Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2021
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 2 hr 24 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
297 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Got my first shot of Moderna. How? Wow, that's exciting. MLT was running the volunteer pool out there at the firehouse, and at the end of the vaccination period, they had somewhere about 12 to 15 extra shots. So we started frantically calling people that we knew were in that demographic, and yeah, I managed to get one in my shoulder. How do you feel today?
0:30 I didn't have any side effect whatsoever. I mean, it's literally the same kind of soreness that you have after a flu shot, at least for me. But no, I felt great last night. No problem. No issues. No, no crazy dreams. Nothing. Great. Well, I registered. I'm hoping that if there's, if that happens, that I can get on the list as well. So we'll see. Yeah, definitely. Maybe reach out to Linda. Let her know. Sure. Okay. And you have a hard listen. And I'll tell you what, Sandra.
1:01 It was a frantic 10 to 20 minutes where they were just calling people saying, if you can get down here in the next five minutes, we'll get you. But if you can't, we're going on to the next person. Okay. All right. I'll text, I'll let Linda know. That's a good, good point. Looks like you're in sweet Z, huh, Sandra? I am in sweet Z, yep. Do we have Jamie today or Angie? Jamie. Hi, guys. I'm sorry, I missed that. Who is it? It's Jamie. Hey, Jamie. Hi.
1:38 Is there any members of the public in Sweet Tea currently? No. Paul. Yeah, Paul will be here. Commissioner Eckert, you look like you are a Zoom master now. You've got to unmute yourself, Greg. Oh, sure. Spoke too early, maybe. Is this just payroll? Okay, it looks like we have the entire commission here. I've got two o'clock on the nose. Sandra, are you good with me calling this to order? Okay.
3:02 Good afternoon, everyone. Good to see all your faces. I would like to call to order the Wednesday, January 13th, 2021 Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Jamie, may we have a roll call, please? Commissioner Chang? Here. Commissioner Eckert? Commissioner Eckert? I know. I'm not watching the video, though. Commissioner Kennedy? Here. Vice Chair Burroughs? Present. Chair Vanderhurst?
3:40 Present. And just for the record, I do want to make sure we have that Commissioner Eckert is attending, is present. He might just be having some technical issues with his Zoom microphone. Do you have the audio now? Yeah, we got the audio now. All right, well, the good news is I got the audio. Better news for you folks is I lost the video, so let's move on.
4:10 All right, if you guys wouldn't all mind standing for the Pledge of Allegiance, and Commissioner Burroughs, will you please lead us? I pledge allegiance of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. I would like to invite the to address the commission during public comment. I would ask that if...
4:41 Your public comment is in regards to something that's a little bit later in our agenda that you wait until that agenda item is being discussed. Do we have anyone for public comment, Jamie? No, we do not. And nobody digitally on Zoom. We do have Stuart Brown on Zoom. I do see Stuart Brown. Good afternoon, my friend. Evening, Chair. Evening, Commission. Well, afternoon. Man, it's only two o'clock. Sorry about that.
5:12 It's all blended together. Do you want me to provide a brief update on COVID and vaccinations? You wouldn't mind, Stu. It would be appreciated. Helpful. Okay, great. Thank you. I will just pop up a screen here. Just bear with me. Let's see what we got. There we go. All right. Let me know if everybody can see that. We got it. Thank you. So this was...
5:42 I know this is real time. So this changes minute by minute. I think I just looked like five minutes ago and I just put this up an hour ago. It's now up to 769, but that's okay. We're at 769, 765, about 35 minutes ago. And you can see here the kind of the break between the cases, North County, Mammoth Lakes, obviously the high population area, more dense, so forth, and 62 South and East County.
6:12 And we're still at the four fatalities. The latest 30-day case count, 765, as I mentioned, 769. It's about a 63% increase over a 30-day period. So that's, you know, tracking clearly in the wrong direction. Seven-day case metrics, seven days tested, two, 16, 97 positive, and it's a very high 31%. I mean, this obviously fluctuates on each day.
6:41 When the test results come in through public health, you can see the big, the big days here is, that's 42 positive cases there on the 10th, that's 30 positive cases there on the 7th, 12, you know, yesterday. So again, these are big numbers and the positivity rate is kind of fluctuating between 25 and 42, sorry, 25 and 31%. And then this was as of January 13th.
7:10 That was run yesterday by Public Health. And you can see again that positivity rate seven days from 1.3 to 1.9. Sorry, 1.3 to 1.9 is just under 25%. And we've been around 20%, you know, for the last several weeks. You can see that kind of the jump in cases there was correspondingly around the Thanksgiving period. And you can see we have a little table there that kind of shows you that same information.
7:36 From the beginning of November through January 9th. And you can kind of see we would really want to go back to that 9%. That looks really good. We're even at 3.98%. But then obviously, clearly we're in a different time. And we're seeing, you know, very high case rates. Mammoth Hospital status is still green. And we get those updates every day from our partners at the Mammoth Hospital. They have seen...
8:03 COVID hospitalisations, don't know if they currently have any at this time. So far, we've been pretty fortunate, honestly, with very low hospitalisation rates from a high positivity rate throughout Mono County. I know quite a few of our residents would move to kind of the North County area and certainly South County towards Northern Inyo or Renowned or healthcare providers up in Nevada, but so far Mammoth Hospital is green.
8:33 Again, we're still in the stay-at-home order. They run these numbers every day. Good news today was, I'll just kind of bump to this next slide, that the Greater Sacramento area has been released from the stay-at-home order. Got out of jail, free card, that's great. Their four-week projections are clearly identifying that they will remain above, or remain above, correct, 15% adult ICU capacity for a four-week period.
9:03 And those criteria there in the middle of the screen is how they calculate the ICU projections. Obviously don't need to read those to you. I kind of popped up this slide here because it speaks to the next one. When you look at the map of California, this is currently the blueprint for a safer economy tiers. I know everybody's probably forgot about this. Dr. Garley yesterday, I think, reminded everybody it's been kind of 19 weeks since the blueprint started.
9:33 This kind of shows you that 99% of the state is under this purple or most widespread tier. So very still restrictive. They run, let me just go to this slide here. They run those numbers frequently. And I know Commissioner Kennedy had some questions on the blueprint. So if I don't answer them here, just jump in and ask those questions.
9:58 But we'll be assigned to our tier based on our current metrics. The two metrics they use to assign the tier are these two here, the positivity rate and the case rate. These two numbers here that you can see, the 18%, the 95.2, they were numbers at the end of December that the state is reporting. So clearly, we're well over that widespread tier. I mean, we only have, you know, we're greater than 8%. We've got to be between 5% and 8%.
10:26 To get back to the red tier. So clearly we're over that. And the case rate of 95.2 is well past. Yeah, clearly those criteria. So we have upwards of 35 for the small county. So that's kind of how we gauge them here. So we have, we can have 35 cases per week, which is kind of where they run them. They used to be two weeks and now they kind of shorten that timeframe down to a seven day period. So we, we allow.
10:54 We are allowed 35 cases each week to remain in that red tier before we get moved to purple. So you can see we would have to get our case rates under 35 per week, which is not happening at this time. I'm just going to jump forward. I think everybody's familiar with the lodging order that was revised. And then I think everybody's understanding that
11:22 A memo came from the town just kind of clarifying the essential workers and how the approval from the approval of those essential workers and the process that the town is now requiring lodging operators to follow that's been published on the town website. Essentially now it's really the requirement of the occupant to self-attest of their
11:51 Visit to Mammoth Lakes regarding short-term rentals. So that's kind of how that's being managed now. The updated travel advisory from January 6 provided some, I think, more defined kind of narrative and definitions clearly for non-essential travel. And then really kind of saying, you know, you shouldn't be traveling any kind of greater than 120 miles from your place of residence.
12:17 And if you are arriving from other states or countries, you should practice self-quarantine for 10 days after arrival. We have updated business resources on the portal. I think everybody's seen this, all these new forms that we're talking about here on the transient rental occupancy and those are under this kind of form graphic here. So definitely look for those.
12:44 Business Assistance Programs, $400,000 is now available through Mammoth Lakes Housing. I believe this program was reset, so maybe Sandra can clarify, but I believe if you received the maximum housing assistance previously of the four times, you're not able to reapply. Community First Programs, I know Sandra will probably talk about this later, but we awarded $180,000 in Round 4, have $520,000 for Round 5.
13:15 Those applications closed today at 5 o'clock. Business Assistance Programs, this is kind of more countywide. You can see the PPE Round 2 Program, California Small Business Grant Relief Program. These are the kind of categories here in that table. And the Mono County CURE Program awarded 420,000 to 48 eligible businesses. I want to kind of touch base, you know, here's obviously a food bank coming up on January 9th. This is next weekend, 10 a.m. to 12 p.m.
13:46 19th, Stu. Yeah, 19th. I think it's what it says, right? Yeah, you said the 9th, so. Good heavens. Sorry about that. So, that's why I even underline it, right? Down around 19th. Sorry about that. 10 a.m. is 12 p.m. Testing. Again, all this information is on the portal. We are testing twice at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, Monday, Thursday. Next week, they'll actually be testing up in the Lee Vining area.
14:15 So I believe that's going to be on Wednesday in Lee Bining. So look for that on the portal when we get that posted. Want to kind of just touch base here. We have a new pre-registration process. So you can certainly scan this. This is kind of what we recommend if you do want to get tested at the public health locations at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. Verily also have the same option. Definitely pre-register. So when you get to the self-swab line at the Mammoth Lakes Foundation parking lot there.
14:42 It'll go that much faster for you. And these results are coming back within three to four days, which is great. Vaccine update. I'll just get through this. I know there's a lot of change here. There's a bit of movement today with some of the occupations and ages from the state. But we were fortunate to receive just under 3,000 doses that are arriving next week, which is great news. Thanks to Brian and the public health team.
15:11 Again, want to make sure everybody's aware that they're free and voluntary. We're following all federal and state guidance. And if we're looking at some updated information, if you haven't got to this website yet, this is our new vaccine dashboard. So look for the vaccinations infographic on the main page of the portal. We want to just be as timely, accurate and transparent as we can. So we're providing the public with updated vaccine information of how much we've received, how many we're dosing.
15:40 for our first and second doses. And we kind of have to wait till a lot of this information is uploaded into a kind of state portal, kind of takes a little bit of time. IT is trying to automate this as best they can. And I'm pretty sure that the hospital received their second doses yesterday. So that's probably an update on that post there.
16:02 Again, this is probably the biggest push that we want to encourage every county residents to complete. This is to kind of pre-register by submitting this questionnaire. This is now in English and Spanish. So definitely click on this link. I know we had some issues. We believe we've resolved most of those, but please let us know if there's still problems that you're unable to submit the questionnaire. And again, just want to clarify, this is not pre-registering you for the vaccine. It's basically just providing information to public health.
16:32 For us to be able to kind of segment all those interested in receiving the vaccine, and then you would receive an additional email that's kind of generated through a state system, it's called PrepMod, that's when you would actually go in and pre-register. So just by completing this questionnaire doesn't mean you're registered, it means you're in the list, and then when your tier and occupation is available and is up, then you will receive a pre-registration to register.
16:59 For your specific pod or clinic. So again, I just want to make sure that's really clear with everybody there. I know there's a lot of confusion. So again, please pre-register. Quick update here on where we're at. You know, we can see we're almost through phase 1A, T1 to T3 again. This is Dr. Burrows getting vaccinated, I think on December 21st. Hopefully they received their second dose yesterday. We are now scheduling phase 1B, T1.
17:30 Just individuals 75 years of age or older. And you can see the different categories here. I know we're already kind of vaccinating a lot of our teachers, a lot of Facebook posts. I saw the sheriff actually got her first dose today, which is great. So this is kind of the non-medical first responders, law enforcement, fire. So we're working through that group. Food and agriculture, these are kind of farm workers.
