TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2021

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 14 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

508 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Dan, is Kirk there with you? Yes, yes, yes, I'm here. Michael, everybody here from your side? Let's see, I see Commissioner Burroughs, I see Commissioner Chang. Recording in progress. I see Commissioner Kennedy, and I thought I saw, there's Commissioner Eckerd. Yeah, we're all here, Linda. Okay, let's get going, shall we?

0:34 Okay, let's start this meeting of Town Council, which is officially starting with a workshop of Planning Economic Development Commission on Wednesday, June 16th at 5 p.m. I'm going to go ahead and read this agenda item just because there may be people listening who aren't sure what we're doing. So we're meeting jointly to for consideration of the concept review application number CR21-001 requesting that the PDC and Town Council

1:02 Give feedback on a proposal to redevelop the Mammoth main lodge base with hospitality and lodging products, multifamily and single family for cell residences, commercial services, including food, beverage and retail offerings, skier service facilities, parking and associated infrastructure and support improvements. So I'm not sure who wants to kick this off. Dan, is that you giving an intro? Sandra, is that you? Yeah, Sandra will kick it off from staff. Thanks.

1:29 Yeah, so thank you all for joining us here today. As Vice Chair Salcido mentioned, this is a joint meeting with the Planning and Economic Development Commission and the Town Council to receive an introduction on the main library development project. So I'm going to hand it over to Chandler, who's going to provide a brief introduction, and then we'll have the applicant team give their presentation. And we're hoping to have about 30 minutes or so for Q&A at the end. So go ahead, Chandler.

1:55 All right. Thanks, Sandra. I'm going to share my screen here. Okay. Let's see. Can everybody see this in slideshow mode? Yes. Okay. So, yes, as we've said, we're here to review the Mammoth Mountain Main Lodge Redevelopment Concept Review, Case Number CR 21001. So, summary, which I think Linda just read.

2:33 We're here for consideration of concept review application number CR 21001 requesting PEDC and Town Council feedback on a proposal to redevelop the Mammoth main lodge base with hospitality and lodging products, multifamily and single family for sale residences, commercial services, including food, beverage and retail offerings, skier service facilities, parking and associated infrastructure and support improvements. So just to quickly go over the purpose of concept review and kind of the framework for how

3:01 For what we're looking for here. So the purpose of concept review is to inform the applicant of town requirements as they apply to the proposed development project, provide a list of issues that will likely be of concern during formal application review, suggest possible alternatives or modifications to the project based on identified development standards or other adopted policies and regulations, and identify any technical studies that may be necessary for the environmental review process.

3:30 Just to clarify, that means, you know, this is not an entitlement application. We're not looking for a formal decision or approval or denial. This is really just the chance for the Planning Commission and the Town Council to give feedback on the project and let the applicant know what they think and what they would like to see change, if anything, when they come back in for formal entitlements. So a little background before I get into the entitlement process. You all probably remember the Forest Service approval of the 2019 Land Exchange.

4:00 And that resulted in the Mammoth Main Lodge base, parcel A and parcel B together comprising approximately 36 acres of land are now owned by Mammoth Mountain Main Lodge Redevelopment LLC, who is the applicant. They are located within the municipal boundary limits of the town, although currently there is no zoning designation or general plan land use designation. They currently include commercial uses and associated infrastructure.

4:27 Including Mammoth Mountain Inn, the Yodeler Restaurant, Gondola and Ski Lift Bases, the Snowmobile and Snowcap Rental and Port Service, Wastewater Treatment Ponds and Parking Areas. The purpose of the exchange was to facilitate potential future redevelopment of the parcels, to increase the intensity of use of the parcel and modernize or replace outmoded and decrepit facilities that have reached the end of their useful life. And then they list basically the acceptable uses that may be allowed.

4:54 So I'm just going to very briefly go over the concept review proposal. The applicant also has a presentation where they're going to get into a lot more detail and show, you know, all the awesome pictures and everything. I'm just going to very quickly go over it at a bird's eye view. So in total, new and existing development on parcels A and B and adjacent ski area permit land will include up to 415 residential units, up to 450 lodging keys distributed between several locations.

5:21 Up to 156,000 square feet of commercial space, 175,000 square feet of skier services and support areas, and about 1,443 parking stalls. Minaret Road is also proposed to be realigned along the northern edge of Parcel A to facilitate direct connection to the permit area and to the new village. And supporting improvements are proposed on Forest Service permit land, including reconstruction of the existing MATLAGE skier services facility.

5:48 New visitor parking lot, a new pulse gondola, and additional ski trails. I'm going to show you some very quick pictures here. This is the overall site plan. Hopefully you all had a chance to look at the attachment, which was the project description and concept review submittal. That was included with the staff report. Parcel A is on the south. Parcel B is on the north. This is a close-up of parcel A with just a site plan showing bird's eye view of the proposed buildings.

6:18 Which will be all residential uses. This is showing the cabins and street network in there. So the other important piece that we want to talk about today, staff, is the entitlement process. So I mentioned that concept review is really just the chance to provide kind of informal feedback. The project will require several different entitlements. It's a very large and complex project.

6:47 So there will be a lot of different opportunities for the Planning Commission and Town Council to revisit the project, to approve, recommend approval, or deny, et cetera. So just a list of the required entitlements. So it will require a general plan, zoning code, and zoning map amendments to include the parcels within the town's urban growth boundary as provided for in policy L6E of the general plan, and to create a Mammoth Main Lodge-based specific plan.

7:16 Land Use Designation and Zoning District. As I just mentioned, it will also require a specific plan that will establish the density, permitted uses, associated development standard, design guidelines, et cetera. Basically, the zoning for the site will be the specific plan. The applicant has also indicated that they are going to submit a development agreement request. We do not have any information on what is going to be asked for in the development agreement at this time, so I haven't really included any information on that, but

7:45 It's worth noting that the development agreement process is kind of its own separate process from all the other entitlements that will require extensive negotiations with the Town Council. Additionally, the following discretionary and ministerial approvals will be required from the Town. These include tentative and final track maps, design review, and grading and building permits. So, as I mentioned in the staff report, really kind of the most

8:17 Important findings, I think, for the Council and Planning Commission to consider at this point are the findings for approval of a specific plan because the specific plan is really going to create the zoning for the site and really dictate how the site is developed and all the nitty-gritty details. The findings for specific plan approval are quite broad with the primary finding being that the specific plan is consistent with the general plan and other adopted goals and policies of the town.

8:46 So it gives the approval bodies, you know, fairly broad reach as far as what policies they do or do not find the project to be consistent with. So that's just something I mentioned to kind of help guide the discussion to try to just keep the general plan or other adopted goals and policies of the town in mind. So in terms of the public process, I just want to go over this because this is...

9:13 Really kind of where the Planning Commission and the Town Council will have additional opportunities to review the project, provide comments on the project, and where also the public will be able to be involved in the review of the project. So the required amendments to the general plan, zoning code, and the zoning map will all require a public hearing and recommendation by the Planning Commission, as well as a public hearing before the Town Council.

9:42 After which the council will have to vote to approve, conditionally approve, or deny these applications. As I mentioned before, there will also be a development agreement. So that will also require, I'm actually not positive that that requires a recommendation by planning commission, but I believe it does. And then also ultimate approval by town council. So in addition to the required entitlements through the town, a joint environmental impact report slash environmental impact statement.

10:11 We'll be prepared to satisfy both CEQA and NEPA requirements because this project is partially on federal land. That's where the NEPA comes in. So in terms of public process, this process will include a noticing and scoping period. That's anticipated in August or September of 2021, later this summer. During the 30-day scoping period, there will be a joint public scoping meeting and open house, which will be organized by the Town and the Forest Service.

10:40 The public draft of the EIR EIS, which is anticipated in April of 2022, will have a 45-day public review period, and there will be a public hearing held during that time. And then the final EIR EIS, these hearings are hoped for in December of 2022, and these will be the final public hearings before PEDC and Town Council addressing the EIR EIS certification and overall project approval.

11:10 So when you look at all this, there'll be at least four other opportunities, public hearings with both the Planning Commission and Town Council as the project moves forward. So I've provided some discussion questions, and these we can come back to if we need to, because the applicant does have a presentation, so I'll take this off the screen. But just as kind of general guiding questions, overall, does the project, as shown, appear consistent with the Town's general plan and other adopted goals and policies?

11:39 What key issues should the applicant take into consideration as they develop their entitlement application package? And are there related issues outside of the project area that the applicant should consider? For example, public access to devil's post pile, employee housing, et cetera. So that's all I have. Now I'm going to turn it over to Mark Brownlee. He's with the Mountain and is part of the applicant team. And they're going to give a presentation. And then after that, we can...

12:08 And move forward with discussion. Thanks, Chandler. And thanks to everyone on the call and Chandler and also, Sandra, for providing the support to get to this point and sharing some of your precious time this evening. On our call this evening, from the Mammoth standpoint, there are David Cochran, who's a principal with DLDT Associates. It's a full service design and construction consultancy out of Georgia, Atlanta. We have...

12:38 Aaron Ashley, who is a longtime associate of Mammoth Mountain, but also with the town with regard to development plans from Hart Harrington. We have Tom Hodges, our vice president of development at Mammoth and Dune Mountains. And we have the newly appointed president and CEO of Mammoth Mountain and Dune Mountain, Ron Cohen. I saw Ron on there earlier. Would you like to say hello to your new community, Ron? Hey, everyone. Great to be back.

13:09 Thank you. Short and sweet, unlike the previous president and CEO, and he has a much better accent, obviously. Just as a point of working through the next stages of this process, but also for the community at large, as we seek a replacement for Ron at Squaw Valley and Alpine Meadows, Ron and I will be remaining in our respective day-to-day operations at myself for Mammoth in June.

13:37 And Ron at Squaw Valley and Alpine Meadows as we find the right replacement for Ron, which we don't really have a specific timeframe on that. So this has been a long process to get to this point. It's been over 20 years of a lot of collaboration from the US Forest Service, the town, other agencies, and obviously Mammoth Mountain.

13:59 It's not a surprise for anyone, as you see the plans, I'm sure. We've shared with the community our strategic plan over the past three to five years, and this has been one of those anchor points in Mammoth's future for ourselves, but also we believe the community as well. Other community items we've invested in are $22 million in Canyon Lodge. We did that to

14:23 Take the Soviet block kind of architecture to the next level of guest experience. But we also did it to drive third party development within the region and provide a catalyst. Obviously COVID got in a wee bit of the way of the next stages of that. But we see Yotelpad somewhat, but really the limelight development that will happen at the village as part of that third party development that we're hoping to drive as a community. I think as we look forward towards

14:53 What the main lodge land development really means. We're looking to continue what we really built as a foundation during COVID with our community. And that was partnering on the safety and the economic development of our community during the most challenging of times. And we look to do that going forward with this process as well. We're really custodians of Dave McCoy's legacy.

15:18 As we think about this, Mammoth is very unique as you look across the ski industry as a whole that we have great access points from Eagle, the Village, Canyon, and then up towards Main Lodge where people can get into their Eastern Sierra Mountain environment. The unique aspect about the Main Lodge development and where the Main Lodge sits is that it's at the cul-de-sac of our entry portals.

15:44 And by that, I mean, you know, it's the most attached to the wilderness, as we saw some points that Chandler was making about Devil's Postpile. We're very cognizant of that. We want to make sure that we do something that's absolutely uniquely relevant to our environment and also to the legacy of Dave and others in our community. We think of that as we have access for everyone. We don't have a...

16:12 Look down our noses if you're not able to ski down Dave's or go hike to the minarets. We want you to come and enjoy the community of Mammoth as a discoverer and have a real attachment to our wilderness and our environment where you can become the best version of yourself. So you'll see some plans this evening that are still getting worked upon, but that's really one of the anchoring...

16:38 Kind of philosophies that we have as we drive this forward and like I said, partnering with the community. So look forward to people's feedback. We've shared this with a large number of our community members and it's been going very well, very well received and it's very exciting for us and we hope that you're excited by it as well. I'd love to turn it over to David Cochran to take the next stage of this presentation this evening. Thank you very much, everyone.

17:05 Thanks, Mark. Good evening, everyone. Again, I'm David Cochran, Principal of the ELDT Associates, and as Mark mentioned, we're a consulting, development, planning, management, construction management, process management firm. We do specialize in leisure, lifestyle, and hospitality, and doing extensive work in ski resorts and recreational areas around the country in Canada with Altera.

17:34 They're partners. We're really excited to be involved in this process and in the Mammoth community. I actually got involved in Mammoth back when Altero was formed and did the acquisition and I was part of the due diligence. I kind of fell in love with the place when I was there for a brief two or three days the first time. So I'm really excited about this project and I think we're all excited about what the project will mean to the area and the community and the mountain.

18:06 And we've put a lot of thought into our design and planning going right back to what Mark was just talking about is really accentuating and embracing this adventure culture and the point of departure for all the great things that the Eastern Sierra provides and hoping that Mammoth Mountain and the other project or Main Lodge redevelop and the other projects we're looking at.

18:33 Serve as a great home base for that kind of stuff. I wanted to take just a quick minute to, I'm going to be a little bit redundant on something Chandler said, but I just wanted to refresh everybody on what the process has been, as Mark alluded to, 20 some odd years working through the land exchange. The land exchange was finalized last March 2nd, which then of course was kind of the launching off point.

19:03 To really proceed with the process that we're in now. I was brought in in June. My role as program managers to shepherd the entire process that we're marching through now to from the initial conceptual planning through the fulfillment and completion of an overall plan, the CEQA process, the NEPA process, all the town processes.

19:31 And really get this project to a point where we're ready to initiate development. And hopefully I'll also stay around for the first few years and watch some things get put together and built. Our general timeline, I'm going to be very, very general here. As I said, Chandler kind of pointed out a couple of these. This year, over the course of the spring and the summer, we are anxious to get in the field.

19:59 And begin doing the field studies that are required for CEQA and NEPA. And of course, in the Mammoth environment, we've got some pretty narrow windows on some of those activities with botany and wildlife and so on. So we're anxious to get in the field and start those, which then leads into the noticing and scoping period more towards the end of the summer 3Q. And we're driving for our first draft, the first review draft of the

20:29 EIR, EIS by mid-December, end of December. Then we'll move on into 2022. And by spring of 2022, hopefully have the public draft of the EIR and EIS and begin that whole public comment, public review, public response process. And then get to all of the various final hearings and approvals and the end of the road, so to speak.

20:59 By the end of the year, next year. Our ambition and really dedicated to this is to get all of those things done so that we can really begin development activities as they become defined in spring of 2023. Altera is anxious to really start seeing this project come to life and now the ski areas and I think the entire community will be. So that's kind of that's

21:28 The process, that's where we are. We are obviously at the very beginning stages. The presentation that Aaron's going to go through with you here in a minute is our conceptual plan. We're pretty proud of it. You'll see it's pretty rough. And we've got a lot of things that we still have to work out and a lot of details that we need to think through. And frankly, we've been looking forward to this particular venue and this particular meeting.

21:55 to get these initial overview comments from everyone so that we can use that as a basis to start moving forward with the planning and the refinement of the planning, the more specific documents that are yet to follow. David, excuse me, could you take a second and maybe introduce some of the staff who are with you tonight? Some of them are, we don't recognize, I think, so if you could maybe just explain to me who's with you here.

22:23 Well, with me, there's no one except for my golden retriever laying on the floor here next to me. Okay. And then Aaron Ashley is a principal with Hart and Howerton. And actually, when I turn it over to Aaron, I'm going to let him introduce a couple of the people that are with him. And, you know, of course, everybody knows Mark and Tom and Ron. So that's kind of the team. There are a couple of new names on the Hart and Howerton side. Okay. All right. That'll work.

22:53 So again, I just wanted to kind of recap the process, reinforce the very beginning stages, punctuate that we're all really excited about this, and I think this is going to be a wonderful project for all of us and a lot of fun to execute as well. With all of that said, Aaron, I think you're on. I hope you're on. I will hand it off to Aaron, and if you could tell us a little bit about Hart-Howerton and your team and then go through the...

23:23 Sure. Good evening. I am in McCall, Idaho, which does not have the bandwidth that Mammoth does, so apologies. Let me share my screen here. By way of introduction, our firm... Hold on one second. Are you all hearing the echo? No, you're sounding good on our end, and the video's good. Okay. Sorry.

24:12 Well, our firm has had the chance to work in Mammoth for some time now. Geez, I think Dave Howerton was working on Creek. And I was skiing Mammoth in the early 80s. And I'm thrilled to know the main launch hasn't changed since then. So it's kind of like jump right left off in high school.

24:45 Rusty engaged us, I guess it was in 2015, 2016, to help the mountain think about itself and a little bit about the town. And we got a chance to meet a number of folks. John Wentworth is the one I recognize more than anybody. Of course, Mark and Ron from the mountain. But that effort was a lot of fun. We had a chance to think about the mountain, the town, what's now called the parcel.

25:18 We got to ask some rusty-like questions, which was fun. But more than anything, it gives a chance to really understand the town, the mountain, and so forth. If you don't mind, I'm going to turn off my camera just to preserve some bandwidth, because I'm in the sticks up here. Okay. So with me on the phone is Jennifer Smith.

25:53 And Jenna Froing, who are both architects and urban designers at our firm. Our firm is about 170 people, planners, architects, landscape architects, interior designers. We work on fun, challenging places. We've had a lot of background in the ski business. You know, a lot of work for Vail over about 25 years in Vail Valley. A lot of work in Park City, all around the mountains there.

26:24 And at places in the Sierras, like Squaw Valley, where we did the specific plan, and North Star and others. So here in Mammoth, you know, it's a little bit of a homecoming for me personally, but it's also a familiar place for the firm. We've had the sort of the ability to look at old

26:54 portfolio that Altera controls and to really understand where the mountain can make improvements and private developers and other landowners can benefit and jump in along with them. I think it's always in its best interest for the town to get developed and improved along with it because it adds to the skier experience, the hiker experience, the mountain biker experience, all that.

27:23 You know, this is principally about launch tonight. But really, it's with an understanding of everything it'll do for the mountain as a whole. So I'm talking specifically about the main lodge. And that is the point of the presentation. There is a number of things going on at the same time with the Forest Service, which relates to how do you get on the mountain? What's the experience?

27:52 How do we make this place really awesome? And so it's called the mill here, which is chairs two and 10. You know, we're not specifically looking at improvements there, but we're thinking about a parking lot and a way to get people on the mountain in a better experience, kind of halfway in between the two. You know, at a base level, this is an amazing piece of land, right?

28:24 It's surrounded all sides by nature. And it's not just sort of mediocre nature, right? This is like as good as it gets. And this is as deep into the eastern Sierra you can get with kind of civilization. And so how do you do that in a smart way that really leverages that kind of just unbelievable address and does right by

28:54 Those adventure seekers and those people who've always sought out Mammoth, choose to drive to Mammoth as opposed to fly to Utah or Colorado. And they don't want this place to be Aspen. They want it to be a version of itself, right? This really cool place to be in nature around cool stuff, cool people, and to get out and do things. And so that high level is sort of the opportunity.

29:25 Destination in Mammoth. Objectively, if you're going to drive real estate values in Mammoth as a whole, this is really the best piece of geography to do that. And so what we can imagine happening at Main Lodge really is the potential of everything. The best experience, the best opportunity to really sort of elevate the Mammoth brand.

29:57 Sort of a number of ingredients that just want to be part of that. I think for a long time, this idea of a world-class ski beach has always been talked about. You know, a lot of our friends and clients in the resort development world have always said, you know, Mammoth has the potential to be the best ski beach in the world. South-facing, unbelievable view, great sun, and what do you do with it?

