Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 2 hr 46 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
348 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
0:01 Thank you.
0:31 Thank you.
0:51 Thank you.
1:10 Thank you.
1:39 Thank you. Thank you.
2:08 Did you get the electronic version? I've got a hard copy for you right here. You never know.
2:38 Well...
2:43 I was really embarrassed last time I showed up. One time I was most prepared. I really did have it. I wonder where it is now. Oh, you know what?
3:11 Thank you.
3:28 Thank you.
3:43 Thank you.
4:13 Okay. Okay. Okay.
4:26 Good, she explained it all to you, so I don't need to know anything.
4:55 Do you want me to give them to you now? We did. Absolutely. Well, no. One year we had several years. Tony and I got together and came up with a starting point. Step back four feet, please.
5:24 What 28.3 is what we have to give away, is that correct? No, it's 28.8 but then minus 6. Yeah.
5:49 I don't know whether they had previous funding. I mean, I know a couple other groups. But how many years? We are alive here.
6:10 Thank you.
6:20 Next Friday.
6:49 Thank you.
7:18 Thank you.
7:47 Thank you.
8:12 Thank you.
8:41 Thank you.
9:01 So to speak. I will call to order this regularly scheduled meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Commission roll call, please. Here. Here. Present.
9:30 Here. Public Comments, this is the time that any member of the public wishing to speak on anything that doesn't otherwise appear on the agenda. We will... You were fidgeting there, John. Are you good? Okay. I just want to make sure. We will close public comments. Consent agenda. Anybody want to pull anything off of consent or make a motion? I move to accept the consent agenda minutes. I second it.
10:02 I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Policy matters. The 2013 youth sports funding. Good afternoon, commissioners. Stephanie Daniel, recreation supervisor. Apologize for the voice. Anyways, before you guys, you have your packets for the 2013 youth sports funding applications from the following six applicants.
10:39 AYSO, Disabled Sports, Eastern Sierra, Mammoth Lake Swim Team, Mammoth Youth Football, Mono County Little League, and Husky Club. So what I'd like to do right now, you guys have all been through your packets and had a chance to review everything. I think for the benefit of Betsy, our newest commissioner, and we do have some new faces on these boards, I'd like to just do just a quick introduction, have each of them come up one at a time, starting with AYSO and Stuart Need.
11:09 And then we'll just go down the list and everybody just come up and say who you are and what your group is. Stuart Nee, Regional Commissioner for AOSO, took over from Stu Brown two months ago. Thank you for your consideration for AOSO today. I'm Laurel Martin from Disabled Sports Eastern Sierra. I'm the Summer Program Manager and Guest Services Manager. I'm standing in for Kathy Copeland who can be here today and we really appreciate the Commission's support for our local kids being able to get out there for our Springtacular event every year. So thank you for your consideration.
11:52 Hello, I'm Christy Furness, and I'm the president of the Mammoth Lake Swim Team. Donna Hustleton, I'm the Mammoth Lake Swim Team Controller. Hi, my name is Teresa Desert, and I'm the new president for the Mammoth Youth Football League in town. Thank you. Hello, Christy Williams, I am the new treasurer for Mono County Little League. Thanks. And Barbara Miller from the Husky Club couldn't make it with us tonight. So, thanks again, all you guys for coming. Welcome, you new board members, and hope you know what you're getting into.
12:37 Because it's going to be fun. So this time, I know you guys did your homework, commissioners, and I'm going to just turn it right over to Bill and let's get to some numbers. Okay, guys, how do you want to go here? It was my idea that anybody that asked for the same that was awarded last year, we just move that figure across. The difference, my understanding, is $1,900 between what we got and what is being asked. I was just about to start doing the math. What's the...
13:07 What's the math if we just went straight across awarding what we did last year? The math is we have $500 extra to distribute. Woohoo. Okay. So if you would like to start the conversation is where to put that $500. I think that would be a great way to go. Can I ask a question of some of the people who are here today? Especially on this first page with regard to the staff report.
13:36 It talks percentage of Mammoth Lakes area residences. And for instance, you know, disabled sports, it says 100%, but then also in the very next column says participants come from out of the area. Funds used, oh, I say, okay, for local scholarships. I guess my question, though, was going to be about all of the Mammoth Lakes residences. We've got some that, for instance, the Mammoth Lakes swim team says 99%. I was just wondering if the Mammoth Lakes swim team
14:06 Aren't there more participants who are from Mono County? Or am I misunderstanding that it's true that 99% of them are all just from... Thank you, Danette. Down at Hustleton. That is true. There's not many that come from Collie and outside the area. I actually thought it was a little bit less, but after they ran the numbers and pretty much most of the kids come from Mammoth Lakes. Okay. Okay. So I just...
14:39 99% out of 90 is, you know, percentage of a person. I was just curious if you had any. I didn't do it. Okay. We can talk to Christy, but maybe, I think they got a little confused, but basically it's about 95% almost that come out of.
14:56 Okay, so you're not able to get a more accurate number? If you like. I actually brought my computer. I can pull my spreadsheet, and I can add it up real quick for you with Chrissy's help because she's the one that knows. Well, I guess I just wanted to, you know, state that I had some questions about, you know. I can do that right now. Okay. Thank you. But I think the question is Mammoth area residents. It didn't distinguish. So you're looking at people outside of Mammoth? Yeah, Mono County. Mono. Specifically. Or Inyo. Okay.
15:25 Remember, part of that conversation was tied to our thought that at some point in time we'd like Mono County to be a better advocate and supporter for Mono County youth than not having to pick up that tab. Not that we were voting anyone up or down based on that. It was just an interesting fact to have. I think when we were reviewing this application process, the way we added that is to Mammoth Lakes area residents.
15:51 Was because, you know, Mono County Little League, the way that their league is divided up, it's by counties. Even though predominantly most of the kids live in Mammoth Lakes, we do have teams from outside of the town within, you know, Colville, Bridgeport, and so on. So I think we wanted to make sure we captured that area too, not just the kids that live in Mammoth Lakes. I just wanted to ask that question. Makes sense though.
16:26 That was kind of just my overall question that I had. Okay. Do any of you have any numbers in you'd like to throw out for consideration? Or do you want me to start that game? I had some, but I based it on an erroneous figure to give away. It's right here in my hand. I'm looking all over for it. I've got it in my hand. We have 28 800s, too.
17:00 $28,800, and you traditionally give them $6,000, which would give you a balance of $22,800 for the remaining application. Right. Do we have $500 more than we did last year? I don't believe so. I think it was $28,800 last year because we kept 10% last year. If we go to the 2012 award, it said $28,300, and that's what I based my calculations off of.
17:32 Oh, I see, because 500 is missing from, gotcha. Yeah. I just figured it out. Youth softball did not, I apologize for that. This year, the youth softball did not apply. So there is essentially, compared to last year, an extra $500 in the pot towards these guys. Do we need to spend that? Well, it doesn't stay in the pot. Okay, we need to spend it. Yes. Okay.
18:02 I think we might want to look at some organizations that have the greater numbers like AYSO, Little League, maybe give them a little bit more money. Or maybe we could look at the groups that have a longer season. I know a swim team had a pretty long season, as does AYSO Little League. And I sort of looked at it the same way. I'm going to throw my numbers out there for you.
18:34 Someone can tell me if these add up or not. AYSO, at their request for $7,000, they have far and away more participants than any other group, and that soccer organization does a great job. Disabled sports, I was going to keep it the same as last year, $27.50. Then I would bump both the swim team and the youth football, I think it's $125 each from last year.
19:04 3725 for the swim team, and 5725 for youth football, 3700 for Little League because it's the same ask as last year, and six for Husky Club, that should come 28-8. I got 28-9. What was happening? If you're saying 250 for AYSO and then you're splitting the remaining. You're splitting the remaining 250 between the swim team and youth football.
19:40 One and a quarter. Yeah. That sounds good. That's my starting suggestion. That's fine. Can we ask the football, or before I say that's fine, um, and actually maybe I need to read in a little bit deeper with regard to the football team. How come you're asking for a thousand dollars more? Because you ran out of aircasts. Bad joke, sorry.
20:09 And the reason we're asking for more money this year is there's several reasons. One, last year we only had two divisions, Division I and Division II, and this year we have a large amount of kids from Division II that are now able to move up to Division III. So instead of having two teams, we're going to have three. And the other reason is in order to come into compliance with our youth football regulations, we need to...
20:33 Put together quite a bit of first aid equipment. Right now we have just a small amount and we really need to have first aid equipment for every team including the cheerleaders which is, you know, quite a bit of stuff that we need to put together in a kit so that they always have all the first aid stuff that they need at every practice and every game. Right now we're sharing one within the four teams and it's not really feasible to do that because if we're not practicing at the same sites or we have a coach who...
20:59 You know, they're trying to get it back and forth between each other. So first aid equipment and the addition of a whole new division. That's the reason. Thank you. I have a point of clarification. How is the money awarded? Is it at the conclusion of the season or is it at the beginning of the sports season? The money comes out by June of every year. So right now we're just in the process.
21:34 You know, it might be towards the end of their season. Like right now, Little League has already started, and AYSO kind of has started because they've got some spring soccer, but most of them, you know, like they'll get their checks June, you know, beginning of June, by the end of the fiscal year for sure because it's in this fiscal year. So then, you know, they'll have the money to spend on this season. AYSO and for the bulk of their season and for Mammoth Youth Football, they don't start until the end of August or right around there, correct?
22:04 Beginning of August. And AYSO starts more towards the end. So usually I don't, nobody's ever had an issue with like, oh my God, we didn't get our check-in time because we need that money. What happens if an organization's enrollment is less than expected? Or more than expected? Well, answer my own question with more than expected. But if it's less than expected. We really haven't had an issue with that. Everybody's, you know,
22:36 For the money that they've historically gotten, as far as I know, they've pretty much used up every penny for what they've needed, whether it's helmets for football or batting helmets for baseball or full uniform replacements for some of our pads and replacements like that. To most of my knowledge, when they reapply the following year, they'll tell you what they spent it on, particularly for that. How did you spend your money last year is how it's written in the application.
23:06 I think it just depends on what they needed that year. Let's face it, we could give them all twice as much and they could all find ways, they were very legitimate ways of spending it. So I'm pretty comfortable with the way I laid it out in some of those changes. That's fine. Steph, did you capture all those numbers? Do you want to put them up on the screen while you're there if you need the chair to read those numbers to you again? Yeah, Bill, why don't you go back and read your numbers again?
23:34 Okay, 3725 for the swim team. So you had 7,000 for AYSO, 2750 for disabled. 3725. 5625, 3700, and 6000. Whoops, see I'm not paying attention. We haven't moved. No. Multitasking. I keep looking for the mouse, I apologize.
24:06 That number adds up to 28,800. Yeah. Next is 5625. And skip that and go down 3,700. 6,000. And we have added it. That total is 2,800. Sorry, I'm still not ready. What do you call this thing? Just go to the 7,000th cell. Just click and drag it down to the 6,000. That's right. You haven't got your mouse.
25:06 We accept these funding amounts as listed shortly on the screen. I have a motion in two seconds. Any further deliberation? All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed? Stu, you got all that, buddy? Stu, it's been quick. Matthew, mate. Again, we would like to thank you all for what you do. You know what, without the volunteers and the parents and everything to bring this forward,
25:42 None of these programs would exist. We realize we're giving you a pittance, and with it you're performing miracles, so we really do thank you for your participation and the time you spend here and out on the fields. Thank you. So it's scheduled to go to council. Everybody's here. We might try and get it on May 1st. It was scheduled for May 16th, so we'll try and get that expedited for your organizations.
26:18 Thank you. Okay, moving on to policy number five. Stu, I lied. We got that in 30 minutes, buddy. Yeah. Saving time. Update on the Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access proposal to provide an expanded trail program.
26:57 So item number five is an ongoing item we've had on the agenda for a couple of meetings now. This is the response from the town which is attached to what's included in your staff report itself on page two. You can see the comments are listed in bullet format and then we did receive a letter dated April 2nd from the U.S. Forest Service which is also attached to your document to your staff report. So I do want to say it's been
27:27 When the proposal came in at the end of January, it's been a three-month process. I think it's been very informative, productive. Several meetings have been held with all those parties. So I think the process alone has been very valuable. You can see the town at this time doesn't see or does not identify really an approach moving forward that would support the proposal as it stands. And in the Forest Service comments you can read,
27:56 That report, as you will, but I believe they came to the same conclusion from that proposal that was received. So it went to the MLTSCC last evening. I know members were there. I think everybody was there. So I know the action. There was really no action taken from that committee. It was a motion addressed. So at this time, it's before the commission. Council would just like an update on the comments.
28:26 from both the MLTACC and the Recreation Commission regarding the proposal that was presented by MLTPA on April 16th. So that's really going to be the context of that item itself. It won't at this time include any other information regarding the subsequent discussions. It's really going to be specific just to this item unless the Commission feels strongly that they want to include any other language pertaining outside the proposal that was received.
28:54 With that chair, I'll keep that very brief and turn it over to the commission. Did you mean on the 17th of April? 17th, yeah, Wednesday, is that right? 17th now? There's so many meetings next week. It's Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, 17th. At this time, what I'd like to do, we have a letter here from Terry. She cannot be at the meeting today, and she has asked if Betsy should read that into the records, or if you would.
