TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2013

Planning & Economic Development Commission Special meeting

· recording 2 hr 55 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

357 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 I see by the clock it's 2, let's say, 5, I apologize to everyone, a small flood in my office. As it all thaws, it all comes in through the windows apparently now, so computers were safe. We can call the meeting to order this time and have the roll call. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. If you all could stand at this time and join us in the pledge of allegiance.

3:58 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation under God, indivisible in liberty and justice for all. Thank you. This time is our public comment portion of the agenda that provides the public an opportunity to address the Planning and Economic Development Commission. A matter is not otherwise on the agenda. If you have something that you'd like to comment, not on the agenda.

4:30 Please come forward to the microphone on the podium and state your name for the record. Thank you. Good afternoon. My name is Jack Copeland, and I know many of you, but there are also some people I don't know. And I'm here this afternoon just to introduce myself. I am the new president of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce, and I will be attending Planning Commission meetings in the future, probably for the next year.

5:04 Weighing in on issues that I think are important to my constituency. And you might ask, I think it's appropriate to ask, well, what is that constituency, Jack? And I think that the membership of the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce represents both the big players in town and the smallest players in town. And in general, the small businesses in town walk somewhat in step with the large businesses.

5:33 That which is good for the large business is good for the small business in the sense that the more salmon that are swimming upstream benefits all the fishermen. And so we certainly support the development and we are pro-development. But there are some issues that arise between our members and between big business and small business in our community. One, for instance, which I don't believe was on your agenda this week, but was,

6:03 last month is the issue of how zoning will be treated in the future and how much density and what kinds of uses will be permitted in large zoning development plans in the future. And I think that a good thing to look at is VONS. So VONS is planning an expansion.

6:27 And what are the unintended consequences of that expansion? Because we all know Bonds needs to expand. There's no question. Anybody who shopped in Bishop knows the difference between the stores. And Bonds has a coffee shop. It's not a new business. It's an existing business. Bonds has a pharmacy. It's not a new business. It's an existing business. And they can't build a new bid.

6:53 Building, so it's perfectly logical that for them to expand their inventory and their shelf space, they need to rearrange and move some businesses, push those businesses out of their existing space. But that does have some consequences to smaller businesses, in particular Java Joint. So what is the Java Joint to do and what do we care as a community?

7:22 about what happens to the Java joint as the Starbucks and bonds expands. And I don't think there's anyone who doesn't understand that that expansion is important and logical, completely logical. But it is undeniable the impact that will have on the Java joint. Now, fortunately, Lynn and Karen are broad-minded and entrepreneurial enough to have seen this coming and gone out and have solved their own problem.

7:51 But not everyone in the business community will be able to do that and will see it that way. But this, my point is that there are sometimes conflicts that are unintended that arise between large business developments and small businesses. And I would ask you, I mean, we are definitely pro-development, assuming that that development is compatible with our community and our community.

8:19 Our way of life and the things that we value in our community. But how many more restaurants can we support today, Wednesday night? How many people will be eating out in restaurants tonight? How many waiters, how many servers can the town support? Every one of these developments is going to come in front of the commission.

8:46 and ask for more commercial spaces. They're going to want to have more restaurants, more rental shops. They're going to want to have more retail spaces. And I ask you, just as our chamber must grapple with this point with our own members, how do you balance that growth and the need to service the new people coming into those beds?

9:13 with the slow times that are inherent in our business here at Mammoth. I know John Urdi is here and he's working to fill beds and put butts in chair seats up at the mountain midweek, but look at the difference between Saturday and today. And so as you consider planning and what will happen in the future,

9:41 Undoubtedly, we will have a gradual increase in improvement in our economy and an increase in investment in Mammoth Lakes, and there will be pressure brought to bear on the Planning Commission and the town by those developers who paid peak prices for their property and now want to develop it in the coming economic time.

10:06 I ask you to consider on behalf of the chamber and all the existing businesses in town, how will we all earn a living on Wednesdays in the future? I'll see you. Thank you very much and thank you for your time. Jack, what's your email? Jack underscore Copeland 6863 at hotmail.com. You don't have a chamber.

10:33 I do, but I forget what, it's president at mammothlakeschamber.com. The most honorable and esteemed president. Thanks, Jack. Thanks, Jack. Are there any other public comments at this time? If not, then we will move on, close the public comments section and move on to business matters. The first item on the agenda is to consider approval of Vaughn's design review. The Vaughn's master sign.

11:04 Program and Minaret Mall Master Sign Plan Amendment. Jessica is our staff member. Good afternoon, Commissioners. Excuse me, my voice is a little scratchy today. The item before you this afternoon is for the Planning Commission to consider the proposed design review application 12-002, the proposed bonds master sign program, and the proposed amendment to the master sign program for the Minaret Village Mall.

11:31 The project proposes to remodel the exterior of the existing Vons grocery store and includes the installation of new signage for Vons and signage for the Starbucks and Vons Pharmacy, which are being relocated from inside the existing grocery store to a vacant space in the Minaret Mall. Additional improvements to the interior of the Minaret Mall are being provided by the applicant. However, these improvements only require building permits and are not being considered by the Commission today.

11:58 As outlined in the staff report, staff finds that the proposed project design is consistent with the general plan in the municipal code in terms of architecture and building design, landscaping and parking. The applicant has proposed a master sign program for the Vons grocery store, which is allowed under the code for a single tenant. The master sign program requests three exceptions to be made to the number of signs allowed and the size of the signs allowed, which the commission

12:24 has authority to grant based on specific site-specific conditions and design features including architectural style, building mass and site visibility. These master sign program exceptions are summarized on page 7 of the staff report. The applicant has also requested an amendment to the existing Minaret Mall master sign program to incorporate the proposed Vons Pharmacy and Starbucks signage. The applicant is here to

12:53 Give us a short presentation. And if you have any questions for me or the applicant after that, I'm happy to do so. In summary, the staff recommends to the Planning and Economic Development Commission choose option number one, which is to adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings.

13:15 Approve design review 12-002 with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Approve the Vons Master Sign Program with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. And approve the Minaret Mall Master Sign Program amendment with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. If it pleases the Commission, I think it might be good to hear from the applicant first and then take questions.

13:41 That's all right with everyone. We'll do that. Hopefully most of our questions will be answered by the applicant. But then we will go back to Jessica for questions and then the applicant. Thank you. Well, hello there. My name is Brian Bratton. I'm Vice President of Real Estate for Vaughn Safeway. I've met a couple of you before when I was first presenting the project in kind of a walk-around format.

14:06 I've got a few slides. You know, over the past 15 years that I've been with Safeway, I've been fortunate to be responsible for many stores and renovations in high-profile areas all across North America. Whether they were off the beaches of Vancouver, British Columbia, Kihei Maui, the California coast, PCH, or Lake Michigan, those high-traffic tourist-related areas are my personal favorite legacy projects.

14:35 The kind of things that I kind of want to leave behind as I reach the twilight part of my career. Included in these analogues are three situations that are analogous to Mammoth, two of which I was personally responsible for the redevelopment of. The first one here is in South Lake Tahoe.

15:02 The second one is Kings Beach, and the last one, I've got the might of order here, the one before was Kings Beach, and this is Lake Tahoe, Bend, Oregon. You know, this is great examples of how we can build projects that match and enhance the natural environment. As a matter of fact, in one of these, we actually took the columns right there, there's the columns on either side there, and we carved

15:30 Totem poles, or had the native population carve totem poles into the columns. You know, and that kind of, you know, two years ago I had the good fortune, I've only been in Southern California a few number of years, and then two years ago I had the good fortune, I'm an avid skier, and to come here for my first time, and this is what I saw. You know, I believe two and a half million visitors per year come here from all across the globe.

15:59 And these are the images that they take back with them as being representative of not only Mammoth, a large shopping center of Mammoth, but also, of course, of our grocery chain. This is a store whose exterior has not been touched since the property was opened in 1989, 23 years ago. It's kind of a bit of an understatement that it's dated and fully depreciated. With the enthusiastic support we've received from the city and the assistance from our design team, we want to change that.

16:29 This represents what can be done in the future, and I've broken the slide down to give you a better representation. The colors, of course, on renderings, it's very difficult to see, but basically, obviously, we have to match the existing center, even though this is basically two-thirds of the center when it's complete, and it'll flow up into the second level, which is the Vaughan's Pharmacy and Starbucks, which was discussed by the previous gentleman.

16:56 Included in these changes, however, we want to do some other things, and some of the things that not necessarily you would normally get involved with, but I want you to know about it anyways. For example, the landscaped areas in front of our store, and I'm being very generous in that description. We would like to install irrigation, kind of a novel idea, and a dry rock riverbed with metal sculptures of fish to illustrate that Mammoth is a year-round resort.

17:26 It's our idea to give some CPR to the mall area, try to bring it back to life by creating an atmosphere. Having Starbucks and our pharmacy in this area will bring the much needed traffic that will not only assist all of the mall tenants, but would give a certain sense of vibrancy to the area. Adding a seating area that you can see that we've modified one of the planters there. Improved lighting and graphics, which will tie our store and the mall together.

17:56 including utilizing the existing windows which you see at the back of the old facility that was there. We'll relocate them from that large wall and take them over here and you can see in the windows where we would have some video presentations and things and public notices, etc. for those people that are meandering over to the movie theaters. I'm almost done here but lastly we wanted to

18:24 Do something to further bind the two areas together to give some synergy to tie where we're expanding to and also our existing store. And you can see in the background there an area where we're going to put in some images. And we've done this in some other areas recently that really got a lot of accolades from the public, and that was to really showcase Mammoth.

18:47 On the large wall, and also on the large wall, which is the corridor, and there's the wall down below, and there's the corridor that's existing right now, we're going to do some interesting things there. First of all, we're going to increase the height of the wall on the left-hand side so that the snow, when it's piled up there, won't break through and hurt somebody. We're going to double glaze the windows. We'll put some heating in there. We'll actually create an atmosphere and some great lighting. And then on the right-hand side of it, we'll do some images.

19:17 I've personally spent some time with some local artists and shops here in Mammoth, and we like to involve them. And these are some examples of some of the images that will show up in these areas. And as you can see, there was an area for about 10 images, and they're approximately 36 by 40 or 30 by 40 in size. You guys will recognize that lake. I apologize, I do not.

19:42 I do recognize that one, only because it says it on the bottom, Lake Marion. This is, of course, is the old Mammoth Lodge, you know, working with the Historical Society, and these are the rope toes, which I'm old enough to remember how many pairs of gloves per year I would go through using those things. And then, of course, I don't have a date for this picture, but obviously it's Mammoth and it's timeless.

20:07 And I'll close with that. We look forward to the staff report. Actually, I was going to give this before the staff report, so after the staff report. I thank the staff for giving such a great report, and I thank you in advance for your support.

20:21 Our goal is to have this project started and completed in the relatively slack time between ski and summer season, so there is a very short window to be able to do that, and obviously it's a great time for the local population in terms of employment and activity and things like that that obviously construction like this generates. And with that, I'll leave it with you, and thank you very much. Thank you. Does any of the commission have any questions for staff, first of all, regarding this?

20:53 Jessica, we used to get these in a larger format, and this is such a huge project. I mean, even with my glasses on, even with the magnifying glass, I have trouble seeing it, so I don't know why we didn't get a larger format. Yeah, okay. Yeah, sorry about that. Any questions? No? Okay.

21:22 Go ahead. Jessica, there's reference made to man-made materials being used. What my concern is, is the rock that is being used, is this a man-made product or is this a natural product?

21:47 The architect might be able to help clarify, but I believe that it is made, it's a veneer, but the veneer itself is made out of sandstone, so it's, I think it's natural-ish. I don't think that it's actual rocks, I think that the rocks are formed by some process where they use sandstone to form the rocks. Does that make sense? Is the architect here? Yeah.

22:16 Am I correct? Yes, please, if you could address that. I'm Paige Winkler with MCG Architecture. To answer the question, yes, the rocks are on the tower elements are not natural rocks, they are prefabricated stone, but the rocks within the dry beds and so on are natural. How high off the ground is that rock beneath your start?

22:53 I don't know that we've looked at that detail. I'm going to go as low as we possibly can, obviously. That's the goal. One of the problems and why I would bring this up, one of the problems that we have here in the Mammoth area is when the man-made rock product is used, it deteriorates very quickly when it goes up against snowblowers and things of that nature and snow removal equipment. There's actually some...

23:23 One particular situation, I guess, is over at the Shiloh Inn, and that was put in with a faux rock. Although it may have looked good going in, it certainly did not hold up, and they continue to have, you know, major problems with that. And especially in the area.

23:51 Commissioner Elizabeth Tenney was mentioning and that is the lower to the ground is more vulnerable. Having said that, we've seen this problem approached with using just cement or brick which neither one of those really solve the issue either. So I think in placement

24:21 And how you may protect these so that the beauty of what you're doing lasts for some period of time, I think needs a lot of consideration. Well, what I could do is I can go back to our manufacturer and talk to them about the situation and see if there are some, but I do understand that when you're talking about faux stone, if it chips off, you get through the finish and you get to the natural concrete. Possibly if it's constructed in such a way that...

24:50 Those vulnerable areas could be partitioned to where a section could be removed and replaced and brought it back to a new look rather than having to make the decision to tear off the hole.

25:09 Tear down the whole structure. What we could do is we could look at the process for removal of the equipment that actually gets close to those locations and see what type of restrictions and barriers, whether it's a deeper concrete base that keeps them from hitting the stone or other solutions and then talking to the manufacturer. We can do that and just note that as a concern and we'll address that in our details and present. Very good. Any other questions?

