TransparentMammoth

Airport Commission · 2012

Airport Commission

· recording 1 hr 8 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

124 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

3:06 I would like to call the meeting to order. We'll go ahead and call the meeting to order. Here. Here. Here. Here. This is the public comments. Is there any members of the public that would like to comment anything not on the agenda for today? Commissioner reports? I'm surprised. I think Commissioner Hughes that you maybe were at one of the meetings of the

4:22 Eastern Sierra Airlines? Yeah. I actually was wondering if John Urdi would be here today, but since he's not... He's out of town and commented that you would be at the meetings. Okay. Update from that? Yeah, well, basically the meeting was convened to try to find mechanisms to fund the air service and try not to get into the same situation we were just in where we...

4:50 We're in a panic mode trying to find some funding and actually had to borrow money out of the Measure U funds. From what John already indicated is that they're investigating such things like a BID, a Business Improvement District. He left it that he was going to get to

5:14 I actually talked to some legal folks on some of the aspects of getting that BID put together, and I don't know if Mark or anybody has some information on that, but he was going to approach some people that actually knew how to do BIDs and get some information. Do you know anything about that, Mark? Initially, John mentioned that the goal was about a million dollars, and that

6:23 They were looking into taking over one flight per year, so it would be a year-round flight that would be actually funded by this BID or whatever other service or other way of funding could be initiated, I guess. And that might include commission-based incentives, I guess, for businesses or just fees or some sort of ad hoc, possibly even sales tax addition, I guess.

6:52 From what I understood from the meeting, a BID of about 0.5% generates approximately $800,000 somewhere in that neighborhood, depending on how big the BID is and who's included with that. And I guess from what I understand, a BID has to identify the business district boundaries and businesses that will be included first, and then it will go on to a petition. And if that's successful, then the council has to enact it.

7:23 So that's my understanding of what happened at the meeting. Thank you. Any other commissioning reports or comments? I was just going to say that I also went to the initial one, not the second one that I think you went to, please. And they were taking some of the initial information from an example in Sacramento that they had had. And I think they are also not using this as a deterrent to following up with other local and regional.

7:53 Outreach for funding as well. We'll go to the consent agenda. First item on the consent agenda is the approval of the regular meeting minutes of January 24th. Do you want to just do these? Chair, this is obviously not honorable. The purpose of the consent agenda is to see those items that they need.

8:31 Easily adopted without discussion or consideration. And so if everybody's satisfied with minutes, someone will make a motion to approve the consent agenda. If somebody wants to pull it, we'll pull it for discussion. So moved. I second. I second. Now to the business matters. And our first is the oath of office, which Jamie did.

9:02 If you could please stand and raise your right hand. And you can repeat it all at the same time. I state your name to solemnly swear. I leave you to solemnly swear. That I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States. That I will support and defend the Constitution of the United States. And the Constitution of the State of California. And the Constitution of the State of California. Against all enemies, foreign and domestic.

9:26 That I will bear true faith and allegiance to the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution of the State of California that I take this obligation freely without any mental reservation or purpose of evasion.

9:47 And that I will well and faithfully discharge the duties upon which I'm about to enter. Thank you. Our next item is selection of officers and committee appointments. So we start with the officers.

10:16 Yes, Chair, you have two officers, the Chair and the Vice Chair, and you should move to nominate, there should be a second for the Vice Chair. Okay, so we have a nomination for Chair. I nominate at least the next. Sure, I also would find the way it is, too. Yes, either way.

10:53 I would nominate Debbie Dutton. If you want to get to me, all in favor? Sure, aye. I really would. Aye. Aye. Sure, we'll mix it up for a colleague. You got it. Mix it up. And then for vice chair, okay, Lee, we would nominate you for vice chair. Oh, okay, well, thank you very much. I accept. So I have a matter of policy.

11:22 Deb now is chair. Does she take over the meeting from here? Yes. We have to move physically, too? Okay. I think it's just... She can stay. Okay, good. I need your help. You got it.

11:54 Okay. Thank you for allowing me to stay today. So we now have to have a selection of officers and committee appointments. And so the committees are... Chair, you have two committees. They're standing now. You should also discuss whether you should have any other committees.

12:23 The ad hoc committees are the Townwide Capital Facilities Committee and also the Municipal Wayfinding and Community Messaging Committee. The current appointment is Anne Murphy to the Capital Facilities Committee, so we should discuss that. And then the current appointments for the Municipal Wayfinding Committee are Commissioners Keller and Commissioner Merrill, Vice Commissioner, Vice Chair, Keith.

