Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2011
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 6 hr 3 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
738 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Can you commission roll call, please?
0:29 Okay. Commissioner Clark. Here. Commissioner Dukin. Here. Commissioner Tenney. Here. Vice Chair Duncan. Here. And Chair Barrett has an excused absence. And Sandy, do you want to have a roll call? Sure. Okay.
0:48 So, Commissioner Baruch. Here. And Chair Hogan. Here. And Eric Wasserman and Linda Salcedo of the program, which the commission could not attend today. Excuse me. So, for the record, you're not convening as a commission, because you don't have a quorum? Do we use Ray? Yes. Ray Scott. Mala. Doug Scott. Public Works Director. All of those things.
1:18 Okay, so we are going to diverge a bit from our normal order and start with our agenda item number five, south districts and townwide neighborhood district planning integration. This part of the meeting is a joint meeting from the building commission, so that way you guys can have this part in the group to stay away.
1:50 Thank you. Commissions, Chairs of the Commissions, this item is potentially a lengthy item, so what I'd like to ask first is how much of a presentation would you like? We have the PowerPoint presentation that presents the South Districts. It's in your package, but it's also prepared to walk through
2:15 And if you'd like a, and we don't have to be excruciating in detail and time, but we can certainly use that to run through the highlights, or we can use the printed material and walk through the highlights and specifically focus on what we think are the actionable items that should be discussed or thoroughly.
2:44 Thank you very much. The purpose of this agenda item is to present the progress of the South District's neighborhood district planning effort and to present to you the integration of all of the now completed or nearly completed district.
3:13 planning studies for the town. As you know, this has been a major work program item since the adoption of the general plan. The general plan included a specific action item that required the conduction of, that's not a word, but I'll use it, conduction of the district planning effort. The general plan was broad in its land use designations, goals, policies, and actions. District planning was meant to establish
3:40 a process, a community-based process, to focus on the particular sub-areas where land use, development standards, and other issues should be more well-developed and defined through that community process. The district planning process has a standard method now. We review the general plan. We review all of our past work.
4:10 And we develop a framework, a scope of work, if you will, and that is presented to the Planning Commission for review and a recommendation to the Town Council. The Town Council reviews and then accepts and directs any changes to that scope of work. And that becomes the district planning effort for each and every particular district planning process. Then we have three standard steps.
4:37 We hold a series of focus group meetings and community workshops to identify and build on the issues, opportunities, and constraints of the site district planning area. We develop alternatives for public review, comment, and discussion. And then finally, based on the comments we receive through those workshops, we present consensus recommendations and actions.
5:02 We have completed that now, that main process for all of the district plans. The public engagement process includes establishing a focus group, which is a smaller group of people who were able to have a more detailed discussion, in-depth discussion. The people that we typically ask to sit on a focus group, which represents a significant commitment of time, by the way, are generally various stakeholders, whether it's a subject.
5:31 Thank you. Thank you.
6:01 Distribution notification. And then after we've completed those and we're starting to form recommendations and consensus, we appear before the Public Art Commission, the Recreation Commission, Mobility Commission, and Planning Commission for input. And then in the final steps, the Planning Commission is to review the district plan study report.
6:26 Make any suggested modifications and recommend acceptance to the Town Council. The Town Council is asked to consider, modify as appropriate and accept. These are studies. They cannot be adopted. No CEQA has been conducted. Neighborhood district planning efforts result of three critical pieces of information. A discussion of the character and program of the district.
6:52 That substantially leads to zoning code standards, and the zoning code is progressing, and those standards are now being incorporated in the Planning Commission's work. We discuss facility infrastructure, essentially capital improvements, and you will begin to see these CIPs come forth in the five-year CIP program that Ray Jarvis is bringing for you before you shortly.
7:20 And then finally we focus on catalyst sites. Those key and important sites that due to their size, their location, their ownership pattern makes them an opportunity to influence in a positive way their surroundings. A good example that I'll just disclose now is the bell-shaped parcel versus the Forest Service compound. The bell-shaped parcel is owned by the town. It's an important asset.
7:50 which is differentiated from a catalyst site. All assets have some real estate value to them. And through this process, the focus group extensively discussed what positive effects would occur to the surrounding properties of the bell-shaped parcel. And the consensus was that essentially the stable residential areas and the golf course links would not be significantly
8:17 improved or have some positive direction by that property. In contrast, the U.S. Forest Service compound that's on the north side of Main Street at the terminus of Old Mammoth Road, if well designed in the appropriate configuration, could stimulate investment and business activity in the surrounding commercial districts. So there is an example of an important asset.
8:40 And it would not have significant positive effects on surrounding areas because we're not seeking them to change versus a catalyst. We have now completed the North Old Mammoth Road study, the North Village study. Snow Creek is completed. And then the downtown area, which includes Main Street. It overlaps North Old Mammoth Road and the Shady Rest areas. The South District's neighborhood district planning area included the already drafted Sierra Star.
9:08 District Study, the already drafted East OSSC Study, which was prepared for the Cardinal Project located at the northeast corner of Old Mammoth Road and Minaret. It also included, or this south district also includes the bell-shaped parcel, and then what we'll focus on today will be the south portion of Old Mammoth Road.
9:35 The Sierra Valley Neighborhood District Planning effort is underway. We've already completed the front-end work of framework and early workshop with the Planning Commission, and Ellen has just completed the first rounds of community workshops, and we have a very good sense of the neighborhood's concerns, so we'll be bringing that forward.
10:00 The final area of a neighborhood district plan for us is the gateway area. We have postponed that in order to allow the major property owners, the county office of education, the school district, the foundation, and the college to understand their particular programs so there can be a more meaningful planning study in that area. And that also will include a little overlap to the hospital and to the town's remaining.
10:30 Civic Center properties. So that will be a future work effort that's directed by the Town Council. So, with that, I'll... Can I just go ahead first, which would be helpful, because I think it belongs in this part. How... The general plan, does that require CEQA at all? CEQA is required when the town...
10:59 takes a particular action to adopt. And because we're only accepting these district studies, we're accepting them, we're receiving and filing them, no CEQA is required. The CEQA will be conducted on the zoning code update. The mobility plan is substantially looking at many of the ideas that will come through this. And you'll start to see the draft mobility plan in June.
11:26 And so when you form a mobility plan and then recommend it to Planning Commission and the Town Council, those actions will require the adoption actions of CEQA. Okay, so the general plan didn't require CEQA. The general plan had CEQA conducted for it. Okay, so it did have CEQA. The general plan did, yes. And that's programmatic.
11:51 It is appropriate. Yes. I'm trying to get this in my mind because I know the forest and the NEPA process, but in general the same thing. Generally NEPA requires a CEQA for its forest land management plan, but that would include the district kind of thing. So this part of it does not require any CEQA until you get to the actual site specifically that you're saying. Correct. Okay.
12:18 It would be, you know, one thing I think would be really helpful in the document, just as a comment, if you don't mind, is some sort of explanation of that for people to understand, only because I did hear from some folks, they thought they just had done deals. And it's really not. I mean, the next reaction.
12:38 Okay. Implementation requires, so that might help. Yes. And that helps me. Thank you. Thank you. If you had an explanation, you'd probably be difficult to sit in there about the right channel. I mean, it's because it's not done at this stage because it might be kind of productive because things can change. Exactly. Exactly. I am going to step to... Okay.
13:00 Thank you.
13:14 I'll encapsulate the entire South District's neighborhood district planning effort.
13:34 By using this as a major discussion point. This, as I've already mentioned, this area included the Sierra Star Master Plan. Sierra Star Master Plan area included a district planning study, and we went all the way through the framework and a series of focus group and community workshops and resulted in a draft study. We built on that. We had no interest in redoing that already done work effort.
14:02 The project that was driving Sierra Star has been withdrawn. So there are no legislative zoning code amendments associated with the Sierra Star neighborhood district planning effort. It's a body of work that's been on our website for some time, and we were able to rely on that and utilize it. The focus group had very early consensus that the Sierra Star area was well formed. We did not have major issues to contend with.
14:32 The program was well known. The development standards in general are suitable. And the only comment that we received is that as that master plan progresses, we ensure that we have the best pedestrian and bicycle connections through that area as can safely be achieved through a golf course. So for all intents and purposes, Sierra Star was accepted. No major changes. And then it was left alone.
15:02 The same situation occurred with the East Open Space and Stream Corridor Study that was initiated with the Cardinal Investment Project. It, too, had a district plan drafted that had gone through that extensive process, and the group felt that with the withdrawal of that application, no other legislative land use matters were on the table, and so they felt that the ideas of preserving the
15:30 We will look, as directed by Council, at setting a more protective, or at least studying a more protective setback area from the center of the stream. We haven't completed that work yet, and we think that we'll roll that into the zoning code in June, figuring out how to set the standard. It's now 50 feet from the center of the stream, so we'll study that more.
15:59 And all in all, again, the group felt that the land use conditions were established, and the only land use that was actually being focused on was that one particular property at the northeast corner of Old Mammoth Road and Minaret. The group also extensively discussed the belt-shaped parcel. We asked specifically, is it a catalyst site? What should we do with it in the long term? What is its best form, function, and contribution to the overall community?
16:29 The area is complicated by a series of designated wetlands. The approximately 16-acre site has at least half of the area constrained by those wetlands. The group felt that out of the alternatives we discussed, leaving it generally as is, no change and no intensification, another option was an intensive athletic or recreation facility.
16:59 Out of a host of alternatives, the group felt it best to leave it as it is in its generally undeveloped natural state, or the town council in some future condition could decide to dispose of it and make it a non-public use. So the focus of the group quickly illuminated Sierra Star, the East OSS Street corridor, and Bellshape as the focus of their study, leaving this area, which is up on the board.
17:29 This is the South Old Mammoth Road District, which includes the Mammoth Creek Park area. In this study, as you can see on the diagram, I'll speak to shapes and colors, if you will, the white circle represents the convenient practical walking area, and the group felt very strongly that it had the potential to be a much more effective walkable commercial district.
17:59 One of the barriers to that now was its current state, its appearance, and also the convenience and, in a sense, safety of the pedestrian route. The sidewalks are very narrow. There's a very poor level of landscaping. They're cracked. They're in disrepair. The grass strip is essentially a mow strip. It's not an effective streetscape design for a commercial district.
18:28 And there's also a lack of continuity. The building walls are not up to the street. The areas of commercial activity are not framing the sidewalks. Overall, it's not a very effective walking district, which is one of the problems to solve and the opportunity to build on. The group also focused on the opportunity to change the surface parking area associated with bonds.
18:57 All the way up to the corner of Meridian and Old Mammoth Road. They felt that there was an opportunity to draw people into this area if, again, there were the clues and safe paths designated to draw people in. And rather than folks just coming to Vaughns and then leaving Vaughns, create an opportunity for the pedestrian to linger. Right now it functions purely as a strip center.
19:24 Where it's a drive-to for single-purpose uses. One of the interesting ideas raised by the group was that in the parking lot area, a little bit to the west of Vaughn's, every season you see the Christmas tree lot arise. And that's also at our peak parking demand. The group felt that that type of an idea of having a community pop-up events, space,
19:52 would be very helpful in trying to achieve the animation of pedestrians and also creating a physical form of attraction, whether it's a farmer's market space, a community market space, an Oktoberfest, more public uses, very similar to what Mayor Harvey has suggested for Main Street occurring here. The yellow diagrams shown on the image represent
20:19 In asterisk forms, the major attractions that we could build on. So the one to the north is the idea of a commercial community center, flexible space. The dashed lines represent where we should, in general, try to channel pedestrians to draw them into the more animated commercial area.
20:42 The second asterisk is the Mammoth Arts Center. That's the former movie theater. And the group felt very strongly that it's an underutilized asset. And the community, the town, should find ways to help that facility become more well-programmed to draw even more people into this district. And then the final asterisk is located on Mammoth Creek Park, which I'll talk about in a moment. The main idea is that the park
21:09 is an incredible opportunity to create a fixed, multi-purpose recreation, flexible recreation space, but more importantly, events locations from a small scale to a large scale. The overall land use program suggested for this area, shown in red, in the commercial districts only, is the idea that yes, this is a commercial district, and to differentiate it from the village, which is our highest intensity visitor-oriented location.
21:39 And to differentiate it from downtown, which is meant to be a more traditional Main Street with higher, with larger footprint commercial uses and residential hotel and offices appropriate, that this area could focus on arts, entertainment, and culture. So acknowledging the existing uses, which include the current theaters, the Mammoth Arts Center, and the connections to the creek, and the idea of a festival event space.
22:08 in the parking lot, that it's building a different theme and a different kind of program to complement the other commercial areas. In the future, as redevelopment and infill development occurs, that street wall should be achieved in the traditional Main Street program. What slide is that? Do you know? And this is the same concept, it's the same physical idea as in the village, the Main Street image.
22:39 So you've seen this before, and the same principles apply, that a commercial retail wall is up to a spacious and well-designed sidewalk, so you're creating the sense of a public room. Both sides frame that public room. That the level of development is one, two, and three floors. We, in this particular workshop room,
23:08 We talked about building height, and the group felt that a three-story configuration, retail is a larger floor height, and two levels above with an upper story step back to preserve views of the Sherwoods along Mammoth, Old Mammoth Road, were very important. Yes? With moving the businesses up closer to the street front, would that also like mainstream?
23:35 Have the idea of moving the parking back behind the business? Two answers to that. The first answer is on Main Street, we focused on bringing buildings to the street edge and disposing of the frontage road. On this particular street, it's more like the Clearwater approach where we're trying to develop a complete street and expand the right-of-way so that there's two lanes of travel.
24:05 A center lane, on street parking, and a safe bike path, and then spacious sidewalks. So we would actually expand the right-of-way in this location and bring the street to the buildings, if you will. The group felt very strongly that this particular street section, which has already been established for the north part of Old 9th Road, should be continued where feasible.
24:31 Everybody acknowledges that this is infill development. It will take time for this to occur. But achieving on-street parking is an important resource and clue to a successful commercial district. It also creates a buffer between the moving traffic and the sidewalk area. And as we found on the Main Street Program, the combination of space for parking and bike path is an important intermediate snow storage.
25:00 Resource. So we push the snow to that area prior to it being trucked. And then that's the configuration also, the strategy for Main Street. Just a follow-up. Yes. Just as a question, have there been calculations as to how many you lose plus how many you lose? I think we would lose a little more than we gain, but we'll go back to that.
25:27 The site would like to help the overall image. Before you go on, while we're on parking, could maybe Grace speak to the fact, if we parallel park, as opposed to maybe the back end diagonal that we've talked about before, how many do we lose? I mean, I'm concerned about parking. Parallel parking as opposed to diagonal.
25:55 I think that's the same question that Sandy was just asking. You are going to lose some. Just intuitively, I'm going to say, probably going to lose one and a half diagonal versus one parallel, if that makes sense. So if you did diagonal part, it might be one and a third to one and a half spaces per one parallel space. Does that make sense?
26:26 So two-thirds, we're losing a third maybe? Yeah, that's a good spot. If you can get nine in a block, you might be able to get 12 otherwise? Something like that. Yeah, that's a good point. One of the challenges in this though is we have a, you know, there's a limited dimension and so the diagonal or head-in parking takes even greater setback and
26:52 The blue dots here, those represent two existing vacant lots, and they're just dirt lots, and one of the comments the group made was that they felt the area, it looked uncared for, untended, and this is perhaps an opportunity for us to simply work with those property owners and pave these as parking lots so that in the summer they're actually available to the public.
27:20 Also on Chateau, where we have a development application, the Rock and Bold Project, we're seeing that we have some extensive, you know, there are large rights of way, and there's no parking permitted on that. So we think that an overall approach, and whatever fits best, parallel or diagonal parking, is dramatically increase the use of our existing service streets to include parking in our commercial districts. And at the same time,
27:50 Focus on these really short-term parking improvements so we're increasing the resource and we're actually building some shared parking facilities, public facilities in the district. So that would require us to talk about that. Yeah, actually my question, really didn't have anything to do with that, but if we're taking the street closer to the buildings, in other words, obviously we're giving up some parking and to me there would be some loss and I wasn't sure that the parallel parking...
28:18 But Mark just partially answered with those two parking, if that could be done, then that would probably offset any loss. Right. I think what that does is it accomplishes a couple of things. The idea of the on-street parallel parking is that that would be a short-term use where people could drop into a shop and whatever, and they're in and out relatively quickly. The locations that are identified by the blue spots are more of a
28:46 You go park and you walk the district. So you have both things working together. Something that we, yes? About the parking, you're talking about a temporary parking lot, you would lease the property, are you going to buy the property? And why are you paving it? What would be the terms of that? How we would do that, so first it's an idea. We'd contact one of the property owners and then we'd
29:14 Set up a meeting and we'd discuss under what conditions would that property owner let us perhaps use grindings that we already have on hand to pave that site to make it, one, obviously useful to the public. We'd ask the property owner to perhaps indemnify the town. We'll have to figure out insurance. But it would have to be a negotiation and a mutual objective.
29:40 One of the reasons to pave it is when you look at a dirt lot in a commercial area, it tells you that it's not improved. It's a dirt lot. It's a vacant lot. And typically, things like paving and perhaps some striping indicate a sense of vitality and that we care. So one, it's a visual clue to say, please park here. And the other is, we care. Oh, and dust.
30:08 Yeah, there's dust. In the winter, both of those are now used in snow stores, so we'd have to talk about that too, and it probably would be that it's not available in the winter. It also tends to indicate to the district that there is a parking supply, and we certainly want to talk about those being used in relationship to our transit program. So park once is how we become feet first. So in essence,
30:38 Yes. I was just going to ask, what kind of right-of-way are you looking at? What have we got and what do you need? Well, that's a good question. We have that concept. We do. It's about a 20-foot increase, and we want to do it symmetrically. So the dimension right now, the little fade line on the shoulder is not wide enough for a bicycle. And so the dimension of a parking space in parallel is about 10 feet, and a safe bike length is at least 5 feet.
31:08 And the balance that we're trying to strike is we're certainly not trying to take people's property, and we want to give those property owners appropriate credit for their density so it's not really a taking. So it would have to be a partnership type of program as development occurs. So long term, there is no guarantee. Part of it, that's my concern. To me, the town has the ability to do complications, so to me.
31:38 That would be my only concern. So in a long-term development proposal, say if the building owners were going to move their property closer or redevelop, then they would be required to provide adequate parking? Yeah, they will. You know, right now,
32:04 The configuration of the entire strip along Old Mammoth Road, it's a little ineffective. There's a travel lane that circuitously links all of the different properties from Vons through, and we think it'll be a more efficient circulation system, and I think that we can improve the short-term parking condition on those existing properties to some degree.
32:33 Right now, in fact, on Mr. Veruck's property, there's a very large amount of space that's dedicated to grass and to an asphalt temporary sidewalk, and the dimensions that we're talking about would fit well within that and not necessarily require a loss of their existing surface parking. You might go to the slide that shows the infill of shopping centers. And I don't know if you can, can you guys see that?
33:06 It is. We're seeing a trend. It is on page 5-19, handwritten, of your PowerPoint package. And it's the bottom right. These are before and after images of large strip center programs. And what you see on the top left,
33:38 is just a big parking lot, and we're seeing smaller infill pads of commercial and residential being built in these spaces, and then the parking is replaced either under structure in a shared configuration. Concurrent with this effort in the zoning code, we have Nelson Nygaard looking at our parking ordinance, and as you recall, out of the Mammoth Crossings, the Snow Creek, and the
34:07 Old Mammoth Place Projects. We're finding that our existing parking requirements are a little excessive, especially in mixed-use projects. So we're going to a place of using parking as a tool to implement fee-first mobility as well. So all in all, we think that we see that the section fits. It'll be probably in better circulation, certainly in more safe than the now condition.
34:35 And I think it will fit nicely with a long-term in-film rehab and redevelopment program for this particular area.
35:05 Temporaries go away. Right. It's a bridge. So we suffered some inconvenience maybe like we had at the village, but we get there someday. Right. But we have. You know, right now, our parking, in a way, this area utilizes a pool of parking. And so we want to have a little more flexibility to help businesses occupy our existing space without being penalized by our parking requirements.
35:35 Okay, so that's kind of the major concept of the overall south area, and if you don't have any questions with that, I'd like to focus on Mammoth Creek. The group felt very strongly that Mammoth Creek is an important anchor to this district, and it's also a connection to the Snail Creek area.
35:57 The biggest concepts were to provide a range of event sites that offer scalable, flexible venues. You all know that the Hayden Cabin exists. It's got a little grassy area. They host small events and weddings there on the scale of 100 or so people. In total, by looking at the different spaces in the creek area, we see at least four different or five different zones that could be used individually or aggregated together to create
36:27 A large particular site. It's a bookend to South Old Mammoth Grove and an entrance to Snow Creek. It's an anchor and a gateway to Mammoth Creek Green Corridor. And we've long thought that we're not really taking advantage of the Mammoth Creek Corridor as a natural asset. And then it becomes in and of itself a focus for local arts, heritage, culture, and natural history.
36:58 This is a little difficult for you to see. It's shown on page 5-20, the bottom side of your facility. The idea is that the west side of the park is relatively large. The existing grass area, the parking lot.
37:28 And then the large area that's left to sage is easily five to six acres. The sage area, it's just sage right now. It's not being used. There have been a host of ideas presented for that western portion of the park. It is not now intended to function as the home of an ice rink. With this workshop, work focus group.
37:54 What I felt was particularly interesting was to make it a flexible recreation space. Perhaps it's got a turf component, but it's also usable for events. And a good example of the idea of flexibility is one day it might be grass, the next day it might have a Ken and Flossie tent on it. And then on the east side of Old Mammoth Road, north of the creek,
38:18 The area is, as well, generally flat. It has tree cover to the south, and so it has some form of windbreak to it, and it also has a sense of scale and closure to it. So by simply removing portions of the existing brush cover, that that eastern side could function as events, whether they're outdoor, protected by a band shell of some sort, or they're hosting a tent facility.
38:47 It starts to add up to become really an events complex, if you will. On the south side of the creek, east of Old Mammoth Road, the group felt that it was certainly an opportunity to consider a flat event space in what is now SAGE, improve the kind of random dirt roads that span the area.
39:13 And to, in the long run, consider building an enclosed facility, enclosed meetings can withstand wind, this area receives a more direct wind than the other side, and provide a cover so it's operable in the winter. This is a just diagrammatic sketch of about a 45,000 square foot indoor facility that could host an indoor riding rink.
39:39 On the bottom right of your image, you see the writing rink associated with the Sherwin's area. That fits inside of this building. And the idea of a flexible events venue is that it can host anything from a Lady Gaga concert to a writing rink, to a ski swap, to a small conference, to a dance, so that it's unprogrammed.
40:05 Sometimes multi-purpose facilities, just by their design, are limited. This is meant to be open and flexible. In its design, some of our architectural friends have suggested that it's an incredible opportunity to orient a building and space that opens up to the Sherwins to the south.
40:26 The group talked about a recently completed facility called The Barn that is located in New Artist Valley in the Truckee area. It's a flexible performance recreation facility, not sports and athletics per se, but by the way, hockey, rink, and tennis could be set up in this kind of facility as well. So anyway, the group felt that it was an important long-term opportunity.
40:56 And so we rolled on from there. What's the maximum number of people building that size for the county? I don't know. I'd have to look that up. In the diagram, we have a lot of different seating configurations so that it's bleacher seating for performance. You know that a basketball stadium will be about 20,000 people, and a basketball court is much smaller than the flat floor space here.
41:24 So in a way you can think of this as a Charlie Brown Auditorium. So it's just open and there. And another idea was not to make it so expensive that it's not attainable. I'm sorry. What would be a parking? What would be the parking requirements for building that size of a number of people of 20,000? It'd be large. We haven't delved into that. We see that we have side area for parking. I think what we have learned through our special events
41:53 is the ability to provide reasonable on-site parking, but also transit, is really important. And we think that in the main, when we look at all of the downtown, or all of Mammoth, transit linking the areas of high intensity, parking ride lots and shuttles are really important. Sam's Wood Sites are a really good example of that.
42:18 And one of the reasons we're focused on this, and you'll see it in our implementation actions as a short-term item, is Sam's Woods is for sale. It's been for sale. And the day that is gone is the day that the same has lost another one of its ad hoc special event facilities. Special events can occur in a lot of different places. And the reason I will point out again why this is an important catalyst site is that those people that...
42:46 Could come to this area, tend to help support the commercial district located to the north in a walking setting. Has the Forest Service approached for you? Ray and I have met with the Forest Service about the idea of special events. I think this would be, the idea of a built permanent structure would be a bare discussion. The Forest District certainly wants to consolidate those lands that are appropriate.
43:16 This should be part of the private or the town's public inventory of land. So it could be that this is a long-term acquisition site. It could be that this is not feasible either. So as a concept to put a stake in the ground as an important talking point, that's a good idea. This would not compete in program.
43:41 with the College Foundation's Performing Arts Center. That's meant to be more of an auditorium with rake seating and a culinary program. That's very different than this. Nor would this compete with, or it's just not the same as a proposed multi-use facility that had been talked about. It's a terrific idea. If it were on an old branch by the town, this
44:11 Presently, on the north side of the creek is where the creek park is east, and it contains 10 acres. It's straight out. There's another five acres that's on the west side, and that's the part you talk about a sage, and about a creek, whatever, and, you know, that, I believe that, the Forest Service is indicated, it might be able to convey to the town. The south part is already in the permit.
44:39 Does that south portion is part of our town permit with them? No, it's not. At least not to my knowledge. It may have been. Yeah, I think it was. So we have a permit for the south side. We do. I thought they laid a permit for the south. Yeah, I mean, we're actually working to amend the permit right now. But you don't have. We have a permit, but we're amending the permit.
45:09 Some potential clearing on that, you know, creek east? East. North of the creek? Above it. To create some, you know, your own bed site. But I thought that that site south of the creek was within a permanent area. The hidden, as far as I know, that's not been included. It didn't talk about. It's its own separate small and it's a very, you know, wet site area. We'll certainly discover that when we go through this process.
45:39 So, with that, I'm going to close on the major detailed items with the South Old Manor Road and move into the related broader issues. Do you have any more questions about what we just covered? I did have a question on the PowerPoint. These photographs that are used throughout aren't identified.
46:06 Can you remind us, except for the Sears and the Mall, is what there? Do you have a page number? I can't see. Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you have a page? Do you
46:30 We'll be asking that. So I'll take a break before we go on to more content. What we want to hear from you in this workshop, what big ideas have we missed? What ideas that are positive should be changed, in your opinion, in order for us to craft a final document? Our final document that we bring to the Planning Commission won't be a PowerPoint.
47:00 There will be more of a report for you to act on. So, you know, we want to make sure we've got the whole big picture and that we're also identifying what we think are the short-term, actionable items. And, okay, so now let me go on. So, now I'm going to put a look at this. The overall, out of all of the town-wide programs, we have resulted in the concept of the community.
