Airport Commission
· recording 1 hr 22 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
154 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:08 Chair Perel, the airport staff, we have full staff for the winter. We have now four full-time employees that are completely trained, ARF certified, ready to roll, and we have two seasonal employees, primarily for snow removal, and they've been trained in airport operations, and I seem to have a really good crew. I'm really pleased with the crew I have, very good crew.
7:39 TSA is also staffed and ready for the winter. They've been bringing in their staff and ready to go. Slight change with United. They have American Eagle doing their over the wing this year. Last year they had Express Jet. This year they have American Eagle. I have met their managers. I haven't met their station manager yet. She's coming next week. But the people that I've met seem like they're really professional and a good crew. Alaska, of course, will be doing under the wing.
8:09 For both airlines and of course their own, their own over the wings stuff. And lastly, we did conduct a live burn on November 15th. We had two old buses that we burned out. It was a joint exercise of Long Valley Fire Department and the Mammoth Lakes Paramedics. And that went very successfully and we reported that to the FAA as an exercise that we had. And that's all I have.
8:48 Actually, we notify all the emergency personnel. Mammoth Lakes was invited, but it was the night that all of the volunteer firefighters get paid. Oh, no, we don't have, actually, that's a good point. No, we don't typically notify them in advance. It's something I could try. It's hard for them to get over there. I'm not sure they'd make it, but maybe we could. But we actually, when we were inspected, we did tell them we were going to hold a drill, but I never invited them. Not at our facility, no.
9:44 They'll have a full staff. It's a challenge this year because our first flight is at 9 a.m. So we're working in conjunction with the county to have the airport road be one of the first roads that's plowed. We're anticipating that they will have it open between 6 and 6.30 and we're going to commence snow removal operations on those days between 6 and 6.30. And by having a staff of 6
10:21 It's much better for the airport where we're able to staff for basically a 12-hour day, seven days a week with pretty much minimal overtime. But it is an impact in that the flights last year came at 10. So this gives us one hour less to have the primary surfaces open. So hence we were staffed, I believe, correctly in order to do that. So it'll be a little different this year. And we will have
10:48 We're used to this, but we will have a couple times when there's two planes on the ground at once. That really won't affect us. It's in the afternoon. It will affect, to some degree, Alaska Airlines operations, but I talked to the station manager, and he assures me it will be no problem. No, we're going to try to minimize our overtime to the extent possible, and we can, obviously, it depends on the intensity of the storm, right? But all things being good, we'll try to minimize our overtime.
11:19 Cover all our shifts. Thank you. Pat Foster, Hawk Creek Aviation. Good afternoon. Not a lot to report on. Similar to the rest of the Mammoth, September, October, pretty slow months for us. We did have a pretty good Thanksgiving weekend. That was very encouraging. We got some snow. Had a lot of people flying in just for the day. And it was interesting, on Friday, we had some folks just fly up for the day. Two different aircrafts come up.
12:04 Had such a great time that they showed up again Saturday morning, flew home, stayed in their bed Friday night, came back Saturday. So it says a lot about the conditions and how excited some of these folks are. As far as visitation goes, October was relatively flat with last year. September was down about 10%. I don't have a whole lot left other than on Friday we did have SkyWest come through and do their annual
12:38 Fuel audits. They check all of our records. Typically, it's about a seven-hour process. They look at all of our equipment, check our fueling manuals, our training, and it went extremely well. We had him out of there in about four hours, and he was very pleased, and so we're ready to go into fuel SkyWest another year, and that's about all I've got. Anything for me? Thank you.
13:17 Excuse me, Chair. I'm sorry to interrupt. We did have the air service update item ahead. I know it's hard to see it, but Mr. Howard Pickett isn't here either, so if Mr. Urdi has anything to add on that, I think he can as well. That's okay. We're going to start off with that anyway. I figured as much. Basically what I wanted to do is update to say that we are pacing a little bit behind in each of the markets coming into this winter.
13:45 It's definitely the hangover from last year, the lack of snow. So even the new snow that we've had this year hasn't really spiked the air traffic yet. It is starting to spike the lodging reservations, so we anticipate seeing those. But right now, LAX is pacing about 17% behind from where we were last year. SFO is 11% behind. Orange County is 39% behind. But San Diego is up 70%. And the numbers are still fairly small, which is why you see a 70% increase in San Diego.
14:15 A seven-person increase, so at this point it's still very early. We do anticipate that that will spike once we see the snowfall and once we get towards the holidays and once we get towards the flight starting. On that note, the LAX flight goes to seven days a week starting December 1st, so this Saturday it will go to seven days a week. Initially it wasn't set to go there until mid-December, but because of the fact that we cut back down to four days a week in the fall, Howard actually started the winter contract with Alaska earlier.
14:44 Two weeks earlier. The second flight from LA will start on the 14th, which is actually five days earlier than it was supposed to start. Alaska scheduled it that way, and it's actually being put into the schedule without really having any minimum revenue guarantee for those five days that it's flying early. So that's a good thing, especially with the fact that we do have snow and we have a good opportunity with the early season conditions. So the remainder of the flights, the United flights, will start on the 19th.
15:14 So that's the update there. We anticipate that based on where we are right now, the load factors have been strong since September. The four-day-a-week schedule did a little bit what we had hoped as far as condensing people. If you look back at September, last year with seven days a week, we were I think 38% load, and this year we ended up around 55%.
15:39 Basically, less flights, more people on each flight makes sense. So that's been a good thing. November was strong as well in that sense. In the grand scheme of things, it looks like we're probably going to be looking between $800,000 and $850,000 in the subsidy for the summer, spring, summer, fall. So still hopeful we'll pick that up and get as close to $800,000 as least as possible. Yep? Right, right.
16:22 Yeah, absolutely. And again, I think that we are starting off a heck of a lot better than we did last year. The mountain is in tremendous shape as far as having the most skiing and riding in the country right now. So from a marketing standpoint, we do have a good message. The goal is to still continue to drive those markets as strong as possible. A lot of online really reaching out through targeted marketing. In fact, if you go on right now, you'll pretty much everywhere you go, you'll start to see the advertising and the links for the snowpack.
