TransparentMammoth

Airport Commission · 2011

Airport Commission

· recording 1 hr 54 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

238 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 And the difference between Bramman and your mother, but if you ask Bramman to come in on this letter, I think you have to ask Bramman to come in on this letter. I think it's all attracted right.

0:30 Okay, you guys, it looks like we can start. Everyone in their place? Move over. Okay, I'd like to call the meeting to order, and we'll begin with the Pledge of Allegiance. Pledge of Allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

1:21 And to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Do I have a roll call? Commissioner Hughes has an excused absence. Commissioner Walter? Here. Vice Chair Perrell? Here. And Chair Murphy? Here. This is a time for any public comments outside of those on the agenda today. Do we have anyone that would like to give any? Any commission reports?

1:59 We just met recently, so I can't imagine. Presentations, no consent agenda. So we'll get to the business matter on the agenda today, which as we all know is a study session on the draft airport layout plan. I'd like to make a couple of notes. I'd like to remind everyone of the request last week to speak more directly into the microphones when we talk so that the audience can hear. We're new at this fancy meeting.

2:30 Table here. We like our little room better. And I'd like to sort of give a little bit of meeting guidance before we go into the plan. We have a large amount of information to cover today in not enough time. Some of it will be stuff we've heard before, and some of it will be new. So how I'd like to do this is that I'd like to allow staff,

2:59 To present this entire section, if the commissioners and guests could take notes of questions, what I'll do after that section is presented, then I'll go to each commissioner for questions, then I'll turn it over and ask the public the same. Remember today, this is the beginning. So the purpose of today is to share information and pose questions.

3:25 We're not here to take action. We're not here to debate. We're not here to make decisions. So we really expect to have a lot of time to do that in the future. We have some plans for, as we've talked about, bringing on some third-party consultants to help us with some of that debate. But today, as brought up by members of the public and other commissioners a few months ago, so we really needed to take a step back.

3:54 And start at the beginning and get information. So that's our goal today. So with that said, let's start. Chair, members of the commission, hello, my name is Mark Wardlong, I'm the Community Development Department. Today we have a presentation workshop for you, a study session to receive comments, questions, and any direction that you wish to share with us. We have actually gathered up an immense amount of information for you.

4:21 It's not practical for us to flip through the binders of material. And so we have prepared a team presentation by key section element. And what we'd like to do, as you've already said, is we'll go through each particular section, and then we'd like to close our report on that section and take any questions and comments from the commission, followed by questions and comments from the general public.

4:49 The presenters today are going to be myself, Bill Manning, Airport Director, and Jen Daugherty and John Urdi with Mammoth Lakes Transportation, and we each have a bit to play. Again, there's a bunch of information, so what we'll provide to you in this PowerPoint synopsis are really just the highest level points. You can certainly ask us follow-up questions and we can provide detail.

5:15 Our objective out of this meeting is to gather as much information as we can that we can then use to go through the rest of this process. Our objectives and purpose today are these. This is our first Airport Commission study session on the draft airport layout plan update narrative.

5:36 We want to pose the information that we know we have today. We continue as we read these documents to find items that should be corrected and perhaps reframed. We're seeking your comments that we will use. We have received extensive comments, so many comments that it's almost difficult to keep up with them, and I want to thank Mr. Malloy and Mr. Kalish. Their diligence in this is actually remarkable.

6:03 We are keeping all of those comments, posing them into a table, as you know, and with the intent of, through the peer review process, being able to address those technical positions. Some of the questions, you know, we as the staff will be able to address, and those comments will come back to you in a workshop presentation later.

6:25 After this meeting, we'll regroup, we'll review the comments that we've received, and we'll meet with the committee that you appointed to decide on how best to pose this information to the consultant for their review. Our format section is background. That will be first a little chronology and history of the airport by Bill, so he'll follow right after I make these remarks. I will then follow with the policy framework. Why is this down?

6:56 Pursuing this and what are the policy documents that relate to this and direct our work to that effort. Then Section 3 will be the air service forecast presentation by Mr. Urdi, followed by a synopsis of the draft ALP by Bill again. And then finally Jen will discuss the decision framework and process and where we go from there. So with each section we will pause and we will take your comments and questions.

7:25 You'll note we have a kind of different setup today. We apologize if it seems rude that our back is to you. But with the PowerPoint screen for you to see it, we have to move. And Jen will be taking notes and projecting them on the board so you can actually see. I can't see it, but if you can see what that says, you'll know that we're capturing those comments. And we're also being recorded today. We have the...

7:49 Granica System that records Town Council and Planning Commission meetings. So today we're actually using a Planning Commission box. So it won't have the right commission label on it, but Karen Ridley is monitoring that, and then this will be a recorded effort where people can review it and see it, and Commissioner Hughes can review it at his leisure as well. So any questions about how we proceed?

8:16 You may wish to put some time limits. We are going to try to be very brief and succinct because this is your meeting, not our meeting. And we certainly want to encourage the public to have succinct, cogent points. So with that, no other questions or comments, I'll turn it over to Bill Manning. Commissioner, I'm Bill Manning from the airport. I want to go back in time a bit. In fact, we'll start back.

8:50 Excuse me, about 1998 to go forth to 2000. This was the large expansion project. It was a hubs and spokes project with American Airlines, and it included Boeing 757 flights in Dallas to Chicago. A huge amount of employments. An employment is one passenger departing the airport. And so at that time we were looking at about 330,000 employments was a projection.

9:18 A lot of infrastructure associated with this project, wider, longer runways, terminal buildings, large ramps, a whole host of big projects. We actually at the time had a $28 million grant from the FAA to go forward, and this project was overturned in the federal court, and the court ordered that the FAA conduct an environmental impact statement.

9:48 On a go-forward basis for that project. Well, in 2001 to hereabout, through 2010, we started down the path of the environmental impact statement for the large project, the Hubs and Spokes project. And about halfway through the document, we changed direction. And we went from a Hubs and Spokes concept to a regional airport concept in regional markets.

10:19 That EIS, which we completed, allowed us to do eight flights a day in the winter, two flights a day in the summer, and with a limit of 80 aircraft with 80 seats or less. If those flights were all filled at 60% capacity, that would give us about 66,000 in planements annually.

10:45 So as we went forward, from about 2008 to 2010, we converted the fire station into a terminal building. We started air service one flight a day with Horizon Air from LAX. A couple years later, we did an environmental assessment to commence jet service at the airport. And then last year, 2010, we had four flights a day.

11:11 And we experienced some real problems at the terminals. A lot of overcrowding. And those of you who traveled know that there are some real issues going forward. So now, around 2011, to mitigate the overcrowding that we experienced in past years, we're wrecking a sprung structure or a tent at the airport. It doesn't do anything to increase capacity for passenger throughput.

11:40 But it's going to keep people out of the weather, keep them from bunching up in the lobby area and allow us to just process one flight at a time through the sterile area. Great thing this year, seven flights a day, four days a week. New markets, Los Angeles, San Francisco, San Jose, and San Diego and Orange County.

12:08 This year, last year, air service, we looked at about 25,000 employments as we finish this season up, and next year, looks like we'll be looking at about 30,000, 35,000 employments. Does that have any questions? So, that's phase one. Any questions? Bill, just as a, in a brief synopsis, can you recall what the points of contention were as far as the EA goes?

12:40 Why was it challenged by the four entities that challenged it? Well, I think there were a number of environmental issues. I think probably in my mind the key issue was growth in the town and associated with the airport. This project just seemed too big to a lot of folks. Right at that time, InterWest was just coming to town. There was a lot of envisioning on how the town was going to look.

13:07 And there were just folks who didn't agree with that, and certainly the airport was part and parcel to that projected growth. No, I think he answered my question. Thank you. Look, this one slide. You've got to come in with it just quickly. Basically, it's a comparison of where we were then in claimants, where we are today, and where we're proposing to go. And as you can see, there's a big difference between

13:41 The injuncted project and what we're proposing to go forward to work in the future. Would that be questions? No, you've got one more slide. One more? Go ahead. No wonder where I was going to keep it short. So what are our problems today? What are our limitations? The main issue that we have at the airport today really is that we have one boarding gate. One boarding gate means that

14:14 We can only process one flight at a time. It's a real problem for our customers coming through. It means that we have to space the aircraft out pretty much every hour. That doesn't allow us to get people in early and go skiing, get people out late after they've been skiing, or help with connections, not only for the locals, but also with the...

14:42 With our visitors. Additionally, a big deal is we need a longer runway. As you know, during the summer months, we have to see that Horizon can't carry or can't book to a full load, and that's because of the density altitude, and that means if we had a longer runway, we'd be able to fill up our flights in the summer. That's not my slide. Okay, so leave it there. Leave it there. Thank you.

15:15 Tom, with the new added slides, do you have any other questions? No. Can you go back to this slide prior to... Two back. Two back. Bill, I know you were a little... because this came up after, but I think this needs some real explanation. So why don't you just go through what it is.