47:29 We have a network of streets. We have a flow of traffic that relates to spreading and managing our transit programs. We have a related pedestrian and bicycle facilities program and classification of streets. So this is the traffic distribution flow and classification program. With that, one key concept that was
47:59 And then it's appropriate identifying the
48:27 Particular commercial districts. So saying that there is some differentiation between the corner of the throne in downtown and the village. And having the idea of community events messaging. This is an events and festivity town, but you wouldn't know it. There's nothing across the street that says 4th of July. There's nothing that says more across. And we're not trying to design it, but we're trying to move into momentum projects that have high impact.
48:57 In much more detail associated with the traffic distribution, there has been strong consensus, and this is a summary of this, strong consensus for implementing the vehicular pedestrian mobility plan, having a relationship to what's already been done with the trails, but certainly different design because people are traveling at speed.
49:24 And it needs to take them to your major points, and then all the way down to identifying where those important public parking places are. So again, we've characterized a concept in something that's not too flashy, something appropriate to have said, and complementing what's been done, but now looking like something that goes into a work program initiative to hire a consultant or completing the house.
49:51 And then it leads to implementation through five-year CIP. So we have those particular actionable items. I'd like you, if you would, to turn to your report, which is the overall integration program. I'm not going to read through this. I'm not going to try to capture every detail that has been listed.
50:23 And I want you to turn, if you would, to page 33, printed, or in handwriting 5-58. The title of this, this is a subheading to your report, the title of this is District Planning Integration Strategy and Actions. So we feel that we have, you know, you're not going backwards and redoing the district plans that have been done.
50:52 We feel that we have now established concepts and strategies that integrate all of our completed district plans where our nearly completed ones. And it looks like this image that's posted on the board. We understand the village and its high-intensity visitor-oriented commercial mixed-use district.
51:18 We understand the downtown area. We understand the western section of Main Street, infill lodging. We understand Shady Rest as an affordable residential workforce neighborhood area with appropriate circulation and public parks. We understand the South District, and we understand our key catalyst sites. So to achieve that, the investment strategy is based on a few principal concepts.
51:48 Number one is build momentum. Show to investors, show to the community, and stay the course as a municipality working with our partners to implement a coordinated investment strategy based on this as a consensus plan, more refined than the general plan. Pool and leverage our limited resources targeted to reinvestment. Remain solvent. That's an important concept, especially now.
52:17 And build fiscal revenue stream, which is principally TOT, sales tax and property tax. Adopt responsive standards that encourage rather than impede investment. And that is both in our streamlined permit processing and also the zoning code and our fees, identifying where our fees are an obstruction to achieving that revenue stream insolvency. Support our local businesses and create a business friendly environment.
52:46 Advance short-range pilot projects, because those are really the first steps to implementation and momentum. Commit to completing plans. So if indeed Mammoth Creek is an important catalyst site, the town, with its recreation commission and staff support, should begin that process to really develop this. What you have seen are some blogs with some ideas behind them.
53:13 But to move forward, stay focused on those key catalyst sites. And then re-scope and re-size our capital improvements in public facilities to focus on items that we can actually accomplish in stages and that achieve the best bang for the buck. That, too, is a recommendation from the Capital Facilities Finance Committee. The next big idea is focus on catalyst properties. It is important, I think, to see those areas to target your resources
53:43 On those particular sites that help you leverage change. The impact of the development of a 2,000 square foot site is different than the impact of the development of a 10 acre site. And I think that's enough said. We've identified what we think those key assets are. And this is not meant to influence, by the way, what is going on with any settlement strategy. That is yet to be revealed and resolved. And so this is a here and now moment.
54:13 That will no doubt be affected by whatever happens through that process. I turn the page on 34 and I identify under projects and programs three basic categories, short range and pilot projects, other projects and programs, and then economic development and business investment. I'm not going to read these to you. I'd like you to.
54:39 I know you've had this packet for some time. So we'd like to hear from you. Again, did we miss anything? Does this look appropriate? What should be modified? So with that, let me close before we go on to details. So we think what we have is the essence of the completed district planning, the focus and completion of the South districts, and the essence of this investment strategy. So we're starting to see the coalescence
55:09 Completion of our major strategic planning efforts. Thank you. I think it'd be most useful for us. You know, you form your questions and comments and we're able to take them by subject or in specific.
55:41 I'd like to bring up the point, and this was discussed with the group, and also discussed with the people, and I don't know what declined for these and things, but item number four is called the Civic Center site, or the Civic Center. In my opinion, there are two minutes, and I think it should be something that should be off the table. I don't really feel that we'll ever be able to spend $60 million on this site.
56:10 We should be looking for ultimate sites and possibly something else to do with that property. My personal opinion is that we mentioned that the courthouse there, but it's either point. But why continue on with this? I don't know if the planning case you think, but I know I did just know the same thing. Why are we doing this? Why put this site over use for something else? Something like that. Another issue, remember, about two or three years ago, there was for folks that used the existing building across the street as a municipal building.
56:37 At that time it was $25 million, now it's down to Broadway. Anyway, my only comment is, is the fact that if we're going to be doing this planning or whatever we're doing, why don't we be realistic here? And is that something you really want to half-step continue on? So it's just a thought that we had talked about. I think, you know, maybe what I just heard you say is the use, you know, I'm calling it a civic center. Maybe it's not a civic center.
57:06 Should we consider that site for some other use? Because the town was going to happen. Yeah, I think we have three acres. I think we sold some back to the hospital. Well, that was an option. I believe you have the site for the police department, the site for the county and the town joint. Correct. The hospital is exercising their option. And their option was the sliver of the hog. Correct.
57:35 It's an asset, is what you're saying. It's an asset. It's an asset. One of the original plans that came forward for that site included a big public gathering space, you know, the stepped-up seating, that sort of thing, and that can be accomplished, and Mammoth Creek Park East probably more cheaper and more successful.
58:05 Well, that's, yeah, are we focusing on the site or the need for some facilities? Yeah, there's a question that I brought up, just the fact that it's called Civic Center and, you know, do we really want to continue with this concept that we're going to spend $60 million? So the question is, as a, looking at that site as a catalyst property, is the possibility that it can be a catalyst property so low that it shouldn't be on the list?
58:34 Yes, I think that would be a good way to put it. If you want to spend staff time working at it, you can sell the property of multi-legality, it has to be used that for an asset. You know, we have this suit. Is that an asset? If you include potential sale of it as part of this potential, then it should stay there.
58:57 It was dated, but not necessarily as a development site. It spent money and staff time review it. That was our one thing about it. I don't know exactly who owns which portion of the county and the town. Actually, the county ownership has now been turned into the parking lot. And so the area in between the extension of Tavern Road and to the edge of, if you will, the Superior Court, that's town.
59:26 So it's a three-acre rectangular site. So does the county sell the rest of the state? No. They just let them pave it. Oh, okay. I see. Oh, okay. Let's talk about the parking. That's right. It's not the parking. Yeah. So may I, is there some consensus that, you know, perhaps the civic centers, it shouldn't be named, we shouldn't refer to it as that, and it might be something to be, you know, considered.
59:54 Considered its disposition and its future use, but it's not necessarily a Civic Center site.
1:00:23 That may not be the focus of value for that site here, so I don't know if it belongs there or somewhere else. Your thoughts are you there? Okay, I'm paid print at page 33. 33. And you're focused on categories of properties, so those properties that are listed there, are listed there as sites that potential to stimulate change. Well, ironically, this USF compound, what the concept of the district plan was, was to move the town's civic center across the street.
1:00:51 onto National Forest Land, and have basically have the Forest Service move its affordable housing. I'm just trying to make sure. Yeah, so it would be a catalyst site, but I think it's maybe a longer term catalyst site. That's another one where, you know, you can plan on somebody else's land, but until you have a plan to get to it, like even letters, formal letters. As far as number one, two, and three, in our opinion, we think that one and two are
1:01:17 You know it's ready to develop. You know, those are easy. South of Mammoth Road is probably one of the easiest and more attainable sites in mammals. And figure if that's the easiest, it means it's hardest. You know, and it can be done tomorrow. You know, it is very good. What, Ken John, where are you? I'm talking about the Mammoth Creek compound.
1:01:44 The South of Monroe District, this district that we're actually looking at, is the easiest and was the fact that it was one of the simplest meetings that we've had. Because of the area, because of the ownership, and the amount of area that we had, if we had a few blocks and we had some cooperative owners, we could change it tomorrow, as opposed to Wall Street, which is going to be. Yeah, and I guess what I'm saying is, to me, the most...
1:02:10 If you're really serious about Mammoth Creek Park East and Forest Service compound, getting rid of the housing and replacing it with a civic center that you don't want to mind, you are alone, then I'm saying I think you can start writing some letters and you can start writing from the Forest Service because you know I was going to Forest Service a long time and that was what's changed, started in about 98, 99, talking for me, and when did we complete that? In about 2006 or 2007.
1:02:39 So, you know, you're looking at anything dealing with the Forest Service is going to take a long time, especially the types of things you're looking at. But there's a combo. A combo. Yeah, the combo. This would be more complicated and more costly, in my opinion. Yeah, the Forest Service Fire Station and Compound. I mean, those are the things that, to me, they're future great ideas, but at this time of reality, the planning horizon, the general planning horizon is what? The next 10 to 12, 15 years before we update again? No, we're updating five.
1:03:09 So may I paraphrase what I think you're saying is the Civic Center is not necessarily a catalyst site. It's an asset that we should study. And I think we'll write it differently and put it in a different spot.
1:03:37 Some of them really are probably in your next time horizon or your next one. But the implementation steps, to me, in your short-range and pile of projects, an awful lot of those, and that's when we get into the streets I'd like to talk about a little bit, you need to start with formal letters to the property owners.
1:03:56 And a lot of these, some of the ones involving streets, again, involve federal property, state property, Mammoth Unified School District. But, Sandra, those kind of details, that's the next level of this process. That's the first level. No, I don't think so. Okay, maybe that's where. I'm used to formal process. Let me respond to one comment here. Ray and I have had extensive, extensive dialogue with Caltrans, with the Forest Service.
1:04:24 With the school district and the hospital district. And although you might see an alignment that might move, I think these concepts have traction. Until the town council establishes an ultimate direction through these commissions, we're just doing this. And so we're driving forward with these basic concepts. We're not doing it in a vacuum.
1:04:51 Information from our partner agencies that something is a fatal flaw, we wouldn't have it in here. So, in fact, I just met with the school district about their plans. They've hired an architect to help them with their facilities, and they're showing a roadway network that's similar to what you see in that plan. So, not quite the same, but it's similar. So, from a concept, this is probably a reasonable starting point. And what we then need, next step for us,
1:05:21 Complete this effort. Planning Commission, Town Council completes their effort. Then this turns into a work program. So when the council says, this is all good, then we would start those next steps of implementation, like wayfinding, and like having more formal discussion and dialogue with our agency partners that would be affected. We know that the Forest Service is very concerned about the state of their housing on the compound. And so that is probably something to start working on.
1:05:51 If we're accepted by the council, because it will take a long time. But if this is a concept of whether, I think to John's point, is it realistic or feasible to pursue this conceptually as a civic center, which in turn would stop you from
1:06:16 Taking advantages of other things might come along because you're blindly going after this particular area when another opportunity might serve a purpose even better at that time. So if you're now no longer limiting it to the civic center, that would allow you to have another place where the rest of our civic needs are met there. Conceptually, is that a good idea?
1:06:44 And that's what Mark's asking us now to say, yes, it is a good idea to leave your options open for other areas that are more feasible, more economical, rather than limiting this one area. Right. And again, what we're not doing is we're not trying to edit reports that have already been accepted. So, you know, on the Main Street program, that has been accepted by council. We've just simply placed it into the bigger context so you can see the whole picture.
1:07:14 So, do you have any other changes to page 33 that we should note? Mark, the first bullet point under Bill of Momentum, could you expand a little bit? Expand. Expand on the first bullet point under Bill of Momentum. I don't exactly understand what you're saying here. Uh-huh. On page 5-33? Yes, page 33. Page 33.
1:07:44 Yes. Whatever strategy the town has, it needs to be implemented or else it won't be an effective strategy. What is the phrase in the general plan? Einstein's comment? Oh, a vision without execution is a hallucination. Thank you. So rather than hallucinating and continuing to simply stir the pot and churn over ideas, if this concept is starting to look
1:08:17 As the actionable map to the future, and all concepts, all strategies change over time, but if that is the case, then to achieve it, we'll have to marshal our few and limited resources to the most effective strategy of implementation. So that may mean, rather than spending a capital improvement fund, a roadway improvement program,
1:08:46 On some, you know, abstract sidebar street that is focused on Minaret, Main Street, Old Mammoth Road, and then those streets that relate to the south districts. So that diagram, that little tissue you see there, those black lines represent focused application of capital improvement investment into the street network and into parking. If we're going to do this,
1:09:16 And if you felt that the Forest Service site is something to work on, we should start. If we never start, we'll never get there. So the point of having a coordinated investment strategy is if that's a consensus plan, then put your dollars where they truly count and make a difference and leverage those dollars. Perhaps, you know, one of the concepts that's written in this report is that with Mammoth Creek, it also functions in the interpretive...
1:09:45 It has interpretive facilities and features. It also has public art. And so your ability as a town to leverage your public art monies to the advancement of that kind of a plan helps bring it all together. So when you say a consensus plan, are you talking about the knit-it-together MVPs? Yes. Because the whole point isn't very clear.
1:10:12 I don't know what you're talking about now. In our report, we also mentioned that you know that we're barely treading water. We're getting our work done. To the extent that the body has some improvement, the changes they'd like to make to this district planning effort to help communicate that vision, we would certainly appreciate the Resort Investment Committee being assigned that effort. That's why you're here.
1:10:40 And this message is going to the Council ultimately. So if you have the time and if you see the need for making some edits, we would certainly appreciate that help. We do not have this, do we, Mark? What? That little tissue? We don't have that because I think that's critical. Absolutely critical. Because I think the focus is what we're about.
1:11:07 Really? And that says the same thing John said as I think. John, isn't that what you said? Well, what I'm saying is that, you know, we have limited resources. Let's not be applying resources for planning or for pre-planning to something that we may never attain. Exactly. And that's kind of what I'm saying. Yeah. Well, and I think it's great to have the ideas, but you may need to...
1:11:29 Putting it to like phase one, phase two, whatever, because that's why I asked the question about the general plan. I didn't realize in five years we're going through this again. But we're not starting from zero. It's not Groundhog Day. What you'll see is these modifications. And I think what I'm suggesting is maybe some of these ought to be, well, as you said, the near, moderate, you know, and the far.
1:11:55 Short range, yeah. Short range, yeah. And the longer range. But I do think... Well, good. Let's keep moving. But in going back to this list, the first three items, I think, are super important, something that I think I'm actually working on. And this has to start. I mean, these, I believe, I mean, I think the compound is that it's a great idea. But I think that, number one, my point was, also, besides the Civic Center should be slashed, is that the amount of three-quarters of one should be...
1:12:24 That's probably the easiest purpose-obtainable permits that we can get, whereas the compound is going to be probably a lot longer. Isn't that what this shows, John? Pardon? Isn't that what that shows? I think so. I hadn't seen that until. I saw it. So is the yellow east and west? So the yellow is what, short-term there? No, yellow is symbolically kind of a base. Oh, okay. And the blue is the infill.
1:12:53 Kind of catalyst sites, infill development, mixed use. It's not, this tissue isn't really time sensitive, it doesn't show your insights, it doesn't show anything. Yeah, it doesn't show anything about time. And I think, actually, a lot of people who did that, kind of get the short term, and really, what's realistic in these economic times, because the federal government is also going through some heavy news stuff.
1:13:20 That they may not be as responsive as they have been in the past and able to get money. That changes every day. So, I mean, what is realistic today is gone tomorrow. And if you focus on, and I think that's what we've been churning out for years, is when we have grant money, we have to use it, we're going to lose it. So we use it on a project that is due for failure because you couldn't, they in no way support it.
1:13:47 I think when you're looking at short term, it is what is achievable without these other things that are beyond our control. And I think that's what John was saying there is that city center side is so contingent on things that we can't control that maybe we should go and look at things that we do have a better sense of control or putting, you know, even
1:14:13 Completing them. Because that's, you know, things get left in limbo because of other things. So in that context, I would agree that yes, they're catalyst sites, they have a lot of ability to make other things happen, but if we are in enough, a reasonable majority of control on it, maybe we should go to another area. And that's kind of where I'm coming from to me. I think it really wasn't short to achieve. We need to move on. I think you've got input.
1:14:42 I think you know where we're going from. I do. I think what I would capture is I see some general support for the comments on page 33. We'll re-coif the Civic Center to being an asset. And if you move to page 34, you'll see some more details, like initiating the Mammoth Creek thing. I think what Sandy has mentioned is perhaps we start the process with a letter
1:15:09 To the forest service for both Mammoth Creek and the forest compound. And then Commissioner Verruck has suggested, and I think we all agree, that Mammoth Creek is, it's a permit we have now plus ownership in hand start. And like the municipal wayfinding, yes, that makes sense to me. The south, old Mammoth districts, the sidewalk, that kind of thing it looks like could be, you could move forward on that. You have the right-of-way.
1:15:38 You can apply to the grants, public grants, get those, those are things that we can do. Right. Those are short-term. What Ray will be looking at is he'll be suggesting to you as you see the CIP the possible funding sources like Measure U to, you know, those items that were intended to be supported by Measure U. And the parking lots, the two parking lot agreements, I would say move forward on those. Those are big ones to me. You know, make them long-term.
1:16:07 If I'm not, I'm looking at the projects here which resemble more, the projects and programs which resemble more action limits. I mean, they're easy to see because we've already, you know, covered the what and where, you know, announced the how portion of it, but I think that there's a, what has developed from today I've seen is an overall, that I think you need to stress a little bit more is, this is talking,
1:16:33 Mostly it's talking about the mobility and parking, those are the issues, but it's changing our behavior. And we're trying to take these areas of town and the whole town itself from traveling to a single destination to multiple destinations. And that's why we're looking to, you know, infill works when you have a place
1:17:00 That you can get to, or you can establish it. Because one thing we don't use is that thousand, you know, that thousand-foot radius. We never use it. We're trying to make that actually usable. And the only way you do that is not providing the one parking place that you have to jockey parallel the street in front of the one place you want to go. It's taking you to a place that will allow you to go to many places.
1:17:28 And that's where I think your short-range projects are, that's what they're designed to do, and to test will we truly change our behavior. And they'll test the feasibility of that. And so now our parking is intended to supply this radius of activity. And that's what's never happened around you there. The closest thing you have to it is the outlet mall.
1:17:57 And how far away will you walk from your car at the outlet mall? You'll only walk as far as there's development or something to go. We could get people further with the infill there. So that's what these short-range projects are designed to do, is to change that behavior that we're talking about, which nobody can visualize with the extent you have now. Thank you. I don't want to see the reconfiguring old Mammoth Road.
1:18:27 Up into that, into the short range, if possible. Because that, it seems like. Well, and that's, you know, possibly what this project is looking at. Can we change behavior? It's very hard to visualize. But if you never drove into town and didn't know where it used to be, could you, you know, would you adopt these things for trying? Of course, your choices are, that's where, you don't have any other choice, so you understand. Thank you. I think we're good.
1:18:59 So thank you. What we will do from this is we will make some modifications to this report and create a slightly different report for the South District's neighboring district plan. We'll come to Planning Commission for your final review and recommendation to Council.
1:19:26 Members of the Mobility Commission, would you like us to appear before you for the next meeting? Thank you very much.
1:19:51 So you can get on record that they either have a successful partner or not. And a lot of them are going to subtract the truth, and they're going to add something to today. And those are keys that the council is going to do, because, you know, rights and grace for the school district for anything.
1:20:10 Thank you very much. Are we going to get this, are you going to use, I still like this, because it illustrates. We will put this in this report. I really like that. Thank you for having us. Thank you for having us. We were willing to.
1:20:35 Oh, no.
1:21:08 Thank you.
1:21:24 It actually sounded from the briefings we've had that it's pretty, uh, it sounds like it's, it works out a lot. Stuff. Yeah, that's what, yeah, that's what a briefings was.
1:21:52 So, what I'm gathering out of this, that's the name of the treasure.
1:22:25 I'm going to ask Jay if I can move down here. I have had trouble hearing. I don't know if I've got something in the ear. Maybe this will come. I don't know what those are. Those are all new cameras? All. Karen, can they move those cameras? I don't know what they were for. They were here when I came in this morning.
1:22:49 I don't see why not. This one's taking, it's taking, because it's...
1:23:10 Well, I have to ask Jay. I don't want to move without permission. You want out of the corner? Well, I have to ask Jay.
1:23:39 If you get over here, maybe I'm painting. I really need to learn lip sense or something.
1:23:47 I'm leaving noon. I don't know about y'all, but 9 to 12 is enough. I kind of wish we could put a limit this afternoon, you know, 2 to 5. I like 3 hour meetings to me.
1:24:11 Well, there's a meeting at 4 about events, the rec straps. Sure, but we're not going to. We're not going to get there. We've had a lot of those. Oh, yeah, that's a, that would be an interesting rec straps this week. It's about what to do about events. It's very interesting. And arts and events. Yeah, how are you doing?
1:24:38 What do we have that has to be sent to us in a Manila envelope? I'll feel it just before we have to sit down and try to do something. Where'd you go? New York and Washington. It's Washington, the major city.
1:25:07 Scribble some journalism.
1:25:36 Well, I don't think that the papers really dealt with the vision for Mammoth Creek Park. You know, that's, if that comes about near or far future, that'll be a real cool thing for our time. Yeah. Hello. Hi, Jake.
1:26:07 Okay, well carry on you people. Don't you want to stay? I'll be back. Okay. Deadline day.
1:26:42 Are we ready? Yes, sir. Okay, let's go back to our normal order of procedure. The next item is reports from the commission. Sharon, nothing to report? Yeah, I've got one thing. I noticed in our packet, I don't know, where does this come from, this sales tax update? Who generates this? This is prepared by HDL, which is a...
1:27:13 A company that provides this service to municipalities throughout California. Oh, okay, and they've been retained by the kind of Mammoth Lakes, okay. Well, I was interested to see that sales tax is up 14% because on a vacation last week, I saw USA Today, and their travel section had a half page on sites where you can, like VRBO, Vacation Rentals by Owner, and there's three more sites, and they're actively promoting these.
1:27:42 And here we talk about how we depend on T.O.T. and a sustainable economy and increasing visitation, but if we don't deal with the transient rentals of single-family homes, you know, this kind of thing is, that's where people are at now. And we need to come to grips with that. That's all I had. Thank you. And I have nothing to report. The next section is the first session, or first presentation.
1:28:09 Time for comments from the public. I see no public presence, so we will continue. We have no presentations. That brings us to the consent agenda. We have on our consent agenda four sets of minutes for four of our past meetings in February, March, and April. Does anyone want to pull any of those? I need to pull the 23rd and the 13th. Okay. Elizabeth, any for you?
1:28:37 No, just point of order, I wanted to ask if I was not able to attend the adjourned section of the meeting of the 14th, does that mean that I, the meeting of the 13th, it was just adjourned to the 14th because the man from Nelson Nigra couldn't get here, do I have to excuse myself from the entire minutes? You don't have to, you can, and it won't make any difference if we have a quorum, so.
1:29:02 I didn't know. Okay, anything to pull on this? Okay, Sharon, first, the February 23rd. Page 1-7, second paragraph, well, it's really the third, I guess. Lee Gosh's comment, the third sentence. I do not think that's what she said, because it makes no sense. The sentence about dumpsters? Yes, uh-huh. In the three, during the winter? Yeah, see. I don't remember that. No, I think she said it.
1:29:42 Not that they can be, that they are, that they are pushed into the street. Yeah, she was saying they should not be, and that's what, yeah. So I think that sentence needs to be rephrased. She suggested, I just made some corrections to see if you think that might be what she said, suggested that dumpsters should be located in front yards in the summer, excuse me, in the winter, and
1:30:11 In backyards during the summer. That's not what I recalled she said. I don't recall. I thought she said they should not be in front yards in the summer and they should not be in the summer. No, no, I missed that. They should be in the front yards in the winter where the trucks can get to them and in the backyards in the summer. The trucks cannot get to them in the winter because of the snow.
1:30:42 I'm not sure I recall that's what she said. I don't either, but it's... But the way it's written, she did not say that. No, she didn't say it the way it's written, yes. I thought she was commenting on the issue of the trash problem. Yes. On Joaquin Street, Sierra Valley sites. She was. So I don't know how you want to... I called her and she definitely said she did not say it the way it's written and I don't know what you want to do about it.
1:31:14 I think the context was her issue statement, and so we'll use your words and then check it to the actual tape in our notes. Okay. Okay. I just think it needs clarification. Okay. And then on agenda item three, the minimum minutes of April 13th. Sure. Page. I need to clarify page three and four. Three dash four. Tony.
1:31:48 Okay, we're at the bottom. Commission had consensus. Last paragraph. Discussion among members of the Commission. During the discussion, Chair Barrett, I don't think he was present. So I think during the discussions, Commission Clark and Tenney announced they would not be available on May 4th. I'm lost. Okay. Page 3-4. You're right. Oh. Okay. 3-4. Last paragraph.
1:32:21 We knew he wouldn't be present, but he didn't, he was not part of the discussion. And that's all I had. Okay. I'll entertain a motion. To those, those amendments? For all four. Oh. Okay. With those amendments? Yeah. For all. So moved. All second. Okay. All in favor? Aye. Any opposed? We have none of us in favor. Okay. Next.
1:33:02 Business matters. As you know, we've already finished Agenda Item 5. The next is Agenda Item 6, Non-Conforming Uses, Structures and Parcels. Pam, is the staff contact? Yep. Thanks. Good morning, members of the Commission and Vice Chair Dyken. I know you have a very busy Planning Commission agenda today, so I will keep my report very brief. You discussed this Non-Conforming Uses, Structures and Parcels chapter.
1:33:31 Once before on December 8th, 2010 and at that time had a lot of questions, asked staff to go back and do additional research, provide some more background information and so we have done that in this report. We provided clear description and examples of different types of non-conforming uses and structures. We also provided additional definitions, did some additional research into some legal and planning documents.
1:33:58 And also had our attorney review the draft chapter that's included in your packet. He concluded that the proposed changes in the draft chapter were appropriate and that they worked to help achieve the town's goals. At your last discussion of this subject, you seem to favor a generally more restrictive non-conforming chapter. And so that's what we've tried to focus on in making our changes today. Specifically, we focused on two competing principles.
1:34:28 One is bringing non-conforming structures into compliance with our current zoning regulations versus allowing property owners reasonable use and enjoyment of their property that was legally constructed or operated under previous codes. I'm not going to go into any details of the background information that was provided in your report, but I did want to focus on five of the major changes that we proposed to this draft chapter since our last meeting.
1:34:54 And these are highlighted on page 6-14 of your report under Planning Commission discussion items. So I just wanted to go through those quickly and kind of summarize the changes that we're proposing. The first one relates to additions to non-conforming structures. And our current code limits additions to 100% of assessed valuation of the structure.
