Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013
Parks & Recreation Commission Special meeting
· recording 2 hr 26 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
250 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
25:30 There's a lot of the projects we've done, are done, delivered to the town, a lot of these things have already been taken care of. Yeah, understood. Okay. Yeah, and I wasn't suggesting anyone start from scratch. No, no, I'm just suggesting we need to get off our backsides and get some informational pieces out there in the public for obvious reasons. Okay, well, just so if you want me to, if I hear things, I'll just raise my hand maybe. Yeah, yeah. Okay. I have a follow-up question for John then. Uh-huh. So, John, you're suggesting that if the, uh,
26:03 Forest Service and the town were to move forward on updating the winter trail use map and the summer trail use map that they go to the standards that are in Section 600 and use them as a formatting base instead of going to the existing maps and trying to update them and revise them in finer detail. So it's a wholesale changeover.
26:31 From the existing winter and summer use maps to the standards that you're referring to. Yes, I would suggest that because think of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System as an attraction, as a branded thing that people coming from all over the world to visit, engage with, and the look and feel across all media should be the same. And you have all the tools. When you're holding a physical map in your hand and you're looking at the trailhead, they are one and the same. Exactly right.
27:00 And you have all the tools that are needed for the graphic designer or whatever will be doing that work. All those tools exist down to the RGB color specs and fonts and everything. It's all ready to go. So your organization also did all the GIS data gathering, waypoints, trails, access points. Are they both in a format where you can marry one with the other, where you can pull trails and access points across?
27:29 And it will format itself in that? Well, you need the web. We built the website so that you could do that. If you're doing a paper map, you'd need to work with a specialized graphics person who'd know how to do that. But it can be done. John, one final follow-up then. I thought I heard somewhere in the conversation that this section 600 may or may not be adopted. We delivered the draft.
28:00 Working closely with the Town Public Works Department, it is ready to go through the process for updating. We delivered that several months ago. The process for adoption. Excuse me? The process for adoption. Yeah, I don't know what the process is, but we delivered them to... But you're saying it's ready to adopt it? Yes, as far as I know. It's ready to go through the Town's formal process to adopt it. But a lot of those guidelines are already here in the mastermind. Well, actually, when you go through the process of taking the guidelines that are in the plan,
28:28 and you actually literally implement them, a lot of things happen along the way, such that, like the Type II Trailhead signs, the R money paid to have those signs built, a civil engineer looked at the specs that came out of the town, and the bolts got a lot thicker, a lot of little details have changed. All of the most current information is in that Section 600. Basically, Section 600 takes this information and turns it into...
28:57 Engineering specs that they can get to a designer. That's correct. So it's now anybody can theoretically come in and get those specs and replicate. You have the same things anywhere throughout the system. Okay. So if we're going to move ahead with moving stuff out of this plan and onto the lists that have been made. I guess maybe I'd like to clarify something because we're talking about, you know, the standards and everything else.
29:34 What are we trying to do here? Because I guess that's what I pulled out of here is that we need seasonal trail maps. Right. So how those seasonal trail maps are done and what they look like are still to be determined, this is just pulling out what we should be doing and then we prioritize these. I guess that's what I was looking at because if we start getting into the minutia of every single thing here, we're never going to get through it. I agree.
30:02 And I'm even looking at some of this now, and there's other things that I could put in here to clarify some of these things, but this was very high level and just kind of, you know, I guess that's what I was looking at, is that if this is the priority, then we get into minutiae as to what that is, and then if there's more, if there's three different things within that one area, then we decide within that, are we doing all three, are we doing just one?
30:28 I guess that's what... I agree with you, Teri. I thought we were just going to make sure that we're all on the same page when it comes to this document. I don't know that we're going to be prioritizing. No, that's not what I'm saying right now. What we need to do today, it seems to me, is we need to go through primarily the executive summary and the general recommendations in here and lay them out as zero to two, zero to two, three to five, and long-term projects.
30:58 As we call them out, get them laid over into this document that we've done with RecStrats that we haven't done. You girls have done with RecStrats and the Parks Master Plan. So that all of the Master Plan, so that all the plans and the priorities that you see right now end up here. And then at the end of the exercise, we go through this long list.
31:23 and prioritize the whole darn thing as to what projects we're going to try to tackle in the next X. Because it's a short-term project here, it doesn't mean we're going to have the wherewithal, maybe the fields, let's see where it's a short-term, maybe the field house is more important, but we won't make that decision today. We just need to get it on the list so we're looking at all the potential. Right, but with respect to the trails, the MLT-FCC, which three of you are part of,
31:54 You already have your bucket list, so you'll be able to let us know, the non-committee members, you know, because maybe you've already talked about this in your meetings, and you already kind of have a focus on where maybe trail maps for all seasons is like in your first bucket, and we're not as familiar with it. Yeah, I didn't think about that. We probably should have brought it. Do you have a list of our bucket list?
32:22 and what we have on it, that's probably a good idea. Don't have it with me. From my standpoint, when we made that bucket list, we were under such a tight deadline to try and get something off the ground for that summer that there's a whole bunch of stuff that was missed and mishandled and haven't been happy with that process. So it's an important asset.
32:46 But as an MLTSCC, we need to go back and readdress all of those things, and that's only my opinion. I'm in agreement. It was, you know, that was one of those things we just bucketed everything. But actually, this is frankly giving me more direction on the MLTSCC than frankly I think we did last year. So, you know, even though this is obviously a guiding document, I'm not saying that I didn't review it as much as I think what's coming out of here is something that we'll really...
33:13 Play, we need to be maybe expressing to the MLTSCC, and again, three of us are here, so. Well, it's probably a document that continues to evolve, so it's, you know. It is. I mean, this, the bucket list was set up so that we kind of knew what the immediate priorities were, and with the, with the goal, which I work out there to go, but with the goal of actually being able to get some things done last time, a few words, a lot more. But,
33:42 Really, this is to help focus this on what are the specific tasks we want to accomplish in the next fiscal year. If we go through, you know, I spent some time with the general recommendations in the executive summary, but also over there on page 112, it goes into much more detail. And, you know, there's a couple things there that, like I want to ask, recommendation number G11 suggests a trail coordinator. Is that what Steve is doing?
34:13 That would be my cape on it right now. Right. So I guess what I even want to throw out there is that we can even go through some of these recommendations and kind of update where we are with them because if the trail coordinator is done, question mark, you know, it's not that I want to check it off the list, but I at least want to update the status of it. I kind of did that informally myself. I did too.
34:42 So it might be best to kind of look at that as maybe the low-hanging fruit or at least the things that we've already started the ball on, and that would apply to both MLTSCC as well as this commission, what we've got done, and then take a look at that, you know, moving the other balls downfield. Mr. Chairman? If I could, maybe help with you guys, I've prepared all the projects that we've worked on in the contract.
35:13 If you wanted to go to Chapter 4 while C getting this document, I can just go through each one of those things like advising what it needs to be more important than the status quo. It's basically that. You gave this to us on the 5th. Yeah, if you need to, and I just can walk you through those things. By the way, I want to say just for the record that I thought that your document on the summary of partnered efforts with dates was very helpful for me since I hadn't been on this commission that long and how far I went back. It was nice to present in our...
35:42 This was on the package. That's why I don't have them. I need copies of those, John, if you've got them. Sure. Thank you, as I have not seen them. Would you probably just walk through on the order in which they show up here and determine the status? I have the recommendations starting on page 112. That's fine. Yeah.
36:10 And that was actually one of the questions that I had about where it is the status of our updated trail maps. The first one was on 4.1 of 8.12. The naming conventions. The naming conventions have been done. Yeah. So is that, well, the leaded protocol to do it has been done, but actual naming all the... Well, the protocol is in there, yeah. Right. Let me say, yeah, everybody's named. If I could, Chair,
36:52 All of the naming conventions on all of the maps that you see, which covers everything in the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, Forest Service, the town, MLTPA worked very hard to develop a standard set of naming conventions for all of that stuff. It's been delivered to the town. The protocols are in place should something, if something's fallen through the cracks, it has to be renamed. But everything is there. It's been delivered to the town. It can be used for the Municipal Signage and Wayfinding Program. It should be.
37:19 Because all of those naming conventions are on the maps, they're on the signs, they're on the website. So that effort has been as complete as it needs to be for now, there may be some future things, but that is one of those things that you can check off your list and say that it's done. Okay, that was going to be my question, is can we consider this done, 100%, at least for now, as of today, because at any point, if we did have a question with regard to what do we call this, at least someone can get us an answer.
37:49 There are lists that we developed. We had to develop exhaustive lists for the website and for the mapping. All those lists exist. If there's some destination, certainly there's no trail or no facility that doesn't have a name, but if there's some question, there's a process that was set up to have things named. This was reviewed, I think, by the Planning Commission or else by the Recreation Commission several years ago. So the list of all these names has already been done and been through a process. Can we mark that as done? The naming convention? Yes. Yes. Okay.
38:28 Next would be the updated trail maps, which isn't done. I would just, again, I would say that the updated trail maps has been done in the sense that per the trail system master plan, all the standards have been established by which any new map would be made. Certainly the website already articulates a Mammoth Lakes Trail System map, as does every one of the type 2 trailhead kiosks. There is a mapping system in place.
38:59 For anything associated with the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, and for any media. I'm actually going to disagree, John, because reading this, it says the maps need to be produced. Right. So it's been done in part and not done in part. So standards are done, but the actual maps are not. The actual maps have not been done. Some of the maps on the website are done. Are done, yeah. And some of them. But the paper maps. Well, and it also makes sense that they need to be updated annually any time new facilities are added. So in theory, it will never be done. Well, right now, if you come to Mammoth,
39:28 And you are a mountain bike rider. There is not a comprehensive mountain bike map that is going to show you the available roads and trails that are being used by locals as the trail system. There is a great trail system out there that isn't even marked. So a map needs to get down to the level of having, you know, IM-13 road.
