TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2013

Planning & Economic Development Commission Special meeting

· recording 3 hr 2 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

375 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Oh, thank goodness, thank goodness. Damn, thank you. Turned out well, thank you. It wasn't?

0:31 Oh, no. Well, thank you very much. It's a great printer. What? Very well. Thank you. Appreciate it. Testing. Good afternoon. Welcome to the Planning and Economic Development Commission special meeting of Wednesday, June 26th here.

1:15 At this time, I'll take the roll call. Pam. Commissioner Hardy. Here. Commissioner Kenney. Here. Vice Chair Brown. Here. Chair Dugan. Here. And Commissioner Fernie had an excused absence, I believe he's out of town at this time. If you'll all rise and join me in the pledge of allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America.

1:48 And to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. Please be seated. This time is our public comment session that provides members of the public to come forward and speak on anything that is not on the agenda. So if you do have something that is not on today's agenda, and I believe that there's a copy at the back there, please come to the podium.

2:20 State your name for the record. We are being filmed and on a mic, so we do need to know your name. And this is anything that's not already on the agenda today. If I could have you please limit your comments to five minutes at this, because we have a lengthy agenda and we want to hear everyone that wants to speak. Thank you. Any public comment at this time? If not, we'll close the public comment section.

2:51 The general public comment section. And now we're going to move on to public hearings. This, and this is how, if none of you have been here, this is how we like to proceed with the public hearing. And I'll open the public hearing, which I'm doing right now. We'll get a statement and a presentation from staff. And then we have a statement or a presentation from the property owner. And then the Planning Commission asks questions.

3:15 Questions, not, does not opine, but they ask questions of staff and possibly the property owner at that time. And then we call for testimony, people who want to speak. And everyone that would like to speak will have a chance to. We do have very many letters. We read all of those before we go here, before this is open. So if you would like to have your letter speak for itself, that's fine. You don't need to reiterate that.

3:44 There, but we do have, we have, do have those for the record, and know, and know that you have voiced opinion one way or another. Then we, after those who wish to speak, we do have an opportunity for rebuttal from the applicant or clarification on any issues from staff. Then we close the public hearing, we deliberate on the matter, and we make a decision as it pertains to that day.

4:13 So if all of that is started, I mean, if all of that's very clear, let's get started. Do, for public hearing number one, to consider approval of tentative parcel map 11-001, the Danko parcel map to subdivide 70 Carter Street into two lots. Our staff contact today is Jen Daugherty and

4:39 For, she's associate planner, and then we will hear from others on, as well as people to, and staff members to help assist her. Jen, take it away. Madam Chair, I'll have to refuse myself on this. Thank you. Thanks. Thank you, Chair Dugan. The proposed subdivision today is to divide approximately two and a half acres of a property along Old Mammoth Road, Tamarack Street, and Carter Street.

5:08 into two lots. Wetlands are located on a substantial portion of this property. In 1994, the required environmental review and permitting was conducted to construct a single-family home, a garage and tack room, and horse corral. Off-site wetland mitigation was required for this development. The proposed lots meet the minimum lot standards and requirements for the rural residential zone and the equestrian overlay.

5:35 The lot would be divided between the existing residence and the garage tack room. Both parcels would provide buildable sites that meet minimum code requirements and would avoid the wetland area. No construction is proposed at this time. Originally, when this tentative parcel map came into the town, the applicant was proposing a three lot subdivision. The three lot subdivision would require

6:02 area of the wetland to be filled to create buildable pads for construction. After realizing the owner, I think, can speak on his behalf, but the owner ended up on his own volition deciding to reduce the subdivision to only two lots. Splitting the lot would result in some non-conforming issues. Splitting the lot would result in

6:25 An accessory structure, the garage and tack room being located on a parcel alone, in other words, an accessory structure without a primary structure, we've proposed to address that through conditions of approval. That would also result in the single family home on parcel one not having the required parking necessary pursuant to code, and so we have included conditions of approval that would require those to be corrected prior to the final map being recorded.

6:56 An addendum to the mitigated negative declaration, which is the environmental review for this site, was prepared. The proposal was reviewed with Army Corps of Engineers, Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board, Department of Fish and Wildlife, the Fire District, Water District and other agencies.

7:15 The mitigation measures that have been included in the environmental review include the requirement that if there was any disturbance outside of the already disturbed area, in other words in the wetland, that consultation with Lahontan Army Corps Fish and Game would be required and the required permitting and analysis process be gone through and possibly if that was approved then offsite mitigation would likely be required.

7:44 Public improvements and dedications are also required with this map. That includes a substantial amount of right-of-way along Tamarack Street and Old Mammoth Road, including space for a bus turnout and, I believe, a shelter as well. It also includes adding a fire hydrant or dry yard pipe system, which would improve the fire response capacity in that area.

8:09 As you know, as the Chair mentioned, we've received numerous comment letters, many of them focused on the protection of the wetlands of this site. This lot split does not propose any disturbance to the wetlands and provides billable sites within the already disturbed area. There's nothing on title or any agreements that prohibit the subdivision of this property. There's also nothing on title that prohibits the disturbance of the wetlands.

8:35 We have discussed requiring the protection of the wetlands with our town attorney, and he does not believe that there is clear nexus that would allow the town to mandate this requirement with the proposed map. Therefore, staff recommends that the commission adopt option one, which is adopting the required CEQA findings and consideration of the addendum to grading plan check 9401, initial study mitigated negative declaration, that's the environmental review,

9:04 Adopt the required subdivision map act findings. Those are the findings required under state law for maps and subdivisions. And approve the tentative parcel map 11-001 with conditions as recommended or with modifications as directed by the commission. And with that, I'd be happy to take any questions that you have. Also, the property owner and applicant, Mr. Jim Danhockle, is also here to make a statement.

9:34 Okay, thank you. Does anyone have any questions, Elizabeth, or of staff regarding the presentation we just saw? I noticed in the parcel map showing the buildable area, which is the disturbed area. Could you clarify for us how much of that area can be used? Can you build up right to the top of the four foot, you know, filled area, right to the very edge of it?

10:06 Or do you have to be set back from the edge of it because of erosion, because of disturbances with landscaping, that sort of stuff? How much of a buffer do you have to have between the wetlands delineation and the buildable area? On the map it looks like it's right there. Well actually the buildable area is set back from the wetland delineation. There is a slope between where the wetlands are delineated and the area that's already been disturbed. Do you know how far back? I wasn't able to read it.

10:35 I may defer to Triad who prepared the plans to scale it appropriate. Actually, I have the map down there and we can get that. We'll get that dimension for you. But Lahontan and Army Corps are the ones that will look stringently at the development boundaries. And what they have said is that any disturbance that exceeds the current disturbed area would require their consultation. I think likely if there was any development that was...

11:02 Getting close in that gray area, we would absolutely consult with those agencies. And that would include landscaping? Or just the foundation of a future building? I think any disturbance that could have a potential impact on the wetland, yeah. Okay, thank you. Jen, for my benefit and for the benefit of the audience, would you mind showing us explicitly on the map where the new proposed build pad is?

11:41 Commission person, I'll show the public. Here's a large-scale print of the property. The lot split is, the line is right here, which is in between the existing single-family home and the taproom garage. This area here that you see in a half circle here, that's the area that was filled for the horse corral.

12:05 So that is already disturbed area. Then you see there's this slope here that separates that corral from here where the delineated wetlands are. Okay. Did that answer you? Maybe. Fine. So here's the property. We've got Tamarack Street and Mammoth Road. Here's the existing single-family home. Here's a tap room with a garage. This split is proposed to go in between those two buildings.

12:38 This half circle here is the area that was built for the horse corral. That's the existing disturbed area that's shown with the measurements as what's called buildable area. Then here, with a bit of a buffer here, is where there's a need. Okay. And what's the approximate size of the disturbed area? A little under half an acre. And what would be the building site for the new parcel too?

13:16 The building site would be required to be a minimum of 2,000 square feet. They've got approximately 7,000 square feet. So, I noticed that we have three non-conforming issues that we discussed that could possibly be conditioned for. I was wondering if the council or commission had any precedent about having non-conforming issues that related to existing buildings, such as the tack room, garage.

13:49 In my experience, I don't recall a situation where we've had a condition that would require, say, an entire building to be either demolished or converted. We have dealt with other nonconformities, but in my experience, I just don't recall anything that's that significant. Okay. Snow Creek 8 development, in that configuration, there was a lot line that was going to go through the middle of a building, and that

14:22 In that case, they had to remove the building prior to that portion of the map recording. No maps have recorded yet on Snow Creek Gate. It's just a tentative map. Yeah. And so the Carter Street, is that a privately maintained street or is that a maintained by the town of Mammoth Lakes? It is privately maintained. All right. It's a private street. And then I noticed that we now have a set of CC&Rs. So is there a maintenance agreement in that CC&Rs? Do you know? I mean,

14:57 And perhaps I'll let the property owners speak to that. They're the parties of that agreement. But they have an agreement for the maintenance and costs of the maintenance of Carter Street between the existing property owners that have access off of Carter Street. And then I just really want to make sure that I'm clear then. So the current opinion of the town attorney is that there is no direct nexus between

15:26 The developer site and then asking the applicant to either put some sort of conservation easement or have some sort of condition saying that there would be no further development on the wetland part of the parcel. Is that correct? That's correct. The town attorney's opinion is that based on what's being proposed with the tentative map, which is a subdivision into two properties that provides for buildable areas that would avoid

15:53 Would allow for the avoidance of wetland and the fact that Army Corps and Lahontan have jurisdiction and regulations over those wetlands for protection, that there wasn't a clear nexus for the town to be able to mandate that as a requirement of this map. Do you want additional questions at this time? Did you have anything? No, that's all. Thank you. So at this time, if there's no other questions at staff, we'd like to hear from the applicant.

16:27 Is she okay? Please, yes. State your name for the record. My name is Jim Don Hockel. I am a part owner of the land in question. It was originally purchased by my brother back in 2001. Anyhow, I wanted to, first of all, thank you to the commission for allowing me to speak, and thank you staff for preparing your report. It's very thorough. It's been a long time coming. Thank you for interested members of the public that are here.

16:57 The first thing I wanted to say, I hope you don't mind, do you need this for the recording or can I just talk? No, you have to. Well, then I'm going to turn this this way because I think half of my presentation is directed at the people who are most concerned, okay? The first thing I want to get out before I talk about the specifics is that we share, when I say we, I'm talking my brother and myself, we share your concerns about this meadow. This is a beautiful,

17:28 Peace. It's a jewel. It's a gem inside Mammoth. I think that many people may have had the mistaken impression that greedy landowners were going to subdivide and throw condos up in our beautiful meadow there. And that never was the intention. It is not the intention. And to speak further to that, we have specifically guarded against that and work to protect what's there and keep it there.

17:58 And that has been our intent all along. This has been an eight-year process. It started in 2005 with the simple idea of adding value to our land. Nothing else. There was never an intention to spin it off, sell it, build a hotel. Nothing like that of the sort. Here we are eight years later, and that is still our intent. There's no, right now, intention to sell the land. We do have in-house a renter who has expressed interest.

18:24 He can't afford to buy the whole piece, but if it was a smaller section, he might be able to afford the house. So that was one of the things that we were thinking of. But there is no plan, although I have been approached by different entities that did want to buy the land. We took this eight years ago. It started with just approaching the city and saying, hey, is this something that's feasible? Is it doable?

18:51 And we're told that it was, but it would probably be a long road process. So we started this process, and for me it really began, what do we have? Let's survey the land. So we did that. And then it quickly became apparent that, hey, we've got this beautiful meadows. People have called it a wetlands in the past. Let's hire some environmental consultants. We used resource concepts up there in Carson to come down and take a look at it.

19:20 When they looked at it back in the 06-07 timeframe, it was a very, we had had a period of dryness. There was not a lot of moisture in the soil. It was late summer when they came down and looked at it. It was basically dry as a bone. For something to be considered a wetlands in non-coastal regions, it has to have wetlands hydrology, wetlands soils, and wetlands vegetation.

19:45 It had one of those. It had the soils, but it did not have the hydrology or the vegetation. So at that point, people told me, hey, good on you. You know, you can go ahead and press as though this was not a wetlands, and you can get a report to say this is not a wetlands. But in my heart, I knew that was not true because I have seen it on wet years. I've seen it after the snow melt. And I just know that nature may have its ups and downs.

20:14 But it always comes back to the middle. And I knew that this was probably a wet time. So I kind of basically put this on hold for a couple years, waited until we had a wet year, and then called the consultants back after the snow melt at the wettest time of the year, and then had them look at it. And sure enough, as I suspected, there were wetlands soils, wetlands hydrology, and wetlands vegetation.

20:44 Was that if I achieved a subdivision of the land without a wetlands delineation, that a new owner, if we ever did sell this land, a new owner could then come forward with a plan to throw condos or further subdivide or build something that was totally out of character for what the town wants and the citizens want and what, frankly, we wanted as well, which is to preserve what we have.

21:14 So, we got a wetlands delineation, primarily for the purpose of preserving the land. We also, and some of you will remember, we used to have horses running around there. And I know that it's a zoned equestrian area. Those of you that are familiar with horses know that they just completely tear our land to pieces. And our horses were beginning to do that.

21:42 So we removed the horses not because we stopped riding but because we didn't want to destroy the land. We thought it would look prettier when grass was allowed to grow and it just looked nice. So that was our plan all along was to protect this property. That said, we went to the next process which was to develop a map.

22:05 And the map that, you know, is what we eventually came out with. You see the buildable area. It's a part that's upland. It's very noticeable. It's complete. It's basically a plateau. And it's a very small area of the entire parcel that you're looking at. You can see that the tack room is already built there, and there's been some discussion. We haven't made any agreement or mitigation to do this.

