TransparentMammoth

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH) · 2021

Housing Board (MLH / ESCH)

· recording 2 hr 22 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

268 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:30 I'm actually going to ask you to hold a minute because for some reason I'm not getting any audio in Sweet Tea. Okay, great. We'll wait a few more minutes. She said she needs... Go ahead and see if that works if I can hear you in here. Okay, how does that sound, Angie? Testing, one, two, three, Angie. Say, Tom. Hello. Okay, it's working now. All right, great. Well, we have a quorum if you'd like to start.

1:38 Okay, I'll start. I'll call to order the Board of Directors regular meeting for Monday, May 3, 2021. Board of Directors for Mammoth Lake Housing. Roll call, Patricia? Go ahead and get that. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes, here. Zaria Cruz? Rogers? Here. Jennifer Kreitz? Here. Kirkstapp? Here. Agnes Fiansen?

2:19 Tony Perkins. Tony Perkins. Present. And Zariah Cruz, looks like she has joined us. Yes. Thank you. I'm here. Thank you. We're all here with the exception of Agnes. Thank you. This is a time for public comment. Are there any public comments that have come in? I have no public comments in Sweet Z or via email or Zoom at this time. I didn't receive any public comments, but I have a couple of comments.

2:52 My first public comment is that Mammoth Lakes Housing received our contract from LISC to help operate the California COVID-19 rent relief program on Friday, so it was after I published the packet for this meeting. In an effort to get that contract,

3:21 for services executed so that Mammoth Lakes Housing can start getting reimbursed for our time spent on that program. I've discussed with the assistant town clerk that it would be best to hold a special meeting. And I will send out a poll to the board this evening after our meeting to see when the best time for a special meeting might be.

3:48 to approve, to potentially approve that contract. Could we not add it as an emergency item? I had asked the assistant town clerk to research that possibility, but I was advised that the best course of action was to hold a special meeting. Okay. Well, since it arose after you published the meeting and it's a critical time sensitivity, do you have a deadline?

4:17 To execute it prior to our next meeting. I don't believe that there's a deadline. I just know that they've asked to have it back as soon as possible. We could, I mean, I would, I'm happy to make a motion given what we've seen and heard that we should add as emergency item and if you're ready to handle it tonight. What would be the wording of the motion since it's, you need two motions. One is to put it on the agenda and the other is to approve. Yeah.

4:59 I wish we had an attorney here to give us advice on that. I think you're correct, Jennifer. We do. It happens. We just did one a couple meetings ago. I can certainly look it up. But we can bring it up later if you want to keep going. Okay. That's my first public comment. So we can think some more about that. And then I've been doing a lot of thinking about

5:33 All of the disparities that we've been seeing with the police violence and, you know, thinking about the diversity, equity, and inclusion work that we have done in the past at this board. And so I wanted to just actually share a poem with the board to start the meeting. And so I'm just going to share my screen so that you're able to read it at your own pace.

6:04 And this poem was written by Joy Harjo, who is the Poet Laureate for the United States. And I just thought it was a really good piece of writing to help us reflect on everything that's been going on in our country over the past year and also obviously our long history. So I'll just give everybody a few minutes. So I hope everybody had a couple of

7:45 moments to just read that. And I think the purpose, I think, for me is to just remind us that we do have, you know, in our strategic plan and initiative to continue to think about how we can implement diversity, equity, and inclusion in our work at Mammoth Lakes Housing. And so just a time for reflection. And I'll be sure to share that with everybody after the meeting. But that's all I have.

8:15 So if I could, the finding is that the issue, there's a finding that an issue in question arose following the release of the board's agenda and that the board must deal with the issue prior to the next board meeting and it must be approved by four-fifths of a vote. And I think it,

8:47 This item seems to meet both of those. And if that's the case, then I'm happy to make a motion to add the emergency item of the list contract with Mammoth Lakes Housing. Discussion? Jennifer, if you'll make the motion, please. Jennifer? Yes. The four-fifths requirement is the four-fifths of your total board. I'm not sure who's all in attendance. If you have enough, there's only four members there. That's all I can see. We had discussed it earlier as well.

9:22 We actually had the information in time. It could have, the agenda could have been amended and reposted and or a special meeting could have been completed prior to the meeting this evening if it was of a critical nature. That was why the recommendation was to schedule it for another special meeting or send out. And as there was not any, it didn't sound like there was an immediate need to have it signed, no loss of revenue, et cetera, if it wasn't done this evening.

9:52 Oh, I understood that it was received after the agenda had been published. Yeah, we had, there was time to amend the agenda and or to do a special meeting agenda, so it could have been addressed with their regular noticing provisions, either as a special meeting and or amended agenda. Yeah, I'd like to avoid a special meeting. If we could just deal with it tonight, that would be great. Yeah, if you have four-fifths, I'm not sure who's all there. If you have four-fifths of your board there, you'll need four-fifths of the total members of the board, not just the members in attendance.

10:27 That's been the recommendation back to us with the council. Well, we have Zariah, Tony, Lindsay, Tom, myself, and Kirk. I think that's worth it. Okay. Yeah. I can't see them on my screen. That's why I was asking. I understand. I know. I know. Yeah. Sorry. Yeah. Welcome to technology. Yeah. I think Jennifer is making the motion. Yeah. That was the basis for the recommendation.

11:01 If you want to go forward, that's your call as far as that goes. Worst case would be you'd have to do it over again if there's a challenge. Yeah, I think this is pretty straightforward. I'm going to look to staff for a recommendation. Yeah, I mean, I'm happy to share the contract with the board and the community this evening. I didn't prepare.

11:29 A staff report, but I mean, I think I've explained what the item is. But I also have some amendments to the third quarter financials that I could bring back if we had a special meeting. So for me, I can go either way. Comments from the board? And I think that we're going to schedule a special meeting unless I hear objections.

12:07 Patricia, do you have a direction? Because you're going to have to schedule it. Yeah, I can schedule a special meeting that was the recommendation that the town made, and so I was prepared to do that, but I'm also happy to go forward with the item as the board wishes. What's the pleasure of the board? The marketing committee had some issues that were yet to be determined if we schedule this.

12:41 Special meeting, could we address those as well in another week or two in the same meeting? Yes, potentially we could add that to the agenda for the special meeting. I think if we have several different things, it justifies another meeting. Comments from the board? And Patricia, you have a direction as to scheduling and figuring out what time to have a special meeting? Yes. All right, that was it.

13:22 Public comment section. Any further discussion or any further items under public comment? I'm not hearing any, so we'll move to agenda item number three, approval of the minutes from April 5, the regular board meeting. This is an action item. Any corrections or deletions? If not, can I have a motion, please? I'll make a motion to adopt the...

13:58 Minutes of the regular meeting of April 5th, 2021. I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded. Further discussion? I'll call for a roll call vote. Patricia? I'll go ahead and get that. Angie, sorry. That's okay. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Soraya Cruz? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Kirkstapp? Yes.

14:34 And Tony Perkins. Yes. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item number four, ad hoc nomination committee, a presentation of nominees and potential appointment to the board of directors. This is an action item. Patricia? Great. Thank you. This item is brought before you this evening by the ad hoc nominations committee who has been working since March 2020 to fill

15:04 an empty position on the Board of Directors. The nominations committee met to discuss a marketing plan, to receive and review applications, and to schedule interviews with three potential applicants. I provided some background information regarding the Mammoth Lakes Housing Bylaws.

15:29 which outline the requirements for the Board of Directors of the nonprofit organization. I also included some information from the Community Housing Action Plan and the Mammoth Lakes Housing Strategic Plan which outlines priorities for candidates to hold a position on the Board of Directors.

15:57 Our Board of Directors requires one-third representation from the low-income community and not more than one-third of our representatives from places of public employment or public officials. And so at this time, there's a vacancy in the at-large category which doesn't have any of those requirements.

16:28 The ad hoc nominations committee would like to recommend this evening that the board of directors nominate and appoint Heidi Steenstra to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors. She's lived in Mammoth Lakes for more than 20 years and came here from Keystone, Colorado. She has a very diverse background in HOA management and in other businesses in the community.

16:58 She has lots of knowledge about project management, employees, and short-term rentals, and the nominations committee believes that her passion in volunteering and serving the community and her experience and skills will be an asset to the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors.

17:21 With that, I will turn it over to the committee if they have anything else they'd like to say about the process. And then I know that the candidate is on the line and I don't know if she would like to speak as well. So the committee, any comments from the committee? Yeah, you know, I'll just make some comments about the outreach. I mean, we ran an advertisement in the local papers for

17:54 Couple weeks. And additionally, I think we had a radio spot, Patricia. And I think I made an announcement on public comment at a town council meeting. And we also did some personal outreach as well. And we had three candidates submit applications. So, yeah, you know, it's still kind of tough out there, attracting interest.

18:24 As much as a lot of things still going on in everybody's lives, but Heidi, I apologize, I missed the interview, the actual interview, but everything that I gathered from what Lindsay and Patricia passed on to me, it sounded like Heidi was a great choice for the board, and I think her experience in condo management, particularly with

18:54 You know, her exposure to the short-term rental effects and so forth, I think brings a good perspective to the board that we don't have currently. So I think that's a positive thing. So I'm in support of recommending Heidi to join our board. Further discussion? Tom, if you want to make a motion? Yeah. Lindsay, did you have anything to add? No, nothing to add at this time. Thank you to Heidi for her interest. And I also am in.

