Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2021
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 3 hr 0 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Notable from this meeting
1 finding- A May 2021 agenda packet page lists AIP 41 at $1,283,094 and AIP 42 Security Gates and Fence at $722,344, both 100% FAA funded Budget and Capital Improvements
Transcript
370 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:04 Good afternoon. What's up, John? Michael, how you doing? Good. Way to power through that 1.30 meeting. How about that, huh? Impressive. Sometimes it happens. Good afternoon. Hey, Sandra. Hi, Michael. Christy Williams, the very first person I met in Mammoth Lakes. How's the family, Christy? Good. Very good. How's yours?
0:56 We're hanging in there. We're waiting for the 12 and older so we can get at least two out of our three backstab. I think it happened today. Yeah, I don't know if the county is officially authorizing it right now, but I think there's a couple of clinics next week. I'm going to try and get them in. Nice. I know somebody who's there all the time. You can do walk-ins or appointments at Vaughn's Pharmacy. I mean, you don't even have to wait for a clinic once they authorize it.
1:35 Probably Rite Aid too, not sure. Sandra, I'm not seeing anybody else from Planning. Yes, I know, I was just noticing that. So I know that I've spoken with the, you know, a majority of the Planning Commission. I know they'll be here, so they might just be logging in. So maybe give them a minute, because we have to have a quorum, at least three of the Planning Commissioners. Yeah. And three of the Town Council members to start. The screen keeps changing, so.
2:19 Well, we've got three town council members. I see four. Perfect. There's Jessica. I see Jessica. So we're just waiting for one more planning commissioner to arrive in the meeting room before we have a quorum and can start this meeting. So apologies for the delayed start. I know that Greg was in Topaz, so he was planning on joining, but who knows if he can. He had said that he was coming down this morning, so he was hoping to join.
3:21 Virtually from his home, I thought. But maybe he's still up there, I'm not sure. Hey, Sandra, what time is that design review meeting tomorrow? It's at noon. Got it. There's Commissioner Chang, so we have three. Perfect. I'm going to go ahead and proceed. I imagine Jen, there's Jen. Okay. Okay. So I'd like to call to order the Wednesday, May 12, 2021 Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting. Jamie, maybe we'll please have a roll call.
4:21 Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Eckert is absent, I believe. Commissioner Kennedy. Here. Vice Chair Burroughs. Present. Chair Vanderhurst. Present. Thank you, Jamie. Now, if you all stand for the Pledge of Allegiance. Commissioner Burroughs, would you mind leading us? Sorry, I should unmute. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for which it stands, one nation, under God.
4:55 Indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. I'd like to open public comment right now. I see we have a couple of staff members who are probably wishing to address during public comment. So why don't we go Jenna first. Thank you. So Jenna Carter from Code Compliance, Town of Mammoth Lakes. Just a quick monthly update. The total current cases we have open comes up to 74, 10 of which...
5:25 We're from the lighting audit that I discussed last month. We have opened seven new cases this month and are in the last month. Over the last 30 days, we've closed 12 new cases and eight of those were from the lighting audit. So we're doing pretty good on that lighting audit. Over half of them have responded and complied. The new trend for the last 30 days, I've been working on getting the half dozen or so abandoned buildings.
5:54 Warned and acknowledged that they need to be either demolished or rehabilitated if they're a public nuisance. You guys at last commission meeting, I was asked to give an update about the animal control, the title, I believe it's title seven update. Rick Bellis, my colleague from the police department, he mentioned that, sorry, I met with him and there have been no animal citations issued. He's issued several warnings.
6:22 But everyone's been pretty compliant, he said, and that's with dog waste and the leash law. And Rick Billis will be available next month for the commission meeting. I'll be out of town, but he'll be taking my place at public comment for code compliance. And that is it from me. Thank you very much. Commissioners, any questions for Jenna? Sounds like Rick has got a big heart if he's letting a lot of people off of the warning because it was pretty rampant out there in the spring.
6:55 Do you have, I'm just curious, did you have an area of concern that seemed to be like Lakes Basin or the park? I think shady rest in the spring was pretty bad, but yeah, I'm happy to hear that the community is on board and obeying, following the leash law and at least cleaning up after their animals. That's positive. Happy to hear that. Yes, thank you. Thank you, Jenna. Mr. Brown.
7:26 Good afternoon. I didn't have any updates for you this afternoon. Okay. But I did want to just to remind the commission, our community that we do provide weekly community recreation center updates, hashtag CRC update each week through the town's Facebook page and on the town website. So please direct any interest or questions or if you're really interested in better understanding what we're building.
7:53 Over there at Mammoth Creek Park, that's where I would direct you to. So I'm just here happy to answer any questions and to listen to the presentation this afternoon. Thank you. Thank you, Stu. Appreciate it. I don't mean to exclude the Town Council members. Do you guys have any questions for Stu? Commissioners? Appreciate it, Stu. Any other members of either staff or the public that would like to raise their hand for public comment? Jamie, do we have any written public comment? No, we do not.
8:29 All right, and I'm going to go ahead and close public comment. Let's go to the business matters. Business matter number one is a presentation on the climate adaptation and resilience assessment. And I believe Sandra is going to tee it up and we'll go from there. Yes, I will. Thank you so much, Chair Vanderhurst. It's a pleasure for me to introduce this item as it represents over a year's worth of work to take a high-level look at climate adaptation and resiliency in our region.
8:56 I'm just going to provide a little bit of context on this before I hand it over to the PlaceWorks team. This project is under the umbrella of the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative. The SRTI included four tracks that were geared towards four different work programs under the initiative. And this presentation today, as you mentioned, is focused on climate change and vulnerability in the Eastern Sierra region.
9:20 The initiative was funded by a grant from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy with funds from Prop 68, and the town accepted that grant on behalf of the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. That partnership includes three counties, Inyo, Alpine, and Mono. It includes two national forests, the Inyo and the Humboldt-Toyabe, as well as two towns, the town of Mammoth Lakes and the city of Bishop, and five national park units.
9:49 And I think this list of the partnership really underscores the regional nature of this program. And I will let PlaceWorks walk you through the final work program, but I just wanted to provide a note that our timing really couldn't be better to finish this program at this point, as there is a long list of different initiatives from the state that could help provide funding for some of the efforts that will come out of this project.
10:13 And in closing, I just wanted to say thank you to all the people who participated in this work effort during a really difficult year. Our consultants worked through the pandemic to bring this project in on time and within budget, and we really saw a lot of public presentation on this project, so thank you. With that, I'll turn it over to PlaceWorks. Is it Eli or Tammy? Thanks, Sandra. This is Tammy. I'm going to get us started and turn it over to the team. All right. Thanks, Eli. So, Sandra.
10:46 Mentioned, we're here to give you a presentation and a summary of the work that we've been doing through the SRTI project throughout the past year. So I'm Tammy Seale, principal with PlaceWorks, leading our climate action and resilience practice. And it's our pleasure to be here today to talk with all of you and to present our work. So our project team, while we might be called the PlaceWorks team, our project team includes representatives from PlaceWorks.
11:15 Atlas Planning Solutions, and ICF. So we're a team of planners and economists committed to climate adaptation and related economic studies. So today you'll get to hear from everyone on our team. We've made a point to make space for everyone to share a bit about the work that they've done.
11:34 My job here to actually turn it over quite quickly to Eli Crispy, who's led us through this work and will provide an overview of our initial steps. Thank you, Eli. Thank you, Tammy, and thank you, Council and Commission members. So this project is really in response to the changes in climate conditions that we've seen direct in the Eastern Sierra region and really beyond throughout all of California.
12:03 I think we're all aware that climate change is already having major impacts in the region and that these impacts are expected to become more frequent and more severe. And although climate change has the potential to affect many quality of life issues and topics of concern in the eastern Sierra, one of them, the recreation and tourism industry that is so vital to the local economy and to the well-being of Mammoth Lakes and the region.
12:31 is one of these areas that does face significant threat. So that is what this project is in response to. So broadly speaking, climate change and the natural hazards that are related to it have the potential to cause widespread damage or destruction, injury or loss of life, and other impacts to the town of Mammoth Lakes and the wider region. Visitors serving buildings and other infrastructure, including infrastructure that supports
13:00 Recreation and Tourism activities. This also faces the threat of damage or destruction. And then beyond the direct harm caused by these hazards, there is the possibility of indirect harm, lost visitors, economic impacts, other changes to other recreational activities as a result of these hazardous conditions. And given the interconnection,
13:25 of the region and Mammoth Lakes' role as a central community in the Eastern Sierra, we really want to recognize through this assessment that even harm in the areas outside of the town, be it Death Valley to Yosemite to Alpine County, edge of the Tahoe Basin, those may all have ramifications for Mammoth Lakes and for other communities in the region, and we want to make sure that those are understood and highlighted as potential topics of concern.
13:53 And as things that can be addressed through this project. Given these changes and the potential for harm, we really have three overarching goals for this effort. First is to have a more detailed understanding of how climate change may affect the region, drawing on the latest science and the best available guidance. Second, we want to understand the value and the benefits provided by the regional ecosystems and how those benefits may be affected by climate change.
14:23 Third, and perhaps most critically, we want to provide a foundation for how the town and other key regional agencies and community stakeholders can consider and implement projects to improve community resilience to these hazards, especially focusing on strengthening resilience in the recreation and tourism sector, but also providing benefits in other issues as well.
14:52 So not only is this a project for the wider Eastern Sierra community and for the town of Mammoth Lakes, but we do want to make sure that this is clearly connected with resources and opportunities that are going on at the state and even the federal level. So the state has established the Natural and Working Lands Climate Smart Strategy, which is aimed at protecting the state's natural lands and taking advantage of the benefits that are provided by these lands as a way of addressing climate change.
15:21 and supporting other statewide goals. So this particular project includes looking at benefits provided by natural lands and identifying how best to protect them and how to preserve these benefits. We really hope that this can serve as a replicable case for other regions in the state. The Eastern Sierra can really be a statewide leader on this topic. So we are hoping that this will provide an effective model for other regions and other communities in California that they can follow.
15:51 As Sandra mentioned, the Eastern Sierra for the purposes of this project is Inyo, Mono and Alpine counties and the jurisdiction within them, plus some federal lands that go beyond these boundaries. So in addition to understanding the overarching risks to the region, we want to have a sense of who and what specifically in the Eastern Sierra is most at risk of climate-related hazards that includes impacts to the regional economy.
16:19 And we do want to make sure that this assessment really reflects the diversity of the region and taking into account the effects of elevation, climate, management unit, other factors that may all affect vulnerability to climate change. So, for example, campgrounds in a national forest may be subject to different considerations, different conditions. They may have different vulnerabilities than a campground that's in a national park.
16:46 So we want to make sure that these distinctions are recognized in the project and that the project provides a good foundation for responding to these unique conditions. Sandra summarized some of the details about the project area. You can see the specific topics and land units here, but it is a mix of state, federal, local, and private lands, all of which have their own particular considerations.
17:14 and abilities to be affected by climate change and to respond to climate change in different ways. The specific project here is made up of four different components. So to start, we have what's called the Baseline Natural Capital Assessment. This is looking at the economic benefit from the regional ecosystems, how those ecosystems support recreational activities and other items of value to the region.
17:43 There is the Climate Change Vulnerability Assessment, which looks at how the climate conditions are expected to change and who and what is most at risk as a result. There is the Climate Change Natural Capital Assessment. This is building on the baseline assessment and helping to understand that given the change in climate and given the changes in risk, how is that going to affect the economic benefits and the other benefits that are provided by the regional ecosystem?
18:11 And fourth, we have a screening process for evaluating projects to see how these projects can help address some of these climate vulnerabilities and improve climate resilience. And that's coupled with an initial set of recommended projects that we're hoping can set the stage for future action. So with that, I'll turn it over to another member of our team, Jacqueline Protzman, who's going to discuss the climate change vulnerability assessment. Thanks, Eli.
18:41 So for this assessment, the project team prepared a climate change vulnerability assessment to analyze which sectors of the recreation and tourism economy that are most vulnerable to hazards created by climate change. This assessment included 136 populations and assets, either directly or indirectly associated with the recreation and tourism economy. Indirectly associated populations and assets are those that may support recreation and tourism but not be directly involved.
19:10 in the actual activities. These include, but are not limited to assets such as retail workers, communication services, and energy delivery infrastructure. The project team split these populations and assets into six categories, including populations, infrastructure, buildings and facilities, recreation and tourism activities, ecosystems and natural resources, and key services.
19:38 The vulnerability assessment identifies 10 distinct hazards, including air quality, smoke and ash, drought, extreme heat, flooding, forestry pests and diseases, human health hazards, landslides, severe weather and severe winter weather, and wildfire. The populations and assets were also separated out based on location or management unit, understanding that each jurisdiction
20:04 And agency may have different recreation activities, varying levels of resources, and may be affected by hazards differently. The assessment included an evaluation of the direct and indirect impacts of these hazards on each population or asset and an analysis of adaptive capacity. Impacts are considered the effects, especially the negative ones, of a climate change hazard, which can be direct or indirect in nature.
20:32 For example, severe weather can directly damage electrical transmission lines causing power outages which can indirectly impact retail workers or hospitality workers who may depend on the electricity for their employers to stay open. Adaptive capacity is the ability of populations or assets to prepare for, respond to, and recover from hazardous events. For example, having emergency power supplies would
21:01 create a higher adaptive capacity for retail workers and hospitality workers who again depend on the electricity for their employers to stay open. So the impact and adaptive capacity scores were used to generate a vulnerability score which ranged from B1 to B5, B1 meaning minimal vulnerability and B5 meaning severe vulnerability. Next slide. This assessment included dozens of
21:31 resources from local, regional, state, and federal sources. At the federal level, we relied on the U.S. Forest Service, Region 5, and Region 4 vulnerability assessments, as well as several other sources for assets and hazard information. We also used several state sources, such as the California Adaptation Planning Guide, the California Fourth Climate Change Assessment, the Cal-Adapt Data
21:59 Database vulnerability assessments created by Caltrans and Cal Fire sources for wildfire. And we use these sources for guidance on the process, obtaining climate change data and understanding the climate change hazards in the Sierra Nevada region. Local data was primarily used to understand the hazards currently affecting the study area and any local policies and programs in place to address these hazards.
