TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2021

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 48 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

233 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Last meeting. Yes. And then on to Mayor Sauser. I will open this Town Council special meeting of Wednesday, April 28th. Roll call, please. Councilmember Rae. Here. Councilmember Stapp. Here. Councilmember Wentworth. Here. Mayor Pro Temp-Salcido. Here. Sauser. Thank you. Pledge of Allegiance, if you would all join me in the pledge and begin. I pledge allegiance.

0:37 Thank you. Public comments. This is the time when any member of the public wishes to comment on anything that is otherwise not on the agenda. Jamie, public comments, please. There are no public comments. Thank you very much.

1:08 Policy matter number one, joint meeting between town council and the board of Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And I will open this meeting. And Dan, you want to give us a little? Yes. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. I'll give you a quick little introduction and then turn it over to yourself and Chair Morris for, John Morris for the MLT board. The items before you on the agenda deals with the

1:37 Agreement between the town and Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We attached a copy of the previous agreement that's currently in place the remainder of this fiscal year. The agreement was originally structured to cover three years. Then every each of those three years, we do an update of the deliverable section. We do the compensation structure and then be able to make those amendments to move into a next year of the agreement.

2:04 I also attached a copy of a set of proposed deliverables. That's one of the elements each year to look at where the expectation is being set. That walks through a number that's gone back and forth between some staff from review and the MLT board. There's a couple of questions in there still. So that's kind of the, if you will, the technical meat of the elements that are before you this evening. But it also affords you the broader opportunity to really have an open discussion.

2:32 With the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board regarding the overall scope of the board and the direction within the agreement, the overall scope, setting expectations, what do you believe the vision should be for MLT as it relates to the relationship with the town council. So it does have a great opportunity to have a much larger discussion. Ultimately, staff direction that we're looking for is...

3:00 The ability to move forward and complete an agreement as maybe directed, agreed upon by the two boards here and then bringing that service agreement ultimately back for approval. Glad to ask answering technical questions, but otherwise this is an open discussion between the two boards. Thanks, Dan. And that's really what we're looking for here is sort of an open discussion. I know there are some questions coming from the MLT board.

3:31 As to what the council believes the direction is or should be. And John, I will open that up to you guys to ask us any questions to start us off. Or do you want to? Yeah. Yeah, thanks. Thanks, Mr. Mayor. And thanks to the to the town council and all the folks on the call for being here tonight. We really appreciate it. In summary, as Dan said, you know, we normally the way this process normally works is that.

3:59 John Urdi usually delivers the or proposes the deliverables to the town council around this time of the year. We just felt that it might make more sense since there's a lot. Obviously, we have a large budget and there are a lot of changes over the last year with COVID and pivoting on messaging and lots of different things. It just seemed to make a lot more sense if we could just have a one-on-one discussion, our board with the town council and really.

4:28 What we're really here for and what we're looking for, our board is looking for, is input from the town council to us, direction if you feel that any of the deliverables are off base, if you have questions about them, now we appreciate comments and questions and honest dialogue about it because MLT, obviously the staff needs to

4:54 Get going on what they're going to be doing for fiscal year 21-22. And this is the time that we start gearing that all up. So it wouldn't make a lot of sense to start that process and then have council say, well, wait a minute, we want you to do something completely different. So that's really the reason for asking to have this meeting. And again, we appreciate the time with you guys. Mr. Mayor, quite honestly, it's really...

5:22 Really, the opportunity for you folks on the council to ask us questions or to pose concerns about anything that's in the deliverables, if they're not clear or if there's a different direction the council wants to go. We'd just love to hear from you guys individually on what you think about this process going forward. I hope everybody's had a chance to look through the deliverables. They're not that long.

5:49 You know, we've been through them several times. We've made changes. But we're really looking for input from you guys. Well, I can tell you, John, there's way too much legalese in this contract. Let's go back to shaking hands. The contract? Yeah. Quite honestly, I know the contract. I think, forgive me, but I think the contract is really there for sort of for reference. I don't think we were really proposing.

6:20 To talk about the contract, unless there were some major concerns on the council's part about what the contract says. That contract, I believe, if I'm not mistaken, it's in place until 2023. It's just boilerplate. I'm just complaining at how tough it is to read that stuff. That's not mine. I will take it to council if you have any questions of the board or comments to make on the

6:50 Both scope of services and deliverables and what was number C and compensation on any of those three items. Now would be the time. Linda. I'll defer to others to go ahead since I'm on the MLT board. I want to hear what everyone wants to say. Okay. Bill, excuse me, if I may. The key deliverables that we're looking at in discussion begins on page 26 of the packet.

7:18 It's the 21-22 deliverables versus those that are attached to the contract, which had been for last year. But the scope, overall scope in the agreement is still current. Okay, does anybody want to start this thing or you want me to go? John, Kirk, Sarah? I can start. Go ahead, John, thank you. So, thank you, MLT board for reaching out. We very much appreciate having this conversation. The first thing I'd like to do is you could all turn your video cameras on so we can all see you. I think that would be helpful.

7:53 I got a couple of questions I'd like to ask of the board. So Michael, Matt, that's all staffed on there. So first question for you guys, just a raise of hands, how many of you have been watching the town council sessions where we've been starting to work through our priorities for the coming year, our strategic direction? Two and a half, maybe. Okay, good. It's just an important thing, I think, that we as a council need to ask. We just had a, the reason we're delayed is we had a long discussion about housing.

8:28 We only had one member of the community show up to ask any questions on this. I think for the councils in this COVID virtual world that we're in, we don't know who's hearing what and what you know where we're at. So I'm going to open up with my observations just by sharing that the council has been working diligently on establishing a new set of priorities for all of us going forward. One of the things we recognize is that we're coming back into a

8:57 Very uncertain world. It's a world that is not like it was a year ago. And I'll put up, I'll ask a quick poll of the MLT board. How many of you think that we're going into a new and different world than we were, say, a year and a half or two years ago? So most of you think we're going back the same way the world that was the way before? I think that's maybe something that the, for the Council on the MLT to have a conversation about, because I don't, what I'm hearing from the Council is we are not going back into a world that was...

9:28 Like the way that it was. We've got challenges in that space and challenges that we want to figure out how best to address. I think that on a high, you know, the job of the council is to establish policy and to demonstrate leadership. And I think what I've heard also from my fellow council members is a frustration about how

9:54 The communication happens between the town council and policy and direction that we set and the NGOs we work with to carry those things out. And frankly, it comes into this sort of contract writing process that happens between the town manager and representatives of the various NGOs. And then it all comes down to the last minute. Oh, it's kind of take it or leave it or, well, we can't really change anything. And the only way to really deal with what we're doing is to say, well, let's cut off the money. Let's just say no and stop funding it.

10:24 That is, from my perspective, that is not an intelligent way to move forward. MLT is a critical part of our community and our destination. And frankly, we are not done completing our strategic priorities and directions for the next year. So a number of things that we're working on. I think the town is working and the town council is working on figuring out how we are going to own our share of the marketing and destination equation.

10:52 How do we make sure that from our side of things, we make sure that the experiences that people have here are ones that are worthy of them coming up here? And we have a role to play in that, and we need to play our part in that. But if we're going to step up and do our part, we need to be working with MLT in a very specific, coordinated program to make sure that we're all going to be successful. I mean, you know me, I've got plenty more to say. Mr. Mayor, I will...

11:20 Stop for the moment. I'll just throw those things out to get started. I will just close with the council has not finished establishing our strategic priorities yet. We are in the process of doing that. It's a very important conversation that we're having. I would encourage you to tune in, but Mr. Mayor, thank you for that time, and I'll leave it at that for the moment. Thank you. Thank you, John. Sarah, would you like to go, or do you want me to go? You can go ahead. Thank you.

11:47 So I'm not as convinced as John we're going to enter into a whole new world. I think there are a lot of things that are going to change. But looking over this contract, there are things in the scope of services that is really not what we're dealing with tonight, but that gives us, I believe, the latitude to do what it is that John's talking about. It talks about quality visitation. It talks about diverse experience opportunities.

12:15 And creating them some with the tourism dollars, something I would like to see MLT get more involved in. And the reason I've pushed through the years, and John, Irdi, and myself have had this conversation many times, to get MLT to step up to that plate more and make it partially about that, partially about marketing, is because that makes it a more dynamic organization. If you're spending money on...

12:42 We have already chopped the marketing budget from what the original measure A

13:11 Political commitments were several times taken close to $2 million a year out of that plate. So that being said, I really like all of that. Going down into the scope, there's one thing that stood out to me that is said several times in here, and that's the earmark of the reserves, if you will, going straight to housing.

13:40 And legally, and I've talked to our legal counsel on this, and he can weigh in, he is still with us. We cannot do that. We can say we have the intention to do that, but we cannot cumber future counsels unless it's in a contract to something like a building contract. So it sounds good that MLT is going to give up all of these reserves.