30:27 And a luxury hotel makes sense. A lot of hospitality driving sort of, quote, hotbeds. This idea of hotel rooms or overnight accommodations. And then what in our package we call commercial space, but it's really all of those other things that make up the daily experience in the winter and the summer. The shopping, the eating, the sort of you want to do with your family.

30:57 And then all the ski services, the rentals, the ski shops, and so forth. And then there's some ideas that sort of bring the best out of Mammoth that you wouldn't do at Steamboat or Vail. And one of those is this idea of an adventure concierge. How do you take baby steps if you're me and you need to work your way into the mountains? Or if you're a hard charger, you know.

31:28 Who shows you where the coolest new place to hike, ride, and climb? And so this adventure concierge concept where the village of Main Lodge becomes sort of the microcosm of the bigger adventure that's offered by Mammoth in the Eastern Sierra. And then, you know, there are things like accommodations for folks who choose to buy here, stay here overnight.

31:58 So that could be called a residence club or other kinds of amenities. And then there's an idea we have, which I'll walk you through, which is to take what could be kind of construed as a conventional village, mountain village, and make it more appealing to a broader demographic, families, kids, non-skiers, non-hikers, people want to be in this great place.

32:27 Whose families are wanting to do all this stuff, but maybe they want to get a latte instead of, you know, hike up the mountain. So just kind of thinking about that idea. We've called that a ski ranch. So the site, as you understand, is really two parcels. And outside of these yellow lines are Forest Service lands that are currently under the ski permit.

32:58 The existing main lodge, for instance, or the existing ski team building, which are part of the experience of this ski beach. For those of you that haven't been down to Parcel B, this is the wastewater treatment ponds for everything that's up there today. So an obvious sort of to-do item for the project is to not have sewer treatment ponds, have us civilized for that.

33:28 And, you know, by consequence sort of make better use of that. So these two parcels are not contiguous and they're the exchange with the Forest Service anticipated a road connecting the two. And then the work we're doing with the Forest Service around the development permit for the mountain as a whole would envelop these two parcels with the rest of the ski permit.

33:58 And honestly, up until about a year ago, it was that way. And for whatever reason, with the transaction, we changed that. So we're going to put that back in place. You know, if you take a bird's eye view of Main Lodge, you've got the road, which really bifurcates Main Lodge and ski terrain, some of the ski terrain, from the gondola and the discovery chair. And so the snow edge,

34:30 When you can control it, really kind of traces this white hatched line. And, you know, much of that is underutilized from a guest experience, visit experience standpoint. There's also just sort of, you know, underutilized or neglected land. You know, we have this two acres on the hill, which really is some stuff. The mountain could probably put somewhere else. It's got a gas tank. It's one of the things.

35:01 And then there's another four acres or so where snow gets pushed over the course of the season and melts away. What you didn't realize, there's only about 200 parking spaces at Main Lodge for skiers and employees. And the balance of the parking is associated with Mammoth Mountain. And just last kind of geography point is the yodeler right there in the middle.

35:33 The big idea and what you saw depicted in the staff report is a series of new buildings, each configured to kind of step up from a pedestrian scale, a number of buildings that really are just one or two stories, others with hotel, for sale residential, hotel, lodging club, a variety of accommodations, new skier services, not just in one building,

36:05 But also distributed through the village to really create a full experience. And the result is a ski beach, the word we use, that's about 1,500 feet long. That stretches from a new, you know, skier services, learn to ski, eat, drink, you know, kind of all the activities along the snow edge to this kind of great address for a hotel.

36:35 1,500 feet to put into comparison is probably one of the biggest, if not the kind of best configured in North America. You know, places like Beaver Creek, which has a really cool ski edge, is only about 1,100 feet. Steamboat's probably got the other biggest, and it's about 1,600 feet. So it's really, it's a big deal. The way this is done,

37:07 is to move Minaret Road, which today obviously traces right along the south edge of the site, and use our land to pull the road through. And what this does is it puts everybody on the beach, right, so that the experience of an arriving guest in summer and winter has that great connection to the snow. And it allows you to start thinking about

37:37 Hosting people here earlier in the spring, later into the fall, because the snow is sort of manageable, and the road is manageable. Part of the idea of unencumbering the site to make the best use of it, and to simplify things with the Forest Service, is to pull the gondola terminal onto the Forest Service land, more or less on where the road is today.

38:08 Same alignment, just the terminal. So this starts to help skiers lap, get on the mountain, and kind of the day-to-day. Another piece of that is to take the connections out to the post file and out to the bigger wilderness, as well as all the people arriving here, you know, in the winter for skiing, and create a proper transit plaza, you know, a really sort of

38:37 Appropriate way to come in here, bus, get out and enjoy your day and really not feel like you have to drive. You know, so in the summer, there'd be parking along the road, parking in the village and a transit stop here that would go out to the post pile. Additionally, if we all think it's a good idea, when folks are coming back from the post pile, the bus could drop you off here.

39:07 Folks could take a nice easy stroll village on their way out. And so we think that this really doesn't just do what it does today, it kind of betters it. Two other things I just wanted to highlight. One is really embracing the between parcel A and parcel B with what we're calling a ski ranch. And this is, it could be fun, learn to ski land. Could be a little tubing hill, little tubing hill.

39:39 But it's also that place at like at 3.30 when you're ready for a glass of wine and your kids want to do six more laps, you can turn them loose on this little bit of ski terrain and they can have a blast while you're doing what you want to be doing. And so it's just about how do you extend that guest experience into more of the day for more folks so they can have a better time here. And then part of this, and you see this kind of snow.

40:08 Sneaking across here is to get a ski back. So from the bottom of chair 10, you can get down into parcel B and enjoy this and then get back onto the mountain. And it's kind of a great win for the chalets because now they've got now a kind of a ski back, ski out. And the last kind of big piece is a hotel. I think it's been our experience and Altera's experience that a marquee hotel.

40:39 Done in an early phase on the best site can really elevate the positioning of this entire village and really kickstart the experience of what it means to be here. And so we, you know, I think the site is really the best site and we've really always earmarked it. A few other components of the plan. So we've kind of differentiated between hotel uses, which

41:10 We're pretty sure hotel uses. And it's certainly the case with the five-star hotel. And residential uses, which we think want to be for sale residential. But I think with all this, what we really want to do in the entitlement process is deliver an experience, limit the massing and other impacts, but retains the flexibility that says,

41:40 Hey, you know what? This is a great residential site, but this awesome hotel operator really wants to be here. If it behaves appropriately, right, the building's the right size, it has enough parking, we'd like the flexibility that that could be a hotel because you don't have that crystal ball that says 10 years from now, we know exactly what it should be. So what we're wanting to do here is to really know enough to sort of...

42:09 Describe the experience that people will have here and describe the maximum impacts of this project, but give ourselves the flexibility to adapt to the market, be flexible so this place can get finished in a recent timeline and not end up being like other projects that sort of are always in that state of being half finished. So just a few other pieces here.

42:39 That still comes up. The idea is there's still a lot of parking on the road. An arriving guest in a bus can come to this generous transit plaza. Tickets, coffee, shops, rentals, your day. If you're dropping kids off from ski school or picking up or you want to come for lunch, there's short-term temporary parking to accommodate that. There's

43:10 Obviously, it's to walk from folks who park on the road. We've anticipated a potential garage for, you know, VIP parking, paid parking under R1, which is a residential building. The Vs indicate village, which is really that kind of small scale, fine grain, you know, shops, restaurants, experiences, skier services, and then all this stuff in between.

43:43 Is a way of thinking about what is Mammoth's version of being out and about in a place like this? So if Vail is a perfect little oval for doing pirouettes on an ice skate, you know, here, could we do like a really cool adventure track, you know, where it's like a ski trail?

44:12 Interesting and funky. Can we do kiosks and dining that are really much more about personality and being outside with friends? And still, you know, provide the kinds of amenities that people expect at the top of the market, pools and hot tubs and spas and so forth. So we've taken a stab at how the ground floor works. So when we talk about commercial, it's everything from skier service, the gondola,

44:43 The dining, the ski school, the lockers, the restrooms. It's restaurants in red, some limited amount of retail in blue, and this is your center that I described. Sometimes it's just easier to kind of see it in 3D. So this is sort of 3D standing above. And I'd say this is the clay model, right? We're thinking about how should buildings step up?

45:14 From a real human scale, how do we manage wind, snow, sun, you know, so the thing really is comfortable. And also views, right? Because this isn't a one-liner where you only want to look to the mountain. There's amazing views in all directions. And so how do we organize building massing? So sun gets down to the ground, we block the big wind.

45:45 And we open up great views. And so some of these, these are some of our early ideas about how the village massing might behave. And you can see this smaller scale in the middle that really, you know, I think we just feel like a charming, almost European village. So we did a few sketches at, you know, and it's like, how do you model mental life? And what are some early ideas about the snow edge?

46:14 Obviously, you've got to manage racks of skis. And, you know, people are going to want to sit out and hang out. People want to eat. Food trucks. Can we do food? Snowcats? You know, the gondola, fire pits, places to hang out. We're sort of searching for the identity of this place through drawings. And, you know, we draw and we'd say, oh, that's too shishy or that's...

46:44 It's maybe a little too grungy. And so this is just some of the process. And so this would be the hotel here in Viana and part of the skating trail and some of the restaurants. And you see we've etched in here provisions for fire trucks and other things. You know, all along, going back to the early visioning we did 2015, 2016 and before, how do you really make this?

47:13 Southern California meets the Sierras, and it's fun, and it's outside, and it's exciting, and it's casual, but it's also one-of-a-kind place. You can't be frivolous with how we think about things. This is if you were in kind of one of the top floor units looking out. Here's the hotel on the right, the skating trail, or playing around with an idea for a really funky building.

47:44 For this adventure center, which could have a climbing wall in it. You know, it's kind of like all the things you do in the eastern Sierras packaged into a building. And so this slide kind of encapsulates the adventure center. So like we should have a playground here because people like me have young kids and those kids want to do something when they're on vacation. But instead of those generic playgrounds, it's designed by a lawyer.

48:13 Let's do some really cool thing that you can scramble over and, you know, it feels like it was made from the mountains. And then here's one last view, sort of on this ski beach, looking back, and you can see how these sort of shorter village V buildings really sort of step down to that human scale. And yeah, there's some larger buildings, but nothing really eclipses the scale of the village down in Mammoth. And so early kind of thinking about architecture,

48:45 Its place wants to be like a traditional mountain building, but with more contemporary events. This is a building in Switzerland. Obviously, there's just some timeless North American ski buildings. And so I think it's still early days about what this is, but ideas of making this from the materials that you'd find in the Eastern Sierras and then coming up with an architecture that feels familiar.

49:15 But it's also, you know, looking to the future. I'll finish with Parcel B. So here's Parcel A. Here's Minaret kind of coming around the back. And then as opposed to the road being straight, to get grades to work out and be a safer drive, we've sort of curved the road down into Parcel B. And that fun little ski ranch I was describing where kids can have, you know, sort of fun after hours.

49:47 Sort of in here, the chalets and the ski back to Parcel B. And, you know, I think we've always been smitten with Tamarack since the first time we ever saw it. And, you know, had the idea that you could complement the kind of scale and intensity of the village, which a lot of people want and makes for a great kind of complement to the ski experience. With something more...

50:16 Kind of relaxed and family oriented. So Parcel B today is a series of ponds. And yeah, I know Mark spent some time kind of keeping people from trying to fish in them. But, you know, they look utilitarian on a map. And then you stand and, you know, they don't look great in the foreground. But what a view. And what an amazing relationship.

50:46 And so how do you take advantage of that? And also kind of be mindful that you're in forest and you want to be appealing to a lot of different kinds of people. And so this idea of tamarack where there's a lodge and then a series of cabins. And so, you know, families, cabins grouped around a pond maybe or a lawn and there's a little fitness pavilion.

51:15 And maybe a handful of private homes or homes in a rental pool. And really, you know, there's a ski in real estate right next to the mountain or cottages like Tamarack that could be operated year round that really appeal to families and extended families. And so we think that this is a really interesting idea and a wonderful compliment. And then, you know, and it's not,

51:47 Ski season, hiking trails, places to walk your dog, you know, all that fun stuff would kind of interconnect these two parcels. So just kind of last, some logistic things. You know, Mammoth's already working pretty hard on transit. And, you know, as you minaret, there's these parking shuttles and various stops. And the idea is to, you know, build on that tradition, give them that great arrival experience.

52:18 You know, we'll relocate the Mammoth, the big Mammoth sculpture to be right here. Obviously, having some convenient parking is helpful. But I think one of the things we want to do is create a new appropriate experience that you could park at. So there's a relatively flat spot here that we call Big Bend because there's a big bend in the road. And if you park here, you can actually ski out down to the base of

52:49 Chair 210. Or you can take a new little jumper and get down to Main Lodge. And so great from an experience standpoint. And in the process of opening that up, we can create more beginner terrain, which really helps that progression. You know, the first hour on the skis to the first morning on the skis to your second day on the skis. This can really be a wonderful experience for beginning skiers.

53:19 And then, you know, the rest of the really kind of unfolds on a pedestrian scale because we've gotten cars out of the way. I think just lastly, you know, we're beginning to work through fire lanes and egress issues. We're thinking about the sections of these roads. Sorry, it's not disappointing here. You know, Minaret, for instance, should that be a road with a bike lane?

53:53 On the side. And the downhill bike lane is in the traffic lane. That's a question we're debating, but we think that's a good idea. And there's gotten some good discussions with Caltrans going on. So those are the kinds of things that we're working. And I think I'll just end with maybe the least exciting slide, but maybe the most interesting. Yeah, what does all this add up to? So ultimately it's...

54:25 What we think is a balance of hotel units, something like 450, and residential units, something like 412. And I say that because we don't have a crystal ball. And we're not far enough along to know it should be 2,000 square foot units or 1,000 square foot units.

54:52 Or it should be a condo hotel or your hotel. So we're going through all that. But we do want to make sure that we provide enough animation, right, skier services, retail, food and beverage, other things that people want to do when they're here. And that we want to provide enough parking so that it functions efficiently. But we don't want to be in the, how do I say this, the parking business for the sake of parking.

55:23 And so what we've learned in a lot of places we're working, mixed use settings in high density cities, as well as in the mountains, is that people's need for dedicated parking spots has evolved and is continuing to evolve. And by an actively managed parking reservoir, we think we can be more efficient with the number of dedicated parking stalls we provide.

55:55 With that, all of us are happy to answer questions. I can go back through the deck, but just I hope that's a good introduction. Hey, Aaron, thank you. Could you back up two slides to 23? This one? I think so. It's compiling itself right now. I just wanted to quickly point out, and everybody may be aware of this, but being respectful of our audience tonight is that...

56:36 Town Council and the Planning Commission. We talked about Big Bend and the new lifts over in the new teaching terrain and the steep back trail to be and so on and so forth just for context and wholeness of the presentation. But obviously those are things that the town, you know, really is outside of the town's purview. That's more on the, of course, more on the Forest Service side. But we did want to

57:05 I want to present Big Bend Parking and those terrain changes in this meeting just again so everybody kind of knows the big picture, sees where we're going and how we really want to create a good fabric of this entire portal up here and really tell you from where it is today, it's just something phenomenal. But I just wanted to quickly delineate that the town's focus

57:34 Is those two areas within the yellow line bound. So as Aaron said, that's our story. We hope you see some cool stuff and there's some enthusiasm bubbling. But Mark and I and Tom and Aaron and Ron are all available for any questions you might have. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much, Aaron and David, for this presentation.

58:09 There are a set of questions that were put forward in the staff report. And Chandler, you can walk us through those. Basically, you know, is this project consistent with the general plan? Is there key issues that the applicant should be taken into consideration that might be pointed out by either council members or planning commission? And that what are the related issues outside the project areas that we would like to talk about?

58:36 I don't know if you were privy to sort of the information that was set before us as these two commissioners, two bodies, but there was also the draft project description that kind of walked through a bunch of pieces here. So I would like to just sort of ask.

58:56 Both planning commission members and town council members to just speak up and ask their questions now. If you're agreeable to that, it's all, we're about an hour and about an hour into this right now. So I'd like to kind of keep it to, you know, half hour max going forward, talk about next steps. Chandler, is there any direction you'd like to give staff here? I mean, the commission and council.

59:22 No, you covered those three questions. I mean, really, this is, you know, the intent of this is just for this to be an opportunity to provide feedback, just give initial impressions, any concerns you may have, ideally that are founded in, you know, general plan or adopted town goals and policies. But really, we just want to raise any red flags or give any nudges that need to happen now instead of when they come back for approval in several months to a year.

59:51 Okay, great. Thanks, Chandler. If you'd like to unshare, well, I don't know, do you want to unshare the screen and then we can go back to it if we need to so we can kind of see everybody, otherwise I can't see who's trying to speak here. Okay, we have one hand up. That would be Jennifer Burrows from Planning Commission. I actually think John Wentworth was before me. Ah, there's John. Sorry, John, I didn't see you in the curtains there. Go ahead, John. Well, Jennifer, why don't you go ahead? I've got my thoughts organized, so I'll be able to hopefully go through them pretty quick.

1:00:24 Well, I have my thoughts organized too, but I will go first. So that area, I think you called it Plan B, I forget, it was back behind where we're moving the road and it seems like there's going to be a lot of trees knocked out there. And what is your plan for

1:00:50 I don't know, planting some trees in that area or giving back to our environment there. And then why don't we start with that? Sure. Lynda, you want me just to respond as we go here? Absolutely. Okay. So actually, Parcel B, which I believe is what you're referring to, Parcel B is, and Tom, feel free, Tom's obviously, Tom Hodges is far more familiar with.

1:01:20 And in fact, I...

1:01:48 Pretty confident that by the time we remove the sewage treatment ponds and then redevelop that, and certainly with the ambition of our development with the Tamarack-style village that Aaron described, single family residences, I think the entirety of Parcel B will be more vegetated and more forest-esque than it is today. I guess I've never really gone back there to see the sewage treatment plants, so I'm not quite familiar with it.

1:02:17 It's not very pretty. We can bring the existing aerial up again, but again, it's not a treatment plant, just for clarification. It is five open ponds where sewage is pumped in and it just settles in the ground. So no trees, just, you know, think of it as trout ponds, except not trout ponds. That sounds awful. Well, and that's kind of the point I'm making, and I'm really not going to flip it.

1:02:46 Parcel B is an example of our development and our development intentions will be a vast improvement over what it is today environmentally and in general. Well, I just have to say that I think that it looks great. It kind of reminds me of the Whistler Blackcomb area and then the Copper Mountain Resort as well. I think it's kind of a combination between those and I think it's...

1:03:15 It's what we need. I know that from our community perspective, we would like something like that, but the community is also concerned about EGLE. We've been talking about EGLE for years and how we're going to develop that. And I think between that and the unfinished zip line, it's like, is the mountain ever going to do what they say they're going to do? So if we approve this project,

1:03:45 I would really, I'd really like to see you say, do what you're going to say. And then one final question I have is, it seems like there's gonna be a need for a lot more employees. What is your plan for employee housing? Because that's a really, you know, housing's a big issue in this town and you guys already are bringing in a lot of employees. What happens when you increase that?

1:04:20 Well, I'm going to ask our affordable housing employee housing expert, Mr. Hodges, to weigh in on that. Can you guys hear me? Yep. Okay. So, I mean, just not to get into the woods too far, but, I mean, basically, we have every intention of complying with the town's affordable housing mitigation regulations as they exist today, Jennifer, and there's a lot of details to figure out.

1:04:55 I don't really think we're in a position to get into exact solutions, but just know that we will comply with what's on the books. I expect nothing less. And I am done with all my questions. Thank you. Thank you, Jen. Go ahead, John. Thank you, Madam Mayor Pro Tem. And so just kind of get started. I just, I can write all these up, Sandra, so you have all these things.

