Town Council Special meeting
· recording 1 hr 0 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
112 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Oh, no. Oh, let's see. Sorry. Oh, Kirk says, no, I'm not going to do it. Good afternoon. Good afternoon, John. Good afternoon. Pleasure to see you all. You're all looking good. I didn't, you know, you're all looking good, so let's just, let's go with it. Except for Dan, who's eating, and that's, even on a Zoom, it's rude to eat like that. It's just not, you know. We're just about there. Is everybody that needs to be here, is anybody missing?
1:19 Dan, is everybody accounted for that needs to be starting out here at 615? Yes, all of the three council members and the staff are present. All right, let's go ahead and convene this meeting of Wednesday, April the 28th, council special meeting. Roll call. Council Member Ray is absent. Council Member Staff? Here. Council Member Wentworth? Present. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido? And Mayor Sauser is absent.
1:55 All right. At this time, if there's anyone that would like to give a special comment about an item that is not on the agenda for this evening, is there anything that you're aware of, Jamie? There are no public comments. All right. So the first item, then, is the resolution authorizing the town manager to execute the disposition and development agreement of DDA with Pacific West Communities, Inc. related to the construction of affordable community housing on the parcel.
2:23 And I think we're going to hand this off now to staff. Grady, I believe that's you. Yes, sir. Thank you. Just a quick overview. First, I'd like to turn to Andy to let him describe what we've done with the resolution in our recent discussions with HCD and why we've continued to decide it a couple of times. And if you could hand it back, I have truth writers I'd like to talk about to kind of focus this for tonight and on some things the public might be interested in. So, Andy. Thank you, Grady.
2:51 With the acronyms, if we could maybe say what the acronyms are, I'm sensing we may get into that kind of a forward. So what is HCD? HCD is the California Department of Housing and Community Development. Great, thank you. They're the nice people that provided the IIG infrastructure grant. They are some of the nice people that we hope will be providing tax credit financing to our friends at Pacific. And they're the people who are charged with...
3:20 Enforcing the Surplus Lands Act. And we initially told HCD how we were going to go about this disposing of the parcel. And they tried to apply a requirement that I don't think is in the law. They suggested a different path. And so then we told them, OK, we'll do that different path. And then they told us, well, we think you still have to comply with this other requirement that's, again, not in the law.
3:47 We said, okay. So we had a call with them on Monday and tweaked the resolution just a little bit. And as of today, they're happy with it. They're encouraging us. They say the resolution is fine. They think our process is fine. If anyone cares, in a nutshell, what they asked us to do is to make a finding that the property is exempt surplus property, which is fine. So that's what the resolution says. It's exempt surplus property for purposes of the Surplus Lands Act.
4:16 The resolution also says that the housing to be built on the property will meet these other standards that require quite a bit of affordability. So that's what we're doing. We've got the resolution squared away. HCD is happy with it. Pacific is okay with meeting the affordability requirements of the path that we're going down. And we think that where all systems go, if the council feels comfortable moving forward. So I'll give it back to Grady.
4:43 Thank you, Andy. And this is a quick summary, and I know that we have another meeting after this, so I'll keep it fairly short, but I did want to cover a couple of things. In case somebody from the public has not had the opportunity to tune in to other meetings, they can get a brief summary of it right now. First of all, we believe as staff that we've brought forward to you at DDA that really provides the protections that the town council is looking for, the community needs, and also provides the flexibility.
5:09 For us to move forward with the whole project. So that's what we've been working towards for several months. We think we've done that. We've responded to every question that we can. Three other items I'd like to touch on. First of all, there's been a concern in the community about the affordability levels. This is an affordable housing project. The DDA and the master plan do allow for some 120% above, 200%, possibly even some market-rate housing at some point in the future. But by and large, this is an affordable housing project.
5:38 The IAG grant actually lays out a spread of affordability levels, if I could. The IAG grant itself includes 450 units. Within that, and I'll go through these boring numbers for the benefit of the public. They're all in your backup documentation. But it actually includes 30 percent, or excuse me, 108 units out of the 450 are for residents 30 percent AMI and below. Another 133 are 50 percent.
6:06 127 or 60%. What that means is out of a total of 450 units, 368 of those are about 82% or at 60% AMI, and that's average, I'm going to say median, and that's incorrect, Sandra. I'm going to get rid of the acronym for John, right? That's the area median income. Area. Thank you. Area median income.
