TransparentMammoth

Trails Committee · 2013

Trails Committee

· recording 3 hr 7 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

396 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

7:34 It started on that approach into Yosemite Valley from the 120 side. Big Meadow Fire. Big Meadow Fire. The prescribed burn that got out of control. And I remember, you know, I was in high school back in the 80s or whenever it was, that the first time that burned through. And, you know, so that was 25 years ago or 30 years ago. And it was just amazing how, you know, I was pleased to see the progress because I remember when that fire happened. And then, boom, the exact same path almost.

8:00 And then it was something like a year later, a year and a half later, that they found a trunk that was still burning from that fire. So it took a year and a half, and it was still smoldering, even after a winter. They go underground. Trees burn. They do, literally. The roots continue to smolder without oxygen. They don't just burn up. I had a green and then it went away. Yes, of course. Is there a way that it's burning?

8:31 Well, I don't know, but I will tell you that the

9:01 The weekend before, I traveled to you from the Bay Area over Sonora Pass, and it really doesn't impact time with much. It's what? It's smoky. It's certainly smoky, but if people were still intending of getting here, it's about to get up. Or I'd even argue that it's faster. Yeah.

9:29 You know, yeah, it's just as fast. Or you can go up through Murphy's. One thing, it should help. Okay, are we on? All right, then let's call this meeting to order. And it was actually, the entire committee was on time. Early. At 1.30. It was a technical instance that's making us start our meeting at 1.40. So let's call this meeting to order. First things, let's do roll call.

9:59 Stu Brown. Here. Sandy Hogan. Here. Bill Souser. Here. Vice Chairman Bill Taylor. Here. And Chairman Sean Turner. I'm present. Public comments. Are there any comments from the public that we may entertain? Good afternoon. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. A couple things coming up. First, this week, MLTPA, Mammoth Medical Missions, Mammoth Burrowing and Community Skis are bringing the Mountain Film Festival to the town of Mammoth Lakes. Probably Friday and Saturday night.

10:31 This is like the BAMF Film Festival, but better, I didn't say that, somebody else did. So I would encourage everybody to come down, right after a very, very busy summer, it's a great opportunity to reflect on Mammoth Lakes as a mountain community, our connection to the mountains, our connection to all recreational opportunities, all the rest would like to be pretty exciting. John, for the record, when's that the location and the time? Sure. That will be September 13th and 14th at 7 p.m. at the Mammoth Lakes Arts Center, 549 Old Mammoth Road.

10:58 We'll have banners up on the sign on either side so if you'll be able to see it, you'll know exactly where it is. And it's going to be $12 per night or $20 for both nights. And we will be, community skis, we'll be giving away a free pair of community skis both nights. You can drink delicious Mammoth Brewing Company beer. There will be a charge for it, but the Mammoth Brewing Company is very graciously helping out with that. But all the profits are going to the event? Yeah, all the profits go to cover the cost of the event.

11:26 If there's anything left over, MLTPA and the Mammoth Medical Mission, let's put it. We hope we'll get there, but if not, the community will have a great chance to see some great movies. Any other questions on that? And there's information on MLTPA's website. We've got some trailers up there. You can see more about the festival. You can go to mountainfilm.org and find out all you need to know. It's a really great, wonderful festival. The second thing is with Friends of Inyo. We're doing the final summer stewardship event, which will come up September 21st.

11:55 Lakes Basin Cleanup, this is done in conjunction with something called the Great Sierra River Cleanup, which is a program that the Sierra Nevada Conservancy does, statewide river, beaches, water cleanup, and there's a lot to clean up. And that's going to be September 21st, 8.30 in the morning. I would let everybody know we've got a lot of accumulated swag over the summer, a lot of great things to give away, to wrap things up.

12:22 But the Lakes Basin as always could use a great cleanup this time of year. So I think Laura's got something to add to this. Thank you. Thank you. And I do want to encourage everyone to come out for the last Summer Stewardship Trails Day. I wanted to mention this last month, but I just wanted to point out on our flyer, Friends of the Inyo received an additional sponsorship from Southern California Edison this year to help support.

12:52 The Summer of Stewardship Programs, both the Trails Days and the Lakes Basin Stewards, and so we've added their logo to this flyer. So if anyone wants to take a closer look, I just wanted to point that out. And then I also wanted to, I know that later on in the agenda you will be reviewing and approving a proposal for reimbursement of funds to MLTPA for the temporary signage.

13:20 Project that we executed earlier this summer. Friends of the Inyo, as you know, we executed the creation of the signs and some other things, and I wanted to talk about the process of that a little bit. I'm happy to comment on when we get to that agenda item, but I wanted to mention it here in case things get busy.

13:44 Thanks very much. Thank you. Oh, sorry. I'm Laura Beardley. I'm the Executive Director of Friends of the Inyo. Thank you. No more comments from the public then? Steve, do you want to explain the presentations that you've got there before the consent agenda? Yes. You'll notice in your back that I've got a bullet item called the MLTSCC meeting handout list, and there are a number of items there that have been either requested...

14:18 By the committee or our materials presented to the committee as following. So instead of having each one of these as an agenda item, I've got a included presentation packet and we can go through these very quickly. And again, they are basically four-year records and as requested by the committee. So the first one is a master challenge cost share agreement.

14:44 For the Mammoth Lakes Trails Implementation Project. So that's the cost share agreement with the Forest Service of the Town Mammoth Lakes. And in your copy, or your packet, are copies two-sided, two pages per page to save space. And you'll notice that the signature blocks in the back are fully executed. And so that is the master agreement for the trail system implementation project. Any questions on that?

15:14 The second, then, is the Challenge Cost Share Supplement Agreement, and that is for the trail system, and in particular, the Sherwins Trail Additional Planning and Decision Making. Again, printed two-sided, two pages per page, and it is the final signed document, and that is what we were working under for the sharks project.

15:38 Third one, excuse me, any questions on it? This goes back to some of the questions I'd asked earlier about scope. And in this particular document, the only actual narrative related to scope is the last sentence of paragraph one on page one, which says the project is focused on requisite planning efforts, NEPA, CEQA, to approve and construct new trails on national forest lands in the areas known as the Sherwins.

16:08 If you go to the Sarbanes Grant, it has a much more detailed description of what the project is. And going forward, I'd just like to make sure, I mean this, as a project, I mean this isn't really our job to administer these contracts, it's the staff's job, but it would be very hard for me to look at the scope in this particular document and know whether we'd in fact, I mean if somebody from the public walked in and said,

16:37 What did you do for this and how do you know that you've met the contract? It would be very hard to know that from this document. So going forward, let's just make sure that we have as much of a reasonable scope so that somebody can know we're buying time, we're buying miles of trail, we're buying X or Y expertise, whatever it is. And that's all. How would you like to keep track of that or at least put it into the record or put it into, I mean, I know it's already in the record, but...

17:06 Into our packet? Well, I think it's just a reminder for all of us going forward that when we review and approve project proposals that we actually know what it is we're reviewing and approving. Do you want a copy of the Sarbanes? It's the next item. Okay. And I think to Bill's point, when staff is working and reviewing these documents with the Forest Service, we can make sure that the scope is much more explicit or more explicit.

17:31 To try and take care of those concerns. And quite frankly, as you report out on what's been done, just describing in more detail so that everybody knows what the town's money was actually spent on. And I know that this is a project that we wanted. We have good partners at the Forest Service. So things are kind of going along fine right now, but if all of us suddenly evaporated,

17:58 I don't think anybody could pick this up and know what had been done or what was needed. But it does reference the shark, and I mean, that's a huge reference. Well, I think that's why. But it only, it references it once, but it doesn't really say, this is what we're doing, and, you know, it's a very, it's very vague. And, you know, as you know from contract administration. The final outcome was a list of recommended trail additions, improvements, and management strategies for that area, and then the fact that they were recommended.

18:26 And proposed for NEPA and CEQA. So, you know, I mean, that's what NEPA and CEQA are about. I mean, the whole purpose of this one is NEPA and CEQA. Right. And it also, I mean. And Sarbanes is really, Sarbanes is a special grant for a special area. Yeah. There's a lot of references, for instance. It says, the town of Mammoth Lakes shall present to the U.S. Forest Service a prioritized list of projects proposed to be added to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System and identify the level of development in any facilities associated with each project.

18:56 We don't have that list. We're going off of sharp. Like I said, right now everybody's working in good faith. It's just, you know, it's one of those things where we are accountable to the public for how we spend their money. And ultimately it's not about us. But, you know, when the time comes, staff is going to have to explain. And I think right now things are going pretty well. Now's the time to explain it? Well, and make sure that it continues. Okay.

19:25 This is the supplement to the master. Right, right. Yeah. But that's where the scope of the project should go. Third golden item is a challenge cost-share supplement project agreement. This is a lakes-based Sarbanes grant project. This one wasn't requested directly by the committee, but it's included for your information and so that you know what is the project. Any questions about the Sarbanes?

19:57 Yeah. John, come. Yeah. I just, I checked on the download off of Granicus and I did not see the Sarbanes document in there. Maybe I'm crazy and I didn't operate it properly, but we could follow up with that later, Steve. I just, I saw the master agreement was repeated twice, but I didn't see the Sarbanes in there. Thank you. Yeah. Well, now, is this the third bullet point that you're referring to, Steve? Okay, that's what I thought. So, it is here.

20:28 Got it. Thank you. Thanks for pointing that out, John. Sure. Next one is the Town of Mammoth Lakes MLTPA Consult Agreement. This is for a website enhancement of 112 new pages. Again, this was requested.

20:51 By the committee. And also it's part of the tracking that we're doing for the Measure R from 2012. And so this is one part of that four-phase agreement. We've got two phases taken care of. And then we're in the process, too, of negotiating with MLTPA for an additional 80 pages of content. I'm sorry, 78. So we may end up with a total of 190.

21:20 Pages of content. And the additional will be proposed at this point at no additional cost to the town. Will this be discussed with item 3 as a part of it? Is it a reference document for item 3 also? Looked like it was. Looked like it went. Yeah, we'll be talking about the necessity for management. Okay. Yeah, and this is the contract that is part of that. Okay, so if we have any questions, that would be the appropriate time to address it. Okay.

21:53 And then, can I ask one question on that? Has this been signed yet? I see Stu Brown has. On the back side. Yes. Turn the page over. Thank you very much. I did the same thing. Okay. Thank you. And then along with that is a two-sided document with four panels that is the background for that notice to proceed. So that details out the specific scope of work.

22:24 Steve, since obviously I haven't read this as well as I should have, the 112 pages, there's 112 specific pages that have been called out to be developed? That's correct. The next bullet item is a memo to the town of Mammoth Lakes Public Works Department from the committee regarding installation of seven interpretive signs.

22:58 So if you remember a number of months ago we went through our procedural notification and so forth about our implementation of projects. We had two types, programmatic and actual hard type projects. So this is a vehicle by which we use then to inform Public Works Department of what the scope is.

23:21 What the funding is and the fact that it's been approved. And as you recall, the rec commission did vote to approve this as was allowed by the town council when we got our fiscal year budget approved. So public works is on notice and they are in the process of putting the bid documents together and we'll hope all that they will come in an expeditious time frame. So that was the answer to my question of not sure if we're going to get them in the ground this year or not.

23:50 We're hopeful. Okay. And quick question on that. You know, there were eight signs. The aquatic life is not to be included, but the price tag is still $84,000. That's our budget. Okay. Our budget. Thank you for clarifying. Remember, too, within the budget are a couple other things having to do with QR code development and so forth. So that's all inclusive. So we're very hopeful, too, that we'll come in under budget because the budget also included hardscape development.

24:16 At each sign, but there are some where we can incorporate existing conditions, and Peter and I reviewed that and discussed it. So we feel comfortable that we will be under budget. Good. Thank you. At this time. At this time. Yes, with seven signs. With seven signs. When we go to eight signs, we'll talk. We'll talk again. All right. Next bullet item is from Friends of the Inyo, Mammoth Lakes.

24:43 Are these posted on our trails website? They're not. They're on the Friends of the Inyo page. Is there, it seems like it should be, they should be on

25:11 Our trails website and also on MLT if there's a link between the two or whatever. But it seems like this is the kind of information that we would really want on. Is that a problem, Laura? I was going to ask Laura first. I understand. We have the contract, as you know, to manage the website. All the information that comes within those trails report...

25:34 Goes to the visitor center. The visitor center then compiles all the information to trail conditions. It then goes to the webmaster. So the trail conditions get forwarded onto the website. The trail report itself does not. I don't know about the logistics of how the website works. Sorry, this is Laura again. But we do send it far and wide. So we send it to Stu. We send it to tourism. We send it to the county. We send it, put it on our Facebook page, and it's on our website.

26:07 Well distributed. But if there are other avenues or other ways that we want to get it posted, just let us know. Yeah. Maybe that's a question for Sarah. Sarah Tomsky, Deputy District Ranger for the Mammoth and Mona Lake Ranger Districts. Yes, we've had extensive conversations about the best ways to incorporate trails conditions onto the MLTS website. And because this is just one piece of all of the trails conditions, I think we've got a pretty good system in place between

26:37 Our Welcome Center and the Webmaster for making sure that the trails conditions for all of the trails are as up-to-date as possible. So I think having an additional PDF download would maybe confuse matters because it wouldn't necessarily be as extensive as simply all of the webpages that are there. Very nice reports. I mean, great ones. Thank you.

27:03 Next bullet item is the MLTPA Measure Hour Performance Report for Summer Stewardship Trails Days 2012, Project 511. For that to hand is a four-year review and consideration. You can see the attachments there for all the money spent and the services provided. Do we have a formal mechanism or should we have a formal mechanism for accepting and reviewing, accepting this?

27:32 I can't remember what the process is. It seems like almost we should. Steve, can you brief us on that? Not typically, no. The only provision is that they have to complete it, and then we attach it to the agendas. So there's no real mechanism, so to speak. The applicants can come forward and speak to it. We can ask them questions on it. But really, their requirement is to provide it 60 days after their completion.

27:58 And I think that we were just using that to base whether or not we fund them next year. Is that correct? That was really the only control. Do we want to take this up at a later date with regard to a formal mechanism? Sorry, Sandy didn't step on you. Because of the time involved in the meetings, getting a report like this, I think, is great. And then if we have questions on that report...

28:26 As a committee and as a commission later down the road for you and I, we can then ask them to come and make an oral report if we have questions or get the questions to them. Doing it this way keeps us a little more streamlined, I think, and it gives us the opportunity to then call them on the carpet if necessary. Well, because I was just wondering as far as comments or, you know, doing comments because, you know, these are very, very complete. I was very happy to see them. You know, we had a few comments on a couple of them.

28:56 Just the volunteers seem to be claimed by both sides, and that's fine as long as we notice, you know, note that they're not 47, 40, 54,000 volunteers or whatever they were, you know. And for Mammoth APA, a little bit maybe simpler budget would be, you know, I realize that this came from the original joint budget, but since they are broken out, it would be, I found it a little more difficult to read than that one, so my suggestion would just be try to simplify a little bit.

29:25 A little bit more. But otherwise, they were very good reports, I thought, in both cases. Yeah, I think encouraging news, too, is the bottom line that the funds awarded versus expended, they were under budget. Yeah. And most people have got a good product. Absolutely. Absolutely. Great programs. The next two are... Sean, you have a... Oh, where did you come say something? Yep.

29:58 I don't know if you'll recall, but at the end, or in the fall of last year, Paul actually came and made a formal report regarding the season of work for the 2013 award. Because of the way that the calendar year versus the budget year falls in place, the reports actually include some of the work that happened this June.

30:23 And then this fall, once the program is complete, we'll again come forward and make a report over the work for this season. But we run into, again, that sort of calendar year versus fiscal year challenge in terms of how we budget for the programs and how the programs are executed. So I just wanted to draw that to your attention as you're reviewing these. Thank you. Steve, didn't we have a fix for at least for the MLTPA portion or not?

30:52 I was trying to think. Yeah, we did. We had 12,500 taken out of one column to give them something to budget against before we got our fiscal year approved. But essentially what that did was put us on a fiscal year cycle. So we have... But we didn't do it with FLI, did we? I don't think we did. So I'm thinking that we did the one fix, but we didn't do the others.