22:26 And this included the vulnerability assessment prepared in 2019 for resilient Mammoth Lakes project and the local hazard mitigation plans for Alpine, Mono and Inyo counties. We also relied on EcoAdopt Sierra Nevada and Southern California ecosystem vulnerability assessments to understand the vulnerabilities of the ecosystems in the region. So the primary focus of the assessment
22:54 was to evaluate the vulnerabilities of the recreation for tourism industry to climate change hazards, and therefore the project team included 19 recreational activities ranging from winter activities such as downhill, backcountry, and cross-country skiing to a full range of summer activities such as hiking, bicycling, picnicking, water-based activities, and fishing. So here are some of
23:25 The key findings from the vulnerability assessment portion of the project. The project team found that tribal communities and other frontline groups will likely face substantial health risks from various climate change hazards. The recreation and tourism workers face economic harm. There is a potential for infrastructure damage during and after hazardous events, especially for energy, water, and wastewater infrastructure.
23:53 Several buildings and facilities are at risk of being damaged, including campgrounds, lodging, homes, and several administrative centers. There's a potential for widespread disruption of recreation in the region, and there's also a substantial risk of ecosystem harm in the region, especially for forest, wetlands, and aquatic habitats.
24:19 So with that, I will now turn it over to David Breiter, who will give an overview of the natural capital assessment. So to understand climate vulnerability, we also need to assess the value of nature and land within the study area. We performed a natural capital assessment to identify the economic value provided by ecosystem services. And ecosystem services are the benefits that humans receive from normal functioning
24:51 of healthy ecosystems. The figure on the right here presents some examples. Ecosystems are usually disaggregated into four different types, including provisioning, regulating, cultural, and supporting services. Some examples include resources for extraction or harvest, like timber or water resources, things like carbon storage and carbon sequestration, water purification, and recreation.
25:21 Next slide, please. So our assessment of the value of ecosystem services happened through a few steps. Different land covers provide different ecosystem services. You can imagine that a heavily forested area provides different ecosystem services compared to a desert or riverine ecosystems. So we identified which ecosystem services are prevalent within the study area using CalVeg land cover data to identify the land covers in the region.
25:52 We then used the land cover data to identify which services were available. Then we went through a monetization process. We used benefit transfer techniques to assign value. And benefit transfer is a commonly used method for assigning existing values within the economic literature for various ecosystem services to a new study area. We carefully matched similar geographic regions and ecosystems when transferring value.
26:21 And you'll see in subsequent slides that we present our results as ranges rather than discrete values. This is a result of how we incorporate a wide variety of economic source literature. When gathering potential values, we assess the minimum and average at a maximum value for each ecosystem service, and then we carry that structure through our analysis. For recreation, we use slightly different method.
26:50 We use visitation and spending data from the National Park Service and from the Forest Service for forests within the region. Next slide, please. So a look at some of the high-level results. We identified that ecosystem services provide between $43 and $190 billion, with an average of $95 billion in annual benefits. The largest value is from carbon storage and water resources, with desert shrubland and coniferous forests providing the largest benefits.
27:20 This is largely due to the abundance of these land cover types within the study area. Next slide, please. This is a slightly different cut at the results. It shows value of ecosystem service across many different ecosystem services. By far the largest values are carbon storage at 40 billion, recreation at 2 billion, waste treatment at 4 billion, water quality at 38, and water regulation at 10 billion. Next slide, please.
27:53 It's important to note that ecosystem services are not distributed evenly. They're tied to the associated land covers. So this map gives you some indication of where you might find some of the value. The coniferous forests range throughout the study area, whereas a shrubland might be more in the northern area and desert shrub might be more in the southern regions. And there's also a small amount of wetlands that provide pretty significant benefits. Next slide, please.
28:21 So having identified the value of ecosystem services within the region, we assess the climate vulnerability. We examine how ecosystem services are at risk from a variety of climate hazards that were presented earlier. We identified the potential losses of ecosystem services based on projected climate change in terms of, say, precipitation or snowpack loss. A couple of examples are on the next slide. So talking about precipitation and snowpack losses, we looked at drought vulnerability as one of the hazards.
28:54 This includes various water limitations, snow-related recreation. So we estimated that roughly 19 billion to 114 billion in annual ecosystem services are at risk from drought, and this includes stress on ecosystem services from periods of, say, low rainfall or precipitation. Because of the importance of tourism in the region, we also examined ski resort revenue losses and found that up to 75% of revenues are at risk as a result of potential snowpack losses.
29:25 Next slide, please. Another important hazard is wildfire. So for wildfire, there's potential increases in frequency and intensity as a result of climate changes. And we know that wildfire can be destructive to ecosystems and disruptive to recreation activities. It's estimated that an average of 79,000 acres were burned annually within the study area in the last five years, resulting in damages from 423 million to approximately 1.9 billion.
29:54 Across the entire study area, we estimate that between 40 and 163 billion in ecosystem services are at risk from large wildfires. And when these ecosystem services are damaged, it takes a while for them to recover, as they don't immediately bounce back. There are lingering effects such as drops in tourism, as well as increases in erosion and landslides. And these impacts often have to be offset by expensive remediation strategies. And now I'll turn the presentation over to Aaron.
30:26 Thanks, David. Well, we've gone through and talked about how we've looked at this from a macro level, but what we know about change and what we know about how we address climate adaptation for it to be meaningful to our communities, we know that that actually has to happen at a more fine-grained level. And through the process, the SRTI project,
30:54 also conducted a whole series of outreach and engagement, and they identified a whole series of projects that went through an evaluation process. And one of the things that was recognized early on is that a lot of these projects may show a high degree of benefit and address many of the needs for users throughout the project study area.
31:23 But we need to connect it to climate resilience and we need to figure out a way to make sure that we can start to prioritize where we want to invest. So next slide, please. And so with that, it was recognized that there was some needs for additional scoring criteria and that we needed to make sure that the vulnerabilities that were identified through the climate vulnerability assessment
31:51 As well as the ecosystem services need to be accounted for in addition to much of the criteria that was developed as part of the SRTI process. One of the key aspects to this is how do we identify not only potential funding sources but priorities where funding may be available and what do we do to ensure that projects moving forward
32:19 are able to advance goals, whether they be at the local community level, state level, or at the federal level. Next slide, please. And so, as part of this process, we worked closely with the entire team in starting to develop a way to expand the scoring criteria and integrate a lot of the information and questions that we anticipate any time you embark on a project like this.
32:49 And so one of the things we were able to create is a framework that allows you to understand how do projects connect to the federal, state, and local level, whether or not those projects may address existing infrastructure that's currently in place versus developing or constructing new infrastructure. And what are going to be some of the
33:14 vulnerabilities, whether they be specific hazards or critical or vulnerable populations based on the climate adaptation vulnerability assessment that may be addressed as part of a proposed project. Next slide. And so through this, we also wanted to make sure we're connecting the dots as far as what resilience features could be incorporated or already proposed as part of a potential project.
33:43 How do we connect it to the ecosystem service benefits as David had described? Making sure that there's always this understanding as to whether or not the project has recreation opportunities or is reinforcing the CalREC vision. And again, critically, where does it fall in the funding spectrum? And are there ways to connect it to other funding opportunities outside of
34:12 the sources that we typically look at, one of which critically being the FEMA mitigation grant funding sources that the county's hazard mitigation plan provides access to. And so with that, not only was this criteria and this tool created that is
34:33 Hopefully wrapping a nice bow around many of the different facets of this project into a decision making structure. But we also identified the need for a number of hypercritical projects that will help the SRTI focus on the next steps moving forward and starting to see these projects actually turn into reality. Next slide. And so
35:02 One of the things that came out of this process were five key recommendations, first of which is the SRTI climate funding ready projects. And so out of the nearly 200 projects that were identified through the process, 65 of those were earmarked that as soon as funding becomes available and is ready, these projects could be implemented in the next one to five years.
35:31 These include things like fuel reduction projects, mapping of evacuation routes and constraints, upgrades to recreation areas, and trail and bike improvements. But what we recognized with a project this complex and with so many partners is that to really see implementation successful.
35:53 It really starts with understanding everything that you have to work with. And so the second project recommendation was what is the SRTI climate asset inventory. And this is where, as one of the first things initiatives, it's identifying and developing a comprehensive asset inventory that includes all stakeholders within the project area so that as new projects are developed,
36:21 It's understood where they fit. Do they currently exist? Is that existing infrastructure or is it new infrastructure that is proposed? And so this is really a way for the SRTI to understand everything that it currently has to work with and whether or not you're going to move forward with expansion or enhancement of existing assets versus new assets. And if we go to the next slide.
36:50 Building off of that asset inventory, the next recommended project was to undertake what's known as a gap assessment. So we have now identified what we currently have available to us and with that and an understanding of what are the demands that we anticipate for our region for this project area, there is a gap. Do we need, you know, 20% more roadways or campsites or
37:20 Other infrastructure improvements to essentially accommodate this anticipated demand. That gap needs to be assessed. And from that assessment, you would then move into what we call the Sustainable Infrastructure Master Plan recommendation. And this is where you...
37:37 start to take all of the projects and all of the anticipated improvements and put them into a plan much like a city or a county would do when it comes to capital improvements programming. And so this master plan would start to identify what infrastructure upgrades, what key projects, and also be able to organize it by who are the entities, where are the projects located, and which specific
38:06 Local, state or federal jurisdiction, etc. And then finally, the fifth recommendation was a sustainable recreation education program. And a majority of this project is really focused on education and climate adaptation. And this was really an umbrella to try to house all of the various entities and organizations that are working on educational opportunities.
38:34 And bringing them onto one hopefully master program to really help ensure that all efforts are really moving in the right direction in the same direction based on the vision and the focus and goals for the SRTI. Next slide. And with that, I will hand it back over to Eli to finish things up. All right. Thank you, Jacqueline, David, and Aaron. So that is an overview of the project.
39:04 There is much more detail in the report that's being published, Changing Climate, Vulnerability in California, Eastern Sierra. That should be available online by Friday of this week. And then there are the recommended actions and projects that Aaron talked about in his summary. Moving forward, those will be considered for funding and implementation by the SRTI and hopefully be put into effect.
39:32 So that concludes our presentation and we'd be happy to take any questions that you have. Thank you guys. It was a pretty interesting presentation. I'll throw it out to my fellow commissioners now. Does anybody have any questions? And I'll include town staff or town council as well. Any questions on the presentation? It's a lot to chew on. Sure. Please, Commissioner Chang. Let's see here. Given that I don't know any of the players here on the screen.
40:10 And I've known nothing about this particular topic in this study. I'm just going to ask some basic questions first. We, so the town chose to do this because, was that a mandate by the state that we had to do this particular study? Or what, why did we choose to?
40:41 Hire a consultant to do this work, especially that climate change has been around for a fair amount of time. What is the significance of this particular study? So I'll start on that and then maybe Christy or someone else from the team can follow up. But this was a result of a grant program that the town applied for.
41:11 with the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. So the intent is really to capture the, I guess, really to try to understand climate change from a regional perspective and the value of this from a regional perspective, the value of the area from a regional perspective. So this is not a mandate. This is not a requirement by the state. This was something that was funded by grants and it was really something proactive that we did on our
41:41 on our behalf. So, and I'm not sure if anyone from the team wants to follow up on that. Christy, please. Yep, Sandra, that's exactly right. The initiative, as Sandra mentioned at the very beginning, has four different tracks. And so this document and this information is headed towards the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership, of which the town is a partner.
42:11 And along with the other organizations that Sandra mentioned at the beginning. And then they'll take this information and apply it along with information learned during the other tracks, which included outreach for sustainable recreation project ideas from the public and an element that was determining a program for connection to our Eastern Sierra visitor.
42:37 And communication and education program for them. So all this information is going to go into the partnership. And then from that, they're going to put forward a recommended portfolio of projects that ultimately can start being implemented. So this is not anything that the town specifically needs to take any action on. But since the town kindly signed up to
43:02 accept and manage the grant on behalf of the partnership. That's why this is being presented here in this forum. Ms. Williams, who are you again? Good question. Sorry about that. I am the project manager for the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative. So the town contracted with MLTPA, who is who I work for, and we are project managing the full grant, which again is a grant from the Sierra Nevada Conservancy.
43:31 So this project was driven by MLTPA initially? It's on behalf of the entire partnership. So MLTPA is facilitating it and implementing and project managing the grant, but it is for the benefit of the region and specifically for the partners, including the counties, the Forest Service, National Park Service, and then...
43:59 Town of Mammoth Lakes and City of Bishop. So it's much broader. It's for the region. Okay. Thank you. Now that we have identified and understand the vulnerabilities that the consultants have identified, there's some of these numbers that you threw at us, one of the consultants threw at us was
44:32 $43 to $190 billion. I wasn't sure if that means that we could benefit from or that's something that was at risk. And does the final report have information that actually quantify those numbers? I can take an initial pass of that and then I'm sure David can add quite a bit of detail to that.
45:04 Those are benefits that the region is currently receiving from ecosystems in the area. So there are advantages that are currently being provided, but they are susceptible to being affected by climate change, which could cause some or all of that value to go away if those ecosystems are damaged or destroyed. David, perhaps you could add anything there. Right. So exactly what Eli said.
45:34 These are the value that's provided by healthy functioning ecosystems. For example, let's take water quality or water filtration. If the natural ecosystems are damaged, that damages this ecosystem service of, say, water filtration, there then need to be water filtration plants or other steps taken to create that ecosystem service, say,
46:04 Man-made function. So it's the value that we receive from ecosystem services in the area that would need to be replaced if the ecosystems are damaged. And that if it was damaged, the percentage you used was 75% that a particular ski resort could suffer in its total revenue?
46:31 Yep. So that's one very specific example where we looked at revenues to ski resorts. And again, the larger report sort of explains what sources we use and how that calculation is created. But there's some data that shows that for a certain percentage of snowpack losses, that's linked to a percentage in revenue losses. Have you seen in any other ski resorts that have impacted their annual revenue?