19:29 support of getting Heidi on our board. Okay. And just to be clear for the public as well is this fills an eighth seat. And then at the time we were into this process, we had another seat vacated. So we still have one open seat that is in that large position that will

19:57 Probably take a look at here in the coming months. I don't think we have an immediate schedule to get right on that right away. I think maybe we'll give it a little bit of time and maybe solicit that, recruit for that position maybe later in the middle of summer or something like that. So in any event, if there's no other questions, I will make a motion to appoint Heidi Singstra to the Board of Mammoth Lakes Housing. I'll second. It's been moved and second.

20:28 Further discussion? Angie, a roll call vote, please. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Zariah Cruz? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Kirk Stapp? Yes. And Tony Perkins? Motion passes. Thank you, Heidi. Welcome. Yeah. Thank you, Heidi. So now...

21:00 So, Angie's going to upgrade Heidi so she can participate in the rest of the meeting and then we can say hi and go to the next item. Okay, great. Heidi, can you hear us okay? Are you there, Heidi? There you are. Great. Well, congratulations and welcome to the team. Thank you all. There you go. Now it's a live person.

22:00 Great, welcome. If I could, just again, now that I can see you, I just want to welcome you and thank you for volunteering. I think as Tom said, there's a lot of need for people to volunteer in our community, in our county, and you know, I was just noticing we have vacancies on the assessment appeal boards, the grand jury's looking for people, everybody's looking for help.

22:25 It means a lot that you're willing to join our team, so to speak. So thank you and welcome. Well, thank you. Look forward to it. Thank you, Heidi. If there's no further comments, we'll move to agenda item number five, review and approval of the Mammoth Lake Housing and Sierra Housing Advocacy, LLC, fiscal year 2020-21, third quarter draft financial statement. Is this an action item? Patricia?

22:58 Thank you. So I had previously mentioned that I noticed some amendments that I'd like to make to the financials, but I've been thinking about it a little bit this afternoon, and I could take them and revise them, but I know that the board has spent time reviewing them, so I'm also happy to go through them this evening, and if we want to approve them at the special meeting,

23:27 That's okay. Or if the board would like to forego the staff report and just have it at our special meeting, that that's okay with me as well. The major amendments, the one major amendment is on the Sierra Housing Advocates statement of financial position, which is the first page of the financial documents in your packet, which shows in the quarter ending 331,

23:57 that we still have two outstanding revolving loan fund balances. However, that unit was sold on March 23rd, and so those loans have been paid back. It's not a major change, and those loans will be paid off in the, you will see that change in the next quarter then, once I have the accountant revise them. So,

24:26 It's not a major issue. It's just that I like everything to be reflective of reality. And so that is one item that isn't exactly accurate. But I'm happy to go through all of the reports at this time. I'm sorry. I just want to clarify, are there corrections to the Mammoth Lakes Housing? Because they're agendized separately. Is it just the Sierra Housing Advocates or is it both that need amendments?

24:58 So that would be the major amendment just on Sierra Housing Advocates. On Mammoth Lakes Housing, I have been doing some outreach to see if we could get a board governance training before the end of the fiscal year, which I didn't necessarily include in the forecast, but I don't think that's a major revision. So I don't see any major revisions to Mammoth Lakes Housing at this time.

25:25 I guess I would be comfortable with postponing the Sierra Housing Advocate since it's pretty significant liability and maybe just moving ahead with Mammoth Lakes Housing, but whatever the, you know, the pleasure of the entire board is, that would just be, I'd be comfortable with that. I would concur with that direction. Okay, great. Thank you. That's helpful. And I apologize for that. We can move then to the Mammoth Lakes Housing financials, which start with

25:58 The Statement of Financial Position for the quarter ending March 31. On this page, you'll see our accounts receivables, our prepaid insurance, amateurization, fixed assets, there's no changes. And then HBA Cal Homes is a grant that we received that we made loans to manufactured homes. So as we receive payments towards those loans,

26:40 That balance goes down. Then you'll see our properties. The change to 238 Sierra Manor Road construction in progress, which is CIP, you'll see went up about $100,000, and that is the capitalization of the costs associated with the architects and engineering. Down below on the second half of the page, you see our current liabilities.

27:18 Our long-term liabilities, which include loans that we have outstanding on properties. And then at the bottom, you'll see our different reserves, our risk reserve, our reserve for Star Apartments for capital improvements, reserve for 238, and our CalHome reuse pot, which is used to make another manufactured home loan.

27:51 So that's the balance that we have available to loan to eligible households. Are there any questions on that page? No questions, go ahead. Okay. The next page is our statement of activities, which shows income and expenses for each period of the fiscal year. I wanted to point out that we do have a separate line item under revenue for emergency rent assistance.

28:35 And then we also have an expense line item for emergency rent assistance. So that's trying to help us keep track of income that we receive for that specific purpose and then matching that up with the expense. You'll notice under expenses, deed restriction retention, we spent approximately $30,000 on that line item. And in the budget, we had only budgeted $17,000.

29:12 That's an overage of about $13,000 on that line item. And that is a result of all the deed restriction transfers that we helped steward over the past 18 months or so. I don't have anything else I want to highlight on this page. Are there any questions? If there are no questions, Patricia?

29:54 You know, I actually had asked Patricia to kind of go through some stuff ahead of time because I had some questions about our actual revenue because as Patricia pointed out, you know, there's $463,000 in our total revenue side that is actually a pass-through. It's not, you know, it's offset obviously on the bottom after, you know,

30:27 Equalize both revenue and expenses. But I guess it would just be helpful for me if we could talk about or sometime another, maybe even at our special meeting, have a discussion about our actual revenue without the pass-through in it and kind of look at that because I know we've taken on more work for the rental assistance program and there's been additional funding for

30:59 operating that program and more impact on staffing and demand on staffing. And so with that, I mean, I would like the board to discuss that revenue and just, and I think around the contract with LISC, it's a good time to have that discussion as well as, because that funding will go into what, the next fiscal year, is that right, Patricia, the LISC grant?

31:28 Or a list contract? Yes, that's right. Yeah. So it wouldn't hit this one, but it would hit the draft budget, which I guess we can discuss under obviously that agenda item. But maybe if when we, I don't know if we'll approve the budget tonight or we're just reviewing it, but I think that that's just a number that's important. I think that we're aware of.

31:58 what our actual total revenue is. So I guess that's all I have to say right now on that. I don't want to get ahead because we're not to the budget yet. I think it's a great idea to bring an outline of the actual revenue. So on this page, the statement of activities, the net operations income at this time without quarter four is about $170,000.

32:30 Part of that, we owe, we received a lump sum from the town for their cares, their CDBG cares allocation, which hasn't been spent yet because the state halted rental assistance for that funding. So we owe that money back to that program, depending on how the town wishes to utilize those funds. That's about $40,000.

32:56 And then we also have a responsibility to continue to fund the Latino coalition position for about $12,000. And so that could potentially come out of this net revenue. And so that number of $170,000 isn't exactly accurate. And so I could definitely bring a better explanation to our next meeting.

33:31 And I'm assuming on the next page those things aren't reflected in there either in the forecast. That's correct. We haven't received program guidelines on how the town would like to utilize those funds, so we haven't forecasted any expenditure of that CARES money, which is a specific pot of about $40,000, and that has not been forecasted to be expended in the next quarter.

34:02 Although it could potentially be expended, depending on the timing. Thank you. Thank you. Further questions on the budget? That's all I have on the statement of activities, but I can move to the forecast. The forecast is a document that we use to attempt to predict where the budget will be at the end of the fiscal year. The fiscal year ends June 30th.

34:42 And so we have one quarter left, April, May, June. And so Diane and I have spent some time going through projected revenue for each of these line items and then projected expenses. I'm just trying to see if I had any specific line items I wanted to highlight. And again, you'll see at the

35:24 The bottom of the total forecast column on the second page, the forecasted or projected net revenue is approximately $150,000, which like I said, isn't exactly accurate, but we can have a table or a spreadsheet with some more detail on that at our next meeting. I guess I'll touch a little bit on where that, you know,

36:02 Just mentioned where some of that income may have come from, and some of it is from our property management fees that we charge to manage the properties that we own. That is revenue for Mammoth Lakes Housing. And then we did receive a contract with Inyo County this past year to develop a rehabilitation program, and we have been fulfilling that contract as well, and so there's revenue from that contract. And we have a variety of other contracts, and so

36:31 That's just an example of where we might get revenue. That's all I have on the forecast. Are there any questions on that item? And then the last page is the statement of cash flow, which is a description of non-cash activities which impact our assets. And so you'll see things like depreciation, accounts receivable,

37:20 Rent deposits, which aren't actually revenue. And then financing activities, which then at the bottom is the balance of cash at the end of March. And that's for all of our accounts. So we have a variety of accounts, including rent deposits for our tenants, an account for Star Apartments Reserve for capital improvements.

