TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2013

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 1 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Notable from this meeting

1 finding

Transcript

374 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 2013, roll call please. Commissioner Dugan? Here. Commissioner Harvey? Here. Commissioner Tenney? Here. Vice Chair Kearney? Here. Chair Brown? Here. Would you please stand? I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.

0:42 We will now have public comments. I'd like just to make a comment about them, that under California law, commission is prohibited from generally discussing or taking any actions not included on the agenda. And so while we always welcome public comments, we will just listen to whatever they are. We will probably not discuss them or make any response comments. So if somebody would like to make a public comment that is not on the agenda, would you please come forward?

1:12 And I ask that you please keep your public comments to five minutes. My name is Andy Ott. I'm a long-time, part-time resident of Mammoth, over 35 years. I love this place. And I would like to share with you some comments I made at town council meeting recently to make you aware of what I said, what I requested, and what is ongoing currently.

1:52 in terms of the undergrounding of cables as part of Mammoth Field. In the interest of doing it within five minutes, since one picture is worth a thousand words, I would like to pass out a little package to each of you. And sir, just to know at least a couple of us were at that commission. Okay. I just want you to know we heard something. Okay.

2:38 Okay, what's illustrated on the first sheet is the Mammoth View project, which has been approved and is going forward. What's also under, what's shown on there in that pale orange is the existing and potential underground cables along Main Street. The new undergrounding will be the ones in front of Mammoth View, the ones all the way to the left in front of Nevados, those already exist.

3:08 They were put in as part of the village when that was done several years ago. What's also highlighted here in a dark rectangle is an existing vault where the current overhead cables go underground. It's also indicated in dotted lines. Another vault that may be required if we leave those five poles that are shown there in black.

3:38 Above ground. And those are the five utility poles that are planned to remain according to the present plans. What I want to point out, there are three separate projects that are going on, on this exact same area. And because of that, I request the town council to send a letter to Southern California Edison to come up with a cost estimate.

4:05 On what it would cost to extend the existing underground an additional 700 feet. That cost estimate should include trenching, okay, the additional 700 feet, the additional two wires that would be required. These are medium voltage wires. It requires very minimal design or engineering.

4:31 Mainly because it's already been done as part of the Mammoth View project. It's just making the cables longer. And if we go all the way to the existing vault, instead of stopping at that pole I indicate, you don't need an underground vault. An underground vault is very expensive. And, of course, if we did this, there is no cause for relocating poles, which is currently the plan.

5:02 Now, where they would relocate them, I don't know. SCE has not decided that, but I submit there's no convenient place to relocate them. Everybody complain or rightfully is concerned about cost. Now, let me illustrate to you a potential scenario where we could do this without any additional cost. Now, please bear with me. I don't know that all my assumptions are valid, but it's just a potential thought process.

5:32 Now, when SCE responds with their cost estimate, and if they provide us the sufficient detail that I hope they do, and that's absolutely key to this, we would look at the existing 20A funding that's in place. We would not require a vault, so therefore, the cost of that vault could be deducted. There would be no engineering design staff required.

6:02 Because the design is already complete, but if there was a bolt required, they would have to design how you connect from underground to above ground, and again from above ground to underground. I'm an electrical engineer by profession, and let me tell you, that is not a trivial engineering exercise. Now, if we were to do this, the wires would already be underground when the Main Street project starts later.

6:32 And there would be no interruption in service required later on because they're already there. So that would be a significant cost saving and that may in and of itself be enough to pay for the underground. However, maybe not. The Viewpoint Road Project is going to beautify Viewpoint Road because Mammoth View wants a very nice, attractive entry to their brand new complex. And there is an agreement.

7:02 In how much Mammoth View is paying, how much the county is paying, how much the town is supporting the Mammoth, the Viewpoint Road improvement. One of the things that should be done as part of that improvement is to remove that pole that's directly in front of Nevados. If you take a look at the first picture, that big pole that you see right there, that is the pole that is currently fronting Nevados.

7:32 If that pole were removed as part of the Viewpoint Road project, you could now, instead of having a right-angle turn here for Viewpoint Road, you could actually have a nice, easy access way to get onto Main Street. A dramatically better approach and, oh, by the way, cheaper because you don't need that pole and the undergrounding has already been paid for by the previous project. Third project, of course, now we still have four poles that are up there.

8:03 Well, along comes the Main Street beautification project. If you take a look at the pictures, you see a retaining wall, and you see how close the existing poles are to that retaining wall. The current Main Street project requires removal of the retaining wall and cutting back by four feet. That means Main Street project will require those poles to be removed.

8:32 No ifs, ands, or buts about it. If Main Street beautification goes forward, those poles have to be removed. The current baseline of relocating those poles somewhere just doesn't make sense to me, and I think the undergrounding solution is the much better solution. So when you take into account the Main Street project costs, the viewpoint road cost, Mammoth View, the total cost, you will get a better design.

8:59 If you combine the objectives of all three projects at the same time. So, and you know, I just would like to thank you. I know you come a long ways to come to our meetings. But just so you know, as a matter of protocol, once Council is discussing an issue...

9:14 Unless they direct it back to us, it's really a council issue. Of course. But we want to thank you very much for coming forward, and we are all very supportive of ultimately having our lines underground. Okay. My only objective was to make you aware of what's going on. Thank you very much. Give you the opportunity of asking questions if you haven't. Madam Chair, can I ask a question? I know we can't discuss. Can I just point an information question?

9:35 Okay. When you say underground vault is very expensive, what order of magnitude? Five figure, six figure, seven? What are you talking about? Just ballpark. Okay. I've had experience with underground vaults of different voltage levels, so I want to be very careful how I answer that. Well, a range then, yeah. Okay, but it is definitely in the large five, perhaps six figure range. Okay, thank you. Take into account not only the...

10:03 Thank you for your time. Thank you. Do we have any additional public comments?

10:35 Then the public comment period is closed for this meeting. We'll now have a public hearing. The hearing is to consider approval of variance 13-002 and administrative design review 13-002 for a rooftop enclosure for Shiloh Inn for the AT&T mobility, including the findings that the project is exempt pursuant to the CEQA guidelines. And at this time, Bill Taylor, would you like to present your report? I would. Just as a...

11:05 Point of order, would you like to recap the original project and original staff report or should we just pick up, right? I don't personally think it's necessary to recap the report. Does anybody on the commission? If you just would state what we're legally being asked to do today would be great. Okay. The action today is approval of variance and administrative design review for a rooftop structure.

11:32 on the Shiloh Inn. The structure, as we discussed before, houses a cellular telephone antenna array and it's currently designed to match the architecture of the existing Shiloh Inn. And I will be very brief and then if you, I'm assuming you've all read the staff report and there are some last minute modifications that we have to talk about but I'll let you know what those are.

12:00 At the last meeting, issues came up related to the condition of the garage walls, the fact that the original conditions of approval from 1988 had not, or 1988, excuse me, had not been completed, and the commission requested that we go back and work with the applicant to see if we couldn't actually bring the exterior of the garage structure up to the same standards as would be demanded of it today.

12:30 A lot of discussion with AT&T and exploration by AT&T of the possibility and the cost of actually doing that. AT&T has decided that they are willing to, they understand the need to meet the earlier, the needs of the property to meet the earlier conditions of approval, but they find no basis in law for

12:59 Moving forward to yet a more advanced standard as we would have today. So in light of that, we need to change the conditions of approval slightly. And what I would suggest if you have your packet is we have condition 31 and 32 that were added. And condition 31 should stay as worded. Condition 32, the first paragraph, would stay as written.

13:31 But then subparts A, B, and C would be deleted. And we would also delete condition 21 because there's a bit of a conflict between 21 and that first paragraph of 32.

13:43 So what this would now say is no building permit shall be issued for the antenna array and shield until the applicant and or property owner has satisfied outstanding use permit 88-2 conditions of approval, specifically condition number 26 regarding the exterior of the garage structure and condition number 5 pertaining to the maintenance of the landscaping. With that, do you have any questions? Anybody have any questions? No.

14:15 Boy, I'm a little perplexed. I was looking at the pictures of the Shiloh Inn, and maybe I didn't hear exactly what you said, Bill, even though the first paragraph in 32 says generally what's required, and A, B, and C say specifically, you're saying the specifics have to be deleted. Because we can't, there's no nexus between this and the AT&T application. Correct. So are those conditions going to happen? No. No.

14:41 Well, let me rephrase that. I think you should address that question to the applicant in terms of what you can require of the applicant. I think there's still some room for discussion and negotiation perhaps, but as written where we were talking about wrapping the whole garage structure, which would be essentially four sides with rock full height,

15:09 The applicant has said that they are not willing to do that. They are willing to bring the garage structure up to the standard required in use permit condition 88-2, number 26. Okay. So, we're questions safe. I've got a discussion comment. I'm fired up about my discussion comment, but I'll wait for discussion.

15:43 My question, Bill, is was this presented to the applicant as a four-sided or three-sided upgrade, or was it as we discussed? It was presented originally as we discussed. And going to the four-sided was based on the bid that the applicant received for the rock work and subsequent discussions.

16:14 So the applicant asked specifically for a bid originally for the entire garage or are we dealing with a misunderstanding here? So I don't believe that was exactly what the commission had requested of the owner of the property. Understood. And we had that discussion, well, we submitted a graphic to the applicant.

16:41 Specifically identifying the areas that you had described as a commission, which was on the east wall of the main building, putting trim around the garage, then the north-facing garage and putting rock along that. We also gave them the option, you know, rock on the vertical surfaces, but then perhaps a decorative wood header, as we've seen on some of the other garages that we proposed.

17:09 And then wrapping the rock partway around the east-facing wall of the garage structure back about to the, if you're familiar with the structure, about to the existing trash enclosure. And then finishing the rest of it off with textured concrete. And that was the graphic that we delivered to the applicant. Okay. Just a point of clarification, I certainly understand the removal of subsection A under 32. Okay.

17:39 I just want to clarify in section B, wasn't the landscaping part of the original CUP? It was. So wouldn't that also fall in line with the original textured concrete of the garage under the original CUP? It's two separate things that both fit with the original conditional use permit. That's correct. So we could leave B and make that, re-letter that as A. Okay.

18:13 Thank you. And tonight, just like a clarification, who's legally representing the owner of the property? Well, actually, for the purposes of this use permit hearing, the owner designated AT&T as their agent on this application. So, the AT&T representative, Andrew, and I'm going to get the last name right. Is it, your last name is Buchen? He's an employee. Buchen. Yeah.

18:45 So they are the designated representatives for this application. All right. Fine. Thank you. Is there any other questions of staff at this time? Would the applicant like to come forward? Do you have any comments you'd like to make? Additions? So AT&T is in a position where they'd like to secure variance approval from the Planning Commission. The concern is that the request to

19:22 Remodel or improve the exterior of that hotel as excessive. The connectivity to the variance application and the remodeling is not apparent to either AT&T or to myself. And we're concerned that that might be that lack of nexus or that disconnect makes it very difficult to...

19:48 digest a condition of approval that would require the remodeling of the entire exterior of the hotel. That is, I think, if the commission would be agreeable to narrow the condition of approval to comply with that 1988 condition of approval, that would be there as an excess, but the request to remodel or improve the entire exterior is simply not.

20:19 It seems out of proportion from, or disproportionate to what were the original variance approval or request. And I'm joined here by Kathy to speak to more broadly about AT&T's concerns. Thank you very much.

20:47 Good afternoon. My name is Kathy Paskin. I have been hired to represent Mono County and support for AT&T's overall velocity initiative to help improve service across their 22-state region, but I'm specifically assigned to your county, so I'm sure I'll be seeing a lot of you guys in the future. The reason we're here today is because...

21:07 We are trying to improve the service. There is a lack of service in the area. I've heard that since I've been in town for the last week. And the process for selecting a site that's going to help not only cover the area that we need coverage but has a willing landlord takes a long time to go through. And trying to find the nexus of those two.

21:27 To quote Andrew's word, is a difficult thing to do. This additional step of asking, everybody seemed to be okay with the original step. We had worked out the details, or working through the details, of how to finance the original condition from the COA of fixing the garage.

21:44 Going this other step probably would have the effect of making this site no longer be viable. It's really a landlord issue. It's not an AT&T issue and really should be separate from AT&T's tower. It really doesn't have anything to do with us trying to provide better service to the constituents here. So if we do have to go back to the drawing board and identify another site, that could take somewhere between upward of six months.

22:07 And, of course, there's not only the casual phone caller that we're trying to help. Businesses, obviously, more and more rely on wireless. There's a huge public safety component. 70% of 911 calls now come through wireless. So to put off this bill and the provision of more service for an additional six to who knows how many more months because of this additional...

22:32 Requirement really is burdensome and burdensome to the constituents and the users here and the visitors to Mammoth. I'm not quite sure who to ask, I guess, staff or the proponent here. This body never came forward with a request to wrap the entire garage and rack up a

23:09 financial burden of, in one case, over $100,000. I'll have to defer to staff on that. You know, I... I did not bring a paper copy of the communication with AT&T, but if you have a moment and you really would like to see what was requested, I would be happy to fire this up. Yeah, that would be great. Thank you, Bill.

23:44 Because we actually had that discussion when we were on the site that we were surprised that the request had been for a full wrap of, as it was presented, it would have been the entire east face of the garage. The garage actually extends onto the building, so it's the entire east face of the garage, the entire south face of the garage, and the entire west face of the garage. Now, in discussing it and looking like maybe this was realistic,

24:11 I think those of us who were there, staff and Commissioner Fernie thought, given the likelihood of development projects to the south and east in the future that we're going to upgrade those properties, that this would be a nice fit with the long-term goals of the downtown plan. But we understood that it was more than we had originally asked for. So let me do this. This will just take a second. Okay. Are there any other questions from Commissioner?