47:00 By that type of percentage? These are projected revenue losses. Okay. So they're looking into the future. And again, the report sort of outlays what time period we're thinking about here. These are not sort of immediate next year impacts. These are forward looking based on precipitation changes out to 2050 and beyond. Got it. Okay.
47:27 There was one gentleman named Aaron, I believe, one of the consultants, used the term CalREx vision. I didn't understand what CalREx vision is. Oh, sure, Mr. Chang, and Christy may be able to help assist with this a little bit, but the state of California has created what is known as the CalREx vision, and it's essentially
47:58 So that vision is really just a focus on how can
48:28 Recreation, all work together, even though it's essentially being managed by multiple different entities. Does that make sense? Yes. Thank you, Aaron. And my final question is for town councils. Is that by having this study, and even though Christy, Ms. Williams said earlier that the town, if I quote her correctly, that
48:57 We're not obligated to do to participate or to do anything with this. What is a town would like to see with this after the study being published? John, you want to take a crack at that? John Wentworth or Christy? Yeah, I can get started on that. Paul, as I'm sure you're aware, you can check in with Sandra. The town has already complied with state general plan.
49:29 Mandates to update our housing element along with the safety element. That was a mandate from the state and the town has already complied with that. I'm sure you're aware of that effort. This is a unique effort and that is a region-wide look at three California counties and I'm sure you're aware as well of things like the Regions Rise Together policies coming out of the state of California.
49:51 And as Eli mentioned at the beginning of the presentation, the state of California is now very aggressively pursuing nature-based solutions to advance the challenges of climate change in the state of California. And this means that the state is now actively coming out into world parts of the state, full geography of the state, to identify where can they find solutions for carbon sequestration and for the ravages of climate change. And as was mentioned at the beginning of the presentation.
50:20 This is a potentially a replicable model that could be reproduced by the state for regions across the rest of the state to get a true inventory of the natural ecosystem assets that exist in the state so the state can deploy nature-based solutions to mitigate and fight the effects of climate change. Christy, did you want to add anything on that? Well, it's not going to be better than that answer, but from a very detailed and project management perspective, this is a deliverable of the grant.
50:49 that the town is the signatory on. So that is an element as well, that this checks a box that we have provided this deliverable for the grant. And then again, the grant continues to say that this information will be used by the partnership in making decisions that will affect the final portfolio projects that come out of this. Paul, this is Dan Holler.
51:16 As Christy just mentioned, where all of these come together is the different tracks and stuff as it pulls together. The goal here is how do we end up with, as referenced, kind of those portfolio projects, but really drilling that down, do we end up with a, you know, 6, 8, 10, 12 projects that actually can be implemented across our region that impact these things positively in terms of climate change, in terms of our recreational climate, our tourism-based economy, and that are funded.
51:45 And so the idea would be to come out of this with actually things that are on the ground, doable, fundable, either from additional Prop 68 grant funds, some other revenue sources to be identified through that process as well, whether that's regional partnerships, putting those together, or more focused into a particular forest or a particular community. So the end game of this would be that we end up with a number of projects, but narrow that down to a small number that are actually the next couple of years.
52:13 Very achievable and implorable, i.e., they can be funded and go through those processes. So it's, you know, big picture stuff, really a lot of, you know, kind of exciting things looking out multiple years, decades is noted. But bringing that back down ultimately is those small steps that we need to take on the ground to enhance both, you know, our climate reduced.
52:40 It impacts potentially the climate change in the region as well as beyond, but resulting in on the ground implementations that enhance our community's viability and taking these things into consideration, help drive those types of projects that make it to, if you will, to the top of that list and the funding sources. So very practical at the end of the day as we come out of the end of the grant process. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Commissioner Chang, any other questions? No, this time.
53:11 Thank you. Commissioner Burroughs, any questions? No? Commissioner Kennedy, Commissioner Eckert, you're muted, Greg. Okay, I just had one clarification, I guess it would be. So the numbers, first, they have a huge range, but are these actual income numbers or are these replacement of infrastructure numbers? In other words, is this if there's a scorched earth and we have to replace all filtration?
53:49 Climate change causes no snow, all the snow has to be snowmaking, plants have to be built, or is this actual loss of income due to these changes? So Eli, I'll jump in here right away. So it depends on what service we're talking about. So for many of the service placement costs, in terms of say water filtration or something, it would be, what is the cost that would need to be borne to
54:23 Replace that ecosystem service. For something like recreation, we did look at impacts in terms of visitor spending, so that would be direct income losses. So it's really dependent on the various ecosystem services. Thank you. I've got a couple of just really quick questions. I guess this one would probably be for Eli. Eli, you said that the final report will be made available online this Friday in two days. Will that report...
54:55 specifically identify projects that have been prioritized or listed in terms of their value to the local climate? It will identify some high-level categories of projects and then within those there are specific items that would make sense to kind of advance in the short term but it's not meant to be an end-all be-all list of total projects that could be put forward.
55:25 Sort of an initial set, if you will. Can you give us a sense, and maybe it was in the presentation, I apologize if it was, there was just a lot of numbers being thrown around in there. Can you give us a sense at how many specific projects are being called out in this final report? The report itself is calling out five different categories of project, or five kind of overarching groups of projects. Some of them are standalone efforts on their own, like the gap assessment.
55:53 or the Sustainable Infrastructure Master Plan that Aaron talked about. There is the first category of projects, which we're calling the Funding Ready Projects. Within those, that's where you have some of these more specific items. And within those, I believe there's, I think, 65 individual items that could be advanced in the next one to five years that would kind of fall under that criteria.
56:20 Got it. And not to be the kid who wants to open his Christmas presents Christmas Eve, did the Mammoth Donut Project make the list? Let me check. I don't believe that is in the initial list, but I think this is an initial recommendation, and I think there's always opportunities to kind of move things in and out based on criteria or priorities. Got it. And again, sorry, if I can...
56:56 Throw in. Please. The Mammoth Donut Project, it somewhat is already started. And so these are projects for the initiative specifically, we're looking at things that hopefully we can get started kind of right away within the next couple of years. But also it could be things in the longer term. So we've had our eye on that from the initiative perspective in watching what's going on.
57:23 We're happily watching that already starting to move forward. Thank you, Christy. And then my last question, and this could be either for Sandra Moberly or for Dan. Once these projects have been identified and once a funding source has been identified, who's going to be point on putting the two together? Is that a town staff?
57:49 initiative, or is that going to come back to this consulting team, or does that go to MLTPA? Please, Christy. Can I hog the answer, and Sandra and Dan, please feel free to weigh in. So the grant itself allows funding for that to happen with a handful of projects. So what the intention is, is that
58:13 So as the SRTI, the Sustainable Recreation and Tourism Initiative, we will be done at the end of this grant, but until then, we can help identify who may be applying for the grant and then help that organization with any data needs, mapping, analysis, anything to prepare to submit that grant application, if that makes sense. So let's say, for example, and this is just me throwing against the wall here.
58:43 Let's say there's a project that's been identified on national forest land and a funding source has been identified. Does that mean that the national forest staff is responsible for applying to the grant to fund their project? Well, it's kind of a weighted question. Remember that the projects that are going to advance through the initiative
59:07 will be discussed and agreed upon by all the partners and that includes the National Forest, the Inyo National Forest and representatives of the parts of Humboldt-Toyabe National Forest that are within our region and so it could totally depend on what the project is. Like if it's an educational campaign that is going to be implemented on Inyo National Forest land, like somebody else maybe could own that and implement that.
59:36 But another organization, another partner organization, or potentially the ESCOG, will be the ones who need to apply for the next round of grants. And there's enough staffing available, staff time, to… The Sierra Nevada Conservancy has allocated that in our budget.
59:59 And so we will not be able to implement all these project ideas. And that's where the partners come in. They need to whittle it down to what we're calling this portfolio of projects. But once we know which ones that are going to advance through the initiative, then yes. If there are other projects that are, I mean, there's so many great project ideas. And if they're not going to advance through the initiative, then that's another question. Individual organizations can, you know, kind of pluck them out, but that would not be something that we have funding for.
1:00:29 Got it, Christy. So it sure sounds like there's obviously a lot of regional partnership that's going on with this study and with the projects in the next one to five years. So I guess my question is, when the final report comes out on Friday, and like Eli said, there will be a list of what they're calling shovel-ready projects for the next one to five years, will there be a point where the public can weigh in on what they think?
1:00:58 Should be prioritized of that list of shovel-ready projects? Or is that decision not being held at the community level? Is that more like town manager, town council, Mono County Board of Supervisors, et cetera, et cetera? So to be clear, to answer your question really directly, it's the partners. And so, yes, it will be a representative from each of the partner organizations.
1:01:27 who are making these decisions. However, that said, gosh, I don't remember, it might have been Jacqueline who mentioned that, maybe it was Eli, that there are almost 200 project ideas that came in from recreation stakeholders across the region. And that's what we spent a lot of time doing last year, was going out, it ended up being virtually, but going out to anybody interested throughout the region to ask them to submit project ideas.
1:01:55 Then towards the end of last year, we had some separate virtual meetings where folks could weigh in on those project ideas. So it's a little bit of a blend, but many of the projects that the PlaceWorks team evaluated came from that inventory. So for those, we have an indication of the most desirable projects from what the recreation stakeholders desire. And this just adds a layer of
1:02:24 From the climate perspective, are they desirable? So it's just more good information overall. Got it. And I'll just throw this out there as just a general comment. Once you guys have identified that list of projects that you would like to move forward when a funding source is available in the next one to five years, the shovel ready projects, like Eli said, I think it would be a very, very good idea to do a little bit of public outreach and explain the rationale.
1:02:54 What went into those decisions to prioritize those projects? I think the more public buy-in, not just partner buy-in, but public buy-in you guys can get on this would benefit all of us. Thank you for that. Absolutely. We have held some money in the budget to do exactly that and to be able to have a public meeting that will be probably not this kind of format. It might be a little more casual format.
1:03:22 And we will invite folks to come and listen. And if I may add, we had at one point, I think 60 something attendees. And I recognize a lot of those names as folks who have submitted project ideas. So it's great to see those folks paying attention here at this level now too. Thank you, Christy. I appreciate it. Any other questions for either town staff or the consulting team from the commission? Or I'll throw it out to town council as well. Has this presentation been made before town council officially?
1:03:54 This is the presentation to both Commission and Town Council, so this is the first time they've seen it as well. Got it, thank you. I don't have everyone on my screen here, it's split a little bit, so if you do want to ask a question or make a comment, please just unmute yourself. And it looks like none. So, Jamie, do we have any public comment? Karina Riggin said, when, where can we see what the 65 chosen projects are?
1:04:31 John Patzer, can you unmute yourself and give your comments? Yeah, okay. This is just on the overall study there. I'm thinking they're not looking at the big gorilla in the shadows, what we call dendrochronology. There's a climate record up in these bristlecone pines, and we have not seen a drought. We probably do. That was, what, about 700 years ago.
1:05:01 There is a 40-year drop according to the tree rings up there. And poor old Mono Lake, another one of the studies, there's tree stumps way farther down in that lake where the water essentially level was a lot lower than it was when all the DWP was diverting it. There is another one about 1,200 or 1,400 years old. Archaeology backed that up. They went from healthy hunter...
1:05:30 Collector indigenous to war injuries, malnutrition. And supposedly that study went all the way up through Alaska. The Pacific coast dried up for 40 years and then the previous one 50 years. I was just, I'm not seeing any of those, you know, maybe looking at the future, what we could deal or desalinization or what would happen with that. You know, that was just.
1:05:58 Thinking of the background here. That's it. Thank you, John. Appreciate that. Jamie, any other public comment? Pam Bold, will you unmute yourself and give your comments? Pam, we don't have you. Can't hear you. And I'd really like to hear your opinion. So are you unmuted, Pam? There we go. There we go. Please, we got you now. Yeah. Okay, great. Hi, this is Pam Bold from the High Sierra Energy Foundation. And this is great. Pam, you still there? We lost you, Pam. Okay. Am I back? Yep, you're back.
1:06:49 Okay, great, sorry. So this is Pam Boldt, the Executive Director of the High Zero Energy Foundation, and I think the work is great on adaptation and mitigation, but I'm curious if at some point the town will be taking on climate action and greenhouse gas inventories for both community and town facilities. Thank you, Pam. Jamie, any other public comment? Nope, that is all the public comment.
1:07:25 Does anybody want to reply to either John or Pam's questions? Michael, this is Christy. Can I just reply to Karina's, which was, if a lot, I see a lot of the folks that are listening are already on our email list, but if you make sure, if you can go to ESSRP.org, at the very top, there's a sign me up button.
1:07:53 And if you go to that, then you'll make sure to get the information that includes a link to the report. Again, we're hoping to get that out Friday, just putting some final touches on it, but that's where the information will be. So if folks are looking for that, they can go to the website and then click on Sign Me Up, and then they will get it right delivered to their inbox. Christy, would you do me a favor and put that URL in the chat? I'm not allowed to, but if somebody could put...
1:08:21 ESSRP.org. We do not have chat for council meetings or planning commission meetings. Rats. Thank you, Christy. Thanks. All right. Well, no further public comment, and I don't see any questions from council or commission. So thank you guys for the presentation. It was very interesting, and I look forward to seeing the final report on Friday. I think it's going to be a good read. Thank you all. With that, I'll...
1:08:53 I'll close business matter number one, and we'll move to business matter number two, which is the Town Council and Planning and Economic Commission discussion regarding strategic priorities and key objectives. And I'm not sure who is going to tee this up. Is this you, Sandra, as well, or is it Dan? I think Dan's going to tee this one up. Yeah, I'll set it up for you for the two bodies there. We wanted to come in with the Planning Commission, Economic Development Commission, and take a look at the priority work setting that's...
1:09:23 The council has been undertaking for the past month or so. A quick overview as we begin to look at this. We do have a set of draft strategic priorities and some key objectives that just was prepared coming out of a workshop on May 7th. Prior to that, we had two other additional workshops on the 9th and 16th of April, kind of helped set up the discussion points, some conversation with council members.
1:09:52 roles, responsibilities, and other elements that actually were able then to be plugged into what we'd call a strategic priorities and key objectives. And really, we've done this practice now since 2014, 16, and 17 was a little different, updated work programs, and then the more recent one was 2018. I believe the information in your packets provided a fair amount of background on that, so I won't spend a lot of time on those prior ones.
