TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2012

Town Council

· recording 3 hr 16 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

409 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Yes. Yes, sir.

0:29 Thank you.

0:54 Thank you.

1:22 I know, I heard that we have a kind of spread of the world, and I haven't seen it. You've got four? Yeah, I think it says, but is my stuff in the measure you? I think it's still going around. No, no, no, I mean, it has to be around right now.

1:52 Are there more coming? Yes?

2:14 There are live participants on the call, including you. You are joining your conference as the host.

2:34 For a menu of available commands from the Star Pound. That'll be here for a couple days. Maybe that was us.

3:01 Maybe it counts as this morning. Oh, this is in our times. Okay. You ready? We're just going to start today. Okay. I woke up this morning thinking that I'm over. My head was hurting.

3:31 It's bad when you wait to put them all together. Yeah. Yeah. It doesn't start to play up. Actually, the problem is it's at 4 o'clock, too. It's still hard. Okay. We'll wait for Bill, and I don't think we have Michael. Michael? Hello. So, John, speaking of that, I think I'm certain that this Achilles heel is his own. Is he getting better? Okay. Did you guys go over recently?

4:03 Thank you.

4:30 I'm tired. Golf is tough stuff. We were just talking about how beat up they are for meetings here. Probably, had I been as dedicated as I should be, I would not have golfed today and made an early time to come here. Wind days would be an affordable day, so do what you can do. Yeah.

4:58 So, Stu, do you want to go ahead and just go on? Certainly can. Welcome. So, the workshop was scheduled to discuss, originally with the Recreation Commission, the full funding priorities and principles, which was requested a council several months ago.

5:26 And we also took this opportunity at the last Council meeting to invite the Measure U application committee to kind of join us in the review and establish the funding priorities for the Measure U for a cycle. So it's not that time. We have apologies. I just started. We have apologies from Commissioner Turner. We also have apologies from Joystone.

5:56 So the Chair can jump in any time from the Recreation Commission, but what we wanted to run through first was the funding priorities that the Recreation Commission reviewed and identified here on this first stage that we have in front of it. No real change from the priorities, although we did take one priority off.

6:25 So primarily now it's just finished, clock, trials and progression projects, plan for the future. What is plan for the future? Plan for the future would be park plan and trail plans that are incomplete so that they can get completed so that we can move forward on them in the future.

6:54 That would be my take. And the prioritization of those plans and projects. Right. Okay. So there was discussion on how amongst the commission about whether those two would actually be the same. But we felt that was distinguishable enough that we should exclude them. But there's a difference. Because some of the trails and recreation projects that we're made in the clear just that, they've been cleared. And we've never finished them. There's a lot of trails and parks that are never finished.

7:22 Planning for the future, we master planning for some of the parts, revisiting some of the other master plans and venues that we need to do to move forward. Which, if I understand it, is essentially what Pat and Terry have been identifying for the whole commission as you're going through the CIP, trying to figure out what do we want each one to be when it grows up. Okay. Now, would the priority be finishing the ones who started before we start the one new plan?

7:51 So we have a plan in place. Did I just tell you I've been golfing today? Some fresh mind. I think it was a bit of a plan. A little bit of a plan in this facility. There's always something that's hotline. That's where the prioritization comes in. I mean, if there's something that's a new project that floats up here and is something you want to do, as long as the other parts are not incomplete to a point that they're not functional.

8:21 There's a lot of planning for the future that probably as a commission we should have dealt with already, but we haven't yet. If we look at the rec strats, it was never completely finished because there's a balancing job yet to be done between aligned and non-aligned projects. So there's a lot of planning for the future and prioritization that the commission still has to do, whether that should come forward as a...

8:51 Application to help pay for staff to help us do that or we haven't dealt with that but there's a lot of planning in the future. Is there any plans to not start a new project?

9:20 Isn't that kind of what you were saying at the last council meeting, Terry, is that gives you the opportunity to have something come forward that it automatically goes to the top of class? Yeah, so, you know, if there's something when we pull all this stuff together and something close to the top that we hadn't been working on or hadn't finished or whatever, but that's the top priority, it may be five years out before that can be done, but there can be money set aside to start working on that.

9:47 While we're still using monies for other things, I mean, it doesn't mean that all monies have to go to that project. Is that what you say? Yes. Matt, if applications come forward to finish something, Trails End Park is an example, it may well take priority over planning. But if we don't plan for the next step, when we get that finished, we have nowhere to go. I mean, it's hugely important that they fit. And, you know, we have to be careful because we talked about this as planning.

10:14 We're not creating any new plans. We're taking the plans that we have in place, and we're actually utilizing those. And, you know, we need to be very clear to everybody that that's what we're doing. I think that's kind of where I was headed. We're already creating any new plans to build some more stuff. So I just kind of want to see us finish what we've started. Look, we've never finished the master plan for Mammoth Creek Park. We have never revisited the master plan for Community Center Park. The tennis courts up there need replacing and repairing. I mean, they need replacing, not just repairing.

10:43 Is that the best place for where we'll be? Before we decide to spend a million dollars to replace them, we need to go back and look at is it better as a partnership with the schools? So there's a lot of planning in them. Does it need to come forward that would weaken them for? But those are things that I think we can do internally. It's more conceptual, I think, as opposed to going and doing a full-blown master plan. You know, just kind of where we are. More like a concept. Yeah.

11:10 And I think the case in point there as an example is the feasibility study for the entertainment menu designation. That's moving along. So there's a plan for the future that's going to come forward. It gives a lot more direction in regards to how we should invest in that special event market. And that was the last piece of kind of the puzzle. And then we have all of the plans that we can sit down and we can start going through and prioritizing and seeing what...

11:38 What was in the plans that we put together and the studies that we've already done. And, you know, there's a lot of good information in those that we just need to start looking at and pulling all the information together and organizing it and prioritizing it. That's kind of how I see it. I think that's what we're looking at. And I think we also have another discussion, too, about just in light of the settlement, just how important planning for the future may be, just as we get an idea of what our future looks like.

12:10 And then the only change on the principles was with the added provided community benefits. So the Commission thought there was a balance between visitor driving and community benefits. The second sheet, and I tried to do this with both measures around the view, the second sheet gives you a little bit of an idea of what provided it means.

12:32 We would be potentially rewarding. You can see the entire grey area is all our estimated funds, and they were really the funds that we received last year at this time. So you can see, you know, a proportion of the amount remitted is estimated to be, you know, $730,000. We take out the 4% administration. We have maintenance funds that we're identifying, which is going in front of the Recreation Commission. We have incumbent funds from the track.

12:59 It was awarded in the spring, and then we have that $300,000 allocation. So that's around the number. So we just have to see how close we get at that time. When's the funding cycle, not the funding cycle, the allocation cycle? The timeline for, it's June to June, June to July? It's actually, yeah, a measure on that is January through September, you can see we take these months that you have.

13:28 We do, so it's the first and second quarter of Truax. The spring award is the October, November, December, and the two Truax, which gives you that spring amount. So this is kind of the large proportion, the three quarters versus the one. I think the spring amount is on emergency projects. And that comes out of August, or October, November, December. And the two Truax, yeah. And that's around 2, 2.50. And the timeline?

13:57 What's your time? So at the moment in front of the Council this evening is the plans to open September 24, close October 24, and we'd be awarding the 7-1 team. Are these the numbers, the financial numbers that have been anticipated? Yeah, because we already award so much each other. So even though I wasn't enough to ask again, I know that in such a little bit of this discussion, it would be a bunch of the team.

14:33 We had that discussion specifically on the Measure U, the three of us, because our priorities on Measure U, and when you get there, you'll see that they're substantially different to take that into account.

14:59 Well, but it was, I think she's speaking to Jo's agenda bill. To the council meeting, yeah. And I think that the feeling was, well, to a certain extent, see what comes in, and some of it may be applications that are saying, start giving this money now for something that is five years down the line, or something. I think it's still leaving it open and going through a slightly, still out of whack, or out of parallel, one more time.

15:32 Oh, we're getting there. We're getting there. And the goal would be that when this comes around the next time, we'll have things prioritized, and we'll have that before the council, and we'll all hopefully be on the same page. Well, some recent funding was to support working towards finishing trips in New York. So it's a phase, it's going to be, I guess, again, completed. And had it gone as planned, the bids would have been left in time for us to realize that the

16:01 It wasn't that the amount we awarded wasn't enough. And in the oopsertunity event in the spring, we would have awarded the extra money instead of having to start to pull things off. So we're kind of in an awkward position on that one because we awarded funds last fall. And we didn't find out we were short until after the spring event. And now here we are having to pull things out of the project, which is something we would prefer not to do. We didn't find out that we were short until two weeks ago. Right. And that's a question that I have for council. If we've awarded something,

16:31 Back in October, you guys approve it typically December. Is there a reason why something wouldn't go to bid until September? Yeah. Shouldn't be a reason. We don't have enough people waiting for us. But that's where, when we come back down to it, this discussion I've had before, and I think...

16:55 We need to have, again, because the 4% administration covers just the allocation process. The actual getting things accomplished, I don't think we have been in the past, recognizing that it does take staff time and there is going to be general plan to cover it. And I know I've said this before, but I think part of that will be that...

17:15 Hopefully, we're getting better at recognizing how much that is so that it is funded and it does get done. Well, within this project, we actually did plan that. So, you know, I guess the issue would then be within their work plan that maybe we're not scheduling the time for them in their work plan to take care of any major art projects that are coming forward or major youth projects that are coming forward.

17:37 We're awarding the funds for that administrative cost, but we're not awarding the time. And that's the problem. You've got X number of employees. Whether we allocate funds to them or not, in the budget, they're already paid for. You can't get more hours out of them unless the extra dollars are going to actually put another body on the ground, which they don't. If they don't put another body on the ground, then all we're doing is allocating dollars to free up them.

18:03 General fund dollars to go into someplace else. So it seems to me that it's a matter of staff prioritization. Is this an important enough project to bring it to the forefront? How do we deal with that when the funds are awarded? The staffs are already. And for the benefit of all councils, Terry and I had a meeting about that a couple of weeks ago, and I'd already passed that along to Dave, and I think he's working on some internal things to make sure that they get the priority they need.

18:30 In the work days. Because the alternative is to try to set a schedule at the time of the award for the time table. I don't know whether that would be helpful. It could be helpful, but it may not be realistic to know in October what a realistic schedule would be for getting this thing to a point where it can be. Correct me if I'm wrong, but you guys have talked on the council level of putting

18:59 Some sort of a list together of things you've approved and following through with a timeline on those so that they can be better tracked. So we know where we're falling behind. And in this instance, with trails in part, none of us knew because we don't have a reporting mechanism for that. Well, and actually, one of the things that Dave and I talked about was making sure that it was reporting back on all the projects on a regular basis to the Regulation Commission or the Mentoring Steering Committee.

19:26 Excuse me, Application Committee, that here's the status of the project, so if there is a slowdown that you know about it, not two weeks ago. We're going to probably have a matrix out there for that. It's a quick disturbing story that James and I would love to share pieces of that. Not just for members of our new project. You guys brought us one night, I remember we were talking about the side of people. So Dave and I had a conversation. Yeah, that's great. Since the reason we probably measure our new projects are...

19:56 Finding along with the CIP projects. And then projects that emerged like gateway projects. Yeah. I have another question since we're here at the workshop. The artificial turf has been pulled from the transcendent park. And I don't know if it would be too late, but at our meeting on September 24th,

20:23 That's when it opens. When is our first? Yeah, September 24th. It just opens the applications. November 6th is your first.

20:38 Okay. I was just wondering if the rec commission could be an emergency application that was put through so that we could actually put that term in this year. So we could say that. And at the same time, I don't know if it's too late already, you know, because I think it's supposed to be done by the middle of October. Because otherwise it doesn't move forward until the next phase of the park because it doesn't make sense to bring in otherwise. So I'm very supportive of that. And I should have probably brought it up earlier, but this is...

21:08 An opportunity, and I thought, you know, if we could get the rec commission together, which I'm sure we could, if we could put an application through for the artificial turf printing, for the amount that, uh, How much is that? From these, about $50,000. $50,000. $50,000. $50,000. $80,000. It's $80,000? That's how much we were sure. Yeah, that was $50,000. I thought it was $50,000 plus this, plus that.

21:36 Dave, I'm supportive of that if it's realistic. I mean, is that realistic we can pull that off? Well, you know, I have strong feelings about having the council be able to do whatever it is they want to do as nimbly as possible. So, you know, the bids are all done. The documents are all completed. It's just a matter of a change order, or in this case, probably a delete order.

22:07 And it'd be a matter of actually, if you follow the procedure of the application process, then you're going to have to work through the modifications of that, just recognize you're kind of violating your own rules. I mean, you can bring this up as an urgency, I don't deny the council and approve it. That's how fast you can get it done, if you want to do it fast. If you want to follow some kind of procedure of putting an application together, organizing the...

22:33 The Recreation Commission have a special meeting to approve it and give it on a council agenda. You're not going to see it until October because this is the last meeting of the month. If you follow a practical procedure, you could put it on tonight as an emergency.

22:48 And approve it. If you wanted to. But you're kind of walking around completely to measure our process. Yeah. And I don't want to do that. That's why I was saying we could do a special meeting if it came back to Council on that October 6th. I don't know where, and so this would be probably a question for Peter, where they would be in the process if that could still then go in this year with that. Because I don't know that they'll be done at that point. But anyways. Would it be a benefit to put it in right before winter, though?

23:17 Well, I'm not sure that the whole benefit of the whole park going to be right before winter is actually a benefit at all, but anyways, it is. And so I think the benefit is that it'll be there next spring and it'll be a complete portion of the phase one will be complete as opposed to it still being in. Well, and actually, Bill, I'm kind of wondering why you said you could save it for...

23:42 The next phase, whatever phase number we're on, is could it not, instead of running around the process, could it not be an application for that and have that put in first thing in the spring? Right. And you're probably right, except my understanding of construction, as limited as it may be, is that you have a cost saving of already having the contractors on the job and working on the job. To have them come back to do just a very small piece normally is going to cost you...

24:12 You know, exponentially higher than the cost, it would be having them do it in the first phase of contract. Well, okay, then let me ask it this way. Is there an anticipation that the next phase of Trails End is going to be one of the applications that's filed this fall? Well, in the agency, though, it is. That's the first factor of it. Oh, okay. And do we have the money for that next phase? Or do we have a lot of use? Right. But I think when we looked at the project for last time,

24:40 You know, so I think it is. We are looking towards, you know, our number one priority, which is finishing our number one priority.

24:56 Yeah, but is the finishing of Trails End Park the largest priority over something else? I guess that's, you know, that's a question that's a million-dollar question right now that we need to come to. Would you not make a go-around with yourself from a brand-new project that just came onto somebody's radar screen?

25:24 This is an application that was made and this project was approved. Yeah, I'm assuming the reason this is not being included is because there's costs associated with a project that run out of contingency or they're worried about that. No, I know why it's not. To follow your point of thought, though, this is not new. It's already built. They're going to bid, expect, approved, budgeted, and they're having to make some decisions about it based upon it.

