TransparentMammoth

Trails Committee · 2013

Trails Committee

· recording 1 hr 40 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

202 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

2:50 Call to order the meeting of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee for Monday, August 5, 2013 at 1.30. Steve, if we could have the roll call. Roll call. Stu Brown. Here. Sandy Hogan. Here. Bill Souser. Absent. Bill Taylor. Here. John Turner. Absent. Okay, this is the time on the agenda for any comments from the public for items that are not otherwise posted on the agenda. Mr. McFarland.

3:28 Hey everybody, Paul McFarlane with Friends of the Inyo. I was just going to come up and give a little quick update on this past weekend. We worked the consolidated mine up at the Coldwater Trailhead. Had 37 folks turn out, which for a smoky day was really pretty good. Did a variety of work. We sent a group all the way up the Duck Pass Trail and they cut some trees out of Arrowhead Lake, which had fallen and folks were creating go-rounds. So those were cut out and then the trailhead...

3:57 Trail Tread down to Arrowhead was fixed. And then my group and another leader, Chris, took two groups over to the consolidated mine and we fixed the trail up to the compressor, which was in dangerous shape. It basically covered in scree. It's now, looks like a wilderness freeway. And we also delineated some loops through the historic buildings, whereas before people were just kind of scattering out, walking everywhere.

4:23 Now we have delineated paths that lead you by every building and back in a nice big loop. And we did what we call duffing, basically restored all of the other little use trails that were going to the buildings and other places to try to get some more controlled use up there. We took down 18 signs and painted them. We stayed late and painted the rest of them. And there was some talk about coordinating, putting some of those back up.

4:51 I actually went up this morning and put all the safety signs back up to keep off the building signs back up before that coordination could occur because those need to go up. That place really needs some care for some of those buildings, so I hope something can come to fruition to allow some stabilization work to be done on those because they're not in good shape. And in the past couple of weeks,

5:16 The program has really exploded. We've worked with the kids from the Mammoth Mountain Ski Team twice, taken them out for full days and done work in the Mammoth Lakes Basin. We also actually got a call from a family that has a second home here, the Porter family, and they had a group of kids that they were bringing up, 17 to 18-year-old kids, and they saw that we do stewardship and they wanted to see if we could put together a project for them.

5:42 So for this family, longtime second homeowners in town, we put together a weekend project over two days. The kids brushed out the trail all the way at Valentine and then helped us put up the last of the signs at Panorama two weeks ago. So all of the signs under our contract for the new temporary signage are done and in place. And I think with that, John, you wanted to say something else about this weekend? Yeah. Went really smooth. Yeah. Thanks, Paul. To Paul's point,

6:11 The numbers are holding steady. They're actually getting better and growing stronger as the summer goes by. The next event is going to be at Hawk Creek, August 17th. Do you have a question? Just for the record, your name. Oh, I'm sorry. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA, following up with Paul McFarland. The next event coming up is Hawk Creek, August 17th. I think we'll be working with the Forest Service in Fenzino this Thursday. Site visit, start getting that figured out. It's a very interesting opportunity for a very important site in town.

6:40 So we're working on that. So the programs are really going small. There'll be one other event after that in September. This is the end of the back-to-back events. They'll wrap everything up. That's the Coastal Cleanup Day. A couple other, anything else on the summer stewardship? Yeah, okay. Hi, I'm Laura Beardsley, friends of Inyo. But I wanted to switch a little bit from the Trails Days and

7:06 Extend a thank you that we've received for the interpretive programs that are going on in the Lakes Basin right now. We have programs happening five days a week and we've had a steady increase in popularity of those programs. We received this beautiful postcard of Yellowstone National Park in our offices, but it says, Dear Friends of the Inyo, this year we return to camp at Lake Mary once again.

7:31 Your tour directors enriched our vacation immensely, underlined. Carol gave us the geology tour of McLeod Lake Saturday and the night hike that evening. Wow. We learned much. We'll pass on to grandchildren. Sunday, Rebecca Stubbs gave us a perfect tour of wildflowers on a hike to Heart Lake. Please extend our thanks to them and to all who made it possible. Regards, Hillary and Tim.

7:59 Thank you. I just wanted to point that out because they're return visitors. They're sharing it with their children. And they've made these interpretive tours part of their summer vacation here. So thanks. Thank you. Just to follow up on that, I've got another topic to talk about. But I'm the proud owner of a new dog. And that dog spends a lot of time walking the lakes basin. I'm happy to see these lakes basin stewards out on a whole variety of trails, all kinds of different places.

8:26 The signs, the interpretive tours, and all that stuff is really going great. So thanks a lot to you guys for providing that. A couple other quick things. The website update. The website is generating a lot of traffic, with a special thanks to Mammoth Lakes Tourism and to others, but it's out there on the internet. The last month was about 10,000 visits, about 35,000 page views, about 7,400 unique visits. That's in the last 30 days. It's really, we're finishing up with a meeting on the management program.

8:55 It's working and it's doing things. The second thing is the Lakes Basin Path. I know the town's got counters out on trails around town. We've got a couple counters up in Lakes Basin Path. Looks like the traffic this year is up about 15%, 20% on Lakes Basin Path. So that continues to increase in popularity. I'm not sure what the town's seeing with their data, but about the same thing. So that's it. Thank you very much. My name is Susie Jackson, and I just have a suggestion for the path that goes up.

9:35 I live on Majestic Pines that dead ends down at Waterford, you know, that goes down, and there's a nice path that goes up there. About halfway up, there's a doggy bag dispenser and a trash can. But when you start down at Waterford, there isn't anything. And people that have dogs like I do, you know, you walk up that path and you see so much.

10:05 Doggy leaving is all on the side and I thought it would be a good idea if you could install one of those doggy bag dispensers and then a little trash can. It's so easy because it's right there and there's one halfway up but there's not one at the beginning of the trail. So that was just my suggestion. Great, thank you. Any other comments from the public? Okay, I guess we'll move on to...

10:40 Haislip Hayes, Associate Engineer, Town of Mammoth Lakes. Steve asked me to come by and give you guys a couple updates on a number of things ranging from the recently stolen sign out at Mammoth Creek Park East to the standards manual to our CIP. I've asked Nate Greenberg to join me because he's helping out with a number of these different items.

11:00 I don't know how much detail you really want me to go into some of these things. I can go in pretty deep if you want. But just a brief overview of the CIP program. We've completed the CIP for 13-14. It has not yet been adopted. I don't have a schedule for adoption given Ray's recent departure. A number of projects are under construction, as you've probably noticed. The College Connector Path, the sidewalks on Sierra Nevada, Mammoth Creek Park Connector is going to start here shortly.

11:28 And we've begun design work on Mammoth Creek Park gap filler, the Waterford project, and we're designing a number of other items. I don't know if you guys have any specific questions about any of the specific projects. I'm happy to answer them. Any questions? No, I'm good. I was wondering what the timing was for construction on Waterford, if you know. We are at 10% design. We're still going through the schematic drawings. We're doing some value engineering as far as bridging and craning to different configurations.

11:56 As it stands right now, we anticipate construction early next summer. We are on schedule as long as we don't hit any snags with any environmental issues. We should be on pace to begin. Excellent. Thank you. Moving on to the standards manual, we have triad engineering cleaning up the last little bits of the standards we just received the other day. The last iteration, there's a couple other cleanup points, and then we'll be taking the...

12:26 Standards Manual Forward for Adoption, I'm hoping sometime in September, early October. Again, depending on our schedule considering raised departure, we have to balance things a little bit differently. It's complete overhaul of the entire Standards Manual from the very specifics to, you know, capital construction to the signage and wayfinding program, which has all been integrated into this new Standards Manual. I have a draft copy if you guys want to look at it.

12:54 But that's pretty much the status of that. I don't know if you have any questions specific to the standards. Just to – I'm sorry. Go ahead. If the draft's available, yes, I'd like. Yeah, it's not publicly available, but I'm happy to share that with you guys. Okay. So it's not – that's what I was curious about was whether it was publicly available. The other question is in the interim, if we have any more trail signage.

13:20 to be installed between now and the time of adoption. Will we be using these standards even though they aren't formally adopted? Absolutely, yeah. I want to make sure that that's part of the program, so good. Yeah, we're not going to be changing anything that's really standardized in there. And as far as, do you have any more questions on the standards? Not really, just, there, I guess, is that on? Yeah, yeah, now I am. With any of these, like, will they,

13:48 Come before us before actually going to the town? No, they'll go to the town council, yeah. Okay, so in other words, this is just perhaps, okay, if we want to look at it. I'm interested in your comments if you have anything, but it's pretty straightforward, the engineering stuff. Okay. And last but not least, we have the issue of the sign that was stolen on Mammoth Creek East. We are working, the town is working with the county to...

