Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013
Parks & Recreation Commission
· recording 3 hr 17 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
425 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Commission to order roll call, please. Patricia Antic, Elizabeth Truax, Elizabeth Truax, Sean Turner, Vice Chair Terry Stehlik, and Chair Bill Sauser. Public comments, this is the time when any member of the public wishing to make a statement on anything that doesn't otherwise appear on the agenda. Please up at our podium, make a line.
0:31 Good afternoon. My name is John Wentworth with MLTPA. A couple of announcements of upcoming events. This Friday and Saturday night, September 13 and 14, MLTPA is proud to bring, along with Mammoth Medical Missions, Mammoth Brewing and Community Skis, the Mountain Film on Tour Festival. Two nights of exciting, interesting films about mountain communities, mountain life, mountain culture.
0:56 Free skis will be given away both nights courtesy of Mammoth Community Skis. Delicious beer and ales provided a non-profit supporting price by Mammoth Brewing. It's going to be down at the Mammoth Lakes Arts Center, 549 Old Mammoth Road. A very interesting series of films to see. A great way to reconnect with our culture, our mountain environment, who we are and what we do.
1:21 John, yes? Do you have a flyer or anything that's electronic that you could send out? Oh, sure. Maybe you could even send it to John Morris and he can shoot that off to all the lodging properties. Okay, sure. Lodging association. Also, on September 21st, the Summer of Stewardship Trail Days Programs at MLTPA does with Frenzadino, the last event, 8.30, Saturday, September 21st up at Horseshoe Lake at the Trailhead.
1:53 Clean up the Mammoth Lakes Basin. It's been a busy summer. Desperately need us at TLC. That'll be the final event. We got a lot of great swag, a lot of great giveaways, a lot of great work to get done up there. So hopefully we'll see you there. Thank you. That's great. Thanks, John. Thank you, John.
2:16 Hi. I think most of you know me. I'm Gail Lonnie with the Mammoth Lakes Tennis Club. And I'm not here to ask for anything. I'm just here to, number one, thank you for taking care of the repairs at the beginning of the summer at the community courts. We appreciate that. I also wanted to just present a petition that we just put together last week, Labor Day weekend.
2:37 And we got 128 signatures of people that just saying that they support tennis and Mammoth and they want to keep this community courts viable. So I want to give you this list of names. And I would say about at least a third to a half of them are from people from out of town. So I thought that might be interesting to you. Also, I have a couple of pictures here from just this last weekend. This is after Labor Day. So most people were up at the kamikaze races or in the bike.
3:04 Races, etc. But even so, on our Sunday social, 22 people showed up at the community courts to play. So I have a picture of the group there and also a picture of the group of people actually out playing and using the community courts. One other thing I wanted to mention is we had a very successful Labor Day doubles tournament at Snow Creek. We ended up with about 75 people and, again, about half of them from out of town.
3:29 We also got a lot of support from the community businesses supporting the girls tennis program, the high school tennis program, boosters, with donations to a raffle where they think where at this point they're not sure how much they made but they think it's around someplace around $1,000 to support that. So here's a list of all the supporters in town that gave to the raffle. There's about 42 of them there. So I just wanted to give this to you and again thank you for
3:59 You know, the work that we got done on the community courts at the beginning of summer, we do appreciate it. Gail, can I ask you a couple of questions? How are the courts? Terrible. Terrible. The courts are really in that shape. They need to be replaced, and I'm not asking for that. I understand that the court is in serious financial trouble. So if we can just keep them maintained, but they, again, you know, and I've stressed this for the last, I don't know how many years,
4:27 They need to be replaced. There's huge dips in them. They turn into pools when it rains, when it snows. They're hard to clean up. I guess that's what I'm asking is, how are they as far as, are we going to be able to go another year with repairs only? Yeah, if you can get the repairs, that's what we need. The alternative is to rip them out and have nothing, and that's not what we want. We will keep those courts, people playing on those courts until
4:55 You know, they sink into the ground. But hopefully it won't come to that. Hopefully at some point there will be money budgeted maybe from Measure R where we can actually replace one court a year, which is what we were sort of hoping to do about five years ago when we first started, you know, asking for maybe a five-year program, $100,000 to $150,000 a year, replacing courts and adding two additional courts. So that's our ultimate goal, but I'm not asking for that today.
5:23 And I'm just curious, yeah, with the mood, with the crowd and, you know, your summer, was it busier summer on the tennis courts or about the same? Yeah, we were getting probably on Sundays about 30, 35 people every Sunday. And then the same thing over at Snow Creek. You know, we also have a Saturday social over there. So we're getting a good group. I was getting 30 to 40 people at Snow Creek and then probably 30 to something.
5:47 Community Courts. So, I mean, it's been good. I mean, there's a lot of people out there playing tennis. I know they say tennis is sort of on a downward slide right now, but it fluctuates. You know, it'll come back again. So we need to keep the courts. And a lot of people from out of town really come up and use the community courts and the Snow Creek courts. There's a big demand for people that are up here visiting.
6:09 Has there been much discussion about, you know, want to see the courts move, want them to see them stay where they are? Has there been much discussion about along those lines? I think people would be happy if there was a new tennis facility, if they got moved someplace, you know, reasonable. I don't think that, I think there was some discussion about it, but the college, it's a little windy up there, it would be very hard to grade up there. I don't think that's the most ideal spot.
6:39 But there has also been discussion, at least among tennis players, of maybe the Mammoth, what's it called, the little one over there by the, where they have the playground Mammoth. Which one? Mammoth Creek? Yeah, Mammoth Creek. Thank you very much. The creek's running right through it. I should remember that. Mammoth Creek Park. I mean, that might be an option. But again, there is no other parks.
7:07 On that, on the community center park. There's no other parks over in that area. It's so close to the village, and a lot of people from the village do come over and play on those tennis courts and appreciate the fact that there is a park there. So I think with some improvements, you'd probably get a lot more people over there playing.
7:26 You know, if the tennis courts were improved and the park remained there. So, you know, I don't know about moving. I like it over there. Most people like to have a park in that neighborhood. But that would be something. You know, if it needs to be moved at some point, we would hope that they would have courts built at another location prior to the removal of those courts. Well, thank you. I was just asking for a few of them. I appreciate your questions. Yes. Thank you. Is there anything else?
7:55 Thank you very much. Thank you. Any other public comments? We will close public comments. Move on to the consensus. Move on to the consensus. Which only contains one thing. Yeah, I actually had a couple of comments. We can talk about them real quick. Steve, just on page two, the second paragraph there, Commissioner Turner noted,
8:21 For the record, it's concerns regarding wind issues and the point when people go home and stop spending money. The point that I was trying to, and I think this is just a grammatical thing. Who's able to change this? Or Jamie's not here today? Oh, okay. Oh, okay. Well, I guess what I just want to say is that I wanted to record my concerns regarding wind issues with regard to the point when people go home and stop spending money.
8:46 The and makes it sound like it's two different subjects, but what I was trying to point out that if the wind is a six rather than a four, that's when people leave and the bar doesn't pay for the event. So if we could just change the word and to with regard to, it just makes it more clear. Where is that, Sean? It's page two of four, second paragraph. Commissioner Turner noted for the record his concerns regarding wind issues with regard to the point when people go home and stop spending money.
9:18 Thank you. That's the point that I'm just trying to make. Otherwise it doesn't sound right. I just want to say the words with regard to. Okay. And then there was just one other point I would like to see changed, and that is on the very last page, Commissioner Turner reported on his Bluza Pluza event. Please don't get me in trouble with the... I'd like it to say Commissioner Turner reported on Mammoth Brewing Company's Bluza Pluza event.
9:52 Thank you. Move to approve the consent agenda with the amendment. Since we're making little corrections, what I reported was that a group of, what the heck is the name of the game they played? Pickleball. Pickleball users were using the tennis courts, not tennis players. Tennis players are using them as well. My point was they were getting used beyond just the tennis players. I will still move to approve the agenda.
10:27 Consent agenda with the amended comments. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Opposed? They'll be unanimous. Moving on. Chair, if I may. You certainly may. Thank you. Staff does have an emergency item that they'd like to bring forward to the commission for their review.
10:55 We would like to present it as 2A because it does relate to the action taken by the Mammoth Lakes Trial System Coordinating Committee at yesterday's meeting. So it's just reviewing action and approving the appropriation of funds for four projects. We have staff reports here. We can hand them out now or we can hand them out prior to that item at whatever you prefer. We have to look at it. You do have to make a vote. It has to be unanimous.
11:24 So I'll just take a motion and add this as an emergency item. I will so move. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? I don't either. Bring it all in favor. Aye. Opposed. So now we should probably pass out those packets if we could. Thanks, Steve.
11:53 And this item, this emergency item would actually follow the item number two, which is just your MLTSCC update. And I think part of the issue here is because the MLTSCC meeting falls so close to the commission meeting, when we change any funding, we almost have to deal with it in this way to get it sent on for payment.
12:23 Because there isn't the required 72 hours between the two meetings. And I don't want to change them because this doesn't happen often. Just as an informative piece, that's why you're getting this as an emergency. But you know, Bill, I was actually going to consider bringing that up in MLTSCC, whether or not, you know, because it will happen often enough, especially as we go through this. You know, I can see it happening five or six times a year. Yep.
12:51 So there may be worth it to consider, and perhaps this discussion should take place at the MLTSCC level, you know, moving that meeting so that it is one week prior or two weeks prior. My comment on that, what I think we should do is replace what is number two on today's agenda, because this is an ongoing monthly thing, where it says Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee update.
13:19 to verbiage that would allow us to act on anything that had occurred in that meeting so that it becomes an actionable item instead of just an informative item. Well, that would be, that would, and frankly, I'd even prefer that. I didn't know that was an option. Yeah, that is certainly an option from my standpoint. Stu, you see any reason why that would not work? No, I think that's all it would be, just the, you know, the update and any action required or recommended by the committee.
13:46 I mean, that's all we need to say. And I think the dates work out well because Steve's, you know, from an efficiency of time point of view here the day before here for this meeting. Right. So I think this is probably the best option. Well, that's great. I was not aware that was an option and I actually prefer that as well. So can we just stand, just change this standing policy matter to say, yeah, update and action. Right. Yeah. That's all we have to do. Okay.
14:20 So with that, there are, I think, Stu, would we come up with finally four different items here? I'm pulling off my memory and not off the paper. What we might do first here, if it's appropriate, is have Steve just provide an update, if you wish, which is the handout. It's just a two-page handout. Steve can kind of run through that, or he can just ask questions related to that item, which is number two. And then we'll have Steve as the MLTACC coordinator.
14:48 Provide a brief overview of the four items that are part of that emergency package. So, Steve, why don't you just run through your, just the update. Just to confirm, I don't know that this was handed out in the package or not. This one? Yes. Great, okay. That one was? Oh yeah, it was. Steve Spidell, Coordinator for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee. One thing that you might notice on this,
15:22 What is it? It was at one point a version was dated September 3rd. So I'll just point out I'm not sure if it was corrected or not because the meeting date was changed. It still says September 3rd, but it's okay. Okay, good. So what I'd like to do is talk about some of the work that the committee has focused on and also then
15:46 discuss some of our next steps and then the next item on the agenda will be then the approval of some of those items that we are intending to move forward. So one of the things that we've accomplished in the last few months is approval of our mission statement and as it's listed on the handout as well at our last meeting we approved the
16:13 Mission, I'm sorry, the draft vision statement and the wording remained as is and as printed here. So that was another one of our accomplishments. The other thing we did was we approved our priorities and strategies for moving projects forward. So as you can see, we're just clicking on down the list, getting these things taken care of. In number four, we created a list of current projects.
16:41 that were of all recommended programs and projects that were in the trail system master plan. That was a four-page document in small print, by the way, so there were many, many recommendations that are being looked at and carried forward from the master plan. The other thing we did was we looked at merging our master tracking list, which you saw in a
17:08 and recommended for approval onto the town council for our budgeting. So it's a way of keeping track then of all the current projects we're working on, the fundings that have been approved for those projects, and then also work it back to the trail system master plan. So one of the things that we'll be doing in the future is looking at formatting on that and trying to keep these multi-page documents, one is over four pages, the other is over five, and trying to keep that down into a manageable.
17:37 number of pages, but at the same time not losing any valuable information. We have created an implementation process for moving projects forward and we had the ability just the other day to inform Public Works that we had approved funding for seven interpretive signs to go up in Lakes Basin for a few and out on the MUP at the Eastern Overlook as well. And so that
18:07 Processes is working and we have our methods in for implementation of our funding. We've contracted for over $175,000 of trails related services and products. Number seven, we received the project list and the $300,000 approval for fiscal year 2013-14 funding.
18:35 As you remember, that came before you and then went on to council for approval. And also within that, council gave you certain leeway to approve additional projects as indicated by asterisk on that particular tracking list. Number eight I already mentioned. We finalized our website maintenance agreement with MLTPA. That's up and running. We finalized our website enhancement agreement to create 112 new pages.
19:05 And we're exploring opportunities and could possibly add 78 additional pages to that website. The Lake Space and Stewardship Program has continued with Friends of the Inyo. Also the continuation of Trails Day Program with Friends of the Inyo and MLTPA, as John mentioned earlier, the last event of this year is coming up. We facilitated a cost share agreement with the Forest Service.
19:35 for performing environmental review and resource review for the Sharps area projects. And that's moving forward on time, on schedule. Number 14, we contracted with Friends of the Indio to install temporary soft surface signage in the Panorama Dome area and the Mountain View earthquake in uptown, downtown area. I had an opportunity the other day to ride through those areas on a mountain bike.
20:01 And the trail signs that we put up are really, very, very helpful. There's a little bit of a rabbit's wand of trails up on the Panaronga Dome, so without that signage you wouldn't quite know where to go or if you were headed off in the direction where you're going to end up. But they're very intuitive. The abbreviations work well. And the same is true with the work that was done at the earthquake fault, uptown, downtown, and mountain view trails.
20:28 New signage is put there so it's very clear when you're riding through that area when you enter into the area where it's needed to have a pass for the mountain bike park for the mountain and then also getting across to the earthquake fault and then up onto Mountain View Trail works very well. That was a great effort. Number 15, we've begun discussions with the U.S. Forest Service.
20:56 On the QR code interpretive content for the eight existing panels that are out there and also for the seven proposed. So we'll be also working with MLTPA to further the scope of that work and the deliverable products in the upcoming weeks. Number 16, we established preliminary discussions with MLTPA then on that development code content.
21:24 So our next steps, really one and two have been taken care of. We've approved the vision statement and we've approved our strategies and priorities for funding. So what we want to do now is keep moving forward, complete the reallocation and carryover funding for 13, that should be 13-14 funding, not 13-13, and finish prioritizing the master tracking list projects.
21:51 for 13 and 14, monitor ongoing agreements, and then maintain our monthly meeting schedule. If there are any questions about our accomplishments and what we hope to handle in the future, I'd take those comments at this time. Questions? I have a couple questions. Where can we find your priorities and strategies that you guys approved?
22:15 That was just approved the other day, and I've yet to have our minutes put together and finalize the document, but we can provide that. I've got mine here if you'd like me to pass it down. Well, when it becomes electronic, I would like to see what you guys came up with. And then in the signs, the seven interpretive signs that you guys...
22:37 Have approved. Does that include the ones that we were looking at previously and included the fishing one that we had asked to be held off? No, if you remember, eight originally came to you and the fishing was removed and that gave us with a net seven. So the fishing one is still, is not going to be constructed at this time and we'll have further conversations on wording. Okay.
23:01 And then so we have a contract signed with the Forest Service for the environmental review for the Sharp Trails Project? That's correct, the challenge cost share agreement. Okay. And so that, is that posted anywhere? It was on Granicus yesterday for our meeting. It was part of the handout package, yes. Would you like a copy? Yeah, I was just wondering exactly what we're doing, so I was kind of curious.
23:28 Anyhow. And that came up yesterday, actually, and one of the reasons why we are entering it into the public record is because, and Bill Taylor brought that up specifically yesterday, making sure that it was well spelled out in the documents that were handed out yesterday. So I think it'd be fair that actually we did get a copy to the Recreation Commission. Steve, is that inappropriate? I don't think there's a problem with that, is there? It's all public, so. Yeah.
23:56 Get it from there, or if they want, they can ask Steve or Stu to send them an email copy. Yeah, I'd love to be included just on your distribution of the monthly agendas and minutes for MLTSCC. You like minutes and agendas? Well, whatever your packet is, I'd just like to be able to look at it electronically.
24:19 It's on, it's on, I think you are on the email list, are you not? No, I'm not. Oh, you're not? Okay, well, is anybody else on? No, I'm on it. Oh, you are receiving? Because I go to most of them. Oh, okay, I don't receive it. I looked at some part of it on Granicus, but I didn't get through everything, so, anyway, before the meeting and before it was taken out. And then, Pat, you're on the list, are you? Yes, I recognize you. Yes, thank you. Okay, well, I'll make sure then that you're added to the email list.
24:47 And then my last question actually isn't included on here, so I'm wondering what you guys, if it's been a discussion, is what we're doing about replacing the Mammoth Creek sign that was stolen, if anything. I think Peter can address that. So we've updated the map to include trails that have been constructed after that sign went up, and our plan is to have it purchased so it'll be installed in the spring. Okay. And how's that paid for? We're using a trail system.
