Parks & Recreation Commission · 2012
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 1 hr 15 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
140 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:04 Member of this meeting of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission, roll call please. Here. Public comments, now is the time of any member of the public wishing to address us on something that doesn't otherwise appear on the agenda. Good afternoon, my name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. Quick question, at the last MLTSCC meeting, there was a presentation about the interpretive program for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. My understanding was that that was going to make its way to the recognition that on the council,
4:22 I didn't see it on the agenda, just checking to see what the fate or status might be. Thank you. Yeah, so it's the interpretive signage program. So as you know, this is our regular meeting for December, and this is the time that we usually request additional items. So staff can either request it for the next following meeting in January or the chair can as well. Yeah, so let's make sure we get that on in January. And it's just really an action to review and receive and file.
4:56 That report. So, yeah, John, you have a question on that? Yeah, my understanding was, and correct me if I'm wrong, that it was a direction of the MLTSCC to have it added as an appendix to the adopted trail system master plan, which is, that's what I heard coming out of the end of the meeting, and I'm assuming that that's the path it's going to take. There's other documents like this we complete under contract, they're going to be part of the whole Mammoth Lakes Trail System Management Program. And I would assume that it's still going to follow that path? Okay.
5:29 It just is going to be a month. Oh, that's fine. Yeah, I just was, it's, yeah. So it would go to you and you guys would review it, recommendation counsel. Will not go to counsel until after it comes us. Got it. Okay, thank you. Any other public comments? We will close public comments and I will ask you about the consent. Do you want me to read those off? Anything pulled off of consent or does someone want to make a motion on consent? I have one item to pull. Mm-hmm.
5:57 On the November 13th meeting, number 5, Commissioner Turner could not attend the town council meeting that evening because he was hosting the chamber mixer. You got that, Stu? Or you? I'm sorry. Would not be. I'm just so used to going over there. Well, just because he was not able to attend the town council meeting that night. It was not, instead it was, yeah. Yeah, he would be, yeah. With that change being made, do I have a motion for the consent? Move the consent.
6:39 Second it. Motion second for the discussion. Those in favor? Aye. Moving on to policy matters. Remove and recommend on the Measure R expenditure plan. And I don't know exactly when this came back from the attorney. Stu, do you have any comments on, did the attorney make any comments on what our comments were on the original? He did.
7:12 For instance, the use of very specific and all of that. It's been a bit of a blur, but let me see if I can keep up with what's been happening. So we met on Thursday, and from that meeting we made those recommended changes by the Commission. We got it to the Attorney, he revised it and got it back to us Friday, and at that time it was included in your packet that we distributed to you at that time.
7:37 And maybe some confusion. It comes from Jamie. So Jamie sends out that notice. So maybe, Bill, if you're looking for an email from me, it typically comes from Jamie, and it's a link to the page. So if there's another way for us to get that information to you, let us know, and we can... Yeah, I don't think I got one from Jamie either. So maybe it just, you know... It's okay. Maybe it viewed it as junk. Right. Yeah.
8:04 So we apologize for that. So the changes that you see in your revised resolution there were made by the town attorney. So if you see things crossed out or changed, I added those changes and then you can see some crossed lines and then the attorney
8:34 added additional language at the request of Recreation Commission. So you can see on the first paragraph there we included the very specific use of measure of funds. The Attorney felt that, yes, it does spell it out in the ordinance, but it's not really a deal breaker. If the Commission wants to make sure it goes in there, that's fine. The other changes were, I think, down here on this second to last paragraph.
9:03 And what we wanted to do there was just spell it out a little bit clearer in regards to how those expenditures relate to the ordinance itself and the expenditure plan. So what you're trying to say there is it is supplanting, so therefore we're amending the expenditure plan. So he tried to make that a little bit clearer, which is those three additional lines underlined on that paragraph.
9:29 Regardless of whether such expenditures supplant existing funding, so the expenditure of measure our funds for operation maintenance of the Whitmore Recreation Area and for the current parks maintenance position do not violate any restrictions in the measure our ordinance. And the problem I have there again is since this is the expenditure plan, he really doesn't need to explain his opinion on whether it supplants or not. That's not legalese. It's not anything that I see would be...
9:59 Necessary. He's just pushing his point that he believes because it wasn't in the expenditure plan or written out specifically in the expenditure plan that it's not supplanting. Actually, in this one, what I had asked to happen is that where it says that regardless of whether such expenditures supplant existing funding, I had asked that to refer to as it relates to Whitmore Recreation Area so that it does not leave supplanting wide open and that it can be spent on anything.
10:29 And then I had also asked that there, and I don't see that anywhere, that the original, after the sunset, that this goes back to the original language. And I guess it kind of speaks to that at the end, but I'm not okay with that one either. But I think it's really key, this that's in the red right here does not even close come to addressing what my concern was, because where there's additional verbiage in this resolution.
10:59 I think that it states that if there's other incomes that come in, then they would be left in Measure R, and that it would go back and be able to spend as the expenditure plan says. Well, the expenditure plan is saying that it can supplant. So I'm not okay with that unless I'm reading it incorrectly. Well, no, yeah, a couple of things. So there has to be some, as I think we talked about, there just has to be that nexus.
11:28 Because we are supplanting, we have to actually say that we're supplanting, so we have to revise the expenditure plan. So I mean, that's the whole intent of this language. So I don't know if we can clear that up. I mean, I don't know how much... I mean, Andy's here tomorrow, so what I might suggest is, you know, we can get this as close as we can, and we'll just have to do it from the dais, or you have to... I mean, I don't know. We're just going to keep...
11:54 I would just like it to say. Going and going. After existing funding as it relates to Whitmore Recreation Area. Well, it spells it out. It spells it out there, though. It says it in here. So the Expanded French Right Funds for Operation Maintenance of the Whitmore Recreation Area and for the Current Park Maintenance Position do not violate any restrictions. Yes, but it's not saying that it is only for Whitmore, and I guess that's the point that I'm trying to make. I would suggest that you give us the specific verbiage which you were going to do. We can note that.