31:15 And that would help you, I think. No, it would just perpetuate the same problem. If we want to get everybody on a calendar year cycle. But I think we just need to remember that we have... One event that's usually... One event that's happening in a different calendar year. Yeah, yeah. Okay, I was thinking we tried to fix that, though, didn't we? We did. We thought we did, but we didn't. And we talked about taking that on, but not today. Okay, not today. Okay, let's just... That's a bigger issue. Okay, okay. That's a bigger issue.

31:49 Okay, then the next one is the Friends of the Inyo Measure Our Performance Report from the Lake Basin Stewards, 2000 ship, I'm sorry, Stewards, 2012 Project 472. This is pretty impressive. This is pretty impressive. The interpretive programs attracted 543 participants. That was amazing. In addition, they had 1,173 public contacts.

32:24 Which is like the trail, oh, that's like a trail trail, yeah. Okay, do you have any questions on that one? Okay, great. Second to the last, town attorney opinion regarding fundraising and grant applications in regards to measure R. So I've included that as an FYI, as you can see down in the second paragraph, the town attorney's recommendation would be not to spend measure R funds on fundraising and seeking grants.

32:59 He goes on to say that that's a safe course of action. And I think his final comment there is allowing a judge to make the final decision that he probably don't want to do. So that's for here. Consideration then when we go back through and move funding forward from 12, 13 to 13, 14. And finally, there has been quite a bit of activity here recently on the blue line and the replacement project status.

33:28 And so that email then was again included as an FYI. And that will also have an effect on our winter recreation map funding if we should so choose to do. So we need to coordinate that as well. I just have a couple technical questions on this one. Did the town provide any of the GIS data for the old diamonds and the mapping that was done? Did the committee...

33:56 I provided that to Mary Kate earlier in the process. And does she have some protocols for now collecting new data to put back in to the town's GIS data so that when we actually go to MAP, everything will be coordinated? Yeah, they're working with the Forest Service on that and what those requirements are for their GIS data. Well, but how about, I'm more worried about...

34:21 The town's GIS data because the data set that the town's working off, the town holds, and maybe it's the same as the Forest Service's protocols, or maybe it's not. I just want to make sure that the data they collect integrates back in to the town's data set. That is the intent. The town uses U.S. Forest Service data for their system trails and so forth. So that is the intent to make it integrated so that when we produce the maps,

34:49 It will not only show the old locations or the existing now locations of the Blue Diamonds but the new ones that they put in. So that concludes the presentation. May I hand out, Chris? If I could just make one comment before I jump in is just I know the fundraising and seeking of grants was kind of important when we were first putting together MLTSCC and initially we had set aside some funds for it but

35:26 This changes the entire strategy there with regard to this opinion by our town attorney. Today's, it's not on the agenda for today, but that is something that, you know, I believe that we do, I would like to seek grants and fundraising, but I'm not sure how to do that without using Measure R, and since this committee is fully funded by Measure R, is there any reason why we can't at least agendize this for a future

35:55 Meeting and to how to, because I do believe that there's got to be grants available out there for a lot of the projects that we're talking about, but this feels like something that I would think worthy enough to agendize for a future meeting. I think it's part of our master tracking too. Absolutely, because other municipalities obviously do the grant writing and the fundraising and public funds, a lot of general funds, is no different than

36:26 Federal funds out of these except specificity of what they need to be, specificity of what they need to be used for. So there's got to be a way to make it work or towns couldn't be using their funds for grant writing and fundraising. Well, I think it's the language of Measure R that the town attorney is referring to. So he doesn't think that the language within Measure R allows for that flexibility that you might have under the general fund.

36:51 And if I might suggest maybe before we agendize it that maybe we could have separate conversations, private conversations with a non-profit to discuss the flexibility that they may have in order to do that and maybe there are some ways that we can support their efforts and then those fundings could be put back into projects. And actually I'd like to go ahead and agendize it because

37:18 Simply because while the $300,000 allocation that we were given is our baseline, I think it was fairly clear that it was A, not the only money we were allowed to address, and B, you know, so, and following up on that, the general fund, in theory, we could make a request to the general fund. So I don't know that we have to wait for all that, and it would be worth having a discussion. You know, we...

37:45 We tend to put the blinders on with regard to the $300,000, and while that's our core funding, those are not the only monies available to us. The town is very successful at seeking grants through general funds. I don't think it's precluding any of that at all, and I think a lot of it is maybe the MLTC can identify applicable grants, and if they're worthy of a measure I matched through a project, I don't see a reason why the town wouldn't pursue that grant like we've done with...

38:14 Charles End Park. I mean, there's a state grant out there that is a $200,000 grant. They came in, they said, you know, we're not going to fund the synthetic turf, so we use that for Measure R, but then we're actually now available to receive, you know, $200,000 of matching funds, you know, for that purpose. So I think there's a protocol there. I think there's a history. I think there's a good record that the town seeks. Well, it's clearly legal to use it for a grant match. Absolutely. There's no problem about grant match.

38:42 It's the fact of going fishing. It's the fact of going fishing with this money. I mean, that's really kind of what it is. Right. Yeah, however, that's why we need to have the conversation. Because to me, saying that there's a grant out there that fits the needs of one of our projects, and then paying for the grant writing out of that, you're spending it on planning for recreation. You're planning to do the project. There's just got to be a way to make that work.

39:10 It is. I understand that his position is it has to be used for what Measure R was called out for, but maintenance, planning, and building of recreation projects, grant writing falls into those. It's part of your planning process. It's getting the funding for the project. Time to agendize it for a different discussion. Otherwise, we'll be here all night. Well said, Sandy. Why don't you put that on that new projects, item number nine there. Let's bring that.

39:38 So that concludes my presentation. Thank you very much. Thank you, Steve. Any further questions? Actually, I like that. I kind of like this list of, you know, in other words, of the informational items and just the, you know, what clarification opportunity can clarify and whether we want to agendize them or not or whatever. I thought that's a good format because we ask for a lot of stuff. Yeah, that's a great handout, Steve. Thanks. Yeah. Okay, well, let's take on the consent agenda. Is there any discussion with regard to the...

40:12 Do I have any motion to accept consent of this? I would second. Do I have a motion and a second? Any further discussion? Who's in favor? Aye. Accept. Agenda accepted. Next item is under business matters, number three, Mammoth Lake Trail System website management agreement, project manager, additional funding discussions and approval.

40:46 So there is a staff report in front of you basically outlining the need for additional consultant services to manage the website. And there are two facets to that website management. One is an enhancement contract that we talked about earlier in handout. And then the other is the website management itself. Currently, the... I guess... Currently, the...

41:19 Trail System Coordinator has been providing services to the town and the committee as represented in consent item number two. And you can see that quite a bit of time has been spent with management and enhanced the contract, various meetings and discussions, having to do with the partners of the website and move the website forward. Again, these costs are not under the original.

41:49 Consult the agreement for providing services to the committee. So there is a request to add additional funds to cover that on an hourly basis. And our estimation at this point is that that would be anywhere from $500 to possibly $750 a month averaged over the 10-month remaining period of the coordinator contract. As you can see from agenda item two, quite a bit of money was spent up front.

42:18 In order to negotiate the contract, to solidify the contract, and move forward. It's anticipated that while that contract could work, is being performed, that those hours dedicated to that effort will drop considerably. And so over the time period, it is hoped that the time necessary to manage both the website management contract and the enhancement contract will be less. But there is that provision.

42:47 For up to $7,500 over the next 10 months. And as I might add, the Measure R enhancement contract has four phases, and we completed basically negotiations on two of those phases, and one of those two phases is in production now. So we have two more phases to go. There are some issues there that are interesting and challenging.

43:13 Working with a forest service on that as well as a contractor. So we're looking forward to a successful completion of that. So I'm here and available to answer any questions. And if they are of a sensitive nature on the contract that I currently hold, I'll defer to Stu Brown. My question would be, I would hope that this is going to the Recreation Commission because

43:42 Basically, if I understand it correctly, you know, that was an award that the rec commission made. The contract's been developed, but we're, you know, our project coordinators being asked to handle it. And so I think the rec, hopefully this is going to the rec commission, rec, the recreation commission for approval so that they acknowledge and understand that, you know, this is, I'm fine with it. You know, I'm fine with it. It's the most efficient way to do it. But I think they need to kind of.

44:12 Recognize that we're taking this on. That's fine. We'll pay it out of the trails dollars. It's appropriate to me. It's a website. But is it on the rec commission agenda, I guess, is my question, Steve? Not yet. Not yet. So it won't be for tomorrow? It can be added as an emergency item if we feel we want to do that. It depends on the direction of the committee. I mean, it's certainly a valuable...

44:38 Arrangement, I think. I mean, to expeditiously fulfill the contracts, working with the consultant, the Forest Service and all the parties, it's the way to go. I mean, there's no doubt that. So it's really the will of the MLTACC. We can move it forward to the Recreation Commission as needed. Procedurally, don't we have to? I don't think we have the ability to authorize funds. Certainly, I support it, too. In fact, I think at the last meeting we asked for this. Yeah, it makes sense.

45:08 Makes sense to me. Just that I think we do need to get their approval. So get their approval. So this can be added as an emergency item for tomorrow's meeting. Bill, are you okay with that? Yeah, I'm fine with it. Yeah, yeah. Because otherwise, you know, I guess my fear would be at the end of the year, they'll come back and they go, oh, look at these administrative costs. And we're going, well, wait a minute. We just took on some of yours. Okay. No, my only questions on it would be, the $7,500, is this going to be now an annual add-on as a cost of the web?

45:37 To manage that contract? Or is this going to go down? Is this a one-year, one-time, get it done and everything else is just addendums after that? Yeah, I think it's fair to say that the bulk of the enhancement contract is a one-time creation of now under contract 112, potentially 78 more web pages. And that at the direction...

46:04 Of the committee in the future, more pages may or may not be added. So that portion would kind of be out of it. The other part has to do with the QR code connection to interpretive content. We have the eight signs in place now. We have seven more that we're producing. So that will be a one-time cost unless we add additional signs or decide we want to add additional content. So those can be managed in the future.

46:32 And then the management, of course, of the website contract will be an ongoing thing and will probably be inexpensively needed to be considered. But not at this level. Hopefully, no. And my question would be, we gave a one-year approval to the website maintenance contract. So in the future, I'd like to see us examine. I'd like a copy of it, first of all.

46:59 That contract, I think that's one we haven't seen, the website maintenance contract, the $34,000. We could have that in our next one, you know, or the one after that, so that in the future, when it comes time, we actually, you know, examine it and decide how do we want to go with this. I don't think anything should be open-ended and just the assumption being that we're going to, you know, willy-nilly approve every contract. I think we had a look at the... You're asking for the maintenance contract? Yeah.

47:30 Yeah, because we haven't had a comment. I appreciate seeing actually a copy of this one because I think this helps, you know, kind of spell out, answers a lot of questions, things like this. Probably saves a lot of time. Yeah, we should. We should have copies of all of those. Yeah, exactly, exactly. Steve, that's not a problem. Yes, that would be good, I think. Okay. So as a part of that then,

48:06 Can we discuss a little bit of this contract, the interpretive part of it you were talking? Because it sounded like that isn't a part of the website management contract. I don't think that's not an agendized item, unfortunately. That was my question earlier. If we were to discuss this, or we had an opportunity to get some clarifications or whatever, you may have answered some of that. Okay. Well then, it sounds like, yeah, if it's not agendized, then we can't really talk about it. Is that correct, Bill?

48:36 Well, check with staff. Check with staff, if they're okay with that. It is part of the presentation. General. Yeah. I don't have problems asking. I'd listen, I'd understand the concerns and the questions. Because we are dealing with website, I think we could probably discuss anything related there, too, but we couldn't make a decision on any of the specific contracts because...

49:07 That's not agenda. No, it's just a clarification. Do you want to go ahead and ask your question, sir? Well, yeah, because you talked a little bit about the phases 1, 2, 3, and 4, and it sounded like, if I understood correctly when we were talking about it, that the interpretive part is still to be developed as far as the contract, or a contract. Okay, that's the main thing. In other words, the interpretive part of it is... If you look on the attachment, four pages...

49:37 If you look at the first page that's dated August 9th, it has four items there. The TNF effort to develop new web pages, that is completed task. The next item, TNF effort to develop interpretive content, that is not completed task, $1,500. Then the lump sum funds for new web page production, $16,000, that is an executed contract that is underway.

50:06 What page is that? I'm not finding it in my packet. Yeah, I'm not finding it. It was under the presentation and it was the follow-up. Yeah, yeah. That's why it seemed like it was... Yeah, that's why I asked because it is a little bit... Yeah. And I did have... So once we get to...

50:39 We will be having further discussion on the interpretive elements of any, in other words, if there were an additional contract or anything outside of this one, then we would be, that would be open to discussion, is that correct? In other words, this isn't an open-ended interpretive contract. The contract is very specific. If you go beyond the bounds of what you have in front of you, then we would need to come to the committee and discuss that.

51:07 Get your approval to go beyond the scope of the dollars that are listed there. Or issue a new contract or, okay, that's my main thing. I don't want to see us issuing open-ended contracts and just, you know, keep on adding money to them and this and that. I think there are times we need to talk about, you know, whether we go for an RFP or whatever because we do have professional interpretation folks around, all around here in the Eastern Sierra, a lot of them.

51:36 You know, if it gets, when it gets down to really looking at interpretive, an interpretive contract long term to develop it, then that's what I, that's what I'm talking about. Okay. Do you want to ask any other questions? I've just got one. Okay. So Steve, you were talking, I was going to try and do the math here before going further, but we've already, so what we're being asked to approve here is $7,500 for you essentially to work with the contractor. That's

52:07 Not to exceed number. Not to exceed number. You've already spent $1,325 on this. So yeah, your time is going to have to ramp down considerably to stay under the $7,500 for the next 10, where are we, 10 months? Okay, 10 plus months. So in order to hit that 10 to 15 hours per month, you're actually going to have to be taken a lot less here in months to come.

52:37 To stay under that $7,500. Well, I think the way to explain it is that it has taken this 26.5 hours of dedicated time to get the project, in a sense, out of Ray's arena, out of Ray's left, and then to work with the contractor under the contract that was existing.

53:00 Getting the four phases fully expressed and flushed out, working with the Forest Service on the number of pages, the types of pages, and so forth. So that effort of 26 hours was very concentrated to this last month. I do not at all anticipate in the next three months coming anywhere near close to those kinds of numbers. And that is my intent.

53:23 This range that we've given at the top end is an estimation, and I'll only be building the hours that are actually spent in that time and effort as I've been doing, and they will be separately built. Okay. You will have a recap like this one every month of how much time and effort is being spent on those website management.

53:47 By the way, I meant to say earlier when you made that presentation, thank you for breaking out your invoiced hours versus website management. I think it is important that we see those separated. Okay? And I just want to comment, I'm really happy to see the new pages. I think those are great ones because they're ones that have, for a long time, you know, I'll touch the page and go see what's on eastern lands and there's nothing there. Now there's going to be something there. Bill and I worked on a lot of those. I want to see them there. And also the same thing for Red's Meadow. I'm happy to see those.

54:18 I think Lakes Basin, you know, I mean, that's been more than adequate. We've got plenty of people up there, but some of these other areas is where we want to draw people, and so I'm happy to see those pages, and going over those with my magnifying glass. Thank you, Steve. They look good, anyway. They're good additions. I'm glad to see those. Can you speak a little bit to the timeline of when you expect to have phases two, three, and four?

54:43 You know, is completed the right word? Because I know it's always ongoing, but... Yeah, in the contract agreement is to be delivered within 90 days of the signed contract, and the signed contract was, I think, about two weeks ago. So, and everything I've heard at this point is we're on target, and hopefully we'll keep that 90 days. Okay. So I'll make a...

55:07 Motion to approve the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee with Coordinators Professional Consultant Services Agreement. Amendment number two for website project management for an amount not to exceed 7,500. This is website enhancement project management, I guess? It's both. Oh, it is both. Okay. Okay. I'll second. We have a motion and a second. Any further discussion?