25:18 Maintenance funds. General fund trail system maintenance funds. Okay. Thank you for that clarification. I have a couple questions if you're done, Gary. Uh-huh. With respect to the QR codes, could you describe a little bit more about that? I thought that they were already on most of our signage. Sure. I don't know what else would need to be developed. Yeah, currently there's a...
25:44 When you take your smartphone and apply it to the sign at the QR code, it takes you to a landing page, but once you click on from that landing page, there is no content to back it up. So we have a current contract that was from a previous Measure R application by MLTPA to create that content. And part of that contract is for them to create a scope of work for creating the content.
26:14 And then the other part of that contract is money set aside then to create that content. And in the meantime, the Forest Service and the town have worked together to come up with a matrix of various ideas and themes to be relayed in that content development. So what we need to do then is continue working with MLTPA.
26:39 to hone in and develop that scope of work for a fixed fee, or I'm sorry, it's an amount not to exceed, and then also there are funds available for developing that content. So we need to make sure that the scope of work fits the funds that are available and the matrix so we can move forward. I guess I don't understand why that wasn't part of some original agreement. It is part of the contract.
27:08 For Web Enhancement, that contract has four phases, and these are two remaining phases within that four, so it's an ongoing process. Pat, are you referring to when they were first installed, why it wasn't there? Right, I thought that that was the selling point, you know, that there's QR codes and, you know, this is better than sliced bread, and I was kind of surprised that there wasn't anything.
27:36 Other than just a QR code on a sign. Well, right now, don't they take you to the website, and then would this be more specific, enhanced content specific to each sign? Because right now, if you put your smartphone up, it takes you to the website and shows you the things that are near you. That's correct, isn't it? My experience has been that it takes you to a landing page where it says hear it, see it, watch it, and then there's no content behind that.
28:07 These are the interpretive signs themselves, not necessarily a trailhead sign or a type 2 sign. Yeah, these are the new interpretive signs that you're putting in? Yeah. John, you want to help us with this answer? Yes, just to help mitigate any confusion. All the wayfinding signs, the QR codes and all the wayfinding signs work perfectly. They work fine.
28:36 This is specific to the interpretive panels. And there are eight interpretive panels on the ground. I think seven more coming. That's what Steve's talking about. So all the wayfinding signs work just fine. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. So as opposed to taking it just to the website, you're taking it to a landing page that explains that interpretive sign. Is that what you're trying to do? That's the intent. Correct. Yeah, there'll be additional content. So let's say conceptually you approach an interpretive sign and let's say it's
29:05 The one about the hole in the wall. So we might have a voice in there that would be the forest geologist explaining the difference between a lava tube and an erosion tube, that type of thing. We might go to another one that's talking about Native American use of the area.
29:28 And we might then go to a representative of the Paiute Tribe who might tell a little story. And so the idea is to provide a little bit more background than just the written word that you would read. So the idea is to create two or three additional pieces of information that you can access off of your smartphone. They may be visual, they may be audio. And what is the amount to that agreement?
29:59 The development of the scope, as I recall, is $1,500, and then the residual for creating the content is currently at $3,000. The whole contract is $25,000. So is that in this handout that you just gave us? Is that one of the items? No. That was previously done.
30:23 Is that the previous $25,000 contract that we did like two years ago? Yes. Okay, because that's what I thought this was. This is different. This is management of that. This is enhancement. This is your emergency thing that you have that's MLTS website enhancement agreement. Right, this is for the additional 190 pages, Steve, just to be clear. Yeah. 112 plus 78. Okay.
30:54 Because it's two separate contracts, so I can't say 190, I need to say 112 and 78. Well, it's the same contract, there's separate amendments. Okay. He just did the amendment two, which is the additional 78 pages. Okay. Still confused about that. Which, can we? Well, because he just said these, the QR codes are coming from the $25,000 that we approved back in 2012, but your second bullet point in item number one.
31:23 is from funded by Fall 2012 Measure R funding allotment of $25,000. Are these two separate items? Are they the same? It's the same contract, the $25,000 contract that was a Measure R application that went through the Public Works process and went through a number of revisions between MLTPA and the Town of Mammoth Lakes. It resulted in a $25,000 contract with four phases. Okay.
31:53 Two of the phases are related to website page creation and enhancement, and two of the phases are related to QR code content development. But to be clear, this is a separate contract, this $25,000. No. Am I making it worse? Okay. The original funding for this came out of Measure R almost two years ago. Right. The contract was never executed on that.
32:24 Right, I get that. So in all the negotiations to this point, this is the final contract that we ended up with for that money. The contract has been altered some from what it was approved for originally. In order to get these extra pages that have now become necessary in the past two years, and this is the way Ray started down it, and we actually gave him sort of verbal approval at our meeting two meetings ago, three meetings ago.
32:53 So that we can get a way to pay for the extra pages that are now needed because the website has to be updated and that's what this is about. It is that contract. But the contract has been altered to cover the four phases that Steve is talking about. Did I get that right? Correct. Yeah. And the website enhancement, just to be clear, includes experiences, right? Patron, participant experiences. I think that's originally what that $25,000 was. Originally it was. So now it's that plus more.
33:24 It is not near as much of that as we need because we have taken the lion's share of it and turned it into bringing the now two-year-old original work on the website up to current speed, showing the current trails and everything else. So that's where we're at. It's necessary to do this to get those in there. I personally am not happy that now we are going to be another year behind the ball in getting the content.
33:54 up to the level that this would have provided, but this contract got... Yeah, I know. Yeah. That's good. So thank you for clarifying because I think maybe Terry and I both thought it was an extra contract. No, this is that contract. Sorry, I confused it. There never was a contract. This is still that award. So this is the modified contract. This is above and beyond the $300,000. And if it was still for what the original intention was, if it was all for...
34:24 The experience enhancement, it wouldn't even be necessary to bring it back because it would still fit, but because it has changed, we do need to bring it back. Thank you. Do we have any kind of a time frame on how long it's going to take to go back and forth with the Forest Service on what that interpretive content is going to look like?
34:48 The interpretive content portion? We've got in the contract it calls for delivery within 90 days of the signed contract, which was just a couple weeks ago. Oh, great. I think so far we're on target. Photographs have been taken. Trails have been ground proof to make sure that they fit and the experiences are being worked on. A lot of that information was started before.
35:14 The data is available, so it's just a matter of putting it together. We're going to be holding a meeting on the 25th to talk about website management, and then shortly thereafter we'll probably be getting some information and update on the enhancement. Thanks. So if we move on then to agenda item 2A, which is a staff report that was handed out as part of the emergency.
35:49 What we're looking for here is the approval of four items recommended by the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee at yesterday's meeting. One, coordinators professional consultant agreement amendment number two for website project management not to exceed $7,500. Number two, reimbursement to MLTPA for funds related to temporary signage not to exceed $500. Number three, use of $3,000 from the fiscal year 2012.
36:19 2013 to fund staff development, updating the winter recreation map and $3,000 for additional maps and guides. Number four, installation of four blue bag dispensers and trash receptacles not to exceed $1,900. So the background is provided here to remind and to update us on our June 19, 2013, the Town Council approved the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee.
36:49 Master Project and Budget Tracking List for Fiscal Year 2013-14. This was also approved to move forward by the Recreation Commission to the Council. The Town Council empowered the Recreation Commission to approve funding for seven projects without gaining additional Town Council approval. And if you recall that those projects were indicated by an asterisk and a parenthesis next to the funding amount.
37:17 So, item one, currently there are two Mammoth Lakes Trail System website agreement contracts between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and MLTPA. They're bullet item below. One is for website content management, and that came out of the yearly $300,000 funding allotment, Project 451, and if you look in your packet, there's an 11 by 17 foldout.
37:47 And in yellow are the five items that relate to the four projects that we're talking about. And that's what that project number comes from is the tracking list. That project is $34,750 for this year. Also, there's a website enhancement agreement, which was a higher funding allotment of $25,000.
38:17 And that's reflected in yellow on page two. Not sure how you want to format this. I can go and give the background for the other three items or go right to the discussion and analysis. It would be your pleasure. I'd rather we just go to the discussion and analysis unless there are some specific questions that someone has. I've actually got a couple of comments if I could. Looking at the yellow page, are we finding temporary signage?
38:55 It says $2,000, but yeah, I thought there was $500. If you recall, the $2,000 was for Friends of the Inyo, as indicated in the almost far right column. So that was their cost to manufacture those signs. What we did not include in that measure was the necessary messaging and the time and effort to actually
39:24 Find the appropriate location for those signs. And that was an effort that MLTPA helped in and was not part of the funds that were allocated to Friends of the Inyo. Okay, so it's $500 or it's $2,000? $500 is what MLTPA is asking for, for reimbursement of time and material spent for messaging.
39:49 I see his issue. Where does that $500 show up in anything highlighted in yellow? And the 11 by 17, it does not. It does not. It's on top of? That will be in addition to? Correct. Yes. This is something that we didn't foresee that became very necessary. The work has now been done. And you've identified the funding? Yes. But I just want to be clear that it's $500, not the $2,000 that's on the yellow.
40:20 On the 11 by 17. 2,000 has already been approved and spent. Okay, so thank you. This is an addition. Right, the 500 is what we approved as a committee yesterday. And it's not on this page. To reimburse MLTPA for some of their expenses in doing the footwork for us to find the locations and create the verbiage for the signs. It is going to come from, and forgive me for not remembering exactly which line, but one of the carryovers from 12-13.
40:48 that didn't get expended or was in excess of what we anticipated spending there. So this is part of the carryover money that we have now reallocated to the signs for the temporary signs, which, by the way, may well end up being semi-permanent because until the forest service of the town has the budget to replace them. I have not seen them personally, but I know exactly the type they are, and from the people I've talked to who have written it,
41:18 They are quite adequate and look very nice and can suffice as permanent signs if necessary. So the bang we got for our buck here, even with the extra 500, is huge. Considering that little one replacement sign at Mammoth Creek is $3,800 or something like that, this is almost a coon. Thank you for explaining that. The other comment that I had was with regard to...
41:46 Item number three on page three of three of your report with regard to the printing maps and guides. Steve, correct me if I'm wrong, but I thought yesterday, Bill, you were there as well, Stu, that we had decided on, it was to be a not to exceed $3,000. Yes. And that it was for, and to be clear that it was for Mammoth Lake staff, town staff time to assist with the development of those prints.
42:15 of those maps for the Mammoth Lakes area only, or at least the MLTS area. Correct me if I'm wrong on this, Steve. This is just, I'm doing this all from memory from yesterday's discussion, so that it was not to exceed $3,000, and to be specific, that it was for town staff time to contribute to the research for the maps, and that we were also going to ask the county. Correct. Okay, I'd like to see that in here, at least explain it to the rest of the commissioners. Okay.
42:44 If I might, I'll get a graphic aid. Okay, so while you're doing that, let me ask one more question on that one. Isn't there green sticker money available for these as well? For the printing of the map, there is, but there's always a match required. Okay. So the $3,000 would be part of the match. Is that our match, or is that the full price? And I can't tell you that. Teri, do you want to answer?
43:10 We don't know, Teri, yet what it's going to cost. So what we're saying right now is we're just going to allocate $3,000, not to exceed $3,000, for staff time to assist in the production of that map. And then we're waiting on Forest Service and that group. And we're actually getting assistance from the county who are donating their time, obviously, on the project. I'm sure we were working with MLTPA and so forth. So we're trying to get those costs right now. So we have those $3,000 available for that map. It could be very well.
43:38 You know, it would be a lot more money than that. That's what we talked about in this together. Yeah. So what we're doing, we allocated in 12-13 for the printing of these maps $3,000. We are asking to reallocate that $3,000 to the staff time necessary to update the maps to fit the current landscape, much like with the web pages for the website. Then the $3,000 that was approved.
44:07 Buy us for this and the 13-14 budget would remain as an NTE for whatever our share of the costs would be, perhaps not as much as $3,000, to actually produce the map, to actually print the map. I don't know from the Forest Service what the cycle, what the current cycle for green sticker dollars are or if the map was approved for green sticker dollars. We have, this is probably about the, what, 10th or 12th iteration of this.
44:36 And sometimes they've approved the printing fees and sometimes they haven't. It vacillates depending on who's on their commission. So that's an application that we have. So that's an application. Right. That the Forest Service, well actually the Forest Service has sometimes submitted it and the town has sometimes submitted it. I think it fell through the cracks when we fell through the cracks in terms of director and it didn't get transferred as it should have been. Corporate memory lagging.
45:02 And there was once or twice when the funds were actually not applied for when it was the town that should have been applying it. But again, that's the faulty memory of an old man having allergy issues. So if I might, this version of the Mammoth Lakes Winter Recreation Map was developed in 2009. So it has been a while since there has been a reprint.
45:27 My understanding is the Forest Service does have some of these still, but they're running out, so that kind of leads to a little bit of this urgency. And then the actual impact area is all the way from Grant Lake down to Convict Lake, and of course the town is in the middle. But as you can see, it depicts many, many recreation opportunities in and around Mammoth.
45:56 This is a motorized and non-motorized map. It shows some blue diamonds and some orange diamonds. And some of the trails have changed and the status in terms of groomed or un-groomed has changed. And so you're looking to partner with the county and get this put together? Yeah, we're hoping that we can utilize the GIS services from the county to help develop the map itself. And then the text data and so forth might need staff internship work.
46:25 And that's where this $3,000 maximum would help to fund that. And then as far as printing as well, I guess I'm just looking if we're going counting, if this is counting wide, then we should partner with them on the total cost. Yeah, well, they should partner with us on a lot of things that don't happen at this point. Well, we can ask at least. Yeah, the printing is anticipated to come from the Forest Service. So our addition to it is to help provide the GIS, the graphic background.
46:55 and work with the Forest Service on revising out-of-date text and showing conditions as we move forward. Further on the history of this thing, if 2009 was the last printing, then if there are any left, it is flat out because somebody didn't get them out of the box and put them out. Our normal print run on this, since I've been involved, which has been, you know, in the decades, normally the printings that they've been getting last for two years.
47:24 It's never been printed for a longer period of time than that because what's on the ground changes in that time frame. So if these are from 2009 or two years overdue. And since there are a lot of closures, is that what you guys are looking to put on there? And it'll be great to have our website and, if possible, a QR code to link to the MLTS website on there. Yeah, we talked about all of that. And, Terry, also to be clear is that, yeah, so 3,000 is the carryover from...
47:51 12-13, and then we still have 3,000 for 13-14. Right. I have a general question. Did the MLTSCC review this yesterday, and was everybody in support of these four items? Yes.
48:10 I think we had unanimous on all four, right? I think as a commission we should kind of take that into consideration because they've already gone through all of this and it's thank you for sharing it with us and getting our feedback. However, I am thankful for a lot of the questions you've been asked because then the people that are in this audience that weren't there yesterday and the rest of the commission is... It's good to know. Yeah. It's being done and discussed and it's all great.
48:36 And I think the only thing that I would ask is just to add another line underneath the wayfinding temporary signage, the 2,000, just another, you know, maybe just showing the 500 and the MLTPA. I guess I do have questions on item number one. I kind of want to clarify this because this is actually one item that I did read on the agenda. And so let me know if I'm reading this incorrectly.
49:05 Allocated $25,000 two years ago for website enhancement, but one year ago, spring, I guess, so it was like, okay, springtime in 2012. Or was it fall? I don't know. Anyways, it was $25,000. And so we've been working on getting a contract in all this time. And so from what I read is the $7,500 that is being proposed for your contract.
49:34 Is coming out of that $25,000 so it's reduced the amount for the website enhancement? Okay, so I did read that in correctly. Okay. Yeah, so the funds are actually coming out of, I think it's, is it 411? Because I thought that the new contract is only for like $16,500 or something. Yeah, so it's actually out of Steve's contract. And where this came about was with the loss of Ray, you know, he was really providing a lot of that oversight. So with no Ray...
50:03 A bit beyond Pete's scope because he's obviously busy. So we dedicated Steve to perform that task. So he's really kind of picking up that extra workload. So that's why in addition to that fund is from the contract that he administers the Trail System Coordinating Committee with. It's not part of the website enhancement contract. But he's going to oversee the website enhancement contract.
50:26 Okay. Because we just don't have sufficient staff to manage it. Why was the website enhancement contract only $16,500? No, it was $25,000 for the website enhancement contract two years ago when we awarded it. The one that I read online was $16,500. Is that a different contract? I think that's one of the four phases. So we've got three phases together. So you guys contracted in phases as opposed to the full $25,000 and we want this?
50:52 No, I don't think that's correct. I think the way to explain it is that the total value of all the work provided is $25,000. There are divisions or phases, four of them, within that $25,000. Two of them are for scope development. Two of them are for product delivery. The website enhancement product delivery of $112,000 potentially plus $78,000 is equal to $16,000.
51:22 The QR code content development is equal to $3,000. The scope to develop the QR code is equal to $1,500. And if my math is correct, the scope to develop the 112 plus potentially 78 pages was $4,500. If you add that all up, it's $25,000. Okay, I didn't read it that way, so I missed something somewhere in there. So, anyways.
