TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2020

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 40 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

565 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 Hello, Smoke. Hello. Is that you or is that Robert Redford? Who's in that photo? What's going on? My wife took that photo on Wednesday. Had you just walked off the set of Jeremiah Johnson? Yeah, I did. Personally, I see no difference between that and this. No, no, no discernible difference. Looked like you were Robert Redford's stunt double back in 72. Yeah, it's amazing how we don't get better looking with age.

0:46 Just a little flashback fun today. Hi, Bill. Can you hear me? It's Kirk. Gotcha, Kirk. You're sounding good. Hey, Kirk. How you doing? How am I doing? I'm choking to death. The smoke this morning was unreal. Yeah, well, I got all my air purifiers going, and it's cold. Will the fire slow down when it's cold? I don't know. Well, if the air inversion, it holds it in.

1:18 It's an interesting concept, Linda. So as I understand fire, and we have Forest Service people on who can answer it better once we get going, as it gets cooler, the intensity of the fire comes down, so you get a more productive fire in terms of the environment, but any time, just as in your fireplace, the fire is cooler, it also generally produces more smoke. Yeah.

1:48 So why do I got to be on this call if I've got you here, Bill? Yeah. Great answer. Thank you, Bill. Deb Schweizer, ladies and gentlemen. I'm going home. Oh, wait a minute. I'm already home. Never mind. Never mind. Thank you for you. I agree, Bill. That was a great answer. Thank you, sir. Do we have everybody here? I'm not seeing Dan. Yeah, there's Dan.

2:21 We have the clerk. We have all five council members. So I see no reason not to bang this meeting to order. The town council meeting, Wednesday, October 21st, 2020. Roll call, please. Councilmember Hoff? Here. Councilmember Stapp? Here. Councilmember Wentworth? John, unmute. Here. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Here. Mayor Salzer?

2:59 President, Pledge of Allegiance. Kirk, how about leading us in the pledge today? We can all look at Dan's picture with the flag in it. Please place your hand on your heart and follow me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, the Republic in which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you.

3:28 Thank you all. You stand up and nobody can hear you. Public comments. This is the time for members of the public wishing to make comments on things that are otherwise not on the agenda. Jamie, do we have any? We do not. In addition to the agenda, Dan, do we have any emergency items? We do not. Reports from commissions and or departments. Do we have any commissions or departments? Yes, Sandra. Thank you.

4:04 I was going to provide an update on the parcel, so I'm not sure if you have to recuse yourself from listening to a brief update, but you might want to mute and blank your screen. Andy, I don't know if that's official, just for a brief update on the parcel. I will, I will. And blank my screen. Thank you so much. So just a brief update to the council and the public. We had a successful community conversation last Tuesday night.

4:35 Had over 70 people participating and then a lot of views on Facebook after the fact. We did put up a frequently asked questions. We pulled questions from that meeting and from some of the other questions we received. That is up on our website now and we are continuously updating those frequently asked questions as we get additional questions. Also, we are working on the master plan, the draft master plan. We spoke about that last Tuesday.

5:04 That document will be available for public review on Monday for two weeks, and that'll be available on Engage Mammoth Lakes. So we'll be pushing out that information to everybody on Monday when that's available. We have coordinated with Mono County Behavioral Health, and we expect that they'll be providing a presentation to the Town Council at your meeting on November 4th on their supportive housing proposal.

5:27 Also on the disposition development agreement, we're working with the town attorney, our staff and Pacific on that draft agreement. And we've requested a closed session item for your November 4th meeting to brief the council on that disposition development agreement. And then just a brief update that your next full update on the parcel will be on November 10th at your joint meeting with the Planning and Economic Development Commission. And that's four o'clock Tuesday, November 10th.

5:56 And that concludes my update. I'm happy to answer any questions if anyone has any. Yes, Councilmember Stapp. Yes, Senator, are we going to, do we start closer to Center Street or are we further away over where, you know, the different parcels, what parcel are we actually focusing on as to starting development on? I mean, other than the infrastructure. It's the area south of Center Street.

6:29 Okay, south, okay, okay, thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions? Councilmember Wentworth? Yeah, I just want to thank staff and everybody for a great job. It was a great meeting. It was really well done. I sent over some minor notes that might make it a little bit easier on the public. The only thing that I want to make sure we don't lose sight of is Digital 395 and how we're going to make sure we get that integrated in the project. I know we're at home.

6:58 We're all thinking about that and how we're going to make that happen, but that's going to obviously be a key component of making this thing as successful as it can be. But thank you all very much. It was a great presentation. I'm looking forward to the next one, frankly. Thank you. Thanks. Any other questions? Thank you. Mayor Salzer, I think you can return. Thank you. Oh, Rob, do you have a question? I was just going to give a little bit of an update for the plan. Okay. We'll get Bill back here. Bill's back. Go ahead.

7:26 So just a really quick update. As you know, we do an annual audit, external audit that's performed for the town, and that is going to begin on November 9th. The gentleman, Ralph, will be here. I think he'll be on site to do a little bit of work and then try to do most of it remotely. But one of the things he likes to do is make himself available for questions from council members.

7:51 So if you would like to reach out and have any conversation with him, please reach out to me and I'll coordinate that and you guys can have a direct conversation, maybe ask questions with him or provide information, but he always likes to make himself available as an independent auditor to have direct dialogue with you. So just know that he'll be here. The audit's on-site data collection is about two weeks long and it starts on November 9th. That's my update.

8:20 Thank you, Rob. Do we have any other departments or commissions that's wanting to make? Hayes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Just a couple updates. We are in the process of closing out all of our major, larger capital projects, Lake Mary Forest Trail. I want to mention that we're going to be doing some closeout reports to Town Council. These will come as consent items, hopefully just to wrap up the project and let you know where we landed.

8:47 So these will be forthcoming while we complete the projects. Early in the summer, it does take us months to close out the paperwork. And so next couple months, you start to see these trickling in. We do have some contractor work going on, some paving on Dorrance. Town has got a contractor doing some concrete maintenance around town that's scattered throughout various neighborhoods. And then we are going to probably receive a donation of some free slurry from Mark Wolter, Black Old Asphalt.

9:16 Remaining supply to the town. So we'll be working with him to use it around town. That's a donation so it doesn't go to waste because he doesn't have anything to use it on himself. We are submitting, I mentioned this to LTC, a Highway Safety Improvement Program Grant. This grant is very, very competitive and it's very restricted to very certain types of projects. This year they did have a set aside for very specific pedestrian improvements.

9:45 Staff saw an opportunity to put together a grant application to replace the beacons on Highway 203. We would be replacing the bulbs with rapid flash beacons like you see on Old Mammoth Road at the locations at the post office in Laurel Mountain. And then we are also proposing a new crosswalk at Mountain Boulevard, and that would be complete with some additional concrete and sidewalk work. This was supported by Caltrans. We did receive a letter of support.

10:14 Total works about $250,000 and we'll be submitting that in the next couple of weeks. And finally, the town opened bids for the Community Recreation Center on Friday the 16th. Staff was excited to see six bids from well-qualified and respected contractors. The apparent low bid was just under $8.9 million. These bids have not yet been analyzed.

10:41 And while the low bid was well within the $13 million overall budget, there are a number of items the Town needs to purchase and construct in order to deliver a complete project. Staff is currently working on a comprehensive budget and project analysis, and this analysis will be inclusive of all the work that is needed to complete the project, as well as everything that's been completed to date.

11:08 In order to deliver a viable project open for business day one without phasing. This examination will be incorporated into a town council presentation that will also include a full review of the project scope, schedule, and associated programming. We expect to have that to you within the next few meetings or next couple of months as it were. That's it. Thank you. Thank you, Hayes.

11:38 Any other departments? Seeing none, I will move on to staff presentations. Item one, update on the Creek Fire and Forest Orders. And Dan, I believe you're going to kick us off with this one. Yeah, thank you. I'll start with this. And then we have some of their fire team on the call, Jeff Henson, Deborah Schweitzer, and Gordon Martin.

12:07 Overall work on the fire has been progressing. There's been some shifts in the management of the fire, going from a two-team to a one-team management structure. We have been working with them on some of the Facebook Live events that the forest service has been hosting. Stu's been providing some key questions for them to make sure it gets addressed for the Mammoth Lakes community, and they have been very responsive to that work. We're doing some ongoing efforts in that in terms of our public outreach.

12:37 As you know, we hosted one community conversation regarding the fire. We looked at scheduling a second one, giving the update tonight and what we're seeing from the Facebook Live. We have not yet scheduled an additional community conversation as we have in the past. That can be done again this next week, kind of just depending on the status of the fire and where it goes and moves. We will have a change in the weather this

13:06 We're looking at even getting down into a first hard freeze of the season. Hopefully that'll have some impact regarding their ability to fight the fire and slowing it down. But the fire professionals here can speak to that in that area. I don't know, Stu, if you want to provide any introductory comments to this, and then we can turn it over to Jeff, Deb, and Gordon to provide us an update on the status of the fire.

13:33 Yeah, thank you, Dan. Just really quickly for the community and council's benefit, the California team one took over north zone and the south zone. So now we have one team managing the fire. It's, you know, upwards of 332,000 acres, a lot of forward progression. But on the public information side, you know, we scheduled that meeting last Thursday just because there were so many questions that were left unanswered. And certainly everyone was concerned with the smoke and the fire's behavior and its movement.

14:02 Up on that northeast section of the fire around the South Fork and Fish Lake area. So I know Gordon and Deb and I'm thinking Jeff is too. That's just great. You can talk about that. But the public outreach will be Friday. So the Facebook live event will be Friday at seven o'clock and then that will shift to Monday and Thursday. So they'll be transitioning to twice a week.

14:30 It's 7 o'clock on the Sierra National Forest Facebook page. That was from Kristen today, who's the PIO for that team. And at this time, what we're asking that team to do is provide a more detailed, thorough kind of pause when they get to kind of that area and speak a little bit more about Mammoth Lakes. You know, what is the strategy again? What's the threat? You know, what we kind of covered in our kind of Mammoth Lakes meeting last week.

14:58 But still kind of in a smaller, you know, scale and context just for Mammoth Lakes. So that's our kind of strategy moving forward with Outreach. You can see we are providing the map, the smoke outlook and the incident briefing each and every day on the town's Facebook page, as is Deb Schweitzer sharing that through her channels. You know, so that's going out every day. And we just received a great little kind of creek fire story.

15:25 Thank you, Stu.

15:58 Jeff, you going to start us off? Sure. So, yeah, you're all correct. We transitioned, you know, I was on the management team that was over there. We transitioned yesterday with California Team 1 and met, you know, our transitions over there, just so you guys know, they showed up about two days ago, started talking with us. I spent yesterday with their ops folks and the folks that are, you know, the ops folks are going to be looking at the,

16:28 The east side of the fire and what's close to the NEO and the Mammoth Lakes. So I spent all day with those guys yesterday, toured around, looked at maps, traded phone numbers, all that good stuff. It's shadow day is what we call it. And so I knew those guys prior. Jeff, you remuted for some reason. Yeah, it was showing me that on my screen. I was like, what was I saying? Sorry about that. But yeah, I think the last thing I said is I knew those ops folks from previous fires.

17:01 California Times, so good download with those folks. So yesterday evening, you know, smoke is, well, I'll back up. So my drive over today, just to let you guys all know, smoke is just as bad in Fresno, Clovis, Oakhurst, up in Wawona, Yosemite Valley, all the way around. It looks the same everywhere today, just on my drive back to the east side here.

17:31 So yesterday, Gordon, I see you shared a screen there. I had a Google Earth map up as well that I was going to share. But, you know, so yesterday evening, about, right about five o'clock, we have a fire watch is what we call it. It's a Cobra helicopter that can fly infrared and shoot videos through the smoke. They discovered that it had slopped over a little bit, a few acres over, over the rim of the Junction Buttes.

18:00 Which are kind of the top of the escarpment there before it drops down. Yep, right there where Gordon's circling. Right at the confluence of Fish Creek and the middle fork of the San Joaquin there. It stopped over there. It got into some trees, kind of torched them out, threw some ember cast, and we got a spot probably three-quarters of the way down the slope, two-thirds to three-quarters, somewhere in that kind of range. As of last night, that was just a small little spot fire. It wasn't doing much yet.

18:30 So, and then our typical infrared fixed wing missions that we have every, usually nightly, didn't happen last night, I think due to pilot time out and had to take a day off. So we should see that again tonight, I think. And the Firewatch helicopter was down today and should be back tomorrow is what I understand. So we current, you know, last week,

18:59 I don't remember what day, I think, before the call that I was on last. We sent a hotshot crew over with a local division supervisor over to the Mammoth there to start scouting lines and just kind of know the area and have an idea of where it's gone. That has since been put on the fire maps, and so the contingency lines for the east side over here, and then the hotshot crew is still over here.

19:27 They came back to Clovis yesterday to check in, and then they came back to Mammoth today. Same crew, and the plan there is that they're going to hike down into the pond on a daily basis and monitor it from that side. And as it gets lower, that's a really steep slope. I mean, it's like, yeah, it's too steep to need ropes and whatnot to kind of be up there. So they'll be monitoring it, and if it drops down into the Fish Creek drainage there.

19:55 They'll be looking for opportunities to take action on it where it'll be sitting. In my eyes, you know, barring a big wind event that if a fire was sitting up on the Junction Butte and we got a big wind event and it would push the fire east further, you know, that wouldn't be great. But with this spot fire down low, it's going to allow the fire to burn back uphill and connect to the main fire and be close to that creek so it's backing down.

20:25 Ideally, holding on the creek so that if we do get that next wind event or whatnot, it's already at the creek and not having a lot of fuel to push across the creek. I hope that makes sense to you there. But yeah, so I'll kind of end with that. If there's questions or Gordon or Deb or if there's any other fire folks I want to add, I'm back on the east side and then back I'll be tomorrow, I'll be back engaged with my daily job, my other hat.

20:52 And I actually hope to plan either tomorrow or the next day to hike down to Pondly myself and join that crew and take a look down there a little bit better. So anyway, I'll stop there. Jeff, I have a question for you, if I might. So where it currently is existing, are the plans from the Forest Service just to allow it if it wants to go down into String Meadows and up to the Silver Creek?

21:22 Drainage and then for it to join, it would appear the fire coming up from Thomas A. Edison so that the whole ridge above the South Fork would be connected with that fire and the whole ridge along what you're calling Junction Bluffs there along the ridge going down into Fish Creek. Would that just be allowed to burn or are we making some efforts to try and put it out before that?

21:49 Yes, in a sense it is right now. With the air quality the way it is and getting firefighters out to those areas and not being able to support them with aircraft, that's a safety concern of the teams is getting firefighters that deep out there and not being able to support them with the aircraft. And that's our number one means of being able to support aircraft. It's probably too far to support them by packers on a daily basis or...

22:19 To be able to extract them if there was a need, if the fire made a run or someone was injured, aircraft is kind of what we count on to support and get people out in a timely manner. So yeah, currently, so if you look down by Thomas Edison Lake there, kind of going west and then north off of Thomas Edison and then coming out of the stuff that's come from the Balloon Dome and Cassidy Meadows area.

22:48 That stuff's slowly starting to join together. And like you said, the silver divide area, it's pretty well delimited on this map, just that lighter gray. And, you know, my time over there, being able to fly when I could and watching the fire behavior going up to Pincushion Peak, which is probably midway there, a little bit higher, Gordon, a little bit back to your left. But, yeah, right in there is Pincushion Peak.

23:14 You know, the fire wasn't really wanting to push east too much in the fields that it was in and starting to rock itself out up in there. We did do a little burnout a couple nights ago around Thomas Edison Lake, just that furthest east piece, that's the Vermilion Valley Resort, furthest east little finger on Thomas Edison there. Burn that out, that was really successful and that was a defensive measure to protect the structures that are out there as the fire does want to move east.

23:44 But as we showed the other day, the fire modeling and the FS Pro Runs is what we call it. Some fire modeling really didn't show it wanting to go east much further. It was mainly connecting the two fires on that east side back together. And then, you know, they showed it dropping into Fish Creek, but not really progressing past Fish Creek. But yeah, Bill, I think, you know, I wouldn't feel comfortable myself being out there and putting crews out there.

24:13 Out in front of it. It's a lot of country and it would take, it's a lot of work and a long ways to go. It'd probably, you know, yeah, hanging people out there kind of. No, I'm not necessarily disagreeing with you, Jim. I just wanted to ask the question so people knew what to look forward to. Yep, yep, I understand. Thank you. I don't know if there's any other fire folks. I don't know if there's anybody from the team, the current team there or not.

24:48 Deborah Gordon, did you want to weigh in on this? I would probably add a couple of things just to reiterate what Stuart said and what Jeff said. One is that this team's pretty engaged. I had a really good conversation with them about what we're looking for for a briefing for the east side. And they were really receptive. And I think they knew they were getting there that last Facebook live meeting was, you know.

25:16 Much, much better and certainly addressed a lot of our concerns. I've been really clear that anytime we drop mentioning what's happening in this sort of pin cushion junction view area, that's a source that we want to hear about what that fire is doing and we want to hear it pretty much every day just so that Mammoth knows what we're seeing. And they heard that very well and I thought their update today did an excellent job with that. So I think we're making some progress there.

25:42 The other thing I would emphasize is, you know, and I think it's hard for the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and I get it, it's been six weeks of smoke and six weeks of fire at your back door, and it's been a long run, but this really is full suppression, and I think folks hear us say this a lot on the eastern Sierra, steep and accessible terrain to the point where people kind of maybe sometimes don't really hear what we're saying. This is not places where we can really safely

26:12 Engage fire for our firefighters and some of these strategies really are the best we can do in the terrain that we're given and that's part of why we live in the eastern Sierra as the mountains but this is you know maybe part of what's making it a little bit more problematic but I get that it's frustrating because it can seem like in the last six weeks there's been very little done on this side but there's been some really good reasons for that.

26:35 And then I think the last thing I would want to emphasize is the smoke has been, as many of you pointed out, and I've done in Bishop and it's not much better, pretty bad. And it's been pretty bad for the last, you know, three to five days in particular. And I don't have a good solution. I wish I could say it could make the smoke go away and I can't.

26:58 But I would say that they have a really, really good air resource advisor on the incident, Dr. Amber Ortega, and she's been putting on some really good products about how to, you know, reduce your exposure, how to create clean rooms, how you can make, you know, little filters in your home. I'm married to an air quality specialist, so I tell you, I have a HEPA filter in my home for these occasions, and I'm using it, and it really, really does help.

27:26 That's not maybe as good as saying, hey, it's going to clear out. But in the absence of being able to say that, at least, you know, there are some pretty good tools and she's a really good resource for how we can do some stuff to kind of reduce exposure to smoke that we're having right now. Yeah, I have a quick go back to just on Bill's question about suppression and what we're doing. You know, really been my time over there this last week or so as it got onto the Junction Buttes.

27:55 Really wanted to use Type 1 helicopters, the heavy helicopters that have the carrying of the most water, kind of be able to get in there and just drop water on the Junction Buttes area and just slow it down and potentially hold it up there. With the air quality, we weren't able to fly and get those helicopters up there. So that was kind of unfortunate. It was a tactic we used on the Lions fire when we had it to keep it out of the middle fork and crossing onto that Junction Buttes area.

28:23 And it worked really well, but we had good air during the Lions fire when we were doing that. And just right now, we're just not able to fly aircraft. And then the question before we haven't started the meeting here and about smoke and cold air and all that, you nailed it, Bill. The cold air is potentially going to slow down the fire. The fuels are still dry. So without precipitation and a good amount of precipitation, those fuels are going to continue to want to burn.

28:52 In the cold air, it's going to not do great things for the smoke necessarily. It's going to keep it held down close to the ground. So you answered that better than I could, Bill, I think. Thank you, sir. Okay. Hey, Bill, I have a couple of questions and comments. Number one, yes, we are dealing with smoke, but the scope...

29:17 of what people on the other side have had to deal with with this fire. It's my understanding a lot of structures, homes, people are displaced. They're not able to even go back and get their belongings. Is that the case right now still? Well, you're exactly right. There were a number of homes over there and, you know, driving.

29:45 You know, my time over there, I didn't drive the whole fire, but driving from Clovis up to the China Peak ski area and Route 168 there, pretty devastating fire effects and seeing the destruction of the fire through there. But as far as I know, all residents have been allowed back to their residence if they're there or to get back to what they've lost and kind of go, you know.

30:11 Search the ground and whatnot. You know, just last weekend, all the vehicles that were stranded at Lake Thomas Edison at Florence Lake where they showed the owners up there to get all the vehicles. So I think that was kind of the last, as far as I know, that was one of the last pieces of the puzzle for the general public to get their belongings. Okay. So I guess what my...

30:37 The issue is that even though we are dealing with smoke and that is not fun, other people have gone through a much worse scenario and is this a time that people should be looking after their personal property as far as cleaning their yards, making sure that they have a fire safe area around their house?

31:05 What can you tell the people of Mammoth Lakes just in case we do get weird wins and something happens? I think that there could be a little bit more proactive behavior on our part. And what would be your thoughts on that? I have thoughts. I know Deb probably does too. You know, I, it's not, now's the time to always let me know.

31:35 It's always the time to be doing that defensible space around your structures and not just this year because of the creek fires threatening us and we've seen all these over 100,000 acres fires and a million acre fire in California. You know, we've known this for a long time that we need to do the defensible space around our structures and yeah, every little bit's going to help if you're out there doing it now for the next fire is going to help. You know, it's been a

32:09 That's what we've preached for a number of years is that 100-foot clearance, that 30-foot clearance, and then went to 100-foot clearance around your house and being prepared for the next one. So anytime's a good time, and yeah, we're not out of the water yet. And not just from the Creek Fire, from another start here on the east side that, you know, if we get east winds or something like that. So we're not out of the water yet by any means, and always clearing is always a good thing.