55:36 The only thing I would add to that would be to say it would be recommended to be presented to the Recreation Commission for this. Yes, as amended. As amended, yep. I thought we just did this by consensus a minute ago. Well, it's all right. If we need a motion, let's go down that road, too. It's money, so we might as well do it. It says business matters approval, so. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Done, done, done. Okay. Good. Okay.

56:02 Business item number four, discuss status of projects and programs listed in the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan. So what I've done, again, is given to a painfully small text document, but it is four pages long, and it is printed double-sided. But what I did here was per the request that he was originated by Vice Chair Phil Taylor.

56:25 To list all the projects that are recommended within the adoptive nanoplate success as a master plan. And these also included programs that were listed. So, on the far left, we have the number G1 through 16, G standing for general, go on, N projects of notable types.

56:48 And it goes so forth and so on up to mucks and soft service, bike paths, many others. And then the title of it is the second column, Navy Convention, Trail Update Match, uniform signage, and so forth. And then finally the staff. So what I did understand is to look to what we have done so far to meet the recommendations that have come out of the master plan.

57:16 So this is by no means a complete and exhaustive description of status. It's my general understanding of where we are. And I've also had the opportunity to go over this list with Member Hogan and get her input as to what's been included, what has happened, and where the status might be. So I think the first thing I would recommend is that

57:43 At the committee members' leisure, they go through this list, try and understand and see where we are for status. And then the second thing that I would propose is the left by 17 foldout that is a graphic concept that's two-sided as well. That's been included in your packet as an idea of the next step. So we can take our Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan,

58:13 Projects and Programs as recommended in the master plan and merge them with our Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee, Master Projects and Budget Tracking Lists that we've been working from for the last few months and actually morph them into one precise and consistent document and so I show a formatting of having the trail system recommendation to the far left and then our indent is how we're responding to that particular lineup.

58:43 So for G1 naming convention, the status is an ongoing within the updated public work standards to be adopted by the town council in the future. And then in particular, for our master tracker, we show it is code 211. We have the trail standards and we show it's a bucket list of four and that there will be a possible future signed contract. So in this way, I think that we can monitor both.

59:11 The projects and programs out of the trail system master plan and then more specifically have a subtext under them as to what our current projects are and how we are moving forward with them either from our last year's funding, this year's funding and our current status. So I present that to you for your consideration.

59:38 So what I understand you're saying is that we wouldn't actually go through the list and talk about it today, but if you're presenting it, we'll go home and digest it, and then next month we'll actually dive into it. Thank you. Yes. It's a great concept, you know, trying to get these integrated so we can really kind of track along. So these two will stay together going forward. You're going to present both these at the same time going forward. That's my suggestion at this point.

1:00:03 Wide open to any other suggestions because as I say, you know, our master tracker is now a five page document and this is a four page document so we're going to have, you know, fairly lengthy documents so I don't know if we want to break it up into chapters or, you know, if we want to just keep chewing on the big, big giant hamburger all at once or how we want to move forward with formatting and make it easy but I think this is a great way to have a mobile document

1:00:33 We're working in concert with each other. It seems like, yeah, go ahead, Steve. Yeah, well, let's hear from the committee first. Is there anyone want any comments here at this time? Yeah, I was just thinking, to me, it seems like it may end up being long, but it is going to have everything there. You know, and some of the things when you start looking at them, especially if you start looking at, for instance, when we get into MUPS, you know, near-term MUPS,

1:01:00 In-town muffs, connectors, muffs outside, the same type of thing with bike lanes and sidewalks, whatever, maybe we actually have some subcommittee assignments and just once in a while do a report on them or something like that, you know, because I think the key is, is, you know, the trail system master planning incorporates all of this. The fact that we're not going to go over all of this all the time, but, you know, an occasional subcommittee report, things like that.

1:01:27 I know a lot of this is the kind of stuff that we used to handle in the Mobility Commission, you know, so as far as I'm concerned, that might be something to think about too, you know, how to kind of chunk it up and sign it out. I like the idea of consolidating the two lists. You know, I want to play with the formatting a little bit and just see if I think there's an easier bit.

1:01:51 If you go back to when we first did this and we started with our bucket list and we had all the projects out of the measure R application and this is pretty much what we did with that and we had the ones that we selected, the ones that were deferred broken out and this just expands on that so that we can see the whole picture at once and I think that's a good idea. I like it. You know, I like having it broken out on the list as he has it. I think that formatting.

1:02:20 Because I'd like to see where each project fits within our bucket list, too, because that's our prioritization project each year, is the bucket list and how it works. So I think we still need that, but we need that extra column on his big list as to where it fits within that, whether we have designated that as a current, a future, or however it fits. That's what I was thinking about the term of formatting. I think, Steve, it looks like formatted it.

1:02:48 Following the trail system master plan, and clearly there's some logic to that. Our other list was formatted or organized based on our prioritization project. There's also some logic to that. So just trying to figure out how the two might mass integrate this. Yeah, and even if it's just shown, it can be this way or it can be by priority, although this probably works best for someone else trying to follow. But then if our prioritization is shown with it as well,

1:03:15 With each project, then the public can better understand where we're at and what direction we're going. Well, I think with some of these, you know, going through, if you remember, the original list didn't come from us. It came from that application that was not, some of it was based on the TSMP, but some of it wasn't. That was the big 365-page application that MLTPA wrote. And then it was withdrawn. And we used that as our list. That was the one that was written.

1:03:44 It was the town's application for 2011, wasn't it? And it was withdrawn, and we adopted that because we were in the formation process. So we used that, and we actually haven't even changed a lot of the, you know, the wording here. So it's kind of a chance for us to take a look at these and make sure that they do fit. And a few of them, maybe we've had them on the bucket list, and it's like anything else on a priority list. If you carry it for too many years, you just drop it.

1:04:10 Yeah, well, that's what the bucket list is about. Yeah, exactly. We can revisit it every year. Exactly. So that we don't allow things to drop and we know what direction we're going. Sometimes, you know, it's just like old clothes in the closet. Or we do, yeah. Yeah. Anyway, this is great, I think, Steve. John, did you have comments? Yeah, I just wanted to follow up on what Sandy was saying and what Steve is proposing. This effort, all of these things will come together. It's designed that way.

1:04:40 So in the original measure application, to Sandy's point, we laid out all those projects per an organizational system for a budget for a Mammoth Lakes Trail System that we did a lot of research on. I think Steve's adopted that in his tracker list. That's a good way to organize the system that you're managing, how you want to do all that stuff. In our performance reports for all the work that we did under contract, we used citations from the Trail System Master Plan that line up with the inventory that Steve has.

1:05:10 So I would recommend using the tracker list as your sort of master document and then reorganizing and slotting the things you're talking about now within that because then you'll have a nice, beautiful, efficient budget template to work from and you'll have citations for projects within there and you'll also know based on the documents he's provided for you which things have already been completed, which things the town has in its possession. I would also encourage you

1:05:36 To get access to the Measure Our Performance Reports that we provided for all the contract work that we did, because that's another way to reconcile back to say, okay, that's what they produced, that's what they delivered to the town, and that will give you good inventory, all the things that you've got, what their citation is in the Trail System Master Plan, and then how all that fits into your master budget tracking list. So this is all designed to come together. It's a great thing you guys are doing to bring it all together. It should make your life a lot more efficient going forward.

1:06:05 Question, John, performance reports, what is the approximate date? Well, we have from spring, excuse me? Or when it was submitted, so I can find it. I can give you all this stuff. It was spring 2009, fall 2009, spring 10. I mean, each one of those performance reports has all those citations in there for all the stuff that we did. So you can reconcile that back, and then you'll know which things got done.

1:06:30 I'm not sure that we want all that detail, though. You know, if it's done, it's done. And, you know, and if it fits within here, John, there's a time for too much information, too. I mean, we're trying to... Again, I just want to make sure that the public understands what was produced with Measure R funds. If anybody wants a record of what was produced, it exists. And if you want to use it, you're free to. Right. Balance it with... And just a quick technical question. You wrote this in Excel? Yes. Okay, so we can sort.

1:06:58 I think the thing that we can do is agendize the discussion on format first, and then on content. And another way of doing it is just taking the information and adding another column to the master tracker, basically the same, you know, under what recommendation number, what page number, what column would this call? So there may be a...

1:07:26 I'm just thinking of sorting options because, you know, totally unrelated project, but I have a data set that I routinely use three different sorts on. It's all one data set, but depending on what of three questions I'm trying to answer at the time, I just do a quick sort. And that's why I was asking what's done in Excel. So we can probably do that. Anyway, good job.

1:07:53 Yeah, thank you, and this is an ongoing process, so, you know, we are finding our way. Business matter number five has a two division to discuss the strategies and priorities for the community. But as you recall, we, at the last meeting, approved the mission.

1:08:18 And on the first page of the handout, the second paragraph there is that approved mission. And that also was reflected in the minutes that we already approved. So if there are any questions or comments about the mission, it has been approved and so reflected in the minutes. And what we did not approve was the vision, which is the first part of the handout. So as I recall,

1:08:47 We were wordsmithing how to best describe the Mammoth Lakes Trail System as the best set of recreation trails and programs. And I think that the last thing we came close to was in the country, integrating wayfinding and interpretation that seamlessly connects users with a great outdoor experience. So per my notes, that's as close as we got to a decision on the wording.

1:09:15 And we still wanted to agendize it and discuss that phrase. So moved. We were just having, you know, we felt like it really captures it, but it just wasn't quite smooth. Well, Bill had a good suggestion. And since you were really leading the discussion on this last meeting, I'd kind of like to hear your comments that you just related. All I said was that we should take, you know, we have the mission, vision, and the strategies as one item. I'd like to split it into two and just go ahead and...

1:09:44 Act on the vision. And I think when I went over this, I looked at some of the notes of the stuff we went back and forth. I think we got it. So unless we want to spend a few more meetings wordsmithing, I would move through. My only problem with it still is, hang on just a second. Who's doing that? I wonder if it was my phone was there. It wasn't doing anything, but it was me.

1:10:17 Must be Steve. No? Is there somebody upstairs? Wait, that's really bad. Yeah. Yep. Okay, there we go. Steve, you're going to be talking loud to our microphones. We could give you one of those over there probably. Do you want to try and plug that back in without the stuff on it? Probably the fading on thing. Want to stand at the podium? Testing. Hello? Hello? Hey, that's working. No static.

1:11:09 Nope. Okay. That was interesting. Great. As I was saying, my only problem in this is we keep trying to make ourselves the best in the country, the best in the world, the best in the... And I don't know that that's ever necessary. I'm not... But we're a great system of trails in a great place that integrates wayfinding, interpretation, and seamlessly connects unions. I have no problem with that. I just... Somehow I keep getting hung up on this. We have to be the best in the country or we have to be the best in the world or we have to be... Yeah.

1:11:40 I had the same, that's the same little thing that I kept trying to play with it, and it's kind of like, well, I, yeah. I just see vision as aspirational, right? So, I mean, it's rich for the stars. It's a vision. Yeah, I don't have to go with that either. He was just saying, well, then let's say the universe. Superlatives. Solar System. It works for me, yeah. If you remember the discussion from last time, and I can't remember who it was that brought it up. They just said, as you read it, when it just said,

1:12:09 The best set of recreational trails and programs in the country, or excuse me, the best set of recreational trails and programs. There was no context. It didn't quite. Yeah, that's what I said. There was no context. It didn't have context. Yeah, that's a good way of putting it. And so it was, it just, whoever it was, and I don't remember from the minutes who it was, but whoever brought it up, I think it was a good point. I was one of the ones who originally said leave out.

1:12:39 Country or World or anything. But after listening to that, I decided that maybe that was fine. Well, and I kind of, you know, I was trying to figure out if we could say something like, you know, it's a wonderful set of recreational trails and programs integrating wayfinding because I have the same problems with in the country. Even the best set, I'm not, eh.

1:13:03 But I was having the same problem. Not in the world, not in the country. It's wonderful, it's unforgettable, it's magnificent. I mean, there are all sorts of things you can put in there without saying in the world. One thing is if you can take set of out, so just the best recreational trails and programs. Yeah, the set of you could get out, get rid of. Okay. Yeah, and I say I've always, superlatives have always bugged me as well, but at the same time you do have to have some kind of contact.

1:13:31 Yeah. I actually would like to keep in the country and without spending too much time on it. Let's take out set of. If we're going to do that, my preference would be to say the Mammoth Lakes Trail System will be the best set of recreational trails and programs in the country instead of is. Who are us to judge? Because, well, visions are always written that way. Visions are written as the future state, not as the... But anyway, it's fun.

1:14:00 Make your motion again. I'll vote for it. Let's read it again. Are we just doing it as is? No. So I will move, and we can debate it again. The Mammoth Lakes Trail System is the best recreational trails and programs in the country, integrating wayfinding and interpretation that seamlessly connects users with a great outdoor experience. That really doesn't sound right. No, it should be R.

1:14:29 When we took set up. Yes. So the math likes trails, no, that doesn't work either. No. Is. We have to put set up back in so all the verbs agree. Yeah, that's part of the problem. Yeah, yeah. Yick. And I was going to suggest seamlessly connecting because that's a little more active and you get rid of one word. Well, let's figure out what we're going to do. I know, I know. Leave it as it is. Yeah, I'm good. I'll make a motion that we accept it as written. I'll second.

1:15:01 I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. I thought we were discussing at that point. I thought that's why the motion was made, so that we could discuss this. Well, I did. I'm sorry, I didn't hear you. Yeah, yeah, yeah. We've got a motion and a second, Sandy. Is it just, in other words, as written? As written. As written. Well, you know, I would add, change it to seamlessly connecting at the very least to get rid of one word, because it is kind of wordy.

1:15:32 Yeah, well, my original version, I think, only had six words in it, so we're not going to get back to what I wanted, so let's approve this thing and move on to other business. Yeah. Well, we're going to live with it. We've got a motion in a second. All those in favor of it as the motion reads? Aye. Aye. Aye. I'll go along with it. Opposed? We'll live with it. We can always amend it. It passes unanimously. We can always come back to it later.

1:16:00 Okay, then the second part is on the next page, options for discussions related to strategy and priority establishment. So here again is a follow-up from our conversations. Last month we made bullet items for these various items that were discussed so as not to infer a one through five prioritization and five being more than one or whatever. So the bullet items are in place.

1:16:30 And the latest list reflects the discussions that were held at that time. So it's presented to you for further discussion. So, question. Assuming we say, yeah, this is a good list, I think obviously this needs to be something that we can amend going forward as we get new ideas and as we find out what works well and what doesn't.

1:17:02 We would then, any project that came to us would be related to these strategies and priorities. It's a tool to help you to basically evaluate all those many recommendations and the master tracker projects and any other projects that might come. The other reason I'm asking is you as staff, you're going to have to actually do the writing on that part. Of course I would, yes. So I want to make sure that we're all in agreement that that's what we're trying to achieve.

1:17:30 The strategies I didn't have too much problem with. I think the priorities need some more discussion because there were some added from our last time and they're really kind of business as usual type of stuff that I don't think should be in priorities necessarily. You know, to me, compliance with measures R&U and other funding sources, that's kind of like, well, duh. I would hope. That's a method of doing business, I would hope for us. Yeah, but I think that's an important finding to make in every...

1:18:00 And now every project analysis. Okay, but it may be a finding, but you're talking about priorities for funding. It's a different, those are different things. Okay. But I would agree, finding is a wonderful thing. Also, like maintenance of existing data sets, programs, and infrastructure, you know, I mean, that's the kind of stuff, that's business.

1:18:19 Yeah, but what's the definition of priorities for funding? If a project comes before us that we are considering, and if those aren't on here, is that something that we wouldn't consider it before looking at something that's ready to go? Well, there's going to be a lot of projects that are coming before us that may be ready to go, but it would be nice to have some of these other...

1:18:42 Definitions of what we're considering. Something that I just want to throw out there with regard to that that's not here in the priorities for funding is public outreach and as far as trying to communicate with the public, you know, what trails are available to us. So, for instance, what's coming before us now or what we were talking about earlier is more of the website development and enhancement. You know, I think that that is one of the most important things that we can spend money on besides the actual

1:19:09 Shovel on the ground as it is, is really promoting our trails, and I don't necessarily see that here unless I'm misreading. Well, it's in the strategies, though. It is in the strategies, but I guess I'm just saying with regard to what's the difference between priorities for funding. For funding, I'd rather have said public education because that's where your maps and your websites and everything else come in. At this point, we're no longer trying to go out and reach the public. We're trying to educate the public as to what's available. Okay.

