TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2020

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 3 hr 56 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

464 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:20 Good afternoon. Good afternoon, everybody. Hi. Hi. Frank, you look so stoic. Smile. Testing, going okay today, Brian? Testing, yeah, I think they did about 80 today. And the vaccines went well, too. Good. Good. Good afternoon, everyone. Good afternoon. Good afternoon. Because I fear where this meeting may go.

3:56 I want you to all remember, it is the season. We're all going to be happy campers and move this thing down the road. Ho, ho, ho. Ho, ho. Let's see, do we have everybody yet? All the council is here. Yeah, well, the faces keep moving all over my screen. I'm having a hard time counting. Okay, do I have the supervisors? Frank, Stacy, Fred. John.

5:00 Jennifer's here. Jennifer. And Frank's not a supervisor. But Bob is. Is Bob going to be joining us? Bob's here. Bob's here. Okay. There he is. In that case, I will call this special joint meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council and Monoconde supervisors to order. Could we have a roll call, please? Councilmember Ray?

5:32 I see a raised hand. Councilmember Stapp, Councilmember Wentworth. Present. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Here. Mayor Salzer. Here. Supervisor Corliss. Here. Supervisor Gardner. Here. Supervisor Kreitz. Present. Supervisor Peters. I'm here. And Supervisor Stump. Here. All right. We are all here and accounting for...

6:09 Mr. Gardner, how about you leading us in the pledge this morning or this afternoon? Absolutely. Letting begin, I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, sir.

6:38 Public comments. This is the time for any member of the public wishing to comment on anything that is not otherwise on the agenda. Jamie, do we have any public comments? Yes. Mr. Maniaci, will you unmute yourself and give your comment? Yeah, I'm just looking forward to the clown show. Please continue. Thank you. Any others? No. Thank you. Okay, moving on to policy matter number one.

7:25 Mayor Sauser, there is another public comment in the room. Okay. I thought you were here to talk on an item. What's that? I thought you were going to talk on an item. Sorry. Hi, this is Brandon Borosia. Can everyone hear me? Hi, I just wanted to let everyone know that I'm on standby representing the Restaurant Association if there's any need for me to have input. Thank you. Thank you, Brandon. I will move on then to item number one.

7:59 Update and possible action on the public health declared emergency and the management response actions taken. Dan, I believe that makes you up for... Yes. Yeah. I'm sorry, somebody else just popped the screen up there from Dana Jorgensen. That should not be up yet, Dana. Yeah, our first element was do an update, and I'm not...

8:36 Sure. Dana, if you're on the call, Dana Jorgensen, you need to quit sharing your screen. Thank you. Sorry about that. Glad you're on the call. Yeah, we want to give a brief update on the situational status and where we are and the numbers and what we're looking at with the coronavirus virus currently in Town of Mammoth Lakes and Bono County. So we will walk through this. If you have questions, please.

9:08 If you can interrupt, we'll try and pause it in a couple places, but get through it, and then you can have more of a dialogue as well. As you know, a lot of different issues going on, a lot of information going out. We still continue to push on everyone to wear face coverings, appropriate mask wearing, to properly space out, distance, and then obviously up to good hand hygiene.

9:36 And also both from a state of order standpoint, local order standpoint, and just safe actions is to not have a large group together, especially if they're not in the same household. That is probably one of the most significant areas that we are seeing. Disease spread is within those gatherings of non-household members. We know there's a number of people coming at least to Mammoth Lakes and I'm assuming throughout the county to stay with friends and other elements.

10:05 Most likely that will result in spread of the coronavirus in the coming weeks. Bono County, we are looking at 546 cases. We've had four deaths now, a recent one just reported. And then you can see kind of the spread throughout the northern part of the county, 527, south 427, town of Mammoth Lakes area, 423 positive cases.

10:34 The cases are continuing to rise at a pretty good level, especially in the last 30 days. So we have seen 296 cases in that time frame. So definitely seeing that community spread, the activities going on across households. And this is impacting local businesses of all sizes, different types of businesses, public sector and others.

11:01 Or just in town visiting, showing up ill at either the hospital or other places needing medical attention. Seven-day medics, still a lot the last seven days or so, 362 people tested, so we're still getting tests done pretty well. Positive 94, 26% positivity rate. On a negative side, we have some of the best stats in the state. We're right down near the most.

11:32 Cases for 100,000 and positivity rates for bad metrics were the top three or four counties in the state. You get a feel here what's going on with our percent positive by PCR test. You kind of see the chart running up to that 25% looking back in weeks where we have good data for. There is a lag in data, so you'll see the information here.

12:00 Our public health department staff does a great job of pulling together and looking at the data, trying to line up with what the state is looking at. Positive cases, 81 this last week, and the week they're looking at theirs November 13th through the 19th, as we look back in that week. The chart here, you see each week going up that we've done since the beginning of November, their 11th.

12:28 November 8th and 14th, we started to 26, dropped to 13 one week, and then have climbed up with a little drop from the last week to this week, going from 95 to 81, but still substantial numbers for our community. Hospital status, still green, meaning they can handle any patient requiring medical assistance. The regional stay-at-home order, which is discussed in a lot more detail at a later item on the agenda.

12:57 Just a reminder of what it is, effective December 6th, so we implemented the following on the 7th. This was the state's response to projected drop in availability of adult ICU beds throughout the state. We are in the Southern California region and a lot of work in terms of why we're there and looking at ways, options for modifications there underway.

13:26 The basic order available to take a look at, it can be lifted starting the 27th or 28th effective date if a four-week projection shows that our capacity of ICU beds will be 15% or greater at that point in time. If it is, we can be lifted, and then every week it's reviewed again. If it's not lifted, every week they look at it again and say, where are you going forward?

13:56 It can be looked at at that level. We are getting daily updates regarding icing beds, availability in our region currently at 0%, along with the Central Valley at 0%, and then California has continued to drop down to 1.1%. You'll note on the chart here, and show like the greater Sacramento region just over the 15% mark. That doesn't mean they move out of the stay-at-home order.

14:26 And so they've been in that status for three weeks, and then the projections done to determine whether or not they move out of that order based on that projection. So a lot of different moving targets as we work through this. One of the most difficult things is nailing down the time frame on doing the analysis looking forward. A lot of requests from the State Department of Public Health to...

14:53 Provide that information as soon as possible. Under the order language, it would actually be done on the 27th or the 28th, which really gives us no deep time in responding. Based on that and based on statements made by the governor and also made by representatives of the Department of Public Health, I think if they read the stats right now, we would not move out of the regional stay-at-home order.

15:22 It's likely that those stats, that outlook is not going to change much. So our current review of that, based on those discussions, is that the stay-at-home order will not be lifted come the 27th, starting under a new level of the 28th. If we are lifted out, we would go back to the appropriate tier status. At this point, that would be purple.

15:52 In the state's opening tier system. At this point, the order continues to apply to the various businesses in Mono County. We have a stay-at-home order related to lodging facilities. We issued that. A lot just to clarify the state order. We've gone back and forth with information from the state for clarification as well. So at this point...

16:19 There is no relaxation of the pay-at-home order, especially if relates to lodging or other facilities such as a restaurant or outside dining. The element here would be continuing through and for a recommendation at this point, we would be recommending that reservations from Monday, December 28th going forward at least for one week would need to be canceled.

16:48 We do not see us being lifted out of that regional stay-at-home order on the 28th. And then it will be reviewed again each week, which will be extremely frustrating, as we will probably get that information on that Sunday or Monday of the next week as well. So kind of gearing up for that and working with ways to try to get some information more appropriately, but based on the current program, that may be very difficult to achieve.

17:18 We'll come back and answer questions related to this in just a moment. The limited stay-at-home order, a different one, this is the one that was referred to as a curfew that was put in place, has been extended, and it runs with the regional stay-at-home order at this point, I believe, going forward, it actually goes into the purple tier. So it'd be asking anybody who's out doing things for businesses and stuff that

17:49 They would need to cease at 10 o'clock at night and not be out until 5 in the morning. That is really for people getting together and types of activities that way. People can still go out, take a walk, do other things, but they should not have any interaction with people outside of their own household or living unit, as it may be defined there, people actually live with on a regular basis, excluding friends and family or just in town visiting each other.

18:15 The non-essential travel that we talked about is anything for tourism, recreation, other nature. There is essential travel that's allowed, defined as not just an essential worker. Some people have shown up and said, I'm in the healthcare or I'm a firefighter or police officer or something, but they're actually here on vacation, not here working. And if you're not here actually working in that essential industry, then...

18:44 You are not exempt from the limitation on travel. We have reached out to working on a number of community-first programs. The county has some programs running as well as the town. I believe the county QR program just closed a couple days ago with $30,000 in providing some grant funding out.

19:09 A business assistance program that gets placed $100,000 into that program closed yesterday for the first round underneath $400,000 availability. We're trying to get those funds out quickly by the end of the month. Based on the number of applications and available funding, an additional round will be initiated probably right after the first of the year as well to utilize the additional funding.

19:36 And then the Housing Rental Assistance Program being managed by Mammoth Lakes Housing, we put an additional $250,000 into that program and encouraging people who visit the town of Mammoth Lakes who need housing support, those funds are available and there is also some additional funding I believe is still available for those residents that need assistance in the unincorporated portion of Mono County.

20:03 Later in today's meeting, we will be recommending some additional funding for both of the two town programs as well. And that's really driven by what we're seeing by demand in those areas and the impacts that the various stay-at-home orders and other limits have had on our business community. If people are needing food, one of our concerns is that we not have food scarcity or insecurity for any family within the county.

20:34 MAKA has stepped up really great in really supporting our communities. There will be distribution in Mammoth Lakes on January 5th and 19th, 11 and 1 behind the promenade on Main Street there. It's open, this food distribution by MAKA is over countywide. You can see the contact information here as well. But if you show up between 11 and 1, January 5th and 19th,

21:03 There is a check-in process if you haven't gone in advance and done the information there. Pretty simple process, drive up distribution, and I'm glad to support our community that way. Continuing testing, week of the 28th, starting Monday. Walk through this, there's a number of different testing sites, a little limited with the holidays this week, this next week's going to be 28th, but in Mammoth Lakes and up in the Antelope Valley Community Center.

21:32 Tuesday, the Verily testing at Mammoth Lakes, Sierra Star Golf Course, and then Public Health at the community center again to town. We are looking at shifting the testing to the Edison Theater beginning Monday, January 4th. Trying to consolidate some areas there for this purpose and ultimately also the same site when we get to a vaccination program for the community.

21:59 Developing some site area there, we'd be able to do that. That'll be out of ways yet. First round of vaccination coming through to medical personnel, first responders. We do have a page up on the website, English and Spanish, if people are interested in looking at that website to offer information on the vaccination process. It is a phased program based on information out of CDC and the federal government side.

22:28 And then implementing at the state level, you kind of get a feel here on phase one, phase two, and three, et cetera, that'll work through. The timing of all of this really is based on the amount of vaccine that will be allocated and received by Mono County. But the first phase is underway with those in the high-risk healthcare personnel and those in our hospital and other medical professionals, as well as virtual responders.

22:58 And then on down there, you'll see the various categories. Again, this information is available on the website. You'll see that. The reality of vaccination, really getting through our community, most likely we're not looking at that until we get into spring and summer of this 2021 year. But it's great to see it coming forward and the vaccines coming forward and beginning to be distributed here in Mono County as well as across the country.

23:27 Business Resource Page. Take a look at this business side. The state program, I think it's $500 million in grants, is up and running. I believe they'll start taking applications shortly in January, a short turnaround for applications there. And still have our fingers crossed that the federal government may also come forward with a bill that will provide some benefit to individuals and businesses as well.

23:57 Information page here, our next community conversation, January 7 to 530. And then ongoing, we've been providing areas for people to respond to various code complaints or other types of complaints related to this or other issues in the county. And again, monocounty.com slash coronavirus provides information on elements here that we've briefly touched on here and gone through.

24:27 Sorry, a lot of data there, a lot of quick. A lot of that's on our website, but I do want to open up for questions, and I'll defer to other folks on the panel here, Dr. Wu or Frank Rivalta or one of our other staff people that they ask needed to address particular questions on kind of a status update that we're looking at at this point in time. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Okay, for questions, I'm going to go to the supervisors first, starting with Stacy.

24:59 No questions right now. Thanks. Thank you. John Peters. Yeah, I'll hold my comments or questions at this point. Thank you. Jennifer Kreitz. I just have one. I'm confused why we would allow reservations to start being booked a week after the 28th when it sounds like that stay-at-home order won't go away for three weeks easily. Yeah, all I can say is

25:32 When they do the update on the 28th, it's only extended for one week period, even though they look out four weeks. So the following weekend, they would be looking forward again. And so we just don't know. At that point, it could end up dropping back off. So it's an unknown rolling weekly analysis. We had the same question because they will tell us.

26:01 On a Sunday or a Monday, that as of that point, you can be back under the stay-at-home order or not. Not necessarily our choice, so yes. And so at that point, every week after the three weeks, they're re-evaluating it. You're really not on another three weeks. You're on a weekly re-evaluation. Is that how I understand it, right? That is correct. Okay. Thank you, Dan.

26:34 Yeah, I think Tom can speak to that as well, but I think that answers the question. Thank you. Jennifer Fred? No questions from me right now. Thank you. Thank you. Mr. Gardner? No questions. Thank you. Moving on then to Council. Linda? No, thank you. I'm fine for now. Thanks. John? No questions. Thank you. Kirk? No questions. Sarah? I think she said no questions, but she...

27:13 Took her finger off too quick. No questions. Thank you. Thank you, Sarah. And at this point, I have no questions as well. I think we'll hold public comments until the end of the presentation and take them all then, if that makes sense to all of you. So, Dan, move us on forward. The item here really is what we were looking at a lot of elements in this one was really just that status update. So unless there's a question just on the information presented.

27:46 We would be ready to move on to the next agenda item unless one of the other EOC members have comments back to the data that kind of gives us the baseline of where we're at at this point. Any other member of the EOC wishing to speak on this? Dr. Boo? Bob? Okay. I'm sorry to interrupt. Since none of them are raising their hands, I'm wondering if we could get an update from the hospital, though, on this section. Seems appropriate.

28:27 Yes, it does. Tom, would you like to? Yes. I was just taking myself off mute. I said last week in our incident management team that the phrase of the year is now, you're still on mute. That's it. Thank you for having me today. I'll just give a couple little additional points. I want to express my gratitude to the EOC, Frank, Tom, Brian, Dan, Bob.

29:03 And then to our own Dr. Craig Burroughs, who attends ELC frequently to provide that liaison role for our hospital incident management team. We've been, as most people know, we've been working at this, everybody's been working at this for quite some time. At the hospital, we've really embraced the concept of being what we call a COVID-capable facility. And what that means is that

29:31 We feel as much the need to be able to be providing a safe environment for patients who are COVID positive as those who are COVID negative. And that safety extends to our commitment to help them all recover from whatever medical condition that they're experiencing. Early in the pandemic, when there was a lot still to learn, we curtailed our elective procedures.

30:01 And we put off a lot of care. We closed down a lot of our clinics. And what we had is we had deferred medical care for a lot of our community. We do not want to do that again. And so we really embraced this concept of being COVID capable. And what I mean by that is if we go back and we look at other medical conditions that we have faced in the past, things like

30:27 Flesh eating disease or necrotizing fasciitis or AIDS. They really stressed our medical system, but we eventually got to a point where we understood them and we incorporated them into all the rest of the medical care that we provide. That is what we are priding ourselves on and are part of the goals for our hospital incident management team is to continue to provide care for people regardless of their COVID status.

30:55 I can say that our inpatient caseload for COVID-positive patients has been extremely low. We've been consistently in green through the pandemic. What we're not seeing is we're not seeing that kind of conversion rate that we're seeing in other communities. We don't know yet the science behind that or the epidemiology behind that.

31:23 There have been people opining on whether or not it's altitude or is it that we have a baseline of a healthy population that helps us not have a higher conversion rate. That means conversion of those who test positive to needing inpatient care. And so while we don't quite understand the mechanism of that, we are fortunate in that our hospital is not one of those that is currently

31:49 Overrun with patients who required inpatient care for COVID treatment. Just to remind everybody that part of the infrastructure of medical care here is transfer. We do rely on our transfer partners, our primary transfer partners being in Reno. And we just yesterday had a conference call, we being a number of other hospitals that depend upon

32:19 Renown Hospital for Transfers. There was a conference call that Renown put together for all of us to help us understand where they are. We continue to be able to transfer patients to Reno on a case-by-case basis. They have not issued a blanket yes or a blanket no. What they're saying to the referring hospitals is let's talk about every case as it comes up and we'll do our best to accommodate that. We thus far have been able to transfer patients and in fact we

32:48 This was a patient with other conditions, but able to transfer a patient just this week. One of the things that we learned in that call is that the renal hospitals are depending upon us to do as much as we can to bring patients back after they have completed their course of care.

