TransparentMammoth

Trails Committee · 2020

Trails Committee

· recording 2 hr 44 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

346 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 We do, and then when Dan gets here. Okay, so we're good on my end. Okay. Welcome, everyone. Let's call this meeting to order at 3.01 on my clock here. Mammoth Trails Committee, October 15th. Angie, could you do a roll call for us? Mm-hmm. Finley Torrance is absent. Dan Holler is absent, attending later.

0:38 John Mueller. Bill Souser. Here. Elise Howell. Here. Caroline Casey is absent. And Chair David Page. Here. Thank you. Thank you. You guys may have discussed this, but you don't sound too good, Angie. I hope you're all right. I think it's just the smoke. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Thank you.

1:07 Okay, so before we jump into administrative items, are there any public comments? Do we have any public listening, attending, watching on Granicus, sending emails in, interacting however the public can? I have received no public comments at this time and I have no hands raised and we are doing this as a webinar format so the public can engage and raise their hand if they want to speak live through the Zoom meeting. Great, thank you, Angie.

1:36 So item number one, I would accept a motion to approve the meeting minutes for August 13th, 2020. One minor correction. Yeah. Under F. Under Mammoth or Mountain View Reroute. In the text it says update on Mammoth View Reroute. I think that was supposed to be Mountain View. It's minor but.

2:10 Good catch. If that's all there is, we're doing great. That's all I saw. And I move that we approve the minutes from the meeting with that correction. I will second. We have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Any other corrections? All those in favor of adopting the minutes with that correction? Aye. And actually, I'm going to do a roll call vote since we're... Yes.

2:42 No problem. Don Mueller?

2:44 Aye.

2:46 Bill Souser?

2:49 Aye.

2:50 Elyse Howell?

2:52 Aye.

2:52 Aye.

2:53 Aye.

2:54 Aye, aye, aye, aye. And David Page?

2:56 Aye, aye, aye, aye.

2:58 Thank you.

2:59 Great. So that passes. Thank you very much.

3:06 with with the committee's permission I'm slated here at number eight to give a quick chair report

3:15 I would love to move it before

3:17 Council Member Wentworth's introductory remarks just to give a little context in terms of where MLR is and then we can launch into John's remarks. Is that okay with everyone? Go for it. Great. I'll be super brief just because I know we've got John and we're lucky to have him. Just to give the committee, those of you, I know a couple of you, I think most of the people on this call have been following it, but a couple of you probably haven't.

3:46 And since we are a subcommittee of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, it seems relevant to know a little bit about where MLR is. We've been through a long and drawn out and I think for some of us somewhat painful contract renewal and negotiation with the town that began in late June. The upshot of which has been there is a contract that has been approved by the town council but has not yet come before the MLR board.

4:16 Which would get us through the rest of this fiscal year, as I think, as I understand it. I do have a copy on my desktop here. And part of that process ended with a separation between the organization, MLR, and its executive director. So we are moving forward, kind of hobbling forward with Kim in the driver's seat right now as our...

4:45 Only and primary staffer. So we are in very capable hands to deliver kind of the baseline deliverables that are established in that contract, one of which is to service the Mammoth Trails Committee. I'm hoping that John will address this and that we can have a bit of a discussion as a committee just to kind of renew our commitment to this project and talk a little bit about what are the duties of this committee and what are the responsibilities.

5:14 They're not really explicitly spelled out in the MLR contract, but there is a long document that has a long title that if I'm not looking at it, I'll butcher it, but it's basically key agreements between MLR and the town that specify a little bit about MTC's oversight. And I think, pardon me for a second, but I think I have the language.

5:46 I had it pulled up somewhere, but I have too many things open on my desktop. Well, anyway, the gist of it is to provide oversight for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System budget. And by oversight, we mean recommendations, tracking the budget, giving strategic advice and recommendations back up to the MLR board, which goes from there to the town council.

6:17 While I think that has generally worked, I think now is probably a good time or as good a time as any to kind of question some of that structure and ask ourselves if that's working and what might work better. I'm also seeing within our agenda packet a fairly nice description of the Mammoth Trails Committee in this grant proposal for OHV money or OSV money, and I'll just read that because I think...

6:45 Fairly well. The Mammoth Trails Committee is a subcommittee to MLR comprised of representatives from multiple user groups and is tasked with providing recommendations to the MLR Board of Directors that in turn provides recommendations to the Mammoth Lakes Town Council. The MTC and MLR Board are chartered with overseeing all aspects of programmatic and budgetary product development delivered by the Town of Mammoth Lakes and the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, which is a formal partnership between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Inyo National Forest,

7:15 For the benefit of the trail system user. And I just, that's not the legal language. The key agreements say something very similar that we should all reference and I can pass that around afterwards. And again, that contract has not yet been ratified by the MLR board. So I'm not sure where that'll go, but it was negotiated with certain board members in the room. So I guess we don't anticipate any issues there.

7:43 But given some of the frustration that I think has come out, especially in the last meeting around, you know, really what are we doing here as volunteers, those of us who are on this committee, and what is the value of our input? I think it's important to understand kind of the legal framework under which we exist. And then to, you know, look backwards and forwards and think about what sort of

8:07 Direction we want to give or have capacity to give and how we track the decisions that we make or the advice we give or the directives that we give to the staff that's running the trail system. Does anybody have questions? Does that kind of cover, I know it's very vague and broad and complex, but that's kind of where we stand with MLR just so that everyone knows. Are there any questions on that?

8:38 And then I'll punt these other two items to the end to my director report just to give you updates on these other programs. But I just wanted to kick that off so that, John, you've got something to stand in as you give us your remarks. John, go ahead. Great. Thank you all very much. I'm here today with a couple of very specific things I want to share with this committee. The first thing I want to do is I want to thank you.

9:12 Elise, Bill, David, John Mueller, the people that aren't present, they don't get thanked. That's going to be their loss. But I want to thank you as a council member, as a citizen, as a resident of this community for the work that you do. And to make it very clear that you perform a critical and very important task for the interest of this community.

9:31 David has mentioned some things about the MLR transition. It's an important transition, and it was done not with any kind of an idea of looking backwards, but this is about looking forward. And the role of this committee and the role that you play is only being gathering increasingly amounts of importance and relevance to this community going forward. So I want to thank you.

9:57 And I want to also know that as one volunteer to another on the MLTPA board, all the work I do at MLTPA is as a volunteer. As a town council member, Bill and I get, we get generous compensation for health insurance and we get a couple bucks a month, but we are basically volunteers for our service. And so we feel your pain, we feel your joy, we know how important it is to be in these kinds of positions and we want to thank you for the service you provided.

10:25 I want to provide you a couple things in terms of situational awareness to think about the importance of what it is that you're doing, what it is going to mean going forward. The first thing is there is a project, a funded project from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy to undertake the largest fuels reduction effort in a community in the state of California.

10:45 It's a planning grant, but this is for 60,000 acres that would completely surround the entire town of Mammoth Lakes. Given what we've been through with the Creek Fire, what we're going through right now, I'm having trouble breathing, I'm sounding like Bill right now, the reality of fire and the reality of climate change as a policy directive of the state of California, this is a critical thing that's coming the way of this community. But what's increasingly critical about that is that the recreation assets

11:13 The outdoor recreation assets that are our culture, that drive the economy in this community, have to be carefully and intelligently integrated into this fuels reduction project. All of these big initiatives, climate change, fuels reduction, outdoor recreation, billion dollar economies, all of that rubber hits the road in a community like Mammoth Lakes. And you guys are uniquely positioned to help guide us and make recommendations as to how we're going to integrate the needs.

11:42 Fuels reduction, climate change, and a sustainable outdoor recreation economy. You guys have a critical role to play in that. The other thing I want to share is that the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, which I hope you have some familiarity with, but it's the four regional governments, County of Inyo, County of Mono, Town of Mammoth Lakes, and the City of Bishop, have established this Eastern Sierra Council of Governments with a joint powers authority. It has, theoretically, the authority to do things.

12:10 Right now, it has the authority to do nothing. But tomorrow, that group is going to meet and it's going to consider hiring a staff person. So there'll be some person working on a part-time basis that you guys can be interfacing with should you need for things on a regional basis. But it's also going to be establishing something called the ESCOG Sustainable Recreation and Forest Management Program as a part of that effort. For that program to be approved, it has to go back to each of the four member organizations.

12:40 Marno County, Inyo County, Town of Mammoth Lakes, and City of Bishop. But this is the kind of effort that the Trails Program, the Outdoor Recreation Program, MLR, in Mammoth Lakes can now be engaging with something that's going to have a region-wide footprint. And it's going to be, and all the work that you guys are doing, frankly, is the laboratory for the entire region of the Eastern Sierra. The programs that Joel comes up with, the things that are in the Trail System Master Plan, these are the types of projects that can scale up for region-wide impact.

13:09 And so I just want to emphasize that you guys are doing very important, very relevant work, and that you have my gratitude, you have Bill's gratitude, and you have the gratitude and the thanks of everybody in the community. And don't for a second doubt your relevance, doubt the importance of the work you're doing, and if you ever need a shoulder to cry on, you know who to call. So that's it. Those are my comments and thoughts. If you have any questions, I'd be more than happy to answer them. It's more just an opportunity to say hello, to thank you, and to...

13:37 And to extend the community's appreciation for your efforts. Thanks, John. I wondered if you, while we've got you, if you would just take a little extra time to dig in a little bit to the brass tacks of that. I appreciate the gratitude. We feel it. It's good. We need it. I'm just, I think some of us are still sort of struggling with the structures, you know, given the multiplicity of organizations that are involved in, in

14:06 Not necessarily the oversight, but well, the oversight and the spending of this trails budget and the strategies behind it. You know, we have MLR, we have MTC, we have the town council engaged at some level. We have MLTPA, we have a town trail staff. If you could just, again, for the sake of the committee members, just kind of give us an overview of how you see that functioning. Well, it has functioned very well for four years.

14:34 And in my mind, it's very kind of crystal clear, but I'll lay it out. Yeah, that's crystal clear to everybody. So if you could just... Okay, fine. There's an annual allocation from the town of about $300,000 to run and manage the Mammoth Lakes Trust System, I believe. The allocation of that money is the charge of this committee. Joel comes to you with budgeted project recommendations. You guys weigh what he's proposing.

15:04 And you come to some kind of a decision about what it is you want the budget to be. You make that recommendation to the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Board. If they want to, they've got some existential problem with it, fine, it may come back to you to make some revisions. That recommendation then goes to the town council. The town council votes and says, we think this is a good program, we think it's appropriately budgeted, great. The town council then directs the town manager, your good friend Dan Holler, Dan, implement this.

15:33 Here's the budget. Here are the things we want to get done next year. It is your duty to implement it. Joel then works with his staff person, the trails manager, a variety of different contractors who help serve the trails manager to get the work done. Then over the course of that year, you guys monitor, you get reports from Joel, what's working, what's not working, what needs to be improved, what doesn't need to be improved. You come around to the budget cycle and you just do it all over again.

16:01 So it's pretty simple. And it works and it provides the public a level of accountability that in the past they have demanded and that they have sought. And you guys, through the work that you do, public meetings, a transparent budget process, if anybody in the community has got a question about what's going on, they can go to the MTC and they go to individual members of the MTC. They can go to the public meetings and say, where is that very important measure of our money going? How is it being spent and for what projects?

16:28 And you have that fiduciary voice to speak to the community that says, this is what we're spending it on, this is what we're getting done, and here's our progress, here's the progress that we're making for these projects. John, one thing to add to that in the secondary analysis, the other unique piece of this is once we have that initial budget, the $300,000 plus allocation into the fund, there's two pieces of that to come into, or actually there's three. One is we also do a portion of general fund allocation to

16:58 Covered Joel's time that is not necessarily maybe measure are eligible. The other element we did several years ago was to put a chunk of money in there for capital projects, you know, half a million dollars, I think it was. And so that's a critical element, too, of what's the prioritization for those capital expenditure out there. And then on top of that, unlike some of our other funds, to the extent that we don't expend the $300,000 or any of those other capital dollars, the commitment has been is to leave that.

17:28 Leave it in the Trails Fund. It's set up separately. So those dollars stay there. And so it can build or go up or down over the year, depending on the work program. The other side of that is once we do the budget with the council and it comes back to this group, and again, that's a little different from some of the other town budgeting processes, is that the MTC has really then given the authority to work within that budget, moving dollars.

17:57 You know, I can't remember if it's on this agenda now, but there's adjustments that you make in the budget throughout the year. We're going to move from line item A to B. I think Joel's normally bringing those in, but, you know, that authority to work within that line items and project list, again, falls back to the MTC side. If there's something there really that you just go, no, we don't think that's a good idea, you know, we're not going to approve that, then that's your authority to do so.

18:23 We've tried to make the council step back and go, here's a work program, but really what we're getting approval for is the $300,000 plus going into the fund and or if there's a particular allocation out of reserves for capital, that's the approval that we're seeking up through MLR to the council and then come back and say, now manage this to get this stuff done because you all know it as well as I do throughout the year, things change. We spend more here, we spend less here, we need dollars for XYZ.

18:53 And I think that falls through. I think there's been some good discussion across the board on some of those types of issues, as well as things into the future is, yeah, how do we move off on X, Y, or Z going down the road? And is that additional dollars? Does that work within the current budget? Is that part of the capital funding, et cetera, that really enhances that overall level of the trail system and the work program, again, that obviously, I think Joel's the primary person at this point implementing that.