12:57 Did the capital committee do anything? We've had, you know, we've had some conversation really especially around the CIP, capital improvement plan, which we reported on, and like maybe Mark can address where it's going more importantly. Chair, the committee had some initial meetings and then we were delayed because we started working more extensively on the

13:27 I'm supporting the Airport Commission and the ALT and also on the TOT and Enforcement and Relative Collection Program. We expect the CFC, the Capital Facilities Committee, to start work again towards the end of fall or perhaps in winter. It happens to be a very important committee and the discussions of Measure U, of Measure R, airport, terminal funding, et cetera, those are all very...

13:54 Is it open for discussion at this point between us? Are these appointed or voted on? You would. You actually can do either way. You can appoint by the chair or you can, through the consensus of the commission, discussing appoint. So it would be appropriate to nominate someone, too.

14:24 So as discussion goes, for continuity's sake or for is there somebody that feels strongly about it that would want to be a part of it or for continuity do you want to remain or how do we... I'm very happy remaining on the Capitol Committee meeting. I know Tom enjoys the Wayfinding meeting. He's not here to answer to that. Okay. And I'd be happy to stay on the Wayfinding Committee as well, if that's appropriate. Can we have two appointees to one?

14:54 You could, however, the terminal facilities committee is a large group, and the attempt is to have one representative from each commission. There are at-large members as well as council members. Would the Eastern Sierra Air Alliance also be another committee? You have a choice if you do that. The Brown Act states that, oh, when you point to a standing commission,

15:23 Thank you for that. At this point in time, you are a volunteer member. You're not actually appointed by the commission. I think it would be more convenient if you remained with, if there was an interested party from the airport commission, if they remained a volunteer person, you're not officially appointed by that commission. Got it. Would you like to weigh in at all?

15:51 Tom, would you like to weigh in at all on the discussion? Well, certainly if Tom Miller wants to continue on the Wayfinding Commission. I was going along, I guess, as a second, but I certainly don't need to be appointed to it. So... Bill, I went through the chair. The question about volunteerism... Is the ESA, I get it. Yeah. So you're... We do notice...

16:15 So may I suggest and discuss still that you remain on the capital improvement and that perhaps you are the volunteer instead of myself for the Eastern Sierra Air Alliance. And then we can leave John, hopefully in his absence, this is a great thing, on the, or Tom, I'm sorry, on the wayfinding committee. It's good to me. All right.

16:48 Next on the agenda, we have the airport layout plan update. Thank you, Chair Corral. I don't think my mic is working either, so I'll try to speak up. This is a really brief update. We formally submitted the ALP after about a year's worth of work to the FAA in July. We received comments from our FAA planner on August 8th.

17:21 That FAA planner was Benny Stuth and now no longer works for the FAA. So we're coordinating with the FAA to determine who our current and new FAA planner will be. We don't know that at this time yet, but we do have an FAA planner assigned to us momentarily to help us work through this process and keep it moving. We are working to address the comments that Benny Stuth provided to us.

17:52 So that we can resubmit the ALP to FAA with those comments addressed. And then the FAA will go through their normal process, which is another completeness review to see if they have any more comments for us. And then route it to the other departments for review as well. Those time periods are 30 days, 30 to 60 days. So we don't really know the total duration of the review period.

18:16 We were hoping for the end of this calendar year. I don't know if this changed in the plan or how that may affect that schedule. I mean, ultimately, it will be up to the FAA for when our ALP gets completed. We have received some emails from Mr. Kalish-Malloy, or Mr. Stephen Kalish-Malloy. They are here today, and I think they may have some questions or comments as well.

18:44 And other than that, we'll continue to come back to the airport commission to update you on our progress with the FAA and keep you updated with our status. Thank you. Any questions for Jen? Yeah, Jen, there are comments. One of the ones that would make it something different than what we approved, other than putting things in different formats and things like that.

19:14 Cleaning up the drawings and providing was the selecting a single design basis aircraft and a critical aircraft. And I'm wondering what your recommended approach of what we do there is. Is that something we've discussed a lot of and it could affect how the thing looks to some of us on the commission at least? In terms of the critical aircraft,

19:42 The way that we determine that is mandated by FAA based on flights that come in, so I don't think there's a question there. In terms of the future aircraft, if you recall, we did put three future design aircrafts in our table, and the comment from Mr. Scooth was to have one. And I'm actually not sure how we're proposing to address that. We're going through the comments now, and I don't think we can turn on the resolution on that one at this point.

