TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2013

Planning & Economic Development Commission

· recording 3 hr 43 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

463 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:18 Good afternoon. We'll now call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission regular meeting for Wednesday, October the 9th at 2013. Roll call, please. Commissioner Dugan most likely will be absent for the entire meeting. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance to the flag.

1:04 of the United States of America, and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. At this time, we'll open the floor for public comments. With there being no public comments, we'll close that, and we'll open it for public hearings. Our procedure for public hearings is staff will do a presentation. There'll be questions from the Planning and Economic Development Commission.

1:45 There will be a call for testimony for those wishing to speak. Any rebuttals, close the public hearing, and the Commission will deliberate on the matter. Our public hearing today is to consider approval of tentative tract map 13-001, Greystone, including finding the project consistent with the EIR addendum for the Low Star at Mammoth Master Plan. The staff contact is Jen Daugherty. Thank you, Chair Brown.

2:13 The proposed subdivision is for seven lots on the Solstice Phase 2 site, which is located in Area 5 of the Lodestar Master Plan. Earlier this year, the Lodestar Master Plan was amended to allow for single-family homes on this site. Transient rentals would be permitted for these homes because that's consistent with Area 5 of the Lodestar Master Plan. The proposed lots conform with municipal code standards for residential single-family zone.

2:42 And there is a single family home currently being processed for a building permit for lot 6. And that building permit looks like it's about ready to be approved. It's consistent with the Lodestar master plan. The proposed subdivision was evaluated under the addendum for the Lodestar at Mammoth EIR, found to be consistent with that. No further environmental review was required. The mitigation measures in that addendum are incorporated as conditions of approval for this tentative.

3:11 Map. Therefore, staff recommends approval of Option 1, which is adopting the required CEQA findings, adopting the required Subdivision Map Act findings, and approving tentative tract map 13-001 with conditions as recommended by staff or as modified by the Commission. And I'm happy to answer any questions you have. Commissioner Tenney, do you have any questions?

3:37 Jen, will these be custom homes or are they, is it a subdivision or attract homes, I mean high-end tract homes, but what is the plan? It's up to the developer in terms of the design of the homes. His intention is to have smaller homes that are more affordable than typically the high-end homes along the golf course, but of course with well-designed architecture and attractive homes. Okay, but will they be, well here's the,

4:05 Developer right now. Yeah. As long as they would be individually designed or. Correct. They will be. Okay. That's fine. Next question was engineering condition number 88 as to 87 and 88. Can you explain a little bit about 87 and then with 88 I wanted to talk about the economic advantage there.

4:29 Sure. So these conditions relate to existing CCNRs and homeowners associations for the property. The property is within the Solstice Homeowners Association and CCNRs because the site was originally identified as Phase 2 for Solstice. So the project can either amend the Solstice CCNRs and be part of those Solstice CCNRs.

4:54 Or, as proposed by the developer, they would de-annex themselves from the Solstice CCNRs. And because there's no common area within this subdivision, they wouldn't be required to have CCNRs or a homeowners association. There is no gate between Solstice 2 and these homes, is there? There's no connection, no. No connection. And then, 88, a declaration about the annexation of this property into Sierra Star West, a master plan development.

5:24 Who would instigate that or why would that be instigated? That's just so we have the documentation because they're having, they're accessed off a private road maintained by the Sierra Star Homeowners Association or Master Association. So it's just ensuring that they are considered part of that association and paying whatever would be required for that. Okay, and then my last question has to do with map 2, referring to lot 6.

5:54 And it shows the building pad there and it says new residence. Is this a residence that's been built or is proposed or what is that residence? That's the residence I was referring to a bit earlier. We have a building permit that is just about ready to be approved for that home to be constructed and construction, well actually I believe they poured the footings for the driveway, just the retaining wall for the driveway I think yesterday.

6:21 And then the home would be constructed next summer. So that's already happened because my question is why it was oriented the way it is in the building pad. To take out that 30-inch pine, we're losing those around town. And I just wondered why it had that sort of diagonal orientation on the building pad. Maybe what we'll do is we'll ask staff our questions and then we'll ask the applicant questions. Okay, I'm looking at John and I should be looking at Jen. Okay, thank you.

6:51 Those are all my questions of staff. Thank you. And if I may, just for a clarification, it's a 20-inch. 20? Oh, okay. There's an X over and I thought it was a 30-inch. Thank you. Commissioner Harvey? No further questions. Would the applicant like to come forward, please? Basically, any questions you have of me. And we know who you are, but just because it's televised. John Rupert.

7:28 Haven't seen you in a long time. Yeah. Hi, John. Just tell me about lot six. Now that I know it's a 20-inch pine, it's a little bit different. I mean, it's an order of magnitude less. But why is it oriented diagonally? Is there some special reason? You know, we went from eight lots to seven lots just to get wider widths on the lot to keep them further apart rather than 20 feet. Most of them will be 30 feet apart. But that's the only tree in the entire 2.54 acres other than some on the building sites.

7:57 Thank you. Thank you.

8:20 You know, with berms and boulders and trees that I bring down from, as you've seen before. Oh, sure. Bring them down that are 15, 20 feet tall from Idaho, various types of trees. But that house won't fit on that lot without taking that one tree down. Okay. And also, excuse me, they were 75 foot widths, which only gave me 55 feet to build on when there were eight lots. That's why we deleted one lot just

8:47 to create a wider building area, but that tree's, there's just no way to save it. And also, with the building pad so close to the tree, it will be damaged in the process of construction and probably die. Even if we moved it over to the 10 feet away and reduce the size of the house, we'll be so close to it, it probably wouldn't make it anything. Yeah, okay, thank you. Those are all my questions. Thank you. I'm happy to see you back in Mammoth. Yeah, it's good to see you back.

9:18 Thank you very much. Is there any public, are there any public comments regarding this public hearing? Then we'll close the public comment period for the public hearing, and any comments from the commissioners? I had one more question, but it's really minor, not, it's more clarification I can ask Jim later. It's not really relevant to the outcome here. So do we have any comments? No, it's good. Would anybody like to make a motion? Pretty straightforward.

10:01 I'll go ahead and make a motion that we choose option one, adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required subdivision map act findings and approve tentative tract map 13-001 with conditions as recommended by staff. I'll second that. Roll call, please. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Tenney? Yes. So the motion passes 4-0 with one person absent.

10:37 Thank you. Won't miss that big pit at all. Even though I know it's filled in. It was sure awful while it was there. Good. Okay. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thanks, John. We'll now move to agenda item number two, which is a workshop. It's a community indicators workshop. And our staff contact is Jessica. Good afternoon, commissioners. This afternoon, we will be presenting

11:11 More or less an introduction to the Community Indicators Report. The Community Indicators Report is something that we've been discussing for some time. There's actually a goal, I'm sorry, an action in the general plan that refers to the preparation of an annual Community Indicators Report. And more or less the intent of this is to produce on an annual basis a state of the town, a state of the community, I should say.

11:40 It is intended to look at the overall community focusing on the triple bottom line, so economy, environment, and society. And what we've done, we've been working with environmental incentives out of South Lake Tahoe to do all the legwork in preparation for this. And we've spent the last several weeks and months

12:04 Coming up with a list of potential indicators or measures that we can use to report out general progress and trends towards overall goals of the community. So Owen Doherty here, he's from Environmental Incentives. He has a presentation that we would like to go through, talk about the process, the purpose, the objectives, and then we would like to ask for commission feedback on

12:31 The list, the draft list of indicators that we have come up with at this point in time. Just so you know, we had a stakeholder meeting this morning with a couple community members. We met with Sandra Pierce from Mono County Health Department, as well as Hector Gonzalez from the Mono County Courts.

12:52 And had a very productive meeting. They gave us a lot of really good feedback. And there are a couple other people on our stakeholder group that weren't able to make it this morning but that we'll be reaching out to you to get their additional feedback as well. So I'm going to turn it over to Owen. And this is going to be kind of a little bit informal, I think, so feel free to jump in and ask questions whenever you have them. Would you kindly turn off the lights for us? Thank you, Jessica. Yes, I'm Owen Doherty. I work for Environmental Incentives.

13:23 We're a small consulting firm based in South Lake Tahoe and we help organizations invest in the community environment more efficiently and effectively by primarily incorporating performance into planning and policy. I've been working with Jessica and Michael Draper for the last couple months.

13:44 Getting to the point where we are today where we have a recommended set of indicators and kind of priority groups using an analytical process primarily with some of their perspective and now we're ready to leverage your guys' perspective so we're not just taking what the analytical kind of process produces but now your guys' perspective on what's important and what matters for the community. The presentation

14:12 Includes most, in the beginning, a background that is basically a summary of the memo that we provided in the package, packet, so the assumption is that you guys have looked at that, so I'll try to move pretty quickly so that we can get to the discussion on the indicators, but please interrupt as I go through these, try to go through these fairly quickly if you have any questions.

14:51 So objectives today, first gain understanding of how we got to where we got, and then, which is basically again the summary of the memo, and then hopefully spend most of our time talking about the specific indicators. The final deliverables of the project will be one, the indicator report, that's the primary deliverable, and I will provide a vision of what that will look like in a second. We've got some mockups that we've put together.

15:23 But it's also important that we're going to produce an annual reporting plan so that next year the reporting can be done efficiently, consistently, accurately using the same methods and to minimize the administrative burden so that this can be a sustainable report and also make it credible because you have the consistency behind it. And then we'll also be providing a tracking spreadsheet so that the historical data is captured and next year and the following years you just have to add, append.

15:50 One more year's worth of data. So in the Community Indicators Report, we've defined a purpose and audience and some objectives to help us as the project team have something to shoot for and be very specific about what that audience is. So the purpose is to educate community members and external audiences. The purpose is not to help a specific organization or department manage

16:24 You know, what they're responsible for. They need a whole set of indicators just to do what they're doing. This is supposed to provide one kind of general broad understanding of the community as a whole. And it's also the community as a whole, not just the town and what the town is responsible for. The audience, in a little more detail, is full-time residents and second homeowners. So keep that in mind when you're thinking about, you know, the target audience of the amount of content and the type of indicators that we're providing.

16:54 As well as potential public and private sector investors. So think of the state legislative staff that may be reviewing a grant application or a private developer in San Francisco that wants to redevelop a dilapidated hotel. So they don't have a ton of understanding of the town government and they want a quick snapshot of how the town is doing. And then some objectives. We want to communicate the trends of sustainability. So are things getting worse, getting better? What are we doing about it?

17:23 Again, trying to provide the right amount of information for that target audience and their attention span. And then create excitement to improve sustainability. So the private sector, public sector, everybody can contribute in influencing the trend of these different indicators. Quick outline. So we're thinking we're going to have an executive summary. We'll just provide the high-level summary of the indicators. Quick introduction.

17:54 Just to provide some context of what's in the report and how the report was developed and then jump right into the indicator. So it's going to be pretty short and brief. This is not some 500 page scientific academic paper. It's something that we want that target audience to be able to grasp. So I've got three mock-ups here. Please do not focus on the actual trend arrows. As you can tell, they're all going

18:25 They're all the same order in each pillar. They're not reflective of those specific indicators. And those indicators are not the final set. This is purely just to give a sense of the look and feel of what the report will look like. So executive summary would be one page and gives you a sense of the breadth of different indicators and the balance between the three pillars. And then a sense of the trend.

18:50 of each of those indicators and then page numbers is just to help navigation. So we've got some other layouts, but this is just one that right now I wanted to share to kind of give a sense of what we're thinking. This is a mock-up of the introduction page. So again, what's in the report, the purposes up above, and then how the indicators were started. So the process that we're going through right now. Okay, I have a question. Sure. What we were given in our packets is

19:21 Copy of the two memoranda that you sent, one in September, one in October. What you're showing us now is the way the indicators report will be designed for the stakeholders and the public. Is that what you're showing us now? Yes. These are mock-ups of the final report of what that will look like, just to give a vision of how those indicators will be presented.

19:44 Because there were different examples in the memorandum, your most recent one, and I wondered, some of them were very simple, others are more complex, but they were so small I couldn't read them. But I'm just wondering what the final product you're producing, and that's what you're showing us now. It's a mock-up of your final product. Yes, so I'm providing this as context before we get into that detail. Does that answer the question? And then the third mock-up is an example indicator page.

20:15 For the economy, one of the three pillars, tourism is one of the categories, and then tourist occupancy tax revenue is one of the indicators. That's on the orange on the left-hand side, a few lines down. Up above is the general plan goals that that indicator is related to and kind of reflects how we're doing in relation to them. And then it says what that indicator is, what it's measuring, why we're measuring it, why this is something that's important.

20:45 To keep an eye on the trend, any other key findings, but a very lightweight amount of content for this audience. And then on the right hand side is an opportunity to describe actions that are being taken that influence that indicator. So any recent policies that have been adopted, any recent projects, there's just an opportunity to highlight things that the town as well as other organizations and partners are doing.

21:14 So those are the three pages that I wanted to share just to provide a vision of what the final report looks like. Any questions? So the process that we've gone through to date, we first looked at seven or eight sustainability standards, looked at a bunch of reports that have been published by other communities, and we created a bunch of best practices, and those are to inform this process.

21:46 Then we compiled a bunch of indicators over 75 related to general plan goals because that is what we had that we believe reflects what matters to the community. That's what we should be measuring. And then we defined criteria to do this analytical evaluation of those indicators. And that analytical evaluation is filtered more than 75 to about 20 that are in the memo that we provided.

22:14 And now we're on the last step where we're asking for stakeholder input from the subject area experts that we spoke to this morning and other one-on-one conversations that we've had and then to get your guys' input. A couple of best practices to highlight. I think we've talked about a couple of these already, but the second one, the manageable list, the idea of, hey, how many indicators does this target audience, can they handle? Do they have the attention span?

22:47 to handle. What's sustainable? So this can be done on an annual basis and not require too much administrative burden. So that's something that we want to make sure we keep in mind here because if you think about one area, of course you want several different indicators to understand exactly what's going on there, but when we're thinking big picture, we've got to remember how many is realistic.

23:11 And then DIA, just to highlight, it's great to leverage existing indicators. So if you have a public health department that is measuring these four things, it's better to grab one of those than to create a fifth indicator. They've probably gone through the process already of finding out what they need to make decisions, what's most reflective of how things are going, what are the conditions on the ground. So it's important to really keep that mind. It reduces the amount of effort.

23:37 And you can kind of piggyback on the effort already invested in figuring out what's important. These are the four criteria that we use to do the analytical evaluation. So when we're talking about the indicators in a minute, keep these in mind. One, is it relevant? So is it really reflecting something that matters to the community as a whole? Or maybe just a sub-constituency?

24:09 And does it really reflect what your goal is too or just a part of it? Is it understandable? So keeping this target audience in mind, are they going to know what that term is? Is that going to resonate with them? Cost and effort, obviously you're not going to create some indicator that requires hundreds of thousands of dollars in monitoring equipment or something. You have to figure out, only include indicators that are feasible. And then last, reliability.

24:36 One is the accuracy. So some of these indicators that have been talked about and we've evaluated, for example, are countywide. And we can't get at the town jurisdiction. And within the town limits and outside town limits, there's some big differences. And so should we use a countywide number in a Mammoth community indicators report is an important question. Because does it accurately reflect what's on the ground?

25:04 The other thing is data integrity. So is it a modeled number or is it an actual conditions number? Is it recent or is it only come out every 10 years and it's a census number or something? So another thing that we want to keep in mind, we want numbers that are as accurately reflective of the conditions as possible. So my proposal is to talk about one pillar at a time. So we'll start with the economy and ask each of you to provide

25:36 One, two, maybe three specific changes that you suggest based on the prioritization that we've identified through the analytical process. Then if there are any public comments that want to be made, and then if we have additional time, we could have some discussion about those changes, but I think our objective is to get as broad of a perspective from you guys as possible on these indicators.

26:10 How does that process sound? We just, excuse me, but we'd like to ask some questions first before we start in this second. Yes, absolutely. Commissioner Harvey. Jessica, possibly some of these questions may be better answered by the town. First of all, is this program tied into our grant funding and

26:49 Yes, it is. Yes. And secondly, is our grant funding dependent upon adopting this program? It is part of our grant funding. It was one of the primary tasks was to complete a community indicators report because it's from the Strategic Growth Council, so this was something that was a very attractive piece of our application.

27:17 I don't know if adoption is the right word. It's probably more acceptance. It's not going to be codified in any way. It's just a tool for the town and the community to use to report out the state of the community. So there's no obligation for adoption, but we should complete it as part of our grant scope and timeline.

27:44 Okay, that was my next question. Is it a document that's going to be codified? No. Okay. One of the things that we have been asked to do by council, as you are aware, is to be developer ready. And the one thing that I look at with a little bit of caution is creating additional hurdles, if you will,

28:14 for developers in the entitlement process. Yes, indeed, the developers coming to town to build something and maybe renovate an older hotel, most developers know exactly what it is that's required from them to get those entitlements and this, in fact, would be, could be another

28:46 Obstacle put forward. Can I respond to that? Go ahead. Yeah, I want to make sure that there shouldn't be any requirement on them. It's only going to inform them. So it helps them understand the community. But they don't have to do that. They don't have to look at it. There's nothing that would be asked of them. Okay. The other things that I would, should we go forward with something of this nature, I would caution about is

29:16 Number one, the legal weight. You answered about the codification of this. That's good. The corresponding nature of this document, specifically to the general plan, would be of paramount concern to me going forward. Because as we do

29:44 These wonderful things of creating more knowledge in the community, which I'm all for, we do need to make sure that we are in compliance with the general plan with every aspect of what we put forward. It's my understanding if after reading the document and listening to you now that should we have indicators

30:19 Sales Tax Occupancy and T.O.T. Surveys on money spent per capita during a visit, metered pedestrian and vehicular traffic. If these things already exist, which will be brought forward and vetted during the initial study process, the CEQA process,

30:46 And if in fact an EIR comes to bear, then they'll be vetted in that process also. Can I interject? So this is part of our grant scope but is not directly related to the zoning code update. So this report is essentially

31:10 As I said, it's a standalone report that is a separate thing from any environmental review. There's no environmental review required of this. It's just reporting out progress towards town goals. So it's going to be, we'll get into some of the indicators that we're proposing, but it's more general in scope and it's saying, you know, are we making progress toward environmental?