16:51 So we started back in March talking with Alaska Airlines about doing a multi-ticket pack. We tried to get it in place for last summer with the idea that it could help with the summer subsidies. They don't do this, so they were reluctant to let us do it. Howard, myself, and Kent Myers, when we left our meeting in Seattle, basically said, well, if they aren't going to figure it out, we'll figure it out and present it to them. So we did for the summer. Their revenue people kind of balked at it.
17:19 When we went back up there in August, we flew back up and met with them in August, and fortunately we had Andrew Harrison, who's the VP of Revenue Management and Operations, and he didn't see any reason why we shouldn't be able to do it, so I think he was able to push that through so that we could launch it for this winter. So those started selling last week. They're selling fairly well. I think we're probably about 40% of our goal right now. They'll sell through December 15th.
17:48 Or until they sell out. I think we're, you know, the number that we're looking at selling is about a thousand units of this program. And basically what it is is there's a six-day, six-segment pack, which is $456, all taxes included. And that's basically three round trips or six one-way segments from here to LA. So they're not carrier-wide with Alaska Airlines. You can't put them all together and fly to Hawaii.
18:16 They're literally the LAX Mammoth segment. The 10-pack is a better deal. It's $660. And the good news is, so for $66 each way, I could actually book the flight tomorrow now. So you can book up to 24 hours in advance of the flight. So that's incredibly flexible because if I were to do that on their website, it would probably be $159 to fly. The other piece that's incredibly flexible is that if you buy a 10-pack, you can use it for family and friends.
18:44 So we've encouraged the properties in town, the lodging properties, to actually buy these and package them in. I just had a meeting with Terry Stellick of Seasons 4, and she was talking about the fact that she can start to package in airfare with people, and she might even be able to get her pricing to a point where she can say, if you book a three-night stay, you fly for free, because she's willing to pick up the tab for those tickets, especially when she knows that it's a consistent $66 versus risking that she's going to book somebody and it's going to be $159.
19:13 So that program should be a big hit with us. The fact that we're promoting that program is also just by doing that, promoting the air service in general, and that's going pretty far and wide. If you picked up the paper last week, we've got a big push for our local community as well. There's a full-page ad in there promoting the snow packs because obviously people here want to get out of town as well as much as second homeowners or visitors do. That is also being pushed down in Inyo County.
19:41 With the idea that we want to get those folks to come up and utilize the airport as well. So a major push on those, billboards on our homepage, billboards on the mountains homepage, major social media push, and radio media, the whole nine yards. So getting that out there and then following it up, just the general advertising with our call to action for air. You know, typically most of our ads that go out there, unless they're in specific markets we don't service with air, there is an air message that talks about the fact that we fly from the Bay Area.
20:10 Or that we fly from Southern California and list the three airports that we fly out of. So that's the marketing update. Moving into funding, we've had a very successful five meetings now with the group that we set up to talk about the Business Improvement District. Initially, the Business Improvement District, the main goal was to focus on marketing with a good portion of it being to secure and stabilize the subsidy funding for spring, summer, fall.
20:41 The group consists of about 18 local business members, lodging, restaurant, retail. The Mountain is involved. Lee Hughes is participating with us on the commission as well. They're on the exploratory committee. And we've gone through these five meetings, and we've had a lot of really good conversations. Initially, we had brought the county into the conversation. But after, I think it was meeting...
21:08 3 or meeting 4, we decided that it wasn't going to be in our best interest to continue that right now. Just because of the size of the program that we're looking at here, I think that involving the county at this point may have been more difficult than trying to just pass it through with Mammoth Lakes right now. We are moving towards, I've got a call with our attorney in Sacramento. So the attorney that we're using in Sacramento, he wrote the BID law in 1994.
21:36 And out of 67 BIDs that are in place in the state, he's done 47 of them, including the renewals. So he is the expert on them. We've got lots of questions for him because this is a multi-headed monster as to how to make it work. But right now we're looking at being probably a test case for a lot of communities because most of the communities out of those 67 BIDs, 90% of them are lodging specific and that's it. So a place like Sacramento has lodging, restaurant, and retail.
22:07 But they're really the only other one that's out there. We are looking at it as lodging, restaurant, and retail segments are tourism-driven here.
22:21 We feel that those businesses are the ones that are being impacted by our guests getting here. So if we can put this PID in place, it's going to bring more people to those. We have ratcheted down the retail so that it eliminates some of the services in town that locals would normally take advantage of, whether it's hair salons, gas stations, bonds, things like that, just because it's not meant to be an assessment on the local community. It's more based on our visitor base. So that being said, we are moving forward.
22:51 The mountain stepped up last week or so, probably two weeks ago, and basically has almost put a carrot out there saying if we can get the three segments, the lodging, restaurant, and retail to participate with us, that they would be willing to do an assessment of 2% on lift tickets. So the total, when we put this all together, and conservatively, the total that we could see raised from this BID is approaching $4 million.
23:19 And that $4 million would be in addition to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism current funding of $2 to $2.5 million a year. The complete use of the funds are to be determined. There's been discussion of us, do we take on the winter subsidies and open up the opportunities to the lodging properties in town with different discounts and different deals and different programs, or do we take the funding and do other programs? One of the things that I'd really like to see us do is take...
23:46 Our need times, early season, late season, mid weeks, and start to do things like work with the lodging properties and say, okay, if you want to put out a promotion that says stay three nights during May 1st till June 30th. So basically early fishing season, late ski season, stay three nights and fly free. Or fly two for one or whatever program we decide to put forth.
24:11 And then part of these funds that we raise would actually be there to buy the tickets. Alaska Airlines isn't going to give us tickets, but if we can get somebody to come into town and stay for three nights and eliminate the need to pay for a seat, it's a win-win. Properties win the sales tax on restaurant and retail and the whole nine yards. So we will start to go out to the community in the next month with the petition. So the way the BID works is that 51% of the participating revenue generators need to petition to say yes.