24:44 Madam Chair, it's a little difficult because we're dealing with a third-party applicant that doesn't happen to be present. So if you hear frustration from the dais, please bear with us and we'll get through this.

25:19 Would you care to comment? I mean, was that your understanding that we had asked you to wrap the entire garage? Yeah, to give some background, if I can imagine. I need to see you to stand in front of the microphone cases. To give some background, so at the first, at the most recent hearing one month ago, there was a concern about the condition, the 1988 condition of approval that was never complied with. So a consultant, construction manager to AT&T met with Bill on site to

25:50 Pinpoint and narrow or determine the scope of the improvement project. So with that, we were able to get a scope of work and a potential bid from a local contractor for the improvement that was envisioned or requested on site. All right. So I guess where our current dilemma comes from is that, one, when we saw the scope of work, it was more than

26:21 We felt that as a commission we had asked AT&T to do. So we were kind of surprised to see that you did that. And I guess what we really need to know, what exactly is AT&T willing to do currently as a scope of work? The scope of work, we're trying to narrow the scope of work to that original condition of approval from 1988 to work with the landowner to agree to that compliance. Which is textured concrete, not rock.

26:51 I think in order to help steer this discussion, we're all missing a piece of information that's very important, which is we don't have a proposal for what the cost to texture four sides of the structure is. And just to be clear, I was the person on site for that meeting, and both of the bids for 5,000 feet of rock work surprised us because they were beyond the scope of what was requested. And I understand that

27:20 That puts them in a neighborhood of six figures, which can make that project cost prohibitive. We understand that. But it would be very helpful for us to understand what the cost associated with bringing the project up to the 1988 conditional use permit would be, and I don't think any of us have that information. I mean, I don't know what it would cost to texture four sides of that structure.

27:54 And that's the condition of approval from 1988, the texturing of the four sides? Correct. So the condition from 1988 is textured concrete on all four sides of the structure as well as the landscaping. So there would clearly be a cost associated with that, and I don't know what that number is and how that compares to a four-sided rock veneer.

28:18 Presumably that's significantly cheaper, but it's difficult to understand without having that figure in front of us. So I think we could, as the applicant slash proponent for AT&T, I think we could go on, we would be comfortable with the condition of approval for this variance that compliance with that 1988 condition of approval would allow, and the variance approval would allow AT&T to go forward on the project.

28:53 That is limited to the original COAs, those two that you mentioned, the texturing and landscaping, and that would be the extent and the finality of the improvement to that underlying structure. And then the applicant will work with staff to confirm and verify that texturing is compliant. Does anybody on the commission have any additional questions? Yes. One second, please. Who would be...

29:30 Who would be responsible for that landscaping at that point? So the property owner, the owner of the property, so the installation or the retrofitting or the installation of compliant landscaping and or texturing, AT&T were the owner, but the upkeep and maintenance of the landscaping, the exterior of the curtilage, that would be the hotel owner, property owner.

30:06 Well, again, we're put in the position of dealing with a third party or relying on a third party that's not a part of this. The original request from the dais was, I believe I got it in the notes of the original meeting, was for a portion of the entrance into the garage and a portion of the east wall to be rocked.

30:38 From the diagrams that Mr. Taylor has shown me, that looks like what was sent to, excuse me, was that AT&T? Yeah, I received those. Okay, you received those. So then there was a meeting on site to further clarify the scope of the improvement project. Prior to the meeting on site, we wind up with a bid, two bids, for

31:10 wrapping the entire garage with rock, which produced a fairly outlandish number, a number that was well in 300% plus of what was suggested from the dais in the beginning. So if we're in a negotiation, the bet just went up.

31:41 significantly and now has come back to us. Well, to give some clarity or some background or history for that bid, AT&T and myself and others involved with this project, consultants involved with this project, are not based here. So we sought to secure some sort of on-site bid from a local contractor.

32:09 Having the limited information that I've provided to our consultant construction manager to find and determine a baseline bid, and that's the bids that were provided by the local contractors. In light of those high bids, we requested and we secured and finalized an on-site visit with Commissioner and Mr. Taylor on-site with the construction manager to further narrow the scope of the project. I think an important

32:37 The point of clarification is that the onsite meeting was after both of the 5,000 foot rock bids. So at a particular point there was a miscommunication or a bid that was put forth that was never requested. So what should be in front of us is the cost for a bid to rock veneer the entrance in the east side, not 5,000 square feet of four siding. Also it would be important to know

33:05 What a cost with texturing all four sides, which is the initial conditional use permit, would cost. Because obviously we're dealing with dollars and cents here. We want to, you know, comparing a $110,000 bid to something that is half or less of that is a significant difference. No, I appreciate that. I think the, I think one way to solve that dilemma is to,

33:35 Have AT&T and Shilohan comply with those two sections of the conditions of approval from 1988 and allow AT&T and Shilohan to work with planning staff to comply with those conditions. And I think AT&T, as we've tried to say, is comfortable with that compliance with those two sets of narrow conditions from the 1988 COA and in turn will work with Shilohan.

34:03 and staff to comply and meet those requirements. Go ahead. If I might, I want to keep this focused on what it needs to be focused on. The cost to the applicant is not really your concern. It doesn't matter if one's free and the other's a million dollars. What matters is what meets the policies.

34:34 Thank you. Thank you, Bill. And that certainly leads into a question that I would pose, and that is, in 1988, we had drastically different standards, design standards, and I think you can appreciate that. The request,

35:05 for the rock veneer was quite frankly a very generous request in today's world. Textured concrete for the west side of the building and for the south side of the building and even part of the east side of the building was really never an issue. Where the issue is, is the visual when guests

35:34 Come into what is a prominent business at the entrance of our town. You might ask how many people see this visual of this building. Well, you're asking us to put a large structure on top of the building and basically what we as a commission are asking is that we

36:03 beautify the building as best we can. Nobody's looking for an overly financial burden for that to happen. But at the same time, so many people see that building. What do we want people used to when they go home from Mammoth? We want them to have seen a lot of rock, a lot of heavy timber.

36:28 We want them to see the experience of being at a mountain resort. Mr. Gervish, I think that concern is a concern that can be raised directly with the property owner. For the purpose of this hearing, I think the variance request is, I just don't see that nexus, and that's the disconnect that I tried to raise earlier. That is, I understand there's a concern about the aesthetic of that, the existing shallow and exterior, but...

36:57 I just have a very difficult time connecting that with the AT&T variance request. Well, maybe I can help. I mean, legally, our dilemma is that we've asked who's legally representing the property owner, and you've said what staff has said to us is that you are legally representing the property owner. So if you're legally representing the property owner, who Commission has a problem with for being out of compliance since 1988,

37:27 Unfortunately, you're the only person that we can have our conversation with. So, I mean, it's, I mean, I just, I know it's not a fair thing in a sense, but this is our legal dilemma, is that if the property owner is not representing himself, we cannot have this conversation with the property owner. So. I understand that. I just, my concern is that to couple that aesthetic concern with the AT&T mobility variance.

37:53 I just don't see that nexus. And I think, unfortunately, that might trigger a decision by AT&T to abandon that property or that option and to look elsewhere, or it might escalate the application to an appeal. Again, I just think if we can narrow this variance request to the original COAs that would make

38:26 It would really, I think, be a lot more connected and a lot more reasonable. Is there any other questions of the applicant at this time? Thank you very much. Thank you. Is there anybody in the public that would like to comment on this matter? Ted Carlton, one comment. I hope you don't pay attention to idle threats by a company. If they don't want to do the project, I'm sure Verizon will be happy.

39:15 Why do I come to these meetings? Tom Cage, you know, 25 years ago I got married in six days. My wife got a new car this year. She kept the old one, but it needs maintenance, and so we've maintained it. You're dealing with a decision on a property that's been out of compliance for almost 25 years. I would think as Planning Commission it's not easy, but you've got to at some point lay down the law. Get into compliance first. That's one issue. The second issue is...

39:45 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

40:15 It is a foremost entry into the community building and if we stick something on top of it that isn't very appealing, you watch. If you were to approve both these things today, that antenna would go up first and you'd struggle to get the rest of the siding put on that's been 25 years coming. Thank you. Are there any other comments from the public? May I ask you one more thing? Just turn the rebuttal from the... I just want to say briefly that...

40:49 We understand the situation with the Shiloh. There is obviously an issue with the landlord. There must be some type of financial issue with the landlord because obviously they've been out of compliance for 25 years. Something's going on. AT&T, to my knowledge, is willing to comply with the original terms of this conditional use permit to...

41:09 Do the repairs and the maintenance repairs, basically, to the sides of the garage or parking structure that was originally called for in the COA. They are willing to do that as part of this permit. That is not even in question. That was the original condition of the COA, and they are willing to do that. It's the additional requirement that's really become the sticking point. That's all I wanted to mention. Thank you very much.

41:40 Are there any other comments from the public? And then the public hearing is closed at this time and the commission will deliberate on the matter. So we need to deliberate really I think on three issues. We have two issues regarding noncompliance. One the parking structure, one the landscaping, and then the third issue is the actual rooftop enclosure on the Shilohan itself. Who would like to start? Elizabeth?

42:14 Where shall I start? I think that the solution in terms of aesthetics for the tower on top, I shouldn't call it a tower, but you know, with antenna on top of the building is successful. I think that's going to work just fine. I follow all the arguments and having seen the bids, even though I'm not supposed to think about money up here.

42:34 I think to require greater than the original condition of approval is not needed because textured concrete can be done very well, but I personally would want to see the textured concrete and the landscaping before you put an antenna on the roof. I agree with Mr. Cage on that. However, I have to say that I'm really offended that we've had no communication from the owner that he sends AT&T

43:02 from whom he will be making money for leasing that space on his roof to represent him here. I'm offended on behalf of the Commission. I really, really am. And there's also an underlying theme here of compliance. And this isn't just making the town look pretty or taking down some banners. It's compliance on everything.

43:25 The fact that for 25 years he hasn't complied with the conditions of approval and yet he received a certificate of occupancy or the corporation did or whoever was running it. The condos that were built along the bike trail immediately south of Juniper Springs Lodge received a condition of approval before they put in the bike bridge across Mammoth Creek so that you could make a circuit on your bike. I've never understood that and we don't have a bike bridge yet and that was years and years ago.

43:52 And an even smaller issue, the high school put up a digital sign, which was somewhat controversial, a condition of approval was that it would have a roof, a little rooflet so it would look like the trail signs and be, you know, an attractive addition. They were allowed to turn that thing on before it was completed. This all has to do with compliance, and we work so hard up here to get best possible outcome, and without compliance, why? I really wonder.

44:20 In the sheet in the last month, there have been two excellent letters to the editor. One was about not having a building official and outsourcing building officials, and the other was about diff. I mean, well thought out, really serious letters by concerned people, and I just, we can't run things like this. I'm terribly, terribly concerned about being out of compliance on so many different levels, and

44:46 People are just sort of thumbing their nose at the town. That's how I look at it. And I'm very, very troubled by that. It goes way beyond aesthetics. I mean, it's serious, serious issues, and we just can't keep running things like this. That's all I have to say. Okay. I'm trying to take a shot at this. Madam Chair, I do understand the financial implications and the way that the

45:20 Commission is supposed to deal with these things, but for purposes of demonstration, I need to talk briefly. When the request was made that the garage entrance and a portion of the east wall be wrapped in rock veneer, similar to the rock veneer that they already have existing,

45:53 My research tells me that it was between $30 and $35 per square foot to do something like this. Commissioner Fernie's comments are absolutely appropriate. What is the cost of shooting that with textured concrete? Well, I'm afraid you're going to be looking at very close to the same amount of money. So I don't think that this is a money

46:26 issue necessarily. I stand with the thought that the nexus between these two issues is aesthetics. The aesthetics that are going to happen on top of the roof while you're coming forward with a variance to achieve that. And offsetting

46:56 Another feature on the structure is the entrance to the garage area and the portion of the east side, a small portion of the east side, which was requested to be wrapped in rock to give our customers, if you will, people visiting Mammoth, that Mammoth feel, that Mammoth look.

47:28 It's absolutely appropriate to believe that if in fact what the commission is asking for does not get built out prior to building permits issued for the enclosure on top of the building, we'll never see any improvement on that garage face.

48:02 The other thing which sort of insults my intelligence is when this was approved in 1988, textured concrete was the greatest and the latest. And asking to meet those standards at this time is the difference between providing somebody with a

48:34 1988 Chevy or a 2014 Chevy. Things change. Things change dramatically. If in the document it said a Chevy would be provided, would it be a Chevy of 1988 or would it be a Chevy of 2013? So I don't...

49:03 I don't really buy into that argument of, well, we're willing to do what was requested way back then. What was requested was state of the art at that time. Well, what's requested now isn't even state of the art. I mean, we have a very hard time approving the type of rock that's on that building in our design standards. It's faux rock. And we know the problems that we have with that. But because it's there now,

49:37 That was certainly a reasonable request. So I'm standing very strong with my first thoughts on this. There are some issues. I'll finish up with this. There are some issues with the landscaping that were brought up upon going back to the site and inspecting the site. It's a difficult situation.

50:09 One of the things that's happened is vehicular traffic has used the area that was set for landscaping, and that's been traffic going over Shiloh's property now for 20-some years. It gets stopped once in a while when people put boulders out, but I don't necessarily know that that's a huge solution for us.

50:46 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

51:25 First of all, thank you for your time for coming. I don't know. Nobody said that, but thank you for jumping in the middle of this. It's very unfortunate that our request was for a change was presented with

51:45 The misunderstanding came along that you were presenting something that was not what anyone asked for. So I know that cost isn't what we were looking, that we were told not to consider, but that's actually what you considered when you had a bid that you said was cost prohibitive.