31:34 goals. Is our water consumption going down? Is it going up? Is our air quality getting worse or is it getting better? You know, it's going to be up arrows and down arrows and flat arrows. And there is no CEQA required for this process and it doesn't have any relationship to individual development projects. The PI-C was something that we had

32:02 Adopted or passed policy on and that spoke to individual development projects and sort of like a scorecard measured those projects against overall objectives. This is something that's way more high level and is just a communication tool and in some cases might be an advocacy tool and it's just looking at very high level goals and objectives of the community, not just the town.

32:31 Does that clarify? So there is no CEQA related with that? It starts to. Okay. I think that we leverage the general plan goals to use that as our understanding of what matters to the community, but I don't think this should be framed as a report card on the general plan implementation. It's not comprehensive enough. It wasn't intended to do that.

32:58 It's supposed to be actually a little bit broader, but also a little bit more summarized than that. So kind of to build on that, it is definitely kind of a separation from the general plan in itself. Okay. And just a couple more questions, if you'll bear with me. Is this going to be an ongoing process that an outside consultancy will be dealing with, or this will be in-house? But when we have this...

33:27 This would be an in-house effort. Environmental Incentives is setting up the framework and so they're giving us the tools, the detailed tools. So they're behind the document that would come out on a yearly basis. There is a spreadsheet, very detailed, that outlines the methodology for data collection so that in the future it should be, you know, it's not plug and play that easy, but we will know.

33:57 For each indicator that we choose, eventually, how to collect that data, whom to contact if it's something about healthcare or education, who the contacts are with those entities, and they would help us get the data on a consistent basis yearly that's reliable, accurate, and can be done pretty easily over time.

34:22 Not only are we building the detailed instructions, but also working with town staff to build the capacity so that they can do it next year efficiently. Very good. And the final question I'll have is do you see this as similar or replacing the vision statement process that we have gone through in years past?

34:49 I think it's similar to, I don't know if it's a replacement, but just maybe a better communication tool. I think that this is a really, it's going to be a really good tool with uses that we haven't even thought of yet. For example, this morning when we were meeting with the stakeholders, Hector Gonzalez of the court system said, you know, this document, once it's produced, it would be a very good HR

35:19 recruitment tool. When you have potential employees coming in who want to get a sense of what the community is doing and how it's progressing, it can be given to those employees to basically advertise the town. So there's a whole slew of opportunities that this document can be used for. Developers from outside of town can use this to get a general sense of the town's progress.

35:48 So I think there's a lot of opportunity for this that will help not only the town government, but also other agencies. They can use that with whatever means they need. And one thing I don't know if Owen touched on yet, but not all the indicators have to be good. We don't need to show that we're solid and strong and moving ahead on every single thing. Having some indicators that we're showing that we need to have more work.

36:18 Do more work, whether it's the town or the school system or something else. You can use those to highlight and advocate for additional resources for those things. So there's a lot of things that can be done with this, I think. Okay, and excuse me, but just a couple more here. In reading through the text, I came across a couple of areas where it indicated that

36:46 This would be a tool for sitting bodies such as ours to make decisions with. And just the inference was in the entitlement process. And my concerns here are that we don't create yet another document on top of

37:15 The environmental study, the EIR, the CEQA, the zoning code, title 24, general plan, and now another report that would be thrown into that mix if it's something that is aside from these documents, that's something that, you know, could be helpful, but I would really caution against creating another

37:45 legislative hurdle for the entitlement process. Absolutely. And the original contract included an indicators report of how the community is doing at the end, kind of what matters most, the outcomes of all the things that you do, as well as a revision to the PISC. And the revision to the PISC is related to evaluating specific projects.

38:10 So it's kind of different scales. Are you talking about the project impact evaluation criteria? Correct. Okay, thank you. So some of the best practices are related to the PISC, not this report. Okay. So I'm guessing that that one that you're referring to had to do, okay, if you were to improve the PISC, not create another process system scorecard, how could you make the PISC have more influence on project design?

38:38 So I think that's separate than actually the conversation we're having today, and sorry for the confusion. There's a change in scope in the project in the middle of the development of that. So the PISC, both the PISC, which is sort of a separate topic, and this Community Indicators Report will be prepared by staff. The PISC...

38:58 has typically been prepared by staff. Once it's come to the commission, we go through the checklist, so it's never been an additional burden for an applicant to fill out themselves. But, you know, having said that, one of the good things about if, you know, if we continue to use the PISC, which we haven't had a project come forward in quite some time that's had to use it,

39:21 Having that information available that this is part of the staff's evaluation, part of the Planning Commission's evaluation is the PISC scorecard. And it might help developers tweak some things in their project based on that to make it get a higher score, if you will. Correct. And I believe that that would be a worthwhile direction to go. The one thing, and Madam Chair, this is the last.

39:49 The one thing is, thank you, what we're looking at here in the development of this document, it is filled with subjectivity and it always concerns me when there are documents that are very subjective that are brought into the process.

40:19 That's how we wind up with scores of public hearings prior to being able to get something accomplished in development. And the less subjective things are, the more comfortable I am with them. But you've answered quite a few of my questions. Thank you. Sure. Are there any more questions of a general nature, Commissioner Chaney? No, I have comments.

40:47 Yeah, just a couple of quick questions. First of all, thanks for involving us in this process. One question I have here, I know it mentions in the report, you guys initially looked at like 75 indicators and have kind of narrowed it down to this list of 25. We've got them organized in priority groups. Is there a number?

41:13 That we're looking to achieve as far as total number, like do things that fall into draft group three, are they not going to make the cut or how are we looking at that, I guess? Excellent question. Ten is kind of the number that we're like, I think that this target audience would read through all of them. Okay. If we end up with nine, twelve, like that just depends on what we feel comfortable with and what you guys recommend. I think there's eight.

41:41 In the priority one group. So we're thinking most of those will probably stay, but you guys may influence dropping one or two. Okay. And then that middle group, probably a few of those will bump up and make the cut, but it depends on, we kind of wanted to make it so that, you know, your changes were going to, you know, influence what made that line rather than us drop a line. No, that's helpful. I mean, I know it mentioned like three to four per category, so.

42:09 I didn't know if there was like a number we're looking to achieve. And then the second... And if you have a number, if you think there is a right number, you know, we're just in that input too. Sure. You know, the last comment I had initially before we go into kind of the debate was just originally I felt like the organization of this chart was a little bit difficult to follow, like from our packet, so it was good to see on the PowerPoint that it's going to be organized in a different manner that will be, you know, easier to read for the public.

42:38 Right. This is targeted for this decision-making process. Okay. Not, yeah, so. Sure. Sorry if that wasn't, no, it's okay. Communicated clearly. Yeah. I just have a comment of a general nature. I think what's going to be very important for this indicators report is the introduction that we put in there so that people really understand how to use it. I think that's going to be a real important part of it. Okay. All right. So with that, which, pardon me.

43:07 I just have one clarifying question. If you would, on, I don't know if it's marked in your packet there, page 81 in our packet, and it's this page. The second bubble, excuse me, the third bubble down, says prioritize indicators using evaluation criteria.

43:34 Just clarify this for me. It says that the criteria were based on criteria, it's the second sentence down, used by other sustainability indicators selection process. And an objective one, and then you have in parentheses worst, through five best rating scale was defined for each criteria. And I was a bit confused on the following page.

44:04 in the draft list of indicators where it says draft priority group and I'm curious, is that, were you rating number one as worst and number five as best? I'm confused. Sorry, so the five being best, one being worst only applies to the evaluation criteria. So the four are the relevance, understandability, effort, and reliability, only those columns.

44:34 The priority group is a separate thing. So I totally understand why that would be confusing. Sorry about that. It's not just me. Why don't we start by going through the list and then you can provide a sample of how it is done. So the list in your five-page memo

45:01 is the same as these slides except for the community. On the community, we have added one based on the conversation of stakeholders this morning. And the slide, I only have the first two priority groups. So if you want to follow along with the memo, obviously there's an area for you guys to take notes, but also just understand that it's a more complete list. So for economic indicators, there were these...

45:39 Two, you can't really see on the slide, but in the handout, the top two were the two that made the top priority list. Both are quite relevant and both are easy, relatively easy and highly reliable. So we know the TOT revenue that comes in and we track it internally, the town does. And it's relevant. It describes how we're doing as we're doing economically in the community.

46:07 Although primarily tourists, there are other aspects of the community, but it is the primary one. Sales tax revenue would be another alternative to consider, to include, replace or include as an alternative indicator. That was going to be my first comment, that I think sales tax revenue needs to be added, not replaced for that, because they are, TOT is driven obviously by

46:37 Heads in beds and ADR and those kind of things. But that's really a different scale of economy than looking at the dollars spent in the community at restaurants, retail stores, those kind of things. So I think they both are important and augment each other. So that was going to be my first comment with the economy, that we would need to add that in as a level one priority. And do we know if the town tracks that? We do. Sales tax, yeah. Okay. Just want to confirm.

47:05 Are we going to do this one page at a time? Is that what we want to do? Yeah, I want to focus just on the economy first, if that's okay. So just a quick highlight, subsidized school lunch eligibility, you know, gives you an understanding of, you know, poverty level and how young families are doing in the basin. This morning a stakeholder suggested that it's probably about 50% in the community that's eligible. And then mountain visitors and business licenses were also considered, but both of them have, you know, they're kind of,

47:33 Provide kind of a component of how you're doing it from a total economy, but not really reflective overall. Could you elaborate a little bit on the other level and priority, the resident healthcare payer groups? Oh, sorry. So the idea there is it tells you percentage-wise of what are the payers using private insurance or public?

48:01 So it gives you a sense of, one, what portion is using government insurance, which reflects poverty level and income. But the higher that is, usually the public insurance pays less, and so there's costs pushed onto the private insurance companies, and it has, usually in a small community, it influences the level of care and

48:28 General cost of, so, in Southlake, for example, it's like three times more expensive to have a, deliver a child there than off the hill. And it's primarily because the, you know, the volume or the percentage of government insurance payers is very high in the community. Go.

48:49 Thank you. So one reason why that's a really good indicator, it may not sound initially like it's a good indicator for the community, but the reliability of the data is extremely good. We can get it specifically for the hospital. We can make sure that it's residents, not people breaking their legs on the hill. So it's a good economic indicator for the overall economic health of the community. And just to add, a lot of these indicators influence multiple pillars, too.

49:18 You could put this under community as well, but we felt it was most relevant under the economy of color. Mr. Taney, we're just commenting one page at a time, so did you have any comments on this particular page? I have general comments related to this page. I haven't made any general comments yet. What would you let me do? Let's make our general comments and then we need to start moving along the page because we have other items to do. Okay.

49:49 I think the concept of having a community indicators report is excellent and I see it as the bridge between the general plan's vision statement and the implementation of the general plan and it sort of helps us keep our eye on the prize with these indicators. I think that conceptually is a good thing. I think we need the fewest indicators possible. I even wonder if 10 or too many. However, this economic page doesn't work for me at all. I think that

50:18 All our indicators economically should be focused on improving the visitor experience because it's only by doing that that we're going to have a healthy economy and be able to have the quality of life that locals want. To do that, improving the visitor experience, whether it's customer service or public safety or reducing graffiti,

50:37 We're going to increase occupancy because we're going to get return visitors. When we increase occupancy, we increase TOT. We've been working for years trying to increase midweek visitation and shoulder season visitation. Until this storm today, we just finished six weeks of gorgeous weather and you could take a nap in the middle of the street. I mean, nobody's here and we've been fighting this for years, how to get those people here in this especially desirable weather shoulder season. I also think economically a draft element

51:06 of our, for our general plan was prepared by our previous Community Development Director, it's called Resort Investment, and it's in our packets attached to the commercial zoning, and the first page and a half of that are the kinds of things that I think we should be, we should be looking at. These, I understand what you're saying, Jessica, about the reliability of the data for the health insurance for residents, and of course school lunch eligibility.

51:31 I'm not even sure what's meant by mountain visitors. Are you talking about number of lift tickets sold? Are you talking about visitors to a mountain resort community based on heads and beds? You know, where did that come from? And the other thing I'd like to say, and I'm very concerned about this, is we just get piles and piles of things to read, and I've been doing this for a long time, and I had to read this twice before I understood it, and I still didn't understand all of it. It's very densely written.

51:58 And the reason I asked you about the mock-up of the report, that is not accessible to the general public. I just wrote down quickly, you wrote, let's see if I can find it, about the economy. TOT revenue is a proxy for the economic health of the community. That just isn't meaningful to most people. And I'm not saying we need any kind of dumbed-down version. Everybody's busy.

52:25 Life is complex enough as it is. We need to have something simple that we can look at and say, yep, we're getting better. Nope, we're getting worse. We've got to work on that. And stuff like that, all the verbiage is just not going to work. I was interested to see the very simple slides that you showed in the back with photographs and arrows about new pedestrian bike paths. I mean, that's very simplistic, but it's very straightforward, too. I thought Whistler's, even though I couldn't read it, was sort of hard to, you know, absorb.

52:55 But it's just going to be another document that sits on the shelf unless it's really accessible. And I think it could be an extremely useful document. So what I would like to see on the economic page, since that's what you're asking me, Chair Brown, would be those criteria that I mentioned, increasing occupancy, increasing TOT, midweek visitation, building shoulder season, and building partnerships.

53:18 Because the town is in such a bad shape financially, I mean, almost everything we do is funded by grants, and we've got to have more public-private partnerships to get things done, and the indicators should be focused on improving the visitor experience, because when we do that, everything's going to go up. And I think we should use the resort investment, the first page and a half of that, as a, what should I say, inspiration maybe, for how to express some of these indicators? This just doesn't work for me. Well, I mean,

53:47 So you have to have, for this process to work, you have to have quantifiable things. Okay, occupancy. And we've looked at that. And so we thought that TOT and sales tax, out of all of the things that we can do to measure increases to visitation, which stems from what you're talking about, improving the community appearance.

54:15 Increasing events. All of those things contribute to the bottom line, if you will, of the town. Exactly. And so, you know, we had thought about, well, maybe we'll measure the number of events. But when you start to dig down into the detail, it's, well, how big is that event? Did it bring five people? Did it bring 3,000? So when you get down to the bottom line, revenue, I think, is probably the best indicator. And not...

54:44 None of the indicators are perfect. There's issues with each one. Not every indicator captures everything. TOT only captures visitation. It doesn't capture the economic impact of local residents. That's where sales tax comes in. So keep in mind that these things are meant to be quantifiable, reliable.

55:11 As objective as possible. So we can't say things like, you know, community design element was really hard for us because it's like, well, how do you objectively measure improvements to community design? Is it, you know, how happy is Elizabeth or how sad is Elizabeth? You know, we can't put that in the indicator report. Stick it to me, Jessica. No, no, I mean that in a very nice way.

55:39 You know what I mean? So it has to be something that we can measure. Okay, but we can measure how many people we've got here in the shoulder season. We can measure emplainments for destination visitors. There's a lot of stuff we can be measuring, and I'm not sure this is a fit for us. And the last thing I want to do is use our limited staff resources and our limited time pursuing something that's not going to get us where we want to go.

56:02 And so that's why this economic section doesn't work for me. This is a report of how you're doing on where you want to go. This document won't get you where you want to go. It's reporting on your progress. But I think the key here, just to keep in mind, to make this particular report effective, we need 10 to 15 indicators. So I think we can do this two ways. Either staff can note what you think should be the indicators.

56:31 Because remember, you have to go through each group. Or if you can, you could tell us what are those top indicators out of your list now, or you could email it to them after you've had some time to reflect on it. No, no, I reflected. Okay, so did you know which indicators? Yeah, can I respond to that? Yes. So first, everything that you've read so far is not going to be...

56:55 Shared with the public, right? None of that is the report. The report is what... Oh, no, I realize that, but seeing the mock-up, I was concerned about where we were going now. I appreciate that you see value in this and also the need to keep the number of indicators short that is often overlooked by people. This experience using surveys is a great indicator.

57:23 So, great idea.

57:52 Something to keep in mind. So often the people who fill out the surveys are people with gripes. What I'm interested in is return visitation. The return visitor is so much cheaper to bring back than to bring the first visitor here. That's what I'm interested in. Do we have that data? Do we have that indicator? From Mammoth Lakes Tourism, we may, but they try and do surveys, I know, and some of these people are sort of irritated to see that in their...

58:15 Program or whatever, you know, it's a problem. Yeah, there's a whole. This is very complicated. There's a whole art to doing surveys. This is very complicated, but we're trying to figure out what we can do today. Commissioner Harvey. Yeah, I've got a couple of items here maybe to, we can move forward with. TOT is definitely, and this is my opinion here, sales tax, definitely, airport and planements. Good.