51:51 When I was reading the contract, that's not how it read, at least unless I didn't finish reading it. Yeah, there's a second, yeah, there's an attachment to the contract, and again, it was posted on Granicus yesterday, and it details out those four phases or tasks. That would be wonderful, I guess, if we can get that as well, just because then we don't have this confusion as far as that goes. But I thought I had read it in full, but obviously I didn't. So, anyhow, okay.
52:18 That sounds great. Thank you. Sorry. Thanks for the clarification. You're welcome. So what we're really looking for here is a motion. Well, I'll move that we accept, if I'm going to say this right, the recommendation for agenda item 2A to approve all four items recommended by the MLTSCC. I'll second it. I have a motion and a second. Any further discussion? Do you want to...
52:54 Roll call, roll call. Okay, roll call vote then. Pat Egnitz? Yes. Elizabeth Truax? Yes. Sean Turner? Yes. Vice Chair Terry Stehlik? Yes. And Chair Bill Sauser? Yes. Passes 5-0. And just for anybody who was questioning why I do that anytime there's money involved, I try to do it. I don't know, I'm not sure we're required to, it's just personal preference.
53:34 Okay. I guess I have an administrative cost question. So we have the town administrative cost that you guys have like a 4% on trails as well as what's left over, the $300,000, because you have on Measure R as a whole administrative cost. That's a 4%, right? Okay.
54:00 So I think it was set up originally, I don't know if it was set up as a percentage, I think it was just set up originally as about a $25,000 allocation to administer the $300,000 I think is how it started. That might be the 4%, I'm not too sure. But the 4% is for the total fund, right. For the total measure R. Correct. Yeah. That's how we do that. Okay. And for you as well, yeah. Okay. Sounds good. Yeah. Okay, moving on to number 3, review the proposed measure.
54:31 Well, that five-minute item will give us an hour. Review the proposed ministry event application for the forum developed by the event task force and provide comments. Thank you, Chair. So the task force, as you know, began several months ago with discussions to really get down to what is it and how should event applications be considered.
55:02 Should there be a separate application form? And a whole bevy of questions were presented by several individual organisations and the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition. This task force was appointed by Council. It consisted of Recreation Commissioner Pat Agnich, Mammoth Lakes Tourism Executive Director John Urdi, Measure U Application Committee Member Joyce Turner, Sandra DiDomizio, Representative of the Chamber of Commerce.
55:31 and Juliana Olenka, representative of the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition. The group met four times, very productive meetings, I might say, it was facilitated by staff. And what we've got you before you is essentially the questions that were presented in the scope of work, the group diligently and very comprehensively went through and provided their recommendations.
55:56 Which is, that goes from page 3 through page, I believe, 7. And then they've also, and Commissioner Agnich kind of put this together, and the committee ratified it as well, is the draft event application form. The first two pages, again, is just a kind of review of the application guidelines. And then the group got the application form down to four pages, which is pretty impressive.
56:26 So what we'd like to do today is really present this to the Commission with an opportunity to review and provide comments to the Measure U Application Committee who would then incorporate this process and the guidelines and application form into the Measure U Fall Award. I'm thinking the best way to probably go through this is to go through the questions if the Commission has any questions on the questions. I guess we can address it that way.
56:55 And then we can consider the application form itself, unless you want to go through them question by question. We do have members of the Measuring Application Committee here. Don's in the audience. I know Evan sat in at a number of meetings, and Commissioner Agnich is here as well, if you did want to have any follow-up questions.
57:17 So the way I was going to handle this too is starting with page number three and asking the commissioners if they have any questions on any of the items that appear on that rather than question by question. There's a question that they don't have any questions on. There's no reason for me to call it up. That was my question. So yeah, thank you. And now we will get to the questions.
57:38 I had a question on number three of page three on the first year events that they would not be allowed to apply for any funding. And I guess when I'm looking at grant funding, there's usually startup events are actually one of the key reasons why you're asking for money, that events that have been historically running should be running on their own.
58:08 Unless it was deemed that they're going to need a yearly stipend and that was agreed upon. But otherwise, usually it's a startup event, you know, not that it's just a one-year event, but something that's planning on at least sticking around. The committee thought that since public funds are involved, that better not to take a risk on a first-time event, let an event take place, test and prove themselves, and then...
58:37 If it was successful or they needed further support, then in subsequent years they would be eligible for funding.
58:43 And it did look like you took into consideration that first-year funding applicants could present a compelling reason why they should be funded. Yes, they could. I'm going to back that up because, you know, I've found that just as far as putting in events, you know, the best thing you can do is just get it under your belt just to kind of help identify if there is going to be a marketplace for it and whether you want to do it. You know, the smaller the event, the first year, when I first saw that, I likewise had the same concern. But on further consideration,
59:13 I actually like the idea that it's, you know, you've got to get one under your belt just to get a feel for, you know, what kind of event are you trying to do? So, anyway, I just, I likewise had concern about not funding first-year events, but upon further consideration, I think we're going to get much stronger applications just even if they do get the first year, even if they have ten people who attend.
59:37 That first year event, they get an idea for identifying what their audience is, what's going to make them, it helps them develop their business plan a little bit. Exactly. And then I think we also looked at other entities that offer grant programs or scholarships, and that is not unusual to make sure that an event is tried and true before funding is provided. Apparently grants don't go to. I don't think we wanted to wait five years for an event to prove its success.
1:00:07 Sorry. The committee didn't want to wait, you know, for a long period of time, but they thought at least one year for, as Sean mentioned, to have an event take place and to see that they're committed to offering something instead of a lot of fly-by-night kind of organizations coming forward and taking money because we did feel like it was a competitive type of a process.
1:00:35 My problem is I've always viewed this as sort of seed money, and many good ideas would not get off the ground without that initial. Now later it does say that their applications can be heard, so my only input on that first one, one-time event and first-year events are both opportunities, and I would hate to create a black and white situation where opportunities had no venue to come forward.
1:01:04 The Rolling Stones say they'll do a one-time concert in Mammoth and we need 10 grand to get them here. I would hate to preclude that because we've created a black and white scenario. So as long as in the later versions where it is talked about one year events can come to a specific meeting to plead their case, as long as we keep that open... Except for if you're saying that they are not going to be funded here and then...
1:01:35 Well, but they're not going to see this. I understand that, but if that's what's on here, then... Well, I think they will see the guidelines, you know, for funding. They will see all of this, you know, once it becomes finalized. And it is asterisked that there would be an opportunity for them to present their case. I don't see that asterisked.
1:02:01 Well, it's asterisked on, the task force will not fund, and then on that part is asterisked. Near the top of page. So not each individual item is not asterisked. No. Okay. Yeah, maybe that's, the asterisked belongs. It's really any event, right? But specifically for first year event. And again, it's, you know, it's not overly black and white. I mean, we looked at some examples and kamikaze bike games, you know, could be considered a first year event, but it's really not. But, you know, he's...
1:02:29 Here's an example that an event organiser is coming forward and considering funding. Great. I think that's an opportunity for that to come forward. And I think there were several others that we talked about as well. But I think there was some good discussion on it. And I kind of, as a facilitator, was very supportive of where the committee went for that.
1:02:51 You know, since the asterisk is there, you may want to change your asterisk as to where it is down here and put it actually next to the item that it refers to because it does not refer to a one-time program, just the first year event. It's only first year. And so maybe that's where it needs to belong. Because I do still have a concern on that. Yes, your point, Sean, is valid, but I think that that's, you know, truly why there's money there is to bring new.
1:03:20 Events that can have a good history. For the one time, it needs to go in that same asterisk. Put an asterisk that could do that as well. I have no problem with that. And then I just want to make sure that I'm clear that it's the Measure U Application Committee that decides what's a compelling reason. That's correct. And the task force all were supportive of this element being excluded. Would you guys consider putting the asterisk there for the...
1:03:51 First year event and one time event. I agree. I think that's what added to the one time event as well. Yeah, I think everything that the commission's bringing forward today on including in their staff report. So it'll be a little section, Recreation Commission recommendations. So absolutely want to capture as much feedback as you can. Well, does everybody feel that way? I mean, you know, I agree that I think the asterisk probably belongs under one year event because that's what the asterisk refers to on page 407.
1:04:23 The question is for consensus. Do we agree or disagree on a one-time event, depending on the event? Or should we just exclude it? No, you know, your point, the what if, you know, Rolling Stones is on the way here and going to do a one-time show, you're right. I think that it could be there. And, you know, Terry, I'm not, you know, with regard to the first-year event,
1:04:46 I could take that argument both sides. So I have no problem if you wanted to. Well, as long as it's something that can be considered, I'm happy with that. Yeah. I just see the benefit in having an event. You know, the first year we did Hop and Sage, I just wanted to get it under, you know, get it done just to have it actually happen. So, and we learned a lot the first year. So, I could go either way on that.
1:05:12 I'm comfortable with the asterisk, and I think, you know, just saying, you know, present a compelling reason and then your application can be considered. For the one-time event as well? For the one-time event as well as the first-year event. You know, if I could say something along those same lines, and I'm going to jump ahead, is item number six, Roman numeral six on four of seven, that a for-profit organization should not be excluded, but they can only apply for 10% of their event's budget.
1:05:37 You know, let me say something along these lines. Blueza Palooza this year, you know, obviously is a for-profit event, but we had six different non-profits involved. The three different bars, the CCBA, which was the overall events organized, the bar beneficiary, the Rotary High School Interact Club. Those six different organizations, we believe, made a total of $30,000. Those non-profit entities.
1:06:07 that had specific tasks within a for-profit event. We believe acquired over $30,000 between all six of those events at a for-profit event. So I would make the argument that a for-profit event, for instance, can be just as beneficial for non-profit entities as a non-profit event.
1:06:34 And I just want to say that I'm a little hesitant. I want to ask, you know, would like to see the asterisk perhaps be applied to that Roman numeral six as much as the items up there on that we were talking about, the eligibility requirements. Can we just finish doing the not funding and then we'll move down to that one? Okay. I'm sorry. I agree. We're still on three. Yeah, I have some questions there as well. Okay.
1:07:03 Yeah, I have another one on the events that expect to receive a majority of event funding from Measure U can't apply for Measure U funding. Well, the committee felt that, once again, Measure U shouldn't be their only funding source. They should have other options. There should also be
1:07:28 They should have done their homework. They should have a business plan. They shouldn't be relying solely upon Measure U to fund their events. So should that be a percentage as opposed to the majority of so that there's an actual percentage that you're looking at? It was pretty specific. I think the committee went around with that question, too, and they were just happy with majority, so it could just be more than 51, right, more than 50%, just the majority of funding. And I think it goes back to the question in the application form, and it really comes down to
1:07:59 If this is your only funding source, will this event be conducted if Measure U funds are not awarded? I think that really spells it out that it should not go on. The public funds should not be used to solely fund a special event. So I think that's where the committee were coming from there. Maybe you should refer to item 5 because it actually says a maximum of a certain percentage can be funded. So as opposed to a majority.
1:08:29 Maybe you can just refer that down to five. I don't know. Yeah, because you're saying we're not going to fund more than 30 percent of an event regardless, so I don't know that we need to say that events that expected to be received, because we're going to knock them out in five. They're not going to get the majority of their money from Measure U. I just thought that was a little too ambiguous, I guess. So you're suggesting that it's, say, 30 percent?
1:09:03 20. It could say, you know, you could even leave it like it is and then just put, please refer to item 5, you know, and then it just, they can look at that and go, oh shoot, I'm only going to be able to get 30% or 20% and it's our 10 or whatever, so it shouldn't move forward. So that was. And I would agree with that. I had two other females on the 3 section. Item 3.
1:09:34 One organization events that receive line item budgetary support from the town. And I've always agreed with that and I've always held the line on that. So this is just for sake of argument, if you will, because my position really hasn't changed. But it becomes tough. What if it is a quality event that for budgetary reasons has simply been cut out of funding?
1:09:59 Then they, I guess they would no longer be receiving funding. That's right. And they would get no funding at all, and we would not consider their funding. Wouldn't, wouldn't it be okay to get funding as long as the town's not funding it that year, or has it ever been funded? Is that? No, it's kind of, if it's, if it's a kind of, the way I interpret it, if it's a current budget. Okay, so if you're scared to receive funding, it's really the double dipping thing, right? Yeah. Right. I think we need to just add the verbiage in there so that it's understood that it's not a double dip.
1:10:27 And not necessarily pertaining to other. The other one I have is events hosted outside of the town of Mammoth Lakes Urban Limit. That urban limit is pretty small. If it was a big event, they got a Forest Service permit to go on at the old elementary school site or at any number of other sites in the forest that are on the trail system, especially for recreational events. I would rather see it events. We didn't say town limits.
1:10:57 Because we know that there are events that are expanding on that. It's just not countywide. Because we talked about, like, the man with the bishop race. Well, how about the track? It's one of the most restrictive lines. When you want to say the planning boundary? I would say sphere of influence. Yeah. Because what about the track? If there was something to come up with that? Yeah, Whitmore. Right, that's way out of the urban limit. So I had an issue with that one.
1:11:25 Obviously, we don't want to promote, or not to promote, but to pay from events that benefit other areas, because that's not what we're in the business of. I just think we need to change the verbiage on that so that it talks more about the needs to be a benefit to the town of Mammoth Lakes rather than specifically where it's being hosted, because there are several sites that could be considered down the road that would...
1:11:56 And the track is one of them. I don't even know if those fall in our, and John's not here, he's the best on that. Our sphere of influence line goes as far as Whitmore and, you know, yeah, so even sphere of influence doesn't belong. At least a town owned or town.
1:12:16 Managed property. Because we got Forest Service people, you know, we do it now. So maybe, maybe the other question is not so much that, is it? So if these are town funds, you know, what's the recommendation for using those town funds? Benefit of Mammoth Lake. The town, so is it something that we just say that? I mean, is it something that, is it something told in June Lake, Crowley Lake, Horseshoe Lake?
1:12:41 I mean, how do we, you know, I mean, that was where the committee really wrestled with, and we spent a lot of time on, probably an hour on it, but really how to, how to define, so if they're town funds, what's the best use, and how do you really define where those funds can be used? And how do you, how do you objectively measure that? I mean, how do you objectively say that, yes or no? Can we say something that just says, events that benefit the town of Mammoth Lakes? Mammoth Lakes, yeah.
1:13:07 Because, you know, it's something that I've always argued with events, whether Measure U is going to fund line items, it's going to, you know, is that it has to be of benefit to Mammoth Lakes. Now, what is the definition of benefit? The chamber music folks, you know, it may never make money on its own, but it sure is a benefit. But something like kamikaze bike races,
1:13:35 benefits the town in the TOT that it brings to town. So I suppose we would be leaving it somewhat subjective with such a definition, but, you know, I think that that would work. Well, I think, like Stu mentioned, I think we were thinking more of, like, June Lake. The June Lake Triathlon, would that really qualify for funding? Or, and we did talk about that event, the Mammoth to Bishop bicycle race.
1:14:03 You know, it started here, but, you know, so. But both of those are events that we have helped fund. That's what we're saying, yeah. So under this, we would not help those events. That's right. And, you know, I think that, you know, must benefit the town of Mammoth Lakes. I think that they have to present what that benefit is to the town of Mammoth Lakes. And you give that, those, you know, events the opportunity.
1:14:32 to make that case. Right, because the June Lake Triathlon people can actually draw a direct correlation to room nights here in Mammoth. Yep, they can. So probably what we'd say there is that events that do not benefit the town of Mammoth Lakes. Right. Yeah. Do not directly benefit the town of Mammoth Lakes. Then I would like that. Not fund events that do not... Directly benefit the town of Mammoth Lakes. Okay, so it's kind of a double negative there, but... Because he's saying, what means you will not fund events that do not...
1:15:00 Yeah, you see what I mean? Okay. That makes sense. Okay. So I am going to call this out by number because Sean keeps getting ahead of us. Anything else on three there? I see no IV. Does somebody not know how to count? Must have been something that was taken out or something. Three to five. There you go. Yeah. Any problem with number five? I just thought the numbers, the percentages were actually fairly generous.
1:15:28 When I was looking at other grant applications from other communities, I thought that was pretty generous. And I guess what I haven't seen in all of this discussion, and it's a discussion for probably the Measure U Committee to bring up, is that, you know, how much money should be spent on something like this? Or actually, should we be buying a stage instead of funding any special events?
1:15:55 You know, in this manner, or is it that we bring it down to a smaller amount so that we're only doing a very small amount for actual money grant application and that we're actually looking at helping people out with capital items like stages or sound systems or barricades or, you know, whatever it is that they need lighting. So anyhow, because if you read the actual measure you to start with, the ordinance.
1:16:25 That's kind of the intent as opposed to actually seeding events, but that's just something that I want to bring up, that it needs to, you know, be a discussion at some point, and so anyways. But I thought these percentages were fairly high. And just to echo what Terry's saying, you know, as I was reading through this, and I think the committee did really great work, but I wouldn't want anyone to misconstrue this as a shift in the measure you...
