Trails Committee
· recording 2 hr 36 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
327 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Oh my goodness, thank you for inviting me. I have some great pictures in my computer.
0:38 I totally spaced it. You were going to email it to me. I know. I know. I'll get it for you. Keep me in mind. Everybody? Upstairs? Hey, Stu. How's it going? No, nothing. Greg was running around up here, so. I'm still telling you. I'm still getting around here.
1:02 That's good, are ya?
1:23 You sent off to the new regional commissioners. Fantastic. That was really good. Thank you. So do you. No, no, no, I'm getting mine on Wednesday. No, no, I'm getting mine on Wednesday. I'm getting mine on Wednesday.
1:56 I am here. And I am here.
2:31 On. Okay. Public comments. Now is the time to make any comments for the public on items that do not regularly appear on the agenda. Do we have any public comments today? Everyone is sitting attentively and not approaching the podium. Therefore, we will close public comments. And if I'm reading the correct... Oh, wait. I'm sorry. I'm jumping around here a little bit. I guess we're going to go straight into presentations.
3:03 Steve, do you want to tell us some stories? Sure. The first item for the presentation has to do with the update regarding the web enhancement QR code interpretive signage development project. And in your packet should be a letter from the town of Mammoth Lakes dated October 21st. And that letter is to MLTPA.
3:33 And in that letter, the town acknowledges that MLTPA board has decided not to accept the extension for the existing website enhancement project in regards to the QR code development. And that letter is in your packet and also the follow-up material and attachments that will include a letter from MLTPA.
4:03 Regarding their board's decision, and that letter had attachments as well. I apologize if they may not be in the exact precise order in which they were received, but we have had some technical difficulties over the past weeks or so within the town office. But the information is there, and if you have any questions, I am more than happy to answer. Steve, I just have one quick question, and that is, do you intend to prepare an RFP to go out?
4:34 For the solicit bids to go ahead and complete that work? Right. That is on page two, second to last paragraph. It says, therefore, the town will now be required to request a proposal from an outside source and or dedicate additional staff and resources to complete the described unfulfilled work effort. And I've been in touch with ESEA in the meantime, and they have expressed an interest.
5:02 And that in helping out with the project. And that was prior to the government shutdown. And so I need to touch base again with them and make sure that they still share an interest. Okay. I just, you know, as we've discussed, it's always nice to keep these things moving. And so if there's a way to get an RFP out or work with whatever solution staff has to keep it moving forward. Steve.
5:33 These are just landing pages, so when people use their smartphones to scan the QR codes, something comes up on their phone, right? That's correct. Video or a map or something. Have we talked to the people over, Christy's here, so I may as well speak to her organization. Have we talked to the people over there, because they already do that sort of thing on a regular basis for promotional purposes. They have a whole bunch of different little...
6:04 One- and two-minute videos and three-minute videos that they have done. Yeah, I have had conversations with them, as a matter of fact, and briefly discussed who the providers of those videos were, are, and so that is part of the option that we can explore when we move forward with those other professional entities. Yeah, I just...
6:32 It seems that perhaps some of that content may even already be out there and some of the videos already that have been produced in terms of some of the hiking and other recreational things that occur. And if we don't have to reinvent that wheel, if they've already got something in the can somewhere that might serve that purpose, I'm quite certain they would love to pay us for the opportunity to put a... Really? Really? I just thought I'd see if anybody was listening. Yeah, fair enough.
7:02 I think more than anything. This was actually an interpretive content, though, right? It was a development of interpretive content for the eight existing interpretive signs that have the QR code bug on them. Because you were one of those that was cited as being, yeah, one that would be interviewed or on it or whatever. Is there any other comments regarding presentation number one?
7:29 Number two is an invitation to attend tomorrow, November 5, Recreation Commission meeting starting at 1 o'clock here in Suite Z to hear a presentation from both MLTPA on the website management and Friends of the Inyo on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System summer programs. So this is just a formal invitation then to the board and soliciting your interest and an invitation to hear that combined presentation.
7:58 Let's do, does that meeting start at? Okay, because I was thinking I read of the agenda that it said 1230. That was if we're going to do a ribbon cutting, which has been not quite ready yet. Ribbon cutting, for what? Trials End Park, the Little Brothers. Oh, yeah. Oh, yeah, okay. So it is one o'clock. Okay, good. I have a couple other items in presentation that I'd like to hand out, if I might. Is that okay if it's not on the agenda?
8:25 This is additional information that's follow up to what's been requested. Okay, great, thank you. So the first is some additional information on the lakes basin closure. This has to do with cost for dumpster emptying. So this will actually be relevant to item 7? Right. And then the other is some information I just received recently from the Forest Service.
9:00 In regards to their SOPA list, this is usually the fifth page of our master track room, and there's new and updated information on Forest Service projects. And my understanding is that Forest Service will be here a little bit later. So we might put this aside to save for that time? Correct. The other thing in your packet, you'll notice, as follow-up information, two items.
9:35 One of them is a final project checklist dated October 7, 2013. This was originally prepared by Bill Taylor and now is in your packet and is for our use in moving projects forward, whether they have planning consistency, funding consistency, strategy priorities, and so forth. So you should find that in your packet.
10:05 And I actually ran about four projects, five projects through that checklist just to kind of see. And Bill, it works pretty well. I think there was only one question I had on it. I wasn't sure what the develop promotional activities meant as far as a strategy. That was the only one that was kind of... Given I just took it off the list we prepared. You know, it's whatever was discussed back when that was adopted.
10:36 Make these up. I just trolled through earlier. So that either came off of one of our, I think that meant, I didn't bring my binder this week, but I think that came out of our, yeah, it came out of our strategies list that we adopted. Actually, the one that I mentioned last time that I was a little unsure about was funding as available. That was a quote from our priorities, and I wasn't quite sure what it meant, but since I was just quoting, I threw it in there.
11:07 The alternate funding more appropriate or available? Right down at the very bottom, next to the last. Oh, funding is available. Oh, I see. I actually think that that probably could come out. Yeah, I think you're right. Because every one of them, it was kind of like a given. If you answered up above, you really didn't need it down there. Right. That was my sense. Okay. Since we had it on the list, I left it on there. Oh, I see. Okay. I know that had some contention anyway, didn't it? Or just with regard to...
11:39 Whether it's grant or fundraising versus the measures. Yeah. And that's why I say I think that either it either applies under priorities and ready to go that funding is in place or it's related to funding consistency up above. So I think it's covered. Yeah, it's probably it. I think so. Yeah. We never really talked about that last time. No. But it did work. I run five of them through here. Yeah. It seems to me that while we talk about funding in other places.
12:11 When we're talking about priorities, that funding maybe not is available, but as Sean just said, is funding in place. But that would be a long ways to. Yeah, I see what you're asking. Oh, they're funding in place, ready to go. Got it. No, I was referring more to just what the funding sources are, but if it's made it this far down, that could probably be stricken. Do you want to just strike it? Or is now the time to be discussing this?
12:38 Because under ready to go it says funding is in place. Not really discussing. Let's bring it back. The other thing you'll find in your packet as discussed at our last meeting was a question about the project numbering framework and the way that we came up with our numbers. So I reprinted that and put it into your packet. It has the 100 series, 200 series. I provided that for you. So that concludes presentations at this time. Thank you.
13:19 Before I ask on the consent agenda, I just want to pull something up. Okay, let's move on to consent agenda. Is there anyone who wants to pull anything from the consent agenda? I just have a brief comment on the minutes with regard to typos. And at a couple places it says a barrow pit as opposed to a borrow pit. So we can just correct the spelling on that. BA or BO? It should be BO. And it's listed as BA. That's all.
13:58 What is a borrow? I don't know why they call it a borrow pit, because they never give it back. Is that where the term comes from? Is borrow? Okay. Is that right? I'm getting nods from the audience, so I'll take that. Thank you for the education for the day. Okay. Eight for the comments on the consent agenda, then. I'll make a motion. Thank you. That's what I said. Second. Second. Second. Second.
14:33 First and second. Any further comments? Aim for the discussion. Those in favor of accepting the consent agenda? Aye. Opposed? Consent agenda has been accepted. All right, let's move on to business matters. Number five, discuss formatting, sorting, status, and next steps for projects and programs as listed in our current MLTS master plan and on the master tracking list. Steve. Yes.
15:05 We've been working feverishly, feverishly, feverishly, to figure out, not quite a Herculean, but a big task, which is to combine our multi-page document, as we prevented before, about seven pages of all the different projects that were listed in the Trail System Master Plan,
15:37 And the 16 pages of comments received by MLTPA on work that has transpired and for their contracts and so forth having to do with the master plan as well as our four and five pages of the master tracking list in the 11 by 17 fold out format. As you remember the last time we had a meeting I presented this graphic.
16:04 Which was an attempt to try and merge that all together. And it looked like it was getting very awkward, very hard to deal with. So somehow, working in the town office, inspiration came to me. I think it's a new season. So what I'd like to do is pass out then a two-page concept of how to merge all that information and those documents for our use.
16:39 I feel like we spend more time on the process than we do on... To make it clear. It'll help us in the long run. That's right. We're just working out the kinks, right? Working out the kinks. So we have about 15 minutes dedicated to discuss this today, so I'd like to go rather quickly and explain then what I'm doing and what the rationale is, take your comments and hopefully move forward.
17:06 So if we look at the document on the extreme left-hand column, we have projects and programs recommended within the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Master Plan. That's in italics. Underneath that, we have recommendations from within Chapter 4. So we're moving chronologically through the chapters, not alphabetically, but chronologically. So then in italics again, we have G1, which is the recommendation number, the naming conventions, which is the name of the recommendation,
17:34 And then over to the right in italics we have information that was provided by MLTPA which discusses the process and the progress that we've had to date in regards to that naming convention. Above that in bold we have the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee identified projects and programs and again they'll stay in non-italics and
18:04 Some of the headings of the project are in bold. And so you can see underneath that then for the G1 naming convention, there's that descriptor of the work that's happened in the past. And then there's our specific code number 211 for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System standard manual update. We have a bucket list number of number four, our total funding. And in that column, what I've done is I've taken the funding off of the master tracker.
18:33 That was for last fiscal year and this fiscal year, combine them together to give us the total number of dollars that we have. And then if we had a contract, it's in the contracted column. If we've paid out on that contract, it's in the payout column. Organization that's responsible for the work, the status, and the next steps. Wait, that's on this 8 1⁄2 by 11? Yes. Okay. It's the second line down.
19:01 Okay, go on. I'm sorry. Now, one of the things that we're doing, as Stu may have mentioned, is that we're working with QuickBooks to help us track the dollars for these projects. So, in the past, when we have had all of our funding columns for signed contracts, paid out 2012-13, carryover money, reallocated, and so forth, all that information then is being
19:31 Consolidated in this report, but we still have it in our QuickBooks for tracking. So I don't know that it's detailed information that the committee needs to know every month as we're moving forward through this document. If there's a particular contract or something, we need additional monies, we can go to the QuickBooks. Just a quick question, and that is we have the
19:58 Account codes for all the different projects. Are you just running those same codes in QuickBooks so everything matches? That is our concept that we are in the process of discussing the best way of coming up with those individual code numbers so that at any point in time, if you got an invoice or you paid out a check, there would be a distinct number and you could track that all the way through. So that is our intent, Bill. Yes. Excellent. Thanks. Where are we with the reconciliation?
20:25 I know that that kind of plays into this a little bit, but essentially everything that's been awarded versus paid, and I may be jumping ahead a little bit, but it helps me form some of the questions. Where are we with the reconciliation? We're in a really good spot right now. Okay. We have found that we are on budget or under budget on our projects for the Trails Committee.
20:51 And there are ongoing discussions with myself and the other staff about making sure that every invoice that's come in has been identified to a particular project, either through the 2012-13 or the 13-14 fiscal years. And so far, we have not found any major mistakes. Okay, but I guess that was my question. So it is not completed? That's correct. That it's still ongoing? Yep. 95%?
21:20 Okay. Is there going to be a point where it will be completed, you'll be reporting back to us, or is that just... Yeah, next month. Okay, very good. And I guess the reason why I was asking that question is just because with regard to the QuickBooks, at the very least, I think I'd like it to come before us. It doesn't necessarily need to be every month, I don't think. But at the same time, it would be good to have us review it long enough just to jog our memory with regard to... I remember something came up in the last meeting. See, this is...