1:05:29 In writing. But my understanding is, again, to the staff report that there's a specific purpose for this review, this concept review that's in the municipal code. So we're not taking any action tonight, but this is something that's on the record. So I want to make sure we're clear that we're saying these things publicly and everybody can hear it and we can work through what we got to work through. So for the first discussion question,

1:05:57 The project is shown appear consistent with the town's general plan and adopted other adopted goals and policies. Sandra and Dan, I would as a council member would like very much like to see the staff's analysis of that question. I'd like you guys to take a first whack at that and then that gives council a planning commission something to respond to. In terms of the related documents, the list that I'm looking at is the general plan, the current town council priorities, the community housing action plan.

1:06:24 The Walk, Bike, Ride Plan, along with the Mobility Planning that the staff is currently doing, Downtown Revitalization Plan, the Trail System Master Plan, a document recently published called The Changing Climate Vulnerability in California's Eastern Sierra, the Management Plan for the Devil's Postmodern National Monument, along with the Inyo National Forest Management Plan. Those, I think, are just a good start. David, if you haven't seen all those things already, that's a good place to start, certainly.

1:06:50 Our expectations are going to be tied back to what's in those documents. There may be others. In terms of key issues that should the applicant be taking into consideration, housing is obviously one of a couple that are going to be top of mind. And David, I asked these questions when we had our brief, we had our little get-together a little while ago about how many human beings are we talking about will be necessary to staff and run this thing at BuildOut? How many human beings are we talking about for this?

1:07:20 Where are they going to live? I think also the question around construction housing. Where is the workforce that's going to be building this thing? Where are they going to live? How are they going to be accommodated? And I think it's just really important to really emphasize what Jennifer said. And I think, you know, most of you, all of us read the national media. We are aware of the fact that the housing challenge is not something that's unique to Mammoth Lakes. This is something that has overwhelmed the entire western United States.

1:07:48 And this is not the kind of thing where I would anticipate in a CEQA document we're going to be making overriding considerations about. This is truly an existential situation. And that's going to require some real creativity. And I think it's going to take, we've talked about working together and collaborating on this kind of a project. This is not the type of challenge that's going to be just mitigated and just really dealt with easily. So I want to encourage everybody to think about that.

1:08:18 The transportation, mobility, and parking issues, those are things we really need to think about. The walk, bike, ride plan is a good guide, but Hayes and Sandra are working on, Council's given direction on what those mobility things need to look like. On the fire front, there's a very interesting project called the ESCCRP, which is...

1:08:38 receiving, frankly, millions of dollars of funding from the state of California. This is a 50,000 acre fuel mitigation project that's happening all around the town of Mammoth Lakes. It'll be great to get some sense of how Mammoth Resorts would like to be involved in that project. This morning, a grant award of about $3.5 million was announced to establish a NEPA ID strike team to start working on that. This project is going to happen, and I think it would be really a good idea for the

1:09:08 Applicant and proponents will start getting involved in that process and understanding what's going to be involved in that. So I think that's something we want to pay attention to that. On the issue of climate change, I think it's going to be really important to understand what is the long-term vision for this project and from the proponent as to how to mitigate and adapt to the reality of climate change.

1:09:29 To Jennifer's point, I think we're all very hopeful that this thing, it gets built and moves forward once approved, but what is it going to look like in 20 years, 30 years, 50 years, 100 years? What is the plan? How is the infrastructure going to be cognizant of what that's going to look like? Again, I refer you back to that report I mentioned, the changing climate vulnerability in California's eastern Sierra. That should give you some clues, but I think we're all really anxious to understand how is this project going to be

1:09:58 I think David, we had a quick conversation about dispersed recreation around the main lodge. We haven't had that follow-up conversation. I know Dan Holler was going to try to set that up. We need to have a real conversation about that.

1:10:24 I don't know how many people you anticipate would be there at a time, but there are already some trails that are right nearby that were not mentioned in either of the presentations. We've got to take a really hard look at what it's going to, if in the summertime or the fall, if the ski season gets shorter, what are we going to do with thousands of people up there? I'm assuming that's going to be addressed to the NEPA process as we do this joint document, but it'd be really good to get some vision, some ideas from you guys of what that, what do you think that's going to look like?

1:10:53 And so that's that. I think that one thing for all of us to be cognizant of is what is going to be the if the regional effect of the cumulative effects of this development. For example, with housing, there's no housing available in the town of Mammoth Lakes. If this project needs to house 1,000 people, 1,500 people to staff and make it work, how is that going to affect Bishop? How is it going to affect June Lake?

1:11:22 You know, these are questions that we need to start dealing with now. Sandra, I have a little bit of a question for you when we do the NEPA and the CEQA documents. Is this just looking at the effects of the Town of Mammoth Lakes or is it going to look at the regional impacts?

1:11:36 For all the other communities in the region. David, you may or may not be aware, 90% of the land mass in the adjoining counties are managed by the federal government. There's very, very little private land. To be able to mitigate these types of things, we've got to be smart. We've got to be creative. We've got to find a way to figure out what's the plan going to be to make all this stuff work. And so then just the...

1:12:00 Sandra will talk a little bit about this on the contract for the environmental services. The town has never done as ambitious a joint CEQA-NEPA document as being proposed this evening. My understanding, we've done some work around the airport, but this is of a whole other level of magnitude of technical complexity and challenge, and I think I want to make sure, I think we all want to make sure that we're going to be able to do this well and efficiently, and everything is going to be coming together at the same time.

1:12:28 You know, it's not going to be one playing off against the other. That's going to be a real set of challenges, and frankly, we've got to figure out how we're going to deal with that. Some other related issues, just things to be aware of, the new road down to Devil's Postpile. I think, Aaron, you were mentioning about bike lanes and the road, the reroute 203 through that. I think it's very important you guys to understand what that new road that's being built with a flat grant that's going to go down to Devil's Postpile, what that's going to look like, how that's going to be configured to make sure whatever is going to happen through the village.

1:12:56 Is it going to be consistent with that infrastructure? We've got all the planning documents for that. And then I go back again to the region. We have you guys, Altera has done this great work to really help us make it possible to move air service down to the Bishop Airport to have reliable regional air service. How is the regional air service going to work as part of this whole proposal? The Eastern Sierra Council of Governments is now a joint powers authority.

1:13:23 And it has embarked on a sustainable recreation ecosystem management program. That $3.5 million grant I just mentioned will be going through the ESCOG. How can we use and leverage the ESCOG to mitigate and make sure this product is going to be successful? I would also point to the Eastern Sierra Sustainable Recreation Partnership. And finally, just the reality that we all live in California. And the budget that's going through the state right now has been approved by the legislature. The governor will sign it soon with some changes. It's a generational investment.

1:13:53 And it's being invested in the values and the policy that the state of California, we as Californians, care about. Climate change is top of the list. Nature-based solutions for climate change. Access and equity. How are we going to be engaging with access and equity with this development ourselves as a community, as a county, in the state of California? And finally, obviously, wildfire. There are going to be huge investments in wildfire mitigation. And we're all very eager to see what that success is going to look like on the ground.

1:14:20 So I'll leave it there. And Sandra, I'll just write this up and send it to you as a document. So we've got this document. So thank you very much. All right. Thank you, John. Okay. Who else? Michael, I see your hand is up. Yeah, I've just got a couple of really quick questions and they're either for Tom or for David. I heard a statement earlier today in the presentation that you guys are not in the parking business. Could you just reaffirm to these two bodies that

1:14:50 All the hotel and residential properties in the project have underground parking and will meet town code in terms of numbers? That is true. I mean, the plan contemplates in structure, under structure parking for all the new buildings for the residential and hospitality. I think Aaron did mention or perhaps glossed over a bit that we have today we have roughly 200.

1:15:20 On-surface public stalls not related to Mammoth Mountain today. One of the specific reasons that we're proposing Big Bend is to replace those 200 and frankly be accretive to. Also, it's very important to remember that the on-road parking that exists today will certainly continue. Big Bend is within kind of that 1,500-foot walking range, so it's not dissimilar from

1:15:49 From road parking anyway. So yes, to answer your point directly, we will provide onsite parking for those onsite fixed occupancy structures, and we will not only maintain, but hopefully improve public parking, skier parking, whatever you want to call it. And I really want to keep emphasizing that we're putting a lot of thought into this whole transit center, transit arrival, transit transfer to the

1:16:19 Devil's Postpile, Red's Meadow, you know, those types of things. Those are high on our list to integrate into our overall vehicle thinking, if you will. And Tom, you can chime in if you want to add to that. No, I think you hit all the high points there, David. I mean, you know, it's again, overall, Michael, it's a much improved situation with what's proposed.

1:16:47 You know, I think the Big Bend idea of replacing the day skier parking is huge. It's also where we're going to relocate the core of our administrative services down there and having that lift and access for our employees. All of our employees will be consolidated in that location as well, which will be much more effective than it is today. You know, remember, like, you know, the existing facility was built over, gosh, 70 years, right, and added onto and added onto and added onto, and this got stuck here and this got stuck there.

1:17:17 And so just realize that's all going away and we're going to build a modern building and modern infrastructure and road network and parking and everything else. I mean, it's going to function so much better. But yeah, there's definitely going to be a net increase in available parking in the area. Thanks for clarifying that, guys, because, you know, to say that we're not in the parking business, I think could fall pretty negatively out there in the community with a lot of people. So I just want some.

1:17:46 Glad you guys, excuse me, clarified that. And then David, I'm going to ask you probably your least favorite question. I'm going to ask you to maybe look into your magic crystal ball and give us a sense of what you think the phasing of parcel A will look like in real time. I can answer that. And that's not my least favorite question. I can tell you that's my least favorite task.

1:18:13 That I have before me is figuring out the phasing on this project. I'm sure you can tell me just intuitively everybody on this meeting can understand that this is a complex project with a lot of intertwining between the new stuff and the old stuff.

1:18:34 We're starting with the old parcel. We're starting with a roadway that's in the wrong place. We're starting with Mammoth Mountain and Yola. They're kind of where other things have to go first. Aaron already pointed out that we have to move the gondola. We have to move Discovery Chair. So the phasing is going to be really difficult. I'll tell you, very top line, and we haven't even really tackled the true phasing question yet.

1:19:00 But it's next up in our internal thinking. But I tell you, top line, honestly, probably the first delivery phase will be what we call H1, the luxury hotel. That being said, in order to do that, there's a lot of stuff we got to do in advance that's not so elegant and not so sexy. It's moving the road, it's moving the gondola, it's moving discovery. And even in my opening remarks, I think I mentioned that

1:19:29 Our intention is to start development work in 2023 if all the stars align, but it's going to be those types of things early on. I can also tell you that it's given to me as my direction and our intent from Altera that this is a fast-paced project. Comparative, we've all seen these big mixed-use projects that hit the newspapers and hit the Business Chronicle.

1:19:59 And then 20 years later, we're still talking about it. Or maybe there's one or two buildings here. I mean, it's our ambition to get this done in a comparatively fast fashion, those types of things. Personally, today, I would sit here and tell you that I'd love to see this at full build out in eight-ish years. You know, I mean, it's just that complex of a project. But the whole phasing plan, not only from what phase one is, but

1:20:29 From what happens from phase one to phase eight or nine or whatever the end point is, is a big process that we're going to face over the next few months. And that's the best answer I can give right now. Okay. Thank you, David. I don't see anybody else indicating they would like to speak, but is there someone that I'm not seeing? Sarah? There you are. Sarah's raising her personal hand, not her...

1:21:00 I raised both. Make sure everyone had a chance. Yeah, Jennifer, I really appreciate you bringing up housing, obviously, you know, when I reviewed this plan with Tom and David last week, you know, at the end of our discussion, I told Tom, okay, you know, this is coming.

1:21:23 Where are these people going to live? And Tom, I think you mentioned, I think I asked how many extra employees are we going to, are we looking at here? And I think you said about a hundred, which I've really been rolling that around in my head for the last few days and looking at the rendering that Aaron shared, I mean, this place kind of looks like Vegas. And I frankly was a little disappointed to hear you say, you know, we'll abide by everything the town has on the books. You know, we all know what the town has on the books is.

1:21:52 Not adequate. And I think you discussed in our meeting the development of 22 units on a parcel that the mountain owns. And I just, I don't want to hear the mountain saying, you know, we're going to abide by what's on the books, essentially saying that we're going to do the bare minimum that you're required to do for housing mitigation. We have been letting developers do the bare minimum for years on housing, and the town is now left holding the bag.

1:22:19 And I just I think we need to set a new precedent for developments going forward that the bare minimum and putting the onus on the town to provide housing for your employees is not going to work for us anymore. And as long as I'm sitting on this council, I'm not going to approve a project that only does the bare minimum for housing. And this goes for parking as well. You know, you have employees in this town who are running up to your lodge to cook breakfast and then they're running to their second job with their change of clothes in the car. And you need to.

1:22:46 Put a place for them to park and the 200 spaces at Big Bend is obviously not going to cut it. I know you don't want to be in the parking business and I know you'd probably rather not be in the housing business but unfortunately every major employer in this town is now in the housing business and is in the parking business and I know Mammoth Mountains always had the luxury of being its own beast but it's a new world out there and we need these bodies I think need to see something a little more concrete and something that goes a little above the bare minimum.

1:23:16 So, Sarah, I don't think I meant to imply that we're going to do the bare minimum, but I just wanted to assure you that we are certainly going to comply with what is the housing mitigation ordinance as a starting point. And, you know, we are actually actively right now engaged in looking at the development of our acre down on Arrowhead Drive that backs up to the parcel where we can develop 22 units. We've had, you know,

1:23:42 Discussions with Sandra and Dan over the last year or so about looking at that. We are actually gearing up to get an application of the town this year. And our, you know, our intent right now is to construct next year with, you know, hopefully having those online by the end of next year, calendar year 22. So that'd be 22 incremental units there. So believe me, I mean, we as, you know, the 600 pound grill employer in town, right? I mean, we recognize as well as anybody that,

1:24:12 That housing and housing for our employees is critical to our success and our long-term sustainability. And, you know, it's an incredibly complicated subject, right? And I just don't think we have the time to get into, you know, all the different types of opportunities this project creates as well, I think. It's something else that really needs to be discussed because it really is going to be the political will of this community and town council, county supervisors, you know.

1:24:40 You know, we touched on this in a number of the individual meetings of, you know, the fact that this property, when it's redeveloped, is going to kick off a tremendous increment in property tax over what it is today. You know, we've kicked around the idea of an EIFD in our community. You know, if there was ever a place where we were going to implement an EIFD, this would be the logical location to do that. So what are uses or what are benefactors of an EIFD?

1:25:09 Affordable housing is on the list that's accepted by the state. So I think, you know, we look for sustainable funding sources for affordable housing, create an EIFD that would create sustainable affordable housing funding from an EIFD district makes a lot of sense. Something that needs to be seriously talked about by all the politicians in our community and the community as a whole. Additionally, there's going to be a huge lift in TOT. You know, you can see because of the increased hospitality lodging.

1:25:37 The higher quality product will be both an increase in units and an increase in ADR. You know, I think just, you know, again, back in the envelope type math on this is likely to double the TOT revenue on this location to the community, to the town. And, you know, that's without a huge increase necessarily in, you know, what the town's budget is going to be to support this development. So there's opportunities there to look at that end of the development cycle as well.

1:26:07 Because, you know, there's the road to development is fraught with incredible risk and potholes and pitfalls and global pandemics and recessions and droughts and market cycles. So, you know, it's I think the point I'm making is it's going to be truly a partnership of all of us together to figure this out properly. And believe me, we are first and foremost recognize the need to do it right and to, you know, have a solution that works.

1:26:35 For the community as a whole. And, you know, you know, we recognize that housing is a number one issue for the community. Absolutely. And Sarah, I'll, I would just add that I, you know, kind of what Tom just said. We, we, Mammoth Mountain Ski Area is part of this community. Forget about Maine Lodge redevelopment. We know, we know that affordable housing is a big issue. Our plans for Maine Lodge and everything else. I, I can tell you that, uh, we are more than willing and anxious to

1:27:07 Talk to all the stakeholders about creative ways to address this problem that maybe aren't just as cut and dried as let's go build 140 housing units. But we bring to bear a lot of resources and certainly with the development of Mammoth Lodge as Tom's talked about with some of the tax lifts and things like that. I think there's some really creative, useful, long-term mechanisms that...

1:27:35 We could all come together and really contribute to some long-term solutions. And we're more than willing to discuss them. I would like to see the solutions brought before these bodies and not just we're going to do this later. Understood. Okay. I think now Gordon Martin from Forest Service. Hi, Gordon. Good evening.

1:28:03 Yeah, a couple items from the Forest Service perspective. One, just prior to this meeting, I finished reviewing the MOU that we're going to have between the Forest Service, the town, and Mammoth Mountain Redevelopment to pay for the consultant that will be doing the EIR, EIS work. So that should be...

1:28:32 Moving forward. Don't know where it is on review from both of the other parties, but I think we're about done. The other thing is we are still waiting for a master development plan to be approved in association with this project. Any master development plan that we had.

1:28:58 Prior to the base exchange no longer applies because it was based on assumptions that are no longer valid. So we're waiting for that. And that's kind of a prerequisite for us receiving any proposals for parts of the plan as far as moving gondolas or any of that stuff that occurs on forest land. Also,

1:29:27 Along with those, something to keep in mind that we tell everybody that wants to do something on national forest land, part of our special use permit process is the first question we ask is, can this happen on private land? Okay. Thank you, Gordon. Any response to Gordon? That's okay. All right. I need to say, Linda, real quick, we are...

1:30:01 Actively completing our master development plan update and we should be providing the draft to the Forest Service for review by the 1st of July. So it's just a couple weeks out. Okay. Okay. Thank you, Tom. All right. Anybody from planning commission want to make a comment, ask a question? No. Anybody else on? Oh, great. Yes. Hi, Greg. Yes. So this parcel B is currently covered by retention ponds.

1:30:34 And is proposed to be developed fairly completely. I'm assuming that these lakes around the Tamarack condos aren't also going to be used as retention ponds. Where would those retention ponds go? We're actually looking, we're analyzing two different options for the wastewater treatment solution. To touch on your direct question there, the ponds in the Tamarack village or anywhere on Parcel B would not be for wastewater treatment at all.

1:31:04 They would be decorative or recreational only. If you look at our draft project description that Sandra's team has, we're analyzing two different solutions for the treatment of wastewater. One is to be annexed into Mammoth Community Water District and send the waste to the town. The second is to develop an on-site modular wastewater treatment plant.

1:31:32 So we would essentially continue to be self-contained as Main Lodge has been with the treatment ponds, but obviously in a more contemporary and current fashion. I have engaged, we have a wastewater consulting engineer engaged right now that is weighing those two options. Those also were analyzed as far back as 2004, so we're updating those assumptions on the...

1:31:59 Pros and cons of those two options, and certainly in the context of current technology, which in that field, wastewater treatment, is five years ahead of what was available in 2004. Very quickly, I mean, my intention is not later than the end of July, we will arrive at a decision on which of those is the better option.

1:32:25 to incorporate more formally into this whole review process and as it relates to CEQA ending. Okay. Thank you again. Greg, is that it for you? Okay. All right. Let's move over to Town Council. Any Town Council people that would like to make comments? Kirk, anything on your end there? Yes, thank you very much.

1:32:58 My concerns are, you know, obviously the parking and because of the skier, the visitors that arrive up there, how is that going to be handled? And my other concern, I sit on the Mammoth Lake Housing Board and we currently have 88 people on the wait list and the Bishop Hospital is having a difficult time finding

1:33:24 Some of their staff because of the problem with salary as well as finding a place to live. So housing is a major issue and you haven't really explained how the visitor parking is going to be or are we going to really rely on transit. But if that's the case, then, you know, where is the people coming up again?

