TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2012

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 5 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

394 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

4:51 First and foremost, Town Budget 101, the composition of the town's budget. We will also provide an update on the town's finances for the year that ended in June of 2011 for the current fiscal year as well as the next fiscal year. We will provide a status of scheduling mediation with the town's creditors and we will present a schedule of meetings for a public discussion on all these items.

5:22 Now it is a little difficult to see this chart because of the lighting, but last thought was the funding sources of the town. And what we wanted to do in this presentation is really go back to basics for the community, for the council to refresh their understanding of how the town's budget works. Because we think this is important for you, the community, to understand how we can or cannot spend your taxpayers' dollars.

5:51 The town has numerous funding sources, and most of them are established by law. A lot of them are restricted. For example, on this chart, you will see on the bottom, there is a slice called grants and subsidies. Well, grants and subsidies in general are restricted to the particular purpose for which they were given to the town.

6:15 There's another large slice on the right-hand side. Transit occupancy tax is one of the largest revenue sources that the town has, as most of you may know. There are other funding sources such as assessment districts, such as utility users tax, measure U, such as gas tax. All of those are restricted.

6:42 One of the larger slices here is called fund transfers. This town has quite a complicated system of transfers among funds. It is not atypical. It is typical for some smaller towns. So that's basically a revenue that gets counted twice or three times. For example, we get our transit occupancy tax, we place it in the general fund, and then we make a transfer.

7:09 To the transit fund, to the tourism fund, to the housing fund. That transfers count as revenue for those funds. So you kind of count that pass through twice, but that's basically how it works. Now let's talk about the funds. The town has a number of funds. And from a personal standpoint, those are like your bank accounts. You may have a bank account for your child's education, a bank account for groceries,

7:37 So our funds, and we have many of them, are like bank accounts. You will notice on this chart that the largest fund of the town is the general fund. It accounts for 34% of our budget. There are also some other larger funding sources or larger funds, including public safety, where we account for police expenses.

8:06 Including public works, where we account for public works expenses, capital projects, and so on. Now, the funds, the bank accounts that I discussed, again, there are many of them, and we use a very discreet system of funds and bank accounts. However, in the audit, the audit uses more general fund groups, and there are only five of them. There are general funds,

8:36 For example, in the town we have a general fund, then we have a tourism fund, we have a housing fund, and then we have a transit fund. Well, from the audit standpoint, all of those end up in a general fund group because they're general in nature. We have special revenue funds, a lot of them have to do with grants, the gas tax is a special revenue fund. We have capital projects funds, those are self-explanatory, enterprise funds and trust and agency funds.

9:04 Now, the last four categories are generally either restricted or committed. And the general fund is really the only unrestricted funding source that we have. And again, that's 34% of our budget. Now, let's look at the general fund itself. And just to give you a sense, we have a total budget, which is something that I failed to include. It just occurred to me. The town's total budget, including all those transfers in and out, is about $50 million, maybe $54 million.

9:35 And the general fund portion of that is about 17 million, so about a third, so that just gives you a sense in dollar, from a dollar standpoint where we stand in the numbers. Now in the general fund that has about 17 million, that fund collects unrestricted revenues.

9:55 And it expenses those revenues on general government purposes. For example, on the left side, you will see that the majority of revenues that come into the general fund come from the transit occupancy taxes, from the tourists. Another large revenue, relatively large, at 19% is a property tax, and another relatively large slice is a sales tax. So those three revenues...

10:22 Account for the majority of funding in the general plan. Now, how do we spend those revenues, those 17 million? Let's look on the right side. We pay about 27% of that into public safety, i.e. police. We pay about 21% of that into public works. We pay about 20% of that into administration. It's not town manager. It includes town manager, it includes town council, it includes legal.

10:52 It includes finance, it includes personnel, it includes premiums that would pay to the insurance authority and things of that nature. So there are a lot of things including administration that is really not administration. Tourism and marketing is another relatively large slice and so on. Now let's talk about fund balances. And this is an interesting concept and again let me see if I could have a parallel concept from an individual person's standpoint.

11:24 If you balance your checkbook at the end of the month and the revenues that you received, your paycheck, were higher than how you spend that paycheck, you would take the balance and you would put it in the savings account. Well, that savings account is the fund balance. So each of the bank accounts that you have has a fund balance. Well, in some cases, there are negative fund balances, which shouldn't exist, but it does. And it's not a criticism to staff, it's just how it works.

11:52 For example, if we expense funds from a gas tax, but the revenue doesn't come in until later, you'll see that negative because the funds were expense and then the revenue comes in later. So, but in general, in each of the funds, we have fund balances. Now, there are different categories of fund balances that government accounting rules make us set in place.

12:18 There's a non-spendable fund balance, which is basically not cash. For example, all of our roads, all of our vehicles and so on are considered assets and are accounted for in the fund balance, but they're not liquid, they're not cash, we can't go out and spend them. There's also restricted fund balance, usually restricted by state and federal law, sometimes by ballot initiatives such as Measure R, Measure U.

12:43 There's committed fund balance, usually cash constrained to specific purposes through town council action, for example, money that we spend on tourism, housing, transit, or committed money. There's assigned fund balance, which is even less restricted than committed, and there's unassigned. We virtually have no unassigned fund balance in the town.

13:10 And in general, the first category, non-spendable, is not cash. Everything else generally represents cash. And the general fund is really where you have fund balance that we have control over because everything else is either restricted or committed. The town has discretion over fund balances in the general fund group. As of June 30, 2011, according to our audit, we had $13 million.

13:41 In the fund balance, in the general fund, well, someone would say, great, well, most of it is not cash. I'll show in the next slide that over 10 million of that is not cash. What is it? Well, let's take a look. This is a little hard to see, but this chart appears on page 6 of the agenda bill. So the breakdown of the 13 million, and we had exactly the same breakdown for this council a year ago, the breakdown of 13 million is

14:17 Ten plus million of that are loans that we're expecting back. Well, frankly, a lot of these loans will never be paid back. For example, there's a loan from the airport for operations, basically, for the legal expenses that the airport paid for related to MLLA. Well, the airport doesn't have the money to pay us back. They're not writing a surplus. So that loan is not likely to be paid back.

14:43 There are loans to the DIF funds, development impact fees. That's 3.6 million. And there's some other loans. So a lot of these loans will never become cash. So that 10 million is just not real money and probably won't be real money for quite some time.

15:00 There's also a committed portion of the corn balance that amounts to 2.9 million. Now the largest portion of that and really what we have control over is the reserve for economic uncertainty, 1.4 million. The town council has a target of 25% for the reserve, which is very typical. It's really the minimum that we need to maintain.

15:25 In case we're having bad snow here, in case we have a big lawsuit. Now, that 1.4 represents only 7%, so we're grossly underfunded when it comes to the reserves. The additional amounts, for example, Fund 465, Workforce Housing has some money. Well, a lot of that money has been used in the current year. There were some council actions, I think, during the last meeting where that money was used, and I think...

15:52 It's going to be pretty much utilized during the current council meeting as well. An additional $1 million is money that we have to set aside in order to pay employees for their compensated leave time. So it's the vacation time and the sick time that employees accumulate according to the union contracts. And an employee can walk into finance office and ask for that.

16:21 Time to either be used or to be cashed out and we need to have the money. Now already as we speak that fund is only funded at an 85% level. So if tomorrow all of our employees came to us and said we want our leave, we will only be able to fund them at 85 cents on the dollar.

16:39 There's also an unassigned portion of the fund balance. The largest of that is transportation and transit, and that fund balance is going to be fully utilized in the current fiscal year. Because recall, these amounts are as of June 2011. So by June 2012, that transportation and transit money is going to be utilized for the items that the Council approved, including the scrum structure, including airport expenses and so on.

17:06 I'll keep going and then I'm sure we'll open it up to questions a bit. Now, why there is fiscal issues in general? Well, in general, and this is very, very typical of California cities and actually cities nationwide, the pace of our revenues is just not keeping up with the pace of our expenditures. That's what's happening. And I'll show you a chart in a few moments. Mainly the issue is within the general fund, except...

17:33 To the extent that we get less money from other sources, the general fund oftentimes has to fill in the gap. For example, next fiscal year we're going to lose a grant that pays for a police officer. Well, the general fund will likely pick up the cost of that police officer.

17:51 Next year we're going to get less gas tax revenue because gas tax revenue overall is based on how much snow we had in the prior year because we had so little snow this year, next year we'll get less money from the state and that gap is going to be filled by the general fund. Our div funds, development impact funds, have over 6 million owed to other funding sources, mainly the general fund, so they're carrying negatives that the general fund currently covers.

18:19 And the general fund gap is widening because again the revenues are just not picking up with the expenditures. Let's look at this chart. The bluish bars are the expenditures and the red bars are revenues. Now let's look at the revenues. They went up a little bit from 05, 06, sorry from 08, 09 to 09, 10 to 10, 11 then dropped significantly.

18:44 In 11-12 and 12-13 mainly because of low TOT in the current fiscal year. Well, the expenditures also dropped in 11-12 because we made significant reductions to the budget in the beginning of this fiscal year. We cut 2.7 million dollars from the budget.

19:03 But the expenses continue to go up. And I'll explain why in a few moments. So you see this gap, for example, in 11-12 and 12-13, where the bar that represents expenses is higher than the bar that represents revenues. Well, how has the town addressed fiscal issues? Well, substantial cuts have been made. And for those of you who visit town offices, who walk around, I'm sure you see the results of those cuts.

19:29 Town staffing, as an example, has gone down from over 130 employees to lower than 80 at this point. And it's really hard to get a job done these days with 80 employees. And the level of services really has not gone down by much. Most recently, about a year ago, in June of 2011, the town cut $2.7 million to the budget. And we've had some really difficult discussions.

19:54 So the result is an organization that is bare bones. Employees are overworked, work oftentimes doesn't get done, and we have unfunded expenses. For example, it takes about 1.5 million dollars annually to maintain the current condition of our streets and roads. 1.5 million annually to maintain the current condition of our roads. We spend 500,000.

20:21 So with that level of funding, the roads are going to get worse and worse and worse. What does the future look like? Not good. In the current fiscal year, we project a budget gap of about $1 million. And in the next year, we project a budget gap of almost $3 million. And I will explain why. These shortfalls do not account for the judgment with MLA. They do not. So we have to find cuts and or revenue increases.

20:52 To fill these gaps and only after that we can look for money for MLLA. In the current fiscal year, fiscal year 11-12, that is about to end. We're now in April. We have April, May and June left of the current fiscal year. The main issue is lower transit occupancy tax. We have had dramatic increases due to low snow.

21:18 In December, TOT went down by 14%, January 42%, February 32%. In March and April, we're projecting a more modest 10% decline and flat revenue in May and June. Expenditures are actually coming under budget mainly because departments are managing and also because we're going to send less money to tourism, housing and transit.

21:45 Because their revenues are based on TOT and as TOT goes down they get less money. But the general fund will be paying for the one year shortfall in the transit fund because of lower TOT they get less revenue and we also accounted for some grant revenues that they also accounted for in their own budget so that puts them upside down. And because they can't change their operations quickly they can't

22:14 You know, change the routes overnight. The general fund will have to help them pay for that gap. And you will see in detailed attachments at the end of this report, not the PowerPoint, but the actual report, that the transit gap is just under 300,000 in the current fiscal year. Now, the shortfall of almost a million in the current fiscal year, exactly, the exact number is 979,000. Current estimate.

22:45 Things may still change between now and the end of the fiscal year, but the current estimate is $100 million. We don't have any choice at this point but to utilize the reserve for that shortfall. Now, our beginning RU, the beginning reserve for economic uncertainty, is $1.35 million. We're expecting a payment from FAA on a long-term note. Basically, the general fund up fronted money for terminal expansion, and we're getting that money back gradually.

23:15 So that revenue will help us, and that goes into the reserves. So at the end of the year, we're going to end with 1.6 in the general fund reserve, which again is grossly insufficient. To get to a 25% level, we should be maintaining about 4 million in our reserves, if not higher, 4.5 million. We only have 1.6. 12-13, fiscal year 12-13, that starts in July of 2012.

23:46 Well, flat revenues versus high costs. I showed this chart to you before. The revenues are staying flat. The costs are going up. Why are the costs going up? Well, I mentioned, let me talk a little bit about the revenues first. A budget gap of 2.88 million, 2.9 round, close to 3 million is projected. It is a result of flat revenues. Again, we do project a moderate recovery in COT revenues.

24:16 We think it's going to go up by 5%, which may be somewhat optimistic, but because this year is so low, we think that it's actually sustainable. There is going to be a continued decline in property taxes. Monon County tells us, based on the assessment roll for next year, there's going to be at least a 4.5% decline. There's going to be a slight increase in some other taxes, such as sales tax and franchise fees. On the personnel side of the expenditure side,

24:45 We have negotiated salary increases for town employees of 4.5%, and we also have increases in retirement and medical insurance costs. I mentioned loss of a grant in the police department and lower state gas tax revenues next year that also contribute to the shortfall because the general plan has to fill in that gap. But again, let's keep in mind that this is a baseline shortfall. This is not what we're...

25:14 What we're planning to do is just if we continue operations and continue the staffing that we currently have, this is how much money we'll need to fill that baseline gap. That baseline gap of $2.9 million does not, again, account for any payment to MLLA. It will require some difficult decisions to fill. And again, keep in mind that we already made cuts of $2.7 million less than a year ago.

25:46 Now, that leads me to the MLA process. You may recall that we now had, I think, two public discussions with regards to the mediation process. New state law, Assembly Bill 506, created a framework for mediation process before going into bankruptcy. We do not want bankruptcy. We want to avoid it as much as possible. So this mediation is really a blessing for us.

26:13 In this mediation, we're going to talk to our creditors about the $2.9 million shortfall and what are we going to do to breach that shortfall. And we're also hoping to talk to MLLA about their judgment and how we're going to afford to pay that judgment. So far, we have 16 out of 44 interested parties who have agreed to participate. We hope to start mediation by the end of April.