14:07 I'm rambling, but the way the reserve structure is currently set up is the MLT gets to weigh in on how they're spent, but it's up to council's purview to expend those money. MLT doesn't actually have control of them. Mayor Sauser's legal analysis of committing future funds is spot on. Thank you, Andy. So that's something we cannot do legally is encumber future councils. So that part doesn't work.

14:36 Other than that, for me, most of what's in here to develop diverse experiences coming through your own budgets works extremely well for what my, as one council member, what my priorities are. I'm pretty happy with everything that's in here except for that, and I'm not looking to make any significant changes. There's a lot of people, you know, saying we need to take a lot of money for a lot of things.

15:03 But the fact is, I know what happens when you completely eliminate your marketing arm. You start to lose your market share, and it takes forever and a whole lot of money to get it back. So that's my little diatribe for now. I will move it on to any other councilman that wishes to speak. Kirk? I have nothing to add. I think Mammoth Lake Tourism is doing a great job, almost too good, because of the overcrowding periodically.

15:34 So I have no, no, I support Mammoth Lake Tourism. Thank you. Sarah or Linda? Yeah, I've got a couple comments, Mayor Sauser. Yeah, I sit on the board and so I've, you know, sort of been party to some of the discussions previously about this and I support all of these deliverables. What I'm constantly thinking, though, are there other deliverables that we just haven't thought of?

16:01 Are there other ways to sort of improve the situation as far as tourism goes and handling? And I'm going to reference this article that John sent out. John, did you send this just to the board, the strategic approach for thought consideration by Carl? Yeah, board and MLT staff. I did not send it to council. Okay. And the reason I bring it up is that as I read through this, it struck me that this has a lot of charts and a lot of strategic things that are interesting, but

16:31 You know, not maybe to everybody. But what it brings up in here is how the playing field has changed in marketing organizations. And what is the right amount of money, I think, is part of the discussion. You know, what is the right amount of money between TOT and TBIT for Mammoth Lakes Tourism to deliver on these official deliverables?

17:00 For 21-22. And Rob, I know that as we discuss the budget for next year and how that would inform the amount of money going to TOT, I mean to MLT as part of their percentage, maybe you could speak to that a little bit because what I'm getting to is, you know, how do you determine how much is too much? You're right. I mean, there has been a steady decrease in money going to MLT over the last few years.

17:27 Based on both the resetting of the percentage and the sort of committing all of the reserve monies into housing. So based on that, I am interested in how much we're talking about would be going into MLT. Thank you, Linda. I appreciate that. Looking it up sort of as we speak. To speak to the numbers,

18:01 As we allocate them, obviously what council has decided that 2.35% of the TOT dollars that are budgeted is what is allocated to tourism. And in the last couple of years, you're correct that we have adjusted that a little bit and taken some of the funds and allocated them to the chamber. And that reduces the amount that goes directly to MLT.

18:28 And anything excess above what is budgeted then goes into that reserve account. As correctly stated earlier, it is a reserve account that MLT has the ability to weigh into, but not necessarily full control over. Looking at this current year's budget, the amount allocated to tourism is $2,339,200, and that is the total.

18:57 Associated that 2.35%, 14.5 million, which is our budget in TOT for 21-22. As opposed to what it would have been this year. Yeah, this year it was $1.751 million to MLT specifically. And next year again would be what? $2,339,200. So my question is then,

19:29 How much is too much? How much is the right amount that goes into TOT to do their deliverables here? And I think that is where some of the discussion is will be going into the next budget year. And I think we don't want to let go of this in this discussion because I support these, you know, deliverables completely. I support the sort of change of direction that MLT has been able to present to the council.

19:58 In that, you know, okay, we got enough maybe people coming, but how do we handle them better? How do we provide other activities for them? How do they, you know, live more happily with permanent residents and the tourists? And I think everyone on MLT is on exactly the same page with that. And we all realize that that's an important time. But when you dive into the money and the contract, what is the right amount based on what our budget is? And is an increase of that much money between this year and next year?

20:25 And is there more we need to do to talk about that? You know, Lynda, I'd like to just add one component. So looking at the two numbers that I gave you, the allocation is based strictly on the amount of TOT that is budgeted for the year. Prior years would be more comparable to what we're talking about for next year, 21-22. Last year was significantly less because we budgeted $11.2 million in TOT.

20:56 When prior to that, we were in $13.5 million, and this year, a million higher than that at $14.5 million. So I think the differential between last year and this year is really going back to a normal versus a heavy increase. I think last year there was some significant cuts that had to happen maybe to accommodate that. So just some more clarity. Thank you. Okay, I think that's all I have. Mayor Stelzer? Go ahead, John. Yeah, so...

21:25 Linda, I appreciate your line of questioning there, but until we at a high level know what we're doing, which I'm not convinced that we do know what we're doing, any discussions around money is maybe perhaps a little bit academic. Mr. Mayor, I would love to hear from the members of the MLT board around a relatively simple question. Given that the tourism industry globally has probably been the most

21:54 The hardest and heavily affected sector internationally, nationally, and the entire planet by COVID. I'd like to hear from members of the MLT board their sense of what kind of a tourism marketing world are we going to be returning into. I'd like to know what the board is thinking. We can not even go one at a time or maybe some volunteer, but I'd like to hear from them. We can go there, but let's get Sarah's first.

22:23 Thanks, Bill. I appreciate that. I don't have too much more to add. I agree with Linda that I do think that MLT has done a great job of pivoting these deliverables to, you know, kind of our new world. I just keep coming down to these numbers.

22:48 When every week I'm hearing someone else tell me that their landlord's kicking them out of their house because they're selling it and that they don't know where they're going to go. And every time I go to bonds, I have the cashiers telling me they, you know, it's too much. It's too much. Like, when's it going to stop? And then I look at these numbers, 0.85 for housing, 2.35 for MLT.

23:16 I'm not the smartest person in the world, but looking at the numbers, like we're giving a lot of money to this thing that people are crying uncle and every week people who make good money, you know, nurses, firefighters are unable to stay here and business owners can't keep their staff. So these things are connected. And I know I sound like a broken record, but.

23:41 Just keep coming back to just, I'm just looking at these numbers and the way we're allocating this and our visitor experience is going to suffer this summer because there are not employees who can afford to live here. Thank you, Sarah. Getting back to John's question, Mr. Morris, starting with you to call out your board, would you like to make comments? Sure. Thank you guys for your comments. Those are obviously very helpful and I think we...

24:13 For the most part, most of us on the board, we've all talked about these things and we pretty much agree with them. What world are we going to get back into? You know, it's a little bit of a guess right now, but I have to say, I mean, from my standpoint and from what I'm seeing from the lodging community, what we saw over the last couple of months, what we're seeing going forward, I do not think that we are going to see a

24:44 If I had to guess right now on what we will actually, what our TOT actually will be in Festival Year 2021, 20 million, not 14 million, 20 million. It'll go back to what it was two years ago because we are a destination that is going to, I hate to say this, but it's going to benefit from people at this point not wanting to travel as much by airplane and people wanting to, you know, be able to.

25:12 Yeah, do some go someplace that's relatively close. And we have all the attributes that people are looking for fresh air, mountain, you know, everything that we offer. So I am extremely optimistic about this next year. I do not believe that I'm being foolish about it. I really do believe that from what I'm seeing and anecdotally from all the people I've talked to and lodging that we're going to be we're going to be busy. That being said, you know, Bill, you and I have had discussions about

25:42 And I don't want to go too much into it right now, but about revenue management and so forth. And yeah, we have issues during a couple months of the year where we're really busy and there are probably too many people in town. And that's a discussion we need to have as a business community of how we handle that. And there are ways of dealing with it. So I will turn it over to...

26:08 Whoever else on the board would like to speak to it, but I'm optimistic. I think we're going to have a very strong fiscal year. And again, you can't budget for, at this point, I don't feel that you can budget for COVID. You can't budget for fires. You can't budget for drought. You have to make assumptions that the things that, at least in my world in business, I cannot present a budget that way to my boss. I have to present a budget based on what

26:36 On the average, what we're going to look for. You can't control certain things of nature and we don't budget for those things. So we make adjustments if we have droughts or if we have fires. We have to, yeah, we have to make drastic adjustments, but we don't budget for those things. So we're optimistic. I'll let anybody else who would like to speak and I will mute myself. Thank you, John. Yeah, I'll step in as the newest member of MLT.

27:07 John Mandel. I look at it pretty simply. I didn't grow up in the tourism business. I grew up in the consumer goods business, automotive primarily. And I have a degree in economics as well. So I'm looking at the basics of retail savings being at the highest they've been in 45 years because they haven't gone anywhere. They haven't spent money. I look at the second largest

27:41 Purchase that most people make, which is an automobile, so I still follow automotive fairly closely. It's running at record levels right now in spite of the fact that dealers can't get vehicles. It's running at an over 18 million annual rate, which would be the highest it's been in the last 10 years because people are out spending money. I share John's optimism. I can't put a number on it because that's not my, I have nothing to prove.