1:33:51 And going to be parking at the main lodge. Those are my concerns. Parking and housing. Well, and again, just to reiterate, the parking plan is roadside parking. It's always existed. It will continue. We won't diminish that at all. The public parking, open parking is being replaced.

1:34:21 added to through the establishment of Big Bend, and then all of the residential hospitality parking on site will be accommodated under structure parking, new parking facilities. And then of course we've touched on all the housing topics. How many spaces per two bedroom at one of the rentals up there? I mean, are we talking about one space or one and a half?

1:34:52 We'll generally follow, well, we will follow the existing town regulations and zoning for the parking requirements. Thank you. Okay. Myself, I think everything I was thinking and needed to ask was well covered by other council members, so thank you. Given that, staff, do you have what you need from this discussion to move forward?

1:35:26 Yes, thank you. I mean, I think we, you know, the intent of this, oh, Councilmember has another question or comment? Yes, a final thought. I'm hoping we get copied these presentations. Aaron, really nice job on the visualizations. It's really helpful to, David, every time we get together, we're going to see a better, better visualization of that. It's really helpful. And I think...

1:35:50 Before we get together again or as we move through this process, I think it'd be very helpful for the community, Aaron, to get a sense of what is an analogous project to this. Are we talking Telluride? Are we talking North Star? I mean, something so the community can really get a sense of what this thing actually is. I won't hold you to that now, but I think that'd be really helpful as we go down the road with this. Those are my two final thoughts. Thank you.

1:36:15 On that note, Chandler, could you just talk a little bit about next steps? I know there was a schedule in here about some events coming up. Do you want to share those? Yeah. So really the major next step is taking the feedback from tonight and preparing their entitlement package. I guess before that happens, likely there will be the noticing and scoping period for the

1:36:45 Yeah, the noticing and scoping period before the draft EIR, EIS. So there'll be a 30-day scoping period where there'll be a joint public meeting slash open house between the town and the Forest Service. So that's likely to happen in August or September of this year. And that'll be mainly focused on the environmental document, obviously. But yeah, other than that, I mean, really the next step is them kind of

1:37:13 Refining their plans and preparing the specific plan and general plan zoning code amendments and submitting those to the town for review. Okay. All right. Madam Mayor, if I might make one more comment. Could I have some sort of summary sheet of how you're going to, how the mountain is going to deal with its, again, affordable housing? Thank you. Thank you.

1:37:43 All right. I want to thank everyone for being here for this presentation. It was very complete and great to start visualizing this. Obviously, as you said, it's very much the beginning phases, a lot of things to do, a lot of things to discuss. But I hope this was helpful to you, too, to get some feedback. Unless you have any other further questions for staff or Planning Commission or Town Council, I think we'll go ahead and wrap this up and look forward to

1:38:12 Getting together again very soon. Yeah, no, this was very, very helpful, and I want to thank everybody for their time, and the comments are great. I mean, it gives us good direction on what we need to really think through and focus on. So thank you, everyone. Okay, good. Good to see you all. All right, Planning Commission, thank you for being here. I think we're, Town Council is going to take a bit of a break and gather back here and commence on our next part of the meeting, which is also a very long meeting.

1:38:43 Thank you, everybody, and we'll see you all soon. Thanks. Bye, all. Thanks. When are we reconvening? Minimally about five minutes, maximally. Like 6.45, you want to say 6.45? That sounds good, John. 6.45 is perfect. Thank you. Great. Thank you. Okay. Are we getting people back here? Sarah, there you are. Me, John, Kirk. Is there Dan, you guys there?

1:47:33 Need to see Kirk here. Oh, there he is. I see him. I'm here. I'm in council chamber. Sweet Z. You're not Dan Holler. Okay. All right. So then I think we can go ahead and it's not kind of a reconvening because this is now a town council meeting. So we're going to start by calling roll call. And I believe Angie's with us tonight. Right, Angie? Yes, ma'am. Hey. Roll call. Mayor Bill Sauser is out today.

1:48:04 Mayor Pro Tem, Lynda Salcido. Present. Councilmember Rae. Here. Councilmember Stapp. Present. Councilmember Wentworth. Present. Thank you. Okay. Pledge of Allegiance. Sarah, would you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance, please? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Great. Thanks, Sarah.

1:48:41 All right. Let's see. Are there any public comments, Angie, for us to have before we continue that these would be issues that are not already contained on the evening's agenda? Yes, I have two public comments. I have Janet Hatfield. You may go ahead and speak. Good evening, Janet. Good evening. Thank you, Ms. Mayor and Town Council.

1:49:10 I'll just reintroduce myself for those of you who know you're juggling a pretty heavy workload. I just caught the previous presentation, which is extremely interesting and relevant to what I'm talking to you about today. My name is Janet Hatfield, and I work for a local nonprofit organization. And if you may recall, I am the project manager on the Eastern Sierra Climate and Communities Resilience Project, which we all like to call the donut because it's much easier to say. To refresh your memory, that project is

1:49:40 Currently developing, collaboratively developing proposed actions for forest restoration on approximately 55,000 acres that surround the town in roughly five miles in every cardinal direction. The current phase of the project is in pre-planning. Like I said, we're developing proposed actions. The next phase of that work will be the NEPA CEQA environmental process. And in February of

1:50:08 This year I worked with the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments to submit a grant proposal to the California Department of Fish and Wildlife to fund that work. And this morning I heard that we were successful in securing that application. It's in the amount of approximately $3.3 million. So there will be no gap in our planning effort and we can move forward with the NEPA.

1:50:33 Environmental Assessment beginning immediately as soon as proposed actions are completed. Congratulations. That's amazing. That's just amazing. I mean, so much to be, you know, just impressed by there. So, yeah, that's great. Yeah, and this team will be working on the NEPA process. It will also build local capacity to continue to do environmental review on further.

1:50:58 Both ecosystem health and sustainable recreation projects across the region when they're done with the Mammoth Donut. And sort of more and equally important, in addition to that, we are also the recipient of a CAL FIRE directed grant funding award through the Forest Health Program for approximately $4.9 million to begin immediate implementation of approximately 2,100 acres. This includes 80 acres of pound and

1:51:27 Los Angeles Department of Parks and Rec land on the Mammoth Creek parcels, the Camp High Sierra parcels, as well as the Bell Shade parcel, all of which were identified as high priority risk acres in the community wildfire protection plan. And we've been working with the talent planning commissioners, Kim Cook and Sandra on that work. The CAL FIRE grant will fund both the CEQA and the implementation of that work. And we expect the implementation to be able to begin.

1:51:55 As early as 2022. So I think in total, that's an $8.25 million investment from the state. And I think it speaks to how serious the state is taking the wildfire risk to this community. And I would just really urge all of you on the council to consider that in the back of your mind as we talk about all the other future planning and projects that are occurring in the Mammoth area. And that's all I have for you tonight. Well, that's a lot. So thank you very much for being here.

1:52:26 Comments or anything particular about this? Just congratulations, Janet. That's huge. Well done. Thank you. Appreciate it. All right. Thank you very much. Anxious to hear more about it as things get moving. And then, Angie, you said there was one more comment? Is there another comment there, Angie? Another public comment? Oops. I'm sorry. I was muted. Yeah. Joel Rathje, you can go ahead and unmute yourself.

1:53:02 Oh, I just wanted to be included in the meeting to be able to give it a department head report. I'm happy to give it now if you like. We'll get that to just in just a second, Joel. Let's go ahead and if there's no other comments, then are there any additions to the agenda? No, you're not having any. Okay, Joel. And now we're going to do reports from commissions and our departments as needed. And Joel, if you'd like to go ahead. I wonder if I may be included, Angie, so that I may share my screen. So there's...

1:53:36 A way that you can include me as part of the meeting? Yes, I've just upgraded you. Thank you. I just wanted to provide a brief update. Summer's begun for the trail system. Snow melted early this year. Not as much water in this waterfall as normally this time of year. Things have really kicked off in earnest. We do have a fairly large presence with the host program, especially on weekends. We're interacting with lots of people.

1:54:16 We're very grateful for the support of Visit Mammoth. We've been able to deploy in a much more robust way than last season. Here you can see on June 5th, we exceeded 350 interactions. That was very good. Directions and wayfinding and busing and transportation questions and questions about access points to trails, kind of the bulk of the queries that we get.

1:54:47 Dog leash observations are improving over time. It's kind of nice to see. I know we do have some new signage around. We do have regulatory signage out that is new. I don't know if that's making a difference or having a presence is making a difference, but our observations are showing an improvement on people controlling their animals. That's good. And we're seeing most of the user groups were...

1:55:14 We're stationed anyway where we're making observations or on bikes or hiking and walking. We're being able to get nice feedback from people on the ground like we could sure use some bike racks out there it looks like. And got a nice broken bridge from a tree at the Horseshoe Lake Loop. That'll be fixed probably early next week if not late this week. We got the lumber in.

1:55:42 And then we're just seeing a lot of folks interested in very multiple use activities, a lot of interest in e-biking and cycling and sightseeing. Everybody's getting out and we are cleaning up everywhere we go. And then shifting over to the trail day as part of our program, this began in earnest last week. So far, we're doing pretty well. We've had two large groups, one last Friday.

1:56:10 A group of 40 young men from the ages of 12 to 17 with six adults. And then last Wednesday I worked with two volunteers and then today with four amazing volunteers. And then just want to promote the Trail Days program a bit. Easy to sign up. You can go to mammothtrails.org and just look at the calendar. We have a sign up page for you.

1:56:36 You can sign up to work with a host on the weekends or holidays, or you can sign up to do trail construction and maintenance with us every Wednesday all season. If you have any questions, I'd be happy to answer them. I have one question, Joel. When you noted that there's a lot more dogs on leashes, are we visible and sighting if dogs are not on leash? So we're not a part of the regulatory implementation of this. We're not police.

1:57:06 We're making up, yeah, we're basically collecting this information, you know, sharing it out with Town Council, sharing it with Al and his staff so that, you know, they're aware of kind of what we're seeing. We provide more of our eyes and ears on the ground. We can kindly ask people to leash up their dogs and let them know what the regulations are, but we can't cite people. Oh, you know, I'm sorry, Joel, that's what I meant. Is law enforcement visible?

1:57:34 Around and about the Lakes Basin in particular and citing if dogs are off leash or not. Can't speak for them. I have seen a nice presence of law enforcement in the Lakes Basin. You know, my kids are saying, hey, dad, that's a police truck. Where's the car? You know, to that point, we're seeing a nice presence, but I can't speak to the number of citations or interactions like that. Okay. All right. Thank you, Joel. Any other questions for Joel? Nope.

1:58:03 All right, thank you. Joel, real quick, everybody's very excited about the new trails that are getting built off in the lake space, and do you have any update for the council on that? Because I know that after that, it's a priority to start working on those trails in the Sherman's Meadows. Maybe a quick update on those things would be helpful. Sure, that's how we're implementing our Trail Days program. I have a couple of T's to cross. I've met with cabin owners. We have to meet with the pack station.

1:58:30 And an archaeologist to be able to proceed in a real robust way. But I do have some projects I'm working on with volunteers right now where we're allowed to work today. And basically we're connecting Horseshoe Lake Loop with Lake Mamie with a formal system trail, multi-use, non-motorized. And then also a connection from where the Horseshoe Lake Loop ties back in with the lake space and path. We'll be providing a dirt multi-use.

1:58:58 Trail experience, just like the other trails down to Twin Lakes, right next to where the cabins are, which is why we're working with the cabin owners on that alignment. And it's going quite well. I had a great day today. It's great to work outside with volunteers that are energized. So, you know, I think it's going to be a great season. It's a little different format for the trail days. We're not doing four large events.

1:59:23 And so far, just from my experience, it feels good. It feels more manageable. It feels like we're going to get some quote-unquote regulars, which, you know, we're really hoping to, you know, kind of create community and culture out of this trail scene. So it was a great day today. You know, I've got to thank Matt Finnegan with FASCE. He's one of our regulars. He's signed up for every Wednesday.

1:59:52 And he's just amazing. And Harry and Leah and Scott, who showed up today, Scott showed up today, and he's going to start signing up every Wednesday after his experience today. So come out and become a regular. I used to be a bartender and, hey, come be a regular. This is much healthier. Come be a regular and take some trails with us. And you've got a big event happening tomorrow afternoon, is that correct?

2:00:20 Thanks for bringing that up. Thanks for asking. I didn't want to take up too much time, but we also, in our planning area of our program, we are having a discussion around potential formal trail system between Mammoth Lakes and June Lake and what that could look like to improve the OHV experience between the communities.

2:00:45 To look at opportunities next to Shady Res Park for trail system, to look at opportunities next to Inyo craters, areas where we have staging areas, and where people are looking for additional trail experiences. We think we can create connections that make sense, and in the process, improve the environmental condition. And that meeting is going to be where, Joel, tomorrow? Shady Res Park, 5 o'clock, and we'll stay until

2:01:16 Everybody's finished. Okay. All right. Great. Thanks so much. All right. Any other reports? Thank you, Joel. No? See none? No? That's it? Okay. Let's do introductions. I believe, Rob, that you do not have Stephanie with us tonight. Is that correct? Yes, that's correct. She has fallen ill, so she's not able to make it tonight.

2:01:51 Won't have her introduction. We'll push that to the next meeting. And Stu, you had somebody for us, huh? Yes, good evening, Mayor Pro Tem, Council. I do have an employee, but they are at softball. But I'm more than welcome to introduce Mark to the Council and at a later time, certainly bring him to Council or we can invite our Council to our offices. So I'm more than happy to run through the introduction.

2:02:22 Sure, why don't you go ahead? Yeah, so again, Mark's at softball. He's our new program and facilities coordinator. And one of his responsibilities is the coordination of many of our programs. So in summertime, that's summer softball. So he's out at the softball league Monday through Thursday evening. We're looking to get some more staff support for that as well. And in wintertime, he'll be...

2:02:49 Supporting a lot of our indoor activities. And that would be kind of adult soccer and volleyball and those type of activities as well. But Mark is a Master of Science graduate in recreation from the University of Illinois. Has a number of years of experience in the recreation field, including a summer season with us back in 2018, if you remember those pre-pandemic days. Most recently, Mark has been working as a facility coordinator.

2:03:18 For events and operations in the University of Minnesota's Recreation and Wellness Department. Mark actually made the drive out from Minnesota and we're very much looking forward to having him settle here in Mammoth Lakes. So again, I just invite you to stop by Parks and Rec or if you're out at Shady Rest Park on many of our softball league nights, please introduce yourself to Mark and I'd like to welcome Mark to Town Council on the community of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you. Thank you, Stuart. It's exciting that we...

2:03:47 Found a good candidate for that and yes, congratulations. Very, very much, thank you. That's great. Okay, let's go ahead and dive into the consent agenda. I'm going to read off some of these items for us to consider. Consent agenda number four, approve the minutes of the regular meeting of June 2nd, 2021. Secondly, approve the resolution authorizing Major U Fund, which is Fund 217.

2:04:16 Funding in the amount of $154,400, I think that's right, for arts and culture programming. Next, approve the 2020 annual planning report, APR, followed by authorizing a professional services agreement with Ascent Environmental for the Mammoth Mountain Main Lodge Redevelopment Project CEQA analysis.

2:04:41 Also approve the resolution authorizing temporary closure of certain town roads for the fourth of July parade and freedom mile run on July 4th, 2021. And to approve the revised parks and recreation department sponsorship policy. And lastly, accept the payment approval report number 21-52 and accept payment approval report 21-52 in parentheses.

2:05:11 Anyhow, do we hear a motion for approval of the consent agenda or is there an item someone would like to remove from the consent agenda? Yes, John. I'd like to pull item number, item number seven. Okay, very good. All right, that being pulled, is there a motion to approve the other items? Madam Mayor, I will move to approve consent item four, five, six, eight, nine, and ten. Second.

2:05:43 I'll second. Okay, thank you. We have a motion and a second. Angie, roll call. Councilmember Rae. Councilmember Stapp. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Yes. Thank you. Okay, so let's go back and talk about number seven. Okay, so I've got a couple questions on this. And I don't know who, Sandra, am I talking to you on this? Yes, I can respond to questions.

2:06:22 Okay, the first thing has to do with the MOU that Gordon Martin referenced. When Linda and I met with the applicant and we were advised that this MOU would be in place before this contract would be approved. I'm wondering if you can give us an update on that and why we shouldn't punt approving this item until that MOU is seen and the Council of Public has had a chance to see it.

2:06:51 And I just, I, as a general comment, I have real concerns about how the town and the Forest Service is going to coordinate and work together and manage this. I was a little disappointed in the workshop we had. There was no discussion about sequencing. I mean, all of, all of that stuff that's going to happen on Forest Service land, moving chairlifts around, moving administrative buildings, I don't think that we, it was, that we, as the two bodies were advised.

2:07:21 That that's a completely separate process and that these things are going to be talking to each other. If the Forest Service for some reason says, well, you know, you can't move that lift over here, you can't put an administrative building over there, that's going to affect what's going to be happening with the entire project that's happening on the town side. So maybe you can speak to the MOU a little bit. I would love to see that before we approve this contract so we have some better idea how this is going to work. And then we can talk a little bit about...

2:07:49 How we're going to coordinate this because the Forest Service moves at a very different pace than we do and vice versa. Sure. Yeah, thank you. Thanks for the questions. And so the MOU, so just to back up a little bit, the town has engaged EBK, Alicia Winterswicks, who I think you are familiar with, an attorney from Best Best Krieger, who is kind of our resident CEQA expert. So she is engaged in this process. She is working with the town. She's...

2:08:19 We've been meeting with her already, but our intent is to keep her in this process from start to finish so that we can ensure that we're doing this process correctly, crossing all the I's, dotting, I'm sorry, dotting all the I's, crossing all the T's. And so upon Alicia's recommendation, we are developing a membrane of understanding between the town, the Forest Service, and Mammoth Mountain, sorry, Main Lodge Redevelopment Corporation.

2:08:46 And really the purpose of the MOU is it just discusses how we are all going to work together and that we are going to work cooperatively to move this project forward. So that's the general gist of the MOU. It isn't a requirement. However, it is something that will definitely help us all understand how we're going to work together to get this process moved forward. You did make a comment.

2:09:11 At the, during the workshop about the complexity and the scope of this. And, and I agree that the main lodge project is very complex, a large project. However, we have done joint environmental, environmental documents with the forest service in the past. We did do Eagle Lodge as a joint document. Granted, like I said, this is a much bigger project, but we do have some experience as a town in doing these joint documents. And I think we're well served having Alicia on our team.

2:09:40 Who is a CEQA and an EPA expert. So I think that the town staff is comfortable with moving forward the contract now before the MOU is going to be approved. We did hear from Gordon during the workshop that it's a couple weeks out for their approval of the MOU. They received it, I think, last week, I think. So that's kind of the status of the MOU and just a little background on kind of joint documents here. I don't know, Andy, did you want to provide some comments as well?

2:10:09 Yeah, the other key point to the assent agreement is that it's set up so that the town can terminate it at any time. No amount of money is guaranteed to assent under this agreement. The town can simply terminate on seven days notice at any time, and we would only pay assent for the work that they've done, and they're not going to do anything until we tell them to. So if the council approves the assent agreement, that gets us having assent in place, but it does not commit us to actually paying anything. So if the MOU at the Forest Service falls through,

2:10:39 Or if the application is withdrawn, we would not be out any money with a cent. So I would be comfortable proceeding with that in mind, get the contract in place, but we're not going to start doing any work, I think, until the council's seen that MOU. And we've looked at it, we think this is going to make sense. There's a couple other things around the project initiation, project lead kickoff meeting and materials review.