24:40 We're willing to assess ourselves on this. Once that 51% is reached, it passes across the segment. So again, lift tickets is a standalone, obviously, but lodging, restaurant, and retail. So it would pass across the board. Our goal is to see 80% plus petition for this because they see the value of bringing more people in with these funds. So if all goes well, we'd be starting to collect May 1.
25:17 It is. It's a petition. It's based on the percentage that you're paying into the program. And so the one thing is, is like, if you look at the participation from the mountain, the basis for those four segments, they make up about 52% of that total weight. But because of the way the law is written, one business cannot pass the whole thing. So they're limited to 40%.
25:43 They can't control the whole vote. So they do have a strong percentage, but then you still need to have the other businesses participate to get to the max. And again, the hope is that we have people understand the value of us bringing more people here in the opportunity times. I don't want to take us from $35,000 on a weekend to $40,000 on a weekend. I want to take us from $5,000 to $10,000 or drive people here Sunday through Thursday.
26:09 The Mountain did extend this. We've worked with them. This is the second year that we've worked with the Mountain on providing a lift ticket for lodging properties to work Sunday through Friday packages. They came down to a $60 a day ticket price for that, which is a deep discount. That was based on a four out of five day ticket. They also just extended today to go to a five out of six day ticket so we could have the property sell that as well.
26:34 Again, trying to drive Sunday through Thursday. We all have occupancy. We all have availability. Restaurants have seats open. So we've got to drive it when we need it. So the way that it works is that we need to put together the business plan now, and then we need to start the petition process. So the petition process, part of this group of 18 that we have together for this exploratory committee is they are the leaders in their segments, and we want to have those folks out talking to the other peers within that segment.
27:10 So if it's retail, Tom Cage may be out there talking with the other retail folks. If it's restaurants, it's Michael Adesma from Gomez or talking to Ed Hurley today, you know, people that can help explain the program. And I find that when you explain it one-on-one, it makes a lot more sense to people. If you read the piece that I had in both papers last week, that was to explain it to people because the previous week's letter to the editor from Paul Rudder was just, it wasn't right. And I wanted to make sure that people at least had the right information.
27:40 Paul and I sat down last Tuesday. I explained it to him, how it works, what it is, what it's for, and what the potential is. And I think he understands it a lot more. Whether he supports it or not is another story, but, you know, I think that's the big thing. So the petition process will come about. Then there's a resolution of intention that has to go to council that says we have all the petitions that say that this is something that the businesses want to do and they believe in what we're doing.
28:09 Two or three public hearings. We'll actually have the attorney come down for that as well. And the public hearings will be all of the segments. So anybody that has a comment on restaurants or on lodging specifically, they'll have the opportunity at those pieces. And then if all goes well, we could start collecting as early as May 1 of 2013. And timing-wise, it actually...
28:33 If we start collecting May 1 of 2013, and part of this process is to be able to fund spring, summer, fall, and potentially even pick up one of the LA flights as a year-round, timing actually works okay because we would collect, collect, collect, and typically if we ran a spring, summer, fall contract with Alaska, the payment really isn't paid until about February. So by February we would have more than enough collected at that point. If there needs to be a bridge, a bridge loan, that would be something that
29:03 I would have to address, and it would either come out of our reserves or potentially out of the mountain. I wouldn't go back to the town. The other piece that I, you know, in the initial numbers, one of the things that I really want to see us do is set aside money for the funding of the new terminal, because it's another piece that I'm not sure that in the grand scheme of things that the town is going to...
29:24 Have as a priority down the road, and I'd hate to see us go through the process and five years from now have approval to build but not have the money to build. So that's one of the things that we ultimately need to address. The way that the BID would work is that it would be my board would be the governing board, would probably change the makeup of the board to include all of the segments that are participating, and we may even add a few more seats to it to have more of a say from the community. And frankly, everything that I...
29:51 Throw out as ideas for use of the funds need to be approved by the board. So the idea of setting aside a quarter million bucks a year for the terminal may not be what the board wants to do, but that's something that I feel is something we should be considering and preparing for. Just to be clear, because you said one thing that caught my ear, and I think what you meant was that funding for the terminal may not be a priority in terms of the match. True.
30:23 Biggest priority that we have in terms of what we're doing at the airport because we recognize that construction of that terminal is by any measure the most important economic driver for the airport and subsequently or consequently the town. So just want to make sure that there's no misunderstanding there. Sorry. No, I know that that's not what you meant. No, and I think just in light of where the town is, I think that for us to
30:53 To be prepared, I'd much rather see us be prepared to have a million, a million and a half dollars in the bank that we can say, okay, here's the money to bond the money needed for the terminal. Because it is the driver, it is the thing that's going to get us to more flights a day, whatever it comes down to. So just trying to be prepared ahead. And we appreciate that. Anything else? Thank you. We'll keep you posted.
31:30 Thank you, Chair. As you know, we're working very hard to get a revised ALP back to the FAA. As you know, we did submit the formal ALP to the FAA in July. That was after direction from the Town Council and after we went through, gosh, about a year of analyzing the ALP, conducting a peer review, going through substantial comments, and getting it to where it is.
31:59 Now since we have submitted it formally to the FAA, there has been some things that have resulted in some changes that need to be addressed and identified on the ALP. One of those is the comments that we received from the FAA on that formal submittal that we submitted in July. We got comments in August from our planner at the time, which we need to address and incorporate into this ALP.
32:26 Since that time, we also have settled with Mammoth Lakes land acquisition, and part of that settlement did result in the Hot Creek Development Agreement being canceled, which results in some substantial changes on our airport layout plan in terms of land uses identified and leases, et cetera. So changes that have resulted from that settlement have been incorporated into the ALP.
32:51 Specifically from that we have changed the future commercial development area to be shown as airport property. That has also allowed us to show some additional tie-down area and ramp space there as well as some long-term vehicle parking which would be relocated with that additional tie-down space and future development there.
33:16 So, and then lastly, the last change that has been incorporated into the ALP is the newly adopted FAA Advisory Circular for airport design, which did include, or which does include some new regulations and requirements for different areas of airport design.