25:50 You're right. So in that way, it's really just that it's a cost overrun. It's not really a new application. It's an oops-ertunity. Well, that's right. And so is it, would it not be, is it inappropriate? And I'm just thinking out loud to consider it an oops-ertunity.

26:07 Who's the chairman? I can't say that word. I'm a lawyer. Yes. We made it up. Is it possible that it effectively can be a draw from these funds but against the spring award process? You see what I mean? I don't mean, I don't mean. So we have to move in. My opinion is to come forward if it's that much of a priority to fund it.

26:35 I think from your point of view, you want to maintain the integrity of the Measure R and the process. So, you know, I think if you like the size, that's a precedent. Right. No, I actually think that we should, you know, honor the Measure R process and that it has to come back through because it did overrun and that we do a special meeting and that we could, you know, possibly push this through faster than having it wait until the end of October and, you know, until January. But I think the question would be to Peter that

27:04 If this was brought to Council the first meeting in October, would that give him sufficient enough time to still put that in during this? If they can't, but I don't think it makes a difference. So you've got direction on this, it looks like. Thank you.

27:30 Anything else on Measure 1? Yes, the Measure U Committee is a Committee of 1 this evening. So we conducted our meeting on September 11, early in the morning. This document you've seen before, there have been a couple of changes made to it. The high-level goals and priorities remain the same, 1 through 5, there's no change there.

27:59 All that was really added to it was point number two and point number five in regards to high impacts. The committee felt quite strongly that they wanted to identify top tier or long-lasting sustainable projects that will, et cetera, be identified and be prioritized. And that was the same for planning for the future. So both of those references are underlying in the document. And the high impact top tier.

28:26 When the Measure U Committee got together and went through all of this, the consensus was that we really would like to see this go to building the big things, not to be used up in small increments and then have the maintenance on those small projects eat up the funds so that we couldn't build the new sports complex or the new...

28:46 Venue or whatever. Really big things. Really big things, yeah. Large capital. So we put the high impact in there, although I don't think there are any shovel-ready high impact projects, which is why it shows up again in Plan for the Future, top tier and long-lasting sustainable projects, so that perhaps we can get some of the planning done on those, although still we need to get back our study on venues.

29:16 So that we know what direction to move forward with some of those top tier projects for arts and recreation, but that's why it appears in the choice to emphasize the fact that ultimately that's what we're looking at, the majority of this change for here. Has anybody talked to, we'll talk about his thoughts, not his thoughts, but the venue at Canyon Road, creating the venue at Canyon Road.

29:47 We had a long discussion about it. I mean anybody from your commission. Not that I know of. And it was always one with talking about these events and places to have events that's always been one of the places that's been looked at. So there were quite a few constraints to that. Yeah, let's remember the Canyon Lodge was used as a large venue in the past.

30:09 And the problem is if you're a blues palooza or if you're jazz jubilee or whoever you are, because of liability reasons, or that's the reason it's been told to me, the mountain doesn't want anybody up there doing a special event where the mountain doesn't do the food and beverage. Well, a big piece of your income to pay for those top tier bands comes from the beverage and food end of it. So if the mountain has to own a piece of your product, then how successful is it?

30:37 I think before as a town we look at the mountain as our big venue site, we need to work out some of those other nuts and bolts so that someone like Bluesapalooza can have a successful event and make the money they need to move that forward.

30:56 Successfully. I would assume that that's been looked at within the feasibility study. Well, the feasibility study has pretty much been put on hold. Oh, it has? Yeah, the reason being, we sat in on a meeting and the scope of it grew so big that it was all of a sudden you're asking the consultant to look at it for events and for recreation and Olympic training in the right way to understand what's going on. So it kind of got out of control.

31:26 As far as what it was we wanted, we needed a better understanding of what it was we wanted to see at that site. So it wasn't unfold, it was just cable. So we're going to get back to that site committee, so you've got a commissioner Turner and a group of city council, and then we'll get it back to the consultant. But hopefully it won't be taken down, if we have to add more money to it, it won't be taken down to such a scope.

31:53 That it doesn't tell us what the appropriate size venues and what type of entertainment and sports we'd be looking at to be successful with our audience. I think sports is being taken out of it. It's just more arts and culture. It's fine. But all of those questions are still important questions. Do we need and can we support a 10,000 seat rock and roll event before? Should we be a...

32:22 Those things need to be answered for us to move forward on the venue locations. Well, I think that was some of the, those were some of the discussions that came up. Do we want a 10,000 person or do we want to have 5,000 or 2,000? You know, these are all the things that were being kicked around. Do we, you know, and we're going to try to look at all the different potential sites and then prioritize them, okay, wins, have them work with the Forest Service, you know, I mean, all the different things were lined up.

32:50 It just got to the point where it became more than just an arts and culture. It became so big that I think we confused the consultant amongst ourselves. So anyway, it sounds like we're looking at it. One thing that should be considered as residential neighborhood doors. Yeah. Well, and that did come up because, you know, the school has a great location and willing to operate.

33:17 And, you know, we have this event concert right next to the hospital. Probably not going to work. Imagine the first concert, the hospital was going to shut us down like that. So just little things like that we have to go through. So this next document, so like we did with Measure R, we kind of estimated the fund balance for the Measure Year Award. And what we did...

33:44 We've estimated what we made, or actually this is the actual amount that we received last year from July 1 through December 31, and this is $280,000. This is the unencumbered fund balance that we have available from the previous awards, the $364,000. You can see our expenses, again, it's the administration, you can see the air service subsidy, you see the maintenance track that we have to come out, so isn't that a loan? Yeah. Yeah, but you've still got it. But we don't need cash. You don't need cash, so...

34:12 Why is, oh, that's right, because it didn't start, why is that July to December, because it's on, because of the data, the effective data of the legislation. Okay. So, the bottom number is it's a negative fund. So, what you're really saying is we don't have any money to allocate this fall. Right. Okay, well, which is another reason why it's lined in a lot of the parallel that there'd be more funds, so if there's, if there's not any, well,

34:42 So do you, the maintenance funds for the track, are they implied or does that mean another application or does the commission just decide that that's what they need? The maintenance funds would be included in an application that comes forward. So when an application comes forward, they're putting down what they're going to need to. So what we're saying is there's not likely to be a fall award until the loan gets paid back.

35:10 Because what's happened with, remember we did the fall wood, which was actually in the spring. Correct. The test was the big amount. Yeah, we were $900,000 in the spring, so now six months later. The question would be, do we do a fall award, do you want in the spring when you know it? Right.

35:28 You got your money back and you know what your maintenance is going to be. It comes back after our opportunity for Measure R, so it can still be awarded with Measure R, but it would be a spring award as opposed to the fall. Because why have people and organizations go to all the work of filing an application right now because we don't have any money? But the only problem with that is that you have the same, well, no, because you won't have that 3.5 that came out. Well, and I think that the,

35:57 Yes, it might make sense to line it up with Measure R, but I think that was one of the problems. It needs to be earlier in the spring. I would say maybe at a cycle that starts in January so that the special events, I would not save it until May because that was too late. That's true. I think we start the application process in January.

36:22 Well, do the awards even sooner than that? Because there won't be a whole bunch of money to award. As a committee member, I'd be comfortable doing that for one more year. I'd like to eventually see this fall into the fall cycle. This is going to be our fund, the next venue, that it needs to be in that fall cycle to fall into the construction cycle properly. Well, let me ask this question because somebody asked, I'm sorry. No, no. The question I had is Stu and Dave.

36:52 So, let's say you were doing an event next year and you're applying now for it. I mean, it's awfully early in some cases. You won't even know, for example, for the pipe games, I want to see if you can get an application for it.

37:15 But, yeah, we're still lining the event up, and it's a new event, and we would probably line up well with a lot of the priorities that set forth in Measure U. But we won't know for anyone or two as far as having a business plan together. I mean, we're going to have to force something for faster, but there's going to be a lot of guests. What's your feeling about the energy community members if we do delay the cycle discovery?

37:44 I think that all of us would be probably comfortable with that so that we can award for the special events side of it. Be careful not to grow that to such an amount that we do exactly what we don't want to do and take so much of this funds away that we can't probably put a project. Yeah, we kind of do like what we did with Trails. Exactly like this. Just an allocation and a portion of it. Then you get back on site. Right, and I think that's where we need to go with it.

38:13 However, I know that at least two of us on the committee are uncomfortable at this point with just the large sum of money going to the coalition without looking at some of the individual events and where the money is going and how it is going so that an old event that's not growing and isn't bringing in enough people to have a substantial punch doesn't continue to get new funds. And as I've said for a long time, I think...

38:43 As one of the committee members, the best way to fund special events in the long term is to do a T.O.T. amount, however much they're bumping the T.O.T. with their event and adding to the room base, you take a percentage of that just as you would with a... I don't know how to promote events, but I don't think just the opposite of what you're saying, which is...

39:13 If you're going to put an event on the next June or July, your budget is set eight months in advance. I think that's about right. For the first season. I guess what I'm getting at is it's kind of awkward to place. If you had two funding areas, you could kind of imagine. You're right, because last year I was saying it's too late in the cycle. We need to do it early. It's like January. Only because we have our seasons.

39:41 But you are right. It's just... Would it really be a problem if we want to align these to push MDRR back another month? Because really the moneys that we're funding in fall are really not being allocated until, you know, our spring... They're being allocated for spring projects. So if for something like this, as far as, you know, starting this in September really doesn't line up.

40:05 With stuff like that, maybe we push it back to October. I think we did that in January instead. I mean, is that really going to put us off where we, you know, we wanted to have so staff had enough time and if we awarded money that they could actually put it together and get the bids out so that we can actually start, you know, first thing in the spring and get things in the ground. But I don't know that...

40:29 Having this come back to us in January is necessarily that other than timing. I mean, everybody starts to be busy. So anyways, that would be the biggest thing. Well, initially, I guess, decided that the third party should be in order to be on that room. Well, was there any discussion whether this first time around since MLTSCC hasn't?

40:56 Allocated all of their $300,000, is there any possibility that Nordic for this winter could come out of that and then you replace it out of a future cycle? I don't know. I think it depends. Because even December is kind of late for Nordic. Yeah. I think it depends on what kind of application comes forward. Okay. Since it's not a town program at this point, I mean, hopefully, in my mind, eventually the town owns a grower.

41:22 And it becomes part of the Measure R cycle. It pays for grooming for more than just that, for snow clay, for Nordic, for a whole bunch of things. But that sounds like the only one that would be date sensitive if it moving things around. Because we hope we have snow in November. We awarded last fall, and the project still didn't move through the cycle in time to use the opportunity if we push it back in another month.

41:51 Then they're even a month further down the cycle. Then when do we start construction in November? And that's what I'm saying. Is there a possibility of this one time that part of it? Because it is a trail. It's just a skinny trail. I'm too little skinny skinny trails. And I think that what you're saying, though, was unusual. I mean, that project shouldn't have moved forward so that it didn't happen the way it did. But for whatever reason, it didn't move forward.

42:20 Until after the hoops are to the knee, until after summer, until after everything. So anyhow, but that's not typical. So anyhow. Yes. Well, and I'm hoping that whatever happens there is part town, part forest service, and part non-profit. I hope it's not a stand-alone like it had been before. So that we can look at it as a whole project.

42:46 Right. What's the factor of your word? Sustainable? Yes. Yes. You know, and I don't know. I don't know if that needs to go back to the general TSCC, which, and I'm looking to you since you sit on that as well. How do you have time to golf? Anyway, I don't know whether... I don't know if I get the chance I do. I don't know whether that's an option to get us through as we're trying to line up all these different timelines.

43:12 But we can certainly take it to the MLTSCC and ask opinions on it. Although some of our projects are already coming in over the original budget, so we're already in the position of having to move some of that money around, robbing Peter as it was to pay Paul. So on one hand, it's a sold-ready project that it could maybe appear that money allocated for trails is moving forward. Right. As opposed to waiting until the next summit.

43:39 Because, well, and, you know, as council, nothing's been reported back to us. I just happen to know that somebody was giving me a chance at the end of the summer because I was working on the trails today. But we don't know what you guys have prioritized or anything. So that's why I was asking these kind of questions. I want to be on our call. I want to tell you, I believe, Jo, just to jump in on the agenda for the next Wednesday's MTSCC meeting is to have a community wood dressing project. So that would be cool.

44:08 Do you address that? I just can't see us look at applications with no money. Yeah, but Measure U is the one without money, not Measure R. Okay. Yeah. That's true. And maybe with the way that Measure U is this year, we can leave Measure R in the cycle that it is, but maybe we look at it next year. And so if next year we need to move Measure R, you know, to awarding in January,

44:36 And maybe something like this comes up in the spring as opposed to coming up in the fall. And so then it can be awarded in the spring so that it is actually funded and in place. And that's kind of great comment is that if you're going to do something, you know, you need that eight months between when you know what you're getting and you actually have, in this case it's the snow, as opposed to having good women do the events, so that...

45:00 Maybe there does need to be a lag. And then that pushes it back a little bit for those folks trying to figure out summer meetings. They still give it in. We'll give it in. It's just, I don't need money right away. It's going to be money a year from now. But if there's just a look. I guess what I was getting at was we have this funding site, the site, the central area. United States, they were split and we had more to fund it. And there's still room to move around because you do. Estimated maintenance funds track. The track's not built yet.

45:29 Probably not going to spend $20,000 in maintenance in this cycle. So we could certainly choose to delay that maintenance and still have something there. Administration, if it's all going to the air service subsidy, do we really need $37,000 in admin fees coming out of you to administer the air work? I understand that, but still, most of the new stuff has been done. If we're not putting out any new...

45:58 If we're not awarding any new contracts, do we need that level of... If there's only one end of the fund, that's why the entire force is in there. No, I understand. Yeah, yeah. So if we don't procreate it now, then there's no money to pay sale. Right. I might just jump in there quickly. The only awkward thing, I think, that we felt last year, because we actually awarded last year in January, like January, February.

46:23 So we watered the fall in January, February, then we started spring straight away, and that came out in May. So you just compressed everything together, so I don't know if that's, again, the best interest of the funding cycles. Well, hopefully this year we will be on more of our original time. Take questions? Good afternoon, everybody. Great to see you all here talking about great things that the public money gives you great things, Scott.

46:48 The question I have is MLTPA last year wrote a measure application for the trust. And my understanding was that the council approved that with $300,000 a year for five years. That's my understanding. I just want to check in with council and commission why it does appear such that if no application gets submitted this year, because MLTPA is not planning on writing another letter,

47:12 That that $300,000 per year for five years is in place. There's no opportunity for a misunderstanding. It's already, yeah, that's my understanding of why it's on here is it's already an application. Good. I haven't seen that document. So I'm checking to make sure it's not convenient for civil assistance. Thank you very much for pushing it back to the next year. No, no, no. In other words, that they don't have to do an application each year because we said we were going to get five years at $300,000 each. The only question would be this one of, well,

47:41 Does something work to come back and then somehow get back filled? Yeah, but we don't have it. John? Yes, sir. I was supportive of that, but you don't have five years' worth of projects in your application. Well, this is the question. We wrote that application originally for MLTPA as an MLTPA official.

