TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2011

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 28 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

311 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 Thank you.

0:30 Thank you.

0:54 How are you? I'm doing very well. It's up to you to make a motion to go. Yeah. That's what we heard. You're doing okay? Yeah? You guys skiing today? I don't know. I'm skiing.

1:24 Oh, wait. Let me write that down.

1:27 Hi, George. George, how you doing? Nice to see you. Thank you.

1:57 At this time, I would like to call to order the Town Council meeting for the Town of Mammoth Lakes for Wednesday, May 18th. Roll call, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. John, would you like to lead us in the pledge, please? Thank you.

2:27 Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time we will open the podium for public comment. If there's anything that is not on tonight's agenda that you would like to bring forward to the...

2:59 Council, now is the time to do it, and we ask that you please keep your comments to five minutes or less. Joe?

3:33 15, 20 years ago. He said there was no interest in anybody using that truck out there. I kind of find that hard to believe. So that's why I thought I was going to come forward here and kind of let everybody know that the motorcycle industry, the dirt bike industry, is on and up and up and is still going. And it continues to go. What I have here is, number one, the big bits that's going on in the room and now these days is they're

4:06 What they're doing is they're going into these stadiums in these local towns, Los Angeles, Anaheim. California hosts five supercross races. These supercross races are what they are is the baseball stadiums. They build motocross tracks inside these stadiums. These races attract close to 40,000 to 60,000 people. Not only that,

4:31 The millions of dollars that these races bring into these towns is unbelievable, and that's why I'm here today. California hosts five motor supercross races, two in Anaheim, one in San Diego, one they did in Oakland this year, and they added one, a new one, which was at Los Angeles Dodger Stadium. And pretty much every one of those events brought close to 40,000 to 50,000 people.

5:00 Now, this kind of gives you an idea. This is a different state that I'm going to be talking about. Utah. Right now, their slogan is the sports state because they really welcome everybody. They welcome all user groups, especially when it comes to motorizing, OHV, and motorcycle people. So Utah has been hosting. This is their third year of a supercross race they hosted.

5:28 They packed their stadium with over 36,000 fans. In a six-day event, brought the state $9 million. $9 million in a six-day event. Now, what event, what anything that we have ever brings with that kind of money in? Kind of give you an update about we do have a motocross coming up within less than a month.

5:54 The first day that that registration went, there was over 1,500 people that registered for that race in one day. So it just kind of tells you the industry is huge. We need those people here. And the reason why we need those people here is because they put gas in those motorcycles and the towns benefit from gas taxes.

6:19 And every time that we try to shut out a user group that pretty much sustains our town, that walks into bonds and walks out with $400 worth of groceries for three days, goes into our restaurants with 15 people and comes out with a $500, $600 bill, fills our lodges, retail stores, walks out with $200, $300 worth of purchases. Those are the kind of people we need in this town right now.

6:46 And like I said, the season is getting ready to come up and all the deal. The problem that's going on now is Inyo County has everything going up and running. There's four free tracks down there. They have everything pretty much up and running down there. So what's happening is all our local people are going down to Bishop. The problem is with that is that our money is leaving Mono County and going to Inyo County. And, you know, the goal is to keep our money in our town.

7:14 So I just want to let everybody know that, you know, how big of a sport this is, that it's a growing sport, and these kind of people that are involved in the sport love spending money. And I think right now, in our crisis, we need every cent we need. Thank you. Any questions? Questions for Joe? No. Thank you, Joe. Is there anyone else that would like to speak in public comment?

7:54 Good evening. My name is Lee Gosch. I'm here for three separate reasons tonight. The first one is starting on the 22nd to the 29th is Mule Days. It's down in Bishop, and we need to support our neighbors. It is the biggest thing for Bishop that goes on. It's the biggest thing in Memorial Weekend in the Eastern Sierras. They have a concert going on on Thursday, and it's at 7 o'clock, and it's...

8:20 McCoy, he's a country western singer. They still have tickets on sale. You can get a hold of them. The parade starts on Saturday the 28th at 10 o'clock. I advise you to get there early because it gets really busy. And they block off the road, too, on 395. They have a craft show in the park. There's about 150 to 200 people that show. It's very fun to go to. And there's a dance on Saturday night. And a lot of people in Mammoth know Jeffrey James. He's going to be playing there.

8:48 And one thing I can say is, to me, I've lived for a few months. I'm an animal person. It is so fun to talk to the old-timers and to learn about aspects and meals and how you mix them and all the stuff that's really neat. And one time they had a zhorst there, and a zhorst is a part of a horse and a zebra. He was there. One time a guy came from Argentina, and he brought his meals from Argentina. One time some people from France brought their meals. It is so fun to go there.

9:16 And I advise a lot of you to go. It's really fun. And if you want to know any more information, you can go to their website, which is mealdays.org. And it's really fun. I think you ought to go. And another thing that I would like to talk about is Pam Henry came here one time and asked each of you if you got the survey for the housing survey. I called up the company myself back in Colorado. It's the RRC.

9:43 And I asked him, how did they pick the people that they gave these surveys to? Because I never got one. I would have been the first one to mail it back. So he was telling me that how they picked them was they picked out the people that were 24-7 that lived in the town. They mailed out 2,300 of them. They've only gotten 400 back.

10:02 So I've talked to quite a few people that never got them. I've talked to some people in the audience that never got them either that live here 24-7. It is very important to get these surveys back. And the people who see our valley sites, it's very important you get them back. Don't give them to your friends. Don't throw them away. You've got to sign them or fill them out. If you don't like the questions, turn it over and write what you think about what they were asking questions of. The gentleman's phone number is, one, if you want to get a survey, you can call them and ask them for one.

10:31 1-888-449-4772, extension 2115, and the gentleman's name is Chris, and I've asked both the papers to put it in the paper too so that people can get it that way. It's very, very important. And then the last thing I'd like to talk about is the Mammoth Lakes Police Community Hispanic Advisory Committee. I highly recommend Hispanics to come to this meeting. I've been to the last two.

11:01 And I've been the only one in the audience. You know, I would say the police chief, Chief Watson, has worked very, very hard. He's a very outgoing person. He likes to commute and, you know, get people engaged. He wants to find out, you know, what's going on, how can they help Hispanics, and how we can come together. On May 25th, they're having a town hall meeting. It's going to be up at the Village in the Emerald Room, and they're going to have guest speakers.

11:28 The Consulate of Mexico is going to be there, the Wild Iris, the first fit five Mono County, the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Department, if that Stewart is going to be used. Stewart is going to be there talking about Park and Recreation. Steve Searle is going to be there speaking about the Bears. I've had a lot of Hispanics ask me what is a consulate. I don't need to know. So I would like to have Chief Watson come up here so people will know who Chief Watson is.

11:56 And he can explain it to them so they'll know what it is so that they can come. Thank you, Lee. Yeah, not the Consul General, but a representative from the Mexican Consulate of Sacramento will be here to answer questions about what services they provide. So just to repeat what Lee said, next Wednesday it's an open meeting.

12:22 The Mayor and Councilmember Eastman are part of the liaisons to that committee, and it'll be at the Emerald Room at the Grand Sierra Lodge, Village Lodge, and the public is welcome, so we'd like to see a good turnout. Time. Time? 4.30 in the afternoon is when it'll get started. The doors are open. It'll really get going about 5 or so. And it's kind of a drop in and kind of see what's there, take advantage of what we're offering. Stay as long as you like.

12:49 Correct. Right. I'm guessing the most valuable portion will be the question and answers afterwards. There will be presentations by the people that Lee mentioned. Then the floor will be opened. For those people that are uncomfortable asking questions in public, we'll have cards they can fill out anonymously. And any questions about services provided by the town or particularly relationship with the police department and the sheriff's department, we are there to answer their questions. Excellent.

13:18 Thank you. Thank you, Chief. And there will be translators. Thank you. Thank you, Lee. You know, I just learned the other day that the mule is the original hybrid. Yes. Is there anyone else that would like to speak during public comment? Steve? Just a real quick brief, not so much for the council, but use this venue to maybe speak to the community and the press. With the wildlife,

13:57 With the amazing amount of snow we're having in the black bear cycle, they need to eat grasses, fresh translucent grasses that come out from the melt for about eight weeks to purge themselves after their wrong fast. There's no natural foods available for them at all. Today I observed several bears eating sod grass. They'll do it just because they're so hungry.

14:24 But there is no natural grass available. And depending on what Mother Nature does, it could really get dizzy in town. We're getting a lot of calls. It's been quite slow. Dumpsters are doing good. But we get calls from people that are leaving trash and food in their cars. And then the bears get in there and they want to call, you know, have the police come out or have me to come out to do a report. If you've lived here or anywhere near here, you know that we have bears.

14:52 If you leak garbage or trash or food in your cars, I'm personally working with the Wildlife Subcommittee and with the Chief of Police to cite you. And so I would not so much call the police. I'd call your insurance company or call the glass shop and get a new window. But, you know, it's like a TV show. Here's your sign. You're going to get a free sticker from me. But everybody knows better. If you have guests or tourists or loved ones coming up that are from out of the area, I can excuse that. But homeowners are longtime residents here in town that are calling me constantly.

15:22 The bears in my open garage eat my trash again. Can you come over? I'm going to encourage that those people be sighted. Everybody knows that we have bears. This is a really unusual year, and so I just wanted to explain that until we have some melt-out and some natural food for the bears, we can get really active, and we need to work as a community. Of the hard things that you need to deal with tonight, this one's a freebie.

15:44 This is just all of our participation like normal. It costs nothing, just common sense and sharing with your neighbor or friends that are coming up to visit. We've got to keep the stuff put away from the bears. Something that we really can't do anything about is the deer. The deer are all blocked up in Murphy's Gulch and coming up 203. We've had two people put in the hospital last week, as most of us know. One of our sheriffs watered a deer at high speed on 395 and did a lot of damage to the car, but not to himself.

16:13 This isn't about how good a driver you are or how good your eyes are. It's by chance. It's not like the bear is something that we can easily take care of and control. The deer that are darting across the road, that's something we can't do anything about. I hit a deer last year. It's not about what a great driver you are or that you're tired at the wheel. Anybody could hit a deer. If we could just put it in our everyday conversation, the people that are coming up, your, again, friends, family, loved ones, guests, to watch out for the deer.

16:43 Deer. Last year, we got somebody killed, you know, a couple people in intensive care, over $100,000 worth of property damage from deer. You know, 10 times the amount of damage that the bears created or the raccoons. So, I know it's redundant to the city council, but I appreciate your time. Slow down. You know, it's probably the most important thing you can do. The deer whistles, you know, I priced them today at $14. They stick right on. You don't need a mechanic. They work really good at...

17:12 Slower speeds at 90 and 100 miles an hour if they don't work. Anything inside the speed limit, they work great. Adjusting your headlights. We've all pulled into a snowbank during the long winter. Your lights are skewed. Check it out. Take it to one of the local shops, the gas station. Anybody will help you get your headlights adjusted. When you wash your windows, wash your headlights. Going to the local gas stations, everybody washes their windows because of the bugs this time of year. We're

17:39 In the 395 corridor, they collect on your windows, they collect on your front headlights, and it's really causing a problem. If they're going to wash your window, just stroke across the headlights and clean them up and get those bugs off there. Again, slow down. I'm out at night patrolling all the time. Use the fast lane if there's nobody out there. A lot of times we're the only person on the road, depending where you are in the corridor. Work over to the fast lane if that's going to be most advantageous, or straddle the lanes.