28:10 I can't predict what TOT is going to be, but people are out to spend money and they are out to buy leisure, which from an economic perspective, that's what people do when they become or feel somewhat flush. Most people do. They're also buying houses, which drives housing prices up and lumber prices and everything else. If you bought a two by four in the last year,

28:40 You'll know it's now about $10 a piece. But I do think people are out to spend, and I think that we have to be there when they want to come. I think we have to be one of those destinations and promote the convenience and the opportunities that people have here in Mammoth to come spend their money and spend their leisure time. I am very bullish on the coming year. Most of you who have had your second shot,

29:12 Have shared the same elation that I have over being somewhat unbridled. And I never thought that just a day trip to Bishop would be high on my priority list. But that has become a high point of my week when I have to do it versus going somewhere else. So given the opportunity, I think we're pretty good indicators as to what people want to do.

29:43 And I think people are going to want to travel, and I think we should get them in Mammoth. Thank you, John. Eric, Clark, you want to? Yeah, thank you. I appreciate the time. And thank all of you for trying to solve all of these issues that we have. And we know we have a lot of issues. And what is the world going to be? It's definitely going to be different, John Wentworth. I mean, it is.

30:13 We've come through and we've pivoted more than we ever expected. And I'd like to make, before I give you my kind of prediction of demand, I'd like to make a comment on the contract too, because I know by watching some of those sessions that all of you are going through, trying to figure out the strategies, I know your frustrations from dealing with the NGOs. And as you look at Mammoth Lakes tourism here,

30:41 John said it really well, John Morris, in the sense that, hey, we want to come and have an open dialogue and make sure we're addressing the issues that you see. And the contract is built that way. Yes, there's an overall scope of activities that we're focused on, but each year we're going to be doing something different, and that's where the deliverables come into that contract. And, I mean, we never imagined that we would have to pivot.

31:10 So with that said, you know, demand is absolutely expected to come back.

31:36 And there's a lot of people that are more than just cautiously optimistic about that. They're very optimistic about it. And there's indicators in the market that are showing that. And I can give you we're happy with our Icon Pass sales. And we think that's going to drive destination visitors, too. It's not just going to drive people driving. But over the last year, what we saw.

32:05 Was, for instance, a Bear, a Snow Summit, the regional areas did extremely well. A Crystal Mountain, those types of areas, our friends up at Switzer, they did really well because they're a different type of destination. We're what we would refer to as a super destination. So we're not full on super regional destination, excuse me. We're not a full on

32:34 Just destination like Steamboat. Steamboat's full destination. Almost everybody flies there. They stay there six nights and they're there. But Mammoth has this incredible drive market from Southern California that comes up. They're going to be visiting us. But we also think that we'll see a lot of visitation from other parts of the country that want to come try Mammoth, especially in the wintertime.

33:01 We know we see that in the summertime with our national parks and so forth. So I think that there will be a lot of destination visits. And when you look at the overall travel industry, I think you have to really highlight the fact that the outdoor experience too is in our favor, right? People are wanting to go do different experiences, get out, feel comfortable with that. And so that's what's going to drive it for us.

33:31 As we continue to plan, we have to understand who are the people that want to come visit us, what do they want, and how do we give it to them? That's our service philosophy. It's something that's ingrained with us that we're asking every time that we sit down in a strategy session, every year that we look at our overall strategies versus what our tactics are for that year.

33:54 And I think that even with all these challenges, Mammoth Lakes is poised to really achieve its goals of trying to get a visitor here that's staying longer, that want to experience more from our great environment that we have and all the amenities that we can give them, and stay longer, spend more.

34:21 And not be as peak and valley that the current weekends sometimes drive. So very bullish. I think we'll see a lot of destination visitors as well. And it will be a challenging year because things will be different. Regulations will be different. Oversight's different. But very bullish on it. Thank you. Pat, go ahead.

34:53 Yeah, I just want to echo Eric's thoughts. I agree with him that we're going to start, especially the Icon Pass, especially, I'm sorry, considering the Icon Pass the last couple of years, I'm starting to see more and more jets coming from somewhere other than Southern California. And interestingly, I'm seeing a lot of them coming from Colorado, which I never had jets coming from Colorado. So I think the Icon Pass is going to make a big impact on where people come from. Short term,

35:22 I think that MLT's main focus needs to be education. Last summer, we kind of got caught off guard. I don't know if anybody saw the influx coming that we got. Frankly, we kind of got rocked back on our heels. We can't have that again. I think that we need to be working with the town. We need to be working with the Forest Service. We need to work with the community, educate visitors. What is appropriate when you get here? I think we need to be throwing money at bathrooms,

35:52 Trash pickup, just working with the host program. The more we can do to educate our visitors, the better we can do. I was talking to others about this in our summer visitation. When you boil it down, it's really a 45-day period. Starting July 1, right before 4th of July, that's when we really get hit and kind of starts wrapping up, tapering off at least about mid-August.

36:19 People start going back to school, kids start going back to school. We've got a 45-day chaos period that I think is our main focus right now. And I think between all of the different organizations, we can figure this out. Long term, I agree with Eric. I think that we've got a great opportunity with the Bishop Airport and moving air service down there. I think we've got the opportunity to attract destination visitors. I think we've got...

36:47 Thank you, Pat. Jeremy, thank you so much.

37:17 So I'm the Chamber Representative on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, and I want to speak to Sarah Rea's concern on workforce housing, because that is a big concern for the Chamber of Commerce. What we've heard Pat, John Mundell, John Morris, and Eric Clark say is exactly what I'm gearing up for as an operator at my business this summer and next winter, which is record...

37:45 Record years. That's what I'm planning for is a record year. December with the closure was the worst December I've ever had, followed by the worst January I've ever had, followed by the best February and the best March once we opened up. So I'm expecting that to continue. What we've seen during the COVID is that markets that depend on air travel and international travel have suffered. Whistler.

38:13 Was a disaster this year. We're not in that boat. We're drive market. We don't even have commercial flights going. And, you know, once the stay at home order lifted, we were totally fine. You know, we were extremely busy dealing with operations. And it was challenging because we're coming off of being completely shut down. Once we were opened up again, you know, the business was there. And so I'm expecting that to continue.

38:43 The outdoor recreation industry has absolutely taken off. You can't travel internationally. You can't go to sporting events. You can't go to music venues. You can't go to large gathering events. Pretty much the only leisure out there, entertainment out there is getting outside and being active and recreating. That's what Mammoth has in abundance. And it's an easy drive up to 395 and everybody wants to get out of the city.

39:12 You know, it's kind of the perfect storm for everybody wanting to come visit Mammoth. So, you know, the deliverables articulate what, you know, you see our change in strategy here for Mammoth Lakes Tourism. The goal is no longer to get as many people here as possible. We feel inundated. We're aware of that on the board.

39:38 That's why we are proposing this new strategy of enhanced education. It's not so much inviting people to get here as managing the visitation now, managing people while they're here, educating them, getting them involved, making sure they're good stewards and they're doing the right thing when they're in our town, when they're in our area, when they're recreating here.

40:03 From the, you know, kind of getting back to the workforce housing, the chamber perspective, that is our biggest challenge. I think you could probably say a couple years ago our biggest challenge was getting people here. I don't see that as being the case right now. People are coming. So our businesses need to be able to handle that. And right now workforce housing is the number one problem. I hear that from my staff on a daily basis.

40:32 I have interviewed and hired multiple people throughout, not even just the last year, throughout the last two, three, four years that don't end up working for me, very qualified, you know, good, you know, individuals that don't end up working for me because they can't find a place to live in Mammoth. So I know that town council from your discussion before we got on here, you know, with

41:01 Thank you so much.

41:31 For the next six months to a year, we are going to be extremely busy with operations. There's no doubt about that. So, you know, in short, I want to see, you know, definitely efforts at the town level put towards workforce housing. The chamber is happy to help with that. Mammoth Lakes Tourism is aware of it. I don't know that it's really Mammoth Lakes Tourism's job to solve.

41:59 Workforce Housing, I don't see that as, you know, that's not a goal for us, that's not a focus, but it's good for us to be aware of, and it is, you know, it is forming our strategy for this year with the education that we're looking to provide, the tactical change with, you know, putting money towards the stewardship and the hosting.

42:27 You know, making sure that we're not inundating the businesses to where we're just breaking everybody's back because we want to avoid that. So, you know, it's a fine balance between all these things and discussions like what we're having tonight, you know, John Wentworth, to your point, is what needs to happen to make sure we're all on the same page and we figure out the solutions to these. So, you know, I think Mammoth Lakes Tourism with the deliverables here is articulating a plan.

