TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2013

Town Council

· recording 4 hr 53 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

599 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

1:19 Thank you for joining us. My apologies for us getting started so late. The closed session items don't ever seem to get any shorter or easier. So I just want to say we don't have anything to report out of closed session. And with that, we're going to go ahead and get started with our basically our policy item one. Actually, one and two we're going to switch. So we had Nate Greenberg was going to give us a

1:48 Presentation on digital 395, but I think we need to address the budget item first, and then we're going to ask me to come forward and give us an update. So with that, I'll go ahead and ask Marianna to go ahead and get us started with item number two. Members, staff, community, good evening. We have somewhat of a brief PowerPoint presentation tonight that continues your budget discussions, and tonight is our last

2:34 Budget Discussion Meeting. Your budget adoption is scheduled for June 19th. Of course, the discussion can still continue during that meeting, but for all intents and purposes, most of the discussion will likely happen tonight. So with that, I'll present a few slides. As always, department managers and directors are mainly here to answer any of your questions, and we'll look forward to the debate.

3:06 We'll talk very briefly about the audit for the last fiscal year because we never officially presented the results to you. We'll talk a little more about the analysis of actuals that staff recently completed to update the numbers. And ultimately, most importantly, we'll talk to you about revisions to the next fiscal year's baseline and our revised recommendations.

3:35 The financial audit for the fiscal year that ended in June of 2012, so almost a year ago, is available online. Attachment 1 shows a critical page from that audit document. And what we try to do for the sake of transparency, this is the third time that I believe we've done this, is normally a financial audit comes out and you don't really see it, and you should see it.

4:04 The audit goes to a number of entities, including the state, the federal government, and so on, and it's posted on the website, but you rarely have a discussion about it. Over the past two years, we have been bringing the audit results to you and explaining them to you and comparing audit presentation to the budget. So in attachment one, what we have done is attempted to connect the audit fund balances.

4:33 What's the budget fund balances? Again, for the year that ended the year ago, but it's important to give you the official audit results. So really the highlight of that audit is twofold. One is not on the slide, but that is we have a clean audit. That's an accomplishment. And that is called an unqualified audit. That means that our auditor did not find any fiscal issues. They're not looking at balances or deficits as an issue.

5:03 But they did not find any improprieties in our financials. And they also did not find any issues with our controls. How we spend money, how we pay bills, how we make payments and authorize payments. So that's an accomplishment. The second thing is that as we've been talking to you, the reserve as of June of 2012 was at $1 million. As of now, we project that reserve to increase to $2 million.

5:32 By the end of June of this year, in about the month. So that's really the highlight of the audit, and as we keep going through the numbers, through the rest of this presentation, in this meeting, you'll see the REU, the reserve, mentioned a few times. So what I wanted to spend a little more time on is now the analysis of the actual results, revenues and expenditures, to the end of March.

6:00 You may recall that at the last meeting we only had actuals fully completed and analyzed to the end of January. We told you at that time that we would look at the actuals through March to see if the numbers should be adjusted. Now, there's really a dilemma. There are two ways to present the budget. One way, and I wanted to make sure that I explain this, and I'll try to do it later as well, but I think it's important for the council and the community to understand.

6:27 One way, and it's done in many places and it was done here in this town years ago, is to present the budget to you whenever it's presented, April, May, was a shortfall, a surplus, was a set of numbers and say, these are the numbers, we're not going to change them. This is the budget in May, you make a decision on those numbers, we're not going to adjust them. Another way is to say, well, in May we presented the budget to you that was based on January's numbers.

6:56 We're going to continue adjusting them through your budget adoption date, which is what we decided to do here. There are different, under the first scenario you may lose on the accuracy of the numbers, but you have stable numbers, you have the stability. Under the second scenario you have more accurate numbers, but they continue changing from meeting to meeting, which is by...

7:21 Intentionally. So the highlight of our analysis shows in various attachments that are in the report. I am going to focus on the general fund in this presentation, but there's a lot more in the report. Attachment 2B shows general fund revenues. As a result of our analysis of actuals through March, we were able to adjust the revenues.

7:46 Mainly in the property tax and the franchise fee categories. And the general fund expenditures also were adjusted in two places. For the current fiscal year, we made a correction to the gas tax estimate that was incorrectly presented to you previously. And we also made a correction in the next fiscal year to the lease pass-through that is related to MLLA.

8:14 That is already collected in the airport and was mistakenly shown in the town manager as well. So adjustments took place both on the revenue side and the expenditure side. The bottom line, and I'll get to that table in a few moments, the bottom line is your surplus for the current year has gone up and your shortfall for the next year has shrunk. And again, we'll talk about those in a minute.

8:43 So the general fund deficit for the next fiscal year that you're about to make a decision on has been adjusted from $626,000 to $370,000. Again, I can anticipate and I've seen it in other places that, well, the numbers keep moving. Well, they keep moving because we intentionally decided to keep reviewing our actuals and revising our estimates. We could have drawn the line in May.

9:13 And we're going to draw the line today. So whatever numbers we're giving you today on June 19th, they're not going to change because it's too late then. Once you adopt the budget, the actuals will keep changing. That's just the way it is. But on a quarterly basis, we'll be reviewing them, we'll be before you formally with the analysis of revenues and expenditures every quarter, every three months.

9:36 And then if adjustments are necessary, up and down to the budget, we'll be making those decisions. But it's not going to be on a weekly or monthly basis. It's going to be every three months. So with that, your shortfall has been revised. And if you would follow me, and I have this on a slide in a few minutes, but I think what's going to be the most critical at the end of this presentation and hopefully for the discussion, if you look at the handwritten page 33 in your packet,

10:03 And that is attachment four, one attachment that has the fiscal year 13-14 numbers as well as the next four fiscal years. We find it important for you to make a decision about balancing next years but in the context of a five-year forecast because your decisions on the 19 will shape

10:32 The budgets for the next four years. I'll explain that table in a little more detail, and I'll highlight some of the points that are on the slide when I talk about, well, this table is really difficult to see, but it's this table that's my passion for, and I'll try to walk you through this, hopefully in a way that's easy to understand. What we have done here, some things are presented really for context.

10:57 We presented on the top, maybe if I get a little closer to the slide, I can show it to the Council on the Public and then I'll go back to my documents. So there's this section over here, the first two columns that compare of April presentation of the current year's financials versus June presentation.

11:21 And in April, we thought that we would have a surplus of $800,000 plus what the police department is retaining of $300,000. And we thought we would have an ending fund balance of $1.8. Right now, we think the fund balance is going to be at $2 million and the surplus is going to be at $1 million, not including the $300,000 in the police department for the additional officer.

11:48 The next two set of columns is for the next fiscal year, where again, we compare May 15 estimates with the current estimates. As of May 15, you have a shortfall of 76. As of now, that shortfall has gone down. You can trace that the shortfall has gone down because of revenue increases mainly and expenditure reduction a little bit. So the bottom line is, your shortfall is 3.7.

12:16 We adjusted in this shaded form your balancing measures accordingly. We're no longer recommending that you freeze the Community Development Director position. It is a critical position that needs to provide help to the Planning Department of Clean. It's a very small staff. So we would like to fill that position as soon as possible. We do recommend that you cut approximately $90,000 from the public safeties.

12:45 We do recommend that you reduce road rehab funding from 750.

13:12 By 160,000, so down to 590, so not 250, but 160. We still recommend that we not fund fireworks in 2014. We're still going forward with fireworks in the current fiscal year. We're talking about funding for the next fiscal year, 2014. We do recommend that we not fund the chamber, since it's going to fall into the MLT, that we reduce funding for the volunteer program.

13:40 And that's pretty much it. Now, what I also wanted to express to you, let me go back to that more adequately. At a higher level, we've talked about the fact that the five-year forecast that you saw in December was balanced. Now we're not. While the differences are still the same differences that we showed you before, and they're shaded on the bottom.

14:05 The five-year forecast did not include funding for the Whitmore Pool and the maintenance position. It's not there. It's 187, it goes up. The five-year forecast, and this is an item that is somewhat new, the five-year forecast also did not include the loss of grants in community and economic development.

14:29 That we just simply didn't know about and did not fully analyze at that time. So there's about 100,000 worth of grants in community and economic development that currently pay for positions that are going to be gone. Well, the five-year forecast did not capture that because the assumption was that those grants paid for the consultants. Well, they pay for staff as well. So those two items put you out of balance with your previous forecast. Other than that, you're still in the same place.

14:57 So once you find those two items and find approximately 270 in the first year down to 300,000 in the third year, your balance was the exception of the last year. You see the 400,000 on the bottom of the last year, well, it's a new year. It's a year that was not the new initial five-year forecast because your previous five-year forecast started with 12,13.

15:25 And went through 16, 17. We now added an additional year. Enough years even worse than your high years. So you have to fund an additional 400,000 to stay at your RU of 8%. If you decide to go lower the RU, you don't need to fund that amount. One other piece that was on the slide before is in the report as well.

15:47 One thing to keep in mind is the five-year forecast, the old one and the new one, still assumes that in December of 2015 and December of 2017, we're going to upfront the money to pay the state for the two housing loans that we own. That money is going to be turned to us once the properties that are assisted with those loans are sold. When is that going to happen? We don't know. It may happen in a year. It may happen in 15 years.

16:17 But that money will return, and it will return to your general fund and add to your fund balance. So I think it's important to keep that as context for the $400,000 that you're yet to identify in the fifth year. Because if you assume that, let's say, half of that state loan, which is combined about $700,000, if half of it returns within five years, then you don't need to look for the $400,000. And again, it's in my report.

16:45 So again, it's important to keep in mind the balancing measures that we recommended and consider them in light of the next five years because the next five years are not going to be any better than what 13, 14 represents. I also believe, and it's important to note, that our revenue assumptions are quite aggressive. For example, our COT is at 11.2, I believe, in the current year.

17:15 And the forecast assumes that it's going to continue increasing per single year from 2 to 4 percent. Is that going to be the case? I hope so, and that's why I put it in the budget. Is it possible that there's going to be a dry year? That's a possibility, and that's why we need to have a reserve. So that's an important factor as well. So with that, I think we're going to conclude this presentation.

17:41 I really encourage you to discuss budget balancing in the context of the five-year forecast. I would encourage you to look at Henry in page 33 and attachment 4 and provide good direction to us. And again, staff are here. They have done a marvelous job. It takes a lot of time for us to do this financial analysis with the systems that we have.

18:03 They all have full plates. So I think it's a good product. You have good numbers. We're not going to change them between now and June 19th. And we're here to answer any questions. Okay. Thank you, Marianna. And thanks, staff, for generating. I can only imagine the time it takes to create it.

18:23 How much time it takes to read it. And Mayor Council, was your permission, I think what we're going to do for the rest of this meeting and maybe even for the regular session, it's always awkward for us to stand here without that to the public. I think we're going to sit there and answer your questions. As you have questions, staff will come up and do that. So that we can also face the public and face you as well. That'd be great. Thank you. Okay. Well, with that, I'll go ahead and...

18:52 Start with Council and see if there are any particular questions or concerns or suggestions any Council members may have with regard to the balancing measures proposed. And Jo? Yes, and actually what I'd like to do is throw out some more ideas for Council and the community to think about

19:18 So that we have more things on the balancing list and then we can debate which stays on, which goes off at the next meeting. You know, in other words, have more available to us in cuts and then argue priorities at that point. With that in mind, I was going to suggest that we still need to consider the $27,000 cut to the phishing enhancement that was on the first set of documents and then has not carried forward.

19:48 My goal is to get as much back into road rehab as possible, so I'd love to have that discussion. I would also suggest that we need to not discuss the single-family home nightly rentals until we have a way to fund the study that gives us something to make our decisions on.

20:16 Do we have that budgeted in here? No. It was on one of the ones saying it's not in the budget. So I'm just reminding us all that it's not in the budget. And I don't remember the cost, but I think it should be on the list. Also, later tonight, we are going to be looking at the idea of a code enforcement team. I can't think of the right word for it now. Task Force. Task Force, thank you. But I would like to propose that we consider

20:44 The fact that for several years now, the business license fees and taxes have all gone to marketing, and I believe that was a council decision. And I was going to suggest that that same amount of money, which is only around $250,000 or $300,000, but that amount of money could get us that task force and also get us incentives to help the businesses spiff up. I don't know what the official term would be, but I'd like that to be on the list.

21:13 That we change that revenue source. And yes, I recognize that's less money to MLT, but it is not touching Measure A. So I'd like that to be considered. And then finally, I will state it again that I do not see taking money from the REU for filling positions. But we also had a previous agenda bill talking about having a different task force for the business incentives and the diff that we've left.

21:43 Unfinished and unfunded that to me using the REU for a one-time study is appropriate and to fund that out of REU. And I believe part of that will be discussed with the Planning and Economic Development Commission next week, but I wanted to put it out there to be on the list for consideration. I'm sorry I missed that, Jo. To fund which study? The DIF and the business incentives. It was again, it was buried in the

22:12 In the May 15th one as one of the details in CED that we didn't have funding for that study to be done, I think it's important enough to consider that coming from RU. It requires study. Oh, yeah. Yeah. Well, it requires doing what we're behind on. Right. But it's part of finishing up everything that's being discussed with the downtown working group, and it's part of getting ourselves ready for investment, so I think it's important for us to discuss it on the 19th. Okay.

22:41 Anything else, Jo? No. Oh, just one thing. I will say it again is that another officer is good, but I don't want us to get in a position where if we have funding for 19 months, and okay, maybe because of hiring that gets us through two years, is we need to be pretty sure that we'd have a way to continue that person. Thank you, Jo. I'll go ahead and bring it over to John. John, if you have some items. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor.

23:14 On page two, first paragraph, says our REU, which is the Reserve for Economic Uncertainty, which is our savings account. In the past year, in fact, June 30th of 2012, so a year ago, it was at $1 million. This is currently projected to increase at the year end, which is right now, to $2 million. So my question is,

23:44 And I think I know the answer. We've increased our reserve for economic uncertainty from $1 million to $2 million. What's the composition of that $1 million that we're adding to it? And where did that $1 million come from? Sure. The $1 million has come from a will. We anticipate that by your end it is going to come from critically two sources. One is

24:13 Less use of the legal retainers. We anticipate that we would spend 1.5 in additional legal retainers on top of the 4 million or so that we spent initially. We only spent 1.1. So there was a savings of about $400,000. And secondly, gas tax revenue for the current year is going to be higher than we initially anticipated because of

24:40 The winter last year being a little worse than what we thought it would be. So those were the two critical sources of the savings. Okay. First of all, is it fair to say that, and we talked about this earlier, you brought it forward, that we have differences in estimations on our property tax, sales tax, and franchise fees. And if you cancel out property tax and franchise,

25:09 That there's really, between those three, there's an about $100,000 increase in what we projected. I believe that's correct. I mean roughly. Yeah. Okay. So the council was told, and I don't know the dates, roughly two months ago that we had a $1 million surplus. Approximately, and I'm just using round numbers, approximately $300,000 of that was for, came from the police department, and that's where

25:42 And again, help me, Joe, but either the council at that time gave direction on a consensus basis or we actually had a vote. And I'm not sure which, or I'm not positive if we had either, gave direction to the chief of police that he had $300,000 to go ahead and move forward in the recruitment process for an additional officer using that $300,000 for

26:11 Creating a position for a two-year time period. That's correct. Do we remember if that was a consensus? I recall exactly what happened. It was a consensus. This was part of staff's year-end presentation on April the 3rd, I believe. And we projected at that time that the police department would have savings of about $300,000. The savings are still there. As a matter of fact, as you just indicated, the savings are higher for the current fiscal year than we anticipated.

26:37 So the police department still has the $300,000 you gave direction to staff at staff's recommendation at that meeting to fund a new position for two years with those savings. Since that time, we had news on the next year's budget, and so that's why we're now proposing to use a portion of the savings that are still there for the current year to balance next year. So that's the only difference. Okay. So as of yet, we haven't changed that consensus.

27:06 From Council as far as hiring a police position for two years? Not in my opinion, not to my knowledge. Okay. And I'm getting sidetracked, Jo, and I apologize, but I wanted to address that point first, and that is that to me there's a big difference between being able to advertise a police officer's position for 19 months versus two years.

27:39 If an officer is coming from somewhere else or wants to join our force, I think it's more likely that they would be interested in that position if they had a two-year guarantee as opposed to 19 months. 19 months is pretty close to a year and a half. So it's a large commitment on whoever might want that position. So I would support following the consensus that we had earlier and reinforcing that.

28:10 That consensus or through a vote at some time, not right now, but at some time to the chief of police so that he can advertise for two years as opposed to 19 months. So I would not support that as a proposed cut to balance our budget. John, let me just add something to that. Because we had originally talked about that February or March, we were thinking it would be like you'd have someone on July 1.

28:38 And they'd have two years. Now, if we approve it now, that 19 months might take them through June of 2015 anyway. I'm not hung up on that. I'm hung up on the two-year situation. Oh, okay. I think that that's important. I've heard that that's important in the recruitment process that the police department has the ability to make that a two-year commitment as opposed to a year and a half. But let's move on. That one-time

29:13 General Fund surplus that we were talking about two months ago, whenever it was. $300,000 is addressed with the police department and then the balance of that, the $700,000, I think the council also gave direction at that same time that we wanted to put that into the REU. Is that correct? That is correct. I believe also that in this current year's budget,

29:44 2012, 2013, that we budgeted, I believe, $400,000 to go towards the REU? No, actually, in the current, the bottom line is, no, we budgeted a balanced budget. You start with $1 million, we anticipated that we would add with $1 million, and so, yeah, no, we did not anticipate that anything would go to the REU. Okay.

30:13 So, but the bottom line as it's presented to us here is that it's being proposed that we would add $1 million to an existing $1 million to bring the REU up to $2 million. That is correct. Okay. As a general statement, I want the council to realize that municipalities provide services to the people, to the public, to the organization, to the community.

30:46 Whatever those services may be. So I have a line that I support not putting money into a savings account when our projected revenue deficit for next year is $300 and some thousand. I think it's our job, our duty, our purpose to provide services more so than

31:17 I support using

31:47 The Reserve for Economic Uncertainty as a loan, as a bank, as a savings to balance the budget, the 300 plus thousand, whatever it is, and putting in not a million dollars, adding a million dollars to the existing one million REU, but adding 700,000. I think that that adding 700,000 instead of a million makes a statement on the importance of the REU and still having

32:16 Enough money to fund the programs that are being proposed to cut. John, you're saying 300, so you would not fund the REU by about 300. You do 700 versus a million. It's listed at 370. There are some things in the balancing recommendations. Oh, so you're saying to take 300, 370 from the REU and pay for all these items that don't make any cuts. Is that where you're going?

32:52 There are a couple of cuts that I do support. Okay. Okay, so roughly $300. Yes. Yeah. I'm just trying to see where you got that $300 from. Yeah, and that's a round number. Okay. Yeah. Did we, in this year's budget, we came up with the, it's a one-time $1 million surplus for a variety of reasons. Do we have the number where,

33:35 In this budget year of projection, we projected revenues and we projected expenditures. Do we have a number of the excess revenues that came in above that are unrelated to that million dollars, you know, bed tax or whatever other revenue that was that came in above our expenditures where we have a surplus in that area?

34:03 Most of your surplus is one time in nature. I explained about 800,000 of the one million. So most of it is one time, and that's what we made or tried to make very clear in April that the reason we wanted for that 700,000 at a time and one million right now to be added to the reserves is because it's one time, and we believe it belongs to the reserves. I understand. Let me rephrase. Maybe so of the one million,

34:32 Surplus, that $1 million came not from revenue from TOT or bed tax that came in above what we had anticipated. It came from other things. It did. For all intents and purposes, it did. And I think it's clear once you look at the next four years, you see huge shortfalls. So your shortfall in the current fiscal year is 370. In the...

35:02 In the following fiscal year, it's actually a little less, and then shortfalls go up to $1 million, to $530,000, to $800,000, and $6,000. Of course, in some of those years, we're going to be paying off the housing loans. So you can see that the surplus is really not sustainable, and most of it was one time. It's clear in those numbers. Thank you. Okay.

35:35 Thank you, John. I'll go ahead and turn to Michael. I just had a couple things. One, Mary, I'm really happy to see the CED position out on the new list. Me too. I think it's a high priority for us. Another question I had was on the $34,000, the firework budget on that, have you had discussions with the county to see if they would pick that tab up or split that or has there been any dialogue?

36:02 I haven't. It's something that we could discuss with the county and see if there is any possibility for regional collaboration. As a matter of fact, I will do that before June 19th. I recall we had a very similar, almost identical discussion about a year ago, and I don't know if at that time we approached the county, but I will discuss it with the interim administrator at this time. Their permanent administrator doesn't start until Monday, I believe.

36:32 Okay. Third thing is, I'm pretty supportive with this revised recommendation. Still a little concerned on the road rehab, as Joe mentioned as well. You know, and I mean, obviously, I'm supportive of finding new revenues and collecting T.O.T. that's out there. So, you know, those funding those positions are a high priority for me.

37:04 I understand what John was saying about on the REU. My opinion is, you know, that it's dangerously low now. And to go in that even for short terms alone, if we have some, you know, lower revenues coming in, then we'll be in trouble. So I'm just, I do like the revised recommendations. Okay. Mayor Pro Tem, Wood.

37:40 My approach is going to be a little bit different than everybody else's thus far, and let's see if I can articulate this. It seems to me that a budget document is the opportunity for the council to establish clearly to the community, to its staff, and to ourselves what our priorities are. And what we try to do, like all people in public office, is

38:12 The best we can with the revenues that we have and what I mean by that is the best we can to meet the requests and the needs that are put before us. So for five months we've been looking at numbers that while they change still suggest to me that we are trying to do too much.

38:41 With too little. And so what I don't think we've done yet successfully as a council is articulate what are, let's take them, the five most important priorities for this community. So in my mind, you know, the thing that we have to focus on first and foremost is the core services. And in my mind, the core services are public safety, public works, which include

39:11 The fact that we own and operate an airport. Community development, finance, administration, and then sort of on the side, because it's an extra, recreation. And I don't mean RNU, but I mean municipal recreation. And so one of the things that Marianna and I have talked about is beginning literally next month,

39:41 Creating the opportunity for us to have a public dialogue about what those broad priorities are because we can't do everything that everybody wants us to do. There isn't enough money. And you can argue, well, you know, we're going to look to the future and grow our way out of it and so on and there may be additional sources of revenue or maybe we've budgeted to do conservatively. None of that really matters to me because I don't think that we have yet said to the public

40:10 In very harsh terms, no, we're not going to do this. Whatever it might be. We always seem to find a way to meet everybody's needs. And so the difficulty that I have in saying tonight what is most important to me is that I don't want to say that other than in a debate setting where we actually have the time to do that. John, generally I'm with you in the sense that

40:41 It seems to me that if there's an expectation, whether it's just sort of institutionalized because it's been around for so long that we're going to fund certain kinds of activities and programs and facilities and the stuff that the government does, that it ought to continue when we have a surplus. And in the past we've done that. But I want to have a broader discussion, and I tend to do that, and I know this council wants to do that as well.

41:09 One could make the argument, I think, really well that the REU addition should be only $700,000 and that $300,000 ought to be used to backfill some of these proposed cuts. Having said that, I'm of a mind that a number of these proposed cuts are appropriate because, honestly, it's really, for me, the top five priorities and the rest of it really falls into second tier. And second tier may mean that we're not going to fund something.

41:40 We're not going to support that which we've supported in the past because we can't and that's a hard decision for the council to make and I'm certainly prepared to make it. So I think all of the suggestions from the three that I've heard are worthy of discussion on the 19th where my sort of bent is.

42:04 Is that it's very important for us to consider those core services. I'm really supportive of bringing back some money into this police department. I think that we put together a plan and we lost 40% of our force. And I don't think the community can afford it. And so I like the suggestion with respect to the police officer. Frankly, I'd like to have two. I don't think we can afford it. Second, I...