26:41 The town will pay the cost of the mediation because we initiated the mediation. And that cost of up to $150,000 is reflected in the current year shortfall. Almost all parties, almost all parties at this point have agreed to make the process public. You're not going to be, it's not going to be an open meeting. The mediation is not going to be an open meeting, but to the extent that information is shared.

27:10 During the mediation, we will post it online and make it public so you all know what's discussed in mediation. Now, almost all parties have agreed to that. We don't have full agreement yet. No direct discussions have taken place with MLA since December of 2011. However, their attorneys have been talking to our attorneys. MLA, we asked MLA to come and mediate on several occasions. Twice now they refused. And we are hopeful.

27:39 That they will come to the table. We want to mediate. We want to avoid bankruptcy. Proposed scheduled public meetings is the last stage of the printed agenda bill. And so what staff is proposing at this point is we will have budget meetings and budget discussions through the months of May and June. The mediation that I just mentioned is also going to happen in the months of May and June.

28:09 We're hoping that at some point they will join, that information that we discuss in mediation about the budget cuts and concessions will become available to the public. How soon, we don't know. We hope it's going to happen early, that it's going to happen in May. But at the very least, there are going to be parallel processes. Nevertheless, in May and June, we will be discussing with you in more detail

28:34 The composition of our budget, where the cuts could or could not take place, your ideas of how the budget should be balanced, your ideas of how we should pay MLLA and so on. The week of May 7th, we plan to have a special meeting of the council for a few hours, so you can come, you can ask your questions. Our legal firm of Fulbright and Jaworski is going to be here to respond to your questions.

28:59 Our financial advisor, FTI, is also going to be here. So it's going to be a very important meeting for you to attend. We don't have a date or time yet, but as soon as we do, we'll let you know. I have a change to the May 16th, June 6th, and June 20th. On June 6th, we listed measures R&U as subject to budget discussion. Measure U tentatively has been scheduled for May 16th.

29:28 And Measure R has been tentatively scheduled for June 20th. So those are the two minor changes. If necessary, we will have additional public meetings that are special in nature in the months of June, but for now, this is the schedule that we have. So with that, we see Council, well, this is not actually an action item, but we wanted to discuss with the Council and get their thoughts on the...

29:57 First and foremost on the use of the reserves to balance the current year shortfall. There's really no other way to do that, unfortunately, this year, given how, given that there's no mediation, we can't...

30:13 Negotiate any of the cuts with the creditors between now and the end of June. We also wanted to get Council's input on the schedule that I just discussed. So let me stop by presenting for too long and see if there are any questions or however else the Mayor would like to handle this. All right. Are there questions from Council? If it's okay with the rest of Council, I'd like to see if there's any input from the community before we discuss these two bullet points. In that case, if there's anyone who would like to...

30:41 Comment, ask a question, whatever, please come up to the podium and do so. Is it no one wants to comment or no one wants to be first? All right, we'll presume then that there is none and presume we should discuss with this page handwritten 14 and handwritten 15. So the first one would be using the RU to address the shortfall. Do we have any comments?

31:26 Well, I guess it starts somewhere. The money has to come from someplace. And unfortunately, that's what it's intended for. So unless we have some ideas or thoughts of where else it can come from, I think that that's what we need to start looking at. I'd just like to reinforce what Matthew was saying, and that is that the REU for the town has always been set up.

31:57 For years like we just had. Obviously, TOT or the bed tax is our largest revenue generation for our budget. And I don't know what the numbers were. The mountain was down 35% this year on ticket sales and the lack of snow and so forth. So to balance this year's budget, which we're through 10 to 11 months of this year, the use of the REU.

32:26 That's what it's intended for and it's totally appropriate and so I would support that. Skip. You said that so well, John, that I think that that's a consensus is to support it. That's exactly what the REU was for. Are there any comments on the proposed meetings schedule? I think the meeting schedule is appropriate. I wanted to point out that

32:56 The special meeting that is scheduled for the week of May 7th, I believe May 7th is a Monday, so I'm hopeful that that meeting can be scheduled either on Monday or Tuesday of that week, either May 7th or May 8th, and that as soon as the town staff and the town council can agree and our legal council can agree upon whether it will be Monday or Tuesday, that we can get that information out.

33:26 to the public as soon as possible so that they can make plans themselves if they want to attend that meeting, whether it's on the 7th or 8th of May. Okay, any other comments? I'm comfortable with it. That's good. Yes. And then I would just kind of add a little bit that those additional meetings would be scheduled. Because we have such a big budget promise, I'm just kind of reminding Council that we may be meeting every Wednesday in June just to get through all of this.

33:56 Okay. Is there anything else that staff needed from us on this particular agenda item? Okay. Then we will move on to public comment on items that are not on tonight's agenda. If there is any, please come forward to the podium. Council, staff, community. I'm Ron Cohen. I'm here on behalf of Rusty Gregory to invite you, council members.

34:36 Staff members, members of the public to a meet and greet fundraiser for Ryan McCachron. He is the mayor of Victorville and he is running for the newly created 8th Congressional District seat which is the seat that will cover our region. We've been, as you know, very ably represented by Congressman Buck McKeon for years in this region.

35:05 And with redistricting, our area is now being tacked into a district that runs all the way into the Inland Empire. And that's going to have a new representative. Congressman McKeon won't be representing us anymore after next January. So with a slew of candidates, I think there are 10 or 12 running in this newly created 8th Congressional District.

35:33 Congressman McKeon has endorsed Ryan McCachron, and we've been able to get him to come here. Rusty is sponsoring an event co-hosted by Jim Demetriatus. It's at the Hyde Lounge at 5 o'clock on Friday, and if anybody wants to come, please call me, Ron Cohen, 760-934-2571. Ask for me, and I'll let you know the arrangements. We'd like to see you there.

36:02 Thank you. We're on real quick while we have you here and since you mentioned Buck McKeon's name. Buck McKeon did represent our area for a number of years. I don't know what it was. Ten years, eight years. But I think it's important, even though he will no longer represent us, Buck McKeon was responsible for representing our area and was directly responsible in getting money.

36:32 Both for our transportation facility, which is down in the industrial park. This was federal grant money. I don't know the numbers, but I think it was around $800,000 towards the purchase of that building. He was also directly responsible for getting a number of our transit buses for the community. Again, I believe in the range of around $800,000. So this gentleman that Rusty's going to hold the open house for, I think it's important.

37:00 For those in the community that can attend and can show support to get him elected so that we have a continuation of representation that financially benefits our community on things that we want here. Yeah, that's exactly right. Congressman McKeon was great at balancing interests. He did a lot of things for the community.

37:26 He has introduced a bill at the ski area to help us achieve a land exchange. He supported the Omnibus Public Lands Management Act in 2009, which put a bunch of areas into wilderness and at the same time created a first-of-its-kind dedicated area for snowmobiling. He's been a very good advocate for our region.

37:50 And this is his, he's endorsed Mayor McCathrin for, to take this, in this election. And so this is a great opportunity for us, and it may be one of the few, to meet him, talk to him, find out where he stands on the issues, and impress upon him what's important to us. You know, we're 13,000 people or so in Mono County.

38:16 He's going to represent 750,000, 800,000 people. So it's easy for us to get lost in the mix. This is a good opportunity to talk to him and find out where he stands and give him that idea of what's really important to us. So I encourage you to get in touch with me. Again, 934-2571. I'll give you the details on the event. It is a fundraiser, so we're looking to have donations.

38:43 But, you know, it would be great to hear from you and see you there. Ron, I'm sorry. One final thing on Buck McKeon, because it's important. Buck McKeon is a Republican, and yet he worked with two Democrats from the state of California, Dianne Feinstein and Barbara Boxer. The three of them work legislatively at a federal level to pass our most recent

39:12 Thank you. Thank you.

39:43 You know, it's easy to be partisan one side or the other, but it's not easy to work cooperatively these three individuals as they did for Monal County. Yeah, and the result of that was great balance in that not only did the Owens River Headwater Wilderness come into existence because of that bill, but as I mentioned, there's a snowmobiling area.

40:07 It's in our past that came into existence because of that bill. And that's the kind of balance that gets created when you have that bipartisan effort. And that's what Buck McKeon was good at for our area. He's going to run for re-election if he wins. He's going to maintain his status as one of the key members of Congress. He's the chairman of the Armed Services Committee, which is incredibly powerful.

40:33 And we're going to be represented, whoever wins, by a freshman. And so the ability to have somebody who we've met and who has the endorsement of Congressman McKeon, if he's the one who actually does end up winning, that's all we're going to manure to our benefit. Good. Thank you. Thank you. All right. Anyone else for public comment? Good evening, Councilmembers. My name is Nate Greenberg. I've been the GIS coordinator for the town in Mono County for the last five or so years.

41:12 As you may have heard, I was recently appointed to Digital 395 Project Manager for the county and wanted to just come before you today and make you aware that I'm available to help answer questions that may come up out of you guys. And just to give you a very brief little status update, our interest really is trying to work with the town council as a whole and the communities at large to get information out to people and make sure everybody has the right information.

41:41 And most of the activity that's been going on as of late has been going on within the last mile provider realm. That's sort of the service connection to homes and the anchor institutions that are established throughout the county and the whole east side really. And most of that affects immediately the unserved and the underserved communities. Unfortunately, Mammoth is not, or fortunately, I guess Mammoth is not either of those. But there are a number of deadlines and grants that are coming up.

42:09 That are out of those two categories. You'll probably be hearing a lot about over the next several months. But in general, the 395 project is moving forward. We've had meetings with Praxis over the last couple weeks. They are working through some federal as well as state issues at the FONSI or finding of no significant impact as well as some cultural evaluation.

42:35 And some issues with the California Department of Fish and Game with respect to the Desert Tortoise and Mojave Ground Squirrel. But things are moving. They are being hopeful. And it sounds like they're hoping to try to break ground as late as this end of this month in Nevada. And then hopefully later in May in Bishop Mammoth area and the south in Ridgecrest.

42:59 So their goal still is to target the end of the year for having light in the fiber that's going to be in the backbone. And that will be basically giving them about six to seven months left in their grant to do testing, to finish any of the other trunks or spurs that are going to be going out to the communities and things like that. So it sounds like there's a few little issues that are being worked through, but in general things are moving along. And I just wanted to let you know that I'm here.

43:28 Happy to answer questions. If I can't answer them, I'll take them away and report back. Nate, does that mean that they're going to actually work on several locations all at the same time? Yeah. So it sounds like there's at least three different major crews, and then within that there's several kind of smaller crews, but they will be working from the north and south simultaneously, and then this crew in the center, their intention is to focus on the areas that could become affected by snow if we have an early snowfall year.

43:57 So I think they'll be doing a lot of work in Monal County. Some of it is going to be pending permits and pending just any holdups that happen within those sections. But as much as they can, they're going to try to work continuous. And from the sounds of things, basically, the way the technology is set up, they need to work relatively continuously. Yeah, so theoretically, by the end of the year, we should have light? Is that what you're saying?

44:25 Yeah, their goal is to have fiber in the ground and have it lit by the end of December. And basically that theoretically means there could be service, but realistically it's probably not going to be until the fall and summer that sites start to come online. But I think for certainly the key backbone components, that's their goal. There may be some key anchor institutions within easy access areas, the town may be one of those, that start to see service before that.

44:55 And so I guess the next question is then, so 395 is going to only come up to about 203, is that right? It will come into town. It is. In my understanding, I don't know the exact fire route in town, but it is certainly coming up to the district at a minimum. Okay. And I'm not exactly sure what the expectation is in town. Okay. That was a question that came up last week to me, and it was how are we getting it from?

45:24 You know, it's a destination to our homes, and what's the timing on that? Well, I mean, just to clarify, you know, the project that's going on is, it's a middle mile and a limited last mile project, and basically what that means is the key backbone itself is providing capacity or capabilities of broadband on Eastern Sierra. It doesn't necessarily hook up every home. They obviously don't have the funding, and the use of the money can't be used for commercial purposes.

45:52 So there is some last mile development, and that's basically going to key anchor institutions like the town or the county, special districts, Mammoth County Office of Education, various different facilities like that, which will use the broadband capacity internally. But we'll also obviously at that point have capacity for last mile existing service providers, Verizon, AT&T, Suddenlink, whoever those providers are, to be able to buy service or capacity from the broadband cooperative at that point and expand.

46:22 Their service areas or their capacity. And in the grant period that's going on over the next six to nine months through the CASF, there's money for the underserved and unserved kind of populations to maybe tap in and implement some technology or some infrastructure to get some of the fiber to houses. But for a served community like us, it would be up to the service providers really to fund that.

46:52 Implement that technology. That's a big responsibility, Nate. Thank you for representing our area. Do it again. Yeah, thank you. Thanks. Anyone else for public comment? Good evening. My name is Doug Thompson, the president of judgmental RC&E, and we applied for the grant to do the demand aggregate study.

47:28 Requested by Indio, Boulder, and Kern County in 2009, we finished the draft proposal, the draft project, and we submitted that to the California Public Utility Commission in December of 2011. During that process, we were funded to do what they call the consortium for the state of California. So we're the Eastern Sierra Connect consortium.

47:54 So we're one step away from Digital 395. We're the actual last mile. Nate Greenberg is on our board. Ron is on our board. The way we set up the board, we have three people from each county. We have three from Mignol County, three from Mono County, and three from Kern County. The main kickoff was March 9th. We're under the CPUC, California Advanced Service Fund. These funds, the money that Nate talked about,

48:25 $225 million. There's a revolving loan fund of $15 million and then a fund of $10 million that funded the consortium to operate for three years to bring the middle ground to the actual house. In April 26th, we have a kickoff meeting with the CPUC, the CASF staff in Palmdale. Nate will be there to make reports back.