22:32 I honestly can't see how somebody's going to be able to build a house there and not demo that tack room. I think that tack room's going to get demoed if anybody builds a house. So effectively, from a view standpoint, anybody driving down Old Mammoth or the Bouchers, you're still going to have your beautiful meadow. It's not going to change. In fact, it's going to be more and more pristine.

22:58 The only thing, instead of having a tack room that you're looking at now, it'll be a slightly larger footprint and have a house on there as well. So once we had the map developed, we took it around to all the different boards that we talked about, Fish and Game, Army Corps of Engineers, Lahotten Water Quality, Regional District. We also took it back to the town and we asked what their thoughts and inputs were. So they gave us a list of

23:30 requirements, qualifications for us to meet and just methodically over the time, over the months and years, we just methodically went through them and agreed to the things that we thought that we could afford to agree to. One of those, and I want to make it clear, we have given up quite a bit. We gave, we put a bus turnaround zone into the old Mammoth, so we gave up about 6,000 square feet of that. We also

23:56 Gave up 18,000 square feet along Tamarack, which enables the road to be re-centered essentially onto our land, or what is now our land. Right now we own the land pretty much all of Carter Street, but we're giving that away. We also agreed to put in a fire hydrant. If this is to get, if the map actually, if somebody actually starts to build on it, we're going to put a fire hydrant on Carter Street, which doesn't exist now.

24:25 That's not just a boon for us, but it's a boon for anybody that lives there because it provides quite a bit of fire protection. Right now there is none. So step by step, we have gone through this. We've complied with every request. I guess the one thing that we probably didn't do, which frankly I was kind of surprised by all the comment that came in,

24:52 And we probably could have done a better job of including, you know, knocking on doors and talking to neighbors and maybe including their input if for nothing else and to maybe assuage the fear that we were going to go and build something that nobody wants there. So our goal is to add a little value for us but also to preserve and protect what the town has right now.

25:20 And I think that we've achieved a pretty good balance between property rights and the valid concerns of the citizens of Mammoth Lakes. So, once again, Jen, I know you put a lot of work into this and the rest of the staff. Thank you very much. Thank you, commissioners. I look forward to answering any questions you have. And thank you for your consideration. I have one question. Sir? Dan, if you want to come forward.

25:49 We just have a couple questions. Sure, you bet. Can you just clarify, I know that this tentative tract map shows an easement on Tamarack, but did you also say you're giving an easement on, what was your comment about Carter Street? On Carter Street, if you look at the property line right now, our land includes all of Carter Street. I'm Gary from Triad, and the dedications are Tamarack.

26:24 As Jim said, to re-center, you know, and basically cover that pavement in a dedication, and also along Old Mammoth Road for a new bus shelter, bus turnaround. So those are the dedications. And then what happens to Carter Street? Carter Street remains unchanged. Okay. Thank you. I have a question.

26:53 Gary, can I ask you, why is there a bus turnaround on Old Mammoth Road, the bus goes up to Red Fur and turns around, it's already a place. I'd like to, maybe I can clarify what that really is for. It'll be a bus turnout, similar to what we have along... Turnout. Turnout. But we have a long golf course in that area. There won't be a bus shelter at that location. Thank you. Any other questions at this time? No, thank you. Thank you very much. So given the...

27:27 Input from the applicant. Now is the time that we would like to hear from the public. And a lot of times there will be a request for pros and cons. At this point, let's just hear from whoever would like to speak. Then please come to the podium, state your name for the record. And if you can, please hold your comments for three minutes. And remember, we do have all your information as well. First.

28:10 Hi, my name is Jeff Boucher. This is my nightmare, public speaking. I'm not sure if the Dawn Hockels are aware of how many people cherish that meadow and don't want to see it disturbed. It's, in a very short period of time, we've had a lot of people rally to support the preservation of the meadow.

28:39 With more time, I think we'd have a lot more people rally to the cause to make sure that that meadow stays as it is. Jim, you stated that the footprint would increase slightly, and I don't know how big slightly is. I understand a tack room may go away, and we may be looking at a house. We can live with that if there's some teeth put in into the title.

29:09 that says there won't be further subdivisions, because currently, as I understand it, talking to Army Corps, after you, if you were granted this subdivision, you could subdivide again and put in another half-acre footprint, and once again, you could subdivide one more time with another half-acre footprint, and if we get something entitled that has some teeth to it that that can't happen, my opposition will go away.

29:40 But we want to make sure that that property stays as it is. One thing by subdividing it, you're losing the biggest equestrian zone parcel in Old Mammoth, or in Mammoth. And I understand the horses may be disturbing, but it was a pleasure having them there. We really enjoyed them. Also in our letter, we did make a mistake. We said that there was a signed sales agreement, and that signed agreement was between

30:09 Tinsley, Jarvis, and Army Corps and all the other entities. That was our mistake in our letter. I wanted to clarify that. So if we can get rid of the possibility to subdivide and subdivide more footprints, we'd be on board with you. Right now, there's not one person on the town staff or the commission that was involved when this original agreement happened. Karen Johnston was the lead person.

30:40 with the Tinsley Jarvis development, and I think it'd behoove, maybe you've already talked to her, but if you haven't, I think it'd behoove getting a hold of her and getting her on board to see what information she might have with the previous agreements. Most everybody's been under this misconception that that meadow would not be touched. People that live there, people that have bought across the street in that Hooper four-plex division.

31:07 They were all told that that could not be developed, obviously erroneously. Army Corps of Engineers did return my phone call. Lahontan did not. Fish and Game did not. So that's about all I have. Thank you very much. Questions? No. Thank you. Anyone else? I think it turns. We're not sure. My name is David Smith. I'm a property owner on Carter Street.

31:53 First, these are just some issues collected among our neighbors. They're just little bullets to be entered. Access in Carter Street, which I'll get back to. It's our easement agreement for the four lots. Carter Street was abandoned by the town. We requested that it be that way. It was vacated.

32:23 For, and I'll keep repeating that so you understand and get the picture of this, there were four lots that we took over that easement agreement and when they abandoned upon request. Now, it's not set up for five, six, seven lots, it's four. So, as far as ownership of Carter Street,

32:52 It's basically owned by the four lots, not by one lot, not by two, by four. And the map, the triad put together for us, shows that on the abandonment process, which this is the resolution, I believe, is in your packet about vacating it. And it is now referred to as it.

33:23 Private road or a private driveway. So the four lots control it. All four lots have to be in agreement on anything that is being done to that road. The maintenance of the road, the snow removal, everything else that goes with that road, that's our responsibility among the four lots within this, which you just received.

33:51 The CCNRs. The creation of these, oh, before I get ahead of myself. So anything that's going to be done with Carter Street at all has to be in agreement with all the four lots, not five. And you're going to create a fifth lot. And that fifth lot doesn't, according to our CCNRs,

34:23 Unless the agreement is made among the four lots, that fifth lot does not have access over or to that private road. The other thing that was brought up was, and you basically addressed it, but being here for the time that I've been, I can see that sometimes this, as Mr. Rouchet, my neighbor, pointed out,

34:53 If it doesn't have some teeth in it somewhere, I have witnessed good intentions just slowly heading down the wrong path that was never intentioned about lot splitting. So here we have a creation of, you're going to, by splitting that, you're going to create two non-conforming lots simply by the structures of themselves. Okay, now,

35:22 Yeah, you can say that, well, we'll come back later, we'll get that, we'll take care of this and that. That doesn't really, I'm not in favor of that kind of approach to anything that we'll get back to it. If you have conforming issues now and you're going to split it and now you've doubled those two conforming issues, no parking for the big house, only one covered space and not meeting minimum livable space footage for the,

35:53 Excuse me, tax slash garage. There's no additional easement footage, requires the majority of the four lot owners to change the CCNRs. There's no further subdivision or substandard streets, and this is regarding to Bill Taylor when he was the Planning Code Supervisor or Director.

36:19 Additional building footprints need to bring two lots into compliance in the loss of wetlands or potential loss of wetlands. And access to this lot, from what we know so far, is that the only access to this brand new lot that you're going to create has to come from Old Mammoth Road. You cannot use.

36:48 That private driveway for the fifth lot because it is not in the CC&Rs and it was never in the agreement in the first place. Now, yeah, if he wishes to split it, fine, but the establishment of the access, potential access to the next lot, the second lot, has already, well, it has some issues that it needs to deal with.

37:17 The four, the other three lot owners, as the CCNRs referred to, were not in favor of it at this time. It would simply be granted because we have things in place that were designed for the four lots. And again, he wishes to have that second lot.

37:45 I think the commission needs to at least take some time to look at, well, what is the possibility of accessing this type of plot. And this is also in there, but it's the Carter Street private easement, legal description of it.

38:09 So that'll help you. It shows then and the map that I have and I'm sure the other property owners have will show that where this easement actually exists or the road actually exists itself. Now, after all of that being said and stated, I would like to encourage the commissioners to

38:38 If you haven't already, take the time, come out, call one of us. We'll be glad to take you around and show you exactly what we're looking at as the property owners, the access to each lot that's there. Thank you. Dave, we have a question. So I just want to make sure

39:03 That I understand this correctly. So as far as the written agreement among the four of you, there's the easement and then there's your CCNRs? And are there any other written documentations about road maintenance or anything else? They're in the CCNR. We're responsible for the road maintenance of that, the upkeep of that.

39:31 That is something, the fourth lot, or the house in the meadow as we refer to it as. It's the fourth lot. It has all the information that the other three lots have. And there is in there,

39:51 Some headings of responsibility to that road in that each of the four lots are responsible to put it together. And unfortunately, the lot in the meadow has for the last two times we did maintenance on the road, which is basically patching any cracks or slurrying the road to keep the asphalt in place.

40:18 We paid for the asphalting of it, the bordering of the road, but the last two times, and we've done it three now since we've had it in place, the last two times of the house in the meadow has, the owner has basically decided, no, he's not going to pay his fair share. There was never any communication with any of us because we communicate.

40:44 Two, we have it all engineered out, who owes what, it's a progressive kind of thing. And after dealing with that kind of a property owner, I'm not really in the mood for it. Okay, but I do have one other question. So who are the other two property owners out of the four? It's obviously yourself, the applicant. The Bowers. Mm-hmm.

41:12 On the north side, knee, and the showers. Okay. Those are the four lots that he's done. All right. Thank you very much. Anything else, Elizabeth? Do you have any questions? Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else like to speak? There will be a chance afterwards for, you know, certain issues if you have rebuttal for certain issues if you want to keep notes on that. Yeah. I'm Tony Taylor.

41:50 I am a resident of the Bluffs. I heard mentioned earlier about the fact that an easement on the remainder of the meadow is not something that a town attorney suggests can be imposed in this situation. I also

42:20 I believe I understand the applicant, Mr. Dan Hackle, saying that his interest is in maintaining the meadow that remains the open meadow. So there is the possibility that as this project moves forward that he could voluntarily put an easement, a permanent easement on the land to assure that

42:49 That he, his ownership, and any future ownership would not be able to do that, and I think that would satisfy some of the concerns of the adjacent property owners. I've been involved with the Eastern Sierra Land Trust for 12 years, and we have done small projects like this. I can't commit that the land trust would be involved, but I have talked to our land director.

43:20 and about it and we've looked it over and so that would be one possibility but we're not the only potential holders of the easement. The town can hold an easement, the county can hold an easement. So there are other ways to do this that I think would respond to the concerns of some of the people that are speaking here today and some of the letters that you have. That's all I have.

43:45 Thank you. Tony, could I ask a couple questions? You're talking about a conservation easement? Yes. And that goes with the title, right? That's correct. It goes with the land even when it's sold. And how permanent is that? That is in perpetuity. In perpetuity? Yeah. Okay, are there any advantages to the property owner for a conservation easement other than peace in the neighborhood and aesthetics? Are there financial advantages? Well, there...

44:12 There is one advantage, and this is well known in the land trust world that we're a part of here in the United States, and that is that property that includes open space on it, that increases the value of that property. And if that's permanent open space, as an easement would ensure, then yes, it does have a

44:41 A positive effect on the value of the land. In your experience, are there any tax advantages to having a conservation easement on property? Tax benefits, that varies by taxing district. Mona County and all of the work that we've done in Mona County has not honored a tax reduction because of an easement being put on the land. That's been our experience.

45:11 Okay, thank you. Any other questions? Thank you very much for your information. Anyone else like to come forward? Okay, don't all stormy. I'm really surprised. I thought everyone would speak. I'm Robin Morning, and I'd like to address as well, sort of. I'm speaking merely from an emotional standpoint, and I would first of all like to thank, is it Mr. I'm sorry, I can't pronounce your name.

46:02 Thank you for your efforts to say that you want to preserve that wetlands as is. And I want to believe that. I don't know you. I know you've gone through a lot of work and spent a lot of money to try to do this properly and that you want to have the value in the land that you've put into it.

46:29 And I understand that totally and I appreciate what you've said here. To the commission, I know that you weren't the commission when the medal was just the medal before Marcia or before Jarvis and Tinsley developed it. So my emotion against that ever having happened is not directed at you personally, but it's been done and

47:01 I don't want to see any more done. I feel that Mammoth has given up so many things in terms of development, which in one way has enhanced the town and the community, particularly the projects that have been done very nicely. I have immense respect for Tom Dempsey. I loved Tom Dempsey. I did not want to see him do any of his development, but he did a beautiful job.

47:31 So did some other people. So going along with seeing this happen through the years, I accept and accept and accept. But when I think of the possibility of any more of that meadow being, oh, Mammoth, the Tamarack meadow being gone, it raises something in me that I can't change. I would not forgive to go any further. When I heard about this, I thought I'm going to be emotional about it.

48:01 And I should find out a little bit of what I'm talking about. So I did go to the documents from the California Water Board and read this in my paper. I've included it. What you already know far better than I do, California's position on protecting wetlands. And it's very strong. And for this reason, I don't understand how the development ever came out in the beginning, Marcia and Ron's development.