17:52 Throughout the county, as well as kind of grocery stores. Vons, we understand, are actually going to vaccinate themselves. They'll actually receive doses from Vons. Vons is kind of acquiring doses and they'll vaccinate themselves, which is great. But again, this is that larger category of our restaurant workers throughout the county as well. So this is kind of a big tier. So they're kind of digging into this right now. So all the pre-registration emails are getting out.
18:19 Phase 1B, Tier 2. I've kind of put an asterisk against this age of 65 to 74. The state just released about an hour ago that they're going to move this age group up into Tier 1. So Phase 1B, Tier 1. So they'll be moved up. So essentially we'll be vaccinating any age group above 65. These are the other sectors here in Tier 2. So transportation.
18:47 Industrial, commercial, residential, sheltering facilities and services, critical manufacturing, which we don't have in the county, but we will be reaching and vaccinating any homeless, unhoused or incarcerated individuals. Any questions? I know we've received this a lot. We get a lot of emails, a lot of calls. If you're unsure of where you fit in these categories, the...
19:10 COVID-19.ca.gov website, just Google, just put in their little search field there, essential workers, and that category and all those occupations are really spelled out very specifically. So if you're looking for any additional detail, that's where you can find it. It's also available on the Vaccinate Questionnaire as well. Phase 1, CT1, this is probably, you know, later February, March.
19:38 So this is individuals 50 plus, people 16, 49, any underlying health conditions. And you can see just a big swath of the final kind of what they're calling the essential workforce list. And then phase two, phase three will be kind of the spring. I didn't list those, but that's basically the general population. We have some FAQs on the website as well. So if you're looking for information, these are all ones you can provide. We can get your answers to. And again, a lot of information is available, CDC, FDA.
20:08 And CDBH there as well. With that, kind of our next larger community conversation is January 21. And this was kind of our slide that we provide just general information. Again, want to encourage everybody to subscribe to receive the COVID newsletter sent every Tuesday and Friday. And with that, Chair, I will pause and take any questions that the commissioners may have. Thank you, Stu. That was very thorough. And we always appreciate it when you...
20:36 Come before us and give us these updates. So thank you for the time, Stu. Very welcome. Anybody on the commission have any questions for something Stu might have covered in his presentation up to this point? I have a question. Go ahead, Greg. It's not really a category. It's more of a vector. So if you've got people who are in a high-risk situation, you know, elderly, and especially when we have a lot of...
21:07 Thank you so much.
21:34 If they get six out of a bottle of five, or if somebody doesn't show up, or if there's some way of having a call list that we can bump some of these folks up who would otherwise be exposing their family members, essentially what you're saying is until April or June, is there any way we could have some sort of a will call list or something like that for those type of folks? Question. Thank you.
22:05 I don't think, I believe the county has some discretion in these tiers because every county is unique. That is a question probably we have to direct to public health. I don't believe I could probably give you the right answer today, Commissioner. So I will probably refrain from that, but I'll try and get an answer to you and share it with Sandra if that's available. And then Sandra can probably get that back out to the commissioners and share that with any constituents that are asking those questions.
22:32 Stu, would you mind if I jump in? I'm asking that question. So, Greg, I volunteered yesterday at the vaccination center over at Firehouse 2, and I will tell you at the end of the time period allotted for appointments, County Health did have a handful of extra doses, and they did
23:00 Have a printed out list of people they started calling to say, come down here. If you could be here in the next five to 10 minutes, we'll get you a shot. If not, we're going on to the next name on the list. Now, how that list was compiled, Greg, I don't know. But I can tell you, it was an absolute scramble to make sure that not a single dose is wasted. As they shouldn't be. I'm just saying there's a lot of people that are not...
23:33 They're not as well informed or as involved as some of us are. And that there is a very large underserved community in a lot of multi-generational households where there's a big risk that could possibly be addressed this way. And we absolutely acknowledge that too, Commissioner. And we've been working with a contracted firm called BPQ. Bobby Pena is kind of running this.
24:04 We've been kind of working with Bobby for a couple of months and he's kind of created with our public health and our behavioral team a pretty impressive list of kind of our Latino influences. Through that list, we...
24:17 Our goal is to more effectively communicate because, you know, digitally that's a challenge. You know, not everybody in these families and households that are living together, as you described, which we recognise, have emails. I mean, I don't know if the grandparents have emails, the parents have emails, most likely the kids have emails, but, you know, they need to register themselves. So what we're really trying to look at is what are the forms of communication can we implement for that group? And that's probably the phone.
24:45 Certainly word of mouth, you know, printed material. So we're kind of digging into how we can kind of better communicate and provide them perhaps a 211, 800 phone number, whatever it is, for them to reach and actually talk to somebody that will help them pre-register or inform them when their time is, you know, coming and how they can actually become involved. Through the general population, once we get through these kind of essential workers,
25:12 It will be kind of that, you know, first come first serve type of scenario. But then we're also still trying to schedule people to come at a specific time because I think as the chair realized yesterday, if everybody comes at the same time and there's two to three hundred people, that's overwhelming. I mean, we really can't obviously keep up with that, you know, level of demand.
25:33 We're trying to provide some of that structure and honestly, it's the team is doing remarkably well considering all the challenges that you're hearing about throughout the state. You know, fortunately, we have a smaller county, we know these smaller groups, but again, absolutely our Latino speakers are certainly a part of our community that we don't want to neglect and we want to make sure they have the opportunity and it's equitable for each and every, you know, county resident. Thanks, Jim. No, you're very welcome. Thank you.
26:03 Commissioner Kennedy, I believe you had a question. Yeah, thank you, Michael. Stu, I guess, first of all, this is great news about the vaccines. Thank you so much for this update. I feel so lucky to be living in this county and I'm excited to see this keep going and us to do really well compared to this country that are not doing the best. So thank you and thanks to everyone involved in that. My question is back to the kind of first thing you were talking about with the
26:31 Tier System, where most of the state is still in purple. Are you able to share what the difference is in terms of function of businesses going from the stay-at-home regional order to purple? So if we were to have, if we were to be in purple tier right now, what would change in terms of businesses being able to operate? Yeah, so we briefly spent, thank you, Commissioner, for the question. We briefly spent, I think, what, I think everybody a week, maybe, in purple. You know, we went to red.
27:01 Went to Purple, and then within that next week, we're in the stay-at-home order. So we were briefly in Purple, and I think everybody was kind of horrified at the time of being in Purple, but I think all we all realize now is, hey, be thrilled to be in Purple. Biggest change is really indoor dining, right? I think from a Purple tier, it allows kind of that indoor dining component, you know, indoor retail. There's no restrictions on the retail.
27:25 So it's indoor activity. So really the stay-at-home order is all predominantly outdoor activity based. The stay-at-home order, sorry, the purple tier is kind of allowing more of those indoor activities. So it's more of the retail and the restaurants. As far as the lodging, you know, our lodging and the board of supervisors in the town have their separate lodging order. So the operators in the county and certainly the town are subject to that order, not to...
27:54 You know, what's specified by the state. So anyway, at this time, it's really, Commissioner, indoor kind of activities that would be open in purple. I thought in purple, it was no indoor dining at all. Was I reading that wrong? Is that, has anyone known? I believe it's permitted at a certain level. And I would encourage anybody to kind of jump on here. I didn't pull that slide up, but this website right there, covid19.ca.gov.
28:25 It's right there in the middle, blueprint for a safer economy. Click on that tier. You'll actually just punch in Mono County. You can see where we're at, or you can kind of look at these different tiers and, you know, what activities permitted. So that's probably what I'd recommend instead of making stuff up for you right now. I don't want to provide inaccurate information. Commissioner Kennedy, I think I do recall that 25% of indoor dining was allowed in the red tier. In the purple tier, there was no indoor dining. There was outdoor dining and takeout.
28:54 But also in the purple tier, personal services, you know, like haircuts and that, you know, hair salons, that those kind of personal services were allowed in the purple tier at a very, very reduced rate. Gotcha. Okay. That's what I thought I was reading. And we can talk more about this later in the agenda. But I guess my question is wondering what the letter later that we're talking about later mentions purple tier. And so it's a big difference to me if it's.
29:23 25%, you know, if it's some capacity of indoor dining or not. So I'll see if I can track that down. But thank you so much, Stu. That's all. And then we were operating, as Stu said, the town had a policy in place that lodging could operate at 70% in the purple tier. Got it. It's obviously a very, very large increase from what we have now. Perfect. Thank you so much, Michael. Anybody else have a question for Stu? Hey, Stu, I got a really quick one.
29:53 I know you've mentioned and I heard yesterday that you guys will be getting the 3,000 doses either at the tail end of this week or early, early next week or perhaps even over the weekend. Have you guys set up any sort of vaccination location schedule for next week? I'm getting a lot of inquiries. Short answer, I don't believe so. I don't know if they're doing it right now. But that would come from, yeah, they have to schedule.
30:18 We have to get it first. You know, we know it's potentially coming. So once it's here, I think they'll schedule those. I think the first one is the 20th. I think there's some carryover clinics next week for the second doses. And then I think the first one is the 20th. And then I think they're looking at scheduling those after that. But I think there'll be clinics every day pretty much from the 20th when those vaccines do arrive. So pretty aggressive schedule. You know, with the 75 years and older, you know,
30:48 We think that category, you know, that first category of 1B is probably, you know, 1,000 to 1,500 people. How many of those people we think will actually get vaccinated, we're not too sure, but that's kind of the top line number. So we've got quite a bit of work to do next week to get that group vaccinated. Got it. Thank you, Stu. You bet. And I think we'll let you go now, Stu. I know you're a busy guy. Thank you. Appreciate the update. Very welcome. See you next time, guys. Thank you.
31:18 And Jen, I'm assuming you want to address us in public comment as well. Thank you. Yeah, I have a short and quick update this time. So since last month, we have 29 current cases open. And in the last 30 days, we've closed 18 cases. So that just shows that we have a lot less open cases at the moment. I think the holidays played a role in that. And the trend for the last 30 days would be unpermitted deck repairs. The nice weather is...
31:48 Let allow people to work on their decks and we're educating them on what is required. And that is all for me. Thank you guys. Hold on a sec, Jen, if you wouldn't mind. Does anybody have a question for Jenna on code compliance? No, you guys are good. I've got a couple of quick coupons for you, Jenna. I left you a voicemail at the tail end of last week. I know you were out of town. I don't know if you've had a chance to go through your voicemail box yet. Still going through them. Thank you, Michael. Okay.
32:18 The other thing I have a question for you, Jenna, is, and this is kind of a weird one, but how far in the rears, if someone is in egregious violation of the COVID-19 restrictions, how long of a grace period do we allow before, you know, it's no longer a relevant case and we can look into it? Are you referring to businesses?
32:43 No, I'm referring to a high school New Year's Eve party that happened down the street from both Stu and Jennifer Burroughs that has contributed to a very large outbreak of COVID-19 amongst high school kids. That's one I have to look into. So normally we would take a case-by-case to answer your question, though, if it were like a business and we can immediately get on them and we can usually give them some kind of written notice.
33:12 And then, you know, the power to shut them down or stop their business from operating. When it comes to private like this and individuals, this is a whole new world for me with the COVID and individual enforcement. So that is something I'd like to come back to the commission next month and have a thorough answer for that, if you don't mind. No problem. And I apologize for putting you on the spot for the curveball question. I appreciate it. Any other questions for Jenna, guys? You guys good?
33:42 Jenna, we appreciate your time and we appreciate what you're doing out there. So thank you very much. Thank you very much, you all. Have a great day. And with that, I'm assuming we do not have any more public comment. Is that true, Jamie? Correct. Okay. Then we'll close public comment and we'll go on to public hearing. Our first agenda item is to consider recommending to the Town Council approval of Zoning Code Amendment 20-004 to implement a zoning code cleanup.
