Trails Committee Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 40 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 findingTranscript
204 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Trails Committee Workshop on the Trail System Master Plan. Angie, if you could start us off with a roll call, that'd be awesome. It'd probably help if I unmuted. Okay. John Conley, he'll be here late. Finley Torrance, Dan Holler. Here. Bill Souser. Yes. Elise Howell. Here. Casey is absent.
0:43 David Page. I'm here. Thank you so much. Thank you. So before we get started, are there any public comments that anyone wants to bring up on something other than the Trail System Master Plan? I have received no comments via email. No one is in Suite Z, and there are currently no hands raised by our Zoom viewers. Okay, they're being done then. Let's go ahead and jump into...
1:17 Review and discussion on the Trail System Master Plan update, or Trail System Master Plan, sorry, from 2011. Very good. Can everybody hear me fine? Heads are nodding. Thank you. My name is Joel. For anybody that doesn't know me, I'm the Trails Manager for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And this is a workshop to educate our committee members, ourselves, and everyone else on
1:48 A trail system master plan that was adopted in 2011. I say adopted because it does have a programmatic environmental impact report associated with it. And the document itself is a plan, an adopted plan of the town of Mammoth Lakes. Thanks for joining us today. This is the cover if you haven't seen it before.
2:15 This is the cover of our Trail System Master Plan for familiarity. And this, in a nutshell, is what we are. So the Mammoth Lakes Trail System equals Trail System Master Plan, in effect. The town does have other transportation-related plans in existence today.
2:45 that complement the Trail System Master Plan in certain ways. These documents have more to do with circulation for vehicles and pathway circulation. So this is a quote from the plan. This is an important statement. This is one of the only slides where I will read it out loud. The Town of Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan was conceived as a way to guide the development.
3:16 of an extensive, integrated, year-round trails network for the Town of Mammoth Lakes, which will improve mobility and quality of life for residents and provide the widest range of outdoor experiences for both residents and visitors. The trails network will also support sustainable economic development, allowing Mammoth Lakes to grow its economy while maintaining desirable characteristics that have brought residents and visitors here in the first place.
3:45 A year-round trail system is essential to sustain Mammoth's recreation-based economy. Okay, coming out of that effort in 2011 and subsequent years, Mammoth Lakes Recreation was created to effectively manage the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Program. And this graphic, in effect, illustrates what we consider trails coordination.
4:17 So we have Mammoth Lakes Recreation advising town council, making recommendations. The town of Mammoth Lakes will implement projects with public works or contractors for service in a continuous cycle. And the way things are set up now, we have a trails committee, a subcommittee of the MLR board that I report to.
4:43 They make fiduciary decisions, budget decisions, and provide guidance for me as to what we should be working on. This graphic illustrates the added capacity to support this effort. So we have Measure R, which is a tax measure, a sales tax that provides funding for this program. We do have other funding.
5:13 But our main funding for this program comes from Measure R. Fundraising happens, user groups support us, volunteers, other public agencies and contractors when we need them. The legal and fiduciary authorities are the United States Forest Service, the Mammoth District of Inyo National Forest, and the Town of Mammoth Lakes. In that, we have a memorandum of understanding, an MOU, with the forest that provides
5:46 Clarity on those things that we can and cannot do on the federal landscape on Forest Service lands. We have updated this recently. So we have about five years, slightly less than five years on our current MOU to operate within your national forest. And it includes all kinds of things from maintenance to signage and also stewardship. Trail System Master Plan.
6:17 Extrapolates to the sphere of influence of the town of Mammoth Lakes. In this graphic, you can see our little urban growth boundary here in the bright green in the center. And then all this land around us where we are connected to it. People come to our town and they want to launch out into these adventure areas for hiking, biking, and horseback riding and all kinds of activities.
6:47 The Trail System Master Plan prescribed subregions for us to focus on with planning efforts. And what you see in this slide are some acronyms in bold white. The one in the center, SHARP, that's the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan. The Sherwins Area Recreation Plan is a part of the adopted Trail System Master Plan. LABS is Lakes Basin Special Study.
7:12 And trick is Shady Rest, Inyo Craters. These are the three areas where we have active projects and planning going on today. Here's the cover of the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan for familiarity that came about in 2009. So that was two years before the adopted trail system master plan. And this map was made by forest staff back then.
7:41 And illustrates concepts that the Sherwins Working Group came up with. And this was a group of interested citizens and partners and stakeholders that worked to come up with different trail concepts for the Sherwins area. This map shows two trails from that plan that have been constructed since then. So here we have the Mammoth Rock Trail Connector and the Meadow Trail Connector.
8:12 That people have been enjoying for a few years now. But nice to see that this was implemented. This slide shows what we have in mind for future trails in the Sherwins. You can see that there's a trailhead in this graphic over here. That's the Sherwins trailhead by the propane tanks. Something just happened in Zoom. Yeah, it said my internet was unstable. Everybody back?
8:50 I saw something come in, yeah. What happened? Am I off? I don't have Zoom anymore. All right, let's get back on here. I am still hearing you, Joel, if it makes any difference. Looks like our internet was cut off for a second. Okay, Mike is telling me we have no internet right now, so I will see what we can do to get this moving again. You must have internet because I'm still hearing you. You can hear us because of the microphone, but our...
9:34 Zoom and Suite Z was cut off. All three of us. I'm logging back in now. It's back on. Okay. Make sure to remute yourself. Okay. Okay. Are we back? Yes. Okay. Did we see this already? I think that's right where it cut off. That's right where it cut off? Okay. Let's see.
11:01 This is a map of the work of the Sherwins Working Group. These are concepts out of the Sherwins Area Recreation Plan. These are two trails that have been constructed out of that planning effort, the Mammoth Rock Trail Connector and the Meadow Trail Connector. This next slide shows the Sherwins Trailhead and other trails that we have planned in the Sherwins Meadow that connect over to Mammoth Creek Park East. And this slide shows all the remainders
11:33 From our Sherwins Working Group and Sherwins Area Recreation Plan, all in green is what we have to build in the future. And just to give you a sense of why, well, one strong reason why it's important to implement this is this map shows user created trails in blue. And if I flip to this and that, you can see all the overlap.
11:58 And you can see that we have miles of trails in existence already that we simply can't maintain because they weren't constructed legally in the first place and not included in the formal system of trails that the Forest Service can manage. So here's the impetus for that. We have all these lines. A lot of these user-created trails are not sustainable. Many of them are in bottomlands or meadows.
12:24 And just not a real sustainable situation for the environment. Many of these trails don't follow sustainable grades. They're too steep in some cases. And this is our effort to make that right. Everybody with me? Okay. I just have one comment on that. An awful lot of the trails that they are saying are illegal user-created trails in the meadow are not.
12:56 They are cow trails from where the Forest Service issued grazing permits in the meadows. So if you issue a grazing permit and cattle walk over it until it becomes a path, I don't know that they can call that illegal or user-created. Just a problem I have with the way they define things. If you look to the Eastville, even out of the meadow, there's all kinds of trails up in those hills. And so whoever created them, we simply can't work on them, can't improve them. We can't even prune back the weeds to make it a...
13:24 Legitimate Trail Experience. And so I won't use the word illegal. Let's just say we can't maintain them. They're non-system trails. And we would like to maintain them in this configuration so that we can include them on maps for the public to use. Right now, to be able to find some of these trails, you really have to know somebody to take you out there. And that's just not really what we're aiming for, if that makes sense.
13:57 Here's an effort in a sub-region in Lakes Basin Special Study. This is not an adopted document. It doesn't have a subsequent environmental document like an EIR, but it has set the stage for our current project on Lakes Basin Connector Trails, and I'll get to that in a second. Lakes Basin Special Study was funded by the Sierra Nevada Conservancy and had a lot to do with mobility.
14:27 sedimentation of waterways and outdoor recreation patterns in the Mammoth Lakes Basin. Here's the cover for familiarity and you can see all the logos in the bottom of participating partners. Just this page out of that plan illustrates the front country focus of that planning effort, really trying to drill down to all that activity that's really focused in the Mammoth Lakes Basin.
15:00 The town also each year, or they try each year, to update town goals and priorities document. The last one that I was really tuned into talked about citing 100 miles of new trails as a part of that effort, that we saw the need, the purpose and need, and so just looking for consistency across different planning efforts.