19:22 Being able to do that and have that oversight at that level, but keeping it out on purpose, frankly, keeping it out of the political realm so it's not a choice of, you know, three council members saying go work on a trail. It's really coming back to this body to say spend these dollars effectively across the set of programs. And I think that's a key element because if it was in other places, we want it would probably be moved around and taken out of trails and potentially put into other.

19:51 Related programs or projects. And this is a really way, a strong way of keeping it there and keeping it focused. And obviously it has a council member comment right now through the mayor who's on here as a member of the MLR board, but that element's there. But the idea was to commit these dollars and retain them into this type of program and not let them be shifted elsewhere. Yeah. I mean, think of what you've got. You've got an annual operation budget of $300,000. You've got a capital fund.

20:20 There's no sunset on this money. You've got a town staff person, and you've got a contracted organization providing you support. I wish I was on your committee. Honestly, I wish I was. And I just, because I obviously am associated with MLTPA, I don't come to the meetings to avoid any perceptions of conflict of interest. But I wish if I get done with all the rest of this nonsense, I want to be in this committee. So, Bill, I'm sorry I interrupted you, sir. No, that's fine, John. You're saying some important things.

20:48 I hate to say that because you talk too damn much most of the time anyway, but I'm proud of that. I'll give it to you this time. But I want to reiterate a couple of things that have been said here. One, the $300,000 grant goes all the way back to the original Trails Committee prior to who we are today. One of the important things that we got in that, that we deal with now as the Trails Committee, is that that $300,000, if it's not all spent, stays in an account for us. Unlike any other Measure R expenditure,

21:18 Or if it's not spent, it has to go back into the Measure RPOD, which allows us to build up funds for CIP projects and other things. There are some things I think we can do a lot better. I think that there is not a good understanding of the members on this committee of how projects get in and removed from our project list. So I would like to see, and maybe I'll work with Joel on this some, because I know he's got it already.

21:47 How we manage that list and then have a workshop on an annual basis that goes along with our to inform our budgetary process of what project we're putting in and what the time frame is. Is this a this year? Is this a three year? Is this a five year? When do we expect to spend those dollars? But more importantly, how do we get things on and off? Another point, the OSV grant's a good

22:16 Example, as that thing moved along and people are asking for potential projects, this group should be meeting to put forward our own potential projects into that, whether it is cross-country skiing or motorcycle riding or mountain biking or e-biking, we need better input on how that's being moved forward to the forest. Pardon me, smoke and chest infection and everything else.

22:47 And I think there are some things there that we can do better. And I think we now will do better. As John's voice shows, I too am very excited about the point we can get to in this next year. With the restructure of MLR and being a little more active on this board, I think we can accomplish some great things and move things forward. I caution everybody on the committee, however, because I know there's frustration.

23:14 I know that Joel has great frustration right now. These things work in hideously slow fashion for the long term. We have to stay very patient and focused on what we want to see move forward. And we have to have a way as individual board members to bring forward some of the things that we want to see happen to the process. Yeah, I have to say two quick things of that. One is don't let the frustration with the federal agency become your frustration.

23:41 This is the fundamental charge of all of us in these rooms here. Dealing with a federal agency is inherently frustrating. Don't let it get to you. Keep a good attitude. Keep working. Focus on persistence. Second thing is the trail system master plan is your guide. That is the adopted document for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Build your ideas about projects and bringing things into it. Find a rationale within that document that supports what you want to do.

24:06 That's critical to keep all this on track. And finally, I know you guys got a lot of work to do today. The Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative is looking for project ideas. I'll send an email out to all of you. It takes about 15 minutes to fill them out. This is a unique opportunity funded by the state of California. I want to see Elisa's ideas. We need to see Bill's ideas, David's ideas, John Mueller's ideas, Dan Holler's ideas. It takes 15 minutes to fill one out. Let's get those things in there. That process is going to close October 31st.

24:36 So I'll send a link out to Kim. Kim can share with you guys, but let's get those projects. Great. Thank you guys for indulging me. I think it's important, at least on an annual basis, to kind of check in on what the purpose is, and that's super helpful, all of that, I think, for everyone on the committee. You guys are in the trenches all the time. Some of us aren't always, so it's good to flesh that out. A couple questions. Well, one comment. I love the project workshop idea, Bill.

25:04 Let's put that on an agenda so we can get that schedule. I think that's really fundamental. I think that would be great, you know, maybe in the new year to sit down and really do some strategic thinking about what the future looks like. John, when you say these funds have no sunset, you mean the measure our funds, right? Because is there one thing I think for us also to be clear about is that there is a sunset.

25:29 That will have to be revisited with the council in terms of the $300,000 annual allocation. Am I right? Correct. But you just have to do your, I mean, I can't imagine that the trail system is going to go away. So Dan can give you advice of when those allocations come up. But the source of the funding, measure R, there is no sunset on these funds. So the work that you guys are doing, these are legacy projects. You're putting in place a recreation system for the community of Mammoth Lakes that's going to well exceed all of us.

25:59 So you don't have to worry about, well, the money's going to run out in three years. Now what the hell are we going to do? There is no sense that a measure on is billed and damn well known. Yeah, I think the $300,000 allocations, David, is noting it's been on kind of a five-year cycle. I think we're in the third round of that. Maybe the fourth. Yeah, I think 21-22 is the fifth year. Yeah. So at that point, we'll be coming back and looking at renewing that.

26:24 Brief discussions with Joel, but I know there's an interest of actually trying to take that up some too, so. Yeah, you guys might need some more money. You might need to come and fight to the MLR board and fight to the council. We need $400,000. We need $500,000. Give us a rationale, fight for it and bring it forward. We'd love to see that proposal. And if I can say one other thing here, John mentioned the Spaniel Rec and Tourism Initiative of putting projects in and the idea of a project workshop.

26:52 To the extent that a lot of these projects are trail related and based and a lot of it's tied to Mammoth Lakes, whether it's probably at this point, probably after it's the projects are closed, but to have this board take a look at all the projects that have come in through that process as they impact the Mammoth Trail System and to have a robust discussion on those projects and any type of input back to the, you know.

27:17 Sustainable Rec Tourism Program. I think that could be really valuable to say, hey, just in looking at the projects in the town of Mammoth Lakes and the trail system here, do we have a preference of which trails or which projects, not just trails in this case, but the recreational product in the community that this group would like to weigh in on, and I would assume that would go from this group and via the MLR board and on up.

27:43 Ultimately to some of the discussions and future meetings on the whole Sustainable Rec and Tourism Program and the projects out of that. I think, you know, that the voice and the group here should be heard in that process. So I really, all that to say, David, I agree. I think we ought to have a project workshop and not just for the dollars sitting here, but really this broader grouping of projects. Let's make our voices heard on those. Yeah, and leverage, Matt Burillo, I don't see him right here. He's now a...

28:11 We now, the county now has a recreation staff person. Bill Souser can give you chapter and verse. They've never had something like that before. Your eyes look to Shady Rest. Look to the OSV network. Look to this entire region. You are the laboratory and the crucible of this entire program. Don't squander it. Love it. Enjoy it. And there's the money. There's no end to the money. Just keep working. Keep allocating. Keep building.

28:39 John makes an important point here, and I'm going to segue a little bit. We are the town's trail committee, but we are somewhat independent as well. We have Perulo. We can comment. We cannot fund for Mammoth tax dollars projects outside of the town of Mammoth Lakes or the trail's master plan, but it certainly should be our purview to comment on them and to send things along with Joel, not Joel, Perulo, Matt.

29:08 To both the county and the Forest Service, this is something we need to add to our plate that is incredibly important for the region, not just us. Just because we can't fund the project doesn't mean we shouldn't have our eyes and ears on it. And there's Mr. Perullo as we speak. So important to remember that. Also, as I've been doing this for a long, long time, each time Forest Service personnel changes, it allows us a new potential.

29:37 Inroad into the things we want. And on the 25th, I believe it is, we will have a new force supervisor. And hopefully, John, you and I can, with Dan at least, and maybe David, set up a meeting with that new force supervisor when they get here to have this conversation and to show that we don't want to push them into anything. We want to work with them to make their job and ours easier in serving the public. Another great point, Bill. We definitely should do that.

30:07 Because there needs to be a little bit of an education because we have unique systems and they should understand what the tools are that we offer. I mentioned the Great American Outdoors Act. Sorry, I digress. By the way, because Congress is doing something else, but it'll start flowing at some point. I want to open it to Elise or...

30:33 John, if you guys have questions or comments or concerns you want to share, now's a great time. I have two comments. One is I love the idea of the workshop. I think it would be great for us to get together and discuss items and kind of come together collectively to have a voice there. And if there is a meeting with the new forest supervisor, I would appreciate...

30:59 An invitation to that or just the opportunity to listen in. I don't necessarily feel like I need to speak in on that meeting, but just to get an idea of what is being said. It helps as a member to get some background, to get some insight.

31:18 And I think the more of that we can have and the more I can hear, you know, I don't work in the trenches, so to speak, every day. You know, a lot of you have that connection and I don't. So to have that ability to kind of sit in on some of these other meetings would be great. So I'd love an invitation that happens. The silver lining of this.

31:44 But this Zoom world is that that's much easier to do than all of us having to carpool down to Bishop and wait and go through security and all that. So, yeah, we can make that happen. That sounds good. Yeah, and our advisor leads that every time a new forest supervisor comes on, they make the rounds. And I would suggest that maybe you request of Kim to get an invitation into the forest supervisor to say our next Mammoth Trails Committee meeting is happening on such a date. We would love to meet and have a formal...

32:12 Introduction to the new Forest Supervisor. That's entirely appropriate. That's something you guys might want to consider doing because you're sitting on more money for your recreation and trails budget than she is. And I think you should keep that in mind. And I think you should extend that invitation and have that conversation. Great point. Thanks. John, give a moment while he scrambles for his mute button. Maybe he's walked away. Okay, well, we'll move on to...

32:51 The trail system master plan was mentioned. That's a good segue to Joel to go ahead and give us an introduction as to where we are and how we might better orient ourselves and the public. Thank you, John. Thank you for your time. Of course. I'm going to sign off. Anybody reach out to me anytime. But again, thank you all. Thank you. We really appreciate your service. So based on this item, number four on the agenda, good segue.

33:25 I seek direction. It's an action item to schedule a formal orientation and review workshop for the 2011 Trail System Master Plan for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. We'll look at the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan that's a part of that to make sure that everybody's on the same page. All I need is a vote to initiate that scheduling. And Joel, are you thinking

33:55 A public meeting on that so we could invite public to come and be oriented. Definitely. I anticipate a Zoom environment similar to this where we'll have committee members and maybe some council members, who knows, kind of as the core group. And then I would expect some time and opportunity for the public to chime in and ask questions as well.

34:24 From a structural standpoint, I'm assuming this would be a meeting of the Mammoth Trails Committee. And then, yeah, it would definitely be open to the community and public. We need to advertise it accordingly or put some information out. And again, a council member could attend or show up. Actually, all of them could listen in. They couldn't have a discussion among themselves. But as a separate body meeting, they could listen in. It would really take the stage for success as we try to do a lot of the things you just described.

34:54 that the group I think wants to do. Having a good basis of knowledge around the trail system master plan I think is a perfect launching pad. Yeah, I totally agree. Kim? Yeah, I had some thoughts about this item today as well. Are the March 2015 key agreements between MLR and town around the trail system the most current?

35:25 I don't think we've done any modifications to a perspective, but if it's something that needs to be reviewed by MLR, this board, that would, you know, if that's what you're looking at, Kim, I think that it'd be a good time to take a look at those if we're reviewing the trail system master plan as well, maybe. Yeah, that's kind of the train of thought I was going down. You know, the trail system master plan is, I mean, quite a document and with all the...

35:53 Roadblocks that we've hit, there's, you know, we haven't nearly begun to exhaust the opportunities for implementation in it. Whereas these key agreements are somewhat outdated. I mean, you know, there's a lot of, there's a lot that won't need to be changed, but it also talks about forming this committee in particular and recruiting and hiring a trails manager. So as

36:23 An agreement between MLR and the town, you know, I certainly can't speak for the whole board, but I would suggest proposing it to the board that ad hoc committee of MLMTC sit down and work with the town to revise these key agreements and, you know, as being the experts on this subject matter. I would like to get input from the whole board, even if we did it as a regular public meeting, I think having the, you know.

36:53 I'll say I take myself out for a second on that, but having the user members who are sitting on this input into those I think would be extremely valuable. Yeah, I think that sounds good. One, just sort of the complicated logistics of it is that the key agreements are referenced in the deliverables of the revised MLR contract and will those be, those will come before the board before our next MTC meeting.

37:21 So we just need to think about how we revise those within the context of a contract that's already been approved by council, since it's an addendum that wasn't attached. Anyway, but I think those key agreements are fundamental to revisit. I completely agree. And I think, yeah, a big point too is the Trail System Master Plan is, it's worth the orientation and review, but there's still so much more to do with it as it stands.

37:53 I'm assuming folks are supportive of putting together a workshop, Joel. That's what you're asking for on this one is to actually get direction or at least consensus to say, yeah, get it countered up and I'm assuming it's a couple of hours or better to really spend the time to dive into it. I would anticipate about a two, two and a half hour, which is I think standard fare for an MTC meeting where we solely focus.