39:51 and the forest which creates this particular trail because the trail itself isn't called out yet. In your deliberation, in the website, every one of those activities that are on the website, the website certainly needs to get up and running and get engaged with, but for every activity, for a mountain biking activity, every legal mountain biking route can be articulated on that website instantaneously. So I think this issue about paper maps, while they're important, they have a place to play in all this,
40:20 But if you're going to be waiting to have paper maps updated, which might take two, three, four, five years sometimes, that website, the activities, the mapping can be done within a matter of weeks. Yeah, and I understand that. Right. The question becomes right here, you know, your paper maps are called out, and they're called out for by most of our user groups and the surveys as well. Maybe technology has passed to the point where the majority of people are going to use it instead.
40:49 From my standpoint, I certainly see the need to develop, which is going to take a year or two, we need to get off the stick and get it done, to develop some paper maps. But I think the description in the book has been done in part and not done in part. Right. Yes. In terms of status, I think that's what we do. I agree. And on the fairness tracking committee list, you have it as a project, anticipated project for this facility.
41:17 This was a priority that we did identify in the MLTSCC, that we need to be getting these. We just have to be getting the maps to the public. I think, John, what you said is that if I want to find the maps, I can go online and search and it's there somewhere. But what we need to be doing is effectively communicating this to tourists and locals alike. Yes, wayfinding is partly education.
41:46 Well, and it's not just wayfinding. It's also a huge part of a marketing tool. Well, as much as I want to propose solutions here, that's not our job today. No. And I think that what we need to be doing here is just identifying this as a priority.
42:04 And there's a question there as far as, you know, what should we be identifying as priorities versus just identifying them. I think it just needs to go. I'm just looking at identifying them right now. That's the MLTSCC to take all of this. Well, it's going to be our job at the end to take this and prioritize all of this. But when it comes to the trails specifically, that's MLTSCC. And I think that we need to then, once we identify all this,
42:30 Have what you guys from MLTSCC, number one, have prioritized, and then go from there. And if we see something else that maybe as a rec commission, we say, hey, this really should be added, and what do you guys think? There's no person not wearing two hats at this ticket. Yeah. You know, like committee member not wearing two hats. I'm taking input, and what I'm hearing is, you want paper maps. And that was one of the first questions that came up, as well as the status of the building. So,
43:00 And it might be something that maybe is phased out or isn't as large a priority once we actually, the website is actually up running. It's something that we're educating our, you know, citizens and our guests.
43:25 That this is where they can go to do this, which is what we should be doing. But right now, I mean, there's always going to be a need for paper maps no matter what. But anyhow.
43:44 You know, and I want to make sure that we're not limiting ourselves only to paper because I think the technology is, I just want to be clear. Absolutely. It needs to be useful on your phone, your tablet, your computer, and paper that you can shove in your back pocket too. Yeah. At your present walking pace, you will achieve Shadow Lake and have, just to say, GPS navigation for bikes and walking is probably right around the corner.
44:13 I use it already, actually. I know, in your car, but... No, no. Oh, yeah. Very good. Okay. All right. See, I'm behind the times. Where's my paper mat? And we're not making recommendations here, but, you know, again, I just want to point out that that's almost something that I can see. Sponsorships, or at least businesses, even being able to... I remember Tony Calasardo saying that they used to produce...
44:40 Bike Maps because no one else was doing it, just on a private basis. And, you know, I hope it doesn't take years or even months. You know, again, looking at what Stu Brown accomplished with regard to our programming and what the Recreation Department does on an annual basis for our municipal programming, I hope that some of these maps are things that we can turn around biannually for summer and for winter based on the current status of the maps.
45:08 I think one thing we did, one of the projects we did was working with the Westin in terms of delivering, using electronic means, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System to the public. And one of the things that the website can do is it's very easy to integrate that into every point of contact you can think of and to customize it.
45:32 To that point of contact. The other thing is the website, you can't print paper maps from the website. So if you're at a business and someone wants to say, Tony Colisado's got his favorite little running routes in Shady Rest, through a partnership program, you can set it up so the businesses can print those maps for their consumers right there at their point of sale and point of contact. I think, again, paper maps are great. They're expensive. And to put a paper map together that's going to be able to articulate all these various activities is going to be a challenge.
46:00 One certainly probably worth doing, but I think that we haven't even begun to exploit the opportunities with the website, with technology, with partner programs, and I think it would be interesting to see, for you guys to see what kinds of things that thing can really deliver. You may need to scale your paper map production needs. There may be a way to find some opportunities there. Okay, so how do you want to deal with this then? Do you want to go through each one of these recommendations?
46:29 And then wait for MLTSCC to send back their prioritized list? Or do you want to add these to our already existing list? What you said you were going to do is go through them all and then what the status is before you come back. So let's go through them. Trail maps is part done, part not done. Uniform trail signage. The information's there. I mean, it's going to be an ongoing project. John pointed out earlier.
47:08 The standards now are there. They haven't all been formally adopted, but they're there to be applied, and some of the signs are in place. Some of them are, yeah, but that's an ongoing. The only part of the trail signage program that's missing is the soft surface trail signage program. That's on the MLTSCC list, but all the other sign types as identified in Chapter 5 are in that update to the public show standards. So the answer here is partly and ongoing.
47:39 I think it's important to note that the trail with the soft surface still needs to be completed. Yeah, and actually, Bill, I'd like to be more specific, though, is that let's actually be specific to the point that everything is completed except the soft surface trail signage. Standards. Is that correct? Yes, standards have been established for all that. Once those are done, can we say this is this?
48:00 Recommendation G3 is completed. It's semantic, but you can say you'd have the standards for everything, and then the implementation program is going to be a question for you guys to deal with. For example, the two proposed OSV staging areas on the scenic loop where the town theoretically is applying for Measure R money, those are nodes. Those are classic nodes as defined by the Trail System Master Plan. Those are opportunities coming forward. It would probably make a lot of sense to put Mammoth Lakes Trail System signage in those places.
48:28 You have all the standards to do it, how to name it, how to do all the work, but it's going to be the implementation of the signage system and the maintenance of it over the long term that's going to be an ongoing process. And I think, unfortunately, to answer your question, Sean, is this is another one that's going to be ongoing. We can maybe be able to check off what the standards have done, and at some point we might actually be able to say, hey, we've got all the signs in place, but the next year there's going to be a new trail or signs are going to...
48:54 There's going to be an ongoing component to this related to maintenance. Okay. That reminds me, I have a question. The signs, were the 90-some signs installed? I remember they were completed about a year and a half ago. I think so. I think so. I thought we held them because summer was over last summer and they were supposed to go up this spring and we never got a report. Any question maybe John can answer?
49:24 Are you afraid of the ARA signs, Pat? There were like 90-some signs. Yeah, there was a... They were ready, but then they were... ARA, and then we funded some for the town. Correct. There was... Right now, in terms of your signage implementation program, you're up to phase four. Phase one was a prototype in Mammoth Creek Park. Phase two were some signs on the lake space and path. Phase... And include all the ARA signs, and that has all been done. There's a phase three, which the town did, and we did some work on.
49:53 Those signs have been installed as well. All the signs that have been specceded, have been advised were to be installed have all been installed. So now you have to face for it. Okay, recommended G4 interpretive signing. I think that's the same thing. It's the same thing, yeah. So you're going to have to prioritize where that goes. You should note that the interpretive manual, the handbook, has been done. Again, interpretive signage is going to be an ongoing. Yeah.
50:29 Can we get any status on? Because they give specifics here. Yeah. Or at least one example. If I could, just one thing on the interpretive. The work that we did, the opportunities that came up, in the trails plan itself, it talks about interpretive signage, but it talks about a larger interpretive program. The actual specs for sign is pretty straightforward, and those have already been included in this dangerous manner. It's pretty straightforward what those things are.
50:56 How the interpretive program is going to develop, how the use of technology is going to be integrated into that, who your partners are going to be with that between the Forest Service and ECEA. You've already got, as Bill mentioned, you've got a very good first draft on interpretive program, but when you hear, when the trail system management refers to signage, that actually is the one place where the entire interpretive program lives within that element, and it's all going to grow out of that thing within the plan. So this is always ongoing? Always ongoing. Signage.
51:25 Always adding in more. And not that we're choosing priorities here. That's a priority. And I think where technology plays a very significant role in this is that you have to, fine, you'll put some signs out on the ground, but the degree to which you're delivering interpreting experiences through the QR code system and through the back end, you have the ability to deliver unique and varying interpretive experiences without necessarily having to putting in.
51:52 Infrastructure and hardware into the ground that you have to pull out and change. That's a trend with all kinds of scientific wayfinding programs going forward, and I think you guys are very well set up to take advantage of that and develop that going forward. But the partnership with the Forest Service on this, because this is something very important to them and with ESEA, is going to be a very important component of the success of this program. But for our purposes today, it's ongoing. It's ongoing as of today. Okay. Trail-oriented development.
52:31 And I really don't know. I put some exclamation points here just because in reading what trail-oriented development is, especially in this town that is supposed to be feet first and isn't on a lot of dangerous corners in my opinion, this is something that I would like to see more of a priority. And it actually comes up in the beginning in the executive summary, you know, and Terry, you made
53:02 Your number one comment here about sidewalks. Are we trails or sidewalks? Are they sidewalks? What I got out of this, this is what that means. What I got out of this thing that says trails equal their sidewalks, their bike facilities, their paved trails, saw surface trails, foot trails, there was foot trails or foot trail through Snow Creek and on the street. I'm not sure what on the street meant, whether that was...
53:30 Bike Lanes or, you know, that type of thing. So I would assume that meant bike lanes. But that's just kind of what I pulled out of here is what it said trails are. So if sidewalks are not part of trails, then it goes in here. It's in here and it goes so far as to tell us what our ratio of all trails, muffs, sidewalks.
53:58 And other trails should be per mile of road. It gives them some specifics. I'm not sure I agree with them, but I'm not going to go back into trying to change the plan at this point. Well, and I guess that was going to be just kind of one of my questions as far as in interpreting this, I think that this is a question we're going to need to really proactively answer. And Steve, I hear what you're saying, I guess from a technical standpoint, that a sidewalk is not a trail. And, you know, I hear that.
54:25 from a technical standpoint. But again, in this town, it doesn't have that good of sidewalks. I feel like we're going to need to address this before. I pulled that out of the existing trail system right there. Well, this is something I wanted to bring up, too, because it makes it very clear in a lot of places that sidewalk maintenance, at least.