15:39 Again, back in 2000, hubs and spokes. Today is regional. Proposed for the future is regional. Employments? So, hubs, the 330,000 employments were, hubs and spokes means the,

15:54 The injuncted, the thrown away, we're not asking for that anymore. We're certainly not. 2,000 is what we did this year. 2,500,000 is what we did this year. And then your regional is what's currently addressed in the ALP that we're addressing today. That's correct, in the forecast. And that'll be John Urdi's piece. Again, we're not doing 757s. We won't be able to bring in aircraft that size. Q400 and CRJ700 are the aircraft of today.

16:23 Twenty years out, we're looking at 15 to 20 years out, a few larger aircraft, but again, our base numbers will be in the Q400, RJ700 size. Wingspan is a big deal for us, the 757 and 124. Today, we're looking at 93 and 98 feet for the CRJ and the Q400. We would tell you that 100 feet.

16:50 100 foot wingspan is generally speaking our limitation in the future. Seats again from a large 187 seats down to 76 today and then up to about 124. That's kind of our bookend is the 124 throughout the 20 year period that we're looking at. We've reduced the runway width.

17:14 From 150 feet and the enjoined project down to 100 feet. And that goes a long way towards limiting the type of aircraft that we actually can accommodate. There's a new terminal in both Brooklyn projects and the sprung marshes going up today. So, okay. Tell me what you're doing.

17:40 I just have two questions or a comment and a question. Knowing that this is going to be on the web and really to explain things, I want to make sure I understand it as well. So when you're saying that what we've changed to in the regional perspective, the 737-500, there are quite a few different 737s, and the 500 is only about one foot and seven inches wider wingspan than what we're already bringing in, and it's a specific 737. It's not any of the bigger ones, correct?

18:07 No, it's not. And I think, as Mr. Mueller and Mr. Kaler should point out, that the 737-500 they were looking at is an obsolete airplane. And please understand, when we look into the future, if Lee was, Mr. Hughes was here, he'd be able to tell you, who knows what airplanes we're really going to be looking at 20 years from now. So consider these, to a certain extent, placeholders.

18:29 And we'll see where the aviation industry takes us. But my question really belies to being clear that it's not one of the larger, because there's a big span of those. The second question I have is when you say requiring a longer runway for our regional flights to use planes to their capacity, what length are you, what edition are you talking about? We're envisioning a 1,200 foot extension to 1,200 feet. Well, reserving the right to ask more, I'm done.

19:00 Bill, are you confident that the 100-foot wingspan is, you know, the right placeholder for what people can guess that the RJs and the Papas to the Q400s are going to look like 20 years from now? Absolutely not.

19:26 Is it worth a study to figure out what we really should be doing? Aircraft 20 years to me is a problem. I'm not sure what it will be. I would say that, again, what we're talking is our bookends are the wingspan and the passenger loads. So that's, I think, a very important note and one that both commissioners bring up. While that's the model used, we're not exceeding 100 foot, whether it's a...

19:59 Planes in 20 years or a plane 10 years, the 100 feet, the limitations, you're calling them bookends, but the limitations are the wingspan of 100 feet and the number of seats of 124. And then, of course, all of the technical things we need to fly into this type of an airport, et cetera, et cetera. My sort of questions would be to the next slide, if you could go forward one more.

20:29 And I think I know this, but I want to ask it again. This slide's important because it's pointing out what the problems if we didn't change air service at all, correct? Like for today's service, these are problems that we have. And the purpose for this is in letting us know that the ALP narrative addresses some of our current issues as well as those future ones that we're describing.

21:01 Okay, we have, this is the public, any questions from the public, questions, comments or input on this section? Yeah, please. Steven Kalish, I'll just pose this as a total question since I have my answer for it, but I'd like the town to come up with an answer. The one item that really struck me on this presentation was the injuncted expansion proposal versus the current proposal, and it seems to me that any plan that proposes

21:32 So just as an example, we're noting that comment and as a subsequent follow-up to this,

22:02 We'll make sure that we've reviewed this and responded in our table. And we'll have attorney reviews so that you have not just words from us, but you'll have written documentation that addresses this particular issue. And both town legal and FAA legal will be looking at what is the appropriate document. Are there any other? Mr. Dawson. Dan Dawson, I'd just like to respond to Tom's question earlier about what the key issue was.

22:39 associated with the injunctive project. I know you've been around this a lot, but I think, Tom, the real issue related to growth-inducing impacts and both the FAA and the town's refusal to consider growth-inducing impacts in the environmental document. And that's the whole reason the state attorney general got involved and several other state attorney generals were concerned.

23:07 Was that the FAA's position was that airports respond to growth, airports do not induce growth, and all those other parties felt differently. I'd say that was pretty much the key issue there. Thank you. Okay, then, section two. Thank you, Mark. This section might seem dry to you, but it is my bread and butter.

23:43 How many minutes did we get? So I'm going to be very, very brief. The purpose of this is to explain why the town is actually proceeding with this kind of an effort. And basically this lives within the general plan context. And that is,

24:12 The town's overarching policy document. The general plan was adopted in 2007, and it establishes a vision and value statement and a host of elements. And one of the keys to the vision and value statement is becoming a premier year-round destination resort. A destination resort is something that we are not right now. As everybody knows, people drive up for a two-day or three-day weekend from the Southern California area.

24:40 And we are very focused on the economic aspect of increasing the shoulder season visitation and trying to improve our mid-week visitation. We know why people come here for recreational purposes as well as some people who actually live here. The general plan is very broad. It covers...

25:01 Virtually every category that we need to be concerned with and provides town staff and decision makers with the guidance to make those types of decisions that come before them. It speaks to sustainability and continuity of our relationship to the natural environment. Very, very important. A stable economy, exceptional standards for design, and a variety of transportation options.

25:27 We have a triple bottom line, which is a score card, a balance score card that we use to judge our decisions. Are we being fair to the natural environment, the economy, as well as community character and social values? We implement that evaluation in the projects that we conduct. The general plan has nine elements, ranging from economy to neighborhood districts to design to public health and safety.

25:55 The key elements that speak specifically to the airport is first in the economy element and it is very, very specific to increased visitor occupancy, midweek and shoulder seasons and a specific strategy statement focused on providing air service, additional amenities and those facilities that drive visitation. We have a specific policy that guides

26:23 The intent and goal, which is to reestablish year-round scheduled air service. So these are the types of programs that we specifically measure our actions and apply our staff work to. I won't read every one of these to you. The mobility plan is the circulation element. We have a draft mobility plan that will be coming to you at your next meeting, and it covers a little less...

26:47 Detailed, but it speaks specifically to the airport, improving transportation options so that air service is available and people are not just driving here, which segues into how people move within the town. We're trying to become much more of a feet-first environment where people are walking, biking, riding transit, and that filters through to the airport as well as land use decisions.

27:13 The land use element actually designates the airport as the airport land use. There's a zoning designation to the airport, which is also affected by a development agreement. But the key on the land use element relative to this conversation is about build-out. There's a very strong growth management value in this community. We have an urban growth boundary, but we also have...

27:41 A population at one time limitation. Our intent is to maintain the town's compact urban form, protect natural resources, and prevent sprawl. We, in the general plan, as you all know, had a fierce public discussion about what growth should look like, what should our character be, and what type of facilities and services can we provide, support, and mitigate. We used...

28:07 In the very last stages of the general plan, some various demographic and trends analysis to figure out what a real growth estimate should be. And our studies determined that 45,000 to 52,000 people at one time, which are both visitors and permanent population here on any particular day, that the 52,000 was our goal. The general plan allows a little bit more, but we are very focused on maintaining 52,000 people.

28:36 The Town Council directed that we develop implementation policies to monitor and enforce that. We have the people at one time policy, which effectively is our build-out model. We maintain a GIS-based parcel analysis of existing development, and when a project comes to us, we measure the density, the number of units, and then its relationship to maintaining that population at one time model. So it's a dynamic tool.

29:03 Many of the people in this room helped form that model. So every decision that comes before the Planning Commission is considering, land use decision, is considering payout, as well as project impact evaluation criteria, which is really monitoring the impacts of the people at one time. Vehicle miles traveled, water capacity, and so forth and so on.

29:30 This is a very dynamic tool that we apply in the decision-making process. And what we're really acknowledging is that growth in the community is essentially driven by our recreational economy, whether it's summer or winter visitation. That's why people generally come here as visitors, in addition to our existing population. More recently, of which you have all received a copy of, we have commissioned...

29:57 An economic forecast and revitalization strategies report. And this has built on that modeling and has confirmed to us that, you know, we will be very fortunate to achieve 52,000 as a maximum population. And it will require policy change. So this analysis has been market-based and built with even more details on...

30:20 Development scenarios of what's been approved, what might likely occur through infill and redevelopment. And I think everybody knows that there's not a lot of vacant land left here in the community. So the policy framework that we're working within is very well established, and we're certainly mindful of what drives growth and the impacts associated with growth here. So we're focused on that.

30:45 The perhaps last document that I'll talk about is the Destination Resort Community and Economic Development Strategy. That was put together in 2008, and it represents a three-year work program to implement the vision and goals of the general plan. And it's far more of how we, the town, and our stakeholders focus on achieving our vision.