33:11 They currently have at Renown Hospital approximately 100 patients that are awaiting repatriation to their home communities and to their home medical centers if they are not ready for full discharge. So we're working with them on that. What we've expressed to them is that repatriation for people who are dealing with what is primarily a respiratory condition

33:41 And having people come back to 8,000 feet is a challenge. And so they, in fact, Craig Burroughs was on the call and he expressed that to them and they will be working with us on that, recognizing that unique challenge. We've discussed in our hospital incident management team the issue of the stay-at-home order and as well the color code system. At this time, we're comfortable with being on purple if that's where we go.

34:10 That's something that our team has talked about. And again, we're not going to resist or we're not going to express concern if we're on Purple. We feel today that we are doing well in providing the care that's needed for our community. So that's an update on where things stand at the hospital. We continue to be

34:39 Well-staffed and well-supplied. As mentioned, there are no businesses probably in town that are unaffected by their employees contracting the virus, and we're the same, but we're able to continue our operations despite that. We stand ready to be able to stand up our employee pools again as needed and move people around in the facility in order to respond to any increases again.

35:08 Thank you, Tom. Do we have any questions for Tom? In this case, I'll just let you go and ask the questions instead of running through us all. Any hands? Seeing none. Dan, Jennifer? Yeah, this is...

35:37 Jennifer Kreitz. I have one question. I wonder, Tom, if you as a hospital administrator were involved at all with the state's delineation of the regions? I was not. Okay. Yeah, thanks for the question. Thanks. You know, Tom, I'm going to throw a question out there as well. If all of a sudden Renown could not take our patients and we could not move them, say that it happened two weeks ago, where it would be sitting now, would we still be in the green?

36:07 Patients do have moved us. We'd still be in green given the limited number of patients that we have asked them to take for us. Okay. And Bill, as the conversation goes forward, if the topic turns to masking, I would like to weigh in at that point, but I'll save that for later in the meeting. Well, this is our update.

36:35 So this would probably be the time to do that. Our next discussion point on COVID is going to be when we get to the Chamber of Commerce's position. And I imagine there will be a great deal of discussion about how we all feel we should go forward then. But in terms of masking, I think this would be the appropriate time. Well, I'm going to shift from representing the hospital incident management team and the hospital to just expressing, since I got this opportunity, that

37:04 You know, there are a number of ways that we can try to affect the flattening of the curve. And we've long said in our innocent management team, and we've said it in the EOC, and everybody has agreed, you know, it's mass distance and wash. And I'd just like to see us put more emphasis in the county and in the town of Mammoth Lakes on potentially enforcing mass, not with...

37:32 People in shackles, but just more encouragement of our mask policy. We have a mask ordinance, whether that be law enforcement, just getting out of the car and encouraging people. Somebody in a uniform has a lot more power than I do. If I get out of the car and I go talk to somebody and say, hey, wouldn't it be great if you put a mask on? And I'm just asking for that next level of encouragement, of compliance.

38:01 I have to tell you, most of what I see in town is great, but occasionally, you know, I see people gather on the street in bus stops, and they're not masked, and I think, oh my gosh, you know, how are we going to get over this if not everybody is doing that one thing that studies have shown, and Dan's slide showed it. If we were consistently masking, we would reduce spread by 80%, and I think that we're, I think it's low-hanging fruit for us, and I think we need to go after it.

38:30 Thanks for letting me have another minute. No problem. Thank you. I appreciate you getting that out to the public. So I will ask if there are any public comments on this item, this item being just the presentation, not the opening and closing of businesses, because we will get to that in item three. Jamie? Seth Maniaci, will you unmute yourself and give your comments? I'm not sure you guys are calling. Are you guys asking for me?

39:09 Yeah, Seth, you're up. Go ahead. All right, thank you. Thank you, Mayor. Thank you guys for having me on the call. I really appreciate the time. The PCR test and the manufacturer, Kerry Mullis, said before his passing in August of 2019 that the PCR test was not to be used for diagnosis of infectious diseases. Another point is my permission slipped to leave the house.

39:39 Are my existing inalienable rights written on ink? It's called the Constitution. So as for me and many of the public members of Mono County and Mammoth Lakes, I will not be a victim and I will not live in fear because fear is the currency of control. And there's not a single individual in this town that's going to tell me how to live my life. I won't be wearing a mask.

40:10 With a 99.97% survival rate, I'll take my chances. Thank you for having me. I'll be here for a while. Thank you, Seth. Any other comments on this portion? Villager, will you unmute yourself and give your comments? Hi, can everyone hear me? Yes. Okay. It might not be the appropriate category to ask this question, but I want to address the fact that vaccines are out there. I have...

40:47 People are getting the vaccines and they're questioning, if I got the vaccine, can I come out here to Mono County? So how do we address that question specifically? Thank you. Dr. Poo, would you like to take how long it takes for the effectiveness of the vaccine and all of that so people can understand it? Sure, sure, sure, Mayor Sauser. You know, it takes, you know, it's a two...

41:21 It's a two-dose vaccine, so nobody in the United States is fully vaccinated except for those people who participated in the initial trials. But the state order is the state order, and essential travel is prohibited. And there's some serious, really important questions still to be answered about the vaccine. We know that the Pfizer and the Moderna vaccines, the two that are on the market right now,

41:50 Extremely effective at preventing illness and keeping us well and keeping us out of the hospital, but we really don't have data yet on whether it's still possible. Like with some vaccines, even if you're vaccinated and the pertussis vaccine comes to mind, you can still get infected and give it to other people. And they simply did not study that yet with these vaccines. There's some very

42:17 You know, intensive efforts to try to understand that question now because it's going to be really important in terms of, you know, understanding, you know, what to expect in terms of the vaccine's ability to truly end the pandemic. So, you know, I've also been fortunate enough to receive my first dose of the vaccine as part of the medical staff at Northern Indian Hospital and all of us are going to continue distancing, masking and exercising the same.

42:46 for causes that we have been until we have a lot more evidence. So no, it doesn't change anything from a travel point of view. Yeah, and correct me if I'm wrong here, but in the information I've read, the Moderna vaccine, you wait four weeks between doses, and after the second dose, there's still a two-week window that you're potentially still able to get it. So it would be six weeks from the first, and no one in California has had it for that long. The vaccine hasn't been out that long.

43:18 Would that be correct? Yes. Yes. Thank you. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Jamie. Matthew Desario, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, Bill. I had a quick question. I don't know if this is the appropriate time, but I noticed, I was reading the agenda, and I know that there seems to be some plea from various business organizations about, I guess, in a simple way, just ignoring the mandates from the state.

43:53 And my question is more a practical one. And I think this will probably be more of a heated debate later on. But is there any mechanism for a county or a town to oppose or not follow the guidelines or orders from the governor? You know, because I think it might be helpful for all of us to understand that maybe the council's hands are completely tied. Maybe there is some law or mechanism that really sort of directs public health officer booze directives.

44:23 And your directives, et cetera. I all know that we're looking and we're, you know, there's many business owners that are desperate. I'm one of them for some relief and to be able to open up the lodging facilities. But I guess my question is, is there even a mechanism, even if the board or the council wanted to do something, is sort of the way that state and local governments are set up that we can't really, there is really no mechanism? You know, Stacey, I don't know that you're not the best to answer that from the legal perspective. Sure.

44:55 And I thought I saw Andy Morris was on as well. So we don't want to. Oh, yes. Great. We can tag team it. Andy, did you want to go first? Well, I'm aware that there have been a few cities that have simply said we are not going to enforce these orders. The first one was the city of Atwater, which is in Merced County. That was back in May. More recently, Solving adopted a resolution. Paso Robles adopted a resolution.

45:26 There have been a few counties like El Dorado County that have adopted purely symbolic resolution saying that we think that locals are the best people to determine how to handle dealing with COVID. So when Atwater announced bravely and proudly that they were just going to ignore everything the state did, the state immediately said they were not eligible for any CARES Act funding, indicated they would claw back any CARES Act funding they'd already gotten.

45:52 And then the state sent about four or five different state agencies to Outwater to start threatening to revoke business licenses. So is there a way? Well, on some level, sure. I mean, the town or the county could just say, yeah, we're not going to enforce any of this. That doesn't mean that it's legal. It doesn't mean that there wouldn't be pretty significant consequences for doing that. But it has been done in a couple of places. There's not a legal mechanism to do it.

46:19 There's just a way of saying we don't care what the orders are. We're not going to follow. The only thing I would add to that, I think that's a great summary and explanation, is that with respect to the health officer in particular and other designated officials in local government, state law actually mandates them to enforce and carry out the state public health orders and related orders pertaining to COVID-19.

46:49 And any other infectious disease. Thank you, guys. And there are some statutes in the Health and Safety Code that would appear to require everyone to comply with the state order. So there would be, I mean, this is a little bit esoteric, but it's probable that a jurisdiction that just says we don't care, we don't think it's valid, probably is itself violating the law. And I will say that just in general,

47:17 Under our system of government, it is simply not the responsibility of cities and counties to decide when something is legal or when something is not legal. That's for the court system to decide. So it's not typical that a city or a county would look at a law, or in this case, an order, and say, well, we just don't think that one's valid, because that's simply not our role. Thank you, Andy. There is case law confirming that we cannot pick and choose which state laws we...

47:49 Think are legal or not. Only a court can declare a state law unconstitutional or invalid. Okay. Moving on from that, do we have any other public comments in this period? Bita Klein, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Sure. I'm a BRBO homeowner and I guess I want to understand. Okay, so I understand the whole state law and all this. Riverside.

48:24 County, Orange County are not doing what Mono is doing. And I guess my big question is why the big huge hammer in Mono County where you could lose your rental license and you could walk, you know, obviously I'm not renting, otherwise I wouldn't be on this call. But what is the huge hammer? Why is it I'm, you know, I'm being told a thousand a night?

48:53 Are those things legal? Is that, is that precedent before? Is that, is that not going to cause any issues for Mono County? You know, if, if some, some lawyer gets hold of this and starts a class action on behalf of our renters that are losing a ton of money right now, Mono should look at that. I'm not all for suing anyone.

49:19 I hate lawsuits. Sorry, lawyers out there. I hate lawsuits. But you know what? I'm just seeing this huge hammer over my head and going, oh, my God, I got to just hide away until February or March. But what's this all about? And then I go on and I'm looking on my other screen, a huge number of people skiing, huge number of people in the village all the time. You know, it doesn't make sense. Obviously, they're not afraid of the

49:48 The hammer or they got something planned. And you can't tell me they're all driving back and forth because they're not. I've canceled all my reservations in December. And, you know, to me, it's like, OK, I understand what the state is saying, but the state is not saying you can't rent your home. That's not what they're saying. If I'm abiding by it, I have a professional cleaning company come through. I have the 24 hours in between renters.

50:19 The cleaner goes in between. They're wearing PPP. Nobody comes into my house without PPP. If any renters don't want anyone there, I've been breaking my back for Mono County Robles, but this one is just getting too much. It's just getting too much. And I totally appreciate what all of you guys are doing. Everything. I mean, I understand how hard it is for you, but at the same time.

50:47 Come on, guys. This is United States of America. You know, that's my property. If I have, you know, I have a high rental property. My renters don't come in without masks. My renters are very worried about COVID. I know not everybody in Mono is, you know, there are, you know, 19-year-olds running around without masks and everything. That's not my renters. But the thing is, like, what you guys are doing,

51:15 With this huge hammer of a thousand a night, if anyone runs, huge hammer of... If you could please wrap up your comments. Yeah, that's it. I mean, it just seems illegal, the amount of, you know, rules that are out there at this point. That's it. This is Stacey Simon, Mono County Council. If I may clarify a couple of the points made by the commenter. Please.

51:46 So I just wanted to address the comment that the state order does not prohibit the renting of individual homes for short-term use. It actually does. That is from the state order. It was ambiguous at first. I know one jurisdiction interpreted it otherwise. That was Bear Valley. They have since been corrected and have retracted that statement. So this is a state order that...

52:13 The county's fines are different from the town's fines. I think you may be referencing the town's fines. Thank you, Stacey.

52:45 Jamie, do we have anyone else on this particular subject? Terry Stellick, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Terry Stellick? Evidently, Terry's having some issues. Can we go on to the next? We've received several emails, so I'm going to read some of the emails, Mayor Sauser.

53:29 Jackie Dobson says, what would happen if the majority of businesses in town just opened regardless of the closure? I would think that the business owners should weigh this decision and the business owners should make this choice. The people who want to quarantine can quarantine. If they do not want to go to the restaurants, they do not have to. Everyone who wants to go can. Regardless which side you want, everyone should wear masks. This is a given. Natalie Simmons says, how many homeowners $1,000 fines have been assessed for violations of the short-term rental order?

53:59 Also, how many licenses suspended? Is there any provision for owners of short-term rentals to be reimbursed for lost income due to cancellations imposed?

54:09 Caroline Pierce says, Hi, I'm trying to understand what the rules are so inconsistent in our region. It is my understanding that Big Bear is allowing rentals so long as it is a single household. Not being able to rent during the season is going to devastate me financially after four months of previous lockdowns and two months impacted by the fires.

54:30 Jeff Posey says, if we allow 40,000 people into town over Christmas, will we be allowed to play adult hockey? Seems to me having 20 hockey players on the outdoor ice rink is much safer than the 100 you allow for public skating, 10,000 skiers on the mountain, and 40,000 tourists in our town. Lauren Tracy says, dear City Council, we are property managers of Mammoth. We are requesting a partial reopening of Mammoth's nightly lodging on December 28th.

54:59 Currently, we would like to address the large black market lodging issue going on in Mammoth first. We do have a large bed base. I believe I have the support of the rest of the nightly rental community here in Mammoth in my proposal for a 25% monthly occupancy opening on the 28th.

55:16 Thank you for your consideration. J-A-O-J-A-F-O-S-C

55:48 Ue at gmail.com says, I find it unfair that Mammoth Mountain allows people to sit outside at their lodges, but restaurants in town aren't allowed to. The mountain has disabled their cameras at the lodges so you can't see their decks full of people. The only cameras you can use are top of the mountain in the village. Also, having the mountain open is bringing people up here even though there is a stay-at-home order.

56:09 Matt Davison says,

56:36 Memo advocating for the termination of the stay-at-home order have been double or triple counted. Seaver Example Lock and Nookie, Lana Altieri-Need and Stuart Need, Mammoth Brewing Company, Dionne Aggie and Sean Turner, Black Tie Skis, Colin Fermi and Jeremy Goico, Mammoth Tavern, Jessica Manning, Patty Manning and Carrie Meckler, The Laundry Annex, Lou and Mark Margulies, and Austria Hoff, Shelby and Joseph Mueller, to name a few. This is misleading and falsely inflates the number of...

57:03 Please reference as a basis for this selfish argument. We need to consider the health and safety of all community members in this decision, not just those with business interests, loud voices, and inherent biases that go against the common good of the community. Lee Dugan says, I am a resident of the town of Mammoth Lakes and county of Mono and writing to express my opposition to the petition submitted by the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. The premise of the position is that the Mono County and Mammoth Lakes become business communities.

57:30 Will not survive if the order is extended beyond December 27th. The petition asserts that the business community has been absolutely diligent in following the coronavirus protocols. While masks are required of businesses in Mono County, I would argue that the latter statement is a subjective evaluation. What I observe is that most people do not wear masks in public, in parking lots or on sidewalk, at the gas stations or on trails. I would argue that compliance at local supermarket...

57:54 Thank you.

58:13 Thriving Tourist Industries. I am unclear why Mono County should be afforded special consideration simply because it relies on tourism. I am reminded that during 2019, Mono County supervisors did not approve a cannabis cultivation permit, which would have diversified and expanded the Mono County economy. Finally, I do not understand the wisdom of the action proposed by the Chamber of Commerce. Mono County cases continue to increase exponentially. According to COVID

58:36 .ca.gov. Mono County has a 14.7 positivity rate and 95.2 new COVID cases per day per 100,000. I express my grave concern that if you take actions to open the town and county prematurely, we will pay with increased death and infection of our community. I am strenuously oppose any such action. And that is all the public comments, Mayor. Thank you, Jamie. With that, let's move on to item number two, support for SB 74.

59:07 Burgess and Caballero, related COVID-19 appropriation to assist small businesses. Dan, I'm assuming you're leading us off here. Yeah, I'll lead it off, and then we do have Dana Jorgensen, representative of the senator's office, to speak to us as well. We did want to bring this forward as one of the requests from our community has come up several times to support the state action or to ask the state to take action to provide a relief funding for local businesses.

59:37 This bill does that. It's currently been introduced $2.6 billion in grant programs for small businesses. A lot of details, I'm sure, to go with that in terms of the process and stuff, but the Office of Small Business Advocates would be there to pursue that. If it is passed, it would be effective immediately. It is looking at utilizing a portion of the...

1:00:02 State surplus in their budget to be able to do that. So given this just came up recently, we wanted to make sure it got in front of the council and the board of supervisors. We're recommending support of the bill as it addresses at least in part that request to provide additional funding support for businesses impacted through the COVID.

1:00:26 Hi, can you hear me? Yes. So one of the things about this bill that is exciting, it's a very bipartisan bill.