52:04 My fellow commissioners, it's hard to compare apples to oranges, and one of the reasons that we were asking for what was the cost of the cement versus the cost of what we asked for is, you know, you might be talking the same thing, and though it's not our concern to save anyone any money, it might be yours, and it might be that it would be in compliance and moving forward, so it's unfortunate that we don't have that to go on.

52:31 There, I think at the very least, before the project is considered completed, that all of this has to be done at the same time. We have a very short window, as we all know that the winter's coming up, but you can understand that there is no confidence that any of these other conditions will be met because they haven't been met in 25 years. It's very unfortunate that you have picked a location that...

52:57 is out of compliance and continues to be. And I think one of the things that we'd ask at the last meeting was what other areas were considered. Apparently nothing was. That did not come back to consider other areas. And so we only have your word to go on that this is the one, the only side, and it will delay progress and our connection with civilization for a little while longer. So that's unfortunate as well.

53:22 I would say that the landscaping, that is part of the 88-2 condition, and that absolutely has to be considered for this year, not next year. And if whatever is decided on the surface, it needs to be at the very minimum, the requirement of what was asked for in 80.

53:49 And 88. And if you then so decide to get a bid and find out that the section that we were looking for, beautifying, comes up and you can make that, meet the request. I think that would be in everybody's best entrance. And knowing that all of this construction going on in the next few months is going to greatly impact everyone's abilities for not only the construction on the building, I have no problem with that.

54:19 And I appreciate you being compliant to what the building looks like right now. But having that this is in everyone's best interest to not draw this out and to get it done this season in order to not only improve the service, the cell service for the few customers that are here in town, but the other customers that we have a lot of AT&T customers that are visitors. So that can be improved, but along with these, these have to be done. And since you are that could.

54:48 The representing the client and the applicant for the building that you would ensure that that would get done. This has been an interesting one. Well, the first thing I'll say is that I absolutely see the value of enhancing AT&T cellular service in Mammoth. It is both necessary and wanted by, you know, people who live here and people who visit. So I have no issue with that.

55:26 Our intent is certainly not to shut that down. I do disagree that I think in 2013 that a four-sided textured concrete on that structure will look aesthetically pleasing. And when I initially went out to the site visit, I was really focused on the entrance and the east-facing wall, which get the majority of viewing traffic at this point.

55:55 But as I continue to walk the site, I do think it's important that all four sides of the structure are addressed because we do have a property on that side that could potentially be developed and then we would be in the same situation we're in now where a neighboring property is looking at a substandard garage. So I certainly understand that we're not supposed to talk about cost and that's not supposed to be a consideration. I'm having a really difficult time.

56:26 Not involving that in the thought process whatsoever because that is the sticking point. So I think it's very unfortunate that the cost estimate that we had come through was for the tune of $100,000, which is not what was requested. Are we okay? You said, I understand what we're legally allowed to do here. We're not legally allowed to require rock veneer on four sides.

56:53 We are legally allowed to require the initial conditional use permit to be met, correct? That is correct. Okay. So that would involve the two things that we're talking about, the textured concrete on the structure and the landscaping. Are we allowed to engage in some sort of negotiation around this without mandating it legally? Yes. Okay.

57:17 So what I'm suggesting, and I hear and appreciate from AT&T, that they are willing to meet the initial conditions of the use permit. What I would suggest, and I don't know how the commission feels about this, is that if we were to look at approving something like this, we could say we're willing to approve this once the initial conditions are met or something that is cost comparable.

57:46 because that's what we're all kind of dancing around here, that if we can look at a bid that's four-side texturing and that costs X number of dollars, if they're willing to look at a bid that would include rock veneer on two sides and that would be cost comparable, is that something that we can do? Well, I'd suggest that rather than saying cost comparable, that you would say require compliance with the original, and I'll have to

58:14 Give you some precise wording, but require compliance with the original conditions or an alternative plan that might be approved by a subcommittee of this body, if you'd be comfortable with that. And not bring cost into it, but allow the subcommittee to have some flexibility to meet with AT&T and perhaps with the property owner and determine

58:42 The exact extent of the textured concrete and whether you could trade some textured concrete for some rock and how that might work out. That is where I would like to see this go personally. I am certainly cognizant of the fact that a $100,000 bid can be cost prohibitive. But I would love to be able to be involved in some sort of negotiation where an alternative solution can be come up that doesn't have to be a $100,000.

59:12 Four-sided rock veneering or on the other side of the spectrum, just four-sided texturing of concrete. If we can find some way to meet in the middle there, that would be what I am most comfortable with. So in regards to what Chair Brown had asked, I have no issues with the antenna structure on top, but I do have an issue fundamentally with approving a variance on a property that is not in current compliance.

59:41 So as far as the parking structure and the landscaping, I'm not willing to issue a certificate of occupancy on the antenna structure on top of the building until those two things are met. And if those can be met at some sort of agreement in the middle that maybe the commission is happy with and AT&T is happy with, that would be my desirable outcome.

1:00:05 Because I don't, at this point, I understand that that is a default position, but I would prefer something else than four-sided textured concrete. I think it's important to realize that a variance runs with a property. It doesn't run with AT&T. I personally feel very strongly that if a property owner is in non-compliant or other issues, I have no inclination to grant future variances.

1:00:38 I understand that we can only legally ask that he's in compliant with 1988 standards, and I just would like to make the comment that we spent a lot of time prepping for our meetings, so it's a little, I almost feel resentful that this was brought to us at the last minute after we did an on-site review of these other bids to hear that, well, no, this isn't what AT&T is.

1:01:08 Willing to pay for. It's not very respectful to us or to our time and it makes us to be in a position where we have to be on the dais trying to make instant decisions, which I personally do not like to do. As far as the tower on top of the building, I am fine with it. I really do not want to personally approve any variance until the two prior conditions have been met.

1:01:35 So with that, does anybody have a motion they'd like to make? Madam Chair, I think the Chairman Fernie's suggestion of, and Mr. Taylor's suggestion of a subcommittee is probably the direction to go here, and I think the charge of the subcommittee is to work out not seeing someone from Shiloh here. It's probably to work out with the AT&T folks exactly what can be done or can't be done.

1:02:15 And if that meets the will of the commission, that's fine. And AT&T, that's good. If it doesn't, then I think we look for alternatives. So is the motion to continue the hearing subject to perhaps design review meeting with AT&T? The design review committee? That would be my recommendation. I would be willing to serve on that committee.

1:02:50 Along with Chair Ferney, if that's the pleasure of the commission. Well, I certainly want them to come into compliance, and I don't see it happening without some leverage, and so I guess that's what it will be. What I was suggesting, if you look at the wording on condition 32, it does not defer compliance to certificate of occupancy. Compliance has to take place prior to issuance of a building permit.

1:03:19 And so what I was suggesting, and I certainly understand the reticence, was that in fact it would approve the variance subject to the conditions, but the condition would say compliance with conditions 26 and 5 prior to issuance of building permit, and the final design of that compliance and determination of consistency with the condition would be up to a subcommittee of the Planning Commission.

1:03:46 That's exactly what I was going to suggest, if we can just add some verbiage to the existing 32 that says, or some sort of alternate agreement with the subcommittee. I'll read you a sentence and then you can. Yeah, sure, perfect. The final design of the landscaping and garage wall shall be approved by, excuse me, final design of the landscaping and garage wall shall be end determination of compliance.

1:04:14 With the conditions of use permit 88-2 shall be by a subcommittee of the Planning Commission. And this all has to take place prior to, as stated in the condition, prior to issuance of the building permit. So we have to know what's going to happen. It probably has to have happened before. I mean, you can work out those details, but that's, since that seems to be the sticking point, get through the rest of it and focus on that.

1:04:49 Personally, I'm comfortable with that. Are you going to make a motion to that effect? Sure. I would make a motion to adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required municipal code findings, and approve variance 13-002 pending conditions

1:05:25 31 and 32 with modified language that was just discussed. Okay, and I'll give you the, so shall I read the condition back one more time? Yes, please. So, new condition, we will be deleting condition 21 because it conflicts with the new 32. Okay. Renumber 30, so we'll renumber, but don't worry about that. Sure.

1:05:51 The new 31 shall be at such time as the exterior design, color, or material at the Shiloh Inn may be changed. The owner of the antenna shield shall modify the exterior of the antenna shield to match the new building exterior, subject to approval through the then applicable design review process of the town. Then the next condition, number 32, no building permit shall be issued for the antenna array and shield.

1:06:15 until the applicant and their property owner has satisfied outstanding use permit 88-2 conditions of approval, specifically condition 26 regarding the exterior of the garage structure and condition 5 pertaining to maintenance of the landscaping. The final design of the landscaping and garage wall and determination of compliance with use permit 88-2 shall be by a subcommittee of the Planning Commission. Is that your motion? Yes. Do I have a second? Second.

1:06:46 Is there any additional discussion? Then who's going to serve on the subcommittee? I'd like to just clarify that. Commissioner Fernie, Commissioner Harvey, or Commissioner Tenney also? No. Roll call, please. Commissioner Dugan? Yes. Commissioner Harvey? Yes. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Fernie? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Motion passes 5-0. This part of the public hearing is closed. Do we continue the public hearing or close it? That public hearing is closed.

1:07:23 The public, you're interested. Okay. We'll now have a presentation by the Mammoth Community Water District by Patrick Hayes, General Manager. Good afternoon, Chairman Brown, members of the Planning Commission. I'm pleased to be here. This is Pat Hayes with the Mammoth Community Water District. Thank you for inviting me here today. What I'm going to discuss is the terms of the settlement that...

1:08:17 Los Angeles Department of Water and Power and the Mammoth Community Water District put into effect as of July 11, 2013. What I'm about to discuss was presented in very brief terms to your council on July 24, and this is a great opportunity to get together as two

1:08:42 Very valuable assets of the community and make sure that we're working together and in concert for the future development and enhancement of the community. I'll start with a brief presentation. I have received some preliminary questions. I'm sure you'll have others. In this presentation, you will see that some of your questions may be answered as I get through it.

1:09:09 If you do feel the need to ask questions while I'm in them, please do so. But I think you'll find that some of your questions will be answered in this process. So briefly, a little geography lesson about the district. You're familiar with the normal boundaries. The district itself is about five and a half square miles within the town limits of Mammoth Lakes. What you see here in red,

1:09:51 Are three water treatment facilities. We can't see that. Jen, can you turn the lights off for Sandra? It could be a little. Too much backlight. Thank you. That's better. Thank you very much. Yeah, now I can see red. The supply for the Mammoth Community Water District constituents comes from three main sources of treatment. Shown down at the bottom is the surface water treatment plant, which takes water from Lake Mary.

1:10:33 That's our preferred source and of the highest water quality. And two groundwater treatment plants, very creatively named groundwater treatment plant one and two. In addition, there are some yellow symbols there. They show the nine groundwater production wells that we draw water. Currently, about 70% of our water supply this day is coming from those wells and the remainder from the Lake Mary plant.

1:11:03 In the spring runoff, virtually all of the water supply comes from Lake Merritt. On the far right, you can see a fourth red dot, and that represents where the district headquarters is, but more importantly, the wastewater treatment plant and the capacities there are also important in this discussion. So the settlement involves the water rights that this community has enjoyed in its 60 years of existence vis-a-vis what

1:11:32 The City of Los Angeles' claim to those rights are as well. The settlement terms were driven by two lawsuits that the Los Angeles Department of Water and Power filed against MCWD. One was in concern to the final environmental impact report for Mammoth Creek Fishery Bypass Flow. They took exception to the numbers in terms of supply and Lake Mary flows. And to the 2010 Urban Water Management Plan.

1:12:08 Both parties claimed water rights, LA claimed pre-1914 rights, and the district had since 1958 several sets of rights given to it by the Department of Water Resources, that's a state agency. This settlement avoids costly litigation where there was really no certain outcome.

1:12:32 I think we've all experienced or seen litigation that went underway that turned out to be very costly and had very bad outcomes. This particular case, we've spent just north of $750,000 in legal fees, and it provides for, thank you, it provides a reliable water supply for at least the next 100 plus years, and I'll explain what that means in a moment.

1:13:16 The settlement costs involve the following. An initial payment of $3.4 million for the primary period of 50 years. A payment in 50 to 60 years of $2.4 million for the secondary period. And what that says in so many words is that we have a guaranteed water supply and no litigation if we follow the terms of the agreement for at least 100 years going forward. We have the ability to extend the primary period for up to 10 years.

1:13:43 That extension would be based on the accumulation of water conservation savings below the maximum annual allowable use of 4,387 acre feet. Our water use in 2012 was 2,730. So you can see we have about, percentage-wise, about 67% of the capacity underneath that 4,387 is currently being used. That leaves the remaining 33%, 34%. Sorry to interrupt.

1:14:14 But on that $3.4 million over the initial 50 years, is that $3.4 million that's split into 50 payments, or how does that work exactly? Thank you for the question. That's important to note. It's a lump sum payment due within 60 days of the July 11th settlement. So coming up very soon, the district will be paying the city of Los Angeles border power $3.4 million.

1:14:43 And then no payment. For 50 years. At least 50 years. Okay. The fourth bullet there about extension, we are currently using well less than what we're allocated. The difference between those goes into a credit fund, if you will, banking, and that it will extend the period to the limit that we can stay under that number during the 50-year period. We can get up to an additional 10 years of credit accumulation based on that.

1:15:14 And it behooves us to do that, to get this down the road for 10 years. Following in, I'm sorry, go ahead, Dave. Okay. Patrick, on the 3.4 million for the first 50 years, does that come out of ratepayer increases? It is coming out of our reserve funds. The district maintains reserves for various purposes. Correct.