15:30 Mammoth Lakes Recreation, their vision is to transform Mammoth Lakes into a world-class high-altitude training center, a premier mountain arts and culture destination, and the best alpine recreation community in the country. Pretty bold and ambitious, but I agree. We certainly have the landscape and amazing amenities already. Just want to hit on sustainability for a moment. Trails planning, trails construction, the addition of new trails is a relative low.
16:02 Capital Investment has its visitor driving infrastructure, also serves the people who live here nicely, low maintenance costs over time if we're building the trails right, and contributes to high quality life for all of us. There are many different impacts to business if we're creating trails that people really want to travel for. There's all kinds of
16:32 Economic data out there and some areas that people are collecting around this. The quality of life, you know, I mean, I think we all know why we live here. It's nice to have trails out your back door, especially now outdoor recreation is so important. Public health goes without saying that exercising outside is very good for us and we can measure those effects on people. Property values do increase when you have amenities like this that are sustainable and known about.
17:03 People love to have trails out their back door. This map, I know some of you have seen before, this shows a little relativity compared to a lot of the other mountain communities in the west, ski towns. You can see for public access, multi-use, non-motorized single track trails, that notion of 100 miles.
17:33 Of new trails seems to make a lot of sense. We are up to 17 now, so this is no longer 14, so that's good. But we have 17 miles compared to St. George with 120. I think that has almost doubled since I made this map. Moab certainly higher than 415 now. And you can see places like Boise with 444 miles of trails. Jackson Hole's up to 98 now.
18:02 That used to be very few miles. When I was in high school in Jackson, Wyoming, I was a part of a small group that was pioneering trails off Teton Pass that are now legitimate system trails, and they really didn't have much back then, but now they're up to almost 100 miles. Some of the concepts around sustainability are really thinking about how water affects our trail tread, and these different diagrams.
18:33 Illustrate what we think about when we go into design and construction. On the stewardship, implementing the stewardship recommendations out of the Trail System Master Plan, we really hit the notes on this, I think, you know, early on with MLTPA, Friends of the Inyo and the town working together with the forest, started Mammoth Lakes Trail System Trail Days, and it's been going strong and growing ever since.
19:06 There's a lot to celebrate there around Trail Days. I just want to point out that, as I pointed out earlier, Measure R is a primary funding stream for our program, and I just wanted to point out that here's the written code that I think about all the time when I am being careful with Measure R dollars. You can see this sentence.
19:38 Without supplanting existing park and recreation facility maintenance funds, right? So this makes sure that the money that is provided for the trails program isn't used to fill potholes as a part of some other program and supplanting other programs for the town. So it's a very separate, safe funding stream where we can focus our efforts on trail design.
20:08 And trail construction and maintenance. On the subject of trail system master plan information, we have a PDF that we can use as an aid, right? Yes, you want me to share the screen? That would be terrific. Take your time. These are the slides I wanted to provide as sort of an introduction to where we are today.
20:41 I think you need to stop sharing yours for a second. Kim is going to share with you a sheet that shows us where we have direction from the plan and where we've implemented that part of the plan. Okay, so we need to share this with the group afterward, right? Yes. Yeah, so all these documents you'll have access to after this workshop so you can study them in fine detail.
21:17 But you can see in this column, Trail System Master Plan Citation. At the top, let's just pick Shady Rest. Inyo Craters Planning. And we're implementing that. So there's our project. It's a part of our program. Tonight at 5, I'll be sharing in the Mammoth Trails meeting some of our progress on that project. But this is a really nice sheet to look at because you can see how it reflected.
21:44 You know, how much we are implementing out of the plan. Sherwins Walk, Bike, Ride has all kinds of goals cited as a part of this. Our standards manual for consistency, signage and wayfinding. We've been really focused on that in recent times. And you may have noticed out on the trail system, a lot of our signs are looking pretty good these days.
22:13 We just implemented the regulatory signage, things like that. So this is a nice guide to see where we've made a lot of progress. And if you look at the plan, you'll see where we have a lot of room to grow and a lot of things yet to accomplish. Back to you. David, those were the slides that I wanted to share with the group to provide a nice baseline of information.
22:51 From here, we had hoped that the committee take up a workshop style conversation and discussion to provide us with some direction on what we might emphasize in the future. If there are areas where committee members would like to see us put more focus on, this is a great opportunity to discuss those things. And it's a great time for everybody to ask questions and get them answered.
23:23 Okay, thanks for that, Joel. I guess I can just open up the floor. I've got a whole long list of things, just notes that I took in my latest reading of the master plan, but I'd like to have other folks go ahead and kick it off. Elise, John, Bill, anybody got anything, or you want me to go ahead and jump in on mine? I just have, I guess, a comment initially. So when reading through the trail system master plan,
24:00 You know, it talked a lot about the multi-use trails, the, you know, the hard service trails in town. And as a committee, since I've been on the committee, we really haven't discussed that much, you know, obviously signage, that sort of thing, wayfinding, but haven't really discussed those trails. And is this an appropriate place to discuss that? Or is that more?
24:28 Town-related and less Trails Committee-related. I think that's a great question. It was definitely one of the things that leapt out at me in checking back in with the document to see how much progress we've made in terms of MOPS since 2011, connectivity, you know, a lot of those, there were a lot of holes in the MOPS system that have mostly been filled. A lot of the wayfinding has been accomplished. But I agree that the soft surface part of the
24:57 of the suggestions have really, I mean, I think as Joel pointed out, I mean, you know, we've managed to do 17 miles. So I think, and I was also struck by the fact that there were suggestions about creating bumps down the Sherwood Creek corridor and Mammoth Creek corridor. It'd be interesting to take that stuff up. Right. I mean, I know it's been
25:27 You know, we've had discussions about it being mildly frustrating to see how little we've accomplished. But then when you read this document, you realize, oh my gosh, we've, you know, there's been so much progress since 2001 when I first moved here and I tried to walk a path and then it would dead end and then you would find another path and then it would dead end. And so making that connection, the connections and having the way finding signs has been a huge accomplishment, I think. I found that a lot of
25:55 There were quite a few things on the Mammoth Trails that I think in some ways would be easy fixes, and most of them were within our urban growth boundaries. So the, what do I want to say, the conflicts or the, you know, some of the problems that we face when trying to create a new trail we may not encounter because it is within that urban growth boundary.
26:22 I have seven items. I don't know if I should just go through them. I don't want to dominate the conversation, but I guess I'd like to talk about Mammoth's first and then, is that okay? Yeah, I'd be interested to hear it. And just to also layer in the fact that, you know, a lot of the sidewalk call-outs and a lot of the mobility call-outs are sort of handled by or have been handled by Public Works. And I think you're absolutely right if not been part of our Trails Committee discussion, but I think it's really worth
26:52 Sort of figuring out where those lines are and which parts of those things we should engage. And there are two things going on there. One is the difference between municipal recreation and such, which is primarily your mucks and sidewalks, and your non-municipal, which Measure R and the Trails Committee more deals with, which are more your soft surface and your outside of the town trail system. Although we have a huge responsibility for making sure we have connectivity.
27:21 Between all of those, but the other difference between them also are the funding sources. I believe, and Hayes isn't here, but Dan could probably answer, virtually all the muffs and sidewalks have been built with highway dollars and grants outside of Measure R and everything else. So there's a delineation in the funding sources. So there's a delineation of who deals with them. Hopefully I explained that correctly. Correct me if I'm wrong, John.
27:51 That's Dan. There's been a few, you know, a little bit of use of major art in more recent years, but the vast majority of elements are coming through either town dollars and or with grants and development requirements and also some private, you know, public partnerships with some of the sidewalk work or some of the month work. And David, if I could just maybe just add a little bit of historical context. I'm sitting here to provide that historical context, which hopefully will be useful.
28:20 And Elise and David, I'm really sort of proud and glad that you guys, you know, that's where you're going to in terms of the Trail System Master Plan, in terms of what things maybe have not been implemented yet. MLTPA initiated this effort back many years ago, and we had a very interesting conversation with Mike Schloppen from the Forest Service. He said, yeah, okay, the Forest Service is going to sign off into a pretty ambitious trail planning effort, but we're really concerned that really I think the town's only got to get its urban.
