TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2011

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 2 hr 3 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

256 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:26 Council Mammoth Lakes for Wednesday, August 10, 2011. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Houston? Here. Councilmember Harvey? Here. Councilmember Boy? Here. Mayor Pro Temerling? Here. Mayor Bacon? Here. John, would you lead us in the pledge, please? Yes, thank you. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the fire of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible,

1:57 With liberty and justice for all. The next item on the agenda is public comments. Anyone wishing to speak on items that are not on tonight's agenda, please step up to the podium. Annette Hesselton, can you hear me? Is it turned out? Not really. No? Can you hear me now? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. I just came from Whitmore Pool, and I was just asked to speak for someone there. They were approached by a parent.

2:37 That would like to put in solar, donated labor and materials, as long as they can have a sign where it says who donated it. I told Lindsay I'd bring it up. I think she's already talked to Stuart. I think there's a process. Don't know what that process is. And I'm not sure who owns the land because you would have to, of course, do that process. But I think a lot of people are trying to figure out how to make money or save money for Whitmore Pool.

3:06 And I don't know what our electricity bills are. That would be an accounting thing. But I think that would help us save a lot of money, especially in the winter when it's being paid back to the grid and then it's being reused in the summer. And that could be quite a bit of savings. So I'm not sure what the process is, but I wanted to see what your thoughts were on that, if it should be pursued and where that should go. Is that something staff would follow up with you on?

3:36 Or whomever the other person is, great. That'd be good? Okay. That'd be great. And then also, I also went to the Park and Recs meeting yesterday and put some input in and listened to what everybody had to say. And I came out of it with kind of one recommendation. When we give a large amount of money to whoever, individuals, nonprofits, so on, if there's a certain amount, I think that we should, the town, should probably request an independent audit on that money to make sure.

4:04 The money is being used the way it should be being used as well as the town, of course, has to make sure that all that money is being used the way it should. I've noticed coming out of that meeting there is a lot of big sums of money going out and there doesn't seem to be a lot of accountability on that and that would be a suggestion that maybe the town needs to look at in their contract process and it would be, of course, the responsibility of the person asking for the money.

4:34 And, of course, that money does not come out of the grant that's given, so they would have to find that money elsewhere to pay for that independent audit. So, at going to the meeting yesterday, that's kind of what I came out of the meeting. Very good meeting. A lot of progress. So, that was one of the things that I found. So, that's what I had. Thank you, Dan. Thank you. Anyone else be wishing to speak? What is it? It's a, just hop up there.

5:06 Hi, my name is Sean Turner, Recreation Commissioner and Business Owner at Mammoth Brewing Company. Thank you very much. I just wanted to talk a little bit about Bluza Palooza, just a summary from this last weekend. First of all, I just want to say I've been in the craft beer industry for 17 years. Mammoth Brewing Company is the fourth brewery project that I've either owned or operated. So I've been in the business a long time and very, very pleased with the direction that Bluza Palooza is going. This is my sixth Bluza Palooza that I've been involved in.

5:34 First two years, I was really just in observation mode as I was purchasing the business from Sam Walker. And my goal from the beginning has really been to turn Bluza Palooza into much more of a tasting event and, excuse the term, much less of a drunk fest. And I use that term just because unfortunately there are beer festivals out there that frankly have that reputation. And for those of you that have attended,

6:04 Blues and Blues in the past couple of years. I can say with certainty that ours is not that. And I know that there is some exceptions. There's definitely some people that had some tough time getting out of there. But for the most part, compared with a lot of other beer festivals in the country, we've got a very, very good reputation. California Small Brewers Association, which I've been involved with for many, many years, is our bar beneficiary and the license holder for the event.

6:32 And again, it is concentrated on craft breweries with an average shelf price of over $9 a six pack. And every year we turn away breweries that are either imports or are owned by domestics. And we use the American Brewers Association definition for what a craft brewery is, which is small, traditional, and independently owned. And again, our focus on that

6:59 And we had over 65 breweries that attended this year. Each one of them is small, traditional, and independent. And in comparison with the El Dorado Beer Festival up in Reno, which is also 16 years old and perhaps the largest in our area, had only 40 breweries. And almost half of those were either owned by Bud Miller or Coors or were imports. So I want you all to know that what we've got here is a very, very unique event.

7:29 Is, I would argue, one of the ten most important beer festivals in the country. And I go to the GABF and the Craft Brewers Conference on a national basis and get compliments for our beer festival because a lot of these breweries have turned this into a retreat for their employees. We get the owners and the brewers, not just the sales reps.

7:54 who come up here and turn this into a two, three, or four day trip for their employees to give them a recreational retreat in addition to doing a beer festival. So we've got a very unique festival here that is sponsored by the California Small Brewers Association. I want to thank the Lodging Partners who help us donate rooms to put the brewers up. A lot of these

8:22 Lodging partners donate two rooms, and then the breweries themselves often purchase a third or fourth night, like I said, so that they can turn it into an ongoing retreat. Just a little bit about the numbers real quick. On Friday night, we estimate that we had over 4,000 people inside the gate. That is almost double what we had last year on Friday night. Saturday, likewise, we sold out the event at 5,000 people.

8:47 And Sunday, we estimate that we had over 2,000 people in the gate on Sunday. And that, likewise, is probably more than double, well, almost double what we had last year. One thing I want to say about the Sunday event, that did not exist three years ago. Three years ago, I was staying at John Baruch's property across the street and noticed how many people kept coming up on Sunday saying, you know, what else is going on? We'd like to have some more.

9:14 And so two years ago, it was a free event. Last year, it was our first paid event. And then this year, we had Robert Cray, which was a big draw and had over 2,000 people. And I just want to bring that up because for two reasons. First of all, I think Jim Vanko of Harvest Moon Presents and myself feel very, very comfortable with this formula that we've created that extending it

9:41 into a 3-day event. Blues Traveler wanted to come on Saturday night, and we pushed them into Friday night because we wanted to bookend the Grand Tasting, which we knew would sell out, and make it a 3-day event, and the reception, or the...

9:57 The lodging partners have all expressed approval at that because, again, it really helps drive people who are usually only coming up for a one or two night stay turn it into a three or four night stay. So we're very comfortable with having, or we really like this formula that we've come up with, that having our major headliner on Friday night, so it's a concert before the grand tasting.

10:18 The Grand Tasting, which was on Saturday, but not necessarily the biggest headliner. And then on Sunday, another headliner, which encourages people to stay longer. And I'm sorry if I could just have another minute. You heard, okay. Okay, I'll keep it as short as I can. Talk faster. And then after Robert Craig performed on Sunday, we had only local bands that took the stage from about 1.30 to about 6 p.m. And they had the performance of their life. And a lot of people stayed for that show.

10:45 And I was very, very encouraged to have local bands performing that night. Street closure. I just want to say this about the street closure is that this was our first year and putting on and just coming from the Recreation Commissioner side for a minute, I'd like to say that as with all events, I was very encouraging of the Mammoth Rocks last year to close Canyon Boulevard.

11:11 And I think that we as event producers need to be experimenting with new event sites, even if anything to realize, well, that doesn't work, or maybe if we tweak it a little bit here or there, it can do better. This was our first year with the street closure. And you bet, there's a couple things that I can tell you already I want to improve for next year. But I got to tell you, it was one of the best and most important things we did.

11:37 From a public safety standpoint, being able to create a pedestrian entrance, just, it was so nice not having the pedestrians go out into traffic. Public transportation, being able to increase and make the public transportation that much more effective. And finally, number three, protecting the property of the neighbors that surround Sam's Woodside. The golf course, the neighbors in Hidden Valley.

12:03 We're all very, very supportive of us because last year we had so many people in the line that literally wrapped all the way around between Hidden Valley. I'm going to let Roger Duffy speak about some of the preferred parking. The reason why we did want to partner with the High School Boosters Club and Rotary International Interactive Club was because the street closure did provide an opportunity for preferred parking. We have not done the final numbers yet, but we estimate we probably spent close to $5,000.

12:31 Between our PSAs, design time, and actual execution and implementation of the street closure. But again, I wouldn't want to do it at Sam's Wood Site without closing the street. I know that Mammoth Festival is looking at just shifting some of the lanes, and we'll see how that works, and I look forward to seeing how that works. But at the same time, just from a public safety standpoint, last year I lost sleep over it. This year it went so much smoother. I just can't say that enough.

12:59 Just a couple things real quick. Steve Searles, I'd like to say a big thank you. That was a huge part as far as getting him up on stage Friday night before Blues Traveler took the stage and said, please pick up your garbage because it bears. We do need to have all the garbage picked up. To my employees and the crew, I just want to say I...

13:17 Couldn't have better employees. They did a fantastic job. We had every single piece of garbage picked up both on Friday night, Saturday night, and Sunday night. And if you've been to that event before, you know there's a lot of food that we have to deal with. There is one concern that I'd like to share in this venue because the town does have a contract with Mammoth Disposal. We contracted with them. We had nearly 40% more port-a-potties this year because that was a problem last year.

13:44 As well as three additional food dumpsters. We were told when the dumpsters were placed that they would be cleaned on Saturday morning and on Sunday morning. That the porta potties would be cleaned as well. The porta potties were cleaned, but we were not left after we had asked specifically with more toilet paper and paper towels for the porta potties. As well as the dumpsters, and this is my biggest concern. They were all supposed to be emptied on Saturday morning.