1:16:49 Being more event focused. I don't think that's where we want to go at all. I think we're just trying to more carefully define the parameters when Measure U does fund events. Now having, I mean, Bill was on the Measure U committee that formed some of the discussions with respect to funding, and I think the committee clearly did not want to allocate money to either, you know, the three, the transportation, recreation, arts, and culture, and they were reluctant to also
1:17:19 Put money aside for capital, you know, buildings versus events or supplies. You know, so maybe you're right, maybe it's up to the Measure U Committee to kind of take a look at that and maybe limit the amount of money that is allocated to special events. That's all we were focusing on, events. Yeah, and we were trying to clarify how people could apply, and I appreciate that. You guys have done great work, but I just...
1:17:46 With looking at this, I just want to bring that back up because I think it needs to be discussed. As a member of the committee, and we have discussed it somewhat but not come to a recommendation, I believe that we need to set a maximum amount out of each year's funding when we do our priorities. And that will be what's available. In terms of 30% being a lot, I agree with you, it is a lot. But again, I'm a guy that hates to set those arbitrary ceilings so that if there is something spectacular and you need to fund them to that level, you can't do it.
1:18:14 So I think the 30 and the 20 and the 10 gives us that wiggle room necessary to bring in the events that are going to do the most good, whether it is cultural or whether it is, you know, dollar or whether it is quality of life.
1:18:30 Just because it says we can fund 30% of the budget doesn't mean the committee is going to fund 30% of the budget. I think this gives us the guideline, and I'm hoping, and there's heads nodding out there, so I am hoping that we set up a far lower limit on events total, recreation and arts, than what we gave out in the past year. But what this would allow, though, 30% for a second and third year event, so once they've already...
1:19:00 Gotten their first year under the belt, their belt. I mean, if they have equipment needs, marketing, supplies, insurance, et cetera, could be used for that. But you're right, it could be up to 30%, it could be less. It's fine, I just voice typing. Yeah, and that's actually addressed in number, Roman numeral 11, it looks like, a little bit anyway. See, there you go, jumping ahead, I apologize. Back it up. Yeah.
1:19:32 Don't give us the whole steal again. Are we talking about number six? Yes. Well, speaking of your argument, though, with respect to the Bluza-Palooza event, would, as an organizer, would you have offered those services in lieu of those voluntary groups that came forward? What do you mean? I'm sorry. Well, you made a point of saying that there were, you know, ten
1:20:02 groups that benefited from participating in the event because they generated about $30,000, which is terrific. But is that something that as a sponsor you would have offered that in lieu of voluntary groups coming forward? You mean provided the services for? You know, let's see. In some cases, for instance, the bar beneficiary. One of the reasons why we did not move
1:20:32 Blueza Palooza up to Canyon Lodge was because we would not have been able to have a bar beneficiary. We would not have been able to participate in the bar proceeds nor would our non-profit bar beneficiary. So the California Craft Brewers Association was the direct bar beneficiary from sales at the bar. We had the hospital's cancer support group, DSES, and the firemen.
1:21:01 Who actually ran the bar and all tips that went into their tip jar. None of that would have been able to happen if it had happened at a private venue up on the mountain. So that was one of the reasons why we didn't even take it up there. Does that answer your question? So, yes, we could have, I mean, that would have been a negotiating point with the mountain to get that free venue or to get that reduced price venue. No, I'm saying would that have been revenue that you would have generated? You would have?
1:21:30 generated if you didn't allow? Yes. The simple answer is yes. We would have benefited from that. In some ways, it's so much easier to turn over just the bars being run by. That way, we don't have to worry about it. The parking, now, you can't have for-profit parking on a closed public right-of-way. So that had to be a non-profit. But again, if it was up at a private location like Canyon Lodge,
1:22:00 Where they were able to charge premium parking, that would have been an added revenue stream if we were at a private location. So the argument could be made that by turning it over to a non-profit entity, we don't have to worry about it. That's just one less thing off our plate. But it's also a loss of revenue from that. So you could make that argument. Does that make sense?
1:22:30 Are you looking to increase the 10% and have if they can give a compelling reason why they should receive more money that it's a possibility? Is that what you were trying to say? I guess what I'm trying to say is that it's difficult to say what is a non-profit. For instance, and I can't remember, I think it was Sandra D. Domizio who made the comment earlier at one of the meetings about some of the events that come forward claiming to be a non-profit, but they're really
1:23:00 A for-profit, but they're actually using a non-profit as their bar beneficiary like we are doing. So I would actually argue that, again, if the Rolling Stones come to town, Bill, it's not going to be a non-profit that's bringing them to town. It's going to be a for-profit entity. So I would almost strike the language of for-profit, non-profit. We had this discussion with regard to holding events in the village.
1:23:29 Because they are a non-profit but non-ticketed. The Village Fest is a non-profit but it's also a non-ticketed event. So they've got these different levels. So the kind of community benefit that the Village Fest is bringing to town is that it's free outdoor music, which is a great benefit, helps bring people to town.
1:23:56 But they're not able to generate any money from tickets coming in. So I would actually suggest striking language with regard to giving preference to a non-profit versus a for-profit altogether, just strike language, and instead weigh the merits of an event based on what they're trying to do, whether or not they include non-profits in the revenue streams that are happening at a for-profit event.
1:24:25 I mean, all of these points can be made on an individual basis, and I would hate to, like Bill Sauser says, put limits on who we're giving to what just because they're either for-profit or non-profit. I don't think that they're precluding a for-profit. I don't think they're saying that one is weighted over the other, other than the amount of money that they can possibly get for their event. There's a 10% cap. And so I guess I, you know, to...
1:24:54 I don't have a problem with keeping that at 10% and you could do the same, you know, asterisk and that they can present a compelling reason to increase that.
1:25:06 If there's something that came up that says the Rolling Stones are coming to town and we need this to bring them here, it's going to bring, you know, bring this much money into town and da-da-da-da-da. If the Rolling Stones are coming into town, they're going to have enough funding and they're not going to need Measure U to support it. Oh, yeah, that's not true. Measure U application degree. Well, you'd be surprised. And the more I learn about the events business, that it really does take some kind of commitment from, you know, private-public partnership
1:25:35 Or some kind of, I don't want to say guarantee, but it's certainly cash flow putting money up front to really seed the event going forward. So, you know, that's why I'm actually hearing what Bill and Terry were saying with regard to why we may want to consider first year or one time events for funding, not just specifically exclude them. So I just want to say that with regard to, you know, whether it's Dave Matthews or, you know, Rolling Stones or whoever it may be.
1:26:04 If the king donates his time, you still have to get him here, you still have to manage the event, there are still expenses that are uncovered even if he's... But if there's a commercial entity or a group that is for profit, they're going to be benefiting financially from this event. Some of the other towns that we looked at, they don't even fund commercial entities for events. So we thought that...
1:26:31 You know, commercial groups and for-profit groups should not be excluded, but there should be a limit on the amount of money that they receive because they're businesses and they're running it for that particular purpose. And actually that's very true in all the ones that I read. It's basically a for-profit, if there's a for-profit event, most of them are saying, go speak to your business partners within your community and get some funding for your event. But that is, you know, in a lot of those.
1:27:01 Applications. But I'm okay with 10% being there at least. I'm fine with 10% being there too. And let's face it, I mean, we can certainly have a for-profit event coming forward and saying, well, we're partnering with a non-profit. I mean, you know, they'll find a way around it if that's what it's going to take to get there. Which is, I think, what happens. Yeah, I still, and if this is the way it goes, it's fine. I have no problem with the 10% because probably I'm not going to want to approve anybody who's asking for more than 10% of the budget regardless whether they're profit or non-profit.
1:27:30 I do have a problem with considering Mammoths, and Mammoths specifically, non-profits different from their profits. We have one very successful for-profit event in town, and that's Bluza Palooza. The rest of the stuff that Sean puts on probably doesn't make much money. He's a for-profit that loses money on the events he puts on. A better example would probably be the Margarita Festival. That's a for-profit event simply because it's been put on by a business. However, it's probably no more for-profit than the Village Fest.
1:28:00 Which is intended to get people in the village spending money in the stores, yet it's a non-profit group that puts it on so we can fund it at a higher rate than we can fund the Margarita Festival, which does the same thing. And both cost money. Neither one can make money. So why do we discriminate? Because one's being operated by a group that doesn't hold a 501c3. One other comment along those lines is that if any...
1:28:30 Event is accepting money. I believe, and correct me if I'm wrong, that they do have to share their books with, it becomes public record, correct? So in a lot of ways, again, that's why I would be hesitant to put any kind of ceiling or any kind of restrictions on it and leave it a little bit more assessing the needs on a case-by-case basis.
1:28:54 After we were able to review their books, because again, it becomes public record, and whoa, you made a lot of money here. You definitely don't need our help. Hey, glad you had a successful event, but you definitely don't need any more money from us. So again, but one thing I do want to say that you actually struck a note with me was that if you're saying that there is precedent out there at other municipalities that they do not fund any for-profit, and if that's the case, then...
1:29:20 There is. I actually pulled up a bunch of them, too. That's pretty much what all of them say is, talk to your businesses. Is that right? Well, in that case, I'll just remove the arguments altogether. I have no problem with it because we've left it in at 10%. And that at least gives us something. And the Measure U Committee, if it feels necessary, can also always make an exception. These are guidelines, not fast and hard rules.
1:29:45 So I, I, well then why do we spend four meetings and a lot of time and energy putting together guidelines if they're not going to be followed? I mean, these are going to be adopted by council, aren't they? Yeah. So. And I think in, and you're right, rules can be broken. That's right. But it shouldn't be arbitrary. I don't think there is. Well, yeah, and I never said arbitrary. No, no, no. Okay. Thank you. Okay. Any other comments? Moving on to page five of seven.
1:30:19 and going on to 7, or is there anything on that page, starting with 7 to 10, that you have questions or want to cover? I think one thing that we did talk about, though, is the surveys that should be conducted. We talked about 50 being the minimum, but then we also talked about 100 was a better sampling, so I see both numbers here.
1:30:42 Right. I read it. 100 would be better. We'd aspire to 100. Minimum is 50. But a sample size is 100. But if they only have 45 people at the event, 40 would be asking too much. I almost think that needs to be a percentage of people in attendance. Because usually you can get 4% of your people to fill out surveys. I think that was the last number I read in some publication somewhere.
1:31:05 But I really like the idea of conducting the surveys electronically, having somebody with an iPad at the event to capture the surveys.
1:31:14 Once an event's done, it's really hard, I think, to go back. That's a good Measure U application is to get that iPad or measure or whatever. I mean, I personally would like to see some Measure U funds going toward more capital things. Absolutely. We had a lot of money going to special events this year, so we had a very successful year of special events. What was the total amount from Measure U that went to actual special events this year? Do you want recreational and arts? Yes. What was the total amount that came from public funds?
1:31:44 that went to fund, that went specifically to events. That's sitting on my dashboard. I'll have to look it up, but it was over $300,000. That's a lot of money, Betsy, just to, you know, just go into line items for, and I think that from the majority of the Measure U people that I've heard this year is that next year it needs to go more to capital.
1:32:07 Yeah, I mean, events are great, but I'm just thinking that at this point it's more worthwhile to invest in something like a stage and permanent venue. My only notes on page five was on number nine, or IX for those of you that are not Romans. Local versus out of town always confuses me in there is, and I've seen several events this year where our lodging numbers weren't that great, but the town was definitely full.
1:32:34 Which means they attracted a lot of second homeowners, perhaps, and fewer out-of-towners, and we still, I think, as a town are unsure how to equate the value of the event and second home, so I just put that down, you don't get DOT, you do not. But you get sales tax, you get utility tax, which is... And you get the quality of life. Is a second homeowner a local, or is he a tourist, or is he some hybrid?
1:33:03 And I'd really love to see some kind of definition of that. Nothing that, you know, because no two people are alike, but it's just one of those things I keep questioning when it comes to benefit. Moving on. We did the 50 to 100 already. Yeah, I jumped ahead. Sorry. So moving on to number 11. Comments? I had a question on the consensus to consider hiring a seasonal special event coordinator. I did too.
1:33:36 Was the thinking that that funding would come out of the Measure U 4% administrative fund, or would it be the additional permit cost? Administration is only managing those funds, so I think that really the consensus here is you can just see how vast the undertaking is, that the town's involved and also the event organizers and the coordination that's required to put on a lot of these events.
1:34:04 So this was specifically from Measure U to support special events. And not only, as it says here, the town's commitment, but also working with all the event parties, partners in tourism. And then, as you can see, it's currently what I and my park superintendent are doing. So again, you've got a little bit of percentage of time.
1:34:26 If that's satisfactory for everybody, then that's the way it's going to be. But you can see it's rapidly expanding and events are becoming a big, big part of our summer business in TOT. So I guess it's really asking the question of as summer events grow, how do we want to manage and how do we want to maximize their impact to the town? That's an easy question for me. As these events grow, TOT grows with it. TOT grows general fund. If general fund grows, then certainly the town should be providing staff.
1:34:55 Out of the general fund to cover, and it wouldn't even take all the TOT that's being generated, I promise you, by these events, to do that. So I think that's a pretty, for me, personally, and I jumped in there before you guys, sorry, I try not to do that, but I get so excited sometimes. To me, it's a no-brainer that staff should be provided by town in general.
1:35:17 to do those things because should it be used to? Maybe not. I'm fine. I'm happy to do it. I enjoy it a lot. It's very time consuming. It's a lot of time. And an already busy time. That's what I'm saying. I'm just not giving it to you credit. Just because Measure U is being successful in creating TOT generation for the town of Mammoth Lakes doesn't mean we should be charged back for that success.
1:35:41 I had a question of that too and I felt that it should be number one I don't think it would really be efficient if it's a seasonal position because I think that there's a lot of history and knowledge that you have that makes things go smoothly so I think that it needs to be a town position that is there and then also you know I don't know is it really something that Parks and Rec should be doing or is that a community development through their permit process that really should be
1:36:11 Something that goes into, and actually I think it may have been there way back when, and then it got changed over to Parks and Rec. So anyhow, I think that it really lies within the town and that it needs to be something that General Fund is funding and that it's a position through the town, whether it's recreation, whether it's community development, I don't know, but anyhow.
1:36:34 Well, I also did like the idea, too, of tiering the permitting because, you know, there are some events that take, you know, a lot more, you know, time. Actually, I think that's a great idea. I mean, I currently deal with the permitting. Yeah. And that's a lot of my time. Yeah, exactly. I mean, you brought the pancake. The pancake breakfast is spelled out. Yeah, it's minimal versus something huge. It's minimal compared to, you know, Sean's Bluza Bluza. Or the half marathon. Mammoth Green Company's Bluza Bluza. No, that's right. Mammoth Green Company's Bluza Bluza. Again, I would pose the same question.
1:37:02 If an event is complex enough that it's requiring more time, if it's a successful event, it's creating income for the tenant. Should we be charging them more money because they're creating income for us? That's sort of double taxing them. They're creating TOT, they're creating sales tax, they're creating, yet we want to charge them a larger fee.
1:37:23 That's true. But it's taking more of staff time to do it, and we just keep asking staff to do more and more and more and not giving them any more resources. I'm not saying we should hire more staff for it. Or give them resources. Well, maybe you look at what the, I mean, this is what they do with, you know, a construction permit, you know, depending on how much time it takes for that construction permit, that's what the price of that permit is. And it should be. And so you could do the same thing with a
1:37:51 Event Permit. And I don't think that any event organizer is going to balk at having to pay more to permit road closures and things that, you know, involve cooperation. I don't know. I'll block at that. You know, it is. It's so tough. And I've got to say, with regard to Bluza Palooza, the more, I feel like the more successful we've gotten, just the only thing that's done is made our expenses that much higher.
1:38:12 I can tell you that actually our cost of goods of putting on that event and our profit on that event has actually gone down the past couple of years, even though the size of it has grown because our cost of putting on that event has become so much more expensive. Sam Walker used to be very generous with the use of his site. He's not as much anymore because he's seen what we are doing with that event site.
1:38:41 And the comment that I've made in the paper, and I'll say it here for the public record, is that that is one more reason why I would love to see the town acquire it, so that if I'm going to be paying money for it, for that site, I sure would like to see that money actually go into capital improvements so I don't have to be putting up and taking down fences every year, lighting every year, bringing in the porta-potties. You know, those expenses, for Bluza Palooza to do that for one weekend, six digits.
1:39:11 For all the amount of labor that went in there for creating a temporary village for 6,000 people. So if I'm going to have to pay Sam Walker and Kurt Odecker and Dennis Hartman, and thank you very much, you know, since this is a public record, to them for allowing us to use that site, I'm not complaining as much as I'm saying that I'd rather be paying for capital improvements to that site rather than just rent. We are going to have to ask. I apologize. Bring it on back. Anyway, at that point. So I think you will.
1:39:41 I still think tiering may be something that we look at at some point. Staff does have metrics. I've been tracking my involvement this year with all these events. Like I said, we talked about this before, and we're certainly going to bring it up. We'll come back to the commission in regards to the town's involvement. And you'll see it's quite extensive. So that's all. Yeah, absolutely. So my question mark is on the tiered part as well.