48:54 What we're trying to do is get all the providers, everybody in the room at the same time. We've requested that Praxis or, you know, digital 395 be there so we can get as much information out to everybody as we possibly can at one time. So a lot of the information we have from the survey for the demand diagram study shows that we have a lot of areas that are remote, rural, and...

49:20 It's going to be hard for the providers to actually make a profit, so that's the emphasis we have. We have areas that are 30, 40, 50 miles off of the 395 corridor. Some of the techniques or technologies that are out there, we've talked to a company called Carlson. Well, Carlson, there's extra bandwidth in the television band. That might be an option. There's other radio options that might be available.

49:47 We're not quite sure how the anchor institution is going to work, but they might have local hotspots. So a lot of this is going to develop in the next six to nine months. It's been quite a learning process. It went from, you know, where we never thought we'd have, well, I come from Low Plain, actually. We have a store 13 miles off of 395. It's a Whitney Portal store. We were told probably in the mid-90s that...

50:17 Never expect cell phone coverage. Well, we've actually come a little further than that. We can actually get internet up in the mountains now, and that's the program that we continue to move with. We know we're not going to get the attention from the main providers because it's just not profitable, but there's obviously some way that we can work with the providers and work with ourselves and make it happen. AT&T, Verizon, some of the major providers have actually did it.

50:47 A great service. And I think they continue to do a great service. Two months ago, I drove our area covers maybe like almost 400 miles. I drove the whole 400 miles and went to many remote locations that I could to see if I could get a hot spot. And it was amazing. Some of the very remote areas I could. As long as we're 10 or 15 miles from, the main 395 corridor, I think, we're in good shape.

51:16 But it's those next areas, the 30 to 50, the middle of Death Valley, Chaffa Valley, these remote Walker Canyon, you know, you get in those areas, those are where we're going to have trouble. But there's methods, I think, we can make it work, and that's what we're going to do in the next three years. Do you have any questions? Questions? No, I don't. Thank you, Doug. Thanks, thanks. Okay, is there anyone else? I saw someone start to get up. Hello, Council.

51:51 My name is Clay Bogan. Oh, Clay, I think you want to wait until we get to the actual agenda item to speak. I was actually just kind of want to take the stand for kind of a test run and respond to your announcements from last week. Since it's an agenda item, we'll have to consider it when we get to that item. I was actually, it wasn't. Oh, okay. A different item? Okay. Yeah, I wasn't planning on touching it at all. Oh, all right. Sorry. But, yeah, just haven't actually participated in public expression, so I kind of wanted to.

52:21 Feel it out a bit. So to start out, I just want to say thanks, Mr. Eastman, for the update on public transportation. I can attest that as a part of that increased ridership, as owner of a four-wheel drive explorer, gas price is near $5 a gallon. I really only use it for trips out of town and for fishing trips. And so when it's not snowing, I usually take the bus or walk around town. And I agree, Mammoth has one of the...

52:50 Most successful public transportation systems, second to none in ski towns across North America. A thousand riders a day is really impressive and possibly 400,000 a year riders annually. And you know that's only going to increase if gas prices continuing to rise. Just imagine if each rider paid 10 cents just to board the bus. That could generate $40,000 annually. Just an idea.

53:19 Thank you, Mr. Lehman, for bringing up the Ski Magazine article, Mammoth, California's Biggest Secret. I actually, when I first came on in March, I was stopped after a few pages because it went on raving about the mountain, which is really basically preaching to the choir because I've been coming up here basically all my life to know how great our mountain is. But I came back to it after you mentioned, and I learned a lot about the challenges that face our town.

53:49 From a third-person, out-of-town viewpoint. Writer Christopher Solomon describes several obstacles facing Mammoth in the shadow of this lawsuit. He starts out pretty uplifting with an interview with Mountain Host Phil Averly. Phil broadcasts some of the major sentiments of locals here, saying it's got some kind of rough and raw edge to it. And his mentality is, the focus is on big, beautiful country.

54:19 I think that parallel is another highlight within the article that our town is viewed by many as a trailhead in the wilderness. And I believe Phil speaks for a large part of our community and obviously preserving our local backcountry is a top priority while continuing sustainable development. Some other optimistic notables early in the article, Solomon mentions a storm that dumped seven feet in the previous five days.

54:46 Emphasized Mammoth's deep dumps and Velveteen Wind Buff and highlights Cornish Bowl, popular run such as Avalanche Chutes and the Immature Five. He also acknowledges several Mammoth Mountain accomplishments such as 100 acres of world-class terrain parks. Solomon also notes that the prestige of the mountain is the elephant in the room here. Basically, it's the foundation of our community.

55:15 The article continues listing three challenges on the plate for Mammoth right now. How will the town develop within the next few years, which I think is on everybody's minds right now. Is Mammoth a veil caliber mountain on brink of national discovery? And how to put Mammoth on the map for destination SKUs. Then Solomon goes into detail on Mammoth's shortcomings, many of which are echoed from visitors I've met in town or in random chairlift conversations.

55:45 A lot of them say there's a lack of a town center and organic connection between the mountain and the town. And I quote, it's the most popular ski area you've likely never visited. There's no there, there, no sense of welcome and fairly charmless. The O.C. with snowbanks and few sidewalks come winter. Solomon alludes to the spirit of Mammoth.

56:11 And the town of Mammoth as what may be the saving grace in this battle, stating that strong-willed individuals tend to move here, and we think it is the best part of our state with California's progressive attitude. Rusty Greger even mentions how Dave McCoy didn't like real estate and thought it was a dirty business, and that can definitely be noticed by numerous abandoned properties around town, regardless of whether it has to do with Dave McCoy or not.

56:41 The town, I think, must prepare to accommodate air service and welcome new guests to an endearing mammoth, a town that represents the paradise that surrounds it. And in my opinion, this economic stimulus development team has a partial blueprint for infrastructure improvements right there within that article. It sounds like destination skews. Clay, I'm sorry to interrupt you, but that was your five minutes. Oh, Jesus.

57:08 Okay. You can come visit us again if you want. Absolutely. Thank you. I'll speak to you next time. Okay. Thanks, Clay. Okay. Any other public comments? Seeing none, we'll move on to Councilmember Reports. Skip? I just have one to report on. I attended last Tuesday, April 10th, along with Mayor Bacon.

57:39 Mammoth Unified School District and Town of Mammoth Lakes Liaison Committee, and it is an ad hoc meeting, to make a point of that. I think probably one of the most encouraging things I heard out of that is that our multi-use facility was very successful this season, and the partnership is going extremely well. I think that is really a feather in everybody's cap that's part of that.

58:03 Venture and that there are a group of people, our Parks and Recreation Department along with the school district and the library district are working hard to find programming for that multi-use facility for this summer so we should see some good things going on out there. So I think that is really great. That's all that I have. Okay. Rick? No report. Okay. John? I have nothing, Madam Mayor. Matthew? I don't have anything.

58:31 Nor do I. Do we have any additions to the agenda? Okay. Madam Mayor? Yes. On consent agenda item number eight, can we pull that? Okay. I wasn't there yet, but yes. Okay. Okay. All right. Yes. Do we have any commission updates? Okay. Any department reports or emerging issues?

59:08 Good evening, Council. Just a quick report for the benefit of the counseling community. Caltrans has initiated work on the High Point Curve on State Route 395. Most of us, you may not know, but we've probably driven through that curve. We've driven from here to Carson City or Minden. It's adjacent to Topaz Lake, and it's where they have the radar speed feedback and the flashing signs.

59:37 A historically dangerous curve. So what they're going to do is they're going to work on removing that curve. And beginning May 2nd, they will have closures. One lane, two-way traffic, one lane between 7 a.m. and 7 p.m. controlled traffic. And then between 7 p.m. and 7 a.m. it will be closed.

1:00:00 Just wanted to give everybody a heads up on that. If you're going to be traveling up that way during that time frame, that's really when they're going to get started. But work will be ongoing through the summer and into the fall. So just wanted to let everybody know that if you're heading that way, check Caltrans website or call District 9 and get current information. So I just wanted to let you know.

1:00:24 Thank you, Ray. Ray, will there be any, do you know whether the Caltrans will post a sign at the south end of Bridgeport? That I'm not, I think, yes, I think they will, because they talk about a posted detour between Holbrook Junction and Bridgeport, so you'll see a detour sign in Bridgeport. Thanks. Evening, Mayor Bacon, Council, Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager.

1:00:56 Community. Did want to update the council in the community on action taken from the Recreation Commission meeting. So the monthly meetings are now scheduled to begin at 2pm and end no later than 5pm. Still scheduled in the first full week, which is the first Tuesday of every month. So that was the change from that meeting. Secondly, Measure U was mentioned tonight. The Measure U Steering Application Committee met yesterday to review

1:01:24 The nine applications for their primary filter requirements. Eight of those met those requirements and moving through the next phase, which are the applicant presentations scheduled on Monday, April 30 at 9 o'clock in Suite Z. Funding recommendations will be made by the steering slash application committee on May 7th and then they're scheduled to be reviewed and potentially adopted, appropriated in front of Town Council on May 16th, as mentioned before as well.

1:01:54 The Measure Hour Spring Award is still open, and that closes on May 2. And as mentioned before, that will be in front of Town Council June 20. Thank you, Stuart. Good evening, Mayor and members of the Council. Mark Woodlock, Community Development Director. The Planning Commission, along with the Recreation Commission, has held a series of meetings talking about improving effectiveness and efficiency. And the Commission has, through a committee,

1:02:28 Accepted recommendations to change the report format, adopt meeting management principles, and revise their agenda to reduce the amount of time spent in meetings and to make the deliberations of the commission and the public review of staff reports more simple. So we continue our efforts there and soon we'll be installing Granicus webcasting of all of our meetings.

1:02:56 Soon also you'll note that the Recreation Commission will be sitting in the front counter area of the town offices right next to community development. So shortly we'll be closing the door and locking it where Recreation used to sit and they'll be joined with us in the front counter, all leading to a one-stop shop. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Any other departmental reports?

1:03:24 Okay, next up is a public presentation and update regarding status of Internet services. Councilor, Mayor, this was an action that we put on the agenda as a result of Councilman Lehman's request to have presented the project. Thank you. Take the point. Good evening, Councilmember in the community. I really appreciate the invitation to be here. Manit is really important to us as a company.

1:04:05 I wanted to make sure that I got here right away as soon as I found out that you wanted to represent me, so thanks for the invitation. Let me interrupt you just for a second. Could you tell us your name, please? Jason Wilfers, the Southern Communications System Manager, and I oversee our California systems. I guess, first off, we're a bit frustrated with the fact that we're having

1:04:35 Some capacity issues. Obviously the previous speakers will be our resolution, digital 395. We hope we'll get this, get our services on track. But again, there's nothing good about the lack of bandwidth to suddenly for our customers. We want to be able to provide the enhanced services that everybody wants, that everyone has in other cities.

1:05:04 And again, there's absolutely no financial benefit for our company to be bandwidth restrained. This is an issue that we inherited, and it's not our normal mode of operation. Sunlink has a proven track record through finding solutions in bandwidth restrained communities. And that's exactly why we partnered with Digital 395.

1:05:36 They're our best long-term solution. A local example of our track record is in Truckee, California. We had similar issues, very similar issues, limited bandwidth, slower internet speeds, and it was resolved quickly as soon as we were able to acquire the bandwidth. We launched over 70 HD channels.

1:06:07 We added video on demand with thousands of hours of content. We launched new music channels. We launched multi-room TiVo. We increased our internet speeds to 20 meg. And now we're looking at increasing our internet speeds to 50 meg. Our plans are exactly the same in Mammoth as they are and weren't tricky. We just need to get that capacity so that we're able to provide these services.

1:06:37 But again, Digital 395 is our quickest and best solution in this. You know, it's so important that the federal government got behind it. They saw the need. That's why we stay in constant communication with Digital 395. We're part of their program in providing that last mile to our customers. We can't wait to connect to the bandwidth and to that capacity because...

1:07:04 We have big plans for the community. So in general, I mean, I think as far as community goes, I know that there's been some slowdowns in the projects of Digital 395 due to permitting environmental issues, et cetera. I mean, I think we need to focus on what we can do to help support Digital 395 to get their project up and completed because

1:07:32 Once that's done and we're connected, that's going to eliminate our congestion and allow all these additional services. Any questions? I have a couple. I appreciate you coming and speaking to this matter. It's been a pretty hot topic. I brought up a question a while ago. I wasn't sure if it was just my office or what it was. After I brought it up, the phone calls started coming in.

1:08:04 The problem I have, and I'm hearing there's not a solution until Digital 395 gets here, but I'm a little concerned about the impacts of what's going to happen between now and then. I've talked to, just to give you an example, in my office, we were paying for, I think, three or four megs of bandwidth, and then we had Verizon come out and measure it, and we were getting one.

1:08:31 And the solution was, well, buy more. Well, you know, the result is you can only get so much in if there's only so much bandwidth out there. And, you know, to me that was a frustrating answer. And I suddenly get home. I'm paying for service I don't even get now. I mean, I get it maybe 10% of the time. And, you know, to me that's frustrating just on a personal level. And then when I start hearing,

1:08:56 From some of the other people, you know, we have visitors coming up here, and that's what drives our economy. A lot of them come up on working vacations. And when they come up here on a working vacation, and then they can't get Internet service, they just defeated the purpose of the vacation. Well, the answer is to go to Colorado or Utah next time. So, you know, we've got a problem that's growing, and I don't know if there's something we can do between now and then. Can we give some priority to...

1:09:23 Maybe this is a solution, but can we get priority, let's say, to business during the day and residence at night? Or can we cut the streaming video or something along those lines that are hogging up that capacity for, you know, watching a video during the day when we have businesses that are trying to operate? So I don't know if there's some solutions here, but it just seems odd to me that we have to wait for digital 305, and the only answer is buy more bandwidth, and I'm really not getting any better service.

