TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2012

Town Council Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 51 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

225 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:52 I call to order a special meeting of the Town Council of Mammoth Lakes for Tuesday, May 8, 2012. John, would you leave? Oh, I'm sorry. Roll call, please. Councilmember Eastman? Here. Councilmember Hartman? Here. Councilmember Wood? Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Lehman? Here. Here. John, would you leave us in the pledge, please? I'd be happy to. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God.

3:24 The next item on the agenda would be public comments on items that are not on tonight's agenda. If there's anyone here to speak on that, please come forward to the podium. Seeing none, we will move right into our presentation by John Urdi.

4:05 Really the power and impact of tourism in Mammoth Lakes, and I think we've got some stats in here that will probably surprise a lot of people, just really where we rank in the state and just how much of an impact it has on our entire community. Basically the fact that visitors fund our economy here in town shouldn't be a surprise to anyone. What we look at when they drive the economy is that Mammoth Lakes is really one industry.

4:35 Just one industry and that's tourism. We don't have anything else here that we can fall back on. We don't have agriculture. We don't have manufacturing. And that's a big piece. And when you look at the information conducted through independent research through SMG, 68% of our workforce here is directly related to tourism. The ironic thing is, my job is not directly related to tourism. I'm actually considered an administration. So if you look at...

5:02 All the other folks that are in town, whether they're bus drivers or construction folks, they're byproducts of tourism, but 68% are directly related to tourism. That's one of the highest in the state. Visitors to Mammoth Lakes spend $415 million directly with our businesses here in town. And that's what really generates the 69.5% of our TOT that funds the general fund. So of the general fund, almost 70% of it comes directly from our visitor spending.

5:33 So that $415 million, the taxes that are derived from that fund the general fund. If you look at the research done by running associates, that means that every single household in Mammoth Lakes and actually within Mono County would pay an additional $3,052 if we didn't have tourism. That is the number one per capita in the state. The amount of money that comes in really greatly reduces the amount of impact that we have.

6:04 That we would need to fund town projects and programs and, frankly, activities. The map on the right there is really just to show that Mammoth Lakes is an isolated community. We know that. We have air traffic. We have 395, but we are still removed. We're a rural community. We have Reno as our nearest city. There's no way we're going to see our folks here. If we lose jobs within tourism, we're not going to see people commuting to Reno or Carson City. It's highly unlikely.

6:35 The other problem is we're surrounded by 2 million acres of public land, and the idea of having something replace tourism is highly unrealistic as well. One of the facts on here that I think is probably the most amazing is number one that we rank number one for California in transient occupancy tax per capita. And then the piece that really blew me away was the fact that out of 480 cities in California on gross TOT receipts, we rank number 17 out of 480 cities.

7:04 Ahead of places like Napa. Ahead of places like Laguna Beach. It's pretty amazing what happens out there. When we talk about visitation, this is a pretty clear example of our across-the-board visitation. Summer dominates the number of folks that come through. This adds up to about 4.7 million visitor days. We have about 1.5 million visitors that come to Mono County, and that adds up to about almost 5 million visitor days over the course of the year.

7:33 Because of the amenities that we have here in Mammoth Lakes, we are the base camp for Mono County. Folks that are coming in, the fact that Tioga Pass opened up yesterday, we have a lot of folks that are rolling in. We had a number of buses that came through the visitor center yesterday because of Tioga being open. It's a great opportunity for us, and we are the base camp, so even if they are coming through here, it's because of the fact that we have so much to offer. And really, Mammoth Lakes Tourism is the one organization that markets on the year-round basis on an unbiased standpoint.

8:02 As I mentioned before, if you look at the general fund revenues, if you look at 73% comes from our sales tax and our TOT. Unfortunately, it doesn't show up very well there, but we've got 12% comes from sales tax and 61% from TOT. So 73% is really from our tax base. 95.2% of that, so almost all of that money is coming from our visitors. It's not me going to Footloose and buying a pair of ski boots.

8:33 It's folks coming into town and spending money with us. So making sure that we continue to fill that funnel is a huge opportunity for us. On the expenditure side, if you look at the amount of money that comes in via TOT, again, 69.5% of the general fund comes from money that's gathered from our visitor tax dollars. Really what that does is it would allow most of the general fund to be funded through just the TOT. If you were to exclude something like public safety,

9:03 The debt service and capital projects that could fund the entire operation of the town from the general fund. No one in this town is untouched by tourism. I think it's important to note that whether you're a business in town, whether you're retired here in town, whether you work for the government, you are touched by tourism. The fact that we have almost 70% of the dollars that go in to support our town in places like Whitmore Pool and the parks and all the operations that we have in town.

9:33 That is coming from our visitors. We need to make sure we keep that funnel full. And the only way to keep that funnel full is to continue to invite people to come visit us. This here is really straightforward. It shows you the tax relief from tourism. Again, I mentioned it earlier. Every household within Mono County sees a tax relief of well over $3,000. Our nearest competitive set here is the West Gateway to Yosemite National Park over in Mariposa. And they see almost half as much of the relief as we do.

10:06 What this means is that if we did not have tourism, it would cost us all $3,000 more per household to have the amenity base that we have and even the services that we have from the town right now. On average, the California state averages $880 per household, to give you an idea of just how far this is. And the $3,052 is the highest in the state as far as the tax relief, and as you can see, it's about twice as much as the nearest competitor. Since its inception back in July of 2010,

10:38 Mammoth Lakes Tourism has really worked hard to reduce the overhead costs, and with that, the idea is to reduce the overhead costs and put more into the direct marketing side of things. We want to make sure that we're inviting everybody we possibly can to come visit us. Visitor spending, the year before Mammoth Lakes Tourism came into being, was $391 million. In just our first year, that's up to $415.8 million, and that's direct spending at restaurants, that's direct spending at ski shops, that's direct spending at gas stations.

11:07 It's a huge amount of money that comes into the town, and we need to keep that going. The quote on the right-hand side there is an important one, and that's from John Quelch at Harvard Business School, and it starts off saying this is not the time to cut advertising. It's well documented that brands that increase advertising during a recession when competitors are cutting back can improve market share and return on investment at lower cost than during good economies. So it's very important that we make sure that we, being Mammoth Lakes Tourism, are

11:37 Providing universal and unbiased marketing for all businesses in Mammoth Lakes. And we have no preferential treatment. We are trying to drive people here so that they eat in the restaurants, that they shop in the stores, that they ski on the hill, and that they take advantage of all the activities that we have. An example of a pretty dramatic loss was Colorado. Back in 1983, Colorado formed a Colorado Tourism Office. And the CTO came into being and they put together a marketing campaign that brought them

12:11 A lot of attention, and they really worked themselves up to 14th place in the summer group segment, bringing people as a summer destination. They really started out hard in 1987 when they were 14th, and they worked themselves up to first place as a summer destination for the United States in 1992. In 1993, their budget came under fire as a new tax, which it really wasn't. It was a broad-based.

12:42 A 2% tax that went to tourism-related businesses and was passed through to the guests. A gentleman by the name of Douglas Bruce really spearheaded efforts to eliminate the tourism because he thought it was a tax that was not necessary. A quote from him was, it's not that we're against tourism, but the Rocky Mountains were here long before Colorado Tourism Board and will be here long, long afterwards. Surely the tourists will come.

13:09 The result of this in 1992 was an immediate drop in business. Colorado in one year lost 30% of their market share from the country. There was a $12 million cut in their budget. So basically the entire Colorado tourism budget went away. In a matter of just a few years, by 1994, they had slipped from number one in the summer destination to number 17 in just that short a time. The initial effect was that they lost $1.4 billion in the first year.

13:43 In direct spending. Longer term, in the later 90s, they lost up to $2.4 billion a year. So in the span of about four years, direct spending dropped over $10 billion to the state of Colorado. The tax implication of that was that the state and local taxes dropped by almost $200,000 as well. So that was just, again, not putting into the funnel, not getting out of the funnel. So we need to make sure that we continue to get people here to eat at our restaurants, to stay in our lodges.

14:09 And then funnel down through so that the government gets funded and so that our businesses stay in business. John, I just wanted to emphasize real quick, if I may, and correct me if my interpretation is incorrect. So basically what you're saying is the state of Colorado for a $12 million investment or something in that vicinity, $12 million resulted, by not spending that, resulted in a $2.4 billion per annum drop.

14:39 Correct. Okay. And I was part of, I was running the ski industry, the marketing for the ski industry in Colorado in 2006 when their budget finally got back to where it should be. We were, when I first got to Colorado, we had a $5 million tourism budget for the state of Colorado. My second year there, we ended up seeing a $19 million budget come back in. But the quote that's on here as well from Al White, who's the current director of the CTO of Colorado Tourism Office is, it's been 18 years since we went dark in 1993.