1:19:36 And you could kind of add that to enhancement of connection with public lands through education. No, because all of our projects may not be on public lands. There may be a program or something else that are different. But do you see what I'm saying is that I don't see public education on the priorities for funding. And while it is on the strategies, if we are going to be considering developing a scoring sheet, for instance, for how we are going to determine whether this project is better than that project,

1:20:06 You know, I would like to see that included in the priorities for funding, even though it's explained in the strategies, I think it needs to be in there. So I don't mind public education, public outreach, whatever, you know, you can call it public education and outreach for that matter. But I just, in speaking, I would have no problem adding that in. How would you, yeah, what's the wording on it? Opportunities for public education? Opportunities for public outreach? I'd just put public outreach slash education. I think it was bullet three, maximize community engagement.

1:20:35 Public Education and Promoting Trail Stewardship. I mean, you can tie it to tie in there. Unless you think it's different. So I guess, Chair, where you're going with this is you're probably seeing something similar to the Measure R process where you have strategies, the first filter and priorities to the second filter. And there's some other things too that with the new Council Agenda Bills, if you've seen those,

1:20:58 They've asked staff to identify, you know, how does that relate to the new strategies that have been identified by council? So it could be something that we could incorporate in your staff reports that you see that would answer those questions. So what strategy is this identified to and how does this align with the priorities of funding? So it could be something we can start to tie in. Okay. Is everyone comfortable with that? Because I think that's important. And I think that would be, and you're right, that's kind of where I was coming from. Right, that's what I think you meant, right.

1:21:26 So we're integrating into our, you know, daily discussion, making sure all projects are going through that kind of filter, so to speak, so. I hope we never get to that point of the detail that we have a measure R and measure U and the filters and the numbers and the, I would hope we. Well for right now we're just doing an agenda. I know. An agenda building. Yeah, yeah. Could be. So another question I have is whether there.

1:21:53 Bullet 4 under item number 2 and bullet 6 were somewhat redundant since theoretically maintenance of existing data sets programs and infrastructure is a recurring program and maybe if we just added to bullet 4 including maintenance. You know, if we included maintenance, I suppose, but I see them as different because when I look at recurring programs, I'm thinking things like the trails.

1:22:27 Stewardship Days and those things. The existing data sets and everything, we, out of sight, out of mind, if they're not out here, then we are likely to forget them, and I would like us not to do that because they are important. That would be the GIS and the photo libraries and the... And actually physically maintaining the trails. And physically maintaining the trails. Well, the trails kind of comes under... Well, this one, the data sets and things like that, who owns these? The town does, right? I mean...

1:22:56 And who uses them? Staff. And when staff needs them updated, they get them updated. But I don't think it needs to be a project that we put out to bid every year because some of this stuff, let's face it, gets updated every five years with pen and ink by the staff when they need it. Sometimes they'll update it right away. Sometimes it'll be 10 years out. But the question always, existing data sets, it's owned by the town. Library programs, infrastructure, aren't those owned by the town?

1:23:24 So look who owns it and then who uses it. But that's fine. The town may be the ones coming and asking for funding to maintain the data sets and actually other people besides the town use the data sets. The Blue Diamond Trails being a perfect example where the town provided the data set to somebody else and they will then be getting.

1:23:43 Input back from those users. Yeah, but. So, I actually think. This is kind of business as usual to me. Again, it's like, put in there, let's update handbooks and, you know, do our filing system. And it's like, things like that are kind of, that's business as usual. Yeah, but it is business as usual. And I've seen the town not do that business as usual over the years. So, I'd just assume that it was left in there as a heads up for us and as a priority for us. I think it's incredibly important. Okay. Or we don't.

1:24:08 Get it done. And I might even delete the if funded by measures R or U because there may be other. Exactly. I have no problem with that. I mean, that part doesn't make any sense either. We already said that we aren't limited to R and U and our funding scope. Yeah. John, did you have comment? Yeah, I have a comment about data sets. This is a critically important subject. One of the first things that MLTPA did when we started working on

1:24:42 A lot of things in the trail system was something called the GIC data set. And this was where we at our own initiative went out and collected points of public access that were used as critical parts of the Snow Creek Gate Master Development Plan project and secured public access easements and all the rest of this kind of stuff. That kind of effort and that kind of material did not come from the town. That came from outside of the town. We've delivered thousands of points.

1:25:09 And lines of data representing the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. They live in the corporate data sets that are managed by the town of the Forest Service. But there were enormous gaps in the data in their currency, i.e. a lot of it was 5, 10, 15 years old. And just as a sort of representation of the value of that, I was down taking pictures for the updated trail system website down in the...

1:25:37 The Crater Meadow area down over the weekend. I encountered two parties of people who wanted to know where the Rim Trail was. The Rim Trail is represented currently on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System maps at all the trailheads. It's a Forest Service. It comes from the Forest Service data that's maybe 10, 15 years old. I don't know how old it is. It represents a trail that goes from Red Cone along the top of the Mammoth Crest and then comes down to McLeod Lake. That data's never been ground truth. There is no sign on the Mammoth Pass Trail to get up to the Rim Trail.

1:26:06 Bill and I were talking this morning, there may be people getting this information just searching on the web. We're all living in the 21st century here. The role of data, and if you look at the very sophisticated contemporary efforts that Mammoth Lakes Tourism is doing to market this community, a photo library is a key part of that. So I would just encourage you to anticipate the value of these things, the value of keeping it current.

1:26:29 Keeping it up to date, having it ground truthed so that what a visitor or what one of us is seeing on a map actually represents what is on the ground. These are critical things. And I think it would serve you well. It's a great way to get value for your system and to keep your stuff contemporary. Thank you. So we're taking these two different topics separately. That'd be good. Do you want to, you know, let's actually try and really narrow down. Is there anything we want to keep on here or add on here?

1:27:01 For strategies. For strategies. Yeah, for strategies, they look pretty good, actually, I thought. I think we've covered the high-level strategies. Right, right. Yeah. You know, the priorities for funding, I'd suggest maybe we give it a little more thought. I'm sorry to say the funding? The funding priorities, right, because we don't really, you know, let's... Well, do you want to give them thought here at this meeting, or are you talking about bringing them back? I'm talking about bringing them back for discussion, as we did with the mission.

1:27:31 You know, think about it. I'm pretty happy with them. It is just like everything else we do. It is a living, breathing document. We can amend it. If one of us sees something we really don't like, we can ask for it to be re-agendized and add or delete anything at that point in time. The only thing I'm seeing here that I'm, if funded by R&U, I think we've all agreed.

1:27:55 That's not our only funding source. So maintenance of existing data sets, programs, and infrastructure can have a period at the end of it as far as I'm concerned. But other than that, I would adopt them for today as is. And if we have the need, any of us individually has the need to bring it back and wants to change them, then we bring it back to the chair and staff and have it re-agendized and make the changes. I'd like to. And that would be my motion, I suppose. Second that for discussion.

1:28:24 Seconded for discussion. For discussion, yes. I'd just like to go back to something that Sandy said about the last bullet and compliance with measures R&U. And other funding sources. And other funding sources. That's really, it's less of a priority. What I would actually do if we're going to change, I mean, we're going to have something about funding, it should be funding is available as a priority. Because we don't, the, the,

1:28:53 In addition to our prioritization and our strategies, Steve has to do a basic staff report and part of our findings has to be, that's on his other sheet, has to be compliant with whatever the funding source is. But we should know in terms of priorities that the money is there. That should be one of the criteria. So I'd recommend changing that bullet from compliance with measures R&U to funding as available.

1:29:21 How about compliance with available funding source? I think that's a finding you make after. But first thing you want to know is there's the money in there. The only thing I'd like to add to that bill is the, as I mentioned, making priorities for funding that it includes public outreach and education. That was the last one. Yeah, I thought we already decided. Yeah, that was added, I thought. So I would add both of those to my. So what we're talking about here, just to be clear,

1:29:48 On the priorities for funding is that we are removing the paragraph there on item number six about if funded by Measure R&U, just strike it. We are removing number eight, compliance with Measure R&U and other funding sources to just change it to funding is available, period. And I guess the final item would be we're adding in of outreach and education. That's exactly an item. I like that. Then I would amend my

1:30:18 Whatever it is I said. Your motion? Yep. And you'll amend jurisprudence? Well, I didn't second. You did. No, I didn't. No, you did. No, you did. No, it's a second. We did a discussion. Second. Okay. So they have been amended. Any further discussion? All right. I think we are. Is this consensus or are we voting on this? All those in favor of these priorities for funding? As motioned. Aye. Aye.

1:30:47 Passes unanimously. Okay. Excellent. Okay, the next item is item number six, which is review and approve MLTPA proposal for reimbursement of funds related to temporary signage and messaging project 490.2. And I'll just make a brief presentation and I think Laura wanted to speak to this as well.

1:31:24 During July when it looked like we had the opportunity to put in temporary signage at two locations, one being the Panorama Dome Trail Complex and the other I'll just call the Mountain View Earthquake Fault Complex, there was quite a bit of work that went into that from Friends of the Inyo and at the same time MLTPA provided messaging.

1:31:52 Information and consistency with messaging and also location of rational points for those signs to be placed. Nowhere in our funding of, as I recall, $2,000 at that time was there a place for MLTPA to recoup any time and material spent in that effort. So after seeing the effort that was put in by MLTPA, it was under my suggestion.

1:32:18 That they provide the committee with a proposal for reimbursement of time and materials spent in that effort. And I think we'll all agree that the temporary signs are well placed. I think they're well messaged. And I took a fellow up the other day who is new to mountain biking.

1:32:39 And we rode through those trail complexes at Panorama Dome. And it's very intuitive. It worked very, very well. And the flow off of the Lakes Basin path is just fantastic. I just can't say enough about it. It really worked out. So we're presenting then before you a $500 not to exceed proposal for reimbursement for those efforts. And Laura, if you want to speak to it.

1:33:07 Hi, again. Yeah, I kind of just want to dovetail on what Steve said, that, you know, the original proposal, the original budget for the project was based on an estimate from Friends of Inyo of about $100 per sign, and that included an hour of staff time, materials, other things like that.

1:33:37 But as Steve mentioned, you know, a lot of work went into putting those signs in under a really tight timeline, and I think it's all turned out really, really well, but it involved a lot more time, I think, from all of us, from MLTPA, from Friends of the Inyo, from Forest Service, and others, Steve, who were involved in getting this project on the ground. And, I mean, from our perspective, just Friends of the Inyo, I think we ended up spending an additional three hours per sign on the project than we had originally budgeted,

1:34:07 Is what it is. I just wanted to bring it up because that is an additional for just our cost, about $1,500 that wasn't included in the original proposal. But as we move forward with projects like this, I think it's great for us to push these things through and get them done. But from a process perspective, I think it'd be good to maybe take a few minutes and try to iron out exactly what we think some of that time allotment would be so that we're not...

1:34:36 Pushing ourselves well over what was estimated at the beginning. That's all. Thanks. Thank you. Were you reimbursed for that $1,500 additional, or did you just absorb it? No, we absorbed it. I mean, to us, you know, it's a great thing for us to have the signs out there. We underestimated, I think, what it would take to get them out there in the time that we wanted to get them done. But I think that the value...

1:35:05 That they add to the trails is worth it. Okay. So essentially our business matter here today is to make a motion and approve reimbursement not to exceed $500. Correct. I will make a motion that we reimburse MLTPA for the work done on this project in an amount not to exceed $500.

1:35:40 I'd like to see some discussion of this, first of all, to know exactly what all this means. Okay. You know, before we start making motions. I'll tell you what all this is. I just want to be clear on abstaining on this one. Oh, right. Yes, I guess you should. I'll go ahead and second it just so that we can have a discussion then. Sandy, you want to start? Well, yeah, I'd just like to know, you know, what all does this mean? And field verification, I heard that Steve field verified, said it was great.

1:36:10 You know, I mean, there are things that... So, Sandy, are you asking... I'm asking these steps. What does it mean? Who does it? Who makes the signs? Who installs them? Who does, you know, that cost? And it sounds like a herd that the signs were made by Friends of the Inyo and the signs were installed by Friends of the Inyo. Is that correct? Friends of the Inyo on the SOS? Yeah? Let's let them speak. A lot of the signs were installed as part of summer stewardship project days. There were other days that we went out and installed.

1:36:43 I think it was a joint effort, really, in terms of, we made the signs, we routed the signs and purchased the materials for the signs, but in terms of sign placement, sign wording, sign, all of the behind the scenes that go into making the signs, it was definitely a joint effort, and John put in a lot of time, MLTPA put in a lot of time to make sure that those signs came together.

1:37:09 I guess I just look at the cost. It's the same issue that when we discussed winter grooming last year, and I heard a lot of nickel and diming about the executive director of Mammoth Nordic and the fact that they were charging $32 an hour to give us groomed trails. Frankly, these are the same issues to me. It's the cost.

1:37:31 Well, let's let John speak to it, and I've got some comments that might satisfy your concerns as well, but John, go ahead. Yeah, I just want to echo what Laura said. I mean, the idea to do these temporary signs came forward in kind of a let's get something done this summer spirit. Friends of Inyo and us, we certainly stepped up and said, okay, we'll do what we can to make this work. You get into the reality of the project. They probably had more costs involved in making, physically making the signs. We, working at the direction of your staff,

1:38:00 Provided messaging documents, provided placement documents, did the kind of things that we did working with the town and the forest service, placing all the signs along the lakes basin path, we provided those services. I provided those services to the direction of the staff, assuming, of course, that this was going to be worked out at some point. I think as a precedent going forward, I think you want to make sure that if your staff is directing people to do things, encourage people to get things done, that, and there's a

1:38:26 There's an implication of reimbursement that that's going to happen. If you guys say you don't want to reimburse us for things that we did, don't, in the future, don't expect that these things are going to happen because it's, I can't, I can't eat this. I mean, the friends of Inyo, they are generously offering to do this. You know, we can't, I can't establish a precedent that says, here's direction, go do some work, and then, by the way, when it comes back to the committee, we're not going to reimburse you for what you did. That's just not a good precedent to go into.

1:38:56 Thank you. Bill? Thank you. Since we brought up the grooming program, I actually don't recall anybody having a problem with the $32 an hour they wanted to charge the groom. I had a problem with us giving a flat rate of $20,000 for their season of grooming, which is what we ended up doing. It is what not has been asked for here. What's been asked for here is reimbursement for the field review and placement of the signs, the messaging development, what's going to be on the signs,

1:39:23 Distribution of the schedule, where the signs are going and everything else, I think it's well worth the time. We have Steve talking as a member of the public telling us that the signs, because they were reviewed for placement and put in the right places, are working fine. $57 an hour is a billable rate. I have no problem with that. If we want to discuss what the billable rate is, we can go there.

1:39:49 But my concern with the Mammoth Nordic was not the billable rate. In fact, you'll recall what I said was I would like to pay them that an hour for every hour that they worked, not for $20,000 in a two-month period of time. It wasn't your comments, Bill. Bill, I want to bring this back to just the business matter at hand. And actually, if I can speak to this, because I attended the meeting with John Kazimirski and John Wentworth.

1:40:17 Specifically talking about the opportunities that we had with regard to having volunteers place these signs. John Wentworth, I remember your comments very specifically concerned that temporary signs might turn into permanent signs. So let's make sure we do this right. What this committee is charged with doing is putting signs in the ground that are going to be permanent.

1:40:40 Public Education and Outreach Signs, as we just discussed in our previous business matter, about what our strategies are or priorities or funding are. I was the one that actually said, I think that $500 or not to exceed would be well worth the ability to get them done this summer to have volunteers put them on the ground during summer of stewardship days. And I don't think I was speaking, you know, without...