1:09:51 For a commercial business, I was getting charged $165 for Internet service I wasn't getting. One of our citizens brought something up. If there's no bandwidth, how come we can sell large blocks of bandwidth for $80,000, $90,000 to a commercial entity? If that's available, how come that can't be trickled down to the residential or the business communities, the smaller business?

1:10:16 Are you speaking of Verizon? Well, I am, I guess. I don't know if Suddenlink has the same options or not. I'm throwing out what I know of I have Verizon in my business and I have Suddenlink at home. And I'm experiencing problems in both areas. And I'm hearing it across the board from people that it's almost pointless in some cases.

1:10:40 Quite honestly, it's affecting my business, and I think it's affecting, you know, some of the condominium owners and the managers. I'm hearing the problem from them. It's affecting their business. So, you know, wait a year and we'll get better. It's kind of a hard, it's a hard solution for me to swallow. I think there's got to be another solution in the interim. Well, I can't speak for a horizon. Yeah. It sounds like in that particular case that, I don't know, is it a writer or a representative here?

1:11:04 I don't think they came today. We asked them to come. Again, I can't speak for Verizon as to still having capacity to sell. Sunlink does not have that. We don't have the luxury if that's a possibility for them. As soon as we saw that our circuit was starting to get to the point where it wasn't effective, we stopped sales, period.

1:11:35 Commercial and residential. We want to keep our customers as happy as we can be throughout this. We know during the winter season it's absolutely the busiest, most congested time on the Internet. And what we do find, kind of getting to some of your questions, what we're finding is that typically 10% of our customers take up 90% of our bandwidth.

1:12:05 Netflix and streaming video, that definitely eats up the capacity. You know, we've never implemented any sort of system or policy to not allow streaming video. I mean, it's just overall bandwidth and people can pick and choose how they fit. But overall, these activities have been doubling.

1:12:35 Year over year, our subscriber base has remained relatively flat. But the difference is that internet usage, so overall bandwidth usage, has doubled year over year. So that's where you see the congestion. And although we try to forecast that...

1:12:59 Add on top of that all the smartphone usage as well when people are visiting from different locations and that adds to the congestion. We saw the need for a larger circuit and that's when we started sending bids out to our long haul carrier which is actually Verizon. They provide that long haul to the internet and when they didn't have any capacity any longer to sell that's when we're really excited.

1:13:27 That digital 395 was about to happen.

1:13:31 Is there any solution between now and then?

1:13:34 Well, although we're working on very exotic solutions that I really can't speak about right now because they're in the very early testing phases,

1:13:49 we are trying to find a solution in the interim until digital 395 is built.

1:13:54 However, that is error.

1:13:57 Digital 395 is the best long-term solution for us. And I'll throw a couple other things that we were pitching out the other day as well. I don't know how realistic this is. I've never heard of anyone doing this, but I'll throw it out. In communities that have drought, like in Texas,

1:14:19 They say, okay, homes with even addresses, you get to water on Mondays and Thursdays. And, I mean, I'm just trying to be creative. You know, you're looking for solutions. That's a wild idea, but, you know, I'm trying to come up with anything. Well, I'm just wondering if, Luke, the streaming seems to be such a big issue. It seems like they could program to download in the middle of the night and then watch the movie the next day. I mean, something like that just so it's not going to impact.

1:14:48 You know, the business community so much. And, you know, residents, we can live with it, I guess. But, you know, like I said, I'm paying for service. I literally get 10% of the time. And I know all the people in my building have the same problem. So, you know, I mean, my guess is you're probably going to have people start dropping off as clients. I don't know. And bottom line, what we're trying to do at this point, knowing that we have the capacity that we have.

1:15:18 Thank you. All right. Any other questions?

1:15:49 Thank you, Jason. Thank you. Thank you. We will now move on to the consent agenda. I have a request to pull item number eight. Are there any other items? Madam Mayor, I would make a motion to approve items number three, four, five, six, seven, and nine. I'll second it. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes.

1:16:17 Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Item number 8, John? I'll defer to Matthew. Yeah, actually. I had some questions on it. So I know we discussed this before, and I had a question either for Pam or somebody else. So there's two buckets of money here that we can pull from in order to accomplish this, keeping our affordable housing unit.

1:16:47 And it seems we're taking it out of Measure A monies right now, right? They're unrestricted funds. Is there a separate pool that's the in-lieu funds that we can draw from? Yes, there is a second pool of money which could be used for this purpose, which is the housing in-lieu funds. Okay, and so we're just, we're leaving that alone right now, just going strictly with the Measure A, right? Correct, that was the census of council from last...

1:17:10 Okay. Okay, great. So with that, I guess my only comment is that I disagree with it the way it's written. I would personally prefer to see it come from the in-lieu funds what we can take out of there to maintain the housing and keep that housing because it is a restricted fund. It's designated for building and maintaining affordable housing and I'd like to see the unrestricted remain unrestricted. That's my only comment.

1:17:41 Okay. John? I was just going to make a motion. Okay. Madam Mayor, I would move that the council adopt consent agenda item number eight. I'll second it. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilman Reesman? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilman Reesman? Yes. Councilman Reesman? Yes. Councilman Reesman? No. Mayor Reesman? Yes. Councilman Reesman? No. Mayor Reesman? Yes. Motion passes 4-1. We will now move on to policy matters. The first one is...

1:18:12 Urgency ordinance establishing a moratorium. Good evening. You have before you a recommendation for a moratorium on the issuance of any additional medical marijuana permits until the courts and state legislature provide additional clarification on the legality of them. I briefed the council about two months ago in February during the emerging issues and told you that we had taken a position to not process any permits.

1:18:47 And then two meetings ago, Councilmember Eastman asked that we agendize this. So that's what we've done in the agenda bill and attached it as an ordinance. As you know, the town has had an ordinance since 2010 that authorizes up to two medical marijuana cooperative permits. In the development of that, there's two levels of review. One is from the police department, which issues the operating permit. And the second level is by the planning commission.

1:19:17 The committee built in a department which issues the required use permit. The permits, when issued, are good for one year and then they're subject to renewal. Pursuant to all of that, back in 2010, two permits were issued to two operators in late 2010. And last fall, when they were up for renewal, one of the operators chose not to request a renewal, meaning that we have one medical marijuana cooperative operating in town.

1:19:44 Since that occurred, there have been inquiries about the feasibility of issuing the second permit from people that have been interested in pursuing that. The reason for my recommendation is that California's medical marijuana laws are in a real state of flux, and it's getting almost daily changes that are occurring. And we're getting mixed messages that are being received from the courts. There have been several conflicting cases.

1:20:12 That the California Supreme Court has agreed to hear probably within about a year. And the expectation is that there'll be better direction from the Supreme Court. Those cases include the PAC case, which is out of Long Beach. Long Beach has an ordinance that is somewhat similar to ours, and that it limits the number of dispensaries that can be operated in the town. That was, in a lawsuit, was ruled unconstitutional in a superior court decision.

1:20:41 And it's been appealed to the Supreme Court. The fact that there are similarities between their ordinance and ours, meaning that there's a method to limit the number of ordinances, independent of our attorneys tell us that ours, if that is upheld, that will pose potential problems for us, and we could be in jeopardy of having an ordinance that's unconstitutional. There's another fairly recent case out of Lake Forest that determined that for an ordinance to be lawful,

1:21:11 The product that is provided has to be grown on site. It can't be brought in. That certainly would impact our current operator and would make it very difficult to develop a dispensary in town if that is upheld. In addition to those cases, and others the Supreme Court will hear within the next year or so, the U.S. Attorney's Office in California have been stepping up their scrutiny of medical marijuana operations throughout the state.

1:21:40 And the reason for that is because regardless of what California has done and several other states that have legalized medical marijuana, it's still illegal by federal statute and the U.S. attorneys are pursuing some operations throughout the state. We have no reason to believe that the small town of Mammoth Lakes is on their radar screen and that they're going to be knocking on our doors in the near future.

1:22:05 Their actions throughout the rest of the state certainly will have a potential on what occurs in all communities. About a year ago it was anticipated that our then new Attorney General would issue new guidelines on the operation of medical marijuana dispensaries. There are some that are existing going back from the previous administration. She, a few months ago, notified all the district attorneys in the state that she was not going to be issuing any new guidelines. In her opinion,

1:22:34 It's a matter that's best left up to the legislature and to the courts to decide how they should be operated within the law. And finally, there are multiple efforts to put something on the ballot in November that will legalize marijuana across the board. Who knows where that's going to go? If something is passed, then that will certainly change our operation in a way that we don't even know what it would be.

1:23:01 So based on all of that, there continues to be confusion, and it's my recommendation that we not pursue issuing another permit until the matter gets, I don't want to say settled, but gives more clarity. It's important to note that there is one operating cooperative in town. Those people that have medical marijuana recommendations from a doctor do have access to it within the town of Mammoth Lakes, so we're not...

1:23:31 We don't have a situation where they don't have access to their medical marijuana. What you have before you is an interim emergency ordinance, which if approved will establish a moratorium for 45 days. If that's approved, we can come back in 45 days with an ordinance that would take it through the rest of the year, and I understand from our town attorney that that can be extended for another year, so we would have up to two years to have a moratorium in place. So that's my presentation.

1:24:02 Any questions for the Chief? I have a question. When this was originally proposed, there was supposed to be pretty good revenue coming from taxes off of this. Have you learned anything on that, just out of curiosity? Has there been a big jump in revenue off of? Not that I'm aware of, but collective finance, no, our ordinance does. We did not collect any tax on it. But it doesn't go to the state level or anything? Okay.

1:24:31 That's all. Any other comments? No. Okay, so anyone wishing to testify on this issue? Thank you, Madam Mayor. So first of all, I'd just like to say out of due respect, I appreciate the agenda bill, and I did see parts of it that were necessary, although I'm strictly opposed to it.

1:25:08 Specific reasons, but mainly because right now we currently have a monopoly operating within this industry in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Clayton, what's your last name? Bogan. Clayton Bogan. Last meeting, last town council meeting, John Urdi from the tourism board started out the meeting with the sports page from the Sunday LA Times, which brandished our high altitude training programs.

1:25:36 I actually thought it was really ironic because I wanted to show you the front page from that same paper. There's a teaser on the front here which has a picture of Meb stretching. But then the main article on the front page is The Green Rush, which has the subtitle of Higher Grade Pot, and it's all about the business of marijuana and its up-and-coming significance, and it's going to be a major role player within California in the near future.

1:26:04 I want to tell you all about three individuals who are active and the stories of these individuals within the article, but I think I'd probably run out of time. So the passing of this agenda would effectively protect a local monopoly. The moratorium may be considered as a form of government intervention, safeguarding the monopoly, which afflicts the common good.

1:26:30 Competition is a public good in the American free market system that governments should protect, and you have the opportunity to do just that here today by voting option two against the moratorium. Monopolies foster a multitude of negative trends, which would be extremely unhealthy for medical cannabis in Mammoth Lakes, meaning that qualified patients could seek better pricing within a black market.

1:26:59 Dealers would continue to profit without taxation, regulation, or abilities to improve the already set of the industry. And authorities would be unable to quantify consumption data. The monopoly, the current monopoly, can also, it's evidence that they can institute pricing and policies without losing business.

1:27:25 MLW, for instance, may charge over 200% of its marginal cost for its product and create operating hours that are less than what would be adequate for a regular business. Patients also undergo excessive transaction costs with a monopoly, such as time spent waiting in a lobby, fuel cost traveling to the facility, and retail public exposure.

1:27:53 Cost the patient his or her privacy. This is an industry that we are trying to safely unveil from the shadows of the black market, and the best way to entice companies to higher standards and comply with strict regulations is by preserving competition. I believe it is in Mammoth's best interest to issue the second permit and satisfy the voter-approved ordinance prior to the rulings from the courts.

1:28:18 Obviously, there are pending trials and voter initiatives that will soon change the nature of cannabis in California. But you... Until it goes red, you've got time. Okay. But you have to ask, what condition is best for manner? Based on the existence of MLW and Green Mammoth coexisting together in the past couple of years, as two successfully compliant cooperatives, the ordinance has served well. And lately, I've been able to talk extensively with Tony Barrett.

1:28:48 And I foresee that he may also serve as advisor of this potential second dispensary. The major case in the California Supreme Court of Appeals is the PAC v. Long Beach case, where PAC argues that Long Beach's city ordinance preempts federal law imposing fees and lotteries on dispensaries. This may be true, but when it comes down to it, federal law is virtually out the window by now regarding medical cannabis. The conventional approach should be to apply regulations and taxes that are built specifically for a community.

1:29:17 Overseen by the state. And Mammoth's ordinance is a proven winner. My argument is the exact opposite of the PAC versus Long Beach case in which I'm rather appealing for the continued support of Mammoth Lakes Town Ordinance 5.38. Okay, that is your five minutes. Oh, Madam Mayor, if I could, you know, you can continue. I have no problem. This is not public comment, so you can continue on if you would like.

1:29:48 So I understand there's going to be an opportunity for your questions, but I wanted to answer one beforehand and why I'm so adamant for this cause. This appears to be one of the most viable opportunities for a small business startup in Mammoth right now. After sitting down in a Steve class in January, I was motivated by his outlook. He said, for somebody with ambition, not a lot to lose in doing this for the right reasons. Just go for it.

1:30:16 And it made sense to him to avoid the inherent risks of losing other successful companies due to potential federal prosecution. Right now, another organization has the opportunity to take up the challenge of establishing higher standards in a turbulent legal field. And I'm confident that our organization will restore a sustainable local market in this booming industry.

1:30:41 In the past three months or so, I've coordinated the fundamental parts of a cooperative, everything from financial planning, staffing, operations, banking, cultivation expertise, security experience, website development, legal representation, product suppliers, advisors, and so on. And there are 13 individuals comprising this potential organization who will be given new opportunities in Mammoth. The nonprofit would spend $48,000 annually.