28:49 Act together first. So before we really start going out into the hinterlands of the Forest Service, we really need, the Forest Service would be most comfortable if the plan would really focus on connectivity, mugs, nodes, all those kinds of things. And that's why the plan is, it's weighted a little heavily in that direction, because that was a direction from one of the most significant partners, which is the Forest Service, as we put this together to make this thing happen.
29:17 So I think it's very important you guys are identifying those deficits. And I think it's especially important as we go into things like building community housing. We look at the walk-by-ride plan and how those things overlap. And there really is a real need now that I would think from my perspective of looking at that hard infrastructure. It's expensive. It's not that easy to do. But it lives in the trails plan. It lives with you guys. And I think if these are things that you think are important, I think.
29:46 Certainly Bill and I as council members would love to see those recommendations coming up because they really are really important. And if you haven't read the Walk by Breitland, I really encourage you to take a look at that because that's that real synergy with those things. And we really need to be able to move people around in town and get people out of cars, get people out of automobiles. I mean, this is what this is, you know, this is walking the walk of being a feet first community. And the only other thing I would add is that there's a lot of money now coming out of the state of California to invest in that.
30:15 Alternative means of transportation and mobility. The governor said that I think it's a multi, it's a multi-hundred million dollar program to start investing in to make it affordable for electric cars, like to be in those electric bikes, all that kind of stuff. A lot of that stuff is in walk, bike, ride, because it wasn't around when did the trail system mastermind. I'll leave it at that, but it's very encouraging that you guys pick up on those points, and those are one of the things that go forward. Yeah, and just briefly, I do want to hear your list, Elise, for sure, but John, just, you know, I think,
30:45 I think this does kind of open up the need for some kind of, I don't know exactly how to describe the effort, but some kind of workshop or organizational plan so that we can kind of decide whose purview.
31:07 Is, you know, who's got what purview over which parts of the trail system master plan? Because although, I mean, I love the idea that we can give recommendations. I agree with Elise that we've generally been focused on things that are, that really fit squarely in the Measure R bucket, whereas MLR more broadly has been engaged with some of the walk, bike, ride mobility pieces. And maybe some of that should come under the purview of the trails committee. You know, I think.
31:34 Moving forward, better coordination between Trails Committee, MLR, MLTPA, and Public Works on some of this stuff. Another thing that I noticed is there were a lot of call-outs for an action plan, and I'm not sure that that's something that we've been very consistent about. So I'm just throwing those out as sort of high-level organizational issues. Yeah, I think, well, the Trails Plan, you guys are specifically charged with that Trail System Master Plan.
32:03 And again, back to the historical perspective where the Forest Service was really encouraging us to really focus on that in the urban interconnectivity. And that's why there's so much of that in there. And I think it's got to start somewhere. And if you guys look at this and say, to benefit the trails program and recreation generally, you're a series of connectors. I think those nodes are particularly exciting. Called out in the trail system master plan because they line up directly with walk, bike, ride. And, you know.
32:31 Little leadership never hurt. And if there's something you guys want to take on and start maybe kind of rolling some of this stuff forward, I think that'd be a great place to get started. Go for it, Elise. Give us your list. Okay. One item is I see a need for a sidewalk to continue along Minaret Road between Meridian and the Village. More bike parking at businesses and trailheads.
33:04 It was mentioned on page 93 that they kicked around the idea of grooming or clearing the multi, the mud up to Tamarack in the winter, which I've never seen, but I'm curious about. The connector that dead ends at Bigwood Condos, which I guess is the Lodestar area there. I'd love to see that get back up to the Lake Mary Road path that takes you up to the basin.
33:34 There was a mention of a high Sierra camp connector on page 130. And instead of using that dirt road that goes up there to have that be part of the system. And I would love to see it. I'd love to see it continue beyond Waterford on Old Mammoth and maybe all the way up to Lake Mary Road. There's so much that Old Mammoth Road has become very busy between
34:04 I guess the bluffs and Lake Mary Road in the summer and people are just flying up and down that road and we try to bike it, we try to walk it, you know, we try to use it in many different ways and I can just see that becoming more of a conflict zone. And then the last one is consider adding diagonal crossing at the school library crosswalk. I have other general questions that aren't specific to
34:33 Mammoth, but I think that's about it. Let's come back to your other questions. I'd love to hear Joel's point of view on this because, you know, again, between Joel and Dan and Hayes and, you know, who sort of, I'm still or sort of always unclear about who's applying for which funding, who decides strategically which pieces to move forward when it comes to these little muffin connector bits. Joel.
35:02 So, Public Works has the lead on all things asphalt and concrete, if you want to think of it that way. Any engineered pathway is going to go through the Public Works Department, at least so far, right? That's how everything is structured, and appropriately so. The road builders, multi-use pathways look like roads to me. They're 10 feet wide in most cases and require the kind of engineering that our program just
35:32 As an example, the Shermans Trailhead, we brought that to a point, and then I worked with Hayes' office on getting the engineered drawings done for that project. And so it's basically, here's the baton, please help us with the asphalt and concrete, thank you very much. Having said that, in the planning is where we reside, right? So as we plan these facilities, in the...
36:00 Up until now, or the way things are done with these MUCs is Public Works has been getting transportation grant funding from the state and implementing the Mobility and Trail System Master Plan over the years. So I would say that our group right now, we reside in the planning realm and we would work with Public Works and plan these facilities.
36:30 But once we go toward construction, it's very much a public work. I've been very focused on the soft surface world and signage and things, and we have more and more been helping public works with the signage on the MUPS, which, you know, this program was not doing before, but in recent times, like, we helped them with the regulatory signage and, you know, our nice
37:00 Type 2s we're helping them with now. We replaced all the maps for our large Type 2 signs. That's what we did and not Public Works this time. So I would say over time we're doing more and more to help for sure. But there's a bit of a line there on the asphalt and concrete. But do you agree with John that it's useful to have this Trails Committee give specific recommendations?
37:36 On those connectivity issues, for example. Definitely connectivity, you know, we want people to understand that if they're on a multi-use pathway at the corner of Old Mammoth and Maine, we want to make darn sure that they know how to get to the Coldwater George Trailhead via our system of multi-use pathways and trails and roads. And Dave, I'll just echo that in terms of this issue around prioritization.
38:00 Public Works may have a list of projects on kind of a CIP that they've got, and they might find a grand opportunity, let's go see if we can do this and do that, but I don't, I'm not aware of any prioritization effort that's happening for this, and I think it would make a lot of sense for you guys looking at it from the perspective, perhaps, of the recreation and soft surface trail system, where are the connectors we need to integrate that system into the town, and also, as Elise has kind of put out there, things in there about just basic
38:29 Connectivity for residents. I mean, how do people get to the schools? How do people get, you know, if we're going to be grooming and how the MUPS make sure they get the MUPS are getting used year-round? That's completely, and that's the point that she made, that's completely within our purview. That's within the jurisdiction of the town. Not dealing with the Forest Service, probably. We're not dealing with a lot of other agencies. We are an incorporated agency of the state of California, and we can take these priorities directly to the state to get funding. So on that note, John, Joel, Dan,
39:00 You know, the multiple references throughout about the idea of creating an action plan. Have we done that in the past? Do we have one? Is that something that maybe we should engage as a trails committee to come up with those priorities from an action plan? Yeah, let me speak a little bit to that. There was an action plan done a long time ago that has basically gotten us to where you guys are today.
39:24 Soft surface trail signage, the soft surface trail work that's been done, the website, the communications, all the things that have already been implemented came out of that action plan. I think it would make a lot of sense to look at what you guys want to do, what's left, and to start putting together an action plan or prioritize the list of projects you think are important and give some rationale as to why you think they're important. And I think that would be enormous at this point. And just as a bit of reminder, the walk, bike, ride.
39:53 Action plan is an action plan. I think Finley's got his hand up. Can you guys hear me? Well, Finley, yeah. Well, I'm very sorry that I'm late. I was having technical difficulties. You know, when you read the master plan, you know, the low-hanging fruit, what we've done as far as hard surface maps, in-town, trails, sidewalks,
40:33 We've actually done a really good job, right? We've knocked a bunch of things off the list, and when you actually look at the master plan, you're like, wow, that was awesome. But, you know, the main thing, if I look at the master plan, was, you know, the connectivity between, as you leave the urban growth boundary, and how does that take you to trailheads and other nodes within the community, or access the lakes basin,
41:01 Devil's Post pile. I mean, all that's mentioned in the master plan. And when I really, when I really look at it, that's where we're not getting any traction. And I look at, you know, what was it written down? But, you know, one of the sections was where we, in the master plan, where we have governmental partners and then we have stakeholders in the community. And it seems like, if we go back to your Sherwin...