12:24 And then I think Andy's going to be here early tomorrow so we can talk to him about it or even call him later today and just say, hey, look, this is the preference. Are you okay with it? And he says, yeah, then fine. This is basically saying that it's okay in the expenditure plan to supplant regardless of whether such expenditure supplanting existing funding. And so then as opposed to stating that it's only relating to Whitmore Recreation and the...
12:54 Employee that this is supposed to fund. It's saying, so, by supplanting Whitmore, we're not, you know, in violating anything within the expenditure plan because it says we can supplant. But I'm not okay with that because I don't think it's saying what we've asked. So, in, I don't know, I'm not an attorney. So, do you want to give us your preferred furbage and we can note it? This I could probably live with, but could we just add exclusive?
13:23 Before where it says Whitmore Recreation Area? Or exclusively for? Just with that. Well, that's what I'm trying to get at. I'm trying to, so it spells out specifically that this is supplanting only for Whitmore Recreation and the one employee and that it doesn't open. So you can just say, so the expansion was our funds. So I had it as it relates to Whitmore Recreation Area and the maintenance, but.
13:55 Like I said, I'm not an attorney. I don't know what that language should be. Let me just add for only the operation and maintenance of the Whitmore Recreation Area. It makes perfect sense to me. You just want to be specific to Whitmore and the maintenance position. It is okay to supplant specific to Whitmore, and it is not okay, it's not opening it wide open to supplant for anything. Okay, yeah, for the exclusive use for operation and maintenance, yeah. Okay, got it.
14:42 Okay, so you guys still have no problem with that, so the expenditure measure our funds for its politicking there for... I don't have a problem because it's clarifying that they're absolutely supplanting. I just want it to be specific to Whitmore, so anyhow. We can just say that only for... Otherwise, yes, I have a problem with it if it's not going to be specific to Whitmore. Well, that's my problem with this here.
15:09 Is that what it says, so the expenditure of Measure R funds for operation maintenance of the Whitmore Recreation Area, do not violate any restrictions in the Measure R ordinance and... Because the ordinance is being changed, but I want this supplanting... I don't think that's what he's saying there, but... Okay. I don't know, that's... What's your interpretation? What he's saying there is that the council, if it chooses, can use Measure R funds for the operation, but not maintenance.
15:39 of anything it chooses, because that's been his definition of the supplanting language of the expenditure plan. And I think that that's what he is putting that opinion out there, not a legal necessity in the document. I agree, that's why I wanted to say specifically to... Only for the appropriate language that's explicitly explicit. Just to clarify, would it be appropriate then just to add the language that you're saying so it's specific?
16:08 It deals specifically with Whitmore Recreation Area and the position for the two-year period. And then, and, so leave that other language in there and just insert that specific language, take this out. Okay, that's what we'll shoot for then. I'm going to take that out. What are we taking again? Just make it specifically relating to Whitmore. So the language that he put in here, the preference of the commission would be to take that out. The whole three lines? Yeah, and then add in that.
16:39 Specific to Whitmore Park Recreation Area. That's me. I don't know. That's fine. That's fine. Okay. Well, we'll shoot through that. I'm just not sure the intent behind why he's putting it in there, if it's as Chair Souser suggests, or if he's trying to protect the council, I don't know. I haven't talked to him about it. Which was my question, because it seemed to me that he was correcting things that weren't of a legal concern.
17:08 In a way to shade them one way or the other. Maybe not, but I don't know. He's not here in front of me for me to ask that question. Right. Our original question to him was, is this legal and does it fit, or do we have to change something to make it legal? Well, I think what we're trying to get through is there's a measure our ordinance and then the expenditure plan. So what that first paragraph is saying, that it doesn't violate the measure our ordinance, right, because the planning language is not in the ordinance, it's in the expenditure plan. So what he's stating is that it doesn't violate restrictions in the measure our ordinance.
17:38 However, the next paragraph speaks directly to amending the Expenditure Plan, which is the action of this resolution. So I think that's the thought, the train of thought being progressive, and it has to create those findings in this legal document. That's really what I think he's trying to say. So we can certainly, you know, specify that it's only for the use of Operation Maintenance, Wickmore Recreation, Area Parks Maintenance, but it really probably does have to say does not violate restrictions in the Measure Art Ordinance, because they have to reference that specifically.
18:10 Okay, are we good there, pretending, seeing that? And then how are we going to do that? Did you two just volunteer to meet with him tomorrow? Well, as I said before, I mean, we can, you know, I'm going to be meeting with him on other matters tomorrow, well before the council meeting. And, you know, we can certainly talk to him about this at that time and just make sure that he's okay with it.
18:39 I'm not the lawyer, so I don't want to do anything else. No, I understand that. But we can certainly convey the message and the specificity that you're looking for and just say, hey, is this good? Is this going to be contrary to the legal part of this? We don't mind actually having, if that's the recommendation of the chair, to nominate a couple of commissioners to meet with him.
19:03 Can we see how many other changes we might have? Yeah. Let's keep going. And it's going to get to the, that's really going to get down to the nitty-gritty, I think it's probably working out. Because again, that's a whereas, which I think is less concern than the number of items. So then let's move on to the number one, therefore be it resolved as follows. Looks fine. He left in the very specific, which we were concerned about. I guess number six is my biggest.
19:44 Question, and it looks like it's Commissioner Agnich's as well from her email. And then there's the red that's been redlined where it says whereas the town intends to submit a resolution amending the measure R expenditure plan to its original language for consideration by the town at the expiration of funding commitment December 31, 2014. That was added and then obviously taken back out. Yeah, I believe it's necessary.
20:17 Well, I think it needs to go back to the original language at the end of the sunset. Did he say why, Stu? That was... Well, yeah, because it spells it out. He felt it was clearly spelled out in the expenditure plan itself because it does say maximum period and it specifies when it would expire. So he didn't deem it necessary to ask to do that because it clearly states that in the expenditure plan that it does expire. So maybe, Commissioner Stehlik, you're just thinking that it should just go back to its original.
