Town Council
· recording 5 hr 3 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
634 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
1:43 Yeah. Okay. There's a couple of pulses out there. Thank you. Good afternoon. Wow. Come on. You talked and then you went away and then you came back. Pulse. And I have a pulse. So that means that I can participate in a public meeting. So I'm all good to go. Yeah. Well, hopefully you're starting out low. Coming in a little hot, Bill, but I will do my best to
2:25 Mitigate the effects of my pulse. Let's see, where are we? We got me, John, and Linda. Well, I had Linda. What happened to her? There she is. There's Kirk. Okay. I can turn on my camera now and you'll have to look at me. Okay. I will call to order this meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council on Wednesday, February 17th. Roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? Here.
3:38 Councilmember Stapp. Mayor. Councilmember Wentworth. Present. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido. Mayor Salzer. Present. Thank you. Pledge of Allegiance. Who am I going to pick on today? Cardinal Shapiro, how about leading us in the pledge today? I'll try. I haven't done it since high school, but I think I got it. Okay. Tell me when you guys are ready. Good. I pledge allegiance to the flag.
4:18 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. You're not the first one to mess it up under pressure.
4:57 Out of everything I was expecting, that was not on there. Yeah. Yeah, I sort of pulled that on you. So we have an announcement. The town council met in closed session to look at existing litigation. We are being sued. And there was no action taken. There are no reportable action taken. Hopefully I got that right. Moving on to public comments.
5:27 This is a time for any member of the public wishing to comment on something that otherwise is not on the agenda. Do we have any public comments, Jamie? Yes, Tom Hodges. Please unmute yourself and give your comments. Hello, can you hear me? Got you, Tom. Go ahead. Hi, Councilmembers. Thanks for taking my call. I'm just making a brief announcement on behalf of Mammoth Lakes Housing. We are actively recruiting for an open board seat.
6:04 On our board of directors, we have a full board is nine members. We currently have eight. So we have one open board position and it is a unrestricted board position. So anyone can apply to become a member of the board of directors of Mammoth Lakes Housing. The only exceptions are we can't accept applicants that are either an elected official position or a
6:33 Employee of a governmental agency, because we already have seats fulfilled with those people. But otherwise, anybody in the community is welcome to apply. You can find details on the mammothlakeshousing.org website. There's a link to the second page that has more details and an application form to submit.
6:59 We're accepting applications until March 15th, and then our recruiting committee will conduct some interviews, and we're hoping to appoint somebody in time for our April board meeting at the beginning of April. So we'd love to have as many people apply as possible, and really would love to get some members of the business community to apply if they're interested. I see Ken's on the call here, and maybe he can pass that on to his chamber members as well.
7:29 So, yeah, that's all we got, and I look forward to receiving some applications from some people who want to participate in our community. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Any further public comments, Jamie? No. Thank you. Dan, do we have any emergency additions for the agenda? We do not. Thank you. Reports from commissions and or departments. Do I have any hands going up? I got one, Bill. Yep.
8:05 Well, Mr. Mayor, we presented the 2020 Town Accomplishments document prior to having it fully complete. So I just wanted to announce that the final document in all its glory, in colour and formatted, is available on the home page of the Town of Mammoth Lakes website. So I'd like to direct council, our community, members here this evening to visit the home page right there on the newsflash section.
8:33 Be patient for opening the document. It is a big document because we accomplished a lot in 2020. Even though we're in the middle of a pandemic, there was a lot going on in the town. Department heads, our volunteers and staff and our council accomplished a great deal for our community. So I just wanted to make council and the community aware of that information. And then just on the parks and recreation front, just again a reminder.
9:00 Because we're not going to meet here until March. The last day for the Mammoth Ice Rink is Sunday, February 28th. So if you want to get your skates on and get some ice time, we encourage you to get it there and hit it in the evening. Ice conditions are far better at that time. That is all I had there. Thank you. Stu, people laugh at me enough already without putting on skates. No comment there, Bill. Thank you.
9:28 Any other department wishing to make any comments? Hayes, go. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. As you're probably aware, the state has mandated a change to alternative fuel vehicles for our transit fleet starting, I believe, 2025, phasing out in 2035. And yesterday, you may have noticed a giant blue electric bus cruising around town. We were fortunate to be part of a demo from Proterra to take a look at their 40-foot, 77-passenger electric bus.
9:57 I got to thank Phil Morris over at Nesta for putting that together. It was an eye-opening experience. Myself, the entirety of our fleet staff, our engineering staff had the opportunity to meet with their representatives and ask a lot of questions. And I got to tell you, the technology curve has gone parabolic. Everything we thought would be an issue with operating an electric vehicle in this town, they have solutions and they have these buses working in regions just like ours.
10:24 And it was really encouraging to have these conversations. These buses use a lot of off-the-shelf parts for consumables, and a lot of the technical packages are just that. They're just packages. You pull them out and replace them, and they have opportunities for leases and warranties to take care of these things. So if you recall, Town Council approved a letter of support to ESTA for a grant application to start planning for the electrification or alternative fuel
10:53 Thank you. Thank you, Hayes. Any other departments? Seeing none, I will move on to public presentation.
11:27 So required under their agreement with the town as reports from the chamber. So we're going to do the works program update from Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. Ken, I'm going to turn that over to you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, council members, town staff. Great to be here. It's hard to believe that 11 months ago we started this pandemic and I think a number of us.
11:59 Sitting on this meeting, we're thinking, ah, a couple weeks, we'll be back to normal. And it's been quite a ride. With me is Brianna Goico, who is our Membership and Marketing Manager, and Curtis Shapiro, who is our Workforce Housing Coordinator. And I'll start off with a few remarks and then turn it over to Brianna and Curtis so they can...
12:27 Talk a little specifically about their programs. You did receive a report from us about concerning using the deliverables that were set up by the town and the chamber when we entered into our first, excuse me, our first agreement back, I think, in July of 2019, in fact. You know,
12:58 One of the first things when the pandemic kind of stepped forward was our board of directors, and I know Rich Sampalipos on the listening is our president this year with Perfect Clean, and I'm sure if any questions come up, he'd be happy to jump in and answer. But one of the things, the commitments we made from the board of directors to the membership,
13:25 Was that we would commit to become the information clearinghouse for the business community. And I think specifically in the fight, you know, trying to make sure our members knew what financial aid packages were available. That's changed a lot over the last year. But I think all of you are on our newsletter email list. And you see that our email has gotten our...
13:53 Newsletters got longer, not shorter. That's for sure. And we try to keep that commitment as the information clearinghouse. We try to keep that going through our newsletter. You know, one of the things that we have tried to continue to do is our training seminars for customer service. Some of the training that we've been doing through the...
14:20 Some of the training that we've been doing through the power lunches and so forth, all of that's included in the reports that we sent to you. We started the industry zooms, restaurants, retail, lodging, and all of those have continued and continued to be fairly strong. We saw good attendance at all those that helped us set up the creation of the Mammoth Lakes Restaurant Association.
14:49 In cooperation with MLT on that and the kind of formalization of the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association, we ended up developing logos for both of those. We reactivated the Mammoth Community Foundation. We raised over $238,000 for our food bank through MLT and we're still raising funds for the AMACA organization.
15:19 And then we raised over $148,000 for the Mountain View Fire Relief Fund, trying to help our neighbors up north in Walker. We have to continue, I mean, one of the goals that Ian set for us was being, was advocacy, representing the business community to you, the town council and county and so forth. I think we've become very effective in that.
15:45 We have the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association, Mammoth Lakes Restaurant Association. Both of those have been very positively received, and it's been good to see those industries working together with us. The other thing that we've really gotten involved with, and we really thank the town and the county for providing the PPE, we have been making sure that our business community has received.
16:14 We have continued to work closely with the MLT on a number of issues.
16:46 Mostly we're working with Molly Porter who has helped us with the Mammoth Lakes Restaurant Association putting together some of those local activities. We have, you know, continued to try to see what marketing they're doing and so forth. It's been an interesting year but I think that we have accomplished a lot. I think we have fulfilled a lot of the deliverables of the town.
17:19 And ask us to work on. With that, I'd like to talk, because one of the things that I do want to say is thanks to the town continuing their monetary support of us is that we've been able to offer free membership for this last year, and we've had quite an increase in membership. With that, I'd like to turn it over to Brianna to let her talk a little bit about membership marketing and some of the programs that she's working on.
17:48 Sure. Thanks, Ken. Thank you, Council, for having us on today. I'm Brianna Goico, and I'm the Membership and Marketing Manager for the Chamber. I came on at the end of June, so all of my training and onboarding was completely virtual, which actually worked out pretty well. So it's been an interesting time to join a new organization and do a lot on Zoom.
18:12 So I've seen a lot of you guys. For our membership that Kim was just speaking about, since COVID has started, we have added about 70 new members. We also went through our system and reactivated some of our lapsed members. That was about 125. So we're up to 375 members total. So we're up quite a bit from...
18:36 Pre-pandemic. And again, echoing Ken, thank you so much for your support for our members and just kind of taking that added stress of a membership dues off their plate. Many of our new members have connected with us due to the roundtables that we've hosted the last.
18:54 Pretty much here, I guess, almost at this point. And a lot of them have come to us looking for financial assistance information as well as, you know, looking for that personal protective equipment. So thank you for your support in that as well. In regards to our marketing, we've been pretty active on Facebook and I've also tried to up our Instagram presence as well. I went through in September and revamped our newsletter. Like Ken said, there is a lot of information in there. So just trying to make it more.
19:24 So that was redesigned and now all of our past issues of the newsletter are available on our website as well for not even our members, for any community member to access. All of our events since I started have been virtual. So I've gotten...
19:46 Pretty good at Zoom for the most part. And we do record most of our meetings, which has been really great for people that aren't able to make them. Usually almost every meeting I get somebody asking for those recordings. So it's been great to provide those to our members. In some areas, attendance is better on Zoom. So it'll be really interesting to see how we navigate back to in-person once that is allowed.
20:12 One event we do have coming up, which I just, we have a lot, but one I just kind of want to highlight is we are putting together a Pandemic Champions Awards Gala at the end of April. So we just want to honor and celebrate all the successes. Just really recognize people that went above and beyond during the pandemic.
20:31 So stay tuned for more information on that. Two big projects that I've really been focusing on since I started is Women in Business and Latinx Outreach. So our Women in Business program kind of
20:43 You know, once COVID was sort of starting, we were focusing on some other areas. So women in business meetings kind of stopped for a few months there. We've been meeting regularly since August. Our topics have included resiliency, health and fitness, diversity and inclusion. Recently, we did one on social media. And we do have a private women in business Facebook group that we use to do a lot of that marketing. However, we do also promote through the chambers channels.
21:11 Attending Women in Business, you do not have to be a member of the chamber to attend Women in Business, but I think it's a great way for women to just get exposure to the chamber and what we do.
21:21 In regards to Latinx Outreach, I connected with Cassandra Montez, who's the Ethnic Service Coordinator for Mono County Behavioral Health, when she spoke at our diversity and inclusion sessions. We actually ended up having two, because there was just so much to talk about there. And through connecting with her, she invited me to join the Latinx Outreach Committee, which is run through the county. And by attending that, I'm just trying to learn the best ways to connect and engage with our Spanish-speaking community.
21:51 It's something that our own board has expressed wanting to explore a little bit more. So I'm still figuring out and connecting with that committee and just learning the best ways to engage with the Latinx community in the most appropriate and the most effective manner. So overall, our business community is very engaged right now. There is a lot of work to be done moving forward. And with that, I will let Curtis speak on.
22:20 Workforce Housing. Rihanna, good afternoon, Council Mayor. I'm Chris Shapiro, Workforce Housing Coordinator for the Chamber of Commerce here. Hopefully this goes better than the Pledge of Allegiance. Let me see if I can share my screen here real quick. Can you guys see that okay? Okay. So, yeah, I just wanted to read through the numbers with you guys for the program polls. So the first year, our workforce housing website launched on October 1st in 2019.
22:56 Up until May 2020, we had 249 prospective renters sign up, and we were able to successfully match five homeowners to those renters, so we had five successful matches there. The second year, June 2020 through current, we've had 385 prospective renters sign up. We've been able to successfully match 51 homeowners to those tenants. The second year, we also started providing
23:25 People, homeowners who come through our program with background checks and credit checks on all of the renters to help to give them some kind of backbone of renting to these people. We've completed 140 of those background and credit checks. So the total numbers for the program since its start in June 2019, we've had 634 renters sign up, 56 successful matches, and again, 140 background and credit checks completed. Due to COVID-19, when it first
23:55 Happened in March. We set up a temporary housing page, which we were attempting to get people who had Airbnbs who couldn't rent nightly to switch over to house local workforce employees. Out of that, we had two that resulted in successful matches for three-month minimum leases. And throughout the whole COVID-19, we've been working with lodging establishments and other short-term rentals to house local workforce employees.
24:21 Of course, working with short-term renters throughout the entire program. Over the summer, we were able to send out approximately 4,800 mailers to second homeowners. We received responses back from approximately 36 of them, roughly six of which resulted in successful homeowner, landlord to tenant matches. It's hard to say exactly because a few of them had heard about the program before and received the mailer, you know, or somebody had told somebody who they think would benefit from it.
24:50 On that mailer, we also had a link to an online survey on the back of the mailer, which we reported 49 responses from people to better gauge what would make the homeowners in Mammoth more inclined to rent out their homes on a long-term basis to the local workforce employees. And these are some of the answers they got. 55% said if the tenants were pre-qualified, so background credit checks. 53% said monthly, weekly, quarterly property inspections.
25:19 46% said if we have an employer master lease, which we were able to come up with and implement, which has touched on in the deliverables. 42% said ability to make more money renting long-term than nightly. 42% said other and entered in a text box that's specified to us. 43% said reduced property management fees. 24% free icon pass. And 20% said none of these interests me.
25:45 And we were also able to put out our workforce housing advocacy video, which we've received great response back on that. I'm not sure if you guys had the chance to watch it yet. I really hope you have. If not, I really hope that you do because it's just great video. And that's about it on the numbers and the program updates so far. I'll turn it back to you, Ken. Thanks, Curtis. At this point in time, you know, we would like to open up.
26:19 If there are any questions the council or staff may have of us, I think Sandra and Dan and Rob and Stu will tell you we haven't been shy in talking with you guys. So we've tried to make sure we've kept a good open communication with the town, county, with our governmental entities.
26:48 With that, I would ask if there's any questions or comments or concerns, anything that we could address for you. So let's go to questions and comments. John, starting with you. Mr. Mayor, Kent, as you know, crises, pandemics are nothing but very big stress tests. And it's really great to see this community coming through this with...
27:14 So much great new information and so many colors flying. So I just want to thank you and your team for all the great work you've been doing on a weekly basis throughout this entire challenge. We're not out of it yet, but the chamber, your members have certainly done an excellent job bringing focused communication to the council, to EOC, and decision makers, and we really thank you for all that work.
27:35 I also want to make sure I thank Brianna. The work you do with the Latinx is really important, and it's great to hear that you're in touch with Ms. Mendez, that we're looking for the next generation of business owners in this community, and you're doing that outreach. It's really important. I would love to follow up with you on that at some point as we move forward. And, Curtis, I know Lynda and I have been coming to your housing meetings. I don't think you may not have been there a little while. You may not have had a meeting a little while. There's a lot of great data that's coming out of the work you're doing, and I think we need to start.
28:03 Getting that data to inform policy from the town, especially with the gorgeous short-term rentals, long-term rental units. I'm sure you've noticed in the state of California, it puts a very nice, you know, restrictions of policy in place having to do with landlords and tenants and raising rents and all the rest of it, which doesn't apply to people who are renting condominiums. And we start talking about in this town where most of the existing housing stock is condominiums.
28:31 This is information and data I'd really like to start talking with you about and bringing that back into the towns. We started looking at policy to do updates on our program and really looking at the costs of having a program like that and the benefits of itself. Ken, thank you. Brianna, Chris, your team. You guys are doing a great job. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you, John. Linda. Thank you, Mayor Salzer. Yes, to the chamber, I would say it was nice to see you so present.
29:01 Thank you.
29:32 So I think you found a good balance between advocating strongly for businesses and yet supporting the decisions of people around public health guidelines. So thank you for that in addition to the other things that have already been mentioned. I appreciated that very much. And Curtis.
30:02 You know, good job on getting some people actually into homes. I know it's been hard, and I've worked super hard on that, and I think, you know, it may not be the number you would like to see, but it's more than we had before, and I certainly take note of that, and I believe that we'll continue to do better on that. And, Grada, good to see you at the table, too. Great addition to our community. So, thanks. Good work, everybody. Thank you. Thank you. Let me unmute here.
30:34 Can you hear me? You're good. Curtis, I think what you're doing is incredibly important, trying to coordinate, you and Ken both, trying to coordinate and find out actually the real need within the community. I do have one question. I mean, how are you working with the mountain? So, I mean, you know, they don't really get special treatment per se, but I am in touch with Lori Carlson.
31:04 So, for the most part, we
31:35 It's a lot of people who are on the wait list for employee housing for the mountain who come through us, or people, we've had people who are in employee housing who want to get out who come through us, but we have not been able to house anybody in employee housing, if that is a clear answer. One last question. Have you reviewed the wait list at Mammoth Lake Housing to see if there's any overlap? I have not, no. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. Sarah?
32:09 Yeah, thank you so much. That was so great to hear. And hiring Brianna, I think, was an excellent decision of the chamber. She's a consummate professional, and we've been to a lot of the lodging association and restaurant association meetings, and they're just, she's a Zoom queen. So thanks, Brianna, for all your hard work, and really great to hear you're reaching out to the Latinx population. So thank you. Curtis, I have a question about the...
32:36 Homeowner-Renter match. I noticed it's such a huge jump. Do you think that the pandemic has anything to do with that jump? And do you foresee that going back down? Or what are your thoughts on that? Yeah, I think the pandemic definitely...
32:54 It has helped us out in some regard. A lot of the homeowners I've spoken to are very cautious to put anybody in their house right now because if they try to evict them, they may not be able to for a year. That's the last I read. So we face problems with that, but it definitely has opened up doors for people who were short-term renting and get somebody long-term in there so they didn't risk losing their income over all of the winter. And a part of the big jump, too, is when the website launched last October,
33:24 It's kind of a hard time for, you know, a housing program to begin up here because a lot of the people who are moving into places are usually wrapping up in October, November, and leases are kind of set, you know, December through March-ish. So it's kind of a dead time to start the program. With that being said, you know, we didn't send out the mailers or really start marketing it until what turned out to be early summer.
33:50 We planned it to be late winter, but with COVID and everything, we decided to hold off on it for a little bit. So I think that's a big part of the influx as well. Moving forward, I think it, I kind of expected to be somewhat constant because a lot of the feedback I was getting wasn't necessarily that the rent or the homeowners in our program were renting out strictly because they couldn't rent out nightly. A lot of them just didn't even know housing was an issue here.
34:18 And, you know, they're pretty blown away by the program and what we're willing to do for them to provide the background checks and credit checks. So the response is pretty good on it. So I don't, you know, really expect it to just drop down to zero or anything like that once the pandemic's over with. Okay, great. Thank you. Oh, and I watched the video. It was wonderful. Well done. Yeah, thanks. And I couldn't have done it without everybody at the chamber either, you know, calling out Point Productions. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you, Sarah. And for me, I think most everything has been said.
34:49 By my colleagues, I'll just say keep up the good work. These have been tough times and I think we're all doing our best to get through them. So I look forward to seeing just how well we come out the other end. So thank you. Any staff would ask anything of the chamber representatives? None of them are jumping up or unmuting. So Ken, unless you have something else to say, we'll move on. That's great. Thank you.
35:24 Let's go to John, and then I'll go to public comment. No, I was just waving goodbye. I think there's a public comment, so let's hear that. Yeah. Jamie, public comment? Richard, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Good afternoon, everyone. Rich Sanfilippo, president, lucky president of the Chamber of Commerce right now. I just wanted you all to know that the board is listening, and we are...
35:54 Forever proud of our executive team, Ken, Brianna, and Curtis. These have been the most trying times for all of us. We could sit and think about it and chat about it forever, but it won't take any of your time. But in these challenging times, I think our chamber's executive team, as well as my fellow board members, have really risen to the occasion, and we continue to be what our mission is.
36:23 advocates for the business community, and I think we're doing a great job. So all of you on the Town Council, certainly Dan, thank you. Thank you for all of your support of the Chamber Board and the Chamber Executive Team. We wouldn't be here without you guys, and the partnership continues to be one that is providing some really great things for our community, both business.
36:51 And just the community at large. So thank you, everybody. I appreciate it a lot. Thank you, Rich. Any further public comments, Jamie? No. Okay, thank you all. With that, I will move on to item number two, update on Mammoth Disposal, implementation of new franchise agreement, winter services, planning for new transfer station in related manners. Dan? Yes, Mr. Mayor. Thank you.
37:31 Yeah, this is a quarterly report, a quarterly update that we're bringing forward to the council. Pam Kobylarz, she's on the call. She's been helping coordinate these efforts as well as a monthly call with Mammoth Disposal. A number of different elements moving forward since this last year when we approved a new franchise agreement. They'll be walking through a number of those elements this evening, both.
37:54 Glenn Long from the Waste Connections. He's the general manager for Mammoth Disposal, I believe Bishop Disposal as well, the work there. So he'll introduce his team that's with him and give a brief introduction here. And then we'll walk through the information that they have, a lot of the focus on the new transfer station as it proceeds forward, and then some of the recycling efforts and other activities being undertaken by Mammoth Disposal. So, Glenn. Thank you, Dan. Mayor Souser.
38:23 Councilmembers, thanks for giving us a little bit of time today. I know we talked about this a few months ago about doing this a little more regularly, and so here we are with the first update. We're going to cover a couple topics. The first, the transfer station project itself, and Dave Brown, our engineer from Lawrence & Associates, is going to talk a little bit about timelines, key checkpoints, key features of the transfer station project, and then try and answer any questions you've got for them.
38:50 I'm also going to introduce Kendra Knight. It's our new sustainability coordinator and some of the things that she's been up to. And then I'll finish up with a little operations update on some of the other activities we've been involved with. So with that, Dave, are you out there? Yeah, Dave, do you want me to share the screen or do you want to put the screen up? Let me share screen real quick. And this will work. There we go. Okay, so you should be seeing a big colorful zoning map for...
39:31 So, yeah, thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, Council Members, for listening to us today. So, this is pretty exciting. So, for those that don't know, you know, Benton Crossing landfill is going to be done receiving waste basically at the end of 2022. So, a big part of that is having somewhere for all the solid waste to go. Right now, the transfer station that Mammoth Disposal operates is over here in the Business Park area. And we have a couple slides that were in the packet that was, you know, in your packet this evening.
40:01 So what's out there right now is they have two basically operations going on out of the transfer station right now as you come in off of commerce. They have a basically a public drop-off in the bins as part of the transfer station and they also have a recycling and buyback center. This location also houses the basically the office for the Mammoth Lakes area and then they just have bin storage. So one of the basically to accommodate a new transfer station a couple things are going to happen. I'll talk about this.
40:31 Recycled Buyback Center here in just a second. But the new site plan, and this is basically the same scale. You're still seeing the recycled buyback center building. It's kind of hard to see the office in the background, but what's happening, some of the key features going in is a new building facility. So this will be a new metal building, transfer building. For those unfamiliar with transfer stations, it's basically a big shell of a building where the public can unload, basically down here on the south side.
41:01 They unload onto what we call a tipping floor, which is a big concrete floor that gets pushed up into a pile and then loaded with either a, you know, a material handler or a loader into big hull trucks and then take out to an appropriate landfill. The way this design is set up is the transfer building and the office will actually be part of the same building. It's just that you'll have the big open space in the transfer building and then have the actual finished interior for the office building. I can zoom in. Sorry, these are, I tend to forget that I'm on a big screen.
41:31 The other part of this project is really trying to make it a little easier for folks to drop off or to check in and get weight as they come in. So it's also planned to basically put in a new scale canopy. So this is a covered canopy where folks can drive in, check with the attendant under the canopy and then go do their drop off or if it's a weight truck, they can actually go over the scales and get weight. Today, you can't weigh out there. Everything's just by load.
42:00 So this is going to be a pretty big improvement out there for the site. I'm pretty excited about it. I'm going to show some elevations here in a second. One of the areas I'm going to show is the southern part of the building where the public is going to drop off. We do have it where the design actually includes an awning to protect the public from snow and other things above their head when they're actually dropping off. And then the other part of this project is I talked about the recycle and buyback center.