14:13 The driver showed up, said, I can't get to them because you broke the fence around them. Okay, we understand, but at the same time, we were told that Mammoth Disposal was going to come back with their pickup truck to pick them up because they can get those back. Repeated phone calls to Mammoth Disposal, please get over here, you've got to empty these because we have to deal with them for the bear that night. No return phone calls, never came back to get those dumpsters. So on Saturday night, my guys were having to load up pickup trucks.

14:43 To go to the dumpsters at Whiskey Creek, at our warehouse on Burner Street, to get rid of that garbage because we knew that it had to be bear proof overnight. So I have some very, some strong frustrations with Mammoth Disposal that I need to voice here because of the town contract with Mammoth Disposal. I'm sorry that I, but I do need to say that. I just want to end on this real quick note is that I'll make this pledge and I've made this several years in a row. The craft beer industry is growing dramatically, double digit growth.

15:13 And even with our focus on staying with craft beers only, if given the venue, I make this commitment that I can grow and if this town commits to wanting to grow this event, I can grow this event to over 10,000 people within the next three to five years. I'm convinced of that because we had a lot of breweries that weren't even represented. We were getting calls the week before saying we want to come and we had to say no, we need to stop signing up 65, 70 breweries.

15:42 That are coming to this event. But I just want to say right now that taking the example of what happened on Sunday didn't exist three years ago. We've already grown it to 2,000 people. In many ways it could be argued it's easier to grow an existing event than even starting a new event. So again, I just want to encourage it again.

16:03 Coming from the Recreation Commission side, Special Events Coalition, we are focusing on this and wanting to present that to you. But at the same time, I just want to reiterate that from an event producer side that have given the venue, we can definitely grow this event dramatically. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you, Sean. Any questions to Sean? Sean, would you tell everyone the press that we got off of this? We were top 10.

16:27 Places to go in the country, MSN? Yeah, thank you very much for that. Huge kudos, and I've got to say, I've got to give credit to Harvest Moon Presents for helping us with our publicity and marketing for this event, and Jim and Harvest Moon Presents booked all the bands, really Mammoth Brewing Company, did the coordination with the brewers, a lot of the lodging partners, and that kind of thing. But the press that we got for this event last week,

16:52 Bluesapalooza and the Mammoth Festival of Beers was number one in MSN's top ten list of weekend getaways for the entire country. So talk about great exposure. And then we also got a number of other press that I forwarded to you all as well with the LA Times, Eat, Drink, Travel, a number of other sites as well.

17:15 You know, again, I was honored with that. Jim sent me an email. Sarah Mason sent me an email, what, like Friday morning, I think it was, saying that we made number one of the top ten list in the entire country of Destination. Thank you for reminding me on that. Sean, first of all, I'm pleased to hear that you have a voice this year. You must not have screamed as much as with you last year.

17:38 And maybe that is a function of the traffic or lack of it, which is the segue into my question, and that is, what were you hearing generally? I'd be interested in knowing about the road closure and the pay for parking. Rick, thanks for the question. Overwhelmingly positive with regard to the street closure.

17:58 Yes, there were some people who were very frustrated that they had to go around town, but, you know, again, we live in a two-by-two town, and I'm, you know, so it doesn't take too long, but at the same time, I want those people to understand, you know, that came through the road closure, and we did have to turn them around and have them exit, and my staff was very, very courteous, I think, in all counts, as I was, in saying, you know, we apologize for this.

18:26 But that was minimal. I think Jim will tell you, he was telling me that people who are coming in the gate, he said you didn't hear one complaint with regard to the street. Well, you run the wristband, the classes area, Jim Mammoth, and also the ticketing area. Really no complaints at all about the charge for parking and everybody was really quite comfortable with that. Again, you're talking about events that have been going on for 60 years. There's a lot of people that are returning people to the city. So the experience of any number of different directions.

18:58 Very overwhelmingly positive. And a number of emails since the event saying road closure is worth it. Thank you. I'd like to say something at that same time. Roger, can you come up to share the microphone? Yes. Right. Look, basically, I was the front person, and she brought you, of all the people coming through the gate, we had people that were going to the handicap that could go right down in front, and they were still throwing money at us for donations.

19:27 Which was really nice. We had one guy give us a hundred bucks. Just because it was a high school, the food service, and the whole thing, and interact. And we had people that were so positive, and like he said, there were a couple people that weren't, but the majority of them were. And I have worked events where we closed not just the town, I mean the street, we closed the whole town in Timby, Arizona. We closed down eight square blocks. And with just as much success as Sean has had here.

19:56 And people, after a while, will learn that the only biggest problem I had is people would be coming in, the Europeans, and their finder, what's it called? GPS. GPS sent them down that street to go to their lodging and they were having a hard time in understanding the rhythm. That was the hardest thing we had. And I didn't think that was that bad. Most people came in with big smiles. And believe me, I saw every...

20:24 Shuttle coming down, just jam-packed with people, all the big smiles and happy, and the fact that they could go down and stop right in front, wonderful. The pay parking, people loved it, it was a donation, we did have other parking elsewhere, they really, really didn't want to pay, so it was a lot of thanks to Jim, Sean, Joyce.

20:46 Well, actually, while you're out there, can we just segue into quickly just talking a little bit about how successful it was for the boosters and interact? Jo, can I just say one more thing real quick? Because I went around to the neighbors on Hidden Valley as well before the event with the flyer of the road closure and explained what we were doing. Again, just overwhelming support for it. Thank you so much. Because last year, to keep people out of traffic,

21:11 We had to cue them all the way around Sam's Woodside. It was ugly. I'll just leave it at that. And actually, there is a debriefing next week to talk about how to make it even better for next year on all of that. Sean, one aspect of your event that I heard positive remarks on was that people have been drinking beer for a period of time, and then before the entertainment started, people were saying that you actually had a...

21:41 A one-hour nap time between 4 and 5 p.m. to let people freshen up. You bet. Again, that's why I just want to say this about the tickets, too. We purposely only sold 1,000 Saturday-only tickets because we had to push people into the combo tickets that involved either Friday, Saturday, Saturday, Sunday, Friday, Saturday, Sunday, that kind of thing, to pay for the acts. I mean, Blues Traveler and Robert Cray were not cheap.

22:08 I got in trouble with my wife and blew our talent budget by about 100%. So we needed to push them into that. We sold out the combo tickets that involved Saturday about two weeks before the event, again this year, and saw this huge spike in ticket sales on Friday and Sunday because Saturday was all sold out. And our tasting room was packed because they couldn't get into the grand tasting on that. So just, you know, speaking to the ticket...

22:38 Component. You know, that was just a huge success along those lines. Did I answer your question or did I? It wasn't a question, it was just an observation. I was thanking you for the nap time. Okay, you're welcome. Well, I'm sorry, that's what I was going to say, is by having the headliners on Friday and Sunday, you know, again, on Saturday, we've already sold out in a lot of ways. We sold a lot of tickets for the after, a lot of Saturday after 5.30 tickets, but overall it was a great success. Good.

23:08 Thank you, Sean. Roger, you want to finish your part? Thank you very much. This is basically just the Bluza Bluza parking summary. This is a press release. It's going to come out in the paper, I believe, this week. The Mammoth Unified School District would like to thank the Mammoth Town Council for allowing the high school students to work with the Bluza Bluza leadership team to provide safety, organized parking for this event. The initial discussion with Joyce, Sean,

23:42 Focused on public safety, which was the main reason for the request to close the road for through traffic. For the event, for the secondary goal was to partner with the high school boosters to provide $10 donation for parking. The city council approved that on August 3rd. We appreciate the opportunity that this endeavor raised $4,417. And if we can push some people to the other side, we can get a little bit more.

24:12 But the Mammoth High School Interact Club, the girls' soccer team, the girls' tennis team will be the main recipients of this money. There will be some others too. It depends on how it gets dispersed at the school. The Mammoth High School Interact Club is sponsored by the Mammoth Lakes Noon Rotary Club with a motto of Service Above Self. That inspires members to provide humanitarian services.

24:41 Encourage high ethical standards and promote goodwill and peace in the world. Interact has engaged in a number of local service projects this year, which included wood raffles for the DD members of our community, supporting the senior citizens, career exploration, and local business with local business leaders. They participated in the Rose Parade float, building alongside of the volunteers down there.

25:09 And other school-related projects. Over the years, Rotary Clubs fund projects and sponsor volunteers with community expertise to provide medical supplies, health care, clean water, food products, and job training education with a focus on improving the quality of life in particularly developing countries. Many of us have been involved in providing support for our youth.

25:38 An international service project says Cortison, Cortison, Cortison, the heart-filled name for non-profit. Almost the entire volunteer organization that has offered shelter, education, community of thousands of neighbors to the north of Baja, California for more than 30 years. It's called Building Communities Across the Borders. Cortison has been building and repairing homes in Mexico.

26:09 Through Build a House a Day Project Since 1978. Last year, students from our high school, Interact Club, traveled to the south of Takati to participate in the house building projects. They built houses that are 16 feet by 20 feet on concrete slabs. This year, the students got the opportunity to meet new people, to cut some wood, to frame houses, bang a few nails, and lay out some roof designs. The celebration for a great, excuse me,

26:41 This celebrates a good accomplishment and promotes the concept of global citizenship. The cost of one building, one house is $7,800. Some of the funds raised for the past weekend are going to support the educational experience of our students through cortisone as a plan to travel again in the spring of 2012 with our students and fellow Rotarians to engage in humanism.