38:22 On the trail system master plan and the goals and policies that are articulated in that document. Kim, I like the idea of maybe also including those key agreements in the same meeting, mostly because of to instill familiarity. We may or may not need to update and we'll see, but the familiarity I think goes hand in hand with the trail system master plan. So I think that would make sense to include those two pillars, if you will.

38:52 I'm assuming that that would be a separate meeting than a regular trails meeting too so we're not eating up time to deal with administrative stuff. It's called an orientation and review workshop. Yeah. It certainly has my support. I would suggest doing it sooner rather than later and I think trying to fit it in sometime early to mid-November seems reasonable to me before the next meeting. I would make that as a motion. Okay. I'll second that motion.

39:26 Anybody want to have any further discussion or amend that motion? Anybody? All those in favor say aye. Aye. Aye. I'm going to run a roll call. You've got to run a roll call. I'll get used to this eventually. All right. Don Mueller. Aye. Dan Holler. Aye. Bill Souser. Yes. Elise Howell. Aye. And Chair Page. Aye. Thanks so much.

40:00 Thank you, Angie. Okay, so jump right into your trail manager report, please, Joel. Thank you. Can I see the screen okay? Yeah, it's good. I'm going to talk a little bit about winter programs that are coming up. It's almost Halloween. That means snow is almost here. Crossing my fingers for some precipitation. Just a reminder about how we're operating this sheet we made before.

40:51 We mobilize this summer for staff. We're going to be using the same best practices and guidelines as we mobilize in winter just for awareness. This is the document that we share with anybody that's participating with us. And then here's a map that shows our winter configuration for our responsible recreation signs that you've seen out on the trail system. We're going to place them in the blue locations. So Lake Mary Road closure.

41:19 Mill City, Sherwins Trailhead, Shady Rest Park. And then we have more for other locations as necessary. These are locations we've chosen for winter. And if we find that there's other locations that work where we don't think they're gonna get ruined, we'll put them out. Just wanted to create the awareness there. Sherwins Access Egress Map, that is this graphic.

41:49 Recently, we introduced to the ranger for consideration for approval, a bit of an improvement or update to our access egress signs. For those of you who aren't aware, we do have three locations along the southern periphery of town, the Sherman's Trailhead, Mill City, and the Sherman's Boot Pack, where we have these big maps up.

42:17 We put a beacon checker, ESAC, Eastern Sierra Avalanche Center, we work with, and they provide us with hardware, these avalanche beacon checkers, so that people can check their equipment before they head out into the side and backcountry. The ranger has approved this layer of information that we've not been able to include in the past. So thank you, Gordon, for allowing us to proceed with this.

42:45 A map that has a lot more useful information on it. We look forward to having these new maps fabricated and put out. Does anybody have any questions so far? So I can't quite see it, but is it, are you, you're naming some of those features? Oh, I see the perch, rock chute, Dempsey Stone. Got it. So this was made with ESAC staff. Nate Greenberg was...

43:14 Right over my shoulder, calling the shots. I was running Adobe Illustrator, and we put together this map together several years ago, and now we have reintroduced this to Gordon Martin, a new ranger, and he approved it recently. So a lot more information on our maps. So that was a big win. Yeah. And also for the group, we're going to be opening up this file.

43:50 And looking at it critically, you know, for any other things that we may have missed in the past. Seems like I always find a typo somewhere. But, you know, if you want to sit down with us, David, more than happy to spend a bit of time to look over the map before we send it over for fabrication. Cool. Looks great. Yeah. That was a big deal for us.

44:17 On the subject of winter staging areas and snow play areas. First on winter staging, Matt Perula is going to talk about a bit of an improvement at Shady Rest. We also had recent discussions with Forest Service staff about potential staging areas, year-round staging areas that could also be used for winter activities. But what we do anticipate this winter is

44:48 Due to the ski area limiting numbers of people, we do anticipate people looking for other things to do outside the ski area boundary. We've seen it every winter since I've been here. I think increasingly where people are looking for other types of activities. And so as we develop further

45:12 Like things like our winter recreation handout, the winter recreation brochure that Matt got a grant for to update that. We want to try to provide more information about snow plate areas. And I just wanted to bring that up. Well, can I see the top of that again? I just wanted to see what, okay, it does show snowmobile. So regarding snowmobile access in this area, can you kind of elaborate on what's allowed?

45:47 Where it's allowed? Sure. On this, on our winter recreation map, in fact, let me just maybe open that up. It's not going to be up. We haven't transitioned to winter yet. I apologize. On our handout that we have available for download, it shows all of the areas off limits and where people can snowmobile and things, the Forest Service.

46:17 Recreation map shows it and things. This particular map doesn't articulate what you can do where specifically on a snowmobile, but like as an example in the Sherwins, you can go all through here. I know like Solitude Canyon is an example. You can go up there in a snowmobile. There are no groomed trails out of the Sherwins for snowmobiling, but you can launch from the Sherwins trailhead right here.

46:47 You can go down Sherwin Creek Road. You can go off trail and off road all up through here. You can likewise stage at Mill City right over here with your snow machine. At the Lake Mary Road, though, however, you'll run into Tamarack's use permit boundary where you cannot snowmobile. Right. Is that noted on the map here or no? It's not. That would be...

47:15 The suggested improvement is to articulate those sort of things carefully to maybe not open a can of worms graphically. Like if we start trying to sort of articulate everything that's allowed and everywhere you could go, you could open a bit of a can of worms just from a cartographic perspective. But I could see us articulating

47:46 Like you couldn't use a snowmobile in Tamarack as an example. Right, or the biking in Tamarack is not allowed. I didn't notice if that's listed at the top as well for winter snow play up here. At the time when this map was made, winter fat bikes were not allowed anywhere. Okay. And so that's another bit of a layer that can be included in this map. The big win for us was being able to include

48:20 This layer that we developed with ESAC around like the hazard level and actually being able to label the fingers and Dempsey Don't and the hose. It was basically a base map before. I'll take note of those. Elise, good ones. Keep them coming. Does anybody else have any questions or comments? Is this map going on all of the stations?

49:01 So this same map will be at the three locations with a different you are here arrow. Hey, Joel, this is Dan. One of the other things I'd just like for the group a little bit is as we anticipate a growth in first-time visitors and people getting out of Southern California area due to COVID and other things coming to Mammoth Lakes, I think we will see an uptick in people who haven't really been here before, but they're definitely come up to play in the snow.

49:32 So some of these access points will be critical, but also looking at the nearby little slopes and stuff by the propane tank farm, if you will, as a potential for creating some play area that we, one other place that we could be directing people to as an area to get out and enjoy the snow. And then the two other elements for that is each year we're always challenged on big storm events of keeping the road open in order to get

50:02 Adequate propane deliveries. We're working with Marigas right now to set two additional tanks out there, which will double the amount of time basically that between having to fill the tank. So in a big storm event, especially multiple days, there will be a very high likelihood that that road could be snowed in and closed during those times due to the amount of staff time it takes to keep it open for that. It's not unusual.

50:31 They end up spending six to 12 hours on a really bad storm day to plow that out and back just to get the propane trucks in there to fill those tanks. And that takes, for us, it takes a full-time position off of the road clearing in the town during that time period. So we do look at keeping it open, you know, in terms of decent weather and stuff, having that road open out there as both a play area as well as some additional access as noted here on the graphic.

51:00 But wanted to give the group just a heads up that that's a little bit of a change in operations where we would actually, we'd want to physically have the road closed. We have had people trapped back there before their vehicles. They can't get back out again. So the cars get left. So as we have big storm events, we coordinate with Amerigas actually to fill the tanks in advance.

51:21 To the extent that we have to clear that roading out again during a storm event is always problematic, but if need be, we'd do it again this year, even with the doubling of tanks. Thank you. Yes, around that issue. And then I have one more quick question. Is there adequate parking at the Mill City Winter Access Area for snowmobiles? You know, trailers, for vehicles and trailers for snowmobilers?

51:53 And I can address that question. No. And the reason I know that is because that has been looked at in the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan and has been identified as a desired winter trailhead. So, you know, in the past, the Sherwins Working Group, you know, the community decided to include it in the trail system master plan that it needed improvement and expansion as a formalized year-round trailhead.

52:24 Yeah, I remember looking over the paperwork there, but I wonder if by putting, you know, snowmobile access up at the top and pointing that out as winter access may create issues that haven't, you know, I think there are going to be a lot of people looking for access. And up at the top of the map, I just want to...

52:46 See the Mill City Winter Access where you have under backcountry access. It shows, you know, winter play, skiing, cross-country skiing, snowshoe, and snowmobiling. I know it's allowed, but I feel that, you know, from there you're feeding people up to Tamarack, which in theory could be problematic. And there's not really sufficient parking at this time. I don't know if that, by putting that on there, if that may create an issue where one doesn't exist or, I don't know, just something to consider.

53:16 Yeah, yeah, you're saying we shouldn't be directing snowmobile activity up to that mill city due to parking and also if they end up running up the old Mammoth Road and end up in the base and then that creates a whole nother conflict. Correct. Okay. I also just add and I know Joel that you're you're conscious of this but we are you know we are very much slated to

53:41 Go through a full NEPA winter recreation planning process starting as early as next year. And so investment in these signs, you know, we should be conscious of the fact that there may be changes down the road. But I would say that if there's a way to, and I think this sort of is to Elise's point, but since the majority of snowmobile traffic in this zone is heading out to solitude, that seems like something that, and that's a place where we do have room for snowmobile turnaround and staging.

54:11 You know, maybe there's a way to sort of focus it there and say, you know, this is, I don't know, it's tricky because, again, we haven't really been through any kind of planning process, so we're committing ourselves down certain roads that may change. It's an allowed use, and that's the duty is to show, you know, those uses that are allowed. If we take it off, it wouldn't be consistent with

54:40 The way that we handle our symbology, we are supposed to represent all activities that you can do from those locations, those staging areas. So if we take... But maybe this is what we do or consider is coming up with an icon that represents snowmobile staging, snowmobile parking, so that you can direct people toward where it's functional and feasible to bring in a big trailer rather than...

55:09 Rather than layering over the landscape, you know, what's allowed or not allowed. Yeah, Matt Perullo, if I could hop in for just a moment. Great comments, David and Elise. And I'm looking on my other monitor here at the existing winter recreation map and some of the boundaries and overlays on where snowmobiles are currently allowed and where they're prohibited and the use of icons.

55:37 For preferred staging areas. And I'll get into this more in my agenda item, but part of the OSV grant that we're working on is really to develop a living document that can kind of change as policies change or as we bring new infrastructure online for staging areas. And so this is a little tricky being a pretty costly sign to fabricate.

56:01 I think that your comments are well received. You know, we don't want to be sending trailers up to Mill City and having a 20-point turnaround there if we can avoid it. And so I'll touch on it a little bit more in my agenda item. But Joel, I know you're keeping notes. I'm keeping notes as well. Yeah, I want to find a way to encourage trailers to go to those areas that work and not necessarily encourage them.

56:31 Where they're legally allowed to stage where logistically it's difficult. Important to remember for that location, besides just snowmobiles, there is no official parking areas. They're parking on the road where the town stopped plowing. There's only room for maybe five or six cars. So do we encourage anyone to park there or do we discourage everyone? Right. It's a problem. I agree with that. I think, you know, we have to be careful.

57:05 We don't want to create an issue kind of like what we saw in the lake space in the summer. Do we want to push people up into that area and have people parking in places where they're blocking traffic, causing issues with town clearing the road? Yeah, I mean, it could very easily, based on what we saw this summer, I mean, that could really become a problem where we see cars parked, you know, a half a mile all the way down Old Mammoth Road. It seems very feasible.

57:36 I have a thought, folks. And so these signs, they're not going to find these maps or signs on the internet, and they're not going to find them unless they go to this location. So that's something to think about and consider. In other words, the map that you're looking at won't be used to promote anything. It's about users who have come to that staging area. And here's a...

58:06 A nice sign that provides information. And so from that perspective, it's a receiving information product, not promoting people to go there, if that makes sense to you. You know, they're not going to find this map anywhere online. And so I think that if we want to sort of manage, use and steer it, we want to think about

58:35 Not having Mill City highlighted on the website, or make sure Visit Mammoth doesn't highlight it, make sure that like the Lake Murray Road closure isn't promoted from those promotional angles. This map is for backcountry and side country users to read about safety and to orient themselves with solid information. So it's a different kind of use, if that makes sense.

59:04 I just have another quick question. You said that there are going to be three signs and one is going to be from the boot pack. Is that going to be listed under backcountry access so that you have it? I can't see that part of it. So here's, I'm glad you brought that up. So when this came up years ago, we were asked to hide that place basically and that we only wanted the sign there for people who found it.

59:30 Okay, can we do that with Mill City? We can, and that's what I'm saying. We can hide these things. It just eliminates maybe useful information. I don't think of these things as promotional materials necessarily. You're on your team across it. Tamarack is very sensitive. That's why they didn't want that on there. Tamarack was the variable that kicked that one item out.

59:59 Well, I think you keep Mill City Winter Access, but if you take off the parking, because there's really not a promise of parking up there. Right, maybe something like that, where it's not, you're not at Sherwin Trailhead Winter Access saying, oh, next time we should go up to Mill City and park. I just think, you know, if we could minimize until we provide appropriate parking and turnaround, if we can minimize

1:00:30 Pushing people in that direction or even telling people about that. I think it's the safe way to go, personally. So I can, we can do this, David, understand that Mr. Wentworth is going to be very sensitive to that proposal. This was years in the making. Just to, just to removing the parking icon of Mill City? To, to sort of, to hide the Sherwin's access egress nodes, these points.