20:12 And so the way that we've interpreted or I have interpreted that was that if we had to pick an aircraft, how does that affect what the airlines coming in and their aircraft choice? Yeah. It is the critical aircraft really is mandated by the FAA. So that would be the Q400 at this point. Okay. Thank you. Any other questions? I'd like to make a comment on that if I recall.

20:42 And then we had an airline that wanted to use a different type of aircraft. We would have to go through a new process on that. Thank you. I have looked at this. One of the problems is that some of the aircrafts suggested will probably never be flown in here by an airline. People who suggest aircraft and do not represent airlines are not.

21:23 The critical thing is you must find an aircraft that operates at this altitude with an adequate payload. The A319 would not. The 737-500 would not. The 737-300 would not. The 737-700 would. Most of these aircraft, which are typically the 124 passenger class,

21:53 Weigh more than 150,000 pounds. And any C-3 aircraft that weighs more than 150,000 pounds requires a 150-foot wide runway. So there are two things you have to do. First, you have to figure out what the taxiway, I mean runway length required for takeoff. That's a federal standard. You can look it up.

22:20 The performance curves, I gave you the ones for the 737 class, there's also such curves for all the other aircraft. So you have to look at this altitude and see how many feet are required for takeoff with a given payload. And of course, there's a considerable reduction in payload range when you take off at 7,000 feet. So you pick an airplane that can go to Dallas, say,

22:50 It ain't going to go to Dallas when you take off in this elevation with a full load or even with a partial load. So that calculation has to be gone through. You need somebody who can do that. And the airlines can do it. But you don't want to be just discussing airplanes in general. You need to ask Alaska what they would like. Thank you. Or somebody. Can I address Mr. Moy, actually?

23:18 Your comments about the airplane, first of all, there are some truth to the fact that the runway width is a bit of an issue, but it's not a showstopper. As a matter of fact, the 319 and the 320 can both land on a 100-foot runway. I didn't say that they could both land. They can land on a 580-3rd if they have to. They can operate on it. Let's just say they can operate on it. I can show it to you in my aircraft manual if you'd like, but that's beside the point.

23:47 I think the fact of the matter is the airport, the ALP, is trying to forecast what will be required. We're not talking about forecast? I'm not talking about forecast. I'm talking about the ALP's future runway. Well, if you'd like to listen to my comment first, and before you make your counter-comment, is the aircraft that you're talking about, the 319, for instance, can now operate on a 100-foot-wide runway. The length of the runway will predetermine what

24:15 Payload the airplane will be able to operate with. But in future planning, I think it's very appropriate to look at what aircraft that could possibly be used and then plan the airport accordingly. And that's exactly, I think, what the AOP is trying to do. Before you go on, Mr. Malloy, could we not make this a discussion? I think I thank you both for your input at this point. Is there anything else you'd like to address? Just read this back. Thank you. I have a question on...

24:50 I can't figure out really whether 2E is substantial or not from the way it's given. Maybe Jen or Brian could address what you're going to do to address 2E. So the comment in this review letter, comment 2E, is stating that all area dimensions and separation should be shown to standard, not greater or less than standard.

25:24 I think that's just the way he wanted to pick it on the ALP in the same way he also mentions having a non-standard dimensions versus things that might at one point in time require a modification to standards. So I really think it's just the way he wants it depicted on the ALP to show these standards. It's really not a change in the values. No, it's not a change. No, not at all. No. It's just the way of looking at it. Any other comments?

25:56 When would you have selected the design of the future aircraft for the write-up? Can we get a look at what you're proposing there? At this point in time, I wouldn't want to comment on which one they're selecting for the future. I mean, I know what the current is, but I'm not sure what the future is.

26:38 Will that be brought back to the commission before it's submitted? Yeah, it will. And one of the reasons why they're, well, the FAA is actually looking at the way they categorize aircraft, but we will have to conform with whatever, whether we have to choose one or a type. One of the new standards is saying that you might be able to choose a type of aircraft that has certain types of characteristics, but that's not necessarily been adopted yet.

27:10 So we might end up being forced to kind of choose a close enough, you know, the closest to that type that has wingspan, speed of landing, tail height, that type of thing. So we'll look at that more carefully and bring it back to the committee. So may I clarify with what you just said that the ALP, once it's gone through its gyrations and the FAA communications as well as the other entities in town, it will come back to the airport commission. Is that correct? Is that what you just said?

27:40 Chair, if I could. Yes. So the front part of the conversation is we expect to get incremental input from FAA and different districts. We know that the forecast has to go to the Columbia Office. And as we gather these and put them together, and we continue to work with them from staff to staff basis, then as we can finally sort out what the mean...