27:10 Humanica, I can't say it. Humanitarian. Anyway, services. We want to thank the Town Council, Sean, Joyce, Jim, and the community for allowing the high school students to engage in the fundraising project to support our school program for sports, producing global citizens. Now, we know that there's always a few problems, as Sean said, but they were minimal. Every one of those can be worked out.

27:40 You know the voice Sean didn't have last year? Well, after the event, I didn't have it. But we learned, we moved. Things worked extremely well. And I thought the lines, people were happy in the lines. And it just, you know, it was well done. So anyway, again, I'd like to thank you. And if you have any questions. Nope. Thank you, Roger. Is there anyone else to speak in public comment? Real quick.

28:15 John Wentworth with MLTPA, and congratulations again to Belooza Belooza. It was a great event, and I was able to hear from a distance, so I was slaving away on the trail system, but I ended at a very peaceful, mild hour, and congratulations. It was a really great event. And before we get to Belooza Belooza in 2012, there's a Summer of Stewardship event in your craters this weekend.

28:37 8.30 to 1.30 meet out there at the Inuit Craters Trailhead. Free food, delicious salmon pasta courtesy of some of the folks here in town. And breakfast from Old New York Bagel, Deli and Bagel Company. And I know that everybody in town talks about wearing two hats, but if you show up and help clean up Inuit Craters, you will not get one, you'll get two hats. And you'll be able to put them on and wear them just like I am right here. It's good, right?

29:07 Secondly, I just want to encourage everybody, the Lakes Basin Special Study, you have until Monday, and then that process is going to be over. It's online. Very easy to take that survey. And I appreciate Donette showing up yesterday at the rec commission. Very good meeting yesterday. It was in the audience, obviously. Excuse me, John. Have you looked in the mirror with that question? I'm seeing my reflection in your comment, John. Thank you very much.

29:31 But on that, on our website, all the reporting, there is a performance report associated with Measure R applications. They're all filed. I can't speak for other Measure R applications or awardees, but all the performance reporting is on there, all the applications on there if you're interested. The 45-minute presentation I gave the rec commissioned is on there as well, and you're not going to get to go. Thank you. Thank you, John. Thank you, John.

30:02 Anyone else speaking in public comment, with or without props? Okay, then we will move on to policy matters. Policy matter number one is a resolution approving a temporary waiver of diff for one year. Dispatch report? Mayor and members of the council, this was a directed item from your last meeting. The council discussed the matter, which was should development impact fees, housing,

30:33 The Council's consensus was to return with a resolution that authorized the reduction of development impact fees only, not housing, not public art, nor permit fees, only development impact fees by 100% for certain small-scale projects for one-year period only. Small-scale projects include single-family dwellings.

31:01 One to four unit residential projects, which include duplexes, triplexes, and quadplexes, and commercial projects and any remodel projects. The direction was to allow this for one year with an opportunity for the Council to consider it at that period of time and determine whether it should be continued or not. And also, you directed us to draft a letter to our other agencies, local agencies.

31:28 To inform them of the Council's interest in economic development and stimulus and the action that you're taking, encouraging them to participate with the Town in this overall discussion. We have drafted that resolution. It is presented. I won't read it to you. And the staff recommendation is that Town Council choose option one and temporarily suspend but not eliminate the development impact fee for programs for certain projects specified in the resolution for 12 months.

31:57 That concludes my presentation. Are there questions, the staff? Okay. Are there any comments from the public before we go into deliberation? All right. Skip, since you were not here, but I did read your e-mail at the appropriate parts, is there anything that you would like to discuss since you were not actually part of the entire conversation last week? No. I fully support the direction the council has chosen to go.

32:31 Are there any other comments? I have one other comment. It was brought up by one of the contractors. They had asked if, as part of the resolution, if we could take into consideration the fact that there is some delay in the planning process to when they actually get their permit. So sometimes there may be a two-month delay or a four-month delay.

32:59 The Planning Commission or Council would be a little bit lenient on that if there were some sort of delay for a couple of months before they pull their permits versus having such a hard date. So let's say August 10th comes around and they're in the planning process, but they've been held up because it had to be sent out or something if we would extend some leniency to them if the process were already underway. Rather than extending that, I'm thinking that

33:29 That since this is a financial aspect of our budget, and our budget will be approved on the first of July, which gives us over a month, almost a month and a half, that this might, we might just say that this will be an agenda item for discussion during our budget sessions in June. June of 2012. Yes.

33:52 Any other comments? And I tend to feel that way as well because by then I'm hoping we finish the whole DIF discussion and we might be going in a different direction because we've reduced the DIF fees or eliminated them in some areas. I had one question and it kind of goes back to our consensus. It's written up as when we were talking small and then commercial, I thought we also meant small commercial. I didn't know.

34:21 You know, we talked one to four units, and I wasn't sure whether or not just any new commercial project, because that's kind of a fine-tuning. I thought it would also be small commercial projects, and I don't know if that was just my understanding of the motion of the consensus we've reached. It's any commercial projects? I didn't hear it as small. Okay. It'd be difficult to define small. But I just wanted to clarify. It's easy to define small on residentials and count units. Okay.

34:56 All right. Is there any further discussion or deliberation? In that case, I'd entertain a motion. I'd make a motion that we approve option number one, which would temporarily suspend but not eliminate development impact fee program for certain projects specified in a resolution for 12 months. Is there a second? I'll second that.

35:19 We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Eason? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Layman? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We will now move on to the meat of the evening, which is our second policy item, which is a continuation of the discussion regarding

35:44 The fiscal year 11-12 year in budget by pray already area with planned deliverables. Good evening, Mayor and Council. Tonight we're going to walk through many of the departments relative to our goal of trying to better understand the Council and the community's priorities in terms of deliverables. I'm going to just take a few minutes and just... Could you take those conversations outside, please? Thank you. Thank you.

36:15 So I'll just walk through the program areas just to remind council about what we're looking at and then we're making the assumption tonight that the first six columns which have been part of your previous packages are areas you may have looked at and then we're going to focus primarily on the remainder columns and we have department directors here today who can respond to questions that you have relative to those columns.

36:41 We're not planning to make detailed presentations tonight and I'll leave it at that. Marianna's done a lot of work on this and she may have some comments as well. So just briefly, the items in the categories are programs and services contributing to the protection and preservations of health and safety, management of risks and liabilities. So those are the areas we're very regularly concerned about and you can see every department has some activity in those areas.

37:07 Next one is programs and services contributing to the preservations of town's essential assets, buildings, facilities, right-of-ways, roads, those kind of things, airports, facilities. Programs and services essential to keep the town's resort status and to maintain the quality of life. And that's a very broad area, of course, and some detail about that. Legally maintained programs or services. Contractional obligated programs or services.

37:35 Self-supporting programs and services, programs and services that help promote the town's economic growth, programs and services helping to ensure prudent management of the town's finances, programs and services helping to ensure prudent management of town operations, and then just kind of a catch-all, which is the last area, all other programs and services. So those are the categories we're looking at tonight.

37:59 The documents you have in front of you have taken those areas and then were deeply drilled into each department's deliverables. So with that, I'll turn it over to Mariana. Thank you. Very briefly, just to add, in terms of the process tonight, we would like to try to go through as many departments.

38:24 As possible and we thought that we would take one department at a time. We did not plan to have departmental presentations. The information is before you. You did not receive it in advance. So if departmental explanation of a particular program is necessary, departments are here. And department directors in general will be available to answer any questions from you. But the goal is really to focus on program deliverables.

38:53 Not specific to the due dates, but in general, deliverables as listed on the departmental pages. Do they make sense to you? Are there things the departments listed that they should not be working on? Are there things that you expect for them to work on and they're not listed? But in addition to that funding allocation, is funding as currently listed allocated appropriately?

39:18 Should funding be shifted among programs, for example? So those are the questions that we would like to get to if time permits tonight and if not on August 17th. The three specific questions that we would like to get direction on are in your recommendation section on page 3 of the agenda report and pretty much listed them a second ago.

39:40 Thank you very much. And we'll start with the airport, if that's okay, with the Mayor and the Council. Okay. One question I want to ask of Council, are there any of the priority areas where the definition needs any clarification of the 10 that we have? I also want to make sure that everyone understands they are just numbered for ease in discussion. They are not in priority number order as we're looking at them. And I'd also like to back up.

40:09 What Marianna said about not being the detailed work plan that, for example, last year's work plan said all of the neighborhood district plans will be done by June 2012. Well, it took us an extra six weeks, but as of the last meeting, we had accepted and reviewed all of the neighborhood district plans. So that level of detail we'll get to in the future. This is just a more general discussion.

40:35 With that in mind, and also we will be flipping between two sets of information for some of us where we'd written comments on the earlier ones. So let's just go ahead, start with the airport, which is handwritten page 9, and look at the planning documents, the statement under essential or mandated, and the impact. So the very first item is under

41:05 Protection and preservation of health and safety, management of risk and liabilities is the airport operation. Does any council member have any questions or comments on that? No. Okay. Wait, wait, wait. Sorry. Okay. I'm sorry. I was waiting for hands. Just for clarification, so the total budget is a little over $2 million. And the general fund portion of that is just under $600.