1:00:59 We have many, many members. About a third of the 120 legislators are supporting this. They're co-sponsors already. That is somewhat rare, and I think it bodes well for the passage of this bill. One of the interesting things about how our taxation system is set up in California, when people that are doing pretty well do very well,

1:01:28 We get a lot of money in California. And that is due to the stock market and a lot of conditions actually occurring. It's somewhat surprising. But it is a nice gift. And I think it is very appropriate. And Senator Board just thinks it's appropriate to share this to keep everybody going. We can all get through this.

1:01:56 It's probably going to be rough, I would guess, for the next three months to maybe six months. If we can all get everybody to keep their businesses going and keep people employed and the vaccine out there by June 1st or so, we can kind of pivot from this and start going forward.

1:02:21 So there are some, this is just one thing that we're doing to try to get through this. I have spent basically the last nine months helping people with unemployment claims. It's been very difficult. I've talked to a lot of people, a lot of young folks that have come to Mammoth, and they're stuck.

1:02:52 And some of them flee back to their parents' homes. These are very young people, most of them. And it's just been very difficult for them. But it's very satisfying when they, when we finally get them approved and they get those funds. And all of these people really need it. I have done this forever. It's the only job I've ever had. This has been the most difficult year.

1:03:21 I think one thing I want to add is I'm very impressed.

1:03:52 By this cohort that you have here, I do not see this in our other counties. You guys are very organized and that serves you very well. So I think that's all for now. I will open it up to comments. Let's start this time with counsel, Linda. No, I have no questions right now, but I'm also in support of this bill. Thank you. Thank you, John.

1:04:30 I don't have any questions. I've reviewed the legislation. I think it makes a lot of sense. I look forward to hearing any comments from the supervisors, my fellow town council members and public comment. But yeah, obviously quite supportive. Thank you. Kirk, okay. I'm supporting. Sarah, I can't hear you yet. Comments, thank you. Thank you. I support this as well. Any aid we can give our small businesses at this point is not just crucial.

1:05:29 I support this effort and really appreciate, Dana, you taking the time to be on here today and thank you for all your work to help our residents through the EDD nightmare that Californians are experiencing. Just one question, Bill. Are you looking for a motion to approve town and county support? Yes. Once I got through everybody, I was going to ask our legal counsel.

1:06:03 Whether this needs to be two motions or whether it can be one motion that the 10 of us vote on. Yeah. If you were confident that we could just go ahead and do it, I was going to make a motion. But I'll wait. This is Stacey. I wasn't sure if there was public comment on this item before. Yeah, I will ask for public comment. Let me get through the supervisor, Stacey, and then I'll come back to you for a question. Yeah.

1:06:40 Support this. It's a no-brainer. We need to continue to advocate for financial relief in any and all means available to us. So, yes. Thank you. No, I support this. I'd support a letter from the two bodies on one letter or two, whichever way is most legal, obviously. County Council Simon for that direction.

1:07:14 Thank you. Thank you, Jennifer. I support it as well. I think Supervisor Peters' comments reflect my views. Thank you. Yeah, I'm supportive. Let's do this. Do we have any public comment on this item, Jamie? Yes. Jackie Johnson, please unmute yourself and give your comments. I was just wondering why if, sorry, if businesses

1:07:55 If businesses are allowed to open, we won't need the free grants. We won't need the free money. We'll be able to support ourselves and keep everyone employed. The people who want to stay home, the people who are worried about coronavirus, the people who are at high risk, they can stay home. They don't have to go to work. Maybe the businesses can not penalize those people, maintain their jobs for them when they're comfortable coming back to work. But everyone else who...

1:08:21 Feels confident wearing a mask and going to restaurants and shopping and recreating can continue to do so. I don't know why we all have to be dictated by this decision that really should be a personal decision. So those are my comments. Thank you. Thank you, Jackie. Do we have any other public comments, Jamie? Seth Maniaci, will you unmute yourself and give your comments? Yeah, these funds are a slap in the face.

1:08:54 To the business owners in this town. And the majority of you are straight up tyrants. And I hope this money makes you feel real good about what you're doing right now. Because you are on the wrong side of history. And the fact that how you behave outside of these meetings and how you try to infiltrate FITUS red pill on Facebook without talking to them.

1:09:24 How some of your actions have been very covert and the complete opposite of transparent. It's a disgrace how you treat your citizenry. And I'm just getting started in this town. My name is Fidus Red Pill on Facebook. I'm known as The Mechanic on revolution.radiofreedomslips.com. You can also find me in town. I'm that dude with the beard challenging mandates head on as my constitution allows me to.

1:09:55 I stand for the Constitution. My playbook is the Bill of Rights, and anybody who wants to join me this Saturday, 11 o'clock, we'll be marching on this town, as we will every other Saturday. You people are near criminal. You've got a real problem. Thank you. Thank you, Seth. Any further public comments? Michelle, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hi, how are you guys? I don't, can you hear me okay? Yes.

1:10:30 Okay, great. Thank you. My comment would be to the gentleman who just gave the presentation about the bill, and I have no problem, and I appreciate if we can get everybody taken care of. The problem I have is his comment was if we can just keep businesses going and people employed till June. That was the context of what he said. There's no way that's going to happen till June. These people are going to stay on.

1:11:00 Stay employed. I think there's an issue there. I think we need to really work on if we're going to get help, we need to get it and we need to get these people taken care of before June. And my comment about lodging, quite honestly, is that booking.com is booking rooms for skiers in Bishop. And I have people call me back and say, oh, I got a room in Bishop. Why can't I have a room there? So I think that if we're going to look at

1:11:29 The fairness, we need to look at all the fairness, including both counties, because it's not fair the way it's being played out now. Thank you for your work. Thank you, Michelle. Any other comments on this item, Jamie? Yes. Bitta Klein, will you unmute yourself and give your comments? Yeah, I, basically I don't want a government handout. I just want to be able to rent my place and that will allow me to

1:12:00 Have my housekeeper work, have my electrician work, have all the craft people that come into my house work. But what you guys, what this is doing, it's making me more dependent on the government, which I don't want to do. So I don't agree with this kind of thing. I don't apply for it. I don't do anything. I just try to wait it out. And you know, the Facebook page made us

1:12:29 Think that there was actually going to be discussion of opening Mammoth again? But that's not what this is. What the gentleman, Dan Holler, said in his opening statement, it's already decided. I don't know why we're on this call. If you guys have already decided you're going to just keep doing things as it is and there's no discussion, there's nothing we can do, I'm not sure why we're all on this call, why there was all this hoopla about this call when there's...

1:12:58 There's no decision to be made. You guys are just saying, come over and get EDD money. Come over and get government grants. I don't want all that. I just want to work. I don't want to be on Facebook calls. I don't want to be on Zoom calls. I just want to work. I want to deal with my renters. I want to deal with my housekeeper. That's it. Thank you. Thank you, Rita. Anything else, Jamie? Yes. Aaron, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Aaron?

1:13:38 Okay, Whitney McCoy, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Yes. Hi there, are you able to hear me? Yes. Are you able to hear me? Okay. So I have to agree with the previous commenter about just kind of how frustrating it is that this meeting was presented as something that...

1:13:58 Where we would be able to offer public comment and we would get responses on that. And so far, you've listened to us, but there's been no response from the board regarding the citizens' concerns. And as a business owner, two businesses actually in June Lake were suffering. And while we are grateful for grants and other things and the government helping us, what we really need is to be able to reopen. And I'm one that I wear a mask when I'm out and about.

1:14:26 We're completely okay with that. We've done everything we're supposed to do. All of the mandates that have come down, all of the new rules and regulations that have come down from the county and from the government regarding allowing hotels to be open, we have complied. We have completely complied. And I guess going back to Mr. Parker's comments about the hospital transferring to Reno, I would really love if we could not be included in SoCal.

1:14:53 We do not transfer people to LA. They always go to Reno. I have had my kids who at the hospital in Mammoth who had to get transferred and they always call Reno first and they always call Sacramento or Stanford area and then the last resort is LA. So I would really love it if the board would put effort into getting the governor or whoever is in charge of deciding which counties are in which section.

1:15:19 If Mono County could not be with Southern California, that is simply not where our patients are transferred to. I've experienced it myself. And so I think that's the biggest thing. And also just getting some response from, you know, direct response from the board as far as all the comments. You know, it's just, oh, next comment, next comment. No one, none of you have answered any of the questions. And I think it is just really frustrating as the previous caller stated.

1:15:45 And so, yeah, as a business owner, and I think I speak for many, especially the hotels in the area, if we've done everything we're supposed to, we have complied at every single email and request, we're still being punished. And it's not fair. And I think that most of us feel as though we're not being heard. You know, you're listening, you're taking it in, but there's no response. There's no...

1:16:10 There's no action being taken, I feel, and that's my comment on basically everything, so thank you. Brittany, thank you. Natalie Simmons, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Can you hear me? Yes, Natalie, thank you. Hi, yeah, I own a rental property up there. I've taken it off of Airbnb and, you know.

1:16:37 I'm complying with your rules, but I would like to know, and I did ask this question earlier and I didn't get an answer, is how many homeowners that are violating these rules have been fined that $1,000 a day and how many have had their licenses revoked because on social media I'm reading that there are people staying up there and they're not homeowners. And I would like an answer to that question, please. Dan, do you have an answer for her or is Rob on the call?

1:17:13 Yeah, I do not have those numbers off the top of my head. I know we've issued citations. I do not know how many off the top of my head, but we can track that down while we're meeting. Thank you. And you will all be hearing more about this, I'm sure, in the next agenda item. So hold your powder. Will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? If I'm live again, I'll take it. And for those of you who don't know, there is a... Will you please give your comments? Oh, yes, absolutely. Sorry about this. I'm on a bad computer.

1:17:54 I just wanted to let people know that you're listening to public comments. You really can't comment. You can't engage in conversation. You just have to listen to people. And I just want to thank everybody for doing such a great job because I know you're hearing from a lot of different sectors in the community. And I just really appreciate all that you're doing. So thank you very much. Thank you, Cleland. Anyone else? Jamie?

1:18:28 That's all. Okay. So at this point, Stacey, well, first I would like to know from one of the attorneys, can we do this as one motion since this is a joint meeting? So we do both believe that you can do that. The only concern would be if we had some kind of a split vote, in which case we'd want to separate out the two agencies so that we'd have good data for each.

1:19:05 Thank you, Stacey. I don't see any danger of that at this moment. Stacey, you wanted to make the motion a while ago, so I'm coming back to you now. Sure, yeah, and I did sense consensus among board and council, so I would move that both Mono County and the Town of Mammoth Lakes take a support position on SB 74. Did I get the bill number right? Yes, yes.

1:19:36 I have a motion. Can I get a second? I'll second. Okay. I have a motion from Supervisor Corliss and a second from Councilmember Wentworth. Any further deliberation? Just a clarification. Are we giving direction to our staff to compose a letter to let the authors know our support? So the recommended motion, Stacey, and I'm assuming this is what you made.

1:20:08 Was to authorize the Mayor and Chair to sign a joint letter in support of Senate Bill 74, providing the appropriation of $2.6 billion in funding to support small businesses. Good, thank you. I didn't have, yeah, you read it, people know what we're going to do. Thank you, Mayor. And that is consistent with my second, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. Any further deliberation? I was just going to note, Mr.

1:20:40 Mayor, you know, to the caller's question that open meeting laws require us to follow agendas and stay on topic and handle public comments in certain ways. So we thank everyone for their patience. Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Supervisor Corliss?

1:21:16 Yes. Supervisor Gardner. Yes. Supervisor Kreitz. Yes. Supervisor Peters. Yes. Supervisor Stump. Yes. All right. It passes 10-0. Thank you all for that. And I look forward to signing it. Moving on. Item number three. Discussion and possible action related to the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce's Restaurant and Lodging Association petition.

1:21:50 regarding termination of regional stay-at-home order. Dan, you want to start this off? Yeah, kick it off, and then we can submit some of the representatives from the Lodging Association, Restaurant Association, are here to express their concerns and recommendations as well. As been mentioned throughout the previous comments, that one of the concerns

1:22:19 That our businesses are facing is the imposition of the stay-at-home order as it applies to the Southern California region of counties and in particular in Mono County. The chamber has drafted a letter to us on a number of details there. I'm not going to read through that. It was provided in the pack of information for the elected officials and out to the community. Then they have the...

1:22:45 Petition itself with the various businesses listed and noted there a large number of businesses and representing a large number of employees. The items before the council based on public comment and others. At a minimum, we can make recommendations up to the state officials regarding the effectiveness and the status of the stay-at-home orders. We can continue to advocate for modifications to the regional assignment.

1:23:15 And that those various elements are impacting our businesses, et cetera. While not necessarily recommended, the bodies could make a decision to say, great, we understand all of the orders, we understand all the regional elements of the state, all businesses are required to follow that. And as a few other communities have done, they've just chosen not to

1:23:45 We're concerned on that mainly because of the spread of the disease we see in our community in the earlier presentation, just a number of positive cases going on.

1:24:06 And the impact that ultimately has on our businesses and our employees and other people in the community as well. So there's a balancing act through all that stuff, but I think we do want to hear from the businesses, their recommendations, their ask, and that we can respond accordingly with various elements that we can do within a legal framework and be able to move from there. A lot of the orders we have in place are not local town or county orders.

1:24:34 But really either the clarification side of it or directly from the state. So based on that, glad to answer questions from the town side, but I'm sorry, I'm not sure who from the chamber associations are ready to speak to the petition and their request from that part of it. So we can take some questions first if there's representatives to speak to the items and they should do so and back to the public discussion.

1:25:03 Well, we had Brandon Brocia on earlier. He was in Sweet Z, I believe. Brandon, did you want to speak to the intent of this? Yeah, I'd love to, Bill. Thank you. You know, the cover letter that you guys all got attached to that petition really spells out the intent. And I think the petition is a

1:25:35 And I think that what we are frustrated with as a community is we don't see a lot of avenues out. We don't see a lot of opportunity to get ourselves through this. Hope,

1:26:05 For bills and things to happen in Congress is not a business plan. We don't operate on hope. We operate on the fact that we have great teams of people that we've employed for years that are going away. We operate on the fact that we put a business plan together in a COVID crisis that executed well and we operated under those plans very well. We hope

1:26:36 That you guys take this petition and the cover letter that's attached and see the real message here. We do not want to go rogue. That comment has been said. That is not the intent of the petition. The intent of the petition is to really reach out to you all individually and let you know how dire this we are getting to. We are getting to a critical point.

1:27:05 Our community, we are a tourist-based community. We have tourism up here right now. But as businesses, we are not allowed to function with that tourist activity. Without us keeping our teams employed, without us being able to do our business like we know we can do, we are being forced into a position where we have to make

1:27:36 Really drastic decisions. I've never thought in a million years I'd be talking a couple days before Christmas about how I might have to close one of my businesses. That's what that same conversations out there in our community right now. I'm going to sit back and listen to the other comments. I'd love to hear from the Lodging Association. And I know you're going to hear from a lot of frustrated people out there. I think when it comes down to it,

1:28:09 Guys, we're talking about these are our neighbors, these are our family members, these are our teams. We've worked in this community for so long building what we have stone by stone, brick by brick, and it's coming down. We just need help. That's all we're asking for. We can't rely on hope for funding. We can't rely on hope that our situation will get so drastic that someone will bail us out. We want to put...

1:28:39 A plan in place where we can do the hard work, do it responsibly, and get back to business. Thank you. Thank you, Brandon. John Morris, I don't know if you're on or not. Would you like to make a quick comment from the lodging? Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. I greatly appreciate it. Good evening, folks. John Morris, Chairman of the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association.

1:29:08 Yeah, just echoing Brandon's comments, I mean, I don't think we need to beat this thing up from individual bullet points more than we already have. The bottom line is that our business closures and our layoffs are going to increase the chance for our unemployed and underemployed folks to gather, to spread COVID. It's causing mental and financial strain on our business owners. It's going to lead very shortly to an every business for themselves mentality in town.

1:29:38 Which is really unfortunate. I'm just very fearful that we're going to start to further rip the town apart, hitting business owner against business owner. Someone may choose to open, someone may choose to not. People ratting on each other. Meanwhile, what we're seeing is our neighbors to the south completely ignoring the order. Some people are staying down in Bishop and coming up here to go skiing.

1:30:04 I've been fortunate enough to have my daughter home for a couple days and I've done some skiing and there's tons of people up there and they are not second homeowners. So the stay at home order basically in my opinion and in the opinion of the restaurant association, the chamber folks and the lodging association is simply not working. It is not keeping people at home. They are traveling and it is also forcing people into illegal rentals who may or may not be enforcing.

1:30:33 The single household rules or employing any of the COVID protocols that all of the legal lodging communities have been doing for months. Many of us have spent tens of thousands of dollars in compliance with COVID mandates and can do things extremely safely and have control over the way that we manage our businesses. And we're just asking for us to be able to do that. I don't believe it was actually said in the order, excuse me, in the petition.

1:31:03 But basically what we're asking for is to be allowed to go back into the purple tier and be able to operate within all of those constraints. We feel we can do that and not greatly impact the further impact COVID situation. I will remain on the call if you guys have any questions. And I just want to say I know you guys are all in a very difficult position with this ask. We understand that and we just hope to understand our position as well. So thank you very much for your time.