28:06 Changes will be. We'll present that back to you so you can see it. And it may be as an information item or it may be as an action item. We don't know yet. Great. Any other comments from here? Any public comments regarding this? Stephen Kalish. I'm sorry, Mark. I couldn't hear a word of what you said. I got a little bit, a word or two. So it sounds like you're thinking you're doing this incrementally and not making another formal submission.

28:36 Now what I said, Mr. Kalich, can you hear me better now? I'm really protected. Can you hear me now? So, Chair, Mr. Kalich, we've submitted to the FAA, and we expect to get incremental comments back from them. So we have some initial comments from the FAA through Mr. Struth. We know that the forecast will be reviewed both

29:08 At a regional office, but also by their national office. And we do not wish to proceed with incremental changes that might require incremental revisions. So once we've gathered the information from the FAA, we'll continue to work with them at a staff level. And once we've sorted out a document that seems to be acceptable, we all understand what it is, we will present that as either an information item or an action item to the airport commission.

29:37 So it sounds like what I'm hearing is you're going to wait for a forecast approval before you resubmit an ALP set of sheets or not? No. The information that they've asked for now in this kind of grammatical sense, we will resubmit that. But ultimately, the document, we expect to see more and more changes, more and more comments, and we'll deal with them as conclusively as we can in one process.

30:06 That's our objective. Okay. Well, I guess my question comes with everyone in the room is who's in charge of doing these revisions? Who's making the decisions about the design aircraft? Who's preparing the request for modifications to standards? I mean, the airport commission seems to want to know if they're going to be approving this. You're suggesting that it's going to just be submitted, and these questions are outstanding.

30:36 On some of this, I mean, to very briefly get back to this discussion between Owen and Lee, the regs say what a certificated takeoff rate is. It doesn't say how light they're flying.

30:54 In terms of designing an airport and a runway, it's supposed to be designed based upon the certificate. Is this your input that you're offering right now? Because what I'd like to do is get us back to not a discussion but to input and listen to what you have to say. But I did not hear it the same way that you did. I heard that my clarification was to understand that as we're watching all the gyrations and components, if we were going to get it back to see it before it was submitted, and he did answer that for me. I don't think there's been any change in who's been...

31:20 Who's been the leader in this initiative with the staff working with the FAA? So I think... I'm having trouble hearing you also. I'm sorry. All right. I just said if you'd like to continue with your input, we would appreciate it. Well, I looked at the document and I saw a couple major items, which I think I put in my emails, which had to do with designing the aircraft, choosing the design aircraft, which affects whether the drawings showing the future runway...

31:51 With is accurate or not and showing what the future runway length would have to be. And I would expect that that would all have to be decided before a resubmission could take place. And so that was one issue. And then the next issue would be if you don't submit a 124 seat. The aviation forecast didn't identify how many flights of which planes were included in the town's aviation forecast.

32:21 And if you were to eliminate larger aircraft from your future five-year forecast, it seems to me that the aviation forecast would have to be redone and recalculated based upon using smaller planes and that it might reduce the aviation forecast. So it seems to me that there are some decisions that need to be made by somebody. And it wasn't clear to me who was making those decisions.

32:49 And I thought it would be nice to hear who is taking the responsibility for making the decisions that have to be made before the requested changes can be implemented. And I found the staff report ambiguous on that subject. And unfortunately, I'm having trouble hearing each of you, so I'm not sure what you've decided to do about it. And so that's the thrust of my question.

33:19 Who's in charge? All right. Thank you for your input, Stephen. Can I make one comment? From my understanding of how the critical aircraft and the design aircraft are being chosen, the critical aircraft is being chosen by an actual operating aircraft in this airport at this point. So you agree with that? It's the Q400. Right. Okay. The design – sorry. Your comments. I'm sorry. Well, no. If –

33:49 If I understand what the design aircraft is, it can be pretty much anything the town or the community desires within reason of the capability of this airport. The A319 and the Boeing 737 new generations are capable if there's some upgrades to this airport. Runway width is not a critical issue. It would be nice to have a wider runway. But there's certain things that the critical aircraft have in common with, correction, the...

34:19 The design aircraft would have in common with any design you choose. It could be an RJ or considered an RJ, a 90-seat RJ or a Boeing 737. It could be a whole myriad of sizes. I've flown the 737 and the 319. I know what it's capable of. The older 300s and 500 737s would have a lot of problem with this airport. But the new generation machines are actually

34:48 Much better at altitude and they would be load restricted. There's no doubt about it. You wouldn't be going from here to Washington, D.C. or Boston. However, the longer the runway is and the better we can make it for these design or, you know, aircraft that we're actually considering, it would upgrade the airport to a point where any similar aircraft would benefit from it. So that's, I don't think, I'm not sure who is.