18:07 Again, the high patrol, they're out there scared of the deer. We are. If you stride up a lane, there's no one around, you're not bothering anybody. It's going to give you that, you know, a little bit more margin of error. If you get into the deer, arms straight, heavy braking. You know, most of our cars don't have brakes. If you have a newer car, you won't flip it or get it sideways. What my friends did down at the airport, straight arms, heavy braking. I think probably one of the best things we can do in the conversation. It's something that, you know, is up to us.

18:45 Last year when I came up and spoke and gave the same presentation in front of the council, we already had people in the hospital. We already had, it's just getting started right now. There was 40 yesterday morning crossing the road on 203. People on 395, we all used the 395 quarter. This advice goes for that too, but 203 is, we're responsible for reach outside of my jurisdiction by picking up dead deer off the 203 or dead bears. Three last year, bears, you know, dozens of deer. But right now it's extremely dangerous.

19:28 Thank you for your time. Is there any questions I could answer to the council? Yes, sir. Stephen, you mentioned some relatively simple things that we can do as far as with our cars and so forth. It seems like one of the larger things we can do is to put signage, whether it's temporary or permanent, on 203. We obviously know that there's a huge number of deer that cross in the Murphy's Gulch area and so forth in deer kills. Are we making any progress?

19:58 On getting signage there. I didn't bring it up, John, but since you asked the question, we're getting absolutely zero cooperation with Caltrans. My sign that I put up on a different easement with Bear Crossing, three bears were hit there last year. We had that sign taken down and put up the new sign. That was torn down and I got emails and hate mail about it from Caltrans. A gentleman that works for the town that's here today, I don't want to put him on the spot, but he's put in, I think, three requests so far to put up additional signage.

20:27 On the 203 corridor and been refused on all of them. We have another application in right now, I believe, and we're giving them a 10-day period to see if they can, you know, help us out. But Caltrans guys, I know them, no disrespect, but the big cats that, you know, live down south that don't visit Mammoth, that could care less, there's zero cooperation, John. And so the signs that I stenciled and put up myself last year, the locals were, you know, let them stay up for about three weeks before they were impounded.

20:57 And I think that signage is a huge thing. When I drive home from LA and come up 203, I'm on the throttle. You know, I'm driving fast uphill up 203. I'm not better than anybody else. It's just such an obvious location, and it's hard to understand why signage hasn't been addressed at that location. You know, Caltrans sent out an email that seven deer and one bear have been hit in the last 10 years on 203.

21:25 We might have seven deer hitting that area in a week. That's correct. And, you know, I respond to most of those calls, or Caltrans will come out if it's something that needs to be picked up with equipment. None of us want to do that kind of duty. But, again, keeping people safe is number one, then property damage. But in a close third, we don't want to keep running over our animals. If when the ten days expires, if you need help, a letter, or communication from the mayor or from the council, would you let us know? I sure will. Okay, thank you. Absolutely.

21:55 Thank you. And I think Joe or I can actually address that regarding the meeting we were in last week. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Steve. Is there anyone else that would like to speak during public comment? John? John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Just want to give you a quick update on some of the things we have going on. We've got this coming weekend we're headed to San Francisco for one of the largest tour operator travel show, wholesaler shows in the world called Palo. It's actually a

22:26 A three-day event with a few other days of activities to work with tour operators, wholesalers from around the world. So Mammoth Mountain Ski Area has a booth. We have a booth, and we'll be representing the area up there. And then following that event, we have a fam trip of about 25 people from around the world, tour operators as well as journalists, that will be coming through on a trip. They're starting up in San Francisco, going to Tahoe, and then coming down here for Memorial Day weekend. And we're taking them out, everything from skiing to showing the area.

22:56 And Mr. Mayor is joining us on the trip, and Steve Searles is also going to help us on that as well. So we're excited to have that opportunity, and it's a worldwide event. The show is massive, and it's a huge opportunity for us to get exposure in groups from around the world. John, quick question. Powwow can be held.

23:15 As you say, anywhere in the world, certainly any state in the United States. So isn't this unusual that we have it so close to us? This is actually fantastic. So this year it's in San Francisco. Typically it moves around the country and it's usually in Orlando or Miami or some of these other places. This year it's in San Francisco. Next year it's in Los Angeles. And the year after it's in Las Vegas. So we have a tremendous opportunity for the next three years to really capitalize on this and build the relationships. And with that we've added Michael Vanderhurst to our team as...

23:43 Industry Relations and Sales Manager. So his job is to build those networks and relationships so that we can continue to grow that and working very closely with the Mountain to make sure that we have the complimentary packages to get people into town. So it's pretty exciting. Good. Thank you. Other questions? Thank you, John. Thank you. Is there anyone else that would like to speak during public comment? If not, we will close the public comment period and we will move to Councilmember Reports, Matt.

24:09 You know, just one. I'll keep it brief, and it's really just following up on some things that John Erty just mentioned, but I sit on that commission, and we get a monthly reporting, and I like the numbers I've been seeing out there. Looking at some of our average daily rates for April, they're up almost 12%.

24:34 And the pacing for May is actually outpacing last year 8-9% whether it be the occupancy or daily rate. So kind of good news there. Hopefully we can continue that trend throughout the rest of the year. And I probably should ask John when he was up here, but I noticed there was also some comments of various magazines and whatnot that MLT's been working with. And it looks like they have some photographers from Smithsonian coming through.

25:01 And hopefully we're going to get some nice press out of these various magazines. But that's about it. Thank you, Mayor. John? Mr. Mayor, earlier in public comment, we were harsh, if you will, on Caltrans higher-ups or bureaucracy on their insensitiveness as it relates to deer kill on 203.

25:27 I'd like to take this time to thank Caltrans as well as our town staff for repaving, widening the shoulders on the scenic route out of town. I don't know if everyone's had a chance to drive that yet. That project was finished late in the fall, early winter in 2010. It's open now. People are using it. If you get a chance, it's an absolutely great

25:55 Roadway now and not only for vehicles but also for cyclists. So thank you Caltrans and town staff for putting that grant money together on that project. On our Friday update last week we were informed that the transit ridership in the community of Mammoth Lakes for the month of April this past month was up 15% over the prior year for the month.

26:22 And in the first four months of this year, January, February, March, and April combined, those four combined were up a total of 25% over the same time period last year. So once again, our transit ridership numbers are very encouraging. On Monday of this week, I attended in Bridgeport the Great Basin Air Pollution Control District Board meeting. There were two main subjects on that agenda. The first one is the Board approved. It's 2011.

26:54 12 budget. Secondly, the Board discussed options for spending the $6 million that was given to the APCD by the City of Los Angeles to address air quality issues, mainly in the Great Basin area of Inyo County. There is a possibility to address air quality issues in Alpine and Mono County as well, but the emphasis will likely be in Inyo County from Elantia to Independence. Some of the likely candidates for funding are

27:23 Replacement of non-certified wood stoves in the Inyo and Mono and Alpine counties. Cinder dust reduction in Mammoth Lakes. I suggested because the town of Mammoth Lakes currently has two cinder sweepers, if you will, I recommended that we possibly get a third sweeper for our town with the strings attached that if we did get the third sweeper that

27:53 That we would have to obey guidelines like the sweeper would have to start at a certain time after a storm or work for a certain time frame after a storm. So we have no idea at this time what projects will be funded, but hopefully we can get another cinder sweeper for the town of Mammoth Lakes. Another area was commercial or home weatherization, the theory being

28:20 If, excuse me, winterization, the theory being if homes or commercial properties were winterized, that that would save on electricity. Other possible funding candidates include public transportation, diesel engine change outs of government vehicles, bike path funding, which would be appropriate, of course, in our community, and education, public education.

28:46 The final one is video teleconferencing for telecommunication opportunities. The Air Pollution Control District Board will discuss further the possible projects at our July meeting which will be held in Markleyville and hopefully looking at which of these projects can either leverage funding through grants and other projects that are ready to start now. Finally, Mr. Mayor, the town has recently received some criticism

29:17 From a member of the local water board in regards to our watering of the lawn areas on both Main Street and along Old Mammoth Road. There are those in town who could care less about the town's landscaping in these areas, and there are those in town, both locals and visitors alike, who are appreciative of the attractive appearance of the greenery, which serves to break up the commercial appearance in these two highly visible sections of the community.

29:46 Is the town perfect in our watering of these two areas? Absolutely not. Do these two areas, because of their relatively small size, high sun exposure, surrounded by asphalt, heated by the summer sun, heavy road cinders, create watering challenges not seen in other more protected areas of town? Yes. Has the town in the past, and is the town currently,

30:14 Making efforts to do better with our watering along these two sections? Yes. I took the time recently to talk with the landscaper doing the contract work in these areas, as well as two members of the town staff who work with that landscaper and also work with the water district in continuing our efforts to do better and to use as little water as possible. Some additional information is as follows. Last summer,

30:41 The town changed all the sprinkler heads along Old Mammoth Road to lower level heads which reduces the water loss from over spraying. There was also last summer the town installed new timers along Main Street and this summer the town is experimenting with a new sprinkler clock along Main Street that has a moisture cup

31:09 Which lets the system know if there's been recent rain and if there has been then it shuts off. Also it's heat sensitive so if we get temperatures that are freezing or near freezing it shuts off so that we're not watering during cold times when the lawn doesn't need it.

31:33 We are also installing in the same area as this single sprinkler clock on Main Street, we're also installing new rotary sprinkler heads. We believe these two improvements will be very helpful, and I think it also shows substantial effort on the town's part in reducing the amount of water we use. The final thing is that this new sprinkler clock also is set on a cycle that's called cycle soak.

32:02 And what that means is that the sprinklers are on for 60 seconds, on for a minute, they're off for five minutes, then they come back on for a minute, and what that does, if you water continuously, let's say for five or ten minutes, then at some point, the ground is going to stop absorbing that water, and you're going to have more runoff in the streets. So if you sprinkle for a minute, off for five minutes, it allows that water to soak into the ground, which helps as well.

32:28 In conclusion, the town has come a long way in conserving water since the days of our original sprinkler installation in those areas, and we are aware that we can do better, and we are making reasoned and sensible adjustments to our system on an annual basis to do even better in our water conservation efforts. Thank you. Thank you, John. I appreciate that report, especially on the water, since it's been an issue for the past several meetings. I appreciate that. Joe?

32:55 Just one quick note. At the Local Transportation Commission meeting a week ago Monday, the issue of the wildlife warning signs was discussed, and I believe staff is following up in efforts to hopefully ensure a permit so that those signs can go up. Thank you. I have nothing to report at this time, so we will move on to the next agenda item. Do we have a report this evening from the Planning Commission? I don't see any members out there. If not,

33:26 We will move on to our public presentation. Jack Copeland from the Mammoth Mountain Ski Area regarding the grand prize drawing for the Ambassador of the Winter from the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce Ambassador Program. Jack, welcome. Thank you, Mayor. Council, staff, this was not a skiing measure. If it's not skiing, was it age-related? No.

33:56 It's an old sports industry injury, John, that is aggravated by many years of obscenity. Don't let Dr. Tibor see me walking without my crutches. I'm Jack Copeland. I'm the Secretary of the Chamber of Commerce, and I'm the Chairman of the Mammoth Ambassador Program for the Chamber. Mammoth Ambassador Program is a joint venture between the Town of Mammoth Lakes, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and

34:27 The Mammoth Chamber of Commerce and the purpose of this endeavor is to promote higher levels of service and hospitality throughout the community. And the chamber has been involved in putting on training programs. We had five workshops this fall in October and November. We had over 150 participants.

