TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2012

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 1 hr 59 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

248 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 All the meeting to order, please. Ms. Dutton, could you lead us in the Pledge of Allegiance? Yes, please. Would you all stand and join me in the Pledge of Allegiance, please? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Thank you. Roll call, please.

0:30 Commissioner Brown, here. Commissioner Clark, excused. Commissioner Dugan, here. Vice Chair Tenney, here. Chair Dyken, here. Thank you. Thank you. That brings us to the public comments section of the meeting. This portion of the agenda provides the public with an opportunity to address the Planning Commission on matters not otherwise listed on the agenda. Anyone in the audience wish to address us?

1:01 During public comment. Seeing no hands or motion, we'll move to commission reports. And Ms. Brown? Good afternoon. For our viewing public and press, would you please note that the spring skiing conditions are excellent up until today. So, it's really, I've been out for three days in a row. It's pretty nice out there. Everybody from Southern California should come up for April.

1:32 I've had the opportunity in the last month to interface with the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors and they are working on the seller disclosure for the TOT enforcement program. In the meantime, I would just really like to note that the town has done a phenomenal job of making live their TOT app

1:59 On the website, you can go onto the website, you can type in any address. So for example, this happens to be my home address, I'm not going to tell you what it is. And you type in the address and it says that transient rentals are allowed. And then there would be possible only exceptions if the CCRs did not allow them. And here I typed in a single family home and it very clearly states that

2:27 transient rentals are not allowed. So I just encourage everybody that if anybody ever has any questions about whether transient rentals are allowed or prohibited, there is this application on the town website now that works really well. Very efficient and congratulations Mark to the staff for doing that. It's great. Thank you. I'll pass that along.

2:52 And lastly, we have a report from Economic Stimulus Council, but when you look at our agenda later on regarding the destination, Dr. Says reports, I'm going to include it in that because it really ties in. That's my report. Thank you. Ms. Dugan. Just briefly, I've had the privilege, I guess I'll call it, to be on the road for the last three weeks.

3:21 Traveling for a variety of resorts and trade shows there and seeing what, how the rest of the West fared with their winter and there's some really positive things and there's some things that we need to be very comfortable, comforts us to know that we are not alone in our situations of having a challenging winter but the world on the street is that everybody had.

3:49 Challenges winters. Mammoth was not particularly the worst place that got it at all. I spent some time in Colorado and Utah. And interesting, the season's been over for quite some time in these places, yet there are a lot of things to do. And they live with short seasons every year and unpredictable seasons. So I had some good ideas on how to be happy to share with our economic stimulus committee on.

4:17 What you do when Mother Nature doesn't cooperate and how to make a party at a certain thing. So it's encouraging. The ski industry, though, it's a healthy industry. And there's a lot of optimism for next year, especially out of foreign markets, looking at China being a very strong partner into the market there. And the West Coast is their area, first place to visit as well.

4:45 A lot of resurgence in South America and the United Kingdom coming back too. So Mammoth is definitely a destination of their choice. Love the people and like the product that we provide and just want to see why we all choose to live in a place like this year round. So they're really interested and it looks like a strong season coming up for not only the winter but as well as the buzz is when is Tioga Pass opening and they're poised, ready to go. So looking forward to a strong.

5:14 Strong summer. Because it's snowing, of course it would be a strong summer. Thank you. Thank you. I don't have anything, but I will add one comment to what Rhonda said. Speaking of encouraging tourism from China, I just read a factoid that last year, 30% of Chinese brides-to-be received a diamond ring. In 1990, 1% of brides-to-be in China received a diamond ring. So, interesting thing to...

5:44 Contemplate. Where they're spending the money. Absolutely. They have disposable income. Thank you. I just want to say one thing. The new revision of the advisory body's handbook for the town was in our packet for this week's meeting, and I wanted to mention that I think it was an excellent job. Please, Mark, pass on to Jamie Gray and the other staff members that helped with that. Great job. I will. Thank you.

6:15 Okay. Our first item on the agenda under the presentations heading is about the Mammoth Arts Center and Bruce Woodward. Hello, everyone. Excuse me. Bruce Woodward, I have a small or short presentation, concept idea that some of us have been bouncing around, and that is for an interim facility at the Mammoth Place.

6:51 Art Center, which is 549 Road, which is where the old classic theater is. A couple of years ago, the exterior of the building was rehabbed to greatly improve the street appeal of the building. The building currently has the Mammoth Lakes Art Center theater space. It has

7:34 Some retail stores, a vacant restaurant space, and office space on the top floor, and a laundromat next to the theater space. So that's kind of what the building is now. It's in the heart of the South Old Mammoth Road District, which was part of the South Mammoth Native River District plan study. In that study,

8:07 This part of town was deemed to be the arts and culture center of town, a walkable arts and culture center. It's relatively flat. It's one of the key things with that. Based on that, we have been looking at this, have seen that this really is just a direct outgrowth of that district planning process.

8:36 And in that, the district plan calls for this area of town to be a walkable arts and culture and commercial district. That is to complement the downtown and North Village districts. In the focus, there's a noted that the focus on the arts and events in this area, and one is one of the comments, or these are the, this is part of the executive summary.

9:09 of that district plan. Investment in existing venues like Mammoth Arts Center, that's what this project is. The district plan also calls for a, under implementation and actions, for building momentum through partnership. Partnership between the town and private investment is critical to achieving desired change.

9:44 And to not read everything that's in that study, I'll skip on. Really, this is just a great opportunity right now. We have a primarily or mostly empty building. It's close to the schools. It's close to a major intersection in town. It's very close. It's right on the bus line. It's close to where someday, hopefully, there's a major events venue.

10:15 You know, the Mammoth Creek Park, the east side. All of that is all within very short walking distance of this. So that's kind of the location and some of the background. The building is a two-story building with a basement area with some minor changes to the building. Weak and the colors don't come out very well on that screen. They're good up here and they're good in your packets.

10:49 There's an existing restaurant space that could be used for culinary classes, being able to bring chefs in from local restaurants to be able to teach classes, be able to do things there, be able to do catering for the rest of the facility. There's an existing 180 seat theater space. There's roughly 8,600 square feet of space that could be used for meeting room space in this building.

11:18 Theater with a little bit of work, there's room, there's a way to make the basement area, which is a dance studio currently, into a backstage area, so there's a really good backstage area for the theater for live performance. So that's this level in the plan that's shown there. This plan, which is in your packet and much easier to read there than on screen, gives an idea of the capacities of this building under different.

11:50 Different uses. And the great thing about this is that it's, the building's, you know, it's an existing structure. We have, the town has needs, the town has needs for meeting space, the town has needs for all these other things that we've put into this plan, but we don't have, sorry, I'm having brain fog.

12:23 But we have the ability with an existing structure to use an existing building. We can get something going. We can do it in the interim. We can do something with this that gets us to where we ultimately want to be. The spaces are available. There are, as I said, there's about 8,600 square feet that can be used for a variety of uses. There is an existing 183 theater.

13:02 There is an existing kitchen. We would need to do an elevator with this capacity of people in the building. We need to have more restroom space and we need to have more up-to-date bathrooms in the building. And it really is the direct manifestation of this recommendation from the district plan. The district plan specifically states that 2.5.

13:28 Work with Mammoth Lakes Art Center to support and grow the center as an indoor location for performing arts and community events. And that's, that's, this is, so this is really just that. It really is close to things. People, you know, when you get into Mammoth and things seem like they're really far apart. And it's like Crowley Lakes, it's so far away. And most people in Southern California commute three times that far, four times that far, daily. So this, from Cerro Coso Building to,

14:04 Mammoth Lakes Arts Center, if you walk through the Vons parking lot, which is what everybody does, it's less than half the distance across the campus of UCLA. We view this as a potential, it's a stepping stone to grow into a future larger purpose-built facility. This gives us a chance to have space now, to use that space now, to grow events, to grow meeting.

14:34 The meeting events and such to the point at which we have a demand where then it starts to make sense to have some purpose-built things. The Geothermal Institute has said they would really like to have space like this. They would really love to have their own building, something down by the geothermal plant.

15:00 That's down the road. It's something this would be a facility that would assist them in getting to that point. Really it's just a project that the space is there, the building is there, it's not building a building from scratch. It's something that can be done now and it would benefit the people of town now. That's my presentation. Thank you. Questions for Mr. Weber? Let's go first. Go ahead. Okay.

15:39 You said it needs an elevator. I know there's not an elevator there, but new bathrooms. Is there existing plumbing, existing bathrooms that need to be rehabbed, or is it all new running plumbing to put in entirely new bathrooms? What's in the plan? I think about the financial scope of the project. Let me try and go back here. The ones on the end. On the end, it's that right leg, it's the south end of the building.

16:12 That's where the elevator would be installed because of the service and the basement also. So for getting things to the backstage area. And installing new facilities there. There are bathrooms throughout the building. In the restaurant space has bathrooms. The theater has bathrooms and those would stay. The office space upstairs has bathrooms. But they're a little bit here and there.

16:38 And if you're going to have meeting spaces, we need to get it all pulled into one area where it's separate from the meeting space. There is plumbing. There's enough capacity in the water system and in the water meter for what we're looking at doing here. And there's enough capacity to be able to put some of these spaces we use as artist studios. We have a lot of sinks in some of those spaces also. So there is that.