48:32 So I take that strong feeling about protecting that, the rest of the metal, and I take the misgivings that if it were to be once again divided and once again divided, how that would be against California policy. So I encourage you to put the teeth in as has been suggested.

49:02 And to either not subdivide it but wait for the proper buyer or work with Tony Taylor and the Eastern Sierra Land Trust and try to increase the value of the property by protecting that open the metal as it is or by securing that it is absolutely in perpetuity not to be developed. And I think with that done that the community that's fighting you now would be very much behind you. Thank you.

49:35 Anyone else? I apologize on an incomplete answer I gave you, Elizabeth, to your question because I was thinking property taxes. In the case of an easement, there's a value being given by the landowner when they extinguish development rights. There obviously are potential future development rights on the meadow.

50:08 And were an easement to be written and agreed to, one option would be that the value of the difference of the developable land and the undevelopable land could be a gift to a nonprofit organization like the Land Trust. And that's a tax-deductible item. So there is that option, and I apologize for not mentioning that.

50:38 Before. I'm glad you came back up because I knew there was something, I wasn't quite sure how it worked. You know it better than I do. No, I don't know the intricacies of tax law at all, but I knew that there's a reason why people do that. Is the Williamson Act still in effect? Williamson still is in effect on, it's primarily agricultural land. But that is still in, so there's no application here with the Williamson Act? I don't think so. Okay, that's good news to hear it's still in effect. You know, okay, thank you for clarifying that, Tony. Thank you.

51:07 Anyone else would like to speak? My name is Susan Fairhoff, and I reside in Old Mammoth, and have for 37 years, and care very much about the uniqueness of Old Mammoth. I have a question, though. On Parcel 2, who owns the meadow? I mean, if this division takes place, then who owns it? Do both of those properties get a portion of it, or how is it, how is it, I mean, say the subdivision goes through, then how is the meadow divided between Parcel 1 and Parcel 2?

51:46 Essentially, the tentative map has a parcel line that bisects the parcel and everything on the north side is owned by parcel, by parcel two and everything on the side. It's somewhat parallel to Old Mammoth Road. And right now that would be the same owner. And right now it's the same owner. I guess my question too is,

52:19 And I do, I agree with Robin when she said that we know, I believe your heart that says you want to protect the meadow. I guess my question then would be if the present owner's only design is to make it possible to build one house where this tact room is or whatever, why not either deed restrict or

52:45 Make an agreement with town or better yet from what we've heard this gentleman propose an easement that would in perpetuity or whatever protect the meadow. I don't understand why that wouldn't be part of this whole package because it certainly would be a lot more palatable to all of us if it were. I have another question too.

53:13 This bus turnout, now, is that on Old Mammoth Road, or is it on Tamarack Street, or is there this bus turnaround place that's being granted? It would be located where currently there's a sign, bus stop sign, and it would be on Old Mammoth Road. Does that have to then land away from the meadow then to do that? No. Okay. It's adjacent to the existing pavement. Just a second, Sue. Peter, isn't the bus turnout on the west side of Tamarack? It's on the east side. The sign's located on the east side of Tamarack.

53:43 On the east side. It used to be on the west side. We moved it last year, I believe. Okay, I guess I hadn't noticed it was moved. I thought it was the west side. And then lastly, my concerns are with this mitigation of wetlands. And again, if there are no mandates, to me that's kind of scary because if this project is allowed to go ahead without any kind of easement or protection with deed restriction or whatever,

54:10 Anything could be mitigated. I mean, I didn't know that you could just, you know, take some wetland credits and buy some laurel pond, trade it for some laurel pond credits. I mean, to me, that's avoiding the whole issue of our communities of Mammoth Lakes, especially our communities in Old Mammoth. If everything can just be mitigated, okay, we have some credits here and we just, you know, buy something down there. Anybody can do that and reduce, constantly reduce, chip away and

54:38 Then it's gone. Anyway, that's all I have to say. Thank you. Thank you. Anyone else? Oh, okay. This is Kathleen Woodward. I live at One Skyline Place, which is one of the four houses right across from the meadow. Can you just clarify what she just asked? Is it true that if they develop, so you divide the property, and he demolishes the barn?

55:11 And builds a property there on the available space. And the footprint's very small if you walk there. Besides looking at the map, if you just walk across the street and look at it, if you built a house that was that large, those houses are almost budding up to each other. And nobody's going to want to buy a house right next to another house. And then they'd have a huge piece of land in front of it. It doesn't make a lot of sense from buying a piece of property's point of view. But if you can mitigate the wetlands.

55:39 Like she's talking about. It is in your 49-page report. And just go down to Crowley and mitigate it. You can get around the wetlands laws anytime you want. I can understand having wetland laws to protect our wetlands and maybe mitigate them for a whole town or a city for the benefit of a large citizenry. But to mitigate them for just one person's benefit cannot be why those rules were put into effect.

56:07 And I can understand how they could be manipulated for that reason, or can be manipulated to do that, but that can't be why those rules were put there. They had to be put there so that sometimes when there's a wetland and there's a need to get rid of the wetland, maybe for a whole town's benefit, like maybe when they put Snow Creek in, it created a lot of jobs and it created a lot of revenue for the town to grow, there was a reason to do that, but to just benefit.

56:37 One person for an investment he made in land that he doesn't live on, doesn't make a lot of sense. So, can you explain the lesson? To answer to your question, I know you explained this, the difference in the beginning of the report, but I think it's, as I'm hearing, exactly what can be done. You know, first of all, nothing can be done without any levels of approvals, but if we could...

57:01 Reiterate again that how deep that really goes and what that would suggest. I think it would help the audience. But that's after the property's already divided. You've divided the property. Let's just say you decide to divide it. And then he... Mr. Van Ackle? Sorry. It's hard to say. And then he decides that he wants to sell the property or build on it. And then he would get into wetland mitigate. He would want to build on the wetlands. Let's just say you ran over part and you wanted to build on it.

57:30 Then he would have to go through the procedure and go through planning again.

57:36 But you've already opened the door for that to be the next step. Well, it's open now. It's open now. He can do that exactly if he wanted to. But there's things that he has chosen not to do because of some of the very things that you've talked about. And so I think it needs to be clear of what that would involve. Because as far as the side, there's restrictions already. There's the size of the home and the height and the setbacks and the easements there. So it can't take up the whole property like you're doing.

58:05 Like you were saying, that example there. But if we can go back to what you were talking about there and let's make sure, because the language is a little nebulous there. And then make sure everyone really understands what that means. And I think that'll be helpful. So if I can do the Jen and see if this answers your questions.

58:29 So first of all, the required setbacks for side yards and rural residential zones are 10 feet, so the houses would be a minimum of 20 feet apart. In terms of wetland mitigation, that's the jurisdiction of the federal agencies and state agencies. So it's up to Army Corps of Engineers and Lahontan Regional Water Quality Control Board, as well as Fish and Wildlife, to review the proposed development.

58:55 Review them, determine what type of permitting is required and whether or not it can be permitted and if so, what type of mitigation would be required. To go back to one of the comments about Army Corps of Engineers specifically, I just got off the phone with Bruce Henderson at Army Corps to get this clarified. Their restriction of half an acre of disturbance which was done when this property was first developed is a threshold that they have under their general permit.

59:23 A little under half an acre was disturbed. So if they wanted to go through and have more development over half an acre, it triggers a higher level of review called, I believe, an independent permit that requires the analysis of alternatives to be done before any wetland is disturbed. But if rural residential zoning in Old Mammoth is a half acre per house and it continued to be subdivided, that wouldn't trigger a Lahontan's review.

59:51 Army Corps said that that half an acre is based off when the general permit was issued, so you cannot get around that by subdividing. You wouldn't get another half acre from subdividing again and again and again. You would still be limited to that half acre under the general permit. Okay. That's what Bruce Henderson of Army Corps told me this afternoon. Okay. Does that help? I'm sorry, I don't see that very too far. Does that help any of the questions at this point? A little bit?

1:00:26 Okay. Thank you. That's not how my conversation with Bruce Henderson went. You have to come up. We're streaming and people at home watch this. Biggest audience we've had in months. My conversation with Bruce Henderson was that it could be subdivided to the parcel size requirement that the town requires and a half acre billable footprint could be put on each one of the parcels that would be subdivided.

1:00:57 And that was how I understood my conversation with Bruce Henderson. He did say that the Army Corps tried not to let that happen, but it was how it used to be done when you start with a 10-acre parcel and get it down to 10 one-acre parcels. They try not to let it happen, but it is doable. That's my understanding. Sure, and I don't want to be the one interpreting the federal agency's regulations either, but that was my understanding.

1:01:22 So regardless of what decision today is, that's in whatever happens, that'll be a point of clarification before we move forward on anything that we will request of staff. Sue, did you want to come back up and had another question? If this access on Carter Street is denied, then in order to access this

1:01:48 property, say the subdivision goes through, in order to access this property, would he have to come off of Old Mammoth Road? That's what would have to be, it would have to be determined, you know, that would not be at his discretion alone. Then we sell wetland credits again, you know. That's, well, that's not, it would not be that way, so there's a variety of options that come along, but I don't,

1:02:17 To disturb that is not what the intent is. And then my only worry about, too, about Lahont and the Army Corps of Engineers and that sort of thing, it's just a little bit more removed. Their bureaucracy, I mean, do they really care about this little meadow in old Mammoth? It's just one more step removed. Can't say although I have no. I know. It sort of takes the, you know, the responsibility out of your shoulders and kind of puts it onto them. So it's like, we didn't have to make that decision.

1:02:46 But I'm just trying to, you know, I'm sorry, but I just, it just went through my mind. So I had to say it. Thank you. Well, if they would like to step in right now and do that for us, I'm sure that that would be okay. No. At least three people, but then not really, because we still live here too. Right. I can never do that, so. I saw someone else. Dave, did you have another question before we begin rebuttal and other issues?

1:03:13 Not necessarily another question, but a quick reminder. Carter Street is a private road for four lots, not five. It doesn't matter if it's the owner now or somebody way down the line when this happens and wants to, they have to find another access to their piece of property.

1:03:44 So I have a question for you. Does all, since this property is larger than, I don't have it subdivided on our maps here of what the size of the other three properties right now? There are four. Including? Including? So the other three, which are on the other side of the street, is that correct?

1:04:07 That's correct. Okay. So I don't know the size of those. On the east side. Because it's not defined on this, ma'am. Where this, the applicants is. Is any of the, for lack of a better term, decision or say within the association, is it weighted based on the property size or is everything equal? Everything is equal. Okay. Every owner has one vote. Okay. It has to be in it says. Okay.

1:04:38 Can I ask a question before you leave the microphone? I live on a private road in Old Mammoth, and we, it was never accepted by the county, and then when the town incorporated, it wasn't accepted by the town, so we have to pay to maintain it privately, as many roads are in Old Mammoth and the rest of town. We have to permit public access over that road, and there are two access points, off Hill Street and off Waterford.

1:05:04 Are you required, I got the CC&Rs just, you know, minutes before the meeting began, I have no chance to look at them, but are you required to provide public access on Carter Street? No. It is a private driveway, the only thing? So it's really more a driveway than a road? Correct. But you call it a street? Well, in the documents in front of you from the town and from the lawyers, they state that they use both terms, but it's meant

1:05:33 That's the road that's there, and that is now because it's vacated as a public road or public access. We took it over. Now it is referred to as a private driveway or a private road. It is not for public access. Okay, because it has been legally vacated. Correct. Oh, that's interesting for me to know. Yeah, thank you.

1:06:01 So if anybody else wants to build on it, splitting again and again and again, which I think is going to happen, is that, no, those people, in order to stay out of the way or to mitigate with Corps of Engineers or Lahaten, that you're going to be stepping into that meadow with a footprint, and then you can't just say, oh, we'll just use this old...

1:06:29 Access here, Carter Street. Well, that's no longer possible. Okay, thank you for clarifying. It ends right there at the end of the panel. Thank you. Thank you. Okay, thank you. Anyone else at this time? Okay, like we said before, I have your letters and your written voices are heard too. At that point, I'd like to move. Did you have another comment? Yeah, just one comment. We did have, the town attorney did review the private easement.

1:07:01 Related to the subdivision, and really he didn't see anything that precluded a subdivision related to the private easement. It is owned, it's a non-exclusive easement to each of the owners, the four lots, and there is provisions in it for maintenance related to where the driveway, I believe, comes off of the street. So depending on how far your driveway comes off the street is how the formula is. And I didn't go through detail of that, I just kind of saw that.

1:07:30 It does have provisions for mediation and arbitration if there is a dispute among the four owners. And so that's what the mechanism that they would need to go through if they needed to change the, or they wanted to change the CC&Rs. So Peter, you're saying if there were a fifth owner? No, I'm just saying that there's four, so it does talk about four lots, not four owners, four lots. So it's owned by the four lots. And then if there were a fifth lot because of subdivision, the attorney says that

1:07:59 No, what he said is that the agreement itself didn't preclude a subdivision. That's what basically he said. It doesn't contemplate a subdivision, nor does it say you can't have a subdivision. It just talks about four lots. And he also said that it's not a town agreement, it's really a private agreement. The town is not involved in the agreement. Right. And did he review the CC&Rs and easement or just the easement? They are one document. Thank you.

1:08:42 I believe the applicant had a couple of points that he wanted to make in response for clarification. Thank you. With regard to the last topic on the CCNRs, the question before you is not related to this. You're not being asked to adjudicate the CCNR. It's not really your function and it's not really appropriate.

1:09:15 I don't think you're an attorney, and I'm certainly not an attorney. The body of law governing CCNR and private rights is a very specific technical body of law that requires a level of expertise that I don't think anybody here really has. Like you said, just my going through it, it identified four lots almost as

1:09:41 Almost like a name. It's saying the four owners, the four lots. To me, there was nothing in there to preclude a fifth lot or a sixth lot or a tenth lot. It was just saying they had to call it something, so they said the four people, the people that own it now. That's the way I read it. But I'm not, like I said, I'm not an attorney, and I don't think that you're being asked to be attorneys, and I don't think that should be something that we delve into.