34:51 They were a few employees of businesses, but mostly supervisors, managers, and owners of businesses. This year we decided to take a tactic that was a little different from previous years. We decided to address the owners and managers directly about integrating service training and hospitality training into that period of November, December when they're onboarding their new employees and training them up for the coming season.

35:19 It was very successful. We had a lot of passionate people, and we identified many ways to integrate in a cost-effective way service training to the employees of our community. We followed that up in March and April with a recognition program. We frequently hear entertaining but probably negative comments about anecdotes about guest service in the community.

35:49 And they are no doubt true. But we also have some incredibly good service providers in the community and some businesses that are really renowned for having consistent, high-quality service in their businesses. So what the chamber wanted to do was to take a slightly different tack this spring and recognize individuals in the town who really gave spectacular guest cigarettes.

36:18 Throughout the community. And to acknowledge their contributions and their efforts on behalf of the community as ambassadors of Mammoth Lakes. I'm going to read you the list. There are only 14. It's Brett Burns from Whiskey Creek, Kurt Snyder from Convict Lake Resort, Jorge Especia from Sierra Nevada Lodge, Otis Hine from Angels, now a fly fishing guy,

36:47 John Bitsberger from the Mammoth Mountain Ski Patrol, Yvonne Eduardo Bramona Fierro from Schatz Bakery, Jesus Laguna from Giovanni's, Annalisa Baker from the Bookie Joint, Tom T.K. Kearns from Footloose Sports, Mike Feibiger from the Alpine Garage, Karen Kasten from Vons and the Java Joint, Andrew Soshinsky from the Rafters,

37:16 Luciano Lou DeLeon from Kittredge's, and Ron Segura from the Westin. If I can approach the council, I wonder if the mayor, I have the names of these individuals in this envelope, secured, impossible to tamper with. If the mayor would like to pick one, one of our sponsors. That would be better. Dr. Tibor would appreciate it.

37:49 Thank you, Skip. We had four sponsors for the awards for this program. They were Footloose Sports, Kittredge Sports, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area, and, oh my God, it's the leg, it's the knee. And, oh gee, I'm going to pay for that. So, if you were to pick one, there's a number on these cards.

38:18 I'll relate to that. Oh, I know who the four of us. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Number 12. And number 12 is Andrew Sosinski from the Rafters. What Andrew wins is a pair of skis, a setup of skis, or a snowboard, or $1,500 towards a mountain bike. And that is from our sponsor, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area.

38:56 $1,500 gift certificate for Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. So that goes to Andrew Sashinsky. We're going to continue this program. We're going to do it in the summer. We're going to have the recognition program in the time frame from the 4th of July until Labor Day. And you'll hear more about that as we move on. Also in the summer, the chamber is going to develop, during our workshops in the fall,

39:24 We've really got some traction with some of the best practice businesses in town in terms of guest service. And what we want to do is work with them over the course of the summer to create an e-learning tool that can be downloaded from the chamber website by any business in town that will provide a framework for a service improvement system that they can integrate into their training and their business in the coming fall. So we're continuing to move forward on the Mammoth Ambassador Program.

39:53 I hope you'll choose to find us in the future. If not, we will endeavor to persevere. Any questions? Questions or comments for Jack? Just a comment. I'd just like to say, as a person that sits on the chamber and a liaison with town, we really appreciate your efforts and the chamber's efforts on that. You know, a long time I've lived here, you do hear negative anecdotes and comments, and I think this was a good, positive approach to try to fix the problem, and just want to say thanks.

40:22 Thank you, Matt. Jack, can I just ask you a couple things? Yeah, there's one. Now, a person sees someone or is aware of a person who is giving outstanding service and they would like to submit their name. How does someone go about that? They would go through the Chamber of Commerce office, which is in the same offices as the Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and contact Annette Scholl, and she will pass along that information. And what we really want to know is it's...

40:51 It's a little hard to define great guest service, but it's more than being friendly. Being friendly is the entree. You've also got to deliver on the service, whatever it is. You've got to be knowledgeable, and you've got to go above and beyond. And I encourage you to recommend outstanding service providers to us, but please give us some detail to go on. And, Jack, would I be correct? This is not necessarily limited to an employee.

41:21 Yeah, we want to encourage a generally friendly, outgoing, and helpful

41:44 Jack, I'd like to apologize publicly if my earlier comment was insensitive.

42:11 We're not insensitive. Well, if it was, I apologize. Thank you, sir. John's looking for a nomination. Just John talking to his peers. Yeah. All right. We're going to move on to our policy matters. Item number two, it is the presentation of the initial financial 2011-2012 budget components, including general fund revenue projections, update on official year 2010-11 year-end results.

42:42 For the general fund and introduction of the key budgetary and policy items for official year 2011 and 12. And before we get started, I would just like to let you know that the way we're going to do this is that we will have a staff report. We will have council questions on that report, if there are any. We will then have an opportunity for any public comment or questions from the public.

43:09 And we will wrap it up with a council discussion and hopefully a motion. So with that being said, Mariana. Mayor and Councilmembers, thank you. For the record, I'm Mariana Marshall-Martinez, interim town manager. I have a few slides to present to you, and they follow agenda item two. Let me start by saying that we have...

43:34 Allocated the number of meetings to the matter of the budget. We're beginning our budget deliberations a little late. Normally you would start much earlier, but because of staff transitions, that was not possible. However, we have made it possible for the council and the public to spend sufficient time to discuss the budget.

43:56 Attachment A to the report lists specifically when those meetings will take place and what will be discussed in those meetings. But generally, we will begin today with today's session. We will move on to a special meeting on May 25th at 3 o'clock.

44:15 There is going to be a regular meeting on June 1st, a special meeting on June 8th, a regular meeting on June 15th, and if necessary, a special meeting on June 22nd. It appears to be a lot. We're hopeful that this number of meetings may not be necessary, but given the size of our shortfall, and I'll get to that in a few moments, this level of discussion may be necessary. What we will do today is begin the deliberation process.

44:44 I do not anticipate that any budget decisions will be made today or at the next meeting or the meeting after. It is possible that most of the decisions will take place on June 15th or 22nd, but today we will begin the deliberation process and the discussion process where we will give you updates on the current fiscal year's estimate.

45:10 Just so that you know where we are projecting to end the year. We will then move on to the next fiscal year's projections. And also would like to discuss with you budget principles on which we believe these budget discussions should be based and budget decisions should be made. Year-end estimated results for the general fund. You could track my presentation with the agenda bill in case it's

45:40 Too difficult to see the slides, and also you could refer to attachment B. On April 20th, we presented to you the estimated year-end results for the current fiscal year that ends at the end of June. Since that time, a few decisions were made that impacted the bottom line. For the positive, but those are, we allocated $131,000 for playground equipment from the general fund.

46:08 To address safety and liability issues, we allocated 36,000 for the new logo as part of the branding initiative. We also learned that we will not be receiving approximately 100,000 in a public safety grant this year. So unfortunately that is going to be a revenue loss to us in the current fiscal year. Finally, the hospital land exchange that was approved by this council back in February

46:39 was finally approved by the two partners, the hospital and the county, and that payment of $358,000 a year will begin at the end of this fiscal year. So once you count those changes to the bottom line, we stand at approximately the same level where we thought we would end the year on April the 20th.

47:05 General fund surplus by the end of this fiscal year is estimated to be at almost $500,000 and our reserve, general fund reserve should be at almost $2 million or 9%. It is not a sufficient level of reserve. You have a policy of 25%. You're a long way from that target but we will have 9% by the end of this fiscal year. So those are the good news.

47:34 And that's pretty much it. Now we move on to the revenues. Mariana, real quick follow on that, if I may. Sure. Can you explain to the public where the $350,000 increase in general fund spending shows up as far as with what we owe, what, our insurance pool?

47:57 If I may, Councilmember, once I get to 11-12, I'll cover that. So that's in the budget? Yeah, it's in the budget, so I'll cover that once I get to 11-12. So I'm done with 10-11 with the current year. So now moving on to 11-12, I wanted to just really emphasize what is in this budget. We consider this budget to be a baseline budget, and that is it shows our current revenue streams, and it takes into account historical...

48:26 Actuals on the revenues and any known changes for the future. It also takes into account the current services and current staffing. The impact of the settlement with the Mammoth Lakes land acquisition company is not factored in. We do not have the results of the settlement. We will not have them any time soon. And we don't know what the impact is going to be on the budget. So once that impact is known,

48:56 We will be back in this room looking at the budget again. But at this point, the baseline budget does not factor the impact of the MLA settlement. There also was an accounting change on the Measure A slash T transfers. And the reason for this is as follows. Currently, and for a number of years, we would take TOT, mainly revenue, transit documents or tax revenue, through Measure A and T. We would place...

49:25 That money into the general fund. And then we would take it on the expenditure side and transfer it to transportation, marketing as well as housing. It's almost like in your household account. You would deposit the check into your checking account. And then you would write the check out of the checking account into your savings account. It just doesn't make sense to go through an additional layer of...

49:50 of an accounting treatment. So in this budget, to minimize the confusion, make it more transparent, we are sending that money directly to the transit, marketing, and housing funds that have existed, have been used for those purposes. So again, it's strictly an accounting change. Specific assumptions on what's in this budget, on the expenditure side, revenue side, are discussed in attachment E.

50:18 But in general, you will notice that we have included contractually negotiated personnel increases. And by the way, in some versions of Attachment E, there was a notion that our current memorandums of understanding expire in 2012. They actually expire in 2014. So I wanted to make that notion available to the public.

50:44 But again, attachment E specifically lists the assumptions that we have included in the budget, again, in the spirit of transparency. So these are, again, in general, the assumptions and the principles. As we move on to the detail, our projected revenues for the general fund in the next fiscal year generally are projected to be down by almost $2 million from the current levels.

51:12 The reason is fourfold as listed on the slides. One is Measure U will restrict utility users' tax revenues beginning July 1st. That will represent a loss of revenue to the general fund. It is not a net loss of revenue to the town, but it is a loss of revenue to the general fund. We also will not be able to take advantage of the one-time funds.

51:40 Thank you.

52:11 Based on our discussions with the experts in the field, including Mammoth Lakes Tourism, that our transit occupancy tax for 11-12 is going to be somewhere between the levels of 09-10 and 10-11. So last fiscal year and the current fiscal year. Property tax revenues are also going down.

52:34 Based again on discussions with experts as well as the assessor's office of the county who ultimately will give those revenues to us, there is a fear that our property taxes will go down by as much as 5%. It may be worse, we won't find out ultimately until August, but at this point it appears that the loss is going to be of about 5% or $150,000. Attachment C.

53:01 details our revenues, but again, the bottom line change on the revenue side is 1.8, almost 2 million dollars. On the expenditure side, you also have an increase in spending, and Mr. Eastman, this is where I would address your question, of 700,000 a year. 350,000 of that is due to the necessary payoff of the general liability and workers' compensation amounts

53:32 That have accumulated in the insurance pool in which we participate. Those amounts have to do directly with town's liabilities going back to our membership in the insurance pool in 1990, the beginning of our membership. And those amounts are our liability and they have to be paid between 2013 and 2015. So there's 350,000.

53:57 Will be deposited with the insurance pool over the next five years to fully repay the amount of the liability that currently totals $1.7 million. Mariana, can you expand on that in the sense that that's a substantial hit for the town of Mammoth Lakes? Are there other members of this pool that are experiencing the same thing as we are?

54:26 There are other members. There are multiple other members. California Joint Powers Insurance Authority. The insurance pool in which we participate is a large pool. It's a statewide pool. They have multiple members. I don't know what percentage of them has experienced the same issues, but a large percentage has. We're all in the same place. And entities have been given an option. You either could pay on your own over the next three to five years.