42:32 I have a lot of concerns about the roads. I don't know whether everybody out there and you notice it, but instead of overlaying and paving over with the thin paving, the roads, we're just crack sealing everything. Have you noticed that? I mean, they're everywhere laying down that tar into those cracks. Well, that's only going to last for so long. And the concern that I have is that we're going to later tonight talk about this.

43:01 New approach to marketing. And it's going to be controversial and it's going to be a difficult decision. But what is it that we're marketing, folks? We're marketing us, our community. And the community includes broken railroad ties and peeling paint and cracked curbs and bike paths whose little cracks turn into big cracks every year because they're not being fixed. And in my mind, that's core stuff. Those are core things that need to be done.

43:30 One of the other things, and we haven't really talked about it in the budget discussion, but I know that Matthew's on board with this, is we set out a timetable to community development to get this zoning code updated so that we'd be ready for the next wave of investment. And we don't have the staff to do it. And for me to say to staff, get it done, is just one thing. But in my mind, that's a core service. That's something that's important. Only governments can do community development. And so...

43:56 I'm prepared to have that discussion about what those priorities are and what that really means to me. If I can put it into concrete terms is that provided that we can reach consensus on what these cuts ought to be, maybe some money ought to come from the REU and then when we get down to business beginning in July, and by the way, this may take a couple months for us to really sort through this, or long sessions, or special sessions, I don't know.

44:24 But it seems to me that we ought to signal to the public on June 19th when we adopt the budget that although it's a budget, it's a final budget, and we need that in order to pay bills on July 1st or 2nd, it's also a budget that may be subject to change because we may decide if we examine our priorities that the priorities that are stated in this budget, including the cuts we've made and the additional cuts that are proposed,

44:54 Are not exactly the right priorities. So there's my different take on it. Okay, thank you. Yeah, it's always challenging, especially when you start getting down to the last bits here because you've always saved the hardest pieces for last. I think one thing Mayor Pro Tem Wood did touch on and I agree with and I wrote it down from my notes tonight is that I do believe that

45:27 In spite of the budget we have before us, the revenue streams, the expenditures, we're all placing great faith in what's going to happen with our marketing. And I think that while we have projected for 2% increases over time, I actually anticipate much greater increases, much greater over time. I think it will be about a year or so before we really start seeing that.

45:55 Because assuming this TBID passes and assuming that a lot of the marketing efforts that have been put into place kick in, I think we are going to see a new normal for revenues, too. This summer, I expect us to have, you know, in the wake of the best summer ever last year, the bestest summer ever this year, if there is such a thing. Is that proper English? No, it's not. It's very improper.

46:23 But with that, I don't want to bank on it until we see it happen. So I'm comfortable looking at the revenue streams as we have it this year, and maybe next year we're going to adjust everything based on a new revenue that we may be seeing come in. With that, for the most part, I'm in agreement with a lot of the recommendations proposed and how we filtered it down. John, I think you've made some very good points, too, as far as, you know,

46:52 You know, trying to get an officer in there with a 19-month, it is interesting to, you know, just look at an offering for a job and see a 19-month position. It's challenging. The fireworks, I'm really not, you know, that's something that draws a lot of folks up here. It's something, it's been a tradition we've been doing for many, many years, and that's certainly a challenging one. I think that, and this may sound hokey, but...

47:19 And Bridgeport, they raise all the money for their fireworks show. It's a pretty impressive show. And they do that over a course of a year. And I think if we start looking back to something as simple as just doing basic fundraising, whether it be sticking to Cannon Bonds or whatever else it may be, you know, if they can raise those types of funds just in a small community like Bridgeport, I imagine we could do the same thing and then some. So I'd be interested in looking towards that and even other revenue sources, but I'm not in favor of that cut.

47:48 The roads, every year we have been cutting further on these roads. $160,000 today is going to be $360,000 next year because I think Ray Jarvis explained it very well that once you let that go so far, the cost isn't to just repair it anymore. You now have to replace it. So I'm interested between now and the next meeting really trying to find a different funding source for that so we don't have to make that cut.

48:17 You know, perhaps Mayor Pro Tem would write in that maybe a combination. Maybe we'd have to take a little bit from REU. Maybe we have to take a look to Measure R and turn direct for some of these other items for a temporary funding until we really see what our revenue stream is going to do. So with that, for the most part, I'm in favor. But between now and the next meeting, I'm still going to be searching pretty hard to see if there's a way we can not make any of these cuts. But there's a few of them there that I've just...

48:47 Absolutely. I don't think we can live with right now. So with that, I'd like to turn it over to any other council members or anybody in the public that would like to come up. Yes, Mariana? Mayor, council members, I also just wanted to take the opportunity and emphasize for the public and for you, even though you know this, so I'm speaking mainly to the public, that we have a great team of managers.

49:11 And what you see before you is something that is the result of teamwork. And I wanted to thank them for this. And as you were speaking about public safety, that really came to mind because I've been in cities and organizations where departments work against each other. Dan Watson could have come in and said, I don't care how you balance the budget. I have my $300,000. He did not. He said, let's see what we can take from me. Let's see what we can take from Ray. Ray the same way. He said,

49:41 Let's cut my road rehab budget a little bit, and that's going to help us with the shortfall. So the teamwork and the cooperation between and among departments really shows in the balancing measures that we brought before you. And I just wanted to recognize that and acknowledge that and thank the team for doing that. On a related note, we spoke about priorities. That's how the budget should have started, was the discussion of priorities.

50:07 Well, we never had time to really start that way because we had the settlement and then we had the December conversation about the budget and the budget adoption and then from there we just went straight into the budget. However, again, to acknowledge staff has done their best to anticipate what the community's priorities are and again it's in our recommendations and it's reflective of their anticipation, their hard work and their teamwork.

50:33 So again, I just wanted to take the time and acknowledge that before we take public speakers. Thank you. Thank you, Marianna. And if I could add one quick thing. I did have an opportunity to meet with some of the department heads in Marianna this morning. And what a lot of department heads and what Marianna came up with were a lot of great suggestions for some long-term solutions.

50:56 And I think by the next meeting hopefully we can at least discuss some of those and incorporate them. They don't fix our budget today necessarily, but I do appreciate the time that they took to offer a lot of those great suggestions. So thank you. And Donette, it looks like you had a comment. Donette Hustleton, before I jump into my comment, I just want to say thank you for the youth program check for the swim team. So the first thing I want to say is to Mariana.

51:28 And I thought the last time she spoke and she was at the negative 626 and bringing it down to three something is pretty amazing. That's a pretty hard task to do. So great job. I also want to address Rick's comment a couple weeks ago when you had said about Measure A we had a 15 year commitment. Last year you guys also had a commitment with the housing and you had to take big cuts there.

51:53 You also, everybody, if you recall Whitmore, everybody showed up and you all decided to do a monkey survey and asked the public what do they really want. This is what you talked about, Rick. This is, we have so much money. What is really important to the public? And maybe that survey needs to go out so you can figure out what is important to the public. Is it to fund measure A over to MLT for the full amount?

52:22 Or is it to cut some of it to offset some of the infrastructure that the town needs to do? Or backfill the 300 that you might need to do, maybe in the future? But the bottom line is you can market all you want. But if you have, like you talked about, crack this, something looks bad, people aren't going to come back. So all the marketing you do isn't going to bring them back. So we need to have a nice place. We need to offer those events. We need to offer our park and recs.

52:52 Plus, you need to have protection. And people need to think that they're safe when they come here. So I think you guys are so challenged with what does the people want? Ask the people what they want. We all filled out that survey, and you guys made decisions based on that survey. And I think that's really important. And I don't know if that's a solution, Rick, but it's a thought.

53:18 I am inclined to use some of the Measure A money to help with the infrastructure backfill if you need to and see what happens with the marketing. And if the marketing is showing that it's bringing in, great, then you raise it. But I don't know if it is showing that if we don't have a great infrastructure. Okay. Thank you, Donna. Thank you. I'm going to ask everybody if they could just keep it as short as they possibly can while getting your point across just because we've gone so far over.

53:51 Go ahead. Sorry, Terry. Good evening, Council. Terry Stelick. I just wanted to clarify Joe's point about the business license, that that wasn't actually a council decision. That was back in the 1986 or 89 when the original measure was passed. That was actually part of that whole measure of raising the TOT tax and then the business license directly for marketing. It's in that as well. Okay. And so anyway, I just wanted to clarify that.

54:19 Kind of just for public knowledge that Measure A was tapped into for $215,000 that has came back into this budget and it's been addressed to stay there for the next five years. Thank you, Terry. Good evening. Jennifer Halperty, Mammoth Lakes Housing. I created a real small spreadsheet that I just want to share with you. For those of you just coming in, we're actually, this is actually the workshop running over. We haven't gotten into the

55:01 Actual meeting yet, so go ahead. Okay, so there's been talk tonight multiple times with regard to Measure A funds and the political commitments, as well as to the five-year budget and the payment of the state loans for housing. And so what I've done here, based on the numbers that were presented in your packet tonight and agenda item two, laid out housing funds over the next, this

55:30 Proposed this next year, 2013-14, all the way through to 2017-18, and the 1% that is dedicated, you'll see that on the top line of 13% to TOT. And then under that you'll see where everybody committed 10% cuts to the settlement of the MLLA, and that's the 10% cut you'll see right there below that, that negative number. And then below that is

55:58 The funds that are going to the general fund. How much of the 1% of 13% dedicated to housing that's going to the general fund. And then below that is what's in the budget to fund housing. And you'll see under fiscal year 15-16 and 17-18 that there's sufficient funds in the 1% of 13% for housing to pay for those state loans. That it doesn't come out of general fund.

56:25 It is within the 1%, and I think that it's not been presented clearly to you or the community, and it seems as if the general fund has to pay for those, but lo and behold, there's actually plenty of funds and still funds for the 10% for the MLA settlement, excuse me, and a little bit left over for general fund as well. So that housing is taking more than a 10% hit, and it is a political commitment. So I just want to point that out. Okay.

56:56 Any comments from Council? I have a comment, Mayor, Councilmembers. I don't see the spreadsheet. Once I take a look at it, I may be able to give you additional information. But I think it's important for us to remind the Council and the community because we went through settlement discussions seemingly fast, even though it seems that we were in closed session for too long. But as part of the settlement, FTI was here, Fulbright was here, and it was a good advice.

57:25 That we made a determination for the next five years that any funds that are not linked to either debt service or contractual obligations in housing or tourism or transit would revert to the general fund. So the savings, so to speak, that Jennifer discussed are already in your general fund

57:52 Baseline projections in the five year as a result of those discussions of hand was forced because the measure A is not a legally binding measure and so that's the way it is. Okay. Thank you, Marianna. Anybody else have a comment on the budget workshop?

58:18 Okay, seeing none, we will be back here for the next meeting and hopefully be able to wrap this up and have a balanced budget for everybody and hopefully we'll have some better news as we move forward. So with that, we'll go ahead and wrap up the workshop and then I want to turn to council and see, we have Nate lined up to still give a discussion on

58:47 Digital 395. And I think a lot of folks have been asking about that. So if everybody doesn't mind, I'd like to give Nate some time to go ahead and present that to us because I think it's something that affects us all. So Nate, if you want to come on up and give us that presentation before we get started with our regular meeting. Sure, thank you. Good evening. My name is Nate Greenberg. I'm the GIS coordinator and the Digital 395 project manager for the county and town of Mammoth.

59:59 Mayor Lehman asked some questions regarding Digital 395 and as I'll describe in a few moments, the Eastern Sierra Connect, which is a regional consortia, is charged with reaching out to all of the local government entities throughout the region to speak about policy and what is happening with Digital 395 as well. So this fits into that. I'm aware you guys have a very full agenda. I've paired this down as much as I can and I'm happy to answer questions out of the original slide deck or

1:00:27 Any other things that come up as I go through it. So just to jump in, to provide just a little bit of background, not to give a full tech lesson, but what we really commonly know the Internet as is more normally broken up into kind of three areas, what's called first, middle, and last mile. And essentially what that is is it's a basic network between servers on one end and consumers on the other end. The Internet is the space that's in between that and

1:00:58 Really, the way we mostly associate with the internet is through the internet service providers, which is in that last mile arena. Digital 395 is what's called a middle mile project. It's a $110 million project roughly to construct about 600 miles of fiber between Barstow and Carson City. And that's really the long haul route. So middle mile, you can equate to a highway transportation system.

1:01:27 Last Mile you can equate to a local road network. And they are basically constructing from Barstow to Carson City and along the way really providing just a few last mile connections to about 250 government education and medical facilities as well as internet service providers. And we as a town and all of our infrastructure, community center, police station, so on and so forth, will be connected.

1:01:56 Through last mile services to Digital 395 directly. But for the general consumer, businesses and residences, we'll be turning to internet service providers in Mammoth. That's pretty much Suddenlink and Verizon to get those last mile connections. And Mammoth is different than every other community in Mono County or Inyo County or Eastern Kern, for that matter, that are connecting to Digital 395. This looks very different depending on the community you're in and the providers that are there. And I'll talk a little bit about that in a moment.

1:02:27 To give you a little more background, the Eastern Sierra Connect Regional Broadband Consortium, which I mentioned a moment ago, is one of 14 regional consortia that is funded through the California Public Utilities Commission out of a rate pair fund that's called the California Advanced Services Fund. That fund is used for grant sources. Some of that money went to Digital 385, as well as other last mile projects to...

1:02:55 Kind of help build those bridges between things like Digital 385 and the average consumer. That fund also paid for consortia to do outreach to local electives and regional governments as well as to the public to focus on various different aspects that range from adoption once the Internet is present to identifying communities of need and trying to partner and pair providers.

1:03:22 With those communities of need to get projects built in those areas. So we're doing all of those things. And in Mammoth, it looks a little different than it does in other portions of the county and throughout the region. The consortia covers basically Mono County, Inyo County, and Eastern Kern County. And as I said, there's 13 others throughout the state that kind of make up the rest of it.

1:03:45 Every consortia is approaching these goals a little bit differently, but one of the first things that our consortia did was we provided a survey, which to date has reached about 700 recipients or respondents, and the main purpose behind the survey was to get a feel from the users or the consumers what their experience is like, and as most of us can imagine, either purchasing the internet or being frustrated because you can't purchase the internet.

1:04:12 They range within those tolerances, that it's either too expensive, it's not available, or once they have it, the speeds aren't good enough. So those are problems that we've all been plagued with throughout the region for a long time, and Digital 395 will clearly change that. The interesting thing about the survey response is that not only did everybody want better internet, but they were willing to pay more. They realized that they may have to pony up another $10, $15 a month potentially to get those services.

1:04:41 And that's something that's very important for providers to understand. And one of the ways that we've been using the survey, not only to understand the makeup within the region, but is also to reach out to the providers and say, Community X has demographic type of this, and, you know, there's 100 people out there who are clamoring for internet, they're willing to pay, so on and so forth.

1:05:04 That has resulted in the greater region in multiple different applications coming to the California Advanced Services Fund to build last mile services. In Mono County, there are three of those applications that total in the neighborhood about $4 million. One of those is SHAV.net. There is a portion of his project which is targeted at the town of Mammoth. It remains to be seen whether it fully qualifies given that there are already providers currently in town.

1:05:33 But luckily in Mammoth we do have those two providers that are both wireline providers, one's DSL through Verizon, the other cable through Suddenlink, and they both provide reasonably good service currently and have the capacity to provide better service once there is additional capacity or backhaul coming in behind them. Now that's the biggest limitation that we see everywhere is not necessarily is there a provider but what is the main pipe that's servicing that provider.

1:06:00 And as we know, up until very recently, with Verizon's upgrade between Bishop and Mammoth, that capacity didn't exist. Now within Mammoth, we're seeing Verizon open up the market or taking on new customers. And they're also offering enhanced DSL services within a certain radius of their central office of 7 meg to 15 meg down, whereas previously they were offering something in the 1 to 3 meg down range.

1:06:29 Suddenlink is interested in ramping up their services once they have additional backhaul. They have the network capacity here. It's just that pipe again that's missing. They're interested in building a model that's similar to what they have in Truckee or Auburn. Up there, they're offering 50 meg down plans. They have a triple play bundle, I believe, that's running around $99. And I don't want to be quoted on any of that, but they're looking at a similar sort of...

1:06:58 So I'd like to just take all of that as background and switch gears just briefly and talk a little bit about policy. And all of the things that I've been talking about up until now are happening independent of the town's engagement in any of these processes. That's all fine and well. The biggest reason that I bring policy up is because

1:07:29 These things are all happening without our engagement. And the result of that could be, it could have deleterious impacts or it could result in some things that we don't necessarily desire necessarily. So broadband itself is unregulated. The FCC itself regulates things like cellular networks and communications. Public Utilities Commission regulates other utilities, water, power, etc. But broadband itself in its true form is

1:07:59 Truly unregulated. It kind of slips between the cracks. And having policies in place with a local entity focus or a regional focus as it may be helps the entities have a little better control potentially over what happens as service comes in. A big thing here is protecting assets and resources. And you guys have been talking a lot about roads. If underground is the expectation or the requirement

1:08:26 of providers to install new services within the community going forward because of capacity of existing overhead structures and things like that. How does that impact our roads going forward if they're going to be saw cutting in the asphalt or doing work in the shoulder or things like that? So having some forward thinking in terms of installing infrastructure and conduit in roads when we're doing road work like was done on Sierra Park, it goes a long way. Not only opens up the door for providers,

1:08:55 But it also protects our assets and positions the town in a better place. And really, it does facilitate the expansion of broadband when we have some forward thinking about how we would like to see that done. Not to digress a ton, but a quick example of this is out on the coast, King City and the city of San Leandro saw an example a few years ago. A large software company, about 1,500 people, was looking for

1:09:24 A outdoor-oriented community like Mammoth to site its software company. They wanted access not only to the Bay Area and all the infrastructure that existed there, but recreation opportunities for employees and business class internet. Well, the city of San Leandro was very interested in engaging the software company and working with them to build what was ultimately a municipal private-public partnership.

1:09:52 King City basically threw up roadblocks, basically waved price tags in front of the provider or the software company the whole way saying, yeah, we'd be fine with you coming in, but you have to basically meet objectives A, B, C, and D. It's going to cost you this and this. They went to San Leandro. It's now a multi-million dollar revenue generating source for that city, and King City is kind of left where it was. So some other things.

1:10:22 That are valuable in terms of putting policies in place are this is a regional network. This is the biggest project that we've seen in the eastern Sierra since the aqueduct, 100 years. And having some regional view with a local application of policy goes a long way. A service provider like Sudden Link who's doing business in Inyo County or the city of Bishop or June Lake in the town of Mammoth doesn't want to see four different sets of policies in terms of what they can do, how they can do it, what it's going to cost.

1:10:51 And those types of things, having consistency, helps smooth their process for coming into places or expanding or looking at new markets to develop in. And when they're different, you know, it just kind of throws up all these different obstacles that they have to negotiate. And it provides the town some standards to lean on when tough issues come up. When Digital 385 is looking to do construction with method A and they come back all of a sudden with a desire to do something different,

1:11:20 If we have some language in a general plan or within our ordinances that say this is what we expect to see and how we expect to see it, it gives us a little more leverage or some more teeth to kind of stand behind. Not to dig in too much to what some of these policy items would be, but the high-level overview, I touched on some development standards. Mono County is in the process of writing a new chapter for our general plan, incidentally, that is going to encompass a lot of these things.

1:11:50 Development standards are one of them in the county. Any new subdivision that goes in is required to put in underground conduit infrastructure to support inclusion of broadband or other telco. Within town rights of way, I think having a dig once standard in place is a wise idea so that if somebody is going in to do utility work, they're putting in open conduit that can be used in the future so we don't cut the road twice. If we're doing road work anyway, looking at finding some additional revenue or some additional...

1:12:19 Money that exists out of the general fund even to put towards, you know, the conduit that could be potentially used in the future. The things that protect our resources and assets. Open access, encouraging competition. We all know that it's only a good thing. There are tremendous economic development opportunities here that I think have yet to be seen. The OCSoft is a good example of that. As well as impacts for open government. So we already are using Granicus and things like that.

1:12:48 To expand that and the public reach that this potentially has is tremendous. And there are some other standards, as we already know, through franchise fees and other revenue generation opportunities that exist through broadband. So in closing, just to talk a little bit about adoption and really what that means, there's kind of three areas. There's the residential and community kind of aspect, business and economic development aspect, and then our

1:13:17 Town or government use of it. As I said, the town is already working with the county to develop a plan for adoption of Digital 395 within our half a dozen or so facilities, so that's something that we're working with Mariana on now. Within the business and economic development side, the consortia has partnered with Cal State University of Bakersfield in their small business development center, offering webinars to local businesses on ways that they can

1:13:47 Bolster and improve their businesses through various different things, including broadband. We also basically funded six small businesses, developing kind of starter website for each of them, and we're going to be following them over the course of a couple of years to see how having an online presence has really helped them build their business up and supported them. And then the residential side, we're doing a lot of work with at-risk populations.

1:14:14 School populations and seniors to try to improve access and adoption within those communities and offering free digital literacy classes and other similar things to parents of children, English as second language and things like that. So I'm happy to answer any questions about that. I also understand that there may be some questions regarding the town-county IT relationship, which I could entertain as well. Okay.

1:14:42 Thank you, Nate. I'll start with any other council members if you have any questions. Yeah, John. First of all, thank you, Nate, for coming here this evening and giving us an update. Thank you. The last mile, we're seeing some activity in the community, or at least coming into the community in recent days. There's some equipment staging across from the Chart House in that parking area.

1:15:10 Is that indicative that at some point they'll be doing the underlying work, underground work? Yeah, they have been doing work on Meridian from the 203 intersection up towards the college. I don't know the exact status of that, but it is underway, and they've done some of the work on Sierra Park Road as well. Some of that cable was placed, I believe, in the conduit that was present. Who's paying for that?

1:15:40 What's that? Who's paying for that? That's all part of the $1910 million grant that originally funded Digital 395. It is. That's not last miles? No. So their obligation is the backbone itself for the long haul, 600 miles, or it's really like 500 miles, and then about another 100 miles, effectively, of distribution within those communities to reach those 250 anchors. So they are basically doing the construction from...

1:16:07 The route that would come up 203 and go out, Samuel Cutoff Road, down Sierra Park Road to the school, to this building, the building across the street. So all of that is the construction that's going on in town to reach those anchors. Okay. So it'll really come into the Vons parking lot area? That's the furthest west it'll come? Actually, there's a route going to the mountain, going across the street, Sierra Center Mall, going to the community center, post office.

1:16:37 Station 1. I want to say there's about a dozen anchors in town. Okay. Last question. I believe the completion date is, is it July 1st or into June? July 31st. 31st. I think the 30th actually. Okay. That's the date they're gunning for. It seems as though they will get pretty much all the backbone work done by then and hopefully a good portion of the anchor work done, but there will most likely be some spillover into the

1:17:07 Middle to the latter part of the summer to get a lot of the other anchors online. I think that's a question for a lot of people in most of the communities and particularly in Mammoth Lakes because of the size of our population, but people are really interested in, you know, when can I get on the internet? Is a reasonable date October or you're hoping before that? I think before that, hopefully. I mean, as I said, so Verizon recently completed some upgrades to their system and now within a...

1:17:34 Well, within the main core portion of town, those services are now available to new customers, and Suddenlink is waiting for the Digital 385 backhaul to come in, and the hope is that they will have a lot of the distribution work in Mammoth done maybe by the end of this month, and that Suddenlink will be able to start working with that handoff and testing and potentially taking on customers in July or August. Thank you. Okay.

1:18:00 Just to make sure I understand it is these anchors are a direct connect. Correct. But they're going to institutions, the hospital, the library, et cetera. Consumers, individual residences will still go through Suddenlink or Verizon or hopefully we get more competition someday. That's, yeah, correct. Anybody else have any questions for Nate? Okay, seeing none, Nate, thank you very much. I think it's very helpful. I've had a lot of questions on that, so I really appreciate it.

