Town Council Special meeting
· recording 20 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
44 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:02 I hope everybody's supposed to be here. Michael back in the hospital or is he okay? Oh, it's true. How's your weekend? Awesome. Hiked on Sunday and worked on Saturday. What? Oh, what you did with Hooper.
0:41 No, we didn't go. Oh, you didn't? We were supposed to go. We didn't go. Oh. We were supposed to pioneer.
0:47 Rick and I hiked from the trailhead there at Rock Creek.
1:16 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:31 Yes. We were thinking of doing that. I think we're going to end up going to be stuck and then back. Oh, yeah. We're going to bring my camera. We're going to spend some time back there. I think we're just going to go take a camera. Take Hanks out of there. Yeah. A little bit more fun. Very nice area. And you know, I know this is what's beautiful. It's good. It's serious.
1:51 Good. Will you take a fish in the swoop? Probably. No? I tried before, and I needed to stop fishing. Yeah. I need to sit by the lake. Are you struck? Yeah. No, I'm not. Well, that'll be a good trip if you get to go. Hopefully you'll make one more. Yeah. It stinks. I know it's great. Yeah. What's the case? Correct. I would have to make this as well. Oh, 12. Uh-huh. Well, you should go because I'm out of town.
2:21 Thank you.
2:40 Oh, I didn't even check it.
3:03 There's an agenda, but there's no agenda bill. This wasn't on.
3:31 Yeah, that might be what the problem is. We're still working it out.
4:01 Okay, thank you everybody for joining us today for our special meeting August 29th. Today we're going to be considering a contract awards for the Mammoth Gateway sign, so we'll go ahead and jump right into that. Actually, should we do the pledge? Should we do that? Either way. Let's go ahead. Sure.
4:30 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Jamie, why don't we go ahead and do roll call as well? Councilmember Bacon? Here. Councilmember Reeson? Here. Councilmember Reeson? Here. Councilmember Reeson? Here. Mayor Tim Hoyt? Here. Mayor Lehman? Here. Mayor Lehman? Here. And before we get started,
5:02 I want to go ahead and see if there's any comments from the public on anything that's not on our agenda bill right now. Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and start. Jessica. I'll make this very quick. Jessica Morris, transportation planner. At your last meeting on the 15th of August, we brought forward...
5:27 Various actions about the gateway, and one of those actions was to reject the bids that were received at that time. A couple days after that, staff reissued bid requests for the project for three separate contracts, electrical, masonry, and concrete. So we were here tonight to award hopefully two of the contracts, electrical and masonry.
5:53 And then the third action would be to authorize the Public Works Director to award and execute a contract for the concrete work. The electrical contract, we're recommending that you award it to Eldridge Electric & Sons in the amount of $52,500.
6:13 The masonry contract, we are recommending that you award to Daniel C. Whitmore in the amount of $189,356.71. And then, as I mentioned, authorizing the Public Works Director to execute the contracts for the concrete services, which we expect to receive additional estimates tomorrow. Any questions? Okay, any questions from Council? Yes.
6:44 Just seeing on the electrical contract a bid, the big difference in the dollar amount, I mean, has everything double checked that there was nothing left out? Yeah, the engineering department reviewed all the bids and I don't know exactly what the differences were between the two, but they have all been bettered pretty heavily and looked to make sure that all the requirements were met. I guess just came back.
7:15 Thank you. Do you see anything unusual, Ray?
7:46 No, I think it's just a situation where you've got two bidders that, you know, read the plans differently. I mean, that happens to people. For the dollar amounts involved, it's a bit higher of a spread than you'd like to see, but there's nothing unusual about, you know, other than that, the numbers that were submitted and evaluated. Okay.
8:10 Yes, Jill. I just had a question that under the financial considerations, it doesn't really say it, but did all these bids fall within what the estimates were? Are you still on track for the budget? Yes. Okay. I think the electrical came in higher than we had anticipated, but the others came in lower, so we're still in that range. Okay. Are there any other questions or comments from Council? With that, I'd like to see if there are any questions or comments from the public.
8:42 Good afternoon, Council Mayor. Martin Kleinberg. I'm here as a concerned citizen. I brought this up last time about the fair bidding practices, public contract code. This entire project, in my eyes as a contractor for many, many, many years, violates, and others, violates.
9:12 Public Contract Code. It was brought to my attention early on in the project that the contract had been split up into bits and pieces. Several portions of the contract were not put out for public bid, therefore evading the Fair Bidding Practices Act. This is a misdemeanor charge for anybody involved. The violations are
9:45 The public contract code, the definitions in 1010, 20,161, 2162, any project over $5,000 must go out to public bidding procedures. 2163 is where any project
10:13 Cannot be split into bits and pieces in order to evade the public bidding process. And anyone who violates that section is subject to misdemeanor charges. I know that the town attorney was a consultant on this because I was told that whether or not he was in fact. I have no idea. But generally they call this a multi-prime project. Multi-prime projects are generally not awarded.
10:41 Under these kinds of jurisdictions, under a million dollars. And then there's a threshold. And the city doesn't really have a right to choose that. They'd have to do an ordinance in order to do these multi-prime. I've asked staff before getting up here several weeks ago to tell me under what rule and the code that allows them to split a project that is to build something into bits and pieces and award it out to separate contractors.