34:13 of the standards related to accessory dwelling units, aka second dwelling units. The proposed amendment includes finding the project exempt from CEQA pursuant to public resources code section 21080.17 and CEQA guidelines section 15282H. And I believe Nolan is our staff contact on this one. Great, thank you.
34:41 Go ahead and share my screen. Can everyone see the PowerPoint there? Yeah. Great. So this zoning code update is initiated by the town and the purpose is to clarify conflicting or confusing code language from the 2019 second dwelling unit regulations update, change all code references throughout the code from second or secondary dwelling units to accessory dwelling units or ADUs.
35:20 And to reorganize the format of the ADU code section to improve the usability for public and staff. Just to reiterate, an ADU or an excessive dwelling unit is a dwelling unit providing complete independent living facilities for one or more persons that is located on a lot with another primary dwelling unit. And an ADU can be within the same structure as a primary unit in an attached structure.
35:48 Or in a detached accessory structure on the same lot as the primary dwelling. Just at the top, there's a couple simple images that kind of just briefly show how an ADU might be located on a property. Why the update to the current code? The town's code has been comprehensively updated three times since it was updated as part of the zoning code update. Each of those updates included
36:18 various changes from the state, and it's really resulted in a piecemealed code section that's hard to understand and hard to implement. Additionally, the state is constantly clarifying and revising the ADU standards. The state has put out an ADU handbook, which provides a robust FAQ section. The link for that handbook is in the staff report as a footnote. It is a very helpful document as a reference document. Lastly, the town's code uses
36:48 Outdated terminology, that's that secondary dwelling unit, why we're going to accessory dwelling unit. The state used ADUs as an important tool to increase the housing stock throughout the state. In 2019, the state passed numerous legislative bills related to ADUs aimed at making it easier to build an ADU. Those standards went into effect January 1st, 2020.
37:15 Those laws made substantial changes to the standards for ADUs, and as part of that legislative act, it voided all local jurisdiction ADU ordinances that did not comply with the state standards. In December 2019, to avoid having an ADU ordinance that did not comply, staff brought forward an urgency ordinance to town council to bring the town's regulations into compliance.
37:42 that those regulations were hastily drafted and there wasn't, they weren't written with the intent to, is this easy to understand and easy to implement for the public and staff and this current update. It is important to note that the state does not prevent local agencies from adopting less restrictive requirements for the creation of ADU. We just can't be more restrictive than the state.
38:07 On the screen here is just some of the highlights of what was included in the state regulations. I can just briefly summarize these. ADUs are permitted outright in all zones throughout the town where single-family residences and or multifamily residences are permitted. This does include master plan areas and specific plan areas.
38:31 For single family residential properties, they're permitted one ADU. These can be either detached, attached, or an interior ADU. Additionally, properties with the single family residence and a detached ADU that's less than 800 square feet. They're also permitted to convert a portion of their single family residence to a junior ADU, thereby creating three units on the property. A junior ADU is a
38:58 ADU that's within a single family structure and does not exceed 500 square feet. For multifamily residential properties, only existing multifamily residential properties can add ADUs. They are permitted to add up to two detached ADUs and they can convert basically any portion of the interior of that multifamily structure such as
39:25 Garages, closets, storage rooms, into an ADU if it meets the building code standards and they're limited to 25% of the dwelling count within that building. So if there's a multifamily structure with 12 units, they could add four interior ADUs or three interior ADUs into that structure. The state also established setback regulations allowing for four foot side and rear yard setbacks.
39:53 No additional setback for conversions of structures. The town is required to allow a height of at least 16 feet for an ADU. The state mandates that the town does not require more than one parking space per unit. They also included a lot of exemptions into their parking regulations, including if the structure is within one half mile walking distance of public transit.
40:18 Or if the ADU is part of a proposed or existing residence or accessory structure. The exemptions are very broad and cover nearly every ADU in almost all circumstances. They also established floor area restriction or allowances. The big one that they added in this recent update is owner occupancy is not required. They did put a sunset date on that of January 2025.
40:46 So that means on a property with a single family residence and an ADU, both properties could be rented out long term, so that's for periods of 31 days or longer. There is a small exemption for a property that has that JADU, the junior ADU. In that circumstance, either the single family residence or the JADU has to be used by the owner. So not all of those can be rented out.
41:12 Also, the state bans short-term rentals of ADUs for all ADUs created after January 1st, 2020. So this is kind of a, yes. Sorry, Nolan, I don't mean to interrupt you, but I just, before you go on to the rest of the presentation, I wanted to ask you about the last bullet. So short-term rentals for ADUs built after the first of last year, what about ADUs built prior to that? Can they be rented out on a nightly basis?
41:41 So our code prior to this did have that owner-occupancy restriction, meaning that either the ADU or the residence has to be used as the primary residence, and so then it allowed that if they're in the correct zone, so if they're in an RMF2 or a resort zone, the ADU in that circumstance could be rented out nightly, but not both structures. So those ones are essentially grandfathered, and there's a...
42:08 Handful throughout town that we've identified. There's not too many that we know of, though. Got it. And so that person would have to have some sort of TOT certificate. Correct, for that unit. Got it. Thank you, Nolan. Sorry to interrupt you. That's okay. So this is kind of a high level of what the state required. And again...
42:29 We cannot be less restrict, or we cannot be more restrictive in the state, but we can be less restrictive. So these are kind of the baseline for what we have to allow for ADUs throughout town. So moving into the proposed code amendments, one of the goals was to improve the usability of the code. To achieve this, staff reorganized the ADU code section by type of standard and broken into purpose.
42:56 General requirements, single family residential requirements, and multifamily residential requirements. The general requirements are those that apply to all ADUs regardless of the zone. The single family and multifamily are specific to that type of use. Many of the standards are similar, but there are some unique variations that are applicable. And to make it easier to use, we went ahead and broke the standards out for each specific type.
43:23 The next few slides just are to highlight some of the code updates, specifically areas where we slightly differ from the minimum state standards. Design standards were added. These were added since the town is required to allow ADUs to be within four feet of side and rear property lines. Staff has proposed these design standards to protect neighboring properties from snowshed and to prevent ADUs from encroaching closer than four feet.
43:51 So the first one is just indicating that the roof has to either shed away from those property lines if it's in that reduced setback area or have a non-shedding roof material such as a comp roof or have engineered snow rails intended to keep the snow on the roof. Then the second one is just clarifying that no portion of that ADE structure can be closer than four feet. The zoning code allows certain features to project into setbacks up to a maximum of three feet.
44:19 Includes eaves, chimneys, and decks. This just reiterates that your eaves, chimneys, and decks can't be closer than four feet. So if you want eaves that go beyond the building, then your structure might have to be more than four feet from that property line. Regarding parking, we touched on it earlier. The state set a maximum of one space per ADU, but then created a number of exemptions from those parking requirements. I'll go forward a slide, then come back. So we took that
44:50 half mile walking distance, put it into GIS, came up with a map of the town that really shows that almost all of the town is within one half mile walking distance, meaning all those areas are automatically exempt from parking requirements for ADUs. The only areas outside of that are the very upper portion of the NOLs, the Bluffs, and Snow Creek 5. Then that second exemption, which is
45:20 If it's part of a proposed or existing residence or an excessive structure, they're also exempt. So due to those exemptions, the only time we could require parking is if it's more than a half mile walking distance from transit and if it's a new detached ADU structure. Because those circumstances are so rare, we took the approach to just say that no parking is required for an ADU. We did add language incurring.
45:47 Encouraging property owners to provide adequate parking by allowing one additional parking space within a setback area. There are guidelines that are applicable to that space, such as snow storage, lot coverage, and access. And then one other piece of the state is we cannot require replacement of garage spaces converted to an ADU. The proposed code language is consistent with that regulation. So again, this is just that map showing all the areas that are
46:18 Within a half mile walking distance. Next one, the state created kind of a specific ADU that they're calling a statewide exemption ADU. That's an ADU at the maximum 800 square feet of habitable area, a maximum height of 16 feet and located no closer than four feet to the side of your property lines. This type of ADU is exempt from lot coverage for area and open space requirements, meaning
46:45 Regardless if you're at or over lot coverage already, the town has to allow this type of ADU on the property. We included that standard in our code, but to encourage an ADU on a property that does exceed lot coverage to build an ADU that has a smaller footprint. If you're building it, if you want to exceed 16 feet in height,
47:11 You're required to adhere to the standard setback regulations, meaning typically 10 feet from the rear or side property lines. You can go up to 35 feet. You're still limited to that 800 square feet, so it's going to reduce the building footprint theoretically in half if you're building a two-story ADU. If it's less than or equal to 16 feet in height, you can encroach into the side and rear yards, but not closer than four feet.
47:37 The last one is regarding ADU removal because ADUs are afforded certain deviations and exemptions from development standards and fees. This is to require that if an ADU is removed or converted to another use after occupancy, the structure is brought into compliance with the current development standards and fees. This is kind of
48:02 To eliminate that scenario where a property owner builds an ADU, taking advantage of all the exemptions in the code and then converts it to some other use. Some examples of when this may apply is a detached ADU that's located at four feet from the side or rear property lines is no longer used as an ADU. Then we have a, you know, potentially 800 square foot structure real close to a property line.
48:28 Or an IMF II zone parcel, they build a single family residence and an ADU. They take advantage of those development standards and fee exemptions. Then they convert to a multifamily use, allowing nightly rentals in both units. This chart on the side, it's probably hard to read on the screen, but it just kind of highlights some of the differences between an ADU and multifamily residence. We have recently had kind of a lot of questions related to is it an ADU or is it multifamily?
48:59 And then that last code change is just the name change going from secondary dwelling unit to accessory dwelling unit. This is just to really bring the code, make it consistent with state standards and consistent with the terms used industry-wide. It also helps the public locate the standards since most people know accessory dwelling unit where they aren't as familiar with secondary dwelling unit terms. The public review and outreach for this is part of
49:27 The review of the standards, the draft regulations were reviewed internally by planning and engineering staff really to get feedback. I told them to read through them with the kind of intent of are these easy to understand? Can these be applied? I took feedback from the staff incorporating those into the regulations. We've also had definitely an increase from the public.
49:55 in interest in building ADUs. I think that's some of, they've, people are familiar with what the states adopted. The sheet also did an article a few months back discussing ADUs and what's allowed. And then the public notice for this hearing was in the sheet and no public comments have been received regarding the regulations update. With that, I will open it up for questions from the commission.
50:23 And also the last slide is just the staff's recommendation, which is to adopt the PEDC resolution, making required CEQA findings and municipal code findings and recommending to the town council adoption or finding the project exempt from CEQA, adopting the municipal code findings and approving the zoning code amendment as recommended by staff. Thank you, Nolan. Any questions for Nolan at this time, guys? At this point? Nolan.
50:58 Just to put you on the spot for a basic guess, how many people have actually reached out to you guys about possibly building an ADU unit? I'd say in the last six months, probably 15 to 20 of people asking about it. We've also, last I looked, which was kind of the end of 2020, I think we had six to eight actual applications submitted.
51:28 We had two ADUs completed last year, and I believe there's about five building permits issued in 2020. Got it. Just in your experience with these applications and the inquiries, are people looking to build these ADUs more for long-term rental or short-term overnight rental if they live in a zone that's applicable?
51:55 Because the state standards went into effect January 1st, 2020, none of the ones permitted, at least in the last year, allow for the nightly rentals. I try to, you know, anecdotally talk with Alcans, what are you going to do with your ADU? It's kind of 50-50. Some say, you know, we intend to rent it long term, so we want that.
52:20 Kind of passive income and others just want additional space for when family members or others come up to their house. Got it. And what would be the process if somebody did kind of pull a fast one on you and said, oh, no, we're just using it for family members, but it was, in fact, increasing the inventory of the black market nightly rentals. How does the town enforce that? So that would be enforced the same as any other TOT enforcement case.