41:33 Can you explain the difference between those two so that those who have asked questions, and I have a couple from members of the public that address that? The bulk of the delta is the money coming in from the million dollars, and there's a few other miscellaneous stuff associated there. Some of that stuff has been pulled out. For example, there's part of a sprung structure in the 91,000. The budget numbers haven't been updated.

42:03 So, and there's also the air service subsidies in there, which have been transferred over to MLT. All right. Oh, okay. So that $2 million is not really $2 million. That's correct. Well, again, $1 million of it is revenue. All right. And a portion, so the air service subsidy is included in this number, but it's been since taken out because we've moved it over. That's correct. Okay.

42:31 Okay, so in a general statement, I think what we're saying is anything we approved in the budget that was measure A, measure T, et cetera, that we put into the budget is reflected there even if the final reconciliation of the numbers might change slightly. Is that another way of saying it? Because I'm just concerned because I think if you look at the full airport, it is about $2 million.

43:00 Well, in general, the budget balancing action that the Council took on June 22nd that took out about $2.7 million from the general fund, those actions are not in these numbers. We simply didn't have time to input the numbers at a program level. We're doing that at department level, but at the program level, we simply didn't have the manpower to do that. So you're about $2.7 million off overall as well as in the general fund.

43:28 So, just so that I'm clear, the sprung structure is in the $2 million? $97,000, $91,000 of it is. Okay. And the rest of it is, where is it? I'm sorry, because I can't remember. What we did was, as no partners stepped forward, when we completed the budget, the Town Council approved the full $275,000 or $271,000. To be funded with measured C, I believe. That's correct.

43:57 All right, so that's not, they aren't, they aren't general, I'm just, I just wanted to be sure that the general fund budget did not include, or if it did, did include a contribution to the sprung structure. It did from Measure T reserves. Okay, and is that reflected then in the 593,000? Partially. That's the 91. Again, these numbers have not been updated, so.

44:22 And I apologize because I didn't actually want to get into the numbers, but I wanted to provide an explanation to a constituent. $91,000 of the sprung structure is in the 590. I see. Okay. On the million dollars that we're getting from the FAA, we have met our 10,000 employments now for two years. Is that correct? So when we talk about this million dollars,

44:52 Are we going back to the 2009, or what year is that million? It would be the first year that we achieve the 10,000 employments. It takes two years for them to process and deliver the actual grant. So we'll all be looking at the million dollars two years out.

45:14 In the budget, so 09, we're going to see it maybe, and we should be seeing it this year, correct? We will see it every year from now on, as long as Congress approves the entire contract. So long as the government has money. Yeah. Okay, thank you. Okay, any other questions on airport operations? Okay, the next page is programs and services contributing to preservation of the town essential assets, and it is the transit operations.

45:44 Any questions there? I'm sorry to hit you with numbers again. I just want to understand conceptually because I see a difference between a million three, which is budgeted from the general fund, 835, which is a $500,000 difference. Are those expected to come from Measure U or some other source? Those come from state funds, LTF funds, and they also come from transit tax within the town for new development.

46:14 Pays a certain portion every year. I have one question here, and I am wondering of the $835,000, how much of that is actually a pass through to ESTA to their contract? Their contract is about $800,000. So even though there's an FTE here, are we funding? Is there also general fund going towards the transit operations?

46:49 That's, you mean town staff? Well, I'm just looking at the numbers here and wondering. We pay a portion of the airport staff salaries to transit or from transit. Okay. Anything else on the airport? No. Okay, we'll move on to police. And the first area is the protection and preservation of health and safety and the management of risk and liabilities.

47:20 So in that area, again, focusing on if the documents make sense and talking about patrol and drug enforcement are the two programs that fall under this priority area. So are there questions? I guess it's sort of related. I just want to – I'm not sure this was completely covered, at least to my satisfaction, during the budget discussion, and so I'm going to ask it tonight.

47:56 The kinds of controls or oversight and review of the amount of overtime that is paid in relation to the amount of overtime that is budgeted. I ask that because it kind of goes back to that issue that we had when we were discussing cutting officers and then needing to pay other officers as required in order to...

48:26 In order to, you know, fulfill your responsibilities, do you feel that we've got, do you have controls within your department to make sure that the amount of overtime that is actually incurred is consistent with what you expect? One of the problems with police overtime is it's difficult to anticipate what's going to occur. We track by different categories of overtime, such as court time.

48:55 Extended Watch. We no longer are paying the on-call status, so that was reduced. I forget the amount of it. So some of those things, you know, it's a guess. We anticipate, we know that we're going to incur overtime costs. We know that if we make more arrests, that means we're going to have more court time. We know in the busy seasons we're going to have

49:24 Extended watch when the bars are busy, you know, on the busy weekends. We're going to have officers that make arrests and are going to have to work overtime for transport. So everything in dealing with police overtime, or most everything, is an educated guess based on past experience. I believe that we budgeted conservatively but an appropriate amount, and it's too soon into the year to make an estimate. And, of course,

49:52 Because of the seasonality of the way our town operates, you can't go month to month because we know some months are going to have more. This last weekend was a good example. Palooza Palooza cost us some overtime money. Let me also add that in terms of controls, specifically spending versus budget, town-wide, we really have not had any structured controls, if you would, controls that apply to all departments.

50:21 And we will have those beginning this fiscal year through financial reports. We have tools for departments to see their actual spending in connection to the budget, a tool that IE Resort Consulting provided to us.

50:35 Departments will start reviewing their actuals very soon, probably in the next month or so, as soon as the budget data are in the system. And based on the information they see, they'll sometimes have to adjust their spending accordingly. Even though there's seasonality in a lot of departments, there's a way to look at current year and current month actual and compare them to last year actual in the same month because if there's seasonality, normally you would see about the same level of spending.

51:04 So we will have tools for departments to control their spending and hopefully that will. Thank you. Any other questions on that page? Okay, the next page is still police services. It's services essential to keep the town's resort status and maintain quality of life and it's animal control services which is a combination of our wildlife specialist and the county animal control shelter. Are there any questions here? Okay.

51:37 Moving on to what's handwritten, page 13, and these are programs and services helping to ensure prudent management of the town's operations, and in this area we have police administration. Any questions here? So that is clear to me, as I reviewed this stuff, without pulling out a calculator, it appeared to me that there's overlap, meaning that you haven't taken a piece of your budget in a...

52:08 Allocated it just to one area. If there's three areas you haven't divided, how do I put this? The three areas together will exceed the amount of, no? That's not correct. I guess I didn't add very well. And we specifically avoided that problem by choosing carefully only one.

52:30 Priority area for a particular program and sometimes we had to make a judgment call as to what priority area to choose because even in police department's case for some of the programs the police chief felt that there's more than one priority area to which that program could be allocated but in order to avoid double and triple counting of the dollars we had to force ourselves and choose only one. Yeah, I could have easily put these

52:58 This portion in the first one dealt with the health and safety. I chose to split it and put the management team in this category. And you could argue either one, I think, logically. But it's all split by program. I mean, there's no split. But you don't, by splitting it, you've not assigned priority or relative priority to the various areas. No, I have not.

53:31 Okay. Any other questions on page 13? On page 14, the finishing up the police department is the all other programs and services where we have investigative services and police training. And I will make the comment that I had questioned why this wasn't under mandated services, but there's both mandated and discretionary training that is done, so I believe that's why it was put into this category. Correct. And I'm unable to add to... Right.

54:00 And we don't need to parse down any further than that, I don't think. Okay, we think the same way. Are there any questions on this page? All right. Thank you, Chief. Then we'll move on to recreation. The first set falls into programs and services essential to keep the town's resort status and maintain the quality of life. And under that, we have recreation programming on page 15.

54:35 Are there any questions on that one? Well, I would offer in the second to the last column to the right, which I guess would be the... The essential slash mandated column. Yeah, the eighth column. You know, frankly, I think it's a little equivocal for me to say some may say offering recreation programming is an essential community service.

55:01 There isn't any question in my mind that is essential. None whatsoever. I think it's an important thing for this council to say to the community that this stuff is really important. It's difficult in some instances to define what is mandated versus essential. Mandated is just that. Essential is...

55:27 I don't consider it an extra at all because it relates to two things in my mind. One is the quality of life for those who live here, but more equally as importantly, there's a nexus between visitorship and things that we do. People come here for

55:52 To participate in some instances in things that we actually program. And I have a direct experience in that yesterday. The details are not particularly important, but somebody from Boston is involved in something that the town has contributed money to, and he came here for it. And so I would like to have that language beefed up because it just seems, to me, it seems obvious.

56:18 To some others it may not seem obvious because it happens to fall in the recreation category, but that tells you what I think the strength of recreation programming as well as some of these other recreation things is. I see heads nodding. Is that consensus to ask for a stronger? I would agree with that. Yes. I think the public made it pretty clear to us also what they thought about it. Okay. Any other comments on page 15?

56:49 On page 16, the next one is Whitmore Pool, and I think that's where you were heading, Matthew, saying that that should also, our community has definitely come out and said that that's important. So I don't, is there consensus to make sure that it's understood that that is essential? Yes. Yes, in particular because we derive revenue. Right.

57:19 Okay. The other two on this page, and we are still in the resort status and quality of life area, are the multi-use facility and the recreation commission. Any comments on those two? I don't like the statement under recreation commission for the same reasons. For us to have all the rest of this work together, I believe that having a commission is essential in staffing it.

