Town Council
· recording 3 hr 59 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
466 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
7:58 There was no reportable action from closed session. We'll move on to a pledge. Matthew, would you please? Sure. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible. We will now move on to an update for the community and council, an information report on frequently asked questions on the town settlement process.
8:41 Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers and the public. My name is Dave Wilbrecht. I'm the Town Manager. So we're here tonight to give an update as much as we possibly can. I'm going to do a little introduction, and then I'm going to turn it over to Marianna, who's been working very closely with this as well as I have. I think for my purposes, I really want to talk to the community. I should turn this thing around, I think. In terms of the process that I'm very familiar with.
9:11 And some people aren't necessarily familiar with, which is, you know, how do we go about the closed session process? Because I think there's lots of questions about what that is like. And so some of you may have served on commissions or councils where you've had to be in a closed session. There's a confidentiality that goes along with that. We also have confidentiality agreements, which Marianna will speak to about in a few minutes with our current situation. The point of all of it, of course, is to give the council a chance to talk openly and freely with...
9:40 Thank you.
10:08 Difficult opinions about things. I think from my observations and from my experience, it's been somewhat of a very pleasurable experience in that the council exchanges opinions, thoughts, and ideas, but these remain respectful and thoughtful, which gives us as staff clear direction about what we need to do when we're not being involved and drawn into other kinds of situations. So I just wanted to clarify for you that that's how we're working together.
10:36 We've spent enormous amounts of time and effort to come together to figure out what we're going to do with a very difficult set of problems. I think some of the more important guiding principles that the Council has thought about, has discussed, that I can talk about because they're all public documents, is that the arguments that we talk about and make really have to do with the community's vision of what it wants to be. We don't make stuff up. You know, there's been a huge amount of work both in terms of the public.
11:05 Commissions and committees on things like the general plan, for example, which speaks to the triple bottom line. It talks about maintenance of essential assets, workforce housing, air service, local transit priorities. There's been a tremendous amount of work that the community has done on what it means to be a destination community and economic development strategies was updated in 2010, which talks about being a premier destination community in order to achieve sustainable year-round economy.
11:33 He speaks to prioritizing allocation of resources to provide activities, programs, and services and facilities to lead to a higher visitation. He talks about the strategies for the initiatives, which includes tourism, destination resort, mobility, recreation, sustainability, air service.
11:53 All of these documents are things that the council has used, we all have used, in various purposes from development agreements to approving projects to looking at zoning, allocating staff, and we've used it, I think, as a basis for a lot of the conversation and decisions that we've had about how do we go about resolving the lawsuit as well as protecting what are important to the town. So we're not moving forward with ideas that are...
12:20 Things we speculate on. They're ideas that the community has endorsed, which is a very important support basis. I just want to say thank you for the community and the work that has been done over the years because we're not making this stuff up. This is what the community desires and it drives us to what we understand what we need to do for our jobs. Other documents include rec strats, which has been a very important document, which means we want to be the best alpine recreation.
12:48 Community in the country. That requires resources and talent and capacity. It includes things like the highest quality winter recreation activities, highest quality non-winter recreation, municipal sports and recreation, trails, special events, high altitude training, arts and culture, and transportation and mobility again. So these are things that the community values. They're things that we have recognized and we respect and respond to. And that's been our approach through this whole process.
13:16 To represent the community in what we believe has been well documented and a clear direction. So with that said, I'll turn it over to Marianna to talk more specifically. Thank you, Dave. Mayor, Councilmembers, again, as Dave pointed out, and I feel strongly about this as well, I am speaking tonight to the community present here watching us tonight. The Council knows information.
13:45 Intimately now that I'm about to present to you. What I'm going to speak about are the responses to the frequently asked questions about the settlement process with MLLA. We do have copies of the four-page document that is actually a two-pager available up front. There should be sufficient copies available.
14:08 Responses also have been posted on the town's website, so if anyone is interested, those are available, and we did send copies to the media. You also have little cards that look like these that provide an email address as well as a phone number for you to follow up. We will record tonight to the extent possible questions, additional questions that you may have.
14:31 And we will respond to them if we have information tonight. And if we don't have information tonight, we will post responses on the website. So with that being said, what I will do is there are four pages. I'm not going to read every single response, but I am going to highlight key points from a response so that we could start the conversation. Once I stop, I suppose we'll open it up to additional questions or comments from the public.
14:57 But let me start by emphasizing what Mr. Wilbrek already mentioned, that is we're still negotiating with Mammoth Lakes Land Acquisition, MLLA. We're still attempting to settle. And there's confidentiality that comes with any negotiation, whether it's negotiation with a developer or a union group or anyone else. So to the extent that we can provide information to you in this document or verbally,
15:24 We will do so, however, to the extent that information is confidential, such as amounts offered by us or the other side, or components of a settlement, those things we may not be able to disclose. In addition, I also want to emphasize that I worked and my career was multiple city councils and town councils. You have an excellent town council here. They're not afraid to make decisions.
15:52 They vote as a group. They have their disagreements. They have their personal opinions. But they are great counsel. And you need to trust them in making decisions that they're making of you to have. In addition, before I move on to the questions, I also wanted to point out and mention to you, I don't think we did this in any of our written documents, that the town recently retained a well-known international law firm of Fulbright and Jaworski. They are experts in restructuring. They're also experts in bankruptcy.
16:22 Which hopefully is an option that we will never utilize, but it is a well-known firm that we're lucky to have. We also have as a special counsel and expert witness and a consultant, a well-known bankruptcy attorney by the name of Ken Klee, K-L-E-E. He has been practicing since 1975, mainly related to bankruptcy matters.
16:49 He represented Orange County on their bankruptcy. He's currently representing the largest municipal bankruptcy case of Jefferson County in Alabama, and so on. We also have a financial advisor standing by, not currently doing the work, but standing by, ready to help us, an international restructuring firm by the name of FTI. So with that, let me just start going through questions. The first question in the document is, why is there a judgment?
17:19 And what is the amount? Well, the judgment really goes back to the development agreement around the airport that the town entered into through the public process in 1997. The development agreement was with Mr. Talens Ballas, Terry Ballas, and Mr. Ballas at some point later on transferred rights to a portion of that development agreement, i.e. the residential portion or the hotel slash condominium portion.
17:47 To a partnership called Mammoth Lakes Land Acquisition, or MLLA, and I'm going to refer to them as MLLA. MLLA sued the town back in 2006. It was a long legal process. In 2008, after a jury trial, MLLA was awarded damages of $30 million. The town has utilized every single right to an appeal that we had. We exhausted all appeals.
18:17 We have gone up all the way up to the California Supreme Court, and about a year ago, in March of 2011, we lost, that lost appeal, lost the opportunity to appeal. So that's what the judgment is all about. The amount of the judgment at this point stands at over $42 million. It includes, in addition to the base $30 million legal fees, as well as interest at 7%, and 7% is set by California Constitution.
18:46 Why is it taking so long to settle? Well, once we lost the last opportunity to appeal in March of last year, in April, we met with the other side. And we developed a process to share information, share town's financial and operational information with the other side. We have gone through the process of providing information to MLLA during the months of May, June, July, August, and September. Finally, in October.
19:16 MLLA, and there was a lot of information shared. The town is not complicated and it's not big, but it does have complicated financials from a private sector standpoint. We provided in total about five binders worth of information. So finally in October, MLLA submitted their first offer to us. We responded and so through the end of December of 2011, we have been in settlement discussions.
19:46 In January of this year, last month, the town had additional financial information that became available to us with regards to the current fiscal year. We received less snow than we normally would. And we also anticipate that there are going to be additional issues as a result of that in the next fiscal year when it comes to our budget.
20:09 So with that information, we informed MLLA in January that we're going to look at things holistically and globally. And we do have to thank our new legal firm of Fulbright and Jaworski for helping us and introducing that idea to us of restructuring holistically, restructuring globally. What that means is looking at all of our operations and looking at all of our issues, not only MLLA as a creditor.
20:37 But also long-term obligations related to employee retirement, long-term obligations related to outstanding debt, looking at all of those issues holistically and trying to solve them all to the extent possible. So we're in the process of developing that restructuring plan right now and we're still attempting to settle with MLA.
20:59 Next question on page 2. It has been reported in the local media that the town's settlement discussions with MLLA have been discontinued. Is that true? Not from our standpoint. Now as I mentioned to you, last month we were not in a position to provide yet another settlement offered to MLLA because we want to do it holistically and globally.
21:25 We did inform MLLA on January the 19th that after February the 1st we will present an offer and that's still our intent once we have the restructuring plan in place. In the meantime, on February the 2nd, MLLA did file a petition in a state court. Now let me step back and I'll address this further later on. Bankruptcy is a federal process. It happens at the federal level. It's a federal law.
21:52 There is another process at the state level, according to the state law, where a judgment creditor or any creditor could file a petition to the court, petitioning the court to order the town, in this case, to pay. So that's what MLA has done. They went to the state court on February the 2nd, and they requested that the state court order the town to pay the full $42 million.
22:19 Despite the fact that that petition was filed, the town is still attempting to settle and negotiate and still attempting to follow the course of the settlement. Next question. What procedural options are available to the town? Okay. Was that for me? It wasn't for me. So procedurally, settlement... Oh, thank you very much. Yes, thank you. It was actually a hidden microphone in here, so I dropped it on purpose.
22:52 Thank you, John. So procedurally, there are really only three options. One is settlement, consensual settlement, and that's what we attempted to do and that's what we will continue to do for as long as that option is available to us. The second option is to continue that settlement but with an outside neutral person. And that person would be a mediator.
23:19 When you have, and Mr. Wood could speak to this in his family practice, when you have two sides that just could not see eye to eye and could not agree, you introduce either a lawyer or a mediator. Earlier today, we sent a letter to MLLA requesting that we enter that next stage of mediation because it appears, because we're so far apart.
23:43 Now, what that means, however, is that we also need to enter a similar
24:12 Mediation process with all other creditors. There is some flexibility on who we mediate with, but in general, major creditors would be invited at the table, and those major creditors would include employees, they would include major contractors, they would include local vendors. We don't have a full list yet. We're still sorting through the details of who to invite.
24:38 But in general that mediation would be not only with MLLA but other creditors as well. Let me turn to page 3. The next question is why not just file for bankruptcy? Well, what I didn't mention in the previous question is bankruptcy is an option. But from the very beginning, and we still firmly believe this, we have seen bankruptcy as the last resort. If we could afford bankruptcy, we will. We don't want to utilize that option, but it is an option.
25:08 What exactly is Chapter 9 bankruptcy? Chapter 9 bankruptcy, as I mentioned, happens at the federal level. It's federal law and Chapter 9 specifically is designed for municipalities, for local governments. It gives you certain protections from creditors and it allows you basically to structure your debt and renegotiate with your creditors. Chapter 9 is overseen by a federal bankruptcy judge.
25:36 Next question. How could the town afford to pay anything at all, given that the town only recently balanced a $2.8 million budget? You know, there's really no easy answer to that, and the answer is before you, but verbally I can tell you there's no easy answer for me, for Dave, for the council, or employees of the community. But the bottom line is we have an obligation. We have an obligation.
26:02 To settle with MLLA, whatever that amount may be. And we're going to meet that obligation. To do so, we are going to develop a restructuring plan that hopefully addresses other debts in addition to MLLA, but also satisfies our judgment to MLLA. What about long-term economic viability of the town? Again, the town cut this past June 2.8 million dollars.
26:32 Prior to that, there were cuts of 1.5 to 2 million dollars. The town a few years ago had 130 positions, now we have only 84. We have cut ourselves close to the bone, but again, we have an obligation, and we have debt outstanding, not only to MLA, but other creditors as well, and we're going to attempt to settle that debt and restructure that debt as part of this restructuring process. That's all I can share with you at this point.
27:00 Page 3, the end of Page 3, what payment options is the town considering? We really can't disclose to you any specific options, but we can tell you that we have been very creative in our options, and we believe that we provided to MLLA various kinds of options that could possibly exist. Page 4.
27:28 Will there be an opportunity for public input and where can I get additional information? Well, tonight's meeting is your first opportunity. We also provided an email address for you to send us emails and we will respond. If we answer a question that hasn't been answered before, we'll post the response online and you can also call us and the phone number is provided. So I'm going to stop here, see if there are any other comments from Dave with the council and if not, I'll allow the mayor to...
27:54 Thank you, Mary Ann and Dave. Yes, this is a community update, and we're really asking you to ask questions if you have them about what you've just heard, ask other questions, give us your comments and ideas. Please remember, though, that because of some of the confidentiality issues, we may not be able to respond to the questions, but they all will be taken down. And as you all remember, our meetings are now webcast.
28:22 So we have a complete recording of it and they will be answered when they can be answered. So I would just ask you to come to the podium. You guys decide on the order you want to come up and state your name and then ask your questions or provide your comments. There has to be at least one person out there who has a question. I'm Stacy Powells. I was emailed a couple of questions today.
28:56 All right, two questions. This is not the first time that the town of Mammoth Lakes, that something has gone bad for a developer here in the town of Mammoth Lakes. But it appears it's the first time a developer has held the town accountable. What is going to change so this doesn't happen again? And the second question is, I haven't read anywhere or heard anybody say that the town or anybody from the town feels any remorse for what is happening to our community. Is there any remorse about the condition that the town is in?
29:28 Can you ask me? No, you don't. I think I can ask, if you're looking at several new people, that certainly will change what we've done. I think we have a different council, and over time, of course, this was a process that began back in the early, part of 2000, and so lots of process changed by that. In terms of the reverse, I think there's two sides to that answer. One is certainly,
30:01 I think everyone agrees that no one wants to be in the position we're in. I think the town has done a lot to defend itself relative to what its legal options are. I don't think there should be any remorse for that at all. I think it's a tragedy that the town's in the position at its end. I think once the settlement was determined last year, early 2011, we really dug in and started to do our best to settle this.
30:29 We're continuing to do that, but I have no remorse for that. I think the council can speak to its own particular point of view, but at least from my perspective, I think Marianna and the councils that I'm working with, as well as Andy, we've got the parts dealt with us. We'll do our best to preserve and protect what we thought the town represented. I mentioned that at the very beginning. We try to stay true to that and also try to do our obligations as well.
30:59 Come on up, John. Town Council, John Baruch. I'd like to just make comments. I don't really have any questions. I think you've answered other questions, but I would like to make some comments and maybe possibly suggestions. You know, the comment, first of all, is that this has been going on for, what, 10 years, and now the public is involved, and so the first question I have is, you know, why?
31:35 I don't really want an answer to that, but I think I haven't answered in a few minutes. And this has been going on for some time, and if you go back to, you know, what happened is, you know, we or whoever, the town council and possibly the staff entered into this lawsuit someway, somehow, and as Marianna has said, we then continued on and we've lost three times. Now we have this huge judgment hanging over our head.
32:01 Where I'm going with this eventually is we have the same people making the same decisions, the same rights, and we come up with the same results. It's been happening for 10, 20 years. I remember Rick Wood, I think the first month he was in office, Rick said, let's not point fingers. And I agree 100% with Rick. It's too late to point fingers. All you have to do is read the lawsuit. There's names in the lawsuit. So we don't have to paint the names of anybody. It happens. It's there. My point is, as Town Council staff,
32:30 They were involved in this. The public was not. Why are we here tonight? In my opinion, I think we're here. The horse is out of the barn where it's too late to do anything. But I think the reason that we're here tonight and why you open this to the public is because of the news that came out, the press release from the other side. My opinion, again, is that this attorney decided, well, let's make this public, and the other side decided to come out with this.
33:01 And I think why they did it was to try and separate us and to have us fight against each other. I think it's a ploy on their part. I think we'll be very careful what we say tonight because I guess the cameras are still on. And I think that one of the important things is that we don't figure that it's us against them. Us against the town council or town council against the employees.
33:30 I think it's one time that we really, really need to assess this and we need to come together as a community. We're not the opposition. No one in this room is the opposition. The opposition has made that press release. So I think that when it said we're dealing in bad faith, I don't know what the number was that the town came up with, but whatever the number was last year, in my opinion, it's got to be a hell of a lot less this year.
34:00 Our skier visits are an all-time low, according to the graph I just saw yesterday. Our TOT is down, and I would like to thank Matthew Lehman and the lodging community for working to get the code enforced for the first time in 30 years, and I think without that enforcement, we'd really be unhurting for a TOT. Our sales tax is down, and definitely property taxes. I know people that have had their property taxes reduced in 2012 already, so we haven't seen the end of this, of the property tax reduction.
34:28 And yes, we only get 6%, but still 6% of a smaller amount is a hell of a lot of money. Probably a couple of examples, and I just found this out yesterday. There's a new federal law that says any commercial property that has a loan, the banks are required to do a yearly appraisal. You take the appraisal, you go to the county, and guess what happens? And your taxes are then adjusted. And I don't think it's going to be adjusted upward.
34:54 There's also another example. There's a condominium that sold in 2006 for $850,000. That same condos in escrow today for $265,000. So when that closes, so my point is I don't know what, you know, what the offer was, but definitely the offer in 2012 is going to be a heck of a lot less than what it was in 2011. And we are going to be, as far as, you know, I think we're looking at, what, another $2 million or whatever, I just heard, for a budget reduction.
35:24 I think that, you know, when I say that we need to work together as a town, I think that there are conflicts. You know, I understand staff at a meeting, the staff has a conflict because, you know, they're concerned about their jobs, they're concerned about their pay, their benefits, etc. Town Council has a little conflict because they want to be elected. The citizens have a conflict possibly because we've got people losing their homes and we've got people that may or may not be in business next year or later on this year. It's been very, very tough for everyone.