1:18:32 Okay, with that, we'll go ahead and get started on our regular meeting here half hour late, but I had a lot of stuff to cover, so with that, we'll go ahead and turn to Jamie. Can we get a roll call, please? Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here.

1:18:55 Okay, and with that, so tonight we've asked Rick Phelps, the President of the Mammoth Lakes Noon Rotary, to come in and lead us through the Pledge of Allegiance. So, Rick, if you would, please. Thank you. What a wonderful night to be on the top of the agenda. You place your hand over your heart and think of the Rotary motto of service above self and also the members of our community that are serving in the Armed Forces around the world.

1:19:26 I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic of which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisibility and justice for all. Thank you. I might point out, with the noon club and the morning sunrise club, about 70 active Rotarians and their extended family and volunteers, that's 200 to 300 people working in the community. So thank you very much for asking.

1:19:55 Rick, and thanks for coming in and doing that for us. Appreciate it. With that, I'm going to go ahead and turn to public comment. And so during this public comment period, if you want to come up and speak to anything that's not on the agenda tonight, please do so. Come up, state your name, and let us know what you're thinking. Good evening, Council Member of the Public. My name is John Wentworth, and I'm just giving you an update on the Summer Stewardship Trail Day program, which kicked off this last Saturday.

1:20:25 Primarily focused on the mountain bike trails that were impacted by the fuels reduction efforts up in the Panorama Dome. We had the highest turnout of the five-year program to date. Fifty-one volunteers showed up and got a lot of work done. There are more events coming up over the course of the summer. The next one is July 6th. The information is on MLTPA's website. I wanted to make sure I acknowledge the sponsors and the participants in the program. Friends of the India and MLTPA do this as a partnered effort.

1:20:53 And this year we're very grateful to have Mammoth Brewing, Old New York Deli, Sunrise Roadway providing the kind of series sponsors, providing food and lunches and breakfast and that kind of stuff. And a lot of really good work got done. I know you guys have a lot of work to do tonight. But about 114 plaques, if you ride your bike in the Lakes Basement Paths, you'll see the new Mammoth Lakes Tourism Logos now on all those plaques up and down the whole length of the path. These are plaques that MLTPA was able to finance and provide to the community. Happy to see them on the ground finally.

1:21:21 Thank you all very much. Looking forward to seeing you out on the trails. Thank you. Thank you, John. Council members, Jack Copeland, President of Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce. I just want to give you an update on a few things the Chamber's involved in. Parade organization and recruiting is going strong, but we still have availability. The parade is a great way for businesses and organizations.

1:21:52 And even other events to advertise their events in front of 3,000 to 5,000 people who are looking for something to do. And we've got about 60% of the entries filled. And I'm hoping that all of you will join as a town council entry into the parade. I know that you have a thankless job. But we thank you. The chamber thanks you. The citizens of Mammoth Lakes thank you for...

1:22:21 The time and effort and the pain that you endure to do your jobs. And we'd like to have you in the parade. No cost. Also, I've been at work scouring the businesses of Mammoth Lakes, California, looking for outstanding customer service. And in next week's Monday morning email, I have an example that I think will interest you of a terrific customer service experience in Mammoth Lakes.

1:22:49 And I want to remind you and everyone that the Chamber Mixer next week on Tuesday is at Campo Restaurant from 5 to 7. I would like to see everybody there who would like to come and talk in an informal setting with other business people if there are any questions that we have to answer them. Any questions for Jack? Thank you, Jack. I appreciate it. Thanks for everything. Here we are.

1:23:18 Good evening, John Urdi, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. I just wanted to let everybody know the summer events guides are out. We have 155,000 of these. They were produced in early May, distributed from San Diego all the way up to the Bay Area, over to Las Vegas, obviously, locally as well. I've left a stack of these in the back for folks if they want to take them, and then we also put up the posters in the back there, but they're all over town and also in that geographic area, again, from the Bay Area down to San Diego.

1:23:45 Driving everybody to the website, mammothfestivals.com. This is a sampling of the biggest events that we have going on, but everything else is listed on the website, so people can get the information there. One other update, I know we talked about some of the pro cycling teams that we've been trying to get to come and train at altitude with us. We do have Team Bissell coming in the, I believe it's the first two weeks of July to come in and use the crib to train here in town, which is fantastic, so a little more recognition on that side as well. We had three,

1:24:15 Olympians in town last week using the crib. We had two Australians and one woman from Great Britain who's going to be training in here for potentially even joining the team down the road. So exciting stuff. John, can you give us an update on the half marathon? Yeah, the half marathon is definitely coming along very well. So we were looking at bumping up against the 1,000-person limit that we had set with the organizers. So it's going to be a great event for us again June 23rd.

1:24:43 The whole weekend is really tied in. Old Mammoth Road is doing a craft beer and wine walk the Friday night and Saturday before, I believe, and that's going to be a nice addition to that, but we're looking at potentially upwards of 1,000 runners and their families coming into town before 4th of July, which is fantastic. Pretty good for a first-year event. It's not bad for a first-year event. I think what's going to happen is people are going to run the course. They're going to see how beautiful it is, and the word of mouth is going to spread pretty quick.

1:25:10 The reason they set the – we had a few reasons on the 1,000-person limit just because it was a first-year event. We want to make sure we get our logistics down. But also for them it's hard because they have to order medals and they have to order bibs and they have to do all these different things well in advance. So I think that the success of it this year, we'll definitely see it grow. They grew their event in San Diego by about 20% this past year. And I think they're fairly maxed out at about 7,500 down there. Great. Thank you. And they do a great job. It's a world-class event.

1:25:38 For those people considering it, it's almost all downhill. And there is a 5K version for folks like me. Thank you, John. Anybody else in the public have anything you'd like to speak to that's not on the agenda? I'll make this brief. Sandy Hogan, and tonight I'm speaking on behalf of the Mammoth Knowles Homeowners Association. And our board, I'm kind of a junior member on it. I've only been in town 18 years.

1:26:14 Thank you.

1:26:44 Going, in other words, fill those positions and institutionalize it because what was missing for so many years was exactly DOT enforcement and now we're seeing it. And for a new organization, I think it's less than a year and a half, that task force, it's really impressive. The second subject, and one of the board wanted to say these are two subjects. The second one, of course, is the issue that has been before you off and on, the single family.

1:27:12 The short-term rentals. And as I say, most of those folks on my board have been here many, many years. And what they are saying is if there are to be changes, make them cautious, be careful, be thoughtful, do not make quick decisions. A lot of them have lived through the past here when we've always had these good ideas on how to bring in money fast. And sometimes it's really been a...

1:27:41 Not a good decision. And so they wanted me to remind you just to be thoughtful, go through the process, do a good study, and then discuss it. So basically that's it. Great. Thank you, Sandy. Anybody have any questions for Sandy? Okay, thank you. Anybody else in the public have anything they'd like to add?

1:28:07 Okay, seeing none, there is a correspondence section and basically for those that aren't familiar with it, a lot of folks send in letters in favor or opposed to a certain item and what we've done is we've included those in the agenda now so everybody can read them, not just council members. So for those of you that are interested in reading what some of the feedback is within the community, those letters are available.

1:28:34 With that, I'll go ahead and turn to Councilmember Reports and any additions to the agenda. So, Jo, I'll start with you. Actually, John Wentworth stole most of my thunder about the summer of stewardship. Mayor Lehman and I were out there, but I do need him to show off his injury from all that hard work. There it is. Happened to sit me on a desk. A paper cut once, but...

1:29:02 That was more than the paper cut. Everybody, the entire community that came out worked really hard. Okay. Anything else, John? No, that's it. John? Thank you, Matthew. I had just one item I wanted to mention to the public. The Mammoth Lakes Police Department held its fifth Community Hispanic Advisory Committee town hall meeting on May 24th. It was a Friday evening, and it went from 4.30 to 8.30 at night.

1:29:31 It was well attended by approximately 60 local residents, including Chief Watson, who was the main sponsor. We had Officer Ramos, one of our local policemen. Mono County Sheriff Odenberger. We also had Hector Gonzalez from the Superior Court offices here in Mammoth. We had Sandra

1:30:01 Canini, Sanini, excuse me, from Wild Iris. We had, excuse me, Guillermo Marquez, and also Gabriel Barone, and these gentlemen were from the Mexican Councilate in Sacramento. The star of the evening, if you will, was a gentleman by the name of Mr. Salazar, and Mr. Salazar is an immigration rights attorney out of Fresno,

1:30:31 And he came over here for this meeting. I believe it's the second meeting that he's attended, the last two. He was able to directly answer many questions from those in the audience and gave free advice. So he was very appropriate. As usual, there was lots of food provided by several local restaurants, such as Smoke Yard, Toomey's, Good Life Cafe, Lackanooki,

1:31:00 Roberto's, McDonald's, Starbucks, Schatz Bakery, and Jalapenos. The town hall meeting proved to be both enlightening and entertaining for those who were able to attend. There will likely be a similar town hall meeting around this time next year, and a special thanks goes to Chief Watson for his leadership and his efforts in organizing this event. I wanted to add just a couple more quick items.

1:31:32 The first meeting that we had, this was the fifth meeting, the first meeting that we had several years ago, and I wanted to bring this up just because it shows the progression of the effectiveness of these meetings. At the first meeting we had about 100 local people there. There was tension and fear in the room. Some people were afraid to even attend the meeting.

1:31:58 Many of the questions that were asked by those there were accusatory. And after five meetings, this meeting that we had last month, it was more of a festive meeting. Those in attendance were at ease. There was laughter. They told stories. What it shows is that trust, because of these meetings, again, I want to give credit to Chief Watson,

1:32:27 Our chief of police. Because of these meetings, the police department in Mammoth has built a much better trust among the Hispanic community here in Mammoth to where they feel free that they're able to come to that meeting and ask questions that are relevant to them. That's all. Thank you. Great. Thank you, John. Councilmember Raimondo. Just FYI, the intense cycle group from Temecula

1:32:55 They're going to be coming up June 12th to the 14th for the 2nd, Intensa Palooza demo bike riding up at the mountain. So everybody can come out and join up for that. Mayor Pro Tem Wood. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Just one item from the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board meeting this week. It's a monthly meeting this week. And that is a couple of items from that. One is...

1:33:24 There are still 34 low and very low income households on the waiting list for rental units showing that the need continues out there for restricted or assisted housing. Second, that we have two units that are in escrow to purchase back in order to save deed restrictions, one of which is already

1:33:53 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:34:23 Okay. Thank you. I just have one thing, and it was that I attended the town clean-up day, and as far as I could see, it was a success. I just really wanted to say thank you to Johnny Gates, Chef John Conley, who was out there cooking for us, and Stu Brown, and other members of staff, and the sponsors, and everybody else that helped make that happen. I think it's always a successful event.

1:34:51 Snowy year. It's always nice to get our town cleaned up. So thank you to all you folks for all that. We greatly appreciate it. And with that, we'll go ahead and move on to reports from commissions and or departments. Did you have some? I believe it's just going to be Recreation Department Mayor. I have a few items. I'd just like to update the council and the members of our public.

1:35:22 So the Recreation Commission on June 4th made their funding recommendations for the Measure R Spring Award. They'll be before Council on the 19th of June. Staff will also be presenting an Agenda Bill on June 19th regarding the contracting of the SMG Group to facilitate the Mammoth Lakes Recreation process.

1:35:43 Special Event Task Force that we talked about, they've met once already and again are scheduled to meet on June 21. I think we can kind of wrap that up in about four meetings, get back before Council again in September, if not earlier. Staff is currently installing a new web-based recreation online reservation system called ActiveNet. So that's where a lot of our time is right now, but it's going to be a tremendous asset for the community and our hundreds of visitors and thousands renting our facilities and our...

1:36:12 Popular Camps. We're set to go live tentatively on June 24th, so look for some press on that as well. This is a big acronym, but I'll just call it the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee have made their funding recommendations for next fiscal year's trail projects. That'll be before the council again on June 19th, which is a busy night. Also I do want to say that

1:36:40 Free Swim Day is June 22nd at the Whitmore Pool. That's our current opening for that facility for recreational swimming season. And Free Scape Day at the Roller Rink. That opens on June 22nd as well. So it's kind of our big launch for summer for recreation in Mammoth Lake. So hopefully the community can come out and join us on those days. A couple of other things as well. Talking about the Whitmore Track, Nike has scheduled a couple of days shooting a commercial with the...

1:37:09 Track later in June for a couple of days. That's good exposure for that facility. On the special event side, Kitapalooza is this Saturday at Mammoth Creek Park. Town's permitted that event as well. And we're also permitting the inaugural Mammoth to Bishop bike ride on June 15th as well. We've just talked about Mammoth Half Marathon. That group is here right now finalising that route. Looks like we've got everything wrapped up for that.

1:37:33 Also, I do want to reiterate, and it's on the town website, and it's going in every information channel we can, but the July 4th Firework Show is on July 4th at Crowley Lake, so make sure you come and join us. It's $25 for vehicle, or if you want to walk in, it's only $5. So again, it's a tremendous annual event that the town hosts, and we did also, as we have done in the past, receive a donation of $5,000 to support that event from the Elkis family.

1:38:03 So that's terrific. So we're kind of making that as affordable as we can. So it's a great donation. And then just quickly, Mayor, there is an item just coming up on the introduction of Recreation Department staff. One of our staff is at the Little Sluggers. The other one's at the pool. The other one's kind of comatose from the installation of ActiveNet. Brain's a bit full.

1:38:29 And our site coordinator is unavailable as well. So we're going to try and bump that recreation staff introduction to June 19th, which I think is closer to kind of our kickoff. But we do and we have available our new camps and facilities brochure. So that's available throughout town. We don't have 155,000 like the little event brochure, but we do have 15,000. So on the front is our camps and facilities. On the back is our Whitmore recreation area.

1:38:55 Offering. So that's all our municipal programs and facilities that we offer throughout the town this summer and fall. So please grab one and also go online and check out what we have. I think that's it. Wow. We've got a lot going on. Thank you. All right. Thanks, Stu. Anybody have any questions for Stu? Okay. Great. Thank you. Any other commissions or department heads? Okay. Seeing none, we'll go ahead and move on to council presentations.

1:39:25 This is item number three, so Chief Watson. I'd like to ask John Mayer to come up. I know he's here somewhere. There he is. Well, today I have good news and bad news. The good news is for John Mayer. Friday will be his last day with the town of Mammoth Lakes after 17 years with us and 30 years in law enforcement. He actually retired in December but came back on a contract for six months to kind of help us through the transition period, and that's been very helpful.

1:40:01 He decided to take an early retirement in December when we lost a number of positions, including the lieutenant's position to help save a police officer's position down the road somewhere. I think that's sort of indicative of what type of individual John Mayer is. With his departure, we'll now be down to 10 sworn officers. We're very, very thin, as you know. We are hopeful that we'll be able to continue to keep the lid on town, and we're doing the best we can.

1:40:30 John started his career in 1983 with the city of Hawthorne as a police officer. He spent 10 years there and went to Huntington Beach. Did about three or four years there and got tired of the beach and came to the mountains in 1996 and joined our department. He was promoted to sergeant in 2005 and lieutenant in 2011. His departure is going to leave a really big void in the police department and in the community.

1:40:57 You know, it's a cliche to say, well, nobody's irreplaceable, and that's true, but John is going to be very difficult to fill what he brings to the police department, and that's the type of leadership that he provides. John is a great mentor, a coach, a leader for the members of the police department. He's the guy in the department that the officers go to for advice and counsel for both personal and professional reasons.

1:41:25 When I got here three years ago, I interviewed every employee on a number of items. And among them, I talked about supervisors and who the top police officers were. And it was evident that John Mayer was highly respected by everybody in the department. Some of the comments that I picked up about John were that he really cares for us as people. He teaches us and then lets us go off and do our job.

1:41:48 And it doesn't keep too strong a leash. He encourages creative thinking and doesn't overreact when ideas don't work out. And I think most important is he makes me want to be a better police officer. I think these are comments that are reflective of a truly great leader. I'm going to miss him as a partner and a friend. John's been a confidant and advisor to me. He tells me when he thinks I'm wrong. I appreciate the fact he does it in the right setting.

1:42:14 That's a sign of loyalty, though, and a lot of people don't have the courage to do that. He keeps his ears to the walls and knows what's going on in the police station and amongst the employees. And that's really valuable information when you're leading an organization is to know not just the performance and the statistics, but what's in people's minds and what issues are causing them problems and help identify ways to solve them. John has served the police department, his people, and the community very well.

1:42:44 For the last 17 years, and I want to wish him best of luck in retirement. And the good news is, he's not completely living town, only part-time, he will be around for a little bit. So, for that, I'd like to just thank John Mayer. Thank you for having me add a few things. John, everybody in this room is standing up, everybody's clapping, everybody knows John Mayer. I just wanted to say that with John leaving, that will create a void that is irreplaceable in my mind.

1:43:33 John Mayer not only was the epitome of a great police officer in this community and lieutenant in his final years, he was here 17 years. He was more than a police officer. He was a member of the community. He participated in things. He was a friend of many of us in this room and outside this room. So I can't imagine having a better police officer and lieutenant than John Mayer was to this community for 17 years. So thank you for your service, John. Thank you.

1:44:08 I just have a couple things to say. First of all, I don't know if I got tired of the beach, but 17 years ago when I got sworn in here, a couple of you were sitting where you are right now, and you're still here, so that says a lot for this place. I just want to say thank you to all of you. Mammoth has provided me with a lot of opportunities, a lot of friendships, a lot of challenges, and I am moving back to the beach, but we're keeping a place here, so we'll be back and forth, but thank you very much.

1:44:53 Okay. We're going to go ahead and move on to introductions now. And we're skipping over that. Okay. This item is to be continued to the next meeting. We do not have staff here tonight, unfortunately. Okay. My fault on that then. With that, we'll move on to the consent agenda.

1:45:18 And with that, I'll go ahead and ask council or any members of the public if there are any items that they would like pulled from the consent agenda. Yes, I would like number seven pulled. Okay, Joe's pulling number seven. Mr. Mayor, item number eight, please. Okay, and number eight. Anybody else? Mr. Mayor, I'll move that the council... Oh, you want to ask the public? We have, please. Seven, which is the electronic media is being pulled.

1:45:46 That was the one, the first one, and the second one was for the letter of support Mammoth Blue Brewing Company. That's number six. That's number six? Would you want, are you pulling that? Yeah. Okay, so, Martin, all right. Mr. Mayor, I'll move for council adoption of consent agenda items five and nine. Second motion. We have a motion and a second. Roll call please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.

1:46:17 Okay. And with that, Martin, I'll go ahead and ask if you want to come up and speak to that item. Martin Highberg, Mammoth Lakes Residence Meeting Council and staff. I just wanted to renew my position that I stated last meeting about the ordinance and the violation section that I still feel that it should be necessary to not be ambiguous with what kind of

1:46:47 assessment of penalties is going to be, we do have a town schedule for penalties and I think it should be attached to that section that says first offense this that and not just say it could be either a misdemeanor or an infraction. I mean you wouldn't want to be pulled over a first speeding ticket and if the officers win because of circumstances to decide how serious five miles over the speed limit is for you. I mean because there's

1:47:16 You know, in the vehicle code, there's several different, you know, other types of tickets they can give you when you get to be more serious. So we have an established set of rules just to have a schedule as opposed to being ambiguous. I just think it's just, it's cleaner. That's what I'm going to call. Okay. Thank you, Martin. Do any council members have anything they'd like to add or comments? Anybody in the public?

1:47:48 Okay. With that, I'll entertain a motion on number six. I'll move to choose option one and wave the first reading introduced by title only, the ordinance amending chapter 8.12 of the Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code related to solid waste collection. I seconded. I have a motion. Any? Oh, yes. I'm sorry. Customers, if I may, one clarification. I think this is the second reading in adoption. I think we've already done the first. Yeah, thanks.

1:48:16 Okay. I'll amend my motion to change first to second. Thanks. Second. Okay. We have an amendment to the motion and amendment to the second. So roll call please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay. Motion passes. And Joe, you pulled item number seven. I did because I believe there's some further clarification on the discussion of what this really meant about

1:48:45 Whether or not electronic records were being deleted versus public documents being deleted. And I'd like to ask our town attorney if you could provide the information that we received by email. Certainly. Mr. Kleinbard has asked a question about why are we doing this? Why are we deleting potentially important public records after two years? In talking to Jamie,

1:49:11 We have an existing document retention policy. It just doesn't cover emails. And emails, of course, can be town records. So to fill in that hole to address what happens with emails that may be important, we think it's necessary to address it as part of the electronic media use policy. The two-year deletion schedule that's in the draft policy is what state law says. It's right there in the government code that you have to maintain most public records for two years.

1:49:38 Mr. Kleinbarg feels that it should be longer, and, you know, the council has the option of doing that if you like, but the policy is consistent with state law. It says we have to keep stuff for two years. Policy says we'll keep stuff for two years. And could you also clarify that that doesn't mean that you didn't in some way retain it offline longer? Like printing something out and putting it in a file if it's an important one? If it's not scheduling a meeting, if it was something important policy? Right, that's absolutely true. This policy only applies to electronic records, so it's only emails.

1:50:08 And if anybody cares to print something out and keep a hard copy, then it would not be, those hard copies would not be subject to this policy. They might be kept for longer. Thank you. And I think there might have been some questions from the public as well. Martin, did you have some comments? Yeah, I do have some comments. Two years is kind of a short period of time for certain correspondence that can be dealt with on town business level that it quite frequently is.

1:50:38 Done through emails. And without that backup on your end, I mean, certainly I would keep the records longer than that. I mean, I have to as a contractor, I have to keep the records for five years after the date of completion. Several other professionals, you keep records for a lot longer taxes, generally around seven years. Yes, I never said that anyone was incorrect by saying that two years was not the minimum standard for the state law.

1:51:08 I just think that when the state law was enacted, that's when media storage was very expensive in comparison to today. Today media storage is very inexpensive and the amount you can store for a little bit of money is really nothing. And I think that the council may think that getting rid of a document sooner than later at the earliest permissible time is beneficial because it's no longer in the town record.

1:51:38 But if disagreements and things come up, and you have a copy because you didn't, you went past the two years, I just think that you would have a problem if you have a copy and then you don't have a copy. You know, I just think that three years, I've looked through some guidelines and a handbook, and a lot of the documents, like documents that are significant.

1:52:07 Official decisions or commitments reached verbally person to person and then was backed up by an email. Those types of things I think need to stay on the public record for a longer period of time. And I think that to print them as a preservation material and then to subsequently scan them to produce them electronically again is a little bit absurd. I mean, keep it electronic.

1:52:35 Keep it a little bit longer. I just think that two years is the absolute minimum for a lot of the documents by law, but there's a lot of documents that it doesn't specify, and when the law was written, it wasn't taken into account the year 2013, where, you know, a hard drive with two terabytes storage would probably sufficiently handle most of the entire email for all of Town Staff, less, of course, photographs and video.

1:53:05 Okay. Thank you, Martin. I would agree with Martin on this point. And now that you're going to get your new servers, Mariana, I'm sure we'll have plenty of storage space, Bill. Ted, you're a newspaper man. You don't think two years is old news? I keep my emails from 2003. Okay. What about bankruptcy documents? Okay.

1:53:35 With that, item number seven. Just one further clarification, Andy, is that what this is setting up is essentially an automatic deletion, but if something has been moved into a separate folder from either deleted items or sent items, it's retained, right? It's retained for two years, yes. Do we have a sense that other municipalities in the state of California have different, what's the norm, do we know?

1:54:05 You know, it's really all over the map. The most common retention period, in my experience, is the retention period state law specifies. So two years for most documents. And then, of course, there are a bunch of documents that you have to keep for longer. And from what I've seen, that's what most cities do. Is it 50-50, 80-20, or do we know? I don't have numbers. Okay. Do you know anybody that retains it for three years or four years? Not off the top of my head. I'm sure I could find an example or two. Okay. Do you know Martin? I did a little bit of research. It is all over the place.