29:22 I will, and also, if I could just call a point of order, I'm not sure, did the proposal ever actually appear on an agenda for us to discuss? Because I believe it was agendized, it was removed from the agenda, I know we've all sort of seen it, but I'm not sure, just in terms of public notice, if that ever happened. Actually, I do not think it ever happened. The March 5th meeting, it was policy number 4, and at that time,
29:51 It gave the Commission just an overview of the steps that have been taken and what was moving forward and I believe everyone did receive a copy of that document. I don't believe it ever appeared in a Commission packet, I think. Was that your question? Yeah, that's my concern. It was publicly noticed because it was removed from our agenda. Yeah, so it was removed, I think, in February and the first time was on March 5th, right, and then this is our second time.
30:16 That was my concern yesterday. I just want to say is that, you know, the MLTSCC was asked to vote on that yesterday, but the actual proposal was not included in our packet. So, you know, and Stu, I thank you very much for sending that to me individually. I don't know, because we had received it, but that it wasn't included in the actual package. Anyway, I hope we've had a chance to review it. So I'll read Terry's letter.
30:43 Fellow Recreation Commissioners, please accept this correspondence in response to item number five on our April 9, 2013 meeting agenda. While I appreciate the perspective and observations collectively being provided by town and Inyo National Forest staff regarding the formation of a MLTS NGO, I would like to offer a different option for our commission to consider and recommend the formation of Mammoth Lakes Recreation.
31:07 In 2009, then members of our commission along with council members, town staff, Inyo National Forest staff, representatives from a variety of local NGOs and other agencies participated in a facilitated public process to explore forming a non-governmental organization that would address a recreation capacity and sustainability problem. At the time of this process, the town was experiencing significant budget shortfalls.
31:32 And with the impending formation of Mammoth Lakes Tourism, the town's recreation budget was going to be significantly impacted. Unfortunately, due to a number of factors, the process was not completed, but did lead to the development of RecStrats. Fast forward to 2013, and our local landscape looks a bit different. MLT has been successfully operating for over two years.
31:51 Measures R&U are annually generating approximately $1.5 million for recreation, trails, mobility, and arts and culture, and the town has settled the MLL age, lawsuit judgment, and is even forecasting a budget surplus for this current fiscal year. However, we still face significant challenges related to growing and enhancing our recreation product. Our federal agency partners are facing budget and capacity cuts, and town capacity continues to be impacted by ongoing stress on the budget.
32:18 Because of these continuing issues, I believe now is the right time to complete the process began in 2009 and form MLR. The rationale for forming MLR includes a need to ensure that Mammoth Lakes has the leadership capacity and resources to identify and develop emerging recreation opportunities expected of a destination resort. A need for an organization that has an entrepreneurial spirit charged with leveraging Measure R&U funds through the development of strategic business partners, grants, and additional funding streams.
32:47 A need for having a place for individual recreation user groups to connect with for more collaborative and efficient efforts. A need for an organization that can manage and program the new facilities and programs that are being developed through Measure R and U funds, including Whitmore Track, Mammoth Lakes Trail System, and a biathlon facility. A desire for making a bold, big, and innovative change that will lead to truly enhancing and growing our recreation product instead of continuing to make incremental decisions that enable our existing conditions. I would like to propose the following.
33:17 Reconvene the participants from the 2009-2010 MLR process and identify additional participants to join in a facilitated process that will define the role, scope, and organizational structure of MLR similar to the process used for the formation of MLT. Use the notes, group exercises, and findings from the 2009-2010 MLR process as the groundwork for this process. Support and nurture this process through to the formation of MLR.
33:41 I would like to be clear, this is about creating economic vitality and delivering a high quality of life for our community by establishing an entity that has the vision, desire, and creativity to grow and sustain our recreation product. This is about pulling together and leveraging our significant resources to deliver a world-class recreation experience. Just as we did with the formation of Mammoth Lakes Tourism, this is about what's doing right for Mammoth Lakes. I believe there is support from members of our Town Council to bring this idea and proposal forward for their approval of actions necessary to get the process underway.
34:11 I also believe we have many talented individuals in our community who can bring their expertise and leadership to this effort. Finally, I believe the timing is right for this effort and we should act. Now is the time for smart and innovative actions. Thank you for your consideration. Sincerely, Teri Stehlik. And we're copied as well as the council. Okay, who'd like to pick it up? We've also heard from, at least I have gotten emails from the town manager and one or two councils. I don't know if you've gotten all of those or not.
34:47 And they're sitting in my printer, so I can't read them to you. I've seen comments from the town manager. I think we were all copied on that. Yes. But I haven't seen anything from cancer. Go ahead. We'll start us off. Just from what I recall from yesterday's presentation at the MLTCC meeting,
35:13 I think, Stu, correct me if I'm wrong, that staff in the Forest Service and board members of MLTPA spent numerous hours reviewing this concept and coming to these conclusions. Well, yeah, I think we estimated there was probably about eight or ten people in each of these meetings with the commissioners, so in everyone's time it was 60 to 100 hours of time in over three months, so I mean there's been a lot of time committed to the endeavor, which is
35:42 Like I said, it was a very productive process. I think that these are two separate topics. I think that we should look at the staff report and what the recommendation is and deliberate upon that. And I think what Commissioner Sillick is proposing is, you know, warranted and we should look at that. But I think it really should require more of a focused review of
36:15 of that and learning more about the history of what occurred in 2009 and before that. So I kind of see them as two separate items. You know, I think that we're looking at staff report and recommendations from the staff and the Forest Service separately from an MLR concept. I made comments yesterday, and I do have some, but I'd actually like to hear, because I got to make comments yesterday, I'd like to hear Betsy's first.
36:47 Well, you know, I have a couple of comments. And, you know, one thing is we hear so often from staff and we know how hard you guys are working with few resources. And so one thing I'd like to hear a little bit from all of you, and especially because I know you did put so much time into these discussions with the Forest Service, is, you know, we're hearing that, you know, there is a great burden on staff.
37:13 And that recreation has certainly expanded far beyond municipal recreation here with Measure R, Measure U. There's a lot on your plates, especially stew. So I'd just like to hear just a little bit in terms of if something like this, not necessarily this, because we certainly heard from the Forest Service on that, but I'd like to hear a little bit about would something like this alleviate that problem? What are other ways that we could address it?
37:45 So just to clarify the question, so what you're saying is if we wanted to consider an NGO, if it was more or less demand on staff time? Yeah, if that would help alleviate. Right. Well, I think the first step, I think it comes back to the productivity and efficiency of the MLTCC. So that body requested assistance and help, kind of what they call an expediter, champion, so to speak, of the trail system.
38:16 With that direction, staff then went through that body, we created an RFP, we did a scope of work, and we hired Steve Spidell to assist in that effort. So we've had two meetings with Steve, so we're trying to catch up and actually move things along in a far more efficient manner. So that has been, I believe, far more efficient for staff because staff now just needs to oversee
38:42 the work that the consultant's doing, not actually do all the work that's required for that committee. So, I mean, the proof is in the pudding and maybe the committee members can respond on, you know, how they see that hiring, how that hiring is going. And I think the Forest Service commented on their kind of efficiency. And I think the issue that came up with the Forest Service is the relationship, and I know Ray can talk about it more, the relationship right now with that MOU is really the town and the Forest Service.
39:10 So that's our first step that we want to really try and solidify as a partnership. And I don't want to speak on their behalf, but that's really how they see the relationship. So that's really how we've explored it. So from an efficiency point of view, I think we've committed to the consultants for the next several months, I think, till the end of June. The committee can evaluate how that's working. But from a staff's point of view,
39:39 Certainly saving us a lot of time, but also not the time saving, it's actually more productive in the work that that group is hopefully accomplishing, you know, more to the point. So I think they're getting more done than what was being done before, right? So I think you've actually got a designated, you know, person responsible for the trail system and the information of that trail system master plan. Did I answer your question? It did. I don't know if Ray has anything to add, but then I have a question. First I just wanted to
40:09 Suggest that the proposal that was submitted was a much narrower focus than what we're talking about in terms of Terry's letter, that the whole MLR approach is completely different and it's a much broader concept. So the comments that were developed by both town staff and the Forest Service were really focused on a different idea altogether. I think, you know, certainly in talking with Marianna,
40:39 And others, there's certainly support for exploring the idea of an MLR. And to answer your question in terms of does that sort of relieve staff of the overburden, I suppose it really depends ultimately on what the scope of MLR becomes. You know, certainly managing Measure R and Measure U funds, accounting for them.
41:08 you know ensuring that they're efficiently used and and collected and spent and on what they're intended for that's a lot of time Stewart spends an awful lot of time on you know accounting his preferred area of expertise and where he really wants to spend time is on municipal recreation and I think given that opportunity you know we would see Stewart would certainly
41:38 Be happier, and I think we would see, you know, that that's a role that he will play quite well and perform in quite well. So I guess to answer your question, it really sort of depends ultimately on what MLR encompasses. Certainly, you know, it could potentially include the trail system and how that's managed. It could include winter and summer recreation, resort recreation. I think there's, you know, many, many
42:07 Ideas, and certainly all of you have ideas of what potentially could be included there. So, again, I would just suggest that the proposal as originally submitted was a much narrower focus. That's what those comments are, you know, really looking at and considering. And, you know, we would certainly welcome the idea of going forward and exploring an MLR. I think it could be a good thing. Thanks, Ray. I really appreciate that answer. That really clarifies a lot for me.
42:36 I guess, you know, I agree with Pat. I think these are two separate conversations. And I am, I think we're all very, well, I don't want to speak for Bill and Sean, but I think that we're all very open to revisiting MLR, especially in light of the workshop process that we're going through and how we will implement whatever it is that we decide to implement. I guess, I just wanted to, and I'm glad that John is here too, I just, I,
43:05 found this letter from the Forest Service a little bit dismissive. And I understand if this particular proposal, if this is not the right thing or the right people at this time. But I do think that as the stewards of these public funds, we need to be doing the best job that we can. And I'm a little bit concerned that we're approaching the end of the fiscal year and
43:31 Less than a third of the 300,000 has been contracted. And, you know, I know Sean yesterday, his new chairmanship of the MLTSCC, maybe you can speak a little bit about, you know, I know that's sort of a young organization and you guys are kind of finding your feet and I have so much respect for everyone who sits on that body. Maybe if you can just speak a little bit to how you feel things are going.
43:55 You know, if you think that things could be better within that, or if we need to be looking at a different solution in the lot wider. Which is actually item 6, so if you're going to deal with that after this, I think it would be good. Okay. Well, and I'll speak a little bit to that, but are you finished with your comments? I think it ties into this conversation. Yeah, I'm finished for now. Okay. Well, then, if I may, I'll go ahead and make some comments. Okay. Sure. Thanks.
44:19 First of all, what I want to say is that this does seem to be a politically charged, contentious issue, and that's unfortunate. And I understand why it's pushing some buttons, especially in light of what's happened with regard to the lawsuit and staff reductions and everything that's going on. But the thing that I want to say is that, first of all, I'll state my position, is that I would like to explore this further in the grander concept of an MLR, not necessarily in the trails.
44:48 For a couple of reasons. First of all, because either, you know, it's been coming up and back and forth for the past couple of years now, and I either would like to explore this to advance it or to put it to bed, to put it away. So that's why I'm going to agree with, just to state my position going forward as I make my comments, that I am going to recommend that we begin exploring this further, not necessarily in the context that the proposal is in front of us the way it's currently written, but just so that we can either
45:17 Do we take it further or do we not? But the comment that I really want to say with regard to the contentiousness of this issue is that this actually could create more opportunities than actually doing away with staff time or taking away any kind of responsibilities from town staff. And I'm not trying to take away any kind of municipal programming or anything in saying this. Let's explore this because I've found in exploring these kind of issues that more often than not they at least open doors for discussion.
45:46 So I just want to make that clear that I would like to explore this to either advance it, to put it to bed, but certainly to look at other opportunities that are available to us. With regard to the letter from John Riegelbrook, yeah, I was a little disheartened by that as well. Felt it was dismissive or even possibly even threatening that the U.S. Forest Service would perhaps walk away from the table if we were to consider such a proposal.
46:14 As I made clear in John Kazmierski, I'm really glad to see you here in the audience today. I want to be very clear that as it stands right now, I would, again, like to explore this discussion with what we, the town of Mammoth Lakes, are going to do with our recreation program, but that, please, the message that I would like to send to the U.S. Forest Service at this time is that we're not making any changes. We certainly haven't adopted the proposal. It didn't come out of the meeting yesterday that we are...
46:44 Trying to change anything up at this time. U.S. Forest Service, you've got a great partner with us. We are going to continue to advance that, the MLTSCC, to partly answer your question with regard to the MLTSCC, the CC, the Coordinating Committee that we've got right now. I think we've started a new day. The first year was a little bit of trying to find ourselves.
47:14 We lost a member, Jim Smith. We're now, we've now got a new chair and vice chair. We are going to be looking at what the composition is in the next meeting. So I think that the MLTSCC is starting to get traction. I just want to make sure that we remain focused. So with regard, getting back to just the proposal though, I think that it does need to be taken into context of a larger recreation program. And
47:44 In saying that, I have heard from most of the town counselors that they would, if not all of the town counselors, that they would like to see this discussion advanced. I would like to make sure that with the meetings that have happened to date, Stu and Ray and everyone, is that the most important thing that we can do both coming out of those meetings and going forward in light of what Terry's recommendation is,
48:14 is capture the questions. First of all, why are we even considering this? Why would this be better than the current structure? And I think that there's a lot of answers there that can go either way. Then there's a lot of what-if questions. There's a lot of questions with regard to how does this work? What's the legal authority? What's the structure of it? I know that MLT went through a lot of these questions.