32:36 And I would follow up with that. And I believe if you look at the updates that goes out, they're reporting just under 900 homes were lost on the Creek Fire. So yes, definitely a lot of people very seriously impacted. And I do like to reiterate what Jeff said. This is the largest single fire in California state history. This is a mega fire.

33:00 It's not something that we want. It's not natural fire regime. Fires of the size and intensity. So, and I would definitely echo that, you know, for the Town of Mammoth Lakes, you know, there's, you know, we live in California. It's getting drier. It's getting hotter. Fire starts are getting scarier every time I see them. It's different than when I started 20-something years ago. So defensible space, I would recommend either going to Ready, Set, Go.

33:28 Which is done by a lot of the local counties. Or I would also take a look at Cal Fire's got a wonderful Ready for Wildfire page. And it tells you how to prepare not only defensible space and, you know, hardening your home, but also what do you do if it comes and what do you bring with you and how do you plan and how do you re-meet with your family if it should come to that. Like those things are reality throughout California in my mind. So, and again, maybe now is...

33:57 The time, but so will it be in a month, and so it will be a month from now. We always need to know what we're doing with that. Thank you both. If I could throw in a couple things here. Yeah, go Gordon. A couple things. One of the reasons I left the map up, all these lighter areas are rock. So you can see there's a lot of rock, you know, between us and the fire. So that's a good thing. The other thing I wanted to mention is that

34:28 The fact that it's down to one team is a very good thing. That's an indication that the fire is becoming less complicated. It also helps that we now only have one team to deal with. The dividing line between the two teams was like right here. And so as the fire was coming this way earlier, we had two different teams to deal with. And that was more complicated.

34:56 They did a good job of coordinating with each other, but it's always better just to have one person to work with. The third thing I have, I don't know if you're ready for it yet, I heard it mentioned, is that we had a meeting today to discuss what we're going to do with the closures. We've been told that the regional forester is going to reissue the closures that he did.

35:24 And that includes the fire closure that does involve the Inyo, and it includes the closures that affect other forests other than the Inyo, but we did submit a request to lighten up a little bit our closure that we've had going, and we'll see what comes back. I don't want to get into details on it, but I will say I did recommend keeping...

35:53 The Reds Meadow area can be closed. We've got a lot invested down there in fire prep, and it's always possible that the fire could come this way, whatever the models show. Like Jeff said, if we get bad wind, it could head this way. Thank you, Gordon. To further answer your question, Cleland, there have been 71 structures damaged, 856 structures destroyed.

36:23 That's residential, commercial, and others. So that's where we stand. Any other questions for our partners from the Forest Service? John. Yeah, two questions. One, Deb, I was on the call today with some Region 5 folk, and I shared out that, you know, the Creek Fire is the biggest fire in state history, and they said, well, are you guys up to a million acres yet? Maybe you could define the difference between the Creek Fire and some of the complex fires. That's the first question.

36:52 And second thing is we've got a couple fronts coming in this weekend and I'd love to hear from Jeff and the team what should our expectations be for fire behavior coming through this weekend. Thank you. So the largest single fire is one single ignition source. I mean I think up to this point prior to that it might have been RIM or I forget maybe one of the ones done in SoCal. One ignition source. Whereas the August complex which I think is reclining

37:22 Giga Fire, we call ourselves a mega fire here on the creek fire, they're a giga fire, I think the media termed it, is a series of lightning strikes that grew together or are in close proximity that are being managed together. And yes, the August complex I believe is somewhere in the vicinity of a million acres right now. Got it, thanks for clarification. Yeah, I think the August fire was like 10 fires or something like that that all grew together.

37:51 You know, the Creek Fire is a single point ignition, so. Yeah, got it. Good to know. Yeah, John, good question about the weather. You know, the weather that I was getting on the fire there from our meteorologists and whatnot, on the west side, they're not talking about big winds coming with these fronts and that, you know, it's supposed to get cold, I think, starting tomorrow, if I remember right, right now, and cool out pretty significantly this weekend with potential.

38:23 A little bit of the pre-step, I think Sunday, is that correct? They weren't calling for a lot of big wins from the west side over there, and I looked at the weather coming from Reno today, and they are kind of talking about wins, and that's pretty typical for, you know, when we do prescribe burning everyone out of the Lions fire that we had, playing both sides, the Hanford weather over there on the west side, and then the Reno weather, and they're often...

38:53 Conflicting to some extent. So, you know, in the Reno weather, I believe, really, they have a hard time predicting our weather here, as we all know, ski season and whatnot, and how much snow we're going to get, and this and that. So I think the west side weather right now would be more of an effect on the Creek Fire. But, you know, during the Lions Fire, we had an anomaly wind that came through early on in that fire and pushed it out to the west, actually.

39:23 And, you know, it wasn't predicted. That's just a tough place for the weather folks to predict. And especially with the river drainages, that's always tough and the mountain slopes and whatnot. But I do believe that the fire is in a pretty good place right now. And I think that that spot that came off the junction, we'll watch it here the next couple of days. But I think that might be a beneficial thing that it's going to burn back up slope.

39:50 And take some fuels out of that and take some of the meat and some of the potential out of it. So I think just from a smoke perspective to hear north winds, northwest winds, that's hopefully is going to be a good thing and get flush things out a little bit. At least we get that, right? Yeah, yeah. I agree. Any kind of a shift out of that south southwest, as long as it's not too strong, is really going to help the smoke on the east side and for a lot of folks everywhere. Yeah, good.

40:20 And I would echo too because if you look at the two forecasts, one's calling for more rain and one's calling for less. I know that the meteorologist on the incident is saying there's a one in five chance for rain. So 20% chance that there'll be rain. It may not be wetting.

40:40 But I've seen some of the forecasts over here on the east side be a little bit more optimistic about that. So, but I think the key point is, is this not what we would call a season ending event coming our way. It's going to help. They're definitely calling for higher relative humidities, which will definitely help. And maybe a little bit of precip and cooler temperatures, you know, fire behaviors, you know, ultimately.

41:04 Dictated by weather's fuels and topography. So anytime the weather gets cooler and the dates gets shorter, that's going to help. I would just follow up with something that Gordon said, because I got confused about the terminology we were using on the closure, and I actually had to ask Pancho about it today. So when we say the fire closure, we're actually talking fire restrictions.

41:28 My understanding is the fire restrictions as they stand right now, which is only propane stoves and campgrounds and no fires whatsoever while dispersed are going to continue for another week. And then there's the issue of what the INEO's closures look like right now, which is the wilderness areas for the most part in the Sierra Nevada. And those are the things we're looking to try to get a little bit more of a loosening up on.

41:57 Thank you, guys. Any further questions? That being said, I want to thank those of you from the Forest Service for putting up with us again today and answering our questions. It is always very helpful as we pass things along to our constituents. Thank you. Moving on then to item number two, quarterly T.O.T. enforcement update. Rob? Yes, sir. I'll just continue it up.

42:37 Can you see the enforcement update on the screen? Yes. Okay, good. Yeah, so this quarter, we're going to go through the standard look that we have for our enforcement report, if you will, mainly talking about... Rob, maybe you get it in presenter mode, is that possible? If not, don't worry about it, it's just a little small. There you go, thank you. All right, sorry about that. That feels a little better for me as well.

43:10 So this is our standard activity report that shows what the team was able to work on. As you know, the month of July and August, the enforcement team was spending a lot of time out in the field with the ambassador program. So we had a lot of ground activity and a little bit less just strict enforcement, if you will. But we did open 10 cases within that period of time that primarily occurred.

43:41 Through August and September time frames. So 10 cases is a pretty good number. Typically on a big year we'll do up to 80 cases, 85 cases. What you'll see a little bit later on is we're shifting a lot of focus to audits and they're fairly productive, but certainly following up on all of our enforcement activity that we have there.

44:06 We did open 10 cases. As I stated, we issued 27 total citations for that. And then assessments issued. Those are, again, those occur if somebody doesn't respond to a citation. Our citations are initiated to have someone contact us. And that's the purpose of those items. But if somebody doesn't contact us within the allotted time frame, then they'll issue an assessment, which is an estimate of earnings.

44:36 NODs are notice of determinations issued. So we had nine of those, which means we completed nine of the enforcement cases and brought them into a, here's your amount owed and that's the final number. So quite a bit of collection if you see in the revenue items, 47,000 and 4,144 in zoning.

45:01 That would be definitely one notice of determination that was issued. So a total of 51,000 in the first quarter for enforcement activity. And we give you the ratio of, you know, how things go there. This is a snapshot from Host Compliance, our online platform that does monitor all the activity within town. So the actual number of units, 3,466. It's kind of hard to read the fine print down below, but there's 6,223 ads.

45:32 Out there right now for rentals within the Town of Mammoth Lakes. So each one of those units is roughly two ads out there, different platforms, if you will, and that's how that's categorized. This time of year is a busy time where folks do have a seasonal aspect of their business. Some people just do it during the winter time. And so we do see things added during the month, and that's really a trigger point for us.

45:58 If it's coming up within the last seven days, we've got eyes on it. We had 74 units added in the last month. And then the identified ratio, 94.1, which you never get to 100%. My target is 95. And it just takes sometimes a lot of effort to find some of those last bits and pieces. But teams doing a great job of focusing on that. And again, this is kind of consistent with what we typically see.

46:29 You know, the progress updates for the quarter, you know, we focus on restarting the short-term rental activity in a safe manner. That was a big challenge, as you know. In June, I think it was the 19th, we opened up for short-term rental. And so we really started hitting hard in the July timeframe to begin this quarter. And so much of that time and effort was spent with the ambassador team out there. A lot of questions from operators on how to safely do business.

46:58 And just the changing rules and regulations that are there. As you know, the health order did contain quite a few restrictions on what they can do in those items. It just took a great deal of time kind of walking people through an education process. I'd say the bulk of what the team does is educational. In every aspect of what we do, there's a piece of education to that.

47:23 You know, talk about a busy time of year as new short-term rental operators start to prepare for the winter season. That's clearly the busiest time that we have. Despite having a lot of information published out there for people to read and research, a lot of folks do a ton of research. They rely on us, which they should, you know, to give them the lay of the land if they're coming in and opening a business as they should be. But it's just a real busy time for that, for the team on that.

47:53 The business tax certificate renewal, as you know, this is an annual renewal process. We begin that in December. So second week in December, we'll be mailing those documents out to all businesses with the expectation they'll be turned back to us by January 31st. And they begin to be late after that point. So it's a very seasonal item. It's very challenging because there's quite a few of them to receive. And just folks.

48:22 You know, need to be pushed through the process quite often. And so we do have quite a bit that do come in late and require us to do additional steps. We do have a process by which we go through where it's, you know, constant communication and it's ramping up of communication, if you will. But the team's got that pretty well seasoned and it functions well. So it just takes a lot of effort. We did go back to TOT collections on a monthly basis for September.

48:53 There is some confusion, not confusion necessarily, but there's some inherent challenges. If you remember when we went out to you guys earlier and said, hey, we want to go to receiving collections every three months, we would report still on a monthly basis, but collect, and it wouldn't be late except for three months at a time. And TBID, quite a bit more complicated process. They have to go out.

49:23 Through their members and have that process. So they went a little bit further. Instead of doing two three-month blocks, they did three three-month blocks. So TBIT is actually not due monthly until I think it's going to be December's due in January. So our TOT is due monthly now. So September's was coming in over the last couple of days. It is the 21st right now.

49:51 What we ran into with that is the persons, if you're a lodging operator, you pay your TOT and T-Bit on the same return. And so we communicated out to them that yes, T-Bit is not due, TOT is due. But if you're paying online, we don't have the ability to take a partial payment and we've actually blocked that functionality. So if someone is going to report their TOT and T-Bit on the return for lodging, they have to pay the full amount.

50:20 Or they're going to have to submit a paper return and pay by check. So quite a bit of moving parts, if you ask me. We came up with a program that supports the intent and what we say down as ground rules. But it's going to be complicated for operators if they choose to try not to pay their T-bid if they're a lodging operator. Teams have been really busy in the last few days walking folks through that process. And I wish it was more streamlined, but it's just the nature of it.

50:49 Two different due dates on the same item. Cannabis audit program that continues to operate. You may or may not remember, we have these audits completed by HDL. They're really the professional organization within the cannabis world as far as regulations and building your regulatory environment as well as the audit process. So that I'd say is getting a little bit more streamlined. There are two audits that are conducted on each business per year. One financial, which covers all 12 months.

51:20 And the other one's an annual regulatory compliance, just to make sure that all the businesses are operating physically in the process in which they're allowed to. So they come up on site, they walk through and do a review of each of the businesses and report back on that. And I think it's getting really pretty streamlined and pretty good. And the cost of that audit is passed on to the operators as part of their annual business taxes surging.

51:49 Looking at our current focus, so the online search engine host compliance, as you know, we just, we renewed it for one more year. We will work on our request for proposals for system replacement in spring of 2021. And that's really just to give us some, with all the things that are going on, to get that RFP out of what had been due in the June, the May-June timeframe in order to be replaced by October. So just decided to push that off a year. We're not unhappy with it.

52:19 With hosts, there's just some additional functionality that's out there in new areas, and I think that we're interested in entertaining some of those, and it's just good to go out once in a while. It's been about three or four years we've had hosts, three years. But again, a review of the advertisements weekly, that's ongoing with the team and functionality. The team did kind of shift over focus, like 75% of the time right now is on enforcement work, and really with regard to health orders, and that comes primarily in audits that are being performed.

52:54 We are working to continue to develop the ambassador program. I think that's been hugely successful for the town and really connecting with the business community and partnering with them through this challenge. I mean, we're all kind of reliant on each other and dependent on the success of one another. I think that ambassador program has been really successful. It's one of the things I'm most proud of in the year and our accomplishments. We're looking to develop that a little bit further. I'm certainly going to revamp that and start through the winter process, get out there a little bit more too.

53:26 And just not make it a COVID thing, but really make it a, here's how we, here's how we determine and engage with our business. The health order enforcement function, so the audit of the short-term rentals ban during, I'm sorry, the rentals during the ban, that's been pretty effective. We've issued citations on those. Those are $1,000 for each occurrence. So if someone has a rental that occurred.

53:54 During that ban, but they don't have the proper documentation and cannot produce the proper documentation, which would be proving that the rental was to an essential worker that was here in town for work business, then they'll receive that. So we've been very successful with that, and I think folks are, I want to get that message out there. I know there's some challenge in saying, hey, support the people that listen to the ban, listen to the headquarters, and effectively

54:22 Executing on that. And that's where we really decided to focus our energies and efforts. And I think it's significant. We're also doing quick audits on those 24-hour gaps. Oh, just back on the health audits too. We'll go as far as calling. People provide documentation. We do follow up on that during contact the individual and get information. And that's been pretty, pretty effective. The quick audits on the 24-hour gaps in rentals, that's something that is, we're still working on. I think there's a health order discussion going on now.

54:57 Maybe some minor adjustments to that, but we were working pretty heavily through that process and just making sure everyone was following the rules there. Looking forward to getting back on that. And again, we just went out and got the violations to be more financial to catch people's attention a bit harder. And it's been really effective. So the audit program, as you know, we kind of paused that a little bit during the ban. We picked it up.

55:26 Quite a bit. So we've conducted 13 audits in the first quarter of the year. And the big number there to focus on reflected $50,420 in unreported tax on those 13 audits. So it's been pretty, it's not that they're all, you know, an average of $4,500. There was a big fish in that pond. And we'd like to continue that. We're targeting 50 audits for this year. With that, you know, we're certainly on target to achieve that. And again,

55:57 It's important that we let people know we're doing that because we're finding some, for the most part, people are doing a very good job and there's people that are deciding to bend the rules a little bit and that comes out in the audit fairly clearly and it's really tough to sit across the table from me and explain maybe why you're underreporting tax. All the regional partnerships, you know, we continue to work closely with Monroe County on a number of areas, but really, you know, I sat through a webinar today on a broader, you know, a California-based review.

56:32 We glean good information from others. Certainly we're a big operator as far as the enforcement of TOT because we have so much activity. But we can get a lot of information from other folks. I've got a list of things. And so what I'll do is glean that information and sit down with Andy Norwood, the attorney, just walk through what we can do and can't do. Most of our enforcement activities. So I think it's been a successful quarter. I look forward to the areas that we're focusing on here.

57:05 Get information to report. Maybe have some public outreach stuff. There are some good outreach programs that the town already is involved in. And as a finance group, I'm looking to get involved in that and involve the community a little bit in this process. And I'll just give you a dabble in one of those thoughts. Some folks are saying, what does it mean to be a resident of the community? So what does it mean to be a mammoth resident? So we might work with a public forum to sort of generate that.

57:34 Processing and maybe get that into either on our websites or maybe some support for tourism notices. It's like, what does it mean to come to Mammoth? So that's been pretty effective and look forward to the next quarter. Are there any questions? Any questions for Rob? Rob, if you want to quit sharing, I can see everybody. Yeah, I'm trying. Any questions for Rob? Linda? No, I don't have any questions. I just appreciate.

58:14 The work, I think those are, you know, the right thing to do to help people be successful landlords, if you will, and oversee what's going on. I think the word will spread in the community. We're serious about this, and I think that's the value also. So thank you and your members for doing such a good job. Kirk? No questions. Three quick things, Rob. I'm interested, we are still in, obviously, the land of COVID. This summer,

58:52 I think it's challenging, but in terms of revenue and dollars, you know, we had something to work with. I'd be interested, if you have them available, just kind of year over year numbers, one, just to kind of looking at trends, but also, I think maybe the subsequent meeting to get some idea of what we're going to be looking at, again, using that council budgeting discipline of extremes high, extreme low, we have no idea what's going to happen this winter, and I think to

59:22 Make sure we're prepared for that. We could do a follow-up with that at some point. So I don't want to put you on the spot for anything right now, but if you have anything, yeah, sure. Actually, I can speak to July and August because, you know, we went through the S&P review, so I had to do quite a bit of work with that. And so July and August for this year, 2020, were the strongest July and August we've ever had for GOT election. Okay. So that's kind of,

59:51 A surprise. Well, not a surprise because we lived through it. We know how many people were here. But July and August, both were, I think one of them was well over and the other one was slightly under, but I think it's now climbed up. So those would be the record months for those collections. They also collected more than the threshold target that I have set for January.

1:00:17 Just in those two months, it was about 3.6 million that was collected, and our target for being concerned about needing to make further cuts is 3.4 million by January. So that tells you the strength of those. Now, we stepped into September, and I don't yet have numbers for those. I'm looking for some information on them. It's a little bit early right now to report that. But I know the closure of the forest was really effective in keeping people from coming here.

1:00:47 As you remember, looking around town, there's just not a lot of people. So I'm expecting September and October to be very soft as they normally are, but actually September's usually got some strength to it. I expect that to be fairly soft, and then October will be what it is, and again, maybe off of that number. But the thing is, on these smaller months, if they're really impacted, we're really lucky. If this would have happened in a very busy time of year, then it would have been much more impactful.

1:01:16 The fact that these are really kind of times that it's supposed to be a little slow for us, it doesn't hurt as much. And so... In July and August, that was in a time where we had restrictions on restaurants, I mean, on restaurants, on hotels, on lodging, and all the rest of it. So I just want to, for all of us, to just keep in mind that the extreme situations we're in.

1:01:42 It's nice to come out with record-setting numbers. That's all good, but this could as easily go the other way, so we want to keep our eye on that. And finally, on the host compliance, I'm assuming you're happy with the services they've been providing, but this RFP and this going out to bid is just basically testing the market and seeing what else is out there and if we can improve on what's already been a pretty good program so far. Yeah, so I get contacted often by new businesses that are up there, and it's ironic. Some folks are like, you know, they're people that are in my position, and they maybe have some IT background as well, but

1:02:12 They live through this stuff, and they're like, you know, here's how a program would look a little bit better for me. So there's a lot of evolution that's going on in that industry. And I know, you know, Host has really been the big player in that. Some of these folks have come up with some creative ideas. So the idea here would be, let's see what that looks like. And Host is definitely going to be a part of the response to the RFP that we do. But it just kind of keeps them honest as well that the cost, Host was purchased by Granicus, and the cost did go up for us on that.

1:02:42 We paid $72,000 for the year versus $50,000 when we first started out. So it's going up a little bit, and it's just good to keep folks honest, but to really see what the new items are that are out there. Yeah, and I think, I mean, so many constituents and so many folks in town, I think, should take so much solace and reassurance that where technology created the beast, technology is actually helping us to mitigate it, track it, enforce it, and stay on top of it.

1:03:09 And that we can manage these kinds of programs going forward as long as we're vigilant and stay on top of it. So thanks a lot. Echoing Linda's comments, great work by the team, and let's get ready for the roller coaster to come. Thanks. Thank you. John Cleland. Yes. No, thank you for that presentation. That was wonderful. I do wonder, it is a little disturbing that we had such high numbers.

1:03:37 Coming from the other, you know, the individuals who are renting their places, how are we doing with hotels? People who are investing have very specific ways of taking care of their guests. How are we stacking up when it comes to hotels to, and I realize some places have

1:04:07 Units like Juniper where people own them, but it's also a hotel, but what are we doing to support the hotel industry? And how have their numbers been? Well, I don't have off the top of my head what the numbers sort of bifurcated between short-term rental and hotel. Some of the restrictions are a little bit different with them, and we try to tailor them to their

1:04:38 The term I use, you know, in talking to folks, these are the terms that we use. So the occupancy rate of the hotel is really a different term than the 24-hour gap that we require in the short-term rental world. So I think, you know, we're trying to do what actually fits best for both. And some of the restrictions are a little bit less on hotels because of the managed staff and of the support that they have.

