent messaging. And I think through that Visitor Connection Working Group that's working with the SRTI grant we talked about this morning, they've got a meeting coming up next week.
1:41:56 We can make an announcement about that. We may have an opportunity for some members of the ESCOG to make a little announcement at the beginning of the meeting how valuable it is to have all those voices at one table and the need that the region has to get into consistent messaging. So if that's something that any member of the ESCOG might be interested in doing, I think their meeting is next Thursday. We could just give you guys a couple of minutes at the beginning of the meeting to make a pitch for that kind of thing. And I think to get us all on the same page regionally,
1:42:26 We've got an opportunity to do that, and I look forward to following up with you and some other folks to make that opportunity available. I think that'd be a really good thing to do. I think in general what the Bishop Chambers' message has changed is please join us next year considering the virus and the limited spaces that we had. Now we've opened up, and now it's a matter of now that you're here, here's what we need to have you do and not do.
1:42:55 Exactly. I think looking forward to next year is a great thing to do. And I think I'll follow up with you, Dan, on that and other members of the ESCOG. And I don't want to, you know, I'm concerned about this, but I've got limited time. And if other people want to take the ball and run with this, that's fine. I don't have to be the person involved with it. Well, you did volunteer yourself. So, Dan, you're not backing away from that now, I can tell. I can talk to myself all the time. And answer.
1:43:24 And we know what that's worth. Yeah, exactly. Okay, great. Any other questions or comments from the board? Thank you, John. And I think if they just handed out all the residents of the Eastern Sierra citation book and the authority to write them, we could solve this pretty quickly. Okay.
1:43:54 So let's move on to an update and brief presentation on the Prop 68 Sierra Nevada Conservancy Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative Grant administered by the Town of Mammoth Lakes on behalf of us. We've covered a lot of that already. I think the most important thing is that the entire initiative has gone virtual. It's working virtually in a digital environment.
1:44:22 You will be getting outreach from the team to really encourage your constituents to submit project ideas. It's very simple, very straightforward. There will be meetings coming up in the fall where all the project ideas are going to start getting sorted and ranked. And again, the idea is to take eight projects from all the submissions to get them to funding to actually build these things or build these programs or do whatever we want to do. So it's up functioning and ready.
1:44:50 The Visitor Connection Working Group, I'm going to follow up with members of this body to maybe make a little introduction at their meeting next week to really emphasize how important the messaging is and a coherent voice is going to be, and they're working very hard on that. And the climate change piece for all of you county folks who are dealing with state initiatives and state policy, we're doing really amazing work bringing the Forest Service to federal agencies together with state policy objectives.
1:45:19 And this fits exactly into this announcement from Governor Newsom yesterday. And this is the work that we're doing is going to give the region an opportunity to leverage a lot of money and do a lot of really important and forward-looking projects going forward. And I look forward to keep you guys posted on that as those things come forward. If anybody has any questions specific to any of this, just reach out, shoot me an email. I'm more than happy to walk you through all the things that are going on. It's a lot.
1:45:48 I don't want to take up too much of the ESCOG's time at this point, but there's a lot going on. I'm very much looking forward to working offline or whatever you guys think is important for public consumption or to agendize for future meetings. Please just reach out and let me know. There's a lot going on. Okay, great. The project list is a pretty fun thing to read to. And I'm sure it's going to be at least double the size by the end. Quadruple. Quadruple.
1:46:17 And get those things on that list that you guys want to fund. That you guys, look, we need messaging, we need whatever we need, get it on that list. And then we'll find money and we'll make it happen. Gotcha. Okay. Any other questions for John on that? Comment? If not, then we move on to item number 14, I believe at this point, discussion regarding grant opportunities, including USDA rural development, rural business development grants.
1:46:46 And I'm not sure who put this on. Anyone claiming this? Hang on. Let me take a quick look here. I think that that might have been a little bit of an overlap. Well, I think it might have been a little bit of an overlap. But again, it goes back to this discussion around this document here, which I'm not sure if it's made to the package or not. And Dan, I think we all owe a little bit of a...