48:09 It was then, we determined that it was better to be doing without the town. The town, part of the work that we've done is establishing an MLTSCC. One would hope and trust that the MLTSCC is capable of identifying future projects. MLTPA could easily identify an annual set of projects for consideration. There's a lot of work that needs to be done with this system.

48:33 Again, it's about mitigating confusion. If someone has an expectation that we're coming up with new projects or we're doing it, we'd just love to know. I think the expectation at this point is the MLTSCC is a self-supporting, self-sustaining body and should be able to come up with new projects, should be able to come up with new efforts. That's kind of the question. I would assume that that's our assumption.

48:56 And that's actually why I was saying to Bill as part of that, that as long as they're reporting back to us on what they're setting as their priorities and things like that, they have become the body.

49:06 That would determine which projects go forward with this stuff. And I think that also... Is that with or without council approval? No, to council. The MLTSCC recommends to Reguliation Commission, then it comes to us, but I don't know if you said a dollar level because the contract with the Friends of the Inno didn't come to us.

49:27 It came to you as like I did basically. It said here was the top level, here was the ones, here's the twos, here's the queens. But I mean the reporting back on what things are actually coming out of that. Because it was a scatter shot. They're just finishing that project. So we should get within how many days are we doing? So there'll be a report back to council on what the first year's allocation looks like.

49:54 Followed then, by the second year, who's going to do that? Yeah. So, if the $300,000 that shows essentially as a linebacker, is how many cycles or how many years were $300,000 had you received? Oh, we haven't received that, Harold. This is all in the hands of the MLTSCC to allocate, appropriate, and do with your money.

50:21 With whatever process they set up with you, it's all supposed to be going through you. So if they allocate this fall, that's for next year's work. Well, and I think that they could, if they had a project that they have a charge that says that they had a project that came up in November, the MLTSCC could say, we want to get this thing done. They can then direct staff to get the contract and make something happen. Yeah, but that doesn't mean that MLTPA is going to be doing the work or receiving the money. Well, of course not.

50:48 That's up for that. These are the kinds of questions and decisions in the hands of the MLTSTC. And none of that $300,000 is going anywhere. It's still sitting in the measure art account until one of these projects come forward, and then it's in noise, and then it's data. I'll assume by now it's in noises. And staff did want to clarify, too, because it came before Town Council February 15.

51:14 So I think that actually has taken on NCCSC in the project and the scope of work. And I think it's outlined the process for appropriations. So it was NCCSC through recreation permission to Town Council. So that's really the part. I probably just made the point that, you know, the summer stewardship didn't ever get reported out to us. The council did allocate all $300,000 of last year's allocation. And a budget we brought you.

51:43 That was, as we admitted at the time, not a debt bank estimate because all the money's in it were estimated. And now we're finding that some things are going to cost us more and we're going to have to move things around in that and report back to the commission and then to the council on how those are getting moved around and approved by your body. You're the only ones who can spend money. So, you know, this year.

52:11 This to me seems like a decade ago. Yeah. So my, but I recall that specifically. The question then that I have, I had an expectation that that $300,000 was going to be spent this year. Was it supposed to have been? And I think we will spend it. And I think it will be spent this year. In this fiscal year. Yeah. And then you'll get a plan to the community for a $300,000 expenditure for next year. Yeah. But we're pretty late. I mean.

52:39 I mean, it's September 19th, but we're moving. And Rick, to answer your question, I think that the application gave enough of an overview that there's definitely more than five years worth of $300,000. Oh, yeah, I understand. And I think that that was the other thing we said is, well, if you find out that, you know, just planning law on the backside of bonds is going to cost more than you come back with a separate application to...

53:08 Matthew was saying it's a very confusing process.

53:35 I don't know why it doesn't sink in with me, but I think it's because there are too many non-parallel processes, which goes to Jo's agenda law a couple weeks ago. Maybe we've created it this way because it forces you to think about it.

53:51 I'm just saying, you know, where else did we go with us? Well, but I think in that, there's the expectation of this. Oh, yeah.

54:14 We've got a meeting starting in five minutes. Thank you. Michael? Was he ever there? No. He had a post on his door in Mexico.

54:44 I'll go ahead and start by saying there's nothing to report from closed session tonight. I know a lot of folks were hoping to hear some additional information on the settlement today, but we have some additional I's to dot, T's to cross, things of that nature, so we're not going to be reporting anything on that today. So with that,

1:04:23 I will go ahead and start. We'll go ahead and start with roll call. So, Jamie, can you get this roll call, please? Councilmember Bacon? Here. Councilmember Reeson? Here. Councilmember Ramondo? Airport Tem, Wood? Here. Mayor Lehman? Here. Okay. Thank you. With that, we'll go ahead and start with Pledge of Allegiance. John, could you lead us in there, please? I'd be happy to. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands.

1:04:53 One nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Okay. With that, we'll go ahead and move on to public comment. So if there's anything that anybody in the audience would like to discuss that's not on tonight's agenda, please approach the podium, state your name, and let's hear it. Thank you very much. Good evening, members of the council and the public. My name is John Wentworth.

1:05:25 On behalf of the ESEA, the Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association, the Sierra Nevada Conservancy, and the Indian National Forest, MLTPA, just bringing to your attention a very interesting and important workshop happening next week. This is the Sierra Cascade Dialogue. This is something that the regional national forest has been conducting over the last, I'll say, year or so.

1:05:46 That focuses specifically on regional-based communications and conversations about opportunities on public lands. And the next one is coming up next Thursday, September 27th at Cerro Coastal College in Bishop. And the specific focus of that conversation is recreation, social and economic opportunities and impacts. And I think with the degree to which recreation is a stable and...

1:06:07 Significant part of our economy and our culture. I would encourage everybody to try to take the day and go down and participate in that. The dialogue itself takes place out of Sacramento, but our local and international for us has set up a satellite office to be able to do this out of Bishop so we can participate in the full conversation, the full dialogue from people all over the state and all over the region. So I would encourage us all to participate. Thank you very much. Thank you, John. Any questions from Council? Members of the public? Okay. Anybody else from the public?

1:06:36 So we have somebody coming up. Very stoic as a business owner. And just kind of letting council know that, you know, we all need to have good customer service, and that needs to go with the staff and projects that are going on with the town as well. Ludushoot, Lake Mary Road connector that's been going on, it's, you know, been a little inconvenient for our businesses all summer. But I just want to let you know that there was never a detour.

1:07:10 That was put up. So people that were coming up the road, we emailed all our customers. So hopefully they got that information and we guided them how to get to our property. But if they went up thinking they were going to turn on Lakeview Road and then couldn't, you know, how do they get back around? There was never any detour. I have to tell you, these last three days have been absolutely ridiculous. And so there has to be some type of communication with businesses because I could have actually.

1:07:39 Kept guests from the upper part of my complex and not put anybody up there for that period of time and only kept them down there because they couldn't get from one end of my complex to the next because they had the entire Lakeview Road right at that intersection closed. And so it affected us actually quite large. They had all of the equipment in the entire one section of our complex where I had to move a customer because they couldn't even get into their complex.

1:08:08 So, you know, if I knew that ahead of time, then I'm taking care of my customer. I don't have anybody that's upset about anything. And then everything can go smoothly. And I realize, you know, just a letter, just to, hey, you know, whatever, you know, maybe I should have assumed that that's what was going to go on. But I came back from vacation. Everything was closed down.

1:08:27 And it was like, are you kidding me? Anyways, there was just no communication whatsoever. And it's being finished today, and it'll be great. It'll be wonderful when we try to cooperate as much as possible. But a little bit of communication would have been a great thing. Okay. Thank you, DeGray. Could we maybe ask Ray to pass something on in the future? Thank you. Is there anybody else in the public that has anything they'd like to speak on? Okay.

1:08:56 With that, I will move on to Councilmember Reports, and we'll start with John. I have none, Mr. Mayor. Okay. Jill? I have none. Rick? I do. I attended the monthly meeting of Mammoth Lakes Housing on Monday. There is an agenda item, which is number six on policy matters, and we'll report the board's

1:09:25 Position on that when it comes forward. Nancy Mahana was there again as well furthering a discussion about either converting or considering converting some of our projects to no smoking or smoke-free projects. I'll report to Council as that is coming forward. That is something that we're taking a look at and we'll have further discussion.

1:09:55 I also, 10 days ago, attended the Clampers Dedication of the Dave McCoy Monument at the Main Lodge. If you haven't been up there to see it, it's positioned just west and in the same round area where the statue of the Woolly Mammoth is at the Main Lodge. Pretty impressive representation of Clampers from all over the place.

1:10:20 It was really quite nice for Dave and Roma McCoy on that day. Just a wonderful tribute to him. I didn't know you were a clamber. I am not, and I was a little out of place. Oh, okay. Just checking. But I hung in there. I also attended, at the request of John Urdi, a dinner for the Outdoor Writers Association of California.

1:10:50 That was held, actually put on by the mountain on Sunday night. About 70 or so riders of things outdoors from California were there. And really good event. Obviously, John put on quite an event over a number of days for those folks, and the weather couldn't have been better. So we'll see what comes from that.

1:11:15 Last but not least, I received in the mail the October issue of Running Times Magazine, and in the very center of the magazine is an article entitled Elite Base Camp, which is a two-page spread pictorial as well as print of Mammoth Lakes.

1:11:40 In this spread, there's a picture of one of the lakes in the lake space, as well as photos of Meb Kevleski and Dina Castor running. Really spectacular. And just a really positive article saying, hey, if you want to run in altitude, here's the place. Go visit Mammoth Lakes. So I don't know if you actually need to buy that kind of coverage. So I suppose you could, but it would cost a lot of money. So I'm really proud of that. That's all I have. Thanks. Great. Thank you, Rick. I have a couple of things.

1:12:10 This report on the outdoor writers, I kind of wish I could have attended that. I was curious, who, what kind of writers, what kind of magazines do you recall that were there? Well, from national magazines to local publications, including outdoor magazine, national geographic magazine. What they are is a group of freelancers who submit articles to various magazines, and so they're not necessarily connected to one or employed by one.

1:12:39 That's as far as I can tell from the folks that I spoke to. So it's primarily people who know and write about outdoor activities and including activities in the mountains. I imagine the marketing benefit off that's going to be pretty amazing. We'll see. Okay. Well, thank you. I just had the report that I met with my – Councilmember Raimondo and I met with Bill Cockroft again.

1:13:04 To discuss a little further the mountain biking event, or the biking event, rather, that we hope to bring forth to Mammoth next September, and Bill's been working feverishly on it, and actually came up with a name, it's going to be the Mammoth Kamikaze Bike Games, it'll be taking place in September 3rd through the 8th of next year, and it's going to host a bunch of different types of disciplines of bicycling, from street,

1:13:31 Hopefully, a criterion. Downhill, cross country, all those good things, but I believe Bill is in Las Vegas right now announcing that at Interbike, which is the big biking event for North America. John Urdi, a number of other people, other groups are working on bringing the Mammoth Half Marathon here in June, so we're really trying to work on, say we, they, are really trying to work on bookending.

1:13:58 Our summer so we can add more festivities and hopefully have a better summer ever. And a lot of those two different groups are working with charities so hopefully after all the expenses are paid and whatnot there'll be some money left over for local charity. I spoke with Nikki Brown and she's going to be bringing forward

1:14:25 New plan for the Economic Stimulus Council, and it will involve a lot of these different events and some other activities, so I look forward to hearing from that. Other than that, I really don't have anything else, and yes, John. Mr. Mayor, if I may, we had a request from an individual to have his letter read. Can I go ahead and read that? Yeah, you would. The council got a letter from an individual who's a second homeowner.

1:14:54 In Mammoth Lakes, primary residence in Calabasas. And he sent us an email and just requested that his email be read into the record. So that's what I'm going to do. He says he's a multiple property owner in Mammoth Lakes. Unfortunately, he cannot be in attendance, but would like to have his statement be read for the record. On Friday, August 24th, he learned from reading headlines in the Mammoth Times that a settlement had been reached with MLLA.

1:15:24 What struck him as most powerful in the headline was the after semicolon, details vague. As a property owner and great lover of Mammoth Lakes, it is my opinion that this council has been instrumental in taking us down a path of great difficulty these past many years, never mind the question of adequate snowfall or the difficulty associated with the lousy national or worldwide economy.

1:15:50 Those are elements far beyond our control, but how we go about handling our own immediate affairs should be well within our capacity to understand and participate. Unless this settlement that the Council says it has reached is profoundly and powerfully a huge benefit to the town, while still being acceptable to the lien holder, we should not be entering into any agreement at all at this early time. We should proceed with the planned bankruptcy.

1:16:17 If we do not, the millions of dollars we have already spent will be for nothing. Specifically, unless this settlement is in the low single digit millions and we have a clear cut and reasonable plan for being able to pay that money, this will be a bad, bad deal. I say go in front of the bankruptcy judge and give it your best. We are broke. The developer, had he gone ahead with this project as he planned, would have likely by now been equally broke.

1:16:47 However, the legal system has judged us to this date with the culpability of wrongdoing to this developer not following through with his bankruptcy proceeding would be the greater crime. Unless the Council is prepared to disclose the entire nature and cost of this settlement and where and how they plan on getting the money to pay for it would be yet the greatest crime of all against the good people of the town of Mammoth Lakes.

1:17:13 We have a right to know what good or bad deal you have planned with our money and our town. Respectfully submitted, Peter, I believe it's... Doc. What? Doc. Doc. Peter Doc. Thank you. Any questions or comments, Council? Public? Okay. With that, we will move on to commission updates. So are there any updates from any commissioners? Okay.

1:17:45 Seeing none. We'll go ahead and move on to department reports and emerging issues. Any reports from departments? Emerging issues? Seeing none. Wow. Okay. Moving along. So we'll move on to council presentations. I just wrote five and a half hours. I'd like to make a comment, please, if I may. I know I'm late, but... Okay. Are you Peter? Yes. Okay. Does council have any objections? I don't. No. Yeah, that's fine. Okay, please.

1:18:15 Come up to the podium if you could state your name at the podium. Dear Doc, D-A-C-H. And quickly, Councilmember Eastman just read your letter. Oh, you did? Yeah. Okay. Can I add to it? Absolutely. Okay. I just think it's important. I know you guys all love Mammoth. We all love Mammoth. But I think in the interest of the community, the council should be forthcoming with what this deal is before you...

1:18:47 So that's a large part of it.

1:19:16 The council will make a decision first before any disclosure is made to the community. Is that correct? Correct. Again, as I said in my letter, if it isn't an astounding deal for the community, it's probably a really bad deal. And again, since I don't know the numbers and you guys are privy to them, I am not. And if the community is not privy to those numbers, is there any way that you can have some kind of dialogue with the community?