6:32 Thank you. Thank you. I knew I had one of those wrong. I wanted to make sure we got that right. So the area median income. So 82% of the projects as planned in the IAG grant fall under that. We did check with MLH, and we believe, and Sheldon has also talked to MLH, that this will satisfy, well, what was the waiting list here towards the end of last year, which was about 90 people. I think it's up to 115 or 20 now. But these first 81 units.
6:57 Fall well within that category. And in fact, phase one out of 81 units, all but one of those are 80% below. And see, 48 plus 15, 64 of them are 60% below. So we really think we've hit the target that the IAG grant requires and that MLH has on their current waiting list. Next, I'd like to talk a brief about parking. It's been a big issue. We think we have a process to mitigate any...
7:24 Thanks, Grady. I think the council remembers that when we talked about the master plan, we did talk a lot about parking. And the master plan includes minimum requirements for parking. So through the design review, the town council is able to look at each phase of the project to determine whether or not that parking minimums are acceptable.
7:51 And to require additional parking as needed. So we found that during phase one, the town council gave us direction to come back to the town council with additional information on parking showing how all of this is going to work. So that just shows kind of how the master plan is operating as we go through and review and approve these design review phases. So, Grady, anything else on that? Any other thoughts on that one?
8:14 Well, that's good for parking. I appreciate that. I didn't want to get into a huge amount of detail. We've got several staff reports and multiple pages for that. But the last item I'd like to touch on is density. During the public outreach process, plan the parcel, we heard everything from leave it alone, open space, to 172 units, to, frankly, on the walk around, somebody asked for 750 units and cut down every single tree. So we heard it all. Where we ended up?
8:42 Was a master plan that has an exhibit in it for 462 units and a master plan and a DDA that contemplates anywhere from 400 to 580 units. We believe that the master plan has the appropriate controls along with the DDA to allow this town council and future town councils to set the density where it needs to be. Every time a development area comes before council for disposition.
9:08 You'll have the opportunity to look at that density, decide if that's correct or not, see how the design's going on the one that's already been produced, frankly, and get a good feel for what that level of density on the parcel really means. So we think it does provide that flexibility. What I'd like to do now is go ahead and give our staff recommendation, which really is to recommend that the Town Council authorize the Town Manager to execute the DDA with the adoption of the resolution as presented.
9:35 And gives the flexibility, like I said, the flexibility we need and the protections we need to move forward. With that, we'd like to answer any questions that Town Council or certainly the public, as you see fit, has. Thank you. Thank you very much, everyone. Let's start with the Council. Any questions on any of this for staff? John, would you go ahead? Thank you. So, my understanding, at the last meeting, Councilmember Stapp requested some additional time to review the language in the agreement.
10:06 And my understanding is that there's a slightly changed version of the resolution that we saw at the last meeting. But other than that, there have been no substantial changes other than the language, Andy, that you proposed in the DDA has now been accepted into the DDA. Is that all correct? Yes, that's correct. Thank you. Thank you, John. Kirk, do you have any questions? Yes. If you look at page nine,
10:35 In our agenda packet, page one of the disposition and development agreement on recital F, it says 580 residential units serving individuals and families. You know, I think that that number needs to be, boy, 580s on 20 acres. Anyway, I think that that needs to be reduced down to
11:02 I still want the grants and everything, but they're reduced down to 450. So, thank you, Kirk. I'll ask staff, is there any, Kirk, you said that was on page 9 under F? Yes, it's on page 9. Okay, I have this 9 now. Okay, so you're saying that we're at lists in that first sentence of F.
11:35 Up to 580 residential units. Staff, would you like to speak to that, please? I'll go first. And we did respond as best we can to the questions we heard on this subject. You know, staff went through a lot of public outreach on this plan, the parcel and everything. And what we came back to, again, as I stated earlier, and not to be argumentative, but was a range, a DDA and a master plan that allowed from 400 to 580. Certainly that 450 is within that range.
12:08 But it's at least, I'll say this one staff member's opinion, and Sandra, Dan, Danny, you can speak yourselves, but that the DDA and the master plan provides the flexibility for this town council and for future town councils to limit it to 450 as we move forward. We can certainly do it now. We can certainly change the DDA to limit it to 450 on the outset, but that opportunity is also there at every stage of the parcel as each and every...