37:56 An account for 238 Sierra Manor Road Reserve to facilitate the completion of that project. So this is all of the cash for the organization. Questions from the board? If there are no questions, Patricia? If there are no other questions, we can approve the third quarter financials for Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I'll bring back the financials for Sierra Housing Advocates. If I can hear a motion.

38:42 So moved. Is there a second? I'll second the motion. It's been moved and seconded to approve the Mammoth Lake Housing, Sierra Housing Advocate, LLC, Fiscal Year 2021, Third Quarter Draft Financial Statement. This is an action item. Angie, a roll call, please. Kirk, that was wrong. We're adopting the Mammoth Lakes Housing. Oh, sorry. Mammoth Lake Housing, 2021 Fiscal Year Budget.

39:14 Third quarter, yeah. Third quarter. Third quarter. This one, but not this one. So moved. Okay, so we had a motion by Tom and a second by President Stout, and we're just approving the Mammoth Lakes Housing quarter ending third quarter, is that correct? Yes. Thank you. Yes. Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Soraya Cruz? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes.

39:50 Jennifer Kreitz?

39:53 Yes.

39:54 Chair Stapp?

39:55 Yes.

39:56 And Toni Perkins?

39:59 Yes.

40:00 Thank you.

40:02 Chair, staff, I failed to abstain from agenda item four and I need to abstain from

40:20 that I don't know what the best

40:27 A course of action is, but I apologize for missing my note. I had made a note and I didn't see it, but I need to abstain. I can't participate. I don't believe in the recruitment and appointment of people to our board. I believe you may fall under that same restriction, but maybe we could do a new, I don't know. I apologize. I don't know how to correct it.

41:00 I'm so sorry. It's really my fault in my staff report. I should have highlighted the fact that the elected officials and those falling into the category of public employees cannot participate in the nomination of board members. So that would include board member Kreitz, board member staff, and board member Cruz as well.

41:31 Do we just need to re-agendize this? I mean, we've already, it's part of the record, so we acknowledge it after the fact, so does it need to be re-agendized to make the correction? Well, I think the person who made the motion could amend their motion, and if the person who seconded it would approve it, or I don't even know if it has to be amended, because I think the motion is still valid, I just think.

42:04 Three of us need to abstain instead of vote. So I think we could just do another roll call vote maybe. I think you seconded the motion, Jennifer? I think I did. So we probably do need a motion. We need to maybe strike that one and redo it. Sorry for the mess. I really apologize. No, thank you for bringing it up. So Jennifer, how do you want to correct this? If Tom can maybe just... Okay.

42:39 I will make a motion to appoint Heidi Steenstra to the Board of Mammoth Lakes Housing to fill the available seat that we were recruiting for. Is Lindsay available? I'm available. I can second. It moved and seconded. So it's moved and seconded. And the three, the elected officials need to abstain.

43:21 Correct. And Zariah as well. Yes. Roll call vote. Lindsay Barksdale. Yes. Zariah Cruz is abstaining. Abstain. Yes. Tom Hodges. Yes. Jennifer Kreitz. I'm going to abstain. I abstain. And Tony Perkins. Yes. Thank you. So the motion passes.

43:59 Thank you. So are we on the parcel? No, we're on the budget. Okay. So we are still on the agenda item six, review and plausible approval. Approve the Mammoth Lake Housing Draft 21-22 physical year budget. Patricia? Thank you. So I have provided with you a draft budget for the next fiscal year starting July 1.

44:28 And I like to provide it to the board in May so that in June we can possibly adopt it. So if there are comments or recommendations, I'm happy to incorporate them as needed. I'll start on the revenue side. This, let's see, what do we have here? So under town contract services, I have

44:58 added a 5% increase for Mammoth Lakes Housing. In 2012, Mammoth Lakes Housing took a budget cut of approximately $50,000. And since that time, 10 years later, we've still been receiving the same contract amount. So in our negotiations with the town, I've asked for a modest 5% increase to help cover our ongoing rising costs.

45:26 And so I've included that in the budget. Under contract income other, you'll see a slight increase in the amount over last budget. And that includes some of our smaller contracts, such as the city of Bishop, the California Coalition for Rural Housing, which helps to pay for our intern. Hopefully we are successful in recruiting an intern.

45:56 And an estimate for fees for our MOU with Mono County. So that's what's included in that line item. I included $1,000 for fundraising as a modest amount. We far surpassed our goal of $20,000 in five years this past year through our fundraising efforts for the emergency rent assistance program, which we fundraised approximately or a little over

46:28 $80,000. So I've included $1,000 here just as a placeholder, although I foresee attempting to do some fundraising for the 238 Sierra Manor Road Project. Under, I believe it's called grant management income, yeah, grant administration. This includes all of our grant contracts and administrative fees for services that we provide under those contracts.

47:04 for down payment assistance specifically, but also I have included 50,000 for our contract with the state for the California COVID-19 rent relief program, which is the contract that we have proposed to bring back at a special meeting. And I've included 50,000 for that contract. We're eligible for up to 100,000.

47:31 for that program, but it's unclear if there's demand for that much staff time. So I've included $50,000 for the next fiscal year under grants administration for that grant. Are there any questions under revenue? That $50,000 is for staff time, not for allocation of funds, right? That's right. That contract has a specific budget within it, which you'll see at the next meeting.

48:07 which includes a majority of staff time, and then there's some, a small allocation for supplies, and then another allocation for mileage reimbursement for travel, and a 10% administration allocation to help cover overhead costs. And that's the list that we're talking about, right? That's right. Okay, thanks.

48:47 Okay, that's revenue. Under operating expenses, I'm just going to highlight some areas where I've made some changes. I increased the software line item $400 to include an annual subscription to Zoom webinar. I'm not sure if that's going to be an ongoing need. However,

49:23 I think there is some demand for, despite being tired of online meetings, I think there is some demand for access to, you know, our resources in an online format. I have had some conversations with Mono County IT, who is not extremely comfortable with providing us services without a fee. And so this would be something that we would have to pay for on our own.

49:52 And additionally, it would allow for us to provide simultaneous Spanish translation if we had our own webinar access. And so I've included it here, but I'm happy to discuss that more. I increased postage and delivery because, as you can see, our forecasted expense for postage was up this year because of the rent assistance program.

50:23 But the cost of stamps also went up, so I increased that by $50. For printing and reproduction, I also increased this line item in preparation for our rebranding initiative and thinking ahead if we are going to have new materials that we might need to print, not only just business cards, but potentially flyers advertising our programs.

50:55 Potentially a flyer or some materials for fundraising around 238 and things of that nature. And so I've increased this line item. Under insurance, we've talked about this before. Last year, we saw a steep increase in our insurance costs. I will be working with our insurance broker who specializes in nonprofit insurance. We'll be renewing again in September.

51:33 And so they're well aware that I'm interested in shopping our policy around again this year. I believe we can find some savings, I'm hopeful. But this, I have projected a 10% increase at renewal for our insurance. Our office space expenses include property tax, HOA fees, and the interest that we pay on our office for our mortgage. Are there any questions?

52:14 this so far. I'd like to just stop in case somebody wants to talk about any of those line items. Questions from the board? I have a comment. I'm not a question maybe or something for Patricia to consider before we bring back a revised draft on license and permits. I know that both Patricia and I or my Patricia and my

52:46 DRE Department of Real Estate licenses need to be renewed this year and then this coming fiscal year and I'm not sure that that will cover them. That's a great comment. Thank you. I will go back and double check that and see if I can't include it. Okay. Yeah, I can. I don't know what the cost is, but I'm sure it's more than standard. Further discussion? If there's no other questions, I'll just keep going.

53:28 Let's see. I guess my only other question that I think, you know, might warrant a little bit of attention would be the deed restriction subsidy. I mean, we did blow that budget this year. We've had a lot of activity with turnover of deed restricted units. I mean, I can see that it's been increased by $3,000 roughly, well, $2,300, but I'm just curious if you could talk a little bit about that.

53:57 So I know we had this conversation at the last budget and I had greatly reduced this line item in the last budget and as we saw we greatly exceeded that budget allocation. I think what I'd like to do is find out how many deed restrictions we have with the old restriction. I would like to know that and then I guess

54:32 Think strategically about the likelihood that we might need to buy back another unit based on the requirement that they market it for 60 days. 60 days seems like enough time to find a qualified buyer, but it's not always. And a lot of times we're coming up on the deadline and sometimes Mammoth X Housing has to buy the unit back, as we know. And I think a lot of

55:07 There are not a lot, but there are expenses associated with the buying and the selling of a unit, regardless of if it needs maintenance or not. So I think that's something else I like to consider as I look at that number. And I think coming up with a more meaningful number would be helpful. Yeah, and I guess it's my understanding that that line item is for

55:36 Is for, you know, the cost of sale, getting something, a property ready for resale, or just the cost of the transaction, and not for, you know, what the revolving loan funds is really there to do, the town or the counties, which have, you know, $900,000 between the two of them. So, yeah, I think it's probably worth a little bit more thought, just so that, yeah, I like your strategy. Thanks.

56:11 Thanks for bringing it up again. Yep, I'm going to move on to payroll expenses. The salaries and wages line item includes the expenses for two full-time employees, one part-time intern, and one part-time staff person who's working on the Latino Housing Coalition, which is partially funded through Mono County, an allocation that we received from Mono County Behavioral Health.