1:19:46 By providing those numbers and not sacrificing your, you know, position in mediation or compromise? I think the short answer is no, we can't. It's just a, it's, there are so many different facets of this situation and as I said before, we are bound by, you know, legal nature. But as far as where that money is going to come from? Yeah.

1:20:13 You can't provide that information in advance either about how that is going to be funded. Whatever the deal is, you're incapable of providing that information before the yields made. Well, where the money comes from and how the money is spent will be something that, I guess I'm trying to think of how we tread water here lightly without crossing the line. You let Andy answer it. I think it's not really possible to explain where the money would come from or when it would have to be paid without divulging details.

1:20:44 Can you provide that information? No, we can provide that information. So we're going to have to live with whatever deal the council chooses to make. I'm just a big advocate that you've spent so many millions of dollars going down this road toward bankruptcy. There's got to be some rationale. Either it's a very good deal for the town, or it's not, or there's some rationale why the town is choosing to

1:21:12 Except some kind of settlement. And my concern as a citizen is the deal is not, I'm concerned that the deal is not as good as it should be. And I think taking your chances in front of the bankruptcy judge is way more sound, way more intelligent. You've spent the funds anyway thus far. You've come this far. Why don't you do it? Why don't you go in front of the bankruptcy judge? I don't think anyone's in a position to comment on that.

1:21:39 That is my piece. I think you need to think long and hard before you make a deal with these people at a number that is too expensive for us to afford when I think you will get a much more favorable ruling in front of a bankruptcy judge than you realize. Thank you. Well, Peter, I appreciate the comment. I really do. Thank you. Counsel, have any comments or questions? Okay.

1:22:07 All right. Well, then, with that, we will move on to council presentations. Dave? Five-year-old? Yes, sir. So I'm now at the Acting Community Development Director. One of the most delightful things I can do today is recognize Ellen for five years of service. And I'm just going to read a little bit. She's given some information to me, which I think is good.

1:22:39 I didn't realize that you were born in the area. She's been with the town for five years. Fire has spent seven years with a consulting firm in the Bay Area. Most of that has been with the small cities with general plans and so forth. With the town, she's been involved in many things over the past five years. Policy development, secret with your neighborhood district plans, developing benefits of populations of one-time policies.

1:23:07 Updated the housing ordinance, housing element, management trail system, master plans, and the parks and recreation, master plan, CEQA, and more recently, the zoning code update. Since I've been the community development director for the past, like, eight hours, I've also had kind of a chance to be working more with you just on what's happening in the planning department. And there's a lot of action, a lot of activities that are going on. We've got a large matrix of all of those things that are, you know, I've kind of known about them from a...

1:23:36 Farm's Life Relationship, but now we've been much more close to that. We've really begun to appreciate how much you have served and what you've been doing for the town, so thank you very much. So our appreciation to you. Appreciate it. Thank you. Okay, great. Thank you, Alan. Did you notice? With that, we'll go ahead and move on to our public presentations. We have a presentation tonight from the Sierra Business Council. So,

1:24:19 Good evening, Mr. Mayor, members of the Town Council. Thank you very much for having me here tonight. My name is Steve Frisch. I'm the president of the Sierra Business Council, which is a regional 501c3 business membership-based organization. We have about 110 members on the east side of the Sierra Nevada, and we are blessed to have many members in the Mammoth Lakes area.

1:24:48 I wanted to update you tonight on a report that we recently completed and provided to you called the Eastern Sierra Innovation and Prosperity Report. And I'm going to tell you a little bit about the background of the report, synopsize the findings and recommendations of the report, but more important, I think, I'd like to save a decent amount of time for questions and answers and discussions about some of the strategies that are included.

1:25:17 Within the report. So the background of the report really the Sierra Business Council working on regional economic development issues watched as the kind of economy of the region collapsed along with the national economy and recognized the point that there were specific regions of the Sierra Nevada where very discreet and relatively short-term interventions could have

1:25:44 Pretty considerable positive benefit to the economy in the long run. So we were looking for opportunities to find areas within the Sierra Nevada where we could actually do some of this economic analysis. And the two areas that we looked at were the southern Sierra Nevada counties of Tulare, Fresno, Madera, and Kern, and then the east side of the Sierra Nevada.

1:26:10 In Inyo and Mono County. We aggregated funding from members in the region to help pay for the report and we also need to thank the Donald Schlager Foundation for major support for the report and the effort as well. So the genesis of the report really was developed or the meat of the report was developed by

1:26:36 A public involvement process that included a steering committee of about 40 citizens from the east side of the Sierra Nevada, and they're listed in the front page of the report, but many of them are people that I think you're used to seeing and dealing with on a relatively regular basis. Susan Estrada from the Eastern Sierra Connect Report, several of the Mono County Supervisors, Dan Leister from Mono County Economic Development, Dan Estroud, John Urdi,

1:27:05 Alicia Venos, John Wentworth, who was here a couple of minutes, oh, is here still today. And the advisory committee met on several occasions, about eight or nine occasions, in order to identify what strategy we would use to move forward, what the content of the report would be, and then what the likely implementation measures might be looking down the line.

1:27:32 So the steering committee met on a regular basis for about a year during the drafting of the report. We did about 80 interviews in the community and interviewed some of you as well. And we did interviews with, we really concentrated on business clusters and business leaders within the Eastern Sierra to ask them what they felt they needed or what they felt would be the best short-term strategies for economic development.

1:27:59 We also interviewed 15 state and federal economic development professionals whose regions cover the Eastern Sierra area, including the Governor's Office of Business Development, the Governor's Office, the USDA Rural Development Agency, the U.S. Department of Commerce, the Small Business Development Center, and a number of others. We conducted eight community workshops in Inyo and Mono County.

1:28:27 circulated a draft document for a public review for about 60 days before finalizing the document. And while we were circulating that draft document, we actually went out and re-interviewed people to see whether or not the strategies that were developed within the document fit with what their expectations were as part of the process. And that's what led to this final document that you have in front of you today. The committee really

1:28:57 Early on in the process determined a couple of things as far as what approach we should be taking in looking at economic development strategies. The first is they were very interested in this idea of doing what's known as cluster-based economic development. It's a relatively common process to be used, particularly in rural areas now, and the idea is that it looks at what your kind of core strengths and capabilities already are.

1:29:26 And then looks at how you can expand on those in order to get new business development, new employment, and higher wage employment. The definition of an economic cluster is a geographic concentration of interconnected businesses, suppliers, service providers, and institutions where improvement made in one will boost productivity in the others.

1:29:50 So the idea here is that you're trying to amplify the effect of your interventions in order to get the best possible outcome. And then the committee also worked on developing criteria for how they would select clusters. We did quite a bit of economic analysis as part of this process. Actually, you'll see an economic profile of Inyo and Mono County that was conducted roughly a year ago.

1:30:17 That is about 40 pages in the middle of the report. And the identification of the clusters was really driven by the data in that report along with the interview process. I want to highlight one interesting statistic from that report that really kind of opened our eyes about what some of the challenges are on the east side. And that is one of the graphs in the report actually shows the sole proprietorship revenue.

1:30:46 I believe it's on 134. 134, yeah. And what you see in that graph is a relatively steady decline. It's the graph titled, it's actually 135, Average Wage Salary in Proprietors' Income. And what you see in that graph is a relatively steady decline in sole proprietorship incomes.

1:31:14 In businesses on the east side, really going from what was about four times the federal poverty level in 1980 down to about double the federal poverty level in 2008. And one of the things that we were struck by here as we interviewed businesses was really this idea that really small business development hasn't advanced much on the east side of the Sierra Nevada in the last 20 to 30 years.

1:31:44 Kind of a major underlying issue that we needed to try to address in this report. So we really did focus quite a bit on that issue of what interventions can actually help small business. The criteria selected for the criteria for selecting the clusters that was agreed upon by the committee is we wanted to look at things where activities that could be done at a local level.

1:32:10 With resources generally in hand, they would require some fundraising and some new partnerships and other things, but generally with resources in hand could be done within three to five years. So they were really looking for the where can we get bang for our buck. The second criteria was that they were governed by things that we could affect locally. So there was quite a bit of discussion of

1:32:36 Some of the things that required long-term federal planning processes or huge infrastructure investments or things like that. And there was general agreement that people really wanted to focus in on, you know, what can we do locally without having to depend upon some huge external process to drive. And then the third thing, of course, was what had high job potential, not just in numbers of jobs.

1:33:00 But also in wages, in higher wage jobs. So the five clusters that were selected by the group were internet and broadband technology, meeting California's renewable energy standard, finding niches in tourism, hospitality, and the arts, diversifying recreation, and value-added agriculture. Now I'm going to go through each of those real quickly and talk about what some of the key strategies were.

1:33:30 One recurrent theme that you will find in the document that actually touches all five of these clusters is the importance and the historic opportunity that Digital 395 actually offers for the east side of the Sierra Nevada. I don't think we really expected to find that when we started, but what we quickly discovered was that in each one of these clusters, access to high-speed communications,

1:33:59 Access to broadband and the ability to bring new technologies to the region actually created some very interesting and desirable opportunities that many people were already envisioning in the community and have been struggling with how you bridge the gap between kind of getting the big pipe and getting to use the big pipe, right? So that was a recurrent theme in the document and it was the first cluster that we selected.

1:34:28 We identified a number of opportunities, including expansion of IT support services, which create direct jobs relatively quickly. These are things like web design, computer software, information systems, and a number of other kind of supporting and maintenance type functions. Expansion of network services. This is the services that come along with cloud computing and

1:34:56 Connecting really home-based businesses and professional service people to high-speed data and cloud computing as a means of allowing them to operate their businesses or pursue their professions on the east side of the Sierra Nevada. And the one area that we really went into real depth on was expansion of e-commerce on the east side of the Sierra Nevada. There was recently a USDA report that has been tracking

1:35:25 The installation of broadband in rural regions in the United States. And their preliminary findings are that within three years of high-speed communications being installed, that retail sales generally increase about 8 to 10 percent adjusted for inflation. So not including the effect of inflation increase about 8 to 10 percent. And there are a couple of key reasons for that. The first reason is that like it or not,

1:35:55 With the rise of essentially online retailing by companies like Amazon and others, that local businesses and small businesses really need to be competing in that market for online sales if they're going to maintain market share. Bricks and mortar retail has only been increasing at about 3% per year. Online retailing has been increasing at about 12% per year for the last 10 years.

1:36:22 So what you're seeing is a gradual erosion of bricks and mortar retailing and there needs to be some effort to create competition from small businesses on bricks and mortar, from small businesses on online retail. So one of the recommendations is a pretty concentrated e-commerce training program for the east side of the Sierra Nevada and we're already in discussions with Saracosa College.

1:36:49 About trying to find some funding from USDA and the Economic Development Administration to do e-commerce training and to train small businesses how to incorporate e-commerce into their business plans and strategies. The second thing that we discovered in the leveraging internet technology was that really the rise of kind of social media based online marketing and brand identity.

1:37:18 That is really driving customers to create loyalty to specific businesses. In many regions of the country is becoming the way small business competes with large business in other regions. So this is essentially creating kind of the fan base that will use your business on a regular basis and will recommend your business to others. And even within the community.

1:37:42 We'll do business-to-business purchasing and create a direct relationship between the business and consumer. So this is kind of setting up business-to-consumer networks that use social media tools in order to connect and build that relationship. So that's one of the second main recommendations within the internet and technology area. In meeting California's renewable energy standard, we really focused in on two key things.

1:38:12 There are a number of kind of drivers of the renewable energy standard in California. Love it or hate it, we have laws now that are requiring that we get 20% of our power from renewable sources by 2020 and 30% by 2030, 33% by 2030. So this opens up.

1:38:37 Some really incredible opportunities for two things that we saw that are really kind of underserved on the east side of the Sierra Nevada. The first is distributed generation and the primary mechanism for distributed generation which would work on the east side of the Sierra Nevada is expanding the implementation of the California Solar Roof Program. Probably not as relevant here in Mammoth Lakes as it is in other areas on the east side.

1:39:04 But it is an opportunity in the surrounding communities that could create employment in the area. But the other area of kind of meeting the renewable energy standard that is growing in the state of California and has increasing funding is energy efficiency. There's about $400 million a year that's distributed statewide for energy efficiency goals. It's distributed by...

1:39:30 Your local utilities like your investor owned utilities like Southern California Edison. And that money goes into targeted energy efficiency programs both at the business level and at the residential level. To give you an idea of the savings that can be available there if you do whole building retrofits for energy efficiency, we're implementing a program on the west slope of the Sierra Nevada where we've done about 700 whole building retrofits.

1:39:58 And the average savings in the utility bills for each of those commercial businesses has been between 25 and 40 percent. And that's money that those small businesses have to reinvest in inventory, invest in salaries, and in other areas. So it really is something that could be done relatively quickly if you can access the CPUC funding for energy efficiency and expand the energy efficiency programs that you have here.

1:40:27 I know that High Sierra Energy Foundation has a program in place in the community, so the mechanism exists for expanding that program or expanding the services that are available through that program and getting real savings to businesses within a two to three year period.

1:40:47 Under finding the niches in tourism, hospitality, and the arts, we really focused in on three key strategies. The first was developing web-based media and marketing tools and tying those web-based media and marketing tools to kind of growing social media connections and kind of web-based mapping and other outreach tools. Just to give you an idea of the growth in that industry,

1:41:16 A project that we've been working on that Mammoth Lakes actually has been a partner in and that John Wentworth has been a partner in is the Sierra Nevada Geotourism Project, which is a web-based map guide to the Sierra Nevada and is also now a mobile app for both iPhones and Androids that you can download and actually acts as a guide when you travel through the region. We were stunned with the growth.

1:41:44 of kind of the community that we built around that project. We expected it to be relatively popular, but in its first 18 months it had 1.7 million unique viewers, and it's now getting 55,000 unique viewers a month to the website. Every one of those unique viewers is someone that's looking at our region, that is interested in the region, wants to come here and do something, and if we build a direct relationship with them,

1:42:13 Will come back. And that's the type of online media and marketing that we're talking about is really looking at how you create an identity for the Eastern Sierra where you get brand loyalty from the people that come here so that you can build a longer term relationship with them and bring them back again and again. The second thing that we looked at was the idea of expanding special events, which I know the town of Mammoth Lakes has been very involved in over the years.

1:42:42 But one of the things that seemed to be lacking that many people recognized was kind of higher level training and microfinance to help advance those special events. That often what happens is it's like the same 20 people doing special events all the time and they get a little bit burnt out. And then the ability of those events to become institutionalized and grow.

1:43:07 So one of the strategies that we identified was kind of a concerted training program for special events and then finding ways to finance those special events so that there's seed money to advance them that gets paid back from the proceeds from the event itself or from other things.