33:38 We have provided that revised ALP to you. It has been posted on the website. We do know that there are corrections that need to be made to this ALP. Staff has found corrections that need to be made. We also have received comments from Mr. Stephen Kalish that have been provided to the commission. Those are also posted on our website.
33:59 Staff is going through those. We haven't gone through them all, and we'll need to review them with our airport engineer to make sure that they are all addressed and incorporated appropriately into the ALP. We are working very hard to get this ALP resubmitted back to the FAA by the end of the year. We did get those comments from the FAA in August. We've, like I mentioned, had some changes which have slowed us down in terms of resubmittal, but we would like to get that in quickly.
34:27 Get some more feedback from the FAA. So at this time I think we're just looking for any comments or feedback from the commission or from the public on those revised sheets and be able to continue with correcting and updating the ALP for resubmittal. I think that's it. If you have any questions or comments we'd love to hear them. Jen, I guess I'd like to throw out a proposal maybe as far as trying to move this process along and I'm glad to hear that you're talking.
35:07 You're targeting the end of December, 1st of January. As a result of some of the same oversights being in this most latest version as well as what was in previous versions, I guess I'd like to suggest that we put together a subgroup of our commission, the identified members of staff, the airport engineer, and
35:42 That we create a schedule with which we meet on a fairly frequent basis in order to ensure that we've got a completed ALP by December 31st. I recognize it won't be 100% complete, and nothing will ever be completed without any mistakes, but there's some pretty glaring mistakes that we still have in this that if I'm picking them up, then it just doesn't seem like
36:09 We've got a complete document. Or we're at the point where we're at the level of a document that should be submitted. I think conceptually that's a fine idea. And I'm glad that you pointed that out in terms of the completeness of the document. You know, in my world, which is the engineering world, there's no such thing as a 100% perfect set of plans, principally because nobody can afford them. So there's always going to be minor things that need to be...
36:44 Updated or edited or changed, revised, etc. I would agree there are some things on here that should have been revised on this round. Our main concern is that we get it submitted to the FAA before the end of the calendar year. So if we can work something into the schedule in terms of what you're proposing to do in that time frame between now and
37:13 The third week of December, because the end of December is going to be pretty tough for everybody, obviously, with holidays, but I don't think that it would take more than a couple meetings, frankly, to do that. What we would like to do is get all the information we can back to our airport engineer now. We will certainly have a meeting with him, and he's down this way fairly often. We can meet with him face to face, and if the subcommittee wants to join us in that meeting, great.
37:43 But I think we're going to keep driving to get these changes corrected so that we can meet that end-of-year deadline. And to the degree that the Commission wants to participate in that, we're obviously open and willing to do that. Thanks, Ray. I concur very much with Tom with respect to the document, kind of not being fine-tuned through it, and there are a lot of malleable points that need to be continually looked at.
38:13 I want to make sure that while the subcommittee is something I would be a proponent of, it also doesn't hinder that it works to what Tom is trying to do, in my opinion, is to expedite. So if it could be even a singular person, I might be open to that with input given to that person to make the schedule even better. But I agree that something needs to happen just to get it fine-tuned and off.
38:39 Right. Because we do want to keep that commitment by the end of the year very much, at least I do. I know you do. I'm pretty sure you're on board with the same thing. Yeah. Well, however the commission would like to, you know, work with staff, we're open to that. I would suggest that, you know, we'll be on the phone with Reiner Branly tomorrow or the next day to let him know, you know, what you guys want to do.
39:06 And propose, you know, we need to get a schedule. We can email a schedule out or suggested schedule. And most importantly, I want to get a schedule from him on what it's going to take time-wise to get these things updated. We have a pretty complete list of edits that need to be addressed. So they need to get working on this like yesterday. So that's our first step.
39:33 However you want to work it out where we get together and review those edits, discuss changes, you know, like I say, for the third time we're open to that, however you want to do it.
40:05 Then they're a bunch of nitty-pickies, you know. I'm not sure, I want to go out and measure the runway, but somebody's going to have to decide somewhere along the line whether it's 490 or 400 feet, or 390 or 400 feet. And I'm not so sure that, you know, you calling a guy sitting in an office somewhere else and him looking at what his wrote.
40:36 It becomes, he says, I'm right, and he says, I'm right. Somebody's got to put all these little, maybe, picky things that really don't amount to a hill of beans, but they should be put to bed because they've become chafed. It just gets thrown up and confuses everything. Right. I don't, you know, I think that's kind of your job to, I'm talking about to all of you guys, to settle these, you know, is it right?
41:07 I think the commission ought to help on some things to make sure we understand. I see the biggies that I listed that look like decisions that maybe I would like to participate or hear about what we're doing here. I'm curious of why we selected 60 instead of 75 feet for the taxiways, which we're really going to go with.
41:39 I'm still concerned about how and why we list a 737 when I think the definition of the design aircraft is it has to have so many, and I forget the number of flights, and we were only forecasting a handful of those bigger planes over the future. It certainly helped the 20 years.
42:09 It keeps coming back. I think we need to settle how we handle the taxi lane wingtip distance to the hangers. I'd like to know why what Kalish said on that one isn't right and how we then handle it. Apparently different people keep coming up with different ways of analyzing the gradients and the half distance. And that seems to me something you ought to be able to put to bed.
42:46 What is the real gradient on the airport out there? If we've got it right, then let's stand by our guns and say this is what it is. If it's some old number that's not really right anymore, let's find out what the right number is. Deleting the billboard, that's a decision I think we, you know, I don't know why, if it's contention to people, we don't just delete it. That's a decision I think needs to be made.
43:27 The question on how you handled the declared distance on sheets 9 and 10 or whatever, the sheets were the declared distance, I think that should be settled. The rest of the things I think are, you know, just it's a question of somebody going out and checking the numbers and deciding which is right. Those I think could be settled in an afternoon. I agree. And as I said, we're happy to sit down with, you know,
44:02 Whichever commissioners, short of a quorum, unless you want to have a public meeting, but are interested in sitting down and going through those points, and we can have Reiner Brandly either here or on the phone and have those questions in particular, the ones you just went through, answered by him and then make some decisions on those things.