1:54:34 Two years was like the absolute, of course, by law was the minimum, but a lot of it is, you know, some of it is five years. And, you know, my biggest concern is that the email exchange of, say, things that happened tonight, those things get deleted because a lot of that stuff doesn't need to be saved for more than two years. Somebody wants to go back and research the record to see what people were thinking about at the time, it's lost. You know, unless somebody who's an official archivist...

1:55:03 Takes over from the town and pulls all that information on a daily, weekly basis and stores it somewhere. Could I ask Jamie to respond to that? Mr. Plymer, for instance, all your emails that you sent regarding this item, they're all printed up, they were all scanned onto Granicus, which is archived forever right now. They're also putting a file in our storage vault, so they're there, with this item. So if in 10 years you wanted to look up these things,

1:55:33 You can look it up online from this meeting. You can email me and ask me to look it up from this item. So I think you're getting confused between emails and public records. Your comments regarding tonight's agenda item is a public record, and that is kept. Emails about, am I available for next week's meeting? Those will be deleted, and they are not kept. It says here, retention time, two years, it says, email that begins or authorizes completes an item.

1:56:01 Or a transaction of an official town business, two years. That's not an official public... It's considered a public record, it says it right here. Okay. That's mine. I think the journalists are more interested in knowing about the secret emails between Mr. Raimondo and Mr. Gregory regarding various issues. That's why we want to keep them.

1:56:33 Mayor, Councilmember, this policy was developed in consultation with our legal counsel, and you have an option of approving it tonight based on staff's recommendations. One option I could see is to delay this policy. We could consult with Mono County IT Department to see what policy they have. We did. Okay? Okay. So we've done that too. Okay.

1:57:01 I'll come back to Council. Jo, you pulled in. Do you have any thoughts? Well, and actually, since we went through discovery last fall, I've been religiously getting rid of the appointment, you know, et cetera, and the number of emails that are in the holding until with two years up is growing rapidly. I think it is just a huge issue. I believe that...

1:57:27 We've got the recommendations here of how to manage it and that nothing that is of import is going to get lost because there's that option of saving it in a different form. Okay. Anyone else? Do I hear a motion? Sure. I'll move that we approve option one, which is to adopt the resolutions approving the town's electronic media use and electronic communication retention policy.

1:57:58 And the volunteer program and handbooked as presented. Okay, I have a motion. Do I hear a second? Second. A motion and a second. Jamie? Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, motion passes. And Councilmember Raimondo, you pulled item number eight regarding Mammoth Brewing Company, SBA, application letter of support. Joyce? I just had a couple quick questions for you.

1:58:30 First off, congratulations on growing your business. It's great. I've just heard some questions in town regarding this and thought it'd bring to your attention of what we're actually supporting. Are we supporting you guys, you know, growing an expanded brewery, you know, brew facility in town or going to Bishop like there's been talk? What the intentions are that we're supporting, really? So what this SBA loan does in particular is refinance it.

1:59:01 Thank you.

1:59:27 At the end of the day, what we will be building is a destination brewery tasting room retail center here in Mammoth Lakes where we'll combine the existing production facility that we have with the tasting room so you can come see the product being made, sample it all, buy a pint, get your case, get your t-shirt, and have the full destination experience of

1:59:54 Our craft beers here in Mammoth Lakes. We will be moving, not moving, but we will be building an additional facility down in Bishop that can grow up to about 100,000 barrels a year, which is the only place we've been able to find that can facilitate the kind of capacity we need and want to grow Mammoth Brewing Company to a true regional brewery in the craft beer industry. That'll put us on the shelves.

2:00:20 All over the rest of California and ideally into Arizona and Nevada as well. So we see that as kind of a win-win for everybody. Mammoth will still brew four to five thousand barrels a year right here in Mammoth Lakes, which is what we're doing now. We'll create a destination here in Mammoth. We'll employ as many or more people than we are now because we envision expanding our retail capacity from what we're doing now.

2:00:46 Bishop will allow us to take the name Mammoth and put it on the shelves all over the western U.S. and draw even more people here. So that's our goal. Thank you. Okay. Any questions for Joyce? Just want to say congratulations as well and I think it's going to be a good marketing effort for us as well, Mammoth.

2:01:08 Well, and we do truly appreciate that the town is supporting us politically like this. Our banking partner is concerned about one little issue that is fairly irrelevant to the intentions of the rules, but they do need to make an exception. And we have fortunately gotten support, hopefully, from you this evening. We've gotten also from the county, as well as Congressman Paul Cook's office, who is very actively involved in our case.

2:01:36 Believe it or not, Congressman Thompson out of Northern California is very interested in this issue because he sees it as a potential way to support the entire craft beer industry, and he's looking at us as a poster child to get that opportunity out to other craft beers in the state. So it's very exciting. Great. Thank you, Joyce. All right. Anybody in the public have any comment? Okay. Seeing none, I'll look for a motion. Mr. Ma'am.

2:02:05 Make a motion to counsel approve the mayor to sign the letter in support of Mammoth Brewing Company. Second. And a second. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, motion passes. And with that, we'll move to a public hearing, which is item number 10. That's the consideration for approval of district zoning amendment 12-002 load start. Sorry? I'm sorry.

2:02:35 Low Star Mammoth Master Amendment. So with that, I'll go ahead and open the public hearing and we'll call on Jen, if you can, when you're ready. Take your time. As you know, the Low Star Master Plan area is your property surrounding the VCRSR golf course. As you can see in these exhibits, we've got some

2:03:25 The intent of the applicant with this amendment is to clean up the master plan. The master plan was adopted in 1991. The development areas identified in that master plan are, for lack of a better word, just conceptual jobs. Since the master plan has been adopted, we've had numerous subdivisions in development since 1991 that now do not conform with those

2:03:55 The intent here is not only to have the master plan match current property boundaries, but also to make the development standards clear for future developers of these properties. No development is proposed with this amendment, and these amendments are generally minor in nature and continue to implement the overall intent of the lodestar master plan, the general plan, and the south district's neighborhood district plan.

2:04:27 The Commission recommended approval unanimously of this amendment on May 8th. There are a few proponents of this application. We have GRM Properties, who owns the majority of the vacant properties in the Lota Master Plan. They are requesting the amendment to clarify the development area boundaries, as I mentioned. That also includes revising the boundaries of development areas 2 and 4.

2:04:57 The general plan allows density to be transferred among development areas in master plans, and this revision doesn't increase the overall density allowed in the master plan. Another amendment being proposed is to set the minimum building separation in development area 2, which is generally on the east side of Minaret Road, to a minimum of 20 feet, down from 25 feet.

2:05:27 This separation was approved for the TALIS development and is consistent with our building separation requirements for the residential multifamily 2 zone and our same snow storage standards would continue to apply. The second part of this amendment request comes from the current property owner for the Solstice Phase 2 site, Mr. John Hooper. We have been working with Mr. Hooper to approve a grading permit currently. You may have seen

2:05:56 They're doing the work to fill the existing hole on the Solstice Space 2 site. The intent there is to subdivide that property for single-family homes. Currently, the Low Star Master Plan doesn't allow for single-family homes in Development Area 5, and so the proposed amendment would allow single-family homes specifically on the Solstice Space 2 site. The commission considered single-family homes...

2:06:21 Allowing single-family homes in the entire development area five and did not recommend that because it could reduce the likelihood of getting a resort hotel in that area. Those single-family homes would be subject to the residential single-family zone setbacks, building height, and lot coverage, so consistent with the majority of single-family homes. We anticipate a tentative track map for that subdivision coming in as soon as the next week.

2:06:53 And then that would have to go through the required public hearing process with the Planning Commission. Planning and Economic Development Commission. Lastly, we have some amendments that have where the town and the commission are proponents of. The first one would be allowing transient rentals as a permitted use in Development Area 1. Currently, transient use is permitted in Development Area 1, which is Lowe Star Drive.

2:07:23 However, a use permit is required. So this revision, as directed by the Planning and Economic Development Commission, would simply eliminate the requirement for the use permit. Single-family homes are allowed in other areas in the resort zones, such as Gina Perridge and Altus, without the requirement of a use permit. And then lastly, at the request of our Public Works Department, an amendment is being proposed to allow the minimum right-of-way for streets.

2:07:53 That are fronted on both sides by golf course to be reduced at the discretion of the public works director. That's to allow snow storage to not be dumped on the areas of the golf course that could cause some undesirable effects. An addendum to the Low Star EIR was prepared to analyze these proposed amendments and found that there would not be any new or increased environmental effects that would result.

2:08:21 And then lastly today we did receive a letter from the San Joaquin Villas regarding how the Low Star Master Plan exhibits identify the access ways through San Joaquin Villas. And the exhibits currently show those paved areas as existing roads. And that actually is not correct. It is currently an emergency vehicle access. So our recommendation would be to ensure that in Council's motion that you include

2:08:51 The correction to make sure that that emergency vehicle access is properly identified. And with that, staff recommends that council choose option one and waive the first reading and introduce by title only an ordinance making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approve district zoning amendment 12002 with conditions as modified to include the correct identification from existing roads to EPA through San Joaquin Villas.

2:09:23 And with that, I know we have Mr. David Hill and James Sedonan here representing GRM. And I did see Mr. John Hooper here as well, and I'm sure they can answer any questions you have, and I'm available for questions too. Thank you. Okay. Thank you, Jen. With that, as part of the public hearing process, I'll go ahead and move and ask if there's any statement by GRM or Mr. Hooper at this time.

2:10:00 Mr. Mayor, Council, Jen, thank you very much. My name is David Hill from GRM Properties. Just a very brief statement. GRM is the current owner of this, not by choice per se, but as a part of the result of economic circumstances in 2009. It's not the primary business of GRM to be real estate developers.

2:10:27 But what you have in front of you is a way that we can clean up the master plan and ultimately prepare it for sale to be perfectly straightforward with you. A series of amendments dating all the way back to 1991 as well as, as Jen said, boundaries of golf courses versus real estate, roads, emergency vehicle access, etc. is all a little bit confusing.

2:10:55 Our desire is to just make sure that it's cleaned up and, as I said, remove any ambiguities on these parcels of land so that if, as and when, there's a new owner, they know exactly what they are getting themselves into. Other than that, I appreciate your time and effort and thank you very much. Okay. Thank you, Ms. Hill. Any other property owners? Mr. Hooper, do you have anything you wanted to add? Yeah, John Hooper, the owner.

2:11:27 It's fairly straightforward. The property has been sitting there for quite a while. Nothing's been done to it. It's essentially what you've already allowed to do at Altus, which is convert condominium-developable property into single-family dwelling. What I propose is eight lots. It would put people to work immediately.

2:11:55 The hole that's been there for years and years is being filled as we speak. And it would, again, essentially put people who work right away because I plan on developing it quickly. My plan is not for larger 4,000 and 5,000 foot, as Dave Harvey called them, trophy homes, but smaller homes, upper end, but smaller homes, 2,000 to 25 feet. But anyway, basically to get it developed pretty quickly here.

2:12:26 Do you have any questions? Okay. With that, yeah, I'll turn to Council and see if there's any questions of either of the property owners. I do have a question of Jen. Of Jen? Okay. And on Exhibit A, when we're talking about the site diagram, there is the name Tana Vista next to that little bump out that's, I guess, 4A. Did that project ever get to an entitlement? Did they get their permit? Yes, sir.

2:12:55 And these changes are consistent with what was approved for Tana Vista? Correct. Nothing was changed. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Any other questions from Council? Any? Okay. With that, I'll go ahead and call for testimony for anybody in the public who has any comments or questions. Okay. We have a member of the public. Mr. Gregory, a member of the public. We found the ski area as the past owner.

2:13:28 of the property that's now held by the bank or the lender as is the vast majority of the transient occupancy large developments in town which are owned by the previous lenders. We're in support of the amendments to the plan and to our friend John Hooper's development proposal and with that support I want to caution or remind

2:13:58 Council and the public that we're at a very dangerous stage in Mammoth for a host of reasons. There's all sorts of things that are major changes being considered. We'll talk about the TBID tonight. Who knows who's right about that? We'll see if I'm right about that or if the people that are against that are right about that. But we're contemplating big change. One of the big changes that could occur without us really understanding the implications

2:14:26 We addressed also back in 1990-91. Town of Mammoth Lakes is four and a half square miles, about 2,200 acres. We've got a growth boundary limit that at least I think that we need to respect and that council has recognized various times. One of the special things about the town of Mammoth Lakes is it's a very small spot of private land and a sea of effectively pristine wilderness for the most part. And I think the more it stays that way, the better.

2:14:54 However, to create a sustainable community, we need to make sure that the development that we're left with allows us to sustain the economies of the future. So we need to be very careful about the land uses and make sure that we end up with enough transient occupancy development opportunities in the future, as well as single-family home development opportunities. And as markets return, there'll be tremendous demand to take the developable land that's remaining and turn it into single-family homes.

2:15:24 That's a great idea in the right areas, in the right proportion. And to quote Sandy Hogan, at least on this issue, we need to be very careful, very thoughtful. And I guess Sandy do a study or two or three. I hate those, but we probably should. This is exactly what we faced back in the early days in 1990-91. Many of you will remember that. It's the whole reason I got stuck in the real estate business, because Tom Revell wanted to develop all of Juniper Ridge.

2:15:54 And a big hunk of the village, what is now the village, into single family homes. Why? Because at the early stage of markets, that's what you can get financed. And it's a very good and easy way to make money. The site that John Hooper is going to develop is a very appropriate place for that, replacing what would have been condominium development. And I think it's a totally appropriate use. But we will face, and this council will face, times where land that is essential

2:16:22 To the transient occupancy revenue base of the town of Mammoth Lakes today and into the foreseeable future to have the wrong pieces of land being proposed for single family housing development. Keep that in mind. Think about, you know, whether you like the architecture of Juniper Ridge and the hundreds of beds and units that are on that spot. Keep in mind what that would be like if we didn't have the transient occupancy for that, if we didn't have the visitation that came from that to drive the rest of our business.

2:16:50 And let's make sure that we're thoughtful about how to do this stuff in the future. As you have been with, I believe, and staff has been with the plans that are before you tonight. Thank you. Thank you, Rusty. Could I ask a question to Jen that goes to that? It's my understanding that within this development area 5, the authorization for the single family homes is only for the solstice piece of the property. It's not for that entire area that's shown as 5 without the dots on exhibit C.

2:17:21 That's correct. The only area or only piece of Area 5 that would allow for single-family space 2 site, which is east of Sierra Star Parkway and south of West Bear Lake Road, and those homes would be allowed to be rented transiently because that's permitted in Area 5. Okay. Thank you. Okay. I'll go ahead and call for any additional testimony if there is any. Okay. Seeing none, I will then ask for any rebuttals, if any, from the property owners.

2:17:55 Okay. Seeing none, I'll go ahead and close the public hearing and turn to Council for deliberation. Jo, do you have anything? No. And actually, Rusty, I specifically asked that question because I agree with you is we don't want to do it wholehearted, whole scale, the switchover. And I think that what was being requested here, and so also to my fellow Councilmembers, is reasonable because it is just that solstice property. And that...

2:18:23 It's not whole scale for that whole area, and I don't think I would be in favor of this if it was for that entire development area. Okay. Other than that, I have no problems with what's been recommended by the Planning and Economic – are they the PEDs now? Planning and Economic Development Commission. Okay. That's a mouthful. John, do you have anything? Anybody else? I'm supportive. Okay. Okay.

2:18:51 I don't have anything, so if somebody wants to, go ahead and give us a motion. And I think staff had suggested incorporating the emergency exit piece in there as well, if that's a motion that's being made. Anybody? Okay, I'll try it. I would move that council approve option one, which is waive the first reading and introduce by title only an ordinance making the required CEQA and municipal code findings and approving district zoning.

2:19:22 Amendment 12-002 with conditions as recommended by the Planning and Economic Development Commission with the modification, and help me with this part, Jen, of changing the exhibits to say it's an EVA through San Joaquin Villas. Correct. Second. I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay.

2:19:54 Motion passes 5-0, and what we're going to do, if everybody doesn't mind, we're going to take a five-minute break, and we'll come back at 7.35. Okay, we're going to go ahead and return here. We're going to move to item number 11, which is the consideration of prohibition of skateboarding on...

2:21:03 Town streets. And with that, I'm going to go ahead and turn it over to Chief Watson. Yes, good evening. Thank you. This is an item that the council visited about 18 months ago in October of 2011. And that was done as a result of an 18-year-old skateboarder who tragically suffered fatal injuries as a result of a crash on a private street where he hit a manhole cover and landed on his head and wasn't wearing a helmet.

2:21:33 At the time, I need to point out, the Vehicle Code does not prohibit riding a skateboard on a public street, but does allow cities to enact ordinances restricting their use. Without an ordinance, someone riding a skateboard on the street is considered a pedestrian and is governed by the same laws that would affect a pedestrian on the street. At that meeting in October of 2011, no specific recommendation was made, and no one spoke in support of the ordinance. There were several speakers.

2:22:02 All boarders who spoke in opposition of developing an ordinance restricting their use. And the council, after hearing that discussion and their own discussion, chose not to take any action. One issue that was not brought forward during that meeting was the potential for town liability as a result of someone being injured or killed as a result of an accident on a skateboard on the street.

2:22:31 A short time after the council discussed that item, a lawsuit was filed from that fatality, and the town and others were named as defendants. Recently, the town's insurance carrier, JPIA, put out an alert advising their clients that having an ordinance restricting the use of skateboards would reduce a town's exposure to liability should someone be injured as a result of a crash.

2:22:54 And the town attorney agrees with JPIA that an ordinance would reduce our exposure to liability. It doesn't guarantee anything, but it would reduce the exposure. As a result of that insurance alert, Councilmember Bacon requested that this item be discussed again, and then I make a recommendation. There are a variety of ordinances throughout the state, ranging from a complete ban on all streets or only on some streets. The agenda bill from October 2011 is attached, and it goes into much more detail.

2:23:23 As to what those options are. The same can apply to sidewalks. Some cities have restricted the use of skateboards on all sidewalks or in only sidewalks in commercial districts but not residential districts. And I recently had a conversation with a resident after hearing about this who suggested the consideration be given towards a restriction on the use of them on bike paths. Since most of the town is hilly,

2:23:49 We have a few sidewalks. My recommendation, if the council wants to go forward with an ordinance, would be that they be restricted on all town streets. Your options directing such an ordinance would be one of those. Citywide or townwide, only on specific streets where it's deemed that it's a problem, you could consider sidewalks or bike paths. Or you can leave it alone.

2:24:18 Take the same action that occurred 18 months ago and not restrict the use of skateboards on streets or sidewalks. And I'll reiterate, if that's the direction, skateboarders are still governed by the California Vehicle Code and treated as pedestrians. So I don't want to make it sound like if we don't do anything, they have complete carte blanche to ride down at any speed on any street in town. They still are obligated, just like a pedestrian, jaywalking applies in any other sections.

2:24:48 Direct an ordinance be drafted. I'll come back with a later date with an agenda bill with that ordinance for consideration. That's my presentation. Okay. Thank you, Chief. With that, I'll go ahead and turn to Council. Joe, you brought it forward. Yes, I did. And I sit as our liaison to the JPIA, which is our insurer. And so when that came to our attention and I realized we did not discuss the liability before,

2:25:15 I thought we should discuss it, especially since we don't tend to do very well in lawsuits. I think we needed to look at the issue and decide whether or not we should go forward with an ordinance that restricts it and also then diminishes our liability. So it's just for discussion. Any other council members have thoughts on this?

2:25:42 My only concern is taking it away is, you know, we don't have our trails and bike, you know, pass connected. Where are people going to go? Where are they going to ride? There's so many areas that are, you know, there's no way for them to take their skateboards. And I mean, I agree, it's probably not the safest thing, but even in some of the designated bike lanes may be an option or an idea just so we can get our, you know,

2:26:13 Transit Connectivity done. That's kind of my thought. What's that? What was your thought until they're done? Prohibited? No. At the least, let them ride in maybe the designated bike lanes areas right now so they can still get around without totally taking away the building at all. Okay. John, I know you had some thoughts on this last time. Yeah, I have thoughts, but I wanted to hear from the public first as well. Okay.

2:26:43 I'll go ahead and turn to the public then, and then bring it back to council, so. You look like a skateboarder. You know, it's interesting because I was here actually as part of that discussion previously, and there was a person that was sitting at that table who was very eloquent and emotional in regards to having skateboarding and the privileges they had within the community. I have a personal...

2:27:14 Philosophy. I believe that everybody I meet, there's a little chance I share with them. So I take a little piece of them with me and I give a little bit of me to them. And I think Skip was very adamant in regards that this should not be changed. And I think I respect for Skip and what's happened and what was in the past. I don't skateboard. I mean, people see me in town and this is about as good as I can do. But it's not me, but I also feel that

2:27:42 That was probably the best town council meeting I've ever been to. But it was also spoken from the heart from all the individuals that showed up. And I just think that a change of regulation is not needed at this point in time. We're all subject to lawsuits. Every day we can't turn around without having a different lawsuit that comes before us. And my recommendation as a citizen of this town is that you don't change the laws. Yes, do I see people going down through the street doing certain things? Yeah, I see people crossing the street, everywhere left and right, bikes, people doing all sorts of different things in the streets.

2:28:10 Is skateboarding part of our community? I think it is. I think it should stay the way it is. I thank you for your time. Okay. Thank you, Brent. Anybody else in the public? Colin Fernie. I'll just speak as a member of the public on this one, but I would agree with Brent that I think, you know, when we talk about our master plan, one of the big focuses that we're moving towards is feet first, pedestrian, alternate transit, and I think skateboarding fits perfectly into that.

2:28:42 I can't even stand on a skateboard, but this to me would be like regulating people biking in town. It's a mode of transit that a lot of people utilize here. This is a great area for skateboarding with the Vulcan Brothers Skate Park, and I think the more things we can do to position this community as something that's attractive to people of all different types of exercise, including skateboarding is a positive thing. I think it's unfortunate that we live...

2:29:10 In the culture we do where people sue for everything, I think people need to take some responsibility for their own actions, especially when they're doing dangerous sports like skateboarding or biking or skiing or anything like that. And I think that's unfortunate and maybe that's something you guys have to look at is how you can restrict yourself, or excuse me, restrict it to the point that it helps you from a legal standpoint. But I think the idea of outlawing it in town would be really upsetting to a lot of people and I just, as a member of the community, I think.

2:29:39 It's a great alternate transit mode that we have right now that I think would be a problem if we took it away. Okay, thanks. Thank you, Colin. Hi, Juliana Olenka. I'm speaking as not only as a citizen of Mammoth Lake, but as a mother of a son who rides a skateboard, because I obviously don't. It is a mode of transportation, and I can recall a couple of times when my son called me and said, oh, this stupid car broke down. I have to get to class. I'm going to have to skateboard.

2:30:09 And I agree with Colin, restricting skateboarding is like restricting bicycles, just because they have four wheels on a short track as opposed to two wheels on another kind of mechanism doesn't necessarily mean it should be restricted. Eliminated, potentially, maybe there can be bike paths, they can be restricted to bike paths, but it is a mode of transportation and I think people should have the right to do it. Okay, thank you. Anybody else?

2:30:38 Mayor, Councilmembers, I'm Dena Campbell, and I'm representing the Kern Community College District at Cerro Coso Community College, and I wasn't prepared to speak on this topic tonight on another topic later this evening, but I do observe that many of our students do not have vehicles, and they come to this town to go to school and go to work, and they don't have other modes of transportation. They do use the bus transit system, which is greatly appreciated.

2:31:04 But on gorgeous days like today and throughout the summer and the fall, they do use skateboards to get around town to get to class and to work. And with bicycles, they have a hard time

2:31:17 Storing the bicycles. For example, class, there's limited space for bicycles to be stored. They're concerned about things being stolen. And so a skateboard is a really economical, efficient, and easy way for our students to get around. And that is from my own perspective and observations on campus. Thank you. Thank you, Dana. I'd just like to add, to clarify that the discussion is not to prohibit the use of skateboards in total. It's just to use, to restrict them on city streets.

