TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2011

Town Council

· recording 6 hr 2 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

293 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:37 If I had known, I would have gone home. Okay, everybody ready? At this time, I would like to call to order the regular meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council for Wednesday, May 4th. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. If you would, please join Councilmember Wood in our pledge.

2:21 Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, invisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time, we will now open public comment for anyone who has something that they would like to bring to the council's attention that is not on tonight's agenda. And if you would, please try to keep your comments to five minutes, if possible.

3:08 My name's Earl Henderson. I'm back again this week. Number one, I want to thank the council for hearing me out last week. My concerns about the irrigation model ordinance, use of water in our irrigation systems in town. I appreciate the fact that it seemed to have broke the rust free on some of the wheels that have been sort of stuck on the tracks for the last several years to deal with it. I brought my little visual aid back with me because...

3:36 Two other points besides the thank you I wanted to cover. I realized my visual aid. It adds to the answers, the information I was given. Number one, after the discussions and concerns over grass and the landscape along Old Manwood and Main Street, I appreciated that perhaps somebody might think that I am against growing turf. I am not. The Irrigation Model Ordinance

4:04 It helps us to understand how to apply water efficiently and have the grass and turf that we want. I used the illustration that this represents the amount of water for each month. This represents the amount of water on top of the turf for the entire year. I pointed out that Sierra Star Golf Course is capable of doing this. Councilman Eastman raised the...

4:31 Somewhat of an objection that it's impossible to apply these standards to our turf on old Mammoth and Main Street and have grass that grows. I think out of that maybe somebody thought I was against growing grass out there. I'm not. I did not mention one other project in town that is dear to my heart that is capable of growing turf with this much water.

5:00 Shady Rest Park. Since 1993, when that park was installed, the irrigation system I'm quite familiar with. I know that there was three pages of information written to the architect that submitted the design, that issues that pertained to Mammoth Lakes were discussed, allowed some modifications in the system, though allows it now, under the very capable hands of the town's maintenance staff, Dennis Rockner and his crew I mentioned last week.

5:28 They do an outstanding job of working with what they've got. They, in reality, are using less water to grow their grass than Sierra Star Golf Course because it's well managed, it was well designed, thought out, and the maintenance has been kept up on it. The issue of the grass and turf on Old Mammoth in Maine, how to water it, how to design the systems,

5:56 The technology that can be used is even more advanced than it was 20 years ago when I helped install the irrigation system at Shady Rest Park. If you'd go to the ordinance and follow the outlines in there for efficient water use, you could keep most of your turf on old Mammoth and maybe not get this well because there are a few things. There is a lot of asphalt and concrete out there, but you could get your water use down to this or close to it. Not.

6:26 The 15 feet that I demonstrated last week. I brought with me a few pieces of paper that I don't intend to cover fully, but number one is next month marks four years of the first workshop that was conducted by the town, and at that point in time the principal planner who was a landscape architect from another state who was not perhaps as familiar with the state codes here.

6:53 As he began to work in Wrangel and try to make the ordinance update work. So for four years we've managed to accumulate everything from planting practices to personal opinions. And I realized last week that maybe part of his problem in trying to draw a conclusion on what this ordinance should be is driven from two ends. Number one, we have those that are very defensive about keeping the grass green growing that we have out here.

7:22 And at the other end, I heard his presentation before the Planning Commission where he pointed out he wanted to reduce the amount of turf that one could plant in a new property or project to 10%. The Planning Commission, perhaps personal preference, has lowered to 5% in the ordinance. So maybe the staff were sort of in the middle here trying to figure out where they had to meet the ends of the public, wanting some grass out there.

7:52 And the Planning Commission trying to help us conserve water they thought by reducing turf. Turf is not the enemy. The demonstrations of how water can be wasted on grass are quite evident. We have the numbers. The evidence of how we can grow grass and still use the state water allowance they've given us. So anyway, it was just those three points. I would suggest or perhaps recommend that you take the ordinance that's been muscled around now for four years. It's the result of...

8:22 Decades of study and numbers and calculations on how to do this. Get rid of all of the things you've tried to add to it and change the name in 34 places as recommended by the town, by the state. Get this ordinance in place. Use it as the guideline to determine how you attack fixing the water problem on Old Lammoth and Maine. Thank you again for your time. Thank you. Mr. Jarvis.

8:56 Just quickly, Council, I wanted to advise the Council and the community that I've had a conversation with Caltrans regarding State Route 203 rehab. Their schedule for redoing their rehab project on State Route 203, they're scheduled to begin right after July 4th, I think it was July 7th, and wrap it up August 12th. I'm also in contact for...

9:23 In contact with Craig Holstie at Caltrans trying to set up a meeting so we can sit down and go through the detail of that schedule. I know there's some concerns with regard to business and economic impacts during that time of the summer, but we want to go through that schedule with them to see if we can minimize those impacts. So I haven't heard back just yet, but looking to set something up for next week or the week after. So just wanted to announce that so everybody knows.

9:50 Excellent. Thank you very much for looking into that. Sure, we are definitely concerned about rehabbing Main Street in the middle of the summer, our busiest season, so thank you very much. Ray, what's the overall scope of the project? What sections are they going to do this year? They will start, it'll be the same thing that they did two years ago, unfortunately. They're going to do from 395 up to Main Lodge. So it's essentially the same scope. They'll be grinding off what's there and repaving it.

10:19 Was this a result of a job that wasn't done, right, or something? You know, I think essentially there might have been a mixed design issue. I think there was issues with temperature when they were placing the asphalt. There was a number of things I think that contributed to that failure. They've worked that out with their contractor. I don't think it's the same contractor this time, but they plan on coming in.

10:46 Redoing the whole project, so we should be in pretty good shape when they're finished. Hopefully they won't be working in the fall, so that will help. Ray, all I would ask for is for you to keep an eye on it, and if there's any changes in their schedule, or if there's any possibility that it might not be completed this summer, that you share that with us. Absolutely. Thank you. Good evening. Sandy Hogan, and I'm representing the Mobility Commission. I chair that commission.

11:21 And I'm here just to remind the public and to let everybody know that we hold several workshops each year so that the public can come and get their input if they have concerns. And one of our workshops is coming up on May 17th. That's Tuesday at 4 o'clock in this room. And we hold this one twice a year. It's our traffic management workshop, which really deals an awful lot with traffic calming and issues that folks have in their neighborhoods.

11:51 We hold our second one in November. And in each case, we usually have the police chief or his staff come and Public Works report on some of the improvements that have been made during the past year, usually in response to things that the public has brought up, especially traffic calming in neighborhoods. And so we really want to encourage the public to be aware of these and not be afraid to bring these up to us.

12:18 Whether it's by email or coming to the meeting or anything like that, because sometimes one problem that's happening in one place, it's happening elsewhere. And some examples over the past couple of years when we started scheduling these workshops, we were really having a lot of complaints out in the Old Mammoth Road area, on Forest Trail, in Manzanita.

12:40 And in those three areas, we had a lot of folks sometimes going through a petition process and wanting us to, especially speed limits. You know, speed has been a problem over the years in a lot of the neighborhoods. And so what happened, I know, with Old Mammoth Road as a result of citizen involvement and things they brought forward, our public works folks and the police department have worked on one, of course, we lowered the speed limit in several areas, added signs above and below.

13:10 Also, you'll see sometimes little flags on signs, and that's a sign generally that it's something to alert you that something has been changed. We have permanent speed feedback signs. So a lot was done out in Old Mammoth Road.

13:26 And really, we haven't heard anything the last couple of years, I don't think, right? But then Forest Trail, we have the same types of issues in Forest Trail, especially people going downhill, you know, from off 203 down towards the fire station. And as a result there, we have a permanent speed feedback sign.

13:47 I drive that a lot, and I see that that has had a good effect, I believe, in additional signing. Sometimes something will come forward, one that came forward actually in the Noles is one of the results of a neighbor who works outside a lot and saw a lot of close calls, and that was where we had a three-way intersection with really just a yield sign, and he'd seen a bunch of close calls and a few fender benders, and so suggested a just one-stop sign, which...

14:16 Public Works looked out, put in, and that's been working wonderfully.

14:19 Of course, it might be because the chief of police lives two houses down, but it is working well. And actually, I drive that a lot, and it does work. And then also in Manzanita, which was one of, you know, that's an area of concern. We had our Sierra Valley Sites district planning meeting last week, very well attended. And, you know, over the years we've heard there's a lot of issues involving speeding and pedestrians and lack of lights.

14:48 Snow removal and all sorts of issues. And over the years, what we've seen is the police department has stepped up its efforts in all of these areas where speed is involved and really made some contacts, and it makes a difference. Also, just double line right down the middle so that people are not pulling up in the middle of the street and really speeding. That slows them down because it is a winding road. And signs, cautionary signs, things like this. We even did a survey.

15:17 And actually, Berkeley did a study, a traffic study. And so a lot of these things will go into the Sierra Valley District Sites Planning as well. But I guess we want to make the public aware and anybody you hear concerns about, you know, anything having to do with traffic, traffic calming, it's an ongoing issue. And so please refer to the Mobility Commission, talk to any one of us, email, come to the meetings because if it's happening in one...

15:45 Part of town, sometimes it's happening another. And we do also, besides that workshop, that's a scheduled workshop twice a year, we also have another workshop that's scheduled twice a year, and that's transit, because our transit system is still evolving and growing, and so in June, we have our transit workshop for the winter schedule, so this gives time for people to give input so that

16:10 You know, something could be done for the winter schedule. And then in January, we have a similar type of workshop having to do with the summer schedule. So anyway, I hear the bell. This is just a reminder, and we do encourage people to come to our annual workshops as well as the regularly scheduled agenda. Thank you. Thank you, Sandy. Any questions for Sandy? No. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Rick Phelps of the High Sierra Energy Foundation.

16:44 I'm here to tell you very briefly about two exciting projects we have through our partnership with Southern California Edison Eastern Sierra Energy Initiative, which covers Inuamono County, City of Bishop, and the Town of Mammoth Lakes. The first one of these is a small business direct install that will kick off on May 18th. I know that some of you are familiar with it. Mayor Harvey participated in it five years ago. There was an article recently in the Times about it. There's a pack in front of each of you.

17:13 Small businesses can get up to $10,000 of retrofits that are paid for by the utility. The reason why is small businesses won't spend that kind of money on retrofits, and this is a quick way for the utility in the state to gain efficiency resources. Contractors will come in. We have over 60 people signed up in Mono County now, and we're expanding it. There will be a letter hitting soon signed by Councilman Eastman in his role on the ESCOG.

17:42 That will urge people to call an ATM number and register. More information there, I'll leave some outside. The other program, for the first time ever, there will be a solar residential workshop in Lee Vining on May 16th, starting at 6.30. It's been offered before in Bishop, and people up here have generally not gone down, or particularly if they're in Bridgeport or June Lake or Lee Vining. And that will be 6.30 at the Lee Vining Community Center. There will be three contractors there as well.