54:50 Can, you know, recreational trails funding should not be used for sidewalk maintenance purposes. So I think it's slightly more than a technicality. But one thing that I did want to point out is that I think it's in June that we have the joint workshop with the Planning Commission. And I think it would be great to bring up some of these mobility issues now that mobility is their purview because, you know, sidewalks and especially sidewalk clearing and, you know, all the things with the crossings I think are really key. And I think where the sidewalk importance of being a trail is.
55:20 If there's an existing sidewalk that accesses a neighborhood, probably we're not going to build a mob next to it doing the same thing. It makes no sense. There's a path there already that can be used for that. If it's a bike lane that's required, we'll go down that road. But I think that's what we look at, and the same thing, and it calls it out. If there's already an existing mob going beside a road, for instance, on Joaquin,
55:46 Probably the need for a sidewalk there is diminished. You wouldn't put a sidewalk in. You've already got them up there. It lets you count them up. Right. So as far as the trail-oriented development, and you don't hear me say this very often, I really think that that is a section of this plan that is a planning department function and not a recreation department function.
56:10 And it probably should be left to them. With regard to sidewalk sites, we've had a technical thing, which once again goes back to, typically that lives in public works arena. It integrates with us because we want people to learn to walk from there, wherever they are to the trail. So we need to know how to connect. But quite often, it's just purely financial, but rather than...
56:37 Recreation Funds to pay for the sidewalk. There are other sources of funding, more traditional sources of street and public facility funding. So recognizing that they're not totally separate, but they're not totally the same. And then with regard to the transportation or trail area development, that's going to be an ongoing thing. I don't think we leave it, but recognizing that the opportunities that come up with that.
57:08 Mostly could be the IOC major planning documents where policies are established or through applications for new development where they have to get implemented. Which is what it calls out here. It should be in the neighborhood district planning process and other planning documents, not... We should all be watching that. Yes. You know, and that's where I pulled out of the development. I kind of put them all together is provide connections to adjacent paths, mobility, pedestrian, bike, acquire easements.
57:38 And so that, I don't know, I kind of pulled all those together and that's what I pulled out of there were just kind of the key points.
58:08 Efficiently in the town's Mammoth System. So, yeah, I think that's what that's really about. I think Elizabeth's comment, too, about talking to the Planning Commission about this in a joint meeting is a really good, appropriate place to start those discussions. And I don't think you just turn it over to the Planning Commission to work together on that to make sure that something works well. Steve, I put it on one. Oh, I was going to just help you out a little bit, too.
58:39 I'm trying to remember back, too, our logic and our thinking process and stuff. I think if we look on page 8 in my document, we talk about pedestrian facilities as a general, liberal, bridging game. And then under that comes things like sidewalks, bikeways and so forth. So that technically a sidewalk is not a trail, but it is a public pedestrian facility.
59:08 So the point of the document was trying to focus on trails, but at the same time not turn us back on other facilities that help us be a feet-first community and that there be that recognition of sidewalks and the role they play, as well as bumps, as well as painted bikeways on the street, dedicated bike lanes, bike routes.
59:38 Those things, again, as Bill was pointing out, are traditionally done through public works and their funding comes from slightly different places. If there's one other point, to the degree to which recreation is the product of this community, the degree to which this community actually leads and says to the public coming here, we take this seriously, it's going to be reflected and manifested in the infrastructure that we build.
1:00:08 This plan was written at the height of the real estate building. And there are plenty of other destination communities that are now retooling their entire product because they can't get people to show up for gambling or for arts festivals or whatever. So it's more than just, yeah, it's a good idea to have, you know, trail stuff integrated into projects. The degree to which the planning, the economic and planning department really integrates recreation accessibility through this infrastructure is the key to the success of how
1:00:37 The role that Recreation plays as our product. So you can do it in an average way and not really that seriously, or like with the Main Street plan, you say no. They park in a garage, they go outside, and they're on it. It's going to be a question of where the political will is to really make that work. So what we kind of...
1:01:05 Well, although it comes in trail-oriented development as well because the sidewalk often is the feeder that feeds them to the recreational trails. I made a note to bring this up in our Planning Commission workshop in June. I just wanted to ask Steve, please make sure that we bring it up in June. Well, I think the answer to G5 is it is ongoing and its ownership is joint.
1:01:33 at best between planning and recreation if we're making notes on each one. Is that a consensus? Yes, I agree. Pedestrian-oriented development, which I think fits with, yeah, it's the same thing. It fits with trail-oriented development. So ongoing? Yeah, ongoing and joint ownership. Data management, which is
1:02:19 Done in the sense of what was being asked when we started this, but it is another one that for the moment is done, but is ongoing because it doesn't cease. Yeah. But the contract that MLTPA had to create trails-related data for the region, that is done and turned over. Yes? Yes. All the data was built, everything for the, there's,
1:02:52 Thousands of pieces of data that have been developed, documented, delivered to the town's GIS department. It's critical that this be an ongoing process. There are protocols in place to do all this that we've signed with the GIS coordinator. The degree to which we're providing data or other people are providing data, we'll see what happens. But certainly for the operations of the website, this stuff is critically important. All the stuff that we develop has all been delivered to the town. One thing I'd like to add is to make it clear that the data is more than just the
1:03:24 Geographic References. It's also user information, user data, and other surveys. It's important that there are information that we make decisions. And I think some of the information, I was fascinated by the user counts from the summer, particularly the number of users on the trail. It was astounding.
1:03:58 Close to the same. Close to the number of cars. Anyway, I've got some anecdotal topics to bring up when we cover that specific little spike, but I'll save that for another time because I thought that was very interesting as well. And I think, just sorry, but I think Bill Taylor makes an excellent point. All that GIS, that kind of data has been done, it's certainly thoroughly covered.
1:04:19 But the data of tracking and usage, MLTPA had some trail counters that we had a permit from the town to have in place. The town's got a couple. There is no integrated program that's been established yet establishing recreation use and usage on trails of this system on a regular ongoing basis. That program does not exist yet. I would encourage you guys to establish that as a priority because the correlation between that, grants, public funding, all kinds of other things, that usage is going to be really important.
1:04:47 and establishing what facilities should be built where, that's really going to matter, and that program doesn't exist anyway. You know, I am going to throw out just a really quick side note, and I don't know if it's necessarily appropriate at this time, but we're developing the brochure for Palooza Palooza over the next month, and I would love to dedicate a page specifically to trail hiking because I can't tell you how many people, again, that anecdotal stories that I've heard is so many people were hitting the trails.
1:05:13 On Saturday mornings, specifically before our grand tasting kind of thing. So we actually wanted to dedicate a page in our brochure specifically to trailers close by. So I may seek your help on that. Sure. Well, I know a lot of people too. Just, you know, basic mobility just to, you know, walk back and forth to the event. I know I did that. The specific counter that was above Kelly Road. Yeah. Above Kelly Road. So these people weren't just... Oh, no, they weren't just... Yeah. That was what was... I would have expected the numbers we saw.
1:05:43 Down lower up there. Bill, where is that county? It's a secret. No, I just wanted to add it. Somewhere between Telluride and Twenland. Somewhere between Telluride and Marshes. Get up there and use it. Is that information that you guys talked about at a trails committee meeting? The counts? We really haven't talked about the count at meetings I've been in. I think it would be great to bring that to the commission at some point. I think we brought that up. I want to say it was at this commission. It was right after I got on the commission.
1:06:12 September maybe? Yeah, they talked about the members and that the members were pretty... And the year over year was... And just, you know, the spike, it was... Not that I noticed that. Because you've just barely lost out to Labor Day, I think. No, it was going to be... Well, we'll have to pull up those numbers. You were like second to someone. Sean's going to run people by them. That's right. That's why we're dedicating a page in the guide.
1:06:38 Okay, G8, Design Guidelines, the Town of Mammoth Lakes should revise public work standard plans as needed. Has that been done? Do we know? Steve? John might have some... That's Steve, the draft 600 I just referred to. The town has a draft of section 600 specific to the trail system that's ready to go through an adoption process. And it still needs the soft surface for that design issue.
1:07:04 Yeah, the soft surface, that's something that probably the town and the forest service have to figure out in terms of what those standards are. For the moment, whatever standards are that come from the forest service, soft surface trail, they have a whole booklet to set up for that. But you've got a whole section 600 that's ready to go through the adoption process. Okay. Moving on then to G9 trail mobility needs. So I would think that this actually, the needs, is where we would add in the trail counters in use.
1:07:44 Because your need has got to be based on your usage, doesn't it? Yeah, it would be part of the... I mean, it's not... Well, part of the... There was a section on engagement that it's community-wide, that there's workshop surveys, media, so you kind of gain all of your knowledge from those needs, from those sources, I guess. Well, this one, if you read it, it doesn't really...
1:08:14 It's not clear that there's anything specific to be done with that. No, I think it's just ongoing. It's just saying that these are called out. Making sure that you kind of don't just do this and then it sits on a shelf, that you're making sure that you're continually looking at what the needs are and go changing environment and changing usage. I think at this time, too, it was anticipated that the Mobility Commission would still be...
1:08:45 Active, and that these aspects of mobility be considered in our planning efforts. Okay. Okay. Future access easements. And this is an important one that is ongoing. And I know we're still dealing with the one crucial one down here along Mammoth Creek. I don't know any other that we're currently working on. We've had some successes in the past.
1:09:21 Private ownership out on Dust Hazard Road, also known as Mill, where we had a situation where the public right-of-way ended at a private residence and then the Forest Service was beyond that and lots of people were using that driveway to walk into the forest, take their dogs into the forest, take their horses into the forest.
1:09:47 And we were able to successfully get an easement with that private property owner for walkers, bikers, dog walkers, but not equestrian. There was a littering problem with the horses. They couldn't read and the riders weren't willing to take the responsibility to scoop the poop. That's a mighty big scoop.
1:10:10 You take your dogs with him, they eat it for you, and then you don't have to worry about it. Just thought I'd throw that out there if you know any equestrians. It's a fact, I'm not joking. There's actually another action item that might come forward to the committee, which is to look about putting some blue bag dispensers and small trash bins or something on that easement. And then I think the other one that...