25:35 I did have another question, and it may come up at a later time here, but I wanted to at least bring it to the surface. Have either of you gentlemen shopped in the store in the middle of winter during a storm and tried to get a shopping cart out to your car full of groceries?

26:01 Okay, my thought in this area is that as long as all the hard work and the effort to do this remodel is going forward, it would be

26:30 I think very interesting to see some consideration as to how that particular problem may be addressed, be it with a temporary wind and snow barrier that could be erected just outside the doors, possibly a drive-through with the valet. To give you an idea how that might work, is you would have a shopper who would shop in the store.

26:59 Pay for their groceries. They would come out and give to a valet their shopping cart. They'd be given a ticket identifying their shopping cart. They would go to their car, drive back through this temporary port-a-cachere area that's protected, collect their groceries, and be off down the road. There's no simple solution to this problem, but I do believe...

27:30 Because of the fact that we have stores in so many other ski areas, obviously Tahoe, Colorado, it's Washington State, we must have had an approach with this problem before. It's something that I personally haven't thought about, but with the experience that's in our company, I'll definitely bring it up and see how we're dealing with it in other areas, because I appreciate what you're saying. I think it's an opportunity, and I hate lost opportunities. Thank you, I appreciate that.

27:59 Our meetings are streamed through Granicus and a lot of people watch them so we have to remember about going to the microphone so those comments aren't getting lost. Okay. While we're on the subject about the front of the store, I mean, the issue is, you know, your store is completely north facing.

28:24 The other issue is probably the only time you're in front of a Planning Commission at every single one of us shop at your store. So we have a lot of practical experience. And, you know, the staff is always great about offering, you know, assistance out to the car, but it's kind of a mountain thing. You would never actually ask for it. But it is very frustrating. So for somebody like myself, I can't push the cart to the car. I have to, like, pull it. So it is kind of an issue. And a lot of it has the fact to do being north-facing.

28:53 The other, I think, safety issue that I want to just really address, and it was in the report, but we have such a problem with the ingress-egress for the parking lot through Old Mammoth Road. It's a little bit like a chicken little situation right now, and I'm assuming from the report that has been corrected now, Jessica? Correct.

29:18 There will be a minor, the driveway itself will remain in the location that is existing. Okay. But the kind of awkward merging situation that exists right now will hopefully be remedied by kind of realigning one of the parking aisles and sort of streamlining the entrance of the vehicles and kind of pushing them towards just one drive aisle. It's, it's...

29:46 depicted a little bit better in Attachment 5. Okay. So it's kind of a test case. We're kind of hoping to make that work a little bit better. And then what happens to the Eastern Sierra Transit bus stop? Does that stay in the same area? No, that is being relocated somewhere on here. Oh, in the kind of the southwest corner.

30:15 Up against Old Mammoth Road, we've designated two parking spaces to stage those two buses. So it's generally in the same location, it's just moved a little bit farther to the west. Okay. And then my next question, can you expand a little bit on the time frames? Is this going to be like a phased renovation and what we are looking at as far as total cost, please?

30:44 I think that would be best for the applicant to discuss the phasing. I believe our goal was to get started right in the first part of April, just as the ski season starts to slow down, and hopefully it doesn't slow down, because I actually ski in that period of time, and then to finish up before Memorial Day. And your second question was? Oh, the total cost of your reservation? I believe I'm at about $4.5 million, but I'd have to...

31:18 I'd have to confirm that. I think it's right in that number, that range. Thank you. And I'd just like to note the applicant does have to get building permits, so that's their next step. And as far as I recall, there wouldn't be any closures of the store. There's no closure of the Starbucks or the Vons pharmacy. It all kind of transitions at once. Yes, that's absolutely true. But the great thing about doing the relocation, the pharmacy, of course, we never want to close for a day.

31:46 For obvious reasons. And just because of the relocation, we'll be able to keep them open and just provide a brand new facility for both of those departments. Any questions? Just a kind of quick question on that scene. I mean, I know it's kind of out of our purvey what you guys do on the interior, but when you are doing that interior remodel, are there going to be certain areas of the store that are kind of closed for reconstruction, or how is that going to phase through?

32:17 You know, there'll be very few that'll be totally closed. I mean, what I mean by that is an area of the department would be closed, but we would still facilitate the sale of the merchandise, because we're used to doing that in areas such as pharmacies, I'm sorry, the delicatessens and the bakeries. In this case, those production, high production areas, there aren't a lot of changes, with the exception of more of the merchandising area of the

32:46 Delicatessen as a result of relocating the Starbucks away from that entrance, which makes it difficult, as you all know, to get into the deli. Any other questions? Yes. This is one of the first chance I've had to see the plans for what you're going to do. The design subcommittee had the tour of the site with over there and over there, but I do have some questions about this. Number one has to do with these tower features.

33:17 Considering how long and horizontal this building is, the towers seem potentially puny. Did you consider making maybe the top third, can only be out and bigger so they're more dominant? They really are puny. Is that ever a consideration? Yeah.

33:38 The towers actually are the same towers that are out there right now, basically clad in stone rather than brick. I'm talking about just enlarging the top of them to make them a little more dominant profile.

34:12 I'm just like Dave, I always think about lost opportunities. And so you're, again right now, as far as keeping the elements that are in place, we're just taking what's there and bring them out without to widen them. I think they're right now, they are slender because that's what they are as existing. If you start adding heights to them, then they're going to start looking very out of proportion. So is it your thought to widen them? Is that what you're looking at?

34:43 Well, I'm just thinking, I mean, you bulked them up a little bit, and just, I mean, I'm not a designer or an architect or anything like that, but if you even took the top third and cantilevered it out a foot and maybe took it up a couple more, just to bulk it up a little bit, is there just a teeny considering the profile? Well, my question is just, did you consider that? What we did is we tried to utilize as much of the existing structure of the building as we could, obviously, for...

35:11 obvious reasons of that. And so we hadn't really gone into anything beyond widening those or lengthening those towers. We did want to save them in place, and that's kind of what the proportions of them look like. I don't see them as being too narrow, per se. Yes, if we were to design them from scratch, I might have added a little bulk, but I think if you look at the towers right now,

35:40 They don't look too small and I don't think they're going to get the feel that maybe you're seeing right now. I understand from the diagrams here that the sidewalk is going to be widened. That's right. Have you considered subsurface heating, either using wastewater or using electric is really expensive, but there are options because that will just be an ice rink the whole winter. Right.

36:06 I believe we are looking at some type of warming, heating of the underside of the cord. That's what I'm understanding. And I thought when we had our tour that there might be an opportunity for local artists to bid or come up with designs for the sculpture that would be in the garden. And then it looks like you've already decided what you want. Was there ever an opportunity for local artists to become involved in that project? Because I know there was interest. I know at least two artists locally who would have been interested in.

36:35 I forget how loud my voice can be. But in any case...

36:49 The main thing that we wanted to be representative of right now is to show what our plans are to do in terms of the actual manufacturer, in terms of exactly what that fish is going to look like or if how many of the fish, et cetera. We know, and that was kind of what we presented when we walked around. There's no real deviation from that. But in terms of who the artists are, who gets involved in the process, the local artists would, of course,

37:16 To the extent that they're capable and have the ability to do it, they, just like anybody else, will have the opportunity to bid to be involved in a project like that. I saw in your photo of the Safeway at South Lake Tahoe a pharmacy icon, you know, the Mortar and Pestle. I think it was the South Lake Tahoe store. Right. Have you considered something like that to go with the pharmacy? Icons are always nice, especially for European visitors.

37:46 Tim, I don't know exactly what we're doing there. There's what you're talking about? Yeah. That may be a little bit more than what we're planning in terms of how much size we have area. And Tim's nodding in agreement about, you know, how much in the master sign plan, how much area we had to work with. Oh, okay. Because we're, because the pharmacy is separated from the store, we're putting Vaughn's Pharmacy there. Typically the pharmacy, when it's on the store, has a mortar pestle.

38:16 It's all about square foot and working with staff. I have a number of comments, but I'll leave you to a list of questions right here. Are there any other questions at this time? I don't see that there's a way that it's written here that there's an option for public comment, but I certainly would want to hear from the public if anybody is at this time, if anyone has.

38:49 Anything they'd like to bring for consideration before the commission, before we actually start to deliberate things? I invite you to the podium at this time. If not, we'll close that portion of it as well, public comment. And so we will deliberate on what our options are here. There's a list of them. And I should make a recommendation. Anyone would like to go first?

39:18 This is comments? Okay. Yeah, this is comments. Okay, good. I'm not sure I understood correctly about the windows that are in the corridor that go up to the mall. Are those, that's a question, but then I have a comment. Are those windows going to be made shorter? In other words, more wood? Yes, it would be made more wood. It was a combination of getting reports from the staff and...

39:43 As I discussed when we walked around it, was to make them higher because for years the snow has been backed up against there, and I think the practice for the local management has been to put ugly pieces of plywood up against the building, so we kind of want to make it look nice. Okay, there's nothing colder than the back side of a snow bank, you know, when you're in a corridor. I'm concerned about Kinnekinig.

40:07 Which you chose as a ground cover, which is a lovely plant, but it's going to be a real trash magnet and a lot of breakage, I'm afraid, with the winter snow. So I don't know how successful that particular plant would be. It's very pretty and makes a nice ground cover, but that's a really tough spot for it to thrive. Whereas the wildflowers that get cut down, they'll come back just fine. We'll definitely take that into consideration. We're obviously working with experts associated with the landscaping. One of the things that was adamant was that we were going to use

40:36 Local vegetation that actually will grow here as opposed to planning stuff that works in Los Angeles but doesn't work at 8,000 feet. My other comments are about the inside, the interior, and that's not really our charge here, so I think in the interest of time, I'll, you know, that's all. Thank you. And again, I think you have my business card, but if you don't, I'll make sure I leave it with you. And if you have comments, I appreciate they aren't part of the Planning Commission's purvey per se today.

41:09 But if you have specific comments on the inside or ideas, suggestions, please call me. Oh, I would love a card. Yeah, that would be great. Okay. At this point, what we have to look at are options before we take some comments is option one will be to...

41:32 Adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings, approve design review with conditions as recommended by staff and modifications, approve the master sign program with conditions by staff or with modifications, and approve the Minaret Mall master sign program amendment with conditions, or option two, which is to not approve the design review, the master sign amendments.

42:02 And option one would approve the project with conditions as recommended. So with that being our charge there, the areas that we want to focus on, can we have some discussion between the commissioners this time? Elizabeth, I keep waiting for you to comment on the signs. On the signs? Yeah, because you're like our...

42:27 You know more about our sign. Wait until later. Okay. I have a lot to say on that. Is this later? Is it regarding this particular application here? No. Okay. No, it is. The master sign programs are part of this approval.

42:52 And I'm realizing right now that for some reason the Master Sign plan is not in your packet and it's supposed to be. Is that for the one for the Minaret Mall? It's for both. Okay. But, let's see, the conditions of approval for the Master Sign programs are included in the resolution. Right. But if you refer to, if you refer to

43:20 Does the applicant happen to have a copy of the Master Sign Program? No, I'm realizing it's not in the packet for some reason. So, let's see if I can figure this out. Is it from your summary on page 6? Yeah, page 6 has a summary. Basically, the Vons Master Sign Program would be a sign program just for the Vons Grocery Store, and it consists of

43:50 of three signs, two signs, sorry, the main bond sign, a small circular sign that says the signature cafe. If you look at your attachment three, which is just the overall exterior, it depicts the signage pretty well in there. It doesn't have the dimensions right now. I apologize. That was supposed to be included in your packet.

44:21 Where's the Starbucks sign and the logo? Where's that? The Starbucks sign and the logo is part of the Minaret Mall Master Sign Plan and it's over to the left above the entrance to the mall area. It's in green. It's in green. This thing? Yeah. And it's also on the big screen there. So for the Vons Master Sign Plan, the primary sign, sign number one, is the Vons sign that just says Vons. It's 67 square feet.

44:55 All of the signage is halo lit. So all of the signage lighting complies with the sign code. There is, as I said, the circular sign for the signature cafe that is above the left door. And then above the right door, there is no sign proposed at this time. So that wall will continue to be blank until

45:27 If the applicant wishes to bring forward a sign at a later date, we have a requirement in there for the maximum sign area for that sign, which would be, I believe, 16 square feet, if I can remember off the top of my head. And then the Minerat Mall Master Sign Plan, again, adds the Vons Pharmacy signage, the Starbucks Mermaid logo sign, and the Starbucks coffee sign.

45:54 The Vons Pharmacy sign is 13 and a half square feet tall and is halo lit. The Starbucks Mermaid logo sign is 9.4 square feet and that will have down directed and shielded lighting. And the Starbucks coffee sign is 16.1 square feet and is halo lit. Which sign is down directed? The Starbucks Mermaid logo sign, which will, it's going to go, correct.

46:26 Also, just to know, there's no, there's not a window near existing, but that's going to be added. So, the Starbucks, you know, I'm going to say a little bit here. And Jessica, while you're staying there, would you be so kind, so what's below the Minaret Cinema sign? This is an existing sign, I think, for tailwaggers. Oh, okay, tailwaggers, okay. So, and the master, just a question regarding the master sign plan for,

47:01 For the mall, that is still allowing for other businesses to have a marquee style, I mean a linear sign on the outside of that as well. Correct. And so they're all about the same size. Correct. The signs that are being proposed for the master sign plan amendment for Minaret Mall, the amendment is only for the signage for Starbucks and for the pharmacy. It doesn't apply to any of the other tenants at this time.