20:50 Language, but I know we want to move forward, and I know the Commission's actually revised an expenditure plan, I think we did that in January, February of this year, remember, and that was going to go to Council for approval, so maybe that might be the next step for the Commission, is to actually present that revised expenditure plan for Council to consider, you know, because that has some sterner language in there. And I would agree with that, rather than going back to the original language. Right.
21:19 I think that we need to craft it. Which we have. Yeah. We did that. We spent a couple of months on that. So if we want to say that in that language there, we can do that. But specifically to this item, that was his comment. I just, the basic intent of the ones lined out is to say that we're going to submit the document that it is in. So I have no problem with that being lined out. I'm okay with that.
22:00 I guess. Okay, so if this is going to sunset, the only way it's not going to sunset is it's going to have to come back before cancel and they would have to extend this in a public manner or? We'd do the whole thing again. Okay, so it will absolutely. Okay. If this is signed by the mayor, this resolution sunsets. Yeah, two years, this expenditure plan. This expenditure plan. And it's null and void after.
22:28 But when December 13th changes in the expenditure plan where it goes because we all have a certain feeling on supplanting that needs to be so you guys are good with two and the changes there was the original said the temporary supplanting we added short term right now that was short term supplanting town council five short term supplanting right that's the main difference that's right you guys are good with that yes
23:03 And then we added that sentence on three. Yeah, and the next one is the language that we actually added. Three. You guys are good with that? Yes. And the next one is the long-term capital investment program for recreation and the arts, which we changed. I have no problem with four. You guys good there? I am, yes. Five is a budget and annual accounting, which we all agree on.
24:11 I'm assuming you were fine there. Yes. You know, this is where I have a concern, and this is why the one line concerns me. You know, any portion of the measure of our funds that the expenditure plan which is authorized hereby, which is not spent for the authorized purposes, shall remain in the measure of our account reallocation in accordance with the expenditure plan.
24:34 And if the expenditure plan does not specifically say Whitmore, then it could be used for other things up to that 1805. And that's how I see it. And that's where my concern lies. But the plan does say Whitmore. Well, sort of. Not really. It says it in a roundabout way, but it does not specify that it is only going to be for Whitmore. Because it states that it can supplant for anything to build. There's several places it says it by that one piece.
25:14 Okay, so how do you want to fix that? Well, that's what we're going to talk to the attorney about, I guess. I've already went through that. And maybe that exclusive language should be in the expenditure plan as well as in the whereas. And both places would be good. Well, which is why we wanted way up top for the very specific language to stay in the debt. Okay, moving on to number six then, which is completely different.
25:45 I was curious about why that language about without increasing the general fund budget for recreation was added and exactly what that means. I did talk to the town attorney about that. He got our reference to that and the concerns because I did forward him Commissioner Agnich's comments. So the intent, I believe, was favourable. It was just he's going to have a recraft that language maybe to come across and say the same thing that we're not going to impact.
26:15 Recreation Funds. So anyway, so he was, he's going to have another step of doing that. Because it makes no sense. It doesn't, right. So that's kind of what I explained. I think he kind of agreed with this too. And aren't we asking that if there are, that if funds should become available, that...
26:32 They would add to the recreation fund. Recreation funding would be restored to the general fund. So that's his intent. If TOT income comes in, so there is money within the general fund, Measure R would not be touched that come from general fund. Or a lesser amount, so to speak. Whatever percentage or whatever portion or all, you know. Yep. Portion or all. Well, yep.
26:57 In the first sentence, all revenues collected for use of the Whitmore Recreation Area and Pool, excluding funds collected for the use of the mammoth track synthetic infield, why should that make a difference? Well, because it's separate right now, so those funds aren't being affected because we don't have a budget for that. So the funds that are going to be used to pay for that would be really used to pay for the administration of that field.
27:24 That's the point. If somebody wants to use the field and they pay us to use it, why wouldn't those funds go into the operation, whether we've budgeted for the operation of that field or not, why wouldn't any revenue generated at Whitmore stay in the Whitmore account to help offset the cost at Whitmore from Measure R? Am I reading this wrong, or do you girls read that the same way? You ladies, you women, I'm sorry.
27:54 Well, I think that's a valid point, but it's hard to know without having a budget how that would all be broken down in terms of... But what we've said is that any monies collected at Whitmore would be used to offset the Measure R contribution first and foremost. And what this is saying is, unless that comes from the synthetic infield...
28:16 Then it wouldn't be used to offset our funds. Yes, I think the $185,000 has been derived from the pool and the ball fields, not the track, because the track wasn't included in the original amount of money that we were looking at in the budget amount. So then you're comfortable with anything that the track raises going into the general fund and not going to help pay for Whitmore as a whole. No, whatever is raised by the track should be used for the track. So, anyways, I, you know.
28:46 Where do those monies go right now? That's what we haven't established. So we haven't had this discussion. We haven't identified our fee structure, administration. We're still working with a proponent on that process. So I thought it was a little bit premature to kind of put that language and take all those monies when we don't have a plan. So, for instance, the administration of that fund typically...
29:08 Would go to maintenance. So if we take the revenue for the field, it would be offset to the maintenance of that property as well. So we have some type of sustainable revenue source. And then we cover the administration of the office time. We just haven't set that fee structure yet. So that's kind of our January assignment to get all this to you. I mean, that could be a decision. But right now, because it wasn't budgeted, we just wanted to make sure it's clear that it's not part of this package.
29:38 So, well, I'm assuming any other program that you have or any other monies that you receive for any of these facilities or programs that you have are going back to offset your expenses against those programs, right? So I don't see why that would be any different. Yeah, but they'd go back into the recreation budget. They wouldn't just go into the general fund to be reallocated to whatever. So everything goes in the general fund, but it would be earmarked for, I would assume, the recreation, so. Yeah, so any revenue right now that we receive from any of our field rental goes into Parks Maintenance.
30:13 So without increasing the general fund budget for recreation I think needs to be taken out of there. Yes. Yes. We also had a question at the bottom. Encumbered Measure R funds shall remain available for reallocation in accordance with the expenditure plan. Right. And we have asked that those that they remain in the Measure R to be reallocated. Yes. But that's where I want to make sure that it doesn't say that you can supplant anything. So without it being specific to them. Whitmore.