1:10:39 We were working with was on the Plum property down on Tamarack Street. My understanding is that's currently a temporary easement until then there's some other provisions that kick in later. And so I think the first step is we've got something now so people legally can cross that property and not be worrying about trespass. And the property owner is in agreement with that.
1:11:09 And then I think you're right, Bill, there is another one that might come along near Mammoth Creek, but that's... That's a critically informed up system that's... That process... Deletes the property, yeah. That process is not fully decided yet as to how to move forward with that. There's a sale sign on the property again, so... But no, yeah, that's a... That was an ongoing effort. Yeah.
1:11:36 That's a critical piece, to finish that from Mammoth Creek Condos to Minaret Road. That path along the Snow Creek Lodges out there gets incredible use. And that project is based on RCIP? Yeah, it is. But I hope that staff has worked in the last couple of years to actually take a town map.
1:12:03 and identify other potential places where we can get from public right-of-ways across private property to public lands. And it's really something that we should do. Don't know how to go about it, but there are all sorts of things called out, and not just this plan. There's a Manzanita connector for one of the roads. I just put down identified easement area needs, so, you know, it may be something that we look throughout the...
1:12:31 You know, we look at where the trails are and see where we need to get easements, not the ones that are just identifying now, but look at what needs to be in the future. If I could, there's a product, sorry, the GIC product that was a GIS product that identified every, on the urban growth boundary, every potential point of interaction between the urban growth boundary and public lands. That would be a pretty good thing to start with.
1:12:59 That was delivered to the town back in the height of the real estate boom. It's probably a good resource to go back and look at where those opportunities are. But there is a data set that would help in those discussions. That would be something, too, that the committee could direct staff to look at. Yeah. You're taking good notes for this staff so that we can appropriately direct you later? We're still looking for that guy. Yeah. So obviously that's ongoing, but there are a couple of critical points there that we need to be looking at.
1:13:29 Short-term, so that we can finish, especially our MUC system, which to me is such an important system that kind of circumnavigates the town and there's holes in it. And yeah, we need to get those holes, as a top priority from my standpoint, we need to get those holes fixed. Point of question, you know, our goal, what we're doing right here is just going through and identifying what's done, what's ongoing.
1:13:53 Are we going to go back and look at these again here in a minute today about what's one to three years out, what's three to five years out? We're not going to, and again, the question, we're not going to try and prioritize today?
1:14:10 We're not prioritizing today. The prioritization comes at the end of this whole process. Mostly this process is to educate us as to all the plans that are out there so that we have everything that's on those plans in front of us when we get down to prioritizing. So will we be trying to put out there what is accomplishable within one to three years? Not that we're prioritizing, but just putting time plans on these.
1:14:36 The low-hanging fruit. And I think we can pick the low-hanging fruit off of it. I don't know how much farther we can go with that not knowing what the costs and the budgetary things are. That's the problem. We've identified a lot of things here in 0 to 2, 3 to 5 long term. And we can do the same thing, but none of it's realistic until we go back and pick what projects we're actually going to pursue until we run out of money. Well, let's see, we ran out of money before the fiscal use started.
1:15:04 How do you accomplish the, you know, zero to two and the, so I don't know how to do that. Yes, I believe we need to get this somehow into this, and I'm not sure that that doesn't maybe come from the MLTSCC. That's what I wonder, what, you know, how you see the roles here between yourselves. Right.
1:15:23 Between yourselves as rec commission and yourselves as coercion. Yeah, because I originally saw this as just going through the plans to familiarize ourselves with them, and this is a great exercise to get there. Yeah, you know, I see that this is familiarizing ourselves with this, and then if as a commission we say, hey, you know, notes are something that we see as a priority, then it goes back to the MLTSCC, and you guys look at, okay, so what's out there, what can we do?
1:15:51 You know, and let's prioritize how the mills go and what jobs you guys would actually then say, what are those jobs that you need to do? But if we see something that we see that needs to be a priority, that we feel it needs to be a priority, then we would give that to the MLTSCC. If you think we're way off base, then you can tell us. And the fact is, a lot of what is in here,
1:16:22 It's already here. We just need to go back and add this as one of the places it's Nordic is in here, Snowplay is in here, Staging is in here called Nodes instead of Staging, but they're already all on the list. So it's just a matter of going back and putting the extra asterisk or whatever on it as to what actually it's going out over here and putting the extra thing that it goes into.
1:16:48 But I think it's a good idea to send it to the MLTSCC for timelines because some of the other plans have the advantage of laying out the timelines for us. Right. Yeah. And this one doesn't? And I guess it is that MLTSCC is a subcommittee of this commission, and so if we see something that is a commission that we feel needs to be a priority, then it goes to MLTSCC, and, you know, if they don't feel it's a priority, then they can let us know why.
1:17:15 But then they can take that and then you would actually then take it and do the fine-tuning of that and how it's done and where it's done and, you know, all of that. Okay. That's the process. Yeah. Moving down. G11 Trail Coordinator. I think for all intents and purposes right now we can call Mr. Spidell the Trail Coordinator. He's taken over the lead role of the...
1:17:44 Staffing the MLTSCC, while it really doesn't fit the thing here, it certainly does the same thing. Do you think you've been, when you look at the job description here and your job description, are most of the tasks covered? I'm pretty close. I just have a couple things to say about that. I think my understanding is that Steve's employment is only, is a, I don't know if it's a
1:18:14 I would hate for you guys to think that as competent, charming, wonderful, and great a human being Steve is, the position that he's currently filling, the job description, the term of service, and all the rest of it, is not a trails coordinator. I think it's a six-month... I would do your due diligence. Steve would be a great candidate for it, but I'm not...
1:18:42 My understanding is that's not the position he's currently in. If you guys want to make it that way, you should make it that way. For the next six months, that's how I'm considering it, from a personal standpoint. The note I made was that his contractor position is the emperor. This is a bridge to whatever we wind up doing. I don't think it's the full program. No.
1:19:08 And I think that that rolls into our discussion of what does recreation look like? Is it a Mammoth Lakes Recreation? Is this position something that can be worked into that overall? Or is it a separate position and how that works? And I think that's an entire conversation as to how it works and how it's paid for. That's the...
1:19:29 Crux of the whole matter in the long run. And once again, do we have something that's strictly trails? Do we have something strictly municipal? How is it that we pull all this together? And do we have five different people doing that? Or is it one person? $300,000 for the next five years has been allocated to trails. So it seems to me to make sense that you have a trail coordinator that would be coming from the $300,000 as opposed to throwing more money at it.
1:19:57 Or is there a director that is, or somebody that's looking at Mammoth Fix Recreation and you're hiring contract services, different things within the trails? I don't know. That still needs to be looked at. I was going to say, for the moment, the short term, the stress. Obviously, the universe changes, the universe changes. Yeah. Right now, this is what we're doing. But that is the overarching conversation that I think that eventually needs to be had. And I think overall, perhaps, an interpretation is that you can,
1:20:31 Can direction be given to contractors? Contractors are separate from staff. I think there has to be, you have to be careful as to what you actually direct a contractor to do. Because I think the expectation is that they're coming with, you know, a skill set and they are able to operate fairly independently. So, you know, if you're talking about managers, we're not talking about managers. But I think that gets it into a whole different ballgame.
1:21:02 I agree. It just needs to be a conversation. You can't direct his work program. Right. No. It has to go through whatever permanent staff members. No, we have to direct staff to direct his work program. That we can do. Okay, so that's all we can do with trail coordinator at the moment. Coordination with local non-government organizations. And this is ongoing. We should always seek opportunities to partner.
1:21:35 This is what Mammoth Trails was doing. This is, you know, ongoing. Don't you have an MOU that's being worked on it now? Well, that's with the Forest Service. That's a governmental agency. Well, that's all of the above, I think. This is a non-governmental organization. I would say that as, you know, in practice, if this is happening, what's missing is probably formalization of how that's going to work.
1:22:05 Yeah. It's kind of been ad hoc at times. Obviously, Mammoth Trails has a structure. They work with a lot of local user groups. Well, but don't you think it's always going to be ad hoc? As personalities come and go. When I say a structure, I mean, who's the point person? It's going to do the coordination. And how are they, and what kinds of organizations are they for? It's, like I said, right now, it's happening, but it's free for it. Yeah. So it needs to be certified.
1:22:33 So I would say that rolls into either the trail coordinating position or a Mammoth Lakes Recreation Organization or South County Recreation District. I think that rolls into part of that conversation. But the coordination to me is just a coordinator because the non-government organizations, at least in Mammoth, are going to change regularly. As personalities come and go, the non-governmental organizations come and go along with them.
1:23:02 So, you know, this comes back to once again, you need to have the conversation. Are we having a whole bunch of different people that are taking care of each individual little item? That's right. Or are you looking at an umbrella organization and somebody that can take all of this and organize it? I agree, yeah. And I think just a couple of things in the last couple of years, well, Mammoth Trails, we were being funded to coordinate, hold regular meetings, help user groups do organizational development. That capacity is integrated into
1:23:33 The summer stewardship trails events, that's where we get volunteers from, that's where we have gotten volunteers from in the past, that we've gotten businesses from in the past, that capacity is no longer placed, it's not happening right now. The experiences, the specific, you mentioned earlier, but the specific recreation activities that happen on the trail system, the trail system is heavily reliant on local users being able to provide that information. Right now, there is no formal NGO relationship.
1:24:00 of the town with anybody. MLTPA does not have any kind of a relationship with the town. Mammoth Trails does not have a relationship with the town. It's not meeting. So you've lost some real capacity in terms of being able to get really good local knowledge, feeding into websites, feeding into stewardship opportunities. I think that that's probably got to be kind of a priority to get that back up and going because it is invaluable. Thank you, John. Anything else on the coordination? It is an important piece.
1:24:31 Cast it with a pretty wide brush. I mean, you know, an organization like disabled sports, you know, cars here and, you know, their input. I can't see her. All I can see is you. Oh. Anyway, so I'm just, I think we just need to think really broadly when we think about what videos would be, because this is a pretty broad definition. It is. What they would do. Yeah. And they change. Who knows what disabled sports force into next, depending on who takes Kathy's position when Kathy goes, and eventually she will. We all do.