21:49 Great example of jogging my memory, where something came up that it had been awarded a year or two ago, and I'm not remembering what that case was. Remember that we discussed this at the last meeting, that there was something that essentially we need to be reminded of every now and then that's still outstanding on QuickBooks, and that's why I think it wouldn't be best for us to at least determine an interval that we are reviewing it. Good. Can do. Okay, thank you. Glad we had that talk.
22:19 That component of it, right? Okay, thanks. So, again, what I've tried to do here is take two pages worth of information to explore the concept with you. I think it's a much better evolution than this particular spreadsheet. It was getting a little awkward, a little hard to deal with. And I think by combining funding, that can take care of a lot of that consolidation. It gives us a good basis for understanding what we've done in the past.
22:47 And it gives us a great tool for moving forward and understanding what our bucket list priorities are, what our future funding may or may not be, and then what our current steps and so forth. So I'm available to answer any questions in regards to this concept dated November 1, 2013. So just, you know, I haven't had a chance obviously to digest all of this, but in terms of merging this information with everything else,
23:18 I assume this is still going to exist so that we can track what funds we've carried over to future years, or is that somehow going to, is there a way to that? I think with the Excel spreadsheets, you're able in the Excel file to have the more detailed information and then be able to consolidate it in our funding total. So this would be like the cover sheet and then you'd have subsequent sheets that would have details?
23:48 No, I don't conceptualize it that way. At this time, I conceptualize it as being total funding, which gives you the information of how much money you've put to this project, but as far as over what year or how it came or so forth, that would be on a separate page, and that would be more consistent with the larger spreadsheet. But you can do that with a different tab in Excel. That's perfect. Excel will be the backup.
24:17 In other words, rather than this one. In other words, the QuickBooks would be the backup. Well, the QuickBooks would be the reality of the monies contracted and paid out. That's handled through the QuickBooks. And then I'll have another tab which basically takes total funding and breaks it out into the categories that we've been experiencing like, you know, the 2012-2013 funds carry over to 2014. So then you know what year.
24:45 You approved those monies and what year you projected them forward. And then if you remember we went through the exercise before and we took particular 12, 13, 14 monies and put it into, I'm sorry, 12, 13 monies and put it into 13, 14. So that detail will not be lost but it'll be consolidated and abbreviated under total funding. So we're talking about
25:18 Reviewing this at every meeting and this only as much less or less frequently, I should say. Yeah, I would think that when we start talking about budgeting for the next fiscal year, then we'll break out the larger spreadsheet and use that tool then to see where the monies originally came from, if they came from the $292,000 budget.
25:46 Or if they came from the $300,000 of this current year and what they'll go forward. So that would be a larger way of tracking the monies. Okay. So this is our sample. We should look it over and... Please, yes. Okay, well, anything further on this then? That was easy. Okay. That's the idea. All right, Steve, let's move on. Okay, if I might suggest the next item involves the Forest Service.
26:28 As well as Friends of the Inyo and Mammoth Nordic. So due to fact that Forest Service has yet to arrive, we may want to put that off for a little bit. I'm fine with that. There's no objections. Although I'm not sure from my standpoint that it's necessary. We're talking about potential organizations willing to take this up and what's been done. I don't know if the Forest Service is going to serve that. Is Jeff Forest Service?
27:01 Are you with the Forest Service? Yeah. I would recommend we wait. We had a good chat with John on Friday, Bill, and I think it's we're pulling it all together. I think every partner needs to kind of, you know, contribute to the conversation. So I think it would be really beneficial if we could. I agree, especially considering the last time we met, the government was officially shut down.
27:28 Maybe if I could suggest that we take up the business items number eight, which have to do, again, with that larger spreadsheet and a couple of housekeeping items, and maybe we can work on that. I agree. Okay, sounds good. Steve, you want to go ahead and introduce that then? Sure. Yeah, item number eight is discuss and take actions regarding projects from the approved master project and budget tracking list for fiscal year 2013-14.
27:59 Continue the 2012-2013 funding reallocation to different projects. In 13-14, discuss and provide comments and recommendations. The three projects that we have to look at are number 441, which is the Mammoth Lakes Trail System grants. That was allocated at 7,500.
28:22 The next is number 221A, which was Sharp NEPA CEQA Alternative Trail Layout of $913. And the final number 490.1 Trail Wayfinding Mapping Update at $3,000. Now you may remember from before when we got our budget approved, these were in red and there was an asterisk following them and this was because we hadn't made final determinations
28:50 And considerations for these items. We were going to then discuss them and formalize the recommendation to the Recreation Commission. And then the Recreation Commission, as given authority by the Town Council, would do the final approval of those funding numbers for those tasks. So it's open for discussion now. Please individually.
29:21 Steve, it may not be a bad idea for you to give us just a little bit of background as we go through these. Sure. On item 441, which is the Mammoth Lakes Trail System grants, the descriptor on this was coordinating, I'm sorry, coordinated writing of grants for the benefits of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System infrastructure and programs. It was a bucket list number four.
29:48 There was $8,500 allocated in the approved 12-13 funding. Of that, $1,000 was reallocated and there was a $7,500 remainder. And again, the discussion we have in regards to grants has been put on the
30:19 Potentially for the January 13th future agenda item, which is discuss opportunities for the committee to pursue grants and fundraising options. So the question really here is what do we formally want to do with this remaining $7,500?
30:38 Do we want to keep it in the category or do we want to reallocate it somewhere else? And just before we go there, could you remind us again what the standing is from our town attorney with regard to fundraising versus grants? Right. If you recall, we received an email from the town attorney in regards to grants and pursuing them. At that time, it was felt that the monies were...
31:06 Not intended through Measure R for actual writing of grants and pursuing the grants. I think that it's fair to say that we can use the monies to augment grants that the town gets, and it may be appropriate to research and look to see if there are grant opportunities. But to actually use the monies to write the grant, it was felt that that might come out of the intended scope of the Measure R monies. Thank you.
31:36 That 7,500, that is actually from the 12-13 budget, not the 13-14 budget, is that correct? The 12-13 is where it came from, correct. Right. Did we allocate anything from the 13-14 in that same spot? And I should be looking at that, but since I'm unable to find it. It would have been on a previous spreadsheet. Yeah. I think your question is, is the money that was rolled over from 12-13 to be added to?
32:09 An amount that was assigned for $1,314? That's right. I stand corrected. The $7,500 is the recommended amount from $1,314. Right. And the amount that's carrying over is the $8,500 from $1,213. I apologize for that. Okay, so then there's a total of $16,000 in this bucket.
32:38 Or on the sideline item, I should say, if we keep it the way it is. But the discussion here is to perhaps reallocate it this time. Is that what we're discussing? It's totally up to the committee as to how they want to appropriate the money. If they want to combine it and leave it in the future for future discussions, because in January the whole concept is going to come up again for discussion. So it's up to the committee. Bill?
33:07 Well, I just want to make sure I was clear on what you said with regard to the town attorney and that the money could not be used for writing grants, but it could be used for researching grant opportunities? I think so. Is that correct? Okay. You know, I didn't read that. Grant, I didn't hear that. I heard that it could be used for matches for sure. Yeah, matches I get. And potentially, I think you said, but I don't think the attorney actually...
33:34 Said anything in that. His basic comment was he's not comfortable with using it for either grant writing or for fundraising. Right. And you're saying we need to do further research. Well, and I just heard Steve say that researching grant opportunities is a potential. And so then what I was going to ask was, okay, I don't think it's going to take $16,000 to research grant opportunities. So how much would we?
34:05 Theoretically want to. If that's legitimate, how much do we need? Because then we could disencumber the rest and move it on to some other. Yeah, or another thought might be just to switch the whole thing, call it MLTS grants and call it potential matches. Then we have a match because we know we're going to be asked for matches. And just to move this item along today, unless there's...
34:32 A burning need for money. My feeling is to let it sit there because it's nice to have a reserve specifically for matching grants. If the committee is not opposed, it sounds like what, and I'm making notes here, is that we need to confirm with the attorney that it can be used for grant research because that is interesting.
34:51 That the attorney's giving us an opinion that it can be used for research but not for writing. I don't think he said that. I may have misspoke on that. Okay, if we could just get confirmation on that. Yeah, I think, well, in your packets from before was the email from the town attorney. Yeah, and it didn't say. It didn't say in that email that you could research for grants. So I stand corrected on that. I'm sorry. It was pretty. Well, but it didn't say you could or you didn't say you couldn't. You didn't deal with research.
35:19 Which research for grant is just staff time dealing with trails. I cannot see how that would be an issue. I understand going out after funding might be an issue. But how we allocate our staff time, it seems to me, should be. So I would like clarification on that. In terms of leaving this as a set aside for grant matches, I don't see that as a need. Because a grant match is going to come from the project which the grant is for.
35:49 And that's going to come as its own project, with its own line, with its own funding. If we were going to set this aside for that, I would rather set it aside in our capital pot, which we've sort of created now, for actual trail construction. I would be more comfortable setting it aside for future trail construction than for grant, specific grant assistance. We do have some, now did you say we're going to discuss this in January? You may be right, maybe it's time to, maybe just.
36:18 We do get asked from staff, especially when they're talking about mumps for matches. I know that. Usually you would handle funding those by giving it its own number and assigning its own funding for that specific project, which would include the match, rather than bringing it out of a fund. Then you're muddying the waters. You're bringing that project out of two or three different funds.
36:43 I'm comfortable not doing anything with it today, but I don't think that, as Bill said, matches are tied to projects. And if we are matching, then we're assigning a project code to it, and it's part of that project. And it should be just coming out of whatever our fiscal year funding priorities are. Now, as you said, obviously,
37:09 Sometimes things pop up in the middle of the fiscal year, but ideally, we should be tying, I mean, if we have a grant opportunity, then we've probably already at least done some initial work on that project. And so there should be a budget, there should be... I just know that many times, like the TE program for Caltrans fell, you know, the state funding fell through, so we have been asked to come up with money.
37:38 Or Measure R has been asked to come up with a to replace the match that they lost. So that's all I'm saying. It's usually through public work. It's usually a month. It's one of those. But as Bill said, then that comes out of our capital fund. If I may make a suggestion with regard to these monies, let's leave them where they are for right now in January. There's no sense in moving them around just to move them around later on because then we're trying to figure out where the money came from. Now, I did have a question here. Steve, the bridge fund.
38:07 The 8,500 used to bridge fund, that was to carry the MLTPA SOS contract through a complete summer, wasn't it? Yes, that was, if you remember, because of the fiscal year timing and the budget approval, we needed to have money, so that was identified, and then on the larger spreadsheet, it was invoiced for and it's been accounted for, and so now the money is back in.
38:39 To move forward with. So we actually do have 16,000 total. Okay. You know, and I'm almost saying that money has been replaced. I almost want to just remove that. The comment. The comment, because, yeah, it's just, you know, since it's already been paid back, can we just remove that comment altogether so it doesn't confuse in the future? It was a temporary. Okay, that's what I was thinking, but I want to be sure. Yeah. Yeah, okay. Now pay back. And I would agree with that under current status once that. Yeah.
39:07 Goes away that that needs to be removed on all projects. Yeah. And hopefully it will get better so that we don't have to do that much more of that in the future. Okay. So let's move on to the second item there, which is 221A, Sharp NEPA CEQA Alternative Trail Layout. That item was put in as a placeholder encased through the NEPA CEQA process.
39:41 There was need for additional funding to go out and identify alternative trail layouts. If there had been habitat problems with the layout or cultural resource problems or something like that, that was set aside money. And in actuality, the number was derived.
40:04 As a balancing number to get us to the round number of $300,000 for our budget. So there is no cost estimate behind that number. It's merely some money we had set aside in case it was needed. I would be very comfortable just moving that into the cost share pot. The 331 construction pot?
40:33 It's like a contingency. Yeah, well, we have the cost share ongoing that we're putting into annually with the Forest Service. Yeah, okay. I would just move this into that account and then that just 900 bucks we don't have to pay out of a future year's allocation. Okay. That's just money we're putting in the bank for the Forest Service's use on the project. Yeah, so 331, yeah. 331? 221? 221? 221 A. Yeah. Put it in, yeah.