2:11:05 I would like to see what documents the town is advising has sent that they need to be familiar with and they need to be aware of as we proceed on this project. I don't think it's in the community's interest to leave any of that kind of stuff to chance. And Sandra, I just sent you a list of all the documents. I think it's the place to start. But I would hope that the council would have the expectation that...

2:11:27 If we're talking about housing, we're talking about the Community Housing Action Plan. If we're talking about mobility and transit, we're talking about walk, bike, ride. I mean, we have things that we've done here, and I would want to have the confidence, I think all of us would want to have the confidence that Ascend is obligated to read these things, to review them, to be familiar with them. So when we have a conversation with the applicant, those things aren't falling through the cracks. Is that a reasonable expectation?

2:11:50 And we certainly will provide all of those documents to the applicants so that they can consider that in their development of the project. I think that a sense focus is really compliance with CEQA and NEPA, so environmental compliance, that's really what they're looking at. They're not developing the project description. With that being said, those documents can be provided to the applicants so they can help use that to design their project.

2:12:19 I see, Gary, you popped on. Did you want to provide some comments? As a way of introduction, Gary Jacobs is the principal for Ascent and might be able to add something to my response. Thank you, Sandra, Mayor Pro Tem, members of the Council. I'm Gary Jacobs with Ascent. Been here all evening listening to the workshop just like you have and taking your comments. And our job is to represent the town and the town's interests.

2:12:46 On this project to help you make an informed decision. So to the degree that these documents that you're citing are key policy documents, they'll be used in our environmental review to reflect the impacts of the project. So that's our job. And that's what we'll do. Okay. So I just thank you, Gary. Nice to meet you. I just said, you've got a list of those things. We may need to add some along the way.

2:13:15 Gary, obviously this is, I mean, there's never been a project like this built anywhere near any of us. I'm thinking closest examples is maybe Universal City in Hollywood and perhaps what's happened up at North Star, but this is completely foreign territory. The other thing I would point out is that the timeline that was represented this evening seems profoundly unrealistic. And that's what we'll do. Okay, so I just...

2:13:45 Hello? Is anybody there? You're muted there, Sandra. Sorry. Yeah, just in dealing with the Forest Service, I think that the timeline that's being presented, which again is dependent upon two different environmental processes, CEQA and NEPA, seems quite ambitious and quite optimistic. And I think it would be good to have a better idea of what's going to happen if timelines aren't going to get met.

2:14:19 You know, what does that look like and how is that, how it's going to start affecting things? I don't see the Forest Service being able to, you know, do the kinds of things that they're being asked to do in the timeline that was presented. Do you guys have any thoughts on that? Sandra, would you like me to respond based on our experience on this? Sure, that'd be great, thank you. Sure. And first off, I want to let the town know that we are experienced in projects like this.

2:14:48 We've just completed a couple of major projects in the Tahoe Basin. One is the Village at Squaw Valley specific plan, which was sizable. It's about the size of this project. And the other was the base-to-base gondola project between Squaw Valley and Alpine Meadows, which was a joint EIR-EIS involving the Forest Service.

2:15:14 You know, there are a couple of ways to look at this. There is a NEPA and a CEQA component, but it can be prepared as one document, which is what we will be doing. The process that we're going to undergo is to have a very coordinated effort between both the town and the Forest Service. Obviously, the applicant has to perform also. The applicant has to produce certain materials.

2:15:41 including a very detailed project description and a firm one at that. We are experienced in working on complex projects like this and how to bring to bear what one needs to move forward and our project management team is a really top-notch team on this project. I'm a principal and the CEO of the organization with 40 years of experience.

2:16:11 In CEQA and NEPA compliance. So yes, it is an aggressive schedule. Whether that schedule can be met is going to be a challenge. We will do our best. We will lay out our expectations with the town and the town will be a partner with us. We'll be a partner with the town on it. We're an extension of your staff. But yes, it'll require a lot of coordination and interaction.

2:16:40 It is an ambitious schedule. I absolutely agree with you, and these are very difficult schedules to meet, but it'll certainly, we will do our share to do what needs to be done. So in terms of that, Dan or Sandra, is it fair to say that Ascend is basically on a T&M basis, and if things get pushed back by, say, a year or so, it's going to be the obligation of the applicant to cover those costs?

2:17:10 The Forest Service runs into trouble and they're delayed. They lose staff. All the kinds of things. Big fires happen and they can't respond to this stuff. The obligation to pay to extend the process is going to be on the applicant. Is that correct? Yes. Yeah. A sense contract is 100% paid by the applicant and they've already provided the deposit for phase one to start. So we've already received that funding. Okay. All right. So one final point. Andy, if you're still with us.

2:17:38 I think it would be a good idea for you to provide your legal advice to both the Planning Commission and the Town Council when you're dealing with a real estate development project, especially one of this size and scope and scale. What are appropriate comments for Town Council members to be making and for Planning Commission members to be making? I'm very, I'm just leery of litigation.

2:18:06 I'm leery if when we're dealing with an existential problem such as housing where, to Sarah Ray's point, if, well, gee, if you just do what's going to be done by the code, that's not going to address the problem. I think it would be helpful to get some guidance from you as to what is appropriate and for town council members to understand. I have a number of questions. What is going to happen if the environmental analysis is not satisfactory?

2:18:34 What is this kind of a process going to look like? I think that would be a useful exercise for all of us. Sure. Well, what I can tell you right now is that I think what you're thinking of is the due process requirement for some types of land use decisions where if a council member kind of announces ahead of time how they're going to vote, that can be a due process issue. However, most of what the Mountain is talking about

2:18:58 So the town is under no obligation to do a general plan amendment, nor a specific plan amendment, nor to create a specific plan of any kind, nor to enter into a development agreement. So because the town can say yes or no, the council and the PEDC have more latitude to talk about what kinds of things that you might want to see in exchange for doing any of these purely discretionary things. So if, for example,

2:19:25 Councilmember Rae says, we want you to do more than the minimum for housing. That's perfectly fine. That's fine. And the council as a whole can make that one of the negotiating points for a DA or can say we feel a lot better about it. Let's back up a little bit. Before we even start talking about a development agreement, to that point that Sarah brought up, the minimum by our codes is not going to address the concerns of the town.

2:19:53 Are we in a position where the EIR and the environmental document could say, I mean, will we have discretion? Will we be able to say they've sat, they will comply with all the minimum standards. Will we be able to say, I'm sorry, that's not going to work. We're not going to approve the EIR. Well, there are, okay, a couple things. The EIR will look at the environmental impacts. Are there environmental impacts from not having enough housing? Maybe.

2:20:21 And the EIR and EIS will look at that. What the council is allowed to do under both CEQA and NEPA is to refuse to adopt statements of override considerations. And that's your ultimate discretion. If a project can be mitigated, it's a little harder to refuse to approve the CEQA document, but a project like this is almost certainly going to require statements of overrides or the NEPA equivalent.

2:20:51 And you're never ever obligated to do that. So that is a way that a jurisdiction can refuse to approve a project that has environmental impacts is simply by refusing to adopt the statement of overrides. And as you'll recall, CEQA says that if there are environmental impacts that cannot be mitigated to a level of less than significance, that the only way to approve the project is to adopt a statement of overriding considerations, which essentially says that the project

2:21:19 will have benefits that override and outweigh the environmental harm that the project may cause. And the case law is very, very clear that you're just allowed to do that. You don't have to adopt the statement of overrides. CEQA allows you to say, no, we don't think the project is worth the environmental consequences. So you have discretion both at the CEQA level and then you have discretion acting as the town's legislative body to...

2:21:46 Decide that you're just not going to do some of these discretionary things. You don't have to enter into a development agreement. You don't have to do a general plan amendment. So we can talk as we go along about where the town has discretion, but in general, those are the two areas. Land use, you have discretion. CEQA, you have discretion. And I think that nothing that I've heard so far from any council member or PEDC member is out of bounds or inappropriate. The council and the PEDC are allowed to have opinions about what you would like to see in the project.

2:22:15 The conditions under which you might be interested in a development agreement or a general plan amendment. And then I guess implicitly, conversely, the conditions under which you would not be interested in that kind of thing. So I think it's just going to be helpful. I mean, Andy, this is, you know, I'm familiar with this. I understand what you're saying. I think when you're dealing with a project like this, where the issue of workforce housing is, in my mind, it's existential. I know that's an overused word.

2:22:44 But nobody can afford to live in this town right now. There is no, I don't see any, I look forward to seeing what they're going to propose. I don't see any way to mitigate this. And I think that it will be very helpful as we go to each decision point for Dan, for you and or any to be polling the council and be very clear. Do you understand what's happening? I don't want to, we don't want to be jerking the applicant around and getting down the road.

2:23:14 When, if at decision points, as they come up, we could be saying directly, look, this is not the housing, just for example, this housing piece is not working. And we're not even close to being where we need to get to to move this thing forward. I don't, this is, this is a, I mean, this is uncharted waters. This is a, we're in some pretty interesting territory here. So I'd look to your and Dan's advice as to how to do this, because it's not, this is not a typical development project.

2:23:41 Yeah, you're right about that. I mean, we're getting a little bit far from the agenda item, which is the ascent contract, but I will say that I haven't had a chance to talk to staff about this, but I would imagine that what we would do as this project starts to unfold a little bit is I imagine that we, the staff, would come to the council and the PEDC and would say, what is it that you would like to see this project do? Beyond simply what the applicant is proposing, what are the kind of the core values that you want to see in the project?

2:24:11 What kinds of things are you going to want we the staff to ask for or require from the applicant as we move along? Because of course, as you say, we don't want to lead them down a road that could be a dead end. We don't want to express the town's priorities to the applicant without knowing what the town's priorities actually are as directed by the council with input from the PEDC. So I think that we'll have probably a number of conversations as we go along. We're just barely getting started.

2:24:40 We will be looking for lots of direction and oversight and input from the council and the PEC, and we look forward to having the conversations. Okay, so I will leave it there, but I certainly share Sarah's concern. I listed a number of other concerns that are just above and beyond any other type of project we've ever seen in this community. So I look forward to staff checking with council, checking with taking our pulse. Please do not get out ahead of us.

2:25:08 Please make sure that you know what we're thinking so you can make those appropriate representations. One last question, which I think is ascent specific. This, the CEQA document, the Town of Mammoth Lakes is the lead agency. Let's go back to housing again. Let's say that the housing impacts are not just going to affect Mammoth Lakes, but again, Gary, you know, the land configuration of this region is 90% federal public land.

2:25:36 There's very, very little private property anywhere around here. So if we can't mitigate housing effects of Mammoth Lakes, this is going to spill over into unincorporated Monroe County, the city of Bishop. Mammoth Resorts already houses a significant percentage of their workforce in Bishop and buses them up here to go back and forth to work. To what degree are we looking at that in the CEQA document? Are we looking at that type of geography or are we not? Maybe you could speak to that a little bit.

2:26:06 Sure. Let me speak to it in a couple of different ways. The first is our contract is a two-phase contract. This first phase, which we are going under contract to now, is to do the scoping for the environmental impact report, environmental impact statement. We know broadly what we need to address, but the issue of housing tonight, which has been so importantly daylighted.

2:26:34 Is an issue that obviously requires a lot of focus. As we go through this phase, we'll continue to listen to the various input that we receive and develop our scope for the next phase, which will also go in front of you for approval. So you will see our work plan to address these issues. The second answer to your question is the issue of housing in CEQA is actually a fairly narrow issue.

2:27:03 It really looks at two key issues, whether you're inducing population growth that's unplanned or whether you're displacing housing. The issue of whether you're housing workers who are important to a project is not really the province of what CEQA asks us to look at.

2:27:29 Now, that doesn't mean that we don't work on projects where housing is an important issue and there are ways to get at that. But the CEQA document itself, unless the town wants to push a little bit of the envelope on CEQA and that happens, doesn't really look at the sort of housing question that you're asking. If there was policies to provide workforce housing,

2:27:59 And we don't, and I'm not going to say we're expert at all in your policies. We're not under contract yet. We will become familiar with these things. But as these policies come out and we look at them and they're tied to the environmental impacts of the project, then they'll help to drive what the analysis will look at and whether it's a problem that can be solved on the site or has to be solved elsewhere.

2:28:24 There aren't really boundaries to our environmental document other than where the impacts might occur. And there are some court cases suggesting that it can, in some circumstances, be appropriate to look at kind of the economic and social ramifications of a project insofar as they affect the physical environment. That was kind of a novel thing that came out of a Walmart case. And so there's some scope to do that. But as Gary said,

2:28:52 The CEQA document is not the primary arena where you're going to look at housing issues. That's really more of a town policy issue. But we will be working through all those issues. We will, Alicia or I will be working with Gary and his team to figure out how much housing can be addressed in the EIR, EIS, and we'll have lots of conversations with the council as we go forward. Okay, I won't belabor this any further. Thanks for your time. But this is certainly an item that I know the council is taking very, very seriously.

2:29:23 This is a great big deal. So thank you very much. Lynda, you're muted, just so you know. Okay. Are you prepared then, John, to make a motion on this item? Yes, I'll make a motion that the Town Council authorize the Professional Services Agreement with Ascent Environmental for the Mammoth Mountain Main Lodge Redevelopment Project CEQA analysis and to return to the Town Council for authorization to proceed.

2:29:57 Once the MOU has been drafted and shared with the council. Okay. So that's your amended motion then from the agenda. Okay. A second for that? Sarah, you moved your lips, but I couldn't hear you. I'll second. Thank you. All right. I'm sorry. Could I just clarify what you mean by to proceed? Do you mean that they should not start work on the contract or? That's correct. That there will not be an authorization to proceed.

2:30:30 Until the MOU has been completed, has been shared with the council. I mean, this project, we've scheduled the kickoff meeting for July 2nd, so I think we're, and they have to get out, as mentioned in the workshop, there is biological resources out there that only occur. Again, I look to staff for creative solution here, but again, we don't know, I mean, this is an MOU between the town and the Forest Service and the applicant on a,

2:31:00 A uniquely complex endeavor for this community. I mean, I guess what we could do is we could go ahead and start working, then the council could maybe cancel the contract at some point once we've already started working, but perhaps there's a draft of the MOU that could be shared. Something that would give the council some insight into how this working relationship is going to work going forward. We certainly could share a draft of the MOU, but we just wouldn't be able to bring it for you in open session until...

2:31:29 And we would really like to start the project, at least start the analysis sooner. I just hope this isn't a harbinger of things to come. Because, you know, Andy, do you have a suggestion on that? Do you have a draft of the MOU that you could share with the council for us to review? Yeah, absolutely. The draft is prepared. I think that we're happy with it in its current form. The wild card in this is going to be how long does it take the Forest Service to review it and hash through it with us?

2:31:58 How long does it take the mountain to review it, hash through it? But the MOU is not intended to be... The current draft is something that I think everyone should be able to agree to. It's not really intended to be onerous. It's really just intended to write down who is doing what. It's not overly complex. It's just, here's what the town's gonna do. Here's what the forest service is gonna do. Here's what the mountain's gonna do. So I'm hoping that it won't take too long once those other two entities can...

2:32:28 We have to start looking at it, but we just can't control how long it takes. And I mean, as I said before, and as you mentioned, Councilmember Wentworth, because we can terminate the contract with a cent at any time, we would have relatively limited exposure if we had a cent start working on bio surveys and things like that that have a kind of a long lead time or can only be done at certain times a year. And even if we then had to terminate the contract later, we would not have spent very much money and the mountain would be on the hook for it anyway.

2:32:57 So I think that I understand your caution about not wanting to get out over the edge of our skis, but there's some kind of critical path issues that maybe we could get Ascent working on before we get things ironed out with the mountain and the Forest Service. Okay, that's fine. So let's go ahead and proceed. But I just, from this council member's perspective, I, this cannot be, we have got to put the interests of this community first. That is what we do and that is who we are.

2:33:29 And we cannot be perceived or, in fact, bending to timelines and aggressive this is an aggressive that. Many of us have worked with the Forest Service for many years. We know the reality of this district. We know the reality of this unit. And so, Gary, buckle up. I will amend my motion to approve, authorize a professional services agreement with the Senate Environment for the Mammoth Mountain Main Lodge Redevelopment.

2:34:00 Project CEQA analysis. Okay, and can I get a second for that, please? Yeah, I can second that. I do just want to, I want to agree with John there. I really, it rubs me the wrong way when it's like, we got to do this now. That's going to be a bona fide way to get me to bulk in the future, so we can keep that in mind. Yeah, and I mean, just to add, to jump on the bandwagon there, I agree. I mean, I think that we want to see it in print.

2:34:29 We want to be able to look at it, to think about it, to talk about it, and not be signing things, you know, prior to that as a regular basis. So I guess if anything, this is sort of a comment to staff that when possible and as much as, you know, feasible, let us see this is what we are agreeing to and what we are agendizing before it's ready. That's not going to be an easy thing to do, I think. So thank you.

2:34:57 I feel like if we start going down that road, I'm going to start opposing things on principle because we haven't had a chance. I just want to say I'll be right there with you. Okay, so we'll do a roll call on this, please, Angie. Councilmember Rae. Yes. Councilmember Stapp. Yes. Councilmember Wetworth. Yes. And Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Yes, thank you. All right, let's move on to public hearings, which is the highlight of the evening.

2:35:28 which will be a public hearing, which we will open now for approval of the appropriations limit, investment policy, debt policy, reserve policy, and annual budget for fiscal year 21-22, which will also include the consideration of the six listed resolutions here. Just FYI, the resolutions listed in the staff report are a short one, so we will be adhering indeed in this

2:35:58 Yes, that is correct, Mayor Pro Tem. That last one was added after that section of the staff report. I did not go back and pick that up. So thank you for clarifying that. I was going to start with that process and that the sixth resolution is returning to repayment of our internal loan for vehicle.

2:36:28 So that's the $340,000 a year. And so we stopped that for two years by resolution. So we're coming back to it to start that process after just one year. So that's the sixth one that's not listed, but it is attached to the agenda. So that's what you're referring to. So thank you. Okay, so consider the public hearing open. And Rob, it's all yours. Thank you. Thank you. I'm going to share my screen real quick.

2:37:03 So, yes, thank you for kind of walking through the complexity of this particular agenda item. There are a number of things that we are covering. They are all items that are part of our annual budget review and are part of our reaffirming policies that are specific to the budget and maybe financial aspects of the town. So I'm going to spend just a brief amount of time on these.

2:37:32 I have them on the list here for you to see. And I'm going to tell you the staff report, which was quite lengthy. Hopefully you all enjoyed the reading. I know we certainly enjoyed the writing of it. But that was meant to be a little bit more in detail through the process, more so than my presentation will be tonight. I'm going to really spend sort of some high-level processes on this, but I want to walk through that. But it's certainly available for questions.

2:38:00 But we did try to provide not only a lengthy staff report that commingled our prior tentative budget and a crosswalk to our current final budget, but also some of the CIP elements that were introduced by Public Works back in the first part of June. So really trying to bring it all together as one document, including, you know, light on detail for the budget as was included in the agenda.

2:38:27 And on all of the policies for your review. So I'm going to go quickly through these items here. So the appropriations limit is really just capping the size of our budget on an annual basis. We can increase it by the calculations between the per capita income of California as well as our growth of

2:38:54 That population within Mono County, that calculation here is 4.5% for this year. We're not near that number. So we'll build that 4.5% over our prior appropriation limit. So prior year was around 27 million. And so we've gone up to 28.245. So we're not near that. And hopefully we don't start bumping into that because that will be a challenge for us if we do so.