1:01:01 To start taking them off maps, it starts taking apart the Sherwins Access Egress Program that was put together as a part of that original program. Yeah, no, I understand that. I'm just, I think we're just, we're just talking about what we actually are offering in terms of parking. That's right. Yeah, and Joel, again, this comes back to the earlier discussion.

1:01:22 This is what we're looking for this community to do, and I hate to say it, I'm not worried about a single council members. Understood. I want to be careful there, Joel, but I mean, if somebody's upset about it, that doesn't, I mean, again, that's why we're here to have, you know, the whole group of folks here looking at that going, is this going to work? We don't want to also create a problem for ourselves to have to deal with, you know, back through other programs or something.

1:01:50 I think it's better to, if it's a little softer and people have a better experience, that's better than a bunch of people showing up and going, hey, I thought there was parking here. And there's like, you know, room for four cars and that's it. Or frankly, in some years, zero cars up there. So until we figure out the parking structure up there and able to actually provide something, I think it's, you know, it's just, it's kind of a false advertising that there's adequate parking there for all of these uses.

1:02:20 I buy it. I'm with you guys. I mean, I'm directed by you guys. So what we're going to end up with is one place that's going to have questionable plowing. That's our reality. Yeah. Joel, is the original access egress point on the map through the neighborhood? Right here. Okay. I'm sorry. I just can't see it. So when the road isn't plowed.

1:02:52 Users could still. They can only come out here. They can't go in. They can go in the Lakes Basin and out. There's no place to park. Of course. And then the Lakes Basin area there, we have the gate that used to be kind of, it was closer to the Tamarack entrance right there past the Twin Lakes across the bridge. That's been moved up the road a ways, almost to the intersection where the, where the.

1:03:20 Mountain has the ticket booth there, not quite to that far, to provide an extended area of parking for snow play there. I don't think the snowmobiles are allowed to go up on the Gruden Trails there, but during the operating time of Tamarack. But there is an expanded parking area. I'm not sure if it's reflected on here or not, Joel, but we did move that gate up. I think graphically it's probably represented okay, but just for the group to know that that gate was moved up to create an additional

1:03:50 You know, areas for the parking for the play area or to hike up into the basin. And I'd like to just make a note on that. I host up at Tamarack in the winter and we constantly have conflict up there with people who were sent up there for snow play because you're not allowed to sled up there. I mean, you can hike, obviously it's public access, but we try to limit, we can't have people sledding from the hill toward the skiing.

1:04:21 We've had sledders come over the lanes. We've had, you know, we've seen some issues with, you know, skiers coming down and not being able to stop. So I think we need to be sensitive to maybe Tamarack's desire up there to limit sledding in that area. And I thought the sledding was mainly being pushed back completely out of the Tamarack.

1:04:49 Area back along the road there, kind of the panorama, panorama dome type little area in there. It's not good. And I think there will be more area for snow play if that then becomes a parking lot. But what was happening before is people were sledding down into that flat area. Yeah, absolutely. So we want to make sure that they know that maybe that's something, it might not go in the slight signage here, but if people are up there and we have a trail host or out there as well as the mountains.

1:05:17 A host program, ideally, hey, welcome up here, great, you know, you can kind of play over here, you can hike up and have a great view and walk around the lake or whatever, but if you want to play in the snow, you need to either go buy tickets and go up and cross-country ski or play down here out of that permitted area. I think we can help with that, you know, we can, and Joel, that's up to your team ultimately on the host program there as well, but the...

1:05:47 If we have any signage, I'm not sure if we need something to say, you know, no sledding beyond this point or something. You need to be really careful on this point. Yeah. While the mountain may not encourage sledding, and in certain areas it probably should not be encouraged, we need to look at what the Forest Service allows. Remember, this is not private property. Yeah, no, I understand that. In our area, the permit is not an exclusive use permit, which is why they have to allow others on the trail. So we need to be careful about saying,

1:06:17 No, and the mountain needs to be careful about saying no tobogganing. It needs to be done safely. I agree we need some signage and stuff to let people know. But let's be careful as an organization saying, you know, we don't want them there because it's an allowed activity. Yeah, be allowed. Yeah, I just be cautious of directing them up there to go do that because we will have conflict. Well, and I think, you know, what we as hosts up there say, if you're in an area where you're not going to be sledding directly toward our groomed trails,

1:06:47 You can sled anywhere you want. It's forest surface land. But when people come up, they don't want to walk more than, majority of them don't want to walk more than 15 feet to a place where they can go sledding. I think moving the gate will create more space there, but people will then be sledding into the cars. You know, if you look at the topography up there, it will just be interesting.

1:07:16 I will tell you as a mountain employee, we are not saying you cannot sled. You just, it's unsafe to sled into tracks that are designed for people who are skiing downhill. Yeah, it'd be interesting to see how to burn it or do whatever with the parking area there to be able to make it a little more usable for the sledding side of that. We went through this with the forest and their policy is to not in any way represent or promote sledding, the activity of sledding.

1:07:45 That's why you see a snowman on our map instead of a sweater. And so it's a very sensitive subject with agency. One quick note and question. In the spirit of our walk-bike ride planning and our public transit, can we make the public transit icon at least as big as the parking icon? And then the second part of that is a question around

1:08:13 And this is maybe off topic, but are we dead in the water with ESTA in terms of potentially getting up to Mill City with a bus in the winter? Yeah, I know for this year we probably are for some other reason. We're looking at trying to figure out how we're providing enough transit around the community with COVID restrictions. Sorry, Bill, you want to jump in on that? Yeah, there's a problem with the hill and the size buses and the sight lines and everything else.

1:08:43 For right now, the capacity isn't there to think about Mill City. I'm hoping in a five-year plan, we can get some cutoffs and run some regular recreation buses outside of the transportation buses. But for right now, I don't see that happening in the next year or two. Got it. Okay, anything else? Move along, Joel. Thank you. Okay, let's see. The next item, put up the agenda.

1:09:30 I want to talk a little bit about what Dan and others are calling the Town of Mammoth Lakes Community Host Program. Dan, did you just walk away? So I think you're all aware of what we deployed this summer. We had a Mammoth Lakes Trail System Trail Host Program where we provided information. We collected data and picked up litter with staff. We used our contractor, MLTPA, to provide the staff.

1:10:00 I was managing the program myself each weekend, making sure everybody got launched happily with all of their things that they needed. We handed out maps and things to people. It was extremely well received by the public, especially locals that saw us out there helping people and keeping things clean. Based on that success and the anticipated

1:10:28 Maybe busyness around town this winter. The town on October 21st is considering funding a community host program. So it'd be sort of an adaptation of the trail host program. Very much focused on non-trailhead facilities like the village, maybe in front of Vons, riding the trolley around town, buses, and providing face-to-face with a mask on.

1:10:57 You know, and following best practices and things like that, but making sure that our visitors and recreators have people out there helping them to be safe and have fun. It's essentially the same program focused on the urban growth boundary. Does anybody have any questions or comments so far? Quick question. I think that sounds awesome. So it is separate but complementary is what you're saying. So like community hosts,

1:11:28 We're green, trail hosts, we're beige, and they're managed both by you, or one's managed by town of Mammoth Lakes? Yep, so I've been asked to launch this, you know, based on what we achieved this summer. We know that with the team we worked with, that we can really go out there today. I could stand in front of us today with my vest on and my mask on and provide information to people and answer questions.

1:11:59 Same team, different jacket. I'm going to propose, we have, you know, we're working out the details, so Gretchen and I both think that we should have a, you know, a winter jacket with the Town of Mammoth Lakes branding, I think is probably appropriate. Why reinvent the wheel for the community host program? We're going to need a warm jacket. We know that the town already has that product, and it won't have to take six weeks to get a new branded jacket.

1:12:26 We know that the town has branded hats. And I could put a, you know, our name tag will still work. And I think it's an adaptation of what we're doing today. I would certainly want the same capable, knowledgeable people to be able to manage it effectively. Okay, you froze there for a second. Am I frozen? You were for a second. You're back. Okay.

1:13:05 Yeah, I mean, that sounds great to me. One thing I wanted to just suggest was, and you and I have talked about this, but I do think as we move forward and this becomes more and more of a formalized program, we should talk about some recognizable uniforms so that it feels like it's an officially sanctioned position rather than just an ad hoc citizen with the vest. And if those

1:13:34 Town of Mammoth Lakes branded jackets work. That's great. If you want to talk about, I did reach out to Fly Low and we could get some super deep pro discounts on some Fly Low winter gear that we could brand with a Mammoth Lakes Trails patch or whatever. Just, you know, I'd put that to the committee to consider thinking about do we want a line item for that within, under the trail host thing.

1:14:03 Or would that fit within the larger community host budget that you now have? Just something to put out there. Just so people aren't confused, who's doing this? I agree. I want to keep the uniforms pretty tight. Everybody agreed on the outfits that we were running around with this summer. You know, they are branded. Like, we had them screen printed. So it's got the MLR, Trail System, Forest Service on the back, and it says Trail Host.

1:14:31 On the back, and then we have the name tags with the trail system thing and the heart. I do think that there's a lot of room for improvement. I have a keen awareness of the kind of time it takes to turn around like a newly branded thing. I need a lot of, you know, lead time on that. I think they want me to turn this around by November 14th to mobilize some people, and that's probably the most.

1:14:58 The thing that takes the most time is to really turn around like a branded uniform and get all the design work done and get the screenshot set up. It just seems it always takes too long. So that's why we kind of thought, well, wait a minute, doesn't Visit Mammoth have nice puffy jackets? Doesn't the town, doesn't Stu's staff have the nice winter jackets that already have the town logo on them? Those were our thoughts around that, is to not rebrand the town, essentially.

1:15:26 So, Joel, does this, my only fundamental concern would be that this takes you away from your core work on the trail system. One thing, thank you for bringing that up. One thing I should say is that compared to trying to develop a trail project, managing the trail host program this summer was smooth as silk. Good people. We hired really good people, David. How many people were hired and how many volunteers did you have? I don't know if I read that anywhere.

1:16:03 Sure, and that's coming up in, I have a whole trail host report from this past summer, but just to give you a foreshadowing, we hired five, MLTPA hired five people. So are the trail hosts primarily hanging out in the staging areas, parking areas, or are they on the trails? So the trail host program, which is different from the community host program, which I was talking about, the trail host program, similar but different. We, as an example,

1:16:38 Typical morning, Saturday morning in the summer, Horseshoe Lake Trailhead, we staged there. We had people staged at the Coldwater Trailheads and people staged at Lake George. Those were three key locations. Also, Lake Mamie is a high traffic area and the staff that handled Horseshoe could easily walk or ride their bikes down there as well. Also, we used Mammoth Creek Park.

1:17:08 As a staging note to do the town loop. And Shady Rest Park last winter for our Shady Rest Winter Trails. And the Welcome Center was also a very important place for us this summer and last winter. So how is that going to look for OSB for this winter? We're going to have the people at the trailhead at Shady Rest.

1:17:41 Are they going to be snowboarding on the trails or just kind of hanging out in the parking area and letting people know what to do and going dog walking? So we think that we're most effective at the staging areas. That's where everybody kind of in the morning, especially as they're beginning their adventures, they have the most questions.

1:18:09 On the busiest of days, we certainly stick right to those staging areas. And then when things quiet down, what we'll often do is go pick up litter, maybe make a lap around horseshoe. You know, we did that. Keep it clean and tidy. As an example, this winter, Matt Perullo got an OHV grant from the state to fund part of the trail host program for the OSV network.

1:18:36 And that grant includes some funding for snowmobile rentals. So the hosts will have the opportunity to use the snowmobiles to go out on the trail system, but also at the staging area. If I can hop in for just a second, John, to your comments, and Joel, I think we've found that, you know, the staging at the staging area as being the control point where everybody's launching from seems to be...

1:19:05 The best way to reach the largest number of people. But that said, I trail hosted a bit last winter, made some loops on the Nordic Trail. And that we do have built into this grant, like Joel said, the opportunity to get mobile and motorized and kind of meet recreation users on a similar venue on the same level, which is great. And I see a lot of opportunity in that.

1:19:33 Town Manager's comments, you know, again, just anticipating a large number of people coming up, probably via vehicle with limited, you know, special use permit boundary operations on MMSA. We're really looking to get ahead of it and have some good positive interaction with the public at, you know, places outside of that permit boundary. And so I think the pilot program last winter was pretty successful, very successful. We're still building it.

1:20:02 And still looking at different opportunities. And I will touch on the motorized grant again in my agenda item coming up. Any other questions about community hosts? Going to town council October 21st. One thing I failed to mention, I'm grateful for Visit Mammoth and John Urdi for really stepping up and showing an interest in this program. On the agenda for town council, you'll notice that 75,000 of the 100,000

1:20:39 Would be coming from the fund that Visit Mammoth has the purview over, if I said that correctly, Dan. Yeah, the funding structure is looking at a, the recommendation is a $100,000 program, $25,000 from town contingency and $75,000 from the town tourism reserve. Those two sources. And discussions with John Urdi is...

