TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2012

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 5 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

378 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:21 How do you figure out how to do that? How do you get it there? Well, unfortunately, the good reader to the boss is, I pull it down on my feet, change the name, because it'll get everything by the same name, and then email it to myself on my Gmail. Yes. It should, it should. It should be a book. The only thing.

1:56 Yeah, my building is great. Yeah, there's a bunch of different ones, yeah. But it does think they have success from making this one individually. Absolutely. Because if you pull them directly, it's really hard. Which is a metaphor, you know, so you can't figure out what you're doing. Well, this is pretty good.

2:24 So you're going to... Where is that? Do you see any access? What's up? Do you see any access? Yeah, our website. We don't use the... Well, I haven't had the iPad until they gave me, not just before. I haven't done it. I've looked at them on the iPad, but I haven't looked at them on the iPad. But at that time, I don't know. But at this point, yeah, but at this point, I don't know.

2:53 Thank you.

3:21 Yeah, yeah.

3:25 Last week, last week I had no problem committing.

3:53 Okay. Do we have some other commissioners that are wandering somewhere? I don't know. Do a little running light. Okay. I just have two extra bands. Okay. Okay.

4:11 Thank you.

4:33 This is it. This is it.

5:03 Can you type in a search word in there and it'll find it? We made it. Yeah, but they're doing well. That's a great job. How that works. Well, I think you might email it to yourself.

5:28 The only problem is they all have the same name because of the way the grading system works.

5:57 Okay, so, how much to leave? Okay, so, how much to leave?

6:24 Did we just leave John? John, he's right there. Okay. All right. I can't see. Oh, there he is. Right. Yeah.

6:32 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

7:00 Are you guys ready back there? Well, oh, he totally disappeared, okay.

7:25 You're going to have a hard time working at your last meeting. Whatever. Why don't we have to make it? Get proud of all of these loose cats out here. Really? Get giddy about. Right. It's like a tipping point. I'm ready to go. I'm ready to go. Yeah, finally. OK.

7:56 So I'll call our study session or workshop, whatever we're calling it, to order and turn it over to the recommendation commission. Okay. Okay. I don't know. Is that me? Okay. Basically, we're running. The two of you. Okay. Okay. Can we jump in there? Basically, we're in here to answer any questions you guys might have from what we went through in the measure arm. So I guess it's...

8:25 Okay. I can jump into it if you need. Let's talk a bit about the process. Maybe just a couple minutes to pray later. Let's do one. Go ahead and start. Yeah, so we started this process recently in March. It's the Spring Award, as you know. So the Spring Award is essentially those opportunity funds from the Fall Award.

8:56 You had to be previously awarded. Or it's an award that insufficient funds were available at the time for a project. So that was really the premise of the Supreme Award. The process runs the same as the Fall Award. So you still have the funding priorities carried over from the Fall. So those funding priorities and principles that were applied in the Fall, which I believe are in the agenda bill. So the Commission filed that process. We had two application presentation times.

9:26 Which were listed in the agenda bill as well. So the first one was more of the extensive one. Each applicant has 10 minutes. They present their project. Commission just follows up with any questions. Try and keep it short and concise as much as we can. And then we followed that up. Usually two weeks later, but it ended up being a little bit longer. So it was kind of joined together in the June 12th meeting, which was last week. So it was a little bit lengthy, but I think the process went well. Commission can jump in at a time.

9:54 That period of time is really for the Commission to come back to the applicants and follow up those questions. They, most of the time, gave them homework questions to do, so there was some follow up that they required to bring in. Typically, it's a lot to do with our budget and any questions about the application. Once they do that, they sit down and do the project filtering application, which you're pretty familiar with. We've seen that done numerous times. We have one sheet per application.

10:21 The Commission presents their scores for each of those, the primary filter and the secondary filter. We add up those scores, check those scores, and then we begin the funding process and make their recommendations using the final score from the project filter and checklist to help in their determination of the funding amount. And that's essentially how that process worked. I know there's a lot of comments about moving it forward and relating it to Measure U, but that's something that the Commission's going to evaluate.

10:50 And the other thing that we came up with on our questions and the project filter and checklist that we'd either like to bring it back to the commission or to the steering committee, that when we were grading something as a project or grading something that was a planning or a study, that they really don't jive other than the fact that sometimes when the upper filters score higher than the lower, they might

11:20 Flip-flop on their, you know, what might, yeah. And so I don't know, that's a discussion that needs to happen is to, you know, do we change that or do you just use that as the way to, you know, the way that one kind of outweighs the other when you start looking at it, whether it's a project or whether it's a study or a plan. And because if you look at the project checklist and, you know, there are definitely questions that fit one but not the other.

11:50 But you can't necessarily answer NA because we're grading this with a score. And to bring something and have it, you know, kind of fit together with a score, you have to grade each single and every one of them. Stuart, I have a question. Yes, on the application process, are we getting an account, a general accounting of the request broken down?

12:16 In other words, if someone's requesting $100,000, are we getting what they're spending $100,000 on in each and every category? The commission can answer that. I think more detail is always better. I don't know if we're getting a lot of detail. I think that was a lot of follow-up questions from the commission to the applicant in regards to that detail and making sure that those categories are clear. I think sometimes it's pretty well itemized and defined, and others it's just a lump sum. And that this is the project we're doing, this is what it's going to take.

12:46 So it isn't an estimate or a estimate? The one thing about Measure R is we only pay on invoices. So if this is the project that we're doing, they have to submit invoices that either take, you know, something that they, if it was something they purchased or time that they spent, whatever that is, and so you do have that that comes through that you can evaluate and it comes through. So it's not a matter of because we're giving somebody $100,000, you're writing a blank check to them for $100,000. It is a county thing.

13:17 Does it come back? I guess I was doing my follow-up on that. So one was do we have a list that we look at before to see where the money's going? And then two, do we check it at the end of it and verify that it actually went to what it was supposed to go to? So measure R does do that at the end. There is a report that needs to be completed before the applicant can submit for a subsequent moving up money. And that's when they need to itemize it. Exactly.

13:45 And I think we've actually had some money in return, right? It's not return, it's just on cents. It's just on cents. Yeah. So you return to the pot. Yeah, that's right. Yeah, that we're previously awarded, yeah. Now that you've had a couple of times for the follow-up questions, do you think that any of those follow-up questions need to be added to the application so that you get it up front instead of...

14:05 And I'd ask the commission to think about that when you go back and you're talking about it is that if you ended up asking the same question of all the applicants, maybe it should be on the application. The questions are usually pretty specific to each application, but there might be some consistency that you can look at. You know, I have a question. I haven't been to any of the sessions where there have been pitches that were made, but I have in the past.

14:36 So the project filter and checklist, as I understand it, is designed to bring some reformity and sort of structure to the process. And you come up with a grading, a grade or a number that determines priority as to how fun to be spent, right? We do come up with a score and then we look at how the scores fall within each other.

15:06 You mean compared to each other? Yeah, to each other. Okay, so where does the community's priorities fit into that? And I'm asking that because I'm feeling a little ignorant about it because it seems to be over the last couple of years we've had a couple of projects in particular that we've thrown a lot of money at and I'm supportive of that. One is the track project, it goes to the top, and the other is MLTPA, not MLTPA, but trails and trails access.

15:35 Which also has risen to the top. Since competitive process and there are limited dollars and there's more money requested always than there is to give, what happens, for example, when the Mammoth Track project is completed? It doesn't need these large sums of money anymore. We're going to have more funds. How do we work? Where do priorities get to be evaluated or re-evaluated and then changed?

16:02 Sure. In my mind, when you've got these large sums of money,

16:34 Well, my bent, if you will, is generally to not fund 25 projects a little, but a few projects a lot. We needed to get something done and move them, you know, in effect, off the table. And so at what point does the council, well, of course, we approved the rec scraps, but we didn't design rec scraps, we didn't develop them. We have council representation in that process.

17:01 At what point does what's lower on the priority list move up to the top? Do the top just fall off or do we re-examine priorities every time? Every fall we set our priorities and so that's a discussion that happens. So right now we're in the process of dealing with trails and there's the trails committee that's working on what's needed there.

17:24 There's the Facilities Committee that's working on, you know, what facilities are needed. And I think once we have all of that, that that's going to be something that we'll look at in the fall when we start, what's our next priority. And is it a long-range goal, you know, when we're looking to build in something large? Is it, you know, is it short-range that we want to just kind of continue to keep finishing what we have? You know, that would be answered. That's something that we look at every single fall.

17:51 And obviously, you know, all of those things sort of come together. At what point do we tell you what we think either the correctness is of the priorities that you've developed or provide a new input or do we at all? I was going to suggest that perhaps maybe after the next cycle of the Commission's value priorities, maybe there's a workshop that

18:16 We approved the priorities before the application period started, but they were still somewhat vague, and I think what I made Rick say is, we really want to see X finished or something.

18:39 Yeah, if that's what we're hearing and three of us or five of us say this is very, very important, even though it might not achieve the highest score in the very structured process, I'm just wondering where that flexibility comes in because I think that we ought to have that opportunity. I mean, obviously,

19:02 We rely on you and want you to do the work and we're talking with you and you're talking with the community but it seems we really want to have a say or should have a say as well and we ought to do that, right? Absolutely. I'm not sure that it wouldn't be beneficial to do it prior to our next, you know, let's have the facilities committee meet again, maybe we tie up what we're doing there because we were supposed to have a meeting with the facilities committee with some of the other partners

19:30 So that we could all kind of work together. What are things that we can partner with and share? And, you know, maybe we have that meeting so we have a little better idea of kind of where we're going there. And the Trails Committee has, you know, their meetings where we all kind of come to some conclusion and that then we can come back to the council before our next fall. We set our next goals. Even if it's just simply an affirmation or reaffirmation of what we've already determined to be priorities,

19:58 One of the things, one of the reasons I say that is if somebody comes up to me and says, well, what are you doing with Measure Our Money? And I'm thinking myself, well, let's see. We're going to throw a lot of money at the track, and we'll throw a lot of money. Well, what are you going to do next? And I'm not feeling like I'm in the loop, and I'm not blaming anybody, but it seems to me that that would be helpful. I don't think we're at the point where you're looking for yet. You know, we're getting there, but I don't think we're there yet.

20:27 I think the feasibility study is very helpful. You know, the facilities committee needs to get there, the trails, and, you know, I think between all of those things that that's what we need, we need some of those final pieces to kind of put the whole plan together. You can well imagine that there is significant pressure that is going to be placed on those funds as we move into this next phase. And I don't mean just for the special

20:55 I think it's a lot of projects that relate to the things that are in both of the measures, but it's a different pressure to evade them, if you will, to our general fund purposes, and we're just holding back and standing firm. But it still seems to be the bright spot in our budget. Those are the funds with which we can do something.

21:20 That would do good for the community while we're hanging on by our fingernails. So I think that's great. And I think that we should keep council in the group and have that discussion so that we can get your input as well. But like I said, I think there's some other pieces that we should meet first to tie up some of those things prior to having that meeting.

21:45 And I think that's what we're trying to get. It's just taking a long time. It's taking a long time. Did you realize you were phone-coordinated? Your thoughts on the show? Actually, I wanted to ask you, as the commissioners, about the one with the rollery, but first I need to ask Stuart.

22:06 You know, there's a recommendation here about revenue being essentially set aside, but has that revenue already been accounted for in the fiscal year 12-13 budget? No, we didn't. No revenue? No budget before. Yeah, because it was measure R and measure U, we didn't want to know it was going to be funded, so we didn't put it in the 12-13 budget. So then, it's really hard for the little sentence down here to understand. What are the thoughts behind holding that revenue aside? Well, basically, if measure R and measure U

22:35 Our funding is in full. Whatever income is brought in from the roller rink should go back into, first we said Measure R, but that's not really fair because Measure D and Measure R are funding this. So we said it should come back into recreation. And so that was our thought, that it shouldn't be something that goes into the general fund when it's fully funded by Measure R and Measure U.

23:00 Just as any other project, if it's not, if the money's not used, it would come back to measure R or it would come back to measure U. Well, at this point, because we haven't gotten to where we're using R and U for anything yet, at this point, if a recreation facility can pay for something, it wouldn't make sense to then pay R and U for it so that you can just circle that money back into the general fund. It would look like a circumvent of the, you know, the intention.

23:28 Just to follow up on that, Jennifer, so the discussion was staff would come back towards the end of that season with the amount of revenue that was generated at the rink. We put some recommendations forward and say maybe options for the commission to consider would be extending the operation of the roll rink, you know, past its time, you know, due to expenses, maybe we need to invest in additional skates, inline skates, equipment, or maybe that's carried over as a bank for the following year, so we would need to apply for it.

23:57 As much the following summit. Okay, but, okay, but you're saying that it would then only, are you suggesting it would only be able to use there or it would be able to use anywhere within the recreation department? Well, that was just... To me, it would be used on that facility. Okay, yeah. Like a lot of our recreation programs, I don't know that this one will ever fully recoup its expenses, but I would hope that anything that a facility...

24:24 And one of the reasons we said that, you know, sort of put a budget together, you know, we have no idea.

24:54 It's the first year it's operating. And then my other question was on the track project, and it may be a staff question, but somewhere in all this, because I looked at the application online and it changed and so on and so forth, but did we get the staff from Public Works, et cetera, to manage the construction? Did we get that funded somewhere? So I do have a little fancy spreadsheet that was given to us. I think

25:23 Commission got it as well. It wasn't online. It wasn't online. Right. Well, just because it's the contact management team. So there's $52,500 for the administration for that project. That's essentially the staff. Because we won't get it done if we don't have it. We just want to make sure of that. All right. That's correct. Well, there's a built-in. Hopefully, there's a $50,000 grant that's going to come back. We're talking about that.