30:58 So that's why, because it keeps referring back to that expenditure plan, which is okay, but when you had your other whereas is that it can supplant anything, I have a problem with that. My problem with that one is it just says can be made available for reallocation and it doesn't specify the Measure R process or that it would stay in the Measure R account to begin with, so it doesn't specify that the money is going to come out of the Measure R account as it normally would.
31:27 And maybe that's something that needs to be put in there, that this is going to be invoiced items. The money doesn't come out of Measure R and go into the general fund as $184,000. But it says that nothing's going to be spent without the council reviewing the budget, and so everything will have to come forward. And I think we discussed that last time, too. Chair, if we like, we can say the same language from the previous Number 5, and the incumbent Measure R fund shall remain in the Measure R.
31:56 Account for reallocation in accordance with the expenditure plan. Which is exactly the language I was looking for. Correct. So we can just correct that. If we can correct that. Make sure it's consistent. And he's good with that. I'm good with it as well. Yep. Not a problem. That's all I was looking for. Okay. We can do that. And it seems like the consensus is just to remove that sentence in parentheses right there. Is that right? The one about the general fund recreation. Right. Unless the... Okay. Okay. Now, do you guys have any more comments on that? On the item specifically?
32:28 No. I'm going to read comments from Pat and Sean. From Pat, I'm sorry that I will miss tomorrow's commission meeting and look forward to hearing the outcome of the Measure R funding recommendations. I have reviewed the revised Measure R resolution. It looks good. The only item I have a question about is the thinking behind a phrase add to item 6 without increasing the general fund budget for recreation. And if we eliminate that, that takes care of it.
32:57 Does this mean that if additional funding is obtained for Whitmore Recreation Area and Pool that exceeds the current funding allocation from the general fund, then it cannot be used in Whitmore? For example, if a donor comes forward and gives it down $200,000 that is earmarked for the Whitmore site, does this language mean that general fund money cannot be used to expand operations or maintenance? Clarification would be helpful, but the current language is not a deal-breaker for her.
33:23 As a park and recreation commissioner and a former recreation professional, I feel strongly the recreational needs of the community, especially children and young adults, should be a priority. Municipal recreation can nourish one's physical and mental health, well-being, and in the case of aquatic safety, can save lives. The commission should support the community's recreational needs and recommending the town council approve the revised measure. Our resolution is a step toward this goal. I wholeheartedly support the funding.
33:51 Support funding the Whitmore Recreation Area and Pool with Measure R funds. And Sean's, hello, I'm sorry I missed today's meeting, but I would like the following statement read today. I believe that Whitmore Pool is one of our most important resources, and I believe it immensely important that it remain open for recreation, physical education, and team sport purposes. I'm disappointed that, in light of the current financial challenges, town staff feels it necessary to tap into Measure R to keep Whitmore Recreation Area open.
34:22 We have been told that this is the only way to keep the area open, even though this is a blatant case, in my mind, of supplanting money that has previously come from the general fund. On November 29, the Recreation Commission asked questions of the town attorney to keep or insert language in a resolution to keep Whitmore area open. I have not heard the outcome of those questions, but if any of that language is not recommended by the town attorney, then I cannot support the resolution without further discussion.
34:49 I understand this email cannot after the vote. I just wish to state my opinion. At that point, I would take any comments or questions from the audience as it pertains to this matter. Then it is up to you guys what you want to do. Do you want to make a motion? Do you want to meet with the town attorney? I would make a motion that we move all measure our applications except for the Whitmore pool.
35:24 forward until such time that we all, that we agree or if the council, you know, forwards this then, you know, they can, but without having the final language on the resolution, I'm not okay with moving that part forward. So I would make a motion that we move all, measure our applications forward other than the Whitmore pool. It seems to me that I agree with the motion in spirit, but because council tomorrow night is...
35:53 Voting on the restructuring. It seems like time is of the essence and perhaps we should meet with the town attorney. Well, we can, but unfortunately we can't vote on integrating, so, you know, it's that chicken and egg and unfortunately we don't have the opportunity to meet again prior to the council, so. Stu, let me ask you a question. The reorganization, this is just phase one, this is just the start of.
36:23 This is something that, from my standpoint at least, is not hanging fire for their tomorrow's meeting. We could put this on a calendar for a meeting after our January meeting and still get it through and have everything open in time and raise questions for you as well. You can have a gun under that table or anything, do you? Okay. As to whether that messes up the cart and horse routine.
36:55 Ray can probably correct me on it if I'm wrong, but our interpretation, what we've been informed, that it's actually part of not so much the outsourcing, but the restructuring plan in regards to the town finances. So the December 5th meeting is to, essentially because there's money involved, there's $185,000 here. So if the Commission didn't come forward with a motion or the recommendation about that $185,000, the Council could not complete that.
37:25 Process tomorrow night. Am I right right? So, or maybe there's other options that come up tomorrow night. I don't know. We don't know. You know what the answer, but I know that they're going to deliberate on each of the items that are, you know, for, are part of the restructuring plan, and of course this is one of those items. So, do we have another option here, Terry, perhaps of moving all of the funding recommendations forward, but not moving the resolution, and I agree with you, I'm not real comfortable with that.
37:55 Not moving forward the resolution that's actually going to allow them to use the money so they can budget it but they can't use it without the resolution until we get our work on the resolution finished. That way it doesn't hold up their December 5th and it doesn't hold up where we're going either. You know, they can move it forward if they wish to because they can change that resolution if they wish to without our input. I'm not okay saying yes, we'll move it forward.
38:25 Without the resolution, without being comfortable with the resolution. So unfortunately, because we don't have the town attorney here, those questions are still not answered. I'm not comfortable moving it forward. And so, you know, we could put it, I would be okay moving everything except for that one forward. And then we can make a second, I would be happy to make a second amendment that upon the acceptance.