15:08 And we still haven't gotten back to the national market share we had. So that's 18 years. So I think that the idea of a short-term gain where they looked at it and it wasn't necessarily that they cut the budget, it just didn't get voted in, the $12 million savings resulted in huge loss, even if you just look at the tax base of $143 million loss. So the state of Colorado is definitely something we need to keep an eye on as an example. The title of the...

15:37 Of the study that was done by Longwoods International is, what happens when you stop marketing? The rise and fall of Colorado. And it fell hard. You know, to go from number one, get yourself all the way back up to number one, and to fall to 17 in just two years, that's a huge hit. That's a huge hit, and they still haven't recovered from it. On the flip side, Wisconsin is an example of a state that's just letting things pass them by.

16:02 Over the past few years, due to recession issues and budget cuts, they really have not increased their marketing budget, but they remain stagnant. And as you'll see on the next slide, this is a big mistake with their competitors or their next-door neighbors. Traveler expenditure in Wisconsin has dropped $700 million, and they've lost 15,000 jobs because of it, because they've stayed stagnant. Not even that they cut the budget, they just remain stagnant. Pure Michigan is probably why.

16:32 Back in 2009 when they were faced with severe budget cuts in Michigan, failing auto industry, and really just challenges with their budgets, they had to make some difficult cuts, and they cut throughout the state, but they ended up doubling the tourism budget to fund this Pure Michigan campaign. And if you open any magazine, turn on any TV station, you see the Pure Michigan campaign. As most of you know, I'm a diehard Red Sox fan.

17:02 Is sponsoring the Boston Red Sox TV broadcast. That's pretty crazy. You know, and amid that, Governor Granholm made the bold decision to do that, and what they've done is they've attracted 1.5 million additional visitors, about 680,000 of them they attribute to being brand new people to Michigan. And basically what it shows is that they're stealing the business from Wisconsin. Wisconsin decided not to pay attention, and Michigan swooped in and took the business.

17:29 They've seen a $622 million increase in visitor spending. That's direct visitor spending. With that, there's been an immediate infusion of $43.5 million in tax revenues. So back when they had to go make some cuts, they had some departments that they cut, and when they saw this $43 million, that's enough to pay for 839 additional state troopers and 844 new teachers. So the idea is that, again, keeping the funnel full lets us recover as quickly as possible.

17:57 And through that, they've also created 10,000 additional jobs within the state of Michigan. Our neighbors to the north had their budgets completely wiped out this year. The state of Washington eliminated their tourism office this year. It's to be determined just exactly what the impact will be up there, but chances are very good they will follow the same path that Colorado did, and that's not a good path. When that happened, we actually looked at it because of our air service with Alaska Airlines. It's a great opportunity to go into Seattle and encourage the folks from Seattle to come visit us.

18:33 Unfortunately, we didn't have enough funding to be able to do it properly. The state of Montana did. And Montana looked at it and said, the people that live in Washington have like activities as we have here in Montana. And if the state of Washington is not going to encourage them to come up and spend some time at Mount Rainier or ski at Crystal Mountain, we're going to invite them over to Montana. So across the state of Washington, Montana has popped up on billboards, advertising, bus wraps. They've really made a huge impact down there.

19:01 And they've really just gone in there and showed the scenery of Montana with a single word, Montana. Really, the idea is if they're not going to invite you to stay in your own backyard, come over and visit ours. Fox did a story down in Utah, and Utah's feeling that campaign because Montana has also stepped up their campaigns on I-80 and I-15 in Utah as well because of the fact that they see like-minded people within Utah that they can draw up to Montana.

19:29 And when we look at budgets and competition for market share increasing around us, it's evident that we need to stay competitive. We've been very aggressive in the last few years with our travel from the Bay Area. We've always been a strong draw from the Bay Area in the summertime, much more now in the wintertime with the three flights out of the Bay Area. And that's really affecting the folks up in Tahoe. We're getting a lot of comments from up there that we are actually making an impact on them.

19:55 The challenge we have right now is that Vail Resorts owns three resorts now up in Tahoe. KSL owns two. They're spending a lot of money in Southern California to help draw traffic past us and up to Lake Tahoe. Not to mention, if you've been in LA this winter, you see buses wrapped with messages for Aspen. Aspen has two flights a day direct from LA. We have a lot of competition out there, and we can't let it just go by. I think the last defining piece here is that we've actually had calls from Colorado businesses.

20:24 Ask them to advertise in our visitor guide. We've said no. The lesson here is we need to stay competitive or we stand to lose our market share. So lost market share equals lost direct spending in the community, and that equals lost tax revenue. In closing, really, the visitors pay for 70% of our town's services. Mammoth Lakes is the only agency with a primary goal to increase visitor numbers, TOT, sales tax for Mammoth Lakes.

20:53 And we do it universally without bias for everyone's benefit. Again, the fact that visitors to Mammoth Lakes account for 70% of our general fund is something we can't ignore and we need to keep that going into the funnel. Are there any questions? Thank you. Thank you, John. Thank you, John. Okay. We are now going to move into our second item. Staff?

21:25 At the end of this item, there will be an opportunity for anyone to ask questions, testify, et cetera, as we go through all of this. And I do apologize, you're seeing a lot of information that's brand new to you. This will not be the only time that you have to ask questions or discuss. Good evening, Council, Mayor, and the community. I'm just going to do a brief introduction.

21:55 And then turn this over to Mariana, which we have typically done. She's been our in-house consultant and expert in trying to get information to our other consultants who are here tonight. So I'd like to introduce those folks first. We have our team from Fulbright and Jaworski, Bill Greendyke and Zach Clement. These are the gentlemen who are legal advisors. And next to them is Scott DeVito. He's from FTI. He's done a lot of work for us on the financial side.

22:22 So Marianna's been doing the heavy lifting in town. I support that. That lifting is supported by these gentlemen from other areas. They're here this week to spend some time with us. We want to encourage community members to talk to us. We can certainly make some appointments if that's something that needs to happen, as well as attending some mediation, which will occur this Thursday and a bit on Friday. So thanks for joining us. Tonight Marianna's going to provide more detail.

22:50 On what our restructuring plan is about. We have been talking regularly about disclosing as much as we can and being as transparent as we can. We've recently learned that our hands are a bit tied because of the nature of the mediation process that we're encountering. So we really can't speak about that specifically, but we can talk about our new budget process a bit. We can disclose our restructuring plan. We can talk as much as we are asked about with that.

23:20 Huge level of detail. We also have long-term plans for stability over time. I think we are looking at at least a 10-year profile to carry this forward over a longer period. So I'll introduce Mariana, and feel free to ask questions as we go forward. Before you start, could I ask everyone to double-check and make sure that their cell phones are turned off? Thank you.

23:55 Mayor, Councilmembers, community staff, thank you. I have a number of slides to discuss with you tonight. We also have quite a detailed report that we copied for the community and those in attendance. The report will be placed on our website for everyone to see.

24:17 We apologize for not being able to provide this report ahead of time. As a matter of fact, we've had some technical difficulties. Email was down, internet was down, has been down. So we were able to finally publish the report right before the meeting. Let me go through the slides that summarize information in the report, and then I anticipate that we will take questions. Again, there's a lot of detail. This is one of the...

24:44 One of the first meetings that we allocated to the issue of budget balancing and the related issue of MLLA judgment. So let me go through the slides and then we'll open it up to questions. So what we'll talk about tonight is first and foremost an update on our baseline budget. You may recall that we started these discussions back in March.

25:13 Actually, back in February of this year, we continued through the months of March and April, and here we are in May continuing this discussion. This is a typical process for us to go through. It's a typical process for a town or a city to go through. I understand this city did not necessarily happen this way in prior years, but it is very typical for us to give you the baseline budget, i.e. the projected budget for next year early on.

25:41 Before the fiscal year actually begins in July, that's exactly what we're doing. What we're mainly going to be talking about is a budget reduction plan that we finally have in place on paper for the council's deliberation and the community's input.

26:01 Portions of that plan will be presented in mediation because pieces of that plan will impact the interest of parties, quote unquote, that we are going to be mediating with. But that plan will address the budget shortfall of 2.8 million. And that is the focus of tonight's presentation and future discussions. What that plan will also do is create an annual cash flow to satisfy a settlement with MLLA and others.

26:31 So as we go through this presentation and the detail available in the report, I will provide more details. We will also talk about the long-term forecast prepared by FTI and Scott Davido, one of the gentlemen that's with us today, is representing FTI.

26:52 Now let me recite some of the information and some of the facts that I presented before in previous meetings because I think it's important for context. First and foremost, we're facing a $2.8 million shortfall. In percentage terms, it's 14%. So if we had to cut across the board, every department, every employee, every program would have to take a 14% cut.