54:54 The accumulated liability that you have. Or you could pay up front in a lump sum, in a balloon payment three to five years from now. We know, I know, that we're not going to be financially better three to five years from now. And we will not be able to afford $1.7 million in a one-time payment at that time. So we have to start planning for it now. So this is actually a reflection of this group, the board, if you will, of this group.

55:23 Making a determination that their actuarials were not correct and they need to catch up now for years of different municipalities not paying in what they should have paid in. You know, I think it's much more complicated than that. My understanding is this, that these liabilities have accumulated. And in the past, the insurance pool...

55:48 Covered those liabilities, basically acting as a credit card for all those agencies. And the insurance pool planned to recoup those losses and those liabilities over the next few years. They simply ran out of cash. They cannot continue to do that, so they need their money back sooner. So would it be fair to say that the town of Mammoth Lakes should have known what our liability was each year?

56:16 And that we basically just didn't address that liability on a year-to-year basis? I'm not sure if that's an accurate statement. The way the insurance pool works, and my understanding of the way that this particular pool works is that they normally add past liabilities, a portion of past liabilities, to the current year's premium. However, there is a limit.

56:42 As to how much your premium could increase in a particular year. So they could only add so much, and therefore the difference has accumulated. I'm just, and I appreciate your answers, I'm just surprised, if you will, that a number this large is coming up and biting us in the butt, if you will, at this point, and why we weren't aware of this financial liability situation earlier.

57:15 I don't have an answer to that. Okay. Fair enough. Thank you. So $350,000 is the liability that we just discussed that will be added to the budget for the next five years. For whatever it's worth, the revenue from the hospital lend exchange that I just discussed is equals to approximately the same number. And it's also going to be received over the next five years. It really is a coincidence, but it's going to help. The remaining

57:44 Mary Ann, I apologize. I think one final question. As we've discussed earlier from the four items that you listed,

58:13 That was a $1.8 million revenue loss, if you will. Is this $350,000 on our liabilities for worker compensation and general liability? Is that to be added on to the $1.8 million or not at this point? It is. So what is going to happen is your revenues

58:41 Have gone down by 1.8. Your expenditures have gone up by .7 million. Of that .7, 350 is for the liability. So added 1.8 and .7 represent 2.5 difference between the current year and next year. So you're 2.5 million overall worse off in the next year than you are in the current year. Thank you. However,

59:07 Because you had a surplus, a structural surplus in the current year, your real deficit that you have to deal with next year is 2 million, even though the net difference is 2.5. So that shortfall of 2 million is what we're facing. This is going to be a difficult budget deliberation process. This town does not have...

59:34 Any fad, so to speak, is staffing elsewhere. So this is going to be a difficult budget process for us to balance a shortfall of $2 million, which represents 13% of our job fund budget. And I'll go through some principles in a moment. But again, I just want to outline that it is going to be a difficult process. Our shortfall continues to grow. We are continuously adjusting the numbers.

1:00:02 And at the next meeting we will give you an update on the shortfall. I think as of today it stands at as high as $2.4 to $2.5 million. And hopefully we'll stop there. But it is going to be a serious issue for us to deal with. I want to outline and highlight and emphasize that the shortfall as presented on the previous two slides.

1:00:28 It's mainly a factor of the revenue loss. Of the $2 million, $1.8 has to do with the revenue loss. And as I discussed before, they have to do with the weak economy, the reductions in your transit occupancy tax and property taxes, as well as loss of one-time funding, as well as measure year restriction. Now, I think it's important for us to start with...

1:00:58 The establishment of some critical budget principles before we go into budget discussions. Staff has recommended to you three specific principles that are listed before you and also in the agenda packet. And we would like for you to adopt these principles in concert by the end of this meeting. One is that we believe that reductions, budget reductions, should be applied fairly across the board.

1:01:27 What this means to us, staff, is that equitable reductions would apply to both employees and non-employee groups. I must state for the record that at least two, the slide says one, but we have an update since that slide was developed, at least two employee unions have asked me to emphasize that they have willingly contributed in concessions over the last few fiscal years, I believe three to four fiscal years.

1:01:58 I also must state, even though I cannot disclose the confidential nature of discussions with employee unions, that they have stepped up to the plate and they are willing to help. And I wanted to thank them and commend them. They have stepped up to the plate in dealing with the current shortfall and they are willing to help. Going back to the first principle, fear of reduction. I do not believe professionally and I do not recommend across-the-board cuts. That simply is not smart.

1:02:28 However, we have to start by putting everything on the table and look at everything that's in our budget with a critical eye and that's what this principle attempts to do. It does not attempt to cut across the board but it attempts to look at everything and not leave any stone unturned. The second principle is that we would seek to resolve financial issues in partnership with employees, residents and businesses.

1:02:57 We have sought budget input from individual employees. As I mentioned, we are working with collective bargaining groups. We also have engaged in discussions with some of the businesses on how they could help us deal with the budget shortfall. The last principle is we need to make sure that we have adequate reserves. And generally for the town of the size,

1:03:24 Given that we do not have a large cash pool to tap into, for example, a lot of cities and counties have redevelopment agencies that they use as a cash pool, since we do not have this and we do have fluctuation in weather and visitorship and so on, for the town, like ours, a 25% reserve level is appropriate and it is a goal that this town council has established.

1:03:52 We're currently at 9%. The Town Council back in 2009 has made the decision to loan money to the airport and to receive that loan back by 2012-2013. Once that loan is received, $1.7 million could be added to the reserves, but even with that money, you will still need an additional $1.3 million.

1:04:22 To get you to the 25% level. I really don't have any timeline for you on how soon you may be at that level. It's going to be challenging for us, but again, I think having the goal of 25% is something that we need to continuously work towards. Mariana, if you would, on the first bullet point, budget reductions should be applied fairly. Of course.

1:04:47 You have, should apply to employees and non-employee entities. Can you give us an example of one or two or three or four what would be categorized as non-employee entities? Basically, in organizations that are not, who are not town employees, we do provide funding to organizations large and small, and not to single anyone out, but to provide examples. Large organizations include Mammoth Lakes Tourism, Mammoth Lakes Housing,

1:05:16 Smaller organizations include Chamber of Commerce, High Sierra Energy, and again, those are just examples that I could think of. By no means I'm trying to single anyone out. Thank you. I also wanted to go to one of the previous slides. I was supposed to read a statement into the record, and I lost track of that statement. It is here in slide four. Settlement was Mammoth Lakes land acquisition.

1:05:45 I was asked to state for the record, and I'm happy to do so, that Mammoth Lakes Land Acquisition Company has asked their statement to be made today for the record that they are concerned about the impact of the baseline budget decisions that we are going to be making through the end of June, because obviously it does impact them.

1:06:09 Ultimately, financially. So I wanted to make that statement available at the request in this meeting. Let me fast forward to the last slide, and that is direction sought by staff of the Town Council tonight. We would like for you to accept, at least in concept, the budget principles that we just discussed, and they're also listed in detail on pages 5 and 6 of the Agenda Bill.

1:06:36 We also would like your authorization, and we would be happy to discuss additional details for you, to fill the following critical vacancies with funding available effective July 1st, so people will be hiring effective July 1st, financial analyst slash TLT compliance specialist and payroll accounting support position. A little bit of a background on these two positions, mainly for the public. The town currently has a vacant administrative services director position.

1:07:06 As part of my job here, I was tasked with the evaluation as to whether that position was necessary as opposed to something else. We have discussed that we really need, in my professional opinion, lower level positions that address two specific areas, actually three specific areas. One is budget preparation and financial analysis. We discovered issues and problems and errors in the budget and we really need a dedicated person.

1:07:36 Dealing with that issue and project, annual project on a dedicated basis. Second issue is COT compliance. Compliance and enforcement of the transit occupancy tax as it specifically applies to residential properties is something that has been lacking. We will have a proposal for the Town Council on how this program will function at the June 1st meeting.

1:08:04 But we do not want to waste time. We would like to have a body by July 1st so that we could start enforcing the ordinance. And lastly, payroll. Between payroll and personnel, things have not been done extremely well. And the town has had some issues in the past as well as the recent past. So that section needs to be addressed as well.

1:08:31 So those are the two positions that we ask your permission to fill. And again, we created these two positions with no net cost to the town by eliminating the administrative services director position. Lastly, we would like to get your direction if you're ready to give that to us tonight on any particular spending reductions that should be pursued. And as I mentioned, direction has been given in closed session with regards to employee unions.

1:08:55 But if you would like to provide direction with regards to non-employer union groups, we would be happy to talk with you and accept that direction. That concludes my presentation. I'm ready to answer any questions. And again, I wanted to acknowledge the hard work of staff. I can't say this enough. Every single member of the executive team, as well as managers underneath, have been engaged in the budget process. They have worked countless hours, countless hours in this budget.

1:09:25 And they know what's in their budgets right now. They truly do. And they're here to address your specific questions if you have such. Any questions from council members? Yes. And actually, Marianna, I think they'll probably both be ones that you can answer. It appears that even though the ERAF or the triple flip funds are at risk, they are still, you are recommending that they be included in the budget for this next year. We still count on the revenue source?

1:09:55 We still count on this revenue source, and really what it comes down to at this point is whether the county office of education turns to the basic aid status. We have heard back from them as of now. They do not anticipate that this will happen in the next fiscal year, but it remains a threat, and we will continue addressing that threat at the state level because it does require a legislative change.

1:10:24 And then one question that you probably would answer next week, but I remember from this last summary is that we did take one-time extra funds, specifically the rest of the utility user tax, and we applied it to certain operational expenses. So when we're looking at the baseline, presumably that means we're somewhat short even without the revenue shortfalls. So how is that going to be displayed so that everyone can understand?

1:10:52 We have looked into that question, because you asked me that question before, either publicly or privately, and we have not been able to find any council decisions, public or otherwise, that dedicated that source of funding to one-time expenses. So we're a little at a loss. I just remember us taking the rest and applying it either to community development or recreation as...

1:11:18 And knowing that we were putting one-time money to operational costs, but maybe that transfer never happened. That appears to be the case. And Cindy, do you have anything to add? So research shows that one-time money basically was used for ongoing costs. Okay. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. I have a number of questions, and a lot of it's for clarity for the public. One, and for myself, but

1:11:48 The public safety grant that wasn't granted, will that be granted in 2011-12? I believe it will be, and our chief is here to address that if you have any additional information. If you're referring to the CalMet grant that is mentioned, yes, we've been informed that we will get the full amount. That pays for one full-time position. Is that a one-time granting, or is it going to be continuing?

1:12:14 I don't know how long we've had it. It's been for several years. It's a continuing ongoing grant for the state. Okay. Thank you. Second question. Just to add some clarity on Reserve for Economic Uncertainty, last year we had asked, and I think council and the public was under the impression that our Reserve for Economic Uncertainty was at 25%, and I kind of wanted to offer some clarity to the public as to why.

1:12:43 We're at 9 now. And it took a little time to be explained to me, but I think that I just want to have them understand a little bit more as to why. Sure. And I think we did have a fair amount of discussion and perhaps written statements in the April 20th agenda bill, just in case someone wants to go back to that particular item. But basically what it is is

1:13:11 Your reserve for economic uncertainty until now included the note receivable from the airport, the 1.7, which is not cash. You do not have it yet. And until you have it, I am not ready to count it as part of your reserve. So that was really the major change to your reserve. Your real cash is 1.3 and will be 1.8 by the end of this fiscal year, given the surplus.