31:10 There are three key goals in that document. Annually increase town visitation and occupancy rates, consistent with the general plan. Stabilize and strengthen our local businesses. And then annually increase our municipal revenues and their reliability. If that was important in 2008, it is even far more so now. What we acknowledge through this program, which is essentially our economic development plan,

31:35 Is that developing partnerships and leveraging resources is important. The town cannot do everything that the community would like to have happen. We have to work with other agencies. We have to work with the private sector. And that's the ethic that's embedded in the general plan that we deploy when we do work. This is essentially showing you that the community's general plan that was developed through an extensive community process.

32:04 It's very focused on air service as an important strategy in this. Certainly tourism is related to air service filling beds during midweek and shoulder season. It's directly related back to the mobility feet first concept. Commercial air service is another way to access the community, and it's certainly related to our own economic development activities. So there are a host of...

32:29 Goals, policies, and adopted actions by the Town Council that create the basis for us working on this and set limits to how it fits within the community. With that, I'll answer any meaty questions you might have. Mark, back to the points of contention of the EIS. In all the plans that you just mentioned, have we as a community addressed the growth-inducing impacts that the airport,

33:02 Potentially would create in town. Broad question. The general plan included the general plan environmental impact report. So the growth-inducing aspects of the community were analyzed there. That document was certified, and it is complete and done.

33:22 As with any new project, whether it's the airport or anything, we will always conduct an initial study, if you will, a checklist review to make sure that we know what the appropriate CEQA evaluation or NEPA evaluation is for any major action. For this ALP, we haven't necessarily done that yet, and we'll certainly follow federal and state law to do so. CEQA and NEPA,

33:52 We'll look at any project and we'll identify potential impacts, the direct impacts related to the project, and there may be indirect impacts that we identify as well. So for this draft ALP, we're not to that point, but we'll certainly follow law. The general plan was done, though. I think you just answered it, but I'll just be a little more specific and say so. It took into account the employments that we're talking about into the general plan, and it met.

34:26 You know, I'll have to go back and respond. I have to check actually the document because essentially what drives growth is not transportation access. It is fundamentally units. In fact, that's how the water district calculates water demand. We have some models where we have some estimate of people per room. Essentially, the common denominator is units.

34:55 And then the key drivers, what's driving is, for us, we do not have a strong office market. We do not have a strong commercial big box market. So for us, it's generally visitation. We take visitation and demographic trends and then associate those with units. And that's what's driving the impacts that lead to everything. Vehicle miles traveled, air quality impacts associated with not only travel, but...

35:24 Wood smoke and cinders, noise that's generated by events but also by traffic. So that becomes the key route in CEQA analysis for us. If we were able to identify some other impact associated with the use such as an airport, we would. But essentially people aren't coming here to fly down the plane. They're coming on the plane to go to the visitation and the...

35:53 Employment in the residential. Mark, you've got a general plan to key to on the town and things like that. How about the county? It's got more land, in some cases less than others. And both things, I think our airport has to fit the growth anticipated in the county.

36:26 Plus we have to analyze what the gross inducing impacts are going to be on the county and Crowley Lake and, you know, the adjacent communities. I think that's a valid point and I've just read some economic studies conducted for the county and essentially, I think most people know this, that the major economic driver and the major demographic driver in the county is the town.

36:55 And so we see relatively low growth. We don't expect Chalfont to grow into a major metropolis. We don't see a lot of growth in Mono City, et cetera, et cetera. We certainly look at the regional service area that we would be supporting through the airport. But by and large, the town is the major economic and demographic center of the county.

37:23 You know, I'm particularly concerned that since this is a 20-year plan, I'm not sure that's, you know, I think we've got to look at what the county is really proposing to be out 20 years from now. Absolutely. Are there any questions from the public for Mark in this presentation? Okay. We'll go to Section 3, the air service forecast. Mr. Irvin. Madam Chair, Commissioners, John Irvin, Place Tourism.

37:55 While I hope to be a little less dry than Mark, I'll counterbalance that with my monotone voice. We're going to talk air forecast here, and really what we want to talk about is how the forecast has been developed. We work very closely with Kent Myers out of Colorado from a company called Air Planners, and Kent's history is really working with small community air services around the West. In fact, he's worked with everyone in Colorado, all the small airports in Colorado, with the exception of Aspen.

38:26 Including Eagle Bale, Gunnison, which is Crested Butte, Steamboat, which is very comparable to where we are here in our trajectory in Virgo Beach, even on the east coast. Other input came from the mountain, of course, being a big player in this, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and then the staff here at the town in place. Factors that we went into when we're looking at the forecasting, the landmark I had mentioned, the general plan direction, and talking about from year-round resort,

38:59 And I think one of the things that we've been focused on from a Mammoth Lakes Tourism standpoint is really the shoulder seasons and looking at the sucking sound that we had in April and May and September and October. And I think for this year, if you look at the successes, we were up 45% in planements in April, had a lot to do with the fantastic ski season continuing. May was also up 18%, which we were pretty happy with. And then just coming out of September and October, both months are coming in 31% over last year.

39:27 Really focusing on the shoulder seasons and trying to get people to keep coming up, whether it's to fish, whether it's to hike. It appears that we're getting the results that we had hoped with the year-round resort focus. Also focusing on the destination resort strategy and obviously economic forecasts. When we're working on these forecasts, something that's 20 years out is very difficult to really factor. The economy, who knows what's going to happen tomorrow, let alone in 20 years.

39:52 I think that when you're looking at Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we are working on a three- to five-year plan. I know that Mammoth Mountain works on a ten-year master plan, and I think that trying to work anything past ten years is really a challenge. And so looking at the 20-year, it's difficult looking at economic forecasts. Really, our regional strategy that we've been focused on, we know that our business comes from California. We're focusing on California right now to make sure that we're capturing that.

40:21 There are a lot of folks in San Diego this winter that will come here versus hopping the flight to Salt Lake or to Denver that they've been doing for the last few years to avoid the seven-hour drive. So we recognize that as a huge opportunity market, and then we'll start to expand into other places like northwest or even branching out to the east of us to try and break into the east coast market and open up some of those opportunities. Airline partners.

40:45 United Airlines really came to the table because they saw the success that we had with Alaska Airlines. And in working with Kent from airplaneers, he was very surprised at how quickly United came to the table. But when they saw what Alaska was doing and they saw the opportunity, it brought that to the table. So we're hoping that that continues to perpetuate new business. Aircraft limitations, as Mr. Manning talked about, we're really focusing on the load capacity or the available seats from 66 to 124 seats per plane.

41:15 And then we look at other airports that are out there and what their growth patterns have been, where their locations are, where their nearest drive markets are, et cetera. And that helped us really figure out what we should be doing here. And then as I mentioned before, the performance of the current air service program. I think if you look even just this past winter, we had some great numbers come through. This summer, July and August, which are our biggest months, we're both up 45%. So the growth is there. The word is getting out that you can get to Mammoth Lakes via.

41:44 Again, when we talk about the long-range forecast, it needs to be fluid, and it needs to be re-forecasted as we move forward. Realistically, the FAA requires the 20-year forecast, so I think when we start to look at that, we looked at 16, excuse me, projected up to 16 winter flights, and this would bring us into new markets like we mentioned before, so as you know, we're in LAX, we're in San Jose, but we'd look back into the northwest, we'd look to

42:16 Our east, including Denver, Houston, Phoenix, and Las Vegas as opportunities. And it would be something that we would look at potentially even additional, like we did this winter, moving into two flights from San Francisco. So there might be multiple flights out of some of these markets based on demand and based on availability. In the summertime, with our access to Yosemite National Park, we have an opportunity to really ramp up to 11 summer flights daily.

42:46 And again, some of those potential markets are some that we're in currently, but also expanding out to our east to include Phoenix and Las Vegas. If you've been in Las Vegas in the summertime, a lot of reason to go to the mountains. It's going to be a mix of aircraft, and it's really, it's everything from the CRJ-700 that we're working with right now at 66 passengers, and really on the high end looking at 124 passenger plane, whatever that may be in the years ahead.

43:12 Again, shorter term, I think it's easier for us and more reliable to work off a 5-year and 10-year. The 20 years, as far as I'm concerned, is a FAA requirement. We've gone through the stages, but there are a lot of things that could change as we move there, so we keep an eye on that moving target. The 5-year and the 10-year, we're a lot more comfortable with the realistic numbers that are out there. We also assumed that we would see a 60% load factor year-round. That's a blended load factor.

43:40 So in the wintertime we could be at 85%, and there are certain months in the summertime we may be at 30%. So that 60% really is a blended factor for the year. To give a little bit of background, too, when we talk about available seats, available seats are the number of seats on the plane time, the number of flights that we have. So it's the total number of seats that come here. If they're full, they're full. If they're empty, they're empty. That's the potential capacity.

44:07 But when we talk about enclinements, it's really the number of seats times the load factor that we have there at 60%. So enclinements are really what we want to talk about because we're estimating an annualized percentage of 60%. So the 20-year forecast right now assumes it will grow to 148,692 enclinements. And that's based off of 247,000 available seats times 60% load. Again, that number could go up, could go down as far as load goes.