27:19 Why is that important? This is our baseline problem. It does not account for any payment to MLA, any other payments, any unfunded needs that we have. And I think it's very important to emphasize and overemphasize. I've tried to do a good job on this for several meetings now, but I think it's very important for us to understand that we have a problem. Forget about MLA. Forget about the writ of mandate that we have.

27:45 That was issued by the State Court. We have a baseline budget problem of $2.8 million, and that's what we need to correct first. The towns, why do we have a problem? Well, generally, the towns' available revenues are not sufficient to pay for all of our expenses. It's a structural issue that needs to be addressed for structural impacts.

28:08 The town already has a high level of taxation. We have a study underway that will show that we already have a very high level of taxes here in this town. And even if we wanted to impose new taxes or raised taxes, we cannot do that without voter approval. That's California state law. So this limits our budget balancing options to expenditure cuts. Now, as I will explain, as the report clearly...

28:38 illustrates we have made significant cuts over the last three years, and that limits the amount of cuts or the areas where we can cut today. Those prior cuts, which are detailed in this report and prior reports, for example, the April 18th report, have created what we call a bare bones organization. There's simply no easy place to cut. There's simply no easy cut for us to make.

29:10 Now, towns spending, and actually there's a word missing on the slide that I just noticed, towns spending on personnel is less than a third of the budget. That is not very typical. A typical city or town spends about two-thirds of their budget on personnel, 75%. In this town, it is only a third. And yet, since 2008, town employees have reduced their pay significantly.

29:37 Our calculations show that the net reduction compensation to some employees since 2008 has been 17%. In the current fiscal year, in the beginning of this year, we also began reducing payments to non-employee groups, including such essential services as tourism, housing, and transit. This fiscal year, they took nearly a 10% cut, and they may be cut even further.

30:05 The result of these cuts is an organization that is very low on staffing. We went from 130 positions to 80 positions, and our staffing is very low compared to other similar communities. We underfund our roads, road rehabilitation as well as maintenance. We underfund our vehicles, and we have insufficient reserves. Our future is even bleaker. There are studies that show nationwide that citizen towns face

30:34 Significant challenges in the future, and we're no exception. Our budget reduction plan is presented in an attachment, and I'll walk through details of that plan, but again, the plan focuses on $2.8 million shortfall. That shortfall is in the general fund.

30:59 It translates to a 14% shortfall and this shortfall occurs or is calculated after we take into account years of reductions that I just mentioned and before we consider a payment to MLLA on the $43 million judgment that is outstanding. The budget reduction plan will do three things. One, balance our next year's budget for 12-13. Two, create surplus funds.

31:26 To satisfy debts and obligations that are currently owed, including MLA's judgment. And three, put the town on a sustainable footing for future years. Now let me stop here and acknowledge the hard work that has gone into this plan. Again, the report speaks for itself. We'll talk about the specifics of the plan, but everyone in the town, including our attorneys, including our consultants, but...

31:54 Also, including our employees, work extremely hard to look inside their departments, to look inside their operations, to look at their compensation, and to develop a plan that we believe would meet those three goals. It's not going to be an easy plan. The deductions are not going to be easy to make, but it is a plan that is the result of that joint effort. The Towns Reduction Plan is presented in Attachment B to the report that you should have copies of.

32:25 So I encourage you to go through the judgment. It has a great level of detail. I will cover that plan in some detail, and I think once we reach the discussion stage of this meeting, we can talk about some specific questions. The plan generates 2.7 million in annual savings. These are annual, sustainable, ongoing savings. There are 14 discrete actions.

32:52 To both reduce expenditures and improve revenues. And I'll talk about revenues in a few minutes. Now this plan reflects the town's best judgment in balancing a number of competing factors. One is we need to fulfill our obligation to provide essential services to the community and to the visitors. We need to support our status as a destination community. We need to support our obligation to pay debts.

33:22 Including a judgment held by MLLA. And we need to allocate the town's resources as insufficient as they may be in pursuit of these goals. So what is in the plan? Let's walk through this. As you can see in a judgment B, we're seeking employee concessions from both civilian and sworn employees to generate $1 million in annual savings. Now most of our employees are in unions.

33:53 And they have contracts that are in place through year 2014. So we have to negotiate with them. We began that process. And in general, we're seeking a 10% reduction for civilian employees and a 24% reduction for sworn employees. Now, among the options available to employees to come up with those concessions, for the civilian employees, options do not include furloughs or position reductions.

34:21 For sworn police officers, position reductions are an option. We're not recommending a reduction of police officers. It's not part of our plan. However, if that reduction were to take place, the report clearly indicates what the impact would be from the loss of one or two or more police officers. Another reduction that is proposed in the balancing plan are lease payments, property lease payments. We have a lease for this property that we're in.

34:51 We have a lease for the police building, and we have a lease for the ice cream. We're proposing a 10% savings, a 10% reduction in those payments. Revenue enhancement. It's actually on the bottom of the plan, but I wanted to address it on this slide. Through enforcement of our transit occupancy tax, we estimate that up to 500,000 annually, approximately 5% of our TOT could be generated.

35:23 Recall that I mentioned a few slides ago that we cannot increase taxes or impose new taxes. So the only options available to us on the revenue end is enforcement. And we have been very active on the enforcement end when it comes to the hotel tax, or TOT, and we estimate that up to $500,000 annually in additional revenue could be generated through those actions. Now a portion of that revenue will go to MLT, Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

35:53 Mammoth Lakes Housing and ASTA because they share the TOT revenue that we receive. Now that brings me to reductions in those entities. We propose a 10% reduction to each of those entities on the amount, on the base amount that they receive. However, because they will get their 5% back from the additional enforcement revenue if it were to come in, their net reduction could be as low as 5%.

36:25 Departmental reductions. There are a lot of reductions proposed, as you can see on Attachment B, and I'll try to go through some of them, but not all of them. Maybe I'll highlight the major ones. There's a section called proposed departmental reductions that could generate up to a million in ongoing savings. Those reductions include the elimination of four positions outside of police. The positions are either vacant or expected to be vacant soon.

36:54 So we do not anticipate any layoffs, but that may occur. So if you turn to attachment B, the departmental reductions, and I'll just speak to the main ones, include, for example, across the board, across all departments, better control of overtime. We do not spend much money in overtime, but we do spend, and Cindy, correct me if I'm wrong, probably 500,000 annual across all departments right now.

37:22 Maybe higher. It seems to show that it's higher. We need to control overtime better. We are restricted to a certain extent by the provisions of the union agreements because they clearly specify when police officers or civilian staff earn overtime, but there are some things that we can do as managers to control overtime. So the overtime reduction is going to be the manager's responsibility, including the police chief, including the public works director, and so on.

37:49 Again, I'll just mention some of the major things. What you will also see as a major item is the elimination of the general fund subsidy for MLTPA. We currently have in place a $70,000 subsidy in the current fiscal year. We put it in place as a one-time measure. It's supposed to go away next year, so that's what the savings represent.

38:14 Another major reduction that you will see here concerns recreation where a position that was recently vacated is going to be eliminated and the counter functions for recently consolidated was financing community development. In parks maintenance we will also see some reductions.

38:37 In engineering, there will be reductions of nearly 60,000, and mainly what will happen here, our engineers basically work for free on a lot of the programs that they should be charging for. For example, programs funded by measures RMU, they provide engineering services to those projects that they do not bill for, and that cannot continue.

39:00 Snow removal, we're going to cut two positions, and portions of those positions are accounted for in the savings that you see. In some of the contract-related deductions, I skipped a few. We're proposing to cancel a few contracts that we currently have in place. One of them is a contract with Mono County for the animal shelter. Another contract is with Heisheer Energy Foundation.

39:32 Another contract is with state lobbyists, and those are all very, very, very important services. But again, our options in balancing this budget were extremely limited. We also, in community development, proposed to eliminate a position that was recently vacated so that vacancy will go away and that position will no longer be there. So those are departmental deductions. Lastly,

39:59 What you will see is that, and let me back up, I discussed during the last few meetings the fact that we're currently underfunding road rehabilitation, road repair, road maintenance. The condition of our roads continues to deteriorate. We should be spending approximately $1.5 million annually. That's the desirable level of funding to keep our road condition at the current level.

40:26 For the current budget, we included only a third of that funding, 500,000. For next year's budget, we propose to include 750,000. We're still not at the optimal level of 1.5, but we are funding half of the desirable level. This is not a sustainable level.

40:46 of funding for road rehab. However, as discussed with regards to departmental cuts, with regards to employee cuts, as you have seen so far, the cuts that we are proposing already are going to be extremely painful. They're going to be painful to the employees. They're going to be painful to the organizations that receive money from us, including tourism, housing, ESTA. They're going to be painful to the contractors, some of whom are going to lose their funding.