35:13 Ultimately deciding the actual type, whether it's Reinhardt or a combination of you, the staff, and Reinhardt. But to me it's not that important, and I guess what Brian said to me, he confirmed that, is that they're actually thinking of grouping these aircraft into a common type of category that would cover all of them. So that's my comment. Thank you. I'm sorry for not looking at you guys. So would you like to succinctly

35:40 Restate that and make sure and include for anything that Stephen may not have heard that we went through, Mark? As best I can. So we're in the, I think, an iterative review process with the FAA. And as they ask questions and clarifications and minor amendments, we will make those and submit as necessary. At a point where there's a policy impact that might have a substantial change, we'll certainly come back and figure out the best way to deal with this.

36:10 What we do have is a document that was recommended or actually directed through the commission and town council process. So to the extent that these changes that we're seeing as a request or actually a requirement from the FAA, we'll make those changes so that we can continue this process. We'll be very careful that we don't establish a programmatic design creep where it takes us off course and we'll touch base with the

36:39 Commission and seek, you know, provide input and seek direction where, where appropriate and needed. But we're not at that point yet. Thank you. Any other comments from the Commission? Thank you. So, there's no action to be taken on that. That was discussion. And moving on, is there anything else? All right, so the next business matter is ground transportation services at Mammoth Yosemite Airport. Brian Picken.

37:23 Ground transportation, this is really referring to the taxi and limousine services that are provided by four vendors that serve our airport. We've been in the process of updating their use agreements for some time now. The purpose for the update of the use agreements was to better have the agreements better reflect what's actually happening on the ground.

37:46 We wanted to relieve crowding around the gate. We wanted to accommodate the kiosks. We wanted to make sure we were conforming to other standards of the town, including insurance and whatnot. To that end, I started meeting with all of the providers, three of which are here tonight. We have been in the process of updating the use agreement. We did bring this to the Mobility Commission the last time they met.

38:16 And I think probably the two main points are, one, we want to have use agreements that are fair and equitable and work for all the parties. One of the vendors was proposing an exclusive contract for themselves. We took these issues to the Mobility Commission, and what my direction from the Mobility Commission was was to continue to work on

38:42 The use agreements, if need be, come up with some kind of an overriding operating plan, and that's really what we've been doing up until this time. Where we are right in the middle of this process is the most current draft of the use agreement has gone to the town lawyers for their review. I should be getting that back shortly, and then it will bring it up to Ray and Mark and other parties that are interested in it.

39:12 And that's pretty much where we are with that today. Our recommendations, our actions are for the airport commission is for the staff to continue to work on the use agreements or option two would be to investigate exclusive transportation contracts. So that's kind of where we're at. I do know we have quite a bit of taxi represented in the audience as well.

39:42 Thank you. Any questions? Any questions or comments from the commission? In following all this, the excitement of it, I'd like the direction the staff is taking. I'm not keen on exclusivity at the airport. As a commission, we've been through this with car rental agencies, airlines, all of the different companies, and I believe that

40:10 Opportunity for local businesses to be able to operate down there, very, very important. I do feel in all of the contracts, I'm not just talking about the taxi, the car rental, or any of the operators we have down there, that it's very important that you establish clearly the operating standards, those issues that are causing the debate. You know, this person's standing five feet closer than this person, or they're...

40:39 Approaching the passengers aggressively. If indeed our contract addresses the operating standards and then we hold operators, again, regardless of the type of the operator we're talking about in this situation, it's taxis, but we've been here before with car rental and hold them all accountable to those standards. I think a lot of the debate can go away. I, for one, am not in favor of exclusivity.

41:07 Yeah, I'd like to actually add to that that I think we haven't seen an issue that would actually prompt us to go with any kind of exclusive contract with one person. I think it actually does eliminate competition. There are other solutions like taxi lines and things that could be done down there to actually solve some of these problems, but like Commissioner Murphy said, the contract could address some of this stuff.

41:35 And I think just more importantly, we're not a huge airport here. We don't really need to eliminate competition, I think, like some of the large airports do. And I think if we do see that actually service suffers or there's some other operational issue that we need to address, we should do it at that time, but not now, other than the contracts, of course. John. Yeah, Brian, I'd like you to briefly address, if you could.