1:35:18 This can sometimes be a problem on older buildings when the assessed valuation is very low. It limits their ability to make any improvements to their structures. At our last meeting, we had discussed limiting additions to a percentage of the building permit valuation, but upon further research and reviewing our comparison cities again, we've changed that recommendation and we're now proposing
1:35:42 additions to be limited to 25% of the existing building floor area, excluding garages, and also requiring an administrative permit for any of those additions. This would allow staff and the director to make sure that any proposed additions to non-conforming structures wouldn't have a detrimental effect on the neighborhood, would be consistent with the character of the building and the other buildings in the neighborhood, and any other considerations to make sure that
1:36:09 There's no negative impacts by allowing those additions. The next item relates to remodels, interior remodels on non-conforming structures, and these are not currently addressed in our code. We do propose that these remodels would be allowed without limitation, and the reason for this is that with our current building permit review process, planning department does not review any permits that don't propose changes to the building footprint.
1:36:39 So we would have to revise our whole building permit review process if we wanted to try to regulate interior remodel somehow. The third item refers to damaged and destroyed buildings. And currently our code allows a building, a non-conforming building, to be rebuilt if it's damaged to the extent of 50% or less. But it doesn't specify if this is the building footprint, value, square footage. So all we're proposing to change is just
1:37:08 Clarifying that it would be 50% of the replacement value of the structure. This is consistent with a few of our comparison cities. The fourth item refers to non-conforming uses, and as we discussed at our last meeting and in the report, there are very few non-conforming uses within the town. We deal much more frequently with non-conforming structures. Our current code allows only six months of non-use prior to a non-conforming use losing its non-conforming status.
1:37:36 And based on our comparison cities, staff is recommending that we change this to be one year of non-use before the non-conforming status is lost. And the final item relates to non-conforming structures crossing a property line. This is a very severe form of a non-conforming structure. They do occur throughout town in some places. And so we discussed whether or not it would be appropriate to have more restrictive requirements for these buildings. So what the draft shacker proposes is that
1:38:07 Interior remodels would be permitted for the reasons that I just discussed. However, no additions would be allowed to these buildings, so you wouldn't be able to increase the square footage or the building footprint at all on these buildings without bringing them into full conformance with our code. So that summarizes the proposed changes, and I'm happy to answer any questions that you have about these or any other changes or items in the staff report. Okay, first, any questions? Okay, I have a...
1:38:38 A lot of trouble with this chapter, and I have a number of questions. I'm sorry. Go ahead with somebody else for a second. Excuse me. Other questions? I have a question, Jerry. The number three, where you just were, when they rebuild the damaged structure, will it be built to code?
1:39:04 The way the code is written is that if the damage is less than 50% of the replacement value, they would be able to rebuild the structure as it existed before. If the damage is more than 50%, then the structure would be required to rebuild to the current code. So even if they rebuild, if it's less than 50%, they can rebuild it out of 50%.
1:39:24 And this would be only for involuntary damage to the building, like if a tree fell on it or if a fire started. If the owner chose to damage or destroy their building intentionally, then they would have to rebuild it to the existing code. Right, and I think that's a pretty standard state requirement. Okay, thank you for clarification. And it will be subject to building code requirements. Right. That was my only question.
1:39:54 Thank you. I have a number of questions and then I'll get to my areas of concern later. On handwritten 620 at the top of the page, it talks about repairs, too, it's highlighted in yellow. And it said, provided that they comply with all building and zoning code requirements in place at that time, which time are you referring to? The time that they make the repairs or the time that the structure crossing the property line was built?
1:40:24 At the time that they make the repairs. And would the same thing apply on page 619 in the first paragraph? The time they make the repairs? I'm sorry, I'm not sure where you're looking on that one. Handwritten 619, structures crossing a property line number one, last line. Right, so if they wanted to relocate that structure, it would have to comply with all of the setbacks, lot coverage, other requirements in place at that time. Okay, because I think the clarity at that time should be clarified.
1:40:55 Okay. Do you have a suggestion on this one? Yeah, at the time the repairs are made or at the time it's moved or whatever, because when I read it initially, I was thinking when the non-conforming structure was originally built. That would be at the time of relocation for C1 and at the time of repair or maintenance on C3. Okay. And then on handwritten 6-10, you said that there's no inspection of improvements to the interior of the building.
1:41:30 What about kitchens and baths and wiring and things that have to be up to code? I didn't say that there's no inspections. I said that the planning department does not review those permits. The building division would still review those and inspect them. Okay, that definitely makes sense. When I first read it, I wasn't sure. And I just want to add to what Pam stated in the report. The reason we don't feel that we would address those issues in the non-conforming use is because of the
1:42:04 The scale and the magnitude. Not because we don't review them, because we could review them. It's because we didn't feel they were important to be reviewed from the planning side. I understand completely. 6-6, the way renovation is defined, cleaning, repairing, which I would have thought would be under repair, and then or rebuilding. How is that different from remodeling?
1:42:32 I mean, I think they're really similar. These definitions all came from the building code, or if they're not defined in the building code, the building code references the Webster's Third New International Dictionary. So these are just standard building definitions. That's fine. 6-4, you were listing varying types of nonconformance. Is that from the building code?
1:42:55 That just generated in-house. These are just generated in-house. They are examples that we've maybe dealt with in the past or had questions about in the past. Because I was surprised that nothing was mentioned about structures built in dedicated rights of way. That would be another example. Okay. But that isn't relevant to the thing. Okay, I'll save my comments for discussion. Questions? I have no questions. So let's see. For organizing discussion,
1:43:25 Do we want to kind of find the page? 6-14. 6-14. Do we want to go through those five Pam covered first and then if anybody has any concerns other than those covered over? Okay. Discussion of the first one, allowing additions to be made to existing non-conforming structures. Thoughts? Do you want to go online or how do you want to do it? Okay. Keep talking. Keep talking.
1:43:58 I'm really frustrated with this section of the zoning code because what we're trying to do just as with signs that aren't in compliance with the code that we have to amortize over a period of time, we're trying to eliminate ones that don't contribute to, you know, quality of life and contribute to property disputes and all kinds of problems and the fact that we are making
1:44:22 Concessions saying, yes, you can remodel, yes, you can add on to, yes, you can do this, yes, you can do that to non-conforming structures. When we're trying to eliminate non-conforming structures, I have a big problem with that philosophically. It just doesn't make sense to me. Maybe somebody can persuade me otherwise. But if we're trying to eliminate non-conforming structures because they're non-conforming, why are we going to these lengths to permit all kinds of modifications and modernizations?
1:44:50 Because trying to eliminate non-conforming structures is not the sole purpose of the codes. Because we're trying to do that at the same time, we're trying to be fair to people for whom that may be a hardship and to allow for situations where there are other considerations of, you know, somebody's got the damage that they need to fix. And if you take as your sole goal of eliminating a non-conforming use, you end up causing a lot of hardship in a lot of cases.
1:45:17 So our ultimate goal over time is to eliminate all nonconforming uses. But if you try to do it immediately, there's going to be some unfairness involved. That's the way I see it. Okay. And that was the discussion in the users group, right? Yeah. Good. Okay. Well, let me ask you another question. Was it discussed in the zoning code users group to go back to see what the original building permit was for the structure? Because many...
1:45:41 A number of nonconforming structures probably were built without permits. If we, let's see, what section is this, Sandra? Is that 040? Oh, in that chapter? This is, this is B, there are changes to a nonconforming structure. Yeah, 040, on page 6-18, it starts. But what we're not doing is, we're not, through this is our Dakota.
1:46:10 We're not trying to retroactively discover every building that was built without a permit. We're setting the future standard for dealing with non-conforming uses and structures. You don't think that someone should be required to find the original building permit? Absolutely not. I don't think so. I would like to hear the discussion. Why do you think that? I don't think that that's the issue. I think Jay stated it perfectly, is that this is not to weed out non-conforming.
1:46:42 Buildings is trying to keep them in the best shape possible whenever they have to do some work to these buildings there and it's considering a hardship there and it's moving forward. It's to make sure that we don't have any additional non-conforming structures there. I don't think that that's the issue at all. I think it's allowing these people to make
1:47:09 To make improvements on their property when they can, that are within, that don't require them to tear it down. Because things change at that time. And what we're allowing is, if it's done, does not increase the non-conforming use. Because the addition is conforming. Yes. We're not making the matter. Oh, that's interesting. You're defining an addition to a non-conforming use as it just all happens to be attached.
1:47:40 To a conforming use, because the addition will conform to the zoning code, therefore it is acceptable. It just happens to be attached to a non-conforming use. That doesn't mean the non-conforming portion is acceptable. It means that we're going to allow the addition with the hope that eventually somebody will want to do enough alterations or one of these other sections that they will eventually bring it all into conforming use.
1:48:11 I'm not sure I'm making myself clear. Yeah. All I can think is when we purchased our property in Old Mammoth in 92, there was a structure that straddled the property line. Before escrow could close, that structure had to be removed. And, you know, we have so little... I appreciate what you're saying about hardship, and I can understand repair and maintenance and a tree falling on a property. It totally makes sense. But we have so little leverage to make things...
1:48:39 In compliance with, you know, what we're trying to accomplish here, whether it's through the general plan or the zoning code or whatever, that I'm having trouble with adding on to non-conforming uses. Can I make a quick clarification? Just to clarify, when we are talking about allowing additions to non-conforming structures, we are not talking about allowing additions to structures crossing a property line. That's specifically prohibited.
1:49:05 These additions would be allowed on nonconforming structures that encroach into a setback or maybe have some other nonconformity but do not cross a property line. But in fact, they cannot continue to encroach in a setback. Exactly. Any addition made would need to meet all of the code requirements. So they're already in the setback but it allows them to put addition on the other side which is not affecting the setback. But if you're not,
1:49:34 They say you can't do anything because you're in noncompliance and I think that's what you wanted to get around is because a lot of properties won't touch anything because that will set off this chain reaction that brings them out of, you know, gets them in bigger trouble and that's what you want to avoid. I want you to continue to keep up your property and improve it because the setback changed now.
1:49:58 May or may not be your fault, but we want to make sure that this property doesn't continue to do practices that are putting them out of compliance, but improvements will make portion of the property in compliance. So what you're saying, Rhonda, is this to improve property? I think it'll give it a chance to, it'll give a lot of a chance to improve property. There are buildings that can't, and this is an example, there are buildings that won't touch their structures.
1:50:27 Okay. What about Kat?
1:50:57 The category of rural residential, which is two to an acre, were there more structures than that on a parcel that's larger than an acre, or that's an acre? That would be a non-conforming use. But is that spelled out in the draft code? Because I didn't see anything about it. Of course, there are lots of different...
1:51:22 Situations I know and you can't necessarily list them all. Yeah, section 040A2 talks about the inability to expand a non-conforming uses. You see the difference from the use as compared to the structure is non-conforming. You can't make changes. Right. Okay. Yeah, use versus structure. Do you appreciate, can you appreciate, I appreciate what you're saying, but can you appreciate my problem with
1:52:00 How few chances we get to have some leverage to make change? Well, I see it as a value judgment. It's balancing the value of allowing certain changes, if you will, versus the detriment of how long you allow non-conformities to go on. And I think the way it's written, it reflects what Rhonda just said, that there is...
1:52:28 Value to having, in certain situations, a structure that improvements can be made to a certain extent, that the judgment is made that that overall improves the neighborhood, if you will, even though there's a non-conforming aspect to that structure or that property. Okay, I understand what you're saying. There's a lot of commercial examples that, I mean, just getting into that there, because things change when they change hands. That is different, too.
1:52:58 But if the property isn't changing hands and going in and saying you're not conforming here, that's very difficult to do because at the time they purchased it, it may have been conforming. And now that we've changed our rules and regulations, it should be from things going forward. And I think that's what we're looking at. But it does give you the flexibility to make improvements in these non-conforming properties.
1:53:26 Before could be interpreted you can't. If you touch anything, you're going to have to, you know, you might as well tear it down and start over. And that's, I think, you want to discourage that. Another way to look at this, it's not that conforming is all good and non-conforming is all bad. Most of these non-conforming aspects were fine at some time or another. They all were.
1:53:49 They were all legally, legally built. Legally at the time. Codes changed. To make the value judgment the way you're making it, we have this thing that's bad, so therefore we have to get rid of it. But it's not. No, I understand your point of view. I live in a sea of non-conforming uses, so I'm intimately acquainted with them. But I'm hearing what Rhonda's saying and what you're saying, and that definitely makes sense. Well, do we need to discuss it for the convention, or are we just going to agree that we're going to disagree?
1:54:21 I mean, I don't hear it coming to consensus. Your arguments are valid. I appreciate what you're saying as opposed to saying, no, you're wrong. I'm not saying that. I'm saying, no, your arguments make sense. Or do our arguments make sense enough that we have consensus on that? Item number one, additions to be made to existing non-conforming structures is acceptable for what it's been revised. Put my money where my mouth is.
1:54:53 Okay, I have a big no written next to it, but I guess you're persuaded me otherwise. I have a big yes written next to it. Well, I'm going to, I'm going to be 3-3-1. We have a desire from a member of the public to make a comment. Thank you. John, you have to come to the mic so we have to see your people online. See and hear you. Thank you very much. John Rook, and as you know, I am one company's property. So,
1:55:19 I'm really concerned if you go too far with this, you're going to print some online copyrights. Exactly. Oh, no, John, I'm thinking about that. I am. There are a number of examples, and I'm giving you a couple. There was a condominium project that were built before 1979 that had different setbacks. They were 10 feet. Okay, so now they're 20 feet. So if that condominium project wants to put the sawed on, if you're not careful,
1:55:46 It will be a slum because you won't be able to do that. Exactly. That was legal in 1979 and 1976. I have an apartment house, I got 16 apartments on half an acre. Now if you're going to say I can't re-roof it, I can't, you know, there's nothing wrong with it, by the way, the parking is great and 16 units have to work in this particular place. So, you know, it was built, we had a permit, it was all legal. So I think you need to be, and as far as a setback is concerned, what you had, there is a legal presence already in place.
1:56:17 The property's in escrow, it's illegal, it has to be removed. So there are already... Chances to remedy. Remedy's in place, thank you very much. Well, that's why I asked the question, it wasn't to be punitive, but can we trace back to the building permit to see if it was, you know, what the conditions were at that time, but that is... You might be able to... I don't have support for that. And we do look for building permits. If it's going to be an addition, we ask the property owner to buy that. Thank you.
1:56:45 Or we try to do the research. So we do as much as we can to try to determine that it was a legal construction. That's the key, whether it was legally constructed or, you know, some buildings that were built, you know, in the 40s, and there's just nothing, there's no records. So we have to kind of make an assumption of what the requirements were at the time and say, okay, it's probably legally constructed. Do we have good records for the 70s and 60s, I wonder, from the counting? Yeah, it's kind of hit or miss. We, you know.
1:57:14 Because I really am thinking of illegal structures that were built without permits. If I could interject, when the county had it, which is when Sierra Center and Marley built for instance, that was county approved. Right. That's 123 parking places under park. That's county. Is it that many? Yeah. So that's county. There was four restaurants that were planned for that. There was four or five thousand square of restaurants. So it's under park. But that's county. I don't know if you'd have rent for the county.
1:57:43 And that was a whole different set of rewards for the town to call. And we're definitely talking about non-conforming versus the illegal. Correct. And that's the big difference there. There's two very different reasons. But if you don't research the building permit, if you can't find it, how do you know? See, that's the issue. So we do do that for additions. Yeah, they do. But what we're saying is we can't do that for just interior remodels.
1:58:09 Oh, no, I understand that. I understand that. But, yeah, so in addition, if somebody wants to come in with an addition, we would ask the property owner to provide us with that information, and if they don't have it, then we'd do some research for it. Oh, but I thought I heard that that wasn't, we shouldn't ask for that. No. No, we're talking about interior remodels, like just little- Is that what you're saying? Yeah, it's-
1:58:26 Yeah. Okay. She's, that's where we were. Okay. I thought you were saying going after the initial billing permit was a bad idea and I really wondered why. No. It was in the context of everything they were looking at is that they do look at these things but you can't stop the process if it doesn't exist. Right. Because there's a lot of it that doesn't exist even in the 80s that they're not even around in things.
1:58:49 Okay, well that gives me a measure of comfort knowing that, no really, because there's so many illegal structures that were built without permits and illegal structures are under my saddle. They are not covered by this. They are not covered, it's not legally conformed. Okay, thank you. Are you comfortable with consensus on number one? Yes, I am.
1:59:12 Thank you. Number two, which is to allow interior remodels and routine maintenance and repairs to non-conforming structures without limitation. Thoughts about the way that was revised? Chair? Fine. You okay with it? Fine with it. Nobody has trouble with without limitation? It's all inside. It's interior. It's all inside. Not changing the building footprint. Or to the sides or anything else. It's all interior.
1:59:43 Okay. Is okay equal consensus? Yeah. Thank you. I feel like you're all sitting on me and I've got a cold. Just wait till we get to number four. Wait till we get to number four. Okay. Number three is allow damaged structures to be rebuilt provided that the damage is less than 50% of the replacement value of the structure. Sharon? Consensus? Rhonda? That's fine. I agree. So if I said 25%, that would make me up. That would make me up.
2:00:14 Then we wouldn't have consensus. Right. But you're free to do that. But that's okay. We're not pressuring you. Can you just talk to me about that one a little bit? Sure. Because since you run the zoning code users group? Yeah. Yes. Oh, should I talk about it? Yes. Would you help her? Would you please? Yes. Would you expand on that? Why 50% is better than 25? I've got to stop and think a minute. Pam, you'd made a comment about that. Yeah, I'm just trying to find it in the report.
2:00:46 I believe that it's a pretty standard threshold in reviewing all of our comparison codes. And I think kind of statewide, that's 50% is kind of the threshold. You know, either the building is damaged beyond repair or it's damaged to the extent that you would be able to rebuild it. And I think that was the same threshold you agreed on for science, right? Damage to science. Which there was precedent for the other areas of the building.
2:01:14 That was fairly common. And Pam, you had some comments in your staff report about it was hard to determine value. When you say replacement value, I still keep thinking of context of Old Mammoth and Sierra Valley sites other than other structures. Sorry. I was going to say, how do you determine replacement value? For instance, if it's a non-conforming structure that has not been maintained on the outside,
2:01:44 But it's been extensively remodeled on the inside, and I could tell you two or three examples of that, you know, that I know of personally. How do you determine the replacement value? Do you just base it on, you know, this is a 10 by 12 storage shed? The idea of choosing the replacement value is that, on the assumption that most people would have insurance policies that would identify a replacement value for those buildings, and that would be what we do. Okay, so that's where you're taking it from. Okay.
2:02:11 Is that in the draft code? Because I remember that, but I don't see it. Yeah, it is in the draft code. It must be in the draft code. You mean the insurance part? It's not that specific. It just says replacement value. It just says replacement value. It's 6-20. Okay, well, I read that you used the insurance. I don't know where I read it. Maybe in the... It was just in the discussion. Okay. So... Discussion? You don't have anything more to say about that with the users group? Really? It's just a judgment of what's...
2:02:47 Okay. What's a reasonable amount to allow? Okay. That's fine. Okay. I think that's fine equals consensus again. And the fifth one. Of course. Aha. Number five is structures crossing property lines for them to allow routine maintenance and repairs as well as interior remodels but do not allow. No, no. You skipped number four. Oh, I'm sorry. Please don't skip number four. I thought that was intentional. I'm sorry. I'm intentional too because he knows it's going to be a two-two. Sorry.
2:03:17 Number four, non-conforming users will lose their non-conforming status after one year of nine years. Sharon? Well, I just wondered, since we were, Elizabeth and I were six months and y'all were 12 months, could we look at something like they get a warning citation from community development at six months? So what's the process right now that is for non-conforming uses?
2:03:47 So what do we go through and can give us an example of what you'd consider non-conforming use? I can try. I think there was one in there. Yeah, I think so and these are kind of hypothetical examples but like one of the examples we listed as an illegal non-conforming use would be a commercial use located in a residential zone. Exactly. So
2:04:14 So the idea, and there's not really a set process that we have, but the idea is, let's say it's a little mini-mart in the Sierra Valley site, and then it closes down, and we all know that it's not operating. So after a year goes by, or six months goes by, whatever we determine is the right time period, the code says that staff shall not need to do any follow-up, and that non-conforming status would be lost.
2:04:43 Exactly. So, you know, another way, especially if it's a commercial use, would be if they don't have an active business license would be another way that we would know that they're not operating. So it's a garage business that had always been there and now that's not conforming to whatever's there. That person moves away or that person, the renter moves away, the next person coming in,
2:05:13 And a year later can't do the same. Right. Are you in favor of that? I'm not saying anything yet. I just want to listen to the discussion. Rob, I wanted to hear what you had to say about, or hear your discussion, about commercial uses, how that would be a problem. You just mentioned the garage business, but how would that be a problem? Well, if it's nonconforming, it was a nonconforming use there that had been there previous to change of.
2:05:41 Anything there, then it changes, it's abandoned, it's no longer there, you can't let the next person come in to do that, so. If it's been abandoned for more than whatever. For more than a year, exactly. Except in the draft code, it talks about page 620, excuse me, 621, number three at the top, you may have granted a permit if there are extenuating circumstances. Reasons, yeah.
2:06:11 Excuse me? Yeah, yeah, extenuating circumstances, reasons that it would make it feasible to do. But that almost gives it a two-year period, and I have trouble with that, too. So we want to make sure that one doesn't contradict the other. That's what it sounds like. Well, I don't think it contradicts it. I think it just sort of automatically extends it. Yeah, and nearly automatically. Well, that depends on what's meant by significant or unusual nature. Do we have any examples of that to show what
2:06:41 I mean, a good example would just be the economic times that we're in right now. Maybe there's a business that for some reason can't operate, can't get enough business to stay in operation for a year, but they have every intention of continuing operations as soon as they're able to start, you know, selling their wares again. And also, just to clarify on that code section we were talking about, it does require an administrative permit to get that extra one-year time extension, so they would have to file for that permit and the director would need to make findings.
2:07:11 As to why he might grant that extension. Well, to me, that just sounds like very poor business procedure. I think that gives it two years. And economic times happen time and again. And I just think a business person would be better equipped to handle it than to just – I mean, Cuppies is a good example. It's sitting – how long is it going to sit there? I just think a year is –
2:07:43 I wanted to stop it at nine months, so I guess I'm just very particular about that. While we're on there, number two on page 620, go back. We have a typo there. The director shall determine. Please. No, thank you. That's minor. But anyway, that's, I just, if it's not, you know, if it's not being used, I think it ought to be.
2:08:11 I hear you saying business reality is different for you than it is for me. I mean, to me, a year is a pretty short time. Well, we don't know how long. I mean, this all started in 08. Could it go on ad infinitum? No, it can go on for a year. No, it can go on for two years if we're in low economic. That's a special circumstance. We've seen a lot of special economic circumstances. The reason I wouldn't be in favor of just six months is business goes out in November.
2:08:43 Doesn't snow doesn't clear until May in those areas. That's six months right there. So we have some, some type of, you know, environmental constraints that would not, that make it possible that you couldn't do anything about it in a year or that we've decided to close for the, or, you know, we close for the winter and it's, we will open in the summer. What if the owner dies at that point? It's a non-conforming business.
2:09:12 Now it's been, you know, a year for somebody to get it back going, but then afterwards it's not. It's, I think that, I don't think it's unreasonable for a year. And like you said, that doesn't mean everybody's not going to come with, I have special circumstances, like, no you don't. We do have the ability to say no at that point. And there's other stops, because now we're talking about the code. And that's a different, you know, a much more...
2:09:39 It's not the one and only place that these things are going to go through review. So I don't have a big problem about a year, but I will go with, you know, whatever's consensus with everything else because I do know people have shut down certain things for the winter and then weren't able to come back to do it. Well, I can appreciate environmental. I hadn't thought of that, Rhonda, so. And things that I haven't seen.
2:10:04 In certain areas of town since November, unfortunately. You know, and that's why I look at it because I look at things in two stages of, you know, when it's feasible to get to and when it's just absolutely not. And non-conforming uses aren't just commercial. It could be like a single-family home in a commercial zone. Exactly. Or it wouldn't be permitted. So if that was vacant for more than six months, then it, you know, that use would lose its status as conforming, so.
2:10:33 So those other examples, it's not just a commercial business, it could be a single family home, it could be a duplex in a zone where it's not permitted, something like that, anymore. Anymore, right. It was legally constructed at the time. Right, another example of what might be considered special circumstances, this is something we dealt with somewhat recently and it was for a conforming use, not a non-conforming use, so this issue didn't come up, but it was a business that creates
2:11:01 Concrete and asphalt, and due to the slow construction, they haven't had anyone buying their concrete and asphalt, so due to no fault of their own, you know, their plant's ready to produce this stuff, and as soon as they have buyers, they're ready to start going again, but they had to close down for a while because they just couldn't sell anything. Would they actually close down? They had closed down, yeah. They ceased to sell rock and gravel.
2:11:32 They continued to pay their utilities to maintain the site. And the owner is probably going to go there regularly. So I don't consider that, you know, boarded up. That's my concern are the boarded up places. You know, this does not necessarily address the boarded up places. So this restricts the uses of a building.
2:12:01 of a business in a structure that had been operating. So there are other uses that can occur in a building. And the act of having, if your issue is how long can a building be boarded up and what its treatment is, that's a different discussion. That lives in the nuisance code. So, for example, on Cuppies, it's a building in a commercial zone.
2:12:29 And until they find a tenant, it's a vacant building. And so maybe one attribute that could apply in that condition is would you continue allowing a drive-in use? So that's a specific use within that particular site. But they remain vacant because there aren't commercial tenants. And so this section of the code would not really address the vacancy of a building. A single-family home residence in a commercial zone
2:12:58 The effect would be, in this case, if it was a non-conforming residential use, it could not be used as a single family home anymore in that commercial zone. So then they would be forced to seek another tenant. So you're looking for a cafe, you're looking for, if it's permitted, a realtor's office or a professional office appropriate to that zone. So this does not directly relate to boarded up buildings. Another way to say that, we're talking about a use that was legal.
2:13:32 At some time. And now isn't for one reason or another. But that, to me, mitigates towards a longer period of time than the boarded up building example, which is different. Well, I don't know if we're going to reach agreement or not. I have a feeling not. If we don't agree, what's the consequence, Mark? If you don't agree, we're going to leave it at one year. And then when you go through the public hearing, you'll have to re-debate this issue.
2:14:03 And by a vote, since you're not finding consensus, it'll be, you know, whatever it is, 5-0 to 3-2 in one direction or another. Yeah. I think you should discuss the director issue to see if, which is item number three on page six, to see if you feel comfortable with that, because that's a slightly different concept.
2:14:25 It is... Which page? Page 621. Number 3. Number 3, the one that... This is pretty straightforward. You would either allow it or you wouldn't. And if you allow it, it's either a director's determination or it's a Planning Commission determination. I'd be more comfortable if you brought it to the Planning Commission. So should we change that to a use permit? No, we shouldn't.
2:14:52 You need to discuss it, and if there's consensus, we'll change it. If not, it will be the same thing as the year. Well, I'm certainly glad you mentioned more non-conforming uses, because there are many more types than had occurred to me. As I said, you know, where I live, there's a lot of illegal structures, and it causes so many problems, property owners in the whole neighborhood. But there's a much broader scope of non-conforming uses than I was aware of, so.