1:25:03 So it's, yeah, it's a terrible thing. Can I just, sorry to interrupt, just one example. I met with Alan Jacoby on Sunday, the mountain bike guy talking about the fat bike stuff. And here's a guy walking into town who wants to know, how do I get my mountain bike club together? How do I get the experiences I know are legal onto a website? How do I organize and get that kind of capacity? When Mammoth Trails is in existence, that person walks in the door and this community can extend to him the kind of coordination capacity necessary to get that stuff up and running quickly.
1:25:33 And it was kind of difficult for me to be able to say, well, you know, six months ago this was all in place and we could have helped organize that community and did all kinds of great things. It currently does not exist. We're going back to where we were five, six, seven years ago. And I think what's going to make the recreation experience unique in Mammoth is the degree to which we integrate this with the users, with the people who've got capacity, show up in town, they've got a new recreation activity that can all flow right up through the town over to the Forest Service.
1:26:01 I just remembered that thought. It goes back to what we said. Somebody needs to handle it. We just need to determine what that outlet and how that is going to work. I think it's two things. We need sort of a frame of the program. It's not as specific as the NGOs or a user group because I think it's actually broader than just NGOs. Some user groups are NGOs. No, that's right. They're just that, user groups.
1:26:32 But I think that dates back to whatever the priority happens to be, and if the priority is for a coordinating entity, I don't know why we're only looking at non-governmental organizations and user groups, but it can also be staff as well. I just don't think staff have been given the direction, or maybe the resources, to be that coordinator. But it doesn't mean that it can't be.
1:27:01 Or have shown the desire to be that coordinator. With the organization that we have right now, we do not have the ability to do this. We do not. So I guess that's what I keep saying is that we need to look at what all the needs are. But you need money to make that happen. Understand. And money could be put towards staffing. They don't have to be put towards something totally a separate entity. And that is for a later discussion. It is, absolutely. Go ahead.
1:27:32 I know that this is John's bloodline, and blood sweat and tears have been put into this, but I kind of think back to what some of the guidelines were when we talked about these workshops. And we talked about, let's all of us talk about it and come to some conclusions and make sure that we're all on the same page. And then if we want feedback from the public, then we would ask for it. I think even Terry made a point of doing that.
1:27:59 at the conclusion of the meeting before we vote. And I know we've been asking John questions, we've been asking Steve questions, but maybe we could just get focused back on to what we're supposed to do. We can, but I'm going to ask him at the end of each if he has a comment on it, because he was integral in this plan, so he has knowledge that the rest of us don't have for it. Right, just like we asked Steve with the Recreation Master Plan. Yes. So, John, until I give you a nod.
1:28:28 Thank you. Summit process, G-13, and there were some summits held. I suppose the question is, how often should this happen? Is this an ongoing need to have the summits?
1:28:59 Well, this is the finalist of summits will be developed early winter 2009. And the summits were held, yes. So I guess it's how often does it need to be updated? And with everything Mammoth has ever done, my comment on them was, how do we get all of our users to the summits and commenting? Because if the summits had an issue, that was the issue again. Is that something that the Trails Master, the committee, should maybe hold into? That can deal with, yeah.
1:29:27 What if we were to do something that is just an annual, certainly no more than biannual, biannual set of summits, but you still got to pay for the facilitation and the space and the... I would almost think maybe every five years or something like that. I don't think you need to do it yearly. If an issue comes up that requires... As needed. Yeah. I always think.
1:29:51 Maybe you want to have one every five years or as needed, if less. Because something may come up in the end of the end period that we need to address through this process. But in terms of what was initially described, the initial summits were done. So in terms of status, the initial summits were done. It's going to be ongoing, ongoing, periodic. What were those summits in early winter 2009?
1:30:22 Is it something that John has outlined in this document? They did a summer one and a winter one. Okay. I think they were at the Canyon Lake, I believe. I'll wait, but it's not related to where things actually work. Okay, John, when did the summits occur? Okay, so the summits and the trail system master plan, it was put in there because the planners felt
1:30:54 that there were certain areas of planning that they could not get to that required specific community engagement. One of them they identified was the motorized, non-motorized issues out of Shady Rest. They felt that that was an issue that felt outside of the scope that they could really handle the planning process. So they identified a summit process to specifically meet and get together and talk about what was happening in Shady Rest. This is a precursor to the Shady Rest Collaborative Planning effort.
1:31:20 Which I think we all wish we had in place now that ORMAT's happening out there. But that summit never happened. There were two camp efforts that happened as part of the planning process. This was outreach for summer recreation activities and winter recreation activities that happened well before the plan was drafted. So the summits in those two camps are not related. Those are two separate things. There was the Sherman's Working Group. The rationale for the funding for that was from the summit process. And that dealt with a specific...
1:31:50 Part of Town, and what was designed by the Alta folks who put this plan together was that you pull a summit together, if you start getting to a point where you've got a real need to do some planning that's going to fall outside the scope of this document, the first one that they had identified was a need for this out of a shady rest. Thank you, John. Do future summits need to be facilitated by a consultant, or do you think it can just be something, you know, where it's just input gathered?
1:32:22 I think it depends on the resources you have available at the time. Yeah. I mean, if you had a staff or an organization that had the suitable resources, then no, but if you don't, then yes. Because to some degree, I kind of look at what the Forest Service was doing with some of your trail projects. They just kind of did it with other information. Maybe from there it goes to some specialist. No, no, that's very true.
1:32:56 People in Place. If you have the capacity, then you can do it in the house. If you don't have the capacity, or if you can do it for less money outside of the house, then you do it outside of the house. Do you want to state for the record that John has joined us? John has joined us. It's fine. My mind isn't in gear yet anyway. I think I understand what you guys are talking about right now. I think there's one point I'll make that I think it's fairly important.
1:33:26 Anything we do outside of the formal NEPA process is really what we call left-side planning. It's conceptual. It's ideas that feed into our NEPA, our formal decision-making process. They don't count for any decision. It's this idea that is an alternative that's being considered. The only thing that really counts is the NEPA process, the decision that is a result of that process. Not to discount.
1:33:54 What anything is, anything going on on the left side, we call it the planning world of conceptual ideas, because that's where a lot of the collaboration, you know, people get together and try to figure out conflicts and resolve problems, but a lot of the problems that we do have with those left-sided planning processes is that not everybody comes to the table to participate, and
1:34:20 It's not really a democratic process per se, the process. So even if that's what everybody agrees to comes to the table on the left side planning, that doesn't mean that's what's going to be the outcome at all. At that point it is an alternative and an idea. So you've got to really consider the value of those left side planning processes in that light. Do you really need it to generate the alternatives to get the ideas on the table or is it better off?
1:34:48 In the formal planning process, putting your resources and energy through that formal planning process. Somebody has to come up with the idea first, which doesn't often come from a formal planning process. It does. Sometimes it doesn't. I mean, our traditional structure is the Forest Service goes out and identifies an idea, proposes it, goes through scoping, and then alternatives are developed through that scoping process, and then we assess those alternatives and make a decision. But the left side...
1:35:17 The process is really, the collaborative process is an opportunity for the community to get together and really sort out some of those issues and try to minimize the conflict that may result once the decision is made. So, with what you're saying, yes, the Forest Service is doing some reach out with their staff on the staging areas and on some other things.
1:35:42 But that's because someone in the Forest Service has made that the priority for staff to do, and they've told John to get his tail over there. The same thing could be done in the town of Mammoth if the managers wanted to make this a priority, or if the town manager wanted to put enough money in the budget to make it for a priority for Stu or someone else to do. At this point, I don't see that happening. So I just pulled this from here. I put summits as needed then, as opposed to having a, and I put conflicts, review interface.
1:36:10 Review Interface Issues, Identify Opportunities, Improve Experience, Determine Resolutions, and Potential Policy, if that's what the summits would. She wrote a lot more than me. I just wrote, maybe called as needed. I'm just trying to make so if I was going to improve my bullet points here, that I'm improving on what they say and what they are.
1:36:35 But it was well stated, yes. John, can I ask you real quick, when you said that people don't show up for those meetings, is that just because they're not aware of it? Because they've got agendas that they disagree with? Is there a combination? It's all of the above. I think you've got people who, they're time consuming. The flower processes take time. And some people don't have the time to participate. There is also the fact that...
1:37:02 Some people, some organizations, individuals may not feel like they have much leverage at that table. And so if you think about it in our formal structure, people understand where the power system lies. In the collaborative process, that power structure is very deeply distributed. Not everybody is comfortable. National organizations often don't participate in local collaborative processes.
1:37:31 And these are federal plans and foreign national organizations who have members across the nation have an interest here locally. You know, John, I'm going to disagree with you on that. I've been through several local collaborative processes with the Forest Service who, if it was a vote, whose results have been skewed greatly because of the power of a national organization to do a blast email or a blast mailing to get comments on it.
1:37:59 I think sometimes that those national organizations have played a larger role in our local forest decisions than perhaps, and this is coming as a user, than perhaps is warranted because all of a sudden a thousand letters come in from Maine saying, no, you shouldn't have access to... I think the point of the summit process is for the community to have an opportunity to have an input, right, and not make a...
1:38:28 It is not the decision-making process. And I don't think this implies that it is.
1:38:48 But it is the mechanism by which the issues we get addressed. Right. And I guess the reason why I ask that question is that I hear you saying every five years or as needed, but I almost see something like this. If I'm understanding what the definition of a summit means, the MLTSCC conducting one once a year as part of its bucketing, trying to determine what's the buckets. And no, I don't think it needs to necessarily be...
1:39:17 Having a coordinator come in and actually organize it. I'm sorry, what was the term you used earlier? Faciliter. Faciliter, thank you. I don't know if it necessarily needs to have a facilitator involved, but if the MLTSCC could dedicate one meeting a year in the early spring, or whatever the case may be, that is looking for its bucket list for the following year, this might be a good way of getting the community involved, and I say that as a question.
1:39:48 And I agree to a point. It may not be needed every year because we may be so far behind on the previous year's input that we're not going to get to anything new. But yes, when there's space available to have one or if we see a changing trend, then the idea of calling out a public meeting for input on something like that is very important. It should not allow us to address the gentleman who is here with the fat bike.