35:50 You know, you've got to remember also that the private sector, people have not taken paychecks home for months or maybe a year. They don't have benefits. They don't have retirement, and they don't have, in some cases, medical insurance. But all that keeping in mind, I still think that we need to work together as a community. We can't be separated. We can't let this letter that came out separate us as a community.
36:16 I don't know what was happening in closed session. No one does. Or in secret meetings, whatever you want to call them. But all that being said, what I'd like to do is suggest something that maybe possibly, I think that it was talked about last year where you have a, you set up a group of citizens and you have an oversight committee of some style. I don't even know if that's legal. I don't know if you can do that. I know that it was suggested. And the only reason I suggest that is don't,
36:46 I don't want you to think that I think you guys are doing a good job, but again, what I've said is for the last 10, 15, 20 years, we have the same people making the same decision with the same results. There's a word for that. So maybe possibly, if you can get other people involved, and I'm not talking about a big group, and definitely what I'm not talking about is a political group. And if you remember, we had, you know, town council appointed a finance committee or a budget committee in 2009. You know, we came back.
37:15 I didn't, but other people came back with a, with a, what I consider a whitewash, because again, it was politicians, it was political people that were on that committee. Appointed committee that's not political. Appointed committee of professionals, people that maybe won't even be your friends, that maybe don't even like you. Accountant types, people that are very analytical. I feel that in order to make this, there was a question asked, how do you pay for this? You know, unfortunately, I think at this point in time,
37:44 The Town Mammoth makes us look at every person that works here, everything that we do, and everything that's going to be analyzed. That's not that committee. That's a professional. No one's going to have time. But like I said, the reason for the committee is hopefully that if you did appoint something like that, we'd have a different idea, maybe fresh ideas, and maybe different results. And again, that's a big maybe. I have no idea. But you know, what is Town Council, what is tap? What have you got to lose? We're in a really no-win-win situation here.
38:14 So again, it can't be political and hopefully we may get different results. And I saw, for instance, Skip and Joe said you're going to rerun and I read the paper and you guys said you're getting along really well and that's great. But maybe we do need some more. Instead of 5-0 votes, maybe we need some more 2-3 votes or different thoughts. So again, I want to make it very, very clear that I'm not knocking anything you guys have done. I'm sure that
38:44 Figuring all your hours, you're probably making minus 25, minus 30 cents an hour, less than what you normally make. So I'm sure it's not the hours you're putting in. It's just a different approach. So those are my comments. And like I say, I don't really want any answers. Just comments on maybe where we're going to go. And I think as a community, it's very, very important. And we do, in fact, stand together as a community for once and see where we're going to go with this. I don't know if you have any questions on me. But otherwise, thank you again for all your time. And thank you for letting me speak.
39:14 Thank you, John. I'm sure there's more. Actually, I have a question for Mr. Brewer, which is, so on the one hand, you want the community to have solidarity, but yet you want council to have a bunch of two, three votes. I'm a little lost. John, if you're going to continue that, you need to come back up so you can be on the record, but please keep it short. What I meant with that is the fact that maybe we don't always want to be
40:12 Okay, to get back on topic, if anyone wants to speak, questions, etc. Hi, my name is Lee Gosch. This decision has
40:44 A lot of consequences for the employees of the town, the residents of the town, and the businesses of the town. Each one of us are walking on eggshells of what's going to happen. There's been a rumor basically about people asking, saying that they'd be willing to put it on their property taxes. I have talked to a lot of people and we do not want it to be added on to our property taxes. If we cannot pay it, the assessor could put a lien on your house and take your house from you.
41:12 I'm not going to lose my house, and nobody else wants to either, and that's one way. I know you need to have the vote of people to do it, but we do not want to have it added to our property taxes to help pay for this. I've talked to a lot of people about that. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. Council, Martin Kleinbarg, resident of Mammoth. I'm curious, when Marianna talked about the bankruptcy, what would that entail for vendors that are doing projects and work?
41:50 Do you already have a tight budget when you do work? Do you have to negotiate again to get paid? You could ask Andy specifically, but is your question about existing contracts or new contracts? Either way, because, you know, it depends if things are paid off before, you know, finally. You know, in a sense, it's a hypothetical question, and I hope it's going to remain hypothetical.
42:21 And in a sense, it's also somewhat confidential because while there are relatively clear guidelines under the federal law for how bankruptcy is done, and the guidelines generally are you negotiate with all of your creditors and the inventors are your creditors, but there are also flexibilities, enormous flexibilities given to municipal governments, towns, cities for choosing.
42:47 Who they want to restructure, whose debt they want to restructure and whose contracts they want to assume. So let me just leave it at that. Andy Morris, Town Attorney. I will add one thing. It's important to bear in mind that bankruptcy only protects the town against debts that arose before the date the bankruptcy petition was filed. So any contract that's awarded after the town files Chapter 9, if that happens, which of course we hope that it won't, would not be affected. Amy Cutter, also a resident of Mammoth Lakes.
43:23 I have a follow-up question to that. So does that mean for a municipality they can enter into new contracts if they're in bankruptcy or new agreements with vendors? Yes. Okay. And then I have a completely different question unrelated. So I've also heard a rumor that Terry Ballas himself, for I guess another portion of the airport project, has filed a lawsuit or is thinking about filing a lawsuit or something about that.
43:52 One, has anybody heard that? Two, how does that affect the existing Wonsuki or the settlement? The town hasn't been sued by Mr. Ballas. As far as we know, if he's filed it but hasn't served us, that's the possibility, but I don't think that's happened. As for what his intentions may be, I can't speculate on that. I have no idea. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Amy. And while the next person is coming up, would everyone please turn off their cell phones? No.
44:31 Other questions? Good evening. My name is John Wentworth. Just two quick questions. Does the town have any information about timelines? Is there another three-month mediation period or any sense of what that might look like? And the other question is, I don't know if you can address this. My understanding is that there are investors in the MLA lawsuit that are seeking to profit from this action. I'm wondering if you have any comment or any insight on that.
45:07 As far as the timelines are concerned, there's a new state law that became effective earlier this calendar year in January. I'm trying to look at you, John. And that state law imposes additional restrictions, guidelines for federal bankruptcy processes, and that state law requires pre-bankruptcy mediation. That mediation should last at least two months.
45:34 So that's your mediation and we're attempting to seek mediation at this point. If we ever go into bankruptcy, which again we hope is a hypothetical question and will never end up in Chapter 9, but if we ever do, it may take a long time. Vallejo, it took them about three years to emerge from bankruptcy. A legal firm of Fulbright and Jaworski has a unique approach.
46:02 When it comes to restructuring and bankruptcy, and they have advocated and convinced us that it should not take more than three months. It doesn't make sense to stay in bankruptcy for more than three months. But again, hopefully this is hypothetical and we'll never end up with anything else other than mediation. But mediation itself may take longer than two months. Remind me of the second question. Investors.
46:36 We know that MLA is a partnership, that it does have partners. What their intentions are, how much was invested, what their shares are, we really don't know. Have you ever thought of doing like a trade with him, like some of the property in town, some of the buildings? I know it won't have $42 million, but a land trade with him or something?
47:11 You used the term him. We're negotiating with MLA, and that's the partnership that has more than Mr. Ballas. There are other partners in it as well. As far as options, we have offered different options. We unfortunately cannot speak to the options that we offered. My name is Steve Searles. I live here. My question was, we're all acutely aware of what our liabilities are. Is it...
47:47 Could it be public knowledge? What our assets are? All of us who've lived here for a long time have financial challenges. First thing is the profit and loss, your liabilities and your assets. Could you tell us what our talent is worth? Well, in general, in this, you know, if I didn't want to answer your question, I would probably refer you to our financial statements because they have our liabilities and assets.
48:16 But frankly, and as you pointed out, our information is public knowledge.
48:21 Most of our information is available publicly. And a good way to really get to the detail of what our liabilities and assets are is to look at our financial statements. They are available online. We do an audit every year and an independent auditor comes in and analyzes both the assets and the liabilities. As far as the assets in general, because again, it may take hours to talk about specific funds that we have, restrictions and so on.
48:51 We have very limited cash. We talked with this council publicly about a year ago when we balanced the budget that at that point we had under $1.5 million in the general fund reserve. That's very low. As far as non-liquid assets, the town has some properties and all of you are aware of them. We have...
49:16 Some properties out there that could be liquidated, but I'll tell you, today is not a good time to do that. The real estate market is such that liquidation is not an option. In addition, the properties that we do have, for example, the community center, it has an essential purpose and continues to serve an essential purpose.
49:38 And helps us provide an essential service. So it may not be a question of the value in dollars. It may be a question of the value to the community. Good evening. Dave Harvey, citizen of Mammoth. The situation that we have at the airport is we've created over the years something that is showing a very positive return in the number of flights and the
50:20 How, in your opinion, and I understand the sensitivity of the lawsuit and there are certain things that you can and cannot address, but in a broad spectrum, what is the town of Mammoth Lakes doing to secure all of the good work that's been done at the airport?
50:50 To get to the level of service that we're at from being deteriorated because of the lawsuit. So I can answer that, I think, somewhat specifically and somewhat generally. The airport is an asset that the town owns. It's part of our asset program. It's subsidized somewhat by the general fund, but mostly it's enterprise on its own.
51:15 So in terms of MLLA's claim against the town, it really affects the general fund. So the airport has a limited general fund subsidy. And we understand that and recognize the priority of that. In the meantime, you know, it continues to operate. The flights are coming to the building. The airport commission has been working through a very lengthy process to do the airport mail plan. I think that was nearly completed and submitted or will be submitted over the next couple of months.
51:44 We've included a lot of work to enhance that program, so it's very complete and responds to a lot of questions and so forth. So I think the town's doing what it needs to do to continue its operation and its future. Dave, can you share with Mr. Harvey the relevance of the airport layout plan and why that's needed? So on a regular basis, and I don't know the details, but what the borderline does, because we're working very closely with it, so we can get those detail answers in the background.
52:12 The airport layout plan is really a master plan, not a document or a plan itself, a physical drawing, which shows the current as well as proposed uses of the airport, including the future location of a terminal building. As you know, the old shop was converted into a terminal building. We determined it was too small for human purposes, as well as leaving passengers out with colds. We've spent some money on the technical structure with the idea that within five years, we would
52:41 We try to fund the terminal building to support the aircraft that we have. The ALP also's purpose is to identify and to move forward the town's interest in changing the classification of the airport, allowing for similar-sized aircraft but a warm variety of carriers. And so we don't anticipate any problems with that. I think it's a very difficult process, like everything that we seem to do as
53:10 Lots of difficulties, but I think the airport commission is an attractive job, and the consultants that we've had have been able to respond directly to the questions that we've received, and I expect that there will be some more conversation, but we hope that that plan has approved the spring. Yeah, I just, the point I think maybe you're looking at is what kind of, what's the future of the airport, what's the future of air service, and I think if you look at where air services come in
53:38 Three relatively short seasons. You know, we started with one flight per day. We went to three, and this year we're at eight flights a day. And the intent of the community is to have even more flights from different locations long term. And if that happens, we're essentially at the point now to where we can't expand too much more because of the holding capacity for the passengers at that location.
54:08 So we would need a larger terminal facility and that's part of what the airport layout plan does is that it will determine what if any additional expansion would be permitted at that location. Very good. I'm sure that it would be comforting to business owners and hospitality operators here in Mammoth Lakes to understand that the airport is
54:38 Taking strong consideration in this whole scenario and that it's going to continue to be supported by council and by town to go forward and produce the product that it started to. It's one of the very good things that we've done over the number of years here.
55:06 And I would hate to think that we would consider losing any traction on this very positive thing for our community. Dave, I had one more note, and I apologize for beating the horse, but we also have to look at it realistically, and even though we have eight flights today, those eight flights are subsidized by Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. Correct. And this has been less than a normal...
55:33 Occupancy on the flights this year, and so I don't want to speak for them, but it's likely that they will have to reconsider what level of investment they're able to make in a future year. Okay. Well, thank you very much. I just wanted my concerns to be noted. Thank you. Thank you, Dave. Ted Carlton. We've talked about the $42 million and about the legal fees that we owe the other side and the interest in judgment.
56:09 How much have we spent on our own legal expenses, which I don't believe are included in that $42 million? Maybe go from pre-first trial to current. So we'll have to come back with that answer, which we're happy to do on the webpage, because it's public information. I can tell you this year that we've allocated $400,000 for the support of the lawsuit, and the council has used that money to pay for Marianna's schedule of time.
56:42 As well as some of the consultants that we've talked about and use some of the retainers for the future. Our hope and desire is not to spend getting more than we need to. And so this year we've actually paid about $400,000. We'll go back in time and look at that. I think we actually have to report someplace of what we produced. I just don't have the details. So you allocated $400,000 for 2011-2012? Yes. And you expect to spend all of that?
57:10 One more. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Ben. Any other questions? Okay. Any final comments? Is it appropriate, and I'll have to look to council and staff on this, but it's my understanding that tonight was the first meeting or the first opportunity for the public to come before council and to ask questions.
57:49 on this particular issue. And I would like to think that in the future, whether it's our, if we can have it scheduled regularly at council meetings or how we're going to do that, but it would be, it would make sense to have additional opportunities for the public to give input or to ask questions. Well, I think part of that will be as the situation changes each day, I don't...
58:12 I think we will definitely incorporate those. I'd also like to remind everyone that there is an email address so that you can send in your questions or you can call the town manager's office and ask your questions that way because I realize not everyone could be here tonight that may have wanted to be. Also remind everyone that these meetings are archived so you can go back and watch a meeting at any point in time. Madam Mayor, if I may, this issue,
58:41 During the 10...
59:12 The two sides have actually worked together openly and cooperatively in trying to understand the entirety of the town's finances and what the town can or can't pay to MLLA to resolve the payment of the judgment. We started this process approximately 10 months ago. We, the town and MLLA,
59:43 By bringing MLA up to date as to what's the town's current finances, both with our budget, what our assets are, what our revenues are, and so forth. So I can't imagine that there has been a better display of a municipality in trying to resolve a judgment in bringing the information to
1:00:11 The other side. We've been completely cooperative, given them all our financial information, told them that if they had any questions on the information they received to give us follow-up questions, and we literally spent face-to-face time as well as financial time with each other, and so I think that the town's financial condition is a very clear book to both sides.
1:00:40 Yet, after this extended period of mutual cooperation between the two sides, MLLA seems at this point to not have anything left to offer and has decided to pursue, through the courts, payment in full of the $42 million judgment, despite the seeming clarity that the town can't possibly pay the full amount and still provide the basic municipal services for our community.
1:01:09 Personally, what I'm focused on is whether the town and MLLA can reach a settlement agreement, either amongst ourselves, the two parties, through mediation, or even through bankruptcy, if that becomes necessary. I also know that currently in the negotiation process, both the town and MLLA are extremely far apart. The town and MLLA have a gaping difference in opinions as to what the town can reasonably pay.
1:01:41 And what the town needs revenue-wise to provide these minimal services to the communities, residents, and visitors alike. As a town council representative, my goal for the past 10 months has been to actively pursue this resolution of the MLLA judgment against the town. Again, personally, I've come to the realization that I don't see how the town can pay the full amount or even anything close to the full amount of the judgment.
1:02:11 Even over an extended period of years. Because of the poor economy, in general, the Council made, as was mentioned earlier, 2.7 or 2.8 million dollars in municipal cuts to balance last year's budget. The year previously, the Council cut approximately 1.5 million to balance the budget two years ago. And additionally now, because of this winter's lack of natural snowfall and the resulting lower
1:02:42 Projected occupancy rates, which result in lower bed tax revenue for the town. This council and our staff is looking to cut as much as an additional $2 million. If you start adding those numbers together, $2 million this year, $2.8 last year, $1.5 the year before, I think it shows the pattern of the commitment of the council and the town in general to have balanced budgets each year.
1:03:13 We can only wish that both the state of California and our federal governments were as financially responsible with their annual budgets. Oh, I'm sorry, that's right. The federal government hasn't even had a budget for the last three years. It was mentioned earlier, the number of employees. We've gone, in a six-year time frame, we've gone from approximately 130 town employees down to
1:03:43 I think we're looking at something in the low 70s in this next year's budget. The good news for the town and the good news for the community is that the town has retained and is working closely with arguably the premier municipal bankruptcy and insolvency law firm in the United States. We are represented by lawyers who will help the town to restructure our organization.
1:04:10 And present a very clear financial picture of the town's current financial condition, including a realization for everyone to see that the town is obviously unable to provide payment of a full $42 million judgment. This continues to be a very challenging time for the town, yet I am optimistic that we are moving forward with the correct plan for restructuring, a plan that will eventually lead us to resolution of the MLLA settlement.
1:04:40 Finally, it is the intent of this organizational restructuring to be prepared for a likely continuation of settlement offers between the two parties, mediation, or the possible bankruptcy procedure. The goal is to attempt to reach closure within a few months instead of many months or even longer. Thank you. One last chance if there were questions or comments out there.
1:05:22 I just have to make a comment because I keep hearing basic services. And, you know, as our business community knows and as our residents knows, you know, to have a viable community to serve our residents and guests, we need more than basic services. The only industry we have in this community is tourism. And to have a resort and to properly serve our guests and our residents, there's no way we can do that with just
1:05:52 Basic Services. You know, we came off of, you know, four years of economic downturn and now this year with the poor snow. It's affecting all of us. I mean, it's scary out there right now. And great, we have some snow and it's definitely going to help us out. But with what's going on, if we just have basic services and where this is leading, it's going to affect businesses.
1:06:19 It's going to affect visitation, and it's going to affect property values, and that's pretty scary. Chair, if I may, to your point, which is really well taken, in some measure it really does come down to a definition of what is basic, and we have spent countless hours both in negotiation and
1:06:47 I just want to assure you that I don't consider basic
1:07:16 Services to include only plowing the roads and filling the potholes and recognize what the importance is of the relationship between the town and the money that it spends and its businesses and the people they employ. So you have our ear and you're certainly making the right comment.