52:49 It'd be the same as a TOT that's violating zoning then. So it probably would be a tip on the hotline, something along those lines? Tip on the hotline or something that, you know, we identify through the online search tool that we use for the TOT enforcement coming up and then the TOT team would build a case against them and bring it forward to town council with the, or
53:17 Levy the fines, and then if they appeal it, it would come to Town Council. And the Town Office has a record over, has basically a list or a record over what property owners have successfully applied and built an ADU. We do. As part of the ADU, I failed to mention this. Prior to the Certificate of Occupancy before the ADU, there are property owners required to record a use restriction on the property.
53:43 So this identifies it on title that there is an illegal ADU on the property. It also then goes into the town's record that identifying this property as having an ADU. Got it. Thank you. Anybody else have a question right now before I open it up to public comment? Going this more of a clarification than a question, but did you say that people can add an ADU to expand room for their family? They can. So we cannot...
54:14 We cannot, we can prohibit short-term rentals of ADUs, but we cannot require someone to actually rent it long-term. So, you know, we have no mechanism to say you shall rent this to someone for 31 days or longer. You know, it could sit empty except when their family members come up and use it, or it could sit empty or their in-laws might live in it and they're not going to charge them.
54:44 Rent or vice versa. So that is definitely something that happens. Well, correct me if I'm wrong, but wasn't the whole reason for encouraging ADUs to increase housing stock for workforce housing? And it seems like they're causing impact in the neighborhoods for no workforce gain. It definitely is. The goal was to increase housing. I think when the state looks at it, they're looking.
55:15 You know, the state doesn't, I want to say, think broadly or think of all the impacts that, you know, that their regulations or laws might cause. And that's definitely an end result is that sometimes the ADU just sits empty except when their guests or other family members come up. Okay, that's what the state says. I suppose we can't be more restrictive, but it seems as though it's not, it's not meeting the goal.
55:48 Yeah, I definitely agree with that. A question came up recently, and that exact question, I reviewed it extensively with the town attorney, and he basically reiterated that we have no way to enforce or require that it actually be rented for that long term versus sitting vacant most of the time. Thanks for the clarification. Thanks for the question, Commissioner. Any other questions? Right now, guys?
56:19 Jamie, do we have any public comment on this matter, either in person or digitally? We do not. No public comment. All right, then I'll close the public comment on item number one, and I'll throw it back to the commission for conversation, opinions, thoughts. Does anyone have a thought or something they'd like to express? I actually have a... Good. Commissioner Chang, do you have a question? I have a question. It's about interior ADU.
56:54 When I looked at the document you provided, the staff's document, all this says is about the percentage of the actual size of the interior ADU. Can you kind of paint a picture for me exactly what an interior ADU would look like? Yes, I think that's a really simplified kind of rendering, but an interior ADU might be, you have an existing
57:25 2,500 square foot house, and you say, I don't use this existing basement or existing, you know, 800 square feet of the house. I want to essentially put an exterior entrance, add a kitchen, and then close it off from the rest of the house, and then that can be now an interior use. So essentially it's created from an existing part of a residence. So it has to be
57:56 You cannot access the interior ADU unit from the primary unit. From the interior of the primary unit. Is that what you're saying? Yeah, so we did not require in the code that you completely close it off. It has to have a lock off or door, but you can still provide interior access. If it is the commission's ideas or if the commission
58:27 There's consensus we could propose adding that language for the Town Council's consideration. I know Truckee had a similar thought that the Planning Commission in Truckee prohibited or voted to prohibit interior access between an ADU and the primary structure. Then the Town Council in Truckee did not go forward with including that prohibition, but that is something that we could add.
59:01 Commissioner Chain, any other questions or follow-up? It seems to me, based on what Greg just asked and staff's response as to the constraints that we have on this, it seems that I would make that recommendation to have the restriction so you would make that a separate unit. And so we will make that available for someone to rent that particular unit.
59:34 on long-term basis. That was the goal for the Truckee's Planning Commission, but they felt prohibiting that interior access would encourage that being used as long-term rental and not just additional space in the residence. So, Nolan, just to be clear, we could request that the town council modify this to not only require an external entrance, but prohibit a
1:00:09 Interior pass-through, which would include not allowing a doorway with a lock from either side, where the only way to go from this ADU into the original living space would be through an external entrance, however the burbage would have to be. That's correct. So the exterior entrance is already a requirement for all ADUs.
1:00:37 So if the commission reached consensus, then the recommendation would be to amend it to add prohibition for the interior access between ADUs and the primary structure. Yeah, well, I like the idea to have that verbiage in there. Maybe I should ask staff maybe to provide some pros and cons if we do do that. What does that really look like?
1:01:08 And perhaps maybe other commissioners can provide input on this. So, I mean, really, I think the pros are that it does create that, you know, that distinct separate dwelling unit as the definition for an ADU indicates where it's that the complete independent living facility. It becomes more obvious when it doesn't have that interior
1:01:42 Passage. I mean, I can't really think of any cons offhand as to including that language other than it might be somewhat difficult to enforce or, you know, catch anyone who's doing an after the fact. I have one question on this topic. Just to confirm, I guess I'm wondering if it's an interior ADU, is this someone that would be adding on?
1:02:19 Square footage to their space. This is not like someone turning their attic into an ADU. So it is somewhat, you know, the differences between an attached ADU and an interior ADU are fairly minimal. The interior ADU, generally it's that you're converting an existing space. The code does allow for a small expansion of up to 150 square feet for ingress and egress. So if it's a second
1:02:49 floor unit, you can add 150 square feet to access it, whereas an attached ADU would be a new structure built onto the existing single family residence, so expanding, say, into the backyard, you know, might be a one-story addition onto a two-story building like that, but the differences are fairly minimal. And I guess I'm wondering why
1:03:17 I guess if we need this language about why would someone have an ADU, an interior ADU if they just wanted it for their guests, like why would they go through that process such that we would need this language? I think, I mean, this language would apply to the attached ADU as well, so then it definitely would, I think, encourage that complete living facility. Like I said, likely it would be added for both just to, so there's consistency between them. Got it, okay.
1:03:47 Thank you. That helps. Any other questions for either Nolan or Sandra? What are your, my other commissioners, what are your thoughts about adding the language that Paul and Greg have mentioned? I'm fine with it. I'm indifferent. I think the whole point of the ADU, again, was to encourage people to add on and make some more workforce housing. So I don't really know that.
1:04:25 Yeah, I would have to say I'm in favor of adding that language, Paul. It just seems to me if an interior ADU has a secondary access route, it's just going to encourage somebody not to rent it long term and just have it basically it sounds like a guest room. So yeah, if there's no further discussion on this, does someone want to put a
1:04:59 Put forth a motion. I'll put a motion, but Nolan, can you share that slide again? Since it's long. Yeah, I'm sorry, I was looking. Let's see, it went too fast. All right, perfect. I will move to adopt the required CEQA findings pursuant to public resources code section 21080.17 and state CEQA guidelines section 15282H, finding the project to be exempt from CEQA.
1:05:56 to adopt the required municipal code findings and to approve zoning code of admin 20-004 with modifications. Is that how I correctly say that? Yes. And so just to clarify that modification would be to include language prohibiting interior access for the attached ADU and interior ADUs. That would be the recommendation to town council. Perfect. With that. Do I have a second? Second.
1:06:29 Any further conversation, guys, or we're good to go to a vote? Okay. Jamie, roll call, please. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Matter passes 5-0. Thank you, Nolan, for the presentation. All right. Thank you all. Let's move on to public hearing agenda item number two. It's a zoning code amendment.
1:07:01 20-001 to update Municipal Code Chapter 17.44, Parking and Loading Standards to clarify alternative parking provisions, establish review and approval process for parking reduction requests and changes or expanses of use that are non-conforming as to parking and facilitate the use of alternative parking and transportation demand management measures in accordance with mobility element goals.
1:07:30 That is a chewy sentence. The amendment also includes a minor change to table 17.76.020 to remove a decrease in the number of required parking spaces from the allowable adjustments as well as an update to chapter 17.100. And I believe Chandler, oh, there's more here, second page. Chapter 17.100.
1:07:58 Non-conforming uses structures and parcels to refer to the updated parking standards. The proposed zoning code amendment includes finding the project exempt from CEQA pursuant to public resources code section 21083.3 and CEQA guidelines section 1518.3. And I do believe Chandler is our staff contact on this. Take it away Chandler. All right. Thank you Michael.
1:08:27 I will share my screen here. Okay, can everyone see that? Yeah. Okay. So yes, this is parking code update ZCA-20001. So in summary, although you've covered most of it there, so this is a zoning code amendment that has been initiated by the town to correct existing discrepancies in the municipal code to clarify alternative parking provisions.
1:09:03 Establish review and approval process for parking reduction requests and changes to uses with non-conforming parking and to encourage the use of alternative parking and transportation demand management measures in accordance with mobility element goals. So why update the current code? So currently there are discrepancies in the current code language which make it hard to interpret and implement. Complex regulations, they're very hard to understand for applicants and staff as well.
1:09:34 There's currently a lack of clear review and approval processes. This translates to a lack of transparency and accountability. All of this has kind of resulted in slow progress in achieving the town and state goals of increasing transit ridership, bicycling pedestrian modes, and decreasing single occupant vehicles, reducing vehicle miles traveled. Also the goal of managing existing parking more efficiently and encouraging TVM measures.
1:10:04 So some of the policies that support the proposed code change, implementation of TDM measures or programs should be encouraged and incentivized for both new development and existing development. That's the mobility element. Also in the mobility element, there's a goal to support alternative transportation, housing affordability and public health goal through implementation of improved parking strategies and requirements.
1:10:29 And also a policy to adjust parking requirements on a case-by-case basis when it can be demonstrated that parking demand can be reduced or parking efficiency can be improved. So just to kind of go over some of the current code sections that we're proposing to amend, so alternative parking provisions are in section 17.44040. These provisions are intended to allow for modifications to on-site parking requirements. Right now they include things like shared parking agreements, parking reductions, which
1:10:59 Can involve TDM, other measures, and parking and loo fees. Currently, these regulations are very complex and confusing. It's a disincentive for businesses or development projects to utilize them. They're very unclear review and approval steps, which makes it hard for staff to evaluate proposals or track approvals. Just an example of this, currently the code in different sections
1:11:27 Within alternative parking provisions refers to documentation acceptable to the review authority, parking demand study, quantitative information, or a trip reduction plan. Those are all listed as things that an applicant can submit as part of a parking reduction request. So pretty confusing, a lot of different language in there. Also significantly, there's no public input process. Because there's no set review or approval process, there's really no way.
1:11:56 for the town to notify people if someone is requesting a parking reduction or for neighbors or concerned citizens to get involved in a parking reduction request. There's also no limits on the size of a parking reduction request. So right now in the adjustments table, it's implied that you can request a parking reduction through the adjustments process, which is not referred to in the alternative parking provisions code section, but it
1:12:23 Theoretically means that somebody could ask for 100% parking reduction and that we could approve that and there would be no application and no public process in that. So there are a lot of holes right now. Non-conforming parking standards, which are currently split between the non-conforming standards in Section 17100 and also there are a few standards included in Section 1744030.
1:12:53 So these are standards that apply to uses that currently do not meet municipal code parking requirements. So developments that are under parked, basically. Currently, the code language contains conflicting standards and puts the burden of proof on staff. When I say conflicting standards, currently the code has two different sections for non-conforming parking.
1:13:18 One of the sections refers to a change in use and another section refers to an expansion of structure. They have different requirements depending on whether it's a change in use or an expansion of structure. These are in conflict with each other because the code only regulates parking based on use, does not regulate parking based on structures or the size of the structure. It's really just the use that occupies that structure. Currently for changes in use, it requires no additional parking unless staff determines that there will be impacts to neighboring properties.
