TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2012

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 4 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

260 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Oh, I see what you're talking about. Mine actually didn't even print that well. I can see this on the screen. It's got that. It's got that.

0:15 What this says, it says draft version. So it says draft version. So some of the letters are kind of, what do you call it, redacted. Yeah, yeah. But, I mean, fine margins. It was intended to be a public event. Well, in other places, it talks about it. But this is essentially, from what I can deline from it, this is what the council is recommending being put into a new agreement. It says, moreover, the consultant will have an opportunity to use

0:44 Thank you.

1:05 Thank you.

1:16 Thank you.

1:40 Thank you very much. Appreciate that. Thanks for your help. Yeah.

2:04 Oh, shoot. What do we do?

2:33 Thank you.

2:55 Thank you.

3:10 Thank you.

3:40 Thank you.

4:08 Thank you.

4:37 We're going to wait just a couple more minutes for John Eastman to get back. And are you expecting Newt to come? We'll give John a couple more minutes.

5:07 Thank you.

5:11 Thank you.

5:40 Thank you.

5:55 Thank you.

6:18 Thank you.

6:48 I know. Are you getting ready for a beer fest? I guess so. Your later hose. Yeah, from here it looks like you're wearing later hose. A nice light. So you're getting ready for a beer fest. The later hose. Huh? Yeah. The chicken dance. Terry will show you.

7:17 Thank you.

7:39 Thank you.

8:02 Yeah. Dave? Yeah.

8:32 Yeah, there was only a couple of pictures.

8:44 Okay, let's go ahead and get started and we'll just expect John to walk in momentarily.

9:08 This is a workshop with the Recreation Commission regarding Measure R, and I guess I'm going to turn it over to, are we starting with you, Jay? You certainly can. What I'm going to do is spend just a couple of minutes talking about the town's process in the Measure R application to bring everybody up to speed on what we've been working on and then discuss briefly a draft resolution that we've put together to kind of...

9:41 Formalize our relationship more closely with the Forest Service and the future projects with them. And then if there's any questions specifically about the document for our application, Stu's here and can answer that. He's the one that helped with that together. So first of all, I want to thank everyone for meeting tonight and being able to be here to talk about the process. I was the Parks and Rec Director many years ago when I worked for the town, and I didn't have the luxury then of having to measure our process to work with. It's just a wonderful...

10:10 Thank you.

10:37 Passed by the voters for parks, recreation, trails. It was really a broad brush of recreation activities, resources, and needs that were being met. But there really wasn't a focused plan for the dollars relative to what that vote was about. In both cities and communities, there's usually bond measures raised for very specific projects, community centers, trails, whatever they might be.

11:01 So this was pretty unique, and I think there was a great desire then to put together an application process to help focus those dollars and specific outcomes. So I think that worked out very well for the first couple of years. And then as time progresses, things get more sophisticated, visions and ideas become more clear. I think the MLTPA group came forward with a very clear vision of what they wanted to do with our trail system. They were a major part of the Measure R application process. John was there as well.

11:30 And I think the record commission embraced those ideas and concepts. And over the past couple of years, there's been quite a bit of work done really on the infrastructure, data infrastructure side of it. And I started to hear interest in a longer vision of how the trail system would be developed as I first started working here. And so as I looked at that, began talking to different people.

11:54 The ship had been launched in a direction that I felt it needed to be shifted a little bit. It didn't need to be reversed or changed direction. It just needed to be moved a little bit. The area that I thought it needed to be moved in is really more in the direction, more of a traditional system where funds are allocated at every year basis through a budget process. The council then typically would work with the commission on how to allocate those funds for certain projects and outcomes.

12:21 The commission does its work based upon that direction, comes back, and council will either adopt it, prove it, modify it, but ultimately it gets into a system that over time develops and builds those kinds of things that the council and the community desires. The problem with the Measure R process in my mind is that because it only went one year out at a time, it was hard for me.

12:43 As an administrator, to look at long-term capital project needs. And we're putting together a new CIP process that's approved by your plan, and I wanted to integrate that into a common language and a common process that follows our budgeting process. So in the meantime, MLTPA was putting together an application, and on behalf of the town, it was submitted. We didn't have much time because the depth and scope of the application needed to be really thoroughly reviewed.

13:11 And it turned out as we looked through it that there were a lot of things that we agreed with. There were some things that we thought we could do a little bit differently. So it wasn't necessarily a disagreement. It was just a different approach. And I talked about that just a few minutes ago. Let's maybe move this into a different form. So the application really had two parts. One was recognizing the valuable relationship we had with the Forest Service. And John Wentworth probably can speak to that more specifically. But he'd spent, and others had spent our council as well, a lot of time working with the Forest Service.

13:40 And John Riekenberg is here tonight as well looking at how can the town interface its trail system planning with the Forest Service and what kind of partnership can we forge on top of what already works to enhance our system based upon what the community's needs are and what the perceived outcomes should look like. So we realized that we needed to continue that process and work forward on some kind of a document. John had proposed the IDOA. I get confused.

14:10 I'm so much now into acronyms, John. I'm sorry, I can't remember what I'm talking about. You've got to catch up. You know, I think for me that was a, it was foreign to how we do our business, which is typically through ordinances, resolutions, those kinds of things. So what I, as I thought through this, and Commissioner Sauser and I spent a lot of time talking about it, it seemed like we wanted to continue the relationship, recognize the value of the Forest Service.

14:35 And move it into a more formalized basis and then separate out the funding side of things so that we could clearly work through how we would go forward with that. The council shortly ago just approved a trails committee process where the members of the commission, myself, Forest Service, we're recommending an additional person to serve on that committee to provide information and recommendations to the commission that will ultimately come back to the council. So now it kind of looks and feels.

15:03 Like other kinds of funding mechanisms we have where the council gives correction and priority, staff and commissions do the work, make the recommendations, it comes back to the council, is funded, and in this particular case becomes part of a larger CIP process. So annually then, the council will be reviewing the CIP process, they'll be talking to the commission about are these your priorities, working with that committee to reaffirm those things, and we have an ongoing system now to keep that momentum moving forward.

15:33 And whatever the funding recommendation is, or ultimately what the council approves, will be part of a budget. Right now we approve measure R and new dollars in the budget, but they're not allocated until the measure R process fulfills. What this would do is set aside some funds for measure R, whatever the council deems to be the appropriate amount, and I think there's going to be some recommendations coming through the commission for that. You would make those approvals or changes, whatever you felt was necessary or important.

15:59 Relative to your goals. That would be part of our next budget cycle and be part of the CIP. Every year that would happen. So I'm going to just kind of close now, but I wanted to let you know we've worked hard. I think this is an important funding source. Everyone's very concerned about it, making sure it's spent in the right way on the right projects. And we've coordinated with John Whitworth and his group. We've been working with the Forest Service. We've worked with the commissioners.

16:27 I worked with the council, and I think we're pretty close to that. So what I would like to do is hand out a draft resolution really for your review. We're not asking you to approve it. We're not asking you to do anything with it but take it and make comments. It's going to go to the commission, rec commission, tomorrow night. We're going to get their input on it, and we're willing to often, or willing and want to make modifications and changes to it to meet your needs and what you felt you should do. But we've also sent it to the Forest Service for their review. We'd like to have it.

16:56 In front of the Council on the February 1st meeting and then conclude that portion of this so that everyone recognizes and acknowledges our important relationship with the Forest Service and reformed some projects. And I think Rae later on tonight is going to report on some additional funding that we have received today on some trail planning. So this is a very big part of our workload and I think it's a very important part of it. So I'll take any questions that anybody might have.

17:24 Let's start. Questions from Council? Okay. Questions from Commission? Hopefully not. And, well, questions from the audience? Yes, but it's an important piece of paper, Dave. And that timeline will meet, the Forest Service needs to have it reviewed if we're considering it on February 1st? Yes. Okay. No problem. We've already reviewed in return times.

18:01 Great. So that was my presentation. Stu's here to work with you on the workshop on our application. And I'll just turn it over to him when you're ready for that. All right. So that's it. Well, it's the commission's workshop. But I would suggest that maybe the first thing to do is just to remind those of us who didn't spend all the hours in the meetings what you've done so far with the applications.

18:32 What your next steps are so we have the context. For this cycle, yeah. Just an overall of what you've done. Well, so far we've opened with our normal presentation meeting, allowing everybody who submitted to measure our application to come and give a small presentation, which we then can ask questions on, then further look at the applications and at our last meeting.

19:00 Had a robust discussion on the merits and any changes that have been made to any of the application. That includes the town application, which was altered significantly from the original format. And then tomorrow we are meeting and we will score and make our recommendations. Tonight's meeting is a little out of sync with the way we lined this up last year. Normally the workshop with the council to go over the application process is after we have scored.

19:28 And made our recommendations so we can explain to you how we got there so that everybody's coming up on the same page. At this point, from my perspective, if you have something specifically on any of the applications you would like to add aspects or input to put in without shading the way one way or the other, we'd be glad to hear it. Okay. I just kind of want to maybe go down the list

19:58 Okay. Before we do that, there was one thing that...