1:31:08 In local rents and contribute excess revenues to charitable donations. If given the opportunity, I would be ready to submit an application to the Police Department and Planning Commission by Friday. And at this point, I'd like to touch just on specific topics within the analysis and discussion of the agenda bill. Attorney General Kamala Harris said that state law needs to be reformed, simplified and improved to better explain how, when and where.

1:31:37 Individuals may cultivate and obtain physician-recommended marijuana and to provide law enforcement officers with guidelines for enforcement. That statement in itself does not sound like the state is repealing or stepping back from any of our previously approved legislation. Words like simplification and improvement show that our legislators want to move forward with medical cannabis because it can be a significant tax.

1:32:06 Definitely agree this industry is an ongoing process and its evolution is going to be a major player in California's economic future. Until better definitions are issued, the best option would be for Mammoth to uphold the previously approved legislation, especially where the ordinance has already proved successful. It appears that, stated in the analysis, it appears that the efforts of the U.S. attorneys are directed at large commercial operations.

1:32:35 And that the remaining cooperative in Mammoth Lakes and our ordinance are not likely to be targeted. But the issuance of a second permit could draw attention, which could result in scrutiny. First off, the U.S. government and the DEA are assisting the state in raiding and shutting down dispensaries that are using terms of nonprofit cooperation.

1:32:59 For recent communication with the author of this LA Times article, I can also tell you that

1:33:26 The decision not to de-monopolize this local industry will most likely result in negative press, opposed to scrutiny from issuing the permit. We've probably run it over quite a bit, so I'll leave it open to questions at this time. Any questions? Okay, thank you, Clay. All right. So, what is the pleasure, Council? Madam Mayor, if I may.

1:34:00 I brought this forward tonight on the agenda because first of all it was brought to my attention by Clay but also I was reminded that the decision to not allow a second dispensary in the community was not made by the voters of Mammoth Lakes. It was the voters of Mammoth Lakes who passed

1:34:31 This ordinance that we have now to allow up to two dispensaries in Mammoth. So I don't think it's appropriate for the town council or town staff or us in combination to do something that was already voted on and expressed by the voters in Mammoth Lakes, which is for the public to allow up to two dispensaries in Mammoth Lakes. We currently have one.

1:35:00 So I think it's appropriate to not have a moratorium and to allow a second dispensary to exist in the community. And it has been stated in our staff report that between the police department and the community development department, they have received at least two other inquiries as to dispensaries in Mammoth.

1:35:34 This individual's application. It could be two. If we don't have a moratorium, who knows it could be more than two. If an individual or a group of individuals or a business is willing, knowing the risks that are involved, that are expressed here, and there are considerable risks for someone to go into this business.

1:35:59 At this time, it's a state of flux within the state of California for the reasons that have been expressed earlier this evening. But if someone's willing to take that risk and still to pursue it, then that's a decision that they have made. The final reason that I support not having a moratorium and accepting additional applications for that second dispensary is that there's no competition today.

1:36:31 And I think that competition is a good thing, and by opening it up, that we will allow the competition that will be a benefit of those people who use either one or two dispensaries. You know, I'll just second what John said. I think really based on the idea that I don't think we want a monopoly. That's just not fair. That's not the way to do business.

1:37:06 We have an ordinance in place that allows two dispensaries in town, and I think we should go that direction. I believe we put the moratorium on initially because there was a period of panic of where this was going, and we did want to wait and see. Well, it's been long enough now to wait and see. I think what we're seeing is some of the less than

1:37:33 Upfront operators are probably being busted. There are people out there that are abusing the law, and I think that is who most of it is who they're going after. I don't think it's the little guy in Mammoth that they're concerned about. It's the people that are blatantly trying to use ways to get through it, that they're checking taxes and everything else that they're going for.

1:37:59 So I support the idea of having a second dispensary. I do, for the town's sake, and Matt brought it up earlier, we've got to get on the thing that there's a small tax that should be derived from that for the town of Mammoth Lakes. We're small dispensaries, the tax doesn't have to be that much, but I think town staff, for whatever reason, needs to start looking into writing that ordinance that will incorporate some kind of a small tax so that we can recoup some of the monies.

1:38:28 That we're spending doing the research and doing all and the time the police have to spend on it and all that kind of stuff. So I think that's the second step that needs to be taken by this town sooner than later. But I definitely support the idea of going ahead, issue the second permit. And as John says, there are risks. And I think it will be up to each individual to decide whether or not they want to take that risk or not.

1:38:55 I have a question. Chief, do you know if these dispensaries, are they required that the sale of cannabis remain on site and within the confines of the walls of their premises? You mean the sale occur on site? Yeah, in other words, I've heard some issue down in L.A. where they're starting to deliver it. I believe our ordinance requires it.

1:39:23 The ordinance requires a location that's selling it to have certainly certain security measures and the ability to do on-site inspections by town staff. So I think that infers, and I did not look at it in detail before the meeting, but I think it infers it has to be sold on-site and delivery service would not meet our current ordinance. I think that's correct. I do remember that now. That was the only question I had.

1:39:52 I've got to admit, I'm torn on this. If it's, you know, placing a greater burden on the police department, I have a bit of an issue with that. At the same time, I think, John, to your point, I mean, the voters voted for this. It's almost like turning over any other vote that the people, you know, unanimously voted for. So that makes the decision tougher for me. I'm with John and Skip on this.

1:40:21 I have one concern, and it's kind of what Skip was saying, and in the future it would be nice to tax it better, is that we're already looking at an almost a million dollar shortfall of the general fund. To go through this process doesn't guarantee that anyone's going to succeed in the process. We could have seven applications. I think there were five or six the last time, and only three made it to the planning commission. So I think everybody needs to understand that we're going to be spending more general fund dollars.

1:40:50 To allow the option and may or may not end up with another dispensary at the end of it. Well, it's every year, too. Yeah. It's just every year we're going to be going through the process and who's paying for that. That decreasing general fund. Yeah. Yeah. Excuse me, Madam Mayor. There's a conversation we had briefly. I think there are, and we have to look at the ordinance. There certainly could be a fee that would cover the cost to administer the program.

1:41:21 I think a tax, I think Andy would agree that we need to go to the voters. Right. A tax on it, some kind of in addition to the business tax? Right. Any new tax requires voter approval. Okay. How hard is it to put an ordinance together to get it onto a ballot? Easy. Very easy. Okay. What's the cost of a special election? Well, not a special election. No, it would be, because if we had it out in November, it would be a special election. It has to be a special election. Yeah.

1:41:50 Wait till the regular election. 2014. It is. So, like you, Matthew, I'm also torn in giving the opportunity, but also recognizing that staff and the planning commission are doing their best to be efficient. And I don't believe that the fee that we have established right now is anywhere near covering the actual cost.

1:42:20 If I remember correctly, the first time we were told that, well, we'll find out how much it was the first time and identify it later. So that I would ask that before we actually open anything is that we have a review of the cost because that might, I don't want to commit us to something that costs us $20,000 and we get a permit fee of a couple hundred. Is that a separate item later, you think?

1:42:49 Well, if we don't approve the, if we're saying to accept applications, I'm kind of suggesting that before we'd want to open an application period, I'd like a review of what it truly costs, because the reality is, is that's money that doesn't go to some other program that's currently general fund. I tend to think we should go ahead and lift the moratorium, and then we will deal with, we can deal with the fee after we've done that. Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council not approve the ordinance.

1:43:19 And direct the police department to accept applications for an additional medical marijuana cooperative permit for the benefit that it will create with additional competition. I'll second that. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:43:45 Yes. Motion passes 5-0. I would actually, I would also like to see if there's council consensus to bring back the cost of that application process to us. I would be in favor of that. Absolutely. Okay. The next item is to appoint an applicant to serve as the arts and cultural representative on the Measure U application committee for the benefit of the community.

1:44:15 Councilmembers Eastman and Lehman and myself interviewed candidates this afternoon along with Sandy Hogan, who is one of the members of the Measure U Application Committee. And before we get into deliberation, I would like to ask Sandy if she has any comments she would like to make for the benefit of the council. Thank you, Mayor and councilmembers. Sandy Hogan.

1:44:48 I'm on the application committee, and I want to thank you for the privilege of sitting in on the interviews today. I want to say also thanks to the four applicants. It's always wonderful when you have all good ones, the cream of the crop. It's always a pleasure for anybody to interview. And my observation is that all have very obvious interest, knowledge, and experience in arts and culture, and varied experience, some of it very deep, some of it

1:45:17 Local here, some of it a little bit broader elsewhere. I saw that three of the applicants have a really in-depth history of arts and culture involvement in the local community, in Mammoth, some of these over many, many years, and showing a lot of volunteerism, serving on boards, committees, and a variety of community involvement activities. They're really valuable members of our community, all of them, but some have really

1:45:46 Big history in arts and culture and otherwise. Three of them showed I felt especially a detailed knowledge of or involved with Measure U itself. Some had done extensive research and familiarity with the Measure U process, and one of them had attended almost every Measure U steering committee meeting to become involved, and actually one was actually a member of the steering committee.

1:46:16 I serve as a representative of mobility. And my commission's understanding, and mine also, was that when the original process was begun, that the steering committee would be one set of representatives, and that the application committee would be another. And so I'm not sure that that is written in stone anywhere, but that was our understanding, and that's why I was appointed.

1:46:43 And our representative, both before, I want to thank you, John Baruch, served well and long on that steering committee, and I know there was a lot of work there. So anyway, the understanding, I guess, was on our part that there would be new faces after the original committee. And for that reason, I am recommending two new faces. And I can't decide between the two of them.

1:47:09 One would be Don Zeleni, or Zeleni, I'm not sure how he pronounces his name, and the other is Ralph Ray. Both of them were terrific, absolutely terrific. I do want to thank also Diane Eagle and Joyce Turner, both for applying, and especially Joyce, because she served on that committee and did a, the work that they did was terrific, I know that, and I know that we will appreciate all the work that was done. Getting those procedures in place, they spent a lot, a lot of days and time on that.

1:47:38 So anyway, those, I can't give you, it's a tie between one and two for me. Okay? Any questions? Thank you, Sandy. Any questions to Sandy? Okay. I'll abstain from this since I was unable to attend the interviews this afternoon. I did not attend the interviews, as can be seen in my attire and lateness tonight, but I would like to participate and will not abstain.

1:48:12 I must say that I appreciate the depth and amount of material that's been provided with respect to each of these candidates and know something about each of them independent of the interview process. Madam Mayor, real quick, it seems like we say this at every interview for candidates for whatever commission it is, but this particular interview process was even...

1:48:41 Magnified greater for me personally, and that is you could choose any one of these four people that interviewed and they'd be excellent. So it's a we can't lose situation, which is very nice. The other thing is that I found striking is that normally when you interview someone that fills out an application and comes before us,

1:49:10 Do we want to start voting yet?

1:49:41 My choice to fill this position is different than Sandy, and I would choose Joyce Turner. John, it's obvious that I echo your comments and sentiments regarding the quality of the applicants. It's always amazing to me having been in the community and public service or community service in one way or the other for the last 20 years.

1:50:13 How passionate people are as they come forward. This community couldn't operate without the numbers of people who not only bring to the community talent but also a desire to do something that they really wouldn't have to do. They could stay home and sit in front of the video streaming computer.

1:50:35 And they don't. And it's a credit to all of these folks, in particular those that I know pretty well who are engaged in so many capacities. But we have to choose one. And my only comment is that I would not ever underestimate the intelligence, the passion, the commitment.

1:51:03 And the expertise of Joyce Turner, and so she's my choice. Thank you. A lot of great choices here, and I think one term that Rick just said that stood out was the breadth of intelligence of a lot of these folks. Just a very wide spectrum of...

1:51:27 Of intellect and also involvement in the community and certainly can appreciate that. I'll keep it short. The person that I thought was most qualified for this position, I agree, it was Joyce Turner. She answered a lot of questions that made it very clear to me that she has very strong involvement in the Measure U process, supporting the campaign.

1:51:56 All along, but also helping to establish some of the tools and whatnot. Also just recognizing her involvement in the community and seeing where her passions are. And I think that they go across a wide variety of different components of art. So Joyce would be my final vote.

1:52:19 It does sound like a repeat, but not only have I worked as a volunteer with all of these individuals, it was just amazing to see the passion and the desire to do something appropriately and move forward with everything that is covered under Measure U. It was a tough decision for me, but I found that Ralph Rae was the candidate that I thought would do the best for us.

1:52:49 So, Jamie, that makes the counts. Three for Joyce Turner and one for Ralph Wright. Madam Mayor, I'd make a motion that the Town Council appoint Joyce Turner to serve on the Arts and Culture Representative on the Measure U Application Committee with the term expiring on July 31, 2016. I'll second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please.

1:53:17 Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 4-0. And again, thank you. It is so wonderful to have these kinds of candidates. We will now move on to number 12, approve the youth sports funding distribution. Mayor Bacon, Council, good evening.

1:53:53 Stephanie Daniel, Recreation Supervisor here for the Parks and Rec Department. I'm here before you guys tonight to present the 2012 youth sports funding applications and the recommendations made by the Recreation Commission. So you guys got your agenda bill with a packet in it, and it's got seven applications that were reviewed, and the recommendations are also attached with that.

1:54:22 Of what the commission made, so we're just looking for your approval for this year's funding. Are there any questions? Thank you, Stephanie and Stuart, and your commission. Madam Mayor, I'll move to approve option one, that is the approval of the 2012 youth sports funding distribution as recommended by the recreation commission and as contained in attachment A.

1:54:53 I'll second that. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. We now move on to Policy Item 13, Recreation Department Municipal Fee Schedule. Thank you, Mayor Bacon, members of Town Council and our community this evening.

1:55:23 So this item before you is the approval of the amended 2012-13 Recreation Department municipal fee schedule. I'm just going to give you a brief kind of executive summary for the benefit of the audience. I know you've read most of the agenda bill. Town Council is scheduled to review and adopt the entire amended municipal fee schedule for the town as part of the upcoming budget process, as this process is scheduled to begin in late June.