25:52 I'm late because I'm jumping in there. Did you all have a nice birthday of summer? That's the important thing. Yes. I thought it didn't start until about half an hour from now. I was going to say it's tomorrow. Can you stay in my head right back towards the winter now? Shh. Yeah. Quiet. Snow weather for you. OK. Then there's a question. And again, it's trying to interpret the one-liner because I think this time I did not have a chance to go back and listen to the sessions.

26:31 On the website, I wasn't sure, I mean, there's two kinds of questions. I don't know whether John has to answer this part, but recently you were telling us that the website was almost ready to go and turn over, and now you're asking for more money to finish it? So I think I can answer that to John, if you don't mind. Sure.

27:02 The website could be made with permission from the Forest Service. They're still going through all of that. You can't put Forest Service content on without their approval at all. It could go live at any time. Where they fell short was developing all of the different experiences that are going to go on the website. So while they knew they wanted to include all of these experiences, the fact is,

27:28 Whether it took them longer in the negotiations with the Forest Service, with town staff, wherever it was, they fell short from their standpoint of being able to fund, to have the funds to complete all the experiences. And I'll give you an example. They came to me a year ago and said, gee Bill, you need to develop all these experiences from a snowmobile standpoint. Bill's been a pretty busy guy. He hasn't had time to go out and take the photos. I'm also not an author. I haven't...

27:56 So they're going to have to send somebody to me and say, well, what is this trail? What is this trail? So there's several pieces of that experience that are missing. And I questioned this when I first got it. But then after going up and seeing the demonstration of what would be the working website, if they get all these experiences in it, it's going to be a piece for us to hang our hat on. I mean, it is just a beautiful thing. And the interactiveness of it.

28:25 It's really impressive. Every time I ask them a question, well, did you think about being able to do this, like follow the trail with your cursor and find out how long you've been and they brought it up, showed me how it's already built into the website and how it functions and everything else, so I was very impressed. To have the extra experiences, if you're a snowmobiler or a motorcycle rider, which are missing almost completely, to be able to go to the website and get a definition of each trail and what the experience is and what the

28:55 The level of expertise required is and all of that is going to be a huge. I'd like to comment on that. As mentioned, the commission has spent hours and hours reviewing the applications and some presentations, deliberating, and we agree 99% of the projects except with respect to myself. Part of the current agreement for the website is to produce these experiences onto the website.

29:28 And apparently there is that information, but it's not as deep as perhaps MLTPA would like to see it on all of the different aspects of activities. So it is part of the current agreement. And then to enhance it beyond that, that's why I suggested why don't we look at the contingency. There's a contingency agreement of $23,000 and change.

29:57 And perhaps that could be utilized to offset some of these further enhancements or a shortfall of money for whatever for this website. And I just found out today that it sounds like maybe some of that money is available. Another thought that I had too is I think it's this week that the town is supposed to receive the website or sometime very soon.

30:24 Why not let the town take a look at it and make an evaluation as to whether further enhancements are needed? Because as I saw a couple weeks ago, the website was really phenomenal. It was great. But maybe the town should make a determination. How much has already been spent on the development of the website?

30:50 To this point, the amount that had been requested is $150,000. They haven't quite spent all of that yet. This will make the total $175,000, which seems like a lot. To me, it seems like a lot. I have talked to other people who have developed very complex websites. They say going well over $100,000 is not out of the ordinary. The things the site will do, the complexity of the site is huge.

31:17 As I understand it, as I understand it, actually, they have an expert that's developing the website, and they're the ones giving the content to put into it. So they're managing that process just as the town staff would manage it if they had to hire outside contractors to build it. Is that about it? Yes. And then on the $25,000 remaining, is that just your staff plan? Yeah. To do work. And it's managed as a...

31:48 $12,500 match for MLTPA, so that's $25,000. And also, in the scope of the application, I think it's important to point out that it addresses issues of experiences, but also photography, and also the interpretive program. This summer, there are, I think, 8 to 10 interpretive families scheduled to go onto the ground. They have QR codes associated with them. And part of the application is going to work with the Forest Service and the ESEA to develop interpretive content for the science as well.

32:17 That was a program we could not have foreseen when we wrote the original measure application two years ago. It's a great opportunity coming forward. So there are really three heads that are in that spring, in the spring, when you're not being discussed. So previous question, and I guess we're tying into this. When this is done or even before, can we get a breakdown of these things? So for example, only because we get so many different things coming before us with requests,

32:45 You know, if we have a website we can have a request, what is it we're getting for that? Is this like the snowmobile component of it, or is this the running trails component? I guess that's my question. In every measure of our application, there's something called the project concept plan. That's what the component lays out a narrative of what they're requesting funds for, and also there's an expectation that a detailed budget should be in there as well. If you go back and look at that application, we can

33:12 And so afterwards, though, we get the follow-up as well. And we, and if it went, if it, you know, when we go to contract with the town on this, the scope of work is a little bit more defined. The contract is one of the things that are within that application, as it should be for every application. The reconciliation at the end

33:37 When the town staff reviews what comes back is, okay, here are the deliverables, here's what's in it, did we get back, did we get back again what was scoped and contracted? Okay, I think that's what we're going to do. Thank you. Okay, so then that makes me, now I understand the comment about the contingency. I wasn't sure that was going, so thank you on that. And then I presume with that and with the final allocation or whatever we're calling it from the

34:07 The other MLTPA piece, again, town staff, along with the Recreation Liaison, which Michael right now is ready for myself, would make sure that the scope of services for the additional funds is what are the priorities, et cetera, and then they go out and do it. I have to backtrack just a little bit, because when we voted on this as a commission, we did not have the answer regarding the contingents. OK. I just found out about it before I walked into this meeting, and you know I've asked a couple times.

34:38 So, I don't know if that changes anything with these working relations. Well, but theoretically, if you finish the contract and there's money left with the scope contingency, it goes back into metro art. That's right. Why does it get put towards this instead of that? Well, because if you've got the overlapping contracts, my fingers, you wouldn't know that. But, I mean, one way or the other, only so much would get spent, right?

35:06 I think it's kind of an accountant. I understand what you're saying. I think by the nature of how we've allocated that is, kind of forced it. Well, I think the original contingency was about $60,000 currently, if I'm wrong, somebody. So if there's $20,000, $3,000 left, already $40,000 of the contingency has been used on other things. The contracts aren't done yet. So we don't know the need for any of that contingency

35:33 If we put it here, then do they have to come back next fall and ask for something else? So hopefully the money stays there. It just never leaves Measure R, and we have to give away in the next cycle. But at this point, I would press forward as we have suggested. But you're not suggesting the money we double spend? No. I'm not suggesting the money we double spend. No, I am not. Are you kind of concerned about that? Yeah. Well, I think if you have an agreement,

36:01 And there's a contingency, then you use the contingency. That's what it's there for. In my professional experience, that's an approach. Yeah, it doesn't get double spent, because everything is spent on invoice. You know, the number of hours worked at the billable rate for the pay. Now, we have no way of sitting in the MLTPA offices, ensuring that they're actually working that number of hours. I have faith that that is being done.

36:38 So I have faith that the project will, you know, not double-dick. No, I'm not expecting that there would be a double-dick, but there might have been some of the projects that maybe we would have done for funding. If you know that the contingency was okay. And that's where I think that when you close my contract and the contingency goes back into offer being, quote, unspanishable, whatever you call it, then it is it. Exactly.

37:11 Okay, and do you have any other councilors that have questions? Anything further that the commission wants to say? What does the revive mean on this agenda? That's me. Oh. Okay, I know. So, we learned, however, that we didn't get the coordinating these recommendations embedded in the measure of all nations.

37:44 We went to the commission, the commission reviewed it, made the recommendations, and then M went on vacation, and I went in another direction and realized we didn't do this. Well, I had thought that since we already agreed and the council already passed, the funding recommendation for the money for the FLTSCC, that that was a done deal. And all we're coming back now is how we are

38:12 Currently allocating those funds, and it doesn't need to come through the standard R process. I'm happy with that. I just want to make sure that we cross the T. Yeah, and I think that's... So it's not necessarily part of tonight's, but... Can we have it for you to look at? Yes. Yes. So the council approved this past spring, the...

38:38 It's a coordinated committee effort, and we put a lot of effort into this, a lot of time, and the result of that is in your hands, which is a representation of all the different projects that have been working together. And so what we did is decided, for prioritization purposes, and I was kind of the leader of the group, using my simple mind to try to craft something I can understand, create buckets, and that's what the number of twos and ones represent. The number one bucket is priorities that are ready to go.

39:08 Bucket 2 are very important projects that need to be worked on. Bucket 3 is kind of a holding bucket, and number 4 are more of a mechanism of operations. So this is the list that we went through, developed, a lot of this came from some of the original work that MLTPA did on behalf of the panel. These are allocations on recommendations that you see on the far right hand column. The direction that we got from the

39:35 The Recreation Commission is that we need to do a much more thorough job of tightening up some of the descriptions and allocations. We just didn't have time to do all of that during the short period of time we had to work with. The highest priorities, obviously, are the items in bucket one and sharps. 331A and 331B are the two projects that we want to do this summer. And then on the second page, under bucket four, is the recommendation

40:03 to fund some of stewardship this summer to the Friends of the Union, which is represented under 472. So those are immediate projects, and I think that was one of the priorities I've heard from the council is, let's get some things done. And so those are our high priorities for us. The remainder of the work, other buckets, will be worked on this summer and winter, and we'll tighten up the scope of work, of course,

40:31 Then come back and report through the commission and through the council the progress of these projects. And I would add that the dollars that are on here are estimates. Since we haven't actually put them out to bid or even decided in most cases who's going to be doing them, that will be coming shortly. We don't have a proposal, so these are best guess scenarios. Okay, and this money is already allocated, so it's just coming to us.

41:01 It's in the senior project. Senior project. From my point of view, from the staff perspective, I think accounting to the commission and the council is an important thing to do. So some of the work will be through a CIP process, some of it will be through consulting, but I think we need to report back so that we still have this process. So I think accountability is really important. We've been just working so hard getting a list done that we haven't

41:30 Spend time on that piece that we certainly need to. But if we're going to continue moving this summer, the importance of getting this approved now, some of these that are on here, and the dollar amounts we spend this summer may be run by somebody else at a whole different rate next year as we get our hands around everything we're doing. But for right now, this is where we need to go to keep continuity moving forward. Did I say that right, boss? When do you actually begin to start working on it? We meet next week. Next week, yeah. It would be nice to probably see it, too.

42:01 Yeah. Is there anything on here as far as Main Street Trail continuation? I mean, is there anything on this with regard to that? There isn't specifically, but you're a council member. There's lots of authority. Well, is there anything in the regular capital improvement?

42:23 Is there any funding for further sections of Main Street through any of the other sources that are in the CIP? That's not currently in next year. Okay, not in next year, but when we do the five-year, is it likely to be in the line? It's likely, yeah. I think the MLT-SCC will consider what kind of that on Main Street. Again, just go ahead.

42:50 We're still slightly on the same thing. We are still on the same thing. And this isn't, by any stretch of the imagination, a complete list. One of the things that John Katomirsky from the Forest Service said after one of the meetings to me when he took me aside was, you know, this doesn't show the new trailhead that's being built out of Shady Rest, which is being built with other dollars, not to measure our general fund dollars. But as I envision, the MLTSCC, that's certainly going to be a part of its

43:18 Overall umbrella. So how we're going to develop the structure to actually list, because in my P grade, that MLTSCC is going to be an umbrella for everything trails that affects the town of Pam, not just in the city confines of three or five square miles or whichever boundary you want to use, but things that positively affect us for tourism and our own use. Most of the trails don't exist inside of that. The mops and the in-town trails

43:48 Really have been done out of the Public Works and Planning end and not come through the REC Commission and there's been kind of a schism there that we're trying to, and I think eventually this committee can get their hands around that whole piece of pie and move it forward with an eye to the whole picture, not just the individual little, you know, here and there pieces. So there's a lot of work left to be done to identify the needs for the Main Street trails, the needs for single track and forest that

44:16 We depend on for tourism. There's a need for equestrian trails, which we've never even looked at yet, but it's another huge component of summer. Mountain bike trails, hiking trails, there's a lot that still have to fit under this umbrella. It's a daunting task. I might try to get my mind behind it, but I have a danger to hold me out. Yeah, kind of weak response. So for tonight, the council's being asked to approve the Measure R applications, and that would be the time, if that

44:46 Main Street area was important, to include that as a motion as part of the approval either as an amendment or an addition, and then that would be part of our work plan. And that's what we would be our marching orders. I continue to be so impressed by the work that you guys do. I say that really sincerely, as you know, the Commission a long, long time ago, like Hand and Recreation, one or the other, is one of the council members of Sanders. This is a tremendous task that you're doing. Well, it's by the way it's huge.

45:26 It's, it's, it can't be overstated. It's, it's amazing. To, to, to bring us in summary form or fashion what you have spent so much time on, it makes it really easy for us. And, and it's, from my perspective, I don't want to be very much in the detail because there are too many other details who we are in. You just do such a great job that it's hard not to approve what you present.