56:57 I'm going to go down to professional fees. So I've added a line item here called design and copy editing services based on the feedback we received from the RFP responses regarding rebranding and marketing. It's pretty standard practice to have the designer update the templates.

57:28 And if you don't have that kind of capacity in-house, it's something that you pay for. I didn't include any expenses in this line item this year because we have allocated some funding in the consulting line item to pay for the initial rebranding and marketing strategy, which will include

57:52 the first pass at some of those templates that we asked for, such as the annual report, some trifolds for programs, business cards, and things of that nature. But I wanted the board and the public to be aware that this isn't something we have professionals in our office that are capable of doing, and so I've included a line item here in case we need those services in the future.

58:23 For website maintenance, I've included a line item here, and this would also include any tech support that we need from either Mono County IT, or we also use CBT in case we need help with our computers or website maintenance, such as upgrades, like security upgrades to our website, things that we're just not experts in. So I've included that line item here.

58:53 I've also included a line item for interpreter services. These services run about $200 per hour. And so I've included enough funding here for three public meetings. And then you'll see our fees for accounting and our legal fees. And then under the consulting line item, we haven't spent any money in this fiscal year on our consulting line item.

59:26 And so the marketing committee would like to allocate this fiscal year's allocation and next fiscal year's allocation for a total of $24,000 for the rebranding and marketing plan for Mammoth Lakes Housing moving forward. Are there any questions or comments so far? You talked about the possibility of finding

59:59 A little bit of additional funds to supplement that? Were you unable to find anything else in the budget to expand that beyond the $24,000? Well, I think that along the lines of talking about our revenue for this year, at our next meeting, I could bring a deeper analysis of any potential revenue that we have at the end of the fiscal year.

1:00:30 And the board could choose to allocate more of that to the rebranding initiative at that time. Or we could also do a budget amendment at a later date. Thank you. Okay, I'm going to move on. So I guess the next item here is travel and training. I believe it was two years ago.

1:01:17 The board had asked for an increase to this line item, and I think we got up to almost $13,000 for all of the travel and training that the board had recommended. And then COVID came, and in the next fiscal year, we reduced the travel and training budget, since everything was online and registration fees were reduced a lot of times, and so we had reduced that budget.

1:01:47 And then in this fiscal year, I'm proposing to go back to the standard approximately $8,000 in travel and training, which includes participation in the annual California Coalition for Rural Housing Summit, as well as the annual Housing California Conference.

1:02:12 And then some other smaller trainings with the Department of Housing and Community Development, mostly a lot about grant programs. But then I've increased it slightly to include additional mileage reimbursement for our Latino coalition staff person to travel and hold open houses regarding the California COVID-19 rent relief program. And that's where you see the increase in this line item.

1:02:48 After depreciation, which the board authorized to include in our operating budget in 2019, the total net income is negative approximately $1,400. And I'm happy to think some more about those specific items that have been mentioned so far. Are there any other comments or questions? And we can bring this back to our June meeting.

1:03:32 Jennifer? Yeah, I think that would be great, Patricia. I really do. And, you know, you mentioned using some carryover from last year for consulting. You know, we talked about the deed restriction retention, looking at that again. Not really sure, obviously, where we're going to close the books at this fiscal year with

1:04:05 with the net operating income, but it seems like it's up quite a bit, just looking at the beginning, the first page of the budget, you know, it's almost, well, it's over $200,000 more, and I understand that there might be some money in there that has to go back to the town or something of that nature, but we could, you know, try to tighten up that forecast a little bit and have a discussion at our...

1:04:32 maybe our special meeting even so that it could better equip you to prepare because I think we have to approve the budget in June a solid budget for our June preview and hopefully approval just the board's consideration of prioritizing spending that carryover funding one of the things that I see we're doing continually is taking on more and more

1:05:00 programs and not really increasing staff capacity. And so I think, you know, if we want to keep growing and doing things, adding work, we should have a conversation about possibilities and some of the funding for additional staff. I think that should be on the table for the board's discussion. And that was my request. So I

1:05:29 Yeah, I'm not prepared to approve the budget tonight, but I do appreciate all the work you put into it. Thank you. Yeah, just kind of tagging on to what Jennifer said. I mean, you know, several years ago when we did the sort of that first round of the new contract with the town and really went through and assessed the number of hours we thought it would take to provide the services that are in the contract.

1:06:01 And my recollection is they ate up 85% of staff time, or thereabouts, if I recall. And then you consider this year, you know, we took on the rental relief program on top of that, albeit maybe some other things got put on hold, but overall, it was more administrative work, right? And so, and there wasn't any direct nexus of reimbursement for those additional efforts. So, so yeah, so I agree, you know, and I think it's,

1:06:32 You know, in order to grow, you know, grow our services and our ability to serve our community, ultimately, we're pretty much maxed out with staff that we have and even with the intern. So it really is coming down to a question of having that discussion about, you know, getting over the hump to get, you know, another, in reality, another full-time staff person, you know, I think is where we probably would want to go to have some more bandwidth. So,

1:07:04 We'll see, you know, and there's going to be potentially, you know, in both the state and federal levels, there might be some additional affordable housing grants, you know, set asides that are going to get legislated and, you know, having the ability to apply for those type of programs is probably going to be more of that work to be done in the coming year or two, for sure. So these are things that are all super important to sustain.

1:07:34 our programs or grow our programs and the need for the, you know, readily apparent need for more affordable housing in our community. So I think it all goes hand in hand. Thank you for your comments. I just want to make sure, do we want to review the budget again at the special meeting or just the net revenue from this fiscal year to inform the budget discussion in June? I think just the last. I'm sorry, go ahead.

1:08:13 Go ahead, that's it. Yeah, well, I think that it's helpful to highlight the areas within this draft we've reviewed where some of our options are so that it's not in isolation of the budget. It just might be more productive if we talked about some of those items specifically. If we're looking at moving the

1:08:43 the carryover from this year. And I think we should talk about that in relation to this draft budget. Okay, just some of the items that we highlighted. Do you want to see the full draft again? Or just those highlighted? Not if there's any, no reason. I mean, you've already increased, like, I don't think we need to talk about printing or stamps, you know? I think the things that might warrant some more discussion and might need some

1:09:17 You know, that we might want to expand upon. And, you know, obviously, it might not be spending, it might be putting more into the razor for 238. I don't know those are, and that's not in the budget. Okay, great. That's helpful. Thank you. I'm not an expert on how all this is put together with the forecast and the budget and everything. I completely agree that we need more

1:09:50 funding for staff time, but being on the committee for marketing, I know it's going to be difficult to get anything done to expand the business if we try to take funds out of that. But where I do think we need to pay attention to is making sure we're getting money for all of our services, what we're doing, such as the contract with the town. Last month we talked about

1:10:18 working something out with Pacific companies, so we're going to make sure that we get paid for anything we end up doing for them regarding the parcel. I don't think that's been brought up since then, but it's those type of things that make sure you get paid for the time that you're spending on this stuff instead of just doing it for free as a charitable donation is how we're going to get those funds, and that goes beyond just

1:10:48 Pulling a couple thousand out of what our carryover from last year and making sure moving forward we're billing for everything we're doing. Great. Thank you all for your really thoughtful feedback. I'll bring something back at the next meeting. And if I can just interrupt really quick, President Stapp, I just want to confirm that this particular item

1:11:22 will be brought back at the next regular meeting, not the special meeting, is that correct? Yes. Thank you. We'll move to agenda item seven, town of Mammoth Lakes measure A allocation is an information item. Patricia? Thank you. So this item, I'm bringing before the board this evening for a number of reasons. One being that the last time the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board

1:11:54 reviewed the measure A allocations was in 2019. I know it's of interest to this board and so it seemed timely to bring it back. Another reason is that because I think I mentioned in my staff report, the programs and development committee has been interested in

1:12:19 Looking for new funding sources for middle income programs, which aren't always funded by grant programs. And so Measure A is a potential source of funding for programs that help higher incomes, unique programs, maybe that help support our unique challenges that we face here and things that don't come with all the strings that state and federal funding comes with.

1:12:48 So I provided a little bit of background on Measure A, was passed in 2002, and then in 2017, the Town Council appointed a subcommittee to analyze the allocations of Measure A across NGO and JPA partners. That recalibration resulted in 2.35% going to Mammoth Lakes Tourism, 0.85% going to Transit,

1:13:18 And 0.85% going to housing. My analysis of this is that, you know, one of the NGOs receives the full percentage allocation, which is 2.35% for tourism, which goes to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Of the 0.85% allocated to transit, ESTA receives approximately 700,000 annually.

1:13:47 And of the 0.85% allocated to housing, Mammoth Lakes Housing has been receiving $330,000 annually since 2012. As I mentioned, the Mammoth Lakes Housing Programs and Development Committee has been discussing different options for funding new programs and creative programs that might help income levels higher than the traditional low income threshold. And that this is

1:14:23 that this is a potential funding source. Other funding sources that have been discussed include new taxes or new tax districts, excess TOT, and other policies that might help with creative solutions. Wanted the board to take a moment and discuss this item

1:14:58 I think it's important for the community to be aware of our priorities. And so this is an information item. And I'm happy to take staff direction as the board sees fit. Comments? Questions? I'll make a couple comments. So I believe it's increased the transit occupancy tax by 4%, right? As I add up the breakdown of the...