17:09 The plumbing is there, but there is a need to consolidate and put the bathrooms on in one space to use it as a conferencing and meeting spaces. Are you envisioning this, or John, maybe you could answer this, as a public-private partnership? This would be a facility that the town would be running? How are you going to market this? How's all that going to work? How do you get money out of this? For the record, this is John Baruch. John Baruch, I'm sorry.

17:39 Thank you for the question. Basically, we've learned a lot in the last three or four years. It costs us a lot of money to learn what we learned about this art center. But it has to be, in my opinion, a public-private ownership of some style. It cannot be run by the private entity. This has to be subsidized some way. We've checked into everything in Los Angeles, Orange County, Santa Barbara. You can't make this work on a private basis, no matter how many people there are.

18:08 So to simply answer your question is it has been public matter. How do you end, well, I don't know who would do the marketing. I mean, are you looking at this as extra classroom? It has multi-functions, I know, but are you thinking primarily of extra classroom space for the college? I heard last week, I think, that the current college district is, quote, cutting back. Well, if I...

18:37 I'll just go ahead. Basically, what Bruce has done in his presentation, everything is in there. I didn't want to reiterate, but the Mammoth Lakes Arts Center really has to be as a facility for education. It's art, it's culture, the existing dance studio, of course, culinary, and it's something for the whole town of Mammoth Lakes. So I think education is very, very important. We are within blocks away from the high school as well as the college. Oh, sure.

19:06 As far as what it is, I think that what we have to do in general, not just with this one building, what we have done for 20, 30 years in this town, is we insist on having these individual little groups and running something. In order to make this work, and we know this for a fact, we have to have one entity run as far as the operation, the productions, one entity has to run.

19:35 Has to run this as well as anything else. We can't have two or three entities in town run by separate people, in our opinion. So we have to figure out some kind of a centralized operation that can run this and know what's going to happen as far as where we're going with the events in the college. And to answer your question about the college, yes. If you look at building a school, you're looking at millions of dollars, you can't just build a classroom. You've got to build a school. You can't just add a classroom.

20:04 You know, here, you could very easily add one, five, six, seven, eight classrooms, pretty much for free, because the building's already there. So these can be meeting rooms, they can be classrooms, they can be, you know, whatever. The meeting rooms idea, by the way, the Women's Club met there last month, so, you know, maybe that's something, you know, the Women's Club would like to meet there on a monthly basis. Other service groups in town, we mentioned the GEO.

20:29 It's going to be a long time before they build a building, or at least a while before they build a building, so maybe Geo would meet there. It'd be a meeting place for anybody in town. It'd be possibly for, also for a meeting place for the, for rafters or something like that, you know, for the hotels in town. So it's a combination. There's a number. It has to be, again, what we have learned, you can't just have one venue. You've got to have every one of these. You've got to have the education components. You've got to have the arts. You've got to have the culture, the dance.

20:58 Theater, movies. We need everything to make this thing work, to make it viable. So who would market it? Okay, well, just one person won't, so I guess we go to the second one. It has to be marketed by the town of Mammoth Lakes. It has to be marketed by, you know, for lack of a better term, like a John Erty. You know, the town is one thing, but I'm really in favor of the private public sector.

21:29 Maybe, you know, the one thing you need about the town or a college owner, you don't pay property taxes, there's lots of, there's a number of tax benefits, but I think it has to be run by an entity, and again, I use John Urdi because I think he's doing a great job on marketing, so, you know, not necessarily him, but somebody else that would be running, maybe would work for John or something of that nature. It has to be, has to be run by them. For lack of a better term, the town of Mammoth Lakes or something like that.

21:57 Elizabeth, I want to get the question about the college and the classrooms and the fact that Kern County is saying they're cutting back. If we're planning for what's happening right now, we're never going to ever have what we need. Good point. The classroom that's cutting back right now, everybody's doing that sort of thing. This is looking to the future. We need to be looking at what we hope is going to be happening in the future and plan for that, not planning for what is happening right now. I totally agree.

22:24 And also, there's cutbacks, I read about the same article, and the cutbacks, and we've talked to the college, the cutbacks are primarily in their education, you know, there are the funds out there, there's a number of ways, I suppose, but the college definitely is cutting back, but there are funds out there to do something like this, I would imagine. Do you have a ballpark what this rehab would cost? I know elevators are really expensive.

22:53 Are you not ready to say? Elevator for this is about $75,000. Ooh, the last I heard it was $60,000, it went up. Okay. Well, it's three stops. It's about $25,000 a stop. It's a three-stop elevator, so it's the way that works. Oh, yeah. That's the way that works. Okay, okay. Any other questions? Chair? No, I'm any doubt. Does anybody else have a question? If I could add one point of information to Commissioner Tanney's question. The, um,

23:23 The Economic Stimulus Council and the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition groups in some of their recent work had suggested that the town support a feasibility and market study for attracting high-altitude events and cultural events to the community. And I think one of the key factors that has been recognized in that ongoing discussion is that there's not an organizational capacity.

23:50 That is now supporting events and attracting sporting activities. And in events, we consider live performance, music, perhaps film, because films have been shown in this facility. And I think one of the recommendations we hope to have addressed, or issues to have addressed, is what should the town do? How does the community combine resources to effectively support?

24:19 Obvious resources include Mammoth Lakes Tourism, who has a substantial overlay or relationship to the subject, town, in terms of facilities, and I think some of the existing community organizations that are now doing it could be strengthened. So it's an important issue that needs to be addressed. Probably won't be addressed through that issue, but through the feasibility study, if approved.

24:47 Do you know what time frame? This is just a presentation, right? We don't make any decisions today. And we'll be talking more in the subject later in the meeting today. Oh, okay. When I do my economic stimulus council report. Good. About the feasibility. I would just like to publicly comment that I think it's a wonderful idea and as we will talk extensively later on today, when I do my economic stimulus council report, we're really focused on near-term, near-term, short-term, short-term.

25:17 And so if we can use a facility that's already in existence, I think it's wonderful. And I would encourage you, if possible, to see what you could do with your facility this summer because our tourism is going to be very important to us this summer. But thank you for your appreciation. Point of information, wasn't this the building that went condominium some years ago, John? Yes, it is. And you were, I think, the chair at the time.

25:47 One of the comments that you made that I won't forget is what happens to this building. If we kind of minimize it, then how are we going to bring it back together at a future date? And I think that what we're doing here today is we can bring it back together at a future date to do whatever we want with it. There are approximately, there's about three or four owners. There's 12 units. And because of the economic turndown and the values have kind of decreased a little bit, it is something that could be...

26:18 Purchase as individual units or as a full building, so there's a lot of possibilities here. So the timing is auspicious? Timing is, yes, and I agree. What I sent out basically is I think this is a great time, it's not a great time, it's a bad time, but the example is that we rely on snow and we find out that we need something besides snow in this town. And if we don't have a good summer,

26:46 We've got some major problems, and I think that's part of what you even reported on this afternoon. But, you know, basically, winter's gone. I don't care how much snow we get, we're done. So we have to rely on summer, and summer's going to start in July. And, you know, the one thing about this facility is the fact that it is built. And, you know, another thing that we went and found out also is that you've got to be very careful in building large projects because if you build something too large, we know for a fact that they will not come.

27:16 Especially with the arts. We have to build that. And whether it's, again, in Los Angeles or anyplace else, and they prove that in Los Angeles, even the theaters in Los Angeles, they can't fill them. So you have to start small and work up. And that's what we have. And again, it's a meeting place. It's everything we need today. The other thing that we were thinking of, too, is the fact that we need something to be a very positive in Mammoth, especially now, and I mean right now.

27:45 I think that's exactly what you just said, Mickey. So we got the entry sign that I think is going to go. We've got a wayfinding. That's been approved. And so if we had the Mammoth Lakes Arts Center, we had all three of those all together. We advertised them some way, somehow in the next couple months. Now we've got something for everyone in the summer of 2012. So it's ready to go. Just a thought.

28:13 And hopefully you'll have comments and your thoughts on where to go from here. Again, it's just information only and everything has gone through. Planning Commissioners probably wanted to come and want to thank you for the time to do it. Is the space usable as is on a small scale to start before you actually do the rehab? Yes. The theater is available. Well, of course, the theater, but I think upstairs. The culinary arts center is available. I mean, it's just the idea of turning the switch on.

28:39 The dance studio is, of course, we just finished that last year. It's finished, it's done, it's all carpeted, it's all painted, it's all finished. And then there are two, there's probably about, there's two units right now that could be used in the next 30 days for space immediately. And then the other ones are just a good matter of how to work it out with the other owners.

29:05 So yes, to answer your question, there's no reason why this building couldn't be utilized in the next 30 to 60 days. Questions? I don't have any questions, comments about that. Comments? Thank you. Thank you. Any members of the public want to comment on the presentation? Thank you. That will take us into the business matters portion of the agenda.

29:38 to consider approval of design review 12-001, which is sign permit 12-00003 for an electronic message sign located on top of the existing sign at the Mammoth High School. Ms. Daugherty. Yes, thank you, Chair Denkin. The applicant for this project is Mr. Gabe Solorio of the Mammoth Unified School District, and he's here to answer any questions that you have.

30:07 After my presentation today. The new sign code was adopted in July 2011, excuse me, and that allowed for electronic message signs to be located in the public and quasi-public zone. The Mammoth Unified School District property is in that zone, as is the college property, which I have received interest in, in terms of getting an electronic message sign up there as well. They haven't come in and applied yet, but are interested.