14:14 Rebuild those signs, but we have to update them. We can't replace them with the images that were used previously because they're no longer accurate. We've actually completed some segments of the path in the time that that's been up. So Nate's here to answer any technical questions, but we're moving forward with bringing those new images forward and getting those produced by Pinier. We're looking at probably a couple months before we actually get that reinstalled. Any questions?

14:48 I didn't realize that. Actually, a missing sign. So we can't duplicate what was there? Yeah, they stole the whole frame. Yeah. We do have the images to reproduce the sign as it was, but that would not be accurate because we have completed the college connector path and we'll have the metal lane connector path completed by the time the sign was completed.

15:11 So it's only, you know, we should go through the process to update those path connections. Right. And so Nadez and his crew are working to do that and we'll be submitting those updated images for production. So will we update every sign in town that way? Over time, yes. Over time. Yeah. I think probably in the next year or two we're going to have to come forward and actually get some funding to reproduce these signs because we've built so many paths and we have so many more on the

15:40 Not so distant future. Okay. That we're going to have to replace a number of signs to get them current. Right. It's not really a discussion item for the moment, but I believe we talked at the last meeting about the need to have the signs on. So a regular rotation, whether it's every two years to just make sure that they're current. Exactly. Exactly. This was, this is, I'll call this taking advantage of the situation. Yeah. Yeah. Opportunistic. Yeah. Okay, okay. But I think that regular rotation, exactly, rather than sign by sign by sign.

16:09 Yeah. Yeah. Any more questions? Jason, if you address the college connector sign set. Yeah, it's the same process. So Nate is working to streamline the production for future signage and bringing that all into ArcGIS for future production. We have the sign frames being built by a local fabricator. Those are under construction.

16:34 And then the sign images will follow shortly after that, probably about the same time frame. The rest of the path is substantially complete. The only other hiccup was the delivery of the solar lighting, which I learned was actually coming from Europe, because that's the only place they could use that type of paint to match the color of all of our other lighting.

16:55 Yeah. So those are on a container ship coming over. They should be here in the next couple of days, actually, and then they'll be installing them, the contractors in town working on another project. And it's just basically the lighting and the signage, and then that project will be completed. And then finally, Hais, can you report tomorrow the Recreation Commission is looking at making or taking the recommendation from the committee and approving funding for the eight new interpretive signs?

17:26 Can you give a little bit of information on the bidding process and how long that might take once we get that approval tomorrow? I haven't been involved with that process, but just in general, once we have funding and we can move it forward, it's just a matter of putting together a bid package and flying that through the typical process. It could probably take a month or so before we could get a contract around board and then sending out for fabrication. I don't know what the intent, if it was going to be a local or if they were going to...

17:55 I don't know. Thank you. So the reason I asked the question about the standards was just that I noted that I happened to walk down the path here. I noted that the bollard right up right there at the intersection of Sierra Park and Meridian wasn't the same design as the ones up in the basin.

18:23 So it wasn't so much about that one as making sure that if we go forward, we have a consistent design. Is that the design that's on the lakes basin path? So there's a difference in those bollards because of funding. So they're the forever wood on a number of bollards in town, and these are just regular wood. The difference in each bollard is about $600. There wasn't funding available to put those ever wood bollards in there, so we're using just a regular wooden one.

18:51 But then it also doesn't have the MLTS. The ballers didn't have those. It was the mile markers. And those mile markers will have the MLTS logo. We've ordered those with the... It was less consistent about the material than the design. Okay. When you say with ballers, I was thinking the center posts were... And the mile markers have the logo that you're talking about. Yeah. Those will have the MLTS logo on. Any more questions? All right. Thank you. Thanks.

19:26 Thanks, Hais. Okay, consent agenda. Does anybody want to pull either of the items from the consent calendar? I wasn't there on July 8th, but I'm fine with it. I just kind of had a couple of minor wordsmithing things, but... Okay, let's pull the... You want to pull them? Okay. Pull the minutes. Okay. And what were your comments? On page, the second page, I know this was our consensus on our vision that maybe it needs...

20:07 There may be a little bit of minor wordsmithing. Will we get a chance to actually, you know, not to change the thought of it, but I think there were a couple of little things that, there was a little bit there that could be changed. And then right under it says options for discussions related to strategy and priority established were postponed. And on the next page I would, the temporary sign status, that was Panorama Dome. It wasn't clear to me. Or was it Mountain View or was it?

20:42 I'm sorry, item two, under six. Temporary signs were discussed. Yeah, that was Panorama Dome. It looks like it was, if that was Roy Moyer, that was probably Panorama Dome. Okay, okay, yeah, and you might want to add Moyer. It just wasn't clear to me. Other than that, that was it. So I moved to approve it as amended. Okay. I'll second. Okay.

21:14 Any other discussion? All in favor? Aye. And then the second item on the consent calendar is the staff report and consultant recap for August fail. Any comments? Nope. Looks good. A motion for approval? We don't have to do it. Nope. Well, no, it is a consent agenda item also. So we'll have to do it because we pulled the first one. Other than to approve? Accept?

21:41 I don't think we have to do anything with it. It's just there for information. Okay. Okay, on to business matters. September meeting. Steve? Yeah, due to the fact that we have Labor Day coming up, I thought it might be appropriate if we discussed our calendars and see when the most effective time to have a September meeting would be. Take a day off. So Monday, September 2nd is the first Monday of the first complete week of the month.

22:13 I'd be fine either way, depending on you guys' calendars. The 9th would work for me or the rest of that week. Yeah, but either of those works fine for me. I don't know, do you want to do a doodle poll with Bill and...

22:50 Sean, or should we just pick a date and they can... The backup, maybe? Yeah, let's pick a date and a time and then ask them if they have a problem. The, uh, I'm assuming the rec commission's going to meet on the 3rd? Mm-hmm, it is. So the 3rd's probably not a good day unless we want to do it in the morning. Should we just go for the next one? I think we could and maybe pick a backup date just in case. Yep, I'm fine. So why don't we just move it a week? Yep. And then if...

23:29 Any suggestion for a back-up date? Does that work for you, Sarah? Okay, so you're referring to Monday the 9th? Uh-huh. Yes. Okay. Okay. And our detailer should be in by then, so I'm ready to introduce it. Great. I want to do a back-up, then, for the first week, just in case Sean is... I know sometimes Sean travels so much that he's only here that one week. Well, as I said, I'm really open pretty much any day. Av dreams are always better. Yeah.

24:02 Sarah and Stu, what about you guys? The week before, is there any afternoon that's good or bad for you? So, the week of the seconds. Yeah, Labor Day. Tuesday, Tuesday and Friday are best in the afternoon. Your best? The third and that's six. Six. I know Tuesday's bad. Yeah. Yep. Wednesday's council, but that's at the end of the day. How about Friday? Yep.

24:37 Thirsty? Maybe Thursday's better? Thirsty work? I'm trying to do Thursday afternoon because I have my staff meeting with my staff. So then how about Friday? Friday afternoon? There's a backup? There's a backup? Friday? Okay, 1.30? Yeah. So that'd be okay. So we'll send out an email calling it for the 9th.

25:05 At 1.30, and if that doesn't work out, then we'll switch over and make it Friday the 6th at 1.30. Sounds good. Consensus? Yep. Okay. Sounds good. Okay, the MLTS website content enhancement contract status. Yes, as part of your package, I included printouts, two-sided, four pages each page.

25:36 In an attempt to not waste too much paper, but to give you the information. Hopefully your eyes are similar to mine than with corrections. I'd like to put a glass of plastic you can read. So that is presented then for your information. I think the thing to focus on really is on the third page, the back side.

26:03 Exhibit A, Scopes of Services. The town has been endeavoring to work diligently with the contractor who's here today to get a full understanding of what that scope is, how that scope is to be delivered to the town, and the monies then that that particular scope is worth as far as the maximum fee.

26:32 For those services. So again, we've had a number of meetings, we've had a number of discussions and emails, and even last week there was a clarification to the scope. The scope's actually been reduced to eliminate, if you are referring then to the milestones on Exhibit A, Milestone 1, Task A, Sub 2, Interpretive Content.

27:01 And under B-sub-2 interpretive content, that work was done earlier by an effort with count staff and U.S. Forest Service, so that those particular tasks are not needed at this time from the consultant, and so the request then for the proposal for that work would be to that conceptual development of the interpretive content as delivered.

27:30 My understanding is that very quickly here we are going to get the products that are called for out of Milestone 1 from the consultant and then we've been requested, the town, the partners to try and expedite that contract revision as quickly as possible so that no resources are lost or capability by that contractor.

27:58 So we sent out an advisory email today to those partners advising them of that and also providing them with copies of the contract that they can review ahead of time before receiving the proposal. So I'm happy to say that we're moving forward. I think we're making good progress. And I hope that the contractor is satisfied with the work that we've been providing.