1:05:06 As far as audit processes, they're very similar in regards to what we're looking at and the information that we require they provide. So it's no different from that perspective as far as enforcement activity, but as far as the management of the health crisis, we think we've got the sweet spot of what works best for both, but always looking for areas of improvement. Okay, thank you. Since I didn't start my little notes in time, Kirk, did you have any other comments?

1:05:45 I was going to save this for the COVID, but since you brought it up, Rob, the ambassador program, I'm getting good feedback at how well your team is going out and doing that and how professional they have been and upbeat they have been. So I wanted to pass that along to council and you as well, that kudos are coming back to us from that program. I think it has been a plus, not just from COVID.

1:06:11 But from people actually being able to see town staff out and about and meet them and ask them questions and have that interpersonal relationship. So, you know, kudos to the team and to you and Sandra especially. With that, if there are no additional questions on this, I will move on to consent. I will read consent real quick. Approve the minutes of the regular meeting of October 7. Adopt a resolution revising.

1:06:42 Addresses for certain properties within the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Approve the resolution continuing the local emergency regarding COVID-19 declared on March 18, 2020. Approve the formal termination of agreement between the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mono County, and Mammoth Lakes Recreation for the shared Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator position. Waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance amending municipal code chapter.

1:07:11 12.10.040 regarding our floodplain ordinance. 8. Approve resolution adopting the program guidelines for the Town of Mammoth Lakes CARES COVID-19 Emergency Rental Assistance Program authorizing the subrecipient agreement with Mammoth Lakes Housing to administer and accept payment approval reports 2117 and 21-18. With that also on item number 8.

1:07:40 We have an updated resolution from what is in your packet. There appears to be no substantial change. So unless someone wants to pull it, I don't see a reason. Dan, did you want to weigh in on that? Yeah, we do have one item that relates to the guidelines that we need to touch on. So we can go ahead and pull that item. I'll have Attorney Morris speak to that. Okay, so I will pull item number eight. Anyone want to pull anything else?

1:08:12 If not, I would entertain a motion. Kirk, unmute. You're muted. There you go. Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion. Can you hear me? Yep, you're there now. I'll make a motion to approve consent agenda items 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, and 9. I'll second. I have a motion from Kirk, a second from John. Any further deliberations or comments? Yeah, Cleland.

1:09:02 Unmute. Here you go. Yeah. Wait a minute. So I have a different consent agenda. So we are pulling for conversation number what? Eight. That is the approve the resolution adopting the program guidelines for CARES COVID. You know what? My paperwork seems to be out of...

1:09:45 I'm looking at the same information, but I have different numbers. On mine, on consent agenda, I have two, three, four, five, six, seven, and eight. And it's a policy, do I have old, no? Leland, I think you're looking at your October 7th. This is the, that's...

1:10:19 That would be in sync with what you just suggested. There should be no reason why I would have. Oh, okay. Maybe I am looking incorrect. So, yeah, as long as we have that one pulled, because I do want to get more information on the agenda item pulled by Dan previously. So, thank you. Yes.

1:11:04 Thank you. I will call for the item. Councilmember Huff? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes, dear. Got to get a smile somewhere. Okay. Dan, number eight. I was going to have Andy address the one legal change and then...

1:11:35 Sandra over here or her team can speak to some of the detail items of the matter and the grant and what the funds are being used for. Thank you. Yeah, so the only change is that when Nolan and I were looking at the guidelines, we realized that it didn't address what would happen if the renter's landlord refused to sign the forms. We do need to get the landlord to sign the forms, and if the landlord won't, there was a little bit of a hole as to what would happen. So Nolan has come up with some...

1:12:04 Really good language in the guidelines that would say that if the renter can't get the landlord signed, then at that point, the renter would lose the allocation and would go back into the pool. They'd still be eligible for a future round of grant funding, but would lose their place on this one. So, Nolan, do you want to expand on that, or is that pretty much it? That pretty much covers it. In the revised resolution that was sent out earlier, that updated language is in Section D of the guidelines. That's on a page.

1:12:34 25 of the resolution or page 3 of Exhibit B. Any counsel? Would you want to touch briefly on the overall scope of the grant and the use and the allocation as presented in the staff report? Sure. So this grant is when it came to council a few months back as a public hearing item. This money was allocated through the CARES Act. It's being run through the state CDBG program.

1:13:09 It can be used to cover basically any response directly related to COVID. Looking through the program guidelines at the state and federal level, we felt it could best be used to provide rental assistance for eligible households. So that's households that meet the 80% area median income level based on the household size. So it does require...

1:13:35 Income certification, which is different than the town's previous rental assistance program. And then we are going to cap the grant since it is only approximately $68,000 total in funding, at least in the round one funding to $500 per month for a maximum period of three months per household. So that would provide assistance for approximately 40 households. It also allows some administration

1:14:04 Money to cover some of the town expenses related to advertising and other related expenses, as well as some money from Mammoth Lakes Housing to administer the program does, since with the income certification does require a bit more administrative work than the previous program. Also with the CARES Act, there was a round two and round three of funding. They anticipated being a similar dollar amount, but they haven't put out the exact

1:14:32 Okay, anybody have any questions? Cleland. Okay.

1:15:09 gives the people who are landlords, which makes them sound as though they have money. I would just like a little bit of reassurance that people who may have started renting to people who were not good tenants, wait a minute, John's waving his hand. That's right, he's going to be after you.

1:15:37 No, I'm sorry, Cleland, my electricity just came back on. I'm ecstatic. So I'm happy to interrupt. Okay, good language is applause for that. So I guess my question is, I totally support having people, where are we with the $30,000 that we were trying to raise two weeks ago?

1:16:03 Whenever that was, where are we now for rent assistance? And then how is that affecting the landlords if they have a person who is not a good tenant, but now is having the COVID?

1:16:26 Excuse that they can't get rid of them. And, you know, I only have a few meetings left, so I'm just going to ask these questions now. So if someone could please let me know, it's that, yes, I want people to have a house. I don't want them to be kicked out. But at the same time, I do not want landlords to be penalized or have issues with their own finances because this is something where they are

1:16:54 Making their livelihood. Councilmember Hoff, just to follow up on your question. I think this program will help landlords by providing additional assistance where maybe someone might not be able to pay anything at all. This will at least get landlords some amount of money from this program. As far as the prohibition on evicting tenants, I don't know the status of that. I thought that that had expired. I don't know, Andy, if you want to hop in on this one.

1:17:28 Yeah, actually there was a law that was passed, AB 3088, that creates some degree of foreclosure protection and eviction protection for owners and for renters. And so landlords are going to be subject to the new law regardless of this program. And it was pretty hard fought by the California Apartment Association and other kind of landlord groups. They were pretty opposed to it.

1:17:57 Again, new state law, nothing we can do about it, and it has taken effect. Okay, thank you. That pretty much answered it. John, any questions? No questions. I'm good. Thank you. Thank you. Linda? I'm just wondering how we were doing on community donations to the program. I don't know off the top of my head, Dan. Have you heard, gotten an update from Patricia at all? No, I know we've gotten some in, but I do not know what the dollar amount was. Okay, thank you. It wasn't substantial. There was some coming in.

1:18:41 Kirk. I think the donations were around $10,000, probably $10,000 to $12,000. Thank you. I have no questions, just a comment. One of my regular customers and that thing that I used to do for a living, her tenants qualified for this and she refused to take it because she refused to take partial payment. I found that very interesting. Are they, I shouldn't let anybody be able to guess who they might be.

1:19:14 Cleveland, that goes back to your point of them not being able to collect full rent and not being able to evict because they've collected partial. So it is more complex than I was, you know, leaving it to be. I thought it would just all be good things and there are different opinions. So just that comment. Any other questions on this? We have a public comment, Mayor Sauser. I would take it now. Thank you.

1:19:43 William Wallace, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? William, you can now unmute and talk to us. Okay. All right, I got it now. Good evening, Town Council members and members of the public. I have a few things here to say, a few items to go over on regards to item number five on the agenda, continuing the health emergency. So if you just bear with me here and listen to me for a little bit.

1:20:31 I have some things to say. So, under the Emergency Services Act, Section 8558B, a state of emergency can only be called if the threat overwhelms the current resources of the town, county, or state. I ask you this question. Has Mammoth Lakes Emergency Resources been overwhelmed since the declaration of the health emergency? And I have some more. According to California Government Code 8630, under the Emergency Services Act,

1:21:02 The governing body shall proclaim the termination of the local emergency at the earliest possible date that conditions warrant. And also, according to California Health and Safety Code 101080, it also says, the governing body, the city council, shall proclaim the termination of the local health emergency at the earliest possible date that conditions warrant the termination. And so I asked the town council, what evidence do you have that Mammoth Lakes is experiencing a health emergency?

1:21:32 Okay, wait a minute. I'm sorry. I have to stop just because I'm super into protocol. Were we to public comment where somebody could pull an item? Because I am not in sync right now with going back to something. So can we just... Bill, can you just put us back on track here? Because I just...

1:22:02 Was thrown a loop here. So is this item being pulled to talk about? This item has already been approved. Well, no, that's what I was wondering. So how are we talking about something? Should this not have been? I'm just a little out of sync. I probably should have asked for public comment on consent before approval. Oh, okay. Well, can we?

1:22:31 In terms of protocol, although I'm not positive on that, but that we normally don't, but probably I should. So I will remember that into the future to ask if there are public comments on things on this. And Andy, I think you are the best to answer these questions. So if you would give it a shot, please. Thank you, sir. Well, you're correct that you should ask for public comment on the consent calendar before the consent calendar is considered.

1:23:01 In this case, because the consent calendar was adopted before the public comment, it would be, I suppose, appropriate to ask the council whether they want to reconsider anything about the continuation of the declaration of emergency in light of Mr. Wallace's comments. I mean, to give him his due, you do need to at least decide whether you want to reconsider it. You don't have to reconsider it, but you probably shouldn't have a final action.

1:23:27 Before taking public comment. So if the council would like to reconsider the declaration of emergency, you're welcome to do so. You can discuss it. You can redo your action. You can decide that you don't want to discuss it and you're good and move forward. Just whatever you'd like to do. Okay. You heard our town attorney's edict there. So my bad. I will ask each of you if you want to go back and revisit this question in light of the public comment.

1:23:58 Starting with John. Thank you, Bill. I do not have an interest in having a look at this item. I want to make clear I'm relying on the advice of our attorney, Andy Morris, the town manager, Dan Holler, and the Emergency Operations Center, and I've not heard any representation from them. Certainly the facts on the ground haven't changed as far as I can see. If Dan or Andy want to weigh in on this.

1:24:28 Advises that anything has changed regarding our estimation of the emergency and the level of the threat it poses. I'm open to it. But at this time, as one Councilmember, I don't see any need to reconsider. Well, the emergency that the Council declared back in March was not based on a huge flood of COVID cases at the time. The emergency was really based on and remains based on the potential for catastrophic spread of COVID-19 throughout the community.

1:25:00 And at the time, the council adopted findings and took action to declare an emergency so as to be able to deal with the threat and take steps to avoid having COVID-19 spread throughout the community. So if the council feels that the threat has abated and that there's no longer anything to worry about, you could certainly terminate the state of emergency. However, if you think that the threat of COVID-19 remains, even though the actual case numbers in the county and the town are low,

1:25:29 You could stick with the action you've taken to continue the local emergency. And thank you for that clarification, Andy. That makes complete sense. I'm completely in sync with that. The other thing is the component of our emergency was an economic emergency. And we are still in a place where we are seeing manic, potentially very manic swings in economic activity. So I'm perfectly comfortable continuing this economic emergency.

1:25:58 Based on what we all heard with Mammoth Resorts on Monday about what this winter may look like, there's certainly no guarantee that snow is the only variable in our economic forecast going forward this winter. So I'm perfectly comfortable saying where we are. Mr. Mayor, I hope that satisfies your request. And I concur with John. Thank you, Cleland. I will mark you as having made your comment. Linda. Yes, I agree. We do not need to revisit this.

1:26:30 Kirk, unmute. I agree. Thank you. For me, I will say that the Emergency Operations Center and the Declaration of Emergency is what makes it possible for us to react in a timely fashion to anything coming down, and COVID certainly is still with us. We are gaining cases on a daily basis, so I think the need for the emergency still stays there.

1:27:03 I don't think that it is negatively affecting anyone in the community at this point. So I am happy with it staying there as well. So we will not go back and revisit number five. But thank you, sir, for your comments. Now you're back on if you wanted to. Okay, yeah. All right. Well, I'm, you know, you guys are saying that, but the law is pretty clear in its language and it's multiple laws, in fact.

1:27:42 And it's really just, it just really comes down to the fact that are our resources at threat of being overwhelmed? Are they being overwhelmed? And I have not seen it a single time since the declaration of the health emergency. And if I haven't seen the hospital get overwhelmed, I haven't seen our, you know, emergency services being overwhelmed whatsoever. But I will refer you guys to the item number 10. I have some stuff there for you guys to read and you can go over it.

1:28:11 And take some of the language with a grain of salt. It's nothing personal, but I think that there's some valuable information in there regarding the way things have been conducted and how they're being conducted. And I will continue to try to inform you guys on some of the laws that are being violated in order to end the health emergency, which is required by law. Thank you. Okay, Mr. Mayor, I would really like to clarify right now.

1:28:38 If this is a comment on item 10, it should have been addressed during public comment in item 10. If we can somehow maybe take a break, regroup, because I think this has gone a little bit off track with the conversation, and I would just...

1:29:04 I'm a little bit confused about where and when. I have received letters from an individual. Can we just take a five-minute break and then just come back to this? I think I can clear this up, Councilmember Hoff. Mr. Mammoth has offered public comment on item five.

1:29:29 He may also wish to offer public comment on item 10. He is entitled to do that. So one way to proceed would be to just get to item 10 and see if he or anybody else wants to make comment on that and then the council can take action. Okay, but since I have received letters about this, there is still, even though we're in COVID Zoom, there is a time limit in which someone can...

1:29:57 Comment, correct? Yeah. Okay. You know what? I'm sorry. I'm just a little thrown off base with the way this was handled. So I'll get back into the game. But I feel as though we're getting ahead of ourselves and backtracking. And I'll hush now and let us go forward. Thank you, Cleland. I think that all we have done is taken some information from a...

1:30:24 Local resident, and we will give him opportunity to speak to 10 when 10 comes up. Right now we are still dealing, I believe, with number 8. I want to go back and get on track. We have, we've gone through the whole process. I would take a motion on number 8. Mr. Mayor, I move that the council approve the resolution as amended, adopting the program guidelines to the Town of Mammoth Lakes Cares COVID-19 Emergency Rental Assistance Program.

1:30:53 and authorizing the subrecipient agreement with Mammoth Lakes Housing to administer the program. I'll second it. I have a motion from John, a second from Cleland. Any further discussion or deliberation? Seeing no hands going up, I will call for the action. Councilmember Hoff? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes.

1:31:27 Passes 5-0. Yeah, okay. Get my bearings here. Moving on to item number 10, update on response and management of the COVID-19 health and economic declared emergency. And Dan, you're going to lead us here. Yeah, thank you, Mayor. Not a lot of detail this evening. We did include some copies of some interim.

1:31:57 Business operating rules that we put out to the community, I think since our last meeting, as we look at continuing to extend that time frame for business to operate outdoors, primarily some other elements in there with signage and those types of elements. Obviously, ultimately, the outdoor operations will be limited by weather, but again, it'll be an option for our businesses to be able to operate underneath those conditions. The other

1:32:27 A couple quick updates I have would be one is in terms of the ongoing work we're doing, we are looking at some modifications to orders as they relate to our short-term lodging that is still being worked through the process, and also looking at an update in the gathering localized order to incorporate some changes in the state level into that order that would apply then at the local level.

1:32:53 The other recent changes we just heard about today was some modifications in the testing, availability and processes. We have been utilizing UCF, UCSFF, SF for a lot of our testing. They had let us, just let us know that they are no longer going to be doing COVID testing as of November 1st. This is partly in response, we believe, to a large state.

1:33:20 Laboratory that is moving forward to come online. Also, hopefully first of the month, it will take a little while to get geared up at the same level. And so being able to provide testing through there. The unknown on that is whether or not it will continue to be free or fully covered by the state or if there will be a local cost share that's unknown at this point. Also, we believe that Verily, the baseline program is currently

1:33:46 Extended through November. There's a question whether or not it would be extended beyond that and or if there will be a similar program but a different provider. So there's a couple things up in the air on that. In the interim with the loss of the testing lab that we were utilizing, public health has reached out to San Joaquin Health Lab and we are able to utilize that lab for up to, I think it's 120 tests per week.

1:34:15 They can go over to the lab there. Under our current regimen, that kind of meets the current meet that public health is working through. And part of that is just due to the number of people coming through testing and currently also wrapping up into this week or end of the month, a focus on flu clinics as well. And so there's been just the resource capacity to continue the level of COVID testing. The other side of that is the health department is working on antigen test.

1:34:45 That can be more of a rapid test, but it's mostly effective, I believe, in the discussion is on symptomatic patients, people who are showing some type of health symptoms. And so the focus and how we utilize that is still being analyzed. And the test itself is going through some calibration and confirmation work by public health in that process. So a few things moving through the public health side of our response and capabilities there.

1:35:14 We have completed our third round of business loan applications, business grant applications have come in. They'll be analyzed that and then those announcements we made shortly in terms of those grants going back out to local businesses. The county also closed their grant program just recently and they're going through the same process to finalize those numbers going out. As mentioned, we had discussion on the housing.

1:35:44 Rental assistance, the grant funds here will allow us to continue some additional work in the town plus some of the donations that have come in accordingly to continue those types of efforts and programs out there. We have a substantial amount of supply still of PPE, be it mask, hand sanitizer, some other elements that we'll continue to work with the Chamber of Congress on. I think it's two times a month on Thursdays that they're doing a distribution to businesses who have a need for that to maintain.

1:36:14 Safety protocols within the various businesses. So continuing to work through and support that type of business activity. We are also reaching out, working with Mammoth Resorts regarding their testing program and protocols for their new employees coming on boarding in the next couple of months. And also looking at ongoing operations for dealing with quarantine.

1:36:43 And isolation and contact tracing for infected individuals or exposed individuals to COVID. On top of that, this last week or so, I think we're up to 175 cases last time I looked. We did have a couple over the weekend that were positive cases. And we'll continue to work through each of those accordingly with the public health contact tracing and follow up and quarantine and isolation as need be.

1:37:11 So a brief overview there. I'm glad to address any questions or, Stu, if the JIC has anything going out you want to touch on, please feel free. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Just quickly on the public information front, just wanted to remind Council and our community members, we're still showcasing and providing some mental relief in this world of the new normal. We're calling Coping in a COVID World is every second Wednesday.

1:37:40 Next one will be October 28th at 5.30pm. Mammoth Lakes Community Coffee, that's a once a month activity, that's October 29th at 8am. And then the monthly at this time community conversation is at 5.30 on November 5th.

1:37:57 And just want to remind everybody that, you know, we update the portal in real time. We've updated the portal recently with the access and functional needs, press release and information, and also the Halloween information as well. So there's some information up there for the public. And again, the Week in Review is published every Friday at 5 p.m. So you can look for that on that portal as well and then subscribe to receive that online. So that's all I had. Thank you. Thank you, Stu.

1:38:26 Welcome. Thank you, Bill. Questions? John? If you have any questions, I appreciate kind of the steadiness that we're in right now. No questions. Let's get ready for winter. It's going to be cold this weekend. Let's see how this goes. Thank you. That's what they tell me. Linda? Thank you, Bill. Dan, could you talk a little bit about the Right to Recovery program? Dan, you're muted. Sorry.

1:39:07 Thank you. Yeah, we've been working with, through the OEC, but really with public health and county social services and a right to recovery program is working with them and putting some information out as we deal with individuals who are quarantined or isolated, looking at them not losing financial capabilities, providing it through a, I think it's a visa card or a structure to where they could be able to actually provide for their family or themselves as need be.

1:39:35 During that time of isolation or where they can't be at work because of COVID either disease and or exposure. And so that program is moving forward. I believe it's primarily funded out of the CARES Act grant the county received to be able to provide some of that income replacement level of support into those individuals who will be negatively impacted by the COVID exposure or actual contracting of the disease.

1:40:04 Following their doctor's orders, if you will, public health orders in terms of isolation and or quarantine. Thanks. I don't want to call the dollar amount off the top of my head or it moves around a little bit, but yes. It was $30,000 that they set aside from the CARES Act. Yeah. To be used in this program. Up to $1,000. Up to $1,000. Okay. It was $1,500. Thank you. Thank you. Linda Kirk. Wave at me if you have nothing to say. There you go. No comments. Sorry.

1:40:41 That's all right. Cleland? Thank you. All good. And I am good as well. Thank you for the update. I will now go to public comments. I will remind the public that if you have questions on what we are doing, that is appropriate. This is only an update on our COVID actions and not an edict on law. Do we have any public comments? There are no public comments at this time. Thank you.

1:41:13 That being said, we will move on to item number 11, approval of agreement between the town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County for the shared position of Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator. Dan. Excuse me, Mr. Mayor, we had a late hand raised from William Wallace again, so I guess there is a public comment maybe on the last item. Okay, William, you have up to three minutes. William, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

1:41:56 There you go. You're on now. I'm not getting any feedback here. Yeah, go ahead. You're on. We hear you. I can't get on. What's the deal? Can you guys hear me now? Yes. Yes. Okay. Sorry, guys. I was having some issues. I wasn't getting any response from Zoom there when I was hitting the star six on that one. Okay. Yeah, I don't have – this isn't going to be a law on this one, but I do want to disagree wholeheartedly that I would –

1:42:34 Stuart Brown calling this the new normal. I mean, I do not want this to be the new normal. I don't know anybody who would want this to be the new normal. So if you guys could stop saying that, it just would be a very, very good thing to do because this is not a healthy new normal. I don't think anyone would agree with that. And if you guys are watching the media, I don't know what you've seen. Have you seen anything going on in Australia, the kind of things that are going down in the name of COVID when they have barely any deaths at all in the country?