1:41:06 Ahead of myself with regard to what this committee needs to recommend and approve. However, considering we just approved earlier this year $84,000 for seven permanent signs, that the ability to only spend $500, or not to exceed, again, with some critical signs. And I'm somebody who rides the...

1:41:28 Uptown, Downtown, with my son just yesterday, actually. And being able to sign that directs me from, that keeps me on a free path, so that keeps me off of Mammoth Mountain ski areas maintained Uptown, Downtown, and having it placed by volunteers was well worth it.

1:41:45 So I think there was something that was done in good faith by MLTPA and Friends of the Inyo, and we're being asked to reimburse for those funds that they put together for the Summer of Stewardship here. So again, just only considering this business matter at hand, you know, I hear your concerns, but at the same time, I think what we are needing to discuss here is something that actually is a pretty minimal, and it sounds like they put in an additional $1,500 that were not being billed back. Friends of the Inyo did, yes, that's correct.

1:42:12 That's correct. They did. And I guess what I'm saying is, John, this is not, if we can talk about this, okay? I'm just trying to make the point that what I've seen in the past, and Bill, they weren't your comments. As a matter of fact, they were yours and Bill's going back and forth about the cost of grooming or whatever. And I was using that as an example because I've seen the same standards applied to the Friends of the Inyo, making them jump through hoops, give twice the information or whatever.

1:42:38 But something that MLTPA comes up with, and John says he was directed to do it by Steve, which I doubt he was directed to do it by Steve. These are the kind of things I think what I'm saying is for the future, I want more scrutiny, a lot more scrutiny, not just for friends of the Inyo and not just for Mammoth Nordic or for somebody else. Let's have a level playing field. I'm saying what I heard and I recall was the cost of having an executive director go out and do the grooming himself rather than hire somebody.

1:43:08 You know, less to do it. And I'm looking at these costs. That's what I'm saying. I'm just, I'm willing to vote for this, but I want the point to be recorded that we need a level playing field. I've said this on a number of occasions. Favoritism doesn't cut it for me. Let's move this on because we need to move this business better forward. Okay, but I just want to make that point. Okay, because at $57 an hour,

1:43:36 That's pretty expensive, but okay, and as far as if there's field verification of signage placement in place, don't go duplicating. Sandy, thank you. We've got a motion and a second, I believe. All those in favor of, yep, let me just make sure I'm saying this correctly. Yeah, reimbursement. All those in favor of approving the MLTPA proposal for reimbursements of funds related to temporary sign messaging, let's have a roll call, please, Steve.

1:44:09 You don't have to have a roll call. I'm going to vote yes. Stu Brown? Yes. Sandy Hogan? Yes. Bill Souser? Yes. Vice Chairman Bill Taylor? Abstain. Thank you. And Chairman Sean Turner? Yes. Sean, one more point. This will go before the rec commission as well as all others, I'm assuming. Thank you very much for reminding me of that. Yes, it will. So I assume it will. It needs to go as a commercial side. So I think what we'll just do is we'll just blend these two emergency items because they're related to funding in front of the commission tomorrow. Packages is one. Okay. That's a good idea.

1:44:40 Thank you. That's the emergency item two. Okay, number seven. Number seven is discuss winter grooming programs 551 and 552, as well as the Lakes Basin early opening and late fall closure 571. There is no staff report. No staff report. It's just the... And Steve, at this time, we haven't received any correspondence back from Mammoth Nordic. Is that correct on...

1:45:14 Yeah, that's correct. For the record, I've made numerous attempts to get in touch directly with Mammoth Nordic and they have all been negative. I've also made attempts to work through a secretary, I think is the proper title, for Mammoth Nordic and she has not been able to reach Mammoth Nordic either. Mammoth Nordic is in default on their

1:45:42 Presentation of their Measure R Performance Report for last year. And again, we regret that we have had no communication and no correspondence with Mammoth Nordic recently. Has the Forest Service heard anything at all? I haven't directly. I'm not sure if John Kazmierski had tried to reach him before he went on his detail. And so I can follow up after this meeting because certainly we'd like to know what's going on as well.

1:46:11 Does he operate under a special use permit? Agreement, yeah. Yes, okay. So that would be helpful to know. Because perhaps he doesn't, you know, plan to request funding. But in any case, I think we have a requirement that a performance report has to be filed. So perhaps it would sure be nice to have the grooming whether or not we pay for it or not. And if I may, I'd like to see us

1:46:39 Keep that allocation there regardless whether he qualifies for it or not. As we've said in the past, there are more than one ways to get something done. If we have to send out an RFP or maybe lease our own machine or do something else and hire the people to do it, there are ways to get this program done. So if today's discussion is about whether or not we should keep the funding in place, I certainly think we should and start looking for other avenues

1:47:10 To accomplish it. That is a non-profit. It has to have a board besides just a leader. We have talked before about leasing their machine for a season. Maybe their board would be in a position to now allow us to pursue that contract and hire a part-time employee. And I can think of a couple who have worked on that particular program in the past who I think would be willing to do it again.

1:47:39 To perform the grooming tasks. So I'd like to see us leave it there. For me, it was never about the organization. It was about getting the job done. So that would be my comment on moving that forward. I think we need to move it forward. I think it is an important program, not just in grooming for Nordic skiing, but grooming, period. That's part of the snow management program that I've been asking us to take on as a whole.

1:48:07 And working with the Forest Service and other partners in the forest that already perform grooming. So for us to step up to the plate and become the necessary partner if that's what it takes to get this service performed. I'm just going to direct a question to Sarah quickly. So if the town was looking at taking over those operations, what type of permits would we be looking at? Time? I mean, is it something realistic we could look at this season? Or what would be some challenges we'd have to?

1:48:38 Well, I would think we would probably want to address it sooner rather than later because winter's coming up. And so certainly for us, this is something that we're going to need to figure out what level of effort we could put in, if any, because we want to be able to provide that service. But we have some restrictions on the funding that we could use. So I think we would probably want to look at if Brian is no longer in the picture, if we'd want to mimic what sort of agreement we had with him.

1:49:04 But I'm actually in the process of sending an email right now about it so that I can get on this because I do think we want to be able to provide you all with either information about Mammoth Nordic, if we have any, and if not, what other options we have. So to me it's definitely a priority to get some answers for you. And as far as where we go from there and how much time it would take, I think that remains to be seen. So maybe staff in this next month could...

1:49:33 Just work with Sarah and try and kind of fill in those blanks and come back. And we can either agendize it or give you an update. Give you an update at the next meeting. I think that might be a good recommendation. You know, being someone who's been involved with user groups like this before and watched them come and go in Mammoth, and they always do, there is another Nordic group out there as well, and maybe we could encourage them, as we've done in the past, for those two to merge to create the necessary nexus to get the job done.

1:50:03 As well, there's just, there's a lot of players and a lot of ways to deal with this. And I'd be willing to put in a little of my own time making some of those calls. I'd agree. I tried to, on my own, to get them communicating a little bit. I just don't seem to. I know, but it'd be great. That's a good idea. I think your point is well taken about for now at least leaving the line item in place because it would be an RFP. And I think that that's part of our new strategy is really looking at the position, not the person.

1:50:31 That we are looking to fill. It goes beyond that. And you guys have heard me say it over and over. This is something we want to take on. We need to look at what's the best, most cost-effective way to do it. This is giving us the opportunity to take one piece and look at does it have to be an RFP or can we in-house through the rec department funded with this bit of funding.

1:50:56 Lease the machinery and put a body in it to get the grooming done. Can I ask a question with regard to that, you know, with regard to the machine, the equipment itself, because that some of it was funded, actually I'm going to ask for clarification on this, with Measure R dollars. The town does not... No, it was never. No, it was privately. Thank you very much. The town would have to...

1:51:20 You know, take on the liability insurance and maintenance and costs and everything. And we've made that offer before. We did two years ago. We had a similar proposal. Thank you for reminding me. You could just revisit that. So I would agree. Let's leave that one and see what works out. And, you know, perhaps they decide they're going to do it as volunteers. I don't know. But can we agree to make that a priority so that we can get busy working on this? We only have about three months before grooming season.

1:51:47 Well, and it obviously needs to be placed much sooner than that. So what we're asking here is that we are going to agendize this for discussion at our next meeting, which will be the first in October. It was one year we started back on the 6th. We'll do some research ahead of time for that. So yes, we're not taking any action. No action. Do we need to discuss lake space in early opening? Lake closing? How about lake closing? 5-71. Sorry.

1:52:16 You know, I think we did. What we discussed was Mr. Searles brings this up every year to us dutifully because of the trash and bear issues that it creates in the Lakes Basin. I told him this would be on the agenda and here he is. So I'd like us to talk about it some and maybe to this point I think what we've heard from the Forest Service is

1:52:44 That if we pay them for full staff that they will then open those. And I'm just curious if there's another way or locations where we could pay just to have the dumpsters dumped without hiring necessary staff to go along with that and maids or whatever is necessary for those bathrooms. One of the reasons I asked Steve is because he knows the areas in the basin.

1:53:10 Where those spot efforts could do us the most good in terms of needing bathrooms and trash open, as he's the one that views it personally every year. Yeah, I'd like to discuss this a little bit further as well, but do we need any kind of briefing from Steve, or are we already fully into discussion? Steve Searles, not Steve Spidell. You are correct. Thank you. Do we know what the cost of the dumpsters per week is? Because we probably have to contract directly with Mammoth Disposal for those.

1:53:37 So we'd have to put somebody up there, or the foresters would have to put somebody up there to coordinate that. Right. And so I guess the problem I'm having, and it's the same one I had last year, was I have no idea what this might cost. Nobody really laid out a program. For instance, when do the water systems shut down up there?

1:53:57 I actually don't know that, but any sort of detailed information that you need after today, I can get to you. So whatever information you might need to determine whether it's something that you all would take on or potentially fund us to keep a crew on, we can talk about that, but I would have to get into some details that I don't have on me. Do you know if, I mean, there are, in addition to the restrooms that are on the water system,

1:54:25 There are a number of restrooms that are vaults, and I'm assuming that the district maintains those up until the snow flies, and then Tamarack, I think, maintains them after that. Maybe you could look into that, but there are at least two, maybe three restrooms up there that are open year-round that are maintained. So just trying to understand what we're actually getting, because at some point, even if it doesn't snow, it turns cold and the water system has to be shut down.

1:54:54 So we can't keep all the campground restrooms open until such time as it snows. In fact, there probably needs to be several week lead time, even in a normal winter, to get everything buttoned up. So it's not just as simple as, oh yeah, we'll keep it open a couple of weeks. No, and I understand that, which is part of why I've had these conversations with Mr. Searles before. Where is the need the greatest? What is he seeing that's happening? Because he is our ambassador up there.

1:55:22 on almost a daily basis when the roads open. I'd love to get on the dumpsters. Yes.

1:55:27 Let's get some answers right now. This causes a lot of, I'm just speaking as a resident, but I am up there every day. It causes a lot of concern, a lot of anxiety every year. I think I understand about draining the system and not having the pipes blow up.

1:55:53 I'm not aware of the bathrooms in the last two years that were open at all in the Lakes Basin, straight drops, and signage has been my recommendation every year so that people that are flagging me down, when they walk up to the restroom and they have the need to use the restroom, that there's a polite note of what's going on, why it's locked, they're extremely frustrated. It really puts a bad impression on our visitors and guests.

1:56:19 And maybe something as simple as a map to where a restroom is and where they could use it might be helpful for a lot of our guests. As far as the trash cans go, again, I understand the logistics. I understand that there's not very much trash.

1:56:36 That goes into the dumpsters. I encourage them to leave the dumpsters open all year round. I don't think you would fill any one dumpster so that people can responsibly throw their trash away as they're recreating up there. Because they're not owned by the local trash company, they're actually owned by the Forest Service.

1:56:55 When I work inside the community on projects, for instance, Mammoth Mountain Housing, where there isn't anybody staying there for part of the year, we have the dumpster removed and yarded so that people don't illegally dump. The same thing here, when the tourists walk up and it's literally bolted shut, a bear-proof dumpster in perfect condition, it's really, really frustrating for the home or the guest.

1:57:21 The people that I've caught illegally dumping on top are next to the dumpster. When I quiz them on it, their frustration level is greater than the offense itself. How can you bolt a dumpster shut? It's a dumpster. So they really don't get it. If we can't afford to keep the dumpsters open, which with money being a crunch, I got it, the staffing being a crunch, I understand all the logistics.

1:57:51 Then if we could just get the forks to yard those dumpsters, then they wouldn't pile their trash alongside from the top of the dumpster out of frustration because they don't have pliers to unbolt the dumpster. So having them out there roadside.

1:58:06 Steve. Steve.

1:58:30 Once the campground is closed, because they're closed when the bathrooms have to be blown out, and before they are open in the spring, are there some locations that are visited so much more than others that the dump service and the toilet service might be best there in terms of scaling down from what the normal Forest Service operation can be? If we did a dumpster at Lake Mamie and at Lake, those sites are...

1:58:59 Again, sure, I'll be glad to map it out for you, help it in any way you want, but our hands are pretty well tied for what bathrooms are hard plumbed versus dropped bathrooms. That's not an option. The dumpsters are well placed throughout the lakes basin. It's just that they're bolted shut. So ones that you're going to leave, unbolt them, let people use them. Ones that you're not going to have there, remove them and yard them in the old boneyard or somewhere that's convenient in the lakes basin so that people stop doing it.

1:59:28 So, Steve, if we got the Forest Service to leave those unbolted, and since you're there on a daily basis anyway, and I know you are, in your regular tours, if one started getting full, would you be willing to call in for a dump if we allocated the funds to pay for that dump? I'd call in those services, broken dumpsters, on a regular basis. In the Forest Service, it's on my list. I think I better wait until Item 9 to speak to that. But I'm sure, again, I'll help in any way I can.

1:59:58 Again, I think it's, you guys work on such big projects, huge amounts of money, on huge multi-year tasks. This seems to be a really simple thing that causes a lot of grief year after year after year. Trash blowing in the lake, it's just, it's the worst thing.

2:00:17 So I think we've got two issues here, the bathrooms and the dumpsters that are of concern. And so something that I was actually noticed when I was up there even over Labor Day weekend that one of the three bathrooms that were up there were locked. And I was just curious, even on Labor Day weekend, this was up actually at Horseshoe Lake at the very top. And I was just wondering why that one bathroom was locked. Do you know?

2:00:45 Not specifically, no. I don't know individual bathrooms, but I know sometimes it's a maintenance issue, and sometimes I know that there was recently...

2:00:56 A bathroom where a member of the public I think got locked into it and so I'm not sure if it was that one but if that was the case certainly until we had an opportunity to repair it it's probably much safer to close it but generally speaking it would be because there was something wrong with the restroom and it needed to be repaired and so we would close it to the public.

2:01:15 Okay. And I think Steve is correct, in my opinion, is that the frustration level, because I was watching people, you know, really pounding on the door, upset, and unfortunately there were two other bathrooms within sight and walking distance, but I was just watching this happen. But signs on the doors? So there wasn't a sign? I mean, typically we do sign them when they're out of order, so all I could think would be that there was...

2:01:42 Either a sign there that went missing, and we do have people going out there all the time, so my assumption is that if there's a sign that was there that was missing, they would replace it. The other thing I could think would be if it was an immediate closure for some reason, for some maintenance or safety issue, and they decided to close it and didn't have a sign on them, that it would be something they would have to go out there and put on later.

2:02:04 Unfortunately, I see a lot of signs on bathrooms around Forest Service land that say out of order. So I know that we do, the intention is to sign them if we have to close them for whatever reason, whether it's temporary or long term. I would, just for a little history, we did used to have a lot of campgrounds up there, but in the mid-90s when we had all of the issues surrounding the CO2 or whatever, we closed and removed campgrounds.

2:02:32 We have plenty of bathrooms. We actually have an excess of bathrooms up there, I believe. And so some of them have been permanently closed for many years, I believe, just because otherwise you have a maintenance person doing, in other words, cleaning a toilet because one person used it. And so I think probably some permanent, the idea of maps and signs showing permanently closed or maybe just a big red sign permanently closed.