45:57 Thank you. I think the commission does a great job, but I also would like to compliment the student for keeping us on track. So I would ask, as your measure of our topic comes up, to include our list as the national one, just so we can get approved again. And we've got some good practice to do that. All right. Thank you. Joe, did you have a copy of the

46:29 A regular meeting of the Town Council of Mammoth Lakes for Wednesday, June 20, 2012. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Michael, would you leave us in the pledge? Absolutely. Raise your right hand, please.

57:12 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. The next item would be public comments on items that are not in this evening's agenda. If anyone has a general public comment, please come forward to the podium. Madam Mayor, Councilmembers, John Urdi, Mayor of Lakes Tourism. I just wanted to give you an update.

57:52 Summer events brochures came in this morning. We're getting those distributed through certified folder. Those will be distributed from San Diego up to the Bay Area, over to Las Vegas, all throughout Los Angeles, as well as locally. Same thing on posters. So posters are up as well. These will be getting out as far and wide as possible. We're also, with our embarking on the best summer campaign, we started sending out emails every Tuesday morning by 9 a.m. We're sending those out to the

58:20 Leaders of different groups throughout town, the Board of Realtors, the Lodging Association, the Rotary, the Lions, with the idea that they then turn that around and send it to their constituents. Great response so far. I think we've got a lot of really good feedback from the guests that are getting the information. The email is very simple. It's really an event and an offer. So we want to let people know what's coming up, and we also want to let them know what the best deal is for them that week. So the response has been great for that.

58:49 We are going to be doing a postcard similar to the one that we did locally here last year with the branding effort. It's going to be the California version of the sticker. It's going to be mailed to all of our second homeowners. It's going to be highlighting the best summer ever, really talking about just how we're kicking off a fantastic summer. And it's also going to be promoting an Alaska Airline deal. So really we're hoping to get folks flying on that. So there's going to be, we're working with Alaska Airlines to have two different offers.

59:16 So that we can actually track and see what works better, a percentage off, a dollar off, or a specific price point. So, very excited to see that. We'll probably have that out in the next week, and then we'll have the remainder of the postcards that we'll print with that same message, best summer ever, and the air deal that we'll be handing out at the 4th of July parade. John, quick question.

59:39 At the start of this winter, we were going to do a program where people that use their American Express card in town were going to be tracked, and we were going to find out where they stayed and spent their money and so forth. Is there any kind of anything put together? We get the report on that quarterly. That is something I apologize for not sharing with you sooner, but I will include that with our...

1:00:02 Monthly report on the quarters when we can finally get that. Yeah, that'd be helpful. And we do have the past four quarters. I can forward those to you tomorrow. Great. Thank you. Absolutely. Thank you, John. Thank you. Is that motorhome for engineers? Neighbors. Just curious. Yeah. He has a motorhome part. Yeah, I just wondered if it was his. It's a neighbor's.

1:00:35 Okay, any other public comments? Stacy Corliss, Friends of the Ineo. Hi, John Wentworth with MLTPA. We're here to give you a quick update about the Mammoth Lakes Summer of Stewardship Program, and I want to thank Council for your consideration of funding this program through the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee's recommendations that you discussed earlier this evening.

1:01:04 I wanted to give you an update. We had our first event. This is, of course, in partnership between Friends of the Inyo and MLTPA in partnership with the Inyo National Forest on National Trail Day, which was June 2nd. We had a great volunteer event. We had 44 volunteers. We cleared 48 logs. That's more than one log per volunteer off trails throughout the lake space, including Duck Pass, the TJ Barrett Trail.

1:01:30 And all around the basin to help make it the best summer ever so people could go hiking in the basin. Friends of the Inyo's crews also helped the Inyo last week by logging out the entire Duck Pass trail, which would not have been clear for equestrian and easy hiker access had it not been for our crews. So appreciate your support. We especially, Councilman Raimondo, for helping feed our volunteers in the morning.

1:01:58 With bagels. Thank you. Much appreciated. Our next event is July 14th at Horseshoe Lake. We'll be working at Horseshoe, but also we have some sturdier volunteers who are now trained up in cross-cut saw work. We're going to go back and help clear the Mammoth Pass and the Red Cones Crater Meadow Trail, which is, of course, a mess from the blowdown. And fire crews have been back there to do some of the really heavy work, but our volunteers will then go back and do some actual trail work.

1:02:28 Tidy things up a bit. So, thank you very much. Stacey, thank you. Good job. Definitely. Any other comments? Seeing none, we'll move on to Councilmember Reports. John? On June 15th, we met in the City of Bishop for both the Eastern Sierra Council of Governments and the Eastern Sierra Transit meetings. At ESCOG, we learned that the

1:02:59 The very worthy Inyo County Adventure Trail System recently approved by a state, California state legislation had a lawsuit filed against them by the biodiversity group. So this new adventure trail system is put off for right now and won't be able to be initiated until the lawsuit is settled. At the SCARB meeting we learned, excuse me, at the

1:03:27 Also at the ESCOG we had an exceptional presentation by John Wentworth. It was one of the better presentations that I've seen. Excellent job. This presentation was in regards to the regional technology and the visitor experience using smartphone technology. At ESTA, Eastern Sierra Transit, we celebrated our anniversary of being in operation for five years.

1:03:56 We also approved the contract between ESTA and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area for ESTA to provide transit service for the ski area on a fixed route basis starting November 2012. The ski area will pay not only the necessary money for operations of their bus system, but also an additional funding for money so we'll have transit replacement costs. Finally, for the first time,

1:04:27 In the five-year history of ESTA, our monthly ridership numbers for April and May declined. That's the first time we've had sporadic declines in the past, but this was the first time we had two months consecutive of a decline. Most likely those declines were associated with low snowfall, fewer visitors, fewer workers necessary to service the visitors.

1:04:57 It was two Friday nights ago on June 8th that we held the Hispanic Advisory Council open house. That was held at the Grand Sierra Lodge. It was emceed by Chief Watson. There were professionals in attendance to answer questions from Bishop, Department of Motor Vehicles. Hefter Gonzalez was there from the U.S. Council's office in Sacramento.

1:05:25 There were officers there both from the Mammoth Lakes Police Department as well as the Sheriff's Office. Middle school principal was there as well as two interpreters. This meeting lasted for about three hours with approximately 70 residents in attendance and enough food to feed not the 70 people in attendance but probably closer to 200 people. We had 10 restaurants in town who donated.

1:05:54 Food and Drink for that event. This was the second annual open house and it was once again very successful and a lot of questions were answered from our local Hispanic community. On Saturday, the very next day, Hector Gonzalez stayed an extra day to meet with people throughout Mono County. I don't know if it was Inyo County as well. Inyo and Mono County both.

1:06:23 And in that single day, he was able to distribute some 500 matriculation permits in just that one day throughout the county. So anyway, good job. Appreciate it, Chief. Okay, Rick? Thank you. I attended, along with the Mayor, the Town of Mammoth Lakes MLTPA Liaison Committee meeting on the 11th. And I just have a couple of things to report. One is that, as John Wentworth so eloquently stated,

1:06:58 We now have a Mammoth Lakes trail system. There's 300 miles in that trail system. And what's going forward, in addition to MLTPA's management role, is the development and completion of a website that will display and highlight the recreational opportunities, trail-related recreational opportunities for the town. I'm really pleased with the work that they have done. The purpose of the meeting, the focus of the meeting was to

1:07:28 Outline the deliverables from the contracts that this council has issued over the last couple of years and there will be more to come as we saw in our workshop today. That's all I have. Thanks. Okay. Michael? Too new for any comments. Okay. Just wait. You'll have assignments shortly. Matthew? Yeah, just a couple quick comments. I attended the Chamber of Commerce.

1:07:58 Meeting Board of Directors, and just a couple quick things. One of the events that the Chamber of Commerce puts on Mammoth Rocks is moving along steadily, and this year they're kind of taking it in a new direction. Historically they've done classic rock type tribute bands, and this year they're going to be focusing more on headliner type bands. A lot of them still back from the classic rock era, but it's actually going to be more of a

1:08:25 Versus classic rock is going to be more of a ska and different punk type music and other various rock and roll. So kind of a new change there. And so keep your eye out for that. That's August 24th and 25th. And then I met with the economic stimulus group last week. And some of the things we're trying to focus on in addition to looking at things such as the best summer ever, we're looking a little bit longer term.

1:08:55 Some of the things we're going to start seeing come up are a greater focus on business attraction, retention, working with the town on looking into event venue sites, and TOT collection obviously will stay a priority, and high altitude training. Also probably start looking into areas of blight and how we might be able to remedy some of those situations.

1:09:21 Just a couple of things that we're going to be working on longer term. We're going to really be focusing on a lot of the Dr. SEDS components that were outlined previously and really just going to focus on implementation. So that's all I have. Okay. Thank you. I have one thing to report on for my fellow council members. Dave Wilbricht and I met with Deanna Doolin from Devil's Postpile, and she has some creative partnership opportunities that she'd like to pursue that could make...

1:09:51 Access to information about the post file available year round. So staff will continue discussing that. As you know, they had a short-term lease for part of the tourism building, and there's a possibility to bring in some money there that would put more money into MLT by having some portion of that possibly be used for interpretive, which would mean that people can see the post file year round.

1:10:20 From up there. So it's to start exploring it and bring that information back to us at another point. Because, you know, even at this point, the Welcome Center is having to tell people the post pile's not open. So look forward to that. So staff will report back to us if there's one and if there's progress on that. Are there any additions to the agenda?

1:10:44 Okay, seeing none, we'll move on to our first item under the reorganization. Is this you, Matthew? Well, I believe it is. So we'll start with item number one under council reorganization, and that is giving recognition to our outgoing Mayor Joe Bacon. So, Joe, if you could join me down here, please. So, anyway, tonight we're recognizing Mayor Joe Bacon for an outstanding job.

1:11:20 That she's done over the course of the year. I have really just a short story I want to tell, and I think it summarizes Joe. The other day we were putting together our agenda for tonight's meeting. It was about a week and a half ago. And part of that meeting, we got the agenda item one, which is recognizing her. And she said, you know, I really don't want to be recognized. Save the money and spend the money on it.

1:11:50 Skip's cake. I think what that is, you know, in a couple of sentences, a really good summarizer, though. It summarizes the fact that she's a fiscally responsible person. She's a person that cares about other people, and she would want to put herself aside. We're very fortunate to have Jo as a member of our council. I'm so glad that she ran again. And Jo, thank you very much for being our mayor. Thank you. Thank you.

1:12:37 Joe, I just wanted to thank you personally and to say a few words about Joe. I think as everyone knows and has learned over the last year, Joe takes the position as mayor very, very seriously, which is a really good thing for us. She runs a professional and a strict meeting. She's a no-nonsense lady.

1:13:02 Jo not only has worked well with the council, but she also works really well with the staff and the press. I don't know the amount of time, Jo, that you spent, but I would suspect that Jo easily has spent more time than any other mayor in the history of Mammoth Lakes. I think so. At least I know. Anyway, thank you very much. Thank you, Jim. Great job. I can't help but add to that.

1:13:34 Because I know of what I speak, having served in that position for a while. You know, a good mayor makes the rest of our jobs easier. And a really great mayor makes us look better as well. And you've really done that. And I say that very sincerely, having sat next to you and whispering in your ear and having you whisper in my ear for this past year.

1:14:02 Jo is and has been the go-to person on this last council. If you can't make a meeting, she'll make it. If you are unprepared, she will get you through it. And it's not an easy job for any of us up there, but I'll tell you, Jo, I just think you've done a superb job, not just in running the meetings, but in representing the council and the community as well, and I congratulate you for it.

1:14:31 Thank you. Just a couple of comments. First of all, I want to thank my fellow council members. The amount of work that you have put in this year has just been incredible, and the decisions that we have deliberated, discussed, argued, and come to consensus, which is the most important part, it's just been amazing to me that you've managed to do that.

1:14:58 Second, I want to thank staff. Without Dave and Marianna and the rest of the staff, we're somewhere down there in not clean water. It's amazing to see what staff has done, and they are just wonderful people to work with. I can't say anything more about them. We'd be lost without our two leaders over there, especially.

1:15:25 I also want to thank the commissioners. They have, on all of our commissions, worked like heck this year. We just saw a workshop. I know how many hours the recreation commission put in doing that. All of our commissions have put in numerous hours.

1:15:41 Finally, I'd like to thank the community because we would not be surviving without the community and what I refer to as our volunteer staff like Chuck and John and some of the others that every time we ask for a new committee, they're willing to step forward. We would not be getting accomplished what we were doing without that.

1:16:00 And the second part of thanking the community is for the fact that you passed both measures R and U and that we're implementing them. And even though things are not necessarily right in our future, we will still be moving forward. So I want to thank everyone else for that. Next item is selection of the mayor and mayor pro tem. We have in front of us what would be the...

1:16:54 Previous rotation that we've talked about, and do we have discussion or motions on this item? Madam Mayor, I would move that the Town Council appoint Mayor Pro Tem, Matthew Lehman as the Mayor of the Town of Mammoth Lakes. Second that motion. We have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Raimondo? Councilmember Raimondo? Councilmember Wood? Councilmember Wood? Councilmember Wood? Mayor Pro Tem Layman? Mayor Pro Tem Layman? Mayor Macon? Mayor Macon? Yes. Motion passes 5-0.