1:43:34 And then the third thing in finding the niches in tourism and hospitality and the arts was something that we didn't expect to find but in both the interview process and in the discussions really kind of raised to the forefront and that was some sort of a regional program for customer service and hospitality training which I know has been discussed several times in the community before but when you think about

1:44:01 How this region actually competes against other regions of the Intermountain West for repeat visitors and customers, that issue of customer service and training is really what gives you a pretty immediate competitive edge. With the installation of Digital 395, access to higher speed communications, there are actually a number of very high quality.

1:44:27 Customer Service Training Programs that are available online through kind of online course training that could be linked to local businesses along with some sort of an incentive program in order to incentivize employees to actually use those training videos and measure progress.

1:44:47 On Customer Service and Hospitality. See, I can say this because I don't live in the community, so I don't have to answer for it tomorrow, which is kind of nice. But we were kind of surprised at that result when we were in our interview process. And it's something that actually, we looked at three or four different tools that could be used, and we've been talking to Saracosa College about potentially working on that piece of it as well.

1:45:15 In diversifying recreation, we looked at several key strategies. The first was really increasing a focus on recreational access for diverse ages and abilities and underserved geographic areas surrounding both the town and the main developed areas of the eastern Sierra. One of the really kind of interesting issues in California, I think, is that

1:45:44 The emergence of kind of a Hispanic travel and tourism industry and the point that the Hispanic audience in California actually wants some different kind of mixes of amenities and services. And you see that planning going on in the U.S. Forest Service for West Slope Sierra Nevada forests right now looking at how they can link to

1:46:08 Kind of specific communities in the Central Valley to bring them into the forest and have access to the forest. We think the same sort of opportunity exists on the east side of the Sierra Nevada as well. That's not the only area of diversity that we looked at. We also looked at age diversity and the importance of really looking at getting a broader kind of cross section of people coming into the region. The second thing we looked at was wayfinding. And I have to tell you,

1:46:36 I'll tell you just a quick story about wayfinding because I think the single most important thing that you could do on the eastern Sierra to diversify recreation and make it more accessible is to expand the wayfinding programs that you have already started here in Mammoth Lakes. That approach where the visitor to the region is instantly comfortable where they are, they have the important information that they need, they need

1:47:05 They know where to park. They know where they can find a restroom. They know how long a trail is. They know what the difficulty level is. They know whether or not they can take their children on it. That sort of instantaneous information that makes people comfortable being in a place is a huge competitive edge. So wayfinding is something that we identified as an absolutely critical strategy, not just

1:47:31 For Mammoth Lakes, but to expand into the rest of the eastern Sierra Nevada as well. And then the final thing we identified within the report, this is the only area in the report where we actually identified a need for real capital improvements. And those capital improvements are things like you have demonstrated on the wall here today. But things like if you're really going to attract a more diverse kind of recreational audience, you need to have the parking,

1:48:01 The restrooms, the signage, the access points, in some cases improved trails, and the other things that are necessary in order to make that possible. So this was the only area of the report where we actually identified long-term capital improvements. And then finally, in the encouraging wellness through value-added agriculture, this was really targeted more at northern Mono County, quite frankly.

1:48:29 Where there is kind of more of an opportunity for a value-added agriculture, although the opportunity exists across the entire region. We looked at three or four key strategies. The first was improving marketing and product development for the value-added products that already exist here. Things like Alpers trout, things like the...

1:48:49 Specialty crops that are being grown and used at your farmers markets, value added products that could be developed from those and sold in the local community, looking at advancing local sales and maybe even creating some preferential treatment for those local products within institutions in the region, schools, jail facilities and other things.

1:49:13 Where you actually could create a market by committing to purchase from locally grown products. But the second key strategy within encouraging wellness was looking at agricultural tourism and development and attracting specific urban markets. And what we were looking at here was really that issue of the kind of growing interest in agricultural tourism across the country.

1:49:40 And the point that the Reno market doesn't really have a close-in agricultural tourism destination region, whereas Sacramento and other areas of California already do. So the strategy we're looking at here is trying to link an ag tourism program in northern Mono County to the Reno-Carson City area. And actually this was a strategy that Carson Valley was pursuing about 10 years ago.

1:50:09 And really what's happened in Carson Valley is that a lot of the agricultural production actually got converted to housing. And the opportunities for ag tourism had diminished quite a bit. That opportunity still exists in the Bridgeport Valley and Antelope Valley. So to wrap up, I wanted to mention just a couple of things that we're doing as a follow-up.

1:50:35 Looking at trying to put together community partnerships around these first two clusters, the e-commerce project with Sierra Cosa College and the renewable energy cluster. And actually we're looking at trying to put together some sort of a community-led effort to go to the Public Utilities Commission and ask for increased service on the east side. To give you an idea of what that differential is,

1:51:03 The way energy efficiency is kind of managed, everything that you install is called a measure, whether it's a light bulb or it's a power plant, right? And on the west slope of the Sierra Nevada, we can install in our program about 180 measures. In Southern California, most of their programs can install somewhere in the area around 250 measures. And on the east side of the Sierra Nevada, you have about 40 measures available to you.

1:51:32 So what we're really looking at is expand that suite of measures that you have available to businesses on the east side and in residential facilities so that they have access to the same suite of services that the rest of the state of California has. So the next steps, prioritize which actions can be taken and we're looking at trying to build kind of community leadership groups around each one of those.

1:51:58 Convene those and then go out and find the funding in each specific area to begin implementing specific recommendations. One thing that I think is really important, this is a big document, there's a lot of stuff in it, like economic development is about doing the things you can do. What we think is really important is find the stuff that you can do to prove success and pick those and do those. And if you keep doing that, eventually you do.

1:52:28 The hundred things that you need to do in order to make it all really work together. So don't get captured by the size of a document or the breadth of a plan. Look at the things that you can do and lead on implementing those as quickly as possible. So before I finish, I do have to say eight hours, huh Dave? I will miss Mark.

1:52:52 Mark was a very good person to work with. I really like Mark Warnlow. I think he did a lot of really good things in the town. I had a great relationship with him over the years. He's been a good friend of Sierra Business Council as far as giving us advice on planning issues. And I just wanted to finish off by saying I think the town of Mammoth Lakes was lucky to have him, and I wish him well in where he is. Thank you. Great. Are there any questions, council, comments?

1:53:22 Just thank you for the presentation and also the information in here is very interesting. The economic profile is, you know, that economic profile is 2008. Most of it is 2008 data. I mean, we are planning on rerunning that economic profile system with 2011 data when it's available early in 2013.

1:53:51 And I think that's going to be very telling about what the impact of the recession really has been. Well, thank you. Thank you. I think it's interesting, too, to understand the importance of the Internet and the multimedia and whatnot, not only how it can benefit us, but how it's going to hurt us if we don't get those things in here sooner. We've been hearing some of the backlash. I've been feeling it personally in my own business, so I've been hearing more and more of that lately.

1:54:20 And we certainly heard that in the interview process. I think this issue of how access to high-speed communications is actually eventually going to affect small business and retail business, I think is really critical. There are fascinating models out there today of small businesses that have adopted e-commerce as a strategy, and they actually don't even take possession of the inventory.

1:54:50 Essentially what they do is they build loyalty from their customers in the community and they drop shift from suppliers directly to someone's house or to their business where the customer can then pick it up. But, you know, this is a wave that's going to sweep across the nation over the next 20 to 30 years and if we don't start getting a handle on it now, it's really going to be devastating to small business. You know, the other thing I mentioned, you and I had talked about it when we met a couple of months, some months ago.

1:55:21 The numbers, the demographic numbers are simply amazing to look at and I commend anybody to this document. I don't know where we're going to keep this document. I'm sure that the Economic Stimulus Council is going to be very interested in this stuff because you don't really have a sense other than just intuitively or maybe anecdotally about how well we're doing as a whole or how poorly we're doing. And we measure...

1:55:48 As a town, how well we're doing principally by TOT, or room receipts and the tax that comes from that, and sales tax and so on. But this really drills down in a way that is really startling. In many respects, we have not done well or progressed economically in the last 20 years in a manner that's consistent with the rest of the state or even the country. And what was really surprising to me

1:56:17 And I've only had this a couple of days, but when you and I were speaking a couple of months ago is that we went through a boom period here, or what most people would call a boom period. And as a long-term effect, we haven't seen a boom. Now, I understand that the boom was halted when, you know, the economy fell off the cliff in 2008 and so on, and maybe that's just an aberration and over the long term we'll see something different, but it really does...

1:56:47 Suggest that in our own strategies for moving forward, not just in construction and development and the things that are traditionally associated with taking a resort community forward, but also in diversification of industry and business, we need to really take a long look at what the impact is going to be because some of these numbers are not just startling, but they're depressing.

1:57:14 The proprietor's income, for example, the average income of proprietors in Mammoth Lakes or in Mono County is less than the average income of workers. I want to be careful about that statistic, though. That's aggregated in Inyo and Mono County. Well, I thought what I saw was broken down, although I may be wrong and I'm sort of flipping through. But really, whether it's two counties or one.

1:57:40 You've got to have people who come into a community and want to take a chance, and taking a chance want to have some benefit. It's got to be sustainable, and the numbers that you see here in many instances reflect what I see in the community, which is that businesses can't make it, and they close their doors, and ultimately not just the employees, but the proprietor is out of business. So this might be a good opportunity, a launching opportunity for the...

1:58:07 The council that this town has put together to look at a lot of different ways to do business and do existing business better here. Out of curiosity, do you keep a set of local indicators of other figures like average median income and unemployment within specific industries? Yes, the Economic Stimulus Council started that about a year ago. Actually, it's interesting because we have a lot of very similar.

1:58:36 I think that's a really important exercise. I know it's hard to do that on an ongoing basis. Many jurisdictions do track indicators annually as part of their annual strategic planning processes.

1:59:01 Plumas County, Nevada County, Placer County all have internal indicator reports that look at a number of different figures other than just TOT and, you know, permits issued and things like that. But we need to start figuring out how to measure our progress a little bit more realistically, I think. We're turning to some of the businesses. So, for example, if you want some real estate data and you want it on a frequent basis,

1:59:28 We're talking about having sponsorship in there so they can put their name in there so when it's distributed out throughout the community, you can say, okay, real estate figures came from X company or maybe Edward Jones supplied some of the national CPI indexes or things of that nature. So we're looking into that, but it's being refined, and it's just really interesting to see a completed document and something very professionally done. It's really nice.

1:59:57 So thank you very much. So anybody else have anything? No, thank you. I just had one comment. Steve, I'm glad to see that emphasis on training our businesses that we already have in the new social media and all of that because it's so important. You're right, it is the new way of marketing yourselves. I hope that that relationship with the college goes through and that we can offer that soon.

2:00:22 Well, we may be back asking you to partner on a project like that, not necessarily financially, but from a sponsorship level, because the Economic Development Administration funding that we're looking at going after needs to come to jurisdictions, not to a nonprofit organization or an educational institution. So keep that in mind that we might need some help pushing that forward.

2:00:49 Thank you very much. I really appreciate the opportunity. I really appreciate it. Okay. Moving on, we will move to the consent agenda for items three and four. Mr. Mayor, I move to approve three and four on the consent agenda. I have a motion. Second. And a second. We get a roll call, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Council motion passes.

2:01:19 4-0. With that, we'll move on to a public hearing. We'll consider approval of District Zoning Amendment 12-001 for the Altus Master Plan Amendment. So, Jen? Thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers. This public hearing is for the Altus Master Plan Amendment. This is District Zoning Amendment, Vesting Tentative Track Map, and Variance 12-001.

2:01:45 The Altus Master Plan area is located at the Bridges Switchback above Lake Mary Road. The proposal will amend the Master Plan to allow for single-family lots in addition to duplex townhomes, which would result for a lower density on the site than is currently entitled. The site was originally entitled back in 2005, and there's been a few modifications to the project since then.

2:02:09 Now, because of current market conditions, the applicant is coming back and asking for the single family lot subdivision. Currently, construction is underway for the access road for this project. The master plan would continue to allow duplex townhomes on the site. So if the market conditions change and condominiums were desirable, they could come back with a new tentative map for planning commission approval to subdivide back into condominiums.

2:02:39 At this point in time, we're looking at nine single family lots in addition to the four existing condominium units that are on the site. An administrative design review permit would be required for these single family homes. This is a standard requirement that we have for lots above a certain elevation. It's the same requirement that we have for Greyhawk and the Bluffs just to ensure that our design guidelines are maintained. These single family homes would be allowed to be rented transiently because they are located in the resort zone.

2:03:10 And since this site is subject to the IntraWest DA, staff has found the project consistent with the 1987 general plan and vision. Staff, in their analysis, we also found that the project would be consistent with the 2007 general plan as well. The project is also consistent with the municipal code. We have a variance application in, a request in, for the width of the right-of-way for the access road. They're proposing a reduced width, which Public Works found to be

2:03:40 A safe situation and the variance findings could be made because of the steep slope of the site and the configuration of the property. So there won't be any unsafe conditions that would result from that access road. It would allow for adequate snow storage and access. Therefore, staff recommends approval of option one, which is approving the project with the conditions of approval as recommended by the planning commission.

2:04:04 Thank you. I'd be happy to answer any questions. And Mr. Jim Smith and Mr. Mark Carney are here on the applicants for the applicant's presentation. Okay. Thank you, Jen. Are there any questions of counsel? Jen? Just one quick one, Jen, is that in this new setup, the what was it called? The amenity building goes away, right?

2:04:27 Right. The amenity building, our municipal code only requires amenity buildings if there are over 20 units. Okay. So that's the threshold that is maintained in the master plan. Okay. Okay. Thank you, Jen. With that, we'll move on to presentation by the property owner, appellant. Jim Smith, Mammoth Mountain, Mayor, Councilmembers. Actually, I don't have a presentation to really let you know that I'm here for questions. I think it's pretty straightforward, although I just want to commend staff on a great job. They work with us.

2:05:01 Put some hard work and effort into this. We appreciate that. And obviously the Planning Commission vetted it pretty well, and we appreciate their recommendation. So if you have any questions on the project, happy to answer it. Any questions? I just had a question. So basically we have nine lots, and all we're really asking for is the ability to put on single families versus duplexes on any given lot? Correct. So the current master plan only allows for condos. Okay.

2:05:31 And so based on market and actually how poor the condo market is for us, but we actually have five of the nine lots with reservations already. So kind of demonstrating the demand for that. So this allows us to be able to do both. Okay. All right. Well, thank you. With that, there's no questions from town council. We'll call for testimony from anybody in public. Okay.

2:06:04 Rebuttled a previous testimony for the property owner. It was none of that. So we'll go ahead and close the public hearing. And town council will go ahead and deliberate on this item. So Jo, do you want to start? Sure. I was just going to congratulate the property owner and the staff for coming up with a creative solution that does really reflect what the market is now.