1:13:41 Okay, thank you. And then Councilmember Bacon brought up the ERAF, and we're assuming that we will have the ERAF in our revenues for this year. Assuming we don't get them, we're talking about a pretty significant shortfall, and it was just, it was about $1.8 million, wasn't it?

1:14:01 We initially received information that it was 1.8. Later on in talking to the county and the school district and the office of education, we have been able to lower that potential loss to 1.2. But regardless, whether it's 1.8 or 1.2, the threat of that revenue loss is still there and it's still imminent.

1:14:24 What I would advise this council is that you re-evaluate your financial position no later than December. And the reason for it is threefold. EREF, your general economic position, your revenues, your expenses, as well as any information that you may have on the settlement was Mammoth Lakes Land Acquisition Company. Okay. And thank you. And then I think...

1:14:52 Councilmember Eastman brought up the JPIA, so we don't need to go over that again. And then we'll get into a little bit more. I just do want to say I appreciate the union's willingness to step up, as you've mentioned here. There are some built-in contractual obligations, and I think where everybody can chip in, that's certainly going to be helpful.

1:15:17 I don't like the numbers at all, obviously, but I do appreciate the transparency and the clarity that you and staff have offered on this thus far. We may have some more questions later as we start talking about the recommendations. Thank you, Matt. Skip, I have one more quick thing, if I may. Mariana, since this is going to be brought back to us in a week, I wondered if part of that presentation in a week could include

1:15:47 A showing of any reserves, vehicle replacement funds, or any other unexpended funds that are currently in each department's budget, and if so, what the justification would be for maintaining those funds in each department's budgets.

1:16:12 We plan to provide to you for the May 25th meeting the totality of your budget, if you would, that will show what is in each of your funds, including the fund balances. So we can go through that fund balance document and discuss where you have positives.

1:16:30 How they could be used, if at all, because some positives really count the assets that you have, such as land and roads and other positives really translate into cash. So we can discuss that at the May 25th. Okay. Thank you. Yeah. First, I just want to second Matt's comment about the transparency and the clarity of how you're presenting our budget to us. Do appreciate it.

1:16:56 It's not good news, but at least we understand now exactly where we stand. I don't feel like I'm in a void anymore or just out of the loop when it comes to financials, so thank you for that. I guess my one question would be to you, Marianna, would be that you talked about two positions that you feel are important. How do you propose? I know we have some human resource needs.

1:17:26 Cover or approach the needs in human resources that we might have. Well, what we have been able to do is basically a human resources specialist has been working on payroll because no one else was available to issue paychecks and provide information to the state level, CURS and so on. We have...

1:17:49 We pulled that person from payroll responsibilities, which are way below her pay grade, and she is focusing solely on personnel matters. So the personnel area is covered. It's really the payroll that is suffering right now. Okay, thank you. And I guess to Andy, I think, would be, maybe this question may do it, is that we're talking about

1:18:16 And I think that I would put forth

1:18:44 to you or the question is that sometimes I know in listening and talking to defense attorneys there's the law and there's the way the law is interpreted. I know California is very strict but can we instead of simply taking an approach that this is the law and there's nothing we can do, can we dig a little deeper into the law and say we need

1:19:08 To make it work for us and begin to look for a way to make it work that we can incorporate methods in operation working with our different groups who are trying to help us, the lodging agencies and all, to really find ways to get even more enforcement and actively pursue the illegal renters in more than just a book manner, but in actually physically approaching it, attacking it.

1:19:36 Yeah, that's a good question. I think that what we're going to try to do and what we're going to present to you at the first meeting in June is present some ideas and some revisions to the municipal code that will give the town more options than it has had. And part of that is that there's a recognition that there's not a one-size-fits-all approach. In some cases, if you have somebody who's just an egregious violator, you may want to take a very formal kind of a prosecutorial approach.

1:20:04 But in other cases, there may be people that simply don't understand. And for people like that, maybe more of an outreach and education effort is what's required. But the idea is to give the town a big toolbox to work with. And then staff, in consultation with my office maybe, will be able to decide which of the many tools you have available is the right one for each situation. Okay. Thank you. Mariana, for clarification, if you will, mainly for the public, can you repeat once more?

1:20:33 These two positions that you're proposing that we add, can you explain the trade-off, if you will, that the council has decided not to fill the one position, what that position was? Sure. So the current vacancy that you have in the budget is the high-level administrative services director position. It's an executive-level position.

1:20:58 That really is supposed to supervise, but at the same time, your needs are in a different level and a different area. Your needs are in budget, your needs are in TOT enforcement, as well as payroll. So the two positions that we are creating as part of this budget process

1:21:20 Our financial analyst slash TOT enforcement officer as well as payroll slash accounting assistant. Both of those areas are currently covered through temporary staff. The work is there and the backlog continues to grow. So we're spending the money. It's just the work is being provided by...

1:21:41 temporary staff, and we would like to replace those temporary staff that end up being relatively expensive was permanent employees who would be more permanent, would have the institutional knowledge, and also would be less expensive. Yeah, in essence, we're exchanging a more expensive department head type position for

1:22:06 Two less expensive, even combined less expensive, what I would call worker bee positions. And I would add, less effective position for two more effective positions. Thank you. Thank you very much. Okay. At this time, if there is anyone from the public that would like to make a comment, if you may, Mr. Baruch. Mr. Mayor, Council of People, John Baruch, speaking to the budget. Here we are again.

1:22:41 I don't want to be negative. I don't know what else to say except for the fact that I think we told you so. I was hoping tonight I could be wrong in saying that and that we had been saying this and I was wrong, but that's not the case. We as taxpayers have said for the last three, four, five, seven years that the budget's not balanced. We have a major problem and it needs to be corrected.

1:23:11 But that being said, we have to move forward, and that's what I think you guys are doing tonight. First of all, I'd like to say on a positive note, congratulations to Mariana. I think that it's the first time in the history of Mammoth that we have a simple, readable, and truthful budget. I've never seen anything like this. John, you've been on a council for 20-some odd years. I don't know if you agree with that or not, but I think this is the first time I've seen it.

1:23:39 And also I have to thank and congratulate Tom Consul for hiring us as a competent person because it's an excellent job, an excellent choice. It's a very good report tonight. We have a problem, and we've had a problem for many years, and it's a big problem. And I think that the first step to recovery, if you will, is to admit you have a problem, and then you go into rehab. And hopefully tonight.

1:24:08 The Council will admit you have a problem and start that process. If you recall, the previous Council set up a Citizens Budget Committee, CBC, I believe it was called, and it was appointed by Town Council. There was five of us on that committee. That was the good news. It only gave us three weeks to come up with 500 pages of budget. That was not readable. But we did come back to you with many suggestions.

1:24:36 And at that time, that town council in 2009 elected to rely on staff and staff convinced you that you don't have a balanced budget and took very few of our suggestions. Luckily for us, this existing town council in the last few months has seen through that and if you look, if you look back at our report in 2009, you'll find that the majority

1:25:02 Of suggestions that we made, you people have done the suggestions. I think you need to finish that. There's one thing that is not in the budget, and everyone seems to forget, and I will do my damnedest to make sure you don't, is that we have a $5.5 million sitting out there that we borrowed. Maybe you can't find it, but we borrowed it from Diff. I don't think we ever got the money, but we borrowed it.

1:25:32 And that money, I believe, went into the general fund, and that general fund paid for wages. It was kind of interesting, if you go back in history, you will find that 5.5 million was about the same identical number that we would have gotten from the rift that had been built. Also, don't forget the 3.2 million that we received in cash from Cyprus in the Three Corners.

1:26:00 That money was earmarked specifically for the parking garage in the village, not for all of it, but a portion of it, to be built on the one acre of ground that InterWest gave the town as part of their development agreement. That money, I don't see it. We could not find it when we were on the CBC. We looked for it. We know it was there. It was admitted it was there. But, again, this is not money that was borrowed on the 5.5. I don't think we already got the money.

1:26:31 Suggestions for 2011, and again, I'm not privy to the individual, what you guys are, what you people have done in closed session, but suggestions, handcuffcy, combined public safety, the lawsuit, I know that you can't figure for the lawsuit, but the lawsuit's going to be a major, major hit on this town no matter what happens, whether it's 30 million or 20 million or whatever that number might be. Suggestion possibly is to

1:27:00 Maybe you appoint or you hire some qualified citizens that have knowledge on this issue and have them sit in your special closed session meetings. I don't know if that's legal, but maybe that might save some cost in your professional fees that you're paying for right now. Important, I think, for your budget discussions, I think number one importance is tourism. That's our lifeblood. The only source of income we're going to have in the next five years is going to be TOG.

1:27:31 You're not going to raise taxes. Probably taxes will decrease if not stay flat. And nothing's going to happen. You're not going to be able to raise taxes on citizens. Planning, I think, is very important. We're doing today for the first time in the history of Mammoth Lakes, and we are planning. And so when the next boom hits, and it will hit, you'll be prepared. I've been on half of the commissions for Main Street. I've been on the one for South Mammoth Road and Old Mammoth Road.

1:28:00 And these, I think, are very, very important for pre-planning. GOP collection, great idea. I mean, this is something that is really, really something we need to put money on to try and get it. We'll get that money back. My favorite topic, diff. Get rid of it. I'm sorry. You know, diff has been a, you know, got the five and a half million bucks and tried to borrow. Diff has been a disaster in this town. There's towns that are 100 years old in this state that never had diff.

1:28:30 If you do it properly, and I think that one project was done, performance-based fees or whatever you want to call them, you can get the developers to pay for the sidewalks, the storm drains, the sewers, the gutters. That's what DIF is for. There was a nexus for DIF, or else you don't have it. You're not going to buy the $30 million performing arts center. You're not going to pay for the $18.5 million cop shop, and you're not going to pay the $60 million for the civic center. It ain't going to happen, and that was in our DIF.

1:29:00 Wishlist, if you remember. The last item I'd like to bring up is what I don't agree with or don't understand, I guess, in the budget is that you're projecting a $900,000 loss in the general fund because of Measure U. The previous tax, which was the 2.5% utility tax,

1:29:24 It wasn't in the general fund, but it was exclusively for to pay back the 20-year obligation bond. So you never really had to spend it to begin with. And now I think that even though the measure yield money is designated for, and there's no sunset on this measure, you do have that money to spend. And it's specific, definitely, but I think you have more money to spend than you would. And you just don't want to have...

1:29:52 Council using that for an excuse. You don't need excuses. You need to find out what you do have a problem. So those are my comments. I want to thank you for your time and also thank you for the amount of time you guys put into this. You're doing a really great job this year. Comments, questions? Questions or comments for John? Thank you, John. Thank you. If you could give me an opportunity. I typically do not respond to public comment, but I feel compelled to for two reasons. One is...

1:30:22 While I am humbled by the praise that was addressed to me, I can't accept it because it really goes over there to all the department heads and I can't emphasize it enough. The reason you have the budget that you have with the clarity and the completeness is because they put countless hours working on the budget and they have come to the effort with open arms and open minds and the

1:30:50 Ability as well as willingness to contribute to solving the budget problem. So again, I just wanted to praise them and address the praise to the department heads.

1:31:02 Have attempted and were hoping to present to the Council the truth on DIF, so to speak, at the May 25th meeting. We probably will not be able to do that. Everyone is just so completely busy, not only with the budget, but other things that I don't think will have a quality document. But we are hoping to have information on DIF for the June 1st meeting. Thank you, Mary Ellen. John. Good evening again. John Urdi from Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

1:31:36 You know, I think that it's easy to recognize that we have tough times ahead of us. And, you know, right now I'd like to appeal to the political commitment behind Measure A and really what formed the organization that I joined 10 months ago. You know, I came on board 10 months ago with the idea that we were forming a specific creation of a destination marketing organization. And it's never more important than it is right now. And I think to echo what Mr. Verruck said, the marketing of tourism right now is what's going to dig us out of our hole.