58:45 Occupancy. And the last one I have is per capita spending. And I know that the last survey that we had done had that particular number. And I'm not sure if that was just a survey directly to the people or if it was equated from occupancy and TOT.

59:21 Occupancy, TOT, and sales tax to come up with that per capita number. Anyway, those one, two, three, four, five, I think are economy indicators for representative of our particular area. I agree. I was just going to say that I think we should have TOT.

59:51 I believe we need to have sales tax because we have often experienced that sometimes our TOT patterns do not necessarily follow our sales tax patterns. Regarding health care, I think that's a little problematic because it appears that we're in some sort of change in health care, but I do believe that there needs to be an indicator because we really want a healthy community, I mean in all aspects of the community.

1:00:17 vote would be to put the subsidized school lunch eligibility in there versus the health care. The health care, you say this is something that could be moved to the community pillar, correct? We could. There are a lot on that page as well. Okay. Yeah. So, yes, we definitely can. Okay. Commissioner? You know, just to kind of circle back, number one and two clearly for me are TOT revenue and sales tax revenue.

1:00:49 I think we need to think about limiting each of these categories to three, maybe four at the maximum for an important category. So I don't necessarily have an exact opinion on what the third one should be, but those are my clear one and two. So do you have enough feedback now on the economy? Yeah, that's great. Okay. You know what I'll do is...

1:01:17 Let us go through this once and then we'll open up to public comments since you're so gracious to sit here and listen to this. So moving on to community, we're going to look at one change is student overweight obesity. That was one that came out of the discussion this morning with stakeholders that those stakeholders felt it was like the public health indicator to consider.

1:01:48 Okay. And the date is available and they will provide it to us for the town. Okay. My one comment that I had on the chart, I actually like most of the level one priorities. We may not be able to keep them all. I feel pretty strongly about the fact that miles of sidewalk and trails created should be moved into a draft priority group one. That's something we really talk about.

1:02:15 extensively in our general plan is moving to more of a pedestrian feet first friendly environment and I think that's a very easily measurable and tangible indicator of how we're doing in that respect. You know it always excites me every time I see a new sidewalk going up and I think I would elevate that to priority one. Great. Which one would you want to get rid of?

1:02:50 See how hard it is? I kept, like, me and Owen have been battling. I wanted all of them, but it's too much. Yeah. Circle back to me. Let somebody else talk for a second. All right. You have comments on this page? Yeah, they're following along Commissioner Ernie's thought, you know, local transit participation, high school graduate rate, crime rate, medium home sales price.

1:03:18 I would move up there also miles of sidewalk and trails created. Quite frankly, going down the list from there, although they're all interesting, I'm not totally sure what decisions going forward we're going to put a lot of weight on any of these. I think individually some of them may have

1:03:57 You know, some weight, but if you look at them all together, that's, well, that's a lot of stuff. Right. So, I'm more in favor of... What's your top two? Out of that group? Yeah, out of that group. What, top two or top three out of a group? Special event permits, and...

1:04:25 Do you mean out of the bottom tier? Out of the bottom tier. Oh, okay. Well, no, you've got to get me out of the page because we're going to get maximum three out of this page. It would be, I like the top three, actually. Okay. So I'm good with that. Okay. So I have an answer for you now. Okay. What's your top? You know, as we're talking about getting somewhere in the neighborhood of 10 to 12 total, I think.

1:04:52 You know, we obviously have a much more extensive list for this. I feel that there need to be five in this category to add to maybe three in three in the other categories for a total of 11. That would be fine. So I think all four of those top ones are the best indicators of those particular categories, and I really see the importance of moving sidewalk and trails up into there. So I would suggest three for economy and five for community, and then we can look at.

1:05:22 You know, maybe two or three for environment. All right. You've got your top three, Elizabeth. Top three? Okay. I'm very intrigued with student obesity. That's a good measure. Miles and sidewalk and trails created, absolutely. Crime rates. And it's a toss-up between transit system participation and high school graduation. Okay. My absolute top one is transit, since we talk about feet first over and over again.

1:05:55 But I am good with the top three, transit, graduation, and crime rate. And then if I had another one to add, I'd put either medium home sales price or household income versus home purchase cost. Moving on to the next page. Unless you want more feedback. That was very direct and concise. I appreciate that. So Elizabeth, you said...

1:06:26 You said crime rates, local transportation system participation. And miles of sidewalks and trails. You know, because of the student of BC not being on this page, I feel like it may have been overlooked a little bit. Do you mind just, what's your general thought on that one? Does it make that final cut? Yeah. It does. I think that's a good one, yeah. And I did overlook it because it wasn't on our chart, so, yeah. Anyone else want to comment on that?

1:06:54 I think it's an indicator of a segment of our population. So as long as somewhere in the report we're tracking the overall health of that segment of the population, I think it's good. But I don't know if necessarily student obesity has to be the indicator. That's kind of a long answer. That's a good point. Did anybody else have a comment about obesity? Yeah, it was interesting talking to Sandra Pierce about that this morning because

1:07:23 She was saying that it's a much higher number than you would think. Well, I'm sure, I'm positive it is. So, but there might be like, that number might also like, for example, correlate with subsidized lunches or something like that. I mean, so that's, I just want to make sure that because we're trying to limit the indicators that if there's another indicator that's also tracking that, that you understand what I'm saying? Yeah. Okay. All right, so let's talk about environmental indicators.

1:07:52 Water consumption is a clear number one for me. That's a really important thing in this community for us to continue to focus on. I think recycling rate is a great top tier one. I think this community is currently deficient in our recycling capabilities. So I'd like to see that improved and focused on. Put a third one in there, it would probably be air pollution would be.

1:08:28 My third priority, but I agree with the top two as a clear one and two. Okay. Okay. Water consumption, definitely, particulate air pollution and stream quality in that order. It pains me about electricity consumption because so many of our condo developments have these resistance heaters in the walls and they're just, you know, burning dollar bills, but water consumption would be top, air pollution would be second.

1:09:03 And I think stream quality over recycling because the environment is our product and if we don't have it, we can't sell it. So that's really, it all goes along with the visitor experience. So mine would actually be, first would be air pollution, water consumption, stream quality, and then if I had a fourth one, it would be recycling. Sorry, can you say those again? My first one was air pollution. Okay. Okay. And then water consumption, stream quality,

1:09:35 And then if I had a fourth one, it would be recycling. Great. My last final comment would be that it seems like it's going to be difficult to keep this under ten indicators. So I would suggest a final indicator number of 12. And, you know, that gives us up to four per category or give five in one area, three in another. I think we can get away with three in the economy, five in the community, and four in the environment.

1:10:07 That's fine. That's still a very manageable list for staff. So if you wouldn't mind, I mean, we do have some knowledgeable people in the public that audience, if you'd like to make comments, either of you, would you please come to the podium? Knowledgeable people. The knowledgeable. And I would also hope before Tom gets here that the final report would have easy to understand graphs, lots of graphics, and limited unverbiage.

1:10:36 Mr. Knowledgeable Person, would you state your name? Tom Hodges, Director of Planning, Mammoth Mountains here. One of the economic indicators I thought should be on this would be building permits and valuations. Oh. More so than, I mean, it would be in my top three for sure. Oh. Did you, had you considered that, Jessica? We did consider that, and I can't remember what the, what the perceived issue was. Community.

1:11:08 Project permit valuation, we also talked about units. I'm sorry, you're going to have to come to the mic, otherwise when it's televised nobody can hear you. So I don't remember exactly why it was downgraded a little bit, but project permit valuation, if that's available, would be even better than the number of projects. So you can see the size of the project as well as the volume. And then we also talked about units approved. So residential units or commercial square feet that are approved.

1:11:39 Annually. Does that resonate with the public? Does it make the top? And you would put that in the community pillar? Well, one thing that Owen and I discussed this morning, and Mickey had brought it to my attention, was that back when we were involved in the PAOT and PIC policy development, the PAOT policy resolution

1:12:07 refers to one of our actions being the creation of a community indicators report and part of it including our progress towards the PAOT number, which is, you know, really ties to the number of units that are approved and that we monitor and track in our build-out model. So the PAOT model, you know, its foundation is the existing unit count, which

1:12:35 Annually we would be adding to that, updating that as units are approved and built every year. So he and I talked about how we might be able to incorporate that into this and it's hard to think about which pillar it might go into. I think maybe economy would be the more relevant one.

1:12:58 Because it's an indication of just overall economic health, you know, the development community. But it could also just serve as a generalized, you know, this is our progress, or not, I shouldn't say progress, but this is the monitoring that we're doing that would account for new building permits and new construction that happens on a yearly basis.

1:13:21 Those are very important indicators. Two comments. One is, you know, they are more action-oriented, you know, things that you're doing to increase your sales tax revenue and increase your TOT or occupancy. So we may be wanting to focus this report on what, at the end result, what matters, not how you get there. The other thing is, does it resonate with the general public? So you may have a few dozen really informed stakeholders that want to know PAOT and units, but, you know, is this second homeowner from

1:13:51 Santa Clara, going to know what a POT is. Is that something that should fit in this report? Hello, Tom. Quantifiable. Tom Cage. So, could we go back two slides? Is that in our capacity? I think so. Not prioritizing these, just pointing out a few things. Subsidized school lunch is really a contrary economic indicator.

1:14:25 If we're busier in town, we will have a higher flow of folks that will become eligible for school lunch programs. Because of the economic base of those people that come into town, a lot of the service workers will apply for that. I'm not saying it's wrong to have that in there, but I don't know that it should be in your top three or four or when Colin says 13 or 14.

1:14:53 I think are his next numbers. And over to a baker's dozen. There's 12, 12, to clarify. So that's just one point I want to bring out. If you want to add a consideration for economic indicators to try to measure people, you can do sewer flows. It's not a pretty thing, but it's pretty accurate. And we can go back in history, we can give a lot of data that will show in January of 2006 when we had, when town was, I think,

1:15:22 The last time it was as full as it's ever been. You can see the spikes and you can take that and then compare it to October 20th. I mean, you know, a date when town is rather sparse on people. So it's a very quantifiable number that you can arrive at people that are here. Tom, would it be safe to say that if you use the occupancy number?

1:15:49 And the sewer flow numbers charted together, you would be able to identify more closely how many people were in town, not just what the rental capacity was during that particular time, but you would be able to tell more accurately how many people were in town. Well, you could... Here's the problem we've always had. Because of the amount of beds you have available.

1:16:17 So how many people are in town has a direct correlation to sewer flow. Okay. Okay. Now, if you look at that and you say, well, our occupancy was 54%. Well, 54% in 2003 is a lot different than 54% today. Correct. That's what I'm saying. So you'd have to have a third indicator on how many beds were available for rent, and that might get tough to keep track of. So just to interject really quick.

1:16:47 You know, PAOT is an important number to this community, or I shouldn't even say to the community. It's an important number to the town and to the decision-making bodies. As far as how many people, in terms of looking just at this community indicators report as a state of the town, in my opinion is that it's not so much about the number of people, it's how much money are they spending. Thank you.

1:17:15 And that's the more important thing for this topic. We would like to perfect a way to figure out what our visitation is and how many people there are, but the thing that it all boils down to is what are they spending their money on. That's my opinion. And I don't disagree with that, but at the same point in time, if you can document a million people going through town in the course of a quarter, let's just say.

1:17:44 And your sales revenue goes down, your sales tax revenue goes down, or your TOT goes down. That's the kind of identifier that you really want to be on top of. If we generate X number of, and all of these go together, they're not by themselves, so they do have some overlap. Exactly. Which they should, and that's great. But you really want to try to hone in on TOT revenue. That's very, very measurable.

1:18:12 That's based on how many dollars came in from and was derived by, okay? If we can tie a fairly accurate number to people and then we look at how much we generated in sales tax revenue, then all those, you know, we want to see go up. If we get any imbalance in any of those, that's what we want to identify and then say, wait a minute, what's happened? Or are people not spending? Or are their spending patterns changed?

1:18:41 Or are they six to a, are they using the full occupancy of that condo? I mean, you can start to derive some of those numbers, and I can't remember all of them in the old days with the resort association, but the number of people per stay has changed. Right. So could we go to the next slide? Can I just comment on that? So one of the things I want to just think about is that maybe what we would do, Jessica,

1:19:10 is have a subset of indicators that would not necessarily be included in our main report. So, because it is a very valid comment that, you know, if your TOT goes up, your sales tax goes down, your sewage rate, you know, goes down, something like that, then somebody needs to really explore that. But I don't know if every single report, so maybe we might have a subset that we would just look at just to make sure that the whole, you know,

1:19:39 realm of revenue was in balance or something. And there's no right or wrong. I mean, you've got good indicators there. There's nothing wrong with any of those. It's just I point out that one. And whatever you do has to be quantifiable and correlate to some other things so you can. So hopefully we take away the peaks and the valleys. Right, correct. In our thought process, in our decision making, and in our businesses. A couple of these. High school graduate, everybody graduates.

1:20:12 So it's not a real good indicator. So instead of high school grad rate, may I suggest average SAT scores or ACT scores? Because in the high school of the kids, I think in the last four or five years, and I'm not counting dropout rates, there have been some dropouts, but it's been very small numbers. But I think in the last four or five years, I've heard of two kids that haven't graduated, that were seniors that stayed in school.

1:20:40 So I don't know that you get a good number, but an SAT or ACT scores, you would get an average number, even though all kids don't take the SAT. So that's a thought there. Dave's leaning forward. No, I agree. The indicators that we use have to be quantifiable information for the decision-making process.

1:21:12 for the general audience, not for a small, specific group, or we're defeating our purpose. And quite frankly, looking at all in community, looking at all of these, that's mind-boggling. The first thing that comes to my mind is how do I correlate them? How do I put them together and make sense? So the idea of, you know,

1:21:42 three or four per pillar, it makes all the sense in the world. If it's information that can correlate with each other and you can come to a conclusion very quickly, I think then it's a usable tool. But I don't, some of these things on community, I don't know how I'm going to balance the local transit system with the

1:22:12 Resident Health Diagnostic Statistics. I don't know how I'm going to do that. And I don't think that you're supposed to. I mean... Well, I wouldn't. I wouldn't do that. But as a decision maker, and I have this information, that's just another step that one has to go through to try and quantify what this really means. And the fewer the items, I think...

1:22:43 That will serve us much better in the long run in the decision making process. That's what I'm saying. I mean, if you're trying to arrive at, is the local school system doing a good job at education, which is the sustainability category, then they have scores that they have there on testing, star testing at lower grades and then other testing in the high school and they have a state.

1:23:13 State test that they assign a number to at the high school and I don't know how often those change but we're at 8, I think 820 was last year's test for the high school and that's a number that's quantifiable and it tests and compares everyone then the SATs and the ACTs. You know, student obesity, it's a choice that unfortunately happens.

1:23:39 Based on lack of participation or poor eating habits. Parks and rep participation, some years they hit home runs. Some years they won't have as popular programs. Miles of sidewalks I like because of the feet first. The local transportation makes a lot of sense to me. The crime rates make a lot of sense. So some of those things up there I don't get. So anyway, my only point is on the high school grad rate and doing it with either SAT or ACT. One more.

1:24:09 Can I just make a comment on what Dave said? I just wanted to follow on what Dave said. Did you want to comment on the previous slide? Is that what you wanted to comment? I did want to make one brief comment on what Dave said about correlating. I think the most useful part of this report were the weaknesses of peer cities in terms of trying to implement, you know, community indicators, and I would hope that you would pay attention to that with all seriousness, and one of the things they point out over and over again, too many indicators.

1:24:38 Following on what Dave said. Yeah, because they do have to correlate. I think the Elizabeth Tenney meter, I think, could hold a lot of water. Anyway, on this one, water consumption, keep in mind we have treated, non-treated, recycled. So soon, within, I would say within three years, we will be able to give you numbers of water that goes to public use and irrigation use.

1:25:07 We might not have every single one, but we will have a real good indicator of that, and we derive that because of winter use and non-winter use. So in the water consumption, just get that a little bit more defined, recycled water will max out. We can only recycle so much water because we can't do it as effectively in the winter, if at all, sometimes, because we don't have enough flow.

1:25:35 In the summer we'll max out based on what we can recycle because of the financial feasibility of who will accept it. Not every condo project would want it and of course the golf courses will take up a good part of it. So the water consumption rate and then if you tie that to water consumption by person, by person living here and by visitors.

1:26:00 It's a big indicator, and LA is doing this more and more. LADWP is looking at, we're using, if I remember the numbers right, 88 gallons per person per day. To give you an idea, in the more arid places in the Middle East, they use under 20 or in the low 20s. So LA is looking at that saying, okay, we've got to close that gap because we can't afford to continue growth and supply water at a rate of 88 gallons per person per day.

1:26:30 So there are ways to do it and they'll be focusing on that. Recycling rate, we all have to get to mandated things by 2020, same as water. So we have to do what we are doing to get the water consumption down by 2020 and it's a 20% reduction over the five-year prior average from when that went into effect. The water district's already accomplished that and so we'll be a great deal lower than that.

1:27:00 But recycling will be the same thing. So that'll be tough to, I think, follow. Electric consumption makes a lot of sense. And particulate, stream quality, again, those are easily quantifiable. And then the last thing is if it gets too complicated on water consumption or if you want to look at a growth factor, you could look at a growth. Instead of building permits, you could look at MEUs.