1:31:33 Thank you, John. That being said, I will move into comments from, let's start with supervisors first, Bob Gardner. And Bob, well, I realize this doesn't affect what you can. It would be helpful to hear from the director, in my opinion, from Ken Brangle, the director of the Chamber of Commerce, and to review what exactly it is they're asking us, because.

1:32:05 There were two different documents that have been out in the community. One was basically a cover letter that went out with a petition last Friday. And then what I would call the statement from the Chamber of Commerce and Associated Entities that was sent to us yesterday that really went into more detail about their exact position and what they're asking us. And I think it would be beneficial to review that a little bit more. Ken, are you on the call? Yes, I am.

1:32:38 There you go. You want to speak to that? Yeah, I appreciate it. Thank you, Supervisor Corliss. You know, this, and I think you could tell by listening to Brandon and to John, the frustration and I would say the fear that is permeating throughout the business community. When you make between

1:33:05 You know, 25 to 40 percent of your revenues over the next six weeks and you have zero coming in. It does get kind of scary when you're looking in the mirror trying to figure out how you're going to survive this. So I want to I really do want to thank Brandon and John for really putting together the restaurant and lodging association and trying to move forward. When we.

1:33:33 looked at the petition, the chamber board at its meeting, we had a special meeting Tuesday, or Monday or Tuesday, whenever it was, they're all running together now. We felt we had to be more definitive, and that's the cover letter that you saw, that we are really talking that we are asking and trying to provide support to you as the county supervisors.

1:34:00 And as our town council, as our administrative leadership throughout the town and county, that to go to the state and try to do whatever we can to move, maybe in a different region, hopefully have to stay at home order, be lifted so that we could go back to the purple. I think if you remember the statement of concern that came out from the Restaurant Association was,

1:34:30 Really hoping that we could go from purple back to red. Well, I tell you right now, we would love to go back to purple because right now there's just, you know, no economic engine driving our economy right now. And so what we were asking is that, you know, that our local officials advocate on behalf of Mammoth Lakes and Mono County businesses at the state level.

1:34:59 To allow the regional stay-at-home order to expire on December 27th. And I think Dan has covered, you know, some of the issues with that. You know, we offer as allies to conduct our businesses safely in the purple tier. We'll continue to operate as we've done since the start of the pandemic with the safety of our guests and employees at our utmost concern.

1:35:26 While we appreciate local efforts to financially support businesses through programs such as the Mammoth Lakes Business Assistance Program and the county's business assistance program, these allotted funds are about a drop in the bucket of the monies needed to operate under the stay-at-home order. We should be operating safely through natural cash flow, and you heard somebody else talk about that, rather than relying on...

1:35:54 Insubstantial public funding. Finally, we request that our county officials consider lobbying to redraw the regional boundaries, removing Mono County from the Southern California region. Regulating a county of approximately 14,000 residents in 3,030 square miles based on the actions of counties that are home to over 10 million people in a slightly larger area is unjust and unreasonable.

1:36:24 We just, we would like Simona County to be placed in a region appropriate to its demographics. So those were the asks that came out from the chamber position. And let me comment on the petition. When you look at it, yeah, we went through and counted businesses, and that meant not counting the ones that had two different owners sign it. But singly, we had over 160 businesses, and it's climbing.

1:36:53 In fact, we had a request yesterday to open back up the signature platform because we had people saying, gee, I didn't get a chance to sign that. Please let me sign it. So we've opened it back up. By the end of next week, we'll provide you an update on that. But the 546 were individuals. Of that, 160 separate individual businesses were signers on that.

1:37:22 Some of those people may be co-owners of a business, but that doesn't mean that they both aren't involved and concerned about their community and asking for the same thing. So, you know, we know that we appreciate the business assistance program. We appreciate what Senator Borges is trying to do at the state level. All those things.

1:37:49 But they can never make up for having a robust economy going, especially this time of year when that's what most of our businesses make their money at. As Senator Borges said in his original letter to the governor, you know, in L.A. County, they figured they had documented that less than 3.1% of all the positive cases came from restaurants. And so with that,

1:38:18 You know, we think with our restaurants operating under the parameters that you guys have helped develop from earlier times in the pandemic that they can continue to operate safely. We have no empirical data that says it's the guests bringing the COVID to our community. The reality is it's us as residents doing things that we shouldn't be doing before and after work and so forth.

1:38:48 We're asking whatever we can do to support you in trying to get the stay-at-home order lifted or get us put in a different region, anything that could help. That's what we're hoping this petition provides backup for you when you go to the state agencies, when you go to lobby on behalf of our county, that you can show that there is a strong support.

1:39:16 From the business community that they would like to be able to move forward and let the economy drive everything instead of having to rely on public funding. So with that, I'm with Brandon and I know that Rich Sanfilippo, our president, if you had anything to add, Rich, you might want to about coming out of our board. But, you know, we're looking at some serious bankruptcies if we don't find a way to get our

1:39:46 Thank you, everyone. First and foremost, so we don't forget, Merry Christmas to all of you and everybody listening. Thank you for your hard work. These are impossible decisions facing all of us. Me individually, I own a large cleaning business here. So I get the effect.

1:40:21 The Chamber Board is diverse. All of us business owners and all of us being impacted along with everybody else in the community. I think Ken spoke to it well. I think Brandon and John spoke to it well. So I'm not going to further those comments. Maybe more on the emotional side of it. You know, the Chamber Board spent a lot of time on this, wanting to support the Restaurant Association and support the Lodging Association.

1:40:51 In this, and that's why we added that cover letter to it. Folks are hurting. Fear drives a lot of, I think, comments and concerns. It's fearful out there at this time for a lot of folks. I think the most important thing I would add then is I don't want...

1:41:15 And when I say I, I mean that personally, but I think the board would share the sentiment. We don't want to see the business community fracture down the middle. We don't want to see the business community having to take sides. We don't want to know about one business is open and, you know, maybe skirting the rules on one side of the parking lot and on the other side, that business is following the rules.

1:41:44 We're going to get through this and we're going to come out on the other side. We want to make sure that the business community is still united. That's the beauty of Mammoth in this business community is being united. Sure, there's competition between businesses, but at the same time, I know I could go across the parking lot to the cleaning company that I can see from my window. And if I needed something from them, they would help me out. I'm sure the same is true with restaurants.

1:42:13 This community looks after each other. It always has. It will again when this is over. And the Chamber is committed to doing what one of its main goals is, be advocates for the business community. And we want to continue to work hard as a Chamber, support all of you in what you're doing, and help the business community get through this. So thank you, everybody. We appreciate a lot what you're all doing.

1:42:41 And real quick, if I could just add on, and this was stated at our board meeting, we do not want to see the mountain closed. We want the mountain open and operating because it's the only way that we will survive the long term. And so we are very supportive of making sure that Mammoth Mountain and hopefully at some point in time, June Mountain, get open. Thank you, Ken. Now I'll bring it back for...

1:43:14 Supervisor and Councilmember comments, starting with Mr. Gardner again. My concern, Mayor Sauser, is we still have public comments pending over there. Did you want to take those before we addressed it, or where are we on all that? If that is what you would like to do, it would give you an opportunity to address the public comments. I was just fearful for how long they would go before we got a chance to comment ourselves. My concern is giving everyone a chance to speak, as they say.

1:43:44 It's important to listen to everyone, and I would like to give everyone an opportunity to speak. Not a problem. We can go down that road. Mayor Sauser, can I interrupt for just a second? Because on item number two, there was a second letter, and it was the Southern California region letter, and that wasn't addressed. So before we go to continue with item three, I just wanted to,

1:44:14 Let the public know that hopefully they've read that letter and that the intent of that letter was to advocate for Mono County being unique and not appropriate for the Southern California region. Also the intent of that letter and the intent of the group of supervisors representing their respective counties was to not prevent

1:44:44 And the connection would hopefully be determined and

1:45:14 Would predicate compliance, voluntary compliance based on local conditions, COVID numbers being at the very basis of that. And we are not doing well with our COVID numbers. We need to bring those down, but also contact tracing, hospital capacity, but we must curtail the rates of transmission in order to be

1:45:44 Considered for local control, for better control over our own destiny, to be quite honest. But that advocacy has been going on, and that letter is dated December 18th, and we are looking for a bottom-up rather than top-down approach when it comes to looking at data about how COVID is impacting.

1:46:14 So I'm going to leave it at that, but I just didn't want to skip over that. And I'm happy to answer specific questions or address other topics of other advocacy work that I've been doing on behalf of Mono County since the beginning of this directly with the state. Thank you, John. And it is important that we let people know during this meeting how much work has been going on by you and others to advocate.

1:46:44 For our businesses and our population here. Because I don't think most people understand how much work has gone into that. That being said, I will go back to public comments on this item and then we'll go to supervisors and council members. So, Jamie. Rose Patch, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hello. Can you hear me? Yeah. I'm a host. I have a second home in Maryland. And, you know, I've, I've,

1:47:22 And following along with the progress of, you know, the town and, you know, trying to responsibly go through this with COVID and keep everybody safe. And I just, it has been really hard to see the just automatic shutdown of the hosts and the second home owners because we really are.

1:47:52 Business owners. And, you know, it's just, there's nothing to help us. And one of the things that has been really disheartening in this whole process is kind of the feel that I've heard from a lot of the people who live in Mammoth full time is that, you know, second homeowners are, you know, wealthy and that this is a, you know, something that we can handle.

1:48:22 And that is not the case with a lot of second home owners. And really, there's just, I'm a single mom. I'm a school teacher. My mortgage on my Airbnb is like all together with HOAs, $3,000 a month. I would love to rent out and help out somebody local, but nobody's going to pay $3,000 a month for our $725.

1:48:52 So, you know, we've had the fire. This is our second shutdown. And when I hear that we're going to be shut down to June, I mean, I don't know what to do. I really don't. And I think that there's a lot of second homeowners that are, I mean, we're homeowners in Mammoth because we love Mammoth. And we love the town.

1:49:22 I've been, you know, I pay top taxes. I really feel like I'm a part of the community, even though I'm not there every day. I've been there every month. It's my second home, but there's, I don't know how we're going to get through this. And we really do need help. We need a way to look at this in a, where we can, you know, rent responsibly and make everybody comfortable.

1:49:51 We have people coming to Mammoth, the mountains open, they are, they're staying in Bishop, which is just right down the road. How can we do this responsibly? How can we all work together? Because there are so many people hurting and I'm just hearing everybody and you can feel it. And I, so, I just want. Please wrap up your comments. I, I just, I thank you for just.

1:50:22 Thinking about looking at this in a different way and seeing how we can help everybody make it through. Thank you. Mr. Mayor, if I could make a clarification. Yes. Several people have referenced the June timeframe. I believe that came up in the context of ultimately having full economy and everything back up and going and wanted that to do.

1:50:50 Do with vaccinations, be able to move everything forward. There is no intent, I think, from anybody here that we would be under this level of shutdown until June. Really looking at those metrics weekly now, looking forward. So please don't misunderstand that either we're advocating or proposing or supporting a multi-month level of lockdown under the current state-at-home order.

1:51:18 That's not the intent from anybody on this call. So I wanted to clarify that because I think I hear that almost a fear in the voice there. I hope for saying that that is kind of scary. I think the element there, yes, it is going to be looked at, it gets reviewed, and we all have the same true belief that if we manage this right and get that disease spread down, that we will move out of this back into the tiered system, which may extend out.

1:51:44 to that time frame, but to be in this level of walk down to that period of time, I don't think is the expectation from anybody at this point, at least that I've heard expressed. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. I want to remind our callers and commenters that we do have a time limit on comments, so keep them as brief as possible, as we have a lot left to get through, I think. Jamie. Denise Trentum, please give your comments. Thank you.

1:52:13 And thank you to the Board of Supervisors and the Town Council for your service. I bet you never anticipated that you'd be dealing with these issues when you ran your last campaigns, huh? I know you're doing the best you can. No one alive has ever gone through this kind of situation. So you're kind of building the plane while you're flying it. And we do appreciate what you're doing. I love Mammoth Lakes. It's made up of lovely people. It's a community of businesses.

1:52:42 It's a haven that feeds our souls. Here's a few questions to consider. We've had four deaths in the county. That is unbelievably tragic and impacts four families and their loved ones. How many businesses are we willing to allow to die? And what's the impact of the families employed by those businesses? How do you balance the lifeblood of the community, i.e. the businesses,

1:53:11 The latest data published by Johns Hopkins indicates that the people hospitalized with the virus have primarily been exposed through lack of following healthy protocols, such as wearing masks and social distancing. Is the council an agreement with mono being included in the Southern California region? If so,

1:53:41 What is your reasoning for that? And if not, what are you doing to separate us from the Southern California group and aligning us with a county or a region more in alignment with who we are, both in terms of businesses and population? What public service campaign is the council promoting, similar to the PSA campaign for people to quit littering or wear seatbelts back?

1:54:09 22 decades ago. Either the masks and social distancing works or it doesn't. If it doesn't, why are these measures still being supported? If they work, we should not be leery of opening our businesses. How can you keep people employed when businesses are not allowed to apply their trade? And finally, why is the town of Mammoth Lakes not supporting short-term business rentals?

1:54:37 It seems that the town of Mammoth Lakes has had a love-hate relationship with short-term rentals for quite some time. Why is the town of Mammoth Lakes more concerned with applying fines and consequences than supporting short-term rentals through, for example, offering grants to these businesses like you're doing to others, surveying our needs, supporting Mono County being treated as its own unique entity, or included with other counties more similar in population in need?

1:55:05 Thank you so much for listening, and I really do appreciate all that you're doing to keep our county viable. Thank you. Thank you, Denise. Jamie? Indigo Dirk, please give your comments. Thank you, Council and Board of Supervisors. This is specifically for Chief Freevolt. Do you believe in your experience that the fact that Mono County and Mammoth

1:55:42 85% of all visitations come from Southern California is the reason why we have been clumped in with Southern California. Thank you and have a good evening. Thank you. Jamie? Brad Hunter, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Did you want to answer that up front, Frank, or wait until the end of comments? Whatever your pleasure is, Mr. Mayor. Yeah, I would prefer we get through comments and then...

1:56:17 Thank you. Jamie? Rob Hunter? Beth P? Hi, everybody. Thank you so much for doing this emergency meeting. What I want to talk about is fairness in law. I've heard some people asking the town to stay shut down to keep people safe. I'm guessing that most of them have already everything they need, and keeping tourists out doesn't affect them.

1:57:00 And I'm just listening, and I heard Tom Parker speak for the hospital, claiming that the hospital's doing fine, and still in the green, even throughout this latest surge. He explained that we have a low conversion rate from infection to hospitalization, and Mammoth Hospital even supports us opening up by moving back to purple. If you are a community member that doesn't work in tourism, or if you work for the town, or if you work for the county, after hearing all this, you probably still would rather stay shut.

1:57:29 But we need to stop taking sides based on what serves our individual needs. Regardless of whether or not we're in the business of tourism, all of us need to think about what is right and what is fair. Currently, the laws are discriminating against one sector while favoring others. People are allowed to move about the town, friends and family are spending the holidays shopping, skiing, picking up food. But you cannot discriminate against lodging when you're allowing others to be open.

1:57:59 The town and county need to stand up for fairness. I just heard one of your legal representatives say that it's not our leader's job to change the law, but rather uphold the law. But that puts all the burden of fighting for fairness on us, the constituents you represent. Instead of encouraging us to file lawsuits, please consider temporarily writing this discriminatory law by not enforcing it.

1:58:25 And finally, I really appreciate Supervisor Peter's efforts to advocate for us separating out from the SoCal region, but I don't think there's time for that. As far as I know, there's not been any action from the state regarding his efforts to advocate for us with CSAC. In the meantime, while we wait for the state to correct this unfair mandate, we simply need to stop aggressively enforcing it ourselves. Thank you. Thank you, Beth. Jamie?

1:58:58 Stacey Schaubmeyer, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you, Town Council and Supervisors. Stacey Schaubmeyer from the Alpenhoff Lodge. I just wanted to make a quick comment in regards to lodging, kind of coming back around to Tom Parker's comment from Mammoth Hospital about our officers helping enforce these mask mandates. Please don't forget that it's our frontline staff that's helping the town, the county, and the community.

1:59:31 Thank you for hearing me this evening. I'm sorry I was on the wrong computer before I didn't have a microphone.

2:00:07 I keep hearing about how this stay-at-home order has been clarified. I don't see that there's been any other stay-at-home order that's been issued since the initial one was issued. And within that one, it does not state that we have to shut down. Bishop is renting rooms. I can rent a hotel in Southern California right now.