1:32:05 You know, really, if you look at every piece of our community, it's affected by what happens with the amount of visitorship that we have coming through town, whether you own a ski area or a gas station or your alarm. It really affects everybody in town, and we need to keep that focus and bring people here. The TOT and sales tax are not going to come if we don't have folks coming to town. And I think when we look at the marketing dollars that are put forward with Measure A, you know, while they're not secure, they're very important to what we have for success rate.

1:32:33 We encourage the commitment continued to be focused on leveraging to bring people here and not convert it into general fund operating expense coverage. I do commend Marianna for recognizing that flat cuts are not really the equitable or fair way to do this. I think there are ways that you, in any normal business, if you're looking at it as a business, you look at the performing pieces and you look at the non-performing pieces and you make your decisions based on who's bringing the bottom line.

1:33:03 So again, I think my point that I'd just like to make is to continue on focusing on the growth opportunities, and I think that growing revenues is a much more attractive way than cutting on a lot of avenues, so we want to make sure that we don't cut ourselves off at the knees and not have the money to bring people here, so thank you. John, real quick, as far as growth opportunities and marketing, would you consider within that category,

1:33:32 Are plans for expanding air service? Absolutely. Absolutely. I think the other pieces of the air service are things that just are part of the experience. So I think when we talk about growth opportunities and expenditures, I think we have to be careful not to just cut everything out of the expenditure piece. I know it's very difficult. You have a very difficult job to figure out where spending happens. But things like the sprung structure that we've been discussing down at the airport, that's going to be critical because right now we've got Mammoth Mountain.

1:34:00 Howard Bickett and I are basically flying out to Chicago on June 1st to hopefully start seeing flights come from San Francisco, come to Mammoth twice a day, and one of them heads to San Diego and one of them heads to Orange County, which are two huge markets for us to farm. And with that, right now with four flights a day to the airport, we're challenged with the facility that we have. So when we look at the expenditures, I know it's a $275,000 expenditure, but if we're going to see the commitment from Mammoth Mountain to a subsidy,

1:34:28 To add those two roots that could bring in, you know, again, if we're looking at the impact, it could bring anywhere from $5 to $10 million a year. We need to look at the facility and make sure that we have that facility in place. And again, it's an operating expense. It's not necessarily a marketing expense. It is part of the experience, though. So an expenditure of, just for clarity, an expenditure of $275,000 could be leveraged into $5 to $10 million?

1:34:56 I think the flights that we'd be bringing in could be the 5 to 10 million. The facilities need to happen in order for us to have those two flights really function. I think as most people have experienced, if you've been at the airport at any given time on the weekends, we have a tendency to have maybe two flights on the ground. If we have any weather issues, we may have three. And the challenges that Bill Manning and his crew and the Horizon crew have down there are pretty sizable when you have a holding room that's really good for one aircraft.

1:35:26 And we don't have any additional holding space. So I think when we look at growth opportunities and expenditures, I think there needs to be some in-depth analysis of really what's going to pay off in the long run because you've got, again, you've got Mammoth Mountain Ski Area willing to pick up the subsidy to add those flights to the mix, which I think we've discussed before are huge opportunities in those markets. If you look at a market of San Diego with a seven-plus-hour drive, if we can...

1:35:50 Add those flights and get people here more frequently. Again, it goes back to TOT. It goes back to sales tax. So in the grand scheme of things, it's just another piece of the big puzzle. Thank you. John, one of the concerns I hear in the community is how is that money filtered through the community? Where does it actually go, that $5 to $10 million? Do we have a way of tracking that and letting a business owner know how much that is actually coming back into his business?

1:36:19 What is actually being distributed throughout our community? I think specifically targeting it to saying it's going to a certain restaurant or a certain retail store or a certain location is difficult. I think what we've done through the research is we've determined that we're seeing an average spend of $576 per passenger per visitor. And I think that's an overall general number. But as far as doing promotions and things, that we might be able to track a little bit more to say this is what's going into restaurants, this is what's going into lodging, this is what's going into retail.

1:36:47 Then we can start to pull that out. It's a little bit difficult to really do that, but the overall spend is really where that number comes from. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, John. Thank you. Tom Cage. Tom Cage, business owner. Two quick questions. Mariano spoke of TOT being 9-10, 10-11 comparable as far as projections for this next budget.

1:37:16 Will the Town Council look at what happens if we don't have robust snow and occupancy is down a little bit in the event that the winter starts either slower or just not quite as strong as it did this year? I know this October, November, December, we had a good quarter. I think lodging had a good quarter. Retail certainly had a good quarter. January, February, March, it slowed down a little bit. I think lodging stayed pretty even. But as we all know, it doesn't always snow.

1:37:46 So I hope Council looks at what Marianna has projected. It sounds logical and it's not robust. It's just a good steady pace. But what happens if things are off a little bit and we get into a lower snowfall and lower TOT in that first quarter? The other question is in the insurance thing. It confuses me. Maybe it's different in municipalities. I know in workers' comp, you...

1:38:15 Give them an estimate of what your payroll is. You have your different categories. You have your experience rating. And by that, the insurance carrier estimates your monthly workers' comp insurance payment that's due. And we pay that payment every month. And at the end of the year, they audit you. And they say you either get a refund or you have to pay some more. And this goes on each year. And in the private sector, we get audited each year. And we make it up or we get a credit.

1:38:45 Which they never seem to give you back. They just posted against next year's bill. So I'm not sure how this could have gone on for three years. But like I say, maybe it's different in a municipality. Hopefully someone is looking at the insurance policy and how this goes forward so that in three years we aren't playing catch-up for this year and next year and the third year. So I hope that someone looks at the insurance policy, how it's written, what the rules are.

1:39:13 If they're different for a municipality, if they can only increase it by a certain amount so that we don't get into this problem again, maybe even find ways to reduce our insurance costs. Thank you very much. Question for Tom. Thank you, Tom. You know, we may have to worry about what happens if it snows through July and August. We're going to shift the seasons.

1:39:36 Mary, if I may, John, before you speak, just on that note, we have gone through the slides so fast, and I didn't have a chance to present the actual table of revenues. It is in the agenda packet, but just to clarify,

1:39:52 First of all, our projections, and I've done projections for many years, and it's something that I started doing in my career. But the projections are based on not only the historical information, but also known trends for the future.

1:40:07 What we're projecting for the next year is a lower level of DOT than what we're experiencing in the current year. So we are projecting a decline knowing that the level of snow are not going to be as high in the next year as they are in the current year. So I wanted to clarify that. Good evening. My name is John Wentworth. There's a lot to talk about. John Varouk alluded to more bad news on the horizon.

1:40:41 Probably an infinite amount of bad news. But I'm speaking on behalf of an NGO, non-governmental organization. And there are several of these in this community that represent a set of tools and capacities to get things done. I think starting to stay with the Measure U discussion. Mariana represented how it is no longer on the books for the general fund.

1:41:10 But the citizens of this community voted. This was a second two-thirds revenue measure. They voted to support that because they want to invest in this place. Measure R was a similar measure. The citizens of this place are investing in this place, and they're investing in it specifically for what the future holds. And I think that speaking

1:41:35 From a modest organization that lost our entire operational funding four days before Christmas, we found a way to survive and to bring things forward to the community. This is a very scrappy, unique place with an enormous reservoir of spirit and capacity to get things done. And if the town, as an organization, has to start thinking about entirely new ways of doing business,

1:42:04 To reach outside of the crisis that you're in, to the capacity this community has, there is a community out here that wants to meet you and figure out ways to do things in new ways to get to a future beyond not just this fiscal crisis, but the promise of whatever fiscal crisis this lawsuit settlement's going to bring. We're going to get to the future, but it's going to require doing things in new ways and thinking of doing things in new ways.

1:42:32 And I think Marianna's suggestions are certainly reasonable in terms of everybody getting together to figure out a way to make these things work. From the NGO capacity out here outside of government, we're certainly willing to do whatever it takes to make these things work, but it's going to be important to have a commitment from the council, from the leadership of this community, to make sure that those opportunities for efficiencies and for doing things in new ways

1:42:58 That you give that direction to the management, that gets from the management through the staff to these capacities outside here, and then we can report back to you that we are in fact doing these things. There is an enormous reservoir of capacity out here to get things done to get us through this stuff. And I want to make sure that you know that it's out here and it's here to be taken advantage of, to work effectively together to move to the future. You know, there's a...

1:43:22 A lot of information that's going to be coming from the trail system in the coming weeks and months about how to get to the future. We're working with Mammoth Lakes Tourism to build the product that's going to bring the people here, that's going to get the TOT happening to get us out of this hole. And I don't want to go on and on and on, but just a couple of points to make sure that we hit.

1:43:43 Measure U is not available to the general fund. Measure U is available to this community. Let's get this program up, get this process in place and start getting these funds strategically targeted to the things we need to invest in. Skip, you mentioned a couple of meetings back about efficiency. It's out here. We can figure out a way to make these things work. There's a guy who came here in December who was a photographer who talked about outsourcing and working with, you know, the time is now to start figuring out, let's really start putting these things together to make all this stuff happen.

1:44:14 I won't believe this, but in these coming discussions, this community is larger than its government, it's larger than its individual businesses, it's larger than just the NGOs. We're all in this thing together. But we're going to have to work efficiently and differently in new ways to get past all this stuff. So you have our commitment to do that. Thank you. Thank you, John. Lee? I have a question. When you were talking about the TOT compliance officer, is that for TOT only?

1:44:50 No, the position that we're recommending is for financial analysis, budget preparation, and TOT compliance. There are going to be a number of responsibilities that that employee would have. So you're not talking about a town compliance officer? Part of the responsibilities is going to be compliance, but there are going to be additional responsibilities. Is that something I would like the town not to overlook?

1:45:16 We've been asking for a town compliance officer for a long time. We haven't had one since Rick Blumeris left. The town is a free-for-all right now. You can do whatever you want. Once you actually get a town compliance person to get people back into doing the law, the town's going to have a hard time because these people are going to fight you. I've been doing it for two years. Why can't I do it anymore? We need a town compliance officer. And I know right now you can call Johnny if you've got a problem.

1:45:43 Johnny is a building inspector, and he is a very, very busy person. And he explained to me, building inspection is his number one job because if something goes wrong, it can hurt the town. You want to talk still? Okay. And so he was saying town compliance is his number one thing. So when it comes to other stuff, that's at the bottom of the list. And someday, I'm going to go around with him, and I'm going to videotape for you guys what he does, because he is busy 24 hours a day when he's here.

1:46:13 When John Veruca was saying to get rid of the DIF fees, I disagree. The DIF fees are to fix the areas that they impact around it of the development. Sierra Valley Sites is one area that has been at the shortfall of all this. It's been neglected in this area, and this area needs to be improved, and it's all because of the developments around it, and we want to make sure that the developments above it always mitigate and have the DIF fees paid because

1:46:42 It needs to be done. Another place the money needs to go to is the tourism. I have to say the mountains are doing a very, very good job on their tourism. I've talked to people in San Francisco, they say every time they turn their head, they see it on the billboard, they hear it on the radio, they see it on the television. You cannot miss Mammoth Mountain in San Francisco. But they never see anything in the town of Mammoth Banks.