1:10:20 We did provide information on the most recent set of objectives and the strategies, their priorities, and a lot of the successes in different ways, the work that was done to implement those. I would like to touch base on kind of what this is and is not. From a practical standpoint, it does set out a group of priorities. It's not listed one, two, three, four on purpose. All of these areas become very important. They have different revenue sources.
1:10:47 It becomes restricted in different areas. It tries to incorporate a broader element of the town and its services that we provide in the work that we do. So definitely helps set guidance. It helps set kind of work programs for the town. And definitely as we have capacity, you look at these areas and go, great, here's either additional revenue or here's efforts we can undertake. And this really provides the guidance. We dive into those when we have that choice or other processes we might be looking at.
1:11:17 That really give us a direction to move in. And also as we go through projects, they're often they're looked at through the lens of these priorities. Does this line up? Does it make sense of where we're going in a number of different areas? And so what it is not is a long range strategic planning effort. It's not looking out.
1:11:38 10 or 15 or 20 years. It is more short term in its scope on purpose. It tends to be updated with council elections or changes in the environment that we're working within. This last year, it was actually interesting to go back and look what was actually accomplished given the COVID pandemic and the challenges that placed on the community and the town and on resources for that.
1:12:05 The other, starting with the last one we did, we really kind of called out the general plan vision statement from 2007. That's in that document. It's not something that is, in this process, something we would modify or change. But key elements in there do drive some of the decision points as well. And then looking at a short-term vision or kind of a reflective statement for the strategic priorities coming forward.
1:12:32 And at this point, that really reflects where we're at today. The idea there having a sustainable economic and social transition from this pandemic we've been in for the last year into a sense of recovery and what does that begin to look like. So the idea here, it sets out that there's four priorities that are currently there. This was emailed out. I'm just going to pop this up quickly. I won't leave it up for the discussion of what this begins to look like.
1:13:02 And again, it's kind of modeled after the last few of these that we have worked through. So you have this statement of these key priorities, one dealing with our availability and affordability of community housing, talking about enhancing a sustainable recreation economy with partnerships and investments, the investment in infrastructure improvements and maintenance. That's, you know, our physical plant that we work from and live in, if you will. And then really looking at the core services.
1:13:31 that the town provides as we look at how do we enhance our municipal level of services. And we identify a number of different objectives in there, some are more focused, some a little more broad, that really do help drive a lot of our work program. So the purpose of coming back to the PEDC is to take a look at these areas, reflective of that, the council can speak to some of the details as well, as well as staff.
1:13:58 Reflects a number of the work programs that have been started and continuing forward as well as some new focus areas that they're coming forward just within the last several months, if you will. But also then if there's from a EDC standpoint, if there's something that is glaringly missing or that would fall into more of the other areas potentially, good to have that discussion and that outlook from the bodies here together.
1:14:25 So that's the goal of this. It sets it out. It's a short timeframe. You're looking at 12 to 18 to 24 months and going through this process and continue to look at that. The four priorities here are very reflective. The last four, a couple of modifications in some areas, but it seemed to be strongly reflective of the work that we've been doing and the priorities that have been set through numerous different processes, whether that's from the community input, council meetings.
1:14:54 The regular workshop type work, and just the overall demands that we see coming forward as we look at the short term and long term futures, different areas and some of that even from just the past presentation as we look at a few different areas that are reflective in the current priorities and some of those objectives.
1:15:15 With that, I'll pause and I'll turn it back if council wants to speak to the process at all. We had three workshops real quick. The notes from the first couple are provided in the packet and really that leads into this kind of a statement page statement of what these priorities look like as we go forward into the next several months. Let me pause there and turn it back to Bill or Michael there, Chair. If you wouldn't mind, Dan, I'd kind of like to attack this in
1:15:46 bits and pieces. I'd like to maybe just take each of the four individually and ask if we could have a discussion on that specific one instead of just bouncing all over between the four. If that works for everyone, I'd like to maybe frame this discussion in that manner. Yeah, it's fine from a staff perspective. I'll defer to the mayor. Same way we did it in our workshop. Yeah.
1:16:11 So I'd like to just start with the first one, expand availability and affordability of community housing. So I'll throw it out to my fellow commissioners in town council. Is there anything in there that you guys think is missing or you strongly agree with or you want to make a comment on? I'll make a comment. This is Kirkstab.
1:16:37 The wait list at the Mammoth Lake Housing to get into rental units or to purchase, well, to purchase is kind of out of the question, but the wait list at Mammoth Lake Housing is 88 people that have submitted the paperwork and everything else and trying to get into some of the rental units that are available out there. Also, there is a lot of people that are commuting to Bishop more so than
1:17:05 Before, these are workers that are permanent, you know, have permanent jobs within the community. So these are just some observations that I've made from, you know, being involved with Mammoth Lake Housing. Thank you. Appreciate that. That's good data. Commissioner Kennedy? I don't have much to add to this one in particular, but I guess the one thing that I kind of wondered about
1:17:44 when I was looking at these strategic priorities is kind of the economic development side of the PEDC and our work as a community and I think it's touched on in the other categories too but my immediate thought with affordable housing was that there's the affordable housing stock issue but also the fact that we have low kind of service industry wages for a lot of people so I guess I just wonder if that
1:18:12 It gets conveyed well enough through this, but it probably does. I think it's the infrastructure and the broadband and all the things that we've talked about, but that was the one thing that stood out in terms of housing was it's I think there's probably some middle ground where wages need to come up to in addition to getting more housing stock and more affordable housing. Thank you, Commissioner Kennedy. Commissioner Burroughs, do you have any questions on community housing? The first of our strategic priority blocks. Please, Commissioner Burroughs, you're muted.
1:18:58 Sorry, it went to the small screen for me and I couldn't find the mute button. I just would like to keep emphasizing how important it is to move along the parcel and I know that we have several phases and whatnot, but to ensure that it continues to be a priority and we reevaluate it in each phase what is needed because I'm sure as soon as the first phase is going to be built that we're going to
1:19:25 identify things that we didn't think of before. And I want to make sure that as town council, that town council sets aside enough money to continue building the parcel in an expeditious manner because it is a need and it needs to be a priority. So that's my opinion on that. And a very good one. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Commissioner Chang?
1:19:56 Any comments or thoughts or questions for the community housing segment? I appreciate the priorities listed in here. I'm curious as to is there a time schedule on this or is this simply just that this will continue until the next time the town council decide to have a
1:20:27 Priority session again. If I might respond to that, I think the goal is to, by 2023, is to have 81 units that are available. And so that'll be the first phase of the parcel. And Paul, this is intended as a short-term plan. This will be our priorities in effect unless it is changed in the interim.
1:20:58 Until we go through this process again, which I would expect to be about this point in time in 23, after the elections and that council is seated. I would expect that after each election, giving a fair amount of time for the new members to get up to speed, that the town would continue to do these priority setting exercises. So I just wanted for clarification, Bill, you said that it's...
1:21:31 This is a short-term priorities and through you think it's approximately June or May of 2023. Am I correct? Right. That's when I would expect the next council to look at the progress made. So if you read through your packet, I think what Dan said he gave to you, you will see the progress that was made on the previous set. And then...
1:22:00 Those were reexamined and reset as these current goals and objectives. Thank you. That's all I have. Commissioner Eckert, any questions on the community housing portion of this? Yeah, I had one for, actually it's for Kirk, I suppose, just to clarify his stat there, about 88 people signed up waiting. Do we know where those people are now? Where are they living now? Is there any breakdown of that?
1:22:36 Yeah, that's a good question. You know, some of them are commuting to bishops and some of them are, shall we say, overcrowding in some of the units that exist, two families in a two-bedroom. You know, those are the, that's the reality out there. Okay. Back to Commissioner Kennedy's comment, and it kind of ties in with Jen's also, I'd like to see us
1:23:09 And maybe it is coming up on the later sections, but we've spent, or there is a potential for high-speed internet to more of Mammoth. It's in the ground, it's just not tied into very many places. And to her comment about the lower wages due to the service economy, I think that one of our priorities ought to be to diversify away from that service economy.
1:23:38 and try and do whatever we can to make that high-speed internet more available to try and get some jobs up here that are more telecommuting or design or non-recreational type jobs that will pay a higher living wage as opposed to wages that do end up with two families in a two-bedroom. And to Jen's comment, we...
1:24:07 Keep room in the shady rest parcel plan so that hopefully if that does become a reality instead of just a pipe dream, some of those units get tailored to more that type of family unit. Thank you, Commissioner Eckert. I think we're going to jump into internet and broadband in either the third one or the fourth one in our conversation here, but I'll definitely circle back to that. It's a very valid point. I've got to
1:24:41 A bit of an axe to grind on that same topic. Hey, Kirk, quick question. The 88 people on the wait list, is that a historical high, you know, by chance? No.
1:24:55 It fluctuates, not quickly, but, you know, over the years, you know, it's been as low as in the 60s, but for the last year, two years, I mean, it's been at the 80s simply because we haven't had new units constructed or new projects constructed. Thank you. And this, I've got a quick question on bullet number three.
1:25:24 In the community housing, it's identify and pursue sustainable funding source or sources for community housing. Would that be a part of the responsibilities of town staff, Sandra or Dan, or who takes ownership of that? Well, you're going back decades because 1% of the TOT was not.
1:25:50 Not a two-thirds vote, but less than a two-thirds vote, was to be committed to housing. And then, of course, the airport litigation, everything. The town is using some of that 1% for the purchase of, you know, the parcel and everything else. So Mammoth Lakes housing budget has been substantially...
1:26:13 reduced as far as providing their level of service. So they're monitoring the units, making sure that the deed restrictions are followed and everything else.
1:26:26 Mammoth Lake Housing is supporting, but we have two different paths. One is maintaining the units that we have, and the other is the development of the parcel. And the town has taken the lead on the development of parcel and, you know, has to look back at the budget and look back at some political commitments, which were...
1:26:47 You know, decades ago, that some of the 1% of the TOT would be used for housing, which if you look at the history of what's happened in the purchase of the parcel and everything else, the town has maintained that political commitment. Michael, I'd like to add to that, that I believe this bullet point comes primarily from the original housing action plan.
1:27:14 where it was identified that we should either pass a tax specifically for housing or look at EIFDs or a lot of other functions to, whether it's a sales tax, whether it's a, but in that action plan was the verbiage for us to look at funding, sustainable funding for housing. Yeah, I just added that, Michael, I'm going to assume
1:27:40 That all the members of the PEDC are well-versed in the Community Housing Action Plan. You know what's in it. You know what we're doing. That's the guiding document that we're all using. So as the mayor just pointed out, that's what that specific reference is all about. Got it. Perhaps my question wasn't as clear as I wanted it to be. Let me restate it.
1:28:03 The 20 plus million dollar grant the town received to build out the infrastructure at the parcel, was the application for that grant created by town staff? Yes. So going forward, Sandra, it would still be the responsibility of town staff if additional grants become available, whether it's federal or state or whatever the source is.
1:28:28 Yes, certainly. So we're kind of always looking for grant opportunities. And so typically, if we're going to apply for a grant, we do need to take it to council to get their blessing to apply for the grant. But we are looking, we are applying. That $20 million infrastructure grant was actually applied. We applied with Pacific, our development partner. So it's a joint application and joint award. But we do, we are constantly looking for grant opportunities.
1:28:58 Hey, Sandra, and not to get too deep into the weeds here, but what is the process to be constantly looking for grants? Is there like a grant webpage? Are you getting a grant newsletter? Like, just really quickly walk us through that.
1:29:17 There's a lot of different ways that we find out about grants. So most of us are on email lists from the state. Housing and community development is where most of the grants come from for the state. So we're all, a lot of us here in the office are on their email lists. So we see them through that way. A lot of the other grants are just on a cyclical basis, like CDBG, HOME, those grants are kind of out every, we know the grant cycle for those types of, so we're
1:29:45 So we're keeping an eye on the next cycle of those types of grants. The infrastructure grant that we received, it was really, part of it was due to a partnership that we had with the Institute for Local Government. We were aware of the grant. We weren't heavily pursuing it, but we had our monthly meeting with our team with the ILG, and they really encouraged us to submit for that.
1:30:12 It really, it clearly worked out. We got the, we got the grant. So it's just a broad range of different ways that we find them, but we're all kind of always looking for grants. We don't have one person that's just a grant person. We're all responsible for that. Got it. Thank you. I just want to add one thing on that, Michael. These grants come with very specific constraints. They're not designed for alpine mountain communities like ours in remote rural areas. They are not good fits.
1:30:41 So if we want to start to address, say, the missing middle housing crisis in this community, that goes back to what's in the Community Housing Action Plan, the need for the community to generate its own specific sustainable source of revenue to be able to do that. And if we're not careful, and again, I'm assuming Sandra's sharing all type of information with you guys, we are going to do nothing more than exacerbate income disparities and income inequality in this community.
1:31:07 Because the only grants we're going to get are going to be for 60% or 80% and lower of AMI. And then we've got a housing situation for, you know, single family residential that's gone up 80% in the last year. So the only way to address that missing middle, which is very well spelled out in the Community Housing Action Plan, we as a community are going to have to come up with our own source of funding to help that out. It's a question for the voters, the mayor referred to it, but I just want to make sure we keep that in mind. The grants...
1:31:35 Are very much of a double-edged sword for us in a community like this. Got it. Thank you for that clarification. Any other questions or comments or opinions on the community housing portion of this objective statement? All right, then we'll move into number two, which is enhance a sustainable recreation economy with partnerships and investment. So I hate to pick on you, Commissioner Kennedy, but I'll pick on you. Do you have any questions or comments or opinions on this portion of the document?
1:32:10 Are we on the through amenity investment, that one? No, number two, it's enhance a sustainable recreation economy with partnerships and investment. And I'm on the wrong document, then come back to me. Okay. Commissioner Burroughs? I'm pulling it up too. Let me, just give me a second. No worries. Commissioner Chang? You know, as I go through this particular list here,
1:32:51 I have to tell you that I am not familiar with and particularly the first one and the history behind it and that we have been in a tourism town, recreational town for so long that suddenly why are we establishing and staff this particular entity or department if you want to call it?