2:06:29 I think that you're definitely moving in the right direction, and if that's where the demand is, this seems like a simple action for us to take to allow that to happen with single-family homes. Thank you. John? I have nothing to add. I have nothing. Okay. I'm happy to make a motion. Okay. Can I get a motion, please? Move to choose option that the council adopt option one, which is waive the first reading and introduced by title only in ordinance making required CEQA and municipal code findings.

2:06:59 And approving district zoning amendment 12-001. Interesting, this is the first zoning amendment of the year, and we're in September. And adopt the attached resolution making the required CEQA subdivision map act and municipal code findings. And approving vesting tentative map 12-001 and variance 12-001 with conditions as recommended by staff. Okay, I have a motion. Do I have a second? Second.

2:07:29 I have a motion and a second. Can I have a roll call, Jamie? Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Mayor Pro Tempoin? Yes. Mayor Lehman? Yes. Motion passes for zero. Okay. Well, congratulations. And we'll go ahead and hopefully see something go on up there. We'll go on to move on to item number six. And Ellen, if you would, please. Good evening, Mayor, members of the council. The item before you tonight is

2:08:01 A item to obtain council input on the terms and conditions included in a composed restrictive covenant for the Kittsville Apartments. The Kittsville Apartments is an affordable housing project, a former motel located in the North Village Pacific Plan area on Burner Street that was acquired by IntraWest in 1998 in order to fulfill the various mitigation options for housing or requirements for housing that

2:08:30 We're incumbent upon the developer at that time for the housing ordinance. The principal apartment was acquired, has provided for some time a workforce or construction work for housing that has been vacant and boarded up for some time. InterWest is now in a position where it wishes to dispose of the property as part of the mitigation requirements, both when the property was acquired and subsequently.

2:08:58 During the settlement agreement with IntraWest regarding terms and conditions of the development agreement, it was directed that a restrictive covenant be recorded against the property, and so IntraWest is now moving to do that, given that they have the properties on the market and they have a prospective buyer, potentially a prospective buyer, they wish to close the loop on this with outstanding procedural item.

2:09:22 We, staff, and Mammoth Lakes Housing have worked with Mr. Mark Carney, who's the applicant's property owner's representative, to craft the terms and conditions of the agreement. We've also reviewed those with our legal counsel. And I think we're very close. We've reached agreement on almost all the terms and conditions of the agreement as they're shown in the attachment to the staff report.

2:09:49 The one item which we are really seeking your direction on tonight is regarding the conditions under which the restrictive covenant may be removed from those property. The applicant has proposed that should the property go into foreclosure and if the town does not exercise an option to purchase the property at the lower of its assessed value or the remaining loan amount, that the property would be lifted and that...

2:10:17 And those units in the property would revert to market rate. After some discussion with legal counsel with Mammoth Lakes Housing, it's staff's recommendation that that provision not be included in the restrictive covenant for the reason that it places those units at very real risk of being lost from the affordable housing inventory. It's not a significant number of units. 17 units of housing is a substantial number.

2:10:45 And as it notes in the staff report, it's our recommendation that that language not be included. All along with the planning to, I think he had an opportunity to speak to present his position on this. But staff's recommendation at this time is to not include the language, to not permit that deed restriction to be lifted in the event of foreclosure because the risk of losing those units is really too great for the town.

2:11:15 Would that all have to answer any questions? Go ahead, Jo. Yeah, I have one. Is that the whole thing of foreclosure, is that foreclosure by the current owner or by this potential buyer, or either? It would be by the owner of the property at the time. At the time, okay. John, Rick? No questions. So let me ask, this covenant is currently in here, is that correct?

2:11:42 The basic terms and conditions of the covenant were directed by the council when the property was acquired back in 1998, and the council minutes reflect certain conditions such as the income levels of those units. Those terms were reiterated in the part of the settlement agreement between the town and interest in 2010, which I accepted relevant provisions from.

2:12:04 And so those are, that's what's encompassed in the terms of restrictions. And this is really the legally binding covenant that would be attached to the property that would run with it when ownership changes or as well as it's recorded really, but would run with the property as it changes owners over time. Okay, I'm just trying to get clarity of if that, in the covenant it says that

2:12:30 If the town does not buy the property, it reverts back to market rate. And that is currently in there? Or they're arguing to have it put in there? There is no covenant currently. The covenant should have been reported quite a while ago, but for whatever reason it wasn't. So we've been trying to work out with the applicant what language would be included in the covenant. And they've proposed to have that restriction that you just described. The staff has proposed not to have that. But if we don't have it?

2:12:59 As I understand, the lender will not lend on it. Is that possibly? Is that not? Okay. Well, I'll let the applicant see what they have to say about it. Are there any other questions with Ellen? Okay. Thank you, Ellen. Good evening, Mayor Lehman and Councilmembers. My name is Mark Carney, and I have been the Attorney, Local Counsel for Interwest since 1996. I was at the Town Council meeting where we...

2:13:31 Sought to get the Kitzbühel Motel zoning changed in order to convert it to be able to provide the affordable housing. I represented InterWest throughout that time period, throughout the 2000s, and actually negotiated and drafted the 2010 settlement agreement where the Kitzbühel deed restriction came up once again. In that time period, I think I represented or worked with six different VPs for InterWest, all of whom took...

2:13:59 The obligation to provide affordable housing for the community very seriously, none of whom balked at any notion whatsoever of any deed restriction that I've come across my desk throughout that time period. We're actually proud to have been able to supply affordable housing to the community throughout that time period, and I think they were the single biggest private supplier of affordable housing for the community while they were developing in the community. And on a personal note, I'd like to say that...

2:14:25 The single biggest source of pride that I have on a personal level of having been a member of this community over the past 25 years is that this council and your predecessors have always and consistently made the decision that this resort is going to be a resort community and not just a resort. And the single biggest expression of that through this council and prior councils is the

2:14:54 The insistence that if you live in this town, excuse me, if you work in this town, you should be able to live here. And the way that that has been expressed is through the Affordable Housing Mitigation Ordinance and through the creation of Mammoth Lakes Housing, where I probably served for a few years. So this is not a question as to whether or not InterWest thinks it's a good idea to sign deed restrictions and to provide affordable housing.

2:15:22 They've proven that time and time again. And on a personal level, I certainly have been in favor of making certain that my clients over the years have complied not only to the letter but to the spirit of the Affordable Housing Mitigation Order throughout. The genesis of this particular clause came as a result of our desire to try to find a way to create a deed restriction

2:15:51 In 2011, which was most like the deed restriction that should have been placed on the property back in 1998. And it is, as I understand from the staff report, it's no longer common for this particular provision to be part of deed restrictions and specifically to say that if the lender forecloses on the property and the town decides not to exercise a right of first refusal,

2:16:21 Then it's evidence that the project has failed. And instead of renewing a failed project, what can we do in order to make certain that the project is successful in the future? And so thus is the reason for this proposal for this clause in the deed restriction. Years ago,

2:16:45 It was not uncommon for this provision to be part of deed restrictions in affordable housing. In fact, when we got this task to create this deed restriction, I asked my associate in my office, Ann Winston, to find all the old deed restrictions that were about this time period when this should have been restricted. And she came up with a number of deed restrictions, and I think in particular some that John Hooper had entered into because I think John...

2:17:12 It was providing affordable housing to the community before there was an affordable housing mitigation ordinance. So this provision was in there, and it made sense to us to try to recreate as closely as we could the deed restriction that would most likely have been included if the deed restriction had been recorded way back in 1998. Now, the purpose of it is to make certain that if

2:17:39 I mean, the clearest indication of a failed project is when the lender forecloses on the property. And it would be hard to say right now that this isn't a failed project, even though that hasn't happened. This property has been basically vacant and boarded up since 2005. There's no indication that that's going to change, especially in this economy. When InterWest was focused on trying to

2:18:08 Remedied the situation. They got bids and came to the conclusion that it was going to cost anywhere between a million dollars and a million two at that time in order to refurbish this property and get it up to speed so it was in a rentable condition again. So whoever purchases this property is going to have to incur a substantial investment. And so the question is really a business judgment. I think we defer to your judgment. This is your call.

2:18:37 But when you make this decision, I would just urge you to make a business decision and make a decision that's intended to look to the future and figure out how we can get out of this predicament that we're in with the kids' people, which is that it's not moving anywhere and it's not likely to be productive and whoever were to purchase it would be making a substantial investment which that

2:19:06 May or may not be a good decision. And so if on top of all those factors, if it is proven that the next owner goes forward, builds a building or refurbishes a building and then fails such that there's a foreclosure, then I think we have a pretty clear indication that something needs to change. So that was the reason, in part because the old lead restrictions had this clause and in part because now we're in a different time and we have a really fragile piece of property here.

2:19:36 With really no hope, in my view anyway, for it to be improved in a business-like fashion. Now, in response to your question, Mayor Lehman, I don't know for a fact that no lender would lend on this property. I'm not making that representation. All I'm trying, but what I do think is fair-minded, is to say that a lender would be more likely to lend on the property, and clearly it's going to need an infusion of money.

2:20:05 Now, there is another way

2:20:34 To think this through. And unfortunately, I just kind of thought this through today, and I had a quick conversation with Pam Hennerty here as well. And I think what we need to be focused on, how can we get the Kitsbuel to succeed, right? InterWest is going to sell the property. They don't particularly care because they're not going to be around anymore. That settlement agreement entered into 2010 was really the culmination of InterWest development activities in this community.

2:21:03 But I think as a community member, and certainly you folks are volunteering your time to do what's right for this community, the question really to be asked is, how do we set this property up for success in the future? And when I had the discussion with Pam today, I said, hey, what if we proposed to the council that the deed restriction were actually changed such that we assured that it would be rental apartment housing?

2:21:31 A deed restriction that insisted that it be rental and that it be rental apartments, but also that instead of the deed restriction for the level of income, a deed restriction that required the property to be rented, the apartments to be rented out to locals and locals only. Because I think that that is likely to set the property up for success.

2:21:58 In the future, at least it has the best chance to do so. Because as I understand it now, the fair market rental rates that this town is dealing with right now may even be lower than the median income rates. So we're at this strange situation right now where market rates, and this is something that actually Pamuk mentioned to me today,

2:22:24 Anecdotally, perhaps, I'm not really sure where she got that information. By quoting him, I don't mean to imply that she supports this third option. But it's certainly close. And so really what we want to do, I think, for the community is get locals inexpensive apartments to live in that will be liable. So one way to look at it is

2:22:50 If we could have this deed restriction on title to this property for another 10 years, and you guys can make the decision whether you think that that's likely to achieve the goal. Another way to look at it is if we have a deed restriction that is devoid of reference to monetary issues and really focus on what we're trying to achieve, which is inexpensive rental housing.

2:23:19 For locals and locals only, it might be worth exploring this deed restriction, which I know when I was on a member of the Board of Directors of Mammoth Lakes Housing, we badged around different types of deed restrictions, deed restrictions for money, deed restrictions for specific people. And that would allow us to restrict the property using Mammoth Lakes Housing's own guidelines as to whether you qualify as a local, whether you work in town. I forget exactly what the details of that are.

2:23:49 Again, we defer to your good judgment on this, but I think it's worth at least discussing the possibility of kind of thinking a little outside the box on this topic and having a restrictive covenant, but make it such that it focuses on who is able to rent what. I'm happy to answer any questions anyone might have.

2:24:17 Do any council members have questions? None at this time. No, but I'd like to hear from staff and or Andy on, you know, what this new proposition right now is, whether that's something that would take a little more time to discuss or whether that's even legal. I would certainly like an opportunity to look into the validity of a restrictive covenant that essentially says that only locals can rent there.

2:24:46 I think there's some potential legal protection concerns about that that I haven't quite had a chance to look into. Mark did talk to me about this before the meeting, but, you know, this is something that would take a little bit of time to look into, and I'm just not in a position to do that as I sit here. Okay. Rick? No, but I'm looking forward to hearing from Pam with respect to the third option as well as the board's position with respect to options one and two. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you, Mark.

2:25:16 Pam, did you want to come up and speak? Pam Hennity, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing. At our meeting on Monday, I brought this before the board, and we've discussed several times the kits fuel and the lack of deed restriction and the lack of it being used for housing. And the board continues to feel very passionate about the fact that this has gone without a deed restriction for so long. And the recommendation of the board...

2:25:50 was to urge council to go with staff recommendation and require that there not be an out clause for this deed restricted apartment complex. I want to talk a couple of things about the deed restrictions that we have and why there's concerns about this. So the deed restriction that was drafted here is really based on a for sale model that was used.

2:26:14 We have other models of rental deed restrictions, none of which have this sort of foreclosure out clause. I've been researching this more and more today after I spoke with Mr. Carney a couple of times, and we did have one unit. Again, it wasn't a complex, but it was one unit where the developer actually had deed restricted one of his units.

2:26:39 Couldn't sell the properties in his complex and let whatever units didn't sell go back to his lender. One of those was a deed-restricted rental unit.

2:26:50 The bank took it back, was able to sell it to an investor that comes in and does affordable housing developments. They bought the unit that was deed restricted and now rented according to our terms and guidelines. So it's not something that we haven't actually seen in our community and I don't think it would completely hamstring the project to require that the deed restriction remain in place even in the event of a foreclosure. Additionally,

2:27:15 Because of the type of agency we are, we often get marketing materials for other affordable developments that are for sale, whether they're in trouble or they're just nearing their end and that someone wants to sell them, and there is certainly a market out there. And we've talked with several different agencies and groups that are in the for-profit affordable housing market that I think could...

2:27:40 Use tools and take on this property and be able to find financing to build on it with the deed restriction in place. I also again talked with Mr. Carney today about this third option and I spoke with our attorney and I held her up on the phone. We just got off the phone about a half an hour. That's why I was late. And she jolted my memory that when

2:28:09 We were looking at different options of how to do affordable housing. We talked about doing a locals-only deed restriction that wasn't tied to income. And at that time, and she reminded me again today of the same concerns that Andy came up with, that there are equal protection rules against that. And really, if you're going to limit who is going to live in a unit, it has to be tied to some indicators such as income, which is...

2:28:38 The common indicator that's used in affordable housing and that a deed restricted based on locals only was not advisable from our affordable housing focused attorney's point of view. Only if you're finished, Pam. You know, the one other thing that I wanted to talk about because I'm not talking about deed restrictions and InterWest in particular.

2:29:07 And maybe I can help sort of lay to rest some of the issues that have come up with regard to deed restrictions and deed restrictions being lifted. When the San Joaquin Villas was built, it was a deed restricted mitigation project. And in that deal, there was essentially an out clause that said that if the units weren't sold by a certain date, the deed restriction could be lifted and they would then be sold at market rate.