1:55:53 And culminate at that time, maybe in July, I'm not too sure. And the Recreation Department begins promoting and selling our summer full products now, getting a lot of inquiries. Staff who's presenting the Recreation Commission approved 2012-13 Recreation Department municipal fee schedule for Town Council approval this evening. Included in the fee schedule is our summer can pricing, program pricing.

1:56:19 Proposed fees for the summer operation of the multi-use facility that you can see in this evening as well. And our facility use fees for our parks and facilities. One major change that I'd like to bring the attention to Council and the community is the elimination of resident and non-resident fees. So in discussion and approval from the Recreation Commission, the Recreation Department will offer certain programs, which is essentially our camps, to all participants.

1:56:48 The purpose of this change is to encourage sign-ups by all users.

1:57:15 Prior to the camp and remove any obstacles to participation for any interested non-residents. I'll just keep speaking. I don't know if you can keep reading. Keep going. We're good, Stuart. Okay, thank you. Sorry. And as you know, it's really about cost effectiveness. So this fee change, there we go. The fee change will enable the Recreation Department to more effectively and efficiently schedule staff and operate the programs.

1:57:45 If we have people purchasing that product in advance. Included in this fee schedule is the proposed fees for the multi-use facility. So we've operated that facility in the wintertime. You approved those ice rink fees prior to operation last October when we commenced in December 2nd. So what we've done over the last two, three months is work on a fee schedule, a programming schedule, as mentioned previously this evening with the school district.

1:58:14 With our community partners and any stakeholders. So we've done considerable research. You can see in the agenda bill a survey that was conducted. We had 114 responses asking those participants what they wanted to do at that facility this summer. As you can see, Roller Hockey was our number one user. Theatre concerts, that's remote control cars if you want to know what RC cars were. Party rentals and full court basketball.

1:58:43 So that was kind of some of the program we put together. You can see in the fee schedule as the attachment. But essentially the goal of the pricing for our first year at that facility was to really keep it affordable and make it attractive to all user groups and to create demand from all those user groups as well. So we factored in facility rental. We really believe special events, private parties, birthday parties would be a big use for this facility. Admission fees were kind of based off comparables.

1:59:13 55 roller hockey facilities in and around California, Arizona, Nevada. We've done a lot of the comparisons. And you can see we're also going to rent roller skates and inline skates. I do want to point out that the funding for this operation this summer, scheduled to begin May 25th through September 2nd, is continued upon Measure U and Measure R funding. As this hasn't been operated in the past,

1:59:42 Really going to be an enhancement to the existing facility. So that's before the Measure U Steering Application Committee at this time. And with their approval, we're going to go out and purchase some skates and operate that facility for the summer months. So staff is requesting Town Council approve option one, which is to approve the amended 2012-13 Recreation Department municipal fee schedule. Happy to answer any questions.

2:00:11 That the Council may have. I said one, Madam Mayor. I was just curious, when you did the survey, were there topics that you put on there, or did people just throw out what they thought they'd like to see there? Yeah, it's a good question. We did prompt them. We kind of listed, obviously the survey is not here, just the results, but we listed about 12 activities that we thought the participants might be able to enjoy.

2:00:39 Just popular events for multi-use facilities. Right. So we did our research. We kind of prompted it. We felt that was a better way to really kind of, you know, get to what our really students and our residents wanted to see and do. Okay. Thank you.

2:00:59 I've got a question, Stuart, and it relates, it's more an operational one that I guess can come back to us, but you've got fees down here for party rentals, concerts, theaters, yet I see that your programming has items going until 8.30 at night on Friday and Saturday, so when would these parties, when do you, when does the commission expect that these parties, theaters, movies, etc. are going to happen?

2:01:20 It's a very scalable schedule, and that's really how we presented it to the partners and also to the commission. So, you know, based on demand, so if something was booked in advance, you know, we can maybe accommodate that, move them around. But, you know, like you said, Friday, Saturday evening is really the peak time that we've found. A lot of the roll-up rinks only operate kind of on a weekend basis. But with our popular ice hockey program and our youth leagues, we've kind of programmed that, you know, on the evenings. For party rentals, you know, I think they're for the kids. They're going to have them more during the day.

2:01:50 Any other questions?

2:02:19 Madam Mayor, I'd make a motion to approve the amended 2012-13 Recreation Department Municipal Fee Schedule. Second the motion. We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Council Member Mises? Yes. Council Member Harvey? Yes. Council Member Mises? Yes. Council Member Mises? Yes. Mayor Fultz and Lehman? Yes. Mayor Bickey? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. We'll next move on to Agenda Item 14, Mammoth Trap Project, Project Update, and Authorization to Advertise.

2:02:48 Has that you been turning the lights off in the back of the room, Peter? Timer is going on. Not you? Just checking. They're going to get the council members. This is an update on the Mammoth Track project at Whitmore. Essentially, the project plans are complete, and we're just finishing up the specifications for the project. As you know, the Striders have been working hard at fundraising.

2:03:17 And have been awarded several Measure R grants to date. They do have a Measure R application submitted and will probably include a Measure R application process. The project's been going on for a couple of years, so it takes a long time for a project of this size and scope. And would also note that the Department of Water Power did approve our next extension.

2:03:45 The terms of the lease were extended to 2041, so it's a 30-year extension. It's got a $500 a year payment for the lease plus the actual taxes that are collected by the county. It was increased in size to incorporate the baseball field that was built outside the lease boundary and then also the new track facility.

2:04:16 The whole park will be within the lease boundaries with the Department of Water and Power. Peter, was that on a consent agenda or do we know? It was on a discussion item. I guess they did have one question. It was, okay. But it was approved without much discussion. Great. It just turned out that Jen was able to listen in at the same time they approved it. And that's a big, is that 11-member council or more? I think it's a five-member board. Five-member board. Yeah. Okay. Thank you.

2:04:47 So the first phase of the project includes the mid, the major grading, the track itself, which is a paved asphalt base and then a polyurethane surface, the infield, which will be a synthetic turf, fence around the project, and then an accessible route to the facility.

2:05:12 From the parking lot. Most of the parking lot will remain dirt. We'll just be paving two ADA parking spaces. Other work that's kind of required as part of the project that maybe you don't see because it's underground, there'll be some drainage work to keep any runoff from flowing across the track. And we have to relocate the leach line system from the existing bathroom so it's not underneath the facility as well. Long term, that would create a settlement problem.

2:05:42 And then those new facilities, relocations will accommodate the future building. They'll have the locker room, the showers, and those type of facilities. To construct the facility and get it complete this summer, the schedule is pretty tight. And that's really due to the weather constraints that occur in the fall.

2:06:12 To pour the polyurethane surface, it really needs to be above 50. And so that becomes problematic October. It really needs to be done in September. So we do have a draft schedule in front of you. We would propose to begin advertising basically next week.

2:06:38 The public bid opening would be about May 22nd if there's no extensions. There's a date in there that's not shown and we plan to go to the Board of Supervisors to give them an update and discussion of maintenance activities on May 15th. So it would be the meeting in Mammoth, third meeting of the month. And the award would happen either June 6th or after the Major U, Major R awards, depending on how that...

2:07:09 Currently, the project has an approved budget or adopted budget of about $1.5 million. And so there is an application for $500 and $3,000. There's different levels. We do have some bid alternatives that are included in the overall budget that could be eliminated or postponed for a future budget.

2:07:39 The future project or the corporate is a change order later on. Obviously, the Town Council can't award a project unless it's fully funded, at least for the base bids and the project. Essentially, there'll be three contracts with the Town. One contract will be with the mass grading work and all the concrete, perimeter, curbs for the facilities themselves. There'll be two CMAS contracts.

2:08:08 Which are the statewide multiple contract options through the state. And those would be for the synthetic turf and for the polyurethane surface. With that, we can get a best value award, which will give the town the opportunity to award the product that we think provides the best service life for our area. And I think we've...

2:08:38 Found basically two companies that could provide that, so when we go out to actually get prices from them, there'll be competition, it won't be a one price thing. The base price is fixed by the contract, and then there's installation costs that go along with it, just related to that product. With that, is there any questions from Council? And Elaine Smith is here, if there's questions regarding the striders. I had a question.

2:09:14 I can ask afterwards regarding just the layout of the track. I had just one question on there, but maybe Elaine can answer that afterwards or something. Okay. Peter, let me make sure I understand. The CMAS allows us to have people competitively bid on the actual installation of the product so that we make sure we get someone who knows what they're doing. Is that a way? Yeah, essentially it's a multiple award contract for the state. Okay.

2:09:43 And so will we have a purchase order through the state for those particular contractors to install it? But basically for these kinds of materials, it's the manufacturers have their own installers to install the products, these high-tech products track on the synthetic turf. What's the difference of the two, actually there's three options, what's the difference for the council's benefit between option number one and option number two?

2:10:12 Option 1 is really asking to go ahead and advertise, even though, you know, we have a budget right now that would allow for awarding the grading contract and either the running surface or the turf. Talking with Dennis Drodner, our main staff, he'd prefer to see the turf in first just because of the location and the wind and the dust that will occur if the infield doesn't have a covering on it.

2:10:43 Is it an issue with the striders? Obviously the striders would rather see the polyurethane to make sure that gets done. Elaine and I were just talking about that and kind of the overall phasing options that we could get once any final grant awards are made with Measure U, Measure R. Thank you. Is that something we have to decide?

2:11:08 Which part is first? Yeah, and so, you know, you're looking at your award schedule at June 6th. That's also a Measure U discussion item. Since there will be multiple meetings in June, you know, maybe that moves to the special meeting the following week for the award. I see. But then that would delay your construction schedule? I think as long as we have awarded the contract and the contract is able to start work in June, you know, the last week of June.

2:11:37 There shouldn't be any reason that they can't complete the polyurethane portion of the work in September. There's a lot of work that has to be done before the polyurethane, but the schedule we've got laid out. And actually, Rick, I don't think we have to decide if it comes down to that. We've got a grant to do the infield. So the difference is that we would wait until all the funding's in place before we advertise. Thank you.

2:12:12 If we do one, we can have that in place, and then if the funding comes through, everything can go a little bit quicker. Is that the deal? Yeah, essentially, there's enough. The current funding level would allow us to do two big pieces of the project and leave one undone pending the Measure R, Measure U discussions, or another donor coming forward that's a large donor. But the schedule has us we would not be awarding the bid.

2:12:42 Until we knew the outcome of either measures R or U. Staff would not be asking Council to award the project until we have full funding on the project. But we can still get the bids in. Gotcha. Okay. Okay. Comments? Is there anyone who wishes to speak? Yes, John? John, we have a question with Peter as far as the bidding. This has to do with Measure U. As you know, this is Measure U. If it's approved, it will be pretty much everything we have.

2:13:18 So can any of this work be done if all the money for Measure U isn't appropriated? And can we start the project and finish it at a later date? I think I tried to answer that question. Basically, there is sufficient funding to complete all the grading and the infill turf area with the current awards and private donations.

2:13:54 Unfunded would be either the, you know, that would be Dennis's decision. He'd like to see the truth done before the, because of the wind and the dust top. And then the polyurethane, it really has to be done either in September or if it's the following season, then that would be in probably May or June. But that would be a problem for the striders. They wouldn't be happy with that. Okay.

2:14:25 There may be some other techniques that we could use on the infield to stabilize it, but that would be an additional expense currently not in the budget, a minor expense. Okay, so comments, thoughts? No, there are comments. Well, you know, I guess my only comment is if there's anybody on the fence as to whether option one or two is the right

2:15:01 choice for this council. I would really strongly encourage and want to make a pitch for option one on the theory or ground that I believe that momentum is pretty important. And sometimes when you begin something without not all of the money, you get all of the money as it goes along. I don't think that that's

2:15:30 An imprudent financial choice to make. I recall, I know that I've told this story before, but so many years ago when Running USA came to this community, I remember sitting in the little conference room with a town staff and there was a number of people, including a couple of legendary running coaches, sitting in that room asking,

2:15:58 For some assistance from the town, specifically $35,000 a year to help them bring elite athletes. And the ultimate goal was not to bring elite athletes in order to obtain or in order to get medals at the 2004 Olympics, which actually occurred. The ultimate goal was to get what is before us.

2:16:22 You know, it takes 10 years to get anything done or to move something along. It's been certainly a long road, but I would not discount the opportunities that we will have as a potential premier and maybe only high altitude training center in the country as this thing goes forward. Now, I'm not suggesting that's going to happen next year once the track is in or this year once it's in, but...

2:16:49 It's just another step toward that long-term goal, which I think meets so many objectives of this community to bring folks here to diversify the economic or economy by bringing in different kinds of activities and events to this community.

2:17:08 I would really hate to see getting that last 10% stand in the way of moving this forward this year while there is so much momentum. And so I would encourage the adoption of option one as recommended. Is that a motion? It is. I'll second that.

2:17:31 We have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie.

2:17:34 Council Member Eason?

2:17:35 Yes.

2:17:35 Council Member Eason?

2:17:36 Yes.

2:17:37 Council Member Eason?

2:17:37 Yes.

2:17:38 Council Member Eason?

2:17:38 Yes.

2:17:39 Mayor Compton?

2:17:40 Yes.

2:17:40 Motion passes 5-0.

2:17:42 And Mayor Bacon, can I just say that I'm kind of a glasses-half-full guy, you know, and I think your comment, Rick, about what that's going to bring to the community.

2:17:51 I have a feeling that just when we get to infield and the track late, I think we're going to be blown away by the number of runners that are going to start coming up here. Well, it's shocking who's up here now. It's just amazing. It's going to be amazing, yes. And, yeah, there's even just athletes that aren't even runners that are up here right now. They're training. It's phenomenal. Yep. Noticing the time, is there...