41:02 So just put it in with the challenge cost share. On page 205. Yeah. Essentially, that's just to make the budget even. Correct. Yeah. Because there's nothing you can do for 900. Steve, you understood what else it is. And then 221A goes away. Correct. Okay. So is that consensus? Is that consensus? Yeah, that is so consensus. Yeah. Okay, next one.
41:32 And the last one, 490.1 Trail Wayfinding Mapping Updates, $3,000. That is installation of up to 10 revised maps on existing Type 2 and Type 4-6 sign panels for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Wayfinding. So, let's see. Now, these are our main maps, the big kiosk maps. Yeah, this...
42:08 Well, yes, for the kiosks as well as the, those are type two, and then the four, six are the smaller map panels. So the idea here was that because we were completing things like the, what is it, the Meadow Lane connector, the college connector, and so forth, and those show up on the map currently as an under construction, if I recall,
42:38 And so these were monies set aside to buy new fiberglass panels to replace that to reflect current status of our system or proposed construction that would be completed by the next year, let's say. So these monies then were set aside to update those map panels. Steve, if I recall, each one of those full-size panels on the large signs cost us about $3,000.
43:10 A piece. You know, it's been a while since I've seen the cost of it. I can't recall one or the other. My thought on this, this summer, as you probably all know, one of those signs was stolen off of the Mammoth Creek sign down here, and it cost the town about $3,000, which it doesn't have. I am told that we have a deductible on our insurance policy with the government group that we insure with that is greater than that. So I'd like to see us use this as a set-aside.
43:41 Not just for updating, but so we also have money in an emergency purpose for when one of our signs is defaced or stolen, it can be replaced. If insurance isn't going to pay for it and general fund doesn't have the ability, it would be a shame. That one sign, it's, Stu, do you know, is it up now? I haven't checked in a week or two. I saw it. I sent you an email. Did you? Yeah, it's up. Well, I didn't get it. Get a look at it.
44:09 You must have sent it today. Yeah. That's right, yes. Yeah, so we went all summer without it because of the process we had to go through. So even if insurance is going to pay for it, I would love to see us have a fund set aside so that one of these signs goes down, we can order a new one and then determine who the responsible party is later, whether it's collected back from whoever stole it or...
44:34 And just to be clear, this 3,000 was not to create new signs. It was simply to redo the graphics so that we would have them when the time came to create the new signs. Just keep it fresh. And so in theory, we should have some amount of the budget ongoing. Either that or in each new project budget. So for instance, when we propose a new trail, that budget should include
45:01 Updating the signs. Updating the signs, updating the website, everything else. And we just need to make sure we're clear on our policies on that so that it doesn't slip through the cracks. And this is up to 10 revised maps. Is that all that needs to be updated with regard to the College Connector, Metal Lane, that kind of thing? I don't know where that 10 number came from, quite frankly. If there's actually...
45:33 Somehow I have a sneaky suspicion there are a lot more than 10 type 4-6 signs out there. I think this was, again, just to be able to have the ability to fund the fiberglass panels. The panels or the design? We were saying it, Bill said, the individual panel probably. It's an installation of 10 revised maps. So it is for the production of those maps.
46:03 See, because you've got... I would rather see us take some of that verbiage off of it and just use this as wayfinding, mapping, repair and updates and continue to put money into it so that we have the ability to repair and update the signs that it occurs. I don't know in the maintenance budget for these what they have for maintenance, but I know it's not enough to come close to replacing anything or fixing signs that get vandalized.
46:32 I think we need to also work out a budget bill on exactly what it would cost to actually replace the map on each of those signs, and then put in an adequate budget amount next year, because obviously $3,000 doesn't seem sufficient at all. It's easily probably double that. However, if we add, and we can certainly look at that, but if we add this every year, that's going to be a growing amount, giving us the ability to change out more than one sign. I would agree with that.
47:02 So 13, 14, we allocated 3,000. We may want to allocate more next year, but I would like to see us have that fund, and that's how I would... We're planning mapping updates slash replacement or something like that. Yeah. Yeah, exactly. I'd probably put... Yeah, I would put update slash repair. Yeah. It exists. It's a replacement if they've lived their normal lifetime, and it's a replacement project.
47:29 I think that has to be a different fund for the graffiti or something. Yeah. I think there's something else to think about here that there might be like three levels of where this could come into place. Let's say something happens and a vehicle loses control and wipes out a complete sign. And that includes all the metal framework, all the background information, as well as a fiberglass panel. So that's...
47:59 One level of impact. The other is vandals take just the sign panel and leave the frame and take the fiberglass map with it. Then the third one is the need to replace the fiberglass map because we've had updates in our system. So the way to maybe look at this is that it is a fund to be drawn upon in case any one of those three scenarios should happen. I would make a motion.
48:29 Stating that. I'd second it. If such a motion were made? Right. I would second it. No, you've made it. Yeah. And I'm going to have Steve repeat what that motion was. Okay. Want me to repeat my motion? Yeah, you. Okay. To use the funds in 490.1 for repair and update signs and maps.
48:59 As required. So a question back to where we started on this. So it sounds, again, like there are a couple components. We have some maps today that don't show correct information because we've completed trail segments. The projects that completed those trail segments did not include money for updating the system. So we need to have some money to do the update of the graphics.
49:30 And we also need some money to actually then reproduce and install the updated graphics. So there's first the graphic work, you know, the stuff you do on the computer to change the map. Then there's the sign construction and installation. And I just, I don't think there's...
49:53 You have money to take this far. No, no, I agree with you. We're going to be allocating more money. Exactly. I think when we do the budget is when we address it. I think for right now, if we just make sure we keep it here. Just want to make sure that this covers all three. Yeah. Yeah. And I think actually, as Stu was saying, developing a budget for it, which includes all of these elements. And we'll probably allocate more money. Right. And I hope as we get into, and this is coming a lot faster than everybody knows.
50:22 After January 1st, we're going to be starting on the next fiscal year budget. So this is going to be a line item, I hope, going forward. Yes. Yeah, I think we all agree with that. So maybe we can revise it to design, manufacture, and install? Something like that. With that covered? Yeah, that sounds good. I'd amend it to that. Well, for that segment, the amount. Segment, yeah. Let's see, some of the kiosk ones, I think, have everything, right? I mean, the big ones.
50:52 Yeah, it's all on one panel. But after one got stolen this year, I think we need to start looking at whether or not we can compartmentalize that and just change out the maps. Yeah, some way to do it. Well, the other thing, too, on that particular one is the affixing detail is now vandal resistant, whereas before it was a little more susceptible. Oh, it was pretty vandal resistant. Yeah. The one now, yeah, the one that's replaced the Hayden cabin trailhead marker has vandal resistant.
51:22 Fasteners. The old one did as well. Yeah, we went and looked at it. That's what I thought. Absolutely it did. Somebody had to have specialized equipment to get that sign off. But it's easy to buy. Yeah, but still. You know, I'm just concerned about the design. I do kind of like what Sandy was talking about is making sure that there really are three different areas where signs may need to be replaced. And in some of them, you know, I want to make sure that we're updating trails.
51:54 Well, I guess it's tough trying to coordinate when the trails are going to be effective, you know, hopefully at the end of the season. I just came across this in my professional life that, you know, we were about to change some things but realized, well, wait, more changes are coming. We really don't need that information until the spring anyway, so let's hold off on updating things until summer hiking season comes around and all the changes have been done. So I just want to make sure that we're paying.
52:23 Attention to that as well. Right, right, yeah. But having said that, we've gotten a little bit off from Bill's motion that you so eloquently. Yeah, I think, I think we're still there. I think we wanted to carry it. Well, Bill, basically, Bill just wanted to add design. Yeah. Okay, of the new maps to it. I have no problem. I will amend my motion to include the map design for updating the maps. Okay. Yep, second to that. And getting rid of the...
52:53 Just the other verbiage here. Because really we're looking at this as being a category we're going to carry forward every year. Yeah. And budget for. And which other verbiage are you wanting to get? You know, this installation up to. Okay. Yeah. In other words. We'll be replaced with the motion language, yeah. Yeah. Yeah, Steve's got the motion and that language from the motion should replace the language that's here. We don't need to have them repeated again. No. Nope. She's got a motion and a second.
53:22 Is there any further discussion? Anyone in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Okay, so that's the $3,000. Then we'll leave the $9,13 in place. Leave the $7,500 in place. I thought the $9,13 we were moving into the cost share agreement.
53:49 Just transferred over. So is that 221A going away? Did we discuss that? 221A goes away. We transfer the money, 221 goes away. We keep 490.1, but with the new verbiage. So we'll take those three to the Recreation Commission tomorrow for their approval. Well, what did we decide about the grants, though? Staying where it is. Oh, I see. To stay where it is until such time. We need it. Sounds good. We're just moving along.
54:28 So at this point, the rest of the business matters, but they should have four services. For new projects, do you have any? It would be helpful. Any committee, anybody have any new projects? I can help with those discussions. Pardon? I can help with those discussions. Great. Have a seat up at the... Do you wanted to do the, uh, Blake's Basin early opening one first, or? That might be the easiest one, huh? Wait for John to come, you know, maybe start with seven.
54:56 So Chair, it was suggested that we move up to number seven. I'm okay with that. Seeing no objections. Discuss and take action regarding the Lakes Basin early opening late fall closure project 571. Earlier on I gave you a handout with some additional information on costs for three yard and four yard dumpster removal. That question came from our last meeting as to a one time basis. What would it cost?
55:26 So the information that you have in front of you is kind of what staff's responsibility was to provide information for this discussion. The government closure made it difficult for us to continue gathering information. Fortunately, Pat's here today to talk further on the subject of keeping the lakes basin open later.
55:55 Allowing Restrooms and Trash Removal and Possibly Parking Lots to Remain Open and then hopefully in the spring we can get it opened earlier and provide trash, provide restrooms and provide parking prior to the concessionaires opening up the campgrounds. Question. The agenda item says discuss and take action.
56:20 I don't really see a program or some alternative programs that are really actionable. So do you have something in mind that is a program and a budget that we could actually forward to the rec commission? My hope was that we would have discussions today from the committee as well as the forest service and that you would maybe make a motion and move something forward.
56:48 You could take action and then give it to the Recreation Commission. If there is no understanding between the committee and the Forest Service, then you don't take any action. If there is an area to move forward, then we can do it. That was my request, actually, that I wanted the words, take action on the agenda. If we don't take any action, then we don't need to. But that way it allows us to, on the agenda, that if we get a great idea, that at least we can forward it to the Recreation Commission in a timely manner.
57:18 I was just going to be safe. Which I think is a good idea, actually. Yeah? Now? Okay. I did have some other questions on this. I asked him, and I didn't know if he'd had a chance yet. These prices are using Mammoth Disposals dumpsters. Are they willing to use Forest Service dumpsters, and is the price any different, or does it stay the same?
57:44 Yes, and the information I gave you today, there is a descriptor on a three and four yard one time dumpster removal, and that assumes that it is a U.S. Forest Service dumpster. And they would, so that removal, each occurrence, one time pickup, they dump it and put it right back in the same place. Correct. Well, yeah. Well, best of my knowledge, they,
58:11 They would dispose, for that fee, they would get rid of the garbage that's within it. Now, whether or not they have to run it off somewhere, or they have a larger truck they put it in, I'm not sure. But they did, when I did talk to the Mammoth's Disposal, I explained to them it was a U.S. Forest Service dumpster in the lakes basin that we were discussing. And that was the price that was given to me. And so we already use them? I mean, this is normally what they do, and this is what we pay for?
58:39 Okay, okay, so that answers my question. Pat, could you introduce yourself? Yeah, so I'm Pat McGurvey, and I'm filling in behind John Kazmierczki while he's down in Lone Pine. I'm the recreation staff officer for the Mammoth District. Thank you. It's nice to meet you. I met some of you, but. Nice to meet you. I haven't met you. Thank you for introducing yourself. Thank you. So you're here to answer questions. Yeah, I don't think I can make any decisions on anything, but I can help you guys, you know, answer some of these questions, I hope.
59:09 Okay, another question that we had. One, I want to make a comment. I went up into the Lake Basin when they were closing the campgrounds, government closure, and some of them were open and it made no sense. There was one at Lake George that was open and being used. There was one right on the road, Lake Mary, that was bolted shut. Talking about dumpsters now. Dumpsters. And yes, the people had put all their trash around the outside of the dumpster at Lake Mary and the trash.