57:54 Is the only way to be efficient. So I would prefer language to that effect. It's a reverse of it of saying why it's essential and that it does get those things accomplished that are going to move us forward as a resort. Any other comments on page 16? All right. Going on to page 17 where the priority category is legally mandated programs or services and we have

58:31 Permit Administration, which is special events permits. Are there any questions on that one? Okay, the next priority category, contractually obligated programs and services where we have, it actually runs across two pages, so why don't we talk about all three of them at once. We have fishing enhancement, local program funding, and July 4th celebration. Again,

59:08 On all three of them, I think that it may not be mandated, but it is essential to supporting tourism. I would rather see statements, something along those lines. And I think the reason why, and I concur, and what I don't want to do is sort of make all of these things feel generic, generically essential.

59:33 My view is that if there is something that this town spends money on to bring people here, which funds nearly 70% of our operating budget and comprises 70% of our revenue, which keeps this town alive, keeps us fiscally solvent, that we need to recognize that. I'm not certain that local program funding does that, but I am certain that fishing enhancement

1:00:03 As I'm on my paddleboard on Lake Mary looking down in this clear water at the fish that are stocked by helpers throughout and all of the lines that are being cast from the shore, those are people that are staying in beds and paying T.O.T., which allows the town to function. It's very important for me to make that connection on those things where it should be made, and I think July 4 is similar. It's certainly good for the...

1:00:33 For the locals, but when you have thousands of people down at Crowley and elsewhere where we spend money, they're here for the event. Go ahead, Matthew. I would almost just add, because we've gone through the budget process already, and I think we've made such deep and heavy cuts, it's almost like...

1:00:58 We've already decided whether or not almost every single thing on here is essential or not. And if it weren't essential, I don't think we would even have it in here. So I think we could almost go through the entire program here and look at that. But I mean, we'll still go line by line. But just a thought moving forward. I was just going to reemphasize, as Rick was doing, that our economy is, in fact,

1:01:25 Not speculative, but is in fact tourism based. Tourism drives not only the town's budget, but also the business in our community. These, whether it's special events, fishing enhancement, children fishing festival, whatever it may be, these are all tourism based events that help bring people to our community and pay the town's bills and the community's bills. Just on a quick side note,

1:01:55 Did participate in the Children's Fishing Festival out there at Snow Creek a couple of weekends ago, and hundreds, I don't know what it was, 700 kids participated in this fishing event, and I was cleaning fish, so I saw who caught fish and who was there, and I don't know, 95% of the people I saw, I'd never seen before in my life, and they come there with their parents.

1:02:24 To get their fish clean. I mean, these people, this is one event, bluesapalooza, whatever it may be, but people come to Mammoth for their vacation and are excited to have these events that we do furnish the people when they come to town. So very, very supportive. It's important to note, too, I think on a lot of these events, it's taken years to build them up to where they are. Okay, so I'm hearing consensus that on fishing enhancement on 4th of July,

1:02:56 We're looking for a statement that talks about how this supports the tourism and therefore results in increased revenues. I did hear you, Rick, say you didn't think local program funding fell into that. Do you have any kind of a comment on what's been written down there as the essential or mandated? It depends upon how you define essential or mandated. It contributes to the quality of life of those of us who live here.

1:03:26 It contributes to a sustainable economy. So I don't mean by not including it that it isn't important, because it certainly is, and we've traditionally funded them. And actually, when I'm looking at the way these particular ones were done, that the...

1:03:48 Some of the statements in the impact column, the far right column, are really the statement that should probably be under essential or mandated or, you know, essentially the definition of why we see it as essential. So I'm wondering if there can be some wordsmithing between those columns when we see it again. Madam Mayor, we also saw, I think, a connection or connectivity displayed tonight when Roger Guffey spoke.

1:04:15 Where he participated in a local event that raised huge amounts of money for the community. And he participated because he got a piece of the action on the parking and he will be able to distribute that to these groups that we're talking about. So there is a connection there for tourism, I believe.

1:04:41 On that note, John, I think also if you just even look at the Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra, they bring in a lot of heads into beds. I mean, that's not just a local program. That is very tourist-based, and almost everybody that participates in that is from out of town. Ski Foundation. Good. Okay. The next category for recreation are the fully self-supporting programs and services.

1:05:11 The first is the annual recreation guide. Does anyone have comments on that one? I do if no one else does. My thought is that that recreation guide supports making sure that the people that we have brought to town have things to do, know how to find them, etc. So from that perspective to me it is also essential. After all, we have approved a recreation plan that says

1:05:40 Recreation is our economic engine. So I would rather see something along those lines. That this guide is in support also of the tourism and the quality of life and essential because of that. It's also, if you notice, nearly self-supporting. I think that measure R and...

1:06:09 Okay, so there's pieces of Measure R. Measure R administration, I would argue that it is mandated because our ordinance requires it that there be administration within the ordinance language that was approved by the voters. And I would make that same argument for the other pieces of R and U on page 19, that they are mandated by the ordinances.

1:06:41 I think that's a good point. And speaking of Measure U, just to comment, so I see that it's all in recreation, but Measure U, of course, has other specifically designated uses as well. And I'm wondering, is it just because it's convenient to put it into recreation?

1:07:04 I think it was my understanding that we did that as part of the budget as a placeholder when the steering committee comes back with how it's going to be handled, it would be moved to wherever council decides based on the options that come to us from the Measure U steering committee, but I believe it was just essentially put there as a placeholder because you're right, it does support

1:07:30 Arts, Culture, Transit, and Recreation. The Recreation Commission is convening that process at this time, so it kind of resides in the... Correct, but that doesn't mean... I think it's truly just a placeholder for now. Okay, yeah. And again, you know, with all of those, they are mandated as the ordinance, which says that our local voters want it to happen. Okay, the next part of recreation...

1:07:54 Is programs or services helping to ensure prudent management of the town's operations? And this has public information under it. Are there any questions there? Okay. Then we'll move on to page 20. Thank you, Stuart. Which is MLT or tourism and marketing. Any questions there? I have a comment.

1:08:32 Just to how essential it is. I think we've all kind of mentioned it before. I've tried to emphasize it, but it seems that being that we are such a remote and tourist-based town with such a heavy emphasis with the majority of our revenues coming from tourism and particularly TOT, I would just reemphasize.

1:09:00 What a priority it is that every department, I think, hinges on the revenues that come from the marketing efforts of this department. So I would just really want to overemphasize how important this particular area is. Any other comments? Okay, just a second, I'm making some notes. Okay, then moving on to page 21, which is Public Works.

1:09:32 The first category being contributing to protection and preservation of health and safety and management of risk and liabilities. Under here we have the snow removal and street maintenance on page 21. Does anyone have any comments on the columns there? Well, I would only point out publicly that we made some very tough decisions that will...

1:10:01 Undoubtedly, we will be paying for in future years by underfunding the required, they're not street improvements, but maintenance, the overlays and so on. And as we all know, we're only doing Meridian and we're only doing Sierra Park this year, but we've got, I don't know how many miles we have in the town, a lot. 104 miles. 104 miles, and we're doing one.

1:10:31 And I realize that not all 104 have to be done in one year, but I think it's important to note that we're not only down to essential and mandated, but as Matthew stated earlier about some of the other areas, we've cut the daylights out of this very important function. And so I think time will tell whether we've acted prudently. I think we've acted as we've had to, and what's left is required.

1:11:00 Okay, any other comments on that page? The same category continues on page 22 with garage services, facilities maintenance, and parks maintenance. Comments? No comments. I believe they're well described as they stand at the moment. Let's move on to page 23, the category then being...

1:11:28 Programs and services essential to keep the town's resort status and to maintain quality of life. And we have capital projects engineering here. Any questions there? I think it's well stated. Okay. Anyone else is okay on that? Moving on to page 24 where we get into legally mandated programs or services and we have engineering there. Questions or comments?

1:12:10 Moving on to page 25, still Public Works, fully self-supporting programs or services. We have the assessment districts and the local transportation commission. I'm almost wondering, I believe the statement on local transportation commission is good, but I wonder if it should not be clearer that the local transportation commission, which is a combination of the town and the county,

1:12:42 Allocates a significant millions of dollars in projects and that they're all long range, long term and that that makes it, that's just another piece of how essential it is. You know, things like we're finally getting into projects that were twinkling someone's eyes in the late 90s. So really what you're saying is that, you know, we budget $241,000 in order to do the work that gets us.

1:13:13 Millions. Yeah, ultimately, it's state money that we're receiving. Correct. State and federal. Yeah. It's almost as if we have to spend this sum. It's not at all discretionary in order to manage the extraordinary amounts of money that are coming to us that are not coming to us. Yes, yes, that it's leveraging enormous amounts of money to us.

1:13:41 And we have say-so, whether it's the town or the county. Correct. Where in the past, historically, 10 years ago or so, this was a decision that was made by Caltrans themselves. Correct. With limited input from the local people, so. Okay, any other comments on page 25? No. Moving on to page 26, still in the same category, we have the Long Valley Pit operation. Any questions?

1:14:14 Any questions on those right-hand three columns? And I am understanding this correctly, that it is at no cost out of the general fund. It's an enterprise fund. It's an enterprise. So that is a self-supporting program. Any questions on that page? All right. Moving on to community development. On page 27, we first have...