41:12 So we had to keep in mind that our options are limited. We had to keep in mind that we also need to create an annual surplus to address a settlement with MLLA. And it's along those lines that we made the decisions that we made. Now, FTI was retained because normally as cities and towns, and this is typical of most cities and towns,

41:41 We focus on an issue one year at a time. We do an annual budget. Some cities have a two-year budget, but most of us have a one-year budget, and that's the case here in this town. In order for us to create a plan, a budget reduction plan that is sustainable, that's not going to fail us tomorrow,

42:01 For the next year or five years from now, we needed a long-term forecast. We also needed someone who would bet on numbers, would come in with the experience in bankruptcy, and Scott Davido used to be a bankruptcy lawyer, and would tell us that, yes, your numbers are going to pass the test of time, that, yes, your numbers are sustainable, both the revenue projections and the expenditure projections, but also the balancing measures. So that's why FTI was retained.

42:30 Their analysis is presented in attachment C of the report. I am going to go through some highlights, but we're not going to address the entire analysis that is here. I'm sure in future meetings there will be opportunities for us to do so, or once we open it up to questions. Now, there are some important differences between what FTI is presenting in their report.

42:54 And what we do in an annual budget, the first difference that's not been listed on the slide is the format. The format may be a little unfamiliar to you because FTI's projections as typical for these purposes are cash-based. Ours mainly focus on the budget, which should approximate cash, but not always. And theirs are cash flow projections, so the format is slightly different. Their projections also include all funding sources.

43:22 Our focus has been on the general fund. That's our only unrestricted source of funding. Their focus is on all funding sources. Now, FTI had to stop moving their numbers at some point so that they could continue with the forecast. We will continue updating our numbers for the current year.

43:43 Through the end of June as well as next fiscal year as additional data become available, as additional revenues come in, additional expenditures get posted. So very soon our numbers may become different from their projection numbers in terms of the baseline. The projections will still hold and the annual surplus will still hold, but if you look at a particular department, their number may be slightly different from what is an FTI. In addition, and this is an important factor,

44:12 Because FTI looks at the totality of our budget, they mainly separate funds into restricted and unrestricted. Now, their unrestricted category includes more funding sources than just the general fund, and that's an important distinction. So if you were to look at our general fund projections and compare them to FTI's model, you won't be able to clearly see how they tie, but they do tie.

44:37 And lastly, FTI's model builds reserves from zero. Why is this important? We currently have in place approximately $1.8 million in the economic uncertainty reserve. We have in place a reserve for employee leave. We have in place a reserve for vehicle replacement, insufficient but still a reserve. FTI's model starts from zero, and they start building those reserves again.

45:03 They also have given us recommendations to build some additional reserves in addition to the ones that I mentioned. So that's what their model is. So what is the bottom line of their model? There are a lot of numbers in here. Some of you may not be comfortable with this level of detail. So the bottom line is this. After taking into account the measures that I just discussed, all of them, without excluding any of them, all those difficult measures, the FTI model estimates that

45:31 Over the five-year forecast period, we will generate some 3.6 million in net funds available. After the first five years, we will generate approximately 550,000 annually. So that's the bottom line. And that concludes my presentation. Mayor Dave, well let me ask if Dave or our consultants wanted to add anything that's important that I perhaps missed. No? Okay. Mayor, whichever way you'd like to handle this.

46:04 My thought is that we would just ask anyone to come up to the podium who has a question or a comment. And I believe that there may be some questions in general about future options. And you'll have to realize that some questions will be taken down but cannot be answered because they deal with the strategy for future litigation. But please understand that your questions would be taken down.

46:33 Please understand if the answer to you is, well, we can't really talk about that right now. I'm really glad that we are in a position now to bring forward what we have been struggling with for many months now of how to go forward in a sustainable manner. So just please come up to the podium and state your name. Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, I'm John Morris, Snow Creek Resort, Director of Operations, and I'm actually here.

47:02 Tonight, as the, representing the MLLA, that's the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association, just so we're not. I'm sure I get quoted properly. Councilmember Eastman last week said that I was preaching to the choir regarding supporting tourism, and what I'm hoping to do tonight, very briefly, is to preach more to the congregation. Just about the power of tourism. I mean, basically, it comes down to this. If you're going to have a party,

47:32 You don't start by making the food. You don't start by setting the table. You start by inviting your guests. And that's what we need to understand in this town is that tourism is everything we do. MLT's presentation clearly shows, and I'm sure there's plenty of data to back it up, that spending more money on tourism, not cutting tourism, is where we need to be. And I know it's a very difficult situation to be in because there are a lot of people that...

47:59 Unfortunately, may lose their jobs, their departments, they may be cut. But in the presentations we're looking at, what we're talking about is how we can save money on the bottom line.

48:08 And again, I want to reiterate, we need to be looking at what we can do to increase our revenues that come into the town. And the revenues that come into town are people. We need to get these visitors here. We need to increase those numbers on an annual basis. Those numbers alone increases. It should help pay for any deficit that we have and will create more sustainability. So the Lodging Association is behind Mammoth Lakes Tourism 100% in this effort. And we hope that the town and the council can...

48:36 Find a way to continue to fund Mammoth Lakes Tourism at a minimum of the current level. And let me make sure everybody understands that since Mammoth Lakes Tourism is funded by Measure A, especially in a year like this, the revenues for MLT are already going to be down approximately 20% for this year because of the weak snow year we've had. That means any further cut takes us down 20, 30, 40% in our tourism marketing.

49:06 At the presentation that John Urdi just did, that's a pretty scary prospect if we cut our tourism budget by that amount. So, again, the power of tourism in this town cannot be overstated, so please consider that. Thank you for your time. Appreciate it. Thank you, John. Yes, my name is Tim Albers. I'm the Lonel County resident and former owner of the Albers-Owns River Ranch Fly Fishing Resort. And I've been asked by several folks here in the community just...

49:40 Talk very briefly about the impact of fishing on tourism. And I know you've got a long evening ahead of you here, so this is going to be quick. But first of all, the fishing industry is a $2 billion industry in California, and some studies have shown that it's the eighth largest industry in the state. The Berkeley Tackle Company has identified the Southern California region of North America as the largest fishing market.

50:06 In the United States and in North America, all things considered freshwater, marine, and warm water fishing. I'm going to give you just a cross section here. We have many groups that have come to the Eastern Sierra, Mammoth, and Mono County fishing groups, fly fishing clubs, general fishing groups, and at the Albers Ranch we cater to six or seven fly fishing clubs every summer for about 20 to 25 years.

50:34 I'm just going to give you a cross-section of one of the clubs on a five-day stay at the Alpers Ranch. This is the Coogan Fly Fishing Group out of San Francisco. Their last trip was to the ranch in June of 2007. They stayed five days with 24 men. Their lodging was $8,470. Their catering was $4,900. Beverage, $1,181.

50:59 Expenditures in the little ranch store out there was $400 for a total of $14,047. Each one of them spent $150 at the fly shops in Mammoth and June Lake for a total of $3,600. All of them fueled and came to the restaurants over here for another $3,000 for a total of 24 men for five days, $20,647. That's $860 per person per trip.

51:25 If this, if a fly fishing club like this group, if this was held in Mammoth currently, this probably would be in excess of $30,000 because we gave very generous cabin rental because they returned each year. So there's probably, I would say, well over 100 of these retreats throughout Mono County. These are people that come in, they take care of the resource, they spend money, and they leave. I think, you know.

51:54 This is a tremendous resource. We've had a fishing program here in Mammoth for last summer. It was the 27th summer. So I encourage you to look at some of these numbers real hard. And, you know, I think we all need to think on a higher level, rise above our circumstances and say, hey, let's get on with it. Let's figure out ways how we can grow ourselves, polish our gym, and move past these tough times. Thank you very much. Thank you, Tim. Good evening.

52:29 I'm Mickey Brown. I'm here on behalf of the Planning Commission and also the Economic Stimulus Council. Council, as you know, the Planning Commission recently spent a lot of time revising Dr. SEDS, but the bad part about always using that acronym, I think we often forget what it stands for, and it stands for a destination resort community. When that plan was first enacted in 2009,

52:54 The significant overarching goal in that plan was to annually increase tourism, and one of the primary strategic issues was at that time, this was back in 2009, to truly fund and have a destination market organization. And the really great thing about the recent update we did is we really accomplished that with our Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

53:21 I know you're going through a very arduous process. I really appreciate all the detail that you've done. But in as much as I personally am very fond of some of our services and contracts, I really believe that we need to fund even more money into tourism. Every single person here in town lives on it. As you know, my primary day job, as now I call it, versus mine.

53:47 And one of the things that I frequently do on weekends during tourism is I hold open houses. Here's just one statistic for one person. Last winter, the winter of 2011, through my winter open houses, I met 66 folks. Those ultimately lead to contacts, prospects, and sales. This year, for winter 12, I only met 19.