42:26 So Mammoth Disposal has two facilities out in the business park. They have the transfer station and buyback center, and then they also have a fleet, basically their truck fleet maintenance center and where they park their haul trucks, route trucks. To make things work more efficiently and to kind of, you know, help reduce queuing for folks, we're actually, you know, splitting off that recycling and buyback center, moving that up the street to where that fleet maintenance site is and bringing the fleet maintenance center down to this building.
42:55 It'll actually, you know, allow us to, you know, get customers in a little bit easier, keep everyone off of commerce from backing up onto there, and, you know, let folks that are only recycling go to just the recycling center. So this is, this is basically an elevation of what the building's going to look like. You know, the area I was talking about where the public drops off is this lower right area, so this is looking at it from the south. You would see, you know, two big public doors where folks can basically back their trailers or vehicles up to. There's going to be an awning up over the top of it.
43:28 The big door immediately to the left of it. This is for route trucks that are coming through that may need to either lift up or just, you know, pull through and dump onto that tipping floor. And then this far left door is only for, you know, the big commercial hull trucks that are being loaded and taken out. So I talked about the recycle center being moved. So this gives an idea. So if you're familiar with the area, you come down Meridian, turn on to Commerce, and the transfer station's right here on the south side. The fleet maintenance center is just up the road at 264 Commerce.
43:59 One of the items in trying to permit this and get this built before Benton Crossing is ceases accepting waste is we have a couple of use permits to get through that we're working on with the town and we also have a design variance for the new transfer station. And right now it made sense because these are basically tied together by use and operation to go ahead and process both those under the same CEQA document and process both use permits at the same time. So we're at that.
44:27 Take this. It's really kind of where we are right now, just thinking big picture on schedule. I'll zoom in a little bit so you guys can see this. So there's three big parts. To meet the objective of being constructed before basically summer of 2022, we have to be mindful of the construction season up there in Mammoth Lakes. We have a very short window to get site work and frames and foundations done, and then we can work on interiors during the winter. So some of this gets
44:55 You know, basically, you know, backscheduled into what, you know, how to basically construct it in time and then also how to then permit, make sure everything's done ahead of time. So we end up with three processes that are happening at the same time right now. We're basically doing the use permits. We're doing the building permits that are submitted either today or sometime this week. And we're also fitting the project. So we have all three of these things really happening all at once. A couple of the key dates coming up that you guys will probably hear about is the...
45:24 Public review period for the CEQA side is expected to basically be somewhere here in April to May. We're planning on doing some public outreach before that, so probably late March, you'll hear about Glenn and his team basically trying to coordinate a virtual meeting so we can let folks know about this. All the while anticipating that this will be coming up in front of public hearings somewhere early summer, late June, early July. And that's a nutshell on the transfer station.
45:54 Happy to answer any questions on that. Council, any questions? John? Not specifically. I'm interested in really understanding how the public interaction is going to work with dumping things off. Right now, I know it's a little kind of loosey-goosey, but you can kind of spread people, spread cars around. You might have a little bit of a traffic management challenge down there.
46:26 But I'll be looking forward to hearing some of the thoughts on that. But other than that, nothing specifically at this moment, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. Linda? Thank you. Dave, will there be any change as far as the materials that are being accepted from what they're presently are being done? Or is it too early to envision that right now?
46:53 That's a great question. So most of it's basically just getting split. So where items, you know, on this, you know, things related to the recycle and buyback will go up the street to the recycle buyback center, you know, cardboard, glass, the household hazardous waste will be up at that location. At this location, they'll still accept green waste, you know, your construction debris, we call it C&D, tires, mattresses, bulky items, things of that nature. So what...
47:17 Currently gets dropped off at the transportation. There's still a home to drop it off either at this site or the one up the street. Yeah. Okay. All right. That makes sense. Thank you. Appreciate that. Sarah. I don't think I have any questions. Thank you so much. Thank you. Kirk? Kirk, we're not hearing you. I don't have any questions. I think that the plan looks good. And I think we just need to keep moving forward on this. Thank you.
47:58 So my questions would be not about the building but about the financial. And, Brown, Dave, I'm sure that's not your department. No. Can you give me the lowdown on the difference between the blue, the green, and the orange arrows? Absolutely. And this really ties to Councilman Wentworth's question. So the blue is where is public traffic routes? So this is looking at what the public would normally do. They would basically come through.
48:28 Check-in here at the attendant. This small little black box is the attendant check. This middle lane is a drive-through lane that does not have a scale. So this is for folks that just need to give their address to the attendant. Most of the loads that come through is just dropping off a bag. It's folks that don't have a pickup at their place. So we have really two options for them. Their easiest option is to come in, basically check them at the attendant, and they can drop immediately off here into some vents and get out of there so that they don't need to be tied up.
48:56 By folks with trailers and things like that at the transfer building. Folks that are coming in that have more than just the load would be, you know, backing up their trailers. We have four, even though it shows two arrows, there's actually, you know, room for four cars and trailers being set up to offload. So that's the blue arrows. The green is your route trucks and, you know, that would basically be pulling through, getting weighed. They have a tear weight on them. They would come through this commercial bay here on the left.
49:24 Dump their load, proceed straight out to Commerce from that location. They don't need to come back through the site. And then the last color, the orange color, these are your big, long tractor trailers that basically will come, pull into the site, be loaded from a material handler or loader, and basically go out to, you know, in this case, you know, heading up the, you know, balance, you know, go into another landfill and everything. So those guys will pull in, park, be there for anywhere from.
49:50 You know, a half hour to, you know, basically about an hour and a half actual time you had to get loaded and go out. One more quick question. So currently, you wouldn't take the transfer station, but you would go down to the landfill if you had an old car that didn't work or if you had old equipment that didn't work or if you had a boat that you were getting rid of because you let it get full of snow and it got busted.
50:20 How are we going to deal with that when the landfill is closed? Will this site be able to accommodate those large and sometimes commercial things? So this won't accommodate commercial type stuff. So that would actually go up to like Tumas Valley or somewhere like that. And Glenn can probably talk about that more here in a little bit. But yeah, some of the big, you know, even the commercial guys with large loads of C&D or the concrete, you know.
50:47 More inert type materials. Those wouldn't come here. Those have to go to a different location. Thank you. One thing I would add to that is that we're still waiting on the Mono County RFP to come out, and that's going to discuss, I think, probably 15 or 16 different options or different services that they need to handle. And so once we see that, then we'll have a better idea where things are going to go. So we're still in a holding pattern on that one. Thank you.
51:22 And Glenn, can they drop cycling off here and those little public drop-offs or do they have to go back up as a residential or do you go back up the road a ways and do this? Going up the road. So if you're doing both, you've got to stop both? Both. Okay. Do we have any, is this the end of the presentation or is there more, guys? There's a little bit more. Okay. Thanks, Dave. All right. So one of the things we talked about when I was here last was hiring a sustainability coordinator and we,
51:56 Interviewed a number of people, and we really found someone special, I have to say. Kendra Knight has been in the community for about 20 years now, I believe. Her and her husband have owned Bluebird Imaging for probably 16 of that. She's currently president of the, I think, the High School Boosters, and has been very involved in the community for just about her entire tenure here. So getting her on the team has been a godsend in a lot of ways.
52:23 You'll get a feel for some of the things she's already accomplished in a very short amount of time, and she's heavily involved with just about every aspect of the community right now. So, Kendra, I'll let you talk for a little bit, and I'll finish up on the operations side. Great, thank you. Thank you so much for having me here today, Councilmembers. Mayor Sauser, it's great to see you guys. I know most of you, and as you know, I've been in this community, as Glenn said, for about 20 years.
52:50 In my new position as Sustainability Coordinator, I am facilitating the implementation of all of the Cal Recycle mandates, which for us is AB 341 and AB 939, as well as educating our community and its residents about recycling and waste management, and I provide all the updates regarding that. I'm also providing outreach to our business community and the residents regarding recycling and sustainability.
53:15 Part of my position will also be to educate our local students once we get back in school via assemblies and demonstrate recycling processes at local events. In just the three months that I've been with Waste Connections, Mammoth Disposal, and Bishop Waste, I have emailed and wrote about 50-plus introductory letters to local business owners in Mono and Inyo counties, as well as commercial property owners and multifamily. These are all regarding the CalRecycle mandates.
53:42 And educating our customers by explaining the importance of the CalRecycle mandates, what that means for them and our community. And I attend all of our local events, as Glenn said, a lot of Mammoth Lakes Chamber meetings, which I love. It's fantastic. All of these Zoom meetings, the Mammoth Lakes Restaurant Association meetings. I'm working directly with CalRecycle 2 for reporting and grant writing and outreach. I also wanted to mention that we do have a grant out right now. We'll hear back in May.
54:11 Regarding our bottle beverage recycling grant, that was a big one, so we'll let you guys know, update you on that. I also provide presentations via Zoom, as I said, to many groups and organizations, such as HOAs, INEO 350, MLRA, and more. And I'm also working with High Sierra Energy Foundation for their green business program. In order to certify your business as green, I will be providing those trash assessments now.
54:39 We also have designed a new residential recycling bear cart flyer. If you have a PO box in Mammoth, you probably received this. That was 4,525 mailed flyers. We got from this, we have 35 new bear carts out since October 1st. 10 replacement carts out for a total of 45 new carts out. 78 total carts, and that includes old carts as well.
55:06 I have lots of future outreach plans. I continue to contact residents, business owners, start doing those site visits, trash assessments once I can get in there, COVID dependent, of course. And I would love to begin doing all the events that we hopefully will have, fingers crossed, live events this summer, maybe, and then school assemblies and so forth. We're also doing an Earth Week celebration, which is going to be really cool. A lot of partners on that one.
55:33 And I'm collaborating with the Town of Mammoth Lakes for our annual town cleanup day. Whew, that was a lot. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to take those as well. Any questions for Kendra? If so, just speak up. Yeah, Mr. Mayor, Kendra, you're bringing a new definition to the multiple hats thing. Congratulations.
56:03 As we, as Kendra, I'm sure you're aware, and Dave and others with Waste Connections, there's been a lot of interesting things coming out of COVID here in the Eastern Sierra. One of them has to do with issues around trash.
56:22 Which ties back to a practice known as dispersed camping. I'm sure you're aware of the dispersed camping summit that happened last week. And to put trash into that same pod that our visitors are in, trash does not respect jurisdictional boundaries. And we're all keenly aware that Waste Connections has service agreements with the town. I'm assuming, I think you also have a service agreement with the U.S. Forest Service.
56:51 I'm wondering if you could speak a little bit about how the community and all the various partners in the region are going to be able to work with you guys to deal with the realities of the trash and the things that our visitor population leaves behind up here. We're going to need flexibility. We're going to need really a lot of creative minds and some open-mindedness.
57:15 With some money, with some cash and some hard dollars, but we want to make sure that we can address these types of problems going forward. I'm wondering if you could speak to that a little bit. Would you like me to speak to that? You know, John, thank you for that. Yes, in terms of outreach and education and working, collaborating with partners, that's what I'm doing right now. It's fabulous. We're getting the word out to all of Bishop, Inyo, Mono County, and as far as visitation and trash.
57:43 I'm working with a lot of people to figure that out. I know with that Sierra Trash Eliminators on Facebook, trying to talk to people, figure out what they would like to see as well. This is our community. And just really get the word out to visitors as well. Don't trash our community. You want to visit here too. But yes, and I'm sure Glenn can speak on that. Actually, John, I think you brought this topic up last time. We need you to speak into the mic. Go ahead.
58:09 I think, John, you brought this topic up last time we were together. One thing I would offer, besides Kendra, but myself as well, maybe to sit down and talk a little bit more about it, maybe brainstorm on it some, and see if we can come up with some solutions to solve this, but it is definitely an important problem. Okay, there's going to be a supervisor of Mono County and Bob Gardner's put together this dispersed camping summit, where basically all of us here in the eastern tier are raising the barn.
58:37 On the challenges with dispersed camping, that means threat of fire, that means trash and waste, it means human waste, it means all kinds of things. But I would certainly, if you could reach out to me, we can certainly get you in touch with Bob and that team. The next meeting of that group is coming up March 25th. We also have the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, which is working on a number of fronts, including some opportunities and rights and grants to help to try to deal with these problems.
59:06 It'll be great if Kendra and some members of your team can be at those tables so you can hear what's going on, understand what's happening so that we can be really coming up with some really proactive solutions. So I look forward to hearing from you guys and keep you guys looped into all that. Yeah, you can count on us. Great. Thank you very much. Thank you, John. Any other council members with questions or comments? Okay. Okay. The last piece is a little bit on the operations side.
59:40 Kent asked us to talk on the storm, and I have to say that I've lived in snow belts all over the country from New York to Northern California, and I don't think I've seen anything like what happened on the 28th, but it went pretty well. We have a number of our employees that work here in Mammoth that live in Bishop, and so when the grade was shut down, that cut out a good portion of my staff from coming up here, but the ones who were here,
1:00:08 Still got a lot of things done during the storm, but we got the entire team back on Saturday, the entire group, and pretty much got caught up on just about everything. I think we had one customer that called for help for a pickup on Sunday, and we had people on site that day, so we were able to help them out. So from a reaction to the storm, a pretty good-sized one, I think the team did really well.
1:00:34 So any questions about that at all? I think everything I saw and heard, the major priority from us or our side, besides getting the trash up, is doing it safely. And the team did a great job of, if they got in a situation that was sketchy, they've been instructed to let it go and we'll come back, which we certainly did. So other than that, it went real well. We were also asked to talk a little bit about what we've heard.
1:01:04 On the new fee structure and whether we've had many complaints, I talked to both our CSRs and they said they may have had two. Now, depending on timing of billing, there could still be more, but for the most part, it's pretty much been a non-event on that side. The other topic was the buyback center when we're going to open and the office. The office has been open with my CSRs in the office, but not open to the public.
1:01:33 The buyback center has been closed to the public for the most part the last I think two months. We'll be opening them both up on the 23rd is the plan. And we expect that just like the last time we opened, it shouldn't be any problems. We're already ready to go. And we've got some new staff in play. And so, yeah, it should go pretty smoothly. The other topic or one of them that I talked about last time was our container situation. We've brought on since the
1:02:03 Probably since December, probably 25 new containers that we've purchased. We've sent out about another 20, 25, and then we've repaired a bunch ourselves. So probably over 80 in particular have been refurbished or brand new. So we're continuing to push that issue and to continue to improve on kind of the look and feel of our commercial bins. So with that, I'll answer any questions you've got if there's something I didn't cover. Okay, any further questions, council members?
1:02:34 Just speak up. I'm seeing no hands go up. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Okay, moving on then to stations, quarterly TOT enforcement update, second quarter of fiscal year 2021. Rob. Yes, thank you, Mayor. I'm going to share my screen here, just one second. You guys all see my screen very good there? Yes. Okay, thank you.
1:03:21 As you know, we come to you every quarter with an enforcement update talking about the activities of my team and the work that they've done. Typically, this presentation really covers zoning and revenue violations. This particular quarter, I added an update to include some health order elements.
1:03:47 As you know, as this pandemic has gone on and some of the health orders that have been issued directly impact transient occupancy tax in our lodging community. And a lot of the work that we've had to do has been in support of enforcing those orders, making sure people are all following the same rules. And so that's been the process here. So the form looks the same. This particular presentation covers time periods of October 2020 through December 2020.
1:04:16 And I'll talk a little bit about the activities of January, as that's probably when the bulk of the enforcement activity for December has occurred. But anyway, I walked through this number of cases. You can see not a lot of activity in our traditional zoning and revenue violation areas. We just haven't had the time to work on those.
1:04:40 We have shifted focus, I would say, starting in February to focus exclusively on that activity, or almost exclusively, and there's some things to be found there. The work that we did during this particular period of time was really preparing for and working through these health orders. You can see the number of citations issued and funding that was received.
1:05:06 Not a lot of detail. I want to read this to you, but that's essentially the work that was done during that particular quarter. This is your traditional slide that we show. This is a screenshot of post-compliance, which is our main rental platform. We may be engaging a separate rental platform here that has some additional capabilities, but this particular one provides us a snapshot of our market at this time.
1:05:35 It's a little bit deceiving. I mean, you know, the number of short-term rails, there's 337 individual units. But in total down below, there's about 6,000 online ads for those units. You can see that, you know, that is 63 in the last month, and 95.1% are identified. The work that we're doing starting in February has been to work to identify more properties and to get some of those that are outliers. A little bit of a recap.
1:06:05 As you know, as I spoke about just a minute ago, teamwork through the changing lodging restrictions. Those primarily came on in early December when the regional stay-at-home order was put into place by the state, and our local health officer issued an order that only essential travel would be allowed within the town. So that was another process, similar to what we did in the springtime where we had to shut down services or shut down operations for most of the lodging.
1:06:35 At the same time we did, we implemented a form, an approval process in form for essential workers. And what that did is tried to outline the process that the operators could use. And at that time we sort of offered up that we would pre-approve those in advance. So that was quite an undertaking because we had a lot of people that were submitting those forms. The town group, you have sometimes interviewed the workers.
1:07:05 To approve that process. And that was a lot of work. We had all hands on deck for that, about four individuals working. And again, our target was about a two-hour response time. We did a pretty good job. We continued that through the first week of January and then realized we just needed to make a little bit of a change in that. So in January, we changed that process up a little bit. Typically, this time of year, focused on my revenue team is the business tax certificate renewal.
1:07:34 We did send that out in December, and we're working through that process. It's been about typical as far as response. There's about 30% who have yet to provide information or pay that renewal fee, so they haven't issued a certificate. But that's not uncommon, and we work through that over the next couple of months. It is a lot of extra work for the team. We did hire part-time support for enforcement activity, primarily this person.
1:08:00 Starting December was working to work on the weekends and address the requests that would come in for essential worker forms. Again, we wanted to have a good response and not have those go dark when folks weren't working in the office. So that person's been working very hard through their approval process. And then now has shifted focus a little bit. And I'll talk about that on the next slide.
1:08:28 Enforcing what occurred in December and then looking at our Red Dot program. We also maintain a commitment to our planned audit processes. As you know, that was an important feature of the team. We are focusing right now on the 24-hour gap between stays as part of the health orders. We've developed a very quick audit process for that. And the team is working through that as we speak. And that's still been very effective.
1:08:59 A little bit of a focus of what we're looking at going forward. We hired, as I said earlier, hiring that part-time help. They are working on what I call the Red Dot Program, which those are the unidentified properties that are not in compliance with our regulations. And so they're working through that, and it has been very productive. Again, that started primarily in February, so my report for third quarter will have more of the fruits of that labor.
1:09:29 I can say that in last week she's identified three major cases, so that's been very effective. Also, we're trying to address, there's advertisements for 31 nights or more in zoning areas, kind of working on our approach to that, and that's going to be a little bit of effort and a little bit of legal support for that. And then we review each new advertisement that comes up every week, and that's a standard process.
1:09:59 We have kind of altered our work program. I do have another reason I had this person come on to part-time help is I've had one person out since the 1st of January. We'll be back sometime in March. And then a second person is out for most of February. And so those absences have sort of put a strain on our traditional workflow. And our existing staff is working through that. And then the enforcement shifted over to the part-time person.
1:10:29 We're working on that. The other thing we're doing is, as you know, January 25th, the stay-at-home order was lifted and then the town issued an order on February 1st for a 70% cap on rental activity and capacity. And so we're working on that, a lot of process for that and how to follow through on that process for review. So they're working on that. On the health order enforcement side,
1:10:59 You know, we've been working through the new processes as they've changed. As each health order has been issued, significant adjustments have had to make in our process in developing ways of enforcement. January has a couple of different moving parts. In the first part of the month, we had rentals that required pre-approval. In the middle part of the month, we have
1:11:29 Operators doing the approvals and submitting those forms with their tax returns. And in the last week, you know, we have basically the 70% cap. So lots of work going on with that. Team is looking at each of those returns as they come in and reviewing the documentation that's provided to make sure there are forms for each of the rentals. We're reaching out to operators if we have anything missing and working with them to get those submitted.
1:11:56 Our goal really here is that everyone's following the same set of rules and everyone is working through the processes that we implemented. We have had a number of things going on for December. The team is reviewing online advertisements. They are requesting detailed PDF reports from online operators on their payout summaries for the month of December to determine if any illegal activity has happened.
1:12:25 That's been a very challenging process. People don't really want to admit to potentially costly errors when they've been renting during a ban, and unfortunately that has happened quite often. So the team is working through that. That's been out there. We've issued a citation. The citation is $1,000 for each occurrence, and so it's fairly substantial. But I do want to remind folks,
1:12:54 Our citations that are issued primarily are to gain conversation with the operator, making sure that we are able to get all the information that we get we need from them. And if they don't provide that, then we issue the citation saying we're in violation of not providing the documentation required by the town. But then following up on that is...
1:13:18 Based upon the activity, they may receive a citation for a rental during the ban that wasn't authorized. And so that's pretty substantial. That can be a big challenge for folks. And the citation process does have a couple of appeals, though. I want to remind people of that. Once it's received, you can appeal to a hearing officer, which is before it gets to town council.
1:13:43 The hearing officer will listen to the operator's comments and discuss why the activity occurred that was banned, give them an opportunity to explain themselves and be accountable for their actions, if you will, and then they will make a determination on the outcome of those citations. If they're upheld and somehow the operator still would like further review of that, they can come to a council meeting through our process. We can establish a...
1:14:12 So, as you know, you've sat through some of those. That's the process of due diligence we give folks to be able to defend themselves against the titations that were issued. And that process is not widely understood. I think we've had a lot of people who've received citations that have never received them in the past, and there's been all sorts of response to that. But we're working through all of those and, again, trying to make sure that
1:14:42 Our processes are fair and balanced, and they have all those appeal processes in place. The further health order stuff, I talked about the 24-hour gap between riddles and the adherence to the 70% cap. Those are our new focus. That 24-hour gap's been there since June 19th when we went back online, but the 70% cap has kind of gone on and off.
1:15:11 The host compliance cleanup, I talked a bit about that on the enforcement focus program. They're working through that, just things that maybe my team hasn't had a chance to do. And it's been important to kind of allow them to focus on the daily operations and really not push too hard on the enforcement focus. But by hiring this part 10 person, that focus has definitely come in sharp.
1:15:39 And so I expect a lot of positive things. We're also working on improved processes for communication. One of the things that we had to do throughout the enforcement or the health order challenges was we had to communicate to the operators what the current situation was, what the current requirements were. And so we've been utilizing some good email distribution programs and through that process developing.
1:16:06 What I think is a really effective way of communicating. So that's out there and working through. And the audit program probably even picked up in April or May, again, where we have a little bit more breathing room and we can work through that process. But we should have no problem hitting our 50 audit process expected for fiscal year 2020. I think that concludes my presentation. And if there are any questions. Okay, questions. Let's start with Kirk.
1:16:40 No questions. Thank you, Kirk. Sarah? Yeah, hi, Rob. Thank you so much. I do have one question. You mentioned that we hired a part-time enforcement person. I remember telling a couple constituents that that position was a replacement. Would that have been an incorrect statement on my part?
1:17:03 Yeah, so it's a little bit convoluted because it wasn't a replacement. The employees that I have, my full-time employees that are on leave, they're on a leave that's approved leave of absence, and so they'll be coming back. This position is part-time and is temporary, so that means it will be probably through May that I'll be able to have them, and it'll be focused on the number of hours. Okay. Thank you for clarifying that.
1:17:34 Linda. Thank you. Hi, Rob. Question. What do you think is the most challenging thing now? I know we talked in the past about when we sort of think we have a handle on it, then the often new ways to get around pain TOT are developed. So do you feel like you're able to keep up with that? Or what is what you would consider to be the most challenging part of this right now? Well, I think
1:18:05 If I can go back to when I first started here and the team was working probably obviously before my arrival, and that was four and a half years ago, on really trying to get everybody who is able to rent to be legally and legal operator and providing all the information that they should for their tax returns. And I think they've done a good job on that. We've got everyone sort of on board with this health orders and the challenges that
1:18:34 We have restricting lodging. I think that that's driven a little bit more underground. That has sort of bolstered the black market, if you will, of rental activity. And so I think it's kind of starting back in what we did maybe in 2016, where we had a significant amount of that going on, that we pushed a lot more of that. So I think that's come up as a new, not new, but a resurgence of...