59:37 Through the Ravens and the Bears, had been spread all over. Not something that we wanted to have happen. One of the potential solutions was for me to get out my, well, no, no. I came that close, folks. You've been sitting around the service too long. Yeah, that's right. I had plenty of tools in my vehicle with me. One of the things we had considered was, at the end of the season, having the Forest Service
1:00:05 Remove their dumpsters so that people didn't see them and just leave trash by the bolted dumpsters because the public doesn't get it. They don't understand why if a dumpster is there they can't put trash in it. And I happen to agree with them. So I don't know. Do you know? I'm stumbling all over myself. Has the Forest Service talked about any of those sorts of things? Well, you know, Steve brought that back to us after you guys discussed that or had that idea. And, you know, we haven't discussed it in depth.
1:00:35 Currently, those dumpsters are owned by Recreation Resource Management, the campground concessionaire. So when they're not in operation, they bolt them shut. So the three, we service three dumpsters year-round that have nothing to do with the campground concessionaire. Well, we pay Mammoth Disposal to deal with those.
1:00:56 So, you know, those three, I guess the Forest Service, if they wanted to, could move those around. We would have to work with our partner to move the ones in the campground, if that's where the concern is. And one of the spots that makes sense to move all that stuff might be that horseshoe pit, but as far as I hear, that's one of the last places that's accessible, so it might be a problem in spring to pull those back out. I'm not sure.
1:01:25 They make these wonderful things called snow plows. It makes everything accessible. Right. Bill? Well, as with Mr. Souser, I was up in the lake space after the closure, and I was watching what was going on at Twin Lakes and the dumpsters that are in place over by the bridge going across Twin Lakes. And there was nothing on the dumpster to indicate
1:01:52 That the dumpster was closed for the season, that there were alternative places, and please don't leave trash here. There was a little bolt in the corner of the lid, and that was it. And the very first thing I'd suggest is having the concessionaires at the end of the season, when they lock up the dumpster, put something on to tell it. I mean, people come up that really don't know. I saw somebody try to stuff a dog poo bag into the handle like it was a hole. They didn't know.
1:02:22 So without any, I mean, we'd love to. Can you tell me what dumpster that is? Because sometimes we use them. It was the left-hand one of the three of them. So anyway, I think the main thing is we assume that people are just stupid, but in fact they walk up, there's a dumpster. Absolutely. There's nothing evident to say that this dumpster is not used for the season anymore. And so.
1:02:49 You know, it'd really be, I think, informing our visitors is probably the most cost-effective, easiest step. And then if that doesn't work, then maybe we have to add something. Yeah, that's a pretty easy step. Yeah, like I said, I just looked at it and said, okay, I get this. There's three dumpsters here. Every one of them is bolted shut. And no word in it. And who knows? No information. Where are the three dumpsters the Forest Service maintains outside of the... There's one at Horseshoe.
1:03:19 Lake George, and then back at Duck Pass. What we're discussing here too is that obviously end of season, you know, from what I'm understanding, it's going to start here in the next week or two. I don't know how accurate that is, and I'm not a weather suit sayer, but, and then we're also talking about early spring. Over the winter,
1:03:48 Is there a lot of garbage that gets left at the dumpsters by people who are snowshoeing or cross-country skiing in? There is a fair amount. It's been told to me that trash, even when there's snow on the ground, gets left at the dumpsters. Yeah. And I've seen that myself in the past when I was allowed to use the Lakes Basin. I'm not allowed to. Okay. You would be if you... That's right, yes. ...motored. However, if we could work a deal...
1:04:17 Where the concessionaires would allow us a dumpster at each campground. It is my belief that being left open, those dumpsters would not fill over the course of a winter. Yeah, I can imagine. There's not that much generated. There's not that much traffic. So if we could leave one at Coldwater and at Lake Mary and at Pine City and at George, Twin Lakes gets taken care of by the mountain because of the tamarack thing.
1:04:45 I think it would go a long ways towards keeping our lakes basin clean. Those who do the lakes basin cleanup at the end of every year during the beach day or the coastal cleanup day can tell you that there's a lot of trash up there. And it's not all just the fishermen. It's the photographers. It's the dog walkers. And I think the whole thing could be solved by just leaving a trash can available in each one of those sites because they are obvious. They stick out of the snow.
1:05:14 Come spring, if we could find it in our budget, and we're not talking about millions of dollars here, to have disposal go up and dump each of those dumpsters, and then dump them on a one-time basis each time we call in, because it's full, I think we're talking a couple of thousand dollars. Then there's the three, you have three pit toilets still in the basin? Yeah, that's correct. And those are at? Those are,
1:05:42 I think, like, Twin Falls, Mamie, right there, and then there's one up at George, and there's another one on the backside of Mary. That's right by where the outlet from George comes into Mary. Right. And then, sorry, I'll just, so then those are under permit in the winter, Tamarack, so they service them and keep them open in the winter. So if we could spring and fall, in the fall as they close, get the permittees to put signs on the campground.
1:06:11 Bathrooms, they cannot be opened because of weather, those are all on the water system now, that they are closed with a map to the three opened bathrooms, that that could solve that whole issue. And again, if we had to, we could hire a maid service to do a weekly service of them. As the snowmobile club, we maintained the bathroom at Shady Rest, which gets a lot more use than these are going to get on an annual basis, cleaning it twice a week.
1:06:39 I don't see why this has to be such a hard thing to get to and why we have to talk about thousands of dollars and extra staff and everything else. It's just too simple. I agree, Bill. I think the communication has got to be the best and easiest thing we can do. Your comment about permittees, the concessionaires must be putting up the signs. I mean, I know you've already signed contracts with them that don't expire for...
1:07:05 You know, another several years. But is there any way in amending the contract to get this to happen this season? Well, they should. We review an annual operating plan every year. So that's somewhere where that could be put in there. Sure. And you know, if not, I'll volunteer Paul and myself to go and put the dates up at the end of the year. I was going to say, some of the restrooms we did sign this year, our temporary employees just saw the same problem that you were saying. They signed them themselves.
1:07:34 But to have something standard would be a good idea. And as far as servicing those restrooms, I know in the spring maybe it's an issue when Tamarac's closed and before we have personnel, but it seems like in the fall, you know, we have folks servicing those right now, and then we're going to swing the gate, and then Tamarac will service them. So I'm not sure where the gap is there unless we have a really long, dry fall. No, I think the gap is that people don't know where the serviceable bathrooms are.
1:08:04 But you were talking about a maid service of some kind. Right, because before the Forest Service has said that, they lose their part-time crew after a certain period of time, and that's who does that, so that there's a period in the fall and a period in the spring that they don't have staff to do it. That's the information we've been given. So I'm saying that I know that organizations have donated time to do it. I know that there are ways to get it cleaned.
1:08:31 Without paying for the Forest Service to bring on their temporary staff at a longer basis and cost, you know, it just shoots the cost of the program up huge. I think the main thing we need to develop actually is an operating plan for the late fall, in other words, the years that we have that late fall, and we've had them sometimes past Thanksgiving. I know that down in Meds Meadow it was horrendous, you know, the amount of traffic you can get, and Lakes Basin would be the same way.
1:09:00 But if we develop some sort of an operating plan for, in other words, with contingencies for the late fall or the early spring, in those situations, and I know that John Rigobroogie had mentioned to me that he would like to see an agreement. You know, so I think we probably need to look at the bigger picture. Do we want to do it? I think it sounds like, you know, we all do. And I think we've got enough information that, you know, it looks like we can definitely afford it in our budget.
1:09:29 Provide a real service, and especially just the signing by the permittees would really help a lot, signing and maps. Well, there's two things. One, you know, somehow, and we're spinning our wheels again. Yes. We need a program. We need somebody to negotiate it. I'm not sure. One of us could volunteer to do it, but I think on behalf of the town, it should be somebody that either the town manager or the town council says.
1:09:55 You know, you have the authority to go talk to the Forest Service or whomever to come up and develop a program. I think it's, I don't think we are empowered to do that. Well, I think we are. We've been talking about it for two years. I remember the council members saying, why aren't we doing it? Why aren't we doing it? That's why we're here. While I'm hearing somebody saying, you know, we'll do this. You know, if... I mean, do what? Drop a challenge cost here to work with the Forest Service? Well, sit down with the Forest Service.
1:10:24 You know, obviously, as I said right now, we don't have a proposal in front of us. We don't have a program. And the second thing, and I know I've brought this up before, is I'm still not willing to say yes, this comes out of the trails allocation. I may get there, but what I am interested in seeing is closure, you know, coming up with a program and moving forward. And I'd even volunteer to work on that.
1:10:48 To get us off the die. Well, I think, yeah, if it begins with a proposal. I'm going to look at Stu, actually, and say, procedurally for the town to initiate this kind of a program, what's the best way to do it? We write a letter. Is that a question or is...? It's a question. Oh, is that a question? Well, we would just meet with the Forest Service, really, I think, honestly. Yeah, write a letter. What we need to do and whatever they need to... Obviously, it needs to be actionable, so it needs to be some type of, you know, proposal. But who should do that? I mean, if we're... Well, it sounds like the town...
1:11:16 We're obviously representative of the town. It sounds like the town needs to submit a proposal, but for incorporation in the concessionaire's agreement that would include payment from the town for these services, I'm assuming, is what we're saying. Should town staff be leaving this charge? Do you want one of us to do it? Do you want to have Dan Holler suggest somebody? I'd draft the letter of proposal, you know, because I think it all starts with a letter of proposal, because we've been talking, talking, talking.
1:11:44 But, you know, just like we proposed before, other projects, we would draft a letter from the town manager's signature to the forest service saying, we would like to, you know, work with you to come up with contingent emergency plan, or planning, I should say, operations plans for the early opening or late closing. So you're going right to what I was asking. It should come from the town manager. Yeah. Okay. So we should, I'd like to make a motion that we ask the town manager to draft a letter
1:12:14 To the Forest Service, offering to sit down and prepare a work plan that we can then assign a budget to. And any necessary agreement. And, you know, consider it. And I would second that. And if you would amend that, that you and I would work with him on that letter, because we know the issue he doesn't, I would be happy to vote for that.
1:12:41 It could be me here. It could be you. I mean, it could be anybody. I would say whoever. Any one of us can draft the framework you guys plug in the figures and whatever, the ops plans. So we've got a motion. Yeah. That Bill Taylor and Bill Souser are going to work with the town manager to draft a proposal to the U.S. Forest Service to work specifically on dumpsters and, well, I'm sorry, to work specifically on the contracts.
1:13:07 With concessionaires. To work on resolving the issue. Okay. Not resolving, addressing the issue related to restrooms and trash disposal in the Lakes Basin after the campgrounds close and before they open. And before they open. Just a point of clarification, before we were also talking about the concept of parking.
1:13:31 Do we want that as well? No. Not for this. No. Not for my motion. Not for my swing at the gate, as you said, right? Not for my motion. Somebody else can make that. No. Let's keep it that way. Before we do a vote, because I know we've got a motion in a second, we're in discussion right now, I would just really like maps.
1:13:54 There's so many visual and so many foreigners that I think that it's important that, you know, with the sign that says this dumpster is closed, that there is a map that says here's where the dumpster is that's open. On the port-a-potties, here's where the port-a-potties that are open. Because we get so many foreigners who don't speak English and visual people who don't read English anyway. Those are the kind of things I think that would be addressed in our operations plans that we would develop. Okay. People that have visited Mammoth, Meridian, are no longer capable of reading.
1:14:24 Point taken. There you go. So we have a motion in a second. Is there any further discussion? Actually, I've got a discussion for you. So this is something that we are going to be able to work for for spring, hopefully for spring for the early opening. But as far as the next couple of weeks until these promised storms that Howard is telling us about,
1:14:51 Come in. We're not doing much right now. The status of the dumpsters is that they're currently bolted closed. Except for three. Except for those three, I explained, that are getting... And likewise with the port potties, there's the three pit toilets and that's it. And they're getting serviced. And there's no signs or maps on the doors currently. I believe on the bathrooms there are signs. Okay. But they need to be refined, like you're saying. They're a pretty simple map.
1:15:22 One other thought just in your discussions is I'd love to, especially since we've just got the one, everyone accesses the Lakes Mary Basin up there at the top of the road just above Tamarack, that's it. I would love to see a big pack it in, pack it out sign right there that makes it clear that if you're taking something in there, bring it out, don't use the dumpsters. I mean, yes, we'll have the dumpsters in there, but it should be, I mean, that's the main point of entry.