48:38 Again, I think that they can be answered, and I think that they need to be done in a transparent way. So that's another reason why I'm supporting Terry's recommendation as far as just continuing to advance it. Those are essentially my comments. Okay. Since you guys both brought it up, I'm going to deal with the letter as well. Okay. Boy, John should have had a gentler, kinder person wordsmith that letter for him.
49:06 The idea of a letter coming forward from a partner saying that if you don't do as we ask, we're going to take our ball and go home, especially when our ball is public lands, just doesn't sit too good. However, I'm sure the relationship with the Forest Service, because it's advantageous for both groups, will continue to go forward. I want to move the conversation forward, as you've all said.
49:34 on an NGO. Whether that NGO is for trails, whether it's for recreation, whether it provides recreation or is just the visioning outreach nonprofit side, you know, as the mountain has created a nonprofit for fundraising and stuff, the town is in need of doing the same thing. We need to have that outreach and towns typically are very bad at doing that.
50:04 How can we, in yesterday's meeting, it was brought up that what we have to do is put more money in staff and then staff will be able to accomplish more. Well, we have a staff that's way overburdened now. They can't accomplish more unless we throw so much cash at them that they can increase their numbers. How does that work? When we went through the MLR process in the first place, it was a very kumbayati kind of experience.
50:30 Where we all talked, you know, wistfully about this great organization, what could accomplish. The place we never got down to was the nuts and bolts. We never got down to what can the town give up. There are certain things it has to do by law. Are we going to have a planning staff at the town that has to look over everything a planning staff somewhere else is going to do? I don't know the answer to that. Does that really save us anything? So for me,
50:57 It's the nuts and bolts that haven't been looked at. We need to look at this from trails, from Mammoth Lakes Recreation, determine what is the product and what's the best way to provide that product. And I don't know what that answer is. We don't know if we have an NGO and they have to have a trails planter, but then the Forest Service has to go back over it and the town has to go back over it. We've duplicated the effort three times.
51:23 But if it's something the town or the Forest Service can give up to an outside agency and we can get it done in a smaller per hour or get it done in a faster fashion, then it's worthwhile. So I think the nuts and bolts haven't been looked at and we've drawn lines in the sand, or some of us have, before we've looked at those things. And I would like to see us all perhaps retract some of what we've said and sit at the table and see how we best can deliver this package called recreation.
51:51 To the public, not just local, but the visiting public that deserves to have that level of recreation offered to them. And that's where I am. So I would like to see this move forward without qualification of it has to be this and not that. And see what the town's capacity is. And is there a way for us to add to that that is to the benefit to all? Or is it just building in town? And I don't know the answers to that. I sat through all of MLR.
52:20 and hope to be involved from this point on. From my standpoint, we never answered the nut and bolts questions. We answered, does this sound good? Would this be wonderful? We never even looked at whether or not perhaps it should be a recreation district from the county level to put money into this and to move it forward. There are still so many questions unanswered. I would like to have those answered.
52:51 So if I'm, oh sorry. We have Pat Wood, go. Well, I'd like to make a motion because I still, coming back full circle, think that these are two separate issues. I think item, agenda item five is separate from the concepts that you're talking about within the law. So I would recommend or make a motion that we accept the staff report and schedule a meeting, a commission meeting, where we could dedicate a focused energy into looking into
53:18 The concept that was presented by Commissioner Stehlik so that we could learn more about the history because not all of us were on that committee or that approach or I don't know how much of the public was really involved in the discussions regarding an MLR. I guess I'm getting beyond my motion here. It's getting too wordy. But I think that we should spend dedicated time in looking at an MLR concept at a future commission meeting.
53:47 because it's a worthy concept that deserves due diligence. So that's my motion. I would second that motion if we could amend it, Pat, to say that the discussion would be guided by these questions that Marianna posed to us. Well, those and other questions that were captured in the initial conversations, and boy, we know that more is going to come up, too. You know, I think that we can learn a lot from how MLT was created.
54:16 I would like to ask, you know, is there precedent for this? Is there any other municipalities that have NGOs running their recreation department? What I was going to, has it been a second? Are we in discussion yet at all? I'm not too sure if I jump in yet. So we have a motion in a second. Now any further deliberation? So that's where we're at. But does staff have input? You know, one of the areas that I have a problem with is we keep,
54:48 Comparing this potential NGO, regardless of where it goes, with MLT, we would never get such an attractive go out of nowhere. The fact is, it worked well with tourism because it is such a finite thing. Recreation has so many tentacles and so many outreaches and so many different things and so many things that the town has to do that they really are two different monsters. Can it be done? I'm sure it can.
55:17 Does it look like MLT? I don't think it looks anything like MLT. I think that this is far too convoluted and complicated to be that simple, to just hand over a bunch of money and say, here, create recreation. We can say marketing, if people understand it. So from my standpoint, I would caution against us looking at it as the same as MLT, or housing for that matter, if they are nowhere near as complex as recreation.
55:47 What I was going to recommend, thank you Commissioner, was exactly what Commissioner Agnich stated. So we want to keep on task related to the item. I think in the motion is that discussion on Mammoth Lakes Recreation, staff would recommend that we do agendize this for the May meeting.
56:08 And then what staff would actually provide to the Commission at that time is your current work plan. So to take in consideration what we're trying to accomplish now, when we could kind of fit this into our work plan, as you know. We're still halfway through our racial facilities. We've still got to do the arts and culture component. We've still got to review the whole Measure R for the ward and that process. So, you know, I do want to...
56:29 Cautionist to kind of keep this in perspective right now. So that was staff's goal for the May meeting to specifically agendise this item, staff can bring the work plan, we can discuss that, maybe put a timeline together and then maybe start the discussion on the questions that we need to answer and then maybe direct staff into what other, you know, organisations you'd like us to consider like we did with the Measure U funding. So that was staff's recommendation at this time, Chair. Before I go to the audience, John.
57:07 Good afternoon. My name is John Wentworth. I'm the CEO and board president of MLTPA. On behalf of the board, the board member here with us today, just to thank you for your careful and deliberate deliberations of these two questions. And I think the question before you is the MLTPA NGO proposal, and we've heard your words, and I think the only question I have is to ask
57:31 There was a vote yesterday at the MLTSCC where the MLTSCC made a recommendation to this body with regard to the staff action. And I'm not sure, I'd just like to hear that representatives of what that was to inform your disposition of that effort. The second thing is with regard to MLR, MLR was a process that involved a lot of stakeholders outside of the town. It was not a town-driven process. It was not a town-driven process.
57:58 Facilitated or convened process. The town certainly participated, was involved in all the discussions, and I would encourage you to stick with the spirit of MLRs, which I believe Teri Stehlik talked about in her letter, to continue with a process that involves all of the stakeholders who have an interest in that process. The Rec Commission is highly burdened at this point with a lot of work that you guys have to do as a staff, and I think perhaps it makes sense to recommend this to the council.
58:25 For their meeting next week to get some direction from them as how they'd like to proceed with this thing. Maybe get it out of your, off of your plate immediately to try to get some sense of how to pull this thing back together. That would be consistent with what was happening back in 2009, 2010. I would offer those suggestions. Thank you. Thank you, John. And my memory of yesterday's meeting was we actually didn't ever vote on this because we did not come to full consensus. We actually had a motion, we had a second, and then we did vote. Did we vote? It did not pass. It did not pass, right? Right. It was a two, three.
58:55 vote. And the motion was very similar to the one we did. Yeah, it was just to, I think, accept the recommendation and to recommend the commission agenda as the Mammoth Lakes Recreation discussion. I think that's what the... Steve, are you able to read what the actual motion was that failed? I don't have it verbatim, but the motion was made and seconded to concur with the U.S. Forest Service in-town staff at this time and to recommend...
59:23 to the Recreation Committee to agendize a broader NGO discussion for Mammoth Lakes Recreation to include Mammoth Lakes Trail System. That did not carry it. It got two votes in favor and three opposed. And then there was consensus that no consensus was being reached through that discussion and that it was my task to come before you today and describe what I've just described.
59:52 10 other points that were brought up in the discussion to show how divergent the opinions are on the issue. That's my recollection as well. And yeah, I thought it was kind of interesting. I think that we were all being very cautious just in how we wanted to advance this. And I think that what came out of that vote was essentially just to advance the comments. Right. And I will say as one of the dissenters that voted no not to carry it forward,
1:00:22 My concern was just shutting off any dialogue on that proposal because it really has not been as vetted as it could have been and seen the light of day. And perhaps I was still burning a little from John's letter. John Rigelroo's letter, to be clear. We have a lot of Johns in the room. Yes. Can I ask a question? Well, just make a comment with regard to John Wentworth's comments just now. What is the advantage?
1:00:53 What's on the agenda today is essentially accept this report, recommendation, accept this report. Yesterday's recommendation was to accept the, well, essentially to concur with the determination of the U.S. Forest Service and town staff that the MLTPA proposal is not needed at this time. I think that what we're trying to accomplish today here and what we can make the recommendation is that we want this discussion to go forward.
1:01:22 So the way that I'm understanding the motion that's currently on the table in light of what John Wentworth's comments are is that we are going to be making a recommendation to the April 17th Town Council meeting, just to be clear, that this conversation go forward. Is that just to kind of sum up the motion in light of John Wentworth's comments? My understanding that the April's, that I guess Stu or staff are going to take comments discussed here and
1:01:51 Just share that with the Council. But no formal recommendation. Well, I think what they're looking for is whether or not we recommend it moving forward. Right now, the issue that we're discussing, am I wrong? Update on Mammoth Lakes Trails and Public Access Proposal to Provide an Expanded Trail Program. That's what we're discussing. There's no mention of an MLR in that report. That's correct.
1:02:19 So that's what I think our focus is for right now, and that's what will then be communicated to council, I guess, if that's what they would like. But there's another issue that has been presented that's not on the agenda for discussion, and that's what my thought was, is that we should put it on agenda, have full discussion, learn history about what transpired in the past, and then start to formulate some ideas and concepts and, you know, might not be settled in one meeting. Maybe it takes...
1:02:47 A little bit of effort to really fully digest it and come up with a conclusion or a proposal. And I do agree with what Betsy mentioned. Mariana has addressed several key issues that I guess should be part of that discussion. Can I ask a question just with regard to this in light of this conversation? Is there any concern with regard to timing?
1:03:13 You know, obviously, the sooner the better, and I don't want to create more bureaucracy or more meetings or anything like that, per se. But this doesn't necessarily, isn't really facing a deadline or anything that's going to go away, is there? Okay, just wanted to be clear. Donna, you've been standing. I don't want to wear you out. Donna Hustleton. And I'd like to answer Sean's question about the kids. I didn't get to answer that. I added them up.
1:03:41 Twenty-five kids out of 90 were from Small Meadows, Crawley Lake, and June Lake. Okay. If that answers your question. Thank you very much. Now I'd like to address this. My personal feeling, I found it to be a bad idea, and these are the reasons why I find it bad, is in the letter that Teri wrote, she only addresses three items of new things that have happened, has happened in the past to start this NGO.
1:04:09 The problem is, is I see competition for the money. The competition would be, well, what about the rest of the stuff, the soccer fields, the baseball fields, Whitmore Pool, all of that. That's a competition if you have an organization for this amount or this, whatever they like to do, and then you have the town with these. I don't know how you can split all that money. Secondly, as a non-profit, hypothetically, if you choose to go to a
1:04:38 A nonprofit, a lot of them are private. They can be public. If it's public, then, you know, everyone gets voted in and goes forward. If it's private, the public loses their ability to have comment as well as the town of what to do with that money because basically the board makes the decisions with the staff of that nonprofit and then brings it back. Well, this is public money, and public money stays with the government agency.
1:05:06 And then if you're turning around and putting it into a non-profit, you lose your control. And as far as the staff, you know, they've been on a shoestring budget, and maybe we need to help them out by they may need an extra staff person to help. I don't know. But I just see some competition with the money being played. And then I feel that the committee, the Trails Committee,
1:05:35 That would get eliminated if this goes forward, and I think they've done an incredible amount of work, and it's gone forward with everything they've done and promised to do. Things take time, and I think that you need to give it time, and I just keep finding people coming up and saying, we want to dissolve this because we want to do something else, and I find that bad. I think that everything takes time, and I think there's been a lot of work done, and I think there will continue to have work done, and the great
1:06:04 Working effort between the Forest Service and the town has been great. So I see things looking at it at a different aspect is like the competition between the money, losing your control over if you put it into some type of nonprofit. Maybe it needs to be a public nonprofit. I just think I find those are things that need to be addressed if you're going to discuss it and move forward with it. Thank you. Okay. I still have a motion and I'm unclear exactly what that motion is.
1:06:37 John? Is this still a public discussion? Absolutely. I feel like I should probably chat. Well, first of all, I want to say it's great that we're all talking about this. I think it's great that we're all passionate about the recreation in this area and public lands. Having organizations and people and individuals who want to take their personal time or commit their careers, whatever it may be, and come and talk about these issues, it's great. We should all celebrate that.
1:07:04 But we've been talking about it for a very long time, well over three years. We've been talking about how to best achieve the objectives that the town of Mammoth has for its trail system here. I want to draw a line real quick because there is the Mammoth Trail System and a majority of that trail system is on National Forest, but there's also a whole set of recreation issues that are not related to the National Forest and I'm not speaking to.
1:07:33 So I just want to draw that line. The town has a recreation program that is unrelated to the U.S. Forest Service, and what I'm going to speak to here is all related to recreation on the National Forest. So when I say we've been talking about how to partner and how to achieve recreation objectives, I'm speaking to those recreation opportunities on the National Forest. So we've been going through this for years. Yes, there was RecStrats that completed and the Forest Service did participate in.