2:15:22 I don't feel quite as uncomfortable with my consensus as I did. Okay, but back to the director. Item number three on page 621. Sharon talking about wanting to change it to Planning Commission. That's the opposite of what we have been generally doing in code sections as we revise them is giving a lot of these things that used to be Planning Commission.
2:15:51 To the director where we think it's appropriate, giving the director that discretion because that makes the code more friendly, which is one of our goals. I'm trying to think, in this example, Mark, is there any kind of public notice of a director's decision? There will be. You know, we're going to...
2:16:16 Change the notice requirement for administrative decisions so people can actually see it better. We have something very similar to this that we discussed in zoning code user group just recently and we changed it. Can you explain how we changed it, Sandra? What the recommendation was was to, it's in the industrial zone so we'll talk about it next, but was to have the director make the determination but have some sort of notice and appeal period for
2:16:42 This decision. So we at the Planning Commission, it would be agendized at one of our meetings so we would know about it, and that would give an opportunity for it to be reevaluated at the Planning Commission level. But the advantage there is, it would give, the advantage would be that your concern would be, I think, I guess, because the Planning Commission would have visibility of the decision and could take action on it if they didn't agree with it. But on the other hand,
2:17:08 For most, likely most of the decisions made by the director, the process would be easier and cheaper and faster for the applicant when there was not disagreement with the director's decision. I appreciate that. I just know the politics and I don't want to put that kind of pressure alone on the director.
2:17:32 Politics of any situation. Yeah, I understand. And I think I'm kind of reading this. It doesn't mean that you have to make the decision. I think we've had many examples of going, you know, I don't want to do this one alone. I want to bring it to the commission. Yes. And that's what allows you that discretion, doesn't it? Yes. You know, the key is that, you know, for an entity, for an individual to make a case for an extension of this is they have to show significant or unusual
2:18:01 Conditions. And, you know, in our world, I couldn't find a tenant is not a significant or unusual condition. That's a common condition. It's hard to find tenants. It could be that you leave it this way and, like, when we come to you frequently because of the nature of the existing code, when a use doesn't fit very well with our definitions and we actually err on the
2:18:30 side of coming to you or to a committee structure to gauge if this is reasonable or unreasonable. And we will, through all of the administrative permits, have a notice period and a mechanism to notice and an appeal period. So there's a reasonable ability to have a proceeding to seek relief from a decision. I think we get the tough ones anyway.
2:19:01 You get all the tables. That's why you get paid so much. Well, when you said economy, that just didn't make it with me, but I hear what you're saying with environment that, you know, so, okay. Otherwise we would get things that they were completely capable, you know, that there would not issue.
2:19:25 And then that was, as to Jay's point, would be counterproductive to streamlining everything. Okay. You know, but all, but the big ones come here, or we wouldn't have it back at this point. You know, a good example of an unusual circumstance might be a property falling into probate, in which it was legally restricted from being disposed of or used. Okay. And, you know, they were, they had no control over that. Well, at any rate, the Planning Commission will be made aware. Oh, yeah.
2:19:54 So this is pretty strong recommendations from staff, but because of the zoning code users group and because of you and Tony serving on it and the discussion that you heard and all the rest, you're comfortable with this? Very comfortable with it. Okay, then I will support it. Okay, so we don't have consensus on the one year period, but we do have the directive provision. Okay. Okay, now one and five. Structures crossing property lines. Oh, I thought we were done.
2:20:21 Allow routine maintenance and repairs as well as interior remodels, but do not allow any additions. Thoughts? Anybody? I think crossing property lines is just a can of worms. Without a lot line adjustment, I can't imagine anything other than routine maintenance and repairs. But we don't have control over the interior. That's the building department. Remember, this is repair maintenance. This isn't remodeling. No, as well as interior remodels.
2:21:01 Wait a minute. And I've seen that happen. That's not affecting the property line. That's already done. You know, one thing you're always trying to measure is creating a disincentive for repair. If I have a disincentive to repair, maintain, or keep it into a current and livable state, you're starting to encourage disinvestment.
2:21:24 Yeah, potentially. Okay, that's a good point. That's a very good point. I think that that's where we're looking at it is the more restrictive or the less they'll do and the worse it gets. Okay, yeah. Good point. I was yes. That was a yes for me. I think we have consensus. Okay. Next item is gen item 7, letter zone code update on industrial zones. Sandra? Thank you.
2:21:55 As you stated, this is the industrial zoning chapter of the zoning code. This is your first chapter of the three kind of main zoning district chapters, residential, commercial, and industrial. We did make some minor changes to the industrial chapter, grammar, spelling, etc. We didn't make any changes to the list of permitted uses other than reorganizing them by the type of use.
2:22:22 And then there were some suggested changes in the staff report. So I'd be happy to walk through each issue in response or if you want to just discuss the issues that you had questions on, we can do that. There are a couple questions for the Planning Commission on page 7-4 of your report. Staff suggested four new uses for the code.
2:22:51 Handicraft, Handicraft Industry, Small Scale Manufacturing, Beverage Production, Food Product Manufacturing, and Vehicle Services Accessories Installation. So that's the first question is if the Planning Commission feels that these are appropriate uses in the industrial zone. And the zoning code users group did agree that these were appropriate.
2:23:12 You say vehicle services, you mean like an auto shop? No, I mean like a radio installation, window tinting. Oh, vehicle services, parentheses, accessories, installations. Vehicle repair is already in there. It is, yes. This is just a clarification. Okay. So any question about any of those uses? Not for me. Okay, so then the next thing is the question about what type of permit for those uses.
2:23:36 The ways recommended is permitted with no entitlement, the handicapped industry, smoke scale manufacturing, food product manufacturing, and vehicle services, accessories installation, and then permitted with an administrative permit is beverage production with a tasting room. Any questions about those types of permits? No, I have a question on another issue. Okay, so Sandra, then there's...
2:24:00 Was that the two or was there another question? There was one more and that was the question that you raised during this non-conforming discussion is right now the zoning code currently designates the planning commission as the authority to determine other uses that are similar to and not more detrimental than uses listed in the table and our question was should this be changed to allow the director to make that determination and the zoning code users group did agree that it should be changed to allow the director to make that determination provided that
2:24:29 It's reported to the Planning Commission and there is an appeal process. Very similar to your concern. You're going all the way through. I think that's great. That's fine with me. Consistency. So we'll carry that all the way through all of the lanes. Yes. Okay. And so now any other issues? Tell me how this all fits together. There's nothing in here about being in compliance with the lighting ordinance.
2:24:59 I don't think there's a light fixture in the industrial park that is. Is that, since that's covered elsewhere, that's so super, it doesn't supersede, it's greater than, and so it applies to this. It's separate and different. So it doesn't have to be with building standards. Correct. Okay. That's what we're trying to avoid. Okay. Duplicate. Duplicate. Duplicate. Exactly. Yeah, that's how all the problems happen to the old one. Other questions? No, that's it. Sharon? No. Good.
2:25:30 Consensus. Thank you. Okay. And that's for zones. Next is agenda item eight. Again, zoning code update. This is the workshop on Hyde and Mammoth. Thank you. This is the continued planning commission discussion to prepare for your workshop with council. We have not yet set that workshop, but we continue to work on convenient meeting time. What you have before you today is a progressive recap of
2:26:02 Your previous work. Attachment one, or attachment A, is a draft, very big draft, building height technical summary report. Sandra has worked very hard to take the concepts that we presented in the PowerPoint and put them to print so that you have a technical document that's summarizing your methodology and your considerations and factors that lead to
2:26:31 discussing building height. So this substantially follows the form that you discussed and that you provided us some comments on, so we incorporated the changes that you had suggested in your workshop. So that's attachment A. Attachment, and also at the close of attachment A, which is your hand number, page 28,
2:26:57 We also have just a synopsis of principles, so you can see the whole big picture of what has been presented in that document. Attachment B, then, is the sense of the conceptual template application to the areas that were discussed as areas A, which is West End and Main Street, area B, which is downtown Main Street.
2:27:24 And then Area C, which is substantially the Old Mammoth Road corridor. And you have the block pattern, and you have the sections that illustrate possible building heights. And then finally, in that attachment, out of expediency, we provided you the text, which you have seen before from Flagstaff regarding building heights, giving you this because
2:27:51 A lot of the text, not all, but a lot of the text and the diagrams we think are very useful for our code. And we didn't want to just try to start writing the code. I'm going to show you this because we have some really useful text in this. Just so the rest of you understand, because Mark and I discussed this a bit, the Flagstaff code is there not because it's
2:28:17 Something we're going to take, extract, and put in a whole cloth, but it's the best example, staff feels, of height and mass code, so they will use that as the primary source to draw from writing our code. That's why it's here. Our objective today is, you know, to represent this information. This also works in concert with the
2:28:43 Townwide District Plan Document that we've provided. So at your last workshop, you discussed having a more clear and salient discussion of context, you know, what, you know, kind of backwards from what, why, where is, where, what, where, why, what. And so you have that in your first agenda item.
2:29:05 And I don't know if you noticed reading through that, but there are some specific references in there directly to this issue, things like the street ratio of building height to width. That was well illustrated. So what we'd like you to focus on is in describing the community context for standards. Does the draft town-wide report adequately describe the program character and placemaking context to define height?
2:29:35 and Mass, and then how should this information be presented to the council and workshop? Do, under draft building height technical summary report, does, do the two documents, the technical and the summary of principles, clearly describe the public discussion for method and conclusions for discussion? And then finally, for the zoning code framework, which is the template applications and the Flagstaff document,
2:30:03 Do these template standards provide appropriate and effective material for discussion? To the extent that you, the Commission, would like to work with us more directly, you could certainly use your existing committee structure, probably the best format to avoid Brown Act issues. If you wish, a resort investment committee can work on that town-wide district document.
2:30:29 And I think the zoning code committee would be best to work on the technical documents. That concludes our report. Thoughts? Mark, I would be happy, Rhonda, would you as the resort investment committee to go through this? Because I think there are some things that need to be clearer for our joint workshop. There's still a lot of...
2:30:54 technical jargon, not the technical diagrams, but technical jargon, but I am a little distressed on page two, the where, why, what, which the last time we discussed this and maybe the first time it was presented, we reversed that order because this is different from what Planning Commission usually talks about, you know, before we had neighborhood district plans, because we're specifically talking about where are we talking about first, and I think
2:31:21 When you talk about principles in stable districts, I think stable needs some clarification too. Maybe stable, built out districts, to distinguish them from commercial districts that will be undergoing change. And then there's the why, and all that has to do with increasing visitation and our economic strategy, and that's clear. But the what is not my understanding of what the what is. The what is about what goes where.
2:31:47 You know, you want the buildings closer to the street, you want step backs, that sort of thing, where you want the height and mass, and that, to me, was the what. And the statement, building height and mass directly affects community character and the way our community grows, is something that should go under why, as far as I'm concerned. This is a misrepresentation, to my mind, of what I heard at that meeting. The what isn't, I think, clear. You know, I think,
2:32:14 Perhaps on the next page. But maybe that's something a subcommittee could deal with. When you look at the where, why, what continued, those principles, we just ran out of room on that page. So we put maintain existing height mass standards stable districts, explore revised height, shift building mass from street edge. That would be the what? Okay. So that's what, okay, I thought because there was white space there, it just had stopped and that was it.
2:32:43 I think that there does need to be a little more clarity here. I don't think it's quite ready for the workshop yet. If Ronda wants to meet and go through some of that stuff, that would be good. I think what we would like to do, though, is... Expeditiously? No, I think that the document you have here, the attachment A, the technical thing, you should consider which committee of the commission works on this.
2:33:12 Okay, I was just talking about this text and the principles and captions. What committee would work on that? Only one can work on this report. That's all I'm saying. Oh, I thought you split it up that the zoning code people were going to work on the diagrams. And I'm just talking about the text for clarity. One or the other. If we're going to sit down and go through this, which your technical summary.
2:33:41 which has all the standards and the diagrams in it. Right, right. If the Zone Income Committee is going to work on it, you should convey your issues to it now. And then the resort investment piece, I'm not trying to make this too complicated, but this section for the town-wide that you already discussed.
2:34:09 Yes. And that's probably most appropriate for the Resort Investment Committee. So I think what Mark is saying is feel free to provide information if your input relates to the technical report, the building technical report. Oh, yes. I was separating it out into diagrams and text. And if we, on the other hand of the zoning code committee, have input that relates to the content of the district planning that relates to this, we...
2:34:37 Forward that to you, and you work on that part of the information. And you want that now in Planning Commission, you know, in a public meeting. You want that input, is that right? No, this is committee work. No, I can't because I'm a different committee. As the body, share your comments now. If you want this piece refined, give the Vice Chair your direction, and he will work with Sandra on this piece.
2:35:02 And I've heard what you've said so far, and I understand. Okay. I have a few more things, then, if you want me to, you want to go through like that? Sure. Okay. The table of contents, I think that's a great way to do it on the front page, but I think that should be expanded somewhat, each title, instead of saying mass articulation and adjacent. I mean, you know, what's important about adjacent? You've got a whole column of white space here. Paragraph two, the paragraph... Back up again. Go through that again.
2:35:29 See where it says mass articulation and adjacent. This is just an example. I think these titles could be expanded upon some so that someone looking at the report would understand exactly why that title was significant. So you want a little more to direct someone by looking at this table of contents to go directly to the part that concerns them? I think you want a description of what it talks about. It's a table of contents, not a place to lobby.
2:35:57 What it is. No, not lobbying. If you don't think that mass articulation adjacent defines what's in there. Exactly. More definition. Okay, that's what I'm saying. Yeah, a little subheading, yeah. That's what I'm saying. I think there, because that's not why it's important. What does that mean? That's what you're looking for. And you'll see typos as you're going through. Elements isn't there. Second paragraph, it just stops. I don't know where the other half of it is. I got that. The next page.
2:36:26 I find this text really, really wordy. It's just too much planning stuff in it and not enough principal stuff in it. I wish more on principals. That's what I would like to see. I made a note here built out with stable, but you may find some other word that would clarify stable. And I think on the third principle, we should say shift building mass back from street edge. It's both.
2:36:57 I noted that too. It can be either way. You're shifting the mask back by incorporating upper story step backs. But on Main Street, you're shifting it forward in relationship. Oh, yes, you're right. I didn't even think of that. So form covers all of that. Of course. It doesn't say back or forth, which you shouldn't have to. Okay. The other thing that I think to Elizabeth's point about, this isn't too wordy to me, it's description, but
2:37:29 What the real takeaway points are what you have in the little column that say, yeah, the Planning Commission explored the building, where building height should be examined, why building height was important, and what factors influence our community growth. That's it. That's it. I would say in every place I read those, they were the important thing. If I didn't read the whole thing, that's what should be in this column. Put them all in bold.
2:37:57 Good idea. Good idea. This reads like a magazine, and that's what it should. So is this like the subheading here? What this is designed to do, if you're reading a magazine, that's the way it's laid out, is I'm looking at this thing. Do I really want to read all that? If I read the bold, I get the idea of what's on the page, and it should entice me to read the details. Okay.
2:38:21 But more than likely, it's the teaser. And so you've got every, almost every bit of language in there is the teaser. There's a couple that you could tease a little bit more, but if you put it in bold, it will, somebody will capture the points of it. And then you won't have to completely detail and refine this so much because that's what they'll take away. So make sure what's ever in there is what they take away. Very good. And it keeps you from having, it might shorten your.
2:38:50 Might shorten it all, it might, you know, clarify, and then I think you're done because more than likely that's going to, that should be conveying what's going on there. And on that same page then I think that first sentence under what belongs under why. Okay, then on page 12, I'm really confused about this. The fourth bullet point under principles, shift taller building elements to center and south site areas.
2:39:22 I'm not exactly sure what that means. Southern areas of the site, I don't know what that means. To minimize shade and shadow impacts, you want as much southern exposure as possible. What are we trying to accomplish there? You're not reading it correctly. I know I'm not. I don't understand it. On the property, the higher elements should move within the south portions so that the shadow that's cast on the north sides are more protected. Sun access is always to the south of the site. Right.
2:39:53 So you want to move the building to the south? The higher elements. The higher elements of the building that are located in the center, so let's say midpoint east and west, and then farther south, will result in a lesser shadow cast on the northern portions of public spaces. This is not a site planning principle about where to place open space. If it's here, the shadow is here.
2:40:23 Okay, so you've got more solar access on this site. Okay. Well, maybe that needs to be rewritten to make sure that's clear because I didn't understand it. I think on page 14, the two columns before and after should have titles over them saying making great streets in the next line before and after. That's not totally clear there.
2:40:48 So the before and after you want above. Yes, just a title for the column. And I think that even though public room is defined later, I think public room needs to be defined here with a clause. Where does it say public room? Oh, the public room, that's the first line. Of the public room should be given public room, comma, and then what a public room is. The takeaway point, that's exactly what round is saying. Here is on the next page saying what a public room is. And maybe that needs to go earlier.
2:41:21 Well, on the next page you want before and after above the two. Oh, same thing. Thank you. Thank you, Sharon. Yeah, it was before and after. I think really pay attention. Why don't you just switch the, on page 11 and 12, I think you could be able to switch those, those bullet points in the column. Because you talk about a straight edge in proportion,
2:41:54 You take careful consideration of the street edge and proportions given to the bold public room, and then you have your little explanation of public room that you have on page 12. And the great streets apply to these pictures as well, because making great streets is up there. If you just switch those two, I think it takes care of her issue, and it provides continuity of how to start looking at great streets, you know.
2:42:20 Because the important thing about these things is what I said last time is this is the very same street. And that's one thing you want to look at is that is the same car. So it provides vision. And that is a real important point about these things. You're saying switch the teasers. The teasers. Flip the teasers and bold public room and you won't have to give the explanation because your eye will fall over to that little car. That's probably it except
2:42:56 I certainly would go through if you had the time and inclination and reread the text and make sure it's clear because often the big idea is buried in the paragraph rather than right out in the beginning. And I've always got my eye out for that. And you want to make sure the big idea is right here. Exactly. Exactly. As long as it's there, it should be reiterated in the paragraph for a little bit more. But I think that that's, from what I read in it, because I...
2:43:23 Very early, I started reading your teasers. Everything made, I applied it to the teaser. And let's, so that would force them to read the teasers first. And then those things, it's guiding the understanding. Thank you. Okay, that's all I got. Are we done? I really like this, this was, it really made a lot of sense. Do we have a date for the joint meeting? Not yet.
2:43:57 We can't get everybody here. So what I'm, my sense of direction and consensus from you is with those changes, you feel that the questions that we've posed in the staff report, they are reasonable, adequate, useful, and then we will meet with the Senate Code Committee to review the text just addressed. The Resort Investment Committee will review the
2:44:27 Neighborhood District Plan text, the townwide neighborhood district plan text, and then the package that goes to the town council would be the neighborhood district plan document, townwide, the zoning code, the technical appendices and the principles, and then finally the template. Do you wish to present the Flagstaff document as well so that they can see the...
2:44:54 What it's looking like, or do you think that's going too far? I think that will confuse them. If we were to present anything at all, it would be to take specific parts and write some sample code, but I'm not, I don't, I think that's perhaps too specific for that point. This is a lot of technical material presented very well with these changes, but it's, I think we need to keep it uncomplicated. Simple. Simple. Yeah. Great. Okay. And so, thank you very much.
2:45:24 Do you wish to see a revised packet if time permits, do you want to see the final at your next meeting if it's reasonably ahead of your... Yes, it's possible. Okay. Okay. Attend to item nine, commission meeting frequency, time limits, staff resources, efficiency. Sorry, this is... This comes from... It just seems interesting to me.
2:45:59 I think what the Town Council is interested in hearing
2:46:35 In the light of everything that we're doing, how we conduct our business more efficiently and effectively, how is it possible for us to save time and money in deliberations, in joint public workshops, which you just continue with your work? You could probably discuss how you might work more effectively with other commissions. It's a really broad subject.
2:47:04 You might, you know, something that the chair or the vice chair has mentioned before is go paperless. So I think it's a broad field that you can discuss. And I don't think if this, you don't have to, you don't necessarily have to conclude at this meeting. You might draft some ideas that you want to discuss more. Or you could say you're working very hard and
2:47:35 which you have before, that your thorough deliberations are necessary in public hearing. So it really is a broad field for you. It occurs to me that this is sort of like brainstorming, at least because it's so broad, and that's certainly not something that we can do very efficiently right now. Do we want a committee to work on that?
2:47:59 Why can't we just talk about it now? Oh, we can, but I'm just not sure. Well, okay, let's talk about it and then see where we come, what we come up with. Okay. Would you like to start? I can't imagine less than two meetings a month because look how long we have to sit in these meetings because there's just so much work to do. Right now. Although we have on occasion had less than two meetings a month, which when it's appropriate. Absolutely. But regularly scheduled two meetings a month.
2:48:26 As needed, you know, that we plan our schedules around them and we have to be able to depend on that. One thing that's occurred to me, it isn't my preference, but it might make our meetings more efficient, although I think meetings with a freewheeling discussion are more productive. Many chairs ago, we had a chair who ran a very formal meeting and he would go down the line and you made your points and that was pretty much it and he summarized.
2:48:55 And you didn't have the kind of freewheeling discussion that we have as we're trying to sort out ideas and get feedback to our opinions and that sort of thing. That might be more efficient. I don't know if it would make as good a meeting. Because if you disagree with someone... Would it make as good a decision? That's my concern because it wouldn't be necessarily as good a decision because the decision point would be the vote. Whereas if you're trying to reach consensus, which I think...
2:49:24 There's a lot to recommend reaching consensus when we can because that shows that the issue has been thoroughly hashed out. It would save time, but I don't think we would do as good a job, and I'm just throwing it out there as a thought. Those are my thoughts. Something related to that that's a thought of mine. I try to make a habit of going through the material before the meeting enough to make notes about issues and questions I have and share them with the
2:49:54 Staff person responsible at least a day before, hopefully two or three days before. I think that promotes efficiency because what I find is maybe one out of five or six or eight of my questions is something that I completely misunderstood and I don't even need to bring it up once it's been clarified in the meeting. So it saves the amount of time that would be representative that all waited to the meeting and brought it up ab initio then to the staff members.
2:50:23 In some instances has some of my questions have enabled the staff members to do some research that they wouldn't have done if I didn't mention it to them before the meeting. So from the way I operate, it promotes efficiency. And I know that we can't all do that every time. We have other lives and sometimes we just get back from the trip like you just did. You just can't do that. But it's something to consider. It really helps. I spent Monday morning an hour with Jessica.
2:50:53 On the big thing this afternoon and it really it'll save a bunch of time this afternoon because my questions are answered. But on the other hand I wonder about that because I will ask staff a question in advance if it's a big issue of concern for me or else I'll alert them that this is going to be coming because I'm really concerned about this but I don't spend a lot of time on the phone with them about agenda items because I feel that they don't have enough time
2:51:19 You know, if they did that for all five of us, my goodness, as well as preparing the staff report, which is a different approach. We need input from staff on that. That's right. You know, with the sign code, we contacted each of you individually to see if you wanted to have a meeting prior to the hearing. We find, you know, if you don't contact us, sometimes we will contact you to make sure that we understand your individual issues, and we're certainly not violating
2:51:47 Brown Act through this effort. We don't tell you what the others have said, et cetera, et cetera. Early contact is better. Smoking out the issues and understanding them and at least providing the information for your consideration is far more effective than finding out at the meeting, at the dais, and then having to continue the meeting.
2:52:08 Point well taken. So you don't mind if I spend 45 minutes with somebody ahead of time? We suggest it because otherwise you'll be 45 minutes in the public box. That's what I thought. And potentially lead to a continuance. Thoughts? My notes are joint workshops with all commissions. I think it obviously saves time. And when the agendas are structured, we will keep people on point. Today was a good example.
2:52:42 of things where we need to listen to their considerations and make sure that we are understanding everything. And we came to some consensus and issues that we hadn't looked at before, which means that now you're talking about getting more people together at the same time. It's impossible. So quorums, the quorums are required, you know, the attendees are required, but these are workshops. We're not making decisions.
2:53:12 Not everybody's going to attend. We can't expect it. And that's where they work with their staff or with their committee chair to fill them in on what they miss because it's not realistic to get everybody together at the same time. I absolutely better utilize, we need to better utilize the staff for questions that prevent us from misinterpreting the information. And I don't ask a lot of questions because I get it.
2:53:41 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
2:54:09 So that with specific deadlines and things that we have to get completed at the town council's direction. So that's why it's amusing to me that we need, you know, should you cut down? It's like, well, then if you're going to change my deadline, okay, not a problem. You know, but until I hear you say changing my deadline and the staff's deadline, we have to power this out. I guess we all get to relax after we're done.
2:54:37 And have fewer meetings and things. But we are, we're turning this out as fast as we possibly can. The work I've seen today is extremely productive, and I don't know how you could do it any faster. I don't either. It's just amazing. You live here. I think it's, along that line, it's important to note something that we don't need to mention in terms of efficiency because it's already there, is staff response to us.
2:55:06 I get, it's amazing, I get almost instant response all the time, whether it's phone calls, email, and that has a lot to do with being as efficient as we are. I wish I was as good as responding as you guys are. I don't know what state I'm in. Sharon, anything else to add? No, I'm better. In the interest of time. Being efficient. Elizabeth?
2:55:32 No, I said my piece, and I appreciated what you said, and I'm glad to hear that staff wants to hear from us, because I was purposely not doing that unless it was a big deal issue, but small questions I was saving for the meeting. So we adjourned is not the right word. You will break. Yeah, take a break. A lunch break. The next item for you is you have a couple of items.
2:56:02 So the next item for you is your public hearing at 2. So you need not return until 2. And do you have any idea when that will be over? Because the rec strats meeting at 4 today is of a special interest. Isn't that up to us? We've mentioned a lot of them. It's like Wednesday at 4.
2:56:23 That you will be done when you decide to be done. Like you said, it's up to us. So we're off. We're at lunch. So see you at 2. So see you at 2. Row 1, zoning, land use, rural residential, and low density residential LDR-1.
2:56:53 Project description is a subdivision of one 4.39 acre parcel into four lots for the future development of single family homes. A grant of a quarter acre of land to the town of Mammoth Lakes to include one ADA compliant public parking space at the end of Tamarack Street, a 10 foot wide non-motorized shared public access easement connecting Tamarack Street to Forest Service lands, paving of three emergency access turnout areas on Tamarack Street,
2:57:23 An addition of one fire hydrant on Tamarack Street and two along the project's private drive. There is a CEQA termination pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act guidelines. A mitigated negative declaration has been prepared for this project. The location is 500 Laverne Street and south 374-376 Tamarack Street, also known as Gibbs Cemetery Road.
2:57:51 The applicant is the Plum Mammoth Lakes Family Limited Partnership. Let me outline the procedure a little bit, the public hearing procedure. We will open the public hearing. After that, we will have a statement and presentation by staff, then a statement and presentation by the applicant. Next, questions from the Planning Commission, then a call for testimony from those persons wishing to speak in support of the project.
2:58:24 Testimony from those persons wishing to speak in opposition, then a call for general testimony, then an opportunity for rebuttal to the previous testimony by the applicant. At that point, we will close the public hearing, terminating public testimony. The Planning Commission will deliberate the matter and arrive at a decision. At this point, we will open the public hearing and have a statement and presentation by staff.