1:47:06 Tourism is very important in this town. A lot of people are losing their jobs. The businesses are laying out their employees to where just the owners are running it. Our town is in a hard time right now. Tourism is very, very important. When it comes to public safety, I've talked about this before, we do need another police officer. Another thing for Sierra Valley sites, they go through our area to not get a drunk driving ticket at night from the bars.

1:47:30 The bars have a hard time. The officers may have to go up to Bridgeport or short officers. We need another police officer. Public safety is the number one thing in this town that should be taken care of. And again, Marianna, you say that you should be happy to thank you that you are. I have talked to a lot of people that have said that they thank you for what you've done.

1:47:55 You have strong leadership. You've gotten the town staff to live together. And that's the only way that this has all come together is from your leadership. And we actually understand what you're talking about. And that's a first. And we do thank you, and I hope you take it as a compliment. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Mark? Mayor, I'd like to respond to the code compliance staffing. About two years ago,

1:48:18 Maybe three years ago, we did lose our specific code compliance officer, and so thereafter, we combined our public works and community development staff that are in the field into the inspection services and code compliance work group. That group has been very effective and is out in the streets all the time conducting code compliance issues. Johnny Gates, who is here in our audience, Ron Fansler.

1:48:42 We do prioritize the life safety first.

1:49:12 The snow continues to melt, maybe if it continues to melt, we'll again begin our trash patrols. And in the fiscal year 11-12 budget, we've recommended, aside from the budget issues you have to deal with, increasing an allocation of planning department staff to code compliance to focus on zoning code related issues. So we do have...

1:49:37 Actually, a very effective code compliance program, given the resources we have to it. And we would probably not recommend in the future having a specific code compliance officer, because the structure that we've developed through the work group is far more effective. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. You may. When he was talking about trash and all that stuff, to help take it off the staff a bit, I think that should be included in Steve Sears' contract.

1:50:08 You know, when he drives around, he used to be washing the trash and everything, reporting to his department what's going on, and that would give our staff more time to be doing what they're doing, because that's part of his job as a wildlife specialist. It's a thought. To let you know, Lee, what we have done is Steve now carries a citation book, and Steve is in, has the ability to address those issues if it becomes, if it is in fact an issue, and he can do everything from give a warning.

1:50:35 To write a citation if he feels it's a repeat offender, Steve does have that ability. So we have taken one small step towards taking some of that responsibility off of some of our other staff members and having Steve take that over. So then you won't have to be calling staff on the right to give them more time to do the jobs that they need to do.

1:50:54 You get a hold of the police department and they'll call Steve Searles. That would be, you call us, that's one of us, be it the police department or the town offices, if it's needed, we will do that. And Steve's out enough too that he will begin, he tracks the bears and he knows where some of these issues are and I'm sure he will stay on top of it. Would it be better to call the police department so you don't have to bother the staff because they're so busy?

1:51:16 All we're trying to do is make sure, for some people who don't know who to call, if they call either one, we can get the message to Steve. It's a simple, quick phone call, either direction, and we can take care of that. Yes. Good evening, Pam Hennerty with Mammoth Lakes Housing. I would really just like to echo the sentiments of my NGO partners out here, John Ernie and John Wentworth. We have been in partnership with the town for a long time. We recognize that there are financial troubles both within the town.

1:51:50 With our businesses, with our residents. We have been working with Mariana and the staff, and we will leave no stone unturned to be able to try and work within the budget constraints we're facing. We also, while doing that, want to continue to urge the town to not lose sight of the vision and the mission and the planning. We heard John Ruth talking about the plans for the towns and how that's continuing to go and how I think that's been successful.

1:52:19 We need to be bringing people into town through the marketing efforts, but we also need to be sure that we're focused on the people who are here when we serve those people. The bad economic times are far reaching and we're seeing that every day in the housing office where people are coming in. We've been able to evolve over time. As you recall, we've started as a major development.

1:52:43 And we moved into down payment assistance. Now we're in acquisition rehab and we're becoming certified in homeownership counseling to help potential buyers not get into foreclosure as well as help those who are in foreclosure situations to try to avoid those things. And so we just urge that you recognize that you have strong partners in this community who are willing to help and participate and do whatever we can in this economic time to help you with that, but also to not lose sight.

1:53:12 The fact that there's hard economic times around and that we need to keep the long-term visions and maintain this to be a wonderful place for the people who live and serve those folks we're working to attract.

1:53:24 Thank you. Thank you. Pam, just out of curiosity. Go ahead. No, go ahead. Probably the same question. You mentioned the economic times. How is your inventory at this time? Are you seeing more demand for certain units, and are we able to keep up the demand, or are we running in a shortfall? How are we doing with inventory? We have a huge demand for rental housing right now.

1:53:50 The lending market is still somewhat difficult to get into. Lenders are looking for bigger down payments than most people have available. So we do have a waiting list of about 85 households on our rental waiting list. We have recently, two years ago, recently, completed a home ownership project. So our home ownership project was completed right as things were taken.

1:54:15 A very bad turn in the economy. Lenders had way over corrected. So we had 24 units at the Aspen Village Complex that we've been working for two years now to sell. I'm proud to say we are down to two units left. So there are two for sale units in our inventory that we're working to sell. But we do have a huge demand in the rental market. We're looking at some different programs to apply for this year that would help people that are in existing rental situations.

1:54:44 Who have had some kind of downturn that may be able to help them on a short-term basis to augment their rental payments. We haven't gotten into that program, but there's a new program available. We do have the Star Apartments, which is acquisition of an existing complex that we're rehabbing that we're hoping to get started on construction next month.

1:55:06 So that we can bring those up to better living conditions for four households in the community. So we do have a continued need in rental that we're chipping away at and hoping to continue to provide those units. Thank you. John. Just congratulations on getting down to two units at Aspen Village. That's huge. Well done. So good job. Thank you. Is there anyone else that would like to speak? If not, we will move into council deliberations.

1:55:40 Just so you know, I'm supportive of one and two and not prepared to give any additional input on number three as yet. I'd like to talk about it a little bit first. A couple questions I have.

1:56:03 Before we just go through and, let's say, accept the items outlined in Section C, I want a little bit of clarification on reductions being applied fairly and across the board. I'm a little confused on this statement versus what was said earlier as opposed to there just being a blanket adjustment across the board. I think our various measures, you know, we've had a community speak very clearly.

1:56:34 As to where they want that money to go. What percentage of, whether it be TOT or whatever, and where it's supposed to be applied. So I think I need some clarification here. It comes off to me that if we make an adjustment in one department, we have to make a comparable adjustment in other departments or with our, you know, whether it be housing or tourism or whatever. And if that's the case, I absolutely disagree with that.

1:57:03 I think that we have to take, whether it be departments or areas of the community and look at where the demand is and we have to apply adjustments accordingly. So if you could please clarify that a little bit. And then on the advertisement for the various positions, I agree with you in that, I mean, you know the finance department better than I do.

1:57:28 So I can't speak to that, but obviously we've been talking about the TOT compliance person. And before, I think we, and I think it needs to happen quickly, but before we rush into hiring an employee, I'd like to have some consideration of the fact that maybe we can outsource that position and possibly the others. Because one of the things we're discussing

1:57:51 Previously is an increase because of contractual obligations of up to $350,000 because of benefits and whatnot. I don't want to see us keep going down this path where we're contractually obligated to keep doing this every single year. So until we get a resolution there, I would like to look into outsourcing. Those are my only two real concerns right now. I would love to. So the first one is on the first budget principle.

1:58:21 Again, as I stated, I do not believe in across-the-board reductions without looking into the details of those reductions. However, what this principal attempts to do is to put everything on the table so we can look at everything that's in our budget and determine if a reduction of 13 percent or 15 percent or 5 percent or 0 percent is applicable to a certain area.

1:58:46 But the first step should be to place everything on the table. Now, once we place everything on the table, and once we have, under the second principle, various organizations step up and determine how they could contribute, it may not be reduction. It may be a revenue increase.

1:59:06 I mentioned that. John and I, without discussing necessarily details, have been talking about how Mammoth Lakes Tourism might contribute to the solution of the budget problem, and it may not include reductions. It may include revenue increases. So again, this principle attempts to put everything on the table and engage everyone in discussions so that everyone contributes, but it may not be a cut to their funding.

1:59:36 So I can move on to the second item unless you have something. Yeah, I think just really quickly, I just want to make sure that we don't start looking at areas that have been doing well and saying, wow, well, they have some money. Let's put it in this other area and start this supplanting process. I want to be careful of that. So that's on that item. I just want to make sure we're clear on that. That's my concern.

2:00:01 And ultimately, obviously, those are the policy decisions for you to make and to give us direction to, but again, staff urges you to put everything on the table and engage everyone in the discussion of the problem that we have. The second question or concern that you had is on the two positions. Both positions are...

2:00:24 Not only critical, but requires someone who would have the knowledge of the town. And once you contract out a position, you almost necessarily lose that knowledge. So that's my concern, especially on the payroll and accounting piece.

2:00:40 What we could do, and this goes back to the TOC, I know one of your concerns, Councilmember Lehman, has been that an individual who is more commission-based, if you would, would do a better job, and I agree with you. So maybe what we do is have this compliance person who would issue letters, respond to phone calls, track revenues, just do the regular assignments that a town employee would do.

2:01:04 But at the same time have an additional contract that is contingency-based, commission-based. If you collect so much in revenue, we give you a percentage of that revenue. So that would be in addition to this position. And that probably would be necessary before we get the program up and running. So that might be something that we should be able to do. As far as union contracts, whether you have an outside organization, outside person providing a service,

2:01:34 Or an employee providing a service, you would have a contract with them. So just a matter of what's in that contract. Okay. Let me just add to that also. I've talked with Mariana about the outsourcing, particularly on the payroll issues. And there was quite a bit of research done with other cities that have contracted out with payroll companies, the ones that are available for municipalities. And it was a general consensus amongst those communities that

2:02:03 The payroll was not being handled in a manner that was accurate enough and at times it was actually even putting them in jeopardy of being in violation of some getting tax payments done on time or payroll taxes being paid properly, checks being received in the required time. So at this time there just really doesn't seem to be a qualified

2:02:28 Okay. Let's see. On the budget principles, I believe in them. I interpret the first one as saying that everything is on the table, there's no sacred cows, we're going to look at everything together and then figure it out. The reality is we've got a lot of pain to look at and we might have to be very creative about it.

2:02:59 I look at number two in our recommendation of the positions as showing that we are looking at things in different ways, that two working level positions are more important to us at this point than a director and that it gets the jobs done that are going to need to get done. So I fully support that, recognizing that starting now, it'd be likely that the person is not...

2:03:27 Thank you, Jim. I've had enough time since we've been

2:03:56 I'm the representative that's been going down to Los Angeles for some of these meetings with the lawsuit. I've had quite a big time to spend with Marianna sitting next door on a plane discussing a lot of these issues and going over what many of our options are. And I think what I appreciate is that we do have a very open presentation here. We know what is out there, what we can look at, and I am comfortable with this first step in the process and willing to...

2:04:24 Move forward, and if we have a motion, we might be able to wrap this up. Okay, then, Mr. Mayor, I will approve adoption of Recommendations 1, 2, and 3 as listed on page 6 of our agenda. Second. I have a motion and a second. Further discussion.

2:04:44 If there is none, roll call please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. We will take a five-minute break and come back for item number two. And may I just remind everyone that the next special meeting at 3 o'clock on May 25th is going to be at a different location, right, Mariana?