28:26 Thank you. Any questions or comments from committee members? Just that I actually appreciated having the contract. I thought this was just fine. I put on my post-reading glasses, but that gives me a good idea of what a good contract looks like, and I think it's well written, and I notice that the town is well protected in there as it should be. And so I would, you know, in the future, if we do want to go over a contract.

28:55 This format works for me just fine. It's worth spending the time on and knowing what's going on. I actually noted that it was actually, I think that, correct me if I want to ask you, but I think there's a newer version that doesn't include the water quality management and compliance section. Yeah, I think it got removed, yeah. Probably so. I've got that new version. I mean, it was very good. I know there's a lot of boilerplate for people or whatever, but, you know, as a former government employee, I expect to see something like that, so that's great to see. And if I may, Chair, I'm just going to briefly update because it seems like it's a relevant time where I can bring it up.

29:25 Later in projects. So the way with the hand-off with Ray's departure, Steve's pretty much our designated appointee. I've been appointed from the town manager, you know, from Ray's functions. So I'm taking over everything that Ray was doing with MLTPA in trails, and then Steve's really essentially our project manager for these contracts and the day-to-day staffing of the MLTSCC. As such, what we're looking at is a lot more probably time

29:54 Than we budgeted in the past with the scope of work. So Steve brought it to my attention recently and we might bring forward an item of the next agenda just to see if we can identify some funds that we might have to tap into just to provide oversight of the contracts that we're managing. If that's okay with the chair and the committee, we'll probably bring that forward in September. I think it's very prudent. This will cover your time.

30:23 It's really more Steve's time. And Steve's, okay. And I think where it's really going, because Ray's out of the equation, you know, it was Ray, myself, and Steve. Now there's no Ray, but we still need, you know, the oversight. So, you know, Steve manages it day to day. He reports back to me. He said, my time's already covered, but it's really additional time for Steve that was Ray. Okay. Outside your contract, over and above your contract. So we've lost Ray, but I'm still there, but someone still needs to provide oversight.

30:50 That's something I think would be very prudent for the committee to review and take action on. Okay. So the other part about that as well is that the website enhancement contract is a fall 2012 measure R. Measure R. Which is outside the $300,000 and it's allocated for. Right. So that's why it's not a direct part of the existing scope of work. Right. And I think as that moves forward, and I'm sure there's...

31:20 Probably going to be more enhancements to that website. I'm assuming it would fall under the MLTACC's purview, right, out of measure R. Exactly. Okay. So that will come forward next time. We'll bring the amendment to the scope, yeah. Because there might be additional funds that we might have to identify in our budget. Right. But that will be September. Thank you. Any comments from the public? Okay. Okay, there being none.

31:51 We move on to the mission and vision. And Steve. Yes, as reflected in the minutes, I did my best to capture what was written on the board at the time and the discussions. And so that's why we have brought this forward for what I would call a vote adoption, whereas before I think we had general consensus with the direction to do a little wordsmithing, maybe a little punctuation and things that were necessary.

32:23 The purpose of this mission and vision dated October 5, 2013 is again to put in writing in front of us the recommendation as I understood it from the committee in its last meeting. So the vision statement there is captured to the best of my ability as well as the mission statement. And then the second half of this item is then our opportunities and options for discussing.

32:53 The related strategies and priorities that the committee wants to establish and that those outlined items are in the second page. So if we can focus on the mission division, I think we're ready to do that. So let's see, I started with you last time, Stu. Any comments on the language for the mission division? Yeah, I think the committee did a great job.

33:20 I missed that meeting in July. I had one question as it related to vision, and it was relating to the context. Did the committee consider adding in a language such as the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is the best set of recreational trials and programs in the country, integrated wayfinding interpretation? I don't know if, did the committee consider that? Because I know it's part of that rec strats, remember the rec strats vision is the...

33:47 I think we talked about it. I think it was originally in the world, and I think we dropped it down. The country? Just put the best set, or the best, yeah, yeah. But I just don't know if that, does that provide enough? There's something in there that doesn't quite flow right for me. Yeah, yeah. You did have that discussion. I didn't know if you had it, so. Yeah, the best set part was a little bit that got, I wasn't sure of, but I understood why we kind of dropped the others, it's, you know. I mean, because if we aligned it, yeah, if we aligned it with the Rekstrats one, then it would be.

34:16 Consistent, so to speak. But, yeah, I think, like the chair said, some context would be helpful. Because the best set could be the best set. Mammoth could be the best set. It's the best set in the universe. I'm happy with the universe. But anyway, that's the only language that I just kind of recommend on the vision. I thought the mission was good. It covered a lot of what we wanted to accomplish. Only thing on the mission, I would say,

34:48 Second from the last line should be probably support, because you're talking about projects, programs, and budgets. Instead of plural? Yes, instead of plural. All right. I did look at that too. I thought that might have been. Yeah. That support implementation of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. Is that? Maintenance and, yeah, that support implementation, yeah. I thought that was great. Through projects, programs, and budgets, that support implementation? Or would you say that supports?

35:17 No, not plural, because you're talking about projects, programs, and budgets. And projects that support the implementation of the Mammoth Lakes, would you say support the implementation? Yeah, that might. That's grammatically correct. Might clean that up, right? Yeah. Yeah, I think drop yes. That support, yes, drop yes, and just add the. Yeah, well, the vision, I know it's not perfect, but I think it's pretty good. I think it really captured the essence of what we talked about, you know, and we had a lot of input, we had input actually from the public, too, on it.

35:47 It was turned into a little workshop exercise, and we kept trying to make a little more concise, I think is what it was. And I think that's where the in the world got cut out, because it was in the world originally, is what we had. I'd like to think about it a minute. Do we have any comments from the public? Just, I'm having the same straight, it's a little...

36:14 It's a little clumsy and inelegant. Right, something's not there. It did capture what we talked about. That's the thing. And I don't want to change anything to the substance of it. Right. No, I... Yeah, it's only the phraseology. That's why I'm struggling. Yeah, yeah, yeah. But I don't know... Do we want to wait until the full committee comes back? Could we do that? Chair, and maybe give them the two options and see where they want to weigh in on it? Or maybe, yeah, Steve, maybe...

36:41 What do you think, Steve? Can we give you one more, a little stab at it to see if... Maybe we can all, now that we've highlighted that we're all kind of a little uncomfortable with that. It's just not quite perfect, but... Those two words are... Yeah, but it did capture the substance, and that's why I don't want to necessarily change anything unless everybody else is here. So consensus at this point would be to say that it is the best set... Well, the problem is that's what we're struggling with. Yeah. We like everything except...

37:11 Only the phraseology. The context of it. If it was the best recreational trails program in the world, if it sort of would flow better. In California, Utah. But we talked about that, but I want to go bigger than California. Good. I'm happy within the country. So I think that's maybe the consensus is to weigh it in, have it weighed in with the full committee at the next meeting.

37:33 And have them consider that. I'd be interested in going ahead and approving the mission statement, however, as... Yep, because it's good. With the deletion of the S. And in addition of the... Do I have a motion? No, you don't need the the. You're okay? No. Okay. Can I get clarification on your comments, too? So we're dropping the S off support. Yep. That's it. Any other changes? Nope. Okay, I'm sorry. Motion? I'll move that we accept the mission statement as amended.

38:04 Second? Any other discussion? All in favor? Aye. Aye. So with that, we'll carry the vision statement over to see if we can come up with something that just focuses on that is the best set of language and see if we can fix that.

38:25 And we'll bring that back to the next meeting. And if anybody's got an idea, I'm sure Steve wouldn't mind. You know what, I think it's some sort of minor tweaking, but I kept trying to do it and I couldn't. I gagged on the same thing. Okay. Now that discussion moves to strategy and priorities, under each category there's a listing of six to seven items that help to define the strategies and also the priorities.

38:56 Looking for various aspects for funding. So under strategies we have enhanced accessibility for all as being a dedicated strategy that we would adopt. Maintain character of the town, the community, and the Inyo National Forest. Number three, maximize community engagement with users. Then we have a list of various users. Four, develop infrastructure through building.

39:26 Maintaining facilities, five, develop programming activities, six, develop emotional activities via mammothrails.org, generate media awareness, and public outreach. I think if we start talking about the strategies first, then we can move into the priorities. Okay. Okay. Any questions before we start? Just comments. No questions. Well, maybe the question about number three, actually. Just the way the format.

39:56 The users, this is meant to be a list of users because stewardship isn't actually users. I didn't understand your format here. Maybe, yes, maybe stewardship may. Right, or high altitude training. Maybe users through the Summer of Stewardship Program. Yeah, that's more than that. You just change that to volunteers? Oh, stewardship, the word stewardship to volunteers, yeah, that would work.