20:05 I noticed in reading them, and I wasn't sure if it was part of the evaluation checklist because it's been changed so many times, but the one piece that I would hope comes back to us is a clear listing of what gets completed on each of these because you have to read through. I know you guys have got to do all that detail, but, you know, on each one, what does it do?

20:30 Tight saying. On the application. Yeah. When you bring them back to us. That's normally why we have this workshop afterwards. Correct. Because we've made the decision on what piece of each application you'd like to fund, or whether it gets funded or not, and we bring you our reasoning so that you can understand, and the public can understand. That makes, it brings it out in the public's light for like a fourth time. Okay. And I think that when we're done, probably we'll still want to see if we can do that. Mm-hmm.

21:00 So you understand that particular thought process. Before we talk about any specific applications, while Dave made a great presentation, remember that these are all still applications. The measure R, the Recreation Commission hasn't made any specific recommendations on funding amounts or even if anything including that trail system is going to be funded. So we're trying to keep it open in mind as we can.

21:29 And would appreciate, you know, the same. Wait, before we go on to it, just let me keep, so are you saying that with this somewhat truncated schedule that your reasons for whatever you're recommending for funding would be part of the February 1st meeting as well as the actual. We should have another workshop for us to present our recommendations.

21:55 As we did last year. I think you can ask each commissioner. I personally feel that that method worked really well. There are some things that we're doing a little differently this year because we've changed some applications and we've got a trail system that we're altering and bringing forward. So any questions on any of that I think would be very appropriate for tonight. But funding recommendations I think need to wait until we finish our deliberations. Terry and then Skip.

22:23 Again, I was going to say the same thing. As far as our timeline goes, this is supposed to be on your agenda for when you guys are reviewing this funding on the first. So if you're doing another workshop where we're going over our suggestions on the first, I don't know if that timeline works very well for you guys. Do you need to then have time to go over those applications? Well, hmm. Because it would all be on the first, yeah.

22:51 Just as a summary of the discussion last week. We could do that. I mean, that would kind of bring Council up to speak as to over-considering, not considering. But we don't have problems. Yeah. Except we don't. We don't have consensus yet. I'm uncomfortable bringing forward how we're each thinking about it before we've gotten together with our score sheets and even score each application. Okay. So it is a process that's still in progress.

23:21 So I think I should apologize for the confusion. It may have been my fault. I thought that you were farther along when we were trying to move this thing fairly quickly to get into the Forest Service cycle. I think that's one of the questions that was asked for John. So we're still lining things up relative to the CIP process, the budget process, the Measure R process. All of these things are still out of sync, and I think I was pushing Stu to...

23:47 Get it moving as quickly as we can. And I think what happened is it sounds like we got ahead of ourselves. I needed to have a presentation for you relative to the resolution. So that was part of my goal. So if there's confusion for lack of direction, I think I should take responsibility. I think that if we're looking at speaking to the trail system application, that we could probably speak to that one.

24:11 In particular, since that's something that Dave brought up in resolutions coming just tomorrow. Because I think that we have had enough discussion on that, but we can probably go down and come up with a consensus on that, I believe. Okay, before you do that, Skip, you had some... Well, I guess I'm looking... I've seen some confused looks over here, and I was going to just ask...

24:33 And maybe it's kind of been answered, but was there some specific issue that you needed direction on or questions that you had of counsel or something else that you're trying to achieve tonight? Is there some goal? I think it's just informative to go over both the potential agreements with the Forest Service, which, as you all know, I view as hugely important and a big step forward from the way we've done business with them in the past.

24:58 And the changes that have been made to the applications, as you may have seen the applications in your packets already, I don't know. And why the changes were made and how we brought those forward. Specifically, we could speak to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System application tonight if you want. Okay, sounds like a good place to start. Sure. I'd like to say, Matthew, it sounds like you have a good idea if you have any questions specific with any of the projects that we might be able to answer or if we haven't passed.

25:29 Well, the only, I guess the first question I have is we have these eight items on here. And then we have the trails application, which isn't on here.

25:56 Is that included, let's say, as part of this Trails End Park Base 3, the 300,000? This is just a hypothetical right now. To go back to the start of the trail system application, there was an application prepared by someone working as a contractor for the town that is 300 and how many pages? 362 pages or something.

26:26 And there were questions about how the amounts were got to. Is this really where we need to be going? Has it been daylighted enough? Town staff did not have adequate time to go through that much. I took a lot of time to go through it myself and meet with John and to meet with Dave and a whole lot of other people, and I think we decided as a commission.

26:48 To ask that that application be altered, correct me if I'm wrong, guys, to ask that that application be altered as just an annual amount going to the trail system. Previously, we had come to you and got your blessings on starting the trails coordinating committee, which is going to be making the actual decisions on prioritizing all things trails and bringing projects forward that would then be funded out of this.

27:13 So in the original 300-page application, there is a whole lot of really good stuff in there. Right. And most of the lines are applicable to how we're going to be moving forward. Whether the funding amounts are right, whether the prioritizations are right, or whether who is going to be performing those tasks is spelled out in that way, will be determined and changed by the trails committee. Okay. So that application, you have a, I think it's got a nine on top of it.

27:43 On the backside of my draft resolution, I have the 2000 Measure R Fall application, which is basically the changed, what the ask is out of that trails application now versus the 300 page. We all got the 300 page on a disk. You may have that somewhere. Rather than printing out 300 and some pages. Because a lot of those pages included our own trails master plan.

28:10 Okay. I guess my confusion was just, you know, we've got the 12-5 ask right now. And then there's a $300,000 ask go in perpetuity starting July. July to line up with, as Dave said, to line up with the town's budget process. Okay. So then there would be an allocation. So the public's not confused. There would be an allocation of money if this application gets approved. Not there yet. Yep. There would be an allocation of money.

28:40 To the trails system. The trails committee would make recommendations on an annual or quarterly or whatever basis that is back to the rec commission who would forward that along to the council to approve the funding out of that bottom line. Okay. So I guess one of the questions for discussion is do we want to look into funding this in perpetuity or at least for a five-year minimum?

29:08 So you don't have to keep coming back to council. You have some latitude as far as going forward with the trail system. And I got to thinking about that a little bit, and I guess I see the pros and cons to it. Just one concern I have is, you know, we really take about half of the measure of our money, and it now disappears for any potential bonding in the future. And if something else comes up, a change, or if we don't want to do a segment now,

29:39 You know, that's kind of out of Council's hands all of a sudden. So there's an annual review, and it should spell it out in here. It was in the stuff that we put together last week, and I haven't read this particular page. Right. Where that award can be ratcheted up or down based on the needs of the system. I think we all agree the trade system is of a huge importance. It's not half a measure on money. It's about a third. It's a little less than a third.

30:08 So what would be the point of doing now as opposed to just bringing it before the budget cycle every year? Well, and that's actually, Matthew, what we're talking about here is having it be part of the budget cycle and not having to wait for an application process. We're talking about dealing with the way, and just because it's $300,000, that doesn't mean it couldn't be used for bonds as well. It's just saying that

30:37 Trails are important enough to the council and the community to give them an allocation for a period of time as part of our capital improvement projects. Okay, and I get that. And I guess the other problem or concern, rather, that I have is, you know, it's like a government entity. You know, if you say, here's a $300,000 allocation, you find a way to spend it. And I mean, I almost rather see...

31:06 What projects were planned for that year? Maybe it's only 280,000 or maybe, you know what I'm saying? I guess we're giving a latitude of up to 300,000. That's where the committee through the commission back to council says this year.

31:20 And I'll pick on it, Bill Taylor's favorite trail, because I don't want to use one of anybody's, if Bill Taylor's favorite trail is going to take a little bit less, then either you're doing something else as well, or if it's going to take a little bit more, that would be part of the annual discussion, but it would be an allocation outside of the application process. You know, Matthew, I think that's the job for the community to figure out what the priorities are for the community, and then kind of outline those priorities, and come up with a business plan that if we need to,

31:52 And so I think that's where the flexibility of the committee comes from. And whether the committee spends $300,000, we've allocated $300,000, how I look at measure R.

32:21 is there's $900,000 a year, of which Measure R is about recreation, but what really is underneath that recreation umbrella is parks and trails. So in my mind, we could spend as much as $450,000 a year in trail-related projects, and who knows what that really goes towards.

32:43 Is it going to go towards a grant? Is it going to go towards completing a trail? We're not really sure yet. I mean, that's where I think the committee has to sit down and prioritize those items, look for the low-hanging fruit, build some credibility with the Forest Service so they know that we are capable of doing what we're saying and then moving on from there. You know, like any business plan or any contract. Yep.

33:10 You know, all good intentions are five years. If it doesn't work, it doesn't work. If somehow there's a breach of contract on either side, then we deal with that at that time. But I think we need to start with the concept, make sure we all agree there, and then start beginning to prioritize and then allocate the funds to facilitate. Okay. If some of it's planning and some of it's...