2:58:53 Good afternoon, Commissioners. Jared Duncan, can you hear me okay? The purpose of this public hearing today is to allow the Planning Commission to consider the application for tentative parcel map and use permit 10-001 in conditions of approval, the final initial study mitigated negative declaration, and the mitigation monitoring and reporting program that were prepared for the proposed project in accordance with the California Environmental Quality Act.
2:59:21 The project application before you today is a vesting tentative parcel map and use permit to subdivide one 4.39 acre parcel into four lots for the future development of single family homes. Three of the new lots would access Tamarack Street and one lot would access Laverne Street in the Bluff subdivision. It should be noted that no homes are being proposed at this time. Also proposed as part of this project is a grant of one quarter acre to the town of Mammoth Lakes.
2:59:51 A 10-foot non-motorized access easement for public access to the U.S. Forest Service land south of the site. Three emergency paved turnouts to be constructed on Tamarack Street within town right-of-way. The addition of one fire hydrant to Tamarack Street and two fire hydrants on the project site. As well as a contribution of $10,000 maximum to the town for transit stop improvements at Old Mammoth Road and Tamarack Street.
3:00:21 Through the public hearing today, the Planning Commission will consider the following actions. Adoption of a resolution to approve the vesting tentative parcel map and use permit 10-001, certification of the final initial study mitigated negative declaration, and adoption of the mitigation monitoring and reporting program that were prepared for the vesting tentative parcel map and use permit.
3:00:46 I'll now provide a brief summary of the discussion analysis topics that were covered in the staff report as well as the initial study. The 4.39 acre project site is located in the rural residential zone and a portion of the site also falls within the snow deposition design overlay zone. Surrounding land uses generally consist of developed low density residential areas to the west and north, the Snow Creek golf course to the east, and the United States Forest Service land to the south.
3:01:16 The project location is depicted in figure one on page three of the staff report. Two undeveloped single family residential lots that are north of the project site are also owned by the applicant but are not part of this project application. The proposed project is consistent with the property development standards of the rural residential zone. The four proposed lots meet minimum requirements for lot size and buildable area. Additionally,
3:01:45 The proposed density is 0.91 units per acre, which is less than the permitted two dwelling units per acre in the residential zone. Proposed parcel one, which sits on top of the bluffs in the bluff subdivision, will require a subsequent use permit and design review for future development in order to comply with the bluffs EIR visual impact mitigation measures, as well as the design requirements of the snow deposition design zone.
3:02:16 The project is required to preserve natural vegetation and trees to the maximum extent possible and replace removed vegetation and trees with native plant materials. Approximately 10 trees between 10 and 30 inches in diameter would be removed to accommodate the proposed driveway access. A number of consultant studies were performed to assess various aspects of the project, all of which have been summarized in the staff report.
3:02:43 and are provided in detail in the mitigated negative declaration. I'll provide a brief review of each of these studies. A comprehensive field review of the project site and surrounding property was conducted in September of 2010 to assess potential impacts to vegetation and wildlife habitat. The study recommended a number of mitigation measures to reduce potential impacts to wildlife species, including the great gray owl, northern goshawk, two species of bat, and mule deer.
3:03:13 These mitigation measures are included as conditions of approval. Additionally, an archaeological review of the project site and surrounding property was performed between July and September of 2010. The study analyzed potential impacts to two existing grave sites on the property, known as the Gibbs grave sites, and it also analyzed potential impacts to two previously identified archaeological sites.
3:03:39 The archaeological study concluded that the project would not impact the two grave sites, which are protected by a conservation easement held by the town. The study did recommend that additional protection of the grave sites be provided by installing a low permanent fence around the sites. This recommendation is included as a condition of approval. The study also concluded that the project would not impact
3:04:05 The previously identified archaeological sites and that no further study of these sites would be necessary. Nonetheless, two mitigation measures are included as conditions of approval that require the applicant to cease construction work and notify the town if any cultural resources are discovered during grading or construction. There have been some concerns raised about drainage and about the potential existence of underground water on the site. The project includes a drainage swale, retention pipes,
3:04:36 And other infrastructure that will capture and divert stormwater to the south of the project site. These drainage measures are required as conditions of approval. The soil study that was prepared in 2003 and that was reaffirmed in 2010 found no evidence of underground water on the site. Nevertheless, conditions of approval have been included that require additional soils and groundwater testing prior to the issuance of a grading or building permit for any of the project improvements.
3:05:06 These would be performed on a more specific site basis. And if any groundwater is encountered during the required testing, then appropriate measures will be required to be implemented to ensure that there are no groundwater impacts to adjacent properties. As discussed in the staff report, the project site is partially located within the snow deposition overlay zone on top of the bluff and is partially within an avalanche runout zone that was identified
3:05:36 in an avalanche hazard study done by Arthur Mears for the Bluff subdivision in 1997. Avalanches have occurred on the site in the past and will presumably continue to occur on the site. The town does not currently have any regulations prohibiting development in these areas. There have been a series of studies done by various avalanche hazard experts for the project site and surrounding property, all of which have been provided in the initial study and are summarized in the staff report.
3:06:05 Another issue analyzed and discussed in detail in the staff report is related to
3:06:35 A request by the Mammoth Community Water District for the town to require the project applicant to provide an easement across the property for the district to use to access their well sites, which are located on Forest Service land south of the project site. The town's legal counsel has determined that the town does not have the legal authority to require the applicant to provide the water district with an easement. I would like to
3:07:03 Take an opportunity to correct a statement made in paragraph two of the letter provided by the water district dated May 4th in which they state that it appears that the town and district agree that ultimate development of the plum property will block the district's access to the wells on Forest Service land. The town does not agree with the statement and has not indicated to the water district that development of the project would prohibit future access by the district.
3:07:33 This topic can be covered in more detail by our town council, Joseph Pannoni, who is here today to answer any questions. Additionally, a traffic study was prepared for the project, the detail of which is provided in the staff report in the initial study. The study concluded that there would be no impacts to the roadway capacity on Tamarack Street or Old Mammoth Road as a result of the project. There have been concerns raised about potential safety issues on Tamarack Street.
3:08:06 As a result of its narrow width, particularly during winter months. These concerns are primarily related to vehicle speed and reduced site distances. The Public Works Department may proceed with measures such as signage and pavement striping to address some of these issues. However, any additional measures would need to follow the town's adopted traffic management procedures which require neighborhood involvement and direction from the town council. The project also proposes to add
3:08:34 Three paved turnouts within the town right of way along Tamarack Street and also proposes to add one additional fire hydrant. These improvements are designed to improve emergency access in accordance with the town's public works policy for substandard streets. Another component of the project is to offer a 10-foot wide non-motorized public access easement to the town to provide public access across the property to connect to forest service land.
3:09:04 The 10-foot easement is located within the access driveway and would not be a separate facility. It would accommodate all forms of non-motorized travel, including pedestrians, bicyclists and equestrians, and is designed to be compliant with federal ADA trail guidelines. Although not required, the project proposes to construct one ADA parking space, which would be located at the existing terminus of Tamarack Street. The ADA space
3:09:36 In conjunction with the ADA compliant trail access will provide improved opportunity for disabled users. Concerns have also been raised about parking enforcement on Tamarack Street, which is currently not actively enforced. The fire district has proposed that parking should be prohibited near the end of Tamarack Street because of emergency access concerns. All enforcement would be provided by the police department and the fire district.
3:10:05 And would likely occur as complaints are received. Sorry. As noted previously, all of these topics are discussed in depth as part of the initial study mitigated negative declaration. In summary, the project is consistent with zoning and general plan land use regulations and is consistent with the goals of the general plan by improving emergency access and by providing improved and legal public access to Forest Service lands.
3:10:36 Staff's recommendation this afternoon is for the Planning Commission to adopt option one, which would certify the final initial study mitigated negative declaration, adopt the mitigation monitoring and reporting program, and adopt the attached resolution to approve vesting tentative parcel map and use permit 10.001, subject to the conditions of approval as recommended or as may be amended by the Planning Commission. This concludes my presentation.
3:11:09 Anything additional from other members of staff, Mark? Or are we ready to go to the statement by applicant? We're ready to move on. Okay. It's time for a statement by the applicant. Good afternoon, commissioners. My name is Terry Plum. My family and I have had residence here in Mammoth Lake since the late 1980s. We've acquired most of this property in the 1990s and have working with town staff.
3:11:39 Town of Mammoth Lakes Fire Protection District, MLTAPA since its existence, the Sherwin's Working Group, the neighborhood, and a lot of folks for many years on this project. And it's my pleasure to bring forward to you what I think is a good public, private project that will take care of our children and grandchildren for many years to come.
3:12:06 So they can access the Sherwin's. And it's my privilege to be involved in this project. And that's all I have to say. Thank you. Good afternoon, Vice Chair, Dyken, and Commissioner. My name is Mark Carney. And I am the attorney for Terry Plum and the Plum family, the applicants before you today. It really is my privilege as well to speak to you today and really a pleasure to do so. Because I feel very strongly about
3:12:41 This project and about the benefits of this project to the community. And I also feel very strongly about the way this process has unfolded. As you may know, I've been practicing law for around 26 years. 23 of those have been in Mammoth Lakes. And in the course of that representation, I've had the opportunity to represent applicants for more than a couple of dozen different land use proposals over the years.
3:13:07 And I've gained a fair amount of understanding and knowledge just through that process. And it's been my kind of goal that I've been harboring in the background over the years that someday when I'm old enough and wise enough and gray enough, or in my case, when I lose enough hair, I would really like to share what I've learned over the past 25 years in a class that I might teach at a high school or a community college or even if I'm lucky enough at college someday.
3:13:36 And as you may know, those land use classes that people attend are really focused on case studies. And if I had the opportunity to conduct a class later on in my career, I really would use this planning process as the model planning process of any that I've seen in Mammoth over the past 23 years. Not because it's the biggest project, not because it's the most controversial project, not because it's the project that has
3:14:04 The most impact on the community. But because it's an example of everything that's been done correctly in the planning process, over the years we've heard a lot of people complain about how difficult it is to develop in Mammoth and how the community is scaring off development interests and things are just too cumbersome and we've walked down a tortured path to approvals. I can tell you from personal experience in this instance that couldn't be further from the truth. What I've learned in this process and what I would hope to impart more widely someday
3:14:34 is that if you have three components to a land use project, you're likely to get two things. One, a better project ultimately than was originally applied for. And number two, the town or the permitting agency is going to get a project which provides community benefits above and beyond those that the community could exact or impose upon the applicant. And that couldn't be more true than in this instance. Those three components that I'm referring to are, number one,
3:15:03 An applicant who has the best interest of the community at heart, number one. And an applicant who is humble enough to understand that just because it wasn't his or her idea, it doesn't mean it's not a good idea. An applicant that understands that this is a process that encourages input from everyone who has an interest in it. And it's that encouragement of input from other parties that makes for a better project.
3:15:31 Influences come from outside to the applicant make for a better project. The second component is a very professional, hardworking staff that shares the applicant's interest of doing what's in the best interest of the community. And the third is the third component of a successful land use application process is an informed and engaged and fair-minded public. Interested parties,
3:16:01 Who are interested in the project because they also share a belief that there's an outcome here that's in the best interest of the community and are focused on improving the project, not killing the project because they as well understand that if you achieve the goals of this project you actually achieve community benefits as well. In this instance, we really do have those three components. We have an applicant who even before he designed his lots,
3:16:31 was focused on providing the community access to the Sherwills. Mr. Plum and his family, even before they put any pen to paper in terms of what the design of this project was going to be, were already working with the Sherwin Working Group, already trying to find out what the community wanted out of this land, what the community needed in terms of public access. And throughout the process,
3:16:52 There was never an instance where an idea that came up that I presented or that Jessica or someone else presented to Mr. Plummer's family that was dismissed out of hand or was not taken seriously because it came from someone who we perceived to be opposed to the project. In every instance, any suggestion was honored and, if possible, incorporated into the project. And with respect to the second component, the professional and hardworking staff, I've really been impressed is what we've seen over the past year.
3:17:21 In terms of the contribution that the staff has made, what we found is the staff has not already been hardworking and professional, but they've been very user-friendly and they've been focused on customer service. And you've heard complaints in the past that maybe that wasn't the way in the past, but it's not true today. From beginning with Jessica and Sandra in organizing our weekly phone meetings in order to get status reports and updates every week,
3:17:49 We moved this project forward towards a goal, culminating in really an extremely well-written staff report that is very clear, very concise, and very informative. To Peter Vernosconi, who whenever we had a question about road alignment, or road surface, or drainage issues, or parking requirements, Peter was always there to give us a quick response and guide us in the right direction to achieve the best result.
3:18:15 In addition, you've got expert legal counsel who is here to advise you on the legal issues associated with that. We've been very impressed with Mr. Pannoni's input at all steps of this process. And also extremely impressed with the work that Helen Clark has done in preparing the initial study, responding to comments from the community with respect to that initial study, and ultimately recommending the mitigated negative declaration.
3:18:42 And the mitigation monitoring program associated with that. But culminating as well, I think this all comes from the top. And so I'd be remiss not to mention the input that Mark Bordelaw has had, because not only was he overseeing everything I just discussed, but he took the extraordinary effort to reach out to the community, to initiate discussions with the community, find out what their concerns might be, and then report back to Mr. Pum and his family.
3:19:10 So that we could incorporate, if possible, those recommendations, those observations, those ways to address those concerns into the project. So we've had the first two components that I think make for a successful land use process very evident in this process. But we've also had a very engaged, informed, and fair-minded public, interested parties from all sorts of interests within the community.
3:19:39 From the Forest Service to MLTPA to DS&S to the neighbors who have legitimate concerns as to whether or not this project will impact the quality of life that they've enjoyed in Mammoth over all these years. So we never heard any crazy talk from any of those folks. We never heard anything that didn't seem reasonable. We understood that what they had to say was legitimate, was well-informed, was well-intended.
3:20:06 And as a consequence, Mr. Poem was able to take those comments and incorporate them to the extent possible. So, as I said, if you have these three components, you can achieve two results that you wouldn't perhaps otherwise be able to achieve. And the first of those results that I alluded to was getting a better project than what was originally applied for. Now, there's a number of ways that this project is better than what it was when it was originally applied for. But for purposes of time, I just want to give one illustrative example.
3:20:36 As to how this project has improved as a consequence of the type of applicant that you have, the type of staff that we have the pleasure to work with, and the type of parties who have given their opinions to the project's components. And that example I'd like to share with you has to do with parking. You may recall from the early stages of this application,
3:21:00 That what Mr. Plum took away from his efforts with the Sherwin Working Group was that the community really did desire and deserve access to the Sherwins. And they actually said to Mr. Plum that they really wanted it to be a trailhead. And so once Mr. Plum heard that it was going to be a trailhead, and he discussed that with his family members, he discussed it with Jessica as well, the staff and Terry decided that the trailhead needs to have some parking.
3:21:30 And so, for many months, the proposal was to have a parking lot closer to the trailhead, which would have up to five parking spaces, including a handicapped accessible parking space. And to be honest with you, we thought throughout this process that that was a great idea. We thought that that was the right thing for the community. We thought that Terry was doing exactly what he set out to do in terms of trying to focus on what was in the best search of the public community. But lo and behold, not everybody thought of it that way.
3:22:00 from some of the neighbors, and they didn't like, they were concerned about the increased impacts to their neighborhood that that parking lot might draw. And so, instead of saying, no, they're opposing the project, we're not going to listen to them, what Terry did is embrace that concept and brought it forward to the staff and said, well, we're hearing some things, and so are you, about people not wanting five spaces.
3:22:23 What do you think we should do? Well, that's when Mark got involved and Mark went out to try to get a consensus on what it is we should do. What do all these people who are interested in the outcome of this project think we should do? And what we realized is what other people were thinking about instead of making sure you could access this trailhead is other people were thinking about don't forget we've got a feet-first policy in town here. We have a goal to make sure that we have feet that we actually achieve.
3:22:50 The opportunity for people to access these amenities on foot as opposed to by car. And so the kind of light went on and said, yikes, that makes perfect sense. And so there was no resistance when the neighbors suggested either eliminating or reducing the size of that parking lot. And so ultimately, our biggest concern was to make sure that DSES was taken care of and that their concerns to make sure that there was disabled access as well to that country was addressed.
3:23:20 And so what Mr. Plum proposed is to put a disabled access parking space down near the trailhead during the turnout of where the fire department was going to turn around, his fire trucks, if necessary. And Peter guided us on the right sizing of that spot, of that place to put the spot, and we had no doubt in our minds that it was a legally permissible location. But then the fire department came and said, you know, it may be legally permissible, but it's not ideal from our perspective.
3:23:49 And instead of saying, well, I'm sorry, it's permitted, Terry went back to the drawing board and said, okay, where's a better place for that disabled parking space? And he moved it again. And he moved it to the location that you see on the plans today, directly in response to legitimate concerns by the Lakes Fire Protection District that even though no parking would be allowed down there, if there was one car that was allowed, it might attract more than one car, and then ultimately,
3:24:19 Prevent the turnaround from being utilized to its full extent. So that's just one example of improving the project because these three factors have come together. Now the other thing that I said that you would get if you have a good planning process which takes advantage of these three elements is you're going to get community benefits which you wouldn't otherwise have had the opportunity to exact or impose.
3:24:48 And that's exactly the case in this instance. The reason that you have these community benefits that Jessica ran off is because you have the right applicants, you have the right staff, and you have the right interested parties. And as a consequence, this project offers lower density than would otherwise be allowed. The density in this area is two dwelling units per acre. But in spite of that,
3:25:17 What you're being asked to approve is .91 units per acre. In addition, and that's something that you couldn't have required, but it's something you've got because we had a good planning process. Secondly, you've got an offer of dedication of an access trail to reach the backcountry. That was something that Terry has thought has been focused on from the very beginning, but it's not something that you could have required. And in addition, you've got
3:25:46 A dedication of .25 acres to the town in fee simple. That's, again, something that was offered but not required. In addition, you've got the construction of the disabled parking space. Again, something that you couldn't have required, but because of the way that this planning process went, something that you're going to end up with if you approve this project. And then in addition, because of Terry's recognition that the people who were talking about the need to be feed first in the community were right,
3:26:15 And because Mark Wardlaw agreed, that Mark and Terry got together and said, okay, if we're going to be feet first, what can we do to achieve that, even offside the property? So Mark said, would you be willing to contribute to the improvement of a transit district on the corner of Old Mammoth Road and Tamarant Grove? That's something he could have required, but something is a good servant he asked for. And something that Terry said, absolutely. So part of this project is the improvement of that.
3:26:45 Transit stops so that people can take a bus to Tamarack and Old Mammoth Road. And if they're going to walk on the trailhead, they can walk from Tamarack, they can walk from Old Mammoth Road to the trailhead as well. And then finally, what you would receive if you approved this project that you wouldn't have the right to exact is Terry's commitment to do the work necessary to provide temporary access over his property.
3:27:14 Even well before the finalization of the final map, before the recordation of the final map, he's offering to, as soon as possible after this approval, is to do what's necessary to provide access to the public to the Sherwoods over this property, even before he's finalized his map, and even before this approval would otherwise require it. So, as a consequence, you've ended up with these six or seven additional community benefits. Because of the way the process...
3:27:43 Thank you for your time. Thank you. Next we have questions.
3:28:18 From the Planning Commission, and my fellow commissioners, I'll ask that we try and group these questions in the order of the issues analysis. So the first issue was design review. If you want to reference that, it's in the packet on pending, page five. Does anybody have questions relating to design review? Comment at the end about that. Sharon, no questions? Okay. The next issue in the analysis list is vegetation and tree removal.
3:28:54 Questions? Jessica, I noted in your response to the email from Robert Creasy, and you actually responded to Rich McAteer and Robert together about the trees, and you said that the roadway has been realigned, so there's no need for an arborist to look at the large, there's a very large tree out there, I know at least one, probably more, how far is the realignment from those trees?
3:29:22 I don't know off the top of my head. It's not close to it. I know that that tree is not going to be impacted by the road. I can scale. I mean, is it 20 feet? Is it 40 feet? Is it 10 feet? Oh, that's fine. Okay, that's fine. I said it's in excess of 100 feet from a real long ago. Okay, thank you. I believe it's about six feet from the road surface.
3:29:52 Yeah, we need to know, are you, Robert? Oh, okay, I guess we need to know what we're talking about because I appreciate your concern about the damage to the root system and it'll go over in a wind. The large 72 foot fur is, yes, well over 100 feet from the driveway access.
3:30:23 Okay. We're referring to the 34-inch, the 30-inch, the 27-inch. And how close are they? Yes, there are, if Elizabeth is referring to the 72-inch fir, the giant fir tree, that is well over 100 feet away from the driveway access, but Mr. Creasy is also referring to a small stand of trees that are between, I'd say, 20.
3:30:50 Inches and 34 inches that are about 6 to 10 feet away from the driveway. Why was the retaining wall removed or eliminated? Well, the driveway access doesn't require any more retaining walls. The previous alignment that included the parking with the parking area that
3:31:15 Required more grading and more fill and cut and that required retaining walls. Since the parking has been removed from the project, the driveway was straightened and doesn't require as much cut and fill and therefore the retaining walls weren't necessary. Are these three large trees at grade with the driveway or are they above it? Below grade. Below grade. Hmm. By a couple feet. Okay. Thank you. That's all on trees. Okay.
3:31:47 I had something related, but I think Jessica's comments covered it. The attachment 8, which is the hand-lettered page 213 of the packet, is a March 23, 2011 letter from the Tamarack Neighborhood Interest Group, and they had raised a question about the viability of large trees next to the retaining walls, and Jessica, you, in an earlier communication with me, you pointed out that
3:32:15 Those retaining walls have been removed, as you mentioned. There's still a possible issue about whether an arborist needs to issue an opinion on that, but it's different than it was originally, is what I understand, without the retaining wall. Correct. Okay. The next issue on our list is biological resources, which in our packet is on handwritten page six. Any questions about
3:32:46 Vegetation and Wildlife Resources. Jay, I have a question or concern about mule by migration. I thought we would talk about it during discussion as opposed to, it's not actually a question. So is that, should it wait then? Yeah, unless you have a question of staff. Thank you. Yeah. Okay. The next item is cultural resources, which is also in handwritten page 6. Cultural.
3:33:19 Archeological Resources. Questions about that? No questions? Moving on to drainage and hydrology, which is on page, handwritten page 7 of the packet. Any questions about that? Yes. Okay, Sharon. At the bottom of page 7, it says appropriate measures will be required to ensure that there are no off-site impacts. Now,
3:33:47 I talked to Jessica, and I do want to thank you, Jessica, for spending time with me yesterday and answering my questions, and you said that a condition of approval was in the packet, and it is, but could you clarify what the appropriate measures will be, not only for groundwater, but for runoff, rain, because this was a soils analysis, but a full, can you tell me a little bit more about that? Thank you, Pete.
3:34:16 As part of the conditions of approval, they will be submitting a final drainage plan, which will show the 100-year storm levels on that plan for the drainage pipe and the infiltrators that are required for on-site retention. Additionally, when there's excavations for the structures and the road itself, they'll be looking for groundwater to see if there's a groundwater issue.
3:34:45 and put in subterains or mitigate those issues if they're encountered. But to date we haven't looked at groundwater. Today, to date. The soils report that was prepared did look at groundwater, they didn't encounter any groundwater. That's correct. The 2003 soils report also looked at groundwater and there was no groundwater encountered.
3:35:16 Okay, that just goes in direct opposition to some of the information from the neighbors, so I was curious about it. Right. And that report was done in 2003, and then the findings of which were reaffirmed by the consultant that performed the initial study, or the original study. And so what Peter's saying is that there was no groundwater encountered in 2003.
3:35:45 But as an additional condition of approval, there will be more site-specific analysis for the building paths and for the roadway improvements. So if there is water encountered at that time, then more site-specific mitigation measures would be applied as part of any grading permit or building permit. And that's clear in the conditions of approval? Yes. Thank you. Anything else? Greenage and hydrology? Okay.
3:36:16 The next item is the avalanche hazard potential, which starts on page 11, handwritten page 7 in the packet. Any questions on the avalanche hazard issues? Yeah, I've got a couple. Yeah, I do too. Okay. Go ahead, Elizabeth. I didn't realize that. That's okay. Is there going to be any design requirements since these homes, unlike the ones in the snow deposition zone up above,
3:36:44 Are in the path of where the avalanche will run out for how the roof is designed, so hopefully instead of having a window wall on the west, it would be lower to the ground, snow would go over it, thinking public safety, is that going to be a requirement? Yes, there were a number of avalanche studies done for the property which analyzed what the requirement, the design requirements would be for any future structures, and those requirements
3:37:13 Need to be met as conditions of approval and there are also mitigation measures and those would be looked at as part of the building permit process and the town has the ability and will require that the plans that are brought forward when homes are to be developed that those are checked by a qualified either civil structural engineer or
3:37:42 Avalanche expert. So at the time of building permit, that would come forward. And one more question I would throw into this since it's public safety. What's the situation with guest parking? How many guest parking places are they required to have on the property as opposed to in the easement? Or will it be any guest parking allowed in the easement? Guests for the three homeowners. For the property owners? Yeah.
3:38:09 Well, I don't believe that our zoning code requires guest parking for single-family homes, but we do have requirements for, you know, minimum parking requirements for single-family homes. But no parking would be required, or no parking would be allowed on the private driveway that would be signed every 100 feet, I believe, because part of that is an emergency access and we need to maintain a 20-foot wide.
3:38:35 Cross-section for emergency access, so that driveway will be signed no parking. And so when these homeowners had guests or a party or whatever, they'd be encouraged to take transit to get there? They could use the driveway, but otherwise, yeah, they could use the driveways, the individual driveways of the home sites, but no parking would be allowed along that access driveway. Okay, thank you. Sure.
3:39:02 At the bottom of page 8, it talks about certification by a recognized expert concerning hazard, avalanche hazard. You know my concern is the town of Mammoth Lakes and our liability granting permission for this to be built. Could somebody clarify, maybe the attorney, does that person then have the liability or does the town? If I may, through the chair,
3:39:34 The city wouldn't have liability for injury or damage resulting from a natural disaster such as an avalanche. The fact that the city may approve a project doesn't mean you then have liability for things that may happen because you approve a project as long as you approve it subject to reasonable conditions, which is what's been laid out. Okay. And along the same line then on page 10, it says...
3:40:05 Applicant is required to defend the town from any claims and so forth, but then it says, with the exception for claims that may result from the public's use of the public access. Obviously then the town would be required to defend itself? In terms of the indemnification, yes. That doesn't mean that the town has liability. It just means that the town would have to be the one at court defending itself.
3:40:38 I quote records not real swift these days. Okay, that's all on that one. Thank you. And Sharon, just to clarify there a little bit, you were asking specifically about liability resulting from an avalanche for someone on the public path. And Jessica, can you go over again the dimension or the location of that avalanche runout zone relative to the public path? Yes, the public
3:41:09 Access easement lies within or is contiguous with the access driveway, which generally runs along the eastern property line. In some locations, it's about six to eight feet away from the property line, but in general, it's along the eastern border of the property. The run-out zone that was identified as part of the Arthur Mears study that was done in 1997 does
3:41:38 overlap that access easement in some locations. And in general, if I might add, the avalanche studies that were done did support the idea of moving the public access easement as far to the east as possible to remove as much of the risk as possible to any public that might be using that easement. Thank you. And Jay, I neglected to ask one question.