1:10:11 However, if you properly decide that the subdivision is merited and granted, that would be something that the owners would have to contend with. Normally, normally speaking, a property owner cannot be denied access of his land. So if, for instance, it was subdivided and the four

1:10:39 Owners decided that they wanted to prevent the owner from accessing his land. They could not do that. Also, although it's a private, considered private, I think the term as it relates to a formerly public road being cared for privately by the people that occupy that, that's a different, that word private is not the same as we own it, nobody can come on here, you're trespassing.

1:11:08 It's a different terminology. So normally what happens if a road ends up going private is that there are still prescriptive easements assumed that the public can still use. So is somebody trespassing if they make a right-hand turn and go down Carter Street in the city of Mammoth? The answer is no. That's what I understand the answer to be. Again, I'm not an attorney, and I think we get into different issues when we start.

1:11:38 I think that's something you want to explore, then I would rely on a land use attorney or somebody, you know, that's technically qualified to talk about that. David, I did want to say that it's true that we don't live on the property like the other three owners do to the extent that we haven't. We always felt that we kept our side of agreements up and paid, but I'll certainly get with you offline on that.

1:12:08 If there's something we haven't been doing, please let us know because we like to be good neighbors. I know that the tenants sometimes aren't necessarily, you know, may not be doing, but I've always, when I've heard about that, I've always been right on it. So I think last time, last year by mistake, we ended up with a different snow removal company than what the other three owners were doing. But prior to that, we were all together and we'd all divvied up. But no, whatever the cost is, we're,

1:12:38 We're fully on board. In terms of traffic considerations, improvements to Carter Street, again, putting a turnaround area in there, which is required as part of the mitigation for emergency vehicles to get around. Right now, if there's a fire in David's house, in our house, anywhere in there, they're stuck. It's a log jam back there. But with the mitigation required that there be a turnaround in there, it would make it a lot easier. Also, with the fire hydrant, that adds a tremendous benefit, tremendous value.

1:13:07 So those are things on the table to consider. Regarding Tony, thank you for your discussion on conservation easements. I'm aware of conservation easements. There is a benefit to the landowner usually getting a tax deductibility on the diminution of value of the land. And what that means simply is that you could have developed that land.

1:13:34 You put it into a conservation easement and therefore the land loss value because of that and broadly speaking the IRS can allow deductibility. That's something we would consider. The problem is that the value of the land and the diminution of the land compared with the property owner is still charged with keeping it up in perpetuity. So when you take sort of the small tax benefits on one side of the ledger,

1:14:03 And balance it against it forever. For the next hundred years, the landowner is responsible for maintaining those bylaws, keeping the conservation easing current, having meetings with the board of directors of the trust, funding the trust. You know, it winds up kind of becoming a wash, and in a small parcel like this, it would be a negative. Robin, I really appreciated you bringing the emotion side of this up. Because, and this is what I want to really speak to.

1:14:35 First of all, during the go-go days, we were approached by developers, and when I talk developers, I'm talking real developers, guys that know how to get stuff done. They saw a meadow, an empty meadow, and in their minds, they're looking at condos and whatever else could make them a buck. They didn't see a beautiful meadow, but they approached us about selling us their land and talking some pretty big dollars to do that.

1:15:04 We explained that the possibility of doing it would be complicated, putting a building, going through the wetlands mitigation and all of that. That's something that these guys do for a living. They come into towns, they basically bulldoze their way through however they're, I don't even know how they do it, but sometimes it's unsavory and they get what they want. We did not want that, and we turned our nose down.

1:15:36 Because we did not want those people coming in and destroying that meadow. So I get emotional about it too. Going back before the Tinsley's bought the land, James R&S owned it. And we all remember him, Matt Dillon. Whenever I picture Matt Dillon, he's in a meadow on a horse. That's the character of that land. That's the heart and soul of that land. So for all the people that we're talking about, well, put your money where your mouth is,

1:16:14 I'm willing to do that. If this is granted, we will, and I can't tell you whether it would be a conservation easement, a donation to the city, an outright donation of partial B to the city, or just a put into the deed, in perpetuity, no development on the wetlands. And that's probably what I'm leaning towards right now. But I would be willing to put in the deed.

1:16:46 A permanent easement for no construction on the wetlands at all. Except if we want to put a fence up there and put some horses not to exceed, you know, the usual things. But no improvements, no development, no houses, not even another barn. I'm willing to do that. There's a possibility that an outright donation of parcel B to the city might be the way to go because we could probably get a tax benefit from that.

1:17:16 A conservation easement. The IRS could very well say, well, you couldn't build on there because there was a wetlands there and you wouldn't have been able to build there anyway, so we're not going to give you any credit for your land being lower value. So I don't know that we want to go that way, but maybe an outright donation to the city, but at a minimum, we're willing to codify this on the deed and the town will have what you and I want.

1:17:46 Which is to be able to drive up that road, old ma'am, 50 years from now, look to the left and see a beautiful meadow. Hopefully with horses on it again. So with that, I put this into your hands and I thank everybody and I really appreciate the comments because and I'm sorry I didn't knock on your doors and get these person to person beforehand. But I'll be hanging around afterwards so if you want to pull me aside and talk to me, I'll be more than happy to. Thank you.

1:18:18 Thank you. So now we move on to the deliberation portion of it between the commission itself. Anyone have any other questions before going into this? Any comments you'd like to make? I think, I think, you know, this is really an example of public comments and public hearings at its very best and I really appreciate what you just offered.

1:18:54 What would my fellow commissioners think if we made a motion to continue this to a date certain so it doesn't have to be reposted and the purpose of doing a date certain continuation would be so that we could redraft the motion. It always makes me nervous when we draft motions on the fly. I mean, I think we have the essence of it, but you always kind of worry about the technical legal aspects of it.

1:19:24 and then hopefully in that period of time then the applicant can meet with the other three homeowners and work out their issues regarding access and easements that would be my thought on that I don't have enough information to make a decision today but I would like before we go on to the next item on the agenda to review the issues that we really do need more information on so I'm not ready to

1:19:50 Vote on continuing or come to consensus on continuing because I have a number of issues that I'd like to review. So. Would they be, if we are continuing to date certain, would that give time to address those with staff? Oh, that's what I would hope. Okay, so that's. Yeah. So look at that too, because. Because I was ready for the discussion and then I just want to be sure these issues are all out there because new ones have come up just today that I didn't even know about. Exactly. Yeah. Exactly. And.

1:20:19 Do you want to address that? No, I was going to say, what were your issues, Elizabeth? I mean, I only have the two issues, personally. It was, I'd like to see, I'd like to see, you know, some sort of permanent easement granting of the open space, I mean, the applicant already said he was willing to do that, and I just really want to make sure that the four owners that have the CC&Rs of Carter, the Carter driveway or slash street, can, you know, work out some sort of reciprocal agreement.

1:20:49 And what else did you have on your list? I've got a few comments to make. Okay, thank you. I would like to say in 12 years up here, and just really getting old, I keep saying 12 years, but the letters that we received on this issue were the most thoughtful and well-considered of any group of letters I've ever seen. I thank you very much for the time and the passion that you put into those letters. They were very, very helpful.

1:21:13 I've lived in Old Mammoth for 20 years. I walk or drive by this parcel every day, several times a day. I knew Martha Jarvis, Marcia Jarvis, excuse me, and Ron Tinsley. I was acquainted with them. And I watched this project being built. And it was mind-blowing. I mean, to see how much dirt had to be brought in, what they had to do. And so, luckily, in this arrow-shaped lot, they put the

1:21:39 Disturbance at the pointed end of the arrow, so we still have this large open space, which of course is what we would all like to see. The preserving these wetlands, Mr. Dan Hockel talked about you have to go on in perpetuity, and you know, we're thinking of things differently around here. Perpetuity

1:22:02 is really what we're about. We just finished a big, big project. It was a volunteer public-private partnership building a gateway to Mammoth. And that was designed to last a minimum of 100 years. That's why it looks so good, because it's a 100-year minimum project. And the policy that the town council adopted in 1993 of an urban growth boundary that we would not sprawl ever beyond

1:22:26 Our four square miles because we're surrounded by this gorgeous scenery, this gorgeous public land, and we want to keep it that way. That's perpetuity. And that's what the land trust is about. It's about perpetuity and making sure that we preserve this treasure that we have. When I first saw this proposal, I thought, well, I don't know, replacing the tack building and the paddock with another house, you know, it's already disturbed. It would be on that disturbed area. It probably wouldn't make any difference. But there wasn't anything anywhere.

1:22:56 They gave me any level of comfort, any security that those wetlands would be there forever. They'd be there in perpetuity. And I'm very, very concerned about that. The fact that the request was reduced from three lots to two lots, well, that's fine, but there's still no protection for the wetlands. Now that this Carter Street access issue has been raised, something I wasn't even aware of, I realize...

1:23:24 Looking at this map, the yellow crosshatching are wetlands, and to get to this parcel would require a bridge. I mean, that's, you know, we have to think about the conditions of a use permit and the public, not the public access, but access. That is something we have to think about up here. So that would require a bridge to not impact the wetlands further. Marcia Jarvis, the letter that was copied that she wrote in 97, their project was done in 94.

1:23:53 She talked about dealing with Lahontan and how this was a pilot project for wetlands mitigation and that's when wetlands banking was becoming popular. People had wetlands and they needed to build and so then they could do something somewhere else, you know, mitigate that somewhere else where the need was greater. It reminds me of what BLM does where they have a scale of values for riparian values and we

1:24:19 We managed to avoid having a casino at Whitmore Pool with a high-rise hotel and acres of free parking because in exchange for a parcel in Benton that had higher riparian values on the BLM scale of values. So these things happen. Even though it was a pilot program for some, you know, Laurel Pond mitigation, and that was important, we needed that mitigation, but this sort of thing can happen again.

1:24:45 I don't have any comfort at all dealing with the Army Corps of Engineers. I mean, I saw New Orleans after Katrina. You know, I just had no comfort there. And Lahontan, which is meticulous about protection, they were the ones who did this pilot program. So I just, I'm just, it's just too loose. Then when the consultant from Carson City, who did this very detailed study, talked about the chaotic hydrology.

1:25:11 In 12 years, I've never heard a consultant use the word chaotic, but they referred to the five, at least five sources of drainage that go underneath this meadow and go to Mammoth Creek. The City of Los Angeles Department of Water and Power just sued the town of Mammoth Lakes, and I don't even know what the resolution is yet, for our water, because they see climate change coming, they're really concerned about being able to provide enough drinking water to their customers, and as they find out,

1:25:39 These five sources of drainage going to Mammoth Creek, which it goes to eventually the city of LA in terms of their water, we could have ramifications. You just can't believe what we could be getting into. Let's see. I was very moved by Jimmy Morning's letter. Robert, is Jimmy your brother? My brother, yes. Oh, okay. I didn't know exactly your relationship. Talking about the schism in the family because he was the one who wanted to protect the meadow.

1:26:08 And his father and James Arness, and I remember Gunsmoke when I was a kid, you know, wanted to develop this big project. And then he was able finally to persuade them that, no, it just mattered too much. And so there's nothing wrong with, if you can say it, perpetuity. There's nothing wrong with thinking 50 years out, 100 years out. I really want to continue this item, so I very much appreciate your suggestion, Mickey. There wasn't...

1:26:38 But you did hear that he's willing to give... Oh, yes, yes. Okay. But I'll say what my issues are. I want to continue it because there wasn't sufficient notice on a matter of this importance. I mean, this doesn't just matter to the old Mammoth neighborhood. It matters to the whole town. There wasn't enough notice. It was the legally required amount. But this wasn't like somebody wants to build a garage next door and, you know, I have to give you notice because you're a neighbor. And it's also shoulder season. A lot of people are out of town before the summer rush starts.

1:27:07 There are way too many issues. There's the Carter Street problem. There's how to protect the wetlands in perpetuity, what's the best way to do it. And Mr. Don Hackel just gave some suggestions for what he would be willing to do, but we can't do that sort of thing on the fly. We've got to see it specifically in paper. It's got to be worked out how that would happen. The way things stand today, I can't even make the findings that I'm required to make as a Planning Commissioner.

1:27:35 That this request is consistent with the general plan and consistent with the CEQA grading plan. Why subdivide if selling the property isn't the objective? I mean, why do it? And obviously that's the objective, so what protection do we have for the future owner? We need to have something that goes with the property, goes with the title, whatever it takes. And I don't have enough information. I'm content to let the DWP chaotic hydrology issue.

1:28:04 Sleeping Dogs Live, but, you know, the other issues, we really need to get those addressed. So, let's see, what else would I say? The access. Yeah, access is an important one. It wouldn't be from Old Mammoth Road, actually, you know, obviously, but my goodness, are we talking about putting in more fill, you know, just to get access to this parcel? Can something maybe be worked out with the Carter Street owners? But, you know, we need to know these things, so.

1:28:32 I'm not ready to make a decision today and I'm glad to hear, Mickey, that you aren't either. I don't know how Rhonda feels. First of all, thanks to everyone for coming here and providing such a civil forum and being respectful of everyone there. It really helps because the outcome is that people are talking and it's very solution-oriented and I really, I haven't been here quite as long as Elizabeth each, but not by much.

1:29:05 Each time that we do this, it's, we hope that it gives a chance to have, to clarify issues, find, you know, some clear-up misconceptions, but then really allow people to say, here's my true concern, and how do you assuage me from those particular feelings, especially about agencies, and we've all sat here and heard it before. It's just, a lot of times, it's deja vu all over again, and

1:29:31 If we don't learn from those and address those issues, that's when we're stuck with what we have. This is a great opportunity to address all of that. I would, too, be in favor of a continuance to clear these issues because something has come forward that was not on the table before, and that was how to secure this parcel of land that is not at the options that is not.