12:35 Different development piece is transferred or is proposed for transfer to Pacific. So let me ask you a question. If we were to change this where the recital said that it was a by 450 units and then in
12:51 You know, 15 years when they're getting ready to do the last parcel and there's some innovative change in housing units and the way that housing is built. If that council wanted to readjust that back up, what would be the process to that? Well, I'll let Andy speak to the development agreement, but in terms of the master plan and the environmental documentation, we could do so because the master plan and the environmental documentation does allow that. Andy?
13:18 Right. So the procedural approach would be to go to Pacific at that time and tell them that we would like to bump up the maximum and get their concurrence to amend the DDA. I mean, the DDA is in the nature of contracts. We can't amend it unilaterally. But if the council at some future date wanted to bump up the unit count that's theoretically possible and Pacific was amenable to it, the council could do that at that time. There's not a way in the DDA to constrain future councils from making changes.
13:48 Right. Okay. So, Kirk, let me come back to you with that question then. Adjusting the number in this piece of the DDA to 450, do you feel that that would be a more safe place for us to start on this DDA?
14:04 Yes, I believe it, because there is a history. When the town bought that particular piece of property, it was, again, 172 units were to be built there. Now, we tripled that number, and I'm saying, okay, that's fine, and especially looking at the AMI of the units that are proposed to be on that. But, you know, again, I'm quite sure that neighbors are not aware.
14:30 of the number of units that we're talking about. So I'm looking at, you know, the history of it and the neighbors that have been around there that think that there's going to be 172 units built there. Okay, Kirk, other than that question, do you have other questions for this evening before we bring this to a vote? Let me look at, no, the financing, it looks good.
15:07 Again, the idea of, I mean, this would not completely stop me or anything, but the idea of 1.3 spaces per unit, we're going to have overflow cars parking in the adjacent areas around there. So when you look at 1.3 spaces per unit,
15:36 That's another reason I was hoping to reduce the number of units in there, because most of the workforce in the community, like in Aspen Village, has two cars, and when their kids hit high school, now there's three cars. So that was my thinking in relationship to that. I appreciate that, Kirk, for you continuing to be our advocate for reasonable parking.
16:05 Does staff want to speak to the implications of those parking limits within this particular first parcel alone? So I'm happy to just kind of talk a little bit about it. So as I mentioned kind of briefly, the way that the master plan is set up, it allows staff to evaluate and bring forward to decision makers each phase, every part of the project on a phase-by-phase plan.
16:32 So that's an opportunity for us to evaluate the parking requirements, the minimums that are listed in the master plan, and then present that to decision makers to see if that works. As we saw with phase one, we did present that parking ratio of around 1.3 or so, and the council wasn't really comfortable with that. And so what they did is we added a condition of approval that requires us to come back to council.
16:59 To have you all review and approve a parking management plan. So really kind of another ability, another opportunity to talk about parking, talk about how it's going to be provided as part of phase one. So I think in staff's perspective, looking at the parcel on a phase by phase basis is really appropriate because we can talk about kind of all of these things.
17:21 Way off in the future, but we don't quite know what's going to happen in the future. We don't know if there's going to be innovative parking techniques, if maybe there's going to be other things that make it so that we don't really need maybe 1.3 spaces is okay. But the way the master plan is set up, it allows everyone to evaluate that on a face-by-face basis. So I think that's kind of the bottom line, I guess, for parking. So what I'm hearing is we are not committing ourselves for the entire development of the parcel.
17:51 Linda, if I might respond to that, look at the existing housing projects that we have built, how parking has been a problem in each of them. I mean, if you look at
18:21 Manzanita, I mean, they park in the snow cover or the snow storage areas. So, you know, parking is expensive, but it also has been an ongoing problem. So I was hoping, yeah, I was hoping that, you know, we might be able to address that up front so that parking in the snow storage area is not in a constant conflict in the winter.
18:51 Thank you, Kirk. I think that what we have before us tonight is this parcel at this time to move along into development and securing the funding sort of in a more immediate fashion. So as far as being able to change that first F from the 580 down to the 450 that you recommended and going ahead and
19:20 Being able to know that we can come back and study this and mitigate this as we would move into the second parcel, would that be most of your questions for this evening? Linda, if you're asking me a question, my response is that, you know, the resolution of the Town Council on this particular one, on G, as long as the parcel concept plant provides up to 450 units of housing to meet the community, with that one change, I would be comfortable.