42:56 Thank you. Jeremy, you know, you state that

43:25 The goal of MLT right now is educating and managing these visitors. So we'll come back to Linda's question and ask, how much is enough money to meet that goal of managing and corralling these visitors? And how much do you not need? How much is enough? I'm just going to hop into that. Again, I think it's a legitimate question. But I think the role of the town, when I hear

43:57 Records, money, big, huge. You guys all understand that that lands on the town as social challenges. That lands on the town, housing, the value of the recreation experience. Are we devaluing our destination just for some short-term DOT numbers? That's a short game. We don't want to be playing the short game. So we're listening and we're hearing all this.

44:26 But I think, Sarah, as we continue with our prioritization and we identify what the role in the town is going to be with this, then I'm looking forward to having those types of financial conversations. But for me, getting to that before we figured out what our role in this is going to be is premature.

44:45 And I need to push back on the idea that Mammoth Lakes Tourism, the amount of tourists that are coming here, is not tied to housing. Because, hear me, you said it yourself, you have people, you can't get employees, you've hired them, they can't end up working for you. So they are absolutely tied together. And to say, this doesn't have anything to do with this is disingenuous. No, that's exactly right. So have I missed any board members before I speak again?

45:17 Michael? Yeah, Bill, thanks. I'll chime in. I don't have much to add on top of what some of my esteemed colleagues have already offered. I'm bullish on the future short term as well. I don't see globally, you know, I'm not as bullish on...

45:39 The new world, as I heard it described earlier, because I'm just, as a student, literally academically and personally of healing behavior and consumer behavior, what I see is a dramatic and drastic need for people to get normal.

45:55 To be normalized in their lives. And we see that just with the unwillingness to almost wear masks and other things at times. It's normal what they're trying to get back to, as John Morris pointed out earlier, everything from concerts to gatherings, all of the weddings and birthdays and anniversaries.

46:16 That have been missed and so forth. I do think short term Mammoth is going to be a prime destination for all the reasons that John Morris pointed out and others that, you know, right now, you know, you can't even travel to many countries by air or sea, right? Cruise lines are still shut down. Air travel is not only restricted or mitigated, in some cases it's just banned. You try to go to Italy right now. One of the largest, you know,

46:45 So I do see staycations and short-term high demand for Mammoth Lakes and other peer resorts. But I think there's a, you know, that pent-up demand for the other types of...

47:00 You know, adventure are going to be, need to be met at some point down the line. And I think we could suffer from that. And if we're not marketing our destination properly, you know, we might, we could see a fall off in visitation and TOT and TBID revenue. So I don't think anything's guaranteed in the long run. I think in the short term, we are going to get, you know, have a lot of visitation this summer and we need to manage that properly.

47:26 As Jeremy pointed out, I really resonate with Sarah's earlier comments as well because I have four businesses, over 100 employees, and it's one of the biggest challenges that I have is staffing. And if you follow the staffing chart down, you'll...

47:45 Find that the biggest reason you have problems with staffing is because we don't have a lot of people that can come here. And the reason they can't come here is because there's not housing or affordable housing. So it's a real challenge that he has to be dealt with. Where I would, you know, where I differ in terms of Sarah's, you know, we are completely lined up with the problem and the challenge. The solution, I think, is where I might deviate a bit because

48:14 I never believe that doing things that might reduce revenues is the answer. I think we need to increase revenues and that would equal more budget for housing. Imagine how much money would be appropriated for affordable housing if the...

48:36 If the TOT gets back to the 20 million that John was talking about, and I really believe that our number of 16 in change, I think it is, is really, really low.

48:47 Is it 14 or 16? I'm sorry, off the top of my head. 14.5. 14.5, right. So in my head, it should have been 16.5. So I feel like we're going to get 2 million to 4 million more than what we think. That's a chunk of that's going to go to housing. But again, I think we need to really grow revenue to obtain more.

49:08 I hear you.

49:36 I don't mean it that way in the sense of the 80s Reagan trickle down. But, you know, if you cut revenue, Sarah,

49:46 You don't have the dollars that you need to go to housing is what I'm trying to say. It's trickle up economics is what it is. We need to raise revenues. And for the people that don't have businesses in the community and don't rely and don't understand that, it's easy to have those types of comments. But when you talk to my staff, they don't want to cut tourism. They understand that the tourism is how they, we are 100%, if not 99%.

50:15 Straight line or dotted line to a tourism-based economy. And there's people that don't really understand that. They don't understand that this town was an abandoned mining town that Dave McCoy opened as a resort town in 1953. And there's people that want to change this to a different type of community. And I don't think that that's possible or sensible. But I do understand the affordable housing issue.

50:42 And I believe that it has to be solved in real time. I just think that how we get there needs to be, you know, looked at differently. And I don't think that initiatives that are going to cut marketing are the solution for that. And it was never that way in my businesses going back 30 years. And there were people in the organization that always, you know, usually be encounters that have suggested that, you know, hey, we're doing great. We should cut the marketing budget.

51:11 And we did that, and we lost 20 or 30 percent revenue. So the idea that Mammoth is such a gifted place that without marketing, without insight in mind, attention, that we are just going to continue on this path forever, I think is illogical.

51:29 And it won't work. And for those of us that have business in the community, we don't want to cut tourism. But what we do want to do is have smarter tourism where people are educated and they treat our community with respect. We want to, like the hotel industry, raise the price a little bit. You know, Mammoth has always been undervalued, in my opinion. And we can have a more, you know, a higher value, charge a little bit more, and that will...

51:56 And I'm not talking about Aspen. I'm just talking about Mammoth, you know, having, you know, increasing our value and our sort of ADR globally within the community.

52:19 Raising more revenues that way. So as was pointed out earlier, not another 10,000 people on a given Saturday, Sunday, but getting more people midweek, getting more people in shoulder seasons, and increasing our sort of global ADR throughout all of our businesses, retail, food and beverage, and so forth. And, you know.

52:40 Then presenting a more, you know, continuing to put emphasis on a quality product, because when you raise price, you have to increase quality. And I think all of those initiatives together will raise revenues with perhaps less guests and then, you know, put more revenues towards the issues that we've been discussing. And at the top of that list, you know, for me, along with Sarah, is affordable.

53:08 Housing, you know, available housing, I think, is perhaps a better way to say it. But, of course, people have to be able to afford that housing as well. Thank you, Michael. Jess Correll. Jess, I don't know you, so. Hi, Bill. I work at Sierra Nevada Resort for lodging for MLT. And with what everybody's saying, everybody's kind of nailed all my views, too. Yes, housing is a hard thing, and we all live it.

53:38 In Mammoth, we live in a resort town. We work off hospitality to all survive one way or another. We're choosing to live here, run our businesses, and we bank on our tourists coming to come and support us and support that. And marketing is a hard point. I know we pulled it for a little bit, and it does hit you, especially with the revenue. And, you know, I've talked to other board members and having pulling marketing from, like, some of the bigger, most expensive cities, like New York, LA, Bay Area.

54:08 Three of our top that we market in to get and push travel here, especially with the new United flights coming in that we can reach more destinations. We're losing the international travel. I mean, that was a big hit with or without COVID. Even those countries that can travel this year, they've all canceled all their tours. For example, for that, for us at Sierra Nevada, for one tour company, that's like 60 bus groups that aren't going to hit Yosemite anymore, that aren't going to hit us in Vegas.

54:35 That affects us all in the long run too. That's not, you know, they're doing marketing for us to get us to come here or get their guests to come here. So, and also I think too with parks being more on a reservation, we're going to lose some tourism that way because they can't just go to Yosemite at any time and drive through and come see us. They have to have a reservation now. So we're going to lose some domestic and some obviously a lot of international in that sense. But having like the LA tourists or the Bay Area.

55:04 People are able to come and drive and come and see us. Summer, we get hit. I hope we have a busy summer. Everybody's talking about, I mean, I'm not saying, if we don't want a busy summer, we can't do it. We should strive to be like, we got this, let's go for it, and helping marketing and helping teach our tourists, which I think MLT did a great job of last year with COVID. It wasn't an easy job. People were so entitled and so opinionated.

55:33 That they didn't care what we were trying to do to save our community, save our community members, but also let them enjoy what we get to enjoy on a daily basis. So marketing correctly and still pushing the education, I think is a huge key point. And yes, Sarah, the workforce thing, it's not fun, it's a nightmare. I feel like we feel it hard at the hotel, but housekeeping and, you know, restaurant staffing.

56:00 Every business I know is feeling it one way or another. Everybody's hiring the same position throughout town right now, and it's pretty difficult, but I like the plan that MLT has for their marketing purposes, and I think it's spent well. They've always done it smart and done their research prior, and it picks the correct markets that we want to hit and draw people in front. Couldn't agree with all of you more, though, across the board. Everybody has some great opinion solutions.

56:31 Hold that down. Thank you, Jess. A couple things I want to touch on. One, as I said earlier, and Michael touched on it a little as well, to cut marketing now because we don't need it now, if we take that money and move it back into the city coffers, it will never find its way back when we need it. And there will be a time, believe me, when it is needed for straight marketing. But the contract is laid out in such a way that we can't segue. MLT itself can segue some.