1:29:59 I really appreciate you.

1:30:24 Not taking the word of an expert at one specific section of time when you knew better. And we've all, you know, there's examples all over town where areas that don't appear to be wet can change quickly. And what you're dealing with that is not something anybody saw. I really appreciate your offer to mitigate this and find out what's the best way to...

1:30:49 Preserve the property that you obviously have. You've seen the value to and for the citizens there. I used to live right across the street from that, so I know. It's a special place in my heart, too. And I would be in favor of a continuance of this so we can work out these issues and allow the public to come forward and for the applicant to work more, you know, those areas and see if that's really, you know, we can set up a workshop if you think it's necessary. The outreach.

1:31:19 Right now seems to be very positive, you know, to clear up those issues and things that we are available through staff to clarify, you know, what truly does this mean and what are the options going forward and how do we get the intent of everybody satisfied there. So I'm in favor of the continuance on this for that reason because I see we're so close to

1:31:46 Coming to resolution there that we want to make sure that we don't miss something. And that's very encouraging. We would be very happy to give a recommendation to council on this because that was arrived at by the citizens and the applicant together. And it's not often that we get to do that. So I think we'd really be looking forward to something like that. Chair Duggan? I forgot one key point.

1:32:14 Commissioner Harvey had to recuse himself because he lives within 300 feet, but this meeting was not called last minute, but it was an unexpected meeting and Commissioner Fernie can't be here today and I would be more comfortable if there were four of us making this decision. So that was my other point. Thank you. So at this point, to staff, I think we might need to clarify a few things of really what we're looking for in expectations for not only

1:32:41 for the commission but the public and the applicant at this because this is not something that is being dragged on because we don't know what to do. I think we know what we want. Everyone wants to achieve and what do you think? What else do you need from us? Thank you. I think I can summarize the direction and just let me know if I've missed anything. The direction is for a continuance to a date certain. I would suggest that date be the first meeting in August.

1:33:10 I will be out and won't be able to I don't know that we'd be able to turn this around by July 10th anyway. And the issues that we'll be resolving between now and then we'll be figuring out the mechanism of this permanent preservation of the wetland and how that works in a manner that achieves our goals of permanent preservation as well as those of the owner.

1:33:38 Hopefully getting a resolution on the Carter Street access issues with those other property owners. And those were the two issues I really heard to get follow-up on other than in terms of notice, August 14th at a date certain wouldn't require additional notice, but I think we've got some good word of mouth out there at this point.

1:34:04 Okay, so that is our, that's the first meeting, the meeting for Planning Commission in August, August 14th. That's correct. Okay, and that's plenty of time for the rest of the property owners to hear about it. So to clarify, we won't be sending out, we won't be sending out mailings and we won't be publishing in the newspaper because you're continuing it to a date certain, August 14th. Okay. Okay.

1:34:30 It will be posted on the website as well. It will, the agenda will be, but we don't re-notice. If the commission continues to a date certain, we don't re-notice it. If you just continue it and you don't have a date, then we are required to re-notice, but we're not required to re-notice if you continue to a date certain.

1:34:48 Okay. Was there a question in the audience? Well, I'm going to be out of the country. Oh, well. Okay. The first option is the 14th. That's the first available date there. Do you anticipate that? Okay. The next meeting, September 11th? Wednesday, September 11th? Okay. Okay. That's fine. If that's, agree with us, others there. Also,

1:35:19 No, that'll be offline, that's fine. You know, the access of that road and the safety issue, you know, kind of was raised today to make sure if we're doing something like this, do we have to address it other than it has been in the past with, you know, for a fire in that area. So we'll make sure that that's satisfied. Okay. At that point. Okay, and so the direction is clear at this time? Clear as much, but no. Thank you again. We need a roll call.

1:35:50 It's not a vote. It's a to continuance. We don't need that, correct? Okay. Thank you. Appreciate everybody's time. I think it was very, very important to see if we could all be on the right track. Thank you. Thank you. Come forward so we can hear you. Hear you and see you and hear you for others. You said you don't need to put a notice because it's continuance, but then you made the point earlier that

1:36:17 It was an important issue, and it wasn't enough that you just sent letters out to people within 300 yards and attending others. So maybe you would consider putting it in the newspaper so that more people would know about the meeting this time? I think by the time they received the letters, it was 12 days, and I didn't think that was sufficient time. Well, I agree, because we haven't done enough. Yeah. But I would hope with this represent, personally, with this representation, that you'd be telling all your neighbors, get the word out. Okay, so it will not go ahead. The town is on a very tight budget. Okay, gotcha.

1:36:47 So it will be posted on the website as well, okay? There's a legal notice there and certain things you have to do by a certain date. Now we have plenty of time. We don't need to satisfy a legal notice. But I think in the interest of this, we'll see what we can do is put it in maybe a public announcement that's not like an ad.

1:37:14 The public service announcement that I think there. That would satisfy everybody and then come forward again. Thank you. Chair, if I may, this was noticed publicly in the newspaper. Yes. Robin, do you want to come forward again? My question is if during this interim time you're doing some work with owners and with other, you know, how to secure the meadows, that you will probably come to some decision and

1:37:48 Will we know about the decision, the new proposal prior to the meeting so that? So what's required is within a certain time before the meeting everything is published. So you have time to do that. Now, should something else become available earlier or takes it anyway, you always have the right to ask.

1:38:14 Absolutely. Has there made any progress or things like that? And that you can ask any of us there or staff as well and Jen that, you know, how is it going? Is there something we need to know? Because it does help. The timeframes are very tight in order to prepare all this information as well. But it does, it is available and there's announcement. If you would like to get any of those announcements, they come to us by email and you can look online and you can sign up to get that.

1:38:43 Well, how long prior to the meeting should it be available, like whatever you come up with? The legal requirement is that agendas need to be published 72 hours prior to a regular meeting or 24 hours prior to a special meeting. This is scheduled for a regular meeting. We normally get our agenda packets out for Planning Commission either the Thursday or Friday before the meeting. So that's about five days.

1:39:11 With the final packet, the final packet is done. So there'll be something, preliminary packets to look at, to see how it's going? No. No. But that's, that's what you see on the Friday, on the week before, is what you would see at the meeting. So you have a few days. I'm sorry to interrupt. You can, please feel free to call or email. I'm happy to give you updates at any time. Okay. Thank you. And that's when we get it too. So we don't get it in advance either. So that's, you know, that's what our weekends look like as well.

1:39:42 Can we have a two-minute break? Thank you very much for all your participation. We do have one other item going forward, but we requested a two- or three-minute break there, and we can bring back our other commissioner. Thank you very much.

1:42:48 Thank you.

1:43:17 I know fully well that

1:43:47 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:44:16 Thank you.

1:44:45 I like your sweater, Mickey. I like your sweater. I like your sweater.

1:45:14 Thank you. Thank you.

1:45:43 And how does that affect you? Now if you, so let's say five laws, does that help? And he's going to have to share with you because that's a lot. He's going to have to try to easily move his property to the other

1:46:13 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:46:42 Thank you.

1:47:11 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

1:47:39 David's in the back. He's chatting in the back. Mickey, I forgot my walking shoes. So I can go home and get them and then meet you and we can go for a walk or we can... What?

1:48:12 No, I can't. Oh, good. Okay. What is...

1:48:34 Okay, Martell. See, I never do that. I just know him as three. Bruce. That's Kathy's Bruce, okay. Yeah, I know Bruce, yeah. Yeah, I know that one. I never do his last name. No, it's just a group of guys type of things. Is that a kid? No, not a kid. Because they got pigs to feed. Because they have two granddaughters from 4A. He's talking.

1:49:03 Thank you.

1:49:29 We need to come back into session. I really appreciate everybody still here talking congenially. That is very nice. It's a big change. Some of the meetings that we're going to. I've got my agenda here. I found it. Okay, we're moving on to

1:49:52 Public hearing number two is consider the approval of use permit 13-001 and design review 13-001 on a new single family home at 265 Pine Street, the Frank residence, and Jen, you are also on that with our contract planner, Bill Taylor. And Bill Taylor will be giving the presentation. Okay, because Jen is gone and Sandra is overseeing this. Yes, thank you. Running into something here. Here we go.

1:50:21 Chair Dugan, members of the Commission, it's nice to see you again. I'm not sure how much detail you would like me to go into on the background of this project, so I think, I know that you're all familiar with the bluffs, with the history of the bluffs, so I think I will not bother going into all the ancient history, but dive right into the project and the issues related to the project. The subject application is for the development of a new home.

1:50:51 on Pine Street in the Bluffs. There were originally two lots that have been merged to create one lot, now numbered 265 Pine Street. Proposed home will have 7,154 street, square feet of living area, one four car garage, one two car garage. The home's also been designed with passive solar strategies and with a 20 kilowatt photovoltaic solar array. This will generate a large percentage of the homes

1:51:23 Energy, the homeowner is also hoping to pursue and to acquire lead platinum or excuse me lead silver certification so you know it's certainly in keeping with the design goals of the town with regard to sustainability the project is zoned rural residential and is also located within the snow deposition design zone these two

1:51:52 factors lead to the need for the application today. The reason for the conditional use permit is the snow deposition design zone and also proposed encroachment into the required 30-foot setback from the edge of the bluff. And then there is also a design review requirement because the elevation of the house is above the elevation line identified in the municipal code. So I think what I will do is start with

1:52:22 The special use permit issues first. And there really are only two special use permit issues. The first one is the snow deposition design zone. Again, that is required for properties essentially within 150 feet of the bluff edge, any development. And the purpose behind that is to make sure that development on the top of the bluff does not exacerbate avalanche hazards at the base.

1:52:55 An avalanche study was performed by John Moinier of Dewberry, and Mr. Moinier is here today. He did not find that the, let me rephrase that, he did find that construction will not cause any increase avalanche hazard, and he used the same formula and analytic process that we've used on virtually all the other homes on the bluff. So it's consistent with that.

1:53:25 And with the findings of other avalanche reviews on other properties. The second issue has to do with the setback from the 30% slope. Municipal code requires, as part of the design review, mitigations from the bluff's EIR that a house be set back a minimum of 30 feet from the 30% line, the point at which the bluff gets steeper than 30%.

1:53:59 This property is actually proposing a significantly reduced setback. The rear yard would actually be 10 feet 11 inches from that line. But the municipal code allows for encroachment when the overall design that is provided better meets the intent of the regulation to mitigate visual impact from off-site pursuant to the certified bluff CIR. There is a rationale, design rationale that was provided to you.

1:54:30 Additionally, the building is developed with a, I'm going to say, a lot of articulation on the front facing the bluff. It's dark colored. And because of the building height, which is significantly lower, it actually presents less of a profile when viewed off-site than a house that would be developed at 35 feet at the 30 foot setback line. So for those reasons,

1:55:00 We felt that the finding could be made that met the intent of this reduced setback provision in the code. Then I think the other portion, the other issue that you have before you today is design review. And the project is designed as a two-story structure with a loft lookout on the third floor. The exterior siding is proposed to be western red cedar lap siding with an Olympic 714 stain, and that's shown on the materials board, which is...

1:55:40 And we did have a meeting with the... Excuse me, Bill. The materials board is so small. Could you bring it to you? Can you just pass it in? Thank you. On May 8th, we did hold a meeting of the design review subcommittee of the Planning Commission. Commissioner Fernie and Commissioner Tenney were there. We reviewed the proposed design and materials. There were some questions asked by the committee. And...

1:56:15 The applicant confirmed that the exterior rock will be a ledger stone as shown on the materials board. The applicant also confirmed that the support posts on the deck will be 18 inches square, so it provides a rather solid look rather than the kind of spindly look we get sometimes with a deck perched on a, you know, a 6x. And we also discussed the reflectivity of solar panels.

1:56:45 discussed a proposal by the applicant to use a different glass than has traditionally been used to reduce the transmission of interior light at night. So in response to the discussion, a proposed roofing material has been changed to a core 10 standing seam roof. The window and door glazing will be a Viracon VE3-2M. This glass has a

1:57:15 Visible light transmittance of 21%. This is about half of the light transmittance of the glass that was previously being used. So it exceeds the standard that the town has been approving for development in the bluffs. And the color of posts and rail, which was a question, they will be painted to match the Olympic 714 stain that you see there. The application was routed to outside agencies and comments were received from the water district and the fire district.

1:57:46 And their comments have either been incorporated into the conditions of approval or into the project itself. The project is exempt from the provisions of the California Environmental Quality Act. And that's because it is a Class III exemption, one single-family residence in a residential zone. So with that, we think the Commission has two options. One is to adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings,

1:58:16 And approve the use permit application with conditions as recommended by staff or with modifications. Or two, to deny the use permit application and design review application. Staff is recommending option one. And do you have any questions? Anyone ask questions to staff? The reason it appears to me the encroachments into that setback from the avalanche zone are so substantial.

1:58:44 I'm not sure what the design rationale was, and I think I would let the applicant respond to that. Certainly in terms of the configuration of the house, it does push that portion back, but there may have been other design considerations. Any other questions at staff? I have no questions. One more.

1:59:17 Maybe I'll ask Mr. Moyer this, but the roof design prevents massive shedding, and that's because of the pitched roofs up against that long flat expanse on the north, right? That's my understanding, yes. And the copper that has a natural finish, how is natural defined? Are you talking about on the roof? No, for the gutters and the downspouts. Let's ask the applicant. Okay. Does the applicant like to come forward to this time?

1:59:52 Madam Chairman, my name is Brian Jeanette, I'm the architect on the project, and Kim and Sean Frank are here today as well as John Honye and also Bruce, sorry if I misspelled her name, who is with the geothermal company that we're working with on the project. I think what I'd like to do is first state that we have read the staff report and the conditions of approval and do agree with those.