33:38 So then I guess how do we how are we going to tie this with our CIP process? I mean is it if we're really prioritizing there too?

34:08 It does be as part of that business plan as well. In your CIP process, you're going to ask each commission to prioritize what is in their purview, the recreation commission. So in the recreation commission, we have parks and town infrastructure, and we have this trail system we're bringing on board. So the trails committee is going to prioritize all things trail and go through the same process we're going through with parks and mobility as with mobility. Right. And we're in the trails portion of that.

34:37 To the town of CIP, to inform the CIP, and then capital projects that are funded out of this $300,000 would come off of that CIP list. It would then fund those particular projects. But not allow staff or inside to just say this year this is going to, it creates an open procedure that the things get done so that the public can watch this and not feel like...

35:06 Something other than they are driving the process of trails and such. And in the application also, we state that there's a big project for trails. That a separate application can come forward for measure our funds for that project. Because $300,000 sounds like a lot, but when you look at the management and maintenance and everything else that goes along with that, it really isn't. This gives, I think, the Forest Service what they would be looking for. If they're going to enter into a use agreement with us.

35:34 Where we are taking over some trails that were theirs, they're going to want to know we have a long-term commitment to that and that we're going to back up what we're saying and accomplishes that as well. Bill, I don't know if you can see her, but Pat has her hand. I can't actually. This whole process has just kind of evolved and it's been proposed by a couple of the commissioners. We haven't really discussed it in its entirety.

36:03 I personally have some concerns with committing $1.5 million towards the trail system in the next five years. As important as I think it is the trails, and working with the Forest Service, I mean, that's monumental. I think that's wonderful. But in a way, it's almost a little bit of blind faith, even though there are safeguards in place being proposed.

36:31 So that projects come forward, but I don't see it any differently than any other project. I don't know why it can't come forward every year. Maybe the sequencing can be a little bit different. For example, any department in the town has to submit a budget every year. You don't just carte blanche give them X number of dollars. You know that you're probably going to commit some amount of money, but to...

36:59 As indicated in the proposal here, a minimum level of $300,000. And it also indicates very clearly that there could be other projects coming forward for measure our funds for the trails. I'm concerned that we just, as a commission, approved a park master plan that would be coming forward to council very soon. And there are a lot of projects in there that need some attention as well.

37:25 I guess I'm concerned that there's enough balance. So there's enough money that money can be allocated for trails, parks, and other elements of the department. And I think that kind of leads to my next question. It's just, I mean, looking at items one through eight here. So let's say that we decide we want to go down, you know, trails and park phase three completion, which is part one of

37:49 I just want to answer that question. Right.

38:17 Are, I mean, your parts and trail system, that's what the money is for, is to spend it. And I don't think this community self-imposed taxes on ourselves to have it sitting around in a bank account and go, we'll spend a little here, spend a little there. It's there to get projects done. You know, we have $600,000 set aside for the track. It's sitting in the bank waiting to be spent. We've allocated that money.

38:46 And some of the monies that have been pre-allocated, those coffers have been filled now, so that money will come available as well. No one's mentioned Measure U. We still don't know where that's going, and that's another $900 to $1 million a year, of which a third that technically should go towards recreation. So, you know, who's going to be give and taken in that respect as well? You know, is every year a third going to go to recreation and a third that?

39:15 Parks and Recreation. Parks and Recreation. Parks and Rec.

39:44 Okay. Yeah, you know, again, I guess I'm just trying to be devil's advocate here a little bit and just trying to answer some of the questions that just really aren't known. So, you know, what I was trying to get at was if we committed,

40:14 To some of these longer term projects, a commitment with the Forest Service, and let's say to this Phase 3 completion and so on, there's no money left for some of these other smaller projects. And that's what I was trying to get at. Or there may not be. Well, I think that's where you budget your funds. You know you have $900,000 a year, so now it's a matter of budgeting, keeping money for contingencies and amounts. You guys go through the same process every year.

40:40 Yeah. Okay. Well, thank you. I appreciate it. And I think that if you looked at this, you know, we actually had $773,000 to spend. And with the allocations that have been committed, we're coming down to the $355,000 at this point. So there are no more funds that have been committed at this point. So going forward, you aren't going to have anything else that's coming out of here.

41:10 Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm. Mm-hmm.

41:39 Another, what, $3, $4 million that, you know, you can make a commitment elsewhere. And so, you know, we have to put that into perspective. And to me, the groundwork that's been done, you know, Trails Master Plan that's been adopted, that this now puts that into place and starts moving it forward.

42:01 You know, we have a website that's being built. So that's going to be maintained and dealt with and finished each year because it's a huge component for our community as well as our visitors. And so that's one part of it. Then you have your capital projects. And then you also are going to have some administration. So, you know, $300,000 when you start looking at all those components.

42:24 Doesn't go that far. And just as we're looking in our meeting on a facilities prioritization process right now, this is the trails part of that. So whatever comes forward from this committee goes into that CIP process. And it can do a long time commitment, which is what we're looking to do with our facilities as well. We're looking to, instead of taking, you know, I never want to have it completely go away so that there's not something small that can come forward each year. So I think we need to look at that.

42:53 But we're looking at the facilities moving forward so we can have a long-range plan and maybe one year we don't find anything because we're saving that money for a larger project in another year or two years. And that's what we're going through right now. And this is the same part except for this is the trails portion as opposed to the facilities portion. Okay. Just had some questions. Thanks. Yeah. All right. Another question was what percentage of this money, $300,000, would actually go to construction elements of a project?

43:23 Shovel in the ground. And $300,000, I guess if you look at it annually, it's really not a lot of money to construct a trail. You know, there could be some sort of, not a guarantee, but some consideration that a majority of this money goes into the capital construction, design or construction. That's what the business plan is designed to do and identify.

43:51 How much are we going to use to plan? How much are you going to use to implement? And maybe there's some grants that are available and things like that that we have to use some funding to get those grants. You know, again, I mean, this is just still in a conceptual stage, and I think there's a lot more work that needs to be done. I don't think anybody's read the 380 pages completely and made notice to reevaluate and change things, but I think this...

44:20 Probably the first job of the committee is to come back to recreation with what are the priorities we're trying to complete this year and five years now. What is Mammoth Terraz system going to look like five years later? And before we can say we're going to spend a certain percentage of this money on capital projects each year, we have to go back. One of the things we do with Measure R now is at the start of every cycle.

44:48 We go back to all the applications that have been approved and funded and take out what the maintenance on that project is supposed to be for that next year. The trail system is no different. Remember, this isn't a brand new $1.5 million. We've been funding the trail system now for several years, and there are several things that are almost complete, like the website that Terry said and a whole lot of other things that are in that initial application.

45:16 They're going to need to be maintained so they're not lost. And we need to figure out what that maintenance end of this is before we can figure out and give the committee sideboards. I would be uncomfortable giving them sideboards that close before we can say we have this much to spend on capital. We need to figure out how much of that's going towards the immediate maintenance of what we've already built. That was actually another question I had, but that's all I have then. Any other comments?

45:44 I think that one of the things we've identified a long time ago was that we have always struggled finishing a project or getting things put together. And I see this as definitely a step in the right direction to begin to develop long-term planning and have something that really completes a project. Trails are definitely an important project within our community. And I think it also plays in...

46:11 With the fact of the partnerships that we need to form, I've been in enough Forest Service meetings to know that they like to know that the partnerships they form are able to fund and maintain and do projects in a way that will be a long-term project and not something that will change with each election cycle or each staff.

46:35 The change of staff or something of that nature. They need some kind of commitment. And I do think making this type of commitment helps us do that. I think Patricia makes a great point about shoveling the ground. What are we really getting? I mean, we've been – I'm hoping this summer we're going to see some signage go up that the people are going to – it's going to be obvious and we're going to begin to see the real shoveling the ground projects taking place and we'll see our money at work because I think that's what –

47:02 The community envisioned when they passed Measure R. They appreciate, understand the need to plan and to do all the administrative parts of it that create the partnerships. But what in the bottom line is they want to be on a new trail. They want to see new signs and they want to do it. The only part that I have some concern on and

47:27 ESTA, Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, recently had a situation where we hired a web designer. And we just, we hired, we thought we were going to have a web page and everything was going to go great and all, and then all of a sudden the web designer disappeared. And what we didn't realize is that what that web designer took with him was the right to the ESTA.com.

47:49 And we had no control over it, and we lost that website. Might still be a legal technicality there, but for the most part, we've lost that website because we didn't have ownership of the website. As I'm looking through some of these newer documents, and I'm not an attorney, so I can't really say that I understand all of it altogether, intellectual property, there's some issues in there about who owns what.

48:16 Thank you.

48:37 Let this slide by. Make sure that we have control over it, we own it, and we can use it in the way that we feel is best for the town of Mammoth Lake. So that's the one concern that I would look at in this to make sure that we have ownership, and it only comes out of the experience I just recently had with Estes. Measure R statement clearly in it, and it's in the application process, that it has to be used for town-owned or managed projects.