44:39 The bulk, obviously, again, if you look at the bottom there, the bulk will be winter seats, but summer we do anticipate with our opportunities with summer activities to grow as well. John, you know, just for the record to make sure everybody understands the 170 versus the 148, you might correct that. Correct. I think that in the ALP there was a number for in planements at 170.

45:03 That is a mistake number. So if you take the 247,820, multiply it by 60%, you're at the 148,692. So that's where that came into play. So it is a fluctuation, but the 148 is the number that we are working with. Just to reiterate some of these again, five-year, 10-year, and 20-year projections. As Mr. Manning mentioned, we're looking at the 25,000 employment mark for this season, this past year. Moving forward, looking at 35,000.

45:37 And then really looking at the year 2017 as a 91,000 enplanement. You know, right now, again, next slide will go into it a little bit more, but when I look at an airport like Steamboat Springs, Steamboat's running about 100,000 and 105,000 enplanements a year. And we're currently on about the same trajectory that they're on. So this puts us at 2017, still about, you know, 10,000 plus, maybe 15,000 shy of where they are currently. So we have a lot of opportunity there.

46:06 And then the projection is that in 2022, it levels out to 148 and will carry on through the immediate forecast that we have right now through 2028. And again, that's all based on a mix of passenger loads, but it's up to 124 seat planes. We have right now this, as I mentioned, the steamboat, it gives us fewer in planements forecast than most of our peer resorts that are out there right now that we have compared against whether it's Gunnison or it's steamboat or Neagledale.

46:40 So, you know, the terminal expansion is something that we know we need right now, and it really is less to do with the 20-year forecast. It's something that we need now. The building itself is fully scalable to add additional gates so that we can grow to these numbers. This is, hopefully you can see the differentiation in colors here. If you look on the far right, we are the round circles that show the current growth, and then it also gives us a future growth potential based on the forecast as we've been talking about.

47:13 So we're here now. We have the opportunity to follow here. This blue line, if you follow it back, is Yampa. So this is Steamboat. And as you can see, we're on a very similar path that both Steamboat and Vail started out with. Now, obviously, this is the Eagle Vail line here, the red squares. We don't anticipate to be getting up into the 270,000 and playing it marked with that. Eagle Vail last year.

47:41 I think they were just around 200,000. But if you look at the way the steamboat has grown, we do feel that that is a very attainable growth pattern. As we move forward in the future here too, in the next month we'll be forming the steering committee for the Eastern Sierra Air Alliance. When I came on board in tourism last year, the intent was that we would start to take over the direction of air subsidy and how we can get public partnerships involved.

48:15 The steering committee will consist of the bullet points up top here so that we can bring in community members, we can bring in commissions in town council, town staff, obviously Mammoth Lakes Tourism, the ski area, and then Mono County. Basically right now the steering committee is made up of all the folks that have skin in the game, whether it's through commission, whether it's through budget, or whether it's through influence. And so we're putting that together to look at...

48:41 Again, a lot of it is to look at the subsidy and how we can get the public involved so that everybody has a piece of the success that we can do here. And then also looking at flight routes, air service marketing, et cetera, where we should go next and why. And so we get input from outside sources as well. Questions? John, based on past discussions you and I have had, I appreciate the 148 number, 148,000. And actually, you know, the reality of it, I think that's a...

49:15 Personally speaking, I think that's a realistic number for total number of seats. Because I guess I don't buy the 60% number at all. Because we have to build towards 248,000 seats when we are saying we're only going to bring in 170. And to me, our future planning needs to really center around that number of employments.

49:37 And work towards that number of employments instead of working towards this larger number, which just puts us, I think, more and more in conflict with the whole growth-inducing issues that we've been challenged on before. You still feel pretty strong about the 248,000 number? The available seats? Available seats? Correct. Okay. I just wanted to say first thank you for comparing apples to apples with the airports.

50:09 And I concur with the 148 agreement and the appreciation of it. I know as a commissioner that we've talked and we don't have any specific statistics, but could you outline, because I'm planning on hoping this is a communication tool not only for us to use, but the community is going to see. What kind of local use, do you have a gut feel just as a person who...

50:29 Oversees a lot of the data. Right, right. And I am getting more and more data in. I've got the American Express information. It doesn't break it out by origination zip code. But, you know, my impression after being here for a year is that it's a stronger local use in the summertime than it is in the wintertime, but that we could be in the vicinity of 30 to 35%. We've been very, since meeting with the commission for the first time when I came on board last year, we have put a very strong push.

50:58 To making sure that the community knows what deals are out there and what availability is out there. We're even working with folks like LA Inc., which is my counterpart in Los Angeles. They have programs that we're working with them to say, hey, we've got preferred hotels that we can direct people to for these programs. So my goal, I honestly could care less which way they're flying, as long as they're flying. And if we can get folks to fly from here to LA or LA to here, it doesn't matter. So our goal is to keep the planes full, and I think we are seeing a lot of that right now. I think this time of year we do see a lot of our workers flying out.

51:28 And with continued research that we'll be doing at the airport in the coming year, we'll definitely get a much better feel for that. Thank you. I happen to think community use is an important factor to the airport. It's both ways. I love it. One of the things that is in our general plan is about how we're a destination resort. And as a regional airport, that helps the destinations get here with the regional jet plan. And I understand that. So what I want to ask is, do you have any...

51:56 What are you envisioning of other destinations over the course of this plan that we haven't talked about? As far as comparables? Or as far as where we might be headed? Well, you know, I think when we're looking at airports, I think the list that we have here are very strong. The one thing I will say is that what we're doing and what we're seeing with the additions of San Diego, where we had at San Francisco last year, is that it's really, it's opening up

52:20 It's opening up the nation for us to have access. So if somebody's flying United, they can come from Chicago to San Francisco and here fairly easily. But I was in London a few weeks ago, and the opportunity to talk to those folks, our challenge in the past, not only being domestically but internationally, has been access. And when I could tell somebody in London that I was flying out on Friday at 10.30 in the morning, I'd be here at 6.30 at night, it meant a lot. So, I mean, we're starting to branch out and open up.

52:46 Worldwide markets because of the access that we're opening through our regional airports. So we had Michael from my office was in Brazil last week. American Airlines flies to Sao Paulo to LA. And they're co-chair with Alaska Airlines. Hope to bring him right in. Great. So we're hitting a goal with that. And also with the Eastern Sierra Airlines. That's a question we're going to ask that group. Where do you think we should be going and why? And we'll do the research to say whether it works or not.

53:15 And then lastly, with the planned growth and with the temporary structure that's been approved that's going in that we spoke about, at what point are we absolutely stuck right now, because I know how crowded it is, but I just want some specifics. At what point is this the end of the growth this year? Is it adding another flight next year until we have to absolutely stop until we get to the...

53:40 The real future structure. Well, I think right now we're somewhat restricted by the eight flights in the winter and two flights in the summer, regardless of what we want to do or what we think we could do. I think the other challenge is, like, this year we've got a couple of United flights that are going to be on the ground within 15 minutes of each other, so if we have any backups, we're going to be pressed this year. But I think a lot of it has to do with how we can negotiate with the airlines on timing, because we could handle eight flights a day standing on their head if they all came every hour.

54:09 Right. But we don't have that sort of control. That's one of the challenges. So we're pretty much at this moment topped out with what we're approving in this front structure. So what I'm trying to do, any future growth, unless it's summer, of course. Yeah, and it depends on the schedules. And I think that obviously two flights in the summertime is not going to be a challenge at all. And as far as expanding summer flights, I think that's a focus moving forward. It's a challenge because we do have subsidy that we have to figure out. And then this may be for the panel, not you finally, but when we talk about the growth.

54:38 And the available seats versus the load factor, one of the issues for those seats not being filled may not just be purchased, it may also be runway length and the inability to fill a plane, correct? Yeah, we are, during the summertime, we are restricted because of heat, elevation, and winds, but I think we were at, Mr. Manning had worked with Alaska last year, I think our restriction last year was that we couldn't put more than 55 of the 76 seats on the plane. This year I think we're up to 63, so.

55:06 Changing some direction of takeoff and some of those other pieces and trying to move things later in the day. I think we were able to solve some of that. And going from 55 to 63, we gained a fair amount. We almost gained 10% of that. And our growth could possibly be more had we filled all the seats we could. I knew we returned. Correct. Correct. I mean, we are limited in that sense. So a full plane right now is not a full plane. I think right now that's all my questions. Thank you. Thank you.

55:37 Utilization to date, in other words, what is our load factor to date? Load factor, the summer right now, I think we're hovering around 52, 53 percent. Do you know what it averaged over the whole year? That I don't, because I don't know the winter number, but... So winter was about 65, and that's 120 days? 120 days, 124 seasons. So the summer's a longer season, 240 days plus.

56:09 In the summer, we've gained quite a bit this summer over last year. I think last year we were in the 30s and now we're, is that correct? 30 some odd. And so we're up over 50% now, which is fantastic. And again, I think some of the things that Commissioner Farrell brought up of load factor limitations in the summer probably hurt us. We were very successful this summer, too. I was just looking at the cancellation reports, and we went through August, which is our biggest month, without a cancellation. In September, we had one cancellation. It happened to be my flight that was connecting me to London.