2:39:17 The next item was the investment policy, and we did make a couple of adjustments to the investment policy. Really, it caps limits on what we can have within particular areas and just how we invest in general. But the only areas that are important to us for tonight and what we bump up against is LAF.

2:39:37 Investment Pool Limits as well as the Mono County Limit. So I've increased both of those and they're really based upon anticipated revenues or fund balances, if you will, within those particular investment pools.

2:39:53 And so those are just minor updates that we would expect over time as we do accumulate more funds. This particular year, we have a lot of capital projects. So that's where the funding is sitting. We acquire the revenue sources for those projects, and then we will expend them over the life of the construction. So we will have a fair amount of money in the bank to start that process. The reserve policy, we've talked about that a few times.

2:40:23 Reserves have altered over the last couple of years. We've established a baseline because of our revenue fluctuations during the COVID budget cycle. And along with that establishment of that baseline revenue item, we created the debt reserve component. So these aren't new. I kind of talked about these in the third quarter presentation for

2:40:52 The current fiscal year as we were making the recommendations to fund these. I'm quite proud that we have as a group funded these reserve elements fully. So everything is within policy. And not only does that obviously set us up for potential needs in the future, it really looks good on our S&P reviews, which they've assured us they will be reviewing us on an annual basis based upon our tourism economy.

2:41:20 And I think we've really done exactly what we said we would do with that. So very, very proud of the reserves. Debt policy, there's no adjustments to that for the year. And then with the adoption of the budget is one more resolution that we're going to talk about tonight. Clearly, that's just you're going to, you've received the staff report, you've received the line in detail, our presentation tonight.

2:41:50 Should give you the level of comfort and the ability to ask questions that you may need to adopt that and to move forward with that resolution. And then finally, as I mentioned in the opening comments, as part of the sort of reduction of expenditures for undetermined amounts of time during COVID, we stopped our repayment of our

2:42:15 Vehicle Service Loan, which was $340,000 a year. We stopped that for two years per resolution. And really, we want to get back to repaying that as quickly as possible. And so we've rolled that back in. So that's the final resolution for tonight. Any questions on that section before I move on? Okay. Part of the final budget, we put together what's an estimated fund balance. And I'm going to put a huge asterisk underlined and a bold around estimated.

2:42:48 Because the way that this particular graph and these balances work is we are trying to predict in our estimated balance that, you know, the first column of numbers, if you will, these are the amounts that we would expect each of these funds to have at the close of this fiscal year. So, you know, in, you know, we'll know those final numbers in a couple of months, but based upon the way we see things going and the trends, this is where we should see these balances landing.

2:43:17 The green column in the middle is reflective of the budget as it's planned for the year. So what we've put together in the budget and the change in fund balance that occurs at each of these funds is present in that green column. And then the final column of estimated new balance would be what we expect if we just hit budget.

2:43:41 For by the end of next fiscal year, so a year from now, where would we expect those balances to actually be? So this is important. This has been important for prior councils to really kind of understand is not only what we're planning for the year, but what we really have in these funds and available. And as you know, I present the first quarter.

2:44:04 A budget review in October, which has the finalized fund balance numbers for in this particular example as of June 2021. I'll be presenting those and council will make some decisions around how to appropriate those funds or let them reside within their fund balances. So these are not anything really in particular to note. On this page, I do want to draw attention to Measure U.

2:44:33 Measure U is expected to have a fund balance of $2.2 million at the end of this fiscal year. And the way we structured the budget, which I'll get to that in a later slide, we have a set aside of $300,000 and another $200,000 that we wanted to contribute to.

2:44:52 Fund balance. And so those are both represented in this $533,000 number. And I think hitting those numbers is pretty easy to do with Measure U because we don't have a lot of moving parts in that throughout the year unless there's a large project that comes forward and that again is a council direction. But we do expect to have Measure U balance above.

2:45:17 And the other accounts, all this kind of flows together in

2:45:49 The change in fund balance, for example, in the green column will show up in subsequent reports and be able to follow through. Now the notes here, they're not inclusive of all of the holdouts or set-asides that do exist within these fund balances or commitments. They're just the ones that were really pertinent to either the presentation this evening or part of the development of the budget.

2:46:15 So when I talk about, you know, the committed items for S operations, that's actually a balancing item within the town's budgets because, you know, S expenditures is higher than the allocation based upon our revenues. And just other things that we really needed to call out, but it's not an exhaustive list. We cover that again in that first presentation in October. When we get to the final budget, we start talking about total revenues across all funds.

2:46:47 The bulk of our presentations today talk about general fund revenue or general fund expenditures and then how they support maybe gas tax and airport and just some of the other ancillary funds are fed in over time. But this is a comprehensive look at all of the sort of revenue sources across all of the funds that are out there, the major ones anyway. And so in general, our proposed budget for this fiscal year is

2:47:15 A total of $63,089,000 in actual revenues listed. Now, I put the capital projects up there. We're going to talk a little bit more about those a little later. That's really not revenue. That's associated with funding that's set aside to perform those tasks, but really including that in our reporting. But it's fairly sizable, and that's the biggest difference that we have this year versus any prior years is those amounts.

2:47:45 And I'm going to hide something real quick here. The other thing this just shows, obviously, we have actuals from prior years. The variance to prior budget is helpful to see how we're growing the budget year over year. Now, this particular year, obviously, because we've come off of a very constrained COVID-19 budget, they look fairly sizable in adjustment. And that's, you know, good to note.

2:48:16 The far right column does provide you with a change from the most recent fiscal year actuals. So it kind of shows you really, you know, the adjustments that are there. And I think some of the conservative budgeting practices that we use really are highlighted in this, you know, when we're comparing the $14.6 million TOT occupancy compared to, you know, $16.2 million. And that was, again, leading into a COVID year.

2:48:46 Very good numbers. But really try to illustrate for you all just an adjustment of revenues across time in comparison. Yes. So a couple of questions. The capital projects explain the variance to the proposed budget from prior budgets again, the $23,000 increase in capital projects. Yeah. So

2:49:18 This particular year, we have developed a more robust CIP, you know, five-year CIP look. We have better reporting on the planned projects, and we actually have planned projects that we are starting. Last fiscal year, we had a continuation of some existing projects, but we did not allocate or start any new capital projects within

2:49:46 So there's nothing really budgeted in 2021 as we were just continuing existing projects at that point. So there's a fairly robust list of projects on the current fiscal year, which we'll get to a little bit later, but that's the discrepancy of that $23 million. So where did that difference, that $20,000, where do we take that from to drop it into revenue? Those would have a various either grant funding.

2:50:16 Support for over time. In this particular one, we have funding coming in from we've accumulated over years. So it's not necessarily revenue in this particular case. And I made a point to that earlier. These are just showing the revenues that we are attributing to capital projects so that we're balanced. For example, for the largest one, there's the $14 million for the Community Recreation Center.

2:50:43 So that includes bond proceeds that we're sitting in a reserve account. It includes some other dollars like that that have moved into that capital project. So the idea there is we're recognizing it as revenue this year because the project will be moving forward and being implemented versus leaving the money sitting into a reserve account, actually recognizing it as the revenue due to the initiation project as part of the capital improvement program. So we're just moving it out of reserves. Okay.

2:51:13 On the total revenue, Rob, for 2021, what does your crystal ball say that would be closer to than the 32 projected? I mean, it's actually 63 projected. You know, I would expect transient occupancy tax to be above, you know, at 20 or above. So I think that particular line item alone, which is the largest item of ours, could produce

2:51:43 What I was asking was against the adopted budget, what you thought the actual...

2:52:11 The 2021 budget. Oh, I'm sorry, 2021? The adopted versus what we think the amended will be. Okay, sorry about that. I didn't understand that question. Yeah, so by the coming year to October when you have the actuals, that'll be interesting. That's what I said. What did your crystal ball tell you for? Yeah, so we, in the third quarter, which we presented in May, we did increase the TOT. I do believe that number is going to come in somewhere close to 16 million.

2:52:41 For the year, so it's going to be very close to 1920s actuals, and that's against an 11.2 budgeted, that 11.39 is just a little bit higher based upon some other areas, but that truly the transient occupancy tax, you know, that's going to be probably 4 million, 4.5 million higher than we expected, and we realized some of that in the third quarter.

2:53:02 I think the rest of them are going to flow through just about as expected. There aren't going to be too many adjustments. So at 32, we'll probably be somewhere around 36 to 37. Okay. All right. Thank you, Rob. Appreciate that. Just, yeah. Thanks. Any other questions? Okay. Now, go on to the appropriations or the expenditures. These are also listed, you know, across all funds.

2:53:33 Capturing both, you know, the expenditures and then transfers out or pass through amounts across the bottom. Nothing really, you know, significance to note here. We did see an adjustment to proposed budget for general fund. As you remember, we did quite a bit of reductions in prior year based upon, you know, COVID-19. And so that's been in there.

2:54:02 TBD, which is a pass-through element, that one was also significantly reduced. So just in general, a pretty good representation of the comparisons. Now, capital projects, again, you'll see the same sort of discrepancies that you saw in the previous one, although these expenditures obviously are tied to specific projects that we'll get to a little bit later in the presentation. Any specific questions on this slide? So, Rob, real quick, so the big...

2:54:34 Do you make any differentiation as to how a project is being funded? So capital projects at $24 million, that's obviously there's a lot of grant money in there. There's a lot of other sources of funding, correct? Yeah, later on in the presentation, we have one particular slide where it shows you the project expenditure, planned expenditure, as well as the revenue source. So you'll be able to see the grants that are associated with that. I didn't break it down by dollar amount.

2:55:02 But at least not for the PowerPoint this evening, but the staff report did provide that level of detail to say exactly what funding was coming from which grant. It's just I think budget process you guys put together has been pretty simple, pretty easy to comprehend. So when they're if we're going to I'm assuming this is a part of what we're doing with the CPI, it's going to be integrated into the budget this way going forward. So there may be.

2:55:29 Some pretty significant variations year to year, which is fine, which is for the council to be able to explain to people, hey, we got a bunch of grants, it's in the budget, we're doing a bunch of capital work, and that will be helpful to explain to people. Yeah, and I can definitely enhance the graphs that we have here that show the funding sources and which are grant funded, which may be coming from reserves, if that helps answer that question.

2:55:55 Yeah, I mean, I think to John's point is when, you know, the public is asking us why it was, you know, you know, last year's adopted expenditures, 31, and this year's 57, you know, almost, you know, a million. So it's good to know just, you know, what the answer is. The answer is, you know, putting money into the capital projects column, that's fine. And I think, Lynda, to your sort of consistent point that you and Sarah both talked about communication to the public, telling our story and all the rest of it.

2:56:24 It may be helpful, Rob, when you publish, you know, here's the budget without the capital projects. You put in the capital projects as a single line. That's how we get to this number. So it's easy, digestible. People understand what's happening. Just a thought. Thank you. Good input. I can do what's basically the operational budget and separate the capital out of that on a third line. So you can see just the growth of operational costs. That's a good recommendation. Thank you. Happy to be of service. Thank you.

2:56:55 Yes, we're so helpful on the budget, aren't we? Absolutely. We spend our lives on this over the last four months, and Second Set of Eyes is pretty good at this stage of the game, so thank you. This is the combined fund statement. I'm sorry, it is a little bit hard to read. I try to put it in here. Certainly within the staff report, it's possibly a little bit easier to read. But that's talking about and showing the actual funds that are there.

2:57:26 What is expected as far as revenue for the year? What is expected as far as transfers in? And, you know, total resources. And that compares to the expenditures, any transfers out, which would support a transfer out in that column would be a transfer in on the other side somewhere. Those two numbers have to balance out in your total appropriation. So total funding that we're spending on.

2:57:52 Then the final column is a change in fund balance expected for each one of those funds, at least how we're budgeting. And so you can see it kind of all tied together here, as we've been talking about in the previous areas. This is really all of it in front of you at once. And so we have a change in fund balance of about $735,000 positive fund balance for the year.

2:58:17 And that's always good to see. Fund balance can be either grown or used to support things so they can reduce. And so that's seeing a positive number in there is always a good thing. These are now going to be a little bit familiar. There are not a lot of changes in these from the tentative budget presentation at the end of May to now. I think in this particular slide we did.

2:58:47 Make an adjustment to add a full-time employee to the parks maintenance department, and at the same time, we pulled out a summer and a winter seasonal employee for the same department, which would have affected parks maintenance and snow removal and facility maintenance. But for the most part, we've sort of netted out between two seasonal and one full-time.

2:59:15 And again, I'm going to kind of skip through these. This is a chart that I provided. We often get questions about, you know, where certainly where salaries are spent, where employees are allocated as far as number of body count, full-time equivalencies, if you will, and the total expenditures by different types. So I was particularly happy with the way this graph came together. And I think, again, it's

2:59:43 Updated, obviously, with the changes that we made, but really not something to dwell on. I can't tell you, so for all the full-time staff, this is where this, the bottom line there is accumulation of both of these graphs, both of these charts, because it's really one chart split in half. But just showing how we're spending the salaries and human capital across our organization, so.

3:00:11 That's the full-time staff and the part-time staff, $754,000 for part-time employees for the year. So total increase in labor costs, really about $1.2 million. So we did have quite a few new positions for the year and just general expenditure increase, which we're going to have on an annual basis. I would say typically

3:00:39 Our growth in labor costs, even if we keep the number of employees static, is somewhere around 450 to 600,000, depending upon where our health insurance premiums and workers' comp and those types of things and PERS adjustments come in. So just kind of keeping who we have, we grow fairly significantly on an annual basis. But this particular year, we had sort of a strategic spending of staff.

3:01:07 In increasing capacities that really support the visitation we expect to see. So any questions on labor? I think I have one graph here that just shows it as a part chart. Yeah, Rob, that year over year number increase. Yeah. Going back a number of years, I don't know if it's been sort of 10% every year, but that's again, that's a key number for council members of the public to say, look, our costs of doing business.

3:01:35 Has it incorporated California down even if we don't change anything? This is what we're dealing with every year. And at some point it runs into reality that we can't afford it. We're not there yet, but again, that's a key talking point to the public. Yeah, I would agree 100% with you, John. If you look at the expenditure of $13.6 million, that's far and away the largest cost we have within our operating budget.

3:02:02 And it typically grows around four and a half to five percent a year. This particular one is higher, obviously, for the additional staff. But when I say typical, that's just without adding staff. So every year we would expect to see something along those lines and grow. So it is something to be aware of. And if we do have, you know, we've enjoyed some fairly strong revenue years. And if we do have challenges, this is one of those things that's much more difficult to stop and to reduce because it's layoffs.

3:02:30 Different things that are just fairly unpleasant. And those would impact core services, obviously, and what we're able to deliver as an organization. One other question. How much or is any of this labor index to inflation? I ask that just because of what's happening these days. Is that Dan shaking his head saying no? Probably not.

3:02:55 Inflation index, the things driving labor this year was a lot of it was some of the ad backs that we cut out last year as we went into COVID mode and that adjusted budget there. And so that resulted in some additional coming back into the budget. Some of the base costs and our labor costs are tied to negotiated agreements at this point are fixed. And so they're not moving up at the same rate of what potentially inflation would look like this year, at least what we're hearing in the news at this point.

3:03:24 And so that's really not tied to that. Where we get a little bit of that type of push would be in some of our materials and supplies and ultimately in the capital projects, but not so much driven on the labor side. Okay, so if inflation turns out to be a huge problem, that's not going to be a problem for us with our workforce, pretty much. It'll be once we get into negotiations with employees, depending on the impact that actually inflation is over time, that's where we'd have that discussion at that point in time. Got it. Okay, thank you.

3:03:59 So this now switching gears back to primarily what we viewed in the tentative budget, just talking about the general fund revenues, major revenue components, not a lot of adjustment here from the prior time that you had seen this. So I will kind of just skip through without too many words here. Any questions on the general fund revenue areas? Different look.

3:04:32 On how this one just shows really the percentage from a budget standpoint of where we, you know, our major components are for revenue. This certainly doesn't stay static. It does adjust throughout the year. That transient occupancy tax climbs up, you know, to high 60s on good years, which we appreciate. And the other ones, you know, will diminish, obviously, as the overall dollars increase for transient occupancy tax.

3:05:04 Just kind of graphically showing it and how it looks for the different items. Still, there's $24,874,000. It's fairly sizable for us. It's certainly, you know, larger than my five years I've been here. This is by far the largest and it's grown. Obviously, last year, fairly sizable. But I think it's appropriately sized. I mean, property taxes is also in there, obviously. That's growing, you know, quite.

3:05:33 Quite rapidly, along with sales tax and other things that are fairly strong. This is a look at the general fund expenditures by department. I often get this question more frequently than most is within the town's departments, how does it fit as far as the overall cost to have that department within our organization and how has it changed over time? So I receive that question quite often. This particular

3:06:06 Chart and the following graph sort of illustrate how they go together. And so it's just important to show that in our overall growth year over year. And there's a graph that basically breaks it down by the different departments. And if there's ever questions about what's included in that, I can certainly provide that level of detail. I also hear that often enough is what is that actually included? But happy to answer individual questions that folks may have. Rob, real quick, back to the previous slide.

3:06:38 Just our department, when we go up $30,000, why do we go up $30,000? Sometimes it's a very, so we did give you a little bit of an increase this year. Let me say that the primary driver on that, John, I think we picked up one additional health insurance component, which is for a family and stuff, that's in the $30,000 range. So when we have

3:07:10 We have both, so an individual's health and care insurance on an annual basis runs about 15,700 and I think it's around 27,34.

3:07:21 For a staff member plus one, which is the highest we have with our council members. But we had prior council members that were not taking the health insurance. And so that primarily is an inclusion of just a different set of council and whether we have health insurance or not. Good to know. Thank you. I should say all of your other council members got a wage increase. And not me. That's good. But not you.

3:07:53 But it's also reflective. I mean, we, you know, Dan and I had to go through within from tentative to final budget and make some adjustments, you know, to expenditures within the departments. I mean, we, as you know, we've kind of added some things, you know, staff wise and we had an imbalance when we were in tentative because we'd added, you know, some new positions, new departments. And so we had to make some adjustments there and there was some cost cutting that went through.

3:08:22 But I think it was not too impactful to the departments. And I think it was balanced and appropriate. But we definitely had that discipline to reduce that. Any further questions on the expenditures? I can show you graphically there. So for the new department, 467 Office of Outdoor Recreation. Yes. That number is inclusive of salary benefits.

3:08:49 Yeah, so what we have, the cost of the department, we certainly have the employees, which it is the manager as well as the trails manager position that was previously funded out of the trails budget on 210, at least a portion of it was. So those two positions are there, but we also have some training, some

3:09:17 Regular expenditures. I think there were less than 15,000 in general expenditures for that department outside of staff. Okay. And then, Rob, I don't think I've ever asked you this. How do we allocate general expenses around, you know, copiers and maintenance for the building and heating? And how do you allocate that across department? By actual uses or just a percentage? We actually, they're in general services at department 416. So we actually don't.

3:09:47 Yeah, so the rent of the building, the utilities, the copier items, the bulk of our supplies are living in that account. And we don't really have to separate it out across departments unless we do really a comprehensive cost study to determine overhead for a billing rate for the department. And we haven't done that in a couple of years, but that's when we would have to figure out how to allocate that.

3:10:13 And it really would be probably based upon overall expenditure of the department and how that flows through and, you know, what type of activities they perform. So when the county does like an A87 allocation plan, is that required in county government but not in town government? I think, Lynda, that depending on some grants require that. If you wish, you charge an overhead account, general overhead because it has that limit on it, the A87 account. I've built those programs in the past.