1:15:50 I can't think of a better place to put a big, fat, pack it in, pack it out sign. If I can just throw that up there. Does that mix a little bit? I mean, normally when we've got services at campgrounds, we don't have those type of signs, whereas, you know, trailheads and more, you know, off-country spots, we do have those signs. So I don't know if that mixes the message a little bit, you know? I think that if you only do it after the gate swung closed.
1:16:16 Yeah, so we've got that big sign right at Lake Mary. And I don't want to be dictating policy if you guys are going into something like this, but just say that I would see something as being helpful. Okay, any further discussion? I just have one other thing, Pat, not to pile on, but I was at Horseshoe Lake this last weekend and noticed that that dumpster that you do have has a carabiner on one side and nothing on the other, so a bear could very easily get in.
1:16:44 And the carabiner is just attached to two pieces of chain. So if I were a vandal and I wanted a carabiner, I could easily just take it off and put it in my pocket. So I might suggest that your maintenance people get weldable carabiners and weld them to the chain. And then the chains can be used then by the users of the dumpster. And the carabiners can be used. Okay. Okay, any further discussion?
1:17:13 You all know the motion in a second. I'm not going to repeat it, but all those in favor? Aye. Opposed? Motion carries. Good. We're moving forward. Okay, well, we're going back. Okay, we're going to go ahead and start on number six without Mr. Kazimierz here, but he may be joining us. But I think him and I have talked, and it sounds like he talked to Stu recently. And TJ's left, too. I don't know. Where did TJ go?
1:17:48 Okay, number six is discuss and take action regarding winter grooming program 551 cross country trail grooming at Shady Rest. And this is at the Shady Rest campground. Also on our master tractor, this project is identified and there has been in the past 2012-13 funding was approved for $20,000. Those contracts were signed.
1:18:17 $19,880 were paid for the service for that fiscal year. And then we have a placeholder of $20,000 this year that needs to have a final recommendation and move forward again to the Recreation Commission for final approval. So we're here today to explore options on cross-country grooming at the Shady Rest Campground for this next winter season.
1:18:47 I'm happy to say that we've had ongoing conversations over the last month with Friends of the Inyo, with Mammoth Nordic representatives, as well as the U.S. Forest Service. And I think we're all in conceptual agreement as to how to move forward. And so the parties are here today to present to you those items and allow for that discussion. Stu Brown's been involved.
1:19:10 Paul McFarland is here from Friends of Inyo, as well as their Executive Director, Laura Beardsley, and TJ was here. TJ was here representing the board of Mammoth Nordic, and I've been in touch with him as well. I might add, Steve, that no one from the Forest Service has talked to Mammoth Nordic, which is probably a pretty important point.
1:19:39 We've tried to get a hold of different players, but nobody from the board. Do you know different, Paul? No, I just know. Come sit next to me. Paul McFarland, Friends of the Inyo. I've spoken with the Mammoth Nordic President as well as members of their board and folks within the Forest Service. So in some ways we've had communication with that group through the Forest Service and telling them what's going on.
1:20:06 But for all intents and purposes right now, Mammoth Nordic is wishing to relinquish this opportunity. And that's how we came into the program, because about a week after your last meeting in September, I was contacted independently by a few people, some on the Mammoth Nordic Board, some from the town, some from other places, wanting to know if there was a possibility that Friends of the Inyo would be interested in helping with this issue to ensure that there would be
1:20:36 Free municipal grooming opportunities made available to the people of Mammoth on the ground. So at that time, I started calling some folks. I began talking with Steve Moore. I talked with Sarah Tomsky and some other people. Both, you know, I talked to leadership within the Forest Service as well as the people on the ground who we would rely on for helping this. Did a fair amount of research over the last month. I've learned more about...
1:21:00 Nordic skiing than I thought I ever would, as well as snow shoveling and changing the oil on a Peugeot, which is the engine in that thing. And TJ, I'd ask him to come today to kind of give some finality and sort of a blessing to what we've worked up outside of this room. But I can, with 100% assurance, tell you that Mammoth Nordic is ready to...
1:21:29 Pass this opportunity on for all intents and purposes. They may not be a going concern. And they are, to a person, committed to seeing this continue and apologize as an organization that this conversation didn't happen earlier. That's the message that has been conveyed to me. Thank you.
1:21:54 Before you jump down, Paul, I've got a couple quick questions. So is Mammoth Nordic willing to – I understood that Mammoth Nordic owned the Nordoni. They do, right. And are they willing to donate that so that there wouldn't be new capital costs or significant new capital costs? No, there would not be new capital costs. The only cost that would be related to the Nordoni would be ongoing fuel and maintenance. Right. But we wouldn't have to go out and buy new equipment.
1:22:24 No. The equipment would be transferred, and legally, as a non-profit, you are allowed only to transfer your goods, your capital investments, to another non-profit. Correct. Or you can trade them in, but then it'd have to stay with you. So that's where we jumped. So then, same question I asked the time before. We don't actually have a work program and budget yet.
1:22:54 We don't, and that's one of the things that I didn't even, when this first came forward, that was my main concern, is, you know, one, public expectation and available dollars, and where do those two meet? This is a time-intensive program. It's a program that is loved by a lot of people. It's a multi-use program. While it was intended to be simply a Nordic ski program, as anybody knows here,
1:23:22 Anything that's groomed is going to get walked on. And so this area is used by a lot of people. And I've been kind of amazed in the last few weeks at the level of passion people feel about this program. So at this time, you know, we worked up basically a budget that laid out
1:23:43 Levels of service, because I think those need to be agreed upon in the discussion that really needs to be had is where do the available funds and the potential levels of service meet? And then let's all make sure that together as partners, this project is well understood by the public as to what actually can be done out there. Because for the last number of years, this program was largely fueled by passion alone, largely from a single individual. That spark plug is not here right now anymore.
1:24:13 So in order to sustain what goes on out there, it's going to require a different level of community investment. Last year's program, from what I can gather, grooming was performed almost seven days a week. Financially, with the numbers we're looking at on the table, that's not possible. We're looking at potentially reduced levels of service. I think the critical part is to agree what those are going to be and how do we fund those costs. You know, the host program that was out there.
1:24:42 The hot chocolate, all the amenities that were provided, we're looking at potentially different programs, so where does this conversation meet that bright ridge where it works, where the funding and the expectations, and we can really lay out a quality program. I have some numbers here we can dive into, but before we do, we'd love to entertain more questions, and one thing I really need to make,
1:25:12 Fully clear, this has unfolded for us very fast, and we are still working through internal issues and approval processes for these. Almost every day something new comes up, such as today I finally was able to find out what our additional liability coverage would be, because to take this on is different than our trail work, and we also would have to provide additionally insured for a number of parties.
1:25:37 So everything is still in flux. This is still in flux for us internally, but as you keep mentioning, the snow's coming, and hopefully this is a time that we don't have to spend as much time on process. We can focus on the product. Now, Paul, I have a question. In your discussions with the Forest Service, I guess with Sarah, will you basically just fill in? You have a challenge cost share already with the Forest Service. We actually work under a, for our,
1:26:07 Projects in Mammoth, we work under a sponsored volunteer group. A sponsored volunteer, so would you, and I believe Brian had a challenge cost share? A challenge cost share that expired in October 2014. Would you be able to assume that, or would you have to develop a new agreement, or work under your sponsored volunteer agreement? Potentially an initial look, and Patrick, please correct me if I'm wrong, but an initial look looks like with the number of agreements that are in place, there is room to make this work now. Okay. Unless you,
1:26:37 That's what Sarah and I discussed. Yeah, I mean, it does look like we set it up so that other volunteers, Forest Service volunteers, could use this equipment. Exactly. But I think, you know, we need to figure that out and make sure everybody's comfortable, like you said, liability and that kind of stuff. Yeah, but I guess my concern and John R's concern, you know, how does Mammoth Nordic...
1:27:06 I mean, they have bylaws and things like that. I'm assuming when they kind of are dissolving, are they in the process of that? That's what I'm having a hard time seeing. Do they still exist? Do we keep this? Because if they don't exist, I don't know that we should have an agreement with them. They still exist on paper. Dissolving of a non-profit, you have to go through corporate dissolution proceedings. They have standard bylaws. All that stuff is in place.
1:27:31 One active board member who was TJ, who actually has been invaluable in this process in digging up the information and providing it. So they are not defunct organizationally, so your paperwork is still in force. Okay. In terms of functionality, coming to meetings, providing this service, that's beyond the scope of what they're able to do at this point. So we could be looking at you as a temporary or long term. Well, I think it would be important.
1:27:59 Just for clarity that they not, I mean, if they have a challenge cost share agreement that they terminate that agreement. The issue is one of timing. The challenge cost shares that I've worked on have taken an inordinate amount of time and that's only gotten worse as the staffing levels have decreased. So if there is a way...
1:28:20 That this can be moved forward using existing paperwork. I think it's the only way we're looking at Grady this season. I totally agree with you, though. So how then would essentially Friends of the Inyo step in as agent of Mammoth Nordic? That's how it's looking right now. I mean, just finding a copy of the Challenge Cost Share took weeks. So, you know, we're scrambling to put the pieces together.
1:28:48 These are very good questions, but if we're looking to get something on the ground, you know, I don't know, Patrick, unless there's some kind of light speed process we could find, which would be great. I haven't seen that since I've been here. It's weird, it's happened a few times. We might, you know, you might share, you know, this cost share agreement does expire after this winter season, so, you know, there's more work to be done, but...
1:29:16 Perhaps a letter from Mammoth Nordic requesting that... Yeah, that's definitely going to be some kind of official communication. Right, something like that in writing, I would think, would allow maybe you to, you know, you look at it as a temporary fill for this year, performing their duties, and with the Forest Service blessing, figuring out how to do it, and then... What do you need from us to help move this forward? I think it is, for us, we're working through our internal process to see if...
1:29:44 This is something that we have our board's blessing to pursue. As staff, what we have worked up is some budget numbers. I mean, really, that's where the rubber hits the road on this. We need to mutually determine what level of service we wish to provide and ensure that the funding is there to do it because I'm a conservative person by nature.
1:30:08 Don't want any of us to be caught in the middle of January. What I'm going to get to is we have $20,000. I know you have $20,000. $20,000 will give you a 10-week program. Okay. At five days a week of service. Five days is the minimum service amount. The discussions that I've had with various Nordic skiers, other people, that provides a quality experience. And one of the reasons you need five days is because the path is multi-use. Because you have people walking literally on the track.
1:30:37 But I think that should continue. I don't think we should go to a single use just to save money. So what we've worked up is simply this is a 17-week budget from December 1st to March 31st. And these numbers, again, this is a ceiling. These would all be
1:31:06 Billable. So if the season was terrible, we didn't get a lot of snow, and we only ended up grooming two days a week, these costs would be much less. But what we've laid out is the minimum pieces that I think need to do there as a point to start discussion. Go ahead, Sean. Well, I just want to, and John, thank you. You really started without you, but you've been well represented. Just to understand,
1:31:35 The way it was explained to me last year is that even when the snow is not good is when you need more grooming. Is that accurate? Yes, it is accurate because the track breaks down through simple freeze thaw as also people walking on it. Okay. So that's why, you know, for me, this is a new area. Myself as well. Yeah. And so we're learning a lot from scratch.
1:32:01 Well, it's going to have to play it a bit by ear as it rolls out. But the nice thing is I've been in contact with Brian's right-hand man, Keith Dolly. He's the only other person that's really fully proficient at driving this machine as well as maintaining it. And him as well as all the other folks I've talked to who have experience with this program are willing to offer a hand. So we have a huge amount of help to draw from.
1:32:25 There was a lot of goodwill built up over the five years this program was going, and it's now coming to the fore to keep it alive. So we're not starting from scratch. We've got some people who know what they're doing. Yeah, that's right. So I'll walk you through this really quick. Basically, like I said, this is predicated on five days a week, 17 weeks. These numbers can all move. This is just where it starts. The professional groomer, that's someone who's paid and trained to show up at 4.30 in the morning, shovel out,
1:32:55 The Machine. If there's a huge dump, sometimes it takes you two hours to get it out of the shed even. And this is estimating four hours of grooming time. Some days it's eight, some days it's two. But on average, I was able to find four hours is what the run time was on the machine per day. And this again is for 20 hours a week, at four hours a day, it's 17 weeks. And then for grooming maintenance time,
1:33:24 Basically, this is just an estimate of 10% of run hours for maintenance. That's oil changes, fixing the track, doing all the other things to keep this machine rolling. And so that's 10% of whatever total grooming hours we land on. Partner coordination, scheduling, and outreach, that's standing here in front of you all, working with the Forest Service, working with volunteers. One component that really came forward as a highlight was the host program.