2:05:07 Yes, I believe the meeting, and Jamie, why don't you address that, because you probably have the exact address for the May 25th meeting. It's in the town conference room of Mammoth Lakes Tourism, 2520 Main Street. Okay, thank you. Glad you told us, thank you. That's why I was sitting here by myself. There is everybody. Thank you.

2:09:27 I'm going to go ahead and recuse myself on this one. I have a potential conflict. I represented Mammoth Times in their most recent move. So, excuse me. You might have fun in the white room. Oh, yeah. It's really boring in there. If I was to go with him, keep him company. Oh, it's boring. Okay. Staff report from Jamie, please.

2:10:05 Now that we have two adjudicated newspapers in the town of Mammoth Lakes, annually we have to award the contract for the publication of the town's legal notices. You can hear me. So I sent out the bid. We received two bids, one from Mammoth Times and one from the sheet. The Mammoth Times didn't answer all of the questions in the bid package, so I do not have an apples-to-apples comparison.

2:10:39 What they submitted is attached to the agenda bill. Thank you. Any questions? Jamie? Thank you. Any comments from the applicants? If you'll come to the microphone and state your name, please. Before we start, I was hoping that the Mammoth Times could, they had a non-exclusive versus exclusive price. I don't quite understand that. If they could elaborate on that, that would be great. Thank you. Rick Rosner, publisher of Mammoth Times.

2:11:25 I want to thank Councilor Ron, who is just you, and explain to you why we feel Mammoth Times is the best vehicle for your presentation. We are part of a Verizon California Publications, which consists of Mammoth Times and all its publications, and the Indian Register in Bishop. And we've been around just a place since the Indian era, I think, for the publications, particularly the Indian Register.

2:11:52 We are owned, in turn, we operate independently in the most of the Horizon Publications, which is in Chicago, who runs a variety of community publications. We have big experience nationally and in Canada also for putting out the finest community newspapers out there. We, in addition to the fact that we are a company consisting, as I mentioned, of video-monna publications.

2:12:20 We have about 13 employees in the area, eight of whom live in Mammoth. Some of them are here. We have George Shirk, our part of RWA board. We have Anne Brooks, our section director, Grace Brooks, our business manager, and I think we have our editor. In addition, we have a variety of other employees who live in Mammoth. We have been located in Mammoth far prior to my

2:12:49 So we've been here a whole long time in various incarnations and we have rented space and paid taxes in this town since then. So we feel that we have, we're interested in continuing to support the community.

2:13:19 As our employees who live here and spend money here. We, forgive me for one second, while I thought so many things before I came up here that I brainwashed myself. Thank you, Tom. We are a paid publication as opposed to, well, there are three basic kinds of circulation in the newspaper and magazine business.

2:13:50 The first is single copy sale. Second is paid circulation. And third is controlled circulation, which is a person who agrees in writing that they want to receive a particular publication. Those are three categories of circulation. So when you compare the numbers of publications that go out to the community, you have to realize that print run is not a measure of circulation for obvious reasons.

2:14:21 It doesn't mean that they've been read or they've been picked up. It means they've been printed. We quote in our numbers we give with you folks. By the way, I apologize to Jamie. I didn't get a hard copy of the RFP. I had an electronic copy, and I only found the front page. I didn't push the button to follow up. But I'll explain to you the differences in the pricing, although the price really isn't a critical issue. When you compare different kinds of circulation,

2:14:54 You have to understand whether, in fact, the publications are picked up or just left on newsstand. One of the reasons that every major newspaper and publication in the country and the world is paid is for two reasons. First of all, they make themselves independent advertising by being able to charge for their content. And the second reason is when you charge for a publication, you're able to measure, in fact,

2:15:22 And document that you have publications that are going into the hands of the readers. So we are proud of the fact that we can quote exact numbers not only in terms of print run, but in terms of the exact numbers of papers that are read by the residents of Mammoth. And there is no way that a free publication can document the identity of the readership that's actually being read in numbers. So as an example, and that's one of the reasons why

2:15:52 The price is relatively unimportant. In both cases, although we quote a much lower price per column inch, I must admit that at the end of the day, because of the size of the columns, our prices are roughly equivalent. So there isn't any big advantage in going to either one of these papers. The advantage for us is that we can document that we have the leadership that we claim to have. Roughly half the people in Mammoth are based on a population of 7,000.

2:16:23 Half the people in Mammoth are subscribers or read the Mammoth Times. It's not a question of opinion, it's a question of fact. We have 2,662 readers circulate by subscription and purchase in the Mammoth area, and an additional 800 are second homeowners who subscribe in the Los Angeles area.

2:16:51 So we have about 3,400 readers, which is roughly half the 7,000 people in Mammoth. Not a question of opinion, not a question of evidence, but a fact. And therefore, we feel that if you're trying to reach the residents of Mammoth, as opposed to visitors, that we have the best access to those readers. Now, to address Ted's question,

2:17:18 We are cognizant of the fact that anything in this organization is that you have money constraints. We're interested in making the best possible offer regardless of the proper structure for our newspaper, but we don't feel that we should have to compete with a publication that doesn't have the proven circulation by offering a very low price unless we have the exclusive access. We're more than happy to offer it.

2:17:47 The other price, which is still about the same equivalent price as the sheet is offering, but we feel that if you want to commit to one of our publications, that we have a very strong story to tell and very strong benefits to offer, and that's the reason it's structured. I'm happy to answer any questions. Thank you, Rick. Are there any questions? I'm still not understanding what you're talking about there. Are you saying that we would do?

2:18:15 All of our advertising only in the Mammoth Times to get the lower rate? Yes. Question, Jim? No, sir. Thank you. Thank you, Rick. Ted Carlton again. I'm sorry my employees couldn't be here. They're out working. You know, I'm going to treat the exclusive versus the, I'm going to wait until he finishes, but if I'm going to treat the exclusive versus non-exclusive to start, I mean,

2:19:02 That seems a little absurd. I mean, for example, if the town wants to publish a particular meeting notice, which is of great importance to the public, or a snow safety warning, you're necessarily going to publish that everywhere. You're not going to jeopardize the public's right to know or the public's safety because you have some sort of exclusive contract. So I'm going to ignore that bid because I just don't think it's realistic. I certainly wouldn't expect it on my end.

2:19:30 I thought Jamie did a great job in writing an agenda bill which attempted to get apples-to-apples answers, and there is enough information to kind of do that. If the Man of the Times column width is 50% less, then you could probably tack 50% onto the 570 they bid, and you end up at 855 versus my 990, just to let you know that

2:19:59 The prices are comparable. I commend Mr. Rosner for actually pointing that out. The prices are largely equivalent. I think the big difference here is Jamie pointed out in the agenda bill that you spent $29,000 with the Mammoth Times in 9-10 and you've spent $15,000 with me to this point this year and the fiscal year is almost done.

2:20:33 What I did talk to Jamie about before I got up here, that $29,000 was actually spent over an eight-month period because I was awarded the contract in March of 2010. So realistically, the Mammoth Times was charging you about $45,000 a year. Thanks to the fact that I became a paper of legal record, you saved $30,000 a year or nearly two-thirds. The question would be, if you have an accountant,

2:21:08 Who you find out has been kind of ripping you off. And do you go back to the accountant just because they claim they've reformed and planned to charge you less now? That they're somehow going to be a better partner? I think you need to go with the person that gave you a realistic and ethical and proper bid last year and has delivered. I don't know what Jamie's...

2:21:41 I don't think any of the reasons cited for awarding the

2:22:10 The bid last year have changed. And finally I would note, you know, in terms of circulation, so I print 2,000 more papers on average per week. Do I do that for my health? Do I want to spend $500, $600, $700 more per week because I just want the papers to sit out there and make it look like it's being read? No. I print the papers because they're picked up and read and enjoyed by the community.

2:22:43 So would I spend a little extra money for great service, great value, and 50% more circulation? I think that's a pretty good argument, and I'm willing to stick by that. Thank you. Thank you, Ted. You may respond. I don't want this to turn into a debate, but since you took the first shot and he got to respond to you, you may have a chance to respond. First of all, I just have to say that...

2:23:17 On behalf of the Mammoth Times, I resent the implication that any rip-off the current money we can charge you. I think that's an important thing to say. Secondly, the reason that we presented an exclusive bid is that's what the sheet was awarded last year. Thirdly, all I can tell you about a print run versus circulation is what's standard in this country and around the world and what is accepted as being the better of the two circulations, which is if it's free, you don't know who's reading it.

2:23:46 If it's paid for, you know who's reading it, and that's how we can guarantee exactly what it is that we're giving you. And that's basically what we're saying. Thank you. Council's discussion? I wanted to make just two quick observations, if I could skip. It sounds like that the circulation numbers are similar, if not fully identifiable. Circulation, in other words, one side is saying that

2:24:20 That it has a higher circulation and the other side is saying that their circulation is equivalent because they have different aspects of circulation. I would disagree. Yeah, it's a toss-up. And then also that prices are roughly equivalent as well. And certainly pricing and circulation are two important issues. Jill? I have no particular comments. Thank you.

2:24:52 I look at the free aspect, and I am out in the public quite a bit, and I actually see it in my own establishment. Throughout the week, there are newspapers sitting in my shop, indeed. People pick them up and they read them, and they actually neatly fold them back up and put them back on the stand again. Not because they don't want them, they have read them, and they're recycling.

2:25:23 That's what we do here in town. They recycle, so they take a paper and they put it back. And I also think that because they're free, they're always available to the customers Monday the entire week. They're always there for anybody, any tourist, anyone that comes in. When you have to pay for a newspaper, usually you keep it and you take it home with you because you paid for it.

2:25:48 And so that kind of plays a little bit of a part. And I agree with the working relationship idea that it was pretty clear in the agenda bill that staff found this to be a good relationship. It was easy to understand and easy to maintain. And they got all the facts they asked for on the initial application. So I just think those are kind of important things to be considered.

2:26:15 Skip, if I could just say one more thing. Actually, two items. This is the second year, I think, and it's always a really, really difficult decision, I think, not only for myself, but for all the council members, because we're in a small community. We know who the people are from both publications. We recognize how important it is for both publications. My feeling at this time is that we had a satisfactory, if not a good experience.

2:26:46 With what we did this past year. And, you know, if it's not broken, then why do we need to fix it? Do I have a motion? I will move. We approve option one, award the bid to the sheet. I'll second the motion. And a second. Jamie, roll call, please. Councilman Raisman? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Bacon? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 3-0. Thank you all very much. And with that, will you get Matt back, please?

2:27:20 Mr. Mayor, did we pull any of the items? No, we didn't. We didn't ask. Okay. Do we know where he is? He's not in the room there? No. No, he wasn't outside. I think he's at Giovanni. Oh, there is. Oh, there is. Okay. Is that at Giovanni's? Is there any basketball game tonight? There is. Yeah. Well, I know that.

2:27:52 We will move on to our consent agenda items. I didn't give Council a chance to pull Matt. Did you have any on a full consent? No. No. Very good. If there's a motion. I'll move approval of consent agenda items number four through seven. Second. I have a motion. Second. Whole call, please. Jamie. Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Layman? Yes. Mayor Pro Tempkins? Yes. Mayor Harvey? Yes. Motion passes 4-0. And any questions on the register demands? No. No.

2:28:20 If not, my honor, are we going back into closed session again? Yes, we are going back into closed session again, and we will report out. Lydia, do you have a question? Are you going to talk about consent? I'm sorry? Are you going to talk about consent? No, that's on the consent, and no one had any, no one wanted to pull it, so we will not be discussing that. It's the final. It's approved. It's approved. It's approved and through.