1:40:14 Any other questions? Nope, I already brought up my other comments. We would move this forward with the comments we've made to the Major U Committee. Yep. And I get to have all these same arguments all over again. Any comments on the application form itself? Is there anything? Well, it goes along the same guidelines, so I would say the same comments go along. Yeah, that's correct. The first two pages are the same. It was just, I mean, you can see that the committee spent, you know, considerable time looking at the
1:40:44 Application Form, trying to trim it down. So any comments that would be great, we can move those forward. Yeah, I had a couple of comments on it, actually. Okay, sorry. Number one, on page four, identify how your event aligns with measure U priorities established by the time it says check all that apply and probably should say and cite example. Just because someone checks a box saying it exists in current plans and studies, I'd like them to tell me.
1:41:15 What current plans and studies it is in, if that makes sense for you all. The budget was covered. I didn't see it the first time I read it. Actually, you know what? Are you guys asking for the full budget? Yeah, and the previous year's actual. Okay. We're asking for proposed for this year and actual for previous year.
1:41:38 Okay, because it says how the funds will be utilized here, but you are specifically asking for the budget. Okay. Yeah, on page four, number five, proposed event budget and previous year's actual budget. Right. Over on page five, number two, identify the event goals. And this, just to me, someplace in here, what I would like to see is the question.
1:42:09 As to how they would, what does it take to make it a successful event for them? So it's the same question, it's just a little bit different. So when I'm engaging them next year, one of the things we get all the time is people coming to us and asking us for funds to augment because it's going to make their event so much bigger. Yet we spend those funds and then they become included annually in their costs. Did it make the event bigger? So your goals is what that is, but...
1:42:38 How do we word that so that we get an answer so that they say an event successful is going to be 1,500 people or it's going to be how do they measure success so that we can at least measure them on their own curve for the next go around? Increasing another night's. Right. Extending it to a three-day event instead of a two-day, going into another market, or is that what you're looking at? It's just identify the event goals.
1:43:10 How would you define success for this event? How would you define success for this event? Yeah. I like that. Okay. Yes. Okay. Then on the performance report, the wording there, I had to read it several times. There's just a word missing, I think. All applicants are required to submit a performance report within 90 days of event or prior to the next funding award.
1:43:41 Because by saying just the funding award, you're asking them to provide their performance report before we fund them for this event. Probably prematurely. I think we were thinking it depended upon when the event took place. So most of the event should provide it within 90 days, but if it came close to the next funding cycle. So you're right, maybe the next funding cycle should be clear. Yeah, that's just a verbiage. The intent is there, obviously.
1:44:12 But I had to read it a couple times, and I'm going, well, now, how can I, within 90 days before the... Okay, next. I got it eventually. You need to say whichever comes first. Yeah. Any other questions? Stu, there are a couple typos on part two. Mm-hmm. Identified principle. Which... Oh, there is one more. Oh, shoot, there's one more. Were you asked for the most recent IRS 990?
1:44:46 If it's an organization that's taking in less than 75,000 a year, they don't have to file on 990. So all copy? Yeah. Okay. All they have to do is file a postcard. And I think most of these groups are probably less than 75,000 a year. So we need... Okay. Anything else? Moving on. Moving on. Thank you, Pat. Good suggestions. It was a committee approach, obviously.
1:45:24 Oh yeah, absolutely. My bad. I would like to just give you an opinion about students. Absolutely. Not that it will make a lot of difference, but you know, events are an interesting animal, and certainly I think we've had one of the best summers we've ever had, and we've had more events this summer than I can ever remember in town. I mean, to the point that there's
1:45:53 It's hard to find volunteers, and we have to pick and choose personally. My wife might go over to the art show, and I might go to the golf tournament. You know, and there's just constant things going on. If I relate back to Measure U and the intent of Measure U, and I was on the sales part of this to the community and to the voters. Never once did we tell a voter,
1:46:22 The intention of Measure U was to generate TOT tax. The voters were under the impression that Measure U was going to help fund things like they'd been paying for in the past, and this is a utility user's tax paid for by the residents and the second homeowners. They got parks and recreation in the past, and whenever we talked to somebody, we said, this is for you guys. This is so we can have more
1:46:53 Products, Services and Facilities in the Community. It got twisted into TOT when the town got into financial problems. The town never stepped forward during any of the public conversations and said, hey, this can be a good TOT generator. It was never the intention to fund events. That was never discussed. Transportation to support events and some services were brought up.
1:47:23 At that time. And what it is now is what it is, and we're not going to send it backwards, but I still get asked all the time about, I asked somebody to vote for something, and they did, and they want to know what it's going to benefit. You know, there's a very definite, I think, distinction, and it's easy for me to make, between a for-profit and a non-profit.
1:47:51 In a non-profit, when you file your articles in the corporation and you file the state attorney general, you have to say what your specific purpose of your organization is. And then whatever you do has to tie back to that purpose. A for-profit is completely different. You know, what happens, and I guess an example that I read a lot about in the, we have a little house down in Indio, it's right across the street from where the Coachella Festival.
1:48:21 They don't get any money from the town, but what they do is they negotiate services and conditions that help them become a more sellable product. And I think those are the kind of things when we look at how do we look at events in the future and how much money should events get and whether profits and for profits are going to bring value to the community.
1:48:50 I think there's other things that come into play that make it easy for an event producer to put things on, and there's very good examples with other major events. I've told Sean I'd love to see him take the event, instead of just trying to grow it as big as it'll go, spread it out over two weeks and get it up to a very comfortable level that brings more people into town and he can utilize the...
1:49:20 Overhead that he has to bring in over more than a one-week period. You know, as this goes forward, there's likely going to be a cap on events. And I think as you guys look at facilities, you look at this concept of mammoth recreation, each of those entities has talked about
1:49:55 being funded with Measure R and Measure U. It's only going to stretch so far. I'll give you an example. The only way I see facilities being funded in the future is some kind of bonding that's guaranteed out of Measure R or Measure U or a combination of those things because the town certainly isn't going to be in a cash position.
1:50:23 And it's going to be interesting to see if the town can even bond with the situation they're in now. But if you were to take even, say, a $2 million debt, you're looking at probably $160,000 to $200,000 a year in a payment on that through a bonding process. And I tend to agree that we need to look at things that maybe are more of a capital nature.
1:50:53 But you've got to have the programming to go with the capital program to make sure that those things are successful. And all these things have to be thought out and looked at how they fit together. And I think what you're doing now is right. You're setting some parameters and you're setting some guidelines. So when people come in to ask for something, they know what they're going to do. But I really believe this is going to change down the line.
1:51:22 Different conditions that come to play. And I guess that's my two cents with this. And I'm not asking you to change anything. I'm just saying keep an open mind to how this comes forward. Sean brought up the bars. The ski area takes the bar business because they pay the operating overhead. They pay to keep the building open. They pay to do the maintenance and repairs. If the town owns a facility,
1:51:50 And when you get around to looking at that facilities report and you look at some of their projections in there about how they pay to operate that, the biggest source of revenue is food and beverage. That doesn't go to outside organizations. That stays within the municipal guidelines to pay the operating overhead of that facility. Those are all things that are going to come to a head, but they all have to be looked at together.
1:52:20 And I thank you for the work you guys do. I read that facility's report. It took me five hours to go through that thing. And I know you guys have a lot of stuff like that to deal with, and it's hard to put it all together sometimes. Thank you. By the way, your point was well taken with regard to what was the intent for Measure U money, and I think that that should be overarching in our discussions with regard to events that, you know, Measure U,
1:52:50 Was not necessarily, or not even spoken specifically, to go to events, was it? Any other audience member wanted to discuss this before we move on? Okay. Going on to number four. Review the 2013 R process and timeline and applications. Okay, Chair, so what we've got here is our second stab at the Measure R4 award. Since the last meeting,
1:53:22 We revised the timeline just to factor in additional time based on the coordination with Measure U and also to receive feedback and any recommendations from the Council on October 2nd on that cycle. So we can kind of look at that revised timeline. What we also need to look at today are the funding priorities. If that's something we want to
1:53:50 Tackle today because on October 2nd that meeting with Council is for that purpose to really discuss those funding priorities concurrently with Measure U as well. But primarily that's our task today to review and hopefully put forward some priorities for this fall award. What we also have is put together the town proposed Measure R applications. It's listed in the staff report and also in the attachment.
1:54:18 And then also, not also, and finally, to review and revise as necessary the application form, the evaluation material, and so forth. So I know we wanted to put a lot of time into this, and we've already spent two hours. I don't know how much time we need, but I think that's kind of why we've added a little bit of time to that measure our timeline, just to consider that. So anyway, I'm just going to send it back to you, and we can probably tackle them.
1:54:48 one item at a time. Okay, so let's start with priorities. This is last year's we have listed, right? That's correct, Bill. Since that time, Provide Nordic Grooming of Cross-Pentry Trails has left a standard Measure R and gone over to the trails, for good, bad, or worse, so probably that should come off of this. Are you guys with me? Yes. Okay. Trails End Park is not done yet, so I think it needs to stay there.
1:55:28 Plan for the future. I think we need to stay there and finish parks, trails, recreation projects that remain incomplete. I wondered if we could change plan for the future to say invest for the future, including an emphasis on setting aside funds for long-term goals because I think we're trying to hold back money and yet it doesn't really show up in our, you know, specifically worded that way in our priorities and I really think that at this point is kind of our first priority. I have no problem with it. That sounds good to me.
1:55:58 So what was the particular wording there, Commissioner? I would say invest for the future, including an emphasis on setting aside funds for long-term goals. I'm glad to hear you say that, because when they haven't talked about a $2 million project, rather than spending a million dollars on the amount of time it takes to plan this, assuming a million dollars on interest, I'd just as soon put aside a half a million dollars each year for four years and cash out the project.
1:56:30 We're going to get more in the long run with that approach. So I am very happy to hear. Could we define it maybe a little bit more instead of it just being kind of open-ended? I mean, just as a goal to reach towards. Otherwise, I can see little by little it's just going to nibble away. Well, we could say long-term goals is set forth and then adopted. No, I mean a dollar amount. Oh, a dollar amount. Or a percentage. Yeah, let's think we need to finish our...
1:56:58 Priorities process before you can really... I would hesitate to put a dollar amount on it just because it does fluctuate from year to year how much is available. I know, but if it's just kind of open-ended, then it's tempting, I think, for other people... We could, and I have no problem with that, other than the fact that when we do things like that, people think it's written in stone. Yeah.
1:57:25 And I always, I'm not a black and white guy. Things that are written in stone bother me because there are always exceptions to rules and you need to make room for those exceptions in emergencies. You could put our aspiration or goals. It's a goal. You know, I wouldn't think set, not hard and fast, but, you know, if we don't even know what our goal is to strive towards, then it's kind of hard. And I think that's kind of what I've heard from a couple of council members, that they're kind of...
1:57:54 Unhappy with, you know, things are kind of vague. We could say invest and save for the future. And, you know, I don't know. You're still not putting a dollar amount, but we're still putting the specifically, you know, invest would be, you know, saving that money. I don't know. I think it just makes it easier to be taken for other things if we don't give a few more parameters to it. And I don't...
1:58:24 Know that I have the answers, but... Because I think Evan brought up a very good point. I think that people are going to be looking at Measure R and Measure U dollars to fund different things that maybe was not the original intent of those measures. And we're already seeing pressure on, you know, on the funds, so... We are, for unintended purposes. I don't know. I'd like just invest for the future. If you wanted to put anything on there, I guess...
1:58:57 Maybe 10%, something like that. I was thinking more 25%. As long as it's not written in stone a number, I have no problem with throwing out a figure like 25%. I guess I was leaning at 10% to keep it so we had some wiggle room. But anyhow. Maybe we could, I mean, because we're having the workshop with...
1:59:18 Council, and is it also the Measure U Committee, if that works out too? So maybe as a group we can all come together and decide on, you know, what kind of a figure, how we want to define that. Well, maybe 10% is a bottom. Maybe we need to put a slide still up 10 to 30%. Yeah. I mean, 10% of a million dollars is only $100,000. That's not much. You know, how long will it take to buy Sam's Wood site at $100,000 a year that we're setting aside? You can put a minimum of 10%. I guess I'm looking that if we're...
1:59:45 Concerned about putting a dollar amount, I was being conservative, so. Well, and I just, I think the reason that I would be concerned about, I like the idea of setting a minimum percentage, it's just that, you know, some years we're going to have really great grant opportunities, you know, that are really going to significantly leverage the funds, so. Well, and using Sam's Woodside as an example, we say we're setting aside 30%, and then we find from the owners of the land that for half a million a year over the next 12 years we could buy the site.
2:00:13 Can we dig into that 10% to buy that site? Because that would be immediate. It wouldn't be planning for the future. So that would be where you don't want that black and white line. But if you say at least a certain percentage, then, you know. I mean, if we ever wanted to bond for something. And actually purchasing property is planning for the future. Well, these are also just our priorities for this year, right? Yeah, that's true. They could change. I say we just leave it as invest for the future. And I have no problem with it.
2:00:45 I like what Betsy added in fund projects, funds for, and set aside funds for long-term goals. And set aside funds for long-term goals, okay. Are you okay with that, Sean? Yes, that sounds good. Because again, these are just priorities and that's a big one and that way we haven't put a limit on it and it's for this year only anyway, correct? Yep.
2:01:15 It ties into spring as well, typically, so it's fall and spring. Principles. The one thing I saw was we need to remove draft from Park and Recreation Master Plan, I believe. Yeah. And then trail system. Both. I also wondered if instead of saying visitor driving projects, we changed that language to say economy driving projects.
2:01:44 I disagree. You know, I think we need to look at quality of life of activities and events because that benefits everybody, visitors and residents alike. Well, and that's actually the point I was trying to make because instead of just saying visitor driving, if we say economy driving projects, then that also can refer to a measurable quality of life benefit that's going to help, you know, stabilize our, you know, workforce.
2:02:11 Create a more stable workforce, because that has an economic component, too. So that way, I thought it would just be a better way of phrasing that instead of just saying solely visitor driving. But when you say economy, to me, that almost means TOT. And I don't know that that's what the Recreation Department and Commission should be about. Well, see, visitor driving, to me, says definitely TOT. I agree with you. This is Measure R. Yeah, I don't think Measure R is...
2:02:35 Well, I understand, but it needs to be, it isn't for one or the other. It's actually kind of the, it's supposed to augment recreation opportunities. Yeah. Right. At this point, I would have more problem just leaving number one off of it completely. Our emphasis on cooperative efforts is good leverage.
2:02:53 And that's always huge. Anybody that can leverage. Emphasis on enhancing recreation. Yeah, that's fine. I'd be fine with that language. I just wanted to get rid of visitor driving. It sounds like there's consensus to do that. Let's get rid of visitor driving and just say quality of life. I actually do like being able to say that, that we are trying to improve quality of life. You know, just to take the example we were just covering, are events a quality of life improving function? They are. Sure.
2:03:17 You know, they also drive people to town, but if we just say, and I actually, Bill, would like to keep emphasis on quality of life projects, let's just change visitor driving to quality of life projects. I'd rather it said emphasis on recreational enhancing, recreation and trail enhancing projects. Well, maybe that's another one. You can add, yeah, a separate principle. You know, maybe there's something. I like that one. Quality of life is just so... It is vague.
2:03:44 But it's beyond vague. But it applies to both. I mean, for residents, for visitors. So why don't we make number two number one? Would you guys have a problem with that? Emphasis on cooperative efforts that significantly leverage, I can't speak, leverage measure our funds? Yeah, as long as we say we're putting it up at number one, not because we value it most, but because...
2:04:08 We're just moving it. Then if you want to put principles not in prioritized order. I would leave with, I would change the language on number one to say either community-based projects or quality of life or, you know, whatever. Well, here's what I wrote, and you guys can decide if this is too economy-focused. I wrote, emphasis on economy-driving projects, which we could certainly change to recreation.
2:04:34 Enhancing. And I wrote, either through increased visitation, TOT generation, or measurable quality of life benefit to, and I said that helps build a strong and stable workforce, but it could be more local focused. Strong and stable community? Yeah, community. It kind of says it all, it's fine. It kind of covers all of it, yeah.
2:04:59 There's a lot there, and I think that we may get criticism for trying to put too much on economy. You know, again, just to move on from this, because we're wordsmithing right now. Let's just, something, emphasis on, what'd you say, recreation, parks and trails? Recreation, okay, on enhancing. Emphasis on enhancing. I like that. Emphasis on recreation and trail enhancing projects. Yeah.
2:05:29 But that's already a priority, in a way. It is. But we're... You know, as a virtual accessible is something that you're striving towards and is more general in nature. Well, then let's say quality of life. I know you don't like it because it's hard to quantify, but so is... Three people think quality of life sometimes. Yeah. I'll go along with quality of life. I like the enhancing recreation and trail. So let's add to both. Yeah, I think both. Okay.
2:05:58 There you go. It's become more verbose instead of less. Well, then you go back to what Betsy had because it kind of said all of that in one thing too, so anyhow. Okay, moving down. Did you get that stoop? Well, I've got emphasis on Recreation Trail Enhancing Projects and emphasis on enhancing quality of life. That's what I wrote down. I mean, do we want to try and capture? Wait, what was the first? Betsy.
2:06:25 Because Betsy was economy and I think it was quality of life. She just gave examples of quality of life. I don't know that we need to do. I think it says the same thing if we put both of those in there. Okay. Yeah. So there's four principles and there's three priorities. Okay. Right. No. No, because didn't we get rid of, there's three priorities. There's three priorities. We got rid of four. And four, we added one. Oh, to be at the bottom. But to be at the bottom, I'm sorry.