1:21:11 Joel has mentioned a bit very positive and I know he's had some discussions with a couple of his board members who are very supportive of this program as well and so we would anticipate that moving forward without any real issues from the funding side but it would provide $100,000 for the winter trails and I call it a community slash trail host program. Our goal would be to have a few folks who could provide information to our visitors and guests.

1:21:40 Either some of the key trolley areas or even at the village or stick them in there, stick them in front of Vons on a Friday evening and they'll probably hit 80% of the people driving in the town. Give them something to talk about while they're waiting in line, I don't know. But looking at ways to get this information out and get good solid engagement with our visitors this winter. One way I can really succinctly put this is that as an example, recently,

1:22:10 At the Welcome Center working as a host between two of us, we prevented over 120 problems by working that day, you know, and that kind of prevention, I think will help to alleviate some things like parking problems at Mill City and those things that we can intercept people before they head out onto their adventures. That's real good mitigation.

1:22:39 I have a quick question. Is this something, the community host program, is that something that they're proposing year-round or just to the funding, would that get you through the winter? Would that be a year-long budget? At this point, that's just for this, just for the current winter, looking at 22 to 24 weeks, give or take, starting mid-November through.

1:23:07 First, second, whatever week of April, depending on number of people and days signed out on the out assisting people. It's what say six to 10 people all depending on what we get for hires and then obviously the volunteer program efforts support right behind it alongside that. Thank you for mentioning that, Dan. Just so everyone's aware, the program that we've developed, it enables volunteers to plug in.

1:23:38 And we have a nice online sign-up sheet where people can go and match themselves with staff one-to-one, and they can choose a location. So in the sign-up genius webpage, you can see, okay, I could work at Horseshoe Lake with Joel today, or I could work, you know, at Coldwater Trailheads with Matt on Monday, and they can actually sign up and participate that way. So we actually have opportunities to leverage.

1:24:07 This resource and plug energy in. Like there's a lot of people out there that really wanted to help us this summer. You know, they saw a lot of people coming. They saw a lot of messes being made. And this allowed people to engage with the public. And the biggest benefit there that I saw was that all of a sudden our visitors weren't bad people anymore. If you actually talk to people face to face, you'll find that 99.9% of our visitors are just great.

1:24:36 Thanks, Joel, for that. I think that's an important aspect of the program is the volunteer opportunity and growing that out. And Elise and John, to your comments, you know, like kind of having folks on equal footing and maybe on a snowmobile. Ultimately, I'd love to see trail hosts on horses, trail hosts on snowmobiles and kind of growing it out that way where possible and feasible and bringing...

1:25:03 That to the committee for consideration and potential volunteers. I'm looking at a few of them on the screen right now. It seems like what we're doing here is we're trying to put a band-aid on. The problem that we have is we don't have adequate parking. We have Mill City, which I've been snowbelling for over 30, 35 years. I've never staged there because there's not a lot of riding up in there. You're up in the lake space. Shady Rest is a joke. It's not large enough. So we're kind of...

1:25:34 Getting to the point where there's too many people going to one area, it's like having one restaurant, Mammoth, and everyone goes there and they can't park because there's not adequate parking. So it seems like in the long term, we're going to have to address the lack of parking and the lack of staging areas. And, you know, I agree, we're telling people that you can park in no city, but you can't turn around. That's, I mean, that's frustrating. That's stupid. So we do need to increase.

1:25:59 What we're doing, we're going to have more visitors coming to Mammoth. I mean, we're not going to have less in five years or ten years. And these host programs, I think, are great, even in the summertime. I was riding some of the new trails this last summer, and there's more e-bikes than regular bikes. And, you know, I tried telling people nicely that they're not allowed on the trails, and they said, why? You know, and I'm like, I don't know. But anyway, I mean, the host program is, you know, I think that's a great idea.

1:26:28 But I think if we didn't have these large issues in the first place, we wouldn't need all these hosts trying to explain to people why they can't do certain things that don't make sense to them. John, I couldn't agree more that there's important infrastructure aspects that need to be brought online. And a lot of this, again, is tied to policy and planning, as Chair Page had mentioned earlier, with the forest and subpart C.

1:26:58 A lot of those infrastructure decisions, but certainly from a town county perspective, we are working to accommodate staging areas and put people where we want to put them, but duly noted and agreed upon. That's the problem with these committees. I mean, we're not supposed to...

1:27:23 Lose our patience. It's tough to be patient, though, when we keep talking about things and nothing ever happens and we keep agreeing that we have problems and then we go down this road and then Forest Service throws a huge roadblock in front of us and nothing ever happens. So I'm just grateful I don't have Joel's job. Hey, John, I think, and Matt can speak to this, too. We were successful, I think.

1:27:46 Working with Caltrans for some of those additional parking areas alongside 395 just outside of town. My understanding is they're going to try to keep those plowed for winter access throughout the season. And then we've been working with the local district here, Ranger, to do some modifications to Shady Rest Park as well to add some additional turnaround parking area there that hopefully will provide a little bit of

1:28:15 Additional support for this season and then there's some future options to look at some additional benefit in that area as well. Hey Dan, can we, I want to get on the, on the radar that Caltrans Cinder Shed location up 203. I know in the past they haven't all, I think last winter they skipped a few beats and plowing that out.

1:28:39 Or it did get plowed adequately, and maybe that's a place where it's an existing place that we just need to make sure it gets plowed properly. I think that plowing is not Caltrans. I think that's Mammoth Mountain that plows that, not Caltrans. Joe, you and I should have a conversation about that. Yeah, it used to be Souser's Plowing Company. Yeah. That trailhead was created in cooperation with the mountain to change the way they were forced to allow snowmobiles to park in the past.

1:29:07 I negotiated the deal. Evidently, we didn't get it in writing. The deal was we stopped. They stopped having to allow us parking behind the inn. In exchange, they plowed the cinder shed, which the Forest Service allowed the Snowmobile Association to create years and years ago. So we need to sit down and have a meeting with the mountain and remind them of those, even if they were verbal and handshakes. In this community, that's an important thing. I'm here to make those handshakes.

1:29:38 Bill, I want to thank you for reiterating that. It seems like you said the same exact thing about one year ago, and you're absolutely right, but it seems like nothing ever happens on that as well. The mountain did not plow it last year. Caltrans, they did not plow it. And unfortunately, you know, with global warming or whatever you want to call it,

1:30:10 Our snow levels have gotten higher. So that has turned into our primary staging area for early season and late season. And those parking lots that they put on 395, I mean, they're beautiful, but realistically, we only get to use them about two months out of a very good season. Most of the time, we can't ride on each side of 395. There's not enough snow. And if there is enough snow, it's very limited.

1:30:37 The higher staging areas like the cinder shed, that thing I'd like to see be much larger and plowed because it is, that's where we go riding in October, end of October, November when we don't have the base yet. Even a shady rest, shady rest takes a while to get deep enough to ride. And then the east side, if you're lucky, you'll get two months, you know, in February, March maybe. So we are very limited to what we actually have.

1:31:06 Has earthquake fault parking lot ever been used as a winter staging area? Interesting question. To a very small extent, yes. But when they built these sleds, even though there's a technical legal way for snowmobiles to get by, the mountain sort of doesn't permit it any longer. So there's no way to get from point A to point B, which is the legal trail system out. Yeah, at least just considering earthquake fault, you know, that potential staging area hits.

1:31:40 Quite a few notes. It's currently paved. It has a vault restroom there. It's, you know, it has potential, but to Mayor Souser's points, there's connectivity issues and topography issues and tying that network in, but it has been considered and is still being considered. Yeah, that'll never happen because Bill's right. You have the ski area, you have the sleds, which you can't legally go through, and then if you go to the north,

1:32:12 It gets into thick trees and then it goes off of a cliff and there's no way to gain access. You can basically ride a small area and then you get to the access road. So it doesn't really take you anywhere. It's never going to happen. That's not a good location. Senator Shedd, it is. Thanks. All right. Moving on. Oh, one second. Excuse me, Chair Page. Sorry.

1:32:44 Before we move on to the next item, I do have a public comment that was emailed in from Sandy Hogan. Sandy says, the town's community host proposal, if hosts are to work in the village, ride trolleys, what funding would fund this? If it's not trails, it doesn't seem right to use Measure R Trails funding. Has this question been raised or answered? Sandy Hogan. Thank you, Sandy. I'll give that to you, Dan. It sounds like we're not.

1:33:15 Yeah, so for this, the program for this winter, we're actually not recommending at this point any Measure R direct funding out of the trails or Measure R in general. For this program, we're looking at $25,000 of town contingency general fund money and $75,000 out of the tourism reserve, which is also a general fund dollar. So this program would be totally funded outside of the Measure R trails budget other than

1:33:45 Part of Joel's time or part of Matt's time if he's engaged in part of this process. And again, that's why we fund a piece of Joel from the general fund when these types of things come up. I think it would be okay for the measure R to help support the program, especially at the trail side. But the other stuff, it was easier at this point to not put this type of funding level on the trail's budget, frankly, and have it be a town-funded program. That's the recommendation. Thank you, Dan.

1:34:18 Back to you, Joel. And just to note that we're at 435. I think we're getting, do we get kicked out at five o'clock? Is that where we are, Angie? No, there is no community meeting in this room tonight, so you are a no-time limit. Take as much time as you can. Actually, there will be one at seven potentially. I'm not sure if we'll use the room or not, but we have a, I was going to mention this at the end, but we do have a community conversation this evening.

1:34:47 To talk about the Creek Fire and update from the Forest Service and where they're at in that whole environment there with the smoke and everything else and to address a lot of questions that were raised last night that were not well addressed. And so FYI for everybody, there will be a Zoom community conversation tonight at 7 regarding the Creek Fire. Thanks, Dan. I can try to blast through some of these items. See, Shady Rest.

1:35:19 Winter grooming. This is an action item. We would like to, the town, purchase for $1 the magical blue Nordoni that's been inherited over the years that keeps going somehow. I just need approval to make that acquisition for a buck. And who are we purchasing it from? MLTPA. MLTPA bought it from?

1:35:49 Friends of Inyo bought it from... Like for a buck. It holds its value. It's only worth a buck, but I will like the person that we buy it. I think it's up to 75 cents. I second. Okay, we have a motion that's second. Any further discussion on that? Angie, can we do a roll call? Committee Member Holler? Yes. Committee Member Mueller? Yes. Committee Member Souser?

1:36:28 Yes, dear. Committee Member Howell. Yes. And Chair Page. Yes. Thank you. Enjoy the equipment. Thanks. That was the most fun I had all day. Now I'd like to share with you our latest trail counter report. It is not comprehensive. The forest got shut down, so we couldn't go do work in some locations, but we got all the locations that we could.

1:37:05 You can see that in the blue, here we are, August 2020, daily averages, you know, compared to August 2019 and August 2018, and trails are quite popular this season, this year. We know we've had smoke, we've had COVID and all these issues, and people are going out to use trails. I think that this,

1:37:35 Is a common theme across the Intermountain West and all these recreation hubs. My folks in Jackson Hole are seeing the same thing. My brother in Colorado in the San Juans is seeing the same thing. Like the whole state of Texas came to Durango this summer. It was crazy. We're seeing the numbers on our trails. Does anybody have any questions or comments? Here's a nice example. We have just...

1:38:08 Completed our installation of our regulatory signage across the system. And here's some examples where we have our pathway signage where we allow Class I e-bikes. And here we have the Horseshoe Lake Loop configuration. And we have the McLeod Lake configuration where there's no kind of bikes allowed. One thing I noted is that especially on the pathway system,

1:38:40 Not these bowlers, but the ones that are in the middle, you'll see those signs up. A real benefit that I didn't anticipate is that they act as a nice, bright, reflective surface at night that I can see better. It's a little safer, I think, so we don't bump into those bowlers that are right in the middle. But thanks to the trail crew, thanks to the graphic design team that put this together, it's coming to completion. We have a few more to install that are little special cases.

1:39:12 But does anybody have any questions or comments? Here's our trail host report. This provides a lot of detail, at least, to the question you had earlier. Here's a lot of detail about how many people we hired, how many hours we put in. We started July 1st. This time period is until September 7th. This report provides a lot of great detail to review. I'm not going to read it to this audience, if that's okay. I don't want to take the time, but

1:39:49 Here's an interesting graphic about dogs being on or off leash. We are collecting data as a part of this program. We have a nice custom data application and over 50% of the dog owners have their dogs off leash. Pretty interesting. And then here's our activity breakdown.

1:40:19 So we're encountering our encounter types are mostly hikers. And then you can see the breakdown coming through here. Just to back up what John Mueller said earlier about e-bike users, it's unbelievable what we encounter at the Horseshoe Lake Loop. We could stand there all day and turn back e-bikes. Just so you know, and that's the kind of data we're collecting. We're going to be providing that data.

1:40:50 To MLR, to support, you know, the People for Bikes program that was begun a while back with MMSA and that funding. They wanted to know what was going on in the system. And now we have some good representative data to share. Here's a list of like a sampling of notes. You know, here's a great one. Bag of dog feces near sign that says, please clean up after your dog. That's great data.

1:41:24 And then moving right on to our Adopt-A-Trail program, here's another nice attachment offering us some detail. Kim, thanks so much for helping us with this. Gretchen's done such a great job. You know, and Matt, you're really hustling with the county program. And you can see the looks in these people's faces. You know, they really wanted to plug in somehow and help out and keep things clean. And this program allows for that. It's been really successful.