19:53 Okay. Thank you. Very good. All right. On that note, do I hear a, well, first, is there any public comment on this? Yeah. It's also, it's mentioned in two different places. One in the resolution and in the DDA. Okay. On page, page nine. It's under F, under the recitals. So if we could change those to 450, I would be very comfortable. Okay. Thank you.
20:25 Well, and then to be consistent with that, we would want to tweak Section 4.2, which has the range of units that would be allowed in each phase and currently says that the range is between 400 and 508. So we would want to do a little bit of work with Pacific to figure out how to reduce the unit count in each phase to get to a maximum of 450, I think, to reflect Councilmember Stapp's request. But that's something that we can work out with Pacific in the next few days, I think. Okay.
20:56 So Andy, okay, let me back up a little bit. Any public comment on this particular question, Jamie? Tom Cage, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Unmute, thank you. It seems like you're sectioning this off into just the density. So if that's the case, my comments are more general. So stop me if you want me to wait for this to progress.
21:28 I recognize that the Town Council has the ability to look at this as it goes along in density and parking restrictions. I guess my question is the what-ifs. I mean, how do we control the development once we give up the ownership to Pacific? How do we control the amount of units that are at market rates once we give up the control to Pacific?
21:58 How do we control the parking once we give up the control to Pacific? This, I've asked a number of people around town that stay fairly aware of things, and none of them realized that we were selling the parcel to Pacific. And I guess I worry about what if they come back and say, gee, we didn't get as many grants as we wanted, so we can't move forward with this. Or what if Pacific says,
22:26 We need to do more market rate for 120% or 200% AMI because of the changes that have been made. I mean, are they posting a bond? Do we have any control over this long term? Because we don't have a great record of entering contractual agreements with people that have come into town, i.e. the wood site.
22:57 I'm just scared that we're losing our last chance for big affordable housing development. And if we give this away, what ifs to me are more important than do we build 450 units or 500 units? That can be done over the next 15 years as this development rolls out. But nobody that I've spoken to was aware that we were selling basically
23:28 The site and entering into this agreement. So I'm just concerned that we're not going to anticipate the what ifs or have the agreement written to where they're going to maintain it in a certain way. They're going to build it in a certain way. They're going to be obligated. What if they say we can't do anymore? Do we get it back? Do we, you know, and at the end of that, last point, at the end of this,
23:58 This process, when it's all built, and I'm going way out, far past my pay grade, but when we go way out, this will have a positive cash flow, and the town should benefit from that, but we're selling it. We're not going to have that benefit. So I'm concerned that we're doing that. I question the transparency of everything, and I welcome your responses. Thank you.
24:27 Okay, I'd ask staff to... I will take a stab at that, and Tom, I don't know if you're watching our video, but this is Andy. So we're not selling the entire parcel to Pacific all at once. The way this is going to work is that we will sell a chunk at a time to Pacific. The DDA calls for six different phases. So as they complete one phase, if they're doing fine, if we haven't had any problems, if they're complying with all the obligations...
24:55 And then they're ready to take down another chunk for another phase and we'll sell them that next chunk. So it's not a question of selling all the property and then hoping that Pacific will comply because there are a couple of things preventing that. One is that we're only selling them one chunk at a time. The other is that they have to comply with affordability requirements that are in the IAG grant. They will have to comply with affordability requirements that are in each.
25:23 They're going to be stitched up as tightly as we can make them so that there's no confusion about what it is the Pacific is going to build. Before they take down the land for any given phase, they have to tell the town how many units they're going to build and that the town has to be okay with that or the town has to say, no, that's not the right number. We'd like you to build a different number. So the number of units and the affordability levels will be agreed upon.
25:51 Before there's a sale and will be memorialized in the sale agreement for that chunk. This is not just sort of giving them a bunch of land and then hoping for the best. This is intended to keep Pacific accountable, make sure that they perform the way that they say that they will and give the town a lot of control over the process. Thank you, Andy. Any more questions? Yes, Sean?
26:29 If I may, just to add a little bit to what Andy said, I think he did describe it well, but just to address Mr. Cage's concerns, one of the things that this project will hopefully cash flow as the different phases are developed and then as they're leased up and as people are living in them.
26:52 And as these phases are successful, the town will be one of the lenders to each phase and will enable, they will have regulation, regulatory agreements, loan agreements, and restrictions around each phase. So they really are, you know, the town really is at the table, if you will, for everything that, you know, not only in regards to any, you know,
27:18 All right. No more questions at this time.