2:31:48 Okay. Because I'm not sure that's clear with everybody. Great. Okay. Thank you, Chief. Good evening again. Martin Kleinbart. I don't think that we should restrict the skateboards from the city streets. I do have a question for the Chief. Is there any way to somehow institute something as far as speed? Because that's the only objection that I could even think of in my book is speeding it much greater.

2:32:16 Faster rate of speed down like Main Street from... I've never heard of radar being used on a skateboarder, but I guess it could be. But you'd have to have a special ordinance to do that. The reality is right now they can go as fast as they want to as a pedestrian. I mean, if you could run that fast, you wouldn't be restricted from doing it. It would require a special ordinance establishing speed limits. I don't know if that's been done anywhere, but I don't know any reason why it couldn't be done.

2:32:45 Thank you. That's the only good question. Thank you, Martin. Good evening, Council. Steve Spinell, Citizen. I have a question for the Chief in your staff report. Did you mention that it was a public or a private street where the accident happened? Where the accident occurred was on a private road. Thank you. And did you mention that the skater hit a manhole cover? That's my understanding, yes. And that caused him to fall. Okay, so.

2:33:20 There might be something with the way that that was constructed or maintained that led to the injury more than... I imagine that's probably what the court in the lawsuit has or will be looking at. And again, a private street, not a public street of the Town of Mammoth Lakes. That's correct. Thank you. Thank you, Steve. I'm assuming that your point was that that would be the case whether there's an ordinance or not. So, I was just...

2:33:52 I think what I was trying to do is just kind of clarify a situation where it was not a town of Mammoth Lakes public street or infrastructure that may have been the problem. So therefore, I don't know that the nexus is there for the town of Mammoth Lakes to create an ordinance to restrict it. And it sounds like more of a physical aspect of the disc or the rim more than the activity itself.

2:34:22 Got it. Okay. Thank you, Steve. Anybody else in the public? Okay. I'll bring it back to council. John. Thank you, sir. It's not often that council members have an issue that they feel strongly about or passionate about. For me, this is one of those issues. Skateboards are not only a form of transportation.

2:34:51 Skateboards are also a form of recreation, they're a form of exercise, and they are a form of release of stress, personal stress. Personally, I want to encourage the use of skateboards because I believe that skateboarding in the community of Mammoth Lakes also creates a sense of vitality and animation in our community.

2:35:21 To me, skateboarding is a good thing. Unfortunately, as was mentioned earlier tonight, we live in a litigious society. I am opposed to the extreme consequences of living in such a litigious society. The fear of being sued restricts the freedom and the ability of humans to act naturally.

2:35:53 May or may not have an effect on someone who wants to sue Mr. Deep Pockets, i.e. the town. The town of Mammoth Lakes has a great skateboard park. We have a great trail system. The eastern Sierra itself is a recreational mecca. I will not support this proposed restriction on the use of skateboards. Okay. Thank you, John. Michael Jospo, Mayor Pro Tem, Wood.

2:36:23 Mr. Marys, you know, I don't do personal injury work or lawful work, so I don't have conflict of interest. My view hasn't changed from six months ago. Okay. My view hasn't changed either, but I do want to say that I live on a corner on Minaret Road, and I watch a lot of people, you know, going up and down Minaret onto Main Street.

2:36:50 The only thing I would say is any of the skateboarders that are out there listening, you guys just watch where you're going because I've seen them cut in front of some pretty fast moving cars and literally cut cars off and almost get run over and it's, they're not always as cautious as they probably should be. So with that, I too would support it. So I'll entertain a motion. Mr. Mayor, I'd like to make a motion. Council approves option six to take no action.

2:37:16 Okay, I have a motion. I'll second the motion and a little bit of discussion. Okay. There is a saying for what you were talking about, and that saying is you can't legislate stupidity. And there is stupidity in every segment of society, but that doesn't necessarily mean you have to legislate a corrected action for it. Thank you. Well, today it'll be a skateboard, tomorrow it's a bike, then it's a walking. So, all right, we have a motion and a second.

2:37:45 Roll call, please, Jamie. Councilmember Bacon? No. Councilmembers? Yes. Councilmember Lamont? Yes. Mayor Pro Templey? Yes. Mayor Pro Templey? Yes. Mayor Pro Templey? Yes. Okay, motion passes, 4-1. And with that, I will go ahead and move on to item number 12, which is a consideration of a code compliance task force. And Sandra, when you're ready. Thank you, Mayor, members of the council.

2:38:14 At the May 15th Town Council meeting, several members of the Planning and Economic Development Commission provided comments regarding the need for code enforcement within town. As you know, we haven't had a code enforcement officer in town since 2008. And since that time, we've been responding to high-priority items like life safety, nuisance, trash-related items, as well as the TOT compliance.

2:38:41 Staff, in response to the comments at the May 15th meeting, staff prepared this item with a suggestion that the town council consider forming a code compliance task force, a group of people to review code compliance issues in town and provide a recommendation to council on how to move forward with code compliance in town. Staff's suggestion follows on the success of the TOT committee, which was a group of people dedicated to TOT compliance

2:39:09 Provided a lot of insight, recommendations, and helped staff move forward with the TOT Revenue Collection and Enforcement Program, which has been very successful. So on page two of your item, we outlined the code compliance task force, and we suggested a variety of people who are interested in this topic. We suggested up to two town staff members to support it.

2:39:36 One or two planning and economic development commissioners, a town council member, a representative from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, and a member, a business owner, a member of the public. Our recommendation would be that this group meets for a limited amount of time with a goal of identifying priority issues and making recommendations. After that, the council can move forward with any of the recommendations or items that are suggested.

2:40:00 And this task force will be primarily staffed by the assistant building official, Johnny Gates, who also has other priorities, including building inspections for the town. He's our sole inspector. He completes all of our building inspections. He's doing solid waste and recycling activities right now, and he's supervising the building division activities. So with these current priorities, the fact that we're right in the peak building permit time, staff would recommend that we form this task force and start work on it.

2:40:29 In September when the building inspections have slowed down a little bit and Johnny has a little bit more time to dedicate to this program. So with that, staff recommends that council consider option one to direct staff to assemble a code compliance task force in September of this year for the purpose of making recommendations to the town council on priority code enforcement items and funding for the program and appointing one member of the town council to that task force. Okay.

2:40:58 Thank you, Sandra. Thank you. I'll turn to Council. John, do you have any questions? Michael? Joe? Joe? I have no questions either. Okay. I'll turn to... Other than, is anyone going to volunteer? We'll all turn to the public then and see if anybody has any comments from the public.

2:41:40 Elizabeth Tenney, Member of Mammoth Lakes Planning and Economic Development Commission. I've heard two things in the last couple months that have had a profound impact on me, and I think I mentioned one of them when we talked about this issue, the Board of Planning Commissioners who were here who came forward about how important this is, and that was that our visitors have the highest capita income of any ski resort in North America, but they're staying two days. And then the other one was what Rusty said,

2:42:08 I believe at the last meeting about the data collection they're doing at the mountain, they're finding that they're getting more people, but less often, and they're not coming back. So what we have to sell is the experience. We've got this fantastic mountain, and what we have to sell in the town that goes with it, where people stay and dine and shop, we're just not cutting it with our peer resort competition, and that's why the four commissioners, and of course I can't speak,

2:42:36 For the commission, but I know the other commissioner based on our discussions in planning commission meetings absolutely agrees. We really need to enforce this code. What we have now is a very cumbersome enforcement, you know, past practice, back when it was being enforced, a very cumbersome, lengthy time sink of labor to enforce, and we need something that's simple, straightforward,

2:43:02 As Commissioner Harvey pointed out at the meeting on May 15th, is that, you know, as soon as people are made aware of what the code is, generally, I mean, the large majority comply with no problem. We just have a few offenders who are resistant to doing that. But we think that the fines should be punitive and we think the process should be much shorter. And we were actually pretty shocked when Colin Fernie and I met with our tourism director, John Urdi,

2:43:31 And our Chamber of Commerce President, Jack Copeland, a week ago, and we said, well, what we're thinking is we need to be much more direct about this. You do the notification, and then, you know, if you don't comply in 14 days, then the fines start. And John Urdi said 14 days. With school starting in the middle of August now, this is, you know, really a big change. It's been evolving. We have like a six-week summer, and 14 days is a third of that. He said you should make it seven. So we really got to get serious about this.

2:44:01 Because we're not providing the experience that we should be. Four people have already volunteered to help with this. There are community development block grants to the International Code Council. There's money available. I would strongly urge you to tell staff that this is so important that the planning for this, even though we can't maybe implement it because of limited staff, because of the busy summer season, but can we form the task force

2:44:28 And start thinking about it. You know, brainstorming. How can we best do this? You know, where will the money come from? How can we best organize it? How can the volunteers be most effectively used? How can we make the process simple and direct? And a lot of that includes a lot of, you know, information in the media so people realize what we're doing. And I just can't urge you strongly enough to support this. Thank you very much. Thank you, Elizabeth. Are there any other members of the public?

2:45:04 Two of three tonight. So I'll keep it really brief. I just want to say that I would echo a lot of the sentiments that Elizabeth just spoke about. I think most people are here to speak about the T-Bid. Obviously, that's one component of the destination experience, marketing to them, getting them here. I think the other major component to that is making sure that they have a great experience while they're here. And I think the clutter that our town is experiencing right now detracts from that. So I do think it's a priority for our town right now.

2:45:34 And I would personally be happy. I'm enjoying temporary retirement right now until November. So I would be happy to volunteer my time. And I think the TOT compliance task force had a lot of success. So I really like that idea of putting community stakeholders together. I've spent a lot more hours than I could have anticipated diving into this issue. And it is complicated. So I think the idea to have a task force to really kind of

2:46:01 Figure out exactly how we want to implement this. It would be a really nice idea, and I'd be happy to volunteer my time. But, you know, I do think it's important to clean up the look of our town right now. Thanks. Great. Thank you, Colin. Any other members of the public want to speak to this item? Good evening, Town Council again. Martin Kleinbard, resident. My biggest concern on this is not the issue of code compliance. I don't think that anyone really would disagree with that. With our budget deficit, I'm really concerned about...

2:46:34 Where this money is going to be coming from to fund this position? You know, I've been concerned over the years that we haven't had anybody in that position. So, I mean, that's like just major number one, you know, concern. And I don't know if I possibly may could have some time if that would be something to entertain the council on their discretion. Thank you. Thank you, Martin. Appreciate that.

2:47:04 Are there any members in the public who want to speak to this? Okay. Seeing none, I'll bring it back to council again and see if there's any additional comments. Okay. Seeing none, the only thing I'd add, like Martin, my only concern with it, I think it's very important, I might like to move forward with it. My only concern is staff time. I have had a conversation with a staff member, too, about how we could go about it.

2:47:35 I really just want to ask staff if they think there's a way, looking at this structure, if there's a way that we're going to, staff will have the time to deal with that or not. And I think Mayor Pro Tem Wood mentioned it earlier this evening, it's easy for us to come up with an idea and just pile it onto the plate of staff. So I want to be very cognizant of that right now. I know we have a recommendation from you, but I just want to make sure that it's something that's

2:48:05 So what Salk has recommended is that we believe in September we may have time to support this task force, but not right now. Is it possible that we get to September and the reality is going to be different? It is. What we can do is return to you at the end of August and let you know if we're still committed to this. Okay.

2:48:32 And actually, I would support staff in that, and that's one of the hard decisions we have to make, is we can't keep cutting the staff and then expecting them to do everything immediately. Yes, it's a priority, but on the other hand, it's going to take the specific people that are identified, and if our assistant building official is not out there doing the work that needs to be done in our construction season, I think we're going to get more feedback on that. So I'm fine with the September date as the...

2:49:02 Time that it would be convened at the end of the busy season. Johnny probably works more hours than he ever puts down on his timesheet as it is, but we don't necessarily want to say, now that's 500 hours a week. Yes, Johnny. I think we have a golden opportunity in the sense that the Town Council and the Planning Commission workshop on Wednesday of next week, so we're a week away from that. I'm hopeful at that meeting that the Planning Commission

2:49:34 Can share with the Council and the Council can share with the Planning Commission what the priorities of each group is. Agendize this subject matter for that meeting so that the Commission and the Council can have a discussion as to where this fits into priorities of the two bodies. Okay. And then bring it back to Council at a later time? Yeah. Okay. I don't know that we need to make a quote-unquote decision tonight. No. We can make a decision a week from that. Okay.

2:50:03 Just one question in what you're saying, John, as I know that there's been a little bit of discussion about setting the priorities, but we haven't given that direction to the Planning Commission yet, and I don't know, can it be added to their meeting? Are you still having a meeting next Wednesday before we meet? No, that meeting... Okay, so the Commission won't have had a chance for their side of the discussion of if we said, okay, what are your five priorities? But I think...

2:50:32 We could discuss it a little bit. I think the reality is that it wouldn't be back to us on the 19th because there wouldn't have been a Planning Commission meeting. I don't know what the date is. I just want to take advantage of our joint meeting next week and see what will come up. Okay, well, Mayor Pro Tem, would you have a moment? Actually, in light of the fact that the staff has suggested that this be initiated in September anyway, that you've got a great suggestion, add it to next week's agenda and then bring it back on the 19th or even the 2nd of July.

2:51:05 Or the third. Okay. All right. Well, then, I guess, Jo, are you okay with that? Yeah. Yeah. Okay. We have direction then. I don't think we need to vote on this. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. With that, we'll go ahead and move on to item number 13, which is a consideration of accepting College Parkway and Wagon Wheel Road extension into the town maintained road system. Hey, Erleman, Councilmembers. College Parkway and south extension of Wagon Wheel

2:51:38 serve Syracosa College, the foundation, long term it will also serve faculty housing, it also serves recreational uses in some of the events that occur in town. The town has been working cooperatively with the gateway area with planning with the college and the school districts over the last many years.

2:52:04 Town Council, and there's a correction to make on your staff, on my staff report, in December 17, 2008, not this year, 2008, did authorize Public Works to begin plowing the road, and so we've been doing that since that time. It really has a minimal impact on the overall services, first of all, because of the proximity of the location with the town yard, and so as we go back and forth to fill up for fuel or shift change,

2:52:33 They can hit that road and give it a level of service as a collector street. And we've been maintaining that as a collector. We have staff has reviewed the condition of the existing roads. It's really poor to fare and does need substantial work to bring it up to a good condition. The college district has indicated that they

2:53:00 Would improve the street either with reconstructing and overlay to bring it up to a good condition. If it was brought up to a good condition, there'd be very little maintenance, probably for, you know, 10 to 15 years, the pavement would be in good condition. But at that time, it would need another rehab overlay, which would cost, as you see in your staff report, about $120,000 or so.

2:53:30 There are several options to consider with the acceptance of the road. You can either – you can just continue to have Public Works continue to plow the road currently, basically a status quo. Direct staff to work with Kern County College District to develop a maintenance agreement where they would contribute maybe to the heavy maintenance of the street when needed and prepare a –

2:53:59 Every vocal operator dedication for that street network. This would obligate the town to, in the long term, we'd own the street, we'd be responsible for the maintenance of the street. We could also work with the college district to accept the road and not have a maintenance agreement for the major capital that would, or maintenance expenses that would long term be needed. Or,

2:54:29 Basically revert to previous 2008 where we were knowing no maintenance on that street network. Dina Campbell is here tonight to speak also I believe regarding this item and staff would recommend either options one or two which one is status quo and two is some type of maintenance agreement where they're still contributing for the long term heavy maintenance expenses. Okay. Thank you, Peter.

2:54:58 Any council members have a question up here? Yes, just a quick clarification. When you said the heavy maintenance, that's the repairing and overlay that has to be done about every 10 or 15 years, and at this point is estimated at 120,000. So within this, one of the recommendations is to enter into a maintenance agreement. Are they the only property owner along that road?

2:55:27 There are two property owners. One's the foundation. Okay. And the other's the college district. And I think actually the school district may have another small piece. Okay. So would this end up being another improvement district or whatever we're calling them? Well, assessment districts really don't fit well with public agencies. Oh, okay. And so it would really be some type of a main decision. Okay.

2:55:53 But would it be possible that the agreement would be with all the agencies so they would share in the cost? It would be possible. That's an option for us to consider? Okay. That's an option. Well, no, that just says with Kern County. That's just with the college district. The college district, they currently own that road. So the title is transferred to the college district with the construction of the college. Okay, but in the long run,

2:56:18 The foundation and the school district have parcels there and would be making use of the road as well? Correct. Or do make use? Or currently make use. Any other council members have questions? Anybody in the public have any comments or questions on this item? Mayor Layman, council members, thank you for consideration of this topic. I am Dena Campbell, representative of the current community college district, and it is our perspective that...

2:56:49 The road really is a public-use road. It does serve properties for the Kern Community College District and provides access also to Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

2:56:59 There also is now with the new bike path which we're very excited about there is public parking which I believe the town has easement for for public parking for access of the town trail system as well and there's also a bus stop there and the bus system does go along College Parkway and Wagon Wheel Road on a daily basis and so it is our perspective that

2:57:26 Again, as Joe Bacon mentioned, there are multiple property owners along this road, and while we don't know what the future will bring, there's been many discussions about issuing parcels to other agencies going forward for other use. But the current use, we believe, is public use. Both the foundation, and I will let my colleague and friend, Juliana Olinka, who represents the Mammoth Lakes Foundation, speak more about their use of the facilities that they have.

2:57:54 But the college does serve students, our students obviously, but we also frequently and continuously donate our facilities for the use of the public. We often host free of charge number of events. For example, this summer there will be three weeks of music programs, music camps going on there. We do not charge for the facilities for that use and brings in 60 to 70 students along with

2:58:22 Faculty from across the country and across the world for these events. We also provide free facilities for the school district and for the county office of education as well as the health department for a number of events that they put on. So we do really believe that the use is a public use for this roadway and would really request that you consider option three which is

2:58:50 A dedication of the road and acceptance of the road. Okay. Thank you very much. Thank you, Dina. Mayor, Town Council, staff. I'm Juliana Olenka with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and I also want to reinforce the public use of the road. Yes, the Mammoth Lakes Foundation is on the property. We also have the Edison Theater where many people throughout the town, we promote to them both

2:59:22 Residents and out-of-town visitors to come to our facility to see our productions. They have to drive on the road to get there. We do have the new bike path, as Dina mentioned. We've also made the Mammoth Lakes Foundation building available to the town for meetings. We've actually had Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition meetings there. We're having the Measure Your Task Force meeting there. And we do provide space to other entities throughout the community.

2:59:51 As the dean has said, it is also on the Eastern Sierra Transit route. It's a regular route through, and we would urge you to take option three as well. Okay, thank you. Anyone else in the public have any comment on this? Okay, I'll bring it back to council and see if anybody has any comments. Peter, just a quick question. Did the town put in the road? Who put the road in? The college district and the foundation built a road at various times. Thanks.

3:00:22 Still private road. Anybody have any questions? The only comment I have, I just, again, we're coming back to another expense, and I see the benefits, certainly, and certainly willing to be helpful on it where we can. I just think that we have to make sure that all of our costs are covered in every way, because we're just looking at every nickel right now.

3:00:51 I think to accept it as a dedication and just take care of it from now on, it's going to be a little challenging for me to accept. But I'd be open to looking at this on a maintenance, perhaps even for a period of time, knowing that there's funding coming in adequate enough to cover everything. Yes? Sorry. I neglected to mention to you also that this summer the Mammoth Food and Wine Experience

3:01:20 The Mammoth Jazz Jubilee, the Sierra Summer Festival, and the Felici Trio's three weeks' worth of programming all will be taking advantage of a tent that we collectively are working and sharing that was part of some Measure U activities, so you may be familiar with it. And that means all of those activities and all of those people coming through there will also be using that as a public road. So it's not just those entities. Thank you.

3:01:49 Anybody else have any comments? Just tag on to what you said. We were all here at the 5 o'clock session, in which I did my little rant or speech or whatever it was, and Matthew, I'm with you. We're going to be making some very tough decisions, and we're going to be saying no a lot, I think. And we'd like to do everything, but we can't.

3:02:18 And so this is one of the things that I think that we can't do. I'm supportive of option one. Or two, sorry. Well, I think, too, what we're saying is for all to pitch in, right? Yeah. Yeah, that was essentially what I was suggesting. We're not saying that we're not going to do our share. Right. Yeah. That's what I'm supportive of. I'm supportive of option two as well.

3:02:42 Option two with it being that it would be with all the entities or significant entities in some way? I would say all. Not staff. I would say all. That's good echo here. Echo, yeah. Mr. Mayor, I have a question to staff. Is it possible to limit the term of the agreement for a set period of time, whether it's 10 or 15 years or some number of years in between? In other words, we know that if an overlay work is done now,

3:03:11 Once we accept the street, we're never getting rid of it. I mean, they're not going to take it back if we accept it. I mean, maintenance agreement, I think. Right. We could do a maintenance agreement with a limited duration where we don't own the street.

3:03:40 They own the street. We agree to maintain it. They agree to pay us. Yeah. Yeah. Sure. And we would still do the snow removal as we have in the past, and that would be part of the agreement. We could do that. I'm thinking of something like that. Okay. We can't commit past the life of the expected life of the payment. Right.

3:04:05 Okay. I was looking at, and I think this may have been what Matthew also said, is that whatever the agreement has reached, and I think we're all saying it might be a larger group, and it might be some kind of shared responsibility for it, but I'm afraid to go into something that ends right when the overlay needs to be done. I think that the agreement has to put in how you have the funds ready to do that overlay at the end of the period. I guess the question is, though, should the town be paying for that?

3:04:34 Well, that's part of having staff come back to us with some ideas and options, which I think is what's part of number two. Yeah, that's my understanding. To work with the, and in this case, it would be all the entities to develop a maintenance agreement and see where those negotiations go. Right. But, yeah, we can't wait until 15 years and then go, golly gee, where are we going to find 120,000, which might be 100 and...

3:05:00 75 by then, who knows? Well, I think that's kind of my point, though. I don't want us to get stuck with that either. Correct. I think that as part of the maintenance agreement, whatever, anything that's done out there should be paid for by the share cost. Yeah, well, already so. Yeah. You got a motion? Yeah. I move that we approve option two with a slight modification to say direct staff to work with

3:05:27 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

3:05:57 That's what I meant. I'll second the motion for discussion. Okay, I have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Okay, motion passes 5-0. We'll go ahead and move on to item number 14, and that is the scheduled interviews for the Medicaid application committee and applicants. So, Jamie?

3:06:30 Whoa. Oh, that's outside. Floor. Yeah. Did we lose power? So, basically, what Jamie was saying is we've got to schedule interviews for the Measure U application. I believe we have three applications. And option one is to schedule for June 9th at 4 o'clock before a regularly scheduled council meeting. I'm okay with that. 19th? 19th? Yeah.

3:07:22 Okay. I'm okay with that. All right. I think we're good with that. We don't need a vote. Okay. We'll go ahead and move on to item number 15, which is I think what everybody's been waiting for, so you all can wake up out there. We're ready to go here. It's basically, this is a public comment period regarding the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District. And just wanted to keep everybody in mind that we're not voting on it tonight.

3:07:54 This is just a public comment period so people can come up and express their thoughts on where they stand with the TBID and TBID process. And it would be really helpful if, because we have a lot of people in here tonight, if when you come up, if somebody has already said what you're thinking, if you could just say I agree with that and we don't need to hear another two minutes of the same thing, that would be great. And with that, I'm going to...

3:08:23 Go ahead and turn it over to John, see if you have any introductions. Thank you, Mr. Mayor, John Urdi, May, Place Tourism. I just wanted to touch on a couple of things. There have been some miscommunications out there, misinterpretations out there. And one of them, there was a letter that was mailed recently. Some people received it as recently as today. That was really a misinterpretation of the TBID law, the 1994 law. It was read that...