1:14:46 Programs and services contributing to protection and preservation of health and safety or management of risk and liabilities. Questions on the columns? I have one statement that I would like to make, and it's a follow-up of a question to bring back to us next week, and some of my other comments will follow. But this is an area where I would hope we can discuss some options where there might be

1:15:23 A few work items in the same department that are a lower priority where the funds are not saying that the general fund is not needed but that we need to beef up inspection services and code compliance and that we might juggle around some of the money that are other work items that are here for this department. And I would add to that that with our limited staffing that's out there, we're having to turn to this department.

1:15:54 More and more for enforcement items, in particular, TOT enforcement. We're having to look and put a lot of weight and consideration to this department in order to see that we get our money collected that's due to the town. Any other comments on this page? All right. Moving on to just a second.

1:16:26 Moving on to page 28, which is programs and services essential for resort status and quality of life. The program here is customer assistance and is that in the building division or is it the whole building division? It's in building division and it's the whole building division too, so both. All right. Any comments on that one from council?

1:16:55 And you realize to the public we're also reading these as we go because we just received this information. And I would again add that there's some items in here that I think are essential just because of the changing economy being that we have to adapt to changing environment of the state, federal government, whatnot.

1:17:17 There are destination, resort, community, and economic development strategies in here. So this also falls into this department. I think it's very critical. Any other comments? Okay, moving on to page 29, which is still resort status and quality of life. This time it's customer assistance planning division. Any comments on the columns there? Okay.

1:17:53 On page 30, the next piece of that same category is for maintaining the zoning code and development standards. And I'm presuming that I understand the statement under essential and mandated, but it appears to me that this is anticipating that once we have done the zoning code update, this is only a placeholder presuming that everything will have been incorporated.

1:18:26 And that's somewhere else in the departmental programs, finishing the update. That's correct. Okay. So that's why there's only two-tenths of a full-time employee here. Okay. Two hundreds. Two hundreds. Two hundreds. Sorry, I can't read those. These are awfully tiny numbers. Okay. Moving on to page 31. Okay, I spoke too soon. It's just the way the table split.

1:18:57 On this page, still under resort status and quality of life, there are two, which is the CEQA zoning code amendment and a single-family transient rental zoning code amendment. Does anyone have any comments? I have some that relate to the zoning code amendment. I think that before we go down the road of

1:19:27 Spending the time to put together a zoning code amendment and run that through the commissions, I think it's important that council just weigh in, not necessarily tonight, but soon, on whether or not we even think now is the time to go forward with this discussion. And this is one of those areas where I would suggest having that discussion, should it not be consensus of council to move forward with this one, that the money go towards more TOT enforcement.

1:19:58 of what we're trying to work on right now because we had talked about getting that done first, getting the people compliant in the areas that are already in the code but where people are not paying their TOT, which was back there, the one I mentioned on the other page. So I'm just kind of putting that out there for now. It's not saying that this is money that is free. It's saying I believe the priority goes first to

1:20:25 The enforcement efforts that we're doing as it relates to compliance with the existing T.O.T. before we go to this one. Just as long as we have agendized and public discussion. Correct. Yeah, that's what I'm saying, is bring it forward to agendize with a public discussion, listen to the community and see whether now is the time to go forward with that before we spend money to create a zoning code amendment.

1:20:52 Yeah, I think we had actually discussed that previously, too. We did. And it wasn't to say that it wasn't important to have this come up. It was just that we really wanted to solidify, I think, the collection process first and then it's really just shifting these monies from this particular priority. Back to the other one. Yeah. That's what I'd like to have come back to us as an option. I'm willing to discuss it at the appropriate time.

1:21:22 I've got strong feelings about this one, but obviously now is not the time to do that. It's listed as a priority because it was stated as a priority in our budget. If we're going to move a specific priority, and I'm hoping, as I know the mayor is, that we are going to be more general tonight than specific, but I'm sure we have our opportunity to have that debate. And I am hoping that bringing it back for a...

1:21:52 Agendized discussion involving the community is something that doesn't take $25,000 until we know if it's going forward. Any other comments on page 31? Okay, going to page 32, which is complete CEQA and adopt the mobility plan. Are there any questions there? No.

1:22:25 I had a question raised by a constituent about this because the mobility plan has not yet been completed. And so are we ahead of ourselves by doing CEQA on the mobility plan? The draft will come out in September. It'll go through a review process and then... So it'll happen this fiscal year? Yes. Yeah. Okay. Any other comments on page 32? Okay. Moving on to page 33.

1:23:03 Still in the category of essential for resort status and maintain the quality of life. There are two on this page, complete the Mammoth Creek Park concept plan and complete the master plans and public facilities finance plan. Please get another name for that. This is an area where I think that completing the Mammoth Creek concept plan is getting ahead of the horse before we have a

1:23:33 Adopted our park and rec master facilities plan and seeing how this fits into that, I would suggest again that this is an item that is not started immediately and that I'm concerned that the amount of money down for the PFFP doesn't seem like enough and I would think that it's going to take those combined amounts based on our discussions about

1:24:03 Figuring out DIF in this year. My only argument with that would be just listening to Sean Turner and others tonight with the increasing demand for facilities, particularly for venue sites and connectivity to these different sites. I'm fearful of closing that door too quickly. It seems that...

1:24:32 I think as this Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition and as these events keep growing and getting more structured, if we should maybe consider the importance of those as we look at these two items. Well, I was just speaking to the Mammoth Creek Park concept. Right. I was not speaking to the PFFP. That definitely needs to go forward. And that would include at least in my...

1:25:03 Feeling of it, it would include an initial feasibility study for any kind of an events venue as opposed to specifically picking out one that, it's my understanding, has not even been to the Recreation Commission. Right. So I'm saying it's a lesser priority and I'm saying that I think that we'll end up spending the money on DIF and the other one. Just a comment. I would just be asking the staff not start working on that.

1:25:34 Immediately. Well, I just want to make sure that to the extent that recreation is included, that it lines up with rec strats. Correct. And I don't know that it does that yet here. And we're rolling out rec strats. We're rolling out next. The final draft is now on our board staff. Right. Which is why I'm saying that I would say that this is one that would not be something staff would start working on immediately until we've seen all of that and how it works in with

1:26:02 The college's plans, etc. Any other comments on page 33? Moving on to page 34, same category, we have complete implementation plans for downtown concept for Main Street and develop and implement an economic development program. That's a mouthful. Comments? I think it's essential. I do as well.

1:26:38 I do as well, but I again have some concern with saying that going forward with implementation plans right now is a, I'd say it's a lesser priority within the essential items just because in this last year we

1:27:01 Put a lot of money towards preparing for reinvestment and we got all of those plans done and staff and the commissions did a wonderful job in getting all of that to us. I'm a little concerned about I understand that implementation plans would be the next step but I'm wondering if they're a slightly lesser priority as we try and finish up the rest of the pieces of the concepts first. The only argument I would have with that is that I think

1:27:31 Now that we have the plans in place, obviously the next step is the implementation. And we've spent a lot of years, I think, working on numbers of studies and studies and studies, and I think we have to somehow put a vehicle in place where if we are able to attract investment, how can we help that move forward?

1:27:56 And I'm presuming that the master facilities plan, the diff discussion, and the public facilities financing plan need to come before we do implementation plans is my only suggestion, that we finish the rest of the higher level ones, which would include feasibility studies and settings up. Well, yeah, I'm not really hung up on what comes first. I mean, I understand what needs to happen, but one thing that I'm impressed with is

1:28:27 You know, and I was going to sort of save this particular comment to the end. You know, really, what going through this 50-page document does is it puts in one place, in plain language, why it is that we spend money the way we do. And it's pretty remarkable. It's a lot different, in my mind, from a budget discussion where we're just, you know, looking at numbers and getting dizzy over it.

1:28:55 And one of the things that we have established, I think now in two budget cycles, is the importance of using this lull period to take care of business that wasn't taken care of before the last go-around. And, you know, we've had some, we will continue to have awful economic news. We can't control that, but what we can control is getting into one place what we think this community is going to look like, because in the end it goes back to,

1:29:25 What we've talked about, and that is to provide an opportunity for revitalization, rehabilitation, new investment, meaning new jobs, meaning more T.O.T. for the town, but more importantly, more money for the financial health of the community.

1:29:41 I just see that as such a fundamental obligation of this town. And it says in here that it's essential or mandated or both to do all of these things. It gets kind of squishy because planning is planning. You can't see. Nothing's being built. Sticks are not going up. But without the planning, you can't put the sticks up. That's got to come first. And that's why it has been so important to throw some significant sums of money, at least now, at this to get it done.

1:30:10 Last but not least, some people have said to me, well, as soon as we finish the planning because it takes so long we have to start all over again in a minute plans. Well, I don't think that's necessarily true. I mean, we've never had a comprehensive plan, meaning everything in one place, and plans are always...

1:30:29 I guess living documents that need to be modified as things go along, but the bulk of the work has been done in this last year and will be done in this year, and I'll leave it to the direction of council as to what the specific priorities are, but it's just important for me to make that statement about the fact that we're spending what is sort of soft money, or money for soft.

1:30:55 Deliverables in advance of doing something that's going to make this community better and financially more secure. Rick, just to reinforce what you're saying is we have, it's a time period where we've had tremendous momentum from that commission as well with the commissioners actually doing a lot of the work and I for one would like to see a continuation of asking them to do as much as they possibly can.