56:58 To help develop more experiences, to help spread people out. There's a million and one things that can be done to help our summer visitation. Last summer was, I didn't view it as a nightmare. I will tell you that, frankly, every time I went into the Lakes Basin and I went up at least once every weekend, what I saw, while it looked overcrowded to us locals, what I saw was a whole lot of families with big, I can't say that's the way I would normally, with big old smiles on their faces.

57:27 Having a great time that we should be proud of as a community that we can offer to them. Not that they're in my way, it's too crowded, I can't go for a hike. Because frankly, as a local, if you can't find a place to go where there are no people, you just haven't become a local yet, because I can show them to you, even when we are that crowded. But there are ways we can segue, and MLT can use their dollars while we don't need to do a lot of extra marketing to help us develop the experiences.

57:55 To spread out these people that are coming so that we don't end up with, you know, clusters in the Lakes Basin. If this summer goes normal at all, and you can walk around the village and walk around town and shop, and we have things like bluesapalooza, you know, any bluesapalooza day, there's 5,000 less people in the basin because they're at a concert. So last year was an anomaly due to COVID.

58:24 And I think we're going to come out of that. Bill, if I could just add one thing to that. Yeah. 75% of our landmass is owned and managed by the federal government. You guys all know that, correct? So the relationship with the federal land management agencies has to be between the town and our federal partners. And I'm hoping that the council will see the wisdom of that, and we're going to step into that relationship in a...

58:53 I want to make sure that MLT, you guys all understand that that's a specific lane that we have to get into. And you're going to start hearing things about caring capacity. How much, what is the caring capacity of the natural resources of this place?

59:20 I just wanted to add on to what Bill's saying. That's a role that we need to get into, and I'm hoping that within the next year, the next time we all get together, it's going to be very clear what MLT is doing, what the town is doing, and how we're doing this in a mutually supportive and beneficial way. So I'll leave it at that. Thank you. Yeah, and John, you know, I can't agree with you more. Our relationship, our lack of relationship with federal partners.

59:50 They used to put out the kind of stuff that I'm talking about MLT doing now, and they no longer do it. They invite everybody here because it's public plans and they have to and then don't give them all the things to do. You know, there's one other thing that weighs heavily on me these days a little. And, Michael, you touched on some raising our prices. And the problem I have with that approach, and I could be completely wrong,

1:00:18 But the problem I have with that approach is in every other town when the nightly rates go up, you see the housing stock prices go up as well. And in today's world, you especially see more people buying old condo units and turning them into nightly rentals because they can now get $300 or $400 a night forward or $200 or $300 a night forward and give a less than stellar product. So I would like to hear from MLT board.

1:00:47 How do we deal with that? How do we get, should we limit the number of TOT certificates so that perhaps some of the older units go back to renting on a monthly basis? Do we, and I'm throwing these out there, I'm not supporting or opposing anything. Do we change zoning in some sections of town to prohibit nightly rentals in larger areas? How do we deal with that ever-growing subpar stock?

1:01:16 of nightly rentals that are owned by individuals and get some of those older, lesser units back into the monthly rental pool. And I hope, MLT board, you're paying attention to what Bill's saying. These are, again, the kinds of priorities and things that we're looking at that we need to do. This is a tool to address housing. But please pay attention to our priorities and what we're saying. We want to hear from you guys. But that's Bill's spot on with that stuff. These are things that we...

1:01:43 I intend to look at and hopefully we will look at and take action to, again, a changing world. When the real estate prices for single family houses in your community go by 80%, that's an indicator of something. And that's going to require some kind of response if we're going to be a community at the end of the day. May I just ask a question? Not a couple of questions. Make a couple of comments.

1:02:12 Sort of a new, and this will hopefully ask a question of Sarah Rae as well. You know, I've looked at, I hear the affordable housing piece, and I hear it, and this is in no way meant disparaging, I hear it mostly from people who either, as Sarah said, you know, people are getting evicted or other people, highest and best use of property.

1:02:40 You know, I've looked at medium household incomes in other resorts, Telluride, Aspen, Vail, Tahoe, Mammoth Lakes, and then affordable, the percentage of people who can afford housing in those states in Colorado and California. So interestingly enough, median household income in Mammoth is within $1,000 a year of what it is in Telluride, Aspen, Vail. It's $20,000 more a year than it is in Tahoe.

1:03:11 Figures lie and liars figure, right? I mean, there's probably ins and outs in that. I can go zip code by zip code, and I'm sure there's some zip codes where have million dollar houses and number two million dollar houses who have very low household income. But the big telltale piece in that is that in Colorado, there's a $2,000 difference between the state and those individual town annual incomes.

1:03:39 The state of Colorado is $69,000. Telluride Vale are $66,000, $67,000. In Mammoth, we're at $64,000, basically. But the average in the state of California is over 80. 30% of people in California can afford a home, to buy a home, forget rent or anything else. So I just, I kind of want to caution a little bit in the idea that we can,

1:04:12 And this isn't an MLT discussion. This is just a broader discussion, in my own opinion. By telling people what to do with their property and what they can't do with their property. We don't have rental property. We personally don't rent our property. We own our property. So I'm not in this fight. By telling people that they have to, you know, can't use Airbnb or anything else. That's a completely different discussion.

1:04:42 But I would offer that saying looking at those gaps versus the state of California and the state of Colorado in those same towns, John, you point out we're, you know, four square miles in the middle of a national forest. There's no other town that I know of, you may know of them, that has that issue. I know in Telluride, Aspen, and Vail, workforce drives between 30 and 50 miles each way a day to come to work, okay?

1:05:14 You know, I just, I want to caution ourselves on thinking that we could potentially do affordable or workforce housing on the slopes or within a mile or two miles of the ski area because I'm not sure we have the, we, any of us have the ability to do that. I do think by creating a 12-month economy about getting our

1:05:43 I don't think we can fix the price of housing, but we can

1:06:14 Give people an affordable and a livable wage where they can make a decision whether they want to try to live in Mammoth or they want to live in Crowley or Bishop or Tom's Place or somewhere else. Yes, we'd love them to live here, but maybe that's not the answer. There's no housing in Bishop either. There's no housing in Crowley either. And do you want your housekeepers?

1:06:41 What I'm hearing you say is that it's okay. I don't have a housekeeper. What I'm hearing you say is that it's okay to have our workers driving 30, 40 miles to work because that's what they do in Telluride. No, they drive more than that in LA to afford housing. All I'm saying is I don't think that that's a five-minute issue about how much marketing you're going to cut and we're going to fix housing in Mammoth. This is a discussion. This is not a discussion.

1:07:10 Probably for tonight because it's not an MLT discussion. But I think it's a bit, it's, you know, super important for everybody, but it's the way to say that we're going to have, you know, $500 rent apartments within a mile of a major ski area that's going to compete.

1:07:34 I'm pretty sure nobody thinks that there's going to be a $500 a month rental. I mean, so my question is. Well, you know what they do in Bozeman? Anyone who works for the town who lives within 50 miles of the city hall, they give them a stipend, a rent stipend. Yeah, but they don't cap housing prices.

1:07:54 They don't limit what people can rent their houses for. No, they're giving them a stipend. Yeah, no, no, no, no. I don't disagree with that. All I'm saying is... Should we maybe suggest doing that for our employees? Well, yeah, I mean, I think there's steps that can be considered. I just think the whole idea of let's stop tourism or slow down tourism as a way to, you know, drop housing prices or make rent more affordable or something else.

1:08:23 It's sort of a false economy. It's just my opinion. I'm not saying slow down tourism. I'm saying why are we giving 2.35% of our TOT to tourism when we're giving 0.85% to housing when housing is clearly underfunded and clearly an issue? We clearly need to boost up our funding for housing. And where is it going to come from? And who will own those houses, Sarah? Who will own those houses?

1:08:49 What do you mean who will own those houses? So we build 435 houses in the parcel, who's going to own those houses? I'm confused. Some of them will be rentals and some of them could be, or 80% of them I believe will be rentals and they'll be below, they'll be low AMI levels. So we're going to try to lock in those units.

1:09:17 Whatever the final number ends up being 450 units so that they will be rental units. And then people from there, if they put together something, hopefully we'll be able to buy something. But you're correct. The housing prices are going to be prohibitive. Yeah, that's all my point. Once someone owns that house, we can't control what they do with it. Well, they can't rent it for nightly rentals, John. Is that part of the deal?

1:09:47 Yes, that's part of the deal. But they could sell it for high price, right? No, they're going to be primarily rentals. Well, but, okay, I misunderstood the comment. They're not market, it's not market-rate housing. Okay, well, then I did correct, but my point is, I'm... And you're right, this is not really... John Wentworth, but, you know, controlling what people can do with their houses, I don't think is the answer, is the solution.