1:33:27 Office of Outdoor Recreation is what it's being called out as. Right. So I guess I'm a little confused. Is Dan, do you want to handle that one or does someone from town council? Certainly take a stab at it if Dan doesn't want to jump right in. Either way, thanks. This meets a lot of the things we've been talking about this for a long time. The need to have someone to coordinate.
1:33:59 All things recreation outside of just municipal. Right now, even our trails supervisor, Joel and Matt Perullo all answer directly to Dan. As you all know, Dan's basket, his end basket is pretty full. So this would be the person that all of those entities would directly relate to and then he would go back to Dan. That includes NGOs like MLR.
1:34:30 This would help with all the Forest Service projects and how do we move forward with all of those things. It is to me a hugely important position that has been missing for quite a while. You're right, we're a tourism-based town, but I screamed at both supervisors prior to incorporation and the council sent them that we need to deal with more than just municipal recreation. Our income is tied to
1:35:00 All things recreation outside of municipal. So I just view this as a very important office. And I'll just add in, as Mr. Vanderhurst mentioned on the donut project, I'm assuming, again, the PEDC is aware of the 50,000 acre proposed fuels reduction project that will completely surround the town of Mammoth Lakes. We don't have, as the town, the capacity to engage with a project like that.
1:35:29 As the mayor said, without it going directly to the town manager. We need staff, we need capacity to engage with these types of opportunities. You know, only, what is it, 25% of the incorporated land mass of the town is on private property. The rest of it is owned and managed by the federal government. And frankly, we're just starting to get overwhelmed by the needs, whether it's fire, fuels, recreation opportunities, all the rest of it. We're getting overwhelmed. We're going to need some dedicated staff.
1:35:56 Support to help with that. This goes back to the Chief Recreation Officer, which you may remember about a year ago, the Council, like, I think Bill was right before COVID, right when COVID was starting to get started. We identified that need about over a year ago, so this is kind of the formalization of that. Can I make a quick question to either Councilman Wentworth or Mayor Souser? Mayor Souser, you mentioned MLR. Maybe you can just walk the Commission through how you envision
1:36:25 The working relationship between this future town department, the Office of Outdoor Recreation and MLR. How do they complement each other and where do they overlap? Well, MLR was sort of formed to be all things outside of municipal recreation. And from my perspective anyway, it went a little sideways in achieving that. So one of the things I'd like to see is to have it tied a little closer to the town, the town structures and the town priorities.
1:36:56 So by having this person work directly with that board on a certain level on a certain amount of time, it sort of brings us all into the same meeting room, if you will. I got a question for that with that comment from Bill, may I? Please. So Bill, are you saying that MLR is a silo all on its own that we really need
1:37:31 Someone else to be the go-between the town and the MLR? And if that's the case, why do we even have MLR in the first place? I mean, not in the first place, but why will we continue to have MLR? Well, there is a need. I'm hearing this correctly. I'm a little confused. Yeah. There is a need for a nonprofit working with the town for...
1:38:02 like the Prop 68 funding and several other things. So there is a need for that. I don't want to establish a whole new, and I'm speaking for myself because we haven't made these decisions as a council yet. We are in negotiations with MLR for their new contract. So I see a need to more closely align the two organizations. So we're sort of going down the same road. And my personal
1:38:31 position has been that we have not necessarily done that in the past. So we know we don't need to replace them, we just need to tie them closer to us. And that method of oversight, Bill, would be having whoever is leading this department sitting on the MLR board? They wouldn't sit on the MLR board, they would sort of act as a, I don't know how to put it, Dan puts it better than I do, a part-time
1:39:04 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:39:34 Just the town to some degree there, MLR is relatively restricted at this point because of the funding structure tied to the dedicated tax measures looking at measure R primarily there. And so as we begin to look out, one of the questions for MLR is how do they get some additional funding? How do they look beyond just the town boundary and the town requirements to be able to be able to work together in looking at those and where do we want them engaged and where does the town engagement go?
1:40:03 And a lot more coordination than what we have today. As you look at the fire issues, you look at the fuel issues in the forest, you look at some of the need to upgrade campgrounds and access points and trails, they definitely have a role in those areas, but again, that coordination often between multiple parties is lacking, and this would allow us to really step into a lot of that space.
1:40:27 Provide that I think a better coordination with the Forest Service, who frankly wants to deal government to government, not government to nonprofit, if you will, or they also deal government, you know, federal government to the large agencies that have legal standing like Southern California Edison and their energy generations off of creeks and things of that nature.
1:40:49 So they have a lot of different pressures on them. To be able to have that role of a government-to-government relationship consistently out there, I think will improve what we're getting out of our trails coordinator, Joel Rathje, in the management of our trail system. The types of MOUs and ongoing operating plans that Matt Perlow has been really key in to be able to do that. Then having that nonprofit be able to step in behind that and a lot of the donations from people and engagement of individual residents and groups.
1:41:17 is a really powerful tool, you know, it's kind of like you see that with the trash cleanups, we see that in other areas, but that nonprofit coordination as it moves into that has some real asset and value to be able to leverage that community capital that we have, but really being able also to help focus that so it's not just a one-off, it becomes an ongoing effort in how we begin to engage in those areas.
1:41:41 And again, but having that Forest Service level buy-in in particular, but you can take that to BLM, you can take it to the National Park Service, LA, frankly, Department of Power and Water, and then across coordination with Mono County and beyond as we look at these areas. So I think when we start to look at the totality of that, the whole outdoor recreation concept,
1:42:03 It's much broader than what MLR is currently able to handle or focus on. It's definitely, you know, stressing the town's staff capabilities to be out there and be engaged in things on a regular basis. You know, you think of the upcoming development projects just by Altera, the main lodge type redevelopment plan that has all kinds of elements in it besides just town codes.
1:42:29 Development Standards and stuff, but it actually is integrated into the forest and fire threat. It's integrated into access and trails. The roadway runs through it, if you will, Highway 203. What does that mean for access to Red's Meadow? What does that mean to access our trail systems? And a much broader element there that we really don't have somebody on point really engaging at that level of activity. And so this would allow us to be able to do that in a much more effective way.
1:42:58 In terms of that focused effort and being able to walk through those types of hurdles, if you will, and just knowledge with the Forest Service, you know, the whole NEPA process that they have to go through and other steps and factors that play into this. So I think it really sets up a department structure, if you will, in the town to be able to do that, be able to have the nonprofit helping, like Sandra's office dealing with MLH or financially and other things dealing with MLT.
1:43:26 Again, not standalone efforts out there, but they need to be coordinated across those various elements as we see things go and how we leverage financial resources as well as staff resources. Thank you for that answer, by the way. Would you mind just giving us a super quick summary on what your ideal time frame is on establishing this new department? Have you got it built into the 2021-22 budget? Yeah.
1:43:54 Currently it is, that'll be going to council next week for that level of discussion, beginning to look at that, it's really a one person additional, and then court holding in the existing personnel that we have working in this area, relationships with parks and rec and some of the overlap there, then also looking with the nonprofit, the relationship there as well. So it will be going through this year's budget process to be effective next year.
1:44:22 Frankly, the recruitment process and finalizing that will take a little more time, but hopefully it could be as early as mid-summer to late-summer having it up and running fully. Got it. Again, pending final approval. Commissioner Chang, did you have any more questions on just that portion of this document, the Office of Outdoor Recreation? I do, and I don't want to take so much time on it, and I'm not expecting an answer, a question and a statement.
1:44:52 And please forgive my question on this, given that I don't know these entities really well, the inner circles and the inner working of these entities. It sounds to me that if MLR is a silo entity and town is having difficulty working with them, that's why they want to establish a separate department for this.
1:45:22 And when I looked at, when I think of MLR and MLTPA, I mean, MLTP, I think that's what it's called. There's a lot of interconnectivity, you know, of these entities. And if, is town having issue with MLTPA with that as well? Or if they don't, why would there be such a...
1:45:54 Yeah. Difficulty, you know, and why would you want to continue to work with MLR? Anyways, I mean, these are just comments and questions that, you know, I'm sure there's a lot of inner workings behind it. Yeah, just a real quick one on that. Some of the distinctives with MLR, MLH, and MLT, the tourism, housing, and recreation.
1:46:25 And then as a joint powers authority, we have ESTA as a separate agency. Each of those were created by the town. They were set up and structured under town authorities. We provide a direct contract of financial support. We provide a we actually appoint a member to serve on those boards. And they actually take on functions of local government. There are certain delegations of authority to them that we've done.
1:46:51 That create a unique relationship, a contractual relationship that is different than an independent agency out there, like the presentation research and place works. We have a contract with them to deliver a particular product and scope of work. MLTPA falls in that type of category. They're an independent nonprofit. They have some projects and stuff they're running on their own. They're out there doing different things in the region or with individual other agencies.
1:47:21 And the town also has a contract with them. We have a very, very focused set contract, set of deliverables, fixed dollar amount. And then, but they, we don't have, we did not create them as a town. They are, they do not have a town council member appointed by the town council to serve on their boards. We don't, we have not delegated to them town authorities. So there is that differential in the structures out there.
1:47:48 You know, we work with a number of different agencies and different elements as we work through a lot of these things to make that happen. I think the relationship here is that uniqueness between a town-created nonprofit and then the relationship there. They do have an independent board and they can definitely pursue some things independent of the town, no different than Mammoth Lakes Housing, who has contracts with Mono County and the City of Bishop, for example, and actually one with the state for delivering certain services.
1:48:15 But we also have an arrangement with them in terms of how we fund them and the other elements that create them as a requirement under government code. Basically, they serve as legislative bodies because of delegation of authority that we've done there. So there's some uniquenesses in those relationships. I think with the three NGOs that we actually call the non-governmental organizations,
1:48:39 There's a much stronger relationship and oversight by the town. They are primarily funded by direct allocations of town dollars and government funding, if you will. MLT, we have the X amount of dollars we put in there directly from the town and also the assessments through the tourism business improvement district. So there's a number of different agencies of that structure and the relationship we have there is different than with either a
1:49:07 Non-profit providing something or a for-profit firm that we contract with for services. And as we work with our NGOs, that relationship and how we work together become critical as a contractual relationship, as well as delegated authority, funding, and having an appointed council member serving by the pleasure of the council on those various boards. So there's some uniquenesses in the elements there. Thanks, Dan.
1:49:37 Can I move on to the next bullet on this one? Michael, I thought Jennifer had her hand up a minute ago. My apologies, Jennifer, I can't see everyone. Would you like me to stop sharing my screen or is it helpful to have this up here? Because you can see each other or you can see the... I've got a printout so you don't have to have it for me. I have the right one pulled up now too. I have the right one pulled up now too. Okay, I'll stop sharing.
1:50:08 Thank you for that. I had a question about the MLR since we brought that up. And I totally admit I have ignorance as far as MLR goes, but I seem to know what tourism is doing all the time. And I know what Planning Commission is doing all the time. And I know
1:50:29 And I'm pretty familiar with what housing is doing, but I don't have a clue as to what MLR is doing. I don't know if they're meeting any outcomes. I don't know what their outcomes are. And so I'm wondering if this new position is going to provide some regulatory oversight for them and to help disseminate what their outcomes are, if there are any. It just seems that...
1:50:57 That you don't hear a lot about them. And I think that it would be beneficial for our community to understand what they do and how they are benefiting the community. And I would like to see more of that. If I might respond, Jennifer, you know, you need to ask for the deliverables. What have they, what have they delivered, you know, given the contract?
1:51:23 And so what deliverables are in the contract and have they achieved those deliverables? Thank you. Well, have they? That's a good question. That's what I would like to know. Jennifer, if you would like to speak with me outside of this meeting, feel free to call me anytime. And we can have a long discussion on my opinion of our NGO. But I don't want to get too deep into that here today for sake of all of our time.
1:51:56 Okay. And Paul, same with you. I'd love to have a conversation with you on our NGOs as well. Thank you. And just one thing to add to this, I think what the council's trying to do is we're really trying to find a way to strike the balance between marketing, visitation, and the viability of our destination. And I think that the town has a role to play to make sure that what's happening on the ground...
1:52:24 We're not compromising and overwhelming and destroying the natural resources in the place that make this destination successful. And we can't effectively engage and direct MLT through their contract if we are not taking a degree of responsibility with what's happening on the ground. And Dan mentioned a very important thing, which is the federal agencies, whether it's the Forest Service or the Park Service, they want to have a peer-to-peer relationship with the town.
1:52:52 They want to be dealing with a specific identified staff person who is an employee of the town of Mammoth Lakes. It's the same way with Joel Rathje. Joel Rathje is not an employee of a nonprofit or an NGO. He is a town staff person. And I think the needs that we've got with this federal landscape that's all around us, we need to have a designated known point of contact for these federal agencies to engage with the town.
1:53:21 And that's part of this larger trying to get this balance over tourism, too much tourism, what's the right balance, all the rest of it. I think a lot of you are aware of what the chamber's doing with the pricing ideas they're starting to talk about with logic and that kind of stuff. This is all part of that same conversation. And I think, again, I'm just one council member, but we need to have a dedicated, specific person who's engaging with these federal agencies.
1:53:49 So as the mayor said, it doesn't all just land on Dan's desk. With the town manager, I don't want to call it Dan personally, but it's one of those things that can quickly overwhelm. And this goes to snow storage, it goes to fire, it goes to fuels, it goes to visitation, it goes to recreation, it goes to all of it. We are a unique town. There's no other town in the country that's got three quarters of its land, its incorporated land mass is federal public lands. There's no one else in the country like us. So it's a particular and specific kind of need.
1:54:17 You're talking about municipal street credit. Yeah. I mean, it's, you know, yeah. Commissioner Kennedy, did you have any comments or opinions or questions? I just think it's a brilliant idea to have a point person like that and to not just sit around waiting for these public land agencies who are chronically and forever underfunded to fix our problems. I wish they could and I wish they would, but I think it's a brilliant idea.
1:54:46 Don't have any thoughts on the MLR thing. I do think it sounds a little bit redundant, but I think this is a great idea. So I hope it can go fast and efficiently. So I think that'll be great. Thanks for that idea. Commissioner Eckert, any questions on the MLR Office of Outdoor Recreation or anything within the Enhanced Sustainable Recreation Economy portion of this? Unfortunately, my phone bounced out, so I missed a lot of it.