1:17:30 Okay. Discussion on second? I have some thoughts, if I may. Okay. And I got one more thought on Jo Bacon, and I know we said some really nice things about her, and she deserved them, but I have one more nice thing to say about Jo. I've been on the council for a number of years, and usually it's a simple transition each year to go to a new mayor, but

1:17:58 Jo Bacon was such an outstanding mayor during her one-year term that, to me, it's the end of an era. I mean, an era is a long period of time, but, Jo, you've created an era in one year, one year's time, so very unusual. You should be very proud of your time as the mayor of the town of Mammoth Lakes, so great job. Thank you, John.

1:18:24 Having said that, rotational wise, I'm next in line as the Mayor Pro Tem. I've considered, I'm on council for two more years, I've considered if I would have the time and energy and be up to being Mayor a year from now. And personally, I would like to defer that option of being the Mayor Pro Tem under Matthew.

1:18:54 Having come to that conclusion, personally, I would like to have, as I see the next person in line, which is Councilmember Rick Wood, who was elected during the same election as Matthew and myself, and if you are willing, Rick, I would like to make a motion for you to be our Mayor Pro Tem. I'm willing if you'd have me. I'd be honored. Okay, I'll also move.

1:19:24 All right.

1:19:26 I'm going to second that.

1:19:30 Go ahead.

1:19:31 Okay.

1:19:31 And we'll move over.

1:19:32 So we'll go ahead and then we have a motion and a second.

1:19:37 And a roll call, please.

1:19:40 Council Member Reeson?

1:19:41 Yes.

1:19:41 Council Member Raimondo?

1:19:42 Yes.

1:19:42 Council Member Wood?

1:19:43 Yes.

1:19:44 Mayor Layton?

1:19:45 Yes.

1:19:46 Council Member Raimond?

1:19:47 Yes.

1:19:49 Okay, we have passes, so we'll go ahead and shift. The biggest difficulty for Joe is going to be over the next year, over the next few meetings as to not be mayor.

1:20:20 Tough adjustment. And none of you called me the enforcer by putting in the timer light. I can't. I wanted to go. You want to go in the corner? Yeah. Okay. I guess I'm going here. Yeah. I'm coming here. I'm taking the chair. Are you going through the end? Yes. Okay. Can I take the chair? Absolutely.

1:20:46 Is this from a James Bond movie, Chaos? Yeah. This is a hard part. Get your PowerPoint.

1:21:16 I'm very serious here, George. With fidgeting, probably. Okay. Situated here.

1:21:44 Okay. So you guys were used to the

1:22:17 Nice smooth operation of Joe. Just be patient, please. Okay, so we'll move on to item number three, which is town council appointments to commissions and committees. So, Jamie, did you want to run through this, or should we go ahead? Doesn't matter. Usually we just go down the list. Okay. So,

1:22:49 I guess before we get started, I wonder if the council might want to, is there any suggestions on how we go about this? Do we want to think of keeping some of the same positions and maybe address some of the vacancies that Councilmember Harvey is leaving and fill them with Michael Raimondo? I think we just go down. Okay. So let's go ahead and go on down the list then. We'll go with the local agency formation commission. So currently it's a...

1:23:22 Councilmember Bacon, myself, and John Eastman is the alternate. Do we keep that? Yeah. Keep it the same? That's an easy one. Okay. Airport Land Use Commission. I'm currently on that, and I was on that with Skip. I'll take that to you. Michael, you want to go on that? Okay. Mono County Collaborative Planning Group is Councilmember Eastman and Bacon is alternate. Yep, that's fine. Okay. Mono County Liaison Subcommittee.

1:23:52 We have Councilmembers Bacon, Wood, and Eastman as alternate. I'm still interested. Sure. As am I. Okay. And John? Yep. Okay. Desert Mountain Division of League of Cities, it's myself and John Eastman as the alternate. Still interested in staying there? Mm-hmm. Eastern Sierra Council of Governments, Eastman and Harvey. So, Michael, would you be interested in... Sure. ESTA, Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, we have Eastman and Harvey.

1:24:24 I would suggest that we have the same people on both of those. Okay. We have Harvey on there, though. Yeah. Michael. I'm Harvey. I'm the new Harvey. Great Basin Unified Air Pollution Control District. We have Eastman and Councilmember Bacon as alternate. That's right. League of Cities Legislative Delegate Program. So we have Councilmember Harvey on that.

1:24:53 So, Michael? You know, I was just going to suggest on that one is do we even have it anymore? Well, that's what I'm wondering if we shouldn't go back through some of these. What do you want to do as we go? I think we do it as we go because on that one I know there was a point in time when I think it started when Wendy was on council because there was some legislation that came up at that point. But it's almost become more ad hoc. But I thought that we were required.

1:25:22 By the league, as members of the league, to have a representative. To the legislative delegate program? Is that not it, or is it simple? Well, we have another one on here, too, that I'm a member of, which is the, there's like three of them on here. So we have the Desert Mountain Division, which that's him, and I think there's a larger one that was. Is that generally the mayor, Dave, on that position? I think it's usually the mayor is in that.

1:25:52 California City's Legislative Delegate Program. Oh, okay. All right. Well, why don't we just keep it for now and if we feel we can get rid of it then. So do we want to have Michael on there or should I take that for now? I think you should for now. And do you want to just change it then to a position that goes with the mayorship? Yeah. Okay. So we'll just make that a mayoral position. Can we add the economics to this?

1:26:19 That hasn't been, that hasn't come forward to us very quickly last year. Yeah, we were, we had talked about formalizing that, I guess we need to probably talk about that. Mammoth Unified School District Board, so we had Bacon and Harvey. And I'd like to stay on that one. Okay, Michael? Yeah, sure. Okay, and then Southern California, JPIA, Council Member Bacon and Council Member Wood is alternate.

1:26:47 All we do is get an email. No, I want to be on that one. You want it? I'll trade you. You can have it. Mammoth Community Water District Board Liaison Subcommittee, we have Bacon and Harvey. So, Michael? Yeah. It's a water district. I'm not sure how many meetings you guys go on that. We have Mammoth Lakes Housing. Councilmember Wood and myself as an alternate. I remain interested. I'm fine with that.

1:27:16 And then Town of Mammoth Lakes, Monroe County, MCDW, WD, Inyo, National Forest Liaison Committee, Harvey and Bacon. And I'd like to stay there. Okay. Harvey? Sure. You have a nickname. All right. And then Casa Diablo Subcommittee, it's Councilmember Bacon and myself. Yeah. Jo, you think we need to keep going with that? I think so because they still haven't even come out with the draft.

1:27:46 Plan, yeah. I just think it's somewhat inactive, but we know the proposal's working its way through. Okay. Caltrans District 9 External Advisory Liaison, Councilmember Reisman? Yep, good. All right. LTC, myself, Councilmember Bacon, and Sandy Hogan. Mm-hmm. You okay there? Yeah. Okay, and we have Councilmember Wood and the Town Manager's alternates. Rick, you okay with that? Sure. Chamber of Commerce, myself, I'm still interested in that.

1:28:15 He has an objection. Mammoth Mountain Ski Area Liaison Committee. So it's the mayor and mayor pro tem. So Rick, are you interested in that position? Yes, you are. Mammoth Lakes Tourism, that's myself, and actually Michael Raimondo's on there as well as a member. Is there any problem having two members on that? I don't think so. So I guess it'll just be the two of us. That's up to the Tourisms.

1:28:47 Board makeup. Yeah. Right. Do you think... I asked that question. I was told no. There was no issue. Yeah, they didn't seem to think it was an issue when they put him on. John's here. Well, the board can have whomever they want on the board, but do we want more than one council member on the board? I think it's the question. I think the one... If there's interest, I don't have any problem. I agree. If there's interest, I'm fine. I'd like to be honest. It's down okay.

1:29:16 So it'll be myself and Councilmember Raimondo, a wildlife committee. So we had Councilmember Eastman and Harvey and Michael. Does that still meet? We don't meet anymore on that. Okay. We haven't yet this year. Okay. You want us to keep that committee? Might as well. I wasn't here when that committee started, but I think a lot of the reasons why the committee was created have been addressed, and I'm not certain that we...

1:29:52 Need to have a committee that is staffed and that we have meetings like we have in the last couple of years. I would agree. Let's not have that unless it becomes necessary again. Okay. So do you want to take it off the list? I would. Okay. Go ahead and take the wildlife committee off. Hispanic advisory committee, we had Councilmember Harvey and Eastman. I'd like to move into the, into Skip Harvey's position as the main person. I'd like to be the alternate. Yeah. Okay. So we'll have...

1:30:21 Okay. All right. And then, okay, CIP, PFFP, we had Councilmember Bacon and Wood. You guys both okay there? Yes. Yes. Okay. And so that's it. So were there any other thoughts on additions or? Well, my only thoughts and additions would be if we can look to move the economic stimulus group or Matthew and I are both on that group.

1:30:50 Is there any opposition to that? Well, my only question would be is that we always talked about bringing it forward at some point, but then there's a presumption of staff time to support that. And so I would say that we'd want to know what that cost is. And if it falls within the discussion? Yeah, I think so. And then I think that gives us an opportunity to decide if it's one or two. Okay.

1:31:19 And, you know, as I think about it a little bit more, I'm wondering about on Mammoth Lakes Tourism whether or not there's more than one council representative on the board versus who just happens to be on the board. I don't know. For some reason with Mammoth Lakes Housing and with everything else, we'd always gone with one. And I don't know if that gets us in any kind of a...

1:31:46 Difficult situation. Why don't we agendize that for next meeting? Yeah, sounds good. Okay. Okay. Well then, if there are... I've got one other. I don't see the MLTPA liaison committee listed anywhere here. I know that Joe Bacon and I are on it. And it was kind of the... Is the recreation one? No. No.

1:32:12 I don't see that here. Yeah, because we were recreation liaisons, which got us into the MLTPA liaisons. Right. But you're right. So I think that one needs to compare. And I'm prepared to sort of continue to serve on both of those if they can be added. As you might. Add the recreation one as well, or just the MLTPA? Yeah, I think the recreation one as well, because that allowed us to work with the Forest Service on a policy level.

1:32:43 Yeah, I do. I think so. And that's how we brought rec strats forward. Yeah. Yeah. Or that was the means within which we brought it forward. We'll have MLTPA. Okay. Are there any other comments or questions or recommendations? Okay. So we're there. We don't need to make any motion to reach it. All right. Well, then.

1:33:23 With that, we'll move on to item number four. And actually, we'll move on to our consent agenda. How about commission updates? There we go. My paper's out of order there. Okay, so we'll move on to commission updates. Mayor Lehman and council members, Sandy Hogan, chair of the Mobility Commission. Just a brief report. We met, our commission met yesterday.

1:33:57 We had postponed our transit workshop until next until July 17th or July 17th meeting as requested by John Helm so that the big announcement about the contract with Mammoth Mountain can be laid out at that commission meeting and as well as any other transit updates and a chance for the public to come in with any comments about transit. Also we

1:34:24 Did discuss yesterday the merger of the Airport Commission and the Mobility Commission, and we do support it. I think Ray will probably give you a more full report a little bit later on. And we will also be agendizing for our next meeting something that I know that you want to go through the commissions, which was the airport taxi service, the contract issue. So that will be on our agenda also next month.

1:34:53 Any questions? No, thank you, Sandy. Okay, we'll move on to Department and Emerging Issues. Mayor Lehman and Mayor Pro Tem Wood, fellow council members and fellow staff and community members, my name is Mike Dang, the Budget and IT Manager and also the Chair of the TOT Committee. Eight months ago, Town Manager Dave Wilbrick asked me to lead the efforts to ensure compliance and enforcement of revenue collection.

1:35:33 And especially T.O.T. At the time, Mark Wardlaw and Cindy Meyerold were busy reactivating the finding aspect of the T.O.T. system, and Cindy was continuing to manage the ongoing collection processes. A review of the T.O.T. system at that time pointed out that we needed to revive and reactivate the assessment systems, or subsystem, and the audit subsystems, which we had been doing.

1:36:02 Just as all lodging operators, whether they have one unit or 500 or more, are obliged to collect the TOT, the taxes, from the lodging visitors, the code, Municipal Code Chapter 3.12, also obliges the town to collect those taxes. And in accordance with that code, we've been developing our assessment and audit systems. As a marker of our progress,

1:36:30 Earlier this year, we conducted a workshop with the Town Council and the community to let them see the progress being made, but also to show a sense of the order of magnitude of potential assessments on non-compliant lodging operators. Meanwhile, Mark and Cindy continued to send out warning notices to people about this, that they needed to get things in order, that they needed to be operating in the proper zones.

1:37:00 Have the proper business tax certificate and TOT certificate and be paying the appropriate TOT taxes. We have now started sending out assessments as a matter of course. Just like we've been sending out, Mark's team has been sending out regular letters every week, warning letters to these operators. We've now started sending out assessments in the same type of process and we've now also started performing audits.

1:37:28 And we have audits continuing to be scheduled forward as well as assessments. And that concludes my report. I just wanted to make sure that the council was current and where we're at now in getting the full TOT system running. Mike, do we have any indication or any guesstimate on what numbers we're looking at? In total? I'm glad you asked that question.

1:37:58 We've, to date, from August of last year, just all the noticing efforts and getting the word out has brought in about 153,000. And the assessments we've got now are over 400,000 out there. And the people seem to be communicating with us? They're definitely communicating with us, yes. Okay, good. Thanks. Do you have any questions? Okay, thank you, Michael. Appreciate it.