1:07:41 That, in some measure, lies at the heart of the gap between the two sides. And I guess my comment to that, if this community isn't viable, then there's no money to pay a settlement anymore. That's correct. Okay. All right. One of the things I'm hearing, and thankfully I'm ignorant to bankruptcy proceedings, is that basically bankruptcy is federal mediation and settlement and restructuring.
1:08:16 So we seem to have a debt of $30 million. It's now $42 million. So there's this huge cost of fighting or trying to renegotiate. My question to the council, et cetera, would be, is it a good investment to continue fighting? What's the difference between bankruptcy and trying to settle for an amount that you've just articulated that there's no possible way that you pay? Thank you.
1:08:50 It's not an easy answer. It's a complicated subject. But I think the answer is that we have to do our very best to settle it. And the last comment by Terry Skellig is, as Rick indicated, there's important difference in what we believe is a basic service to the town. And we're defending that service. We think it's very important. And it's worth it for us to defend that at the same time trying to reach a settlement.
1:09:20 It's worth the time and effort and money to do that because it has such a long and pervasive problem that we can't. If we wind up having to pay more than we can afford, things are going to change dramatically. We're not going to be able to provide the resource services that community needs to its visitation and its tourism. So it's worth it for us to defend that. When we go into the bankruptcy process, if that happens, one of the things we need to do is defend that we have done it.
1:09:49 That we're at a point of insolvency. That when we move forward, we aren't able to meet our needs and our debt. So it's a requirement that I think we can take seriously. We've done our very best to go through the process to achieve. We would say, oh, a lot of settlement is what we want. And ultimately, it will happen. And it will happen in bankruptcy, or it will happen in mediation, or if it happened if someone has a change of heart tonight. But we have to preserve what we have as much as possible.
1:10:27 Jeremy Glico, Citizen of Mammoth Lakes and Local Business Owner. It seems like the Town Council has done a really good job trying to cut back, you know, whenever I'm looking at my business, obviously we have this massive debt in front of us, we want to get rid of expenses, it seems like we've done that. Has the Town Council done anything to try to help generate business, or do we have any plans in place to do that, to help
1:10:56 Bring visitors here, drive business towards the town. Is that part of our plan moving forward with possibly dealing with this massive debt that we have on our hands? So the town to measure A allocates about $2.4 billion to tourism a year. That allocation is specifically to determine or set aside for tourism dollars. How do you do the marketing as well as a lot of other things? And we are very, very interested and concerned about reserving this budget-based process.
1:11:29 We're also working on our TOT ordinance, revising that as well as being much more active in proportion of the TOT. Okay, one final chance. I know someone out there still has some questions. All right. I guess I was wrong, so do we want to take a quick break at this point? Five-minute break? Thank you all for coming and for speaking out. If you did not feel that you could speak out, please feel free to call or send an email. Thank you.
1:12:09 We're going to go back into session, and we are now at public comment on items that are not a portion of tonight's agenda. If you have a comment, please come forward to the podium. I'm here to introduce you to Jamin. She is a guide dog in training. She's seven months old. And I'll have her for about another seven months to a year. And I'm here this evening to talk about etiquette of how to approach a guide dog.
1:14:28 When you approach a guide dog, always ask first if you can pet the dog. And if the person says no to you, don't take it as an insult because this is a working dog. And they have to learn not to always be jumping and licking people. And if you pet them a whole bunch, then they start soliciting people. And they need to be focused on the person they're with. And they need to learn to ignore people and to ignore dogs. And not to give them any treats also.
1:14:55 They are on a very strict schedule of when they eat. And we're teaching them, like, she has a green vest on. She cannot go to the bathroom until I take that off and I ask her to go to the bathroom. If she goes too much in her vest, she could be career changed. So if you feed them treats and everything, it will throw off their system. And they might have to go to the bathroom, like, to the little store or something. You don't want that to happen. So please do not feed them any treats.
1:15:24 Always, always ask somebody before you pet them. That's the main thing. And when you're at lawns, one thing I've noticed there is people sometimes, when you're walking, you're looking real fast and you're looking for what you're looking for. People at Christmas time, I was told there was a guide dog that somebody ran over their tail with a shopping cart. You need to look down once in a while and realize that there are things lower because these are service dogs and someday a blind person will be walking through lawns with one and you want to be cordial to them at all times.
1:15:54 And the guide dogs are always looking for puppy raisers and puppy sitters. And the puppy club that I belong to is always looking for them. And you can call Betsy Thompson and Bishop. And her phone number is area code 760-258-1189. And I gave each of you, you guys all have these, right? Yep.
1:16:18 I'll try to stay up with you guys so you'll know if Jamin makes it or not. I really do hope she makes it because she's going to be an awesome daughter to somebody. And the next thing I'd like to mention is I want to thank Mammoth Mountain for the wonderful, wonderful job that they have done since December making man-made snow. A lot of people called me lately and said, I'm not coming. You don't have enough snow. We're canceling our trip. I want people to know it's not how many feet you have. The mountain is...
1:16:47 Been doing an excellent job on man-made snow, and it is a blast. It's fun. It's a dream to be able to go down and run by yourself with nobody around after its room. I think people are really missing out on a good time to get yourself up here and enjoy the mountain because it's beautiful and the sky is blue, everything, so I encourage people to come. Thank you. Thank you, Lee. Is there anyone else for public comment? Good evening, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism.
1:17:22 I just wanted to give you a couple of different updates, and one of them pertains to the conversation about air subsidy and what we're doing in that direction. We got our first meeting of the steering committee of the Eastern Sierra Air Alliance last week, and the steering committee is really made up of the stakeholders that are involved, the mountain, the town, the county, and the airport commission. And we just really had the first kickoff meeting last week to talk about how we can start to look forward to public-private partnerships.
1:17:48 What we need to look at for air service moving forward and how we can sustain service even if we're falling on tough times here. The one thing I do ask is last time we were here, Matthew joined the meeting as a volunteer at that point. I don't see it on the agenda to officially appoint someone, so we do need to make sure that that gets either added or addressed. I'm not sure how we get that on there.
1:18:20 Think about it in terms of ad hoc and other members of the council can come and go as they like. That's fine as well. It certainly is appropriate as well. No, that's fine. I think we have participation when available. That would be fantastic as well. Okay. The second thing is just a reminder for tomorrow night with the Mammoth Lakes Track and Field Project coming online here. Hopefully this spring is groundbreaking. There's a fundraiser tomorrow night at Rafters.
1:18:48 From 5 o'clock to 7.30, and we encourage everybody to come and see what's going on with the project, and I know that we're getting very close to being able to fund Phase 1, which would be fantastic and would be another opportunity for us to combat the challenges that we have in a year like this where there's not as much snow to bring in as many people. It gives us off-season opportunity, and then it also enhances the summer activity. So, again, 5 to 7.30 tomorrow night at Raptors, so look forward to seeing folks there.
1:19:14 Thank you. John, real quick, while we got you, can you share with us how we are looking occupancy-wise for the holiday weekend coming up? You know, the snow is definitely getting the phones to ring. You know, we're definitely off a little bit from where we were last year, and I have a feeling that our ADR, our average daily rates, will be a little bit lower because people have been willing to deal, you know, they've been cutting down on their limited night store.
1:19:38 Required night stays and things like that, but we are getting much stronger. I had a property email me today that said that they're up to 90% for the weekend, and I think that this snow definitely is an unexpected benefit right now, and the phones are definitely ringing. Is the village, is it typically near full occupancy on a weekend like this? You know, I think last year we...
1:20:04 The report comes out tomorrow, but I think we were about 84% last year, so it'll be interesting to see. You're talking town-wide? Correct. I meant at the village. Yeah, that I don't know. Don't know. I don't have it broken out. Basically, the way we run the occupancy is it's a sampling of 30 properties that represent everything from smaller properties to bigger properties, condos, hotels, motels. Okay. So we have a good mix of what we're looking at. Moving forward as part of our TOT compliance group, we're actually getting a much better reporting from all properties.
1:20:34 It won't be as immediate because the TOT process is a little bit of a delay to it, but what it will do is it will give us a six-month pacing. So we'll be able to know that for two months from now that we're pacing 20% ahead of where we were pacing the exact same time last year. So at least we can do some planning to say we expect TOT to be up that month versus we expect TOT to be down that month, then we can make some budget adjustments either way. Okay. Thank you. You're welcome. Any other questions?
1:21:02 John, did you want us to agendize that? No, let me think about that and we'll get back to you on that one. Excellent. Thanks very much. Thank you, John. Anyone else? Seeing none, we'll move on to Councilmember Reports. Skip? I have nothing, Madam Mayor. Rick? I'll defer to the next meeting on Mammoth Lakes Housing Report. John? Madam Mayor, I had just a single report met on Monday of last week.
1:21:34 For the Great Basin Air Pollution Control District down in Bishop, the relevance of that, the particular relevance of that meeting was the general manager of LADWP, Ron Nichols was in attendance with a few of their attorneys and he made a presentation to the board and the basis of the presentation is that DWP is looking for some certainty as to when the
1:22:00 They might anticipate the end of their requirements for dust control mitigation on the Owens Dry Lake. And, of course, it wasn't agendized for any action, but they, in these tight water times, they seem to be, in many times, they seem to be looking to wrap it up. They have mitigated approximately 80% of the dust on the lake, and they
1:22:26 It's their opinion that that's enough, that some of the additional 20% dust on the lake is historic, if you will, and wasn't caused from LADWP diversions, so that would be a discussion. He was also there to request the board to defer $250,000 that we have requested reimbursement from them because they were late on another portion of the dust control measures on the lake.
1:22:56 So, that's it. Oh, yeah, I'm sorry, final thing, and this number's been out before, but LEDWP has actually spent in excess of a billion dollars in controlling the dust on the Owens Lake, so that's another reason that they're looking to try to wrap that project up. Okay, Matthew? Thank you, Madam Mayor. I have two reports. One,
1:23:24 Been meeting with the Chamber of Commerce on a number of different issues, and I just wanted to report back on some of the things that the Chamber's trying to do to really improve some of the things that we're doing in the community. One, they're starting an educational committee, and what this is going to do, it's really going to be providing some educational tools for businesses, you know, touch on different areas, whether it be law or various...
1:23:54 Software programs, things like that, just educating the business community a little bit more, providing some tools out there that may not readily be available to the business community. They're also going to be starting a finance committee, and this will really, the goal of this will really to be touch on what one of the citizens, Jeremy, I believe it was, said earlier, trying to improve the revenue.
1:24:18 Coming into the community, so they'll be focusing on things like trying to expand events, working to help out the lodging association or staff on increasing TOT, revenue enforcement procedures, things like that to really help out the business and lodging community. And finally, this year, with one of the events that the Chamber's put on, the Mammoth Rocks event, it's their goal to try to expand the event.
1:24:45 A little bit and increase occupancy up to 10% this year. So those are a couple of their goals and I think the chamber president will touch on a few others that they're working on. And then I don't know if staff's going to touch on this or not, but I'll hit a few items regarding TOT collection. The TOT enforcement procedures, that committee's moving forward with a lot of momentum. The group's making strides in
1:25:14 Some of their enforcement and programming procedures. They're computerizing a lot of the reporting efforts that are out there. And they're working with tourism to work better with the lodging community on, as John said earlier, the six-month pacing so we have a better idea of what's going on over the up-and-coming six months versus the last six. Just something to kind of help us look for some better indicators for business and whatnot. So that's all I have.
1:25:44 Okay, I have just one item, which is to report that we had the Local Transportation Commission meeting this Monday, and Sandy Hogan attended her first meeting as our other appointed representative. We do not know yet about the funding for the 2012 summer that we should know at the next meeting. Jo, can I ask a question on that? Does that, the funding, does that include the, what did they call it? That's the state, what they call the CGC. Yeah.
1:26:14 But is that funding for the project that they're talking about doing up at Lake Topaz? High Point Curve is already funded to be done this summer. These were the additional requests, other things that are continuing. Do we know approximately what the start date is for that North Point? May. May. Is it May? Yes. And they will actually be closing the road completely at night. Oh, good. We've got Peter here. Thank you.
1:26:44 Yeah, it should be May. They did have an irregularity in the low bidder, and so they're going with the second bidder. They have to go back to the CTC to get some additional funding to augment their price. But the plan is to start in May, and it'll be the two weeks of heart closures at night, or during that period when they're doing the major demo, and then we'll be open with the routine. But that project, is that a six-month project?
1:27:12 That'll be all, basically, I think the full contract is for two seasons. Two, okay. Most of the work will be done this summer. Thank you. Thank you, Peter. Joe, if I could just add to that. So if you're thinking, if you're going to Reno in May, June, July, August, you may want to take the Smith Valley route out of Bridgeport if you're going north. And just before you come up the hill to come into Lake Topaz, there's a turnoff to your right to...
1:27:42 Holbrook. Holbrook. Yes, Holbrook Junction. You'll take that turn off and come down through the back way, coming back down, just so you know. You can kind of plan on it. Thank you. Okay, do we have any additions to the agenda? Do we have any commission updates? Okay. Do we have any department reports or emerging issues? Yes, good evening. Again, Watson Police Chief. I'd like to give you an update on our medical marijuana ordinance.
1:28:21 As you know, the voters approved an ordinance in 2010 that authorized up to two cooperatives in town. The process was initiated in the summer of 2010, resulting in five applicants. Following a review process, the Planning Commission selected the two that were granted the permits.
1:28:48 The conditional use permit from the planning department and then police department issued one-year permits for each of them. Those permits were due to expire in late 2011. The ordinance requires the permit holder, if they want to renew the permit, to go through a renewal process. One of the permit holders initiated that process. The other chose not to continue the operation.
1:29:13 That location, which was Green Mammoth, closes doors in late 2011 and is no longer in operation. Since then, the Community Development Department and the Police Department have been approached by at least two different individuals that have expressed interest in taking over the permit that was not renewed. The town manager and I have discussed this and we believe that a temporary moratorium on issuing a second permit is appropriate for the time being.
1:29:42 That's because the state's medical marijuana laws are in a state of flux. There are a number of things that are on the horizon that could be changing how they're operated. There's three basic reasons that I see. One of them is that there are, I believe there's three cases that are going to be heard by the California Supreme Court. One of them involved the town of Long Beach, the city of Long Beach, that had an ordinance that was not identical but similar to ours in many ways.
1:30:10 In that it had a selection process for determining how many cooperatives or dispensaries are going to be authorized. The court case in question determined that the Long Beach ordinance was unconstitutional, which could have a potential impact on ours since ours is somewhat similar. Although because the Supreme Court is going to hear it, the results of that are not binding for the time being.
1:30:37 Another reason is the U.S. Attorney's Office has stepped up their examination on medical marijuana operations in California. What I understand is they are really focusing on larger, large-scale operations that are more commercial in the way they're operated. But I don't think that means that we can expect them swooping down on our town. But it does mean that there might be some changes as a result of their efforts.
1:31:06 Finally, the state's relatively new Attorney General has reviewed guidelines that were prepared by the previous Attorney General, now Governor Brown. There was about a year-long period where local district attorneys and law enforcement were expecting some new guidelines. Within the last month or so, the Attorney General informed all the district attorneys in the state that she will not be issuing any new guidelines. And her position is that she believes this is something for...
1:31:35 The courts to resolve and potentially for the state legislature if they want to make any changes. We still have one permitted cooperative in town. Those people that have medical marijuana cards and the need for medical marijuana do have the opportunity to obtain it within town. So there's not the lost opportunity for those people that have the need for it.
1:31:58 So that's the direction that we intend on going for the time being. I don't believe there's any action required by the council. I just wanted to inform you that's where we are. Any questions again? Thank you. Thank you. Good evening, Mayor, members of the council. Mark Wardlock, Community Development Director. First, I'd like to give you some more update on our TOT compliance program. Last week, we had a meeting with our TOT committee.
1:32:32 And the TOT committee actually presented to us some of their research that they've been doing on vacation rental by order program. And for us, it was a very useful discussion to go through research tips and then how we can follow up. And based on that discussion, we've been able to take some of the...
1:32:53 Difficult to identify cases and distribute them to local folks who are aware of individual buildings where we might not have an address. So our progress is picking up a lot of good work through that group. We're very thankful for their time and commitment to that program. The letter to Senator Gaines has been completed and we're working with Mono County to assist us with getting it through that process to the Senator.
1:33:21 We're starting to firm up our schedule for audit programs. We expect to begin those in May. We'll be working with Mono County and augmenting with our own community development staff on that program. Tonight we'll have a public hearing to consider some ordinance changes, and we'll implement the TOT program. And then finally, our...
1:33:45 Caseload is really quite large now. We have 126 total cases. That's up from the last two-week period of 101. And this week we have additional warnings going out and two more citations. So we're well into the administrative citation process. Any questions on TOT? Also, I'm very pleased to report that we have now received and posted
1:34:13 The Mammoth Yosemite Airport Layout Plan Update Narrative Report Peer Review. In September, the Airport Commission was fielding an awful lot of public questions and comments about the document. The Commission itself had comments, and they requested that we contract with a different, qualified airport planning or service consulting firm. We went through a competitive process.
1:34:42 And we started that program, and we're on schedule with this effort. We ended up, through that competitive process, hiring Mead and Hunt. And in this report, which is located on our website, we're responding to 283 separate public comments and questions. The report is very thorough. The airport commission will be holding a meeting on February 28th at 3 p.m. That will be their regular airport commission. And the sole matter on that agenda will be this report.
1:35:11 We'll ask the Commission to review this document and find their points of consensus and provide us staff, airport and community development staff, on direction to complete any revisions to the draft airport layout plan update narrative. And then based on their direction, we would return to them with a revised document for their consideration and recommendation and addressing any additional questions.