38:59 of the resolution from the Recreation Commission that that other item would move forward. I would be okay with doing something like that, but I would like to have them, you asked us to have them separate before, and I was hoping to have this come forward and we could just pass it through and I wouldn't have a problem, but unfortunately I'm not comfortable doing that. Chair, maybe what I could suggest is if we're comfortable with the language and if it goes forward,
39:28 Maybe we schedule a special meeting tomorrow. I think there's a 24-hour notice. I think, is that right, Jamie, that we could do that? If we schedule it at 3 or 4 o'clock tomorrow, we could have the town attorney present. We could get this reviewed, get it amended, get in front of the commission. I would be in favour of that. I just think this needs to get moved forward and be put before the council.
39:51 I share the reservations about the language, particularly in number six, but it seems to me that the bulk of the resolution we are okay with at this point, so could we make a motion to move forward with this contingent on? I guess I'm okay with that, but I think we need to have them, I do think we need to have them separate, because if we make it all contingent, if there's something that falls apart with Whitmore, then the other measure our applications don't move forward.
40:18 I thought, though, that the Measure R applications were as the December 19th Council meeting, not tomorrow's. Number one, they are number two, you guys always work on it in the first one. Yeah. And this agenda does not talk about all the Measure R applications. So you shouldn't take the vote on all the Measure R applications. Well, okay. You already took the vote. Okay.
40:37 And it was that they were all moving forward contingent upon this resolution. So then I would have to say no on all measure our applications if we cannot revise that. Well, the last motion was contingent upon that. So it's still contingent.
41:06 So if we don't approve this today, it just moves forward as we left it contingent on our approval. Yes. So we can take no action and move forward. Well, I don't know how we consider it forward, but. Yeah. We'll move on. So we'll move forward unless we do something else that contradicts our last. And it's still contingent. So then tomorrow night, there's still no answer.
41:36 So we could meet with the town attorney tomorrow, and if there needed to be, we can talk to, we can speak at council tomorrow night, and then we could possibly have an emergency meeting after that, once we hear what the council has to say, once we hear what the attorney has to say to finalize this, before the December 19th meeting, is that correct? My question is, are you saying then that
42:08 We could have an emergency meeting tomorrow. A special meeting. It just needs to be 24-hour notice. A special meeting with the town attorney. Just for this item. And we could approve it or disapprove it at that point, and then anything further is not necessary. I think it would save a lot of the go back and forth in between. I think the town attorney is critical. And you probably don't want to do it from the council and the dais with the town attorney here, so I think it would be probably the best, the most prudent course of action. You can probably get closure on it in 15 minutes.
42:37 You'd be able to be satisfied or not. That would work fine for me. And then you'd be able to make a motion and then you'd be able to, you know, move that on to that evening. That would be good because we really only have really three, I mean, they're critical, but there are really only three areas. I'm okay with that. Any particular time, I can contact the attorney and see when he's available. I know there's a closed session, Jamie, at 5. Well, if you have to give 24-hour notice, you better make it 4 o'clock. It could be 3 o'clock.
43:07 Well, 4 o'clock. That's right. Maybe do 4 o'clock. It's going to need to do 4 o'clock if she's going to have to post it. Yep. So we'll shoot for 4 o'clock tomorrow. Is that okay? That's fine. Okay. Okay. Okay. Number 5, discuss and provide direction to staff on creation of a long-term capital facilities investment program for recreation and the arts.
43:41 Do you have a public comment on this one or the last one, John? Just a general comment. This is a technical question. I was watching the meeting over the internet last week and there was a consistent buzzing that made it sometimes hard to hear what was going on. I'm hearing that same buzzing in the room. You may just want to check with your technical folks. It's the same sort of staticky stuff you're hearing here is coming through. It would probably be a place for the council meeting next tomorrow night. It's fine. I'm just looking for that. Thank you. There are those, John, who said you've had buzzing between those ears for a long time now.
44:14 Sorry. Okay. Let's discuss staff. Do you have a presentation or do you want us to just go? Well, so this item, as you know, is really, again, a follow-up to the previous item that we just talked about in a resolution. And it's obviously an action item that the commission has been tackling for several months. But what it does is really hopefully define and focus the conversation specifically to
44:48 What we're talking about is a long-term five-plus years capital facilities investment program for recreation and the arts. So because this is such a broad topic, Commissioner Stelick and Agnich met with Ray and myself yesterday, and we kind of went through and framed some of these questions. So we believe would be the most prudent course of action is to kind of just walk through these questions and these discussion items that would help.
45:18 I think our discussion in general and really what we're trying to do with this item at the end is to direct staff and give some direction in regards to what we're trying to achieve, the deliverables, any timeline that we want to start looking at. The timeline as you know is really June 30, 2014 so we can kind of work backwards from that and develop a timeline. A couple of things that came up yesterday is that we wanted to tackle in a little different order the number of questions so we can kind of walk through that.
45:48 But that's really our goal today is not to spend, you know, an odd amount of time on it, but really with the commission, frame the discussion and then develop a level of meetings, workshops and a timeline and then direction to staff on how best to proceed. And I know Commissioner Stelick was in that meeting. And then what we've done as well is we revised a little bit of existing town documents. We also added another section for additional reference documents.
46:18 We have some examples of Recreation Capitals Facilities Plan. So without going to the extent of producing everything here today, we just thought the most prudent course of action, Chair, was just to walk through these questions. And I believe the order of presentations, Commissioner Stelick, wasn't 1, 2, 3, 4, it was 1, 4, 2, 3. There you go. So if that hasn't confused anybody even further, I'll hand it back over to the Chair.
46:52 Do I seem to be missing my report on item 5? It should be right there. Thank you. Thank you.
47:26 And we moved number two to number four because we felt we needed to go through the whole process before we could really look at what the current five-year capital improvement plan said and what we would like if there's any amendments to that or additions or whatever. So anyhow, we felt that that was kind of the last thing that we would want to do is look at the five-year and have that long-term plan. So we just moved the numbers around. So it's one, four, two, three. That sounds good.