18:12 Registration is down a little bit. I think the mailer went out late. So anybody you know that's interested in this, please urge them to attend or call me if there are any questions or look at their mailer that they've received that hit about last Thursday, I believe. But two exciting programs. Both will save energy, save money, help the environment. Any questions? Questions for Rick. Thank you very much, Rick. Thank you. Hi, my name's Tim.

18:49 I'm the elected president of the Mammoth Lakes Contractors Association. I'd like to address council tonight regarding the suspension of or elimination of development impact fees. What the body of people that I represent feel is that with the economic situation the way it is, the new California State Building Code changes, i.e. Cal Green and residential fire sprinklers being required in any new construction project, we in our industry have taken a substantial hit.

19:19 To the cost of construction. Then you add the cost of permit fees, school and water, and development impact fees. It's difficult for somebody who wants to build a potential single-family home to want to do it here in Mammoth and use our local contractors to facilitate it. So what I would like to ask Council to do tonight is consider the fact that here in Mammoth we are already presented with enormous building challenges and costs with structural, seismic, and snow load requirements.

19:48 The cost of building here in Mammoth is already 20 to 30 percent higher than anywhere else. What we need is the suspension or elimination of fees to stimulate our industry for a to-be-determined time until we can rightly apply again. Thank you. Tim, real quick, thank you for your presentation, first of all, and then will you be making a similar presentation and request of other special districts in the community?

20:18 In other words, construction fees come partially from the town of Mammoth Lakes, but they also come from other special districts, if you will. I believe we already pay, you know, the permit fees, and then we pay school and water. Yeah, I'm just talking about permit fees. Yeah, no, I'm not looking at eliminating those, just development impact fees. Okay. Any other questions? Concerns? I have a question, I don't know if...

20:49 This goes to Council or not, but can we ask staff to take a little bit harder look into that? Possible further reduction in some of these fees. I've heard an agenda. Would we not be discussing that as part of our budget? Yes. Because...

21:09 If you reduce them or keep them down at the currently reduced level, then we have to find that money elsewhere. I understand, but let's do that and we pass it on to all of the people that are out there trying to make their businesses work. So I think there's got to be a balancing act somewhere. At some point I would like to agendize that for further discussion. We can work that in with our budget discussion if we can, Marianna.

21:36 Yeah, definitely. Just for the public, and again, I'm not recommending, I'm not obviously suggesting any decisions, but to give you the full context, our development impact fee funds have a huge negative fund balance because we have made some improvements and we're yet to recover the costs through the fees. So it's something for us to keep in mind. I have a question. Where have those improvements been made?

22:04 You know, I really don't have an answer for you. I haven't been here long enough to have that level of detail, but we certainly can provide a level of detail. I'm sure it's properly documented. I'd like to find that out. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, Town Council and the community. As we are aware, there's a significant project called the Cast of Diablo 4 project happening out in the Shady Rest Area. It's being proposed. Comments on the initial scoping of that project are due May 9th.

22:41 There's an item in your consent agenda to that. I'm not sure if it will be pulled or not. But just to give counsel to the public advice that on Thursday this week, the Mammoth Trails program will have about an hour-long workshop over the library between 4 and 5 o'clock to review a variety of pertinent documents with regards to this project in case people want to get their comments together for this very significant project happening out there. And we've done some initial analysis and identified a number of potential conflicts.

23:09 Running conflicts, OSV conflicts, that kind of thing. More information, you can get in touch with MLTPA. We'll see you at the library on Thursday at 4 o'clock. Thank you. Thank you. Hi, council. I'm Craig Tapley. I'm here to bring something to your attention, try to get it on the agenda, and I'm speaking to the development impact fee issue. And I just want to thank the council members that are currently on board that were here back in 2008 when we originally started that.

23:43 And I think we just need to look at it again and kind of start a continuum to see what we can do. And I don't want to be the person that says, oh, we need to eliminate the fees. I definitely think, as our manager had said, that if we eliminate those fees, they have to be generated from somewhere else. What I would like to bring to the table, I don't want to discuss numbers at this point.

24:07 A ton of research and a lot of numbers to share with you that are interested. I've already spoken to a couple council members about where we could generate funds, what we could possibly look at eliminating, and what we could do to possibly start some kind of economic stimulus package within our town. The reason this was brought up again was I was just doing a couple of projects, and a lot of our tentative design projects that are coming into my office are

24:37 Leaving as soon as I do the preliminary cost estimates for design, permits, development impact fees. Just that term alone makes me want to cringe when we're talking about single family residences. A lot of the people that I've been talking to have either inherited property or deciding to build with the best labor costs going right now and material costs, but they're kind of...

25:03 I'm upset with the development impact fee. Let's say they've owned the property for 20 years, and now the fees seem to be as high as they were before, but it's just the knee-jerk reaction they have when they look at the schedule and what the different line item fees are going to. They don't completely understand, and sometimes I bear the burden of having to educate them. And I don't know, some of the things that...

25:28 What we brought up before back in 2008 was we were doing a comparative analysis to different agencies or different jurisdictions, and that's almost like comparing apples to oranges. But at least it gave us some kind of comprehensive analysis to say how does South Lake Tahoe look at things compared to Costa Mesa or Dana Point or Mammoth Lakes. But what I'm here to tell you tonight is I know that Mono County is starting a new stimulus package where they're looking at the benefit of

25:55 And you mentioned just a minute ago, John, to Tim that they're going to be instigating, as I understand, they'll have a grant, some kind of grant money available. And what they're going to be doing is eliminating the permit fees completely. Already their development impact fees, if you compare them to the town of Mammoth Lakes, is just a fraction of Mammoth Lakes. So what we've got is almost like a double indemnity.

26:21 Also, just to compare it to another local jurisdiction, our closest would be Bishop and Inyo counties, and they do not charge development impact fees. So, again, I want to come up with a strategy that works. I don't want to be the person that says, well, we have to do this without having a solution. I know there is a solution, and I know we need to take advantage of it now, because I've been talking on this matter for the last six months, and finally, you know, spoke with somebody to say, well, let's just bring it to an agenda item.

26:49 Just to see where we can make it go from here. So we just need to create a strategy, and I thank you for your input, council members that have spoken to this, and I just thank you for the time. Craig, real quick, while we've got you, and you thanked some of the council members that are here that reduced development impact fees a year ago, 18 months ago? That was about two years ago. Was it two years ago? Yeah. And they've actually extended that deadline. Yeah, by 50%? Mm-hmm. Okay.

27:18 So we have taken some action in those lines. And also just as a reminder, because I think it's important to remember the past, the reason that Mammoth Lakes has development impact fees and the reason that the City of Bishop does not have development impact fees is because the City of Bishop has a redevelopment agency which funds and pays for some of the improvements that are needed. Redevelopment was taken away.

27:47 From the Town of Mammoth Lakes by a court decision, and therefore we did not have the opportunity to generate revenues in the community through redevelopment, which almost every other city and county in the state of California has the benefit of that. So I just wanted to bring that up because that shows why it originated that the Town of Mammoth Lakes does have such high development impact fees. Thank you. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Craig.

28:23 I think it's my last one. Good evening, Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. We did want to take the opportunity this evening on behalf of the Recreation Commission to inform everybody that the RecStrat's workshops, the third wave, as we like to call them, resume next week. So RecStrat's, as we know, is a process to become the best high alpine recreation community in the country. And those workshops resume with special events on Wednesday, May 11th.

28:51 And the Arts and Culture Interactive Workshop on Thursday, May 12th. Both workshops take place at the Community Centre on Forest Trail between 4 and 7pm. Participants are welcome to come any time. You can come before you begin work or before you start work. We have fresh cookies. We'll bribe anybody. We really need a lot of public engagement. It's a very important process. If you are unable to attend, we have both English and Spanish surveys online at recstrats.com.

29:21 Or you can fill in a survey at the Mammoth Lakes Library, Snow Creek Athletic Club, or the Mammoth Lakes Post Office. The final thing I'd like to mention is that I'll have more information on May 15th regarding Town Cleanup Day. I know you're eagerly waiting for Town Cleanup Day. You want those orange trash bags. So we'll have all that information available at May 15th, but we have rescheduled Town Cleanup Day to June 11th. So June 11th for Town Cleanup Day. That's all I had. We hope to see you next week. Thank you for your time.

29:52 Thank you, Stuart. If there are no other public comments, I will close public comment period and move on to the council member reports. Before we get to that, is there anything on the consent agenda that any council members or public would like to have hold? Hearing none, I will move into council member reports, and I'll start with Rick, if I could. No report. John. Mr. Mayor, I had just one. I attended the Mono County Collaborative Planning Team meeting this week. Excuse me, last week on Thursday.

30:26 A couple of items of interest. I think as everybody is familiar with, the Devil's Postpile National Park Service is celebrating this summer their 100th year anniversary of being organized. They're having activities two particular days. One is July 7th, Thursday night at the Welcome Center. They're having an event there.

30:51 Also on Friday, down at the post pile, they're having a three-hour geological tour for those interested. Of course, a lot of geology down there, so that would be a good tour. The other thing I wanted to mention was Ryan Dermody of Caltrans was present, and I think he was also at the LTC meeting on Monday of this week, and if there's any updates that he gave LTC, that would be great.

31:20 In particular on timing of any past openings? No, we don't meet until next Monday. Oh, coming Monday. Okay. Well, if you get them then. The other thing was we've done a number of improvements along 395 all the way from Levining down through the cities in the Owens Valley.

31:42 There's one section of Divided Highway that is yet to be done that's of interest to most of us who live in this area, and that's the Olantia-Cartago section, a very big section, a very expensive section. There is good news, I believe, in that Caltrans has worked with that community down there, and they seem to have reached agreement on the alignment.

32:07 Of where that divided highway will go through that community. Just roughly it's to the west of the existing 395. I wouldn't say at the base of the Sierra, but between the base of the Sierra and the existing alignment. So at least they have the alignment. Ryan said that if the state of California recovers from its economic condition, and we all know that's a huge if, and it's also unlikely.

32:35 But if in case it did happen, that project is scheduled for start of construction in the year 2015, so four years from now. Again, keep in mind that that's unlikely that that will actually happen at that time frame, but that's when it's scheduled. The other item I would like to do, if I could, Mr. Mayor, is I'd like to have our interim town manager

33:02 Give an explanation to the community because we got some information this week that came actually last week came to the council and it's somewhat confusing and it has to do with the town's liability payments to our insurance provider and if Marianna could do that I think that'd be helpful. Sure, I would be happy to. What you're referring to, Councilmember Eastman, is a notification that we received from our insurance carrier.

33:31 California Joint Powers Insurance Authority CJPIA that they had a change in how they assess all of their member agencies including Mammoth Lakes as well as other organizations for prior liabilities. The town has

33:51 The town participates in two insurance policies with CJPIA. One is for workers' compensation, and the second one is for general liability. In years past, and this is very typical of insurance companies as well as retirement plans for that matter, in years past, our current year premium would be calculated based on past liabilities. To the extent that the current year premium did not fully capture

34:20 Past Liabilities. The premium would go up, and to the extent that the liabilities were lower, the premium would go down. Sometime in the last few months, the insurance carrier changed the way they calculate the premium, and instead of adding past liabilities to the premium, they decided to defer them for several years, and let member agencies, including Mammoth Lakes, decide.