49:07 This talks like some of the work, there are some things, it sounds like, and I may be wrong, but it sounds like some of the things that are being done, and this could be owned by somebody else. It could be somebody else's property, and they might have control over who gets to use it. And while I think the people right now that are on MLTPA are solidly rooted in our community and are doing the best for our community, that may change someday. And somebody may decide that, hey, you know what, if you don't want to do things our way, then you don't get...

49:36 We're waiting for some response to the channel about intellectual property needs. MLTPA has invested about $5,000 in legal advice.

50:06 To help bring this whole partnership together, there's a lot of brain work, technical reasons to get those issues resolved. I appreciate you saying that from the Dias. We've invested in that. There are things in front of the town manager, the town staffs, for bringing these things together. It's critical to Forest Service as well. Thank you for pushing in that direction. Rick, do you have any comments? You know, there's... I do recognize, because I hear it out in the community, that in a competitive environment, that is...

50:34 More people seeking money in amounts that are greater than the amount of money that is available, we're going to have differences of views about how that money should be allocated and spent. But I think it's important to keep in mind that the priority, the project or the idea, because I think trails is more than just a project, it's a huge idea.

50:59 You know, floated to the top of the list of priorities. And there's a difference in my mind between planning a regional trail system and planning a pocket park, which means that you have to front load in the planning arena the money in order to do it correctly, or you're going to do it incorrectly, and you're going to do it again at some point in the future. And I think that we're very fortunate that we've got some

51:27 Broader view, long range thinkers looking at and involved in this trails project. It has become a priority. The track was a priority. We allocated a lot of money to that track. It was leveraged in the sense that we doubled our money, doubled the allocation, and it's going to become a reality, and that's a direct result of Measure Our Funds.

51:52 I see the same thing with respect to trails, even though I don't know yet specifically how the money is going to be spent, but I'm a firm believer in completing the planning process before... I resist the pressure, if you will, to simply put something in the ground for the sake of having something in the ground. It's important, and we need to show the community that we're building something.

52:17 I think we all recognize that, but we want to make sure that what we're building is being built in the right place and what we're building is the right thing to build. So there's a lot of structure that surrounds this. One last comment. Dave, you mentioned that you wanted to add a member of the committee, and one of the things I don't see on this list, and I just thought I'd raise it, is representatives of user groups. It's feeling like more of a

52:43 And I just wonder if we ought to think through who should...

53:12 Not who, but what should be on that committee in order to make it as broadly representative as possible.

53:21 John, do you have any comments? I don't have anything to add. Thank you, John. Well, then I will start on following up with that. I agree with you, Rick, that I think that the commission got a general approval of the committee already, but I think that at some point the scope of what that committee is going to do, how it's going to work and things, comes back, and at that point you figure out exactly who the members need to be. I also want to say that I...

53:51 Support this approach because we have to get into a strategic planning mode. We can't just open up the doors and say, okay, tell us what projects you want and not have any idea of where we are going to be in that five years and have some goals that we can reach because we can leverage the funds. And you know me, I'm always talking about, so how can I take one dollar of Measure R funds and find somebody else who's going to give me ten to match it?

54:17 So I think that we've got those opportunities when we do this planning. And I like the idea of moving this forward. I recognize how important it is to the Forest Service that we make such a commitment. And they are our partners. If you think about it, all of us, it's our public lands, but we're all out there recreating on stuff that's theirs as much as ours. And I think we need to really get that agreement in place.

54:45 And I have seen in the past, and I presume by having John and John here tonight, that there is a lot of commitment on the Forest Service side as well to get that in place and to show our support for it. Now, we've just about used up your whole hour, but go ahead. One more comment on the sixth person in the paperwork that I brought to the commission, which was slightly different from the fall application that you see here. I talked about the need for potentially that sixth person.

55:16 And that the committee could deal with that in terms of who was best suited for that. There has been some talk about waiting to bring this committee together for its first meeting until after the February meeting where it may or may not be. We've already ratified the committee. The importance of this committee, regardless of the funding coming forward for Measure R and regardless of whether we are or aren't going to add another person to it, is huge.

55:44 So what I'd like to ask is for consensus if I could that we get them no consensus. I can't ask for consensus. I think it is ultimately important that this committee starts meeting as immediately as possible to get their work underway.

56:08 So you're the candidate and I'm the super PAC? Or am I the candidate? Who's going to wear the tiara? I think that this is a new idea. It's getting out to the whole community at this point. I know we'll be talking about it more at the next meeting, especially the relationship with the Forest Service.

56:32 I think that you're right that at that point it might be after applications have been reviewed, accepted, whatever's been done with them, is it might be the time at that point to very quickly revisit what's going on. Now I recognize that for the coming year the Recreation Commission has two members on the facilities group that will be putting together the capital improvement plan and all of that, so I can't imagine that getting us to buckets is going to be that much different.

57:02 At the start, but I recognize that that committee would definitely need to be in place as soon as possible so that we can be doing things this summer, which is hopefully very far away after lots of feet of snow. Okay, any other comments? I'm going to thank you in advance for the work you're going to be doing tomorrow and over the next time as you're deliberating on all of these applications.

57:35 Okay, then I guess we'll take a two-minute break before we start the regular meeting. All right.

58:01 Thank you.

58:31 Thank you.

59:01 Do you need a copy of the record of what I'm handing the Council?

59:30 Thank you.

59:57 Thank you.

1:00:16 I mean, I guess the same thing comes with it. I mean, I'm going to fall away, not that way. It's just the ability to alter on an annual basis. And it's going to be reviewed by a committee, which is a public meeting. The commission is a public meeting, and the council is a public meeting. It's laid out for a certain amount of time to take staff out of it. It's going to be a lot of time to take staff out of it.

1:00:46 Would you please take them outside because I'm going to now call to order the regular meeting of Town Council of Mammoth Lakes for Wednesday, January 18, 2002. We'll begin with roll call, please, Jamie. Yes.

1:07:29 Here. Councilmember Wood. Here. Here. Here. I have asked our class winner in his marathon to lead the pledge tonight. If you'll please rise and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you, Rick.

1:08:02 We will now move to public comment on items that are not on tonight's agenda. Please come up to the dais and Linda. Good evening, council members. For the record, my name is Linda Roberts and I'm here in my capacity as the Mono County Elections Official. I wanted to just touch base with you briefly about the upcoming June election and let you know that Jamie and I have been in touch about some things that are associated with the town's part of the election.

1:08:30 I did receive your two resolutions and will get the consolidation request before the Board of Supervisors soon so that they can approve that request. I did want to mention that if any other issues come up that you will be needing to put on the ballot, the deadline to get the resolution to my office is March 9th. And I did write this in a memo to Jamie and I believe she's passed out a copy to Albin.

1:08:58 And then I did want to talk just briefly about the completion of the canvas and the certifying results and just let you know that per elections code that I will prepare a certified statement of the results of the election and submit it to the governing body within 28 days of the election. That deadline is July 3rd, but it typically, we work to get the canvas finished before the end of June.

1:09:26 I did want to point out that in doing some research in the Elections Code, there is a section that says the governing body shall declare the results of the election under its jurisdiction. As you know, past practice has been that we take the election before the Board of Supervisors to certify the election, and then we've been getting it to Jamie for your body. Well, the town issues are not under the jurisdiction of the county.

1:09:56 That election is certified. I will be getting a copy to Jamie so that it can come to you as soon as possible. So I did want to mention that there will be fewer issues on the ballot for this upcoming June election than for the June 2010. There will be fewer state offices, fewer county offices. So I really anticipate being able to move the certification forward. And unless we run into any major problems,

1:10:23 I believe we can have it certified before the end of June. So my plan is to stay in touch with Jamie during the process, or she can contact me to see how we're doing so that she can keep you posted. Do you have any questions? Thank you, Linda. Thank you. Good evening. I'm Rick Phelps of the High Sierra Energy Foundation, and it's my pleasure to tell you about the success of the Eastern Sierra Energy Initiative.

1:10:56 Last year, and to also introduce our partners from Southern California Edison, who will give you a flavor of what's ahead for 2012. First, I want to introduce Pamela Staden, who works with me, many of you know, and also we have four new board members in place, two of which are here, Don Zeleny and Robert Creasy. Robert Creasy is an architect focusing a lot on sustainable building, and Don Zeleny is a retired physicist and other things to make.

1:11:26 The number is far more complicated. But we're happy to have them there. And as you know, we've been continuing to be very active in our outreach to the community, our education projects. I just want to highlight one thing that we did last year working with Southern California Edison and their contractors, the Small Business Direct Install Program. To give you a flavor of this, in the town of Mammoth Lakes, within the borders,

1:11:53 There were nearly $300,000 in retrofits done at 234 businesses and resulting in annual savings that SCE reports of $545,000 kilowatt hours and a slight reduction in demand. That's worth at $0.15 a kilowatt hour, about $82,000 annually. That's an ongoing savings to small businesses in our town.