47:30 The mall owner has approved this or given his blessing for this amendment and if the owner would like to update other aspects of the existing master sign plan for the Minaret Mall, then they can certainly come forward if they'd like to do that in the future. Okay. Vicki, you asked for my opinion. I have, halo lit signs are permitted under our updated sign code.

48:00 And considering what bonds means to the community and our visitors, in a blizzard, I have no problem at all with these, you know, signs being halo lit because that's the destination. So I think it's well integrated, the whole thing. I'm fine with it. Okay. Any other questions at this time or maintain comments from the commission? Anyone want to go first? Well, first of all, I'd like to thank

48:38 Thank you very much for coming forward and investing in our community. I often refer to Vons as the center of our universe. If you lived here, you know why. Even if you shop at midnight, you often spend numerous hours chatting with everybody up and down the aisles. So it's a very key business to our community, and I'm really very delighted that the company is willing to invest.

49:05 In our town, we really believe in it, and it's a real compliment to us, and I'm very pleased that you came forward. Regarding our options, I have no problems with the SQL findings, I have no problems with the municipal code, I'm fine with the design review, and the master signed program for both the Vons and the Minaret Meet. I have no questions or... Okay. Okay. Colleen, do you have anything to add?

49:39 Not particularly. You know, I had the pleasure of already kind of going through a lot of this stuff, so I also am thrilled that you guys are investing in the community here. It's obviously a hub of activity for Mammoth, and it is dated, and this looks fantastic. So I appreciate the reinvestment in our community. I do think it would be an interesting thing to kind of mock up a little bit.

50:07 If you can come up with some sort of process like Commissioner Harvey was talking about with maybe some sort of valet of groceries, I think, I don't know that I've ever been to a grocery store that had that as an option, but I think it would be a nice value added for the guests here, and I think people would really enjoy that, and it would be an opportunity to up the service level. So I think that's something that would be interesting to spitball a little bit, but other than that, I'm fine with everything, and I'm looking forward to it.

50:36 To completion. I have been to such a market and it wasn't a Gelson's pavilions type market, it was just an ordinary supermarket in Reno and they had that where they had a conveyor belt and you just, there was somebody there to load your groceries in and it was wonderful. So that might be something to consider, that would be a real benefit for our guests. I'm fine with it, I'm very happy that you're doing this, thank you. Thank you.

51:09 As am I, I came here 23 years ago when you were new there. We all have not held up as well at this point. I actually, to Elizabeth's comments regarding the towers, looking at here with the proportions and the eyebrows that don't exist now that you're adding over those, I think that the proportion looks.

51:33 It looks pretty good. I'm very excited to see that. And I think with the front of it, you're going to have a lot of opportunities to do things that are required of, you know, service level that I think you have something that you're not locking yourself into. And if it becomes ballet groceries at the next service level, I'll sign up for that as well, as long as it doesn't affect my lettuce price.

51:56 And so I think that we're a long time coming in. Really appreciate the effort that you're taking in here. And I'm very pleased at your vision. It's hard to look at some of these things and see something other than what is there. And I think it's a great job that you've done so far. So with that, I will entertain a motion to a recommendation there from anybody on the commission. Somebody jump in there. No, I move that we...

52:33 We approve as recommended by staff. Option one. Option one. Option one. I'll second that. Yes. I second that. Any further discussion? Do we need a roll call on this? Sure. Why not? Okay. Let's do a roll call vote. Commissioner Harvey? Yes. Commissioner Harvey? Yes. Commissioner Argeny? Yes. Commissioner Argeny? Yes. Vice Chair Brown? Yes. Chair Dewey? Yes. Okay. Thank you.

53:05 Good luck hitting that elusive window there. We have best laid plans all the time. Thanks again. Appreciate it. Thank you. Next item on our agenda is we've had a variety of items, but there is one item. I think we're going to move item number six up to item two, which is the review of the proposed old Mammoth road jam.

53:32 2013 special event permit and determine if it falls within the definition of a special permit. At this time, though I'm not a direct participant with this, it has been stated that my particular business is part of this and just for clarity and no confusion, I will recuse myself from this and then turn over to the

54:00 Gabble over to the Vice Chair. Sandra, would you like to start with the staff report? Sure. Thank you. The item before you today is a request for an extension of the Old Mammoth Road Jam Special Event Permit. As you recall, the Planning Commission reviewed a 2012 Old Mammoth Road Jam Special Event Permit on November 14th, and at that time, you determined that it met the definition of a special event.

54:39 which is called out on page 136 of the packet. Basically the Planning Commission determined that it was an outdoor entertainment activity and that allowed staff to move forward and to issue the special event permit. At this time the applicant is requesting an extension to that special event permit to allow the exterior signage which is the large wall sign on the side of the building and an outdoor movie showing through the end of May 2013.

55:08 Other items that are related to the activity but we're issuing permits separately for, the applicant has proposed a rail jam on February 15th and 16th. It's a two-day rail jam event in the location just south of the Sierra Center Mall, and we're issuing that as a standard special event permit because it falls within our typical definitions.

55:33 The other item is the outdoor snow play area, which was part of the special event permit. The applicant would like to continue that outdoor snow play area through the end of the season, and we're processing that as an administrative permit, basically a temporary use permit to allow that separately. So those items aren't before the commission today for review. It's basically to review the request to have the outdoor video and

55:59 Sign and whether or not that meets the definition of a special event permit. And that concludes my presentation. I'm available for any questions you have. And I know the applicant is here and can maybe speak into more detail as to his event. Does anybody have any questions or clarifications of staff? Do you have any questions, clarification of staff? At this time, I'd like to know how many people in the audience would like to speak.

56:29 In favor of this and how many in the audience would like to speak opposed? So who's going to speak in favor? And who's going to, how many people would like to speak opposed? All right. So while we are always very, you know, willing and accommodating to hear everybody, we have really a very tight time frame today because there's a town council meeting that starts here in the suite at 5 o'clock.

56:58 So we are going to limit all comments to five minutes. So I really ask that you honor the timer when the timer goes off. And this is the only way we can really be fair to everybody here in the room. And so if the applicant would like to come forward and make his comments this time, you're welcome to do that. Thank you. My name is Phil Herzog. And I would ask if there's any comments from the commissioners. Does anybody have any comments? Nothing. Not this time.

57:39 Is there anybody else in the public that would like to speak in favor of this permit? Hi, Robin Stater from Sierra Design Studio. Just the overview of the snow park there I think was had really good public response and people who were visiting the town were active and enjoying the animation of that part of town. We heard

58:19 Quite a few comments on people who had been in the town for the holidays and who had come into the empty mall, basically, and had seen the movie, had gone on to the snow park, and basically everyone that I spoke to who was a non-vendor in town was really enjoying it and loved seeing the movie on the wall and the big posters, so I think.

58:49 It's something to take into consideration. Thank you. Thank you. At this time, we'll take comments to anybody that's opposed to the special permit being issued. Good afternoon, Planning Commission. My name's Tim Gallagher. I'm a 24-year resident of Mammoth Lakes. I've been working at Wave Rafe Snowboard Shop for 22 years. I'm a position I hold for the last 12 years as general manager. And, you know, one of the big reasons I work there is because of that and it's new classroom.

59:31 Steve's ethics are well regarded in the industry as someone who does what he says. He has deep-rooted relationships as a professional snowboarder and as a successful businessman. Number one, he pays his bills. I think it's a little bit disingenuous for Mr. Herzog to claim that his signage was to promote an event.

59:57 When we are being bombarded on the side of the building, you know, and in the newspapers, with company logos and the words, huge sale, you know, from what I understand, this clearly went against the agreement he had with the town. You know, Mammoth Lakes is a small town, and Main Street and Old Mammoth Road, as you know, are two of the major streets, the aesthetics alone of what Mr. Hurtzog has done all last summer, of course, and since the holidays devalues, I believe, our town and the surrounding businesses.

1:00:27 You know, I'm all for animation, but it should be done tastefully and, of course, with integrity, following the rules and an agreed-upon ordinance. You know, we're a small town. Business owners should act in good faith when conducting business in a small community. And then, based on my observation and involvement in retail business, Mr. Herzog's practices and conduct, you know, and continued disregard for ordinances.

1:00:54 That other owners abide by is nothing but bad faith business practice. In our sports, snowboarding and skiing, integrity and trust is huge. I ride with a lot of people and it's really important to me to know that either on the mountain or in the backcountry, my fellow riders have my back when it comes to digging me out of an avalanche or whatever.

1:01:21 As a bonus-based employee at WaveRave, you know, a big part of my income is based on bonuses, you know, how much did WaveRave lose because of these unfair practices? A hundred thousand dollars? A quarter of a million dollars? I don't know. But how much did I lose? You know, that affects me personally. So I asked the Planning Commission today to, you know, number one, deny the extension of the special event permit, and number two, to also penalize and fine Mr. Herzog.

1:01:49 As far as continued disregard of both the site ordinance and the special event permit. Thank you for listening. Thank you. Are there any other public comments at this time? Bruce Woodward, local architect. I don't really have a retail vested interest in this one way or the other, so I'm not going to speak too much to that. I think the presentation of this snow park and the lighting and such is atrocious. I think the lighting is glary. I've heard a lot of comments about how

1:02:33 Sort of hoped up it is. And I think a special event is a special event and is a short period and not a six month, five, six, seven, whatever. I mean, it becomes the year round. Why not do year round a special event? So I'm opposed to this. I think it's a really bad idea. So it's a bad precedent. Thanks. Thank you. Tom Cage. I'm not sure what it was.

1:03:09 So I don't know whether it's a special event or whether it was a big sale. I talked to some of the restaurant vendors that were there. None of them had anything positive to say as far as the turnout or dealings with the principals operating this. I don't know enough about snowboarding, but it didn't look safe to me with that short hill, and then it appeared that the kids came off a rail and they would end up in a hole.

1:03:37 Someone from Wave Rape can speak to that much more clearer than I can, but that concerned me. So if the commission allows this to continue, I would hope we make it as safe as possible for the kids that are out there in the snow park, if that's what is going to continue. And it just seemed like a conglomeration of miscellaneous things there with a lot of banners and a lot of lights.

1:04:06 To try to draw attention to a big sale. So hopefully the commission will get a better understanding of what a full winter of this is going to be and what kind of an event can be defined. Thank you. Hello, my name is Dakota Franklin. I'm a 10-year resident of town. I'm also an employee of Wavera Snowboard Shop. And I'm also, I think it's pretty distasteful, like my colleague Tim said, just the presentation.

1:04:46 I would really like to do a contest like this, but just driving by is just disappointing. It looks like somebody that sets something up really long. The rails don't have that good quality. It just doesn't, for the standard that our town has, I don't think it represents that level. It brings it down really well. Yeah, and I'd just like to agree with pretty much everything that you want to say. All right, my name is Steve Klassman. I'm the owner of WaveRave Snowboard Shop, and I think

1:05:28 Sure. Yeah.

1:05:57 Would I ask that you please just address the issues and not the applicant personally, please? Okay. Well, given the fact that I feel like the applicant is disingenuous with being forthcoming about what his intentions are, I believe that you guys should vote no in renewing this permit. I'm also going to say that, you know, there's a really interesting event that's going on at the

1:06:26 Ski and Snowboard Trade Show that we're all going to in about a week's time. It's a charity event. And it's a charity event that helps underprivileged kids get on the snow. And this event raises a lot of money for it. And I'm going to ask Mr. Herzog to be involved in this event. I'm sure you'd probably want to be involved.

1:06:47 Okay, but now this event, hold on, this is important. Wait, wait, wait, no, this is really important because this is a public meeting and we have to follow the rules of order. Okay, this is, this is a boxing event. No, no, no, this is a challenge. I am challenging Mr. Hurtzog to a boxing event in one week's time. Okay, thank you very much. Listen, excuse me, but really out of respect to your fellow commissioners, Mr. Clausen, can you stick to the issue at hand, please?

1:07:23 I think that what I'm doing is entirely appropriate. He has been a liar. Okay. I think of him as a thief now. And then... I'm sorry, you're out of order. This public comment period is over. So the organizers... Would you please sit down? Are there any other public comments? Before the applicant responds, is there any written comments that were submitted to this?

1:08:22 No. Okay. The applicant may respond. I'd like to explain to you a little bit about what went on from a positive side. We were able to generate through the process of ski and snowboard shows in San Diego, Los Angeles, and Las Vegas quite a few thousand email registrations which converted to visitors to Mammoth Lakes. We were able to quantify the benefits

1:09:04 of the program, established a new business, which we invested a million dollars worth of retail investment in an additional 10,000 square feet of retail space at the vacant Sierra Center Mall. That proved quite successful, which may be some of these gentlemen's problem, but we generated new business into town through active participation.

1:09:32 We saw 100,000 ski and snowboard enthusiasts, and we were able to bring a small percentage, but a developing percentage, thanks to John Urdi and his participation with us. We have a sign-approved plan at the Sierra Center Mall, if there was tenants there, that would call for 13 to 20 individualized signs lighted.

1:09:59 Where we now have been showing the video of ski and snowboard activity on the face, on the vacant face of the mall. We took down the lights, and of course, we have Paul Rudder and ourselves have the right to put all kinds of signage up there, which I don't think would be a good use of the space. We had very, as it was commented earlier, we had really positive response, and according to staff last week, there was no negative comments from anyone.

1:10:30 The only negative comments came from certain internal people questioning what was going on. And so if there's any points, negative points, I'm here to answer anything directly, but we had a successful event. The kids have a place to go when it's dark as opposed to what kids can get involved in elsewhere. And we have tried to provide a wholesome family environment and to continue it.