56:38 But it was the one flight in September that we canceled. So we've really got a lot of those things solved as well. We've got a lot more flight time this year. Does anybody know what the basis that Kent used to come up with, you know, that he's going to increase from 35,000 to 90,000 in...

57:05 Five years. Five years. Yeah, that's a tremendous growth rate. I'd like to see, I don't know whether it'd be a workshop or a committee, just throw the number out and saying that seems reasonable. It doesn't seem reasonable to me. Well, I think that's where the RFQ for a, we'll call it a second opinion, comes in. But I think if you look even at this year's numbers versus next year's numbers, which we think are very feasible, it's a...

57:32 It's a jump from $25,000 to $35,000, which is a sizable jump. It's a 40% jump. So I think that we're looking at the compounded growth, and I think we're looking at new markets. I think we're looking at the successes that we've had, as well as some of the other airports in our competitive set. But I think there should be some kind of methodology behind this. How we came up with this. There is, and I think it goes back to the factors that we looked at here.

58:03 But it was not given in the document. In which document? In the ALP. The draft ALP. Okay. Where you just said, here it is. Okay. I guess, you know, sort of to follow up on that, I guess, you know, the 25, in fact, the document says it's 35,000 last year. So, you know, the document needs a lot of work. Right. And, but even if you, you know, if you achieve 35,000.

58:34 Next year. It's 40% growth. And you then fall back to a reasonable growth rate, sort of, you know, double the national economy or something like that. You're going to be at 70,000 about in 20 years. Well, that amounts more than enough to justify a new terminal. And I guess I, you know, it seems to me we're taking a pie-in-the-sky approach rather than

59:05 Analyzing the pluses and the minuses and coming up with an even-handed approach that then says, yeah, and this is expandable to hit the high number and we're not going to waste money by doing the low number. Well, I think where we went with the number here is that it is a middle number. It's not too conservative and it's not too aggressive and I think that's where these numbers came from. I've invited Kent to come to, he's going to be in town for the inaugural flights in December.

59:32 And we'd love to set up a meeting with you folks and we can sit down with them directly as well. I personally would like to see how they come up with 11 summer flights. Yep. Absolutely. So you mentioned briefly cancellations, just for a moment. And as a commissioner we've had a lot of feedback about...

1:00:02 Seemingly high. But in looking back at the numbers that we worked with the FAA on, on allowable weather issues and so on, it seemed, and maybe this is a panel question, it seemed like we were well within or below normal rates for cancels for wind and weather. We did have a pretty horrendous storm over the holiday season last year. But could somebody speak to that a little bit and maybe help me out with where we are in cancellations in the bigger picture?

1:00:32 I think, as John mentioned, our summer looked really good, and working with the airlines, we've done better and better, adjusting times, doing some of the other things have helped out. In the winter, we've done a lot of analysis on weather patterns and predicted cancellations. Last year was tough.

1:00:57 It was just tough and it was tough across the country. It's important to go back to the year before and we had four flights a day. We had six cancellations due to weather. Significant difference. So we'll see how the weather plays out this year. I tell you this, we have better weather than Colorado airports, better weather than most other mountain airports we have.

1:01:24 California winter weather. So if we can maintain that 6% of time of below minimums, we'll do quite well. Bill, can you speak to the changes that we made this year with the timing on the United flight because of the darkness? Absolutely. Speaking to United flights last year, we had a number of cancellations due to the fact that they were arriving.

1:01:55 After dark. There are a couple factors that go into that. One, pilots, brand new pilots flying into a mountain airport was tough for them. Number two, after they adapted, we still had issues because at night their company will not allow them to take off on runway 27. And there were a lot of times when the winds were out of 27.

1:02:22 And so those flights were canceled. So a lot of cancellations for United due to that wind factor. And that's why we've moved them, or the folks have moved them into the daylight hours. And that will allow them to take off on either runway, particularly into the wind on 2-7. And that will, should, we should see a significant improvement in their cancellation rate. Thanks, Bill. Thank you.

1:02:50 I'll have some comments, questions, and we'll ask the audience. Sorry, Deb. It's in for the next section. So, you know, I'm hearing a trend here. While I don't necessarily agree with Tom that the max seat should be the $148,000, I think there's a good question that John's bringing up and Tom, I think, has addressed in the past, which is better clarification and understanding when you talk to Kent on why 60%.

1:03:17 Don't need an answer today because I don't think we really know. There's industry averages out there. No airlines flies at 100%. Otherwise the airline industry wouldn't be in so much trouble and I don't think there'd be subsidies. So I think that that's the gap in my mind between Tom's employments and John's question of seats. So I'd love to have staff and figure out a way to address what that is and what it really is.

1:03:44 There's a lot that goes into that. Listening to you right now, wow, we're almost at 60% already. But then remember, we're adding seats. So therefore then your occupancies go down. I've worked with him years ago. I haven't seen him in a few years, but I know he does have a little bit of a model on that. The second kind of comment or question listening to everyone here is this understanding then of the

1:04:12 I think you used the word fluid, and I think that's a very important point. We're not projecting 20 years because we want to and because we really believe that. That's a good way to do business. It's because the FAA is requiring it. This might be a better question of you. They require a 20-year projection for their AOP, correct? That's absolutely correct. So there's a belief and an understanding in all of our processes that if we have to...

1:04:43 Somewhat gasp high in the sky because 20 years, no, I think any great business has a hard time projecting 20. I'd like to believe Mammoth does 10. I see some Mammoth people out there. To me, I think we do five months, or five minutes usually, but really five to 10 is more realistic. So it's really important that, to me, that we know that that will always be able to be revisited.

1:05:07 We say we're writing a 20-year plan, and that's our plan, and that we should have a lot of our concentration in the 5- to 10-year projections, which I think John was commenting about. And then that's, as we talk about the terminal, which is in the ALP, a little bit also separate from it, that we're really addressing those numbers, not the 20-year numbers when we talk about what we need built. Those are the two common things I think I hear here that we'd be great to address in sessions going forward.

1:05:35 I think when we talk about the low factors, I think one of the things to look at is if you look again, and I keep going back to Steamboat, but if you look at their schedule for this coming winter, they've got six daily flights, but then they've got six flights that are one day a week, two day a week, three day a week that they have that are on higher low days. We've got that coming in this winter with San Jose going to a four day a week flight and also Orange County going to four day a week. So there are some efficiencies that we may see as we go forward so that we're flying on the peak.

1:06:02 Load days versus us saying we're going to fly seven days a week with ten people on the first three days of the week and then 76 on the last four. So I think there are some of those efficiencies that we've also factored in here to get to those members. Great. Are there any public questions or comments? Owen? Mr. Malloy, excuse me. Hi, Owen Malloy, Mammoth Lakes. I have a lot of trouble with this pier resort.

1:06:32 Comparable airport business. Steamboat. It's Yampa Valley Regional Airport. It serves five counties of color. The total population of those five counties is 50,000. The Moffett County, County Seat, Craig is closer to the airport than steamboat is. So with a total population of 50,000 and a total enclaimants of 100,000, that's two enclaimants for residents.

1:07:07 Eagle County, the population of Eagle County itself last year was, or 2009 estimate was 53,000. The adjoining counties together with that have a total population of 80 counties. Now, okay, they have 201,000 here, there have been claimants last year, and by that, by the eight, you get 25,000 here. In other words, there's absolutely nothing in those estimates.

1:07:38 That justifies any number like 150,000 employees here. And in fact, in five years in the old plan that was enjoined, after five years they projected under 50,000. So I believe those estimates are faulty. And that the graph of the actual data, namely real data, real employees versus real population, during the slope of about three.

1:08:09 Per resident per year. If we have 10,000 people in this area that gives us 30,000, we'll play hell getting bigger than that. And that's what needs to be looked at by the consultants. But this business in comparable resorts is not successful. Thank you, Owen. Another direction, some question that maybe addresses his, and it's not to address it, but going forward, there was a question about local traffic, how much local traffic, what percent of local traffic?

1:08:38 Travels on ours now. What percent of the local traffic do we think would travel on ours in the future? Is there any data like that from the other airports that we're looking at? That, again, not to answer here. Well, I think the one piece that I would mention, even with a place like Steamboat, is that while we're looking at the residents, I look at Routte County and Mammoth County being about 50,000 or 46,000. I think the other piece that we need to look at is the transient.

1:09:08 Right now, if we're looking at winter traffic, which is higher for both of us, the steamboat end here, Mammoth Mountain is doing roughly 40% more visitation in the wintertime, you know, the 1.4 million range versus the 1 million range, so I think that does need to be a factor versus the... Which is, I think, the point here, the differences going forward in our employments when we get with Kent, why are our differences hiring visitors if they are? Again, this is me just making sure this gets going forward. If our employments determine...

1:09:38 Depend more on visitors and residents because we're doing 30% more or 40% more. People still want to be working like me for the mountain more than that, more in 20 years. So those are good points and good things we should consider in that group. There are places in agriculture and that's why it's different. Yeah. Okay. Which is a great point there. More rely on that. Any other comments? Stephen Kalish. Stephen Kalish. This is as much related to the next.