2:18:16 Take a short break or keep moving? No, keep moving. We've got two more, right? And we'll move on to agenda item number 15, which is your TOT enforcement update. Mayor Bacon, Mayor Pro Tem, Lehman, Councilmembers Eastman, Wood, and Harvey, fellow staff and community members, my name is Mike Dang, and I'm here tonight speaking as the head of the TOT committee. The TOT committee is a public-private committee that has the focus of

2:18:50 Working together to improve the TOT process for the town and to help the town to optimize the TOT revenue. You have the agenda bill, which Sandra Moberly prepared for us. Appreciate that. And I wanted to just point out some key things on there. Briefly, the team mentioned that. We've been adjusting the team as we've gone forward. When Dave asked me to head it up, I talked with various members of the committee.

2:19:21 About what we needed. And a good TOT system should have various systems and subsystems. And one of those would be the finding aspect. Of course, the ongoing collection aspect. And then the assessment and the audit parts of it. And we've been, through Cindy's help, maintaining the ongoing collections part of it. But with the cutbacks, she hasn't been able to keep up the emphasis on the finding aspect.

2:19:52 And that's where Mark Wardlaw's team and Sandra Moberly have stepped up to help the finance division. With the efforts so far from August 1, where we're counting, there's currently 75 open cases. 175 have been opened since August 1. Today I ran a accounting system, and from the August 1 date forward to sometime in January or so,

2:20:20 We've collected about $70,000 in new TOT applicant revenue, so that reflects a base of about over a half million in TOT revenue to get that TOT of about $70,000. And that, I can emphasize, is really good because that hasn't come at the more aggressive efforts that we're stepping into now.

2:20:50 That's been mostly through word of mouth and through advertising. And even with that, in my office I hear people come in from time to time to apply and they comment about the increased efforts even at that public level. So as we've been working on different pieces of this, one of the systems we're focusing on bringing online now is the assessment part of it. And you have those steps before you.

2:21:19 They say steps, but they're actually contingent steps. In the ideal world, the operators would just go ahead and, of course, complete their returns and submit. But as that's not always the case, we have these different sub-processes. The first one is the data gathering and preparing the assessments. The code refers to gathering facts and information upon which to base an assessment. So the staff regularly is looking.

2:21:49 Out on the web looking for identifying who's in business essentially, who's putting themselves out there, who's marketing themselves, whether a person is advertising that they have one unit to lease out their condo, for example, in a properly zoned area, or whether they've got hundreds of units out there. The staff is monitoring this, looking at who's open for business, and then confirming whether or not they have a valid TOT certificate.

2:22:19 If not, then they gather information. That can come in the form of the calendars on the web, of how often the person is occupied, what their occupancy is, and also what the rates are. And then we use a historical index and can base an assessment, prepare the assessment and give it to the person to pay their taxes. If they don't pay the taxes, they request a hearing, they can come before the finance hearing officer.

2:22:48 One of the staff members. And at this point, the code shifts the burden to the operator. So after the basic facts and information are gathered, the burden shifts to the operator and they come in and present information as to why the taxes, interest, penalties, and enforcement charges that were assessed to them should not be at the level that they were assessed or whether they should be eliminated altogether. The finance hearing officer makes a decision on that. If the person...

2:23:18 Disagrees with that. They can appeal to the Town Council. Another shift happens there. When it comes before you, the Town Council, the full evidentiary record is presented so that what the person, what the staff has gathered is evidence. It's combined with what the operator has presented as evidence, which could be their bank statements and their operating records. That all comes before you.

2:23:45 To review your Town Council meeting and make a decision on. And hopefully everything is resolved then. You make a decision on the amount, whether you agree with the amount of our assessment or whether you would adjust it up or down. And after that final decision then, if the person pays, that's great. If not, then we would file a notice to file judgment. If the person doesn't pay at that step, then the judgment would be filed.

2:24:13 And a lien would be placed against the property. So that's the basic processes there. And I wanted to drill down a little bit more on the assessment methodology to make sure it's clear. We reviewed it in one of our last DOT workshop. It's basically three parts to it. One is the occupancy rate, which we can get from the calendars. Let's see if they're 50% occupied for any month. And we're monitoring this throughout the month.

2:24:40 So we get the occupancy, let's say if they're occupied half a month, and we look at the rates that they were charging for that time. We can calculate it now. We know the amount of revenue they generated for that month. And then we can calculate, of course, what the TOT should be. Then what we do, because we're going to go back three years, what we do is, you probably recall seeing, we email out to you every month the TOT revenue by month. And you notice the pattern, of course, in there.

2:25:10 And we create an index. And with next month's report, you'll see an index at the bottom that shows, for example, it sets January at 100. And then every other month is indexed off of that. And with that type of index, we can look at their revenue for any month and estimate what it could be for the remaining months of the year and go back three years. Then the staff, if they feel it's proper, can discount that.

2:25:37 As seems proper. So that's the basic assessment model. So it's pretty straightforward. And it's based on the history of TOT in the town. So those are the basic elements that we have. I wanted to mention also, as you saw in the agenda bill, that we have a goal of collecting half a million in TOT this year. And based in the coming fiscal year, and based on the 70,000 collected so far in the past few months, we feel confident.

2:26:07 In fact, it's certainly a stretch goal, but we feel confident in our ability to do that. Staff has also been active with the press, and all of these things are coming together to achieve that fully functioning and robust TOT system. After the assessment part, after we get that going, we're slowly and gradually bringing up the audit side of this process, and I can give you a report in a few months on that piece also.

2:26:37 These are the basic parts that I wanted to highlight out of the agenda bill, and at this time, turn it over to you in case you have any questions, comments, or conclusions. John. Michael, first of all, I wanted to thank you because the feedback I'm getting is that so far this has been a very successful effort on our part. We're not where we want to be yet, but the initial feedback is that we're doing a good job. Have you found...

2:27:07 With the people that you're dealing with, you know, the numbers, 75 open cases, 170 inquiries or whatever, that as a general rule that the feedback and the response you're getting from the people we're dealing with has been a positive experience? Well, positive in the sense that most are just complying. So we're not having, we're having very few

2:27:34 Very, very few noncompliant, and we haven't taken actions in those cases. But for the most part, it's been positive. I have heard people at the counter complaining, coming in complaining, well, why don't you get my neighbor, things like this. But overall, it seems like people are starting to realize, okay, we're taking this further than we have. And I've been hearing that also, that the town is taking this process much further than they've ever taken it before. And that the town's...

2:28:03 Okay, thank you.

2:28:34 I'd just like to add a thank you as well to you, your staff, and the Lodging Association again for all the work. It's really interesting having come on council two years ago and assuming that a lot of this stuff was in place and maybe pieces of it were and there were reasons why we couldn't follow through but it's really nice to have.

2:29:02 Getting a better process, especially with changes happening, you know, staff probably didn't have to deal with the online VRBO, things like that, and have that problem grow so rapidly. So I think you guys have done a great job, and I think another thing to emphasize is once this program is in place, once we figure out all the little hurdles and loopholes and whatnot, I think it'll be a much more efficient process, and hopefully computerized.

2:29:31 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:30:02 Another committee member? Hi, Cheryl Witherell, and I sit on the TOT committee. And just quickly, because I know it's getting late, I just wanted to applaud the efforts of council, staff. This is a really important endeavor for our community. The message really that I wanted to bring from the team today is that our hope is that you as council really uphold these assessments as they come forward to you.

2:30:29 And as we move forward in the steps that Mike has explained here today, there will be people that are going to come up here and they're going to tell their sad story. On a lodging standpoint, alone in dealing with owners and being behind in assessments and being behind in their common area dues, it's hard. It's a hard position. It's a hard thing to listen to. It won't be easy, but your support will be essential in the message and a lot of the work that the staff has done.

2:30:58 You know, we look at page 7 of Marianna's report today, the bar graph, showing expenses over income. There's really two ways for us to build that general fund. And TOT, 61% of that general fund coming from TOT, you know, enforcement is a big part of that. We can build on the general fund by some of the enforcement efforts that we've put into place with this committee. Tourism is another. We've got to be able to build.

2:31:27 On community and the people that are coming here and the services that we offer, a lot of what you talked about tonight are going to build on that as well, the track. But revenue is going to be important as we move it forward. Lastly, just a really big appreciation for our current team. We really are getting somewhere. And a part of this process since the TOT committee has been formed.

2:31:52 Prior to that, in a lodging community, in a lot of discussions, and I really feel that our system is in place. We've got a long way to go, but the momentum is picking up, and there will be cases that come to you, and your support will be more important than ever moving forward. Thank you. Thank you, Cheryl. May are canceled. I'll only add just a few small points. For CDD, we have...

2:32:22 Two people almost fully dedicated to this program and then parts of three others, an arm, a leg, and a head. And so for us, this is our department's highest priority. And so, you know, we're driving through this program. It's a project to us and we employ project management. And so we're keeping this effort on track and on time.

2:32:46 In your coming budget, we will be recommending to you that we treat this as something like an enterprise fund so that the revenues that are captured through this program, the escaped TOT, is actually set aside and...

2:33:03 And focused to this particular effort to make sure that the commitment you've directed now is maintained in future years. So effectively, the revenues generated from the program support the staff effort. And excess revenues, of course, can be for other purposes. But we want to make sure that in this effort, because it will have to be an ongoing thing or else we'll go back to where we were, so that you can see and measure the staff costs.

2:33:32 to the staff revenues. As we grow, we may be in a position to actually add contract staff to increase our enforcement efforts. So we're moving forward. We'll have this as a major work program priority in your next fiscal year budget work program. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Thank you. Mickey. Thank you, Brown, Mammoth Lakes.

2:34:07 I'd just like to make a comment about the recourse of using liens because we found this with our owner's associations. If an owner does not have any equity in their property, it has little or no value. So that is one consideration if you get to that step before you file a lien. You really need to determine if there's equity first. If they don't have equity, then you have to take it to an additional step. That's my recommendation. I think, too, we had discussed a little bit of that.

2:34:37 And I think it goes beyond just a lien on the property. And we wanted to get some clarification, but couldn't it become a general lien where it also attaches to the person and follows in other areas, bank accounts and other property they may have in other areas. So I think that was something we were going to look into. I don't think that that option is available just through the imposition of a lien. I think that for significant violators, we always have the option of simply taking them to court and asking for a judgment.

2:35:06 Depending on the size of it, it could be small claims court, it could be regular civil action superior court. If we do get a judgment, then the judgment is against the person rather than just against the property. So we have a lot of tools at our disposal, and we'll have to pick the right one for each case. Right at the moment, we're pursuing one to somebody who owes, I think, over $100,000 who's bankrupt, and so we're working on that one through the bankruptcy court. And wouldn't a municipal...

2:35:34 Lean against the property, take precedence over a first mortgage? I don't know that off the top of my head, truthful. I'd have to look into that. Yeah.

2:35:46 I was going to add that in Auckland, and their case may be different, for parking tickets, we were able to basically impose liens on state income taxes. And I think you can do that with federal income taxes. So that's as close as it gets to an individual as opposed to a business solution, which will explore them. Any other comments? I'll make a comment, actually.

2:36:15 I think on Mark's point that the money that's collected is going to go into a fund to help cover the cost of running this program. I think that we need to be careful. I don't think 100% of the money should go in there because we're doing this to build up our general fund. So that's going to defeat the purpose. I think we need to put a portion of that money in there. And we also don't want a department that just also looks like they've got a big bank account and they can do all kinds of good stuff with it.

2:36:42 I think we need to be leery of that. And I also think that we need to really stay focused on the idea of contracting this work out, because I've heard several times tonight about how stretched town staff is and how they can't get to their work. And I think probably the private community, once we've got all the details in place about how this program will work and how we can collect, we then need to turn it over to probably contract it out to a private individual.

2:37:12 A or multiple private individuals for enforcement and I think we'll get some good results out of that. So it's my only comments. There's another component to that as well that we approved in our ordinance and that was imposing cost of collection onto the taxpayer in the event that it ends up.

2:37:36 We have to hire attorneys and staff time and this and that. So I certainly could see a portion of that going back in just to help keep the effort going. Okay. We'll now move on to Agenda Item 16. Mark? Mayor and Member of the Council, this is an agenda item that was requested by Mayor Pro Tem. And the purpose of this is to...

2:38:05 Receive Town Council direction and perhaps action on the recommended three-year update to the Destination Resort Community and Economic Development Strategy and to receive any comments or direction from the Council on our future economic development initiatives and work program items. In October, we came to the Town Council with a recommended economic development program. One of those items included the update of the Destination Resort Strategy.

2:38:35 Some of the specific comments we received were actually to make this a very simple update. Don't reinvent it. Keep it quick and focused. We have done that. We established, through the Planning Commission, an Economic Development Committee. That committee has worked extensively listening to the Economic Stimulus Council and also the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition. They also worked with the Planning Commission.

2:39:02 And formed the recommendations that you see here before you in attachment A, which is the recommended destination resort strategy. It is focused on a couple of types of changes. We identified those items that have been completed, and so they're in the back of the report, and there's a number of objectives and strategies have been completed.

2:39:26 Through the last three years, we consolidated some of the objectives to make them a little tighter and more grouped to specific strategies. And we also identified through the work of the committee and the planning commission some of the major new strategies and objectives that have been suggested. I'll review those very quickly. One major new theme is economic recovery in the context of not only the Great Recession, our current...

2:39:53 The seasonal effects of low snow, but also the to-be-determined result of the judgment. I think it's obvious that the town's economic efforts need to be far more focused on improving the economic condition of the town. The economic recovery heading has one major strategy to it, which is to promote our economic recovery. I won't read that to you.

2:40:20 Some of the major ideas behind that build on the work that the Recreation Commission has done through RecStrat's Parks and Recreation Master Plan, as well as the events in the stimulus committee. A major idea has been to become a branded high-altitude sports and cultural destination, known for its innovation, and then there are a number of objectives beneath that. They include completing a feasibility study so we can actually target what types of events we should...