1:27:29 So when someone comes in for a water permit, it's a meter equivalent unit, is how it's measured. How much water could that person potentially use? We have to be able to deliver. So when we put in a one-inch meter, we have to be ready to deliver more water than if it's a three-quarter or if it's a three-inch. So it's a very easy thing to monitor and to see as growth goes up because building permits for a condo, single-family home, commercial.

1:27:58 Those all change. So again, you were talking about building permits, but it gets tough to quantify that. Thank you. Thank you very much. Thank you, Dawn. So I have a suggestion. Should we ask staff to come back with another, in essence, scaled-down draft? So I mean, basically, if we start, I mean, we did eliminate some items. I don't know if you realize that or not. But maybe you could come back, you know, and you don't necessarily, you don't have to come back.

1:28:28 Jessica, you could just come back at one of our meetings with a scaled downdraft, you know, maybe it would be 20 items or whatever, and then we could just take a look at it one more time and then give you some more concise feedback if you need it. Yeah, I think we can definitely do that. And then I think also part of this that we haven't really focused on today is the caveats, I think is a good word for some of these things.

1:28:56 You know, on face value, electricity consumption seems like a good one, but when you, as I said before, when you start to drill down into the specifics of it, it's like, well, does that include Mammoth Mountain? You know, things that could potentially have huge influences on that number. So what we can do is we can narrow it down and then maybe we can also, we'll bring it back and report out some of the

1:29:21 A little bit more detail about what the pros and cons of each one of those is to maybe help make your decision more informed. Is that agreeable? Yes. I have one more small point, okay? I forgot a really big point. How do indicators figure in with, like, we don't get snow, or the mountain has to make a lot more snow than they think they're going to have to, and then all the electricity costs that go along with that, or even the possibilities almost happen, I think.

1:29:48 Somewhat recently, running out of enough water to make snow. How does that fit in with these indicators? What if you have an extenuating circumstance? What if we have poor media coverage like we did last year? We had great snow and then people said, oh, no, it's not snowing so I'm not going to go ski. How do those things fit in? So I think that, you know, yeah, there will be extenuating circumstances. There might be...

1:30:12 A new factor that influences one of the indicators one year and not the next or one year out of ten. Is it going to be a footnote or is it going to be a subtitle or how is it going to fit in? On that indicator mock-up at the bottom where it was like what is this measuring, why is it important, the bottom said additional findings where you can have one or two bullets to have an opportunity to describe some of those nuances.

1:30:36 You have to prioritize what you put there because you want to keep that short. But that would be the opportunity to say, hey, you know, there was a major macroeconomic factor here that took into play. It wasn't like we did something. Or we had an earthquake or something. Yeah, or a terrible, very warm winter. And keep in mind that there is detailed information that supports this that will be used by staff.

1:31:02 Can be also provided to the public if there are specific questions about how did you get to this number? That will always be available, but it wouldn't be in the final report, just to keep things simple and short. But transparency is part of this. Credibility is important. So we want to make sure that we have all the backup documentation that feeds into it.

1:31:28 Okay. Thank you. Well, thank you. Did we give you enough input? Yes. Thank you for the investment in time before the meeting and during the meeting. That was really good input. I appreciate it. Thank you. Thank you very much for coming. Thanks. I'd like to propose that we take a five-minute break to see if Commissioner Dugans can be able to join us, and then we will adjourn after that five minutes and go to agenda item number three. Yeah. I hope Rhonda can be here. I did, but I can drink.

1:32:20 Code. So we thought we would talk about each of these separately. So, for example, we would talk about the three commercial zoning areas. And if you had any questions of staff, then you could ask staff. Then we'd move on to the next one, unless somebody wanted an overview of the actual zoning code update. And then the last thing that we would talk about is density.

1:33:03 Is that agreeable to everybody? Okay. So if you would please, Jessica, would you start? The first one is that the commercial zoning update is presented. It has three commercial zoning sub-areas. Now the downtown, the mixed lodging residential, and the old Mammoth Road. So does anybody have any questions about that? Is everybody in agreement with three sub-areas? Yes? Okay. The second one.

1:33:37 Is use tables. We spent a lot of time in our working group working on use tables and they were revised at the 7-12-13 meeting. Does anybody have any questions about the use tables? The overall concept of the use table was to make it very easy to approve something by permit only. No, Pete.

1:34:12 Permitted is, it means it's as of right. They would get a business license and they would get a building permit. But permitted, there's permitted, there's administrative, and then there's use permit. So the concept that we carried forward with the use tables was to simplify the process for uses that are desired in those zones by making more of them, things that used to be a use permit, are now permitted as of right.

1:34:41 So page 105 of the packet under district and use regulations tables, there's four bullet points at the top that describe some of the concepts that went into the use tables and regulations. One of those, as Mickey said, is having the three commercial districts. That allows us to refine the regulations for those zones more specifically. Designated active frontages, which we haven't touched on yet.

1:35:11 But the third bullet point on page 105 says establishing additional permitted uses as of right to promote desired uses and also streamline the development process. Does that make sense? All right. Would you please note that Commissioner Dugan joined us? Thank you. And then what we're doing is we are going through the key elements of the commercial zoning chapter one element at a time and then we're going to ask questions and then we'll just make sure that. So we

1:35:41 I'll discuss the three sub-areas. I'm sure you're in agreement with us. Okay. Now we're talking about the use tables as presented. Does anybody have any questions or comments about the use table as presented? So let me just bring one thing to attention for the sake of the public. We did prepare a revision to the staff report yesterday that has been provided to the Commission. There are copies available in the back.

1:36:07 The primary revision to the staff report included an additional option for consideration by the Planning Commission. So I just want to make that clear that if anyone has an older version, there is an update available. And if anybody in the public would like to comment on any of these sections, you can just let us know. All right. So everybody's agreement on the use tables. The next one is the development standards as accepted by the working group on 7-12-13.

1:36:39 Are there any questions on the development standards? Do you need any... Oh, wait, wait, I'm sorry. Commissioner, Danny asked that we go back to the use tables. I'm sorry, or maybe this is something that has to be taken. Daycare, why is it specified as only children? Because there's senior daycare in many communities. What page are you on? I'm sorry. Well, I'm on page 161. It's the appendix.

1:37:15 Oh, and the definitions. Use classifications. So we can. I think there's assisted living facility. No, this is senior daycare where you, the senior person who needs care during the day while the person with whom they're living is at work. Are you looking at family daycare home? Yes. So that's a definition that comes state from the state health and safety code and is specific to child.

1:37:47 Care. Should we do a second one for seniors? Well, we do have, so you're saying it's something different than residential care system. Make it consistent with the daycare centers as defined on page 165, and that needs to be specified for seniors. One thing that, so it says it's other, it says other than family daycare.

1:38:24 So that would be persons other than as defined under family daycare, which is specific to state code. Okay, so one minute. And Chair, can I ask two more questions? Yes. Nurseries and garden centers, page 164, why are they only allowed to sell a limited amount of a product they grow themselves? What was the rationale for that? That is something I would have to look into. I'm just curious about that. Well, I believe, remember, this is our,

1:38:58 Our commercial zones that we're, you know, we're trying to develop these pedestrian-friendly environments. They wouldn't be growing it on the site, they'd be growing it off-site, I'm sure. I mean, how could they grow it on the site? Well, I mean, that was the purpose. Maybe it wasn't explicit enough. Yeah, perhaps we clarify that it refers to limited amount of product that is grown on-site. That's the intent. I think that's the intent. And then one small thing on that same page where it says pet grooming.

1:39:29 And then the text says grooming or selling dogs, cats, similar small animals. So I think we ought to change, make a more inclusive title. Okay. That's all, thank you. Did you, anybody else have any comments on the use tables? So, is everybody good with the way the use table was presented? Good. All right. So we'll move to the third section, which is development standards.

1:40:08 Was there any comments about development standards? So there's, just to give a brief synopsis, starting on the bottom of page 105 and continuing to page 106, those bullet points describe the general intent of the development standards to further pedestrian-oriented streetscapes.

1:40:35 Design standards such as stepbacks, setbacks, building articulation, roof articulation, all the things that we have looked at through our design guidelines but haven't been codified. So that's the intent of the development standards. We did have group consensus from the working group that they were in support of the development standards.

1:41:15 Does anybody have any comments on the development standards? Commissioner Tenney, did you have comments? Well, it's just a matter of wording, and this is only the staff report, this isn't in the zoning code, but the whole concept of a white box was to show a potential investor what they could do, and they could figure out if they could take the property pencils, you know, our standard phrase. And it says the white box also ensures that the community has high design standards in that. I don't see the linkage there.

1:41:46 And you expressed that concept twice, and I wasn't quite sure what the connection is. We're going to actually talk about the white box in a second. So we'll talk about that. Right. So this is the actual development standards as presented in the draft commercial zone. Yeah, maybe I wasn't clear, but yeah, the white box is just the envelope. And I mean, to some extent that...

1:42:10 I mean, to a large extent, that overlaps with the development standards. The development standards form the white box. So before, we didn't have things in the code like step backs that help form that white box. It might not be a perfectly square box. It could be a, you know.

1:42:31 A multi-formed box. So those two things together are trying to achieve the design standards. Not design standards from is the building pink or purple, but does it have the articulation that we want to see. Now what we discussed last week is that last meeting just seems like where our white box previously was an envelope and a white box and that's where it is to take it.

1:43:03 to where that's more of a generic term for all the design standards you need to start with here to ensure that we have the right design standards given to the developer at the beginning. Correct. So it's greatly enhanced. It's a much more enhanced white box. Yes. Correct. So I'm getting to your term of when you...

1:43:27 Describe a white box, it's not empty, and it starts, it's already preloaded with a lot of things that meet those design standards. Right. Right, but I, yeah. Yeah, so we're using it. The purpose of the white box was so that somebody did not have to design a complete set of plans to know if they were going to be able to get it. So it would address our new definition of white box would address your concerns to people.

1:43:56 Yes. I want to be sure I'm in the right category. Okay, we're talking just strictly about the whole section of the code on development standards. Okay, does that include pathway width and parking? Yes. Do you want specific comments on that? Yes, if you have specific comments, that's fine. This is on page 141 or in the actual draft zone? Right, okay. Okay. Arcades.

1:44:20 Talks about five feet of clearance, and there's a planter that doesn't include a planter, a bench. Can you tell me what page you're on, Elizabeth? 141. Okay. And there's another place where we talked about five feet for a pathway. Can people pass on a five-foot pathway easily? And should we specify that this pathway be snow-free? Can we talk about how it's designed?

1:44:48 I think that's specifically referring to, I guess maybe the definition of arcade could be enhanced. I think it's specifically referring to covered walkways. And we can discuss whether that standard needs to be greater. If you flip the page to 142,

1:45:17 That gives a more, I think a little bit more complete picture that the pedestrian realm might not just be the covered walkway, it might be a covered walkway and additional space uncovered outside of that. Page 143, 5A, walkways should be a minimum of 5 feet wide, should be part of service and paved with permeable materials. 5 feet wide is not very wide and should be specified that they need to be kept snow free. Or are they going to use part of that 5 feet to

1:45:47 Yes, we can, we'll discuss that further with public works and compare to, make sure that it's consistent with our public works standards and we can certainly add language regarding snow removal. Wouldn't that already be addressed in other portions of the code that, you know, snow removal would be required to be taken care of for that area? So generally for the public,

1:46:20 Walkways, we have a six foot minimum width and that's really because that's what our equipment is so we can easily remove snow with the equipment we have and don't have to hand shovel. From the building code standpoint, five feet is the minimum width for accessibility requirements and then they can go down to a point for different reasons. Look at the problem, Peter, with the sidewalk out here. Correct. It's better to have a wider sidewalk.

1:46:49 It's a better, I'm sorry, it better have a wide? It's better to have a wider sidewalk. So the sidewalks we have on Main Street are generally 8 to 10 feet wide. The sidewalk on Old Mammoth is 6 feet wide, which is a little narrow. When you've got groups of people passing, they'd have to basically go single file while you're passing. So Jessica, would you make a note to ask Martha? Because I assume that's where the 5 feet originally came from, right? Likely.

1:47:18 Right. So probably she just took the standard code. So would you ask her if there was any something that we're not taking into account if we switched it to six feet? Okay. Certainly. Yes. Okay. Page 138. Number two. This makes me very nervous. Exceptions for parking garages. A parking garage that does not incorporate ground floor, non-residential or residential use, or is not otherwise screened, must provide a landscaped area.

1:47:48 Well, it's a landscaped area, you know, some perennials or a strip of grass, and we still have to look at the parking garage. I was quite interested, so I was in Santa Monica this weekend, and I saw what they had done to Santa Monica Place, that shopping center down there, they've completely redone it, and they took their ordinary, ugly parking garage, and they put slats of steel, irregular widths, on the facade.

1:48:13 And there's space between, I mean, you can look through, you can see cars, but they, and then they have a big piece of art on one facade, too. And it was so simple, and it made the thing look, it just looked great for really a very small investment. So I think we should have other options besides just landscaping, which can be just the minimum. I would like to, you know, figure out how we could express a screening option. Well, that's two different things.

1:48:40 Well, yeah, exactly. Well, that's not restricting it, that it must be screened. And that is, landscaping is, landscaping, are you talking about you want things screened now instead of just landscaping? What we don't want, I don't think, is to have the pedestrian walk past a parking garage. That's not any street interest. No, I didn't know that's the way there to be. If you're looking screened, that's a completely different thing, and the cost is quite a bit different out there.

1:49:09 Because before it's been landscaped, we want to say, you're talking about screening it out, so they can't see it. Is that what you, the consensus and desire? I have to draw a picture of what I saw this weekend, which so impressed me. It was really a small investment in making partial screenings that you just saw, you know, a much more attractive facade. I'm sure it always would be that, but that's getting into quite a change in the code that's requiring the parking.

1:49:37 So we haven't really discussed the primary and secondary act of frontages, but one of the things that falls under that is that parking structures that

1:50:04 May be on a primary or secondary active frontage, so visible locations, that they be wrapped with commercial use or residential use. Yeah, so that standard holds true for the streets that are designated primary and secondary. So, for example, Sierra Manor is not a designated active frontage.

1:50:32 Someone, let's use the Tavern Road parking ride site, for example. The west side of it is on a designated active frontage. The east side of it is on Sarah Manor. So it's, on the west side, on the old Mammoth Road side, it would have to be wrapped with.

1:50:50 So you wouldn't see, kind of like in the village, you wouldn't see the parking structure. On the east side, that's less pedestrian active, you would have this standard apply, which would be that there would be some landscaping provided between the sidewalk and the parking garage itself. And we could try and emphasize that screening, appropriate screening.

1:51:19 And landscaping would be required in that instance. Is that kind of... Well, the landscaping is just what gave me a little heartburn because it could just be a strip of grass and you haven't accomplished anything. But then to plant a tree in a narrow strip next to a parking garage is impractical, so where's the trade-off there? But that, you, okay, so... But it's a requirement that you have to be wrapped with the commercial or residential. Only on the primary and secondary climate.

1:51:50 Okay. Right. So is there any other comments about the development standards? So is everybody in agreement on the way the development standards are currently drafted? Yes. Yes. Yes. All right. Which leads us nicely into the next one. Downtown Working Group spent a long time talking about primary and secondary active frontage roads.

1:52:19 We felt that they were really important, but we also felt that we didn't want too many of them because what you're really trying to do is cluster your retail and your pedestrian-friendly areas. So has everybody taken a look at the exhibit for primary and secondary? And is there any questions about that? The exhibit is on page 127. It might be a little bit hard to read, but we did have working group consensus on those.

1:52:58 And lots of back and forth. You good? Commissioner Fernandez. Okay. Then the next one we basically already talked about, so the whole concept of the white box was that somebody then could take the code, they could understand the permitted uses, they could get approval, and then they could ultimately come for design review if it made economic sense.

1:53:29 So I just want to make, I think everybody talked about white box in detail so everybody's good about white box concept. All right. Then I just want to, we had a little bit of discussion actually about what was included in floor area ratio and there's a definition in your packet. So is everybody good with the definition of floor area ratio? What page would that be on? Good question.

1:54:03 This was my bonus question I threw in there, Jessica. Yeah, I didn't notice it being an issue before, but I'd like to double check it. But there were some emails among the downtown working group, so I just want to make sure that... Does everybody understand the concept of floor area ratio? Yes. Okay. I know I had it in here somewhere. Because it's where the hotel standards are, Mickey. Right. Do you want to just say it out loud?

1:54:39 Oh, I don't know if I could do that. It's in the meeting notes in meeting two. You're working with that discussion. Is that what you're doing? Oh, I found it. I found it. Sorry. It's on page 146. There's a, you know, the definite, in the overall zoning code, the definitions are all in one chapter now. They're not in each individual chapter. So I've pulled a few definitions from the definitions chapter that are really relevant to this, one being Floria ratio.

1:55:08 Another being height measurement and what the exceptions are to the height measurement. That was another major topic for the working group. So at the top of page 146 is the definition of floor area ratio and floor area. And one of the topics that the working group discussed was whether or not parking, whether it be above grade or surface or under.

1:55:38 Under structure, whether that should be counted as floor area, and the consensus was that it should not. Otherwise it would act as sort of a disincentive. Keeping in mind that the other development standards such as height, setbacks, stepbacks, all that stuff still defines your box and how big it can be in addition to floor area.

1:56:16 Good with the definition of four area ratio? Yes. Yes? All right. Does anybody in the public have any comments on those sections of the commercial, draft commercial zone? Yes. Tom Heller speaking for the fire department. In the design guidelines, the fire district's completely agreeable in not a very enthusiastic way, but...