3:10:42 A few years back, looking at it here, the amount of work and effort that goes into it and for the amount of revenue that you would end up sharing across the departments was pretty minimal. Plus, a lot of those allocations would go to departments, which then you would just increase your general fund transfer out to cover the cost to be covered and potentially come back. And so when we did that analysis about four years ago, I think it was, for example, the road department would have a large allocation to it.

3:11:11 Yet we just have to move more general fund money over there to cover the allocation to move it back. And because we're not billing based on that overhead rate in the vast majority of our departments, the cost and effort to do that to move the money back and forth really wasn't justified through that process. We do pick up overhead rates in terms of our employees and their total costs, and we do direct billings out.

3:11:38 A couple of the other departments we've looked at on that area, again, you're probably from the 87 type allocations is very minimal in terms of what the dollar amount would be, yet the overall work program to actually collect the information would probably be the equivalent to a half time plus body by the time you would spend the time counting like copies or square footages and other elements and breaking out all the different pieces.

3:12:05 It really wasn't cost effective to work through that process. I think the town doesn't have as many grant-based allocations as the county would, I suppose. So, okay, thank you. It's kind of a general question. Thanks. To clarify, I mean, we do obviously have direct billing amounts that we charge folks for services. And when those billings go through, we have calculations on staff time. Obviously, we have the hours.

3:12:34 Present and the salary based upon that. But then we use calculations, which we update annually on the cost of benefits for those particular departments. So there's a billable rate that is updated annually that we can charge out to special projects where people have those performing services. Switching gears a little bit to gas tax fund to 10, just minor adjustments in here. You're really talking about the cost of our roads department.

3:13:08 That's funded by gas tax, at least 50% of the revenue that is funded. The rest of it's coming from, actually, it's probably a little bit more of it's coming from General Fund. As you can see, $3 million of support from General Fund for this fiscal year's budget, as opposed to a total just under $5 million for the revenue. And so that's really representative of the town supporting work within either

3:13:36 Road rehabilitation projects or just snow removal in general. Snow removal is also very challenging to budget annually because of just how much snow is going to fall. We have obviously some working points in here. One of them is the snow pit and we're working fairly closely with.

3:13:59 The Forest Service on how to solve that problem. I think we've illustrated a few times we have a very costly program at the moment and the operations of the snow pit fairly significant for last year. I think in here I've got about $450,000 in anticipated expenditure for snow pit operations and that's equivalent to what we had for the current fiscal year, which there were only two major storms.

3:14:27 That's highly concerning, but I know as a staff and folks in Forest Service are working on a resolution for that. But gas taxes is an interesting one. We receive the revenue in the current year from 50% of the actual snow removal expenditures for the prior year as that gas tax snow removal element.

3:14:50 And we also receive, you know, an allocation of SB1 funding, which can go to projects as long as we have, you know, projects designated for that, which there are some in these projects today. But that's the gist of the Gas Tax Fund 210. Again, an illustration of really how those monies flow across any expenditures. This account will always be in balance. Essentially what I'll do is...

3:15:22 I will allocate whatever is necessary from general fund to make sure that there's no change in fund balance for this. Prior year when we were trying to develop it for COVID, we did have intentionally use of fund balance because we needed to reserve some funding within general fund to support our operations, but we're going back to fully funding through 10 for this fiscal year. Measure R to fund 216 is the sales tax component.

3:15:53 This is where the tax measure funds come in and are collected. That $1.3 million reflects that. That's probably a conservative number. I have sales tax both for general fund as well as the sales tax measure for R to be fairly conservative this year, just with the unknowns of coming off of COVID year and just how sustainable our recreation and visitation is going to be. But $1.3 is probably a fairly doable number.

3:16:21 In our annual expenses, the transfer to Fund 215 trails, there's an increase in that for this fiscal year to 350 from 300,000, which we've been doing for the prior four or five years. We have an agreement for MLR, the 80,000, a new item of CRC support of 75.

3:16:48 And special projects has increased this slightly. This has all been reviewed through Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and they review and approve the budget for this, or at least recommend the budget for this, and Council can come forward. I think Dan's got some comments on that. On this one here also, as you're aware, we're working through each year, or every few years, we work through the contracts with our NGOs. Mammoth Lakes Recreation is one of those.

3:17:15 That agreement is still in the process of being finalized depending how the final kind of negotiations go through that and coming back to council on July 7th. That town administration number could be modified a little bit up or down based on the final agreement in the work program that we ask MLR to do on behalf of the town. The last round of negotiations, there's a couple different moving targets in there. We've tried to really nail that down.

3:17:42 Potentially, that could bump up to as much as $85,000 or $88,000. The other question was some changes on the MLR board. More detail there, but there is an option to, if we do bump that a little bit, is to actually potentially take that out of the Measure U side versus 100% out of Measure R, in part because the amount of effort and time they're putting into the programming side of Measure U.

3:18:08 They do spend a fair amount of time on that, and that'd be a legitimate expense. In the past, we've had board members who have had family members involved with the direct family members involved with the programming. So we've tried to keep that split out and to make sure there'd be no undue influence on the budget process with staff and also to have those board members involved in those programmings to recuse themselves out of the decision-making process at the MLR level.

3:18:37 Ultimately, the final decision on those does come back to the Council, so there is some buffer in there, but that is something that will be finalized here as we come back to the first meeting in July for their agreement with Mammoth Lakes Recreation. And then how many years left on the debt payment for the CRC financing, the bond? There would be six years left on that. I think there's a schedule at the end of the report. There's a schedule at the end of the report.

3:19:07 The good news, and Dan talked about some potential moving parts that we have here. We do have, even with all anticipated expenditures listed, a change in fund balance of $62,000. I think that's conservative. So there's some movement in there. There's some funding available. But that's a positive change in fund balance. Was that just due to increased revenue? I'm sorry? Was that just due to the increased revenue?

3:19:35 No, it's really just the balancing of the expenditures against the revenue. I think our revenue has been fairly consistent. In fact, we removed interest because we just are not seeing enough interest this year. But it's typically been a little bit higher than that. This particular account is supposed to generate positive fund balance. And I think we've leveraged it to a point now where it isn't providing too much. It's only 62.

3:20:05 But yeah, so that's just a reflection of expenditures versus revenue. It did go up a little bit from the COVID expectations last year. I think we dropped it down to 1.1. So there's been a little bit of a bump up. But if you go back the last couple of years, it's in line or a hair less than a couple of the previous years. Fund C15 is where we basically capture all of the Measure Our Trails funding.

3:20:37 That doesn't actually have revenue coming directly into it. All the revenue sources are transfers in, but just a way of capturing the expenditure spent on the trail work and development in its own fund. This particular case, as I referenced in the prior slide, $350,000 from Fund 216. We have some support from General Fund, which basically covers a portion of the Sustainable Recreation Coordinator position.

3:21:04 And we have 75,000 transfer in that supports the rest of the recreation coordinator position. So a total of 95,000 comes from the town on that and unfortunately comes from the Bono County to support their operations as well as the position is defined today. And that's the position that Matt Perullo currently serves in that position as I think we've made comment before.

3:21:31 He has been hired full-time into the county, I believe, starting in October. And so we will have some savings in here. We've left a budget loan at this point. That does give us some flexibility if we look like we need that type of position, again, out of Measure U or not, or on the trail side. And so given that, there will be some potential savings in here as well. So we'll be looking at that amendment or modification once that movement of...

3:22:00 The current employees moved into the county full-time. The expenditure side down below, the staff and labor is Matt's position as well as some part-time individuals, Trill crew leaders that work with Joel on that process. But Joel has been removed from staff and labor and put back into the general fund 100%.

3:22:27 Then there's a transfer out down below of $150,000 that supports, you know, just about 75% of the cost of Joel's position all in. I think it's around $186,000 with benefits and such. But the general fund is picking up the full cost and then this transfer in just allocates some support for that position. Contractual services is really a plug number that balances this equation and it is really

3:22:55 Providing each of the funds that are available for trails production work, contract expenditures and other items that can be utilized to build trails. Measure U, the revenue sources there, I think, again, similar fluctuations that we had the prior year, I think we were around 700, we came up maybe around 100,000 from prior years revenue expectations because utilities, you know, were impacted by the lack of visitation of the reduced visitation.

3:23:27 And we expect them to come back to similar levels for prior years. So again, on par with what we're projecting for Measure R. The programming expense did go up a little bit. We had some carryover, I think, that we wanted to allocate. And then when you want to basically spend fund balance, which everything lives within fund 217 here. So the allocation of fund balance, that programming expense increasing just as we're planning on spending it this year versus

3:23:56 Letting it flow to the balance below. That rec coordinator position, we talked about that just a moment ago, that you saw that transfer in over in 215. I listed the recreational officer partial support. We had that in there as a recommendation, but that was removed during review by MLR. So we've kind of balanced it out, but that was really intended to be providing some support for that position.

3:24:25 And we've increased a little bit of special projects in sort of in conjunction with work we expect to happen. You had a comment, Dan, you wanted to make? As you mentioned that partial support for the rec officer, rather than calling it out specifically there based on the recommendations, we had $25,000 in there. That is now sitting in that special projects line item. Should it be a desire to move it back into that other support position, that could be done.

3:24:52 Go back to the review process and back to the council for final decision. At the bottom, I'd call out some MAC operating and MAC capital funding elements, and we talked about that in the fund balance estimate section. The $300,000, we've been reporting that, I think, for the last two years as a future expenditure once that facility is operational, just to give a sense of if that's fully operational and utilizing those expenditures.

3:25:25 That really is going to be the impact we see on Measure U as far as revenues compared to expenditures. So we wanted to kind of hold that over there. It isn't meaning that those funds in prior years were spent on anything. They just remain within the fund balance. This year, we are making the recommendation certainly that the $300,000 and the $200,000 do remain in the fund balance designated for the MAC.

3:25:53 to replace those funds that were used for CRC. So as I tried to illustrate in the very beginning, there's opportunity there to really fully commit to that again, possibly by the end of next year, or yet of this budgeted year. But that's really council direction, if you will. Change in fund balance, comparisons of revenue over expenditures, about $33,000.

3:26:16 You saw in the previous slide, it's $533,000 because I pulled out those sort of commitments to fund balance that we're making. Airport operations, we've talked about this a number of times, the significant adjustments over prior years, really the change for removing commercial flights and the revenues that we would see associated with those.

3:26:48 Are going to impact certainly the operations at the airport, but more importantly, the amount of funding required from the general fund to support the operations at the airport. So those top three items alone, they're around $280,000 in revenue reduction. They're something that we need to address in future years. That's going to be...

3:27:14 Something we have to either find additional charter flights and things that are coming into the airport to support that revenue stream or just find a source of revenue. Our expenditures are fixed and growing at the airport as far as operations. You know, not a generally large scale, but they are there and will increment similar to what we see on other staff expenditures.

3:27:40 For general funds. So we have a tendency of four and a half to five percent growth on an annual basis in at least labor costs. The other thing that fluctuates fairly significant in the airport is whether or not we have any capital improvement project out there. We did have significant one in the prior year, but really a smaller one for this fiscal year. And they're really finishing off the existing projects that were in process for last year.

3:28:10 The changes there show that that's where the bulk of the fluctuation is. And I do try to show it in the staff report at least more about operational versus the capital, as we discussed earlier in a way of clarifying, you know, the reports that we show in the fluctuation revenue year over year or budget year over year is a little bit easier to follow. So airport is one of those ones that has quite a bit of moving parts to it, if you will. But the one I want to highlight is really the

3:28:39 The loss of revenue from the loss of commercial flights, and that's something that we will have to address. Let me also mention now, we've had some really good discussions with the FAA regarding the calculation of employment and numbers, and they're looking at like a three-year average last few years to look at, which may mean this next year we would have at least one more year of the million dollars in capital improvement funding that would come to the airport.

3:29:07 That's not absolute yet. They're walking through the numbers and we're redoing those. I think it goes back to 17, 18, and then 18, 19, 19, 20, kind of taking out that COVID year, as they've seen that across the country with the drop in employments and activities in air service. So that was a positive discussion and a positive look the way they're trying to look at those numbers. So that could actually...

3:29:31 Result in one more year at least of a million dollars in capital funding that could come in and help with the airport. Yeah, that's a good point, Dan. I was focused so much on the operational expenditures and revenue changes that didn't really highlight the fact that FAA does provide us with grant funding annually in the term of a million dollars for capital improvement projects.

3:29:55 That would go away without the number of employments required, the 10,000 employments. And so in one way, I guess we benefited this from the COVID because they actually backed up that versus if it was just general years, we would start to incur that loss already. And I think we've also would have been impacted with the FAA CARES and CRSSA funding that they provided as response to COVID because they utilize those same numbers from prior years.

3:30:24 To provide us those funding. So quite a benefit. I guess only one little benefit we've received from COVID in our timing. Give you an indication of that, similar graphs. Capital projects that we have listed for the year. This is really a chart that pulled from Hayes's presentation on CIP.

3:31:00 In June 2nd. And that's what we utilize to say, here are the projects that are expected for fiscal year 21-22, or at least expected to be initiated. And so the total cost of those projects is listed. I provided the revenue and then the revenue source.

3:31:19 So you can see that this sort of addresses the question I think, John, you were asking earlier about, you know, there's different grants and funds that are there. The staff report itself, Hais put together that section on all of the, you know, review of CIP. They had a specific, you know, very detailed list of what.

3:31:40 The revenue sources were, whether they were, you know, all grant or some combination and what those combinations were. I tried to simplify it here to show, you know, the bulk of it's coming from either grant funding or, you know, fund balance from a different particular area. But that's the only attempt to, I think, describe what you were looking for earlier.

3:32:02 The CRC in the staff report has the detailed list out of all those. It's fairly lengthy, so I couldn't really fit it on the slide here. There are two items that are listed here, and I think we received council direction that there was a desire to include these capital projects in 21-22, but funding sources have not been identified for them as of yet, and that's the town hall maintenance and improvements of $175,000.

3:32:31 And the dog park for $100,000. We will have an opportunity coming on the fourth quarter where there could be some revenues that if there's adequate revenue, staff would be bringing those forward as a recommendation to fund these projects. As I believe council has made it clear, they would like to see these projects move forward. But right now, the unfunded portion is around $275,000. So, Rob, in this

3:33:04 Rendering here. How much general fund is in it, in this, in what's funded? I'd have to break that down, that the bulk of where general fund is, is in the CRC. Because most of it, I mean, it's really very little general fund in you. That's correct, at least for new projects. I mean, the only one, I think, is CRC, and the details are listed in the staff report, but yeah, the bulk of these are grant or

3:33:37 Fund balance. 100,000 going into the storage lots out to Sierra Business Park, which would be general fund dollar support there. Otherwise, the vast majority of all of this would be coming out of restricted funds. Yeah, and that 100,000 is actually a future capital, so it's a roundabout from general fund. Any other questions? I know that I'm trying to find where I stashed the letter, the public comment about the

3:34:12 Yeah, we don't have that built in the next year's capital. We don't have that in the next year's capital? Yeah, we don't have it in the coming year we're adopting right now, 21-22. We have been looking at the tennis courts. There's one set of the courts there that

3:34:43 The ground, it's so uneven, it's unsafe to play. The other equivalent, basically the other two sets, so four quarts are actually in pretty decent shape. I know Stu went out and walked them here a while back and you have some cracking in those asphalt areas there, but it's not where it was. We have put a fair amount of repair work in there previous years. And so we understand the concern raised by the community on that, about wanting to see a decrease in the number of quarts there.

3:35:09 So we are looking at options. We believe there's some better locations where if you're going to have to rebuild it, you know, $300,000 per kind of set of courts or more, maybe putting them where you have more months of play and less harshness in terms of some of the weather and the type of court to be built. These are asphalt courts. So we want to go to that post-tension concrete court that has a much healthier lifestyle.

3:35:37 Lifeline, if you will, useful life. Steve can speak to some of the details there as well. But yeah, it's a good question to look at and say a lot of the courts are starting to become multiple-use courts. They're pickleball, they're tennis. Other communities will actually put a portion of a basketball, like a half-court basketball, on some of their tennis courts because of just the demand they're seeing. Whether that's here or not, I can say. But I know pickleball is becoming...

3:36:04 Relatively popular on our tennis courts as well. So we do try to make them multiple use, if you will, which has been picked up play on the courts. Stu, if you want to add to that some of the details, sorry. It's real quick and short there, Sarah. But yeah, that is a concern. I don't really want to belabor the point. I just think it's worth noting that this is like the only capital thing that we've had public comment on. Thank you. Yeah, in terms of that asset, I agree. And development impact fees.

3:36:39 Really tied to the anticipated revenue from building permits for the year, and that sort of feeds directly into the individual line items. Associated with that, we talk about in our next hearing is going to be the fee impact. There is a 2.8% increase, which is a CPI increase to the development impact fees. We do have plans for a development impact fee study.

3:37:10 Which will do some analysis. It's fairly comprehensive. We've met as a staff already on that process and looking forward to kind of bringing that throughout the year. It's, again, a fairly comprehensive review. But that will inform, you know, the actual amounts that we would be looking to adopt for fiscal year 2022-23 next year. And that's, you know, the project completion will be for that particular period of time. But right now, the diff...

3:37:38 Fee increases about 2.8% over last year. Provide the fund balance for assessment districts. Prior councils have wanted to see a little bit more detail, so we developed these charts that really talk about, you know, the purpose of the district, some of the budget elements for the year. And a lot of this stuff is coming from what you're seeing in the NBS reports that are on consent agenda.

3:38:12 That Public Works has been, our engineering team has been pulling together over the last month and will continue to do a little bit into July. But these numbers really talk about what the current balance is. That's the dollar amount that you see basically in the middle of the page. And then what the assessment per unit is for the coming fiscal year.

3:38:37 And that's informed by those reports. This particular year, in addition to the purpose, meaning what the funds are accumulated for, I added a section below on the budget that gives a little bit more detail about, you know, what are the expenditure items and how many lots and so forth are in this district. So hopefully that was helpful. I won't really read through the details on these, but they're a mix of maintenance and there's two.

3:39:06 That are associated with infrastructure bonds that they repay. And those are included in the debt schedule as well at the end of the report. And hopefully you get a chance to, you know, review those on the, in the staff report or have questions if you want to ask them. Debt schedule, you know, we talked about, we've kind of shared this before and I think I got some feedback from prior presentations. They want a little bit more information, you know, providing the total term and date, interest rates.

3:39:40 And source of the payment, but fairly good debt ratio from our overall revenue sources, if you will. And that's the end of the presentation for this evening. So are there any questions or anything? Again, the staff report was fairly comprehensive and the presentation may be a bit more condensed, but I also provided the line item detail.

3:40:08 To give you a little sense of the next steps for finance staff, we'll take, as provided this is adopted this evening, we will prepare an upload for our financial systems, so we load the budgets in there before July 1st, and that'll be what's informing our decisions at that point, obviously executing the budget. We'll also develop a budget book really for

3:40:37 Dissemination in probably late September, early October once we have a full complete fiscal year 2021 to use as comparisons. But the budget book, something we've done in the last couple of years, has been pretty helpful for staff and I think general public to understand really the better detail of what we do and our goals within departments and so forth.

3:41:06 Pretty comprehensive document, and each of you will receive a copy of that when it's completed. Any questions, comments? Thank you, Rob. I think everyone asked questions, but is there anybody else that has any questions for staff? No? Okay. Hearing that, what about any public comment? Angie, is there anybody waiting to make a public comment on the budget? No comments at this time. No comments at this time.

3:41:40 Okay, I think that we can probably close the public hearing. So consider it closed at this point. And now we would like to deliberate the matter, which in this case is the six resolutions that we discussed previously. And I understand, and Andy can weigh in on this also, we can do them one at a time, or could we do them as a slate as listed in the agenda?