40:35 I think stewardship could almost be a strategy on its own, shouldn't it, really? I mean, is that... Yeah, could be, huh? I mean, is for kind of what we're really saying, develop infrastructure through building and maintaining facilities, and would facilities equal trails? Would it be just stewardship? Mammoth Trails, to me, that doesn't say people. That says an organization or something. Trail users? I don't know. Well, I think that was Mammoth Trails, that organization.

41:04 That meets the MLTPA overseas. That's that mammoth trials user group where the members of... That group. That's that group, yeah. Okay. But it is sort of a mixed bag there because we've got a user group and we have an organization. We have two organizations, two sort of... Yeah, it's a little mixed jumble. Two types of users, residents and visitors. And then we have...

41:34 Two activities, stewardship and high altitude training. So I see what you're... Yeah, that was my kind of struggle with it. I wasn't quite sure. So I think it just needs a little more work. I get the idea. I'm just not sure that the words are, you know. But I do think maximizing the community engagement, yeah, is, that's a good strategy. Yeah, I did have some sort of background questions on this. Does everybody on the committee have a copy of the trail system master plan? Oh, yeah. You know, Sean and Bill have copies.

42:04 And did you go through that and see what it might have said about strategies and priorities? I'd like to make sure that particularly with our mission that we're always aligning with what's in that. And make sure that we're doing that. We could do that. And as we go, this probably isn't for this section, but as we go forward maybe for the next meeting, if we could get a list of, you know, which of the...

42:37 Trail System Master Plan projects have actually been implemented or are underway so that we aren't reprioritizing things we've already done unless they need it for some reason. I think that will give us a good jumping off point moving forward if we actually have a summary of what's been done to date. Did you want some comments on some of these other strategies? Yeah, okay, I'm sorry. A little bit of an aside, but if we could do that, that would be great. I think number four,

43:09 I would drop the through building and maintaining facilities, and I would just put maintain and develop infrastructure, or maintain and develop facilities, whether it's infrastructure and facilities, but something, I think, and then on number five, I would say maintain and develop programming activities, because we have great programming activities. I mean, we absolutely have great ones, and we just need to maintain them in both of them, and add to them. So maybe...

43:40 So maintain and develop on both of them? Yeah, and then I'd say on four, you may want to put in facilities and infrastructure, infrastructure and facilities, I don't know. If we want to say construction up, the word building. I would just put a line through building and maintaining. Infrastructure and that would be trials, it would be all inclusive, right? Maintain and develop infrastructure and facilities. Something like that. Yeah. Yeah, that kind of is a little cleaner.

44:09 And then maintain and develop programming activities because we've got good ones. Two M's for programming. And on number six, develop promotional activities via, and you know, I think MLT should be in there. I mean, that's a big deal, MLT. Yep, they're actually in charge. Yep.

44:46 We can put town slash Mammoth Lakes Tourism because we're all, it goes through the town, through MLT. Whichever, but I think, yeah, definitely as promotional as their business. Public outreach and media awareness, yeah. So just going back to number three, did we close out what we need to do with that? Do we even need to list them? Because one of the things that we found out here lately is I don't think Mammoth Trails currently is meeting on a regular schedule. Okay.

45:21 You could just say maximize community engagement, yeah. You're probably right. Maybe just to have the statement about maximizing community engagement. That's probably, I could probably understand, because as we understand, these are all types of users and we, I mean, forget someone if we, that would work for me. So any other comments on that section right now?

45:51 The only other one that I thought about, when we had stewardship there, would we say something about promote stewardship of the trails infrastructure? I mean, is that tied in with four? Can it be separate? Or maybe you put maximize community engagement and promote stewardship with users. Because then again, we're getting maintenance and stewardship. We want people to not only use it, but protect it.

46:19 Yeah. Make it better. Because you're right. Even if they never come work on a trail, you want them to stop cutting switchbacks. You know? Stuff like that. Okay. Okay. Did you get that, Steve? Does that sound good, Steve? Yeah. Okay. So before we go on to the priorities section, any comments from the public on the strategies? Just while

46:45 John's coming up. I'd like to say that I don't want to close this out this time because I really would like to go back to the Trail System Master Plan and make sure we pick the strategic elements out of that. Kind of give you the substance of it and then come back later. Hi. Mr. Wentworth. Thank you. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. I've been watching the progress of the MLTSTC and I've been eagerly anticipating at what point the Trail System Master Plan and all the very specific

47:11 Detailed recommendations of that plan start coming into sync with the committee's efforts. I think that there are maybe two or three things to keep in mind. The budgeting structure that I know that you're using. When we wrote the measure application, MLTPA wrote the measure application back in 2012 that funds your efforts in the next couple years, we organized all of those projects per those categories. Things have changed a little bit since then. But I think that

47:40 In terms of doing your inventory of what things you currently have that have already been built, they fit very neatly into that. And I would encourage the committee to start doing the inventory of what programs and things you currently have to work with, organizing them that way because they're all there and it all starts coming together at this point.

47:59 I would also encourage issues about community involvement and volunteers and all that kind of stuff. There are a lot of specific things in the Trail System Master Plan that I think that you guys, instead of identifying an idea that you want to encourage you want to do, it's very easy to map that to a specific recommendation in the Trail System Master Plan. I think you're at the time now where these things are starting to come together. I would encourage you to do that work. Thank you. Thank you. And by the way, Steve, so...

48:29 My sense from having spoken with you earlier, what we're really trying to do today is not actually do the prioritization of projects, but get a leg up on the framework that we're going to be using for making decisions when we get into the actual project prioritization so that we'll be able to tie everything back to this process. Is that how you understood it? Okay.

48:57 Priorities for funding. Any comments, Stu? Well, I think we just talked about the project linked to trial system us plan, so I think we've covered that one. Number four, is that continuation of reoccurring programs after review, so is that something of, say, SHARP that has now got a three-year timeline, is that something that we keep? What does that mean, continuation? The programs would be for a program like maybe winter grooming might be an example, summer stewardship might be another.

49:29 Yeah. So I think that, you know, that idea of the continuation of a program that the community has come to expect and rely on for a couple of years, and I think we need to have the after review in there because, again, things change over time, and so we need to make sure that we're current as far as providing services and we're current as far as the cost.

49:55 So maybe that could be said, could be said a little bit differently, could just be consideration of existing programs, you know, consideration for continuing existing programs, I don't know, it just seems like a bit clunky, that priority. I know, that makes sense. So obviously you've got them on the radar, it's a trials grooming program, you want to make sure that there's consideration for future funding of existing programs. Maybe that's what it is.

50:24 Yeah. I vaguely remember some of the discussions. Some of it, I think, may have even flowed back from the Recreation Commission where, and the Measure R process, and Measure U, where people didn't want to just be hopscotching from one program to another every year to build some robust programs that had some continuity. Yeah. But not just blindly. That was why the. After review. Yeah.

50:48 They have to review. They have to build into our process with requiring an end-of-the-year report. Yep. You know, so, yeah, I mean, I understood that. I didn't, you know, I don't think, there's nothing about programs that talks about projects, because once you commit to a project, it's really not, I don't think we want to get into any review type of stuff. Right. You know, until you get really, maybe major milestones, but not, you know, but programs definitely, because we're funding programs, and if we get good feedback, then.

51:17 Yeah, and if we don't. So just to discuss how we would use these, and again, I think looking back at the trail system master plan and seeing if there's anything else in there would be helpful. But these aren't intended to be essentially in order of priority amongst themselves. So we would weigh a given project against all six or seven of these equally. In other words, being ready to go isn't necessarily more important than leveraging.

51:48 And I'll just go into the mix. Is that correct? I think you're right. I think that the way I would see it is that you would come up with a list of five, six, seven, eight categories. And then of those categories, you might determine that a scoring one to five might be appropriate. And similar to the way that you were evaluated with the recognition, you may say something to the effect, okay, ready to go. You have this project shovel ready. We'll give it a five on the scorecard.

52:17 And do it that way. I'd love to comment on that. I would love to comment on that. Let's not go into that level of detail yet because I think there's some real issues with that. Exactly. Actually, my comment was pretty much coming like Bill's. The one thing I thought when I first, whenever you see a list of things, 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, you automatically assume, oh, are these priorities in order? I would suggest we do bullets. Do bullets, get rid of those numbers because I started pointing things around and going, here's what I do, you know, but I think just do bullets.

52:46 Let's not, every time we've used those numbering systems, you know what I see, and then every time they calculate it up, then the first thing somebody says, oh, well, you know, because their numbering didn't come out, I'd say let's just put them out there and. I mean, obviously at some point, certain things are going to be showstoppers. For instance, if the project's not ready to go. Then let's just, yeah, exactly. I don't want to get too deep into that. Okay, are there any other.