1:47:27 Acknowledgement to Dan and Angie. It was a little bit chaotic putting together this agenda packet. But this announcement, I'll put a link to this in the chat as well, from USDA RD around the economic development resources for rural communities. I think we may not have all had a chance to digest this, but there's a lot of money out there. That's what I know about this item. So Inyo County applied for, and we're right at the, we believe we have received a $50,000
1:47:57 Rural Business Development Grant. I just signed a letter yesterday confirming that we have soft match for that in our budget, which we do. And it's the $50,000 is to do business and operations planning for the small business development center that we're looking at here that the board's been putting money in the budget for for a few years. And this is a way to
1:48:27 Get some federal funding to move that along and put some more form to it. Excellent. Great. To be continued on that, it's an exciting project. And as it gets fleshed out, we'll be sure to share with the rest of the group. If nobody has any more comments on that, then we'll move on to item number 15, which is board member and agency reports. And it's a good thing that Clint has gone live.
1:49:00 Because the first item is a update on the Bishop Eastern Sierra Regional Airport Air Service. So go ahead, Clint. Sure. So on the construction side, our taxiway project, they're just finishing up the striping next week, which means they're getting very near to being completed with that particular project. The runway rehabilitation project.
1:49:27 Started this last Monday. They started doing some of the electrical work and some of those things. That'll continue on. They have until November to get that completed. Our EA, we should have a draft of the EA for internal administrative review next week. It'll then go to the FAA and some other federal folks for a review before we issue that.
1:49:53 We expect to see that circulated probably in January. We are with our partners, the FAA, everybody else that we've been working with right now, we are planning to be prepared to receive commercial air service on July 1st. That's from a physical and regulatory standpoint.
1:50:22 Clearly, when air service starts, there's a lot of things to that, a lot of other things to that, such as, you know, what happens to COVID? Are people actually gonna fly? Are we open for people to fly? I mean, just a lot of things. What's the economy look like? But right now, we expect to be prepared to receive that service, both physically and from a regulatory perspective by July 1st.
1:50:47 We have a guy that we've contracted with, we're working with, his name's Guy Ruel, and he's been assisting us. We're working right now with United on our terminal and landing fee leases, and we've completed draft agreements. Those are with United right now for them to be, they're reviewing those leases, and we're looking forward to hearing back from them.
1:51:13 And then we're working with United Express directly on their ground needs. So we're working through that process with them. And then we open bids on for the ARF, for the fire truck. I don't know if you guys were aware of it, but that's another 100% no match grant for the fire vehicle. We open bids for it. It is below our grant amount. So that will be paid for 100%.
1:51:41 They'll get started building that. They take about a year to build. Anybody who's been involved with the construction of any sort of firefighting vehicle, they get custom. They don't start building them until you order them. And then they take about a year. So we expect to see that in about a year. So anyway, that's kind of where we're at moving forward. Unfortunately, our timeline did not have much room in it for slips or errors or anything else. And when we hit the...
1:52:10 When the COVID hit, that kind of just sucked any of the additional time that we might have had out of the schedule and pushed us back six or eight months. So that's kind of where we're at right now. Okay, great. Thanks, Quint. Are there any questions for Quint? Is there any update that anyone wants to make on the current status of the Mammoth Airport? I don't know, Dan, if you anything want to add? We've got a...
1:52:48 Pretty significant CARES grant for infrastructure improvements and updates. Still consistent with all of our regional agreements. And I know that we're moving forward with a lot of that stuff. But it's all within everything that we, you know, all the expectations have been set for regional air service. It all fits within that. I know we're moving forward with a bunch of that stuff. I guess that is one other thing I do want to mention is really appreciate.
1:53:18 Grady and Dan and all the folks at Mammoth as we were trying to figure out whether or not service was gonna be able to be in Bishop this year. They've been very helpful, very cooperative and everything else on ensuring that if folks do wanna fly this winter, that's going to be able to occur. So sorry, I forgot to mention that in my initial report. Okay, great. So we will move on to item number B, which is an update on housing initiatives.