1:10:59 And it's been, for a first year event, relatively successful. We tried to meet the criteria of providing a family event and a sustainable business model, and we ended up investing an additional $1 million. Do my commissioners have any questions of the applicant? Just comments. Okay. The public comment period is now closed. We'll do commission deliberation. Commissioner Tenney, would you like to start? You take.

1:11:33 First off is a preamble. We had a consultant back in the 90s when we were trying to do, remember Mike Vance was here and we were trying to do a vision plan for Mammoth Lakes and what we wanted it to be and his name was Dennis Crabb and he said something which I wrote on a post-it and put on my computer monitor and he said the environment is your product. If you don't have it, you can't sell it and he was absolutely right. That's why I put this on the cover of our general plan because this is what guides us. This is why town council was so wise in 1992.

1:12:03 To declare an urban growth boundary. We didn't want to sprawl. We wanted to stick to the four square miles, have a village in the trees, and around us is all this spectacular scenery and surroundings where people can have phenomenal recreation. That's why we put in the general plan, the man-made shall not dominate the natural, the spectacular surroundings, because we realize how vital this is. I won't comment on...

1:12:31 I'll delay my comment on this specific application for a minute. Because of a change in the business climate in Mammoth, and in my 12 years on Planning Commission, I've not seen this before, but because of the proliferation of banners and trashy signs and all this kind of stuff, I think we need to revisit the sign code update that we recommended to Council back in April 2011 because the business climate has changed. We're just not playing the same game anymore, and what we're putting out there

1:13:00 It's not worthy of a destination resort. Visitors, they go on vacation to a place that's different from where they live, and we have become a just sort of trashy place in the mountains. I mean, we have some bright spots for sure, but the deterioration of the way our town looks troubles me greatly when I think of how much time staff and the planning commissioners spend on trying to get the best possible outcome, any permit that comes before us, any request.

1:13:30 We try and get the best possible outcome. We deliberate the details, not to be nitpicky, not to be, you know, obsessive or anything like that, but just to make sure that it's really going to turn out the way we want it to and it's going to be worthy of our surroundings. Now, with respect to the specific application, I was very hesitant about voting for this as a special event back in December when Mr. Hertzog came forward.

1:13:55 But I looked on it and I commented at the time, I see this as a pilot project. We'll just sort of see how it goes. I was here for the rail jam. I was not here over the Christmas holiday. But friends who were in town reported to me what their experiences were. And when I got back, I went to inside the mall and saw the sales room or whatever, the store frontage, the sale.

1:14:21 A young mother with four children commented to me how much she liked it because it was so well organized, it was easy to find with merchandise, and it was affordable because, you know, once a cast-off runs out of the hand-me-downs, you know, you really, if you've got a growing family and you're struggling in this economy, then you need all the help you can get. So that was a positive thing. In December, I commented that I really liked your murals, the photo murals that you had put in your store windows at Mammoth Outdoor Sports.

1:14:50 Because they represented with great photographs what we've got here. I mean, what people come to do. I was incredibly disappointed when the big mural went up and there were brands and logos all over it, which are illegal according to our sign code. I will quote, 17.040.050 brands, logos, product information.

1:15:14 Illegal on the outside of a building. And so that was a clear violation. Now people are taking advantage of the fact that the town is in such straits that we don't have a code compliance officer. We're trying to figure out how we're going to tackle that problem, but we're going to have to have cooperation and participation. You know, we're all in this together. People come to Mammoth. We can't have this internal conflict. Things have gotten so bad, to my way of thinking, that I think we need to reassess if banners will even be permitted.

1:15:43 Unless it's a special event. We need to reassess what we do about temporary signs because with a 90-day period of being able to hang up a temporary sign that's, you know, the entire season in the summer and about 60% of the season in the winter, that's not what we want. I mean, we've just got to get ready for our guests. We've got to look like we're ready to welcome them and they're coming to a place that is as special as our surroundings and that we work so hard to keep special. With respect to the snow play,

1:16:10 I don't see that as a special event. I see that as something that a business owner in Mammoth should do to give back to the community. That's just a given. I heard many complaints about the lighting at the rail jam and Tom Cage's comment about it being unsafe. I didn't understand how a rail jam works, so I thought, well, they'll figure it out. They must have nets or parachutes or something. I didn't know, but Tom does make a good point. I was concerned about that. I've been concerned.

1:16:37 Since last summer about the violation, you know, just flagrant disregard and disrespect for what we're trying to do with the banners that you have hung up on Main Street and you've hung up here. And even with a special event permit, you had more banners than were permitted, had to be asked to take them down. There were logos which are non-compliant on the big photo mural, which is a great photograph, and it looked really good there. In fact, it looks sort of bare now that it's gone. Then if it had just been a photo mural of the activity,

1:17:04 I could have been absolutely supportive, but this isn't what we should be doing. Now that we're so short on staff and we're now doing the work of four commissions, we have to be really sure that we don't get stuck down in the weeds and lose track of that big picture about why we're here, why we live here, why this economy, why our whole resort economy can work so well and how we can compete with our peer resorts. Not with LA strip malls, how we can compete with our peer resorts.

1:17:35 This summer didn't look that way. So I cannot support extending this as a special event. I think that the video screen should be part of a master sign plan. The idea of showing videos that don't include logos, don't include brands, that aren't advertising, but are sheer unadulterated fun, like your animated photo murals is what it would be. That could be part of a master sign plan. And I think that could be an asset and maybe something to look into. But I cannot support continuing this permit. Thank you.

1:18:05 Can I just clarify quickly? The snow park staff is actually processing that separately as part of an administrative permit. So that's not actually part of the special event permit that would continue through May 30th. That would just continue until the snow melts. So we were processing that separately and we will look into and condition the lighting and any other conditions that are needed.

1:18:28 We do require, they're required to have insurance for that, and in fact, they make everyone who uses that park area sign a waiver, so there are insurance requirements for that. Okay, I was just using that to contrast, you know, a short special event versus this long thing, which is really a sale, which had some good points, but had more bad points, and just trying to make my point. Thank you, Sandra. Commissioner Harvey. Well, first of all, I'd like to thank the staff for all of their hard work.

1:19:04 I'd like to thank the Commission for all the hard work that's been brought forward here. This all began some time ago when the Commission realized that banners and signage were being used without any adherence to the code whatsoever. And there was a process.

1:19:45 The process is painful sometimes and it takes a lot of time. The process we started with was to get this under control. We would basically have a workshop and from that workshop we would hear from the different merchants in town and see if in fact there were things that we could do to the signage ordinance to make it better here in town, to address the needs of our merchants.

1:20:17 here in town. So, you know, to the efforts of, through the efforts of staff, through the efforts of commission, we went down this road of figuring out how do we take something that is difficult at best and craft it so that in fact it serves the merchants in a better way, a more efficient way. And still,

1:20:54 We could retain our goals in the general plan. Well, it hasn't been easy, sitting as a commission member, and I'm sure the rest of the commission would agree with me, in dealing with this over and over again. The one thing that we continued to deal with was a particular individual not adhering to the code. Why this was done, I'm really not sure.

1:21:34 Was it done because we don't have a code enforcement officer? Is that going to solve our problems? Well, I would hope that it would. But as a town, financially, we're in some tough times. And we've got to figure out, how do we step out of the box and make things happen? So the commission was willing to do that. The result is very disheartening. I read through the background.

1:22:12 in the analysis that staff provided, and it just went after instant after instant after instant of non-adherence to the code. We can't do this. For whatever reasons, it doesn't matter. We just, we can't do this. We have rules and regulations in our town as well as other towns, and people abide by it, and that's how we keep civility.

1:22:53 There's also another element here that I'm looking at our commission and I'm looking at staff and I don't necessarily expect that any of these people would necessarily know the inner workings of Mr. Herzog's business or Tom Cage's business or Steve Clawson's business because we're not in that business but it seems that there's issues within the industry.

1:23:29 and the merchants that we have in this town that participate in that industry that are far bigger than all of us to the extent that people would choose not to adhere to the existing codes. I've got to give kudos to Commission and I've got to give kudos to staff for being willing to try to meet the needs of the merchants. For whatever reasons, we obviously weren't able to meet that.

1:24:11 At this point in time. Will we give up? I doubt it. We don't do that. We will need to move in another direction. We will need to figure out how we make this work in an equitable manner for everyone, all the merchants in town. I look at John Urdi. John, how many hours and hours and hours of work to bring people to Mammoth and to make things work.

1:24:52 What everyone has to understand is that this is not just one little piece over here or one little piece over there. It's how it all works together. John began to teach me that about a year and a half ago. And he had a vision. And the vision is that it all works together. When one individual starts to fragment that, then in fact the whole system breaks down. So I've pretty much said what I came to say today.

1:25:35 I'm not in favor of moving forward with extending any more permits. I think we have a lot of work in front of us so that this situation doesn't happen again. So I'll leave it at that. I can't look at this process as a special event at this time. And my recommendation to the Commission is that we study this and come up with a solution.

1:26:19 I think we need to take a long, hard look at how we approach this at the coming time. Thank you. For me, the difficulty is not in whether or not I'm willing to approve the continuation of the special event. That's an easy decision, and that would be a no for me. The difficult thing for me is exactly what I want to say. It's not my intent to continue to belabor this point. That is obviously pretty passionate among a lot of people.

1:26:53 The reality of the situation is I would love to add some animation to Old Mammoth Road. I think the idea of having a snow park is a good idea. I think the idea of having a movie screen that streams ski and snowboard films is also a fantastic idea. However, I think it was pretty clear when this special event permit came before us before that we were kind of going out on a limb and approving that.

1:27:25 And we were directly told that what we approved would be complied with, that the signage would comply with what we approved, and that was not the case. So I feel a little bit disappointed with that. It's been shown throughout this past event, which continues to linger, well past the allotted time frame,

1:27:54 that when given an inch Mr. Herzog wasn't able to just take that consideration and stay in compliance had to take it a mile so I'm a little bit disappointed on the way that that went forth it was obviously a facade for a mega sale that was cloaked as a special event

1:28:21 And I, in good conscience, can't approve any sort of extension of this event. It's already been lingering too long and signage needs to come down and I'm not willing to approve it moving forward. That's all I have to say. As a commission, we have a lot of work to do, a lot of really important work to do today, so I think really the best thing that we could do now as a commission is have a motion and a second. Sure. I move that we...

1:29:03 Determine the proposed Old Mammoth Road Jam 2013 activity does not meet the definition of a special event. Option two. Second. Option two. No, option two does not. Option two. I would second. Roll call. Commissioner Farney. No. Commissioner Harvey. No. Commissioner Tenney. Just a second. Just a second. I'm going to back up for a second.

1:29:40 Saying yes to option two. Yeah, the motion was that it does not meet. Yes. Okay. Okay. Yes. Commissioner Clayton. Yes. Vice Chair Brown. Yes. The agenda item's closed. Okay, we'll continue with our meeting on to the next item in the business matters, which is item number two in the packet, but it's actually item number three at this time, and that's the zoning code update workshop.

1:30:44 This portion is regarding lakes and streams, and Jessica, you are, again, our staff person on this. You're going to do it? Yes, I'm going to present this item. Okay. I'll save Jessica's voice. For you today is, in a workshop format, is a draft zoning code section regarding lake and stream setbacks. The current code...

1:31:13 includes standards for setbacks from lakes, streams, and other waterways of 50 feet, which are included in the residential, commercial, and industrial zoning sections. Staff was asked as part of the SGC grant-funded process to re-look at those standards, and in particular to determine if the standards were sufficiently protective of our water resources, our lakes and streams in town.

1:31:40 If the setback standards should be revisited, either enlarged or a different point of measurement defined. And staff looked at a number of our comparison codes and peer communities, places that have similarities to Mammoth Lakes to determine how our standards compare to those. And based on that review, have drafted some revised standards.

1:32:04 For lakes and stream setbacks, which would be included in the general standard for development, so it would affect all development that was adjacent to a water body. These standards would be in addition to any existing standards that also regulate development in the stream corridor around Mammoth Creek, the OSSC zone in particular, and also the restrictions that are associated with the FEMA floodplain and flooding requirements and setbacks that are associated with

1:32:31 Intend to be protective for properties looking in the floodplain. The major points are highlighted in the staff report, the items that are included in the revised standards. The major one, or the first of those is the setback measurement point. The current code really includes a definition that says it's a 50-foot setback from the bank of the stream, but doesn't really provide a very good definition of how you measure or identify that point.

1:32:59 And then looking at our comparison codes, most of them had a much more precise definition that used top of bank, which is a more technical definition, more commonly understood about what that actually means, which is really the topographical break to where usually the seasonal high flow of the stream occurs in a typical year, and then where the upland areas transition from that.

1:33:22 Because this seems to be a fairly standard and well-used definition, we have decided to include it in the draft code. The question was also asked about the width of the setback standard. Currently, it's 50 feet from that measurement point. We looked at our comparison codes and found that 50 feet was really very consistent with most of the other cities, the exceptions being in places that had a more, I'd say, more rural character, much larger parcels where

1:33:50 It was appropriate perhaps to have a larger setback because you could continue to accommodate some degree of development on those sites. As you know, and as shown in the attached diagram, most of the properties adjoining Mammoth Creek, with a few exceptions, are rather small, a quarter of an acre or less. And so with that in mind, and particularly the constraint that it would place on many of those parts to be able to build anything at all, that 50 feet remains a sufficiently protective standard.

1:34:18 The one major change that we did include was to allow for, in reviewing a project, if there were particular special circumstances, special conditions, if there were particularly a wide band of vegetation, if there were special status species or some sort of resource that seemed to be more important to protect.