54:17 Holding the same number of open houses. Just gives you an indication about what the rippling effect is when we don't have tourism in town. So I just would really encourage if there's any more money that we can eke out for Mammoth Lakes Tourism that we do it. And I also want the council and, as John would refer, the congregation to know that the Economic Stimulus Council is still working diligently with our grassroots movements to increase tourism this summer.

54:46 We've praised the best summer ever, and we've made the commitment to work on that all summer to do what we can to increase the revenue coming into town. Thank you, Mickey. Hello there. Cheryl Witherell. We wear many hats in Mammoth Lakes these days. I'm the general manager of 1849 condominiums. So I'm not only the general manager for a homeowner's association, but for also the rental company. I own a small business in town, Mammoth Kayaks.

55:22 Directly, directly, every day affected by tourism in Mammoth. It's a tough job that you have on your shoulders right now in the town. As I look at my budget and start preparing for my fiscal year, which is a small smidgen of the numbers that you're talking about here today, the one thing I'm not cutting is my advertising budget. In fact, for the last three years consecutively, it has increased by 10% due to the economic times.

55:51 Mammoth Lakes Tourism will be starting the fiscal year 2012-13 behind roughly 20%, mirroring a little bit what John Morris said. That dollar amount is really $350,000 to $400,000 in projected loss already this year. A further cut will surely result in a loss of TOT and sales tax revenue. There are no other departments. They're starting off with a natural drop.

56:20 To take another cut with the budget cuts, 5%, 10%, really makes no sense. This is an income source. Cutting an income source during these times will be a domino effect down the road. And I think the biggest picture here, and when you talk to people in the community, and I have reached out with being on the MLT board, is that really everyone will feel this, whether or not it's this year or it's three years down the road. Every individual, every second homeowner, every resident, every employee.

56:48 Every visitor, even in just the services that we offer. This is an area that we just can't stand a cut on, or we're going to feel it. Thank you. Thank you, Cheryl. I'm Ruth Harrell, a homeowner here in Mammoth Lakes. Thank you, Town Council and fellow Mammoth Lakes citizens. I'd like to emphasize the fact that we're here to offer some ideas and perspectives on solving the budget issues that face our community, not to criticize or be negative.

57:21 The lawsuit notwithstanding the town has been in a budget crisis for close to four years and will not recover unless bold steps are taken to change our direction. I love the fact that John Erdi's presentation had that slide with a bold move that was taken in the Midwest regarding the tourism dollars. It's an important thing to consider. Suggestions are evaluate the possibility of contracting with the Sheriff's Department for law enforcement. If it's already been studied, can the citizens learn the results?

57:51 And if it hasn't, why not? Reduce town departments even further than has been done already, which I see in the plan, at least in the slideshow, that that is being done. But such as assistant town manager, parks and rec director, or assistant housing director, community development, when activity picks up, we can contract for services rather than hire full-time employees with all the expenses that go with that. Definitely keep current levels of funding for tourism and even increase it since this is our major source of funding.

58:21 Tourism is the economic engine of Mammoth Lakes. We cannot afford to cut in this area if we are to increase the revenue. Consider disincorporation as a town. Years ago in 1984 when the town incorporated, too much of our property taxes were given away in the deal. This left us even more dependent on T.O.T. than anything else. This position is particularly vulnerable in low T.O.T. years.

58:48 If the town were unincorporated, the county would be obligated to spend more of our property taxes paid on services and facilities within the Mammoth Lakes area. Occasionally, small towns disincorporate when they become fiscally insolvent. For example, Cabazon in 1972. Bankruptcy is certainly an option and restructuring of the town. I believe these last two ideas are compatible and can include all of the above when restructuring.

59:16 I'd like to emphasize one more time to definitely keep levels of funding for tourism and even increase it. This is our major source of funding. Other municipalities have gone through this crisis, have done it successfully and continue today. We have the opportunity to move into the future with a new perspective and let's make the most of it and be proactive. Thank you. Thank you, Ruth. I had a whole speech prepared but I come to just want to.

59:57 Share just a couple of items from this document, and this is a document of the city of South Lake Tahoe, and this is their budget document that they have for the year of 2011, and the town council accepted what they put in here, and they have some major, major, bold steps.

1:00:19 One of the first things that they say right in their document is that the current city organizational model is simply not financially sustainable. They say that right in their document. I mean, I would like to see our city start to take a look at our sustainability because what I just heard and what Marianna just was talking about was a lot more smoke and mirrors of other budgets that we've heard. Oh, we're going to project these revenues. These revenues may come in.

1:00:47 But they have not come up. And then we find ourselves in a deeper hole, in a deeper hole, in a deeper hole, and it's just been going on. Now one of the very bold moves is they did right-size the organizational structure through the elimination of department director positions. So they eliminated assistant city manager, community development director, redevelopment of housing director, park and recreation's assistant director.

1:01:15 A police captain, a division fire chief, a recreation supervisor, and eight-line staff for an annual savings of $1.8 million. 57% came from management positions. So I can go on in this document, and this is really a good document because something else that Marianna was talking about was not funding roads.

1:01:42 That was one thing they added to their budget was to make sure that they did fund their roads because they had postponed road repair. And they knew that if they kept postponing it, they were going to have a problem. So they added to that. And I think adding to our tourism budget. So if anybody would like to see this document, and I'd love for all the councilmen to read this document and staff and see what they said and how they managed their budget, taking, I believe, a true

1:02:10 Honest look at their budget and make bold steps. Thank you very much. Thank you, Maureen. Good evening. Good evening, Mayor and Council members. Thank you for taking the time to listen to this community. You know, I really, just a note on South Lake Tahoe. I don't know if that's South Lake Tahoe, California, or Nevada, since they do have separate...

1:02:45 Thank you. Separate governing issues, and if you were on the Californian side, you can see that there's a lot of issues that are there, but tourism is not growing there at all, and a lot of the cuts that they have made have not stimulated the economy at all, and they have a very large hole in the ground with a convention center that hopefully is coming out of bankruptcy soon. So what I think the lesson is there, cuts don't necessarily mean that it'll get you to a level that you can grow and rebuild.

1:03:13 I've been on the road for the last month working on tourism and working with the Mammoth Lakes Tourism and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area in ways that are reminiscent of many, many years ago. And what John's presentation was talking about is really hard to envision until you've seen what the effect of cutting out dollars that you think for a mature industry that it can survive on.

1:03:42 Where it is now and those things go away. The minute we stop supporting tourism for today, we won't feel it today. We'll feel it in 2013, 2014, clear to 2020. And there's no better example again not to pick on hard times at what was an organization called Colorado Ski Country. At significant trade shows which hosted tour operators from all over the world,

1:04:13 There's one major trade show. It's called Travel America Industry Pow Wow. And for many years, I have attended this particular show. I've attended over 20 of them, and many people in this room have attended them as well. There was always this formidable presence called Colorado Ski Country, and their presentation was twice the length of the wall there. It was all blue and white, and they were skiing.

1:04:41 It was very formidable. Nobody could, and the people that came there really knew that this is where you went for skiing. This year I went, and I had not attended this particular show in a while. But Colorado's ski country is gone. So the cohesive presence that they have in the industry is now left to individual business owners to push this. Their presence not only in the marketplace is diminishing, but it's ripe for the taking right now.

1:05:09 This is the first time that our presence has been stronger and more cohesive in the state of Colorado, and we're proud of that. I would like that to not go away, because this is the only dollars that you invest that you actually get something back. The other services, you will spend the money to keep those services going, but there's not a return. Tourism is the only thing that you get a return. You get it through TOT, but you also get it through...

1:05:38 Additional jobs, additional revenues, more people coming to town, more people needing housing, more people buying houses. Take them up the ladder of being a visitor, being a frequent visitor and a loyalist, to being a resident. And that's how you get a sustainable community here. So if you think that you can disconnect these particular areas and not have it affect the other, it's a domino effect. And you can look at it.

1:06:08 Through the eyes of the others and see where it's working and where it's not. We have recently participated very heavily through the state of California through what is now a new program. Most people didn't know, and I didn't know this, that the United States did not have a singular branding message. There is now an organization, the federal government is funding tourism to where there is a brand USA message that goes all over the world.

1:06:38 And plays not only in our marketplaces, but plays throughout the country. California's featured very prominently in there. And you can see us in there. It's because we worked for that. They didn't choose us. We had to work to get it. And those were the things that I think the community is working harder than it ever has. And now's not the time to pull the rug out from under it because we've made significant ground.

1:07:02 In the last two years, by working smarter, taking advantage of technologies that we never did before, and it's beginning to pay off, we're at the bottom right now, and it's moving up. So let's continue to keep moving forward. Thanks. Thank you, Rhonda. Good evening, council staff. I also wear a lot of hats in this town, as so many of us do.