41:32 The Solitude Canyon project that we realized early on that was a good project. We all invested years of our time talking about it. We had many stakeholders from the community sitting in our meetings and we all talked about it and we all said, hey, that's a good project. Hey, is there anyone that's not into this? And everyone was like, yeah, that's a good project. That's a good project. Some people weren't quiet, but there was no one that actually said, hey, we got an issue. And then the project gets nixed right at the 11th hour or so.
42:03 My question is, how could we, can we, we obviously need to communicate better with the community and do more outreach to all the stakeholders that will either say to us, hey, you know, that's a dumb idea, you know, it's not good for, sorry to turn my radio down, it's not good for the deer mice, migration between Sherwood Creek and the Lakes Basin, or, you know, we save ourselves some time.
42:33 And move on to projects that actually we're able to accomplish. And so where did we not communicate properly with the community in the four years that I've been on the Trails Committee? Because we spent a lot of time talking and then we got no traction out of it altogether. So could we invest more time having public meetings? Do we need to, you know, really...
43:04 Invest time, create a relationship with friends at the Inyo and go, hey, guys, we really want to know. That's my point. I mean, I think we've really got to try and make some efforts in that connectivity into all the areas that our visitors need and that residents expect. Yeah, I think those are really excellent points. And I would just layer in another piece of it, which is that
43:34 If you look at this holistically and you look at what's been accomplished in that master plan and what hasn't, the remaining pieces that have not, as you said, gotten much traction all have to do with the Forest Service, right? And how do we, I mean, as Joel pointed out, certain aspects have been adopted in certain ways, but just that engagement with
44:02 With the Forest Service, which ultimately has to approve these projects, has, you know, we've just never gotten there. So how do we, looking forward, how do we start to look at some of these soft surface trail systems and, as Finley said, you know, make sure that we have public support from the community, but also make sure that we've got agency support to build out the system side of these trails. John, get your hand up. Yeah, just real quick, I want to...
44:30 It's an excellent point. I think you guys now have a very good idea of what it's going to take to do soft surface trails on the federal public landscape. You kind of know what's going on. I just want to share something. This is, if I could share my screen. Can I do that? Is that possible? Should be. Okay, I'm just going to share. This is a list. Can you guys all see this okay? Yep. So this is, Elise, back to your point about going through and looking at the mumps and that hard infrastructure stuff. This is a...
44:58 It's a full Excel document of every recommendation from the Trail System Master Plan, which is the citation, the code number right there. And this lists everything that's in there and what's been done and what hasn't been done. And the stuff in the dark red, this is all the stuff that from at least a couple of years ago just hasn't been touched at all. And these are all, there's a lot of mumps in here. There's a lot of nodes. There's a lot of these, you see these in-town connectors down in here.
45:27 This is a whole space that you guys have brought up at the beginning of the meeting. It really hasn't been engaged with yet. And I think, David, to your point about where does it sit with the town, well, it's in an adopted plan. It's got programmatic environmental work on it, but there hasn't been any prioritization for it that I'm aware of. And it's a lot of kind of low-hanging fruit.
45:49 I think Finley's point is an excellent one. If you're going to deal with the Forest Service, you know what you've got to do to try to be successful in that space. But a lot of these things are, it's a different kind of low-hanging fruit, but it really hasn't been engaged with yet. And I'm more than happy to share this list at some point. This will be helpful. But there's a lot of stuff in here that, again, overlaps to Joel's point about the walk-bike-ride as being an action plan. There's a lot of overlap and synergy between what's in the trail system master plan and what's in the walk-bike-ride plan.
46:19 And maybe bringing these things together and advising the town, staff, and council, look, we got a lot of overlaps here. We got some really important infrastructure we really need to focus on. And none of this is necessarily going to involve the Forest Service. I mean, this goes back to the point of being, this is within the urban growth boundary. This is within the town. And it may be more expensive. It may be more problematic. But it may have...
46:41 Things to do with other needs like housing and mobility and reducing vehicle miles travel and climate change and being a furt-feast community that really tied back to the town's general plan that there's going to be a lot of citations to go with it that might make these projects really ripe for funding from the state and to get that kind of money and to get these kinds of things done. So I just wanted to share that with you guys. I appreciate that, John. I think it'd be great if you could share that with the committee.
47:08 Kim and Joel, I think it makes a lot of sense to put that down as an agenda item for a meeting to really look at some of that and put it down as an action item so we can begin to have a real robust discussion about prioritizing. Yeah, I think I'm working on a list for a related project, but it will be...
47:26 Kind of a thing that we can look at between Kim, Gretchen, myself, and Joel. It's a nice synthesis of block bike ride, trail system master plan, hard infrastructure, and all those different kinds of things I think would be a good starting off point for you guys to start looking at. And we'll get to work on that. Just a note to share. So in my discussions with the public works director in the past, you know, I came to understand based on his experience that
47:56 There's sort of a balance in how things move. And so while they may or may, you may have things like ordered, like here's our first, second, third priority. And then what he informed me of is sometimes there's opportunities that come out of left field and you take them and we pounce. Oh, here's this, you know, ATP grant from the state and it lines up perfectly with X and you pounce. And I know a couple of things have happened that way in recent times.
48:25 But just so the group understands, it may not be as simple as one, two, three. You set the stage that way, and then opportunism comes into play here and there. I think that's an excellent point, Joel. And John, since you mentioned funding as well, this is kind of jumping into another sector, but there's a whole section in this master plan about funding, potential funding sources. Obviously, a lot of those are old.
48:55 But as I see it just off the top of my head, it seems like we have three different entities that occasionally have applied for grants or sought funding. One is public works. Obviously, a lot of work has been done through those opportunities that you just described, Joel. MLTPA has applied for some pretty significant planning grants and money from other sources. MLR has applied for some grants.
49:24 And I see that as another issue that we have where on the one hand, okay, we can prioritize and say, you know, this is A, B, and C for soft surface and we can create a priority list for municipal boundary capital improvement connectivity projects. But how do we know that we're, I mean, who's applying for funding for those things? Who's tracking that stuff? You know, I look at the list in the,
49:54 Master Trail System Master Plan, and have we ever applied for an LWCF grant as a town, just as an example? It's certainly, when you look at the list of projects that have been done by LWCF over the last 11 years in the state of California, some of them are really analogous to some of the things we've tried to do. So I think having a good, firm discussion about who's tracking those grants, who's, you know, so we can just sort of say, here's an opportunity.
50:22 This goes to Public Works. Here's an opportunity. This goes to MLTPA. Here's an opportunity. And I think, Dave, what's really helpful for that is the first place to start is back with those priorities. Don't worry about the money. Just, okay, what are the things that we want to do? Because the nature of the projects you guys want to pursue is going to dictate the financial source and who the applicant's going to be, right? So if it's a MUP connector in town, that's going to be, that's going to allow and lend itself.
50:52 To this type of funding. If it's a soft surface trail thing, that's a multi-partner thing, it's going to allow to that kind of funding. So really, if you guys start prioritizing the things that you think are important, and that we can bring, you know, then the funding sources start kind of falling into place based on what kind of a project it is. The other thing I would say is the SRTI is putting together a lot of research on funding opportunities.
51:15 That we will be gathering and putting all that stuff together. And as you know, the town has the contract with the Sierra Nevada Conservancy for that grant. And so we're going to be more than happy to share out all those resources. And those are going to be current resources because we're building that whole inventory of funding opportunities now. And there's a lot of great opportunities for that. We can share that with whoever you want us to share it with, with Cam or Joel, whoever. But that's something in your meetings coming up the next couple months, we should be able to share with you some.
51:45 Pretty robust, pretty broad ranging range of different funding sources for projects. And if you guys are breaking prioritizing the things you want to do, then we can start just lining those things up and, you know, figure out who applies and how to make it happen. Just to create some awareness around some of the gap, a gap. So just observation, I've seen, you know, plans get paid for.
52:15 By grants, I've seen construction get paid for by grants. There's a gap, and that gap is, it'd be great if there were grants for NEPA and CEQA, you know, to get our projects to the point of shovel ready in the middle part of the process. So we've got a nice trail system master plan. I've got a walk, bike, ride action plan that makes beautiful prescriptions, has goals and things in it.