1:33:53 That was all volunteer run. That would take coordination time. We've conservatively estimated 10 hours a week for 19 weeks. The program runs ideally for 17. That leaves a week on either side to work on paperwork, cost shares, cleaning up, setting up the track. Fuel maintenance and supplies, I put $4,700 in there because that was the amount that was in the original Mammoth Nordic request.
1:34:20 And I always think that it's good to overestimate your maintenance supplies. Many of the parts for this machine are, you know, unique and expensive. Supplies, directional signage, snow poles, maps, really a nominal amount, pretty simple. And then general liability. This is based on numbers provided by Mammoth Nordic for a liability policy through the National Nordic Ski Center, which is an association of non-profits that provide grooming and education. We would have to join that group.
1:34:50 And then get a policy. We have not been able to talk to the insurance person because I just learned his name this morning. So that number is up and down. That is just an estimate that based on what Mammoth Nordic's policy was, this is what I think it may add to our general liability. And then that totals for a 17-week program down to $28,390. And then we...
1:35:16 Generally, for all our contracts, have a 10% administration cost thrown onto the top to the subtotal. We're willing to provide that cost as a match to see this program continue. I'm sorry, what was that? We're willing to provide that 10% administration cost as a match. That's that bottom line. So you're saying that we need to come up with the 29.3?
1:35:37 28, 390. Well, that's a number, again, predicated on having a 17-week program at five days a week. If there's something you'd like to see different, that number can move. But for a 17-week program, that's the conservative cost estimate we've come forward with. That's the ceiling. You mentioned that people are very passionate about this program and it has a lot of interest in people. It does. Have you passed the tin cup? I have not passed the tin cup. We passed the tin cup to keep the lights on.
1:36:07 Every day. That's how we do this. So we have not done that yet. I will tell you that last year, with the cut being passed exceedingly aggressively by Brian and others within Mammoth Nordic, they made enough to cover fuels and supplies. That was it, huh? Yeah. And as anybody, you all know, you're all involved in local nonprofits. I mean, it's shoe leather work, and it takes time.
1:36:39 And they had a lot of fundraisers, I know. They do. And as for our organization, unrestricted fundraising is always a challenge, as it is for everyone. So it's something that if this were to go forward, it's something we would definitely consider simply to sustain the program and also to expand it because these numbers are also only for grooming the outside loop. The interior shortcuts are logistically very difficult and will raise the cost until we all really learn.
1:37:09 What we're doing. How to do it. I understand. Machine doesn't back up even. That's what I understand. It doesn't back up. No. But, you know, Bill, you're right. And it's something that we're all going to have to commit to together to making it. But at this time, it's very organizationally difficult for us to take on a new fundraising challenge for unrestricted funds to fund a new program. We've got to keep the other things we're doing. No, I was just thinking that if you specifically had individuals who said, we love this and
1:37:37 We really want to see it happen that they become natural targets. We are praying for that and we are in target acquisition mode. And with regard to the difficulty, as I told Brian last year, I am much more familiar with grooming that trail system than I wish I was. There's a target, there's a target. I know, I picked out the easy marks. And I, you know, I have,
1:38:03 Because I did it for years. Yeah, I did. And so I understand the problems with trying to run the equipment. The new equipment is obviously, you know, superior to the old EDU that we had, but it's still...
1:38:20 I do understand what it takes, and it's definitely labor intensive. I've got to tell you that I actually think the 10% for maintenance is probably going to turn out to be low. Fortunately, I think the partner coordination number is probably going to turn out to be a little high, so those may balance. And I'm not going to sit here and nitpick. I mean, as long as the estimates work out in the end, it doesn't really matter. Sorry. I just want to add, I mean, I knew you were talking. This is Laura Beards, Liam.
1:38:49 I just want to add with the fundraising part, you know, you just referred to partner coordination, scheduling, and outreach line item, and that outreach is really what's going to help us to identify and really bring in those people that are passionate about the program and want to see it continue by giving their funding to do so.
1:39:17 I think that's something to consider when you're looking at that overall. Will Barbara Richter continue to be involved? Because, I mean, Barbara was a spark plug for this. I mean, she was a wonderful asset.
1:39:29 She was, and she's one of the people who was very happy to hear that this was going. I have no firm commitments from anybody because I didn't want to raise expectations. We internally don't even have 100% go-ahead that we can – It's still – So we're still – Yeah. We're still all in this together, but people like that that you've known and who provided the friendly face out there, you know, they're there. So thanks, Bill, for the 10% concern. That was – I had a question – one more question. When you say grooming only the outside loop, is it just the one trail then?
1:39:59 It's the one trail on the outside, yeah, because what I've been able to find is that the machine gets stuck more on the inside than it did on the outside, and grooming that inside loop was more technical, and the snow conditions on the inside made it harder to do, so the four hour a day estimate was predicated on the one loop, unless you have a driver like Keith who really knows what they're doing, the snow conditions are bomber, and then we can open up that middle loop. Okay.
1:40:26 So there's potential for opening up more. There is a potential, but one of the things I really want to be cautious of is not setting expectations beyond what we can deliver, because collectively I want none of us to get in that situation, because so often that's what eats our lunch. Yeah. You know, not the goodwill, but not being able to deliver on what the expectation has become. Agreed with that. So? Originally, I don't know if you guys have thought about this or not, but two years ago,
1:40:56 When Ryan wasn't able to run it for, you know, legitimate reasons, the town made an offer that the town would lease the equipment from him for a buck for the year and then hire drivers, Keith, as I've talked to him, to drive and then that eliminates the insurance issues and the town already has some cost share agreements going with the Forest Service and then that would leave on your part the
1:41:25 Coordination and outreach, that's an important piece of it. If this comes to fruition and you end up with the machine, if something like that was necessary to keep the price in line, would you be willing to go there? I still don't know why Mammoth Nordic was not willing to go there. So this is the first I've heard of that offer. Basically what would happen then is the machine would be available for use and then the town would pay one of their staff to drive the machine.
1:41:55 Correct. Okay. The town, with these trails monies, the town would hire a part-time driver to drive and maintain the equipment, or perhaps even the maintenance could be done by the town staff out of funds that are already there. You know, you're looking for how to... Exactly, yeah, how to make a balance. To create that balance. I think as long as there was a mutually agreed upon...
1:42:24 Minimum days of service for a given time frame, you know, that's a potential. I think if we were going to get into that, that would be a longer discussion to figure out how the logistics would actually work because a lot of other things change too. There's a lot of discussion that has to go into the whole thing still. We're starting six months too late. Yeah, I know. And that's just one of the potential considerations. Something else, we were talking about the inner loop and of course the problem with the inner loop are the tighter corners.
1:42:55 Perhaps it would behoove us, and maybe the Forest Service would be willing to work with us, to create another loop that is like the outside loop, and there's enough road and open area to make that happen, to expand the system without having the tightness of the inside loop. You know, the one thing that was interesting, and I didn't really appreciate this until I talked to some people who actually used that facility as a Nordic training facility,
1:43:21 The inside loop provides the best terrain from a training standpoint as it's laid out. So any changes to this, you know, I, and I, I, I ski on the east side of 395, I don't know. Would you guys, would you be looking at the hiring Keith Dahle? He's one of the people who we discussed and he expressed an interest. And he would be an excellent trainer it sounds like. He would be, but he's not looking, as many people aren't in the winter, for a full-time commitment. Everybody wants a pretty limited.
1:43:51 Role. Right. Okay. So, but he has expressed, you know, strong interest in keeping it alive. So, and he's one of the people who I've approached because we couldn't do it without his experience and he was willing to take on a role in helping. So, right. So, um, so a key component of this poll and now that John's here is the challenge cost your agreement. Yes, thanks. And it is held by men of the week who have that agreement and it's in place until October 2014. So,
1:44:21 What we're seeing is the kind of easier way to go, which John and I talked about, is how the Forest Service is satisfied by Mammoth Nordic and the Friends of the Inyo proposal. We had a chat about that on Friday. Maybe John can kind of elaborate on what those requirements would be to satisfy the Forest Service and the agreement. And then where Bill was going is kind of the next step. So once that challenge cost share agreement is expired,
1:44:47 Then what? And I think that's probably what we would then come back at, start to look at some long-term or sustainable solutions. You know, how the town can get involved, you know, then the permits with the town, or is it still with Frenzino? But I think, you know, those discussions, you know, we want to try and elaborate on. But I think the priority here is really getting this program going with the time that we have. I mean, because it's really, could be next week, next month. It's a lot of power. Fingers crossed. So maybe, John, you could just elaborate a little bit on...
1:45:15 And what would satisfy the Forest Service in regards to this agreement. Okay, and I'll try not to blast everyone out with the microphone. You know, you all make me a little nervous sitting here because most of the people that I've known who've sat in this row, many of them haven't stayed in this town that long. So I'm a little nervous about that. I think just some spots with Pat. I think the attorney's... Well, he's leaving anyway, so we'll do that. You've lived your worst, John. Yeah, just to...
1:45:44 Get to the point. The challenge cost share agreement is with Mammoth Nordic and it does allow for us to sign up volunteers or employees. So the biggest thing that I think needs to happen for us to be satisfied for working with some other parties is we really need to hear from Mammoth Nordic that they're okay and in the ideal world that would be in writing.
1:46:15 Not made much progress trying to get hold of some folks. I understand their board is a little bit scattered, or maybe what was their board when we negotiated the challenge cost share is no longer their board. The biggest reason why that's an issue is they own the equipment, and unless someone else shows me a title that says this piece doesn't belong to Mammoth Nordic, it belongs to me now, then we'd be happy to work with that person.
1:46:42 Our agreement says it'd be stored in our garage. It is stored in our garage. But for us to move forward, we really need to get concurrence that Mammoth Nordic is okay because the Forest Service does not want to buy that machine when someone else breaks it, acting in good faith, trying to operate. So I think everything else that I've heard, we're willing to work with people and all these things can come together in a variety of ways. But we just need that communication from Mammoth Nordic, as I shared with you last week, Stu.
1:47:12 Those transfers have all been first a minute away. I'd like to go back to the question that I asked earlier, which is what you need from us so that this can continue to move forward, if anything, at this meeting. I mean, I realize you need money before you can actually turn the key on the Nordoni, but what else? What's the timing? What do you need? I think at this point,
1:47:42 You know, we've put forward what we think costs are for a 17-week program to know, and I know you have $20,000 on the table, to know what's available. Is $20,000 a ceiling? Is there the ability to move? Is there the support of this body to continue to go forward? I think that's what we're looking for. As far as all the parts that John has just laid out, those can be handled. Thank you for laying that out so clearly.
1:48:11 I think that's what we're looking for for you. Unless, Laura, do you have anything to add? We're looking to see what we can deliver. Our costs are here. We're looking to see what we can deliver for the amount that's available. And I think from the perspective of our board, for them to, and for us to be able to take this on, obviously, we have to have their agreement.
1:48:38 I think it's really important to make sure that the expectation of what can be delivered for what is available is really well lined up so that we are, as Paul said, not sort of hitting ourselves mid-season and finding out that we've well exceeded our budget and our time capacity to make sure that we're providing a really good quality experience for residents and visitors to use these.
1:49:08 What I'd probably recommend from the Town's point of view is to have those agreements ratified in some form from the Forest Service with Friends of the Inyo and Mammoth Nordic. We'd get a proposal officially back from Friends of the Inyo to MLTCC that we can actually move an action on and maybe that could be a little bit of discussion. We'll work together on that.
1:49:33 With those levels of service and maybe we can put some alternatives in here at some scale to the project and have that back. December 9 is our next meeting. I don't know if that's too late. Too late. We really need something that's actionable. We really need to make sure that the Forest Service is being satisfied first. But that's probably our next step unless we want to commit to going with that money. But there's no proposal yet. We haven't satisfied the agreement. So I think we need to kind of follow this step. And I think we want to move it forward. I think there's intent.