1:53:48 I guess I can start off with sort of Inyo County, City of Bishop and Maka update and that would be that the Silver Peaks project has been approved for its pre-development loan and it's currently trying to put that package together to be able to
1:54:14 Purchase that property and move forward. There has been quite a bit of money that the state is putting forward for Project Home Key, which is a continuation of Project Room Key, which was providing housing, hotel, motel vouchers for homeless individuals during the COVID time. The governor realized that a lot of this money could be more wisely spent if they just purchased the hotel.
1:54:44 Or other property for development. So they put out a large amount of grant funding for that. It's a very quick turnaround. The money needs to be expended by the end of the year. So there was discussions at the city council meeting on whether that's something that the city is interested in pursuing. And it sounds like there's some general interest in it, but of course the devil's in the details.
1:55:14 Weather can be pulled off in time. Jim or Karen, do you have anything else from the City of Bishop? I know there's some houses currently being built. The houses being built? Aren't they actually constructing houses at the old nursery? Yeah, construction's moving forward there. We had a few hiccups with some starting a little bit early, but we, you know, great public works and our staff.
1:55:48 Ironed that out between contractors and everybody. So that is moving forward. And then you're seeing, I know it's come before us a few times, the changeover from what used to be, say, an office building into housing. So we're starting to see that change into the mixed use. And I think every community is going to see it to a point, as you're saying with the mock, you know, how do you make the best use of a older building? And we're starting to see that.
1:56:16 Kind of come to fruition. Great. So anybody from Mammoth or Mono want to update on their housing? Yes, Mr. Wentworth. I think, I'm not sure if we've announced this yet, but the town got a pretty, got a very significant grant to help with infrastructure for the parcel. And we're in the process of bringing the developers and the team on board.
1:56:46 And I know in talking with the ski area and talking about like this winter and just being mindful of the burden that the workforce needs and Mammoth put on Bishop and other places in the region, we're trying to be, you know, smart and considerate and contentious about that and all that is possible. But the idea if we bring this together that maybe some dirt would move next summer in terms of starting to putting in the first stages of the infrastructure. I don't lend anything you want to add to that or?
1:57:18 No, I think that's well covered. I mean, I think that's exciting. It was great to get that kind of money to move forward. So, no, all good. Okay. We'll keep you guys posted on that. Bob? Yeah, I would just say the county board continues to work on the Tioga Inn proposal, which is a proposed 100 units at the Mobile Mart site at the base of 395 and 120.
1:57:49 To provide housing for the proposed hotel and restaurant. We had another meeting on that on August 6th, but did not reach a final decision. Then there's some selected smaller projects in June Lake, for example, and some other communities that are moving forward. That's where we are. Okay, great. So now I think I will throw it out. Oh, yeah, Clint. I did just have one little housing thing to toss out.
1:58:22 So Inyo County had received $75,000 technical assistance grant from the No Place Like Home, $50,000 of that went to the Silver Peaks Project. The other $25,000 we entered into a memorandum of understanding with Mammoth Lakes Housing for them to develop a home rehab program.
1:58:51 So that was another thing that we did there with Mammoth Lakes Housing. Great, thank you. Okay, we will move on to other board member and agency reports. And what time is it? It's 10.30, so I don't know if we could go somewhat rapidly. How's about the town of Mammoth Lakes to start out? Linda, you want me to go first? Okay.
1:59:25 I think we've shared most of it. From the visitation side of things, things seem to be backing off a little bit. Again, just an anecdotal sense. I've been participating in that trail host program. I'll be up there volunteering this weekend. We are working very actively with Mammoth Resorts to start getting ready for winter. It's not just Mammoth Resorts. It's the entire winter recreation program. Dan, I know, has kind of a bunch of important things to share on that.
1:59:54 And we're really trying to learn the lessons from the summer, learn the lessons from last spring. Dr. Boo was encouraging, advising that the hospital, you know, we should all anticipate there'll be a functioning working hospital as we go forward. And we'll see. We're hoping to have a community meeting sometime in the second week of October to be able to advise the community and all of our friends, partners, and stakeholders what winter is going to look like in Mammoth Lakes for this season.