1:56:51 And agreeable to this whole concept of putting parking behind buildings? We understand the concept. The reality, though, is that for our vehicles to get in and deal with life-saving issues, the front side of the building takes up a very small footprint as far as how much asphalt and how much area one needs to have in order to be able to park vehicles off of the main road but still be able to service those establishments.

1:57:21 When you, and you know, down the road, if we have alternate roads that go in behind buildings and parking lots are served off of those roads, this concept will work fabulously. But for the initial few who try to begin to implement this, and for those where it's not being done block by block, they are going to use up a lot of their private space, putting in roadways that meet

1:57:47 The town's requirements and our requirements, they're going to use up a lot of square footage building parking lots large enough to be able to accommodate our turning radiuses and I just don't want to see us become the downfall for the first several people who walk through the door and find out that this panacea of being able to move their businesses forward really comes with a major drawback.

1:58:15 In that they lose developable space. Now if they can compensate for that with height, that's wonderful. But that's not our decision. Our issue is that we're going to require a certain amount of space through our codes as well as the town standards for roadways and parking lots. And I just don't, I want to make sure that that's provided up front.

1:58:42 So that we don't get into some kind of a disagreement down the road with the first person who walks through the door and says, this is what the town wants, and we're going to turn around and tell them that's fine, but here's what you're going to lose as a result of accommodating that desire. You know, I'm sure you're aware that next Wednesday on the 16th, that Winner and Company is going to be here. And, you know, I mean, I think they have great vision, but they also have a lot of practical experience.

1:59:10 So hopefully there would be an opportunity when they're here to have that discussion in some format. Because you bring a very valid point. I mean, we can sit here and have these terrific ideas, but they have to work. So I really appreciate you sharing that with us. And hopefully you can come next week. Yes? Tom, if there's parking behind the building and you have access in front of the building with the fire truck, what kind of configuration does the fire truck require?

1:59:38 To be able to access the back of the building and turn around. The parking in a block in the middle and then an aisle all the way around. It really varies with every different situation. There's certain turning radiuses. If it's a dead end, there's certain requirements for either hammerheads or radius turns. It would be impossible to give you a standard.

2:00:05 Because every situation tends to be a little bit different. Right. And the other part of that is we can't really do a whole lot over top of parked vehicles. So you begin to really lose what your capabilities are as you end up with building and then parking immediately adjacent to the building, which just pushes us further away from that structure. So just to follow up on what Tom says, we definitely agree with that.

2:00:36 Just like our current process, any development project that comes forward, we look at either through the building permit, if it does happen in a need-to-use permit, all of that detail is looked at and evaluated through that permit process. So every site is different and has its unique issues. Different lot sizes create different challenges, and access that might be good in one location might not be.

2:01:01 So good at another. And ultimately all that, included with the town's regulations, definitely shapes what that development can be. We call that our red box. The bread box? Very good, Elizabeth. That seems to me to be something that has probably been addressed by a lot of our peer resorts. I mean, if you look at the configurations of most of those downtowns, they're long stretches of retail frontage with pedestrian.

2:01:31 In between and street parking. So it seems to me that that would be something that's pretty easy for us to look to some of our peer resorts to see how they've handled that. I mean, Tom is right. We are in a challenging position because we're trying to transform our main street to be a more traditional main street. Using Bishop as an example, you know, they have parking in the back, but...

2:01:58 That community was laid out that way. There are backage roads. There is access to where Fire District can get to fronts and backs of buildings. Here we're trying to move towards that overall goal. And so in a way it is a little bit more of a challenge for us because we will to some extent be doing this piecemeal over time. But we certainly wouldn't compromise public safety and fire access. So each development that moves forward will comply with all those.

2:02:27 Those regulations. Okay. Were there any other comments about the first six sections? Okay. So now we'll start the topic at hand that we've all been waiting for. And this is on height and density in our commercial zoning. And I think it's really important that as we start this discussion, I think today what's going to happen is we're going to have really two discussions on the topic.

2:02:59 One discussion is what is appropriate height and density that makes good planning sense. And then we have to dovetail that discussion with how do we make this practically happen with some of the constraints that we have between our grant and our staffing and those kinds of things. And so let's just start.

2:03:27 With height, because I think the height that's the easier part of it. And Jessica, do you want to make some comments about height? Or would you like me to make some comments about the height? I can go. So two aspects of height that were discussed extensively by the working group was the maximum overall building height as well as the building face height or the street wall height. So the height of the structure at the street wall.

2:03:54 Starting with the maximum building height, I think that there was consensus from the group that we should have a maximum building height, that we do need to have that in place, and overall, generally, I think there was consensus on the proposed heights that we have in the current draft, which is 55 feet maximum height in the downtown, 45 feet in the mixed lodging residential, and the Old Mammoth Road.

2:04:22 There were a couple members of the working group that felt that perhaps the mixed lodging residential, which is farther up near the village, that lots that may have a significant slope, we could extend the height to 55. But generally speaking, the group felt that the proposed heights were adequate or appropriate. In terms of the building face height, there was, I believe,

2:04:51 unanimous consensus by the group that a 25-foot maximum street wall for all of the commercial zones, so all of Main Street, all of Old Mammoth Road in the commercial zones was appropriate. Does that sound right, Mickey? And then we do have some other standards in there regarding minimum ground floor heights if your use is non-residential, eight feet for residential uses.

2:05:23 Any questions about height? Yes. Jessica, I read all these minutes, and they were very, very helpful, and I can't find it now, but there was a reference in there, I think a couple people talked about or were interested in having the street wall height be 35 feet on the north side because of the southern exposure. I can't find the reference. It's on, well, it's page three, I don't have a number in here, but it's page three of the notes.

2:05:54 of meeting six of June 5th. So originally a previous draft of the commercial zoning had the north side of Main Street with a 35 foot building face and everything else would have a 25 foot building face and the initial logic for that was

2:06:24 If you wanted to allow additional building face height, a reasonable place to do it would be the north side of Main Street because it gets more sun exposure and two, the views in that direction are not as important, if you will, as the ones going to the south. And we had originally drafted it that way to provide some additional flexibility in building face height for that north side.

2:06:54 Ultimately, I think the working group felt like it was just a little too cumbersome and that having a 25 foot across the board would just be more simple for people to understand and to implement. Cumbersome? Cumbersome from, yeah, cumbersome, I think, from reading the code perspective, not cumbersome in

2:07:23 practical development building standards. Yeah, I agree with you because actually if you look at it, the mountain goes like that and the streets cut through it. The street's flat, but that's the reason there is because 25 feet on the north side looks very different than 25 feet on the other side. So

2:07:54 But remember we're talking about more streets than Main Street and that's where the cumbersome... But that's what, no, this is except the north side of Main Street is 35. And am I hearing that you want to take it all to 25? No, I was wondering why we... No, I mean that that's, isn't that what you're questioning? Right. Leaving this in here. That's what I'm saying. Right. Why does it go 25 on... Because they're not going to look like 25 foot walls because of that perspective. Yeah.

2:08:24 That's certainly something the Commission can consider. We're not married to that. I don't think I would recommend increasing the building face height on Old Mammoth Road or on the south side of Main Street. But, you know, I don't really know if there was a really strong feeling about that, Mickey, other than just from a readability standpoint, I think was more the concern. I don't know.

2:08:54 Tom Hodges or Tom Cage want to speak up, but we could change it back to 35 on the north side. It's... I'd like to do it. Commissioner Harvey. Can you put a light? If I recall correctly, and I may be mistaken, but I thought the conversation was going in the direction of if we did 35 on the north side, then that would possibly limit the number of stories.

2:09:28 That could be built. No. No. The building height and the building face height don't impact the number of stories. It's just defining the building face height just sort of defines the public realm. What you're seeing as you're driving down the street or walking on the sidewalk. Yeah, I don't recall. Tom, do you? The notes are here.

2:10:00 Do you want to read them? Why does the north side of the street have a higher street wall than the south? The south has more solar access and view constraints, but the solar access and view constraints are more by the overall height of the building. We should look at this more closely. So it doesn't sound like there's a how decided other than 25 feet. Is that the outcome for both?

2:10:29 So, at the meetings, we brought this up, we discussed it, and I think I brought up the point that, look, you're going to have a developer come to you and they're going to say, 25 here, 35 there, I want 35, but I want it on this side. And I brought up the point is, how can you fairly say to a landowner on one side of the street or the other, which I am on both, you get 25, you get 35.

2:10:59 You know, so I couldn't come up with a rationale that would justify that. And I started to think about a 35 foot on both sides if they were to go. That gets pretty imposing. That was a no. So that was, you know, that was a no. You could certainly make just by the way the sun is, which it's to the south, so a lower roof line on the south side. But again, the realities of that, you can have a 55 foot high limit on both sides.

2:11:27 So you're going to potentially have, with your step backs, the same overall height. So I just thought, it's kind of like putting in a law that you can't enforce. You know, why are we doing that to staff and to confuse the issue further? And I think the group agreed with that consensus, and that's why it was agreed to leave it 25 feet both sides. That's my recollection of it, and that was some of the discussion.

2:11:55 And why couldn't it be enforced? I'm not clear. If it were 35 on the north and 25 on the... How many applications of variance would you have? In other words, you're going to have people, rightly so, on the south side of the street coming in and saying, we want 35. Why in the world can't we have 35? They have 35. They're 90 feet away. Not even 90 feet away. They're 50 feet away. It would create a situation that...

2:12:25 I personally, I don't know that the rest of everybody bought into this. I didn't think it was fair to staff or the commission or future staffs, future commissions and to the developer to rationally justify this. Any comments about that? No, I have to think about that while you guys are talking. Did you have any comments? I would agree with the final determination of 25 on both sides of the street.

2:13:00 I think it's the best way to go. I think 35 feet could be a little ominous from the streetscape. And, you know, we could get into a thing where everybody wants to build on one side of the street based on different regulations per side of the street. And I just think it makes sense to keep it uniform. Commissioner, do you have any other comments or you're thinking? No, I'd like to see somebody come forward with anything beat it out at that point. You know, because there's one point if you want to build, you're going to have to.

2:13:35 into the mountain there. And I think when we're thinking of that spot is where it is, but in reality, yeah, we don't want it to be a ton. So maybe it'll be a 25-foot ton instead of a big ton. Look at that. Winter and Company, just so you know, even though they are only indirectly involved with the code part of both the Main Street Project and this, you know, we're working very closely with them, and they'd actually encourage the 25 feet.

2:14:04 Just from a public realm standpoint. I think several years ago we were looking at 35 for both sides and they felt that that just didn't, wouldn't result in the right character. Alright, so let's start on the easy parts of height. So on Old Mammoth Road, is everybody agreeable to 45 feet, which is by the way what we as a Planning Commission previously had approved or recommended? Yes.

2:14:35 So we're all good with that on Old Mammoth Road, that height. Yep. On the mixed lodging residential on height, is everybody good with 45 feet? No. No. Okay. No. I would agree that there should be some allowances for 55 feet on the sloped areas. I think that makes sense to me. And it's also adjacent to the village where the higher height is permitted. Well, the...

2:15:08 Yeah, the topography is really interesting because, you know, you go up. Now, Mammoth View is, that's approved, right? Yes. Okay. So then the first village property on that side of the street would be what's known today as the Dempsey property. That's in the North Village specific plan. Right.

2:15:37 But that's the, okay. Right. Because Elizabeth made the comment that it butts up against the North Village Pacific Plan. Correct. Okay. And then on the opposite side of the street, the first one would be Ward Jones' property. Correct. And Ward Jones' property was approved at what? Do you have to know? I believe 45. I don't think that there was a zoning code amendment or a variance process for that. So basically this, as far as the North Village Pacific Plan goes, it would be

2:16:06 adjacent to properties that are four to five stories. What was Mammoth View approved at, right, Wes? I think 45 as well for the hotel portion. Mammoth View was within the zoning code. It didn't ask for any variances or amendments. So we're talking about the stretch of road from Manzanita up to the adjacent to the North Village specific plan. Right.

2:16:36 So, I mean, the problem is you just have huge topography changes between north and south. This is my thought. You had huge changes between north and south on the road because you do have, like, pardon the expression where the birdhouses are now, which is way below grade, or probably a better explanation would be where the old Mexican restaurant is, which is way below roadside, and then you have

2:17:03 Other properties in the opposite side of the street, like let's say if somebody was going to come in and redevelop where the Texaco is, which is at street level or above street level. Right. I believe, right, Tom Hodges, that you had an opinion on this subject? Tom Hodges representing the ski area. Yeah, our opinion was that, you know, because of the slopes, you may get in situations where you're fighting a design.

2:17:38 To fit in the height limit, but in the transition of the slope, part of the building might go above the 45 feet, and then you would, you know, thereby exclude that design for like a brand hotel. So that was our concern, that you just have some flexibility to allow it up to 55. My personal preference would be for that particular area,

2:18:04 Just because of the nature of the topography would be to say 45 and then they could come in and ask for a variance. Which I know isn't a very good, but I mean that. Recognize that the, as you go up the street, like you say, it gets more extreme, the pitch. And, you know, my suggestion was maybe you put some kind of an average lot grade stipulation on that. So like if your lot has over a 10% grade differential on it, then you would allow the higher.

2:18:34 Height limit. So it gives you some more flexibility because you're essentially going to have an additional story difference between your street front and the back side of your lot, for instance, which I think is the case, like, for instance, on Holiday House, for example. But it's not so much 10% slope as being below Main Street, right? Because sometimes those lots are pretty obvious. Even on the uphill side, there's a vacant lot there that's next to Angels, right?

2:19:01 Between... Right, correct. Motel Six and Angels, is that right? The two-acre parcel. Real... Yeah, so a two-acre parcel. So that's a great parcel that would fit a lot of the national brands, right? That's the size lot that they kind of build to. And it's a challenge to get up onto that lot, but if you... You know, it might, in that particular lot, to get off the street frontage into the lot, you may have an instance, depending on how you interpret the building height requirements.

2:19:31 That might push you higher just because of that topography. I mean, it gets, it's very steep on the front part of that lot and then it flattens out towards the back of it, but that's a very challenging lot. So if, but if you said 45 feet, you may, you may end up having to eat up 20, 25 feet in the frontage just to get up to where you can actually build your podium more or less for the, for the building. And all of a sudden you can only get two floors of, of,

2:20:00 Development in there and you can't make it work. So, again, I think, I know that the staff has put in a more detailed description of how we measure height on these sloping lots, but I think we would be wise to test that on a couple of examples where, because a lot of these brand hotels are four stories and there's not too many of these lots on this street, on that particular zone where we're kind of looking, where we'd want that type of product.

2:20:28 You think of Los Sierros as an acre, that lot across the street, Holiday House, you know, if it gets redesigned potentially. You know, those are lots that we could, you know, make work, fit in these brand hotels that we need. So we don't want to arbitrarily create a height restriction that creates a problem for a variance because then it just opens the door to delays and everything else. So my recommendation is maybe we just do a couple site-specific examples and study them.

2:20:58 If we could do a quick, you know, sort of site study to see. I know Bruce Woodward, he and I talked about it in that particular lot between Next to Angels. He had done some work on that. Between Hotel 6 and Angels. Yeah. Yeah. So, you know, maybe we could talk to Bruce, maybe we could work out some, like I say, just to kind of vet it out a little bit so we don't cut off our nose and spot our face here. And, you know, I think in terms of the view sheds and so forth, because you have these slopes going up.

2:21:26 You know, that higher height is going to get lost in the trees anyway behind the site as well as below. You know, it's dropping away from the road anyway so you can see it further. So I don't see that it's providing or create a problem from the perspective of, you know, the view corridors. I'm not necessarily adamant about it one way or the other, but those are some of my exact points for feeling that way, that I don't think it impacts the view shed in those areas to the same degree. And I think because if you look at Old Mammoth,

2:21:54 Relatively similar on the topography on both sides of the street. Same with Main Street. As you start to get into that area, there is such a major difference in the topography. I think that's why we need to consider this. And the entire goal of this exercise is to get us out of the pattern that we're in right now where every property that comes forth wants a variance. So I think that, you know, because of the difference in topography, that's why I think it makes sense to me. But I'm not...

2:22:23 Adamant about it. Something I'm concerned about, and probably Colin's seen this more recently than I have, is on our peer resort tour, I remember clearly in Aspen and in Jackson.

2:22:43 Jackson had a lodge which went right up to the height and then they had these little dinky dormers on the top, you know, that was the, quote, articulation and it just looked horrible. Yeah, perspective on it, yeah. And this, you remember that, Rhonda, and the St. Regis Hotel in Aspen, same way, you know, boom, right up to almost the height limit and I guess they called those appurtenances. By the way, why isn't there any reference to appurtenances? You know, elevator shafts and... There is.

2:23:07 Okay, maybe I missed it then. But that's what I wouldn't want to see happen. And with that 45 feet limit, you know, adjacent to the North Village specific plan where we'll see hotels built, I hope, you know, that could be a problem and we'd end up getting some really bad design. If you turn to page 149, I've included the various...

2:23:31 Definitions for height. I apologize, I had some built-in references that didn't come through, so it says error reference source not found in some locations, but page 149, exceptions to height limits. A, so we've built in flexibility for encouraging design elements that we want, so chimneys, elevators, steeples, towers, antennas, none of those are included in the height maximum. Okay.