1:35:38 We receive up to that point in time. And then we'll return to the Planning Commission for general plan consistency recommendation. And then we'll come to the Town Council in probably March, maybe April, to seek your direction on filing with the FAA an airport layout plan. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Any others?
1:36:05 Okay, we'll move on to the consent agenda. I have requests to pull item 4 and item 8. Are there any others council wishes to pull or any member of the audience? Okay, then I would look for a motion. Madam Mayor, I'll move for approval of consent agenda items 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9, 10, and 11.
1:36:28 I'll second that. Thank you. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Erickson? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Layman? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. On number 4, I believe we have a new recommendation from staff. So moved. I'll second that.
1:36:55 For the benefit of the public, that is to reject all bids and direct staff to rebid the project. We have a motion to second. Jamie, roll call vote, please. Oh, I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Do you wish to speak on it? Is it too late to speak on it? No. This is regarding the town yard terrific lighting project? Yes, it is. My name is Ryan Bernigmeyer. I am the operating officer with FG Electric.
1:37:25 Several things I'd like to put up. Putting this job back out to bid makes it no longer a blind bidding process. My exact numbers that I've proposed to the town are not public record. One of the concerns from two weeks ago was the discrepancy regarding the fixture count, some fixtures being at eight feet off the ground versus 20 feet off the ground. If you say that going up to 20 feet off the ground adds $20 per fixture,
1:37:56 To your cost, and you count the fact that it's 22 fixtures, that's $400. The difference in the two bids is over $2,000. I don't know if this means it's a good idea to hold it up. Also, my cost will be increasing if I'm forced to rebid this. I just got a call yesterday from my wholesaler reminding me that my time's running out to actually use the bid I got from him for my materials.
1:38:28 And I know fluorescent light fixtures, mostly fluorescent bulbs, the costs are increasing faster than on a yearly basis these days. Also, we just heard in the beginning of today's meeting that there is a good chance, well, no, I shouldn't say that, there is a possibility that contractors will in the near future end up in mediation started by the process with MLLA.
1:38:58 If I'm faced with that reality, I'm also going to have to add more money to my bid to make up for the uncertainty of whether or not I'm going to get paid the full amount. Next, my last point, I've been in business, I've worked for Michael Kelly for at least eight years, and I've been in business for myself for more than four years. In all that time, I've never seen a bid or put in a bid where there was zero questions.
1:39:28 It doesn't happen. Please keep that in mind. Okay, thank you. Just a joke. We just wanted a million complaints. The money that's made for this comes from SCE relative to rebates. So that's going to be accepted from the lawsuit. Am I going to be... Is the winning bidder going to be paid directly by the town or by SCE? The bidder will be paid by the town as I understand. Peter did... Yeah, the bidder...
1:40:13 The contract's with the town, and so the town would be paying all of the expenses with the project and then being reimbursed from this for the rebates, and then we have a loan for part of the project from Edison. Peter, while we got you there, I'm somewhat uncomfortable that we're doing this, and I'm assuming that there's a legal reason why we're doing it. There's not a legal reason. Not.
1:40:46 I'm just wondering if there's not a legal problem.
1:41:08 As one of five council members, I'm willing to move forward with this particular proposal and making the adjustments in our bidding process for our next bid. I agree. Do you agree? Yeah, okay. Then I'll withdraw my motion. I'll withdraw my second. And I'll make a motion to approve option number four and award the bid to the town. Excuse me, option one. I'm sorry, option number one and award the contract to the town.
1:41:37 Yard Lighting Retrofit Project to FG Electric Incorporated. I have a question. Do I have a second? Oh, sorry. I need a second. I'd second. Okay. You got a second. So, Dave, if we go with option two, how long is it going to take to reopen the bidding process and get it through? Well, it's not understanding the leader can respond specifically. The work has to be accomplished and paid for at the end of the fiscal year and so forth.
1:42:08 It would take about a week to repackage the bid, and so it would be out to bid in about two weeks. We'd try to award it at the first meeting in April. And so all work would be done by the first of June, which would give us 30 days to process the paperwork with Edison. Oops, there goes our lights again. And I have one additional question that I want to make clear that because the money is coming from Edison,
1:42:41 It is considered restricted funds designated to that particular purpose. Yes. Okay, so the money is there to be spent. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? No. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem Layman? Yes. Mayor Bacon? No. Motion passes 3-2. Item number 8, I believe, was pulled by a member of the audience.
1:43:21 Good evening. I'm Donna Hustleton. I had an opportunity to read the advisory body's handbook, and I went back to see who wrote it. It happened to be Jamie. And I wanted to thank her for all her hard work, and it was an excellent update to the original body, advisory. And I always – government doesn't always get recognized for their hard work, and I wanted to point that out in this meeting. Thank you. Thank you. So do I have a motion?
1:43:56 I'll make a motion, Madam Mayor, that we approve Agenda Item Number 8. Second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote. Please go me. Council Member Eastman? Yes. Council Member Herbie? Yes. Council Member Wood? Yes. Council Member Linden? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes. 5-0. We will now move on to a public hearing regarding changes to several chapters, the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code.
1:44:26 To clarify and amend civil penalties, et cetera, so I will first open the hearing and ask for a statement of presentation from staff. Mayor, members of the council, Mark Woodlaw, community developer, developer, development. I apologize, I have a cold, so I have a lozenge in my mouth and I may cough during this presentation. Thank you, Dave. The purpose of this public hearing is to allow the town council to consider amending
1:44:57 Chapters 1.12, 3.12, 8.20, and 8.32 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code to clarify and amend civil penalties and administrative citations punishable as misdemeanors and infractions, the amount and structure of fines, definitions, and the collection of enforcement costs related to code enforcement procedures and penalties. This to improve the effectiveness
1:45:27 of our T.O.T. enforcement and collection program as well as other municipal code enforcement activities that we conduct throughout the town. The town's existing civil penalty and administrative citation procedures in the code are rather ambiguous and they're unclear and in some cases they don't comply with state law. These amendments clarify that and effectively simplify our enforcement efforts.
1:45:55 It's very onerous sometimes for us to try to chase down violators and to achieve compliance with the code. This will streamline and perfect these procedures. We've worked with the town attorney who has done extensive work with other municipalities in code compliance programs. They've essentially drafted these changes for us, and we're working also with them to develop a code compliance manual. The essence of the changes are in Chapter 1.2.
1:46:23 Include reorganizing the chapter to include new and modified definitions. Chapter 8.20 would allow amendments to three sections. These changes include new and improved procedures regarding liens, special assessments, and alternative remedies for collecting unpaid fees and fines. Chapter 8.32 is also confusing and difficult to implement.
1:46:53 This will effectively address and delete Article II civil penalties and replace them with other language. And then finally, Chapter 3.12 will amend the progressive fine structure for generic violations of the chapter.
1:47:13 Limit increased fines for violations within a one-year period. And I'll also remove the specific TOT-related references to code and refer back to those penalties in Chapter 8. Finally, your options are to waive the first reading and introduce by title only the attached ordinance adopting these amendments or deny the proposed amendments. Staff recommends
1:47:40 I have one, and it's just the clarification that in Chapter 3.12,
1:48:10 If I understand it correctly, the mechanism is to take the amount out of this particular ordinance, but then we as a council in setting fees and fines as we are allowed to would be doing it through that way. That's what it means by saying allowing the town to decide. Andy Morris, town attorney. That's correct, Madam Mary. Instead of having specific TOT fines, it's a cross-reference to the general fine and penalty provision in the code, which is how it's more typically done.
1:48:38 If the law changes so that the town can assess fines for misdemeanors and infractions that are different, you only have to make the change in one place in the code rather than having to go through and make it in a bunch of places. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? Is there anyone in the audience that would wish to comment on this issue? Come up to the podium. No? Does this just have to do with TOT or does it have anything to do with any compliance?
1:49:09 These ordinance changes apply to all of our code enforcement activities, whether it's building permit, land use zoning, actual nuisance abatement, or TOT, municipal revenue enforcement. What happens if you, our code compliance person is a building inspector, which is always busy, is it that kind of compliance, like if somebody's dumping snow on the street, or dumping snow on people's properties, or... Essentially, the municipal code...
1:49:37 We no longer have one dedicated position to be code compliance, but in
1:50:07 Okay, because I have concerns about this.
1:50:36 In the past, if somebody was dumping snow on the street and we called the town up, they would tell me we can't do anything because we can't give one person a fine, we have to give everybody a fine and we don't have the finances to hire somebody to go out and do it to everybody. So, you know, with you guys budget cutting and all that stuff and you'll be getting more people back, there's a service that's gone and there's a lot of issues in Sierra Valley sites. I know John Muir Road had some last week when we had the snow on this one.
1:51:03 How are you going to get the people out there to do the job when you're cutting people back and keep telling us that we can't do anything because we don't have the people and the manpower? And then when you leave a message for somebody, it takes forever to get a call back sometimes because they're so busy. The lack of employees. What are you going to do? How do we do help compliance? That's my question. Thanks. Okay. Anyone else? Seeing then, I will close the public hearing. Oh, I'm sorry, Amy. Sorry.
1:51:35 Amy Cutter, President. So the question I have is two questions. One is, are the fines equal across all violations, or is it different depending upon what the violation is? Or are the fines actually stipulated in the... The fines are specified in the Unicode. State law...
1:51:58 It limits the amount of fines that the town can charge for most violations. There are a couple of exceptions. One is that building code violations can be charged fines that are higher. In other cases, actually, there's one thing that we're adding. State law allows the town to try to get not only recover its abatement costs but get triple its abatement costs to repeat offenders in some cases. So we've now added that to the code. So by and large, they're uniform, but there are some exceptions. So is there a schedule of the fines or the rate?
1:52:25 I didn't notice that. Yeah. That's in Chapter 1.12. Okay. And then the other question was somewhere in there there was a comment made about for every day the problem exists. In essence, there's a new citation. So you get fined a subsequent time. Is that true? And can you talk to how that works? Every day that a violation exists represents a new violation. So the town could write a separate citation for every day that a violation exists.
1:52:55 In practice, I don't know whether the town would actually do that or not, but that's pretty common. The law allows the cities and towns to do that, and most cities and towns do have it on the books that way, and then it's up to staff, up to their discretion about whether it actually makes sense to write someone 400 separate citations or whether a smaller number would do the trick. If I could, the objective of this program is to achieve compliance with the code. It's not intended to be
1:53:24 A revenue generator through fines, and fines are not actually covering the costs of our enforcement program. Okay. And then a final question, sorry, is, schedule? Oh, there was a section in the old code that sort of spoke to how the town works with the violator to achieve compliance, so there's some interim action that is performed before a fine is actually assigned.
1:53:56 Or a citation is given. Is there anything like that in this revised code or what the town is going to do? Yes. I mean, the revised code would call for due process to be observed, of course, always, but we think it's not necessary in all cases to have a specific process laid out. I mean, there is something that addresses how it would work. We essentially have discretion in what we are doing now through our TOT compliance program.
1:54:26 Is issuing letters of warning to notify people that it's come to our attention that there is a violation. The purpose of the warning is to actually create compliance. We give them time to do so and up to this point we've been issuing two letters of warning. The purpose of the citation letter is to say we're giving you ten days now to comply and if you don't this citation applies.
1:54:55 So, again, the citation method, whether it's an infraction and a fine or a misdemeanor that's going to civil proceedings, is really meant to catch the attention of the person that's not in compliance and achieve the correction. Okay, thank you. You're welcome. Thank you, Amy. Is there anyone else? Okay, I will close the public hearing, and council will deliberate, arrive at a decision.
1:55:28 Madam Mayor, I'll move that the council adopt option number one. I'll second that. I have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Brooks, I'm leaning? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Our next item is a policy matter regarding the measure used during committee process, et cetera. Good evening, Madam Mayor, members of town council, staff, and the community.
1:56:01 Before I invite SMG and Carl Roboto as in the audience this evening to present the Measure U process recommendations, I would like to personally and publicly thank the Measure U steering committee and the members, some are here this evening, and Carl Danner and the SMG team for their hard work, their intense scrutiny and dogged persistence, I think was a good term, in providing the absolute best recommendations for Town Council approval this evening.
1:56:31 I'm going to return after the presentation that Carl Roboto is going to make to you to present the staff recommendations for this item. So with that, Carl. Thanks, Stuart. Good evening, Madam Mayor and Town Council. It's a pleasure to be here. My name is Carl Roboto with the Strategic Marketing Group in South Lake Tahoe. And I appreciate the opportunity to come and present to you recommendations from the Measure U process.
1:57:17 Before I do, I want to let you know that I feel very confident that we've put together a very tight piece of work here. This has been an exhaustive process with an incredible cast of volunteers and staff to assist in this important effort. Our project goal was very simple, was to work with the town council appointed Measure U steering committee to develop a Measure U funding process for the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:57:46 You guys are very unique in this state that you have such a Measure U, and I think the process that has been developed to absolutely try and fund in the best possible way has been achieved with this. As Stuart mentioned, we had an incredible support group with the Measure U Steering Committee. I definitely want to acknowledge them. In total, that group put in over 190 volunteer hours in this process.
1:58:16 So I think it's important to acknowledge that the time and effort that this crew put in. And they're very different than any other committee I have ever dealt with. We had probably four original meetings scheduled. They actually liked to meet. They wanted to meet to make sure that this thing was as tight with as many I's dotted and T's crossed as they possibly could.
1:58:43 I kept thinking, oh, we can do this on the phone. No, we've got to have another meeting. You know, and so to their credit, they have put in a tremendous amount of time on behalf of the community. As far as deliverables, we have a number of pieces for your consideration. The first is the final report addressing all areas of the RFP. That was laid out. We have developed a Measure U filter to help filter applicants through the process.
1:59:11 We have an application that was developed, and then we have even a glossary of terms for people to understand what's in the documents. So, again, a very, very comprehensive effort. What I'd like to do is just spend a little bit of time focused on the recommendations. I know you're very busy tonight, so I'll move through these as quickly as possible. The first was in the area of supplanting. I believe the town council asked for a recommendation on supplanting.
1:59:40 And the group spent quite a bit of time working through that issue. It is before you. I'm not sure if you want me to read through it word by word. You've got it. But they did come up with a very comprehensive and tight definition of what supplanting could be and have made that recommendation to you. They did develop a Measure U application and process. It is a six-step.
2:00:05 process that is laid out in the report on page 11 that really takes you through exactly how this whole thing should move forward. They also agreed that everyone has to complete the application process before they can move on. In terms of revenue, any areas of revenue allocation, town administration needs to identify
2:00:33 What staff and what level measure you funding will require. The group recommended administrative fees not to exceed 4%. That may have to be reviewed at some point, but I think it was a very good starting point that the group recommended. If an applicant does not meet the primary filter requirement, in other words, you have to get all five yeses, then you're kicked out of the system.
2:01:01 To reapply at a future funding cycle. And we've spent a lot of time in the process of how that person can get that applications and filters squared away so they have the best possible chance to be successful in the process. If the town council doesn't agree with Measure U Application Committee funding recommendations, the complete set of applications is sent back altogether. It's an up or down vote on all the recommendations.
2:01:31 And that is, I think, designed so that there wouldn't be cherry picking on this and that. That this group was very committed to developing the best set of recommendations for the town's consideration and to get an up or down vote on those. The Measure U and R process should remain separate, but they are synchronized to align with the town's annual budget process. There's a lot of talk about aligning goals, priorities.
2:02:00 Processes all together to maximize, you know, and make it work within a funding cycle. And that Spring 2012 Measure U test process should be conducted to see how, in fact, that works. And again, changes can be made afterwards. Majority of funds should be allocated to capital-related projects for infrastructure and capacity building, though funds can also be available for programming and operations and maintenance.
2:02:29 There's a matrix with two components on it. The first is where the area of funding could occur, which would be mobility, recreation, or arts and culture. And then on another access, there's capital, programming, and operations. So somewhere in that matrix, projects can be looked at in an analytical way and funded appropriately.
2:02:56 The group also recommended that no ratio be established between so much money should go to recreation or so much money should go to mobility, but only the best projects should be moved through the process and allowed to come to the top without sort of preconceived, well, we've got to spend this over here or this over there. And these, again, received quite a bit of debate and discussion, but I think there's a very good framework.
2:03:25 To look at strategically how to spend the money. One of the overriding discussion points is, if you're five or ten years down the road, will this money have made a material and strategic difference in the town, or do you run the risk of sort of a little piece here, a little piece there, and turning back and saying, where did the money go? How did we leverage money? And so on and so forth. So the focus was on capital-related projects, but certainly there was funding.
2:03:53 Funding for viable projects that have feasibility testing and so forth in the areas of operations as well as programs. Capital projects should be adopted from town plans and should be provided to measure the application committee to help determine what qualifies as top tier projects. Again, there's a glossary on what top tier means that we've laid out.
2:04:22 But again, we want to have applicants look at the documents you've created so that nothing comes out of right field that doesn't fit into where you want to go as a town, as a town council, and that's why we want to have them look at documents like the, you know, your town plans and so forth. And Measure U funds do not need to be spent or awarded. If there's no good projects, the money stays in the bank to encourage
2:04:51 Projects to come forward. It's not a requirement that, hey, we've got to spend this money. It's we want to spend the money on the best projects absolutely possible. Prioritization process. A variety of projects exist in the town's adopted plan that should go through a funneling process to help prioritize the project. The prioritization funnel and town goals should serve as a guideline for resources for you application.
2:05:20 For the U Application Committee project to review and create funding recommendations. Again, everything is designed to come as a result of town priorities, town goals, and so forth, and there's a funnel. It starts at this big with all these ideas coming into it, and ends up this big with recommendations and recommended projects to be considered.