30:36 The proposed electronic message signs approximately 10 square feet. It's single-sided and it would be placed on top of the existing high school sign. The proposed sign does conform with our sign standards with the incorporation of some conditions of approval. Those include to ensure that the message remains up for a minimum of four seconds, doesn't blink or flash or include video messaging.

31:04 That it would maintain the required brightness levels, wouldn't be of an intensity that exceeds our standards. And that it incorporates a well-designed opaque roof feature as required by the code, and that roof feature would not be allowed to exceed nine feet in total height. And with those inclusions of conditions, the sign would meet the sign code standards.

31:30 Also, the environmental analysis for the sign was conducted with the sign code update, which analyzed electronic message signs being allowed in the public and quasi-public zone. So that is covered through the sign code update mitigated negative declaration. Therefore, staff recommends that the Planning Commission choose option one and adopt the attached resolution, making the required CEQA and municipal code findings, approving design review 12-001 and sign permit 12-001.

32:01 0-0-0-0-0-3, including all conditions of approval. I'd be happy to answer any questions. Thank you. Any questions of staff? The only question I have is regarding the conditions, was that jointly worked out between staff and the applicant? We did review those conditions with Mr. Solorio, and I believe he is, those are amenable, he's acceptable. Thank you, conditions, yeah. Other questions? One other question is, you'd mentioned the roof.

32:32 To the sign, and I believe that the original picture you showed me did have a roof aperture that isn't on this, or did I just not, because it was a black and white? They have not finalized the roof design feature, so we haven't seen that yet. Okay, but it was talking about some sort of covering over the sign? Yes. A little bit, yeah. The sign code does require there to be an opaque roof feature. Okay, thank you. That was it. More questions?

33:03 Mr. Solorio, do you have any comments? Yeah, my name is Gabe Solorio, principal of Mammoth High School, and I want to say thank you for putting us on the agenda today and taking our assignment into consideration. This has been a project that we've been throwing around for the last couple of years, even before I was the high school's principal that was talking about. For whatever reasons, constraints, financial, we haven't been pulled together. We fortunately to have high depressants this year take a charge with us this year, and

33:38 And we thought it was time, you know, the high school, we've seen some other ones as we come up, 395, Big Pine, and they've done a good job and they look pretty nice and obviously want to conform to the town's mandates and make it impeachable and make it so it looks nice out front of the high school. We do not have the restructural working currently with Robbie Preston, the press instruction. He was going to sketch something up and we'd be more than happy to submit it, obviously, so you can see it before we put it up and make sure that it does meet, conform to.

34:07 Your codes. And, you know, we're really looking for a lot of people. It obviously would be nice to be able to advertise games and functions and registration and different things like that. And as Ms. Gary pointed out, the dimming technology meets the code. And like I said, we want to do something that looks nice in front of high school. As soon as we find out what those materials are going to be and conform to wind, snow, and what have you, we'll sketch it up, put it on top of there.

34:37 Let you guys take a look at it to make sure we're good. We're fortunate to have a lot of volunteers helping out with this. Our goal is when we get approval from you to move forward, we're right now getting different bits for the dirt work and moving electrical out there and what have you. I'm looking forward to having it as part of a feature at the high school. Thank you. Any questions for Mr. Salario?

35:03 You said that Robby Preston will be in charge of the construction involved? Well, the little roof that we're putting over, he's willing to help us out and donate some time to put that together, so he's putting the materials. Robby's currently working out of town right now, so we've been trying to coordinate some, but he's been busy, and I think he's put some together right now, just wasn't able to submit it in time for this meeting. So as soon as we get it, we'll send it to Ms. Daugherty and for your review. Thank you. Okay, thank you.

35:34 One question for staff. Is there any need for this to come back to the commission with that design? I would assume we can approve it as long as whatever design is brought forward complies with the conditions of approval. We're okay, correct? Correct. The way the condition of approval reads is that the roof design would be reviewed by the Community Development Department before installation. Good. Question?

36:04 Okay, I would like it to come back to the commission. You tell me when we're going to start discussion. We're starting discussion right now. Okay, good. I have no problem with the digital reader board, and I think this is fine for events, but this is a very, very prominent corner. And what you have is a beautiful monument sign. I mean, California Distinguished School, Mammoth High School, the wildflowers, its landscape, it's beautiful. And then you have something completely different just on top of it. And I can't...

36:34 vote for this positively until I see what this roof feature is going to be because it doesn't meet my idea of the highest standard of design because it's not integrated. You know what I mean? You've got two completely different things, one on top of the other. But after Robby comes up with a design for the roof and possibly even separating the two signs so the digital one isn't on the monument but a little bit above it or something so that

37:02 We're looking at a hole, you know, with a roof. I'm thinking of the trail signs that they've done, you know, with a little eyebrow ruse. Have you seen those over at the Visitor Center? Heidi, are you here on behalf of Robbie? Is that the idea? Sure. Okay, that's great. That's great. But this is such a prominent corner, and it's a very... Oh, I'm sorry. She does. That's right. That's right.

37:29 I'm sorry, yeah, I addressed you and you weren't at the podium and that's a problem for people at home and I just made that comment. What I would like to see is I would like to see the final design because this is such an important corner and also because we have this grant for upgrading our wayfinding and signage for our visitors and it's just going to be a comprehensive plan throughout the town and it would be nice if all the different signage

37:57 complemented each other and there was some consistency not matching it necessarily at all but some of the roof features and things like that they're currently in the planning process right now so it would be really nice before we actually vote on this and I don't know what this does to your timetable from my from my point of view and I don't know what the rest of the Commission feels but I would like to see

38:19 The final design with the roof and how it all integrates to make one whole as opposed to the digital signs on top of the monument sign. I think it detracts from both. Heidi, I do know you have to come to the podium for the people at home. It's a height requirement, right? Nine feet height or below? Correct. So now we're going to have a gap in between the sign and then a roof on top of it and still stay below nine feet? Is that the goal?

38:49 We're not telling you how to design the sign. No, no. And then what you just mentioned, you have a grant that all the signs can match each other? It's redoing the signage all over town. Visitors can't find their way around. You can't read the street signs at night. They're dark brown, you know, that sort of thing. So it's just sort of be a comprehensive upgrading of Mammoth Lakes streets and sidewalks and just getting around. That's what's in the works right now.

39:19 Okay, so do you guys want to pitch in on sign? I have a suggestion. Go ahead. Mark, please. Chair, we have a directional wayfinding program underway, so it's really municipal signage that directs drivers and travelers. It won't establish design guidelines for

39:43 All individual monument identification signs, and we don't have funds to contribute to your project. And nor will its timing match your timing to develop. And so it was not our intent to use the wayfinding program to set up standards for all monumentation projects. I wasn't suggesting that. I was just talking about some kind of theme, you know, some kind of... Right.

40:12 And then it kind of is a bummer to have to come back for another meeting to have you guys vote on our design. Does that have to happen? Do we need design approval, or would that just be a courtesy? Let me break in and make a suggestion for the commission. I heard two concerns expressed by Ms. Tinney. One was integration of the new electronic sign with the existing sign, and the other was

40:44 Compatibility, that's not the best word you used. I forget the word you used. I said consistency, but compatibility is better, actually. But consistency with other signage throughout the town. And those two concerns, I can understand that and agree that maybe we can all suggest that the work on the top of the sign try to address those two issues. As to coming back to the whole Planning Commission, I would suggest perhaps some more.

41:14 Expeditious alternative is to have when your design for the roof of the sign is ready or is in preliminary, whatever stage you want to present it, to have it presented to staff and staff discuss it with the sign committee and commission can rely on the sign committee to make a recommendation back to us instead of having to have it come back to us before there's any approval. Thoughts?

41:45 That would, that the sign committee would be the logical subcommittee. Okay. Who is the sign committee? So it's on the sign committee. I forgot. And it's seen this already and addresses some of these concerns off the bat here. Did I imagine I saw the rendering, Jen, of the picture with the roof on it? Or did you see? I have not seen that. Okay, so I was dreaming. No, you've seen that. It was what you said.

42:15 There was one in that, which you guys have isn't quite the scale. All we have is this. Right. The electronic board is closer to the size of the sign that says at the school. Right. It was mirrored that and it had the roof on it. Yeah. So what it did. And that was all to scale. The plan is it will be a composite roof or it will be metal, depending on.

42:43 Kind of the supplies that D&J roofing has like extras of because we don't have the funds to just go first and do stuff. But they'll of course be in like earth tones and then the plan is also to use some masonry to go up the sides to hold the roof. To integrate it. Yeah, to integrate it. And it's hard to be like consistent and compatible with other signs in town when this is the first. Well, I don't believe that's the goal here. You know, I may have a dissenting opinion, but it's sitting on.

43:13 Committee and seeing what it was is this is taking a monument sign and turning it into a marquee sign, which is consistent with any high school in the country. You have no place to advertise where the game is and what time. We used to have one right at the, it wasn't for the school, but it used to be right at the corner of Footloose. That was our one and only reader board of marquee signs. So, and I'm not opposed to using current technology at all.

43:40 They use, and this turns it into a marquee now. I think what, after seeing a possible rendition with the narrower reader board portion that was in proportion to Mammoth High School and the little roof over it, it integrated it well. It didn't provide any glare. It didn't, you know, where it was as it allowed it to. And it didn't move, but it allowed it to announce that.