2:02:56 I have a feeling that's what's happened because there are so many of them up there. Thanks. That actually makes sense. I don't have some of the history, but it would make sense that with a lot of our declining budget, if we weren't able to make up for that staff, that our option would be to try to limit the number of restrooms we clean. Yeah, exactly. And typically in a lot of the, you know, concessionaire campgrounds, the concessionaires do that on the off days, you know, when they lock a couple of them so that they don't have to clean everyone, you know, and that's just.

2:03:25 You know, trying to be efficient about it. So in that one you might want to just, you know, consult with the staff and see even on Labor Day how many do they need. They probably could close about, I guess, almost a half dozen up. And I'm talking just about horseshoe because that's where the excess is. Providing that they're putting signs up saying where the others are. Exactly. I like the idea of the signs and the maps and the, you know. People won't find them. Yeah, because nobody knows that. A lot of people don't know that. The other question that I would have just for my own information in dealing with this as we go through the fall, do you guys have a map?

2:03:55 Where you have pits versus the flush toilets, what's on system and what is SST? I'm sure that our facilities engineers do. I think there are only three vaults up there. There's one at George. There's one right next to where the Lake George outlet enters Lake Mary. And then there's one over right above the waterfall of Twin Lakes.

2:04:20 I think those are the only three. No, there's another one also at the far side of Lake Mary. Did you mention that one? Far side of Lake Mary? Right by the Lake George outlet where it comes down and flows into the lake. Yeah, okay. Those are the three. Now, if you happen to be at the Duck Pass Trailhead, none of those are terribly convenient. But I think those, I mean, I know they're open in the winter, and I know they don't freeze. They close up when the mountain closes because the responsibility that the mountain has to maintain them goes away.

2:04:50 And it's my understanding that then they get locked and they don't get reopened until the Forest Service brings on board either their part-time summer health or in the fall. What about Tamarack? Don't they take care of them? In the wintertime. Only in the winter. What happens between... The problem is the transition. Yeah, exactly. And I know what happens in the spring. You know what happens in the fall. Same thing. When the concessionaires go away, I believe all the bathrooms are locked.

2:05:17 When the Forest Service gets rid of their seasonal employees, and I understand that. But for those pit bathrooms, it seems to me there has to be some way we could pay to keep them open in the interim without engaging a whole bunch of staff. Because those aren't concessionaire. I believe those are Forest Service staff. And the same thing for the dumpsters. If we have someone willing to do the pipping around up there,

2:05:46 What it costs to dump a couple of dumpsters between opening of the road, which is usually Memorial Day, and the middle to end of June when the campgrounds are open isn't going to be all that much. Well, this is a pretty important subject. We've learned just in past falls just how as

2:06:06 John Urdi would say if you were here that we're getting bad experience with our guests who are critical. So I think that you brought up the subject, Bill, of how are we going to pay for this if the Forest Service is unable or, no offense, unwilling to pay for all these different bathrooms or dumpsters. This is pretty critical because it is leaving our guests with bad experiences. I really, really like something that Steve

2:06:35 Well, I liked a lot of what Steve said, but particularly the idea of yarding the dumpsters. I took a trip up to the North Coast, and the state parks, of course, are having major problems, and they just pulled most of the trash cans out and said, haul your trash out. And, you know, for the most part, people were doing it. There wasn't a place where they felt they were entitled to dump it. That's the issue, isn't it? Entitled to dump it. So once that's gone,

2:07:05 Then I think people wouldn't feel like they could just throw it anywhere in the woods. But when they see a dumpster, they think, yeah, that's good. So I don't know what it would cost to move them all over to the old borrow pit there behind horseshoe for the winter and then put them back out when the campground's open, but it seems like that's something that one guy with a set of forks could do in a day.

2:07:31 Would that be something that if we funded it should be done? I'm sure we can look into it. We're certainly, just to be clear, the Forest Service recognizes that the town has an interest in extending the season and I think we've said repeatedly that we're certainly willing to work with you on that and if we can't...

2:07:51 Afford to do it, then we want to work with you on alternate ways to make that happen. So I think just getting into the specifics and the conversations about what our options are is where we're at right now. Perhaps we could put together a list of the questions we need to get answered for our next meeting. You know, that's going to be October 7th.

2:08:13 So, you know, we're already kind of pushing. Can we come up with a list right now? Well, and I guess that's fine. Yeah, let's do that. We'd like to know what it would cost to yard those dumpsters. We've got a couple of comments from the audience. I'll ask you to keep your comments brief. And then, yeah, let's put together that list of questions now, if we could. Sure. Just in the interest of avoiding any perception of scope creep, it might be interesting to look back at the Trail System Master Plan that specifically identifies trailheads.

2:08:40 of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. In the Lakes Basin, there are several, and trailheads are identified to have certain types of facilities to go with them. If you guys were to proceed with this, it would be a great thing to be able to notice those things on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System website, have that consistent with the identified trailheads, destinations, all the rest of it, so it works with the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. If you're going to put maps and things like that up on doors of bathrooms, probably use the Mammoth Lakes Trail System graphics.

2:09:05 So it's all consistent with the program we're talking about. I'd also be interested in knowing who's responsible for the dumpsters that Steve was alluding to. I don't know if that's the trail system's responsibility. Maybe whoever's responsible for those in the interest of following up at a good idea from Steve Searles and good wildlife management could move those things. I'm not exactly sure how that's the responsibility of the trail system. If you guys can provide a nexus and a rationale that makes all this make sense, then I think you're in good shape. Otherwise, I just threw that little scope flag.

2:09:33 Thank you. And I'd like to just be clear that I share virtually all of John's concerns on that, and I wasn't necessarily assuming that Measure R and our budget would pay for that. We may be developing and crafting a solution that helps our system users, but we may be looking back to the Council and the General Fund for money. Thank you very much for both those points. Steve Searles, did you have comment? No way.

2:10:05 Wanted to interrupt the meeting or that the meeting was just about the Mammoth Lakes Trail System or to imply that there was a connection there. I brought these issues in front of the council, in front of the media to Forest Service meetings. I was just trying another avenue. But I don't want this to be disruptive to your overall meeting in any way. You know what, this is critical and I'm really glad you're bringing it here. Frankly, if anything, this might be the best place to bring it forward, Steve. And that, you know, we'll...

2:10:33 Then shame other people into getting it paid for. You know, I say with love. But at the same time, you know, I think this is actually a great place to bring it forward. Let's get these identified. And it still could be Measure RRU. It could be. Yep. Outside of the trails. Sounds like we're not talking about this year then. Yeah. And the same thing came up last year. You know, and Skip Harvey was the one who really used to hammer on this in the council.

2:11:01 How many times did I hear him talk about our guests and the complaints up there? Same thing we're talking about. Now, we're two years later, and every fall we get to this point, and we've talked about it, these are Forest Service facilities, Steve, and they're ones that are closed by the Forest Service for budget reasons. And, I mean, we've known that, and we've talked about it, and, I mean, to me, we're talking about a very small amount of money to take care of our guests' complaints. Well, why are you saying we can't do it this year, then?

2:11:28 Well, because you're talking about Measure R and Measure U and going through a process and going back to the council, I mean, that's what I heard. Maybe I didn't hear that. Let's not be defeated too soon. Let's actually, you know, see what we can accomplish this year. And I think Bill's comment was, let's work on, let's identify some of these questions. Yeah, I mean, let's face it, pretty soon it'll be the snow on the ground and it'll be like, yeah. If we don't know what it costs. Yes.

2:11:54 Twelve months from now, we're going to be sitting in the same place asking the same questions. Yep. So I'd like to get it done next year. Yep. I don't think I have my notes. Certainly I'd like to be prepared to get it done next year. I know. Okay. So to move this subject forward, Sarah, I think we're going to put together a quick list of questions I think that we'd like to get answered certainly by October 7th. I don't know if it's realistic to try and do anything sooner. That's good. Okay.

2:12:20 Are we going to be able to, you know, even if we do get these identified, is October 7th, let's say that we get all our questions answered. I just want to do a timeline question here real quick. Are we going to be able to put together an action plan in place before you close the roads up there? And I know trying to predict when the roads are going to close is tough going. Well, more importantly, the camp roads.

2:12:47 In addition to that, our seasonal employees, when they leave is when we have to start cutting back our services. And I haven't seen, there's probably some staggered dates, but certainly I'm thinking potentially end of October, maybe sooner. Again, this is something, I'm sorry, this is something that Kaz would be able, John Kazmierski would be able to tell you off the top of his head, so.

2:13:13 Pat McGurvey, who's going to be, who's currently here as the acting recreation officer, is going to be my main point of contact on that, and he's going to be able to get this information. But off the top of my head, I don't know, but the point is a lot of it does have to do with the bodies and how long they've been hired on for and when they leave. So that's another piece of the puzzle. I think that one of the big questions that we need to ask by October 7 for the meeting here is,

2:13:41 When do the concessionaires plan on closing the campgrounds? Because that's the trigger that triggers everything else downhill from it. So that's going to be really important for us so we know what our operating is. And I think that by the 7th of October they will be closed. So normally the week after Labor Day is when they start closing them. Secondly, are the dumpsters compatible with the equipment that Mammoth Disposal has? Because I don't know what...

2:14:10 And a lot of times the Forest Service aren't because they're rear hook instead of fork. They operate on a different kind of trauma. We'll have to find out. So that's just one of the things. If we're developing a list of the things we need to know, I would love to know where the pit toilets are so that we can look over those and see if keeping those open versus the flush, see if we can keep those open between the mountains operation and the seasonal operation for the Forest Service.

2:14:37 With maps couldn't solve the bathroom issues. And what would it cost? And what would it cost? What would it cost to keep the toilet paper in there and cleaning it and maps? Yeah, exactly. I think that was, you know, where are they? When do they normally close? Because I don't know who maintains them right now. I think it's, I think it's Forest Service seasonals because I've seen the green truck over there. One of the things that Dennis Rotner mentioned was that one of his seasonals could be kept on. He could give us a cost to have his seasonal go up and maintain it.

2:15:05 You know, those are the kind of things that, but also... ...to have a seasonal go through the toilets. Yeah, and I would ask, what would it cost the Forest Service to have their engineering folks go up and do the yarding, whether it's one day or two days, you know, that's probably one of those costs that we ought to look at. Just to, so, and Steve, I know you're recording all these questions.

2:15:26 Hopefully, yes. Okay. Yeah. Because here's from September 26, 2012. The committee stated that it does not have the costs or information necessary to make any decisions about where assistance and facilities are most needed in the Lakes Basin. Bill Souser stated he does not think this is an MLTS matter and it should instead be addressed by the Recreation Commission. Well, you know, these are the kind of things every year. We need to do some action. Let's do some action. Yeah.

2:15:53 So that last question you just asked was what was the cost of either town or forest service to maintain these perhaps on a weekly basis? That way we know that if we go to October 20th and we go to October 30th, we know it's going to cost this much more. If they're, say, there are three or four kit toilets. Dubsters and toilets. Have one of the town seasonings go up and put the, you know, clean it and put the TP in. I think Steve's comment about the dumpsters triggered something with me.

2:16:22 I'm really interested in just removing them out. Except for maybe three of them that you leave open. Maybe. In other words, if there are ones near there by the pit toilets. Maybe you leave three open, try, you know, I don't know, you know, Sarah, the rec officer may not be thrilled with that, but maybe look at it as a pilot project, something like that. So what would it cost to remove all the dumpsters except the ones that are near pit or vault toilets that we hope to keep in place?

2:16:51 For the entire winter. Yep. Is that what yours were suggesting? Yep. And let's face it, once the snow comes, they can close them, you know. Dumpsters. Not the toilets. Not the toilets. Not lock them. Yeah, but just close them. Close them. With the beer-proof. Yeah, yeah. Caribbeaners, where the case may be. Yeah, something, whatever. The theory being that they would not fill to the brim. The theory being that they would not fill to the brim. Well, but if they're by the pit toilet, whoever is doing the maintenance on the toilet can check it. Yeah.

2:17:20 And if they need to call for a dump, they call for one. No, the dumpsters are done in the wintertime. Are you just saying dumpsters need to be removed? I'd lock them in the wintertime. Yeah, I'd lock them, yeah. Just do a pack it in, pack it out sign. I would lock them for the skiers. I would unbolt them for the opening of fishing season because I don't think they will fill between the opening of fishing season and when the road opens. And the opening of fishing season is a big trash event up there.

2:17:49 It's just, you know, you get over X number of people and the trash starts to pile. So that would be my... Since they're not driving, they're not driving a huge amount. Yep, that makes sense. Well, if I could, you know, one of the key things for me is also going to be the signage. So, you know, where we gate Lake Mary there just above...

2:18:10 Twin Lakes, or just even as you're starting up from there, that there is a big fat pack it in, pack it out sign. There are no dumpsters available beyond this point. So I guess the next question would be, what is the cost of a sign? Then you're really talking two signs because there's two.

2:18:29 What types of signs? True. And then I'm asking all these questions. What types of signs? What are they going to say? Is this temporary versus permanent signs that we're talking about? And it does need to say pack it in, pack it out because there are no dumpsters above at this point. Yeah. So I think we're also asking what kind of, what's the cost on these signs? What I propose to do is put together an email outlining a lot of this conversation and

2:18:58 Send it to the Forest Service from the committee, and then I'll CC the committee members so you're aware of what the points are, and if I've missed any or through Granta's case, don't, or if you want to add more to it, we can continue that conversation. That's fine. And then, you know, and Sandy, to your point, you know, I want this to happen this year. And if it doesn't, then, you know, at the very least, let's get it identified, because you're right, for the past two years that I've been here. Same thing. So let's not repeat that. Yeah, exactly. Yes.

2:19:28 Again, just to focus my points, it wasn't so much in the winter months, the cross-country skiers, which we should attend to them too, but it's from the...

2:19:42 Because the weather is unpredictable, the concessionaires that rent our campgrounds out are on a fixed schedule, Mother Nature is not. So, like I said, the campgrounds weren't open for opening day, but all the people came. So we weren't set up for them, and that's what caused the problem. The same thing, as they close down the concessionaires and they pull out of the campgrounds, they'll lock everything up and everything will start getting

2:20:12 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.

2:20:29 Late opening, early closing is where we're having the biggest problems. If I may, the same thing as you're going down this list that we might look to the Forest Service or whoever can help. There's other things and the, for instance, barricading all the campgrounds is each

2:20:50 Concessionaire locks up his own campground. We all see it. They barricade him shut. When I help with the parking issues up there every day, here are, you know, campgrounds with huge areas to park, to sit on a picnic bench, to go fish, to unload your bicycles, and they're all barricaded shut. I get that question all the time. Why can't we park there? We own it. It's a campground. It's closed. We understand that we can't camp there, but why can't we use it for parking? Because there is no parking.

2:21:20 And so that causes a big problem. If you could put that on your laundry list of questions, this has come up over the last few years.

2:21:29 With all the frustration of the people up there. Again, what we recently, town staff did an inventory of all the signs that have been blasted over in the last two years that are laying on the ground up there. I think signage is important. We sure have learned about that, that they continue to lay in the dirt. Is it free to put them back up? No, but an eight-foot, four-by-four post, an hour of your time to re-bolt the thing up there and put it up is, again,

2:21:57 A speck of sand in the comparison of the challenges you guys have and the amount of money that you fund out there. Again, I have other things on here. I'll leave it to rest. But we've had to tolerate the horse crossing signs and the horses smoking a bong. I think that was funny for about a week. And so how many thousands or tens of thousands of visitors saw that pre-approved, a brand new bicycle trail,

2:22:26 Prettiest Place in the World, and all the horses are smoking bombs. I just, I find it incredible, and again, it's not a, the reason I bring this up is not to pick on somebody or make somebody feel bad, but these aren't money issues, they all seem to have a common thing of just maintenance issues. We've spent millions of dollars, we've all seen the horse smoking the bomb, and blame me too, I didn't stop it.

2:22:51 You know, stand on the top of my truck and pull it off. But every, you know, quarter mile, we see something that's not the end of the world, but why is it laying on the ground? Why is it beat up when we're spending this kind of money? And so I think that we, again, it's the most beautiful place. Everybody's done a super great job and cooperated, but boy, oh boy, it's a whole bunch of tiny things that seem to be really causing a lot of frustration in the lakes.