52:46 We can certainly find construction dollars. I've been approached by a state agency. Hey, what do you have that's shovel ready? We really want to pay for that. And I say, well, I need money for NEPA and CEQA first. And they say, well, we don't pay for that because it's not a legacy project. It's not something that somebody can go walk on. It's not a bridge to celebrate. And so there's a gap in the middle. And if everybody can kind of...
53:14 Keep your ear to the train track for that kind of funding. I'm very interested to see if there's an agency that can understand the challenge of paying for, in many cases, especially for trail projects, it's the most costly part of the whole process. Well, but we do have Measure R for that, right? We do. And we do have money set aside for environmental review in Measure R. I'm interested in getting it paid for, not by Measure R, but, you know.
53:45 Yes, we have that. If you're seeing an opportunity where somebody's willing to pay construction costs if NEPA and CEQA are done, then that seems like a natural match for Measure R. Agreed. Just to be clear, it gets quite expensive, though. I mean, so, you know, we have an annual budget of, I think it's $350 that was approved for this past fiscal year. That could get gobbled up by a group of archaeologists.
54:24 And botanists and wildlife biologists pretty quickly. Or like, let's say we were faced with an EIS, it'd be a quarter of a million bucks out of the gate. John Connolly or Bill or Finley, just want to throw something on the table? Yeah, well, I think the priority is soft surface trails and, you know, getting our numbers closer to 100.
55:03 I mean, now that, what do you say, Joel, 17 or 18 miles? We're up to 17 miles of system soft surface trails. Yeah, and, you know, we really need to increase the mileage. And, you know, I'm not sure how it's done. That's why I wanted to be part of this board. But, you know, I notice that a lot of these trails happened a long time ago.
55:34 We need a couple more trails like Mammoth Rock Trail, maybe four more like the Mountain View Trail. And you just need to, you know, get the miles. You know, that's most important to me. And that's what I like to see. There's lots of connections around town and they're awesome, but we need the distance. And so that's, I think, should be our priority.
56:07 Yeah, and I mean, so John Wentworth, you steered us back toward, you know, hey, let's try to stick within the urban growth boundary, but I think that there's a question on the table that I think is worth very much discussing that Finley brings up. You know, one thing is public outreach and making sure that we've got community buy-in and unity around strategic priorities for soft surface trails. The other is...
56:34 You know, how do we improve our partnership with the Forest Service? It's just, you know, it's been a question since I've been doing this. It's been a question since you've been doing this. Yeah, and I just, I just, I'm not advocating for anything. I just, I'm just trying to bring awareness. Your calls, your decisions, your priorities, I'm just, I'm just bringing those ideas to you guys from an awareness perspective. The, you know, on the Forest Service side, there's another set of interesting opportunities.
57:03 Where the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments is pursuing a sustainable recreation and ecosystem management program. The Bishop City Council approved the program 5-0 on Monday. Mammoth County approved it 5-0 on Tuesday. Inyo County is going to be looking at it on Tuesday next week, and then the Mammoth Lakes Town Council looks at it on Wednesday. And there's an opportunity out there to bring in a pretty significant grant that would set up a...
57:29 An opportunity to do what's called third-party NEPA. So, John Conley, to your point, how come we can't build more soft-surface trails? Well, the consistent refrain from the Forest Service is, we don't have any capacity, we don't have any people to do the environmental work that Joel is talking about.
57:45 And then the suggestion is made, well, okay, can we do what's called third-party NEPA? Could the town hire the environmental specialists and do all that kind of work, bring all that work back to the international force, and then they can review it and hopefully approve it? And they say, well, yeah, we can do something like that. But then it turns into a conversation of, well, we don't even have the people who can go back reviewing that stuff, even if you hired the consultants to do that work. So it's this constant loop of frustration.
58:10 But through the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, there may be an opportunity to set up and establish an environmental, what's called an ID team, which is a whole staffed group of environmental specialists that would be specializing on, you know, people working.
58:27 Grant would fund primarily fuels work and firework because there's a lot of money in the state to do that. But if that kind of a team is in place, it does two things. One is you guys as a committee would know that there are bodies and people out there who could get that kind of work done. But the second, the most important thing is that the Forest Service would have to be acknowledging that doing third-party EPA is the way forward. And they wouldn't.
58:51 We wouldn't find ourselves in this constant loop of, well, we can't do it, but even get somebody else to do it, we can't even do it then, there would be a capacity in place to be able to address that situation and that problem. It's a little ways down the road, nothing's set yet, but those are the kinds of opportunities we've got to pursue at scale and regionally to be able to kind of crack that log jam between getting that environmental work done, and that's the biggest holdup.
59:18 And even just to what Joel's saying, even if the town, even if you guys wanted to say we're going to put $100,000 or $150,000 into doing environmental work, there's still no real representation from the Forest Service that they could do it because they don't even have the people to review the stuff if we did it as a third party. So it comes down to capacity and bandwidth and those kinds of ideas. Joel? I just want to add, so the ranger shared that good information with us this week in our Tuesday morning meeting, John.
59:47 I was very excited to hear that an ID team would be set up to help the region get projects to the point of shovel ready. I just wanted to have everybody aware that that ID team, that effort, should not just be NEPA. Because of the funding that will likely come from the state and subjurisdictions of the state, like Mono County and the town,
1:00:14 All the projects will also require CEQA environmental analysis. And so whatever group is put together, I'm hoping that they can provide services that satisfy both processes, both the state and federal process. That's another gap, you know, that we've seen over the years in working with the federal land managers. They're like, what's CEQA? And I'm like, well, we're in the state of California. So, you know.
1:00:43 And any project that is tied to state funding, it will require that process as well. Somehow, if I may, somehow one of the things we have to do first off is create a relationship with the Forest Service to determine from them each Forest Supervisor and each District Ranger I've worked with have been completely different from the one before.
1:01:11 There is no corporate memory, so they don't remember the history and sometimes need to be taught that history. We're dealing with that now at Shady Rest staging area. Frankly, we're being hosed. With that said, before we go after grants and spend a bunch of money to make a project shovel-ready, we somehow have to determine from our partners if they're willing to move that project forward. Because if they aren't...
1:01:40 Spinning our wheels isn't going to do us any good. Now, they have said they were ready for trails that Joel has brought forward and then they haven't been able to move them forward. But somehow we've got to get them to have a meeting with themselves as they used to do in their management group once a week to come out and say, you know what, a single track here we can go along with or we can't go along with. So we know where to put our focus for us to
1:02:08 Say, here's one, two, three, four of the projects we'd like to have done without knowing what the current forest supervisor and district ranger is willing to do is a moot point. There's no sense going down that road. As they change, and I'm hoping we get some change here in Mammoth shortly. This is a public meeting. I probably shouldn't have said that, but that's where I stand.
1:02:34 Then we can, you know, change our direction and see if they'd be willing to go there. But somehow we need for them to get together and come back to us and say, here's what we'd be willing to consider. And that takes a personal connection. I know Joel and Matt are both working on that. And I know the frustration of it. I've dealt with it myself for decades. But somehow we've got to get that from our partners so that we can then move forward. Otherwise, we're just going to continue to spin our wheels.
1:03:04 Don't mean to be negative. No, I mean, I think we have, we've got a dozen years worth of hard experience on that front. So, what do we do differently now? Well, I notice, you know, every forest must have their different rules and different opportunities. And there's a reason why we're at 17 miles and everyone else is at 100 plus. So, I'm just not sure.
1:03:39 You know why that is but you know if it works on another forest it should work on the Inyo. That's my thought and it'd be nice to get out of the way and let the trail builders you know do their thing. Matt, Joel you guys want to speak on this a little bit? Sure. I have not been shown in writing this policy but what I am told consistently
1:04:10 By both BLM and Forest Service staff, reasonable people. It's like they hit the play button. But the statement goes something like this. We can't build anything new until we can take care of everything we got. And it just stops right there. Because that logic says that until all the potholes and all the campsites are fixed up, spiffy and perfect, and all the trails are perfect, we're not going to get new trails.
1:04:39 It's an unrealistic perspective, in my opinion, and I bump into that not just here, pretty much everywhere I've lived. That's an easy thing for people to say if they don't have capacity to do more work than they currently are doing. But I hear it over and over and over again, and it's almost exactly that. And I just don't see it written down in policy, but I hear it over and over again.