2:05:47 In terms of oversight, quite a bit. The Measure U application committee to be established to oversee the application process should be comprised of three individuals, a mobility commissioner, a recreation commissioner, and an at-large member representing the arts and culture community. A lot of debate on whether that should be three people, four people, five people. I think the intention of the group, and many of them here, so...
2:06:13 Jump in if I'm missing something, was to make this as efficient as possible, to not have unlimited committee, but to make it as absolutely efficient as possible. Again, it may need to be reviewed as the process goes on. The Measure U committee has volunteered to meet with the application committee once it is formed, and it's sort of a handoff, so their volunteer efforts continue.
2:06:38 Even though their primary efforts are done. We recommend, SMG recommends that both committees reconvene after the first funding cycle. How did it work? What changes need to be made? What can we improve on? What did we do good? What did we not do so good? And we also recommend the current measure of our application and evaluation criteria may be re-evaluated in light of some of the changes we've made to you. Okay? So there's a process of taking...
2:07:08 We took a look at R, made some refinements to Measure U. It might be time at some future point for the R process to look at, hey, Measure U, what can we learn from that process and make modifications. Project funding reports should follow a gap, generally accepted accounting principles. That should be a gap. You application committees make a final recommendation to the council, as we mentioned.
2:07:37 For an up or down vote, the EU application questions as submitted should be electronically formatted into a formal application that's user friendly and so forth. An instruction packet should be developed so that people can understand how to actually go through the process and so forth. We have also established a ratings guideline so that on the filter people know how to score and rate different projects. Again, the group was incredibly...
2:08:05 Thorough and detailed. The town should develop a list of standard procedures and operating guidelines to inform awarded projects what requirements are necessary for funding, how the town wants to get billing, how that billing is conducted, how reporting goes on, and so on and so forth. So we've made allowances for all that. We also recommend an annual Measure U program audit be conducted to make sure the funds are being used as they should be.
2:08:35 Getting to the end here real quickly. Application questions. We have, again, created an application. We took a look at what Measure R application was and made appropriate modifications to the Measure U application. And, again, this section should be evaluated and edited, again, after a cycle goes through so that we understand, again, what can be made better and so forth.
2:09:03 Feasibility questions should be answered by all applicants as defined in the pre-screening process. Again, this I think goes back to one of the findings coming out of rec strats. There's got to be some sort of level of feasibility attached to requests for funding. And some people may not be able to answer every question, but every attempt should be made to answer those questions. So as much complete information can be had as possible.
2:09:30 That concludes sort of the recommendations. It's very thorough in your materials, and I'd be happy to answer any questions that you may have. I will say, again, I think it's a very, very detailed and tight process. Are there any questions for Carl? I have a couple. Okay. Again, what was the update and award dates that are projected? I can't remember. Stuart? Roughly.
2:10:01 Is that for the test spring award? No. The final. Once we get it into the full process, I mean, do we know exactly when the application dates and then the award dates will be? I know you're trying to align them with the budget cycle. And the reason I ask the question is I've been through a couple of the measure cycles before. And one of the problems I think we have is so many of the things that we need are at the beginning of summer.
2:10:32 And then they don't know if they're going to get the money until after they have to program the entire event or something like that. And I'm just wondering if there's something built in to where, you know, people can find out sooner than later if they're going to receive funding because a lot of these things we do in the summertime, we start planning them six, nine months ahead. Yes, so part of the recommendations this evening for council is to, you know, approve that test.
2:11:00 Award that would align with the Measure R and would sync up with that town budget process and that's scheduled to open April 2nd, close May 2 and that would be awarded June 2027 or I'll just leave it hanging there. So I think that's the proposal as it stands right now and I think the goal after that was to re-evaluate that process and then try and align and schedule the major award time. Okay, okay. Okay, then I guess with that,
2:11:28 I'm wondering, are we set in stone on April and May, or can we push it back a month closer to us? Is that possible? Move it up. Start it in March and finish it in April? Only because I'm just concerned about a lot of this funding not being available. If we don't have the test done until June and all of a sudden a lot of these people that are going to be looking to receive an award, the programming's over.
2:11:58 I think a lot of the feedback too from the steering committee in their analysis was to try and align it with the town budget and to, from the town staff point of view, to try and align everything in context. So town council would be evaluating, you know, measure R, measure U and the town budget in one big context as opposed to kind of, you know, piecemealing these items. I see where you're coming from and want to move it forward. And from a staff point of view, once this work's done by this committee...
2:12:23 As Carl pointed out, there's a tremendous amount of work still to be done, you know, in building these forms, the applications, and convening the steering committee and the application committee together to get it. So actually April 2 was a pretty tight timeline for us to get it up and running. Okay. Yeah, I'm just hoping maybe the committee can look into that, because we ran into the same situation with the county on an event we did, and, you know, it came June, or actually it was...
2:12:47 March, April, and by the time we got to the point where they were able to do anything, they had already closed the funding cycle, and it was just kind of an odd process because the way our seasons work, but I do see why you want to align it, so hopefully we have some consideration on that. And then the other two questions I had were, you have on page three of nine, it says under supplanting policy recommendation, Measure U funds can be used to enhance and improve existing efforts.
2:13:18 As I understand it, this is supposed to be for new efforts. And I actually called up one of your members and got some clarification on it, but I'm just wondering, is there going to be any change in that to let people know that this is actually for newer projects? Or new efforts? I'm sorry? Page 3 of 9, item number 1. Oh, Lord.
2:13:46 A lot of debate on this issue in terms of what it meant. There may be an existing event, for example. That event in itself would not be eligible for funding. But if that event came before the group and said, hey, with this additional funding, we want to enhance and do something new. We want to reach a new target market. We want to add this component, which will increase the economic impact of this particular event or whatever it is.
2:14:16 That was permissible, but not funding sort of the core existing event. Okay. Yeah, and it was explained to me that way. I just didn't know if there was going to be some clarification on that. And then I guess the last question I had was, I noticed you had in your filter, you have, for example, number five, did the applicant provide detailed project, program, conceptual plan, and economic analysis? And then under item C of socioeconomic benefit, how much consideration or how are you...
2:14:44 Giving the consideration to the economic benefit of the funding application. We had many, many debates on that issue. We really, this group really tried to look at the economic and the social elements. And in fact, we stress tested the process using a Mommy and Me tumbling program. Could a Mommy and Me tumbling program
2:15:13 Get through the process and receive funding. And so the group was exhaustive and we had several champions on that, Rich included, that really tried to get a balance and to look at the economic as well as the social benefit to the community. And so if anyone can lay that out in their request, I think they'll score high. Okay. I'll leave it at that. I just...
2:15:42 You want to bring them up? Okay. You bet. I have one question. I'm not sure if it's you, Carl, or if it's Stuart. How much money is going to be in this test cycle? Stuart? So on page 7 and 9 of the agenda bill, middle of the page has financial considerations. So a balance of $296,189.35 currently resides in that measure you account.
2:16:14 We're asking for an appropriation this evening of 1% of the annual amount of 9,228. So really the final amount for award will be determined by staff in conjunction with the Measured Application Committee and any direction from Town Council. This balance was as of January 24th, so when the application period opens, those funds have to be available. So we'll go and recalculate how much we want to put in there, but I think...
2:16:41 So are you looking for direction on whether to do a portion of it, all of it, or...? The annual allocation of Measure U, I believe, was about $922,000. Again, that will obviously fluctuate based on the town budget. So the $296 is consistent with like a spring award for Measure R. It's typically about a third of that funding amount. So where it currently sits is about a third of that funding amount.
2:17:10 And then the rest of those funds will roll over to that major reward period. So we believe it's pretty consistent with that R and the way we've kind of put it together. Okay, but if we only received $300,000 by January, are we really going to hit $900,000 this year? Cindy could probably answer that with finance, but that's, I think it all, the way, the way just... That was a rhetorical question. I'm with you, sorry. I guess we'll get to that. Okay, any other questions? Are there...
2:17:41 Any questions from the community of Carl or Stuart? Oh, you have a question too, Rick? Actually, I have a question of one of the two gentlemen sitting in the first row on the right-hand side of the room as participants. And mine is, either to John or to Bill or to both, what do you see as the difference between the supplanting language as proposed for you and the existing supplanting language in R? And was that something that was considered or was R used as either
2:18:10 A template or as comparative language when this language was drafted. We started out at R and I think that you're going to see actually a recommendation from us coming back to amend the what we call an R where it exists and exists in different places in both to amend R and fall more into line with what we have come up with for you. We think it's a better approach or definition.
2:18:46 Yeah. John? My two cents. Having been through the Measure R draft of the legislation process, the steering committee, all those efforts, the haggling over the language of Measure R, I think that the Measure U definition for supplanting is better than the Measure R language. I think it had a chance to season a little bit. The Measure U committee looked at it very thoroughly.
2:19:13 The Recreation Commission at the last meeting, I think, made a recommendation to include that language as part of the recommendation from Mr. Hogan Ford. I think it's more facile. I think it covers the issue of improving existing things in a way. To Matthew's point earlier, it's a lot clearer and makes a lot more sense. Thank you. Any more questions from Council? Any questions from the community or comments that other members of the committee might want to make? All right. Go ahead.
2:19:45 Our portion is the same thing a little bit that Matthew hit up a little before. When we look at where the town's headed with the TOT tax, maybe a million two, maybe a million three, that's not going to be there. We see it and would recognize all this great work that's going into this recommendation. We encourage a decision process that would at least move forward more towards like a month earlier.
2:20:11 Just so there could be some awarding of funds so that people would know and get some things started for the summertime. And if there's a way to increase that backside, if the application process is April 2nd, maybe there could be a decision process by Memorial Day. I know it puts a little more demand, but I think we're in a time where we do have to respond to demands, where we do have to respond to the realities of our economic situation in town.
2:20:32 And this will at least allow parties to be involved. I don't think there's going to be a lack of applications. I think there's going to be a ton of applications for this money. I think it's going to be a difficult process to sort through those. But we would encourage and hope that the council would look at that time frame and say, let's have a decision date that's a little sooner so we can utilize that money this summer. Okay, thank you, Fred. And who else? Donna Hustleton. The supplanting language in Measure R versus Measure U.
2:21:06 There's been quite a debate about it, and one of the things that keeps coming up is do we let our existing parks and wrecks, the maintenance part of it, or if you want to call supplanting or the improvement part of it, go by the wayside, we let it deteriorate. So I don't think many of us want to do that, and it does say enhancement of facilities, and it says enhancement of all of our parks.
2:21:35 I hope that we don't go in the direction of it's only going to be for new items and we let other things go by the wayside. So this keeps coming up a lot and considering the state that the town is in, I just wouldn't want to see what we have now deteriorate. Thanks. Thank you, Donette. Just to respond to that, I think that John Wentworth actually
2:22:04 said it well, is that the ordinance was written differently, and yes, the measure R supplanting is probably something that will be looked at again, but is not under consideration tonight. Okay. All right. I believe Ms. Huzelton makes an excellent point. I did hear, and I think I'm correct on this, the majority of funds will go to capital projects.
2:22:37 You're at risk of everyone likes a bright, new, shiny project, but how are they maintained? The novelist Kurt Vonnegut said everybody likes to build, but nobody likes to do maintenance. I think I would take that majority language out and give yourselves some leeway. Carl, could you speak to the other portions that are considered for funding? Yeah, we talked a lot about ongoing maintenance and operations.
2:23:07 Certainly eligible for funding under this proposal. In fact, if somebody were to put a capital project forward, you would anticipate seeing a certain amount for building and so forth and a certain amount for ongoing maintenance and so forth. So the committee did spend a lot of time dealing with that exact very issue because he didn't want to just build something and not have any funds available to upkeep the maintenance.
2:23:35 Okay. I don't think that actually goes to Ted's point.
2:24:05 And I want to hear from the committee on this. You know, the politics of the measures R and U included the idea that if we were to adopt by a two-thirds plus one majority an ordinance that effectively restricted the use of the funds, then the town...
2:24:35 Council at whatever time in the future would not be able to use those funds as a replacement for funds that have previously been allocated for things that exist already. And I believe that the voters passed that measure because they wanted to effectively restrict the council from
2:25:01 Reducing, for example, the Parks and Recreation budget because all of a sudden there's a couple of million dollars available to do the same thing that general funds would already provide. Now, we're in a fiscal reality today that is much different than that which existed at the time these measures were passed. But still, I think the point of the community, and I hear it regularly, is
2:25:29 Why would we build something new at the same time as letting something that already exists deteriorate because we don't have the general funds, legitimately don't have the general funds? And so I think, and I'm looking forward to Bill speaking to this because this is not a new discussion or debate. And the reality is that we've got competing interests. The flexibility of the language that is proposed on supplanting
2:25:59 gives provides the opportunity to do which the vote that which the voters didn't really want the council to do and I can't predict what this council or for that matter future councils will do but I recognize the conflict or at least the competing intent of the language versus versus simply
2:26:27 I guess the expanded or more flexible language versus a more rigid interpretation. To your point, Councilman, it is the elephant in the room that guides every bit of discussion based on the situation that the community is in. And I'll let Bill speak on his behalf, but from the committee's standpoint, it was a very long discussion on exactly that issue. So I'll let the others speak.
2:26:59 I think the importance of the supplanting language isn't that at some point we might not have to supplant. In fact, if we look at the Measure R process, we have supplanted regularly. If we look at the tennis courts in particular, in a workshop we had with the council, we pretty much all agreed that the maintenance at the tennis facility was supplanted. The town had maintained and done the crack seal and everything else for years leading up to Measure R.
2:27:27 When Measure R first paid for that because there was no money in the general fund to do it, no money has been found since. It has been an ongoing annual maintenance item for Measure R. It is important to me personally, and I'm not going to speak on behalf of the committee, there's enough of them here, they can get up and do it, that these funds can't slowly go to what the town's current obligations are to maintain their parks. I don't think any of us that are involved
2:27:58 If we get to the point where we cannot maintain our parks, we would not allocate money to do that before building new. But we don't want to make it easy for these funds to go into an annual revenue stream to pay for things that perhaps should come from other places. And we've seen attempts at this already in the past. And when we have put our foot down or come up and cried like babies, the council has...
2:28:23 Manage to find the money to continue maintaining the things that they already have. So I think it's a very important piece. Moving forward, I think we all know that eventually lawsuit settlement, that some of this may well have to go to things we all agree is supplanting. And I think there are ways to do that. But I think it's an important provision that we define it in this way to separate it out from what the town's current obligation is and what the town needs to find.
2:28:52 Every, or look at every possible way to fund the ongoing maintenance of its existing facilities as it has in the past. Hopefully that helps them. I'm very passionate about this subject of not being able to move this into the general fund and being able to use it at will to supplant, if you will, what the town's obligations are already. Well, Bill, I agree, but
2:29:20 The politics of this change from year to year and from commission to commission and council to council. And I'm not taking a position with respect to the language, but it's clear to me that the language of U is more flexible than the language of R in allowing for that discretion. And in particular because of the opinion that we received from the town attorney.
2:29:47 As to the definition of supplanting. So I'm not advocating that it be rigid, and I'm not advocating that it be flexible. I'm just raising the question or the issue that is on everybody's minds, and that is, is the public going to trust the committee, the commission, and the council with the authority to spend the monies that come in consistent with what the voters thought the monies were going to be spent on?
2:30:16 And, you know, I think what the public is looking for, when we supplant, and we have, I think that they're looking for the council and the commission to fess up and say, folks, we're sorry, there's no money this year, we have to supplant, and here's why, and here's what we're going to use it for. And when money is available, so this is a contract with the people of the town, a political commitment, if you will, when the money's available in the general fund to go back to...
2:30:46 Maintaining this already built project, we will do that. And I think that's what the supplanting language gets down to. So you can't spend it without making the admission that you are supplanting. And without the contract that says as funds become available, they are not going to be used someplace else because now we can leave this in the budget here. We've made a contract with ourselves that as we get whole again, that money will be spent out of general fund.
2:31:14 To maintain what existed before the date that's in the, what do you call it? To measure you. To measure. To measure. To make better sense at that time. I'm only here because I told Rick I didn't want to speak tonight, so you had to, right? Bill, but aren't those the same promises that state and federal governments make and don't follow through on? Yeah, but John, I know where you live.
2:31:44 The point is, is in a small community, hopefully it's something that we can follow through with. Just to, you know, everybody appreciates the very real choices and difficult ones that are coming the way of this community. What you have in Measure R and in Measure U is you have clearly defined processes for accessing those funds.
2:32:13 Anybody can fill out an application. Part of the work, I think the reason why the Measure You, Measure Our Committee members did all this work so that there was going to be a clear and transparent process by which the funds can be accessed. And I think, you know, for my involvement in both the Measure Our Campaign and the Measure You Campaign, we can have a long discussion about that. But a primary concern to the voters was they wanted to be able to know and see
2:32:41 How the funds were going to be accessed and how they were going to be spent. And in the measure art process, the application process, and now this measure you process, there can't be any doubt about that. Someone's going to have to fill out an application. If the town has to come forward with a very draconian request based on extraordinary circumstances, fill out an application just like everybody else. Fill out an application just like everybody else. That's what this process is for. Anybody can come in and apply for the money. I think in terms of...
2:33:10 Public credibility and how we're going to navigate these difficult situations with these very precious and unique and significant funding resources, that's what these application processes are about. Thank you. I have a question for any member of the committee and it deals with the size of the committee. When we started Measure R, Recreation and Tourism Commission with seven people, it's six now, we'll go down to five next summer.
2:33:42 I think that that has given the opportunity for all points of view to be vetted, so I'd like to know why the decision to have only three is being recommended. Do you change? I think, Madam Mayor, the bulk of the discussion was inefficiency to how to move a vast number of a potentially large number of applications through a process. With three people, you can sort of meet, go over.