1:10:08 Section, however, it was brought up in this one, so I'd like to raise it. It's not a rhetorical question. I don't have the answer. In terms of the number of seats in summer, going from 55 to 63, I noticed in the Table 11-1 that there is provision for a throwaway, and I presume that that has something to do with the increase in the number of seats available.

1:10:37 A longer takeoff distance available. I suppose it could be people don't carry any baggage or you don't have any fuel on the plane, but I'm assuming you're expanding the runway for an increase in the number of seats in the summer. And my question is, the table says that there needs to be, that there are hazards in the clearways if you use clearways. And I'd like to know if that has been approved, if the takeoff distance available has been approved by the FAA.

1:11:07 Or if you're sending planes out there with known hazards without permission. Okay, so two comments. We will get to the table. I understand that we did address summit flights, so that's why it's coming up now. But again, we're not answering those questions. We're taking that as a comment and something that we need to look at. And did you take that as a comment, Jen? Or did you get enough of it, even though it was referring to a future slide, so that we make sure we have that as a comment?

1:11:38 Comments, last question that needs to be answered. Thank you. Heather? Thank you, Ms. Urdi. Great presentation. So there are two real parts to this ALP narrative. The one that drives all the projects in the future is the forecast. The other part of the ALP narrative are the technical portions. Mark's told me he'd buy me a beer if I could really explain B3 versus C3.

1:12:24 Probably not going out drinking tonight. Having said that, the two airport reference codes that we're dealing with here are airport reference code B3 and C3. B3 is a little more restrained than the C category. The reference codes relate to airport geometry, approach speeds of the aircraft, tail height, wingspan, those types of things.

1:12:55 Most of these technical issues are going to be looked at by our peer reviewers, so I'm certainly not going to go into any depth. Let me explain. I've given you a glossary of terms to help you as you go through the comments that folks have made. This glossary is based on direct quotes, generally speaking, from the FAA guidance. So existing constraints, guess what?

1:13:26 We're a mountain airport. It's just that simple, that density, altitude, wind, snow, ice, all those different kinds of things are issues that we have to deal with today as wind. There just, quite frankly, are very few perfect airports in the country. Almost all airports deviate from standards one way or another, and we certainly have our deviations standards. On the other hand,

1:13:54 We are an FAA certified class 1 airport and what that means is the airport is not going to certify an airport unless they deem it safe. We are inspected annually by the FAA and Caltrans Aeronautics for safety and compliance and we did win the 2010 Western Pacific Region Airport Safety Award. We're currently a B3 class airport but

1:14:25 The airplanes that we are currently flying in are C-3 airplanes. So that means that the airlines are getting a waiver to fly their C-3 class airplanes into a B-3 airport. So we do have existing modifications standards. We do have existing issues at the airport. And we'll take a quick look at those. Hard to read. I'm not going to really go into detail here. But basically,

1:14:57 These are the issues that we've identified as deviations of standards. I think Mr. Taylor says he has another three, four, four, seven to add on. We'll certainly take a look at those. These are the technical issues that we're looking at on the left-hand side. These are the geometries that currently exist at the airport and are existing. The B-3 standards.

1:15:27 That the FAA recommends, and you can see we don't meet, we certainly don't meet all the B-3 standards. And then as you go up to the higher classification of airport, we're looking at C-3 standards. And again, some of them are higher, some of them are the same. Some we meet, many of them we don't. And on the right-hand side is the proposed action that we would take, whether to request a modification to standards, which would be part of the ALP process.

1:15:58 Or projects that we could undertake reasonably to meet those standards or as close to those standards as we could. Chapter 5, the infamous Chapter 5 caused a lot of consternation. Chapter 5 was derived from a request from the Federal Aviation Administration to say if you're thinking about achieving a 3C3 status, what would it take to achieve that? What projects would it take to achieve those?

1:16:32 Those standards without any modification of the standards. Bill, that was a C-3 or a B-3? C-3. C-3. C-3. So we looked at six different alternatives and everything from moving the airport south to moving 395 to cutting down Doe Ridge and a number of others. None of those, from our opinion, are feasible due to the funding requirements. All of them are over $100 million to fund.

1:17:03 There's huge environmental impacts and a lot of land use issues that would be very difficult to tackle. So if we're going to move from B3 to C3, the final authority on that is certainly going to be the Federal Aviation Administration. What we're really doing with a C3 status versus a B3 status, and I think Commissioner Hughes put it very well and said, look, if we stay B3 and fly C3 airplanes,

1:17:39 The airlines are going to need a waiver for a modification. If we go to C3, it's going to make it, we're the ones that will have the waivers, and it's going to make it a lot easier for the airlines to operate out of Mammoth Airport. So, as we've discussed, we need a new terminal today. The forecast certainly demonstrates that we need a new terminal. We're looking at a 38,000 square foot building that is expandable. We're not trying to

1:18:11 I'm not trying to over-design it. It's not a 20-year building. It's probably an 8- to 10-year building. And we know that, along with that, by the way, of course, all the associated ramps, parking, roads, those types of things, the infrastructure that is required. And as we go forward with the AOP process, that will be followed by, at some point, a CEQA public process. We'll see what type of document that turns out to be.

1:18:44 And as we go beyond that document, it's funding and construction of a terminal. I really don't have any questions. I just want to, I guess, thank Steve, Mr. Kalish, for some of his comments from an exploratory explanation standpoint. I think I learned more from reading through your comments than I had from...

1:19:15 Being associated with the EA back in 2000. And I sincerely believe that those comments and your questions as to why it is we're doing what we're doing will form somewhat the framework behind what we do as far as moving forward. I think that provides us with a really good ground floor to work from.

1:19:47 Well said. I concur and thank you for all the public input. I said I concur and thank you for all the public input. It's really helped me a lot as well. And I have a couple of questions. So, Bill, first of all, all the current deviations that we are working around as our current status in flights, they're known to the FAA. Is that correct? That's right. So, right, we're in line with, okay, thank you. And the second thing is that

1:20:17 The draft that was submitted that was worst case whatever it was, it actually alluded to, am I incorrect in remembering it alluded to D, a D type airport? It did and it really shouldn't have but some of the... I just want to bring out that that's not any kind of...

1:20:43 Correct. That is not on our... No, absolutely not. Okay. So it's not there. It alluded to it, and anything with it was a mistake. Okay. And finally, in getting the C3 qualification and going through this process that we're doing, it really is just going to allow us to use the planes that are currently landing to their capability, among other things. Correct? Correct. I just wanted to make sure I understood it. Yeah, actually, I have a comment.

1:21:14 I have to say before we close, which is you're pie in the sky. I really, you know, I really listen to this, and I think I, one of the things that I'm hesitant, I want to make sure as a commissioner, in my view, that we don't do, is I don't want to over-guess or pie in the sky, but really I see a lot of towns saying, oh, we're going to build this as big as it could ever be, and then

1:21:37 Five years later, you're having to pay more, cost more, and reassess because things did grow rather than having a little growth room that maybe you never use or is comfort level. Highway 101 is a really great example. As I was a kid, it was never going to need to be any bigger. And so I think that as long as we're allowing for maybe it's not going to be exactly that, but there's room for comfort and it fits within our needs, I think that's something that we should look to. Tom?

1:22:06 Bill, not on the terminal, but on the field and some of the questions on it. How sensitive is it to the selection of the design aircraft? In other words, are some of the things that are in there, were they brought up to a higher level by selecting the 737-500?

1:22:35 Would you come to a day any different conclusions if you'd use the Q400 as the design aircraft? Well, I would say the Q400 is the design aircraft for the first 18 years. And we don't even, when we talk about design aircraft, it doesn't get any bigger until they have here. So from the airport's perspective, really the design limits are the runway-taxiway separation at this point.

1:23:05 Which, if you are to use runway-specific criteria, that allows us to use wingspans up to 100 feet. And I noticed in the document, it describes certain actions you would take to come closer to the criteria for a C-3 and certain ones you would ask for waivers on.

1:23:38 You didn't go into that today, and I think that's one of the things that needs to be a subject of discussion is, you know, if we're not going to meet all the standards, which ones are we going to, if we deemed, you know, important, and we're going to try to, you know, put in the new plan, and which ones are we just going to make do with and, you know, put, ask for waivers on?

1:24:08 And I think that has to then be justified, which ones we're doing. Absolutely. There are modifications to standards, not waivers. Absolutely. And I think that without getting into another two or three days of technical discussions, I think the peer review will take a really close look at that. I'll just check. You are a B3 now? Correct. Okay. But we don't...

1:24:41 Meet the B3 requirements 100%. Absolutely correct. But the FAA has not accepted our request for a deviation from standards. Where does that actually leave us? We have a number of deviations from standards that exist, but we wanted to make sure they acknowledge some of the others that had just been recognized.

1:25:10 When we submitted the document, I can't remember whether it was a year, two years, probably two years ago, they said, look, you're going to do anyway, let's wait until we will cross that bridge later. And so they returned the request. So I have a couple of comments. I mean, I know that we're saying the reality of this plan that we're looking at is the five to maybe ten years.