2:24:01 But those elements cannot exceed 20% of the roof area and the height shall not exceed 14 feet above the maximum permitted height. We also had some exceptions for roofs that were a certain pitch would get an extra 5 feet to try and encourage some additional roof articulation. I don't know what section that's in.

2:24:32 We have two different height measurements depending on if your lot is flat or if it's sloped greater than 10%. And, oh, okay, on page 147, under AD, groups of primary buildings with a pitch greater than 612 shall be allowed an additional 5 feet above the maximum building height in the zone. Sorry, I missed that. So that helps.

2:25:02 encourage articulation. And then on the next page, 148, it describes the alternative height calculation for lots having an average slope of 10% or greater. And that takes an average of the outermost corners of the building and looks at the height from that perspective rather than just an overall height. So that helps with the topography a little bit.

2:25:31 But if the commission wants to consider further changes to the overall maximum height, they can. I had another question on page 147, Jessica. This is what our consultant from Diet and Bhatia wrote. Is that correct? This whole section? What section are you referring to? 147, building height calculation on lots having an average slope of less than 10%. Our current code actually has some of this. I think we have tried to make it more clear and understandable.

2:26:02 What concerns me is this warped plane. What is a warped plane? How is it a plane if it's warped? That word warped is really confusing. Yeah, we could definitely clarify that. I think the point is that at all points perpendicular to the surface of the lot. So unless your lot is perfectly flat, your plane is going to follow the topography of the site. It articulates right there. Oh.

2:26:33 So it's not a... I guess calling it a plane is what confuses me. All right, so let's go back to the topic. But it was a height question. It was a height question. Yeah, it was good. Commissioner Harvey. I'm on to ask. I have no problem with the additional height with property at 10% on those challenging areas. I mean, if we take care of it now, it's going to save us from dealing with variances in the...

2:27:09 In the future. So just, sorry. I can't think of the exact number of properties that we'd be dealing with, but it's quite minimal, as I recall. Well, this is my conceptual problem, and I also am not really strong one way or the other. So let's take the sample property that we were talking about adjacent to Motel 6. So assuming that that is 20 feet

2:27:41 Let's assume that the average grade of that is like 20 feet above Main Street because there is some sort of variance. It is above Main Street. And then you allow 55 feet. Does that give an appearance of 75 feet? And then you go, to example, what we approved at the Holiday House, which is maybe now 10 to 15 feet below Main Street that's only 55 feet. So, I mean, what we don't want to have happen in our community

2:28:11 The concept of Main Street, remember we're trying to create this entrance, this bookend, et cetera, that starts at Main Street and Old Mammoth Road, and now you don't want to have, as much as I want to make it really accessible for some sort of limited service hotel to come in, I just want to make sure that in the middle of Main Street between Old Mammoth Road and Minaret Road isn't this

2:28:39 Trophy building, in height at least. Am I expressing that well? Help me out here. So you're assuming that people would build on top of the existing grade, there wouldn't be excavation? Is that what you're saying? Well, if I remember the parcel right, I mean, I'm not... Well, whether it's... Well, and, and, I mean, I haven't walked that safe, but keep in mind that it's the average slope of the property, the lot.

2:29:10 And the parcel line for that is outside of the right-of-way. So it's possible that that lot in particular, the majority of the slope is at the front end, which might not even be part of their lot. So it may not even meet the qualifications. Do you know what I'm saying? Okay. Now that we've all expressed our opinions, and just so you know, when we go to council next week, we don't have to be in consensus.

2:29:40 on these topics, but I'd like to be. So, why doesn't everybody tell me what they think? 55, 45? 55. 55. 55. 55. Okay. 55 it is. Okay. Just the sloping lots? Yeah, you need to be... Sloping, for me. I was referring to the sloping lots. Yeah.

2:30:15 You're not talking about it. Above 10% grade mixed lodging residential zone, right? Right. Above a 10% zone. That's what we're talking about. Correct. That's what I was talking about. Thank you. Okay. Okay. Okay. These are the easy questions, remember. Now the fun begins. Okay. So, and then downtown, this says 55 and that was also the recommendation of Planning Commission. So is everybody good on 55? Yes. Yep. Okay.

2:30:44 So, now let's talk about floor area ratio for our three districts. Okay. Give us the exact page around. Because my pages didn't get numbered. Oh, I'm sorry. I have my cliff notes here. 107. 107, okay. So, this is, like I said, where the fun begins. There's, in the recommendation, or I'm sorry, in the options, the differences in the options are really focused on this.

2:31:17 So the current code proposes the use of an FAR, of an overall FAR of two and a half for all types of uses, residential and non-residential. However, given what staff and our town attorney believe are legal and environmental requirements, constraints, I guess I should say,

2:31:47 of the general plan and the general plan EIR. We do not feel that at this point in time without further analysis, CEQA review, et cetera, that it's acceptable, allowable to completely abandon the density limits that are in place right now. So what's proposed is kind of a combination, which is

2:32:15 Annoying, but, and not ideal, but we feel we're a bit hamstrung on, is the combination of FAR and current density limits. That's sort of a general summary. There's been lots of discussion amongst the working group about FAR and density. I think the consensus of the group is that the ultimate goal, and staff agrees, is to move to only using an FAR standard to

2:32:45 Regulate the development intensity. But right now, because we have in the commercial zones the lodging 40 units up to 80 units with community benefits, which throws another wrinkle into the whole thing, we have recommended that we maintain that at this time until we are directed to do otherwise. I don't know if you want me to elaborate on any of those points.

2:33:17 If you could elaborate on something for me. Sure. I think originally when we were shifting from density to fluoride area ratio, I'm curious as to exactly how the FAR of 2.5 was arrived at. Was that kind of a translation from our current density requirements? Or can you just go into a little bit of background on where that number was, where that came from?

2:33:44 Yes, I will do my best. So, you know, in a perfect world, density to FAR would be like this straight equation, and it would be super simple to say 40 rooms per acre is X FAR, but it's not that simple. So coming up with that number was sort of an iterative process, but it was based on some existing development looking at

2:34:12 Places like the Westin and other developments in town looking at what their FAR equivalent was and what their density was. Some of that's described in the background paper that Dye and Bhatia did. And then the other part of it was looking at other places, what they use.

2:34:35 And then looking at the development standards as we had drafted them and doing some site-specific models for, I think we did six different sites in town using the development standards that we had drafted to come up with this hypothetical building and what the FAR would be for that building.

2:34:56 And looking at the feasibility of it. So wouldn't it be correct to say that the 2.5 was arrived at by doing your best guess of translating the density into an FAR? There were other methods that were used. There were multiple methods that were used. Did that factor into it at all? Yes. Trying to translate 40 units per acre into an FAR? Yes, that did. In fact, Diet and Batia's original proposal for the FAR was that we

2:35:26 Have residential, like condo, more traditional non-transient, residential use would not be included in FAR, and that lodging and commercial would, but that we would have a maximum FAR for the lodging of 1.5. So the overall building could be 2.5 FAR, but the lodging component of it would be limited to 1.5. They came up with that number because

2:35:54 Their best estimation of how that would equate to density was they said that it's within the range of your current density. Because, you know, going back to our constraints, without going so far as doing CEQA review and general plan amendment, we were trying to keep everything within the current general plan and general plan EIR. So they had come up with that proposal.

2:36:23 But subsequently we have been informed by our town attorney that if you move to an FAR that could result in density exceeding the current density limit of the general plan on any property, not just overall the district, then that would be a potential violation of the general plan EIR.

2:36:46 That's why we reintroduced, not ideally, but we reintroduced the density limitations at this time. And I certainly understand that it's not one-to-one, but it seems like Diet and Bhatia's best estimate of translating 40 units per acre to FAR was closer to 1.5, not 2.5, is that correct? For lodging, yes. For lodging, okay. But the overall development, if it was a mixed-use project that had commercial component plus lodging in it,

2:37:14 The overall, the extra, there could be an extra 1.0 FAR dedicated to non-lodging uses. So what we're proposing now is to, because we feel that we have to maintain the density limitation, we've decided that we're putting FAR in there as well, even though it's not necessary, but we want to move in that direction and show that we're moving in that direction. Thanks.

2:37:43 Okay, can I, I'd like to make a, some footnote comments to that. First of all, you know, we've had Ditenbachia who's worked on the code and then we've had planners in Winter & Company and Hart Howerton. So, so we've asked all these people about recommendations for FAR. So that's partially where the 2.5 came from. The other thing is we looked at the existing

2:38:12 Village, because remember what we're trying to do is create that entrance presence into town to give our existing village basically an anchor or presence. So it's like, well, what do we need to have on Main Street, Old Mammoth Road, to really complement what's already there at the village? So it's a combination of approaches where that 2.5 recommendation came from. I'd like to just say that

2:38:43 The issue, okay, one of the things that we have to decide today, just so that you know, is what is our recommended FAR? Does FAR include residential, lodging, commercial? Are we going to eliminate CBIS from the general plan? These are, I'm just going to sample the questions we're going to talk about. And are we going to recommend a general plan amendment?

2:39:10 And with that, an evaluation of CEQA work. Now, so this goes back to the two-prong approach we have. So one, we're going to talk about good planning and what our recommendation is. Then the issue that staff has is that the way the current draft of the commercial zone in code is written, and Sandra can elaborate on this, is that

2:39:39 It's not like we took just the existing commercial zone chapter and have updated it. We took a combination of several different chapters and combined it into our commercial zone update. So you can't just say, because I have tried this, it doesn't work, you can't just say, okay, we're going to adopt all of the zoning code except for perhaps the commercial zone because the cross-references don't work.

2:40:09 So this is why staff then really said, okay, well we want to recommend that you leave the density with a recommendation for FAR and then the existing density and so then when the other work is done, the general plan amendment work, the CEQA evaluation work, then those density

2:40:37 comments can be struck out and you would be left with a FAR calculation. So I just wanted to make sure that as a background, everybody knows where we're going with this discussion. And then I don't know, Sandra, if you want to add any more about how the zoning code chapters are intertwined. No, I think that was a good summary, so we agree. And yes, did you have any other comments about that?

2:41:07 Why are you not? No, I'm just setting the stage. Do you want to put anything else on the stage? You have to come up. Well, why don't you come up to that? Tom Hodges, Mammoth Bounce here. You know, I think the other thing to point out about the far number is, you know, in conjunction with the white box concept, you've created the envelope with the white box with the height and the set max. So with the far number,

2:41:40 We just want to make sure we're giving people the ability to use that. I think in many cases they won't be able to obtain the FAR because the white box is going to restrict them. So, you know, you need to think about that. But by the same token, we don't want to have, we want them to have the number high enough so that, like I said, they can utilize it. If we restrict it and then they couldn't use the white box, we sort of failed at the task of the whole concept of the white box and the planning standards.

2:42:06 When you say not utilize the far, do you mean not reach that level or exceed that level? So it's the ratio of the building square footage to the lot square footage, right? And by the time you start to put in all the other requirements that you're going to have to provide for, parking in particular, and then you have your height in combination with that.

2:42:33 Depending on if you're proposing to build some above ground parking, structured parking for instance, then all of a sudden that's going to be taken away from usable floors in the height envelope that would go towards commercial residential uses or lodging uses that would be assessed to your FAR number. So that's why I'm saying that depending on how this redevelopment plays out and the timing and so forth, and parking is a big part of this.

2:43:00 Probably need to have that whole other subject that needs to be taken up after this is all approved, the discussion with parking districts. But, you know, I think that our feeling was that the 2.4 provided that flexibility so that, you know, people would be able to, you know, make the mix of product type and use the heights that are allowed in the other standards, you know, so we can get a vital redevelopment going. Yeah, the other point I was going to make,

2:43:29 I evaluated some brand hotels, and I looked at, I actually was able to pick off the internet, some really good programs and very specific details of what it, like a Courtyard Marriott, for instance. And I took those numbers and ran it against some of the parcels and said, okay, how could this work on, in the main street area or the lodging district? And, you know, those numbers were, in some cases, again, because

2:43:56 Depending on how we're going to handle parking, if they're going to be forced to put all the parking underneath their structure, for example, you know, on those sites, because they're a little bit smaller than what their sort of brand standard is, if they're going to try and squeeze into a one-acre lot, for instance, it's going to push the far number up higher. So in those cases, you know, those examples were exceeding 2.0 FAR. And I think it would be a, you know, huge error on our part if we came up with this code.

2:44:26 And it doesn't accommodate the national brand standards that are out there that we want to attract to our community that are vital to bringing incremental visitors and creating all the things that we've talked about and filling the white space, you know, the midweeks and the shoulder season and so forth. Did you mean exceed 2.5 or 2.0? I'm sorry? Did you mean exceed, you mentioned that they would exceed 2.0? They would be between 2.0 and 2.5.

2:44:51 But they wouldn't exceed 2.5. Yeah, and the way I looked at it, I couldn't see a scenario where we'd exceed 2.5. But it, you know, I think it's interesting because as you start to look, if you start to evaluate different lots, the metrics of it change drastically. I mean, the smaller the lot is, I think the higher the far is going to go. So, you know, as you get into some of the smaller parcels like, I don't know, the Turner propane gas or A-frame liquor, like that little quarter acre, whatever it is,

2:45:19 You know, and if somebody's going to put a four-story, you know, building in there, you know, with the parking and everything else, I mean, those numbers, I think, are going to be a lot closer to that 2.5 FAR. So, but I think the feeling of the Downtown Working Group was that I was participating in and substitute for Jim Smith after he left, but that we wanted to provide, again, sort of along the lines of the street frontage height, to just try and make it simple. So across the board, we thought the 2.5 number addressed all scenarios.

2:45:47 And, you know, largely when a developer comes to town and is looking at this, they're going to consult with staff and get the feedback of, you know, they're going to try to build a product that they can ultimately sell and make it pencil. But if we provide, if we create it too restrictive, then it's just going to limit the options of a developer to make these things pencil. And another thing you have to consider in this whole district is that

2:46:14 You know, nearly all of these parcels are developed and there's a handful that are vacant and certainly a few of them clearly need to be redeveloped like a lot of yours, but a lot of them have existing uses on it, so you just have so many things to overcome to somebody to actually say, okay, this is going to work out to take these properties out and demolish them and then redevelop them and then all the things that we have to do. So, in any event, our conclusion was that the 2.5 number

2:46:42 Provided the flexibility and you have the protection of the height limits and the setbacks of the white box that everybody has agreed to those numbers. So I think in terms of the visual impact and density, intensity, you know, we're kind of covered on that end from the height restrictions. And then, you know, I think it's certainly going to be, you know, it'll be necessary to go through this general kind of amendment just to adopt the FAR language, right?

2:47:11 And then it certainly is going to probably increase densities in certain cases. So, you know, that's something that can be studied in the sequel analysis and determine what the impacts might be. So, that's our feeling is that, you know, the two-step process, so we kind of cover the basis for now. And keep in mind, you know, the 12 units per acre, that's the birdhouses development up on Main Street, right? That's what you get for 12 units per acre. I don't think that's going to provide us the intensity that we need. We need a critical mass in this.

2:47:40 Particularly in the downtown areas to create the feet first synergy that we need, right? You know, you look at the village and it's, you know, it's just enough, right, to kind of activate retail, but, you know, not even like I was up there this morning and there was nobody there. But point being is you have to have, you have to have the intensity to make the feet first work and the transportation systems work and, you know, the 12 units per acre that's currently overlying these areas.

2:48:09 He's going to get you the birdhouses. So we don't want that. Thank you. Yes, can I add a bit of scenery to the stage you just set? To birdhouses? No, no, no, to the stage you set. And I'm going to need help from Rhonda and probably from Sandra too. But I'm just thinking about these densities because it's so frustrating, you know, the sort of trap we're in because of the grant funding and all the rest of it. But when we're updating the general plan in 2007, that was like the peak of the go-go years.

2:48:41 And projects were coming before us. It was a tsunami of projects. You know, after InterWest came, everybody wanted in. And we're updating the general plan, and many people in the community are thinking, with good reason, what's happening to our town? What's happening to our village? You know, and in fact, there was one group, their slogan was, how dense can we be? Because they were really concerned about density. And so I think when we finally, one of the big delays with the general plan update,

2:49:07 was agreeing on the number of people at one time. Is this what you recall too, Rhonda? Agreeing on people at one time. And we finally came to consensus on that. And then an offshoot of that was density. There just, there was such, panic is not the right word to use, but such apprehension, you know, about density. And I think that's where those artificially low numbers came from or were a result of.

2:49:35 Just wondering, with all this development that was coming in, of course, everything crashed, and, you know, we're in a different place today. We're in a very different place today, and we have to remember the general plan is a living document, but CEQA's expensive, so there's another rock and a hard place where between. Is that what you recall, Sandra? Yes. So, okay, the first question I want to ask commission is, is everybody in agreement that we will make a recommendation

2:50:04 With the understanding that it's going to require a general plan amendment to the land element and then CEQA, then there's going to have to be an evaluation of CEQA. We don't really know if it's what will actually happen. It could be a negative deck. It could be a lot of things. You're talking option two? Well, no, I'm just not even option two. In general, okay.

2:50:30 We have to be in agreement that whatever our decision is going to be, we understand, first of all, that it's going to require some sort of general plan amendment work and some sort of CEQA work. So is everybody agree okay with that general premise? You could round up with that gentleman? Yeah. I feel like I'm in Groundhog Day. Yeah. It's just... But to Elizabeth's point, things evolve and...

2:50:58 There's more tools that come in that help you solve the situation and I look at the somehow finding a common level between the density standards and the overall FAR is one of those tools that's going to help us resolve that. So, you know, maybe it's providing not such a hard line but you don't have to meet both standards. One of them may exceed the density but gives you something else in those.