2:00:33 And so the county and the town have taken this a step further. And so if there's been an additional order from the state that's been issued, I would love to see it because I can't find it anywhere. So it's been an interpretation of the county and the town, in my opinion, not what the state order states. You know, this whole order, if all of us being shut down, except for the mountain,

2:01:03 was actually helping and putting a stop to our cases. Then we would be saying, okay, we're going to hold on and we're going to, you know, do another week. We're going to make it through. We're going to make this happen. And we would know that we only have another week, maybe that we have to support our staff because our staff is our family. Our staff has been with us for so long. And right now, after a second shutdown and the summer that we had,

2:01:32 I can't keep supporting my staff, not without help. The town hasn't helped out lodging. The county has not helped out lodging. And it appears that possibly our funding that we were going to possibly be able to apply for federal is now in jeopardy. But, you know, this is dire. And if this was truly helping and it was stopping the cases or they were reducing, then that would be one thing.

2:02:02 Not helping the situation that we're in. Our cases are either staying level and still continuing to happen or they're still rising. So obviously what this is doing right now is not helping our situation. So why do we continue to do something when it is clearly not helping? And you are going to have businesses and our employees because it's not just the businesses, it's our staff. And if we lose our staff,

2:02:32 Even if a month from now you tell us that we can open, we're not going to be able to open because I have nobody to do this business. Those people have been family. They've been people that have worked for us for a very long time. And I would like to support them in any way I can. And I can't support them without being in business because there isn't enough. Well, there's no help out there right now. There may be a glimmer at some point if our federal government can get it together.

2:02:58 You know, we're asking for you guys to fight for us. Obviously, there's other counties that are in business, in the lodging business, that are letting lodging happen. So I'm not sure why our small county and community is taking it to another level, because I don't feel it's coming from the state border. Thank you. Thank you, Jerry. Yeah, hi.

2:03:26 Brad Hunter here. I'm sorry. I was away when you guys wanted me to talk. If I could have a quick minute. Go ahead, Brad. Okay. Yeah, I'm down here in San Diego. I live in Mission Beach, and then I also have a place up there. Just kind of a couple quick things. I'm sure everybody here is aware, but the historical ICU capacity for the Los Angeles area from late, it's from about

2:03:55 Mid-December through the end of April is between 95% and 98%. So, you know, just knowing that this will extend that entire period, I mean, most likely, right? I mean, it doesn't seem like ICU capacity is going to improve with COVID around. So it seems very likely this is going to be an all-winter thing. And then just the other kind of thing on that is the idea that

2:04:23 Yeah, I mean, I look down here. I mean, you can book rooms all day long in Bishop, which just seems absurd. And we're down in Mission Beach. I mean, as far as vacation rentals go, we're vacation rent like crazy down here. I mean, there has absolutely been zero, you know, I don't know, counties just kind of ignored it. You can't find one thing on the county website that even tells us we're not supposed to be doing it. I mean, I can just tell you being down here, it's everywhere. And there is zero even.

2:04:53 Like talk that we're not supposed to be doing it down here. So that's all. Thank you, Brad. Jamie. Jennifer Burroughs, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you for your time. I just, I'm going to be brief about this. I am the co-chair of the PEDC, Planning and Economic Commission, but

2:05:23 I'm not speaking on behalf of them because we have not made an official vote or discussed any of this, but Michael Vanderhurst, who is the chair, and I have both signed the petition from the chamber supporting moving into a less restrictive tier. Further, I believe that the scientific data does not support the closures in which we have instilled in our community. The hospital is open. It's in the green.

2:05:52 We are able to take COVID patients and support them. And finally, I would like to speak regarding Brandon Groesch's quote about last week in which he said that the more we keep our workers, and I'm sorry if this is not the exact words he spoke, but the more we keep our workers home and not working,

2:06:20 The more chance they're going to socialize, which is really what is spreading this, the parties, the time off that people have because people are tired of being alone. We need to open our business. We need to move to a less restrictive tier and we need to support our businesses and our economy. Thank you. Jennifer? Jamie? Eric Wasserman, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, thanks everybody. Happy holidays. Thanks for taking my questions.

2:06:54 So much to say in such a short time here. So let's get down to it. I was totally supportive of the shutdown in the spring when we didn't know what was going on. It made sense. But this couldn't be more against it. Many of you on this call, I sent an email on September 12th citing that I didn't like the way things were going. We're being wrapped up in Southern California and we need to do something about it. I only got one response from all of you. It was from Stacey Corliss. Thank you very much for responding. And we heard things were being worked on.

2:07:24 Well, now I'm hearing today there's a letter being dated December 18th. You've got to be kidding me. You should have seen this coming. The whole point of this from the governor's standpoint is to stop the spread of the virus. So let's get down to it. Are we doing that? Are we keeping people out of here with the lodging shut down? The answer is clearly no. If any of you have walked around town, people are here. So instead, what you're doing is you're killing this community.

2:07:52 We're worried about a few people maybe dying. That's tragic. But you're going to claim people are going to go bankrupt. There's going to be suicides, alcoholism, depression. There are other side effects here that are happening. Other counties, as we've heard on this call, are opening up. We're choosing not to enforce this. I don't see why we'd be any different when our neighbors in Inyo are doing this as well. These people are still coming here. If you are really serious about stopping people from coming here.

2:08:20 Why is it that when it snows, there's chain control, and you can't get up to grade if you're not wearing chains, but in such a serious pandemic, we can't implement that to keep people out? It's clearly politics and not based on scientific data. I think that, number one, I'd like to know, and I want to answer cities, not just get glossed over like a lot of these questions. Anyone in the decision-making process here, your salaries should be on hold, including accrual of benefits, and stand by the community.

2:08:49 Who are suffering financially. It is not fair to have everything shut down right now for everybody. It's absolutely ridiculous. Also, on the health side, where could you get a quick result antibody test? There are quick result tests in this town. Do you really want to stop the spread? If I have a fever, if my throat is sore, I don't want to have to wait a couple days to get it. I should have a 15 or 30 minute test result. Where can I get an antibody test? Maybe I'm not spreading the disease. These are things, you should have a more comprehensive health policy,

2:09:19 That goes along with the mandate to shut us down if you're seriously concerned about the virus. Instead, we are just killing this town and it can't stay this way. I am totally supportive of the Chamber of Commerce and their petition and I wish more people would sign it and actually act on it. And again, I'd like to know, you know, what we're going to, why we are doing this.

2:09:46 We also, you know, as a result, a minimum of 25 to 30 percent of the annual budget of the town of TOT is collected in this period. Probably going to be approaching a lot more than that since this won't go away until likely end of January, beginning of February. So what reductions of staff, what is the town doing to change their budget? Thank you. I look forward to hearing your answers. Thank you, Eric. Moving on to the next, Jamie. Tracy, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

2:10:21 Hi. Yeah, I am a short-term rental owner, and I would like for your consideration that my particular unit is very self-contained. It has its own garage, and people go in. They're in their own unit. There is no interaction at all with anybody else around them. There's no hallways. They get in.

2:10:50 Through the front door, through a keyless entry. I just feel like you guys are really putting the hammer down on everybody and you need to consider different situations. Thank you. Jamie? Natalie Simmons, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Hello. I would like to say that I appreciate you guys. I'm on the board of directors of my homeowners association and I know it's a commitment.

2:11:29 But I would also like to say that I love Mammoth. I've been coming up there for 20 years. I have a vacation rental up there. As I said earlier, I canceled my bookings. It's crazy that people are staying in hotels in Bishop and coming up to Mammoth anyway. What's the point? My condo is, like the previous person said, keyless entry. There's zero contact. People go in there. They cook their own meals.

2:11:57 I rent to families and not, you know, people that I think are going to party and it couldn't be safer. It's much safer than staying in a hotel where there's hallways and common areas and, you know, lots of different staff and all that stuff. I'm paying housekeepers, I pay for laundry, I'm supporting the community and the businesses there that support the homeowners. I mean, it's just a kind of...

2:12:26 Food chain. And it's just, I don't think it's working. I mean, it doesn't make any sense to me if people are staying in hotels in Bishop and coming up to Mammoth, what's the point? The men's open, people are going to come. Let's give them somewhere safe to stay. It would just make so much more sense. We clean, we sanitize, we do the laundry, we leave 24 hours between guests, we're following the rules. Let us do it. Let, you know, let's.

2:12:56 Let people stay safely instead of staying in hotels with hallways and common areas where there's more likely to be transmission. And those people down there in the hotels in Bishop, they don't care who they rent to. They're going to let people come in there and be partiers and do whatever they want to do. There's no monitoring of it. So, I mean, I just think we need to be able to...

2:13:23 Be safe and rent safely to people who are going to be responsible. Thank you. Mr. Mayor, I'm just wondering if we could ask legal counsel to provide a, just in the interest of public information, the status of Inyo County and their orders, if Stacey and people are comfortable providing an update, that would be helpful for folks. I'd be happy to do that. I do believe that Andy Morris is having internet connectivity problems, so he may not be on.

2:13:55 Inyo County is subject to the same regional stay-at-home order as Mono County is. I have no doubt that there is illegal renting in Inyo County. I cannot speak to their or the City of Bishop's enforcement policies or strategies. I know this came up at the beginning of the pandemic as well, where there were folks renting in Inyo County and in Bishop, and in most cases, those rentals were illegal.

2:14:23 We don't have the inside information about what kind of enforcement actions are being taken against them, but certainly folks could contact the city of Bishop or Inyo County to ask for that information. Thank you. And just to be clear, there are ongoing communications between the two counties and to the council of governments, other things to make sure that we'll be consistent with all this. So thank you for that, Stacey. If people need to report things, please do that to the appropriate authorities. Thank you.

2:14:53 Thank you, Stacey, and I'm going to push it a little further. One, I have had a conversation with one of my counterparts in the city of Bishop, and what they have said is they just simply don't have the wherewithal to do the enforcement piece, so it's being left up to the individual motels and hotels to check for the legality of the people who are saying they are essential workers. But, Stacey, before we move on to more public comments, we have heard several times that we're the ones putting the hammer down hard.

2:15:23 We've heard someone say that the state order doesn't prohibit short-term rentals. So from you or Andy, if he can get back on, I would love to hear. I know I've gone and read the state order and I'm pretty clear on what it says, but for the sake of further conversation tonight, can you clarify for me what the stay-at-home order says about short-term rentals and hotels, motels?

2:15:50 Sure. Actually, in anticipation of that, I had pulled up the FAQ on the state's website. Sometimes their Q&A, their FAQ is a little more clear than the legalese, the orders. So if I may start with that, I'm on the state's website, COVID-19. I can actually post this website right in the chat box. Oh, no, you don't have that function in your meeting.

2:16:22 Yeah, we're in a webinar. Yeah, okay. So I'm on the state's website. I Googled California COVID restrictions and there is a question, a list of questions and you press the button, the plus sign to open up and get the answer and it says under a regional stay at home order, can hotels, vacation rentals and short-term lodging sites accept reservations?

2:16:48 And then the answer is when any California region is under a regional stay-at-home order, no hotel or lodging entity in California can accept or honor out-of-state reservations for non-essential travel. And then it goes on to talk about the exception for people who are quarantining here. And then it says additionally hotels and lodging entities in a county under a regional stay-at-home order cannot accept in-state reservations for non-essential travel.

2:17:17 Hotels or other commercial and residential buildings may offer lodging for essential functions and travel, including COVID-19 mitigation and containment measures, treatment measures, accommodation for essential workers, or solutions, including measures to protect homeless populations. So that's the attempt at the plain English interpretation of the regional stay-at-home order, and it is that language which has changed.

2:17:46 Since the initial order was issued. The initial order uses the terms, and this is, I think, the source of the confusion with the city of Big Bear. It uses two terms, lodging and hotels. The state's intention was and has always been that lodging encompasses all types of units, but Big Bear, as my understanding,

2:18:15 Somehow thought that by using the term hotel and lodging, that did not include short-term rentals. And when multiple cities and counties across the state contacted the state at all different levels to say, hey, this interpretation is out there from this city. Can you clarify it? The state did issue that clarification, which I read. And state representatives have repeatedly told.

2:18:44 All of us in counties and cities across the state that that was their intention all along, that that interpretation was incorrect. So again, the term lodging in the state order is a reference to any type of short-term lodging. Doesn't apply to long-term, 31 days or more. Thank you, Stacey. Okay, Jamie, on with the parade. Matthew Deserio, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Yes, hello, can you hear me? Yes.

2:19:23 Hey, Bill. So I guess I just wanted to respond to a couple things. First off, I know that several angry homeowners are sort of asking, why are we having this meeting? If you guys aren't going to change anything, if you're not going to go against the state order, what is the purpose of this meeting? And I think, in truth, having served on a board or serving on a board right now myself, the venting from your constituents and having to take it and also...

2:19:51 Updating those constituents on the information that you've been provided by the state is the purpose of the meeting. And it might not feel great for us as homeowners, but I want to encourage everybody to understand that if you listen to what a lot of our representatives are saying, you have the hospital representatives saying that they weren't consulted when Mammoth was placed in the Southern California region. You've got our city council saying that if we...

2:20:18 You know, sorry, the attorney or the council to the city council saying that if we violate the state order, we're liable to have funds that were already given to our homeowners and to our business owners clawed back. And so we're really in this tough position. And this really affects me personally. Like if I was in charge, if it was a dictatorship, I would open up and just sort of let people do whatever they want to do and take their own personal responsibility. That's my personal view. I say that as an Airbnb-er.

2:20:47 But that's not the situation that we're in. We have funding that comes from the state. We have mandates that come from the state. I know that we're all very upset, but I think it's really important not to vent or threaten people or get really angry at the people. They're just volunteers that are trying to...

2:21:05 Do their civic duty and to serve us and to sort of, you know, be transparent with the information that they're given from the state. So that's the first thing. The other thing that I would encourage for, you know, I think a lot of Airbnbers who spoke out that and the woman from Southern California, that's a school teacher, the guy in San Diego in Mission Beach.

2:21:24 So, immediately, when

2:21:54 This ban happened on December 6th. I just immediately pivoted to the same thing that I did in the spring to long-term rentals. Long-term rentals of 31 days or more are not subject to the ban. It's very clear that that's a different type of rental. It's not short-term rental. And I would really encourage people, yeah, it's not great, but if you're in a situation, this is sort of a PSA to my fellow homeowners, second homeowners, Airbnb-ers, hoteliers, if you're in a situation where you're going to go bankrupt,

2:22:21 Look at extending one of your more lucrative weeks of booking over New Year's to a 31-day rental. And yeah, you might not make a ton of money, but maybe you'll be able to survive. And ultimately, that's what we're trying to do. We're trying to survive as an industry. I'm sure that, strictly speaking, having restaurants closed, having gyms closed, having the mountains completely closed would be better in the mitigation of the... Yes, I will. 50 more seconds. I'm sure that would be better.

2:22:47 For the mitigation of the spread, but those industries are trying to survive in whatever way is legally compliant. And by engaging in long-term rentals, you may be able to make it to March. Thank you, Matthew. Jamie? Ron Day, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, folks. It's Ron Day. I just want to thank you all for going through all of this stuff we're going through right now. There is no direct answer.

2:23:30 I think what you're doing is the best thing you can do. Especially John Peters with what he said. So have a great Christmas. Thank you, Ron. Jamie? Andrea Walker, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello, thank you. I will be so quick. Let me go over here real quick.

2:24:00 So, I appreciate the ethical bonds you have to the duties of your positions, but what about the ethics and morals of representing the communities and citizens you represent? Businesses are being held financially responsible for lowering cases in Mono County, but it is out of our control to regulate gatherings outside of our businesses. Further, if we can't provide a safe place for our employees to work and house their attention for eight hours a day to promote...

2:24:26 I echo Denise's comment, how many businesses are you willing to let die? Can you choose to allow our businesses to stay safe, to stay open? The businesses should not be held financially responsible and propelled into debt as a way to control the spread. That is an unrealistic expectation. What will happen when our valuable

2:24:55 VRBO, parent B&B owners lose their homes. Will those homes be acquired by good people who are committed to our community? Or will these properties be acquired by people who have zero interest in anything other than their own economic interests? I understand the impact of COVID on the whole entire world right now, but is there some way when the city that we send our COVID patients to, if we have them,

2:25:25 Is open and that state is inviting people to come to it. How is it that when they're open in our cases like prevent us from being open? It just doesn't make a whole lot of sense. So I'm just looking for ways for you guys as our representatives to look around, see what's being done in other areas and help these people out.

2:25:56 Mama!

2:27:06 Thank you.

2:27:58 Thank you. Thank you.

2:28:39 Thank you.

2:29:24 Thank you, Erin. Jamie? Villager, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi there. Yeah, I just want to piggyback on Erin's comment that we need to implement all these strategic supervisal implements. Like, we have lodging restrictions and no one's upholding them. We have, you know, people commenting on these

2:30:06 Missed compliances and nothing's being held. So we have this new farm that you just released yesterday, right? At 7.30 for lodging. But who's actually going to implement that? That's what I need to ask is who's actually going to follow through with what is being implemented that you guys put forward for lodging. Thank you. Thank you, Villager. Jamie. Seth Maniaci, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

2:30:37 I applaud you for pronouncing that correctly. Thank you. First of all, I'd just like to address a few things. I find it ironic that you would take the Pledge of Allegiance at the beginning of this meeting, and it mentions the Republic inside of that there pledge that the majority of you have taken. Now, I want to give a few exceptions before I start calling individuals out for their behavior during this meeting.