2:00:24 So we can start to really set expectations. We're going to be working very closely to coordinate messaging between Mammoth Lakes Tourism, the town, and Mammoth Resorts. And we want to make sure we're doing everything we can to share that with all of our partners in the region so we can all be on the same page and be consistent with that. I think the big thing we want to avoid is we do not want to get into a situation where the winter recreation capacity is, say, 15,000 and we've got 25 or 30 or 40,000 people in town. That's not going to work.
2:00:53 So we have to really put together systems that we can have a truly balanced approach and see if we can possibly pull off a successful winter. And I know that Dr. Boo is reaching out to county health officers that have ski areas throughout the state of California so that they can advocate for the idiosyncrasies of what a program like this is going to look like. And we're all just getting underway with that. And I will defer to Dan and Linda for anything else that I'm sure I missed. Thank you.
2:01:25 Go ahead, Linda. I don't think I have anything else to add in regards to town specifically, but I've been working with the public health department out of the county, county public health department, which covers the whole county, and just, you know, trying to make sure that we're able to have the capacity to do the testing, epidemiology, surveillance, future planning, all the things involved with public health. So I've been sort of drawn over a bit into that side. I don't know that we need to go into a lot of details on that for you all, but
2:01:56 We're very concerned, you know, also what's happening with Inyo because Inyo and Mono as well as fires don't know where the county lines, our residents don't know where county lines either. You know, we travel easily between our counties. We consider it all our region. And so, you know, what happens in one region of that or one area involves the other. So we're all, you know, working together as well as possible. I think that we're definitely
2:02:23 Looking towards the winter and what's that going to mean and how is that going to impact all of the disease and transmission as well as economics. So that's pretty much it unless anyone has specific questions, but that's pretty much it for me. Thank you. Sorry, John, I didn't know if you touched on it or not, but we've done a couple of things, outreach and helping the community here. One is setting up one of the temporary ticket booths from the ski area by the...
2:02:51 Visitor Center, so we can provide information to people coming into the Visitor Center. They're currently closed under the Forest Service structure, so we've stepped up to provide that. Some volunteers, others in town staff now managing that little kiosk, if you will. And then also we put some restrooms out to port-a-toiles out around town. We've had a big influx of people utilizing restrooms and businesses, both
2:03:18 appropriately and inappropriately. So trying to provide some additional restroom facilities for the community that way. We put some out on Old Mammoth Road and Main Street. We'll see how that goes. We'll monitor that and see the need. The trolley system serving the Lakes Basin has been hit, I'll say, heavily utilized. And again, they're limited capacity. So it's not unusual to have people left standing after the first.
2:03:43 One or two trolleys go through, trying to keep it down to no more than one trolley weight, but at times it's two, which is a 40 minute plus weight, so people get a little anxious about that getting up to the basin. We've extended that through Labor Day for sure, then looking at it going the following weekend as well, then we'll evaluate accordingly if it needs to stay in place anymore into September or not based on need and use.
2:04:08 But a lot of activity in town, working, coordinating a lot of law enforcement issues across Forest Town County. There's a lot of coordination happening on that and looking at enforcement levels in different areas where we can. Everybody stretched pretty thin in that particular area, so there's a lot more complaints than there are. People respond to them, but they are, they being the Forest Service initially as talked about.
2:04:34 Some systems they're putting in place to kind of ramp up some of their citations, especially for the illegal campfires. Yeah, just to add one thing real quick, ESTA, I'm not sure, is there an ESTA meeting today? Yeah. Yeah, just to, if you guys could just bring forward, ESTA, we talked about this at the LTC, ESTA and their winter contract with Mammoth Resorts and really starting to talk about COVID, how is that going to work?
2:05:01 Phil advised at the LTC, oh yeah, we got to get a contract together with Mammoth Resource for the wintertime, but to emphasize it's going to look different. People on buses, Mountain is emphasizing masks, masks, masks. It's going to be all about that, bus stops, but it'd be a great thing to bring up with them to start getting ready for what the winter semester program's going to look like. We're looking at that from a town perspective, and Mountain also just in what's going to be the allowed capacity on buses.