1:43:04 If that's what you guys want, then maybe that's where you should move, but I don't want that in America. And somebody said something about nobody, he's not seeing anybody suffering due to the health emergency or the economic emergency or whatever. I definitely disagree with that as well. And in fact, I mean, we have all these people that are in forbearance and need rent assistance and are running out of food and there's psychological trauma going on on all kinds of levels.

1:43:33 I see that as suffering, and I don't know anybody in their right mind who can say that's not suffering. And maybe once those people are homeless and starving, then they'll say they'll see some suffering. But I already see suffering, and that's all I have to say on that. Thank you. Thank you, William. Mr. Mayor, I would just like to note for the record, too, that we did receive an email from Mr. Wallace outlining a number of items, and that will be made part of the formal record of the meeting this evening as well.

1:44:06 Thank you, Dan. So now we are on to the sustainable rec position, Dan. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This item is a consideration of agreement between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County for the shared position of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator position. The item before you really has two significant or two...

1:44:33 The core changes from the current program we have been running with the position. It's not a new position by any means. We began working on this back in September or so of 2018, following some work on that in coordination with Mono County and Mammoth Lakes Recreation. The position was filled by Matt Parullo. He's still currently working as the

1:45:00 Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator in that position. The changes that we have worked through and proposed is the first one is the change is the agreement from a three-party agreement to a two-party agreement. The agreement would now just be between the town of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County for a shared position, no longer utilizing Mammoth Lakes Recreation as the hiring agency for the position.

1:45:29 And that is the second real change in that position that it would be housed within Bono County. It is a county-level position. This was done for a couple of primary reasons. One is the ongoing funding mechanism being the town and the county, but more importantly, the position as we brought it on board began to work with it. Mr. Perlow did a very good job in stepping forward, working on a lot of...

1:45:56 Old permits, some MOUs and special use permits, challenged cost share agreements that we had with the United States Forest Service, some of those which had expired. He's also done a good job in some public outreach, specifically out in the county, going to a number of the RPACs and different community meetings and really getting a good handle on what people are looking for in some areas related to recreation, which was one of the tasks there.

1:46:25 He's done a little bit of grant writing there. He's provided some funding coming in as he was working with Mammoth Lakes Recreation. Probably the most significant issue we ran into is through these processes, there was a lot of expectation for elements to be completed on the ground, actually, you know, trail maintenance to be completed, trail construction to be completed, improvements to be made. In a lot of the county areas, this expectation was there. And then also,

1:46:54 Being able to assist with a lot of those elements within the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And I do say, well, they're not as recent now, but changes in contracting code. And what we came back to is, as an employee of a nonprofit, to come in and actually be assigned to do construction-level work, maintenance-level work, even detailed design work beyond that of the initial scope.

1:47:22 Environmental work and some of the higher level planning side of that, that work is not allowed just to be handed off to a nonprofit in that nature without going through a process under the public contracting code for that type of capital or maintenance level work. We saw that the request coming in for construction work, also some of the grant writing work, for example, with Mono County.

1:47:50 We were successful in obtaining a grant to do work at Buckeye Creek, the Hot Springs. And the expectation was to have this position to be able to help manage that work beyond the ground, work with county public works in terms of doing work on the ground, which he is legally prohibited from doing. We've also wanted to have Mr. Perlow coordinate and work on some trails with volunteers, other nonprofits, including Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

1:48:18 And also to coordinate some work with fire crews for clearing trees and other larger materials and stuff off the trails. A lot of that work follows very closely to what we've done here in Mammoth Lakes with our trails coordinator, trails manager, Joel Rathje, in getting out and working on the trails, including replacement of bridges. Same issue with the fire crews and clearing and doing a lot of significant maintenance work.

1:48:45 In order to do that and make it to work, the recreation coordinator position needs to live with as a public agency employee, and there's a way when we can do that between each of us and independently into the county as a county employee, being able to work in a number of areas. He has different options up through Colville and Barker, June Lake, Lee Vining, and down in Rock Creek area and in the

1:49:16 Convict Lake area, et cetera. So there's a lot of demand and work out there for the position. It is definitely why we had the initial work heavily focused on permitting work and paperwork. And he was actually able to set up and be able to be in the Forest Service office a couple of days a week to provide assistance there. The demand from the communities that he's working in has definitely morphed into.

1:49:42 When do we actually get on the ground improvements made in the various elements where he has been working with communities? So the change in the agreement really allows a lot more fluidity for this to be able to have that type of work done. It doesn't necessarily limit the capability to continue to work with permits and grant work in that perspective, but it does expand out the ability to do that.

1:50:07 Now, obviously, we're working with one position here, and so it's just a restricted amount of time. It is currently as an allocation split between two-fifths to Mono County and three-fifths to the Town of Mammoth Lakes, and that's tied to the funding structure, which is the same as what it has been since the position was created. Mono County provides $50,000 to the program, and we provide $95,000. That is for the cost of the employee as well as some other program costs associated with the work.

1:50:36 That is being done. So the moving forward after this was discussion with Mammoth Lakes Recreation and seeing the actual project work and the elements that came forward through the success of the position was a need to make a modification to allow this to be a county-based employee in order to meet those requirements and some of the demands we saw coming forward.

1:51:00 So this agreement simply changes that employee status to be able to expand the work and the capabilities of what they can be engaged in. The funding structure does not change. It is the same as it has been since the position was brought on board. The agreement with the employee by Mono County that was entered into extends out through June 30, 2023. There are termination options within those agreements to be able to do that.

1:51:30 One element in the agreement that does require we look at how we self-insure each other, work for insurances across between town and county work if something was to happen. The current language needs to be modified slightly. Andy Morris is working on that. Some language there with county council. And so staff is recommending approval of the agreement between Bono County and the town of Mammoth Lakes for the Eastern Sierra System of Recreation Coordinator position.

1:51:59 But would also incorporate that staff be authorized to finalize the agreement after a final legal review and addressing the insurance element accordingly. With that, we'd be glad to answer any questions or take any comments. Okay, question or comments. Let's start with Cleland. Here, come back to me, please, Bill. You bet. Kirk, mute.

1:52:39 So we're terminating the position on the Consent Agenda, Item 6, and then we're recreating a funding mechanism on this item. Is that correct? If I may get correct, the termination was to enable the elimination of Mammoth Lakes Recreation as the party to the agreement. And so this brings it back to the two parties, just the town and the county. And the funding structure we highlighted in here, but it is the same.

1:53:08 That it was under the previous agreement as well. The county and the town funding commitments are identical to what they were before. And who does they work for? Does he fall under Stu Brown? No, there's coordination with our Parks and Rec side, but the direct reporting for the position is split between Tony DiBleno, who is the county public works director, and myself in the town.

1:53:36 He also does a lot of coordinating work with Joel Rathji, who is our trails manager. So there's coordination there, but the direct oversight responsibility falls to the town manager. So there's three individuals overseeing his workload. Yeah, right now there's two primary ones, myself and Tony, but also the coordination with Stu and with Joel.

1:54:04 That does influence his work. And he also coordinates projects with our public works department, for example, if there's a construction project or something of that nature. But the primary oversight is over two people in coordination with the others. Thank you. Linda. Thank you. So basically, this is just a change of where the position sits. Now sits in the county without oversight by MLR.

1:54:37 And everything else remains pretty much the same. That being said, could you maybe, so how long has Matt Prillo been with us now? Over a year? The hiring letter effect as we're doing that went out toward the end of February 2019. 2019? Yeah. Beginning of February. Okay. Okay. Okay. And based on that, what are some of the lessons we've learned?

1:55:06 And how to help Matt, you know, be successful at his position. Do you think that we're the, you know, what are some of the highlights of the things that Matt has been able to accomplish in this last year? I think the things we really do like, I mean, the idea that we have a position that is shared between the county and the town has really enhanced the level of communications between the

1:55:34 The two agencies, as well as within the communities, having somebody out on the ground, speaking with the various RPACs, various community groups on their needs and desires. And so I think we've got a much better feel for some of the requests and responses that citizens are expecting in the recreation world in terms, be it a trailhead, be it an improved campground or new toilet, be it broader issues in that, both municipal rec as well as

1:56:01 Forest Service-related recreational elements. The same element in the town, it really has, when you have somebody who can update some old permits and work through those processes, that's been a real valuable component. I think longer term, as we really look at new permitting, and especially some of the more complicated ones, we're dealing one right now with our snow pit, having a much higher level skill set there would be helpful in terms of what we've learned, if you will.

1:56:30 But being able to take a lot of what I call our basic cost share agreements and those types of things forward, that's been very beneficial. So that coordination and having somebody coordinating with us and with the county and with the Forest Service on a number of things, that whole element of working together, I think this has enhanced that work and we would support the idea of this being this joint position because I think it does improve working relationships and also develop skills.

1:57:00 Joel Rathke had really developed a really strong working relationship with the fire crews. That has now morphed into a capability that can be utilized on some of the county trail maintenances. What we did find up until now, though, they had nobody to run those crews. They had nobody out there to really walk the trail, define the work, and then manage the crews on the ground.

1:57:26 Matt has gone out with Joel and watched and observed some of that and has definitely, between the two of them working together, has now taken on or has the capability to take on some of that work within the county. And I must say, I know the fire crews, they definitely, especially in the summertime, definitely enjoy working in the Mammoth area versus lower elevations where it's much warmer. Of course, we did lose them somewhat this year because of the fire season and the need to be out on the fire lines, which has a higher priority than trail work.

1:57:55 So that element has definitely been there. The other thing I think that one of the big takeaways is the community expectations that as we get this thing moving and make things happen, that there will be actually on-the-ground work. There's people going to volunteer. We have different programs out there. And I know in the position, Matt was extremely frustrated, frankly, because he...

1:58:22 Was not able to legally go out and do that type of work. And so this really got us over that hurdle. I think the other side that allowed us to deal with the positives through this is the ongoing relationship with Mammoth Lakes Recreation and some of the other nonprofit organizations that Matt has engaged with.

1:58:40 That relationship will still, I think, bear fruit for us. He knows the players. He knows the organization. He knows some of the information there in terms of communication, some of the PR work that can be done. And also, he has that ability and no problem reaching out to Mammoth Lakes Recreation and particularly going, hey, can we use that nonprofit status as a means and support for raising funds or to help support a grant work?

1:59:05 And we saw that with the Tango Free Waters Program, for example, and some other things that have come forward. The nice part now that if those things are successful, Matt can actually go do the work on those projects versus just the front end work. So I think it's been a very good relationship building exercise. And now that he can actually do on the ground maintenance work and trail work, which he's very excited about, that really does enhance our overall.

1:59:32 A program that can go out, both for us, too. It gives Joel a backup and gives him additional support when we're running two or three projects out on the ground to have somebody at his level to be able to supervise that has been a real asset that we will be able to take advantage of going forward. Great. Thank you for that. Thanks. Jelinda, John. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Are we at questions for staff or are we deliberating?

2:00:03 Where are we at right here? Comments and questions, both. Okay. I don't have any questions for staff. Dan, thanks for that summary. Just from personal observations, a couple things to add. I believe that Matt Perillo is the first staff person that Mono County has hired with a specific focus on recreation. Correct me if I'm wrong.

2:00:32 But I think that was part of when we all started working together with the county to get the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership going and to bring on this position. I think it was always a dream of a bunch of us that eventually, one way or the other, Matt would find himself in the county. It's an incredibly important capacity for the county to hold. And I think all of us who've seen this come to fruition are enormously pleased that it's moving in this direction.

2:01:00 The other thing I would add is that when this position came forward, the Forest Service was willing to bring Mr. Perillo into the district office to give him access to federal computers and federal information systems. And it's been a very important test of the ability of in a sustainable recreation environment.

2:01:25 For federal agencies and local stakeholders and gateway communities to actually really start working together. And it was enormously successful. There's a lot of other things to learn. And we're going to build and grow on that. So change of venue, great. I think it's great that this position is getting to the county. It's about time, I think some of us would say. But a very successful program so far. A change of venue is fine because...

2:01:54 We are in California, and California has prevailing wage laws, and unless you're a prevailing wage contractor, you've got to be associated with a public agency. Go Monro County. So those are my thoughts, and I'm very successful and great to see this moving forward. Thank you. Thank you, John. Cleland, I will come back to you now. Thank you. Thank you for everything that everyone has said. I'm a big fan of

2:02:24 of Matt and the job that he has been doing. However, this is very different from when this position was this contract is nothing except for maybe the name with recreation, but as far as I can tell what setting up this job

2:02:54 Matt ended up dealing with parking, people going to the bathroom in wrong places. The scope of the job was much larger, and it was working with permits. It was something that was going to be, and I did vote for it.

2:03:21 Because it seemed as though it was going to be a much better position. Now it seems to me that everybody has corralled him. It's going to be back into the county. We expect him to have these relationships with federal entities, which we have absolutely nothing that we can do. I think he is doing a great job.

2:03:48 I don't have any really heartache, but I just want to let everyone know who is watching this meeting that I know where this started from and where it has gone now is far from the original intent which was in his contract and now you have moved it into the position where it

2:04:14 So I'm a big fan of his. I'm glad that the county is going to do that. I'm very disappointed that there are going to be a lot of things that were initially in the contract that are missing now from what he's going to be doing with county. So I really do not know where you guys are heading at this point.

2:04:43 I'll just leave it at that if anybody wants to contact me. I'll go back and look at my paperwork. But we have moved away from what this originally was meant to be. And then we had him doing a lot of things that he should not have been having to deal with. So I'm glad that you guys are all hopeful and I hope it works out. Thank you, Cleland. Yeah, Kirk.

2:05:14 If you read the agenda packet on page 106, the scope of work, we don't have Exhibit A in there, which is the job description. And I just think I support this. I think it's important. I recognize the work that he's been doing. But I do think that we need to give him a job description because that's what's supposed to be attached to the agenda bill. And also it protects him.

2:05:42 As to what work he is working on and everything rather than just have an open-ended where an expectation, a huge expectation. I support. I think he's done a good job. I think it's our responsibility that he has the job description. Thank you, Kirk. Actually, I believe there is a job description that has been done and circulated. It just is not in our packet. Correct me if I'm wrong, Dan.

2:06:13 Yeah, it's a county job description. And yeah, Kirk actually noted that yesterday that it was not attached there. I did send one out last night that was prepared. I think it's been uploaded to Granicus as well and went out to the council. You are correct. That job description does need to be there. And it was one that it's under the county structure for that job description, but it does exist out there. Yes. Thank you. And for my part, I will tell you, I'm happy with the job he's done.

2:06:42 I don't think this segue changes our ability to rely on him for dealing with permits and other things which was part of the original intent. I think that his base has just expanded. So that's where I'm at. Do we have any public comment? Yes, we do. We have a public commenter in Suite Z right now. Okay. Sandy Hogan and former chair of the Mobility Commission.

2:07:15 Former member of the Measure U Allocation Committee. I was a former member of the MLTSCC. And I'm going to have two major comments tonight that I would like to make. So, Mayor and Councilmembers, my comments, the first one is about Matt and the job description, which was added yesterday because I was working off the old one.

2:07:43 Matt is an exceptionally well-qualified

2:08:14 And he's in the right position description. If you read it, it is really, it's a high level staff position, which actually ties to that next position description. He is, he works, I used to be a district ranger, so I understand high level staff, and I understand who relates to whom.

2:08:45 And he is working with the Forest Service. The reason he was given access to the computer and an email address is because he is, in fact, a very senior level operator. Because you wouldn't have special uses folks who are senior staff, and it's a very complex thing. Maybe the town doesn't recognize that, but in special uses, I can tell you,

2:09:14 I went up from seven to nine to 11 in them because they are, you know, it's a very big thing. He is, I'm sure he has that same great relationship with the BLM. The Forest Service staff that I've talked to think highly of him. So, Lynda, I hope this answers some of your questions. And talking to Matt, it took about the first year.

2:09:43 For him to build that staff, the Forest Service doesn't open their doors and let a town or county employee walk in and get access to their computers, I can tell you that. So that he built that trust. The position description.

2:09:59 Describes essential duties and responsibilities. And if we were to read some of these, it's, well, the definition is his job is to enable efficient and productive working relationships between many agencies. Down to the essential duties and responsibilities, it's working with all of these agencies. I'm going to have to go on a little bit longer. I've been sitting here for about an hour and a half, so.

2:10:26 If you don't mind, nobody else is coming in to make public comment. But basically, identify and process agreements. And I can tell you, grants and agreements in the Forest Service, they are complex, they're heavy duty, and it's done by senior level staff. So what caught my eye was when I saw the staff report saying maintenance and construction.

2:10:52 I thought, oh, yeah, we're going to take a GS-11 at the Forest Service level or 12 and put them out there building trails. You have a trails coordinator and it's wonderful that they coordinate together and that maybe Matt takes the message to the Forest Service or to BLM or to the county. But I would surely hope that the town is not going to downgrade this position, you know.

2:11:19 And so I'm looking at also the 70.

2:11:48 And I want that, you know, Measure U is specifically for facilities and projects for recreation arts and culture and mobility. And renewing permits, working with permits, the special use permit meetings, that really does work, you know, for

2:12:15 But it's not a base salary. That's what general fund is for, and we all know that. So when he's not specifically working on permits and whatever, he shouldn't probably be charging enough to measure you unless he's working on specific projects that he can charge to.

2:12:36 We understand this because I used to have all of these, you know, archaeologists' budgets, what they charge too, like on this Inyo National Forest, they have probably 40 codes and they have to keep track of all those hours. That's fine. So it's proper for that. But, you know, I just, my conclusion, all I'm trying to point out is

2:12:57 He is a good employee. It's taken a long time to get to where he is. It's a very high-level relationship that he has. Probably more than anything, patience with federal agencies because they're so slow. I know the Forest Service is. I keep looking over at the TV here, the council over here. Sorry, I should be talking to them. But anyway, I'm just saying.

2:13:21 With an excellent employee in the right position description, and Kirk, they should send that to you or go on and get it online. Let's avoid wasting using his time and talents doing construction and maintenance when all that is just an enabler so he can go out once in a while and work with volunteers. That should not be the focus of this job ever.

2:13:50 Use your Measure U funds appropriately with permits and agreements where it's going to take time and he'll charge to that. But otherwise, you know, use your general funds. So thanks. And can I answer any questions to you now that I see you over there? Any questions for Sandy? Seeing none, Sandy, thank you. All right. Thank you very much for listening. And I'll put my mask back on.

2:14:20 We also have another speaker on Zoom, Stacey Corliss, please unmute yourself. Hi, good evening, Mayor Sauser and Councilmembers. Just wanted to, as chair of the Mono County Board of Supervisors, just wanted to let you know that the county approved this contract, this agreement, two weeks ago, I think, and we're happy to be able to continue to have Matt on board.

2:15:01 Continue this partnership with the town. I just want to note that back, I was trying to remember which year it was, 2016 or 2017, at one of our joint county-town meetings, we formed a recreation task force and had some meetings with the then district ranger and recreation staff on the international forest and really envisioned

2:15:28 A position in exactly the kind of work that Matt has been doing and that this agreement allows him to continue to do. And from the time that we hired him back in early 2018 or 2019, sorry, Matt has been supervised on the county side by Public Works Director, Tony Dablino. It's worked out really well. And as Mayor Sauser said, I see this just as a...

2:15:54 Continuation of the excellent work and partnership and it's vital work for our community and for our economy and I appreciate the town's partnership. Thank you. Thank you, Stacey. Any further public comment? That is all. Thank you. With that, I will bring it back to council if you want to further deliberate or for a motion. I just would like to state that what is in history

2:16:25 The county contract is a different representation what was with the when it was a combined and I think that that is just worth noting for anyone who wants to go back that there are some things that were specifically included to as far as I can see push his position forward.

2:16:52 Kicked it out of the park, did a great job, but I do feel as though the contract with the county is leaving out some very important issues and potential for the area, and that is my statement. Thank you, Cleland. Bill, if I may, on that, I believe one of the issues that we...

2:17:23 Wanted Matt to work on, brought him in, I was working with a lot of our, the permitting side of that, but one of those areas was film and media permits. That is still an issue on our conditions of work, and that's still called out to be able to do that. I don't know if the county has plugged him into the film commission to support that side for the forest service, but that was an area, you know,

2:17:46 About that, I don't think we did as well as we could have in that particular area. That is an area that we do have a good, there's an economic base for filming in this region in the Eastern Sierra and Town of Mammoth Lakes in particular and Mono County. We've had several requests under the COVID world and some of those have been denied because of the size of the crews and other activities and earlier in the process. I know there is also a process we're looking at to be able to prove some going forward.

2:18:15 There has been a couple of small crews come in. I know they did a shoot up in Bodie and some other places. But that whole permitting process through the Forest Service, and Councilmember Hoff can speak to more detail than that than I can. It can be very cumbersome. It can be problematic. But it is a key element in terms of one of the economic drivers in this area as people come in and do, you know, several nights of hotel. They do catering. They do a number of other expenditures in our community.

2:18:44 And that is an area that, frankly, we could step up and do better work with. There may be some other elements as well, but we've had these conversations. I just wanted to be transparent in that. And we do call it out in the job description still, the actual description to talk about film and media permits. We've kind of broadened that out if people are going to be out there doing elements within the forest. And I think, you know, our planning department issues at the town level, but having this type of level of support within the

2:19:15 Forest Service is a huge element that I know there was a couple of issues early on between the permitting text for that. The Forest Service, they had some changeover, and I think there were some challenges just in the staffing relationship and structure there. So I don't think we probably had quite the impact there we were hoping to see, but it is still in the actual job description, where they were under Town of Mammoth Lakes, it specifically calls out film and media permits as one of the areas of work.