1:19:03 And so that's definitely a focus that my team's got to have. And really, I think just the illegal criminal activity and the varying abilities for people to do that. Some people don't advertise online, which makes it much more difficult for us. And it's word of mouth. But we've got a pretty strong tip program. I think that's one of the things that has been a benefit of this process is people have
1:19:33 They decided to step up, call in, and make recommendations when there is something going on in their neighborhood. And I think that's been bolstered by all of this. So it's a little bit of an either direction. But right now, I think the black market and the way these health orders enhance it is our biggest challenge. Yeah, I agree, Rob. Thank you, though, for this. John. Thanks, Rob. Thanks to you and the team. You guys have done really excellent work.
1:20:01 Unbelievably difficult in trying circumstances. However, we have to go back to that old adage of getting the lemonade out of lemons. And my particular interest in this is in the quality of life ordinance. And I know you're not speaking to that too much this evening, but I would like to propose that in the near future, you put your quality of life ordinance hat on and let's start thinking about how we can make adjustments to this.
1:20:28 I think what I've heard anecdotally is that the 24-hour response thing, it doesn't work if your 24-hour contact lives in Gardnerville or in Phoenix. That kind of stuff is not going to work. I think we always knew that the quality of life ordinance would be a work in progress and it would need to be updated based on the things that are happening on the ground. So I would be very much interested in following up on that. I hope my fellow council members agree that we need to, probably need to.
1:20:56 Come back to that and sharpen up a little bit. This is part of a larger concern with transient rentals. I think, first, I think we have too many in town. I think that people, there's not even the guise that this is part of an investment in the community. This is purely a business opportunity for folks. Folks that don't live in the community, don't even come to the community. This can all be done, managed online, using the internet.
1:21:21 The other thing I would add is the uniqueness of our jurisdiction as a town. The state of California passed some pretty interesting legislation about
1:21:50 You know, you can't raise rents and rental restrictions and landlord stuff, which is all very good legislation, except there's this huge loophole in that it doesn't apply to people who are running from condominium owners. So if you're renting a unit that you're living in that's owned by a condominium owner, none of that legislation in the state of California applies. And that's, if you look at, you know, the vast majority of our housing stock are condominiums.
1:22:18 We've got to dig into this. We've got to really do what we can to get more opportunities for long-term rentals for our residents in this community. And this is not the evening or the agenda item to do that on, but I'm personally quite serious about this. Rob, I know you are as well. I'm looking forward to working with you on this and to sharpening up that quality of life ordinance, how we can get more housing for folks in this community.
1:22:38 That's it for me. Thanks again. You guys have just really, again, we're not out of the woods yet. You guys have just done great work on all this. And thank you very much for your patience, your civility, your diplomacy, and dealing with a lot of very challenging and difficult circumstances. So thank you. Thank you, John. I will reiterate a lot of what he said. Rob, I think your staff is, with what you have available for staff right now, is doing a great job. I would like us as a council to go back and look at that quality of life ordinance.
1:23:09 As a local locksmith, it disturbed me when someone calls me because they're locked out of a place they've rented for a nightly basis and there is nobody in town, even though it's required by code. And believe me, I have given that speech more times than I care to, to renters and owners of units as to why it exists out there. You call me at two o'clock in the morning, I have no idea if you belong in that unit. And managers won't let them in in the condo projects.
1:23:37 Unless the manager handles the unit themselves. So that is something that I would like to see us follow through on and see if we can devise a way to enforce it. It is such an out there thing. I don't know how we would enforce it, but I would love to look at that again because to me that quality of life needs to be updated and enforced. With that, I will move on to any public comments on this, Jamie.
1:24:06 There are no public comments. Thank you. Rob, I thank you for your patience in putting all this together. Thank you. Moving on then. Consent agenda. I will read these off really quick. Approval of minutes of the regular meeting of February 3. Approve the resolution continuing the local emergency regarding COVID. Receive and file Snow Creek Development Agreement 2020 Annual Review Report.
1:24:37 And accept payment approval reports number 21-33 and 21-34. Does anybody wish to pull anything from consent? Mr. Mayor, I'll make the motion to approve the consent agenda as presented, but I do have one additional comment for the final vote on this. Okay. I have a motion. And I would like to suggest that Vice Mayor Salcido and Councilmember Stapp abstain from...
1:25:07 The Snow Creek Development Agreement acceptance, even though the council is not really taking any action other than accepting it, they should still abstain. And as always with consent items, you don't have to kind of turn off your camera or mic in order to abstain from a consent calendar item. But just from that one item? Just the one item. Right. Do I have a second on the motion? I will second the motion. Thank you.
1:25:39 Okay, John, you had another point in deliberations. Yes, thank you. I'm wondering, staff, on the Stoke Creek Development Agreement, I know there was some conversation between, I think, the trails manager and the Stoke Creek group on some opportunities out there. I'd just like to maybe get an update on that at our next meeting, just to understand what happened with those conversations, what the status of that is. And that's the only thing I'd like to add to that. Otherwise, my motion stands.
1:26:06 Yeah, John, are you referring to like the road rehab that there was talk about getting done that isn't getting done? No, that's a different topic. This has to do with Joe Rathje was talking about some opportunities for the Snow Creek Group with those new trails that are hopefully going to be getting built in the Sherwin's Meadow and the opportunity for the Snow Creek Group maybe to be participating in some of that work. And I know that some conversations happened. I just don't know what came out the other side. It'd be great to get an update on that. All right. Thank you, John.
1:26:35 So I have a motion from John, a second from myself. Any further deliberation? Jamie, please. Council Member Ray? Yes. Council Member Staff? Yes, with a recuse on item 6. Council Member Wentworth? Aye. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes, aye, with a recuse on item 6. Mayor Souser? Yes. I'm sorry, Annie, should that be an abstention?
1:27:08 How would you rather that phrase? No, you had it exactly right. I described it as an abstention, but no, you're right. Technically, it is a recusal. Okay, thank you. Thank you all. Moving on now. God, I made a mistake again. I've got to get my meeting running in better condition here. Public hearings. Number eight, consider adoption of zoning code amendment 20-004 to implement zoning code cleanup.
1:27:42 of the standards related to accessory dwelling units. The proposed amendment includes finding the project exempt from CEQA pursuant to public resources code 21080.17 and CEQA guidelines 15282. H. Nolan. Great. Hello, Town Council, and good evening, everyone. So this update was initiated by the town to...
1:28:13 Accomplish a number of items. One was to clarify conflicting and or confusing code language from the 2019 secondary dwelling unit regulations update. Second was to change all code references from second or secondary dwelling units to accessory dwelling units or ADUs throughout the zoning code. And third was to reorganize the format of the ADU code section to improve the usability for public and staff. Just to clarify for everyone, what is an accessory dwelling unit?
1:28:43 It's a dwelling unit that can provide complete independent living facilities for one or more persons as located on a lot with another primary dwelling unit. An ADU can be an interior ADU such as an area that's converted from an existing residence, say a spare bedroom or
1:29:07 Game room that's converted to an independent living facility. It can also be attached to an existing residence as an addition, or it can be a detached standalone structure. Just at the top of the screen is just some simple images kind of conceptualizing those different ADU types. Why update the current code? The town's code has been comprehensively updated three times since it was updated.
1:29:32 Adopt as part of the zoning code update, at least the ADU code section with each amendment. The amendments have been kind of piecemealed into the code and the regulations have never been comprehensively reviewed for their effectiveness. Also, the state continues to revise and clarify their standards and pass new laws. The state did put out an ADU handbook, which provides a robust FAQ section on all the new laws. That link is in the staff report.
1:30:00 And lastly, the town's code uses outdated terminology throughout the code, such as second or secondary dwelling units, and this will change all those references. Just a summary of the 2019 California ADU update. This is the laws that were passed in 2019. These laws made substantial changes to the standards for ADUs and voided all local jurisdiction ADU ordinances that did not comply with the state standards.
1:30:31 To avoid having an ordinance that was not in compliance with state laws, staff brought forward an urgency ordinance in December 2019 that brought it into compliance with the state, but not necessarily in a format that was very useful for staff or public. It is important to note that the state does not prevent local agencies from adopting less restrictive requirements for the creation of an ADU. We just cannot be more restrictive.
1:30:58 So it's on the screen is some of the standards, some of the highlight ones. A couple of the ones was the state changed it to now you can have with a single family residence a detached ADU and you can also in some cases add a junior ADU. So there's the potential that a single family property could have three independent living facilities on it. They also allow ADUs for existing multifamily properties.
1:31:24 They required us to allow ADUs with reduced side and rear yard setbacks. Then a few other ones, they no longer require owner occupancy of either the ADU or the primary dwelling unit. And they prohibited short-term rentals for all ADUs that were constructed after January 1, 2020. It's important to note that if you're in a zone that allows short-term rentals,
1:31:52 The primary residence on the property could still be rented short term. This just applies to the ADU. So moving into the proposed amendment. First one was reorganization of the ADU chapter. It reformatted it into more user-friendly with general requirements that apply to all ADUs.
1:32:19 Then it broke it into single-family residential requirements and multifamily residential requirements. And within each of those categories, it broke it down based on each type of ADU. So depending on what type you might want to build, it's very clear to find those regulations and standards. Moving on, this is just some of the proposed code changes. I'm highlighting specifically the areas where we defer from the state. The first one is regarding interior access.
1:32:50 This was a recommendation that the Planning and Economic Development Commission made at the January 2021 public hearing. Their recommendation was to prohibit interior access between an interior or attached ADU and the primary unit. The rationale for this was to ensure that the ADU functions as a complete independent living facility and to increase the chances that the unit will be used as a long-term housing unit rather than used as a guest suite or in an enlarged main dwelling.
1:33:17 If the town council is interested in this recommendation, staff is recommending in addition to the language, which is to give the director the ability to provide for an exemption in instances when it is impractical to close up the interior access or it creates some kind of hardship such as financial or something else. So there is some...
1:33:46 Potential language here on the screen that could be included in a town council recommendation if they desire. A few other areas, this is regarding roof design and architectural projections. Since the town is required to allow ADUs to be within four feet of side and rear property lines, staff is proposing these design standards to
1:34:10 Protect neighboring properties from snowshed and to prevent ADU or any portion of an ADU from going closer than four feet to the property line. The architectural projections regarding eaves, decks, entryways, those items because in the code right now just says they can go up to within three feet of a side or rear property line. Regarding parking, the state standards prohibit jurisdictions from requiring more than one space per ADU.
1:34:39 But then they added numerous exemptions which result in no parking being required in almost all instances. Those exemptions include being within a half mile walking distance of public transit or when an ADU is part of a proposed or existing primary residence for an accessory structure. We also cannot require replacement of garage spaces converted to an ADU. Just here is a brief map showing
1:35:07 All the areas that are within a half mile of transit stop. So really the only areas that fall outside of it are the bluffs, Snow Creek 5, and a few residences in the very top end of the Knolls. Because of this broad exemptions, the proposed regulations are requiring no parking for any ADUs. This is to clarify and reduce the ambiguity of whether it's
1:35:36 0.51 miles to a train stop or 0.49 depending on how it's measured. But also we added to encourage provision of adequate parking, the allowance for one additional unenclosed parking space to be within a setback area. The proposed regulations contain a number of items that they have to meet in order to provide that parking to minimize any impacts for neighboring properties or snow storage.
1:36:05 And then the proposed regulations are consistent with the state regarding garages converted to an ADU. The state also created what's known as a statewide exemption ADU. This is an ADU that does not exceed 800 square feet, does not exceed 16 feet in height, and is located no closer than four feet to side and rear property lines. This type of ADU is exempt from lot coverage for area and open space requirements. However, the town...
1:36:35 It is required to allow these types of ADUs, but in order to minimize how much lot coverage some of these might occupy if they're located outside of the side and rear yard setback area, so within the standard setback area, we're recommending that they adhere to the standard height for that zone, but still maintain that 800 square foot limit. That would reduce the building footprint by potentially half if they build a two-story ADU that's outside the setback areas.
1:37:03 They are encroaching into that side or rear yard setback and they are held to that 16 foot height limit in order to minimize impacts for neighboring properties. Lastly, we added an area regarding ADU removal or conversion to another use. Because ADUs are granted a number of development standard exemptions or reductions and also are exempt from a number of fees.
1:37:33 This is intended to prevent a property owner from coming in, permitting an ADU, then converting it to another use once they get their CFO. All ADUs do require a use agreement be recorded on title, acknowledging that there's an ADU on the property. If a property owner is to come to the town and say, we no longer want that on title, we want to remove the ADU, staff can look at it, and if it...
1:38:00 The proposed use is not consistent with the new setbacks or lot coverage or height or the new use would require payment of a housing fee or some other impact fee, then this would give staff the opportunity to impose those standards on that new use in exchange for removing that use restriction from title. The last change, as we talked about earlier, is just changing all code references from secondary dwelling unit to accessory dwelling unit.
1:38:31 This will help the public locate the standards since the accessory dwelling in is the common term used industry-wide. Public review for this item as part of just the development of the standards, the draft code language was routed and reviewed internally by planning and engineering staff with the direction of is this easy to understand? Are there any questions? Are there any areas that are confusing or could be improved upon?
1:39:02 The comments were incorporated into the regulations. Additionally, since adoption of the state standards, we have seen an increase in inquiries for adding an ADU to the property with some increase in actual building permit activity. Sunscreen here shows building permits submitted, issued, and completed since 2017 for specifically ADUs. At the end of 2019, we saw a big jump in those submitted.
1:39:30 But with 2020 being the way it is, development of new residential uses kind of slowed down at the beginning of the year, but we did see some increased activity in the latter part, and we will see what this upcoming building season brings. Also, the public hearing was noticed in the sheet, and no public comments have been received. Zoning Code amendments in order...
1:39:59 Approve a zoning code amendment. The findings require finding it consistent with the general plan and the zoning code. The proposed amendments are consistent with the vision statements from the general plan of providing adequate and appropriate housing. It also creates infill opportunities to prevent having to expand outwards or expand into other vacant properties.
1:40:24 It's also consistent with the housing element and the action in the housing element to review ADU standards and revise as necessary to encourage the development of ADUs. And it's internally consistent with the zoning code. It's going to provide improved internal consistency and improved usability and format for the ADU code section.
1:40:51 That, based on the information in the staff report, the ordinance, and here at the public hearing, staff is recommending Town Council waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving zoning code amendment 20-004, either as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission or as modified by the Town Council. And with that, I will...
1:41:19 We'll open it up to questions from the Town Council and or the public. Thank you, Nolan. So, Council, let's start with John. Mr. Mayor, I have no questions. I'm waiting to see if there's any public comment. This is obviously a very important program. Nolan, thanks for your work on this, getting things cleaned up so we can be able to deal with this. But I don't have any questions. Thank you. Thank you, John. Linda. Thank you, Nolan. Good presentation. I just have a question.
1:41:51 So at the beginning, did you say that we could have our ordinances the same as the state, less or less than, but not more restrictive? Is that accurate? Correct. It's a little different from most state laws where the state kind of sets the baseline and we can be more restrictive, but with ADUs, it's the opposite.
1:42:20 The maximum standards that we can impose, but we can be less restrictive. So then when you talked about not allowing an entrance from the main residence into the ADU, was that more restrictive then that we were proposing than the state guidelines? The state standards are silent on requiring or not requiring interior access. I can also let...
1:42:49 Andy weigh in a little more, him being the Town Attorney for Truckee as well. This similar recommendation went to their Planning Commission and Town Council as well. Okay, before Andy, there was one more then, also the parking requirement that sounded a little bit more restrictive than the state. So those two things I was kind of wondering about. So if Andy could talk about those at the municipal thing. Sure, and our parking one is actually less restrictive because the state right now says you...
1:43:18 Okay, thank you. I had that backwards. Thanks. Right, so the parking one is completely clean. The interior access is one that we talked about a fair bit in Truckee and ultimately came down on the side of it's not really making it any more difficult to build an ADU. It's just sort of changing how it's accessed. So we concluded finally that
1:43:47 It wasn't really a restriction. It was just a matter of where the door was going to go. So we felt that was probably going to work. And on the parking on the snowshed issue, these are issues that even if no one's asking about them, I will tell you that they came up in Truckee. There was a lot of concern that doesn't the state understand that having four foot setbacks is going to make falling snow a real problem.
1:44:12 I think Nolan's idea that he came up with of having snow rails or designing the roofs to not shed toward the property line is a really, really good one. We did in Truckee have kind of an initial conversation with the town's lobbyist about whether he thought we could get any support of the legislature for some very tailored revisions to the ADU law that would address some of the issues in snow country like parking and setbacks.
1:44:40 And the response we got back was there was no way that the legislature was going to even think about doing anything that could be perceived as watering down the ADU law. So even though not having any parking is kind of a problem where street parking is prohibited for six months out of the year, and the ADU legislation doesn't really seem to have been drafted with that in mind, there does not seem to be any legislative help forthcoming.
1:45:08 The kind of blanket exemption that Nolan's describing is very practical and avoids having what would in Mammoth be a very confusing map based on a half mile walking distance of public transit. If you use that as the criteria. Yeah, the only thing I was thinking about as far as the doorway went was if you had an elderly relative or perhaps another person living with you that you may need access to for safety.
1:45:36 And then we prohibited that entrance from the primary residence to the ADU. Would that set up possible or couldn't that set up a possible issue? Just an example of this. It did. And that's why our recommendation did include this ability for the director to provide an exception to that requirement. Okay.
1:46:01 Here is shown on the screen. So it's a fairly broad exception, similar to other exceptions that we use elsewhere in the code, such as a propane tank being in a side yard setback allows the director and the public works director to approve that when it otherwise wouldn't be. There's kind of a number of those instances when it's kind of based on a case-by-case scenario to allow that director that gives the director that ability. Okay, that should do it. Thank you. Appreciate that. Thanks so much.
1:46:30 And Andy, thank you. That's all. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. Sarah? Yeah, those were my questions, the interior door and the parking, so I think that was covered. Thank you. Thank you, Sarah. Kirk? Yeah, my question is, Noah, how close can they build to the lock line?
1:46:55 On a side and rear lot line that can go to within four feet of the property line, the standard front yard setback still applies, which is dependent on the zone. So how does that impact snow removal when people push snow between units? That's a great question for the state. But yes, we have attempted to address that by requiring that this...
1:47:22 Roof does not shed towards the property line if they're in that reduced setback area. And if they are, then they add snow rails or use a roof material that holds the snow on the roof, such as a composite roof, it's going to shed a lot less than a metal roof would. So currently, if somebody is already developed, then they will be required to put on snow rails?
1:47:51 No, it's not retroactive, so this would just be from adoption for when the code becomes effective going forward. And the four feet, that's not our recommendation, that's the state requirements, and that's one of those that we couldn't require more than four feet. If we thought four feet was too much, we could require less, but we couldn't go more. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk.
1:48:25 Nolan, I'm glad to see the exemption in here you're putting that the director can allow an internal access. I think that's great. So if someone has a house that's large enough and they want to create an ADU in the space they have, it allows them to do that without kicking an exterior wall out to build a door and a staircase. I have a problem with the parking issues in that I don't think we should ever build anything without a parking space.
1:48:53 Every time we've done anything like that, it has, you know, created issues. I realize the state requires it, but I just don't like it. If someone builds new, and then I would hold them to the exterior entrance to an ADU, but if they build new with an ADU and get the four-foot setback exemption,
1:49:20 Is there something in the law that prevents them from then changing it later to their own uses? I mean, is that just a way for them to get around setback rules? So I can touch on this and then I'll likely have Andy weigh in as well. This was the intent of including this ADU removal language. Like I said, we do require use restriction be recorded on title, identifying it as an ADU.
1:49:46 Typically, if it changed use, we wouldn't necessarily know about it unless it becomes either a code enforcement case based on a complaint or when the property owner goes to sell and the new owner looks and says, well, why does the title report say there's an ADU, but this is just a workshop or a shed or whatever else. As part of removing that from title, we then can require that the unit be brought into compliance with the development standards for the
1:50:16 Whatever the current use is, so whether that's setbacks, lot coverage, height, or like I said, if it's a change of use from single family with an ADU and wants to go to a multifamily because they're in the right zone, it would require payment of fees and a number of other items for that conversion of use. We have recently had a number of inquiries of property owners in the RMF2 zone looking to build ADUs on their property.
1:50:46 And we make it very clear to them up front what they're allowed to do with that use. Even though they're in the right zone for nightly rentals, the ADU cannot be used for nightly rental uses. And just on the screen here, it's probably a little hard to see, but it's a table we put together just comparing the ADU versus multifamily residential use that we then can provide out to the public just showing what those differences are.
1:51:15 I feel we have the ability to require conversion of use if it converts from an ADU to something else. I can let Andy weigh in on that as well because him and I talked about that as well. So ostensibly, if someone said they were going to build an ADU and provided an exterior entrance to it and then never rented it or used it for personal use, if we found out about it, we could go back and tell them to take off five foot of their building.
1:51:47 Yeah, as a practical matter, I don't think that's going to happen. And really, an ADU that's used for personal use, it would be very difficult to be able to definitively determine that it's not being used as an ADU. I mean, because even an ADU that's being used to house members of the family or something, that's still probably used as an ADU. So this is one that may not really come into play very often. It simply may not
1:52:17 Thank you, Andy. Do we have any public comments on this, Jamie? No, we do not. Okay. With that, then, I will close the public hearing. That's my gavel hitting.
1:52:49 And we will move to deliberations and a possible moving forward of this motion. If you could, yeah, thank you. The one item for it that does come to making a recommendation was to whether recommend as proposed by the Planning and Economic Development Commission or with the modification to allow that the director's exception for that interior access.
1:53:25 Remind Town Council of that. Okay. John? Yes, Mr. Mayor, I'm prepared to make a motion, but this is the, this will come back to us for final approval, is that correct? There's a couple little technical things in there, I might have a couple questions about, is that fair to assume? Or if we approve this tonight, is that it, and it's done? It will come back for the second reading, but that's typically on consent.
1:53:59 And if the council were to make any changes between the first reading and the second reading, you'd have to do a new first reading. So, Councilmember Wentworth, if you have a good sense of the changes that you would like to see, the time to introduce those changes would be tonight. If you've identified some things that you would still like to mull over a little bit so that you're not prepared to make amendments tonight, what we could do is have the council, perhaps, if everyone agrees with you, not do the first reading tonight.
1:54:28 Talk to staff later. Tell staff what you'd like to see amended, and then we'd bring it back as amended for a new first reading. Let me see if I can ask this little weedy question and make it as anti-weedy as possible, and no one maybe can see what we can do with this. So let's say that a proposed accessory dwelling unit in an existing structure has a discrete external entrance.
1:54:57 And let's say that the proposed accessory dwelling unit, should there be an internal access to the rest of the building, would mean that the accessory dwelling unit could have access to, say, laundry facilities or a garage or some other things within existing structure. Tell me what that scenario looks like. I think that's one of the scenarios where...
1:55:25 They proposed it and it seemed reasonable that the director could make that exception to the interior access prohibition. Just to clarify, though, that all ADUs attached or interior do require that separate exterior entrance. That doesn't change anything on that side, but it is a bit. They came and said, you know, there's a...
1:55:49 Shared laundry facility or garage that's directly accessible to the ADU and the primary residents. And that's, I think, one of the instances when interior access could be maintained. Good. It's just those, be able to do those kinds of scenarios that we can fully make this work. So that answers my question. So that being said, I'm prepared to make a motion, Mr. Mayor. Yes, John. So I would recommend that the council waive the first reading and introduce by title only.
1:56:15 The ordinance making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approved zoning amendment 20-004 is recommended by the Planned Economic Development Commission with inclusion of the language as presented by staff with regards to interior access. Thank you, John. I have a motion. I'll second that. I have a second. So I have a motion from John, a second from Linda.
1:56:47 Any further deliberations? I can't see you all, so you'll just have to speak up. I can stop sharing if I can figure out how. None. Jamie, please. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Aye. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Okay. Moving on then. Get my paperwork together here. Another public hearing.
1:57:25 To consider adoption of zoning code amendment 20-001 to update municipal code chapter 17.44 parking and loading standards to clarify alternative parking provisions, establish review and approval process for parking reduction requests and changes or expansion of uses that are non-conforming as to parking and facilitate the use of alternative parking and transportation demand management measures.
1:57:53 in accordance with mobility element goals. The amendment also includes a minor change to Table 17.76.020 to remove a decrease in the number of required parking spaces from the allowable adjustments, as well as an update to Chapter 17.100, Nonconforming Uses Structures Parcels to Refer to the Updated Parking Standards.