2:51:27 Because it's just, if it would be done, if it were that easy, but you have to have more tools to do it. So one of the unfortunate things is it's going to cause these two, trigger these two actions. Yeah, so no agreement. Okay. So, and is everybody in commission agreement that when we're finished with our commercial zone update, we want to eliminate the CBiz, all references to community benefit incentive zoning?

2:51:57 See, this was a nightmare. Endless negotiations and haggling and oh my goodness. So we're all in agreement that it's subjective? Mm-hmm. Yes. It's too subjective. Okay. Could never find common ground, the value of anything. It just couldn't agree on one part of it appeared. Okay. Are we all in agreement that FAR should include all residential, lodging, and commercial? Yes.

2:52:28 In these three districts that we're talking, the commercial zoning districts. Yes. And it doesn't include parking. Pardon? And does include parking. It does not include parking. Okay, that was my question. And where do we have that? It's in the FAR definition, the floor area definition. It's in the definition there. Yes. Okay, and that's why it's not in the resolution here. In the code. Or in the code. Correct. The option on the code that we're going to be. It is in your packet. Okay.

2:52:59 Under the definition, yeah. Yes. Okay. Good. Okay. So we're all in agreement on those six. Mm-hmm. All right. Who wants to start with their thoughts on FAR? Does anybody want higher FAR than 2.5? Well, I think my questions have been appropriately answered, but, you know, looking through a lot of this documentation, I'm certainly not a developer, so I'm going to defer to people with...

2:53:26 With better knowledge around this, but, you know, looking through the documents, the few downtown working group meetings that I've been to, I was initially a little bit concerned about whether that number was even high enough. You look at the Weston, that's a 2.8 far. Heavenly Village, which is a really important anchor in South Lake, is 2.8 far. I just did not want to get it, and there's a lot of language in here talking about how brand hotels can't make things pencil.

2:53:54 So I just wanted, and I think my concerns were appropriately addressed, but I want to make sure that, and I think I'm hearing that 2.5 is an acceptable number to get development. So if I'm being told that 2.5 is high enough and that's pencilable, then I'm totally fine with that. But I initially had some concerns around that because of all the language through the meetings and stuff.

2:54:19 Where I'm coming from with most of this stuff is that we need development for the continued prosperity and growth of Mammoth. So to go through this whole exercise and then come up with a FAR that developers can't make pencil is just an academic exercise. It's a waste of time. So I think I'm now comfortable with that based on what Tom had said.

2:54:45 You know, Tom, you were the one that was kind of most outspoken through a lot of this about, you know, making sure that these numbers pencil for brand hotels and stuff, and I want to make sure that that concern is addressed appropriately. What he said. You just did it? Yeah, no, absolutely. From the two of you that were involved in the group, you know, 2.5 is a sufficient number for developers to put a product in. You know, my feeling on that,

2:55:15 Falls around, I think, where Tom was going with the smaller properties. I think it may be a challenge for a smaller property, but at the same time, there's only so much you can build on a small property. Sure. I really don't envision that Main Street is going to be developed small property by small property. Right. I envision it more being assembled over a period of time and the appropriate type of product.

2:55:46 will be built. This FAR calculation may be absolutely not appropriate for a half-acre development, and we have to realize that, but I think we have a sense of what we want for development on Main Street, and that's where we need to put our focus.

2:56:11 I mean, on the flip side of that, you look at the village, it's at two, Mammoth View's at .5, Old Mammoth, you know, there's a number of things on here that fall well below that 2.5 as well. So I think I'm comfortable with 2.5 and keeping it there. As am I. So do we have assurances that 2.5 will get us the brand hotels we want? No. Well, there's no assurances in life. Anybody that can't make it work with 2.5, we're going to hear from them.

2:56:43 Just to add a little bit more background for consideration, the North Old Mammoth Road District Special Study said that they recommended for, and North Old Mammoth Road District Special Study is basically the downtown portion of Old Mammoth Road. So they had recommended a FAR of 2.5. So that's one resource we had.

2:57:08 Winter and Company and I and Bhatia both felt that that was a comfortable number as well. The working group, I think, had general consensus that that was a good number as well. However, there were two to three people that thought that potentially a higher FAR in the downtown might be something to consider. Bill Taylor emailed me this week and said that

2:57:33 He would be okay with a slightly higher FAR in the downtown, but if that extra was only dedicated to commercial use. So there is a little bit of, you know, variation, but I would say, generally speaking, 2.5 seemed to be the number that people felt most comfortable with. It sounds like MMSA and Snow Creek are supportive of that as well. So that's the whole picture for you.

2:58:01 But Winter and Associates and Diat and Bhatia and who else did you just mention were comfortable with the North Old Mammoth Road Special Study? Correct. Was that taking into account the current density in the 2007 general plan? No. No, this is just looking at it with your FAR, your FAR glasses on that if we were to move to a FAR only standard that that would be a good number. If you look on page 108,

2:58:30 At the top, I've summarized in four bullet points what the recommendations of the working group were, which we've sort of already discussed those things. And this to me represents what the ultimate goal is, and staff concurs with that, which is to use an FAR only. And the ideal world is we will eventually have an FAR only.

2:58:56 Not in combination with density limitations, because it's kind of counterproductive. That the FAR should include all types of uses. And that, well, the consensus of the group was that the FAR should be the same in all commercial districts, with the exception of a couple people. And that 2.5 was an appropriate number. So those four bullet points sort of summed up the general consensus on that.

2:59:28 So since I spent a lot of time talking to staff, I agree with those points, but I just, if you want to know what my position is. Do you think it's worthwhile to have the conversation of 2.8? No, just whether it should be different from the downtown district, because that comes up a lot. Well,

2:59:45 I thought we should have the conversation if we thought we were going to negotiate with counsel. You know, it's kind of like a real estate transaction. You go in with one number knowing that they'll come back with another number just for the sake of negotiation. Next Wednesday will be interesting. I think it's also important to look at it from a character perspective. No, okay. So let me just, I think, so this is...

3:00:10 And I have personally thought about it. When we started this whole discussion, one of the things that's really important to me is to develop critical mass in downtown. I mean, because, you know, going back to our village conversation, the village always lacks a certain element of critical mass. If it had...

3:00:36 You know, just a little bit more, another hotel or whatever, all the retail, everybody would do just a little bit better. I mean, because that's the way it was originally designed, was there was going to be the whole, you know, South Hotel, North Hotel components. So I personally at one time thought that downtown should have a higher FAR than Old Mammoth Road and the mixed lodging. Okay. In order to?

3:01:03 To push developers into building there first? Right. So that if somebody was sitting down doing what I would call the paper napkin approach, okay, should I buy this property to develop or should I buy this property to develop? Well, there was all these things that would make the downtown more financially conducive. But I've kind of switched...

3:01:27 From that opinion. Because the other thing that I feel really strongly about our commercial zone is that it has to be simple enough that everybody can understand that you can, any person should be able to drive down Old Mammoth Road, turn left on Main Street, you know, from, go from Suite Z up to the village and be able to explain what you can build on a parcel.

3:01:52 I mean, that's my personal goal, and that's why I've switched back to just 2.5 in all three zones. But I'm open to hearing what everybody else has to say on that. Well, the drop-off on the south side of Main Street is so extreme that it's easy to see a higher far there. But then also, you know, it's not the goal to level this out.

3:02:21 Right. You know? That's true. That's good. The articulation and the high on one side. Yeah, you talked earlier about a trophy hotel on the hill. Anything on the hill is going to look like a trophy hotel because it's on the hill. And anything in the pit is going to look like it's in the pit because it's in the pit. So you don't want to, you're not trying to change the topography. It's like San Francisco at that point. It's just undulating and everything follows the ground here.

3:02:55 why we're still having this discussion after 20 years. I know, it is kind of like, so, but I do think you're coming to closer resolution here. I'm still fresh, I haven't been here for 20 years, so. Well, but, but you know what, but you're right on, we're right on point, and that part has not changed, that we're doing this, and yeah, I can see, you know, what you're saying, I, you know, to what to draw there, but then the point earlier,

3:03:23 If you're doing this and nobody's going to bite, this is not, you know, there has to be a little bait in it in order to get the fish to bite. Unless you really don't want to go fishing. We've been through that part of it too. So that's not the intent here anymore. And also, the other thing is we have put in so many checks and balances of reviews that we're not going to get the

3:03:53 Outrageous project that we can't stop. There's so many things. There's so, you know, and we've had some things that we just, it didn't feel right and we made it really follow the lines and it went away because then it wasn't feasible what they had. So, you know, earlier to the point of having, you know, is 2.5 enough, there will be somebody that comes and says, I need 2.8 and we're going to ask, so show me, show us why.

3:04:22 And that will, they'll have to go through, you know, through that whole process to do that. And we may agree and we may not agree. But there's, so I'm not worried that there's not the flexibility in there. There always is the flexibility. And, but I, but to the say is, well, this is what can be here and that there. It's still, it's always going to be subjective. So I don't know that we'll ever be able to get to that level. But you have to get somewhere and by your,

3:04:51 Your white box is now getting more defined and eliminating a lot of questions. And that's what you want to do. And so I look at this as a starting point as we transition from density to so. And yes, somebody could exceed far what we had in mind, but it won't pencil out for them. And it won't meet the design guidelines for them. And it won't meet the other things that we have put in for just the situation.

3:05:20 So looking at it should be, you know, and the reality is we have parts of town that give you a much more narrow feeling than we do others. And those standards, you don't feel the same going down Main Street as you go down the, go down into the

3:05:39 into the old Mammoth Road area because it's not the same. Does that give you more ability to drive a certain level of development? And I think what you're looking for is we want to drive the development in there and we've given them the guidelines. So I don't, we don't want to get arguing about the details too much that get us right back to that you can't do anything there. So as long as you don't

3:06:08 When I'm looking further down, you know, project sets back three to eight feet, completely academic, you know, to that the five feet, you know, set the situation there. It's even, see, the screen's even going dark on me. It's had enough of it. So I think what you've got are things that everybody can live with. So your recommendation is the overall bar then 2.5?

3:06:34 I think that that's, I think it's a great starting point. Okay. And that is not going to eliminate people that have, that don't, a developer, and actually it's not designed to, it's to say here's the starting point, but we, but everything can't be a one-time negotiation. So, and there will be several one-time, but we have to start somewhere. And I think 2.5 is getting it off the ground. It's going to allow some of the smaller flagship properties to be.

3:07:03 Creative on these lots. And, you know, I can see they could happen because now if you do look back in some of the other places in Peer Resorts that they have these properties tucked away that are meeting the needs, we'll have that as well because it won't be something huge. It'll be something that fits the topography, that fits their business model.

3:07:28 It'll be something that enhances the community because we do have examples of that and continue along with that. So you would not be supportive of increasing the FAR for downtown? I think there's going to be areas that we're going to have somebody who's going to come forward and say, I want to increase it here because this particular lot is going to do that. So what you're trying to do is look for the, you can't build it on the exception.

3:08:00 Unless your whole area is the exception, and that's your question. Is it so exceptional that it can't follow that level? If that's what the determination is, if everything is exceptional in that area because all of the easy stuff has been built and the only things left is exceptional, then that would work for me as well. Because I can see either argument and I'm not, but I don't think that we're going to achieve the goal of answering all questions.

3:08:30 So one thing is, you know, we also have these economic profiles built, and what was kind of interesting is, is that when you got your density at a certain point, then there was an inverse ratio to your profits. Your profits started to drop because your parking, especially your underground parking number, became so huge. So increasing your density did not necessarily correctly break.

3:08:58 So it may not necessarily bait somebody into building in downtown. I mean, I'm totally on the fence with this one. I'm now 100% convinced that I'm good with 2.5 and Old Mammoth and MLR. I'm just, you know, I defer to the rest of the commission on, you know, whether they think there's any merit to increasing the downtown area, and it sounds like not really. Commissioner Harvey here. If I may, the...

3:09:27 A couple of things. I'm looking at our options. In option number two, the item three, we would be asking a consultant to determine what changes the general plan would need. And my question to staff is, is that language broad enough to include

3:09:56 an exploration by a consultant going through this exercise to examine if we got the right number. Well, I think, well, the consultants that we have on board right now feel like 2.5 is the right number. We can always ask for third and fourth and fifth opinions.

3:10:25 I think we're talking about that consultant would be an environmental quality specialist, you know, a CEQA specialist, a general plan amendment specialist versus Winner & Company and Hart Howard and who are planning specialists. Okay, the short answer is I believe the 2.5. I've crunched numbers and I think the 2.5.

3:10:51 It gets us to where we want to go and will attract the right people. Rhonda is exactly right, though. We will have the exception. They will come in depending upon the product that they bring forward. That's just a fact of life. I want to get on with this and get this thing done. The fact that we need to go through a general plan update, that's fine. If that's what we need to do, then that's what we need to do. And we need not to waste any more time.

3:11:21 Getting it done. All right. So I'm convinced 2.5 in all districts for me is good. The thing that persuades me is Mr. Hodges says 2.5 will work for a brand hotel and the fact that the downtown working group was unanimous on that and the downtown working group represented quite a range of constituencies so that... Your other consultant said yes. Yeah, and the other consultant said that and, you know, we seem to have consensus here. So I think...

3:11:50 With the, let's see, dramatic recommendation that is evident in option two, I think sticking with something where there's already consensus and then knowing that the exception would come forward asking for a variance or whatever is the way to go. So I'm in favor of 2.5. Okay. So it's overall FAR 2.5 includes all residential, lodging, commercial, elimination of CBIS from the commercial, from the general plan. Mm-hmm.

3:12:20 And now we'll talk about how we're going to fund a general plan amendment, CEQA, or when. Lottery ticket. How are we going to fund it? So, okay. Sell cookbooks, you know, bake sales. Bake sales. That's what you said. So, just so you, just so everyone's clear, there's five options. Staff has recommended option one. Having said that, I think

3:12:52 That option two is also, you know, perfectly acceptable. I think the only reason why we're recommending option one right now is because we would have to have the direction from council, the resources, funding, etc. And that generally is the only differences between options one and two is one says let's look at this during the budget process and schedule it for 2014-15. Option two says no, make this the highest priority.

3:13:22 Do it now. Find the money to do it now. And the resources. That's the general options. Option three is basically saying that we wouldn't pursue further evaluation of density or FAR or general plan amendments or anything. Option four is do nothing, basically. And option five is any other options anyone wants to throw out there. Just one more clarification.

3:13:51 You know, staff's perspective is that we, this is one chapter of a big document which you're going to be really excited to get in a couple weeks. And we want to keep that process moving forward because there's a lot of other really important stuff in there and also we have to meet our grant obligations. So option one and two would be basically saying that we would commit to finish that because that's important as well.

3:14:20 Option two makes it a little bit more challenging for us because we would be having these two parallel processes that we would have to staff. Not saying it can't be done, but it's a little more challenging. I don't know if you want to say anything else. So I'd just like to add a little bit to that. Mayor Wood and other council members have certainly given their very clear

3:14:49 direction that we are to be developer ready and as you know being developer ready the zoning code is one part of it then we really need to do a full evaluation and come up with our development impact fees and really analysis of all our fees and then as alluded before that we really didn't have to talk about parking districts so I felt really strongly that

3:15:19 We need to at least ask council to make a business decision if they can financially fund having a consultant hired that would have the ability to do an analysis of the general plan CEQA work that's required.

3:15:39 Because if we want to be developer ready, we need to be developer ready in my opinion now. It can't be part of the 14-15 work program because it's too late in the business cycle. So the purpose at the workshop would be to discuss this with council, to see what they're willing to do, and then just so you would understand is at the workshop they really can't take any action.

3:16:06 But staff did have put on the council's agenda for that evening an agenda item so that if council wanted to move forward with any of this that they could vote on it at the council meeting. Are you also saying if this doesn't get prioritized higher we're not going to be able to meet our target dates and completion of the zoning code amendment as well?

3:16:35 Wouldn't that also be a two-fold benefit of them dedicating and putting this higher up on our level? But that's, we'll give them that choice. I mean, it's going to be completed. The question is, do you want it completed in the year 14? In essence, what we're saying to council, and it's truly their decision, do you want it completed in 14-15? I just felt that we needed...

3:17:02 As a commission to give them another option to do that. Okay, and then would you like to make a comment? Tom Hodge is from Esquire. Yeah, I mean, we strongly support Mickey's position on this that we would urge you to recommend option two. And for the very reason that she stated that, you know, we have this little issue with the grant fund and getting the zone code update completed, which we understand. And so we're essentially saying

3:17:31 Adopt the zoning code with the FAR numbers, but put this density overlay, which then you don't accomplish the FAR. Exactly. But it satisfies what you need to do to get your grant fund money and so forth in this period of time between now and June. But, you know, that issue aside, I think it's important to understand that, you know, the business cycle is turning. You know, there is evidence that, I mean, you go to Los Angeles, the Bay Area.