1:50:03 I think we're absolutely behind it. But I think we just have to follow that cheap process. Do you think we could do a tentative, in other words, approval? Could we provisionally authorize the $20,000, and then as the program, that gives you something to start with and gives you 12 weeks. It does. My one concern with that is I don't want to be in a place where all of a sudden we have a room full of people advocating to find more money to keep something going.
1:50:32 Let's come up with an agreed upon level of service, I think, now before it becomes, I just, you know. I like the idea of committing the $20,000. We have it there. I'm uncomfortable with trying to find more money than that today. I would also be comfortable with starting the program on the 15th of December and going through the 15th of March. Rarely do we have the kind of snow necessary to create quality.
1:51:00 Cross Country Ski Program, or Snowmobile Program, for that matter, prior to or after those dates, without grooming on an hourly basis. That cuts almost $3,000 off the program and gives us a few more weeks to get the program ready and to get it going. Because there is the volunteer piece in terms of the
1:51:29 What do we call them out there? The trail stewards? Well, and that's, you know, the hosts out there, this is simply to provide the grooming, the hosts, and that, you know, that, if people come forward and that materializes, that's great, but I want to make sure that. There is another Nordic group out there. I don't know if you had a chance to meet with any of them or with theirs. No, this has all happened exceedingly, exceedingly fast. We were actually contacted. I would be very comfortable with giving the $20,000 and shortening the season by four weeks.
1:51:57 And if we run out of money prior to that, then we run out of money prior to that. If we have money left, or if things go better than we hoped, or if we alter it in such a way to find money savings, then we do it. But I think that for today's purposes, that would get us, in fact, I would even make that motion that we allocate the $20,000 on a tentative schedule from December 15th to March 15th, and that we meet.
1:52:27 Back here again and hammer out the details. That definitively spends the money on the program so they should feel comfortable moving forward and knowing what they have to move forward with. The only other trigger date that comes forward is we have our next in-person Friends of the Inyo board meeting on November 15. So that's the day where we would have full go-ahead to accept funds and move forward with that.
1:52:56 Yeah, because we approve it doesn't mean you have to accept it. No, I know. I just want to lay that out there with full disclosure. I mean, we spend enough time in these rooms, let's make it valuable. So the motion that's on that has been proposed, and it sounds like we need to take a second before we go forward with any discussion, and I do have quite a few questions. Essentially, it's shortening your proposal here. Essentially, by four weeks from 17...
1:53:24 To 13 weeks, December 15th through March 15th. You're asking for $28,390. You're doing math right now. It's $1,700 a week. Times 12 or times 13? Times 12 will take that number off. At 13 weeks, the subtotal with fuels of maintenance staying static goes down to $23,710. How much? $23,710.
1:53:55 And that's with fuel remaining static. That's with coordination, grooming time, and grooming maintenance all fluctuating based on the time change. So that takes us. And one thing that I don't know if your motion included was essentially that we are proposing these funds provided that the Forest Service and Friends of the Inyo. That has to be conditional. Yeah, that has to be conditional. I just didn't hear your motion. Yeah, it needs to be part of that motion.
1:54:22 You don't see any major roadblocks this time provided that we get the status of Mammoth Nordic satisfied. That's correct. Thank you. Friends of the Inyo would do this. We would not be involved in that. Yep. Yep. Exactly. Just in point of order. I think I'll go ahead and second for the purposes of discussion. I guess everybody jumped into the discussion. Okay. Yeah. Thank you for... I would actually...
1:54:50 Being I'm a trail user for the first time ever last year, okay, and it was a wonderful experience. That's what I've heard. And I think we have some good skiing in March. As a matter of fact, our biathlon is the last week in March. So I guess I really would like to see us go up to the maybe NTE 28 390, knowing that we do have some money. And then if it doesn't, if the snow doesn't come, obviously,
1:55:20 If it doesn't come until December the 1st or December the 15th or whatever, the charges would be less. But I sure would like to see it. You know, I mean, I think they're going to go to a lot of work for 13 weeks. 13 weeks isn't much. Having actually run a Winterfest twice out of Shady Rest on the third weekend of March, I will tell you that 90% of the time pavement is showing.
1:55:50 On several of the campground loops by then. Yes, we do have, yes, we can have some things. The Norgoni is not capable of moving snow. It's only capable of laying track. So without blades and everything else, I think on an average winter, the last two weeks of March are more cost than you're going to gain out of running the program at that point. Given that we're all praying for a phenomenal winter. Quick question. It is on December 9th. Mm-hmm. Thank you.
1:56:21 And we may well find that the program runs smoother and costs less than we're anticipating. So I'm pretty comfortable with the $20,000 figure. And it's time and materials, I'm assuming. It'll just be a monthly invoice? It's a billable invoice, just like all the contracts. So there you go. So I mean, it's something that we can keep track of, and if there's additional funds available, or likewise, you know, we can reallocate funds, you know, later on. So if it is an exceptional winter and we want to extend, we've utilized the funds, we'll be back in front of the committee.
1:56:51 Looking at what we have available at town. Thanks. I think it's great. So thank you. You're welcome. Yeah, thank you very much. I really, really appreciate that. You're welcome. And to Steve, it's the Forest Service for your flexibility, obviously, and working with everybody. Yeah, Steve has been a catalyst. Yeah. It's fun. And it's a good thing for the town. Thank you for investing in it. So we would then go back and revisit if we have an early winter. Is that what I'm hearing? In other words, Bill, you're not...
1:57:20 In other words, if we had a fabulous winter, whatever, you're not saying, whoa, we can't go above 20,000 if we had extra money? No, no, no. You've known me long enough to know that I don't write things in stone. Okay. Then I will do it. The world is not black and white. Okay. The world is definitely out. I just wanted to hear you say it. I know that, but I just wanted to hear it. That's in the minutes. That's in the minutes, right. Well, thank you all very much. So the motion before us is essentially not to exceed 20,000 at this time. We have a proposed amended.
1:57:50 Schedule December 15th through March 15th. This is a recommendation to the recommendation pending. Everything gets worked out. Our board's approval. Are you comfortable being locked in December 15th, even if we get great storms? To be honest, it gives us more time. A little more time to prepare. Yeah. We're getting December 1st.
1:58:20 Because we're praying the next week's storms show up. We didn't want to jinx it by kicking it back, but no, December 15th. Create that desire, you know. Yes. I was going to relax my skis. We need to wait until the 15th. Exactly. I just want to pack it in, pack it out, make sure it's in aluminum. It's a lot lighter. There you go. Thank you. Good point. That's exactly the kind of contingency that might necessitate you coming back. I know. So, you know, and I think we're all comfortable with that.
1:58:49 And I think we are open to it, but at this time, motion, it's here. Okay. Enough to get going. Can I call for the motion? Yep. That's where I was going back. Go for a vote. All those in favor? Aye. Aye. And I do want to quickly say, too, just jump in. It was, I did a press release for this way back then with the town and Mammoth Nautic, and it was just that kind of town, you know, public partnership, and now it's obviously evolving even further. I mean, now you've got...
1:59:18 The town, you've got our federal partners, you've got an additional, you know, non-profit organization. So now it's taking, you know, four plus organizations and a committee to pull this together. So I mean, it's just a fabulous community-wide, you know, partnership. So I think it's great. Thanks for everyone. And thank you guys. Putting it together. And thank you, board, for taking this on. I know it's kind of out of your line, but I mean, maybe you'll like it. I think it ties into it. Yes. I think it ties into it. Thank you. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Great.
1:59:56 So, Mr. Spidell, does that cover all our business matters except for number nine? It looks as though that's true. I do have some additional information to pass on. But, yeah, I guess we're at number nine. Okay, should we save that? Yeah, let's save that then for any kind of staff reports. New projects. This is an agenda item for anything that needs to come forward from either individuals from the audience or this committee.
2:00:27 I think that was a good new project. Yeah. I think that's a great new project. I think we're good with new projects. Yeah. I've got one that I'd like to just ask if it's a possibility, and I'm not sure if it is, but just something that I've been wanting to actually put, or at least open up, is, boy, the McMurray bike path, and I'm living up off of adjusted pines. I've been riding a lot this summer. There is a strip of just dirt and gravel that is essentially between the bike path and
2:00:56 And Lake Mary Road that goes up in there. And I was wondering if there's any way of, and I just want to throw this out there, as far as getting any kind of native plants in that strip. Because right now it's just dusty and if any bicyclist skids out, kicks rocks into it. And I know there's a lot of native flowers that do bloom with very little irrigation.
2:01:21 And taking the cue from what Elizabeth Tenney did with the U.S. Postal Service, with the U.S., the Post Office. I wonder if there's any way, I had no idea what the cost would be, but I just wanted to throw it out there with regard to new projects and getting that trail beautification project looked into. I don't know what a budget would be involved in that, but just getting some kind of native plants that do not require irrigation.
2:01:49 And can strip. And can live under four inches of rote cinders. I think the guy sitting next to you has a wife that can give all the answers to that. She could give a lot of answers, for sure. She's the native plant person that grows them. I know that we buy them. Okay. Yeah.
2:02:10 I just wanted to throw that out there. Maybe rough size, you know, find out what the rough size is and Sherry can tell. Again, that is such a picture perfect and I'm amazed, you know, in my writing of it, how many people are stopping taking pictures. It'd be great to have some kind of native plants, at least just on that strip. How big a strip do you think it is in square footage? What are we talking about? Oh boy. Well, here's where I would like to actually propose again. I'm going to say about somewhere 20 to 30,000 square feet total.
2:02:39 Okay, you know, right. We'll talk about that because I've noticed there's a lot of native plants. It's two miles long and five feet wide. Go for it. 25,000 square feet. The whole way? I thought they were just one little strips you were talking about. Well, no, and it is about five feet wide, but essentially it does kind of have a bit of a groove that comes together. And it would be worth talking also. I mean, there's talking with public works and people who designed that because that strip serves a function.
2:03:09 Yes, it does. So we just need to make sure. Whether you can actually shrub it and actually put a barrier there of some description, right? Well, we can also talk to our landscape coordinator, landscape architect, trails coordinator. The purpose of this business matter is just to bring new projects forward. To try and come up with solutions. Love it. That's the purpose of my suggestion. He helped us design the one at the community center, the native. This guy. And we bought the plants from Sherry.
2:03:38 Well, I think we have quite a bit on that already because Nordic skiing is obviously coming back. And our updates to the tracking list are obviously coming back. Any other items? With that, let's close number nine. Discuss future agenda items. December 9th was delayed due to the holidays. What's the holiday in the beginning of December? Oh, the thing called Thanksgiving. Oh, just because it's the last weekend? Okay.
2:04:16 Did we do the same, Stuart? I think you did, didn't you? No, Bill. I think the issue is it's December 7th, and that's our recommendations, I believe, or the start of our applicant presentations. Oh, that's right. So we had to really stay on schedule to fit in the timeline. So we did not change. We're on our existing schedule. Which is going to be November, I'm sorry, December 2nd? No, December 3rd is the Tuesday.
2:04:47 Yep. So that's when the Recreation Commission is? And, yeah, that's our joint meeting with the Measure U Committee, too. Okay. Yep. Well, my only concern is just I do like having this meeting immediately before the Recreation Commission meeting, but if that's already set up, I don't know if there's, you know, a real need to change it at this point. Are there any future agenda items that are coming before us on December 9th that may need to be considered by the Recreation Commission?
2:05:17 December 3rd because that would delay things. Probably the draft proposal for Lakes Basin toilets and dumpsters. I don't know if we'd be ready by then for that. You don't think as far as a proposal letter to the Forest Service? Even if we were, we're going to be in the middle of winter, so it's not date critical. We'll work on it. But I don't think that that's a critical path item as far as... We'll have to get it started, though.
2:05:47 Well, oh, but we'll, all we need is, I mean, the direction was, you know, if we get support from Dan Holler to move forward, then we move forward on working on that. So that part, I think we're good on. Well, I was trying to, you know, John, I was under the impression that you would like an agreement, though, is that correct, if we do the Lakes Basin, some sort of an agreement for the early opening, late closing?