2:06:54 Yep. To the bottom we added an extra line for emphasis on... Enhancing quality of work. Enhancing projects. Okay. Sorry. Measure U, remember these will just be comments going to the Measure U Committee. We don't set these. We don't have a problem with it there. Moving on to page three. Is that how you want to do this too? Yeah, you missed the timeline. I didn't know if you had any comments on the timeline. Well, that's because the timeline appears in the next page in my package. Okay, all right.
2:07:29 Paul, I'll get you a rationale. I just had one, and that's the, I mean, the timeline looks fine to me, except that October 10th is a Thursday, so I think maybe that's supposed to say the 8th. Okay, let's go back to, okay, so we have the performance reports, and then we have the maintenance costs, and... Going back to performance reports, why don't we just say 60 days after the completion of the project? Why do we have to say prior to submitting a new application? I think it...
2:08:05 60 days should just, or 90 days or whatever we decide upon. I think it was some go longer than the year. But it says after the completion of the project. But if the project isn't completed prior to them asking for more money for the next phase of the project, I would at least want to report back on how they had spent that money already, so I have no problem with being there.
2:08:28 Sixty days. Or prior to submitting a new funding, somebody actually comes in and their funding actually goes right up to when we apply again. I don't know. I don't think that's a problem. You know, if we ever run into another website contract that doesn't get done and then that organization is looking for their next contract, I'd like at least a call out of what they've done on the previous contract before we reward them. The trap is a project like that too, right?
2:08:57 What's that? The track was also a project like that? Yes. Yeah, the track is still ongoing. And I certainly want a progress report back before I consider giving more funding. So I think it's appropriate to leave it there. And then maintenance was just set by the town. And I guess we agreed to put that $7,000 in attendance. I think we did that in one of our meetings. Yeah. And then we got the third admin funds. And a bit more.
2:09:27 Proposed Town, Measure Our Applications. So this is what you guys are proposing to bring forward for this fall? That's correct. That's why P2C is very patient. We can kind of go through that. There's also the attachment, I think. So there's no information on any of these?
2:09:46 So it depends if you want to tackle the application form and all that first, or you want to do the proposed application. Well, why don't we go there so Peter can speak, and then if he wants to stay for the rest of it, he can. I mean, now he's a little busy. Okay, so we'll go to, I think the attachment is here. So it's probably, I think it's the last section of that. I just thought that was the application, so I apologize, I didn't read. Yeah, so it's this.
2:10:11 Yeah, it's on the back side of the last page of the application, so it's, I think this is probably the best way to go through it. Yeah, it's after 404. Right. That's this right here, okay. Okay, we'll start at the top. Whitmore Pool Capital Enhancements, Pump Room Upgrades, High Efficiency Boilers Pumps, Chlorinator, Internet Hardware for Wi-Fi Access to... That's the point of sale. Point of sale, yeah.
2:10:44 So I'll speak to that one. So our goal next year is to have point of sale at that facility like we are with the facility here at the Multi-Use Facility. And the way the county are proposing to do it is to go off the Internet access at the airport, bounce a site off Doe Ridge, the theater off Doe Ridge, and then swing it down to the top of the pool, which is pretty kind of unique because there's no hard line out there. We don't want to just pay to play on those very expensive plans.
2:11:13 So that would be that cost for that hardware. With budgeted costs in our general fund budget for the purchase of the computer already. So this is really just to pay for the repeaters. And then the other items here, I believe, are already in the capital facilities plan, I believe. And most of these items are actually that they look... Can you do a breakout of number one? Because this says pump room upgrades, including high efficiencies.
2:11:43 Boilers, Pumps, and Chlorinator. So how much of the amount is that? So I mean, the hardware is probably a couple of thousand dollars. So the remaining is the balance of that project. So it's really just replacing. We looked at initially, remember, the analysis of that efficiency of the facility. And a little bit of what this is is the same. So what's the best way to improve the efficiency of that pool in regards to five to 10 years, right? I mean, that's really what we're looking at.
2:12:11 So the idea here was to look at solar, which we looked at. We didn't have the roof for solar. It was inefficient. The wells, I think, we looked at were about $100,000 to tap a geothermal well. So what we came back with is really the best way is to replace that heater in there with a more efficient system. Well, actually, I think we can get two... Two smaller heaters. Two smaller heaters. Similar to the ones we have at the Voodoo Chute and at the...
2:12:39 At the shop last year we put in smaller high efficiency electronic controlled boilers. And so a couple of those similar to those would be highly efficient. You know, kind of the back of the napkin, we didn't do a full analysis, but the back of the napkin review really showed that the solar system, we don't really have enough area unless we want to cover the parking lot with solar panels, which then becomes expensive because of all those bigger structures. The well is expensive because you've got to drill a well.
2:13:09 to get down to the thermal level. I think we still have surface water coming in at 100 degrees at how many feet per second that it never deviates. We cannot use that? Well, and then you've got the heat exchangers that go into that well to do that. And is there enough depth to get enough, to actually create enough heat for the pool? It might be that it'll be enough to do just the kiddie pool, but for the bigger pool, there's a lot of information related to how much heat you need for a bigger pool.
2:13:39 And it really over, you know, it was bigger than what we really have out there without building structures. And the thermal balance really wasn't enough heat to do that. It wasn't even close. That was the back when I can review without doing a full engineering review. You know, the original pump or the heater units were actually primarily purchased with funds we received from Swim Club, as you recall, back in like 99, I think.
2:14:07 They came up with about $8,000. At that time, that's about what they cost, and that was, it's 15 years ago, so that's about the life of that, you know, the pool heater, we've had several problems this year, and so it's on its last legs, we think, as far as the heat exchanger goes, and some of the electronics. We've done some original repairs for it, but essentially, this one team paid for most of the installation of that pool heater at the time.
2:14:39 So the boilers are $22,000 to $25,000, the pumps are $15,000, the chlorinator would be a high-tech chlorinator which would require less of Dennis' time out there on a daily basis to make adjustments. Any more questions on number one? I'm going to run through all of these. I'm going to make questions on all of these right now because there's an awful lot of these that once again...
2:15:10 I feel are supplanting. There's got to be some money that is set aside for capital improvement for existing facilities. And this every year more and more comes just back to Measure R to backfill exactly what, you know, as Evan said, we said wasn't going to happen. And, you know, every year it comes back further and further that these are coming forward. Anyhow. And I also...
2:15:39 I'm concerned that all of these things are, number one, you'll lump them together so that we have to have these things separated out when they're like this. And then also we need the consideration of the county anytime we're looking at anything like this. So anyways, but I have a real concern that I'm looking at this list and
2:15:59 You know, we're supplanting more and more. And then the other thing that I would like to see on here that I'm not seeing is the funds that we set aside previously, and I know we've asked for this before, if we can see that dollar amount. I think it was like $240,000, $240,000 plus for the last fall, and then there was money this last spring too, which was, I can't remember, about $145,000 I think. You want to see that? I want to see it as a line on it. Yeah.
2:16:29 I want to see it as a line item, because otherwise it just gets lost, as Pat was saying earlier. And so I just, we've, we made a conscious effort to put that aside. It's actually in here, it's $291,278.31. Where's that? Is what our, I'm sorry, yeah, it's just in, this information here, I was just, I was just putting the available funds together, but that's the amount that's in my unencumbered. $291? $291,278 is what we're carrying. And, and Commissioner, we, we agree with you. We,
2:16:58 We would love to see these items. I think what we're saying from a town's point of view is these items need to be funded, right? Whether they're funded through General Fund or Measure R, whatever it is, but we're at a point where we need to invest in our existing facilities. So if the commission can advocate to council to help us get these funding, then that's great. But I think the purpose here is just to bring them forward to really identify and prioritize that we really have some needs right now with our facilities.
2:17:28 You know, that's the purpose of why we're doing this. They're just coming forward. We completely understand. But at the moment, none of these items are funded with any general fund monies. And that's why they're sitting here in Measure R. So if we can get them moved aside in a different column, then that's great. But these are priorities that we have identified in our park. And I know that the Commission has gone through that process, too, with our Recreation Facilities Planning, that you've seen all these before, and these are the ones that we've identified that really need the attention.
2:17:57 You know, now. So these are coming off the list that the Commission paired with Hayes and Ray and identified them as capital improvements. But is there another way of bringing them forward? And I get it. You know, you're right. We need to fund these somehow. Totally agree with Terry saying that this needs to come out of, you know, this is replacing equipment that general funds should be paying for. Is there another way of bringing it forward not on Measure R?
2:18:26 Just bringing it forward via Measure R, you know, the public doesn't necessarily understand our position with regard to supplanting, and all they see is us turning down a request for Measure R dollars to put boilers in the Whitmore pool. When really we want to spend Measure R on building a new pool. Well, that's right. That's exactly right. You know, building on a new pool. So I guess is there another way, and you're right, we as the Recreation Commission need to be doing our job and advocating our town counselors to
2:18:55 Pay for the Recreation Department that should be paid out of the general fund. I guess I'm just asking, I feel like there should be another way of doing this other than a Measure R application. Ideally it should go through the budget cycle, you know, ideally. But it's just been such a mess. And I guess the other part of it too is that, you know, when you're looking at the language of Measure R, we're going to get into that debate again about what's maintenance, what's capital, right? Right.
2:19:21 Anyway, um, but that, but anyway, that's why we, that's why these items are in front of you, yeah. And I take, just one last thought on that is, boy, you know, I see with the high efficiency boilers, you know, if we were to actually add something before us that was solar or true heat exchange with geothermal, you know, that's something that I think is very new technology rather than just, um, what you might
2:19:45 Carl, with regard to a high-efficiency boiler, I mean, that's just the way technology is going anyway. Yeah, so the existing boiler is about an 80% efficient boiler, which was kind of the general, generally was available 15 years ago. The new one would be about 94%. Okay. And just, what's the justification for a new chlorinator? I mean, if we're going to look at doing that, do we also want to look at, you know, alternatives like reverse osmosis or, you know, other systems, I know they'd be more expensive. They're changing it to salt.
2:20:13 Well, currently it's a, you know, it's a chlorinator that has been having trouble over the last few years. And we've had, you know, a couple times instances where the health department comes down and we're out of compliance. So this would be really a higher tech one that self-modulates to maintain a certain chlorine level without having to have, you know, dentists. We have had two people that are certified for that now. Well, now that Derek's certified.
2:20:43 Before it was just dentists that could do that, make those adjustments. Because you have to be a pool operator to make these adjustments. Exactly what the pH is at every time, so you can monitor more efficiently. He explained the system to me. I didn't understand quite an upgrade from what we had. Well, I guess I'm just thinking of it in terms of, if we're going to make a change, should we also look at, just like with the high-efficiency boilers.
2:21:09 Would it be better to look at a capital improvement that is just a total change that might be more sustainable in the long run? So this year we did replace all the pumps, I mean the filters, that was included in this year's budget and so that has been done, the pumps need to be replaced, updated. That was general fund money? So out of this $35,000, how much stew is just for the internet hardware? Two.
2:21:36 2,000. We think, you know, I'm still getting that quote from the county, but that's what made us told us so far. It's two repeaters, we think. I mean, two to three. However, that's the equipment. If we have to put a location on Doe Ridge, that placement's going to cost us some money as well. Not to mention the special use permit with DLM to...
2:21:58 Put it up there. Isn't there a repeater there already? Because I think Snarl draws from that. You know, I didn't get into that detail with Nate, but, you know, that's the number he gave me, and I'm assuming he knows what's up there on DOREF, so. My comments on the pump room upgrades and enhancements, if it is brand new technology or something, while I believe it is supplanting, although it doesn't fit the legal definition, as a one-time thing, if we're really gaining that kind of efficiency.
2:22:29 My issue isn't the $35,000 to put the pumps in. My issue is now we've opened the door to the maintenance of the entire facility to Measure R. So I'd really love to see a breakout of all of that and what it is we do gain so that if we can call it new, we can. So that if we felt, and I'm giving no indication one way or the other, believe me, if we felt that it could be funded, we could fund it with a provision that the town then provide the maintenance from that point forward.
2:22:59 And they can either accept that or not. The same thing for me is true of the shady rest. I'd sure like to see a breakout of all of that because some of that I think is supplanted and some of it is enhancing. Actually, I think it's all... That was in CIP. Yeah. So these are... Can we go to number two, the Whitmore track? Yeah. Okay, the bathroom. Now, wasn't that bathroom in there for the ball fields? So they're...
2:23:29 The bathrooms are for the ball fields. The ball fields were utilized really in the summer and the spring when we don't need heat to protect the facility. So what this would be doing is really upgrading for ADA access, but also adding some heat elements so that the pipes, so we can leave the pipes on year-round so people that are using the track have a place to go to the restroom. That's what this is. So once again, I guess the reason I ask that is it is a county.
2:23:57 It matches well, because those bathrooms were there, so we're taking on the maintenance if it's going to be open year-round. You're not having to winterize it, so that actually reduces the cost of that, but you do have maintenance, so it probably is a wash over time. But the ADA is definitely something that we would need to go, and it would be split with the county. Now, do I still think that this is Measure R? That's another question, but that's my comments on that one.
2:24:26 Well, I felt that the ADA was an enhancement. It wasn't a requirement then. I don't think it can fit with regular maintenance because it wasn't a requirement then it is today. ADA is something that the town has to take care of no matter whether we have been here or not. It's something that they have to deal with. It's ADA, it is a legal requirement, and the town and county, depending on the facility, needs to take care of that. So how does that break out, the 25,000? I think the ADA improvements were about 10 and it was 15 to...
2:24:58 To basically winterize the water lines and the fixtures. And I think I might be hesitant to move forward with winterizing until we've really got a plan for the track. Is the track going to be used all year? Are we just going to be throwing away money on heat for a facility no one's using? So the kind of heat that we're looking at is similar to the other parks where it's really a, it would be putting a small slab in so we can embed the heat mill tube.
2:25:28 Heat melt wires. Okay. So that we're just heating enough to keep it from freezing. We're not heating the restroom so that the toilet seat's warm. Okay. Thanks. And where I would differ with you is knowing what happens when a bathroom is closed when the bathroom is there and having had to clean those messes up myself when the club used to do the shady rest bathrooms. Oh, yeah. If that crack's going to be there, that winter and summer, that bathroom needs to be open. Yeah.
2:25:58 How it's paid for. It's with me beyond the point at the moment, but that bathroom needs to be open or we're going to have serious sanitary issues. I think we've actually just put locks on those doors too, by the way. Yeah, they can definitely use some upgrades. So we're just getting that going. So anyway. Moving on. Shady rest capital enhancements. So these are the projects that were listed in the capital improvement program for shady rest and we just packaged them into one. So it would be.
2:26:27 You know, big enough that we can just contract the work out. Those also need to be split out. And I know that when Pat and I met with you guys, I know we talked about, you know, reaching out to the Contractors Association and saying maybe about getting help with snack shack siding or volleyball court edging. And so anyhow, that would still be my thought. But all of these need to be split out so that we know what each individual cost is. And it's an A, B, and C scenario.
2:27:00 Yeah, and I'm assuming they would be, and it didn't have to be an application, but so far we're not asking for the application. Actually, I think they'll split out in the facilities plan, too, and then we were working on Terry. So we added them up and just put them in one. That's what we did. So what happened last time, you know, I go to council next time to either to support or follow up with direction of staff on which ones to submit. Last time, the only applications that went forward were the ones that had full support of the commission.
2:27:28 If it wasn't a 5-0 vote, or at that time, I think there was like four here, then it was not to move forward. Are staff taking the initiative to put this forward, or are you being directed to do this, or you just know that there's no money there, so? That's a question I was going to ask, is how can someone like myself make, ask the town to carry a proposed application, a specific application?
2:27:56 Well, staff sat down and looked at the capital and pre-group program that had been reviewed with the commission and with Dennis to figure out what does he think the priorities are, and then we put together this list based on really on the previous capital and pre-group program that the commission already looked at. This was really put in at our request because not these specific projects, but us town council didn't want to spend staff time.
2:28:23 Preparing a whole bunch of projects for applications that we weren't interested in seeing. So they asked the council that they come forward to us before staff spends all the time creating the applications to see which ones we would like to then have moved forward, not guaranteeing funding because they have to go through the process. So that's what this is. Do we see something here we don't want? Then they don't want to waste.
2:28:49 40 hours of staff time preparing the application. No, that's not my question. I'm actually asking is how can we, for instance, as a commission, ask town staff to...
2:28:59 Consider this specific project. I think that's what we were supposed to do with our priorities so that we can get to that point and say that this is what we'd like to see move forward. We do have that sink again, right? But we do have that information in the next agenda. If we get to it. And if there's others that you want to see, then this is the time to bring them up. I think we need to advocate that these are capital improvement projects that need to be funded through the general fund. Yeah, I'm going to agree with that.
2:29:24 And I think, as you mentioned, Sean, we need to be the advocates and we need to be the ones pushing for this. And, you know, maybe, you know, as you mentioned, it's during the budget time, but I can see that if it doesn't get approved during budget time, then they're stuck. You know, we're stuck for another year and these things maybe not taking place or occurring. So maybe now's the time to start planting the seed. Yeah. Well, are you sitting there for all of these or just for the ones currently? I'm just thinking.