1:12:22 And to put our success in perspective with, since I know we like to, in town, think of ourselves at the top of the pile, of the 379 communities that participated with Southern California Edison, we ranked number five with 98% capture rate and a significant number of businesses. The only ones ahead of us had like three or four businesses each.

1:12:47 And that was all through a team effort of ourselves, the contractors, the support of the elected officials and staff. And we're certainly very proud of it. Southern California Edison, I want to introduce our project manager, Jesse Langley, who will give you an update on some things ahead for the coming year. And then we'll be out of here under five minutes. Thank you very much. Good evening, Mayor, Councilmembers.

1:13:17 My name is Jesse Langley, and as Rick mentioned, I work for Southern California Edison, and I lead our sustainability and strategic plan activities as they relate to over 100 different local governments in California. But I also have the pleasure to be the program manager for the Eastern Sierra Energy Initiative, so it's a great pleasure to be up here and be able to provide this. And I first want to congratulate the community and your leadership.

1:13:41 On that capture rate that Rick mentioned of 98%. That's phenomenal. That's awesome to have that large of a capture rate. And that means several things, that the community is actively engaged in energy efficiency and they understand the benefits of it. It also shows that the small businesses are able to embrace the opportunity in a time when...

1:14:04 The economics are looking for any number that they can save and the 80-some thousand dollars that will be saved annually by small businesses as a direct reflection of that. And finally, it demonstrates the energy efficiency culture that is here in the town. It's really, you know, tried and true with the backbone of the small business has seen that as it's prevalent throughout the community.

1:14:28 But in 2012, I do challenge the local government to do more strategic plan activities that are policy development and plan development for energy. And I understand there's a Sustainable Communities Plan grant that's being proposed. I encourage that because it's through those efforts that you really embed and institutionalize energy efficiency for the local government. And it speaks to what the community has already proven and their voice with energy efficiency. And to be able to document that in plans and policies for...

1:14:57 For the future is phenomenal. Also encourage continuing to implement energy efficiency opportunities in your municipal facilities because it's through those that you'll be able to realize continued economic conflict and also reduce your carbon footprint. So again, I want to thank you for your leadership and I thank the community for their level of engagement and participation in this program and future ones. Thank you, Jesse. Question? Well, if I could, I just want to thank

1:15:25 Hi, Sierra Energy, NSCE, for the programs they bring to the Town of Mammoth Lakes. I was able to take part in their small business program, and I can state for a fact that my energy bill has gone down between 20 and 25 percent thanks to the efforts that they have made. And with the cost of electricity up here, that is substantial. So it works, and I encourage everybody to take part in it and work with them to bring their businesses up to code. It's a good deal.

1:15:55 Is there anyone else wishing to speak? Good evening. My name is Lee Gosh. The first thing I'd like to do is I would like to really thank Todd Murphy, the maintenance manager in town here. He's an excellent person that you guys have working for you. In Sierra Valley Sites, we have quite a few issues out there. The signs are busted down. Stop signs are broken. Speed signs are broken. Stakes are bent over.

1:16:31 Todd's right on it. You give him a call and he's right there and he fixes it. Todd, thank you very much. And I went to a supervisor meeting yesterday and I don't know if you guys are aware of this because I've talked to some people in the town offices and they weren't aware of it. The county announced Tuesday, last Tuesday, fighting trash in Mammoth residential areas is a battle it wants to take on even if it has to take a loss doing so. This was in the Mammoth Times on June 6th to the 12th.

1:17:01 What they're going to do is they're going to waive the fees for the roll-offs. The town has to get together with them, and they have to talk to Matt Carter. You need to talk to him. And what they're going to do is they're going to waive the fees for the roll-offs, only on specific days, though. It's not like you can't have a roll-off there and say, go dump your trash, you know, for, like, trash or for couches and refrigerators and everything. So what they're going to do is it has to be an organized-based day for, like, a work day, a clean-up day, a community day or something.

1:17:31 Thank you. Okay.

1:18:02 Is there anyone else who'd like to speak in public comment? All right. Then we'll move on to councilmember reports. John? Madam Mayor, I didn't have anything to report. I wanted to add, if it was appropriate, tonight, council discussion and possible direction on the proposed, some might say imminent, absorption of local gas company by Amerigas.

1:18:34 So you want an addition to the agenda? If I could. And do we have any statement we have to read on that? The council can add something to the agenda on a vote, two-thirds vote of the council, if it's something where there's a need to take immediate action and it came to the attention of the council after the agenda was posted. So if you believe there's a need to take immediate action, if you've only just become aware of it, then the council can...

1:19:02 Make a motion to put this on the agenda, then you can discuss it. Yeah, it's come to my attention, and it's also come to my attention that it's scheduled to go forward possibly as early as this Friday, a couple of days from now. Okay, so is that a motion under emergency services to add a policy item? So moved. Do we have a second? I'll second it. Do we need a roll call or just a... You can do it either way.

1:19:32 Okay. Wait, Jamie's typing furiously. Roll call vote, please. Councilmember Reeson? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Bayer Fortson-Laymond? Yes. Bayer Bacon? Yes. Pass is 5-0, so it'll be policy item number one. Okay. Skip. Any councilmember reports? I have nothing to report. Okay. Rick? I attended the monthly Mammoth Lakes Housing Meeting.

1:19:58 And just an update of the report that I had given. The Mammoth Lakes Housing has consolidated its offices from two into one as a result of budget cuts. And it is unfortunate, but it is making do with what it has. And just simply thought I would let you know that.

1:20:25 I also had the privilege of attending as a spectator the United States Marathon Olympic Time Trials which were held in Houston, Texas. The whole contingent of Mammoth runners, elite runners, competed in the men's and women's marathon and we were fortunate enough again to have one of our own going to the 2012.

1:20:50 As many of you know, an impromptu and informal welcome home celebration was put on for him yesterday at the village at 5 o'clock. One thing I can tell you, and I know that this has been long in process, 10 years I think we've been.

1:21:17 Supporting financially and in other ways the development of distance running. Dina Castor, who finished sixth and did not make the team this year, and Meb Kowleski may together single-handedly be responsible for the resurgence in distance running in the United States over the last decade. And we have them and call them our own.

1:21:45 They are, there were 250,000 people estimated watching those time trials. I didn't count them, but the crowds were big. And, you know, it's simply remarkable how many people know and are supportive of those two individuals in particular. And we had a number of other Mammoth individuals as well who were running and did well, including Amy Hastings, who finished fourth.

1:22:14 On the women's side and may yet as an alternate have a chance at the Olympics if one of the qualifiers decides to compete in another event. So, you know, what we're doing at really a tiny little cost is pretty extraordinary. And what I gather from speaking with an individual who's connected to the Olympic coaching staff

1:22:44 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:23:00 I see really great things as yet one other activity that will bring people here to the eastern Sierra. My congratulations to all of the runners. It was pretty exciting. Last but not least, John Urdi, who had never seen a big race before, a major event, certainly never seen the Olympic trials before, was visibly emotionally overwhelmed by it. It's an extraordinary energy.

1:23:28 He said, you know, I get it. I get what this is about. Not that he didn't get it before, but to be there was pretty special for him, and it was just a delight to see. That's all I have. Thanks. Thank you, Rick. Matthew. Thank you. I was going to actually talk on that as well, but I don't think I could have done as well a job as Rick did. And I think another performance that probably should be noted about that is Council Member Wood also attended.

1:23:56 This is a marathon, and what I found to be just remarkable was that Rick in his category, what was it, about 175 people in your category, Rick finished number one, and I think having another council member there representing us as well and doing as well as he did really showed some leadership.

1:24:21 I was very impressed by it, Rick. Your time was phenomenal as well. Was it 7.13? 7.13 pace, 3.09, 35 result, yeah. I couldn't run one mile that fast, so I'm impressed. And the other things I wanted to bring up, and maybe for discussion at the next council meeting, is this, we've brought it up before, and some other people have approached me on it, and we've had a number of discussions, but this idea of,

1:24:51 Potentially bringing the 4th of July to Mammoth. And I think with some of the budget cuts and other things happening out there and the desire to try to really keep some folks in town and even put our marketing department to work and even drive folks here for a number of different types of events, I would like to agendatize that for the next meeting and see if there's any interest in council in having this discussion.

1:25:20 Just because it's come up a couple of times. And I think there's been some great ideas flown around out there and some solutions to fireworks situations and things like that that I think as it starts to evolve, we'd like to share. And it would be something that if we decide to move that direction, we'd have to do it quickly because obviously something as big as what would need to be planned here would take some time. So I just want to know if the council would be okay with that.

1:25:49 And then another thing I would like to possibly bring up later, with this evolution of the TOT and some of the enforcement efforts, one thing that got brought up was the possibility of the town maybe writing a letter to Senator Gaines and even the state level to see if we can get some help at the state level to try to pass a law or a bill, have our senator do that, to help us help ourselves.