1:07:37 I'm on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. I'm a recreation commissioner, and I'm a small business owner. I have a rental agency. And a couple questions to start with. Marianna, are all these documents online because there wasn't anything back there so that we can find out exactly the numbers? We don't yet. Our e-mail and internet has been down, so as soon as it goes back out, we'll post them online. Okay. Sounds good. Thank you.

1:08:06 Are the documents that we looked at tonight that you discussed, is that just taking a 10% cut across the board? No. We began with a 10% cut approach after we looked at the history of cuts that left us bare bones, but we also allowed each department, each function, to tell us what the impacts of that 10% cut would be.

1:08:37 Okay. You know, I guess, you know,

1:09:04 Yes, this is government, but government needs to look at itself as a business. And, you know, I was at a commission meeting earlier and Tony Colasire and I were talking and it's like, you know, okay, if you have a business, what's your product? Our product is Mammoth Lakes. It's the recreation, it's the beauty, events that go on within our community. And that's what we have to offer. That's what we have to sell. What is the next thing you need to do is you need to sell that product.

1:09:33 How do you sell that product? You need to, as John Morris said, as John Urdi said, you need to invite the customers. You need to market that product. Without a marketing, it doesn't matter what product you have. It isn't a matter of if you build it, they will come. We have to market that product to stay. It's constantly putting your name out into...

1:09:55 The public eye and so that we stay on everybody's forefront and their thoughts and their vacation choice and that type of thing. At the beginning of the season, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, as did the rest of the town budget, took a 10% cut right off the top because that was how the budget was being balanced originally. So through the attrition of a poor winter, Mammoth Lakes Tourism has taken an additional 20%.

1:10:23 So now if we're looking at cutting that again, you're taking the only ability to build this community to get the word out that Mammoth Lakes is still functioning, still open, and still a viable vacation community and opportunity for your recreation needs and everything else. That needs to be out there more than ever. And so this isn't the time to cut something like that. I grew up here. I graduated from Mammoth Lakes, from Mammoth High School.

1:10:52 I used to live here. We didn't have the hospitals that we have now. There was originally not a high school here when I originally moved here. So through our tourism, we have now a community that you have folks that want to come up here and retire. You have folks that want to come up here and live because we have the infrastructure that they come to enjoy. And how do we get that infrastructure?

1:11:21 Through our tourism dollars. And so it's something that we always need to keep in mind. I know John's presentation said that a high 60% was a direct tourism job. 100% of the jobs in this community are touched by tourism. It's a trickle-down theory. I don't care if you're an attorney. I don't care if you're, you know, what job you're in, school teachers, hospital workers, anything.

1:11:49 If there weren't tourism in this town, we wouldn't have the number of jobs. The jobs wouldn't continually increase and grow. And so, you know, in this time, I guess, and the reason I asked Marianna if we just did a 10% cut, we need to look at a true restructuring. We need to start from the base of business. What does that business structure look like? What do we need to accomplish? How do we accomplish that? And it's not just a straight percentage.

1:12:18 And, you know, as John Morris said last week, it affects all of us. All of us have friends or neighbors or that work within this community. I personally have taken about a 40% cut in salary and, you know, insurance and you want to add, you know, it can kind of keep going on and on and everybody in this community has because that's private business that's having to balance their budget.

1:12:45 And so we look within to say where can we adjust those items. And I think that's what the town staff needs to do. I know there's still a lot of things within the budget that could possibly be adjusted. Thank you. Thank you, Terry. Hi, Tom Cage, local business owner. I'm going to expand on some of the things Terry touched on. 05-06 peak year.

1:13:22 Town was doing the most business it's ever done. The economy, we all know what happened to it. Things dropped. Give or take 40%, some would argue. But value of real estate, total retail dollars. 10-11, big snow year, we started to see a rebound. This year, we're going to probably be off in the 25% range. Some might be a little more, some might be a little less. But keeping in mind that this year,

1:13:50 Was a drought year consistent with 76, 80, and 90. The difference was we had snowmaking. 90, 91 they had some snowmaking, but this year they had a lot more. The difference was we had a marketing department. The difference was we were more aggressive with air service via the mountains, expansion into that, and subsidy of that. So being off only 25% this year, I think most of us that have been here a while accept it and...

1:14:18 Appreciate only being off that much because it could have been a lot worse because in 76 and 80 when it didn't snow, we were all standing around doing Zippo business. So we're so close, right? We start to last year dig out of the economy. We start to have some good success with marketing. This year we took a little bit of a hit because it didn't snow. But we took less of a hit than we would have had we not had air subsidy, had we not had marketing departments.

1:14:48 Both in town and on the mountain to the extent that we have. Those organizations can do more than individual businesses. That's no surprise. It's a concerted, coordinated effort, a pool of money, so to speak. Now there's a lot you can't tell us and a lot you can't go into. On page 5, our budget reduction plan will balance the fiscal year budget 12-13, create a surplus of funds to satisfy debts.

1:15:15 And obligations currently owed, including MLLA. On the back page, the bottom line after taking into account measures for the general fund, the models estimate additional surpluses. So it estimates $3.6 million over a five-year forecasted period funds will be generated. And after a five-year, it looks like $550,000 in annual savings or annual funds available, if I read that right. So very responsible.

1:15:47 You've looked at the whole basket of things, and you have been goal-oriented towards balancing and dealing with the MLLA. So there appears, based on these comments, that there is some extra money there. I would advocate that you shouldn't cut marketing. You should increase marketing. You should increase it now. You should increase it based on these comments on page 5 and the last page.

1:16:16 If not in this immediate next fiscal year, but a plan over the next five years to increase it so that it can deal with the things that we have coming up. Those things, whether they're a municipal bankruptcy, you're going to need to handle that marketing-wise. That's a PR issue. Monies need to be devoted to that if that's the way the town goes. If the town doesn't go that way and you settle with MLLA,

1:16:45 For whatever amount, whatever terms, that's a PR marketing need you need to address. You must address. For those of you that are in business, you're talking to people just like I do all the time. Bankers, friends, customers, insurance people. Their first questions are not like in 1980. Their first questions were, those earthquakes. Now their first questions are, what about this lawsuit? Is the town going to go broke?

1:17:15 What about LADWP and the water district? Are you going to have water in the future? Those are the first two questions on any business level for major development, for bankers. It's not good. That's why this needs to be dealt with on a PR basis once you have everything wrapped up in a pretty little box with a bow on top of it. That's why you need more marketing dollars because you will need to coordinate with John Urdi's office.

1:17:44 A PR campaign once you get all this wrapped up. That's why you need to put more money into them. Rumors are worse than reality most of the time. And they cause and create, what do I do next? Oh my God, the sky is falling. They cause all these effects in people. I won't invest my money. I won't buy a condo. I won't do this. I'll wait and see what happens. That's what we're living within right now. And it's hurting the community.

1:18:15 It's hurting, I'll wrap up. It's hurting where we go as a community, and we need to get this wrapped up and done with. Whichever way council and the advisors direct you, we're all going to have to live with it. We voted you in, we put you in place, we all hope you make good decisions, but you've got to get this done. The rumors are killing us. The time that this is taking, the extra interest that is accruing on this debt.

1:18:43 One way or another, please get this done. The devil's in the details. I understand all that. But it looks like, based on page five and the last page, the comments that are made here, it looks like you've got a little bit held back. Use that little bit held back responsibly planned over the next period of time. This talks about five years and this talks about at the end of five years to make sure that we increase

1:19:12 The PR and marketing, which are the same but slightly different, as we all know, dollars so that we can emerge from all the things going on and be a better, stronger community. But you've got to push the button. Get it done. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Hello. Stacy Schaubmeyer from the Alpenhof Lodge. Sitting here listening to everybody, especially MLT and the Mammoth Lakes Lodging Association, which I am a part of,

1:19:53 Something kind of crossed my mind that made me realize why we don't want to cut our tourism dollars. None of our properties are 100% occupied 100% of the time. They're not 80% occupied. We have rooms available for people to come to. Our property has people coming from other countries. And I have the available resources that give you 13% for everything I sell.

1:20:22 That comes from my marketing dollars, and most importantly, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. Thank you. Thank you. Ted Carlton with the sheet. In your presentation, you talked about a 10% employee concession. Is that for management, all employees, or just for the rank and file? The savings that we included in the plan suits the employees. Okay, thank you.

1:21:02 Hello, Mark Margulies. I have a lot of hats in this town, too. Father also have a business, do a lot of laundry in town, so we definitely need a lot of tourists to dirty sheets and towels so we can do more laundry. Another business I do, because I don't make enough money in the laundry business because of the cuts that have happened all over the world, is I am in the movie business. And has anybody seen a movie in the last...