1:15:43 And this reserve fund is a very appropriate place when you have unscheduled, unforeseen expenses to make sure the district stays solvent during a period of crisis. Another way to say this is that once we've removed this $3.4 million, we've also removed the potential of any further litigation about it. So the balance is our risks are now reduced.

1:16:13 Concurrently. Okay, I guess my direct question was, is there going to be rate increases due to the settlement? We do not think so at this time. Okay. Excuse me, what was the rationale for the community of Mammoth Lakes to pay the City of Los Angeles this money?

1:16:32 As part of the settlement, what is the figure for, or what was the rationale behind it? If you'll bear with me, Commissioner, for just a moment, you might see where the money is going to be spent. Okay. The settlement quantities provide for 4,387 acre-feet per year. That's the maximum that we can take from the system. And that's the sum of surface water, groundwater, and recycled water.

1:17:04 And it includes 2,760 acre feet per year of surface water from Lake Mary, which was a component of that first lawsuit on the EIR from Mammoth Creek. And it's based on a calculated consumptive use of 1,779 acre feet. That's about 40% of the 4387 number. Consumptive use, I'm sure it's a term you bandy around every day, right? Probably not.

1:17:33 What that means is if you consume 10 gallons of water, 6 of it stays in the system, 4 of it is lost. And where is it lost? It's lost generally to evapotranspiration. That's the consumptive use component, and that's the amount that we are mitigating in the way of conservation majors as part of this lawsuit. So how will that money be used? It will be to convert from inefficient flood irrigation to more efficient sprinkler irrigation.

1:18:04 in LADWP leasehold lands. It will save the consumed water, the $1,779, and it will maintain the system for 50 years. The initial payment of $3.4 million that we'll be doing in the next several weeks will go to build a sprinkler system and maintain it for 50 years. The secondary payment is to revamp the system 50 years out so that it will work for another 50 years hence. These are the several areas that are likely to be involved in the sprinkler.

1:18:35 There are three of them. This is the Chance Ranch area. The lightly colored pinkish area, if you will, is land owned by the LA Department of Water and Power. Where flood irrigation is done, it's not a very efficient method. Sprinkler irrigation, replacing that for pasture lands is much more efficient. Laurel Pond, again, the area really showing in gray here. Those are LA DWP lands and a second opportunity.

1:19:06 And the third opportunity is in the Crowley Lake area. These pasture lands will likely get sprinkler irrigation, pay for it with the $3.4 million. Commissioner Tenney, I'm not sure I've answered your question, but that's what I was leading to when I was referring to it earlier. I just didn't see the rationale for why we were paying DWP. Is it fair to say, Patrick, that the $3.4 million is staying here in the county?

1:19:36 It is in the context of what I've just stated. There's no requirement in the agreement as to exactly how the city of Los Angeles will spend that money. That is what has been purported they will spend it on. So in that context, I can say yes. If they are pointing out these lands and that's where they're going to use it, it's up to them to use it as efficiently as they see fit. Now, for a slight diversion, LA Charter, their city charter,

1:20:08 Does not allow them to sell water rights. So in effect what we are doing in this settlement is not disputing water rights by either party, but providing some money for water conservation that will be equivalent in savings to what we consume. That's the deal. So you might wonder where the 4387 came from.

1:20:39 The basis for it can be found in the 2010 Urban Water Management Plan, and I'm going to cite some tables from that now. Table ES1 in that plan, and I have a copy here. If you're interested in this plan, it's on our website online if you care to go take a look at it. You can see on the first column there's three descriptions. Resident population, I think everybody's clear what that means. Those are the people that live here.

1:21:11 on a year-round basis. The people at one time number is just that. What's the most you ever saw here at any one time? I think 2003 there were 35,000 people here at one time. What the Department of Water Resources, which requires us to do these plans every five years, dictates is that we use an effective annual population.

1:21:37 Those are the driving numbers, the effective annual population as to how we determine what our use will be at build out. What this chart attempts to do is to relate to you, if you're familiar with the people at one time number, how that relates to the number we have to use, effective annual population. In this case, 52,000 versus 24,210 of the effective annual population. There's a formula for how those relate, but I won't get into that here.

1:22:06 Any questions about that? Table ES2 shows what our use was over a 10-year period through 2010, which went into the report, showing the average daily use, and more importantly, the per capita or gallons per capita day in the far right column. If you track those numbers, generally they're going down over the 10-year period. This is not atypical in the water industry. With water conservation,

1:22:40 Higher costs for water, water signals, tiered rates, a less than stellar economy, water consumption has been going down on a per capita day basis. We're required to reach a 20% reduction by 2020. That's the 141 gallon number in the far lower right corner. You can see that we're already there in these numbers.

1:23:10 That requirement is by the state that's completely separate from this lawsuit, correct? It is. And that's generally why these plans are done. One of the components is water conservation is a state-level issue. It's a regional issue. It's a national issue. It's not going away. And the restrictions and regulations that we operate on are continuing to get stricter.

1:23:38 This figure, ES2, shows the change in gross water use in effective population. You can see over the last 10 years leading to 2010 that the annual consumption has dropped. What's important about this is if you look to the far right, that only is 2010. I have some more up-to-date information that I'll show you in a minute. This talks about the distribution of where the water goes. This is driven entirely by the market.

1:24:07 You as a planning commission and zoning efforts determine what that market looks like and the economy dictates it. We are there to supply water as the requests come in. So you can see that in terms of units, multifamily and single family constitute the majority of the applications. No surprises there. The irrigation component further down the page

1:24:34 Irrigation meters are now being required more and more, and the number is growing daily. And the reason for that is it puts an emphasis on outdoor water use and how efficiently that's being done. I'll get into that a bit more later. This shows the range going through five-year, ten-year increments up to 2030, what the total acre-foot numbers are. By 2030, we expect to be in the 3,751 range.

1:25:07 If we add to that some losses, the number is in the 4180. The 4387 is still greater than that build-out number at 2030. These are some updated data. You saw this chart earlier. It only went through 2010. In 2011, we used 2,292 acre-feet, and last year, 2,730. First time in many years that it's gone up. That's driven by several things.

1:25:40 Perhaps an improvement in the economy, but also hydrologic factors, evapotranspiration, temperature, wind, humidity, but we're still well within the bounds of the 20% reduction by 2020. So this is the more up-to-date chart showing a projected effective population on a straight-line basis and that we are currently at, as you saw from the previous chart,

1:26:10 2,738 feet. That's still considerably below the 4,387 that we've been allocated vis-a-vis the settlement agreement. This is the average per capita day trend line, and until 2012, you can see it's generally trending lower. Kind of to the point of the discussion, the bar in the dark blue shows what we used last year. The gray area shows what's left.

1:26:48 And in rough terms, the community has been using about two-thirds of the water that's allocated per this agreement. Now, this doesn't tell the whole story. The dark blue part represents indoor and outdoor use. At 2,700 acre feet, with water conservation, we expect that that number could be reduced to 2,000 by more efficient use of irrigation and the tools we have available.

1:27:21 So there's two ways to look at this. You've got a ceiling of 4387. You've got a third of it left to grow in. But through better and more efficient use of the water supply you have, you can actually create more room for planning, development, and the further growth of the community. So there are opportunities here for conservation. Currently, we produce today about 4.5 million gallons during the summer months.

1:27:52 We treat only 1.5 million gallons at our wastewater treatment plant. That leaves about 3 million gallons. That's all irrigation. We've looked at our top 100 users. We have an ongoing water conservation program. During this time of the year, we have two full-time people involved in irrigation and conservation. More than half of those 100 top users exceed the maximum allowable water allowance. The maximum water allowance

1:28:23 is what people need to grow their landscaping and keep it healthy. More than half of the people that are in the top 100 are exceeding that number. More than 25% are exceeding it by 200%. That is where I'm talking about considerable opportunity to reduce consumption and still have green lawns and a thriving community. This concludes my formal part of the presentation. I'll entertain whatever questions you might have.

1:28:57 I've been attending meetings of the Downtown Working Group, which is dealing with the commercial zoning aspect of the zoning code update, and they're really struggling with, not density, but struggling with how to zone the downtown area and Old Mammoth Road, you know, of the commercial, and we're talking about, or they are talking about, buildings that are white boxes. In other words, a developer would know what he was able to do within a building envelope.

1:29:27 Then he could go and figure out could he make a project pencil and then he would come back with a proposal. And the thing that has me confused, which I hope you'll address, you said how much water is left, but how is this water allocated? I've never even thought about that until all this happened because I know a single family residence is not the same kind of meter that a hotel gets or that a motel gets or a retail, you know, ski shop.

1:29:55 How do you allocate those meters? What are the equivalents as far as those meters go? And I know when we reach the 52,000, when you reach your agreement, even with conservation and recycling and all the rest, I mean, we will reach that point. You're really the tail wagging the dog here in terms of planning efforts because, you know, you know how much water there is based on this agreement.

1:30:19 So we need some guidance from the water district. Just what have we got to work with and is it really first come, first served? Should we put, you know, anybody who wants to develop a piece of property on notice or just can you talk about that a little bit? First we need to talk about risk. The number that you saw there, the 4387, represents what Los Angeles and Mammoth have agreed to that we will not exceed for the next 100 years. Will that water be available?

1:30:52 Just because it's written into an agreement? No. Oh, great. How many here would like to see a massive snowfall this winter? How many of you will guarantee that that will occur? We are in exactly the same position from a water supply point of view. Water supply is very mercurial. It's driven by the hydrologic cycle. No one has control of that. We're at effect. We do...

1:31:20 Everything we do, our mission is to provide water supply reliably as possible. As long as it's raining, as long as it's snowing, as long as the Lake Mary fills up with snow melt and our groundwater occupiers recharge, and they have about a lag time of two years. You have a good year, you're going to get two years of good water supply for groundwater. You have a bad year, it's going to take two years to catch up again. So that 4387 by no means is...

1:31:48 Our guarantee that we're going to deliver that to you is only an upper limit of what we can take. When we're doing an allocation of meters, the amount of flow that's available is dependent directly on the size of that meter. We have a connection charge based on the size of the meter. We can provide that information and have regularly provided that to developers so that they know what those costs are and they can allocate the water based on other drivers.

1:32:21 In terms of the number of fixture units, not something we can control. That's driven by a plumbing code and your own ordinances. But we can tell the developer what it's going to cost for the amount of water that developer wants to take. Then it's up to them to decide how that pencils out in their agreement. Just a point of clarification, is the commercial meter based on square footage?

1:32:48 Number of plumbing fixtures, number of heads and beds, what is it based on for a commercial application? First of all, we don't dictate the size of the meter. We provide the meter that's requested. Other drivers from other locations not within the district are determining what the fixture count driving points are as to what amount of water is needed for that particular development. So you just keep

1:33:19 Giving will serve letters? I mean, how do you know when you've reached your, God, I'm just, I'm going in a circle here, but I'm very confused by this, because you know you have a finite amount of water, which can vary depending on precipitation, and so then how do you decide, gee, we can't give out any more will serve letters? When does that point come? So you're trying to determine how long is a piece of string. We can't tell you that with a full guarantee. We have to evaluate.

1:33:46 Every time we're in a request for a will serve letter, what is the available supply currently available in the system? If we're in the midst of a five year or ten year drought, that number might be zero. It's what we're able to serve based on what the hydrologic conditions are dictating to us. At the other end of the parameters, the 4387, we're not going to be in a position to exceed that number, so we won't be issuing

1:34:17 Will serve letters beyond a meter equivalent capacity that would exceed that number. Patrick, I've got a couple of questions. The settlement, I'm sure, is a lengthy document that you all spend a lot of time going through and probably a lot of information in there that would be hard for a lot of us lay people to digest. The question that I...

1:34:53 that I have that comes to mind is in the settlement is Mammoth Community Water District prohibited from looking for additional sources of water and if so what are those limitations? We are not limited but the availability of other sources will come with a price tag in terms of what it costs to acquire that.

1:35:25 And probably more importantly what it would cost to actually deliver it to us. To develop it. Sure. And the water rights environment is pretty well staked out at this point. There isn't really any unclaimed water left in this state. Well, that was my next question, and I understand that it is pretty well, you know, staked out. Hypothetically, are there opportunities?

1:35:56 for the water district to explore for additional waters. And if so, does this settlement preclude the water district from doing that? There are always opportunities at a price. Nothing in this settlement precludes us from doing that. Okay. Thank you. No questions?

1:36:28 Just a quick question that maybe you can elaborate on a little bit, looking at the chart that you put forth regarding local population, PAOT, and what was the third term, I'm sorry? Effective. Effective annual. Effective annual population. Okay. Can you talk a little bit about, let's say those estimates are off.

1:36:52 In one way or the other. So, for example, let's say we have less locals than projected at 2013, but more visitors, or vice versa, more locals, less visitors. How does that skew those numbers on the annual basis? I could answer that, but not in the context that you put it forth. We would need to know actual numbers and run it through our modeling to see what that means.

1:37:20 The urban water management plan is done every five years. The current plan is the 2010 one. We keep tracking it, as you saw from my numbers up there earlier. The next one we do in 2015, and that is the opportunity to re-index with what the current projections are. These are all, like much of what we do, pro forma. We don't know exactly what's going to happen 20 or 30 years out.

1:37:45 Let me rephrase the question, I don't know if this is even answerable, but what of those two entities puts a larger strain on water usage? You have a couple components here, not unlike the electric business, you have a demand charge, basically we have to build infrastructure for the peak demand, which in this case would be the, what do you call it, the maximum probable number of people here, number.

1:38:16 But that's not likely to occur very often. You're building for a one-off sort of event that occurs not very frequently. You also have to make sure that the costs of the district, which are mainly fixed costs, are being met through charges, through fixed meter charges and other revenue sources. Selling water alone in a community like this where you have so many absentee owners doesn't really pencil out. It's mainly fixed charges.