1:13:48 Whereas for an expansion structure, it requires parking only for an addition unless staff determines that there is not enough parking in the surrounding area to meet requirements. So it doesn't really jive with the way the code is set up and it also provides kind of different processes that don't really work well when you apply them. So again, there's a lack of clear review or approval process, no public process.
1:14:18 The code ends up being very permissive in this regard. Why is that a bad thing? So currently the code really puts the burden of proof on staff. So if somebody with non-conforming parking wants to expand their business or replace it with a different business that has higher parking requirements, it's completely up to staff to determine whether there might be impacts. Staff is not really qualified to identify potential off-site impacts with.
1:14:45 With regards to parking, that would usually be done by a transportation planner, transportation engineer. There's no incentive or requirement for applicants currently to offset impacts or to reduce parking demand. Parking really is best managed comprehensively townwide, and that's what a lot of our policy documents talk about, is improving townwide parking management. This requires tracking how parking is being used.
1:15:12 Encouraging shared parking where appropriate and trying to reduce overall parking demand to make the existing supply work better. So currently the way the code is set up, we really don't have a way to kind of achieve any of those things. So transportation demand management or TDM, this is in section 17.44050. So these are measures that are intended to help reduce demand for vehicle parking. Examples of these.
1:15:39 These are generally intended to increase transit ridership, bicycling, walking, carpooling, anything to get people out of their cars so that they're not utilizing parking as much. So these can include employee incentives, provision of bike racks or other bike or pedestrian supported facilities such as showers or changing rooms or bike pumps or something like that. Unbundling parking, that would be mainly for residential projects, but that's basically
1:16:05 Making it so that it costs money to have a parking space and a residential development as opposed to providing free parking. Allowing for alternative scheduling, so you're kind of breaking up the demand. Providing information on commuting options. You know, in Mammoth, transit is free, but in a lot of places, this TDM measures would include paying for bus passes or something like that. You know, in Mammoth, it could, assuming someday we get car share or bike share, it could.
1:16:34 It could be like an employer providing employees money to use bike share or car share or something like that. So there's a variety of different measures. Again, the current regulations in our code are very complicated and very hard to monitor. So there are different measures allowed based on employer size and there's no relation to the size of request. So an example of this is that currently the code requires
1:17:04 Employers of 25 or more to reduce work-related vehicle trips by 20%. And that's just regardless of the size of requests. So if somebody comes in and asks for 100% parking reduction, our code currently makes them show that they're reducing just work-related vehicle trips by 20%. So there's some gaps there. There's really no clear toolbox. And when I say toolbox, I just kind of mean a list of potential.
1:17:31 tools or measures that people can use to reduce demand. And there's no consistent requirements. So currently there's no requirement that applicants who want to use TDM to achieve a parking reduction, they don't have to show that it will work on an ongoing basis. There's no requirement that it be monitored to ensure that it's working. So really we have no way of kind of knowing what works well and what doesn't in the world of TDM.
1:18:02 So as a result of these, we decided to amend the code and the big changes are the amendment will reorganize and consolidate code sections to make them clearer and easier to understand. It will remove the existing discrepancies. So for example, the parking adjustments table, we will be removing parking from allowable adjustments since the adjustment process is really not the correct process to allow for parking reductions.
1:18:30 The structure references that I mentioned before in the non-conforming standards. So discrepancies like that will be removed. We are proposing to apply existing planning review and approval processes, specifically administrative permit and use permit processes to parking reduction requests and changes or expansions of non-conforming uses based upon the size of the request. And I'll get into the specifics of that a little bit more in a second here.
1:18:57 This will allow both residential and non-residential uses to request reductions. That's kind of an existing discrepancy in the code right now. Currently, there's language that basically limits parking reduction requests to commercial uses, but then later in the code, there are specific standards for residential and mixed uses. So we believe that the intent of the code really was to allow all uses to request that, but that there's just an error. It will expand the toolbox available to applicants.
1:19:27 It will create clear requirements and it will require ongoing monitoring for parking reduction requests to ensure that they're working. It'll create a public process for larger parking reduction requests and it will allow staff to consider proximity to on-street or other public parking when evaluating parking reduction requests. So I'll get into that in a second here too. So these are the specific changes just kind of in bullet point format.
1:19:54 The code sections that we're proposing to change are 174430. So this is just to improve consistency with parking requirements tables, add reference to the alternative parking provisions section, and address exceptions to parking standards related to state density bonus law. Now that is just to kind of dive into the state density bonus law a little bit. The state density bonus law allows developments who are requesting a state density bonus to request
1:20:22 Exceptions to the zoning code, including exceptions to parking standards. So really the part of this amendment is adding some language that basically says you can't double dip. If you have received a parking reduction as part of a state density bonus request, you cannot also request a parking reduction through the municipal code standards. Changes to sections 174430 and 17100.
1:20:50 20 regarding non-conforming parking standards. So we're basically adding the non-conforming parking standards to the alternative parking provisions, correcting discrepancies and aligning the review and approval processes for changes or expansions of non-conforming uses with the process requirements for parking productions. Section 174440, alternative parking provisions. So again, it'll allow alternative parking provisions to apply to both residential and non-residential uses.
1:21:18 It'll clarify code requirements pertaining to state density bonus laws I just discussed. It will require approval of an administrative permit for parking reductions up to 25% and a use permit for reductions greater than 25%. So what this means is if the code requires 100 spaces and you are asking to provide 76 spaces, so let's say it's a 24% reduction.
1:21:46 You would be required to submit an administrative permit for review. And if you're asking for 50 spaces, so a 50% reduction, you would be required to go through the use permit process, in which case it would have a public comment process and it would go through PEDC for ultimate approval. The amendment would grant town staff the discretion to require a parking study and or a transportation demand management plan as part of a parking reduction request.
1:22:16 Which currently the code kind of implies but doesn't really specifically give us that authority and it doesn't really have clear requirements for what we expect. It would incorporate the shared parking standards into the reduction of parking standards and the reason for that is really a shared parking agreement as we know it is an agreement between two properties where they are basically sharing the burden of providing the required parking between them.
1:22:44 So when you have a shared parking agreement, it's essentially a parking reduction for at least one of the two properties that are involved in the agreement. Otherwise, they would not need to share parking if they can both provide the required parking. So really, it's just kind of a matter of clarifying that entering into a shared parking agreement is really just another way of justifying parking reduction. So it's adding that to the parking reduction standards.
1:23:08 It would also allow town staff to consider the availability of on-street parking when reviewing a parking reduction request. Just to be clear on that, really is just one of many factors that can be considered in a parking reduction request. It's not saying that if a business has on-street parking next to it, that it will automatically qualify to have reduced on-site parking. It's just saying that that can be considered in addition to other measures that are...
1:23:37 Provided by the applicant in a parking study or in a TDM plan. If they do create a parking study and show that there happens to be, you know, widely available public parking very nearby, and they're going to provide bike racks, and they're going to incentivize employees to use transit, then we are now authorized basically to take that into consideration and to grant the parking reduction based on that, whereas currently the code does not allow that.
1:24:02 In terms of the changes to Section 174450, Transportation Demand Management, really these will clarify the requirements for a TDM plan and allow all applicants to have access to the same toolbox when proposing TDM measures. So this is really, right now it's broken up basically between employer size, which we don't really have the ability to monitor how many employees a business has or really to verify that.
1:24:32 So really, this just makes it so that anyone, regardless of the size of their business, whether it is a residential, mixed use, or a commercial project, they can all use the same TDM measures as part of a TDM plan to request a parking reduction. It will also tie reduction in demand to the size of request. So there's, like I said before, right now, there's kind of some language that just says you have to have a 20% reduction in demand. We're changing the language to basically say that you have to
1:25:02 Demonstrate a reduction in demand for vehicle parking, commensurate with the size of the request. So if you're asking for a 75% parking reduction, you need to show us that you are reducing demand by close to that amount. And then finally, again, just the change to table 172620 adjustments, which is just to remove parking from the allowable adjustments. Now that we are creating a clear review and approval process for parking reductions,
1:25:31 We do not need to have it included in the adjustments. So what this means, really, so parking reductions or changes or expansions to non-conforming uses will have applications and associated fees. Again, it's an administrative permit for a request for 25% below or use permits for above 25%. We are exploring reduced fees for changes in non-conforming use with the same parking requirements. So part of the code language here is
1:26:03 Really, if there's non-conforming use, a use that doesn't have enough parking, or if there is a use that has received a parking reduction approval, they cannot just change uses and sell their business to someone else without basically going through a process to verify that they're still meeting either their approved parking reduction or that they are, that the new use is going to undertake measures to keep the demand reduced.
1:26:32 So in that sense, you could theoretically change uses to a new use that has the exact same parking requirement. So you're not really increasing the parking requirement. So for those situations, we would like to have a reduced fee structure, basically. So it's a very, very cheap and easy application. So we're not putting any sort of undue burden on people. Really, the full permit fees would just be in instances where people are either requesting a reduction in parking.
1:27:01 Or where they are proposing to increase the size or change the operating characteristics of an existing use that currently doesn't meet parking requirements. So as I said before, parking reductions or changes in use will need to demonstrate proportionate reductions of demand. This will improve transparency and accountability on the town side. And so all requests will go through the same process. They'll be held to the same standards. They'll be part of the public record.
1:27:31 We will, you know, as these requests come in, we will develop a quote unquote library of examples of TDM plans that people can look at to see what's been successful. There will be opportunities for public review and input. So more options or a bigger toolbox for how to justify park reduction requests, improved town-wide parking management, and more opportunities for shared use of parking and just generally more free needs.
1:28:00 In terms of public outreach, we began working on this update in summer 2020. Once some initial draft was completed, there were two opportunities for public review and comment. The first was August 3rd, 2020. We had a notice meeting of the PEDC Mobility Committee. We presented the proposed update and responded to questions. In general, they were very supportive of the parking code update and there were no public comments associated with that.
1:28:29 And then I also presented the proposed pardon code update to the Chamber of Commerce at a power lunch meeting on September 22nd and solicited feedback from members there and there were no comments or questions at that time. Oh, and I should have also mentioned, as Nolan mentioned in his presentation, that this was noticed in the appropriate manner for this public hearing as well. So just going quickly to zoning code amendment findings. The first finding is that the proposed amendment is internally consistent with all other provisions of the general plan.
1:29:01 In any applicable specific or master plan. In this case, there is no specific or master plan. So really, it's just general plan consistency that we're looking at. We found that it's consistent with the general plan vision statement of offering a variety of transportation options that emphasize connectivity, convenience, and alternatives to use of personal vehicles with a strong pedestrian emphasis. Goal M14, the mobility element to support alternative transportation, housing affordability, and public health goals through implementation of improved parking strategies and requirements. Policy M14-1.
1:29:30 to adjust parking requirements on a community-based basis, when it can be demonstrated that the parking demand can be reduced or parking efficiency improved, mobility principle to reduce demand and encourage more efficient use of the existing transportation system, and finally, the mobility element management strategy to manage the demand on the transportation system, including streets and parking. Finding two is that the proposed amendment would not be detrimental to public interest, health, safety, convenience, or welfare.
1:29:59 Improving the public's ability to utilize alternative parking provisions and TDM measures will improve public convenience from a process standpoint while helping to achieve several mobility element goals related to public health, safety, and welfare, including reducing the number of vehicle trips, promoting alternative travel modes, and more efficiently managing existing transportation infrastructure. Three, that the proposed amendment is in compliance with the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. So the proposed amendment is consistent with the development densities established by the general plan.