1:05:08 Can't build anything new until we can fix everything we've got. Dan Holler, a while back, enlightened me on the failure of that logic. And Dan, I forget exactly what you told me, but it was really good. And, you know, I really think that if you can muster up what you told me then, it's something to the effect of, well, go ahead.
1:05:35 If that's truly the logic, then we will build nothing. You can't build streets, you can't build sidewalks, you'd never build schools, we'd never build community recreation facilities. Because everything you do, if you have to make sure how do you maintain it and take it, kind of life cycle costing out on that, that upfront cost component to that, you know, you'd never do it. You know, we have one, I don't know the numbers that we have, you know.
1:06:00 $50 million worth of streets in town. You say, well, it's going to cost you $3 million a year to maintain those if you build that many streets. Great, we're not doing that, so we would never build another street until we figure out how to maintain the current ones. In the meantime, what do you do? I guess you just go dirt and gravel or you just never worry about building anything new. Or you pass that cost on to whoever else is coming in at a level that makes it unattainable.
1:06:26 And so I think that logic ultimately in the Forest Service is the same thing. If you never build a new trail and you can't maintain what you have, all you do is shrink as things fall apart. So ultimately at some point that logic just doesn't work because really the bottom line answer to that, because of the unknowns is you'd never build anything that you'd have to maintain.
1:06:50 And the BLM does have a sage-grouse habitat issue they can point to for a no net gain in disturbed surface or things like that. But I am aware of field offices that work around that with mitigation measures and offsets and all kinds of things. When there are motivated people, you know, the projects, they happen. And soft surface trails are very popular. They're sustainable if you build them right.
1:07:19 These land managers do this. They provide trail facilities for people. We see it across the country. Right. It comes down to a personal bit by the person in charge again. I hate to keep harping on it, but for 40 years plus, the county of Mono first and then the town of Mammoth Lakes operated with a special use permit, a snow storage lot down on what originally was a mixing table when they moved the state highway. All of a sudden, a new...
1:07:48 District Ranger comes in and that's no longer doable. That's illegal. It's never been doable. Of course not. It's been done for 40 years. So I can't tell you how frustrated I get. It comes down to the people in charge. The District Ranger has an extraordinary amount of power. And when you get one that will work with you, I saw that Sandy Hogan was listening to us. Hopefully she's still there. I worked with Sandy a lot. We didn't always agree.
1:08:17 But we managed to get things done and build trails and do things. The current administration we have is not there. And I don't know how to get past that. I don't know how to build a relationship with someone that doesn't want to go there. Dan's going to shoot me later for saying this stuff on a recording meeting. But my frustration level, ladies and gentlemen, is over the top. Matt, go ahead. You're muted, bro. Yeah, thanks.
1:08:52 I definitely hear and share with some of the frustrations pointed out, Bill, by yourself and others on the discussion. And I'm happy the discussion's happening because it's a hard one to have. It's a bit of a hard reality to face. I definitely want to support what John Wentworth said, referring to bottlenecking of resources and NEPA being a pretty large obstacle to overcome.
1:09:22 And, you know, to your point with working with the current administration and historical knowledge, you know, I got to say, Joel and I work tirelessly at those relationships and making them work. And the bottom line is, you know, we can't, you can't cut down a tree to improve your view in your neighbor's yard. And that's not changing. So it is the communication and relationship component that's got to
1:09:50 Lead us and steer us to success. And we've got to be super tightly organized on our end to know what our asks are, to not flounder in those asks, to have, you know, cultural and community support for those things that we do want and not flounder in what our request is. And Joel and myself and others in the Public Works Department, Dan Holler, we need to continue to cultivate those relationships.
1:10:17 And jacked and infused monies to bring projects to completion. And frankly, I do think we have seen successes. And they may have been small successes, but I feel that there's momentum there. And just to be the other side of the coin there, Bill, and be maybe naively optimistic, I think that that can happen with this administration, with this agency, and that we are really building on small successes.
1:10:46 It's not to say that there haven't been setbacks. There's been miscommunications with the agency. There's been miscommunications internal to our own agency and specifying our own priorities. So I think we have a lot of work to do. And yeah, I just want to say difficult conversation to have, but I'm glad it's being had. Also, real quick on that too. I mean, it was the previous district rangers as well, that same commitment in terms of maintenance, et cetera.
1:11:16 On the front end, as we went into that, one of the first programs we did was get the permits in place for us to actually go out and maintain trails. Okay, now that we're maintaining stuff, let's build something new. Drag of that. And also with the commitment saying, if we're going to build it, we're going to use town resources to do that, then we want to have an agreement that then long term allows us to maintain it. If that's the hang up, then let's step up and fix that issue and take that off the table as an argument. I think it did help us in a couple of areas.
1:11:44 But obviously then it rolls back into, well, yeah, we understand that, but now it's back to the NEPA secret dialogue and stuff before you can actually put the trail down on the ground. So there are other elements. But as we make those commitments going forward, we want to take that one argument off the table. We're helping maintain. If we're building something new, we're stepping up and maintaining it. We want to be able to follow through on those types of comments. And if we do them right,
1:12:08 Joel and I have had this discussion several times, especially on soft surface trails. If we build them right, the maintenance is pretty low cost. But a lot of that is getting that design right on the front end, which some of the existing ones are not as well done as they could be. So on that point, just quickly, maybe this goes to Joel, but I mean, obviously, I understand the fallacy of the argument from the get-go, but it appeared all summer long in the pages of the, you know, in the op-ed.
1:12:39 Section and the sheet. And I think there's a bit of a narrative around that. Like, why would we think about building new trails if we can't maintain what we have? But my question now, having tracked, you know, looking back at the trail system master plan, our budget in 2007-8 for trail maintenance was $35,000. And now we have a trails budget of $300,000 and a trail...
1:13:04 Coordinator and a bunch of MLTPA staff. And it seems to me we're doing a damn good job of maintaining what we have in the system. So, you know, on the one hand, how do we communicate that better to the public? How do we make sure that the Forest Service recognizes the fact that, in fact, our trail system as exists is really top notch and is being maintained to the highest standards? And as the least...
1:13:32 So much better than it used to be in terms of the wayfinding and all of the alignments that you've done, Joel, all of these things. It seems like we're maintaining what we have. And back to your initial point of, you know, there's this proliferation of all these used trails or historic trails or in any case, non-system trails that we're not allowed to maintain. So how do we make that point in such a way that it's productive where we say, look, in order for us to...
1:14:00 To expand our maintenance program, we need to expand our right to maintain these trails, which means we need to bring them into the system. And if we need to pay for some NEPA analysis, you know, we can scrounge those funds, but we need, as Bill said, we need the commitment to, you know, from the agency that we're going to be able to do this before we spend that money. One quick point on that is I think that we had some discussion about
1:14:27 Coming out of the Solitude Canyon Project to prioritize Lakes Basin, Sherwins Meadow, and Shrick, that goes to Matt Parolo's point about going into the agency with like a laser focus from our side. It's this. And we don't, and you guys set those priorities. I'm not advocating, but again, you guys set what you want to do, but then we stick with it. And then I think what Bill Souser is a great example of this. It's about persistence.
1:14:54 You know, and it's about on the Forest Service side of things, it's going to be about persistence. We're not going anywhere. We're nice. We're friendly. We've got resources. We're not going anywhere. Things will get done.
1:15:06 Back on the town side, where we're not dealing with the Forest Service, that goes back to Joel's point about being more opportunistic and having like, you know, more expensive types of things in the queue, ready to done. If there's no NEPA necessary, we can get the CEQA done. So those are shovel-ready projects. They're not maybe as much fun as we like because they're not soft surface, but hell, they're teed up and they're ready to go. And we got...
1:15:28 You know, the state of California is flush right now. I mean, they have a lot, a lot, a lot, a lot of money. All those tech companies are based in California, and the state gets its revenue from stock valuations and things like that. There's an enormous amount of money out there. So if it's a town-only, CEQA-only type of project, we should get some of those things cured up because there's going to be some opportunities there.
1:15:56 And real quick, one of the ways we actually do that is through the LTC, the Local Transportation Commission, a lot of the hard stuff that qualifies for the state funding elements for on-street items through PSRs or public project study reports. I think there's two or three of those underway now where you look at a lot of these, some of the trail segments and connectors. We've looked at one like going from Maine basically down.