44:26 Oh, I'm sorry. No, that's fine. Even if there's some question as to the numbers being a couple times different because there's different ways to do it or different reasons for why doing it that way, we've spoken many times about how when we submit it to the FAA, there are going to be things they're going to come back on and there's never an airport that is without discrepancy to the code. It's more making sure that it's safe, correct, and workable for the area. So I think if we do sit...
44:54 Quickly whip off some of the things, understand some of the why behind picking one of those numbers maybe versus which one is correct because I think they can all be correct if there's different reasons for them behind them in some respect. So I think it's leaning on those people who are making these decisions in a scope of the technology for it and getting it done. I would be for...
45:18 Going to any meetings that needed, but I'd also be very, very open to making this easier and giving my feedback to one of you, maybe Tom, because I know that, and or either one of you, and allowing that to be a faster process. Where do we go from here? I think the commission, you know, you guys can just decide how you want to represent yourselves and get with staff, and we can get Ryder on the phone, or as I said, he's down here.
45:47 Somewhat frequently we can meet with him face to face or ask him to come down here. Could we open it up to just understanding your schedule and then participating as we can through it and just being at the meetings and calling a, we'll have this first draft up to us by what date and then we'll have this shored up by what date and can we send it off before our next meeting or? Yeah, well what I would like to do is, you know, get your
46:16 You know, Commissioner Walter just went through a list of items. If others have specific items that they would like addressed, if we can get those and just jump on those immediately with our airport engineer, and you're right, there is rationale behind some of these things, and understand that so that we all have a, you know, clear understanding of the decisions that are being made, then we can move it forward and we can certainly schedule meetings.
46:44 Or let you know of the meetings that we have scheduled with Reinhardt or just with staff and then you can come in and we can have a conversation about those specifically and in addition to whatever items you want to talk about. You know, I guess I'd also like to point out, and I think it's pretty obvious for those that have read Kalish's letter, he's gone through a pretty complete review of the existing draft.
47:09 May not agree with all of his comments, but a lot of the comments that he provides are actually positive solutions to some of the problems that we've seen. Right. And we haven't corrected. So I would like to somehow or another incorporate Mr. Kalish in the final product before we send it off. But obviously with some sort of parameter, some sort of sideboards, I mean, I gladly would talk to him.
47:41 About what we can do, what we can't do, and the commitment to the time frames, just so that, for lack of a better way to put it, the full disclosure, we're throwing everything out there. If there's a disagreement in a couple of those methods by which we calculate things, we can have a discussion about those different methods, and we may learn something, we may learn something. And we may choose to disagree. That's fine. Well, I think that's been demonstrated all along.
48:08 And I'm not, I don't want to sound negative about what you just described, but I'm just keeping that deadline in mind, the end of the year, and this needs to get submitted, and I'm only concerned that, and I appreciate the comments that Mr. Kalish has provided me, because many of them are valid and good comments, and frankly, a lot of them have been incorporated. I'm just fearful that
48:34 It potentially drags that timeline out longer. Maybe that's one of those conditions that, you know, you were just talking about. We need to, at some point, cut it off and get it submitted back to the FAA. So what I would say to that is that I think Mr. Kalish has been extremely involved.
48:51 And I think that we, in my opinion, have never dismissed his input. In fact, used some of it. And I would suggest that this is his input and that we could utilize this and maybe give him a date if he had anything else to submit so that we could move forward. So it's really not a discussion or an argument, but it's just clarification from anything else that he wanted to add. Because I think he has been extremely well-received and participative.
49:19 Agree or not. Yeah. No, I agree with you. Yeah. Compared to the discrepancies in philosophy and everything like that in the past, this thing is very close. I think it can be cleaned up in a point where it just cleaned up so that I just don't want too many of these nitty-picky things flying back at us. I mean, it's embarrassing.
49:59 But I think we're at the point where I don't know what the FAA feels about it. And I think this thing is very close to that point. I'm a little concerned about the narrative because one of the things we were worried about was what kind of feedback we were going to get from the FAA on the forecast. And I don't know if we've heard anything yet. I mean, you know, do we expect anything?
50:34 Of course we expect getting comments back from the FAA on the forecast. I think they've had difficulty with staffing changes with the switch in our planner. I know Brian has been getting in touch with Fernando to try to get some feedback on when we're going to hear on the forecast, but at this point we haven't received a date. So we're just going to go ahead with the narrative, with the forecast in there.
50:59 In the comments that we received from the FAA in August, they didn't note in there anything about changing the forecast or anything in the narrative, so I think we leave that as is, and we only are proposing to make the changes to the narrative to reflect those changes that we're making into the ALP sheets. And we agreed to do that in our last meeting. Just add one thing here. I think when we submitted it to Benny, we got back the feedback, actual feedback from the FAA when we did our first submittal.
51:29 And that came back with really pretty minimal types of comments. We were being driven here by holiday schedules, vacation times, and we had to get a draft for your review. This was not the draft that was ever intended to be sent to the FAA. We continue to work on it.
51:45 And so I just want to bear in mind that I think we have a very clean document here. Regardless of some of the comments or interpretations that Mr. Kalish has, some of them valid, some of them not so valid, we do intend to take them into complete consideration and submit as clean a document as we can. I think we should bear in mind that unfortunately I wish it were different, but we're driven by everybody's schedules. We were not able to provide you with the document that was actually going to the FAA. So I just wanted to point that out. The document that we did submit,
52:14 Based on the old advisory circulars, came back with very minimal comments from the FAA. I fully expect the same result from this submittal, but we can't get those comments unless we submit it. So it sounds like we are agreed to give you our comments, say by, do you need them by a certain date? As soon as possible, so maybe by the end of the week or at the latest, at the end of day Thursday?
52:45 As soon as you can get them to us, and I'd certainly like to see them no later than the end of this week. And you'll share with us your schedule? Yes. And we will participate as we can. And are we in agreement that Mr. Kalish has participated fairly well and that we'll encourage him to do the same if he has one more round to give us? Is that doable by the staff?