53:14 Yeah. Priorities. Yeah, just quickly, Chair, would six, only because we changed the strategies, would six be maintenance of existing infrastructure? Would we kind of link those two together that we tried to do there? Because I know Sandy had some language there. Yeah, either way to me, yeah. If the strategy four was going to be, I guess that ties into the priority of that strategy.

53:36 Infrastructure was a little bit more. Yeah, infrastructure and facilities or, you know, I see what you're saying, yeah. Could be, I mean, the whole case. Is it just the worst meeting, but just the fact that we've used infrastructure, we probably should try and keep it. Yeah, you could add infrastructure, I guess. What limitations do we actually have on preventing maintenance dollars? Well, that speaks to it a lot, doesn't it? Oh, from the general, the only athlete and measure R, the only thing is it was existing.

54:05 Facility maintenance. Recreation and Parks Facilities Maintenance Funding. That's the only thing. And as most times you go as the date of passage. So anything from 2000 to 2008, you could figure out what that is. It's probably pretty low since we didn't have lots of investment. But that's really, however you want to look at it, even if it's some major thing, it only applies to existing maintenance funding.

54:34 Town-owned or town-managed, but now that we actually have the MOU, I think that covers the intent. And I think it's been very clear in Measures R&U that projects that were built with Measures R&U are eligible for maintenance. They don't necessarily always get it, but they're eligible for maintenance under Measures R&U. Now, Measure U is much more general about supplanting. So in that one, you're talking, it isn't just Parks and Recreation Maintenance funding. U is much broader.

55:03 And it implies any funding pretty much before the date of that passage. So yes, in other words, you can't supplant Measure U too much. So we just need to be careful when we're talking about Mammoth to make sure we know before which projects. Correct. And is it R or is it U?

55:23 Yeah. And personally, I'm always going to be pushing to go to other places first for the maintenance dollars so we can stretch R&U as far as possible. But I will – let's not let them fall apart. Right. No. Yeah. While everybody – yeah. While others quibble about it, let's not let things fall apart. But that does get to a question under priorities for funding, and I don't know exactly how – whether this fits in priorities or if it's somewhere else in our evaluation criteria. But I always want to make sure that conformance with the –

55:52 Desired funding source. And for us, primarily, that's going to be Measure R. Oh, federal, state grants? Well, but... Huge. That's what most of our stuff is built with. But what I'm talking about is for this committee, in terms of the funds that we're allocating, we don't allocate the federal grants. Yep, you're right. But I want to make sure that we always... Informants with funding sources. Yeah. Okay. Because we could have grants. Mm-hmm. Yeah, whatever. Okay.

56:17 Obviously we can recommend funding out of the general fund, we can recommend funding out of measures R and U, but primarily we're tied to measure R. Yep. Yep. That's in addition to number seven, the bullet? Yes. Okay. Let's see if I'm complete. So any other comments right now from the committee? Any comments from the public?

56:49 Hi, John Wentworth again. It would be very helpful, I think, to have the inventory of projects that were built from the Trail System Master Plan since 2009 when the first measure applications went out. MLTPA as a contractor built and developed a lot of things that had specific citations from the Trail System Master Plan. Your conversation about maintenance, obviously, there's an expectation that those programs would be maintained with Measure R funds.

57:15 It's a question probably to the committee to determine whether or not the committee wants to continue to pursue some of those programs that have been delivered to the town, but the town may have not acted upon them yet. One example of that would be the photo library, which we delivered, I don't know, last year or so. MLTPA and Mammoth Lakes Tourism are now working actively to consider developing a photo library for the town that would tie in with the TBIT efforts and all the rest of it. And I think it would be great to have a sense of, there's a

57:42 A lot of reasons why that serves a lot of different purposes at the same time. The website enhancement contract, we're seeing a significant leveraging opportunity with MLT to enhance the content of the website. So the degree to which you can go through and have an inventory of all those things that have been produced, whether or not the committee chooses to pursue them or not, what the fate of those things then becomes, I think would be very helpful. I think you can also look to see how there's a lot of things you can start weaving a lot of these programs together because they tend to support themselves.

58:09 So when I'm looking at this bulleted list, I don't see that exact concept listed. Right. And I'm just trying, do you have any suggested language on it? Because it's not really, in some ways it's a project that's ready to go, but in some ways it's really, it's the implementation of a developed program. Yeah, it was an analysis of trail system master plan projects delivered to date to Town of Mammoth Lakes. But the objective is to implement.

58:39 In other words, we've invested in a really in an asset. Yes. And now we have to take that to the next step and maintain it. So in a lot of ways the data library is just like a length of trail. Sure. We just need to make sure that the program maintenance is treated the same way as the physical facility maintenance. Exactly right. And you guys should go through that list of all these things that were delivered and do your analysis and figure out whether or not you want to maintain it or not.

59:07 So maybe if we modify number six. Six, I'm thinking in programs. Yeah. In programs. I would, yeah, I think that works. Yeah, the data thing is a very, I mean, that feeds websites, it feeds mapping, it feeds all kinds of different things. And we've talked about the data before. Yeah. My personal concern that that stuff gets stale very quickly if it doesn't. Yeah, sure. Maintained. Yeah, I, actually, that one thing that I realized, I think.

59:36 There's a step in our process that hasn't been followed very well that I think we need to add to it. And that's when something comes forward. I would like to be sure that the appropriate partner has reviewed it and recommends for us to continue it, whether it's usable or whatever. And I've got a couple of examples. One of them was an excellent example, I thought, until I started thinking about it afterward. And that was that really nice interpretive plan you brought forward.

1:00:05 Gave to us. I mean, it was, I think it was 17,000. Very well written. You know, I looked at it. I found a couple little minor errors, but I didn't think anything about it. I think we accepted it. And then John Kazmierski said, yep, but I think the Forest Service needs to review it. And we went. It's like, I don't think anything should come forward without a cover sheet from the appropriate agency, staff, saying, now, take it in. Because otherwise, we're just creating work for ourselves and work for the staff.

1:00:34 The other example was the management plan. I think it shouldn't have come forward to us. That's a waste of our time because I think the staff had already given input. It wasn't usable at the time, but a cover sheet saying that would be helpful. I think we're going to streamline our process that way. So I agree, John, exactly what you're saying. When something comes forward, I don't think it should just automatically come forward to us. We're not experts in all this. The town staff, perhaps.

1:01:04 In other words, as they've done here, it looks like, have done these standards plans for public works. You know, when they take it to the council, it won't actually come to us, but I mean, if this were a document that came to us, it should have a cover sheet saying staff says, yeah, it's ready to go. Just to follow up saying if that's a way that you'd like to see these things come forward, it would be great for

1:01:30 The public or the contractor, people involved in the process, they can certainly may have some thoughts and ideas to whoever is the body that's addressing these kinds of things. It would be very helpful. I remember with the interpretive plan, John Kazmierski, I think he said some appropriate thing. He said, this is fine, this is good, we don't have a problem with it, there's things that need to be done. But he was certainly in the run the way Sarah is today and said,

1:01:52 He hadn't reviewed it. The Forest Service had not reviewed it. Well, that's fine. But I think to establish a process of these things come forward one thing at a time, and everybody can sort of say this is what these things are, this is what the utility of the program is, this is how it might work. It may not occur to some people. I mean, again, those standards, MLTPA produced all those standards, the standards manual for the town, and there may be some things in there. There's a public review of what's in those things that maybe...

1:02:16 It's a chance for everybody to get a sense of what the value of these things are so you can determine whether or not to pursue them or not. And I think it's simply a matter of being in this list that Steve prepared, in which I think we're still, what I look at what we're doing right now is, if you recall, it was development of an implementation program. That's what we're doing. And so these items will wind up on this and we should just essentially have, I think,

1:02:47 If this had been completed on projects that had been brought forward in the past, those questions would have been answered. And all I'm just saying is it's very clean. I mean, it's the way at least where I used to work was done. You know, staff had to review stuff before they ever brought it forward to anybody for approval or recommendation even. And so that's all I'm saying. I think with any one of them. And that may be standard in our process, in our new process. So just going forward, I hope that we'll be using this on every project. You bet. It's a good one.

1:03:17 And it may be tweaked by what we're doing here, but I don't want to lose sight of this because... Well, that's, and I think what got me going here was the data library, the photo library, because I believe that's one of those that we really, it's still being sorted out from what I understand, and I would like to, when that comes forward, I would really like to have that, you know, as a staff report, and I'd like to know, yes, this was reviewed by the town, by the Forest Service, by da-da-da-da, and accepted and recommended for us to say, yeah, that looks good.