1:25:43 And then we'll adjust to the 20 going forward. I want to make sure I heard you right, and I really haven't studied aircraft type, but in these assumptions, the Q400 is the largest plane that has the most stringent standards to the C-3 for 18 years. There's not a difference. Did you say? I can't remember exactly which hour. Do you recall when we started looking at larger aircraft? What year? It's sooner than 18 years.

1:26:09 It's, it's, I think, I understand what you're saying, and it's, I just want to make sure that, that, that, on record, we get that corrected, because I'd hate to get, someone pull it out. 18 years, that means it's only two years of other aircraft time.

1:26:29 2014. Okay, I misspoken. As early as 2014. Okay. And whether or not that larger aircraft, there are some cases where the wingspan of the Q400, I understand that there's different, we don't need to get into all that, I just wanted to clarify that. The other is, to John's point, I think, or if not, my first, same question is,

1:26:54 The proposed actions for the difference between B3 and C3, those are really open. We're bringing in a third-party review. We have lots of comments from the public. And while currently you have some proposed actions, as they put it here,

1:27:12 Based on information we have, those are obviously able to be changed and moved with future input and with the third-party review. Absolutely. And please understand the effort. We'll see where the FAA's comments are. We anticipate comments from the FAA on their draft, I believe, this week. We'll see where they go. So the public, the FAA, all the governing bodies, the third-party review, just want to make sure that everyone understands that so that no one thinks we're taking these actions quite yet.

1:27:41 Are there any more questions? Great help to me. Thanks, Bill. Yeah, public. Mr. Malloy. Yes, Ellen Malloy again. I think, I don't think this is a good way to go about this, listing a bunch of requirements and saying which ones can we avoid. It's not good marketing. I mean, you're saying we've got a substandard airport, we can't afford to fix it.

1:28:13 That's not very good. I think what you need to do is get a modification or a master plan or expansion plan done by your consultants that tries to meet all the FAA standards. And yes, that will be drastic. And then you have to raise some money. It's a fundraising question, right? It's not a technical question for airport people, and it's not a – it's a money question. So you go to Starwood and say, okay, you guys are the experts.

1:28:42 Find us the money. You know, you want the service? Find us the money. So, in other words, if you take a more positive approach, you'll save a lot of trouble. I think you could go round and round in a circle, like in a whirlpool, deciding which little requirement you might ask the FAA to waive and they don't waive it. You never get done. Okay. Thank you for that. I appreciate it. I just would like to say, I didn't hear Bill call it a substandard airport. I think that would...

1:29:13 Raised the hair on his back, and then he called it an airport with limitations. So the same point is to... Well, yeah, but you see, that depends upon what the viewer sees. The person who is listening sees. Then what they see, maybe you don't see substandard, but somebody else might, and that's what you don't want. Yeah, I see. Stephen Kalish, I just have a quick couple comments. One is, I noticed that this slide 31 is in your packet today.

1:29:45 Table 11-1 is now the fourth version of 11-1 since July. It still says it was prepared in July of 2011. It's different than the one that you got last week in your agenda packet and staff report, and it's different than the one that I submitted my 11-page comment letter on Sunday. Specifically, I see that all the waivers have been now changed to modifications to standards, and there's a new triple of stars there at the bottom. I'm not sure if there's anything else.

1:30:15 The question I have, and I have not raised this question before, and I think it's really important, and that is right at the top of the table, I don't know how to go back, but right at the top of the table, it says ARC C-3 visibility not lower than three quarters mile. And right now, the airport is certified, I think it's for a mile and a quarter, or three miles visibility for a C-3 aircraft.

1:30:45 At some point, somebody made a decision on this draft ALP update to propose not more than three-quarter mile visibility, and that has repercussions. That's an upgrade that requires new standards for FAR 77 and transition zone separations, and it means that we're...

1:31:10 Doe Ridge might have been okay where it was for a mile and a quarter or three mile approach. It's no longer appropriate for a three quarter mile approach. And I'd like to know who made that decision to try to bring this up to three quarter mile and what would be the issues, the reduced number of issues, if you were leaving the approach standards the way they were now and trying to meet the standards for the current approach. Thank you.

1:31:39 I noticed Jen in the notes, you have why, which he asked, but he also wanted him to know who, if you would put that, who makes that determination. Thank you. My name is Dan Dawson. I work for the University of California, Santa Barbara. I'm the director of the Sierra Nevada Aquatic Research Laboratory, which, as you know, is across the highway from the airport. And we are the owners and operators of the Green Church, which appears in...

1:32:11 Item number 17 in your table. I think my first letter to the town of Mammoth Lakes concerning the eventual disposition of the Green Church was probably in about 1996 or 97. So we've been sort of hanging around and trying to wait for the town to figure out what's going to happen at the airport.

1:32:40 Not investing in the green church with the expectation that we're going to lose the use of it. So as you know, the church sits in the area designated as the runway protection zone. One of the uses that is explicitly not permitted is public assembly, which is the only thing we use it for. So we would like to sort of get on with this.

1:33:06 And what I'd like you as commissioners to do is help us do that. What's indicated there is either that we modify the standard or we relocate the use. I want to make sure you understand that relocate doesn't mean relocate the building. This tells you how long this issue has been on the table. When the village was proposed,

1:33:35 And the ski area was looking to move the travel lodge. You brought in three house movers to look at the travel lodge and have them consider moving the travel lodge. I took those same three house movers and drove them down to the church to do an assessment for me. And it was their consensus opinion that if we tried to move the green church, we would end up with a pile of unreinforced masonry block in 395.

1:34:03 So the church can't be relocated. The use has to be relocated. We'd like to do that as well. We're on the same page you guys are. And we'd like to get on with it. We actually have some opportunity right now to take whatever kind of settlement we can make with the town for loss of the use of the church and leverage that through some grant funding into a new facility on our main campus.

1:34:31 What's going to happen is we'll miss that, should we miss that window of opportunity and at some point in the not too distant future if we fail to get this modification of standard you'll tell us we can't use the church for public assembly anymore and then we'll be in a real stalemate because I'll have lost this chance to leverage those funds. So I guess I want to make

1:35:00 A couple of points. One, if you and your staff could help us identify funds that would allow the town to effectively buy us out, you could take over ownership of the church or you could just have us relocate our use, but we could negotiate a settlement and be done. Whether or not the building gets torn down and what we do with

1:35:28 With the physical site is a different issue, but at least we get the public assembly out of there. That might also give you the opportunity to make some other modifications to the site. You've got two power poles there that are an issue. Edison came out and cut three feet off the top of the power poles this year. And I stood out there. It made me really nervous to fly, to think if that little extra three feet of power pole was the difference between safety and not.

1:35:56 But we could underground those power lines. We could reduce the height of that one light standard. We could take down the trees so that we're not constantly topping them and deal with the issues off the end of the runway and do it cooperatively in a proactive manner so that this isn't one of your outstanding standards that you're in violation in the future. That would be really helpful for us. Thank you.

1:36:34 Public comments. That means Mark will get to see your note-taking expertise. It doesn't count, right? It has to do with that section. Okay. We have one more question on that section. Yeah. We didn't discuss at all the section on there on private aviation.

1:37:07 And I hope somebody in the public, I notice Pat's here, takes a good, you know, close look at that to make sure we're properly accommodating our local pilots and our visitors that come in with their own airplanes. Thank you. Thank you. Jen Daugherty, Community Development Director. In closing, we're just going to go over quickly some of the decision framework and the process for the draft AOP.

1:37:42 Update narrative. As you can see, we have a flow chart kind of showing how all these documents and agencies that we've discussed today, how they fit together and interact. The FAA, as you know, is the approval body for the ALP. We do consider the general plan and associated forecasts and economic strategies in developing the ALP and the forecast.

1:38:12 Other appropriate agencies including Mono County, Long Valley Fire Department and their regulations and standards throughout our process including the development of the airport capital improvement program and ultimately going through funding appropriation of funds and constructing projects. NEPA and CEQA, the federal and state required environmental review process are also considered

1:38:41 Throughout this process and during all projects on the airport property. Our next steps in this process are to continue to compile the comments on the draft ALP administrative. We are keeping a spreadsheet as well as a tracking list for all the comments. We will compile the ones that we received today as well.

1:39:09 Those will be sent on to our third-party peer review, especially for those technical comments to make sure that we have the expertise to address those. We're going to continue this process of having public outreach study sessions to make sure that the public is involved and aware of what's going on during this process. We will be receiving preliminary comments from the FAA on this draft document. And after this workshop, we will be...

1:39:38 Working with the Airport Commission Committee on finalizing the RFQ and RFP for that third-party consultant peer review. They'll be reviewing the draft, airport layout plan update narrative, all comments. That includes the aviation forecasts and questions that have been brought up today. We'll hold additional airport commission study sessions and workshops to present the results of that third-party review and any revisions to the draft ALP.