1:55:17 There was the first item that we talked about or that came up on the list had something to the effect of promote joint recreational projects, investments, whatever. And, you know, at risk of beating a dead horse, I'd like to add one word in there and that would be non. We have a very good recreational economy. It's never going to change. We will always be a recreational economy.
1:55:48 Standard sustainable economy needs to be diversified and our recreational economy I think has the ability to draw private funds and projects better than most municipalities do but virtually all municipalities have some sort of economic officer who draws in new business to sustain them in a
1:56:18 Or at least to get them started in whatever venture they may come up with. And I'd really like to see us focus, not focus, but at least diversify into some non-recreational promotion as well as just, you know, fattening up the grill in the room. Okay. Hey, Dan, I've got a question on bullet number two in this little portion of the document.
1:56:48 The enhanced public recreational and community service experience through focused destination management strategies. Does the destination management strategies include the creation of a destination management plan? It can, yes. We started down that road before the pandemic to look at that. There's a number of different strategies that are already out there. You look at the community trail host program.
1:57:17 We look at some of the partnerships we have already for management of trash and people and restrooms and everything else with the Forest Service. There's a number of different things in that that some are very granular, others that are broad. If you talk about the destination management plan, those can be out there, they can be relatively narrowly focused, or we could actually go spend two or three hundred thousand dollars to develop one. So we've done a little bit of work with that early on, about a year ago and over a year ago.
1:57:46 To begin to look at that, I think those strategies start to come into play of who's your audience, who's your visitor, discussions of that nature. I think there's some caution in how far you go with that. Are you just a high-end playground versus a diversified community? Those types of elements. So there's a lot of elements that fall into that. As we made this broad on purpose, because of the things we're doing in those areas, you could end up to a long-term plan still in that process.
1:58:16 But the initial thought has been really what are we doing near term versus long term, but that definitely could play into that. Thank you, Dan. I tell you, Michael, a lot of these things go into not, Greg was talking about, you know, fattening the pig, if you will, in terms of tourism. But most of these things currently are going into managing the tourism rather than just inciting the tourism and getting them to come here.
1:58:44 Even in the power lunch from the chamber earlier this week, Carl Roboto, one of their people on the call, suggested that we are moving from advertising to get people here to doing things to manage them once they are here. So a lot of this goes to that purpose, to manage the numbers that we're going to get, to spread them out, to work with them to create a good environment for all of us.
1:59:16 Got it. I'd actually would love to hear, I've got a quick question I'm going to soft toss out to the entire town council and I'd love to, if anybody has any thoughts or opinions on it, I'd love to hear it. So this Office of Outdoor Recreation, it seems to me that if we did create a destination management plan, that that would be the Bible or the backbone of that office.
1:59:43 Here's what we want to get done in one year. Here's what we want to get done in three years. Here's what we want to get done in five years. You know, more restrooms in the lake space and more garbage receptacles, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera. I just would love to know how you guys see those two tied together. Please, John. Michael, it's not just that management plan would not just be for this Office of Natural Recreation. It would also be for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, right? So that we start connecting the dots of these capacities.
2:00:11 We break down the silos so that the system, the entire ecosystem can work efficiently. So the desk, but we, because we don't have this office of outdoor recreation, we don't have any capacity on that side of the house. We got to get that in place. Once that's in place and set up, then doing a destination management plan starts to make sense because then we can say, MLT, these are the goals. These are the things that we need you to be working on.
2:00:39 Because we know that's working in conjunction with the capacity that's dealing with what's happening on the ground, if that makes sense. It does. Any other town council opinions or comments on that? So, Dan, is it safe to assume that there are current conversations about creating a destination management plan? Not just strategies, but an actual document that will be our...
2:01:10 It's not being actually pursued at this point, but it had started about a year ago and it's been put on hold at this point and hasn't been revived, kind of re-energizes at this point. Got it. Any other questions from the Commission on this block of bullet points? Have we beat this one thoroughly? Okay. I've got a question for Dan. Please, Greg. When this plan does get resuscitated,
2:01:45 Can there be some discussion about balancing the advertising expenditure versus the quality of experience? Because it doesn't really do us a lot of long-term good to bring people who don't have the best experience they can. And I don't mean just sort of a concept, but actual, if there's a problem with X, Y, and Z, we take money from
2:02:16 Marketing and put it into X, Y, and Z as a mandate. Yeah, all those types of things to be on the table through that type of process. This last year, for example, kind of a narrower experience of that was the whole idea of the community trail and host program to have people out there. You know, it was amazing how many times they told people that our transit was free. People did not know that. And so those types of discussions at that.
2:02:45 granular level, which enhances your experience. Hey, why don't you take the bus? Well, how much does it cost? Well, it's free. Oh, really? Great. People are doing that. And MLT has stepped up and provided funding for that. They're putting, I think, $100,000, $150,000 into that program this next year to enhance exactly to that on-the-ground experience piece. So I think you're right, Greg, in terms of looking at those things and balancing that back and forth to say, how do we have a better user experience and what does that mean?
2:03:15 And how do we, if it's up to us and are under our control on the funding side, how do we do that becomes a very critical element. And where do those resources come from? Yeah, I think, you know, that would definitely be a discussion, whether it's from tourism or the town general fund or other resources are definitely one of the elements to be looked at. Thanks, Dan. I'm going to move it in the hope of having us finish this meeting up by five.
2:03:47 I'm going to move it on to the next series of bullets, investment in infrastructure, improvements and maintenance. And I'll throw this out now to Commissioner Chang. Do you have any questions on the four bullets that are listed in this portion of the document? Specifically with the airport, can either town manager or councils provide some perspective on this when there's all these talks about having Bishop.
2:04:20 Airport, then what is the point of having this strategic vision? Grady, I think that's you, my friend. Yep. Yeah, Grady. Yeah, I'll go ahead. There's actually a lot of value, then we can quote articles if you like, but there's an awful lot of value, an awful lot of activity, frankly, at the airport on a year-round basis. The commercial flights are actually a very, very tiny percentage of operations there.
2:04:48 There's a significant number of smaller charter flights, general aviation airport. Unfortunately, with fires becoming more and more prevalent every single year, we have more and more activity with fire. In fact, our current airport layout plan shows a future helipad area specifically for firefighting. What I'd like to do is address that on June 2nd, I believe, maybe June 16th, or our target is June 2nd, is to actually have a session with town council to go through all aspects of
2:05:17 Mammoth Yosemite Airport after commercial flights leave. In terms of passengers, I'll mention one thing, MLT is actually working very hard to increase the number of unscheduled, non-scheduled, excuse me, scheduled charter flights. We had JetSuite X before, now we're going to have advanced air, and we think through an aggressive program there, we could actually get up to 10,000 employments with just charter flights into
2:05:43 Mammoth. The advantage, of course, is then if we have issues with weather during the winter, guess what? They can divert to Bishop and find their way up the hill. So there's a lot of advantages there. So there's a lot of things in the offing there, a lot of things that will be a full workshop with town council. I encourage you to look at that staff report again, hopefully for June 2nd and a workshop and we'll be talking about funding. We'll be talking about entitlements, FAA funding, Caltrans, a regional planning effort, basic maintenance.
2:06:12 Opportunities, things like that at the airport. So if you have a specific question about the airport, love to have it. I can give you another 10 seconds on Bishop in our last meeting with FAA. They do plan on receiving flights with United Airlines in December. They think they'll actually be ready in August, but there's no reason to schedule, you know, start of flights in August or September. So MLT and MMA say are working with Inyo County to start flights.
2:06:39 to Bishop in December. The same schedule basically we had last year through United with Los Angeles, San Francisco and Denver and we'll move forward with there. We're frankly waiting to make sure that happens and then we can react very quickly to what we need to do here at Mammoth Yosemite. But again, workshop coming up and if you have a specific question, I'd be glad to try to answer it. Hey Grady, would you just explain to Commissioner Chang really, really quickly why the 10,000 employments is such a magical number?
2:07:07 Absolutely. That's a great question. Thank you, Michael. With FAA, they basically will fund development programs at an airport to the tune of $1 million a year if you have over 10,000 employments. It's a flat number. Frankly, it's not a sliding scale by any means. If you have 10,000 employments or 40,000 employments, either one, you've earned a $1 million entitlement from FAA. And by entitlement, I mean as long as you have a project that's eligible.
2:07:35 It's on your airport layout plan. You can apply to FAA for funding and they basically are required to give it to you unless they have some objection. As long as you meet environmental, you know, disclosure documentation, things like that. If you're under 10,000, number drops to, you're more of a general aviation type airport, even though we're still part 139, which is commercial flight certification.
2:07:58 But it drops to about $150,000. So that's a huge number. And that's the big reason we've been talking to MLT and MMSA about working to really encourage those scheduled charter flights to keep us at that 10,000 level. It'll mean a lot to our major maintenance and the building program for the future. So Commissioner Chang, it sounds like that workshop might be some time well spent. The one that Brady mentioned. Thank you.
2:08:29 Sorry. We actually talked, Michael, if I could just finish it with about coming to PDC, possibly on June 9th, the next meeting, we will have the EA for some work at the airport, should be ready to see you on June 9th on that, and we can work with Sandra's office and everybody to see if you'd like a presentation to follow up on the town council workshop, so. We would definitely would like that, so please, let's have that conversation.
2:08:54 Before I open it up to the rest of the commissioners, I've got a question that I want to just lob out there. This can be either answered by town council or Dan, the town manager. In this series of bullets, I don't really see any sort of a call out for a future event site. That is a necessity in this town. And I would love to have some feedback on that. Please, Councilman Wentworth.
2:09:23 One thing that I don't think is on Dan's list here, but something that the council's talked about is the reality of our reemergence from the pandemic. And I think as the mayor mentioned, this is not a long-term strategic plan. We are cautiously all emerging from what has been an historic 12, 13 months.
2:09:50 We recognize that things are going to be bumpy and disorienting along the way out. So I think larger endeavors like you're talking about, Michael, that's entirely appropriate to be talking about down the road as we get there. But we're taking, you know, we're taking tentative kind of high priority steps to get out of where we've been. But I want to make sure that the Planning Commission understands that. It's not, is that in here, Dan? We thought that was going to be the short-term vision or something.
2:10:18 Yeah, the short-term vision speaks to that transition out of pandemic to recovery. Specifically to an event center, that really comes up in that with the partnerships and investment. That is a discussion ongoing we've had with the Forest Service. It's a really heavy lift because that's not a type of facility or activity that they normally, they don't really have a permitting process to allow that. So it's a whole other process of looking at sites in that nature.
2:10:47 Most likely where we've done a lot of look historically at private sites or town owned sites within the community that are not on Forest Service property become very narrow very quickly in terms of opportunities for a true event site. So that's out there. We understand the need for some of that and some of the discussion this year and what's happening, you know, historically with the wood site, for example.
2:11:10 There are a few options out there, but without getting into the forested land, whatever we do will probably look dramatically different than what our historical type of event site has been. Got it. No offense in this statement, John, but I think events are going to be on top of us sooner than we want to realize. I mean, I don't know if you saw the e-blast that went out, but Blues is up and running, and they're selling tickets, and
2:11:39 We currently, the site that he's holding the event and has historically hold the event is owned by an individual that has got a soured relationship with the town now. So I don't know how long, how much longer that's a viable event space. So I just think this is coming quicker than any of us want to acknowledge. Like this is... We're not gonna be able to deal that with this song.
2:12:06 I mean, it's certainly something that we all know for the long term, this is something we got to deal with. I think, again, just speaking as one council member, we're looking at a list of things. Again, are we done with this thing? Maybe we're done with the pandemic, medically, maybe, but inflation, supply chain issues, all the kind of chaos we're seeing socially across the country, we've got to all get on this infirmly footing. And that...
2:12:32 Everybody, I think, is quite well aware of that relationship and the challenges with all that. But I think, again, I go back to Chief Recreation of that Office of Outdoor Recreation, you know, think of the opportunities on the federal landscape to make that happen. There is something that's not in here, but there's an opportunity to convert administrative sites, like where the Forest Service currently has their housing at the intersection of 203 and Old Mammoth Road, to convert that to housing, right? So these...
2:13:00 These are the types of things that we're pursuing in kind of the short, medium term to get back up on our feet. And then we can be in a position to start getting into these longer term, larger, more important opportunities like the one you described. Okay. So I don't want to... Please, Bill. It doesn't exist specifically on this list. It is certainly embodied in several different bullet points, partnerships and investment, as Dan suggested. It lives in here, even though it isn't called out as a specific project.
2:13:29 We all understand the need and we have pursued this for years and years. And as of yet, nobody has come up with the quality solution. So if something, if an opportunity comes up, believe me, I for one would jump on it as quick as I could. Thank you, Bill. And myself just speaking as one commissioner, not for the Planning Commission, I think it would be beneficial for it to specifically be called out in this
2:14:00 in this block of bullets. I just think it's that important. And I think it's coming back a lot quicker than we might anticipate. So I'll move off this now, get off my soapbox a bit, and I'll ask Commissioner Burroughs if she has any questions on these four bullets. Me and my mute button today is not working for me. Yeah, I do have a couple things that I'd like to address. One, the first...
2:14:33 The first bullet point, invest in pavement, roads, sidewalks. I think that it's really important that, and I have been bringing this up for a couple years now, I think that it's important to repave.
2:14:48 That road behind on Old Mammoth Road by Mammoth Rock because it is really falling apart and we have more and more tourists going through there every year and Mammoth Rock is a big destination for the track and field runners that come up here and just people in general to hike and bike on and we really need to have that road looking better. In addition, Hayes, we received some money from the local transportation
2:15:16 Commission statewide, and John knows about this, but Hayes was able to secure some money for our town in order to develop a plan to extend our multi-use paths over off Meridian.
2:15:36 And going down towards Snow Creek. And I really think that it's a priority, should be a priority to continue that path because it's a big connection for, to get to Mammoth Creek Park, to get up to the village, to get up to Lakes Basin. And I think that would be a great thing for our tourist economy as well. And I think that is all I had to add to that. And Jennifer, thanks for picking up on that.