1:03:45 It's on our master tracking list on page three. It's identified and it's future work for us to do. We're trying not to lose any of those items for consideration. To a certain extent, I think that that may fall under projects are ready to go because if a key approving agency...

1:04:15 Hasn't signed off. It's not ready to go. That's right. Okay. Anything else to add to this discussion at this time? Again, I think I'd like to just do one more go-around after a review of the trail system master plan. When the rest of them are here, yeah. And then maybe we can adopt this as our fiscal year priorities and strategies. Good. Thanks a lot. Good.

1:04:47 Good going, Steve. Good draft. Next item. Let's see. So that takes care of item five. Is there anything under item six that we need to do? My sense. This is the agenda bill just to check in with the forest service on their sharp trails and facilities, NEPA, CEQA planning, prioritization, and strategies. I was out at the Hayden cabin here late last week and ran into

1:05:19 Two sets of reviewers of the field work and so forth. So, you know, from that informal standpoint, I know that the work is continuing ongoing. And this is on the agenda just to see if there's any further update from the U.S. Forest Service. That's all. Yep. They cuddle up to it. Yeah. Okay. So, I checked in with John Kazimerski a week or two ago just so he could give me an update.

1:05:48 And we've basically tiered our work into three sets of priorities for the surveyors. The first tier are the priorities from the Sherwin Working Group that we've identified. So surveys have already been done on the Forest Service top priorities, which is the borrow pit trailhead, the backbone connector from the borrow pit to Tamaracks Road. And I believe that's

1:06:16 SWG number 7. We've also completed surveys on the connector to Mammoth Rock Trail, which is number 13, and number 6, which is Mammoth Creek Park connector. So those surveys have already been completed. They're now moving on to the second set of priorities for the Forest Service. So right now they're surveying equestrian and angler user trails along Mammoth Creek.

1:06:45 Trails in Mammoth Meadows that go under Mammoth Rock, and connector trails from Mammoth Meadows into the Lakes Basin. The third set of priorities, which they have not yet gotten to, potentially may get to this season, but we're not sure yet, are trails up to the Sherwins and Mammoth Rock, so Solitude Canyon and some other equestrian trails.

1:07:06 They're also going to be inventorying user trails that are already on the ground that do not appear on the Sherwin Working Group trail map. So while they're out there, they're making sure they're inventorying those as well. So that's where we are with that project at this time. That's great. That's great progress. Yeah. Did you need other updates? I know we asked specifically about some of the collection agreements, but I wasn't sure if you wanted to talk about those now.

1:07:39 Well, let's see if there's anything else on this one. Stuart, do you have any questions or comments? I just, I know that there had been discussion at the last meeting about the priorities, and there was concern that there were, that the Forest Service priorities had, particularly one user group, which was the runners and the ability to turn the rock trail into a loop coming down by the bluffs, and I was wondering if there had been any adjustment in the Forest Service priorities.

1:08:11 To reflect that. You know, that was the update that I got from John Kazmierski, but my guess is that we'll certainly be done with, before the end of the summer, the surveys of those trails, just from what I'm getting, so. And the critical issue, of course, was the botanical, and did they, you know, if they got to jump ahead of everybody else, because cultural resources aren't going to move away, but the plants are going to, they're.

1:08:37 Going fast. Gone. Yeah, you know, I can follow up on that, to be honest. The update I gave you is the most information I have, and getting Kaz's time with his new baby and his new job has been hard enough, so I'm appreciative for anything he's been able to do. I understand. I just, I want to make sure we get as much done in this season because it sounded like the contract. Whatever didn't get done in this season might not get done, and there was at least one critical trail segment that...

1:09:04 So I guess from what I understand from John Kazimirski, the only things that might not get surveyed this season are the trails that get up to the Sherwins. Is that what you're talking about? No, he was talking about the Bluffs Trail. Yeah, I think the Bluffs Trail, there was one trail particularly headed up towards the Sherwin that at least the testimony at the last meeting was that it was a lower priority.

1:09:31 All right. So for the next one, I'll make sure I have more information with you on that. And if I get anything sooner, I can always let you know. Thanks. Appreciate it. Any comments from the public? Good afternoon again. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. A couple just overall kind of questions. Measure R is paying for this work. Is that correct?

1:09:56 It would be really great to get some sense of who's establishing the priorities for how this work is being done. It's great to know the Forest Service has got a prioritization system. They kind of know the kinds of things they want to do. Haven't heard anything from the committee or the town as to what the priorities are for how this work is being done? I think we commented at the last meeting, John. I think at least I know I did, and I think other ones did. The fact is we said we didn't pick out single ones, but I know that we said,

1:10:26 Go for 100%. Right. If you can get 100% done, that's great. But I know I pointed out a couple of them. But I said to me, when I rocked these and took notes on them, I said, these are lower priorities if you have to drop something for right now. Because as I explained, and I think Sarah can explain, if we have a document that covers 85%, 90% of what was in here, it's going to be a fabulous document. And I am thrilled.

1:10:55 Because at any time after that, you have an awful lot of the basis of work done to be able to do a much shorter document, not a full EA, sometimes a decision memo will do it or whatever, but if you've got the surveys and the studies, you know, I mean, we did give, we did give our input. So to be clear, is it the committee's expectation that the environmental work that the Forest Service is doing will be for everything in the SHARP document?

1:11:21 Everything that they can get to. If the flowers die before they get there, that might be one where they're going to have to do it next spring when the flowers are blooming again. Okay, so over two years would it be all? I think we got a commitment from Kaczmierski at the last meeting that the Forest Service are going to do everything they can to work the program and to get the information this year. And I think that...

1:11:45 Without receiving something from Kazmerski in the last two days saying that there's a problem, I think we're on schedule and we're on track and it's consistent with what was presented to the committee at the last meeting. Okay, as long as we're going for an all-in, that's the goal to kind of do, then I'm happy. I'm just hearing what Sarah's saying. A couple other points. All of the user trails in the Sherwins, at least MLTPA documented those very thoroughly. I'd hate to see Forest Service staff having to do all that stuff again.

1:12:13 The data was delivered to the town. These are resource surveys, John. They're resource surveys. They are not just data collecting. In other words, a botanist looks at flowers. I heard use trails. I specifically heard Sarah say use trails. I just wanted to make sure that there wasn't any extra effort going on. Sarah, you could be clear. I think my understanding is that they're out there doing resource service, but they're also inventorying user trails that were not on the Sherwin's working group maps while they're out there. So it's not duplicative work. They're just...

1:12:42 If they're out there, they're making sure that they're getting map points for anything that maybe wasn't captured in the most recent map. Now, I'm not sure if there's – if you're saying there are additional GIS files that the town has that we need to make sure we have as well, certainly I understand that. Yeah, I would just encourage you because we did a very – with the SATS effort, there's a lot of – all those use trials, I think, if that can help you guys out, I think that data already exists. That's it. Thank you. Okay, well, thank you, and thank you for the updates, Nora.

1:13:15 Sure. And so let's see. The next item was update on the USFS TOML SHARP Challenge Cost Share Agreement scope. And do we have anything on that? Again, this is a placeholder on the agenda to allow if there is anything that's coming through the SHARP efforts that need to be changed or revised from the

1:13:41 Signed agreements. This is an opportunity for the Forest Service to provide that to the committee. Again, I'll turn it over to Sarah if there's anything that has come up. I haven't been made aware of any. Yeah, I checked in with John Kazmierski. Actually, I did speak with him today before the meeting just to make sure I had all the information. And I understand there are two challenge cost share agreements that were in process. One was for Sherwins.

1:14:08 The other was for Sarbanes. And the Sherwins Working Group, my understanding is that that challenge cost share agreement was signed about six weeks ago, and that one is an advanced billing situation. And I think that what Kaz told me this morning is that there is a bill outstanding to the town.

1:14:31 And that there's a payment pending from the town on that one. And then the Sarbanes cost share agreement was signed last Friday. Steve, is there any chance that we can get copies of that challenge cost share agreement? I don't want to be beating up the Forest Service on something about scope if, in fact, everything is completely consistent. And I, you know, haven't seen it, so I'm, you know, I'm a little bit at a loss as to exactly what...

1:15:03 You know, what the stated scope of services is. So if we could get a copy of that for the next meeting, I would appreciate it. I think I've provided you with drafts in the past. Unfortunately, I do not have a final signed executed copy that's been turned over to me to send off to you. I have requested it and I'm working on it. And if you could, not right at this moment, but if you could maybe find me the email or whatever the communication was that you think just sent back because I don't have it in my...

1:15:33 Packet here. So maybe it was a meeting I missed. I'm not sure. What did we miss? The early draft of the cost share agreement with the attached scope. Yeah, they were. I think I have them someplace long ago. Well, I did miss the June meeting, so it's possible. Or May meeting, I guess. It was possible. It was right back there, and it was pretty well. Yeah. I would really appreciate it. Well, what I'd really like to do is get the sign. Yeah.