1:15:35 Tourism, Transit, and Housing. Well, I think there were a couple of different measures all added together. I think this one, this specific one may have only been 2%, but all told at the end of the day, the rate today is 13%. Okay. And to be clear, town policy is that this money goes into housing reserve fund that's at the discretion of town council.

1:16:05 Yes. Of which currently $330 is contracted to MLH for the contract agreement with MLH annually. And then the other monies have been, at least in recent years, have gone largely to the parcel acquisition and other such expenses related to the parcel, which is all great because it provides a land bank for building housing in the communities.

1:16:35 Yeah, so, you know, really, I think the other part of it is, I believe that that percentage is, did you have the number in there that's been equating to totally? 0.85 is about $700,000 to $800,000 a year? Well, if you're looking at actuals versus the adoptive budget.

1:17:03 You know, reconciling the excess TOT over what has been budgeted has never been, I would say, completely clarified. So yeah, if it's over the town's budget, $14.5 million or whatever, so the excess TOT, you're saying there's no commitment of that allocation necessarily along the lines of measuring? Not that I'm aware of. Yeah.

1:17:36 So, I mean, what, you know, I'll just kind of throw it out there because this is sort of related, but, you know, as we kind of look for sources of funding for housing, you know, I've been kind of advocating that in addition to Measure A, that excess TOT, if you will, which is above what our budget, the town's budget is for collection of TOT, you know, is

1:18:09 Trended into five million range. I mean, before COVID, obviously, before things changed with COVID, but so say, for example, for easy math, if the budget's 14 and a half million TOT and we have an actual TOT capture of 20 million, which is about where we were at before things, you know, before the pandemic, you know, you'd be at five and a half million of excess TOT. So, you know, my

1:18:38 My pitch is that town council needs to entertain a policy discussion about, okay, taking some proportion of that excess TOT, which I think is going to be fairly consistent moving ahead here as we come out of the pandemic, you know, and earmarking that towards housing to some level. So, you know, I mean, housing, I think is, I think everybody agrees that it's a critical issue for this community.

1:19:08 Both for our existing population, workforce, as well as any opportunity to grow our economy and add new jobs, right? There's not housing for people to come into the community at this point. So we've got to grow our affordable housing. And it all takes money, right? Whether it's middle income or even lower income, any of those income levels, bottom line is we need more money.

1:19:37 It's just a question of, you know, like I say, the political will to prioritize housing and take some proportion of, and what I would throw out there is like, hey, let's, I know there's been discussions before about tacking another point on TOT, but the point is we're making excess TOT, so let's put our money where our mouth is and let's start saying, again, this is going to be up to the council to come up with this policy direction, but.

1:20:07 Take, I don't know, you pick a number, I mean, you can kind of forecast what our, our, our, you know, their demands that we need for money are, they're endless, right? So, I mean, even if you were to put $3 million a year into additional money in the housing reserve, you know, we're going to need all that more, right? For at least for a while. So, and being that it's, you know, I think we say this over and over again, there's no silver bullet solution to this issue. It takes, it takes.

1:20:35 It's going to take a long-term, consistent effort, commitment, in the good, in the bad times, which we never seem we're willing to do. And, you know, here we are again with no money in the kitty for housing, and we're in dire need of housing, and it's a super critical issue because we didn't, you know, whatever, everything happened that we couldn't save the money, you know, but we should see prosperous times moving ahead with, as we rebound from the pandemic, you know, people are still going to come to Mammoth in droves, and we're going to,

1:21:05 likely increase our TOT to a point, not a whole lot more, but a little bit more. And so, you know, Kirk, you and your fellow council members have to decide what other priorities are. I mean, I know you always say there's all these other infrastructure problems that we need to address, you know, paving the roads. Roads are starting to look a little rough here and there from the winters, and maybe there's additional money needed for that. But again, it's just all a question of prioritization.

1:21:34 You know, this certainly, I think, I think there's strong agreement in the community that housing is probably our number one issue right now. And it's likely to continue to be for quite a while. You know, I think, you know, the only thing that backs that up is the fact that, you know, real estate prices only continue to grow, increase quarter to quarter. And, and the sad reality is they can still increase because we're still behind our peer resorts in terms of sales.

1:22:03 Sales values for condos, resort condos, for example. So that gap, that affordability gap is only going to continue to increase in the foreseeable future. I don't really see that changing. I don't think we're going to see a bubble burst. There isn't mortgage-backed security issues with the current market. I think things are going to flatten out a little bit, but I don't see any giant.

1:22:32 Reduction or course correction prices coming back down anytime soon. So that's my opinion, but that's how I read the tea leaves from all the things I'm watching in the news with the economy and everything else that's going on. So anyway, that's my pitch. Sorry to be long-winded, but I'm going to kind of get back on that soapbox every chance I get. And yeah, I'll leave it at that because I'll probably mention a few other things in my board report. Thanks. No, I completely agree. I mean, my wife,

1:23:04 Travels to Mammoth from Bishop to work a minimum wage job because we can't afford to live up there, but that's where the work is. Would it be possible to incorporate some of that into the contract we have with the town to suggest that some of that excess TOT funds gets directed into our contract?

1:23:34 Without putting a solid number on it, maybe just a certain percentage? There's a long history to Measure A and the 1% that originally of DOT went through and then there's the airport litigation and all these different things that have impacted the different budgets. Just to give you guys a little bit of a heads up.

1:24:04 I mean, roads, we have been underfunding for four years. And so, I mean, we haven't underfunded them, but we budgeted half the amount of money that should be. So it's been the excess TOT that has been fully funding the maintenance of road. A single blower, which we need to replace the one that's down there, they guys have to, anyway, the working conditions are not great. That's $850,000.

1:24:32 We need to build two new bays down in the industrial park so the guys don't work under canvas that they pull over the broken equipment and work outside with the heater underneath the piece of equipment to try to keep their fingers from freezing. We've got a lot of different priorities. Housing has always been one of my major priorities and we're slowly moving forward but I'm just trying to warn.

1:24:59 Everybody that when it goes before council, council is going to, you know, look at a lot of different budget items. I completely support that without the workers, we're not going to be successful. And the workers, you know, having to drive up, the town employees driving up from Bishop is not exactly efficient. I'm just trying to give you a little bit of the dynamics of what's happening at the council level.

1:25:31 I just feel like compared with ESTA and Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we're viewed as a charity and that helps them just let our services get overlooked. And so as long as we're viewed as a charity, they're going to keep on bypassing us and getting whatever they can out of us for as little money as we can. But it's really

1:26:00 Not a charity and it needs to improve because the housing prices are only getting worse and the wages are not getting any better. So there's a growing gap and especially with Airbnb and all the places being second home rentals and everything, it's impossible to find anything. And especially for families, maybe if you're a teenager coming in, you can rent a

1:26:30 place and share room with somebody but for families it's practically impossible and it's really only going to get worse and we're out here giving our services for free and the town expects us since we're a charitable non-profit that we're just going to keep doing that but we really need to

1:26:55 push forward and grow our organization to serve more people and we're only going to be harming ourselves if we keep just helping out for nothing. Tony, I completely agree with you. Further discussion? Jennifer? Well, I appreciate the dialogue and I think that, you know, Tom and I agree with what everyone has said.

1:27:29 And, you know, Tom made the point that it comes down to the council setting priorities. And, you know, I know that that's always an ongoing challenge to find funding. But, you know, I did happen to read the sheet today and I thought that I think it was Ted or somebody did a good analysis of, you know.

1:27:54 I think it was $40 million had spent over the past five years on MLT, and I think it was maybe $13 or something on housing. It just paled in comparison. Obviously, I'm not saying that his math was 100% or anything of that nature, but I thought that the disparity was shocking.

1:28:25 serve on a board of a nonprofit with a mission to create housing for our communities and the region. And I think we have to continue to push for that and advocate for that and work to solve those challenges because they're real. There, you know, there was a lot of housing in the paper this week and, you know, a lot of people are struggling and it's not going to get easier.

1:28:55 I'm just grateful that we do have some town council members that want to look at it and have dialogue about it and hopefully actually set some funding aside more than what's been set aside because if we don't have a place for our employees to live and we just don't have a community and then we don't have anybody to fill our jobs.

1:29:24 I don't, you know, I agree. Thanks. Further discussion? We're going to move to Sierra Manor Road. Yeah. If there's no further discussion on the Measure A allocation, we'll move to Agenda Item Number 8, the 238 Sierra Manor Road Affordable Housing Project update and possible approval of fee waiver requests. This is an action item. Patricia? Thanks. So this is our...

1:30:00 Update on progress on the 238 Sierra Manor Road project. Mammoth Lakes Housing purchased this building in 2017 through a partial land donation of the previous owner. The intention is to convert the property into 11 one-bedroom apartments with five garages. Each of those apartments is approximately 700 square feet.

1:30:29 You know, the site of this project is really ideal, not only for residents, but for grant funding, competitiveness. It's walkable, less than one block, to multiple free transit stops, to grocery stores, the schools, the public library, and other public services. Let's see, I provided some photos from our design.