2:16:05 To be clear, it's for planning and design. So it will get us to that and get us to the environmental work. And I think, Dan, maybe you can speak a little bit to, as Bill was just saying, there's a lot of things that are going on that are moving forward that, you know, we can't put everything on the list. But that's certainly one of the things, Jennifer. And I would point out, though, that that idea that opportunity lives under finalized
2:16:30 Mobility Master Plan, Initiate Work Program, including micro-ability, EV capacity, transit improvements, right, including integration with regional air service. That kind of thing sort of nests in with that. And that's why I think of it. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Let's see, have I picked on you yet, Commissioner Kennedy, on this one? Not yet, but I don't have any questions or comments on this one. Okay. Commissioner Eckert. Yeah, I had one clarification or question for Grady to clarify.
2:17:04 This magic 10,000 number, if, let's take last year out because it's an anomaly, but in general, our employments over the last few years, minus the flights that are scheduled to be diverted to Bishop, where in that 10,000 number would be our historical average without those flights? Well, I can address last year easily. We had about 1,200 flights.
2:17:33 from Jet Suite X in January, February and March and the other chartered flights were about another thousand. So even last year with the first three months we were at about 2,000 passengers. So I think the 10,000 is certainly something that's within reach. I don't have the number in front of me for 2019 but it was significantly more than that with certainly more Jet Suite X flights early and late in the year.
2:17:59 We can get you that number by the workshop on June 2nd or after that. But I think we think the 10,000 is certainly within reach with an aggressive campaign for scheduled charters. Do private flights such as NetJet and fractional flights, do those count as in planements or are those general aviation? Yes, they actually do. I just, in fact, prepared a summary of all that information that we got from those charters directly through Pat Foster at Hawk Creek Aviation.
2:18:27 And all those flights, even if it's five people getting off a plane at once, if we can get that charter company to report it, we can count it. And that's what we're reporting to FA for last year. I'm ready real quick to chime in the we got a preliminary number of 10,077 the other day. Thank you, Hayes. All right, so we move on to the last block here. Unless there's any other discussion or comments by Town Council, please Councilwoman Salcedo.
2:19:01 Yes, I have a comment. In hearing the Planning Commission discuss some of the issues and having questions, it calls to mind on May 7th, we had a strategic planning session. And that staff report that we had for that day, I don't know if the Planning Commission received this automatically, but on the strategic priorities and key objectives, it was really a well-done list by staff of sort of what we've accomplished this year, what we're hoping to accomplish next year. And I think that would...
2:19:27 You know, probably answer a lot of questions for the Planning Commission. Dan, can we get that to a Planning Commission so that they are party to that? Or is there something on there that we wouldn't want to necessarily have out? We did share the staff report, the larger one, I can check the smaller one that went in with the one on the 7th, but yeah, they're more than, it may have been attached, but they are more than willing to get that. We can ship that to them. That's a public document that's out there, so.
2:19:58 I think the work staff elements completed and ongoing implementation of, you know, it was just, it was really, it was really had a lot of, a lot of information and honestly, Michael, I think, you know, you and your commission would really gain a lot of information from that, so we should share that. I appreciate that and I look forward to getting that document. Thank you so much for that suggestion. Any other comments or you guys just all glass-eyed right now? Glass-eyed over. All right, last one.
2:20:31 Implication of enhanced and required municipal services. And I want to piggyback on something that Commissioner Eckert brought up earlier. And I'm not really sure if this belongs in this series of bullets or the previous series of bullets when we talked about infrastructure improvements. But I think, and you guys have heard me rant on this before, it's become incredibly obvious during this pandemic.
2:20:58 with people working remotely in schools on virtual learning that our partnership with Suddenlink is a train wreck and it's an absolute disservice to this community the approach that Suddenlink has when it comes to improving the customer service experience and improving their physical infrastructure to increase the broadband
2:21:28 Capacity within town. So I don't, like I said, I don't know exactly where that falls in these bullets, but I personally feel like it's got to be called out directly. If you could tell me what power we have to do anything with them, I would be happy to try and pursue it. And Nate has been incredibly gracious with his time and given us a couple of presentations about
2:22:02 Our lack of power to change that dynamic. But there's got to be something we can do maybe outside the box. And the example that's always been brought up to me, we've got this incredible asset of the digital 395 that is sitting out on the 395. When that was being built,
2:22:28 Through the community of Crowley, somehow a grant became available that allowed the fiber to be pulled up into Crowley and Crowley's got broadband, high-speed broadband. Is there any such funding source, governmental funding source that has been explored to help us pull fiber into town? Please, John. Yeah, I was on the, I served on the consortium, the broadband consortium for a while.
2:22:59 Places like Crowley benefited from the fact that they were considered to be underserved communities. And because they had no broadband at all, it allowed them to have access to those types of grants and to fall into a space where those kinds of things would be available. If the Planning and Economic Development Commission, I mean, there are alternatives. The town could set up a broadband utility.
2:23:28 And funded ourselves and do it all by ourselves. We wanted to do it. It's a very, very expensive proposition that's been done in Nashville and some other towns across the country. But if the PEDC, if Michael, if you want to start looking into some of those kinds of scenarios, maybe there would be some way to start doing some preliminary cost accounting for it. But I see the town attorneys popped on and he's going to tell you what we all need to know. We do not have any power over that. But Andy's got some updates on things that are happening.
2:23:58 with Mammoth and Truckee and overtures being made to the CPUC, I'm sure. Yeah, so as Councilman Wentworth said, the town doesn't have any direct regulatory authority over Sudlink due to how the law that they're operating under was set up back in 2006. So we don't have a franchise agreement. They have a state franchise agreement. It's the state public utilities commission that regulates them. And the law doesn't even really allow the PUC to do all that much. That said,
2:24:25 We are engaged in ongoing dialogue with the PUC and Suddenlink. That's the town, Mono County, Placer County, which is up next to me in Truckee, as well as the town of Truckee, trying to find some way of getting Suddenlink to do better. We have another meeting set up in a couple weeks.
2:24:45 My initial look at the new treasury regulations for all the COVID funding that governments are going to get suggests that broadband development may be in allowable use, although I think there are some strings attached and we'll be continuing to look at that. But, you know, we're working on it. I mean, it's just, as Council Member Wentworth said, there's no solution to this that doesn't involve a ton of money. Cities can go do their own fiber networks.
2:25:14 The public utility district up here in Truckee is talking about doing a public network and the idea is that they would build it and then they try to find some third-party operator to lease capacity and provide service to the customers. That's a model that has worked. I think there are some jurisdictions where the city or county provides service themselves, although it's not usually kind of like a core competency of a city or county. So it's not all bleak.
2:25:44 There are things we're looking at, things to work on, but there are no easy, cheap, or fast solutions. Thank you for that summary. I appreciate it, Andy. All right, I'm going to throw it back to Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Chang, do you have any questions on this last bit of the document or comments or opinions? The really only comment I have in regards to Sunlink is that, you know, I keep hearing this theme this entire meeting.
2:26:17 is that we kept having to deal with so much toxicness that's beyond our power to do, to fix. And I hope that we will continue to learn from this and to know when to cut off the toe or the arm or the hand, whatever it is you want to call it.
2:26:49 and do something else with it to innovate. You know, if Sunlink can't provide that infrastructure due to cost, which I understand is extremely expensive, maybe there's some other entities out there that can help us that collectively with various different counties that we can partner together and to get this to work. I mean, can we reach out to Starlink?
2:27:21 For example, that can help us, you know, for cities like ours, towns like ours, in Truckee, in Tahoe, in various areas, Placer County, whatever. Anyway, there's something to think about. And, you know, I think a lot of times we just need to think outside the box. We need to continue to think outside the box. And town needs to be its own entrepreneur.
2:27:53 And somehow, you know, I mean, there's so much technology out there. There's got to be something that we can do. Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Commissioner Burroughs, anything on these last four bullets? There's still a lot of meat on the bone that we haven't really hit on here, but. Yeah, I would just like to echo Commissioner Chang's point on looking outside the box and finding.
2:28:23 alternative solutions. I don't think that Suddenlink really cares about the small town in Mammoth Lake with lakes when they have bigger fish to fry. And unfortunately, I don't think we're going to get a lot of their attention. And I'm looking at the other stuff, and I think that that's appropriate, and I don't really have anything to add. Thank you, Commissioner Burrows. Commissioner Kennedy. I have a question on that first bullet point.
2:28:52 Define and implement technology-based systems for customer service improvement. Is that within the town specifically for town like business and stuff? Yeah, it's a good question. It's primarily focused on how we engage with our customers and the different systems that we have.
2:29:14 implemented different things at different times and getting a little better integrated in the system would be important. Came up with an example, which is changing how we do dog licensing recently, a small thing, but, you know, it was expanded level of service there, reducing staff time, et cetera. And so as we look at those types of services, what does that begin to look like in how we actually provide services?
2:29:38 and engage with our community in that perspective. There's applications to that down the road. Does that get outside the town offices potentially? But it was really focused on our customer service, our core services that we provide as a town. Perfect. Thank you. And then my one other question was the third bullet enhanced towns public outreach engagement information strategies, et cetera. Is that, I watched part of the meeting, the council meeting, they were discussing that. So I guess I'm wondering,
2:30:08 There were some new ideas of different communication avenues. Is there thought of having a new position to do this or just kind of continuing to piecemeal various people in that kind of communication side of things? Right now, as with existing staff, we haven't ruled out that idea of either a part-time or some support help there, but at this point, it's really trying to figure if you brought somebody else in, the question is, what would we have them do?
2:30:34 Until we get that defined in that strategy and that outlook, what that begins to look like, that could form up and say, again, it's a resource question there, of course, but yes, now if you had somebody on full-time, part-time, whatever that might look like, what would that focus be? A lot of the resources, we have the information we have, whether you have a person sitting there, everybody else around is, okay, how do I gather that information? Where does it come from for somebody to actually write it and put it out and do that effort and work?
2:31:02 And so I think part of this is to set that up and say, what does it begin to look like? And then if it's overwhelming or whatever that element might be or the need to have, you know, that person who could sit down and actually take information from everybody else that you see on the screen here even and say, actually, how do we translate that out to our community would be kind of a future step in that area. But right now, I think if somebody walked in,
2:31:30 Everybody here would still be doing almost the same level of work of getting information to somebody. And so we're trying to look through that and what does that begin to look like and how do we maximize and utilize some of the other tools that are out there already that we haven't taken full advantage of. Perfect. Thank you. Yeah, I think that's an important one.
2:31:50 I mean, I think one of the most common things I hear about in town is like, oh, who knows what the town's doing or who knows what anyone's doing? And there's so much that happens, as you all know. So I work in communications and the more I see like a dedicated person, the much easier it is for the information to get out there. Anyway, so that was my one thought when I was seeing the Office of Outdoor Recreation. I immediately went to like.
2:32:14 Oh, could there be a person for communication? Could it maybe fall under that? Have some connection to that? But I think that's awesome that you guys are moving in that direction. So thanks, Dan. We're taking that really seriously, Jessica. We've got to do some analysis and some forensic work to figure out what may work well. But I know Councilor Rosalcedo has been pushing this pretty hard and I think we all support that. Awesome. Thanks, John. And again, in this document, this is set up as priorities, things we see where we're deficient, we need to move forward.
2:32:44 Not necessarily providing the solutions, but the solutions are things we need to come up with in the time span of the document. Thank you. Commissioner Eckert, do you have any questions, comments, or opinions on this last series of bullets? Yeah, back to the sudden length thing again. I think we've got a pretty good batch of pretty smart people here. And what's really not being said, what everybody's thinking is, you know, our whole community is being abused by this.
2:33:15 It's not going to change with the current situation. And I think that the best solution to a problem is generally competition. And while it is hugely expensive, if there's grants through this infrastructure bill that's going through, there may not be the expertise in the town staff to run a utility, basically. But whatever there is, we have a very competent utility here.
2:33:45 In the water district. And I believe they have a very broad charter as to what sort of services they can provide. And if we can work out something with them that we can attract a grant as a town and hire them as somebody who will run a very profitable, I mean, everybody who's got an internet connection town is going to jump on this as soon as availability comes up. Water district will make money on it. They're pretty darn good at what they do.
2:34:15 And if we as a town can qualify for a grant that they can't, I think that's something that ought to be pursued because Sutherland's not going to do nothing about this. They've made that pretty clear. That would definitely qualify as thinking outside the box, Greg. Any other questions or comments or opinions? Jamie, do we have any public comment on this? Yes.
2:34:48 Sandy Hogan sent in an email that says, creating another high-level permanent staff position, probably at the salary level of a director to deal with federal state DWP lands is probably duplicative. That is traditionally at the federal level at least, staff talks to staff and line officers talk to decision makers, or at least to the town manager who speaks for our town council. Using anything but general funds for a high-level permanent staff position,
2:35:15 Measure R, portions of Measure U without a defined project would seem to be in conflict with both of those town ordinances and in conflict with community expectations. Most of us, if not all, expected to see tangible projects, not additional town staff. And then Kim Anaclario from Mammoth Lakes Recreation said she'd be happy to give an update at a future meeting. And that is all the public comments we have. Thank you, Jamie. Appreciate that. Any other final thoughts or?
2:35:48 Opinions, comments? We'd love to hear from the Town Council if you do. You know, I don't mean to, Chair, if I may. Please. I just want to make sure that, you know, we get perspective from all of the Town Councils here, especially now we have their years here. I didn't hear much from Linda and I didn't hear anything from Sarah. And I think your opinion is very valuable to us.
2:36:19 I just want to make sure that if there's something that needs to be said, please do so at this time. We'd love to hear from you. Thank you. Yeah, thank you, Paul. I appreciate that. Having worked on this strategic plan for the last three sessions and kind of putting it together like we did, I was really wanting to hear your input on it. What did you have to say about it or your thoughts about it?
2:36:47 And then we have another go at this where we can kind of incorporate all that. So the questions you asked were excellent and hearing us try to explain it back, I think helped me kind of solidify it more in my own mind. And if I'd have had anything additional to say to some of the excellent comments made by the other council people, I would have spoken up for sure. But thank you for your question.