1:16:02 Yeah, and that's what I'm endeavoring to do, and I've asked the clerk to provide that to me, and I'll pass it on as soon as I get it. For both would be helpful. Sarbanes as well, just to see that, because that's an interesting one, I think. That is the one that we're not necessarily involved in. Right. I don't believe there's any measure R or trails funding. No, it's funded 100%. It's a wonderful trail. It's 100% funded by Sarbanes. Do you want a copy of the Sarbanes? Well, when it comes, sure. I mean, they're...

1:16:31 Doesn't make any difference. I mean, if it's not a big deal. Whenever. You know, when you get the other one. Yeah. Okay. Sure. You know me. I like to read. Okay. Okay. Anything else on that one? Anything from the public on that issue? Nope. Okay. Discuss projects from the approved master project and budget tracking list for fiscal year 2013-14.

1:17:08 This is on the agenda. We've got just about 40 minutes or so left. A couple of things that I'd like to draw your attention to have to do with, let's start off first with the MLTPA proposal for temporary signed services in your packet. It should be a two-page proposal to Steve Spidell from John Wentworth dated July 8, 2013.

1:17:37 If you recall, at the time we authorized Friends of the Inyo to a contract not to exceed $2,000 for temporary signage. What was not included in that particular piece was the work that MLTPA has done in the past and did in this particular

1:18:00 Occasion to help with the field location and the actual logic and terminology used on the signs. Whereas with Friends of the Inyo, we just asked for a proposal for the production of the sign and not necessarily the printed word content. And so when I realized that, I asked MLTPA to please provide the committee with a proposal for those services.

1:18:27 It was submitted and there was approximately a $500 not to exceed limit on that and so I'd like to bring it to your attention for discussion and also possible approval then. I'm going to abstain from this one because of my board member status with MLTPA. Thank you. Does that give us a quorum to... No, it doesn't. I was just going to say it doesn't. I would say why don't we put this off to the next meeting.

1:18:57 So that we have a quorum. Actually, technically, I think an abstention leads you with a quorum, a disqualification would not. So I think you guys can discuss that if you agree. And Sandy, would you take over for this item? Well... Not too sure. We want to be careful. I'll leave that to you guys. What's up?

1:19:20 If you still have a quorum on the, if there's any decision to be made, I guess, is that? Yeah, I'd rather have a quorum, frankly. Do you need a decision today, Steve? Is that? No. No. I think it would be better to have the other two involved, yeah. Is that okay, John, to put that off? Sure. Okay, it would be better off, I think, having the other time in, too. Okay.

1:19:53 Then the other things that we can take care of here quickly are FYI information. We have two copies then of trails reports from July 21st and 28th. These are efforts, again, that are funded through Friends of Inyo and the stewardship program. So these are just FYI to show you continuing work that is being done.

1:20:20 Also on our master tracker list, and if we refer to that, page 5 is the SOPA, and it has been updated to reflect some new Forest Service projects. One, of course, is a revision of the forest plan itself. I'll point out, too, the Mammoth Airport Alternative Access Road has been added.

1:20:53 Let's see. The scenic loop staging project number 132 has been put on hold. So this is, again, an update of what the Forest Service projects are, and I don't know if Sarah has anything more to add to any of the new projects, the ones on hold or the older projects that are going through the process. But, again, I endeavor to update that quarterly for the committee.

1:21:24 And then to the master tracking list, if we can start at the back there as well on page four under the CIP projects. On your current copy, the numbers for the 13-14 estimated funding will be revised per my discussions today with Hayes. And also I'll be updating the current status and next action of those CIP trails related projects.

1:21:54 So all of the CIPs you'll be updating? That's correct. Okay. So just to let you know, for instance, the funding on all those categories has changed, and then the current status and next actions will be updated as well. Because one of my notes when I was reviewing is with a number of projects, we do have some funds that we can reallocate. We carried them over with the intent of reallocating. And, I mean, with some of these...

1:22:25 It might be appropriate for matches, grant matches, or who knows what. And I think that continues to be true, Sandy, for TR11, the Mammoth Elementary Connector Path. My understanding is that there's still some possible match opportunities for us to consider with that. And I could always bring Peter Bernasconi forward to help with that discussion and understanding. On that same page, not CIP, but since we're on that page, I was noticing number 7.

1:22:58 41, the season opener, you know, I think we don't have to discuss that today. I think that's much more logical for winter, but under winter grooming, the Shady Rest Trailhead, the Sherwin Road Barrel Pit type of thing, that was one of the newer things that I think was added to our list, but I think things like that we probably ought to put on our future agenda, in other words, items to discuss before winter is upon us. You know, that's the one I think Bill brought forward. That was the, didn't Bill Souser bring it forward? Winter grooming.

1:23:29 Yeah. In other words, this is not the Walton Center grooming, not cross-country. This is the winter grooming, Shady Rest Trailhead to Sherwin Road Barrow Trailhead, the use of the tunnel and all of that kind of stuff. Sounds familiar. I don't know if they talked about it last time. Yeah, and so... Probably should. Yeah, I would think so, and I mean, that may be a very long discussion, I know, because I'm really with that history, but I think if, you know, if we're ever going to discuss it, we ought to start before winter.

1:24:02 We'll put that on the agenda for the next meeting. Yeah. Could be. Could be for at least giving us some background on it. Right. Even if it's not something we can carry forward right away, but it might be worthwhile to know the background on it. And. An update to then on page 205, the wayfinding for the interpretive, eight interpretive sign panels, number 473, the $84,105.

1:24:33 Recommendation from you will go to the rec commission tomorrow for approval. And so once that's taken care of, then we'll be able to work closely with Public Works to push that through, as Hayes mentioned, for the request for proposals and dividing out the bid. I did have one on page three also. And this is one, it's noted as new 571, I don't know if that was a new number on it.

1:24:58 The Lakes Basin Early Opening Lake Fall Closure. I mean, this one we have discussed several times without coming to any agreement. I know that the Forest Service has said, and I know the Council has said, I've heard them say many times since the days of Skip Harvey, that he would like to see those bathrooms be opened early and closed late. The Forest Service has said, and I think it's still probably true, Sarah, that

1:25:27 There isn't funding to open them up early or close them late. And whether it's a port-a-potty or whether it's, you know, a town seasonal staff that stays on a bit later and takes care of some of this, I just know the council has said over and over again, and I think it's time for us to bring up this discussion because it's almost fall, I would say that one, if anything, is probably the crucial one to discuss next time. You know, and come to some consensus and let's figure out how to do it.

1:25:59 Let's put it on the agenda. Yes. Anything else? Yeah, down at the bottom of page two, there's one that's been on here for quite some time. It's 490.2, Wayfinding Temporary Signage. Oh, wait a second. I'm sorry. I'm reading the wrong one. Because that one was the one, I think, that was the trails report, right, John? With the photos that they're already in. Uptown, downtown, earthquake fault, mountain view. I think that's the photos we have.

1:26:58 Yeah, that's complete. I'm sorry. That is complete. Okay. I was pointing out the wrong one. Okay. I'm sorry to say. I was looking for something and I still can't find it. One thing that I did want to bring up today, though, is the maps and guides and winter recreation map printing. I don't know what the current status is and I think I sent an email to Sarah a number of days ago asking for that.

1:27:29 Because we do have an opportunity to, I think, under reallocation of funds under 731 maps and guides to work with the Forest Service on the production of a new set of winter recreation activity maps. Not to belabor the point, but because this is an older program that was initiated outside of the MLTS and outside of Measures R&U,

1:27:59 Just make sure we have a thorough analysis as to how these maps connect to the purposes and funding sources for this program. And I think John can probably, Kazmirsky can probably brief you on that. Yeah, I have to, I did speak to him a little bit because I know there's also some questions about the Blue Diamond Trails and whether or not they would go onto the winter maps and so I've been just doing some research. I guess one of the

1:28:29 One of the things that John Kazmierski informed me of is that there are some minor updates even outside the addition of potentially more Blue Diamond Trails on there that there are some minor updates but from what John Kazmierski tells me we have some funding set aside that we could reprint the maps but as far as the graphic design for the maps I believe that the town may own them but that they were files created or currently under possession of MLTPA and I'm not sure if that's accurate that was my

1:28:59 First understanding in the quick brief update. So I know that there's a potential for us to fund printed maps, but I think there are some minor adjustments we definitely want to make, and we also may want to have further discussion. I would need to touch base with John Ruggelbrugge about the idea of putting more of those Blue Diamond Trails on there. I know that we're going to be having some people out there putting more Blue Diamonds up. So, John.