44:05 So seeing that, coming back to the

44:35 Committee, when we see that done, you know, with whatever those things, I think that we should be able to do it unless we as a commission have a fundamental disagreement on using these at all because I know we don't have a lot of running signs but we have, but this is technology today and I would like to see that we have better use of technology and I think this is a good integration of

45:02 The technology there with this particular sign on a very prominent corner as it should be is going to have a lot of visibility where right now it doesn't have quite the visibility that it could have because there is nowhere else in sign in town that you would be having this opportunity. So I had to look at it very closely of what was it trying to achieve and I think with what you're trying to achieve this is a viable.

45:30 This, in my opinion, is a viable option, but we'll see what, you know, the rest of the commission says. Just for clarification, to be sure, I made myself clear, I have no objection to the digital, the electronic reader board, but I was thinking from a design point of view, if you could put two or three inches between the design reader board and the monument sign with a, you know, structure around it like you're talking about, in my personal opinion, I think you would get a much better result rather than having it sitting there. I don't know, like,

45:59 How it all has to get set up. Well, Robin knows all that. You know, as far as like the electronics and all of that. But I agree, I think that would. Yeah. I think this would be a wonderful addition. I mean, just a wonderful addition. I really do. We've got an existing condition 13 that talks about the roof feature, and I would suggest we can just add to that the desirability of having the way the roof design helped integrate the whole site.

46:29 As to the second issue that you talked about with compatibility, I don't know. We could put some, all other things being equal, it would be nice to have it, for there to be a look at making it compatible, but not a requirement. It's not a requirement in my mind at all. Just to consider it. I think that it already is compatible because of the existing monument sign.

46:58 I think it's updating and providing another functionality for this. I would have to leave it to the builder to decide if it can have space between it or not. I don't think the space is, you know, for a place to not get snow built up underneath it or something. You know, a functionality is, we want to make sure that it functions well, as well as being aesthetic. So I think I would have to defer at that point. And I'm sure that Robbie would be more than happy to look at the sketches of

47:26 You know, what you're going for and keep it in the similar, you know. So what I saw, that's the original sketch, it was fine. And so that's why I was a little surprised to see this because that's not what I saw the first time. And I can understand that it's top heavy. And once you put it in proportion with the Mammoth High School sign, which is what I saw in the roof, it wasn't top heavy, it was proportionate. More discussion? No comments. Okay.

47:58 Jen, do you want to take a cut at that wording? Sure. So for the second sentence for condition of approval 13, that's on page 27 of your packet, we could say the roof feature shall not exceed 9 feet in height and shall be constructed of durable and earth tone colors and shall integrate the entire sign.

48:28 Or shall integrate the electronic message sign with the rest of the sign? Well, it will serve to do that. And shall be designed to be integrated? That's good. Yeah. Okay. Thank you. That's better. Are we all agreeable on that? Mm-hmm. I'm fine with that. Are we taking a motion? I move that we, let's see, this is option number one, with condition 13 amended, as Jen just read to us. Through the chair, before you make your motion, do you want this to be reviewed by the sign committee?

49:00 If so, we should add that. In the motion. Okay. It's either Community Development Director, Signed Committee, or Planning Committee. Just discuss it before. I withdraw my motion. My recommendation is the Community Development Director just review it. I'm fine with that. Okay. I'll reintroduce the motion to recommend option one, which is adoption, excuse me, I'm a doctor says.

49:40 What page is the motion on? 19. What was I surprised? Here we go. Okay, option one, adopt the attached resolution with condition 13 revised as Jen just read to us and subject to the final integrated designs review and approval by the community development director making the required CEQA findings and municipal code findings approving design review 12001 and sign permit.

50:10 12-0-0-0-0-0-0-0-3 and including all conditions of approval as listed and amended. Did I get everything in? I think so. Do we have a second? I second it. We have a motion and a second. Does this need to be a roll call vote, Mr. Moorley? Please. Okay. Roll call vote. Commissioner Dugan? Yes. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Commissioner Brown? Yes. Chair Dyken? Yes. 4-0. Passes. Thank you.

50:40 Thank you. That brings us to agenda item three, to review and recommend adoption of the updated destination resort community and economic development strategy. Chair, Mark Wardlaw, Community Development Director. I'll make a very brief presentation, and you may wish to hear from the Economic Development Committee subsequently. The purpose of this agenda item is to present an update to the three-year

51:14 Destination Resort Community and Economic Development Strategy that we sometimes call Dr. Seds. We were directed by Town Council to work on this through the Economic Development Program that we started last fall, and the Council specifically emphasized updating rather than wholesale redrafting of that document. We worked with the Economic Development Committee of the Planning Commission to pose possible

51:43 Limited new strategies and objectives for this document. And in terms of context, this is probably one of the most salient times to be considering this particular subject. In light of the Great Recession, our current low snowfall for this season, and the pending resolution of the lawsuit between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Lakes Land Acquisition, it is

52:13 It's obvious that we'll be facing a very tough economic condition in terms of resources available to the town to provide various services, programs, and facilities. One of the most important items that is added to this is the idea of an economic recovery focus. In your report, beginning on page 31 and continuing through page 33, we have identified

52:42 From the resort strategy, those items we think that are of particular importance for the first year of this overall effort. In this update, we did not add completion times as we did in the last because as soon as we completed the 2008 document, we started going through layoffs and so the particular timing and completion objectives, many of which were missed, so we don't want to repeat that. So we're focusing on

53:11 Identifying really the top priorities and asking the commission to review these. Are they the key priorities? Should there be any changes or modifications or additions to these priorities listed? And we also call your attention to page 34 at the top under business assistance programs. Under that, it's referring to one specific objective, but it's also asking the commission to discuss the commission's role in economic development activities.

53:39 Is it well described and well defined or should there be actions or projects or programs the Commission should take the lead or champion through a particular process? Ultimately, the Planning Commission recommendations of this document we would expect to present to the Town Council. The Town Council has asked for an economic development report scheduled for their next meeting on April 18th.

54:08 And I would expect or hope that the Chair and at least one member of the Committee present this matter to the Town Council in terms of re-report. Attachment A is the summary document that has been reviewed by the Economic Development Committee. We created a number of drafts. They reviewed a strikeout underline, and they've provided us with some questions. We will have some minor errata to complete.

54:37 Formatting, you know, minor spelling and edits. And then we could go through any questions you have. So the staff recommendation for this item is that the Planning Commission consider this report, identify any changes, and recommend approval to the Town Council. The Town Council approved the last document by resolution. Thank you. Questions of staff? Questions of the committee?

55:07 Okay, so maybe perhaps comments by the committee. First of all, I'd like to really compliment the original committee because it's a very thoughtful and really a workable document and it even became more obvious when we went to update it what a great document the initial document was. I think out of our body of work,

55:33 that this particular document is really one of the most essential things that we're going to do as planning commissions because it clearly then sets the work program for staff and the one thing we know during the next fiscal year we're going to have to be really efficient with staff time and so I would say that every item that's currently in the report is something that we really thought through very

56:02 Clearly. To give you a little bit of a background, we, you know, got a lot of input recently from our Economic Development Committee and the Economic Stimulus Committee. We fed all of that into this report and then subsequently in our presentation today I am going to then talk about a 2012-2013 Economic Development Program that Matthew Lehman is going to present to council next week.

56:32 So the whole idea was to take this whole series of information like a giant funnel. Originally at the Economic Stimulus Council we had 100 plus ideas. We funneled them down to key components that are now really included into this report and then we're going to even narrow the focus down more into what we hope to accomplish this summer. So with that said, I think what's really important is this whole

57:02 section beneath the economic recovery and especially this first objective about becoming a branded high altitude sports and cultural destination and underneath there there was two key tactics and the first one was to complete a cultural and events market feasibility study this was the number one priority of the economic stimulus council and some of us have had the opportunity to see

57:32 The reports, for example, that Whistler has prepared. Whistler has the most comprehensive event and cultural feasibility study that you can imagine. And so if we then can now have like the next document, which would really be this very strong comprehensive study, then when we have questions like the Mammoth Arts Center or anything else that come in front of us, it will be really just give us that guideline.

58:01 And then the second point that the Economic Stimulus Council, out of all their suggestions, felt very strongly about was that we will need then to dedicate some sort of resources. This goes back to your question earlier on, Elizabeth, about how to attract, support, and coordinate then our town-wide events and cultural centers. So when you were asking these questions earlier on of Mr. Verruck,

58:31 It's the number two item. We just don't have an answer for you yet. And it will have to be definitely some sort of private-public partnership. We're just not quite sure where that will fall in. And so I think that really kind of explains my comments about the report itself. And then at the appropriate time, I'd like to just go on and share with you a little bit our 2012-2013 ideas.

59:00 Comment on this report first. Other questions about the report? Do it was fun to make a comment on this? You know what? Go ahead. Go ahead. I'm going to hold them. The thing about how to market it and the public-private, I was surprised when I read this, knowing the semi-unique status of the town. We shared this with Stockton and Vallejo, but, you know, knowing our status.