2:23:19 And certainly embarrass me as a local. Okay. So, Steve, what I just heard you say is who's responsible for putting signs back up and who's maintaining them? Well, it sounds like what we're really talking about is funding like an office or partially funding perhaps through a CCS, a challenge cost share, you know, maintenance type of thing where people are checking signs and, you know, cleaning the toilets and restocking and checking the dumpsters or whatever and whether it would be the town.

2:23:47 You know, coming through the town staff if they have the seasonal lawn or funding a forest service. Well, I think that's what we're looking at investigating. And I think actually noting all of those things really helps. Because one person can do that. It doesn't have to be a money guy. Yeah. Kittredge Sports adopts this toilet. Gets to put their sign up that it's ours for the shoulder season. There's just ways to do it. We'll get that done by October. If we can just kind of keep this discussion point going. I think what we need to then start, or Steve Spidell, what you suggested then is.

2:24:16 I started an email thread here that does kind of elaborate on these questions because I know I'm going to come up with additional ones. You just asked why can't people park in the campgrounds. I don't know if that's a question that you'd be able to answer now or perhaps find an answer for us by October 7th. Let's think about it. Find out. We're best going to let us answer that. All of these questions really take a little bit more investigation on my part, but we can certainly answer all of your questions.

2:24:42 I don't know if they'll all be satisfying answers, but we'll do our best. I mean, our hope is to be partners in making sure that we're providing the best kind of recreation opportunities we can, but we also have our own limitations. And then just to speak to Steve's comment about maintenance, I mean, that's a problem we have across the board, and that's why any time any entity wants us to put together a new trail, we always remind them.

2:25:06 There's more than just developing. There's also the cost of maintenance and making it a sustainable thing. So we just have to keep in mind that it would be great if we had all the time and money and people in the world that we could go out there and fix every single sign as it breaks. But that's why we rely on partners to help us get that work done. So that's why, of course, we're amenable to talking about solutions.

2:25:30 Thank you for your time. If Steve can include me on that email thread, I have a list of other small items that I think are part and parcel to the bigger conversation. Could be included in that job, in that position, yeah.

2:25:44 Can you write down your address one? That's a good idea. Let's move this subject on because this... No, but I was going to compliment him on it. And I just want to say for the public that if anyone wants to have any additional comments, they can forward that to the MLTSC coordinator. Thank you. Also, I'll remind you that there is another item on number seven was 552, which is the winter grooming Shady Rest Trailhead to Sherwin.

2:26:11 Road Borrow Pit. Thank you, Steve. I was looking for that. Which page is that? It's on the last page. Page four from five, third item down. And it also has discussion for use of the trail number 203. You know, and that's... So any other item, just, Sandy, if I could just clarify, on business matter number seven is discussing 552. Is that correct?

2:26:35 No, I think there are a couple of others. Well, number seven was 551, 552, and 571. We have discussed 551 and 571. We have not discussed 552. Okay. I've got to give a little bit of history here. My suggestion is that we do, if we're going to be discussing this, that we probably do it sometime during this winter. Bill and I can go over a lot of history on this, I'm sure. And it's the type of thing where the Forest Service obviously would have to be very much involved.

2:27:05 As far as the, especially if you're talking about winter grooming and motorized versus non-motorized use or whatever, it's a big subject. I was going to ask, is this non-motorized only or is it both? This is, no, to me this is both motorized. If this goes back to the one that I wanted to add to our list, being the opening of the tunnel and the council has passed resolutions in the past at least once, I think twice.

2:27:36 Telling staff to do whatever is necessary to get that open for snowmobiles. It never went anywhere. It's in the trail system master plan as a multi-use trail. So I think this is a multi-use winter trail would be my take and the grooming of it. What's happened in past winters is that the snow removal off of 203 has just blown drifts down.

2:28:05 Into that area and block the tunnel. So nobody's been using it. It's been literally de facto blocked. I think it's always been shown as non-motorized by the Forest Service. So, you know, that was the issue. It's a big subject. I would think that that's the kind of thing we're going to have to defer to the Forest Service for whenever you're ready to discuss it. Because I just know from my history with it and Bill's history with it, we know it's a big subject. And the Forest Service was going to lay out a plan.

2:28:34 And staff at one point was directed to go down the trail to see what that plan would do and what it was going to take and it never went anywhere from there. So it is hugely important from my standpoint that the two open areas be legally connected. It could be linked to the Shady Rest decision also. Well, the trailhead decision, it's very...

2:29:04 As far as the plan of action goes, is this something that there's no dollar amount assigned to this. Obviously, we're going to leave it on the tracking list. Is this something that we want to put out a scope of work for an RFP? Is this something that we can even discuss right now? Doesn't the Trail System Master Plan include this area as one of the areas to be addressed through the summit process? For a winter use.

2:29:34 So I think if we want to do something, unless you have something else in mind, I think... No, I wasn't even looking at it really as grooming. To me it was just the opening of the tunnel and marking a route so that if you're staying, again, at the RV park or if you launch at Shady Rest, you have access to the available riding area without having to ride illegal.

2:30:01 The four-laning of 203 is what necessitated this. In the past, we were able to cross 203. I know most of you haven't been here that long, but it's painful being this old. It is. But that's why it became illegal for us to just cross 203, and then it became an issue. And then going through the path across the, I believe, across the RV park, shown as non-motorized, so therefore, in other words, there's a lot of issues that...

2:30:31 It's exactly, it's the winter summit. John Wentworth, did you have a comment before we kind of decide on a plan of action? Sure, very good comment. To Sandy and Bill's points both, this has been a long and complex issue for the community. When the trail system master plan process was in full swing, camp winter, camp summer, lots of public input, some of the best consultants in the country, good town staff, everybody working on this thing, it was specifically deemed that this kind of process was worthy of something called a summit.

2:30:59 And it is addressed specifically in the Trail System Master Plan. And it's a great thing to take on. It's an extremely important issue. But it's the kind of thing that I think personally, from our perspective, MLTPA's perspective perhaps, get a little bit of money together, put together a process that's going to bring forward some specific recommendations and ideas based on the history, based on things that have happened.

2:31:22 Don't try to hash this out in front of a committee. The Brett Commissioner messed up this for years and nothing ever seemed to work. But it's in the Trust System Master Plan. That's a specific recommendation. I would encourage you guys to put some dollars aside and figure out a way to start going down that road. Thank you. Okay. I don't know if there's much more we can do with it. Nope. I think not. I agree. Do we want to have staff outline what the process would be and an approximate cost?

2:31:56 Yeah, I think that that would be fair. I think so. You think we're ready to take this one on? We ought to ask if the Forest Service – Well, I mean, I think first again, the number one question is, is there a showstopper out there? I mean, if it's – if the Forest Service, for whatever reason, if it doesn't comply with their rules and regulations, then we're kind of done.

2:32:19 You know, again, this is another place I'd have to do some research, but Sandy made reference to the Shady Rest Staging Area, EA, and that one's on hold right now, and I'm not being familiar with how that connects to this decision. I think the most important thing would be to see if engaging in that process is actually the right place to address this versus waiting to see what the decision is and seeing how to move forward from there. So to me, that's the first question that comes to my mind.

2:32:47 How is that decision tied to this? Is there a place to address it within there? And if not, do we need to wait until that decision is signed before we know the best way to move forward? It would be, to me, inefficient to start working on this if that decision really is going to impact how that system connects to underneath 203. Well, and included in all of that, just because I inherited it when I came here, it'll open up issues like in the Knolls to try to get rid of snowmobile access.

2:33:16 It was opened up in the 80s finally. I mean, those are the kind of things, if it's a winter access, in other words, a winter summit, you would want to take on all of those issues, just as camp did for the summer, whatever. So it's a big deal. It's not just this one project, and it is linked. And just realize there's a lot of history there. Bill knows what I both know. And internally, I mean, there were disagreements internally how to handle it when I was with the forester. So, I mean, it's not an easy button.

2:33:45 Is there any kind of a timeline for the staging area, the Shady Rest staging area process? We're actually going to be having a meeting about our program of work for the coming fiscal year, and I'm sure the on-hold projects will be brought up and discussed as to where they fit into next year's program of work. So the answer right now is no. And also I think the Shady Rest decision may be contingent on where the CD4...

2:34:11 Project falls. So I think there are just some complicating factors there to keep in mind. So it is something that could be a while before all those pieces are really understood. That's right. That's being appealed at this point, as I understand. So again. We haven't entered, officially entered the appeal period, but we have had different agencies tell us that they do plan on appealings. Right. Or bodies. Yeah. Time to discuss it proudly. So the process with this is going to be that

2:34:40 Well, what is the process? You said you were going to look into the questions that are surrounding the winter grooming around the Shader, Australia? Yeah, and actually, let me just correct something I just said. We are in the appeal period for CD4, but it hasn't ended yet, and we haven't received any appeals, so I want to clarify that. And then the process for this particular agenda item...

2:35:04 We can answer whatever questions you have. If the questions are what in the Forest Service opinion is it that really should be determined first and what the potential time frame is that before we would be ready and willing to move on to this topic, I can certainly get that information for you. But to me, having a better understanding of what those complexities and outstanding questions are before you want to move forward into another planning process, that to me is the first step.

2:35:31 So I can certainly by October 7 come back to you with our estimation of at least in the Forest Service's opinion the questions and decisions that may be outstanding that would potentially be beneficial to wait for before you start tackling this. And then if there are any other policies or regulations that would also impact this, I can certainly get that information for you as well. Does that sound like a good plan to all eyes and go on?

2:35:59 I think they're probably strapped for time. You've got a bunch of actings in place. To me, the urgency bill knows how complex this will be. I mean, it's going to be a biggie. I hate to lay a lot of homework on you when my sense is this is a big conversation to have. And I agree with John. I think it is a part of that winter summit, and it does open up a lot of stuff. So before we kind of...

2:36:26 I'm happy to answer basic questions, but I do think that what Sandy's saying in the bigger picture is one of the things that we often talk about when working on projects in coordination with the town is that we need it to be an appropriate mix of our priorities as well as yours. And so I think having a better understanding of how much this is a priority of the town and how that fits in with our current priorities and workloads.

2:36:54 Before you move on to really tackling a big project, I think we want to take a look at the bigger picture because just in reference to the conversation about the lakes basin, we keep hearing every year that the lakes basin is an issue in terms of extending the seasons, and we're happy to do that, but it takes both sides making that a priority, and again, I think that's something that's doable more in the short term.

2:37:18 These longer-term projects, they're certainly something we can start talking about, but keeping in mind that we all need to be aware of what the most important priorities are to your group and how that fits in with our priorities and scheduling. Anytime we deal with a motorized versus non-motorized, there's a segment in town that wants to stop one from happening.

2:37:44 So unless we are going to say that the Mammoth Lakes Trail System is strictly a non-motorized so that we avoid potential conflicts with those who believe that's the way it should be, this is something we need on our radar. Is it complex? You betcha. Are people going to come out of the woodwork telling us why it won't work and giving us reasons that for the most part make no sense? Absolutely they are. I believe we need to serve all trail users.

2:38:10 Therefore, I believe this needs to stay on our radar list and we need to start asking some of these questions. Or we continue to have a fragmented trail system for the motorized public because we're afraid to deal with complex issues. I think another thing for this group to keep in mind is that subpart C of travel management does direct us to look at over snow travel and I think that that's a big effort that we're going to be

2:38:40 Taking on that's going to be a forest wide. And I think there may be some benefit in waiting until that process starts. And we may have some hesitation about moving forward with a whole lot of trail planning that has to do with over snow vehicles because we're concerned about potential appeals. And we just want to make sure that just like we did with

2:39:04 Motorized Trails that we want to give the same sort of attention and foresight to over snow systems. So that is definitely something that we are tasked to do agency-wide is to do subpart C of tribal management, which is the over snow piece. So keep that in mind that there is a bigger forest-wide trail planning effort coming for that. Any idea when that will be coming forward, Sarah?

2:39:30 I don't, but I believe it will be within the next few years, maybe something that will be directed. I'm sure the regional forester, if not the Washington office, has a timeline that we do need to adhere to. Right now we're focused on plan revision, but subpart C won't be too far behind. So it'll be after plan revision most likely then? It's potential that it would start concurrently. Okay.

2:39:56 I haven't looked at the timelines and what our requirements are for meeting the travel management rule and when we need to address subpart C, but it's definitely on our radar. That's good to know. John, it looks like Laura, you have a comment as well? No. Okay. Let's just keep this short because I do want to move on from this business better. No, I just want to, I want to...

2:40:18 Emphasize that I think that this committee should appropriate funds to start moving forward with this summit process to get this thing done. And you're suggesting a summit for just winter? Go read the trust plan, read the trust system master plan, read what the recommendation is that lies within there. It's specific to the shady rest area and the complex areas that Sandy's talking about. I think that...

2:40:40 When this trail system is effective is when it's proactive and when it's ahead of things that are coming our way. If things are coming this way out of the Forest Service, these are particularly town-centric issues and it's policies and commitments that the town has to make and the level of connectivity of whatever the town's going to be able to do to what's ever coming out of the Forest Service, you want to get that figured out, know what you can do, what you can't do, settle these issues.

2:41:05 So that you can take advantage of opportunities as they come forward. Thank you. Why don't we agendize this for maybe midwinter or something, yeah. It'd be tough to do it any time sooner. I mean, there's no way, yeah. So, Steve, just to put this on an agenda, not necessarily for October 7th. No. But something that we would like to review in the winter. How's that for ambiguity? Yep. That works.

2:41:37 But we will leave it on the list. Yeah, yeah, yeah, because I think, yeah, someday the winter... Let's move on. Is there anything else to... No, that's it for seven. Thank you. Number eight is discuss projects from the approved master project and budget tracking list for fiscal year 13-14. Continue discussion, provide comments and recommendations, particularly bullet item project 731.

2:42:02 Print maps slash guides, and number two, placement of doggy bag dispensers and trash cans at Waterford Trail End, and the existing pedestrian easements projects, 721 and 581. If we jump into this, I'd like to just ask the committee, can we limit it to only those two items, or are there going to be others that need to be brought up? I can tell you that I'm going to be out of here in five or ten minutes. Yeah. Okay, regardless. Okay. So.

2:42:29 Yes, we're going to leave it to just these two. Thank you. Let's jump in. So I might direct your attention to page 205 on our master tracking list, about mid-page 731, print maps and guides. We've been in discussion with Forest Service and others on putting together then the winter recreation map reprint.

2:42:55 And some of that reprint information will contain the blue diamonds that were discussed earlier. And also there are some text changes that the Forest Service is looking to make. So one of the things you'll notice is that there was $3,000 in the 2012-13 budget that was not spent. My recommendation would be to carry that $3,000 over to this fiscal year to pay for some of that coordination and work effort.

2:43:24 Recommendation would be also for the 3,000 that we have asterisked for the 13-14 to have that money in reserve in case it takes additional staff time to put together that text and or the GIS mapping data for that particular project.

2:43:45 Just to clarify, then, are we talking about $6,000 or just $3,000? $6,000. $6,000. $6,000. It seems that you have to, because as I understand it, on the heels of the winter use map will be the summer use map, which hasn't been reprinted for two years either. Yep, just wanted to clarify. On the blue diamond piece of this that you were speaking to, has the blue diamond trail system changed? I thought they were just redoing the diamonds. Are there new routes to be added to this? Are there...

2:44:13 No, I actually think they're, I went to one of the meetings with the Forest Service representative in attendance, and I actually think they may delete some of the routes. Yeah, okay. You know, I'm not sure that that's accurate. We've been having conversations in-house, but I think the bigger picture is that my understanding is that they were historic routes that had blue diamonds on them. A lot of them have fallen off over the years, and so the Sierra Club wanted to go out and refurbish those trails, but then a piece of that would be to

2:44:42 Get GPS points for those and map them so that we could add them back to the map. Specifically what I was speaking to were the trails in the lake space and over Mammoth Pass into the wilderness, which at the time, and I don't know if that's, maybe the agency's changed its mind, but at the time they wanted to delete those from the Blue Diamond System.