34:47 If we want to pay them as we go, basically stretching the past liabilities, or if we want to reach the end of the deferment period and make those payments at that time. What this means in dollar terms to the town is that we are scheduled to make a payment, a balloon payment, so to speak, on past liabilities in the amount of $1.6 million in the next two to five years.

35:16 So we have to start planning right now. Now, again, it's a relatively new policy by the insurer. It's something that they changed relatively recently. If we did not have to pay...

35:30 ourselves and basically make plans ourselves to finance that payment. They would have added this to our premium. So one way or another, we would have had an increase in our premium. $1.7 million that I mentioned would be stretched over the next five years. That's what staff is going to be recommending. So it's going to add to our budget $350,000. But again, that amount would have been added under the old plan anyway. So hopefully that provides enough explanation. Thank you.

36:04 I don't have any other comments. I actually have a couple of good news items. I would like to thank everybody, the community and those people who worked so hard on the census last year. I don't know if you've heard the numbers yet, but the town population is now 8,237 people, which is a 16% increase between 2000 and 2010. So a lot of things may have been going down for us, but there are more of us. There are more of us to share in it.

36:34 The other thing was that on Friday night I attended a celebration.

36:40 of the Andrea Lawrence Institute for Mountains and Rivers being absorbed into the Mona Lake Committee as a separate fund. The mountain was very nice to sponsor a dinner, and I think the best part of it was having so many members of Andrea's family there. And to watch as the sun set, we were able to see the mountain that will be Mount Andrea on the horizon. Any update on that?

37:09 Process at the federal level? It's working about as fast as everything else in Washington, but it's still moving. Thank you, Jerry. I have a few things here. Today I attended the Public Arts Commission meeting, and they have managed to finish up their review of the public art plan, and that will be coming before Council for approval here in the near future, I am sure.

37:39 And so that's an accomplishment that we now have one of the documents that we can check off of our list. We also received a report from the Mammoth Lakes Police Department this week that let us know that as far as crime goes in the town of Mammoth Lakes, the crime rate is down 27%, which is actually, it's good news for us. And I think it says a lot for what our police department is doing.

38:07 The fact that Mammoth is indeed a good place to be living, especially when you look at numbers and you realize that for an entire year in 2010 we had 68 burglaries. Larceny was probably the biggest thing. That was probably a lot of that might have been snow equipment coming off the mountain at various times, which tends to happen in the winter months.

38:33 And we only had six vehicle thefts throughout an entire year. I think for a lot of communities in California, that's pretty darn good. So that's good news there. I would like to announce that the Mammoth Lakes Police Community Hispanic Advisory Committee is going to be holding its first town hall meeting on May 24th.

38:58 5th at 4.30 in the Emerald Room at the Grand Sierra Lodge up in the village. And what will be going on up there is they're going to have the Mexican Council that will be there to answer questions about immigration. Wild Iris will be up there living with wildlife. The star Steve Searles will be up there.

39:24 We will have First Five from Mono County represented for people that have questions about daycare and the services that they provide, and Stu Brown from our recreation, Mammoth Lakes Recreation, will be there to provide information about activities not going on in the town. And I think this is important because we really have tried to close the gap that a lot of people have felt it has been between our Hispanic community.

39:52 And the other communities and really make them feel a part of us. We also, if you are interested, and I would highly recommend and ask that all the business owners contact the police department and through email you can get notices to put up in your place of businesses. And we have had them translated into Spanish, which is something that I think would...

40:15 Give people a more comfortable feeling about attending an event and really let them know that this is something we want to reach out to them about. So contact Mammoth Lakes Police Department and put that up in your business so that we can get a turnout. And it is not just for the Hispanic community. If you have employees or employees working for you or friends or whatever, it would be nice to support them and come up and stop in and see what is going on.

40:44 Skip, excuse me for interrupting, but I think it's important too for the community to know that at this open house on the 25th, there will be two translators there. So if someone, just because you don't speak English, there will be people there that can translate any questions that you might have. Yes, thank you, John.

41:06 Also, just to add on to what John said about the Devil's Post Pile, as part of their celebrations, and you will need to, as we get closer, they will post their schedules, but they are going to, the Park Service is going to provide some bus transportation from the visitor center and or you can catch it up at the main lodge to get transportation down into Red's Meadow for the day to take part in some of the events that are going down there. And we are working with

41:35 The National Park Service for them to have a booth at the Farmer's Market on the 6th because the anniversary is technically actually going to be on July 6th and so they're going to have a booth at the Farmer's Market to give out information, brochures and schedules.

41:54 On the events that they will be having coming up. And we are encouraging, talking with other community members and businesses, we are encouraging people to take advantage of this event because the Park Service is really going big on this with their national advertising and getting the word out and hopefully encouraging people to make it a weekend Mammoth when they think about coming up for the 4th of July instead of just a weekend. That if they stayed another day or two, there's going to be a lot going on. I think we're going to try and get Mammoth.

42:23 Brewing is making a special brew, I understand, for the occasion that will be launched on the

42:28 The 6th and I think some of the restaurants may have special dishes and things they will do to acknowledge the devil's post pile and a lot of good things are happening and then we had the Blue Sky Festival happening the next weekend so it's going to be one of those periods from July 1st right on through until the 8th that it's going to be a happening time here in Mammoth so I think everybody needs to be on their A game for that. Lastly as I'm looking at the

42:57 Price of gas throughout the country, actually, and particularly in California and our area. It dawned on me as I was listening to some reports of people on the news in Reno talk about how they're handling this gas crisis.

43:12 They're talking about buying bicycles so that they can get around easier. And it just dawned on me that I would like to just put the suggestion out there to our business community, property owners and businesses to start looking around your property and make sure that you have some kind of a bike rack or an area where if people come to our town and want to ride bikes to get around and park their car.

43:35 It's going to be an opportunity for us to say, look how easy it is. No matter where you go, no matter where you want to shop, be it the village, be it on Main Street or down Old Mammoth Road, you can ride your bike there and there will be some place where you can safely lock your bike or place it so that it will still be there when you come out. We don't have the bike theft report on the thing.

43:58 I do, I think that we should, you know, this is one of those situations where we can either look at the gas prices as being really bad and worry about what it's going to do for us or the glass can be half full. We can take advantage of it and show them what a great public transportation system we have. We're going to have bike racks on our...

44:17 A lot of our trolleys, they all carry bikes so that people that want to get an uphill lift can be on the trolley. We will have trolleys going to the Lakes Basin with full bike racks.

44:29 Trailers on the back to carry multiple bikes up so you can ride our absolutely gorgeous new bike path from the Lakes Basin back down into town and hopefully we will have bike racks around for you so it will be a really convenient thing for you to shop and explore our town. So I just kind of want to put that out there as a suggestion to take advantage of this and tout Mammoth is a walkable, rideable, public transportation type of town.

44:59 And with that, I am finished and we will move on to the Planning Commission update. Jay, do you have anything for us tonight? Good evening. Jay Deinkin, Vice Chair of Planning Commission with a summary of some of the highlights of what we've been up to. First thing I want to mention is the zoning code update. That's been occupying a lot of our time. In April, we reviewed and commented on seven different draft sections of the code.

45:31 And we also had a workshop on parking. We also, at our last meeting in April, had a public hearing on the zoning code amendment for the sign code. So that's the first new drafts section that we've approved, and I'm sure you'll be seeing that sometime soon. Upcoming in May on the zoning code issues, we have four more draft code sections that we'll be reviewing.

45:59 So that's ongoing, and we are on schedule, so we're happy that things are proceeding apace with the zoning code update. One special part of that is building height in mass. We have had multiple meetings, multiple sessions where we worked on that issue starting in March, I think, and then a couple of different sessions, a workshop and a follow-up in April.

46:26 We will have another follow-up session at our next meeting in May. So obviously we've spent a lot of time on that. We've been developing key concepts for analyzing height and mass. One of the first questions is where, which areas require new height and mass standards, which areas in town. We think those are okay.

46:50 Developing the parameters are important to evaluate height and mass, things like building setbacks and stepbacks, view corridors, the ratio of street wall height to street width, the practicality of building construction methods and so on. Those are just some examples. That's an exhaustive list, but we're working hard and trying to come up with a real effective analysis for that issue. And as you probably know, we have a workshop, a joint workshop between the council.

47:20 And the Planning Commission on Hyde and Mass. There's a little bit of an effort working to find a date we can all meet, so I'm not sure when that'll be yet, but as soon as we can come up with a compatible date. The next thing I want to mention is the neighborhood district plans integration. In May, we'll be having that on our agenda for discussing both the south district plans and the integration of all the neighborhood district plans together.

47:50 That integration is important because there are a number of other issues that are dealt with in the integration plan. For example, there are zoning code update items that are part of that integration, such as street front proportion between buildings, which I mentioned with the height and mass, parking management, a number of those things that are also part of the zoning code, so it's important to that. Investment strategies are also involved for building fiscal revenue.

48:19 Capital Improvement Projects are also mentioned there. So there's a lot of facets to the neighborhood district plan integration that are important. That sums up what I've got to say. Any questions? Jay, I can't help but sit here and reminisce right now hearing you say all the things that the Planning Commission is doing and how productive they are. I mean, you guys are just no other way to say it kicking butt. And as far as production,

48:47 I remember when Jay was proposed to be a planning commissioner, and I was concerned that Jay, because he's retired, semi-retired, likes to travel. My concern was justified. But mine was not. And so I wanted to publicly thank you that you have exceeded, I think, anyone's expectations as far as not only you, but the commission in general as well on the level of productivity. And so thank you very much. Great job.

49:17 Jay, I just had one question on your zoning code updates as we're moving forward. People are asking about the process, and it's going through the Planning Commission at this point. I know we have the sign code coming before council shortly now. As it comes before council, the first time it comes before us, is that going to be a review and just a public hearing before council, or are we looking to actually approve? And I don't know if you or Mark.

49:46 Want to answer that? Or what will be the role of the council on this first round of? I could guess, but I'll let Mark, I know Mark will have a more definitive answer. Okay. The planning commission just conducted the public hearing recommending the adoption of the signed code. That's coming to you on May 18th. And as you'll recall, a series of workshops were held well in advance. Staff met specifically and individually with community groups, the board of realtors.

50:15 We held a specific workshop on the concepts of the sign code with the planning commission, and we held that workshop with you, the town council, in maybe February or March. So based on the input that we received in all of those discussions and all of those workshops, we drafted that code for planning commission consideration. We also reviewed it with the zoning code users group.

50:42 I see. So if a property owner were interested or concerned

51:10 Yes, absolutely. Jen Daugherty is the

51:28 Case Manager for this project. And in our packet that will be coming to you, we show some illustrations of what you could do in the future. And we're more than happy to meet with any interested parties and explain, you know, the new code, how it works. And it's, in general, it's less restrictive than the existing code. It's much more business friendly. Great. Thank you, Mark. Thank you very much, Jay. All right. We'll move on to policy matters. Policy.