1:38:44 So we've issued those permits, put out meters of different sizes, they all come with a capacity, and we have built a system that is there to deliver that capacity when it occurs at the maximum probable event. And just one other thing that maybe you could elaborate on a little bit. I did have a chance to go to the talk last week, and something that was brought up that I'm not sure if everybody is aware of is

1:39:15 You know, really the focus of that was was irrigation of lawns and the idea that I believe it might have been you had brought up that density is not something that we should be afraid of in the sense that having a dense condo development or a dense hotel is actually less water intensive than than some other options. Or somewhat equivalent. I did state that and

1:39:46 I'll reiterate it for the benefit of everyone here. You can see from these numbers here that we have up, right now, two-thirds of the water that we're producing is not supporting any life to speak of in terms of human life. It's going on the ground to enhance the community. And I've postulated earlier that with the conservation that's possible, and we're starting to look very closely at interval data about how that water is actually being used.

1:40:16 There's ripe opportunity to reduce that 3 million in the 1.5 million range, which creates additional capacity. The problem that you're talking about, about densification, you take Southern California cities that have already been built out in the 20s and 30s, they're densifying like crazy now. You're taking out three or four duplexes and putting in a 50-unit apartment building.

1:40:45 Their water demands will not change a whole lot. It's probably not exactly the right proportions, but what happens is that we have a lot of built-in water conservation devices within the homes now. Toilets, shower heads, aerators on faucets, low-flow dishwashers, washing machines, all of that is driving down the per capita consumption. And when you put a larger footprint, you're wiping out the irrigation demand. You no longer have the irrigation.

1:41:14 surface area to water. And with that, you get a commensurate reduction. So, in general, in Southern California, the Metropolitan Water District area has increased in population in the last 20 years, mainly through densification, by about 30%. The water use today is the same as it was 20 years ago. So that's the basis of what I was talking about. Thank you for that. I think that might help to answer your question. Yeah, I'll grab another one. Go ahead.

1:41:45 What would be the Water District's recommendation to the Planning and Economic Development Commission as we plan for reinvestment? I mean, we're really hoping, you know, with Main Street, with our downtown area for infill and some good development to happen that's beneficial to the community, and yet it was my impression because of this agreement, and I outlined that in a number of questions that I forwarded to Sandra, that water is going to limit that.

1:42:15 What would be your recommendation to help us do wise planning? There's always going to be a limit. In this case, we have a hard limit in terms of a litigated settlement that has come out of this about what the upper limit of what we can take. As Commissioner Harvey was saying, there's other potential sources of water out there for a price. There's always those avenues available to us if you want to make that investment. I think to be more direct,

1:42:45 The District and the Planning Commission need to work hand in glove with working toward and supporting strong conservation methods and measures, and you'll see a lot more of that in the next year or so because of this agreement and what our plans are to make it much more effective. In light of your desire for growth and development, you have some numbers here that tell you how much is available in the general context.

1:43:15 We can't predict what the rainfall is tomorrow, next week, or the next 10 years. That's going to be the real number that's going to limit us on a year-over-year basis. Climate change is another factor. So we need to keep in close communication with each other about what the circumstances are. And jointly, the town of Mammoth Lakes and the district need to work on conservation.

1:43:43 Commissioner Ferney attended was the water efficiency landscape ordinance that the city is updating. The town of Mammoth Lakes is updating. And the purpose of that ordinance is to make more efficient use of the water that is available for landscaping and have controls and checks and balances on it. Once it's built, then the water district has to enforce that. We have in that 100 top users list a number of people that

1:44:10 We have a pilot program with 25 of those. We've had some amazing results so far. We found one development with a 300,000 gallon per month leak through the use of interval data. That tells us there's a lot of opportunity for reduction. That's more than one acre foot per month with one property. Others, we've shown them what they're wasting in the way of dollars per month.

1:44:40 Once that reaches homeowners associations, they get the attention of their managers. We have one that's committed to reduce their outdoor irrigation by over 50%. And we're just in the very early days of that pilot program. So I think there's a lot of opportunities out there. But with it will come some reinvestment requirements. Irrigation systems built 20 years ago. You can put the smartest clock or the smartest meter in the world on there. It still won't work.

1:45:07 They need to update their systems. They need to spend some money to get there. There will be a return on that investment. So as a community, we need to support the conservation efforts that are clearly in front of us. So if an investor comes to town and is interested in assembling some parcels or, you know, buying empty property on Main Street, for example, where should that investor go first, the water district or the town? I think they start with the town.

1:45:34 Because we are able to provide at this present time will serve letters to development. Okay. But that is constantly evolving dynamics. Thank you. Do you have the ability to go back a couple of screens? I wanted to go back to the screen. I don't know. Without your computer restarting or our computer restarting. So it was the screen that said single family, 450, multi, this? Right there. Is this the one?

1:46:05 There was another one that was just for the 2010 time. Oh, yeah, the one that was for the 2000. So this is what I wanted to ask you. So is the multifamily so much higher because of the most multifamily have bigger landscaping needs? Or is it that multifamily people tend not to conserve water? Because they're not built directly. What are you asking specifically? Well, because...

1:46:33 I mean, a single-family resident, and I don't know what the correlation is, is like 450 acre-feet per year, where the multi-family is 926 acre-feet per year. Well, I would say that it's probably just the opposite. You have three times as many multi-family as single-family, but only twice the amount of use. Multi-families are more efficient. Back to Commissioner Fernie's question, you use less water, the more densification you get, and that, I think, shows the point.

1:47:03 So is, in like, for example, in that multifamily, does it include like the irrigation or is the irrigation all separate on that if it's a larger complex? Most of that is single or sets of meters that have both internal consumption and irrigation on them. Okay. As I was saying down below there, there's, the last line talks about irrigation meters. Right. With the WELO, the Water Efficiency Landscape Ordinance, with MAWA, the maximum allowable water.

1:47:32 With state's directive, anything over 2,500 square feet in today's world that's irrigated must have its own irrigation meter. And so that number's 42 down there is going to rise dramatically. But specifically that the multifamily has mixed use going on, irrigation and domestic consumption. And do you think our current

1:48:01 Draft of the zoning code of water efficiency has gone far enough. I mean, this is our time, but we haven't officially adopted it yet. I mean, do you have any other additional recommendations for that zoning code update and water efficiency? You already have a, you know, just use the acronym WELO, in fact, from previous requirements, but you're required by the state to update it. So that update is what's been going on. Our water conservation people have been working very closely with your

1:48:31 Planner Jessica. And it's been a very cooperative undertaking and, you know, effectively demonstrated by the meeting we held for the city's ordinance on our facility last week. So we're right in lockstep with what it says. And can you make any comments on our general infrastructure? We were at a, I was at a League of City meeting and one of the League of City people was saying that all they do right now is repair.

1:49:01 Thank you for that question. We do, on a monthly basis, what's called a non-revenue water or unaccounted for water report. Twenty years ago, the steel pipes that were largely making up the system were generating an unfathomable number, 45 or 50 percent of every gallon we produced.

1:49:30 was lost to leaks. That was 20 years ago. The board and the community have supported a water main replacement program over the last 20 years. It's largely run its course. We're now down to some water laterals, you know, going from the main to the homes. That number's now down well below 7%. So we've made an investment. That investment has paid huge dividends. What you're referring to

1:50:01 is not atypical. There's a lot of foregone investment in water infrastructure that hasn't been done, and that's the consequence of it, is water loss. And then my last question is, so I assume now you'll be, I think you've always have, but you'll be really diligent about your annual reporting, basically on an annual, right, some type of annual

1:50:35 Either fiscal or calendar year, you'll have some sort of reporting system about how we're doing? Yes, we have to do that by, you know, we're a regulated health organization by both the California Department of Public Health and by the State Water Resource Control Board. In fact, there's, that goes on much more frequently. This just institutionalizes a communication between us and Los Angeles. Right. But it will be, it's public information and it will be disseminated how we're doing.

1:51:03 Well, I mean, and kind of the bottom line, and to your point about being in a partnership, it'd be really nice in some format when you finish your reporting that you can come back and convey to us so we know how we're all doing, so. We should be committed to doing that, and we have various already standing committees that at various levels within the town and the district get together on a regular basis to make sure all those items are in play. Are there any other additional comments or questions?

1:51:35 One last small question, and thank you again for all your time in answering all these questions, but you had talked about the maximum allowable usage via the lawsuit was 4,700 acres. 4,387, yes. Okay. And I know you said that that's just dealing with the lawsuit and that doesn't take into account actual environmental factors that determine how much water we can actually use.

1:52:03 Take 2013 when we've had a couple of drought years. If we wanted to, would we be able to take that $4,300 currently? Yes, we would. It would have, as you imagine, impacts. We're allowed to take about 2,700 acre feet of that out of Lake Mary, but in practical terms, we've never come close to that number just because of other limitations, both in our own system and...

1:52:32 And in fish flow requirements. But we do have groundwater. And as I said, right now, 70% of our supply is coming from groundwater. But this is not a typical aquifer. Nothing is typical in the hydrogeology here. It's fractured rock. It fills up with melted water. And there's a finite capacity to it. When we get a good year like 2011, 10-11, that recharges the aquifers. And we're kind of living off that year still.

1:53:02 If we have extended drought, if we have several more years of drought, we wouldn't be able to say yes to your question. Okay. Thank you. Well, thank you very much, and welcome to Mammoth Lakes. Thank you, Commissioner Brown. Commissioner Brown. Did you? Could I add, and Patrick, could you go back one slide? No, I'm looking for the one. There you go, that one. Could you leave that up for me? Sure. If I might.

1:53:32 Madam Chairman, just Tom Cage from the Mammoth Community Water District, so I'll speak as a board member, just to make a few things perfectly clear. We monitor water and water use and delivery by the month. So this board or anyone could ask where the water is coming from, where it's being used by month. It's been like that for a long time, 20 plus years. So we have a great level of detail.

1:54:00 The pilot program that Patrick was talking about is we can read some meters, and this is going to get expanded, by the hour, by the day. So in this MAWA on one of those screens, violations where there's a ton of water being used by some users, we're going to them saying, we don't want all your money, we want you to use less water, and you water this hour, this hour, this hour, and how many gallons?

1:54:30 And on the day when they weren't supposed to, and we're politely going to them and sitting down with them and saying, we want to save you money, we want to save the water, and we have the technology now to see how much water you're using by the hour. So if they say, no, no, we don't water on odd day because we're an even address, we can say, well, gee, from two to three today, you used 10,000 gallons more than you used the hour before and the hour after. That's not flushing toilets, right?

1:54:59 So the irrigation thing is huge, and I can't emphasize enough that in the future for your planning purposes, it's just vital that the Mawa is followed. We're working to help people to follow it, but it's a biggie because that irrigation water, as you saw, we use four and a half million gallons a day in the summer. We use a million and a half gallons a day on average in the winter. That three million is not sustaining life, it's sustaining nice green grass.

1:55:29 And we have people that if it's green with that much water, gee, water it more, it'll get greener. It won't get greener. So we're trying to work with people on that. Commissioner Harvey, we can go out and find more water. We can go drill another well. We can't exceed the water use. So be very clear that that 4387 acre feet of allowable water use

1:56:00 is the ceiling. If we were to exceed that, we would A, have issues with LEDWP. If we planned it, we would have to ask permission. We would have to pay for it at prevailing rates, if they would give it to us, if we could find it. So it is not available to us. This lawsuit caps us there. Our plan at 2030...

1:56:29 In water use was approximately 4,000 acre feet. It was on one of the other slides. So this plan, I believe, ties in with the general plan at PAOT, at units of single family, multi-family, based on the estimates of density and development around town. So, Elizabeth, when you're thinking of how do we plan for this or what happens to the last guy in?

1:56:57 These are the estimates of units from commercial to single family that tie back in to your general plan work that you guys have worked hard on that arrived at PAOT, that arrived at densities. So if 2030 equals approximately 4,000, I think it was 67 acre feet of water, there's a cushion there.

1:57:26 That cushion, if we don't fix some of these excessive water uses on irrigation, could evaporate. So we need to stay diligent on that. We're working hard on our part. I don't know of any other water districts that are technologically more advanced than we are. Patrick might. Or newer than we are. Getting back to whoever asked on fixing pipes and leaks.

1:57:53 Our water system, because the guys have been replacing 7,000 to 10,000 feet of water line each and every summer for the past 10 plus summers, I don't know if we've replaced everything, but we've replaced a lot. And I think we're down to give or take 15,000 feet, maybe two summers. It's all laterals. So our main piping system in town for delivering water is within 10, 15 years old.

1:58:23 Which is very, very new. Because we estimate that those pipes will last 40 to 50 years. Our treatment plant is 15 years old. It should last 40 to 50 years. Will there be new technology that will change that we'll stay on top of? Yes. So just the new pipes, the finding water, and we're still at that limit. We can find all the water in the world. Essentially, LA owns it. We own the right to use 4,300 acre feet a year.

1:58:55 Okay, I guess that's the way I should have asked the question. So, yeah, I just wanted to make sure that was clear. If we were to go find a well on your property at your house tomorrow and we bulldoze your house and we drill that well and we start pumping, that's not ours to use in excess, unfortunately. If, I think the question that Colin asked, perfect question, today if we were at build-out, could we deliver 4,300 acre feet of water? And it's a great question and it's something that the board...

1:59:25 thinks about a lot in the sense that we're at level one water restrictions now because it was prudent to do so. It's not much of a water restriction. We're not saying you can't water. We're not turning off the water on Main Street. We're not limiting someone putting in new sod. We're just, we're odd even days. No watering between 10 and 5. There might be a few other little things that I'm forgetting.