27:51 Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido, Tom Cage has raised his hand again. Did you want to hear from him again? I was kind of waiting to see if he had a key. Thank you, Tom. Go ahead. Tom Cage, please unmute yourself. Sorry. Sorry. Thank you. I guess to the points that Ms. Rodriguez and Annie brought up, how does this work in that are we dividing the parcel into multiple parcels because it's one parcel?
28:23 So how do we retain the ownership of the property? I'm kind of confused on the mechanics of how do we enforce what Pacific builds, how many units Pacific builds, how many units at market rate Pacific builds that they can sell as opposed to lease? And I'm a little confused on the clarity of how we can enforce that.
28:53 And what if Pacific comes back and says, gee, we didn't get enough grant money, so we can't build 400 units. We can only build 300 at a 120 AMI, and I'm just, you know, giving you ballpark numbers, and we need to build 50 units at market rate in order to make this pencil. How do we avoid that pitfall? Thank you, Andy. All right, let me take a stab at these questions.
29:21 Parcel will be parcelized. For the first phase, we don't need to. We can do a lot line adjustment because the parcel is actually two parcels. So we can reconfigure the two parcels so that phase one stands alone and convey that to Pacific. After that, it will be a tentative map and then a final map to get the rest of the parcel chopped up in a way that we can sell chunks of it at a time. The town will retain ownership of the streets and probably the little wetland area and the multi-use path.
29:50 But only sell to Pacific as much as they need for each one phase. And as for how we can enforce the affordability requirements and the unit counts, each phase will be the subject of a purchase and sale agreement that will have conditions in it explaining what Pacific has to do. And there will also be something called a regulatory agreement that's in the nature of a deed restriction that prevents higher rents from being charged going forward.
30:20 The town of Pacific will be parties to agreements that specify the affordability levels and the unit counts. If Pacific were to try to do something different, the town would sue Pacific for breach of contract and would get that stopped. Also, if Pacific comes to the town at some point and says, we don't want to build the number of units that we agreed to build back in the DDA, the town is not obligated to sell them the land for that next phase. There are minimum unit counts.
30:48 In the DDA, so Pacific tries to build, proposes to build less, we'll say, no, you don't get the land. Again, before Pacific can purchase the land for any phase, we will reach agreement with them on the affordability levels and on the unit counts, and that will be stitched into the purchase and sale agreement for that phase, so that for each phase, there's something in writing committing Pacific to build exactly what we've agreed upon with them and have affordability levels at exactly what we've agreed upon.
31:17 So it's not a matter of hoping that Pacific will do the right thing, but not really having any way of compelling that. This is intended to set down in black and white what each party is going to do to give the town meaningful remedies if Pacific tries to deviate from that path. But I will say, I mean, it's appropriate to be cautious. Town's had a little bit of a checkered history with development agreements, but...
31:43 We have not seen from Pacific anything other than a willingness to do what they say they're going to do. They've built a couple projects up by me in Truckee. They've performed on those. They do what they say they're going to do there. They've done what they said they were going to do on previous Mammoth projects. And, I mean, without trying to sound like a Pacific fanboy, Pacific, I mean, Caleb and Andrea and Michelle and the team, it's the most trustworthy developer I've ever personally worked with.
32:11 And that doesn't mean that they'll always be that way, of course. And it's right for people to have questions and it's right for people to want to know that the town is protected. But I'd say Pacific has a good track record and we look forward to continuing to work with them and for them to continue doing exactly what they say they'll do. Any other questions right now? Tom Cage, please unmute yourself. So thank you, Andy. I appreciate that. And I'm sure they are in all good faith.
32:51 representing what they plan to do. My last question is, on the $20 million grant that we've received so far, and I believe that's for infrastructure, but you can correct me if I'm wrong, will that be sectioned off as each phase gets developed, or will they use that entire grant at the beginning, phase one, to put in?
33:15 Water, electric roads, et cetera, et cetera. And I won't disturb you with any more questions. Thank you for your explanation. But that first grant that I understand to be about $20 million, how will that be handled? Thank you. If I could, I'll let Sheldon get into more detail that she wants. What we've seen from the IAG proposal and what they've given us in terms of spreadsheets is that of that $20.6 million or so, which is that IAG grant,
33:45 Over time, that should cover the cost of all the public streets, roadways, and utilities throughout the phases. A significant portion is also allowable for use on-site for podium parking. It is shown to be over, I think it's five phases shown, correct me if I'm wrong, for spending those monies. One of the key parts, though, is there's a contract that is the I&G contract, which will come before pretty soon, which shows how many units they have.