52:01 Item number one, Town Manager Employment Agreement, and I will turn this over to Andy. Sure. Thank you, Mayor Harvey. You may recall that at the last meeting we had identified there were a couple of small changes that needed to be made to Dave Wilprecht's draft employment agreement. We have since made those changes, and the agreement continued to evolve even after the agenda was published, and we need to make one additional minor technical change to the version that's in your agenda packet.

52:31 We have discussed all these changes with Dave. Dave has indicated that all the changes that we've made since the last meeting are acceptable to him, and they're consistent with all the town's adopted resolutions and other policies. So if you're curious about what the change is, it is the deletion of one sentence from the published draft. In Section 3.4.1, Retirement Benefits, there's an indented paragraph. We're simply deleting the sentence that says, if the service is coordinated with Social Security,

53:01 The final compensation will be reduced by 133.33. We've determined that that sentence, although it's in the town's purse contract, is not really relevant here, nor is it necessary, and as a result, it can be deleted. That's all I have. Thank you. Any questions or comments from Council? Questions or comments from Dave?

53:32 I'm really glad to be here. I want to thank everyone for working so hard over the last months to get this dialed in. It's a very important contract for me personally. I think it's an important contract for the town to move forward with some directions that you have, provisions that you have. I've gotten huge support from the community, which is to be very humbling. People have walked up and thanked me for doing this.

53:58 I guess a year from now we'll all decide if that was a good decision on both of our parts or not, but I'm really looking forward to the opportunity to serve here. I came to the town in 2000 and I was delighted to be here at the time and I had an opportunity to go to the county, which...

54:14 It was a very different environment that I had not worked in before, but I had a chance to be there for eight years. And with that group, with those board members during that time, I was able to accomplish a lot of things that, you know, have really served the town in many ways. And now I'm able to come back and do some things, I think, that all of us will benefit from. And I'm really appreciative of the council and citizens and staff for all the support that I've received. So thank you very much. And I've got my pen.

54:39 Ready? So, as soon as you're ready, I'm ready. I'm ready. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to move that the Town Council approve the Town Manager Employment Agreement as amended. I have a motion. I'll second that motion. I have a motion in a second, and before we take the vote, I would also just like to say, Dave, it's just between the skills that you bring and the experience,

55:10 I think your knowledge and time in Mammoth, your understanding of our town is probably one of the biggest assets that we have got going forward, so I really look forward to working with you, so thank you very much. With that, can I call for the vote, please? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Welcome, Dave. Yes. Yes.

55:34 Moving on to item number two, the new branding for the town of Mammoth Lakes. John, I believe, are you...

56:19 Good evening, Mr. Mayor, Council. Thanks for having me. It's great to be here. Tonight we'd like to just discuss the rebranding of the town and come to an agreement on the approval, adoption, and funding for the rebranding of the town of Mammoth Lakes. I think as most people know, the town and Mammoth Mountain ski area back in 2007 embarked on a

56:56 Opportunity to do some research and really find out what we have for a brand here in Mammoth and what that means to us. There was a tremendous amount of research that was done. There was quite a bit that was worked on through a company called Siegel & Gale to find out exactly who our guests were, who our locals were, and why people were here. And then from that information, the Mountain took that information and came up with the branding through a company called Hornell Anderson up in Seattle.

57:23 And we resurrected that information when I came on board as part of the directive for Mammoth Lakes Tourism was to revisit this information, make sure that the content of the research was correct, that we had enough information to be able to start on the brand again. And part of what we did was we went through it and felt that the research was good, but we did do some local groups as well to research the brand that we were working on.

57:48 And it was amazing. So we were able to take the information again, and we actually went back to Hornel Anderson up in Seattle, who had done the brand for the mountain. The goal here being that we wanted to tie into the mountain, but not into it literally or exactly. I think the biggest telling thing when I moved here was when I told my friends that I was moving to Mammoth Lakes, the first question was, how far is that from Mammoth? So it was a little bit of a disconnect and I think a little bit of an opportunity for us to really take this to another level.

58:19 So as you can see currently, the logo on the left is what we've been using from the Mammoth Lakes Tourism side, and the logo on the right obviously is the town logo. And when we came through the research, we really found that what Mammoth meant to people, it was about discovery. It was about discovery and it was about escape. So we have most of our folks that are coming in from Southern California or escaping Southern California and coming here to enjoy the wilderness with us and all the different activities that we have.

58:47 As you can see, Mammoth Lakes is all about discovery. Discovering the area's rich forest season experiences and outdoor offerings. It's about locals and visitors unparalleled in amazing moments. So from this information, we had the agency start to work on a couple of different mock-ups to give us some direction. Initially, this is what they came back with. They presented two different opportunities to us, and we had a group of probably 30 that reviewed this.

59:14 They went through their explanations as to where things came from and why they had presented this, and then we had the opportunity to ask questions and really throughout the group talk about it and discuss what they saw in each of these pieces. And the logo on the right-hand side, which was, I think, lovingly decided that it was the Dorito logo, it was really geared towards talking about the fact that everything points into Mammoth and everything, this is the center of everything.

59:40 The challenge that we had with that one was the fact that it really wasn't something that we could put out in the marketplace without having people ask questions as to what it is. I think there was an opportunity for us to make something a little bit more deliberate, a little bit more understandable right out of the box. The logo on the left, the general feeling was that based on the discovery that it was a good logo, but it was still a little too corporate. It was a little too harsh. The fonts that we had in there were just a little too boxy, and it really wasn't whimsical to fund.

1:00:10 That we really wanted to present for the destination. So based on the group's feedback, we went back to the drawing board and worked on it with the agency again. The components, when we talk about the discovery, if you looked at the logo, you see obviously it's got the mountain, but there's also the four seasonality of the water, and then the snow cap on the mountain represents an M. So there's part of discovery in that as well when people look at the logo. I showed the logo to someone today, and they...

1:00:39 They still didn't see the water. They still couldn't find the water. So it's one of those things where when you're looking at the logo in its new form, it has that sense of discovery. So after some reviewing and tweaking, and unfortunately you can't see the colors on the screen very well, we've come up with a very earthy blue logo with a gray font. The Mammoth Lakes font on this logo is handwritten, and it is handwritten by the exact same woman who did the typescript for Mammoth Mountain.

1:01:07 So we wanted to make sure that it tied together, but we didn't want to have it so that it tied exactly together. And then we also felt that there needed to be a locator for us to say that we are California. I think there's an opportunity with all that we're doing in international markets as well as reaching out into further states. Southern California is great, but we need to start bringing folks in from other places. And the longer they can stay, the better off we're going to be. So we wanted to make sure there was a locator on it for California. And so this is the logo as it stands right now.

1:01:37 We put together a few different variations based on the fact that we have different applications, and this was part of the challenge that I gave to the agency was, how do I take the logo and put it on top of a visitor guide or a vacation planner? So from a design standpoint, we've come up with the horizontal version, which you see at the bottom there, four places like that. There are certain places where it just works out better. The logo up to the upper right, which we're calling the badge logo, that's an all-encompassed logo. That's just an easy one for us to do stickers or...

1:02:06 Or signs that we don't want multiple pieces to and things like that. So that's the sticker we see on every car in Southern California in the next few years. So to give you a little bit of an idea here, and again, it's unfortunate that the blues don't show up as well, this is how the two logos work together. You know, they're very far from exact, but they are definitely tied in. There are two different shades of blue. Ours, again, is an earthy steel blue. Mammoth is more of a royal blue.

1:02:37 The fonts are very similar, but they definitely stand apart. So this is something that we really wanted to make sure that we had that tie-in so that people know this is one destination. This is just some of the applications that we could potentially see down the road with wayfinding signage and just how the mark can work into that. And the goal here is to actually have the mark work into everything as we move forward. So new street signs, new directional signs, just anywhere where we can tie in the colors.

1:03:09 The type strips, the images themselves, it's a great opportunity to do that. Example of just how it would look on the side of a town truck. This is, I actually had a company that I've been working with for years on signage, sent me three examples of the vinyl for the size of the trucks, and it's pretty sharp. It really does look clean, look clear. You can definitely tell who it is. It's not a hidden typeface in there. So the idea here would be to

1:03:40 Get all of the vehicles switched out as soon as possible, obviously the signage, and to take the brand moving forward. So again, the brand is not just the mark, but it's the feel, it's the look, it's the colors, it's the type shift. So being able to take that and put it into the future development of the town. This mark also represents a great opportunity for branding and for merchandising. I think that this is a piece that...

1:04:07 Really, with the existing logo right now, I'm not sure that we would have that same sort of opportunity to license this and merchandise it throughout the area. Here are just a few examples of potential opportunities, and I think that we could sell these in the Welcome Center, we could license it to different shops in town, and we could really see this be something that people take home with them. One of the other things that I've found out from folks when I've talked to them about the logo,

1:04:33 There are a number of people in town that want to even tie this into their businesses. So whether it's a logo on the sleeve or it's something on their vehicles, just to tie in again a sense of pride for the area. So I think that it has that sort of potential to grow and to have people utilize it in their own businesses. And of course, because we have so many beer and wine festivals, we had to show a pint glass and a wine glass up there as well. And it does look sharp on there. This is just a quick example of...

1:05:03 Moving forward, how potentially we can put together our ad layouts and keeping them very clean, very crisp, very classy. And this is really, you'll see in the next few slides, this is a very basic format and it is something that is very clean. And we definitely want to sell the area on this. These are mock-ups of what potentially we can see with our visitor guide. So when people come into town, they pick these up and it well represents the brand. So this is really the brand expression where we're using the white border.

1:05:35 To tie in and just big bold imaging and some call outs on the things like visitor guides so that we really drive us home that this is a destination that you want to come to. This is a very professional look. It's a very clean look. It's a very crisp look. Same goes for the vacation planner. The vacation planner is a piece that we put out in the market. So this is the piece that goes to the folks in Minneapolis when they call for information or that they log on to the website and request that. So I think just picturing this being something that somebody receives in the mail, it shows us as a very

1:06:06 It just shows the destination in a great new light. This is a very basic mock-up of what potentially our homepage for the website could look like as well. You've got your basic navigation at the top. You've got a series of photos at the bottom that you click through as well. So I think just to give you an idea of how this brand can carry forward and how it can tie in to the expression of the experience that people have up here. One of the things we also have is we have the opportunity with

1:06:36 The year-round recreation guide that's going to be going to print here, I think, in the next few days, to be able to get this brand out and really show people that we're moving forward. We have used the brand as part of Mammoth Lakes Tourism on a few different pieces, including a collaborative 150,000-piece brochure run for all of the event brochure. It's an event brochure with all of the music festivals, cultural festivals.