1:34:38 Then in the review process, the review authority being either the director or the planning commission if it was a use permit item could request that a larger setback be required of that property. So it gives the council flexibility and ability to demand a larger setback generally to allow a balance between protections but also preserving development rights for properties that would be subject to the standards. The other items that we included in the code were

1:35:05 Really more well-defined standards for what you can do within the stream setback, understanding that we have trails adjacent to our streams and lakes. We may want to have, for example, a bench or some furniture to allow for the enjoyment of those public areas.

1:35:24 That we may need to have flood control structures, bridges, crossings, that sort of thing. And then also what happens in terms of landscaping in those creek corridors is very important. We've had in the past complaints about vegetation removal along the creek corridor. And so this would make it very clear that installing non-native vegetation, doing vegetation management that was not approved by, you know, part of an approved scheme to maintain or to maintain the health of the creek would not be acceptable. But it also allowed some reasonable

1:35:54 Projection or encroachment into those areas, for example, for candle-leavered structures that would not place footings or supports into the creek corridor itself. And finally, findings for the approval of a variance or adjustment to those stream setbacks have to stand before you have a particular constraint or particular physical circumstance that would suggest that a reduced setback should be approved to allow some reasonable development of the property.

1:36:19 We took this chapter to our zoning code committee, asking them, focusing really on the set of four questions that are included on pages 49 to 50 in your report. Those included questioning whether or not the top of bank was an appropriate definition, and the zoning code committee agreed that it was, recognizing that in some cases, particularly I think for one of the committee members brought up the

1:36:46 For lakes in particular, we have sort of an undulating shoreline or different, you might have a very different high water level from year to year, if it's a heavy snow year, heavy snow melt, that you might need to get the opinion of an engineer or some sort of professional to actually confirm that point of measurement, but nonetheless, it gives a much better, more precise definition. The zoning code committee also felt a 50 foot setback retaining that standard was.

1:37:13 Remained appropriate, including a provision that would offer that larger setback as I mentioned. And finally, the zoning code committee also agreed with the recommended standards for development within the pre-corridor as well. So with that, I would ask the commission if they have any questions or invite discussion of this chapter. Anyone have any questions about Ellen? Ellen, when you were working on the open space dune corridor overlay, did OSSC, got that right?

1:37:42 What were the requirements about what happens in the riparian area, the area right next to the creek? As far as the, it could be private property, including the creek, and yet in that overlay area, the private property owner couldn't impact the resources there without permit.

1:38:03 Is that correct? Because we did have that problem with that one condo project that, you know, trimmed back all the vegetation and the birds left, you know. That was a recommendation of the OSSC study was that there be some additional, additionally protective standards for those aspects of preserving that riparian vegetation. I mean, it's often a need to do some vegetation maintenance, you know, you're choked with weeds and bushes and so on, but that should really be done in a thoughtful way and obviously in that.

1:38:33 protects the creek resources rather than damaging them. So on page 50, the second bullet point, the zoning code committee's recommendation was requiring a larger setback where there were special circumstances such as the presence of sensitive environmental resources. How would that be determined? Would that be a case-by-case basis before the Planning Commission? I think it would be on a case-by-case basis. I think in particular when we were reviewing the Sherwin Hotel.

1:39:01 Project. That was a question that came up and whether or not that was that. And we received a comment letter related to that effect suggesting that actually there'd be a blanket, 100 foot larger setback for larger properties. And we felt that what we recommended is appropriate because we don't have the resources now to go and do that study and determine where all those things are. And so because of the OSSC overlay requires a use permit for anything other than a single family home.

1:39:28 For a larger project, for a project that may be more impactful, it would allow for that review to recur at the Planning Commission level and tentatively as part of the CEQA process. And in the past, we have required a biologist's opinion on...

1:39:44 On these things, is there something particular special here that's going on, is there a, is this willow fly patch or habitat for example, that's a protected resource. And then one last quick question, once the OSSC overlay was adopted, were the property owners in that overlay notified to, that they had to have a permit to

1:40:03 There has been no change to the OSSC. Trim vegetation or anything? The OSSC study does not change the regulations. They were really recommendations. So we're now translating some of those recommendations into these revised standards. Okay. The OSSC overlay has not been modified from, it's not proposed to be modified from how it's currently included in the zoning code. But are the property owners in that overlay aware of the fact that they shouldn't just go in and, you know, with a hedge trimmer?

1:40:31 Cut back all the willows. We haven't done that. Oh, I think that would be important. Yeah. Thank you. Thank you. Those are all my questions. Any other questions? Staff ones? Okay. Then you need from us the adoption of this, the options. This is a workshop item, but it looks like we've made for, we've made provisions for changing, you know.

1:41:04 What happens with erosion and things as well and still protecting these areas and I do agree with Elizabeth that we should probably just make that clear because it's been some time since we did that and change of ownership and those are one of the things especially with vast changes in climate from year to year so one year what may not even be necessary consideration can definitely rear its head in a couple years and somebody you know may

1:41:33 No, well, meaning it, uh, attack a cleaning project that we need, they need to have a little bit more consideration for us, so I think it'd be a good idea to get to the community and just an outreach, let them know, especially by the spring. Any other comment? Yes? I had problems all the way through with a 50-foot setback until I got to that bullet point about, you know, insensitive areas, and that's okay, that's good. Thank you. We can move on then to the second.

1:42:03 portion of this tree removal and protection. You're going to stay with this one, Ellen? Yes. You're on a roll. You're on a roll. The second zoning code workshop item is regarding standards for tree removal and protection. Trees are an extremely important aspect of our community. We have a lot of general plan policies that seek to protect our tree canopy, maintain the sense of village in the trees.

1:42:31 And because of that, the town does regulate tree removal through a permit process. That said, despite the fondness that we have for trees, it's remarkable perhaps how limited our tree protection standards are relative to many other communities that we were looking at in our comparison pose. And so the proposed revisions...

1:42:54 are really an effort to flesh out some of the regulations and some of the things that right now are really embodied through our tree permit removal process, to embed those into the code, to make it more clear what the penalties and the repercussions are of removing trees without permit while still allowing for reasonable tree removal under circumstances that should allow it.

1:43:22 As noted in the staff report, our current tree removal or tree protection standards are really confined to a single paragraph which is quoted in the staff report and which appears in our various zoning chapters and just has some basic standards including a requirement that any live tree over 6 inches of any type, meaning it could be a native tree, a non-native tree, a palm tree,

1:43:51 Or a red oak requires a permit. When this was previously brought to the Commission in a more limited format, really to make some minor revisions to this chapter, there was some discussion and a recommendation at the time from the Planning Commission that the standard be reduced from six inches to four to require a tree permit. And the rationale at that time, as I understand it, was really because

1:44:16 What's this?

1:44:46 6 inches, 4 inches. Just as an illustration of the difference in size, and looking at our comparison communities, really only the city of Aspen, which has probably the most stringent of all the communities we looked at, most protective standards, had a smaller standard that's 6 inches, and only for certain species of trees that they were particularly able to protect.

1:45:13 So it's a statutory recommendation actually to retain the existing 6-inch standard to allow pre-removal for below that without a permit. And at the same time, in the draft code, we have proposed a number of other measures which I think are much more protected and much more clear in the town's intent about how to protect trees. Those include...

1:45:37 Some additional clarification regarding construction-related tree removal, the requirements to submit a tree removal plan with a project that's proposing substantial tree removal, and that also includes more clear definition of how trees remaining on the sites are to be protected, and also the detail of the code I think goes, I won't quote in detail, but there's a number of things including fencing, distances from the drip lines.

1:46:05 Activities during construction that cannot occur in that vicinity, and so much more clear and protective of what happens with trees that are being protected during construction. The second aspect is mitigation for tree removal, and so we do require mitigation. There's some discretion on the part of the town to require additional mitigation of more than a one-to-one basis, and as recommended in the general plan,

1:46:35 There is an option for the town to require a valuation-based approach, which is to say, particularly where you have a very large specimen tree, like a 60-inch red oak or one of the great trees that we have in the community, that if that were removed, that the town could actually say, this tree is so special that we want you to...

1:46:58 Plant maybe more trees or to pay a larger fee that would allow for replacement tree planting based on that valuation. And that would be based on a recommendation from a professional. It's a pretty complicated process to value a tree. And so an outside resource would be required to make that valuation.

1:47:16 And similarly for violations, penalties for tree removals, currently we just issue citations similar to other citations, which I believe is a $100 fine for the first tree and sort of a ratcheting scale of punishment for removing more trees. And this would step that up to be more higher dollar value for tree removal of $1,000 per tree or a value-based fine.

1:47:45 for the instance that I mentioned, and no such percent for the fine to be less than $500 per tree. So this allows the town to really make its point to really come down hard on people when they can do remove trees and think that ignoring our permit report, it's not hard to get a tree removal permit in the town and we really want people to go through that process.

1:48:06 And those were really the discussion questions that we brought to the zoning code committee who agreed with the staff recommendation that six inches remain the minimum diameter for tree removal permit, that the exceptions, which we didn't go into detail on, but include, many of the things included our tree removal permit, including for construction purposes where the tree is interfering with a building, as a life safety hazard is interfering with utilities.

1:48:33 And we also added a provision that would allow for a public recreation facility, publicly accessible recreation facility, be it a golf course or a public park, that you may want to remove some trees just to the extent that they would enhance the enjoyment of that area and that would really be a finding for that permanent approval. And the zoning code committee also agreed with the recommendation regarding mitigation and penalties and in fact suggested that

1:49:01 Perhaps the fines suggested are not sufficient and maybe could be increased to, in fact, make more of a point and to further discourage illegal tree removal in town. So with that, I would welcome any additional comments or questions. Any other comments, questions? Comments. Are you ready for comments? Sure, additional questions. Okay.

1:49:28 This is something that's driven me nuts for 12 years since I've been on Planning Commission because of this one-to-one ratio and the three-gallon tree replaces a big tree. I mean, if we're supposed to be a village in the trees and this is sort of an amenity and a draw for our visitors, I think we have to be much more judicious and punitive when people go and limb up trees to improve the view both for them and of them.

1:49:54 I'm concerned about six inch diameter. I disagree with the zoning code committee on that. I think that's too big when you consider the standard forestry standard is diameter at breast height, which the California Department of Forestry labels four feet and the town said was four and a half feet. I don't know why there was that discrepancy. But you consider a trunk tapers, I mean, that's a big tree. That's a good sized tree and there might be other ways to be able to preserve the tree and yet improve fire safety.

1:50:23 All that sort of stuff, so I'm concerned about the size. I very much like what Aspen does. I do agree with the last bullet point about increasing the fines, and when Aspen says $38 per square inch, and you end up for $17,000 for a 24-inch tree, because, you know, everybody's got chainsaws and wood splitters, and that's really the noise you hear in the summer and the fall, and those trees can go down awful fast, and then it sort of oops.

1:50:53 I would like to see a much stronger fine and a replacement on a one-to-one basis and then a minimum tree size of three gallons. That's a stick. You know, that's not enough. And interesting, Mike Vance said, when they landscaped the village, I said, oh, Mike, they've over-planted. How are all those trees going to grow? And he says, oh, we always do that because the survival rate, you know, it's always problematic. And he said, we may lose half of them.

1:51:17 And actually the village landscaping really looks pretty good and I know they've lost quite a few trees so this one to one ratio is not enough. And then I would favor the aspen valuation and then I just have a few minor comments on language. We have a lot of blank pages in our packet. Here we go, page 75. C, number two, routine tree maintenance such as the trimming or thinning of branches.

1:51:46 I think we need to add some language there about limbing up for fire safety, but not to improve the view the way many people do. I also think we need to make the utilities aware of how important our trees are to us. In the corner of Minaret and Lake Mary Road, there is, no, excuse me, Canyon at Lake Mary Road, there is a specimen tree, just gorgeous tree.

1:52:09 And the utility company came through and they cut out the branches that were interfering with the lines and then they decided to cut the branches all the way around so it would be even. So what we have there is a laboratory bottle brush now. I mean, it just looks so stupid. And it was a specimen tree that would have been integrated into future development on that corner and that sort of thing cannot be permitted to continue. Number seven on that, I don't agree with six inches, is the proposed

1:52:35 Six inch minimum, I would actually go with four, possibly five. And the diameter of breast height, are we talking four and a half, or are we talking four? Because that is a discrepancy. Yeah, in our comparison research, it seemed that most of the comparison cities used four and a half feet. When we met with the zoning code committee, Mr. Harvey had pointed out that our

1:52:57 Our tree removal permit says four feet, so we can go with either one. Well, it does make a difference for what size tree you're taking out. You know, really, considering the taper of the trunk, you know, it really does make a difference. It sounds like you prefer four feet. Yeah, the forestry standard, that's what my preference would be. Are you getting all this? Oh, I'm talking really fast. Okay. Page 78, B3, talking about the tree drip line shall be maintained free.

1:53:24 I would like some language added to that saying including any sloping grade above the tree's drip line. If you had a sloping grade above the tree and you had, you know, toxic substances or whatever, it's going to drain right into the tree's root zone. So it would be outside the drip line, but if it's a sloping grade, do you understand what I'm saying? I mean, here's the tree and, you know, you know what I'm saying? A number of communities had a

1:53:51 Requirement of protecting 10 feet beyond the drip line. That's good. Because the roots go beyond that. I think our concern there was just that because we have so many heavily treed sites that it would be difficult to really, not that practical maybe. So many places do have a buffer. Well, I'm just concerned about drainage into the root zone from a slope outside the drip line. Then on page 5, line 3, I don't think minimum replacement tree size should be 3.