2:19:44 Thank you. Hope that helps, Member Hoffman. Thank you, Dan. I'm still looking for a motion. John. Mr. Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion. Before I do that, I just want to, as part of the deliberation part of this, I want to make sure we all thank Mammoth Lakes Recreation. When the town and the county were looking for a home for this position to get this thing started, they stepped up. And then Matt did great work working under the aegis of MLR. I want to make sure we all thank Mammoth Lakes Recreation.

2:20:16 I think it's a great thing to be going from a three-party agreement to a two-party agreement. Anytime you can do that in life, it's probably a good thing. I also want to make sure that the council is fully aware of the green sticker grant that the town has looking at trails and recreation opportunities in the Shady Rasset, Inyo Graders area, which is north of town. And that is going to require an exceptional level of coordination between the town and the county.

2:20:43 Having Matt in his position with the county is going to allow him to work with Joel as a peer on that project. There's been a lot of a certain amount of frustration in the community of late with the project proposal of the Solitude Canyon. We can talk about the next item, but I think it's going to be, I can't say how proud I am of the county for stepping up into this opportunity. So now we've got two recreation trail types from two different agencies working together.

2:21:11 In a landscape of common interest to both agencies. And the only way you can do that is to have the kind of configuration that we're talking about. So I'm very excited about that. And I also just want to say that on the fire crew issue that Dan mentioned, the fire crews do a lot more than just trail work. They're helping us with fuel work. They're helping us with fuel reduction work. And I'm sure there's a lot of residents in June Lake and other communities throughout Mono County that are going to be...

2:21:39 Very grateful. Matt Perlow is out there directing, working with fire crews to deal with fuel breaks and defensible space and things like that on federal public lands. So I think I'm just very excited about this whole thing. And I think as Stacey pointed out, this goes back to a meeting, a joint meeting of the town and the county many years ago that set this vision forward. And we're seeing it come to life. And I think we should all take a certain amount of pride in that, that we can actually lay out a track, stick with it, and see it go to where we hoped it would go.

2:22:08 So with all that, and I apologize for going on, I will make the motion. And I would move that the Town Council approve and authorize the Town Manager to sign the agreement between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Pomona County for the shared position of Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator, man, I'd like the ring of that, with some adjustments to be made perhaps by County Council or Town Council. So there's my motion. Thank you. Thank you. I'll second that. I have a motion and a second.

2:22:40 Any further deliberation? John, did you lose your electricity again? No, that's kind of a personal question. I can wait until after the vote is taken and then I may request a point of order to move the part of my house that has a lamp. Yeah. Any further deliberation? Seeing none, I will call for the item, please. Thank you. Councilmember Hough? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido?

2:23:14 Yes. Mayor Sauser. Yes. Motion passes, 5-0. Kirk, I'm going to try and help you out here a little bit, buddy. You know when you're muted, all you have to do is press your space key, and as long as you hold your space key, you can talk. Then when you lift it, you go back to being muted. Thank you. I'll probably forget that in two minutes. Yeah, well, it took me a while as well. Okay.

2:23:46 Moving on then to item number 12. Mr. Mayor, I would like to make that point of order. If I could move to a room in my house that has a lamp. Yeah, we will take a five-minute break, John. I appreciate that. Thank you very much. Yes, I need to stretch anyway. Thank you. Yeah, there we go. Thank you.

2:26:15 Yeah, yeah, exactly. Yeah.

2:26:55 I think they may have done it. I don't recall which one I thought it was the one that went up.

2:28:02 Hey Dan, Sandy, we can hear you, just FYI. Thank you. Well, I hope we weren't talking about.

2:28:34 No, you were saying nice things. I just wanted to let you know before you went into anything else. As soon as I see John's icon pop back up, I will restart us. This smoke is killing me.

2:30:04 Hey, Bill, I just love your profile picture. I have your wife send a copy so I can have that as a screensaver. Okay, I can do that. John seems to be having a hard time finding that lamp. Did his power go out just at his place? Did he not pay his bill or is there a power outage? SCE is doing work in the neighborhood. Oh, okay. Oh.

2:31:14 Did anyone notice I have new glasses, by the way? Very chic. Well, they're not as square as my last pair. I wonder if he lost power to his laptop. Um, or his internet service. Could be. You lose power, you lose that router. There he is. Okay, John, are you with us? I believe so. There you go. I'm seeing you.

2:32:59 I can see me too. That's a good thing. Yeah. Thanks for your patience. I appreciate it. Thank you. Not a problem. I'll bring myself back into the real world. So moving on to item number 12, and it says authorization to establish the position of chief recreation officer. I don't believe that's actually what we're doing here tonight. What we're doing is talking this over and seeing if this is something we want staff to spend a little time on.

2:33:33 to bring back to us in a more complete form. With that, Dan, you can correct me if I'm wrong. I will turn it over to you. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, final direction is up to the council in terms of if they wish to proceed with the proposal that's on the table for discussion either as an authorized position or as a position that needs supportive of that needs additional material brought forward before any final decision.

2:34:02 You would be taking another review and look at this regardless, so definitely it is a step in the process. I wanted to address a couple of issues that have come up and some of that in public comment that we received. We brought the position forward, frankly, on purpose without everything fully completed because we really did want to have this level of discussion on is it desirable to move this forward.

2:34:26 To look at some elements of it and it will be a fairly fair amount of work to actually develop and finalize up the position. We do want to coordinate with the Forest Service. We have a new Forest Supervisor coming in. We'll have some conversations there as well with the District Ranger. We have continued those dialogues with the current positions as the one we just talked about as well as others.

2:34:49 This also builds off of a lot of work that was done several years ago through the creation of Mammoth Lakes Recreation, looking at an executive director, looking at a chief recreation officer and other support staff. The original thought process there was administrative costs in the neighborhood of about $400,000. Obviously, we have not gone down that road at that point in time, and this type of position was on hold at that point.

2:35:16 We did, as just in the last item discussed, came back with a joint position between the town and the county, I think, which was a great move in order to take a lot of the trails and the coordination work beyond the town of Mammoth Lakes. The position that's being discussed before you and for consideration in terms of moving forward, and there will take additional work to do that. We are looking at a position that

2:35:44 Does have a higher level of education and experience skills requirements. I'll touch on that a little bit more. And the structure of the position that would drop into overseeing the trail program in terms of the trail manager's position, overseeing some of the staff there, ongoing coordination with Public Works and our Parks and Rec side.

2:36:09 As the outdoor area, maybe a better title would be outdoor recreation specialist in terms of that focus, not so much on the indoor side or the traditional recreation elements. The other side of that is, frankly, at my level of stuff, is having a single point of contact that we work with in a number of these areas. As we have worked with the Forest Service and from our other partners over time,

2:36:34 One of the elements that have come into that is there's very much a desire to work with direct representation from the local agencies, the local government in this case, and having a single point of that reference has been very beneficial historically. And we've lost a little bit of that in the last couple of years as we've had multiple people involved with the agency for service side here, not to mention BLM. We're also dealing with the city of LA on projects.

2:37:04 Ongoing work with the county and the previous position discussed has really helped with that county coordination. But looking at those elements in terms of managing people, managing projects and programs, and managing a budget that isn't just town dollars, but also leveraging federal dollars, grant dollars, and private investment dollars that we believe are readily available to work through some of those pieces.

2:37:30 I do want to address, and this should just come up a couple of times, just in terms of timing. We look at a new position. We're in the middle of COVID. We have uncertainty in our own financial structures. We look forward to our, you know, we're hoping to have a good winter, both from a COVID perspective as well as from Mother Nature and man-made snow and elements of that nature. So we wanted to bring this forward, and I wanted to bring this forward at this point in time to look at the position.

2:37:57 We do want to look and see what happens in December and January. Do we have a good winter and kickoff and a start? Do we have a healthy community at that point in time? Are we able to actually move this type of element forward? The COVID world has changed a lot of what we do and how we do it. And so it's definitely something that we're not diving into right on the front end. And part of that is the reason it's here and it's not fully...

2:38:25 Vetted out, if you will, with 100% of a job description, some other elements. And that was done on purpose to bring the item forward for discussion without putting the what would literally probably be 20 to 40 hours or better of staff time and work and to develop a lot of those elements that you will ultimately want to see. But the question I really have is a direction we're moving in our overall recreation outdoor environment work. The idea of

2:38:52 These level of positions and the work that we're doing, something you want to see us continue to work with. Ultimately, as with other positions, you know, be very blunt, if we really can't afford it, no, we won't hire a position. Nor, frankly, if we can't get the right skill sets right into a position, nor would we move forward at that point either. So we look at these and we look at a salary source, we look at a management source, it looks at the overall scope and work of the...

2:39:21 Project or the position just in a broad sense, the amount of people oversight, the budget oversight, those types of elements. We did look at the, I think as Ms. Hogan brought up earlier, the position looks about a, you know, GS 12 or 13 level position if you compare it to federal agencies. Some of their pay scales have a little difference because they have allocations based on where you live and work and so it moves around based on where you're at in the country.

2:39:49 For the salary components, but it's in that level type of item there. We're also looking at a multiple funding source. We have looked at the general fund, Measure R, Measure U. One of the questions, and this was internal as well, asking, well, what's going to be the actual percentages of each of those or dollars in each of those areas? And frankly, I think it'll be an ongoing review based on the actual work program that the physician is assigned to.

2:40:18 If it is a project that is a town-managed-owned project out on the right element and falls squarely in the concept of the Measure R program that's out there, it can be funded out of those dollars. If it's a broader, as discussed earlier, a little bit in some of the recreational elements, the transportation mobility element, a lot of that ties together.

2:40:43 We even have discussions a little bit with arts and culture and some of the ability to utilize forest service properties for those purposes. We deal with the hidden cabin. We deal with other elements on the forest. If it lines up with those particular funding sources, then we want to be able to use those dollars to fund the position. The other side of that will be general fund dollars. A lot of the work will be required there. We have some very, very ambitious programs out there related to fuels management.

2:41:11 Ecosystem management in terms of looking at several thousands acres of potential fuels work in and around the town of Mammoth Lakes. To have somebody engaged in that level who understands the Forest Service and the processes there, I think will create a great value to our community. At the same time as you're doing that type of work, there is a lot of remediation goes with that, there's different pieces with that.

2:41:37 The real key issue for me in looking at that and looking at other places we've been working in this type of element, you want to make sure as you do those elements that your recreation elements are taking into consideration. That involves, you know, healthy ecosystems in terms of our watersheds. It means looking at if you're going to be doing on the ground work, does it line up with trail potential work? Otherwise, you're duplicating efforts down the road.

2:42:05 As you look at the ability to integrate some of that work with our values and culture and what we're doing on our landscape for our residents and our visitors, how do we make those line up as well as getting a healthy forest in terms of fuel reduction and fire protection? The scope and scale of the projects being looked at out there are multiple years. You're looking at 20 years, 30 years down the road of ongoing fuel management work within our region here.

2:42:33 And again, if we have learned anything from just to the east of us, over the hill, the amount of dead trees sitting in that forest that are now literally gone up in smoke, the amount of beetle kill that was there, 80 or 90 percent of some of the stands, based on the updates we've received from the Creek Fire, the amount of dead fuel out there and those types and the threat that that brings.

2:42:57 That is a whole element that has a community-wide basis. We definitely need to take a look at and engage in that discussion. But doing so, we can't forget how does that integrate with ultimately our greatest asset here, which is our national forest as a recreational attraction for people to come and make their living, spend their money, have a great time, go home, come back, repeat type activity.

2:43:26 At the same time, how does our built environment engage in that? Having somebody who's engaged at our public works level, as we look at our trail system, we look at our transit system, we look at our, you know, the bikes and all the whole piece that we're doing in town. How well is that integrated into our natural landscape? The two of those are not independent activities. They're not independent systems. They really do need to talk to each other. So when you come into Mammoth Lakes,

2:43:55 Whether you live here or whether you're visiting here, the level of your experience is seamless between shopping at Vaughn's to walking up that path. You have a great time wherever you go. And I'll say the Vaughn's facetiously is it can get very busy and crowded. You can still have a great time getting to know people in line if you don't mind spending the time to open up and visit.

2:44:21 Talk and get to know people from that perspective. But that aside, but the idea is we have great assets, but the integration of those, I think, are soft at this point. When we did some of our downtown revitalization work in the Walk and Bike Ride program, part of those elements was to make our built environment, our natural environment, talk to each other. Part of that is we come from two different management agencies, some

2:44:49 75% of the property within the town is owned and managed by the United States Forest Service, so we have a smaller footprint from which to build it. But as we build out and as we do things, how do we make those systems talk to each other? At the break, Sandy Hogan and I were talking about our new housing program on the parcel, looking at 450, you know, plus or minus affordable housing units, workforce housing units coming in.

2:45:14 Think of that as being a thousand plus people coming in if you're an average two people per unit. How are those individuals who will be moving here and maybe are here and moving in there where they live and what they do, how are they connecting to our environment? And we truly believe, I think a lot of those folks that are here and working and supporting our hospitality industry and other services in our community are also out really enjoying the recreational areas and the stuff we have.

2:45:43 Even with the smoke, and if I can pick on Councilmember Hoff for a second, sorry, Clem, did not, as a resident, and walking up to the Vista, not too bad in the smoke, but getting out and being able to walk and enjoy that as a resident here, personally being able to get out and do that, and being able to leave from your backyard and go out and enjoy the stuff we have, but that takes a lot of coordination and connection, I believe when the lake,

2:46:09 Mary Bike Path was done. That was like crazy. Why would you invest in that? Why would we do that? Yet it took a lot of work and effort to connect that. And that has truly changed the connection between the built environment of the Town of Mammoth Lakes and the Lakes Basin. And my guess is everybody on the call here or practically everybody on the town have at some level.

2:46:36 Enjoyed that pathway, whether it's watching people utilizing it, riding a bike, hiking, walking, different things. So as we start to look at those elements and that need for the town to be very intimately integrated into the forest and the forest service, it does take a skill set that I don't believe we currently have on staff in the town to be able to do that. It's starting from, you know, a NEPA CEQA process. It's starting with even before that with broad planning and looking and saying,

2:47:05 What actually makes sense? How is it multiple use? How do we not disenfranchise any one of our user groups, be that snowmobiling or off-roading to, you know, the backcountry wilderness hiking? How do we bring those elements together, work with the forest through that? I think it becomes very, very complicated in some cases. And also, I believe the comment was made earlier, it takes a lot of patience, a lot of process.

2:47:33 And making sure we work through it correctly. I think the town has missed some great opportunities in those areas, in part, frankly, probably more on the town side of missing some steps in there in terms of getting certain things approved and processed and actually walking through the proper federal steps to make that happen. A little bit with Solitude Canyon, a great trail project up. And the Sherwood's there, some issues came up on that. That project is...

2:48:01 At this point off the table, we need to get reworked if it comes back. Some of the Sarbanes grant work we did up in the Lakes Basin, again, not following, getting followed through with some of the CEQA work and the NEPA process to truly pull the trigger on some really key elements. And again, I think that Dunn Wright does what I'm talking about, this integration of our built town and how that reaches out into the forest and gets this symbiotic relationship between our

2:48:31 Local residents, our guests, our visitors, and our permittees. How does this integrate with Mammoth Mountain, which is a permittee on the U.S. Forest Service lands. How do we work through that? The businesses up in the Lakes Basin, the snowmobile rental program, the parks and rec department, our key parts in our community are on these property. Shady Rest Park is on national forest land. The Whitmore Park is part of the

2:49:01 City of Los Angeles, LA Department of Water and Power. And so, and we're working with them right now to expand that footprint, to expand the lease. Those are very critical negotiations with those agencies and also very critical public processes that need to be engaged in. And so, as we look at this level of position in here, we start to look at, you know, that outdoor rec side that isn't necessarily building a performing arts center, completing, you know, a community recreation center.

2:49:30 It really is getting out there on this landscape and saying, this is what speaks to people. Sorry, I'm passionate about this, you made me tell, but it is, it's what speaks to people as they come to Mammoth Lakes and I'll speak to a personal as well as talking to people. And again, knowing the council members here, every one of you have spent time in these areas, whether it's driving, whether it's hiking, whether it's, you know, backpacking.

2:49:56 Feel that other photo you had up for yourself. You probably spent a lot more time in the backcountry than you do today. But it's those types of developments. It's how do we deal with the Hayden Cabin and the experiences there, the music and the arts up in the lake space and at the art gallery there. How do we take those things and make those experiences something that become generational? This isn't just about us here today, but it's about the people who will visit Mammoth Lakes and our region.

2:50:24 Five years, one year, 20 years, 30 years. You know, if you have children, maybe it's your children's children, great grandchildren that hopefully come to Mammoth Lakes and go, wow, what a great experience. I believe to be able to do that right, we do need to have good, solid relationships with the Forest Service. We need to be able to work through a lot of the elements out there that enhance our ability to have sustainable quality trail systems. And I believe...

2:50:52 Joel Rathge is on the call. He has done an excellent job in some of that trail work out there. So these trails will be long lasting. They're better designed. They're laid out properly. It's a lot of effort. On the front end of that is, you know, money, time and effort to scope out projects. But then when you get into the NEPA process, I think, frankly, we have not done a fantastic job in a lot of those areas. We have examples around where we still are.

2:51:21 You know, on soft footing, if you will, in some of our community facilities and infrastructure as far as the permitting and the processing of that. And Matt Perullo has been able to step in and help us clean up some of those permits. But being able to walk in and do that, that level of work that's going to be required to get there, I think, is huge. And it is going to be somebody who needs to engage and bring in other dollars, non-profit. It may be grant work. It'll be other elements that come together.

2:51:48 To really step in and manage this landscape. So we become a premier destination as a gateway community into a region that surrounds us. And the beauty that we see as we look, I say the beauty we see, we look out the window the last few days, that's been mostly smoked. So take a look at the photo on the screen here from our police chief Al Davis. That's the beauty we're talking about as you get into this landscape. And so I want to talk a lot about that because as you come back to a position, the development of a position in place,

2:52:18 One is I think we're very bifurcated or fractured, if you will, internally in terms of the people we have, the talents we have and where they work and spend time. There's not a core single what I would call leadership role over that particular focus, be that out of our planning, public works, parks and rec, trails, construction management.

2:52:44 And the whole permitting process with federal agencies. And this goes beyond just the forest services. We look at the Bureau of Land Management, we look at national parks, and then the other agencies we work with. But to put that into a single focus, it's a lot of pressure, a lot of expectations to put on a single position. But I think we're going to need that to really excel in these areas.

2:53:07 And with that, we also see new stuff coming out of the federal government, the Great American Outdoor Act. A lot of maintenance dollars are going to flow to the Forest Service. We need to be engaged in that process, and we don't have anybody at this point in time who can say that's our go-to person to be able to leverage those dollars for the elements that we've looked at and the planning work that the town has done, both as we look at the integration of a lot of the planning that has been done.

2:53:37 In the National Forest Management Plan. It has some key elements in there that we need to be ready to take advantage of. You look at the Devil's Postpile Management Plan. Great plan, but it's like, frankly, some of the town plans, and it's sitting on a shelf. It has some elements that really speak to Mammoth Lakes as a gateway community. We have not had the bandwidth from a staffing standpoint to really leverage that out.

2:54:04 Gain full value out of that. That is an area that because of the creative work actually from our public works department that is going to be much more accessible into the future as we get out a few years and we end up with a new roadway and access component down there. The ability of us to enjoy that res meadow area and for people to see that wonder of the devil's pulse pile.

2:54:29 It's going to need to be well managed, but it is going to have a great opportunity from people in our region coming into that. And how do we bring that connection back into Town of Mammoth Lakes? A classic example was this weekend, a group of people sitting and eating and talking, and they're planning to go see Devil's Postpile. It's like, by the way, you know it's closed. Not to mention the smoke, you're not going to be able to see much, but the attraction that that has is huge out there.

2:54:58 But that coordinated effort of what it takes between the Forest Service, our transportation elements, and the connection back into town with our bed base and the other services we provide is huge to be able to bring that forward. So as we begin to look at that coordination, those types of efforts, and it's beyond just coordination on that, it's really taking concepts and ideas and moving that through a public process.

2:55:27 Through the federal public process, so you actually have a final decision in NEPA documents and the things we need in place to do projects right, to make sure we are meeting the needs and requirements of our local residents and others who have a vested interest in the American public, if you will, in this great landscape that we get to live and play in. To be able to have somebody to walk all that through and walk out the back end and says, now we have a great project, let's get it.

2:55:55 Let's get it funded. Let's get it built. Let's get it done. And that, again, the amount of work and effort in that is huge, those types of efforts. And then the last piece of this is really going out and saying, how do we end up getting somebody in that skill set, that work? And I think that's going to be, that's going to take time and effort. It'll probably be some target recruitment levels. We're looking at somebody who knows federal agencies, whether they work there or they have that experience at a very,

2:56:25 You know, that upper level staff experience level, they can walk in and go, yes, I know what it takes to make sure we get through the floral and fauna and animal and the review and the biology and et cetera, fill in the blank, the archeology element. And being able to pull that staff's level work together and then drive it through and really, again, engage that community through the process. We believe we have a lot of very strong

2:56:54 Recreational enthusiasts in our community and how do we take that energy and move it forward? And it is broad. I mean, it goes from everything from we don't have a great bouldering track out there yet, but let's create one. You can get out there on the four-wheel side of it. You can, you know, we have a great motorcycle track that's open two weeks out of the year, which would be nice to have one that was open at least, you know, eight or nine months out of the year.