2:00:21 Kim and Sean are full-time residents here in Mammoth. And as Bill pointed out, sustainability and the whole green concept is something that my office and the Franks believe in wholeheartedly. We're looking at and likely using the geothermal for heating as well as melding the snow off the driveways, PV for electrical source, and solar orientations of passive and active systems within the home.

2:00:51 I actually helped develop the Title 24 energy standards in the late 1970s for the California Energy Commission, so this is something that we've been practicing for over 30 years. This is roughly a 7,000 square foot house on 4.6 acres. It's a very large piece of property, but we also want to be friendly with our neighbors by keeping the second floor area to a minimum, which allows people across the street to use over both the

2:01:20 The right and left wings of the house. We are, as Bill mentioned, requesting the approval of the use permit and the design review and acceptance of the snow deposition report. Now, if I may just touch a bit on Commissioner Tenney's comments. The 30-foot rear yard setback, actually, we pushed the home. I'm going to go through a couple of pictures here.

2:01:50 From the looks of that, it's not as easy to see as it may be in your staff report. But the little white spot is the home itself. Sandra's got some ideas. That's a little bit better. The two trees that are – this is a panorama actually showing on the extreme left, the house to the west, northwest, and on the extreme right, you just see a little bit of the –

2:02:35 to the home on the easterly side of the property. But the two trees that are seen, I don't have a pointer on me, there's one up here, that are on the right-hand side of the screen are two trees that we feel are very important. In locating the house, we tried to sneak the house in so that we didn't have to disturb the trees, which meant pushing it a little closer to the 30-foot setback. So the primary purpose was to save those and move the house more toward

2:03:03 The bluff, which gave, obviously, a much larger front yard setback. All of our setbacks are substantially larger than, all of our setbacks are substantially larger, these are the two trees I was talking about. This is the home to the, on the right-hand side of the property, and this is the home on the left side of the property. So in pushing the house a little bit more forward, we were able to save these trees and, as well as, almost all the trees on the site. Toward, yes, toward the edge of the bluff.

2:03:40 And obviously it created a very nice front yard setback as well. So here are the two trees we're able to sneak the building underneath, which lie here and here. This is the site plan. As mentioned by Bill, we have the upper car garage. This is Kim's. And the one down below, for Sean down below, on the lower portion of the site. The building is somewhat stealthy. And I'm going to go to, this is the basement area. So it's partially basement, it's not full.

2:04:13 So that we daylight base, we do have a daylight basement off on this side of the slope. So it's about six feet below grade on the front side, the street side. This is the second floor. And then the upper level is this lookout area and just some portion of the larger space in the great room. These portions are all one story in height from the street, as here as well. Again, the setbacks, the property line is 16 feet, more than generous than

2:04:43 And zoning, and close to 45 feet on the opposite side. This is the exterior colors, and again, this is the trees that we're able to work around on the front yard setback. This is the front elevation, which is a little bit easier to see here. And landscape is our indigenous materials, and we've worked with the landscape contractor here in the Mammoth area for the trees that we're utilizing. This is the rear elevation of the house, again, stepping down to

2:05:16 The neighbors, 45 foot plus setback on this side and 16 plus on this side. So those are, and this is the landscape plan showing the trees that help to, in a sense, hide the building from the lower bluff areas and the existing trees that we're keeping. If we move the building back, this is the rear, the area where the setback is the least. But if we move the building more to the street, it would have impacted both of these. So that's one of the reasons for.

2:05:50 For that request. This is the site from Old Mammoth Road. I don't think this is that far from that meadow you were talking about earlier. And here's the site without the building and then with the building. So from that standpoint, at this point, if you have any questions, I'm more than happy to answer those. Any wall made of a dry stack ledger stone? It's actually a concrete block retaining wall, and then we veneer it with a dry stack.

2:06:24 Stone, yes. And the natural finish on the copper fittings, you know, the gutters and dark spouts, flashing? It will be, it will ultimately turn like an oil rub bronze, and so it will be a brown tone, very similar to the, to the, to the stain that we have on the house. So it will have a patina, I mean, is it, when it says natural finish, unfinished copper, well, of course, like a copper pot, you know, just tarnish.

2:06:53 and develop a patina, but this has a finish on it. Well, if you look at copper in beach areas, typically, it gets this very strong green cast to it. Here, it does not. It stays in a more oil rubbed bronze look, which is what we don't like to treat that, per se, by pre-treating it or having it advance to a certain material color, but it ends up losing its gloss within about a month or two.

2:07:22 And then stays with a natural, almost this kind of a color of the exterior itself of the material. The roof itself is Corten, which you may be familiar with that as a rustic kind of color. I'm just concerned. Right. We don't want any reflectivity as well. We're looking for the house to be really quite stealthy on the site. Thank you. Any other questions? Could you describe in a little bit more detail the solar panels for us?

2:07:52 The solar panels that we're using here are likely going to be a Suniva panel, which is almost a black glass panel. It has a black frame around it. They're approximately 85 on the building. And they do face south, which is perfect orientation. They are what's called an in-phase type of a panel, which means that each panel has its own inverter on it. So if there's snow covering one, it doesn't mean the whole system goes down.

2:08:21 Each one generates its own power based on its exposure to the sun. Extremely efficient, and again, it eliminates the issues of shading. There are panels, I understand, that are heated, but I'd be better off just letting the sun do its trick, warm them up, and get them clear and regenerate electricity. Thank you. Any other questions? No, not at this time. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you. Okay.

2:08:56 No other questions of staff or the applicant have deliberation, but we actually need to talk to the public first. We won't preempt anything there. So this is a public hearing. If there's anyone that'd like to speak towards the project, please come forward and state your name. All for the last show. We do just want to make note for the record that we do have four, I believe, four letters.

2:09:28 submitted by residents of the Bluffs that I think are neighbors in that area and they are in support of the project. Now, I'll close the public hearing and let's move on to deliberations or any further questions from the commission. Anyone want to go? Do you have comments? It's time. It's time. I was looking at your plant list.

2:09:59 And we have just removed junipers from our recommended plant list, not officially, but the one we're working on, our recommended plant list for Mammoth Lakes because of the fire danger. And so if there's an alternative for juniper ground cover, that would be a good idea. And the other one that jumped out was the Colorado blue spruce, which we highly discourage because it looks so alien in the Sierra. It's really alien, so we discourage that one.

2:10:27 And that's also not on the plant list. I hope those are just a couple of questions. If you'd like me to comment. Go ahead. The blue spruce actually I got from a very well-known gardener here in the city. But we're more than happy to work with the plant palette and staff in finding materials that will be appropriate. The other comment I have is thank you for introducing us to this glazing.

2:10:59 For vets is, you know, what, 80, 79% of light being transmitted from inside because that public view shift is so important to our community and we're trying to avoid the mistakes that we've seen in Vail and in Deer Valley and other places where, you know, the big house on top of the hill that everybody gets to look at instead of, oh, gee, there's a house up there, you know, looking at the gorgeous view, so.

2:11:21 Thank you. The nighttime view is just as important to us because you see the Sierra Crest and the storms. So I was really glad to find out there's something even better than the one that we had been recommending to people. So that was good. And I'd also like to say, Bill, I'm glad John Moyniere is here. That's the best avalanche report I've ever seen. I mean, that was really thorough and well done and much clearer than anything we've had before. So I appreciate that.

2:11:51 Except for those two plants, that's my only issue. Thank you. Okay, anything else? Okay. So, we've been working on our zoning code update and one of the things we've been doing is rewriting our design standards and I just want to say that

2:12:12 You haven't even read our design standards, but you really implemented everything that we try to create with far as having a mountain look, and it's a beautiful home, and I congratulate you on that. And I'm sure you got a lot of great input from Elizabeth. Regarding blue spruces, I live in Snow Creek 5, I think we have 200 of them. They seem to be doing very well out there. But seriously, it's a very well thought out home. It fits well in the Mammoth area. I congratulate you on that.

2:12:42 Anyone else? I'm just very pleased with the presentation. The architecture is superb. The things that you're doing for renewable energy are excellent. I think this is going to be an asset to our community. Thank you very much. Elizabeth, do you have anything else to add? Just a question about the geothermal. You're digging a well?

2:13:15 Actually, we're intending to do a test well very soon, and it would be a series of wells, actually, that Bruce might be easier to help explain it, but basically, we're generating heat from the rock below and using that for melting through a heat exchanger, melting the snow and creating heat within the home without having to go to the grid.

2:13:42 Yes. Aha, okay, because I was going to say, if you wanted to bring geothermal from Casa Diablo up here, the town would be great. I'm not a big fan of the name geothermal heat pump, but the DOE says we have to call it that, so let's grab a seat. Oh, it's just so smart. I have someone who lives on my road, heats his driveway with electric, you know, all winter. I just don't know. How many floors are? Yeah, well, it's all the size of the house, I guess it doesn't matter.

2:14:11 If I might too, Jen has been fabulous to work with. Her questions and her doggedness to make sure she was getting the right kinds of answers and I appreciate the process of allowing consultants out of the area to meet as we spoke, Elizabeth, and other members through your design team. It made it very easy and comfortable for us to work those questions out, come up with answers that really meet the goal and I think that is

2:14:41 Quite exciting for us. I've done homes here in Mammoth, but they were long before these kinds of things were needed, but it made it very easy to work with staff and come up with a real good solution, so I applaud your team of planners. Thank you.

2:14:58 Just one last thing to make sure this horse has really been beaten well about the junipers and the blue spruce. What I've discovered lately is that there are now some varieties that are being reintroduced into this area that specifically address that as far as I just purchased some junipers that are not.

2:15:22 the residence type and they they almost like a Moogle pine but then also the blue spruce

2:15:28 If you don't put the acid on them, they look just like all of the others, and they're not blue anymore, but they are very strong, and that's what gets them blue, is what you feed into it. And when you're in Crowley... They're like hydrangeas. Uh-huh, they're like hydrangeas. Yes, and then in Crowley, where you don't have dirt, you just have small rocks. Aren't you saying you found junipers that aren't a fire hazard? Uh-huh, I doubt them.

2:15:53 Well, I don't want to give a plug for anybody, but they are locally grown. So keeping, and that's probably where you're coming with local growers who are looking for that very same thing because there are junipers and junipers and if you don't feed the acid to the blue spruce, they don't turn blue, which we found after somebody didn't do that and then it looks just like every other tree. The project is fabulous. We've all been very

2:16:19 Invested in it, watched, you know, watching the development of it there, and to see the innovations in the low-e glass, which goes beyond anything that we've tried before, the roofing and the, have many properties that have the copper patina that we expected to go green and it didn't, it just went brown. So it does have very much a look like the steel at the gondola building at the village.

2:16:47 So, because my neighbor has this particular area, so they're all, and so glad to see Ledgerstone versus River Rock, because I think we, if we can find anything, we're becoming more of a Ledgerstone community, which we know that that, you know, represents not only the mountains, but a modern look to things that isn't a log home, as always, so glad to see this project coming forward, too. It looks great.

2:17:14 And I'd be interested to see how many bottles you have in the wine room. Great. Great. Thank you. Anything else? I'll entertain a motion. I move that we accept staff's recommendation and we choose option one to adopt the required CEQA findings, finding the project categorically exempt, presumed to CEQA section 1-5.

2:17:49 303, new construction or conversion of small structures. Then we adopt the required municipal code findings and approve use permit application 13-001 and design review 13-001 with conditions as recommended by staff. And I don't believe there were any modifications. No.

2:18:18 Do I hear a second? A second. I'm going to do a roll call vote. Commissioner Harvey? Yes. Commissioner Payne? Yes. Commissioner Payne? Yes. Commissioner Brown? Yes. Commissioner Hurley? Yes. Thank you very much. Yes. Next on our schedule is a workshop from ESTA Transit. And now that transit and mobility falls under the auspices,

2:18:51 Thank you for having us.

2:19:21 We're glad to be here. Ray Jarvis is in Hawaii, so I'm kind of standing in for him a little bit here. Could have phoned in, right? John Helm is the director. Yeah, he's having a good time. John Helm is the, actually, director? Who's right? ESTA. As you know, we're all part of a joint powers association. ESTA was formed, and he's the general manager of that. But let me go back in time a little bit and say originally,

2:19:49 Probably 10 years ago, there was the Transit Advisory Group, which really handled the public outreach portion of sort of what we're doing here today. That got passed on to the Mobility Commission. The Mobility Commission handled everything mobile except for the airport because there was an airport commission at that time. And twice a year, the Mobility Commission had workshops and sort of kind of divided itself into a summer-winter type of a program where we discuss.

2:20:18 Any types of change in service at that time. Now, we're following under your jurisprudence here, so we're here as part of a public workshop where what we hope to do is announce any changes to service, stops, or anything that would affect transit and see, you know, maybe we can also go further as we're part of the Economic Commission and see what transit can do.

2:20:47 Town Transit, I don't want to go on too long, but the town originally started with its own transit system. It pretty much used local transportation funds. That's what got sort of the, what we now call the purple and the gray lines off the ground. After that, the Joint Powers Association was formed, which formed ESTA. That would be the town of Mammoth Lakes, town of Bishop, Inyo and Mono counties.

2:21:19 ESTA provides service, as you guys, as you're probably well aware, from Reno all the way down to Lancaster where they can hook up with the transit system down there. A lot of this service in the other entities is provided by the local transportation funds and some federal money that ESTA is eligible to receive. The way it's funded in town, the town gets about $280,000.