1:38:31 Are there any other department reports, emerging issues? Okay. And with that, we'll go ahead and move on to the consent agenda. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to remove for discussion consent agenda item number 11, please. And I'd also like to remove four and five. Okay. Anybody else?

1:39:02 Mr. Mayor, I'll move for Council approval of Consent Agenda Items 6, 7, 8, 9, 10, 12, and 13. I'll second that. Do we have a motion and a second? Yes. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Eason? Yes. Councilmember Ray Logan? Yes. Mayor Ramon? Yes. Mayor Ramon? Yes. Mayor Ramon? Yes. I just, I pulled four and five, Ray, just if we could take an opportunity to

1:39:30 Educate the public as to what we're doing on those two items and because I think it's important that the public knows that these are two really nice positive projects. Sure, thank you. I appreciate the opportunity. Item four is the award of a contract for construction Lakeview Boulevard ice melt project. Most of us know that Lakeview Boulevard is also known as the voodoo shoot. It's that steep section.

1:39:57 A road that connects Lake Mary Road to Lakeview Road. And for years there's been problems there with ice buildup and cars sliding down through Lake Mary Road, not able to get up the slope due to ice. This is a grant project that will fund the improvements to install an ice melt system to mitigate those problems that we've had over the years. The only

1:40:25 There's a little bit of general fund money going into this project, but it's primarily grant-funded money, grant-funded project, and some Measure U money, $20,000, and Measure U will pay for this project. The heat will initially be generated through a propane system, but the way it's designed is that we will be able to retrofit that to a geothermal system or...

1:40:51 What was originally designed was a downhole heat exchange system. It just became too expensive. So we've sort of fallen back to plan B and revised the scope. So great project. It's a safety improvement project. And I think the community, the residents and visitors here will appreciate the change when it's done. This project should be done this fall. So we'll have it in place for next month. Great. Thank you.

1:41:21 Item 5 is award a contract for construction of the Sierra Park and Sierra Nevada Safe Routes to School Project. This project includes improvements on Sierra Nevada, sidewalk improvements between Sierra Park and Old Mammoth Road, and it also will complete Sierra Park Boulevard down to 203, so we'll see a full-width street essentially from where the sidewalk ends.

1:41:50 Near the hospital down to 203. The ditch that's currently there right behind the AOC or the court building will be piped and we'll see a new sidewalk there and again a full width road. Drainage improvements, you know how it's kind of messy by McDonald's and the driveway and the ponds there all the time. We'll be fixing all of that so we'll have a nice complete street all the way from 203 up to Meridian.

1:42:18 And again, it's a safe routes project. The AOC, or the Administrative Office of the Courts, is contributing $120,000 to this project. That is going towards their off-site improvement requirements, so they're partially funding the project as well. Again, it'll be a nice result when it's completed, and that project will also be completed this summer. And it's grant money as well? Grant money as well, yeah.

1:42:45 I'm not positive, but I believe that it was at the time Councilmember or Mayor Kathy Cage who researched and found the Safe Routes to School grant monies, the funding for that. So I think it's to Kathy's credit that she started that program a number of years ago and it's made...

1:43:07 Significant improvements for our school district. Yeah, we've been quite successful in winning those grants, so it's a great program. Thank you. Sure. Ray, I had a quick question on those. Currently, the sidewalk, I think they just finished a piece of it on the corner of Sierra Park Road and Tavern, and it's on that northern side where the industrial building is. It stops right there. Yes.

1:43:33 What's going to happen with the rest of that? Is it going to extend on? Right now, one of the requirements is that you meet ADA requirements, including accessible wheelchair ramps. So we had to include that in the project. There's new wheelchair ramps on either side of that intersection, including the one that you just described on the north side. So what you see there is a standard ramp.

1:44:02 There isn't currently any sidewalk planned on the north side of Tavern that would extend back towards Old Mammoth Road. Not to say that it couldn't be built, but the fact is that we had to install a wheelchair ramp there. That particular design was chosen because of existing utilities, and it just facilitated the construction to use that particular design.

1:44:26 Okay. And is that town property or is that the... It's within the town right away, yeah. Okay. So is it going to be landscaped where that is or... There's existing grass on either side of the wheelchair ramp. Okay. One other thing I might add is that going north from that ramp, there's existing sidewalk that's really substandard, it's narrow, it's kind of old and beat up. We're hoping we have enough money in our Sierra Park project budget, and I think we will,

1:44:55 To install new concrete sidewalks on that side of the street. So it'll freshen everything up, give it a new look, and again, improve drainage. Thank you. Sure. While I have you, sir, I also pulled number 11. Thank you. A question was raised. We have benefit assessment districts around town.

1:45:25 I don't know what the number is. Let's say there's five or six maybe in different areas of town, including the Old Mammoth Road Benefit Assessment District. And we generate revenues from those districts each year. There's an assessment to the property owners there. And that money goes towards operations of snow removal on the roads as well as improvements and maintenance.

1:45:56 of the roads. Particularly in this area, do we have a time frame, a ten year time frame where we do an overlay and things like that? Do we have a situation that has arised except for this past winter where we have five or six heavy winters out of ten and we've used more of that funding in the Benefit Assessment District for snow removal?

1:46:29 And I'm concerned that we don't have enough money left over to do the maintenance on those roads. How does that work? Can you explain that? Sure. In this particular case, the Bluffs District, that's a maintenance district, so we are responsible for snow removal, maintenance of the road itself. Town forces don't do that work. It's contracted out. You'll note that this year, on these particular districts that are before you tonight, there's no increase in assessment.

1:46:58 Last year, if I'm not mistaken, on the Bluffs District, we did increase the assessment to cover an overlay that will be done, I believe it's next year, next summer, so it's certainly in need of an overlay, some rehab, we do crack sealing up there to try to calm down some of the cracks in the road, but we plan to overlay that road. I don't want to, this is consent agenda and I don't want to

1:47:28 Take any action other than consent agenda, but I'd like to maybe see an agenda bill at some point, let's say in August, where maybe we can have the council give input to staff and possibly do some kind of an update or a report for the status of funding in those accounts and also, and we may already have this information and when

1:47:56 These benefited assessment districts wherever they may be located when they can expect overlay of the roads. Right. And we do annually do engineer's reports that provide the information that you were just suggesting. So I think those will be coming forward. And we can certainly expand on that report to the council.

1:48:19 Not necessarily a workshop, but maybe just a little bit more information in terms of how these districts work, you know, what the purpose of them are, and how the funding works. Great. Final thing. I don't believe they are, but the funding in benefit assessment districts is not vulnerable to the MLLA lawsuit. No, these are special districts. Special districts, okay. So that funding is not in jeopardy. Thank you. I think that's right, but yeah. Okay.

1:48:49 Good. Thank you, sir. Sure. Having said that, I would like to go ahead and move the Council approve Consent Agenda Items 4, 5, and 11. I'll second that. I have a motion and a second. Council Member Deacon? Yes. Council Member Eason? Yes. Council Member Runyoner? Yes. Council Member Runyoner? Yes. Mayor Layton? Yes. Mayor Layton? Yes. Okay. The motion passes. 5-0. We'll go ahead and move on to the public hearing.

1:49:17 Item number 14, adoption of the town's fiscal budget, year 2012-13. So with that, Mariana. Dear council members, this is an exciting night. We're adopting our annual budget. Our budget is balanced. We're adopting it on time. The state of California should take a cue from the town of Manor Place.

1:49:45 With that, I do have a presentation. We have had a number of meetings on the budget, and you have seen the same format of the presentation over and over again. There are some things that I'm going to repeat for the record because it is a budget adoption night, but I have attempted to keep my comments as brief as possible. So what we're going to be talking about tonight is a pressure on the town's fiscal challenges.

1:50:15 A budget reduction plan that addresses those fiscal challenges and most importantly the annual budget shortfall of $2.8 million. Also the plan, that same plan that creates a cash flow that is going to be available for a settlement was MLLA and other creditors. We also will touch upon a long-term fiscal forecast that has been prepared by FCI and

1:50:44 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:51:13 Nevertheless, I'll walk through the fiscal challenges again, mostly for the record. The fiscal year 12-13 baseline shortfall is $2.8 million. Now keep in mind that last fiscal year's shortfall was $2.7 million. It's not the same $2.7, $2.8. It's cumulative. Last fiscal year a year ago with balance, a shortfall of $2.7 million, things have deteriorated.

1:51:42 And therefore this year we're balancing yet an additional shortfall of $2.8 million. This represents a 14% gap, quite a significant gap in our budget. The $2.8 million baseline shortfall did not take into account a payment to MLLA. And the reason for the baseline shortfall is simple. The town's available revenues are simply not growing at the same rate that the expenses are growing.

1:52:11 Or put it in a different manner or a different way, our revenues actually are shrinking and our expenses continue to grow. The town already has a high level of taxation. You made a call that in May of this year we presented to you a study that FTI has conducted for us on the tax level here in the town.

1:52:41 Touch upon that study later on. But basically it showed that the current taxation level in the town is relatively high. In addition to that, even if the level of taxation was low, we are not able to impose taxes or increase taxes without voter approval. The town, in addition, has made significant cuts over the years, and those cuts are documented in the report tonight.

1:53:05 As well as previous reports. And all of our budget reports, all of them since February, all of our presentations, our detailed budget documents are all available online. The result of the cuts that have been made in the last few years is an organization that is bare bones. We have cut ourselves to the bone. This last fiscal year, a year ago,

1:53:30 We start touching, we start cutting areas that are high priority for the town such as tourism, housing and transit. The town's budget reduction plan which again has been presented previously and the details are available in your packet. I'll walk a little more detail to the budget reduction plan but in general

1:53:56 The budget reduction plan, given that our level of taxation is high, given that we cannot impose in peace taxes, given that we've cut so much already in the last few years, it was extremely difficult for us to come up with yet an additional $2.8 million. However, this council, town staff, and all of our partners, such as MLH, MLT, ASTA, and other contractors,

1:54:24 Have shown extreme leadership in developing this budget reduction plan. And this budget reduction plan attempts to do the following. To adjust the town's expenditures and revenues through specific measures. To create a surplus that is available for a settlement with MLLA.

1:54:44 And to put the town on a sustainable footing so we don't continue going through this process every single year. We don't know what the next year is going to bring, but hopefully the measures that we're about to approve tonight are going to be sustainable measures. The budget reduction plan is presented in attachment A.

1:55:04 And it does reflect the adjustments that have been made to this plan since it was last presented on May the 16th. I'd like to take a little bit of time because I think it's important for us to do that tonight and walk you through the attachment A for a couple of reasons. One is I need to make a correction and I advise the attachment A is available for the audience and perhaps the council members. We found a typographical error.

1:55:33 But let me take the time to walk you through the attachment A, perhaps not through every single line item, but through some of the most significant line items. And as I walk you through the reduction plan, let me also state up front that the town, as you're aware, as we talk to you and the community about, is in the mediation process, a state-mandated mediation process.

1:56:00 The mediation by law is a confidential process, however, we have obtained confidentiality waivers from the participating parties, and we're able to talk a little more freely about the process tonight. So a lot of the adjustments that you see in the balancing plan are discussed in that mediation process. So for example, employee concessions.

1:56:24 The town's employees mainly are part of various union associations, and all of those associations have existing contracts that do not expire until June of 2014. We have requested concessions from the unionized and non-unionized employees of 10% for the civilian staff and 24% for the sworn staff.

1:56:50 And those figures show the student savings from those concessions. We are reducing by 10% our lease payments on this property, police building, as well as the ice rink. Departmental reductions, there are really a number of them. And again, I'll just try to highlight the most significant ones. Across all departments, overtime is going to be reduced by $100,000. Now, the maturity of this reduction is going to happen in the police department.

1:57:20 There is a statement or a description of the impacts from the police chief that addresses both this overtime reduction as well as the potential loss of two police officers if that were to happen as part of the police union reduction. And those impacts follow Exhibit A.

1:57:43 Some of the other major impacts is the discontinuation of the general fund subsidy for MLTPA in the amount of $70,000. There are a number of position reductions that are listed, and there's a column that talks about potential layoffs. On page 2 of this document, or handwritten page 12,

1:58:07 There are a number of additional reductions. For example, the third line from the top talks about two position reductions in public works to save $126,000 along with some other savings. A number of contracts are going to be duties to cancel. For example, the town wishes to cancel the animal shelter contract with the county.

1:58:33 There's elimination of position in community development and so on. The last few lines on page two of this exhibit are highlighted and they represent divisions since the plan presented to you on May the 16th. As part of the budget analysis and mediation process, we have determined that

1:58:59 The FBO, the general aviation contract at the airport must be revised. It's simply not financially sustainable. It's a conversation that we've had for quite some time with the service provider and that the impact of the division to that contract is a revenue loss to the town of $135,000. To offset that revenue loss, a number of changes have been made.

1:59:27 Mainly the elimination of the airport director position as well as a maintenance supervisor position in public works. A couple of positions were added back, for example, in the airport additional help is needed with maintenance as well as admin duties. So those are the changes that you see highlighted on page two. Moving on to page three or handwritten page 13 of exhibit A.

1:59:57 You see reductions in voter-committed funding, and those are the reductions that continue from the current year and increase. I mentioned my remarks a few minutes ago that a year ago we did reduce funding to these three areas of tourism, housing, and transit. Those reductions now continue and again are being increased.