1:30:29 Does not have the potential to result in impacts peculiar to the project. There are no other potential impacts of this amendment to the zoning code that were not addressed in the general plan EIR. There are no potentially significant off-site or cumulative impacts posed by this amendment to the zoning code that were not addressed in general plan EIR. And substantial new information has not come to light that shows that the impacts previously addressed will be more significant than that described in the
1:30:53 General Plan EIR. So consequently, under Public Resources Code, Section 21083.3, and State CEQA Guidelines, Section 15183C, no additional EIR or other environmental analysis is required. Finally, there's just one additional finding for zoning code amendments, which is that it's internally consistent with other applicable provisions of the zoning code. So again, really this amendment is intended to correct errors, clarify existing standards,
1:31:22 More clearly defined application review requirements and increased flexibility within the parking code. Overall, the proposed amendment improves the usability of the existing alternative parking provisions while more clearly defining procedural requirements and therefore increasing the town's ability to ensure that parking reduction requests are consistent with all other applicable provisions of the zoning code. So staff has found that all of the findings for zoning code amendment have been met.
1:31:49 And are therefore recommending that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA findings and municipal code findings, and recommending that the Town Council take the following actions, adopt the required CEQA findings and find the project exempt, adopt the required municipal code findings, and approve zoning code amendment 20001 as recommended by staff. Now I will take questions. Does anyone on the commission have a question for Chandler right now?
1:32:22 Can you please go back to the previous slide that says the recommendations? Thank you. Commissioner Chang? How often do our business here in town request for reduction in parking? So far, very, very rarely, if ever, and that's part of why we're trying to update this code. Commissioner Eckert, would you have a question? I would like to see something that doesn't allow for
1:33:08 I'm not sure if this code is really on this point or not, but we've got a couple of projects in town that have been built over the years based on projections of parking demand that we now have permanent structures that have inadequate parking. And I'm not sure that this zoning code amendment really speaks directly to that, but just in general, I would be more in favor of having
1:33:38 More public discussion, less staff approval over the counter, and especially something that requires that there be a proven track record of some of these ideas working before they're accepted as alternatives. Yeah, I think, so, I guess, not knowing which developments you're referring to, if they're, you know, the code does allow people to basically create their own parking requirements as part of the master plan or specific plan.
1:34:09 So in some cases there have been developments like, you know, the North Village Pacific plan essentially created its own parking requirements. So in that regard, that wouldn't really be addressed by this code update because that's, even if it's not working, it's still considered legal because they went through this specific plan. But if there was a development that basically asked for reduced parking just kind of informally and was granted a parking reduction previously and
1:34:40 Now is not meeting, you know, it's not working well. Depending on whether or not there's any sort of record of that approval that that use may or may not be considered non-conforming. So if it were a non-conforming use, then it would fall under this new zoning code update, and we would kind of have the ability to better deal with that, at least when they decided to change or expand the use. And then as far as the track record goes,
1:35:10 You know, really what this code update requires is that they, anyone who's asking for a parking reduction request, staff has the discretion to request either a parking study or a TDM plan prepared by a qualified transportation consultant essentially or a transportation professional. So it would be kind of up to them through their transportation consultant to provide that backing evidence.
1:35:36 I think in that regard, this zoning code update definitely does improve our ability to get proof, basically, of what people are asking for to justify a parking reduction, if that makes sense. It does, Chandler, thank you. Chandler, can you just reiterate one more time what is the trigger threshold when the application comes before the PEDC and at what point is it an administrative decision? So it's 25%.
1:36:06 And this is just what I took based on my previous experience. So that's what the city of Boulder uses. And then also just researching other similar cities to us. 25% seems to be a fairly common number to be the basically the threshold between staff level administrative review versus a discretionary review. And the discretionary review is a public process. It's a use permit.
1:36:37 Got it. Great. Does that make sense? Yeah, I just like to see the threshold maybe even drop to 10%. I mean, it seems like the parking that we have now is barely adequate as it is and that, you know, if we're going to have a 25% reduction from barely adequate, it's going to take some pretty elaborate plans to pull it off. Chandler, would you like to respond to that or do you want me to just go back to that? I mean, it's...
1:37:10 I guess it's kind of a matter of opinion, really, and what the commission's preference is. I mean, for what it's worth, the town of Mammoth Lakes actually has pretty high parking requirements. So I know that there is the perception in the community at points that we don't have adequate parking, but in terms of how much parking we actually require, we're quite high compared to most other places.
1:37:41 So it's really, it's just a matter of what the commission is comfortable with. I mean, I think the thing to take into consideration is that right now, this is all trying to really encourage the use of TDM measures, or at least that was staff's intent, and to really, to achieve the goals of trying to kind of reduce the amount of driving that's happening in Mammoth and to use alternate modes.
1:38:07 You know, we're trying to really encourage people to reduce their amount of parking, but only if they can do so by showing that they're really going to support these other modes of travel and that it's really going to work. So if you have small businesses, like let's say you're a business and you're required to provide five parking spaces and you are asking to provide four, but you are located right next to a bus stop, right next to public parking, you're going to provide a whole bunch of bike racks and you're going to, you know,
1:38:37 Give a day off a month to the employee who can prove that they haven't driven or something like that. You know, that would be a 25% reduction that could theoretically be staff level. So I think part of it is, and the fee difference is significant between an administrative permit and a use permit. So to ask that business owner to go through a use permit process, you know, and pay several thousand dollars and go to Planning Commission, et cetera, to reduce it by one space.
1:39:07 You know, I mean, it's up to you guys, but I think the idea generally is that up to 25%, we felt comfortable that staff would have the ability to kind of approve or deny that, and that really is just the larger ones that you guys would want to be involved in, but if the commission wants to reduce the threshold, that's completely up to you, and that is fine.
1:39:30 And just to kind of follow up on that, as Chandler mentioned during his presentation that we currently don't have any requirements to reduce parking. So there's no public process right now. So this is kind of a new public process that business owners would have to go through. And so we thought it was reasonable to kind of split it this way so that if kind of quote unquote smaller requests would stay at the staff level, whereas something kind of above that 25% would come to the commission.
1:39:58 That was also kind of part of the thinking as we put this together for you. I mean, one way of getting at that, Greg, maybe if I may, is, I mean, because I do recognize that there, you know, a difference, a development that has 100 required parking spaces asking for a 25% reduction is very different than a development that is required to have four parking spaces asking for a 25% reduction.
1:40:29 I mean, if you wanted to, we could add some language that actually talks about the size of the project and just say for projects that have, you know, a base requirement of X spaces, the threshold will be lower, but for projects that are below that, the threshold will remain the same. I mean, that could, you know, maybe be appropriate. I don't know, just spitballing. I'd be more comfortable with something along those lines. I just don't want to see, I don't want to see somebody get a parking reduction.
1:41:01 In exchange for a plan that down the line doesn't work. And for the next 30 years, there's a building there within that department. Right. And I mean, and that's what, I mean, the current code is, that's what the current code just allows, no matter what. I mean, someone can just come in and get 100% parking reduction and we wouldn't even have to tell you guys about it. So this is a significant improvement from that. So it's really just a matter of how comfortable you feel with kind of the protections that we've put in place in the code language.
1:41:36 I'd definitely like to see some sort of size limit on it. Any other thoughts or questions for Chandler at this time, guys? I appreciate the work that y'all put in on this, and I really appreciate that we're cleaning up the parking code because it is such a huge issue for people in our community to ensure that there is enough parking, even though we are trying to move to a more white.
1:42:11 Bike, Walk, Ride Program, and I think this is a great improvement over what we had before. Commissioner Burroughs, what are your thoughts on adding some additional language on the size of the project or possibly lowering the percentage threshold? I would be up for that if that's what my fellow commissioners are interested in. Commissioner Kennedy, do you have some thoughts on either of those amendments?
1:42:43 I'm pretty neutral about it. I'm up for going whichever way the commission goes. I agree that this is great work and I feel good about the direction it's going and that it's a little more oversight than we've had before. So thanks to Chandler and team for that. Commissioner Chang? I appreciate the recommendation. I mean, I don't think we have too many parcels here in town that have sizable parking, you know, 100 to 200 spaces.
1:43:17 We can certainly make some kind of limitation or have some type of constraints on those or some constraints or brackets around those things. Thank you. Chandler, did you receive any written comments or feedback in regards to this matter? No, not directly related to this. I mean, I've been fielding questions from business owners just very generally about the parking code update since
1:43:49 Really since I started working on it. But no, I mean, I've sent the draft to folks and I haven't received any comments or questions on the draft. Got it. Jamie, I'm going to open it up to public comment. Do we have anyone in suite Z physically that would like to make public comment or digitally on Zoom? No, either way, there's no public comment. No public comment. So I'll close public comment. Now throw it back onto the commission for some conversation, opinions.
1:44:21 Or if you guys feel like you're settled, Greg, would you care to make a motion with the adjustment at the bottom at the end with the new language? And we'll see. I don't have the video here to read the exact verbiage of the resolution, but if we could have a motion that would allow for this to take place but require that anything over, I don't know.
1:44:51 We'll pick a number of 10 spaces. If it's going to be over 25%, that that has to be addressed. Sandra Moberly, what are your thoughts on that number? So is the request that it would be a 10 space reduction? Is that what you were saying, Commissioner Eckert? No, a 10 space project. Oh, that's a pretty small project. I think most of our projects would probably...
1:45:23 Fall into that. I mean, thinking about, you know, grocery outlet, that project, you know, I think they had maybe 57 or around, let's just say 60 spaces. So if they came in, you know, for a reduction, you know, I mean, we'd be looking at, I think it'd be better to frame it in the amount of reduction rather than framing it in the total number of spaces. I don't know, Chandler, do you have any thoughts on that? I mean,
1:45:54 Personally, I feel like if the intent is to make sure that bigger projects that might have more of an impact are the ones that have to go through the use permit, I mean, my only concern is really that if we reduce the percentage, I feel like that will potentially put kind of a greater financial burden on small businesses. So a small business with few parking spaces, if we have a 10% limit or something like that,
1:46:25 And that basically means that any parking reduction they ask for, they're going to have to pay a several thousand dollar use permit fee and go to Planning Commission. So I think that it may end up kind of acting as a disincentive for people to implement these measures. So I personally would feel more comfortable basing it on project size. And like Sandra said, I think 10 spaces is a really small number. I mean, I would say
1:46:54 Yeah, 50 or 100 spaces, maybe. Like, I mean, these are big developments that are, that clearly have deep pockets that we're talking about. But, but I wouldn't want to make it so that any, you know, basically any business in town who's requesting a park reduction can't do it administratively. Yeah, I would, I would.
1:47:17 I appreciate your feedback on that. And I think that if we go, if we change the way that Greg is suggesting that we are going to see like every project in front of us. And frankly, there just aren't that many projects left in town to do. We just don't have that much space. And I think that with the big projects, like the limelight one that's about to come before us, they're going to have to come before us anyway, most likely. So I don't know that.
1:47:47 Additional verbiage is necessary here. And I certainly don't want to discourage small businesses and make them pay more. Our small businesses are already suffering right now. That is a good point in that any project that has 50 or 100 parking spaces will be coming in front of you guys anyways. Commissioner Burroughs, what are your thoughts on maybe us putting the threshold number at 35 or more parking spaces comes before us or 50?
1:48:26 Well, let me ask, how many parking spaces did the Starbucks have? Because that came before us. Yeah, I'm not sure. So I would think that it's like a project that is that size. I remember Starbucks having a lot of parking spaces. In fact, they had more than they were required to have, and they still came before us. And that project came before you as a design review.
1:48:55 I mean, looking, kind of looking at design, which design review is triggered kind of based on the location of the project. So, you know, it doesn't necessarily mean that, you know, every design review that comes to you is going to be a really large project. But, you know, I mean, I think, you know, as Chandler mentioned, I think, you know, projects of 50 spaces or more, those are bigger projects like grocery outlet, right? Grocer outlet had, I think, like I said, around 60 spaces.