53:09 I have an interested parties distribution list for the airport, and I continue to send updates when we have any new materials or anything posted on the web, and Mr. Kalish is on that list. Great. And our target is to get this out, although we say by the end of the year it's pre-holiday. Pre-holiday, correct, yeah. Great. Anything else on the draft ALP? Terminal update, Jen.
53:42 Thank you, Chair. We really don't have anything new to update the Commission on in regards to the terminal. The ALP, getting that resubmitted and ultimately getting approval from the FAA on that ALP will be significant progress towards us getting starting work on the terminal because we can't get going on the environmental until after the ALP is approved. So that's really our big step.
54:07 And otherwise, just the information that Mr. Urdi presented about, you know, potential funding options through a future BID that would ultimately have to be decided on by the board. But at least some options out there to consider. Thank you. Taxi use agreement update, Brian. Okay, sort of similar to what we discussed last week, after discussing this with our lawyer and determining whether the need and really rather the need,
54:39 Was there to change the municipal code. We put a lot of those issues sort of on that side of them, put them aside, so to speak, to see if there was a need. In the meantime, I've met with all the taxi companies. We probably will come up with what basically is a lease for the property, for the space that they use for their taxi stands and whatnot. I have complete commitment from all taxi companies to abide by.
55:05 The rules and regulations we want to set up there in terms of not having to have people run a gauntlet in terms of having their taxi stands in certain locations. They are already abiding by those rules. Ruben was there yesterday picking up people. Scotty was there yesterday picking up 18 people. Scotty has assured me he will be there for every flight and provide the same level of service that he has always provided. So I think on the surface of it we have agreement from all the operators to provide service. I think we have agreement for them to not...
55:35 Get into arguments and to create a nice atmosphere for our guests coming off the plane. We have our courtesy phone up and operating. We're working on a list with Alaska to easily funnel people when there's a weather or mechanical problem to one of these companies so they can actually get a land ride back to Los Angeles. One of the taxi operators is...
55:56 Interested in purchasing another sort of a van so he'd have the capacity then to maybe move up to 30 or 32 people he told me down to LA if it were really required so I think we're I think we have a spirit of cooperation there with although not actually an agreement an overall agreement but we have a spirit of cooperation we will have leases for their spots and
56:20 We will monitor it very closely. I have guys who will be watching this very closely. And if the need arises to do something else, we'll certainly jump in. Great. And we discussed having the whatever it ended up being next meeting, coming to the next meeting, the draft of the agreement. When we have a lease, yes, we'll have it. Yes.
56:45 We seem to be pretty good at making arrangements to get people out of town and back to LA or wherever. Is there something at the other end that they're routed to people who can rent them cars and things like that? If you've got somebody coming in from London on a week's vacation and they find you're stuck in LA, you know? I haven't heard anything like that. John Urdi?
57:13 There is nothing on that side. Unfortunately, it's because of the mass down there. It's easy for us to control the message here. It's harder down there. At this point, we have a canceled flight ride card that we use up here to try and get Alaska Airlines to hand out that with the same sort of information down there. Unfortunately, our guests are on their own, just like they would be flying anywhere else to find either another flight or a rental car or a hotel or whatever it is. It's not the best guest service.
57:41 Having been on a missed flight, I can say that they do give you the rental car agencies or point you in the direction. Maybe it's an opportunity for Tom Cage to do something down there. You buzzed by the terminal thing. I was trying to ask a question on that, too. Tom Cage, in regards to the terminal, does the town have a long-range budget of any monies for the terminal?
58:15 I don't know if the town budgets for anticipated capital projects five, ten years out. And if they do, have they plugged in a number, you know, in the future for terminal expense? Yes. We have the airport capital improvement program. So the terminal is in that program right now. So the question for the town is going to be matching federal grant money from the FAA.
58:41 John Urdi spoke about that a bit earlier, that potentially some of that money could be set aside from the BID. But that's really the component that we need to be planning on. As far as... That component being what? The match to the federal grant money. Right, right. Not counting on the BID money that, as John referenced, his board has to approve that. Right. And Brian may know the answer to the question. I don't believe, other than the total project budget...
59:11 That the federal grant money versus the match money is described in the ACIP. Does the town have the 10% matching projected in the future? I don't think we have it in our pocket. Well, I know you don't have it in your pocket, but do you have it plugged in over the next 5 to 10 years? I think the answer to that is yes. I think that's what we're working on to make sure that happens, yeah. I mean...
59:36 It's a work in progress, but we will know approximately what our amount should be because it will vary a little bit because the amount of federal funding available could vary somewhat significantly. We could get anywhere from 65% funding to perhaps more. I just don't want to do a pie in the sky thing. Basically, the feds will pay for things that aren't public.
59:58 Public spaces. We do it at the water district. We plan as best as we can and then the state says your tolerances need to change and the price goes up. So we'll need a certain amount of money and then we'll probably want to bond against that money to come up with it. The revenue sources that we've identified right at this moment are perhaps what John's saying with the BID. We also have our passenger facility charge money which is about $130,000 a year.
1:00:25 Typically we'll be spending some of that every year as a match for our ongoing projects. There'll be a significant number of capital projects that we have to complete in the meantime, but that's another funding source and it could go up depending on if the feds raise it from $450 to $750 and the number of passengers we get. And then I think we'll be looking for other sources.
1:00:45 Okay, great. Thank you. And, Tom, to just tell you, we did go through the capital expenditure plan very specifically through our meeting in the summer, and it had numbers in it, again, maybe a moving target, but best guesses, but it's definitely for the next 20 years out that we were planning on it. Okay. You know, I'm asking the question because working with John on the bid thing, you know, there are a lot of questions that have come up, and there are some things to
1:01:14 Work out, I think, still, obviously. And the airport is going to be one of those things. And, you know, I'm a little concerned on a few issues that I think need to be clarified. So that was one of them. In regards to the car rental slash shuttle taxi, I just hope we remind the air carriers that we do offer one-ways for car rentals. Hertz always has one-ways available. Always.
1:01:44 From at the airport or in town if a flight is canceled. And recently we've lowered our rates by $50 for each destination. So it's $100 to Reno, it's $150 to Los Angeles and Las Vegas, and it's $200 to San Diego or the Bay Area. So they can rent a car from us one way, just as though if they were stuck in one of the cities and rent. Whereas some...