2:00:18 Generally, we start with a reduction of 10% to those areas. However, because we are somewhat confident that we will generate additional transient occupancy tax revenues through enforcement, which is an item on this plan, those three areas will get 5% back. So the net reduction to them is likely to be 5%, and that's how we're going to budget it. The correction that I'd like to make, and again, a corrected copy has been distributed.

2:00:48 While we have been talking and have communicated to MLH that the reduction is 5%, this exhibit showed that they would actually get some more money from the town, which was not the intent. So the line that says less return of 5% of TOT enforcement.

2:01:07 That shows a return of $38,000 in a change has been revised on the corrected printout to show the return of $17,000 in a change. So MLH's contract will be reduced by 5%. The next item is, as I mentioned a minute ago, enhancement in COT revenue collection through additional enforcement. And Mike Deng spoke about this a few minutes ago in his remarks.

2:01:36 Lastly, this budget adds $250,000 to road rehabilitation. The ideal funding level for this expense is $1.5 million annually. This would fund half of that need, that's $750,000, which really puts us in danger of our roads getting worse and worse, but we feel that this is the maximum that we could afford to spend in the next few years.

2:02:05 So that's attachment A. I think what I would like to do with the council's permission and the mayors is continue going through the slides and then if there are any questions we could discuss there. FTI's fiscal forecast, again, is available on the town's website. We presented it publicly, I believe, on May the 2nd. And the forecast suggests that once you take into account the balancing plan that we have,

2:02:33 There is an estimated $3.6 million in net funds generated in the first five years of the forecast, which is the next five calendar years or fiscal years, and an additional $550,000 on an annual basis after that. So $3.6 million in the first five years and $5.5 per year in the following years.

2:03:02 FTI also conducted a tax study for the town. It was presented to the council previously. The analysis was necessary to assess the feasibility of increasing taxes, even though we know, as I mentioned previously, we cannot do that without voter approval. But the FTI effort concluded that the current level of taxation in the town is already high. The town's population is generally not wealthy.

2:03:29 And the town's economy is not likely to sustain additional tax burden. And again, that study is available online. The budget documents that are in your packet, and some of them are available online, are as follows. We have a very detailed budget document for you. Every year we continue proving on the document. This version includes budget highlights for every single department. It includes the organizational charts and so on.

2:03:58 The document, we only made a few copies, mainly for the council and key staff, but a detailed document is available online on the town's website. The budget reduction plan, we just walked over that document, it is available also online. FTI's long-term forecasts, along with the tax study, are online. And there's a budget facts publication, which is basically a four-page summary of this document.

2:04:27 That is also available online. Annual budget legislation that we ask you to approve tonight includes in attachment B budget adoption resolution, legislation to establish the town's appropriation limit, which is something that we're required to do by law, by state law on an annual basis, and legislation to approve the town's investment policy, which again is included in your package.

2:04:53 Attachment C. As I discussed in the report itself, attachment C includes the budget, includes the resolutions to implement an aspect of the budget reduction plan. And the aspect is as follows. Let me just step back and kind of explain and give you a little bit of background, mainly for the public. The town pays for town employees into the Culper's retirement system.

2:05:23 Under the Culper's plan, there's a town portion of retirement and there's an employee portion of retirement. Historically, in many places, employers, i.e. towns and cities and counties and so on, have chosen to pay both. And years ago, the employee portion was zero, so it was easy to pay because it was zero. Then it grew to 8% and 9%. So currently, for the non-safety employees, the employee portion is 8%.

2:05:51 The public safety portion is 9%, in addition to the town's portion, which is around 20%. So what the balancing plan assumes is that the employees will begin paying their own share, i.e. 8 to 9% of retirement beginning July 1st. And the resolution is necessary in order for culpers to implement that change.

2:06:15 Now, they're actually, and I think I pointed out later, there are four resolutions attached, so I may as well do that right now, as opposed to three that I mentioned in the agenda bill, and we also noticed that one of the resolutions was printed twice, so five resolutions are in your packet, or pages 32 and 33, handwritten pages, those two resolutions are identical, they were just printed twice, but when we approve them, we'll approve them as four.

2:06:44 On a positive note, we correctly anticipated who the next mayor is going to be in, so you see Mr. Lane has named it. Implementation of 12-13 budget. It is important to note that some of the measures that are presented in the budget reduction plan have already been implemented or are in the process of being implemented. The layoffs that are in the plan are, some of them have happened, others are about to happen.

2:07:15 Some other reductions require significant concessions from employee unions, changes to property leases, changes to contractual agreements and so on. As I mentioned, we are on mediation and we hope that agreements in that mediation are going to be signed by June 29th, before the beginning of the fiscal year. If some or many agreements are not reached, the town intends to implement

2:07:42 All of the balancing measures included in the balancing plan on July 1st, whether we have agreements or not. That may mean that we will be breaching some of the agreements, but we intend to implement all of the balancing measures as presented in the balancing plan on July 1st. We have to work on the choice. The request of council action tonight is to approve the three budget resolutions and four retirement pickup resolutions. I believe that...

2:08:14 This is my presentation, and I'm available for questions, and so is Seth. Thank you. Are there any questions of Council or comments? Okay. I'm having none. Are there any questions or comments of public? All right. Well, then, with that, we'll close the public hearing and Council deliberate. John, do you want to? I have no discussion. I'm prepared to make a motion.

2:08:56 Mr. Mayor, I'll move that the Town Council approved the attached legislation, including items one through four, as well as attachments A, B and C. A, B, C. Second. Okay. Before we do roll call, Rick, did you have some questions? I don't have questions, but I do have some comments. I think this is my 10th or 11th budget.

2:09:32 This budget would not have come together without

2:10:02 Our, I think, former interim town manager and now, I believe, assistant town manager, Mariana Marysheva-Martinez. And I think, I think that it's important to recognize her and, of course, many other members of staff, two of whom are here, Cindy Myrold and, of course, Dave Wilbrecht, for the work that went into this.

2:10:31 Fundamentally, we have changed the approach, and that approach changed after essentially turning over every stone and finding out things that no prior council probably in the history of Mammoth Lakes has known about how municipal finance works, how our government has worked. And, you know, we've seen some things that for me have been shocking.

2:10:59 In their scope. Monies that we thought we had, we didn't. Things that we spent our money on that we didn't know about. Things that were shortfalls in revenues that were in some instances anticipated and others not. It's been an extraordinary process and it's been going for six months. Now what we did a year ago

2:11:25 We wanted to accomplish a couple of things. One is that we wanted to make the budget process easier to read. And we've succeeded in doing that, I think, because if you look online, it's very, very readable without getting into the dozens and hundreds of pages of detail that go into the line-by-line items. And the second thing is that we have looked differently or

2:11:55 Tried to do things differently. The way we deliver services will be different. We have less money. The level of service delivery will be different. We have less money. We identified a couple of years ago, and there were some seated in the room who were on a committee that made some recommendations that had been adopted. We identified a structural deficit, and it's come to pass.

2:12:25 What we have now is something that, in my judgment, is conservative and fiscally prudent. And what I've been simply amazed at in this six-month period of time in the discussions that we've had among council is, one, how little rancor. We haven't had the budget battles. We haven't had the policy priority battles that we have had in the past.

2:12:50 I think hard times probably gets us there. Hard times allows us to be on the same page, makes it easier for us to go forward and try to figure out how as an entity we're going to survive in these times. And there's a lot of credit to council members who are seated here in not taking things that they might be very, very interested in and not...

2:13:17 Compromising on those items. We've compromised on everything. We've cut everything. There isn't anything that I can think of that has been cut, that has not been cut. And as a consequence, you can imagine that the rancor that you see on the national level and the state level would be really easy to fall into and to engage in. We just haven't done that.

2:13:40 Again, I credit in some measure our staff, in some measure our former mayor and certainly the other council members in getting us to this. I saw something in the paper last week about there being an apparent lack of transparency in this process. On the contrary, it's been extraordinarily transparent. We've put things up online. We've been available for questions. It is true that we've been in a lot of closed sessions. As we know, we've got a

2:14:09 Looming potential bankruptcy on our hands. We're in a mediation process. We're asking for blood from everybody. And it appears that a lot of that has gone on behind closed doors. But if you really look closely at this budget, what you see is that the priorities that have been established by previous councils are largely adhered to by this council.

2:14:33 And those priorities come from the values that have been stated from this community, from members of this community. And so I know we're not going to have a lot of discussion about it tonight because we've had six months of discussion among ourselves, but I can assure you that we're doing the very best that we can to try to make things work.

2:14:59 I'm very happy to be able to do this. I think six months ago, if you had suggested that we would be able to get this done in the way that we'd done, I would not have thought so. But here we are. And I think that it is simply worth stating. That's the reason why I wanted to make those comments, Mr. Mayor. Thank you. Thank you, Council Member Wood. Anybody else have anything? I would like to make a quick comment, and that's just, thank you.

2:15:26 Rick for stating that. There has been a lot of hard work gone into this. And I think there's been even a frustration level with the council that we haven't been able to, whether it be legal or otherwise, be transparent with the community. It's certainly not intentional. It's certainly not something we prefer. But we've done a lot of work. There's been a lot of good decisions. And it hasn't all just been cutting. It has been truly restructuring. We're looking toward the future at not just...

2:15:55 Looking back on our cuts, but also now we have to really place a great focus on revenue generation and changing the way we do some of those things. So thank you for that. It's really hard to follow that, Rick. That's great. And with that, we have a motion and a second. So, Jamie? Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Wilson? Yes. Councilmember Brown? Yes. Councilmember Brown? Yes. Councilmember Brown? Yes. Mayor Lane? Yes. Okay, motion passes 5-0.

2:16:22 Okay, with that we'll move on to policy matters, item number 15, which is Measure R spring funding. So with that, Stuart. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. Good evening. Mayor Lehman, Councilmembers, staff, community. So the proposed action before you this evening is the approval of the 2012 Measure R spring funding recommendations made by the Recreation Commission on June 12, 2012 in the amount of $294,500.

2:16:56 The award also includes the final payment to MLTPA of $46,000 for projects identified and approved in the Town of Mammoth Lakes slash MLTPA Amendment 1 and 2 that was approved by Town Council on December 1, 2010. The resolution before you in your agenda bill appropriates $294,500 of measure our funds for fiscal year 2012-13 and reallocates $46,000 of measure our funds.

2:17:25 for the MLTPA agreement from fiscal year 2011-12 to 2012-13. Just briefly, for the benefit of the public that wasn't at the workshop before us and mightn't have been following the measure-up process, the application period for the 2012 award process opened on April 2nd and closed on May 2nd. Eight applications were received for a total request of $535,500. All those applications are available for you online.

2:17:55 Funding requests were subsequently revised by the applicants due to Measure U funding by Town Council on May 16th that the Recreation Commission took into consideration. The Recreation Commission conducted the first of two special hearings on May 15th and the second and final hearing was conducted on June 12th. All these applicants, all project applicants were in attendance and both the meetings were broadcast and webcast to the public.

2:18:34 So the project recommendations and the options in the Agenda Bill are identified on page 4. So at this time I would conclude my presentation briefly and just seek direction from the Mayor and Council on how you'd like to proceed. From the previous discussion in the workshop I know there's a request by the Council that I can certainly read if you wish that would be included in the motion before you this evening. Any questions of Stuart?

2:19:06 Are there any questions of counsel? Does that mean that you've got some wording for us? I do. Okay. Since there's nothing from counsel or anything from the public, can anybody from the public like to add anything? Okay. Well, then with that, we'll go ahead and... Oh, I'm sorry. Yeah. Yeah. So we're going to also take a look here at attachment A. I don't know if everybody got that, so I want to make sure they did. All right.

2:19:40 Question on that? On attachment A? Yeah. Okay. If you're ready to go. Yeah, go ahead. Going over those, going over the recommendations, there's nothing on there that's anything to addition of Lake Mary Trail down Main Street that I wanted to see if we can put that on there to discuss. You know, I think there's a big need for that. I think that I would like to, you know, bring it up. Okay.

2:20:11 Could I make a suggestion, Michael, that we did discuss this just a little bit in the workshop about whether or not additional portions of Main Street would have things is that we send that back to the Coordinating Committee and Public Works to discuss. My reason being that we said we would provide a minimum of $300,000 and that if there were other things they could bring it forward to us.

2:20:38 And so to let them deal with where it would come in and approve this so that this can happen this summer, but even within the measure, our fall award or even in between, there could be a request for additional funds if it's seen as a priority and then that gives us the opportunity to discuss the priorities. Yeah, that makes a lot of sense to me. Although I don't disagree, it's very important.

2:21:06 piece of the overall plan I want to I'm very impressed with this list of 30 or 40 actual projects and don't want to take away from them but I think to Jo's point it's it's a good one and it could very well be that the priorities during the fall award process would reflect if the Main Street Trail comes to the

2:21:36 So essentially we're looking at possibly including this attachment and then coming back with

2:22:05 A recommendation to take a look at the ministry in the fall. Or asking the committee, the coordinating committee in public works to figure out. To take it on, yeah. Okay. And the reason I'm saying it, Michael, is my feeling is that normally in that case we've got to get either state or federal money and something like Measure R's can only afford the matching funds. But where we've made other things a priority, staff has been able to go out and find those grants.

2:22:36 Yeah, I just, I think it's an important piece that I'd like to see us work on. Okay, so we'll ask them to take a look at that then in the fall. Sure. Okay. Mr. Mayor, my only comment, other comment is, especially after that bad news that I was talking about just a few minutes ago was what great news this is. To be able to award $300 plus thousand for things that this community says it wants and needs.