1:08:00 At the time, it was Jeff Marcellet, the Forest Rec Officer, Mike Schloffman, the Deputy Ranger, and John Regalberger, today's District Ranger. And we participated, but we didn't approve the final report. We didn't agree with the recommendations made in that, and I think that's very key to understand. We don't agree with everything in that report, and we take issue with some of the recommendations that were made.
1:08:26 So that has to be revisited. What is in that report is not agreed to. It was not consensus. And we would have to talk about what those recommendations if they were to move forward with Mammoth Recreation NGO that included trying to manage recreation on national forests. That's a big dialogue. That's going to take a lot of time to sort out. You guys are right. There's a lot of nuts and bolts that would have to be figured out.
1:08:54 In order to do that, and it warrants a lot of discussion, a lot of meetings, and a lot of planning. And right now, the Indian National Forest does not have the capacity to enter into those discussions. The letter that you have characterized as dismissive is because we have decided we do not have the time and energy and staff resources to go ahead and enter into these discussions. It's not right for us.
1:09:23 As a partner, we're asking that you respect that and understand that. So perhaps that wasn't made entirely clear. Maybe John could have done a better job in that letter explaining that. But that's why he's saying no to this new proposal. And we addressed RecStrats in that letter. And John said, we don't have time to do that right now. And if we have to go back and put time and energy into revisiting these issues, we're going to have to reconsider the way we're partnering.
1:09:51 to meet the objectives of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. If you want us to put energy into that, we're not going to be putting energy into moving the trail system forward because we've only got so much time and energy to put into these programs. So, you know, we've been talking about it. We agreed to what the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is.
1:10:11 We've come to agreement through many, many meetings on that. We've come to agreement through many meetings on how to meet the needs of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System through the MLTSCC, the Forest Service being an ex officio member of that organization, and for the Forest Service in the town to have a staff-to-staff relationship to accomplish the objectives of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. The Forest Service is very comfortable with that. We are making progress. I don't think there is $140,000 left unspent right now.
1:10:41 There's a lot less left unspent after we responded yesterday to a proposal showing that we're going to move forward all the projects in the SHARP document and we're going to start moving forward with the NEPA on those and hopefully by 2014 we'll at least be able to move forward with a couple projects. By 2015 we may have many new trails on the ground. So projects are moving forward.
1:11:05 I don't think everybody in the community is happy with the structure that we have in place now, but you're never going to make everybody happy, and we need to at some point end the discussions and keep moving forward. Right now, if we have to go back and revisit some of the past decisions and we have to put more time and energy into trying to figure out how we want to partner, we've got to reconsider whether we can do that or not.
1:11:33 So it's not trying to be, we're not trying to be rude, we're not trying to say we don't want to give you time and energy, we are, we're giving you everything we can, we've given you a lot over the last few years, we're going to continue to give you a lot. It's in our interest to Forest Service, the U.S. Forest Service manages the National Forest, the recreation programs that you're asking us to endeavor upon with you in partnership,
1:12:03 We have an interest in maintaining management responsibilities over those lands. We don't want to delegate that. And I believe there is an interest in seeing us move some of that responsibility to other organizations. We're not going to do that. And I think that that's another competing interest out there that's driving these ideas. And we've said no to that in the past. We continue to say no to it. And we can only say no so many different ways.
1:12:30 That letter really was to say no. We want to move forward with the structure we've agreed to. And if you ask us to keep moving forward in other ways, we're going to have to reconsider what we've agreed to today. So I'll be happy answering questions about it. Again, we're not trying to be rude. We're not trying to be bad guys. We're trying to get some really good things done with you. I think we're on the verge of some huge success in the Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
1:12:57 And I hope that you can digest that and reconsider your comments earlier because it was not intended to be upsetting. It was intended to clearly communicate where we are today and what we expect from our partners. Any questions for John? No questions. I just want to make sure that we are clear that what we are discussing here is not
1:13:26 A change for MLTSCC. Town Council has agreed to $300,000 a year for five years with annual reviews to go forward in the structure that it is. So the message that I'd really like to send back, especially, and thank you for your comments, is that, you know, the MLTSCC is still going forward as the way that we have defined that role. We, as the Town of Mammoth Lakes, I think, need to have a discussion what we want to do with our money.
1:13:52 Measure R. The $300,000 for five years, that's already been committed to work with the U.S. Forest Service. But with regard to the overarching money that is Measure R, Measure U, possibly Measure A, I think if I'm reading into that, is that we need to have those discussions internally about what we want to do with our recreation program that is for the town of Mammoth Lakes. Please consider, I would like to say, I think,
1:14:20 Is that, you know, the U.S. Forest Service needs to hear the message that MLTSCC, for right now, is going forward. Sure. I understand that. And I just want to make clear, you know, we aren't trying to direct town funds in any way, shape, or form. You guys have asked, the town has asked the Forest Service, the partner, in a new way and on some specific projects as well and moving them forward. And we've responded saying, here's what it's going to take.
1:14:45 We're not trying to tell you how to spend your money, but if you want to do the things that you've asked us to do and work with us in the ways you've asked to work with us, we do have to respond and tell you there's a cost associated with it. So if you choose to pursue a Mammoth Rec organization that does not include Recreation on National Forest, I think you should go ahead and move forward. If you're going to try to pursue...
1:15:11 A conversation about an organization that addresses Recreation on National Forests, we ask that you hold off until we can have the capacity to participate. Thanks very much, John. If I could just, John, just for, in terms of semantics, to make sure we're clear about what these processes were. I don't believe you guys were involved in the RecStats process. I just, so that it's clear, I think you were involved in the NLR process. That's where Jeff Marcellet and John...
1:15:38 No, no, RecStrats was a separate effort. RecStrats came after that process concluded. But just so we're clear about the timing of all this stuff. The process that John's referring to is that MLR process, 2009-2010. The RecStrats process, I don't believe you guys were involved in that, either in phase one or phase two, just to be just so clear on the terms of this stuff. And I think also, I mean, in terms of measure art, speaking from MLTPAs, the organization that ran the campaign and put these questions in front of the taxpayers,
1:16:06 You have an obligation to the public money of the town of Mammoth Lakes. You do it very well. You exercise that fiduciary responsibility very well. To act as a proponent for projects that happen on federal land, that is a right of any citizen in the country to do that. And I think if the Forest Service is advising that they've got resource issues and they can't participate in an MLR process, I think to Sean's part, that's entirely appropriate. I think that's something that's within the purview of the scope of the responsibility of the town to do that.
1:16:34 And so, just to be clear on those semantic terms, I think it's okay. And just lastly, we wish we could. We had the capacity. We had, from where we were three or four years ago, four people on board. We'd be happy to participate and have these discussions to try to figure out how we can best meet recreation needs in the community. Unfortunately, we have a lot of other demands for our time, mutual priorities, and a lot of other work that has to be done that supports recreation in this area that we have to compete.
1:17:03 Recreation programs in the U.S. Forest Service aren't limited to our trails, and I think you all know that, but there are a lot more, there's a lot more going on here in town, with Mammoth, and Recreation, and we have a responsibility to other permanent holders and follow-up to the U.S. John, thank you very much. Could I have just one thought? I think two of the most significant projects that are on
1:17:31 The list for consideration by the, I'll just say the CC because it's easier, are work in the Lakes Basin and Sharps. And those in fact are going forward. So I just want to let you know and just remind you, I'm sure you're already aware of that, that those are significant projects in and of themselves that the Forest Service is partnering with the town on. And, you know, I think it's worth noting that those are moving forward.
1:17:59 We will make significant strides in lakes basin projects shortly. The Forest Service is coming forward at this point in time and offering up their support and help to work with the town on the Sharps projects as well. So I just wanted to mention that. Thank you, Ray. Yep. Okay, that brings us back to the motion we're debating. Can we read that motion back? Because my memory isn't that long.
1:18:31 Let me paraphrase it. I'll have it. Do you have a gem? Do you want me to have a stab at it? No. Well, there was a lot of other talk, but I think the essential motion is accept the staff report and scheduled meeting dedicated to the MLR concept with a discussion guided by town managers, the town managers' question. Okay, I want to ask when you say accept, you mean just accept as informational, not accept as in the gospel.
1:19:00 I'm more than willing to accept it as an informational piece. Well, yes, the recommendation from staff is to accept this report, and that's what I'm recommending, that we accept this report. That's right. You're just receiving a file. But you're also saying let's schedule more meetings. Yes. That's where we're going to say something. Yeah, a meeting where we can really concentrate our efforts on looking into other concepts. Yeah.
1:19:30 Or agendize this for the main medium as I heard in there as well. That's what the staff recommended. Would you want to add that to it? I just said a meeting in the future. So I have a motion and second to discuss this any further. We're on about an hour and 10 minutes now. Okay. That's fine. I'll call for it. All those in favor. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Okay. I should kill them. I can't read that in front of you. Update. No. Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee update.
1:20:06 Steve, do you want to give that or would you like to Sean and I to start this off? I'll be happy to read the staff report or paraphrase it. Paraphrase, please. Sure. As you all know then, as far as background, we've been holding meetings with the now addition of the Trail System Program Administrator.
1:20:37 from myself and that agreement is in place as of February 5th and we've conducted two meetings. We are moving forward then with the master tracking list and the appendages that go along with that. We've presented a categorization.
1:21:03 Formula for how to assign numbers to the various projects so that we can follow them. We're using descriptors for the actual projects themselves. We're coordinating back with agenda items and dates for how they were either combined or authorization for contracts and so forth bringing forward. We're also carrying forward budgets and allocations and unallocated.
1:21:33 Columns for Monies so that we're tracking the dollars that have been appropriated, contracted, and also dollars spent. We're following also staff time and also consultant time. One thing I might point out that we didn't quite get to in yesterday's meeting is that in the last quarter then we have expended about the same number of staff hours and consultant hours as all of last year.
1:22:02 And we've brought that forward at about half the price. So I think we're being fairly efficient and straightforward and meeting at least financial goals of the committee. Again, through this tracking list and its various appendages and portions, we're able to also bring forward a discussion of how projects are brought forward to
1:22:28 The committee and eventually realized these projects are divided up into two categories. One is programmatic in nature and the other are hard projects that are construction type projects that go with a much lengthier and more involved process. So the next couple of meetings are going to really be important because we were unable to get through our long agenda.
1:22:58 Last night's meeting, there's a special meeting, or an additional meeting, I guess, scheduled for a week from Monday on the 15th of April. Working on the agenda today as well as the minutes, so hopefully that information will get out here quickly.
1:23:19 I think again that we're going to see a lot of progress in the next two meetings because we'll be able to get these agenda items out of the way and some of these standing issues and then be able to get into the actual project list themselves and start moving forward with various task items within the projects that are already allocated for funding in this fiscal year as well as assigning dollars for additional projects for
1:23:48 The next fiscal year or the next $300,000. So I'm available to answer any questions, specific questions that you may have or follow up from last night's meeting. If I could just add to it, yeah, we, you know, I knew it was going to be a tough agenda to try and get through it in just two hours and I think that what we're talking about is we did, actually, Teri, both of you sat in the audience, didn't you, Pat? Okay, great. So I don't know how much I need to,
1:24:21 Overview it, but obviously it was a long agenda and maybe a little bit overambitious. Glad we scheduled that additional meeting. I think we're going to need to talk about making, if we're going to keep those meetings at once a month, I think it needs to go to three hours. We did only get about halfway through the agenda itself and in light of looking at the master tracking list, we did take on a couple things. John Kazimirski, I'm really glad that the Forest Service
1:24:49 Was willing to advance the Sherwin alignments specifically, the Sherwin, or the Sharp projects, excuse me, in a three-year proposal. So I think that it was good. We got a lot more work to do. Glad to see that staff time is same number of hours, I'm sorry, twice as many hours for, same amount of hours. Is that what it was? Yeah, okay. Two for one, whatever it was.
1:25:20 I want to say that I'm really happy we have someone on board to help us through this project. We got yesterday a document called a master tracking list supplement suggested programmatic and physical project implementation steps. I wish I would have had this a year ago. I think this will change the way we look at things and help the committee go from being proactive, from reactive.
1:25:51 to decide what programs we want to deliver and then figure out how best to deliver them instead of just throwing money at the wall and seeing where it would stick. So I am for the first time in a long time feeling a lot more optimistic about that committee and the work that we can get done. We still have a good deal left from last year that we have to go back and re-look at. But yeah, I am
1:26:22 Feeling much more positive than I was just a couple of weeks ago, so I hopefully feel the same way. Oh, yeah. And I was very happy to make the suggestion that Sean be the new head of that organization, and thank you very much for taking that on. Thank you for your trust. Having attended a good portion of your meetings, I, too, am optimistic that you're on the right track, and congratulations, Sean and Bill Taylor for being chair and vice chair, and I agree.
1:26:51 With what Betsy mentioned, that everyone on that committee is very talented and resourceful and very professional. And it kind of is very consistent with what I think Town Council wanted to look forward to with a voluntary group moving forward and fulfilling needs of the town. So congratulations.
1:27:18 I am really happy to hear that. I think you guys are headed in a good direction. But I did just want to clarify, on the staff report, it says that $97,592 worth of contracts from the $292,652 has been approved. And I just wanted to know the status of contracting on the rest of the money. So actually, $292,000.