3:17:59 You know, there's a lot of stuff coming on the ground. There's a tower crane down in downtown Santa Monica. I mean, things are starting to happen and the market's turning. And this is when we need to be ready because this is when these outside developers are going to come here looking for opportunities. And when the values of these properties are still a little bit low and the tide's starting to rise, that's when you want to be able to get in. But they're going to need to see the opportunity now. If you see it two years from now, we're going to miss the boat. So I think the point is that

3:18:28 You know, let's look at the big picture from 30,000 feet. We're talking about, you know, if you look at the whole commercial zone and that redevelopment area, I mean, it's over a billion dollars of redevelopment, you know, in cost. And, you know, we're, I think we would be so short-sighted as a community if we were to quibble over a couple hundred thousand dollars to go through this sequel process that we're talking about. Oh, yes. And, you know, I think the other point Chuck had made during the working group,

3:18:58 Two is like, if we don't do the work now, if we don't tell the outside development world, this is what we want, and then we've already decided, and we've actually, you know, it's already done, and we're going to put the burden back on, and we're back where we were five years ago. We're back to everybody having asked for a variance, and nothing getting done. So, you know, I think we all learned a big lesson, you know, and a lot of things happened, a lot of good things happened the last round, but a lot of good things that were on the books never happened, or didn't get...

3:19:25 Didn't break ground, right? We had a Hard Rock Hotel that was this close to starting. We had a Ritz-Carlton that didn't break ground. And a lot of those projects were took, you know, Old Mammoth Place, you know, how many, two years? I can't even believe he had the endurance to get through that process of those approvals. So, I mean, I think the whole point is we're all the way down to the one-yard line here with all the standards and the recommendations and the commercial zoning code. We just have to layer this a little bit of a distensity restriction for the moment.

3:19:55 Let's continue the work. Let's get it done. Let's recommend council, hey, let's buy the money. This is critical to the future of our community to provide these approvals so the zoning code is there and that people can see that we know what we want and they're going to come in and do the work. So that's, you know, I just think we don't want to lose sight of the fact, you know, I know money's tight and we have all these other issues going on, but

3:20:22 When you look at the priorities of this community and what's going to carry us into the future, you know, this is probably the highest priority for the community in my opinion of this year as well. Thanks. Nikki, I have a question for staff. Yes, go ahead. Okay. Sandra, what are the logistics of this? If this is a concurrent study, is it possible to find consultants who do expedited CEQA who are good? Would it be possible to get adopted in June or May? When does it go to council?

3:20:54 May? We're hoping it's going to go to Council in April, actually. Oh, April? Ooh. Would we be able to expedite this soon enough so it would be part of the zoning code update, the whole package? We never would have to send the density and the CBiz to adopt that in April? It would depend on what the actual CEQA document ends up to be. Whether it's a neg deck or... It would not be done, I'm sure, by April.

3:21:19 Okay. But, you know, if it's something other than that, you know, it's possible. I don't know if we've kind of blocked out the timelines for ADEC, but, you know, we could look into that. But, I mean, I think that the thought is we could, at this point, we could do an RFP. We're ready to publish the, you know, the public review draft, so kind of the work that we're doing on that is going to be, you know, lifted a little bit. We would have time to do a scope of work, time to get a consultant on board, and to kind of carry the parallel path.

3:21:48 And, I mean, if it's a month after the zoning code updates adopted, it's a month after, or two months, you know, whatever it is, I mean. But then you have to go through the whole process of the hearings and all that stuff. Right, yeah, but you're going to have to go through that with the general plan. Yeah, that's true. Updates as well, so those would all be, it would all be one package together. The density portion separate and the rest of it, so. I mean, if things were really good, maybe we could, but my guess is that it likely will be after.

3:22:16 And then how about a supplemental EIR? Is that just as big a deal? No, it just depends. I mean, I think it just kind of depends on what we... Our current general plan EIR is relatively limiting on the density, so I think that we would have to look and see if we could do something like that or like a focused EIR just for certain pieces. So we can look at kind of different options, and that's kind of what we would explore with the consultant.

3:22:45 Oh, good. Okay. Thank you. Can anybody answer any questions for staff? Did you, Tom, have some additional comments? Tom, I just want to scare you. Yeah, I think Stan was correct. I actually spoke with a couple of consultants yesterday, Christopher Joseph and PCR, who actually did the work on the original general plan, EIR. And, yeah, I mean, an April timeframe is probably not achievable for an approval.

3:23:16 You know, could we get one out, the draft document out for public comment by then? That's, you know, certainly likely. And then it just, you have the mandatory, you know, 45-day comment period, and then response to comments, and then the final draft goes out. So, you know, the time frames I was discussing with consultants, they thought June was doable, but certainly it would take the focus of that, you know, we would need the approval right away from the town council to move ahead and, you know, fund it and get moving on it.

3:23:46 So I think the point is we should go ahead with it and we should do as fast as we can. But if we adopt the recommendation option two, we're going to adopt the commercial zoning code with everything in it, just with the density overlay issue on there. And then that suffices for your deadline on your grant fund. Two months later, three months later, we come through with the approval on the supplemental EIR or whatever it is and the general plan amendment.

3:24:15 And then we can just remove that in due course. I don't think it's a problem, you know, from a timeline standpoint. Right. I just think the point is we don't, you know, the biggest mistake we can make is just not make the commitment now to fund this effort and continue to get it finished. Because, you know, it's what it's going to take. I mean, we have to do what we have to do, and we're bound to the laws of CEQA, and we have to follow the rules. So, but again, you know, we,

3:24:45 You look in the relative terms of this small investment on our part to find a couple hundred thousand dollars to fund this effort in the grand scheme of the future growth of this community and sustainability. It's an easy decision. Do you anticipate members of the public will be there on the 16th to make the case you made? I know a couple other members of the public will be here. I think Rusty and Chuck will plan to be here next week for the town council meeting.

3:25:15 Okay. Thank you. That's the longest we've had a public in a long time. I know. The public. We have a public. The public. The longest we've had a public. I just have a comment about option 2.2. I didn't think it's evaluate and resolve community benefits. I think it's, I don't know, maybe you don't want to use the word eliminate. I mean, we don't want it evaluated. We want it removed. So I just didn't know if there was a reason that.

3:25:46 Choice of words was used. No. Maybe we should just say resolve. Or, I mean, we could say, I suppose we could say eliminate, if that's what the commission recommends. I think we're just concerned about, I mean, we don't know what the answer is going to be. So the current general plan says, in order to get that expediency, you have to go through incident zoning. So the revision...

3:26:12 Why don't we put possible elimination? Yeah, I just think, we just didn't want to commit to something that we don't, maybe it's an easy thing, like double, you know, underground parking, double this. So let's put, I would be more comfortable if the word said evaluate and possible elimination. Sure. I like that too. Are we ready to have a motion? Do you want to continue discussion on this? Do we call for a motion? No more discussion. 20 years of discussion. Put a white flag here.

3:26:42 It was actually exciting to read this packet. I mean, this was, we're getting somewhere, you know, it was a good packet this time. I think this is the longest set of options ever. Yeah. I'll go ahead with a motion. I'm only supportive of option two, and there's no way I'm reading that, so. Yeah. As noted. Option two as written. Yes. With the small change that Mickey had addressed. The change to the language.

3:27:11 I'll second that. Good. Can we have a roll call vote? Commissioner Dugan? Yes. Commissioner Hardy? Yes. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Kearney? Yes. Chairman Brown? Yes. Thank you, staff, in quotes. Sandra, Jessica, you did a really fine job. You really did. I thank the public for all their comments. Our public representative. Our public representative, yes.

3:27:47 All right. Let me find the agenda. So regarding, I have every agenda here but the one that I need. Okay. Okay. So let me, business matters number four. We have this water efficient landscape ordinance. We tried to set up a separate meeting to discuss it. We weren't really, could never come to a consensus on a good date.

3:28:20 But, you know, it's a pretty interesting ordinance because we're state mandated basically about what it can say. I mean, we don't have a lot of discretionary input. Commissioner Tinney may want to comment on it. So my thought was that maybe we would just be better off to let the staff go ahead and put the ordinance the way it's written into the draft code book that we're going to get. And if anybody had any comments, they could just make it in the comment period of the zoning code rather than trying to struggle with having another meeting.

3:28:50 And we did hold a public meeting, a meeting with the public at the water district, I think it was last month, August 8th. So we have, it has been presented to the public, but the commission hasn't, hasn't commented on it. For Elizabeth's benefit, you emailed me about whether we had revised the user's guide, so there's the ordinance, and then we had a user's guide developed.

3:29:20 And yes, I have revised it substantially. And we will always have the opportunity to update back to that document. It's just a user's guide, not codified. So I can provide that to you guys for comment and review just individually. But we'll put the regulations in the public review draft. But not have a meeting, right?

3:29:49 Right. You okay with that? No, that's fine. My concern was that it was just so wordy and incomprehensible and it, you know, these user guides and things like that represent the town. Right. And, you know, quality and it just was so inadequate. Right. Yeah, there was a lot of inconsistencies between that and the actual regulations. Yeah, it really wasn't well done, but I wasn't going to spend my time, you know, editing the thing.

3:30:15 But it certainly needed to be better, so I'm glad to hear it is better. We've made it better. I wouldn't say that it's perfect, but it's better, and over time it can be revamped. That'll be fine. Just so it's of the quality that we have come to expect with the staff that we have. We have very good staff. So we're going to please. Everybody's okay with that? Yeah. So that means there's no meeting at 3 o'clock on the 16th?

3:30:42 No. Correct. We will have, we'll start our joint meeting on the 16th. Okay. And in winter we'll do a presentation of the draft Main Street plan. Okay. Then we will talk about this again. Okay. And, you know, I'll probably meet with the chair to discuss how we, how that meeting flows. You know, I don't know if the council is going to want to get into the.

3:31:09 detail about development standards and so on or just get right to the heart of the matter which is the density in FAR discussion. So the plan was I meet with Mayor Wood before the meeting, discuss the agenda with him. Oh good, that's a good idea. All right, should we move on to Commissioner Reports, design committee, design review? I haven't reviewed anything. I think

3:31:41 The only thing we had since the last meeting was the approval of the Fun Shop sign. Is that right? Oh, that's right. We did look at that. Yeah. Mammoth Fun Shop, Camille Miller's property on Main Street, put through their sign application, and I think poor Camille is finally going to be able to open her place. We did approve the sign. It's kind of a metal overlay on the front of the building and kind of like a, almost like an 80s style.

3:32:11 Cartoon, Wham, Pal, sign. So we did approve that. I think that's all we've had since the last meeting, I think. Economic development, probably nothing, right? Main Street, next week is the big Main Street. And what time is the downtown working group meeting on the 16th? 10, I think. 10. Oh. I didn't know about that one. Okay. All right.

3:32:43 Downtown Working Group. Capital Facilities, Municipal Wayfair, we've done, we're way over zoning code update. And the only thing I wanted to ask, especially after today's presentation, did anybody in the commission want to be part of the community indicators group? Originally, I mean, there was always the original intention that somebody from the commission was going to be on that group, but I thought we were a little committee doubt, so that...

3:33:11 Are you looking for volunteers? I don't think it's necessary unless somebody really wants to. I think we got good input from you as a whole today and then we'll be bringing it back for further. So I don't know. I'm fine with that. I just want to make sure that this is not a futile exercise and that we have the ability to get quantitative results from these indicators.

3:33:42 And I think less is more in this case, keeping our number of indicators down and keeping those pillars in a manageable way. And the idea of being able to circulate this publicly and actually get people to

3:34:08 Respond and look at it and, oh, yeah, you're going in the right direction. Something we could put in the newspaper, literally. And somebody could look at it and make sense of it. I've got to agree with Commissioner Tenney. It was so wordy. Oh, so hard to read. Yeah, the background information. It just wasn't necessary.

3:34:34 Yeah. And I had to read two, three times over and over. I did too, yeah. To really understand it. So if that could be cleaned up, certainly before it goes out to the public, that would be great. Yeah, the public will not see that stuff. Yeah. Well, any body of work that they do, the writing just wasn't, it wasn't what it should have been. I understand. It's interesting, I saw

3:35:00 When I went out during the break, he was in the hall, and he said he really appreciated all the feedback he got from us, and he says, we don't usually see that. People just, you know, whatever. And he was really, really gratified that he drove all the way to Mammoth in a storm, you know, and got all that feedback, so that was good. Can I, can I just, I just want to report one thing, because I see municipal wayfinding and community messaging committee.

3:35:27 There's not really a committee per se anymore, but I don't know if the commission is aware that the town is proposing a Measure U application to further fund the wayfinding. Wonderful. So we, I think I present that to the committee next week, I can't remember, but basically our application is, it's like roughly $330,000 and it would

3:35:56 Fund the pedestrian signs and all of the vehicular signs. Do you need support from us on that, anyway? If the commission wants to support it, I mean, you know, we'll be up against many other Measure U applications. You know, I don't know what, it's not on the agenda, so I guess you can't really say anything, but...

3:36:21 I just want to let you know that that was what staff had proposed for a Measure U project was to further that effort. That's great. And the director? Just a couple quick things. The building official recruitment closes next week, the application period, so we'll be starting interviews probably the following week, week after. So hopefully we can get that person on board quickly. Code enforcement, we are still working with Sierra Employment to get a qualified person to start, so we're going to be interviewing two people for that.

3:36:55 The temporary help, so hopefully they'll start next week, and that full-time position probably won't be filled until January, but at least we'll have the stopgap of the temporary help starting next week. And also, just kind of moving to future agenda items, your November 13th meeting is, in addition to just the drive zone and code update, you have a number of things. It was a possible joint workshop with the recreation commission. We'll be having a workshop on the in, the 80-50-C project.

3:37:25 That day and possibly a request for a public art refund for the Mammoth Rock and Bowl. So I think that will be your first action kind of as the public art commission. So it will be a recommendation to council. So we may be polling you to ask if you could meet earlier on that day just because it is kind of a big agenda. On the 13th, you said? Right, November 13th. Your agenda incorrectly under adjournment says...

3:37:49 November 11th, it's actually November 13th. It says it correctly, right? Well, aren't we really adjourning to October the 16th, the workshop? That's a town council meeting, technically. All right. Well, we're not going to meet early unless we get heat in the room. Okay.

3:38:05 Yeah, I'm pretty cold. Do we have a vote on that? I have my coat on. I can't really. We're all wearing our coats. I'm fine. I'm excited. I'm in favor of meeting early because we don't feel so rushed. I mean, I don't feel today we wasted any time at all thanks to our chair who's just so good at moving us forward. But I didn't feel rushed because I look at that clock and think about child care and just, you know, think about all that stuff.

3:38:32 And it just, one o'clock was fine. And we have big meetings, I think we should. And if we get out of here at four, that's great. But then we don't feel so rushed. You said on the 13th we're doing a workshop on the 80-50?

3:38:48 Because it's ADP on the 14th. That's usually how we do it. We have the Planning Commission workshop and then the ADP is the following day. That will be an opportunity for the public, the applicants also having public workshops kind of separate from the town with the neighbors and the community before that, hopefully this month. So it'll be a good, we'll have gotten a lot of input through their kind of public or private kind of process and then we'll have a public meeting.

3:39:18 Just a workshop, just to discuss and get your kind of preliminary comments and to present the project. So how are you going to bring us up to speed on the North Village specific plan now that's so totally different than our commercial zone before the 80-50 workshop? Can you like download like...

3:39:36 Tapes we can listen to in our sleep or something. We can give you an updated copy. We have no lives. We don't have it on books on tape. Maybe we can hire somebody to read it so you guys can listen to it. We could give you guys updated versions. It is available on our website as well. Well, I mean, I know it's available on our website, but, you know, it's a very different, it's very different than everything we've been talking about in our commercial zones. It is.

3:40:02 So we're going to have to have at least, you know, I would like an overview of key points before we get into this workshop because we're not going to be able to evaluate that project based on the commercial zone criteria. That's my only point of this. Yeah, the intent of that workshop is not for you to evaluate, just simply to hear, get your kind of feedback, or just kind of a regional, just hear it. So they are proposing amendments to the North Phillips Pacific plan so we can give you the context of what currently is required and

3:40:29 Because they're proposing, I think, a density, height, and setback amendments increases. So that will all kind of give you the context of that so that you can have that background. Yes. That's all I have. We can do for the next 10 minutes. I got a couple questions for the director. Yes. What about the Mammoth Brewing Company tanks? Yes.

3:40:53 We've been working with Joyce and Sean. Joyce had a family emergency. She is out of the state right now, but she should be back. I did email her and she's aware of the issue. And they have been working with...

3:41:08 Thank you. Thank you.

3:41:27 It might be at the beginning of November. Then my other question was this draft resort investment element that was included in our packets. Is that anything that we want to be looking at if we're considering if a general plan amendment and the CEQA and all the rest of that stuff is involved with the FAR at the same time? The county bundles amendments. Is it a good thing to bundle amendments or does it make the CEQA so much more complicated we should put this on the back burner?

3:41:57 Even though the first page and a half are completely consistent with what we're trying to do. What do you think? Well, I think we need just to get through the first step next week. That's true. That is sort of crossing a threshold. Okay. But I just was wondering if that was something that we should be considering at the same time. Do we have an AT&T update? Oh, yeah. What's going on with them? I think they're still working on the design of the Shiloh.

3:42:26 Vice Chair Fernandes, have you met with them recently? I can't recall the stats. Dave, correct me if I'm wrong, but basically all the notes that we made to them they've agreed upon, I think. We haven't seen the final draft review, but they said that they submitted an initial draft plan and we made some comments to that that weren't in compliance with what we had.

3:42:56 Hope for and then they said that they were okay with making those changes. We just haven't seen the final. Yeah, I'm not sure if they've submitted for an actual field meeting. Yeah, I think it's moving in the right direction. We just haven't seen the final occupancy. Then I move to adjournment to our November 13, 2013 meeting. Thank you. Thank you, everybody.