2:34:14 Get it done. As you broaden it, scheduling meetings become a little more challenging. You know, it becomes a whole different bailiwick, and I think the committee, and happy to have them on that, what their key focus was, was developing an efficient process. And I understand the efficiency, but I guess my question is, does that give us a broad enough point of view, since, as Brent said, there's going to be a ton of apps. I realize that.
2:34:42 To get the broad view, you had representation from each one of the areas. You had somebody from recreation. You had somebody from mobility. You would have somebody from arts and culture. So you would have a perspective from each of the key members that were originally articulated in the measure that went before the people for voting. See, Bill, now I got you to stand up.
2:35:07 You know, there's a whole bunch of matters. Start calling. I know. I'm looking at them. They're all hiding. You know, I think you get great representation. The assumption I would make, and I have made, is that each person from each one of those commissions is going to go back to their commission and discuss it with the commission. So they're going to be getting a broad group of opinions on these things as they move forward. As commissioners, we stay pretty up on that sort of thing.
2:35:35 How do you expand it much farther? If you include this group, then, well, if we include this group, then we have to include this group, and pretty soon we're back up to an 11 or 12 member committee that, believe me, going through these applications, it takes a long time for each person to get out there. So I think it does work, and I think it does give you a broad base because you've brought two commissions into it and still gives us a group with staff that can go through this and be very efficient.
2:36:06 I just want to make one point. Everyone keeps talking about the intent of the voters. I was a voter on these measures, and the intent that people keep talking to me about, and my intent was not for new projects, but to keep existing projects, and it would be nice to have new projects. And I think our attorney had pointed out the intent of what we voted on, and that's how I voted. And people keep coming up and saying this is the intent of what the public wants.
2:36:35 Well, I'm part of that public, and that wasn't my intent, and there's a lot of other people that also have the same intent I did, and that is to keep our stuff going and what we have now. John Berube. The new projects and the maintenance, again, I think you have to be careful. The whole principle of this, and Dave was at one of our meetings for a couple hours, is that we don't want Measure U, it's very restrictive, to supplant general fund.
2:37:06 So if we are maintaining a park with general funds, we cannot use Measure U. But on the other hand, the chance of us approving a new park with a Measure U while another park is dying, I don't think it's going to happen. Unless the Town Council has the political whereforeal to do that. But the reason also for the committee to do what we did and why we spent the extra, I don't know, 100 hours that Carl wasn't too happy with us with, is
2:37:34 We wanted to make it, and be very blunt, because I'm trying to get, John was unhappy with my first comment, because I didn't make him feel bad. But basically, we wanted to make this so restrictive that we were doing the basic part, and you people are the politicians. If you want to override that, you can. We want to make it as restrictive as possible. If you want to override that, you want to put it in general funds, that's your prerogative to do. But the purpose of this is to make it as restrictive as possible.
2:38:03 Again, because of the political aspect of it. So I doubt seriously. And one example that we used, for instance, was Mammoth Rocks. If Mammoth Rocks is going and they come to us and they ask us for money for Mammoth Rocks, the answer is no. If they come to us and say, okay, we want to increase Mammoth Rocks by solar, we want to add two more trolleys, the extra trolleys probably will come out of Mexico.
2:38:24 That's a very simple example. And again, there's no way we're going to improve new projects if we have something dying. In my opinion, I won't be on that committee, but that was, we talked about that for many hours. Okay. Any other questions up here? Okay. Do you have a wrap-up, Carl? No. Are you going to deliberation? Okay. Was there anything, any other questions from the audience or any other comments from the committee members? I just have one comment here.
2:38:57 That is, the idea of efficiency is great. These are round-out meetings. I just want anybody to think that we're going to be able to have a few people meet at some place and get the work accomplished. These are a whole lot of requirements to most meeting, agendize it, make it available to the public, take notes, and post events. Okay. Comments? I have one. I just, I don't know if it was a comment.
2:39:31 On moving this process forward a month, is that something that's possible for the committee? Well, I think that maybe that's a question because I'm going to, if there has to be someone who goes through an appointment process, it may not be. Is that an easy way to say it? Well, I guess, yeah, that's part of it. That's part of the question, I guess. Is it possible to do that? I mean, can we go through the appointment process and move it forward or not? I think anything's possible.
2:40:03 I want to provide that summary to you. Option 1 has five items before you, and I'll just kind of run them through for the benefit of the council and the audience here. So option 1A is approve the Measure U funding process recommendations, and that's the packet in its entirety.
2:40:26 That's been presented before you. B is approve the Test Measure U Spring Award period, which is what we're discussing now to open April 2, close May 2. C was to approve the proposed three-member composition of the Measure U Application Committee and include the Recreation and Mobility Commissioners in the interview process for the third committee member. D authorise a town manager to open applications for the Arts and Culture seat on Monday, February 20th for an initial period of two weeks.
2:40:55 Was to adopt the resolution appropriating 1% of the budgeted annual allocation and measure you funds for town administration for this fiscal year. So those were the recommendations before you. Thank you, Stuart. If it's a pleasure, Council, I'd like to go through each of those and ask if there's any comments from Council on any of them. First on the funding process. No. I have one, and it has to do with the 4% cap.
2:41:24 And I'm relating it back to the fact within Measure R, yes, we've been using about 4% to run the application processes. My feeling is we have not been doing, and I'm hearing it from the community, we have not done an adequate job of auditing or contract management. And that I believe that that's going to take us to a higher amount in order to get that done. I believe for this first process,
2:41:50 Town staff is only asking for 1% to do the test process, but I believe that when we find out when we actually have an application saying it takes this much to do the contract management, to do the auditing when we're looking at the next year's allocations, I believe it's going to be higher. Has the problem been a lack of funding or is it just not?
2:42:17 They're just not appropriate and properly. No, there has not been enough funding to do that. In fact, audit was never really defined under Measure R, but we have heard comments about how's the money being spent, how are the contracts being monitored, are we hearing back about deliverables? There's a lot of those things that we haven't been doing, and I think the community is going to say those need to be done as well to prove how the money is being spent.
2:42:44 I'm not suggesting that we change it tonight. I'm just putting that as a forward thing that when we look at the next year's allocations and if I believe the recommendations were to review everything after the test process, I think we're kidding ourselves if we think that all of the application process, the support of the committee and everything is going to be done for only 4%. Does anyone have any comments on the test measure spring award? Just the dates. I'd like to suggest March.
2:43:14 And April versus April and May. Okay. And as I said, I think that's going to lead into the other ones about getting the other member of the committee. Any other comments? I don't see how you can do that and still have the appropriate process to bring on the third member, which it's just, that's the reality. That's the practical reality.
2:43:38 I am wondering if we want to say that all the available funds at the time of the spring award are available for consideration or if we want to limit them in some way. I don't want to limit them. Okay. That would probably solve the problem. Okay. Approving the proposed three-member composition and the interview process. Comments on that?
2:44:06 I have a big concern there. If we're saying that this is such an important committee and we're saying we're going to appoint this person under the advisory committee, then I feel it's the responsibility of the council to do the interviews, not to have the committee doing the interviews. I would consider it like any other commission appointment where it's our responsibility to do the interview for the at-large member for the art and culture seat.
2:44:38 I actually didn't have an understanding that we wouldn't be doing that. It says in here that they would first interview the applicants, they would interview the applicants before us. They would review the submitted applications and make a recommendation for the third appointment. I'm sorry, I believe that's our responsibility. It's on page five. Yeah, for the initial test or for all of them? No, no, no, for the committee member. Right. For the committee member, not for the applications. Okay.
2:45:08 The applications to the committee, I believe that's our responsibility. You take their recommendation, but not, okay. Well, and that also speeds up the process, if the people only have to be interviewed once. I don't have any problem with them doing the initial interview, and then, I mean, it says right here, then the town council would make the final appointment. Well, my presumption of that is they would be screening the applicants down, and that's the part that I believe is our responsibility.
2:45:37 And as I say, it would also speed up the process if they did not have to do it. I just don't see it a big deal, and I don't know where we're going to save any time. And then the other one, and I do agree, Matthew, with Rick, that it's going to take time for that application to be found. And the committee can't go forward with only two. Okay. Okay, and any questions about the resolution on the 1% for this year?
2:46:11 Madam Mayor, I move to approve adoption, I mean to accept the Measure U Steering Committee, Measure U Recommendations as set forth in Option 1, A through E. Second. We have a motion and a second. Yes. Can I speak with it? So we just talked, the committee, a few members just talked to maybe speed up the process to
2:46:41 Matt's point, maybe we consider, at least for this spring test award, not going through the selection process for the committee, maybe presenting all applications to you guys directly instead. That way you don't have to wait three weeks or a month. There could be a hundred of them. Yeah, yeah. After Brad said tons of them.
2:47:01 Just a recommendation. He's calling his bluff. No, no, no. What I was saying was that we would interview the applicants for the third position on the committee, not the applications for funding. I understand, but what I heard was, the concern was, is that by the time you select, go through that process, kick it off, it may be...
2:47:25 It takes longer in a process than you were hoping for. At least I heard from Matt. So what I'm suggesting is, and having talked to a couple committee members now, granted, it puts all that work back into you guys, is that instead of going through that selection process and speed it up and kind of kick it off now, that you guys would actually be the selection committee, at least for this first round. That's all. And actually, with everything else that's on our plates, I think that would delay it until about December. That's my opinion. Okay.
2:47:55 Sorry, Mayor Bacon. I did want to clarify. So you were correct in your first note saying that the two commissioners would actually make their recommendation to council. The recreational commission did meet and said that those two commissioners, the recreational mobility, would just be part of the interview process with council at the same time. So we wouldn't add...
2:48:20 Any time to that, that would just be sitting with you in that interview process. That was kind of the recommendation from that meeting. Based on the advisory body handbook and what you passed this evening, which I think is what you've indicated before, if it's just the advisory body handbook and those recommendations, that would just be a council selection and interview, excluding those two commissioners. So that was the recommendation before you. That's how C reads. So I think just before you...
2:48:48 Consider that motion. Just consider that point. One more idea. So what if the committee actually became the selection committee for this round? We'd be willing to do it. They're yelling, screaming. The $100 was not enough, obviously. So we want to do more. So if that would be something acceptable for this round.
2:49:16 For the spring test, we'll be that committee for the selection. I feel like that. And who represents arts and cultures on that? Bill Taylor. Bill Taylor. Think about it. You're saying the selection committee for the third member? No, it works. The selection committee. The steering committee would actually review the applications and provide a recommendation. We would step in and do that to speed it up.
2:49:48 As you've already mentioned, by the time you select the three and get them teed up, that's many weeks, if not a month or longer. Well, we're suggesting we're off. We know the process. We created it. We would be willing to step in and do that for the spring. Okay, so that the steering committee would run the spring test. Correct. And in that same time period, hopefully, we would get the committee established and the changeover would happen probably after this first test award. Right, and at least that way we can get it up faster.
2:50:18 That's probably a great point. Okay? That'd be great. I think that's what Jo is saying. Yeah, that's what I was saying is have you guys kind of do the transition in together because you're right, it will slow us down no matter how we go about getting that third member on there. But we obviously haven't created the process and been through it. We're keyed up and ready to go to actually start reviewing if we haven't. Okay. All right. Thanks, Jim.
2:50:48 If we're calling this a test process of Measure U, then we need to get the committee that's going to actually be the U committee together to do a test. If we're looking for the fastest way to get Measure U money on the street, then having the committee, which I was a part of, review the applications is a great idea. But then we're not going to get, in a true sense, a test.
2:51:19 of the U process and whether that three-man committee is viable or not, whether we need to add or subtract. So there's two different things here. So I suppose you need to ask yourselves whether your goal here tonight is to expedite getting that money on the street in June or in May rather than June or a test of the Measure U process and how that's going to work with the proposed three-man committee. So there's sort of two different things.
2:51:50 I think the committee, well, and I'm going to let Bill say he agrees with me, is that getting it out faster I think is more important because of, you know, Matt's concern about a lot of these summer projects that are already on the table or be prepared to come on the table. Dave, can you see any reason we can't do that?
2:52:21 Okay. So would the motion maker state, so the idea, if I understand it, correct me, motion maker and seconder, is that we begin the test process using the measure year steering committee while we're concurrently getting the other one together with the idea that the steering committee would actually be making recommendations to us on the spring test award. I will...
2:52:50 Amend my motion to so move. And the second was? I'll second. Okay. Okay. We have a motion and a second. And Stuart, are you up there because you have another comment? I'm just going to clarify, if I may. So that takes care of item C. It also takes care of item D. So you're really going to have A, B, and now E. So B.
2:53:17 So that's approving the test spring award period opening April 2. So what we're saying there is maybe staff could come back at the next council meeting with a recommendation on the timing. And what we still need to do is have council approve the application material itself. So what you're seeing tonight is just a list of questions and what forth. So similar to measure R, we would actually have to come forward with you to have you adopt those pieces of material and the timeline and the funding amount as well. I think that's what we were saying. So that would be...
2:53:47 March 7th, I think is our next council meeting. Would that be the direction at this time? So you're suggesting that B needs to be amended to reflect the March 7th date, and you would propose that it remain open for 30 days? That's correct. I'll amend my motion to so reflect that. I will second it. All right. Are we done?
2:54:13 We have motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Rickson? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Lane? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And thank you to the committee who has now obviously obligated themselves to even more time volunteering for the town. Okay. Do we need to keep going? Keep going. Keep going. All right. John. We lost John. He'll be back.
2:54:46 Next item is to approve the composition, convening, and scope of work for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. Mayor Bacon, Councilmembers. Agenda item 14. So the purpose of this policy item is for Town Council to approve the composition, convening, and scope of work, including the terms of office, which is listed in the Agenda Bill of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee, as recommended by the Recreation Commission.
2:55:26 As you know, just a brief background here. On February 1st, Town Council amended and approved a policy item that directed the Town Manager and the Commission to present a proposal to the Town Council for the convening of the MLTSCC. On February 7th, the Recreation Commission passed a motion reaffirming the composition of the MLTSCC, which is that composition you can see at the bottom of page 1 of the Agenda Bill. They also reviewed the scope of work.
2:55:56 Meeting Schedule, and we talked about the Terms of Office, which is page 3 of the Agenda Bill. It should be noted that Commissioner Colisado did excuse himself from the MLTSCC, and the Recreation Commission appointed Chair Souser to replace that vacated seat. The composition of the MLTSCC as it stands this evening, two Recreation Commissioners, being Chair Souser, Commissioner Turner. Mobility Commission was Chair Hogan.
2:56:26 Town of Mammoth Lakes designee was Town Manager, Dave Wilbeck, MLTPA was John Wentworth, Mammoth Mountain Skier was included, representative being Jim Smith, the ex-officio CETAs we've talked about would be an international forest representative, and they talked about the two or user groups, there's really no number there, to be determined. The recommendation was to establish that coordinating committee as soon as possible.
2:56:55 To review the composition of that group and to identify any user groups that might be applicable for that group. The other item that did come up was the terms of office and I added this to the agenda bill. As this would be a town council elected technical advisory committee subject again to the Brown Act, town staff is recommending that the term of office for the commission members be their current term. For non-commission members who vacate their seat on the MLTSCC, town staff
2:57:25 Would use, or is advising Town Council to once again use the advisory body appointment process that was adopted this evening. So there's three, there's option one, there's again three items, I'm trying to make it clear. Option one, point A was to establish the MLTSCC with the initial composition recommended by the Recreation Commission, which is at the bottom of page one. Approve the scope of work listed on page two of the agenda bill.
2:57:53 And C, approve the terms of office for four years and use the advisory body's handbook as a method for filling vacated seats on the Mammoth Lakes Trust System Coordinating Committee. Thank you, sir. Welcome. Questions? Okay. Any comments? Okay. If it's a pleasure, I'd like to go through each piece of the option again so we can discuss if there's any. So we have the initial composition. Any comments on that? Okay.
2:58:27 Scope of Work. I have a question on the scope of work, and it's really more a clarification. Number four and number five talk about assigning funding to the entities and engaging entities, but I believe that is, again, a council responsibility to contract and or hire, and I would just like to have those reflect they could recommend.
2:58:59 This committee does not engage anyone, I don't believe, as a technical committee. Any comments? No, I don't have any. Okay, any comments on the term for those that are not currently on a commission? All right, any other comments? Madam Mayor, I move that the town council approve option number one, as stated. I'll second that. A clarification, that's without changing the language from engage to recommend.
2:59:35 Correct. He's saying that my suggestion was not accepted, that they don't have the right to hire or a contract. I will keep my second as is. Okay. All right. Okay. Discussion. Well, I don't... Go ahead. Go ahead. No, please. I don't read the scope of work as permitting the committee to...
3:00:12 Do something that either staff or the council is required to approve in order to expend money. It appears to me that the focus of number four is to determine a process for implementation and funding. Ultimately, the funding decisions are ours. And so I'm okay with the language. I don't read it broadly. I read it in a very restrictive way. I read it that funding will be assigned by the...
3:00:41 Committee to those entities. And that to me sounds like... No, I see that. And I see why you got that question. But it seems to me that that sentence, which is the second sentence of the paragraph, must follow the primary sentence in the paragraph to simply describe what it is that they're going to be considering.
3:01:08 As they make the recommendations they make, I don't think that they get to spend money. Okay, and determining requirements of staffing needs and engaged entities isn't hiring? I don't read it as that. I mean, ultimately, if money is going to be expended, I mean, I don't know of any commission or committee or subcommittee that has the authority
3:01:36 To bind the town as this, if it were read broadly, would suggest. So I'm okay with that. And Madam Mayor and Council Members, just to clarify, I concur with Council Member Wood. This does not actually give the committee spending authority. And then to address the point that the town manager has brought up,
3:01:57 The proposed annual $300,000 appropriation, I believe, is the proposal that's going to be made in item 15 on tonight's agenda. So depending on what you do with that, that source of funds may or may not be available. Okay. Thank you. All right. Thank you for that clarification from Rick and Andy.