1:27:48 was put forward and approved by Council on various projects. Some of those dollars may have to be changed because some of them were just placeholders. As of yet, we haven't gotten, like anything I do, I consider myself a piece of. As a whole, we haven't gotten around to letting those contracts for whatever reason. And we're just now getting into the nuts and bolts of...
1:28:09 Getting that. Did I state that correctly, sir? Well, I think the other thing, too, is as Ray pointed out, we were able to progress with sharps, and there was 57-some-odd thousand dollars right there yesterday that has been, I guess I'd say, recommitted or now assigned to an entity, and that number doesn't appear within the 97 because those agreements haven't been finalized.
1:28:35 That money is headed in that direction. So the good news is we haven't spent all the money. We're not over budget. And the good news is that we still have money to work with as we move forward. And then the other thing, we don't have a commitment that we have to spend or put under contract the money in this fiscal year. We can bridge it over so that we can use that money as leverage as the future.
1:29:04 Funding opportunities come up with different projects within the list or projects that will be on the list. Thank you. And just to clarify, I wanted to ask this because, you know, in the funding cycle, you know, this money does come back to the commission and we look at it and say, you know, okay, go ahead. And so I just wanted to make sure that those things are moving forward and that they are the things that, you know, that we approved. Could I clarify that, Sandy Hogan?
1:29:30 Member of the Committee also. One of the things that we talked about in developing the tracking sheet, the word contract is misleading in that we don't contract with the Forest Service. And if you look at actually the figures there, there's a lot of money that has been verbally obligated, in other words, put forward to the Forest Service. And yesterday what they did is they came forward and they...
1:29:57 accepted that one, because they've been in these planning discussions, and John has told us for a long time, I'm not going to be able to let you know until the last minute, because the forest is going through all sorts of machinations, if you want to call it. I mean, the sequester's part of it. That's a federal issue. I mean, they're hurting. But those have been discussed, and it doesn't have to come back through. Not the $12, $13. We came through.
1:30:22 You and we went through the Town Council. It was all approved $292,000 for projects. The only placeholders I think totaled something like less than $15,000. Everything else was pretty much lined out to a project. So in other words, yes, there's a few. We have a few thousand to play with. Yesterday one of the things we did is we were able to because we do have a little excess here.
1:30:48 Here and there, we were able to add $5,000 to the website contract as an emergency contingency. And we do have a few other things, I think around $20,000 is what I figured out, that we can look at this next time. But please don't think that we've only obligated or tied up or committed $97,000. I think it's just the wording in the sheet, and we're still trying to get that. In other words,
1:31:18 We committed to 292,000 and so did the council for this year. So we're ready to start working on 13-14. Okay. No, I appreciate that clarification. I just, um, and I'm not looking for it. It's just a semantic. And I'm not looking for it to come back through. I'm just, you know, making sure that what we all, you know, agreed on that the council approved. I had the same question, though. I think yesterday, you know, that it didn't quite show how much we actually have committed. So it's just a wording thing on the table.
1:31:48 Thank you. The work that the committee's doing, all the great things are getting done. I just don't want to make sure that there's a clear eye in the public's mind. While that 292 is committed, and that's great, I'm not sure how much that money is actually contracted and how much work will actually get done with that money. So things are moving forward, I guess, and moving in the right direction. But just because the money's been committed to projects, I don't know if they've been contracted to people who are actually going to do all that work.
1:32:23 I would just keep that in mind. Right. And that was understood. Okay. No further questions on that. We'll move along to review and private direction of staff on the selection of web-based software. Thank you, Chair. So this item will appear before you as part of the Measure R Spring Award as well. It is going to be submitted as an application which you recommended.
1:32:52 The request here from staff, once I run through the staff report, which took us a little while to put together, is a recommendation to, or for the commission to consider this application, review it on May 7, and then make a funding recommendation to council on May 16. As you know, we're trying to, well let me back up here, so really a priority, you know, for the town,
1:33:20 Certainly, as we've been directed from the town manager, is for the town to operate in a more efficient, cost-effective manner. So staff has determined through a lot of research and analysis that web-based recreation software is really the direction that the department needs to explore, as you've understanding with our financial constraints. And new facilities coming in line, specifically Whitmore Track, this software provides not only the efficiency of booking a reservation, a program,
1:33:49 But also the capability of reporting, marketing, and tracking of our guests, which I think is extremely important and something that we're not currently able to really provide in a very effective manner. So what I'd like to do, just briefly, Chair, is to walk you through the substance and the content very quickly, or expeditiously as I can. Yes, Chair? Has everyone written, because he's got a whole lot of work here.
1:34:20 As much as I love Stu, I'd rather not listen to him for half an hour. One minute or less, how about that? Okay, that's fine. There you go, thank you. As I said, you'll review it again in the application process, which is really what you're seeing here. So just the background, so the analysis and discussion provides an overview of what the Recreation Department does. There's a table in the back there that kind of overviews the number of transactions we receive. So I try to give you a little bit more information on what we're currently performing as a department.
1:34:49 We describe the current reservation process. We provide a direction in regards to a solution. There's information on case study. And we've identified 10 primary needs specifically to our department. And I've addressed that in the staff report itself, hopefully in enough detail for you. The big issue, you know, when you're looking at programs like this, you know, specifically money. So we've come up with a number of
1:35:18 And we researched a number of alternative vendors. What we've really tried to do here is look at parks and recreation solutions. So there's a lot of web-based software systems out there on the market that are very broad, very scope, very broad in their scope. So what we've tried to do is narrow that down and we looked at ActiveNet and we looked at Easy Facility. They were the two that really provided
1:35:43 A complete parks and recreation solution, kind of a turnkey solution, so to speak, as opposed to when we looked at a lot of other free or very broad providing vendors in regards to they have a parks and recreation product, but they also have other products as well. So we wanted to keep it specifically something that was as able to we can implement immediately and not try and customise throughout the year and waste time and staff and resources and hopefully potential funds.
1:36:13 The recreation needs are identified. We've tried to address them in the staff report. We did a vendor comparison. Civic Plus was included. They're implementing a module specifically for facility reservation, not so much for activity registration. So they were providing a module for facility reservation, so we included that in the comparison because they are an existing web provider for our website.
1:36:40 And then in the back there was also a table on the fees. And I know that was something that is a big part of what we were trying to analyse. So with ActiveNet specifically, and I've included that documentation, all they require is an upfront one time forever, what they call kind of an evergreen provision of their software that would include lifetime updates and warranties. So once you purchase that product in advance,
1:37:08 We get it installed. We're only ever paying the processing fee for either credit cards, transactions via cash and checks, and a convenience fee paid for by the customer if they do purchase their products online. So we thought and we believe and we've demonstrated that in the report that that's the most cost-effective and efficient manner to move forward with ActiveNet. Was that brief enough? For Stuart, would someone who'd like to make a motion? Well,
1:37:40 My question is, yeah, that seems like a great deal. Somebody is looking at cloud-based software for my company right now. What was it, $11,500? So it's, yeah, $8,600 for the modules that we've required at this time. And then it's a $2,000 cost for the on-site training. So that would mean a representative from ActiveNet would come up from San Diego, and they're close by, and actually install and build a product for us on-site, which we believe is just huge. And then...
1:38:09 Sorry, Commissioner. And what they've also committed to, if we're able to commit that funding by mid-May instead of that 60-day window, they'll turn that around in two to three weeks for us. So they'll pretty much try and guarantee us to be up by mid-June and be operating. So we'd miss a lot of that early registration, but we ought to actually go back in and input a lot of that data into that system. So you actually have a complete first year of transactions and programs in that system.
1:38:37 I mean that just sounds great, almost too good to be true. You've checked references for ActiveNet then? Yep. Okay. It's the largest one and it's still in California and I've looked at and I've actually looked at how it looks on different sites as well. So what they'll kind of do is come in, they'll come in through mammothrecreation.com as our portal and then you'll click into either want to make a facility reservation or an activity registration and from that point on it's pretty much their website so it just portals into their
1:39:05 into their system, and they'll match that brand and that look and feel to our current website. So as far as the guest experience, it wouldn't look any different, but it's all hosted on their site. So for us, with only 2.75 URN employees, it does sound too good to be true, but heck, we're going to give it a go, right? Yep, okay.
1:39:27 Well, just a quick comment to that. Pat and I sat in on the presentation for ActiveNet, and I was very impressed. I'm a huge proponent of moving forward with this software. I find it amazing that we don't have anything now. And I was very impressed with their presentation. And I also just think that the company, having just registered for the June Lake Triathlon, I think ties in really well to our community needs and just that whole brand. And I think they really get what we're looking for.
1:39:55 I'm sorry, is this being, how is this being paid for? This is a Measure R application. Okay. So, can we actually, in just a point of order, does this need to come through as part of the Measure R application and we're making the recommendation here that it comes forward as a Measure R application? Yes. Thank you very much. And just to jump on from Commissioner Truex's point, so I did ask John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism, on active and how they're found active and their uses. So there's an email from John.
1:40:23 The Commission as well if you wanted to review that as well on Active. But he was certainly endorsing that product because it is a large activity registration portal for special events. So if someone comes into our area, looks up 93546 to see everything that's going on, you'll actually see all our products in there as well. And then we're also able to tap into the 7 million users of Active for our region as well. So it's a great opportunity for us to really kind of elevate our recreation in our community.
1:40:54 In a very small way, I believe. When I worked down south, we upgraded our computer registration system, online registration, and the upfront cost, because we purchased it and had quite a large IT department to manage it, it was much more expensive. It was well over $100,000. And so I think this is an incredible advantage to the town.
1:41:24 financially, and I think it'll be great for the consumer. Can we ask one other question then, Mr. Gary, to that? Because I know that, again, my company's looking at this cloud-based software, which is not going to do bells and whistles for us, but we can't install it until the digital 395 is complete. Are there any concerns with regard to that here? No, there's a section here in the vendor comparison, and we ask the operating requirement of the system.
1:41:56 56 kilobyte online access, so it operates on a pretty low bandwidth right now, so you can just imagine when it comes into broadband, you'll be probably completed before you even started to think about it, right? Yeah, good. One other question I do have, will the participant be writing a check or will the credit card reflect Town of Mammoth Lakes or will it be active net? Because the money goes to them and then...
1:42:28 They issue money. Correct. Yeah, we never invoice them. They'll just basically bimonthly submit payment or remittance back to us. I'd have to check on that question. That's a good question how it would receive. But we also did bring them down from a 6% cost to a 3% cost, which I think was great. 2% for cash and checks. And then a $2.50 convenience fee based on a transaction. So I think it's very fair. I think the comparison showed that way.
1:42:59 To have fees of maybe $2,000 a year as opposed to $4,000 to $5,000. We can't afford $4,000 to $5,000 a year. So I think this opportunity for Measure R is ideal. So that's really what we're looking at today. So you'll review it as part of your application, Chair, and then it'll come forward on May 7 when you do your typical review. At that time, staff is just asking you to make a recommendation to Council for May 16. In that meantime, upon direction today, we would
1:43:28 Get those contracts from active net and start working through those as well. So once we've triggered that date, we can just. That is the one difference between. So to make this work. Thank you. We'll have to deviate some from the standard measure our process and make a recommendation for this specific item to move forward outside of the others and the other timeline. And for one, I see no issue with that. But that's the segue. Although we're not approving that here, we're just approving to move forward here.
1:43:56 Yeah. And just to be clear, because this is Measure R monies, there's no, we don't need to worry about any maintenance, you know, there's no of those general concerns when we're talking about buying barricades or something like that, that, you know, we're needing to set aside funds from Measure R to pay for replacement or maintenance. The only thing that we'd come back to, Commission, is if we wanted to consider points of sale at our pool and the multi-use facility.
1:44:24 So to have a module that actually link everything together is something we'd like to really consider as well. So that's something we would come back. But as far as maintenance fees, the town pays that as part of this one time upfront cost. And then we pay all the transaction fees, which is what we're currently doing right now in our budget. So we pay all those fees. Thank you for clarifying. Any more from here before I go to the audience? To answer Pat's question at work, we have four of these type of
1:44:58 companies, and when people go in, it's, it'll, you set it up as the name of, so it'll be Town of Mammoth Lakes, in our case it's Mono Lake Committee, we set that up that way, and you can do that. My second question for Stu, so we had an incident where someone actually got onto that particular site and changed it into a Turkish language, and I wanted to make sure that, ask you, is it in their contract that if, if someone was able to access it, go past your firewall,
1:45:27 Are they responsible to change it back to the correct language or any other issues that may come up? And my third thing is possibly that you can get one of those plug-ins that you do, because we've been doing it at the swim team, to your phone at the pool that's access to link to that, that the money goes into that account, which is very cheap to do. So I just wanted to point a couple of those things out. We just had that.
1:45:55 Things changing our language has happened recently, and we had our IT guy had to go in and fix it. And so I just want to make sure if that happens that you have that in your contract for repair. We'd look forward to seeing the contract. We'd hopefully look at all that, make sure that's the case. Would somebody like to make a motion to the recommendation, one, two, and three, as it occurs with your packet? So moved. So seconded. I have a motion.
1:46:25 And second, any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. And thank you. Moving on to item 8, provide direction to staff on 2013 Measure R Award. So I'll do another brief, hopefully two minutes or less. So this item came about from the joint April 2nd meeting that the Recreation Commission hosted.
1:47:00 The goal there was to move this forward, have the Recreation Commission and the Measure U Application Committee consider this request. It was one of those action items that came out from that workshop. Obviously at the workshop we really couldn't talk about or make a recommendation regarding this suggestion. So the item before you is to discuss the formation of a committee to provide recommendations to the Recreation Commission.