1:07:02 Fishing and sporting events all into one brochure that will be distributed from San Diego to Las Vegas to Reno to Bay Area and locally here, as well as the posters for each of those groups as well. This is just a little bit of a mock-up of what the business card looks like. It's definitely, again, it's a very clean logo. It's a very crisp logo, and it's something that really has a lot of class for our destination, and I think this is something that gives us a new light in light of all the things that are going on.

1:07:33 This gives us a new face to really be able to take out and show the area in a whole new light. On that, a little sampling of the logo. I'm going to have to serve another year, you guys. Yeah, exactly. Can't waste the cards. So based on the discussion points, as I mentioned at the beginning, our goal here is to seek approval, adoption,

1:08:13 And execution and funding for this process here. And with that in mind, I've been working with the town office and Mark and Ray and just trying to figure out right now what we have to replace. And I think we've got a good idea of really what needs to be replaced within the town. Handful of signs, about 120 stickers for vehicles, some letterhead envelopes and business cards. And I think we're probably looking at about a $30,000 to $35,000 price tag too.

1:08:43 To be able to swap out the old brand and bring in the new brand. And then obviously moving forward, when we look at opportunities like new street signs or directional signs or any of those pieces, that we have the opportunity to encompass the brand moving forward. Thank you, John. Questions for John? Comments? No, I don't really have any comments. What I really like about the whole branding idea is it's not just a logo.

1:09:11 Really identifying all of Mammoth, and it is giving it that unified image that I think we've all been looking for in a sense of place. What I also like is looking at where some of these branding ideas are coming out. I know when we formed Mammoth Lakes Tourism, part of the idea was to try to let Mammoth Lakes Tourism get some legs under itself and get some independence.

1:09:38 You know, there's that potential for raising funds in the future and whatnot through licensing and whatnot, as John has mentioned. I think that's very important. I noticed also that there's, you'll notice also that there's a, the snow cap is also an M. Right. So let's see the water on the bottom. But yeah, I'm just, I'm in favor of it. Awesome.

1:10:04 I was just going to say thank you for continuing the process to a point from the initial two designs and choosing one of the two, which I think was the consensus of the group. Thank you very much. And once you got there, further polishing that one up to get to the point where you are today. Well, I think the point there was that the group, when we sat down, we really felt that this was something we could launch and people would understand it immediately. Whereas, again, the Dorito logo may have taken a lot more.

1:10:33 I was just going to say thank you for a design that is going to be used electronically more than not and that it does read clearly in that case and

1:11:00 I look forward to seeing all the different ways it could be incorporated. I just have concerns that I'll state now over how long it will take us to implement it in the non-electronic forms, like on the website, etc., where it means replacement of things. I do have a concern with that.

1:11:19 I'm sorry, replacing it on time? You know, how long it's going to take us to get 120 vehicles with this new sticker on them, et cetera, all of that kind of thing. I think that's one of the things. Can I break and speak to that at all? Well, I meant to have the money to do that. Okay, that's what I was asking. There was time and money that you were considering. Yeah, I'm just looking at, you know, phasing it in and not having pieces hang out everywhere. And I'm also...

1:11:45 I'm interested to see how it's going to work in with some of the integrated town, forest service, et cetera, wayfinding and some of the signage that we've got in place already. So I'm looking forward to seeing how that works together. Yep. And we have been working with the forest service to put it in as a placeholder as well. If I could make one comment to that. I think it's important that you're right in the phasing.

1:12:15 I think it's important that it is done at one time because if we do it piecemeal, I don't think we have the impact. We don't have the impact of really letting people know what it is. If we have this on the side of half of our vehicles and then we have our new image on the other half, I don't think that it works as well.

1:12:35 Yeah, Nathan. Sorry, go ahead. Go ahead, John. I was just going to say, the opportunity, when I rebranded my resort in New Hampshire, and it was one of those things where we literally tried to do it as quickly as we could.

1:12:46 Because we didn't want to have that old brand out there. And it was one of the things where we were very clear that old uniforms went away, old business cards went away. It didn't matter if you had 50 of them left in your pocket. It's very important with the brand to have that consistency and to be able to put that out there. And we will be, you know, from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we will be utilizing this very far-reaching as well as locally. So we want to make sure that this is something that gets out and about everything from, you know, the potential of taking the top.

1:13:13 John, just to clarify, the $36,000 you feel will pretty much

1:13:41 Make that change. Correct. And that includes the man hours as well. So we've gone through. I've got quotes to replace everything from the sign behind you to signs on some bus shelters, all the vehicles. I've got three decals hanging on my wall in the office with pricing from a sign company that I've worked with in the past. And, yeah, we've done all the math on that piece. Okay. And then you talked about businesses possibly incorporating, which I think is great.

1:14:08 They just come to the town and ask that they can have the electronic image to give to their screeners or... There would need to be some licensing agreements that would be done because it would be something that we... One of the biggest things from this is trademark and one of the things that I want to avoid is any of the bastardization of the logo because we put a lot of time, effort, and money into it and I just don't want to see people drop off the mountain or take off the California. It's a complete package. So it's something that that's a policing thing that we'll work on as well as the town.

1:14:35 Will there be, do you anticipate a fee for people to use it? Yes. Okay, very good. The other thing, you showed one slide there that had the three different versions for different uses. Could you just email just that one page to the council members, please, just so we can have it and kind of see how the different variations are going to be and probably give a little better color idea, too, on our computer screens. But if you would email that to us, I would appreciate it. Absolutely. And like I mentioned, the badge logo on the upper right-hand side is really what we need to contain.

1:15:05 Situation, a contained logo. And that's been, our agency has even suggested that on some of the outdoor signage. For example, the sign behind you would end up being a multi-piece sign where the mountain itself is one piece, Mammoth is one piece, Lakes is one piece, then California are all individual letters that are actually noted. So it's a nice presentation. Okay. All right. If there are no further questions, any comments from the public?

1:15:36 Just to advise in response to Joe's question, as you all know, there are probably 50 plus signs coming to Mammoth Lakes, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, later in the summer through the R stimulus package. The capacity that MLTPA has working with the Town of the Forest Service ensures that should you approve this logo concept moving forward, we can make the swap out and have this logo incorporated into all that signage.

1:16:03 Going into the ground this summer for the Mammoth Lakes Tourism going forward, it's a great opportunity to take a new look and a new brand and a new logo and build it right into the signage system. So that's an opportunity that you guys decide to go forward. With that specific direction, we would figure out a way to make all that work. Excellent. Thanks, John. Good evening, Councilmembers. John Morris, and I actually wear several hats regarding the topic of branding. Currently, a Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board member was on the branding committee.

1:16:38 I'm the current Lodging Association Chairman and Representative of Snow Creek Resort, foremost to come to you as a proud citizen of Mammoth Lakes. And I feel that the need for broad-reaching branding of Mammoth Lakes could not be more evident than after the difficult winter that especially the lodging community in Mammoth has just experienced. Despite record snowfalls, business was not what many of us had hoped to be, and we can only shudder at what a weak snow season could have wrought. I feel it's really critical.

1:17:08 That we stand behind the Mammoth Lakes brand as a united front involving all businesses, public and private, in the town. And we need to, as a community, impress our image, the image of our town, upon our visiting guests, our second homeowners, and have a brand that we as locals can be proud of. We must do this. I feel we must do this to be competitive with many of the destination choices.

1:17:36 Thank you, John.

1:18:12 Hi, Harvey, Councilmembers. My name is Maggie Thompson. I'm president of the Chamber of Commerce, and I'm just here to support this branding change. We work hand-in-hand with the tourism, and I think it's just a really valuable position that the town is taking, so I thank you. And then personally, I want to tell you, I'm going through a branding change, so I can see that John's got everything under control, similar to what we're doing, so we're probably all going to be doing this about the same time. Thank you very much.

1:18:42 Thank you, Maggie. Eric. Good evening. Eric Wasserman, former president of the Chamber of Commerce and current MLT board member, and like John, I wear a few hats. I've helped with the branding process. First, I want to applaud town council and the town for the aggressive cost-cutting measures we've seen. As I'm no stranger to this podium, I've talked about that for years. But when it comes to branding, as you can see,

1:19:11 We did a great job being a true professional in Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and John's done in nine months what really was languishing for the last three years, and it's one of the objects that Mammoth Lakes Tourism was tasked with. I think if we look at the big picture, what kind of message are we sending if we task an organization of creating a new branding?

1:19:36 Campaign. And then we don't spend $35,000, $36,000 to put on some logos, vehicles, letterhead, etc. But it comes down to a tenth of a percent of the town's budget. And these are costs that need to be replaced anyway. People run into business cards. Decals need to be repurchased every couple of years. I think that it's very important that we rebrand the right way.

1:20:02 Look at corporate America. You're going to see right now both airlines that fly into town. Horizon and United are in the process of doing some rebranding with the merger and dropping the Horizon name. And I'll bet you what, those planes will all change. You won't see half of them one way and half of them the other. So by saying the same thing, you don't get half pregnant. We should do this and do it right, and let's rebrand the town professionally and not halfway. Thank you. Thank you, Eric.

1:20:32 Thank you. One thing I didn't mention was within that $36,000, it has funding in there to actually replace what I lovingly refer to as the Bavarian Cheese Village signs out on the highway. If you don't recognize those, next time you come up and look at those. So you finally figured out who those belong to? I did. We've actually been working with John Kaczmarski on who has the permits so we can actually go down there and update those. So we have a nice representation of who we are on the highway as well. Excellent. That's fun.

1:21:01 Thank you, John. Any further questions? We're good. Council, deliberation. If I understand what we have in front of us, it's two-piece options here. One is to adopt the new branding identity, and then the other one is to consider funding within the next year budget, as it's been proposed by staff.

1:21:27 Either by using a general fund or using measure A. I wonder, since we are here on May 4th, whether or not that would be something we would deal with early in the budget deliberation so we can look at it in light of all the other things that we have to deal with.

1:21:49 So that it does not slow people down. If I remember correctly, John, you said you have some stuff ready to go out with this logo on it. Actually, the biggest thing right now, I am using the logo because at this point Mammoth Lakes Tourism has adopted it as a Mammoth Lakes Tourism logo, even if the town does not decide to adopt it. The biggest thing is the year-round recreation guide that they're producing. So instead of having a seasonal piece, it'll be a 12-month piece. And that being going to print this week, we wanted to try and get the new brand on it if possible.

1:22:15 Okay, and I have no problem with that, but I do have some concerns about, again, pulling one piece out when we've got some huge budget decisions to look at. Do we want to break this up and have one motion to adopt the new brand and then continue the discussion on the funding? I'd like to see us go with option one and adopt both pieces one and two, and part of the reasoning behind that is

1:22:47 I understand we need to deal with this in our budget, but there's two things. One, I think this allows Mammoth Lakes Tourism, as I said earlier, to get on their way to perhaps raising funds on their own. And two, I think that a lot of these items, these street signs, directional way of finding bus shelters, etc., these are expenses that would typically be operational expenses within the town anyway.

1:23:15 So I'm in favor of option one, both items one and two. Can I ask staff to clarify? The way it's written, the money would not be available to be spent until July by saying 11-12? Because I think what you're saying, Matthew, is you want to allocate the money now in 10-11.