3:08:58 It was understood by some that a business that controls more than 40% of the vote would be excluded. What it is, anything above the 40% is excluded. So the mailing that went out that talked about that being that Mammoth Mountain in this case would not be able to vote was erroneous. I just wanted to square that away. There's also still some confusion out there as to how this works. It's not out of the...

3:09:24 Gross profits of the business. It is an add-on. It is a pass-through to the customer. So it's not the business writing a check out of their bottom line. It's something that gets added to the check. In a restaurant case, it's a 1.5% that gets added to the check. Again, if it's a $20 tab, it's 30 cents. It gets added on. There's been some questions about the weighted vote. And one of the things to keep in mind is that since our country began, assessments have been weighted vote. That's the fair way to do this. So they have always been weighted vote.

3:09:54 And that's important to note. And there's some question of the equity of how this works. And really, we are following the letter of the law. The law permits us to have one partner that can carry up to 40% of the weight. One of the things that I did do just to go back and see what would happen is if I took out Mammoth Mountain completely, if I took out all of their gross revenues, and I took out all of their 40% and would still be over 50% with the remaining businesses that did petition for this.

3:10:23 So I think that's something that's very important to note. There have been some questions raised about helping fund the settlement. And, you know, again, we've talked about this, that taking money out of tourism and to directly pay the settlement makes no sense. We need to make money to pay the settlement. We need to bring people to town, and we need to be able to raise those funds. As I've mentioned before, basically every million dollars in TOT that comes in, the general fund receives $650,000 of that. Lastly, there's some question over the numbers of businesses.

3:10:53 And I think it's interesting, there's been, there are a few letters in the back that talk about the fact that only 11% of the businesses eligible to petition as far as a number of businesses petitioned. I think it's interesting, there's 798 businesses on the percentage petition. 625 of those contribute less than one half of one percent. So 78% of the businesses that are on that entire list contribute less than one half of one percent. So that's a big number. About what?

3:11:23 I'm sorry? Of the entire total revenue. So there are 798 businesses in that percentage. 625 of them don't even come in at a half of 1%. Thank you. So that's 78%. And of that, that leaves 173 businesses that contribute the remainder. And we had 71 petition in favor. It's 41% of the business. It's not the 11% as stated. We also have numerous national chains and absentee owners that just never responded.

3:11:53 Another piece that I wanted to note was just of the top 68 revenue generators in town. So if you look at the top 68 businesses in town, those 68 businesses contribute 81% of all revenue. Of those 68 businesses, 43 petitioned in favor of the TBID. That's 65% of that total. John, can you say those again? I'm sorry to interrupt you. So I just looked at the top 68 businesses. And of those 68 businesses, it's the 80-20 rule, those 68 businesses,

3:12:24 Produce 81% of the revenue, the direct revenue in town. Of those 43 businesses, excuse me, of the 68, 43 petitioned for the T-Bid. Of the remaining 25, 11 of them are national chains. There's no way I would even find the person at Coach or Shiloh Inn or Carl's Jr. to even talk to by the time we were going through this process just because it's a corporation that I'd have to go and try and track down the right people.

3:12:56 So we've got 11 of those national chains. So really 21 out of the 25 remaining never responded. Four did respond saying that they were against it. Now I think there are more in the letters that we see now, but as of the petition, there were 21 out of 25 that didn't respond. Again, we've talked about the successes in Napa. I just spoke with the director of the DMO down in Santa Barbara, and she's going to get me her numbers to compare as well. I don't think she's as strong as the 38% growth that Napa Valley saw in the first three years.

3:13:27 But they're recording some very strong numbers at Santa Barbara as well. And the biggest thing that I would ask people to do is do the research. I think there are a lot of things that are still misunderstood. One of the letters in here talks about the fact that $2 million is going to the air subsidy and there's only $500,000 left. It's not the case. The total T-bit is $4.7 million. So I think it's trying to educate people as much as possible.

3:13:54 I've said it before, I'll say it again, my door is open, my phone is available anytime, and I'm more than happy to meet with anyone to explain the program, explain the reasons behind it, explain how it affects their business, explain that it's not something that comes out of their gross profits, and really www.mltbid.com has all of the data, it has all of the current schedules, it even lists all the businesses that have positively petitioned for this.

3:14:20 John, quickly can you clarify how a portion of that money is spent? You mentioned air service. Is it true that the MLT will pay for air service for spring, summer, and fall, and the mountain still pays the air subsidy in the winter, or can you explain that? Sure. The summer air subsidy will be coming out of the T-Bid. When you say summer. Summer, spring, summer, fall. Summer and fall. Yes, the current season that we're in right now with the one flight from Los Angeles.

3:14:49 That's usually anywhere from $500,000 to $800,000 over the last few years. I still will go back to the county, looking for at least $100,000 out of the county because of the benefits that come to the rest of Mono County as well. So in the wintertime, the subsidy, we would be responsible for the first $1.5 million of subsidy for the winter. And then anything above and beyond that will be picked up by the mountain. The mountain is also still handling the line of credit for both airlines, which is sizable.

3:15:18 As well as the liability insurance, which is also sizable. What has the number been for winter subsidy? You said we pick up the first 1.5. What's the number after that? You know, I'd have to defer to Howard on it, but I believe last winter, the four winter we had was over $3 million. It was? Yeah. So if last winter it would have been $5 million.

3:15:41 So it was 3.2 the winter before. It was 2.2 this past winter. And we are looking, you know, this winter, and I'm not sure I can talk about new routes. Okay. So we are talking about it. We are adding three days a week to Las Vegas with Alaska Airlines. One of our Los Angeles flights will fly Monday, Wednesday, and Saturday. We'll fly to Las Vegas for us. And then we're also working with United Airlines on Denver. So these flights do have a lot of risk.

3:16:11 So again, our risk at this point with the TBID is $1.5 million. If we decide that we're going to go after Seattle or Phoenix or Salt Lake City or Chicago or any other market, then all of a sudden anything above the $1.5 million is still something that the mountain would pick up. How long period is that $1.5 locked in? At this point, it's a five-year life of the TBID. Thank you. So if we want to keep expanding, it's actually, I think it's giving us the opportunity to continue to expand the markets.

3:16:42 Las Vegas is confirmed? Las Vegas is confirmed. It'll be in the system soon. And then Denver, I think we're looking at the end of the month to get into the systems as well. Oh, Denver's in the month. Okay. And then to answer your question too, so out of the 4.7 million, 2.5 of that is for marketing. And again, on the management district plan, which is available at MLTBID.com, it does break out a rough idea of $300,000 going into PR, $150,000 going into training.

3:17:10 Excuse me, $150,000 into research, $50,000 into training our local staff. There is an agency we are working with, Marion Carson, who does all of this at California's work, and we started a process with them on the research side this week. Currently there's a lot of second guessing going on as far as the effectiveness of marketing. That's been since day one of time.

3:17:36 When could we expect after what period of time? After six months? After a year? After two years? When could we expect to get a sense for the effectiveness of the marketing we're doing?

3:17:45 Sure. I think because of the timing, realistically, we're looking at the earliest probably 12 months. Realistically, it's 18 months. But there are some things that we'll do immediately that will be trackable and that will be well seen in town. We've talked about some of the programs to get our visitors that come into town to go out and explore as many restaurants retail as they possibly can when they are here. And so we're actually going to have a...

3:18:09 A card program in place by July 1 to get people, when they check in, they'll receive this card, they'll have an app on their phone that they can see what all the different deals are at the different restaurants and retail, and specifically restaurant and retail. Okay. Any other questions for John? I've got some questions. Yeah. John, can you, can you, is my understanding correct that this is the first TBID as proposed that includes retail businesses? Correct.

3:18:41 I'd like to hear from your counsel on that issue at an appropriate time. That is, how sound it is legally for us to include retail in the mix, in the formula. Second question is, in your discussion with people in particular in restaurants and retail, are you hearing from people that the

3:19:10 TBID might be acceptable if the rate for those were lowered or if a different formula were to apply, for example, excluding the first $100,000 of gross sales from taxation. I don't know if that's even feasible, but I'm wondering, I know that you're having a lot of conversation. We all are. And what I'm wondering is what you're hearing from people about the rate itself.

3:19:41 I think there's, in general, there's just an overall reluctance. Restaurants and retail have not participated in the funding of tourism in the past. It's been TOT. The lodging properties have funded that. So I think that it is something that's a change for both restaurants and retail. Yes, it's groundbreaking for retail. There are a couple of tourism, or there are a few restaurant BIDs that are out there. I think there are three or four in the state of California.

3:20:07 But it's something where when we look at the town of Mammoth Lakes and we look at the amount of people that are truly our visitors that are coming here, every business is affected. So it is something that I think because it's new, the percentage, if it were a half a percent, I'm sure we'd still have people saying that it's either too much or it's something that they wouldn't support. So I don't know that this was not a ploy to say we're going to go at one and a half percent so that you accept one percent. That wasn't the point. It was not.

3:20:37 It was done because it was felt that that was where we needed to be to build the war chest to get people here when we need them. And again, the funds are being used to bring people here midweek winter, shoulder seasons, and summer. Are VONS and Rite Aid included in this? They are. Are you – I've asked this question before, and I'll ask it again. Have you considered the rationale which would support having –

3:21:07 Every business, including the service industries, the professions, after all, we're all dependent upon tourism, even if we're not front line. Sure. Included in this pool of people that you would either extract money from or add 1.5% to whatever it is that's either billed or collected. Yeah, and we did explore that. I think the biggest challenge is if you look at right now, we've got restaurant and retail which are very, very, very tied to tourism.

3:21:37 And it's a struggle. If we start adding in lawyers and dentists and the auto body shops and the rest of the service industry, it's going to be, it would be that much more difficult. And again, that's where South Lake Tahoe attempted to incorporate everyone with a business license into their program and it failed. It was too broad-based, it was too hard to manage, it was too hard to get the support for it.

3:22:00 But if you did that, is there a nexus between collecting from those types of businesses or professions or industries and what the money is to be used for? Well, it has to be spent to benefit those businesses. And I think that if you're going to go that far to say, let's expand it to lawyers, you know, the fact that we're spending money to bring people here, which creates jobs, which gets lawyers business, it's a cycle that goes down. It's just it's hard to show the direct impact on the people that are paying in.

3:22:31 As a follow-up to one of Rick's earlier questions, have you – oh, I forgot what I was going to say. Oh, have you – is there – you mentioned that we're breaking new ground. Yes. In the past, in breaking new ground, we've gotten into trouble sometimes legally. I just want to make sure that legally that this has been researched to where the TBID, as it's being proposed,

3:23:02 Is on solid legal ground. Yeah, and we've worked very closely. Our legal counsel, myself, have worked very closely with BBK, both Andrew and Kelly Salt down in San Diego, who works on their improvement district division. And we've made sure that we cross all the T's and dot all the I's. So while it's a different segment, the retail segment, it is being set up under the 94 law, just like lodging, just like restaurants, even though there are only three restaurant districts in the state. But it's being set up exactly like those. So we do feel that...

3:23:31 We've run through all the courses to say that it is a legitimate opportunity to get more involved. If I can get in on your questions, Rick, because I didn't understand you're saying that it's not broader in covering every business in town just because it's harder to get consensus? Absolutely. Because it's harder to justify the direct impact on a lawyer or a dentist, that tourism is a direct impact, to get an indirect impact.

3:24:01 Again, I'm in town because I work in tourism, and my family of four goes to Dr. Schrager to get our teeth cleaned. That's a very indirect tourism town. When I asked Dr. Schrager last year, I said, how much of your business is impacted by tourism? He said, very little. We get a few people that get chipped teeth when they go skiing, and we take care of that. And I said, no, no, no. How many people like me come into your shop because I work in tourism, or they work at the mountain, or they work at a restaurant, or they work at a lodging property? And it's an indirect impact.

3:24:30 And the law is definitely clear that it has to be a direct impact and a direct benefit to those people that are paying in. It doesn't actually say direct benefit, but it says estimated benefit. And once you start getting secondary, tertiary impacts, it becomes harder to quantify them. And if you can't quantify them, you can't assess them. So what about, I had an impression after the last presentation that

3:24:57 There has never been a successful challenge of a T bid. I can't remember how many there are in the state, but there are. 76. That's right, something like that. But I have seen some literature from some of the folks that are opposed to this that suggests otherwise. Can you address that, or can your counsel address that? Yeah, I'd bring John Lambeth up. You're talking directly about the BIDs that are out there that have been challenged, the ARC district and a few others. I've only seen one, so I haven't done the research on my own, but I've...

3:25:26 I thought that it's worthy of addressing whether we are in some danger if we were to pass this in its present form of having it struck down. Thank you. Good evening, Mayor, Councilmembers. John Lambeth with Civitas. Pleasure to be back here with you again tonight. I guess I would say, and first I'd defer to your counsel in terms of legal advice to the counsel. We can certainly share with you our opinion about this.

3:25:55 A little much has been made about the novelty of this district. The 94 Act provides for business assessments. To the extent that you're putting a program together that benefits those businesses, the 94 Act allows this council essentially to assess those businesses. And there are hundreds of examples of business improvement districts up and down the state that have assessed retail businesses, that have assessed restaurants, that have assessed all different kinds of businesses for their programs.

3:26:25 When people are talking about the novelty of this district, they're talking about, in particular, the tourism improvement districts. And these are a little bit of a different mechanism in that they promote tourism exclusively. Other business improvement districts sometimes promote tourism, but they really are focused on bringing more visitors into your community. And so, like John said, there are actually now 78 of them in the state. There are two more that have been formed just in the last week.

3:26:54 Out of those 78, none have chosen to assess retail or restaurants, so that part of it is different. However, if there was a community that might be a good candidate for this kind of an approach, from our standpoint, it is Mammoth Lakes. You are a community that is much more dependent upon tourism in your local economy.

3:27:17 than, say, many other communities around the state. So from our standpoint, it is absolutely legally justified. In fact, some of the newer statutes talk about making sure that you include folks that are benefiting and are pushing districts more toward being more inclusive, not less inclusive of their assesses. So that is to the first question. As to the second, as it relates to other lawsuits.

3:27:44 Bids have been around in California since the mid-60s, and there have been lots of challenges, and there have been bids that have been successfully overturned, including one recently in Los Angeles. What's happened in some areas of bids, those bids that rely on property assessments, there have been some recent rulings that have sort of changed the rules as it relates to property assessments. And the bid in Los Angeles, the Arts District, got caught up in those change of rules.

3:28:10 Those rules that that challenge was under do not apply to this district because it is not a property assessment. So the talk of the arts district or talk of other districts that have been overturned, that law in particular has nothing to do with and does not impact your district. I will mention there has been one...

3:28:32 One district that has been challenged in the state tourism district, and that was San Diego, and that suit is ongoing. It hasn't been overturned, and in fact, so far, the city and the district is essentially winning in that case. Thank you. Any other council members have questions? Yes, I do. John, when the rates were being worked out and there was a limit and a $500 fee,

3:29:06 Determined. Was there any discussion that if you have someone who has a very small business that they actually end up paying more because the $500 fee is a larger percentage of their, like let's say, I don't know how much the vacuum and sewing guy makes, let's say it's $20,000, then he actually pays more than the 1.5%. Was there any consideration of a cutoff of where someone was so small that they didn't pay in? At this point when we

3:29:35 When we put the program together initially, the plan as we presented it to BBK was to actually exclude completely businesses that were less than $150,000 or that did more than 51% of their business locally. When we went to BBK, there was a caveat that came back that said we need to have every person in every segment included. So we came back with a flat $500 annual fee. Okay, but what I'm suggesting is maybe that that fee should scale down.

3:30:05 Okay. At a point because you are getting in a position at a certain level where it is a higher percentage to the tiny, tiny businesses. Right. That's to be a consideration. Let's go back to 1%. Or something less. I just did the math quickly and if somebody was making less than $34,000, it's actually a higher percentage. And I'm sure we've got some businesses that fall in that. There are. There are a few. I will say that there are a few. Even when we looked at the $150,000 and lower, there are...

3:30:35 So is that something where you'd be saying, well, they could either protest it or appeal it? Well, in the case of the vacuum store, the majority of his business is service, and we spoke on the phone about that. So the service is not included. Same thing with Mammoth Spot Creations. True, but the way you set it up is that the service is by credit card receipts. Well, what if it's a cash business? We'll have to figure out another appeal piece on that. And following on that is that I understand there's a protest period.

3:31:05 And the appeals come to council after it's imposed, if it is imposed? And the appeals come, as far as I know, they come to the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board. We'll have a three-person panel. Okay, is there a cost for someone to appeal? No, not at this point. Okay. But they will have to provide the information that shows that they've got 51% of their business level or that they're less than $150,000. But there are really, at this point, unless somebody's completely wrongly classed by the town,

3:31:35 Where there are 100% service industry, there would be no full exemptions. And that was, again, based on the BBK recommendation. Okay. Is there a way to consider a sliding scale within this, or does it have to go through one of those processes? Can things be changed within the petition? The statute specifically provides that council can make some changes to this at the final hearing, not tonight, but at the final hearing.

3:32:07 And those are limited in scope. And one of the limits is that it would have to be a reduction. So if you were to look at that lower end and council wanted to reduce some assessments on the very low end like that, in my view, that would be within the discretion of the town. But again, it would defer to your council ultimately for your direction. What about internet sales? What about sales that businesses who are...

3:32:37 Primarily located here, but do business on the Internet. Yeah, I think that as of the drafting now, they would not be included, but it's certainly something that, you know, we can look at that. I don't think that, you know, it sort of goes back to, I guess, the nature of the business and how they relate to the nature of the promotion efforts. Well, I mean, in a classic, let's assume a sporting goods store or a ski shop has an Internet component or segments.

3:33:09 Obviously, it's the same product that they might be selling in the store, but they're selling it online. Yes. Would online sales be included? Well, I think if the programs were designed to drive online sales, then they would have been included, and the programs are not designed to drive online sales. The programs are designed to drive visitors here, to drive sales in the store, not drive online sales. And so it would be appropriate that they would not be assessed for that.

3:33:41 Any other council members have questions? Okay. Thank you, John and John. With that, I'm going to go ahead and open it up to the public for comments. So if you all would, please come up. And again, please limit your time to, was it three minutes we have on there, Jamie? Yeah. It's 9 o'clock, yeah. Yeah. And thank you. Rusty. Rusty Gregory, Chairman and CEO of Mammoth Mountain Scareo.

3:34:15 So tonight's a very important night to start listening to others than us. So I'm going to uncharacteristically stop talking about our well-documented support and the reasons for support of, pardon my voice, for the TBIN. I do want to remind the council that I made a promise to the town in November of 2012 that I was going to get out of the way and that we were in a very important time in the

3:34:44 The future and the presence of the Town of Mammoth Lakes, the municipality and the community. And that the things that were going to be required in the future were different than the things that we comfortably have done in the past, starting with Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. And so true to that, we've made a lot of changes, some of which are public, some of which are not. Our picket here is here tonight. It's been a great job with Chief Marketing Officer of Mammoth Mountain Ski Area.

3:35:12 It's going to be with the company for the foreseeable future because we believe that we need special help to work with the TBID to coordinate with them if it passes so that we can take our marketing effort, fold it into their marketing effort so that we're leveraging up the benefits. We've made a lot of other changes. In two or three weeks, I'll be announcing who's going to run Mammoth Mountain ski area next. And Mammoth Mountain will not be run by me.

3:35:40 Thank you for that. Appreciate that. And we're making a lot of changes organizationally that are difficult to make because for us to do things in the future, we can't do things the same way, harder and faster and expect a different result. So it's not a natural act for us considering this very...

3:36:06 New program for the ski area. It's not a natural, excuse me, for the town, not a natural act to put up more money at a time when people are very concerned about how expensive things are. We believe that it is the only growth strategy that we could see on the horizon. And we need as a community on the resort side of our resort community, we need a growth strategy. All the different things that we're talking about earlier tonight, the budgets,

3:36:32 The ability of the town to get back to provide for police service, for town services, that comes primarily from transient occupancy taxes. That comes from people visiting the community. So you'll see us standing up for things that will add to visitation on a year-round basis, winter and summer. We think the T bid will do that. So we'll be quiet. It's a very important time for you all to listen.

3:37:01 Thank you very much. Thank you, Rusty.

3:37:33 Yeah, my name is Gene Martin, a manufacturing and sewing machine company. I opened it up in 1987. It's a part-time business because I ran my own shop and store down in Torrance for 20-some years. Now my daughter and son will have that, and they have the headaches of working six days a week. I don't want to do that anymore. So I'm roughly doing about two days a week in Mammoth, one day a week in Bishop. I do not distinguish between what I get and whatever. My wife and I have been doing this for 50-some years, over.

3:38:01 56 years in a month, in a few days. And I just feel like my profit margin is about 25%. Last year I did less than $30,000 for the business. And I keep my prices low, I can compete with the internet, but people still don't know that I do that. So I can't afford to advertise because it breaks even. If I put $50 in advertising, I might get $50 in repair, and it's working for nothing.

3:38:30 So I found that advertising has not worked. I've done mailers and didn't even pay for the mailers. So that's the type it is. I get about 5% of the people in Mammoth giving me business. 95% I feel are giving business out of town. I know even a county spends their money out of state. They bought 25 vacuum cleaners and never called me once. They gave me 25 to repair and they said, no, just do two of them, three of them. And they kept all the other broken ones back. Never get a call.

3:38:57 So it's not like they're spending money here in town. I try to keep my money local, and that helps. But I feel like people will come back if they have a good experience. If you pay somebody $8 an hour, you're only going to get an $8 employee. Why should they work and give you $12, $15 worth of people have written in the paper how they've had poor experience at stores and things like that? Well, I don't think I'd be very happy at $8 an hour myself.

3:39:25 And so basically I'm not for this program because I feel it's hitting the small people to me in particular. $500 would have to come out of my savings. I do not earn enough money to pay my bills. I have to hit savings every month just to cover the bills because it's not cheap to live up here. We all know that between taxes, health insurance and everything else and the price of gas. Everything costs too much money to live up here, but I wouldn't want to move and I wouldn't want to live.

3:39:54 I live someplace else. I enjoy this and I take the sacrifice of not being able to do everything I want to to just to have to be enjoy it up here. So basically I feel like there should be at least some exemption. I'm 90 some percent service. That's what I do. I repair them. I do it myself. I couldn't afford an employee. I do everything myself and have been doing that since 1987. So I don't feel like I should be hit for $500.

3:40:20 I didn't sleep that night when I got that notice. It bothered me really bad. And I just don't feel like I should be hit with that kind of an expense. I don't feel I get that much out of the tourism. And I do the best job I can. 90% of my business, I feel, is referral. I put my ads down to nothing in the yellow pages.

3:40:42 When I was down south in Torrance, every time of the year came around with a bigger ad, bigger ad, bigger ad. Nobody did any more business. We just paid out more advertising. And the same thing could happen, too. If you've got a town and you start paying a lot more advertising, the next town will have to pay out more advertising. They're still competing. I think the best way to make the town grow is by giving people the best opportunity, the best enjoyment, and have them come back and stay longer. So that's my opinion.

3:41:10 Thank you. And I want to apologize. I did not specifically pick you out. I just thought you were one at the small business. There was no collusion here. Yes. Okay. Well, thank you for your time. Thank you. Appreciate it. I can't read a hat that far away. Anyone else? Yep. Please. Hi. Excuse me. Good evening, Mr. Williamson. Mr. Mayor, Councilmembers. I don't know if I can be heard from out here. Yeah, we can hear you. Great. So I was here a few weeks ago. It won't come as any surprise. I haven't changed my mind.

3:41:42 I'm still pretty vehemently opposed to this. With all due respect to Rusty, the man left, I actually met with him for 90 minutes. It's the only time I've ever spoken to him. On that 90 minutes, I have great respect for him. I think he's... Oh, sorry. Derek Johnson, Crystal Crag Lodge on Lake Mary. I am not one of the people who, at least at this point, thinks that they wield too much power the mountain or that Rusty does or none of that. He's just filling the space that he should fill.