1:47:27 and Town Council on the best use of town funds for arts and cultural events, including a proposed application, evaluation, and funding process. Yes. Isn't what you're looking at 9? Am I jumped ahead? Oh, okay, sorry. You're in Measure R, Bill. Yeah, I provide direction to staff on the Measure R Spring Award, and I think that all we're doing here is spring award, yeah. We could take it out of order and just do 9 right now and come back if you wanted to, or since I've already...
1:47:59 Either way, you've already started on it, so take your eight foot aside, guys, and deal with nine. Thank you. So just to finish off this brief staff report, so the conclusion of the meeting, staff recommended that we, well, the organizations consider forming a five-person working group made up of recreation commissioners, Measure U application committee members, and representatives of the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition.
1:48:27 To work with staff directly on this issue, because it is a broad, complex, and as you've seen the 18 to 20 pages of comments from the group, it's a very substantial and complex discussion. So again, the goal of this short-term working group would be to assist staff in the, I guess, the process to determine the best way to kind of move this forward and the benefit of the special events. And then ultimately to come back to council.
1:48:55 with some action on how to move this forward. In the Measure U recommendation that the council made, in the resolution they basically stated in regards to the recommendation for special events to consider paying back Measure U funds from special events, they basically put language in there that would be contingent upon these further discussions. So there's really no action, there's no hard and fast action in there.
1:49:25 Binding any of those special event organisers to pay back those funds, but it really is a topic right now that's part of our work plan and something that we need to address. So that's the item before you. I can see some members of the audience were here to discuss it. I know Evan was here. I don't know if he's still able to be here. That's okay, but I was just making him aware that he probably thought we were doing eight and we were doing nine. But anyway, so that's... Maybe we should make him aware that we're discussing item number nine.
1:49:55 But we took it out of the world, I apologise. Yeah. And then as you know, those weren't there, I think everyone was there at the meeting, but staff did provide a lot of that research, so I think a lot of that research, and I guess the goal of that committee is to really, you know, dig into that. There were some great programs from Telleride, and they also did receive, which was looking at Evan, information about the Park City Program, and that's, I think it's an ordinance that went before the community in, I think, 2000, that's...
1:50:24 I think it was Recreation Arts Programme that set aside a specific amount of funds. So it sounds very similar to what we're doing, but they were able to provide far clearer criteria and guidelines on who could apply for that funding and what the process looked like and then ultimately what funds were available to use. So it was a lot more defined, had a lot more sideboards on it. It was a lot clearer for both the applicant and for the committee to award those funds.
1:50:51 I think it certainly warrants good discussion, and that was the recommendation, and that's a very broad recommendation that staff springing forward as a result of that workshop. And Evan, why don't you get a cup of coffee? We'll start. Anyway, it concludes my report. Well, I just got to say, I thought that workshop was a great workshop. I thought it was one of the more productive meetings that I've been in, in my civic...
1:51:22 Life here. I went into that meeting with three of the five, with an opinion on three of the five questions and the other two saying I wasn't sure but essentially allowed me to form some opinions coming out of that. As I made mention that day, you know, I looked around the room and just saw an enormous amount of talent, really talented event organizers here that I certainly want to encourage and would like to be involved in that committee even though, you know, we've
1:51:51 Already got a motion from this meeting today to form a committee with regard to the trails, but at the same time, you know, also aware though that, and I made this comment, and as an event producer myself, one of my events actually seeking Measure U funds or receiving Measure U funds, just that, you know, I am aware that there is some conflict of interest there, stated that outright, but at the same time, we'd like to be involved in those discussions because of my experience as an events organizer myself.
1:52:24 I thought it was a great workshop. I learned a lot. I went in with some opinions that changed after reading the material, after hearing from everyone. I thought it was great. And I think the formation of a committee is a great idea. I think one of the first things that needs to happen is to have the application revised to reflect something that's better aligned with events.
1:52:46 Requests for Funding, and I think, you know, Sean, if you're available, I think having your expertise on that committee would really be invaluable. Thank you. Go ahead. I, too, agree that it was a very productive meeting. I was impressed with the comments that were made and a lot of consideration that was given to answering each of the questions by the organizations. I, too, have an interest in perhaps being on that committee. I have over 30 years of experience in
1:53:19 Coordinating special events and managing them and implementing them. Anything from cultural concert series to egg hunts to Halloween concerts to carnivals to larger events. 10K runs that we used to work with Perry on and an art show that is held twice a year that attracted about 50,000 people throughout the weekend. So I know Sean certainly has
1:53:48 A lot of expertise in this area and more locally than I, but I'd be interested as well. But I know there's only one from the group, I think. Well, we haven't actually made any of those decisions yet. In a text to me from Terry on the events applications, and she's referring specifically to this item, there's already a steering committee that it could go back to.
1:54:17 And I agree with her. On both measures, R and U, we had steering committees. And when changes have been asked for, it has been at least implied that the steering committees would get the first crack at that, since they're the ones that put it together in the first place, although as a commission we've done a lot of work on them, that the first logical place would be to go back to that steering committee, although they weren't at our meeting and probably should have been.
1:54:47 Out of respect for the work that they've done, I would suggest that that's probably the first stop that this needs to make. And that's, there's more to it than just the, as it appears. On how to spend, there's the amount that should or shouldn't come out. I know I was very disappointed in the percentage that went just to special events. Special events aren't called out specifically in the Measure U process.
1:55:23 It was the foundation that got the arts and culture item put in the Measure U process in the first place, and it was put in because they've got $9 million to build a structure and no O&M money, and it was thought that this could provide the O&M money. The discussion then was not special events. I think it's been a great seed for special events. However, I think it's in its second year grown out of proportion.
1:55:53 for what's going to special events. And I would like to have input on that from the original application committee. And I know there are people from the events coalition that were on that committee. I don't remember the exact makeup. But I would like to see it go back to them with all the questions. What is a proper amount of you that should be spent? Look at the application. How do we make a specific application for events? And give them all of the information that came.
1:56:23 Out of that MLEC meeting and make it an open workshop format so that MLEC could be there and participate. Were you talking about the Measure U Committee? The Measure U Steering Committee, yeah. You were on it and I was an alternate. Right. And I think they're missing a member now because Rich Bocci is no longer in town. And I don't think any other members were part of the coalition. I don't remember who all the members were. I think it was Bill Taylor. But that's how we have traditionally dealt
1:56:54 Unless you feel at this point in time we need to take it out of the hands of that group and deal with it on our own. I think that was the first question to start with, was Measure U, you know, was for what, mobility, recreation, and arts and culture, right? And it never did say special events, and I thought specifically. And, you know, let's determine if you're suggesting returning it to that original steering committee, is that what you're saying?
1:57:20 To get an idea just to start the discussion, you know, how much measure you or you guys think it needs to go to special events, that's fine, you know, and then you can even break it down further just like a lot of these questions you mentioned here. Is that non-profit? Is that for-profit? Is it community-oriented or visitor-driven? Boy, I could ask questions, and they're all valid questions.
1:57:46 So if you're suggesting taking it back to the steering committee initially to get a read from them what their ideas were as far as how much of Measure U should be going to special events. And perhaps a relook at the application as well. They were very clear, though, not to allocate percentages. Percentages. Yeah. Because remember it was a third, a third, a third. And I think recreation...
1:58:12 Don't remember the language exactly, but I think it's pretty broad. I think special events could fall into that recreation category. Well, I think the... And even in Measure R. Most of them go back to all the categories. I mean, parts of arts and culture is going to be the places to have arts and culture, which we're going to lose eventually. I think all of us have stated that we would like to see the lion's share of you.
1:58:39 Go into a fund for big ticket items, one of which would be related to arts, and that is space. But after getting Teri's email, not email, text, tech dinosaur, I thought, you know, she's right. We had the committee, and if they don't want to deal with it, let them tell Stu when he calls them that they're not interested in dealing with it, and then we can pick it up and run with it if necessary.
1:59:09 At this point, in all fairness, I think it needs to go back to that committee first. Well, and I think that's, I think that's good, and I think, you know, with you having been involved in that, Pat, if you're the alternate, I think you may be a member of the steering committee now. So, you know, just with both of you having been here, you know, and participated in the workshop, I think that would be, that would be a good starting point. Sandy. Sandy Hogan, a member of the Measure U Committee along with Bill, which,
1:59:38 You know, I think our committee will be discussing this, so it sounds like you're making recommendations for the Measure U committee right here. I really don't think it would be that productive to go back to the committee. For one thing, they're going to have to come totally up to speed with all of the stuff that we did in that workshop. That was a very valuable workshop, I agree. You know, and we had a lot, and the MLEC, I think if all of a sudden they're dealing with
2:00:07 Other people, they've got to bring up the speed. You know, that's kind of a waste of their time. Those are busy folks. I mean, you're right. The brain power in that room was just astounding. But they're all pretty darn busy. And so, you know, I would suggest that, you know, you do have maybe a couple of members that I'm hoping that in Measure U we will have a couple of members. I do feel that the
2:00:38 That the purpose of the committee is to listen and to get some good ideas because those folks will help us with the application, with solving these problems of the profit, non-profit. A lot of those questions that are coming up, I think they will help us. If we're going back to a steering committee that's not up to date, that hasn't sat and heard all of the things that we've heard from those folks over time, and then we're asking the steering committee to make decisions,
2:01:06 That's kind of the wrong way to go. I guess that's just the way I'm sure hoping to work with that group and have them come up with the answers, not have the answers dictated. I do think what would be appropriate if they were asked, again, the steering committee, maybe the broader question of should special events be in Measure U or split between Measure U and Measure R? You know, we kind of just,
2:01:36 And this is, I think we just kind of said, hey, looks like a good home for them. Because all three, you know, we have three categories, recreation is there, and it actually kind of relieved a little bit of Measure R. But, you know, I'm not, I would be fine with asking the steering committee some special questions like that. You know, where do you think, is, does Measure U
2:01:59 Money, should that be the one that does special events, all special events, part of special events, and perhaps re-asking this allocation a question again, perhaps, how do we finally figure out some way to start setting up a capital fund, you know, or limiting, you can put it two ways, you know, limiting the special events or setting up a, you know, starting to collect money for a capital fund, because we all want to do that. So, yeah, maybe there is some use for them.
2:02:27 But I don't see them being the committee to work with MLEC. I mean, and that's just me speaking here, and I will say the same thing next week. Anyway, just my thoughts. Do you have any questions? A good comment about that is that everybody was in the room last week. You know, I think they kind of thought that we're moving in this direction of forming this committee, and then maybe to switch gears does make it seem awkward. If I may suggest it, it could be a...
2:03:01 I think a consideration here. I think we can certainly invite the Measure U Steering Committee to that workshop. We could still do the same thing. It could be instead of maybe a workshop, we could actually just schedule a policy item because we do want to formulate some recommendations. And the Measure U Application Committee is weighing in on this next week as well. So I think we have to do this collectively because we both manage
2:03:27 Both committees, commissions, oversee special use funds. So it's kind of an interesting dilemma. But I do recognize that the EU steering committee should be involved. Much like when we start the Measure R review process, we'd probably want to engage those folks that kind of started this process as well. I think that's very respectful. But at the same time, obviously, we're moving forward. We've got some good momentum. So maybe there's a way to weave all this together and not lose that.
2:03:56 That energy that we've kind of created. So anyway, that would be my suggestion to kind of at least consider, you know, the Measure U application committee will discuss this on Tuesday, I believe, in the morning. We actually have a workshop on Tuesday afternoon and we can maybe bring that back at that time again and actually have it as maybe a policy item that we can, you know, review once we've received input from the application committee, the Measure U folks.
2:04:23 And then, you know, come together and recommend the next path. And that might be a way to kind of piece this together. But you're right, I think there's all valid points, and I think we need to just keep moving forward. Time's kind of the essence. You know, we're coming up with the Fall Award, and that Fall Award, if we, for the Measure U process, potentially would be an annual award. So at that time, all those special event applicants are going to come back.
2:04:51 and submit the application again, which is kind of October. So, you know, now in April, it's something we need to kind of at least get, you know, done and get in front of Council, so. Pleasure. What's the, what's the recommendation just to discuss it? The recommendation found at the end here will be discuss and present a proposed structure for the formation of committee. Which could very well include that, you know, steering committee. I believe Stu is suggesting it will be you, committee,
2:05:33 Original Steering Committee Steering Committee and the Rec Commission and then done in a workshop format but agendized so that we can take an action on something with input from MLEC. All of us Recreation Commissioners, which is fine. I think that's what we're, I think that's what the recommendation is at this point. We could schedule that for next Tuesday, ideally, you know, if you wanted to consider that as a
2:06:02 You know, policy item before the workshop. I know they get very busy. We try not to belabor it, but at the same time, we need to have the Measure U Application Committee consider that. And then hopefully, you know, jointly we can discuss it and keep moving it forward. So I think that's a fair representation. I think we can, staff can certainly contact those members and invite them to the meeting. We're not losing time, I think. I think that would be a good recommendation. My concern would be the scope of that meeting all by itself.
2:06:32 Would make it a long meeting. I don't know that we have that much time in the workshop format unless we make it a meeting prior to the workshop and then narrow the scope some so it can be gone through in an hour. By the time we hear from each one of the MLEC again, we've burned an hour there all by itself. Well, but this, what we're talking about here is really just a workshop
2:07:04 With the MLC in the audience. With the goal, ultimately, Chair, with the goal of just to provide direction in regards to what committee should move this forward, I think is what we're trying to say. We're not really going to tackle the application, evaluation, funding processes of what group, body, organisation should be moving this forward, taking into account and comments and feedback from that used steering committee.