1:49:25 You know, that's maybe a better way to look at it. And yeah, I think I agree that, you know, having the limit be so low that it really just means that every single project will come, any project requesting a parking reduction would come before you if it's that low. Commissioner Eckert, what are your thoughts on the fifth parking spot trigger point? I don't really, in the overall scheme of things it is, but in the...
1:49:56 In the universe of Mammoth Lakes, I don't think a grocery outlet is a small project. Right. And in that regard, though, that would have come to you for design review. And so, if they were asking for a parking reduction, regardless of the size, as part of the approval, we would just lump it together with the design review and bring it to you anyways. So really, I think any project where design review is required,
1:50:26 If they were also asking for a parking reduction, even if it was technically an administrative parking reduction as part of their approval, we would be consolidating those and bringing them all to the Planning Commission as a package. And now that I'm actually thinking about it out loud, I don't know that there would ever be a project that would have 50 spaces that wouldn't require design review, but yeah, I don't know. I guess I'm just saying that even if...
1:50:55 Grocery Owlette asked for a 5% parking reduction as part of their design review. You guys still would have had the ultimate approval of that just based on the fact that it had to go to you anyways? I believe they actually did request a reduction in parking and we gave it to them. Okay. So it doesn't sound like Greg has got the video in front of him, so I don't think I feel comfortable having him read or making a motion. Would one of you other commissioners like to make a motion and we can talk about additional language if you like?
1:51:29 But, yeah. I'll make a motion, but I don't really feel like we need additional language. So, if someone else wants to make a motion with an additional language, please do so. But I don't feel like we need that. Minister Chang, what are your thoughts? I agree with the feedback that Sandra and Chandler had, and also Jennifer's assessment on this.
1:51:59 I think we have enough safeguard within the toolbox that we have with town staff and with the municipal code that I think we should be okay. Especially, we just don't have that many projects that have 50 parking spaces and above. And I'm sure pretty much everything in that category will have to come up and come to PDC.
1:52:31 One way or the other. Right. Yeah, I gotta say, I just, I kind of concur with Chandler that the idea of putting more financial burden on a small business to hire the consultant, come up with a defensible reason why they should lose a parking spot or two, just sounds like a bit of overreach on our part. So I think I would be inclined with the motion as is.
1:53:02 Okay. I'll go ahead and make the motion then. I'll recommend that the Planning and Economic Development Commission adopt the attached planning, sorry, and Economic Development Commission resolution making the required CEQA findings and municipal code findings and recommending that the town council take the following actions, adopt the required CEQA findings pursuant to public resources code section 21083.
1:53:32 and state CEQA guidelines section 15183C that no additional EIR or other environmental analysis is required and to adopt the required municipal code findings and approve zoning code amendment 20-001 as recommended by staff. We have a motion. Do I have a second? I'll second that. Any further conversation or discussion? Jamie, roll call please. Commissioner Chang.
1:54:09 Yes. Commissioner Eckert? No. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. The matter passes 4 to 1. Thank you, Chandler, for the presentation. Thank you for the robust conversation, commissioners. I appreciate that. I like the idea of everybody expressing their opinion. We will move on to business matter. Agenda item number 3.
1:54:36 Support for the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce letter dated December 30th, 2020 regarding supporting the viability of the business community while keeping our community safe in the pandemic. And unfortunately, I think the chamber has got a board meeting that is running concurrent to this. So we won't have anybody speaking on behalf of the chamber. So Sandra, how do you want to, are you our staff contact, Sandra?
1:55:05 I am, yes. So just briefly, the Chamber, Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce sent a letter to Governor Newsom on December 30th. The letter had a number of points and requests in it. Some of those we have mirrored in this letter that is drafted from the Planning and Economic Development Commission to Governor Newsom. Chair Vanderhurst, as you know, you requested that we put this item on the agenda just to allow the Commission to discuss this.
1:55:34 So this is an opportunity for the commission to review this letter, to provide any comments amending the letter, and then with a consensus vote just to give the chair the ability to sign this letter and send it off to the governor. So noting that there was a joint town council board of supervisors letter that went out I believe last Thursday.
1:56:03 to Governor Newsom with some of the similar language as well. And I did forward that to you all earlier this week. So with that, we would be looking for any comments on this letter. And if there is support from the commission for this letter, just to give authorization to your chair to allow Chair Vanderhurst to sign the letter and then staff will send it on to Governor Newsom.
1:56:27 Thank you, Sandra. And I did confirm with Stu just after his presentation, we haven't received any response to either of those letters as far as we know at this point, so. Have you guys all had a chance to take a peek at the letter? Basically, we're asking, number one, that the governor terminates their regional stay-at-home order, which, you know, is a big ask.
1:56:57 But more realistically, we're asking the governor, ideally to move Mono County out of the Southern California region. We think it's very unfair to our business community that we're in that region. Most of our ties tend to be towards Nevada for our medical emergencies and medical support. We're asking him to put us in the Sacramento region.
1:57:22 For the second reason that all of the Lake Tahoe ski resorts and those resort communities are in the Sacramento region. So we feel that our interests would be more concurrent with that area and those resort towns than it would be with San Bernardino County, San Diego County, LA County, you know. And quite frankly, it's going to be a very, very long time for the Southern California region.
1:57:51 Reaches the threshold of 15% or more of ICU beds available before the stay-at-home order is lifted. So our local business community, as I'm not telling you guys anything you don't know already, is suffocating, is getting strangled to death with this stay-at-home order. Obviously, we're in the midst of the biggest public health emergency that any of us will ever see in our lifetimes. Fingers crossed, hopefully, right?
1:58:21 But there has to be some little bit of balance between public health emergency and economic emergency with our local business community. I'm not saying it has to be a 50-50, but it can't be 100% on one and zero on the other. We won't have a town, we won't have a community, we won't have a business community on the back end of this if this continues much longer.
1:58:47 You guys live here, you know it's tearing this community apart right now. I don't think I've ever seen emotions so raw in the town of Mammoth Lakes. It's a very polarizing time. So I thought since half of our title is economic development for the town of Mammoth Lakes, I thought it would be wise if we threw our support behind some sort of a throttling back on the heavy hand of restrictions that we're living in right now.
1:59:15 That was the impetus for this letter. And I would love to hear your comments about that right now, if you guys wouldn't mind. Commissioner Eckert, did you have some thoughts on that? Sure. One of my biggest frustrations with this is, you know, from, I've got pretty strong healthcare background and influence in my life. And one of my biggest frustrations with this whole situation is that we are so focused,
1:59:52 on infection rates and test positive rates when the whole reason and justification for the economic shutdown has been to flatten the curve. Our curve has been pretty darn flat. We do have some pretty unique exposures in that it's not going to take much of a bump in that flat to exceed our capacity here, but
2:00:23 In students' earlier comments, he indicated that, you know, back in the spring we were running at 3%, now we're running at 30%. But even though that is, you know, I'm not sure I'm doing the math, but a thousand percent increase, our hospital impact is still virtually identical. Our economic impact is bankrupting us. So while I am very much in favor of people being distant,
2:00:53 Being masked. What we really need to do is get people to get off their ass and figure out how to be compliant so they're not out of work. I would absolutely support having us put more with Sacramento and Tahoe than LA. I think that's crazy. And there's a way to have that be triggered by serious hospitalizations as opposed to infection rates.
2:01:22 and test positives, I think it would make a lot more sense. Thank you, Commissioner Eckert. Commissioner Chang, any thoughts on the letter? I'm in complete agreement with the Chair on this, and I appreciate the effort on this, and also with the Chamber on this one. Without fueling the debate with additional words, I think I would just leave it at that I think it's important.
2:02:00 for us to continue to move forward. And I'm 100% supportive of this letter. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Kennedy, any thoughts? I do have some thoughts, and I have one question, which is that, maybe this is a Sandra question, the town and county letter, the only ask in that letter was for Mono County to be removed from the Southern California region. Is that correct? Yes. Okay.
2:02:29 I guess that's my biggest concern with this letter. I'm all for sending a letter. I, to be completely honest, don't know that it will do very much since we have responses from the other letters, but that's not for us to decide anyway. So I'm all for kind of putting it out there that we need some extra support and consideration here. That said, I'm really excited to hear Stu's vaccination news. I think we really are.
2:02:57 Almost to the end of this, if we can just hang in there, but just going through those couple of bullet points on the letter. The first bullet point, I think, is we all want that, so totally in support of that. Again, I think that's the state's goal, is to let us out as soon as possible. The second point, I support moving toward purple tier, but reviewing, I did review, since Stu said that,
2:03:27 Purple tier only allows outdoor dining, no indoor dining. So I guess I feel like the purple tier doesn't really functionally change that much for the community and the business community. Maybe if it keeps not snowing and we have a drought year, then that's great. But are people going to keep coming here in that sense? So functionally, purple doesn't feel that different. If we were moving toward red, which I guess hopefully is what we move toward if the positivity rate will decrease, then red makes a big difference.
2:03:57 And essentially, when we went into Purple Tear, the business community said, that's death for us. So it feels like, oh, we're going from post-death to death. Feels a little odd, but I'm okay with that. And then the third point, I guess my only suggestion on that is that it feels a little bit, I guess I feel like if we're going to go through the trouble to write a letter pitching things, that we should pitch something with a little more
2:04:26 Wait to it. Like I love the thought of us being included with Sacramento, but I guess it feels like I would love to see a little bit firmer of an ask in that, whether that's we want to be in Sacramento because of this, because of Tahoe, because of, you know, we'll send people there if they need care or whatever it may be, or ask for not just say that we're relying on Reno and Carson City, but ask their ICU numbers to come into play. I guess I just feel like we need
2:04:54 A data point for this, if there's any hope for the state to consider it. And again, like I said before, I don't mean to be hopeless, but like if they didn't listen to town council and county supervisors, I don't know that they will listen to the Planning Commission, but that would be my only suggestion on that third point is to have a little more, you know, take us out, but not just take us out, but take us out and put us here with this data point being the hook for it.
2:05:20 And then my only last point I want to bring up, which I think all of you commissioners are on board with this and so is town staff. We have great community programs, but just remembering to myself and to this community that COVID didn't bring up problems that we didn't already know about. These are all issues that we've been talking about and thinking about for the most part for the last few years beyond when I've lived here.
2:05:49 And I just want to remember that, I don't know, I guess, hope that we can focus beyond this pandemic. Hopefully we all get vaccinated this spring and we can kind of move on from this. But to remember that part of the trauma of this is that we're completely dependent on tourism and think through as a commission how we can be more active in an economic development sense to really diversify things. So I know that's a bit off topic, but...
2:06:15 That's all. So I support it. I wonder if we can make the third bullet point a little more actionable, but otherwise, thank you for your work on this, Michael, and looking forward to getting it out there. Hey, Jessica, could I just reply to a couple of your comments? And then, Sandra, I would love to hear your thoughts on maybe revising the wordsmiths on the third bullet. So one of the things that would happen if we did manage to move back into purple...
2:06:41 Was lodging would go up to 70%. Oh, gotcha, right. Okay, so that increases the, granted, the indoor dining ban is detrimental and deathly to our restaurant sector, but having lodging at a solid 70% would really increase the amount of takeout and outdoor dining. Plus, personal services get to reopen at a reduced capacity, so we have that going for us as well. So, I mean,
2:07:09 Granted, I would love to be in red, but just looking at the numbers that Sue presented earlier, it's going to be a while before we're in red, especially if we're stuck in the Southern California region and we can't get out of that. The other thing, and I agree, you know, this letter might get lost in the wash of Sacramento, and I'm sure there are counties all over the state that are petitioning the Sacramento to get moved out of certain regions, but I do feel what this letter will do will show our local business community that we've got their back.