3:42:12 That's all. It's just up to the rest of the people around here to do the same. It's nothing he's doing wrong or John Urdi's doing wrong. He's doing his job. People are doing their jobs. I respect all of them. It's not that. It's just we disagree about whether this is a good idea or not. It's that simple. And to me, to pick up on his point, Rusty's point, to keep doing the same old thing, you know, that's a straw man. Doing the same old thing, some would argue, I would argue, is raising taxes. That is doing the same old thing.

3:42:41 Raising taxes. So to create this idea that it's some novel thing, it's just a fancy way of getting around having a vote on a tax increase. That's what the bid is. It's an end run on a vote of the people on a tax increase. Is it new and novel? No, it's a tax increase. It's that simple. So to say it's new and novel or we ought to be doing something different, with all due respect, as I said, I really like Rusty. We just disagree about it. One thing I do agree with him about is that this is risky. He told me that when I met with him. He told us that tonight.

3:43:11 If you were listening carefully, he said, we don't know how this is going to come out. What he told me when I sat down with him in his office is, this could backfire. People going around town, buying things, going to restaurants, going to hotels, and seeing this thing on every single one could backfire. He said that. It's true. Now, I think he says that to somewhat disarm the opposition, because if he's so reasonable, he could sell ice to Eskimo. But it's really true what he said. It could backfire. And it's risky. It's risky on the marketing level.

3:43:39 It's risky on the legal level. This is very young law, just like these mountains are young geologically. This law is young. It's only a couple decades old, which in the law is pretty young. It's been challenged on the assessment level, which means if you get your property assessed versus your sales assessed, it's been very successfully challenged if it's too loose. So there's a legal risk, which a few of you council members have alluded to. There's the risk of our customers, our loyal customers being asked

3:44:08 To pay tax to support our disloyal or new customers. Yeah, the guns will come every time. Come six times. Who's going to pay all that tax? They are to hopefully attract new people. It's risky on a number of levels. And it comes down to you guys. This petition is window dressing. It's meeting the requirements of the law. It's trying to give you guys a little cover, but it really isn't. It would have taken 85% of the remainder of businesses doing dollar volume to overcome the mountains.

3:44:37 40-yard lead and a 50-yard dash. It would have taken 85%. We would have had to do it without any money, any paid staff, any 40, 50, 100, who knows what Civitas gets paid? We don't have that on our side. So it wasn't, come on, anybody who's honest, that petition is window dressing and it meets the requirements of the law, but it doesn't really give you guys any cover. This is on you. When you vote for this or against this, it's on you guys.

3:45:06 It's your choice. What do you want for this town? You're the grown-ups on the playground deciding what's going to be best for this town. You won't be able to lay it off on a petition that was kind of legally gerrymandered to anyone's honest about it. But anyway, this is risky. It's risky legally. It's risky for our customers. It's risky for my business. Personally,

3:45:27 Derek, I'm going to cut you off if you don't mind, just because I know there's a lot of people out there that are going to... All right, cool. That's great. Last time I was the only one, so I thought I could take the floor. The last thing I'm going to say is you can vote it down. You can vote it in, and you probably very well likely have a 2-18 challenge to this.

3:45:55 Somebody said here tonight we're not very lucky in those legal challenges, so I really think you should think twice about it. And then finally, just personally, I'm a member of a small group of people who will be challenging it, either just with you, hopefully, or if not, elsewhere, that there are a few of us who really don't play in the sandbox called Mammoth Lakes, the town. We play outside the sandbox. You guys are wanting to charge our customers to put new and better sand in the sandbox, which I understand if I was on a business on...

3:46:24 Mammoth, Old Mammoth Road, I might support. I don't play in that sandbox, and so you're taxing my customers to pay for new sand for the sandbox in Mammoth. And there are a few of us in that category who just by chance happen to be within the city limits, but we really aren't in the town, and we will want to redress this with you as a board, hopefully, to some success. If not, we will try it elsewhere. I don't want to. That's my last choice. I hope you just broke the whole thing down, because I think it's bad for the town. Thank you. Thank you, Derek.

3:46:56 Hi. Good evening again. Martin Kleinbard. As a resident and a business owner, and I have to say that as a business owner, as a contractor, I'm not going to be affected by this, but I still have some strong concerns. I have to reiterate, Derek from Crystal Crack Lodge, his comments made a few weeks ago, and his biggest concern was that on an average week stays at his complex for a family,

3:47:25 Would probably run upwards of more than $400 just in the taxes. And that would be increased to even more with the TBIT. Rusty Gregory stood up and said that the data that they have over the past few years, that they have customers that aren't staying as long and they're not doing as many visits. Derek said the same thing from...

3:47:51 From his complex. He hasn't owned it as long as the original owners, but I'm sure he has the data from the previous owner, because I had worked on their place with the previous owner, and I know that they used to tell me how they have the same people using the same condo, but the same cabin over and over again, same family. And if Derek's saying that the same people are not returning year after year, and that it's a real, it has to be a real privilege for the family to come up and do one of these vacations, and you're not getting

3:48:20 The return customers, that's a big thing. So maybe we need to look at, are we starting to price ourselves out of the market? And just increasing taxes to pay for advertising to try to get more people, it's almost like there's a vicious cycle. So on another thing is I have many customers who have condominiums, they also rent them out, and they've

3:48:50 Have no clue of what the TBID is. Now, granted, they haven't done a lot of visits. The few people I've talked to, I asked them, and there were three people I did service calls for. And neither one of them knew, but they also hadn't been reading the paper when they were here, and they haven't had a lot of time up here. But what concerns me the most is I asked them if they got any mailings, because they are on the TOT program, so they should be getting something in the mail about this.

3:49:20 Because it's going to affect them as well. And when I started to tell them the situation, they were just dumbfounded. They feel that already they're having to show their guests on paper that when they do a longer stay that they discount the price of the stay substantially so it's almost like they're just absorbing that TOT already on a future day stay. Because they really don't want to reduce the cost of the stay much more, but they have to.

3:49:51 Because they don't want to piss the people off about all the taxes. Because that's like one of the number one complaints that the visitors say is, boy, that costs a lot of money. I guess my time is up. Thank you, Martin. Appreciate it. Thank you for your time, Mayor, Council. My name is Glenn Taylor. I'm the owner of Perry's Italian Cafe. And first I'd like to do is present you guys with my letter of protest.

3:50:38 I realize time is short, so I'll try to make this as brief as possible. I just wrote down a few ideas here, and I think they need to be addressed and at least brought out into the open. Number one on the time-sensitive mailer that was sent out, it was sent to Roger Guffey's P.O. Box. I'm sure the town has, I mean, I know they have my current business license on file, and, you know, it's...

3:51:09 Plainly states the current PO Box. Roger hasn't owned Perry's Italian Cafe for nine years. The only reason I got this is because he came into the restaurant and personally gave it to me. So I think updating your files and things should be something that's pretty easy to do, and I don't see how it could be overlooked unless possibly it was done on purpose.

3:51:34 You say in the T-bit outline there that activities are designed to provide specific benefits to assessed businesses by increasing tourism and commerce at assessed businesses, etc., end quote. My question is how are we going to track that? You know, I can tell you right off the bat I haven't seen a half a percent of business increase midweek due to the airlines in the airport.

3:52:04 You know, as somebody who's in their business every day, I can tell you that people have already stopped coming to Mammoth. I have personal friends who have stopped coming to Mammoth. I hear it from people who come into our restaurant that they just can't afford it anymore. And, you know, they're at the breaking point. I think, you know, passing this tax, which is what it is, it's like another lime item.

3:52:33 It's going to be right underneath your sales tax. On to your guests that are coming to town. I think it's going to be the tipping point. I think it's going to break them. I think they're finally going to have enough and say, you know what, we just can't do this anymore. Another point I just made here is, you know, I did find it kind of interesting just a few minutes ago that, you know, Rusty was the first one up here to address everybody. And the one who says we should all sit here and listen.

3:53:03 Was the first one to head for the door. Okay? Take that for what you want. I feel it's unfair and it needs to be equal and fair across the board. There is no way one business should have any more of a percentage vote than any other business in this town. It needs to be fair and legal across the board. I think, you know, that's, might be setting ourselves up for some

3:53:33 Interesting things down the road as far as legalities go with that. Another thing is the effect this is going to have on the locals here. I think it is anti-small business in town. The locals are going to be punished and penalized for patronizing local businesses. The locals that can barely afford to go out to eat anymore, that still do.

3:54:00 They're going to be hit with that other 1.5% tax. They're not tourists. They live here. But then again, it has to be fair across the board. So they're going to be taxed just like the tourists are. That'll push them over the edge. They're not going to go out anymore. That's going to affect small local business, front line, bottom line. Retail, same thing. Locals, you know, they're not going to buy skis locally. I don't think they're going to, when there's such good deals online,

3:54:30 The people who pride themselves in shopping locally, I mean, I remember, that's kind of a push, right? Shop local, support local business. They're not going to be able to anymore. They're going to go on the internet and they're going to order it. Get it delivered right to their door. Or next time they're up in Reno, they're going to find what they need up there. So it's taking dollars away from local business here in town. Land, I'm going to cut you off just because I've got a bunch of people behind as well. I'm sorry to do that. That's okay. I just wanted to add one.

3:54:59 One more real quick item. I don't think we need to add any extra dollars to advertising until we fix what the real problem is. I think everybody needs to realize that we've priced ourselves out of the market. Mammoth was built on being an affordable family destination. It's far from that anymore. I think if we're going to spend money on marketing, why don't we market Mammoth Lakes and Mammoth Mountain Ski Area as Southern California's local ski mountain.

3:55:29 It's a five-hour drive. It's almost all divided highway all the way now. And let's get the families back up here, the people who can come up and make it affordable for them. Not $105 lift tickets a day. So they can come up two times, three times a year instead of once, if that. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Glenn. Hi, I'm Julie Fontaine, and I am not a local business owner. So I agree with what Glenn has just stated, and I just wanted to bring a perspective as just a voting member.

3:56:03 of the town of Mammoth Lakes. You know, I live and reside and within your jurisdiction. And my assumptions with the democratic system is that we elect public officials to represent us as residents of Mammoth Lakes that look out for the people's interest, particularly those that voted the officials in.

3:56:29 You know the Gettysburg Statement by Lincoln, government of the people, by the people, and for the people? Well, in determining whether this tax is in the best interest of the residents of Mammoth Lakes and if they support it, I really didn't see any action on your part to seek input whether we as citizens, as non-business owners, will support this tax or not. Because we know that the business owners are going to just tax us. They're just going to pass it on.

3:56:59 When I go to bonds, I'm going to get taxed 1%, 1.5% more if I shop here, if I shop in Bishop. No matter, you know, this tax affects me directly as a citizen, whether I'm a business owner or not. I mean, you guys met behind closed doors, you know, you've indicated you want to pass this, and just now you're seeking input. But have you possibly considered what the constituents, the people voted you in, want this tax or not?

3:57:26 It seems a little bit screwed up to me that you're approaching it in this way. You know, perhaps if we lived in the Middle Ages and a few powerful entities decided who got taxed, that'd be fine, but we don't. And we don't want to be served by having really no vote in this matter. We don't want to say, you know, you're going to be taxed indirectly because that's, as Glenn said, that's what this is, is an indirect tax. You know, you didn't even simply, you didn't even send out a poll.

3:57:56 So, you know, I think there's a lot of businesses here and individuals that didn't show up today because they're afraid of the repercussions that may come about as a result of going against some of the deep-pocketed economic powers of this town. You know, and I commend the courage of those that are here today that are here publicly speaking saying, I don't want this.

3:58:25 When a few businesses kind of control the pocketbooks of the town and have a lot of voting rights, as in the case of this, it's scary to go in and say, well, I don't agree with Mammoth Mountain. Now, I don't have that at stake, but there's a lot of other businesses that I've talked to that are afraid to speak up. So you need to be aware of that. So I hope this council takes a step back and remember who they represent.

3:58:50 It's us, the citizens, the locals here in Mammoth Lakes, and not necessarily the deep-pocketed corporate entities with a lot of financial muscle. So, you know, let the people and the businesses of Mammoth decide in a fair playing field, not based on, you know, who has the most financial backing or contributes to the most funds. You know, let us decide if the TBID is right for us, because it affects us.

3:59:17 So I ask you to consider this and potentially consider an open public vote where all have equal to say and equal voting power. My name is Phil Herzog and my brother and I own Mammoth Outdoor Sports on Old Mammoth Road and Value Sports on Main Street and Mega Sale inside the Sierra Center Mall.

3:59:47 I've been a, let's say, a friendly thorn in the side of John Urdi for the past year and a half because I've wanted to dig in to his budget, what numbers he's producing in terms of results midweek in the winter, and I wanted to understand his marketing program. I wanted to understand his marketing organization. I've had numerous meetings with him. I'm convinced that he's using his current budget in a responsible...

4:00:18 And in that situation, I work with the owners.

4:00:48 And the producers of these ski and snowboard shows. What I've discovered is that over the past two decades, where once Mammoth was recognized by registrants as 50% of the attendees at a show in Los Angeles, San Diego, and Las Vegas, today it's 28%. Now, how can we change things here in Mammoth Lakes?

4:01:16 There's 1.3 million to 2 million participants in the sport in Southern California. We don't need a market research study to tell us, let's get our ass down there and let's participate, which we haven't done. The mountain and Mammoth Lakes, I've been to numerous planning session meetings, which we're talking about, gee, we need to be like Breckenridge. If we're just like Breckenridge, people will come. If we just change, you know, we're a little more like Vale, people will come. Bullshit.

4:01:48 We have the world's greatest mountain right here. And I love what you did, voicing what Glenn was asking for, which you've done, which is Mammoth, Southern California's only world-class mountain. So although I have concerns with all the subsidies of the airlines, that's a strategy that's in place. We want to be a destination resort. We've been working for over a decade or longer to be a destination resort. Let's go after Southern California.

4:02:18 Let's take this $2.5 million, and John has convinced me that that's what he's going to do. In meetings with Howard and in meetings with Rusty, I'm convinced that they're going to price themselves, they're going to market themselves, and what do we need? We certainly have to pass for another million ski visits a year, just to finish. If we pick off 100,000, just 10%,

4:02:45 What a small percentage of the 1.5 to 2 million market there is down in Southern California. Every 100,000 ski visits helps them out a lot. I know it helps my business a lot, and it helps all the retail and all the restaurant visits, and that's why I'm for the E&D. Thank you, Phil. Yeah. Council Mayor, thank you for having us tonight. Michael Ledesma is my name. I'm a resident, first and foremost, and also a business owner here in Mammoth Lakes.

4:03:15 Co-owner with Russ Squire of Gomez's in the village. And I am a staunch supporter of the TBID. I understand all of the controversies that come with it, and I'm confident that we'll work through those things for the people that are open-minded on both sides of the issue. As a resident, I support the TBID because I believe firmly that visitation and commerce and revenue increases that come into Mammoth, particularly midweek, will increase demand.

4:03:46 And with subsequent inventory staying the same or relatively the same will increase prices or values for homes in Mammoth. So as a homeowner and a resident, I support it. It will increase property values. As an employer of more than 50 people, Russ and I will tell you and most business owners will tell you that one of the biggest grievances or challenges we hear from our employees, our staff base, is that in the shoulder season, midweek,

4:04:16 Summer, even in winter, they're distressed. It's hard to make ends meet. Investing millions of dollars over a five-year period into mid-week and shoulder season visitation here will help them dramatically. It will increase revenues in the town, demand on businesses and retail and restaurants and all services who will indirectly benefit.

4:04:45 And therefore, more jobs will be created. It's a trickle-down scenario. From a business ownership standpoint, you know, Russ and I's background is in sales and marketing. We've had 25 years' experience in sales and marketing, and we know that this type of aggressive campaign to market the brand and the infrastructure of our town will have great and positive impact.

4:05:15 We understand that there's bugs to be worked out, there's controversies at hand, but we are in great support of trying something. And one of the things I worry about is that we, as a community, all have problems or challenges and grievances, but very few solutions. And I really do believe that this is a great opportunity to have a solution for this entire community.

4:05:45 Of great scale. And if it doesn't work, we have the remedy to back out of it, whether it's on the annual basis of a protest or at the end of the five-year cycle. But at the end of the day, we need to do something. And this is the best something that I personally have heard of since I've been coming up here in the 80s, since I first purchased up here in the 90s, and since I first started living up here full-time.

4:06:13 In the 2000s as a business owner. Again, thank you for your time. Thank you, Michael. Colin Fernie. I'll speak this time as a local business owner. I'm the owner of Black Tie Ski Rentals. Thank you for hearing me for the third time tonight. So I'd just like to bring up a couple of points. I think our business is unique in this town in the sense that

4:06:43 Not only are we a local business, but we're connected to 13 black tie branches that represent some of the top 13 resorts in North America. So what I'm mostly going to speak upon is kind of my reference point, which is black tie ski rentals. So a lot of things that I've heard, first of all, I'm a very strong supporter of the TBID. I think John Urdi and his staff.

4:07:08 Are the most competent people to implement this and I have the utmost faith in them to do a great job with this. A lot of people here talk very often about how our tax rates here are exorbitant. So relative to the 13 black tie branches that we have in North America, we are the third lowest. The only two below us are Park City at 7.95% and Big Sky at 3%. They have no tax rate in Montana.

4:07:38 But all of the other resorts that we represent have a higher tax rate than us. So at 8%, not only are we lower than our competition as far as our tax rate, but we are also lower than the majority of California, and I know a little bit less about that. But I do think that there's room for our tax rate to move. So a lot of people have wanted to call this assessment a tax. That's fine. So essentially our tax would move from 8% to 9.5 to our customers.

4:08:05 That'll still keep us significantly below Aspen, which is at 10.4%. So I do think there's room for our tax rate to move. We've only been in business four years, and I certainly respect all the business owners in this community. I think everybody's entitled to their opinion, but I just want to kind of talk about my opinion personally. Since we've been here in four years, I believe our tax rate has changed three times.

4:08:33 I don't think that most locals that don't own businesses or invested in this even know what our tax rate is. And I know for a fact that in four years of business I've never had a single client ask us what our tax rate is. And when it changes it doesn't make an impact on the client from my experience.

4:08:55 I was recently reading a study that was done, Aspen, when they tried to put together a marketing program. They brought in an outside marketing firm to kind of look at their situation, and a number that I thought really stuck out at me is they told the Aspen Chamber of Commerce, whoever was implementing their marketing strategy, that they thought that $3 million in direct marketing was the minimum amount of money that the town of Aspen needed to spend to actually see a return on investment.

4:09:25 Right now, John Urdi's budget, I just asked him, is around a million. So we're falling far short of that. With this T bid, that'll put us up in that $3 million range. So I think that's something important. And I guess I'm out of time. But the last thing I'll say real quickly is I don't believe that we're pricing ourselves out of the market. The only two resorts in North America that get more skier visits than us are Vail and Breckenridge.

4:09:53 Both of which are significantly more expensive than Mammoth. So it's about creating experience that people want to come to, not whether they're going to have to pay an extra 30 cents on a bill. So that's my viewpoint. Thank you. Thank you, Colin. Can you try to clarify that number? Yep. The marketing. It says there's a million dollar budget, the effective marketing dollars. So the million dollars is the effective marketing dollars. It's what actually is put into placement of ads.

4:10:25 Not design, not research, not staff, not overhead. No, that's, I mean, it is a million dollars, roughly. And your total budget is? Two point, this year we budgeted at 2.1. Can I briefly address something about tax rates and relative tax rates? When I looked at the three that were brought up at the last meeting, Salvataw, Breckenridge, and Vail, with these increases, we will be significantly higher than all three of them, both in sales tax and bed tax. Now, of course,

4:11:03 If we do this, then they'll be able to say at their town council meetings, hey, you guys, we're below Mammoth and who else? This is how an arms race works. Civitas, the marketing company that does this, goes around to towns and say, you guys need a bid. Guess who has a bid? Your competition. By the way, they help them get their bid. It's like in the Middle East, you know, they run around trying to say, you need some more guns. The guy next door has more guns. Well, they sold them those guns. So there's a lot of this game playing about tax rates and who has a bid and who doesn't. And you've got to really...

4:11:30 Focus and pay attention. So we are maybe lowered, but we will be significantly higher. And the last thing I want to say is raise your hand if you're willing to pay 14% on top of your sales. Anybody, lawyers, doctors, stores, restaurants, 14%. So please don't talk to me about how your business wouldn't mind another 1.5%. Are you going to pay 14%?

4:11:51 If you could please direct everything up this way versus engaging in it. Okay, sorry, I'm really, really livid about it because people put 40 cents on a hamburger thing, like it's, or four cents on a hamburger. It's insulting, John. I respect John Ernie, but stop quoting that because that's a red herring. Who cares about a Big Mac? We're talking about big ticket items. I have a friend who has a business in the village. He can't say anything publicly because, look, he's in the village. But he's going to lose business to Bishop. There are people who are just saying, I'm buying a big ticket item. I'm not going to pay him extra.

4:12:19 You've just got to watch this stuff, because it's so easy to say, oh, it's 9%, oh, it's 9%. If leapfrogs, and then mail-raising, then will-raising, you've just got, somebody's got to say, enough, enough. People are not buying or coming because it's too expensive and taxes are too high. Period. No more. Find another way.

4:12:44 First of all, I've got a couple of businesses in town ask me to, or a business in town ask me to, and they are protesting against the TBID. Hello, and first of all, I'd like to thank you for letting me speak here tonight. My name is Brian Ellison, and I'm a long-time resident of Mammoth Lakes. I'm also a long-time owner and operator of Brian's Bicycles and Cross-Country Skis.

4:13:15 I have three points of protest that I would like to address tonight. There are many other issues that I'd like to speak about relating to my own business, but I feel that three points will be enough for now. All three have to do with the formation of the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Business Improvement District, which from now on I will address as either the MLTPID or the TPID. The first point I have is whether the TPID

4:13:46 Is the best interest of small businesses collecting tax for this TBID? I feel this tax will have to be added on to the price of products sold, which can push the customers to buy online or out of town. As for people going to eat, they may not eat out at all. The tax will also create an additional bookkeeping burden. Is the TBID in the best interest?

4:14:16 For the other businesses and towns that are not subjected to the TBID, these other businesses will fulfill the effects of the tax as Mammoth becomes more expensive due to the results of the TBID. Is the TBID good for the people and the community? Many people working in Mammoth will feel the financial increase and this will make it harder for them to be able to afford to live in town.

4:14:44 Is the TBID in the best interest for others outside the area, whether for Mono or Inyo County, or for the tourists coming into town? Many will choose to shop out of the area or to take their vacations elsewhere due to the increased expense of coming to Mammoth. So I say no, it is not in the best interest to collect tax for the TBID. Who is the TBID in the best interest for?

4:15:14 It is in the best interest for MLTPID and the businesses directly involved in the forming of the MLTPID. The second point is the Town of Mammoth Lakes and the MLTPID are now and will be in the future once again opening up channels for more ridicule, lawsuits, and penalties due to the formation of the MLTPID.

4:15:43 Thank you again for letting me speak. Thank you, Brian. Appreciate it.

4:16:20 Good evening, Mayor and Councilmembers, Ronja Dugan. Wow. Don't quite know what to say, except just addressing a couple things that, first of all, you know, I hear a lot of talk about the Machiavellian efforts of a few people. I'm sorry, we did not, we only had one thing that we were looking at, it was protecting marketing dollars.

4:16:51 With the judgment against the town of Mammoth Lakes, those marketing dollars are at great risk. And that was the one intent, was to make sure that those people that were paying into marketing funds would actually get those used for marketing. Number one thing. So as not to trespass on anybody's rights to, you know, go after anyone here and not do something un-American.

4:17:21 It was to protect our marketing dollars. Number two is that it would be very easy to do business as usual and let the big entities continue to market themselves with no concern for the rest of the town. The people that are putting a lot more money into it are getting very little out of it compared to what the community does because those dollars go to market the entire community. And if you don't think

4:17:50 That we are all in tourism. We can argue whether directly or not. You can ponder would you still be here if tourism was not the support of the business. And the last thing is whether it goes one way or another, the lodging community still is going to pay TOT and pay those fees that will go to the general fund.