1:41:56 And Kim set up a really nice system that allows for convenient reports like this. And if you get a chance, go check out the Mammoth Lakes Recreation and Adopta Trail webpage and you can read all about it. We're very excited about that program. Does anybody have any questions about hosting or Adopta? Okay, moving on to the Lakes Basin and Sherwins Area Trail Enhancement Project.

1:42:28 In a nutshell, we're going to get a Lakes Basin project out of the deal. The solitude line will not go forward according to the feedback I received from the Forest Service team in our last meeting at the motocross track outside. The wildlife biologists from the state made it clear that due to important deer habitat that the project should not move forward. And just to note, I was aware that deer are up there.

1:43:00 I take full responsibility for that line, you know, going off the rails, fully aware that it's deer habitat, in the same sense that I've never built a trail project that was not in deer habitat or deer migration corridor. I'm pretty sure that every trail I've ever constructed was in a deer migration corridor, according to state biologists at the time. And so...

1:43:27 I think that this does set a bit of a precedent in the sense that I've not seen deer be used as a reason not to do a trail project in 18 years of my career. So we may have something to look at as we have that workshop around the trail system master plan to really think about some of the constraints like deer habitat, like archaeological heritage and these constraints that we're really faced with around our community.

1:43:57 And kind of face the reality that there's a list of probably seven to nine things that could stop a project. So it's a pretty good menu. If it's not deer, it might be sage grouse. It could be arrowheads. It could be mining things from old mine operations. It could be whitebark pine next time. It could be Yosemite toad habitat next time.

1:44:27 Sage grouse is really ominous to me as we look east of town in those areas. And so I think we really need to work with Inyo National Forest to figure out once and for all, you know, will it be possible for us to proceed? Because everywhere I look, I see deer. I don't know about you guys, but I see deer all over the place, especially like right out my window. You know, Snow Creek and...

1:44:55 Right next to Old Mammoth Road. I see them on 395, unfortunately. You know, Doe Ridge, where we'd like to do projects, the airport. And so I think that I really look forward to working with our partners to try to find a way forward. Joel, if I can just add, I mean, I hear you on that and I don't disagree, but I think that...

1:45:22 You know, I think we need to, we haven't seen that. I'm interested to see the decision memo and see how that rationale is articulated. I think we can all, we all understand internally that if we had had full community support, I think some of these questions around deer migration may not have been raised in the way that we thought that, as you said, there may be some, in fact,

1:45:47 More biological concerns for some of those segments in the Lakes Basin, but there was no public pushback against those, and therefore the forest felt it was possible to go ahead and move ahead with those. So I think, you know, I hear your precedent. I hear the lesson. It is something we need to be conscious of, absolutely, but I think we, first and foremost, as a committee and as a trail system and as a municipality,

1:46:17 Need to do a much better job of building broad community support for our program. And I think that's where doing this trail system master plan workshop and then I think our next pivot needs to be one that can be roundly supported. And then we really have a way to challenge the Forest Service on the reality of the science. And on that note, I would just

1:46:46 I'm curious, what are your thoughts now in terms of timing, in terms of, you know, looking now two years ahead, can we go ahead now and move ahead with, you know, trying to see a scoping proposal for a full environmental assessment on the meadow trails that have some sharp collaborative clearance?

1:47:13 Can we do the work between now and when that scoping goes out to build that community support so that we can really approach the Forest Service with a unified community voice saying, hey, it's long overdue that we restore these trails in the meadow. Yeah, I'll be optimistic the whole way through, right? I mean, there's got to be a way that our community can build trails like every other mountain community in the world. And there has to be a way forward. So what I would...

1:47:43 Asked for is help with Inyo National Forest. Fan that trails can be a thing. That we went from 70 miles of proposed lines to 15, and now we're basically at net zero out of 70. Again, Joel, though, I mean, one entity is, and one challenge is the agency, and that's a complicated issue that, you know, you and Matt and myself, I mean, we have some expertise working with the agency.

1:48:17 I think the piece that has been left behind here for whatever reason that we need to really pay attention to is the community buy-in piece. And I think that in my past experience and a lot of the projects that you've referenced over the years, those are coming to the agency with broad community support. And so let's figure out how to build that support and then go to the agency rather than going to the agency, having them propose something.

1:48:44 Which is in a perceived vacuum, whether it is actually in a vacuum or not. But it, you know, it clearly makes the agency's job harder to propose something when the community is not fully supportive of it. So it seems to me that that's our job to do that outreach and help build that community support. And my sense, and I would certainly want to be more scientific about it, but my sense is that there's broad community support for restoring those sharp trails in the meadow.

1:49:13 And we know that that's going to be costly, but we also know that we have the budget to do that environmental assessment. And so I would just ask from this seat, and I would ask the committee to weigh in on this as well, but let's start moving forward on those sharp trails. And a piece of that is not just building the GIS lines and taking it to the forest, but actually providing the community with a good vision for that.

1:49:42 Before we are in an official process so that we can have a fair amount of assurance that we're walking into the door with some organizational and community support that basically helps give the forest cover to say yes, which we need. That's our job. Well, I disagree, David. There's a lot of community support for getting things going. This is environmental terrorists that keep throwing roadblocks in front of us. This is Sierra Club.

1:50:14 Your friends at Friends of the Inyo, and they jump on every single boat, and they block everything, and it's frustrating. I would not want Joel's job. Every time you work hard, and you try to lay down some trails, and then you get these terrorists that jump in front of you, and they threaten lawsuits to the Forest Service, the Forest Service doesn't want to get sued, and then it stops everything. I feel like it's so frustrating, we're just being stopped at our tracks.

1:50:44 Most of the community, they're going to want to move forward with e-bikes and building new trails and managing our forests. I mean, this is just ridiculous what we're seeing here. Well, so one, I won't get into that with you, but one thing that we didn't see in terms of the comments, and Matt, maybe you can speak to this with more detail than I can. I've read a lot of them. I haven't read all of them.

1:51:11 But, you know, I completely agree with you, John, that there was a lot of pushback from National and from those organizations that you mentioned. There was not an equal amount of support articulated from the community. And had there been, you know, if there had been a thousand comments from mountain bikers and community members in support of it and 500 from environmental organizations, I think it would have shifted the tables and this project would have been assessed differently.

1:51:40 So I think either we throw in the towel and say we can't do anything, which I'm not willing to do and I don't hear Joel being willing to do, or we say on our next batch, let's frame it in such a way that we're going to have the whole community step up and write letters and be in support of this project. And if we can bring some of those organizations on from the beginning and make it clear to them that this is in fact good for the environment.

1:52:06 Which I think we can do, especially in the case of the Sherwins Meadow Trails. I think we have an infinitely better chance of moving the agency. I'll just hop in for a second. First of all, to state that, Chair Page, I think your comments to look for that articulation in an official decision memo is the right next step for this committee coming from the Forest Service.

1:52:38 To see exactly what the issues were. We're still working on the proposal in the seven remainder miles of trail in the lakes basin and shaping this proposal and paring it down and making the best possible trail system we can with what we have. And so I would wait for that. Joel, I think your characterization is generally accurate.

1:53:06 On where we are with Solitude Canyon Trail and where we are with the project. And in terms of pivoting, I think that there is opportunity and appetite to manage recreation through a comprehensive trail system. And I think that the agency, the land manager understands that as well. And so in pivoting, it's just more crucial than ever that we walk really hand in hand to whatever degree.

1:53:34 Capable with both the agency and the community and I agree with your statements in that department and I should also mention Joel I generally agree with your characterization of the project to date I disagree that this project has really gone off the rails I think that this is part of the NEPA process and again we'll wait for that decision memo from the agency but

1:54:05 You know, operating under a categorical exclusion and getting resource specialists into the field is what this process is about to bring back good data and make good decisions. And so it may feel like a failure in many respects because it's so uncommon that we have this degree of interface with the agency in developing a project. And if this is...

1:54:31 Normal, and I think it is elsewhere on other forests and other jurisdictions and the new normal, I would like to see us move forward with the agency, then I would characterize this project as a success in many respects. So as we pivot, I'd just like to keep that in mind and disagree with you on your one comment. Take that well, Matt. I just had one last request. If anybody's aware of a proposal for trails,

1:54:59 That was stopped because of deer. I would like to know about it. Yeah, several trails out of the old motocross track. And in fact, the deer and the deer migration were used as the main focus to close that track down in the first place. While the local, I call them anti-groups, the anti-human league. I don't call them terrorists. I don't go quite that far. While they disavowed it, I was in several meetings where they threatened the lawsuits.

1:55:29 Which cowed the local officials into closing that project. It goes deeper than that, but that's the impetus of why it got started. So deer have been used over and over again in this area to stop projects that one special interest group or another did not want to see. And mark my words, that is what we're seeing here. It is not community lack of buy-in. It is one special interest group that has created its own respect in the local community.

1:55:58 Doing a call for action and getting people to write letters based on the comments through their website and their emails to oppose a project that most of them have no concept of. And I totally agree with, but we had no, there was no other side to that. We didn't rally comments and support and therefore they're hearing from Joel, they're hearing from the town, they're hearing from Matt, they're hearing from a few people that are in support.

1:56:27 From hundreds and hundreds of people from the country were against it. So we need to do better next time. One thing that was written in a lot of that literature, Bill, was the idea that somehow we're not doing the proper science under a CE, that we don't go look at the land under a CE. And that was a lie that was put out there by these groups. Because what we found is that, yes, indeed, wildlife biologists

1:56:55 A Forest Service Wildlife Biologist and two state wildlife biologists looked at it and told us that we can't build a trail there because of deer. So we certainly went through the process. We didn't do an EA like they were telling us we had to. It was just a lie. I'll just add, I think it's important for my role in the county to state that, you know,

1:57:21 Trail proposals and development of comprehensive, smartly designed trail systems that tie into infrastructure and connect communities, not a unique concept to Mammoth Lakes, not a unique concept to other parts of the county. If as a public servant, my job was to not work with groups to formalize trail systems, I can tell you my job would be a lot easier because there are several, you know, constituents countywide that are really,

1:57:50 From Antelope Valley to Crawley Lake Community, looking to develop front country trails that can benefit the community, work well and sustainably with the environment. And so it's not unique. And I think that is important bringing to light to this committee. I'm sure it's not news to you, but worth mentioning. So if I could just circle back to my initial question, Joel and Matt. So we'll see the decision memo. Obviously that will provide...

1:58:22 A platform for decision making, but how long after that decision memo do we turn around and put together a proposal and start building some community buy-in and maybe bring some stakeholders together and put together a proposal for the Sherwins Meadow? I can tell you that my role in this, moving this project through,

1:58:52 Process in the Forest Service, that Forest Service leadership, again, is very much interested in pivoting where possible to make smart community-supported trail decisions. There's been no time frame given for that, so I can't speak to that. And that's, again, you know, some of the issues in the meadows came to light in this project.

1:59:18 The general consensus among the resource specialists is that this is a big problem and we'd like to fix it. And so the biggest obstacle there, it's working around and mitigating heritage concerns. And that is primarily a cost prohibitive issue more so than a dead stop. It needs to be mitigated and those mitigations can be costly.

1:59:45 So that's one I just want to keep pushing from the Trails Committee Chair point of view, and I hope the committee will join me in pushing for that. Let's figure out what that cost is. Let's figure out how much we can go to council for as needed or other organizations if we need to raise money. But we need to move this trail system forward. We need to restore that landscape. So whatever we can do to help keep moving that forward in the spirit of

2:00:16 John's call to action. Let's keep moving this ball. Hey, David. When I first joined this organization, we were supposed to reach across the aisle and make friends with these guys and communicate, and it seems like that's not happening. I mean, we're supposed to rally up a bunch of people and write a bunch of letters to move forward with our project, but we have this opposition of thousands of these environmental groups that...

2:00:46 A lot of them don't even know where Mammoth Lakes is. I mean, they've been fighting everything we've been doing. They're writing letters from, you know, the 50th floor of a San Francisco skyscraper, and they just, that's what they do. So it seems like we do need to reach across to these people and say, hey, what do you guys want? Let's cut a deal. Let's negotiate. We want to do this. We're not going to tear up the environment, but it just seems like we're wasting our time. Joel's wasting his time. It's got to be discouraging to put all this time and effort in.

2:01:14 All these meetings and talking about things. And then you just run into this roadblock. It just seems like we need to cut a deal and say, you know, what do we need to do with the Forest Service, with the environmental groups and try to work together and say, you know, what do we need to do before we waste a bunch of time and money? I mean, we're going to keep going down these roads and we're going to keep hitting these same roadblocks. And it just seems like a big waste of time and money. And I don't know what the solution is. This has been gone for years.

2:01:43 For, you know, as long as I know, it's been happening in this area, and it's tough to deal with not getting anywhere. No, John, I totally agree with you, and I think that is the next step, at least from my advantage, is to sit down with Friends of the Inyo, to sit down with some of these organizations and say, look, here are the problems we've got at the landscape. What can you guys get behind? How can you help us? And that's something we failed to do this round, and we'll do it the next time. And, Chair Page, before we move on, I do have another public comment. Great.

2:02:17 This is also from Sandy Hogan. It says, it is not deer, but deer migration. It could lead to an EA, but the same conclusion would likely be reached. Solitude is the only deer migration path left open. If you look at the lakes basin as the other, which is not available for the deer. I hear you. Thank you, Sandy. I think we also need to start working on...