1:59:51 But if we were to build out after a second year in a row of lean snowfall, we would probably be at a higher level of water restriction so that we were not impacting our wells if we were at build out today. So our wells could maintain that 4,000 acre feet of water, but we would probably elevate the water restrictions. We wouldn't allow new soil. You probably would have to water, hypothetically, maybe every three days.

2:00:21 If there was a water user that was exceeding Mawa by 50%, we would probably go to them and say, you're going to either fix this or we're going to shut you down. Those kinds of measures in a multi-year drought at build-out, I could foresee, so that when you turn on the faucet, the water's there. And last but not least, we base things on meter equivalents.

2:00:50 So a three-inch water main and a one-inch water main deliver a different amount of water. We have a model that says if there's 35,000 people in town based on the units that we've had and it's 35,000 people in town based on this amount of property, here's how much water is flowing. As we build, that water model is watched and followed and we will stay the course with that if it changes.

2:01:20 So that you would never have everyone come into town and turn on the faucet. But if you did, we have to be somewhat prepared. So the model is, if we're at build-out, and 70% of the people come into town and turn, and I don't know the exact number, turn on the faucet, there's water there. And the district has different zones in town, water reserves, water tanks that you see. There's one at the end. The newest one is at the end of Old Mammoth Road.

2:01:51 For that area. For that reason, because the engineers at the district determined that, okay, we need that, you know, as the village builds out, I think that's the next area, we need another tank, is one up by scheme racket. I think there's a tank up by scheme racket. I'm, you know, I don't know where they all are, but we would need another tank there if the village built out overnight. And we have to be in front of that.

2:02:19 You can't have them build that condo or that complex and say, we're going to get the water next year. They won't like that. Right? So it has to be built up front. So anyway, that's just some of the clearing up points that I wanted to make sure. Hopefully that helps, Elizabeth, because you're working on this now with your density. So we take this that you gave to the district 2007. Thank you.

2:02:47 We work from what you gave us in 07 to our urban water management plan every five years. As you change yours, it's our job to follow you, not you to follow us. Hand in glove makes sense because we do have a limit. It's 4,300 acre feet. So we've taken our best guess on when this might implement based on these units, based on the water, the acre feet year, AFY, and we build to that.

2:03:17 If density doubles on Main Street, and again, I'm exaggerating that, those numbers are going to change. At some point in time, it exceeds the water level. It exceeds the water that we can deliver. And I'm exaggerating. Again, you take Main Street, you double, it develops at double density and double water need if that were to happen. If everything else stays the same. If everything else stays the same, we could have a problem.

2:03:48 Just a point of information, up here we discourage turf, we really do, because it just doesn't fit in with, you know, the mountain climate, except for small areas for pets and children to play, but great expanses of lawn, we discourage that. Has the water district considered, or is there even a reason to try and give incentives for using, you know, drip irrigation and irrigation methods that don't waste a lot for evapotranspiration?

2:04:16 Or is it just the water that runs through the meter? Or have you discouraged turf? I mean, we have the demonstration garden now, and we have a list in our water-efficient landscape ordinance of drought-tolerant, you know, attractive plants. It would be gone further. The currently proposed water-efficiency landscape ordinance really does start restricting the use of turf. You get an allocation of about 71% of what you might have been getting in the past.

2:04:46 And you can choose to use that on high intensity water use like turf, medium intensity and lower intensity like the demonstration garden, but you only get 71% of the water you got in the past. And that in effect will say to make that happen your turf space is going to be a very small percentage of your property. You're not outlawing turf, but you're making it restricted in the amount of water that is going to be available for that given piece of irrigated land.

2:05:16 And clear choices have to be made as to how they're going to use the water that is available. And pretty soon the user will figure out the most efficient use of their allocation. Right. If you look at turf, imagine putting this much water on it every year. That's what turf takes in this climate. It's an incredibly thirsty product. And imagine 200% of that or more that some people are doing.

2:05:45 So there are some communities that are very challenged with water, Las Vegas being one of them. They're having to build a fourth connector to Lake Mead because Lake Mead has dropped almost to the bottom of the third connector. They have been paying people to remove turf. I don't think that's something we need to do here. I think the pricing signals are there. We have a tiered water structure, four layers to it.

2:06:11 By the time you're getting turf, you're going to be well into the top rates and paying, and that will hopefully connect that this is a costly undertaking to be doing. It's not saying don't do it. It's saying you're going to be more prudent about how you do it. The ordinances for water conservation are under review, and with the new tools available on this interval data, we'll have interval data on every meter for every customer in the next year.

2:06:39 And that will have a customer-facing website that people can check into so they understand what they're doing. Currently, meters are read once a month. It's like you went to the gas pump five times this month and never saw a bill, never knew how much gas you were using, and then all of a sudden, at the end of the month, wham, here's your bill. There's a disconnection. Having a customer-facing website where people can get this information, as well as their way in Los Angeles.

2:07:07 Pipes freeze, all of a sudden they've got a high use going on, they'll get a notification of that. If they have an internal leak, we'll be telling them about that. These are all the kind of cues that are coming down the track in terms of how water can be better used. There's a cost to that, but the board at this point in time recognizes that it's worth it and we're proceeding with the due diligence that we need to. I don't want to be over the top with this, but

2:07:38 We have enough water. We just need to use it better than we're using it now. And if we're doing it prudently and following in lockstep with what the city's plan is, updating it every five years, you're doing the same thing, you know, we can guide this ship in a very effective way. Thank you. Thank you, Mr. Coach. Thank you. Thank you. Moving on, on our agenda to business matters, discussion proposed zoning code amendments related to

2:08:15 Signs, outdoor sales, and special events. Thank you. This item is a follow-up from the May 8th Planning Commission meeting regarding these topics. At that meeting, the commission requested that Commissioners Tenney and Vice Chair Fernie review the signs and outdoor sales and special events requirements and report back to the commission with some suggestions on changes.

2:08:45 Since that time, staff has met with Commissioner Tenney and Vice Chair Fernie on their suggestions and has included them into this report and has provided the draft or updated code to show how the changes would change the zoning code. So I can walk through each topic and we can talk about how the items were changed and then just so you know, these items would then be included in the zoning code update.

2:09:12 So they will all be part of the public review draft. Any items that you make a decision on today would be included, and they would be part of the public review draft, which will hopefully be published in the next couple months so that we can take public comments on all of the items that are as a part of the zoning code update. And as another note, we did put a hold on the special events section. The Recreation Commission is conducting a special event study. They will be coming probably

2:09:40 At your October meeting, we're going to try to schedule a joint session with the Recreation Commission and the Planning and Economic Development Commission to discuss special events and any changes that they have suggested to the code. So we'll move forward with that at that time. So if you'd like, I can walk through each item or if you want to take the items that you have questions on or however you'd like to proceed. What's the commission's, do we need to walk through it or are we... Not necessarily, but there's just a...

2:10:10 A few comments and things. What I would like Sandra to do is just review the purpose of the chapter on page 33, why we even did this, if that's the pleasure of the commission. Read it out loud? Or we can go through it or talk about it in general terms, but exactly what it is we're trying to accomplish. Okay. The purpose of the chapter is to establish regulations to control signage within the town, the number of signs, the placement of signs, the height, size, type, and lighting of the signs.

2:10:45 In order to advance our community design standards and safety standards, support the local economy and help nurture businesses, strengthen the identity of the community as a premier year-round destination resort, encourage creative design that adds to our character of our streets and districts, contributes to an attractive and hospitable streetscape, to discourage visual clutter,

2:11:13 and negative impacts to the public realm, eliminate glare, minimize light pollution to improve public safety and preserve views of the stars in the night sky, provide for signs as an effective channel of communication while ensuring that they're aesthetically compatible with the structures they identify, safeguard and protect the public health, safety and general welfare.

2:11:37 Avoid traffic safety hazards to pedestrians, bicyclists, and motorists caused by visual distractions and obstructions. Maximize public convenience by providing easily visible traffic, directional, informational, and wayfinding signage. And minimize the cost of sign permits through clear and user-friendly regulations. I just thought it was important to keep that in mind as we talk about these points.

2:12:07 All right. Who would like to start the discussion? You want to start calling? Oh, okay. You know we've been concerned about the lack of code enforcement because of the proliferating banners and just general sloppy appearance of the town, but this goes way beyond that. I was struck when I went into a local grocery store that sells healthy food last week just how nicely

2:12:37 The signage was done in that store. And what this signage conveyed, there were, you know, red signs with white letters in each aisle, and they were all put up very neatly. It conveyed, we know what we're doing, and we care, and we're here to offer you the best product that we can. It wasn't merchandise sort of, you know, piled high in a corner with cheap signs on it, that sort of thing. It really conveyed, this is special. What we have is special. You're special.

2:13:05 We respect you. We respect ourselves. It was really impressive. I just stood and stared at it and thought, how often do you see that? So that was just something that happened recently. Then when Colin and I started talking about this and what we could do to enforce the code, but even more importantly, what we could do to get the right language in the zoning code, was that business survey we did, which you'll remember we reported on, and there was a lot of

2:13:33 Concern about all the banners and how sort of cheap and shabby they made the town look, but that was just a small element. And what we've seen since then, because we have no code enforcement, is everybody's out there for themselves doing what they can, and the cumulative impression is, you know, it's not a good one. And you can say, I see my pet peeve, these vertical flags, flag banners, which are illegal under our current code. They are not permitted.

2:14:03 They have commercial advertising on them. They're not permitted. And you see those everywhere now. I mean, just, you know, Reno, Carson City, LA, San Fernando Valley, Mammoth Lakes, California, Bishop, you see them everywhere. But that doesn't mean we have to have them. Because what we're trying to do is strengthen our identity as a premier year-round destination resort. We should be special. I mean, look what we're surrounded with. Of course we should be special. And that's the reason.

2:14:31 for caring so much about this. Then the other thing that came out in the business survey results was overwhelming. Both the survey and talking to individual business owners, and Colin and I met with a number of business owners, was the enthusiasm for having a town-wide sale three times a year. They just really, really liked that idea. It wasn't 100%, but it was a very high percentage, where it would be marketed by Mammoth Lakes Tourism.

2:15:01 You could put out your sale stuff, you know, tents, the whole thing, and it would be the Mammoth Market, whereas what we have now is attention discount shoppers, you know, Blue Light Special, Mammoth is on sale all the time, you know, just come look for the cheapest thing you can find, and it's, you know, it's not what we're trying to offer to our guests and to get our guests to come back. They can go to any strip mall in any big city and get the same bargains, and we're special, and we should be treating

2:15:31 Treating this place just like that grocery store. You know, we care about this and we respect you and respect yourselves. So anyway, that idea of a mammoth market three weekends a season and then there was a request by one business owner in particular for an additional individual sale as well as the three town-wide sales. But the beauty of that is you don't have to have

2:15:58 These Excel spreadsheets of record-keeping for how many days a year so-and-so had a sale banner up, yadda-dy, yadda-dy. It's a record-keeping nightmare. And because we are so limited on staff, it's out of the question. And so what we end up with is what we've had this summer. Not a pretty sight, you know? Just not special at all. So that's my current soapbox. Colin, why don't you put another soapbox on top?

2:16:27 Colin and I are consumed with this. Well, I don't want to get into the minute details because, you know, that's in our report and if there's any questions about them, but just kind of the overarching strategy here. I thought with this was not to come down with an iron fist and take away all avenues of advertising for businesses. However, I think we have to be selective about which ones are effective and which ones...

2:16:59 You know, go through and I appreciate that you brought that up, Elizabeth, you know, the purpose of this chapter. And I think that what we have going on right now is not achieving a lot of those ends. So, you know, the first thing that we tried to do is in certain instances we are trying to restrict things that are in the current code, but at the same time we're also trying to have that be a give and take where

2:17:28 If we are taking certain things away, we're allowing other things. So I think that's important to note. The other thing is, you know, Mammoth existed prior to the proliferation of floppy, tacky banners, and the intent behind that change in the sign code was to be more business friendly and help the businesses in a way that they thought they needed. And I would argue that I don't think it's...

2:17:58 Achieve that. I don't think that it's promoted our business environment. Now, I mean, that did coincide with a tough economic downturn, but I don't think that having tacky sale banners all up and down our commercial districts has enhanced our business environment here. I think it's detracted from it. So as we look at a couple of things, I think the outdoor sales idea, the open market, which was not

2:18:26 Our idea is a fantastic one, I think. I'm sick of this Mammoth perpetually on sale in discorded and individual type manner. So if we can put all those businesses together and say, hey, this is a weekend, we're having an outdoor market, any business in town can participate, very low regulations for that, and it can become a festive environment for our guests.

2:18:56 What we've got going on right now with these individual businesses doing it every other weekend does not promote that type of environment. So I feel very strongly about moving in that direction. The major change we made around the signage is just no more sale banners. And I don't believe that they're necessary or that they enhance the look of our community. And the last thing I'm going to say, and this is really kind of a cart before the horse type,

2:19:26 Scenario, but we can put in this code, but until some code enforcement is a priority, nothing's going to change. The environment we have right now is a free-for-all, and businesses, as we talked about before,

2:19:44 And what are we going to do about that? We've had four people volunteer to help with it.

2:20:12 I mean, go out and photograph examples and, you know, keep a log, but we're not getting any support. As I said earlier, I'm just really concerned about compliance is the underpinning of everything we're doing, and it's not happening, and I'm very distressed by that. I had a business owner that sent me an email the other day that said, you know, what's going on with all the fluttering banners at this particular business? I thought, you know.

2:20:40 This is what you guys were trying to restrict. And I had to explain that all we can really do is institute the policy, but that as far as enforcing the actual action, that's really beyond our purvey. So, you know, I think people may not understand that, but I think that's the reality of the situation is until we invest in some code enforcement, which I strongly support, it's not going to change.