47:55 And then just in the existing town adopted plans, we added the master facility plan to that one. And on reference material, we added a section for reference materials. And one of them was the USOC for the Olympic training facility. And then the gateway plans, the information that we're getting from the gateway for reference materials because they're not adopted. So it would be reference material.
48:29 And so what we were really looking at is how we move forward with this because, you know, we need to take all of the plans that we have and kind of wrap our arms around it and figure out how we move forward and see how things work together. So we were talking about having workshops and maybe, I don't know, it was suggested that possibly each one of us takes one plan and kind of focuses on that. It was suggested that, because I kind of had a concern with that, because I think each of us might come out with a little bit something different from each of those plans.
49:00 That maybe we take one or two plans at a time and that we have, you know, each month we have at least one workshop on maybe two of those plans. We put down what our executive summary would be of what we've gone through that and come back together and then have the conversation on that. And as we move through all of that, hopefully come up with, you know, we have that summary on each one and we can put that all together at the end of.
49:29 Those meetings, that's kind of the discussion we had yesterday. The only issue I have going down the road that way, and it can be done as part of that process, is we've never actually finished RecStrats. I know it's been adopted, but it was recommended by the consultants that we go back and look at the aligned and the non-aligned because the scoring was skewed somewhat.
49:55 By the fact that some of them appeared in more than one category, and others only appeared in one category, which didn't make them more or less significant, and we haven't even gone back to that plan. So I would love to see a workshop on just that plan to get it. Well, if we want to take one individually, that would be fine, but this is exactly what that would be doing, because we would be looking at that plan as a whole. Right. And, you know, taking what it actually means, what's in there. Maybe we start with that one.
50:23 You know, are there any commonalities with that one than the other ones? And then putting those together and moving forward. So, you know, if we want to take any of them on their own, I have no problem with that. If we want to, you know, we're trying, we're originally looking at a six-month time period, and I think six months is too long. So that's why we were looking at possibly taking two at a time instead of doing one at a time. You mean to go through the current plans? Go through the current plans. Right.
50:57 Yeah. And so this would be homework that we would all need to do on our own and then come back to a workshop, have that conversation. We would put down and come up with one executive summary with everything combined. At the end of that workshop, have public input so we can add that into whatever we're working on and then use all of those summaries for each of those plans at the end to come up with it.
51:26 Long term. So then you would see that out of that the work program would be things such as master planning certain parks and adding those into work. Quite possibly. That would be what comes out of this. Is there a master plan? Is it already done? Is the facility already there? We just need to change the use of it or improve the use of it? I don't know. So that's what it would be looking for.
51:50 Were you thinking that if we did two at a time, then we could do that in a three-month time period versus six months? Yeah, that sounds great. I have no problem with that. I think it's been so long since I've looked at the Parks and Trails Master Plan, even though we worked on all of those things, the opportunity to go through them and air them out as it were makes a lot of sense. Yeah, so kind of what I had written down here is, you know, what do we want? What do we want to achieve? Where does it live? Who are the partners?
52:20 And then putting the timeline and finance plan together. You know, what are the commonalities within each of the plans that can go towards each of these? So those are some of the things that came out of the meeting yesterday that I came up with. Do you guys have anything to add? Well, I think you've summarized it well, and this is really sort of picking up where we left off last year. You know, we had a new approach to developing the five-year capital improvement program, and part of that was going to be
52:50 Going to the next level, which is really sort of beyond that five-year period, and we talked last year about the public facilities finance plan, and boy, that name was too long, so let's call it the capital facilities whatever. The name is less important than I think the objective, and that is to come up with a long-term strategy for parks, recreation, and art. We can throw that in there. I think yesterday we talked about maybe
53:20 Right now focusing on parks and recreation facilities. But nonetheless, I think the goal here is to have a firm strategy, not so firm that you don't have any wiggle room, but have a strategy going forward so that we know where we're going and we can put together a solid plan to get there that will list project priorities, that will describe funding options and opportunities, and it's really
53:48 A complete package on how to achieve what it is you want to achieve, and I think that's the underlying theme here. What Commissioner Stehlik was just talking about was there's a whole body of work that's been done, and we certainly don't want to redo that. I think it's really important that we go through the materials that we have, understand what's in them, and just as you said, Chair Souser, you know, these aren't documents that we're regularly looking at, so sort of reacquainting ourselves with
54:17 with these documents, what's in them, and beginning to pull them together in a synthesized document that can help us move forward is really kind of the goal here. And what Ray just referred to as, I missed that part, is in this resolution moving forward it refers to recreation and arts. And so we didn't feel that we should do both of them together. We felt we should tackle the recreation.
54:47 And then identify who all the partners are and the people that we need to pull in for the arts discussion and actually possibly expand it beyond the rec commission and then do the same thing for the arts and move that forward. Although aren't the two where it comes to facilities pretty much tied together at the hip, hard to look at recreation without looking at the areas where we're going to have our concerts and where we're going to...
55:15 So if we can call that Recreation, I suppose, and say we're moving forward with that, not moving forward with the arts, but I see the two of them in terms of our master plans and RecStrats and everything else completely tied together when it comes to the capital program. And I'm not looking at finalizing one without the other, but I think that we need to achieve one and look at that and then achieve the arts, and then is there anything where the facilities can kind of commingle or is there something we need to add to that? I just, I think if we try to...
55:43 Do both of them at the same time that, you know, we're going to lose sight of what we're trying to do. So, I don't know, that was just our thought yesterday as we were moving forward. Not only that, we have the feasibility study that's going to be coming back that's just been, that scope of work's been approved. So, if we do take on the recreation first, hopefully by that time then we'll have the feasibility study, we can take on the arts, and then we're going to put, merge the two together.
56:12 That's how I would, that's what we were talking about yesterday. That wasn't me, it was our group that we were talking about yesterday. Does that make sense? Yeah. If nothing else here, anyone from, any member of the public wishing to comment on this agenda item? Elaine Smith, High Sierra Strider, sir. I think it's a really good idea to go back and go over everything that has already been done.