2:05:29 Which will translate back into the capacity at bus stops. Right. And which will translate back into how many people are going to just try to drive to the mountain. And it could affect the value of that contract with ESCO. I mean, I know it's a very important part of your budget. And just to start, you know. Same questions for their buses on how full can they run them. And under the state guidance, they have to have distancing still on the buses. But so we'll be walking through that a little bit, see if there's any options or not for that.
2:06:01 It's going to be a little problematic, I believe. Okay, great. Thank you. Mono County, Bob? Yeah, we spent most of the week working on budget and got workshops out of the way on that. So we're making progress. And then a lot of similar things to the town. Some chambers and nonprofits are stepping up. June Lake's chamber is paying for dumpsters and restrooms.
2:06:32 Portable Restrooms. We're going to hopefully be able to help them out with the county. On Lake Committee has been having an information desk out in front of their building. And so a lot of the groups are stepping up. And that's kind of where I've been to a lot of people. We're at the point where resources are hard, where it takes too much time to get resources. Everybody's just got to do something.
2:06:55 I was kidding the other day saying we ought to say to people, we know you want to come up here and enjoy your time in Eastern Sierra, but would you give us an hour or two picking up trash? And that sort of thing where it's enjoy your time, enjoy your weekend, but bail us out and help us out. So it really is in terms of finishing strong here to Labor Day and really into the fall season, everybody's got to do more and not point the finger and say, why aren't they doing more? Let's all do more and we'll get through this. That's about it, Jeff.
2:07:25 Okay, thank you, Bob. City of Bishop. Okay, Jim. Jim is running away. So Ron or Karen? I can try. Every time I press one button on my computer, everything goes to hell. But the City of Bishop is, you know, just kind of hanging tight right now. We are, it's a concern, I guess it's more Inyo County, but for the City of Bishop as well, that we,
2:08:01 have seen that huge increase in COVID cases. And so we are anticipating getting put on the state's monitoring list in the city, which means gyms and hair salons. So that's a lot of talk, at least within my business as Age to Summit. Everyone keeps asking me, when are we getting shut down? And then as far as, you know, Jeff brought up when we talked about the housing and, you know, it's been
2:08:30 Such a huge topic I know both in Mono County and Inyo County and Town of Mammoth Lakes and Bishop about homelessness. And so it's been, you know, one of the benefits of COVID is a potential purchase of a motel to help get our homeless population into some more stable housing. Other than that, I don't have a lot to report on. Okay, thank you. Mr. Ellis, are you back?
2:09:04 Yeah, just a quick update on my parents. So that was all. Sorry. Actually, I do have one more thing to share. I forgot that it's been a bit a while since I've been to ESCOG. We, un-COVID related, kicked off our Caltrans grant, which was really exciting. About a month ago, we hosted community meetings talking about our potential rezoning of downtown.
2:09:32 So what's going to happen is we are going to hopefully convert some commercial zones into residential zones and just there's a lot of community input on, you know, what to do with just a better circulation within Bishop for fostering more pedestrian use and bicycle use and more shade and more landscaping.
2:09:58 And how that all works in. So we kicked off our two first community meetings with our consultants and they were well attended. You know, a lot of the same conversations came up. So hopefully we can rezone some of our commercial areas and turn them into some housing. Great. Thank you, Karen. Let's see. I think that leaves us. Dan, do you have anything? I don't have anything to add. Go ahead, Jeff. Okay. I'll just say,
2:10:32 Some fun non-COVID things. We have a project underway redoing South Lake Road, which is progressing. There's been some delays, traffic delays, but it's going to be nice to have that project complete, very major project. The BLM
2:10:57 is currently looking at the management plan for the Alabama Hills. And I think it's pretty exciting, the work that they're doing. And I think that it's a well-developed plan. It's looking to put a little bit of control over the dispersed camping, just because it's been pretty out of control there. And so it would be defining sites and requiring a free permit to
2:11:27 Camp in the Alabama Hills that will come with some education along with it. Also looking at potential of a campground with a trail that would lead into the popular area of the hills and possibly a trail that goes from the Alabama Hills to Mount Whitney and some trash and restroom facilities there.
2:11:53 On the COVID front, I think everybody probably has seen the news, but as was alluded to by Karen, we did have a really sad outbreak within the Bishop Care Center that has resulted in three deaths so far, and it is possible or likely that there will be more deaths to come out of that. Lots of cases.