1:54:21 Gallons, that really is just a stick of the can. And I would favor the penalties under H. I would favor the Aspen precedent. I think that's an excellent one. Just to add, most of the cities, comparison cities, actually use a 15-gallon minimum tree size, which is pretty big, I think. You know, one of the problems with those, I mean, I really know a lot about trees. They are...

1:54:46 Take a long time to establish if they do establish, so 15 gallons isn't necessarily the answer, bald and burlap conifers in a 15 gallon, they don't actually come that way, but you know, bald and burlap, that's a possibility, but for a deciduous tree, sometimes it's hard to get it to, especially aspen, get it hard to establish, so I wouldn't request that large a tree, but 7 gallon or possibly 5 depending, it's actually better to do the diameter of the trunk and the size of the

1:55:14 Than the size of the can, because what the nurseries do to up the price is they stick sticks in big cans and what you're buying is dirt, you know, with a pencil in it. So, anyway. And just to note, I don't know where the $38 comes from. I just like the total.

1:55:36 Because $500 is nothing. I mean, look at all the people skiing with their big families this winter, you know, over the holidays, you know, $500 is nothing for a fine to take out a specimen tree. The way that we've tried to structure the penalty is to provide some flexibility for the town to require an arborist valuation, which could be more than what Aspen says or less.

1:56:05 We were trying to find a good balance of flexibility, but... Did you contact anybody in Aspen to see where that came from? I did not. That would be very interesting to know. We did look, do some research into the valuation methodology, hoping that there would be some simple formula that we could come up with to, you know, maybe come up with a dollar figure or something similar, and it's really complicated. You have to, there's all these factors a visit, you know, a...

1:56:33 We've got the condition of the tree and the location and the, you know, there's a bunch of different, you look at this thing, it's an equation that's, you know, two sentences long and really outside of our ability in this department, in the staff to do it. So we decided this was sort of a good compromise between allowing for that expert evaluation if necessary. Insurance companies do this when we lose.

1:56:55 Trees in there. They can't blow them down and so on. But then our urban growth boundary, I'm in favor of stronger fines, you know, to conserve what we have here. A lot of stuff to get off my chest today. I'm fired up. You're fired up. Anything else? Any other questions or discussions? I had some. Because of where I come from and

1:57:30 Thousand Oaks. I mean, nobody touches an oak tree. So I've always been amazed how lenient our policy is. But so then you start working on this zoning code update. And I'm really surprised that I haven't been in a traffic accident because all I do now is drive around looking at trees and the size of them, right? And then you look at some of these trees and you're going, oh, for God's sake, you really wouldn't want to have a permit to cut that ugly little thing down. So I do feel that four inches is too small.

1:57:57 But would you, how about a compromise in saying that we'd measure it at four feet, six inches, would that work? Well, it's still a pretty substantial tree. It depends on what's left on the lot. And there is the issue, as Ellen pointed out, of sustainability. Because you want the younger ones to come up as the bigger ones die off, and they do, you know. And the other thing I'm not 100% sure we talked about that we really addressed is, you know, the aspens are basically weeds.

1:58:26 So I don't, you know, I'm not, I'm not overly concerned about an aspirin tree necessarily. You guys, that's going to be the headline in the sheet? No, he's not here anymore. I can't believe you said that. Well, no, no, no, because, you know, aspens, you know, as the way they grow, the underground root system, they grow from what, basically as a growth, you know, so I mean, that's a lot different than a specimen tree, and I don't know if we really accounted for that. But I'm very,

1:58:55 Big proponent. I think our fine system needs to be very definitive so that somebody doesn't say, well, it's worth cutting down this tree. It's only going to cost me $1,000. I mean, whatever. Yeah, right. So. If I could add, one approach might be in a lot of cities doing this is to categorize different kinds of trees that they wish to be more protective of than others. Right. And as Mickey suggested, there might be certain less desirable species or non-day or that would

1:59:24 You know, it's okay to remove, if they're bigger, and like Aspen does, to say, if there's, you know, a particular set of tree species that we want to protect, that we make a more protective standard for those, and more lenient standard for other types, that might be a solution, although we have to come up with that list. Yeah, there's willows, and then there's fir trees, exactly. I think I lack the knowledge on trees of my fellow commissioners, but...

1:59:53 You know, only a couple of things struck me. I would support making more stringent finds for tree removal, certainly. I think part of the reason why Aspen has that smaller diameter restriction is because a lot of their trees are Aspens, which typically have, you know, a smaller diameter than most of the redwoods that we have in California. So I'm not sure that I have an issue with the six-inch diameter, but, you know, really,

2:00:20 I'm comfortable either way. The only thing I would like to see is more stringent finds for tree removal. So, pretty simple. That's all I got. I like Mickey's idea of categorizing the different types of trees and maybe having the standards vary. I mean, two or three categories, not infinite. Yeah, I think that makes sense. Well, at the risk of feeling your ire, Elizabeth, I know your passion for trees.

2:00:53 I'm fine with the six inch at rest height. You know, one of the things that we have to remember is that we're so fortunate to live in an area that is forested. That's true. If we were living in an area where we didn't have the forest that we have, I think I could become much more passionate, if you will, about the trees.

2:01:24 The idea that we give ourselves the ability to have an arborist or a forester guide us, I think is extremely important. There's so much that someone in which you know, someone that understands, truly understands trees can give us an insight that we may not have. The laddering of trees.

2:01:55 You've been cutting the limbs out? Yeah. I think it's terrible. But it's a fire. Oh, for fire, you have to do it. It's a fire requirement. But what happens is when the tree begins to get laddered, it continues to grow. And as it continues to grow, then the ladder goes higher and higher and higher. So we don't necessarily have from a large, mature tree that's been laddered.

2:02:25 We don't have that foliage at the bottom. The issue with utility companies cutting specimen trees, my assumption is that those specimen trees are on an easement and do we have any purview over the utility companies doing something like that? This is a canyon in Lake Mary Row, the tree I was distressed about. I would assume that we

2:02:57 We do, because it would be our right-of-way. Yeah. But, well, that's a good question. I believe generally SCE comes in for an encroachment permit to come and do work in the right-of-way to do trimming associated with the utility lines. And obviously they have a safety concern that, you know, the tree branches aren't knocking down the poles and the power lines. So I think there has to be some balance in there for them to be able to do that work, but obviously not.

2:03:23 Abandon and not to do more than they need to do to maintain the safety. Yeah. So anyway, generally I think you're certainly on the right track. You've done a lot of research. I'm very much in favor of the arborist or forester claws in there. Six inches, fine with me. Did I miss anything? I think that's good. I think you did.

2:03:55 Fairly in agreement, I think, because this is so broad, as it needs to be, when you're talking a couple of different types of species, which is evergreen versus a birch or an aspen or a water-based tree with a very shallow root system and a very wide drip line. And it's two different things there. So I'm in favor of leaving it at six inches, but definitely delineating.

2:04:25 The difference for the conifers because I think that's where the issue is. One of my areas concerning this is not as much agree that the fines need to be there but a little bit more protection because what we're actually getting into an area now is the reason there's issues with the SCEs because those trees were there.

2:04:53 And nobody thought that there would ever come a time that they'd have to deal with it, that, you know, the worlds would collide, but they do. And that's what a lot of our major specimen trees now, as we go through not only development projects, but street repairs, even deliveries in areas in larger trucks, and going over parking lots, they're damaging the root systems of the tree.

2:05:18 Maintaining maybe the building is going to be damaging these, and it's going to happen much more because these trees are getting really big in areas that they're too close to building of any type. And I think that as we, the arborist is, you know, come from our property that we lost four of our major, you know, the four trees that we were trying to save. And it was just that they had reached the limit of where,

2:05:48 We could protect them because even the delivery trucks driving over the asphalt, now they were in the path of the drip line and that was 20 feet away and it happened in a year. That can happen to us and how are we looking at protecting these areas? So definitely looking at stiffer penalties for removal. I didn't see anything in there. So if a tree like

2:06:16 Fall breaks and falls. Or is it requiring a permit to do that? I don't think it is, but it didn't say it's one of the exceptions. Including an exception to say a tree that's felled by an act of gods or a windstorm or a lightning bolt or something and you're just really out of removing it from your property, you don't require a permit for that. Okay. Yeah, and though that may be the same level as CE would have taken it down too, but at that point it's become a...

2:06:41 It's become a hazard to others. I was just curious about that other than that. The exceptions are listed on page 75 in section C. Okay. Because I just think that it's going to happen a lot more. And we see we had a lot more bark beetle infestation in one year around here. And your trees may be fine, but just protecting it there. So as long as our language is looking at...

2:07:12 You know, keeping up with protection. Yeah, trees that are infested with disease, we generally do require a tree permit for those because we need to make a determination as to whether or not that's true. That's true. So, but for, you know, the $10 tree permit, the planner will come out and do an inspection and say, yes, your tree is clearly dying. It's going to go. And take the neighbors with it. It is. You know, probably do. So, okay. I think it's great work on this. You know, I definitely would.

2:07:42 With Lisbeth on Stranger, but I am also looking for protection. We've experienced a few things in the last five years. We're obviously getting toward the threshold of our existing development is going to be affected by the trees. We want to protect them, but streets are really coming up, and there's a lot of the root system is affecting our right-of-ways and how we address that, and not just pave over it in every area.

2:08:12 So could I get a couple of just just clarifications as we move forward? It sounded like there was some support for having a distinction between different types of trees and potentially a smaller diameter for certain types of trees. Is that the case or are we just sticking with a six-inch standard? Well, you want deciduous versus conifers, for sure. Yeah, it's the root system. You know, the ones that have a deep root system is...

2:08:39 They're going to be affected a lot differently than once at a time. So could we have for the conifers the six inches and then a higher like 12, 18 for a deciduous tree? Or am I saying wrong? 12, 18 what? A different, so the question is, is do you want to establish a different minimum diameter that would require a tree removal permit for different species of trees?

2:09:09 And so if there are some trees that are more desirable, you'd want to have a smaller minimum diameter that requires a permit. If you don't care as much about other types of trees, then you could make it a higher minimum diameter, like 18 inches, that would reduce the number of permits that would come in for trees that the community may not feel that they need to be protected as stringently. Are you talking about an 18 inch evergreen?

2:09:37 Maybe I got the two mixed up, but the desirable versus the undesirable. Less desirable. Less desirable. It would certainly reduce staff time to not have to do a tree permit, process a tree permit for every single tree that's six inches. And how do we educate all about these things? This is part of the problem, is getting the word out, you know? See, my thought was,

2:10:07 that you would leave it at chest height, you leave it at six inches, but that if it was a tree that was on our desirable list, so our pine trees, evergreens, that then if it was cut down, maybe the fines would be higher, or the replacement would be a bigger tree.

2:10:38 Versus I think we're talking about two things maybe because the diameter at breast height is used for the determination of whether it needs a permit or not. Right. So if so but if you but if but like in if in the construction we said that

2:11:05 Don't we use the same measurements for construction and what they have to do as far as replacement? No, right now the replacement isn't based on the DVH. It's based on either a valuation or that could be one of the variables that determines the valuation.

2:11:28 Or it's based on the ratio of the replacement and the size. And the town frequently does not require, for example, if someone's building a single family home and needs to remove six or eight trees in order to build that house, typically does not require replacement plantings. It tends to be with larger projects. Mammoth View, for example, is doing a pretty substantial replanting because they're taking out a lot of trees on that property. So it's really at the discretion of the town as to whether or not that mitigation is required.

2:11:57 of the project. Which property is taking out a lot of trees? Now a few, just, you know, that's. Oh, now a few, yes. Right. So I think the question we're trying to get to is really, should we leave the standard as is really six inches for any tree, regardless of species, should a different standard be established that would require a permit for different types of trees, and if so, we need to know, you know, help to determine what those.

2:12:26 What those are. Is there a reason to? Like in Aspen, for example, they have four inches for coniferous trees and six inches for deciduous trees as a standard. For requirement of a permit. Yeah. That's the question. Chair, what would you think if the zoning code worked on this? I think that would be fine because, you know, seeing the two different standards there, I think...

2:12:49 There's, we're open to that there. I, to come back, and you know, in the interest of time, because I, this room is taken at four o'clock? Four and forty-five. Four and forty-five. Oh, they are, okay. Until five, okay. So make sure that there's on a code committee to maybe look at some options for distinguishing and perhaps. It would be useful to have the recommended tree list or plant list, because that's got all kinds of trees on it, so that would be a good reference to have handy. And did we come to any consensus about

2:13:17 valuation versus a one-to-one replacement with three-gallon trees? I think, I mean, I don't think there's a reason not to increase the minimum size for the replacement planting. Three is just a carryover from the old code. We can certainly increase it to five or seven, as you suggested, Commissioner Kenney. I think that's part of what we give back to the Senate Code Commission. So, right now, the replacement section,

2:13:46 Requires a minimum of 1 to 1 for a ratio, minimum replacement of 3 gallons, which we can increase, and then there is also a sentence in here that says replacement requirements may also be determined based on the valuation of the tree as determined by an RPF or an arborist.

2:14:08 That would be my preference. So there's one commission evaluation. To say you've removed six, you know, beautiful trees, large trees, specimen trees, you need to do something more significant in terms of mitigation for those. Okay. We can sense it with that. It's a workshop, but if you could, come on up. Hi, my name is Leigh Gosh. Have you guys mentioned about, like, in my backyard it's really thick, and there are some that are very weak.