1:23:44 Consider funding in the fiscal year 2011-12, which is coming up. Which I believe from staff would mean that the money would not be available until July 1st. Yes, but the council could make a decision to allocate funds from the current budget. John, are you looking to have it by immediately or is by July 1st? Well, I think we really have everything in place to run with it immediately. So it's something where we can wait until July 1, but really the brand would not be visible to anybody coming into the summer.

1:24:13 It would be in place for winter at that point. John, is it possible for you, if I may, to go with the work and to wait on the payment of the bills until July 1st? Here's what I'm proposing specifically, and it's very uncomfortable to negotiate in public, but

1:24:42 If there's a way for your organization, someone else to fund the money and then for us to reimburse you on July 1st, that may be a possibility. John Spilling? Yeah, John. I think as the council did last, at our last council meeting and we've done it on a couple of items, one of them was the playground equipment at the Mammoth Creek Park and another one was renewing the contract for our wildlife specialists. This, to me, this fault, that

1:25:12 This falls into that same category. Even though we are burdened, and burden is the appropriate word, with the heavy financial consequences of the airport lawsuit against us, there are certain things that we as the town council and we as the community need to move forward on in a timely manner, and I think this is one of those areas, and therefore, Matthew, I would support your proposal on option number one.

1:25:40 I just want to clarify something that on option number one that Mariana mentioned something about taking it out of this year's budget. Do we have it in this year's budget? Do we have an extra $36,000 in any of our funds that we can take it out now? The other question would be is how would it affect Measure A if we were to use Measure A funds to pay for this?

1:26:03 Two questions. One is, do we have this in the current year's budget? Yes and no. I believe there's some money left in the council discretionary account that we could use, but what it's going to do is decrease your projected surplus that we presented to you at the last council meeting. So we'll just have less money available in the reserves, which are now down to $1.7 million.

1:26:31 The second question on Measure A, basically if you use Measure A money, which is transit occupancy tax in general, you would be in a sense taking that money from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. So it cuts to their budget.

1:26:46 Plus it's a... Excuse me, you say it cuts their budget or it just reduces the surplus that they were going to get at the end of the year? From staff's perspective, it reduces the surplus, but again, they might have planned to use that surplus already because our COT seats are higher this year.

1:27:02 I could imagine that what we initially planned to give you in the beginning of the year is lower than what we will actually give you because of higher TOT seats, but again, Mammoth Lakes Tourism might have had plans for that money already. And that would be money that would be used towards marketing. Without further education to me and the rest of the council on even the appropriateness of taking that money out of measure A, I'm not willing to take it out of measure A.

1:27:33 Tonight, maybe never. Even if we did, it's a slippery slope. It's a small dollar amount, but I'm not willing to go there. So once again, I would support option number one with both one and two and take that money out of our general fund access revenues that we generated this year. So that's because one of

1:28:02 One says to take it out of next year. One is saying next year. That's what I want to clarify, John. One is saying come out of next year, but I agree with you. I would rather pay as we go and not hand out IOUs. And if we, rather than have the 1.7, I'd be willing to take the $36,000 out of our discretionary fund for this year, move forward with it and be done, and then go into the next year's budget without already spending some of it. And I agree with you, but I believe that...

1:28:28 To me, option number one is very simple. We approve the branding identity, and we approve funding of 36 from the general fund. It doesn't say anything about next year's budget. Well, it does when you look on page four. It's different on page six. Yeah, I think what we should do is look at a motion, perhaps, to look at option one with one and two, but instead of having fiscal year 2011-12, make it 2010-11. Regardless of how the options are presented in the agenda bill, the council can, of course, make a motion.

1:28:58 Make any decision you like. Yeah. Right, right. But we just want to make the right decision. We want to make sure we're all on the same page. We prefer to do that the first time around. Then go on page six. So we have a revision there. Matthew, do you want to take a shot at the revision? Sure. I'd like to make a motion that council adopt option number one, both items one and two, to adopt the recommended new branding identity for the town of Mammoth Lakes and

1:29:27 Consider funding of $36,000 for fiscal year 2010-11 for the budget for initial implementation of the new brand. Second the motion. I have a motion and a second for the comment and discussion. If not, we'll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. No. Yes. Motion passes 4-1. Thank you very much. Thank you.

1:30:01 Moving on to item number three. We will TOT collection enforcement issues, a legal memorandum. Andy, is that on your? Council members, I will make the initial introduction. What's before you is an agenda bill that basically makes a legal analysis from our town attorney available to you as well as publicly available. The analysis is on questions.

1:30:36 posed by the TOT Committee slash Lodging Association on a number of legal aspects of enforcing our TOT ordinance. The opinion is attached. I might add that TOT compliance and enforcement is a significant issue for us. It needs to be implemented. And the staff will present to the full council on June the 1st

1:31:04 Our recommendations for the full program, those recommendations are currently being drafted based on the extensive work by the TOT Committee of Residents and Councilmember Lehman. I'm going to stop there and see if there are any additional comments from our Town Attorney. Thank you, Marianna. The nutshell version of this is that the Town has a lot of options. There are certainly some options that you have under your current ordinances, and I think making a few carefully

1:31:31 Drafted and carefully considered amendments to the town's municipal code would give you some additional options. But as Marianna mentioned, there are no really easy approaches. And you can certainly do some community outreach without having to spend a lot of time and money. But when it comes to enforcement, all the options that you have now or that we can develop for you are going to take some effort. They're going to take some staff time. They may take some of our time. And it's something that the council is probably going to want to think about.

1:32:01 How much of a priority this is for you and to what extent you're willing to fund TOT enforcement efforts. And, of course, staff in my office will be happy to assist you with whatever course of action you choose. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions from the council? I think we've been thinking about it for a while. Any public comment? Deliberation? There's one comment. Oh, Terry, sorry. Part of the TOT Community Lodging Association.

1:32:40 I was just going to come up to see if there were any questions, because this is kind of, this doesn't address everything that we were looking at, and we haven't had an opportunity to speak to the town's attorney, and it addresses quite a few things. There's some ordinance changes that we're looking to have happen, and some education, education obviously first. And so, you know, the amount of monies that can come out of this, I think far,

1:33:09 Tell you why we have you real quick, if I may, if I understand what you're saying correctly, would it make sense for us to, let's say, adopt what we have before us this evening as a starting point and then over time make, not amendments, but add to what we're doing here?

1:33:33 I think this is the first step that you have here. And then as we come back on June 1st, it's going to be the complete packet with each step. We're working on a matrix right now. So it'll go step by step by step as to what this looks like, what the education process is, what the research process is, what the letters are that go out if there is somebody that's not in compliance.

1:33:54 And what the steps are after that. So that would be the next thing that's coming to you guys on June 1st. So this is a good start. Yeah, it's a good start. And certainly I'd be happy to meet with any members of the Lodging Association or anybody else that may have additional questions or comments that should be addressed. And we've been waiting. We knew this was coming forward. You needed to adopt this so that we could move forward with the information. Thank you. Thank you.

1:34:22 Sandy Hogan, I'd like to change my hat here to the president of the Mammoth Mills Homeowners Association. In the enforcement efforts, we would strongly support enforcement and stiffer penalties in the single-family residences such as the trails, majestic pines, and the knolls because we do have folks, not too many, but a few who have

1:34:51 Violated the CC&Rs and the town zoning ordinance. We've made the town aware of it. And, you know, nothing, not even the letters have gone out. We have almost a lawsuit action that may happen. You know, it's a lot better if we have the town following up also and notifying these homeowners that they are in violation of the zoning. It's a real serious issue for those folks who live here.

1:35:19 Year-round, and we've lived here for years, and we don't want to see, you know, party houses and five and six autos and somebody else's snow being dumped on their property. I mean, all of this, I could give you plenty of examples, but I'm just, I hope that you will not forget in your enforcement efforts, because I think there is, it's very important, I mean, there are places that are renting for huge amounts, and it's on vacation, you know,

1:35:48 What's the VRBO, Vacation Rental by Owner? Those are huge losses to the town that could be going to legal rentals, and they are losses to the town. It's also a violation. So I hope that this is something that will be included in your enforcement, stiffer penalties, if you think about those for people violating a town ordinance, the zoning. Thank you. Thank you, Shannon. Good evening. I'm Cheryl Witherell. I'm on the TOT Committee.

1:36:23 But I think that it's important, and I want to second what Terry said, that I really think efforts and maybe a little bit more money put towards us working closely with the town attorney will more than pay off for itself on our research. We've been meeting as a group. We met to review the first draft of our matrix of really how we see this all happening. But we've been stopped a little by receiving the input from the town attorney. And I know that it has to go through the process. And I don't know if it's appropriate to ask that if we have further questions.

1:36:52 And we have approval to work with the attorney that we don't have to wait on the input so we can leave this faster. I know that we have a letter ready to go, and Marianna reviewed the letter, but it looks like that won't come to you now until June in the process. And so I don't want to wait so long that the enforcement efforts have to wait for the winner, that we can maybe get some of this done this summer as well. But I really think that the money spent with the attorney and getting the opinions and making sure that we've got this down correctly will more than pay for itself.

1:37:22 Thank you. And I think just to ask Matthew, you're going to continue to work with these folks? Yes, I am. And there's just some issues that we had to bring before Council tonight. Most importantly, we asked for a response from legal counsel. He provided it. But because there was a client attorney privilege, we needed Council's approval to release the information out to the public. And just to kind of wrap up what a lot of people have been saying here,

1:37:51 There is a multi-step process. By the beginning of June, we hope to have that entire package ready to go. That's an educational. It's having new letters drafted for people. There's infractions. Have this matrix completed with new legal language and our new ordinances hopefully at least redefined. I know there's a process. We're going to have to go through a waiting period before we can actually implement them.

1:38:19 We at least need to have that in place. Reason being, these folks in the lodging community, they're going to start taking reservations here by summer. And we want to have that education and enforcement, the educational aspect at the very least going out there with all of the other avenues of being able to address phone calls when people start calling in on this. Because if we don't do this soon enough,

1:38:45 The people are still going to be reserving these properties come summer for the winter months, and we don't want that to happen. So, Annie, I think my question to you would be is to address the issue that they were currently having with the release of information. Will we be able to remedy that tonight? It's already happened because this was included as part of the agenda packet. It's already publicly available. Okay. Excellent. Very good. We're moving forward.

1:39:10 But then if Matthew is on an unofficial subcommittee or we want to make you official, future conversations, if Matthew is there, do we still have the attorney-client privilege issue? The council as a whole, acting on behalf of the town, can waive the attorney-client privilege with respect to anything that I produce. So if you'd like to decide now that the work product that I produce on the TOT stuff can be shared with stakeholder groups,

1:39:40 That's okay. You can do that. I just want to make sure that I have clear direction if that's the direction that you'd like to give. And that doesn't really take a motion. It's more of just an agreement of all council members? Yeah, I think consensus of the council is enough for me. So do I have consensus of all council members? Yes. So you have five yeses on that? Thank you very much. Okay. All right. Any further discussion or motions? I'd like to make a motion that we adopt option one.