1:21:31 Month. Raise your hand. Okay. A few people have seen a movie. Anybody seen a movie up there? Anybody seen a movie? Do you think they market movies to get you guys to go see the movie? Yes, they put millions of dollars. So put more money in the marketing. That's what I'd like to say. Put more marketing money in Mammoth.

1:21:55 The movie business would love to come up here and make movies up here, too, and they spend a lot of money. Thanks. Thank you, Mark. Good evening, my name is John Wentworth. What I'm hearing from people speaking tonight is a growing, emerging consensus among entrepreneurs and businesses in the community of how are we getting out of this and what the future is going to look like.

1:22:26 And I just want to make sure that we all understand that the marketing getting the word out there is critical and it's vital. We've heard very good reasons why that really matters. Let's not forget that the voters voted twice in back-to-back elections by two-thirds votes to secure the resources to invest in the product that John Urdi and all of us are going to sell. There is a compelling product without investing in it that we have in Mammoth Lakes right now.

1:22:56 I just got done with the Measure U Committee on Monday. The Measure R Committee, the Measure R process goes on. The product development will not stop. And we're all working together here to find a way to get to the future that we know we're going to get to. Tom Cage, I think, made a lot of very good, obvious points. But I think let's absorb this pain, get it ingested, get it into our system.

1:23:22 But let's all start getting together and working together to do whatever restructuring has to get done, whatever entrepreneurial initiatives and efforts we have to do to get to the future that, again, the voters have already said we are investing in this place. As far as I know, MLLA doesn't get their hands on you or are. That's $1.6 million a year investing in this place. So let's keep doing what we've been doing. Let's keep moving forward. Thank you. Thank you, John.

1:24:01 Hi, my name is Ligosh. I agree with everybody else that the money should be put into tourism. That is our service area and we need to cater to our guests that come in. Each one of us can participate in our own way. One way is the Mammoth Insider. When I go to Reno, I take a whole bunch of them and I leave them in all the doctor's offices, wherever I can put them. When I'm at Costco and people sit in the parking lot with them, they ask me for them in the parking lot.

1:24:27 So each one of us can volunteer and take them to places where we're going to visit and leave those mammoth inciders. And another one that I'm very passionate about keeping is our police officers. I'm very concerned. Where I live, I've had people jump my fence. When I call the town up, they tell me that people don't know the geographic of my area. Come on, it's a six-foot fence. I know better. It scares the crap out of me. This summer, or this winter, there were some gunshots in my front yard.

1:24:57 I found the bullet casings in my front yard. You know, I'm starting to get afraid where I'm at, and I want our police officers. I want to feel that I am safe where I live. I live in Sierra Valley sites. The first 10 homes get affected by all the bars when they close. We have 80 liquor licenses in town. Our officers are always, if you eliminate them, they're going to be less effective. We're not going to feel as safe, and they're not going to be safe anymore either.

1:25:24 Because they're not going to be able to help us anymore. Because they have to be up where the bars are. You know, we do have a lot of bars. And I'm concerned about our youth in our area, too, because they are our future leaders. If you cut out the bike rodeo thing and the school officer and the DARE, how are we going to educate our kids for the future? They need help. So please don't eliminate the officers in the Sierra Valley Sites area.

1:25:51 I mean, the stakes are always bad. They stole the speed limit sign this weekend. We need help out there. Please do not eliminate our officers and put more money into the marketing. Thanks. Thank you, Lee. I'm presuming there are more people who just haven't got their legs stretched out yet. Okay, as I mentioned before, we are heading into the season, and there will be many more opportunities to ask questions, provide input.

1:26:41 Just to remind everyone, in addition to these documents being on the website, there are frequently asked questions about the whole process that we're going through. There's an email address if you want to email a question. There's also a phone number to call if you have questions to ask. So we want to hear what we can from you. John. Madam Mayor, I'd like to make two statements. The first one is,

1:27:10 Not only the people that spoke tonight, but particularly the people that did speak, but also those people in the audience, the people that came to this meeting tonight because they're concerned about the situation. If you look at those people who spoke and the people that are in the audience, this is our community. These are people that didn't come here out of curiosity, but people that came here because they participate in Mammoth Lakes.

1:27:37 In a number of areas, I was going to make a couple of comments. We have a young lady here this evening, John, who's a condominium manager. We have John Morris. Both of them are on a committee. And they, as well as their committee, put together the effort, and it took several months, and I forgot to mention Terry Stalick as well, but these people put together the effort to generate

1:28:05 To the enforcement of transient occupancy tax or the bed tax. And that's the benefit of their efforts and town staff as well. But that benefit, we're budgeting $500,000 this next year. And $500,000, a portion of that will come to the organization. But also, I think it was $173,000 or $193,000 will go to Mammoth Lakes Housing.

1:28:32 Go to tourism and also to transportation. So that effort by these individuals, basically a handful of individuals, resulted in a significant enhancement in our revenues for this next year. Just wanted to point that out. The second thing that I wanted to mention, and at the risk of beating a dead horse, because if you heard a number of people speak tonight, it was there in almost every person who spoke about it, and that is the importance.

1:29:02 of the TOT or the bed tax. And whether it's TOT or sales tax, the revenues, the combined revenues from those two that come to the community from the visitor, you know, it takes marketing. It takes marketing to get the visitor in town. Once that visitor gets into town and rents a room and pays for that room year-round, winter and summer, but particularly in winter, that generates

1:29:33 You know, almost 70% of what we have in the community to spend. So I just wanted to emphasize or reemphasize, if you will, the importance of bringing visitors to our community through marketing. Thank you. Thank you, John. Any other comments? I have a couple. I kind of wanted to reflect a little bit what John and the rest of me said as well. But a few things that did ring out with me in addition to just marketing.

1:30:01 The fact that we're, you know, 300 miles.

1:30:30 From a major city is another key factor that makes us very different from other communities, and I think that's what's so important. John used a very good analogy, and I think it's that, you know, it's like a funnel. You have to keep pouring in, in our case, visitors and people in order for everything else underneath that to survive. Some people may have a particular department or an item or a recreation or whatever it is that they like to do that they feel is so important.

1:31:00 As we all do. But what happens at the end of the day is all of those things are dependent on folks coming here. So if there's one thing that's important to you, whatever it may be, it's all going to be dependent on getting our visitors here. So I want to thank all those people that did speak up on the behalf. And I would also like to thank those folks that have stepped up on the TOT enforcement. Again, part of Mammoth Lakes Tourism was the...

1:31:30 Really helping along with staff and lodging and whatnot to get that program together. We really haven't had a solid program that had the facilities in place to really collect these uncaptured revenues for really ever. And it was a combination of these efforts that did help that happen. So I want to thank them as well. Thank you, Matthew. I do want to make a couple of comments.

1:32:01 I don't want to have them seem gratuitous. First of all, you know, we talk about restructuring and, you know, we use the term. I'm not sure that a lot of people have the same or everyone has the same view of what that actually means, but I point out a couple of things. We have begun a restructuring process long before what we proposed or what we...

1:32:31 Are going to be doing over the next several weeks and months. We have effectively outsourced tourism. We've outsourced housing. We've outsourced transit. And we have outsourced on individual departments a number of functions that used to be town functions. We had 130 employees. We now have 80. As you can see, we're going to go down by another six if our plan is

1:33:00 is adopted at the time of the budget in June. And so these are not novel ideas, nor are they new. This is an evolving process. Second, the fact is that we identified in 2009, before the council at that time, that we were suffering from a structural deficit. Well, it came to a head this year for a couple of reasons.

1:33:29 Not the least of which is the dramatic decline in revenues because of the low snow year. Even if we had had a good snow year, we would still be in a structural deficit. We would have one. That's what we're trying to change. Three, restructuring, it seems to me, requires some changes in our thinking about what the role of government, what the function of government should be.

1:33:58 Having said that, by July 1 every year we're required to adopt a budget which is balanced. So the immediate issue for us is to balance a budget. So we know that we have lower revenues. We have therefore had to approach the balancing process by cutting because we can't raise revenues and we can't print money. So I see this actually as a first step.

1:34:27 I heard a couple of folks allude to the fact that perhaps management positions could be cut. I would suggest that the town put up on its website, if it doesn't have it already, its list of employees as well as the chart, who reports to who and how many managers we have. I can guarantee you we've got fewer than we had last year.

1:34:56 And we've got, we had last year fewer than the year before. Now I'm not suggesting that we have not made or cannot make more cuts. I'm not suggesting that we can't do business differently. What I am suggesting, as Mariana, I thought so eloquently stated, is that this isn't the first round of cutting. For this council, this is the third round of cutting.