2:31:11 Fred Stump and Bob Gardner, you two are dismissed from the following statement. You are upstanding individuals. You've taken my phone calls several times, actually, and it's appreciated. I really do appreciate the time we've had to go on the phone. The remainder of you are snakes in the grass, quite frankly. And it's amazing to me that you second homeowners here.

2:31:42 Are looking for sympathy from individuals in the town when for years it was you who refused to rent to locals. Oh, and now it seems that you might be forced to do that very thing. How unfortunate that is for you because you're barely making it. I'm sorry. I simply don't have the tolerance for people in your position for years who turned a blind eye for the housing issue.

2:32:11 That Mono County has in the town of Mammoth Lakes has. And I'm relatively new as a resident in this town. Garbage. Let me address another issue. The sheriff. You see, there was a question early on. The question was, how do we fight these things? How do we address these things? Are there other options to where the county can say no to Gavin Newsom? Well, here's the truth, folks. The sheriff, throughout the history of this nation,

2:32:44 Has been the officer of the Constitution. She and she alone has the ability to sign on or off on a document allowing an outside agency to enter the county and strip a business of its license. I am the founder and the person behind Recall Mono County Sheriff Ingram Braun. Join me, friends. Join me.

2:33:18 And I'll show you what it's like to live in a county where the sheriff is obliged to the Constitution and only the Constitution, where a county lets every citizen know that their rights trump people's feelings. And that self-responsibility is just that, self-responsibility. I'm not a villain. I'm not a criminal. Please wrap up your comments.

2:33:50 Yeah, you'll hear plenty of my comments as we continue down this path. Thank you for having me. Thank you, Seth. Jamie? Now I'm just going to read some emails that were received. Craig Shilligan says, here's a possible workaround. Can the Town Council recognize that our visitors may qualify as quarantining guests when traveling to Mammoth? Right now, the form designed by the Town that verifies quarantining guests is very restrictive.

2:34:21 Can the town modify that or rather better yet not require a form filled out for essential and or quarantining visitors? John Herzog says, is the town considering opening and going against the Southern California regional state order or are we waiting for an exception from the governor's office?

2:34:38 Anne Hyde says, hello. As an owner of a lodging facility in June Lake, I would like to add my support to opening up lodging as soon as possible. We have done everything asked of us to be compliant in keeping our community safe. There is no data that shows that hotels are big contributors to the spread of COVID. Mental, emotional, and financial health are essential to our community as well. Please look for ways to keep us open. It always feels there are more working...

2:35:03 Amanda Spencer says, I was just able to call and make reservations for a hotel in LA County. This is absurd. Please fight for our lodging and restaurant businesses. Clearly, our southern neighbors are not following the rules. There are far worse outcomes that an increase in positive tests that will

2:35:32 We will all be facing if this isn't addressed and fought for. Jeremy Goico says, thank you to the council and county supervisors for meeting this evening. My name is Jeremy Goico and I'm a business owner in Mammoth Lakes and want to ask that the town council and county supervisors try to convince state officials to achieve a balance between health concerns and economic viability. The business community is aware of the very concerning health pandemic we are going through, but we still need to be able to work and earn a living. I do not feel the regional stay-at-home owner is working.

2:36:04 In fact, I believe it is exacerbating the transmission of the virus in our community because it is putting people on unemployment and allowing them more availability to gather outside of work. In March, when we closed down due to the stay-at-home order, that made sense because we did not understand this virus. But today, vaccines are being distributed and we are very aware of how this virus transmits. So it is very difficult to understand why we need to bankrupt our community at this time.

2:36:29 I am in support of the petition from the Chamber of Commerce and hope that you will use this to convince state officials that a modification needs to be made to the lodging portion of the current regional stay-at-home order so that businesses in Mammoth Lakes and Mono County can get back to work. That is all the public comments. Thank you. So now I'm going to say those of you who are complaining about the illegal rentals, help us out. Call the hotline and then we can enforce it without knowing that we can't.

2:36:59 And I'm going to go to Rob right now. There were several questions on enforcement. I'm going to let him give his answer before we move back to supervisors. Thank you, Bill, and thank you for the comment with regard to assistance from other folks who are talking about seeing illegal rentals in town but not being able to or not thinking there's enforcement. I will guarantee there's enforcement. You talk about citations.

2:37:27 There's about five of us within the office, including myself, that are working on this. I haven't polled the group to see how many citations I've issued. I know that I have personally issued two citations. With regard to people who are doing this illegally, our first efforts are to gain compliance. So we're reaching out. I'm making a lot of phone calls. In those two that were issued, those are people that are...

2:37:54 Are being defiant. We're contacting folks and saying, this is what we have. You've either earned a citation or you haven't. Please be respectful of the order and take immediate action on that. That's what I'm wanting our team to do. We're looking for compliance. Citations are not a revenue stream for the town. They're a way of getting compliance. For all those that are in compliance, I appreciate those efforts.

2:38:18 We do have a couple of people that are facing loss of business tax certificates because their repeated desire not to be a part of the solution here. So I want to kind of talk about that. It's not about citations and number of issuances. It's really about compliance, and that's what my team is focused on. You know, secondly, we do have a lot of people who are working on this. You know, we are upholding the current restrictions that are within the town.

2:38:47 And we will respond to those that come into our hotline. So folks that are out there, please continue to provide that information. If you have specific stuff you want to provide, definitely we'll follow up on it. For all the other folks that are out there, none of us want this to extend beyond the absolute amount of time it has to. We don't want months long. We don't want this. This is not a desire of us to have this shut down. We recognize how catastrophic it is economically for

2:39:15 Our town and our community. And that's not lost on us. It's certainly not lost on me. My job is simply to make sure that we do the best we can to gain compliance with our current orders and to make the best possible chance we have about getting the virus under control and opening up as soon as we possibly can. So thank you for the comments tonight. I do appreciate everyone who's brought those forward to us. And thank you. Brian.

2:39:45 Yeah, hi. I just wanted to respond to Eric Wasserman's comment regarding rapid testing, and we do have that in town. Public health does it every day we're out testing. We did it today. We had 10 positives. The hospital does the rapid antigen test every day, and I believe we got about seven positives from the hospital. So there is rapid antigen testing in town. It's pretty readily available.

2:40:15 And if you would like to get tested, please look at our calendar for testing dates and come get tested. But it is available. Thank you, ma'am. Thank you, Brian. It's another question on that, though. I am told that the quick tests are not that accurate, that we wait for a longer-term test before we put them on our COVID numbers. Yeah, that is, that's...

2:40:39 Correct, in a sense. The antigen tests are, and Dr. Boom may want to weigh in on this if he's still on the line, but the antigen tests are best indicated for people with symptoms, people that are symptomatic that probably at the time of the test have a high viral load. Asymptomatic people, it's not really indicated for. People that have no symptoms, it's not indicated for. So yeah, we do back them up with a PCR test.

2:41:09 Just to make sure that it is an accurate test. Thank you. So now I'm going to move back to Bob. Thank you. And I do appreciate the many people that have taken the time and been patient this evening, this afternoon, this evening to express themselves. I absolutely understand the difficult situation our businesses are in.

2:41:43 Many individuals are in. I know personally business owners and individuals who've lost their jobs. This is not something that is beyond my comprehension by any means. It's a very difficult situation, one that doesn't lend itself to easy answers. I do think it's important to reflect on what was stated at the outset from our county council, Stacey Simon, and the town council, Andy.

2:42:13 For us about our legal options in terms of the role that we play. Many people that have sent me emails seem to say you have to end the shutdown. We don't have the legal authority to end the shutdown. And I hope that's been made clear to everyone in terms of what's happened this afternoon, in terms of understanding the legality of the situation we're in.

2:42:39 I do want to mention, as Supervisor Peters pointed out, once our numbers get in better shape, I think we can make a strong case to the state that would be excluded from the Southern California region based on better case numbers, based on progress, based on the fact that we shouldn't be put in that category because we're doing better. But indeed, we need to do better to make that case. And our numbers are not there now.

2:43:09 We're not doing better, and we need to stay the course and get the case numbers down so that we can then get through this and get our business community back in shape, get people back in their jobs. And it is some heavy, to be sure, short-term pain to hopefully get long-term gain. I certainly, as I say, I'm sympathetic to the impact.

2:43:38 But I feel like we have to continue this. And I'm certainly supportive of, as we did earlier, sending a letter. I do believe there will be federal assistance provided both for businesses and individuals. The federal bill that is pending has $300 billion for small businesses, under $3 million, I believe, and employing less than 300 individuals, which would include, I would assume, most of our small businesses in the city and the county.

2:44:07 And there's state assistance, as we heard, that we're supportive of and some other state assistance. And we have both town and county assistance. We can provide assistance for businesses. We can provide assistance for individuals. And we'll continue to do that. We unfortunately can't provide assistance for someone who is sick and dying. And that's difficult at this point. We must hang in there. Easy to say, hard to do.

2:44:36 And as I say, I certainly feel for everyone that is suffering and having a difficult time. But the sooner we get through this and maintain compliance, the sooner it will be over and we'll be able to resume a normal life and get our businesses going again. Thank you, Bob. Moving on to Fred. Thank you. I just have a couple comments.

2:45:11 It's the short time I'm here. I'm trying to keep my comments short. The first is I do want to bring attention to Supervisor Peters and his efforts going back months that have interacted not just with CSAC but with the State Department of California and with the Governor's Office itself. Many of the requests made tonight were to push, well,

2:45:43 Pushing has occurred. I understand that the outcomes have not been what they wanted, but pushing has occurred, and Supervisor Peters has put in an awful lot of effort, not just on behalf of the unincorporated portions of the county, but on behalf of the entire county. When the state decided which region Mono and Mammoth were going to be in, there was an advice that came from the state that this was going to happen.

2:46:14 But there wasn't a back check to find out if it's what we wanted. They just did it. So there has been action taken. And some of the proposals that I've heard verge on, even though the chamber said they're not proposing, verge on outright defiance. And I'm fully aware as a board member of other counties that did that and the consequences.

2:46:45 That they suffered. Second, fairness issue. It's absolutely out there. And I know what's going on in Duneo County. My district board is in Duneo County. And Michelle said, it isn't fair. It happened earlier. It's happening now. And in addition to what we're saying here, all the letters we may send here, we need to believe more or more forceful with Duneo County and the City of Bishop to step up. If this is the way it's going to be,

2:47:17 We need to be a little more forceful with them. So it's not seeing Mammoth and staying Bishop. I understand Bishop. I sit on a board with Bishop City. I understand they have staffing issues, but so do we. And I think that recommendation needs to go out. And if SCOG is the place to push it, then push it. SCOG is now a joint powers authority. And it needs to act as a representative of all entities, which include both the town.

2:47:48 Lastly, I just want to express the need for compassion in all of this and the need to listen. I forget who it was that commented here tonight that people are angry. Yeah, they are angry and they're upset and they're scared and they should have the opportunity to vent. And I don't mind them because I know I'm not the target. When you're about to lose your livelihood, you're scared.

2:48:19 When I got my master's degree, which was a long, long time ago, we talked a lot about Maslow's hierarchy of needs. And you cannot have more enlightened thoughts when you're worried about what you're going to eat, what your kids are going to eat. And so anything we can do, any support we can give, as both the town council and the board of supervisors move forward into the next year, I would really encourage as much activism as possible.

2:48:49 Thank you. Thank you for that. Jennifer? Yeah, thank you. I don't have a lot to add. I appreciate my colleagues' comments, and I appreciate everyone's frustration, all the callers, all the emails. It's been overwhelming, and I don't say that because I'm complaining, but it has been significant, rightfully so.

2:49:29 I think about what we wouldn't do, as Supervisor Stump said, to take care of our loved ones and our families, not just their health, but, you know, all of their well-being, and there's probably not much we wouldn't do for that, any of us. So I appreciate people's being pushed to the brink and not knowing how they're going to survive and what it looks like at the end of this pandemic.

2:50:00 I wish that we had more unanimity with Inyo County and Bishop's Enforcement. I think it's unfortunate that Mono County and the town are acting in a way that isn't consistent with Inyo County or vice versa. We're too close on so many levels for that kind of disparity.

2:50:31 And the lack of parity is so apparent and frustrating. And I would hope that either the EOC or the Incident Command or the SCOG or us tonight send a letter to them imploring them to either step up or...

2:50:59 I don't know, but there has to be some kind of parity has to be implemented because our businesses are suffering while their businesses are certainly not suffering to the same degree. And as leaders, I think that's the least we can do is advocate for that. You know, I heard the request to stay on the purple tier. Clearly, we can't do that. I do think we need to start advocating today for change in region.

2:51:31 And not wait for better test results. I think that we need to start that conversation sooner than later so that we're priming the pump so that when those are ready, that's not a brand new request that they're now asking or looking at and considering.

2:51:51 That would be something I would encourage. And of course, I defer to Supervisor Peters, given his work at the state with CSAC, et cetera, to see what he feels is the best chain of events and process to go forward. But hope is not a strategy. I don't want us to be sitting here hoping for better things. I want us to think about how we can actually encourage.

2:52:19 Change that is better for all of our residents. I know that there's a lot of people who want to pit each other. You know, you're older, you are established, or you're just worried about your second home. And this is not about somebody's needs being more vital than another. But as a community, how do all of us come out of this more heard?

2:52:49 And feel like we're respected. One of the things that, and I know this hasn't been brought up tonight, it's rarely brought up, is our schools. And we don't even talk about getting schools open. That's just crazy to me. So I'd like to see us do more advocating there and pushing on that for funding and opening.

2:53:18 There's plenty of complaints to go around. There's plenty of frustration. But I think the caller pointed out, I mean, we really don't have a lot of options. And as County Council pointed out, we're at the mercy of the governor at this point. So that's where we are. Merry Christmas. Thank you, Jennifer. John, Mr. Peters. Yeah, thank you, Mayor Sauser. I kind of covered a lot of what I wanted to say earlier.

2:53:52 But in response, first of all, to Supervisor Crites, and what is the next best step to advocate for recognition of Mono County, rural California, separating us from a region that basically has 60% of the population of the entire state. And earlier today, I was on separate phone calls with Siskiy Supervisor,

2:54:22 Ed Valenzuela, Supervisor Kelly Long from Ventura, Supervisor Chuck Washington from Riverside, talking about exactly this. How do we get out of this? What does it look like coming out of the stay-at-home order? And I believe our best strategy is to align ourselves with other rural counties in California, like Siskiyou, like Calusa. I was also on a call earlier with Supervisor Denise Carter.

2:54:51 To use the ability to work through our associations and Supervisor Corliss at RCRC, Rural County Representatives of California, myself and Supervisor Crites with CSAC, and to put the pressure on the state to continue to recognize the unique abilities of rural.

2:55:16 Counties in California to know their communities, know their conditions, and know their ability to measure the risk of activity in sectors that to date, the state has not been able to come up with metrics that show that COVID-19 is spreading in a restaurant that operates at 25% capacity indoors or that a lodging.

2:55:44 Facility is a vector for the transmission of COVID-19 and stick to the data, stick to those specific statistical approaches to this. And that's the kind of advocacy that I'm working through. It's not just going to the governor's office or the secretary of health and human services and saying, please, you know, just give us a break. And we're going there with real

2:56:13 Asks with real numbers. And I'm telling you, they hear what we're saying. Before this started, they didn't know what, you know, maybe someone visited Mammoth and Skeed that's in the state administration. They understand where we are. The state is, it's going to have, something's going to have to give. And it's not, I don't believe it's going to be another month's long stay-at-home strategy because it's obvious to all of us. It's not.

2:56:41 Working the confidence with that throughout the state in the slow of the spread is not there. And so that's what we have to, we have to really look at, look at ourselves first, as Supervisor Gardner said, get our numbers down, focus on our community, supporting them. We do not want people that we can help without help, food.

2:57:08 Shelter, whatever we can do to keep people secure in their, you know, in their mental status and support them with the, I know people don't want to put their hand out, I wasn't raised that way, to accept aid from the government, but these are unique times, unprecedented times, so we need to be able to stand those up who need a little bit, who need to have something to lean on.

2:57:38 I will continue my efforts. Everyone's been here a long time tonight. My phone number, my email is available. I'm happy to meet with the various associations independently, help to craft statistical data that can be used to advocate. But it's happening every day, the advocacy, seven days a week. And if it's not...

2:58:04 Directly with the state or a state association. It's amongst other colleagues throughout the state that are in similar, more dire, or, you know, situations that are the result of COVID-19. So I will end it up that. And I do appreciate all the comments and all the passion. And I'll continue to work hard to try to get us.

2:58:33 Out of this in a way that allows us to operate and have a bit of our own destiny in our hands at a minimum. Thank you, John. Stacey. Yeah, thanks, everyone. And we're really in an untenable situation. And we've heard from a lot of people. It's awful. For most of you we heard from, you know, we can't do what you want. We can't fix this. We can't get you your condo rental income back.