56:51 Numerous plans point to some of the same things. I think we don't have enough money to do everything in all of those plans and the priorities will come up as you go back and look at it. You know, I did the same thing you're talking about on my own with RecStrats to say, okay, what does it say and if I were a commissioner, what would I find there? And there's more than we could probably do to, you know, to fund. So I think it's a good thing. I'm hoping you can go.
57:21 Quicker than that even, perhaps, and if you need help from the community to help in review of that, you know, I've started these kinds of things and I give this as just something to start your, each of your own deliberation over the plans. Thank you. Great. Thank you very much. Okay, thank you. Okay, any other?
58:19 Evan Russell with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. And I think your direction to break these two up is a good idea because I think when you look at what's going to be good for the community and what's good for the community is good for, I think, the visitor long term is recreation and activities that you do indoors and outdoors and arts and cultural programs that you do indoors and outdoors.
58:47 They both have different uniquenesses to them and eventually some may be able to cross over but we've been trying to take a hard look at the indoor activities and they don't necessarily work in the same place that the outdoor activities work in and they have different uniquenesses to them. There's certainly a lot to talk about especially if you want to try to identify what your outcomes are going to be and who your users are going to be.
59:15 I think it's important, you know, that as this goes forward that we develop programs in concert with facilities so that when facilities hit the ground, they're full, they're producing what you want them to produce, and that's been thought out as part of the process. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? Okay. So what do we have to do from here to move this forward? I concur with how you move the numbers around.
59:48 We could pick which two plans we want to start with and then choose when we want to meet for our first workshop. Because I truly feel that this needs to be in a workshop so that we can have a discussion as opposed to and then come back to our meetings instead of having a discussion in our meetings. So I think that's what we would need to do. Which is kind of what I think what we propose would be for a first meeting in January, which I think is that first week, we would bring a
1:00:18 Central timeline, kind of a work plan. The idea of scheduling that workshop two weeks after each regular meeting, so we'd be meeting every two weeks like we used to do, but that second meeting would just be that workshop. So at this time what we'd recommend is we'd meet on January, staff would present kind of the work plan, the timeline. We'd identify that RecStrats would be the first workshop in January and that would be the, we can kind of look at that date right now if you wanted to, but I think as
1:00:47 There's a study assignment. That's probably got the most body of work, I think, at this time, because it is somewhat incomplete, as the chair said, so we believe that would be a standalone workshop. So probably what we would recommend is your regular meetings on the 8th. On the 22nd of January would be the first scheduled workshop for RecStrats at that time, so that would be our homework assignment. But in January, what we'd lay out is the complete timeline with all the workshops identified and what plans you'd be addressing. So as part of that workshop,
1:01:17 We'd want to identify the participants that joined us for the RecStrats process, invite them to that workshop, you know, so they can at least engage at the end, is what we talked about, commission to go through their discussion items, then engage the participants, you know, public comment, and then the Parks Rec Master Plan. You know, there's a lot of work done in that needs assessment, and there are some very specific recommendations in that plan already that you can probably just start walking through, like for the Trail System Master Plan. And I'm thinking for general plan,
1:01:45 Dr. Seds, and some of those documents, we can start doubling up, as we talked about, and we can kind of start condensing that timeline somewhat. And then we have those other plans, you have the South Gatway planning, the USIC, and then you still have to review the five-year CIP, which Ray's trying to finalise by, you know, end of February, so there wouldn't have to be some time dedicated to, you know, review that draft five-year CIP as well, so we'd kind of build that in to your timeline. You don't think we could take RecStrats and the Park and Rec Master plan and put them together?
1:02:16 You know, I think I would agree with Stu that the RecStrat still needs some work done on it. And unless we're going to have a mighty long meeting, I think that it requires one on its own. I think if two fit better together would be the Parks Master Plan and the Trails Master Plan as a group because they sort of dovetail. And we're thinking about a two-hour workshop, right, I think is about the most, I think, after that time we ordered. But I still am uncomfortable with it.
1:02:47 RecStrats not being finished as we've left it. I would see that being one meeting. That's just me, I don't know. I could go either way, really. I would see the Parks and Rec Master Plan dovetailing somewhat with rec strats, too, but maybe for the first one, just, it might be better just to deal with one thing, just in that initial one. Okay. Okay, so, is that good direction? We feel we have enough? Okay. So that's your homework, essentially.
1:03:24 Yep, January 22nd at this time would be that workshop. We would look at, that typically was the time for Mobility Commission, but we think that might be available at that time, so we'll see how we do, but either morning or afternoon on March 19th. And we try and do them here as well, I believe, if we can. Well, the action was to...
1:03:57 It's really up to Commission. On January 8th, we would present the full timeline for this discussion, so maybe at that time it gives two weeks notice for participants. I think that we have, the three of us have concurred that twice a month regular meeting and then a workshop for those three, probably four months. Does that work for you two weeks after? That's fine for me. So I don't know. I wouldn't have a problem with it being.
1:04:27 As long as you go back to the master calendar and that's all going to work for town meetings and staff and everything else, that we go ahead and schedule it and post it. Without getting into the calendars right now. No, exactly. That's what I mean. I just do want to look at space and reserve space. If that works, then you can do that. I see where John's coming from. He wants to have as much time as possible for people to know when to.
1:04:57 So what I've just heard is that January 8th, you have a specific plan. Yes. Yeah, and it might be better to wait to post any of that because then we can actually put what plans we're discussing at each of those meetings so that there's going to be a better discussion and public information. And certainly the purpose of the workshop too, so what the deliverables are so that the community knows what they're coming and need to be prepared for. Yeah, exactly. That works.
1:05:27 That's good. And then we can make sure that timeline works for you, Sean. I'm excited we're going to move forward and we're actually, you know, this is a good thing. And then what I'll do, just Chair, as a follow-up, is just to email the commissioners to make sure everyone does have that document. If we need to print it, we can print it. It is online. We can send you the links. But something like this, you probably do want to have that printed out. So again, I'll just inquire with the commissioners.