42:06 You know, what is the real experience, in other words, from where you sit? There have been times people have been left. Do you get complaints, feedback? What, from your, as an airport manager, what kind of a pain is it to you, and what, what, can we make the passenger experience better? Yeah, I think that's the most important thing, is to make the passenger experience the best possible. Honestly,

42:35 Ninety-five percent of the time, the transportation is we have it now work just fine. Where we got into troubles, where some over-aggressiveness with people crowding the gate, and where to locate kiosks around, you know, on the limited space we had, you know, we're forced to have some of our

42:58 Operating stuff outside on the patio, we don't have room inside the terminal. So I think in general it worked well 95-99% of the time. The complaints that I did get were for crowding the gate and a few issues of some altercations between some of the vendors where there were some pricing, you know, trying to sneak passengers, you know, away from one another.

43:24 So what we would like to do is try to level the playing field and kind of make it easier for everybody to stay in their place and still serve the customers quite well. So to my knowledge and all of our guys checked, we've never left anybody. I've never seen anybody left behind at the airport. Nobody has ever called me and told me that they weren't able to make it to the airport because they couldn't get a taxi to come to the airport. That's a little harder for me to know, but nobody has ever called me and told me that. So truthfully, we've had...

43:51 Minimal complaints, but in the process of updating these contracts, it brings everything to light, and it's an opportunity to correct everything and try to make it as fair and equitable as possible. Ryan, is there pricing guidelines in the contracts, or is that just left open? We have discussed pricing with all the different vendors to some kind of an agreement, but it has not been set.

44:19 By the town. There's not like a minimum price guarantee or some such thing as that. So as I've read and seen and heard, this has become somewhat of a contentious area. And I think that John brought it out best. The thing that I personally care about most along with safety is guest service and how fluid it is. And while I don't believe in a...

44:43 In a singular entity, I do believe that we have the need and the community would welcome multiple options. I believe that Pam hit it on the head with standards, but I want to go one more with that and say that perhaps when they do get the contract together, we could look at it before it's done at our next meeting because I think...

45:04 I want to ensure, as a commissioner, that we not only are looking at the guest service, the hours that might play in in the future, and make sure that the people are accountable to holding to those standards or they do lose their contract or something of that nature. I think that's very good, and we will make sure that all the commissions get a chance to review this contract before it's signed. Great. Is there any public comment on this topic?

45:34 Can I ask one question? Is this, does it be the draft of the contract currently? The draft that the attorney has? It's actually not the most current draft. It's about, that's when there's a, there is now a more current draft than that. And we'll get that back from the attorney probably tomorrow or Thursday at the latest. And then we'll be able to get those email to us? For input? Yeah. Chair, so if you have specific comments,

46:04 Thank you. I knew there was another. Any other comments? All right. Moving on to the director reports. You were supposed to take some action on that. Oh, did we not?

46:40 And the action to be taken was to decide on a singular and let them move forward. Yeah, it's written in his overview.

47:09 And that we would get to see the final draft and comment before it went into place. Yeah, I'd like to throw mine. I haven't heard anything that would, at this time, I would support a single source contract. I think the staff report to have them keep trying to work out what is a fair way of doing it.

47:35 They ought to just bolt them to the table until they agree. So are you good with our decision to get the final draft for comment before they move forward? This will remain on the agenda for next meeting. Yes. Thank you. Director reports. Did I miss one?

47:59 Oh, I'm sorry. Again. And I did not mean this. I'm just ignoring Pat. General aviation update. I must see you and think that you. I really do apologize. Chair, Commission, good to see you all again. I'll keep this brief. But general aviation has been going pretty well. We're having a decent summer.

48:26 Our visitation for both June and July were down about 12% from last year, but our revenue has been up. We've had a few anomalies that have really helped us out. It's interesting, we had the British Royal Air Force come visit us last month. They were doing high-altitude testing and ended up coming back multiple times. Really enjoyed it. We ended up setting them up with a couple cars. They spent some time in town, bought a lot of fuel. That helped a lot.

48:51 I've got a helicopter company replacing the power lines in the binding, and they've been sending their fuel truck over to top off of this once or twice a week. And then, of course, we had the fires going, and I don't know if any of you drove by the airport while the fires were going, but we had a really big, impressive Ericsson air crane based with us for about two weeks off and on, and a number of other helicopters that have really boosted revenue.

49:20 So overall things are going well. Even though our visitation is down, kind of an interesting stat, we keep track of first-time visitors as they come in. If a plane comes in and we type their tail number in, they haven't been in yet. My gals have to take a couple extra steps to enter them into our database and I have them log those folks. We actually had 24 first-time visitors in July and 18 in June.