1:26:18 And I think it's a type of a bill that we'd like to push forward that I think all senators and congressmen would probably be on board with because it would help solve their budget solutions because so much of our economy is tourist-based. So another item that may come forward at the next council meeting. And then finally, and I think Dave can probably address this a little better than I, but I know there was an issue at the airport.

1:26:49 With regard to some of the pumps out there, and I was going to let Dave address that when he gets to his comments. That's all I have. Joe, can I jump in real quick? I just had two items that I wanted to mention. First of all, I wanted to publicly thank the National Park Service for their efforts in reopening and keeping Talga Pass Road open. I don't know what it's been, several weeks.

1:27:18 But it just created a wonderful opportunity for myself and many others in our community and our visitors to use the park over the last several weeks for a variety of adventures. So really great, great stuff. I also wanted to publicly thank Rusty Gregory and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area for their snowmaking efforts in having a skiable mountain over the holidays and up to date until now.

1:27:48 Everybody's tremendous hit on the community, people not being able to ski on snow like they expected, but at least the ski area was open and provided the opportunity for those people who wanted to ski and snowboard on the mountain. So great effort by the mountain. Thank you, Rusty, and appreciate all your efforts on keeping the mountain open.

1:28:12 Okay, I have one item to report on that came up since Matthew and I attended the local transportation commission meeting a week ago Monday. John Armstrong, who is the town representative, one of the three of us, has tendered his resignation. So I'd first like to thank John publicly for the hard work he's done in the time he's represented this council and our town on that commission. And I also want to remind...

1:28:39 Council Members that we will then have to deal with that vacancy in some way over the next few weeks. And does anyone else have additions to the agenda? Should we just have John's? Okay, then we'll move on to commission updates. Do we have any commission updates? Sandy Hogan, Chair of the Mobility Commission. And I wanted to give a quick, well, I'll pass out the handle, but a quick report on our meeting yesterday on the transit workshop.

1:29:16 Basically, the main thing I want to go over is some of the updates that came out because it's a lot of good stuff that's happening in transit. John Helm and Bill Manning and Brian Picken updated us on a number of things. One important thing is our ridership continues to go up across the board, 15%. And actually, the purple and gray lines, which were now the old midtown and

1:29:44 And Old Mammoth Roots are, we're now referring to them by colors, but those especially have been up. And John noted that one morning he was here and rode the, I believe it was the Gray Line Inn from the Old Mammoth lift, and it was standing room only, which is really something. Also he talked a bit about the Ritz Meadow this next year. There will be 11 new buses.

1:30:10 And actually, there's going to be a 12th, I guess, coming. You'll hear from Ray probably, but I don't know if it'll be here this year. But 11 new buses now being constructed. One of them has actually gotten to the point of being painted in the construction, and they're going to be here early, probably by late March. Actually, they weren't due until May, but they're going to be here. And as a part of that, ESTA and Mammoth are...

1:30:35 Discussing how to consolidate and have ESTA be the operator for Mammoth Mountain in the future using, with the help of those 11, now 12, new buses. Mammoth is also, Mammoth Mountain this year, and its winter roots has been experimenting and it's going well with a timed system, a scheduled system, so that its riders are going to know when the buses arrive, and it's going well. For a long time they really weren't thrilled about that, but that's going well also.

1:31:04 And also, the one thing that's been happening is ESTA, on its crest route and also on the Mammoth Express, has been experimenting with the, it has in place, the next bus system, so a person with a smartphone or numbers of transponders on the buses and people can check when these buses are coming with a phone call, with a smartphone, and someday, of course, even with, we'll have actually readouts at certain stops.

1:31:32 So those are the initial steps, and he's hoping in the next year or so all the new buses come equipped with these transponders, so maybe some of those will start being put on that system. And then they're developing and reviewing right now an MOU between the Town of Mammoth Lakes, ESTA, Mammoth Mountain, and the Forest Service concerning the whole relationship.

1:31:56 Because, of course, the buses are a result of the Forest Service application supported by the Park Service, supported by ESTA, and supported by the town. Federal funds purchase those buses and we'll be getting another one. And then there will have some contract changes also. Because ESTA will have so many buses, the old impound lot next to our present transportation building will be taken care of this summer, I believe using Prop B funds.

1:32:23 Transportation funds to pave it so that we have actually space to store the buses. So anyway, just a little briefing. It's really fun to hear good things going on with our transit. And I'm going to just give you this. It's just our outline. We maintain a wish list also, but it kind of gives you an idea of how the workshop went. Any questions? Sandy, real quick. Yeah. You mentioned Red Smetal Route for this upcoming summer and the new buses. Do we have any, has anybody heard?

1:32:52 If the National Park Service has been able to clear any of the trees. Well, the Park Service, one, it's the Forest Service, and I've heard it's pretty bad. Well, the trees that are down, there are thousands of them down. But, I mean, has there been any effort with the good weather we've had to clear any of those trees? I don't know. You know what? We should have probably asked it. Probably should have asked John Riegel to do that. I don't know if a contract's been let to clear those, but there are a lot of them.

1:33:21 There is a fear that it could be a late opening because of that if they don't get in or if we get too much snow. That's why I was curious if they took advantage of that. I forgot to ask him when he was here. I should have. Good question. Matt? Good question, Sina. Yeah. I walk past the village on Minaret quite a bit, and I notice at the one bus stop there at the stairs at the base of the village, there's always a ton of people there. It's got to be our busiest bus stop. And I'm wondering,

1:33:48 Only because I've heard it a couple times. Has there ever been any discussion on putting an enclosure there and getting people off the sidewalk? Because a lot of people have to walk out in the road to go around and up the stairs. And I was just curious if there's ever been a discussion on that because I see it a lot. There's a lot of people there. And especially when the bus is there, you just can't get by them. And then people tend to stand all over the sidewalk. And I don't know if that's something maybe mobility.

1:34:15 Thank you, Sandy.

1:34:42 And sorry you had to miss yesterday's celebration for your commission meeting. Do we have any other commissions with updates? Seeing none, we will move on to department reports and emerging issues. Good evening, Council. I know I've been before you before and touted the ability of your staff to apply for and receive grants, and I...

1:35:15 I'm proud and actually pretty thrilled to announce that about six months ago staff applied for two grants to the Paul S. Sarbanes Transit and Parks Discretionary Program. Just received word before this meeting that we were awarded those two grants. One of them is for $1,245,000 and the second is $153,000. The first one relates to the Lakes Basin Intermodal Transportation.

1:35:44 And this actually came out of the labs process that we've been working on. The grant, it's sponsored by the Indian National Forest, and what it's going to provide us is a third trolley to serve the Lakes Basin, a bike trailer that goes with it, additional transit shelters, and the construction of the path between Poconoby and Lake Mary Loop, where it goes back up to George.

1:36:14 Pretty exciting news. And then the other application that we were awarded relates to the Lake Mary Loop alternatives analysis. One of the things that we considered, again, with the LAPS project was the idea of one-waying the Lake Mary Loop. This grant will actually allow us to study that, the feasibility, potential impacts of one-waying that loop.

1:36:41 With a mixture of pedestrian vehicle traffic bikes and so forth. And also the idea of if we were to one-way it, we could potentially use part of that pavement as a path. And it may also meander off that main route in certain locations. So I just wanted to share that with the council and the community. We're very excited about that. And we're going to continue to apply for these grants that I think...

1:37:08 Target particular projects that enhance the amenities that we have in the community. So just wanted to share that with you. Thank you, Ray. That's really good news. One other thing real quick. Also, ESTA applied for a grant. Sandy just alluded to this a moment ago. They were awarded $400,000 to buy a 12th bus to add to the 11 that are currently being built. And that will service Red Meadow and other.

1:37:37 Ray, do you have any idea, when the trees went down in the lake space and there was a big push because no one was going to snow to clean that up, do we know if that has been completed or work stoppage until spring? Coincidentally, I heard your question to Sandy, and as you're asking that,

1:38:05 You know, I was never a big smartphone person, but they do have their advantages. And I sent a text message to John Kazmierski and asked him specifically with regards to Reds Meadow if the Forest Service had been working. He says, yes, lots. Call if you need details. So I know that they're back there working. There may be a delayed opening in the spring because of...

1:38:26 The number of trees that were blown down. We did have a similar issue in the Lakes Basin. I don't think it was quite to the extent of as in Reds. But we did have a meeting, and I don't recall when it was. It was before Thanksgiving, I believe, with the Forest Service, the Water District, Edison, and others to discuss the issues related to the Lakes Basin. And as you know, there were a lot of trees blown down up there.

1:38:55 Initially, what we wanted to make sure happened was that trees were cleared from the roadway. That had been done pretty quickly. There was electrical lines down. I think Edison has fixed all of that now. The biggest impact was to Mammoth Pack, the Mammoth Pack outfit up there. I'm not sure what he's been able to do, but I don't think it's going to slow us down, you know, in terms of opening the lakes basin in the springtime.