3:02:17 Okay, we have a motion and a second. We'll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Eisman? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Portem-Laymond? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And we now move on to item 15. Stuart? Good evening again. So this item was presented and brought forward, really initiated by Chair Souser and Commissioner Stellick with the goal of clarifying
3:02:58 The action taken from February 1st meeting. So what staff has done is try to provide maybe a little clearer explanation of the action by Town Council at the previous meeting. So what staff is presenting this evening for Council consideration is the approval of Table 1, and they were the actual 2011 four measure our funds recommended.
3:03:23 Being in that amount of $355,350.83 by the Regression Commission on January 19, 2012. So Table 1 is the funding, the recommendations for funding. What Council acted on February 1st was the resolution. So what staff did, which is Table 2, was take those items that are going to be funded and need to be, funds need to be appropriated for this fiscal year.
3:03:53 So that resolution was signed. That's Table 2. So that's taking those funds and being appropriated this fiscal year. Table 3 of those funds are going to be appropriated in the following year, fiscal year 12-13, which will be budgeted accordingly through the town budget process. So really, that action is probably more housekeeping than anything, but that's just approving Table 1 for those recommendations. Action has already been taken.
3:04:21 for the appropriation of those funds. The second item is the approval, I know we've talked about this in the past, is the actual approval of the multi-year commitment of Measure R funds to enhance and improve the Maniflakes Trial System, MLTS, that includes an annual minimum request of $300,000 to be appropriated from Measure R beginning July 1, 2012 for a period of five years, which is attachment C, and they were the
3:04:51 Attachment C is the actual Recreation Commission recommendations for that award. The item that needs the note from that is the funding was appropriated for the staffing, which we've just previously discussed. And as these funds weren't available in the 2011 measure of four award, that funding request wasn't submitted because those funds aren't available. But this request is for next fiscal year.
3:05:19 So the request there is you can see option one. I'm just going to roll right into this while we're here. Option one is A, as we talked about, approved table one, which is recommending the $355,000 or just really approving what the recommendation, what the Recreation Commission approved. And then option B is to make that approval of those funds. I know what was discussed previously at council.
3:05:50 Was the budgeting of those funds in this fiscal year 12-13 town budget was what was discussed at the February 1st meeting. So that's actually identified in option two, part B. But option one is the recommendation from the Recreation Commission that they made on January 19th, 2012. I don't know if that's confused people more or hopefully it's clarified. Skip? Stuart, I just...
3:06:19 I've always been under the impression that this was going to be a $300,000 a year commitment, and I'm wondering why we have to budget a minimum of $300,000. Why don't we just say to budget $300,000? Yeah, again, that was actually the recommendation from the Recreation Commission. It was on, I think it's, yeah, handwritten number 11, which is the first page, attachment C's funding request.
3:06:49 The application as it was brought forward is a request for a minimum of $300,000 to be appropriated from Measure R annually beginning July 1. This minimum level does not preclude increasing the annual amount based on funding needs for future prioritised projects nor from submitting additional Measure R applications for specific projects. It would also mean that whatever the MLTS Coordinating Committee brings forward, if it's obviously less than the $300,000, then you wouldn't obviously need to appropriate.
3:07:18 The $300,000, it's really the actual recommendations from the MLTS board forward to council for appropriation, so that's really the minimum. If it's less, you can't go, it's saying a minimum of $300,000. If it's less than that, how can we go backwards? Again, a little sticky point. Appropriate a minimum of $300,000 doesn't mean that all $300,000 has to be spent in that year. So there's going to be an annual review.
3:07:55 This just takes it out of the application process every year. There's going to be an annual review, and I suppose if there needs to be a change one way or the other, then that would be brought forward to Council with our regular measure, our housekeeping stuff. So that was just the way it was written for a minimum of $300,000. Madam Mayor, Council Members, if I may, Andy Morristown Attorney, I think this is a good point to point out that
3:08:24 This language is really just a statement of intention. It's aspirational only. You can't do anything tonight that really ties your hands for the FY 12-13 budget or any future budget because the council always has the discretion in the future to deviate from this. You could decide to budget less. You could decide to budget more. So really this would only be a symbolic gesture, I think, not anything that you could really be held to other than people saying, well, this is what you said you're going to do and now you're not. But it's not really enforceable.
3:08:54 Not law. Political commitment. I appreciate you saying that because that was the understanding that I had at the last meeting and it is consistent with on handwritten 11 under the section term the language that states this term and amount
3:09:19 Will be evaluated annually by the Recreation Commission and adjusted as needed. And I read that language to mean that each year, MLTPA is going to be required to submit an application just like everybody else. Sorry. Whoever is going to submit the application needs to do it every year.
3:09:45 And compete for dollars. But the importance of this agenda bill tonight is to provide the opportunity for council to weigh in on it. That is a five-year commitment of approximately that amount as a priority that has been established by our constituents and then obviously affirmed and developed and affirmed by the commission and now brought before council.
3:10:15 I've always thought that it's not a green light. It won't take $300,000 automatically out because just as our attorney has stated, we can't do that. We can simply make that commitment and future councils can change it if they wish. That's how I've read this and that's how I saw it last week but now it's a formal agenda bill and motion coming up, I guess. Okay.
3:10:44 Okay. Other questions? I just have a comment. I just, I don't understand why we're going and giving a commitment that we don't have to keep, and I guess I understand we're making a statement to this effect that, you know, we're going to do it, but some of us may not even be here in another year or so, so what's the point? I, you know, I quite honestly, I'm comfortable with what we voted on last time.
3:11:09 And I'm comfortable with option two. I just think we should look at it every year, especially with all we have going on right now. I don't want to give any kind of commitment. Okay, well that's really deliberation, so let's get back to that in a minute. Questions from the audience? We don't want to keep deferring, like I said the last time, is they're asking for $300,000 and they're bypassing the whole application process. Again, what Rick said is,
3:11:39 Let the committee get a board, let them get their budget, then present it and be in competition with everybody else and figure out if we need to use it for that money or if there's other applications that's more important. What I'm seeing is they're asking you to commit to this without going through the due process that was set up for everybody and that due process has been skipped and so I just want to point that out.
3:12:03 That exactly what Rick Wood said is it's competition for everybody and it should be reviewed as an annual basis and we should not be deferring. What we don't have, especially this year, seems to get us in trouble. That's my comment. Yes, sir. Hi, Madam Mayor. Matthew, a little bit to your point. The reason why this came forward in this way has a significant amount to do with the town's relationship with the Forest Service.
3:12:42 The resolution you guys passed at your last meeting, and which a lot of work and a lot of time went into, was to establish with the Forest Service a sense of a long-term commitment to this program. And I think it's very important not to decouple those things. Don't look at those as two completely unrelated things. They're completely related. The opportunities for the trail system is going to involve the Forest Service, and to the degree that you legally can make a reliable commitment to that, things will change over time.
3:13:12 But it's going to be very important for the MLTSCC, for all the folks working to make an effective relationship with the Forest Service, for all these facilities to have a background of this that, to the degree possible, the town is making a commitment to fund the resolution you guys voted on last week. And that's how those things are tied. And it's not intended to overwhelm or overwrite what you guys can do legally. But again, it's that agency to know that there's a willing partner over here with whatever resources is
3:13:40 Community has to put to this to take this program forward. So those things are related and connected to each other. Related, John, to the point where the Forest Service actually put out a press release this past week promoting the relationship that they have developed with Town? Exactly. Okay. Okay, any other comments? Okay, now we're in deliberation.
3:14:06 You know, I just wanted to add, since John made that statement, that the other thing that's important to me is to affirm the priority that was established in the rec strats process, which was an open, exhaustive, comprehensive process that...
3:14:25 In which the commitment to the trails system rose to the top. And so I see us as having two reasons to make a political commitment. One is stated by John and the other as I've just stated. That's good. Anything? Good.
3:14:46 And I agree with you totally, Rick. I mean, we have been on this path to get recreation as a priority, and to me this commitment is the next step in that, that we are actually saying, yes, we will go forward with this. Matthew, did you want to add anything else? I just was going to add, if it's not legally binding, I guess I don't really have, it doesn't really matter to me one way or another. That was my primary concern, was just the legal binding aspect of it. So, yeah.
3:15:15 Madam Mayor, I move that the council approve option number one as stated, including attachments A through D. I second it. We have a motion and second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Eason? Councilmember Harvest? Councilmember Wood? Councilmember Wood? Mayor Poiton-Laymond? Mayor Bacon? Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Okay. How are we doing? A break or keep going? Keep going. Okay. So.
3:15:46 The next item is direction regarding Town of Mammoth Lakes 4th of July celebration. Good evening. So we have provided extensive agenda bills. I know there's people here wishing to speak on this item this evening, Madam Mayor. So really the goal of this evening, I'll just kind of surmise as quickly as I can, but as a request made by Councilor Lehman, for Town Council to discuss the annual Mammoth Lakes 4th of July celebrations and determine...
3:16:17 If the Town should continue to fund the fireworks at Crowley Lake, as has been done in the past, or evaluate other alternatives that the Town and community could safely, financially, and logistically explore within the Town of Mammoth Lakes. This item was presented to the Recreation Commission on February 7th, and the Commission passed a motion stating that the Town should commit to contracting with Spyro Spectacular Incorporated for up to $29,000 for the fireworks show at Crowley Lake.
3:16:46 But negotiate savings with all vendors and explore revenue generating options for the event. They also participated in a discussion proposing some ideas to reduce expenses, which are listed at the top of page 2, and to reduce, oh sorry, and to increase revenue for the event as well, which they're listed there. The other part of the agenda bill provides a little bit of a history on the 4th of July. Fireworks show them on the town's participation.
3:17:15 has been in the past. The town has also funded Pops in the Park since 2008. The town produced a Main Street Block Party in 2006. And then on page 4 of 5, the Chamber of Commerce and members of the local business community did meet recently and discuss this new concept, which is centred around maximising and leveraging the town's budgeted 4th of July funds.
3:17:46 Being in the amount of just under $32,000 for this fiscal year with the Village Neighbourhood Association, community funds from local businesses, etc. By creating a multi-day program of events that includes a variety of activities and events for all ages in the Town of Mammoth Lakes. So really the option before you is just to provide direction to town staff regarding the annual Town of Mammoth Lakes 4th of July celebrations. Okay, are there questions, Stuart?
3:18:18 All right. I believe there are some people who wish to speak. Good evening. Brent Truaxman of Place Chamber of Commerce. I'll try to talk a little louder. So we, as the Chamber of Commerce, truly believes that there is a great opportunity, given the fact of where we see our TOT tax revenues, our sales tax revenues, and where the town is headed with its financial challenges to come ahead. We have proposed that the whole events take place within the town of Mammoth Lakes, and even including the fireworks.
3:18:52 But we still support that as a general idea. We also recognize that, and went before the recognition, and made an argument in that regards, and they have recommended it differently, and we're not going to go against that as a recommendation. We do believe that would be an ideal scenario, but not the funds exist there. We thought that the combination of funds with other parties in town would lead to a greater enhanced recreation activities for people who come into town. That would be, in turn, creating more dollars for town. If we take it just very simply,
3:19:22 You know, with a few thousand people in town spending $10 an hour with a little more occupancy because we're typically averaging, sorry, about 37% occupancy on the last time, July 4th was on the 4th of July. You increase the occupancy by 10%, the increase in hourly spending. You're also talking $300,000 to $400,000 additional revenue in town that can be attributable to new tax revenue businesses having revenues within town. But to back that down just a little bit, we don't, at this point in time, want to
3:19:50 Go and make a statement that we are going to fight for the fireworks to remain in town. The recognition was very clear. And what we would and still going to try to seek is to enhance the town activity on that day. We see there's an opportunity to keep people within town and to have really a block party that exists. I've talked to more than 25 business owners in town, and while there's a general support, they're also saying at this point in time they don't want to make any financial commitments.
3:20:17 Because given the fact of where business has been so far, there's uncertainty really even where the spring is going to be at. So while they want to help, we're looking at ways to seed some money into that so that we can get some commitments with kids' activities, some advance, at least get things started so we can have the local business owners help augment those activities. We had a very productive conversation with the REC Commission in regards to and would hopefully be involved in some conversations how we can combine that event.
3:20:45 And with the 4th of July parade, the fireworks, so there is really a true long day event. And if there's a possibility of monies that are found from that process of saving costs, whether it's fireworks or contract services, et cetera, that maybe those extra savings could be applied and utilized towards some of the activities within town. We just see this great opportunity saying, you know, business has not been as good as one would like to anticipate. I came here last January. The snow was practically as tall as a building out here.
3:21:13 This year, a shovel, and you can pretty much clear your sidewalk every single day this year. It's obviously impacted everybody in town. There's only a few opportunities we see looking ahead where you can really gain some of that back. Summer is really a very short period of time. By having 4th of July to Wednesday, it's really not the most ideal date. You want to try to extend those dates out. You want to try to maximize the opportunity. The reality is it's about getting people in town. If you get people to stay in town, they're going to spend on food, they're going to spend on beverage, they're going to spend more activities.
3:21:43 If we have an event series where they can come in on a Wednesday, have a fantastic Fourth of July, stay through on a Thursday, create some events, work with other parties in town to create whether it's a mountain bike event or more kids or equestrian events, and then we also right now have Blue Sky Fest and the June Lake Triathlon ending that weekend. So it's going to be a great finish to the week. We need to fill in the Thursday a little bit, but everything takes money. The reality, though, is we are a tourist economy.
3:22:11 That's a few dollars that we're looking to spend in the order of $10,000. It's very small in the world of, you know, when I sat here earlier this evening, you could almost cut it with a knife in terms of everyone's, could feel your burden and decisions that you have to deal with that are so much larger than small amounts of money that we talk here. We have to start at one step. One step is, first of all, it's Fourth of July. It's a great opportunity, great opportunity to get better recognition if we have a program going, if we have something that takes place.
3:22:40 The Mammoth Lakes Tourism can put it out there as a stay event, not just a one-time parade event, but really a true several-day activity. This will drive revenue into town, this will drive taxes, this will drive sales taxes. It's not the end-all, but it's a start, and we have to start somewheres, because there's really not that many opportunities during the summer to increase that activity. And therefore, from our standpoint, we would concede from the standpoint of the fireworks being probably this year. We would still try to push it and make an argument for the following year.
3:23:09 That there maybe is an alternative as we investigate with businesses and the fire department, fire marshals, as we go through all those different options. But we would like to figure out ways to finance and at least get seed money so that we can do some things to the 4th of July to keep people in town to 5 or 6 o'clock at night and have them spend that money within town and create tax and sales revenue for the town. Thank you. Okay, before we go, any questions? Okay, thank you. Is there anyone else who wanted to speak on this?
3:23:49 Council, staff, and others. I just want to let you know this year, and a lot of you here are following what's going on. This year, the motocross will be the 21st to the 1st of July. It's a perfect window to literally do what we can to keep those people here, because those people that ride our motocross track, that race, spend the most money in this town. And that's a good opportunity to keep those people here from the 21st to the 4th. That'll be two weeks of a lot of spending money.
3:24:22 of my user group that is being discriminated. Now, I just want to let you know that it's flat out that what's going on with my industry and our user group is. We host, California hosts five Supercross races. A lot of people don't know, the people don't know what Supercross race is. What they do is they actually go in the stadiums, Anaheim Stadium, LA Dodger Stadium, Oakland Stadium.
3:24:51 The San Diego Stadium. California actually hosts five Supercross races in California. Out of all the series, we have the most races in California. And the reason being is because we pretty much bring in the most revenue. Our state brings in the most revenue when it comes to OHV. This year, every event, Anaheim, which is the starter for this race, for this series,
3:25:20 This year was up 15,000 fans. Last year was 35,000. This year, 46,000 fans. Then it went over to Phoenix. 50,000 fans in Phoenix. Then it came back to California, the Dodger Stadium. Dodger Stadium is a new venue. It's their second year. Over 40,000 fans that participated at that event. Then it goes back to Anaheim, a sold-out crowd. They televised it. Sold-out crowd.
3:25:48 And then San Diego, which just was the last race last weekend, 60,000 fans. Now, I just want to let you know that a lot of those fans do come to this mountain and ski and snowboard. A lot of those fans do come up here and do ride and use a mountain bike park. A lot of those fans would love to come up to be able to bring their dirt bikes up and ride that track. And not just on a race, but on literally on a contingency, but to come up and do high altitude training.
3:26:18 And it just seems to me that still the OHV industry in this town is being discriminated. And again, I just read the new little agenda and it flat out said we need to do whatever we can to get people here in the summer. Well, ladies and gentlemen, they'll come. They want to come here. The problem is we're having too much government close, shut down our industry. And you can see flat out what it's doing to our town. We're not making our money this winter.
3:26:46 I mean, flat out, this is it. I mean, I hate to tell you, but after this, the presidents, that's it, guys, because why not? If it's 90 degrees down the beach, they're already getting half naked pulling out the boats. We're not going to get that big crowd that we have. And I can see it. I can see the businesses and the whole deal. I mean, I don't see it in my business where I work at because it seems like alcohol, booze and alcohol, or alcohol and nicotine are probably, you know, people got to have it. So those kind of sales don't drop.
3:27:13 But everything else is. The Chamber of Commerce is literally saying, here, let me do stuff. Well, I've been in front of Chamber of Commerce and bringing this forward about what an industry that is being discriminated. And flat out, they didn't even want to hear me. I was on the agenda, and all I got was a five-minute comment, and that was it. That's all. We need to stop discriminating OHV. It was brought up at the last meeting. Matt Lehman brought it up. Mo Salzer brought it up. And even Mr. Wilbrek brought it up.