1:05:59 If they need the document, we'll print it, make it available, and so forth. You know, the general plan is in here, but I guess one thing that would be good is for everybody to go over the recreation portion of the general plan, because that's what we should be basing all of this on. Okay, anything else on that? I would just add, you know, we've listed documents here, we talked about some others yesterday. If anything else comes to mind, I think we've got pretty much everything here, but if anything else does come to mind that you think would be useful to the group, then...
1:06:35 By all means, let us know and we'll pull that together as well. Does the public have any knowledge of documents that are out there that we don't know about? Speak now. Well, there are a lot of documents the town has on their shelves, but they are more relevant after the initial putting these together, like the 14 different plans for Mammoth Creek Park East, but that's after everything's prioritized.
1:07:11 Okay, moving on then to number six, manager's report is typed in here. In the packet, yeah. In the packet, any questions on the report? Anything in particular you want the public to know about, Stu, out of the report? We've got a couple of things. Obviously, our tree lighting ceremony is always a big annual event this Friday at Footloose Sports Parking Lot. Looking forward to some nice weather. Or cold, hopefully. Doesn't need to snow, but nice and cold.
1:07:38 And then just a quick update on the ice rink. So we have identified the leak. So in fact, the faulty coupling that when it was originally installed wasn't fit correctly. So we took two days to identify that, which we were doing last Thursday. The contractor is actually over there now. Completing that will hopefully be probably a couple of days. Then we have to get the train.
1:08:05 Representative from Fresno over, so we think that's probably Thursday or Friday. Restart the chiller, reset it. So obviously our timeline for Friday to 7 is a bit optimistic at this time. So just due to those unforeseen circumstances, the rink is probably bumped back either the following Friday or as soon as we can, but it's about five days to make the ice. Stuart, what does a train have to come over and do for us each year?
1:08:30 Well, this would be a special trip. Basically, the chiller won't start right now unless we have them come over and run through the diagnostics. It's a pretty expensive little piece of machinery. So he does have to come out and reset it and calibrate it and so forth. I didn't know that because you said we'd run it over the summer to make sure everything was up and working. And we think what happened, Chair, is because of that leak, the chiller started then stopped because of that leak. It tried to restart again.
1:09:00 And then it basically just shuts off, you know, just to protect itself. So that's essentially what happened. So that was the update on that. And the market and feasibility study, we've received the revised scope of work. It's down to, as we discussed very specifically, just special events. So we're at the point that we can go ahead and contract with that consultant to begin that work. And that came down to about a $25,000 contract.
1:09:28 It has all the deliverables in it, that working groups met, they've reviewed that scope of work, so that is moving forward. As you know, a trails end park is completed. If you've been down there, had a look, so it's kind of wrapped up. And I believe Ray might update us on the track, on the field. Ray, is it both accepted? No, we're not quite there yet, working as quickly as we can. The turf itself is essentially complete.
1:09:58 We're still working with the general contractor on a punch list so we're working through those items as quickly as we can and hope to have the facility open and operating of course until it snows down there so working away on it's looking good this might be a bit unusual if you indulge me for just a minute I since Elaine is sitting here many of you were at the opening
1:10:26 Or I should say the ribbon cutting. We're going to do the grand, grand opening in the springtime. But, you know, I was there and many of us were. And as I looked around, I thought, this is an amazing accomplishment, really. Elaine and Jim and the track club and all those folks did a lot of work and put a lot of effort in to making this a reality. And they've been working on it for years, as you guys know. But it just dawned on me as I was standing there and looking at all the people and the facility.
1:10:56 And just sort of taking in the moment, it's a wonderful example, I think, of a public-private partnership. Multiple agencies, multiple partners that really brought this thing to fruition. And I think it's certainly a model that we're going to want to look at in the future. And as we talk about long-term plans for facilities and, you know, how we're actually going to achieve these things that are important in the community,
1:11:24 We can look to the example of the track as a way to go and get things done. So I just wanted to say thank you to Elaine for all the work that she and her folks did and certainly our staff in getting the facility built. But it just proves if you all work together, you can get stuff done. So I just wanted to add that and I thank you. Tomorrow, 1210, Cerro Coso College, Mammoth Moves. It's a half-hour walk dressed for the weather.
1:11:59 I'm sorry, I wasn't ready to do it. I had a question for Stu on his manager's report when he was doing his presentation. When is the feasibility study supposed to be done and completed and handed back to us? I have to look at the scope of work. I can't remember off the top of my head. I just don't know if they need to be here in summertime, right, to be able to do that work. So let me get back in there and look at that timeline. The timeline was in there, so I'll...
1:12:25 Maybe what I can do is just forward that to the Commission if they'd like to see that revised scope of work and that might be helpful for you. That would be great. Okay. Sorry about that. And as far as just my report goes, I have to apologize because I did not print out my minutes from the USOC, the Olympic Training Group's discussion, but it's moving forward. It's a dynamic group. It's pretty large. We have a lot of people within each of the sports that would be...
1:12:56 Users of, you know, facilities and programs and so, you know, what they need in something that's moving forward. They realize that we're moving this forward and are very cognizant of that and want to be a part of, make sure that they have, are able to speak to our programs as we're moving forward as it relates to facilities.
1:13:19 Because they are more focused on the programming portion right now because realizing that the facilities are going to take longer, but obviously realizing that you need to know what's going to be programmed in each of your facilities to make this happen. So that's moving forward. It's been a great discussion, and like I say, I think the group grows every time we go to a different meeting. We have a few different...
1:13:42 People there. So anyways. It's been a good process. And then I just want to publicly apologize to Elaine and the High Sierra Striders because it appears that in our last meeting there was some things that I said that were kind of misconstrued and that in no way, you know, there were assumptions made as far as the funding for the loan goes and that it was taken.
1:14:11 You know, I was saying that they were not telling me that they didn't tell us the truth. And there's an assumption that was made, I think, on our parts as to what a fundraiser was. And I apologize for that. So, Elaine, I apologize if that was taken out of context because that's not what I meant. So, anyways. And I have no report. So, I think agenda items we've already dealt with, I would entertain a motion. That's a move. Second.
1:14:56 I motion and second. Further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Thank you.