1:40:13 Discuss and give direction to staff regarding changes of town municipal code ordinances as outlined above in order to develop a legal foundation for TOT compliance and enforcement efforts. I have a motion. Second. I have a motion and a second for the discussion. None. Jamie, you look perplexed. Yeah. Yeah. It's different from what? Sorry. I was just going to say. I want to kiss that. Is it the one through four? Is it not? Yeah. I have a motion. Oh.

1:40:43 Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Okay. I'd like to amend the motion to include the recommendations as listed. I have a motion. I'll amend my second. And amended second. If there's no further discussion, roll call, please, Gene. Yes.

1:41:04 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. And we will have for you at your first meeting in June a package of suggested ordinance amendments. In the meantime, we'll also be happy to meet with representatives and stakeholder groups to address any additional questions there may be. And, of course, Councilmember Layman can call me any time. Excellent. Thank you very much. Moving on to item number four, the Mammoth View Development Agreement application acceptance.

1:41:35 We will start with staff. Mark? Yes, thank you very much, Mayor and members of the Council. This agenda item is presented to you to initiate the development agreement process by accepting an application for a development agreement between Mammoth View LLC, Mammoth View 2 LLC and Alpine Circle LLC.

1:42:04 And the Town of Mammoth Lakes. The item before you is simply an application. We have not conducted any negotiations to this point. We have not started that effort. This is certainly not a public hearing, and you can't actually take action on anything germane to the discussions of an agreement. What you can do certainly is discuss the matter and present us with any issues you'd like us to study if you do wish us to proceed with this item.

1:42:34 And then we would go on. So again, this is not a public hearing. There's nothing that has been done on this to date. As you recall, in February 16th, the applicant and staff appeared before you with the idea of initiating a development agreement as requested by the project applicant. Their request to you is that the town enter into financial participations.

1:43:03 That may result in capping fees, waiving certain development impact fees and other mitigation measures and then participating in some form of a cash flow agreement principally through a rebate of TOT revenues that may be generated through the project. At that meeting we included a scope of work that would be a financial analysis.

1:43:29 Thank you.

1:43:59 conditions that might guide this effort. The council debated the matter and agreed to initiate the process and had the applicant fund the request. So the applicant has funded this through a three-party agreement, meaning that EPS is working on behalf of the town, although the effort is funded by the Mammoth View applicant. The

1:44:21 The purpose of the development agreement application is to allow some form of an agreement, which, if we do proceed, may not actually be a development agreement. There could be a financial assistance agreement, for example. But this allows you, the council, to acknowledge that this is before you, again, to express any issues, concerns, or things you want us to consider if we should begin those negotiations.

1:44:45 The municipal code actually requires council acceptance of the application, again an acknowledgement that it has been filed. The code establishes specific requirements to process the development agreement, and those have been met by the applicant. We've described those more thoroughly in the report. The financial analysis I think is worth recapping, and so if you don't mind,

1:45:13 I'd like to highlight the major findings conducted and found by EPS because that represents to us the idea that there is value in considering some form of financial participation. If we do indeed receive direction from Town Council to pursue this effort, we'll use the EPS as background information to guide our financial discussions.

1:45:43 Follow some very basic principles regarding project negotiations. One that, you know, it's an open book process and it's very frank and honest between the applicant and the town representing a true partnership that will certainly maximize the public amenities received by the town council and the town and the community, achieving a fair return on investment for both parties.

1:46:08 And then finally equitable terms and terms that are very protective to the town and any kind of long-term agreement that might be reached. And I want to also reiterate that this is not a density bonus or an incentive zoning effort. This is looking principally at financial cash flow between the parties. The project is...

1:46:36 Underway in terms of a use permit and tentative map application. So the project design, conditions of approval, et cetera, will be considered by the planning commission. And they've already done substantial work on this effort. Attachment three to your staff report is the summary findings prepared by EPS. The very first finding is that the price points and revenue and expense

1:47:04 Assumptions in the project pro forma prepared by the applicant are reasonable. So they're not outlandish, and the case that they're presenting to the town makes some apparent sense. Their second point is that the branding of a hotel, which the applicant intends to have a three to four star level of branding, is indeed important to the town. It's essential to achieving room rates and occupancy rates.

1:47:33 Presented in the pro forma, but it's also one of the merits of the project itself. It has long been suggested that branding helps the overall destination resort reach achievement. Financial assistance, number three, is in the amount generally consistent with what Mammoth View is requesting, is required in order for this hotel project to be financially feasible, and it would allow development to occur sooner.

1:48:03 than would otherwise in the pure private sector kind of scenario. Point number four is compared with other project alternatives. The hotel project generates significant tax revenue and other public benefits. The analysis by EPS looked at this hotel project and the current mix of residential and hotel units. They also compared it to a pure residential project.

1:48:34 And then they compared it to no project, which is the third alternative, doing nothing and not proceeding. Their estimates are that the project would generate approximately $630,000 in TOT revenue per year, and that's the hotel project, property taxes of approximately $40,000 per year, and approximately $31,000 in retail sales taxes.

1:49:00 Those comparative rates that do nothing is nothing and just the existing property taxes received and the residential comparative is substantially less. The total of the hotel project in annual revenues once the project is stabilized in occupancy is $714,000 per year compared to $36,500 per year in the residential scenario.

1:49:27 Point five is the proposed financial assistance, if approved as requested, would consume a significant portion of fiscal benefits that might achieve or be realized from this project for a fixed number of years. However, that needs to be compared to the project alternatives. So even though in a short or a midterm, some of the fiscal benefits would not be realized, that compared to dramatically lower fiscal benefits.

1:49:56 And then finally, financial participation requested should be viewed in a broader perspective of community and resort development. For a number of years, through our incentive zoning programs and through project entitlements that we have processed, we have incrementally built a policy framework about density. Density is a form of internal subsidy to projects.

1:50:23 And we continue to work on that policy structure as we complete district planning and the zoning code update. This represents a new theme that we haven't taken on. The idea has been broached, but we haven't had an opportunity to focus on the fiscal impacts and the policy structure for doing this. In this particular case, in our original scope, we talked about this through the EPS work about setting policy parameters and probably the

1:50:53 The practical way to do that is actually through the discussion of this project and bringing to town council terms. If directed to proceed with this, we would begin discussions. We would frame more detailed project alternatives within the parameters set up in the staff report in the fiscal analysis by EPS, and we bring those

1:51:20 We do not want to craft an agreement and all of its technical findings until we have a meeting of the minds on terms.

1:51:50 An appropriate direction from Town Council. With that, the applicant is here. The full applicant team is here this evening, and I'm sure that you may have questions for them. I think they do indeed want to address you. Our staff recommendation for this particular item is that you choose option one.

1:52:14 Which is accept the Mammoth View Development Agreement application, provide any comments you wish to this evening, and we would promptly begin discussions with the applicant team with the objective of responding quickly and coming back for instructions from Town Council. Questions for Mark?

1:52:33 Yes. Mark, I don't understand how if this is something that's new, it's policy that this council has never discussed, that you can go off and start talking about terms with the other party before we've given you direction. Can you explain what your timeline would be? Well, first let me talk about the policy structure. In the alternatives that we're looking at, we've found that the analysis is a reasonable analysis.

1:53:03 Their request has merit. So policy options are do nothing, build a residential project with less fiscal benefits or focus on a mixed-use hotel residential project. The policies that are embedded in those options are really those of fiscal benefits and then the other merits that come with the project, which are branding, momentum, and commitment to implementing the downtown program and achieving off-site improvements.

1:53:32 Some off-site improvements would also accrue to the town, the community, if a residential project would be built. And so the principal difference is in fiscal benefits. And I think our applicant has made it very clear to us, their board of directors is looking at this and certainly time and their own return on investment numbers. And so their options are to get it.

1:54:02 Early and quick feedback from the Town Council so that they can make their decision to proceed with either a residential project or no project or to continue discussions and focus on the mixed-use project. So the policy decisions that would come with this are not the general policy decisions. They're just big ones. Should we have greater fiscal revenue or not?

1:54:29 The smaller policy decisions that might come through the evaluation of different alternatives will really only come through the evaluation alternatives. What is on the table financially may be TOT rebate for certain aspects of the project. It could include variations in permit processing fees or variations of impact fees. But in essence, it's still a large amount of money.

1:54:59 Let me also clarify, if I may add to what Mark said,

1:55:25 Just logistically, what's before you tonight is the acceptance of the application. You really do not, and this is not a forum and not the time for you to give us direction, policy direction or otherwise on how to negotiate. That would have to be done separately. And we need to decide what's the best way for that to happen. Obviously, we need to move forward very, very quickly, as Mark indicated. And perhaps the best way for the council to give direction to the negotiation team is by forming a subcommittee.

1:55:55 And so that might be the process to follow. But what's before you tonight is to accept the application and quickly thereafter to give staff direction on the negotiation parameters. Mark, did I hear you say that you were accepting of the analysis that Walter did and everything that's in it? I think that it's a reasonable analysis for the level of work that they've done. They've looked at the broad pro forma, well, actually a detailed pro forma provided by the applicant.

1:56:27 A confidentiality agreement was entered into between EPS and Mammoth View, which is typical, so that once we receive the information, the competitors are not allowed to see the details of their pro forma. And by hiring Walter and EPS, we trust him. He is acting as our financial expert in this particular case. This isn't giving us detailed negotiating.

1:56:56 It's giving us an order of magnitude that's saying that their request has merit. Some of the alternatives that we should consider are the parameters of time for any form of participation. We have not tried to parse out options, as I've already said, in capping fee structures or off-site improvements. We do, however, on the town side, have limited cash on hand resources. We have limited capital improvements.

1:57:24 And capital improvement programs that we can bring to bear on the off-site improvements. So it's a fairly narrow field of alternatives to discuss. I'll save the rest for deliberation. Any further questions to Stan? Comments from the applicants? Good evening. Thank you for your consideration. I'm Tom Cody with the applicant. This is Hector Caldera. We also have with us Eva Hill and Anirai Haliba.

1:57:58 And we have a short 10-slide presentation that we would work through at your pleasure, but we are willing to forego that, of course, for the sake of expediency, and we're essentially here at your pleasure. Is the council interested in this slide presentation, or do we feel we can move forward without it? I'm comfortable with what I've read. Could I ask just one question of them? Is that when you talk about a residential, which was cabins and townhomes,

1:58:28 If I understand that correctly, if you go that way, why would there be no TOT on those? They would be strictly for sale product with no rental program. But if anybody's in a multi, it would be a multi-unit project, right? Well, what they do, what the town does is they de-restrict the town. So unless we decide to entitle it for TOT, we would not be able to do that.

1:58:56 Okay. Now I'm more confused. But see, that's the kind of detail that I don't necessarily want to get in tonight, but I'm using it to point to the fact that we have to understand what we're telling them to negotiate on what these things all mean. I mean, that is on the full just residential option. But on the hotel option, they would not be de-restricted and it would be entitled as a full hotel.