1:35:22 And if you add all of the cuts together, they're in excess of $7 million over three years. So there are a whole lot of folks who have already lost their jobs, and there are a whole lot of services that have been impacted, and there will be more. Finally, what I want to get to are two thoughts that have sort of come from or emerged from what I've heard tonight. And by the way,

1:35:47 It is difficult to argue with what anyone has said tonight. I think that if you were to poll the council members, you would find everybody in exactly the same frame of mind as those who have spoken tonight. But it seems to me that what this community needs to examine with respect to tourism is this. And I didn't hear it tonight, and I'd like to have the debate. And that is, what role should the government play in the promotion of itself and its product?

1:36:17 What I mean by that is what should the relationship be between government and the money that it throws through tax dollars and the private sector that benefits directly and indirectly? I ask the question because I think that initiates the debate. Second, what is the importance of investing in our product? John Wentworth, I don't know where you are. There you are.

1:36:43 But I was happy to see you speak up because I had written it down, which is that if you invest heavily and mightily, as we should, in attracting people to come to this community and they run through potholes or the snow isn't cleared or the streetlights don't work or the police don't come or the bike paths aren't fixed.

1:37:07 And either open in the winter for people to walk on the sidewalks or are available in the summertime to ride bikes and travel on safely, then you haven't provided the visitor experience that you've advertised. And I'm not suggesting that we don't do those things. What we heard tonight, for example, on roads is that we have grossly underfunded our roads, which would be more expensive in the future. It's just an example of what it is that we need to do once we bring the folks here, because you can see the mountains in the pictures.

1:37:35 And you can certainly see the advertising, but we've got to provide them with a quality experience when they get here, and the government should play a role in investing in that as well. So all of the comments, I think, are consistent with the things that we've been laboring over the past weeks and months. The five of us represent differing and broad constituencies. We're hearing the same thing.

1:38:01 These are very tough times. We haven't got enough money. But this seems to me to be not the first step but the next step in moving forward in a way that will have this community be more sustainable than it ever has been in the past. Thank you. Thank you, Rick. Skip. What a mess. It's a total mess. The restructuring that we're doing tonight is to

1:38:29 For myself, I think I owe everybody in this town an apology for not having this thing.

1:39:00 I grew up in a...

1:39:27 This meeting is, you know, we're talking about restructuring, but I think what is on everybody's mind, again, is the lawsuit. And I have a little trouble moving forward with a lawsuit until we address some of the issues that got us into this lawsuit. And if we don't do that, I think we are in probably a bigger, we may have a bigger problem down the road. I was brought up that bankruptcy is not good for anyone.

1:39:58 And call it foolish pride if you want, but I don't really want to be known as the resort town that declared bankruptcy. I would like to try to avoid that if at all possible, if at all possible. But there are some issues that have sort of been avoided for a long time that people haven't, we're not talking about it. We're planning for the future and that's good.

1:40:21 We've got a positive outlook, an idea of which direction to go and some things to do. That's good. I agree with the marketing that we need to keep that up. I agree with what Rick said, you know, about making sure we're not doing smoke and mirror marketing, that we're not bringing people here and then they find things aren't really what they thought they were going to be. But a number of issues that have been on my mind for a long time is

1:40:48 At what point does a town take responsibility for its actions, for what it did to get us into this mess that we are in right now? Our people. They're people just like us. They're not some big ugly monster out there chomping down on our town. They did not determine the amount of this lawsuit a jury did in Bridgeport. They are just the recipients of it. Is it fair? Probably not.

1:41:22 Does it need to be negotiated? Absolutely. To the minimal. To what we can get it down to. But they're not the bad guys. We've been told three times by a judge that our actions were wrong. That we made mistakes. That we shouldn't have conducted our business the way we conducted our business. And I think we need to find out why and what that is. Based on the tone, some of the letters that MLLA has been

1:41:52 Sending back and forth. I think they're getting mad. I think they're really mad. And I don't think that's a good thing to have happening right now. I think we need to talk to them. You know, I will personally, respectfully ask that MLLA participate in this mediation, and I hope they will in some form.

1:42:16 Come up here and talk and work with us. This could be our last chance to get something solved. So I would invite them to come up and participate in this mediation. If you think about it, all along the way, we have been listening to the experts. We have listened to the experts since day one, and with all due respect to the gentlemen that are joining us tonight, the experts in this town are sitting right here in front of you. There's five of us.

1:42:45 You elected us to make the decisions that need to be made to get this town out of this mess. We know this town better than anybody. We have a lot of smart minds up here. Personally, I think you need to lock the team from MLLA, this council, and our town managers in a room and say, don't come out until you find a solution. Sit down and figure it out. We need to wrap this thing up.

1:43:14 We can't keep it going for another six months or a year or whatever it may take to get out of this. We've got to wrap this thing up. I was at the Knowles Homeowners meeting two Saturdays ago, and there are two things that I think are important that the people of this town want to know about. They want accountability for what has happened, why did it happen, and they want to make sure that we have taken steps to make that it doesn't happen again.

1:43:48 Thank you.

1:44:20 If they see a letter that could be a deal killer, it doesn't get buried, but it gets to the right people, it gets to the town council, it gets to the town managers, it gets to the people that have to know about who is supposed to, who was down there at that time doing it? You know, who made sure that we got the facts? You know, I don't know. It was missed somewhere along the line. That does not seem acceptable in my book.

1:44:51 I don't think we bought the airport with a plan of, hey, let's try and get air service in 12 years. I think we wanted it a lot sooner than that. But the airport has been mired in bad decisions, bad choices, lawsuits, be it our fault, environmental, whatever. We've lost them all. I don't think we've won a single lawsuit down there. It just...

1:45:22 Who is there? Who is watching after our best interest down at the airport? I don't know about the rest of our community, but I, for one, am tired of watching our most important asset, the airport, being managed in a mediocre form. I'm tired of it. It needs to change. It's got to change. And that's what this is all about. It's changing what started all this to begin with.

1:45:51 We can plan for the future, but if we don't change what caused us to get into this position, then we're going to be right back in it again. You know, if you want an example, this lawsuit hadn't even cooled from the final judgment from the Supreme Court of California before the airport was trying to hire an unqualified person to take a position because they had the future of being related.

1:46:23 To an important person. That could have been another lawsuit. Luckily, Marianna stepped in while she was acting as town manager and made a do-over. But to me, that says just, I can do what I want, you can't touch me, arrogance. It's got to change, folks. We've got to make those changes. I don't want to see this town go backwards. We simply can't go backwards.

1:46:52 We're on a good roll. We're getting things moving. But I don't think we can get out of this problem without the help of the people. I think we're going to need some kind of a measure to get out of this to help us move forward. And it's going to take some kind of a tax on the people, an entertainment, an admissions tax, something that will bring the people,

1:47:22 Bring it forward. It will also bring the mountain, Mammoth Mountain, in on this to help get us out of it. It just seems like something that has to be considered. It simply has to be considered. You can't have your cake, which would be all of your amenities that you need to make the town work, and eat it too, which would be the marketing and promotion of our town that we need. We've gone through the budget. We've gone through it

1:47:51 Many times over. And there's only so much money. We need to generate some revenue. We can continue to cut, but we need to generate some revenue to help get us out of this mess that we're in. I don't know what else to say, but I think we need help. We need a lot of help to get out of this. And I plead with the people of this town to at least give it some consideration, something that will get us going. I know it irks you.

1:48:25 To maybe have to pay for something that you had nothing to do with and that you probably could see should never have happened. But things are what they are. But we all love our town. We all do. That's why we're here. That's why we put up with the weather and the adversities that we put up with. We love it here. And I think we need to pull together and help get us out of this mess that we're in.

1:48:57 I realized that most of this meeting was to introduce the fiscal side of it and that that's going to take some work. I realized that we did not get any questions about the process and I also forgot to offer our legal counsel if there were any comments, general comments that they wanted to make this evening. No? Okay. All right. I thank the community in advance or actually for all the

1:49:28 Interest that you've shown so far, I beg you to stay with it and look through this financial data and really understand it and recognize the fact that we're having to balance providing a level of essential services with an obligation that we must do something with. There is a lot of information in here. I'm not going to repeat what everyone else said because I'd like to get everybody home before dark.

1:49:57 But I do thank you for your input. I thank those of you who spoke tonight. I thank the numerous people in the community that are a part and extension of our government and what council can do through the advisory bodies we've put together, the commissions, etc. It is going to take all of us to work through this and get out of it. And I'm not always the eternal optimist, but I do believe that we will have a solution.

1:50:23 It has to balance all of those things, and there are a lot of tough decisions that this council has made and will continue to make, and the best way for us to have a balanced approach to that is to have you speak out. So I'll again repeat, you can email the town, you can call me, I'll come talk to your groups or whatever, you can call any of us, we will share everything that we can and continue to update you as often as possible. With that,

1:50:54 We will adjourn to the regular meeting of May 16th.