2:29:34 That was right when the economy was crashing, things were turning extremely sour, and financing was really the difficulty in selling those units. But we didn't meet those deadlines on all those units, and about half of those units did lose those seed restrictions. I don't think it's because there wasn't a need, and I don't think it wasn't because people couldn't get behind the idea of buying a deed restricted housing, but it was because there was an out. And that out that we've

2:30:01 Have felt ramifications for longstanding concerns that deed restrictions aren't valid continue to haunt us today when we talk about deed restricted units and offering an out on a project such as this, especially a rental project where we know we continue to have demand and need for rental units is not something that I would advise. I think that it would be in the Council's best interest to

2:30:29 Maintain that the deed restriction stays in place even in the event of a foreclosure. Now I think I'm done, John. Thanks, Bill. The original tent for this particular property was for low and very low? You know what, I don't know if it was originally that way, but it allows to be, the rentals are at median income at this point, so 100% of the median income. Okay. Yes.

2:30:56 So, and especially at that time, and even now, you know, our funding that Mammoth Lakes Housing can apply for through state and federal sources allows us to house those at the lower income levels. And so there is, at the time, and somewhat still so, there is a need for housing that is

2:31:17 Above that level, we can provide with our state and federal funding sources. So that was the reasoning behind that. So you would see, if we didn't keep that requirement, you would see this as a missed opportunity to get workforce housing, additional units of workforce housing? I think certainly if the project were to go into foreclosure and all deed restriction, there was no requirement on the property.

2:31:45 Then the property could be demolished and built into something, you know, anything else. And I think that would be a travesty. We couldn't require that it be built for 17 market rate housing units. Well, you could. Well, in theory, you could. You could allow that. But I think that that would, right now, market rate units would be fine. But in the future, if things,

2:32:15 Prosper and we get back to a place where this community is doing well and rents and the market increases, which, you know, it certainly goes on those cycles. At the top of the cycle, we would find ourselves in 17 units short in our workforce housing and I don't think that that would be the intention of the council at the time that approved this project. It's the mitigation and I think it would be a disservice to the community. Thank you. Pam, can you describe the condition of the property now and

2:32:44 Do you have any information or view as to why, notwithstanding that InterWest was given credit against its housing requirement, the units were not built? Or were not converted to workforce housing? The condition of the project is bad, to say the least. I haven't been in it in probably two years.

2:33:15 It was a converted motel and the units were in fairly bad shape back in 2006 when it was last used. At that time it was being used by a construction crew that was here to actually they were working on some of our units and the San Joaquin Villas. And I think part of the deal that they signed as far as living there was that construction crew was going to upgrade the units while they're there and then when they moved out they would be converted to

2:33:44 Two deed-restricted affordable housing units. That contractor was not a good person, not upstanding and not honest. He ended up in lawsuits with both us and InterWest on separate projects and I think actually ended up leaving the project in worse condition than when he got in it. We looked at the property with Neubauer Jenison a couple of years ago to see what it would cost to bring it up to maybe...

2:34:14 Apply for state and federal grants. And there is substantial mold, leaky roofs. It's horrid, and it's a health hazard to be inside those buildings. And the retaining wall, the site is up against a retaining wall. The retaining wall is in pretty bad shape. And additionally, there's 17 units there, but there is probably enough parking for...

2:34:44 Six or seven units. There's just, it's going to be a tough thing. So, knowing that, the condition of it, and that the, knowing that the income would be very limited to, based on a person's income, what would be the motivation for a person to fix it, you think? Price of the land. Yeah, I mean, the land is relatively inexpensive. We've had talks with some of the folks who are,

2:35:15 Potentially interested in buying this site. As indeed restricted property? Yes. So they'd have to have the expense of tearing it down and rebuilding a new one at the cost of the land, basically, and the cost of demolition. Right. And potentially the units could be moved, right? I mean, it's in the North Village specifically, and so in theory...

2:35:41 You know, if you, if a developer wanted to accumulate enough property around there and do something else, they would obviously have to come before the town, but in theory, those units could be relocated as long as they provided an equivalent of 17 EHUs, and that may be part of the draw. One developer we talked to, we talked about that and said, well, we'll give them somewhere else and we'll, so, you know, it's a developer's prerogative, which.

2:36:08 It can certainly be varied, but there have been a couple of affordable housing developers who are successful in state and federal grants and bonds and tax credits that could come in and potentially use federal and state subsidy to bring, to develop the project and turn it around. I don't think you could put 17 units on that property again either, could you? I don't think, I think it's about a quarter of an acre you could probably. It is over density right now. Is it?

2:36:37 Yeah, I just, you know, my opinion, I mean, we'll get to, I guess, deliberation on this, but I'll beat my head on the wall a little bit more here as we go. Thanks, Pam. Pam, this is just a general, am I remembering correctly that we're already at less, a lower number of units than we're supposed to have by now for our regional needs? Yes, we are. Anybody else have questions of Pam? No questions. Okay, thank you, Pam.

2:37:09 Anybody else have questions or comments in the public? Okay, then I guess that's for deliberation amongst council members. Anybody has any comments or questions? I'll start if you wish. Yeah, sure, go ahead. You know, I'd like to find a creative solution whenever we've got these kinds of situations, but I don't know what that is, and maybe that third option is something or some...

2:37:36 A hybrid or a variation of that third option makes some sense. I don't have in mind what that is at the moment. But, you know, the interest entered into an agreement in 1998, and they built a lot of product in this community, and part of that agreement was they were to comply with what was a terribly onerous workforce housing requirement by anybody's measure. I knew it then, and I believe it now.

2:38:04 But, you know, they got credit for those 17 units, and I always wondered, you know, why they were not built, and I learned at the Mammoth Lakes Housing, at one of the, more of the meetings, we have a number of meetings on this project, that they were housing construction workers, and that they, essentially the property has declined significantly since the construction ended in

2:38:33 Oh, five or six. It's really not the town's fault that it's full of mold. And it's not the town's fault that it's uninhabitable or that it's a health hazard. And it just seems to me, and maybe this is way too simplistic. If you have a property that's reached the point of deterioration where it's just a teardown and it has land value only, well, land value is determined by the restrictions against the property as well as zoning and

2:39:03 Location and slope and cost of building and everything else that goes into a decision as to whether to build. Maybe the price is too high. My view is that the price is always right for somebody. And maybe the land ultimately is worth zero in order to make it work. I don't know if that's the solution to simply go back to the interest and say, look, what you're asking us to do is make a business decision, but it's a business decision for you. You make the business decision, get rid of the property, let it go.

2:39:33 Sell it for a dollar to a developer. I'm not suggesting that because I'd like to try to have this be something that is sensible. But in the end, if we don't choose the option, if we allow the language to be included, essentially what we're doing is enhancing the value for InterWest and potentially moving 17 units out of the supply.

2:39:58 I'm just having a real hard time living with that, particularly because I was here in 1998 when that deal was done, and I'd like to see it carried through or followed through. I take a little bit of an opposite approach on it. The problem is if the language isn't put in there, then you're stuck with a property that is, in effect, deed-restricted, right? And there's no incentive for them to fix it up and repair it for anybody.

2:40:32 So we're going to sit here with more blight in our town. And in my opinion, you know, this just continues to demonstrate the lack of demand. If there was a demand for this type of product, people would be fixing it up. They'd be leasing it up. They'd be doing something with it other than let it dilapidate because there's really not a financial benefit to it. This language that's going in here has been a problem in our community. It's been a problem with affordable housing for years.

2:41:02 The last report we got I think said we had five units or something like that that had gone back as a result of this. It's more like 25 units or 28 units that went back as a result of having this language in here. I think here in our document it says similar affordable rental properties in Mammoth Lakes. None of them contain such language, but I think a lot of them did. And I think whether they're rental properties or for sale properties, the language was in there.

2:41:32 Personally, I would be okay with this, getting rid of the affordable housing altogether on this property and not building any more. I think that we need to follow the county's lead and start looking in a new direction as opposed to trying to keep putting a band-aid on a problem that's just not going to go away.

2:41:54 Anybody else have any questions? I'm going to agree with Rick's point, and it really, for me, it comes down to, it was a commitment that this developer made, and I don't want to give him an easy out on not meeting what we need when we know we still need rental affordable housing. Do we know we need that? Yes, we do. From the reports we're getting from Maniflex Housing, we know, I know that. I believe there are reports. We're going to have a 2-2 on this one, I'm afraid. But when this,

2:42:27 was put into the, on this piece of property, the times were different. I think that for a whole bunch of reasons we can see that times have changed today. You can, we can sit up here and we can make a good argument on either side of this issue and I would support it on either side. Personally, I look at it as a situation where it is an eyesore, it's a teardown, it's a,

2:42:58 Piece of, you know what, in our community close to the village. And I don't see, you know, yes, there could be a buyer that goes in there and builds medium price housing, but I know that it's more likely that there's a

2:43:25 A person, an investor that's going to go in there and buy the property and build market rate housing. And so I think there's more of an incentive for someone to do that and therefore to get rid of that blight in our community in a shorter time frame. One could say if we do that, then, you know, as I asked Pam, if that piece of property is taken off the market,

2:43:56 For workforce housing, then it's a missed opportunity to provide for a piece of property to provide housing there. So to me it's not a clear answer, but the overriding consideration for me personally is that there's a better chance that someone will buy that piece of property and build market rate rental units there and upgrade that property in the community.

2:44:29 Thank you, John. So I have a reply if I can, and I'd like to approach it in two ways. One is, this is not an instance where you've got a new developer coming into town weighing the benefits of putting something on a piece of property. Workforce housing, as the ordinance was developed that is or was required of those who came in and put stuff up at market rate, was not intended to be a financial benefit.

2:45:02 A cost benefit or financial analysis is not made independent of the benefit that the developer receives from selling market rate housing. And we saw hundreds of millions of dollars of market rate housing sold in the village. And we saw Interwest leave this town with hundreds of millions of dollars in its pocket. And so I don't buy the argument in this particular case.

2:45:32 That there has to be some financial benefit in order for this to make any sense. I would argue just the opposite. It's not a financial benefit. It's a burden. And, Matthew, you and I may one day agree that we have different needs today than we had 15 years ago. I will dispute that. It is a different day today. And it will be a different day in the future. And we're going to be able to have that debate. And we may be closer on that issue.

2:46:00 Then it might appear tonight. But the problem is that INUES is no longer here. They don't have anything here other than commercially leased space in the village. And they want out of here. And they're incentivized to get out of here in any event because this is the last of what they have as far as I can tell.

2:46:25 There will be a point in time when that building becomes so dilapidated that it will be a health hazard and the town will have the opportunity or the health department will come in and condemn it. And so I don't see that there is a long-term lost opportunity. What I see is that there was a requirement that wasn't fulfilled. You can argue that it was too onerous or that it wasn't onerous enough. That's not the debate tonight.

2:46:54 It was a deal that was cut 14 years ago, and to the extent that InterWest really wants out, they'll make the price right for an investor to come in and tear the building down and build housing that makes sense. I'm not a developer, and I haven't gone through the cost analysis. I can't tell you that specifically. That's just my sense. But I think that they ought to abide by the terms of the agreement that they entered into because they got the benefit of that agreement by developing the village.

2:47:23 And so I see this as a lot different than a new, potentially undeveloped parcel that might otherwise be deed restricted, such as, for example, the parcel, the Shader S parcel in the middle of town. I think the problem with that argument, though, is that we can sit here and try to hold their feet at the fire, but we're still going to be left with a property that is horribly dilapidated and is already a health hazard. I've looked inside that property and there is significant mold in there.

2:47:54 I agree with you that we did have an agreement and to the extent we can, we should abide by that agreement, but we're going to punish ourselves by leaving this property here dilapidated and not incentivizing any type of owner to come in and purchase this property. I mean, this is why when we have deed-restricted properties, they turn into projects because there's no incentive for the public to

2:48:23 For somebody to own the property. You say that there is no financial benefit and there's not that intent to be there, but there is that intent. You do have to have that there because without it, nobody's going to maintain the property. Nobody's going to keep the property. It's going to fall apart over time. It's an argument we will continue to go on with Rick. I agree. I stand with my...

2:48:48 My argument. Well, my suggestion is it appears that John suggested that it's... No, I'm going to change my mind. All right. I was going to make this. Yes. And I am very interested in hearing other alternatives. I don't know what they are yet. Okay. Your argument that because of the condition of the property as it is today, I think it is close to condemnation, and I think that that...

2:49:18 You know, should be moved. That's another agenda item, but that should be considered sooner rather than later because of its condition. And if it is condemned, if it goes through the process and it is and it's torn down, then I can live with a vacant lot until that piece of property is ready to be something else built on it. But the deed restriction follows through with it.

2:49:48 I understand. I actually support the deed restriction, but I didn't want to live with a dilapidated building on that location in perpetuity or for an extended period of time. So I can live with a vacant lot and therefore will support the direction of the majority of council. Mr. Merritt, I'll move to adopt

2:50:17 Option 1, which is to direct the applicant to delete the language in Exhibit B, lender provisions of the Kittsville restrictive covenant, which would allow the covenant to be removed in the event that the property goes into foreclosure and the town elects not to purchase it. A comment that is in the, oh pardon me, I'm in the options analysis and so I don't know. I think you just stopped there. I think I stopped there. And would also say that I would encourage

2:50:48 Additional creative discussion to try to resolve this in a way that makes sense for the town and meets the objectives of the council members. So you, let me clarify, so you are in favor, just because the language is almost like some double negatives, so you're in favor of deleting the language that says that they can opt out in the event that...

2:51:12 Yeah. In favor of deleting the language. I realize it's not really artfully written, and I kind of sort of struggled through it when I was reading it as well. It leaves the restriction. It leaves the restriction. That's the intent of my motion. Restriction stays there, and it's only in the event that the property value drops below market value and it can't sell it, or that it goes into foreclosure. No. It survives that.

2:51:42 If I'm using a second. Okay, so we have a motion and a second. Do we need some correction? I'm going to agree with your synopsis, which was yes, that would preserve restrictive covenant even in the event that the property foreclosed. By deleting this? Correct. The highlighted language is the proposed language from the applicant that we proposed to delete. Okay, you got it. Okay, I have a motion and a second.

2:52:13 Roll call, Jamie. Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Reese? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem, Wood? Yes. Mayor Layton? No. Okay. Motion passes with 3-1. Thank you. And with that, we will move on to items 7 and 8. Item number 7, excuse me. Before we do that, Matthew, can I quickly give direction to staff to, at some point,

2:52:40 Bring back if Council, if there's a majority of Council that wants to pursue the condition of the property. Thank you. Yeah, Mark. That's obviously your prerogative, but I just wanted to make you aware of a term in the settlement agreement that the Council entered into two years ago. And essentially what that settlement agreement says is there will be a 10-year hold from the date of the settlement agreement for the town.

2:53:09 To enable the town to, which would allow the town to enter into any kind of condemnation proceedings. In other words, sorry that was poorly stated, the town can't initiate condemnation proceedings until 10 years have passed since the day of the agreement, as long as the property has remained locked and secure. So I just wanted to make sure you're aware of that. To the extent you want to go down that path, that's your prerogative, but I just wanted to make sure you're aware of that. There might be an opportunity for some negotiations there.

2:53:35 Yeah. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Okay. Let's move on to item number seven, please. And Stu. Good evening, Mayor, Members of Council, staff, and community. So before you this evening is item number seven, which is the measure of full award.