3:42:08 It says the current applicant, but if the applicant sells the land, then the buyer or whoever inherits that land would abide by the same condition? Yes, they would. Thank you. On page handwritten 15 of your report, there is a figure 3, and on that figure 3, it shows the Avalanche right outside. The darker dashed line, yes. It's also, I believe, on sheet 2.
3:42:39 And sheet three. I think it's on most of the TPM sheets. That did for avalanche? Okay. The next issue is the Mammoth Community Water District easement request. I think it may be helpful to start this with if Mr. Pannoni can give us a general summary of the issues here, the issues involving whether the town
3:43:14 Can impose an easement requirement, the nexus proportionality test, and the issues with respect to whether or not there is a prescriptive easement there? Certainly. As you know, one of the fundamental protections that the U.S. and California Constitution give is protection to a person's private property. So before a city or a town or a state can require a property owner to give up some
3:43:45 Right to their property. There has to be some connection between the project that's being proposed and the need for that property. There has to be some connection between the project and the impacts of that project. If the impacts are, the term of art that is used by the US Supreme Court was rough proportionality, meaning there has to be some connection. They don't really designate
3:44:15 The level of connection, but they used those words specifically because they wanted to make sure that it wasn't just a rational basis connection and it wasn't some strict requirement of connection, so somewhere in between there has to be some connection. Typically, if a street is needed, for example, obviously there's cars that I have to get to the project. The cars need to go on a street and therefore that's why the city, the town can
3:44:46 require a street to be improved or a street to be dedicated in order to get to the property. If there's another thing that a town could require, the town could require is emergency access because in order to service a particular property, depending upon what the development is of that property, you want to make sure that the fire trucks can get to the property to save the people that may be occupying the property and to save the structures so that a town
3:45:18 The town can require access for the fire trucks. They can also require fire hydrants as you have a condition to make sure that there's water source closed to be able to protect the structures and the people. What the courts don't like to see is just because there's someone coming to the town and asking for approval that the town sort of
3:45:46 exercises the authority it has and says, well, unless you give me this, I'm not going to approve your project. That's the kind of thing the court definitely wants to shy away from. And when it's an exaction of an interest in property, the courts are more protective than if it's, say, asking for some money to provide, for a fund to provide some public service. With regard to the specifics of this project, the access that
3:46:17 I understand what's being requested is access to get to existing wells that require existing, there's an existing need to get to those wells and apparently over many years this property had been used to get to those wells. From a practical perspective the design of the project actually won't prohibit that access to continue so there isn't anything physical that's going to be built or approved.
3:46:48 By this action today and by any action of a development approved in the future because there's an access way that's necessary to get the cars to their garages for the people to actually access their property. That's the same access way that the fire department, the fire district is going to be using, which as I said, the town could actually require that open area for the fire district to get access. The difference is the access to the wells.
3:47:20 The need for the access to the wells is not being caused by this subdivision, nor would it be caused by the development. It's true that when the development occurs, if it occurs, that some of the water that's necessary for that development will, I'm sure, come from those wells, but remember, there has to be a rough proportionality. What is being suggested by the district, the water district, is that this property owner,
3:47:50 Should bear the entire burden of getting to the wells, even though the amount of need of water, as compared to the entire town needing water from those wells, and the need for those wells, the access to those wells, is not really driven by this project. So it's sort of, if you think of, if there's a pitcher of water and a glass of water, the glass of water is this development, the pitcher of water is what the town needs.
3:48:20 And what they're asking is for space to put the pitcher on this property as opposed to putting the glass on the property. And that I don't see the U.S. Supreme Court standards allowing. With regard to whether or not there's been indication from the district that they believe they have what's called a prescriptive easement. They very well may. What that prescriptive easement means is because they've used the property for so many years and they've used it without permission,
3:48:52 That they have a right to continue using it because they're using it for a public purpose. That may be true, but you're not the body to decide whether or not that's true. If that's true, the district would need to go to court and get a court action to say that's true. Another option the district has is to condemn their right, use eminent domain to condemn an access way, an easement for them to access over this property.
3:49:20 And then it would come down to what's the value of the property that they're going to have access over. And they could argue potentially that because they've been using it, maybe the value of that property they need is not that high and so they'll pay at less value. But again, that's not something for the commission or the town to decide. That's about it. If I could add, at the outset of this application, we the town had looked at the idea and the issue of
3:49:53 Requiring an easement, and we see the practical desirability of having an easement for the water district. The issue of the town goes back to the legal authority, and we discussed this matter with the applicant, and the applicant, unlike making transit improvements, was not willing to, through the town, offer an easement that would be attached as a condition approval.
3:50:21 So it's not a lack of desire on the town to do this. It is a lack of legal authority. And we've discussed this at length with the Water District and their staff. And we're certainly considerate of their requirements. But it truly is just a legal authority issue. And based on our knowledge of the situation and the conditions, we've recommended that we don't have the ability to compel this.
3:50:51 As a condition, as Joe has explained. Thank you. Questions related to the water district issues? Even though you say we don't have any authority to make a decision in this matter, we're just the Planning Commission. Two questions. How is fire fighting emergency access different from water supply emergency access, both for drinking and for fighting fires? How is that different? Is emergency access...
3:51:22 You obviously need water to fight a fire, so I'm not suggesting that... And the water supply to the community, you know, drinking water. The difference is the focus has to be on this project and the impact this project is causing for the need, to grant you the authority to issue a condition. Obviously, there's going to be buildings on this property and there's going to be people living on the property and using the property.
3:51:53 So obviously it needs to get fire protection because the project's going to have people there. The access to the water is, the access to the wells is not being driven or caused by this property. Okay. And one more quick question. If the easement is access for the public and it's non-motorized, is there any reason why, if the water district should so decide, they could access their wells on foot with a hand truck?
3:52:25 Were there equipment on it? Would they be prohibited from that? That's a very interesting question. I don't know if practically that's something that can be done. Maybe it is. And I wouldn't want to venture and speak for the property owners whether or not they'd be agreeable to that and whether or not the ease of the public foot traffic, non-motorized access is broad enough to cover that kind of use because the non-motorized access was really... Remember that non-motorized access?
3:52:57 Motorized Access Way isn't a condition being required. It's something that's being offered by the property owner. So I'm not quite sure that that would be sufficient. But if the area is there and the district uses the area and no one objects, then they'll use it just like they're using it now. So, Mark, what you're saying is we're not to consider this issue today? No. What you're not able to act on and consider
3:53:27 Okay.
3:53:57 That's the point for us. I thought we had a legal paper from the Water District that used those same court cases to reach a totally different decision. I'm not an attorney, but I think that's what we have in our packet. Is that true? Yes. You have the district's counsel's interpretation of how they think
3:54:29 The Nolan Dosen cases would give you that authority? Yes. Which really is very confusing and sort of legal hair splitting. Along the lines that Elizabeth was asking, did the water company require wider path? And that's why they, did they, are there trucks bigger than the other trucks that use this path?
3:54:56 I mean, I can't, the town can't really speak to why the issue is. I mean, I thought maybe. I think what you'll hear through your public comments is, you know, some of the reasons why those two parties were not able to agree and agree on the issue of their own mutual easement. We are graced today with four attorneys representing different parties, so you have a lot of legal consultation.
3:55:26 We also, you know, this, Joe Pannoni is our special legal counsel. We've reviewed this in general with our other now town attorney, BBK, Andy Morris, and they agreed with this position. And you know that we are always going to be as conservative and as protective as possible to the town's condition to avoid future lawsuits. Thank you.
3:55:54 I have one follow-up question to that. And maybe, Mr. Pannoni, you're the best one to answer this, but whoever. Do we have the authority to place a condition on this approval, if we so approve, that the water district and the applicant engage in a good-faith effort for the next period of time? I don't know how to limit it.
3:56:23 Try and resolve these differences with respect to working out an easement agreement. We probably could come up with some language that says district and property owner make nice and see what you can come up with. Other than that, I'm not really sure. If they don't, I don't want to be the one to determine whether or not they're making nice, and I don't think you should either. Yes, it's not something with really very sharp teeth, but it's something. I think that
3:56:58 As a condition of approval, that would be somewhat awkward because it would require a determination of when the NICE was completed and to what end. One of the things that we have looked at here, and again, we're very sympathetic to the situation, in that there is a driveway and there is a public access easement. There is an opportunity for the parties to work this out separately and independent of this project.
3:57:28 The access agreement, the easement between those parties could occur sooner, it could be later, and resolve their issue. And the unfortunate situation in that what is not allowing this perhaps to be a condition is that the Water District does have a less convenient form of access to those wells.
3:57:57 We're in this situation, and I think in the main, those parties have to continue to work on this, you know, to find some solution. Thank you. Anything else about water district issues? Okay. The next item in the issues analysis list is traffic and transportation. Questions about that? Mm-hmm. Not a few. Okay.
3:58:25 I was trying to gather Jessica or maybe Pete from the, Peter, from the letters, is the concern about traffic, we're talking about three more houses on the street or, you know, on the private road, is the concern about traffic, construction traffic, guest traffic, there wouldn't be any looky-loo traffic probably, what is the nature of the concern, I mean, everybody wants traffic calming all over town, you know, everybody drives too fast.
3:58:54 But is that just sort of a residual problem or a problem they've had for some time and others saying, you know, this is enough and we want traffic calming or is there something particular about this proposal that's causing all these requests for more traffic calming? Where's that coming from? Is it construction only or what? Well, I'm sure that some of the public might want to speak to this and I don't want to put words in anybody's mouth but I would say in general the comments, the way I
3:59:25 Read them is that it's the concerns are mostly centered on what I would call existing issues, existing physical constraints of Tamarack Street. Yes, the project does add three additional homes to Tamarack Street, so there is an increased use, but I would say by and large the concerns are mostly related to speed.
3:59:52 The narrowness of the roadway, the lack of site distances that might be because of curves in the road or large trees. So I think there's just a general want and desire to see that addressed, and that's an existing issue. Thank you. Does that summarize? Sharon, questions? Right, I'm trying to figure it out.
4:00:21 If you want to keep looking, I can do one more. Go, thank you. Peter, on handwritten page 213 of the packet, which again is the March 23, 2000 letter from the Tamarack Neighborhood Interest Group, they state that Tamarack Street has a limited width of 15 feet at places in winter. And I'm wondering if, is there something uniquely different about that condition on Tamarack?
4:00:51 Limited experience is that there are a lot of streets in town that after a big storm have that kind of single lane access for a while until the town can get everything cleared out. Is that the situation or something different? I think, you know, Tamarack currently for the town's snow maintenance is a cul-de-sac because the town doesn't maintain sunny slopes. The CSD, that's maintained through a CSD.
4:01:16 And so cul-de-sacs are the lowest priority as far as on regular street in town. And so there would be the condition where it's being plowed maybe once a day, but the plow, I mean, the snowblower isn't getting out, which is what really widens out the street. And during heavy years, it probably does get a little bit narrower until things melt back and they can actually put snow someplace. Thank you. Sharon?
4:01:45 I think I was going to the next one. Okay. So the next item is non-motorized public access easement. Is that what you have a question about? I can ask one while we're there. Okay. If I'm not mistaken, the water district works, we have a little map there on that page. They will be doing drainage easements in that little green area on page 15. Is that correct?
4:02:17 Drainage easements are for the town of Mammoth Lakes. Oh, that doesn't have anything to do with water company. No, storm water is drainage and the town is responsible. Do they not put sewer? Okay, maybe I should have said sewer easements.
4:02:33 Will they not be putting those in there? Yes, there's sewer and water easements that are related. I mean, this is general utility, right? Yes, there's utilities including sewer and water easements for the water district, but they should be distinguished from the access easement that the water district is requesting. But they are working in that whole area, is that correct? Yes, I believe so. All the way down? I presume all the homes have to have sewers? Yes. And water? Yes.
4:03:03 But the utilities, the utilities that don't, they'll just serve the individual homes and they actually won't go all the way to the end of the property line between the Forest Service and the applicant's parcel. Just most of the way? Almost a little bit. More questions about the public access easement? Okay. The next item is parking, which is on handwritten page 16. Oh, okay, I want to talk about the history. Okay.
4:03:40 Okay. Page 16? Yes. It says that the easement might be recorded in a temporary easement prior to the actual final parcel map. So what is the status of that right now? The status is that there is a condition of approval, I believe it's condition of approval number 114, that
4:04:10 Requires that a temporary access easement to the town of Mammoth Lakes be established within, I think, 36 months. Mr. Plum has indicated that he would be interested and willing to work with the town to provide that access sooner than that. So that's something that we would work with the applicant on. So within three years. Correct. Thank you. Okay. Anything else on parking?
4:04:44 I guess it goes all the way to page 17, right? Jay? Yes. Okay. What is the cost, Peter, of the bus stop, new bus stop, moving it from one place to the other? The bus stop itself on Old Mammoth Road would be similar to the turnouts the town built last summer, and he's offered to provide the town $10,000, up to $10,000 to build that.
4:05:24 I believe the town spent about $15,000 for the three we constructed last summer. So $5,000 each? That's about what they were. You know, we haven't really laid out this one as a preliminary plan, but they're relatively expensive. So the $10,000 would definitely cover it? Yes. Thank you. Okay. Next item is conformance with the general plan and vision. That topic is on page 17 in the packet. Questions about that? No. I have one final question.
4:05:56 Then the summary of the resolution, which is on 17 and 18. Any questions about that? That's the end of the list. So anything else that you may have? Backing up a second to the biological resources, you said that those three large trees were two feet below the road grade. Did I understand correctly? Is the road grade that's fill, right? Fill that will be brought in. And it's six to eight feet from the trees.
4:06:28 The roadway, the edge of pavement is about 68 feet away from those trees. Thank you. Yes, Sharon. Tamarack is obviously designed for the current homes that were on it now, and we're adding maybe possibly five. Are there other potential lots that could be developed there or no? On Tamarack Street? That are up in this area. There's vacant land there. Is it a potential place for more lots?
4:07:00 I don't know the answer to that question. I'm going here because I'm wondering if there's going to be continued growth in that area. Is there any way to assess some sort of growth so that the town doesn't have to end up widening Tamarack? Is there any way to plan for that? Well, the traffic study did include
4:07:27 All of the cumulative trips that could be produced from lots that are currently undeveloped. I would say that the likelihood of further subdivisions of some of the lots up near the base of Tamarack Street are probably less likely. And if there were, then it would maybe be a couple more houses, if I were just to take a guess.
4:07:57 Based on the traffic study, the cumulative analysis, I believe, projected around 650 vehicles in the cumulative, so the build-out condition. And the capacity of that roadway is around 1,500. So even if there were a handful more lots developed, the capacity would not be reached on that road. So the road is fine as it is for...
4:08:24 Future development. Yeah, I don't believe there would be any situation where enough lots would be developed to ever reach that 1,500 capacity. Thank you. And are we trying to get all our questions answered now? Page attachment three, exhibit three, I was unable to decipher. Did you have a page number? Oh, you mean the mass? Yes, did it.
4:08:54 Right up here, it's illegible, and I wonder what it says. What second? Proposed up to 20 feet wide, and then it's not legible. Oh, okay. I believe that says proposed up to 20 foot wide vehicle access easement to TLML, Town of Mammoth Lakes, to be created by separate. To be made to the Town of Mammoth Lakes? Yes, proposed.
4:09:32 Proposed up to 20 foot wide vehicle access easement to the COML to be completed by separate documents. Thank you. It's just a printing error. But I couldn't quite figure it out. Thank you. Thank you. More questions? Rhonda? Okay. The next part of the process is...
4:10:12 We call for testimony from those persons wishing to speak in support. When you come up to speak, please state your name and your place of residence, and please limit your comments to five minutes. Do we have anyone that would like to testify in support of the project? Okay. John? Good afternoon. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. MLTPA's mission is specifically focused towards issues of
4:10:49 Trail assistance and public access, we're not really speaking on behalf of the project in total, but certainly with regards to our mission. We support the idea of an easement. We think that's important. I think the community believes that's important. We believe that how the public access easement and trail has been developed with a lot of input from the neighborhoods, the folks who live in that area is important, and I think that the current articulation of that easement in those facilities is consistent with
4:11:18 The consensus of the neighbors there, and it's certainly consistent with the needs of a trail system. We've got a concern about the temporary situation, and I've heard Mr. Plum's statements about wanting to get moving on this and get some kind of infrastructure on the ground soon, but I think that it's reasonable to represent that in the conditions of approval for three years is probably too long a time to let that go. This town's got sort of a bad history with development projects and promises of getting things done and things not happening.
4:11:48 in a timely fashion. I think also that any temporary arrangements, the terms of that arrangement needs to be very clear to the public and to the neighbors in the neighborhood and everybody else in terms of exactly what's happening with that. I think also we have a concern that Mr. Plummer, I'm not sure exactly what is intended in terms of what kinds of buildings, whether they're for personal use or whether it's speculative development, that there may be opportunities coming to the community
4:12:17 to build a very significant piece of trail and recreation and mobility infrastructure connecting the Tamarack neighborhood all the way around to the Hayden Cabin, of which this piece through Mr. Plum's property is a very significant part of that. It's short, but it makes that whole loop one large and very compelling facility. I think it's important that the town have the right, independent of Mr. Plum's development timeline, to be able to improve
4:12:46 on the easement that the town will have across that property irrespective of what's happening with the actual construction of buildings or dwellings on that site. I think that the Schoen's Working Group did a lot of work lining out that trail alignment from the Hayden Cabin to the Borough Pit around across public lands. That's in a developed stage of design at this point. And MLTPA, the town, anticipate starting to look for funding to get those things built. And so it's going to be very important to say, well, we can build the whole thing except for this little piece, which
4:13:16 Which might make it problematic for grant writing and that kind of stuff. We're supportive of the idea of just a single ADA space, and I think Kathy Copeland, she can't be here today, but I think that between DSCS and ourselves, that works to fulfill the needs of this being a fully ADA compliant trail. And I think that the way that this, the recommendations coming out of the Shoreham Working Group, as this has evolved with input from the neighborhoods, I think is consistent with the needs of the trail system and consistent with the needs of
4:13:45 The facility. We also support in the staff report the idea about the substandard street policy. The neighborhood, the folks at Tamrac made a very, you know, good and compelling series of arguments about retaining a quality, a neighborhood quality, along that street without having to get into sidewalks and getting it to be conforming to be a full kind of a roadway that would enhance motor vehicle traffic, would be inconsistent with feet first ideas. And I think the idea that the
4:14:15 The ability to incorporate the trail across Mr. Plum's property out Tamrack Street to Old Mammoth Road to Tamrack Street makes a lot of sense. And that's something that's in the town staff report. And that that section of the trail that would be co- I don't know if the right word is co-mingled with Tamrack Street itself be formalized through some thoughts and ideas that Ray Jarvis has about that. And so those are our thoughts. I think that this
4:14:45 You know, this easement and the ability to develop this easement means that the community can hopefully send them to access to a really beautiful ADA compliant commuter trail that will get folks from that neighborhood all the way around to the Hayden Cabin, the commercial center of town, and also provide legal, finally legal access at another point along the southern boundary of town to public lands. So within that context, we support the project.
4:15:11 Thank you, John. And John mentioned DSAES. We do have a letter in the packet that confirms their support for it as well. More testimony in support of the project? Okay. The next call for testimony is from those persons wishing to speak in opposition. Have anybody wishes to speak in opposition? My name is Tim Sanford, and I've been retained by Stacey Bartfield, who had to be out of town today.
4:15:56 You've probably all seen a letter that I wrote some time ago that should have been in your packet expressing Stacy's concerns with this project. And she also supports the concerns that have been mentioned by Robert Creasy and his letters. But rather than reiterate those, I'd like to limit my comments very specifically to what I think is a very serious legal concern with the way this is being carried out. California Environmental Quality Act
4:16:27 requires that mitigated negative declarations can only be used by an applicant if the mitigation measures eliminate all significant impacts to the environment or reduce them to a point where clearly no significant effect on the environment would occur. There is something called the fair argument doctrine which states that
4:16:58 If a fair argument can be made that impacts from a project may result, so if you can make a fair argument that impacts may result from a project that a mitigated negative declaration cannot be used and that instead an environmental impact report has to be drafted. An environmental impact report is necessary to substitute some degree of factual certainty.
4:17:27 for tentative opinions that may exist with regard to the impacts of a project. And, commissioners, I submit to you that in numerous respects, what we have before us and what's been presented in the staff report are tentative opinions about environmental impacts. They're not final opinions. There are studies that still need to be done. The law, and there is ample case law and statutory law on this,
4:17:55 The law says that you cannot adopt a mitigated negative declaration for a project that contemplates evaluating potential impacts down the road. You're supposed to evaluate those now before you approve a project. And if you do that, you're subjecting yourself to the potential for legal challenge. The prudent course of action is to evaluate all potential impacts before you approve a project with an EIR. Now, you don't have to take my word for it.
4:18:25 That what is before you contemplates subsequent studies to determine whether or not there are impacts because they're right in the staff report. At page 7, the staff report indicates that the applicant will be required to undergo additional soils and groundwater tests. If we were confident that there were no issues with groundwater or soils, why would we be requiring the applicant to undergo further tests?
4:18:56 At page 9, the study, or excuse me, the staff report requires the applicant to conduct an additional avalanche study. Also at page 9, the staff report requires the applicant to conduct an additional assessment of home sites. At page 14, the staff report says that the Public Works Department will conduct a subsequent speed study in winter conditions.
4:19:27 All these studies have to be done now, not after approval. And I submit that there are some legitimate reasons why the staff feels that those reports are necessary. And I'm not going to bore you with all of them, but just a sampling. The storage report was done eight years ago. The storage report did not contemplate the fact that a quarter of an acre is being given to the town in this project for snow storage.
4:19:56 A huge mound of snow will have an effect, I'm not an expert, seems to me would have an effect on groundwater, and that groundwater drains right down towards my client's property. If a building in an avalanche area is so risky that the town needs a disclaimer and needs an indemnity agreement from the applicant before the town is going to allow a project to be built in an avalanche zone, should it be allowed?
4:20:32 Is that consistent with our conclusion in the staff report that there's no risk from avalanche danger? The staff report concedes that its solution, the mitigations for the problem with parking on substandard Tamarack Street is that there are, quote, limited staff resources to enforce a parking prohibition
4:21:04 So, traffic study, as I understand it, the traffic study,
4:21:42 was conducted on the north end of Tamarack Street and in the summertime. I'm not aware that there's been a traffic study of the problematic end, the narrow end of Tamarack Street in the wintertime. That's why it makes sense that the staff is going to require the applicant to conduct a subsequent study on this, except you cannot, under the state law, adopt a mitigated negative declaration
4:22:11 Based on studies that you haven't yet done. So that's really the point that states the points that Stacey asked me to make. She has very serious concerns with this project for all the reasons that have been mentioned in the letters that are before you. And we believe there would be a very serious legal flaw if the county hadn't adopted, approved this project subject to the mitigating negative declaration.
4:22:42 This project requires an EIR. I'd like to conclude by quoting Mark Woodward, who just recently at this hearing said, I wrote it down as quickly as I could, I might not have got it exactly right, we are always going to be as conservative as possible and protective as possible to protect the town from lawsuits. Good point, especially these days. To prove the approach, the protective approach,
4:23:12 The required approach in the state law is to reject this application and require the applicant to do an EIR. And apart from the legalities, it's the approach that will be consistent with making sure that the neighboring property owner's rights are protected. Because right now, we just don't know. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Sanford. Any other testimony in opposition to the project?
4:23:55 My name is Deanna Lantari. I'm a resident at Head and Link Circle, which is adjacent to the project. I oppose public parking in a residential neighborhood. On the plan, there's a 2,000-gallon propane tank located 25 feet from an existing residential structure. I spoke with Turner Gas. 2,000-gallon tank for five homes in that area is not adequate, so it would have to be something much larger.
4:24:25 Which is a concern to me being located, you know, 25 feet from an existing residence. And also I would have to agree in 2002 maybe there wasn't a groundwater issue. My home was constructed in 2002. In 2003 I had no problems in 2004. I had groundwater issues at my residence coming up in my substructure. So things do change and that whole area out there.
4:24:54 With Snow Creek 5, if you look at the ponds of the Snow Creek Golf Course right now, they're almost overflowing, so there is groundwater out there. And I'm just asking for the Planning Commission to postpone their decision on this project today until there are future studies done, including what Tim Stanford proposed, which is further VRI. Thank you. Thank you. More testimony? Good afternoon, Councilmembers.
4:25:30 Robert Creasy, and I'm speaking on behalf of the Tamarack Neighborhood Interest Group. But I, first I'll speak personally, I do appreciate that in law, Mr. Fleming, the low density and the public access that we've provided, which I think is a great benefit to the community. And, but there are still a couple of issues which we raised in our initial letter, which we don't feel have been fully addressed and require further study.
4:25:57 There are public safety issues and I think somewhat significant. The trees, which we talked about earlier, there's a cluster of three that are 27 to 34 inches in diameter. They're within about six feet of the road's edge. But if you look at their drip line, probably 40% of the drip line is either covered by paving or fill up to six to eight feet deep. And I'm not an arborist, but I do think an arborist ought to look at those trees.
4:26:26 They are in a high wind area and they are adjacent to existing residential structures that could be impacted if they were to fall. The traffic study, it's true, Tarek Street has existing conditions which make it quite narrow and poor sight lines and in winter it's often snow and ice covered for months at a time. Actually, the town does a great job of snow removal on it and they do get a blower through their
4:26:55 Usually within the first day after a storm. Nevertheless, the winter width is about 15 feet in some places. In between snow poles is about 18 feet. And the reason that's significant is that according to the Federal Highway Administration, a one-lane road is up to 16 to 18 feet in width. And the study that was done was using usage volumes based on, and this is a quote from the report,
4:27:25 The actual roadway capacity for a typical secondary two-lane residential street. I would venture to guess that this is neither a typical nor a two-lane residential street. So the capacities that are used in the comparison are inaccurate. And while these are existing conditions, that end of Tamarack Street that's in question, which has the poor sight lines and the narrow conditions, has about seven existing structures on it.
4:27:55 This plumb subdivision will add three, but it also increases access to two more plumb properties. So there'll be almost a doubling, you know, adding five to an existing seven structures. So while the street has compromised conditions to begin with, this will be almost a doubling of full-time traffic and then construction traffic, as you know, might triple that. Furthermore, the study was done in the summertime.
4:28:22 So, and at the other end of the street where it's quite wide with good sight lines and the winter conditions I think would yield much different speed results and furthermore, winter weekends are one of the highest traffic periods and this was done in the middle of summer when potentially the traffic study didn't address the peak loads that naturally occur.
4:28:53 Thank you very much for your consideration. Thank you. Anyone else? My name is Dennis Farron. I live on Ranch Road, and I'm involved in the Owners Association of the Ranch at Snow Creek. And I just have two minor points. I'm trying to understand in the documentation why Robert Creasy's issue about the ultimate right of way on Tamarack.