1:58:20 I feel like I'm reading a novel to my school class. With that, I will open the public hearing and turn it over to Chandler. Great. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I will share screen here. Okay. Can everyone see my presentation? Is everyone seeing this? Yes. Okay. So, yes, this is parking code update, zoning code amendment 20-001. You pretty much just summarized it very well.
1:59:05 This was initiated by the town to correct existing discrepancies in the municipal code, to clarify alternative parking provisions, to establish review and approval process for parking reduction requests and changes to uses with non-conforming parking, and to encourage the use of alternative parking and transportation demand management measures in accordance with mobility element goals. So why are we updating the current code? Currently, there are discrepancies in the current code language.
1:59:35 Which make it hard to implement and understand for both applicants and staff. Complex regulations that are hard to understand. There is a lack of clear review and approval processes, which translates to a lack of transparency or accountability. We've had slow progress in achieving the town and state goals of increasing transit, bike, and pedestrian modes and decreasing single occupant vehicles and reducing vehicle miles traveled.
2:00:04 We've had slow progress in improving the management of existing town parking more efficiently and encouraging transportation demand management measures. So these are just a few of the policies in the mobility element that support transportation demand management. Implementation of TDM measures or programs should be encouraged and incentivized for both new development and existing development. Support alternative transportation, housing affordability, and public health goals.
2:00:33 Through implementation of improved parking strategies and requirements and adjusting parking requirements on a case-by-case basis when it can be demonstrated that parking demand can be reduced or parking efficiency can be improved. So currently the alternative parking provisions in section 17.44040, they are intended to allow for modifications to on-site parking requirements. So this can be done through shared parking agreements, parking reductions which can incorporate.
2:01:03 TDM and other measures for parking and move fees. Currently, these regulations are very complex and confusing, which is a disincentive for businesses or developers to use them. It's unclear what the review and approval process steps are. It makes it really hard for staff to evaluate proposals or to track existing approvals. There is no public input process and no limits on the size of requests. So theoretically, under the current code language,
2:01:32 Somebody could come in and ask for a 100% parking reduction. It would not require any sort of formal application process. And theoretically, town staff could approve such a reduction with no public process and without planning commission or town council review. So similarly, not conforming parking standards. These are standards that apply to uses that do not meet current code parking requirements.
2:02:02 So it may just be an existing business that was constructed a long time ago before we adopted the parking code and it has fewer than the required number of spaces that would be non-conforming as to parking. So this code section currently contains conflicting standards. It puts the burden of proof on staff, meaning that if somebody wants to expand a business, let's say that it doesn't meet current parking requirements, it's basically up to staff to determine
2:02:31 On their own without any kind of data that provided by the applicant, whether that could potentially cause issues off site or whether that's acceptable. So that's another issue of the current code language. Also, there's a lack of clear review and approval process, no public process. It's very permissive and it's not necessarily a bad thing, but there are some potential negative impacts associated with that.
2:03:00 Staff cannot identify all potential off-site impacts. Usually this requires a transportation engineer to determine those impacts. There's no incentive or requirement for applicants to offset impacts or boost parking demand. So really someone could theoretically expand a business and there's nothing in the code that says if you're going to expand your business but keep the same amount of parking, you have to provide more bicycle parking or you have to
2:03:30 Make it easier for employees to carpool or take transit. So parking is best managed comprehensively town-wide. We have many policies supporting that idea. That requires tracking how parking is being used, encouraging shared parking where appropriate, and trying to reduce overall parking demand to make the existing supply work better. So currently our code doesn't really do those things. So section 17.44050.
2:04:01 Transportation Demand Management, or TDM. So these are measures that are intended to help reduce demand for vehicle parking. So some examples, and this includes increasing transit ridership, increasing bicycling, walking, or carpooling. So just some examples of this would be employee incentives. So that could be something like offering employees
2:04:28 The day off if they're the one who rides their bike the most or offering preferred parking to employees who carpool, stuff like that. Provision of bike racks or other bike-supported facilities. The easier you make it for people to bike to work if you have showers there and good bike racks where they're sure their bike's not going to get stolen, maybe have some air pumps, that can really help increase bicycling. Unbundling parking, and that's mainly for residential projects, but that's essentially
2:04:58 Charging residents for the cost of parking, not just providing free parking no matter what, but essentially making parking an extra thing that they have to pay for. Alternative scheduling, so that can just be allowing people to keep schedules other than the typical 9 to 5 workday, which could make it easier for them to find a parking space when they need to drive.
2:05:25 Or to work from home, which would obviously be keys driving significantly. And providing information on commuting options. So that can just be fairly simple kind of informational handouts. So again, the current regulations as they stand are very complicated. They're hard to monitor. Different measures are allowed currently based on employer size, which really isn't the way that most cities typically deal with transportation demand management.
2:05:53 There's no relation to the size of the request. So right now I think the code has a, you have to demonstrate a 20% reduction in parking demand no matter what the size of the parking production is that you're asking for. So you could be asking for a 50% reduction in parking and you're only required to show that you're reducing parking demand by 20%. So there's a disconnect there. There's no clear toolbox. So there's kind of different measures are allowed.
2:06:22 Based on the number of employees you have, which also is not something the town typically monitors or enforces. So it's really hard to know whether an applicant would be telling the truth about their number of employees and what TDM measures they're allowed to use. And no consistent requirements really equals no way of monitoring what works and what doesn't. So theoretically, we could grant somebody a parking reduction right now. They could say that they're going to use
2:06:52 TDM to support the parking reduction. We would approve it, and then that would be it. There would be no follow-up. There would be no, there's no requirement in the code that they continue to show us that it's working. There's really no way that even that we would know who approved it or in the property address theoretically because there's no real applications. So there's a lot of gaps right now in the way the code is structured. So the big changes with this proposed.
2:07:22 Code change. The amendment will reorganize and consolidate code sections to make them easier to understand for both staff and applicants. It will remove discrepancies. Examples of these discrepancies, which I haven't mentioned yet. So the parking adjustments. Nowhere in the code does it say that you can get a parking reduction through the adjustment process, yet reduction in parking is included in the adjustments table.
2:07:51 Same thing with references to uses versus buildings versus structures. Depending on where you look in the parking code, we sometimes reference structures, which doesn't make a lot of sense because we don't regulate parking based on structures. We regulate it based on uses. So depending on the size of the use, that's where the parking requirement comes from. The size of the structure itself really has nothing to do with
2:08:21 The amount of parking required. So cleaning up some of these discrepancies and making them consistent with existing code language, applying existing planning review and approval processes, specifically administrative permit and use permit process to parking reduction requests and changes or expansions of uses with non-conforming parking based on the size of the request. And I'll get into that a little bit more later.
2:08:47 Allowing both residential and non-residential uses to request parking reductions. Currently in the code, you can kind of read it either way. In some places it says that only commercial uses can request parking reductions. In other sections of the code, it allows for mixed use and residential projects to request parking reductions. So this is just clarifying. Expanding the toolbox available to applicants. So that just...
2:09:16 Basically means expanding kind of the number of measures that they can use in a TDM plan to justify parking reduction. Creating clear requirements require ongoing monitoring. So that's a really big one. Create a public process for larger reductions. So specifically anyone requesting a parking reduction over 25% in the future would be required to go through a use permit, which means there's a public notification process. There's a public hearing in front of the planning commission.
2:09:46 And then finally allowing staff to consider proximity to on-street or other public parking when evaluating parking reduction requests. Now that kind of comes directly from the downtown revitalization action plan. There is a section in there that encourages allowing on-street parking just to count for commercial business parking requirements. So we didn't want to go that far and just allow on-street parking to count.
2:10:14 Across the board, but this allows staff to consider on-street parking when they're considering parking reduction requests. So specific changes, and this is just kind of drilling down on what I just mentioned. So on 17.44030, number of parking spaces are required. It is improving consistency with parking requirements tables. It refers to the alternative parking provisions.
2:10:42 sections and addresses exceptions to parking standards related to state density bonus law. So that last one, state density bonus law also allows you to request a reduction in parking as part of the state density bonus. So the code change there is really just to clarify that people cannot double dip, so to speak, and that if you have been granted a parking reduction,
2:11:10 Through a state density bonus request, you cannot also come in and request a parking reduction through the town municipal code standards. So in sections 174430 and 17120 non-conforming parking standards, we're adding those standards to section 174440, which is the alternative parking provisions, correcting discrepancies in a line.
2:11:37 Review and approval process for changes or expansions of non-conforming uses with the process requirements for parking reductions. Again, I'll explain that in a bit more detail in a second. 17.440, alternative parking provisions. As I said, it would allow alternative parking provisions to apply to both residential and non-residential uses. It would clarify code requirements pertaining to state density bonus law. It would require approval of an administrative permit.
2:12:06 For parking reductions up to 25% and a use permit for reductions greater than 25%. So that means if someone asks for a parking reduction that is 25% or below, that would be a staff level administrative approval. And anything greater than that is a use permit with public hearing. And again, as a reminder, currently there is no limit and no process for parking reductions.
2:12:35 It would grant town staff the discretion to require a parking study and or a TDM plan as part of a parking reduction request. And it sets forth the standards for what we expect to be included in a parking study, the requirements that it be prepared by a qualified transportation engineer. So that also is an improvement right now. The requirements for kind of how people can justify a parking reduction are very loose.
2:13:01 It would incorporate shared parking standards into the reduction of parking standards. So right now, shared parking is kind of its own section separate from reduction of parking, but really a shared parking agreement. If you have a shared parking agreement between two parties, they're only necessary if one of the two parties is providing less than the required amount of parking. No one who is meeting municipal code parking requirements
2:13:29 Wants to go into a shared parking agreement because they have all the parking on site. So really when you're talking about shared parking agreements, you are always talking about a reduction of parking in at least one of the two parties who are involved in the agreement. So therefore we thought it would be a sense to move that into the reduction of parking standards. Finally, allowing town staff to consider the availability of on-street parking when reviewing a parking reduction request. And then in the transportation management section,
2:13:58 Clarifying the requirements for a TDM plan, allowing all applicants, so no longer differentiating based on number of employees, but allowing all applicants to have access to the same toolbox when proposing TDM measures, and also tying the reduction in demand to the size of the request. So as I mentioned before, currently the code has kind of a blanket requirement that you demonstrate a 20% reduction in demand.
2:14:24 We have rephrased that to basically say that you have to demonstrate a reduction in demand commensurate with the size of the reduction being requested. And then finally, as mentioned before, in the adjustments table, removing parking from the allowable adjustments. And really, that's not only does nowhere else in the code refer to adjustments as a process by which you can request a parking reduction, but
2:14:52 Adjustments really are kind of hardship based. So we have never seen a request for a parking adjustment. And we don't think that given the criteria for approval of adjustments that such a request could really be approved. So we just removed it and are keeping parking reductions in the parking code section with their own standards. So what this means,
2:15:20 Is that parking reductions and changes to non-conforming uses will have applications and associated fees where currently there are none. So that's an administrative permit for requests of up to 25% and a use permit for requests greater than 25%. A side note there is that we are exploring reduced fees for changes in non-conforming use with the same parking requirements. So basically that's if there is an existing business,
2:15:51 That does not meet municipal code parking requirements and a new use wants to replace that business that basically has the same parking requirements as the existing business, but it's just a new use. We would still want to document that just so we're keeping track of what use is in there that's not meeting parking requirements, but we wouldn't want to charge them the full administrative permit fee since they're not really changing anything other than use.
2:16:20 So we are hoping to be able to just provide reduced fees for applications like that. So parking reductions or change in non-conforming use requests will need to demonstrate proportionate production of demand. So that's kind of what I just went over. Transparency and accountability. So all requests will go through the same process and be held to the same standards. This will improve records keeping on the town end.
2:16:49 It will improve the ability of the public to comment and get involved, and it will ensure that larger requests go through the Planning Commission. It will provide opportunities for public review and input, where currently there are none. More options for a bigger toolbox for how to justify parking reduction requests. Improved town-wide parking management, and this will be largely improved by just improving the tracking of
2:17:19 Uses that are non-conforming as well as uses that have received parking requests and more opportunities for shared use of parking and creative solutions to parking issues. So in terms of public outreach, we began working on this in the summer of 2020. Once the initial draft was completed, there were two opportunities, well, I guess three now for public review and comment. On August 3rd, we held a PEDC Mobility Committee meeting.
2:17:51 During which I presented the proposed parking code update and responded to questions from committee members. Committee members expressed overall support for the proposed parking code update and there were no public comments. We also presented the proposed parking code update to the Chamber of Commerce at their power lunch meeting on September 22, 2020 and solicited feedback. There were no comments or questions from them. And then on January 13th, we had the PEDC public hearing and PEDC approved the proposed amendment.
2:18:19 The four to one vote and there were no public comments there. So I'll quickly go over the zoning code amendment findings. So the proposed amendment is internally consistent with all of the provisions of the general plan and any applicable specific or master plan. So it is consistent with the general plan vision statement of offering a variety of transportation options that emphasize connectivity, convenience, and alternatives to use of personal vehicles with a strong pedestrian emphasis. And then the other goal M14 and policy M14.
2:18:51 One, I read in the beginning, but they're both just about supporting alternative transportation and allowing for alternative parking when it can be demonstrated that parking demand can be reduced. There's a mobility principle to reduce demand and encourage more efficient use of the existing transportation system and mobility element management strategy to manage the demand on the transportation system, including streets and parking. The proposed amendment would not be detrimental to the public.
2:19:23 The proposed amendment is in compliance with the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act.
2:19:55 I won't read all five of those, but basically under Public Resources Code, Section 21083.3 and State CEQA Guidelines, Section 15183C, no additional EIR or other environmental analysis is required for this proposed amendment. Additional findings for zoning code amendments, the proposed amendment is internally consistent with other applicable sections of the zoning code.
2:20:22 So really this amendment is intended to correct minor errors, clarify existing standards, more clearly define application and review requirements, and increase flexibility within the parking sections of the code in accordance with existing goals, policies, and actions, including mobility on the general plan. Overall, the proposed amendment improves the usability of the existing alternative parking provisions, more clearly defining procedural requirements.
2:20:49 And therefore, increasing the Town's ability to ensure that parking reduction requests are consistent with all other applicable provisions of the zoning code. So this criterion is also met. So the staff recommendation is to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the ordinance making the required CEQA and municipal findings and approving zoning code amendment 20-001 as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission or as modified by the Town Council to answer any questions. I can't, I think you're muted, Mr. Mayor.
2:21:30 Sorry about that. So let's go to questions, starting with John, or comments. Thank you very much, Chandler. Thank you for this most thorough, most detailed, every T cross and I dotted presentation. Thank you very much for that. My concern with this, as we all know, we had a discussion and provided some direction to staff around mobility. And when I read...
2:21:59 The agenda item, the big thing that was missing for me was the connection, the relationship of these proposed amendments to policy. And until, unless this thing is on fire tonight, I would propose that we maybe put this off a little bit so we can like get our heads around the policy components of this so that we're not going to approve and adopt something that's going to come back and bite us later on.
2:22:29 I've got a bunch of, I didn't even know where to begin to start asking the questions because what was missing was how is this tying into the, you know, the walk, bike, ride, trail system, master plan, all those things we've been talking about. And I frankly didn't have the energy or the bandwidth to be able to figure out how to start making those connections. So my request would be that this is thorough, this is...
2:22:53 Very detailed, very good. But we put this off for a little bit so we can digest this in the context of some policy ideas that may be coming forward in the coming weeks or months. So that's it for me. Thank you. Thank you. John, Linda. I have no questions in regards to this. I would not disagree with what Councilmember Wentworth is saying. And I would defer to staff and to...
2:23:23 Move this forward as recommended. Thanks. Thank you. Sarah? Yeah, I got to piggyback on this is way over my digestibility level. I went through all this and Chandler, well done. I was like, this is very thorough. So I'm not opposed to John's suggestion. Thank you, Sarah. Kirk? I'm not opposed to John's suggestion, but I think it is a huge step in the right direction.
2:23:56 Thank you, Kirk. So I'm not particularly opposed to John's direction either, although pretty much what this does is clean up stuff we already have. My problem is that the Transportation Demand Management Program and all of the other programs out there trying to get people out of their cars, we used it in the North Village and we created a nightmare.
2:24:27 Because we have bus routes, we have all of this other stuff going up there. We are a drive market. The majority of cars in our town are driven here by tourists. If we don't provide the right type of parking for them, we are just going to create more problems as we go down the road. Reading this, I see a time when somebody develops another condominium project and says, look, I'm on the bus route.
2:24:57 I've got all of this stuff. I don't need all these parking spaces. And then when their guests drive up from Southern California, after they've bought their units, they find out there's no place for them to park. We have that at some of our condo projects now. So my problem isn't really with what we're doing here, because actually we're making it harder for some people to get reductions in parking by making a process. And I agree with that process. And Chandler, I agree with everybody else. You've done a great job here.
2:25:27 Don't take my comments negatively towards you. But I believe as a town, when it comes to our parking ordinances, residential on down, we have failed by being, trying to be in lockstep with the state who wants us to have reduced vehicle traffic in favor of walking and everything else. With the hills and the steepness and everybody driving here, that's a hard thing to accomplish.
2:25:54 So I think maybe the entire parking code needs to be looked at again, and what we require of people need to be looked at one more time. Years ago, one of the comments from one of our hired guns from out of town to teach us about these things that I have remembered forever is you have to remember a pedestrian is a driver who's found a parking spot.
2:26:25 Believe in that still today, and we don't design towards that. So that's what I'm going to say, and I'm going to go on and ask if there's any public comment on this item. No, there is not. Thank you. With that, then, I will close the public hearing and move us into deliberations. So if someone has a suggestion, Chandler, if I can get you to stop sharing your screen so I can see everybody again. Yeah, totally. Thank you.
2:27:02 There we go. All your little pretty faces are back. So I would bring this to somebody for a recommendation or a motion. So Mr. Mayor, I would move that we defer action on this item for date to be determined by staff based on the comments of the council and to bring it back for consideration and action when the time is deemed break.
2:27:30 I think staff would just request that you continue to sign to a date certain, so it doesn't need to be re-noticed, but we're happy to just continue it, but it would just require noticing again. Yeah, if we continue, this is Dan, if we continue that out to the March 17th date, that would give us, you know, a little less than a month to really kind of take a look at it, see if there's some follow-up with individuals, if there are particular issues that you need to have addressed, we can, should be able to do that. If not, we can always.
2:27:57 Bring it back to the public hearing process of that, and I assume we could continue it again if need be. Or we could move it to the first meeting of April as well. We could continue this, and we wouldn't have to re-notice it, correct? If you go to a date, certainly. Let's go to that. I would move that we move it to that first meeting in April. Dan, I'm not sure what the date is. Give me that date. April 7th. April 7th. Yeah.
2:28:26 Let's, I would move that we continue this item until April 7th. And Bill, please be sure that I hear those comments. Would you say about, you know, driving here? The question is really about once they get here, how do we move them around? That's part of a larger discussion. But my motion would be that we continue this item until April 7th. I have a motion. I'll second that. And I have a second. Any further deliberation? Seeing none, I will.
2:29:00 Call for the action, Jamie. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Aye. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes. Mayor Sauser? Yes. So this item is continued until April 7th. Thank you all. Great work, Chairman. Thank you very much. Thanks. So at this point, we've been at it for two and a half hours plus the closed session. I'm going to call about a seven or eight minute...
2:29:31 I don't have my clock on me. Time out. So at about 634, we will reconvene. Thank you. I'll be right with you. Yeah. Okay. It is now 634. And do I reconvene this meeting of the Town Council? Moving on to policy matters. Discussion, update, and possible action related to the declared COVID-19.
2:30:25 Public Health and Economic Emergency Status Management and Response. Dan. Yes, Mr. Mayor. We'll do a quick walk through a number of items related to COVID and address any questions the council may have. Also, I do want to note, I can't remember if I've done it formally at the past council meeting, but a little bit of transition in our emergency operations center with...
2:30:50 Chief Frank Freevault transitioning back into his day job, if you will, as the fire chief for the Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District. And then our paramedic chief for Mono County, Chris McCrassick, is stepping in as DOC director. Chris is on the call. You'll see his name up on the list of attendees now. So I'll give him a chance later if he has anything to add or introduce himself. He's been involved with the...
2:31:18 Emergency Response all along. He has been overseeing a lot of the support efforts and some additional duties also has assigned in there for the since the beginning of the pandemic. So it's nothing new for him to be stepping into this and also some good background in other related emergency level activities in the fire service over his career. Also,
2:31:45 No significant change at this point, but as you may be aware that Dr. Thomas Boo has not re-upped his agreement with Mono County, but has agreed to stay on through at least through the end of March and the first part of April. As helping through this pandemic, he is looking to restart his regular practice in April down at Northern Annual Hospital. He'll be setting a date and processing that as it gets closer.
2:32:14 But with that, as we continue to work through elements, we continue to see some case increases throughout Mono County with the, again, the majority of cases here in the town of Mammoth Lakes. As last checked, this may have went up today, but 943 positive cases in the county. This is kind of our trend line. The one good thing about this is that we look at those last several days, it looks to be flattening out. That's a key element.
2:32:41 That we will end up speaking to here shortly as we look at the tier system and some of the options as we look forward. One of the two elements that we deal with as we are in the purple tier looking to transition into a red tier is the number of cases per 100,000 population and also the positivity rate. And as we look to schools to open, it's a hard case number of 25 cases.
2:33:07 And over a five-day period being below that, which we are getting to from that perspective. Here you'll see that same thing, the positivity rate by week down there in the 6.6, 7.2 range the last couple of weeks. We do try to link these back in and tie these numbers to the state. Now and again, there will be some movement around from what's on our website to the state numbers. Emily in the Public Health Department does a great job of trying to work these together and making sure we're counting things correctly.
2:33:37 And in the same way, because they'll look at either a symptom start date, a actual test date, or the date we get a response back, all depending. We've also had cases that are reported as a Mono County case, and through some of our contact tracing, find out later that they actually do not live in Mono County. And so then that's an adjustment that gets made to their place of residence. As I mentioned,
2:34:04 Under the blueprint for a safer economy, the town is currently in that purple tier, and so as we look at this data over the last couple of weeks, last three weeks, it comes out of the state. This is updated every Tuesday about noon, and it looks backwards. It's a one-week lag time, and so you'll see the dates here, the three we're looking at here of week ending 2-6, 1-31, and 1-23, and so as we...
2:34:33 Worked through that, the case rate per 100,000. We were at 29.7 back in January 23rd. It dropped to 17.4 and are now the most recent data showing us at 20.5. Testing positivity rate, 9.1, 6.6, and 7.2. The positivity rate is really a positive statement for us as we are below the 8% number.
2:35:00 Which is we need to be at that level for two consecutive weeks of two of the metrics to move into a red tier, allowing for greater opening of the community, primarily the key industries would be our restaurants getting back to indoor dining. However, the second metric, which is the case rate per 100,000, we would need to be back at the seven. You'll look at the number in the chart there showing between four to seven. So we'd have to be at a minimum of seven cases on a weekly.
2:35:29 There are basically one per day or seven for the week as we work through that. And we do have to be within that state status for two consecutive weeks. We went into the purple till here January 25th, which means February 15th would be a three week minimum timeframe would be in that purple tier. And again, needing two consecutive weeks in the red data to be able to move out of the purple tier. We are currently not there. There's been some discussions.
2:35:56 Back and forth on being at the red tier level. And actually, we have not met that minimum testing case rate per 100,000 yet to be able to move into that red tier. So we are still sitting in the purple tier. Then as I noted earlier, with being less than 25 cases, the school district is looking to be able to open and they have a process they're looking at with a couple of.
2:36:22 Lower grades starting and then open up to K-6, I believe the district's looking at K-5 through their elementary school, ultimately in a slower opening process. The other really big push has been on the vaccine side. Again, this may have been updated since we put the slide together, but we've received 8,365 doses of vaccine, and you can see on the slide there we've issued.
2:36:49 4,595 first doses, 1,449 second doses. And this is updated a couple times a week, so this will lag a little bit behind in some of the hard numbers. But I think the real key issue for us is that ability, as you see here, as we start to work to get up to that 4,000, 4,500, up to 5,000 maybe people vaccinated. If we can get up to about an 8,000, give or take vaccination of our population base.
2:37:18 That would be pushing us 70% or so, between 70 to 80% of the adults in our community being vaccinated. That would be a great move in terms of helping to kind of bulletproof the community, if you will, in some level of that spread of COVID as we have people vaccinated accordingly, both providing protection for them and hopefully limiting the amount of spread that we would see within our community.