1:31:25 And to keep that momentum going. Mayor, just to let you know, this is principally funded by the Caltrans grant that we just received for $165,000. Any other comments on page 34? Moving on to page 35, where, same category, but it's the Gateway Neighborhood District Planning Study, Redevelopment Feasibility Study, and the Ormat Geothermal, CEQA, and NEPA.

1:31:58 Comments? And I will, and the redevelopment feasibility study, I realize these were written before the actions taken by the state. I would hope that determining whether or not there's even a realistic chance to create a redevelopment agency now that the

1:32:24 Legislatures taking all their actions would happen first before any kind of money is spent on a feasibility study. Mayor, in the third column, we note potential deferral due to actions in the state. Correct. Next to last, we say it's not essential now until that's sorted out. Okay. So that gives it a lesser priority within the year's work plan. Yes. Or maybe a...

1:32:49 Substitution. Substitution, yes. Well, I'm looking to move some things into the TOT and code enforcement, and I'm also looking to somehow get us into a spit and polish program. And where things are not likely to happen, I'd rather see us transfer them to make sure that our highest priorities within what community development is doing are actually adequately funded.

1:33:17 I completely agree, Jo. I mean, with what's going on at the state level, to spend money there is certainly in the next year is not a priority. But I also believe that we underfunded some of the other activities, and so I'm not suggesting there's money that is not assigned. I think that we may have underestimated or cut ourselves too far in some of the other areas that are essential.

1:33:45 Okay, moving on to page 36, we have support public art commission and public arts plan and housing element. Any comments there? No. Joe, I had some input and I think this is the section to bring it up. Did we all get the information? So I'd like to ask some questions if I can.

1:34:26 On the housing element, and I apologize to staff, I don't know if you have this document. On the specific deliverables, the housing element includes extremely low income housing analysis, policies and programs, home weatherization program. How were these identified as priorities, program priorities?

1:34:55 The housing element's adopted document, and in the housing element there are a series of actions. And for all of the housing-related programs, we very quickly in the last round of budget when housing funds were shifted, our staff, Ellen and myself, reviewed all of the major headings that you have before you, and we started putting our own time accounts to

1:35:24 To all of the programs. So many of the programs under housing elements are in the approved housing element. So this is an adopted document, went through the full process. Everybody that had a role in it reviewed and commented. And so we're using that as the guide to work program items. And we're matching work resource to funding to priorities in the element. Thank you. I've got a couple more questions, if I may.

1:35:54 In the housing element, it also includes analysis and development of fair housing program. Fair housing requirements are outlined by federal law and do not require analysis or development to be followed. Can you explain why we put in analysis and development? I'll have to meet with Ellen to know that one because it could be our wording is different than the law or what MLH is speaking to.

1:36:23 If I can interrupt you for just a second, John, I think if we put the questions out, these would be ones where then we ask them to come back with the answers next week. Yeah, absolutely. Another one very similar, Mark, is Housing Ordinance Administration includes, quote, determination on fees and housing mitigation requirements for development projects and determination and analysis for proposed alternate.

1:36:52 Housing mitigation plans. These items should not be paid for by the 2002A housing funds. These are project-specific items that have historically and should continue to be paid for by the project developer along with other required planning and application fees. Two-part answer. One is that in our analysis and setting up our fees, we didn't automatically put hours to...

1:37:18 Those things that are paid for through a development process, so if the applicant is doing that. The other part of the answer is in many of our applications we're finding policy issues and we're not associating town policy issues to the processing costs of all development permits. So some issues are funded through this, some issues are not. Okay. And they're billed to the projects. Thank you. Okay, does anyone else have comments?

1:37:48 I'm having some difficulty in the housing ordinance or the housing items are split over three or four of the priority areas, but it's still not clear to me. I keep seeing the same dollar amount and the same very small staff amount and getting confused with that. So I'm almost asking if you could bring back just the pieces that relate to housing

1:38:15 In one spot so we can understand because I see the same 248, 939 on four different columns and I'm not understanding exactly how that split, how much of it is contracted to MLH, how much of it is things that town staff are doing. So I'd like that. I think that's good. I'm feeling the same confusion and I'm hearing it in John's questions as well as Jo's comments.

1:38:46 Yes, and that is true. This represents that large lump that was divided, and so we'll come back with the hours to the tasks. Okay. And also please split up between town staff, town employee and contractor hours so we can understand, or dollar amounts, however it's working out so we can understand how much is being done in which spot.

1:39:10 Before we leave page 36, I had some questions about the 138,000 that's called Public Arts Plan Implementation Actions. Is that finally getting the monument sign in the ground? Yes. That's the cost of the monument sign. So that's committed.

1:39:32 That's a legally committed amount? Well, no, you've approved it. We've entered into a contract, a design contract, but we're not committed to necessarily proceed with the project. Okay. Is this, which monument signs of this? This is the one far outside of town. I know. This is the entry mark. This is one of the 40 signs on the way into town. This is the project, obviously. Yes.

1:39:56 And the line above that, the 3,032, is the estimated staff to support the Public Art Commission? Yes. Would that amount increase if a direction came from Council to just, let's spend all that money we have this year and close out that account? I'm just, that's a rhetorical question. Yes, it would increase because

1:40:25 You know, we assume that we might do one more art project, and it would be depending on how we devised an art project to implement. So if you had a whole bunch of little projects, it would cost more in staff time. And I, you know, perhaps your, if your direction is you want to deploy the art funds, you know, I think we'd have to do some work with the art commission. They'll have to have a

1:40:54 Pointed and effective strategy. But it would, I think, increase to some extent that amount of money. Okay. And outside of this, there's still another $200,000 or $300,000 available? That needs to be in the ground somewhere. Okay. That's page 36. Moving on to page 37, new category.

1:41:20 Legally mandated programs or services, and we have supporting the planning commission and processing development applications. Are there any comments on the right-hand three columns on this page? Just a general comment as support planning commission, I think $84,000 is money pretty well spent in recent years. God, they do a great job. Anyone else have comments on 37?

1:41:51 All right. Let's move on to 38, which is still mandated programs or services. We have building code and issuing permits. And then I think we've already kind of said we're going to deal with housing. We're going to ask to deal with housing separately. So any comments on what's down here for administer building code and issue permits? Some more comments? Okay. We'll move on to page 39.

1:42:22 Those, I believe, are also still pieces of the housing that we were going to defer over. I believe that's what monitoring there is related to housing, right? Correct. Okay. Page 40 has fully self-supporting programs and services. And there we have the PIEC and the Trail System Master Plan.

1:42:51 Any comments there? I am just going to say that I believe that these are both funded by other than general fund sources. Correct. To get these completed. Exactly. Same to the next page. So I'm trying to do a page at a time. Yeah, sorry. Okay, so any comments on page 40? So then when we flip over to 41, we also have the Lakes Basin Special Study, Transportation Planning Grant, and Shady Rest Staging.

1:43:20 So what we're saying is we've been able to garner almost $500,000 to get these done without general fund money. Correct. And they're definitely so. I have a problem with the shady rest staging saying it's not mandated or essential. I think, again, I think we want some of the comments that might be in the following impact column are really there because, yes, it is essential. Well, I think it's become more and more essential as the ORMAT.

1:43:51 Correct. And other items start to take hold. Mark, do we have an update on the security of the Sierra Nevada Conservancy grants? Are they solid? Yes. They are. John, I think the answer to that is if we have the grants awarded, let's spend it while they're still, and so we don't go through what happened last time. Just checking. Okay, over to page 42.

1:44:24 Programs or services to ensure prudent management of the town's finances. This is finance in budget. I presume this is the work done by CDD that rolls into this. Correct. Are there any questions from anyone on that one or the statements that are made there? Then under programs or services helping to ensure prudent management of town operations.

1:44:56 I believe you called it supervision. Some other departments have called it administration. But it's the same thing. It's the overall management of the department. Right. We generally, just so you know, we generally include administration project management with the tasks. And so we made it very focused to this particular item. Any questions there? Okay. That moves this on to page 43, which is administration. That's pretty easy. Let's see if I have anything written on my other pages.

1:45:32 Okay. Administration, any question on the programs that are here underneath protection and preservation of health and safety, management of risk and liabilities, which are safety and fuels reduction? Mandated. Okay. Yes. Definitely mandated. Going on to page 44, programs and services contributing to preservation of the town's essential assets, where we have

1:46:02 General liability and workers' compensation and property insurance. Any questions there? I'm just surprised at the dollar figure. I guess I shouldn't be on property insurance. $140,000 a year. I'm not surprised. Don't your insurance bills go up every year too? Yes, they do. Okay, moving on to legally mandated programs or services.

1:46:34 We have Town Council, Town Manager, Legal Services Training, and the Tax Administration Fee, which is the county's charge to us for administering property tax. Any comments there? Isn't that mandated by the county to do that? Mm-hmm. So it's mandated and we still have to pay for it?

1:46:58 Well, if you notice over there, now you and I might agree that maybe they are charging us an awful lot, but I'm just teasing. It's a contract. I believe we have a contract with a fee, but that doesn't mean that can't be revisited. But if we want to get our $700,000, we have to pay something for it. Also in that same column are the town clerk and the

1:47:29 Town audit, meaning the mandated financial audit by an independent auditor. Any questions on those as being mandated? Okay, the next. I guess you're safe, Jamie. Irreplaceable is more like it. Continuing on the bottom of page 46, programs and services that help promote town's economic growth.