1:40:17 Menti or whatever it was, that, you know, when he comes forward and he says, hey, why can't I get on the trails, being able to say to him, well, come to our summit, which is held the first weekend or the first, you know, Wednesday in March of every year, you know, it just sets in place a standard for being able to bring those things forward. I guess I could see where the priorities are brought forward by the MLTSCC.
1:40:42 and that there then could be a community vetting, say this is what, you know, we're looking at, this is what the work plan is, does anybody have any comments, questions, or anything else, but I, you know, I don't know, I, because, because of what the definition of the summit is, I'm not sure that it's still not as needed, because it's really more to identify conflicts and what the opportunities might be to resolve those, at least that's how I'm reading it, so, anyhow.
1:41:15 Are you taking a public comment? Yeah, John. I think that, Sean, you may not have been around like when the lab's process was going on, when the Sherman's working process group was going on. Bill Taylor, I think, between Bill and John, they gave a really excellent definition of what these things are intended to be. A certain issue gets a kind of a critical mass. Everybody knows some planning or something needs to happen. It is a convened, facilitated process to get the community together to figure out, okay, how is this going to kind of work?
1:41:43 And it provides some direction. It's not a formal decision-making process. It may not ever be the formal decision-making process. But if the Forest Service then has to make some choices or some calls, they can look to a process that may have taken four or five meetings where representatives have the opportunity to show up and really talk these things through and figure out what the best way is for things to work. The Terry Plum easement through Tamarack Street came out of the Sherwin's working group process.
1:42:10 The rationale, what it was supposed to be, how it was going to work, that came out of a collaborative process. It wasn't the decision, but it was a kind of a consensus process that when you need to have it, you can kind of figure out this is how we should do it. That's how the winter egress coming back across the Snow Creek Golf Course came out of the Sherman's Working Group process. So those summits are specifically designed for a critical need situation.
1:42:34 Where you've got a lot of different interests, a lot of different things going on, you need to get a bunch of people together and kind of hash it out, figure out, okay, what is the best way to do this? It's not the decision, but it's good direction for decision makers to use if they want to going forward. We've spent a lot of time on this one. I think that we just need to say ongoing. Maybe call as needed. I can see as MLTSCC, if we actually start getting stuff done, we may need to have more than one summit.
1:43:07 We may need a summit to look at conflicts in the tunnel if we decide to take that one on, and we may need to do a conflict in the Sherwin's with equestrian and pedestrian, or mountain bike usage. So we could have two a year, or we may not need any for the year. I think the need for the summit comes out of our work program. If there's something in there that's going to be controversial enough, we need to do the outreach to get the public in to...
1:43:36 Does that make sense? It does. Thank you. Can I add one last thing? Yep. I think the largest value in this process is getting the public involved, period. Getting them engaged and having them come to the table and just think about and talk about these issues. It's incredible. So I have that first thing you highly would do. Although I think we should add alcohol to them because there's enough fighting going on.
1:44:03 P.D. needs something to do. Action plan, develop detailed action plan for implementation. That's kind of what we're trying to do, yes. So can we just put ongoing? Ongoing and important. In progress. Well, okay.
1:44:29 Ongoing makes more sense to me than in progress, actually. But it's going to be ongoing all the time. It's going to matter what you do, it's not going to be set in stone. It's going to be something you look at. G-15 Trail System Management MOU, which is going on currently. The MOU with the Forest Service is underway. We still haven't signed any MOU. They're ready to be signed. They just haven't been signed. They will be. We can have a public ceremony.
1:44:58 Formal meeting? Right, yeah. Okay. I'm just asking. I'll bring the root beer. We can call that near term. I just have MOUs, roles and responsibilities, because I think once you figure out what that whole thing is, you may need other MOUs, but right now you have one that's going on with the forest service. Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
1:45:31 We did that one. Yeah. And it's not even ongoing. I think we can say we now have named the Mammoth Lakes Trail System the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Are we going to put done there? I'm putting done there. That means we've got two items here that are done? Three. So do you want to look over the improvements and changes that they're looking at here with the recreation nodes and nodal typing and all of this other?
1:46:05 I just identified that all these things were on these different pages, so I don't know. Right. Yeah, I don't know if we necessarily, I don't think we need to go through this whole thing. But you know. Call out the charts because they have the Fs for the future. Which page? 120 and 123 have the charts for the notes for the future things that she added. And some of them are done, but. Not that we're prioritizing this thing. But would we want to in the future?
1:46:35 Prioritize some of these nodes as needing more growth than others. I think this is where when you say, okay, nodes are a priority, so then which nodes are a priority and, you know, what does that node need to look like? Yeah, first we have to go down and take out any of the nodes that really aren't in our control. Our input is the best advisory.
1:47:05 Yeah, and I guess that's what I would say is if you feel that one of these is the most important but it's out of our control, then you contact that partner and, you know, yeah, exactly. And maybe then there becomes some type of a partnership that's formed. Maybe then that brings that node up to a priority level for them as well. Well, in some, like the community centers I was just pointing out here, you know, are nodes that we are going to be reviewing as part of this process.
1:47:35 So maybe that'll all come out in the end anyway. But I definitely feel like, again, not to be getting ahead of myself here, that some of these nodes, I can tell already, you know, I would love to see, you know, the gifted children pushed forward a little bit. I guess I would see that when we're done with all of this, if we're going to say we really want to focus on nodes, that maybe as a rec commission we might want to say that these are ones that we see, send it to the MLTSCC, you guys.
1:48:05 Look at them. Are there any others that you need to add? And then how do we make these happen? Are there partners that you need to contact? Are they done within this organization? You know, how are they done? And then that goes into your work plan and you guys figure it out. Okay. I don't know. We can do that. Yeah, well, at some point, I'm assuming the MLTSCC is going to look at the nodes. Yeah. I mean, we're already going to be looking at the shady and the scenic loop ideas.
1:48:34 Well, and again, not to prioritize, but you know, one of the things that's in these node enhancement recommendations has a lot to do with transit, and I wondered how much of that is sort of our low-hanging fruit in terms of, you know, how difficult it is to add a shuttle stop to the trailhead at Lake George, for example. But that would go to a partner. Or how hard is it to get bus access to shady rest? Yeah.
1:48:58 So I think, I guess you'd identify which one you think needs to be done, and like I say, you identify if there's a partner, you've got to talk to that partner and see how it goes, and if not, then we would see within our own organization what we would do. And if, you know, if you want, we can go through and... I think this is a pretty thorough list. It is, it's a very thorough list, yeah. Well, although on it, for instance, the Winter Recreation notes,
1:49:29 The ones at the Forest Service is now, Shady Rest Park is where it is now, and that's going to be moved. There's one that's being talked about at the Lookout Mountain Road, and one on the old Ed Aritz, and I don't remember which road that is off of Sandy Glute, 3S22, that aren't even on here. So they need to be added.
1:49:56 And the ones whose places they're taking, because they do. Because I think the cinder shed is on here, although that's not what it's called. Power plant is what it's called here. I think there needs to be a naming convention for that S-R. Yeah, yeah. 3S-22. Yeah, Ed Loritz's old staging spots probably doesn't get for most people, huh? But that's the cinder shed. 3S-22 is...
1:50:27 No, it should just Dry Creek Trailhead. You know, to get completely off task here, the Scenic Loop never should have been called the Scenic Loop in the first place because it follows what was the Dry Creek Road for years and years and why we went through the naming convention because...
1:50:52 Somebody didn't think Dry Creek was good, so we called it the Scenic Loop Road, and then we put a sign at 395 asking people not to use it because we didn't want the traffic on it. Really? Yeah. Things get really confusing after a while. We use it all. That's what they call it. I know. Because it's been redone now. When it was originally done, it wasn't built to handle the kind of traffic that it was getting, so there were issues. Okay.
1:51:20 It was completely destroyed. Okay. It's a beautiful road with flying parking and everything else now. In fact, there are areas for winter recreation along the scenic loop that are plowed wide enough to be called nodes for tobogganing and stuff that aren't on here, that need to be added on here. So there's a piece of work that MLTSCC and the Forest Service needs to do to modify the nodes list. You're right. However we get that done. Yeah.
1:51:52 John. Nodes, trailheads, access points, wonderful terms, warm, fuzzy, friendly. There is a specific infrastructure guideline through each one of these things. So when you guys have these two things, if the town of Forest Service can figure out a way that those staging areas are in fact to be nodes in the plan and the design guidelines have been established, it's very nice.
1:52:21 Not too specific, but good procedure to go about to figure out how do you designate it, how do you name it, what level of service it gets on it, the rest of that kind of stuff. So I would just encourage you to go look at all the work that's been done. You've got a really good baseline of design standards in place to make all this stuff happen. Okay. Moving on from nodes. Let's go to MUPS. No, wait. Future Nodal Designs, which is really what we all went down to. N8. Which page are you on? 127.
1:53:09 Recommendation N8, Continually Updates GIC Database, Inventory Status, Illinois, I'm looking at N8. Future Nodal Designations goes along with the conversation that John just brought up to us and that the conventions are already there and that work's been done. We don't need to redo that. So I went on to the GIC database and basically what it tells us is
1:53:45 That when new points, trails, and things are done, they should be added to the database by someone, and the changes need to be reflected in there. So I think we can just put there that that is ongoing. 127. Well, we went to nodes, so maybe we need to go back to activity centers, which took us into nodes.
1:54:23 Explain what recreation nodes were, and then typing was N1, uniform nodal signage was, N2 was naming of recreation nodes, and that work, as John has said, has been done. The signage uniform, the signage and wayfinding plan has been done, right? Yes.
1:54:58 Yes, John. The standards for all, Chapter 5 in the plan is all about the signs and wayfinding program conceptually. Now that you have signs around that have been built, you have construction-ready standards for every sign type. For every node that gets designated, when you designate it as a certain type, it gets a certain type of time. Sign, the standards are in place to build it, how you name it, the rest of it, there's some work that has to be done that can happen, but it's all there. So all of N1, N2, N3,
1:55:25 had to do with things that we had discussed, so I sort of went by them. Four is public transit access to recreation nodes, and we just briefly touched on that, too. I think it's a no-brainer that it's ongoing, but that trolleys, we need to somehow figure a way to get one of our buses to go out to Shady Rest. But I'm also going to, I don't know, I've been putting down little qualifiers that just say important. Yeah, that's fine.