2:37:42 A lot of information on this, a lot of questions related to this. There's a lot of information on the website. If there's particular questions, we'll address those at the end related to some of the vaccination processes and working through the various clinics.
2:37:55 I believe, you know, everybody I've spoken to who have gone through the clinic or been in and looked at it has been very impressed with the process. It runs very smooth. People are treated well. There's good information throughout the process, getting them in, getting them processed through, get the vaccination, that short wait time to make sure there's no reactions, and then being able to continue to move that through. So very, very pleased with the public health staff, the volunteers.
2:38:21 A number of people involved in that clinic works. That's been a great, great asset here in Mono County. One of the elements there is we are working through the whole vaccination side of it, proof of eligibility. We've had some issues on this one come up, and so now it's got to be a resident of Mono County. There's a lot of different ways you can prove that.
2:38:43 Or that they're actually an employee working in a required industry that allows them to be vaccinated, such as our food hospitality type workers in the food industry, restaurants, et cetera. And so there's a lot of elements to go through that. We've been working through that overall pretty well received. I think people understand it once it's explained if somebody's coming in looking to get a vaccine in Mono County faster than they can in some other places in the state. One is
2:39:13 We're taking it serious. We work through it. There's a lot of different questions that come up through this process. And it's not perfect, but definitely I think we've had a substantial improvement for the last few weeks and really working through a lot of that area. This kind of tells you where we're at in that whole vaccination process, still in a phase 1B and the different groupings in there that can be vaccinated. So we're working through that. We're getting most of the way through.
2:39:42 Now again, you'll find at the end of a vaccine clinic, if people who had reservations do not show up, the staff there will go through a phone tree, try to get next round of people who were scheduled, can they come in early, are they available, as in various listings that we do have, and can we bring them into the clinic at an earlier timeframe, and that's been very effective to make sure that...
2:40:08 No vaccine doses are left unused at the end of a clinic. It's a very critical element, very high priority not to waste any of the vaccines here in Monroe County. So the other shift and change in this, there has been a shift in the tiering looking at 55 years and older versus 65. And then with the qualification that there needs to be underlying medical conditions, there's a whole list of those. I think we brought this up in the past.
2:40:36 But working through this type of a list, it's added one more level of review and process that we are dealing with as we work through the vaccination process. You can go on and pre-register yourself. We encourage people to do that. There will be some shifting in that registration process. The state is changing its primary...
2:41:02 Resource or the technology shifting from a prep mod to a my turn. There'll be more information on that coming out. I believe that starts middle of March. And so there will be some change that way. But if you've already pre-registered, you get in and do that. And public health is transferring people from one type of registration to the other. So it should not impact individuals going on to pre-register for vaccination. So this is my turn that you'll see coming up.
2:41:31 It's coming forward. They're trying to get the pilot by the end of the month. That sounds like March 14th, I believe, is the start date for the new system. So getting vaccinated is important. Still a lot of questions out there for folks in terms of the safety of it, the effectiveness of the vaccinations. Right here, you'll see a lot of that data. You know, the current ones that we're utilizing here between the Moderna and the Pfizer have that 94% plus.
2:42:00 Effectiveness in preventing illness definitely often protects you from getting as ill or sick if you do catch the virus, but also reduces some of the transmission component as well, a bunch of different elements that way. So it's working through that. Once you are vaccinated, the guidelines and stuff is still to continue to wear a face covering or a mask. A number of reasons for that. One is just
2:42:30 Understanding how other people see it and concerns there. Also, because they're not 100% effective, they still provide protection from people from catching the disease and wearing a mask. So we're not relaxing on those safety measures at this point in time. So a lot of local information out there. We're dealing with it daily as we work through all the different resources here. We're continuing to work through elements. And as I mentioned earlier, as we looked at various
2:43:00 Tears where we're at and what we're doing. And earlier this evening, we spoke to some of the enforcement efforts regarding local ordinances or local restrictions in place. Our big one is really looking at our lodging industry. We currently have a 70% occupancy limit with a 24-hour gap between stays. That is something that we're reviewing weekly as we look at the various
2:43:28 Numbers we're seeing now in the state as we look at that moving toward that red tier level. We want to make sure there's a consistent movement downward in terms of cases and our positivity rate. We are seeing some individuals who are coming into the community through contact tracing who, as I mentioned earlier, we find out that they actually have an address outside of the community. And I know we've had a couple of incidents where people have been transported to the hospital.
2:43:57 We are seeing some variant strains hitting California. And again, some level limit there, we believe it's still a good public health.
2:44:24 And so as soon as I think there's that concurrence between the town and our public health officials that that shift is
2:44:52 Justified to lift that lodging water, we'd begin to do so. But we do want to take it kind of easy right now. We have no idea the impact, if any, that we'll see from the Super Bowl weekend and the activities of that weekend. Probably less so, but also with the President's holiday that we just went through as people are doing different elements, a little more travel activity. And we want to make sure that we're doing everything we can to really keep our community safe first, but also...
2:45:21 Looking at the economic health of our community from the lodging component, I think it's, at least it's stable with the current numbers that we've been able to have and see out there and some of the folks in the call may be able to speak to that in more detail. But also, really that other push is getting our numbers down on our own to the extent that we can get restaurants open again would be a huge benefit to the community. Secondly on that is a continued discussion now again with state officials and looking at our...
2:45:49 At our level, but there's been other discussions from the small county group working through CSAC on looking at a different number, maybe a hard number there, a different metric to be able to move into that red tier, again, meeting the safety protocols accordingly. That is a real concern as we get through that. And of course, as I mentioned, the other push is getting our schools open, getting kids back in seat learning.
2:46:17 And again, that transition that that's going to take in time. Pop through the slide there. We do have a community conversation tomorrow evening. Encourage people to dial into that. They can ask questions. We can spend more time on some of these items as well. And that is a bilingual process in terms of people listening in being able to ask questions.
2:46:39 With that, I'd like to, I'm going to ask Chris McCrassick, I don't know if you've all met him or not, but he can introduce himself briefly and feel free to add anything, Chris, in terms of where we're at in some of the support programs or other elements that I may have missed in the presentation here and then turn it back to council in the community for comment or questions. All right. Thank you, Dan. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, thank you for having me this evening. You know, I just want to...
2:47:09 Really thank Chief Freeval for his leadership for the past eight months or more and just his attention to detail and just the awesome job he did. And I just hope that I can step up and do half of the work that he did. He made the transition very easy. So I look forward to moving forward. You know, we're doing an outstanding job with getting the vaccination out.
2:47:39 You know, still are, or, you know, we're number one in the state for vaccinations. So that group is just doing an outstanding job in public health. We're also, you know, with testing, trying to get, you know, maintain a good testing regimen so that we're showing that we're making improvements in Mono County and in the town of Mammoth Lakes. That's, you know, that's our priority. You know, I see a light at the end of the tunnel.
2:48:09 I hope it's a light at the end of the tunnel and not a train, but I think it is, and I think we're doing very good. So everybody has really pulled together and done an outstanding job. We're also doing community support. We're taking care of individuals that need to quarantine at Sierra Nevada Resort. Fortunately, there's no one in there right now, which is great. We're seeing those numbers go down.
2:48:38 So, you know, all of the statistics and everything here are definitely going in the right direction. So I know we're doing the right thing out there. We'll continue to support the community with PPE distribution, providing the tools they need to stay safe so we can stay open and continue, depending on what the state decides, we can continue in that direction.
2:49:07 Continue to open up more in the future. So, you know, that's going to be my priority moving forward, working with Unified Command, and that's really our goal. So, thank you very much. Thank you, Chris. Dan, anything else you wanted to tell us? I can't hear you. That's where we're at at this point in time. Kind of a quick overview of things we're working on. Not a lot of substantial changes there. I think the key issue for us is...
2:49:47 As Chris McCrassick noted there is really how do we manage this the best we can to make sure that we can transition into hopefully a red tier sooner than later and be able to open up more of our businesses there. I know John Morris from the lodging industry is on the call and would like to speak in the lodging.
2:50:08 Issues, and again, that request that we look to open lodging up as soon as possible to reduce some of the restrictions there as we look to the future as well. So, but that's all unless there's a question for me in particular. I'd be glad to address anything that you have. Thank you, Dan. John, any questions or comments? I think staying the course at this point is good. We're doing well, but we're not out of this thing.
2:50:39 One thing I would recommend, the current administration puts on their COVID updates, and they're actually really informative. I watched a bunch of one of them this morning. Dr. Fauci gave a great little summary and presentation on the reality of getting vaccinated and whether or not you can spread the virus. It was super interesting, the data and the statistics we're putting out would be of interest to every American, certainly of interest to all of us.
2:51:08 Actually really grateful that the current administration is putting that level of information on it. I would encourage folks to watch it. It's worth watching. But that's it. Thank you. Thank you, John. Lynda? Just a quick comment is that, you know, we've been doing huge vaccination clinics, 700 people, 800 people. Those were most recent ones, of course, were seven, I'm sorry, second injections, second vaccines. So once we've finished that kind of second vaccine,
2:51:38 Then our clinics will grow smaller because we will have used most of our existing doses. So then what we're getting from the state, I think in the last two weeks, we got 200 and then maybe 300. So we will then go back in and try to begin on first doses again and not really being assured anymore from the state that you're going to get the second. So you're going to have to kind of allocate those numbers to both first and second. So we're going to see what the bottom line is we're going to see smaller clinics.
2:52:07 So we will not see the rapid deployment that we had been seeing in the first couple, you know, like we started the end of December. So anyway, so it's going to change a little bit. It'll slow down. We'll get further down into the tiers. We'll get to the point where we're able to vaccinate, you know, much younger ages. And they said today that by the end of, what did they say? Was it July? That everyone who wants a vaccine will be able to get one. I hope that we're ahead of that curve.
2:52:35 And that Mono County will reach the point where anyone in Mono County who wants to get a vaccine will have been able to get it before then. So that's the goal. And every clinic is like, it feels like a party for two reasons. You're doing good work and it feels good to get people protected. And people are so not used to seeing each other that seeing each other is just a big excitement. People gathered in that 15 minute waiting area.
2:52:59 I'll pull their chairs around and circle around and just chat away because they're, you know, I haven't seen anybody for a long time and I'm in a clinic so I get to talk. So all in all, it's been a great experience and Chris is going to do an exceptional job as the EOC commander and congratulations, Chris. I have all the faith in you. So that's all I got. Thanks. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. Sarah? No, no, thank you. Thanks, Chris, for taking this on and Linda, thanks for sharing that. That was a warm fuzzy for sure.
2:53:31 Kirk. Unmuted, Kirk. You unmuted and then you remuted, Kirk. Okay, sorry. There you go. Thank you, Linda. Thank you, Chris. I've gotten both of my shots. I appreciate everything that's been done and just keep up the good work. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. We have been Mono County with Linda's help.
2:54:07 Has been doing an incredible job getting everybody vaccinated. I couldn't be more proud of our Mono County Health Department for the job they've done. Do we have any public comments, Jamie? Yes. John Morris, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Thank you, Jamie. Good evening, Mayor Sauser, County Councilmembers and Town Staff. John Morris, Chairman of the Lodging Association in Town.
2:54:37 I just wanted to follow up regarding the letter that was sent out via the chamber regarding from the Lodging Association regarding the occupancy percentage restriction of 70% that's currently in force. And I just want to be really clear about it. What the Lodging Association is asking for is not to have the 24-hour gap between stays removed.
2:54:59 Only to have the 70% restriction removed. And that is important because you have to understand our business. Not everybody arrives. I know there's a big concern about weekend occupancy. Not everybody arrives on Thursday and leaves Monday or Friday and leave Sunday. A lot of people come in on Saturdays. A lot of people come in on Sundays. And so with that 24 hour gap, it is virtually impossible for a lodging entity to achieve more than about.
2:55:27 Close to 80% occupancy at any given time. Just the nature of the way our businesses work. Now you may say, well, what's the difference? 70%, 80%. Well,
2:55:37 There's a big difference. This time of the year, as you all know, is the time of year where our businesses try to make a little extra money and sock it away for the lean times that come ahead. We still have slow periods in April, May, early June, and in the fall. And so the wintertime is when we are profitable and we need to try to be as profitable as possible so we can keep all of our employees and keep our businesses running through the lean times.
2:56:04 It does make a big difference. If we can eke out another five or six or seven rentals every week, that will make a difference. It also will make a difference for our restaurants. I know there was a lot of concern about this last weekend as to how we were going to handle President's Holiday without, you know, seated indoor dining. I was around town. I went to Vons. I went to grocery outlet. It was fine. Everybody did a great job. It was busy, but it was not nuts. There were...
2:56:32 No fights that I know of anywhere. Everything seemed to be under control, which is great. So I think we can, you know, I really feel confident that we've been open for three or four weeks now. Following the statistics very carefully myself, I really have not seen any major increase in cases. We seem to be hovering around the low 20-ish mark per week, which is way better than we've been.
2:56:59 So that does not seem to have spiked due to having more folks in town. And the last thing I'll say here is we only have about six weeks left in winter of good demand. We will slow down after Easter is the 4th of April. So we will slow down after Easter, probably by mid-April, we'll be back to fairly slow again for a couple of months.
2:57:23 So the clock is ticking for us, for everybody in town to try to make just a little bit more, not trying to be greedy, just being realistic about where we're going to be in the spring, you know, with less demand. So I appreciate, Dan, your comments. I appreciate that you guys are looking at this on a regular basis. I know we spoke when we first reopened.
2:57:44 That we would, you know, walk or crawl before we walked. And I think we're walking. I think now we can at least jog. So whatever you folks can do. I know this is a county and town order and not a state order. I'm referring to our occupancy restrictions. So we do have the power within our county to change that.
2:58:05 So please continue to look at it. If I know that the governor said today or yesterday, I can't remember what day it was, that some things are going to be opening up potentially next week a little bit more. So things are moving in the right direction. We don't have a whole lot of...
2:58:20 A busy time left, so we'd like to, you know, be able to open up that lodging restriction or just get rid of the 70%, keep the 24-hour gap there. That will naturally keep things at a reasonable amount and will not overrun the town on weekends. I just want to reiterate it does not mean if we don't have that 70%.
2:58:44 Restriction there. It does not mean that we're going to see 100% occupancy every weekend. That is just not going to happen because that gap prevents that from happening. So with that, I appreciate you letting me speak tonight. And whatever you might need, any information from the Lodging Association, any data or whatever, we're glad to provide that to you. And let's please get this restriction lifted as soon as we can. Thank you all for letting me speak tonight. I appreciate it.
2:59:15 Thank you, John. Jamie, do we have any further public comments? No, we do not. Okay, thank you. And thank you, Dan. So we will now move on to the second quarter fiscal year 2021 budget review. Rob? Yes, thank you, Mayor. I'm going to share my screen just a moment. Okay. So, yeah, so we're doing a budget presentation tonight, the second quarter. This is part of our...
2:59:49 Typical annual budget review process. I was going to get up in our department head presentations in the beginning of the meeting and tell folks that I'm very excited about getting ready to start the process for 21-22 budget. That will actually begin at the next council meeting and run through this early part of June, or we should adopt. But this normal process is where we review our quarter updates.
3:00:17 And this was actually the second quarter, not the fourth quarter update, as indicated on the slide. Hold these. There we go. So I don't have any recommendations tonight for transient occupancy tax, but I do want to talk about that because that's one of our most significant elements. If you remember at the beginning of the fiscal year, we had gone through several different iterations of analysis and determined really how we were going to approach
3:00:49 Budgeting this for the year. We landed on sort of a middle-of-the-road approach as far as conserving as much expenditures as we could and then just kind of laying out how we expected the pandemic to impact us for the year and where we thought we would be most impacted. So if you remember in that first set of analysis, we had trigger points where we were reviewing performance to date.
3:01:19 I'm glad to say that we have exceeded each one of those trigger points by a wide margin, and so we haven't had any natural requirements to trigger a reduction in expenditures, but as you'll see in a little bit, we have implemented some of that. The reason that we have is December itself, we sort of thought that our impact of the pandemic would start to migrate out of
3:01:49 You know, the deepest impacts by the wintertime. Maybe that was a little bit hopeful thinking, wishful thinking. But in this particular scenario, you know, December really undercut the expectations that we have from the budget perspective. So that's why we made that adjustment. But this presentation here, we landed on 11.2 million for the total DOT budget. The distribution that you see on the budget is based upon how we typically
3:02:18 Receive those funds across the year. And that's based on a three-year average. And so we just distribute that out there just to kind of get a sense of how we're doing on that. The actual column right in the middle of the page shows you the performance of each of those months. July and August, there was a tremendous amount of pent-up demand for people to be able to travel after the restrictions that were released or relieved a little bit on June 19th.
3:02:47 And so we saw tremendous activity within town July and August. And both of those numbers did set records for those particular months. And so we really enjoyed a strong response. And we got ahead of our game there by about $1.6 million easily. So July and August were sort of saved your months. In September through October, we had the smoke impacts from Creek Fire.
3:03:14 And that definitely, as well as the forest closure associated with that, that was a really strong impact. But what we were blessed with is that particular time of year is really our softest time of year. So the fact that September and October were softer, it didn't hurt as bad as we would have seen if it were a higher productive year, our month of the year. November then comes rolling in with by far our highest November.
3:03:44 By at least 200,000. And that, again, is a result of pens of demand and people not really being able to visit. December started off with, I think it was the 7th of December is when we had the regional stay at home order put in place and really locked down on lodging and essentially were only for essential workers. And that resulted in, you know, by far the worst December that I've seen and I think that we endured as a town.
3:04:12 But even as a smaller budget, that $1.6 million being a fairly small budget, typically December is somewhere in the $2.7 to $2.8 million range. We achieve only $279,000. So really sort of sobering results, but not unexpected based on the activity. We only have collected December so far, through December so far. January will come in here in a couple of days.
3:04:41 I do expect January to be a little bit stronger. January in the last couple of years has been a $3 million month, but I do anticipate it will come in somewhere around $824,000. That's taking into consideration the caps and the periods of time in which the operation was shut down, and so that's, I think, a pretty good number. The February...
3:05:06 March, April, May. Those are also conservative estimates, those numbers being down significantly from the traditional time period. With the exception of June, June I'm giving a little bit of a bump to. That's pretty much what we achieve on the highest level within June on a typical basis, about a million fifty. And I'm giving that based upon the results of July, August, and November when
3:05:34 Some of the restrictions were lifted and people felt more free to travel, and so they were able to get out. With those estimates and our actuals that have been received so far, I do anticipate TOT will come in somewhere around $12.8 million, so exceeding our budget by around $1.6 million. So I want to kind of put this out there, again, making no recommendations for an increase within transient occupancy tax.
3:06:04 Just sort of talking through the methodology, talking through the actuals in that process. So due to the significance of this one, I'll pause and see if there's any questions at this point. Any questions for Rob? Just speak up. Rob, I had one question. The figures that the budget distribution numbers, were those the numbers that we did at budget time or have any of those been revised from what was?
3:06:36 Put forward at the beginning of budget, July 1. They have not been revised. Those are the budgets that we adopted. Okay, that's what I thought. Thank you. That's all I have. Any further questions from anyone? Hearing none, Rob, I will move forward. Yeah, thank you. We do review in the second quarter. Typically, there's not a lot to adjust. Usually, based upon the conservative nature of our TOT,
3:07:09 There may be sometimes some TOT to realize, as we may have had a stronger year this year, that not being the case. But we do review in detail general fund gas tax and airport operations as our primary elements for this particular quarter. And we did have a few of the revenue items within general fund that I do think is notable for adjustment. As you may not remember from our budget process,
3:07:38 We thought property tax was really going to be fairly consistent with what we'd seen in prior years and not necessarily impacted by the pandemic in year one. What we really didn't anticipate was the exodus that we saw or the desire for people to move to our community or out to mountainous communities or away from general high population areas and still being able to conduct work from home has been sort of well established.
3:08:07 And so we had a very, very strong real estate market right now. In fact, the inventory on the market is at a historic low. But that just means a lot of transactions have occurred and they're high-value transactions. So the parcel documentary transfer tax, which is a main part of real estate associated with sales transactions, is a lot stronger than anticipated. So that $100,000 that I'm recommending, it's still...
3:08:33 There's still some money to be realized in that, which I will come back in ultimate quarters and do so. But real estate, I think, is strong. Property tax will be strong for the year. So franchise fees for solid waste, there was a 2% increase in fact of October that bumped that number up a little bit. Building activity, the building department has been very busy and that activity is strong. So again, up a little bit higher than anticipated.
3:09:01 The rental facilities and the recreation program fees, both of those are impacted by direct results of COVID, the fact that we can't have gatherings, and the fact that our programs for either youth or adults are impacted by the ability to have them during this time. So really kind of cutting those down. I did make just a first pass on those elements, but we'll take a look at them again each quarter and take a look. $160,000 state grant.
3:09:30 Miscellaneous, that's a SB2 grant for community development, and that's some activity that was performed last year. This is typical with grants, it's behind the activity and across fiscal year, so revenue was received in this fiscal year. And then interest on investments, we don't really give a lot to that. I will say that I'm on the Treasury Advisory Committee for the county, and those, the interest rates,
3:09:58 That we're receiving have just plummeted. We're down in small basis point discussion on what we're receiving. So we really don't give that a huge sort of revenue expectation annually. And while we don't, we did have a pretty strong performance at the beginning of the year. So head up that a little bit. General fund revenue adjustments, $225,000. It's pretty modest for this time of year.
3:10:25 Really not a lot of expenditures to speak of as well. For general funds, as I spent earlier, Dan kind of called us all open and said we need to really restrict our expenditures down to what's critical in our budget and make sure that we're not doing anything we don't necessarily have to do.
3:10:48 And so that's really how we're going to probably roll from now until the end of the fiscal year, depending upon how the revenue rolls in for the next couple of months. But there wasn't a lot of savings associated with that because there are some additional expenditures to talk about. So I did go another pass through in training and conferences. We've not allowed any out-of-town training to occur, so that's significantly reduced those elements.
3:11:15 A lot of areas within a lot of departments in here where they had some budget remaining, I kind of removed a higher portion of that and to give us a little bit of savings. We had some offsets like we had with the closures of the restaurants and things like that during the heights of the COVID impact, we really didn't have restaurant facilities around town. So we had to put quarter potties around town for people to be able to utilize. And that was additional expenditures.
3:11:43 I also have that lodging order enforcement support, both overtime as well as the temporary wages for the part-time employee that I have to do for host compliance, had a contract increase this year. And looking at the police services and wildlife management, that's just an offset. We're actually performing those functions within the police salary now, so that we're moving those dollars out of wildlife management into police salaries.
3:12:13 The fireworks display and planning temporary wages. Those are just two items that were necessarily missed during the budget process. We didn't anticipate the payment for the fireworks being this year for next year's activity and missed the planning commission stipend. But in the final item, the building contract services, we hired an inspector as a hybrid position between
3:12:42 The engineering and building, and that's produced a better result in our inspection process and fewer, less need for outside contracts to come and perform those services. So we expect some pretty good savings in that one. All told, we only saved $1,500, but we did cover some of our shortfalls in other areas. But general funding in total is up $226,500.
3:13:12 Gas tax just had a small element, and that is not on the slides here, but it is in the staff report. The staff report does contain more detail to provide information. The main item was the administration of the snow pit. That's an additional $200,000 that I did not capture in the original budget. We had another line item that appeared to be that, but it was snow removal from Main Street. So correcting a couple of my mistakes in this process, but that's how.
3:13:42 This process works. Revenue for the airport. That's one of the areas, as you remember, the FAA CARES Act that would receive the $1.096 million that would cover expenditures from January 20th, 2020 through the four years, essentially, or until spent. That was really a benefit for us in covering airport expenditures where the general fund would typically put revenue in there.
3:14:11 But the airport costs more to run than just what is contributed by the general fund or taken care of by that CARES Act. It requires the operations of the airport to produce revenue. And without commercial flights, which this year we will have had no commercial flights for the entire fiscal year, there are a number of items that just are not going to come in as far as revenue. Some of them directly depend upon.
3:14:40 Commercial flights and payments by those vendors or just general like parking and taxi services and those items. So in total, the operations revenue is reduced to $235,000 and the capital reduction is $75,000. That's in that first line item, which is passenger facility fees, which are restricted solely for capital projects.
3:15:08 We definitely have a shortfall here. Thankfully, we do have, I believe, enough CARES Act funds to carry us through this fiscal year and some positive things on the horizon. We'll let Grady talk about those when it's appropriate. But we think that for now, as far as airport operations, we'd be able to fund that through the end of the fiscal year without any problems.