3:42:13 You could do one vote on all of them collectively. None of them, I think, are the kind that would require a separate vote. Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I'm prepared to make a motion. Okay, I would move that the Town Council adopt the following resolutions en masse. Resolution established in the Town of Mammoth Lakes appropriations limit for fiscal year 21-22.

3:42:45 The resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes investment policy for fiscal year 21-22. The resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes reserve policy for fiscal year 21-22. The resolution reaffirming the Town of Mammoth Lakes debt policy for fiscal year 21-22. The resolution approving the annual budget for the Town of Mammoth Lakes for fiscal year 21-22 as presented.

3:43:11 I don't believe there are any modifications along the way, so as presented. Thank you. John, if we may add also the resolution, it's moving an amendment to the resolution 20-83, modifying the terms and use of funds of an internal loan from the vehicle replacement fund to the general fund. Thank you. I'd like to add the resolutions Dan Holler mentioned to my motion. Thank you. Okay, we have a second for that. I'll second the motion.

3:43:41 Thank you very much. We have a first by Wentworth and a second by Mr. Stapp. All right. Let's call for the question. Angie? Councilmember Rae? Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Aye. And Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, everybody. You got to do that. That was great. Okay. And thank you all and your staff for all the work you did.

3:44:16 Not an easy thing, but making it somewhat comprehensible. It was well done. And again, the process over the year, for the last few months of piece by piece, taking a look at, I think you got everybody as well educated on this as could be. So thank you for that. Thank you. All right. Now we have another public hearing. We will open now. Consider the public hearing open. To consider the question and conduct the public hearing and adopt the resolution for fiscal year.

3:44:47 21-22 Master Fee Schedule Update for Town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay, I think, Rob, this is also yours? Yes, it is. Thank you very much, Mayor Pro Tem and Councilmembers. We're going to talk now about the fee schedule, which is a part of the annual budget review, but is adopted separately and through a separate public hearing.

3:45:15 The fees, I will start off by saying that the fees as presented in the fee schedule are reflective of what we have in the budget. Obviously, that's expected that what we believe we need to charge for fees is what we've obviously included in our revenue and elements that we just finished discussing. We talk about these on an annual basis. There aren't a lot of fees with the town.

3:45:41 I will say Parks and Recreation, which has the most program and other fees, come to council in February because they need to establish those fee structures in advance of their, you know, program year and when they open up for enrollment. So they really have to get that done prior. So in Parks and Recreation, those fees are captured from the presentation in February, but I list them and show the ones that changed in at least the

3:46:10 Detailed list of master fees. For this one, I'll talk briefly about some of the changes that we had for the year. Again, they were fairly minor within the finance and administration fees. We do charge our cannabis businesses. In prior, we were charging them $4,000 a year for their business license, and that $4,000 covered.

3:46:33 The bulk of a audit that was performed annually. We had two audits performed. One is a financial audit and the other is a compliance audit. Our contract with HDL expired in December of 2020. So all audits conducted for calendar 21 are going up significantly. In fact, the proposal from our contractor was, in my opinion, too high.

3:47:03 And so we, because it was $8,200 versus the $5,000 we were paying previously. So we have not renewed that contract. I'm expecting to go out for RFP. And I request for proposal for people that can conduct those audits. It may separate compliance from the financial one.

3:47:27 But just knowing that we were going to have additional costs for the year, I have increased that particular item from $4,000 to $6,000, and that's reflected in the notes. Community economic development, we talk about the International Code of Council building valuations, that's updated annually, and the town does utilize that as a notifying source.

3:47:52 For our fees that we charge, and we have a little bit of factor we add on to that to the staff report. I talked earlier about the development impact fees being increased by the 2.8%, which is the construction cost index. We didn't do that in the prior year. We're kind of getting back to it, if you will. So for fiscal year 21-22, that is the increase that we have listed.

3:48:20 Under public safety, we, as you know, updated several of the ordinances around dog licenses, and there were a lot of adjustments made to those, so there's a few additional elements added based upon that update, but no other changes within public safety. The airport, there was a bit of a simplification. We used to have separate prices for Part 91 and Part 135 aircraft certifications, which are...

3:48:47 Are removed for the year. But we did add some separation for helicopters. And then I think the storage fees for different sizes of RVs out there were slightly adjusted. So just in general, an update, not anything large and significantly adjusted to the airport. Public Works.

3:49:08 We did have, and we established in November of 2020, the charges for the snow pit. And these are for folks that are delivering to the snow pit the charges they pay per load. It is highly subsidized by the town. That's part of the discussion I had earlier on gas tax expenditures. But when we established those rates, we did kind of forecast them across two years. So for fiscal year 21 and 22,

3:49:35 Each of those load sizes, which are three sizes, increased by $20 per load, as well as our storage fee for basically a land use permit to store on town, on property. That actually doubled, and that's a per square footage presentation. And it's really based upon the size of the season, so it's quite ingenious the way that that was put together by our engineering staff.

3:50:02 It is a two-year program, and so this year we're recognizing that sort of final impact of that. I would expect to see those fees adjusted again depending upon how we do with figuring out a solution for snow pit cost going forward because as we are doing this, we are heavily subsidizing the community and the cost of snow storage. But again, it's just something we've got to do in order to have people delivering snow out there.

3:50:30 Versus finding other places that are not beneficial to be dumping it. So those are sort of in a nutshell review of the fee structure updates. The staff report itself I've pretty much read through, but you have a detailed list of those changes there, and I've highlighted them to show you which fees specifically have changed, and I'm open for any questions. Questions for Rob? What's that?

3:51:00 I said, are there any questions for Rob from Council? Hearing none, are there any public comments on this? Angie? No public comments at this time. Okay, we'll close the public hearing then and ask for the motion. Okay. Hearing none, I will make a motion myself that the Town Council approve the resolution.

3:51:41 For the Town of Mammoth Lake, State of California, establishing an updated schedule of fees and charges for town services. Can I have a second? Second. Okay. We call for the vote. Councilmember Rae? Yes. Councilmember Stapp? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. And Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Second. All right. The committee has been held and the resolution is adopted for the update to the...

3:52:16 Passed your fee schedule. All right. That takes us out of all the public hearings. Sorry, Linda. Excuse me. We do have a second resolution of the fees. It's the public art resolution where we have been holding that fee at zero. That's been the last several years keeping the fee as a viable fee but setting it at zero as we have not had a viable really art program to tie that fee back into. And it was very substantial for some projects.

3:52:46 Substantial point of contention about three or four years ago. So the recommendation is to continue it for another year at the rate of zero. That does need to be done by a resolution each year. Sorry, I missed that one. Do I need to reopen a public hearing to hear that one? Yeah, if you request any public input or comment, there's no change in the fee. All right, so any questions from council? Any public comments? No public comments.

3:53:21 All right. Let's go ahead and get a motion to approve that resolution. Second. Okay. I don't have the language in front of me. Where is it? There you go. Kirk is going to. I'll make adopt a resolution of the town of the town council of the town of Mammoth Lakes, state of California, temporary reducing the public art fees through July 31, 2023. Thank you.

3:53:56 We have a motion. I get a second. Second. From Councilmember Wentworth. All right, Angie, let's call for this vote. I think you're muted, Angie. I apologize. We had a motion by Kirk Stapp, a second by John Wentworth. Councilmember Wentworth. And the roll call vote, Councilmember Ray? Yes. Councilmember Wentworth? Yes. Councilmember Stapp?

3:54:33 Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Salcido. Yes. Okay. That now concludes the resolutions and the votes for that. So let's proceed to number 13 under policy matters. Resolution terminating local public health emergency. Echoing staff, the recommendation would be so moved. Just given the level of work we've had this last year and working through the emergency, the public health emergency.

3:55:09 I do want to touch on a couple of items here. One is the item before council would be consideration to terminate the local public emergency as declared by the town council resolution 20-10. Approximately 15 months ago, we moved into the COVID-19 pandemic public health emergency. And then with the town, we incorporated also the potential for a financial level emergency. So that was.

3:55:38 built into that resolution. The recommendation to terminate the local emergency is really following up on actions taken by the state and also the condition of the town. The goal when you go into an emergency is to look at the soonest possible time that you can practically terminate that emergency is the goal within state law given the conditions that we're under at this point.

3:56:06 The public health side, we really looked at that concern at the front end of the potential to overwhelm our public health system, the potential impact on life and property from the result of seeing a pandemic come through our community, and then obviously the resulting impact economically. We have seen both of those key situations there reversed, given the...

3:56:31 Stellar job that we've done in Mono County with vaccinations, the testing work, the healthiness of our community in one sense, just seeing the number of people that were infected but extremely low number of deaths. There's four associated to Mono County. Sad on those four, but given the potential that we saw at the front end of this, we ended very strongly from that perspective. Then also

3:57:02 The financial side, as we just went through the budget, we did come back stronger than we anticipated, a couple of strong months this past year, even with the COVID restrictions in place. And secondly, what the state changes in terms of the structure also supports lifting the local emergency. They have the governor's executive orders that put in, the stay-at-home orders have been lifted.

3:57:27 The public health orders have put in all of the tiering system. The mitigation measures have been lifted as well. And so the real conditions for us to have a local emergency, we believe, have been extinguished. And so we're very comfortable in lifting the local emergency.

3:57:48 The local emergency does provide us ability to take immediate action, to delegate a lot of power down through myself and the staff to be able to respond appropriately, to protect life, property, and to address the issues of the emergency that are out there. There are a number of things continuing. The Mono County Declaration, I think, is going to continue to be in place. The state proclamation of emergency is set to continue through the end of September. With the state action,

3:58:18 They will continue a number of different factors, a lot of different state actions that was taken. A few of them that apply to us would be the modifications to the Brown Act so we can continue to conduct meetings via Zoom and or in person. That continues through September 30th. Commercial evictions continue to be protected through September 30th. A number of the business type

3:58:47 Actions allowing, for example, the outdoor dining, the sale of outdoor alcohol and some elements in there to help restaurants, I believe, are also set up to continue through September 30th. So a number of those actions have gone through that. The other major change has been in the requirements for just our operations in terms of wearing a face covering and mask. Some of the in-person activities can happen now has been greatly expanded.

3:59:16 We anticipate some additional changes here within the week, potentially as early as tomorrow from Cal OSHA on some additional limits on what vaccinated employees have to comply with. If that goes through, that would be effective at the end of the month. And so given all the factors leading up into where we're at tonight, the recommendation is that we believe we're in a condition and a position to...

3:59:40 Adopt the resolution that would terminate the local public and economic emergency that we declared back on March 18th, 2020. So it's been, as you all are aware, quite a ride for the last 15 months in addressing this and responding to it. Hats off again to town staff that have stepped up, you all, and to our partners from the county and the fire district have really stepped together to help manage this, and obviously to the community who really stepped in.

4:00:10 A number of different times, a number of different areas to really carry us through this. And even as our emergency, if it's terminate at this point, we still have work in front of us. COVID-19 is still a real disease. We need to be cautious as we go forward. But we definitely have reached a significant milestone. Glad to answer any questions or address any of the other items. I've kind of noted that a lot of information going out here shortly on changes in.

4:00:39 The various areas there, a lot of confusion over mass care recently this week with conflicting information between Cal OSHA, CDPH, CDC, et cetera. Trying to get all those lined up, that'll probably take a little bit of time then. Okay, any questions or comments from council? I guess I'm just, I'm curious what this looks like for us as a council and our meetings. Yeah, I think it...

4:01:12 If I can jump into that a little bit, we discussed a little bit with the council. It really opens up the door, but it's still a council decision whether you wish to wait a bit yet or transition to in-person meetings. If you do go into in-person meetings, you can set up some standards for how you want the public to come into the meetings. You can put some signage up requiring vaccinations and or masks if they're not.

4:01:40 You can stay on the Zoom level activity here if that's your desire as well. Andy can weigh into some of those issues as well. But the options given underneath the extension of some of those elements that are the governor's order really provides very substantial flexibility for the council, at least through the end of September. Right. To put it in a nutshell, I would say that the cessation of the town emergency

4:02:09 is unrelated to the council's options going forward for conducting meetings. Okay, that's helpful. Okay, thank you, Andy. Is there any public comment? Oh, sorry, John, go ahead. I was just going to say good riddance, but, you know, I said that's it, so thanks. Don't burn your mask yet. I finally found a really good mask. Ah, those are great, huh? Yeah, those are good. Really good ones.

4:02:48 Yeah, I definitely have my favorites after the last 15. Stu, just for the weekly count, where do we end up? 67 weeks, 66. We're at 66 weeks, Mayor Pro Tem. Wow. And it just seems so, it just feels so flat now to even talk about it. It's kind of like all the air out of the balloon, and we're just kind of like... Deflated. We're exhausted. Yeah. Or one of their brain dead.

4:03:18 Something I'm not sure what of that, which one of those things it is. Any public comment on this? No public comments at this time. Okay. Based on that, who would like to make a motion on this? I'll just, I'll make a motion. I just want to add on behalf of the council, I'm sure on behalf of the council, a really profound expression of gratitude and thanks to the staff of this organization that just stepped up and

4:03:47 The most profound and amazing ways, just exemplars of public service. And thank you, thank you, thank you. You guys did a great job. Thank you. And Linda, you kind of counted that, but this is for these guys. I have to tell you that never, I don't know how Stu feels about this, but never in any of the people in town that I personally asked to do something, whether it was help on whatever.

4:04:16 No one ever said anything except, how can I help? Tell me what I can do to help. Amazing outcome from not only our community, but especially our town staff. We need someone to come direct traffic. We need someone to show up and make a sign. We need somebody to do something. And that meant so much that no one ever didn't say yes. Okay, with that being said, I would like to make the motion, Madam.

4:04:47 Mayor Pro Tem, if that's okay. Please. And I would move that the Town Council approve the resolution terminating the local public and economic emergency declared on March 18, 2020 by Town Council resolution number 20-10. Second. Okay, we have a motion by Mr. Wentworth, a second by Ms. Ray, and without any further discussion, can we call for the vote, please, Angie? Councilmember Ray? Yes.

4:05:20 Councilmember Stapp. Yes. Councilmember Wentworth. Yes. And Mayor Pro Tem, Linda Salcido. Yes, please. And if I may ask from the council members as we look to the July 7th council meeting, if you wish for us to bring an item back in this type of format to discuss how you wish to proceed forward. We had some discussion on it, but we had some unknowns.

4:05:47 What would be happening? So be glad to just don't need any formal action or motion there, but if there's consensus to bring an item back before we actually open up into full public meetings to have that discussion again with the full council on your preferences for moving forward. That would be great. Let's do that. Okay. Okay. That was good work, everybody. And that brings us to council member reports. Let's go first with Sarah.

4:06:21 Oh my gosh. I keep meaning to like write notes for this portion. I'm always toast by the end. I'm like trying to look at my calendar. Well, I met with Mammoth regarding the main lodge. I'm choking now. I don't think I've had anything super big come up. So I'm just going to go with that.

4:06:53 Okay, let's do Councilmember Stapp. Just a quick report on Mammoth Lake Housing. The wait list for rentals is still very high, people waiting to get in. So housing continues to be a pressing issue for our community. Lots of people are commuting from Bishop. I'm repeating myself, but this is important that it gets out in the community.

4:07:23 And that we keep working on the parcel. Thank you. Council Member Wentworth. Thank you, Madam Mayor Pro Tem. I'm going to focus on the SCOG update. So let me know what I may have missed. But I actually took some notes on that one. I will share that I was not able to attend the LTC meeting on Monday. I was out of town. But the SCOG had a good meeting. A lot of things are moving forward with that group.

4:07:53 We had a great presentation with a guy named Derek Kurt, who is our region's business development specialist for GoBiz. And I think if the town is looking for a guide through the state budget and all the money that's going to be available, this is the guy to talk to about where all the money's buried. His name is Derek Kurt. We can provide you with contact information as needed. Very good discussion on that. Yes, God, approve the budget for next year.

4:08:22 We pointed a working group for California congressional redistricting with the basic idea in mind that we're not represented by anybody around here. So it would be good if we could change it even a little bit, that would help. And we talked about California Fire Safe Council County Wildfire Coordinators. Both counties are going to apply for that. And we are going to work on putting together a regional housing summit.

4:08:52 So I'm going to work, I will be working with Jeff Griffiths of Indio County to start getting that figured out because this housing thing is a regional thing. I think, I hope we're all disabused of the idea that, well, gee, it's bad at Mammoth, but it's okay in Lone Pine or Bishop. It's not. This is the same thing everywhere. It's across the entire Western United States. So we'll start getting to work on that. That'll be fun. And got some updates on the ESSRP and the SRTI.

4:09:19 I shared reports on the main lodge redevelopment, which I think is really a regional, I mean, this project, it's a small city. It's not unfair to, you know, look at it that way. And this is going to ripple out across the region. So I think I know a lot of our colleagues in neighboring counties and towns are interested. They're watching this thing pretty closely. For the next meeting coming up in August, we've requested an update on air service. As you all know, air service, Bishop, will start this fall.

4:09:49 I'll talk about the state budget, and we'll talk about the housing summit, what that's looking like, and the redistricting. And that's what I have to share this evening. Thank you. Okay, that leaves me to say, I went to the ESCON meeting too, and I don't think John did anything. That's all I got. That'll do. Madam Mayor, if I may, I did sit in for John and or Mayor Sauser at the LTC meeting.

4:10:21 For the two things of note, they did approve the overall work program budget. We actually are seeing additional revenue coming into the LTC. So that was really great to see some of the level of activity going on there. The town will definitely benefit from that as we coordinate with the county on projects. We approved a trade out of dollars or a swap of dollars with the Sacramento Council of Governments, I believe it was ESCOG.

4:10:49 I think it was Council of Governments, which actually defederalizes the money so it's easier to utilize here and it's money that they could potentially otherwise lose. So by giving federal dollars to them and taking state dollars to the Mono County LTC actually creates some simpler usage of those funds for us and be able to move some projects forward. We also approved a letter going forward expressing concerns over the proposed

4:11:17 Fire regulations in the state response areas, the responsibility areas. For Motto County, it would have a devastating impact on their ability to do any type of future development, especially affordable housing. It would, the conditions are just onerous in terms of rural communities. And so, in supporting that, we have indicated that we would also do a support letter from the town accordingly in supporting the LTC's action.

4:11:44 Expressing concerns over the limits that that type of restrictions would place on development. Almost to the point in some cases, like if you actually had something burned down or lost a facility, a home, there would be a real question of whether or not in some cases you could even rebuild it. I believe Andy's dealt with this in a couple of areas as well. I think the Truckee area has substantially impacted.

4:12:08 By the proposed regulations as well. It would be devastating to a lot of the rural counties that have a high severity fire area within the state responsibility areas. Yeah, it's bad news. And beyond just the Cal Fire action, there is legislation pending that would kind of write a lot of those restrictions into law. I'm keeping an eye on that up here through Truckee's lobbyists and getting updates whenever anything happens. But the two congressmen...

4:12:37 One representing this area and one representing another area sent a joint letter to CAL FIRE saying, hey, don't do this. This is poorly thought through. Jennifer Burroughs is still with us. If she wanted to add anything to the LTC meeting discussion, she's our appointed rep as well. It's been nice to have her with us. She's just forgot to log off Zoom.

4:13:17 I wondered. She was so, okay. All right. Well, I think that concludes our business for this evening. That being said, we're now going to adjourn to closed session. I think, Dan, did you send a link out on that, it looked like? Yes, I did. I sent a separate link out for the closed session. It's anticipated litigation. It's pursuant to paragraph two, subdivision D of section 5495, 6.91 case involving Stephanie Thompson.

4:13:45 Okay, very good. All right, let's take a little bit of a break. I'm going to vote for not returning until 920. We'll see you in the other side. Bye, everybody. Thank you very much. Thank you.