1:31:01 review process with the architects that we had in 2019. They had this nice little 3D model that the community was able to look at, and then some schematic drawings and a potential visualization of what the project will look like when it's complete. On page three, I've outlined some of the financing for this project. In February of 2020,

1:31:35 The estimated total development cost was approximately $6 million. In 2019, the MLH Board approved an application for home funds of 1.3 million. And then in 2020, the town of Mammoth Lakes approved a partnership application for $3 million.

1:32:09 Some other funding components include some funding from IMACA for homelessness prevention. The town of Mammoth Lakes has indicated their willingness to contribute $300,000 to the project. Mono County Social Services has said that they would be willing to partner. There was the land donation and then Mammoth Lakes Housing has contributed approximately $800,000.

1:32:40 That includes our down payment to purchase the property and then ongoing mortgage payments that we make on an outstanding loan. So we've been doing a lot of work on this project. We procured the architects. We have the architectural plans. We've submitted the grant applications. We are just doing a lot. There's a lot to do for this type of project.

1:33:12 So the next step in this project is really, we applied for a building permit through the town, and now in order to help reduce some of the costs of the project, we need to ask for some fee waivers. If there's a possibility that we can reduce the fees and have the community jurisdictions help contribute in that way, it will only help make the project more feasible.

1:33:43 Especially considering the time that it's taking for grant awards, the cost of the project goes up the longer we wait for our awards to come in. I provided an estimate of the fees based on a really rough preliminary estimate. I'm having ongoing conversations with the water district and the town of Mammoth Lakes regarding

1:34:10 The fee estimates. And so this is more of an example of fees and not any portrayal of what the actual fees are at this time, because I don't have that at this moment. The town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code allows for developers to ask for fee waivers. And so I included the language of the Municipal Code in the staff report for your reference.

1:34:44 And that process would include submitting a request for a fee waiver in writing. And then the town council will hear the request for fee waiver within 60 days of that request. And bringing this item to the board this evening to give you an update on the process and also to ask for approval of the submission of these fee waivers.

1:35:18 request for fee waivers in an effort to show that we're doing our due diligence, we are attempting to keep costs down and in partnership with the jurisdictions that will help make this project possible. So this evening I'm asking the board of directors to approve fee waiver requests

1:35:50 to all of the jurisdictions that are charging fees for this project. That's all I have for my staff report on this item, but I'm happy to answer any questions that you might have about the status of this project, the fee waiver request process, or anything else that you need more information on. Question from the board? Yeah, I have a couple quick questions in regards to the fee estimate from the town on the building permit.

1:36:23 There's some diff fees for library and childcare and fire district. Is that taking into account the fact that this building exists and that square footage is basically the same? So, I mean, the analysis should be going from, if I understand, I believe I recall the code correctly on this type of a conversion, you evaluate

1:36:54 The change in use and what the fees are, the change in use versus what it, how it would be evaluated in its current commercial use. And then the difference is what you're on the hook for, not being evaluated as 11 new apartments out of the blue because the building's already there. Does that make sense? Yeah. So I actually have, I have a call, an inquiry and a call

1:37:24 proposed for this week with the person who provides these fee estimates and so that we can go over some of the finer details regarding the numbers. Yeah, so just make sure that you're getting credit for the existing square footage and its existing use as it relates to the fee structure versus its converted use to residential. And I think it would be, I know that applies, I'm pretty certain for the town.

1:37:55 I would assume it's similar for the fire district and the water district as well. I think the water district's all by meter size, so it just depends what the current meter is versus what the required meter will be, you know, then you'd be paying the delta, I suppose, but notwithstanding requesting a waiver of fees regardless. Yeah, I think so. I think my recommendation is that we ask for all the fees from all the jurisdictions.

1:38:30 I think it's our responsibility. Further discussion? Kirk, this is Dan Holler. If I can speak to some of the fees there. As mentioned, I'm not sure if these were finalized through our staff yet or not, based on the project and the comments made by Member Hodges there. A couple of things in here real quick on the building fees. There's two pieces of that. Part of that's an outside plan check charge, which would be difficult to waive.

1:39:07 In terms of town staff time inspections and stuff, assuming we're not using outside inspectors, there's a potential for that to be waived ultimately a council decision. The other two that are the town's authority there would be the document management fee and the new development fee. The other two listed there, the SMIP fee and the admin fee, those are both state mandated fees that are passed through to the state. We don't have the authority to waive those.

1:39:34 Then the rest of the fees listed would have to go to those individual agencies. The town has no authority to waive the fees that we collect on behalf of library, the trial care of the fire, and obviously water school, et cetera. So those would all need to go through those other agencies if there's a waiver of those fees. So the ones here actually that we could waive, they're pretty minimal from a town perspective, other than a portion of the building permit fee that is not a direct.

1:40:03 Charged to the town from the plan review. FYI on those. And the housing component fees are already a waiver for affordable housing. Just to make a comment, when you look at the different districts, the water district, the fire protection district, and the school district, they have very limited funding sources. So, you know, I would be, I'll be very proud of it. I'd be surprised if they,

1:40:39 gave up their fees, because it does take staff time, but I think we need to ask, yes, for the discussion. I'm kind of confused if those agencies are on their own independently, then how is it enforced if it's not the town that's requiring us to give them the money, and if those agencies independently, how do they...

1:41:18 Enforce it. How is it required for us to pay in order to get the permits? Tony, this would be, Dan, again, what we have to do is get a receipt of payment before we issue the building permit. So each agency, if some of those we collect on their behalf, so we like to file, we actually collect and hold it in a fund, then the fire department requests payment to them. I believe the water district and the schools provide a receipt of payment, at least the school district does.

1:41:49 Showing that those fees have been indeed paid. So if we don't have those receipts, we have not collected it directly until all that has been certified or documented, then the building permit is held until such time that it's paid. So it's a regular process we do with all development in town. So it's pretty streamlined across the agencies. I think the comment that Tom raised is probably the most valid one of going back and saying, what's the net differential?

1:42:20 And you may get some charges on housing that are not commercial. I don't recall the differentials off the top of my head there, but that could be a portion of this. I think that's true. And I still think we should go for a waiver of everything. And if that doesn't go through, we have to renegotiate. But I would imagine that if we have some support from the town about those separate fees, then

1:42:49 It would be influential toward those different agencies that are expecting to get those fees before you issue a permit. And if you're the ones issuing the permit, it's really your decision. It's their expectation. But as far as I can tell, you're the ones issuing the permit, not the library. Correct. But if we issue the permit without collecting fees, we'd be doing it illegally. So we would not issue it unless that fee.

1:43:20 We don't mind supporting that. I'll be honest. I think normally our town projects, we've requested similar few waivers and generally unsuccessfully. Can we get a letter of support from the town then for those different agencies? I think that'd be a good request to put in. You know, that'd be a council item to support that and waive those fees that aren't direct charges and pass-throughs.

1:43:50 that we would be able to waive on the town side. Great, that'd be appreciated if we could get a letter of support from the town for that because we're obviously not just your average for-profit developer and this is an urban infill project so it's not going to have the same impacts as a greenfield development so if we can get a letter of support from the town that would go a long way. Thanks.

1:44:21 On this agenda item, I'm going to recuse myself because this might come before the town council. Is this an action item? Is this an action item? It wasn't the agenda is an action item, was it? It was. The agenda is an action item. Okay. I think that I just have one question. I believe that Pacific West is getting the fee waiver for phase one. Is that right? I believe I heard that.

1:44:52 Yeah, for the parcel, they request, well, the fee waiver for the affordable housing for the fees and stuff for that related. The diff fees, what they requested is a deferral to pay it, you know, basically feature part of the project. So it's not a waiver of the fee, but deferral on timing of the fee is what they've requested us to consider. Is that for the infrastructure or did you say, Dan? I'm sorry, I didn't hear that. That's like the diff fees, the...

1:45:20 The non-chargeable, the front end, like, it's going to be paying for all the permit, plan checks and building permit fees, but the towns that develop an impact fees, they've requested a deferral on those out until, I'm not sure the timeline, if it's part of residual receipts payback or if it's time certain out that they would make a repayment of the fee amount, but it's not a full waiver of that, not being requested. Just like what you were saying, the format with Lakes Housing.

1:45:51 Same thing. I'm saying here for Amos Lakes Housing, I mean the stuff that we can waive, we can waive certain fees through a process versus just saying we can defer them out until you get it built and then pay us back five years or ten years down the road. I believe the request here would just be for a pure waiver of the town-related fees for the civic companies to request a deferral of those fees until some time in the future. I don't recall the time frame. An interest rate.

1:46:20 It's like an interest-free loan. Basically, yeah. I don't know. I don't think we're charging interest to it. I'm happy to make a motion for the recommended action. I'll second the motion. Can you do a roll call, Andy? Lindsay Barksdale? Yes. Soraya Cruz? Yes. Tom Hodges? Yes. Jennifer Kreitz? Yes. Kirk Stapp? McCuse? Oops. Tony Perkins?

1:47:10 Yes. And Heidi, is it Steenstra? Yes and yes. Thank you very much. Great, thank you very much. Agenda item nine. Yep. This is an information item, agenda item number nine. Number nine is Mammoth Lake Housing program update. Okay, thank you. I have a lot of exciting updates in my staff report this month.