3:15:30 But just wanted to kind of note, recognize that the lack of commercial service does have a significant impact on our airport operations. And so that's being realized here in the second quarter. There are really no other items or areas that I really need to update you on this second quarter. Like I said, typically it's a light one and this one is no different. So happy to field any questions.
3:16:01 Questions or comments? Rob, thank you. I have a couple things that we need to be looking at. The reality of what's happening in the real estate market and the effects that that's having on housing, we need to start, we need to figure out a way to start expecting data out of all that. You know, what is, if these transactions are happening,
3:16:28 How is that affecting the rental market? How is that affecting opportunities for housing for residents in this community? And I'm not sure, Dan, exactly how we do that between MLH and ourselves, but we need to start, we need facts and data in front of us that's going to help us make some decisions on this stuff, because this is an entirely significant change. The other thing is looking at air service, both at SCOG and LTC, we're getting updates on what's happening in Bishop.
3:16:58 And I'm hoping we can start getting a little proactive about what the transitions could look like for next year. If we stay on track with what the administration is saying, estimates that everybody is going to be vaccinated by the end of the summer, you know, some, you know, normalcy, that doesn't even mean anything anymore. But heading into next winter, I would anticipate the air service and those kinds of things are going to be, you know, full on. It may be happening at a bishop.
3:17:26 But it would be helpful to start hearing some anticipating costs or things associated with that transition. So those are the two big things for me. I think everything else is we'll just kind of see what happens. But housing, the effect of this hyperinflated real estate market on housing for our residents and the airport transition. So thanks again. Once again, thank you very much for making that clear and easy to understand and comprehend. Thank you, John. Linda.
3:17:52 Yes, thank you, Mayor Sauser. Rob, the only positive thing that I can say is that I hope that we'll see a bump in our property taxes going into the next fiscal year at least. There's a lot of new stock coming online and a lot of the re-evaluations due to sale I think might serve us well. So I know you didn't take a guess at that right now, but I'm hoping that that's going to be positive also. Thank you, Linda. Sarah.
3:18:25 No questions. Thank you so much, Rob. Kirk? Evidently that was no comment, but yeah, no questions. Thank you, Rob. Thank you. Rob, if I would have seen your PowerPoint at the end of your presentation, maybe I wouldn't have read through that whole report, but I did. Thank you very well done. There is a lot of information in there. You're welcome. Bill, I'd like to add something that I forgot to give during the presentation, just a minor update. Go ahead.
3:19:02 You know, as we've gone through this COVID impacts and our responses, the town has provided a lot of additional funds to support either businesses or community support funds for rental assistance and so forth. Those were done out of general fund reserves or tourism reserves or housing reserves. Those did not actually impact our
3:19:30 Reserves for Economic Uncertainty, our Operating Reserve, or our Contingency, or our Debt Service Reserve. So those remain fully intact, and that's around $6 million, $6.5 million. And that's significant, because that's not going to, we don't anticipate tapping that this year, which means our main elements of defense against
3:19:58 Economic downturn are still fully intact. So I want folks to kind of understand that. I'm sorry I missed that in the general presentation. Thank you, Rob. That is important. Do we have any public comment on this item, Jamie? No, we do not. Thank you very much. Okay. Make my mark so I know what I've done. In that case, let's move on to item number 12.
3:20:33 Construction Contract for the Community Recreation Center, CRC. Dan, you're going to kick us off on this one? Hey, Bill, on the last item, we do have a resolution for approval there. Okay, yes. My bad, I was looking at it as a report. So, Council, we do have a motion for the last item. Staff recommends the Town Council receive a second quarter budget update for fiscal year 2021 and adopt the resolution amending...
3:21:03 Physical year 2021 budget is recommended on attachment A. I will make that motion. I'll second. Motion from me. A second from Linda. Any further deliberation? Jamie? Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Sorry. Sorry. Red. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Aye. Mayor Pro Temp-Salcido? Yes. Did I lose Jamie or am I just not hearing? I said Mayor Salzer. Yeah.
3:21:45 Didn't hear it, Jamie. Sorry. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Now we will move on to the acceptance of the CRC or construction contract for the CRC. Dan. Yeah. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. This is going to be a tag team between Haislip Hayes and Stu and myself kind of walking through a number of the items here as we look at the potential.
3:22:14 Structure for the Community Recreation Center for Council Consideration. So I'm going to have Hayes kind of pull up a PowerPoint we'll be walking through, but I think just, you know, you're all familiar with the kind of the background. This has been in the works for several years now and stuff, and I think we're at a point to where either we move forward with the project or, frankly, we don't and just, you know, set it aside, let somebody else deal with it, the next generation, if you will, so to speak.
3:22:43 I think we really do just need to work back through it. There's been a lot of work, a lot of effort put to bring a project forward. And so we'll work through and go from there and hopefully we can address questions, counsel from the community as we look at this project potentially moving forward. So with that, I'm going to turn to Hayes to do a brief introduction and we'll kind of tag team through it. Thank you. Thanks, Dan.
3:23:08 Like Bill said, Mayor said, we're here for the award of the construction contract for the Community Recreation Center. This evening, we're going to go over the staff recommendation, the bid results, a little bit of project history as well, project scope and mobility, some programming, and the costs and funding. And the recommendation before tonight, and I will paraphrase, it's to approve the plans and specifications for the project.
3:23:36 Award the contract to the lowest responsive bidder, Hamel Contracting, for $8,884,008, waive any minor irregularities. Authorize the Public Works Director to execute the construction contract and accept the project. Authorize the Public Works Director to review approved minor revisions to complete the project within the established budget.
3:23:58 Authorize the Public Works Director to purchase defined owner-provided items such as the sprung structure and the chiller package, dashboard, scoreboard, and other appurtenances. And authorize the town manager to make any necessary budget adjustments, including the transfer of $1.5 million from Measure U. We'll fund 217 reserves and $315,640 from transit-related reserves to the project count, which is from $300. In preparing for this meeting,
3:24:28 As reminded by Stu that we have been working on this project for almost seven years. It's been seven years since we received town council directive to advance this project, to select the site, and to begin working on the construction plans. And it has been a lot of work over many years. And Dan is going to take a little bit deeper dive into that history. So take it away, Dan.
3:24:52 Thank you. Yeah, I did want to just touch base on kind of where we were at and how we got to the proposed project. Again, a one-slide review of this that covers several years of work. But one of the questions that has come back up is looking at the selection of Mammoth Creek Park and the new build component. And really, the primary comparison on that, while a number of sites were looked at, the one element on that was looking at the
3:25:20 Staying in the current location is one of, it was probably the most reviewed elements. I just kind of walked through a couple of different elements there as we looked at those two options of the current site under lease with the Mammoth Unified School District and the Mammoth Creek Park site as currently recommended. One of the key elements we spent a fair amount of time over the ownership of the land and full control of our facilities versus the lease structure.
3:25:48 As you look at a facility here that will have a several generation life to it in terms of 50, 60 years versus a lease that would be on an extension potential, but on like a 20 year, 10 year, 20 year type agreements going forward and additional costs there. And I think the direction on that was really to have control over the land and the facility versus come through a third party lease agreement.
3:26:15 The expanded recreational programming was a key element, and we'll talk more about this, mainly really adding the summer program elements and really to serve as a hub for activities. We know we can increase a lot of our camps that we do if we have the location structured right. Currently, a lot of those programs sell out very quickly. We turn a lot of people away from those. And being able to expand that program, we believe a set facility would allow us to do that.
3:26:42 The other side of that was kind of a lack of community space, indoor, outdoor. And then, again, limited activity areas within the current site, somewhat restricted with the shared parking with the library and other activities there that go on, you know, in that joint area. The winter activities, again, are limited just due to, like, I think we have another week or two, February 28th or so will be the last day of the ice rink being open, for example, just due to weather changes.
3:27:12 But also we lost some days every year based on snowstorms and the activities. And we always have that tradeoff on enjoying outdoor skating versus the weather that tends to limit some of our outdoor skating capabilities. And then really looking at the idea of a new larger facility versus a rebuild. We did take a real look at the current site in terms of the buildings that are there. One of them definitely needs to be replaced. The other one would be replaced shortly. We were looking at
3:27:42 The support facilities there being needed in a chiller replacement, both from age and also the type of frion is used in that particular chiller is quickly being eliminated as a legal refrigerant, so it would have to go through a change of process to be able to continue to use that piece of equipment. We do have concrete cracking and some chipping and different elements going on there in terms of work.
3:28:06 The piping is in need of an upgrade. There's a couple of areas of just how the piping works underneath the slab in terms of keeping it frozen, depending on the structure that you'd put over the top and whether or not it would still be able to maintain the same level of freezing and be able to get to the edges in some different areas that we were looking at. Those types of elements that were coming into play there.
3:28:32 We did look at the, you know, the roof and a rain concept. That was the first discussion. A lot of different review of that, looking at the options there. The challenge on the roofing was, one, getting it to extend brightly over the ice in order to keep the winter, just getting the sun off of the ice to be able to extend the season. But also for the summer activities, what we really ran into was the height of the roof necessary if we were to add in a number of the different activities.
3:29:02 As currently planned. So some conflicts back and forth for that. Going to a new facility, recognized it will have a higher construction cost. Now this is going back a few years and looking at this, roughly maybe 30% plus or minus. Part of that was just for the larger facility, the new build in terms of cost for that. But again, the added programming and the elements there, looking at that over time.
3:29:28 And then the operational cost a little bit offsetting that all depending on what our actual cost recovery will be. And we would say it's probably higher, but depending on there's a factor we had originally with the lease agreement in there that tended to add a very consistent operating cost that added to the cost of the current location versus a new location. But end of the day, you probably do have a larger.
3:29:58 Overall operating cost component. We believe there's greater potential for cost recovery, but that'll take a couple of years to level out. And then also, again, just the cost of the facility. The other thing was really looking at the ability to enhance our mobility component and looking at the parking area. A lot of debate over that originally, where it was going to be reduced and what does it take to add that back in. And so the current program took a hard look again.
3:30:25 Adding in, I believe it's 118 or so spaces of parking, but a lot of other elements to it, both for expanded transit connections, flexibility for other types of programs, be that electric vehicle charging, bike programs, those types of elements. The final conclusion and decision by the Town Council through that process was to proceed with the location at Mammoth Creek Park and with the construction of a new facility.
3:30:53 The new facility also went through several different designs and bids. The initial design and some of the beauty of that in the construction that we looked at ended up coming in dramatically higher than any of the projections. I think the first bid was in the $20 million range. One of the modified ones continued to be well above where our budget was established at. And so through that process is really...
3:31:18 We've done a number of modifications to it as appropriate, but with the goal to be able to meet the core programming needs and desires that the community has put together and that we'll walk through here later in the program here this evening. But being able to maintain the core goals of that expanded capability in terms of the types of services we can provide to our community. So we came back into this. I think the project is currently presented is financially and operationally viable.
3:31:47 It's doable out of current revenues. Those elements will speak more to that in detail. There's definitely some options there for council to weigh as you make a decision on this. But we do believe there is a project now that's before you that meets those requirements. And if so desired, it can by ability of it moving forward is definitely there. So next slide, Hais. Yeah, so thanks, Dan.
3:32:15 I'm going to quickly walk through the bid results and the scope that was bid and kind of go through some of the items that Dan alluded to regarding mobility and transit. So on June 3rd of last year, staff was directed by town council to rebid the project with some modifications. We left that contract a couple months later in August. We opened bids in October. We did receive six bids, which was great for us. The bids were pretty tight.
3:32:44 Low bid was Hamill Construction on a Marietta, and like I stated earlier, $8,884,008. What was in the bid? Grading, foundations, utilities, the Olympic ice spring slab, the piping, installation of the sprung structure, interior structures, the public restrooms, storage rooms, janitorial rooms, locker rooms, some shared restroom shower space, mechanical rooms, ice surface rooms, snow pit.
3:33:14 It did include the HVAC and dehumidification systems, fire protection, LED ring facility lighting, and then, of course, it included the general contractor overhead fees, liability insurance, and so forth. What that kind of looks like, and I kind of color-coded it to try to make this a little bit simpler, and I'll go into some detail on these. So the orange-ish area is kind of the entry rental area.
3:33:40 Grayish, greenish area was the previous community center area. The bluish is the locker rooms and bathrooms, shared shower facilities, and over on the other side is the yellow storage mechanical rooms. So the rental space, we modified that. We'd previously put some office space in there and had some public counters. We removed that as part of the cost-saving exercise. We also removed the mezzamine and second floor.
3:34:10 Community room spaces from the lower area in the Greenish, about 2,500 square feet of that space was removed. Now we've reserved this space for future build out. We are planning on putting in all the electrical, plumbing, and infrastructure so that at a date forward, if it was so considered, we could expand those spaces. But these spaces right now are fully programmed. So Stu can still program for a number of uses and he'll go into those details.
3:34:38 And in order to meet the need, we'll just pull our existing infrastructure over from the existing ice frame to meet our need for racking skates and campfire space and so forth. The locker rooms and shower spaces were relatively unchanged. This previously had a second story kind of observation deck with stadium seating. We did retain all the structural elements to build that at a later date. We did remove the...
3:35:07 The elevator and so forth is the cost of any measure. But the spaces, the locker room spaces are intact. Those were critical for programming and the facility wouldn't function without them. And lastly, our mechanical and storage spaces, again, these were critical for the facility to operate. So little changes here.
3:35:28 So there's a few items that were not included within. Landscaping, which is pretty minor, and staff intends to complete that. Like I mentioned, the mezzanine level, the stadium seating, the ADA lift, and the community center, those were eliminated. The south canopy and the south seat wall were eliminated, and that was for snow loading issues. We have to clear this regularly, and these features would have inhibited our equipment to operate appropriately.
3:35:58 And then we also, for the summer programming, need a sport court and some equipment, and there's potential grant funding for those opportunities, which Stu will get into. Part of the award, part of the recommendation is to direct staff to directly purchase the pre-engineered sprung structure, the train 30-ton air-cooled chiller, the dasher board system.
3:36:20 And the scoreboard, again, these were cost-saving measures, so we're not paying profit and overhead on these items. These are all readily available off the shelf, so we elected to direct purchase them and have the contractor install them. As Dan was speaking to, we intend to let a separate bid for the construction of the parking lot and associated mobility elements. In the staff report, I said 119 parking spaces. I'll explain why.
3:36:47 But those parking spaces, it turns out to be 118 under the current plan. Includes clean air vehicles, ADA spaces, electric vehicle spaces, bus turnout, location for shelter, bike racks, recycling trash, and signage, which we'll need to address as we'll need to modify some of our trail signage, and we'll have to update our municipal signage as well. So that's part of the program. And I'll dive into that a little bit deeper.
3:37:16 This is what we're proposing. This is pretty schematic. The orange area is parking that includes seven electric vehicle charging spots, 11 clean air spots, and 6 ADA. Those are required by code, and if directed by policy, we can make modifications to that. Also required by code is a total of 19 bike parking spaces, but I suspect we'll be more than that with all the demand we see.
3:37:42 And we'll be able to adapt to that and put more parking, more bike parking to the demand. The blue space on there is kind of the transit area, transit shelter. And the red lines are to the upper right is the existing sidewalk on Old Mammoth Road. And then that red line is horizontal as a proposed connection to the facility. So I wanted to demonstrate that we have connectivity to existing public infrastructure sidewalks.
3:38:11 And then the green is an existing map that connects to the town loop. So the site is already very well connected to existing, you know, pedestrian outlets. I did allude to this parking space. The discrepancy in the staff report was actually this parking space right here. We identified it as needing to be a van accessible space. And so we had to utilize this area for the van ramp. So that was discrepancy in the staff report.
3:38:40 Between the 118 spaces and 119 spaces. And I will add, there's probably an opportunity to squeeze a few more spaces into this layout. I also included this to show you that this mobility parking lot area is not just schematic. It's pretty well designed. It's not far from being able to be let. Just some minor tweaks on where the racks and shelter will go, and it's ready to be set out to bid.
3:39:08 I don't want to go spend a lot of time on this, but I think it's important to address it, and there's going to be a couple spoilers in here. We keep talking about this site as a potential opportunity for mobility issues, and some key issues we're trying to address is there's currently no transit access out in Mammoth neighborhood.
3:39:30 And you may or may not know that with the Snow Creek 7 development, we're going to lose our staging area over by the athletic club. And we have issues, we've discussed them before with the Purple Line staging here in Bonds, and then the shelter out at Carl's Jr. just needs to be replaced. It's just, it's past its useful life. So how can we address those elements through the CRC?
3:39:58 I made this myself. So I modified the existing transit map. And a couple of things that are going on here. We would stage the purple line and the red line at the CRC. We have that hub that we kind of pull out that we included. That provides that opportunity for the driver to get out, use the restroom, take a break, provides that opportunity to set the headway so we can get the timing correct.
3:40:27 And here's the spoiler. We're working on putting a minor mobility hub on the corner of Old Mammoth Road and Woodman. I'll show that in exhibit. This is still preliminary. We're still working with our partners at MCWD, but this is looking pretty good for us to actually be able to drag the red line all the way out to Old Mammoth and Woodman. We'd also have the opportunity to run the owl line out there. And so this helps us to meet a need. And because of the changes in the headway at the athletic club,
3:40:55 Staging at the CRC. We're going to actually be able to run this route in the same amount of time that we do right now, but actually expand service to that part of the community. We're also proposing making some modifications to the transit pullout and shelter near Vons. That's going to come later this season, but we would be cleaning up all of this with this kind of change in utilization of this parking area.
3:41:18 And here's the spoiler. This is what this hub on the corner of Woodman and Old Mammoth is starting to look like. It's a minor hub. The blue area is a transit shelter with some bike parking. The kind of orange areas is a couple parking spaces and circulation of design so a bus can pull in, pick up people, and head back out. So we're pretty excited. You know, still, I don't want to get people too excited because we're still in negotiations, but it's looking good, and this opportunity would solve a lot of problems for the Old Mammoth neighborhood.
3:41:49 So with that, I'm going to turn it over to Stu to talk a little bit about programming on his end. Thank you, Hais. Yeah, I've just got a few slides here. We have Chair of the Recreation Commission as well. Betsy is going to speak and talk a little bit about the Recreation Commission and their efforts over the last several years. We'll talk a little bit about the programming, summer and winter. We'll also kind of touch base.
3:42:17 On the O&M costs as well. It's included in the staff report. So just again, just setting expectations. This is the Parks and Recreation Department vision. This vision was actually established in 2010 as part of the rec extracts process. So this is what we aspire to as a community. This is kind of our collective combined vision for Parks and Rec, for Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And we, you know, we look to achieve and seek.
3:42:46 And realise this vision with everything we do and all the capital projects that we bring forward to council. Mission, I mean, again, I just want to make sure that everybody's clear on what the mission is of our department and that's clearly, you know, to provide that multi-purpose year-round indoor and outdoor recreation opportunities accessible to all residents and visitors. So that's how we decide how we program and what opportunities, activities and events we bring forward to our community and visitors.
3:43:14 And again, just some comments there on recreation as an essential service. And our community relies on the Parks and Recreation Department, right? We have many value-driven, affordable camps, programs, events, and seasonal activities that all contribute to an enhanced quality of life. Hazel, just flip the next screen there, buddy. Thank you. So with that, I'm just going to hand it over to Betsy. I just want to thank Betsy. And again, the Recreation Commission have obviously spent an inordinate amount of time.
3:43:47 You know, through this process, their passion, their advocacy. I'm always amazed each and every time we meet. We've had this item on the Recreation Commission essentially for every month, probably Betsy, for 10 years, right? So, you know, this is the lead advisory body and they've done an exceptional job and I'm being proud to work with the Commission and Betsy through this process. So with that, Betsy, thank you.
3:44:14 Thanks very much, Stu, and good evening, Council. You've all seen these community goals before. These goals are on every staff report that the commission has. This item is a standing monthly item for us. You've seen them. I don't want to belabor them. But one thing I do want to point out is that this facility...
3:44:33 You know, it's really a true multipurpose facility. And it's also really, this project also really encompasses the whole park. I think you got some of that from Hayes' discussion of mobility hubs. This isn't just about plopping something down. The whole idea is this will really work with the elements of the park. You know, we completed the inclusive playground, which is actually part of this whole vision for the park and for our community.
3:45:00 From the commission's perspective, our objectives for this project have remained consistent as stated by these goals. And the commission last met on Tuesday, February 2nd. So I thought that I would just share some of the consensus comments that came out of the commissioners. We had a pretty robust discussion that day of design and programming of the facility and its current iteration.
3:45:24 And so these were some of the comments that the commissioner shared. One was my commitment to this facility is even stronger than it was last year. I am even more excited now. This facility will touch so many people. Our community needs enhanced recreation facilities and this is it.
3:45:42 The CRC will be a recreation destination, recreation hub, and a facility we can all use in some form. Bottom line, it's going to be an amazing facility for this town. One of the commissioners actually commented that even just to have year-round bathrooms available in that part of town at the park is just going to be kind of a game changer. So, you know, there's a lot. There's a lot of elements and a lot of thought has gone into this facility. And the commission continues to stand firmly behind this project.
3:46:11 We're really proud of the work that's been done by staff on programming and on design. I think that we are equally honored to work with, you know, with public, you know, with the Parks and Recreation Department, with Hayes and his team. And, you know, we're all hanging in there after seven years. So nothing has really changed from the commission's perspective about our support of the project. And we're just really excited to keep, you know, keep building on the programming that's been developed for the facility as it moves forward.
3:46:40 Commissioner Turner had actually hoped to join me this evening, and since he wasn't available, he actually sent me some comments that I will share with you. They're very brief. He said, as a recreation commissioner, I've been through the review process for the community recreation center since introduction. And even though it has had numerous challenges and cost estimate increases, I remain fully supportive of this effort. Mammoth Lakes needs a designated location where the community can come together for community-focused recreation.
3:47:08 While I know the talk has been on this as an ice rink for winter programming, I am most excited about the summer programming opportunities. The CRC is designed based on specific direction given from the community on programming that we want, and most of that programming is actually for the summer. Thank you for keeping this project on track. Let's complete this for the entire community and the entire year. So this project is certainly not just an ice rink. We've said over and over, it's a true community facility. It's a multi-use facility.
3:47:37 Thank you very much for your time. I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have on behalf of the commission, but we really appreciate you all hanging in there with us through the multiple bids and iterations of this project. Thank you, Betsy. Hais, if you just want to jump to a couple of slides, just go forward one more. Yeah, so I just want to pause here and, you know, I just want to spend a little bit of time and...
3:48:03 And thank, you know, the many people, the organisations for getting us to this, you know, this milestone. I mean, this is really a defining moment for community recreation in Mammoth Lakes. Just the many comments. I mean, I was just profoundly impressed and astounded, you know, today by our community, you know, yet again, who took time out of their busy lives to comment either in favour, you know, or in rejection to the CIC. I've just included several of the comments here.
3:48:31 And the public engagement, the many meetings, the workshops, the site visits, you know, these past seven years is really critical, you know, in making a decision that is more informed, that is better understood, that is implementable and sustainable. So again, just want to thank the community and everybody that's been involved in this project, regardless of whether you support it or not. We believe that those comments and that advocacy, all the objections have made this a better facility.
3:49:00 I just want to talk a little bit about, you know, it's easy to get distracted, right, by the many project reiterations, you know, seven years, we've had three bids, we've seen this thing move, we've had mezzanines, we've had community centres, we've had everything change in and out of this facility, but I just want to talk a little bit about not what's not included in the CIC, but, you know, let's talk a little bit about what this facility will do for the community. So firstly, I think, as we've all talked about, it will deliver a roof.
3:49:30 Over an ice rink. I mean, we've started this process. This was part of, as Dan was talking about, 2007, when we originally started this ice rink project over at the school site. You know, the plan was by 2010 to have a permanent site and have a roof. Now, here we are in 2021. That's 14 years later. So, I mean, again, let's just really stick to kind of some key objectives here. So, we'll deliver a roof.
3:49:56 And again, I just want to reiterate, and it will actually deliver the mission, you know, of the Parks and Recreation Department. And that's really to deliver that multi-purpose, you know, the year-round, the indoor, the outdoor recreation opportunities that this entire park will deliver for the community. So, Hais, let's just jump back to the summer. Go back a couple of slides here. So you can kind of read, I've just kind of pulled some bullets from the staff report. You can kind of see the layout of the sport court. You know, I just wanted to kind of provide.