2:21:04 So I think it's good to have the code and have that discussion and have everybody feel comfortable with that and have that precede it. But I think, you know, code enforcement is the next piece. Sure. Yeah, a couple of things. Hold on, I can barely see you down here. It's okay. I'm used to it. I couldn't see when I was sitting there either. There was no peripheral. A couple of things I noticed in reading through here. I think that...

2:21:34 You know, if we're going to restrict the, you know, restrict the use of vinyl to a couple of places, which isn't overall, if we have an outdoor street banner, it has to be vinyl, okay, and so, and, you know, and that's kind of what it gets down to, or whatever it is, or if it's to something that is a sale or a promotional discount, I think you,

2:22:03 Which I have no problem with at all. I think then it allows for some clarification of what format is acceptable for an activity. It's not necessarily an event, but it's an activity. Now, it may have a revenue component associated with it, but how do you get across that there's live music at this particular venue? Or is, you know...

2:22:27 That this is a kid's night or something there out there. And I don't think that that's fully developed yet in this because I can see a lot what it isn't. But if somebody did have that opportunity that was, is it in vinyl? Is it permanent? Can it be added on? I don't think we've addressed that yet because I think that's where a lot of it we're going to much more of.

2:22:50 As we develop more visitor services, make sure that we have an opportunity to get visitor services out there. So it's not really defined here. So I would just look for how that would evolve. And that's something that I think when I volunteer to work with Elizabeth, that's what I'm talking about, are things, and we have not gotten to do this yet, but keep in mind, how do we educate that there's more to do?

2:23:18 And, you know, I appreciate that, you know, Sundance is able to merchandise that way. I want to make sure people know Sundance is there. And if you aren't looking towards the back, how do they know that that business is there? Also, one thing I found through the changes and corrections, I think we need some clarification on the term property versus business. Because a property can have multi-businesses and not necessarily in the same building.

2:23:47 And there's some restrictions there that says only one X per property, but what if it has multiple businesses on that particular property? And I know that, so it's not really clear and it's not consistent. There are some places, well it's pretty much throughout the document, but I was thinking when you got down to about page 52 or 3, no attachment 3, it suddenly became more defined.

2:24:16 which allowed me to look back and go, I don't think it's very defined. So it doesn't matter which one it is, but understanding what's the intent. So if you have multi-businesses like

2:24:31 It really would say that if the property here is this corner, Carl's Jr. is the only one that can have a neon sign because it's one neon sign per property. Are we considering that or do you really mean business in there? And just if we're going to be, don't want to restrict it in areas that you didn't intend but recognize that there might be some other options there. And, you know, so overall I haven't

2:24:59 I think it's absolutely in the right direction. It's just kind of looking beyond things as property versus business or is it clear what you're really talking about as you get into there. So I didn't have any issues with any of the changes. I mean, you know, a sales sign is, it's kind of like, oh, but I'd be more in favor of activities and it's not particularly a large organized special event, but if one particular business has, you know, has a fashion show.

2:25:28 How do they get to say that they have a fashion show that night that's free to the public as an activity? How is that defined? Is it okay in vinyl? Do you need something permanent? Oh, but it changes the structure. And I think that we're going to go to more of those things that give animation to the resort. Let's make sure that we have...

2:25:47 Cleared it enough to allow it so we don't have to come back every time and say, oh, you can't have a banner because it's there, but it's not advertising a sale. Oh, well, we didn't cover that. So I think that's kind of the area that if you put to bed, you know, this restrict the sale, the full-on promotional retail event, that will allow us more opportunity to look for how can we creatively market.

2:26:14 I think that we have an opportunity to be more creative and maybe some of those things become part of permanent science instead of, you know, that we're doing this here.

2:26:42 That, you know, every Thursday night is the kids' night at the movie theater or something there. Do you have to, and just finding other areas and how to promote that stuff. And that's where looking forward, not so regulatory, I think you've just defined regulations fine. Now let's make sure that we do allow for other things that come along there. And Tom...

2:27:07 Well, that's what we have to define it. Doesn't Chevron give you those banners for free? Or do you have to pay for those? As an example. As an example, yes. Is most of that provided free? They were free. And just as a point on those banners, those stand-up fluttery ones. Elizabeth called me a while ago. They'd been up for a few months. And she said, would you please take those down? And I said, yes. Provide me something.

2:27:35 What's that? And if I were a business, I'd say, so what you, can you provide me what parameters to do to be just as effective as if something that comes in? I said, yes, Elizabeth. So I took them down. Four or five days later, our Chevron rep, which is the district, and I have to operate under corporate order for Chevron and Hertz. It's very foreign to me. So my corporate guy comes up from Chevron and he goes, hey, where are your banners?

2:28:04 We signed a contract when they did the Vons deal. We got a $750 rebate. We got the POP for stickers and things that's in the store. We got these two banners. And we were required to participate in the program for a minimum of one year. So we could opt out after that, but we had to be in it for a minimum of one year. And he said, those have to go back up.

2:28:33 After you had asked me, I took them down, I did wash them, but I, you know, about a week afterwards, I put them back up. So, it's a unique thing, and he didn't look at me and say, well, there's some down on the corner, but if I would have said no, you know, he probably would have, and then I would have been stuck between a rock and a hard place, but, you know, that makes it a unique thing. So, to add to your discussion, national chain type of

2:29:01 You know, Vons, Carl's Jr., Chevron, Shell. I mean, we could, you know, I don't know how the parameters are different for those guys, but they might be. Right. And I think that's the whole point, is don't assume all flag is the same, okay? Some people purchase those, you know, because they know that there's a lot of things that are provided and contractually that you have to do for certain businesses.

2:29:26 And then you can ride the tails on them. If they have one, I can have one. They're not the same. So I think that, and, you know, we can dictate anything we want if we're going to help everyone pay for it. That hasn't come up yet. Some communities absolutely do that. You know, Aspen and Vail and Breckenridge does that. They provide those things for them. Just clarify that, because that's exactly the point I was going to make. We're going to say, no, we don't do that here.

2:29:53 You don't just say you don't do that here, you provide an alternative, and they're looking to their community to help them financially to do that. So, that's not what I'm advocating, but what I'm saying is... An alternative for a cheap free banner? Exactly, okay, because...

2:30:11 That is something they don't have to pay for, okay, is their marketing there. So that's how that part of it works. Now, that doesn't mean that we're restricted and our hands are completely tied. That means that we can move forward and say, here's some options, you know, and we can help the community approach their contractual things and say, those aren't allowed in my community, what else do you have? That is tasteful. And if they don't,

2:30:37 Then we, you know, then that's something that is legitimate. We have to figure out what to do. You know what? You just hit the nail on the head, I think, Rhonda. If the community saw those banners go up at Chevron and there were none anywhere else and everyone abided, I would get so much pressure from fellow business people, from the board, the town sends me a letter that says, look, we don't care about your national affiliation. This looks junky. Take it down. And if you don't take it down, we're not going to buy gas from you.

2:31:08 I mean, that's where you want it to get to. Exactly. Because there's, at that point, there's self-imposed regulation, which right now, you know. That you're able to take to your company and say, so this is it. And they want to support you, but this is, what else can we do? That's right. And I would be able to look at my Chevron district manager and say that, whereas now, it's pretty hard for me. You know, I looked at them and went, okay.

2:31:38 Yeah, exactly. Well, I think that's an extremely valid point, and I mean, the way to summarize that is we don't have a level playing field currently. Right, and that's absolutely the truth, and that's a very valid point, and I think that that's what gets back to the code enforcement, that, you know, you take McDonald's, for example,

2:32:01 They can't necessarily build their building and color it the same way as they might in LA because we have regulations and design guidelines in Mammoth. So it's a very valid point right now that you couldn't look your rep in the face and say, well, I can't put it up because it's against community restrictions. They'd say, well, I see 50 of them right now. So I think just to address a couple of your points, Rhonda, which I thought were fantastic,

2:32:27 You're right that there's probably not a lot in there that focuses on business versus property. So I think that's something that definitely needs to be addressed. I mean, the property that you represent is a prime example. There's a bunch of different businesses. I was actually thinking of another one, but yeah. Sure. That's a prime example. There's a bunch of different businesses that represent the same space. So is it business versus property? I think there's some clarification there. You know, the one thing I would like to point out through all this is there's nothing

2:32:55 That says that people can't have permanent signs. So if you take John's Pizza Works for an example, they've done a really great job with some of their permanent signs that hang under their marquee sign that say, what is a continued offering there? They've got an arcade, they've got pizza, etc. But then it gets into what you were discussing before is really what we're looking at is vinyl here.

2:33:22 Call it what it is. Sure. So the only thing I would like to bring up on that, because I think it is a valid point, is something that we have to think about that has continued to be an issue in looking through this process is we are not allowed to legally dictate what goes on a sign. So if we can say you can have a vinyl sign that says kids night, but you can't have a vinyl sign that says 25% off sale.

2:33:52 We are not allowed to do that. Exactly. So that is what has become so difficult through this process is I don't think anybody wants to see 70% off sale banner here, there, and everywhere throughout town, but that's where we get stuck between this rock and a hard place. Exactly. Is if you want to have a vinyl sign that promotes Cinco de Mayo, I don't have an issue with that really. You know, if you want to put that up for that weekend, any reasonable person is not going to leave a Cinco de Mayo sign up for a year.

2:34:21 But we are not allowed to dictate what goes on a sign. So that's really what the major struggle with this process has been. Just as an aside or to follow up on that point, the current code does allow community event signs. So in a community event sign is any sign identifying or communicating information about any type of race, parade, show, competition, special or temporary event, or community activity to which the general public is invited.

2:34:51 Permitted right now. And people use that, right, the signs that you see out on Old Mammoth and Main Street inviting you to go to the Kids Fishing Festival, those kinds of things. Those are allowed right now. And I saw that, and I was just wondering, is, does it, because I kind of took that to be that it had to be, you could argue that it was, you know, well, if it's one particular business, it's not for the community. Now, and if we think that that description is allowing it,

2:35:20 I'm fine with that. Because what I wouldn't want is that you're allowing a sign for, you know, the fireman's picnic or your headquarters for the fireman's picnic on a particular business and then somebody came back and challenged on, I don't know who they'd challenge, but that's a whole other argument, is that how can they have this temporary sign up and you're not letting me to do this? So that's kind of the clarification I'm looking for as it comes down to it. And then my last comment was, you know, I appreciate the volunteer

2:35:49 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:36:11 And there's no way to do anything about it. And that's not what we're asking the volunteers in the community to do, is to do something about it, because they can't. And that's, you know, if they don't, if council doesn't believe that this is a priority, I'd have to look back and say, how many things are coming out of this that can be linked back to not having a code enforcement that have become

2:36:39 Problems in, you know, are coming, problems in providing animosity in the community. And as we're looking to rebuild the community and rebuild the image, if you don't think this is part of it, then I have to question your priorities. And it just keeps building and building and building. And there's no end in sight, though there's a lot of desire inside. And that's, if we were, if this is something that nobody wanted, that'd be different.

2:37:04 I think that's a very valid point, that we just need to make sure that that is fully vetted, that idea of really looking into the vinyl signs and banners and sales signs. If that's what it is, let's come up with an alternative. Sure, and that's fine. And just as a counterexample, we addressed the pop-up signs throughout this process, and we came to that same sticking point, is how can we do this?

2:37:34 There was a very, what I thought, creative and good suggestion to, okay, maybe we regulate this sign in the commercial districts so that it allows the real estate community, which needs those signs to direct to open houses to have what they want, at the same time that it doesn't allow this proliferation of pop-up signs throughout our commercial districts. So that's an example of a way to maybe think about, you know,

2:38:00 Looking at this, I'm not sure that it's applicable in this exact example, but there should be some way to get that desired effect. Because by the, you know, I didn't appreciate all the work on it, but at the rate it's going in dealing with this, we're going to have to have a section on holograms in there because it's going to, this is going to be obsolete talking about vinyl, it's going to be projected. So, Commissioner Hurray. Okay, a couple of things and I'll keep it short.

2:38:28 We've worked with our sign ordinance four times in the past that I can recall, which we've had major, major discussion and countless hours and people's input and hard work. I think we need to, this is a wonderful ordinance. It needs some tweaking here and there. Rhonda had pointed out very succinctly that

2:38:56 You know, it needs to stay a very fluid ordinance. New technology is going to drive a lot of what signage is going to be, how people advertise, how they reach out for their customers. National companies, yeah, Tom, thanks for being here. I wish the place was full. This is, yeah. This is really, it's really discouraging for it.

2:39:25 For the Commission, because this is important. It's very, very important. But, as everyone has stated, it's all enforcement. If we don't have enforcement, and for whatever reason, council has decided this was not a priority. It should be a priority. I think you have five people up here that believe it should be a priority.

2:39:55 I don't want to get that across. Well, we've got Ted in the background there. Ted, I really implore you to write something up on this. We want to be heard. We want our constituency out there to hear us and to participate in continued workshops and, you know, give the commission ideas. I mean, you're out there on the front line.

2:40:23 Tom and others, you know, you know what's coming down the pike as far as new technology goes. Certainly Wanda does in her business and, you know, it's participate in these workshops and continue to do that. Our ordinance, the bones of the ordinance, great, fine, I'm there. There's no issues. But it's a fluid ordinance. It will continue to change as time goes on.

2:40:53 We do need the enforcement support, and until we get it, it's going to be very difficult to enforce what we have on our ordinance.

2:41:10 Yes. Oh, I'm sorry. I think our one other person who's not sitting at the table. No, no, you've got plenty of. No, just real quick, you know. I've been talking all of you. Can you just get Steve up? I know. He slams the press, you know, geez. Where was I going? You know, Steve, or Dave, with regards to the code enforcement, you know, look, we know that's an issue.