4:18:18 And we'll continue to pay for everyone's services and their marketing, whether this happens or not. But, you know, our customers are just as, we have to deal with that as everyone else does. But whether you decide, you know, and I'm sorry this has really come down on you because you all have nothing to do with it. Okay, and I want to make that clear too.

4:18:44 So this didn't happen behind closed doors for any of you. It was those people that are interested in moving Mammoth forward no matter what the economy is and protecting or deciding that maybe there's a way to look at that to protect dollars and maybe we'd pay into it ourselves. So everybody can believe what they want to believe. There was nothing that sinister about it. It was trying to protect our marketing efforts. Whether it passes or not,

4:19:12 Those people will still continue to market. Do you just want them to market for themselves? Or do you want to take some of those dollars that they are willing to assess and take out of their funds and give it to the community? That's what the bottom line will end up being. Thank you. Thank you, Rhonda. Hi. I'm Susan Baumgart and I'm with Glenda Perry's Italian Cafe. And I'd just like to point out that in this 11-page document,

4:19:43 Talking about highways and what is it documented? At any rate, 36600 code. It states here that these improvements can also be used for parking facilities, benches, pedestrian shelters, lighting, heating, parks, foundations, facilities, equipment, ramps, sidewalks, plazas. We need a bunch of that stuff.

4:20:12 To make our town look better before we advertise for it. And maybe if we used some of these funds to improve our town the way it looks, unsightly things, that we could probably get some more people to come here. And before we spend these advertising dollars to get them to come to our dilapidated town, let's fix it up first. Another thing I want to point out is that I don't think it's fair that only some businesses are paying for this. With all due respect,

4:20:39 The real estate companies are benefiting from our tourists, real estate agents, reservations, appraisals, construction workers. I know I'm not having my house fixed up. I know a lot of tourists are. And I think that this should be a fair tax for everybody, not just some businesses. And it states in this document, professions, restaurants, all of that. So I just think that we should open our minds and be fair across the board and maybe use some of this dollars to improve our town.

4:21:09 And not advertise, put all our money into advertising, but to use some of it to fix our roads and highways and sidewalks on Main Street and some lighting on Main Street. And that's all I have to say. Thank you. Thanks, Susan. Ted Carlton. I would agree with Susan on that point. I don't really understand how I'm getting away with not paying it or how Rick or John or Matthew.

4:21:44 I don't buy the argument that, well, because South Lake Tahoe tried it and it failed, therefore, we're not going to broaden the scope of what we're doing here and not have this be a community venture because we're going to risk failure. That just doesn't seem, I have great empathy for the fact that this doesn't seem quite democratic.

4:22:15 And I think you have to broaden that and then put it up to a vote. I also don't quite understand why it's not structured in some sort of business license type format where based on your gross revenues you would be subject to a certain tax. It would seem to make sense for me. I mean, if that's impossible, we're too late in the game, I guess you're looking at the new chairman of the Mammoth Lakes Fireworks Fund.

4:22:41 You know, I believe that there are a lot of businesses that need to throw in. The second thing that I found pretty interesting was just related to numbers. If we're raising $4.7 million off this, I guess the Mountain's take at 53% would be $2.4 that they would be spending a year. Based on Mr. Pickett's numbers and based upon, I guess they subsidized summer air two years ago,

4:23:12 So right now the mountain is paying about $3 million a year in subsidy. We're putting through a bid where they're raising $2.4 and it looks like they're risking about $1.2 million a year on the back end. So as I look at the numbers, just flat numbers, that the mountain proposes to spend $3.6 million going forward. They were spending $3.6 million.

4:23:42 And then for that, I guess that means that they're still basically subsidizing air service and then they want to throw 600 grand into the 2.5 million for marketing for the town. So I guess I would just like to see that as sort of a clear so we know, okay, this is what the mountain is proposing, this is their share, this is our share, do we want it? Because I don't, it was nice finally to get some actual, you know,

4:24:11 So we had some idea of what they were paying before, what they're going to pay now, and that should be under consideration. But really, it needs to be broader. The other question I had with Mr. Lambeth was, if you have 68 businesses paying 81%, that means you've got 67 businesses paying 28% or about $20,000 a piece. So those remaining 67 businesses are paying about $20,000 a piece in TBID.

4:24:40 In a typical T-Big community, what is the average business paying? Are they paying $500 a year, $1,000 a year, $2,000, $5,000? Are we taking our tiny community and really putting a lot of burden on a very few backs? So those are my concerns and questions. Thanks, Ted. Joe Perino. Up here just as a citizen, just here to kind of give you guys an idea of just the basic citizen in this town.

4:25:15 That doesn't own a property, doesn't own a business, that's here for the quality of life. Well, I'll tell you what's right now, the way I've seen, I've been back 14 years, I went to high school here back in the 70s. Back in those days, there wasn't really much marketing, because most of the time, it was all word of mouth, and Mammoth was a family-oriented place to come. Just like the fishing thing, you know, from grandpa to little Joey.

4:25:45 And what's going on now, what I can see, and Mammoth is a Scooby-Doo cartoon. That's what it reminds me of. And why I say that is because there's always a villain, and that's Rusty Gregory. And there's always that villain trying to destroy the town so he can benefit some way. And then you've got Scooby and Shaggy who figure out the deal and end up catching them. And the old saying, like, if it wasn't for those damn kids, I would have got away with it. So that's what I see what's going on here.

4:26:14 I don't think really we need to market Mammoth Lakes because people come here for the mountain during the wintertime and during the summertime, they come here for the fishing. They come here for the lakes and that type of stuff. Mammoth has nothing to offer. We have no value. People are not driving 600 miles to go to Perry's Cafe. They're not driving 600 miles to go to Skatey's. They're not driving 600 miles to go to Gomez's. We don't have anything. The value of the area sucks.

4:26:44 And that's one part where I'm seeing one of the biggest problems right now. And every year, it keeps decreasing, decreasing, decreasing. I mean, I'm out picking up trash. When I walk to my dog every day, there's trash over Main Street. How many of you drive down Main Street? How many of you stop and see trash and pull over and pick it up and throw it away? None of you. I've never seen it. I'm on those roads a lot. Sorry, I don't see it, Joe. I just did it two days ago. So, anyways, on top of that,

4:27:13 The main thing is this, like I said, the mountain pretty much does the marketing. People don't go on the town of Mammoth Lakes website, they go on Mammoth Mountain website. That's what I do. And if you look at the numbers, you'll see clearly, it's pretty clear that what really is the big, is definitely the big focus here. So I think that having a tourism department at Mammoth Lakes, it's just not, it's a waste of money to let the mountain, let the mountain do it. Let the mountain market what they have.

4:27:43 And again, because of the way the town looks, it does, it looks run down. And the biggest problem is this, is I don't want to, I don't want to shop here. I don't want to spend my money here. You know, I've had so many bad experiences when I've gone into local places, and just the way I've been treated by some of these people here, it just amazes me. Hey, I'm here to give you my money, and it's just like they don't want my business. I've had, it's happened to be a bad. Thanks, Joe.

4:28:12 I'd just like to make one statement to that. I have to say nobody goes to the town website. John, how many people go to that site a year? The only reason I bring that up, I just like to keep it as truthful as possible. We had some marketing for some of the events in town, and that was the number one driver to the events, just for a little clarification. Is there anybody else in the audience that wants to come up and speak?

4:28:48 My name is Kirk Schaubmeyer. I'm the chief parking lot sweeper at the Eltenhoff Lock. I'm the owner of Petra's Bistro and Wine Bar and the Clock Tower Cellar. I'm in support of the TIPA. I grew up in this town. I've seen it from when I was little to what it is today. And I admire everybody's support.

4:29:16 That's here. And I also admire everybody's fervor in their convictions. I think that's important. You know, when things were being increased for the lodging community years ago and that was the sole target, where were these people saying, oh, hey, I'd like to throw in. I think it's fair that everybody else should throw in. I think that's the right attitude. By way of example, you know,

4:29:46 My dad used to say you could close the doors back in the old days because nobody was coming to town. Along came a day where meal days was in full swing and some European bus came through town. They couldn't stay. They came up to Mammoth. My dad said to the tour leader, yeah, you bet I can take a busload of people because there wasn't anything happening. You know, these are, this is rather one example of what

4:30:16 Tourism gives to this town. Now, you know, the issue is what Rhonda was talking about, and I really kind of second that. It's maintaining the tourism dollars and trying to make sure that we have a viable marketing effort to attract more people and to maintain good relationships to get those people coming here so that they can spend their money, enjoy this place.

4:30:46 Which, whether you feel is dilapidated or not, it's still a very special place. And I think that it's something to support because you either believe in the marketing or you don't. I, you know, have long felt that the lodging community bared the burden of this. I am willing to support this with my restaurant and with my bar because I think that it's the only fair thing to do.

4:31:15 And I applaud those that want to contribute to this because I think it's important to get those people here and to maintain and bring more people because it makes it a very viable community if that's the case. Public speaking is not my forte. Thank you for your time. Thank you, Kirk.

4:31:44 Good evening once again. Terry Stellick. I do have a small lodging business, season four, and I also am on the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, just so I'm kind of clear. Also a recreation commissioner. So I wear a few different hats, but I've also lived in this town since I was 11 years old. That's a couple years ago. And I graduated from the school, watched my parents. My parents were in the lodging business prior to me. And there's no way anybody can say that we don't need to market ourselves.

4:32:13 Mammoth Mountain is a private business. And if we all relied on Mammoth Mountain to do the marketing here, there wouldn't be any small businesses in this community. We have to market ourselves. And the reason that we have a tourism organization, a tourism marketing organization, is to take care of and market the entire community, not one entity.

4:32:38 You know, obviously had some disagreements with Rusty. But Mammoth Mountain is our main attraction, especially in the wintertime. And they're a big attraction in the summertime along with everything else that why we moved here. There's, you know, beauty. When we started Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we did a lot of research, looked at where our marketing dollars were. We were one of the lowest resorts around as far as what we were doing to market ourselves. We have to market against our peer resorts.

4:33:08 And unfortunately, as much as we all hate it, you know, I would love things to be cheaper. Unfortunately, that's not reality. So reality is that we need the money to market ourselves. We need people here for our roads. If we didn't have tourism, tourism is our industry. We wouldn't need roads. We wouldn't need parks. We wouldn't be here because we couldn't live here. When I moved here, there were no hospitals. There wasn't a hospital. There was a small doctor's office. You know, all of these things, the school came.

4:33:37 You know, I went to the first year of Mammoth High School was built and I was in sixth grade. So all of these things, the infrastructure that we all enjoy is because that we have a healthy tourist industry. So you can argue, you know, the economy's been tough. We've had a couple tough years. But I remember a time when we had a couple tough years and there was a sign out there that says, last one out, turn out the lights. We haven't been there because we do have a marketing organization.

4:34:04 And it is successful. I have great trust in what John and his team has done. And I have, you know, kind of probably a little more insight about that than some others have had. And it's kind of nice because that tourism board, the Mammoth Lakes Tourism Board, actually has a great diverse group on that board so that it is representing many different people within this community.

4:34:30 It's kind of like having a baby, you know. You can plan all you want, but it's really never the right time. So is this the right time for this? You know, I think it is because we need to be in control of our own destiny. So thank you. Thank you, Terry. Paul, how you doing, sir? You guys must be getting fired. Not us, Paul. My name is Paul Rudder. I'm a commercial property owner. I wish we could do things the way we did.

4:35:10 Back in the 1970s when Mammoth Mountain was the largest ticket-selling organization in the United States, it's a much more competitive world effort. And I think that's probably fairly obvious. We have to do more. More people have to contribute to do it. One of the things that I've heard tonight a number of times, and believe me, I understand nobody likes taxes. Nobody likes, excuse me, nobody likes to pay taxes. They're an unpleasant fact of life.

4:35:39 They say the only two sure things are debt and taxes. But I did hear a lot of people say that the town looks galactic. And that hurts me personally, and I'm sure it hurts all of you on the town council. The truth of the matter, though, is business in Mammoth Lakes faces a huge challenge, much greater than many other places. We have, out of 52 weeks in a year, 17 of those or more are shoulder seats.

4:36:08 So that leaves us with about 35 weeks to do business. And of those 35 weeks, we get to do business on two or three days a week. If we have a successful marketing program, and we can get one more day on average per week of business, if we can have three or four days a week of business instead of two or three, the merchants in town, the landowners, will have the money to be able to fix up the way it looks and make it look

4:36:38 One of the ways we can acquire that is simply to be better at putting our name out there to the public that, for instance, as Phil pointed out, only 28% of them in Southern California thinks about Mammoth. That's disastrous for us. We have to have people in Southern California thinking about us when they think scheme.

4:37:09 They should think Mammoth Mountain first. They should think the town of Mammoth Lakes first. And the only clear path to improvement right now is to increase our market. So as reluctant as I am, as I'm sure you are, to endorse more taxes, that's the only thing that's on the plate right now. That's the only thing that's available. I wish there were other things.

4:37:35 And I hope that when there is more money around, and I know this will happen, we'll do things to improve the look of the town. And then we'll be spiraling up. A town can go one of two ways. It can spiral up or it can spiral down. We're on the edge of something now. It'll be one way or the other. Thank you. Thank you, Paul. Hey, Paul, I got a question for you. And I don't want to put you on the spot, but it occurs to me. Oh, go right ahead. And I know you can handle it.

4:38:05 The mountain does a million skier visits, but at one time it did a million five. Do you think that when it was doing a million five businesses had more money to spend on spiffing up their properties? That's a very good question and it's kind of a tough question because at the time the mountain had a million five, I didn't own anything.

4:38:31 I will tell you this, though, from a historical perspective. When I arrived in eastern Sierra in, well, I came here in 1975. I moved to Mammoth in 81 as a bishop. In 81, rent for commercial space was a buck and a quarter. We are now 30 years past that, and rent for commercial space is a buck and a quarter. On a dollar and a quarter,

4:39:02 Building costs today for commercial space are three to four to five hundred dollars a square foot. You cannot afford on a dollar and a quarter of income to build a building to house someone that costs you three or four hundred dollars to build. It can't be done. And that's why Mammoth doesn't look as attractive as we'd like it to because when you get a buck and a quarter, it doesn't leave very much to improve your building width. You're hanging on. You're just paying your mortgage.

4:39:31 If you're doing that. So that's the difficulty we face. And the T-bid, as much as nothing that raises taxes is ever going to receive an outpouring of love, the T-bid is something that can help us to get more, when we have more business, people can afford to pay more money in rent, building owners that have their own business in the building will have more money that they can spend on their building,

4:40:01 We can make Mammoth look better. But it's a simple fact of just doing more business. We have to go through that to get to where we all want to be and have this town look like it should. So I hope that answers your question. That's the logical answer. But we did more business once. And so the question in my mind is have we in this decline that we've experienced over the years, have we...

4:40:34 Are we different from when we were at a million five skiers? And I don't know the answer. We were building buildings. Most of the shopping centers here in town, the large ones, were all built in the years 80 to 82. Since that time, there hasn't been a great deal of construction because you can't make it pencil. You can't make any economic sense out of it. Today in Aspen or Vail,

4:41:03 Rents are not a dollar and a quarter a square foot. They are on the order of $15 a foot. They all can afford to look really, really nice. If I was getting $15 a foot on my rental space, I could, you know, I could gold plate the outside of the building and have it look like the Taj Mahal. But there aren't any merchants in town that could afford to pay that. You were just putting...

4:41:31 There was a fellow who owned the Sierra Center for a little while, and he raised the rent to $2 a foot and was out of business in about two years. Merchants here can't, they just simply can't afford to pay more. So it puts us in this situation of being squeezed from both sides. We are going to spend a great deal of money at the Sierra Center making it look better. Because when we came to the plate, we said, if we don't arrive with money to make that place look better, we'll never do it from the rents that we're going to get.

4:42:02 So we've got to do it up front. So we're going to do that. But, you know, God willing, things will get better. And we're making an investment in the belief and the hope that it'll get better. I think that it will. But if it doesn't, 40 years, have worked like dogs to stay alive, not to get rich. Very, very few people in the house get rich. They work like crazy to enjoy the lifestyle, to just be able to stay here and raise their kids in a decent environment.

4:42:36 And go to the local high school and that sort of thing. It's not about making a zillion dollars. It doesn't happen here. Because there isn't a zillion dollars to be made. Maybe with an effective T-Bid that John Urdi will lead, we can make enough money to be able to pay employees more, to have health care, and to fix up our buildings and have the basic things that Mammoth really should be able to enjoy. Because everyone here, everyone in this room, the people who are against the T-Bid, the people who are for it,

4:43:05 Every single one of them works very, very hard. Someone who owns a restaurant works 60 hours a week. And so do most of the other business owners in town. As business owners, the virtue of it, gee, you get to work 60 hours a week. That's terrific. But that's the effect of life in Mammoth Lakes. Thanks. You're welcome. Thank you, Paul.

4:43:31 One more quick turn. One thing is I don't think our people that live in town support the town. I don't think people shop local as much as they could. I think people are shopping out of town. I think that's a big case. I'm down about 25 percent from what I was a number of years ago, and I don't know why, and it's not advertising and everything else. I've got the same customers over and over, and everybody else, I'm in yellow pages. People say, I don't even know a place. How can you advertise? And rent, I can't afford a store.

4:43:59 Not with my small business. And another thing about the tax you want to charge, I think it's really wrong. I think my business license is only $50 and you want to charge me 10 times that just for this tax thing and my business license is enough. I don't think I should go over that business license if you're that small a business. I just don't think that I, and I'm 90% service. I know other service places are not, locksmiths are being hit with this.

4:44:29 And like I just said, everybody that benefits, lawyers, everybody makes a benefit if there's more people here coming into town and everything else. But they're not hit. Only business people are. Business people are generous. I donate gift certificates for all the charities. I go around for other charities that I'm working for. And I collect the business people are generous.

4:44:53 They give us meals. They give us prizes. They give us everything, all for good causes, for hospice and all the other ones. So we do a lot of that work. I'm with the American Legion. I'm with the United We Ride. We do charity work every year. We do a lot of that work. But the businesses are very generous in this way. So I think we ought to try and support our local businesses and not shop out of town. That's why there's so many empty stores. That doesn't look good in a town. When you come into town, it looks like a ghost town either. That makes a...

4:45:22 A bad look. Maybe it isn't as fancy, but don't see a lot of empty stores. Everybody thinks the town is leaving. Okay. Thank you, Gene. I'm Tom Barnes. I'm Mammoth's Bar Creations, which really is great, but I'm more here as a concerned citizen. Most of you know, for 32 years, I worked for Vons. We've entailed retail sales in here, but we haven't...

4:45:54 They recluded Bonds, right way, and these other corporations into this plan. As far as I know, no one at Bonds has been contacted, I was told. And they responded back? Is it good? Okay, then my whole concern is gone. Yeah, but a quarter there, a third there, I need to sell a taxable. And it's just what I was told was, there was a sit back and wait and turn over to the corporate attorneys.

4:46:26 So, okay. Never mind. Thanks, Tom. Is there anybody else in the audience who wanted to speak this item? Okay. Howard? Gone through everybody. Howard Pickett from the Mountain Ski Area. And I think all of you guys know my advocacy for this, so I'm not going to be standing up here advocating for the TBID because I'm very much in favor of it. I think it's the right thing to do. I think...

4:46:56 Rick, you asked a very good question a few moments ago about what's different now between 2005 and we had a million six-year visits and people were all over town and everybody's business was great. The world has changed and that's really hard. I've been in a lot of industries. I've been in the theme park industry, the hotel industry. I've been in a lot of places where the world changed and it took a while for people to really understand that the world had in fact changed. You couldn't just stand back and rely on word of mouth to drive people here anymore. What's happened since 2005?

4:47:25 Our core market of Los Angeles used to sit and watch their houses appreciate 20%, 30% a year. I know. I live there. I used to take that money and take two, three, four, five vacations a year. You can't do that anymore. Our competitors, Vail Resorts in 2005 and 2006 didn't have the Epic Pass program that they've got now. All of a sudden, they've got three, four hundred thousand people in that program by some counts that are being marketed to to go to all the different Vail Resorts.

4:47:54 We're in the most expensive media market in the country. And if we don't have a voice down there, all the good things that are good about Mammoth, the great skiing, the great community, all the great businesses that are here, if you can't tell people about it, it doesn't matter. And that's what really fundamentally has changed is pretty much everybody is in the Southern California market. It's three million very affluent skiers that everybody wants to compete for. And if we don't have the money,

4:48:21 To be in that market to compete with those people, then just close the doors because you're not going to just sit back and not spend any money and not drive people to Mammoth while everybody else is spending tons and tons of money. I mean, I've been the CMO at the Mountain for five or six years and I can't tell you how many people who live in Southern California are constantly beating my brains out because they don't see enough of our advertising. It's because we don't have enough money to compete with the people that are down there. This is a small step.

4:48:50 In the right direction of really getting out there and having the money to grow our business and to get back to a million six and hopefully even more skiers than that so that everybody can profit by what that brings, which is all those people and all that revenue and all that visitation. So no matter what we do, we've got to find a way to get some money, more money than what we've had to get into the market. We've committed from the mountain standpoint. We're going to continue to spend and grow our spending, but we've got to have help.

4:49:19 There's nobody, Disney, any of those people, you look at all of them, they all depend on their own marketing monies, plus they depend on the marketing monies from the local DMOs and the CVBs and the state organizations. We've got to step up and we've got to put that money in place so that we can be competitive in that market and grow the business. Thank you. Thank you, Howard. Anybody else? Okay. Seeing none, I...

4:49:46 Just wanted, yeah, Jo. Just one thing before we close out on this issue is that due to some family obligations, I will not be here at the July 3rd meeting. So I wanted to know, first of all, if it is possible to move the public hearing and if it was, does Council want to do that or does Council want to go ahead on the 3rd? I believe the hearing was noticed for that date specifically. So if you abandoned that date entirely, we'd have to re-notice it. What the Council could do...

4:50:15 Is open the hearing, take testimony, and then continue the hearing to another date that you might be available. Okay. Could it be done before the testimony was given so that I would be able to hear the testimony? Again, this is just rhetorical because I haven't asked my fellow members up here yet. That's a Parliamentary procedure question. I don't know the answer to it off the top of my head. I mean, usually if you open a hearing, you have to take some testimony. Otherwise, you haven't really opened a hearing. Well, if you could guarantee me that the Granicus would be working that night. Okay, so then.

4:50:43 The question is, would my fellow council members be willing to take the deliberation part to another date? And what impact would that have on the timing of all this? I know it's going to run for five years, so I'm essentially asking the question, would two weeks make a difference? I'm wondering if one of the Johns could let us know. Is there a problem with moving it from a legal standpoint on...

4:51:14 Or I guess having. Well, what I'm saying is if you had and you took testimony, but if you delayed the deliberation because we've extended public hearings before, what would be the impact over the five years for moving it back two weeks? Well, it wouldn't necessarily be over the five years. I think the impact would be that the plan was after July 3rd to be able to put this in place by August 1, giving us almost a month to educate and train people on it.

4:51:41 I think if we move that to, I don't know what the next meeting would be. So maybe it would be mid-August? Okay. Right. But again, the challenge there is that August is really our bread and butter summer month. So we lose the opportunity to keep collecting during that time. Okay. And I'm going in the middle of July at that meeting. Okay. Can you phone in? No, that's not going to be possible where I will be. I guess we'll have to think about that and come up with something on there.

4:52:14 Anybody else have any comments on that? I just want to say thank you to everybody for coming in tonight. I know this is one of those topics that's passionate on both ends, and I think we can all see both sides of it, and I think we have a lot to digest, and just really appreciate you coming in. I know it can be frustrating at times, so I just want to say thank you.

4:52:44 Look forward to seeing you guys at the next meeting. With that, we'll go ahead and adjourn. Thank you.