49:49 We've had 113 for the year, so roughly 16 a month. Just about every other day we're getting a first-time visitor, somebody who hasn't been to Mammoth before, which is encouraging. I've been talking to some of our customers that are based in Los Angeles and Santa Monica and El Monte. They go, gosh, Pat, we see planes on the ramp here that it's clear they haven't flown for months and months. So the fact that we're still getting a lot of first-time visitors I thought was really cool.

50:20 I think the events that the town has been putting on and the concerts are definitely bringing folks in in the right direction. So that's all I've got unless you guys have comments or questions for me. Just curious if the parking actually is generating much revenue. It just seems like it's full a lot of the time or fairly full. Overnight auto parking? Yeah. It does. It does. It typically generates about $1,600 a month, which is split with the town.

50:50 Dan? Two. So I think you answered a lot of the reason for first-timers coming. It sounded like events was one of the reasons. Have they given you other? You know, they really haven't. And I'm going to start pressing my gals to kind of find out what brought these folks to Mammoth. But that's pretty consistent with what we've seen over the years. Back when the economy was good, we were averaging about 23 or 24 a month. And I haven't taken a look at that number in a while.

51:20 I did recently and thought, wow, that's really cool. We had 24 last month. That's pretty impressive, I think, given the economy and where everybody's at. My question was on your first comment that while your visitation is down about 12%, your revenue's up for the reasons you mentioned. With the visitation down, I know Horizon Alaska is up a little bit over last summer in the months you're mentioning.

51:50 Do you think that's why the visitation is done or is it the economy and just your thoughts on that? You know, we absolutely see some of our customers unloading off of the airlines. We see folks that are still wanting to come to Mammoth but not necessarily wanting to fly their own plane out. It costs quite a bit more. So we do see that. And we do see a lot of our passengers that have hangers at the airport even.

52:19 Will stop by and see us even though they've driven it. So a lot of those folks are driving. Okay. That's curious. Thank you. And my only question was that, and if it's too personal to the business you can say so, but your numbers were down, your revenue was up. Is it up over last year or quite a bit? Yeah, not significantly, but revenue's up about 10%. So it is up over last year while your numbers are down.

52:47 The anomalies that I mentioned were either big helicopters or big planes taking on a lot of fuel. So typically I average about 135 gallons of jet fuel per plane. And, for instance, that air crane that was there would take 1,000 gallons at a time. The British Royal Air Force would take close to 1,000 gallons at a time. So that's a significant boost for us. Thank you. No problem. Pat, you know, we've talked in the past about

53:16 When times were better, of having a fly-in barbecue or whatever, or tied in with the Belusa, as long as they don't fly right afterwards. And have you worked with John at all, or the town staff, to try to get any co-events going? You know, I've had conversations with John.

53:45 About the idea. And we haven't acted on them, but would love to. Absolutely think it would be great. I don't know what we could do at the airport that would really help bring folks in. Generally, the attraction is whatever's happening in town or the mountain or whatever's going on. We just try to treat them nice while they're coming through. Yes. I'm sorry. Pat Foster with Hot Creek Aviation.

54:16 That came up very deep in that. Thank you. Thank you, Pat. Anything else in the commission? All right. Now, moving on to director reports. Good afternoon, commission. The only thing I'd like to add is that staff is currently wrapping up the airport emergency plan. We have an outside consultant that we're working with on that. We expect to have that completed shortly.

54:46 The airport security plan we should have back from TSA anytime we're expecting to get that back and we'll have that completed. And we do expect our airport engineer, Ryder Brantley, to have our comments back on the ALP in about 10 days. So I think we're moving forward on all fronts and staff is diligently pursuing all of these projects. We're also trying to keep up with the changes at FAA and make sure that

55:16 The staff with FAA can put a face and a name and a voice to staff on this end. So we feel that that is important as well to keep all of these projects moving forward. So other than that, I don't have anything else. Thank you. I noticed that two things that we normally have on the discussion sort of dropped off the agenda this time. One is the status of air service.

55:47 And we usually don't get much feedback on it, but we keep asking for the status of the budget. And I guess since they've been part of the agendas in the past, I think we're entitled to an update on both those things.

56:16 Are we on budget? At this point, honestly, we're being very conservative with our budget. Frankly, we're having a bit of a production challenge getting our budget out.

56:46 When we need to make any purchases, we're checking in at that point in time, but we expect to have a completed budget shortly that staff can be working with. So may I ask if Pam can give us an update on air service? I can just tell you, sir, the numbers have been good this summer. They're better than last summer. I glanced at a report that I saw from Howard.

57:15 And especially August has been very, very good. I know an email came through from Horizon to start their kind of fall planning for the winter ground services and all of those. I don't know if you have any real specific questions. Do we know numbers on the...