2:02:44 Helping the county and Caltrans and the Forest Service and BLM and the existing partnerships to start building wildlife migration bridges over 395 because I think that's a bigger barrier than a non-motorized trail but point taken. Just say thank you Sandy for the comment and again I would look for you know the deer migration corridor to be articulated in the decision memo is the best answer I can provide at the moment.

2:03:17 Just quickly, I'm going to make a request that the decision memo be shared with everyone on the committee. I think that would be useful for us before we go into like a trail system master plan meeting. Just kind of have that information. And then I'm wondering if you have a map of the seven remaining miles in the lake space and do you have that? It's in the additional proposal. Okay.

2:03:45 So it's what was originally proposed along with the Solitude Canyon or the Solitude Canyon? At least that's correct. The project that was put forward and proposed is the Lakes Basin Sherwins Area Recreation Enhancement Project and it basically ties in our developed Lakes Basin with our developed Sherwins Creek Road via Solitude Canyon as well as a nexus or pod of trails connecting.

2:04:12 Lakes and Infrastructure within the Lakes Basin, and that's that seven miles that we're still developing with Resource Specialists and with the Forest Service, and it's going to be part of that decision memo moving forward. The decision memo will be shared publicly, and of course I can share that directly with committee members going into any further orientation with the Trail System Master Plan, but it will be made public, and I anticipate that to be before the snow flies.

2:04:41 But again, that's just the best guess I have at this time. Okay, thanks guys. Moving on. No problem. Next on the list is Shady Rest in Your Craters OHV planning grant update. Staff has been busy most of the summer. The variables of forest shutdown and smoke have hindered some ground operations. But we've done some great corridor design work. We've done...

2:05:12 We've had weekly meetings with Forest Service staff, Jeremy, who has a new OHV position on Inyo National Forest. Congratulations to Jeremy. And I'm going to move on, Matt, because I think we're hitting a rhythm with that project. I don't have anything big to report to this group. We are in stride in that, and I hope to have good things to report out in our next MTC meeting. We still have a lot of work to do before it snows out there.

2:05:41 One thing about the Shady Rest, Inyo Craters Planning Grant is we will be proposing a lot of new trails. And so we're going to be, you know, bringing a whole new set of trails forward to the district for consideration. And the same kind of constraints are going to be out there, everything from archie to deer and everything else. And so expect a pretty big proposal to come with that one. It'll have the same set of issues, maybe some additional ones. We shall see.

2:06:10 Mountain View Trail Reroute Accessibility Improvements, that is finished. We made improvements to the trail above the reroute to accommodate the special mountain bikes for people that have disabilities. We've made some of the pinch points wider so that those devices can move through easily. It's a nice five and a half mile trail experience now. If you haven't been out there in a while, I highly recommend it.

2:06:40 One of our success stories this season. The Mammoth Rock Trail reroute is finished. We're staging material right now with fire crews to cover all that up right before the first snowstorm. We'll go ahead and cover up the old part of the trail. The new trail's built. People are riding it. I'm getting good reports about how that experience is. And then Horseshoe Lake Loop Bridge number two was installed also recently.

2:07:09 Thanks to Beverly Langston, who also funded the second bridge. Thanks to Kim for bringing that all together with the funding, and we were successful in that endeavor as well. The Horseshoe Lake Loop is running really good these days. Does anybody have any questions about those items? I'm going to move on to our budget, our fiscal year end report. We're looking pretty good here. We're $3,500 within budget. That's very good as far as I'm concerned.

2:07:44 Here's how everything worked out. Things are pretty tight, mostly because of reallocations a couple of times in the year. And in our next budget sheet for this year, I do not have a requested reallocation for the committee today. It's the first quarter. We're running really in line with what we expected. I think we will have a reallocation coming for the next quarter, maybe one or two.

2:08:13 But our budgeting is getting a little smarter based on previous experience. Does anybody have any questions about these budget sheets? I just have a comment, really. And it kind of circles back to what you were talking about at the very beginning of the meeting. And that is, first of all, it looks great. I think I'm pleased with the work that's been done and the budget that it's being done within. I have an ongoing concern about the work.

2:08:46 Investment. The what? The website. I feel like it's a lot of money, and we're not, and I've already, Kim and I have already set up a meeting down with John, and hopefully you too, Joel, and let's, now would like a great time to kind of step back and say, you know, what is the MLR supposed to do? What is the Mammoth Trails website supposed to do? What is the,

2:09:14 Town Website, MLTPA. I mean, we have five different websites that touch the trail system in different ways. And, you know, if I, it's still, if I type in, in Google, where to hike in Mammoth Lakes, what I get is the AllTrails app. And mammothtrails.org is about seven or eight down the list. When I look at, you know, thank you guys for building that conditions page last year. That took some time. But when I look at it, the latest update is from,

2:09:43 Looks like July. There's a link to September 7th forest closure. So I'm just worried that, you know, especially as our visitation continues to go through the roof, that there's really no place that makes sense from a public facing standpoint to get information about our trail system. And yet we're spending, what was it, 27,000 total on our website last year, which I just wonder if that

2:10:12 Is the most effective way to spend the money. So I just, that's just a bookmark. It's not a critique of this budget in particular, but I think that's a discussion I'd like to have at the next Trails Committee meeting with some data around, you know, how many people are using other apps to navigate in our trail system versus our website. Where are people getting actual on-the-ground conditions information as things change? And as we know, things have been

2:10:42 You know, for the last four or five months, things have been super up in the air and it's important for people to have a source of information that makes sense. So I just want to have that as a discussion. And again, Kim and I will sit down with you and talk about some possible strategies and hopefully we can bring that back to the committee. Very good. Thank you for that feedback. Yeah. Anybody else have questions on any of these budget items? It's not new. We've seen all this, but. Very good.

2:11:26 Matt Perula, I think we are to your section seven. Just a moment. Let me get caught up with you. Okay, great. Thank you very much. And I will be as brief as possible given that we're at 515 now. Item 7A, just to provide a brief update on my employment status and to reference some mature Paige's comments and introductory remarks.

2:12:03 The Mono County Board of Supervisors approved a resolution on October 6th to transition my position, the Sustainable Recreation Coordinator position housed under MLR into being housed under Mono County directly. And the funding stream and divisions, roles and responsibilities remains the same in this transition, jointly shared and funded by the Town of Mammoth Lakes in Mono County.

2:12:28 And I will continue to work very closely with this committee, with Joel, and with Kim and MLR and the MLR board to develop projects and programs and leverage non-appropriated funding to bring those programs into sustainability. And so just wanted to provide that update. And if you have any questions on that, please let me know. And building off of that last item, Mono County has

2:13:04 Funded approximately $10,000 in wayfinding signage that I can now work directly on the ground as a county employee with volunteers, with tools in the public works, under the public works department in implementing and getting this wayfinding signage in the ground, working with volunteers and contracted crews where possible, including fire crews. So the transition provides my position and myself an opportunity to work in

2:13:33 Much the same way that Joel works on the town side. Agenda item 7C, adopted trail. This was touched upon growing the program outside of town's jurisdiction into unincorporated Mono County. Again, sharing this responsibility and the public interface and public donation aspects with Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Thank you, Kim, for your work on hosting that website and working with me to

2:14:05 Cultivate adoptees, volunteers, and financial adoptees, and programs gaining ground. I have both interested volunteers and welling financial donors really kind of throughout the county and looking to grow this up and get some very much needed trail resources to those areas of the county that don't benefit from the products and programs that we've had in the town for several seasons now.

2:14:34 More to follow on that and very optimistic, great initial response from the community. And do you have any questions on that? Moving forward and again, working closely with Kim and MLR to transition some of my roles with Tingle Free Waters and make a fluid transition to my transition to the county. At this point, I believe, I think we have three financial donors to the program and just...

2:15:08 Ecstatic and super pleased with folks that have been adopting facilities financially, adopting as volunteers, have taken cleaning up lake shores and waterways very seriously, and folks that are making financial donations in honor of loved ones. It's just great to see. And again, the program is inching ever nearer to being self-sustainable.

2:15:37 Without any appropriate funding stream, which is great, which is where we want to end up. Any questions on that? Great, just cruising along. Facelift, I'd like the community to be aware of the Yosemite Facelift Act local regional cleanup that is currently happening. Facelift is a park-wide volunteer event that was started in Yosemite in 2004 and amassed

2:16:10 You know, hundreds of visitors that help clean up the park after busy seasons. In 2020, Facelift has looked outside of the park to local gateway communities. And I've been working very closely with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, which is the lead for the region on this program to incorporate several areas region-wide. And today was the first day of the event for the region. It will continue through Saturday the 17th. If you have any

2:16:40 Questions on how to get involved or engaged, there is a link to take the participation pledge in the agenda. You can ask me directly or you can direct those questions to Dakota Snyder, who's the lead POC for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And again, thank you to MLT for being involved and engaged in this way. And thank you to all the organizations from Friends of the Inyo, ESEA, Mono Lake Committee, Mono Lake Volunteers, DeChambeau Creek Foundation, Community Service Area,

2:17:10 One down in Crawley, the BLM, Inyo National Forest, and any others that I may have failed to mention. Oh, June Lake Trails Committee, I was up there working with them today. So thank you very much. And this program, while it's been very tricky in the age of COVID and forest closures due to fires, we've worked pretty carefully to mitigate those concerns, to abide by CDC guidelines, to postpone the event due to forest...

2:17:40 Forest closures and fire and public safety and air quality. So 2020 has been difficult to say the least, but, you know, looking at our annual lake space and cleanup at Horseshoe Lake in the lake space and where we have 200 plus volunteers, which is just a great turnout. They're all showing up to clean up and care for an area after a busy season and looking to grow that outwards with these different organizations along the 395 corridor.

2:18:06 It's been rewarding work for me and just something we want to cultivate and grow in years to come. So I'd like you to be aware of it and if you'd like to be involved, Kim, I know Mammoth Lakes Recreation is helping to host Joel's trail host program and the town is helping plug in and you can always direct inquiries to myself as well. And any questions on that line item? Mammoth Lakes Recreation will be out at the...

2:18:34 Mammoth Shooting Range tomorrow, 10 a.m. to 2. I feel like coming out and joining, we'll be there. I believe you're gone at home. Tomorrow. At least till 2 p.m. Okay. It'll be a nice clean slate. Great. I have a quick question, Matt. How has this been communicated to the community at large? Yeah, great question.

2:19:02 I know why you're asking it, because it's been very, very tricky to market this. We're living in an age of no permitted events on Inyo National Forest, and so initially, you know, the forest was obviously understands there's a stated need and purpose and would like to okay this event, but we had to work through policy to arrive at a program that was acceptable for their special events and how their COVID-19 or public health guidelines.

2:19:32 Kind of dictate events or limiting social gatherings. And so how it works is Mammoth Lakes Tourism Acting as lead has reached out to several different organizations throughout the community. And each one of those organizations is taking on hosting a specific site and marketing through their own channel.

2:19:52 My role has been primarily to work with unincorporated Mono County agencies and affiliates to kind of organize those efforts. So DeChambeau Creek Foundation and Mono Lake Committee, for instance, have teamed up in putting out through their mailing and distro list and helping join staff tables on different days. The June Lake Trails Committee has stepped up in June Lake and is marketing through their means of communications. And it was important from the outset for the forest.

2:20:19 For the BLM that we're not marketing an event that's bringing a ton of people to town that runs contrary to public policy and public health guidelines. And so great question. I know why you asked it. It's been kind of disparate marketing. I would hope that in, you know, a sunnier future that that's not the case. But, you know, working, organizing these groups. We had a group call the other day to kind of fine tune some of this. And, you know, I'm looking at 15, 20 different organizations throughout the region on the call, all behind the same program.

2:20:49 And that's what we want to see, right? Disperse, get people engaged, active, and, you know, do it from top to bottom, quite literally. And if someone wants to get involved, I was just looking at the...

2:21:02 The forum online. Once you put your information in, will you then be contacted? And will you be aware of everything that's going on in your community? Or is there a website or somewhere where you can go to see a list of different organizations and times and activities? Or is it kind of designed as well, you sign up to be a sponsor or participant, and you maybe do your own thing? What's kind of the goal?

2:21:30 Yeah, so again, no centrally focused marketing by design. So where communication kind of went out through individual channels. I can plug you in wherever you want to be. Kim's going out, you know, in Mammoth tomorrow. Mammoth Lakes Tourism was staffing a booth today at the tourism building. June Mountain Ski Patrol Alumni Association is plugging in on Mammoth Scenic Loop and getting all of the dispersed camping that was hit hard.

2:21:59 Not a centrally located information portal for you by design, but I can plug you in wherever you want to be. That'd be great. The reason I ask, I would like to be involved, but my daughter is in an AP Environmental Science class, and I think this would be a great thing for her class to know about, for her instructor to know about, so she can maybe get the kids in our community involved in something like this.

2:22:26 I love the fine line between educational opportunity and free labor, so I'll take it. That just sounds great to me. Yeah, and that sunny future that you referenced is exciting that this gets decentralized because the facelift event has always just been a blast down in Yosemite Valley, and to import that up here will be really neat in the future when we can have bands and beers and get the whole community out.