2:57:21 How do you take the over snow vehicle work and the things that are going there? We have subpart C coming up for planning work, the whole element of over snow activity. That is going to take a ton of effort for us to be actively engaged in that and address some of the challenges of what that's going to look like.

2:57:41 I'll pick on Mayor Sauser in terms of the work he's done in the past on that in terms of the Orange Diamond Program that's out there. How do we look at those elements? And while the position, yes, is primarily focused on the town of Mammoth Lakes and our 25 square miles of community here, the connection we have beyond that is extremely valuable, extremely important. Trails don't know they cross those boundaries and half the time we don't either.

2:58:11 In terms of route hiking and doing stuff, it's, you know, what wilderness are you in, what town, county, et cetera. But it's an extremely valuable piece of who we are and our future economy. And I'll go back to the earlier comments related to the filming and the permitting and that and the media element and that. All that activity is going on here because of the setting we're in. How do we work with that? How do we expand on some of those areas? So we are financially healthy for the long term.

2:58:40 But again, the natural environment that we're playing in is here for generations to come, not just for us. So a lot of passion behind the position, so I'm not going to apologize for that. I think it's an area that we need to have focus, an area we need to be engaged in as we look at the...

2:59:00 Economic development of our built environment. We look at a new hotel coming in. We look at these other elements down the road. This is going to be, you know, hopefully COVID is way similar back in our rear view mirror at this point in time. But we're able to move a lot of these things forward and really develop, you know, that world-class resort that provides this amenity to all, you know, walks of life, if you will, of people who wish to be here and see the things. And it moves up and down from Death Valley to Topaz.

2:59:29 And those types of things. So let me get back to the item before you. Having the level of position in the town organization that understands this, that believes this, that can engage at this level with our federal partners, I think will carry us a long ways in this type of vision that has been exposed in almost every planning document I've read or looked at that talks about Mammoth Lakes.

2:59:55 And to be able to have that, it takes a lot. It takes a lot of skill set. And it's beyond just being able to create a beautiful trail. It's truly the big vision of that, pushing it out there and being able to move that vision forward and being able to see it accomplished on the ground. So I believe we need that support. We can put a lot of this into a job description going forward. We can also work through it, obviously, in the funding and the structure. All of that technical work is very, very important.

3:00:24 But if we don't have the commonality of the vision of where we want to go, then I would say we don't need the position created. If we really see that value and see where we can get to, then we need to have that skill set as part of the town structure and part of the town family here to really be able to drive that forward and to have that coordinated management effort. Because frankly, I don't have the time or all the skills.

3:00:54 Stu doesn't have that. Hayes, our Public Works Office, doesn't have that. Even Joel and Matt, for their skill sets, I don't believe, rise at that level yet today to where we can really see this happen. So are we looking for, you know, a blue unicorn at some point? Maybe. But we really trust that they're out there and that they would love to be a part of this vision, a part of the work that we believe we can see going forward.

3:01:22 Here in Mammoth Lake. So let me stop with that. I'll answer questions and try to address other detailed level questions in the proposal before us. There's a lot of work to do on this before it's finalized, but I hope you get a feel for the passion and the desire that I believe that Mammoth Lakes is deserving of. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Hi. Put your hand up. You want to go first? Go. That was a very passionate

3:01:53 Talk. And Dan, I only have, what, two more meetings after this meeting, so I can be a little more candid than I could if I were up for re-election. So this position is not only unnecessary, I

3:02:15 And I know John, you know, did John Wentworth.

3:02:41 Kudos to you. You did make great roads 20 years ago with making some things happen, but I don't think that we're giving the people of the town a good scope of what the federal, what the state, all, everything that we have to deal with is just getting tighter and tighter and tighter. We're not going to find that blue unicorn.

3:03:07 And if we do find that blue unicorn, you can guarantee he is gonna cost so much more than what is put out on this paperwork. What I would like to see is for this town to start to develop relationships that are making things happen. Since I have had to deal with a lot of these agencies in my private business before I was on town council, I can tell you

3:03:36 The changeover, I would be talking with a new person every, you know, few months, every six months. Any progress I made would be lost. I am so flummoxed why everyone kind of is on the train of thought that right now that things are going to change. I am not being, I'm not trying to be negative.

3:04:05 But I am just trying to give you a reality check that this is not the time. With everything that we are dealing with, with everything that is going on, this position is something that should not even be on the table. So I am going to listen to what everybody else says, but just mind you, I will be chiming in and saying that again, because as I said,

3:04:33 I'm the one person on the Town Council, I don't have anything to lose. So I can bluntly say what I think and we would be doing a great disservice to our town budget to put someone in this position. So thank you. Thank you, Cleland. John, with that I will move over to you, sir. Thank you, Bill.

3:05:01 And Dan, thank you very much for that introduction. You covered a lot of things, but there are a lot of things to cover with this. I want to make clear that for those of us who are serving in the council, not up for election, I can only speak for myself. I'm not, I don't couch my terms or bring anything that is disingenuous to my seat here. And I will speak truthfully and honestly, as I always have. I don't, I'm not hiding behind any kind of election, you know,

3:05:32 paradigm. I believe that the question that Dan has brought up is the fundamental challenge that faces the community of Mammoth Lakes, and it has always been there. For many years, the town and the community was led to believe that our success would be defined by becoming a world-class ski resort. We all know the old adage, we got to be like Vail, we got to be like one of those kinds of places.

3:06:00 And for a variety of reasons, we are a world-class ski destination, but we never turned into a place like that for a whole variety of different reasons. And I would argue that's because the destiny of Mammoth Lakes did not lie down that road. That was not the path that we were on. We were on a path of being one of the, I don't know of any other community, any other town in the country where three-quarters of its land mass is managed by the federal government.

3:06:29 No other community in the world or in the nation has that kind of a land configuration. It is our unique challenge to rise to that challenge, as Dan has articulated. And in very stark terms, the success or failure of Mammoth Lakes, I believe, lies in our ability to rise to that challenge. And as Dan has pointed out, we are now confronted by a whole series of challenges.

3:06:58 And in the world of big initiatives from Washington or from Sacramento, from all over the place, all of these challenges come and hit the ground in a little town like Mammoth Lakes. It is on us to resolve and to reconcile the things that are in front of us, as Cleland pointed out. We are right next to the largest single ignition fire in the state of California's history. That's an effect of climate change.

3:07:24 Mammoth Lakes lives in the heart of the largest Jeffrey Pine forest in the world. It has not been managed for 100 years. We're going to have to deal with that. And we're getting money from the state to address with that. And as Dan said, we have to balance the needs of the recreation, infrastructure, and economy with that simultaneously. There's a lot of other things I can say, but Dan, I think you touched on a lot of it. I want to see this position developed, articulated, and brought back to Council.

3:07:54 And I want to point out a very important lesson to all of us on the council. All of us, I think, were around when the town was flirting with municipal bankruptcy, when the town was on the front page of the New York Times. Another set of exceptionally dire circumstances for this community. And there were members of the council looking at the very difficult situation the town was in that said, you know what, in this dire, difficult situation, the first thing we've got to get rid of is housing. We've got to cut money for housing. We've got to cut support for housing.

3:08:25 And Kirk, you remember this because you came on the council. Plenty of people in this community said housing is the top priority. What are you doing? In the darkest of moments, those kinds of decisions were made. We are in a dark moment. And these things, this opportunity that Dan is putting in front of us is exactly the time to say we have to embrace this. This is the challenge that is in front of us. And if we don't, if we do not rise in this challenge, this community flirts with failure.

3:08:54 The Lakes Basin is not a parking lot. It cannot become the parking lot that we're seeing it become year over year over year. We must engage with our federal partners. We must engage with this federal landscape. It is the destiny of this community. And the success or failure of this community and our role as a destination will be measured, in my mind, to the degree to which we rise to this challenge. So I strongly support Dan, staff putting some time into this.

3:09:23 Let's see what you come up with, and I look forward to seeing what you come up with when he comes back. Thank you. Thank you, John. I'm going to do something I normally don't do, and I'm going to go out of order here. So I am as passionate as Dan is about this, cautiously. You heard Dan say that the qualifications are paramount. We can't do, as some of our partners have done, put out a...

3:09:52 perspective and interview people and take whoever we can get. This doesn't move forward in my mind unless we find the right person to do the things we needed to do. That is important. Tonight's meeting is about bringing that position back better defined than for us to work on. And I'm going to be a little scattered here because that's the way I've been writing things down. One of the things that face us

3:10:21 When John came on and he was working so hard for public access and everything else, the Forest Service came back to the town and says, look, I don't want to talk to him. I only want to talk to a management level position from the town of Mammoth Lakes. Dan has taken up that role. The things we have asked Dan to do are beyond the capacity of what most town managers would ever do. This position can be that management level position dealing with the Forest Service. They're still under Dan. They still get

3:10:51 Council and Dan's permission to do things, but they are that management level position that the Forest Service will deal with. So this helps us clear Dan's plate a little bit and hopefully keep him around for a while. John mentioned the Lakes Basin. You've all heard me say that we're going to have increasing crowds. There's nothing we can do about it. We can't put a gate on Highway 395. And if we don't plan for that and plan appropriately and build the right infrastructure,

3:11:23 And give them the right things to do, then we are going to crush what assets we have. So that makes this even further more important. To do what has been done, and I'll pat myself some on the back here as well, by Mr. Wentworth and by myself, through nonprofits in terms of creating trails, because I do have my thumbprint on an awful lot of trails in the forest.

3:11:58 It takes passion. It takes commitment. It takes time. And we're no longer seeing those things produced by nonprofits. You're not going to get another me working for years for free or another John, as he's currently doing, working for free to create these things. We're going to have to step up to the plate, which is partly why we created MLR in the first place.

3:12:25 But when you create that agency, they go off and do sort of their own thing. We lose the control over having them do things that are focused on the region. And I say region because the importance of this position is regional, not just the town. We can't have a trailhead in Mammoth that goes nowhere to ungrouped trails or unmarked bike trails or whatever. So this position to me...

3:12:54 is absolutely critical moving forward. This is not going to happen overnight. We are not going to hire this position if we go into a huge COVID shutdown and we don't have the money to do it. We're all going into this with eyes wide open. I have been pushing way before the town was incorporated, the county, and now the county and the town, to move forward with recreation, the type of recreation that...

3:13:25 Butters our bread, frankly, that makes us all a living and that we all love to do from mountain bike trails to motorcycle trails to hiking trails to dog walking trails. You name it, it's endless. And we need a management level position. You all know how much I hate to spend money on management level. I'm the only guy that talked about Dan not getting raises for crying out loud. But this is huge. This is huge. This is what I have been asking for for decades. What I think the town of Mammoth Lakes.

3:13:54 Although a lot of people may not understand it or realize it, but it is what they have been aching for, to help create the opportunities. And if we can get a person and dedicate their time, and they already have passion coming in, we can accomplish more things than we've accomplished in the last three decades as a town of Mammoth Lakes to help ourselves move forward and become that premier resort. I never talked about becoming a premier ski resort.

3:14:21 We still, in your national forest in the town of Mammoth Lakes, serve more people in the summertime every year than we do in the wintertime. If you look at your convenience stores and bonds and everybody else, they make more in the summer than they do in the winter. They just have more days to do it in because in the winter it's, you know, two days a week. So I just, I view this as critical. I want to see, I want to work with Dan.

3:14:51 To bring this to council in a more complete version. And there's a lot more I could say, but at this point, I will go on to Kirk. Mute Kirk. Can you hear me? Dan, that was a great presentation, but it is also a sales pitch.

3:15:26 You know, to have this, you know, fill this position. My concerns are, you know, again, we're the pandemic, you know, what's going to happen with Mammoth Mountain and everything else. So given that impact on the town's budget, my first reaction to, you know, hiring staff because we didn't hire two maintenance staff people and the police department wants two different individuals down there.

3:15:56 So there's a budget concern that I have. And so I'd like to put this on hold, or at least my position would be arguing with the council that we should put this on hold and bring it up in six months or whatever. If we're not marketing right now, and so we're bringing this particular individual on, it seems that we're...

3:16:22 sending mixed messages as a council. So I start from, again, the budget and looking forward to what's happening this winter, driving up to, you know, the mountain and looking at what they're doing and talking to some of their individuals. So I'm not opposed to this position. I think it's a good position, but I just, I'm just not ready to do.

3:16:50 Implement it at this particular point of time or even have staff working on it. I think it's something we need with that coordination and everything. But again, I'm concerned about the budget. That's my comments. Thank you, Kirk. Linda. Okay. Thank you, Dan. Thank you, Bill. Thank you, John. Thank you, for your comments. I have some questions.

3:17:26 A couple of comments. Starting out with a comment, of course, fiscally, this is a very uneasy time. You know, what is gonna happen in the next few months with winter, the pandemic, economic recovery, where are we gonna be in a year from now? Obviously, those are important questions. Are we gonna have the TOT to see us through? Are we gonna continue to receive funding to keep the lights on?

3:17:55 You know, clearly Dan spoke to that, that that is the first priority. We'll take a look at this and see where we are. This is not any kind of a commentary on we have so much money that we should spend it on, you know, positions like this. However, we have fared well through this due to fiscal conservatism over the years. I feel like we're in a pretty good position. So what I want then question wise is,

3:18:25 What is different now? I know some of the answers, but to kind of condense this. When we haven't, you know, seated this position since the town started, how were things different 20 years ago, 10 years ago with the Forest Service? What has transpired? And what are the opportunities that exist now that make it so imperative to move on this?

3:18:56 In the near future. That's what I'd like to hear a little bit more about. I'd like the community to hear a little bit more about that to kind of help to understand why the urgency exists in this time and place. Dan, John, Bill, I think any of you can kind of help answer some of this. I've got a, Mr. Mary, a couple of quick thoughts. Linda,

3:19:25 The Forest Service 20, 30 years ago was a completely different organization. To Bill's point about funding, we, the town, when it was incorporated, could reasonably have an expectation that the Forest Service would staff their district offices, would staff their management teams, and would be a reliable partner delivering the things in their mission they said they would deliver. A great example of that is the management plan that was just rewritten.

3:19:54 When it was written in 1986, it was enormously prescriptive. The Forest Service will do this project, it will do this project, it will do this project. Very specifically detailed. The new management plan we've just adopted, that they've just adopted, is at a much higher level because the Forest Service understands they do not have the capacity to perform. Right now, International Forest is down three recreation staff officers. They do not have staff. They do not have people.

3:20:24 And that's a reality that we're living with, which means to Dan's point about permitting, the frustration that the community feels about why can't we get things done? We're dealing with an agency that is trying to do its mission with one and a half hands behind its back. That's one thing that has changed. The second thing that has changed is that the federal government has incorporated that reality into a policy known as sustainable recreation, where they have said,

3:20:53 If we cannot find partners to deliver recreation programming and this kind of work, it will not happen. This is happening at the national level. Some other things that have changed. The state of California has just signed a shared stewardship agreement with the U.S. Forest Service, which calls out sustainable recreation as a specific action plan to pursue. And the state is now investing with that policy framework in mind. As you know, we have a $300,000 grant.

3:21:21 I'm moving now on to climate change and to forests and to fuels. The state is now investing as a top priority in fuels management. There's an unfortunate level of confusion at the federal level where the president of the United States says, well, California should clean up its forests. Those are, in fact, the forests of the federal government. Whoever does not want to take responsibility, we are seeing the worst fire season that's ever been seen in the history of the state.

3:21:50 And the state is now investing in communities like ours to do forest management, to partner with the Forest Service. That was a point of a shared stewardship agreement. So now, for the sake of all the buildings, infrastructure, and business in this community, the state has now funded a $300,000 grant to plan the most ambitious fuels reduction project of any community in the state of California's history. That is going to be happening over the next year. That's going to start next month.

3:22:18 That group is pulling together the steering committee to start coming up with a plan to do that work. We don't have anybody to go to those meetings to represent the town's interests. Dan cannot assign anybody with that level of expertise to go to that meeting. Dan could probably cover it. Bill or I could probably cover it in a pinch. But we're talking about a fuels management program that is going to go on in perpetuity. It's a paper farm management kind of a program.

3:22:48 Okay, that, those kinds of things have changed. The second thing is that the recreation assets and needs of this community have to be integrated into that program, as Bill said. These things have to happen synergistically. They have to happen simultaneously. The vital interests of the town and the community are at stake on these types of efforts. These are a couple things that have changed. There's more, but I just want to point out those two.

3:23:15 Linda, I'm going to answer that question a little bit differently than John did. Shame on us as a town for not having this position back when the Forest Service did its land management plan in the 80s. As John said, it was very prescriptive, and it defined what recreation in that day was going to be like. And the town and county both relied on people like myself to represent recreation. They didn't feel it was their business. I think it was.

3:23:45 Shame on us. We just went through a new land management plan process, which came up with sustainable recreation and everything else. And I know that Sandra, who is still on, I believe, gave input from the town's standpoint. But Sandra is not a recreation officer. She does not have that experience. She did a great job. But shame on us for not having this position to take care of that management plan at that point in time. Now we're moving into subpart C.

3:24:14 Which is going to define what winter recreation looks like on the Indian National Forest. That's going to happen in another year or so out, but it is going to happen because of a lawsuit trying to shut down recreation, frankly. Shame on us if we haven't planned and advanced and have somebody capable of being our representative in that process. If you want to see them closed or not have input, it's fine.

3:24:42 We can continue to be the ostrich with its head in the sand. But shame on us. This is something that not that much has changed. You're right. This is something the town should have had at its inception because we rely on these recreational assets to move forward. Sorry, on recreation, I get a little passionate myself. So one more question then. What happens if we don't have someone like this?

3:25:10 What happens if we keep things just the way they are now, another five years goes by? What do you forecast will have been the effect of that? Okay, John, a little briefer than last time. I'll do my best. Great American Outdoors Act, hundreds, billions of dollars being invested into rural places like ours, onto forests like the International Forest. Land, Water, and Conservation Fund, billions of dollars in perpetuity.

3:25:39 We have a unit of the National Park Service in Devil's Postpile. As Dan mentioned, we have done nothing with that management plan. We sit in LTC meetings and listen to Madera County saying, well, we want to come over and get involved in this. If you read that management plan, it is pointed directly at the town and the community of Mammoth Lakes. 70% of that LWCF money is going to the Park Service. We can leverage that for the interests of our community. If we do not engage and we do not rise to this challenge, we fundamentally compromise.

3:26:07 The future and the future success of this community in this town. And I could go on, but I won't. But it is that stark and it's that simple. Okay, thank you. I have no further questions, Bill. Thank you. Kirk. You know, we're talking about budget. We're talking about expenditures. You know, we underfund annually roads by $500,000. Now, if we have excess TOT, we actually spend a million dollars. The maintenance yards, we need two new bays.

3:26:39 Down there. The guys that use a tarp to cover equipment and work out in the snow and that sort of thing to keep our equipment running, as well as we need a new snowblower, by the way. So the police department has asked for two new employees. You know, to have this discussion, and I'm not completely opposed to what we're suggesting and everything, it's just that we're talking about it in isolation.

3:27:07 Two new police officers have been brought to our attention. Community development, the parcel, you know, what is that the cost and how much do we, yes, we've got a $20 million grant for infrastructure and everything else, but it's not going to cover the full cost, so we're going to also need to have money for that.

3:27:27 My concern is that we're talking about this in isolation and not in relationship to the total budget as well as all our capital projects as well as our future expenditures. And that gives me a little bit of heartburn. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. Do we have any public comment on this?

3:27:54 Yes, we do. We received an email from Sharon Raven-Clark. It reads, Good evening, Town Council. Establishing a new town position, Chief Recreation Officer, would be a duplicate level of bureaucracy we already have with the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator. To consider using Measure R and Measure U money to pay that salary is not what we, the people, voted for. Measure R and Measure U funds were earmarked to construct or enhance recreation, arts, trails, etc.

3:28:22 To use them to pay a new staff position salary would be a grave misuse of the funds. We expect to see facilities built with measures R and U dollars as promised. If there are $119,710 extra dollars available, please consider using them for what you all say is your top priority, workforce housing. Mammoth Lakes Housing is seeking public donations for emergency rent assistance. COVID-19 has...

3:28:45 Wrecked havoc for renters who have lost jobs, gotten sick, or worse. With Measure A funding, MLH built workforce housing for 12 years until Town Council directed their funds elsewhere in 2012. Town assumed workforce housing responsibility and nothing has been built. It is pathetic that we, the people, are being asked for money to assist renters. We passed Measure A dollars to build housing. You have Measure A funds. Please use them and any extra money to support our residents who might otherwise be evicted.

3:29:14 I applaud Eastern Sierra cooperation among all agencies via our Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator. We do not need more bureaucracy and certainly we do not need staff duplication. Our Recreation Commission, Recreation Department, and Mammoth Lakes Recreation provide outstanding public service for our town. Thanks, Sharon Raven-Clark. Earlier we also received an email from Pat Agnich. Did you want me to read that into the record as well, Mayor Salzer? Certainly.

3:29:43 Pat Agnett says, a new town staff position? Really? In reviewing this week's town council agenda, I was surprised to see a request for a new administrative position, Chief Recreation Officer. In the midst of COVID-19 and the recent fire smoke impacts to the town, is it fiscally responsible to fund a new position at this time?

3:30:02 The unexpected expenditures due to these unforeseen situations probably caused Town Council and management to discuss budgetary options of furloughing staff or eliminating positions. Are we so far beyond those recent days that now is the time to consider creating a new position at a significant salary level? Despite this proposed position being termed exempt at will, it is never easy to delete a position once established and filled.

3:30:27 As mentioned, the salary range with benefits is significant, and this would be a year-over-year expenditure. How is the salary level determined? Is there a comparable position in the region that was used to compare and determine the salary level? What are the exact dollar amounts coming from each funding source? Will Measures R&U be rated to fund this position? When voters approved Measure R in 2008, I bet community members' expectations were that the funds would be utilized for recreational facilities and programs, not to fund staff positions.