2:59:02 By voting on something tonight. We just can't. And it's not just Mammoth. I've proved that over and over again. We're not alone in this. 98% of the state's population is under the same order. And we can, you know, find disparities. We can find inconsistencies. But really, we're all in it together. And we've got to be looking for a way out now. You know, it's unacceptable. I think even today, on Wednesday, two days before Christmas holiday,

2:59:32 To not really know that we're going to be under the stay-at-home order for another week, to know because of the data, but to have the state not really tell us what's going to happen. And to have all of you who own lodging properties have reservations that you're now going to have to cancel two days before. I mean, it's pretty obvious, but that really isn't acceptable, and we've got to do better. That said, no one, including the state, has ever done this before.

3:00:03 Let's try to help improve the response as best we can, but we cannot deny that we're in the middle of a pandemic and that there's more death and illness than there ever has been. So with that as a starting point, I support doing what the chamber has actually asked us to do. That's what this request was about, namely advocating. And even though we're not ready to...

3:00:33 Get back to full business yet with our COVID situation being what it is. We need to, we are the ones that need to start forging and, you know, painting the road forward. So let's do what they're asking. I think it's reasonable enough. We're not going to get the stay-at-home order ended on Monday. That's unfortunately just...

3:00:58 Not going to happen, but I think we just should be communicating to states that it's not acceptable to kind of take this operate businesses like lodging businesses day by day and that it's not realistic to just manage by closure. A lot of you have said that to us tonight. The people are here. The people are here. And are we meeting our health objectives?

3:01:22 By doing our best to enforce, but still having visitors here, maybe renting illegally, not operating under the COVID guidelines that our business community has been upholding so well over the last few months. So, you know, we've got to face reality. And we can't manage by closure. Also, if there's not going to be adequate financial relief, it's just not going to work. It's not working right now.

3:01:51 So I want to end on it. So I say let's write the letters. We'll continue advocacy through California State Association of Counties, through our legislative representatives, through our organizations. But let's write our own letter and say what we want to say here. And I basically support what the chamber has asked us. So let's find a way out of the Southern California region.

3:02:17 That all has to be data-driven, and it has to have the support of public health and the medical community. We heard from the hospital earlier. It's got to be all of that. And finally, just very negative. It all sounds doom and gloom, but the state has listened to us before. Back in June, we were on another precipice where Yosemite was opening.

3:02:40 Summer was coming. People were coming up. We were having visitation issues on public lands. We communicated all of that to the state and said, look, you have got to let us open lodging. We have to get campgrounds open. They listened. Later or earlier this fall, when, or really maybe late summer, when the tier system and data really wasn't working for small counties, people like Supervisor Peters advocated, explained.

3:03:08 We need absolute numbers. We got a small county exemption. This can happen. This will work. But we have got to start stating our case now. So let's do what they're asking, which is advocacy. Thank you, Stacey. Mr. Freewell, I was remiss. I was supposed to come back to you on a question that one of our commenters asked specifically. So I'm going to do that now. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.

3:03:38 That's the question posed by Dirk. I understood his question to be, are we in the Southern California local health officer region based on the percentage of our Southern California tourism? I do not believe that is the case. Dr. Bill will probably have better information, but that local health officer region is actually a combination of two of the normally six Cal OES regions.

3:04:08 I won't know the history on why those two were joined, but the state has divided under the KELOES side, those regions for some time, and the local health officers region is just a slightly different version of that. I don't think it has anything to do with our tourism or where it comes from. Thank you. Thank you, Frank. I'm going to change things up and go backwards from what I was doing earlier and speak first and then go up the chain on the council.

3:04:40 The current state orders are not working. They are not helping. They are causing division in our community. They're causing unfair business practices and competition. One of the things that I would advocate for and that I would ask are EOC and John, you're doing a great job with the county pushing things forward to find out from the state what, if anything, they plan on doing about enforcement.

3:05:08 There are a lot of counties who are not going to enforce, who don't have the wherewithal to enforce, and frankly, if we allow them to stay open and we continue because we can enforcement at this level, we've done our business owners a huge disservice. We cannot afford to allow all of our guests to stay in Bishop. The other problem I'm having, and I cannot tell you the level of my frustration,

3:05:37 It probably comes through in my voice. We spent a lot of money and a lot of time to chase down the illegal renters in Mammoth and bring them on board to the tax rolls for TOT and to make them legal to make it a fair business line across the board so nobody was operating at an advantage. And right now what the current state orders have done has put the local businesses

3:06:05 That are doing everything they can, that are following our rules at a disadvantage within your county, at a disadvantage. I've talked to a couple different homeowner groups in town that manage absentee homes. All of their homes are booked, and they are not booked with owners. They may be owner guests that aren't paying, but still that would fall against state regulations. So for me, this is a tirade.

3:06:35 Normally have to follow whatever the state says, but if the state won't step up their own enforcement, or they won't send the money along for enforcement, and they have no understanding of what a resort community like Mammoth, what happens here, then at some point, we will have to do the same thing that Bishop was doing, and just agree not to enforce anything beyond the purple tier, which we are rightfully in. For those who are advocating us to get out of the Southern California region,

3:07:06 I want to remind you that just a week ago, we were like the third worst county in the state for our numbers in population. So at this point, we don't deserve out of that in terms of how we're handling this. But those are my thoughts. We cannot stay closed like this while those around us are managing to stay open. We need to advocate with the state not just to allow us to open, but if they aren't going to, to...

3:07:36 Come down with their own hammers so it doesn't look like the town of Mammoth is doing this on their own because we are not. And enforce some of their rules. And maybe not say, okay, everybody has to stay at home unless you don't want to. If you want to go skiing, it's okay. But you can't rent a lodge. If you want to travel three hours from your house, well, maybe that's okay. And that is everything that I took out of the governor's speech when he locked us down.

3:08:04 With that, I will give way to something else, but I would encourage us to have this meeting again if no movement happens on any of those to make a determination if we're going to continue to enforce the way we're currently enforcing because it is not tenable. My community that I love dearly is being torn apart by how this COVID is being handled, in my opinion, at the state level. I will now shut up and move on to Sarah.

3:08:37 Yeah, Bill, not just your community is being torn apart, but this country is being torn apart at the seams. I guess just the takeaway from this is that because of the catastrophic failure of our federal government to step in and help us, we have neighbor fighting against neighbor. I mean, a lot of the people.

3:09:08 That spoke tonight. I worked for when I was in the restaurant business and it's only been three years since I made two thirds of my yearly income during this period. So I understand. It's easy for me to say now because I am getting a paycheck, but that's outside of working in a restaurant, but I'm not very far from that. And I truly understand what.

3:09:38 What is happening, what people are going through, your life's work is hanging by a thread. You know, I don't see any point in echoing the sentiments of what we're capable of doing as a local body, but there are a couple things I want to say. I just need to push back on the idea that without

3:10:03 A place to go for eight hours a day, people are going to gather. I've worked in restaurants in Mammoth. I get sick about five times a winter. People gather with their coworkers. And so I do need to push back on that a little bit. The idea that if they don't have the stability of restaurant work, that people are going to gather outside of that because I've been in that life.

3:10:28 So I do feel like I need to say that. It's Mono, not Mono. So I also need to say if you're coming on the Zoom and talking about Mono County and how you're a part of this community, it would be good to pronounce it correctly. And yeah, that's my only pushback. Just some notes that I made.

3:10:55 I don't think I really have anything further to add in terms of my sympathies and where we are. I've been a part of this life. This is how I made my living here for a really long time. And I'm really sorry that our government has failed us. And I will vote for whatever I can for business assistance and housing assistance. And I will not vote to defy state orders, but I will hope to advocate.

3:11:27 Thank you, Sarah. Thank you, Bill. This has been a very good discussion, but I think what we need to come out of this with is what are the strategies and at what level, such as what are we going to do with California? What are we going to do as the county? And what are we going to do locally? So I was thinking...

3:12:04 What would be good to come out of this would be an outline or a listing of, okay, what are we going to advocate for? What are we going to push on? And how are we going to protect our businesses and everything else? Because it's been a free-flowing discussion. So it would be good to have a listing of

3:12:30 You know, and perhaps a priority in that listing of, okay, we're going to do this with the county. We're going to do this with Dr. Boo. We're going to do, you know, the educational aspects and the advocacy aspects. So that's my comment. I want something to come out of this that we can, that we'd have a handle on. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. John. Thank you. I support the,

3:13:03 The proposed motion and the advocacy to the state. I think between the elected officials of the county and the town, we have an excellent team to do that. I think it's important the public to understand that between the EOC, county representatives and the town, there's ongoing and daily engagement with the state. This is something that this group is working on a daily basis to try to get to the solutions we need to get to.

3:13:30 I think I just also want to add that while we're sort of we're focused and obsessing on the real dangers of COVID and the pandemic, public officials, public staff and elected officials are keeping the lights on the trains running. We are doing all the work that's expected of local government and it's continuing even while this pandemic happens. So in the back of most of our minds, I'm assuming most of our minds, are

3:13:59 Mixing it up with the state means risking things like the assistance of the Walker Fire. It means risking the $20 million grant that the town of Mammoth Lakes has for building community housing. We have to keep doing all of this work in parallel, and you're seeing a lot of juggling and balancing going on, but that is the burden that we've all taken on when we take an oath and we serve, and that's what we're doing. And I can't, I've seen nothing but exceptional service from elected officials and public servants all around.

3:14:28 I think we also need to really focus on in Mammoth Lakes what we're going to be doing to help the workforce and renters to the town's community first program. The town is investing, I think we're close to a million dollars. It's going to be a lot more. The council and the staff is playing the long game. We're going to be making sure that this will be sustainable for the long term. Obviously, we cannot replace the needs and the reality of healthy business activity. That's not...

3:14:56 In the end of the day, that's not the role of the public sector to do that. But we're certainly going to do everything we can to support the workforce, the staff, help with mortgages to get people through this thing. So Town of Mammoth Lakes is going to step up. We're going to work with Mono County. And I would just caution, advise all my fellow electives to think of the words you're saying when you're talking about other agencies and other jurisdictions. There will be a reckoning from us down the road. Let's make sure that reckoning is being one of love.

3:15:25 We got this together. We supported each other and that we were not looking back about pointing a finger here or pointing a finger there. This is an existential challenge and we need to rise to it. So I support the motion as presented and thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, John. Linda. Okay. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. After nine other really intelligent, well thought out responses to this.

3:15:57 I could just stop and say, yes, everything they said, and let's move forward. But, you know, my view on this is, you know, from many seats. You know, one is an elected official, one is a longtime resident in Longo County, one is a longtime, you know, kind of a small rental unit that we've had for a while.

3:16:20 Yeah, I see into those things, and I hear what people say, and I just want to take an opportunity to thank all the people who sat here tonight and shared their feelings, their emotions, their hopes and their dreams and their fears. I mean, it was compelling. And definitely, you know, there's nobody that spoke tonight that I didn't, you know, resound with here. Well, almost everybody.

3:16:47 And really feel and understand and try to sort of absorb the level of feeling that people have about this. If I could wave a magic wand and return this to the purple tear tomorrow, I would do that. But I also work in the public health and I see the number of cases that we can just not keep up with.

3:17:15 You know, 90-some cases in a week in this small county is overwhelming. And so I see that reality of it, too. But, you know, 58 counties in the state, and every one of them has their own unique story. Everyone else has their own compelling reasons why this shouldn't apply to us, we should be different. But we are worrying about Mona County. We have good representation. We have people who are, you know, working with the state, you know.

3:17:45 Through the Public Health Department, through Dr. Boo, Brian Wheeler, advocating for our county at that level. We have John Peters, we have Stacey, we have all of our supervisors working at these levels. We have joint communication with other counties. We are working on this as diligently and as hard as possible. So, yes, I...

3:18:11 You know, go back to what was given to us by the chamber, this letter, these, you know, four bullet points. I think that if we concentrate on these, make our case to the state, continue to know that this is not going to go on for every other state, every other county of the city is also advocating to get out of this regional shutdown. There's nobody that wants to stay in that. It is stifling everyone. It is choking businesses everywhere. It's making life untenable for...

3:18:39 So I think we fight the good fight from our seat here in Monop County. We advocate for ourselves. We point out our differences. We point out what we need to be doing. And we stick to that knowing that this is not going to continue, hopefully, you know, one more go around. We have to get control of our numbers. We have to get our numbers down because even if the regional stay-at-home comes off and we stay in the purple, that's not where we want to be for very long.

3:19:08 That's what I'm going to end up with is that in this season, we are friends, we are co-workers, we are neighbors. We need to take care of each other. And even though it appears that maybe we're going at this in different ways, the ultimate goal is the preservation of our community, the preservation of our county, the preservation of our region and our country. The lack of federal leadership in this pandemic has been

3:19:36 Beyond words. You know, Sarah mentioned it, John referred to it, other people have talked about it. It is beyond words. That is why we find ourselves in this hospodge of regulations and county and state. Nobody's doing anything exactly the same. It has been beyond words. So with that being said, I think we're ready to wrap this up. Everyone, thank you for being here. Thank you for helping each other. And let's keep it up until we can.

3:20:02 Peek our nose out of the regional stay at home, at least into purple. Whoever thought we would be happy to be in purple, but I'd be really happy to be in purple today. So thank you all. Good night from all of us. Don't hang up yet. We have more to do, but thank everyone for just being here and being heard. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. I just got another public comment to please make it clear that lodging may not open on the 28th. I think we've already done that, but I will pass that.

3:20:35 Message along. We have no communication from the state one way or the other for what they're going to do. So that being said, there is a recommended motion here to authorize the mayor and chair to co-sign letters to appropriate state officials, including Governor Newsom, Mono County Senate, Assembly Representatives, expressing the negative impacts and other concerns related to the state regional stay-at-home order.

3:21:05 In conjunction with the Chamber of Commerce's Restaurant and Lodging Association and others and other actions as appropriate. So I would entertain a motion if someone wanted to make that. Personally, if it's made, I would like to add into it to advocate for the state when they pass edict to pass along some money to enforce those state edicts with.

3:21:35 Yeah, as long as you go to the Sacramento with that hat on, I think we can all support it. Yeah, well, John, after my tirade, I had to go back to a little Christmas magic, buddy. So I will make that motion as I spoke it, if necessary. I'll second. So I have a motion from me, a second from Supervisor Corliss. Any further deliberation? Jamie, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes.

3:22:14 Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Souser? Yes. Supervisor Corliss? Yes. Supervisor Gardner? Yes. Supervisor Kreitz? Yes. Supervisor Peters? Yes. Supervisor Stump? Probably be my last vote, but yes. We have a passage 10-0 to draw that letter. I'm assuming that Dan Yuen...

3:22:47 Bob, we'll work together on that and give it to Stacey and myself for signature. Thank you. Moving on then. Mr. Mayor, I don't know. I'm sorry. I can see the attendee list. It appears there are at least two hands raised that did not have a chance to speak. It's all right from you. I'm willing to listen to those two people.

3:23:22 Victoria Mobley, will you please unmute yourself and give your comments? Wow, I cannot believe I'm on. I want you all to know that I really appreciate all your work. Can you hear me? Yes. I do. I appreciate all your work. I just don't understand why you guys don't just put a team together. I'm more a marketing person.

3:24:00 And I don't understand why you don't just put a team together and go to the governor and tell them that this town is going to be, there isn't going to be one if we don't do something soon. And now we can't wait. We can't go through another Christmas. I'm not believing I am on, but I want you to know that you need to put, you need to get rusty and you need to get,

3:24:31 You need to get the mountain with you and put together a team and go to Newsom and tell them that they are devastating our town and there's no reason for it. And that's all I want to say. My God, I've been on here forever and I cannot believe you have put me on.

3:24:59 But I love you guys, and I want you to really, really do something, and it's not that hard. Victoria, thank you. You're welcome. Do we have another? Please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you. Can you hear me? Yes, this is actually Carolyn Schwinn talking, and we've been listening the whole evening, and I do appreciate your comments, but I...

3:25:36 Wanted to say that I believe all the legitimate lodging companies, the big rental companies, we're not the biggest in town, but we're all on here listening to, and it's not just a few Airbnb people that spoke from Southern California. And we're very concerned that we aren't open.

3:26:03 Like we've all said, we've done everything we can to comply. All our maids have masks, they have gloves, blah, blah, blah. But I'd like to know, I understand that there are other counties in the state that have joined a lawsuit against the state to be open and to get rid of this stay-at-home order.

3:26:30 And I would like maybe our town attorney or someone to look into it to see if we could get on with something like that so that we don't have to wait another month for the state to come through with changing their plans. But I know it's, you know, a lot of people do have the COVID in town. My understanding is that currently no one's in the hospital. Everyone's home.

3:27:00 And I'd really like you to take into consideration to let us stay open at least through the New Year's week and see how lodging goes during this busiest time and let people come to town, legitimately family groups that we have been told to rent to that we have and let us try to work it out through lodging and see what happens.