1:39:25 Reds is another matter. I don't want to beat a dead horse, but, you know, the lakes basin was addressed by a number of agencies when the trees went down. And Tioga Pass, Yosemite, there were trees down across the roads there. Those were addressed. And I'm just hopeful that the same procedures were followed in the Devil's Postpile, Reds Meadow area so that when the time comes, when the snow melts,

1:39:56 Yes, there's going to be additional cleanup because the volume was so great, but at least hopefully they'll have the road open and not have to wait a month or two or three or whatever it is to clean the trees from the road. Yeah, I'll follow up with Forest Service on this. Like I said, I just got that text message. It sounds like they're spending a lot of time back there cleaning up. Certainly the first thing they would want to do is make sure the road is clear so that we can get in there in the spring with snow removal equipment.

1:40:24 At least get the road open so there's access. Okay. Thank you. Sure. Thank you for all that good news, Ray. Town Council, I just have a couple of things I wanted to mention. As you recall, Noreen Wilbur retired at the end of December, and she was our HR manager. We have made a couple of changes in organization, which might affect your phone calls and schedules. Robin Picken has been appointed to fill her old position as the HR manager, and Pam Kobylarz has been...

1:40:55 Applied for and selected as Robbins Replacement. So we're in that transition period now, so probably within a month when you make the phone call to make appointments and schedules, Pam will be doing that job full time. I did have a chance to talk and meet with the county yesterday regarding solid waste. I'll have more of a report, but they did mention to me they did approve, the board of supervisors did approve funding to pay for the dumpsters, so we will begin coordinating.

1:41:22 Some of those pickups that Lee Gosch mentioned. I did get on my notes for the 4th of July. We'll bring that up as an agenda item. Stu mentioned to me that it's also on the agenda for the Rec Commission for their February 7th meeting. So we've been having a little bit of these mismatches on schedules. Would you like to do it before the commission or do you want to wait until our report? To have that discussion? Well, I suppose

1:41:53 When's the commission? On the 7th? Yes. And then when's our meeting? When would our meeting be? The following week, I think. The 15th? Oh, I think that's fine. I think they could have their meeting and then we could discuss it after because I think it'd be important to talk with them anyway on that. Okay, I just wanted to get that clear. We did have a meeting earlier today also on TOT enforcement.

1:42:15 And continue to work on that area. We will be bringing some ordinance changes to the council, working with our town attorney on those things. I wanted to mention that to you. And then lastly, we did have some problems with the water pumps at the airport. And the airport's a pretty high priority for us in many areas.

1:42:34 And over time, those pumps have failed. We're working with Hawk Creek Aviation to resolve that. But in the meantime, because of the priority of water, both in terms of fire protection and in potable water, I've made a decision to replace those pumps. And we'll move forward with a collection agreement or some kind of a deal with the Hawk Creek. Because ultimately, it's their pumps. But we just need to get them fixed. I was going to not do that, but airport at risk. So just let you know about that.

1:43:05 Okay. Thank you, Dave. Thank you for waiting so patiently, Stacey. Our next item is a public presentation from Stacey Carlos, Friends of the Inyo. I promise I'll make it short. And Councilmembers, thank you very much for letting me come to your meeting and give you an update on our activities, focusing on what we do on the Inyo National Forest lands here around Mammoth. But a brief overview. Friends of the Inyo is a nonprofit.

1:43:40 Based in Bishop, we've been around for 25 years now, but really active in public land stewardship in the last seven. Caring for the Eastern Sierra Public Lands is our mission. We have a membership of about 600 people and a much bigger email list thanks to all our volunteers. We've got several hundred Mono County residents and dozens and dozens scores of Mammoth Lakes residents who are members.

1:44:04 In 2011, we completed over 100 stewardship projects on the eastern Sierra's public lands. We engaged over 1,800 volunteers. We worked with a couple dozen land managers, nonprofit partners, schools, universities, and organizations and groups. And as our name implies, the INYO, National Forest, is our primary partner.

1:44:29 Well over half of our work is done on the INYO. But we do also work with the Bureau of Land Management, Bishop, and Ridgecrest Field Offices. And also Death Valley National Park. So we cover everything from the Great Falls Basin down on the southern end of, you know, near Ridgecrest up to the Bodie Hills north of Monal Lake.

1:44:55 I'm hoping that I noticed a couple typos in my presentation. You know, it's hard to focus when you have millions of acres you're trying to take care of. So I hope you'll forgive me. We have three program areas, preservation, exploration, and stewardship. Preservation is really our public lands advocacy. We advocate for conservation-focused lands management. Exploration is connecting people to their public lands with free hikes, with publications and presentations.

1:45:23 And then stewardship is taking care of these places on the ground both with our paid staff and volunteers. So most of our work here in Mammoth falls into our stewardship and exploration program areas with staff and volunteers caring for both wilderness and front country. That's split pretty evenly on the Inyo in wilderness and front country. And then also with our staff leading free hikes and interpretive tours as we did every week this summer in the Mammoth Lakes Basin.

1:45:52 I'm sure many people took the trolley and the new path to get to those hikes. So just a recap of our projects over the last year. The first one actually we've done for three years now, the Mammoth Lakes Summer of Stewardship or SOS is a partnership with MLTPA where we engage volunteers for

1:46:16 What we call the trail days, and that's getting volunteers out for a single day of trail maintenance somewhere, usually around the lakes basin, Convict Lake, just doing light trail maintenance for a morning. We get local businesses involved to donate raffle prizes and lunch and so forth. It's incredibly successful. We've had...

1:46:38 Gosh, it's probably over 800 volunteers total, close to 800 volunteers total over the last three years, 209 volunteers in 2011. But overall, and then another part of that, along with the volunteer events, is a daily presence in the lakes basin with paid staff. Our lakes basin steward for the past two years has been Carol Lester, and she does trail patrols, trail maintenance, and leads interpretive tours and hikes. So overall, we had 872

1:47:08 Volunteers and trip participants in 2011. Over 1,500 visitor contacts, so that's our paid staff and our volunteers greeting people on the trails, talking to people when they get off the trolley at Horseshoe Lake and want to know why the trees are dead. I think this is such an important part of the work we're doing and something I hope we can continue to grow, to be ambassadors for Mammoth while we're out there on the trail.

1:47:34 So we had over almost 4,000 stewardship hours, 135 miles of trail maintained, and lots and lots of trash removed. A lot of those fishing lines was not that heavy, so I hope you can be impressed with 766 pounds of trash. So the SOS is a wonderful partnership and really successful program that we plan to continue in 2012. Another aspect of our stewardship program is wilderness stewardship, and that's something we really

1:48:03 We had to up the ante in 2011 based on some pretty extreme cutbacks that the Inyo had to make in their wilderness program. I found out last March that they weren't going to hire back any of their seasonal wilderness rangers. They'd previously had four. And so we were able to hire one former wilderness ranger, Deb Bale.

1:48:27 Her duties as a non-profit employee versus federal agency employee were a little bit different. She wasn't a law enforcement officer, for instance, and couldn't write people tickets, but she did maintain an on-the-ground presence in some of the most popular areas in the Ansel Adams Wilderness and John Muir Wilderness. She did regular patrols, you know, the Shadow Lake area, Thousand Island Lake, these places where we know people are hiking, and she did, along with a couple interns, did a lot of the trail maintenance out there.

1:48:56 This summer, because Inyo also didn't have a dedicated trail crew. And she did, at the same time, collected a lot of data and did monitoring that were funded through grants to help the Forest Service with. So that's another program we plan to continue in 2012 and I hope expand and hire another wilderness steward that would be based here out of Mammoth. And then finally, another big part of our stewardship program this year has been Inyo National Forest Travel Management implementation.

1:49:27 We received funding from California State Parks OHV Division specifically for restoration. They have different grant categories. We were funded for restoration to assist the INYO with travel management restoration efforts. So we had one crew, and we did mostly work in Mono County. We did some work in the Shady Rest and Scenic Loop areas as well. We had one paid crew.

1:49:56 We also worked with the Student Conservation Association, a student crew that came out for about a month and helped with travel management. We engaged a couple of school groups, volunteers in travel management and completed about almost a third of the work that was slated to get done over the three-year period, so we're right on track. And we were supervised in this work, directed, really, by Inyo National Forest staff.

1:50:25 And that work will also continue in 2012, I think at about the same pace. We're going to be focusing a little more of our efforts and our crews down in the southern half of the forest. But I'm happy to report that I think you'll see a, how do I very diplomatically say this, a more concerted effort in public outreach for travel management implementation that I hope the council will be able to engage in.

1:50:54 So, for 2012, we're going to continue these programs I've just told you about, try to grow our wilderness program, and speaking of the blowdown event in Reds Meadow, we're anticipating a lot of need for help. Actually, I just talked to some INEO volunteers who said, this is trails, of course, not roads.