2:21:48 Local Transportation Funds, essentially that's claimed by ESTA to provide service in town and to provide, also helps them with their overall structure and their administrative costs. They get about $39,000 worth of federal money. The town through Measure T buys additional service on top of that up to the tune of about $700,000 a year and they get about $12,000 a year in fares. So we have

2:22:16 Just over a million dollar operating budget. And the reason why there's a greater amount of service in Mammoth Lakes than, say, other parts is because we go beyond the LTF funds and we have the Measure T funds and that's what funds all of our programs. Last year, SF secured contracts with both Mammoth Mountain Ski Area to provide the red line service in the winter and, of course, they're also providing

2:22:45 The Forest Service, they've contracted with the Forest Service for Reds Meadow, and that also, those kind of collaborations also allow them to pick up, what is it, 12 new buses, I think, which is the buses that you see, you know, going to Reds Meadow, and those are used on the Red Line in the winter, so you have a real, you know, public-private kind of relationship going on there. So, having said that, I guess,

2:23:15 A couple quick figures is we did about 400,000 riders last year. We're on target to be a little bit under that this year, but we still move a substantial number of riders. We move a large number of local people, primarily on the purple and the gray lines. The transits also, the trolleys also carry locals, but they carry a larger number of tourists, and they're very well thought of. Through Measure U, we provide

2:23:44 ESTA provides additional service to events in town. So when you see the Jazz Jubilee, Festival of Beers, the Hack Marathon last week, these are all funded by Measure U, and what they do is provide additional service. With this million dollars, we get just a little over 18,000 of service hours here in the town of Mammoth Lakes.

2:24:08 That's not counting those special events. Those are on top of that. Okay. So that's just kind of a brief overview of our relationship with ESTA. Any questions on that? Anyone have any questions on the relationship or what they do? They're basically, we contract with them to be the operator in town. So really, in town, we manage to contract with them and buy service hours. We like to plan routes with them. We plan stops with them.

2:24:39 The Measure U process, where they buy additional service, that works through the town and the Measure U committee. So what the town's role in all of this is to decide where we want the transportation, where we want the stops, how many service hours do we want to provide, and what John's people do is provide all those hours that we agree that we want. So really, we contract with him to provide those.

2:25:09 Those hours of service. So which of you would I ask if you considered charging a nominal fare? Ask John because he can answer that. He can ask that better than I can. Go ahead. Yes, good afternoon. Again, my name is John Helm. I am, in fact, the Executive Director of the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority. I use that first word of my title only to distinguish myself from our true directors who are the elected officials that serve on our board of directors.

2:25:37 There are two elected officials from each of the four member entities, the town, city of Bishop, county of Mono, and Inyo County. In response to your question specifically, and it is a question that has come up periodically in the community, and our transit services in the town of Mammoth Lakes are the only transit services that we provide that are fare-free. Fixed drought public transit service in Mammoth Lakes has, as long as I'm aware, always been fare-free.

2:26:07 There are several issues to be considered when looking at whether or not to implement a fare here within the town. First off, it would not, under any circumstances, be able to offset all of the operating costs for the service. As Brian pointed out, our services, roughly 18,000 vehicle service hours, are a little over a million dollars.

2:26:35 And, you know, 400, little under 400,000 passengers, so it would be over $2.50 per person per ride, and we wouldn't have anywhere near that ridership if a fare were charged. So it would be some percentage that would be realized. One of the other complications is, as Brian pointed out, the transit service that we operate in the town of Mammoth Lakes is

2:27:00 Somewhat complicated. And it's difficult to explain to folks who are trying to grasp and understand service. And part of the reason for the complication is all the various funding sources that are contracting for the transit services that are provided. And that expanded from our world, the Eastern Sierra Transit Authority, greatly last year as we entered into a contract with Mammoth Mountain for the operation of the red, blue, green, and yellow lines in the winter. The contract with the Mammoth Mountain ski area

2:27:30 For those very high ridership routes, envisions free service on those routes, and the mountain is not interested in charging a fare. They see the value in keeping people out of their cars, off the streets, out of their parking lots that would not be sufficient to accommodate all of their skiers and all their visitors if everyone had to drive to their portals.

2:27:56 So based on that value, they're very pleased and want to continue a fare-free service. That adds a big complexity if the other routes were to charge a fare. Not only would it only generate a small percentage of the overall operating cost, but it would add further confusion. If, for example, we were to charge a fare, let's say a dollar, on the purple and gray routes that operate from here to the village and Snow Creek and the hospital and other places.

2:28:25 Yet the Red Line and Blue Line and others were operating fare free. It would be A, very confusing for guests to our area who didn't live here all the time and seemingly unfair to many of the residents, I think, who would see free service on one route, the Red Line that goes to the village and a dollar to ride the Purple Line that goes to the same place. So it has been considered in the past.

2:28:52 The Mobility Commission addressed it on occasion. I have answered the question similarly to Town Council in the past as well. So hopefully that provides you some of the insights into... What's the ridership in summer compared to... Well... I know the trolleys are super popular. They are. One of the ways that we measure ridership in the transit world is something we call productivity, which is the number of passenger trips per hour.

2:29:24 It's difficult to me to say summer or winter because we operate so much more service overall in the winter. So obviously there are more passenger trips that are provided in the winter months. But the productivity in the summer is equal to or greater on the trolley routes than our productivity on the trolleys in the winter. So it's very, very well used in the summer. One of the things, two things. One, we operate a seasonal route, the Lakes Basin Trolley. It only operates basically in July.

2:29:53 In August, or from July through Labor Day, that has seen dramatic increases in ridership over the past couple of years. That's directly attributable to the completion of the Lake Mary bike path. And people are just seeing that as a wonderful opportunity. You ride the trolleys up, see the lakes basin, hop out at the end of the line and ride their bikes back down into town. And they're seen as a great family adventure. We've had to go. This is a good problem to have.

2:30:22 We've had to go to setting up queues and barricades for the folks who are waiting for the bus at the village to keep people in order in terms of boarding that bus. But at any rate, again, kind of a long answer, but ridership is equal to or greater on trolleys in terms of passengers per hour in the summer as it is in the winter. When I said nominal, I was literally thinking 50 cents, you know, just to offset some of those costs.

2:30:51 And I don't know if you could do that summer only when you're not operating for the mountain. I don't know what impact that would have. Go ahead. Let me just add one thing. Because John's thought about it. He has presented this to the town council. And the town council, to this date, because of the Measure T, the way it was set aside and their goal of feet first,

2:31:15 Really, it's the town council that set this mandate. And so the question would be if they were going to change the mandate that they set themselves, because obviously they could change it. They wanted to know if there would be a true benefit to it. What would really be the benefit? And that's the question that John has all, you know, and I can let John answer that. But where did it come from originally? It was one of the town visions and goals to be able to offer free transportation to the public. Well, that's a wonderful benefit.

2:31:41 It is. Again, not to overly complicate this, but there are a lot of angles to this. In the summer, one of the things that was considered, I mentioned how successful the Lakes Basin Trolley has become with people riding with their bikes. And in some forms, it's moved beyond just transportation to a form of recreation. Because people are using this as a means to facilitate the recreation, their bike riding down from up there.

2:32:08 So a thought was, well, maybe we look at a fare on that, on just that route, because it really is, in addition to just transportation, it's recreation. The problem with that is it's totally counter to what the U.S. Forest Service wants to do, which is to reduce cars in the lakes basin area and

2:32:28 So if you make it less desirable via a fare to use like space and trolley, then people might be more encouraged to drive a car up there, which is countered again what the Forest Service wants to accomplish. I have a question. How does increased ridership affect your funding? I mean, is it just, how does your, because you have so many funding mechanisms there, which ones are beneficial, which ones are detrimental if you have more riders?

2:32:58 Basically, it doesn't. And it doesn't because we're a rural transit operator, and the funding formulas for rural transit operators are really formula-based, and it's based on population. So as we provide more trips, it doesn't really benefit our funding, unfortunately. Too bad. It does help, though. It does help when we're applying for grants, for some of the FTA grants.

2:33:27 It is very beneficial to show the ridership and the increase in ridership over time. Okay. Yeah. Go ahead. Yeah, and in addition to on the Lakes Basin Trolley, the town was successful in receiving a grant, federal grant, that are going to fund larger bike trailers for the Lakes Basin Trolley and an additional trolley to supplement the existing fleet for the service.

2:33:55 As Peter points out, it is beneficial in that regard that we can show, yes, we're in this little, you know, or small community or small population base, but we provide big time ridership numbers. Combined between just the quote unquote town routes and the contracted Mammoth Mountains area routes, our agency, our authority will provide over a million passenger trips in Mammoth Lakes this year. Because I think

2:34:25 The areas as I was looking at if combining this with, you know, economic development is now I think our challenge is how do we in how does this enhance our economic development and our goals by having free ridership all through town that we now have something to market and people have are using more of that bike trail not because they see it on the road because we actually are marketing it and if we have

2:34:54 Those particular programs in place that now can enhance grants to increase indirect funding sources there, that's something that is newsworthy, PR worthy and then grows the experience in town and that's why it makes sense that it's now under our auspices instead because these two things work together and when we talk about planning routes,

2:35:22 What is it where the stops are? Are the stops enhancing revenue sources? Are they bringing at the right times of day? Are we increasing ridership at certain times of day when more people have the opportunity to use it? And is it something that we push to our visitors as well as us here in the summer just as much as the winter? Because there's a lot of people now that have been coming for years that aren't necessarily car dependent.

2:35:50 Or they don't want to drive because they would rather, they'd much rather ride the very scenic trolley. And do we have enough of those? And if we increase that visitation, can we get more trolleys? And how do we do all that? So that's why it's very exciting to bring it in under Planning and Economic Development because those are the things that we link together for other areas. So that's why the program, I think, is really exciting. See how we can help support it a little bit better.

2:36:19 Excellent point. And public transit service in the town of Mammoth Lakes absolutely contributes to the economic livelihood of the community. The extensive nature of the services that are there, the frequency that is there, the fact that it is fare-free and makes it very easy. And the fact that the way it has been developed over the years...

2:36:41 Contributes to that. That it's not just a means to get from point A to point B, but that family of four sees that open air trolley on a nice summer day like today and says, that looks like fun, let's hop aboard and see where we go. And they end up at the village and they explore that area. Exactly. Yes. And that's what we would walk in. It definitely leads into that. To chime in because I think I 100% agree. I mean, we could probably run four trolleys up in the lakes basin if we have the money to do it. We could, you know, we could.

2:37:09 If we could do things like that would be helpful. And that's where we're looking, so, because the worst thing would be is that we get increased ridership that we can't support and want to make sure that we're doing whatever it takes now that this is a...

2:37:24 Let's say that it is a town-wide initiative that is marketed, that we plan events around these things. Does that qualify us for a grant that we hadn't looked into before? Because now it's different. It's not just an expense. It is something that is a service level that we provide, and we would be telling everybody about that before they even book, because those things are the attractions.

2:37:53 Before they ever get here, not just what they discover once they're here. That's where we really should be working in and help with that particular program. Absolutely. Unfortunately, and again, just in terms of a brief overview and education of transportation for the commissioners,

2:38:11 The vast majority of grants that are available or potentially available to us for transit needs are capital grants at this point. We've pretty well tapped into every source of operating that we can. But again, as Peter pointed out, the significance of transit in this community benefits us in the consideration for capital grants that can help.

2:38:33 Operating. Case in point, right now, we have a grant that's being considered under the TIGER program is the acronym for it. It's a FTA, Federal Transit Administration Grant Program, to enhance and expand the transit operating facility from where we operate the buses here in town. And if we're successful on that, that will lower our operating costs for maintenance and improve and increase the life cycle of the buses.

2:39:01 So even a capital grant can have benefits in terms of reducing operating. So we're all trying to work along those lines. The opportunities are very exciting. Just to chime in, because it is very exciting. And I think when the council, when they went through the first budget process and they made across the board 10% cuts, they didn't realize that that meant service cuts. And then they had to re-

2:39:25 Re-funds so that we could run trolleys till 2 a.m. in the winter months, which is what the guests actually want. Yeah, that was a change. We had to make some changes in the service level late last summer following basically the decree from town administration that all departments had to cut their budgets by 10%. And as Brian points out, in the transit contract,

2:39:53 Budget. The only thing that, the only wiggle room was service hours. And one of the service hours that were cut were the late night trolley service. But again, this came to the attention of the community, both the private sector and the public sector. And in early December, Town Council reinstituted the late night trolley service, which we operated through the bulk of the winter season this winter.

2:40:20 So just again, we're trying to provide a brief overview for the commission. This is new, transit is new to you. Sure. And there has been previously a mobility commission. Thought it might be of value to talk just about a few of the things that the mobility commission previously, some of the outcomes of their commission. And the value to me as the transit operator here is this forum for both the commission and obviously the public and the community to comment on transit and to tell us what's working, what's not, what they'd like to see.

2:40:49 Some of the things that over the years, Mobility Commission brought about, and these aren't in any particular order, but as Brian mentioned, we're operating the Reds and Meadows Service. We included designated time point pickups at the village to provide service to the Reds and Meadows Service from the village that hadn't been there previously.

2:41:10 We expanded service on the Gray Line, one of the community circulator fixed routes to include service to Juniper Springs Resort and the Upper Meridian Street area. Expanded late night, this was several years back, but expanded the late night trolley service to the village that I just mentioned and that has been very well received by the community. Some changes in the Blue Line route that operates around Canyon Boulevard and Lakeview Boulevard added a stop.

2:41:40 On that at the request of the community where there was a long distance between two stops and similarly added a stop on the yellow line on Majestic Pines and Monterey Pines. And last but not least, over the years we have transitioned to scheduled times on all of the routes and that has come to full fruition this summer with the implementation of scheduled times on the trolley routes.

2:42:08 The summer trolley routes, whereas previously it would say service every 20 minutes, but you were left to guess, well, did I just miss it by one minute or will it be 19 minutes until the next one comes? We have posted scheduled times at each of the trolley stops this summer, and that in fact will be enhanced by our next bus system, which is an electronic arrival prediction that people can use any wide variety, smart phones and other things.

2:42:37 To get a real-time prediction of how long until the next bus comes to that stop. So that's just a sampling of a few things the Mobility Commission had addressed and recommended and that were implemented over the past few years. We had a winter and summer workshop. The summer workshop addressed winter transit so we could plan and implement before the winter and vice versa. The winter workshop addressed summer.