11:12 And they would tell me all I was told by several staff members, including Ray Jarvis, that town attorneys said it was okay. I did a Google search last night. I found out that BBK had been involved in some stuff in San Diego where they wrote some presentation to allow the multi-prime thing. But that's for schools and bigger projects, a million dollars and more. And the town needs to establish.
11:43 These kinds of things by ordinance in order to split up these contracts. Several general contractors, I thought that they were going to be there today, but they weren't, brought a lot of this information to me, and they were really upset. I know at least two or three that had complained about not being able to bid the project as a general contractor.
12:09 And by law, general contractors allow to bid a project like that. It has more than just framing. It has more than just concrete. It has more than just stonework. It has more than just electrical. They have a right to bid on that project. The town has a right to decide which specialty trades can do a job, but they have no right to change the classifications of contractors.
12:41 For a contract that's mostly electrical or a contract that's mostly contract as long as they don't go over the threshold set by law and there's maximum and minimum thresholds that they have to abide by. And I'm not going to sit here and go over every little detail, but I'm upset because the town continues to do things wrong.
13:11 And I don't understand why we here in Mammoth think that we can just make up rules as we go along. If anyone has no comment, I'm going to sit down. Any comments? Counsel? My only comment is to staff. I mean, this is one individual's impression. Do we have an opinion? Or one individual's opinion? What's our opinion? Mr. Kleinbar is correct. Staff did consult our legal counsel, BB&K.
13:40 What we were advised of, not just once but twice, was that the municipal government has the authority to specify what contractor's licenses are going to be solicited. And in this case, we solicited a C8, C10, and C29. So it's perfectly within the municipality's right to do so. One of the things that Mr. Kleinbar is alluding to is
14:10 I think what he's saying is that we should have opened it up to B contractors. We don't have to do that. And we have a specific reason for not doing that because those, and that would be a general contractor, those services have been donated. So why would we do that and add cost to the project? So we're not breaking new ground, we're just following the existing code? Well, I would say that this is,
14:38 Unusual for us. We have not, as long as I've been here, we haven't broken up a contract this way before, but I'm confident that we're on firm legal ground based on what our attorneys have told us, and the rationale for not opening it up to a B license is that we have construction management services donated that will oversee the other contracts. Okay. That's the approach that we took, and it seemed to be rational.
15:06 And based on legal counsel's advice, perfectly legal within state code. Thank you. Thank you. Mark, did you have another comment? As far as what Ray said, yes, the law specifically says that a town, a municipality, a public subdivision, political subdivision, can designate, and they must, in the bid documents, must decide what subcontractors.
15:39 But what they can't do is they can't invent new ways of doing things. There are procedures for doing that. This was not done here. And as far as volunteer work, there's a whole code section on volunteer work. And this project does not fall in that. And the section on bid splitting specifically says for the purpose of evading the public bidding process.
16:07 You're allowing somebody, for whatever reason he's donating services, to donate them, and say that's okay, and not put that portion up for public bid. There's several items on the plans that are redlined. I mean, two weeks ago, the demolition of the existing monument that the Contractors Association, through Lions Club, built.
16:32 And I was a member of the contractor association at the time, and we helped to take care of that sign. It's being demolished. That portion of this project has now been pulled out, and now it's being done by others without going through the public bidding process. So you can't one day say it's part of the project and then tomorrow say it's not part of the project. You can't have the new sign and that old sign there at the same time. That's part of the project.
17:03 So I understand what Ray's saying, but the multi-prime contracting in this instance does not apply. And I'm sorry that Andy's not here tonight to debate this, but this is the second go around where there's some shenanigans going down. And I didn't even go through the other shenanigans that went on. They're in my email, and I've sent it to every one of you. So you guys do what you wish.
17:36 I've said my piece and I don't know where else this will take and whether the general contractors that were not allowed to bid the project, what they're going to do. I can only know what they've told me. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Are there any other comments from public? Okay. Dave, did you have a comment?
18:03 Just a brief comment. I think it's important to just re-emphasize that our staff does go to our legal counsel for these kinds of decisions. Andy is a licensed attorney who works for Best Best in Creek, which is a large organization that provides legal services throughout California. We don't take these comments and concerns lightly. We believe we don't pull shenanigans. We try to follow the law as quickly and closely and as competently as possible.
18:31 Thank you, Dave. Any other, with that, any comments or questions from Council? Yeah.
18:59 I just have a comment. I appreciate the concern, but I'm satisfied that there was a public bidding process for the work that this town is paying for. It seems pretty simple to me. I may be naive, and I may not get it, but it appears to me that we are going to expend some money, and we went out to the public, and bids were solicited, bids were obtained, and bids were awarded.
19:26 I'm not entirely sure what the issue is, but I'm prepared to support option one. Okay. Anybody else? No. Okay. I'll move for council adoption of option number one as recommended in our agenda bill. I'll second it. I have a motion and a second. We're all accomplishing. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Eastman? Yes. Councilmember Raymondo? Yes. Motion Wood? Yes. Mayor Lehman? Yes. Motion passes 5-0.
19:57 And with that, we will go ahead and... Oh, I'm sorry. Yes. Thank you. I'd like to say that you will see work commence no later than Tuesday morning. Thanks very much. And I'll be done next week, is that right? At the end, maybe Thursday, not Friday. Thank you. With that, we will go ahead and move into a closed session. Go ahead and move into a closed session.