2:29:54 You know, I agree with Terry. Some of these are supplanting. Can I make a suggestion, actually? You know, what I would actually like to see brought forward is the $2,000 for the Wi-Fi access for POS at Whitmore Pool. Not bring forward two or three. Bring forward number four. Number five, I probably have a question on number six and number seven. And that's what I would actually recommend that is brought forward.
2:30:23 with town proposed applications. I would like to ask that community tennis courts rehab not just be thrown immediately into the obligations because I think, Bill, you actually talked about that that's something we need to consider every year and that that actually should be moved up to the proposed town funding applications instead of just assuming... No, I think last time we did a two-year... Was it a two-year? I stand corrected then. I do remember...
2:30:51 For the reason that we don't want them to have to spend the time to do an application for something that we are just going to fund. I'm happy to go either way. I just put it in. Yeah, no, I think for this year, for me anyway, for me that it will all... Actually, I do remember it, so I think our priorities and then we can, you know, figure out where we are from there, but anyhow. Well, in my notes, I would concur with you, other than that I thought the ADA was actually an upgrade and therefore might be available for us, but 4, 6, and 7 with some questions.
2:31:20 Definitely the ones that I see moving forward. Yeah. My question on six was, is this just more planning or does this actually, does that amount of money close the gap? So, yeah, a little bit of history on the gap closure project. We thought we had that fully funded with STIP money, a TE grant. With the new federal legislation on transportation funds, they deleted the TE program. So we currently have a $69,000 allocation that...
2:31:50 in hand to begin the CEQA-NEPA portion of that project. The proposals we received are more than that. So this basically fills the gap so that we can do the NEPA-CEQA and the design so that we can look at other funding opportunities for the construction. The trail construction here, this is purely CEQA-NEPA? Correct. Our proposals were about a little over $150,000 for that.
2:32:20 Part. It's got, for the environmental, just the environmental part without any design work, was 80, a little over 80,000. Which portion is this piece? This is the piece from Snow Creek 7 to Mammoth Creek Park, so it's that whole, this will actually finish our full loop. And that's not on somebody else's property that there's going to be an issue? So we'll be acquiring some right away from the project. Do we already have that right away?
2:32:49 No, it'll be part of the right-of-way. Part of the project will be acquiring a right-of-way needed based on the environmental work that we do. Is it right-of-way from a private entity or governmental? Correct. From a private party. And so will we get that right-of-way prior to actually moving forward with spending any money on the planning? So we need to do the environmental to basically sort out where the trail goes, which would identify what, if any, right-of-way we need. We can't predisposition the...
2:33:19 Solution of the NEPA document. You don't have plot lines that you can... We have a good idea. I mean, there's always so much room between the creek and the road, so it's pretty easy to surmise that it's going to be in that area, but from a legal standpoint, we can't surmise exactly where it's at until you learn all the stuff. Should this be part of the $300,000 for trail funding? Well, we put it here.
2:33:45 It's not on their list yet, but it will be soon. Because I know last time we had the $300,000, and then there were a couple of gaps that we funded through Measure R, and I think there was some controversy about that. We didn't want to have it one place and not the other, and then in the end say, well, it should be one or the other. So the idea is if you want a full application, we can provide all that information. And then, Peter, I have a question on Trails End Park turf. You're only bringing the turf forward.
2:34:16 Yeah. Because the other part to that, isn't there a picnic pavilion? Yeah, so the thought really was, so we met with the grant administrators, they came over, visited the site, and then in the end they made recommendations and we weren't funded for that state park grant. State park grant about a month ago? So the key there was that they, you know, they're not going to pay for turf, whether it be synthetic turf or real turf in this, because it's not listed as a...
2:34:46 as a priority for Mono County, or really the eastern Sierra. TERF isn't listed as one of the state's priorities. So I think by funding this separately, our grant application will be much more competitive with the resubmittal at the end of November of this year. Okay. Because they said, you know, please resubmit, and she basically said, you know, TERF, don't include the TERF. So it's a $200,000, I think, grant.
2:35:15 $250,000 grant. It's a 50% match. So in this case, now that we're going to, if we fund the turf separately, it'll be about a $400,000 project. So half of that would be a measure of our application in the future if we got it. And the other half would be state parks. So did we miss out on the grant this year? So we have to reapply next year? Yeah, it's an annual grant. It's due usually about the first week of November.
2:35:42 And so are we applying this year or are we applying next year? Are we already applied? No, we would apply, you know, we'll be back to the commission once third, final application packets out to provide a recommendation to council so we can pass a resolution to apply again. And it'll be applied for this year, by this November? Yeah, and it would be funded, it'll be funded next October, so it'll be next fiscal year when it's funded. Okay. It's another year away essentially. Yeah. Okay.
2:36:13 So we could consider putting in all of those projects if we wish in lieu of the state park ramp. Or include the state park match as part of this application. So last time we applied for, I think, the full state park match. So we could just kind of reconfigure that application to show that it will be done in two phases. One part is town-only contributions for the turf area, and maybe we can get the water district if it's a turf synthetic.
2:36:42 Would that help our grant application? Employees showed that there was an application and approval for their grant match out of federal funds? In the grant application, they're okay with showing that the turf is completed. She didn't want to see the turf. She thought it would be less competitive to have the turf in the application. They're not going to tell us what not to include it, but she was...
2:37:09 I think what Terry was saying, would it be more enticing to them if they know that there's already a match in place? It would be more enticing.
2:37:19 And then that way also, you know, if it, well, if it's not going to come back until next October, it's not going to happen until the following year. So we're looking at two years anyways. But still our priority is going to finish that part. But it would be better to have the match at hand. So I almost would think that that would be beneficial to bring that forward as the grant match. Plus the grant match. My question on that one is I thought the original cost of the turf was like $40,000. I thought it was less too. But the bits came in at like $82,000, $85,000.
2:37:46 One was 82 and one was 106. Yeah, that was the problem. That's why we didn't go forward. We think it's more of the $80,000 to $90,000 range if it's just by itself for synthetic turf. Important piece. I want to see it there. Okay, so we'll add. How much water would it take to get to $90,000? You know, my concern isn't the water, even the saving of water. My concern is how hard it is to maintain turf and Mammoth.
2:38:17 What Dennis does with those soccer fields is incredible. And the soccer and baseball field turf is a terrible shape. And it's always in terrible shape because turf in Mammoth is just really tough to maintain. But they get used. They get athletic used as opposed to it being more passive. And it's a smaller area. It's going to be spilled on it. More dogs are going to use it as their private toilet. More kids. As they would synthetic turf. Yeah, the kids are going to. Yeah, I think synthetic turf is the only way to go. Philosophical differences.
2:38:46 Yeah. Is it? I guess I'd like to see some kind of analysis of synthetic versus regular turf for a park like that as well. And I can bring that back. We have, we've provided that some time ago, but it's been a while and it may have been a different commission makeup, I think a couple of years ago. But yeah, I would really like to know the difference, the analysis between the pros and cons of each.
2:39:13 Okay. Yeah, and my only concern down there, especially in the way that park is, it's not a fenced park around a big neighborhood. You ever seen what an overdog's urine does to lawns and Mammoth? Yeah. Oh, that kind of sounds gross for us. Kills, we holes in it. So you're going to end up with big holes in it. The artificial just drains right through. Spray with water and you're clean. But there are other nuisances from dogs.
2:39:43 That would be more impactful. Are there other surfaces, artificial surfaces that we could use that would be conducive and you're not, I mean, it's not going to be green like grass would be, but I don't know, they have, you know, the tire tread, you know, covers that are. Just because.
2:40:01 Can we just see an analysis with this? Because all we're doing is asking for stuff to be brought forward. Yeah, no, we can include that with the education. A lot of that for the difference between the synthetic and the mowing, we've got that. We can look at a couple other. The tire, I'm not sure that we really want to have the rubber tire stuff in with the playground long term.
2:40:25 I guess I was thinking they have ground cover that's like a mat, that's like more like a mat as opposed to where you're going to put picnic stuff. Yeah, there's astroturf, like carpet is another, basically the synthetic turf is carpet. It's kind of the same. It's great that the community garden people wanted to just, you know, maintain some grass for us there. There you go. Okay, so we'll include analysis. Okay.
2:40:48 What's the next step with regard to this? Okay. So we've got number one, Internet Access for Whitmore. We've got number four, in addition to the $250,000 rent match, number six and number seven, and then the annual obligations maintenance items. And I'm not sure that we don't want to win this agenda bill comes forward.
2:41:07 that we don't want to list these other items and say that, you know, these need to be funded through general fund opportunities and so that they don't just disappear, but we can support bringing them forward as, you know, things that need to happen. I agree. I wanted to say something along those lines and kind of at the conclusion of this discussion, I also wanted, the reason why I asked earlier about
2:41:32 You know, what is the role that the Recreation Commission can now do in advocating proposed applications that the town of Mammoth Lakes brings forward? I've heard more than two or three town councilors say that now is the time to make a recommendation with regard to the wood site or other event locations that this is the year there is political momentum to do that. I see that we are talking about, with regard to the revised Measure R,
2:42:02 Fall Award Timeline, that October 21st is when those applications open. I guess my question with regard to just an overall question is that how can we as a recreation commission make a recommendation that is a big suggestion with regard to whether it's the wood site, another events location. We've heard people telling us that we've been talking about bonding measure R, measure U. I feel like this is the year to really do something.
2:42:30 And that this will involve some process. So my question is, Bill, as chair, maybe you can help direct this. How do we make a big proposal? If we decide we would like to see an application to come back to potentially purchase that site, we can ask town to make that application and to find out that information. If we would like to do that this year, then I recommend it to us and we have that discussion and ask staff to bring back a proposal to buy that site.
2:43:01 Or it, and I don't, I don't necessarily want to say it's a proposal to buy that site, and I see Evans back in the audience, but actually put together a proposal that frankly, I've been kind of shopping this around with a number of community leaders, just kind of what I've been calling a bar napkin business plan, that may involve several different town-owned properties here in the area, that is, would I think satisfy a lot of
2:43:29 Concerns we've heard with regard to the tennis courts, an aquatic center, if that's what's going to happen, an events venue or two. So I am actually proposing making a recommendation that could be brought forward for Measure R and Measure U. I just don't want another year to go by. Isn't it September 24th? We have our next workshop. That's right. We did move it back. I think that's right. Priorities.
2:43:59 And maybe that's, you know, because I think we need to look at everything as a whole and moving, you know, any suggestion like that forward, including events. But I don't think that I'm willing to, or right now until we actually look at everything as a whole, move forward. And I'd love to hear those suggestions, but I guess I would like to see.
2:44:24 I think that gives us enough time to still put something together. And truly, and that's all I'm asking. I'm not going to make any kind of proposals or recommendations here tonight. What I'm asking is, what is the process if an advocate, either individual or commission, wants to push something forward, what's the process? This is the process. We're bringing it forward and we decide if we want to ask staff to prepare the application.
2:44:50 Would that be something that would happen on the 24th or submit that to Stu? Well, it seems like we could have a conversation on the 24th and then on the 8th decide to go forward, you know, to direct staff to go forward with the application. Well, do you discuss on the set council before that, so, yeah. But couldn't, well, because it's just a workshop, so we couldn't actually make that recommendation. Yeah, I was trying to find that. Right. With that timeline going, just got the timeline. Couldn't that be made at a workshop level?
2:45:20 It can be if you add it as an action item to the agenda. October 16th is actually when we're moving forward with the town proposed applications, right? Are we not having a September 24th? Yes, we are. Yeah. Okay. Now we're taking a workshop on the funding priorities. So if we add to the agenda that that's an action item that we would like to potentially come out with proposed projects or priorities.
2:45:51 That could be presented to the Council on October 2nd? Yeah. You can. It's already scheduled on October 16th, so you can leave it on October 16th or move it up. Oh, it's proposed on October 16th? Well, then we have plenty of time because we're going to have another meeting on between then. So, yeah. Okay. So, that's good. Yeah, that was that kind of whole package. So, they would be reviewing the whole package. Okay. And that's why that's the trigger date. So, once they approve the process and the timelines and the material, that's when we open.
2:46:22 That's why I kind of built in a little bit more time in the schedule. Okay. Well, then we have another meeting, so we can do that meeting and then bring it back to our next commission meeting. Okay. So maybe I can put together an outline for the September 24th? Because that's not in anything that we've put forward so far, so yeah. Yeah. Okay. And just so you know, my concern up there is...
2:46:46 I keep thinking of it as the Hartman and Walker property, but evidently we're using a bunch more people's properties than that. No, only one other, Kurt Otaker's property. Yeah. So it is two different parcels though. Yeah, which takes the price way beyond what I thought it was. And I've had some conversation about what they think that property is worth. So I just wanted to make sure that that was in the mix. That's a fair and valid concern that I've expressed to the owners as well.
2:47:16 Now, when you mention there's two parcels, I guess we'll talk about later, is that with the expanded event site, or was that existing? I don't know if you know this, but what we consider the wood site is actually two different parcels, one that's owned by Sam Walker and Dennis Hartman, and another one that's owned by Kurt Odecker, and they're both about four acres, and if you take a look at the town map, you can see exactly what it is, but essentially everything north of the food court.
2:47:41 is actually Kurt Odecker's property, the food court that we have on Bluza Pluza and Jazz, or, you know, when the Mammoth Mountain had their event there was, is a separate parcel. Okay. I'm just entering in these dates. Okay, so, um, the next place I see us at is the revised timeline. Mm-hmm. We've got to get through this quick. I think we've heard the members of four, right?
2:48:09 Yeah. I've captured that comment from Commissioner Truex. So October 10 actually should be October 8. That's the Tuesday. So you'll meet on October 2 with Council and the Measure U Application Committee to review your funding priorities, relationship to Measure U. October 8 is your next Commission meeting. October 16 is the Council action to essentially approve all of the measure up all.
2:48:32 Pat, I would love to just change when we meet to just be the first Tuesday of each month. That would just be really lovely. Today isn't working. I know, but it's the first full week. I'd like it to be the first Tuesday. Please, please. Anyhow, whether it's the first full week or not, it's just the first Tuesday. Because this is killing me. This is not a good day. I don't know that I'll be here. And it happens all the time. Anytime it hits that second week, it always becomes problematic for me.
2:49:03 Yeah. Because the first Tuesday, I think, is October 1st. It is, yeah. But the problem then is we wouldn't be able to take action on the comments from the council. Yeah, we would, because it's not going to them until the 16th. But we wouldn't meet again, though, so we'd meet and then go to council and council. Okay. Anyways, I don't see it any different. But maybe for next year. It's just a conversation. Let's move down this road. Other than the October 8th change,
2:49:32 Do we see any issues with the revised timeline? When once, twice gone. That would bring us to the review fall timeline? That was just for... That's information on? Right. Just to show how it's kind of lining up. So within about two weeks of each other now, really, is what we've got. And then there was a meeting in the...
2:49:58 December 3rd meeting was an option to meet with the Measure of Application Committee to review the applications because you can see Measure R closes if you look at the timeline on November 15th and Measure U is closing on December 4th. So, you know, there's that opportunity on December 3rd. We'll know pretty closely what applications are in if we wanted to jointly review those applications. I think we should. So that was why that meeting's there. Yeah, that's fine.
2:50:28 We approved it. Great. Even if they didn't know it was there. Okay. Application form. Questions on it? Are we happy with, because I know we need to make some changes. Are we good with them? I suggest maybe the Measure U group go through their new application, whatever that happens to be, and then maybe next time around we look to see if we want to parallel. Yeah.
2:50:59 Right, because you've got additional meaning in there. It does just seem like we always struggle with G and H on the filter and checklist when we get to that. The evaluation guidelines? Yeah. Yeah. But ultimately it works. It does. It's objective anyway. Yeah, so I don't think, I don't know that there's a solution. Yeah. I think I'm... Okay, you guys have looked over the guideline.
2:51:34 On what gets a low score and a high score and are happy with that. And the performance report. We just need to start requiring people to have performance reports. I think that's something you want to include. You know, if you want to submit an application, you have to submit your previous performance report. That's always been a requirement. We just haven't enforced it. We need to enforce it. So anyhow. So that's an appendix to the application.
2:52:11 Okay, anything else on number five or number four? Good enough. Moving on then. We have eight minutes. So this item, Chair, is again, we put it here at the regular agenda to discuss what we've done. I know we haven't met for quite a while because we've been in the Mammoth Lakes Recreation discussion. So what we've attached to this item was what was discussed on July 25th.
2:52:41 When Commissioner Stehlik, Commissioner Agnes, Schmidt, we found staff. And that's attachment A and B. We also participated on June 18, if you remember, seems like so long ago, in exercising, scoring, and ranking those facilities and programs. And what I was able to do was I was able to kind of collect those and put those on an Excel spreadsheet and sort them for you. And I believe that is attachment C.