59:29 Why there wasn't more talk about partnerships with the private sector, and also I didn't see anything about corporate sponsors, whether it's facilities, events, whatever, have you talked about that? Well, do you know where the reference is? Public-private partnerships are very important, and

59:49 I think we felt that this was a three-year document, so we didn't want to say something specific. There are a number of private-public partnerships that John Urdi is currently working on, but it's really too early to state that. And do you have the reference where it is in the report? Well, it gets much more specific as looking at

1:00:13 Loan or grant programs for specific things because what the difference is now is talking about of course there should be public-private partnerships and the next question is for what? And when we've looked in and this is supposed to be a much more tactical document than a strategic document because we've agreed on the strategy but now it's getting into having some things that have a payoff on it. So if you look at

1:00:42 On page 33 at 1-11G at the very bottom is that to develop an economic stimulus program that helps implement business retention and attracts programs. You're looking at loan and grant applications there and programs, that would have to be, the oversight of that would be in someone who has the experience or an entity that has

1:01:07 The resources to write those. But then if you're looking at next to it is creating incentives, well that can come directly from the business community itself. So it's how you do this, but an incentive of you put, here is my product, put it together with your product, we have a bigger product. And I think where the best example is this is the art center itself with looking at taking some very viable space.

1:01:37 And not dedicating it to something that is maybe out the window in a few years. So you're taking that particular space and meeting space. That meeting space can evolve into a television studio where RSM may finally decide that we're worthy of broadcasting from a mammoth legs. But you have the space, but today we don't have that. But in the future, we have the ability to morph these programs into what

1:02:06 Can bring us some more either revenue generation or media exposure that we don't have today. And that's where these small creating these incentives, that's where the business community comes back and answers this, where it may turn out to be that with our very limited staff resources now, we're going to have to get specific, is that we can't go out and promote something.

1:02:32 But we actually have a grant writer here that may go forward and write this particular grant that you could apply to these incentives. So that's where it's getting much more specific in the idea of public-private partnership. Okay, we want to work together. You do this. We do that. Everybody's contributing their expertise. And then we don't have, finding then what resources we don't have left. And then go out and decide.

1:03:00 We're going to put some money towards that, going to put some effort towards that, put some manpower towards it, or do we not do it and move on to one that we have? And that's where this document is starting to get really specific and something that is measurable. Because the strategies aren't measurable, it's only the tactics and what happens out of it, and those have changed.

1:03:24 Oh, yeah. Huge. They've changed. The good news is the overall strategy is still the right thing. It's how we're going to execute it right now that we won't have to wait for any longer. We're just going to do certain things. Chair, also, if I could, embedded in the report towards the end on my page 59 of the packet, you'll see a complete heading devoted to community and economic principles, which specifically address partnerships. So partnerships become a value.

1:03:54 Not a task. A value. An important principle. Oh, absolutely. I have a very specific question. Objective 1.9A on packet page 33, which is to develop a strategy to bring the town into compliance with mandatory waste diversion rates for commercial and multifamily recycling. I assume that comes from the state mandatory requirement. And right now, I understand from

1:04:27 I'm hearing a talk from Brian Robinette from Sierra Recycling that currently the rates for paying for aluminum, paper, and so on are really down, and there's just no profit to be made from it. But do you, with that objective in here, do you foresee that eventually becoming an economic positive, not just a cost?

1:04:50 Is there a way to plan for that? It's actually rather complicated because it relates to the state mandates of how we divert waste and how the facilities here in the town need to be expanded so that there is a capacity to separate them. And then there's the complexity of the rate structure associated with the county landfill. This is a public works task and Ray Jarvis, so Dave Wilbrecht, Ray Jarvis,

1:05:20 Johnny Gates, our senior building inspector, are working on this particular effort. And it's not simple and it's complex. But I think to expand, remember this report has to address what we term our triple bottom line. And that's in there because of the natural resources, not because we figured out yet the economic, but if you can...

1:05:44 No money to be made, you know, the action itself other than the indirect. But you're preserving value. The indirect benefit of seeing a town that looks pristine no matter when as opposed to one that looks like it could use against scrubbing all the time. So that's where the value comes in of these programs. And after seeing communities that have these there, you can tell the difference. You can definitely tell the difference.

1:06:18 Comment on the report? This is good. It's an awful lot for the town to do. I don't know how. Well, let me. I'm worried about that. I think that the difference in, because I've been sitting on this committee and you kind of got, you know, it was an idea that went, well, we should be caring about this is, I think what this does is allow, it has some real specific tactics that I don't see the town doing them all.

1:06:49 I see that there are entities, there's a business community, gives them something very specific that we could sit there and go, okay, I do that every day in my business. Now I can connect with somebody else. And it's not, I don't have to go out and learn something new, figure something out, it's what I do, now I can apply it. And these are ways that the, you know, the chamber absolutely gives them something to say.

1:07:16 Do this specifically, it has a benefit. That's what they're doing in other communities instead of where do I start? Because these particular programs can feel like where do I start? And I see that there's things that the business community we're doing as individuals, but we can pull together and get a better effect out of it, not hurt our individual businesses, enhance our individual businesses and represent us more as a resort.

1:07:45 And then help each other with their economic recovery. And there are some things that come, this came, surprisingly, these tactics came not from the government end of it, it came from the business community. And the reason they're worded this way is because these are the things that are happening in business and there's a certain level of support. And it's the difference between who markets an event center as to who operates an event center.

1:08:15 And one entity doesn't do both effectively unless they've got a lot of staff. And those things aren't happening anymore. So when you say, who markets the event center? Because I work in tourism with Mammoth Lakes Tourism, I'm marketing the event center every time that I recommend coming to stay at my property. What is there to do?

1:08:44 There's something to do right there. I market it. And what Mammoth Lakes Tourism, if they market it, it says, they tell me the specifics. I do it anyway. I could add this link right to my site. We're all in partnership, and now the chain is connected. And everybody has something to market. They don't have a task of marketing it. Marketing it, they have resources to add to

1:09:11 to the shopping basket that the guest is looking for. So suddenly you don't have one entity doing all the work, you have everybody doing it because we're all joined together. That allows another entity who operates to operate and not have to work. There's nothing worse than having to, you know, to build it and fill it to yourself, you know, because you just simply isn't the resource and the time. But now it's taking, it's...

1:09:39 Making people be your spokesperson there. And that's what the business community can do. We just provide them the information and they put it through their channels. So that's how this grows and becomes. Everybody knows what's going on. That everybody knows you have this place to go. Or this, that we are the high altitude mecca for training here. And that's word of mouth and top of mind that you can't buy.

1:10:05 But everybody knows about it there. So that's the difference in these particular things because the town can't do it and the business community can't do it. We can all take a little bit of it. Nikki and Rhonda, do you see us becoming the Planning and Economic Development Commission? Well, yes and no. And let me just answer that in a second. So to dovetail on what Rhonda was saying,

1:10:32 Matthew Lehman at the Council meeting next week as Mayor Pro Tem is going to really introduce his 2012-2013 Economic Development Plan. And in that Economic Development Plan, he is asking community leaders to develop a passion for a program which will enhance tourism this summer. Increase tourism, enhance tourism this summer. As he says, you know, we can't

1:11:02 We don't need snow to be the best summer ever. And so we now call this our best summer ever program. And so, for example, the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors is going to start a campaign this summer, a marketing advertising campaign about why it's a good time to buy in Mammoth Lakes. And it is a very good time to buy in Mammoth Lakes. The Mammoth Mountain has agreed that they're going to really

1:11:29 Promote and try to increase the size of their Mammoth Mud Run. John Urdi is going to go and do an all-out increasing our high altitude training center. So what's going to happen is that we're going to take these key ideas and then really promote them through the community leaders.

1:11:54 And at one time we had talked about that particular program would be through the Planning Commission, but we were advised we really run into a problem doing that, to answer your question, because of the Brown Act. So as far as our...

1:12:09 2012-2013 Economic Development Program. We certainly are encouraging you as individuals, I mean, Elizabeth, you've already kind of done this, is to take a program that you really champion and get involved with it to make it like the best ever. I mean, they've already started this great campaign for fishing, but we want it like to be our best fishing season.

1:12:32 Ever. Because if we have a really strong summer, it will go a long ways to curing a lot of our economic ills that we've experienced this winter. So the 2012-2013 campaign, we will not be running through Planning Commission per se. That will still be through the Economic Stimulus Council. What we will do, and we haven't quite defined this,

1:12:59 But we had a conversation with Mark Warlaw and actually Dave Wilberg about what role then, because if you go through these other objectives, what are these other objectives, such as the neighborhood district planning for gateway, would be very appropriate then to run through Planning Commission, and that would be a cause that we would champion, that would tie into this, but we do not have that action agenda yet. Right, Mark? Right. Okay. You talk about the gateway district. Yeah, right, precisely. So.

1:13:29 So if I could add to that piece, so what you're looking at is essentially priority programs that the council would have to approve as a work program effort. So the timeliness is that we're starting, we'll be getting soon into the public discussion portion of the budget, and so your review of the priorities is important, and being very thoughtful that we have some pretty severe staff limitations.

1:13:58 And so if we're working on one project, we can't do another project. So we want to make sure that we're working on the right projects at the right time. Good work. And then in my, I sent a series of minor corrections that need to be made to the document. But one recommendation I had was, and I'm just as guilty as everybody, we really use a lot of acronyms.

1:14:32 And so I thought it'd be very nice if we put a key, and I can help you do that, to the document with our acronyms in it, so. Okay, so are we... I have no other comments. Do you have any questions? From the public, questions? I see a hand. John Baruch. I'm listening and I got a little confused. So, and I think half people in this room were on the Economic Students Council.