3:27:42 We need to really start working on OHV to get it back going in our town because it's a liable, huge revenue maker and it will keep our businesses open. Thank you. Thank you, Joe. Is there anyone else who wishes to speak on the 4th of July? What's the pleasure, Council? I guess I just want to make a few comments if I could. Just kind of recap on what Brent was saying. I think the initial...
3:28:13 Thought was to bring everything here to keep people here, bring the fireworks here to keep people here. It's falling on a Wednesday. Being that there was some pushback from the rec commission, the chamber of commerce has decided to kind of work with them and keep the fireworks where they are. And maybe, let me back up a little bit. The point of working with the village was the village has a pool of funds that we could have combined.
3:28:41 With existing funds that would have allowed the town some additional cash to bring that down, to liven up the rest of town during Thursday and Friday or even after the parade. Keeping the fireworks down there, we don't have that available to us. So I think what Brent was after ultimately is if there's a way that we can start to look and see if there isn't somewhere measure monies or something or help the chamber try to find them.
3:29:11 So that maybe we can liven up the rest of that week from Wednesday on. And where that comes from, I think, is really ultimately the discussion of could we come up with some money and try to find that. And going back to the Measure U discussion, maybe that's a place where we might be able to have the chamber put in an application and look for those funds. So I'm assuming that's the direction you're kind of going, Brent, right?
3:29:38 Sorry. Yes, and I'm sorry. And I wanted to just make their last point was I hope that the council would be favorable that we could keep working with the rec commission and if there is money that's left over for favorable negotiation by the town with fireworks or other contracts, maybe there is some funds there and then we could discuss potentially using those also with the town if there is such an advantage. And I think the point is we have somebody that's willing to step forward and try to create a revenue generating.
3:30:07 Event of some sort, or at least expand on what we have. I think that was one of the thought processes of the chamber was to create some new and start expanding on what we have. Okay. So is that enough direction? I think so. Okay. Brent, you good with that? Thank you. Yeah. Okay. Move on to item number 17. Who's handling this for staff? Mark?
3:30:41 Oh, I'm sorry. Yes? I didn't question. What was the direction? I think that you're going to work together. Well, I think the direction I really wanted to give was can Town work with the Chamber to try to find some avenues to help the Chamber out in finding funds to expand on some of these events. Oh, I'm sorry. I thought you meant to work with the Recreation Commission because
3:31:20 From my perspective, town staff is already pushed to the limit. I thought you meant to work along with the reputation. Well, I guess we could work, you're already working with the rec commission a little bit, right? Right. So, yeah, I think that's fine for now. There's nothing we need to decide on that's going to be financial. All right. Then we will move on to number 17. So I'll hear your feedback.
3:31:46 Ma'am, members of the council, the purpose of this item is to allow the town council to consider a request for public arts funding to support the Mammoth Gateway Community Project, which is a citizen-driven effort to build a gateway on Main Street of the town entry. This item was requested to be placed on the agenda by councilmember Eastman at the February 1st, 2012 town council meeting.
3:32:13 By way of background, I think the only thing I have to add to the report itself is to want to make sure that you received an email that I sent that was clarifying some of the items in the report. First, we provided a staff report for the item, and attachment A to that staff report was the full Public Arts Commission report.
3:32:40 Which referenced some of their previous consideration of this item. And I just want to make sure that you know that on March 24th, Ms. Tenney appeared before the Public Arts Commission making a request for public arts funds. This was at the direction of the Town Council. And at that meeting, the Public Arts Commission considered the request and voted 3-1 not to support the use of public art funds for this project.
3:33:10 So that information might have been buried in your report, so I wanted to call it to your attention. The second item I wanted to point out and clarify is that in your report on page four, you have table one. This represents the current progress and thinking of the Public Arts Commission in their work to establish projects and program priorities. They've conducted
3:33:37 A number of meetings, they've completed the sense of their art plan, and table one is showing you their current thinking of their top priorities, which are the placement of the Trail of the Trout Sculptures, the Meridian Gateway Monument, kinetic art at Mammoth Creek, public art at Waterford Bridges, and then a couple of programs. You will see that the sum of those projects, we've provided
3:34:05 Ranges of the cost estimates for that. And so the four top projects range from $248,200 to $373,400. And if you add in the additional programs, the total comes to $301,600 to $533,400 for a total estimated budget. That exceeds the current balance of public art funds.
3:34:30 Which are now approximately $371,954. Public art funds are generated as an impact fee, if you will, associated with new development, that new development that chooses not to meet the standards of the public art ordinance on site through their own devices. So it's an in lieu of payment. So at this time we have a very...
3:34:55 Kind of a low expectation of new development and wouldn't expect significant additions to this art fund. So with that, I'm available for questions. You have representatives of the project application here, and so I'll conclude my report. Okay. Any questions of Mark? I'd like to just make a statement, if I could, initially. Do you want me to hold that? Is that a deliberative, but is that more like deliberation? I thought we'd hear from you.
3:35:24 For members, if there's anyone who wishes to speak on it. Bruce Woodward, local. I want to hand out a letter that Tony Colosardo wrote. He couldn't make it tonight. Mayor, I'm sorry. Also, I wanted to point out, I failed to do so, that
3:35:56 Chair Holst of the Public Arts Commission has submitted an email correspondence to you that should have been passed out to you at the dais. Mark, I wonder if I could ask you a question. It certainly passed me by. What's the meaning of encumbered funds? Earmarked. They have not been actually expended. They have been set aside. Are they actually committed? No, they are not. Okay.
3:36:30 Yes, Bruce. So, I guess where to start. We met or we went to present to the Public Arts Commission and with a project that we feel meets the guidelines that have been revised since the original presentation to the Public Arts Commission and their original
3:37:02 decision not to fund the project. We have a project that does meet the guidelines now, and we think it's a great opportunity for the town to have a wonderful piece of art on the incoming and exiting of town on the main way in and out of town. I'm not going to read Tony's letter. If you've all got it, you can read through it.
3:37:39 It's just another member of the town and the community who feels really strongly that this is a great project and should go forward. Mark made comment that the public art fund money comes from development. It should be noted that the development is, it's not single-family homes that are being built that are paying that money. It's multifamily and any other kind of commercial that's paying for that.
3:38:11 I just want to make that clear. That's what I have to say at this point. I think that we have a project that has an opportunity to make a huge impact on the town and on our visitors and an opportunity to show that the town is not, you know, all the bad press that we're getting lately.
3:38:39 That's really not who we are and what we are in the town. There are good things and things are moving forward and we have a bright future. This is a great way to show that. So that's it for me. Thank you. Were there questions at first? No questions. Thank you. John Baruch. I really haven't done a proposal. I haven't really said yes or no on the sign issue, but I would like to speak to the funding.
3:39:18 And I have a question. I don't know if you can answer this, but maybe you can give me the information. In 2009, we had $850,000 in that account. And today we have $350,000. Maybe someone could find out where that money went to. Just out of curiosity, where the $500,000 went. I heard the fish thing or whatever else that was about. These were all little things around town that I don't think we'll ever see.
3:39:47 You know, to me, and again, the chance that more funds into this account are pretty remote because it is tied to development and we're not really dead, but development. So this was set up, I think, with a 1% commercial property. So what I would suggest is that, you know, you are recommended to do appropriate the funds that are left in that community, $350,000, whatever.
3:40:14 And do something even more grander than that. And maybe, you know, there's plaques that are rather being offered. Maybe we give the commission a large plaque. And in that plaque, we put down all their names for something that will be there forever. That takes care of the funding. There's no discussion about the fish or what we're going to do about this or what we're going to do about some other so-called org.
3:40:41 To me, it sounds like a win-win for everyone. And again, they would have their name there forever and give them the largest plaque that's available. So that's my suggestion or my comment. Thank you, John. Anyone else? Jim Smith. I was before you before last time on this project, obviously. And we found a project to be...
3:41:17 A very important part of the community. I know there's a lot of discussion whether it's art or not. Obviously, the Art Commission felt differently to the point where they didn't want to consider it at the last meeting, which I felt was very unfair. However, I will tell you that knowing Larry like I know him and his skills, the question Larry and his skills is whether it's art or not is almost offensive to me personally because I think he's a great artist.
3:41:46 Design of this gateway actually represents art in every shape and form, especially for the town of Mammoth Lakes. The materials and the design and the look and feel and how it is integrated into not only the architectural vernacular that we're trying to get to, but is actually complementary of the natural landscape that we're doing. It's very important. I think it speaks well to the town. I also like to state that, you know, look, things are...
3:42:14 We've got obviously a lot going on. There was a big discussion earlier today. I think to be able to build a project like this that is community-based, that is leveraged, you know, we're fundraising, a lot of money. Elizabeth's done a great job. We all know that. I don't know the exact numbers. I believe at one point she was up to $50,000. Plus, you know,
3:42:38 Snow Creek and Mammoth Mountain are going to provide in-kind services. Some other contractors in town are going to do the same. We actually have a couple other fundraisers coming up that will help leverage funds to get this project kicked off. It is a shovel-ready project. Bruce and Larry have put the plans together. We're ready to go. And a great part is to be able to see something like this based on what's going on, get it kicked off for the summer. I think it's actually very important to the town. I encourage you.
3:43:07 To support the project and support as much art fund as possible, so arguably all of it that's available and contributed to this project. Thanks. Thank you, Jim. I'd love to speak. How can I not stand up here? Chuck Landy of Snow Creek. Just to add a couple things, I want to repeat what Jim said. First of all, a comment was made that it's not art by some. If you go to the people that wrote the ordinance, this absolutely fits within the context of
3:43:41 of their writing, of their creation. And it's a phenomenal. I think Larry has done a great job on this. Secondly, as you recall, what, a year ago, maybe a year and a half, a couple of us sponsored the Main Street district plan. And a big element to that, which you adopted, was an entry, an arrival, a central place. And this really makes that first statement in a major way. It is the gateway. It is the entry to town.
3:44:08 And I think it's just critical for all of us. We're obviously concerned about Snow Creek. We're concerned about the town itself. We're concerned about emerging out of these issues that we face both nationally and locally. This is a great way to say welcome to Mammoth with a beautiful edifice. So I do also encourage you to approve this tonight if you would. Thank you. Thank you, Chuck. And anyone else who wishes to speak? Brent Shurek, Ms. Lake Chambers of Commerce.
3:44:41 Just one more thing, and I guess all these same points have been added. First of all, I think about, and I don't want to make it personal, but I just think that Elizabeth would have been here if she could have been tonight, and I could just hear how passionate she's been over the last several weeks, and I've seen her in town move and just have such heart for this project. The Chamber of Commerce Board fully endorses this, and we really see this as a sentiment to Mammoth Lakes. I'm in the hospitality industry. The two things that we preach without hesitation with everybody is, first,
3:45:10 Contact, last contact. This is the first contact into town. This is the last contact out of town. This is something that would enhance the visibility and the promotion within Mammoth Lakes. It's a starting step to other things that could be done in town to enhance the overall visual aspects of town. But here's something that can be started and going and move forward. And we fully support this and fully, from a business standpoint, endorse this as a great usage of the funds and the pay.
3:45:37 A viable aspect to the town overall will be a great benefit to the town once it is completed. Thank you. Thank you, Greg. Anyone else? John, you had a statement? I was just going to say that initially when this came up, the initial sign on 203, on the east end of 203 down by 395, and we approved the sign, the specific sign that was designed to go at that location.
3:46:12 I supported putting that sign and paying the money, which was a large sum of money down at that location, and the council as a whole approved it. I don't know if it was a 3-2 or a 4-1 vote. It doesn't matter, but the council approved it. And personally, I approved it at the time because I wanted to support the recommendation to the council of the commission for placing that sign down there. I didn't hear the end of it.
3:46:43 The criticism for my voting to support that at the time, and maybe my reason for supporting it was not well thought out, but I would submit that at this time the clarity for me and the support in the community for this new sign at this new location is tremendous in the community. Things that were said tonight were
3:47:11 That it's community-based and supported. It's leveraged financially. I put this on the agenda tonight out of frustration because I felt the sense of urgency and the timeliness of the Council taking action now instead of waiting another two weeks or a month or however long it might be to have the Arts Commission to
3:47:40 Reagendize it and readdress it. I think it's so important to the community and I think it's so important to get this project started now so that it can be completed this summer so that people visiting can see the progress of it this summer. I would just add to that. I keep hearing a sense of arrival, something I've been hearing for years here in town. That's something that our town has been asking for.
3:48:18 It's a project in our community during trying times right now, and I do agree with that, and it sounds to me like there's already a lot of community participation out there and funding and whatnot for it, so clearly there's a desire, so that's all I have to say. I've just been listening to those comments all day. Mark, when this first came before us, we agreed to give it something in lieu of
3:48:49 Do we know what the value of those fees are that we have? As I recall, it was a relatively nominal amount, and it represented in-kind services some structural review, which we did not actually do. There has been staff time associated with the signed permit and then the subsequent processing and work on the expanded project. So we have exceeded that amount, but not
3:49:19 It's not a super significant amount of money. Bill needs some needs to do a land swap or a lease for the county that owns the land. There's a desire to make sure the property is clear and clean relative to the title. It's on county property, so we're going to suggest that the similar size parcel, a similar location on the town land swap to the county land to make it just a nice clean.
3:49:50 So we still have to resolve that issue before we can move forward, really. The county's already agreed to it. We could follow already with their terms and conditions. I met with Marshall Rudolph and asked him, is there a cleaner way to do this for a long-term situation? The property lies in the utility easement.
3:50:19 Councilmember Harvey, your question is answered on page six of the report.
3:50:44 So we had about 20 hours of $2,000 or so, as well as a fee waiver of $2,807. But we have exceeded that amount. Skip, an answer to your question, wouldn't it be nice if a single community that's in Mono County, the town of Mammoth Lakes, that represents approximately two-thirds of the population in the county and has representation of three Mono County supervisors, wouldn't it be nice if those three
3:51:16 Monroe County Supervisors would support the town of Mammoth Lakes and donate that land instead of worrying about a land trade. Just a thought. I think it would be worth our while to ask for them to agendize it and to at least consider that and see where our three representatives stand on that issue. Anything else, Skip? Well, I definitely see the value of this coming in and out of town.
3:51:52 I believe up in Carson as you're going north into town, they're building a monument sign up there. Nothing like this. This is going to blow that away. There's no doubt about it. So I'm for it. The thing that I guess I'm a little bit stuck on is that originally it was brought forward to us as a community project.
3:52:20 That the community was going to fund it. That only the community was going to fund it. And granted, I think it has doubled in size since we did that. So that's something I need to take into consideration. But I'm just kind of going back and forth in my mind. You know, sometimes we override one of our commissions or committees.
3:52:48 And I think we try not to do it. We try not to override them, to listen to what they had to say and take their advice. And in this case, the Public Art Commission said, not our money. You want to do it, you can find another way to do it, but don't do it with our money. So I have a little bit of a concern about that. With that said, I think I'll let Rick talk and tell me why I should. Because we are the community.
3:53:21 We are. Any other comment? I've got a question of John, which is, do you have an amount in mind? I see that option one doesn't include an amount, but to be determined by the council. I'd like to hear from you on that. Yeah, I was just assuming that the original request to the arts council was for $250,000, and I was just assuming that that would be the amount that we would allocate.
3:53:54 Skip along your point of view. I still am trying to be sensitive to the commission, and I want to be sensitive to where there is some level of funding left to where they can prioritize the balance of that funding for the projects that they have previously considered, because I think some of those art projects are worthy.
3:54:23 How much does that leave, if we give them $250,000, what's that, what's that going to leave them, though, it's not going to leave them? $121,000, yes, over $100,000, which I think for the projects, the scale of the projects that they're considering, or that they had considered and actually had prioritized, I think that that would be adequate funding to fund most, if not all, those projects. Okay. The kind of, kind of the difference is, do you spend
3:54:50 And let's just say that $250,000 is the number. Do you spend $250,000 to leverage on the signing project, the monument project that we're considering, or do we spend that money instead on a sign on Meridian Boulevard down by the skate park that has limited exposure to our guests coming in and out of town? I think the one on Main Street is clearly the higher priority. I would agree with that.
3:55:22 Well, as the other liaison to the Public Art Commission, some of the words I heard earlier were impact, passion, etc. Having worked closely with that commission, I have seen them take on the tasks that we asked of them, which is to come up with projects, prioritize them. They've gone through their process and created what goes throughout the community and is on a scale.
3:55:45 Where people are going to be dealing with it face to face. It will not be something they zoom by. I'm also, like Skip said, concerned that it'd start out as no money, then it was $25,000, now it's $250,000. And I just don't know where that part is going to end. My feeling is it's not the right fund to spend the money from.
3:56:11 That, you know, this is the same group that changed their wording to make it applicable for Measure R, and when they got turned down there, they just went essentially to the next pot of money. I understand what you're talking about. A lot of what I also have heard in the letters makes it almost sound like it's more like a, it's part of getting people here and keeping them here and having them take the picture in front of the signs and send it on, and to me, that's marketing.
3:56:43 Not public art. So I cannot support it. Mayor, I would move that the Town Council adopt option number one to determine that the proposed Mammoth Gateway Community Project meets applicable criteria established in the Municipal Code Chapter 15.18 and in the Public Arts Plan and approve the attached resolution authorizing public art funding for the project in an amount of $250,000 by the Town Council.
3:57:19 I'll second it. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Reesman? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Layman? Yes. Mayor Bacon? No. Motion passes 4-1. Are we adjourned? Do we need any more closer? Okay, so we are adjourned to the meeting of Wednesday, March 7th.