1:47:52 If I go too fast, just feel free to jump in and ask your questions or comments. But I don't want to take up too much of your time, but I do want to hit on the highlights. So for deed restriction retention, we sold Meridian Court H-101, a closed escrow on March 23rd, and we paid back the revolving loan funds.

1:48:24 And then Aspen Village G106 is also in escrow. It closed last week, I think. So that'll be an update for next month. Under home buyer's assistance, I added this graph to show the gap between the current median sales price and what would be an affordable price.

1:48:53 For a household earning 120% of the area median income. I included that analysis for both the town and for Mono County. So you'll see in the beginning of March, the median sales price for a single family home in Mammoth Lakes was $975. And what would be affordable to a household earning 120% of the area median income was $520,000.

1:49:24 That's a gap of $450,000. The median condo price was $480,000, the affordable price would be $409,000, and that's a gap of about $70,000. In Mono County, the single family home gap is about $140,000, and the gap for a condo is about $40,000. Previously, some board members had asked for this information, and this is my first

1:49:58 My first try at visualizing it, but I'm happy to maybe add another visual or try something different next month to make sure we're getting all the information that we need. For down payment assistance funds, we have town home and town CDBG, which will be expiring the end of this summer. We have begin reuse funds available. And then we have the moderate income.

1:50:38 Down Payment Assistance Lottery, which staff needs to prioritize opening the lottery and receiving applications for that program, marketing and setting up the process for that. In Mono County, we have a home grant, which is set up and approved, and we are taking applications for down payment assistance in Mono County for households earning below 80% AMI.

1:51:13 Are there any questions? I was just going to thank you for getting the affordability gap graphs done. I think that's really helpful visual. I was having a little trouble reading it, but did you help clarify that for me? But I think it points to the fact that these programs like the home program at Moto County at 80% AMI and you look at the affordability gap, you know, it's hard for these, it's hard to find somebody

1:51:46 who even can qualify at that AMI level with the affordability gaps we're seeing now in the community and the county. So it's almost like that money's never going to get used, sadly, because our gap's grown so enormously. Yeah, I think we will begin to see additional challenges with our down payment assistance programs as we move through the next year. But I'll have a better sense of what those challenges are.

1:52:17 Once we start getting some more clients in the queue. Right. And the other thing I mentioned in the gap, I mean, if you look at for a condo in Mammoth, $70,600, you know, I mean, again, this kind of goes to town council, Kirk, in terms of if you can get people, middle income, and you can fund the gap and they can buy existing housing stock, then that's serving an immediate solution.

1:52:47 Right? At a fraction of the price of cost of developing new. So, you know, something to consider, but it certainly, it's pretty much out of reach for a single family home at this point, but maybe the condos, there might still be some opportunity there. I agree. I did see that HCD released new income levels, limits.

1:53:21 Right, because, um,

1:54:00 A low-income household or even a household earning 120% of the area median income can only afford so much in a primary mortgage. And then if the gap is $200,000 or $300,000 and the funding says you can only loan up to $200,000, then they're short $100,000, therefore the program doesn't work. The other thing I think I read, and I'm not sure, maybe it creates more opportunity in that.

1:54:32 Unincorporated County than in town is that the modesty clause I think was eliminated, which required that the home must be a three bedroom, two bath. So now it could be a two and a half bath. I can recall days at Mammoth Lakes Housing when we couldn't lend on a home because it had a half bath. So at least that's, you know, expands potentially inventory a little bit.

1:55:02 Absolutely. Yep, I'm going to move on to emergency rent assistance. You know, this program raised, I'll say almost a million dollars, and I just want to say thank you to all of our partners. We put an advertisement in the Times and in the sheet, I think it will come out this week, saying thank you to all of our donors.

1:55:37 I didn't think it was going to be such a large undertaking. I mean, I guess I knew it was going to be a large undertaking, but I didn't know we would have so much financial support from the community. And so we have a thank you page on our website and we put those ads in the paper to say thank you to all of our donors. To date, we've assisted or we've made more than 1,500.

1:56:07 Partial rent payments. And so we'll be winding down that program in the next quarter. We did some fundraising around this program and it was successful, like I mentioned, but now my mind is moving towards fundraising for 238 Sierra Manor Road to help fill any gaps in that development pro forma. In terms of grants,

1:56:41 I'm in weekly communication with the home program, answering their follow-up questions. They said we should hear something in May, if not sooner. So hopefully I'll have an update at the next meeting. I have a call in to the CDBG program manager regarding our CDBG application for 3 million, and they have not returned my call. So they said the earliest we would hear would be September of 2021.

1:57:11 Maybe we'll hear something in September, or maybe later. And then the CDBG applications, we're working with the town and Mono County to do applications for down payment assistance. And that application deadline was extended to June 15th. I lost my page. Okay. I'm back. Are there any questions on those items? Or I'll just keep going.

1:57:51 Item number four is the LISC Partnership for Rental Assistance. We've been partnering with LISC and the state on this program since March. Both IMACA and Mammoth Lakes Housing are coordinating on assisting clients complete their application. It's a lengthy online-only application for

1:58:18 tenants earning below 80% of the area median income who owe back rent or back utilities or need help paying their rent through June to help them comply with the eviction moratorium which expires. The contract, like I mentioned, is forthcoming. It's approximately $100,000 to pay for staff, some supplies, and travel. We've been doing newsletters.

1:58:55 Press release, radio coverage. We're working very closely with IMACA. We have a weekly meeting with them to coordinate on outreach efforts. We're really trying to make it a team effort for the region. And we're in the process of scheduling open houses throughout Mono County. And then we'll move to Inyo County with a team of staff who will participate in open houses for clients to help them fill out the application.

1:59:25 I attached information to the staff report for your reference. And then I wanted to let the board know that Mammoth Lakes Housing was awarded a pandemic champion award at their gala on April 27th for our emergency rent assistance program and a best pandemic pivot. We really took the lead on

1:59:55 making sure rent assistance was part of our pandemic response and as you all know it was very impressive and we're very proud of all the staff who worked on this program even our web designers who jumped at a moment's notice to implement the online application it's just been amazing all around including the participation from the jurisdictions and

2:00:25 The private donations that we raised from private individuals who donated their subsidy checks from the government. So all around it was amazing and I'm just proud of everybody and thank you to the board for all of your support as well. I wanted to update the board on the HUD proposed rule on mixed income status or mixed immigration status families.

2:00:58 The board and the town of Mammoth Lakes submitted a joint letter in response to the proposed rule which would make mixed immigration status families ineligible to live in subsidized housing. Mammoth Lakes Housing and the town both opposed the rule and I think that HUD received more than

2:01:27 30,000 comment letters, 95% of them in opposition or something along those lines. And I provided a press release by the National Low Income Housing Coalition for your reference so that you know the rule was thrown out. And so that proposed rule will not be adopted. And thank you for the town.

2:01:55 Mammoth Lakes Housing Board for submitting your comment letter on that issue. We have a lot of work items coming up. I think you're all well aware of what they all are. 238, CDBG, moderate income down payment assistance program, database trainings, all kinds of things. Marketing RFP for rebranding.

2:02:26 I need to renew my real estate license, which is going to take some time. And then staff are participating in some online trainings regarding deed restriction stewardship and some things, diversity, equity and inclusion and a couple of other things. That's all I have for my staff report, but I'm happy to answer any questions. Questions from the board?

2:02:59 I just have a couple about the LISC program, the California AB91, or maybe it's SB91, either way. How many tenants have actually, have you helped apply for funding? So Judith is working with approximately three clients a week. The process is pretty laborious. It takes about two hours per client. So I would say

2:03:30 She's probably done about 10. Okay, and there's, go ahead. We also have, we've had a lot of clients call our office saying that they submitted their own application online and they want us to tell them the status of their application, which we can't do, but so we do know there's other people out there filling out the application. Okay, great. And then, how,

2:04:01 How about landlords then? Because I know the landlords have to apply as well. So is MLH assisting with the landlord side then too? Yeah, so what happens is when the tenant applies, they have to submit the contact information of the landlord and then the state case manager will contact the landlord directly if the landlord hasn't already submitted an application as well.

2:04:28 Mammoth Lakes Housing did send out a mailer to about 80 or more landlords in Mammoth Lakes advertising the program and letting them know that we were available to assist them if they needed help. But I haven't heard any response specifically from landlords in Mammoth Lakes. I have been thinking about what kinds of outreach I can do to landlords in Mono County. We haven't done that yet.

2:04:54 But I do know that IMACA is reaching out to landlords in Inyo County. Okay. What about Mammoth Lakes Housing Properties? So we have had some conversations with the property management company and the initial reaction was that they were not open to forgiving the 20% owed and participating in the program.

2:05:32 But I'm not sure of how many clients they have that need, that owe back rent. Okay. Well, I know that CCRH is working with Brian Augusta, and he, we had an alleged call today, and he's looking for challenges. So if you have some to share with him, he's asking everyone to share.

2:06:09 their challenges so he can share that with the legislature and the governor's office, et cetera. Okay, great. Absolutely. Thank you. Are there questions, discussion? That was number nine. We'll move to agenda item 10, committee updates. Oh, let's see. The governance committee is not active at the moment. The diversity committee is not active.