2:23:05 It's great. I agree. Any other comments or questions? Okay. Do we then have a motion? Mr. Mayor, I would move that we approve the Measure Our Spring funding recommendations in Table 1, adopt the resolution, and approve Attachment 1, which is the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee final project recommendations. We'll second them. We have a motion and a second.

2:23:38 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, motion passes 5-0. And with that, we're going to move on to item number 16, which is a discussion on the Measure U Steering Committee's application. And I'm going to actually have to recuse myself from this one. So with that, Mayor Pro Tem, Wood, if you could.

2:24:08 Takeover, please. Sure. The agenda item is to approve Measure U Steering Application Committee 2012 Measure U Spring Test Additional Funding Recommendations and approve a resolution related to that. Stuart? Thank you, Councilor Wood. Sorry, Mayor Pro Temer Wood. Yeah, so just as a little bit of a background, again, for the council and the public,

2:24:35 On May 16, 2012, Town Council did approve the Measure U Steering Application Committee's 2012 Measure U Spring Test Funding Recommendations in the amount of $653,215. Those allocations can be seen in Attachment A of your Agenda Bill. Town Council also adopted a resolution appropriating $30,000 of Measure U funds for this fiscal year and directed staff to budget the balance of those funds.

2:25:03 In Fiscal Year 2012-13. At that meeting, Town Council also directed staff to convene the Measure U Steering Application Committee to consider funding any 2012 Measure U Spring Test applicants that were not fully funded using the balance of Fiscal Year 2012-2011-2012 Measure U funds.

2:25:28 Staff determined that between May 7th, which was when the award was recommended by the Steering Application Committee, and June 12th is when they met, a total of $92,326.24 had accrued in the MeasureU fund and was available for allocation. And the attachment is B, which provides a detailed analysis of those funds that are available. The MeasureU Steering Application Committee met on June 13th.

2:25:55 And this date was scheduled after the Recreation Commission made their 2012 Measure R spring funding recommendations. Let me just turn the page. As several 2012 Measure U spring test applications required matching funds from Measure R. So there was joint applications that were in both funds at the time. At that meeting, the committee determined that two applications qualified for additional funding.

2:26:24 They were the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition for the Summer Arts and Culture Events Support, and the second was the Mammoth Lakes Foundation for the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theatre. Those two applications are also included in your agenda bill on that page two. I'm not sure I need to read them out, but essentially the Events Coalition requested $88,600, and they were sure taking out an application that withdrew

2:26:54 From that funding request, they were short $25,385. The Mammoth Lakes Foundation requested $85,000 of funds. They were awarded $40,000, so they were short $45,000. So the recommendation was made and the motion was approved by the Measure Use During Application Committee to fund the Events Coalition to the balance of $25,385 and the Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

2:27:22 to $45,000. That motion was unanimously approved that evening. So the options before you is just to approve the Measure U Steering Application Committees 2012, Measure U Spring Test, additional funding recommendations, and the resolution appropriating $70,385 of Measure U funds accrued and unallocated from May 7 through June 12, 2012 for fiscal year 2012-13.

2:27:53 That concludes my presentation. Thank you, sir. Questions from Council? No. Comments or questions from the audience? All right. Seeing none, I'll entertain a motion. I'll move approval of the Steering Application Committee's additional funding recommendations and the attached resolution. Second the motion. All right. There's been a motion and a second as stated. If no further discussion, roll call, Jamie. Council Member Bacon? Yes. Council Member Eason? Yes. Council Member Raymondo? Yes. Council Member Raymondo? Yes.

2:28:27 Yes. Motion passes 4-0. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, so we'll move on to item number 17, which is the airport layout plan. So with that, Jen. Thank you, Mayor Lehman, council members. Jen Daugherty, associate planner with the community development department. The purpose of this item is for the town council to provide staff direction regarding the formal submittal.

2:29:21 of the airport layout plan update narrative to the FAA for review and comment. The ALP update narrative describes the development criteria and rationale for the existing and proposed facilities necessary for the operation and development of the airport. It includes a 20-year aviation forecast, an analysis of changing the airport designation from B3 to C3. It identifies current airport obstructions and deviations from standards.

2:29:51 And identifies those that we propose to correct when funding becomes available and those that we are requesting FAA-approved modifications to standards for. The draft ALP update narrative was prepared by the Town's airport consulting engineer in July of 2011 and over the past year has received extensive public input and comments, including a professional peer review by Mead and Hunt. The Town has worked and continues to work with the FAA through this process.

2:30:22 And as a result, FAA comments and direction have been incorporated into the ALP update narrative. We have also incorporated airport commission direction. The airport commission has spent extensive time on this as well. Public comments and recommendations from Meadenhunt's peer review report. On May 22nd, the airport commission recommended that the ALP update narrative with modifications be formally submitted to the FAA. Their modifications are included in the errata sheet attached to your packet.

2:30:53 On June 13th, the Planning Commission found that the ALP update narrative is consistent with the town's general plan and also recommended that it be forwarded on to the FAA. Throughout this process, we have received extensive public comments from both Mr. Owen Molloy and Mr. Stephen Kalish. During the professional peer review, Meaden Hunt responded to 283 comments received, and since that time, staff has continued to receive additional public comments, which we have reviewed and responded to

2:31:23 By incorporating them into the ALP update narrative or the errata sheet as appropriate. The June 18th letter provided by Mr. Kalish to Council contains comments that we have previously received and reviewed and incorporated as appropriate. It's important to note that during the professional review, peer review done by Mead and Hunt, that they found that the ALP update narrative is in conformance with aviation industry and FAA standards, that the aviation forecast is appropriate for facility planning at the airport,

2:31:54 They reminded us that non-standard conditions are common at airports, and they did state that it was anticipated that the FAA will require a timeline or a schedule for the town to correct deviations from standards that are being requested. However, Mead and Hunt did recommend that the town move forward with this, submit it to the FAA so we can start our discussions with the FAA for review and comment, and we can discuss how to revise the ALP update narrative as directed by the FAA.

2:32:25 And with that, I would be happy to answer any questions. We have our staff team here, Mark Wardlaw, Ray Jarvis, Brian Hicken, and also our airport commission chair, Pam Murphy. Okay. Thank you, Jen. Are there any questions from council? No questions. No. No questions at all. Are there any questions from the public? Any comments? Okay. I'm seeing none out there.

2:33:00 Do we have a motion? Quick comment. I will be supporting the recommendation tonight, and I think we've tried really, really hard in a number of areas to address the concerns of the public on this issue, and personally, I'm at the point where I don't feel that the public is going to be, that I can't make the public happy, so I'm comfortable with

2:33:29 The number of people that we've had involved, whether it's our local staff member, our consultants, our commission, and so I think we've done a really good job to get to where we are, and so I will be supporting the recommendation. I support it as well, and just want to state that I was really impressed at our last workshop with the airport commission with the

2:33:56 The level of detail that they had, the knowledge that they had, and the perspective that they brought to the process, and it certainly makes me feel comfortable with that, which is coming forward is as thorough as it possibly could have been in coming together, so I'm with you, John. I agree with both of you. I think staff's done a really great job addressing a lot of the issues, a lot of the letters.

2:34:26 From two particular folks. And I'm very supportive of it. And I'll say ditto to all of that and that I look forward to staff and the commission, et cetera, working with whatever the FAA is to find out what their actual comments will be and then responding to those. Ditto all that as well. And I think having two qualified folks look this over and review it and address

2:34:58 Not only the comments, but just the fact that the ALP is in conformance and that we have, you know, a lot of non-standard items at all these airports. I feel comfortable with the work that we've done so far. Mr. Mayor, I wanted to make one more comment, and that is, and most of us in this room already realize it, and that is that we hired a consultant to do our airport plan. And it's a...

2:35:26 consultant who is well respected in the industry, both by the FAA and the cities that this consultant has done work for. And we didn't just do that. We hired a second equally qualified consultant to peer review the work that our consultant did. Never happened before on this. So, I mean, how can we do any better?

2:35:51 Than we've done on this process. So I'm fully comfortable in supporting this. And I'll move for Council's adoption of option number one and direct staff to formally submit the revised airport layout plan update narrative to the Federal Aviation Administration for review and comment without any modifications. Let's second the motion. We have a motion and a second. Yes.

2:36:22 Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Okay. With that, we will move on to item number 18, dealing with the airport commission and mobility commission. Good evening, Mr. Mayor, council members. As you're well aware, this is an item that was tabled at your June 6th council meeting.

2:36:53 You had requested that folks from the commissions provide you with input. I think that's taken place. Chair Hogan from the Mobility Commission was up a bit earlier and shared some of her thoughts. I don't have much to add other than the Mobility Commission did express a desire to have, in the event of a merger, to maintain some kind of Chamber of Commerce representation.

2:37:23 On a new commission, they felt pretty strongly that that was an important piece of that commission going forward, if it is in fact merged. There was also discussion related to social services. One of the purposes of the mobility commission was in fact to try to keep an eye on some of those specific issues related to mobility around town, not just for visitors but for residents of the community.

2:37:52 And the fact that we are providing services that help folks get to work, get to school, doctor's appointment, et cetera, et cetera, those were important characteristics that they felt they would like to see go forward with any change in the commission structure. So with that, I'll have a seat, and if you have questions for me, I'll try to answer them. Okay. Any questions from council? Greg? Are there any questions from the public?

2:38:23 Any comments? Pam? Thank you, Mayor and Council Members. And if you could state your name for the public. Pam Murphy, I'm the Chair of the Current Airport Commission. You heard it at our workshop, and I just wanted to, one more time, make a plea that for a while longer, we keep the Airport Commission intact. As you know, we've done a lot of great work. As Council Member Bacon just stated, there's a lot of follow-up work for that to do. We have a lot of expert.

2:38:59 Expertise on that commission that could help with that at least, I think, to the next six months to a year. We're very, very good with time. Staff will tell you we cancel meetings when we don't have agenda items. We don't ask staff to work when not needed, just really at the very important times. There's a lot of great expertise on the commission right now. We put a lot of years into that ALP and other projects.

2:39:27 I know you have a tough decision to make, and I understand the reasons why, but I really feel it's important to the continuation of the airport, especially with the changes in the manager and at the FAA level with the retirement of the gentleman at the FAA that's been handling the Mammoth program. Really, myself especially, but many other council members aren't the only connection through.

2:39:56 Many changes, both at FAA level and town staff level to continue the good work that's been going on. Pam, do you think, I mean, I get that. I get what you're saying. How do you think combining mobility with airport would impact the work that you're doing or the

2:40:29 I mean, is it a make-up of the commission problem? There's five current members who I know a few haven't resubmitted yet because they're waiting to see which way this goes. There's five current members with that expertise, and the new Transportation Commission has five seats. And every one of the members brings a really good level of expertise.

2:40:55 Right now with the process that we're in and a lot of experience. And so it's really that concern that if it's five positions and without a doubt they're very smart people in the Mobility Commission that would come over who we work very, very well with, but the bringing them up to speed and replacing seats of two of the commissioners would be a concern to me. I think we talked about this at the workshop and spoke to the individual expertise of the members.

2:41:27 Any other questions with Pam? No. Are there any other comments? Thank you, Pam. Are there any comments or questions from public? Okay. Yeah, I'd like to start off. You know, we all had a chance to go away and get input and think about this, and I realized from my perspective, you know, when it was a Tourism and Recreation Commission, it was a seven-member commission.

2:41:55 And we only started downsizing it as the tourism went off and became MLT and that board and everything. I'm wondering if one of the ways to start getting that cross-pollination would be to go forward with a merger but have it start at seven members so that it could incorporate the existing commissioners if they reapply and as well as the two mobility commissioners.

2:42:23 One who would be carrying over and one who has applied and work through some of that and figure out the get that cross-pollination going in an interim period and then revisit it at the end of the next set of terms which would be in two years. And if there were resignations in the meantime that would also be an opportunity to consider how it's going. But, you know, one of the things that was said at that workshop and it's not to say, you know,

2:42:55 Yes, those members have got a lot of background and information, and so do the mobility, but we've heard both, well, it'll be really busy, and it won't be busy at all. And if we're really working towards efficiency and trying to work things together and change things a little bit, I think that, I mean, I've seen members of the Airport Commission on Public Transit in our town, so I know that there's already some knowledge.

2:43:20 In both directions. And so I was just going to throw that out there as an opportunity to go ahead and combine, but make it seven members to start with. Anybody else have any other thoughts? Michael? I'm in favor of keeping it standalone. I think, and I agree with, we talked about it at the workshop, and Pam made a great point. I mean, with our contact at the FAA retiring,

2:43:51 Airport Management here changing or being eliminated. I think we really should rely on the five, four, well, there's I think four, well, five, there's one that didn't reapply, but I think we really should see it through. I think we're at a critical time to see it through. I mean, I almost think mobility, my personal thought is it could even be handled by staff on the mobility side.