2:45:02 I know that when Rick Laborde went out with the group, he had some suggestions for the Sierra Club, but we hadn't vetted those internally, and so before we finalized those, I think there was going to be some more discussions. I know he had some concerns about wilderness, and I think the concerns were that if you put up any trail system marker, that potentially you would get.

2:45:27 Either somebody on an over-snow vehicle or, you know, like a snowmobile or a mountain bike in the summer would just be following a trail and not be aware that it was going into wilderness. And so I don't know necessarily that we've determined we want to avoid putting those diamonds up there. I'm not sure that the final... I think the concern was that the wilderness boundary changed since that...

2:45:53 Red Cones Trail was originally put in, and that what may have been appropriate back in the early 80s may not be appropriate today, and that in the Lakes Basin itself, the Blue Diamond Trail, and in most cases, was concurrent with the now

2:46:13 Maintained Nordic System. And in fact, it was essentially the predecessor to the maintained Nordic System. So it was more cleanup. Yeah. Yeah. I think over time just a lot of those trails were removed from the map because of some of those conflicts. And so I think the idea is to make sure that the trails that are being remarked are also GPSed and then added back to the winter recreation map. Yeah. Whichever trails those are. Go ahead. So for any trails that currently aren't on the map, is there going to be a public process?

2:46:43 Explaining to people, are we going to get a chance to comment on those trails? Because they are going to be part of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, I'm assuming. You know, one of the questions I have also on the map is, what's the geographic scope of the map? Because my recollection of both the winter and summer recreation maps was they went.

2:47:05 Well beyond the planning area that we have. And so I want to make sure that, one, if we're putting Measure R dollars into it, that we're not funding the entire reprint of the whole world necessarily. And two, that we make sure that the MLTS is identified on the publication. So I want to make it clear that I'm not just ready to go reprint the winter maps just because.

2:47:30 Well, it sounds like they're working on it, so the main thing is I would say let's hang on to that money. Yeah, agreed. Exactly, and it may be a match because I believe John had said that there was some money available to the Forest Service, maybe at least for the winter, I can't remember. So, yeah, I'd say let's keep it as it is, $6,000. There may be a need for some of Town of Mammoth Lake staff in

2:47:59 Coordination with Mono County GIS staff to do some work. So it may be that 3,000 of the six could be allocated not to exceed to help support staff in that effort because currently there is no funding for it. But it may be required of staff to provide that service in coordination.

2:48:20 With the Forest Service. Given that the map has a comment, it covers a geographic area much larger than the town of Mammoth Lakes in its planning area, much larger than the scope of the trail system master plan. Would Murdoch County be interested in kicking in some money too? Probably not. Well, interesting problem. What's the timeline? You know, winter map should be printing these next week.

2:48:47 Not quite, but I'm just saying, has a timeline been established for new maps and guides for this winter? I think we were waiting to see how far we got along with the GPS changes. We could reprint the maps as they are. One of the things that actually, in the context of the earlier conversation about Brian Knox and

2:49:10 And Mammoth Nordic, some of the language that's on the existing map implies that all of those blue diamond trails are groomed, and the additions to a lot of these, to the blue diamond system on the winter map, we won't be able to groom some of those new trails, so some of the language that we think should be changed would actually be beneficial depending on whether or not Mammoth Nordic can either groom, but is essentially to imply that for the most part they are not.

2:49:39 And so then we're setting up visitor expectations. As far as how far in advance the printing process goes, I think it probably depends. I know that we have money set aside, and I think we could order them sooner rather than later without there being any changes or updates. I don't know what the drop dead deadline is.

2:49:59 For making changes and then ordering a new set. We have some in storage that we can use. We have a few boxes remaining that are the existing maps. Certainly we'd like to be able to make updates and get new maps printed before this winter season. Originally when we did those maps, and they go way back, the non-groomed trails were showed in one way and the groomed trails were as another way.

2:50:27 And I use those maps all the time because I give them out to tourists when they come to town so I can show them where to go. I'm assuming it's still the same on these maps, that the both Blue Diamond and Orange Diamond Trails, because there are groomed versions and non-groomed of each, that the groomed are shown.

2:50:45 As the solid lines and the non-groomed are shown as the dotted lines or I don't remember if you use the color combination. I think the most recent iteration it went to one type of line and then it expressed that most of them are groomed but sometimes they are not. But that's why I think a lot of pieces of that old, the very first version of the map were removed. And so there was an interest in putting more of those cross-country routes back on the map, re-signing them. But I think that the trade-off then is that

2:51:13 You have to be a little more explicit that they won't all be groomed. And so it does leave a lot more room for flexibility. You don't have to update them as much and reprint them as much if you're a little more vague about whether you illustrate them as groomed or not groomed. And certainly with the potential that there may not be groomed trails at all, at least where Brian, certainly we have some funding to do grooming.

2:51:40 But I think it does allow for flexibility when you have certain years where something happens where potentially the entity that you have an agreement with isn't able to groom. You're not setting up expectations that you can't necessarily meet every year. But to be more specific, I think the most recent iteration that I've seen does not delineate between groomed and ungroomed. I'm not sure if anybody else can. I missed that then because I would have made a negative comment on that. It's very important.

2:52:10 For motorized and non-motorized to know which trails are groomed and which trails aren't groomed. I think I'm referring just to the cross-country. Cross-country, yeah. Yeah, the OSV, yes.

2:52:22 I think it's very important that they both be listed, what is groomed and what isn't, or what is randomly groomed. Yeah, so I think the way that the winter map shows OSV is it'll say open area, and then it'll show the grooved trails with the orange diamond, but I think the cross-country trails is what were the blue diamond. But there are orange diamond trails that are not groomed.

2:52:48 Now it's outside of my confidence level. We know that we're all saying the same thing. Just to kind of move this along, we're going to leave this line item in place. I think that's fair. The question that I've got is when are changes going to be discussed so that we can actually move this project forward? And certainly one month from now probably seems like it's going to be too long.

2:53:18 If we're going to try and get these out by this year. So my question is going to be, what's the process? Well, I believe that this year club is out doing those blue diamonds between now and through the end of October. So we wouldn't have updated GPS information until after that.

2:53:35 So. Okay. And frankly, at least I heard that you have extras in storage. So, I mean, if you start off with the old one, that's not a huge one. Yeah, we do. It's not a huge problem. It wouldn't get us, I don't think it's going to get us all the way through winter. No. But we do have some leftover that will probably get us into November. That's good. Again, might I express a desire to provide some funding to staff so that staff can help with the Forest Service on putting this together?

2:54:04 Again, I think the $3,000 that we carried over, if the committee designates that as a not to exceed for staff hours to provide that service, then we can help move this process along and at least have dedicated staff and communication with the Forest Service to put this forward. Do you have any comments on that? Works for me. It's just the same comment I made earlier that, you know, obviously a portion of this

2:54:30 Yeah, if it's the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, a portion of it does not, and I would like to see the other partners, and I understand the Forest Service has money for printing the maps, so I'm not worried about them, but certainly seeing if Mono County can come to the table with some of that money because the unincorporated areas are going to get a huge benefit of this as well. Steve, can you ask Mono County that we would like to match the funds that they bring forward? Or maybe they can.

2:54:57 Challenged cost share. As I said, I think we share a GIS coordinator of some sort. Is that a good place to start? I know you're asking for not to exceed 3,000, but instead of going that high, I think I'd like to put a little pressure on the county to say, hey, you guys come to the table, we'll come to the table.

2:55:14 That could be contributed staff time. I think that's what it is. They are contributed staff time. Nate's engaged in the process. We've been seeing back and forth emails from Nate's. I mean, they're working on it with us. I think they're contributing. In that case, I would make a motion that we use the rollover $3,000 as an NTE for potential staff time to help grease the wheels, as it were, for the MAP process.

2:55:45 So the motion on the table is... I got your comment. It's already been seconded. Okay. I got his concept. That's good. And Steve, I deliberately left off winter versus summer because if there are funds left over from that $3,000, then we can use them to do the same thing and help to get the summer map off the ground too. They are both really important pieces. Yep. I'm going to ask if this is, so it's not to exceed $3,000, but that it also matches the funds that are coming from the county?

2:56:13 Or is that asking too much? That's asking too much. Yeah. Let's just say that this is for town staff and not to pay meat stock. But I want to echo Bill Taylor's comments that, you know, that our funds are really going towards MLT SCC, scope, realm, area. I don't know how you want to define that bill or what you're trying to say. It's a challenge because, as I said, I...

2:56:39 I want to make sure that it's known that Measure R is contributing to this. This is beyond the scope of the Mammoth Trail System. It goes much farther. And so, you know, once again, I'm finding myself in the same position I was in in the spring with Sharp and some other things where I've got a deadline and I have two choices, neither one of which I like, because one implies that Measure R is the easy button.

2:57:08 Now we've got a trails-related thing, we'll just go to Measure R and get some money. It doesn't really matter whether it's directly related to the Trail System Master Plan or any of the other plans and programs. This map has lived outside of Measure R and the town for quite a while. So I will probably vote for it begrudgingly, but...

2:57:30 Please do not do this to us again. The comment that I think I'd like to make is that if MLTSCC dollars or Measure R dollars go into this, that our logo would need to be on the map. Is that inappropriate? I don't see that it would be inappropriate. I'm not sure the history of how the map was initially created, so I think we just need to make sure that there isn't anything.

2:57:54 That would make that problematic. Okay. And I think so, too, and I hear what you're saying, and I think you're right, as well, but let's just get a definitive answer on that, if we could, please. It's moved. Okay. So, we've got a motion and a second? Yep. Yep. And he doesn't suggest you have... Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. Aye. We got the concept. Thank you. Okay. Yep. The last thing, then... Should that go on that urgency item? Yes. Add that to the urgency item, too. I've got three. Yep. Okay. Thank you, Steve.

2:58:23 Okay. Thanks for covering for us. Okay, the last thing then here, we'll get this quickly, is also on page 205, a little bit further down, items 721 and 581, existing pedestrian edificements. In this area, we want to provide for the doggy bag dispensers and trash receptacles. This has been on the agenda and pushed on and on and on since May. So I'm hopeful that you can...

2:58:49 See clear to approve three locations, one at the end of Waterford, one is at the end of Tamarack Street, and the other is at the end of Mill or Dust Hazard Road. There was an email way back in April from Dennis Rotner outlining the cost per installation, and I hope you received a double-sided...

2:59:19 We're missing part of it. It was on the website. As hard as I work, sometimes I make a mistake. Oh, really, yeah. I'm really sorry. This is installation, not... Well, the flip side had capital costs. Yeah, it had more information on costs. Capital costs, that's what I was looking for. I maybe can quickly recover. Yes, I can. What do you know? Well, I could just watch my questions on it. Yeah. There's also... Passes home.

2:59:47 What's the capital cost? In other words, the 15? There's a maintenance cost also if we're going to install trash receptacles. Somebody's got to go out and clean it out. So that's the capital cost and this is the installation cost? Does this 1900 cover both? If you'll notice, it's for a number, as I recall. For two of these? I think it's... I'm sorry. Yeah, two of them.

3:00:16 Well, no, I'm not sure. I'll let you confirm that. Okay. Yeah, you'd have to confirm it. Yeah, four each. So the $1,500 is the capital divided by four. Is the capital divided by four? $1,500. Okay. For each price. Plus, in other words, if we did four, then we'd add another $100, so roughly $2,000 if we did four, huh? Correct. So your $1,900 does, so your $1,900 does cover everything. So we're talking $1,900. Okay.

3:00:46 So I'm looking for a motion to approve. Yep. $1,900 just for the installation and purchase of the bags? This is just for the installation and purchase, not for the maintenance. So it looks so moved. Generally, Dennis said it would be inconsequential because it's part of their overall thing. Okay. So we didn't have a specific...

3:01:08 Line Item 4 Maintenance. Okay, we put a big sign on it saying, do not leave your bags around while you're walking. Isn't that something? Isn't that amazing? It's disgusting. I'm sure they have good intentions of picking it up, but then they go back the same way. The question is, with regard to the maintenance issue, because if this is going to be something that's going to be coming out of our future MLTSCC budget,

3:01:31 On an ongoing annual basis. No. I think this is going to be under the general fund maintenance for the overall MUB that Dennis does. Then perhaps what I'd like to do is make a motion that we approve this amount provided that there is no maintenance funds coming out of the MLTSCC annual budget for the cleanup, removal of these doggie bags or the garbage cans associated with them.

3:01:59 I'll second it. I'll second it. That's fine. Let's just move it forward. Motion and second. Any further discussion? Just a question on the Mill Street one. Mill Street is, is it located at the intersection of Tamarack and Mill? No, it's where the actual end of Mill, where Goody property is, and then on the other side of that easement that the town has secured across the Goody property, that's where they'd be placed because people...

3:02:28 Walk their dogs up Mill Street across the easement that we have that's been given to us, but there isn't that opportunity for trash and dog manure. And one of the concerns of the property owner is I've given the town an easement. Can we do the next right thing, which is to provide a receptacle and a dispenser so that I don't have to go out onto my property that I've eased to the town and clean up the dog poop? Understood. Further discussion?

3:02:56 Sorry, where's the money coming from? Do we have that allocated in any, is it one of the asterisk items that, just from our master tracking list? Yeah, on page, oh, yeah, on page two and five, under the column, Recommended 2013-14 Funding, $1,900 with an asterisk. Perfect.

3:03:16 Existing pedestrian easement. So that's another item we have to add to the town council, or the recognition that it's sold. So this will be a fourth emergency. Fourth emergency, yeah. Discussion from the audience. Hi, just real quick. I personally am not convinced that collecting fecal matter and plastic bags, while a very effective program in an urban area like New York City or Chicago, I'm not really convinced that that's the best way to be dealing with these kinds of issues.

3:03:46 I would encourage the committee, perhaps as part of a summit, something like that, to head this out for discussion. I think we've all seen what happens on winter trails. I see it in summer trails all the time. It ends up in the bag. The bag ends up on the ground. Would it have been better to just leave the poop on the ground itself and not put it in some...

3:04:04 Type of enclosure that makes it even more difficult for it to break down. I think this is a serious question and I would encourage you guys to look into this. Speaking from those of us at the Hayden cabin, I'd rather have to go pick up the blue bag later when they leave it. Than the poop. Than the poop. I'm sure the good fill us in. That's the existing town. I'm sure the good fill us in. That's what I asked. We've had discussion. I'm sorry, I think we need to move this along. Let's vote. Let's just capitalize on. You got me in my second so you know what my vote is. We've got a motion and a second. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye.

3:04:33 Thank you. Passes. Okay, new projects that we want to bring forward? Not at this time. We mentioned a couple earlier. If you could just cover those, Steve. Shady Rest Winter Summit. Put that, but that's not a... That's in the middle of the winter. That's it. I don't know if it's a future agenda item or a new project. It's not just a Shady Rest. It's a winter summit we're talking about. Yeah. A lot of items. Yeah. And it was also grant writing. Agendized that.

3:05:06 Discussion for later. And then there was also, you were going to give us a copy of the website content management agreement. I can do that outside of an agenda item. Yeah. Unless you want to agendize it. Yeah, and the winter summit was sometime later, months out. Yeah. And just to be clear, we're going to have some discussions with regard to the lakes basin closure. Yeah. Got a bunch of questions for the forest service. That's right.

3:05:36 And that's going to be, that is, we will agendize that for our, in the show, October 7th. So we can take action if we need it. And Shady Restoring. Shady Restoring. You think, should that be agendized for action probably, if we have costs? For October 7th. If we have the answers to questions? Let's see why, you know, the least we can do is let's call for action, and then if we need to table it, we can. Yeah. Good. Good. Finally, we'll get something done on that.

3:06:05 Any other new projects, audience who are here? Sounds good to me. Okay then. All right. Are there any staff reports? None. Are there any committee reports? Well, I'm not sure what to do with the extra time. How about this, huh? How about this? I will entertain a motion at this time. I move to adjourn. Second. That's adjourned. Anyone opposed?

3:06:37 Nope. Okay. We are over. Were we supposed to finish? Two hours.

3:06:52 I was feeling confident we were going to five. Well, I think that actually is pretty good because some things, you know, it's good to just briefly go over it. Yeah, I mean, let's face it. I just want to remember that our target is too much. Our target is too much.