34:15 We don't get reimbursement for those IEG monies unless they produce the actual units. So if for some reason Pacific only builds 300 units, they only get three-fourths of that $20 million back, so that money's not available. It's a commitment to build those affordable housing units. It actually gets that money out of HCD. I don't know, Shell, if you want to provide more detail on that, but it's pretty tight and you have some pretty substantial performance requirements.
34:44 Yeah, I don't have anything to add, Grady. I think you, it's pretty complicated, but I think you described it exactly how it, how it, how it all plays out. Thank you, Sheldon. Thank you, Grady. Jamie, are there any other questions from the public? No, there are not. Okay. That being said, would someone be willing to make a resolution on this? Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I'd like to have some discussion on this item, if we could. Absolutely. Go for it.
35:18 Yeah, I'm a little concerned because these items that Councilmember Stapp had brought up, these are both items, the maximum number of units of parking questions are things that this Councilman Stapp spent many, many, many, many, many, many hours on. And I believe we had a series of consecutive votes where we repeatedly approved those items.
35:48 So I don't quite understand why it is we're going back and looking at these again. We continued this item because Councilmember Stapp had not had a chance to sufficiently read the document. So I would like to understand why we are reviewing these things again. And I'd like to understand a compelling rationale for dropping the number down from 580. I think we've had hours of conversation on that.
36:17 It's very clear that that is not, that's a maximum allowed density in the environmental document. That is not something that we're proposing to actually do. I would really like to understand why it is that we're changing, why would we be entertaining to change and make a change at this point? I think it's very important, again, for the council as we make decisions and we lock things in as we move forward in very complex efforts like this.
36:44 That we stick to the things that we voted on, the things that we've agreed to. And I'm just concerned that, you know, hey, I'd like some more time to read something, and then all of a sudden we're opening it up and revisiting some of the fundamental foundational understandings and the agreements we've brought forward. So I'm frankly concerned about that. So I'd like to hear a little bit of council discussion. I'm not, I know how important it is to move forward with this. We need to move this thing forward.
37:11 I'm not comfortable with how we're doing business with this. I'd like to have some discussion about that. Thank you, John. I think those are good points. You're correct. We did in prior meetings and numerous prior other votes had discussed this and it had been ongoing. We were comfortable with it. And now we have, you know, Councilmember Stapp who is, you know, not comfortable with that and wants to see about changing at this point. I agree. It is a little bit.
37:41 You know, wondering why, but I'm willing to, you know, discuss that further, Kirk? If I might respond, Mayor Pro Tem. Remember, it wasn't in our packet the last time it was brought to us. This is the first time I've been able to read this. So it's nice to say, you know, well, we've had these, you know, we've had these discussions or we had this information before, but we didn't.
38:08 So this is the first time I've gotten to read all the way through it. And yes, you know, I'm not comfortable with 580. I look at what our grants are available, so that's why I look at 450, so we can get those grants and we can move forward on this. Again, I just remind...
38:31 Folks that I was involved with the election back in 1980 at 172. So I have some responsibility to some of those old timers that are still here. Thank you. Yeah, but I just want to make clear, Kirk, that 580 number, we've voted on that. I can't even count how many times we have reaffirmed that 580. That's why I don't quite understand why we're revisiting that at this point.
39:02 I think what Kirk is stressing is that seeing it as part of the DEA is the first time that he's seen it there. So perhaps that's why there's a new conversation around it. Remember when this came forward, it was up to, and now all of a sudden it is now we're looking at developing 580 or 500 or whatever, and I'm not comfortable with that.
39:32 So, yes, I've opened the door for it, and I accept that responsibility. But at this particular point, after being able to read everything, you know, I look at that density on that particular piece of property, and I'm very uncomfortable with it. Well, Kirk, just to be clear, just humor me here for a second, but I'm reading this, and it still says up to 580 units. So the language hasn't changed. Am I wrong about that, or is that still consistent with what we voted on in the past?
40:05 I don't believe the language has changed either. I am uncomfortable with the language at this point in time. This is the same language that we voted on to be in that you supported in the past. John, I changed my mind. 450. I don't quite know what to say. So, in order to proceed with this first parcel, understanding that there is still ability to go into...