2:43:04 And we're hoping to be able to have an opportunity to have input from both the commission and from members of the public who have an interest in transit issues moving forward through your commission. Thank you. Just to follow up a little bit about some of the funding, one of the funding sources, Brian maybe briefly mentioned it, but it is our transit fee program, and previously that was basically a contract between the HOA or the owner of a property.

2:43:34 That has, it's a transient property. And the council just recently adopted CFD 2013-3, which is, takes that place for future properties, which is a transit fee, but they'll pay it through their taxes. And currently that funding source is over $200,000 a year, part of the million dollars a year for service hours. So, you know, we try to grow the funding as things develop and as properties that have impacts on service levels develop.

2:44:07 Mr. Helmet, it's been over a year, maybe longer since I've taken Crest to Reno. I used to do it pretty frequently. And one time, all my friends were out of town, so there was nobody to take me over to McDonald's. And I called Dial-A-Ride, and they said, oh, we don't start until 8.30 because we have to take the school kids. Is there any consideration of coordinating the Crest schedule with the pickup at McDonald's with Dial-A-Ride options for the previous half hour?

2:44:35 And maybe all that's changed. That could have been two years ago. Well, it actually has changed, but not in a positive way from your perspective or what you're raising there. How do you get to McDonald's? We have the community circulator routes, as I mentioned, the purple and gray lines that service much of the community. And they do operate early enough to get folks to

2:45:04 McDonald's in time for the bus to Reno. But our dial ride service is actually starting later now than it used to, and the first 30 minutes to an hour is pre-scheduled with special needs students runs, you know, very young kids. So it's a matter of getting to the bus. Right. Don't pick up at the door. Right. Call me.

2:45:32 I'll get you there. If I'm down. I'm not trying to, but I will make this point. I'm not trying to say that we're purposely not doing something because a community member needs it or whatnot. But there is an option in the town of Mammoth Lakes that doesn't exist anywhere else in Inyo and Mono County, which is a CAF service.

2:45:54 And again, people do have an option here. There literally is no taxi service in the City of Bishop. So if we don't run, there is no option there. Thank you. I just want to comment that I think the new buses look so fantastic. I mean, it really makes me proud to see them driving around, especially in the winter after having all those old Mammoth Mountain buses. And it's really great to see how the trolley is.

2:46:21 It has become a thing. I mean, because I can remember what was the big controversy. Oh, why are we doing that? It's an attraction. It's an attraction. I just don't want to, we just don't want to make it worse to provide that level of service, but marketing is an attraction, and it's for first-time adventurers, you're just not used to this, and that is, that's part of the attraction out there that you can immerse and do something and get outside. A lot of people, that's it.

2:46:47 Thank you very much for that comment. I appreciate that. Not only do they look nice, but they're much easier to use too. There's a low floor design, one step on your abort. And that's been commented on very favorably. That's huge. We are supposed to mention further changes. There are, I will mention, there are a couple of specific items that we were looking to implement that we wanted to have any comment. I'm not seeing anyone here. I'm not sure that there will be. But from the commission, and at least the commission has advised and can comment on these.

2:47:15 There are three proposed either addition or modifications to existing bus stops. First, we would propose to add a bus stop on Sierra Park Road across from McDonald's, at the entrance to McDonald's on Sierra Park Road. And in fact, this is to accommodate those riders who are using that to access the Reno or Lancaster buses. That'd be great. They can use the Purple Ride. There is no stop there right now. There's an informal one, but we thought, well,

2:47:46 Maybe we should formalize this. All we're proposing is that a sign be placed at the north end of the driveway into the employee parking lot, the courthouse employee parking lot. Normally the bus would pull into the parallel parking area there if there are no cars, which is most days, but if there's a big trial or a jury selection going on and there are cars parked there, we would stop just momentarily in that driveway and then proceed on. So that's one.

2:48:13 Secondly, we're proposing to add a stop on Meridian between Old Mammoth Road and Azimuth. Right now, there's no stop on eastbound Meridian for our routes that travel there from basically Manzanita to Old Mammoth Road, which is a long distance. We've looked at it. There is a sufficient area to provide a stop there.

2:48:38 Again, between Azimuth and Old Mammoth Road, so we would propose to add a stop there. And lastly, this is a very minor change. At the bus turnout at the hospital on Sierra Park Road, and there is an actual curb cut, concrete curb cut there, the sign itself is on the entrance side as opposed to the exit side of that pullout, but people in the loading door is at the exit side, so we just want to move the sign.

2:49:06 Along to the other end of that. Then the other proposed service change for consideration, and Chair Duggan mentioned, you know, in terms of having our ridership and spending our dollars where our ridership and where it's contributing to economic vitality of the community. I have brought to staff's attention the fact that our weekend dial ride service, which has always been weak, has gotten extremely weak over the last year.

2:49:35 And we provide less than one passenger trip per hour on the dial ride service. It averaged 5.8 trips per day over the course of the last year as measured there. And that's as compared to over 22 trips per day on weekdays for the service. So, and again, there were several days, not all, obviously, but there were some days without any passenger trips.

2:50:04 So again, wanting to spend transit dollars wisely and brought this to staff's attention and we wanted to bring it to the commission, be it mobility or now the Planning and Economic Development Commission, to say, is this a wise use of the monies or should we look at a modification or doing away with weekend dollar ride? So I bring that to staff and to the commission's attention. Just to, again, I'm trying to not overload you with...

2:50:33 Transit information today, but this being your first opportunity at it. There is a requirement under the Americans with Disabilities Act that transit operators that operate fixed drought service, which we do, provide complementary paratransit service to individuals who are functionally unable to use fixed drought service. We've always provided that transit service with dial-a-ride during the hours that we operate fixed drought service, or we make special arrangements if we don't have dial-a-ride during those hours.

2:51:02 That would be, if weekend dial-a-ride service were done away with, we would need to continue to provide or make special arrangements when that situation arose. But this is service that is available only to individuals who have been deemed certified eligible by either our transit agency or another transit agency for this complimentary ADA paratransit service. So it's not that, that is a value.

2:51:31 On some level that we get from weekend dial-a-ride service now, although again I would mention to the commission it is very infrequent that we have an ADA eligible rider for those services. I'd just like to point out that when it started there was nothing but dial-a-ride in this town and it was used sort of as a free taxi service around town and of course we have private taxis that want to make a living too but the point is we've curtailed dial-a-ride

2:52:01 As a taxi service, in lieu of providing things like trolleys, which moves somewhere like 25 or 26 people per hour versus a dial ride that's not even necessarily moving somebody who is certified to need it, 0.5 an hour over the weekends. So service hours or service hours. So we're either paying a dial ride person to just basically sit there or we can...

2:52:26 Augment a line or put those service hours somewhere else. So that's where this request comes from. The tremendous growth that you've seen in our ridership has really come because we curtailed a dial-a-ride and built up fixed service lines to the point now where they're actually on a time schedule and working quite well. So I just wanted to give a little bit more background on where this comes from because we think it actually enhances service in town. Makes sense.

2:52:53 Weekend dial ride amounts to 728 service hours per year, which equates to just over $30,000 based on our current contract rate. So what would you use the extra, if you switched out, what would you use it for? Well, we used to run, we used to have 19,000 service hours and due to budget cuts and whatnot, we're down to 18,000 hours. So basically,

2:53:19 We would look to see where those additional service hours, those 700 could be put. So we really actually still wouldn't be back to where we were, what, two years ago, John? Right. And we don't have a specific proposal to say that we want to add this new route or add these hours to an existing route. One thing I would say is that the town, last December, council approved the expansion of the late night service hours to go until late 2 a.m.

2:53:48 Which was basically, in many ways, unfunded. And that was to the tune of $25,000. So that's the better part of that. So I don't know for sure, but it might be looked at as a means to fund that additional. That's where it should be. Absolutely. And as long as you still think you can fulfill the requirements of, you know, that was for those that are truly

2:54:16 The ADA requirements through another mechanism or how do we take care of that? If you're not providing the service, can the local taxi services provide this? I doubt it. I'm not aware that they have any accessible equipment. I think, again, on those special occurrence basis is we could work out under our current contract with the town just to bill for those hours when they occur. But, again, that's very infrequent.

2:54:44 And we're certainly not talking about not providing service. Exactly. They will still have that service. It's just that we believe it will be so minimal that we can manage it based on call instead of schedule. And it requires a 24-hour notice to the transit provider.

2:55:07 So do you need like a vote from, what do you need from us? So really what we're looking for is consensus on the changes, any budget average will go back to town and maybe into council for budget adjustments, but essentially we're looking for consensus on the changes that are proposed and they'll be implemented. Is there any further discussion needed on the changes that were proposed as far as the routes and things now? I don't think so. I think you have consensus there.

2:55:36 Makes sense. We're glad to see that, you know, what is going into consideration is based on need, ridership, right buses is the right area. The scheduling works, I mean, when you talked about there will be an app that you could go eventually and get that. Reminds us of Elizabeth I, we were in, I believe it was Whistler, or Vail, where there was an electronic sign that said, next bus there. And we all thought how wonderful it is, but...

2:56:05 By not doing that, now we can take advantage of less intrusive technology and those things. We're really glad to see those particular things there because that's the number one question from our guests is when will it be there. And to say that Mammoth Lakes Tourism, you know, operates an app there that you can go up to any one of these and through your smartphone be able to see when the next bus goes there.

2:56:31 I mean, and that's coming, whether it is now, but those things that you don't have to invest in infrastructure. Right. We had that on the red line this winter, and I hope to have that in place for the trolley within three weeks. Good deal. Exciting. Thank you. Wonderful. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Just one more. Most of these commission media or these workshops actually are not well attended. Occasionally in the past they have been well attended, especially when there's been controversial changes like

2:57:01 The major change with dial ride reduction in service increases in other service. In the future, we'll try to do a little more outreach also with the Hispanic community so that they've got an opportunity to be here so we'll post public notices in Spanish as well as English. That is one of our requirements with the ADA and Department of Justice. Thank you. Thank you very much. We have to honor item on the consent agenda, which is minutes of the May 8th meeting.

2:57:31 Yeah, entertain a motion or we can move it forward. Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Miss approved. Commissioners report this time. Does anyone have anything they'd like to? I have a topic but I'm going to save it for July because it's only. Okay. And I would like a little discussion about it. Okay. Okay. Oh, we have something juicy for the next meeting. Wonderful. Director's report.

2:58:00 I will very quickly go through a couple of items. On hirings, we recently hired a permit tech, Jamie Wolf, you probably saw her when you picked up the packets. So she's a permanent full-time employee. She will be our permit tech. She just got her master's degree in architecture last Saturday, I think. So yeah, we're really excited to have her here, and she's doing great so far. We're conducting the interviews for the Community and Economic Development Director in a couple weeks.

2:58:28 Late July, I think, so we'll let you know how that goes. We're interviewing human resource managers tomorrow. I'll be in interviews all day tomorrow on that. And just a heads up that we may be asking to schedule a special meeting for July 24th for the Planning Commission. We'll let you know, but just a heads up, we may be asking for that.

2:58:50 And also on special meetings, if you're not already aware, the town council's having a special priorities meeting on July 8th at 2.30. It's a Monday. They're going to have a second meeting on July 9th at 3 o'clock. So July 8th at 2.30 on Monday, Tuesday, July 9th at 3 o'clock just to discuss the town council's priorities. So that's all I have. Question, with such a reduction in staff, why do we need a full-time human resources person?

2:59:20 Even though we have small staff, there's still a significant amount of work, human resources, and risk analyst, person responsible for it includes all recruitment, day-to-day tasks, grievances, workers' complaints, setting up trainings, both mandated and not mandated, and about a million other things. So I definitely think that there's more work.

2:59:47 Just real quickly, where are we with the water efficiency?

3:00:18 The Water Efficient Landscape Ordinance. Jessica, I believe, had a meeting on that a couple weeks ago with the Water District, and I think we may need to schedule the July 24th so she can come before you that day for that. But it should be coming forward in the next month and a half or so, two months, to the Planning Commission. Okay. The reason I ask is because I know that Earl Henderson has, and I'll talk to Jessica, has been working with a lot of the

3:00:48 Local, you know, condo association people, business people, and I don't know if it's the water district program or our program, but there's a lot of complaint that's just not practical. The current program is not. No, I think it's the proposed one that they think, don't think it's practical. Well, we've been working with Earl as a part of the process. I think he's on the board.

3:01:10 He's on the water board. He's on the water board. So we've been working with the water board and the water district on this, and we've been engaging him. Okay. So as long as he's involved, then that's good. Okay. About meeting date changes, I didn't understand why the June 12th meeting was canceled. And yet we do, now that we're down to one meeting a month, generally, we do plan our lives around it. And Colin was really disappointed he couldn't be here today. So can we...

3:01:39 Stick to that meeting at the beginning of the month, generally, that we all plan on, and then special meetings, we'll see if we can work out. We try to. This meeting, we had these public hearings that people wanted to move forward in this timely manner, so that's why we asked for this special meeting. And I was not, I was out of town on business on the 12th, which would have not given you a forum. Well, maybe it would have with Colin, but I probably flipped a coin we wouldn't have had for.

3:02:09 Yeah, we do try to do that, but I think that with the zoning code update, we're going to have more items that are going to be coming before you in the next couple months, so we may be asking for some special meeting dates. Okay. Well, we were all used to two meetings a month. I know, now you're... We just count on those Wednesdays. Yes. That's all I have. Okay. Thank you. I see the future agenda items that are on here coming forward, so those are things that are in the pipeline.

3:02:35 If there's nothing else, no commissioner's reports at this time, we'll save them. And at that point, we will move to adjourn at this time, adjourn our meeting until our next meeting on July, scheduled meeting is July 10th. Thank you.