1:55:55 You just determined to prioritize. I am. I am. You're right. Which took us to the recommendation summer recreation modes, and what I'm saying there is that these, both the summer and winter recreation modes, we can go over them on the map if we want to, but I don't see any reason to go there, that we need to look at where we are today versus where we were here, because through stuff that the Forest Service has done and stuff that the town has done, both of those lists need to be updated and changed.
1:56:28 John? Just a quick point on the transit. It would be useful, I think, for the Recreation Commission and the MLTSCC to provide kind of a prioritized language to the staff and other things coming forward so that you don't get a horse wagging the cart situation where bus stops and transit stops are being put in place and established without being integrated into the recreation opportunities. A little bit of that was happening in the Lake Space in the summer where bus stops are kind of popping up all over the place.
1:56:58 They may not be tying into the recreation opportunities. You may want to just try to coordinate that a little bit. There's some good opportunities there. Good idea. Mr. Chairman, why'd you burp? Two hours are up. Thank you. Well, we've about climbed through this. What I think we need to go over. Question. Okay, with...
1:57:37 With the trails kind of being a key kind of its own entity kind of type thing as to how things have gone, we have in our chart here implement trail system master plan. Do we want to fit all of this in here? Do we want to actually take this and maybe put it at the end and then it would have its own little section? No, I would say we can put it in its own little section if you want. MLTSCC can come up with that.
1:58:05 Implement Trail System Master Plan is what needs to be here, but we need to go through all of the other things that are on here and call out how many of them appear in this plan as well, because I don't think we could. Yeah, things like covering the ice rink is in here. Right. Nordic is in this plan, so it needs to be added. Snow play is in this plan. Staging is in this plan. I know staging is, yeah. Viking is in this plan.
1:58:36 Well, yeah, and that would be putting in where the documents here would be the trail system master plan would be added in here. So maybe we want to go through this document and put where does the trail system master plan touch one of these? So if we go field house? I don't think that there's a field house in the trail system master plan. Okay, high altitude? High altitude is in the trail system master plan. Multi-use outdoor? It's not. Fields?
1:59:07 Is not. Correct me if I'm wrong, somebody. Access is, though. Access to fields absolutely are. Access, and also there's some reference to, well, I think you have a separate category, because there's some reference to events in here. Yes, there are. Tennis courts. So did you just point out that multi-use outdoor is mentioned in drill systems? No. No. I think it would go separately under events, though. None of these specifically come up under.
1:59:38 No, transportation. Transportation does. Nordic. Nordic does. Snowflay does. Snowflay does. Snowflay. Staging. Winter, summer. You know, the one thing, if I can go back a minute, we just went through Nordic and Snowflay and staging. The one thing that's in here that may play on this list as well as on a separate list is snow management.
2:00:08 We talked about it some last time, but it's called out specifically in here for several things, from sidewalks to mops to other trails, so I would like to see it have its own list on our main list, if that's all right with the rest of you.
2:00:28 Do you want its own place or do you want snow management just put in the trail system master plan or snow management overall? I'd like snow management overall because it's really called out. Part of the reason that Nordic and Snow Play show up in the other plans, as I said before, was the need for snow management. You can't do them without grooming or snow removal or something.
2:00:51 This has a lot of references. And it's called out so much in here. Yeah. And also the possibility of, you know, snow removal then being used for a snow play area. Yeah. It doesn't work. It's been tried. Information. We should talk about it again. Marketing. So biking was in it. Did you already get that one? Yeah. Funding partnerships. Sponsorship. And...
2:01:24 So Recreation Trends is part of it, although it's not called out specifically. Yeah, I put that on there. I put information marketing for Recreation Trends, funding partnerships, sponsorships, S-Trail System Master Plan. Those are the ones I put on there. Okay. Sounds good to me. Are you going to add your notes onto this one? Yeah, I'll add everything to what I have here, and then I'll send it around, and you guys can decide what you want to do with it.
2:02:04 And if there's anything I missed. You know, one thing I think we should incorporate, it's mentioned in here a couple of times, is funding. I just talked a lot about in Chapter 8 and implementation and also just maintenance and, you know, just the lack of funding available for maintenance. Yeah, you know, earlier on. Probably. Some of the things that I had on here that I had read in here were lighting on mutts. Yeah, that on the light.
2:02:33 Bike Lanes, Main Street, Forest Trail, Meridian, others as space allows, address interface issues from Canyon Lodge and other intersections. And can we also add snow removal slash grooming on Mumps Navy? Well, that's part of the snow management. Snow management. I don't have that anywhere here, though. Yeah. So, I'll just put snow management on here. It's another bullet.
2:03:04 So are there any other bullets that's missing as far as the bullets go? The other thing they call out in here, and again, one of the things that I necessarily did not agree with, but in our prioritizing process, one of the things that they mentioned in here was changing the way we prioritize snow rule, because they're talking about moving trails and sidewalks, snow management, because they're talking about grooming and snow removing.
2:03:35 from number seven up to number three. So I don't know how we want to deal with that or if it's something that we think is even feasible. No, I think it's worth discussing in terms of if we're going to be at the first pedestrian-oriented community. Of course, that just comes under snow management as well, I suppose, so we can talk about that. So snow management, we're looking at trails, sidewalks, muts, and then snowflake? Mm-hmm.
2:04:04 So I thought this made a really good point that, you know, in the winter is when we have the most dangerous conditions for being a pedestrian-oriented community. But then I asked, you know, unfortunately, I think we have to go back to the reality. I mean, realistically, can we afford to be the full feet first that everybody wants to be? Because if we are, then there needs to be some money that's brought forward somewhere else. Well, that's for the funding question. Yeah.
2:04:34 Yeah, is it possible to remove, and I get hit over the head with it every day, is it really possible to remove the snow on the Lake Murray bike path up to Lee Road? I'd love it if we could. Even if the money is there, how do you accomplish it? Not an easy task, unless you're going to take Woodstock, not Woodstock, Big Wood.
2:04:56 You have to take the snow from point A to point B somewhere, worse point B. And are you going to do more damage to the infrastructure of the trail? I mean, one of the recommendations, some are really not practical. It suggests actually grooming all the way up from Davison all the way up into the lakes basin, but you're in the avalanche zone. Actually, that one I didn't see is that bad of an idea. Rather than remove the snow from the Lake Murray bike path,
2:05:26 To just groom over the top of it. However, with the fences and retainers being what they are and with drop-off being what it is, yeah, I don't know that I want to be the driver. Cross-country skier. Well, we're the cross-country skier. Yeah. Well, cross-country skier can just do a couple of tellies and make it down the hill. Not a big deal. There's some pretty steep sections on there. Is there marketing on there?
2:05:59 Marketing is in there. Marketing definitely needs to be included, and that's where I sort of thought, you know, the trail maps. Which is what they talk about. Yeah. Education. I think benefits. To produce, yeah. And I think that comes focused. Benefits, economic. Yeah, economic and health. I can add marketing.
2:06:28 Economic is going to be marketing, but information and marketing. Let me draw us back. At this point, we are going to drop this, or did you want to go through the specific recommendations for MUPS and such? You know what? All I did was put the pages.
2:06:48 So I identified the pages that this was on, and so that when we're looking at it, when, you know, okay, we want to look, we're working at MUPS this time, so then you can go to those pages and say, what do they say instead of sitting here and listing everything? I think we're all pretty clear on what they are, and even though we're not prioritizing, I think we'd all agree that it's an activity. I did add the pages for the MUPS class 1, for the bike lane class 2, and the bike routes class 3 in those pages, so that those are on here too, so that...
2:07:18 They can easily be identified. So when you're going through and you're dealing with one of these, you can go back and refer to it. I don't know. Is that fair enough? No, that makes sense. I'm going to retype the whole document. I'm not up for that. And these are just some of the things that I see that you would be using when you're putting a trail together or anything else.
2:07:51 These are the identifiers, benefits. It's economic and health, implementation, needs and safety, pedestrian activity and safety, access that, you know, the more people that can access this, obviously it's going to rise to the top character that needs to maintain a small town character. Engagement is community-wide workshop survey media. That's kind of the summit thing. Cooperation.
2:08:15 You know, who are the partners that we need to work with to make that happen and that it stewards, it's the natural environment and it's a sustainable design and year-round essential to maintain recreation-based economy. So those would be things I think that kind of make it maybe float to the top kind of type thing that I identified that was in here. If you're looking at priorities. I don't know. It makes sense to me.
2:08:45 I like it. Those are the things we need to look at, yes. Okay. John. Again, just one thought. Public Works Department, they're all looking at grants, finding all kinds of great opportunities. A lot of times, these projects can come forward, even though it's a void of prioritization. So I think it's going to be very helpful for you guys to establish, look, we need to do this, we need to do this.
2:09:11 So those guys have got some directions to not have any things coming at you kind of help yourself. Which is where we hope to be at the end of the prioritization process. Yeah. And if something comes forward just because there's a grant that comes forward, then it also needs to be looked at as to the benefit and to the ongoing maintenance and to, you know, there's, unfortunately, we've done things just because we have a grant and we're in trouble in the end. So, anyhow. Before we end today's meeting, there's a couple things I'd like to go back to because we have John here now.
2:09:41 And just for educational purposes for all of us here, except for me, of course. Okay. We were talking about maps earlier in the creation of maps and how much we need maps and we need paper maps and we need maps on the thing. So from a Forest Service perspective, how do we go about, because we cannot just produce a map that shows trails without getting Forest Service approval if they're on Forest Service lands.
2:10:11 So how do we get that approval? How do we make that happen in a timely fashion? Once we have this MOU in place, will there be a conduit there so that this stuff can be fairly free-flowing? Or are you so overtaxed and overstressed as is our own?
2:10:41 That's the same as the summer OHV map that's out there now.
2:11:00 And then, I guess,
2:11:25 With what John was talking about earlier, that the maps that are on the sign are going to coordinate with the maps that we're producing. That would be great if we could make sure there's kind of some consistency in the look and feel. And I think we're seeing announcing on the town and we have this grant money to decide how to make this work. We should send money towards the town and let them go to contract with it or if the town wants to contribute to it.