2:22:57 Doing a full facelift will be really great. It's accompanied traditionally by professional athletes, climbers, and different advocates in Yosemite from different user groups having lectures and films and live music, like you said. So we've done a great job cultivating that celebration in Mammoth at the end of the season, and it's great to potentially see it grow. Of course, I can't predict what the future holds, but we're hoping 2021 is

2:23:27 Better in many respects than what we're working with now. So if there's no additional comments on that, at least I will get something to you and move on in the agenda. Item F, Off Highway Motor Vehicle Recreation Division OSB grant. Joel, do you have that screen up or can you pull it up for me, please? Great, it's in the agenda. Should you?

2:24:08 Choose to, you know, really dissect this. But essentially, the grant has been vetted by the public and approved by the California State Off-Highway Motor Vehicle Division. And so it is pending a contract which will need to be signed by Mammoth Lakes Recreation Chair at a forthcoming MLR board meeting. The contract's still being drawn up between the state and MLR.

2:24:33 And the deliverables in a nutshell include funding the trial host program along the OSB motorized network with emphasis placed on Shady Rest Park, perhaps Dead Man Summit, other areas where we can use that interface with the host and motorized recreation. And the other deliverables include cleaning up the winter recreation brochure, which

2:25:01 Provides really good information currently, but as policies change, we're basically reverse engineering that file to make it a living document that can change with time, that we can change the icons on that as we bring infrastructure online, we can make that map reflect those changes. And so those earlier comments about the Mill City signage, where we really want to seize an opportunity to direct people is through this map, both online and in retailers, where

2:25:29 Somebody wants to go build a snowman. Boom, you hand the map to them. We know where we want to put that user group. Somebody's launching a snowmobile. We know we're not going to launch them at Mill City. Maybe we launch them at the new staging areas along 395 if we have the snowpack. And so Elise and John, to your comments earlier, there is funding also in this grant to deploy the trail host.

2:25:55 You know, kind of on equal fitting with that user group to rent snowmobiles and get out there to warming hut, check on supplies and grow this thing over subsequent years. And are there any questions on this? Great. And I note that, Kim, thanks for adding in attachment 10, the Forest Service OSV fat bike announcement. Again, include this as an example of policy that has changed in time.

2:26:37 And that with future iterations, we can insert some of this information that's included in the Winter Recreation handout. Again, Joel's turning around, you know, how many e-bikes a day on the Horseshoe Lake Trail. They can go right to their heart's content on the Motorized Network, and we want to convey that information to our users. Joel, if you're willing to help me out here, agenda item G, attachment 11, Shady Rest Winter Parking. And if you could just scroll down for me, please, to the...

2:27:09 Ariel, yeah, thank you. So the Shady Rest Winter Parking, this proposal has been submitted to the Mammoth District Ranger and will be issued as a scoping letter shortly to move through NEPA and public comment. Very simple project, not intended in any way to be a panacea for a lack of infrastructure to launch snowmobiles. It is designed to improve public safety.

2:27:36 Line of Sight, Accommodate Vehicle Movements, and Accommodate All Season Use with the new disc golf course that stages out of this site. And, you know, I was there yesterday meeting with the OHV manager for summer recreation, and we were looking at a full parking lot in, you know, the middle of October. And so when Stu is programming softball tournaments, again, in that sunnier future,

2:28:02 This is going to help accommodate a lot of that use. And it's on a prior disturbed area, really right at the current site, the site of the current winter road closure. And so by no means a panacea, but definitely going to provide some all-season help there. And the town of Mammoth Lakes Public Works Department is going to be the implementing agency on this and improve some of the sloughing and erosion that inevitably washes out there every springtime.

2:28:34 Any questions on this? Thanks, you guys, for moving that forward. Yeah, our pleasure. Yeah, and again, just a lot of concentrated use among different user groups here. John, you know, astutely pointed out, you know, a Band-Aid solution. And unfortunately, this isn't, you know, a cure-all.

2:29:04 We've got a lot of dogs, a lot of low profile, hard to see children. This is a park, a lot of big vehicles, icy terrain, muddy, mucky runoff, something I think needs to happen and I hope to support it and we can make happen in short order. Great. So does that conclude your report, Matt? It does indeed. If you have any questions, I'm here and happy to jump in. David, I know you have a couple.

2:29:40 A couple items in your report that I might be able to provide a little bit of input on. Sure. Any questions for Matt before we move on? Okay. I actually, I have very little to say about the, I've already, the Great American Outdoors Act, I think, as I mentioned, funding is kind of stalled for the next round of projects. We didn't make the next round of projects, but there will be a 2022 project solicitation.

2:30:11 My intel says that it's sitting in the Washington office now and will make its way back to the region. So we might see it sometime after the election, I would guess. And so another reason to have a project workshop sooner rather than later, because we might be able to frame some things to get in the pipeline for some funding from the federal government.

2:30:36 Winter Recreation Planning, Subpart C Collaborative. We've talked about this quite a bit. There won't be any full NEPA process until next year that would begin for Winter Recreation Planning, but there does seem to be appetite from the forest for us to begin to assemble a good, robust stakeholder collaborative to address a pretty broad range of Winter Recreation topics.

2:31:04 The forest has committed to spending the next month or so internally trying to figure out what it wants the scope to be from its side. And I suggest that the town do the same and the mountain do the same and that this committee do the same in terms of, you know, let's begin to inventory what we think are the outstanding winter recreation issues that might be solved through a big NEPA process. And by a big NEPA process, I mean, probably three years of,

2:31:34 Varying degrees of public input and forest presenting alternatives and a lot of research and pages and hopefully it will, the scope will include family snow play areas, different staging area development, designation of trails, designation of areas for different winter sports and I'm optimistic that we may have a forest that can do this better than

2:32:04 We've seen on other forests where it's been really piecemeal. And funding has been offered from MLTPA and perhaps there's some municipal funding that we could put toward this, but it's something for us to think about really sooner rather than later, what that collaborative might look like and which issues we want to address. Because the goal would be, and there seems to be appetite from the forest, for us,

2:32:33 As a community to come up with sort of a citizen's alternative that would then be considered in a full NEPA process as a separate alternative from the other alternatives. And again, in the interest of building community support behind a broad planning effort, potentially a really great opportunity for us. And John already mentioned the Eastern Sierra Climate and Community Resilience Project. That's this big forest health project. More on that as it develops.

2:33:05 They've sort of said that they're not gonna really deal with recreation, but we're gonna need to engage with it and make sure that they're conscious of what recreation infrastructure we have and where that is and how that intersects with the forest health projects as those move forward. It's a pretty massive project. That's it for me. And any committee member reports before we close out for the day? I just wanna make a couple.

2:33:37 I was, and I don't know that this is the right place to do this, but I was out at the disc golf course and noticed that there were chains in the last nine holes. And I'm wondering if, I know there were a lot of people out there kind of wondering about it and starting a petition to get those put in place before the end of the year. I don't know if that's a possibility, but I wanted to bring that back to this committee.

2:34:06 They got put up, Elise, actually. They did. Yeah, on Tuesday afternoon, Parks and Rec worked with the Mammoth Disc Golf Club. Excellent. So they're up and will be up through November 1st. Excellent. Thank you. And then was also out in the Shady Rest area talking to someone and he has young children. He's a mountain biker, loves the trails.

2:34:31 But he was saying one thing he thinks our community lacks is a pump track. And once again, I don't know that this is the right committee to bring this to, but I think if we are creating trails, it would be great to find a way to get the young kids out on the trails or involved in biking a little bit more. You see a ton of kids in the skate park. I'd love to see a ton of kids.

2:34:56 At the park on their bikes. You see less kids on mountain bikes. So I thought that was a great idea. Just thought that I would bring that to the committee. And then I do want to just circle back to the middle city parking. I do feel strongly about removing that P from that staging area because I feel like it's false advertisement. And I think we as a group, our job is to create and convey

2:35:25 And I was told that this is a place where I can access and

2:35:54 You know, park a trailer. So just speaking on those terms, I also loved David's recommendation that the T for transit on that map is just as big as parking because I think we really, really do need to encourage people to use public transportation as much as possible, especially in the winter. Well, bulk seasons, but that's it. Thank you. Thanks, Elise. John, anything? Final word? Yeah. Yeah, I just bought an e-bike and

2:36:27 I can't believe how much fun these things are. I mean, it is just incredible. I sold my Pebble bike and unfortunately I'm finding out that I can ride about four times as far and four times as fast and the trail systems we have are pretty much lacking now and it seems like these things are really going to take off. I mean, it's already happening in Moab, St. George. I mean, those places are packed. Everyone is switching to e-bikes and I'm just afraid we're going to drop the ball in our area.

2:36:56 We're very limited to where you can go unless you want to ride on, you know, dirt roads or asphalt. You know, you see Footloose is renting the hell out of these things when people are riding around town, but most people want to ride on trails, single track, and I really hope that we keep pushing forward where we can get more, more terrain for these bikes. I mean, this is like, kind of reminds me of when, like, snowboarding came along and, you know, if the mountain wouldn't have adopted it and said, yeah, let's do it, we would have been way behind the curve and snowboarding has gotten huge.

2:37:25 E-bikes are coming, whether you like it or not. I mean, they are going to get really big. I think in five or ten years, you won't even have a conventional pedal bike anymore. So I hope we can kind of bridge the gap between our environmental friends, I guess we'll call them instead of terrorists, or whatever we've got to do, but try to get some of these trails open so we can all recreate and have a good time. Thank you. May I say one thing, John?

2:37:55 Couldn't agree more. I am meeting on a weekly basis with some folks in Northern California. They're working with the Sierra Nevada Conservancy. They also got a grant like our region did, and they're working on a project called Connected Communities, and it's an over 300-mile trail project, multiple-use trails, motorized, horses, hikers, runners, mountain bikers can all use them. That's the concept, connecting all the communities from about Truckee.

2:38:25 All the way to the Oregon border. And so what I'm going to do is pay close attention, follow their process. I'm going to help them a little bit with things that I am capable of. And I'm going to become a PhD at what they're doing and watch everything. And so I'm going to watch like how many meetings they had, how did they handle their meetings? How are things being done in the Region 5 forest to carry that torch with them?

2:38:51 You know, how are they able to get these 300 miles of lines approved and through process without controversy or with some controversy? And I want to take what I learned from that process and with the good folks with the CRB's trail stewardship, and I'm going to try to apply some of that knowledge and some of that learning here so that we too can connect our communities with multiple use trails and provide facilities that can accommodate these amazing devices.

2:39:22 You know, that brings up a question to me. We just saw that fat bikes are going to be allowed on the bulk of our groomed trail system. Does that include fat, tired e-bikes? Only on the OSV network. They are still classified and recently re-solidified by the agency that it is a motorized device and is limited to motorized recreation trails. That said,

2:39:54 Joel's point, you know, Shady Rest in Yo Craters Planning is a motorized grant and so there's opportunities there. But yeah, to more directly answer your question, EE fat bikes are not permitted on the Nordic Trails, they are permitted on the groomed OHV or OSV trails. Thank you, Matt. We're going to have to start including in our off-road and non-motorized brochures and literature and maps the rules for

2:40:24 E-Bikes and staying on the right and doing the rest of those things so that when John and I are, and yourself, when you're joining me on the snowmobiles, don't encounter somebody in the middle of the road at 10 miles an hour. Right, right. Yep, absolutely. And I think we're kind of at that crossroads where we have that opportunity to get that information out there through a couple programs that were mentioned. Dan, did you have a committee member report?

2:40:54 Yeah, I'll give you a couple of things. I mentioned it earlier, but we have a Creek Fire update tonight at 7. Also just some disturbing news in one of the emails that popped up from Sacramento Bee article that that fire has not been included in the federal declaration for funding. So it's on the back of the state at this point. Hopefully that will change through that process. Also on good news, we've been working with...

2:41:21 Los Angeles Department of Water and Power on expanding the lease at Whitmore. We've gotten a positive indication that they're taking that forward through the board there and town council ultimately for the city of LA, city council there. But that includes an expanded area by the pool where it used to have some of those buildings that were there, if you recall driving by in that fenced area. Those have all been removed and that area has been cleaned up. And then with Whitmore going toward the airport,

2:41:50 Toward 395 there, expanding out that park, adding probably some of the neighborhood of 50 acres of land there that then would be opened up for expansion of that park. It is used very heavily as a starting point for people for bike riding, as you know, on the Green Church Road there, the Benton Crossing Road. Be nice in terms of expanded fields and other activities. One of the elements Elise mentioned.

2:42:19 As we look at different places, like for the little pump track, for Acamo's kind of training way of riding mountain bikes, that may be a location for something like that as one, and we've looked at a couple of other locations for that as well. Also some other expanded ideas along that park also. The one thing we will need to do on that is some public outreach and process and looking at options on the park, and so need to remind our...

2:42:47 Park Director, Stu Brown, but to incorporate the committee here, our input from this group into that, if we're able to ultimately get some trail systems, be they bike, hiking, running into the Doe Ridge area and that element, again, it serves as another staging area, if you will, for those types of uses. And so we're very excited in working with LA to expand the park out and also that additional area there by the town pool.

2:43:15 It would be under another 50-year lease. So that would be a nice asset to our community in terms of that becoming much more of a county-wide regional park destination, not just a town park from that perspective. That's all. Cool. Bill, did you have a final word? No, I'm just excited to see where we can go in the next year. Excited by the possibilities.

2:43:48 Bringing more things forward. So here we go. Stay patient. Here we go. Stay patient. Good. All right. Well, thanks, everybody, for your time. Pretty good. Two hours and 44 minutes. Meeting adjourned. Thank you very much. Thank you all for your time. Much appreciated.