1:15:08 We spent a lot of time on that and then of course got down to like you said. So am I hearing that you're going to be doing two things? One, you're going to be doing this survey or whatever, you're going to have a, we're going to hire someone to do a, what's the word I'm looking for? Feasibility study. Feasibility study. And of course like every other study that we do is going to take, it's going to take money, time, and then we have to study it and then we have to implement it. So right there we got nine months.

1:15:38 So we're going to do parallel tracks. We're going to do this study so that next year at this time we might implement it. And then we're also going to do something that we're going to be doing something by June of 2012. Is that what I'm hearing? So, okay, let me see if I can clarify this for you. So regarding the feasibility study, we have put together an application for Measure U and Measure R money for the feasibility study. Okay. Regarding how we're going to provide the resources

1:16:08 We felt that we needed to have at least an idea of what the feasibility study said first. That was part two of the Economic Stimulus Council's primary objectives. One was the feasibility study, two was to have the resources to promote. And what we felt, what we're working towards as far as that goes is a September 2012 date because by September of 2012,

1:16:37 Then we need to be starting to put together our 2013 calendar. All right. So while in planning that's relatively short term, that was not short term, short term enough for the summer. So then that's when we started the next where we're just having a 2012 economic development campaign that Matthew Lehman's really launching. What can we do this summer?

1:17:05 And he's going out, he's just starting this next week where he's going to ask every community leader, what can you do to help increase or enhance tourism this summer? And if nothing else, would you please adopt a program that some of these other organizations are spearheading, like the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors Program or the Mammoth Mountain Program, because if we all chip in, we can make this summer a very strong summer. So that's our short-term, short-term.

1:17:33 Okay, so I did understand, I guess there are two parallel tracks. Correct. You're not going to wait for the economic. No, we can't afford to wait. You can't, because this is going to take. Right. Even though you get in September, October, it's going to be next year at the 24-minute. But what I haven't heard is, and if you're going to rely on business people, this is great. Right. But, again, it's like, I guess, what was that term? Are they herding cats? You're going to have to figure out, you know, who's going to be in charge of this.

1:18:03 And so far I haven't heard who's going to be in charge. Is this going to be tourism? Is this going to be the town of Mammoth Lakes? Is this going to be individual owners? Who's going to be in charge? No, the economic development campaign for the summer is going to come through the Economic Stimulus Council. Okay. Primarily Matthew Lehman and Mickey Brown. Okay. And we're very open to any suggestions, anybody in the public has, about what we can do to help this summer. Okay. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you.

1:18:33 Any other comments from the public? Nikki, could you talk a little bit about the feasibility study? Because I'm still looking at this with the point of view of a seven-year-old. But just like, why do we need that when you consider the talented, smart people we have in this town? And we have such a good model with Whistler. Why do we need to do that? Is that your position? That's not my position. So it's hard for me to defend.

1:19:04 But we, you know, Economic Stimulus Council met. There is an event coalition group. There is the Recreation Commission. Have I left anybody out? And so there are various entities that had, everybody agrees on the end, but they had different ideas about how to get there and what exactly we needed.

1:19:31 So it was determined that this was the best way to do it. Rhonda, do you have any? I totally understand. That was very well done. You know, because everyone has particular passions and agendas. Absolutely. And if they all got to agree on that, the goal was increased revenue, increased visitation. So we all knew what we wanted to get, and getting there was differently. And there are some things that...

1:19:58 That may not be feasible here. And we need to take some of this stuff off the table. And I think that being the high-altitude recreation center defines something that we believe that we can execute because we are executing it in certain ways with the limited facilities that we have, that it's comparable by studying these other feasibility.

1:20:28 Particular studies and looking at them saying, yes, we can do that. We're in balance to do that. But there are certain things that are particular passions of people that, yes, it can be done, but we're going to have to say it just doesn't bring in the desired goal over the way another one does. And it's to where we all agree on something, that if this is the way that we're going to...

1:20:55 Take the banner and go for it. We're going to go for it and give it, you know, and support it completely. And to John's point, you know, it's the business community is not taking the lead, this, you know, this division of the Economic Stimulus Council is, but the business community contributes their portions. So obviously they can't come back to me and give me one more thing to do, you know.

1:21:20 Jump out the window. But I do have, I know what I can provide for you, and I can deliver that, which is very, very important to getting it all together, and everybody provides what they can and contributes to there, and it will have this end result. So it's so, don't we have every bit of information that we possibly need? Don't even have time to digest it. But in the effort of these things are just not feasible.

1:21:46 It's not to say we can do everything. It's that, no, we need to narrow it down and do a few things right. Do you think you have buy-in from all the groups on the feasibility, accepting the feasibility, a feasibility study? You can answer that better. We had a joint meeting with the Economic Stimulus Council and the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition, and at that meeting, the focus was how do we initiate

1:22:15 The real outcome, which are event facilities. You know, we've talked extensively about having formalized quality outdoor amphitheater event facilities to hold what we have now, but also to grow new ones. And the core objective is heads and beds. We have gaps in our calendar. We have, you know, fantastic opportunities to fill days throughout the summer as well in the winter.

1:22:44 So some should be outdoors, some should be indoor, but there isn't a cogent strategy. There are too many adverse opinions and belief structures that don't allow us to move forward with a particular facility plan. So at that meeting, members of that group actually asked for the feasibility study. So we reviewed feasibility studies.

1:23:11 A raft of feasibility studies and we found three very well done models. All of them described in detail what that market was. What population are you trying to attract and why would they come here? What will draw them here? Why would you expect them to come? What facility program requirements then should you be looking at? How does a proposed facility size in comparison to

1:23:38 Major facilities and major metropolitan areas to smaller facilities such as Murphy's, the Ironwood amphitheater. The more well done studies looked not only at cultural events, and for us cultural events include music, live performance, film showings, not film distribution is selling, that's the Sundance Film Festival, they're actually selling film product to producers and distributors.

1:24:08 But why would people come here to see a film performance? They also speak to athletic events. We long know that we have very successful softball use here in town. How do we grow that? Can we grow that? What does it mean to us to have more high-altitude training? Is it sponsorship? Is it people? Or is it possible for us to have other sporting events? The Indian Wells Tennis?

1:24:38 Championship, that didn't used to be there. The Coachella Music Festival, it did not used to be there. The Laguna Beach Arts Festival, it did not used to be there. So until we take initiative based on solid information that we can then grow and change to, you know, it's just back to opinions and beliefs and hopes. And so the easiest way for us to actually change our visitation market

1:25:05 is by identifying these that complement our recreational structure and then be focused to achieve implementation. Just like our TMT implementation program is built around a team of people who are dedicated to a purpose, that's what this program is intended to be. I like that we're growing, just like in Bruce's presentation and John, too, talking about starting with something we have and, you know, making it a facility that we can use but on a small scale and then it will grow. And we just, we can grow.

1:25:35 Lots of things. Yeah, we all need to be good gardeners. Inherent into this is the partnership involved. So we have a strong tourism agency now that's marketing and promoting, as well as, you know, John has specific experience in putting on events, which is a great asset to us. We do not now have anybody on the phone attracting producers. So, you know, for me to try to hold an event, that's not what we're set up to do.

1:26:03 The town has just revamped its special permit application process, and we also are interested in finding ways to support and grow our existing facilities. So it's really a totally new work program that's focused on an outcome and result. This is good. And I just, one last comment from my point. And while originally I wasn't

1:26:28 Highly in favor of doing a market and feasibility study after seeing some that were really well done. I do think it's going to be a great advantage. I've never seen one, so. Well, I'll email you. It's 238 pages. No, don't email me. Chair, also, I want to point out one thing that we kind of tricked you on. In the original...

1:26:50 Strategy and objective of attracting people. We included the idea of completing the Gateway District Master Plan with recreation facilities. We moved it so it's not quite as prominent. We put it under the placemaking category on page 43 of your report. And the idea in high-altitude sports, for example, is not only do we need to understand the market, but following that market and feasibility study, what are the facilities that are required?

1:27:20 And can we develop a truly practical development program that can be built over time that enhances and actually achieves these types of recommendations? And so, you know, speaking to facilities and the organizational infrastructure is equally important. Okay. Are we ready to consider recommending adoption of the three-year update? I have to change it. Tactics.

1:27:56 Strategy. That was a good word to you, is tactical. Chair, also, if I could, in the recommendation that's posed by staff, option one, we'd like to recommend that, but also modify it so that the errata minor changes that would be made were actually reviewed by the committee before it's forwarded. So it might be...

1:28:24 Recommend adoption of the three-year update to the Dr. Seds, the Destination Resort Community Economic Development Strategy with modifications and as approved by the Economic Development Committee. Can I entertain a motion to that effect? I so move. So move. Do we have a second? I second. Does this need to be a roll call vote? No. I ask all those in favor to say aye. Aye. Aye. All those opposed?

1:28:54 Motion carries 4 to 0. Thank you. Thank you. That brings us to Agenda Item 4, which is to consider and provide direction on the recommendations made by the Ad Hoc Efficiency Committee regarding agenda organization, meeting frequency and length, content of meeting minutes, and paperless meeting packets. Chair, to what extent of a staff report would you like on this item?