1:40:07 And then we will be bringing that revised draft back to the Airport Commission, to our Planning Commission, and to Town Council before we submit that revised version to the FAA for action. And in summary and in closing, just a reminder of the purpose and objectives of our meeting today. Just basically presenting the draft information and getting comments from the Commission and the public, starting off this process.

1:40:38 Hopefully being able to work together to revise and get a corrected and accurate document for the airport. Any questions? Jen, I don't know if this is a fair question for you and maybe for the group as a whole, but time frames, timeline, some sort of a, have we put together any kind of a projected timeline for this? We are hoping for issuing the RFQ as soon as possible.

1:41:06 We expect that that work will hopefully be done in February coming back to you so that we can have a revised airport layout plan update narrative to the FAA maybe in March. Does that seem reasonable? So our next step is we're going to reconcile these notes with your committee. I believe it's members Heller and Hughes. We'll issue the RFQ. We'll give them a reasonable period.

1:41:40 A reasonably short period of time to respond to when we can begin that work. And overall, we'd like to start wrapping up an ALP. I think our target timeline would be about March or so. But what's most important is that we've, through the RFQ process, and it sounds like an opportunity in December to have a special workshop again on perhaps the forecast.

1:42:09 So if we can start building this information and presenting it in a cogent way, avoiding document creep, so you won't see another table on deviations until we've got all of this done. We want to have one strikeout document, you know, a report addressing comments, start developing the strikeout document that you and the public can review and discuss and debate.

1:42:37 Go through a process of the meetings that Jen has described. So March is going to get to an end product in March. That's a lot of work, believe it or not. The meetings of this commission, so we're already looking at two meetings, forecast, review of the comments with our peer resort person, and then there's going to be a reconciliation meeting. And every time we meet, we're going to find some new thing to address.

1:43:07 And so January and February, you can expect to have some meetings on this. But the outside target for us right now is March. As you develop this, there's some decision points along the way that maybe you're saying they've been made already. I guess that, you know, the original draft uses the 737 as at least it states it as a designed aircraft. It may not have used it.

1:43:38 And now we've talked today that the Q400 is the design aircraft. I mean, is that a decision that you're going to proceed with in the writing? Let me continue. The other one is the C3 versus B3. Is that a decision that has been made and you're going to write the document that way or is it when you're going to wait until you get the feedback from the consultant?

1:44:06 And the same with the runway length. There's some key decisions you need to make before you come up with a draft, really, for review. And it seems to me those decisions need to be reviewed. Then you proceed with the final draft or the review draft. The we is you. So first, we hope to hold this workshop on the forecast. And we would like...

1:44:35 Your direction on what key points you think are valid and that we're using. The peer review person, we've got a host of questions. We've got a host of questions now and we're adding to them. And so you've asked for what are the key decision points that are driving the ALP and we'll be bringing that information back to you. And then you will be helping to frame what will then redraft.

1:45:01 The ALP. Staff is not going to redraft the ALP and come back with this baked cake and say, look what we baked. This whole process is to get to a revised draft with informative technical responses for you to weigh in on. FAA comments are helping us. They're saying, change this. What's this? And so that's now all going to work through the process. So the next pieces you see will be more information on the forecast.

1:45:30 The RFQ will go out and we'll get written report results and we expect to have that person come and speak to the airport commission and the public and we'll publish this information in advance of the meetings so we can do what we're doing now and offer the public an opportunity to review and comment as well. But you are right. There are key points and you need to be able to see what they are and understand the implications. Okay.

1:45:59 That brings up a question, and then I want to go back to what I really wanted to ask, which was, should we, does that mean we should, are going to agendize something to talk about those? Is that what we're, with the consultant or the third party coming to our next meeting, is that what's going on? Is that our specific next step? I think we need to get some details on when they're here and make sure that there's the ability to have a meeting. Okay, so I just wanted to say as we're closing out through this that

1:46:26 Stephen pointed out some changes to a document that hadn't been correctly changed, and I think it's a really big trust factor to have all of our T's crossed and our I's dotted, and I think I need to say, even for me, to trust the documents that I get, we've got to be really careful. I make a lot of mistakes, believe me, but just a careful eye is really good. This has been a good...

1:46:45 Learning experience for me and so has the information that's been shared from the public and understanding what's fact-based and how we move forward is important to me. I also think one of my key issues, as you know, has been communication to the public and I think this has been a good tool, I hope. And in our next meeting, I'd hope we'd also like to talk, I'd like to talk about how we expand on that and maybe brainstorm prior to and bring some ideas about how we can be better at that outreach.

1:47:12 And I would welcome any public input as to that, too, as we go through this and where we are with our steps so that it's kind of known. And then, well, I'll leave that till it because I know we're going to agenda some items, so I'll go from there. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. So I think that John's question, there's a point of clarification, but what was in the document, but also what we heard.

1:47:44 I heard Bill say that the larger airplane wasn't for 18 years. It was Q400, but then that was corrected. That actually was sooner. So it's not just the Q400. Those are very important points, you know, to your question, where are the points of clarification of all of the things that were discussed today that were cleared up today and then have to be decided of how we'll use them going forward. I'd really like to thank...

1:48:10 The staff for this very first step. There are, as Deb pointed out and everyone, ways for us to get more information, have the accuracy of the information, and then when we present it, you know, some things we won't know because there are going to be questions of how many local residents fly. That's just not something we would have. Some we should know, and we should answer those questions correctly just so that we're not

1:48:40 Creating more fog in an already pretty foggy sky here. But excellent flow, presentation. I really appreciate the public. Your comments are very, very valuable to us, as other commissioners have pointed out. And we'll continue to bring them in more. And for that section of it, I'd really like to begin to thank everyone.

1:49:07 Talk when we get down to the future agenda, maybe on next steps for this. As Mark pointed out, there's a couple of them are going to be timing. When Kate is actually here and what type of the session we could set up for that. When you think the peer could, or the third party consultant, we'll have a look. So with that, I'll close this section of the agenda and we'll go on to really any directors.

1:49:38 Any additional directorial report bill today? Very quickly, we continue on with this front structure. We've got the frames erected. We're putting on the outside membrane. We met last week with the ski area folks and Levy, which is their new folks who are doing their, I guess, Commissioner Murphy doing all your restaurant work at the ski area now.

1:50:09 They are, the Mammoth Scares hired them to take over all their food service. Food service. So, working closely with them. Also, we had a conference call today with United and Horizon. And we're working really through a lot of detail items from ground support equipment to where kiosks are going to go, a lot of IT kind of stuff. So that moves the pace and getting ready for December 15th. Questions?

1:50:38 Any questions on our director's report? Thank you very much. So as we talk about future agenda items, we had set some items for our November, I believe it's 22nd meeting, which is our next regular meeting. My question really to Mark is adding any of, well either, it doesn't, let me phrase this differently, we know that the employment,

1:51:08 Meeting with Kent. He's not here until December. There has to be some work on that, so that won't be on the November. Do you anticipate any of the other steps being ready for that agenda? I don't think so. I think what, so our direction was hold this meeting, take our notes, meet with the committee on the issuance of the RFQ, so we will do that separately, and we won't bring that back to the entire commission. And so your items, you've, Commissioner Perel, mentioned public.

1:51:38 Outreach discussion. So you could put that on your 20-second agenda. And then we have mobility plan, CIP, and car rental. Okay. And then we would poll you electronically to find out your availability and coordinate with Mr. Myers. Okay. And at that meeting then we'll set, we'll more than likely need a special meeting. And it sounds like at that meeting there'll be more information from staff on progress and we can then set it.

1:52:10 Some of the special things. Okay. For additional work session. If it were possible, could we get the consultants around the same time for that, or the third party, or the, you know, so we, for the special meeting. Yeah, that's why I think we would set that special meeting. Put them together. Hopefully. Chair, we can't hear. The question for the agenda was that when we had a special meeting, if it was possible, if it wasn't too soon, it might be for the third party review, but to have the employment and the third party review.

1:52:39 That's December. I don't know if that's too early for the peer. That's too early. Okay, that's what it sounds like. So we'll just have to have them meet. You guys don't like that, too. Any other questions on the future agenda, Tom? Mark, I think today's workshop was very fruitful, provided a lot of information. I'm sure there'll be some synopsis of this in the local press, but

1:53:07 What's the chances of the town being able to put together a fact sheet of just the highlights of what we talked about today and maybe anticipate doing the same thing for each one of these so that we can maybe generate some – keep public informed and generate some interest as part of the outreach? I think the answer is what's our possibility of 100 percent. So we'll take these notes and we'll –

1:53:36 Use it for the RFQ process, but we'll also put the RFQ and these notes on the website, and then we'll start working to get ahead. We work closely with the sheet and the times, and so we'll want to work to post messages, public service advisories to let them know to look, and we'll also include this in Stu's News and the extensive, we have an email network. So we're going to start getting ahead and putting this information out there for the public.

1:54:06 And then when we start holding these next commission sessions on this, you'll see more and more outreach, advising of special workshops and inviting the public. Okay, I think that we are set for our next meeting and we'll have a adjournment. Do you need a motion or make it? Thank you, Tom.

1:54:35 Thank you. Yeah, you can talk to two.