1:16:25 Minaret all the way to Old Mammoth Road. You look at the last piece of the south side of Main Street. The project study report does exactly what you're talking about. It goes in and takes a look at it, you know, bigger picture cost estimates, but gets it teed up, walks through the environmental checklist and do you have to do a full CEQA analysis or not, but it actually gets it ready so if there is funding available, or I should say wind funding available for a lot of these,
1:16:54 They're set up to be good competitive projects for funding. And again, the funding source to do that is restricted, limited to certain things within the transportation system versus soft surface things. But that's the same type of element of how do you get those project study reports done. Sometimes it's up to CEQA or NEPA. That isn't completed yet. Just dollar issues.
1:17:20 But they're teed up at that level, then how do you move it into that next piece versus starting from scratch going, hey, here's a great idea, now let's start from all we have is a concept plan versus any type of actual true project study report, for lack of a better term here. I know that that was, we use that really heavily for a lot of the mumps in town, everything from, you know, the main street sidewalks, if you will, to some of the connectors we're able to link into that as well.
1:17:49 A couple that are working now, most of that's going to go on-site roadway element, you know, either just off or on the edge. There's some limits in terms of how you can use those dollars, but that type of pre-work, it's not inexpensive, but it definitely pays dividends when you start to see the other dollars available for that. And then, for example, this year, we have been working through the LTC process, but part of that was a couple years ago.
1:18:18 Getting the town's MUP systems is part of our paid transportation network, for lack of a better term here, but it puts it into that. So this year, I think we're eligible. It's going to be close to the ballpark of $1.3 million plus or minus to go through and do a massive upgrade, you know, rehab of the paid MUPs within the town that fall into that category.
1:18:43 The LTC funding allowances. So being able to do that and have that study done, we've done some work on that. That's taken probably six or seven years to tee that up. So this is not a quick process. Obviously, LTC funds were juggling back and forth between priorities of the town and the county as we share in that resource and funding. John's been on that board for a while. Bill just stepped onto it.
1:19:09 That was a huge thing for us a couple years ago when we started looking at the dollars and we're looking at the mumps and we put some dollars out to go patch cracks and stuff and we're showing that falling apart. That question of back and how do we make that part of our paved system so we could actually take these types of dollars and roll into it. But that's a different, it's a different designation so there's some, you know, cautions that come with that when you do it. But to be able to go back in and say now here's a, you know, million, million, three to do that.
1:19:38 Reworking those mumps to get new pavement on them, get a lot of the cracked areas and stuff cleaned up and rejuvenated. And I think the technology we're going forward in terms of the paving level will probably also be easier to maintain going forward if we keep up on it, you know, getting the slurry seals or whatever the other elements into those mumps so they actually have a longer life schedule as well.
1:20:04 So work like that is ongoing throughout a lot of the different processes that are, again, all the different pots and pieces and places. That's a huge one coming up, for example. Hopefully a project, hopefully that project will get moved forward for, you know, this spring or fall. And just to ask this kind of stupid question, you guys all know what an LTC is? Local Transportation Commission. Dan, you're cheating. I'm just saying it. I'm sorry. Yeah, I did. Okay, I just want to make sure the members of the committee understand.
1:20:32 Exactly right. It's a local transportation commission. But the way this is set up, if President Biden, if they put through a big infrastructure bill, and we're talking billions and billions of dollars for roads and infrastructure, federal government goes to the state of California, and then the state of California, all those dollars get distributed through a local transportation commission. Every county's got them throughout the country, throughout the state. But as Dan mentioned, Bill and I are both on that commission now.
1:21:02 Comes in and out of that. But that's, there's big money there. And the state of California is redoing through Caltrans. What does it mean to be multimodal transportation? A lot of money coming through those kinds of things. And to also make clear, the trails plan, such that it is for the county, for Mono County, exists and lives in that LTC as well. There is no trails plan for Mono County, just so you know. And Bill, I'm not getting in trouble with saying that out loud.
1:21:30 I've never seen a document that is the Monroe County Trail System. I know it's in the program of work to the LTC, but all that stuff goes to that LTC. Another thing to keep your eyes on. Again, that's all part of a paved network of transportation. It's tougher to get dollars into the soft surface to the LTC and stuff like that. But just giving you one example of that where this process is multiple years going through. I think the Main Street sidewalks culminated about.
1:21:58 Eight to ten million dollars of investment over time, and we still got one, you know, pretty good section there to get completed up on the upper south side. But trying to get that, those study reports done, goes back to the comments made earlier on, it's prioritizing stuff, but it's also been getting those things prioritized that can be shovel ready, that can be, whether they're outside of the environmental process or they're exempt or they're
1:22:26 You know, pretty easy from a checklist standpoint. And so you do get opportunistic in terms of that priority too. So you're not going, well, our number one project is a million dollars worth of environmental work. So every nickel we have, we throw into there and then we do nothing for several years. But the other comment real quick I wanted to make, and some of that is that intersection between the paved and the urban elements into the
1:22:53 Soft surface into the forest, that whole idea of the community connection that runs through the community into the forest and rec areas. But I would be a little cautious on how much of this gets dropped into that through adherence, especially with the Measure R oversight, because I'll guarantee you if all of a sudden a bunch of the hard surface trails in town come to the top, legally to utilize it. You'd see a real big push for Measure R and you to go into building a lot more sidewalks and pavements in town.
1:23:23 Unless that's where we want to shove those dollars to, I would just be a little cautious of that because there tends to be more dollars available in different sources for that than there are for soft surface trails as we look at things outside the trail system. I know the trail system master plan, just the data of it, it looked heavily at the stuff in the urban growth boundary first, which a lot of that has been done, and then outside. But just be cautious in terms of, one, getting...
1:23:52 Too far spread, but also it's really easy to come in with, hey, here's a shovel ready sidewalk project, muck project, it's only 150 grand to finish this little connection. Can we, you know, take half of the trails budget, go build it? I just, there's a caution in that just in terms of effort and leveraging of dollars and the types that we do have. So, I think it's good to look at that connection because I get frustrated too from that issue of
1:24:22 We have an urban area that gets really built and focused, but the connection into the non-urban area and into that broader town boundary, even forget the planning area, is often, it seems that connection level seems to get dropped. It just is not as strong as I think it should be or could be in terms of the very reason, you know, vast number of people are here is because of that connection to the outdoors. It should be nice to get there a lot simpler, walking, biking, whatever, transit.
1:24:52 Et cetera, versus having to drive up and do stuff. So anyway. He just said it, walk, bike, ride. So I think if we start looking what's in the Trip Trail System Master Plan and what's in walk, bike, ride, find those overlaps, find those common things and say, look, let's start looking at some of these priorities. You know, maybe you guys can think about prioritizing some of those kinds of things. And some of the priority out of here may focus on the urban built stuff because of the linkage it has to the outdoors.
1:25:23 Don't have any stuff in front of that, but that's the items there, so thanks. Okay, so we're at 4.33, and just in the interest of time, I want to make sure everybody's got a chance to cover anything else that they had questions about or comments or concerns, and then I want to be sure that we've got five or six people.
1:25:50 In the audience, as it were, and I want to make sure there's some opportunity for them to ask the question if they so desire. Go ahead, Joel. Yeah, I just want to hit on what I think we all know is obvious, and it's like, so I want to try toward the future to get to the point where, you know, the word single track isn't a bad word to a subculture in the Eastern Sierra.
1:26:15 You know, so the areas where I was pointing out whether there's seven, 800 miles or 400 miles of trails, we have in a lot of those communities, nonprofits that are advocating for more trails all the time without resistance from another entity that wants to fight those projects. And, you know, that's a difference that I see. Like if you go up to Lake Tahoe, you've got Tampa, the Tahoe Rim Trail Association, all working together.
1:26:43 Advocating for trails, so Tahoe National Forest has a level of comfort that they can be very ambitious. And that soft surface trails aren't looked at as a scourge on the environment. They're looked at as a part of a sustainable economy. Like we discussed earlier in the presentation that I was giving, for our community to consider soft surface trails.