1:59:25 With residential that would include a residential rental program as well. John? My position on this this evening is it's, to me, we're only being asked to accept an application. We're accepting an application. We're not negotiating. And to me, it's a formality. I don't see what the issue is. We are required as a council to accept this application. So, okay, we accept it.

1:59:57 Staff and the applicant move forward and planning commission on the negotiation. Well, that's where I differ, is I think that council needs to set the policy, we don't defer that to someone else. Right now? No, no, at another date, we accept it, but if you're saying it just goes to staff to negotiate, then you're not giving council... Whatever the process is to negotiate. Through the chair, just, if I could respond to that comment, we're not...

2:00:26 We staff are not attempting to set policy. We're going to frame options through this process and bring them to you so that you can set policy and provide us with instructions. I think a little bit of confusion coming in on this is the fact that we have all of these numbers in here and these suggestions as to what might happen. You know, they're in here and it's confusing. It's kind of clouding the issue a little bit.

2:00:53 It doesn't look like something that we're just accepting an application. It looks like someone is telling us this is kind of what we want if we're going to move this project forward. And in approving this, that we are, in a sense, accepting some of these things as being what we may be willing to offer. And we don't have enough information at this time to take that position.

2:01:21 I agree. This is just about an application. It needs to be made very clear what it is we are approving or accepting tonight and that everything is still on the table for negotiation. So that has to be made very, very clear. I would just agree, Matthew, that I don't need to see the slides for sake of time. I think we're good without the slides. Thank you. Any further questions of the applicant?

2:01:54 Terry, I'll take public comment for a little bit now. Terry Stapp is a citizen of Mammoth Lakes. And I understand that you're just accepting an application here, but as you said, there's a lot of members in here that are quite disconcerting to me. And so since the negotiations, to my understanding, are just going to be between the town attorney, the applicant, and I think...

2:02:24 One, the action town manager. I would just love to at least put my two cents in here. You know, with the monies, you know, I remember an article in the paper that said, you know, how wonderful the project's coming forward that they're not asking anything. So nobody didn't ask for densities. But in this, they're asking for a whole lot of money. And, you know, who's going to backfill the 6.1 that they have in here? Part of that being...

2:02:52 That it's improvements. What I'm seeing the improvements are to a road that's going to service their project and burying lines that are going to improve a view. You're going to be able to sell these for a whole lot more money if you bury your power lines. And so, you know, as a citizen, I just want to make sure that, you know, these numbers are taken into consideration because that's a pretty large figure that we're looking at. Thank you, Terry. Any other public comment?

2:03:24 If not, council discussion. I'd just like to say again that this, in my mind, this is truly a formality. We're accepting the application. Until we accept the application, we can't get into the discussions and the negotiations of things that have been said tonight. So let's accept the application and then move forward with the process to where we'll be able to talk about these issues.

2:03:55 The question on Snow Creek Development Agreement, which was the last one that we did, there was a subcommittee of council, or does this want to come before whole council as we're trying to understand everything that's in that memo? I think whole council. I agree. I also, John, it's almost a formality. I think really what

2:04:23 Mayor Pro Tem Bacon is speaking to arises out of the last negotiation and Matthew and I were not on council. We were certainly in the audience and there was among some quarters a perception that the bus was being driven by staff instead of council. I may be misconstruing what I hear of Joe's comments but

2:04:50 I don't see that this does that. I'm mindful of that, very, very mindful of that. And so the question really is whether, you know, the train moves too far down the track before we have the opportunity to provide the kind of direction that I think Joe would like to provide and many of us, others, others of us would like to as well. I don't see that the action that we take tonight will do that, but there, there,

2:05:20 But I don't want to be in a position where I'm having to choose among lousy alternatives or alternatives that we haven't really fully vetted the implications of. So I'm supportive of the recommendation with those comments in mind. With that, do I have a motion? Mr. Mayor, I would move that the council adopt option number one and accept the Mammoth View development agreement application. I have a motion. I'll second it. I have a motion and a second. Further discussion?

2:05:52 If not, roll call, please, Jeanne. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Before we go on from here, may I ask that we, yeah, further discussion that we have any kind of consensus of when further explanation is comes back, and I'm also kind of wondering is when our third

2:06:17 Session with Walter comes back to us on the municipal finance. June 8th. What? June 8th. June 8th for that one? Thank you. Because I do not want to hold the applicant up at all, I think it's important for us in the community to understand what this memo means sooner rather than later. Excuse me, I'd just like to say...

2:06:43 Obviously, time is of the essence, and I think there are a lot of numbers in the package in front of you, but we are also ahead of it. We have been entirely transparent, as Mark alluded to, with our detailed numbers going to EPS. And so the good news with that is we're kind of ahead of schedule in a manner, but in another manner, it's our ambition, and you heard a lot about economic stimulus.

2:07:12 And fee concessions and things like that before we came up. But it's our, we endeavor to get this project should it be received favorably under construction by May 2012. And if we work our way backwards, we would like a decision by council in June essentially of this year. And so whatever construct and we appreciate and ourselves adhere to.

2:07:39 This notion of transparency, whatever construct you do choose to advance the negotiations, we appeal to you to make it as expeditious as possible. Mayor and Council members, if I could also clarify and elaborate that, again, this is a big project for this community. It's a significant project. There's also significant amount of detail in this report that...

2:08:06 Both the Council and the community need to evaluate and analyze. I understand the urgency and I appreciate the urgency and I respect the urgency that the developer has emphasized and we on our side will work very fast to accommodate them. But again, at the same time, the Council needs to participate in this project fully and you need to give us direction based on your full understanding. So now, so that was...

2:08:34 Clarification to my previous comments to make sure that you know fully and the public knows fully where staff is coming from. Now on the logistics, it may make sense given the importance of this project and how much time this will probably take for us to discuss, not the length of time, but the time during the meeting to schedule a separate meeting. We have on the next council agenda on May 18th,

2:08:59 The beginning of the budget discussion, and that will take a lot of time. So I'm concerned that we simply will not have enough time or the energy to digest a lot of the important items at that meeting. So we will work with you to potentially schedule a separate meeting, a special meeting to discuss this item. I don't know if it's logistically appropriate, but it seems like that since we are going to have, with the budget discussions, a meeting, a council meeting,

2:09:28 Agenda is essentially every week for the month of June that this could, as necessary, could be added to those already agreed upon meeting dates, just as an option. Thank you. We'll move on to item number five, the 2011 youth sports funding. Skip, can we take just a five minute break? Yeah, we'll take a five minute break. Absolutely. We will be back.

2:10:01 Groups, so that they can, you know, if they need a little extra money, we've got some that we can provide to them. The monies that are identified in the fiscal year 2010-2011 general fund budget, and we had eight applications this year.

2:14:10 And of those eight applications, they were filed and received by us back in March, and they were presented to the Recreation Commission on April 5th at the regular meeting. And they went through a rigorous and thorough award process and unanimously voted 5-0 to recommend the council to fund the youth sports program as identified in the table on the next page of your agenda bill.

2:14:42 So I'm just asking for your approval. Questions for Steph? Nope. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to say that I trust that the rec commission did their due diligence and had appropriate reasons to come forward with their recommendation for funding, and therefore I would accept their recommendation and approve option number one. I have a motion. Second. I have a motion and a second for their discussion.

2:15:12 If none, roll call please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. And a little bit out of it. Did anybody else want to speak? Do you still feel in need? Go on up. Thank you all for your appropriation. On the swim team, we actually have to pay our coaches because of their certification. So we're not 100% voluntary program. There's severe strain, so anybody's looking for the program.

2:15:57 You're welcome. Thank you. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you. All right. Thanks, Jeff. Mr. Mayor, if I can, I see in the back of the room we have a young man whose son or sons benefited from the Mammoth Lakes swim program, and at least, did you have a son that swam in college as well? Yeah? Same son. Same son. Yeah. So congratulations, and I'm glad we had the program.

2:16:29 Back when your son was of age to be on the swim team. Bishop, okay. Either way. How many years ago was that? Almost 20 years ago. Wow. Yeah. Good stuff. Alrighty. We will move on to item number six to review the resolution regarding the selection of mayor and mayor pro tem. Staff, I believe, or Joe, or Jamie.

2:17:14 Well, okay. If you remember, last summer was the point where we came to realize that the existing resolution put five people in four years, which is physically impossible, and we had most people having their term of office outside of the term in which they were elected. So this is just a recommendation that since John abdicated, or whatever would be the appropriate word for his year, well, that's possible,

2:17:42 That we continue with the rest of the progression through 2014 and then that the council at that point would decide how they're going to deal with the issue for future years. I guess my only question is why not just change it? Why are we ending it in 2014? To me, because if I understand how you're doing this, it's the top two vote getters and that way

2:18:09 The person who's going to be mayor will always sit in the mayor pro tem seat prior to the year of their state. That is true, but then the third highest vote getter in those some elections would never have the opportunity to be mayor. There's a three letter synonym for that. Start with an S. Yeah.

2:18:34 Well, yes. A council member would like to speak to that. I did that five times.

2:18:50 I don't know if there would be any other way to do it. The other way, but just say the first and second in each and that the third was always left out. Because it is consistent. It is confusing when you have someone sitting as mayor pro tem, but you don't even know if they're going to be back the following year to sit as mayor. And I was totally confused as to what was going on right up until the moment.

2:19:12 I sat down this year and John said, oh, by the way. Skip, is there any interest on your part? I think that councils over the years have a tendency, a propensity, if you will, to do what they want to do, and I don't see this as any different. Things have changed over the years. We can have a policy now, and if it expires in 2014, who knows?

2:19:39 The new council, there's going to be. It might be amended before. Yes. It might be amended after the 2012 election. I think we take a baby step and move forward with this. Okay. Very good. Any further discussion for council? If not, we just can do it all in favor? Aye. All opposed? Just give direction then? Yeah. To update it. Now, so then you have to bring the other resolution back to us?

2:20:05 What's your direction? What's your consensus? That we are going to accept option one, discuss and give direction to staff updating the resolution annually appointing Mayor and Mayor Pro Tem, and we will do it through 2014. That's your direction? There are a couple ways you can handle this. Because you have an existing resolution that is not consistent with how you want to do it going forward,

2:20:28 You could either have Jamie bring you back a resolution that undoes the old resolution and creates a new system, or you could take action in the next meeting to simply repeal the old resolution because you don't want to follow it, and you don't have to have another resolution that sets up the system. Most cities actually don't have a resolution that sets up the system. You can make your own decision as you go. Okay, and would that be a consent item or just go through discussion again? No, it could be a consent item. Something as trivial as repealing the resolution is not a big deal. Okay. Good.

2:20:58 Very good. Direction. All right. With that, do I have a motion for the consent items? So moved. I have a motion. Second. We'll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Passes 5-0. And any questions on the register of demands? If there are none, we will now go back into closed session and report out any...

2:21:26 I think that's the lowest register of demands we've ever had. The lowest amount.