1:10:12 Well, people just aren't going to rent their houses to locals out of the goodness of their heart. I know plenty of people who bought a house a year ago and they're like, you know, I could make my income by just moving back down to LA and renting my house out for the next year. That's right. I do kind of think that we need to do something that controls what people do with their houses because certainly they're not just going to, out of the goodness of their heart, rent to a local and they could be making $3,000 a month cash up front. You're making my point.

1:10:41 And so how many people do you think are going to buy houses up here and continue? We've got a back and forth going here. Let's get away from that. However, I will say, Sarah, that we put far more than 0.83% of DOT into housing. If you look at the average over the last five years, we have spent more on housing out of our tax dollars than we have on tourism by far. But let's go back to the original question of should we do something with zoning or

1:11:11 Limit the number of nightly rentals, John, for us. Yeah, you know, Bill, you and I have talked about this before. I don't know what tools you guys have at your disposal. I mean, you guys know that better than I do. My comments on that would be there's a blend. I mean, there's a blend of people that are buying houses to just live in them, to do this, do that, the other thing. I don't really know that the direction that that's going is...

1:11:42 My number one concern, to be honest with you. I mean, again, you guys probably, you may have some tools at your disposal, but if I could, just kind of want to get too far off topic, and I don't want this conversation to go on all night because you guys have already had, we've all had a long day, but I want you, I just want to throw one more thing out there when we talk about how busy we are, how busy we are, how busy we are. We're really busy during the summer.

1:12:11 As I think Pat, I'm not sure, I think it might have been Pat said, for about 45 days. Then our occupancy goes to less than 50, less than 30, less than 20 for a long time. And we don't get that back. We get a blip at Thanksgiving. We get Christmas is busy. Our winter weekends, yeah, our winter weekends are good. Our winter midweeks are not that busy. We get to spring right now. Snow Creek, I'm at what? I don't know.

1:12:39 25% this weekend. So again, this is a blend of marketing. We're talking, we really need to focus on what we're doing with our deliverables, short term, medium term, long term. Short term, we know we don't need to be inviting a lot of people here right now. We need to be educating them what to do when they come here.

1:13:01 But let's not lose sight of the fact that it's not going to be that long before people are going to be getting on planes again and are wanting to go to Europe and wherever else. And Mammoth, we can't let Mammoth be an afterthought. We just can't let that happen because it will. If we just back off the marketing, that's going to happen. It's happened. John Urdi can talk about what happened in Colorado. It took them 10 years to recover after they cut their budgets there. So, again, we're not proposing to work.

1:13:29 What the deliverables are proposing is a very, is a whole mixed bag and blend of what we plan to do going forward.

1:13:36 But we do need to continue. There are things that are 12 to 18 to 24 months out there as far as messaging that need to be continued to be brought forward. And Sarah and Linda to your questions as far as how much money, it's not necessarily just how much do we need for the next three months or six months. It's looking into the future as well because we're always looking into the future and inviting guests out there, trying to get the right guests to come here midweek, off season.

1:14:04 On a plane, staying 10 nights, spending three times what a drive visitor spends. Those are the kind of guests we're looking to attract. We don't need, obviously, at this point, to be attracting a ton of people between July 1st and August 20th or whatever it's going to be. We know that and we need to mitigate that. So I just, I don't want to get too far away from or too...

1:14:28 Wrapped up in the notion that we're just so busy all the time that it's just a nightmare. Honestly, it's a very small period of time where we are really overcrowded. And, John, when we're through your point, yes, those are the times. Absolutely, we need to work with those partners, and hopefully you guys are with those governmental partners to make sure that we're not screwing up the woods.

1:14:50 We can't do that. That's irresponsible for anybody to do that. And we don't, MLT is not proposing to invite more people here to make that a problem. In fact, what we really want to do is educate our business people in town to talk about how they handle their supply and demand so we can have a better experience for the guests who are going to come here and also have something for our kids to come, grandkids, some of us, to come to later on and their kids. So yes, that is extremely important.

1:15:18 I will stop there. But again, we're not 12 months craziness. It's a much smaller piece than that. So please keep that in mind if we can. Thanks. Thank you, John. Anyone else? Any comments? Go ahead, Pat. Unmute. Hey, you know what? I just want to tell Sarah I appreciate her passion. And that's a lot of the reason why we're in this meeting is MLT wants to hear directly from the council. I think we all agree that we don't get...

1:15:53 And I think that that's something that needs to change. I think our whole board agrees with that. I think John Bell mentioned, hey, look, instead of once a year or twice, let's do it quarterly. Let's do it until the council's tired of talking to this, because we all do need to be on the same page. So, Sarah, look, we have a problem, absolutely. I don't know that any of us are going to solve it tonight. But my opinion is similar to Michael LeDesmond's, in that

1:16:22 If Mammoth Lakes Tourism can achieve $20 million in TOT years, that creates opportunity for the town to allocate resources to whatever it is that's important to them at the time. Right now it's housing, and that can create a lot of money going towards housing to help solve the problem, however we do that. So I think that's important. Maybe in a few years it's something else, but the high TOT revenue just creates opportunity for us to do things with.

1:16:52 And so that's why I think it's important. I don't think that at this point we start cannibalizing each other. I think that what we're demonstrating here is MLT realizes it's a problem, but we're also happy to help. We want to help. The mechanism that we had lined out in our deliverables obviously doesn't quite work because of the legality, but I think what we're demonstrating, we want to hear your opinion and we want to help and we know how it's an issue.

1:17:21 Let's figure out how we can contribute. Thank you, Pat. Anyone else? I'm seeing no hands. Are you all tired? Okay. Real quick, just wanted to kind of, you know, Bill, you kind of asked the question, what are some possible solutions? You know, Sarah, you kind of asked the question, kind of what is the, you know, dollar amount that MLT needs? And I just want to speak to that.

1:17:56 You know, John Urdi is a budgetary master. Rob Patterson, I know, is very good at budgeting and very good at his job. I don't know what, I don't have an answer for you what exactly that number is, but what I can say is that I don't think slashing MLT dollars is the answer to workforce housing. You know, what I see in the deliverables,

1:18:25 Is MLT as an organization recognizing the workforce housing issue and adjusting our strategy to help provide solutions to the workforce housing and workforce issue for the businesses? And so I would ask that you view MLT

1:18:53 As a partner in finding a solution to the workforce housing and not just say, you know, you know, and not just slash our funding, you know, that's one thing I would just put out there for you. Bill, kind of to your point, some, you know, what are some possible solutions that we can take a look at? You know, the nice thing about our situation here in Mammoth.

1:19:21 Is that we don't have a lack of inventory. You go to Big Sky, there's literally no place for somebody to rent or, you know, I think half of our town sits empty all the time. You know, so, you know, what we've been working on at the chamber is approaching those landlords and property owners and saying, how can we work with you?

1:19:51 To turn your property into a long-term rental for local workforce and local residents. And, you know, I think, you know, I think we've had some success. Could we have more? Probably, you know, and we can discuss that. But, you know, I think we're in a good situation. We need to, in terms of the fact that there is inventory there.

1:20:20 We need to kind of figure out how to convert that. And there's different ways of going about that than just like zoning and laws and this and that. You can establish these programs to work with landlords and property owners to provide long-term housing. So that's something we've been working on at the chamber with our workforce coordinator.

1:20:50 And I know we've had some success in doing that. And, you know, I think that we should put a little bit more focus on trying to take some of this inventory and making it available for locals and long-term rents. We need to subsidize them. Give them money. If you owned a second home and you could make more rent in it nightly, what would it take for you to rent it to a local, Jeremy?

1:21:24 Would it take someone paying you as much as you would pay? You know, every situation is going to be different, Sarah. What would it take for you? I don't, I am not a landlord. Pretend that you are. I'm just saying these are, you know, once you get down into the nitty gritty of everything, you know, that's for the program to figure out in that particular situation.

1:21:52 You know, like I'm talking kind of broader ideas, strategy to get us to where we want to go. You know, that's, that is what I am discussing right now. Like a steady funding stream, like that as a strategy, a steady funding stream that maybe was tied directly to the amount of tourism dollars we got. Could that be a strategy? These are things we can certainly, Sarah, these are things that the council needs to talk about. If we go back to community housing action plan, there's a specific.

1:22:24 Recommendation to put it to the voters, to put that question to the voters. We postpone that because of COVID. I think what we at the council have to do is we have to figure out how much is this going to cost? You know, what do we need? How much money are we talking about? So we've got some work to do. But I think certainly that's on us to do that and get those types of questions and opportunities back to the community to say, okay, look, we want to, you know, address this question in a serious way. This is the council's proposal. That's on us to do that.

1:22:54 I mean, if we're saying that the more successful we are, you know, the more that money is going to trickle down, then we just need to develop that strategy. Absolutely. That's on us. You could also consider tax breaks for a direct funding flow, tax breaks for people who rent their properties to locals. That's a great idea, John. That way you're not just giving money back to taxpayers and you're not enriching the people who don't know.