1:02:10 Car rental companies don't offer that. Enterprise does sometimes, but not always. But I always have cars. And I guess it's starting to become an issue for Hertz because what we're seeing is we're seeing a lot of one-ways in. And that's by accident of flights that cancel coming in. And then the flights are good going out or they all jump on a van because it gets coordinated. The problem with that is...
1:02:37 Hertz all of a sudden says, hey, you've got 50 cars up there and they haven't been rented in two weeks. And I say, you know, you're right. And there's not much I can do. So then Hertz says, all right, we'll send a car hauler down. They come down, they pick up nine or ten at a time, depending on the size. My point is, is that if that continues, pretty soon they're going to say, we won't rent one way from the cities. They can shut that off. And if they do, that's problematic.
1:03:06 And if they don't shut it off, they triple the price. So they're not, you know, they're not bound by any regs or rules, but it's becoming an issue that I don't want it to backfire on all of us. Because if we have a guest, you know, family down in LA and they fly in and all of a sudden the flight's canceled for weather. And Hertz says, well, we're not going to rent cars up there anymore. So, you know, the vans up here are a great idea.
1:03:34 I just don't want to be excluded from it so that I can keep trying to turn a car or two. And that's why we lowered the one-way rates to encourage people for those situations. Last year we tried to do something with John Urdi's cards as far as information when you were, you know, and quite honestly it was problematic billing-wise and, you know, I just lowered the price. So it made it easier.
1:04:00 Thanks, Tom. Just to respond, we do have the rack cards, and we make people aware, you know, I think the station manager, when the new station manager comes in, we try to make them aware of all the possibilities and the avenues of escape out of here, but for people who absolutely have to go, so I understand your concern, but it's just...
1:04:18 We try to make all those options available. As long as every option is thrown out there so that they don't think the only option is a mass transit. And it's not. It's not presented that way. People have an option. Okay. Thank you. Thank you, Tom. Anything else on those topics? Budget update. Ray. Thank you, Chair Perel. I just wanted to make one final comment about, and I know Mr. Cage knows this, but
1:04:52 It's rare that you have a fully funded five-year CIP, and in particular when you get into years three, four, five, the purpose for putting a lot of those projects in the five-year CIP is so that you can work towards fully funding those projects, whether it's through grants, other sources, etc. So as Brian pointed out, we're working on that, and certainly we're interested in the outcome of the BID because that
1:05:20 You know, as a potential financial support for that terminal, a valid one, I might add. But clearly the objective is once you get to awarding a contract, or hopefully sooner than that, you have to have it fully funded before you get to that point, or you can't award a contract. So just wanted to add that point. It's no different than in our town-wide CIP either. Ray, in the scrubbing of the...
1:05:49 Drastic reducing of the town budgets that have occurred since we looked at the capital improvement budget. Has the capital improvement budget been upgraded to the new reduced town budgets, or is it still as we saw? We have an updated ACIP. We also have an updated five-year CIP.
1:06:17 Outside of the airport work. It's actually all incorporated into the five-year capital improvement program. So we have a completed draft five-year CIP for the next budget year. That's going to start coming out pretty quick here, probably as soon as next week. Okay, and this is plowed in to fit the austerity budget. That's an apt description. Yeah, so, you know, we're...
1:06:47 Only programming projects that the current staff can achieve. And obviously, one of the bigger concerns is that we continue, I think, to add important facilities in town. We also identify what the maintenance cost going forward is for those facilities. And our biggest concern is not just being able to fund that maintenance going forward, but having staff to maintain it.
1:07:15 So that can be done internally. It can be contracted out. There's obviously a variety of ways you can achieve that, but I think that's a question mark for us right now. So I think it's going to certainly be part of the dialogue going forward here in the next few months. I guess at times like these, the best you can ask for is to make sure it's in there so everybody knows what they're taking out or what's, you know, what...
1:07:44 Right. Well, and most of our projects are funded through state and federal grants or other grant sources. You know, we've been really successful at getting grant awards for our projects. And so with measure money, we can oftentimes match those grants where there's a match required, particularly if it's a recreation project or a trail.
1:08:12 There's very little general fund money that goes into the capital improvement program other than maintenance work. Okay, so moving right along. In terms of the budget update, one of the things that I wanted to discuss and I think we'll want to bring forward in the near future is the airport business plan. We have a five-year plan. It was put together in 2008.
1:08:44 So we're right about that time where we really want to look at updating that whole plan. One of the things I think that's going to be really important going forward, as Jen discussed earlier, we have resolved the issue with Terry Ballas and the airport DA, and essentially what that means to us is now the town is back in control of airport land. And what are the right uses for that land going forward?
1:09:14 Are there leases that would be appropriate to support airport operations? What does the revenue mean to the town and the airport? I think all of those thoughts and ideas need to be incorporated into a business plan. Like I said, we have one. It's time to update it. We'll bring something forward probably as soon as January so we can start discussing that with the airport commission.
1:09:42 At least get a framework together on what you guys think should be included in that. Having just resolved that DA issue, I think it's prudent to move forward very thoughtfully in terms of what we're going to ultimately end up doing out there. If anything, I don't know what we're going to do out there. We have general aviation with Pat. We want to work closely with him in terms of aeronautical uses for that land.
1:10:11 And the FAA in particular, we want to make sure that they are involved up front and know what we're thinking about in terms of land use out there. So this is just something that is beginning to come up, and we just want to be very thoughtful going forward about how we approach all of that. So I bring that up in the budget context because it has potentially huge ramifications in terms of
1:10:40 Revenue, financial matters at the airport. And so I wanted to mention that at this point in time. Aside from that, you have a revenue and expenditure summary that we gave you before. That's really kind of right out of the budget. And then there's an expenditure detail and then a report that is pretty current in terms of what our current expenditures are. One thing I wanted to point out,
1:11:05 We had $215,000 budgeted in contractual services for the airport, and what we're doing to get our second winter temp is we're funding that out of contractual services. We felt that it was extremely important to have that second temp at the airport. There was only one in the budget, and none of us were comfortable that we were going to...