1:51:16 They estimated over 100 miles of trail are affected with 3,000 to 4,000 down trees. So the entire Mammoth Pass Trail is obliterated. The trail out to Red Cones is gone. Fish Creek Trail is gone. It's under these massive old-growth red furs. So I think they'll need to have professional crews out there, obviously, but there'll be a great need for volunteers.

1:51:42 Can engage them. Of course, Mayor Bacon is a volunteer extraordinaire. I want to thank her for her service with Friends of the Inyo. She untied a big log knot out near Thousand Island Lake this summer, and maybe we need to have you be a technical... I was going to say, how many more crosscut saws are you purchasing? Yes, we're sending our crosscut saws out to be sharpened as we speak. I didn't realize it until I read this, but pretty impressive that...

1:52:09 Mayor Joe Bacon spent five days at Thousand Island. It was fantastic. It was a wonderful experience. So you read about my summer vacation? I did. Yes. Yes. I would recommend the program to anyone. With an article by Mayor Bacon talking about her experience on one of our volunteer wilderness vacations. So that's it. Any questions? All right. Thank you, Stacey. All right. Thanks a lot. Thank you.

1:52:40 All right. Next would be the Consent Agenda. Are there any items to pull from consent? Madam Mayor, I'll move for adoption of Consent Agenda Items 2, 3, 4, and 5. I'll second that. Thank you. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Council Member Eason? Yes. Council Member Harvey? Yes. Council Member LeWood? Yes. Council Member LeWood? Yes. Council Member LeWood? Yes. Council Member LeWood? Yes. Council Member LeWood? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And we will go on to our Policy Item Number 1. Madam Mayor, thank you

1:53:11 for agendizing this. I just brought it up because for a number of reasons. I just found out that there's a chance that Amerigas is going to buy out Turner Gas and was curious as to what effect that would have on the community as far as having just one gas company in the community. And I didn't know if there was any

1:53:42 Any other support from the rest of the council members to have staff to look into what the arrangements are with the gas providers in town and if the municipality, the town of Mammoth Lakes has any say-so in any of this. I'm always concerned when there's only one provider and how that might affect the people and their rates in the community.

1:54:12 And I believe, do we have some information from staff? We have talked about this with the county briefly, and there's really nothing the town can do. You can write a letter expressing your concerns, of course, but the town can't do anything to block the sale. You can't sort of block it on the grounds that it would create a monopoly. You probably can't prevent the transfer of the business. There's just not a lot that the law allows you to do. Okay.

1:54:47 There's a second piece of it, which is service provided underneath the franchise agreements that we have. There is a franchise agreement, however, I haven't had a chance to look at it, but either it wouldn't have any restrictions on sale, that's one possibility, so that they could just transfer it. The other possibility is that Marigas could keep the existing franchisee entity alive if there is a restriction on transfer.

1:55:16 So they could transfer control without actually transferring the franchise. There's not really anything you can do with that. I've dealt with a lot of gas franchises and water franchises and other franchises over the years, and this issue comes up regularly, and there's just not a way to do it if they're willing to keep the entity alive. So if there is one gas company, they can make their own determination as to what rate they're going to charge?

1:55:45 Well, gas companies, a lot of them are regulated by the California Public Utilities Commission, just like electric companies are, and I believe that they would have to go to the PUC for a rate increase if they wanted to increase their rates. Okay. With respect to underground stuff, I mean, propane's a little bit different, but underground natural gas, I think they're regulated. Okay. And I'm just curious, who owns the lines? Are those city or are those private?

1:56:14 It would be private and placed in your streets under a franchise agreement. Okay, that's your term. Okay, so, yeah, because some time ago I had talked to a good friend of mine that's actually in the gas and propane business, and I know there was an interest in coming up here, but I think there were some challenges with that, obviously, and, you know, who owns the lines and what couldn't be done with that, so. You know, there's nothing in the law that prevents somebody from coming up and wanting to...

1:56:42 Have a competing business using underground lines, but have to install their own lines, which is prohibitively expensive in most cases. Or if the town doesn't have an ordinance prohibiting gas tanks, well, both in residential and commercial areas, a new gas provider, I'm guessing, could come up with gas tanks and install their own gas tanks. If that's something the town allows, yeah. And I think it does at this point.

1:57:12 I don't think there's a prohibition. I know with the fire department we're trying to go in a direction to remove tanks, but my gas bill for November was almost $1,000. And, I mean, you get to a rate that's so excessive at some point, you know, I'm going to be looking to put a tank in my yard, regardless of, you know, if there's no town ordinance against it.

1:57:43 I also know that in my business in property management for second homeowners that there are second homeowners that do call me, I would say on a weekly basis and say, you know, will you go check my thermostat at my house because my gas bill was, you know, $1,000 or $2,000 and we're not there. You know, so it's an issue with

1:58:11 People who have invested in our community who eat at our restaurants, ski at our mountain, purchase property in Mammoth so that at some point they're not going to pay $1,000 or $2,000 a month for one of their utilities. So anyway, we need to keep our eye open and if it becomes a problem then we need to respond to it. One of the other issues I was informed about too is to make sure that

1:58:40 Mayor Gas is going to maintain maintenance people in our area so that if there's an emergency with the gas system that they can respond immediately and that they're not sending somebody up from Bishop or someplace else to deal with gas issues. So it's just something that is probably in our, I don't know if that's in our franchise agreement or not, but it's just another point that we need to be sure that they have the proper service available to us.

1:59:08 In emergency situations 24-7. I actually talked to the fire chief recently and he said, remember those on council when that line was installed and Amerigas was told that just what you're talking about, Skip, that they needed to provide that and they needed to make some changes on the existing line that was already in as far as maintenance procedures.

1:59:36 And I think that was a couple of years ago or more. And they haven't followed up. They haven't responded to a requirement or a request from either the town or the fire department. So, you know, like you say, we don't have any control over them, but they're thumbing their nose at us. And pretty soon they're going to be the only show in town. And so I'm bringing it up because we need to be leery of some of the potential issues that come up.

2:00:06 And address them as best we can. Are we able to put service requirements into a franchise agreement? For public safety, we can. You're fairly limited. There's some things you can do in a franchise agreement, but utility franchising law is governed by something called the Franchise Act of 1937. It's in the Public Utilities Code, and it pretty much constrains you in terms of what you can require. Now, sometimes you'll be able to negotiate a franchise with a utility provider that...

2:00:34 It kind of goes beyond what the law really allows you to do, and if you can negotiate that, great. But if the utility provider is not willing to go beyond what the law really requires or allows, there's not a lot you can do. As I said, I haven't looked at your gas franchise. I can take a look at it. It could be that it has maybe a relatively limited amount of time left, and so you might have some leverage to negotiate with Amerigas.

2:00:57 The franchise has an indeterminate term, so that it just goes on forever, which is fairly common, and you don't have as much leverage. But we can look at it. We can also look at the Public Utility Commission general orders, which govern pipeline maintenance, which I think they've been getting a little bit more scrutiny ever since the pipeline explosion in Northern California last year or two years ago. We can look at the general orders and see if there's any way that we think that...

2:01:24 But Amerigas is not in compliance, and if they're not, we can take that up with the PUC or we can write to them directly. I'd like to have the town attorney have a conversation with the fire chief and see what the issue is and report back what happened. I can do that. Thank you. I'm hearing safety, I'm hearing service, and then another piece that I've heard from some of our community members is that apparently they've changed.

2:01:53 How people can no longer walk into a Marigas and pay a bill. I think what happened is they're building up here, their office up here flooded during the freeze, and they had to relocate their Mammoth office to Bishop. I'm assuming that once they absorb Turner Gas that they'll have a local office. I guess the question is, do we have any control over requiring them to have a local office? That would be a pretty typical feature of a franchise agreement.

2:02:24 And I can see whether there is anything in your franchise agreement to that effect. Yeah, I'd appreciate it if you take a look at that, because as I recall, the franchise agreement was developed at the time and within the context of the installation of lines by an entity that was ultimately purchased by Amerigas that required, obviously, placement in public rights of way.

2:02:52 And it's pretty limited, as I recall. Second, I have always had an understanding, and I'd like to have you check it out, that propane providers are not public utilities and are not governed by PUC regulations. I believe that's correct. I mean, the PUC does very much regulate natural gas, but I think you're right that propane is exempt from regulation. It's not viewed as the same type of utility as a natural gas utility is, but I'll verify that. Just take a few minutes.

2:03:22 So if they're thumbing their nose at us in a competitive environment, it'll be interesting to see what happens when it's no longer competitive. I've seen how this has really impacted the commercial market out there, too, because a lot of these costs get passed through to the tenants, and I know it's just every year they have a homeowner's meeting at these various projects, and that is a big point of contention. So is the cost, and is this real? You know, so...

2:03:50 What am I missing? Thank you. Okay, so that was what you intended. Thank you. Okay. Then in that case, we will be going into closed session. Was it Neil used to say, if we got done by 7.30, everybody would go out for a glass of beer or something?