1:23:26 Yeah, I want to say, too, that, you know, in 2010, 11, 12, 13, I think for five years straight, anybody that knows me knows during those years, I was preaching pretty heavily in town that in that down market that we should be buying condos.

1:23:45 Because then we control those condos and they can't be rented for above market value or nightly rentals or monthly rentals to out-of-towners, seasonal rentals. We would control. And if we had 50, 75, 100 of those units, again, we would control those and renting those to locals who are working in the community. We would own the asset and that asset.

1:24:11 I can't say off, you know, for certain, but I'm guessing that if you bought a condo, a two-bedroom condo in 2010, it would, you know, be worth substantially more now. And if we did those on 10 or 15-year notes, they'd be paid off by now. And, you know, so that's something I think, you know, we can't do now. It's top of the market, obviously. I think this is a short-term market, possibly, because the demands on some

1:24:40 The demand is kind of artificial. I think there'll be a correction, but I would propose to the town that if and when there's another down market, we should execute on buying up inventory and owning and then controlling that inventory in our market because I wholeheartedly agree with John Mandel. You can't...

1:25:04 You know, this is, if you like it or not, it's a democracy with capitalism. You can't, you know, tell people how to, you know, what to pay for something and how to spend their money and what to do with their house. Michael, the only thing I would add to that is the recognition that I certainly share, I think, with a lot of folks that housing in Mammoth Lakes is a failed and broken market. This is a failed and broken market, and it requires intervention if we're going to be a community.

1:25:33 You can call it what you will. But, John, to the point about our land configuration, we are an island. So we're dealing with island economics. And the town of the council has to weigh how we intervene and engage with that failed market so that we will have a community here. And we're already doing that. We're buying up land. We bought up the parcel. We're hiring a developer. We're going to build units. But that's...

1:25:59 And that should not be a hyperbolic statement. It's just that's the reality of what we're dealing with. So we get exactly the right point. Buy on the dips. Acquire the inventory. Frankly, it's the government that's going to have to do a lot of that kind of stuff to address these kinds of issues. But how many units did we buy during that period? I wasn't on the council. I don't think we bought any. Oh, of course it was a different council, for sure. But I'm not asking a loaded question.

1:26:25 It's an excellent thing. I think we looked back in hindsight and said in 2007, 2005, 2007, during that big economic downturn, we should have had a fund in place that we could have gone out and been acquiring inventory. Guys, I'm going to bring this back from the housing argument for a moment. Appreciate it. Thank you. We're getting towards the end of the evening and we've all worn out our vocal cords, I'm certain.

1:26:53 The two people we haven't heard from, and I'm going to give an opportunity, are the heads of the two units. One would be Mr. John Urdi, and the other would be Dan Holler. So, Mr. Urdi, if you had anything to add, I will give you 15 seconds. Sorry. Thanks. I guess I would start off with the same question of the council that Mr. Wentworth asked of our board.

1:27:19 Is truly how many of the council members recognize what MLT is doing for quote-unquote marketing? Especially last summer when we saw the impacts of overcrowding and peak visitation. Yeah, I'm well aware of what you're doing. Right. So you're incredible. You're absolutely incredible. And I say this to anyone who listens. If anything, you're a victim of your own success. You've done absolutely far and beyond what we've tasked you with doing. Incredible. Thank you. But the point of my question there is that

1:27:52 You know, all we've been doing is educating. And John Wentworth and I have talked about this for four years. This is not a new thing that came with COVID. You know, the overcrowding that we saw last summer happened the year before, happened the year before, and some of the same challenges. I guess my position back to council would be to challenge the council to look at the surplus funding that you have been achieving every single year since 2015. You know, back in 2015, we had a budget of $11,500.

1:28:21 We actually met the annual budget with March. The budget was $11.2. We're at $12.

1:28:49 So, you know, everything April, May, and June is great. You're probably going to end up with $4 million in excess TOT this year. That needs to be earmarked to housing. If housing is the biggest problem, that needs to be earmarked to housing. The point about MLT committing tourism reserves, fine, it's not a commitment, it's a recommendation. MLT has recommended to the Town Council that for the next four years that we dedicate those tourism funds.

1:29:20 Even in a year like this, where we lost $5 million in the months of December and January compared to last year, that's important. We lost $5 million in two months, and we're still going to be $4 million over budget. I think the other piece is that looking at the pace and the trends, the month of March came in 91% ahead of budget. The month of February came in 66% ahead of budget. So we know that people are coming. We know that people are paying.

1:29:51 We know that people are paying more. Those dollars need to be committed to housing. Those dollars need to be committed to restaurants. Those dollars need to be committed to trash, parking, all of the other things that we've talked about. I think the idea that MLT is we have partnered with the Ambassador Program. In fact, we just increased that probably to $150,000 for this year. All of our quote-unquote marketing is asking people to respect our community and our environment when they come here. It's not just opening the floodgates to come here.

1:30:18 And I think probably the most important piece that I look at here has been brought up by a few people that, you know, we're talking about overcrowding, we're talking about the fact that we don't need to market. Again, it's six weeks. It's July 1 through August 15th when people go back to school. You know, right now, the occupancy in town is 20%, 30% midweek and maybe 40% on the weekends. And that's going to be the same way until we hit July. You know, we are not a mature destination by any means.

1:30:47 Weekends in the winter, sure, we're packed. July and August, sure, we're packed. September, October, November, March, April, May, or April, May, June, we have opportunity. Midweek winter, we've been talking about destination business. Jess Corral brought up international is probably going to be a little slow for a while. You know, so we're actually filling holes with domestic visitors that were filled by international folks. I think the opportunity that we have with air service, with destination traffic,

1:31:17 Getting people that are going to be here on a Tuesday or Wednesday. You know, I think if you're a server in town, Tuesday and Wednesday, you're not making a lot of money. We need to fix that. We need to level out the valleys and the peaks. We need to get people to come here to respect our community and our environment. It's critical that we do that. We are marketing, again, I use air quotes on marketing. We are talking to people about respecting our place so that it's here for the next generation. We don't want people here that are going to disrespect it.

1:31:48 You know, we are working hard. We are your marketing agency. You know, again, the dollars that come in in excess of the TOT budget, that is from your visitors. Your visitors are paying you. If we have challenges with their experience, if we have challenges with the disruption that they cause, you need to use those dollars to fix those challenges. We are happy to be a partner, and we have shown that. You know, $150,000 into the...

1:32:18 It's the host program this year, $100,000 last year. We recognize that we need to fix the six-week problem, but I can guarantee you that in September and October, not overcrowded. And I can also guarantee you that half of the people that were worried about being able to afford housing aren't making enough money during those months to pay the rent. So I think that, I guess, you know, I think that the system or this process is broken. We should have had this conversation four months ago.

1:32:46 You know, we're coming up on the fiscal year here pretty quickly. We've got two months left of the fiscal year. You know, we have our budgets drafted. We have our plan drafted. We have disbursement maps to make sure that people, everybody wants to go to Duck Lake. We're going to disperse people over to TJ and Barrett. We have these plans, and it just is disconnected because we're putting the cart before the horse here. This conversation needs to be done in January or February in order for us to be ready at the end of the fiscal year. We have our plans.

1:33:17 I truly believe that our plans and our deliverables are right up the alley with what you're going to end up with your strategic decisions and directions. More than 15 seconds, Bill. Well, a little, John, but you're good. Thanks. Thanks. Dan, anything to add? Just a couple things, but yeah, one is when we developed the deliverables, we did try to structure those with a lot more of a focus about the investment back into the community versus...

1:33:48 Reaching out, inviting people to the community. And that outreach is focused more on the responsibility of those types of elements, definitely from that. And I think as we look at each of these things and all the various points have been made this evening, it gives you the field, the dynamic issues we're dealing with. We're not a, it's not a one single priority community. As we look at issues and we deal with our budgeting.

1:34:13 And we have chosen the last several years to budget very conservatively. Frankly, that allowed us survive the last year that we just went through. Had we started this four months ago in a lockdown situation with the state, our budget would be dramatically lower because we did not know what would be happening going forward. So this year is a bad one for the timeline. Other years, correctly, to look out that way.

1:34:39 But by doing what we've done from a budget standpoint, we're able to respond to those issues. We were actually, because we do that, we're able to buy the parcel. Because we've done that, we've been able to invest back into the community's infrastructure that we're responsible to manage. And so I'd be cautious that we may make the comment that every extra dollar goes to one purpose. Because we actually do have roads that are failing. We've got drainage systems that need work. We have our parks facilities that have deferred maintenance.

1:35:06 Trail systems that need work. We have a number of different things out there in our infrastructure that we do need to address. So I think we've done a great job from a town perspective in terms of the dollars we're able to put in there. This last year, we put over $2 million directly back into our economy here in the community on top of what we spent in the response side to the COVID issues there.