3:50:25 You know, a one-page summary, and again, this is really driven from the playbooks that were developed through the community, through the Recreation Commission from 2016, and we've continued to refine them. So, you know, more importantly, the Rec Zone will be the hub for our Parks and Recreation Department. Right now, that function is served either at the Rec Zone or the Community Centre, so very challenging.
3:50:49 So it will be the kind of recreation destination. It'll be the home for our Parks and Recreation Department and our home really for kind of our youth and adult activities and events in Mammoth Lakes. More importantly, you know, we talk about the opportunities for our local youth, right? So we can really provide that affordable, supervised after-school sport activities that is so needed in our community. You know, week-long sports camps and our signature...
3:51:14 Summer camps are so limited by capacity. You know, this facility will be able to provide additional, you know, single day, multi-day, you know, sports camps for our kids and youth during summer, which I think is critical. Provide those kind of adult youth basketball, indoor soccer leagues as well. And later in the fall, you know, it's been working with a lot of our event producers around town. What a great event venue, you know, festivals in the fall.
3:51:41 So I really want to kind of make sure that, you know, five month, you know, period of time, truly a multi-use, it serves a multi-generational, you know, segment of our community from, you know, age one to a hundred, you know, we can have activities, you know, programmed in this facility. So very excited. Let's just jump into winter, the next slide, A's. So again, kind of same background, again, just list all the bullets, you know, from the playbook. Again, the biggest,
3:52:12 Takeaway from this is it will be a six-month facility. You know, currently we have a three-month facility and staff spends probably more of their time working to either shovel the snow, cover it with blankets, you know, keep that chiller operating and just kind of blimp that facility along. I believe it's a great proof of concept. I think the team that we have with Kat, Lauren, Warren and all our ice rink staff over the last 10 years have been operating it.
3:52:42 At the multi, you know, the side of the school, the 10 years prior to that over at the RV park, we have proved that we can and we've demonstrated that we can provide a great ice experience for not only our residents but our community and that's really the priority for this facility. So again, it's a six-month facility, it wastes all those, it just eliminates the wasteful costs of labour, keeps the rink frozen, right? Now the chiller can actually, you know.
3:53:10 Work to keep it frozen, which is great. And most importantly, improve that skating experience. And you can see here the list of activities, right? So public skating, you know, it's just a reliable facility for our residents and our communities to skate. If you look at all the weather, the challenges that we have, if you look at last Monday, I mean, what a dreary, miserable day. This facility will be fully open. You can come and skate for a 10-hour period of time.
3:53:37 Figure skating, practice arena, curling, leagues, tournaments, home for the Mammoth Stars, Mammoth Lakes Youth Hockey, you know, Patrick and Jeff and the entire team. They've got 68 kids on this program. They have many of those kids come up from Bishop. It's a true regional facility, right? So it's not just, you know, one rink that's going to serve one purpose. It'll do all of these activities and more. So really kind of proud of...
3:54:03 The programming that's taken place, again, very community driven. We've hosted many meetings, come through the commission, and we continue to refine this as we move along. Just a couple of slides, just a couple of bullets on the bottom there. It talks about in the winter and summer, the number of seasonal jobs that we're bringing in. I mean, this facility will split six months winter, six months summer. It's essentially a total of 26 seasonal jobs that we're looking at for this facility.
3:54:32 Which I think is significant. So if you talk about, you know, economic development, sustainability, that's a lot of jobs, it's a lot of employment, that's a lot of, you know, activity that we can kind of generate out of this facility. So I'm very excited. Just wrapping up, really in summary, the facility will provide clearly a more sustainable, you know, recreation experience for our visitors and primarily our residents, right? That's really what we're building it for. It will be a driver for clearly economic development. It will enhance the community's quality of life.
3:55:02 And further positioning Mammoth Lakes as a great place to live, work and play and hopefully get us that much closer to our vision to be the best alpine recreation community in the country. So with that, I'm going to pause. I can answer any questions now or we can kind of just get through the presentation and we'll answer them at the end. So Hayes, just move that one forward and I think we're at costs and I think I'll either turn it back to Dan or Hayes to kind of move through this slide here. Yeah, I can run through this one, Stu.
3:55:32 So this table in front of you just kind of enumerates all of the costs as part of the award package that we're discussing this evening. So we have the construction contract, AML. We have a need for some construction management, material testing, architectural services as we move through. That's really to deal with any design contingencies, and we always have to test the materials as we put them in. That's the concrete and the earthwork.
3:55:57 Like I mentioned, we're going to purchase directly the Sprite Structure, the Dasher Boards, the Chiller, the Scoreboard, those figures are right there. We totaled up all of our work to date, about $1.873 million. And then the mining mobility, which I touched on the details of earlier, about $800,000. So all in all, we're looking at a total all-in cost of $14,831.40.
3:56:26 And I'll turn it over to Dan to kind of go through the funding of this project. Thank you, Hayes, Stu. Yeah, I wanted to walk through the operational cost briefly here shortly, but also just the front-end commitment for the funding for the project itself to move forward. So as noted on that, this has been up other times before, but the general fund commitment was made over the last several years. That has basically been expended in the offset of the current expenditures to date.
3:56:55 We did have, at the time, Measure R and U reserves that were committed to the project. We had a Measure R bond issue that was committed to the project. That bond is $5.5 million. That's been sitting in the account still and actually has generated some additional revenue coming in out of interest from that earned plus what we're paying out though. So that element's been there. We've raised some local community funds, about $16,000 for the scoreboard. So that would be an offset directly to the scoreboard cost of purchase of that.
3:57:25 The development impact fee for parks, this is an eligible project for that, so those dollars are committed there over time. The fractional Melrose, this is a special district that was created mainly to deal with the 8050 building and I think the Obsidian project where there is fractional ownership, but it's a non-rental product, so there's no TOT generated. The CFD that created that.
3:57:52 It has a fairly tight restriction on the use of those funds. It has to go to an enhanced level of service over and above that was in place, I believe it's in 2004, 2005. So there's a number of areas those dollars can be used, but given the reductions in town operations that happened due to the economic challenges of 08 and the following challenges with the airport issues there that we ran into in terms of
3:58:22 The bankruptcy filing, et cetera. There's very few actually departments that are back to those levels of operation. So the ability of those funds are relatively restricted in the use. That's also one of our key operating funding sources on an annualized basis as well. I will touch on the other use of Measure U coming out of current reserves identified for the MAC project. That's the Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center.
3:58:48 And then our transit reserves have been set aside over time as well for enhancements to our transit program. And the budget is, we had worked really hard to look at a $13 million budget going into this. Some of the ongoing expenses have definitely driven some of that cost up just with the redesign work. But also looking at just the construction cost index and the impact that just inflation's had on us. We've seen this in a number of other areas in the community, both in the private.
3:59:16 As well as the town side, looking at just taking that construction index for the last five years, we'd be moving from a $13 million to a $15 million budget based on the data pulled from some of the state information that they tracked some of the cost increases for construction with. So given the time frame that we're in, difficult to come in and ask for additional funding, but on the other hand, we've seen that cost increase.
3:59:42 Due to the amount of time that the project has been under review. And before I leave the slides here, I just wanted to touch real quick. And it's in the staff report. We didn't have a separate slide on it. It's on page 8 of the staff report, a 193 of the packet. It's the estimated operating expenses and revenue. This has been an ongoing refinement that has Stu kind of pulling his hair out and his staff as they have been working through a number of different elements, looking at the number of staff required to run the facility.
4:00:13 Building in recent changes for mandatory increases in minimum wages in California, looking at the staffing of people currently in the organization and how do we leverage them into the support for the facility. And as I mentioned earlier, the Melrose provides a good chunk of that operating revenue, about $200,000 a year coming in from that. We have a...
4:00:39 200,000, 230,000 estimating from the ice rink operations. And that's really based off of what we've been able to achieve in a much shorter timeframe on the current facility and looking at that capability to expand that out. Then the rec zone, the summer operations, that's probably a rough, kind of a rougher estimate of 70,000 just because we do not have this type of facility to actually operate out of today. So there's some projections built in that. We honestly think it's somewhat conservative that we think
4:01:08 We'll have it in that facility. And then the gap closure on that is looking at, we noted that both as measure our general fund about $150,000 to make sure that the operating costs are covered. The expenses, winter operation about $385,000 and summer $265,000. We're looking at $650,000 operating budget for the facility. Again, a lot of this, it's an educated estimate, but there are some.
4:01:37 Elements in terms of the chiller running over a longer period of time, but also in a confined space. We think we can get some efficiencies out of it in the type. Some of the other lighting and dehumidification and elements of the facility, some of those are unknowns a little bit. Again, we've done our best work through those to be able to define that. But the largest cost in there really comes back to our whole labor, the structure we set up to run the facility.
4:02:04 Again, heavily reliance on those part-time seasonal positions. And over time, we've been pretty effective getting a number of people coming back. That skill set that comes back here, they really do enjoy working in Mammoth, whether it's a college student or people who have other jobs and they split between us and other work. And the ability to do that, we do have a built-in cost escalator there for returning employees. We want to make sure that we get the ones that want to be back back, and that's a great, great asset for us in the town.
4:02:34 As well as for those employees and the skill sets they're learning in the recreational world. So that expense and revenue, that will be updated probably at least two additional times before this facility is built, hopefully kicking it off and being built December of 2022. So with that, those dollars are there. And I really did want to touch on the two reserve issues that we're looking at utilizing. The first one being the transit reserve balance.
4:03:01 There is $668,000, almost $669,000 in there committed for the transit side of revenue. We've also set aside a large portion of our transit reserve actually in the vehicle replacement side. We have actually set that aside knowing that down the road we're looking at replacement of trolleys, partnering with ESTA for expanded service capability in some of the buses. And Hayes mentioned at the beginning of the meeting.
4:03:29 Looking at an all-electric bus fleet, ultimately, as we begin to look at that, a lot of that is out of grant dollars. Those grants require batches. And so we've been very proactive the last couple of years of setting aside, I want to say it's over $400,000 or $500,000 that we've set aside to be able to enhance our transit fleet in the future. But the current dollars here were identified for parking and mobility hub work. This here would go into the parking lot, the dollars there.
4:03:57 And also additional for our transit shelter program for new and replacing shelters. And the work is noted in the little in the new turnaround up on Woodland. So those dollars are set aside for those areas to make that work. The other element that came up is looking at our Measure U funding. We currently have a reserve balance of $3.1 million sitting in that fund.
4:04:24 Assume there's 1.5 million used for the CRC as recommended. We have 2.5 million that was committed to the MAC. And so if we take 1.5 out of that, we'd have a million dollars still available to support the MAC program. And then just the general reserves in there, it gets complicated working through it, but there's $600,000 that will be remaining. That can go back in to help replace the capital request from the MAC project. And also,
4:04:54 In a letter received from the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and looking at the redesign of that facility, they're going to need some additional dollars to work through that design and will they expect a request in the near future to be able to support some of that additional design work as they're facing some of the challenges we face with the CRC in terms of getting a facility to meet the goals and purposes within a scope and budget that is achievable.
4:05:20 So I would anticipate some dollars going back into that design work. We don't really have a number for that at this point. As we end the current fiscal year, so come June, we anticipate having about a half a million dollars in revenue savings within that Measure U fund. Part of that has been how we've managed to set aside what...
4:05:41 Dollars were identified for ongoing operating costs of the MAC of $300,000 a year. We've actually been budgeting that and setting it aside to be able to build into that reserve account. And also some additional dollars in there due to COVID. Some of the programming dollars will not be expended this year. And then 21-22, an additional half a million dollar growth in that potential Azure U. And those assumes a pretty tight...
4:06:09 Revenues versus what we've seen a few years back when better times, those revenues started to move up a little bit. And so by walking into the year 22, 23, where we would anticipate the MAC to be under construction and needing those dollars, that the commitment from the town, the two and a half million would be fully committed back into the facility. That would be the strong recommendation from staff that would make those commitments, but also looking at some dollars on the front end to finalize the design there.
4:06:38 Again, so we know the type of facility and the structure that'll be moving forward with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, the work on the Mammoth Arts and Culture Center there. Longer term discussions on that in terms of operation, et cetera, the facility as well that'll need to spend some time and work through those elements as that facility also moves forward. When we look at the two facilities there, we have two great facilities that we believe by
4:07:07 FY22-23, maybe a hair later, depending on the timing on the MAC, that both of these facilities would be up and running and fully funded and financially viable projects in the community that provide different but complementary, a service to our community on the culture side and art side, the meeting side, the recreational side. So it's actually an exciting element to be able to see these two types of projects able to move forward.
4:07:35 Probably within a year of each other of being completed. Both of these have been under discussion for numerous years. So it's an exciting element from that perspective. So I wanted to touch on those two additional reserve pieces as that's the additional dollars we're requesting to move into the fund to be able to fully fund the project as currently proposed. Next slide is so the.
4:08:04 I'll end our staff presentation on this, the staff recommendations. Hayes kind of walked through these at the beginning, but it would be the award that bid Hamlet Contracting, allowing for the small modifications or irregularities in the bid to be set aside for the Public Works Director to approve minor revisions as we need to go through the project. Also to...
4:08:27 Move forward with the purchase of defined owner provided items such as the sprung structure, the chiller package, dasher boards, the dash of boards and glass go around the ice rink, scoreboard and other small items in there to complete those projects. As noted, the reason we're doing those is a purchase by the town. We have that opportunity to do so and that reduces the general contractor overhead and cost of purchasing those programs as a contractor, those project elements.
4:08:55 And then also to make the necessary budget adjustments, including the 1.5 million transfer out of Measure U and the 315, 640 hour transit reserves to move into the project fund. With that, we're available for any questions from the council. We have received numerous public comments on this, and Jamie will be able to give you a brief overview of those. But we can come in to you. And then we do have, I will note we have two.
4:09:24 Public members here in suite Z who I believe both want to address town council as well. But if we can address any particular questions to the council at this point, that would be appropriate. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. So with that, I'm going to separate this into two. One, first off, will be any questions for staff. And then we will come back and take comments. So for questions, John. Thank you, Mr. Mayor.
4:09:54 As mentioned, this project has been in gestation for a long time, and I've had a couple of questions on this item for staff, for members of the community, for the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and others, and I'm satisfied at this point. I don't have any questions, technical questions for staff or otherwise, and I'm prepared to move into deliberation when you do, and that's the appropriate time to do that, so thank you. Thank you, John. Linda? As far as questions go,
4:10:27 After spending a considerable amount of time on this item, you know, I don't think I have any direct questions, comments, I think will come later. So no, I'm not going to, there's no questions at this time. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. Sarah? No questions. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. No questions. Thank you. For myself, no questions, but thank you for a presentation well put.
4:10:58 And you've missed the boat for how long we've been talking about this. It goes way, way, way back, almost to the town's inception and the first recreation studies that were done. I don't even remember when I first got on the Red Commission, but it's been almost 30 years ago, I think. Kirk, go ahead.
4:11:22 Bill, it's been 45 years. You remember when we incorporated that the water district tried to put an ice rink out at the equestrian center. So maybe it's time to move forward. Yeah, thank you, Kirk. So with that, I will come back for comments on this item. John? Bill, do you want to do council comments first or do you want to do public comments?
4:11:54 Well, you know, in this case, maybe we should go to public comments first. Personal public comments, Jamie. Would you guys like to speak? I'm sorry, are you calling? No, no, we do have a public comment here in Sweet Z, so Sharon Clark is approaching the microphone, so we'll do the public comments. Thank you. Hi, I'm Sharon Clark. I'm used to talking to people, but okay. I'm a resident.
4:12:31 Taxpayer and a fiscal conservative. Six years ago, Town Council interfered with the Recreation Commission's plan to finish our existing $2.5 million ice rink. Instead, Town Council decided to relocate the ice rink and build an amenity. We were told by staff our school district would not negotiate in good faith. Untrue.
4:12:57 Mono County needed the concrete slab for a child care center. Untrue. The LA Kings would use the new Olympic ice rink. Really? Staff said the existing ice rink will not support a roof, which is a direct contradiction of staff member Grady Dutton's plan in December 2014. Which comment is true?
4:13:28 Finally, staff said, and you agree, we will build an all-in, multi-use facility, community recreation center for $13 million. Once again, misleading the public. Staff and town council have rigged on what they said they would do. Even if we spend $15 million.
4:13:54 We will build only a rink in a shell with restrooms, showers, and a large empty space. Certainly not an all-in facility. What is the actual cost for an all-in facility? Concessions, kitchen, rentals, offices, storage spaces, multi-purpose room, durable sport tiles, mezzanine.
4:14:24 Built-in bleachers, elevated walkways, stairs, ADA access, community room with support kitchen. We need transparency. We want to know all the costs for a finished product. Is there a timeline and how to pay for this? And Dan explained where the money's coming from measure you.
4:14:54 Among other things. The staff report for the CRC says there will be concessions, rentals, staff, storage space, but they are not included now. Is this just an oversight? Now, staff is asking for $1.5 billion Measure U Reserve funds already dedicated to the MAC.
4:15:21 Assuring us that they will restore the funding in a couple of years. Staff has been disingenuous so many times for so long. Why should we believe them now? Trust once lost is almost impossible to restore. We did not learn about the new $15 million plan until last Thursday, February 11th, six days ago.
4:15:48 You've wasted six years and now you want a decision in six days? Tonight? Has Mammoth Lakes Recreation seen the new empty MUF CRC floor plan? Did they recommend spending 1.5 million Measure U reserve funds? Has the Recreation Commission actually seen the new floor plan?
4:16:14 Did the Recreation Commission advise you to spend $15 million for an incomplete MUF CRC? Does our community know the empty shell has no rentals, concessions, offices, storage, kitchen, multipurpose room, mezzanine, bleachers, etc.? Does the public have any idea what your staff is proposing? Do we have any complete
4:16:44 Hello, ladies and gentlemen. I'm Phil Heigert.
4:17:26 I rise today to ask the Council for their support of the Community Recreation Center, specifically for there to be the continuing existence of an ice rink in Mammoth. I see it as a very important recreational asset for residents of all ages as well as for our visitors. I've been involved in Mammoth Hockey for 41 years. When I moved here in 1980, we formed the Mammoth Quakes and played in the Northern Nevada B League.
4:17:55 For the next 25 years, we were remarkably competitive given that for our first 20 years, we had no home ice on which to practice. Thanks to the tireless and persistent efforts of Greg Seamus and Jeff Posey over those 20 years, we acquired the rink equipment that we still enjoy today. I can testify that hockey is a lifetime sport in that nearly that.
4:18:21 Nearly age 66, I have continuously played in the Mammoth Adult League with players averaging half my age. Happily, in spite of COVID, Mammoth Youth Hockey has been able to practice this year and it's been a great delight for me to be involved in the third generation of Mammoth Hockey as an assistant coach to my grandson's team, the Mammoth Stars.
4:18:45 An enormous amount of time and dedication has been put in by Patrick Bernard and his coaches to build this youth program, which even in this unusual year has 68 kids involved in the very fun, healthy, and affordable outdoor activity. It would be a tragedy for it all to be scuttled. Furthermore, those of us who are not avid skiers or snowboarders, the adult leagues, the drop-in hockey, the
4:19:17 Figure skating, public skating, and even curling has made our normal five-month winter a season to be enjoyed and not just endured. I understand that there are some residents that have expressed their strong opposition to following through with the building of the CRC, advocating instead for the MAC. Coincidentally, I identify with both of these special interest groups.
4:19:44 In that, besides being a lifelong hockey player, I'm also a lifelong choral group singer. Within a week of my moving here in 1980, Barbara Campbell had me in her living room, Walter Buchanan had me in his garage rehearsing musical plays and barbershop quartets, which rolled into decades of Messiah performances, Easter concerts, Fourth of July parades, Ski Education Foundation fundraisers.
4:20:11 Village, caroling, etc. I was lamenting the other day about the loss of a large part of what used to be a very vibrant musical culture for a town as small as ours. Thankfully, Brian Schulz and Rebecca Hang have continued to do a wonderful job with the Eastern Sierra and Children's Orchestras and the Felici Trio, but sadly, the vocal and choral component has faded away. But that's not...
4:20:41 Due to the lack of a venue. It's due to the lack of high-powered people with the love of music to make it happen. When Walter passed away and Barbara Stephanie Everson and Kenan Fossey-Coulter moved away, no one was around to step up to fill their shoes. As nice as it would have been to have had a Mac, we did fine with the Catholic and Lutheran churches.
4:21:09 The high school and middle school MPRs, the college lobby, the old gondola building, and all of the summer outdoor venues. As much as I would like to see the MAC materialize, I think that the recreation center should be the first priority for the following reasons. One, bonds were floated through measure R for this express purpose and substantial funds have already been invested for the plans, etc.
4:21:38 Two, the rink will be used seven days or a week by far more people, both local and visitors. Three, no one among us who wants to be involved with music, theater, or other arts will be deprived of that opportunity by the delay of the construction of the MAC because other venues, while not ideal, presently do exist. Four, skaters, on the other hand,
4:22:05 Have nothing if the CRC is not built and the present rink is abandoned. If the present rink were sustainable into the future, we wouldn't be asking for a second, newer, nicer one in addition. Finally, I would suggest that you not construe any scarcity of correspondence and support of the CRC as any indication of actual weak public support, since I, for one, am very interested, but I was only made aware...
4:22:35 of the immediate impending vote today by a personal contact. Thank you for your consideration. Thank you, Phil. Any more public comments? Jamie? So before the Town Council meeting, I forwarded emails to the Town Council and have been posted online, and we received 67 emails in support of the CRC and 11 emails against the CRC. In addition, during the meeting,
4:23:10 I've received several emails and I'll read them. Sarah Saturday says, Hello, I am writing to voice my support of the building of a permanent indoor ice rink in the town of Mammoth Lakes. This will only increase tourism opportunities, support our recreation programs, and encourage individuals, both young and old, to stay active in yet another way in town. There are so many hockey figure skating advocates in town and they deserve a place to skate year-round.
4:23:36 Beverly Vandervelde says, hi there, just wanted my voice to be heard. I think it would be great if Mammoth had an indoor ice rink. Craig Albright submitted a comment as the MLR board president.
4:23:55 And it says, Dear Council and community members, over the past several years as a community recreation center and Mammoth Arts and Cultural Center in all of their iterations have progressed through the public process and Mammoth Lakes Recreation has made various recommendations in regard to the design and financing of each and the use of Measure R&U funds for such. By contract with the Town of Mammoth Lakes from 2017 to 2020,
4:24:20 MLR was to serve as the Council's designated body to provide the public process and the development of funding recommendations for Council considerations as provided for the voter-approved Measure R and U and in compliance with the requirements of the measures as codified by Town ordinances. The current contract between MLR and the Town is for MLR to serve as the Town's designated body to receive public input, conduct necessary public hearings, and make reservations.
4:24:47 recommendations to the Town Council on the expenditure of uncommitted Measure R and U revenues, including the continued recommendation of allocation of Measure U funding for arts and cultural programming and after-event evaluations. MLR did not have the opportunity to engage the public, provide for public process, and make a recommendation as a board of directors. MLR was made aware of the Town's intention to transfer
4:25:10 $1.5 million from the measure year reserve funds to close the budget gap for the CRC when the agenda for this meeting and accompanying staff report was made public. Simultaneously, members of the public contacted MLR questioning when the recommendation of such expenditure by the MLR board occurred. No such recommendation was asked of the MLR board and as such has not occurred. The MLR
4:25:35 Board stands ready to assist town council with any requests to aid with public input and provide recommendations on this or any other project that will help our shared mission of meeting the recreation, arts and cultural and mobility needs of our mountain community. Colin Fernie says, Dear council members and staff, first I would like to thank everyone for their time, energy and commitment to this community during a moment, monumentally challenging time.
4:26:11 Unfortunately, I am not able to attend tonight's meeting due to work commitments. However, I would like to provide some comments as someone who was very involved in the development of the CRC project since inception. I am speaking both as a member of the public and a board member of MLR, although unfortunately the full MLR board did not have the opportunity to weigh in on this particular item, despite being the designated recommending body for expenditures and measures R&U. Ultimately, these are all...
4:26:37 Dollars are at the discretion of council, and if the council desires to change MLR's role, that is certainly their prerogative, but it seems as if some better communication around the issue was warranted. Arriving at tonight's umpteenth vote has been a long and arduous process for many staff members, members of the public, both in support and against the facility, and has unfortunately spanned multiple councils in just the most recent go-around, let alone the nearly 40 years this community has established this facility as a priority.