2:11:52 and send money towards us to do the contract. And it all depends upon how much money we're talking about and what contracting rules we're going to find out. So this year the Forest Service applied for the grant to redo the winter map? We actually applied for it last year. We have money to spend that we have to spend by December 4th of this year. Because originally it was the town that was making the application. The town and Forest Service. The town originally had submitted that and after the change from Visitor Bureau to Tourism,
2:12:21 We just started applying to the money, and we can do it either way. Right. It's just a partnership. It's a partnership. An important partnership. Yes. You have to have an agreement in place to move money. Right. Right. So that's where you have the Section 600 in the Public Court Standards. Right. What about summer, though? Same thing. Is there money available? Yes, there's money for AIDS, summer, motorized, recreation map.
2:12:48 And then a winter OSV map also includes non-motorized recreation opportunities. I think the third product that is somewhat lacking is the non-motorized free map, but there's a lot of those for sale in our bookstore too. You know, John, back in the day, the ones that were probably used the most were very specific to a certain experience that the Forest Service used to produce, and I realize that was probably before you were born.
2:13:19 What do you say? What is it? The forest, at the original visitor center, before it was rebuilt down there, you could go in and they had a whole line of mimeographed sheets and maps on them. We call them ROGS, Recreation Opportunity Guides, and we still have them. Okay. We're actually trying to update them. We're trying to update them. I've never heard them called them. We're also trying to put them on our website. We need them on our website now.
2:13:48 So it is a forest across the nation, forest service standard, and to date, like you said, front back, speaker near draft. I found something, I think it was on the forest services website, and it was trails for this area, and it gives you the distance, it gives you the type of hike it is, how hard it is, and where the trailhead is, and where you go, and I copy that for my guests.
2:14:19 They're really important. They work. We could. We should, I think, given the goals and objectives of the MLTS, create a better product that reflects the website. That's something that we could work through the Forest Service fairly quickly in terms of getting permission to...
2:14:44 Maybe you grab a bunch of them to print out a bunch. When we have something out behind our front desk, we have to meet some certain standards as far as contrasts and making sure there's a civil rights statement on that. So we want to try to adhere to some of those standards. Absolutely. That's not a very difficult thing to do. So we can create new publications and have them reviewed by our regional office. That's the other hurdle.
2:15:17 But you can start handing them out elsewhere before you're approved. And I guess I'm going to ask the question just as far as businesses. And our tasting room is a huge information center, lodging partners, that kind of thing. How do we, to enhance the visitor's experience, just get this out to the public as correct information as possible? I would see that as one of the goals of the MLTSCC for sure.
2:15:46 It's huge. Like I say, yes, people want to use the website, and that's where we should start directing people, but I copy those things like the hot cakes all summer long. Again, I'm going to go back to Tony Colisardo's comment when he said on this commission just about the number of maps that he would give out for off-road biking.
2:16:06 And the level of difficulty, the starting point, that kind of thing. But see, what Tony could do, and that's why I was asking the question about mapping. Okay. I've gotten in trouble with the Forest Service in the past, not me personally, the town has actually. Not the town, the telephone company. Because in the telephone book, they came and they asked me for a snowmobile map, and I gave them a snowmobile map. And evidently, someone at the Forest Service level took exception to one of the trails, even though it was an open trail, that was shown on the map.
2:16:36 Because they were anticipating some changes. And because it was Forest Service, at that point in time, I was told that if it's going into a publication, that it has to be approved by the Forest Service for you to be putting that trail out there. So that's why I asked the question, how do we get that approval to put it out and publish? What Tony could do is he could take any dirt road he wanted to as a private citizen, and he could make his own map saying this is a great route because...
2:17:03 The routes aren't all designated out there. You can't follow them on signs on the ground, something we're hoping to get to now that we've got the MLTSCC and the partnership going, and he can reproduce that. As a town, I don't know that we can without first getting the publishing permission from the Forest Service, which is why I asked the question in the first place. How do we make that happen quick enough so that if we want to produce some this year, if we want a Shadow Lake 8 1⁄2 by 11 Shadow Lake Trail, and I only use that as an example,
2:17:32 How do we get the permission to get that done in a timely enough fashion to print it out? And then we also go to this website that, you know, we really need to start pushing that out. That's marketing, that's maps, that's everything. Yes, I agree. And we need to get it functioning and running. Yes. Okay. John, just a couple things. One is, it's going to be, these are great challenges, great opportunities. But I think, as stewards of measure are,
2:17:58 And the relationship of Measure R to the Implementate the Trail System Master Plan to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Working out with the Forest Service the scope. What is a Mammoth Lakes Trail System product? What is strictly a Forest Service product? Figuring that kind of stuff out. If the Forest Service and the town are going to work together on these staging areas in the scenic loop, same thing with the Friends of the Indian, the Stewardship Program up in the Lakes Basin. This has all got to come home to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System somehow.
2:18:25 And I think just, it's, there's a lot of things to sort out and figure all this stuff out, but that's, I think the public's going to have an expectation that if it's a Mammoth Lakes Trail System product, okay, that makes sense, but it's going to have to meet that level of rationale. And the other point is with the maps is that within the website, Teri, whoever's interested in this, to really start exploiting that, to getting these 8.5 by 11 tear-off or things that can be easily printed and reproduced, the website can deliver a lot of that stuff.
2:18:51 That's data that's already approved by the Forest Service. They've already blessed everything that's on there. It's a question of integrating it into businesses and integrating people how to use it. It's not the whole thing, but there's a lot of tools in it that can help out with this stuff. John, I agree with you. I've told you myself that I need a new tutorial because you gave me one, and now I've forgotten how to do that. I think that at some point in time, a workshop inviting the lodging partners and everybody down to have an on-screen demonstration.
2:19:18 of the website and how to print those maps for specific because the Shadow Lake Trail's on there. Right. You can print it out and it gives you the elevation changes and it gives you the trail and everything else. How do we print up the business cards that have the QR code and those are sitting in my, because I have one of the little cards that John has and I put it on my bulletin board that has the QR code there. You know, you want to go to this, you know, here's the website. Moving on to my next question. Because we now have the MLTS, the Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
2:19:48 And we're going to formalize that with a MOU. When someone comes to us and doesn't go to the Forest Service first, such as the gentleman with the fat tire bike to look at, if that's something we want to look at, even though it's a Forest Service trail, how do we bring that discussion then to you? Just through the MLTSCC because you're sitting there? Yeah, I think, I mean, the way that happened,
2:20:16 I believe the citizens understand that there is an organization that they can go to, whether it's the Rec Commission or the MLTSCC. There's nothing wrong with that. The issue surfaced, and now you're asking, how do we resolve it? And it has to go through our formal processes. So it just needs to be brought to our attention. If the MLTSCC or the Rec Commission decide that they want to take action to try to urge the Forest Service to conduct the necessary study and go through the process, you can see that it's closer to us.
2:20:46 That says, here's what we would like to do. We would like to change the forest order to deal with bikes on the engineering system. And we'll come back to you and say, hey, here's the process we're going to have to go through. Here's how much it's going to cost. If you as a proponent want to see this happen, we don't have it in a budget because some things we may be able to say, yeah, we can do that. Don't worry about it. No money required. Some things may require a process and specialist time. And we'll say, here's how much it should cost.
2:21:16 I think that's actually kind of how things are sorted out with a fat tire fight. We've been in a lot of contact with Alex Cody, also some representatives from the IMBA, and there's somebody who's on the conference, somebody who's going to go through fat tires, and we're all talking about, we're not the open place to deal with this issue. There's a lot of other places around the country that have concerns or have prohibitions on these fights, and so we've talked about the need for it.
2:21:45 Yeah, I just use that as an example, because things like that are going to come up where somebody's asking for an extra use.
2:22:14 And then how do we as the two collaborate? Yeah, that's a great example. I think, you know, let people come forward and talk to you guys about it. I think if you all have the understanding that we have a formal process, that we have to go through, corral the information, corral the ideas, and let the public know that the Forest Service needs to be talked to or just discuss with the Forest Service. I felt the Forest Service needed to be talked to for a long time. As an example.
2:22:43 Is there more power and opportunity for those users to bring that forward themselves as individuals or through the collective power of the town and the commission and the committee, is there more power coming to the Forest Service to do that route? So if something does come to the future, could the committee or the rec commission say, well, you know, all you have to do is go talk to the Forest Service, you don't need to come to us.
2:23:13 Well, I think that no matter who comes to us, individuals, groups, they come to the agency, we're going to respond in one way or the other, but our response may be governed by how important the community feels that issue is. So if the Rec Commission feels that's an important issue and they want to throw resources at it because of this existing partnership, I have a feeling we're probably going to pay a little closer attention. If an individual comes, they really don't have any way to help the Forest Service address the issue.
2:23:42 They're a little, they don't have as many problems. So I think there is actually some influence that this committee has. We have an established partnership to work on this. Not to say that an individual can influence change, but... Right now you're looking for partners, and so, anyhow. If you need to change something, it may need a partnership. And I think, just want to throw it out there, you know, just because we all think it's a good idea. I personally think it's a great idea to have that type of advice on our travel system.
2:24:13 On some of our trail systems. Right, and that doesn't mean it's going to be the decision. I mean, you have to go through the process, the analysis, the public, the dialogue, and the decision maker, John Ruttenberg, has to actually take the end of it, because it's a force order, and it will need to be amended, and make that decision. Just out of curiosity, are there on the sleds?
2:24:38 And the forced order was put in place after the grooming program started because of the old, it started out with the three-wheeled OHVs that wanted to use the groomed trail system that tore the heck out of it, not to mention the four-wheel drive guys from Southern California and their Toyotas who thought that they could drive down the roads because they were groomed.
2:25:08 But primarily it was the OHVs that were coming up to use that specifically and were just tearing the groom into pieces. And I have the same fear of the fat bikes. I know they say that they float really well. But as you know, in slush conditions or in really cold conditions, I'd be anxious to see. That's why I said they should contact you and we should go out on the trail system in different conditions and look at what kind of track they lay down. Use some data. That's exactly right.
2:25:38 Anything else? Any other public comments? I think we're good. I move to adjourn. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Those in favor? Aye. Opposed? We're done.