1:11:30 Be able to achieve what we needed to achieve with just the one temp. So we're in a place now, I think, where we feel pretty good about staffing, as Brian pointed out. We have the four full-time folks. We have the two seasonals for the winter. So I think that gives us a pretty good shot at keeping things going out there, keeping the airport open. Not that I can predict the weather, but there may be times where you just can't keep up.
1:11:56 Nonetheless, I wanted to point that particular item out because we're going to be moving money out of that to fund that temporary person. So other than that, if you have any specific questions about budget or business plan or any of those things, I'm happy to try to answer those questions.
1:12:30 That's correct. The lease, the land lease rent for the Hot Creek properties have been assigned to Terry Ballas. So that was a loss about of $111,000, $112,000 a year to the airport. By the way, the final line item here, what is the current budget, the June 20th?
1:13:05 Approved budget. I'm sorry, which report are you looking at? It's the final column on the... The line item. Oh, the summary. Yeah, the summary. Yes, it's the June 20th budget. And does that reflect the total revenue that comes from the FBO operations, fuel sales and whatever we get revenue out of on that?
1:13:36 Well, it is going to be considerably less because I think fuel sales and overnight parking are the only revenues that we're going to be receiving directly to the airport, correct me if I'm wrong, Pat, this year. So although I don't know if this budget is completely, completely finalized, this is something that's going on sort of at above our level here.
1:14:04 Well, I would say, let me just take a step back. The June 20th budget is the budget that we've been operating on since the start of the fiscal year. Obviously, there's, as you mentioned, an austerity feel in the air. So there's a lot of things moving. And frankly, at this point, we don't really know where we're going to end up. But this is the current budget. It just surprised me that that number was, it doesn't surprise me it was low, but it surprises me that it was that low.
1:14:37 Yeah, all that other rent has been assigned away from the airport, and that's the result. There's the result where you've lost revenue. I think it's hard to speak about it personally until we really get a picture where we're at. Yeah, I mean, clearly from the airport's point of view, we're asking that money to be made up with general fund money because, but again, we're not maybe at that point where we can really speak about it.
1:15:04 Yeah. I would like to ask, if I could, that we get a copy of the current business plan emailed to us. Absolutely. So that we can get familiar with it before the January proposed changes by you before we started on. We can do a couple things. We can make hard copies and make them available here, or we can scan it and email it, whichever you prefer. We have it electronically. We have it electronically. Oh, good. Perfect. That would be my choice.
1:15:33 I think that to that point, I'm glad you brought that up, and I think that's something really good to look at, and I for one am probably extremely cautious in the area of moving forward and making decisions with how we move forward with the airport without understanding best practices, understanding benchmarking, thinking.
1:15:58 A little outside the box, maybe even, and really acknowledging all of the opportunity that this allows us. As much hardship as this has cost us over the past years, now that it's settled, I think it is nothing but wide-open opportunity, and I would be very hard-pressed as a commissioner to think that we could make any decisions faster. So I think that's a great thing to look at. Ray, under your more detailed, I think maybe this is, you told me the answer to this.
1:16:34 There's quite a drop in the personnel cost between the baseline budget and the approved budget of the almost $100,000. I was going to ask how you could get away with that, but then I guess you've added in, you've cut back on the contract a fairly large amount down there, $315,000. You're taking some money out of that to supplement.
1:17:05 We've also lost positions at the airport. Well, we're, yeah, so I'm now a multi-department director. Yes, that's about that number. And the other thing that's worth pointing out is when you're looking at personnel services cost in this budget, Ryan is also, you know, working on transit, so some of his salary is captured in the transit budget also, but I would suggest probably the biggest reduction here
1:17:34 Is, you know, we've lost Bill Manning at the airport. I guess my question was, is that, you know, there's almost a 30% reduction shown in the area. Right. Can you run the airport on that? We think so. Okay. We're going to do our largest. You had that at one more time. Well, yeah, and we do feel very good about that. I was, frankly, you know, when I was, let's see, assigned the airport, I was...
1:18:07 Concerned about the staffing levels down there. You all know that the airport has been run at a bare minimum for a long time, and in that context, I think we're in pretty good shape. I, frankly, would probably have more people down there if we could, but under the circumstances, I think we've got a pretty good staff down there. They're good employees, and I think we'll be okay.
1:18:40 Typically we receive it around June. We received it this last June and that was, you know, they're on a different fiscal year than us. So we're, again, expecting the next check this summer, probably around May, June. Anything else for this topic, the budget? Moving on to the director reports.
1:19:16 I don't actually have anything in addition to report. I think we've covered it quite well. Future agenda items and commission meeting dates. So in December. The next, excuse me, Chair, the next commission, regular commission date is on Christmas. So then the following meeting would be January 22nd.
1:19:48 I don't know how everybody here feels, but I would be very much interested with Tom's suggestion to participate in getting the ALP out to not necessarily have a December one, but to get the business plan, not just because of the date, but I think that's more of our focus right now to take us through, unless anyone here just agrees with that. All right?
1:20:16 So would that mean that we're in agreement or need a motion to miss the next meeting? How do we do that? We'll just cancel. We'll just do a notice of cancellation. And for the agenda for the January meeting, I think the business plan is a great addition on its own next to the budget, leaving the budget. Hopefully we'll have some numbers by then for my input. And I like that we now have some consistent topics here that we keep.
1:20:45 Any other input for the agenda on our next meeting? I don't think we need to run it through the town council again. I think the plan at this stage is incorporate the appropriate edits and get it sent off to the FAA.
1:21:20 That's my understanding as well that everybody has approved with the changes that we needed to make to move forward. Right. And I just heard Brian whispering loudly. Obviously, once the FAA approves the ALP, then we'll bring it back to the Airport Commission and the Town Council. I'd love to hear the date you've sent it off. I'd love to. Well, you'll hear bells ring. I think the church bells over there will start ringing. Yeah. Anything else?
1:21:50 Then I think we're adjourned. Thank you all.