4:27:04 The reason I personally, as one council member, didn't pursue putting a roof on the existing rink is because it was a subpar facility on land that we do not own, which would get in the way of the school district's future plans for their own land. The facility proposed by the school district had just as much merit, so I felt it was critical that the project was developed on land that we, the town, owned to not throw away more money or get in the way of the school's plans and desires.
4:27:29 We also always discussed and reiterated the importance of developing complementary facilities, providing the community a much-needed covered ice sheet, as well as a community center, another subpar existing facility, and a covered space for summer recreation programming. Staff and council were acutely aware that the finances of the organization were in the best place they had ever been and that we had significant resources to pull together to develop a world-class facility. Staff should be commended for that effort.
4:27:56 Unfortunately, the actual bids came in well above projections and blame can be placed wherever one sees fit for that unfortunate reality. That development put the existing council at crossroads. Do we continue to charge forward and get creative with how we finance the gap or do we tow a hard line and direct staff to re-engineer a facility that fits within the budget constraints established at the time?
4:28:17 Council chose the latter, which was unfortunate to me. That is not the path I would have chosen, but I fully respect that when you step off council, you have relinquished that control. For the four years I served on council, one of the guiding lights that yes votes always referenced is that we were going to do this. It needed to be done right and not in a subpar fashion as we have typically operated as a community over the years. Unfortunately, that important principle seems to have been lost in translation over the many years that we have been pushing forward with this facility.
4:28:46 The facility proposed tonight is a far cry from what many of us originally set out to do. It has now been stripped down to a $14 million plus tent over a rig. Many of the components that made this facility worth pursuing are no longer incorporated, which begs the question, what is the point?
4:29:02 It pains me to say it because it was always my goal to push this community to want better for itself, but we already have a subpar facility, so it doesn't seem sensible to just build another one at the cost proposed, especially considering that the funding proposed now suggests reallocating dollars that were previously allocated to the MAC. Both projects are worthy of consideration, but it would be hard to argue that one is more important than the other. That is why our former counselor was so careful in spreading over...
4:29:28 And finally, from Joe Hannigan,
4:29:58 As a business here in Mammoth, we greatly support a new hockey rink. Every time we donate our time, food, and welcome all of those who participated in holiday tournaments as well as buy yearly sponsorship ads. A year-round facility managed properly is a win-win for the town and community. On top of the communal benefits, the potential untapped revenue stream will only help out the town.
4:30:19 Hockey is an expensive sport with dedicated players, families, fans who will travel hundreds of miles in a day just to play. Factor in the proximity to NHL teams, men's and women's Olympic hockey teams, and other levels looking for high-altitude training in development camps, and you have a slam dunk. Get it done. That is all. Thank you, Jamie. Now I will come back for council comments. John. Mr. Mayor, I count four wins associated with the current proposal.
4:30:54 I count first the facility as described by staff, year-round multi-use facility, including ice and activities in the summertime as well. Critically important, when I first came on the council, the bar that was set, this facility exceeds the situation we're currently in. To me, that's a win. The second win is to make clear to
4:31:20 The entire Mammoth Lakes community, this is not an either or proposition with the MAC. The MAC is going through some of the similar growing pains that we've had to go through. Too expensive. What we envisioned and what we drew, there's no way we can afford it. Let's hang in there. Let's persevere. Let's work the project, which is what we've been doing with this community recreation center.
4:31:46 I want to make sure that when we come to our final motions, when we get to that point, that we reaffirm and restate our commitment to the MAC and our commitment to having those dollars available in a timely fashion once that reimagined process and project is presented. The third win is an opportunity to establish a minor mobility hub for this community. I've heard from...
4:32:10 Many members of the public, when are we going to get to feet first? When are we going to actually start doing this? Council has given specific direction to staff around mobility in the last meetings. We had a lot of hangling over the first phases of the parcel about how we were going to be true and good to the needs of mobility in this community. The parking, the interface of this CRC with the community, with that parking, is critically important. And it's a leadership vision for where we're going to be going.
4:32:39 As we move people throughout the community. And finally, the representation that Hayes made this evening about the ability to expand transit down into Mammoth. That's a fourth component of the win. So there are four wins that are happening here. In looking at the public comment that's come in this evening, what I've been impressed by is that the ratio of support to opposition to the project is running close to seven to one.
4:33:04 In the six years I've been going in meetings with this, I've never seen that level of support for this project. And I want to make sure that all the people that wrote in, I read every single letter and every single comment. And I want to make sure to restate that the opposition of this project has not changed. I honestly, it's been vague. It's been based on alternatives that don't exist. That's fine. But it has not changed over six years. What I heard this evening and the last couple of days reading these comments was,
4:33:33 Individualized, specific expressions of desire to see this project made. There were no foreign letters in there, no copy and paste. It was heartfelt, sincere expressions of support for this project. And I've never seen this ratio of comments coming forward for this project in the six years we've been working on this thing.
4:33:54 I also was very encouraged reading the numerous citations of the Mauna County Board of Supervisors' adoption of their resolution recognizing racism as a public health crisis and how that's associated with the ability to give folks and youth an opportunity to enjoy sport and enjoy exercise in a facility like this. And I think it's really important to point out just two final things. This is probably the first public infrastructure project.
4:34:22 That's going to be coming out of the town, not just the town, but the entire community. We've heard a lot about being, you know, development ready and the private development is going to come in here. And the truth of this of the matter is that the town and the community with two, potentially three projects between this, the parcel and the MAC are going to be leading the way in building new infrastructure and new facilities for this community. Private development will follow, no doubt about that. But it's the community and it's the folks that live here to make this community possible.
4:34:52 How fitting is it that the first project out of the gate is going to be a project that's going to specifically benefit the youth of our community, the youth of this region, I'm sure you all saw that in the letters that came in from Bishop, from Crowley, from north of here, that this is a regional opportunity. So I've been very careful to read all the letters, to listen to all the comments, to weigh all the various pros and cons.
4:35:19 And I self stand fully behind this project and I encourage my fellow council members to support the seat. Thank you. Thank you, John. Linda. Thank you, John. Well put and noted. On that theme, what are the pluses of this? Is it exactly what we would like? No, there's disappointments in here. I'm disappointed that we are not going to be able to immediately finish the community room. That was a really big plus for this. But I have...
4:35:49 I'm convinced that we will get there, that that will continue. But I'm going to go back to this. So in my opinion, the kids win here. Our children and our community and our region win in this project. There is not another place now besides the ice rink during the winter where kids can gather. This is an opportunity for kids to have a place to gather year round, whether or not they are, you know.
4:36:18 Hockey players, skating rinks gather people. Sometimes I pull in over there at the skating rink and just sit and watch it in the evening. Kids are out there, families are out there, you know, it's not the greatest rink, but you know what? It works, except when it doesn't and it melts too early or other things happen to it. The opportunity for this, those months of the year, I think is endless. It's health for our kids, it's wellness for our kids, it's social interaction for our kids.
4:36:45 It's a place for families to go in an evening and have activities. It's places for kids to be able to go, you know, maybe they'll do, you know, PE, PE at the skating rink, you know, introduce everybody to it. The other thing about this with kids is the affordability. And I talked to Stu about this, I talked to some other people about this. The fact that in our community, we have now a new, even,
4:37:13 Kind of sports scholarship program, the Tony Calisaro Memorial Fund for funding kids who can't afford maybe, maybe there's a kid that loves, you know, skating so much and they really want to be a hockey player. I would like to think that any kid who wanted to, that we would be able to stand them up and encourage them and to help fund these activities. So no child would be unable to participate at the level that they wanted to.
4:37:40 I think our families absolutely win for this. There's families and people that don't have kids at home anymore, but curling is really fun. Adult hockey leagues are really fun. People get out there and they skate and they have camaraderie. And when Phil talks about being a hockey player, I didn't know that about him. I thought his letter was really amazing that he had been doing hockey for that long. There are a lot of adults in our community who also are looking for a place to gather.
4:38:10 To be together, to do something fun that doesn't involve always, you know, going to a, I mean, not that I don't love them, but you know, I'll know what our festivals are like and they're great fun, but in the evening, it'd be really fun to go out there and go skating and do fun things together. So our families win. Our community wins because we have now a community amenity that is more than just an ice skating break. It is a place to gather. It is a place to be. I think Stu said what, we could have 2,000.
4:38:40 Seats set up on that ice rink floor for activities and get-togethers. We all know where we go now. And this would be great in the middle of town to be able to access that, to be able to use that. And I'm not going to reiterate everything John said because I think he said it very well, that the MAC is not a competition to the CRC and vice versa. The fact that we can leverage these monies that are not needed immediately and by the time they are needed.
4:39:09 Being able to have them repaid into that pot, that is an absolute commitment on the part of at least this council person, that there would be no walking away from the commitment we made to the MAC. We've made $2.5 billion plus an ongoing $300,000 a year into the future for the MAC. I think that's a pretty solid commitment to another facility, which I agree, people are going to enjoy both of those things. It is an absolute win and I am...
4:39:36 Completely committed to seeing both of those and following through on both of those. So rather than blathering on longer and giving everybody else a chance to speak, those are some of my thoughts. When I joined Town Council in, let's see, July of 18th, I drove staff crazy because I said, I want to be convinced that we can't put a roof on this existing ring. Why not? So they went and I think it was, they brought this forward in like February of 2019.
4:40:05 With this big report, again, why it was not a good idea to put a rope on the existing rink. And I went ahead and sent it to some relatives back in Minnesota who actually had friends who run skating rinks and they looked at this and probably said, yeah, you're right, this is not, this stuff, this is long on the tooth. This is time to, you know, you have to pretty much trap the whole thing and replace it. Whether it was going to be this year, next year, or we can patch it together a few more years. But I became convinced, okay, putting a rope on this rink is not.
4:40:33 feasible. It's not the best expenditure of money. So long way of saying that I'm supportive of this. I'm excited about it. I look forward to getting this going and I will now cede the floor to somebody else. Thank you, Mayor Sauser. Thank you, Linda. Kirk. Hi, thank you, Bill. Can you hear me? Yep, you're good.
4:41:00 The difficulty of this, making this decision tonight is that we don't talk about it in relationship to other capital projects. You know, the roads are, to be honest, underfunded, $500,000 a year, a new blower down in the, you know, there's a lot of different things. A blower is $850,000. We need two bays down in the industrial park. You know, we talk about things.
4:41:27 In isolation. Am I opposed to the ice rink? Not at all. And yet, I think that budgetary discussions and the capital project discussions are lacking. And so that makes it difficult. We're still renting space for town offices, which is 46 years now. And we were supposed to do that. So there's an awful lot of capital projects out there.
4:41:56 I oppose the ice rink. I have serious concerns about the budget. So those are my comments. Thank you, Bill. Thank you, Kirk. Cheryl. Yes, thank you, Bill. I want to begin by saying that there are community decision makers who are so invested in getting this thing built that they went to the town manager and attempted to get me removed from this vote because I expressed my opposition to this project. Here's the thing.
4:42:25 I have been vocal about the cut rate nature and cost of this project since I announced my run for office. It was the second policy stance that I listed on my website after housing. And I hate to be that guy, but I won this seat by a significant margin. And many of those votes were because I had the courage to take a stance on this project and to announce that stance publicly. Frankly, this feels like last week's impeachment vote, like...
4:42:50 No matter how much evidence this council is presented with, how much is cut from the facility, how much the price rises, council is dug in. So I don't really feel like this soliloquy is going to win hearts and minds, but I do feel like it needs to be said. I'm old enough to remember when this was sold to the community as a multi-use facility, but I read every single one of the letters we received in support of this project, and maybe two of them.
4:43:17 Did not mention skating as the reason for their support. And the way this has been framed, asking us to think of the kids and ignore the fact that this project is cut rate and fiscally irresponsible is pure gaslighting. I am thinking of the kids. Mammoth's kids should have had a roof on their rink seven years ago. But because the decision makers wanted a legacy project, the kids that just wanted to skate when this fiasco began are in college now.
4:43:47 Does the list of ice rink support emails that we got today outnumber the list of opposed emails? Of course it does, because these people just want to be able to skate on a reliable rink, and the town government told them that this was the only option. Also, they were solicited by a Facebook post on my cell trade, which is the reason we had a flood of comments coming in today. At every step, moving this project forward has been a Sisyphean task.
4:44:15 At every step, there was opposition from this community. It never flowed. It never fell into place. But everyone kept pushing instead of spending a million dollars to put a roof on our rink. And I honestly, I just can't get my head around why. I didn't run to this office so that I could get my name on a plaque.
4:44:32 Or a brick or a dasher board. I ran for this office so I could do right by this community and building a facility that is a hollow shell of what was first envisioned at a cost that nobody agreed to that has been sold to us in this piecemeal fashion that is frankly insulting to my intelligence is not doing right by this community. This is such a slam dunk for Mammoth. Why isn't this an easier decision? Why isn't this a no-brainer? I don't believe that we should claim it to a mistake just because we spent a lot of time making it.
4:45:01 And that's all I have to say. I will start my comments by saying there was never a $900,000 roof proposed for the other rink. I was on the rec commission. I got the reports. It wasn't even close. The current rink needs to be completely rebuilt. Whether we rebuild at the school site or whether we rebuild on our own property, the cost of building is the same. So let's start with the Measure U.
4:45:33 We're asking to take 1.5 million of Measure U reserves. That's not all MAC funding because there's 3.135 in the reserves now. That is as of last June. In order for us to put something out to bid, we have to have the money in hand as a government entity to do that. To have the money in hand, we need to transfer these funds over. The reality is...
4:46:03 That they will not be paid out until this project is almost complete. By the time we have to pay them out, I am confident Measure U will have replaced its fund. As John said, I am absolutely committed to the MAC, but it's going through the same iterations. Are we going to oppose it because it is now a scaled down version and is not what we asked for? No, we're going to move forward with what is best for this community to suggest that I do anything.
4:46:31 For my own name, it would suggest that somebody hasn't known me very long or been around. We have, as a town, there have been a minimum of three groups, independently appointed citizenry groups that have been asked to look at where this rink should end up. All of them, without exception, have come up with the same thing, Mammoth Creek Park West, for a whole lot of very valid economic reasons.
4:47:03 And I'm not going to go on. John said it, most of it, and so did Lynda. This is not just a hockey rink. You know, before COVID started, as I showed up early for a lot of council meetings, there would be anywhere from six to 15 kids in the hall in front of Suite Z because it was a place they could go and hang out. This provides a place for them to go and hang out at no cost.
4:47:31 Everyone's saying we have scaled this project down. If you go and you look at what Stu and the rec department originally put out for this project when we had to change it to the soft-sided structure, this is exactly the project. We were told by consultants that we would be able to add in the mezzanine, the public center upstairs, all of the rest of this, and still come in at cost. That turned out not to be true.
4:47:58 So when we had to pull those things, we went back to the original plans. This is not a scaled down version of what was proposed. This is not a scaled down version of what MLR put forward and approved. This is a scaled down version of what we told we could be done and we couldn't. So I believe it's time to move this on to ask for more public input. What that's going to do is it's going to take...
4:48:26 What was a $13 million project, which is now becoming a $15 million project, and it's going to create a $17 million project. Public process has been done here over and over and over again. I'm sorry. That's my feelings on this. We've been working on this for a long time. So I will get off that horse. I think enough has been said. And I will ask anybody if they would like to make a motion.
4:48:55 Mr. Mayor, I would like to make a motion, and I would like to add an additional point, a number five, which I've written up, I'll read it out loud, but I'll read points one through four, and then I'll add a number five, if that's okay with you. That's fine. Thank you. So I would move that the Town Council approve the plans and specifications for the Community Recreation Center, award the contract to the lowest responsible bidder, Hamilton Contracting, Inkford.
4:49:23 $8,884,008. Waive any minor or regularity in the bid total. Authorize the Public Works Director to execute the construction contract and accept the project upon completion. Point number two. Authorize the Public Works Director to review and approve minor revisions to complete the project within the established budget. Point number three. Authorize the Public Works Director to purchase defined owner...
4:49:49 Provided items including sprung structure, chiller package, dashboards, court board, and other appurtenances. Yeah, thank you, Hais. Yeah, you know what I'm saying. Number four, authorize the town manager to make the necessary budget adjustments to including the transfer of $1.5 million from Measure U, Fund 217.
4:50:15 Reserves and $315,640 in transit-related reserves to the project account Fund 300. And finally, I would add a number five that the Council to will reaffirm the Town's commitment to participating in the financing of a reimagined MAC to be proposed by the Mammoth Lakes Foundation in the near future and to provide regular and public updates as to when the $1.5 million being used to fund the construction of the CRC.
4:50:43 Will be made whole in the measure you fund over the coming 12 to 18 months. I will second that. I have a motion from Mr. Wentworth, a second from Ms. Salcido. Any further deliberations? I have one thing to add. I understand the rationale for wanting to discuss MAC funding, but that's not really on the agenda. Well, Councillor, help us.
4:51:15 Andy, could you just put in a little extra comma on the fourth point?
4:51:45 Just put and report regularly back to council or something in regards to that rather than a whole new item? That would be cleaner, yes. Okay, why don't we do that? I think that if the motion passes, the feeling of the council about the MAC funding and about moving the funds will be pretty clear direction to staff. So I think it's unambiguous. I think staff will understand, but I'm just somewhat wary of the council.
4:52:15 Including what sound like binding commitments on things that are not on the agenda. Well, I appreciate the legal niceties and the legal necessity of that, but I think it's important that the council make sure on behalf of the community, as Linda and I both said, that the commitment stands. Linda, if you have an idea, maybe I guess I'll remove that fifth bullet that I just read. And Linda, I think you had an idea about adding a punctuation or a couple words number four that would satisfy.
4:52:46 Your needs there. Okay, because first it talks about Measure U and then transit. So let's put a comma after $1.5 from Measure U fund reserves, comma, reporting at regular intervals to the council on progress in repaying that reserve, period. And then the
4:53:17 Last sentence would be additionally $315,000 from the transfer related reserves to the project to count. That seems perfectly consistent with the agenda item. Thank you. I will amend my motion, Lynda, to be consistent with yours. We now have a first from Lynda and a second from John. Is that correct? John is amending his. Okay, I'll make a second. We have amended motion. Right. Amended second.
4:53:51 Yes. Yep. Any further deliberation? Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Rae? No. Councilmember Stapp? No. Councilmember Wentworth? Aye. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes. Mayor Salzer? Yes. Passes three to two. Thank you all for your effort. That was a long one. And moving on now, find my agenda.
4:54:23 That brings us to Councilmember Reports, I believe. John, let's start with you. Thank you, Mayor Sauer. Sauer, just a quick report out. I made a commitment to donate six months of my salary to local needs to help with this pandemic. Just reporting out that $2,000 is going to go to Wild Virus, $1,000 is going to MMLH to help with rental assistance.
4:54:57 And $1,000 is going to go to the Tony Colisado Fund, but if anybody wants to try to get money using the town's webpage to donate, they'll understand why I haven't written that check yet. I'm good for it, but there's got to be a simpler way to do these things. On the host program, I'm looking forward to all of us getting an update in the coming weeks on that. There's some great narrative reports.
4:55:25 At Shady Rest, there were 38 dogs present from 9.30 to 11.30 in the morning. Of the 38 dogs present, five were leashed. All snowmobilers were friendly and willing to chat it up. In the village, windy and snowy, minimal lifts open, two MMSA hosts running massive gondola line going up past distillery, trying to reroute people to Blue Line, but buses kept filling up. 30 people left behind by buses between morning and the afternoon. Interesting thing to know.
4:55:56 Spots along Road Haven on Lake Mary Road, closure, haven't been plowed since recent snow. Some people are creeping onto the pavement, blocking two-way traffic, especially two-wheel drive, because they're afraid of getting stuck. Middle Rock remains unplowed except for two spots. This is the kind of information we're getting from the field. And this is going to be great information going forward as we really figure out how we're going to manage all these different recreation nodes. Friday, February 8th at the LTC meeting, we heard about the electric bus.
4:56:24 I missed my opportunity to ride in that beautiful blue electric bus, but I did see it drive by down Main Street as I was on my electric bike. But I was kind of happier to be on my bike than to be in that bus, but it's a beautiful looking bus. Yosemite, we heard from at the LTC meeting that Yosemite for the coming season will be instituting and using the same program they used last year for permits to access the park. There'll be limited ridership going.
4:56:52 Availability using yards went through the park. The draft 2021-22 overall work programs coming together. And on February 24th, the new members of the Mammoth Lakes LTC team, that's Bill, yourself, myself, Jennifer Burrows, Dan Holler, we're going to get together and talk about the LTC and meet with Hayes and look at all the great opportunities coming forward with that group and how we're going to work to be effective on behalf of the community working at the LTC.
4:57:19 I had a great, very long discussion with Leslie Yen of the International Forest on February 10th. It's a great and very welcome breath of fresh air with her leadership here for the International Forest. And for those of you who haven't met with her yet, I would encourage you to try to get a couple of minutes to say hi to Leslie. She's got great experience in this region, and she's really going to be, I think, doing really good and effective work. Finally, the Dispersed Camping Summit. I want to send kudos out to Supervisor Gardner that happened last week.
4:57:49 Raise the barn event that's happening here in the eastern Sierra so that we can take proactive steps against opportunities for wildfire, cleaning up trash that the humans bring with them, that the humans create all by themselves. I think this is going to be a key important part as we move into managing what's going to be happening on the ground this coming summer. So I want to give a big shout out to Supervisor Gardner of Bob McFarland to pull that thing together. I think there are about 50 or 60 people on that Zoom call.
4:58:18 And that's going to be a great effort going into the summer. The ESCOG had a very good and positive meeting. A $3 million grant proposal for the...
4:58:27 To the California Department of Fish and Wildlife looks to be submitted this week. This is going to establish a NEPA ID team that can be used throughout the region to do third-party NEPA for fuels projects, recreation projects, all kinds of great stuff. Again, Leslie Yen was a big part of that, and a big hats off to Janet Hadfield. The first project coming out of that is going to be working on this Mammoth Donor Project, so it's going to be very, very exciting. That's my report for this evening. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, John. Linda.
4:58:57 Thank you, Mayor. Let's see. If I were to list every state meeting on COVID and vaccine that I've had to attend, I would, but it would not be relevant. I did attend the ESCOG meeting, and it was a very, very well-received meeting. Lots of good conversation, especially around some of the efforts around the ESSRP and the sample work being done there.
4:59:23 John gave a great presentation on the projects that have been done, the progress of those groups, so that was worthwhile. And then that's it. I think that's the only meeting outside of the hundreds of, well, it feels like hundreds, but many, many, many letters in the last week on the CRC topic and trying to respond to each of those, at least to acknowledge if people took the time to write a note about that. Some really, really
4:59:52 Well thought out things and it was a lot of fun to read them. I actually learned a lot. So on that note, I think that's all I have to report. Thank you. Thank you, Linda. Sarah. Thank you. I did not attend any meetings outside of Town Council, but I do want to thank John Wentworth so much for donating to Wild Iris. I'm on the board of that organization and we really appreciate it. So thank you. Thank you, Sarah. Kirk. Thank you, Bill.
5:00:25 I attended the finance committee and the investment pool where the different counties and all the investment pool, the interest rates are minuscule. So we're not making any money off of our investment pool or very, very little. I attended an ESPA meeting.
5:00:50 Zoom meeting and our ridership on the buses is substantially down. And people have been very good about wearing masks other than one incident. And so that's been excellent. So those are my two reports. Mammoth Lake Housing has distributed the rental assistance program, all those different funds. So I think we are
5:01:19 Pretty much extended all those rental assistance checks. So that's my report. Thank you. Thank you, Kirk. As for me, I attended the Esther meeting with Kirk. Got there a little late, but I got there nonetheless. Some interesting things. Esther was going to build a new facility at the airport, and that has somewhat been gummed up by the city of Los Angeles.
5:01:48 In a fight within Yo County, they're trying to extract their pound of flesh, it would seem. Ridership, as Kirk says, on the buses is down, due in large part to the COVID, you know, issues and lack of ridership there. I also, with John, attended the LCC meeting. I think the one conversation that you might be interested in is that the Bishop people submitted their report on the airport.
5:02:16 And they're making great strides. They got an ARF truck coming. NEPA and CEQA goes out for public comment on February 28th for 30 days. And they expect their final environmental documents to be done sometime mid-July and expect to be operational for air service by the fall.
5:02:45 Other than that, just some other routine things at LTC, and that's about it. So I thank you all. Unless somebody has something else they would like to discuss, I will adjourn this meeting. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Thank you, colleagues. Thank you, staff.