2:40:50 Designed to and how we develop the facilities and what the facilities look like for that. Dedicating resources to supported position, perhaps through Mammoth Lakes Tourism, to actually work to attract event producers here. So not us producing events, but attracting to this community. The ideas you've seen all over the place, Coachella Music Festival.

2:41:17 The Laguna Arts Festival, Sundance Film Festival, the Indian Wells Tennis Championship. The examples are all around us. And so those are the ideas that this feasibility study would identify. And those are the types of events that producers would produce, concert events, for example. And the idea is certainly to support what we have and attract more.

2:41:44 Another major objective, which is part of your last discussion, is improve revenue collection. And I think what's important with the last conversation is to achieve results in some certain area, a dedicated focus that includes town council leadership, constituency involvement, and a focused, dedicated staff team.

2:42:09 That's what makes our efforts work. So whether it's a general plan or district planning or TOT collection, identifying the top priorities and then staffing them is essential. Another group of objectives follow, which I won't read, developing new fiscal revenue sources I think will be essential for us in the future, whether they're through taxing districts, assessment districts.

2:42:38 Securing more and more grant funds, dedicating staff to that purpose will be important. There are a number of other priority strategies that have been listed on page 4 and on page 5, so we hope to hear that we've identified, the planning commission has identified the top priorities. And then finally on page 5, we're seeking any ideas or direction from the council.

2:43:04 So our intent is to receive direction. Hopefully you can

2:43:32 Make modifications as appropriate and approve this document. We will use this then, if it's captured your priorities, to formulate the work program that you will see coming forward in your fiscal year budget. So with that, I'll close my presentation. Planning Commissioner Brown is here and would like to address the council on the committee of Planning Commission's work. Thank you.

2:44:04 Good evening, Mayor, Council. I just wanted to express to you that the Planning Commission took this particular task very seriously because we do know that it's key, it's a very key document for establishing the work program and it's very interesting how the agendas work tonight because you had this wonderful presentation, not wonderful, but you certainly had this

2:44:28 Very detailed presentation about our economic landscape to start with. You've heard about the TOT enhancement. And then this is really then our next strategy about how we feel what the priorities should be to enhance our economy during the next three years. So it was certainly a document that we spent a lot of time at. We looked at every objective and said, well, how is this going to really help?

2:44:56 Produce a rate of return, and I'm happy to answer any questions that you may have on it. Any questions? I don't know. Go ahead. And if you don't have questions about the specific document, then Matthew was going to address what we term our near-term strategy about what we would like to accomplish this summer. I can do that now if you like Madam Mayor. Sure. So is it like a...

2:45:29 Distillation of what's in here? It's kind of an add-on, if you will. These are the main top-tier priorities, and then there are some other elements that we have picked out of the Economic Stimulus Program out of a vast number of ideas that came up. We started picking out some of these different near-term priorities that could be easily achievable.

2:45:58 Preferably this summer. So with that, we identified a number of different things. We tried to put a name to it as well, especially in light of the tough winter we just had. So we titled it the best summer ever. And what we've done is really tried to take a grassroots effort and reach out to a number of different community leaders or entities and whatnot.

2:46:26 And one of the areas we're going to expand there was in speaking with Michelle Tamir.

2:46:53 Was expanding the mud run, trying to get the marketing for that going a little bit early. Last year we had 700, they had 725 participants in the first year, and that was after a lot of flaws in marketing and whatnot. So they think that we could probably triple that this year, if not more. There's also some good cooperation with some celebrities on cooperative marketing that we can help.

2:47:20 Working with the village, the village agreed to try to do something in the fall to step up, even create a new event or expand an existing one like Oktoberfest. Some other ideas were thrown around for Oktoberfest about how a number of different local entities, whether it be restaurants or bars or whatever, could each own a tent and try to make it so that there could be a little bit, instead of just one area where we go to, there could be a little bit more connectivity in a walking environment.

2:47:50 Something for next year that we had discussed with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area was the possibility of doing something like they do at Whistler, an event called Crank Works where they bring in 150,000 people for a mountain biking event. And I think this is something that Mammoth has missed out on. We have an incredible venue for that and something that we can do in the summer or early spring, really start hitting our shoulder seasons with that. So in my initial discussions with Rusty and some of his staff,

2:48:19 There seemed to be a lot of excitement over these components. Mickey's reached out to the Mammoth Lakes Board of Realtors and also with Mammoth Lakes Tourism on getting some marketing components, whether it be just something as simple as our events and sporting events and having the real estate community reach out to their clients. One, on start a marketing campaign of why you should buy in Mammoth. At the same time, they're reaching tens of thousands of people and explaining to them what's going on and why this can be such a great summer.

2:48:49 We had a phenomenal summer last year. I think it can be better this year. And I think with just a little bit more of a push, we can obtain that. That's kind of our goal. Mammoth Lakes Tourism, I asked if there's anything else they could reach out and help with. And obviously high altitude training has been a priority of theirs. So in speaking with John Urdi, I said, what do you think Mammoth Lakes Tourism could do to push that extra mile?

2:49:16 His response was they were going to try to bring some camps up this year and make an extra effort for that. So work with the lodging community on finding some lodging components where we can start really driving up schools and whatnot, whether it be running or some other athletic component, just try to drive folks up here, larger groups and teams. And then we talked a little bit about an economic indicators report.

2:49:42 We picked up a few of them off online, looking at Boulder and a few other places. They're just little two-page indicators, but they're really important for investors coming to town, and that's something else that the Board of Realtors or anybody else for that matter can go online and see the health or lack thereof of a community. We have a lot of components already built up. There's just a few more pieces we need for that, and we may turn to the Chamber of Commerce.

2:50:09 Even staff to finish up that report and finalize it. And finally, there was mention of an event coordinator. We'd like to possibly touch on reaching out to some of these event coordinators and seeing what they can do, using grant monies and things of that nature to incentivize them. But this is having an event coordinator that oversees a number of different events and programs.

2:50:37 Really helps the structure of what's going on up here, whether it be a play or something like that. They can reach out to people in L.A. that bring, or any other area and say, look, come on up here, we have facilities. You get, you know, a take of the house or whatever that is, or all of it, just bring your program up here. So there's people out there that do that. These components, they're not something where...

2:51:00 We're looking for a handout from the town or anybody else. They're looking to community members to step up a little bit in hard time and really take a grassroots effort to try to drive tourism up here. So this is a piece that we're adding on as a short-term component, hopefully with a lot of these goals being achievable in the fall. Great. So that was it. All right. I don't know if, Mickey, you have anything else you wanted to add.

2:51:29 I think what we're really asking from all community leaders is to be passionate about something that would really help the town this summer. And it doesn't have to necessarily be a new program. It can even be an existing program. But it has been, Matthew and I have been talking about this for a couple of weeks, and we're really doing it just so you understand through the venue of the Economic Stimulus Council.

2:51:53 So that we don't get in violation of any Browns Act. But it's been really fun going out to various community leaders and saying, well, what can you do to help make this the best summer ever? And everybody just lights up. And so we're very enthusiastic because we think everybody's going to become happy, positive, and put their efforts towards something that's very focused and achievable in a short period of time. And then I happy to answer any other questions you had about her. Any other questions of Nikki?

2:52:24 All right. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you. Okay. So, I'm looking, is there anyone else who wishes to speak? Okay. I think the rest of them laughed for a kiss. All right. What's the council's pleasure? Well, I'd make a motion that we adopt option number one. The doctor says three-year plan and some of the short-term priorities.

2:53:05 And programs as discussed. Do we have a second? I'll second the motion. Thank you. We have a motion and a second. Or I'll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilman Grayson? Yes. Councilmember Harvey? Yes. Councilmember Wood? Yes. Mayor Porteum-Lytton? Yes. Mayor Bacon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And we move on to policy item 17, resolution granting housing funds to Mammoth Lakes Housing. Good evening, council.

2:53:42 Madam Mayor, Ellen Clark, Senior Planner. This agenda item is being brought forward on behalf of Mammoth Lakes Housing, who have made a request to the Council for funding, the purpose of which would be to repay an outstanding loan that was provided to the organization in 2004 by John Baruch to assist them with purchase of their current office space at 587 Old Named Road due to various

2:54:10 Circumstances, which are outlined in the memorandum, included in the agenda bill, Mammoth Lakes Housing finds itself unable to repay for the balance of the loan, and so it's in a situation where they're being pressed for payment and cannot afford to make that payment. So the request is for funding to be provided to Mammoth Lakes Housing by the town in the amount of $93,000, which would allow that loan to be repaid for

2:54:39 For Mammoth Lakes Housing to retain its existing office space and the current operations that it makes from that space. We have a resolution included in the Agenda Bill which includes the findings of public benefits or the granting of funds which at this time it's recommended are made from the Measure A account. I think that will conclude my presentation. It's late. Keep it brief.

2:55:09 Do you have any questions we have to answer? I have one question, is that if we look at page 6, which is the resolution, I just wanted to clarify that the resolution states that it would be up to 93,000. I am presuming that there's a presumption that our...

2:55:34 Extremely poor financial situation that there might be an ability to negotiate a lower amount? Set a little lower amount? So we have had conversations at the board who have the public's housing and have tend to be considered a number that is less than that. And that's where we'll go back. I think we were asking the council for authorization and now we'll go back and be more specific with that.

2:56:03 Process. Exactly as you stated. Okay. Okay, so this resolution, we award the money to Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc., and the board does the discussions. Yes. Included in the resolution is an agreement that the town would execute with Mammoth Lakes Housing regarding expenditure of these funds. Any terms and conditions that provide. Okay. With grant to the funds.

2:56:41 Okay, any other questions of staff? Before we comment, anyone in the audience wishing to speak on this? Good evening, Mayor Bacon, Councilmembers, Pam Hennerty, Executive Director of Maniflex Housing. I stand before you tonight humbly requesting funds for a very difficult financial situation we find ourselves in. As you know, Maniflex Housing does...

2:57:17 Very good work in this community, providing housing to our community. And it's difficult that we find ourselves in this situation in housing our office and our space. And as times were good and we had several more staff members, we expanded. We did this back in the peak days in 2004, 2006. And as we've cut costs and revenues have been cut.

2:57:45 We find ourselves in need of reducing overhead in several different ways, and the reduction of our office space was one that made the most sense. Jennifer and I certainly didn't need to occupy almost 1,600 square feet of space, so it is a difficult situation and not an easy request to make, but we do request that you grant us this grant to pay this so that we can be alleviated from the lawsuit we currently find ourselves in. Thank you.

2:58:21 Okay. Ellen, were you going to add something? No. Okay, just waiting to see if there's more questions. Okay, anyone else in the public? All right. So, what's the pleasure of council? Well, I just want to indicate as the council representative on that board that I appreciate that Pam stands humbly before us, but quite frankly, notwithstanding that housing is a separate entity,

2:58:55 It was created as part of and after the passage by the community of a measure that provided a specific portion of our TOT for housing. That was the right thing to do. It was and it is. And as part of that

2:59:23 As part of the setting up of the organization, it was apparent that we needed to have people to staff it, otherwise we'd be running it as a town. And I remember again at the beginning that Kirk Stapp, who was a council member and I asked the council to put in place the structure.

2:59:47 That still exists today and the council did so and it was formed and an executive director as well as additional staff as required were hired. Over the years as grants were obtained the agency or the entity did quite a lot of good work but it has to be remembered that its core funding source

3:00:16 Other than specific grants for the construction of buildings themselves or the rehabilitation of buildings or the purchase of land or whatever that might be, is the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And so in that respect, it's an extension of us. And as Pam indicated, it fell on hard times. But it fell on hard times because this and prior councils have determined to fund it at a rate.

3:00:45 Less than it had previously and to not expend all of the housing funds that the voters approved on housing, meaning that we are responsible for the cutbacks and we as a town and as this council and prior councils are responsible for creating a circumstance in which as it's

3:01:15 Primary, if not now sole funding source, it could not pay its bills. So the bill couldn't pay was a note. And the note happened to be granted by a person who lives here, who works here, who contributes to the community, who is involved in the community. And so back to my first statement about the housing entity doing things.

3:01:40 That were the right thing to do. It is the right thing to do for us to try to resolve this litigation because the effect of it is that the housing entity is not going to have funds, meaning the effect of a judgment in the event that the housing foundation loses, as I would expect it would, is that it will have to dig into some other

3:02:09 So one could argue that we shouldn't be using housing money to pay a note to someone for a housing office. I would argue that you need a housing office in order to administer housing programs that the voters asked us to...

3:02:38 Create, establish, and administer, so I'm supportive of the option, or the option that is recommended by staff. Any other comments? Is that a motion? Yes, that's a motion. I'll second that motion. You know, 9 o'clock. Can't speak, can't think. Just to quit the point of order is, if it needed to be included in the

3:03:09 Motion attachments A and B, or not really? Inclusion of A and B? Well, thanks, John. Let me just amend the general or vague motion to choose option one, to adopt the attached resolution authorizing a grant of housing funds to Mammoth Lakes Housing, Inc. to repay an outstanding loan amount.

3:03:39 of $93,000. I'll note that the resolution calls for a grant of up to $93,000 to repay an outstanding loan amount for the office space occupied by Mammoth Lakes Housing. Including attachments A and B? Attachment A is not really part of the motion. But attachment B looks like we need to approve.

3:04:06 What happens to the funds if they don't pay the entire 93? They remain in the housing reserve. Reserve. They just remain in the same account that they currently sit in. True, but I think what Matthew's pointing out is that, and it's why I made the comment earlier about the dire financial situation and wanting to stress the up to, because after this, that housing reserve will only have $14,000 in it.

3:04:37 Hopefully there's some room for negotiation. Okay, we had a motion. Did the amendment... I'll amend a second, Jess, to whatever Rick said. We have a motion at a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. And we will adjourn to the regular meeting of Wednesday, May 2nd.