57:41 Cancellations, percentage-wise or number-wise, and whether or not they were due to mechanical or weather or... Do you have that information handy? Sorry, I didn't bring it with me. I can bring it next time. I usually have cancellations. They're not necessarily broken down by weather and mechanical, but I do have a number of cancellations, but I do not have that information with me today. Brian, do you also have the numbers on load restrictions that came into play, like, for instance, people being...

58:09 I don't. Deny warnings? Yeah, I do not. I know that some did occur this year, but I don't have a number. Then, um, oh, go ahead. So, any other? To John's point, maybe under Director's Report, right, going forward, we could add that back in just with a brief update. Absolutely. An operational update that would include cancellations, issues.

58:39 Occupancy, loads, et cetera. I don't think we need a, you know, John's detailed update of the big picture every time, but I think we do not. For one thing, I, like, an example is I, being on the commission, I get questions. And one of the questions I got was, oh, I see you cut back to four a week because I can't book on three days a week. Is that true? Yes.

59:09 I told them I didn't think it was because nobody told me. So to quantify this then, can we get on the agenda on a meeting, every meeting basis, a facilities operational update that's brief but to those points? We'll just, we'll include that as a standing agenda item. Thank you very much. So you can get that each meeting. Sure. Anything else from the director's reports? Not at this time. From me. Thank you. I just had one curiosity question. The backscatter machine showed up sometime between.

59:40 Now and a few months ago, I guess. And I'm just curious, did the TSA, I'm just surprised it showed up at a small venue like this. Did they do it based on a winter forecast or are they just trying to install them everywhere? They're going to be installed in all airports. They are, okay. So we just had ours and we asked them to time it so it came in the summer. Gotcha. What is backscanner? Body scanner. Yeah, it's...

1:00:10 Some kind of a microwave that doesn't supposedly penetrate your whole body, but it can look through your clothes. Oh, that makes sense. It's an x-ray. It's just a soft x-ray. Yeah, more or less. It's looking for weapons and whatnot. Great. If there's nothing else under directory reports, future agenda items and commission meeting dates. So I'd like to outline that we're going to have a beefier off in facilities report.

1:00:39 I would like an air service update going forward as well. And I think that could be static as well because even if there's nothing to report, it can bring us to where we're at because I believe discussions are ongoing consistently. I would like to request that our next meeting have a budget update just as to where we are because we haven't seen the full budget and we know the challenges with the town.

1:01:05 We're going to see before, if not on the agenda, the ground transportation document for comment. Of course, the ALP update will probably be there. Anything else you would like to add to that? A question. So the air service update, there's how we've been doing, and then our next meeting, it would be good to have the winter update.

1:01:37 That might be how I'd pick it at that time to come in and talk about the winter update as the contact to prepare into. Yes, I agree. And in my mind, it's kind of both ongoing when there is something from any side of it. So if we could bring that into the static meetings, that would be great because it's always nice to hear where we are both in the communications as well as the travel. Are there two, so under director's report, that's a staff winter.

1:02:04 Service is maybe in this situation an agenda item because we'd really like to have him report, you know, what they've contracted for the winter, what the service lights are. And maybe we could have him bring what happened in fall at the end result as well. Thank you. And can I ask a discussion up here for this next agenda item? Do we want to discuss?

1:02:32 Is this an area that we want to bring on at all? It pairs the funding to hear what's going on from the ESAA or anything like that because I think it's so integral to what's going on that I don't want to ignore it from a commission standpoint. We might just take updates from Lee, our volunteer with the ESAA, or is there anything else that the commission feels we'd want to discuss with it?

1:02:55 John's here for other reasons. He would be a great update to it, I think. Yeah, I think he's got the finger on the pulse of that, so he would be very appropriate. I can try to fill in where he's not here, but he obviously has the up-to-date picture. There's two funding issues, correct? There's funding being ahead of the summer and off-season funding, and then there's the longer-term terminal funding and all of the work that comes with that, all of the environmental.

1:03:25 Right. And I think initially it's concentrating on this one year-round flight. I mean, it's kind of the first step. And then after that funding gets put in place or at least figured out, then I think it's probably time to move on to the next step. It's subsidy funding. Correct. Good. Anything else we'd like to add to a future agenda? So our next meeting is September 25th, Chair. Thank you.

1:03:56 September 20th? Unfortunately, I can't attend, but out of town. All right. Then in that, I think we're adjourned. What do we use this for? Thanks, Chair Perel. Thanks, guys.

1:04:29 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.