40:38 A phase of changing this or adjusting this up to the sort of general of the master plan for subsequent town councils in order to reach consensus on this item, can we accept a change to this, go forward, let the tax credits become available, let the funding begin, let the work begin? Are we able to come to consensus around this and move this forward?
41:06 Madam Mayor, I accept the fact that future councils can change and that they can change the number of units being built there. You know, the issue before us today is 580 or 450. I am comfortable with a 450 and we can move forward or, you know, I can make my vote, my voice heard and we can go wherever it goes. Okay. Council Member Wentworth. Well, again, just to be clear, that is not a question.
41:34 This is not an either or choice between 450 and 580. I just, again, we need to be clear about what we're doing. The language before us clearly states up to 580, meaning not to exceed 580. It is not a binary choice of 450 or 580. So, Madam Mayor, pretend we need to be clear about what we're talking here. This is not a binary choice. It's a cap. It is a cap.
42:05 And I'm comfortable with the cap. And I'm comfortable with having a decision space as we've designed this entire process. As Tom Gates is asking these questions about how do we guarantee that the community is going to get what it needs. And we put together a very sophisticated program to ensure that that's going to happen. And I think we've all done excellent work together. And I think that this is exactly what the community needs at the time that it needs it.
42:33 And the fact that we have allowed a not-to-exceed and up-to number has been part of that package all the way through. You know, and again, we need to clearly state that this is not a binary choice. It is still a not-to-exceed 580 number. So I could point out that unless we are able to come to consensus on this item and pass this resolution tonight,
43:03 Okay, so Madam Mayor, can someone propose some language that if, as you've demonstrated,
43:33 Future councils have the ability to raise that number. If someone could propose some language, so we're not capping this with 450, but with the understanding that we're setting at 450 now, but preserving the future councils that have the ability to raise it should they see fit. If someone could propose some language along those lines, perhaps I could support that. Okay, given that, I will look to our wizard of words, Mr. Morris.
44:04 Well, we could… Were you asking, Lynda? I asked Andy if he could help us make a proposal for this resolution. Thank you. Well, I've… Okay, a couple things. My understanding is that the master plan might have called for something above 450. It might have been 462. So, that's…
44:32 One thing, I mean, you could make 450 the max, or you could make 462 the max to be consistent with the master plan that's already been approved. But aside from the number, I suppose what we could do is have an additional paragraph in the resolution, and you'll excuse me that I'm looking at the resolution rather than the camera, that says something like, be it further resolved, the town council acknowledges that at some future date,
45:01 It may need to revisit the number of units in or within the parcel or something. So you could have a motion that rather than me trying to draft this completely on the fly, you could have a motion that would be to adopt the resolution with whatever number you like and with the addition of one more paragraph that indicates that the council has the authority to revisit the number of units permitted to the DDA at some future date.
45:30 The subsequent town councils may revisit the number as desired. Yes. Yes. Just to clarify. It's dicey enough that I don't want to just try to do that on the fly right now. I was just going to clarify that the master plan does allow up to 580 units. So all that would need to be changed in the future would be the EDA. Right. No master plan amendment. No new CEQA. That's already been done. Okay. Right here.
46:04 Andy, can we say on paragraph F, developer intends to develop a property with an initial goal of 450 residential units? Yes, you could say that, yeah. Okay, so moved. Okay, and just so that I understand, we're not changing the resolution at all. The reference to 580 units in the resolution is not...
46:36 I'm not sure that needs to be changed because that's just a statement of fact. The personal concept plan does describe up to 580 units. So as I hear it, the motion is approve the resolution as presented, approve the DDA with that change to recital F and with changes to the table in section 4.2 that we will work out in the next couple of days with Pacific. So moved. Any further comments or discussion? Jamie, I can restate the language you would like.
47:14 I got it when Andy restated it, but there's no second to the motion yet, Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido. Thank you. Do I hear a second? I will second it. Okay, Jamie, roll call. Councilmember Stapp? No. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido? Yes, I'm sorry, I didn't hear Kirk. He said no. Okay, and as we've previously discussed, all resolutions that the council might want to adopt have been approved by a majority of the entire council, which in this case...