1:29:28 Yeah, sure. Just as a brief overview of what happened. Several years ago, MLTPA, I believe, there was some Measure R funding. We produced the master file. We coordinated the data from the Forest Service from the town. We created the master file. And the printing costs, I think, Stuart, do involve in that. That came from OHV funds. That's right. So that's how it was produced. I don't know how you guys want to do it, but that's how the program, that's how it worked last time.

1:29:51 Yeah, so I guess the question is, does the town have the graphic design files so that if there were some updates that needed to be made, that would be, I guess, to my understanding as far as who has the graphics, that the Forest Service doesn't have the graphics, so we might be able to fund more printing of the maps, but there are some updates we might want to make to those maps beforehand.

1:30:17 Yeah, and I think those are the kind of things probably Hayes would be the one to brief us on, the staff, as far as, or you might be able to produce before that. I would think it would come out of the old recreation tourism, would it not, Stu? Yeah, I don't, I might have a PDF of the file. I don't know if I've got the original PSD files. I don't know if John and MLTPA have those. No, we have,

1:30:37 You know, as a graphic design, when we do these kinds of things, we deliver master files. These have all been done historically through very productive, effective partner agreements, taking advantage of everybody's different capacities and who can do what well with the most efficiency. So there hasn't been a request for those files. This was a couple years ago. I'm sure we still have them. It would be a very easy thing to take them as long as you use them in the current software, the kind of, you know, best practices way to do these things. It would be a very easy thing to make these updates if you tried to translate them into a whole different...

1:31:06 Program, that would be problematic. Do these belong to the town? I would assume so. I mean, we would certainly, if the town requested them, we would certainly share them. So they haven't been delivered to the town? I don't know, the file that was necessary to make the maps, the printing file, that was delivered to the town, the master file. I don't know if the town ever requested the underlying design files. But they were funded by Measure R? I think, I'm not sure, I have to go back and check the record, I don't know. We will share the files. If the town wants those map files, we would be more than happy to share them.

1:31:35 So I guess probably the first thing that needs to happen is that I need to have a conversation with John Ragabroga about whether or not we want to consider making some fairly larger updates, which would be including more of the Blue Diamond Trails. And then when I have that conversation with him, we can talk about timing and how much lead time we need in order to make those updates to those files. And then at that point it may be a conversation about whether the town wants to contract.

1:32:05 Someone MLTPA to update those files and certainly we can share whatever GPS files we have but let me do a little more conversation. I know that the Sierra Club I believe is going to go out under a volunteer agreement with us to put up some more blue diamonds and they'll be mapping those at our request and they haven't started that work yet. I believe it's going to start in a few weeks and so

1:32:29 We just need to figure out how many trails that is and how many trails there are that they already have provided to us from some mapping they've already done. I think they've done some of that as well in the past. So I need to have some conversations about whether or not we want to go ahead and update all of those Blue Diamond trails for the winter map, and then if so, what sort of graphic design update needs to be done versus, I guess, the alternative, which is that we take the old PDF file and just have those printed and we can take care of that through.

1:32:58 The funding that we have on file. Yeah, my point in the meantime is I think the town should have whatever you've got, John, if it belongs to the town, so that we can have staff review if it's usable or not. So if Regal Brugge says, yeah, let's do a major one, we need to know if the files are usable and can be used. I think we're happy to work with MLTPA on that, Steve. And if there's additional work needed, we can look at that too, right? Because to me, if anything, if it's something that...

1:33:28 But as the towns, the towns should have it. I mean, you can have a copy, that's fine, but it seems to me if it's the towns. Yeah, we'll just wait for a request from the town, whether it's Steve or someone sends an email. Why would you request it? I thought these are delivered. Well, because, Sandy, we have a lot of things we're working on. If the town, if the staff determines they want to have a copy of the file, just send an email over and we'll figure out a way to get it to you. I think, you know, typically having done this, you deliver what was requested, which was a PDF file.

1:33:56 You don't necessarily get all the data files and layers that were behind it unless that's requested. So we're requesting all of the background. So if the town wants it, great. If not, that's okay. The other problem is that if it doesn't have a home on the town server, then... Well, we have a contract with the county coming up. Well, just to be fair, we've delivered a lot of things to the town that, you know, they...

1:34:22 They go without moorings. So we've got it. We've got a server. It's there. If the town wants it, we're happy to do it. I want to comment just on one thing about the trails reports coming out of the Friends of the Inyo. If that's appropriate, I can wait. I'm sorry. You talked about the trails reports coming from the Friends of the Inyo? Yes. If it's appropriate, I'd like to just make a quick comment on that. I'll leave that to the Chair. Is there any other discussion on this item at this time?

1:34:49 I had just a few things that I noted on the SOPA tracker list, and I think they're just some things that are a little bit out of date, so maybe our SOPA report is out of date. But I know for sure that the Monocritus Restoration Project EA is out for comment right now, and I believe that also the one above that, Upper Owens, Bishop Creek is as well. And some of these may be a little bit outdated. Those are the two that jump out for me.

1:35:18 Thank you. Any other comments? Anything else, Steve, under this item? I think that if John wants to make a comment on the Friends of the Inyo Trails report, that's within the item. Well, I mean, if it's not within this item, it's just we'll jump back to the earlier item that is on with everybody with the pleasure of the committee. I'm fine. Thank you. John Wentworth again. I just wanted to point out this is the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee.

1:35:50 And to point out the value of how some of these trails reports find their ways into many other aspects of the program. Friends of Inyo does their, have got their lake space and stewards up there and they're providing these trail reports. That information goes a lot of different places, but it goes to the visitor center where Lawson reviews that information. The visitor center we're talking about in the website meeting is the gatekeeper for the trail conditions that are exhibited up on the website. That information then from Friends of Inyo gets

1:36:18 Into the visitor center, it gets to loss, it gets integrated with other information the Forest Service has, that then comes to us, we're managing the website, so trail conditions from people on the ground giving reliable reporting ends up on the website. And this may or may not have been the original intention of it, who knows, but it's a minor window into how all the components of this system, which is truly a system, are integrated and work together to produce the kind of results I think everybody's interested in.

1:36:47 So I just wanted to bring that to light. No, I'm glad you did because actually I had, when I reviewed all this, one of my questions that I'd written was, you know, where is this posted? How is it posted? And so that does help me understand because my questions were, was it on the MLTS website? I'm glad it is. You know, or MLT or ECIA. And so that's...

1:37:05 Yeah, that helps, that helps to know how it works. It's getting to, and the MLTS website is, you know, it's not a jurisdictional website, but it's a good consumer website. It's a very easy way for people to get access to that information. But the review is done by the Forest Service person, which is, yes, they're the gatekeeper. That's my earlier point. In other words, following a process that makes a lot of sense. Yeah, Laura. And they're very nice. Thank you. Nice report. This is Laura again. Just to get to your question, in addition to Visitor Center and MLTS website,

1:37:33 We're also posting these through Friends of the Inyo's website. They're being shared with the county and tourism staff. They're shared through Facebook and social media. So they're really blasted out there, and they're available for people through multiple outlets as they're making their decisions about where to go and what to do. Terrific. Laura was able to provide a copy the other day, so thanks, Laura. It's on Recreation this week now as well. We linked to that.

1:38:02 Page, that repository page, which is great. It has everything there. And town news, we included on that as well. So it's great. And that's, you know, I mean, that's exactly, you know, I do appreciate knowing how these link up. And it seems like, you know, John, you answered my questions where I ever even asked it. Because it is important to see, you know, we have to figure out how to do it right. And it sounds like it's really coming together wonderfully. Yeah. Yep. All right. One final item having to do with the master tracker list.

1:38:34 You may recall over the past few months there's been continued discussion as to the town's attorney's opinion on monies used for fundraisers and also for grant writing. I sent an email to the town attorney asking him for further clarification on that and asked that he respond prior to this meeting. Unfortunately, I haven't heard from him. Okay. Good. Got that question in because that's good. Yeah.

1:39:03 Yeah, we don't want to lose track of that one. Nope. Nope. Thank you. It's very important. With that, we'll move on to new projects. I guess the question here is, does anybody have anything to add to the list for future consideration? I had that one item that we just covered, which I think we're going to deal with anyway. Yeah. Which one was that? That was additional funds for the contractor to handle the project management due to raise. Oh, yeah. Due to raise departure. Okay. Yeah.

1:39:36 Because my time is budgeted, but not that. Anyone from the public? Okay. I think with that, we may be done. Could be. How about that? Nothing else? I'm impressed. The meeting is hereby adjourned. Very well run, Mr. Chairman. All right. Thank you. Thank you all. Thank you, Sarah. Yeah, thank you, Sarah, for coming. I know. Three jobs. Two jobs now. Last week she was three people.

1:40:13 Oh, is he going off? Back to three. Oh, boy. Oh, boy.