1:29:25 Use your best judgment. That's sufficient. Before you today are a couple of items, a revised report, and you'll notice a totally different format, and this is titled the Mammoth Lakes Planning Commission Recommendation Report. Attachment 1 is a report by the American Planning Association, zoning practice, titled Better Staff Reports.

1:29:54 And also Attachment 2, which is a modified report to something that you've already reviewed. Attachment 2 and the report itself embodies the recommendations of the Commission so that you can see the recommended report format changes. The report format changes are intended to increase the ease of the Planning Commission and interested parties, the public, to understand the reports that are presented.

1:30:22 and reduce the time in discussion, making it more still, more focused with the flow of the presentation leading up to your actions. The committee reviewed a number of drafts and recommended this. The committee also had specific recommendations regarding a revised agenda as described in the report.

1:30:47 specific comments on the frequency and length of meetings, which includes a more focused management of meetings, and I will point this out. One of the keys under meeting management technique is when you as a commission are speaking, that you follow a more rigorous agenda, that you first identify the item, that you accept the staff report, and the staff report is only

1:31:15 Meant to provide information. You ask questions to clarify if you have any questions of staff and with the applicant, and then you accept public comment. We would recommend, and your committee recommends, that you no longer continue open dialogues from the dais to the floor. Your deliberations should be your deliberations, and then when you have some form of consensus, you can then form your recommendations.

1:31:44 And the idea of this is to be more structured. This is common with other communities do. And we're trying to have more efficient meetings, reduce the time so that you are always on schedule. The committee also recommended a revised report organization, which is described. They confirmed the current content of minutes. And then finally, we have not completed our work on paperless meeting packets.

1:32:15 That concludes our analysis. Thank you. Questions of staff? Questions of the ad hoc committee? Well, I asked a lot of questions today, so I know we went over our time, but on the last round, I asked. Well, we don't have to be efficient until we adopt those. And I can see that, again, I was being singled out, but that's okay. But anyway, these are questions that I thought were relevant and of interest.

1:32:46 But I did ask permission of the Chair, Sada Voce on the last one, to see if I could extend for a few minutes. The time limitation, I know, you know, all deliberate speed is what we're after, but the time, I mean, this is really good discussion about the Economic Stimulus Council and about, you know, John's ideas that, you know, are figured out by Bruce. That was good stuff. That was stuff to talk about. And so it was hard to keep it artificially to.

1:33:13 You know, nine minutes or whatever was allotted. So what do we do about that problem? Because it affects me so often. I think that takes all the members of the commission discipline and also both ends of that are not good. Letting it go too long.

1:33:38 Or cutting things off just because you've got a principle of cutting things off because different discussions take different amounts of time. So that's something that's ongoing that takes the chair realizing when you have to cut it off and sometimes the chair doesn't realize it and needs a little elbowing from one of the commissioners. So all this together can do that, I think. Okay. Questions, comments? Well, first of all, I'd like to thank staff for

1:34:11 Doing a mock staff report for us. I mean, I'm sure they're not fun to do the first time and let alone to go back and do it a second time. But Commissioner Jay really spent a lot of time trying to reformat the staff report so that they would go into the order that we'd be discussing them and most of all about in the executive summary setting up what the legal question is that we're being asked to comment on.

1:34:40 And I think it really worked out well. So now, with somebody in the public, please bring us forward a project so we can approve it. Wouldn't that be nice? Yeah, I like the executive summer too. One thing I would note is that I think this is something that probably on a yearly basis needs to be revisited because there's always room for improvement. And I'm sure that this will not be anywhere near perfect. We'll find things that...

1:35:10 We've made a change and then we'll say, well, this may not be as good as it was before. So we do need to, on an ongoing basis, keep the issue of efficiency in mind and make changes when we need to. And then you may have noticed what we try to do is use fewer attachments and more graphs so that you could just read your report and not have to flip back and forth. That was the key. Yeah, and I think that the idea of graphical or chart...

1:35:40 Type presentations came originally from staff and it became immediately apparent to me when we did the first sample compared to the way it was to adding those those graphical chart matrix kind of forms of organizing information is a tremendous improvement and efficiently being able to absorb the material so I really like that change very small item for my efficient reading of my packet would be to have all the subheadings in caps it just

1:36:10 Much easier to scan through. That's an idiosyncrasy probably, but just I would like them in caps. The commission is to have subheadings in caps. We're happy to accommodate you. Good. Okay. Thank you. That would make it easier to refer back. Bold and caps. Worth a try. We have a comment from the audience? Not from there, but from the podium, yes.

1:36:41 Hi, my name is Lee Gosch. You're talking about the agenda and how you write it out. Is that what you're talking about and how it works? Yes. Agenda item number four. I remember once before we talked about, like, it says the Mammoth Arts Center. Put the address down. Nobody knows where the address is. We talked about that before. I didn't know where it was until I saw a picture up on the film thing there. Because they mentioned to put the address, you know, the specific address instead of,

1:37:12 Review 12.00. That is in the new format. And then at the last town council meeting, I talked to some people about this. After each subject that you talk about, put public comment because they forgot it last time at the council meeting and some things didn't have public comment and it was taken care of without the public comment. The people are very important to be involved in the political process.

1:37:37 It's nice when you talk to them when you're at the diocese because it makes them feel like they're part of the process and they're involved with you guys. I don't like to see that cut off because people feel like when they come up here and you don't acknowledge them that you're not listening. So it would be nice if you talk a little bit. Okay, I want to clarify a little. I thought I heard you maybe saying two different things, but the discussion you were having here about limiting comment wasn't eliminating comment, but you're talking about making sure that

1:38:05 There is an opportunity for public comment, correct? Right. That would be nice underneath each agenda to put public comments so that you don't forget because everybody's, they're saying council's really distracted at this time. It would be nice to have public comment underneath each matter agenda so to remind you so you don't forget. Okay. I don't know whether it's advisable to have it in writing on the agenda but it's worth considering. And if you don't have public comment at the bottom of your agenda anymore, you don't have it at the end anymore?

1:38:31 Oh, okay. I'm misunderstanding. I'm talking about both of them. I'm talking about both. Okay. So we did consider that. We have had periods of public comment at both the start and the finish, and we discussed that extensively, and our conclusion was that we did not need both of those comment periods. So that is, we are eliminating the second public comment period.

1:38:57 From what I understand why you put it at 2 o'clock was so people in the morning, they can come halfway. And so that's when the people get off work late. They can come at public comment because they can't come in the middle of the day. And other people are just the opposite and can't come for the other one. But that's why you have both of them. No, that's... Don't forget the people. We're not forgetting the people. Can I just comment? Well, one reason, too, is because now you can make e-comments.

1:39:25 Which we will take in so if somebody can't actually be physically present in our meeting, they're able to make e-comments. But then to go to your first point, Mark, aren't I correct? There are certain items that we discuss that don't require public comments, right? It's not that we're being rude to the public. I think that's the procedure, legal procedure. I don't think we have a technical procedure for all items. For a public hearing, there's a specified step.

1:39:55 But it has been the tradition of the commission, and on an item, as defined in this report, you accept a staff presentation, the commission asks questions and clarifications, and then you ask if there's public comment, as you did today, and then you stop the public comment, and then the commission deliberates and finds consensus to act or extend or whatever your action is.

1:40:23 So you do do that, and we recommend that you do that. Yeah, I think it's appropriate on this subject matter also to talk about the difference between a public meeting and a meeting with the public. Yes. This is a public meeting. It is not a meeting with the public in the sense that it's an ongoing dialogue. It is a more formalized procedure, and there is a time when it's appropriate for the public to...

1:40:51 To air its opinions and there's a time when it isn't. So it's important to keep that distinction in mind as well. Yes. So when you have the emails for public comment, are they on the internet so people can read it? Because it's nice to know what other people are thinking and people feed off of each other and it makes people come forward. So how do you find out about things when people email stuff in? It's a compromise. That's what's good about public comment here. People can see. It's a compromise because on the one hand, if you

1:41:19 Were to ensure that the e-mailed comments were available to the public before the meeting, you'd have to cut them off, whereas we now allow e-mailed comments right up to close to the start of the meeting, so obviously you can't promulgate those. I feel like it's time for getting the people and the purpose of it. Thanks. Thank you. Chair, just to be clear, through our Granicus system, that's the software provider,

1:41:46 We accept email comments, and when we get them, we pass them out. For written comments that we receive before we publish the packet, we'll include those in your packet, and you receive and file those. And receive and file is an acknowledgment that you've received them, and we've placed them in the file. So there's no limitation to information. What the Commission has discussed at length before years ago, it has been a policy.

1:42:15 When a citizen or an entity gives you extensive written information at the meeting, you do not have time to read it. And so you have an option in certain circumstances to receive it and not rely on it, or you can continue the matter if it's salient and worthy of additional consideration. So you always have options.

1:42:44 Yes. I did have one comment that I forgot. On page 66, D, written comments, you're only referring to written public comments being submitted in advance of the meeting to allow reasonable time for that information to be read and thoughtfully considered. That doesn't refer to our practice, I mean, almost a rule that anything related to an application has to come in in time to go in the packet.

1:43:11 So we're not getting to be considered. To be considered. That's with an application. This is just general public comment about agenda items. Is that correct? Well, you know, on an application or, you know, if you think about what you do, you have land use permits, you have legislative actions, general plan actions, and your sentence is, the Planning Commission has previously determined that written material is to be submitted in advance of the meeting.