2:07:37 That we're supporting and we understand the situation they're in and how dire it is and that we're part of, we're on the helping side or we're attempting to be on the helping side. Sure. Thoughts on that. And let me jump to Commissioner Burroughs before I go back to you, Sandra, if you don't mind. Commissioner Burroughs, any thought on the letter? Yeah, quite a few thoughts. As you may or may not know, I've been...
2:08:05 Pretty strong advocate at town council meetings and whatnot supporting our business community being open up at least somewhat because they're dying. They're dying. And I have a very strong medical background for those of you who may not know that. And I think it's very important that we balance this community health crisis.
2:08:35 Along with keeping our businesses open so that they can function. There's a report by the Wall Street Journal saying that one in four small businesses will not make it through this pandemic. This is going to turn us into a financial recession, if not a depression is the prediction. And we need to be advocates for our business community. We have enough healthcare officials out there being advocates for our health.
2:09:04 And our job is to be advocates for our town economy. And Michael, you're right.
2:09:15 San Diego, Southern California region is not going to get out of this anytime soon. I have so many nurse friends down south who have all said that their ICUs have a waiting list to get in. The hospital I used to work for has three floors that were just taken over by the state so the state can run their own ICUs. It's incredibly insane down there right now.
2:09:40 You know, whether it's the health of our community or whatnot, we're not seeing that here. And we are lucky. And our patients aren't going down to San Diego or Southern California. They are going up to Carson City. They are going up to Reno. And we've been fortunate that we've been able to transfer our patients there. So I think that it's really important that we start focusing on the health and livelihood of our businesses. Otherwise, Michael's right, we will not have.
2:10:07 a town, a community after this. So I am 100% in support of this letter. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Sandra, what are your thoughts on the third bullet? So I think that I could certainly pull some data from the Nevada Region Hospitals and include that in there. I think that would make it, I think that provides that data point that Commissioner Kennedy is looking for. And then, you know,
2:10:37 The discussion about Sacramento, I can take a look at what we wrote. I don't think we provided any data points in the letter from the county and the town, that joint letter, but I can kind of think through that and try to figure out what we could put in there to make it more actionable to request to Sacramento. Because it sounds to me like the commission wants to see a request, kind of this joint request, like either put us in Sacramento or give us our own region.
2:11:06 So we can kind of keep the letter as is and then I can pull that together. And then if the Commission gives us direction to do that, Chair Vanderhurst, you can just sign the final letter and, you know, authorize that I've done all, I've put in the data points that you think are sufficient. Got it. So what I really don't want to see is this letter just stalled because of revisions and we address it at our next meeting in a month.
2:11:31 I'd like to get this letter out ASAP. So are you, my fellow commissioners, comfortable if we have Sandra kind of wordsmith the third one a little bit and then I sign it and send it on our behalf? Yes. I think that's perfect. I have one other comment which is, I guess just to clarify, it's not, I think Sandra and Michael, you both understand this, but my goal is to be, I guess when we talk about being our own region, then we're
2:11:59 We're acting like an island and realistically we do need ICU capacity. We've had a couple of instances from here that have gone to Nevada. So I guess, and maybe there's, you guys know more about this, but maybe if we said let's rely on Reno and Carson, that might not fly and maybe we shouldn't even propose that. We should just focus on the Sacramento thing. But I just...
2:12:20 I guess I just want to avoid us saying, hey, make us our own island because then we have nowhere for people to go. And if I were Governor Newsom, I'd say, well, that's crazy. You've got to send your people somewhere. So I'm fine with either of those options and totally fine with you guys wordsmithing and moving on from there. And I agree. Let's get it out ASAP. So thank you. Perfect. Jamie, do we have any public? Sorry, Greg, go ahead. I think it's going to be a really big ad to even have them open the envelope.
2:12:48 If they do, the likelihood that they redraw any boundaries is nil. I think if we have any chance of actual progress here, it's going to get switched from one existing jurisdiction to another. There's nobody over on the other side of the hill that's going to redraw the boundaries for us and make our own island. Sandra, you want to maybe address that?
2:13:20 I mean, I don't know that much about this process and how they're allocating, how they lump this into Southern California. So I think that maybe Commissioner Eckert is correct and that it's limited that we would likely be put into our own island, relying on another state for ICU care.
2:13:43 But I don't think it hurts to ask. We certainly could split up that bullet point into two bullet points and first request the Sacramento tier or Sacramento region and then subsequent we could have another bullet point that talks about kind of being our own island with a reliance on the Nevada hospitals because I do think it's a good point that we really don't transfer to Sacramento. We really only transfer to Nevada and then I think there are some times that we do.
2:14:11 Transport down to Southern California, but so, you know, I mean, I think that we could split it up and kind of make that request a little bit more clear if that helps. I like that idea, Sandra. And it also, if we did, Grant, you're probably 100% correct that, you know, the three-county island is not realistic, but by having both those requests out there on behalf of this commission, it aligns us with the work that's being done on a county level and a city level, whether it's a public.
2:14:40 Process for the lobbying that's being done behind the scenes by the Board of Supervisors, specifically John Peters. I know he's making both of those requests, so I just want to make sure that we're kind of aligned with his efforts. I'm all fine with it. I'd love to see us succeed in Nevada entirely, but at the same time, I want to make sure we do something that we can accomplish and not something that we just want. Right. I hear you there. Can I throw in one more comment, Michael? Please.
2:15:11 I do think that, I don't know if there's a way to work it in, but somehow working in the why of Sacramento that we are, you know, tied to Tahoe or tied, you know, that there's some pitch to that. I guess I worry that Sacramento is the only one that's free now. So we're just like, oh, send us there. Right. So tying that in somehow would be awesome. And hopefully, I guess the thought is.
2:15:36 Once you leave the stay-at-home regional order, then you're in whatever tier your case is qualified for. So once, if we could get out of the stay-at-home order, then we'd be in purple and hopefully the goal is to move our local case rate down. Gotcha. Okay, cool. Thank you, Michael. Thanks, Sandra. Would you mind incorporating that into the Sacramento, the relocation in Sacramento region ask that we're naturally aligned with the Lake Tahoe region? Yes, I can include that. Thank you. Okay.
2:16:06 Jamie, any public comment on this matter, either in person or digitally? No, there is no public comment. Got it. All right, I'll close public comment, and unless there's some more thoughts by my fellow commissioners, I would entertain a motion. I'll move. What am I moving here? To support the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce letter dated December 30th, 2020 regarding supporting the viability of the business community while keeping our community safe in the pandemic. Do I have a second?
2:16:40 Second. Any further discussion? Okay, let's go to roll call, please, Jamie. Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Passes 5-0, and thank you for the support, commissioners. I really appreciate it, and I really feel like it's the right thing to do. Let's go to consent agenda.
2:17:13 Does anyone want to pull anything out of the consent agenda or is there a motion to approve the consent agenda? I'll make a motion to approve the consent agenda. Do I have a second? I'll second. Any further conversation? Jamie, may I have a roll call vote, please? Commissioner Chang? Yes. Commissioner Eckert? Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst?
2:17:52 Yes, passes 5-0, thank you. Commissioner Reports, why don't we start with, why don't we start with Mr. Commissioner Eckert. I've been out of town quite a bit lately, but virtually all of the comments I've got from public have been regarding the virus, regarding the business closures, and I think that, you know, this letter, while it may be of limited effect.
2:18:23 is something that needs to be done, and we need to try and get more people to be more compliant in any way that we can, because this is something that, I mean, I'm just thankful that we have a very bad flu here. If we would have had something like an Ebola or a terrorized use of a bioweapon, we can't even pull this off. Our general population needs to be much more
2:18:49 Aware of what they're not doing and be more compliant. I think we've gotten past the point of people thinking that it doesn't exist, but they really need to step up and do more in their off time, their personal life, not just in their business life. Well said. Well said, Commissioner Eckerd. Commissioner Burrows, do you have a report you'd like to share with us today? I do. Thank you for asking. We did not have any design committee meetings this month.
2:19:22 I have been appointed to the Local Transportation Commission, and we had a meeting on Monday, and so I am the Planning and Economic Commission representative for the Transportation Commission. Boy, that's a mouthful. Anyway, we made two motions.
2:19:44 During that meeting, the first was to resent, I don't know if any of you knew this, because I sure as heck didn't know that, but the Tioga Pass 120 was originally supposed to be a four-lane road, and so we rescinded the plan to make it a four-way road and keep it as it is, because there's just not enough traffic through there to need that.
2:20:09 So that was the first thing we did, and then we approved replacement of a guard rail that was destroyed during the Walker fire, and it's off one of the county roads back there, and apparently it is much needed in that area. So those were the two actions I have to report on that. That meeting meets once a month, and I will be reporting back from that meeting to our commission meeting every month. That's all I have.
2:20:39 Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Commissioner Chang, do you have a report you'd like to share with us today? I do not have any additional items other than what we have discussed already. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Thank you. And last but not least, Commissioner Kennedy. Nothing from me. I just can't wait till we get through this COVID stuff. Right. There, there, there. I'm just going to throw out there that you guys heard me talk about it earlier. I was volunteering at the Vaccination Center on Monday.
2:21:09 I cannot tell you how enthusiastic people were coming through to get their first shot. Unbelievable amounts of energy. People were calling it Happy Vaccination Day. It was mainly school teachers and first responders. Ski patrol members came through. And then obviously the older demographic that's in that first tier came through in great numbers. But the energy I saw there was unbelievable.
2:21:38 And again, like Sue said earlier, we've got 3,000 doses on the way that will be here shortly. Next week is going to be very fast paced in terms of information and vaccination, location and timing. So definitely get the word out there, let people know about it. You know, it does kind of feel like the light at the end of the tunnel. So pretty exciting stuff. And that's all I have for Commissioner, my Commissioner report.
2:22:07 Question, Michael? Yeah, please. Is there, I got John's email about volunteering. Is there any more formal process? Are they still seeking volunteers or just keeping an eye on emails for that? Yeah, just keeping an eye on emails. And I think at some point here, the county's going to make CERT operationally effective for handling, you know, these larger vaccination periods when it's open to the general public because you're going to, there's a lot still to be determined. Jessica?
2:22:35 They don't know if it's going to be walk-in or if it's going to be drive-through, you know, what to do if there's bad weather. They're going to look at other locations besides the firehouse. They're talking about maybe the college or maybe the high school. So there's a lot of moving parts right now, so I would just kind of keep your eye on email. But yeah, it was incredibly rewarding to be down there. Maybe this will finally prompt the snow to come as soon as we get ready with the vaccines. Right? Right? No, that'll be in June.
2:23:03 when we're finally ready to turn the page. Sandra, did you have a director's report you'd like to share with us? I do. Just briefly a reminder that next week on January 20th,
2:23:16 is an opportunity for ethics training for all of our commissions. So Jamie Gray had sent out information to all of you on that. It is mandatory every two years. So if you didn't do your ethics training last year, you should join that meeting next week.
2:23:37 Andy Morris, our town attorney, will be giving that presentation or the training and he usually does a good job of making it interesting and has a lot of interesting stories for you during that training. So that's all I have for my report. Would you mind asking Jamie to resend that out to the entire commission, please? Sure, we can resend it out, yep. Thank you very much. All right, guys, I just wanted to say thank you for all your feedback today. I thought we had some great discussion on all of our items.
2:24:08 Your thoughts are always very valued. And thank you for the time. I'm going to adjourn, and Sandra, thank you team too. I know Chandler and Nolan, that was some heavy lifting with both of those matters. It was very much appreciated. And just reach out to me when the revised letter is ready and I'll swing by the town offices and John Hancock will get it out. With that, I'm going to adjourn today's meeting.
2:24:36 And our next scheduled meeting for the PEDC is February 10th, 2021 at 2 p.m. on Zoom. So I'll see you guys then.