2:07:29 I think that if we keep it maybe that narrowed focus, we can then at least determine then at that point, the committee, the structure, composition, and then we can start to fill it and move forward. If we were going to move it that way, then my recommendation would be to get the U committee and the U, the original steering committee, the measure U committee and the rec commission. We don't need MLEC to make that determination. Correct. And then move the committee forward from there. Then it can just be a half an hour before the...
2:08:00 Or an hour, because that's still a lot of people, an hour before the workshop. What time does that mean I need to change my setting in my calendar? It's currently at 2, so you look like you might start at 1. The Measure U Committee is scheduled for 2 p.m.? Measure U Application Committee is 8.30 to 10.30 in the morning. And then we would start our workshop discussion for our facilities planning at 2, so what we're saying here is we'd start at 1 o'clock, just to consider the proposed structure and information of this.
2:08:30 Committee of this, you know, short-term committee to address the special event needs, I guess is what we're saying. But not involve the NLEC? Not in the formation of the committee. If we said we want them on the committee itself, then we would move that forward and ask for their participation then. Why wouldn't we want them on the committee? No, no, I don't think that's what Bill said. I think he's saying that we decide on how the committee would look. And I think it's pretty clear that they want to participate and be involved in that, so.
2:09:06 You're deciding on the composition, I believe, of the committee, yeah, not who's on it, just what seats you'd want to represent, I think, is... There's a lot of discussion if you had, then. How many of them do we want on? How do you pick which people out of MLEs? Yeah. How do we not bias it towards non-profits versus for-profits? There's... That's going to be... It's not such an easy question when you dig down into the totality of it. But...
2:09:33 What was presented at that last meeting, which is in our packet from Juliana, seemed to be kind of a consensus based upon the meetings that they've had, which kind of addressed both non-profit and for-profit. Well, let me speak to that, because I'm in the MLEC, but was not able to attend the majority of the meetings, actually. And I disagree with the overall...
2:09:58 Comments that came out of the MLC recommendations that there is a difference between profit and non-profit, and I can, you know, I can actually take both sides of that argument, but at the same time, I think that there were a lot of people in the audience that, you know, I'm aware of what the MLEC came forward with, but that I don't think that that really is complete consensus. Right. There will be,
2:10:26 And I think that next week when we do discuss this, we're not saying that MLC members wouldn't be able to weigh in, but I would like to point out that there will be a lot of agendas there that are coming forward, and I think that, you know, and this is actually where maybe I even need to remove myself, I'm not sure, you know, let's talk about this next week, just so that it's clear that the
2:10:57 Recommendations that are coming forward, you know, how much should be dedicated to special events, the very first question, before you even get to the non-profit versus profit event, needs to be answered in the best interests of what money is going to be spent for arts and culture versus mobility versus recreation and what defines recreation and what develops, what defines paying back, you know, there's just so many questions that we'll dive into.
2:11:27 I would like it to see this discussion spearheaded by people who maybe don't have a vested interest in an actual event themselves. So maybe I'm even recusing myself right there. Maybe that's for the best. But at the same time, I think it's going to be important that who is really making the recommendations that goes forward to town council is maybe does not have a
2:11:58 Vested interest in receiving money for events. Are we going to add this to Tuesday's agenda then would seem to be the question as Stuart suggested. Stuart, Stuart, we have consensus on that. Terrific. Moving forward. Okay, thank you. So we'll just double back quickly to item number eight. So this was placed on the agenda by commission.
2:12:37 As we run through any award process, we leave it on the agenda for the commission to discuss measure R and provide any direction to staff on the award process. One of the action items on here that's already been addressed was to consider the web-based software application through the spring award outside that competitive process, so to speak. I believe the action taken on the previous item
2:13:07 address that request, so unless the Commission thinks differently, that's the direction that staff are going to follow through. So staff will submit the application by May 1st, Commission would review that application on May 7, would make a recommendation to Council, and then Council would consider that on May 16th. At this time is how we're addressing that. And if you had any other comments on the Spring Award at this time, we haven't received any applications.
2:13:36 We are, however, meeting with the Mammoth Track Club on the 15th of April. So staff's trying to try and engage that group because there was a follow-up question regarding fundraising that was brought up by council for Measure U and the town attorney made an opinion that the request that was put forward as part of that application to contract an organisation to solicit corporate sponsorship for that facility
2:14:05 Fundraising was outside the ordinance, as stated. So that was the determination. So what we're doing with Track Club next week is to really determine what their needs are. What we're looking at here, is it a marketing, is it advertising, it is a campaign. John Urdi is going to attend for Mammoth Lakes Tourism, so we can kind of address those needs all at once. And then looking forward to see how that facility is going to be phased in over the next several years, and including what.
2:14:33 Town are seeing right now needs for that facility as well. I mean, bleachers have been identified. We don't have really many places for people to sit right now. So we're going to address that with that group. And that's the only application apart from the four that the Commission and Council moved forward with, which was the two applications for the Mammoth Ice Rink. So it was the replacing the header pipes.
2:14:59 The concrete stain, the web-based recreation system, and then completing the fence around the Whitmore Recreation Area. So there would be a change here, because currently it's open one, close one, we review the application on the 7th, and an addition needs to be made to that, that we would take the application for software out of order and make a recommendation on that that night, so that needs to be added in. Okay, we can do that.
2:15:32 So the applicant presentation therefore could be May 7th for that web-based software. The web-based software should be on the 7th. So we're keeping it, okay, keeping it within as best we can the. Right. Your processing. Make clear to other presenters that theirs is going to be on the 14th. Okay. If that's the pleasure of the commission. That's fine. Can I make a comment with regard to the staff report film? Mm-hmm.
2:16:02 The Wickmore Recreation Area and Parks Maintenance Position. You know, I was disappointed to see that attached to the Measure R applications that went to Town Council when we specifically said it was not going for it. Or at least we voted on that. Just reading this report, I want to make clear that very last sentence in that
2:16:29 is that staff will not be submitting a spring measure or application for this obligation. That's correct. So staff was directed to put that in, that staff report at that time. I wasn't at that meeting, so I wasn't able to speak to that. And following on further discussion with our budget process, this will actually be included in the town budget moving forward. So when you'll see that in May, the first presentation for our fiscal year 2013-14 budget.
2:17:00 You'll see this budgeted in that line item. And I was actually at council that night and as was Terry. And, you know, we expressed that we as a commission were surprised to see that when it hadn't been included in our regular process. And council, I think, was very receptive. They indicated that they did not want to revisit that conversation. So I think it was put to bed pretty well.
2:17:34 So our recommendation would be what the changes we just made to do to move that forward. We have consensus on that. Yes, we do. Or I do. Any further questions? Okay. Moving along then. Mr. Ten. Discuss and provide direction to staff on the Recreation Facilities Program and planning process and scheduled workshop days. So again, another standing item. I apologize, I missed the last meeting. I haven't received that latest facility matrix from Commissioner Stelic.
2:18:08 So I wasn't able to attach it to this agenda bell. We did also take action to move the April 23rd, sorry, the April 23rd meeting right to next Tuesday. And that's, at this time, if that's the Commission's pleasure to review, and again you can correct me if you had a substantial enough conversation on the trail system master plan, but this one was to review the general plan, the Dr. Sedd's document.
2:18:35 The South Gateway Draft 5 Year and the South Gateway Plan and the Draft 5 CIP Plan. So we've got two hours. So really what we're looking at here as part of this agenda item is to provide direction to staff on what you want to review and what we can get to you for your workshop next Tuesday. Currently, and my calendar may be off, I'm showing a start time of 3 p.m. Is that accurate?
2:19:01 On the 16th? I believe it was always was 2 to 4. 2 to 4. Is that right? I think that's where we've scheduled. We'll try to keep the same time. And now we're talking about moving it to 1 p.m. so that we can discuss the events coalition. So for my calendar, I'm putting it down as 1 to 4 p.m.? Correct. Thank you. It seems pretty... Depending, of course, on how short you keep your comments. Ouch. It seems like that is a pretty ambitious...
2:19:28 It does. And maybe we could move a couple things to the May 21st workshop, which is elements of phase two, which now I don't even remember what that is. Well, phase one was going through all of the plans. Phase two, as I remember, would be to go over the prioritization process. So now we've looked at everything. What bubbles to the surface is our top priority for recreation moving forward.
2:19:58 That would be phase two. And that's going to take a lot all by itself. I don't know that the general plan, because the parks element is the general plan element. We've already looked at the parks plan. Dr. Seds, some people think it holds weight, some don't. But the recreation piece of Dr. Seds shouldn't take that much to get through. Stu, correct me if I'm wrong, it's been a long time since I've read Dr. Seds.
2:20:26 What is Dr. Seuss? That's the Economic Development Document, and I think there's been some updates made to that document as well, so we can look into that. That's kind of why we want to talk about it with you. The other one there is that big South Gateway draft that was published in review but never really got in front of Commission or Council for that matter, so I mean it does warrant certainly a review. And then I think the biggest one is actually probably Ray
2:20:54 You know, walking through that Draft 5 Year CIP, I think that's probably your priority if you're looking at May 21, kind of looking into compacting that matrix that Commissioner Stokes put together. I think that'll be a substantial meaning right there. And then if you talked about prioritising. So I think the Draft 5 Year CIP plan, I think the general plan is an element of the parks. Well, the parks and recreation is the element. Is that section?
2:21:22 Dr. Seds, I think, is pretty small, so we can kind of, you know, pull that together. So it's probably primarily the Draft 5-U-C-I-P and the South Gateway plan. I think if you have 30 minutes on, probably an hour on those three items, I'm thinking the general plan, Dr. Seds and South Gateway could be an hour discussion, maybe 20 minutes each, which would give you an hour to go through that Draft 5-U-C-I-P. I think that's probably reasonably realistic.
2:21:53 Again, if something doesn't make it, you want to continue that discussion, we can carry it over either to May 7 for your commission meeting, then you're not losing time on that compaction of the elements of phase 2. Maybe we should start with the CIP discussion if that's the top priority. Maybe it should be rearranged. The general plan that Dr. Sett's done really quick, because I don't see any need for us to go through everything that's in the general plan.
2:22:26 And since the park master plan is the parks element of the general plan, I, we've already gone over it, that should be a slam dunk, but we can rearrange these as we see fit at the meeting, that we can take them out of order then if necessary. Okay. So I'm good with the plan, just continuing on as we're going, Stu. Okay. Consensus on that? So, yeah. How can we access some of these documents? I mean. So what I'll do is, um. I have the South Gateway, but.
2:23:09 I don't know that we've seen the current CIP proposal. So I'll look into that tomorrow morning and either push out an email with that information or if I need to print hard copies, I'll have them available at the office or if they're electronic, I can get them too as well. I know you do prefer printed copies. So I know the draft five year CIP is online right now. You can get in and have a look at that. I'll check with Ray on making copies. South Gateway plan, there's actually two different plans available on that plan, so I'll make sure we get you the right one.
2:23:39 And the other two are quite small. So I'll update the commission tomorrow on that. Any other questions from Stu on the planning process? Thank you. Okay. Provide direction to staff on recognition of vendors who provide in-kind products or services. So staff wasn't really able to dig into this item. As you can see, we're up to discussion item 11. We apologize. Jamie and I just probably just need to sit down and see what's been done in the past. Typically, it's really a letter from the town manager recognizing that service.
2:24:17 If that's something that we want us to continue to look into, more than happy to do that. I know Z has actually been working with Dennis a lot recently. He was able to acquire some discounted chlorine, some filters that were provided in kind and those type of things. So it's turning into a pretty good partnership down there. So Dennis is quite happy. Stu, we haven't done it in a long time. Yep. But one of the tools in that box that I would like to see us maybe start up again,
2:24:48 In the past, well, distant past, if somebody like Z, the amount of time and effort they've put in, deserves really more community recognition than a letter from the town manager. So the town council, if we suggested, and they do it on their own a lot as well, would give a public certificate of appreciation, and since it's just a computer printout inside of a frame, it should be something that they would still be willing to do for us. And for our in-kind vendors that
2:25:17 Or any volunteers that come up to that level that we think deserve more than just a letter from the town manager. I would like to see that come forward or any suggestions for that come forward so that we can move it to the council or ourselves make our own public presentation at our own meeting for that because it's granicus now. We could easily do that. So I would like to see for some people who are higher deserving, who are really spending the time.
2:25:46 I would like to see that public, I know we laugh about the television broadcasts of this, but I can tell you I get hacked all the time for my appearances, so people do actually watch it, and I think that public recognition goes a long ways to getting people to give their time, so I would like to see us add that in the toolbox.
2:26:11 Does Council have a policy on that? Because I know that they recently recognized the monument signs as you enter into town. No. They don't have a policy. They just individual council members of the mayor bring it up who they want and I bring it up and we put it on the agenda. Right. And there's no reason we couldn't do that ourselves here at this. Don't be nice, I think. Yeah. So I would like to see us consider that and maybe once or twice a year make a list of people that might be deserving and consider that list and move it forward. Okay.
2:26:44 So is that something you'd like to bring back for next, or is that really the direction? So what we're saying there is that the Recreation Commission would consider throughout the year any volunteers or organisations that worthy of in-kind or volunteer above and beyond support of the town would get put forward to town council for public recognition. I think that I've reconsidered my stance on that. I think they would get put forward for us to award the presentation ourselves. You'd do it here? Okay. Yeah.