47:53 It's three people. So although it's a 2-1 vote in favor of the resolution, the resolution fails, or the motion fails, I should say, the motion to adopt the resolution. So I'd like to propose a motion to reconsider and I'd ask Councilmember Stapp to propose some language to keep the application. Councilmember Stapp.
48:16 Then the only, the change I would say in the resolution would be the parcel concept plan. This is under G, the whereas. The parcel concept plan provides up to 450 units. And just for clarifying, I recognize future councils can change that number. But let me read it again. The parcel concept plan provides up to 450 units of housing to meet community demands for attainable and affordable workforce housing.
48:46 So I have a question for staff on that. Andy, this resolution and that number is referring to a master plan that we've already adopted. This is about we're changing language in a resolution referring to a master plan. It occurs to me what Kirk wants to do, he wants to change the language in a master plan. And I need to get a clarification on that if that's what he's talking about. Well, I'm not sure. I'll let Councilmember Stapp speak to that.
49:14 But the 580 reference that's in the draft resolution does not speak to anything going forward, doesn't apply prospectively. It's simply an item in a list of things that the town has already done with respect to the parcel. I mean, it says the town identified guiding principles and development objectives that included a concept plan of up to 580 units. So that's in the past, and that can't be changed and won't be changed by this resolution. I mean, that's something that's already occurred.
49:44 So I'm not sure what to do with this. And it is that Councilmember Stapp is wishing to put in language that he is more comfortable with around the ultimate build-out of this, not to, in his thoughts, demand a 580 build-out but start with a 450, understanding that every parcel and every council will be considering that next parcel.
50:18 So by putting it in this DDA, it doesn't feel like there's any need to permanently change a master plan, which, as you said, Andy, cannot be done at this point. Madam Mayor, if I might ask for a five-minute break, I need to confer with the town manager. All right, five minutes. We'll be back.
50:44 Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido, I would also like to note for all the people who are waiting for the 640 special council meeting that it has not occurred yet and it will be late, obviously. Thank you. All right, we'll convene back at 710. Wait a minute, wait a minute. You're on page. Dan and Kirk, you might as well want to mute yourself. Hey, Jess, you might want to mute yourself. On again? Are we on? Yes. Oh, okay.
56:28 Okay, thank you. Are we about ready to... Yes, Linda, ready to come back. Comment from staff? Is John back on? Thank you, yeah, I'm here. Let me see if I can articulate the discussion with Councilmember Stapp. The resolution, the amended resolution as presented today would be a motion to approve that with...
57:18 Striking Section G relating to the parcel concept plan, just taking that out of the resolution. I don't think it is required to be in the resolution. I'm fine with that. And then the two amendments to the DDA would be in the recital Section F. Developer intends to develop the property with up to 450 residential units. And then the chart in Section 4.2.
57:47 Would need to be amended by agreement between staff and Pacific to show a maximum number of 450 units, a minimum of 400. And then it's recognized that a future council could amend the DDA in the future, modifying those numbers as desired. I'm okay with all that. I have an idea for how to give effect to that last sentence that Dan said about future councils. I think that the...
58:19 First sentence of recital F in the DDA, the one where we're going from 580 units to 450, it could say something like 450 units, comma, subject to potential future Town Council approval of a different number. Yes. Yes. That sounds reasonable. John? That works for me. Thank you. We want to tee that up as a resolution. Yeah.
58:57 Do you want me to restate the motion as we've discussed? The motion would be to approve the resolution authorizing the town manager to execute the disposition and development agreement with Pacific West communities related to construction of affordable community housing on the parcel as amended for the resolution to strike section D and for the DDA to change section F to
59:30 450 units subject to potential future Town Council approval of a different number. Change 4.2 the chart to 450 units as well. Okay. Can I have a motion to approve resolution? Madam Clerk, you did say delete item G, right, in the resolution? Yes, I did. Okay, thank you. Madam Mayor, I will amend my motion per what was just stated. Yeah, that was...
1:00:03 Councilmember Stapp, motion. All second. All right. Any further discussion or comments? Marina and Jamie, roll call, please. Councilmember Stapp. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Salcido. Very good. Yes. All right. Thank you, everybody. We will then now adjourn this meeting and then reconvene within five minutes on the next meeting. Anybody have the link to do that? Are we good?
1:00:33 It's the same link. You do not have to go anywhere. Okay, that's right. Everybody's here. Let's just do it. On that note, I think, is the mayor available? Yes, dear. There you are. I knew I saw you there. Okay.