1:35:31 As we look going forward, yeah, you'll see next week we'll be recommending another $1.4 million, go back into what I would call Creative Housing Solution Fund without defining what those solutions are yet, but setting that money aside. We continue that as a priority. We've seen some successes there. But again, we have a multitude of demands and issues out there. Getting back and looking at our event.

1:35:55 Activities and those things that disperse people differently, not just other places in the forest, but diverse them to those activities in the community. Working with Blueza Palooza, they'll be making a request to say, how can we actually be successful this year versus waiting a whole other year in order to be successful in our events? So our diversification of activity and that destination experience is more than...

1:36:21 Just the national forest, if you will, but that's such a huge draw that we know we have to deal with. And we talked about a couple of meetings ago, the investment that the town's going to be making in that we're looking at dollars going in partnering with the Forest Service. We're looking at some staffing issues that focus directly on those issues, both from education, enforcement, presence, and fixing and repairing issues that are out there that are broken or things that need to be addressed.

1:36:49 But by doing that, we're also trying to say, how do we invest back into our community for those people that will be here? So we're balancing a number of issues as we look through that priority setting side. Housing is definitely one. We still have deferred maintenance. We have issues with capital investment. We're dealing with the amenity base here, be it the municipal community base or our partnership in the communities and amenities that are out there that we need to work through.

1:37:16 At the same side of that, we have taken very, very strong steps to manage the growth of government. We're making $20 million in TOT. It'd be really easy to staff up. I mean, we could have, you know, another, we could get back to 130 employees. A lot of different things could happen. And we think that from a management perspective, that would be a responsibility. So we are trying to manage through a lot of those things as well as we look at these priorities and how we invest in them. And probably the most,

1:37:46 The challenging thing on the housing side is we're doing a lot of steps to move housing forward, but a lot of it is very slow, especially if you're going to build something. We have three or four different folks who have come to us looking at how do we do this, and to get it to financially work at an affordable level is extremely difficult, and or for the town side, it becomes extremely expensive to invest in that.

1:38:09 We have looked at buying units. We've bought a couple for the town, which has been a real benefit to our employees. So there's a number of factors. I don't think there's a silver bullet for housing. And the same thing on the marketing side. Often quote, this is from casino marketing folks. They'd say 50% of their marketing dollars are really effective. They just had a hard time telling which 50%.

1:38:32 The branding versus the direct recruitment, those types of issues. And we know that we are a resort community. We're in the hospitality business. And that hospitality business, as kind of mentioned already, starts at home. What are we doing here to help people? What are we doing here to engage with people? What are we doing here to have our community look clean and fresh and doing those types of elements? And I think the deliverables as presented to a large part are focused on that. What are we doing here first?

1:39:02 Inviting people second. But ultimately, if our service industry can't be in our community, they really don't have opportunities to go into Down Valley or Up Valley Solutions as in other areas. I think we're kind of unique in that situation, that ability to disperse out of workforce is extremely limited here. And we're seeing that as a town and our own recruitments, and I'm sure other people are too in terms of

1:39:28 People not be able to find housing as they look to come here and work. So we understand that mix of challenges. I don't think there's a single solution or a single silver bullet. You know, if you looked at tourism and said, yeah, we want to move a 0.2 piece of the pie into housing for four years. Great. I mean, ultimately this takes funding and there's dollars associated with that, I think.

1:39:53 Sorry, I forgot to mention that comment first, but maybe Sarah in terms of we could do a lot of that, but we do have a funding issue and limited resources regardless of what's being pulled out on that investment side to make these things happen. We've been very aggressive on that side with parcel work, you know, getting grants and other things in place. So a lot of things to go there, a lot of competing interest. We could have the same discussion with.

1:40:18 Our other NGOs and it'd be a completely different discussion and priorities and where we should be putting any of that excess dollars. So we have that, I'll say we collectively and then we as a town council have a extremely challenging position in terms of setting those priorities and going, yeah, we are going to commit X dollars to housing, we're going to commit X dollars to infrastructure. You know, you talk to other.

1:40:44 Individuals, one of their major challenges is childcare. Is that something the town does or doesn't do? So start to work at all of those factors. And there's a lot of demands and priority setting and focusing on where do we actually make that difference? Again, not just short term, but long term. So appreciate the dialogue. That's been extremely healthy. Thank you. So in parting, I do appreciate the openness. This was a great conversation, one of the better we've had.

1:41:13 And as one council member, I would also like to add to any of you on the MLT board, you can feel free to call me at any time. And I'm more than happy to continue having this conversation. My phone's always open, as is my house. And Bill, we do have some public comment, I believe. Okay, public comment. Tom Cage, you want to unmute yourself and give your comments? I just had to wake up here. So first of all,

1:41:44 Thank you. I appreciate all your comments tonight. I think we've got a lot of great minds and a lot of great ideas. I'm also into my third glass of wine. Jeremy will appreciate that. You know, in any meeting, you have goals and objectives, and hopefully you come out with an action plan. We are trying to make the best decisions with the information that we have. We only have one chance to make a first impression to our guests.

1:42:12 And we've all dealt in business on how do we do that? My answer to it is I had shortage of staff, so I was open 30% less hours than I normally would be this winter because I just didn't have enough staff. We know the housing element. I look at John Urdi and his marketing. He has delivered over year, over year, over year, and we've increased our traffic.

1:42:39 Now we're in this unique situation. We're not going to get foreign visitors this year. So I look at the MLT and I look and I say, keep your powder dry, keep us in the forefront of people's ideas to travel to, but don't necessarily market to Australia. They're closed, right? They're closed for inbound and if you go outbound, it's hard to get back in. So I'm sure he's thinking about those areas.

1:43:08 As an example that you market to and you don't market to. The Mountain has stated that they're happy with their pass sales. You know, that's great. People want to come here. So what is the action plan at the end of this great two-hour meeting that you've had plus? And what can the town council do? What can MLT do? What can we divert money towards housing for? And all these questions get put together.

1:43:37 And Dan Holler makes a presentation to what he comes out of this meeting with. He works with John Urdi in marketing and he says, okay, look, we can maybe do this and do that with X number of dollars. Don't cry over spilled milk. You didn't buy units over the last 10 years. That's okay. You didn't buy them. What can you do now? Does it make sense to subsidize rental units? Does it make sense to buy units? Does it make sense to fund MLH more?

1:44:06 What makes sense is we get the parcel built as quickly as parcel. What makes sense is can we buy a unit or two through Mammoth Lakes Housing? What makes sense is to me you come up with this action plan and then execute it. You've had a lot of great ideas tonight and every single one of them I think has been stellar. So I hope an action plan is developed after the end of this and you execute to that action plan.

1:44:36 To the best of everyone's abilities, both the town, MLT, and all of you and all your great ideas. So thank you very much. Have a good night. Any other public comments, Jamie? No. Okay. Unless I see someone desperate to talk, I will thank you. I have one last request. Can we please get someone to make a visit me with the TikTok channel? I volunteer Dakota.

1:45:08 We've had one for a year and a half. Oh, you have? Well, I guess I should follow you then. Bill, if I may, I just, in parting, I just want to thank everybody. And I'll, MLT will work with Dan and the council. Again, I would like to make this much more of a recurring deal quarterly, if you guys can stand it, at least twice a year, because we definitely need to have these discussions.

1:45:36 And make sure we're on the same page so we don't get behind the eight ball, so to speak. But thank you, everybody, for your time and your comments tonight. I really appreciate it. And just to follow up on that, I think the council is aware that there is flexibility built into your agreement with the deliverables. And, Dan, I think we need to work on that because we have not been exercising that. And I think it's frustrating for the council to get the deliverables. Hey, got to sign the contract in a month. We got to make it work.

1:46:03 We've got to figure out some way to do that. To your point, John Barr, so we're checking in on a regular basis so that this dialogue, this is probably one of the most important dialogues between an NGO and the council that could be happening. We need to be doing this on a regular basis. Mayor Sauser, I think that, you know, I think we don't want to forget that the last year was informed by a pandemic. And, you know, if we were not checking in, I mean, the deliverables had changed.

1:46:33 I think we've done pretty well, given the...

1:47:02 Reality of the last year. And I think it's time to begin to think about a more normal world, but we're not quite there yet. So that's what I'm feeling tonight. Rob, go ahead. Yeah, no, I just want to make a point that, you know, we developed this style of contract a couple of years ago. And Section D of the contract does outline the timing of which MLT is supposed to come to council with.

1:47:30 Presentations on items. And those are really designed around what we thought at the time was an appropriate timing for that. And that can be adjusted. That's something that's a part of the contract. And it was just something we had really formalized the first time when we decided that it was important for you guys to talk on a regular basis. And I think that adjusting that is very simple, but it's in the contract itself, Section D.

1:47:59 And would appreciate if you guys want to update that, that's the place to do it. Thank you, Rob. Okay, any other hands? Going once, going twice. I will adjourn this very special meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Town Council and MLT Board. Thank you all for your participation. Have a good day.