1:43:39 We will want to make sure that we've reviewed that information.

1:44:09 And it has been adequately considered in the CEQA evaluation. So that's why there can be some different circumstances. Okay, what I was referring to is like nine or ten years ago, we would get torrents of information the night before a meeting. Principally from the applicants. From the applicants. And you do not accept that anymore. Exactly. I just wanted to be sure that we were distinguishing between the two so the applicants won't do that anymore.

1:44:38 There won't be permitted to do that. What? And they have not. Yes. Good. Comments? Can we entertain a motion, I think, at this point? Vicki, you do that. I hate to. Oh, you really can do that. I know. Oh, you're on the committee. Okay, was it Rhonda? I think I did sure. Okay, Rhonda, you do that. I made all the motions today. Proposed that we approve the proposed changes for the Planning Commission's agenda. This is option one organization.

1:45:17 Agenda meetings, organization meeting frequency, length, and contents of meetings with any modifications determined necessary by the commission. I second. We have a motion and a second. This can be a voicemail? Yes. All those in favor, please say aye. Aye. Aye. All those opposed? Motion passes 4-2-0. Good. That brings us to director reports, Mr. Wardlock. Thank you, Chair, members of the commission. A number of items for you today.

1:45:49 First, I want to let you know that we have been, we the town, have had a series of conversations with Mammoth Brewing Company. As you know, probably Brad, they are potentially leaving town, looking for a larger production facility site, perhaps in Inyo County. And we the town are actually interested in having them stay. They represent jobs, they represent investment, and they represent a brand image that's very well...

1:46:18 And widely distributed throughout the community, throughout the state. So we're interested. And so we've been studying different sites with them. Nothing formal. We're trying to investigate if it's feasible. And the sites, the bigger sites, they're looking for something, that three and a half to five acre site. And they're also a little time sensitive. So they're going to move forward shortly. Some of the sites that we...

1:46:45 Did a quick survey of, included the Civic Center site. It's not obvious that we will be building a Civic Center anytime soon. And so that site may have some merit. We've looked at the college and foundation site. We've discussed with Mr. Russell some opportunities there. And we're also considering sites in the vicinity of the airport. The paper, the sheet, on April 7th, cited a community center.

1:47:14 Sorry, on Forest Trail, we're not looking at that site. It wouldn't be appropriate to the land use and the situation and the proximity to the neighbors. So continue to work with them, and it will be a fast-track item. And I think that subject goes to show the importance of economic development, because economic development is essentially a policy and way of thinking a community has. So you're either engaged in attracting and retaining employment or you're not.

1:47:43 And I think that most people would agree that one of the best forms of affordable housing is job creation and economic vitality in the community so people can actually afford to live within the community. I'd also like to remind you on April 18th that this economic development material would be presented, I think, by the Chair and by Mickey Brown.

1:48:13 Rhonda is out of town that day, so I think a good showing would be valued. In terms of... You're doing council on the 18th. Yes, town council presentation. The TOT Enforcement and Revenue Collection Program is really well established now. We have completed two sets of municipal code changes. They're now effective. They improve our ability to achieve code compliance and revenue collection.

1:48:42 So that is complete. We have a pretty solid team. We've added Sandra Moberly to be our overall project manager. And so that gives us Sandra, our planning intern, Ms. Kent, who is doing a fantastic job and extensive research on the Internet. And we've formulated all of our kind of procedural morning letters and now citations. And now we're moving.

1:49:11 into an even faster process where with a letter of warning, we're also requiring the payment of TOT, so referring those applicants or those people to a finance department. The team also includes some time from our permanent technician and also time from our administrative analyst and myself, so it's a lot of resource to this effort and in terms of revenue collection.

1:49:41 It's probably the highest priority we have right now. We've been leaving money on the table, and so we're going to address that. Our now effort has shifted from code compliance. We have the code compliance program set up, and now we're moving into assessments. We have had about 170 different cases. Many of those have been closed out, and out of those cases, we have about 100 projects, 100 units.

1:50:09 Can you do a tax lien? For those

1:50:40 Owners who choose not to cease and desist, who choose not to pay fines and penalties, and who choose not to remit. There are a host of penalties. First, the citation process can be either an administrative process or it can be a non-administrative, it can be a misdemeanor event. And the fines go up dramatically. They start at about $100 a day.

1:51:08 Advance to $250 and then up to $500 a day. And then each and every day there is a violation. It is a new violation. And we will report it and track it. And so you can quickly see the fines will add up. In a misdemeanor case, which is a discretionary decision, the fines can go up to $1,000 a day. And so we will enforce those. Ultimately, they're either collected through a lien.

1:51:34 Are you finished with your report, Mark? Yes, ma'am.

1:52:05 What realistically can happen next with John's idea that was presented today? Under Director's Report, what you have seen in your total presentation today is, principally through the destination resort, a focus on events, athletics, and what that means to us, really a couple of different things. One, we need to get our program together so we're...

1:52:38 Operating on facts and information about what we're going to do and then figure out how we're going to do it. Mr. Verruck's project happens to be one of those few facilities that has seating and a roof on it, so there's a lot of merit to it. Some of the top priorities that came out of our ESC work was the focus on events and drawing people here and the focus on meeting space.

1:53:07 Before, you know, at that time, this was not a gel concept that that group had discussed, and so that group focused on the importance of, you know, certainly requiring event space with appropriate development, but also taking advantage of what we have now. The members talked about the fact that this is a four-square-mile city, and we need to...

1:53:31 Combine our assets so that we're getting more out of what we've got now. And so this would tend to fit within that. I think Mr. Verruck, as really the owner and perhaps philanthropist in this effort, what we've seen is his work with Mr. Woodward to come up with a concept. And I think what he probably would need to do next is start forming some more collaborations.

1:54:00 How does he work to develop relationships with people that would actually operate the facility in terms of developing whatever the program is, film, live performance? And then that went back to one of our strategy items, is how do we create a stronger organizational capacity to support events, performance, and film, and be stronger together?

1:54:29 And kind of collaborate more effectively. So we hope that will be, you know, something that he needs to do himself, but also something that comes out of our feasibility study. In the long run, or in the short term, you know, I think we've laid out our steps, you know, first with the feasibility study, then we probably move to the gateway and that facility planning process. Measure D, measure R.

1:54:55 Our financial resources that should be considered in this. When we look to the gateway site, the key, you know, we won't be doing much with the trails or the industrial park, and so the major focus areas will be on college foundation and school district properties. You know, are the right things in the right places, and have those opportunities, you know, been explored in today's climate, not the 10-year-ago climate.

1:55:24 I think that there are some steps that Mr. Baruch needs to continue taking, and I think the community and the town need to develop their strategies concurrently. I will add one thing I should mention. We've just applied, submitted an application for a CDBG grant, which one of them will focus on developing an economic development strategy, community development block grant monies.

1:55:55 And we're also starting to explore USDA grant sources. And there's a tremendous breadth in the grant programs that the USDA provides, which includes community facilities. So, of course, we have to be directed to allocate staff resources to developing the financial resources that we might be able to plow back into the community. Thank you. Thank you.

1:56:28 Next item is future agenda items and commission meeting dates. Any discussion? I have nothing for you at this point in time. We'll hold your regular May meeting. So it'll be the second Wednesday of May? Yes. Okay. This may be the last opportunity for a second public comment period. Am I right?

1:56:55 I believe this is. So, members of the public, here's your last chance. Pardon me, if you wish to address the council commission, please speak to the microphone. John, just a note for your information that the first agenda item was on schedule. Thank you. Last public comment. No, no. Pay attention to him.

1:57:32 Just a very brief public comment. I'm Jeremy Goico, head of the Political Action Committee for Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce and owner of Black Tie Ski Rental Delivery in town. And just wanted to let you guys know, all the talk about the feasibility study sounds really great. I've talked to John Urdi on a separate occasion kind of about that and high-altitude training in Mammoth, and I think that's a great direction for this town to go.

1:58:01 I've also been in talks with John Connolly to try to put together a Columbus Day youth soccer tournament in town, so I hope to maybe talk to you guys a little bit about that at some point. Is that something that could happen this year? I hope so. My business will be kind of wrapping up in the next week or two, and I'll have a lot more free time to put into that. I'm going to try to use the...

1:58:27 Mammoth Lakes Young Professionals Group as kind of to help me put that together as well. I just started that with Casey Hendrickson and we had Rusty Gregory as our guest speaker the other night in our third meeting and things seemed to be going really well with that so I just kind of wanted to let the Planning Commission know about that as well and just kind of really support everything that was discussed here especially about.

1:58:54 You know, the direction, where we're headed with all that stuff in the feasibility study. I'm sorry I missed the media or the Bruce and John's thing, but I'll talk then.

1:59:06 Thank you. And Jeremy, if you would ever like any of the planning commissioners to come speak, we'd be happy. We're not quite to par with Rusty, although we are too old for your group. No, it's for young professionals and people that are young at heart. Quick question for Commissioner Mickey Brown. When is Matthew Lehman going to be giving his this is the best summer ever talk?

1:59:35 He will at council meeting on the 18th. It's on the agenda. Okay. And then they formally have to approve it. All right. And so we'll be in contact with you. Fantastic. Thank you. Thank you. With that, I think we can adjourn the meeting. Thank you. That's good. Thank you. That's good.