2:54:07 I'm just going to give a really brief background and then the action that staff is recommending Council take this evening. So the 2012 Measure R Fund Award application period is scheduled to open on Monday, September 24 at 8 o'clock and close on Wednesday, October 24 at 5pm. At the close of applications, the Recreation Commission has the responsibility to receive public input and provide funding recommendations to Town Council regarding the appropriation of Measure R funds.

2:54:36 Prior to the commencement of the Annual Measure R Fall Award Cycle, the Recreation Commission meets to review and establish the timeline, the application form, the evaluation material, and Annual Measure R funding priorities and principles for Town Council approval, which is this evening. On August 7, 2012, the Recreation Commission unanimously approved the process materials as identified above, and on September 4,

2:55:03 Drafted the 2012 Measure R4 Funding Principles and Priorities, which Town Council reviewed this afternoon in a workshop with the Commission and Measure U Application Committee. So before you this evening is sections of the Measure R4 Award Timeline, and staff is recommending Town Council adopt Option 1, which I'll read tonight for the benefit of the Council and the community here this evening. And I'll also go through those items as Council.

2:55:35 Directed. So option one is to A, approve the 2012 Measure R Fall Award timeline, application form, Measure R Fall Award project filter and checklist as submitted by the Recreation Commission. B is to approve the 2012 Measure R principles and priorities as presented by the Recreation Commission and discussed this afternoon in the workshop. C is to provide priority recommendations to staff for the proposed 2012

2:56:03 Town of Mammoth Lakes measure R4 applications. And I do want to point out that those, due to the compressed timeline and what we're trying to deal with, haven't gone before the Recreation Commission. So if Town Council desires, we can put those in front of the Recreation Commission at their October meeting. But staff believes that the intent of those applications are consistent with previous applications and what's been funded previously.

2:56:29 And then D is to direct the Town Manager to conduct the 2012 Measure R Fall Award. So I'm not too sure what Council's pleasure is. We can go through each of those items if you deem necessary or whatever action you decide is necessary. Okay, Stu, thank you. I turn to Council and see what their desire is. Well, I think I'll defer to Joe, but I, you know, it seems...

2:56:58 A couple weeks ago, the council determined that it wanted to have the commission go forward while reserving the right on behalf of the council to say no to all the awards or the applicants. And that is, I think, really for two reasons. One was to see if we can get on parallel tracks the Measure U and our award process

2:57:28 So that it feels more coherent. And two, because of the uncertainties surrounding the settlement and its impact on town finances. And I suppose three, because we've got a number of other planning processes that are not yet complete that might affect the priorities. And so I've looked at the materials and I personally don't have any...

2:57:56 Problems with the approach or the timeline, recognizing again that I'm not sure exactly what we're going to do. So my question to you is are you looking for us to take among these seven unprioritized matters on page four of seven and prioritize them for you? Because what I really want to do is have the commission. I don't really want to publicly get ahead of the commission.

2:58:26 Not that I don't have an opinion as to whether some things that are not on the list ought to be or some things that are on the list shouldn't be there and which order these seven ought to go, but, you know, I really respect the thoroughness of the process that the commission engages in, and so I'm kind of reluctant to do that. I'll participate if I have to, but I'm kind of reluctant to do that until it comes forward. Unless the commission comes to us and says, we can't figure it out, we want you to help us.

2:58:55 So there's my long window. I'm sorry. No, and Ashley, Rick, I think the same thing, I might say the same thing, but in a different way, is that I would hope that town staff and the commission would discuss what applications are going to be filed on behalf of the town in light of the reality that there's only $354,000 available to allocate

2:59:19 And looking at leveraging, for example, I know on the two, you know, some of these ones that are grant matches, if we don't want to lose, you know, bigger grants at this point, I would just ask the staff to be reasonable and might maybe do their own first cut or have a discussion with the Recreation Commission because we don't have staff time to have people go through 50-page applications for things that just aren't feasible at this point.

2:59:46 Is that kind of the same thing you were saying, right? Well, actually, it's in addition because you raised a good point, and that is if there's 20 applications that are 50 pages each and we don't have the staff to go through. Or even to write them. It could be that it needs to be one level higher and that would be at the commission level to try to, as you say, take a first cut at it. I absolutely agree with that. Yeah. Okay. John?

3:00:15 And so I think there's kind of consensus on that piece that we wouldn't prioritize if we say to, you know, just be realistic in it. It actually relates to the next one, because in Measure U there was the discussion about having some kind of a budget template, and I'd really like to see that here as well, because I know in last year in looking at the applications and listening to the first commission meeting that half of the time they were asking questions about, well, what are you spending the money on?

3:00:43 I'd like to see that idea of a budget template be in this application as well to help them figure out how to tell the commission what they're going to want to know. What are you going to spend the money on? Where's your match? What's your total project cost? Those kinds of things. Because this one still says just, well, give us a project budget. And that's like, well, I can tell you it's going to cost a million dollars and take three years. You're going to believe me? Well, and really to tag onto that,

3:01:09 I concur with, and we had this workshop at 5 with, I can't find it, one of the, oh here it is, one of the priorities, the broad priorities of the Recreation Commission, which were adopted on September 4, which is

3:01:25 Finish parks, trails, and recreation projects that remain incomplete. Correct. I'm very much in favor if we've got something that we've given money to before and it's not enough and we think it's legitimate that it's not enough, we just didn't give it enough that we finish that project before we move on to another one. And so the, and I don't know what those are, but I'm sure that there will be lots of folks who are proponents of those projects who will be.

3:01:48 And there's one other issue that came up this afternoon. Well, actually, there's two. I just wanted it to be stated publicly that it is our...

3:02:11 Our understanding or direction that the Mammoth Lakes Trail System allocation will exist without another application having to be filed. Right. And then the final thing is that I am concerned even with this timeline, which is again tight, that one of the priorities had been Nordic grooming and that

3:02:37 Ask the Recreation Commission and the separate Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee to talk about how that might happen in other ways because the reality is if we allocate the money on December 19th, presuming we have the meeting right before Christmas, and they get contracts going and everything, it's the end of January and that's halfway through our four snow months for cross country.

3:03:02 Because we only get that on the ground when nature gives it to us. So that I think we've got a separate timing issue that I'd like to see the Recreation Commission and our MLTSCC talk about how we might achieve that. Because the reality is, is if that isn't already planned by now, it won't happen this winter. And it's also snow dependent. And I don't have an answer. I just want them to think about it and come back to us with answers.

3:03:34 One thing I would probably add to that, and I don't think this is anything we've decided on today, but one thing I hope we can consider in the future with some of these measure monies is maybe these applicants finding matching funds. I know a lot of other folks out there that are being asked for funding. They're saying, we'll help you out, but you need to...

3:03:55 You know, we'll match up to X number of dollars, and I think it'd be nice to... I think that is on the checklist, isn't it? Yeah, what's being leveraged? Yeah. No, no, it's on the... If you go to page 17, there is an evaluation in the filter and checklist. I guess we should look at it as a stronger emphasis somewhere, but... They do score high with more leveraged funds and... Okay, great. Leveraged funds and volunteers and resources that they can bring to the project as well. Okay. All right. Anybody else have any...

3:04:24 Questions? Comments? Does the public have any questions or comments? We do have three commissioners. We have the chair, actually the vice chair, and two commissioners. I don't know. Any commissioners have any comments? Okay. Seeing none, we have a motion on this. Well, let's see. We could move approval of option one, which is the timeline application form, project filter and checklist, approve their

3:04:57 Priorities and Principles is presented by the Recreation Commission. I'm going to change C to say ask staff in the commission to realistically apply for only those things that are reasonable and within the funding available, to direct the town manager to conduct the 2012 Measure R Fall Award, and also to incorporate the comments.

3:05:27 We have made or the direction given. Second. Okay, we have a motion and a second. Jamie? Councilmember Bacon? Yes. Councilmember Eason? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem. Yes. Mayor Lane? Yes. Okay. Motion passes 4-0. All right. With that, we'll move on to item number 8, which is the Measure U Spring Test Award. Okay. So item number 8 is very similar.

3:06:02 Thank you.

3:06:31 Through Item 1 first, that's the desire of Council and we can then address Item 2. So on May 19th, the two committees, which from this point on actually transitioned into the Measure U Application Committee, this was kind of the final scope of work item from that steering committee, was to conduct a review and provide some recommendations to Town Council.

3:07:00 Regarding that Spring Test Award conducted in March, April and May. Those three sections of that. So they addressed Items A, B, C, D, E and F. I'm not too sure I need to go through each one or read them, but I do want to just affirm in Item F, Part 3, Committee Member Hogan did want to point out that

3:07:26 That says to align run concurrently with Measure R Fall and Spring Awards. So I think the agreement there was that it certainly wants to, as we've talked about this evening, is to concurrently run those together, being Measure R and Measure U, but they still believe that an annual Measure U Fall Award is appropriate at this time. But again, we'll address that in the second part of our discussion. So if there's any questions...

3:07:53 On that that Council might have, we can address those first. Actually, I do have one, Stuart, and it's really a concern I have had the whole time about having just a three-person application committee. So in the review of this, did the current application committee discuss the instance of if two or maybe even all three of the committee members are on it, how are they going to have a vote on...

3:08:18 If they happen to all be involved, and I'm not being facetious, but let's say there was some kind of an old mill music and mobility type thing at Hayden Cabin, and you've recused your three people, who's going to vote on the recommendation? Guess it would be us. Council. You know, I was still thinking that five people gives you more of a cross.

3:08:44 Section of the community. And as we've seen from the applications that have come in and will come in because the people who volunteer for us are involved in so many other things, I'd still like us to consider increasing the size of the application committee. And that's just my comment that I'm going to throw out there again. Agendize it. Yeah. Well, and when we get through all of this, I think that it won't necessarily need to be agendized right away. Yeah, I...

3:09:20 Part of a broader discussion for me. Yes. Exactly. Okay. Yeah. All right. Well, with that... So then the second part... Jump into it. Yeah, let's go to the second part. Just run... Yeah, I'll give you a brief staff report on the second... Second section of the agenda bill is to, you know, review and approve the Measure U Fall Award timeline, annual funding priorities, application form, evaluation material, and direct the town managers to conduct the 2012 Measure U Fall Award.

3:09:50 So during the workshop staff were able to bring the committee members and the council some updated information that essentially outlined that the available funds for award for the measure use cycle are insufficient at this time to really, I believe, conduct the award. We provided a small condensed balance sheet.

3:10:16 And I believe the discussion that we had at that time was to not conduct the Measure U Fall Award at this time due to insufficient funds and direct or put forward to the Year Committee to establish a revised timeline to potentially start in the Spring Award and then to establish a funding amount that was consistent with a Spring Award period while trying to maintain the integrity of the Fall Award for the following cycle.

3:10:45 Because we've previously, in the Spring Test Award, utilised all the funding available, typically what would happen in the Fall Award, we're now a little off-sync again. I know we're trying to get this aligned with Measure R, but now we're kind of off-sync again, so I think if we come forward with a, you know, winter-spring award, trying to get those funds to the community March-April in a limited amount, we can then hold a sufficient or majority of those funds available for the Fall Award.

3:11:14 Which would then hopefully get us synced and in line and then would hopefully get us these priorities prioritised or these projects prioritised by council and have a better direction and maybe some clearer understanding of where we want to use these funds for the community. So that's kind of what staff is going to advise the council on here this evening and see if there's any discussion on that item. Anybody want to start on this?

3:11:42 I know we had discussed a little bit about maybe moving the timeline to January since the funding wasn't there and maybe considering an application period around January 1 or that period of time and then a funding period around May. Correct. Or earlier. Or earlier. March, April. Yep. Actually, yeah, much earlier. Yeah. Probably by March. It would be similar to the measure of spring.

3:12:15 Award, which is, you know, the funding amount for previously awarded projects that, you know, unexpectedly require additional funds. So it's always around about a quarter of amount of the total annual amount of available funds. So Measure U has a fund balance of, we believe, in the budgeted amount of $922,853. So, you know, at that time we could have maybe a couple hundred thousand available and then hold that majority again for that fall award and get us back in sync.

3:12:44 What are the dates for R again for spring? Well, it depends again when we award the fall cycle, but currently it's December for the award and then they would open that up in March and then they would award in May.

3:12:59 And June is when you typically awarded those spring funds, early June. And I think that for you, what we were talking about was really a winter application cycle, doing it January 4th of March, so that people know since last year the test was really too late for people to really plan. So I think we're agreeing that we have to be out of sync for another year. So my thought was, well, maybe send this back and have them bring the whole packet back.

3:13:27 with a different timeline. I mean, there's pieces of this, like the application and everything I'm fine with, but I think we have to consider changing the timeline around. Okay. You know, I was thinking that I was going to ask Stu how we would modify the options specifically to approve certain pieces to make it happen. I like your suggestion, which is based upon what you heard and what we did in the workshop as well as

3:13:57 The comments tonight, bringing back something that's specific, because there is some uncertainty, if not confusion, about what happens when and when the actual money is released, and if we were more specific on that, I'd feel a little more comfortable as well. Okay. So, sounds as though we're giving direction to staff to bring it back to commission? To the council. To bring it back to us. Okay.

3:14:26 Yeah, we can, so option one there is, I mean, the first item was to accept the steering application committee's spring test recommendations. We can still go ahead and do B. Well, we can do A, can we not? You can do A. And then we change B. And then you could, yeah, right, we'd probably, the timeline would change whether we wanted to change the application form, whether you wanted to review the funding priorities again at a later time.

3:14:53 Or if you still believe they're consistent. Well, and that's why I was suggesting if they can meet and bring it back as a package, then we don't have confusion of telling an applicant, well, you have to go to this agenda bill for these pieces and you have to go to another one for another piece. You know, if it could be back. I don't think there'd be any problem with having it back on the first meeting in October. Just send the whole thing back. Yeah. Just for clarification. Yeah, just, we've scheduled the next Measure U Application Committee meeting on the 16th.

3:15:24 Of October. Okay. And that meeting is to review and then to receive performance reports from those previously funded spring test award applicants. So that's a pretty important meeting. And at that time, we can then go ahead and review these items so we could probably get it back to you. Okay. I mean, maybe the first meeting in November, I think, would be.

3:15:43 With a timeline that starts in January. With an application period that starts in January. And then the one thing that I noticed, even that was talked about in the recommendations, but I didn't see it attached, was that same sample budget. I didn't see it anywhere in what you gave us. I thought it was actually going to be, you know, like an Excel spreadsheet type thing.

3:16:10 Yeah, we did add in the application form, we added question one, which is to provide that one page executive summary. Correct. So what we can do there is include it in that summary is a detailed itemized budget. Right. For your project or service. Okay. All right. So you have direction on that? I do. Okay. We'll go from there. We'll see you back in... Thank you. Okay. Thank you, Stu. With that, we are going to adjourn. So...

3:16:41 Thank you, everybody, for coming.