2:44:18 I just don't think the timing's right. I'm not saying that six months a year, I mean, once we, you know, get feedback from the FAA, once we make some progress there and then look at it again, I'm not opposed to that, but I just, I think, really should leave it to the Commission to really see this thing through. Okay. Anybody else on Council? John, Rick? Just my thoughts are, um,

2:44:48 That I'm not interested in changing this commission, the makeup of it, or even the personnel, if we're fortunate enough to have a full five-member commission. I just look at it as simply as if it's not broken, don't need to fix it. And the airport commission is an outstanding commission, and it's not broken in my mind, so I'd like to keep it the same. You know, I'm not going to make a commitment forever, but

2:45:17 You know, we'll see if in six months or a year we can always address it again in the future. What would be your suggestion then for mobility? I don't have one at this point, but it's most important for me to keep the airport commission as a five-member commission and keep it as much intact as possible. So,

2:45:49 You know, we went down this road because we were concerned about staff time, efficiency, our ability to afford these commissions, and I've been persuaded by the members of the airport commission with whom I have spoken that it is important enough to segregate its function or to keep it segregated for now. And I think

2:46:18 I think part of the problem is that I didn't have an understanding until the last, at least a clear understanding, until the last workshop of exactly how technical and detailed the subject matter is that they're engaged in. And so that leaves, and so I'm basically with the two of you as well on keeping it as a stand-alone committee for now and perhaps revisiting it later.

2:46:46 The question is, as you raised, well, what do you do with mobility? And I think that we can either not take that on and simply retreat from the position that brought this agenda bill or that has come forward in this agenda bill by simply not taking any action or by adding some mobility members to airport or by disbanding the mobility commission in its entirety.

2:47:15 The thing that, there are two things that come to my mind. One is, I don't really think I want to dilute the strength, if you will, of airport by adding mobility commissioners. I understand, Joe, your comment. Charlie Long, years ago, recommended that tourism and recreation, which were separate, it was parks and recreation, combined, and it would become a seven-member housing, and it didn't work.

2:47:43 Or it didn't work as well and now of course they're back separate. And the theory at the time was very similar which was it would create efficiencies and after all they go together because tourism and recreation, although they're not seamlessly together, they certainly feed upon one another, support one another. So I get the idea.

2:48:08 I think what I don't know is what mobility really does, and I would probably like to hear from mobility, and two, and therefore whether it's really needed, because I don't know if it is. We didn't have it in the past, but we didn't have transit in the past. We didn't have ESTA in the past. The other thing that occurs to me as I've been thinking about this the last couple of weeks is the commissions are the way that we get people more actively engaged and involved in government.

2:48:36 In the interest or in the name of efficiency, we eliminate commissions and we are necessarily pushing people out in a way. And I've always thought that it becomes easier and easier for council to become isolated. We're talking to the same people all the time, the same groups, and that there ought to be broader participation. And the way you do that is to get people to serve on commissions.

2:49:03 They want to do it. It's volunteer. They contribute. They've got knowledge and expertise and different perspective. I just haven't figured it out yet. I haven't balanced it yet in my own mind. And so, John, I think I'm probably with you, which is that I can't make a decision on mobility. I'd probably just leave it as it is and take no action instead for now and perhaps bring it back after we've had an opportunity to have our next workshop with mobility. Sandy, isn't that in July?

2:49:33 Do we have a workshop in July with mobility? No, I don't use it. Oh, okay. I thought I had heard you say that earlier. So, as you can see, I'm still a little muddled on it, but that's the current thinking. Okay. And I like both suggestions. Since you brought it up in our last meeting, I had kicked around similar ideas, whether it was a seven-member transportation board or just leaving things as they are.

2:50:04 And the reason I'm leaning away from the seven-member board is the same reason as you brought up. I didn't want to dilute the airport commission. I do like the idea of seeing a transition over, and this is one good way of doing that. But I think for now, I personally would probably like to see us just retract and go back to where we were with this and allow

2:50:32 Airport mobility just to remain separate. And one of the reasons I would suggest that with mobility is, you know, we do have LTC, which does offer a lot of input on mobility, but I think if we were to get rid of mobility right now, and I'm not opposed to it, but I just don't know if that's going to place an additional burden on staff at this time and if it's going to disconnect us from the community. So I'm

2:51:03 Kind of leaning in favor of just leaving the commissions as they are. Mr. Mayor, I have a question of our town attorney. The way this agenda bill is set up, option number one, can we approve a part of what's in that ordinance, or do we have to take it all? No, no, you can certainly slice the ordinance up and have you approve only those portions that you like. Okay. Easy to do. Okay.

2:51:34 Thank you. My question is, and for staff, maybe someone can answer this. Is mobility something that you guys could take on? Is it, I mean, is it? Actually, Michael, let me answer that one, and I don't think so. And rather than make a quick decision on it, maybe we do just keep it there because there's certain things with the circulation element, the needs assessment, the summer route and winter route review that they do.

2:52:02 Where they bring the community in and they act on the behalf of staff. So they do have assigned duties. And if you go back and look at the code section, they have a number of things that they are given to do that would have to be parceled out in some other way to another commission or something. So maybe instead of maybe leaving it as it is and having that looked at at a later date at the same time the airport commission is better than just deciding they don't. You know, it's the same thing as

2:52:31 Rick's saying, well, you know, I didn't really know what the Airport Commission did, and I've also heard everybody say, well, I don't know what the Mobility Commission does. So before you get rid of something that then you find out you still needed it. Well, I'm not saying – that's what I'm just saying. I'm just wondering on staff's point of view if it's something that they feel that they could take on or not take on or so I can understand a little bit more about it as well. Ray Jarvis, Public Works. We've been working with the Mobility Commission now for

2:53:05 Two years, I believe. We've gotten to a point with that commission where it's become fairly routine, and the fact of the matter is if there are no items to be placed on the agenda that require action and mobility commission, we will cancel meetings. So we're all very mindful of staff time spent on these commissions. I think we're already sort of self-streamlining, if you will.

2:53:32 So to answer your question, yes, I mean, it's certainly something we can continue to do. There are a lot of different outlets that I think Mayor Lehman mentioned, the LTC, Airport Commission, of course, the Town Council. There's other outlets for the community to come and discuss their concerns related to mobility. But the simple answer is yes. I mean, it's something we can continue to do as we have been.

2:54:00 One thing I might add, though, is we've been short a commissioner on that commission. We've been operating with four commissioners. There's five seats. Council chose, I don't recall when that was, last summer maybe, or last fall, not to fill that vacancy because this conversation was anticipated, and so there was no decision made at that time to fill that seat. I would just suggest that if we want to maintain that commission,

2:54:30 They would consider advertising to fill that vacancy. I think Eric Wasserman's application was that he still wanted to be on that. Yeah, I believe the applications were for transportation, so my guess, and we'll address this later as far as what we would have to do in the event. I'm sure we'd have to advertise for both of them. Right. I'm not supportive of that.

2:54:58 Cutting off continuation of the Mobility Commission. I'm happy to have the continuation of the commission at this time. Having said that, I'm prepared to make a motion whenever you're ready. May I make a couple of comments just to, maybe we have streamlined ourselves too much and gotten a little too efficient, but maybe I could remind the council some of the things that we do. We serve as the eyes and ears of the public.

2:55:26 For anything having to do with transit, we hold two transit workshops a year, and changes have been made over the years because people come and they talk about or they send us emails and it comes up and changes are made with ESTA. We serve as actually ESTA's mammoth public hearing. In other words, we are the, and we do it twice a year, which they have like once a year in Bishop and once a year in other areas. We hold two traffic management workshops each year also.

2:55:55 And these are one, again, where if you've noticed feedback signs, radar feedback signs here and there, or like the stop sign in the NOLS, or a reduced speed limit here and there, those are the results of, again, the public being able to come in and make us aware of these issues. And many times, staff, with all due respect, Ray, does not always agree with some of these. But, you know, we are there to represent the public.

2:56:26 And staff, many times, we have these discussions and something does happen because of that. That's why commissions exist, to be, and actually so that the public doesn't come to you. You know, we have some regulars that come back and because of that, if you've driven down Manzanita, there have been so many changes there in response to the requests.

2:56:54 But we do serve that. But besides the fact that we do, we have other things, of course, we review the snow removal policies. We also make recommendations for snow removal, sidewalk snow removal each year for the budget process. Not this year, because we understood the limitations. We also review the CIP, actually, of the, how many projects? Maybe 20, 21 projects on the CIP list this year, all but for water mobility related.

2:57:23 And we make comments on those. In other words, if you look at our annual calendar, we have tried to be efficient and respond. But the fact is, these are things that were there, otherwise it takes up staff time. And staff time is very valuable. So, and we try to make it as efficient as possible. I do think it serves a purpose. As I said, Eric and I were both interested in the airport. He has served on the Hospitality Commission, as a matter of fact.

2:57:52 In my Forest Service days, I actually prepared the environmental assessment, took it over and completed it for the runway safety area. So I'm familiar with a number of the things involved with the airport. A lot of it, of course, is on national forest land. And, of course, there are other permits involved with that. So both of us are quick learners. And I think we were looking forward to this merger. We felt it's a logical one. But if you wish to keep two commissions, we can do that.

2:58:22 Mobility does serve a good purpose, and as the eyes and ears of the community in all matters transportation related, we started back in 2005, I believe, as a tag, the transportation advisory group with 11 or 12 seats, and it was very unwieldy, and then we went down to 7, and slowly but surely we shrank to 5. But anyway, so just to familiarize the council with some of the things that we do, I know we're...

2:58:49 We're a low profile, but we try to do our job well. Thank you, Sandy. I appreciate it. John. I need some help, Andy, if I may. I just want to make sure the motion is correct. What I'm thinking of is making a motion to keep the Airport Commission whole as it is today to reduce the Recreation Commission to a five-member body. Excuse me. Recreation's not part of this one.

2:59:22 We already did that. We did. We could. We could. We could take no action on this item. Take it. Yeah, okay. So no action on that. Take no action would just keep the Airport Commission to Ability Commission intact and then would not form the new Transportation Commission. Thank you. That was easy. So moved. I'll second the motion. We have a motion in the second. Well, but if there's no action, there's no action. There's no action. I'm sorry. I've done a motion.

2:59:49 Yeah. Withdraw my motion. And I'll withdraw my second. Okay. Do we have a motion? No. We just take – our consensus is no action. Okay. That's it. Well, then, with that, a bit of confusion there, we'll go ahead and move on to item number 19 and discuss scheduling interviews for planning, recreation. It will not be transportation. Right. I have a question. Okay. Mobility and – just one second – airport.

3:00:21 Okay. Well, but we've got to do applications for mobility in airports, so. Right, so we need to reopen that. Yeah. We need to reopen, I think. And I have a question about that. Is it possible to just extend the airport commission terms? Yeah, that's what I was asked. Because last time the airport commission plugged their case to keep their current members and reappoint them, and I assume they're going to ask for that again, and she kind of mentioned it tonight.

3:00:49 So is there a reason we have to go through a process if you guys are ultimately going to probably keep the same people? Can we just extend their terms? I think the council has that within its discretion, yeah. So it's an option for you guys if you go. My only concern is one person didn't reapply.

3:01:09 Well, more than one didn't. There are no applications for the airport commission. Because it wasn't advertised. Right, that's separate. We're going to have to advertise for mobility, I'm pretty sure. It sounds as though for airport, we wouldn't have to advertise. We could just reappoint the airport commission as they currently exist. Extend it for one year? Assuming that...

3:01:38 Come on up, Pam. Come on up. There are three members whose terms would be up and would have needed to reapply. If you didn't extend their terms, Perel, not Heller, Heller and I are the ones, Walter and Hughes. But as you saw at the workshop, all three of them have expressed a great concern to stay if you were to either lengthen their term.

3:02:09 Okay. I'm thinking what we may want to do is just reopen it up anyway. Because there may be other applicants. Yeah, there could be other applicants that are very qualified, and then also we don't know who would or wouldn't apply. We can say we're going to appoint somebody, and then they say, well, I'm not going to do it. So I think the right thing to do is just for us to reapply. I'm supportive of that. Yeah. I am as well. Okay.

3:02:40 Have a three-week application period? Is that... You can be whatever you want. Well, we don't meet until July... July 31st? No, we meet July 18th. Is it possible to have it open and close before then so we could be sitting interviews at that time? Yes, that's what I'm... Okay. No legal time frame. Triford, yeah. Okay. Does the time do anything with our submit to the FAA?

3:03:09 No, because that's staff. I believe they're in their term too, July? July 31st. Which works great, and our next meeting is actually the 24th, and right around there, so it's after your next meeting, so if it was a process you could complete by that date, I think that would work very well. Okay. Well then, you just need a consensus for that?

3:03:36 Well, yeah, mobility and airport are going to open the vacancies and advertise, right? Correct. Yes. And then, so we have to schedule interviews for all of these, and I'm assuming... Yeah. Well, one, two, three. You're going to just schedule interviews for planning and recreation. Six, seven, eight. Correct. So for planning and recreation, we'll go ahead and, are we thinking the first meeting in July? We're not having a first meeting in July. That's the fourth. This could be the first meeting, though.

3:04:05 You mean a special meeting? Okay. Oh. So... Well, the other thing I'm going to say is you've got eight people at 15 minutes apiece. That's two hours worth of interviews. Yeah. We're tough. Okay. Yep. Reduce down to seven and a half. So are we thinking then...

3:04:28 So are we doing a special meeting? Is that what? I would not. I would propose doing it before the July 18th meeting at about 3 o'clock. I would agree. Maybe 3.30. Sounds good. Okay. So we'll schedule for 3.30 on July the 18th, is it, or 19th? 18th. Okay, so July 18th we will schedule this. Okay, and that's it.

3:04:59 And with that, we will go ahead and adjourn. I don't know. Oh, yeah, sorry. We are adjourned to the closed session.