2:12:23 And then that is also ricocheting throughout the community. And it's beyond the care center, we're also seeing a pretty steady smattering of positive cases throughout the county, north and south. So it's obviously something that we're trying to keep on top of. I think our public health staff has been doing an amazing job.
2:12:51 We're just in a very challenging political and tourist environment where it's very hard to get compliance from everybody. I will give a shout out to Mr. Rudolph and Grace, our attorney for ESCOG, did an amazing job on enforcement action against one of our rogue businesses and hopefully
2:13:21 The message is getting out. We are really striving for voluntary compliance, which is so important, not just from a public health standpoint, but from a business standpoint to be able to keep stuff open as much as we can in a safe manner. So even with that, anecdotally, walking around town, I see 90 plus percent compliance from folks.
2:13:48 So I think our community is doing a really good job and the businesses are really doing their best in a challenging environment. And so I am proud of my community. Sometimes it's hard to see it when there's the crazy stuff from one side or the other to realize that, okay, most of the people here are buckling down and doing the right thing and being kind about it.
2:14:14 So I think that's all I have. Clint, did you have anything to add for Inyo County? I don't. I think you covered it really well, Jeff. Okay, great. Jeff, you just muted yourself. I was trying to like go to my other computer. Okay, I guess we have requests for future agenda items. Does anybody have anything off the top of their head for that? Just a clarification, that campground effort.
2:14:50 While it seems to be focused on the Inyo National Forest, there is an allowance, and it should be anticipated that this could work for Inyo County campgrounds and other facilities as well. So don't think of that as being just for Inyo National Forest. And as those guys reach out to all the stakeholders, they'll be reaching out to all you guys. Bring your needs forward if you've got county needs and things like that as well. Okay, what about park service and BLM? Yeah.
2:15:19 They're all going to be part of the stakeholders of this entire thing. The net is the ESSRP. So that's how we're going to cast it. And I don't think we don't have anything yet from Mammoth, Linda, or Dan. I think things will pop up. Dan, maybe you could talk a little bit about how you'd like to consume agenda items so we can avoid the burden on you and Angie as we go into the next meeting.
2:15:43 Yeah, two different things, I think, for the agenda. Last week, there's a whole lot of stuff coming in right prior to the agenda. One is just timeliness, getting them in advance so we have a chance to kind of get them structured up. The other request there would be normally if you could take them through the chair would be helpful just to make sure they're ready and appropriate for the agenda. At least if it's time in the process. If some coordination there would be helpful.
2:16:12 As we get a lot of different things is coming in from different board members. It got to be really kind of messy of the agenda item, the title, the purpose, the attachments. You had to do a scrambling right at the end to get all the attachments squared away. So the sooner, the better as far as for coordination, but also I'd ask if you would, if you could run that through Stacey, then to Angela, that would be great. So that would help just to help streamline it. If there's something that really doesn't.
2:16:41 You know, have to be there. Then from a matter of time issues, that's kind of helpful as well. So think about the purpose and the reason for the item. The other item I started at the bottom of the agenda, just through those items are the boards that have been some standing update items on the airport or housing. Just need to know if you want to continue to see that or maybe there's some other stuff like that. It's more of a board report than it is a formal agenda item.
2:17:09 Because a lot of those areas, there's nothing, we're not actually the board to take any action or do anything other than just, here's information. So there may be a way to tighten up that information exchange process as well. So if there's other items on that bottom piece you'd like to see there, ship that to us, we can add that and just kind of do it through that member update process versus maybe a longer formalized agenda item. Today it was nice, like the SR, the Sustainable Rec and Tourism Grant.
2:17:39 It was just a public comment update. That was great. Makes it pretty simple. But something like that can go underneath that type of item at the bottom there too. Again, where we're not actually asking for ESCOG for direction. It's more informational. Great. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Wonderful. Okay. Then with 1051, nine minutes for a break before the ESTA meeting. Nice seeing everybody. And I will call this meeting to adjourn.
2:18:11 Thank you all. Great to see everybody. Stay safe. Yep. Thank you.