2:53:05 And actually, you know what, when we briefly met before Ray left, we had asked for the capital CIP list to come forward that we had looked at, so we broke everything into whether it was kind of a maintenance issue, whether it was a high priority, low priority, mid priority, and whether we kind of tabled it until
2:53:34 You know, we felt that it needed to have a master plan. And that was a list that Hayes was going to work on that. Hayes was going to work on that, but that's not what we have here. So I guess, you know, moving forward, I just think that that list was kind of beneficial when we're looking at things. Should we have that for the 24th? I would like it to be there, and that's what we wanted to come back forward to the commission. So that way it was just a list that
2:54:02 Kind of is very simply broken out a little bit more. And it's not the ones that are there right now? No. These are the ones that have been there forever. It's the list where we actually took each item and broke it out and made it a high level, mid level, low level. We said whether it was a maintenance issue or... Oh, a matrix. Yeah. And then whether it needed a master plan that we felt that we shouldn't move forward with spending that type of money without planning the park.
2:54:31 Anyhow, I just think that that was a beneficial list that we had put together. Maybe just ask Hayes if he has that meeting on the 24th. No, Hayes had that. He was going to update it with what you guys are doing currently, so that was taken out.
2:54:57 Because that was our very brief meeting that we had with Jason before Rayla. So we'll need that for September 24th? That would be awesome, yeah. That's our workshop now. Okay, so we tabulated those results and we kind of split it into facilities and programs if you look at attachment C. So hopefully that was a little bit clearer. So that's as far as we got there. And then I revised the timeline just to bump that meeting back a week because...
2:55:27 We've bumped this meeting back a week, so we're now meeting September 24th at 2 o'clock, and that's the elements of Phase 3 workshop. The other discussion here on this item was, you know, is there a need for an agenda? I put this item up here to essentially maybe focus our discussion at that time, so when we are meeting in that workshop, we know what we're meeting for, we know what staff need to prepare, and obviously we've got some information here we can bring, but what's the outcome of that workshop that we want to...
2:55:58 Do we want to set an agenda? Are we okay continuing on with the process? Well, with everything we have here, I think that probably we're going to use that up, just going over everything we've done and refreshing. It seems to me we're going to need yet one more meeting to actually get down to the business of, before public engagement, to get down to the business of actually
2:56:34 Prioritizing. I don't see us getting it done at the same time we're going over all of these lists because my mind isn't that fresh now. Yeah, it's been a while. So I'm thinking that our commission meeting public engagement, that we need to somehow push that. Back in November? Yeah, in November. And October needs to be.
2:56:59 Between the regular meeting and additional workshop needs to be actually putting all these things on board and coming up with an actual priority. Yes, no? Yeah, you can do that. I don't know that that fits in Sean's timing. It doesn't. That's my concern. Maybe, I mean, if we have a couple weeks before the 24th, we'd take a look at this information and just kind of refresh our...
2:57:26 Our memories and then maybe start to tackle the difficult part of rating things. Yeah, I think that we can keep this timeline. I mean, I know we've got a lot going on, but just starting the process, Bill, would be my...
2:57:38 We could start the process. I just don't see us getting through. Well, you know, we can make that decision on the 24th. Could we make a decision on the 24th and see where we get? Absolutely. And if we don't get to where we want to get? And you could still schedule an hour on the October 8th meeting, right? Right. We could. But then I would put on that September 24th, we do need an agenda.
2:57:57 That gives us an actionable line in terms of prioritization so that we can push up in a business audit. And we can either act on it or not. Okay, that makes sense. That's good. Okay, great. Moving on. And what about what you're going to come back for the meeting on the 24th with Sean? Do we need, would that also be?
2:58:18 Potentially actionable item. But if we put the actionable item on the for priorities moving forward, then that would cover that as well. Anyhow, I would think. You're more familiar with process than I am, so yeah, that would work for me. Okay. Goodness. Okay, moving right on to manager report. So I don't know if there's anything else you want me to talk about here. I do have some other items that I'll just briefly discuss with you.
2:58:53 A couple of new programs. We've started Toddler Time, which is that Mommy and Daddy program. It's pretty cool. It's a lady actually starting that. It's at the Mammoth Lakes Community Center every Tuesday. Toddler Time? Toddler Time. Yep. So they're doing that from 9.30 to 10.30. Tuesday's in September. So that's running right now. Where is that? Up at our Community Center. Okay, great. Who is that? Miss Sarah.
2:59:25 Anyway, and then we've also introduced a new four cooking class at the community centre as well, and that's hosted by Lacey, it's on October 1st at the community centre at 6pm, so she's just going to start to see how this goes and if it receives some good response, we'll try and keep that going. But anyway, a couple of new programs we've got going there, so that was... Are these for children?
2:59:50 I don't think the four cooking classes. Well, obviously the four classes. I think the toddler time is probably self-explanatory. I think that's, yeah, forget that. Okay. Okay. Right. Back to the monthly report. Great wrap-up to the summer softball season. The only issue there is it ran a little bit later than normal, and anyway, so I had to scramble to get all their fields ready, but anyway, they made it work. We closed our roller rink.
3:00:19 And a lot of our numbers are coming forward in October, so that we'll kind of have that package for you again like we normally do. And then the only other item here I thought was a really productive session we had with all our seasonal staff is we hosted it for a seasonal lunch at the community centre, bought them some great two-week food. With that, they were very innovative, gave us some good ideas. So what we did was we worked on a process similar to what we did with MLR about what we liked, what we didn't like, and ways to improve it for next year.
3:00:49 We'll have those notes for you, very well collated. I think some very ingenious ideas. So I think we're pretty excited about that. So that was a good meeting. And I think the staff really appreciated some recognition for their efforts for the season. I know the pool staff had a tough time with a number of things, but I think they made it work. Kari over here at the rink, I mean, she was pretty much flying solo most of the season and had a great time. So we're really happy with her. So anyway, so it was a really, really productive session.
3:01:20 If you met Rob, he was our adult summer softball, actually adult sports coordinator. He was at softball. He's also a DJ on KMNT. He was great. See, he's actually with us all the time now. So we're looking at one of the programs that came up was whether we can do a fall flag league and how soon we can get the soccer league program. Can we kind of take a little bit more involvement in the winter hockey league? Right, that's always a little bit of a hit and miss type of thing with Jeff. So we want to kind of take a little bit more ownership in those programs so that they actually...
3:01:49 We've talked about special event permits. It's been a very busy summer. Quick update on the Measure R and Measure U reconciliation. We put together a list of priority items or criteria that was important for staff from a lot of the feedback we received from commission and committee. We presented that to the Sierra Employment Centre or the agency, I think it is.
3:02:18 And then they selected a candidate. We agreed. So that candidate will start next Monday with that process. And what are you doing? And that's the reconciliation of Measure Armour U. So that person is going to basically back in and reconcile those funds. OK. And that isn't something our town staff can do? No. We started on it, but we need someone just dedicated to it. So that person is going to basically go through all our accounts and then convert everything into QuickBooks.
3:02:43 Really? So that's going to be a full QuickBooks account. Can I ask about this? Yeah, so it was Elena Lundgren, so she was our previous permit tech from here. So we had three options, you know, we went through them. And anyway, from our criteria, they selected this candidate, seemed to work. But what we're also, with this candidate as well, is we also receive and will pay for the use of their CPA to come in and oversee that work as well. So not only will we get that.
3:03:11 Translated into QuickBooks, but also be essentially balancing those funds. Can I ask him why we didn't go with a CPA? Because we're not auditing the books, we're just reconciling the books, and we didn't have it in our budget to really fund something like that. We're getting this service for $30 an hour, and the CPA was at $50 to $60 an hour. And we talked to a couple of those people who are CPAs, and they just didn't have the time to 100 to 200 hours to really do this work. A lot of it is actually the transferring of the data into QuickBooks.
3:03:40 AS 400 for us is really quite... Can I then ask again why our town staff finance department didn't have time to do that? Because they didn't have time to do it. They don't have the resources to do it. Sandy, excuse me. I'm asking a question. Okay? So, anyway, I think this is the best way to get it done in the time that we have. So this project will be done by the end of October. What do you mean by reconciliation? So what's awarded and what's been spent?
3:04:11 So balancing. This is balancing the checkbook. Balancing the checkbook. So what's been spent on staff time, measure hour, measure use since inception service. Didn't we discuss this at our last mission meeting? We did. We did, and I know I asked the same questions. We discussed it every time.
3:04:27 Florida, this is the route that we're taking. I guess, I don't know. I'm uncomfortable in the route that we're taking. I thought it was also to help with the whole Measure R process and the Measure U process. No, originally it was administration. And staff has decided that at this point, this is what needs to be done first. And I don't disagree with them. We've been asking all along for what is out there, what has been spent, how has it been spent.
3:04:54 And the answer that Stu gets from finance and that we get is we can just punch those numbers up for you. Well, they can't. So now there needs to be... And so why can't they? Is it because of the accounting system? Because I think this needs to go back to the council again because I'm sorry, this really should not go outside of the town in what needs to be reconciled. This should be within their realm.
3:05:22 of ability and it's probably not a matter of not their ability. It's probably software driven that they can't pull the information that we need. And so once again, Council, that's the reason we need to update our system. So I guess I just really have a hard time that this is even pulled out and that we're having to pull information out and put it in QuickBooks. There's just a level, you know, not to say that Elena isn't capable of doing that. There's just...
3:05:50 That's a step that shouldn't have to happen. The finance department should be able to give us all of this information. From my standpoint, this is something we've been calling for for a long time, and they haven't been able to give it to us. So if we can fund it and pay for it and finally have a complete separate accounting.
3:06:09 For RU, I'm going to be a happy camper. Okay, so as a commissioner, I would like to stand up and speak, and I don't know, and that's why I would like to know why this is a problem. Is it a software problem? Is it the finance software? Or is it a staffing problem? Both. So we need to definitely...
3:06:28 I agree with you too. It just got to a point where we just needed to get this done. I know we've been asking for it for a long time. I think it's going to be the most efficient way. We'll get it done in six weeks. We'll be moving on. And then moving forward, you know, we'll hopefully be in a position to better manage those funds. When was the last time it was done? Has never been done. Well, it's never been done. Never been done. It's done. If I can, I will apologize because I threw up my head like this because it seems like there's such a disconnect between the understanding of workforce.
3:06:58 and workload in this town. And workforce is bodies, and you can count bodies, but when you keep taking away bodies and you keep adding jobs to people, the finance department is barely getting along now and they just lost their best and most knowledgeable person. These are priorities, at least they're up there, but the fact is these are the kind of things that when I say Stu has 40% of his time left for municipal recreation,
3:07:28 Recreation. It's because that other 40% of it is being taken up by Measure U and Measure R and trying to reconcile it. I mean, he's not an accountant and he's been worried about this for a long time. The other 10 or 20%, I think, is public information officer. So I do want to apologize, Teri, because it is as a former manager who has gone through many budget crises and seen shrinking workforce and was the one who had to take
3:07:57 Just say, we're not going to do it. We're not going to do it. I mean, the council doesn't have a clue sometimes. I'm sorry. And so what I'm saying is, I think we need to have a reconciliation of Measure R. You can't even have an audit until you have that. And it's time for an audit. So I'm not here to debate. I'm here to apologize for you, for throwing up my hands, but to say, I think you really need to think about workforce, the number of bodies.
3:08:25 and workload can realize we've got to get it done. If you can get somebody for $30 an hour to take on $200 of this and get it done and we can afford that, do it. That's my comment. That's my comment. I'm not debating. It isn't resolving how it is dealt with within the town's budget. And so, unfortunately, you're resolving it on one end, but you aren't on the other. Well, I don't know.
3:08:52 So I think that's something that we need to find out. It's a town tax, and it's something that the town should be reconciling. We are the town. We are the town. Sandy, I understand that. Thank you. I think the other point, too, is the bar is the town. That's taxpayer dollars. It's a restricted fund of the town. You are not one body and here another. I am reconciling. Do you understand that, please? I don't think so sometimes. And let us finish. Thank you.
3:09:18 Yeah, the only thing I was saying is it's part of that 4%, so we're working it into that budget that we have of the 4% to administer the funds. I just see that that 4% is a justifiable expense to administer the accounts. This will pull it out of the convoluted town budget and put it in an operating system of its own. At least that's my purpose, that's what I've been told. Well, I will stand up at council next time and say this is an issue. And, you know, council...
3:09:46 If it's software, and that's why I'm asking, if it's software, because I've heard that time and time again, it's an antiquated system, they need to update it so that we don't have these issues and so this can be broken out and it's a done deal. So I'm sorry. It's, you know, anyways. I would imagine that it's impacting other facets of the town's finances. It is. It's impacting a lot of different things. No, but I mean, if this one little bit is...
3:10:12 Problematic. You can imagine the entire budget. Can I ask one question of the recreation manager briefly? I guess I was busy this summer because all of a sudden I found out that Marianna resigned. Yeah, I know. I've known this for a couple of weeks, but at the same time I feel like this is something that should be reported just at the commission level.
3:10:38 What is the current status? Are you able to report on who is acting town manager? I can certainly do that commission. Thank you. That's actually a good prompt into it. The acting town manager is the police chief right now. The search is underway for an interim town manager. The town attorney is actually conducting that search. And he's looking at kind of a Canada pool of retired city managers.
3:11:07 And he hopes to have at least three to five candidates for council consideration by the end of the month. So council would then actually go through a process of interviewing those city managers as an interim. And then once that interim is in place, then they'll start the process to recruit a permanent town manager as that replacement. Thank you. How is that affecting, and just on a logistical, you know, not necessarily morale or anything like that, but just I guess what I want to ask is just making sure that the recreation department, that this isn't necessarily affecting
3:11:37 the Recreation Department, or is it, or can you speak to that? I think it's affecting the entire town. You know, the morale in this entire community is... And that's why I guess what I wanted to do is I did want to ask that at this time because I feel like that is something that perhaps needs to be reported to us at a commission and for the public record. So, thank you. I wasn't trying to cause any kind of
3:12:06 I just wanted to understand what's going on. The other one, our new human resources director actually starts next week on the 18th. So that's our first hiring in a senior management position for quite some time. Pam Kobylarz has been taking on that responsibility as the assistant to the town manager, so she's happy to come and see that.
3:12:30 So, I mean, everybody's just taken on more workload. I mean, I think that was a lot of the discussion because we are resourced. I don't know where we're at with the Community Development Director or the Public Works Director. We're still kind of looking for a Finance Director. But I think that's all on hold now until we get an interim town manager. Understood. Commissioner reports. We'll start with you. I have nothing to report.
3:12:55 I do just want to say real quick that I thought it was an excellent summer with regard to events. I think that everyone, a lot of the events learned something, whether it was the Bluegrass Festival or the Kamikaze event, Hoppin Sage, that for-profit event was not profitable. But at the same time, it was a great, great community event, if I can say anything with regard to events.
3:13:23 I will just say on the record that, you know, unfortunately, the Rim Fire really affected both the Aspen Fire, affected Paloza Paloza, and, you know, we're still doing the final numbers, but believe it or not, our tickets were actually down on that, even though the expansion of the site made it much more comfortable. So I know that the Aspen Fire affected us, and that the Rim Fire, unfortunately, I can tell you has been affecting business since it has closed Tioga Road, and I just wanted to say that out loud.
3:13:53 Yes, we need to educate our brethren in the Bay Area that's just as fast to come across Sonora. I would argue faster. Yeah, as it is 120, but they don't know that. Except for, I guess, the visibility on Sonora at times was pretty bad. So, anyhow. I'll just say that I met with our smaller subcommittee for MLR, Betsy and I and Stuart and Joe and Rick.
3:14:18 And so what's being proposed is moving forward to go to the next steps with a smaller committee of nine plus the town manager and plus Stu. So that should be 11 altogether, but nine on a committee. And that'll be coming forward. Stu is going to send out some invitations. And that's coming back to the council on the 16th, the meeting on the 16th.
3:14:43 So anyways, that's moving forward and then that'll come back to the larger group at, you know, the end of that proposal. And then I did meet with the group this morning with the final feasibility study. It's the first time that I've met with anybody and went through that whole study. And that's all I have to say. Going back to the MLR, very disappointing that it's going to be a smaller group, which...
3:15:11 You know, I kind of got the impression at that last meeting that it would be still the existing group. But who's making the decision as to those nine individuals? That was actually council. The people that are representing the council on that committee were the ones that made that recommendation. And they're bringing that to the full council, and the full council will make that recommendation.
3:15:33 And that was also, it was the recommendation of the consultants that the meetings still be kept public and that the original participants still be invited to come and participate, but just that it go down to a slightly smaller committee to do the kind of more nuts and bolts to move forward. And then the public will only have comments at the conclusion of the meeting? How the meetings are going to be facilitated is going to be with the consultants once again.
3:16:05 I'd like to go on record saying that I think that this was conducted inappropriately and I think that we are being directed to come to this conclusion and I think that many people in that room had financial gain that maybe had an impact. But the council still has the decision to whether or not to move forward with the process or not and so they'll make that decision on the 16th.
3:16:38 So I'm just reporting on the meeting that we attended. Thank you. Got a report? Nothing. Nothing for me. Agenda items. I think our next agenda is already probably going to be pretty full. Any other items you'd like to see added? So I've got the MLTSCC update action items. I've got Measure R4. I've got the feasibility study, which is kind of a receive and file. Recreation facilities planning, which is an ongoing one, and then the Recreation Department facilities programming.
3:17:08 Summer. I'll second pen motion. Motion second for the discussion. All those in favor? Aye. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Steve. Thank you, Steve. You're welcome. You're welcome.