2:27:13 Yeah, and I, as the owner of a couple of buildings. Right. Yeah, so I think it makes sense for us to give those awards ourselves, and I think it's a good thing for us to do. But we might want to consider if somebody provides in-kind services that...
2:27:36 Are significant. That maybe that should be on a council level so that you, because you do have a little bit bigger audience, I think, and that might encourage more people to donate money or time. Yes. Well, and is there anything, if a group did donate something to town, is there any kind of tax relief? Is there any kind of tax benefits for doing something like that? So the town is considered a non-profit by law. If you were given $100,000,
2:28:06 You can take the same deduction as you would given to any other non-profit. Okay. I think they're not for profit. I think they're not for profit as opposed to non-profit. May I? Yes. In-kind donations, the law says from the IRS, if someone wants to give something to a non-profit and it's an in-kind like chlorine or whatever, you cannot put a value on it. It's against the law. But what you do is you thank them for
2:28:36 The purchase of the chlorine and so on and then all they have to do is attach their receipt to it to show the IRS that they donated with the amount of money on the invoice and then their donation shows it in the letter. That's your write-off for the IRS. Cash, on the other hand, is delivered at the end of the year or at the time with the letter that says thank you for your donation of $100,000. It is a taxable reimbursement unless it's for a service.
2:29:05 For instance, if you purchase a ticket or you go to a dinner and some of that proceeds is part of the dinner, you can't write that part of it off. Only the difference can be written off by IRS rules. Thank you. Does that answer your question? Thank you. That was a change because people did that car program and got it. Okay. Right. Okay. So, Stu, you got our consensus on that? I believe so.
2:29:38 So what would, probably at the direction of either staff or commission, we would agendize this item at a monthly meeting and would recognize those folks? You'd deal with them more than us, so anybody you think is particularly bring that forward to commission at a meeting. And if any of us see somebody that we think is, you know, providing a big service, then we can bring it forward as well. I'd like to see us give more attaboys. It's a good thing for us to do.
2:30:10 Okay, moving right along to manager's report, Stu, I see here that you participated in Easter egg for something to give. Yeah, well, it's like... Look, I can only take ten, Chair. There's a... Well, yeah, I mean, I put the photos in there because we had a... You know, Commissioner Truex was there and it was... There's a lot of kids. It's a great event. It was very spring-like. We had a thousand eggs. We tried to keep it to ten each.
2:30:38 So it's probably more than 100 people because there's people out there that didn't get all their eggs. So it was woof. So we had some issues there, but we solved that. But you know, it was a great event. We had a lot of great volunteers. How many of the eggs got eaten by the bear that lives under the porch right there at the park? Yeah, definitely none. We did find all the three golden eggs too. So it's just a fantastic fun event. We'd love to continue to enhance that and provide that for the community.
2:31:09 The other information in there is instructional basketball. We're moving forward. We'll have a proof of the Recreation Guide available shortly. We had the designer in the other day. So we'll probably send that around just by email to you just to kind of keep you up to speed on how that's looking. It's still that 16 page. There's a Whitmore Recreation Area section.
2:31:34 We've got individual calendar throughout the whole year. So if you want to look at what the Recreation Department provides throughout that summer and fall, you can go straight to the calendar. Or for our primary products, which are our summer camps, will be one page of summer camps. So all the camps we provide, the soccer camps, the year-round programs and events that we have, and the provision for Whitmore Pool and the roller rink as well. So it's a pretty tight program. There's reference to online.
2:32:01 So it's directing people to Mammoth Recreation right there. So it's a great little piece that will hopefully be out, say, probably by the end of the month, easily. I think three weeks is very realistic. And then what we're trying to do with that program this year, and what I think we really need to do is to get that piece to our community. So we want to really get that in a PA box through our postal service, so every resident would receive a recreation guide, because it's really...
2:32:29 That's our piece, right? That's our local community piece. It provides everything that we do primarily for our community. So we want to get that in our local box drop. We also want to get it through Certified, which is really primarily for our visitors. And then we'll have available at all our facilities as well, and we can mail it to those folks that requested those pieces as well. We're still recruiting all those positions. We've got some great applications in. And as we know, we're moving forward with this web-based system.
2:32:58 That office manager position is really someone who has a lot of experience with online or web-based or internet and that type of facility activity management. So that's something that really kind of crystallises that person and what we're looking for. That person would start mid-May. So they'll be ready to go on their installation of that system. And the other thing here we put in was the ice rink. As you can see, somewhat dismal.
2:33:27 The challenges, you can see there quite clearly, we weren't operating for 15 days, I believe is what it was. So we operated for 59 days compared to 87 consecutive days the year prior. So it's certainly one of our lowest participation visitation at the rink for quite some time due to the issues certainly with the weather and those mechanical issues. So we provided that overview. But as you can see there,
2:33:57 We, you know, didn't anticipate the revenue quite clearly, but we did save significant savings on wages, contractual services and public utilities. So that operation was budgeted at about $223,000, I think, for the operation, and I think we only spent about $130 is probably what's going to come forward. So there's quite a considerable general fund savings, actually, from that. But we are budgeting next year to open again once we get these.
2:34:27 Issues solved Thanksgiving Friday, so it would be November 29 all the way through February 23rd, I believe. So, you know, we're really trying to go for that timeline. That's really what we want to do and what we want to provide for the community. So that's the information there. And then you can see we've purchased that steeplechase water barrier for the Mammoth Track Club. Can we go back for a minute? Sure. A couple of questions. I understand we had 28 fewer days.
2:34:55 But obviously our participation on the days we were open was down significantly as well to have that big of a decrease. So if I look at the hockey, which was just over 900 people on 11-12 and 269 in 12-13, are we seeing a drop in the, or just were the days we closed coincided with the days that they would have, which skewed the numbers even more?
2:35:25 Is the energy of that group still up and still there? We think so. We think the energy's there. Just because of those issues, the quality of that surface wasn't really sufficient during the holidays for hockey. So they didn't really start their league until after the holidays. So they started essentially beginning of January. I think it was that first Tuesday night in January. And essentially after that break in February, I think they only had probably four nights.
2:35:56 You know, like league nights, four or five, so it was way down on when they were before, so, you know, we're optimistic, but we do, it brings up a good point, we do, and we have the opportunity with that new software to be a lot more active or to be, you know, more engaged in that league, you know, so we do really want to kind of take a more active role in generating, you know, more interest.
2:36:20 with that league night, because we do, and we have committed to, you know, a lot of time and hours, and then certainly with the glass that we're going to install, with the integrity of the mechanical, with the paint, we're really, you know, I think investing a lot of time and resources into hockey, certainly, but not to the, you know, the loss of any of our regular recreational skating, because that's still our primary market, so.
2:36:48 I kind of took a look at the average based upon the number of days versus the number of participants, and it kind of averaged kind of similar to last year. I came up with 122 people per day average versus last year, 128. So it's similar, but that's a very good point, Bill, to take a look at the numbers on hockey and some of those other uses.
2:37:14 I also recall that toward the end of the season, we had days when we weren't able to open until it got cold enough since the chiller wasn't working. So some of these are partial days, right? That's correct. So the days that we weren't operating, that was closed days, but the days that we were operating, we only operated for maybe two hours.
2:37:34 So I'm already looking for a shade structure. There were also snow days that my family went to the rink and it was closed. Yeah. I do look forward to, you know, you said that there's a decrease in operating expenses as well. So at the end of the day, or the end of the season, I should say, I look forward to seeing just kind of what the overall subsidized number was. Yeah, the subsidized number from the general fund was maybe $10,000, $10,000 to $15,000 from the general fund. You know, the primary source of this revenue was the Mellaroos Assessment District. So it's,
2:38:04 It ran a very limited subsidy apart from Melrose, so the general fund is quite small. Just quickly finishing off, just on that market and feasibility study, so Bill Taylor was contracted with the town to manage a lot of projects within community development, and we've contracted him to oversee the feasibility study, so we think he was a good selection to assist staff in that project, so he already has the scope of work, he's contacted the consultants, so
2:38:36 We're trying to just get that thing up and running and moving as quickly as we can. Can you tell us what the final scope of work came out? What are we actually getting? I think I did send it out to you, but primarily we took out all the recreation component bills, so it's specifically just to do with special event venues, market, demand, cost-benefit analysis. So it's very specific just kind of to an arts and cultural slash special event study. It's a 10-week presentation.
2:39:03 proposed scope of work right now from the time they start to deliver a product and a presentation. Thank you. Do we have a time for the May 7th ribbon-cutting ceremony? Because I believe we're also meeting that day. Yes, so we wanted to do that prior to that meeting, so thanks for bringing it up. Staff, we're probably looking at maybe a 1.30 time, so we can kind of meet down there, or we can do it at 2 and just get that out of the way.
2:39:33 What I wanted to do was just go through the agenda items from what the commission recommended just to work out how full that meeting was so we can either start early or start at 2. I know we've done that previously. We've done either ribbon cuttings and come back at 2. Any preference? I would just suggest that maybe we look at doing it right after the elementary school gets out, which is 1.40, although I don't think that's an early release day because I know kids are really excited about that, and I just think it would be nice to have some kids.
2:40:02 Attend a ribbon-cutting for a playground versus a bunch of middles. You know, but I'd love to bring my kid, but then I've got to take it back to Husky Club. So, I don't know. Yeah, it's tricky. What if we had at T-shirts? You know, my suggestion would be that perhaps we convene the Recreation Commission meeting at 145 at the, can we do that, can we start the meeting at the park, or do we need to start here and then move?
2:40:31 I would suggest we start at 145 at the park, and then however long it takes us, it takes us, and we come back and finish the meeting after that, and that that is our first agenda item, and we deal with it down there. That way, if we are talking about it, we aren't breaking any Brown Act violations, because it is our agenda item, number one. Will there be speeches? Will there be speeches?
2:40:59 That's a good idea. I'm sure there will be. Yes. Stu's pinning his already. You know, actually, Betsy just made a great comment. I wonder if we could get the Husky Club to walk the kids down there. You know, I'll talk to Barbara about, Ms. Barbara about that. Yeah, I think that's a great idea. Yeah. Okay. Can I make one comment with regard to your report, Stu? Of course. I just want the record to show that
2:41:30 On the basketball, where is that? I thought John did a great job as a coach. You know, Jamie, I know your kid was there. Boy, I learned lessons on how to coach a team from John. It was a great program, and I just want to give, put it into the record that I thought John did a great job in coaching the first and second graders in basketball.
2:41:53 And I had a number of people say that to me as well, that they were just really pleased. It was a great program. By that program. That's great. John Connolly, right? Yes. Sorry. Yes, thank you, John. A room full of John's. We got a lot of John's in there. Yeah, no, don't go there. That does conclude my manager's report.
2:42:17 Thank you very much. You're welcome, Chair. We will move on to Commissioner Reports, and we'll start with Sean, since that's the direction I've been leading on. Yeah, okay. Just one, that's only because, you know, I'm involved with the event, but Blizzard Blizzard did announce our headliners, Joan Osborne, and Vintage Trouble was on Jay Leno last night, which is going to be headlining our Friday night, and Mavis Staples on Sunday, and we're already half, 2,500 out of 5,000 tickets sold. So, crazy, huh? Super good job.
2:42:44 Just to reiterate, I was at the community egg hunt, and I really want to commend staff. They did a great job. People had a great time, and I also would like to note it was a very diverse attendance, a lot of locals, but it really, I think, reflected our community. There were some visitors there, so great, great job to you guys. You did a great time, great time, buzzed by all. The new playground.
2:43:09 You know, my six-year-old, very happy, and along with every other kid I've talked to down there. And finally, today I'm going to attend, there's a forum at the elementary school at 545 on the search for a new school superintendent. So if any of you guys have anything you'd like me to mention at that, it's with the school board. You know, since you bring it up and I'm probably not going to be able to be there, Rich.
2:43:39 Brought a passion to work with the town and to make that relationship with the town work that we have never seen before. And I would hate, because of whatever the reasons were that caused him to leave, I would hate to see us get off that trap and go back to the old silo building and the old what can you do for me, not what can we do for our community.
2:44:05 That we experienced before. So that would be what I would want you to take from me to that. Is that what we as a commission can make that statement? Or did you just use that? We can't because it's not on our agenda. This is a commissioner report. But I'm going to answer that for you. But I plan to make a statement to that effect that we just really are, you know, as a parent and as a commissioner just...
2:44:32 I think we'd all like to see that partnership continue, and we'd like them to take that into consideration when they're reviewing candidates. I looked out my window the other day, and it was snowing. I grabbed my fishing pole. I figured it's April. It's snowing. It's got to be opening day. Lo and behold, it wasn't. That's my only report. Thank you. I will take a motion to a request for agenda items. No, I don't care about it. I think that we...
2:45:08 We have several already. Does anybody have anything we haven't spoken to already for agenda? We can just go through them just to clarify. So update on the expanded trial system. Is that needed to come back at all? That's going to go to council on the 17th. I don't think we need to come back here. You'll have the trial system coordinating committee update. That's a standing item. Measure R, obviously, will be on the item.
2:45:35 I think we'll probably put on the best use of town funds, that kind of committee. I think that'll be an item we'll put on there, pending the results from the workshop. And then you'll have your facilities planning and programming discussion. I don't know if there's anything else that we... I'm sure something will come up in the... ...that we discussed, unless you want... Okay. Okay, thank you. See, I didn't make my little clicks by all of these as I went down the road. Got in trouble. Now I went down the road. Move to adjourn.
2:46:10 Second. Motion, a second. Further discussion. All those in favor. Thank you. Thank you. Good job. We'll see if I want a left. We'll see if I want a left.