1:27:10 A sustainable way for us to move forward economically or a piece of it, right? It's just a small piece of it. But to not have the word single track or new single track looked at as a negative thing, that would be a pivot. That would be the difference that it takes. I mean, that would do it. It would be a cultural shift that I think is required for us to gain the momentum that's required to shoot for 100 miles a new single track.
1:27:37 Well, I would say, Joel, and we've talked about this a lot, but I think we can do and need to do a better job at showing why trails are a mitigation strategy environmentally, because I think a lot of the analogs that you cite, Tahoe, Moab, Boise, those are much bigger population-based areas. There's much more human impact on the landscape than we have, and so I can see where, you know, we don't want to be those places.
1:28:06 So if, you know, if the development of single track has led to, you know, huge population booms and more impacts in those areas, we need to show why that won't happen here. What about Crested Butte with over 700 miles? That's a smaller town than us. No, so I'm just saying, let's focus in on those examples where, you know, creating sustainable trails has been good for the environment and good for wildlife.
1:28:34 So Crested Butte, Durango, those kind of smaller towns where there's hundreds and hundreds of miles. Easy to make a map of those. I'll just pull out populations over 8,000 and we'll end up with places like, you know, Truckee, Tahoe City, Susanville, you know, Downeyville, Quincy. Quincy is much smaller, Crested Butte, you know, there's all kinds of examples we can cite.
1:29:02 That have way more than 17 miles of multi-use non-moto single track, and in many cases, lots and lots of moto-friendly single track. So one thing that I don't know, Joel, if you or Matt have looked at, back in, what year was it? A long time ago, I sat on a action team for the Forest Service made up of environmental and all sorts of user groups.
1:29:30 For the travel management plan on the Indian National Forest. To my dismay, but to other people's likings, they closed about 1,000 miles of road, which has, of course, created more traffic on the roads that were left. But that's beside the point. One of the things they said in the process was that once that was over, they would be willing to come back and look at those for potential trails, motorized, not motorized, single traffic. And that's been a long time ago, and I don't know.
1:29:58 Other than I know, Connelly, your group, what do we call ourselves? It doesn't matter. My mind is gone. I don't know that we've gone back and looked at those maps, to look at those 1,000 miles of now closed roads to see if we could turn some of them into single track or motorized and non-motorized or even hiking trails or whatever it is. But I think it's an area the Forest Service has said in the past they might be willing to be.
1:30:28 In the past, they said they would be willing to go there. But is there an opportunity for us then? It may not be the path we would like to do first, but if there's an opportunity to get anything done, we ought to take that overlay and put it over our trail planning process for motorized and non-motorized alike and see if maybe we can hit some opportunities that they would be willing to allow because already disturbed land, so you know that it takes a lesser degree of NEPA process.
1:30:58 To go through it. Just something to throw out there. Yeah, Bill, just on that point, Marty Harnick, before he left, there were a number of those trails out in Shady, in the Shady Rest area, that he shared that data with. MLTPA's got that data, and that's something that we should, Joel, we should follow up on that, get that rolling into the shrink thing, because we've got all that stuff. Yeah, there's on both sides of 395, from here to Levining, there are literally hundreds of miles.
1:31:27 David, I picked right up on what you stated and I've heard it from both Forest Service staff and just friends of mine where
1:31:53 They're not so concerned about new trails as more humans coming to the Eastern Sierra. That if our trails are too fun, that we will somehow see more visitation and that that is a negative. And I just, I just, I think I fundamentally just disagree. So a good ally there would be Mr. Erty, who can show that by the growth of California's population and what percentage.
1:32:22 Recreate Outdoors, that we are going to have scores of additional recreationists and it behooves us to create more trails and plan for them or we will see environmental degradation. Yeah. No, I'm not, I'm just trying to focus less on, you know, you keep bringing up the economic benefit of trails and I see that and I get that, but I want to also focus on how
1:32:50 Good sustainably built trails are a good solution for managing people and for managing impacts to the landscape. And I couldn't agree more. If Joel and his crew were allowed to maintain the trails along Mammoth Creek, the creek bed wouldn't be getting degraded, the vegetation wouldn't be getting killed, and we would have a spectacular legal trail system going all the way from...
1:33:20 Mammoth Creek Park East to 395 of that. All the way to Crowley. So, case in point, in Bishop, I think there's north of 200 miles of illegally constructed trails now in the Chipmunk Canyon area. I don't know what to say. I mean, it didn't cost any money for environmental analysis. Nobody paid any attention to what could be sensitive resources there. If you went over a grave site, you didn't know about it.
1:33:49 And nobody is saying shut those trails down. There's like 200 miles. So this tells me loud and clear, they don't really have a problem with the trails. If we put those trails on a map in Bishop and put signs up, then they might have a problem with it is what I am starting to realize. Okay, so now we're at 442. We've got a hard stop in about 10 minutes because we've got to transition over to the Mammoth Trails meeting. Kim?
1:34:21 You want to say something? I was just going to say we've got a hard stop in about three minutes. Three minutes. So, okay, three minutes. Elise, Finley, John, any last thoughts, anything you want to put out? And then I'd like to open it up just in case anybody in the audience has anything they want to say. I would like to put an agenda or request an agenda item for our next meeting where we have an opportunity to talk about our thoughts regarding
1:34:53 The plan and what we kind of took from it and where we would like to go and maybe just have a little more time as individual committee members to discuss this because I didn't hear anything from you regarding this. I'd love to just have another conversation regarding it. Agreed. That sounds great. I would just say that, you know, you know, we're a resort community and all our livelihoods are based around that, whether it's skiing or hiking in the summer.
1:35:24 We're mountain biking and, you know, denying that people come and visit here is just absolutely pointless and very short-sighted. We've got to try and improve the facilities for our guests and ourselves because I'm selfish too. We've got to try and improve the facilities so that it is something that people want to come and experience because that will keep everyone being successful in this community. That's what it's about. Thanks for me. John? Yeah.
1:36:00 Said what I wanted to. I just want to focus on the miles. That's about it. Great. Yeah, I totally agree, Elise. Let's definitely revisit this and have some more time for some internal discussion and hopefully have that lead into a prioritization exercise of some kind. And then I have one more quick question. I know Christy Williams has been working with sustainable recreation and got some good feedback.
1:36:30 And she came to talk to us a while back at one of our meetings. I'm wondering if we might be able to get her back just to get some feedback from what she learned from that whole process and maybe consider what she heard since she had so many voices while we're considering where we want to go with our trails. Yep, great point. Angie or Kim, do you see, does anybody who's...
1:37:01 So Christy's in attendance as well. Does anybody from the public have anything they want to say or questions or comments before we wrap up here? Yeah, I don't have anybody in Suite Z and I have no hands currently raised from our Zoom attendees. I just wanted to give a moment in case people were fumbling with their keyboards, but it seems like there is. There we go. We've got one. Let's see. Alex Ertod, you can go ahead and unmute yourself and give a comment. Hi, hello.
1:37:38 Yes, Alex R. Todd, Stewardship Director, friends at Inyo. Wanted to see if there was a timeline, I know it had been mentioned a couple years ago at some meetings, for some strict planning, and when, if there was a timetable for when that would be going ahead. I can speak to that, unless somebody else wants to. Go ahead, Joel. Sure. Several years ago, we started planning for that sub-region. More recently,
1:38:10 We got a grant for $155,000 from the state OHV program to do a three-year planning effort. We are in the first year, Matt Perullo, we're like three quarters through the first year, I think, of that three-year process, and that will include NEPA and CEQA in that three-year process. Is that correct? Yeah, Joel, that's correct. We're basically going into year two of a three-year planning grant.
1:38:43 Everything at this point is highly conceptual level. NEPA and CEQA is, NEPA document is the primary deliverable of that grant at the end of three years. So it is very much a planning grant, not implementation to plan, design some of that, some of that ESA 395 lands that you were talking about, Bill, and come to a decision with the forest. Thank you very much.
1:39:17 Okay, thanks, Alex. Anyone else? Okay, it looks like that's it. Thank you all for participating. I think that was a helpful first round of discussion, and I look forward to carrying it through into our next meeting. Thanks for all your time and insights. And for agenda items on our next meeting, please send those over to Kim. We'll make sure that happens.
1:39:47 Are we using this same address or do I have another one in my inbox somewhere? I think you have another one in your inbox. Correct. So you'll sign off and then sign back on at 5. Thank you all. Thanks everybody for seeing in a few minutes. Meeting adjourned. All right.