2:14:41 And they grow like staircases. And they're trying to find the sun. But those need to be eliminated so we can give help to the bigger ones. So I want to make sure that that's in there, that people understand that. Yeah, fitting for the health of other, like, I think there's a clause that says to allow other more desirable trees to grow, in that case where they're really crowded together and the trees aren't growing well because there's too many of them too close together, too many saplings. Because I like the trees. It's just you've got to make them healthy for the other ones also.

2:15:09 And another thing was is I'd like to make sure that people that have homes, affordable housing, or even businesses leave more in the front. It seems like some businesses in affordable housing have just completely leveled their whole places and it's all building. I'd like to see more trees. I've loved how the mountain did theirs. Have you seen the affordable housing in Sierra Valley sites? They left all the trees in the front and it blends in really nice. I'd like to see more of that instead of leveling the whole lot on any lot in this town.

2:15:38 The thinning that Ellen's talking about lead, you'll also need to do that for fire. I mean, that's a real problem. So it's not just for the health of the trees. We didn't actually bring that to light with our...

2:15:57 The packet does include language that is what you're talking about. And we do typically review in the plan check or the permit process, you know, which trees are being proposed. That's why we require you to show which trees you're proposing to remove and we can ask. If we feel it's not necessary to remove a tree or to be protected, we will request that that should be launched. That actually happens in our, through the permit process of the project and a lot of it to the landscaping plan we've suggested.

2:16:24 Moving things around here to give it exactly what you're talking about. Good point. Thanks. And then we check it once it's final. We go out and do a site visit and make sure that the tree is... The loader didn't run over that tree, right? Got it. Absolutely. Thank you. The last item, Vin Oz, on the zoning code update, the workshop, mobile vendors. The item before you this afternoon is a discussion about...

2:16:52 The operation of mobile businesses both on public streets and on private property. The current municipal code prohibits mobile businesses from operating on town streets completely and in our discussions with the town attorney and our review of state law, we've determined that this is inconsistent and needs to be updated. Staff has drafted a code section addressing the operation of all types of mobile businesses including

2:17:21 businesses that sell food and other items, both non-motorized and motorized, perform services from a vehicle such as mobile detailing, those types of different mobile businesses. As discussed in the staff report at the state, the state allows local governments to impose regulations on these types of businesses in terms of regulating the time, place, and manner of the vending. However, the regulations

2:17:48 that are imposed must be based on legitimate public safety concerns only. Page 4 of the staff report outlines the key components of the draft code chapter, which include regulations regarding the permitting requirements, parking requirements, hours of operation, separation distances between vendors, and buffers from certain uses or certain things such as intersections, driveways, etc.

2:18:16 I should note that the state law prohibits any kind of mobile vending from occurring on a state highway, so that's important to keep in mind. The zoning code committee has reviewed the draft code, and in general, they felt that the code may be a bit too restrictive, particularly for businesses that, mobile businesses that may be able to provide a level of animation in the commercial zones separately from special events such as the farmer's market or an art show.

2:18:47 Likewise, the committee felt that it might be a good way to provide some additional economic development opportunities to existing restaurant businesses or other businesses who might be able to benefit from having a mobile component to their business. In conclusion, the commission should consider and provide direction to staff on the draft code section.

2:19:16 Jessica, I was really shocked about mobile vending operations aren't permitted within 10 feet of an existing business. I mean, is that state law, 10 feet? No, that's not state law. When we started drafting this chapter and looking at a lot of different example codes, as staff, we sort of started on the conservative side because we weren't really sure what the commission... Is 10 feet conservative?

2:19:45 You were saying 10 feet is conservative. I mean, I think it's dramatic. Yes, I mean, it is, well, conservative in terms of regulation, in terms of prohibiting the use from occurring within 10 feet. If you made that distance larger, then it wouldn't be as restrictive. That seems excessively close, even for...

2:20:11 Mobile vending operations that are an offshoot of the adjacent restaurant. I mean, it still just seems incredibly close. Just logistically, it just doesn't seem to work. I can't conceive of it. So you're saying that it should be... It's too close to my way of thinking, but give me an example about how it would work. You're speaking to the 10 feet from the entrance to the... Oh, yeah.

2:20:36 The balance we were trying to strike was, you know, obviously some reasonable regulations that would allow these businesses, because when you look at the complete set of restrictions which are, you know, 25 feet from a corner, from a crosswalk, from a, you know, there's a whole series of restrictions and when you start to actually think about how many places it would actually be for someone to park, it becomes a pretty small set of locations.

2:21:04 Some places do have a larger buffer requirement from other businesses and really with the intent that generally to avoid congregation or being too close with this and brick and mortar businesses. And obviously we're a congregation of pedestrians coming and you have a place where you have six food trucks in a row and you've got a thousand people there, it can create sidewalks, it can create safety issues.

2:21:34 That's the spirit with which most communities are regulating these businesses. Do you see something like this in the park and ride lot? I'm thinking of the vacant lot in Portland where they have hugely successful food trucks. It's like a fair almost and wonderful food.

2:21:53 Much of it from restaurants, some of it independent, but, you know, there it is all assembled in one place. It's sort of like a portable food court, you know. We thought about that and a lot of cities are doing this. They're saying, you know, you can park and they have quite restrictive requirements often on the public streets, but to compensate for that, they designate certain areas that where on certain times, certain days, you can have a congregation or pod of food trucks set up and bend.

2:22:21 And so, you know, the town could either treat that as a special event, to say we're having a, you know, a Wednesday night food truck night in Mammoth, or they could park on public property, private property, no more than two food trucks on a piece of private property if they wanted to do that with the commission of the owner. So it is done, cities are regulating this in different ways, it's clearly something that a lot of communities want and welcome, but it does need to be regulated to some degree.

2:22:52 Any other questions or comments? Comments, no questions. Go ahead. When kind of reading through this, there were four things that I highlighted. Personally, I'm in support of something like this. I think it's another avenue to add animation to the town and a possible source of revenue as well. But the four things that I highlighted, most of those were then

2:23:27 Talked about further on with the zoning code committee. The four things I had were the regulation of 100 feet separation between mobile vendors. That would obviously completely preclude what you're talking about doing a, you know, kind of a mobile truck bonanza, if you will, or, you know, area. Also, you know, among the same is delete the regulation limiting the number of mobile vendors allowed on one parcel.

2:24:00 I also think that talking about revising or deleting the regulation requiring mobile members to change every three hours and move at least 500 feet away, I think that's a little bit restrictive and silly, but the fourth one that I had highlighted that was actually the one that initially jumped out to me that I didn't see discussed further was prohibiting it between the hours of 10 p.m. and 8 a.m. To me,

2:24:27 And maybe the rest of the commission disagrees, but the thing that immediately jumps out at me when you're talking about mobile vending and food trucks and those kind of things is the potential to have late night food. And that's really limited currently in this town. I mean, the only place I can think of that you can get food after 10 p.m. would be like Pita Pit. And so when I envisioned thinking about changing this regulation,

2:24:54 You know, one of those hubs that I thought would be conducive to this type of business would be the village for kind of late night vending and people that are enjoying the bars and restaurants up there and that kind of stuff. And that regulation doesn't allow that at all. So when looking through this, I know this is something that we want to consider allowing. It just seems very restrictive that there's an area or a time or a place that this is going to actually be able to be facilitated.

2:25:24 That's kind of what I saw when reading through this. Those are good points. That's why we have young commissioners. They usually eat after 10 o'clock. Well, for example, at the university I went to, there was a mobile food vendor that used to come park on the frat quad, and he would not come until 10 p.m., and he wouldn't leave until 3 o'clock in the morning. Oh, my goodness.

2:25:57 That place was jam-packed every single night of the week with a line like I saw on the mountain over MLK. I mean, just that's what everybody wanted to do late night when they got done doing what they were doing is pick up some food. So that to me, I would say, is very restrictive of mobile vending. I mean, when I lived in Steamboat, they did allow this.

2:26:21 And the two times that mobile vending mostly occurred were during lunch hours on construction sites. You know, they would come by with like a burrito buggy or something to facilitate, you know, 100 people that are working on a construction site. And the other time that they would have it is up in Ski Time Square at the end of the night. And those are the two times that jump out to me as making sense to have mobile vending. And if we have a regulation that doesn't allow it between 10 p.m. and 8 a.m. that completely.

2:26:50 You know, precludes probably what a lot of these people would be thinking is their main revenue stream. Yeah, I would agree. One thing we could look at doing is either eliminating the hour restrictions altogether and looking at it on a case-by-case basis when someone applies for a permit, or we could have an hour restriction on operations that occur on public streets, but

2:27:20 On private property, we could have that looked at as part of the administrative permit for private property and have that be on a case-by-case basis. Because one thing you might want to think about is with public streets, they can't operate at all on Highway 203, but they can operate on any public street anywhere else as long as they're safely parked.

2:27:46 You could theoretically have mobile operations going on in Sierra Valley sites or anywhere, but they can't park on the street in wintertime. So there's a lot of nuances to this, but we could perhaps have a restriction, if you'd like, for operations on public streets, but have it be more case-by-case basis on private property with an admin permit. Yeah, I think to

2:28:14 I think to Colin's point, the market is going to drive what times that people are going to want to have this service. And I think if we put time restrictions in there, we're not helping ourselves any. Or the vendor. Or the customer. Part of what I was struggling is thinking about, and maybe we can just kind of discuss this, like areas where this would be.

2:28:46 Where this would make sense. And immediately what kind of jumped out to me, because I actually have some people that have spoken to me in the past about, you know, this is something they want to do. They want to start this business. And most of them talk about the fact that they think the spot to do it is up in the village late night. When you have to adhere to all the parking regulations, you know, which is part of this proposal is that

2:29:11 You know, these mobile vendors would have to adhere to parking regulations. That entire area up in the village is regulated as, what, 30-minute parking? Yeah, and that's, unfortunately, that's one of the state law requirements. Okay. They have to comply with the California Vehicle Code, and so, therefore, they have to be safely parked, whether that's in a striped parking space or just safely parked, you know, parallel on the side of the street.

2:29:42 But again, with the village, you can't do it on State Route 203 at all. So the only, if you were in the village area, you could do it on Canyon if you're safely parked. But there's not a lot of opportunity for parking. You couldn't do it on Minaret, though? That's a continuation of 203. Okay. Yeah. Well, I'm certainly in favor of moving forward with allowing this type of business, but...

2:30:11 I'm struggling with finding where it would fit in and how we allow it so that it's not completely out of hand but at the same time it's not over restrictive that it can't even be facilitated. I think because we talked a lot about this in committee because I was trying to envision after reading all these requirements where could you actually do it then it combined it with our road requirements in the winter, etc.

2:30:42 So there's not very many places that a mobile vendor could actually park the reality is in the winter. Someday I think it would be really great if there was a parcel that we allowed it because it's such a great venue to offset our expanding crowds at certain times of years. And in LA, those mobile vendors are really a popular thing. Everybody tweets where they are and the hot type of food and those kinds of things.

2:31:11 I think for the time being though we should just eliminate the 100 feet between allow more than one per parcel and eliminate the three hours and then I think take Jessica's suggestion about if it's a private parcel then it would be looked at in an administrative review way. Another option I think we could include language to this effect in the code is that

2:31:39 That would allow the town, if the town were to designate a certain area to say that here's a zone or a place where we want to encourage this specific type of use, that might allow for different standards to be applied to mobile vehicles operating within that approved zone or area. I think that would work. And that might solve some of the concern where the town would be able to, you know, obviously look at all the issues, deal with them, but then kind of provide a blanket set of modifications that were more reasonable and that encouraged.

2:32:08 I think that's absolutely the right direction to go in because the reality of the situation is it's a pretty heavily regulated parking environment in Mammoth and a lot of that is due to wintertime snowfall. So if there's some area that we can push to kind of be an area where this occurs, I think that's the best way to kind of allow this type of business to begin to start operating.

2:32:37 Have any of my fellow commissioners talked to business owners, restaurant owners who might be considered, who might consider doing this as an adjunct to their, you know, bricks and mortar business? I have not. I've only spoken to people that would like to do this as their primary business, but not. It's a lot more overhead for the existing restaurant owner. Sure. It would be interesting because I think in a lot of communities,

2:33:01 You know, the pattern has been for food trucks to come into a community for the brick-and-mortar restaurants to have an issue with it on the basis that it's competing with them, and so the city will then adopt either excessively stringent regulations that get challenged in court and then come back and revise them. And I think what we've heard from the Mazzoni Cook Committee is the feeling that this is likely to be a different situation. It's actually a business opportunity for brick-and-mortar restaurants to provide additional vending opportunities.

2:33:28 And we might not have the same issue. So it would be interesting to get that feedback from the restaurant owners and see just how they felt about a change like this. Is anybody troubled by the 10 feet from an existing business's entrance? Well, my thought on that was by the time you combined everything, it wouldn't be an issue? No, because it's not like, let's say 10 feet here, but it's not even, you're not even, you would, you, let's take all these businesses, you're out on the road. Mm-hmm.

2:33:59 So even if you were out, tell me where there's one business that's within 10 feet of the road. I mean, I couldn't figure out anything. Yeah, I was while we were talking, I was trying to think of an example and I couldn't think of one. Maybe salsas. One of the. That's a good example. One thing to keep in mind is that there, I think there have been other cities who have had a larger distance, larger buffer distance. You can't be 50 feet within a.

2:34:29 Within a building. And they have gotten challenged legally for that because it has to be based on public safety and not avoiding competition. These are very popular. And it's not just burritos either. And just for further reference, for food trucks in particular, as opposed to other types of mobile businesses, there are a lot.