3:27:31 So thank you very much. And I know this has been a long night and it's much appreciated. Thank you. Okay. I can address that. Mayor Sauser, I can address the litigation. If you like. This is Andy Morris, County Attorney, Town of Mammoth Lakes. The only county that I'm aware of is San Bernardino County. San Bernardino County filed a suit against the state of California last week asking

3:28:00 They went directly to the California Supreme Court and they asked the court to find that the regional stay-at-home orders are illegal, exceeding the governor's authority. And, you know, we'll just stop and see what happens. I mean, I don't know that there's much of a need for the town or the county to join that. I mean, San Bernardino County has a lot more resources than the town or the county put together. But as with all the other litigation about COVID, and there's been quite a bit of it.

3:28:28 Stacey and I will be monitoring it. We'll be staying on top of it. And if anything happens in the litigation that changes the law, changes the orders, or changes how the town and the county need to be doing business, we will certainly tell the council and the board about it. Thank you, Andy. Any more public comments? Jamie? David Van Wert, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

3:28:59 Yeah, everyone, I just thought I'd let you know real quick, a quick update. While we're chatting here, the town posted on their website that the EOC is advising that everyone cancel all short-term lodging through at least January 4th, as of, you know, probably 30 to 45 minutes ago. So it looks like, you know, the decision's already been made to extend this stay-at-home order. Thank you. Amy? Ryan Murphy, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

3:29:43 Brian Murphy? I believe everybody else that has their hands raised, Mayor Sauser, has already spoken. Okay. Brian, sorry. There you go. Hi, guys. Can you hear me? Yes. Okay. Sorry about that. Computer issues. I just wanted to thank everybody for their efforts as well. I'm a lodging business owner in town.

3:30:19 Here also, so I wanted to echo Carolyn's sentiments and her statement. I'm strongly in support of the Chamber, the Lodging Association, the Restaurant Association. Whatever rock we have to look under, stone we have to unturn. I think that listening to all the comments, it's apparent that everybody has

3:30:44 An appreciation of how dire and how severe the situation is for the local business community here, for the staff, for our owners as well that we represent that have properties up here and the income that they rely on to support those properties.

3:31:03 We are getting to a catastrophic stage. And so I think some things have been made clear in terms of the county and the town's hands being tied. And I appreciate the fact that everybody's pulling in the right direction and trying the best that they can. And I'm hopeful that that continues. And I'm hopeful that we find a solution very quickly.

3:31:30 Somebody just came on and said that, you know, it's been recommended that we're closed until the fourth now. Hopefully that's just not true in my ear. I had something in my ears. But if it is, then we're going to have to deal with it. I want to make two final points. One is, I just wonder about the penalties involved to the county and the town and whether from a, you know, strictly economic standpoint.

3:31:56 The TOT revenues outweigh whatever funding comes from the state. That would be my one comment. It would be interesting to look at that. I would encourage you guys to look at that as well. And then the other comment was, you know, what if the county and the town tells the state that we simply don't have the resources to enforce this order? If Inyo County is doing that and they're getting away with it, what prevents us from doing the same thing?

3:32:25 I'm hopeful that you guys are going to continue to look at every possible available option and we find ourselves through this and hopefully most of us can survive it. Thanks a lot. Thank you, Brian. Okay, with that, I think we've come to the end of this item. I thank you all for your patience and for your efforts. I will now move on to item number four.

3:32:59 Authorization of additional funds for the town's community-first housing and business assistance programs. Take it away, Dan. Thank you. As we've had previous discussions on, and let me, real quick, this is probably a town item, but if the board of supervisors hang out, if they can, I'd love to, at the end of the meeting, sign the agenda, but I'd like to say thank you to Fred Stump, formerly from the town and town council for his service.

3:33:29 Sorry, Fred, you don't get out that easily. The item before you, though, is really is how do we step back in and continue to support our community with housing rental assistance and also with our business assistance program. The council did allocate some money already for these programs and updated it as well just recently. Given the response that we've had from the current round of funding that we will very quickly exceed what we've already allocated.

3:33:59 So the request is to put up to another kind of up to $50,000 in rental housing assistance and $300,000 in business assistance. And the business assistance is one of those elements that our goal is kind of that short term keep businesses going and open so they can retain employees. They can make the payroll if need be. They can continue through that because ultimately their success benefits directly to our employees.

3:34:24 The employees in our workforce, in our community, keeping them employed and keeping them here so that as we hopefully move out of this thing sooner than later that they will be here and able to step back into that employment role. I was going to ask Sandra Moberly to just touch base real quick on what we did for the first round. It was open very short. She's been spending a few extra hours to say the least in reviewing the applications that came in. We do have one.

3:34:51 criteria modification that we're considering as well. Sandra? Thanks, Dan. So we received 37 complete applications for this round of business assistance. We had a lot more people who kind of started the application but didn't actually finish in the middle of their information. Of those 37, 12 of them meet the requirements of the grant.

3:35:16 The biggest requirement that people didn't meet was the requirement to have a 50% loss between 2019 and 2020. There's a number of applicants who didn't meet that. And the average loss of the people who didn't meet that was about 26%. So they lost 26% between 2019 and 2020.

3:35:39 So I think Dan is kind of alluding to the fact that we might look at the percentage loss for the next round, which would kind of be round five of the business assistance program. And for these 12 applicants, that 50% loss, if we awarded them 100% of what they requested, we would send out about $180,000. Typically, we don't give them the full grant award. It kind of depends on the need.

3:36:06 I did send all of the applications to our selection committee, so they are reviewing the applications hopefully as we speak, and we'll get those all completed and get the checks cut next week. So I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about it. I think that changing that percentage loss will result in a lot more businesses being able to take advantage of this grant program.

3:36:29 And one of the reasons looking at that, it does not include, I don't think it includes like December, the month where now a lot of people are taking a huge loss. It obviously would not, doesn't currently carry into January, but definitely seeing some shifts in that. And so this may be a way to, again, provide, I think we had about 70 or 80 people who started the program process, only about, as Sandra mentioned, 31 or so that actually completed it. In part, potentially looking at, well, I'm not sure I qualify, so.

3:36:57 The other note I want to make at this point, it does not include lodging, just given the shared number and other issues, we're having some real challenges how to make something fair that works through that. You can always come back and look at that, but at this point, it's looking at the other businesses and a very large number of those. Thank you, Dan. Any questions for Dan or Sandra? Sorry, starting with who? Linda.

3:37:34 Nothing. Okay. John? I have some comments and questions. Bill, I'm assuming you'll come back to us after public comment. I've got a couple of thoughts. We can do that. Yes. Kirk? Nothing. Sarah? No comments. Thank you. Thank you. I have no questions as well. I support this. Do we have any public comments on this item? Please unmute yourself and give your comments.

3:38:21 Villager? Jackie Dobson, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Jackie Dobson? Jackie, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Andrea Walker, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hey, guys. We're still here. Thank you for being here and for your long hours that you're putting in on all of them. My only concern is that after so many business funding grants, SBA loans, and all of that, which is appreciative,

3:39:21 That's going to really impact us once it becomes tax time. You know, like when we have to go and do our taxes, we're going to basically be having to, and please correct me if I'm wrong, because this is the reason that I'm not applying for any more funding, is I just feel like all of a sudden my income tax bill is going to be really, really high, and it's going to be almost counteractive to any help it might provide. So that's my thought on the funding, though it's appreciated.

3:39:51 It also has a tax impact at the end of it, too. It's not the same as being able to do business and actually having an income. And also, too, I have to state that, like, my business is probably the least impacted in all of this. So when I speak, I'm more so speaking for my dear, beloved community. And thank you. Thank you, Andrea. Any more, Jamie? Jackie Dobson, are you back? Do you want to?

3:40:22 Thank you so much. I was just wondering, and I had asked this question earlier and didn't get an answer. I was wondering what the legal ramifications would be if all of the businesses in town band together and just opened. Because I have honestly been part of a community of local business owners that are talking about doing that. And we'd love to have the town backing us and to do this with a united front.

3:40:51 But I was wondering from a town's perspective what the legal ramifications would be of an action like that. Andy, would you like to do that? Sure, I can do that. This is Andy Morris, Town Attorney for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. What the town and the county have done to address a couple restaurants that have not complied with closure orders up until now has been to go and cite them and then issue an order requiring them to close.

3:41:23 In that case or in those cases, it was until they could demonstrate that all their employees had been tested and demonstrate that they were complying with all the COVID requirements. I think we got pretty close to taking at least one of those. Well, actually, I think the county did take one of those businesses to court. The town got pretty close to taking the other business to court because it was within Mammoth Lakes. But probably that's kind of how it would roll out. It would be first contacting businesses that were

3:41:52 Doing the wrong thing and trying to explain to them they need to do the right thing. And then having follow-up conversations explaining to them exactly what would be coming, which could be loss of licenses, reporting them to state alcoholic beverage control people, and then ultimately could be an injunction ordering them to close down. I have not heard anything from the council or from the board of supervisors tonight indicating that they would support businesses just

3:42:21 Ignoring the closure orders and opening up. I'm not hearing anything that the town and county would be willing to look the other way. I suspect it would kind of lay out an education and an enforcement path as has been done previously. Thank you, Andy. Hopefully that answers the question. Do we have anyone else? Vita Klein, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

3:42:52 Hi, I think the lawyer for the city of Mammoth or whoever that guy was just now missed the point. She's asking for all of us to band together and go against Newsom. And the lawyer's just saying, oh, we'll come and, you know, tap you on the shoulder and then give you a warning and then we'll take you to the liquor board or whatever. I think he's missing the point. And also on another note,

3:43:21 The TOT guy, Rob, he said, they sent us a notice saying, if you rent, you're going to be fined $1,000 a night, you're going to be losing your license. And now he's saying, oh, we just go over and ask them not to rent. And if they don't comply, then we take their license away. Well, you know, in these weeks of Christmas and New Year's,

3:43:47 That is like the deal breaker for us. I just lost rentals, I don't know, for two, three weeks now. You mean I could have rented and he would just be tacked to me on the shoulder and I would say, oh, sorry, Rob, I didn't know. And then maybe later he comes and gives me a ticket or just, you know, finds me a thousand a night. That doesn't make sense.

3:44:18 You guys just, you know, you send out these letters that are almost like, hey, you know, again, hammering the point, but not really. Oh, no, we've only sent out, Rob said he's only had two issues or two people that he's gotten to find or take their license away. I have lost $20,000 in these two weeks.

3:44:47 And he's saying, I cannot believe, he's saying he just tapped the people on the shoulder, and if they were going to listen to him, then he didn't do anything. That's like, it's a large part of my income that I lost. And TOT is not, you know, putting those people in their place. That's just horrible. It's horrible for those that...

3:45:18 That are listening to you guys. Please do something. I mean, we should not be tapping people on the shoulder and saying, oh, you need to listen to the TOT rules. If we're going to set the rules, then people need to abide by it. For God's sake, I've lost so much money in the last two, three weeks. And I'm hearing only two people were told by Rob, and he's got like three or four other guys. I know all of them in the office.

3:45:48 Come on, guys. Either put the rule down on everyone or don't. Let me rent and get my $20,000 and I can pay you your $1,000 a night. I mean, I should have just done that and just play dumb like whoever it is that Rob is going after. I mean, it doesn't make sense to follow the rules anymore. Anyway, that's all. Thank you. Jamie? Seth Maniaci, please unmute yourself and give your comments.

3:46:21 Yeah. First of all, for those who don't know, this is disinformation, the notion that people in Bishop are breaking the law. There are plenty of second homeowners in Bishop that are renting their places out and having no issues, and they are within the law. You want to know why they're within the law? Because the Constitution says they're within the law, and the sheriff down there is obliging the Constitution. Do your homework on this, folks.

3:46:49 The sheriff is the officer of the Constitution, and it's appalling to me that you public officials haven't mentioned the Constitution iota. A disgrace, in my opinion. And furthermore, you second homeowners, and I feel the true, raw emotion from you. I do. I do. If you want real change, if you want real support, you can tell, you can hear it. You're hearing the voice of our public officials right now.

3:47:17 They're not hearing you. They're not listening to you. If you want real change, you need an officer of the Constitution. We've given these people nine months to right this ship. They're listening to medical advice that is completely unsustained, unfounded. The PCR test is...

3:47:39 Complete garbage. Please, do your own homework. Come to your conclusions. Understand this. This is a controlled demolition of the middle class and nothing less. Join me in this fight. I hereby nominate, of my own free will, Sergeant Joe Vedder of the MLPD for Sheriff of Monroe County. You can find me at Fighters Red Pill.

3:48:03 On Facebook, you can find the recall page on Facebook as well. I have given this sheriff plenty of opportunities to answer my calls and return my calls, and she won't. She's been castrated. She's at the will of the governor, and that's enough. Seth, I don't want any personal attacks here. We're trying to get information.

3:48:23 Sorry. I'm calling the facts out, sir. Unfortunately, you may disagree with these facts. You're not the only person that knows the Constitution. How come you guys aren't talking about the Constitution? You just want to throw your weight around and try to impress me with your poster. Thank you, Jamie. Zachary Krieger, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hi, everyone. That was interesting to say at least. I spoke last week regarding what you've already heard many times tonight.

3:48:55 Second homeowners struggling to pay their mortgage. I'm right there in the same boat as them. What I'm hearing is that the town council is considering throwing more money into the funding for small businesses. And I would really appreciate if short-term rentals are considered in the next rounds of funding. We are viable. We are businesses that exist within

3:49:25 The town of Mammoth Lakes. In fact, a lot of us are very small businesses that are just trying to survive like everyone else. And it was upsetting to me to see that the last round didn't consider us as part of that funding. And I understand that there's not a lot of money to go around, but every little bit helps. And it would, you know, kind of dilute the double standard of...

3:49:52 You know why some businesses are getting money and some aren't and some businesses are open and some aren't if even a little bit came to those who need it desperately. I live and work in Mono County. I absolutely love this place and I want to be able to stay here and that kind of money would help. So I just wanted to put my voice in there as well. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Zach. Jamie? That is all.

3:50:25 Thank you. Okay, John, I will come back to you for comments on this item. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Dan, Rob, all of us will remember when we started getting into this six, seven months ago, we talked about having those three tiers of the budget and expectations for dollars to spend. I think I'm more than happy to support this this evening, but I'm asking staff to come up with a six-month

3:50:53 Expenditure, anticipated expenditure plan. We need to start really looking at how sustainable this is going to be and how we're going to be able to target funding going forward. So I would want to include that as part of the motion and also to have clear identification of the sources of the money we're going to be using to make these payments and to support these programs going forward.

3:51:17 You can easily anticipate we're going to get into an all-hands-on-deck contribution mode to support our community, which includes our organization. These are conversations I think we need to start having at some point, but I just want to make sure that we are, let's look at this with a six-month horizon, worst-case scenario, so we can share with our constituents and ourselves what we're going to be able to sustain as we go forward. So that's my, I would like to add that to the motion once that motion comes forward. Thank you.

3:51:48 Anyone else want to speak? Have comments on that from Council? Raise your hand. I'm seeing none. Bill, can I just say as a resident of Mammoth Lakes, I really appreciate Council taking this action and all that Council and Town staff have done to support residents and businesses. Thank you. Thank you very much, Stacey. So, John, if you want to add something to the motion, I would suggest you make it.

3:52:22 Thank you, Mr. Mayor. So I would move that the Town Council authorize the Town Manager to provide an additional allocation of up to $50,000 in rental housing assistance and up to $300,000 in business assistance and to provide to the Town Council an expenditure program covering the six months starting with the month of January, advising the Town Council on

3:52:50 The sustainability of resources to continue to support these programs for Council's consideration at a future date. Thank you, John. I have a motion from John. Do I hear a second? A second. I have a motion from John, a second from Linda. Any further deliberations? Or you can ask for clarification of what John just said, if that's what you need. Seeing none, I will ask for the question. Jamie? Council Member Ray? Yes. Council Member Staff? Yes.

3:53:33 Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Passes five votes. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I just want to say thank you for that. And we are planning to be back on January 6th with a budget update. And before we adjourn the meeting, if you don't mind, I would like to express thank you to Supervisor Fred Stump. I've dealt with him in a number of different capacities.

3:54:03 Sat on some boards and stuff. His involvement, comments, you know, thought process, I've really appreciated and just wanted to take an opportunity publicly to say thank you for your service and thank you for your just engagement in a number of areas. I know none of our employees live in your district and they often make comments related to you and the vast majority are positive.

3:54:31 If not all of them, frankly. They do enjoy having you represent them. So I just want to add my thank you to you for your service, and I really appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you, Fred. Thank you very much. Yes, ditto. Who's going to lead us in for he's a jolly good fellow? Dr. Boo will. Dr. Boo? No, I'm going to miss you, Fred. You know, I missed you when I stopped working full-time at the county.

3:55:03 You know, you were a great neighbor, great friend, worked really, really hard, always with the best intention, always with passion, and always with the wish for the best for everybody, and you will be sorely missed, very hard to replace. Thank you, Fred. You're here. And I also want to thank all the supervisors for their participation tonight, and all the council members for sitting through what was a lengthy meeting.

3:55:34 And for putting up with my initial tirade and then me losing my patience with our last speaker. That being said, I will adjourn this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council and Mono County Supervisors. Thank you all. Happy holidays. Merry Christmas, everybody. Merry Christmas. Happy holidays, everybody. Bye. Bye. Bye.