2:41:38 And you guys are working hard to get this into place. And I look forward to it because I want to do a new sign for P3. But part of this is just like with the Shiloh-In thing earlier. Good point. Someone comes to you with a request for a variance or a special event or someone goes to measure R or someone goes to measure U looking for money that's in violation. You know, that's your first line of code enforcement at this point to where you say, not entertaining.

2:42:08 You are violating what's going on. I would venture to guess my competitor across the street from me was probably in compliance more with everything prior to this summer than any other business in town, including mine. You know, I mean, he has a good facade, a great sign, a great business, and look what, you know what, collectively, look what we've driven him to.

2:42:33 Right? And I'll let him speak to it. And he and I are friendly competitors, but out of respect, there's no question that he was, if not the most compliant, certainly one of the most compliant. And I got a pig across the street that I try to put lipstick on as much as I can. And as soon as this gets into place, I'll remedy the hurt sign and I'll remedy how we're going to do it, but I just don't know.

2:43:03 I don't know how, you know. I don't know what material to pick yet. What's that? You don't know what material to pick? I don't know what material to pick. I think Steve will tell you he hates his sign as much as anyone, so. I can't stand by the numbers. I'm sorry, but you do need to stay. Okay, my name is Steve Klassen. I'm the owner of Wave Rave. It will be our 24th season at Wave Rave here this next year.

2:43:28 We are also opening an outlet store in Bishop. We're building out the old Meadow Farms Liquor Building to be an outlet store down there. I feel like I've been in compliance with the sign ordinance and the tent ordinance, the sale ordinance, for 23 years. This year, I came to speak to Sandra right at the end of July after noticing that one of my competitors had a tent up.

2:43:58 It seemed since the 4th of July weekend and did not come down a tent sale. And I told her simply, I said, I can't do this anymore. I am putting my tent up and I'm not taking it down until things start being enforced around here. And she said, I'm sorry, there's no way we can't enforce it because there is nobody to enforce it. And, you know, that's simply what it's come to, is that for us to be competitive now, we have to have an outdoor tent.

2:44:27 We have to have multiple banners outside. And I guess what it is, it's an act of civil disobedience to get our government to actually perform. You know, I will say that it has made a difference of approximately 25% in sales for the last 15 days to have that tent out there. So to have an outdoor sale, I can see an increase of 25%. You know, I understand there's certain ways around this.

2:44:58 Such as having multiple business names in one building. Now, I know that there was once five businesses operating on my property that I own. So I guess that means I could go get a permit for five different businesses and have 15 summer sales. I don't think that's appropriate. I think that the model that Elizabeth said of having three sales a summer is the right way to do it. I do not think there should be an extra sale for anybody.

2:45:27 I think three sales a summer, you give us the days to do it and that's the days we go outside and that's the days we do it. I think that's the right way. I also think that at this point with banners and the possibility of projecting images on the side of your building, I think that that just needs to be squelched and stopped and not be allowed anymore because it seems like we have people in this community that are disingenuous with their intentions and they will

2:45:56 Take it to whatever extent needs to be. I mean, if this, the banner thing is not solved by the time, let's say, December 1st rolls around, it's very probable that I'll have approximately 30 banners on the side of my building with different vendors, and I would reckon to guess that that's going to make a difference of approximately 20% in my sales during the month of December, which is hundreds of thousands of dollars. Okay, we're trying to get out of here by five. Okay.

2:46:31 So, if there's no enforcement, it's just going to keep going like this. And I would say, I would like to see it going back to me not having to do what I'm doing. I mean, I'm going and opening this business in Bishop as a closeout store, as an outlet, and if it doesn't change by next summer,

2:46:56 I'm going to rent multiple spots in town and have multiple outdoor sales going all summer. I do not want to have to do that, but the way that it's going, that's the business model that has become the business model that will succeed in this town. With no enforcement officer, the sale, mega sale, super sale, snowboard sale business model is what is the most successful business model. Because in tents,

2:47:26 People expect there to be sales. So please do whatever you can do to no longer have that happen. Thank you very much. So we do need to wrap this up because we have a couple other items. I just would like to make just a couple points. I think as far as enforcement goes, we should have maximum fines allowable on these things. If it becomes a profit center then, you know, we've talked about this. I really want to, Sandra,

2:47:54 Do this anyways is see if in our zoning code update we can legally write some sort of paragraph that says that if you're in noncompliance that no other variance, conditional use, permit, whatever. I mean, I know there's other towns that do that. I think it's a great idea to see if legally they can be denied measure our money, measure you money. So I think there's a lot more that we can do than just as far as a compliance officer and we should really look at it across the board. I'm also going to say that since

2:48:23 Since it means hundreds of thousands of dollars during the month of December to have brands on the outside of the building, it needs to be at least a $5,000 a day penalty, because at a $1,000 a day penalty, it makes sense to continue doing it. Okay. Okay. Thank you very much for that. All right. I think you just found your marketing fund, right? All right. I was going to say, just to kind of wrap it up for me, I heard that we need...

2:48:52 So either like a definition or more information on what a business is versus a property. Correct. So I can go back and do that. And then something more with the banners. Does the commission want Vice Chair Ferney and Commissioner Tenney to continue to work on this and come back to you? Or are we satisfied with what we've proposed today? Well, I would perhaps the two of you can get together with Commissioner Dugan.

2:49:17 And just wrap that. They can't. Yeah. Oh, that's right. I'm sorry. So I can't talk to Commissioner Dugan about creative ways to. And then not then talk to Vice Chair. You can talk to the tube. You can talk to us now. You can't. Oh, then we would just present it to the commission but not go back and say change it to this. That's not what we're talking about. So I'm just trying to wrap it up so we can get it into the zoning code update. But there is a hole I didn't think about and that's what Ron was talking about, this idea of special activities, maybe not an event but activities.

2:49:47 And if that's going to be a Sing of the Mayo banner, if it's going to be a Live News Tonight banner, if it's going to be, you know, what have we accomplished? We're trying, the way we thought because of the free speech requirement, the only way we could get rid of all these banners is to allow a banner for grand opening or for special events. All right. But all the other banners. Okay. So I see that as a whole still. But isn't your question, yeah, I think that holds there, but isn't your question on what the work that we've done today, is that accepted?

2:50:15 Is that what your, that's your question is, I would say, I would, you know, move that yes, it is accepted. Right. And going further is that we, to read it, that we define where necessary the difference between a property and a business as opposed to some regulations. It wasn't every place it was necessary, but I did see some places that there was a cause of confusion. Do I need to?

2:50:41 Point a couple of those out to the subcommittee. No, I would give it to you. How's that? Perfect. There was a couple of them that I'd highlighted and just said I was a little confused in this situation. And if you don't have an answer to that right now, that's fine too. And then staff can continue. I guess we can work to propose some provision to allow a special event banner for private special events like a dance or something at a business. Right.

2:51:07 That's out of business as opposed to a community center. I think you have that very well covered. But now, you know, they may get more creative with their sites and events. And if it looks like we have it covered, I have no problem. I just didn't want anybody that you're denying something to come back and say, well, why did you approve this when you're denying me? Great point. So would the commission be comfortable with that?

2:51:31 allowing private special event banners to be drafted and determined by Commissioner Tenney, Vice Chair Ferney, and not coming back to you separately before the public review draft of the zoning code update? Or do you want to talk about this? But I thought Commissioner Tenney and Commissioner Dugan were going to do that part. But alternatives to special activity banners. I think it... I'm just wondering... Yes, and we would be comfortable with them drafting it. They don't have to come back to commission. Separately from the public review. We will have other opportunities to discuss this, but just not a whole separate meeting. Because this is...

2:52:00 It's actually more, we'll take, if you want to separate it for, this is more of an economic development project. Exactly. And it is, and it may or may not affect the zoning code. Having a fresh look at it can't hurt. Oh, exactly. So, yeah. Thank you. Thank you very much for your efforts. And thank you for doing this, Sandra. It's perfect. It really was helpful. Sandra, the issue of maximum fines,

2:52:27 I would suggest that because as Steve and Tom

2:52:55 Said, you know, $1,000 a day is nothing if you're making $100,000 a month. And it costs the business. And just one of the last points on this is we don't know if this promotional activity has added to the bottom line or do we have more visitors. There's a lot of businesses that have seen a summer like no other. If you haven't, you might want to ask what you're doing, you know, what you're not, what you're doing different.

2:53:23 Is it because of the promotional? Is it because we have more people here? And are we able to reach those? We can't answer those questions. Right now, we have to assume, you would rightly assume it's your promotional activity. But are we capturing that guest for everything that's available, not only retail, but activities and things there down the line? So maybe only TOT will show that that is.

2:53:50 There, but I just think that this is probably part of our developing economic strategy is how do we keep businesses vibrant and attractive here as well. Unfortunately, we really need to close this conversation. Thank you. Moving on to the consent agenda. Pamela, do you have one comment to make about the consent agenda?

2:54:24 Do I have a motion to approve the consent agenda? I move we approve the consent agenda. Second. Very quickly, underneath just commissioner reports, Sandra and I had talked briefly about our meetings, and one thing, Sandra, I want to go back. If after we've had our pre-meeting with the chair and the vice chair,

2:54:54 I just want you to know I am really fundamentally opposed to coming to the meeting and saying basically the applicant has changed their stance or their opinion on something. I'm not quite sure when this happened today with AT&T. Today. Today. So, I mean, I don't know how the rest of the commission feels about this, but I think if somebody wants to come and change it, then it has to be continued because it puts us in a very awkward situation after we've submitted the package.

2:55:24 Than to hear it today. That's the Commission's prerogative. I think if you don't feel prepared to make a decision, you can continue it. And I think the Commission has had a discussion about that in the past. Before I was here, there were huge projects that were coming forward and changing things right at the meeting, and there was a Planning Commission policy that said...

2:55:45 You know, we weren't going to do that. We weren't going to approve things right at the meeting. We were going to take some time to think about it. I can pull that policy, send it to you, and, you know, we can use that in the future. I agree it wasn't... Yeah, well, in essence, we did continue it, didn't we? We did, exactly. Because, you know, and so... That was... It's a different thing to come to a different direction and conclusion during the debate and send it back, but that one should have...

2:56:15 That one should have been pulled. Because we didn't have the right stuff. You just can put the applicants on notice that this commission really doesn't like that. I don't think it happens that often, but I agree it's not right when it doesn't. And then the other thing I wanted to mention to my fellow commissioners is that in some states they actually formally require continuing education for commissioners, and California certainly doesn't have that requirement.

2:56:42 But I think education is hugely important. I think the scope of some of the things that we're going to see before us in the future is going to be very different. So we have an opportunity now to attend a CEQA class. Did everybody see that email? I'm signed up. Okay, so I think that's a great thing. I want to get a little disappointed that they're doing the advance before the...

2:57:05 It's kind of odd. The town will pay for you to attend that, so you can attend whichever portions that you want. Basically, there's an advanced CEQA workshop, a NEPA workshop, which is the National Environmental Policy Act, and a CEQA basics and refresher, so you can attend however you like. The cost is the same. And then, Sandra also found a great reference for an online site for us.

2:57:32 And so if anybody has any interest in that, if you would let her know, my thought was maybe we'd ask the town to pay for the actual membership, and then if we actually individually wanted to order books or materials, we could just, my thought was just order it on ourselves. It's basically a membership to the APA website, so you can use all of their, get all their articles, download things. If there's a topic coming up, you can see the history on, read that, read up on that, so. I very much miss that journal.

2:57:59 I know. You can get it as a website. That was one of the first expenses they cut. The historical versions of that job, too, which is really helpful. It does. That's a good organization. And then in the future, commission reports will allow enough time for this. I was going to ask that every standing committee and the ad hoc committees actually give a report. So, for example, we had an issue where there was something that was done, a design review that I wasn't particularly aware of.

2:58:25 And it was just kind of weird how it came through the back door. So if you could just kind of quickly say we did this design review or, you know, we'll try to give you some zoning code updates, it would be a good thing. Okay. So is there anything else the commissioner has a report? Well, I could say. You've got 25 seconds. Okay, since I didn't have time to say it before, the business owners we talked to about this.

2:58:47 The only thing I have is I've also been sitting on the Mammoth Lakes Recreation Steering Committee over the past month. So that's been an interesting process with, you know, 35 recreation stakeholders throughout the community.

2:59:13 We have our final meeting Monday the 19th and at that point a recommendation will be made to Council on what the Steering Committee has come up with. I will just mention very briefly, ORMAT has received the blessing of BLM and the Forest Service. They sent out that notice today for the Basalt Canyon drilling project.

2:59:41 Will ultimately involve 16, up to 16, production wells, injection wells, and monitoring wells in the area. And quite frankly, I'm very happy to see that going forward. This means jobs for Mammoth. It means an expanded industry for Mammoth other than tourism.

3:00:12 This will help families keep the possibility of keeping children here within the area other than just the hospitality business or the ski area business. So I'll keep you posted on these things as we go forward.

3:00:36 And now, for the director report. Ten seconds. The only thing is just that we're going to be trying to work to schedule a joint recreation commission meeting with you, hopefully on the same date of your October meeting, which is October 9th. Okay, annual. Our next meeting is? September 11th. I will not be in attendance. I'm in Crested Butte for our annual retreat, so I will miss that meeting. Yes. Okay.

3:01:01 What's the status of Winter & Associates coming back? They were going to come back in September, I thought, with a draft plan and then adoption in December. Where does that stand? They provided us with a draft plan a couple of weeks ago. We provided comments to them on the draft plan. So once they've incorporated those comments, we'll schedule a time. It probably will be our October meeting. Okay, and it'll be a public workshop? I would assume so, yes. Okay, so that draft plan dated August 3rd is what you're referring to? The most recent, yeah. Okay, thank you.

3:01:33 to our next regular scheduled meeting September the 11th. Thank you everybody.