2:35:03 More additional state restrictions. For example, you have to have a local commissary where you keep and store your food. So that presents an additional, I don't want to say burden, but an additional hurdle for

2:35:19 for food trucks to... Is that state law? Mm-hmm. Even if you have refrigeration, of course you have refrigeration in the truck, and that's not... Is it health and safety code requirement that there has to be a place where food is being prepared and stored when the vehicle's not in operation, I think that's the concern? And there's other, um, there's other regulations for food trucks in particular, I think, about moving every hour if they don't have a bathroom.

2:35:46 They have to be within a certain distance of a publicly accessible bathroom for their employees and their patrons. I remember reading some of those provisions and those to me lend themselves more as an extension of an existing business as opposed to just a business that's its own entity out of a vehicle because where are you going to find that space to store food?

2:36:11 Where are you going to find another business that's going to be okay with you coming in and using their facility, you know, those kind of things. So I think some of those state regulations actually lend it more to an extension of an existing business than otherwise. So is it staff's feeling that ours has been overly restrictive, not even allowing these type of businesses to find if there's a market or not, and coming into more of the state compliance would not...

2:36:43 open it up too much to where we're allowing infringement on other businesses, but I see these four items here by removing those and then seeing if the market will bear this type of business by removing the time restrictions and there's so many other regulations that are just inherent with it. It's like with the health code there, the separation between the number of vendors because we're looking at is

2:37:11 is the opportunity, especially in the summer, for several feelings of outdoor marketplace. So it's not just food, it is there are arts and crafts and other things that are we mobile vendors and there are places where we can gather to create more pedestrian and village feeling events here rather than forcing our guests to drive to everything.

2:37:38 And that's, you know, right now, I think it's set up to where you have to get in a car and drive to everything, and even with the connectivity of the mobility, I think this would help our new charter with mobility to allow certain businesses to cluster in areas at times that make sense. And then for the new market, any of you who've ever dealt with a guest arriving after 9 o'clock and trying to get them, you know, to eat?

2:38:08 It's not pretty. Right. And, you know, John's Pizza Works is pretty happy about that, and then the other one that's open late, and bonds, but it's, there is really a hole in the market, and if we can help anybody fulfill that, it's non-competitive with any place that's closed down and not serving food afterwards. So, I would see that those particular items, yeah, I see them as a little excessive and restrictive, those four. Sierra Center Mall, just love them up.

2:38:37 It's still a play area. Apparently, yeah. Okay. I think that gives us the feedback we need, so we'll make some interesting, I think, to address the separation and some of those points made in the political committee and confirm those with the committee as well. Okay. So, yeah, I just wanted to add that fourth one in looking at the hour restrictions in addition to the other three, which I think are spot on. Okay. Can we have one more item here?

2:39:09 On our business matters, and that's consider of approval, public art proposal to satisfy the public art requirement for new duplex. I think we can handle this for a short time longer. Thank you, Chair Dugan. I'll be brief. This item before you is before you because you are now acting as the Public Arts Commission. This is a public arts proposal for a new duplex that is going in on 200 Lupin Street.

2:39:40 We had an administrative design review approved by our design committee for this project, and they're now processing their building permit. The proposal to satisfy the public art fee of around $2,300, a little under that, is a ocean-themed oil painting, three feet by three feet, that would be located down at the breezeway at Wentmore Pool.

2:40:08 It would have a plexiglass covering to protect it during wind or rain or UV. It would be only displayed during the operating season of the pool. The artist, her name is Ursula Kuzpit. She has a fine arts degree. She lives in San Diego. She creates artwork for galleries and for her church and runs an art restoration business.

2:40:40 Painting a unique painting for Whitmore Pool would incorporate some of the shark mascot from the local swim team into the painting. Staff finds that the proposal meets, excuse me, meets the requirements for public art because it is valued at more than the required fee. It would be located in a location that's publicly accessible and the content of the painting would be appropriate to the pool being ocean themed.

2:41:10 Furthermore, the plexiglass would allow for the required permanence that the code requires. We reviewed this proposal with both the recreation manager and public works director and they're both supportive of the proposal. Therefore, staff recommends that the commission finds the proposal consistent with the public arts fee and program, which is municipal code 15.18, because the proposed artwork is of the appropriate quality, integrity and permanence.

2:41:38 And scale and content for the environment in which it relates and would be located in a publicly accessible place and approve the public art proposal to satisfy the public art requirement for this new duplex. Mr. Ed Hill couldn't be here today. He lives out of town and has a newborn baby. So hopefully I can answer the questions that you may have. And that concludes my presentation. Okay. Any questions of Jen? No, just a comment.

2:42:12 Okay, no questions. Comment? Elizabeth, do you want to go first? Well, what I'd like to see is a mural with sharks with those Olympic caps on, you know, and goggles, racing in the lanes. That would be the coolest thing in the world. But, you know, that's just what I'd like to see. We did talk about a mural, actually. Okay, I'm concerned about condensation behind the plexiglass, actually. That could really be a problem.

2:42:41 The problem with this, and I saw the color version that you emailed to us, is not the quality of the art or, you know, it shares the water theme with the pool, but there's no context. I mean, there are no mountains. And, of course, this is the ocean, but still it's the Pacific Rim and we do have mountains, you know, the Andes, Hawaii, volcanic activity, but it's just little flat islands with palm trees. And so it doesn't...

2:43:10 Fit the context. And I don't have to see, you know, Convict Lake with Mount Morrison behind it. I don't need to see that. But we've got to have some mountains in here. We've got to have some context that makes it go with mammoths, even if it's just part of the Pacific Rim. That's my thought. And these are all bottlenose dolphins. She's going to do sharks? Yes. Okay. Or maybe that's a really happy shark at the bottom, the one who's smiling with all the bottlenose dolphins. I don't know. He's about to eat.

2:43:41 Yeah, that's what I was thinking. I have a snack. But I got a real problem with the content in terms of fitting the context of Mammoth and Whitmore Pool. And she, I, um, she's, she's done a variety of natural landscapes, so I think including some mountain landscape into the painting would be totally appropriate and she could do that. Can't you see the sharks in those, those Olympic hats, you know, and goggles? It'd be so cool. I would love that. I wish I could paint it. I would, I would.

2:44:10 Submit of the other comments. I just have a general comment. I mean, and I'm fine with this because of the scope and the dollar amount, but in general, I don't think our public art should be down at Whitmore Pool. I mean, I think we should start with our public art in the center of town and when we're all public art out and they're sitting, you know, and Whitmore Pool probably would be like the last place we'd put.

2:44:39 Public Art. That's just a general comment, not specifically about this. Interesting idea. Go ahead. Dave? Both of my kids were Mammoth Sharks, and so many children here in Mammoth participate in this program, and so many parents wind up down at Whitmore Pool. So I think there'll be a strong representation of viewers, if you will, of

2:45:11 from the public at Whitmore. And I like Elizabeth's suggestion of getting it more in context with where we live. I think that's probably very doable. I don't know if this gentleman has children in the swim program or not. Not yet. But if, you know, he's having a baby, he might have someday.

2:45:42 Anyway, I'm fine with it. I think it's a gesture in the right direction. As Mickey said, it's a minimum investment. So there's not a whole lot that can be done with that for public. But I think this is a good idea. Just a point of clarification, this is just an example of the artist's work. This isn't the painting that we're talking about. She's being commissioned. Okay. Correct. Anything called?

2:46:14 Careful what you give us. We're going to go for it, aren't we? I have to agree, you know, yes, it meets the letter of the intent, but let's find something a little bit more in context. I'm sure they're quite creative. This just makes me want to be there, right? See if we can tie it together. That'd be great. Otherwise, I think yes. So if we still have time to give them input, I'd like to see what they come up with.

2:46:44 Really reflects our area. I think she'll be very receptive to the feedback. She's been very receptive to the feedback we've had so far, so I'm sure that is absolutely doable. Thanks. I think just a voice vote is fine. I expect to see it. I move we accept option one as recommended by staff. Second. Do we have discussion? With.

2:47:13 The proviso that it's the mammoth context and put some mountains in it somehow. That's my understanding. Okay, good. Less tropical, more mountain context. Thank you. Next, we have on there the consent agenda, the minutes of January 9th and also minutes of October 26, 2011. Good luck on that one. Anybody, anybody I trust, something will jump out that'll be.

2:47:44 Not worthy. Anyone want those items pulled or do I hear a motion to approve? I move we approve the minutes of, what was the date? January 9th. January 9th. 2013 and October 26, 2011. That's a consent. Do you want them both or do you want to pull one? No, that's fine. I move we approve those minutes. Second. Second. Aye. Aye. Aye. Okay, approve aye. So moved.

2:48:16 Commissioner reports in our next five minutes. Anyone have anything happen since our last meeting we need to share? Just remember the downtown working group meets Monday, 8.30. I hope you can be there. I'll be there on the calendar. Great. Participate, great. Director's report? Yeah, just very briefly, as Commissioner Brown mentioned, downtown working group meeting is scheduled for 8.30 on Friday in the county conference room.

2:48:46 We will be distributing the agenda for that, hopefully on Friday, and some good discussion topics regarding testing of our development standards, draft development standards, and how our consultant is doing some modeling, and it's pretty interesting, so we'll present that information.

2:49:04 I'm sorry, I didn't hear what the topic of that, or what that meeting is. So we've asked our consultants to. The Main Street consultants. The Main Street consultants. To look at our draft zone standards, the heights, the setbacks, and to look at some prototype sites and to actually kind of try and model those in real space to figure out if they're.

2:49:26 Feasible and to give us some feedback on those standards and just to, they're really just testing the standards. And that is a week from Friday? It's on Monday the 28th. Oh, the meeting that Vicky's talking about. I thought I heard Friday and I thought this is a separate meeting and I, okay. But I did want to make you aware in February, on February the 12th, we are having a workshop with the Planning Commission and our consultants are coming to Mammoth.

2:49:50 To have a really a public kickoff for the Main Street project and provide an update on the work of the downtown working group so far. That will probably start at 5 on the 12th, which is on a Tuesday. So it's February 12th at 5? Correct. I think most of you responded to Pam on your availability for that. And then we will be having the regular scheduled planning commission meeting on the 13th.

2:50:17 That meeting will include some additional zoning code items, the adult businesses ordinance, and also a matter regarding permitting medical marijuana grows in commercial zones. We received a proposal to do that and have the Planning Commission consider that. And any follow-ups? And then the final item I wanted to mention was over the last couple of weeks we've had a lot of

2:50:47 comments and inquiries about the sign, current sign, enforcement of the current sign code, the banners in particular. At the recommendation of the town manager, we're going to put together a little bit more information for the commission about the sort of staff resources we think it would take to do a more stepped-up code enforcement effort for signage.

2:51:08 Some of the legal issues associated with that and citations and give you some additional information and then ask the Planning Commission to make a recommendation as to whether or not that should be included as a higher priority item in our work program for this fiscal year. So we want to give the Commission that information to make that decision relative to our other work program items. So that will be on the 13th. Is the meeting on the 28th here?

2:51:36 The downtown working group meeting is in the town and county conference room, which is that room down near the county offices. I think that's all for me. Okay. Chair? Yes. Alan, following on what I said about signage and how we needed to revisit the sign code, there are four issues that I really think we need to revisit in light of the changed business climate. This is a dramatic change, you know, in the last year. That is not allowing banners at all.

2:52:08 Except for special events. Or across the street banners, you know, for like a town-wide special event. Temporary signs being, you have to have a plan for where the temporary sign is going to go and approving it in a much shorter length of time than 90 days, which is like the entire summer season. And not having numbers or prices on signs.

2:52:31 And also think again about master sign plans, like a business that wants to have more than one sign, in other words, the name of the business and then various products or services it has, that would require a master sign plan, not just multiple businesses. These are big issues that go along with the code enforcement and all the rest of it, and I'm just very concerned about how all our hard work is just going down the tubes. So would the Planning Commission like to agendize for future meeting?

2:53:00 Discussion of some of the sign issues that Elizabeth, or that Christian Tenney suggested? I would 100%. Oh, thank you. I just don't know that you can do that for the third time. You can probably do it the second.

2:53:12 I'm just interested in doing this before the zoning code update is adopted. I mean, I don't think we can adopt it without it. Thank you, Brenda. But couldn't we, but Elizabeth, couldn't you present it as an amendment to the zoning code and like basically then we, is that what you're saying, like in a month and then we'd come and do it as a workshop, something like we did today?

2:53:40 We could, except there's some language, I mean, I've been through this sign thing from April 2011, and there's a bunch of stuff that we just didn't realize.

2:53:49 Okay. What could happen? Right. And now we've seen what could happen, and we need to revisit this. I think we have a few other things, for example, regarding the mobile businesses, we'll need to update our vehicle, signage on vehicles, restrictions, and there's a few other things I think that we have. We can make it easy, but then we need to go back. And this also relates to outdoor sales, because that's all about signage, and, you know, there have been suggestions that we have, like.

2:54:14 Two or three weekends a year where the whole town's on sale and you have pop-ups and pennants and flags and, you know, it's a real festive atmosphere. It would be like Macy's after Christmas sale. Everybody would come here because we'd become famous for it. And that's been a suggestion from several businessmen. So is that something we're interested in doing? And that's all part and parcel of this. It's just what our town, you know, the image we're presenting to our visitors, and it's not to be, quote, fancy or, you know, excessively restricted. It's just we want to show how special this place is.

2:54:43 And it just isn't happening right now. So we will, I just den-dize for that, the first Planning Commission meeting in March. Wonderful. That's great. That's all for me. Okay. Thank you. If there's nothing else, we will adjourn to our scheduling meeting on February 13th. Workshop on 12th and this meeting, regular meeting. Yeah, I was going to say that, but I think I got it backwards. Thank you. Appreciate it.