2:06:55 Programs and housing development, would you like to update? Or I don't think we've met since the last, or I'm not sure. I couldn't remember if we had that meeting since our last board meeting, but at the risk of repeating ourselves, we, Jennifer, myself, and Patricia met with town council members, Kirk, staff, and Sarah Ray, and town staff, Dan Holler, and Sandra Moberly.

2:07:26 And had a discussion about, well, the focus was to be on subsidizing middle income workforce housing and just trying to start a discussion about how that could be addressed to provide a sustainable revenue source to support that. And it quickly led into a long, you know, the discussion basically goes into everything again, right? So a little bit of what I already kind of got on my soapbox about as far as

2:07:58 You know, what are ways that we could identify funding? And again, I'm strongly advocating this idea of some percentage of excess TOT on an annual basis gets committed to the housing reserve. And I think the other point about it was, as we were all on, had the presentation from specific companies, communities, last board meeting, you know, they did express their willingness to entertain a

2:08:27 possibly a for sale, middle income product earlier in their development in the parcel, which, you know, I think I had mentioned that, though maybe I mentioned it during the committee meeting, what we had with the town staff and council was, you know, Mammoth Mountain had conducted our annual employee survey and we had a lot of anecdotal comments.

2:08:55 We receive from our year-round employees about their desire to, you know, be able to buy a home in the community and how that is beginning to be discouraging for people that, you know, they fear that they may never be able to do that and question whether they're in here, you know, if they're going to be able to stay in the community or not. So you're hearing that more and more, I think, on, you know, multiple levels from different people in the community and different employees, groups and so forth.

2:09:24 So anyway, it's just, you know, it's part of the overall puzzle and part of the overall demand or need, identifying need. And again, the medium income type programs or the medium income product really can only be funded through local subsidy. We can't, you know, there's not really any state or federal funds out there that are earmarked to anybody about 80% AMI.

2:09:51 And, you know, that's that missing middle, which is a tough one. So, in any event, that was that discussion. We have scheduled another meeting, I think, coming up this week or next, I believe, to follow up on that first one and continue that discussion and conversation. Hopefully, we'll kind of maybe get at least some consensus in that sort of task force, if you will, to look at what can be done, you know, what are some opportunities.

2:10:20 There were also discussions I'll mention, Tony, because you had mentioned, or, you know, we all recognize the effects of Airbnb, and there were some discussions about, you know, from a policy perspective, are there other ways that that can be addressed? Because at the end of the day, everybody who has an Airbnb has to obtain a business license from the town. Always the town have ability to manage that through the issuance or limitation of business license for transit rentals.

2:10:51 So anyway, there's, you know, those are all come with pitfalls and risk and all kinds of other things, right? So none of it's easy. Anything to add to that, Jennifer, I forgot? No, and I think you guys have a meeting coming up this week. Yeah, I think it might be on Friday. Yeah, I'm not going to be able to make it and apologize, but I know you're in good hands and I think the dialogue, I know, I think we covered this at the last meeting too, but it was good.

2:11:29 Yeah, Friday, we have our next meeting, so yeah, look forward to it. Okay, great. And then the marketing committee, would you like to provide an update? I was under the impression you were going to. Oh, sure. The marketing committee has been super busy. I think we received seven responses to the RFP that we released for rebranding and marketing services.

2:12:04 And so we conducted four interviews and have met a lot of times just rehashing the deliverables and making sure that the proposals are going to meet our needs. And so I think we are going to regroup soon and

2:12:33 hopefully bring the board a recommendation to move forward with contract negotiations with the firm, definitely by our due meeting. And then, Tom, do you want to give an update on the chamber committee? Oh, you're on mute. So yeah, the chamber of commerce workforce housing task force met last week, and we were informed that Curtis Shapiro is going to be moving on from the

2:13:19 From the Chamber. However, they did sort of summarize the success of the tenant matching, you know, landlord tenant matching program, which I was actually impressed, you know, it started out kind of slow and I was having my doubts, but based on the update that Curtis provided, you know, they said that, it was impressive, they sent over 4,000 postcards out to second homeowners.

2:13:47 To solicit interest in the program. They started doing employee income and verification as a service to the landlords. And they got more traction as time went on. And I missed, I don't know, Patricia, you were on the call as well. I missed the exact number, but it was over 200 matches that they have created since the inception of doing the work. So that's impressive. I mean, I don't know that it's all necessarily incremental, but certainly had some.

2:14:16 positive impact for sure. And then we all kind of, again, discussion kind of ramped up into the larger discussion about overall challenges, you know, of affordability. Levi Mellie from, who's the area manager for Amerigas joined, you know, as a chamber member, and he was relating his personal experience having to change housing here recently with his family.

2:14:45 To your point, Tony, about how challenging it is for a family. And yeah, it was, you know, somebody with a solid job in our community and, you know, his unity was renting. I don't know if the landlord was going to go back to transient rental or sold it or something. He had to move out and was scrambling, you know, really hard to find another place and was fortunate enough just through his networking, being able to identify any place to move to.

2:15:14 Not cheap. So, so yeah, so it's, it's real, you know, that those issues, you hear every single day, anecdotal stories from everybody about, you know, what a, what a challenge it is right now to find rental housing in our community, much less affordable anything in the marketplace. Yeah, so, you know, I think it kind of got left and that, you know, the chamber, I think, is trying to look for what

2:15:41 where they're going to focus their efforts moving forward and their membership. There were some discussions about maybe some modest fundraising efforts they might make with their membership. But again, I think it all kind of comes back to the bigger issue of really longer term sustainable funding, local funding source for supporting housing in our community. Thank you, Tom. And then

2:16:12 I'll just jump to board nominations committee. I think that committee has been working really efficiently as much as possible and diligently about getting the word out and recruiting new board members. And thanks to them, we now have Heidi Steenster on our board. So I think that board will regroup in the next couple of weeks to talk about

2:16:36 ongoing recruitment in what the committee sees in terms of the need to fill our ninth board seat. And then for town contract negotiations committee, that committee has met once to review our draft proposal to the town and then is meeting again early next week to review

2:17:07 the complete red line version, including the MLH comments and the town comments. And then hopefully, I think we're trying to have a full draft before the full board at the June meeting. I think that's all for committee updates, unless I forgot one. Questions? Otherwise, we'll move to adjourn.

2:17:43 No, board member reports. Board member, oh, sorry, board member reports. Do we have any board member reports? Yeah, I'll throw a little something out there. So on the Altera side, Mammoth Mountain, Skiri side, we are evaluating our acre over there on Arrowhead Drive that backs up to the parcel. And we are seriously evaluating our

2:18:16 Ability to put in 21 units in there next year. Trying to work through the financing side of it and the design aspects. We're considering a modular product, working with a group that is both in Idaho and now is a factory in Colorado as well. And we're actually at the Altera level, we're talking to this particular manufacturer for unit set.

2:18:45 a number of Altera resorts, not just Mammoth. So, so it's, I think it speaks to some of the benefits of being part of a larger organization that gives us access to, you know, have better ability to work with groups like this, that it makes it more, you know, viable for them, as opposed to just being a single California resort, we're part of a larger, larger.

2:19:12 collection of resorts across the country that have needs. So it's a more compelling business case to be made with this particular instance. So in any event, we'll see. I mean, I think my hope is that we would actually actively be making an application to the town and maybe in the next several months to go through planning approvals and, of course, building permits and everything else, but be in a position to be ready to go next spring.

2:19:41 So that's kind of the goal. So that would add 21 units, two and three bedroom apartments with understructure parking likely, or mixed understructure and surface parking. So, and that's, nobody subsidies, no, I mean, that's just them out and building more units because we recognize the need with our employees. Well, you can see how much quicker you can move when you don't have subsidies. Yeah. Lucky.

2:20:14 All right. That's it for me. Anybody else? Any other committee reports? Well, this is just a quick board recap. I think I mentioned at our last board meeting that there's a lot of momentum to add possibly $3 billion to the governors may revise to clear the deck of all.

2:20:49 140 projects that are waiting for tax credits in order to move forward. They've already received their funding from HCD, but they need tax credits. And so it sounds like that's still a go, although the actual end amount is unknown, whether it will be $3 billion or more or less, but it seems to have traction. And since

2:21:18 It seems like the parcel project wasn't funded in the first round of their tax credits, and they have MHSA funding that they would be eligible should they want to and should it be in the May revise. So I'll keep you updated on that at our next meeting. Thank you. Any other committee reports? If not, we'll move to agenda item 12. Does Lindsay want to report? Lindsay?

2:21:52 No. No. She's driving. Agenda item number 12 is adjourned to the regular board meeting scheduled for June 7, 2021. Do we have anything on COVID? No. Okay. All right. Thank you, everyone. Thank you for your... I apologize for interrupting. Are we adjourning to the June meeting or are we adjourning to a special meeting with a date to be announced at a later time?

2:22:25 A special meeting can be called, I think, independently of how we adjourn this meeting. Thank you. Great. Thank you, everybody. Thank you. And welcome again, Heidi. Thanks, everybody. Bye-bye. Bye.