3:30:57 Currently, what percentage of Measure R funds are allocated to staffing administration? Measure U. How is it that a large portion of Measure R and U funds are used for staffing when it seems to me that there are ethical considerations and political promises to be kept? Another consideration is that the proposed position does not appear to be different than that of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator.

3:31:19 In reviewing the ASSRC job description, collaboration with the United States Forest Service and Bureau of Land Management is listed along with other agencies. Isn't the proposed chief recreation officer position a duplication of these efforts? The staff report justifies this new position by indicating that it will reduce fracture and duplicative staff efforts and improve overall communication through the different authority levels within the agencies. Yet there seems to be an overlap of responsibilities.

3:31:46 Why is an additional layer needed to fill these important components when the ESSRC is currently managing these responsibilities? If three-fifths time that the ESSRC position is insufficient, why not fully fill the position instead of sharing it with the county, which would be cheaper in the long run, given the lower salary level, an average of 28% less. Also, as noted in the report, 75% of the land within the town is managed by U.S. Forest Service.

3:32:14 Is it justifiable to fund an additional administrative position that would only have responsibility for a fraction of town land? Also, is it prudent for the town council to approve a position without a complete job description and a detailed funding source regardless of staff's recommendation to return to council at a later date? Bottom line, is the timing right to create a new full-time position? Perhaps this request should return to town council at a much later time when the town's budget status and other factors are clearly known. Thank you for your consideration. Pat Agnich, resident.

3:32:42 In addition, we have somebody in Sweet Z. Okay. Sandy Hogan again. Thank you for the passion. I recognize that we all have that same passion for recreation. The problem is we also have to be fiscally prudent. And I think I hadn't heard Sharon's before. I had Red Pats. It's been in the agenda packet. So anyway, I thank you for allowing me to also.

3:33:13 comment. Her past comments were articulate and knowledgeable. And I also am a very fiscal conservative, you know, conservative fiscally and always was as a district ranger. And so I just commented in item 11 on the existing Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Coordinator who is doing

3:33:42 What you're talking about doing. And as I told you, it took him almost a year to have to gain that trust. I have a feeling that the position description that you will bring forward whenever you bring it forward is going to be that same one that he's working under right now. In other words, he's doing the job.

3:34:10 So the job that you're describing so passionately, he is doing it. So let him do it. I'm an optimist by nature, and I think most of you know that. But I'll tell you right now, we're in uncharted waters. And in my notes, our citizens right now need more rental assistance. The business needs food. They need assistance more probably. And our employees need food assistance.

3:34:40 We don't know what's coming. Mammoth Mountain, and I've worked with them. I had the pleasure to work with Dave and Rusty. They are a great organization. They're planning for control success, and if anybody can do it, they can do it. But they've got fallback plans, I can tell you that. And they cut capital projects because they're looking at worst-case scenario. If you're listening to...

3:35:06 Scientists and doctors, they're all saying the darker days are coming ahead of us. We're not rounding the bend according to them, you know, or curving whatever it is. Some of the economists that you listen to, and I listen a lot to PBS, I don't listen to some of the other ones, they're saying not just recession, but they, some have talked about depression. I mean, this is not good times to be in.

3:35:34 As I say, I'm an optimist, but I'm smart enough to know that I don't know it all. And, you know, there are times to listen to some of the experts, and the old expression is hope for the best and plan for the worst. Planning for the worst. Therefore, I really appreciate all of the conservative budgeting that's been going on for especially the last four years. It's allowed us to actually help out with the rental assistance.

3:36:02 The businesses senses, the MLT with the food bank. I mean, it's a community I've been very proud of, and I've told people that. You know, it is, we've done well, and we can be proud of it. I appreciate the staff ambassador program, especially, I was having my hair cut, and here comes Robin and Sandra checking out, you know, but very professionally. I mean, really, it's neat.

3:36:30 So they check on businesses for compliance, but, you know, they're not obtrusive and whatever. But even right now at a time when I read that the Bishop Town Council is looking at giving up their long-term health benefits because they know that some hard times are coming, this position is one that maybe you need to step into it. That's what Matt is actually doing.

3:36:59 You know, rather than creating a new one right now or just using his position description for this position so that you can fill it. And also, you know, I commented before about the use of Measure U and the use of Measure R. As I want to add one little thing to it, because, Bill, staff does not deal with rangers. Town managers.

3:37:28 The Forest Service works government to government. Dan is the mouthpiece for the council. In other words, you don't individually go to a ranger. Dan takes the decisions of the council to the ranger. He talks government to government. Staff talks staff to staff. In other words, that's the importance of a high-level position. But that's what Matt is doing right now. You're getting it.

3:37:58 Pretty much at a bargain. But, you know, I'm just saying, I think this is a, it may be a wonderful vision for some time, but some, in some situations, you've got to live with what you've got and be proud of it and realize we're doing a lot of good things. You guys are, you're making some great decisions. Let's not get so, chase all these bubbles that we all, shiny bubbles that I've seen over the years.

3:38:27 Let's get through this together so we don't lose our employees. Let's just hold off and look at it again maybe next spring or next summer when you know what's happening because we know it's not going to be a great, there's not going to be a lot of big changes, I don't think. And it's hard to say, but so anyway, I think it's premature. Thank you.

3:38:57 And one other comment. You mentioned a bachelor's degree being needed. Well, that's what Matt is working under from a college, accredited college or university with a major coursework in planning, geography, land use management or a related field. That's in his position description. So he's working in that. Thank you. Questions? Any questions for Sandy? Seeing none. Thank you, Sandy. Bill and I worked together many years ago.

3:39:27 And did a lot of good stuff. It's just that the Forest Service is slow and you got to have good relationships and don't try to tell them what to do. Okay, thank you. Stacey Corliss, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello again, Mayor Sauser and Councilmembers. Speaking as a resident of Mammoth Lake and somebody who's worked alongside Councilmember Wentworth and Mayor Sauser on recreation issues for many years.

3:40:03 I strongly believe we need to continue investing in public lands management and recreation. It's our lifeblood. It's not only economic, but it's community well-being. And I would support moving ahead and exploring options for this. We all heard this summer so many complaints about land management. They were endless. There was fear about out of control.

3:40:32 Just impacts on the land. This isn't going to go away. These problems are going to continue. Additionally, with great opportunities like the Great American Outdoors Act, there are a number of projects coming forward, and the scope of these projects could be massive. Rebuilding campgrounds, rebuilding roads, as will happen in Reds Meadow Valley soon.

3:41:03 We need in local government someone to engage with this on the highest level, and Town Manager Holler is certainly capable, but I don't even know how he gets through what he's doing now with COVID, with wildfires, with very capable hands-on management of the town. We need to do more, so I support exploring this, and thank you for the presentation and consideration. Thank you, Stacey. With that,

3:41:34 Is there any more public comment? That's all. Thank you. With that, I will move this forward. And I would go ahead and make a motion. Can I speak before you make a motion? Sure. I think everyone has done a great presentation about why they think that this is a positive thing.

3:41:59 But you have to realize only in the state of California, we have what almost 500 towns, cities who are fighting for the same dollars that we are for different reasons. We are surrounded by federal lands. I think what Sandy Hogan said was really important that it's almost as though this little town in the midst of

3:42:27 The Forest Service, a federal government, we want to dictate. So my question is, number one, when we are having trash problems, when we are having people pooping in the forest problems, we're having dogs pooping, it has all come down to town dollars to save this. Everything that you guys are saying is going to help us.

3:42:57 I think it's still going to end up coming out of the town dollars, but it will be facilitated by someone who we are paying way too much money to facilitate this. I just am so flummoxed by this, what you are bringing forward to us.

3:43:21 That I really think that the average person needs a little bit more clarification why. And I know that there may be a little bit, we're not going to call it a chief recreation officer or whatever. But right now, I am so opposed to this. I just don't see any.

3:43:46 Reason how this is going to move us forward. And I think that our ego has gotten so big that we think that Mammoth is the end-all be-all, that we are going to be the world-class resort, that we are going to be this upscale resort. We can't even house our people. We can't even make sure that our workers are healthy, fed.

3:44:09 Taking care of, but all of a sudden we're going to be so wonderful because we're going to have someone who is in charge. I really hope that everybody goes home and thinks about this tonight and for again.

3:44:27 December, I'll be off town council. So you can have this conversation then. And hopefully you'll have people who are just backing all of the things that you were saying right now. But I do have a very big problem. I do think it was a very big sales pitch. I think that people are wanting this position, but this position is not going to move us.

3:44:55 Any further, and unless you guys already have and haven't told me of some superstar who is in line that has a great communication who can move all these federal dollars, why would they be living and working in Mammoth? I don't even understand. So, I mean, I could go on, but, you know, I've heard other people go on in length.

3:45:24 Giving me a sales pitch for this, but I'm just telling you, you haven't sold me and I don't think you've sold other people in this town on this. And if anybody would like to answer that and give us a real reason why this is something we should be spending our money on when we have been so conservative in the past with our money that we have been able to thrive.

3:45:53 Even in really horrible times right now, all of a sudden we're going to start throwing money to the wind. That's my big problem. Thank you. Thank you, Cleland. Anybody else want to make any last statements before I make a motion? I look forward to your motion. I've got a couple of comments to go with it. I'd like to second. All right. Thank you. So I don't like the title of the Chief Recreation Officer, so I'm going to leave that out of my motion.

3:46:25 Authorize the town manager and staff to bring back to us a management level position with detailed funding allocation and job description to come back for town confirmation. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'd like to second that motion. I'd just like to add a couple things. Perhaps we haven't done a good job providing the background necessary for all the council members to understand, and that's a conversation.

3:46:55 I would like to say that my specific concern is to echo what Supervisor Corliss said. We all lived through this summer. We saw things happening on the public landscape that we've never seen in our lifetimes, but it is a preview of what's going to happen in this community going forward. And if we don't step up and if we don't listen to the concerns of our constituents that have formed things like that.

3:47:23 Sierra Trash Collectors that have formed community volunteer groups to go out and deal with the deficit from the federal commitment to our resources, we're going to be in a lot of trouble. When petitions come in with thousands of signatures saying, get rid of Mammoth Lakes Tourism, get rid of this whole thing, that's something that we as elected officials need to be listening to and responding to. And I think this gives us an opportunity to do that. I think one other thing I want to advise is the frustration in the community is palpable.

3:47:51 The Mammoth Trails Committee had a meeting this last week in which words such as terrorist and eco-terrorists were thrown around casually, which is unfortunate and unacceptable. Mr. Mayor, I want to commend your diplomatic response to those terms. I know you go back to the committee and say, look, guys, we cannot use that type of terminology in these discussions. We are dealing with a level of public frustration in the space that we must address.

3:48:16 And I think if we do not respond to the constituents asking us to deal with the things that Stacey Corliss just talked about, we're failing our duties as elected officials. Okay, wait a minute. Excuse me, I am not done. Thank you. So with enthusiasm, I second the motion. Thank you. Okay, with that said, you in your initial sentence said that council members do not understand. I understand.

3:48:46 So much more than you are giving me credit for and other people in town. So that was very offensive. Do not say that my thoughts on this matter is because I do not understand you. So I'm sorry if I interrupted you. Thank you. I have a motion by myself and a second from John.

3:49:17 Any further discussion or deliberation? Yes, I have some comments to make on this. Thank you. While I support the idea of this position, I am hesitant to authorize the establishment of that position, lacking a further financial analysis. Yeah, this is what I'm getting to. I want you to explain

3:49:47 to me your intention of your motion, what that is actually saying and what kind of commitment we're making to this in a time when I would really have to feel more secure with the funding and with the status of our financial situation going into maybe past winter. I'm just, while I am

3:50:17 I'm extremely supportive of this position and I believe am able to understand the advantages of it and the importance of it and the proactivity of it. I'm a little still uneasy about the financial piece. Yeah, so my motion specifically I didn't say to create the position. I said to ferret out all the information and bring us back all the pertinent information. What my motion is doing is allowing staff

3:50:47 to spend staff time to work this out and bring it back to us as a whole presentation. Not to authorize spending money, just to authorize them to put in the work to bring it back to us as a full-fledged presentation. Okay, then I would ask that Jamie read back the motion, please, so I can understand it better. Authorize the town manager and staff to develop a management-level position with a detailed job description.

3:51:16 to be brought back to council for confirmation. Dan, or Dan, does that? Yeah, we would come back with that detailed amount of work. It'll take some time to get done in terms of the job description. That would incorporate by necessity then working through funding or program elements and a timeline. And as I mentioned early on, we have the same concerns, you know, what's going to happen financially with the winter. So again,

3:51:51 Not rushing into this, but really I did want to have and thank you for the honest debate discussion to be able to take a look at this very passionately across the board here. We're not going to jump into something we can't financially commit to and ongoing. You know, we've been very conservative to staff level as well as with Town Council support in doing that. So that would include a, you know, a full-blown what is the position, the relationship, the work, the job.

3:52:20 What does that financial commitment look like? Give you some great, great layout for that at that point in time. But also, whether or not we're ready to pull the trigger will be a key issue, and we will not know that for another few months. Okay. You know, speaking from the public health side of things, I think we're a long way from the conclusion of this pandemic. I think we're a distance away from vaccine. We're a distance away from...

3:52:45 Understanding how that vaccine works, what kind of protection that's going to give us going forward. We're a long way from knowing the, you know, full impacts of the economics of this, you know, event. And I also want to understand sort of to Kirk's comments around competing interests, you know, first concern being the health and welfare of our community.

3:53:10 And the health and welfare of our businesses. I think those are some of the priorities. So if within all that, it looks like there is space and condition where this position would be able to be funded in a way that is agreeable to the majority of the council, then I would support that. I just wanna make sure that this motion doesn't get us into a position that we cannot.

3:53:41 At the end of the day, back away from. It is. From my perspective, it is not a commitment to fund the position or a commitment to staff this level of position. It really is a discussion about it will take some time and effort to prepare it and it will go through the analysis we're talking about. But frankly, I'll be honest, I did not want to spend...

3:54:09 I'll say 40 hours of staff time or more working through this without this level of discussion. The comments from each of you have been taken to heart and I understand the concerns. All right, thank you. Okay, John, before I call on you, Andy, a minute ago you showed us your face. Was that just a treat or would you like to speak up? No, I don't have anything to say. Vice Mayor Salcido mentioned my name and in case she was going to ask me a question, I was popping up.

3:54:38 I actually said, I actually said, and so you're right. I was, but I was thinking about that word. So you're right. You, you, you popped on just at the right time, Andy. Thank you for being present. Thank you. John. Yeah, Linda, I'll just add that the way you articulated your understanding of the motion and what Dan said, I think what Bill said, my second is consistent with, with that, with that, with Bill's motion along those lines. Okay. Thank you, John. Okay. Again.

3:55:08 It's almost as though it's a motion that we're going to think about thinking about a position and I seriously do not understand where this is coming from and why this is coming up at this point. So I will hush now and wait for the next whatever is going to happen. Okay. Any further deliberation?

3:55:40 I have a motion and a second. Jamie, please. Council Member Hoff? No. Council Member Staff? No. Council Member Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Motion passes 3 to 2. Thank you all for your passion on this. It is appreciated, believe me. Moving on now to item number 13.

3:56:16 Item number 13, we are actually breaking into two items. There will be 13 and 13A. The first item 13 is to authorize the winter operations, town staffing modifications, and funding. Community host will be the next agenda item. With that, Dan, I will turn it to you. Thank you. The discussion before us is looking at as we were prepping for the winter.

3:56:48 It goes back to a lot of discussions we've had this evening as we look at the impact of COVID-19. We look at the uncertainty about what the winter will look like. We do believe that there are going to be a couple of things happening this winter that we need to be very cognizant of. One is we have looked at modifying our own work schedules and processes as it relates to snow removal in our public works overall operations.

3:57:16 We have taken steps already to look at our mechanics and how we structure that in the work. We've taken a look at that in our public work staff and the number how they work in a pod or a team. In some cases, just two at a time. But if we have more now, we have to be able to pull them together to get the right type of work done. The reason we're looking at that is we cannot afford to have a COVID-19 case that wipes out our public works department.

3:57:46 You know, in the middle of winter, assuming we have some good snowstorms, it's a very, very critical service that we need to be able to provide and not have a loss of staffing due to people being out ill either slightly or seriously from COVID. And you can throw on top of that is the other seasonal flu and other elements that impact our workforce as well. So we begin to look at that and also looking at operationally, we've had discussions with ESTA.

3:58:16 And right now we're running about 50% or so of a bus capacity-wise. We anticipate that continuing into the winter, which means as you go by a bus stop, you have a couple different things happening as we pick people up. One is that half capacity means there's a likelihood of additional people being left at that stop as the bus goes by because it is at capacity for distancing requirements.

3:58:42 So we have two elements there on the ground. One is making sure that our bus stops are clear of snow and that we have area for people to wait and also that they can meet distancing requirements. A couple of the elements that we've looked at on this is that ongoing effort, education on the use of face coverings and social distancing, good hygiene, and, you know, if you're ill, please, you know, stay home, those types of elements. And so we're looking at additional potential hand work.

3:59:12 I.e., been having to get out and hand shovel areas out of the way. Looking at the shift in our road department of how we shift and have people in different pods and working together. So the recommendations that we're making to council for consideration is if within the public works department, we'd be leaving one of our part-time positions vacant, bringing out a full-time position. That actually gives us greater flexibility in terms of the work and the time and depending on the length of the winter that we can put into that.

3:59:41 The position there would ultimately fit long-term. Long-term, our goal is to have the equivalent of 14 positions within our public works department between full-time and part-time. This would actually put us at 13 in balance, I believe, there to look at that. The full-time position also allows to extend a little further into the spring and into the summertime.

4:00:08 And as Linda mentioned, we do not know the timeline when COVID may be over, but we saw it this summer, we had one scare with some exposures and stuff, and what did we have to do with our staff, moving them around, being able to have that capacity, and again, continue this team concept, and being able to have that flexibility in those operations.

4:00:30 Now and going forward, we've become very critical. The net cost of this is probably in the $15,000 range, depending on timing of hiring and filling, but we're sure there's adequate funding within our road fund or gas tax fund for the position. It does add that full-time position ongoing. We believe it fits in there. We've also been doing a lot of work, and if there's any additional detail on this.

4:00:55 Haislip Hayes can address this as well. We've been working very closely with Caltrans in the work on Highway 203, working through a multiple of agreements. We have initial, at least it sounds like we will be looking for some additional funding to come in to help support our cost of snow removal off of 203 with the frontage roads and the sidewalks. We believe this year that could be in a $40,000 range.

4:01:21 Obviously, we'd like it if it was a little bit higher, frankly, and have asked for that. We'll continue to negotiate through that. But that would be a decent offset in terms of some of our snow removal requirements. Tied to that is an additional part-time position within parks maintenance. The parks maintenance side are challenged or assigned, I should say, to all of the sidewalk clearing and removing of snow. We've added...

4:01:48 A fair amount of distance in our sidewalk, especially on Main Street. Again, the same idea of this teamwork element, this would give us three, four people that we could actually run a couple of 12-hour shifts in terms of our sidewalk as snowblowers, the smaller ones, and have them working on the opposite sides, if you will, of time. So again, we're not having the same number of employees potentially exposed to each other in terms of a COVID issue.

4:02:17 Also, again, that's just staff that can assist with more detail work around bus stops, be it through the with the snow, the smaller snow blowers and door hand shoveling in those areas. It also frees up a little bit of time from our parks manager who often gets called on to assist with road maintenance work, either in a blower or a loader. That's not our goal for him to spend a lot of time there, but if need be, and that's where the needs are, he can step into that.

4:02:45 Additional position gives him a little more flexibility to be able to do those things, as well as managing the overall removal within the park side. The same staff also coordinate a lot of clearing of park areas, you know, around our facilities, be it our police station, our community center, and other places where we do need to have snow removal done. And I think this year we're going to be challenged in that area. We do anticipate, you know, if the mountain is open, things are going. A little bit of a

4:03:13 It won't be a bit surprised if we have some of the repeat of this summer where we have a lot of people coming to Mammoth Lakes to get out of where they're at. Either just they're tired of being locked up at home and or they want to get out of the city areas and get out to the mountains, get up, play in the snow, new experience and making sure that we have snow removal operations that we can all be proud of. And we have some great, great guys out there doing that work.

4:03:39 To be able to make sure we have a community that's ready to welcome those guests. The part-time parks maintenance position estimated about $27,000 over the season. Excuse me. This would not necessarily be an ongoing position if you want to review on an annual basis as part of the budget. But just last year, we did not fully fund.

4:04:03 Several of our part-time positions, you'll see it later report here, but about $28,000 in savings from the current year that would be requesting the rolling to fund this position for this winter. Frankly, we do expect this winter to have some really unique elements to it because of COVID and the visitor element that we anticipate coming up to Mammoth Lakes this year. So that the net impact of this is probably $15,000 within the roads department budget.

4:04:31 That can come out of reserves at this point, and or it will be offset within savings in the department, depending on the level of the winter that we experience. So that would be the public work side, but really are trying to be creative and protect our employees to keep them safe, to keep the level of services that we can provide to our community at the level that allows for the movement of people through our community in a good snow year. And again,

4:05:00 Your guess is probably as good as mine of how much snow we're going to get this year and how much snow and how many given days and the work that that takes. You're all aware of the demands that places on our snow removal crew. I do want to say that we are prepped up for this. As Councilmember Stapp mentioned, the need on equipment.