4:29:29 which is described to be 40 feet was not considered in the placement of this ADA parking space. The ADA parking space was originally part of the five or added after there were some adjustments of that. And what has happened is in the current plan, they have taken that ADA space and moved it from that group of five location to
4:30:01 A location that's right adjacent to one of the pieces of property owned by the Robert Davenport. It's a very nice house, and I think that location would impact the livability of his property. So I'm just concerned about why that ADA space got moved from where it was originally designed over to the edge. I think it could have been
4:30:30 Put back or at least place somewhere in the center of Mr. Plum's property near Tamarack so that if someone was pulling in, they could, the lights or snow removal activity could be contained within the property as opposed to over on the edge impacting the adjacent property owner. Thank you. Thank you. Any others testifying in opposition? Members of the Planning Commission, Brent Harper, Mountain Fire Department.
4:31:04 I'm not against the project, obviously, but just want to reiterate the concerns that were in our letter to staff that that one area of Tamrack as we make that corner come to sunny slopes is a big concern of the fire department because it gets congested. That's one of our areas. As we go back there towards Summit, a lot of times that's our only access into that area. We don't advocate for a parking place.
4:31:31 or advocate for having parking along there, but we do request that that road be made as wide as possible through that corner. We would be comfortable with no parking signs or whatever, but that does become a congested area, especially as you guys were discussing in the heavy snow, when there's heavy snowfall. As far as enforcement, we will, you know, as the gentleman said, we will get out there and enforce as best we can.
4:31:59 But it's not typically a normal route that either the fire district or the police officers take through there. But as requested, we would go back there. Thanks. Thank you. More testimony in opposition? And we'll move to a call for general testimony. Anyone want to speak in general? Yes. Rich McIntyre at 309 Tamarack.
4:32:36 This project has been going on a long time at the left, but Dave Lavery is here, and I remember four or five years ago meeting and kind of talking about it, and it's gone through iterations. I want to commend Terry for the easement and listening to the different things, but what I really want to say is I felt included in the process. Chief Harper didn't know that we had three secret meetings, so he couldn't come and talk to our group.
4:33:03 But Chief Watson and Jessica and Mark and Ray gave me more than enough time that they understand my point of view. I don't necessarily agree with how it all came out, but it was a process, and that's the nature of the beast. I think that the roadway, and we actually were going to have many homeowners sign our letter, and as the process went along, it just was kind of going along and being taken care of, and so I didn't...
4:33:31 I didn't feel this need that we had to do that. But we're really a feeder for the old mammoth community, at least part of it. And the number of people that walk, the horses, the kids, the dogs, won't show up in a traffic setting. And I don't quibble with the numbers. They make sense. There's a way to do it. And they did it. But it is something that we're a feeder group and are concerned about that, particularly in the summer.
4:34:00 I could have actually stood out there when the weather got, each day that we had nice weather, which hasn't been very many times this spring, but I got three signatures just when I was out there for 30 minutes picking up leaves. So it's just something to consider. I guess where I'm befuddled as a citizen, that I find it, I understand proportionality and I understand whether we can push or not push, but if you have a
4:34:30 I don't know how much a ladder truck weighs, but if it can drive down the driveway, certainly anything the water district has, and so if it's a matter of controlling or making some agreement about the number of uses, it seems incredible to me that the water district doesn't have access. And I would just encourage Mr. Plum and the water district to get it together and figure out what would make sense, because that legally it may make sense.
4:34:59 It doesn't make any common sense. So I do appreciate the talent in the process, and even though they didn't listen to me 100%, I think that they listened, and I appreciate that. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else general testimony? Okay, seeing no hands or movement, we will move on to the next step, which is the applicant's opportunity to rebut previous testimony. We have no rebuttal. Thank you.
4:35:35 Okay, that is, I believe, the end of the public parts of the hearing, so we'll close the public hearing, and time for the Planning Commission to deliberate the matter and arrive at a decision. I'd like to ask Mr. Pannoni about CEQA, what your thoughts are on that. That's the first item under deliberation, so you're right in order. Oh, there was an order, I'm sorry. That's the first thing in my head. Oh, the comments from Mr. Sanford about CEQA should be required for this project because there are too many things remaining.
4:36:17 that haven't been determined yet, in his opinion. It's up to me a decision for the commission to make on whether or not they feel that there's sufficient information in the documentation that you have, the mitigated negative declaration, that you feel that there is sufficient information given to you so that you know what the impacts of the project would be and whether or not there's sufficient mitigation to take care of those projects, to take care of those impacts. With regard to
4:36:47 The specific identified issues, it seems to me that the studies, the additional studies, I'll call them additional studies, the additional studies are not studies that, at least for example, the groundwater, the mitigating degradation staff is saying there's sufficient information to say there's not enough ground, there's not a groundwater problem, but even though we think that, we want to just go that extra mile.
4:37:16 We don't need to go the extra mile because we feel there's enough information, but we're going to go that extra mile. With regard to some of the other studies, just because something's called a study doesn't mean it has to happen before the mitigated negative declaration is approved because some information isn't known until certain things happen. So some of the studies that were described are those kinds of detail that
4:37:44 The impact is identified as, here's what the impact could be, here's what we know about the impact today, but to take care of that specifically, we're going to need more analysis, but the mitigation says, you have to mitigate it and take care of it. So, I'm not legally concerned, but again, if you feel that you need more information, you certainly have a right to ask for more information. More discussion about CEQA. If I could add just quickly to Mr. Pernone's comments.
4:38:38 Predominantly the studies that were identified as needing to be done generally are those that are associated with the actual construction of houses on each of those laws. And so this initial study looked at the potential future development of homes on those sites. But obviously at this point we don't have enough information to know exactly where and how those would be designed. And so as Mr. Pernone suggested, those are principally studies that are going to look at specific designs and recommendations for structural
4:39:08 Mitigations and so on and that level of detail. So those are the nature of the additional studies that are required. And as he said, as we did this analysis, we were able with the input from our technical consultants to, you know, we consulted extensively with people expert in all of the various fields with avalanche, with hydrological conditions in soils, with biological resources to provide as much information as we could.
4:39:37 for each of those impact areas. That's the basis for the inner study that you see. And for closed public hearing. You could certainly let people talk. The record, even though the public hearing has been closed, everything has entered into the record still. Okay. Thank you, Tim Sanford again. With regard to that last comment, I just wanted to point out, and I know you don't want to hear lawyers arguing who does, but one of the cases I read specifically dealt with that argument, where the
4:40:24 The entity in the case said, hey, these studies that we were going to do later, they just really pertain to what we needed to know to approve the actual building of homes. And the appellate court said, that doesn't fly. If you know that there's a fair argument that there may be a significant impact, whether it has to do with the development of homes or something else, you can't do a mitigated negative debt. So that argument has been brought up, and it didn't fly with the California appellate court. Thank you. Thank you.
4:41:00 I'm curious. I have asked you before about traffic. I'm going to stay there because I'm concerned about public health and safely. And I commented some time ago that I drove Tamarack in the wintertime, and I live on a street that… Is this within CEQA, which is what we're talking about now? I want to ask about the traffic study. Excuse me. I sort of go around the bush. Yes, because the traffic study…
4:41:26 Was done in the summertime at one end? That's where I'm going, Jay. Yes, yes and no. There were two components to the traffic study. One was just looking at the number of existing homes on Tamarack Street, the number of existing undeveloped lots, and the additional home sites that would be added if this project were approved. And I, and we,
4:41:55 estimated the number of trips based on those conditions. The traffic study was then, I'll say, checked by looking at existing traffic, actual traffic volumes. That was done during the summertime. So it was kind of a second step reconfirmation of the initial analysis which looked at the number of homes, the number of undeveloped lots, and the number of units that would be added by the project.
4:42:25 And based on ITE standard trip generation rates for single family homes, we estimated what the cumulative number of trips would be on Tamarack Street. So the traffic analysis that Mr. Creasy is referring to was we went out, we counted cars, and then we checked that against what our projection was based on the number of homes that are accessing Tamarack Street.
4:42:54 The traffic volumes, yes, were looked at in total, cumulative, build-out, future, and that doesn't take into consideration winter or summer, it's year-round. But then we rechecked the numbers in the field by counting vehicles in the summertime. Does that make sense? You did an ADT then. Yes. You did actually. Yes. And I think you'd stated before that was on potential build-out of all lots.
4:43:27 Correct. That were there. So it wasn't based under what was there now. It's if every lot had a home. Yes. And cumulatively, based on ITE, standard trip generation rates for single-family homes, the ADT was about 650. And Mr. Creasy referred to staff using a standard two-lane roadway capacity
4:43:56 And that's not exactly true. A standard two-lane roadway has a capacity of about 4,000 to 6,000 vehicles per day. It's more appropriate for a street of this nature to not use that. So 1,500 was the capacity that is used by other jurisdictions and what we call a livability capacity. And that takes into consideration the physical nature of a street such as Tamarack Street.
4:44:26 So we were conservative in our analysis. We didn't use a capacity of 4,000 vehicles. We said 15,000 or 1,500 is a more appropriate capacity limit. And at build-out, we're projecting that a maximum would be 650. So that's about less than half of the available capacity on that street. Further about traffic or CEQA? Yes. No, nothing further. Okay.
4:45:09 Maybe it would help here to read the findings that are part of the resolution related to CEQA and see if we're agreeing on. Page. The page is Henron 22, towards the bottom of the page. Maybe I should read them. Section 1 findings, 1 CEQA A. Planning Commission considered the proposed initial study, mitigated negative declaration together with all comments received.
4:45:53 During the public review process, including the response to comments and mitigation monitoring and reporting program, and finds that on the basis of the whole record, there is no substantial evidence that the project will have a significant effect on the environment. Do you support that? Well, I'm very concerned about the drainage still. But does that mean you don't support it? I don't think the groundwater studies were done that I think needs to be done. It's that simple.
4:46:37 Okay. I suspect they'll have the same problem everybody else in the meadow has because they all flood on heavy years. But how is that? But I don't see the project as the cause of the flooding. I see them suffering along with everybody else, but not as the cause of the flooding. Okay. Subparagraph B, the Planning Commission finds that the initial study mitigated negative declaration reflects the lead agency's independent judgment and analysis. I agree with that. Okay.
4:47:12 C, where it isn't pertinent. D, a program for reporting on or monitoring the required mitigation measures has been prepared and will be adopted with the initial study mitigated negative declaration. Oh, mitigation measures. Which go along with any time that we have this. This is not an unusual request that these are conditions of approval.
4:47:44 And the conditions have been met and there's action for those that are not met. So this is not, it's not rare. But that is condition of approval of the project and we have instances where we have projects had approval with conditions and they did not meet those conditions and there was recourse with that. What is the recourse?
4:48:12 It depends on the, you know, it depends on what, if it stops, if it stopped the project, or, or that they had to comply before they go any further, or they were not, they were not allowed to just continue and not do it, and not meet those. Staff, if we, I mean, I think you have, if there's instances that we know of, or any conditions along that way, because it would be contingent on what was, what was the condition.
4:48:47 Leave your question as, you know, once an EIR with mitigation measures or an MND has been adopted and we have in effect mitigation measures, we do enforce those. So if a mitigation measure has not been conducted, we remediate. So they either have to stop work and address it or they have to institute or reinstitute a program. But essentially this is part of the project. So once adopted, those mitigation measures must be met.
4:49:16 And we do monitor and track them. And if I might add, the mitigation monitoring and reporting program, which is part of attachment two, that outlines all the mitigation measures and the responsible parties for the enforcement of those measures. Okay, the next subparagraph E, I don't think there's any controversy here. The Planning Commission finds that project will not result in a safety hazard or noise problem for persons using the Mammoth Yosemite Airport or for
4:49:51 Persons residing or working in the project area with the incorporation of mitigation measures identified in the initial study, mitigated negative declaration, and mitigation monitoring and reporting program. Why is this a noise problem for the airport? It's not. Why is it in there? I mean, it's not a noise problem for Bishop either. Is it because the town owns the airport? It's standard language. I think that was just a standard.
4:50:19 Mitigation Measure Bio-8 has been revised as a result of the public review process and just to add, Bio-8 is the one that is there to reduce impacts on mule deer, great gray owl and northern goshawk construction and northern goshawk period. So that's the one that they revised to address that.
4:50:42 has been revised as a result of the public review process and the revised language as identified in response to comments and mitigation monitoring and reporting program is more effective in mitigating or avoiding potentially significant effects and that it in itself will not cause any potentially significant effect on the environment. I think that modification was as a result of the letter from the, is it State Fish and Game? Yes, Department of Fish and Game. So any questions about that?
4:51:12 Inacceptable? Well, that was the one that I wanted to talk to you about. Is this the time to do it? Yes. Okay, just let me find that sheet. Page, maybe it's where you just were. Jay, what page were you on? That is handwritten page 129. Okay, let's look at page 115, please, while we're on this topic. It's just a matter of two weeks that I would...
4:51:56 When I talked to Tim Taylor at, again, California Fishing Game, I was a little worried about the small amount of time for fall migration and wondered if we could extend it from October 1st to November 15th instead of November 1 simply because the deer might not have started down. When they start down, they come very quickly, but
4:52:27 They, if they, if we haven't had snow by the end of October, they're not going to start until the first snow falls, and I think we'd be better protected if we waited until the 15th for them to come down. But, and that's, he concurred, I thought it was too short a time, so that's why I called. So that would just be my recommendation. So you're talking about that November 1st, moving that to the 15th? Yes.
4:52:57 I just felt that one 30-day period wasn't quite enough, and so I called, and that's what he recommended. So the 30-day period you're referring to is? October 1 to November 1. Between October 1 and November 1. I didn't think it would make that much difference to the construction, but it might make a difference to the deer herd. I don't feel like I'm much of an expert on that. I wasn't either. That's why I called.
4:53:35 But I've had deer in the yard next to me, and we know that that's a migration route. So I just wanted to put it on the table for discussion. Any other thoughts? I would imagine we would refer to the expert that Sharon talked to. I have no thought on that at all. Is there any comment from Jessica? What's that? I'm sorry. About the deer herd migration on page 115 and the length of time that's being a processation of construction activity so they can migrate?
4:54:10 Well, I can tell you that the mule deer migration was studied in the bluff CIR, and the original mitigation measure was basically taken from that. Then we got the comment from DFG, and they asked to have the construction activities further restricted, but it was not based on mule deer migration, it was based on the potential foraging of
4:54:37 The different raptor species. So Bio 8 was revised to reflect a more conservative or more restrictive construction schedule. So staff, I don't think, would have an issue with making it more restrictive. That would only make the mitigation measure more conservative.
4:55:03 But it wasn't brought to our attention by DFG that specifically to mule deer it should be changed. Okay. I'm fine with that if that's what the commission thinks we should do. So can I ask you now what the construction window, because it's crossed out a couple times here. What construction window are you looking at now? Construction activities shall be scheduled between, it reads now, November 1st to April 1st.
4:55:33 And August 1st to October 1st. So as Sharon is suggesting, it would be changed to between November 15th and April 1st and August 1st and October 1st. So we're talking about exterior building from November 15th to April 1st? It would be what we would consider major construction activities. Earth moving, paving, extensive exterior work, etc. Correct.
4:56:23 So in essence, this mitigation measure would be more restrictive than the Bluffs mitigation measure for mule deer migration. And the commission has the discretion to modify this. Are we sure, Sharon, that this is exactly what you were talking about? He understood you were talking about? Yes, he was very pleased with the spring migration, holding, and fawning because that takes place in the meadow. We know that.
4:57:05 And he thought April 1 to July 1, 31 was great for that. But I ask him specifically about the fall migration because I just didn't think 30 days was enough. So that's why I'm putting it on the table. I guess I don't have a big objection to it. I'm kind of going out of a limb assuming that that's, I guess from what you're saying, that's what he is saying. Well,
4:57:41 I wasn't sure, but it sounded short to me, and that's why I called. Okay. I called first with Eastern Sierra Land Trust. They referred me to California Fish and Game, and that person referred me to Tim Taylor. So it was getting to somebody who knew. Okay. And anyway, I think that's where you were. Mm-hmm. Yep. So any further discussion issues?
4:58:15 Under CEQA, Initial Study, Mitigated Negative Debt. I'm uneasy. I'm not saying you agree with it, but we kind of polled where we're standing. Yeah. We've discussed it. Okay, then the deliberation for the tentative parcel map and use permit. First area is design review, discussion of design review. I've got a few on that. Okay. On page 32, handwritten 32, the conditions,
4:58:54 I would like to see throughout, it's listed in the mitigation measures, but I would like to see everywhere in the resolution, Jessica, visually unobtrusive. You used that phrase in the mitigation measures, but you didn't use that phrase in condition 46. And so I think visually unobtrusive is a lot stronger than just harmonious. We know how, you know, very, very special that Bluffs Ushed is, and we've worked hard, and only...
4:59:22 One house and one roof got past us, but we worked pretty hard to keep that. Then also on condition 46, the last line, we talk about reducing light glare impacts by utilizing low E glass. Craig, Craig, what's, I can't remember Craig's last name. Oh, Craig Olson. Oh, I feel terrible I couldn't remember his name. Craig, anyway. Craig did a lot of research on that.
4:59:52 investigating the kind of glass that was used on the beach resorts in North Carolina so that the turtles wouldn't get distracted by the light shining from within the house. And I can't remember the exact name of the glass. I think it's Sun 2. It could even be HP Sun 2. I'm not sure the exact name of the glass. But in any reports that Craig did related to the bluffs, it'll be listed as a condition. And the purpose of that is so you don't get glare.
5:00:19 It from internally, from the, and this is for parcel one, the glass parcel, which we haven't even discussed, we've been focused on the three below, but that's to minimize the impact in the viewshed of that internal lighting, so that should be not Louis glasses for insulation. But I'd also like to see, and I'd like to see this, it's nice to have a project come in before us, but I wish we'd start talking about this a lot sooner, on condition 48, roof vents, exhaust pipes, flues, and other mechanical appurtenances,
5:00:49 I would like to see them decessified to be non-reflective. I don't know whether that means they, you know, dip those things in acid to make them a dull finish or whether they get painted or what, but we had some projects get by us and the flues are very, very shiny, so those are my comments on design. Any other issues with design? The next item is vegetation and tree removal.
5:01:38 Page. Are you asking me the page? Yes. It is page 5, handwritten 5. Are we going to have an arborist? I don't know. Is that a condition of approval? I don't think it is now. Is it, Jessica? No, it's not at this time. I believe the discussion was having an arborist look at the two trees that are within.
5:02:25 The 27 to 35 inch trees that are within the 68 feet of the driving to make sure that those would hold up to the paving and to the extra width. So because now the giant red fur is not disturbed. That's been requested of us to just study that. What do you think about that? I don't, I...
5:02:58 I would be fine with that. It's not a reasonable request of that. There's many trees around here that are very large that are around paved surfaces and things, and over a matter of time it's going to affect them, but then there's other places where the big tree falls. Anyway, we've got a few on our own property there, so I don't think that's an out-raised request to satisfy that, if that's what would.
5:03:27 Satisfy some of the conditions. How do we write the condition? The arborist is going to evaluate this. What's the, how do we write it? What's the result of the evaluation? Depending on Jeff. Because then, yeah. Yeah, that's good. I was trying to think in my own minds. Because this is adjacent to the road. So normally, they're going to clear the existing vegetation and go down to some stable surface that would be viewed by a
5:03:55 The soil engineer prior to building that fill for the street. So there could be that there's a root there or not. And that's the concern, I guess, is if the root's cut, that it may damage the tree. If the root's not cut, then the road will be in a long term damaged. There was considerable time by the applicant realigning the road to provide limit, to basically pull it away from the adjoining properties from Snow Creek.
5:04:24 And so, you know, maybe the arborists would have some recommendations of how the street would be constructed, and maybe not. We haven't ever had that situation. So maybe it can be written so that the arborists can evaluate the situation and make recommendations, if necessary, for changes to maximize the viability of those trees. We could do something like that, yeah. That would be, we can, yeah, I'm not sure where we had it.
5:04:58 Something like a well, you know, around the, there's some kind of support there, rather than just, I assume it's going to be road-based on top of fill. Yeah, it certainly could be a tree well adjacent to the tree, which we do common, you know, pretty often, adjacent to the tree so that the actual fill isn't on the bark. And we do that as common practice. Oh, no, I didn't mean the bark, I meant the root zone. But the root zone, you know, it's a large tree.
5:05:26 In this area, it's hard to say whether the roots are going to be going away from the road or to the road. We won't know that until they actually excavate the foundation for the road. That would be important to preserve those trees. Those are some nice ones. So perhaps we'll include a new condition number 56B. So I have a 56A and a 56B. We would have an arborist review to clients provide recommendations to ensure the health and safety of
5:05:56 The existing trees to the extent possible and recommendations included in the construction and excavation plants for the roadway. Wow. And you got that. That was good. Okay. Anything else under that category, vegetation and tree removal? No, I'm fine. Okay. The next item is biological resources, referring back to handwritten page 6 in the report. We have no conditions on that.
5:06:39 There are conditions of approval on this with the analysis of potential impact. I think we were just talking about this there. But in future grading or building the project's parcels to reduce potential impacts, and these are also included as conditions of approval. Okay. Any more on biological resources? How about cultural resources? This is again on Henry, page 6. Part of the issue of archaeological sites.
5:07:33 And there are existing conditions, I know. As well as fencing the gray sites there, the existing conditions are, you know, should they find human remains, all work ceases until program is implemented. That's a condition there already. Additional discussion, Sharon? Okay. Next item is drainage and hydrology on the page.
5:08:13 And written page seven. Jay, I mentioned that I was uncomfortable with the drainage and the hydrology study done. You're telling me that you think the conditions of approval are sufficient to answer to mitigate that situation? We're asking that question, yeah. I think they are, but we're asking that of each of us. I particularly remember what, I think it was Mr. Creasy who said that
5:09:03 This was done without the path that in itself is going to be kind of like a dam at the southeast end of the property. So I thought it was going to be turf blocks. Not the whole thing. Well, the section by the lots is going to be turf blocks. Yeah. A couple things with the drainage. Currently, the town does use basically the quarter-acre parcel that
5:09:34 They're going to be offering for dedication to the town. Four snow storage from Tamarack Street. We push a significant amount of snow in that area. This project is going to provide drainage. Currently the drainage just runs, sheath flows and percolates from that area as the snow melts and as runoff occurs from either rainstorms or other events. This project is actually going to provide drainage to that.
5:10:00 That area, so, and direct it down along the new driveway public access easement to some infiltrators at the bottom of the project for that. So the project should really improve the drainage situation as it, what it is today. And so those homes on Ridge Woodcrest won't be impacted? So those are to the east of the driveway and access easement to these properties, which is where the drainage, there'll be a drainage swill and a
5:10:34 Pipeline that'll be incorporated into... To direct it down to the meadow? Direct it down to the meadow. So its existing surface would go east, but the new drainage would direct it south, it sounds like. Would direct it south, yeah. Currently it's going east. Okay. More discussion? Drainage? No. Avalanche hazard? I guess that's where I have a problem mainly with the negative declaration. I just...
5:11:13 There's no way we can know. I mean, we're dealing here with weather, with Mother Nature. Well, be more specific. No way we can know what? What the avalanche is going to do, because it's going to happen. But I don't think... And I don't know how we address that. Well, as I understand it, it addresses it by saying, here's what we understand about avalanches, and it agrees with you, yeah, they're going to occur. We don't know when. And...
5:11:42 That there are things that can be done to mitigate that impact, and that those are part of the conditions of approval. And you don't think an EIR would tell us anymore? No, I don't think so. Anybody else have thoughts? Am I the only one who's leery? Okay. I've seen letters from those people many, many times, and they are what they are. Well, at one time... Elizabeth, you talked at one point.
5:12:18 about some town that allowed building and then they were sued and lost. I don't know if that was the Malibu mudslide or an actual avalanche somewhere. When did I talk about that? You talked about it way, way back and it just scared the socks off of me. They're all in Espindale outside of Bishop. They don't let them build on some of the lots there.
5:12:43 Mr. Panetta. With regard to the Malibu mudslide, the issue there was very different than what you're addressing. The issue there is the court determined that because the city had actually put in some public improvements and it was those public improvements that were causing the water to seep into the ground and cause the slide, that's why the county, actually it was the county,
5:13:11 And then the city incorporated and the city had to take on the county's responsibility. But that's what happened with that. That's not, that's a totally different situation than what we have here. What we have here is we have an area that's identified as avalanche prone. We have a public, a path that the public can use, but they aren't required to use. It's not something that the town is
5:13:37 Requiring. It's something that the property owner is offering because the town can't require it because there isn't that rough proportionality issue. So if an avalanche causes injury to a person or damage, I'm not seeing the town's liability. Again, the town can always get sued. I'm just not seeing the town's liability. So, Sharon, are you concerned with an avalanche occurring or with liability? I'm concerned with liability issues for the town, pure and simple.
5:14:09 And you heard what the expert just said. I know. And I also know what kind of society we live in. Well, but there's a difference between being sued and losing. Okay. I'm just, it's a little red flag. There's the sound bite now. We've already had our lawsuits. Maybe on that condition that says, beware of avalanche, have a sign at the beginning and the end of the pet says, beware of avalanche? Whatever it takes. Okay.
5:14:40 Moving on to the community water district easement issues. Elizabeth, do you want to address your concerns? Okay. I like this project. I appreciate what you've done, but I have a real problem with the fact that when we went out there on a field trip last July, and I've had this in my office, Mr. Plum was saying, you know, the vehicle access for agencies and things like that, what happened between last July?
5:15:08 And today, May 11th, I don't know. But I'm really thinking of the greater good and that water issue, not being able to access the wells for our public safety, whether it's fire, or even more importantly, enough drinking water. You know, I just, I'm very troubled by that. And so I'm supportive of the project, but I'm not supportive of it until that issue gets resolved. So that's, that's it right there.
5:15:36 Which I'm sure is a giant monkey wrench. My understanding is we don't have the power to resolve that. No, we don't. Until it's resolved. Until they work that out. What I hear you saying is you're holding this hostage until they resolve it. I'm not sure that's proper for us to do. I agree with you that I would sure like to see it resolved. That's not proper for us to do? No. I don't think so. We can't do that? I feel like I'm being irresponsible as a representative of the community.
5:16:12 If I say this is fine, even though you've got this big issue with the water district. But I didn't realize I was, I didn't intend to hold anybody hostage. I just said I felt uncomfortable in my appointed position. I understand the concern that you have. I understand the concern, especially because hearing the developer, the applicant, discuss community interest and knowing the district is involved with community interest, I too don't understand.
5:16:44 why this has become a stumbling block, but that's not what I'm here to advise about. I'm here to make sure that whatever action you take or don't take is based on legal grounds that I think can be supported. If you don't approve the project or you delay the project approval or don't take any action until there's resolution of that issue, fundamentally the only way you'd be able to do that is if you could have required it as a condition
5:17:15 The first place. And because you can't require the condition of that access, I don't see how you can say, I'm not going to approve this project until that gets resolved. Because it's sort of saying the same thing, just in different words. So you obviously have, if you want to, you now know the risk. If you want to take the risk, you certainly have the authority to take that action. I would at least suggest to you that if you want to take an action like that,
5:17:45 At least condition your action on saying that you want to have the district indemnify you for any potential taking liability that you may have by adding that condition because you're adding it really on the district's behalf and the condition won't be enforceable until that condition is added. I'm saying that to you. I'm not recommending that to you. I'm saying because my job is to give you avenues that you may be able to take. That's an avenue.