2:37:10 Yeah, thanks, Paul, as well. I apologize for coming in late. I was traveling today, so I just was kind of wanting to be here, but coming in a little late, so apologies for that. I agree with Linda. You know, I think we've talked a lot about all these points and wordsmithed them and hammered them in, so this was really looking forward to hearing what you had to say and what your questions were.
2:37:40 I just didn't feel like I had that much extra to offer, but I do appreciate you asking for our opinion. Thank you, Sarah. Any other comments or opinions from the Planning Commission? You guys good? Well, as the chair, I would just like to thank each and every one of the town council members for taking the time today to walk through this document with us. Gosh knows that your schedules are all incredibly...
2:38:10 busy with meetings, not to mention your lives outside of the public domain. So thank you very much for the time. Thank you for the energy and the vision you guys put into this document in creating these priorities. Quite a few of them, I think, are absolutely essential to our forward, I guess the word would be evolution as a destination. So your time is appreciated.
2:38:39 And I'm going to cut you all loose now. So try and get outside and enjoy some of the sunshine this afternoon. So thank you for your time, guys. I'm going to close that business matter item number two, and we're going to open up the public hearing. We have one item on the public hearing. It's to consider approval of a variance request, VAR 20-002, for a 75% reduction of the front yard setback to allow for a five foot setback for proposed.
2:39:09 Two-car garage and an adjustment request ADJ20-007 to allow for an exterior parking space to be located in a setback not leading to a garage at 40 Beaver Trail in the residential single-family zone. And I believe Michael is our staff contact. That's correct. Thank you for the patience hanging in there, Michael. Yeah, I guess one of the perks of Zoom is that...
2:39:39 Can multitask while waiting for my turn. So yeah, like Michael said, the property owner at 40 Beaver Trails requesting a variance for 20 or requesting variance 20-002 for a 75% reduction of the front yard setback, which would allow for a five foot setback for a proposed to a car garage, along with adjustment 20-007 to allow for an exterior parking space.
2:40:08 To be located in a setback not leading to a garage. Forte Beaver Trail is located in the residential single-family zoning district. The existing single-family residence was constructed in 1971 with no garage or other enclosed parking spaces. The property currently has non-conforming parking with uncovered spaces located in the front and side setbacks and in the town's right-of-way.
2:40:40 The lot is steeply sloped up from the street with access to the house provided by a non-conforming asphalt driveway and a wooden stairway providing secondary access from street level. The zoning code allows garages a five-foot setback on steep upsloping lots, but this project parcel does not meet the requirement that the lot be seven feet above the center line of the street, 20 feet in from the property line. The property was heavily graded when the site was developed.
2:41:09 And had the current five foot setback allowance been in the code at that time, it would have likely qualified for reduced front setback. Here's a picture of the current conditions and slope on the site. Current parking is located on the far side of the lot opposite from where this picture was taken. As you can see, the configuration or the current parking configuration results in vehicles being parked in the town right of way.
2:41:46 The project is proposing a variance to reduce the standard 20-foot front yard setback to five feet to allow construction of a two-car garage. The project is also proposing an adjustment to allow vehicle parking in a setback area not leading to a garage. The unenclosed parking space is in the front and side yard setbacks and will allow the property to meet the minimum parking requirements, which is three spaces for a house under 3,000 square feet.
2:42:14 The code requires two of the spaces to be enclosed and one unenclosed. Additionally, the public works director has authorized an exception to the town standards for residential driveway width to authorize a driveway that is 28 feet wide at the property line. This is four feet wider than the town standard of 24 feet and it will correct the existing non-conforming driveway and parking issues and consolidate the parking areas into a single driveway apron.
2:42:43 As the existing paved parking area will be removed as part of this project. Prior to the certificate of occupancy, the town will require a hold harmless agreement that will indemnify the town against damages from snow removal to the portions of the property within the setback area. Additionally, the garage is approximately 22 feet from the edge of the pavement and will not interfere with the snow storage or removal in the right of way. The property will also have adequate on-site snow storage for their new driveway.
2:43:13 and existing exterior, er, and their exterior parking space, the new parking space. And vehicles will also not be permitted to park within the portion of the driveway that's in the right-of-way. Here is a proposed site plan and an elevation for the property. The existing single-family residence is outlined in red on the site plan with the proposed garage and parking space located below and to the right of the existing house.
2:43:43 The existing asphalt parking space is located to the left of the garage, and again, that will be removed. By granting this site-specific variance and adjustment, the property will conform to the municipal code parking requirements, and it will also compensate for the special circumstances of the lot related to the slope and allow the property to be developed in a manner comparable to other properties in the same zoning district and in the vicinity.
2:44:11 Public notices were sent out to property owners within 300 feet, and notices were also placed in the sheet the past two weeks, and as of this meeting, we have not received any comments from the public. And with that, staff has determined that the findings for the variance and adjustment can be met, and recommends the adoption of the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution, making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings end.
2:44:39 Approved variance 20-002 and adjustment 20-007 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. And this concludes my presentation. I believe the property owners, John and Sandy McNutt are on the Zoom call to answer any questions if needed as well. Thank you, Michael. Yeah. Do the property owners wish to make a statement before questions of any kind?
2:45:13 Michael, we do have an attendee, Jamie Henson, is that someone from the property owners team, do you know? No, it's not. Okay, so the property owners. I spoke to the property owners yesterday and they said they would be on the call, but. Okay, yeah, they just raised their hands. So Jamie, you want to allow John McNutt to provide a comment? Cool. John McNutt, please unmute yourself and give your comments. Good afternoon, thank you. Can everyone hear me? Yes.
2:45:46 Great, thank you. No, I have nothing to add, Michael. You gave a fantastic presentation, so nothing more to add, but I'm happy to answer questions. And thank you for attending this meeting, John. We appreciate it. Do we have any questions from the Planning Commission for either staff or the applicant at this time? I don't have a question, but I have a comment. Please. We've developed these parking space codes in town for our houses, and this obviously...
2:46:19 This homeowner is trying to update their home to meet our codes and to provide them necessary parking. And I think it's a win-win for both the town and this resident and it will only increase their property value and try to get us where we want to be in town as far as parking regulations. So I support this. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Commissioner Chang.
2:46:50 Any questions for staff or the applicant? I do. Thank you, Chair. Earlier, Michael, I think you mentioned that there are currently the parking spaces on the public right-of-way. Can you go back to that map? I think it was either an aerial map or a photo in front of the house. How wide is that public right-of-way?
2:47:22 Where is the boundary of that public right-of-way? Is this the site plan you're talking about? No. It's a photo. Can you repeat your question? Where is the boundary of that public right-of-way? It is approximately 17 feet from the edge of the pavement. Of the asphalt? Yeah. Yes.
2:47:55 17 feet in towards the building. Yep, that's correct. This whole thing, it's public right of way. Almost, yeah. The public right of way, and this is Amy in engineering, the public right of way we have there is 60 feet wide, so it's about 30 feet from the center of the pavement, and that lands a couple of feet in front of the sort of the rock border that you see around the bushes.
2:48:26 Okay. So that's two feet away from those river rocks. And the garage is going to sit where those river rocks are? Essentially, yes. The front of the garage will be 22 feet from the edge of the pavement where the asphalt currently ends. Okay.
2:49:01 So I'm assuming this whole section, I know you cannot see my cursor, but this whole section with the shrubs and the rocks, that's all going to get cut out? The right-hand portion of it, I guess right-hand two-thirds of it or so. But wouldn't that garage still be sitting on part of the public right away? No, it will be...
2:49:35 And five feet back. That's what the variance request is to be five feet from the property line instead of the 20 that is the standard front yard setback in the zone. And currently they're parking right where the right in front of the rocks essentially. And just to the left of the rocks there's a small paved area as well. And there will be a condition in the in the resolution that requires that to be removed and unusable.
2:50:08 Prior to the certificate of occupancy. The asphalt has to be removed. Yeah. Okay. But the stairs that's connected to it, that's not going to get removed. No. There will be, I think on the site plan, you can see how there'll be a walkway of sorts that connects to the stairs up into the house.
2:50:34 So what is the theory, what is the reasoning behind why would you ask the applicants to tear out that perfectly good asphalt? Amy, do you want to talk about your standards? Yes, our Public Works standards only allow one driveway entrance per parcel.
2:50:58 And that for that driveway entrance to be a maximum of 24 feet wide within the public right of way. And the primary reason for this is to preserve the area for snow storage from the city, from the town streets. By having that asphalt there, it doesn't constitute public storage? The asphalt and then the extension, it's the connection to the street that if it were to be cleared of snow.
2:51:33 Compromises snow storage for the town right away. That's, I guess that's kind of confusing to me. Okay. Let me try to explain it in another way. Currently, they have one driveway access to the property. That's on the left, on the west side of the property. And in proposing to construct a garage with the driveway access on the right side of the property,
2:52:13 In order to maintain our town standards, we would ask that their first driveway access be removed. And that's in order to preserve room for snow storage for the town right-of-way. Whether that's asphalt or not, I mean, that's just a surface. If they wanted to keep it asphalt on their side of the property, unless it becomes a lot coverage issue, Public Works wouldn't have a problem with it.
2:52:45 It's the asphalt connection to the edge of the pavement, which presumably could or would be cleared of snow, thus removing that area as available space for snow storage from the public right of way. Okay. I guess in my mind, I'm just thinking that, you know, the applicant is asking for exceptions, variance, to be May, but at the same time, we're asking the applicant to remove something
2:53:15 That seems to be perfectly okay condition to, you know, to incur additional costs. So I just, I guess I don't understand the logic. So, okay. Thank you, Commissioner Chang. Any other questions? Commissioner Kennedy, Commissioner Eckert, do you have any questions for staff or the applicant at this time? I've got one comment. I think, Paul, the reason that the town wants that asphalt gone is between
2:53:49 The existing asphalt and that driveway, essentially you've got a hard surface for the front yard. This historically has been wide open for parking, probably will be in, you know, this is definitely an improvement, but if you leave that pavement, A, it's not real aesthetic for the neighbors, but B, it's just a further width that may in the future end up being parked on. I just like to throw something out there that
2:54:18 Not only should the asphalt be removed, but it ought to be planted with something that is low and norland resistant and would prevent that area from being parked on in the future. Thank you, Commissioner Eckert. Commissioner Kennedy, you good? Yeah, nothing here. Thanks, Michael. Okay. Hey, Michael, I just have a couple of quick questions and I know you touched on this already in your presentation, but I just want to make it abundantly clear for the public.
2:54:53 So you sent out notices to all the neighboring properties about this application for variance and have received no response whatsoever. Is that correct? That's correct. I think there were 164 property owners because of a couple of condo complexes that were just within the 300 feet and as of now have not received anything. Okay. And my second question is,
2:55:21 With this proposed variance, the two-car garage and the third exposed parking space, does this property still meet its snow storage requirements? Yep, I don't have the square footage right in front of me, but they're required to have 75% of the area of driveway and parking areas, and they do have that directly adjacent to the driveway and parking area.
2:55:53 Got it. Okay. And, Jamie, I'm assuming we don't have any public comment on this. No, we do not. Thank you, Jamie. Well, I'm inclined to support this request. If there's no further discussion, then I will definitely entertain a motion. I'll make a motion, although I don't have the resolution in front of me for it. I don't know how helpful that is. I can share it. Okay, that would be great.
2:56:32 Sorry. Yeah. Okay. I make a motion to adopt the Planning and Economic Development Commission resolution making the required CEQA and Municipal Code findings and approved variance 20-002 and adjustment 20-007 with conditions as recommended by staff. I'll second that. All right. We have a motion and a second. Is there any further discussion? Jamie, may we have a vote, please? Commissioner Chang?
2:57:07 Commissioner Eckert? Yes. Commissioner Kennedy? Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs? Yes. Chair Vanderhurst? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And I will say congratulations to the applicant, to John McNutt. And I would highly recommend that you think about Commissioner Eckert's suggestion about planning some vegetation on the space that the asphalt will be removed from. I think that's a...
2:57:36 A very, very fair proposal. Understood. And I appreciate everyone's time and thank you for your approval. Thank you. And with that, we will close the public hearing and go to the consent agenda. Do we have anything that from the meeting, the April 14th meeting minutes, anything that needs to be edited or can we just get a motion? Motion to accept the meeting, the minutes from the meeting of April. And a second.
2:58:10 I'll second. Go for it, Jen. I'll second. Jamie, vote, please. Commissioner Jang. I wasn't there. You can still vote. Are you abstaining or? Abstaining. Okay. Commissioner Eckert. Through. Commissioner Kennedy. Yes. Vice Chair Burroughs. Yes. Chair Vanderhurst. Yes. Passes. Thank you, Jamie. All right. This one has gone wrong, so.
2:58:40 If we do have any Commissioner reports, I'm going to ask that you guys keep them succinct. Commissioner Kennedy, anything? Nada? Commissioner Eckert? Very succinct, nothing. Commissioner Burroughs? I'll just say that being with the Local Transportation Commission, we will be bringing something forward to the Planning Commission next month. So that's it. Awesome. Thank you, Commissioner Burroughs. Commissioner Chang? Nothing for me. And I'm going to...
2:59:13 Take the time to skip mine as well. So we'll move right to director's report. Sandra? Just a note, at the last meeting, you all asked about the design committee meeting for the CRC, and that will be occurring tomorrow at noon. And so we will have some information after that meeting occurs. And that's all I have. I don't have any other items. Got it. And Sandra, I...
2:59:38 Don't remember the exact date, but Grady had mentioned possibly coming before us with an airport presentation. I think it would greatly benefit all five of us. Agreed. And Grady, I think was suggesting possibly doing it at your regular meeting in June, which is June 9th. So, but I'll coordinate with Grady. And if it's not your regular meeting, I will reach out to you to find some dates that work. Thank you, Sandra. Appreciate it.
3:00:08 And with that, I'm going to adjourn this meeting of the VEDC to our next scheduled meeting, which is June 9th, 2021. I appreciate all of your time. This one went long, but I think we expressed some very valid points to town council and to town staff about what our personal thoughts are in terms of...
3:00:31 priorities for this community for the 12, 18, 24 month period we're talking about. So thank you for taking this time. Thank you. Thank you.