4:05:22 We actually did replace a blower, we placed that blower this year, so we did actually step up and replace the blower. We'll have five blowers available within town, one that spared the airport supporting down there, and I believe that we have five loaders. We actually replaced the loader and some of the blades this year as well. That's that whole element of setting aside money over time for those types of replacement pieces of equipment, that that serves us very well.

4:05:48 So we are equipment ready. Actually, I went with people at the yard, our staff down there yesterday afternoon, I think it was out there, and really got a good feel of, they're feeling very good about our equipment. It's ready. They're feeling good about the staffing levels. We did have a vacancy. We filled that. They were very excited. One of the elements this year that was unique.

4:06:12 We advertise for a vacant position. We had 31 applications. 16 of them already have their CDL. That is the best recruitment from a public worksite that I've seen since I've been here. And so that was exciting to see. So we have, you know, some really solid people to work with in terms of these positions and the level of service that we can provide for the community. So we are trying to be proactive.

4:06:41 You know, estimating what we're going to see happen. Again, a little bit of an unknown as we've seen walking into this. So let me pause there in terms of that winter operational side of the house. We focus on our public work side. If there's any additional questions to that, I'd be glad to address those. And Hayes is on the call. He can speak to some of the other, if anything, on that level in terms of that public works crew and they're being ready to...

4:07:10 Take on some of the issues that we're seeing out there. Okay. I would do this as questions and comments together here for the sake of time. And, John, we will start with you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Dan, I support this. I think it's reasonable, well presented. One question is, is there a COVID element in this, in that are we going to make sure that sidewalks are well plowed, we can provide social distancing space in the winter?

4:07:41 World, if you could speak to that just for a second, but I'm supportive and look forward to this going forward. Yeah, I can or Hayes, if you want to. Yeah, it is a primary concern, John, being ready for COVID in the winter. There's a lot of variables out there. You know, we're working, you heard Dan articulate our position on creating some additional staffing to have the flexibility to be nimble, to work in small groups, to mitigate spread.

4:08:07 You will see a new shoveling bid before Council. We're opening bids tomorrow. It'll be before you on the 4th. We want to have expanded capacity to shovel bus shelters, public spaces, if our staff can't get there, because we need to create enough space for people to queue up, social distance, and do things appropriately. Thank you. Thanks for the foresight and proactivity. Thank you. Thank you, John. Linda.

4:08:37 No, I support this. I think it's well planned. Definitely important to make these considerations during this time of pandemic and yeah, good work. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. Kirk? Perfect. Yes. Cleland? Nothing. Thank you. Thank you. And I think that this is a good move forward. The town is making some great plans as to how to use its

4:09:14 Do we have any public comment on this item? No, we do not. Thank you.

4:09:44 So if you're going to read the recommended motion, one and two pertain to this item, three is for the next. I would entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I'll move that the council authorize the hiring of an additional full-time public works maintenance worker, leaving one part-time maintenance worker position vacant for fiscal year 2021, and the use of additional funding of $15,000 from gas tax fund reserves.

4:10:11 That's item number one. Item number two, authorize the hiring of an additional part-time parks maintenance worker to be funded from departmental savings, estimated $27,000 for fiscal year 2021. I'll second the motion. I have a motion from John, a second from Kirk. Any further deliberation? Seeing none, I will call for the item. Jamie? Councilmember Hoff? Yes. Councilmember Staff? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Temp-Salcido?

4:10:46 Yes. Mayor Sauser. Yes. Passes 5-0. The second part of this is the community host program. And, John, go ahead. Mr. Mayor, fellow council members, I'm going to recuse myself from this item. I personally don't have a financial interest in this, but MLTPA may. So as I serve on that board, I'm going to turn off my video and mute myself. It's everybody's great relief.

4:11:17 I always appreciate a muted job. So with that, Dan. Yeah, thank you. This is other element of our winter operations planning. And this, the idea of a community trail host program really builds off of our summer program that was very successful. We've also had a pilot program, I think, a year ago. I think if Joel Ratge is still on the call here, he can speak to some of the planning work that's gone into this and some of the pilot projects.

4:11:48 And again, as we look at the host program, the key issue here really is how do we meet our visitors where they're at as they come into town, whether that be at our welcome center, whether that be at a commercial site, or out at a trailhead trail site. What we saw this summer was a lot of questions, a lot of issues that came up, and we're able to actually address a lot of potential problems on the front end.

4:12:13 The program is proposed. We look at, depending on the number of people, 6 to 10 people, 22 to 24 weeks, you know, a few different days if they're out there, we'll work through that. The program is scalable to meet the demand. The funding source for this, again, is twofold, one being one-time money with the general fund of $25,000 from contingency.

4:12:39 And we've also been working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism on this and looking at a $75,000 of use from the tourism reserve held by the town. So be able to walk through those types of pieces to this. I'll have Joel talk to the program and some of the specifics of it and elements there. The idea there would have some paid people in terms of this process. Ultimately, in our programs, we'd like to have kind of part-time level, but the management or the lead worker on that really be at a town level.

4:13:08 And then be able to utilize either town or employees from nonprofits. We have used MLTPA for this purpose in the past. That's why John is stepping off under our current contract for services. MLR can be another source for that type of work as well. But we're looking at about $100,000 program. We can scale it accordingly or if we have other donations to work through that.

4:13:33 I think the value of the program can't be overstated based on what we saw last winter and this summer. As people get out and have that social interaction, ask those questions. And again, if we're estimating correctly, if seeing new people come here, maybe their first time visiting Mammoth Lakes, or as we saw this summer, several first-time visitors, having somebody to assist them of where to go, what to do, how to get there, where to go safely.

4:14:00 Where to go plain to snow will be really valuable information. So, Joel, I want you to be able to talk briefly to the preparation for this in terms of the past work and then the anticipated level of interaction we would have this winter with our visitors, guests, and locals. Thank you, Dan. Thank you, council members. Mr. Mayor.

4:14:24 So we did begin a Mammoth Lakes Trail System Trailhouse program that was prescribed in the Trail System Master Plan in 2011. We began a pilot program last winter in the Shady Rest Winter Trails Network. We learned a lot, developed the program further. This summer we mobilized July 1st, right before July 4th weekend in a pretty crazy time between COVID, forest shutdowns, and smoke.

4:14:53 It's been a challenge. We've had an amazing dynamic team that really rose to the occasion. One unique thing about this program is it does enable people who want to contribute as volunteers. We have a way for them to volunteer and join us to help our visitors and trail users have fun safely. And that's what we strive to do. One other thing that...

4:15:18 It became extremely valuable. We were able to provide backup services at the Welcome Center when that shut down for inside services. And we were able to work with Visit Mammoth staff to provide a welcoming presence in the parking lot there. And that's where it really became evident to me, the real value of this. I felt like we were preventing 80 headaches in a couple of hours.

4:15:45 You know, people that may have run into a traffic jam in the Lakes Basin or trying to get into Red's Meadow. And we would say just an example, you know, one example that I think struck me was a family pulls up and they just really want to get out of the car and stretch out and take a walk. And they heard that the Lakes Basin or Red's Meadow was and I knew that there was a traffic jam all the way down to the village. And so I advised them that they could take their next right and go to Shady Rest Park.

4:16:14 And stretch out. They can have a giant field for their kids to run around on. They could play disc golf for free. And by the way, I had a disc in my car if they needed to borrow one. It was the most grateful group of people. We prevented them from spending hours in traffic. And they had a delightful time at one of our municipal parks that is on public lands, on federal lands. And they just had a great experience at Mammoth Lakes. And it was the first right turn.

4:16:44 So that kind of service, that kind of engagement, I think is critical in a service-based economy, especially like ours. You know, and another great thing that was very intrinsic about this was the people that were volunteering with us and the staff even, and myself included. You know, there's a lot of sediment that there was like a lot of idiots out there causing problems. And I can tell you, yes, there are always idiots. But our engagement with these people made it,

4:17:14 You know, clear to us that 99.9% of our visitors are authentically here for healthy outdoor experiences. And that's what we are here to help them have. And, you know, we were picking up litter. We collect data that's meaningful to people like Dan Holler so he can see what's going on out there. And I'm very proud of the dynamic team that has put this together.

4:17:42 And my best recommendation is to continue with the same group of people doing this great work. We really rallied together. The people that have been hired as a part of this program are dedicated people that know a lot about the community. So with that, we've had some discussions around expanding this for winter and adapting it to more of the urban core. Picture us with a vest on in front of bonds or on a trolley.

4:18:12 You know, those kinds of places really interacting and helping people know that we really do, you know, care about their visit to Mammoth Lakes and that we hope that they have a great experience here. If I can piggyback one more thing on that, we have been having discussions with the Forest Service on the Welcome Center. They are still in a virtual mode, if you will.

4:18:39 There will not be Forest Service staff at the Welcome Center going into the winter. They are looking at shifting that staff from the Welcome Center into the Ranger's office, utilizing one of the conference room for computer and phone services. That will allow ECIA to move back into the center, at least initially. It looks like they would be in there Friday through Monday. So reached out to John Urdi at MLT.

4:19:06 The program here looking at if we can't help provide some services in there Tuesday, Wednesday, and Thursday. So we do not have people pulling in and stopping at a vacant Welcome Center. Again, winter shift can change. We'll need people indoors versus outdoors just from a safety standpoint, an element there. But we are trying to step into some of those spaces to make sure that our guests this winters, they come up in this environment of...

4:19:32 You know, COVID and uncertainty, and hopefully it will be a very inviting winter season, but to be able to give them the best service and information that we can provide. So with that, I'd be glad to take any questions or other comments regarding the proposal, which would be the, and we've kind of consolidated the community at a trail host program, having people in town as well as out at our trailheads for this winter season.

4:20:02 Minimum funding for the program at $25,000 from the general fund contingency and $75,000 from the tourism reserves. Thank you, Dan. Let's start with Cleland for questions or comments. Nothing. Thank you. Thank you. Kirk. Unmute, Kirk. The $25,000 from the general fund contingency. Why isn't this coming from RRU? I'm just curious.

4:20:38 Based on the type of program, it was a difficult fit, especially if we have people working like in the Welcome Center or working in town involved with that from a commercial standpoint. It was hard fit because it's really not a recreational based program at this point. So I was frankly going through it. We did look at that a little bit, but a little uncomfortable with.

4:21:02 The linkage back to the purpose of those two funds. It was a stretch. So this just becomes part of the parks program? Yeah, between the trail system and assistance through coordination with those other departments. More under Joel on the trail side than parks directly. And again, we're looking at this as one-time funding at this point, that this program is going to be continued beyond. That would be a whole other financial and budgetary discussion down the road. Thank you.

4:21:33 Thanks. Linda, you got to unmute. Yeah, get the other way. Thank you, Jill, for, you know, kind of fostering this program. This brings out the best in volunteers, the kindness that you can show strangers, and I think brings out the best in our visitors also. When they're greeted with kindness, I believe that they then generate their better side, and I think it's a win for everybody. So it'll be fun to see how we...

4:22:09 Manage this in the winter and boot up all the people and send them out there to do their magic. So yeah, very much in support of this and thank you again for this. And I'm going to mirror some of those comments. I went out a couple different times and met with Joel's staff. I'm going to call him Joel's staff. He ran this program incredibly well this summer and saw the great work they were doing and the information they were doling out and how happy they made people. It's an excellent program.

4:22:41 And I look forward to somebody being able to maybe go to some of our trailheads in the winter and tell these idiots out of park so we can get more than six cars at Shady Rest. That being said, I am also in favor of this program. Do we have any public comments on this program, Jamie? Yes. Sandy Hogan says, great program, summer, great idea for winter, but be sure it's MLT money.

4:23:13 Great. Thanks to MLT. Be careful using any Measure R and Measure U funding. Supervise closely how it's being used, if used. General fund at 25%. I can grudgingly support. Good for our COVID situation. Sandy Hogan. Thank you. And that is all. Thank you. That being said, then I would entertain the motion. Okay. Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion that we authorize the establishment of a community trail host program.

4:23:45 For the winter season and provide minimum funding for the program of $25,000 from general fund contingency and a recommendation to utilize $75,000 in tourism reserves. I'll second it. Yeah, I think Kirk already seconded. He raised his hand anyway. Oh. That was your intention, right, Kirk? Yes, okay. So I have a motion by Linda, a second from Kirk. Any further discussion or deliberation? Seeing none, I will call for the item. Jamie? Council Member Hoff?

4:24:21 Yes. Councilmember Stapp. If you can read lips, he said yes. Kirk, you're muted. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido. Yes. Mayor Salzer. Yes. Passes 4-0 with one abstention. Thank you all. John, you may now rejoin us. Thank you. The next item on the agenda is presentation and action on pre-audit financial results for fiscal year 1920.

4:25:00 Fund balance projects in continuing commitments. Rob, I expected this meeting to be over at 8 o'clock, so you have a negative 24 minutes. Continue. Mr. Mayor, I was going to start this. This presentation is the most important presentation of the year, followed only by the budget adoption we do in June. What I am offering up to you is

4:25:29 Okay, we will not lose anything by continuing this.

4:25:56 Critical items, and Dan, I didn't ask you about this, so jump in. There's no critical items on here that we would need decision on tonight, in my opinion. I think from Andy's perspective, it's something that can be done. So any other comments to Dan particularly? Dan, I'd like to hear from you on that. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. As Rob mentioned, there's some key elements in here with some policy structure and some changes and some recommendations for funding and moving some funding around.

4:26:31 But if it's delayed to the next meeting, that is fine. We don't lose anything in the next couple of weeks to be able to do that. I would like if there's particular questions from council that we could be prepared to address at that point in time, if you wish to ask one this evening, I would leave that part open. But yes, we could spend the time with the presentation and stuff at the next election or next council meeting. It's day after the election. Thank you, sir.

4:27:01 But we will all still be here. The council will not change. So current council will have a chance to weigh in completely. That being said, you guys have all read the packet. Do you have any questions of Rob you would like to ask so that he can have them prepared to answer at the next meeting? John? I don't, and I appreciate this. I have to get up and leave at 5 in the morning, so I appreciate this continuously. Thank you. Thank you.

4:27:32 Linda? No, I think it's a good idea. After four and a half hours, I think most of our brain cells are a little tired, so I would rather get better attention at a later date. Thank you. Kirk? No questions. Cleland? No, I'm making dinner for my husband, so yeah, cool. Perfect. My dinner's getting cold. I could take just a couple minutes.

4:28:01 And maybe give a cliff note version of things to focus on and things that I'm going to be really interested in. One, it's a pretty strong financial performance, even though the challenges that we had. The items that we're carrying over, typically we've had just appropriate items that do span fiscal years that we need to make sure we have funding for. Much of the requests are circled.

4:28:30 It surfaced around bolstering our reserves. That was partly due to the recent review from S&P and recommendations that they provided back to us on how to further strengthen our resolve against challenges that we may face. So there's some significant adjustments to that. One, the adjustment to the reserve policy, the ways that we're vibrating that between operating and REU.

4:28:59 But also that debt reserve, 50% of the annual debt payments out of the general fund. That's a fairly significant amount of money, but it does go into an area that is committed but inaccessible. It just really strengthens our position. I did go through and do a good reconciliation of the reserve accounts for transit, tourism, and housing. So those are out there for you and listed the items that are coming about on them. We talked briefly about

4:29:29 Thank you, Rob. Any other questions you guys would like to ask?

4:30:03 Seeing none, I will move forward to Councilmember Reports, starting with John. Bill, I would ask you to go on to somebody else, because mine, I've got to pull it up. Give me one, I need a second to pull it up. You got it. Linda, you're muted. How many years will it take? I know. On Friday, I attended the Business Roundtable with Mayor Sauser and some of our business.

4:30:41 It's always an interesting meeting, always a lot of good conversation. It's a chance to also dispense a lot of information. So that was good. I did not make the LTC meeting on the Monday. And most of my other meetings are just involved around ESCOG. ESCOG was last Friday. Yes, ESCOG was last Friday. That was a great meeting. A lot of conversation, a lot of knowledge again.

4:31:11 Learning more about the moving pieces in both counties around, you know, better collaboration, better, you know, working towards common goals, identifying projects. So, yeah, good meeting and John can do a better job articulating that I think than I can right now. And the rest of the meetings were EOC, you know, connected public health meetings, you know, economic recovery branch meetings, JIC meetings, EOC meetings, and still lots of things, public health, even though I'm not.

4:31:41 I'm not officially in charge of things anymore. It's trying to keep my hand in so I can be of help. So a reminder that this Saturday is the next flu clinic here in Mammoth, or if you have not gotten your flu vaccine, it will be held from 10 to 2, I believe. Yeah, 10 to 2 at the new Civic Center. Enter there and then you'll wind around the parking lot to get the flu shot all outdoors. So if you didn't get it the first time around, use your...

4:32:10 Next chance. So don't miss out on it. That's all I have. Thanks. Thank you, Linda. Kirk, unmute. You're muted. There you go. Okay. I have nothing to report. Thank you. Cleland. Sorry, I was muted. I went to the estimating. You were there. I have to say I'm very impressed with...

4:32:44 Everything that they are doing there are so nimble with all the things that are thrown at them, not only from the COVID, but looking towards, you know, more efficient vehicles in the future. So, you know, maybe Bill could tell a little bit more, but I am continually impressed with everybody who is making us to work in our bus system. Thank you.

4:33:15 John, I'll go back to you again. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So on October 8th, I attended a meeting with the Pacific Crest Trail Association. This is the PCT group. They're working with Forest Service and the National Park Service on sort of a planning effort. It won't involve NEPA, but it's a very interesting planning effort. Rumors out there that Mammoth Lakes is going to be named one of the first trail towns as part of the PCT, which is those familiar with the Appalachian Trail know what a big deal that is back east.

4:33:45 This is also a component in walk, bike, ride and the integration that Dan was speaking about earlier, integrating things like the PCT and the walk, bike, ride and the mobility hubs and those thousands of people that will be living in our beautiful new parcel project. It's going to be part of why they're going to be here. The community conversation, the parcel was great. I really appreciated that. I think we identified, I'm looking forward to the conversation with Mono County Behavioral Health on their housing piece to that. I think it's very important.

4:34:14 And also Digital 395, making sure we've got a very good plan for making sure that that entire thing is going to be hardwired just right out of the box. That's going to be a critical thing that we won't miss. But thanks to that, as I mentioned, Sandra, I'm looking forward to the next one. I'm very excited. If we can get to January and be approving that master plan in January, that would be just terrific. Then the ESCOG meeting, the ESCOG has now hired a part-time staffer.

4:34:42 Which is very exciting. There's now a body there. Elaine Cabala, who works part-time in the City of Bishop, responded to the RFQ, and she was hired by the ESCOG, so that's great. There's now a point of contact for that. It's a modest step in the right direction. She's only working part-time for six months, and we'll see how that goes down the road. The ESCOG also approved a program of work for the region called the ESCOG Sustainable Recreation and Ecosystem Management Program. The full ESCOG supports it. They support it unanimously. It's going to go back to...

4:35:11 It'll come back to us. It'll come back to City of Bishop, Inyo County, Mono County for approval to move forward. Right now, the ESCOG, it's a great idea, but it can't even apply for a grant. This is the kind of thing that would make it possible to apply for grants and get money. There's certainly a lot of money out there coming everybody's way. The LTC, we had a very good conversation about a number of things. We checked on the state's active transportation plan, which Hayes can talk a lot about in Engineering Ease.

4:35:40 Essentially, the state is going to start taking even more money away from rural areas like ours. They're going to be going to population count-based allocation of funds. We have, correct me if I'm wrong, with 35,000 people and 4 to 6 million visitors a year, and yet the state is not going to want to take us seriously with that audience. So we are going to move forward with an idea to development a tool, a GIS tool.

4:36:08 That can link trail counters, Caltrans traffic counts, Forest Service counter data, so we can advocate back to the state to say, look, we know there's only six of us over here, but there's six million cousins coming here every summer and winter, and we think the only way they, we know the only way they get to these federal public lands is on state highway infrastructure, so we might want to be thinking about that. Very interesting conversation on that, and that's it. Thank you very much. Thank you, John.

4:36:36 As for myself, I once again have had more Zoom meetings and phone conversations than I care to note, but in the sense of brevity, there was nothing really epic or earth-shattering that needs to come forward. There is one thing, however, I did attend some of the League of California Cities conference digitally. I missed a bunch of it because of health reasons. I did get to vote for us and was very surprised at the amount of

4:37:06 Angst on that silly little proposal. It really means nothing, but it's good. One thing of positive that came out of it, and I'll try to hold this up so you can see it. Wow. From the Institute for Local Government, we won a silver award for sustainability best practices. So our little town got this beautiful award. We got this beautiful plaque, which I will give to Dan to either put in.

4:37:35 His or Sandra's office or wherever it is appropriate. But a little tiny place like us getting noticed for our good deeds in sustainability is very important for us. So this is a wonderful thing. And I wanted to just mention that moving forward. Other than that, there's really no actionable items on all the things I did. So in the anticipation of getting out of here when we can, I will cut mine short.

4:38:04 Anybody else have any report they would like to give? Sandra, Dan, Rob, Andy? I'd like to hear a report from Andy, please. Yeah, I actually have something to report. I was appointed to a League of California Cities committee representing the town. This is the Legal Advocacy Committee, which decides which lawsuits the League wants to weigh in on and support. There are four permanent members from LA, San Diego, San Jose, and San Francisco.

4:38:36 And then 12 members representing the different regions of the state. And I was approached to please, please, please, we need somebody to represent the Desert Mountain Division, which includes Mammoth. So that's me. I'm sitting in and monitoring legal developments around the state. And I'll report back if there's anything interesting. Great, Andy. Congratulations. Nice report. Okay. With that, if I see nothing else, I will adjourn this meeting to the next regularly scheduled meeting on November 4th.

4:39:09 Look forward to seeing you all then. Vote! Vote! Stay well, everyone.