1:47:56 We have revenue, compliance, and enforcement. Oh, here it is again. And revenue collection. Yep. You want to increase that one. I do, if we can. And again, I wonder, can that one, when we discuss it the next time, can we see everything that's going towards enforcement? Because I know it does break across departments. This is just coming out of the plan.

1:48:24 Correct. But we want to see, I want to be able to see what the total is and whether or not there are some lesser priority ones where money going into it, into the whole program would get us a greater return. Yeah, I like your thinking on that only because it's for every dollar we spend in this department. I'm wondering if we're not going to get several back. Should there also be the analysis of are we going to have a headhunter or not? Is that a viable option or not?

1:48:51 I believe that the committee finally said that we would try some of these other options first when they brought back the options to us, including the letter, etc. But I also understand that one of the reasons I want to increase the funding there is staff has not been able to get that letter sent out yet, reminding everyone of their obligations to pay TOT.

1:49:16 To collect and pick. I think we're meeting tomorrow to finalize that letter. And as far as the head hunter goes, I think we're going to try to vet out all these different items here internally. And then I think we're going to look at that as a good option because I think it's something that we should take seriously. It's a bounty hunter, isn't it? We're a bounty. Bounty hunter. Yeah, we'll get a dog in here. Yeah.

1:49:47 Can you see the showdown between dog and Steve? Okay, continuing on page 47, there are personnel, and this is developing the policies and procedures and then computer support, which is essentially maintaining and supporting our assets, our computer assets. Any comments there? Okay, moving on to page 48.

1:50:20 Which are programs and services helping to ensure prudent management of the town's finances. On this page we have payroll accounts payable and financial reporting. Any comments on the statements in the right three columns? Okay. Moving on, same category continues on page 49 where we have budget, the new budget document, risk management, and

1:50:52 Information Systems. And my only comment was, I understand that you split those two and I can live with it, but I wasn't sure why that was not part of computer support, why they're listed in two separate areas. But that would be just something that staff would... I couldn't see how you would... I understand that the equipment is an asset, but... I should have put the computer support listed earlier as a contract.

1:51:23 Because that's the support that we receive. Okay, so that'll come back to us next week as a... It actually is listed as a contract over work for the program description. We have a contract on that side. Okay. That's the computer people that support our financial system. And the information systems is the staff that supports all of the town computers and...

1:51:48 Okay, maybe that can just be clarified as a follow-up item as which pieces are which because I was having trouble figuring out what the difference was between the two. Well, the FTE was a clue for me. Yeah. That's personnel. Any other comments on page 49? Second to last page. Programs and services helping to ensure prudent management of the town's operation.

1:52:19 We have town administration support. We have personnel, which is meeting the legal mandates, records management, recycling, and other contracts, which sounds a little bit like a placeholder for anticipated contracts. The records management? No, no, no, the other contractual, the very last line. Oh, this is actually put in by...

1:52:49 The Town Manager, as they request to be able to review staffing levels in. Okay, any other questions on page 50? Okay, on page 51, all other programs and services, we have facilities maintenance, which is the library unit's facilities maintenance. Any questions there?

1:53:31 Oh, I'm sorry, we have a couple more pages. Debt service on page 52, which is our debt service. Any questions on that? Okay, page 53, self-insurance. Any questions there? Okay, and now we're really at the final page, which is comprehensive leave program, which is the set aside to cover the...

1:54:07 Obligations for leave. Any questions there? I would actually like to maybe have the council consider adding something more about how essential it is to be funding your known obligations, knowing that many of the areas, and in fact even some of the Midwestern states, have gotten themselves into trouble because they were not funding.

1:54:37 Their leave and retirement. Oh, right. And so I would ask for some stronger language there. And so maybe, again, what's over in the impact is kind of bleeding a little bit into why it's essential. Yeah, good point. So I have got a question about that funding of retirement as opposed to comprehensive leave and some of the other things. Are we on a pay-as-you-go? Yes, we are. Okay.

1:55:09 For PERS, yeah. For PERS. Yeah. So where, and so where, where is that? I mean, is it just, you know, all of the department? It's not, I didn't see that as a separate item. It's part of the staffing costs that are, that's part of the staffing costs that everybody has listed under their. In each department? In each department. Okay, right.

1:55:34 And it's my understanding that we allocate it that way so that the reimbursement rate on all of our grants covers the full cost of like administering a federal grant or something like that. Okay. Okay. I believe we asked – we have –

1:55:58 answered the three questions, and our, some of our community has been patiently waiting, so I would ask if there are any comments on what has occurred this evening, knowing that this is an interim staff, if you want to come up to the podium. Donette Hustleton, can you answer how much is out in collections on TOT as you're receivable?

1:56:32 How much what? How much is owed to the town on TOT and collections? Because that seems to have been brought up several times that there's quite a bit of money that has not been collected on TOT because it's in collections. How much is owed actually to the town? Well, it's not so much that there's monies, I think, in collection. It's how much it's not being collected. Unreported. Unreported, yeah.

1:56:59 So what you're telling me is that people are saying they actually don't owe that and you're saying they do owe that? No, we're saying the activity is going on that is not reported. They're renting their units, they're collecting taxes, and they're not remitting that to the town, not reporting it, not any of that. And is there some type of documentation to that where you can go after that?

1:57:28 We search internet sites. We can see people that do not have, are not registered, are not, do not have a business tax certificate and are not collecting. We can see their calendars online and to see that there's activity going on and know that that entity does not have a business tax certificate and is not collecting or reporting to you.

1:57:51 The reason why I was asking, I just noticed in the paper that the Mammoth Lakes Water District just posted people that hadn't paid their dues. I don't know what the legal state is on that, but I'm wondering if there should be some way of being able to collect it through embarrassment or other means.

1:58:10 That was my question because it was simply a big topic tonight about TOT and I was curious how much money was really out there that has not been collected and now I understand. So thanks. The Lawson Association has done some of my work and they firm that a number that they feel we're missing $800,000 to a million dollars in uncollected TOT. Per year. Per year.

1:58:37 Wow. That's a lot. That's the right response. Wow. Which is why you're hearing us say the more money we can spend on enforcement, the more return we get. Exactly. So I guess that was my question. I thought maybe they just didn't want to pay and get us sitting on the receivables, but it's actually you're catching people that are not. For the last 12 months, there's actually been a group out there.

1:59:05 It's been looking and doing research and collecting this data, and we've been waiting to get these resolutions passed where we can change the enforcement policies and also make the fines and whatnot a lot stricter. Those have passed, and now we're waiting just to finalize some of the letters and some of the other items for the enforcement to get into place, which should start happening in the next week or so.

1:59:33 And so you'll start seeing more in the paper and you're going to start seeing a lot more of these things happening. Good. Yeah. I also have a couple of comments. I also got the budget last night and had my calculator on my bed and getting all those numbers and the same questions. My first question was, hmm, they don't balance. Oh, it must be restricted money. And so I made my list and called at 8 o'clock this morning and that was the case. Referred me to Cindy and she answered my questions.

2:00:00 So I also went through it just like you all did. And what came out of my reviewing the whole budget until 1130 last night was I see that, and I know Rick made this comment, so that if we've got a big lawsuit, or you have a big lawsuit, and if we lower our park and recs budget and events, that lowers our tourism.

2:00:28 That means that then we don't have the money for the snow removal or the repairs or the airport people coming in aren't making their money. So I hope that we look at the whole picture of if we go with parking wrecks and we have to cut certain stuff, what's the ramifications for the future? Because hopefully the person at Hot Creek realizes

2:00:58 The town will have to pay a lot of money. The town's going to have to find that money. They're going to have to cut possibly services. That will trickle down to the airport. They will also lose money. So I'm hoping in the negotiations of all of this that that is pointed out to them that if you demand all this money, and I'm sure they're going to want all their legal costs, and I expect they will, and they should.

2:01:27 And other costs. But to take the, to ask for more than above that, I hopefully someone will point out to them that it's also going to hurt them if there's no one coming in on the airplanes because we don't have the services to provide. Now I've also noticed when, where I work, we've done some economic

2:01:55 I've looked at stuff like store stuff and percentages, and I found when the price of gas goes up, we seem to have more visitors because this is about as far as people want to go. They don't want to go up north or they don't want to go back east or they don't want to fly to Hawaii. This is a short, quick vacation, and I've noticed sometimes our revenue goes up when the gas prices go up because

2:02:23 It's a quick place, cheaper place sometimes. They can go camping. They can do lots of things. I've noticed in some years that our visitor has gone up. And this year, I think it'll stable out or it maybe be lower due to other reasons. But in the past, we have looked at it. And a comment had come out about, yeah, we always seem to do a lot better when the gas prices go up or the economy gets worse. Because everyone looks at what's the shortest.

2:02:51 You know, we're LA's backyard, basically. So what's the shortest vacation? So we need to make sure that we, that happens and try not to take those services away so that people don't go somewhere else. And hopefully we can, somebody can get to Hawk Creek and say it's really, it is going to hurt you in the end as well. That was all my comments. Thank you, Danette. Does anyone else like to make a comment?

2:03:18 Okay, does staff have the direction that they need for next week's meeting? In that case, we would adjourn to next Wednesday, August 17th.