5:18:14 But I'm not recommending it. I'm recommending that you don't require the condition and that you don't hold up your approval on this because of that. Okay, I'm not doing this on the district's behalf. I'm doing this as a representative of the community, on the community's behalf. That's my thinking. I have a bad cold, so I'm not thinking anyway, so. I still see that you're taking sides. Because look at it this way. Sides? Yeah, we know that the district and the applicant have had discussions on this issue. We know they've had discussions. We know they haven't resolved it.
5:18:46 That an easement did not result. We don't know why until they tell us why. That isn't the issue. The issue is them not having access. For you forcing it, that's assuming that whatever went wrong, it was the applicant's fault. Because by failing to approve it for that reason, you see what I'm saying? You're making an assumption that I can't think because I don't know what went wrong.
5:19:18 I'm not assuming anything about that. I just thought it was representing the community's interest. That's what I'm trying to do. It's appropriate for the commission to represent the community's interest as it lies within the general plan, the standards of the municipal code, and law. And in this case, the actions and decisions that the planning commission should take should live and reside within that body. And what we have told you is we do not think that there is a legal basis.
5:19:48 for you to require this on behalf of the Water District. It becomes a Water District an applicant issue that still could be resolved. The challenge is, and it's an awkward circular reference, and I can understand the dilemma that you see. The Water District does have access. They have access across Snow Creek Golf Course to this site, and that is the truth. They've accessed the site from
5:20:18 from that position. If we could assist in this on the town side, we would. But we're confined and constrained by the Nolan and Dolan cases, and we would recommend that this issue remains to be solved by the Water District and the party. And I think if you hear what Mr. Petoni is saying, that
5:20:46 The water district indemnify the town. That's a significant step in and of itself. By establishing a condition that would require the permit to, in order to be effective or in order to proceed, the parties must agree, which they haven't, you are possibly setting up a condition that can't be solved for whatever reasons they haven't agreed.
5:21:14 And the parties may never agree. We don't know. And so I think it would be unwise to establish that type of a restriction. And if I may add, it's also important to remember that the action you're taking, if you were to approve this today, nothing you're doing today physically changes what's out there. And if the district feels that the district still has the ability to go over this property to get to that well,
5:21:44 Even though this isn't, you're saying this isn't a planning,
5:22:14 Department issue. This is, you know, a legal issue with the Water District and the applicant. It's not a town of Mammoth Lakes issue. Town of Mammoth Lakes issue. But I was viewing this from my, you know, non-legal amateur point of view with this big flurry of letters we got. It's like an application that's deemed incomplete. I mean, to my way of thinking, this should have been resolved before the application came forward, but that obviously is erroneous thinking. So that's how I was looking at it. But I understand what you're saying. And, you know, I mean, it's...
5:22:43 Describe some possible actions. And so let's say the Commission voted to approve this with modifications. An appeal process exists. So parties, including the Water District, can appeal the Planning Commission's determination to the Town Council. Our recommendation is going to follow and go forth to the Town Council in that same way because of the legal issue.
5:23:11 And if the Town Council upholds the Planning Commission's recommendation, then the Water District, I think, could try to take us to court. And if they don't, either the Commission now or the Council in the future, they could impose a condition. And then the applicant may contest as well.
5:23:35 We see, again, that it's awkward and it's unfortunate, but I think it really does reside between the district, which is a separate district with its own legal authorities, and the applicant. That's why it's good that we have good staff and a council, so something that seems like common sense may not be, and you can say the reasons why. I appreciate that. Thank you. Well, Elizabeth, I totally agree with you. I just, as a representative of the public and our community, I just...
5:24:05 The fire district, town of Mammoth Lakes, the public, emergency vehicles, Verizon, cable TV, propane, public works, all use that 10 foot easement. Water district vehicles aren't any larger. That isn't the issue for us to decide as Mr. Pannoni and Martin says. I just heard them, but I have to say where I'm coming from and whether it's in my purview or not as a plan commissioner.
5:24:35 I just feel that we are being asked to do something that we shouldn't be asked to do, which is put our community at risk. We know that well 10 failed in 09. We know that we needed 25% of that water for our community. If they were unable to access this, that puts our community at risk. And I'm not willing to... They are able to access it even without this permission.
5:25:07 Is that reasonable? They're doing it. They're doing it now? That's not my understanding. Is that what we want our community district to have to do? Can we do anything about it through this? I can. And you're telling me I cannot. Although I appreciate what has happened on parking and all that you said, but I heard...
5:25:45 Mark Carney say that in the best interest of the town of Mammoth Lakes is what we're all about and that the community deserves access. Those words alone convinced me that we need to have that settled before I just don't think I can, although you tell me, Mr. Attorney, that I'm out of order if I say no to the project.
5:26:14 Because I think it puts our community at risk. Their arguments are very compelling. They really are. And I think all the legalese that's happened between all of these attorneys does not impress me. And the whole thing just doesn't pass my taste test. It smells funny. We can't cooperate. We can't be reasonably good neighbors. I'm offended. We can't enforce that. We don't have the power to enforce that. So I have to abstain. Is that what I have to do?
5:26:48 I don't think you would abstain. I think you would have, you should vote if you feel. But I don't want to get sued because I am out of order. I just, I just think it's, that we're being asked to do something that we shouldn't be asked to do. In a practical sense, if the commission were to deny this application, the applicant would take it, I'm assuming the applicant would appeal it to the city council, so the commission won't.
5:27:20 Ever get sued for denying this project. Would the town council have more ability to do anything about the dilemma we're in? They have the same legal restrictions that you have, whether or not you or the town council or some other community-minded person could convince the two parties to do what you recognize makes sense. Maybe there is someone out there that can do that. So I want to make sure that you understand. I understand what you're saying.
5:27:53 It hits me the same way it hits you that there's two parties that both actually would benefit if this deal was made. I have no clue as to why the deal is not being made. It's not really within my purview to know, and it doesn't really change the legal structure if I know. My obligation is to make sure you understand what the legal risks are, what your legal authority is, and then your job is to decide what you think should be done.
5:28:23 Knowing the risks. And I want to say again, in the beginning of this effort, we thought it was intuitively an obvious thing to do. And when we learned of the issues between the parties, we also explored whether we could allow the water district to access through some other entity's easement, and we found that we couldn't legally do that either. So it's, again, an awkward situation.
5:28:55 It makes me very suspicious now of many other issues that have come before us today. So I'm just an unhappy camper. And I don't see any, I can't think of anything the rest of us are going to say at this point that are going to change that. No, I don't think you can either. Let's leave it at that and go to the next issue. Agreed? Agreed. Next issue, traffic and transportation. I'd like to hear again from Chief Harper what he said about widening
5:29:28 The area at Sunny Slopes, because that has not been addressed, but that sounds like a real difficult, and if so, could somebody tell me why it hasn't been addressed, if this was recommended? That hairpin turn? Yes, the hairpin turn. Part of the thing, we gave a letter to market staff, we've had several discussions about that corner, and we've just asked that
5:29:57 Consideration begin to making that as wide as possible within the constraints that they have to work within, just so that doesn't get gummed up, if you will, during the winter. And is that in the plan? Well, can we ask Peter? Yeah, that's what I'm... Is there a condition that can accomplish that and within reason? Actually, the current design does, with those parking spaces there, it actually does widen it to the extent possible within the right-of-way that we have there.
5:30:27 And it meets, you know, it was analyzed for the radiuses of the vehicles they have, so it does meet that turning radius. How wide is that radius, radius, Peter? I was just looking at the plan, five feet. The radius is actually entering the property of 75 feet, and the radius that's going around through sunny slopes, which is really an off-site improvement, or an off-site condition, approximately to the center line. And that sounds pretty good for,
5:32:37 What we need. And then if we can have it mark no parking so that people can't, would that be reasonable? And that is in a condition of the fire district that's incorporated in your conditions approval. Okay, so that's great. Thank you. Good. Thank you. So that is, his issue is covered here. That issue is covered. Thank you. I just want to clarify that the location of the ADA
5:33:18 Parking lot is due to the access of the trail, which that's what that's for. I'm sorry, could you repeat? Just clarify that the location of the ADA parking space is adjacent to the trail, because that's what it's for, is to have that access. Yes, yes, essentially the trail is an easement that lies within the driveway, so
5:33:45 The access for the vehicles and the non-motorized uses all lies within that same footprint. And so, yes, it does connect. It does connect. And that's why that location just deserved for it there, because it's the access to the trail. Yes, and in part. And throughout the process, as you recall, one of the earlier plans that was presented in this.
5:34:14 Application had, you know, six spaces in a slightly different configuration. And then as we listened to the neighbors and listened to their concerns about the sense of intensification of the trailhead itself, we looked at alternate locations. We considered a parking location that was actually in Forest Service lands at the southernmost terminus of the site. We considered a
5:34:42 An ADA-required space at approximately the grave site within that turnaround area. And in all of those, in all of the different configurations that we studied, the Forest Service was not supportive of putting the parking space on Forest Service land. The fire district had significant concerns with the public health and safety and accessibility of having a parking space located at the grave site that was so far down the trail, if you will.
5:35:10 And of all the alternatives we looked at, this appeared to be the best location if an ADA space was required. And so that's why it is cited where you see it. Okay. Thank you. One more question on traffic. Will there be a Mammoth Lakes Trail System sign at the relocated transit stop at Old Mammoth Road? Saying, you know, 0.3 miles or whatever to the trailhead? That's something that we've definitely considered.
5:35:39 I mean, I think that would be a reasonable thing. Yeah, I assume it'll be indicated on the bus map, but it seems like it should have a sign as well. And just so the commission knows, those are off-site improvements, but we would have a sign there. We also, you know, currently, the town loop goes up Old Mammoth Road from where it ends at the housing by Aspen Creek to Waterford, Dr. Sherwin, that whole area will be signed as well.
5:36:08 With our current measure, our grant was just submitted. On to the next issue, the public access easement, comments about that? Oh, yes. I didn't ask when we did the landscaping section, what kind of landscaping has been specified as a buffer between the adjacent neighbors and the public easement? At this time, there's not been any specific landscaping discussed. I would...
5:36:41 That would be looked at as part of the building permit process. That isn't required as part of developing the parcel, developing the whole project, or does it go by individual building permits? I'm talking about along the property line. I believe that any landscaping would be required as part of the grading permit that would be done for the improvements as well. Okay.
5:37:06 So it's the roadway improvements, the driveway improvements. So is there a condition, I didn't see a condition that spoke to that. Is it supposed to be a privacy screen of trees? Is it just supposed to be shrubs and a few trees? I didn't see that as a condition. That level of detail of what types of vegetation would be provided hasn't been considered at this time, but if you wanted to make some recommendations. Condition 56 now, what we would intend to be 56A, speaks to the project bill.
5:37:37 Provide a final landscape plan and it will be consistent with landscape design guidelines. If you would like to add intent to the condition to ensure adequate screening, you can do that. I think it would be important to add that that's a conceptual thing. That isn't a specific tree thing. It's just the idea is it's screening for the neighbors and I think that would be important.
5:38:04 Okay. So, yeah, 56 final landscape irrigation plans shall be submitted and approved by the Community Development Department of Conclusion and the Project Engineer Grading Permit, which is a permit that's required for the road and the access area, so that we could just say shall include some screening. So, perhaps your intent is to provide substantial screening. I like that. Substantial screening. Yes. For the neighbor's privacy.
5:38:38 Okay. Where are we now? We are, next is parking, which is the ADA parking space and parking enforcement. Rhonda just had a discussion about the park, the ADA space. Anything further about that or enforcement? No, I think, didn't we already talk about enforcement? Yeah, I think we did. Okay. Okay, and 11 is conditions of approval. We've added a number. Are there any issues with respect to any of the existing conditions? Mm-hmm.
5:39:07 Jessica, on condition 65 under life safety. What page number is this? Excuse me, page 35. It talks about vegetation may be reduced or changed, this is for fire, such as tree and shrub thinning and pruning, and I wish after thinning you would insert limbing up to prevent the fire ladders. I think that would be, pruning is too general, but limbing up is really specific. Okay.
5:39:40 And then since we're on the conditions, page 42, I had noted this in my report before John Wentworth made his comments, I think 36 months is definitely too long for that period. I don't know what would be a reasonable period, you know, next summer, 18 months, 15 months, I have no idea. And this is a condition that the applicant has offered, and so we need to make sure that he's agreeable to that condition. It's not something we can actually require. I see.
5:40:13 Can we ask the applicant? You may ask the applicant if they would consider an accelerated. Mr. Plum, would you consider accelerating the public access trail? Instead of 36 months, would you consider doing that sooner? Absolutely. Within the speed of the amount of staff permitting process and the cooperation of MLTPA, which I expect that to go very quickly.
5:40:40 Okay. But I can't go any faster than they would allow me to go. So do you want us to change this condition that says within 36 months or just leave it like that and... The staff, the staff even wanted to sit at 36 months and I have written with the staff that I wanted to, as soon as my... Yes. My name is Terry Plum. People are watching, yeah. And I have communicated with the staff in writing and MLTPA.
5:41:08 That as soon as my project is a go, which means it won't be appealed, I won't be tied up in lawsuits, okay, I know that I can continue with my projects. The first thing I want to do, and hopefully I can do it this summer, is to work with the town of Mammoth Lake staff and MLTPA to put in the temporary four-foot pedestrian access, okay?
5:41:35 And I would love to have that done by this fall, okay, and so forth. So I would absolutely love to have that as well. Because what I want to do is to have the pedestrians go as far east on the property. Grab this and show you. Here's the, the, the art meters avalanche run out zone. And right now the public is using, coming through here in the winter time.
5:42:12 And that's well in the Avalanche Zone. I would certainly prefer to, this summer, have it come down along here, along the east early side, where there are permanent 10-foot lines, but it's going to be, so we can get these folks out of the Avalanche Zone as much as possible. The only place they'll still be in it will be near the Ray property where the Avalanche Zone runs into the Ray residence. I can't do anything.
5:42:39 Okay. But I can certainly, I would love to provide it this summer. It would make me happy. Chair, peace in this language. So I'm suggesting condition 114 that we put as soon as possible and not exceeding 36 months. Okay. Please come to the podium. What page are we on? 42. 42.
5:43:08 Just as we brought in a letter, I think it's very important to be clear about this. The current condition says 36 months. Mr. Plum's main representation, MLTPA has some capacity that we haven't talked with Mr. Plum about this yet, but we could. But I think the language that Mr. Plum is agreeable to this, 12 months, I mean, we have this summer, and then next summer you can make maybe 18 months. But I think that we should agree on a number that's different than what's in the conditions of approval, if we're going to change it. I mean, otherwise...
5:43:38 Keep it 36, but I'm hearing Mr. Plum saying that he's willing to do something sooner than that. I'm willing to do as soon as I have control to do it, okay, and the authority to do it, okay. Might it be this summer, next summer? I think the reason the town staff may have said 36 months is because I've been working on this project for many years, and it's been a very participative and cooperative project, and it's been, it's a better project today than it was initially.
5:44:10 And if the town of Mammoth Lakes can issue me the permits required and MLTPA can work with me, we can get this done as soon as possible. As long as it's not, as long as I'm not bound by something, that's not within my control. So perhaps you modify to the first sentence to say as soon as reasonably feasible and within 18 months.
5:44:45 Aren't you saying the same thing? Yeah. When an 18 months is saying no later than that. 18 minutes, 18 months. That enables the parties that would implement this to get it together and move forward. Thank you. I appreciate the clarification of that. Another question that I'd like to get some clarification on is the ability of the town to do something
5:45:19 with regards to the full 10-foot wide easement, independent of Mr. Plum's construction of projects out there. MLTPA in the town is very interested in pursuing opportunities, and there are opportunities that one of them is going to be starting to engage with next week to start looking at being able to bring resources to get that entire trail built from Tamarack Street all the way through. I'd like to know from the town staff and Mr. Plum and
5:45:49 In terms of what are the, I guess, what can MLTPA and or the town represent to a granting authority, to a financial opportunity with regards to a 10-foot wide easement independent of Mr. Plum's plans for development if that representation can be made? In other words, can we go try to get a multi-million dollar grant to build the entire thing even if Mr. Plum is going to decide he wants to wait a couple years to actually build anything on the property? I think that's the essence of
5:46:18 Condition Number 114, which allows the use of the four-foot wide area across and independent of the project and to allow a temporary license agreement that shall allow for clearing of existing vegetation as necessary for such use of the licensed area. I do not see a condition that requires an early implementation of the improvements that are said, but this
5:46:45 Condition is meant to allow those parties who want to get together and implement a plan to go forth and do so. The modification by allowing as soon as feasible is after the project and if approved when it becomes effective, so after any appeal motion. So we've said start soon, achieve within 18 months, but I think the text.
5:47:16 Satisfies Mr. Weiner's comments. I agree. That's how I write it. I'm sorry, just a point of clarification. The temporary situation is forefoot. The desired ultimate infrastructure would be 10 foot and would involve pavers and different types of servicing we've talked about. Does the town have the right to be pursuing something that's not just the forefoot,
5:47:43 developed infrastructure, but something that is more in line with the 10 foot. If we're going after, if we're pursuing significant grants and financial opportunities, we would want to be representing, certainly for the design process, the full 10 foot ultimate build out scenario rather than dealing with the four foot in between. That's kind of my question. So what you have before you is a vesting tentative map which intends the applicant to install the improvements. And so the
5:48:12 Full implementation is based on the applicant act actually progressing. The temporary license agreement would allow a temporary facility to go. It is not the town's intention to have the town install Mr. Plum's private improvements. I'm satisfied with it.
5:48:39 So we have the 10 feet or we don't? I thought John had to have it in order to ask for it. No, we have, this is, this is an interim condition. What we're going to have to have is access, correct? We'll have access, and then in the final map we'll have a 10 foot easement that really doesn't provide construction access to do, to construct the full width of his improvements. So there is, it's, there's a sequential process here, so there's a temporary that will be
5:49:10 Condition that allows a temporary installation through a license agreement, if you will, of access. The complete easement is part of the overall project, and then the construction of the driveway and the final easement is part of the project itself. So the four-foot easement is all we, that doesn't address your issue, does it, John? I mean, I thought you said you needed the 10 feet.
5:49:40 Easement in order to apply for grants. Well, in discussions with Peter Bernasconi, we've talked about this, defining what rights the town has with regards to that easement. And my assumption has been that the town would have rights to construct on that 10-foot wide easement. I understand that there's a condition of improvement for the development, but if we are putting together a grant application or we're seeking funds to build this entire system,
5:50:08 My question is, would the town have the right either to enforce its conditions of improvement for the 10-foot wide final infrastructure that's desired to be built, or would the town have the right to be able to help Mr. Plum out with getting those things built to complete the final desired 10-foot piece of infrastructure independent of Mr. Plum's development plans? And my understanding from Peter is that the town is requesting
5:50:37 to have those rights. And I just want to make sure that that's clear. I don't, with the 10-foot easement, I don't think that the town would have the ability to construct the improvements within our 10-foot easement without having additional rights beyond the 10 feet. I couldn't hear that. I said with a 10-foot easement, the town wouldn't have the ability to construct the road, the fill that's required to access that area.
5:51:11 Without having wider construction rights beyond the limits of the 10-foot easement. If I may, through the chair. This condition is not a condition that the city has authority to impose. What we understand the developer, the applicant, has agreed to is at some point they're going to give us a 10-foot easement and they're going to pay to improve it. A 10-foot easement is actually part of
5:51:42 their driveway access to the site. So the ultimate design of that, the 10 foot part is really going to be part of that driveway design. So trying to do it now in the next 18 months to me wouldn't make sense because it may have to get undone because of the design of the final project. What Mr. Plum has also agreed to is because he'd like to have people access in that area rather than across his property, he's also willing to give
5:52:12 A narrower easement right now and not an easement that's going to require a lot of grading, just something so that it gets improved sufficiently so someone knows, oh, we can walk here, not there. That's what's going to happen under this temporary license and ultimately when the project goes forward, if it goes forward with housing, that's when the 10 foot is going to be granted and it's going to be improved by them. It's not going to cost any public money. If this
5:52:41 Foundation wants to go seek a grant, I'm sure that Mr. Plum would be more than willing to have someone else pay for that improvement and they can work together to get that grant. One second. I just want to interject a matter of practicality here. I think we're very close to discussing all the issues. If we're going to have a vote on this today, we have to do it now because Rhonda has got to leave. Okay.
5:53:13 This is a practical matter, you know, all of his utilities are within the driveway, so the path, the driveway can't be constructed until all of the utilities are in the ground. So from practical matter, they've got to be consistent, basically going together with all of the utilities for the project. And there's a plan, and it shows where it's going to be, and it's, you know, it's a tract map, and...
5:53:33 I just don't see that as a problem for your grant application, John. But I'm thinking also in terms of, go back to the Snow Creek Gate project, the town has the right to build a multi-use path even if nothing gets built out there for 20 or 30 years. If we go through this 18-month process and there's a nice little four-foot path out there, a way for people to know where they're supposed to go, and now we're in a temporary condition, Mr. Plum, for whatever reason, decides not to build for 10 or 15, 20 years,
5:54:03 I just want to make sure that the town still has the right to put in, to figure out a way to put in that infrastructure so this entire system can be built and we're not left with a great big beautiful multi-use path coming through the meadows and we get to something that's four foot wide and cannot be improved. My understanding was that the town would have the right to do that. I was trying to make sure that that's clear. That's not the understanding I got.
5:54:32 I mean, eventually the 10-foot easement will be donated. Is there a problem doing it up front? Yes. That's what they're saying. Because that's where all the sewer and water... It's going to go, but nobody wants to put that in now. The easement is all he needs in order to tell a grant, fell out a grant application saying that that easement is in place. If he doesn't have that easement in place, nobody's going to participate. I mean...
5:55:01 No, that's not the idea. I'm misunderstanding, I guess, John. Yeah, the idea is that a temporary access would be provided in a better location. The second idea is that the applicant, with his development project, has agreed to provide a 10-foot easement and an improved access way, contingent and part of their development as they progress.
5:55:29 The idea is not that the town builds a 10-foot wide trail through this property regardless of the state of construction of the applicant's program. And so this is a standard condition idea wherein many of the improvements occur with the development itself, not in some independent action by the town. So this is, as you see in many of your projects, improvements are built.
5:55:57 Permanent improvements are built with the project itself. So we do have a temporary condition and then there's a future condition. But nobody's interested in doing any improvements now. It's just the easement, the dedication. The easement is, the easement, the permanent easement is with the final parcel left, which is another future step. Normally the town wouldn't get any easements until the final parcel left, but in this case he's offering to give us an easement prior with it.
5:56:32 Completion of the tentative map. All these benefits you talked about at the beginning are beginning to evaporate, Mr. Kiney. If I may, the benefits that we propose are real and they've been offered. And let me just back up a little bit with respect to this easement. Again, you would have no right whatsoever to exact this 10-foot easement. So that is a community benefit being offered by Mr. Plum.
5:57:02 Moreover, you would have no right to impose a construction of a temporary easement whatsoever. That was another thing that was offered as a community benefit by Mr. Plum. Not only would you have no right to insist upon a temporary easement, you would have no right to insist upon it being constructed under any timetable. That was also offered by Mr. Plum. And it was a three-year offer based upon what it was reasonably anticipated it was going to take to do that.
5:57:31 Today you've seen another concession by Mr. Plum with respect to this license where he said if 36 isn't fast enough for Mr. Wentworth's organization, he'll do whatever he can to do with 18 months. So now we've just gone through four discernible concrete community benefits with respect to this path that I represented at the beginning of this meeting and I'm confirming right now. Thank you. Any other questions?
5:58:03 Discussion of conditions of approval? Jessica, I just wanted to make sure that on condition 46, page 32, you've got visually unobtrusive in there. Yes. And you'll find somebody who knows what kind of glass that is. Yes. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Finally, any other issues for discussion? No. I think we're ready to entertain a motion.
5:58:32 For the record, may I recite the changes that you've made to the conditions? I have a count of eight of them. The first is, as Commissioner Tenney stated, the two changes to condition 46 will now repeat. The second is adding a non-reflective finish to the roof vents and pertinences on condition 48. The next is modifying condition 56 to make it 56A.
5:59:02 And adding the intent is to provide substantial privacy screening between the trail, the properties, and the existing properties to the east. Adding condition 56B, which will have an arborist review and advise on the plans and construction to preserve the trees. Adding to condition 65, limbing up after tree shrub, thinning, pruning, and limbing.
5:59:34 Condition 114, modifying within 36 months to read as soon as feasible and within 18 months, which I also think would result in the last sentence regarding the implementation of clearing activities modified to within 18 months. There's two references to that. And that concluded my question. I didn't hear you mention the Bio 8.
6:00:00 Oh, that's the mitigation measure, so I did capture that. You did get that, and the, in 46, the visually unobtrusive, I think you did mention that, just to make sure. Yeah. Okay, that's everything I have. Complete. So, I think we're ready to entertain a motion. I move that we adopt the initial study, mitigated negative declaration, response to comments, mitigation monitoring and reporting program, and approving vesting tentative personal map 10-001.
6:00:31 and use permit 10-001 for property located at 500 Laverne Street south of 374-376 Tamarac Street. Second. Call for a vote. Okay. Roll call vote. Aye. Vice Chair Duncan? Aye. Commissioner Teddy? Aye. Commissioner Clark? No. Okay. Thank you. And I will say I learned a lot this afternoon. We...
6:01:14 I have a couple of things, just a little bit more. We have no briefing matters, directives report, work program status. For brevity, oh, I'll be very brief. We have, our work program is moving forward. You've now completed a host of your zoning code update items. You've discussed the neighborhood district planning efforts. So we're largely on track.
6:01:48 We have a few current planning items that are currently underway. The search and rescue building, the use permit, will come to you on May 25th. We received no comments on the mitigated negative deck that was, or the initial study that was issued for that project. Mammoth View tentative tract map is on track. We expect to complete the analysis quickly.
6:02:16 and come forward with a public hearing this summer on that project. The Town Council accepted the application for a development agreement or some other form of agreement to consider financial participation in Mammoth View. The Mammoth Rock and Bowl Project, that application is in and staff expects to complete the determining the completeness of the application this week and then begin analysis of that project.
6:02:46 And the Lighthouse Church, which was an administrative permit, administrative use permit, an administrative use permit to allow the church in the former commercial building of the Oak Tree Furniture Site. That application was approved on May 4th. And then finally we have a
6:03:12 application for an administrative design review for the Sierra Manor's project for full repainting that project and that is in progress and we're working on the color review. Future special meetings? Still working on the... Still working. Okay. Comments from the public, this is our second public comment section for anyone who wants to comment on matters not on the agenda. Sorry.
6:03:42 We will adjourn to our regular meeting of May 25th, which will be at 9 a.m. Thank you.