2:06:19 So, yeah, I think that's what we were talking about before John was here is, you know, starting that discussion with the letter or proposal, I guess. Right. Instead of the way. Exactly. It would really just be the letter first, which would kind of formalize some type of, you know, discussion and then look at the proposals, I think is what we were really talking about. Would you say a challenge cost share or? I was going to talk to John after. Oh, yeah. Yeah, same thing. Yep.
2:06:43 Yeah, it would, real quick, it would seem to me there'd be a variety of ways to do that, and so sorting it out a little bit would probably be helpful before getting, before trying to write things in stone for bills purposes. Okay. Okay. May have to, blood. We're hoping that they will assign two bills to talk to you about it. So, I don't know what you did wrong in a former life, John.
2:07:11 Whatever it is, we can handle it. Okay, so any further discussion with regard to future agenda items, meeting dates, staff reports. Staff reports. What I'd like to do is let you know that I received an email today starting the review process for the additional web pages that we're getting added to the website.
2:07:39 So today a linkage to 12 destination pages was sent and we're using that as a test model and the additional up to about 190 pages in total will be coming probably on Wednesday. So I just want to let you know that we're in that process of review. We've identified people within the town whose responsibility it will be to review that. We've also notified the Forest Service as being our website partner that this
2:08:08 Review will be coming along and their comments will come to me two weeks from Wednesday and then we'll consolidate that also with comments coming from Mammoth Lakes Tourism, also a partner on the website and then we'll convey that as one document to MLTPA for consideration and adjustment before issuing the final pages. So we're on track. What's the agenda for that or what's the timeline for that?
2:08:38 Basically, two weeks after this coming Wednesday, we are challenged by getting our review comments to MLTPA. And then there is an overall 90-day contract period, and I'm not exactly sure, I think somewhere like December 15th or something like that, when the total project will be completed. I thought the contract went through next Tuesday. Maybe it's been extended, I don't know.
2:09:06 Bill, you would probably know that. I thought I read in all of the information we got that that part of that contract had been gone through November. Maybe it was December. I don't know. As I recall, it was December. It was 90 days. So we had ample time and we're on that track. So a staff report on that. And then I was hoping with the Forest Service here today that maybe we could get...
2:09:35 A report on the SHARP progress. We were billed about $20,000 the other day and authorized that for payment. Also the Shady Rest Trailhead proposal and then any of the projects that are on the SOPA list that I handed out earlier that might be helpful to have a Forest Service discussion about those. Well, I can start sharing maybe about SHARPs. We've done a lot of resource
2:10:07 We have our specialists out in the field through the summer and fall. So they're compiling their reports so that we've got all that information as we proceed. And the same for Sarbanes up in Lakes Basin. So that pretty much included wildlife, hydrology, soils, and archaeology. And botany as well. There was a question early in the summer as to whether all the botany would be able to be completed on all the trail segments.
2:10:38 Before the little annuals all went dormant. And do you know if the botanists were able to get to all the trail segments? Yeah, from the reports they gave me, they did get to all the trail segments. And a lot of that had to do with them getting started before we got the money, basically. Great, well, thank you. That's good. That's great.
2:11:08 So on that, Pat, do we have some milestones to look forward to? Well, I'll be working with John to transition to John and, you know, just kind of summarizing where we're at, what information we have, and then looking again at the proposal that, I don't know if it was this group or the Sharps group, I guess, put one together and then the town with the other proposal and seeing what works or what, you know, any...
2:11:38 Red flags or anything like that after looking at all those resources. Would you agree with that, John? Yes. When do you see a draft EA potentially? Would that be like in the spring? Probably not. I apologize. We might be a little ahead of ourselves. I'm not aware that we've committed to a specific proposed action to take through NEPA within that, but to investigate.
2:12:11 Those alignments, and I think there's a lot of discussion that still needs to be had before we move something forward for a decision, unless I'm missing something. I guess we need to have the discussion. Yeah, I mean, what we want to do is review the trail alignments in the context of the resource information that we obtained with the inventories, and then regroup, and then jointly decide how we would move forward.
2:12:47 Right. Quite a bit of it was actually not necessarily new trail construction. There were some, I believe, some restoration areas and areas to avoid, but a lot of it had to do with existing trails, but there were some new, there was some new trail construction also, yeah. Yeah, it was a pretty thorough proposal from, you know, me just looking at it from the outside. Yeah. There was a lot, a pretty big mix of new construction and different development, different class trails. That's on the, that's on the shark.
2:13:20 Is that correct? Yes. Any further discussions about the SHARP questions? On the SOPA list, is there any discussion or questions here? There it is. I've got a quick one with regard to the bike lanes, just because I see it here. Are there bike lanes being considered for the connection between Benton Crossing Road to the airport? That may be a little premature as well, because it looks like the proposal isn't even scoping until the middle of this month.
2:14:02 I think usually Public Works does try to put in bike lanes, generally, if the easements widen up. I honestly don't know. I don't believe that was part of their proposal. I'm not sure where this document came from, but I don't believe that was part of the Public Works proposal. There aren't bike lanes out at the airport anywhere, lots of bikes.
2:14:28 Use the shoulder on Benton Crossing. My understanding was that project is solely driven by an FAA need for secondary ingress, egress. Yeah, it is. My understanding is right. But I think one of the projects we're having coming forward with the LTC is actually reconstructing some of the other roads going out to the airport. So, you know, since that'll be a new one in the future.
2:14:52 Could be. And Sandy, you know, actually, with your involvement in the LTC, I know that there was discussion just as far as bike lanes that since we're developing Whitmore Recreation Center, you know, obviously it'd be great to try and get some better bike access out there. It doesn't necessarily involve you guys, but, well, it does. Everything does. Somewhere. But essentially, just, you know, looking for connecting bikes out to Whitmore. Right. Well, right, exactly. More and more, any of the road...
2:15:21 The roads that, you know, are funded through with dollars through the LTC, we're trying to do as many bike lanes as possible. I don't know, you know, that was just a question it looks like. It is, and it's just a good one just done. We can have this conversation. Probably worth you all coordinating with the Public Works Department, because quite honestly, if there were an interest there, it would make sense to incorporate it in this proposal, and we...
2:15:49 We do the environmental analysis rather than the access road is built and then a subsequent proposal might come forward for bike lanes. So maybe if we just did the environmental analysis just to get it done, is that what you're saying? If ultimately the intent is to have bike lanes out there, it would be more efficient to do it once. I think the important thing is for us to have a discussion with public works. Right.
2:16:17 Given the nature of the use of the airport and origins and destinations, whether that's a place where we really want to spend bike lane money. It may be. I mean, you said coming out of Whitmore, maybe it makes a, you know, a loop. This was just a conversation. It'll probably be money from the FAA anyway. Does the committee have any other questions on the Shady Rest Trailhead?
2:16:47 Proposal or? The staging area? Is that the staging area? Yes. The EA? So what's the next path? So the EA comment period closed, John? That's correct. And we received a number of comments. I'm not sure I know the total number. Our next step would be to review those comments and then publish a
2:17:17 Final environmental assessment and a draft decision and that would start the objection period. And so that draft decision would articulate what the intent for the decision would be. And as you guys maybe are aware, our process has changed from a post-decisional appeal to a pre-decisional objection. Otherwise, it's pretty similar. But yeah, that's the next step and we would hope to be doing that. We did receive word that
2:17:46 Funding for that and a couple of other grants that we had from the State Off-Highway Motor Vehicle Commission were extended to sometime in March. I can't remember if it's the beginning of March or the end of March, but so we have some additional time to finish a couple of those projects, that being one of them. Good. Okay, any further discussion? John, did you want to talk to the committee about any other projects that you have in the future lined up?
2:18:20 And last year, we...
2:18:47 Did a decision, did a small NEPA analysis to continue our over-snow vehicle grooming program. And as you may be aware, the Forest Service in the Pacific Southwest region, which is, were part of that, was in a lawsuit with the Snowlands Network and several other environmental organizations. That lawsuit has been settled.
2:19:16 And the decisions we did for short-term extensions of the grooming program weren't challenged, but I think the number is five out of the 11 forests that were named originally in the lawsuit will be preparing an environmental impact statement for their over-snow programs. There was also a lawsuit in Idaho that
2:19:43 resulted in. The Forest Service has regulations that, similar to the travel management processes we've done, that says that on forests that have over-snow motor vehicle programs or those uses that forests could, at their discretion, choose to subject those programs to
2:20:10 A travel management analysis type process. The case in Idaho was brought by Winter Wildlands Alliance and other environmental groups, I believe. These groups just change who's the lead and the other ones, they all partner in these things. But I think the same Snowlands Network and Center for Biological Diversity were also involved in that. Those three parties were involved in a different arrangement in that.
2:20:38 Previous lawsuit. The judge ruled in that case that the fact that our regulations allowed for us to choose at their discretion to conduct over snow motorized travel analysis was not consistent with the executive order that directed us to do motorized travel analysis. So perhaps put more simply, the plaintiffs contended that if we have over snow motorized, we should have been compelled to
2:21:07 Conduct an analysis. And the judge, in essence, ruled in their favor. And so the Forest Service nationally has until September 2014 to rewrite that regulation. So we don't know what that will look like, but we anticipate that it will say that over-snow motorized travel analysis is required, based on the judge's order, not discretionary.
2:21:38 So that fact coming plus the fact that the categorical exclusion decision that we made last year to continue our program said that we would groom for the 2012-2013 season and for the 2013-2014 season, which are the last two years of our current contract.
2:22:05 We believe it is likely in our interest that we are going to have to undertake some form of NEPA decision evaluating our over-snow program. And what we don't know to decide to continue what it looks like. What we don't know is whether that would be comprehensive in scope or simply try to focus narrowly as we did in the last categorical exclusion.
2:22:33 Recognizing that we've never done a comprehensive NEPA analysis on the system that I inherited when I got here. And I inherited too. The bar. So both Sandy's and my predecessors left that for us. I thought Bill might have started it or at least been involved when things were started. Certainly we're under a lot more scrutiny and a lot of things have changed over the years with respect to
2:23:04 Some of the uses, some of the interest in uses, some of the environmental standards and the backdrop of the regulations. So I think, quite honestly, we may very well be a little bit under the gun in terms of having a NEPA decision done such that we'd be in a position to execute a contract with the state and have that grooming go on for the winter of 2014-2015.
2:23:34 Program, there's a lot of users, there brings a lot of economic activity and a lot of tourism to the community. We know that we will be challenged as far as the staff time and the funding to kick something like that off because we're under pressure to complete forest plan revision and other things. And so what I really wanted to do today was to put the seed in
2:24:02 You're thinking that that may be something that we may jointly want to contribute to that effort. We may jointly want to undertake public involvement in that effort, et cetera. And again, at this point, I don't know the scale or scope of it. I do know from watching how things happen in other parts of the state or the region that if we try to narrow the scope of it for expedience sake,
2:24:29 It could potentially leave us some vulnerability with respect to NEPA's efficiency, cumulative effects analysis, those sorts of things with some of the non-motorized interest groups because we can't ever point to anywhere where those things have been done in the past. So I know that was a lot. If you all have some questions or some thoughts in that regard, I think it would be worthwhile to have the discussion with you.
2:24:54 And I suspect we'll be talking about this again in the future. But certainly if you have thoughts, comments, questions, I think it would be good if we discussed it for a bit, assuming you all are interested in taking the time to do so. John, I had a question. You said five out of the 11 in the Pacific Southwest region will have to do an EIS. We weren't one of those five? We were not one of those five. Wow. That's correct. How did that happen? Because the controversy seems to be greater on some other forests. On the west side more.
2:25:22 Yeah, basically the conflicts between motorized and non-motorized winter use. We weren't the biggest fish that the plaintiffs had to fry. The forests, I believe, are... If you look at Snow End's network there from the Bay Area and they recreate... Well, and Reno and... Yeah. Yeah, so it was the Lassen, the Plumas, the Tahoe National Forest, the El Dorado National Forest, and the Stanislaw. Okay. So...
2:25:49 Close, but we're a little further south. Yeah, yeah. That's funny. That's funny. Yeah, I was going to say Lassen and Plumas. Woo. If I get it correct and if I understand the lawsuits correct, and of course I've been watching both of these, it's two different suits really. One has to do with the grooming and their desire to eliminate grooming and making you go through a NEPA process and making it as expensive as possible before you continue the grooming, even though it's on top of existing roadways for the most part. The other is
2:26:19 General OSV use and how they're used and subjecting them to a travel management plan as the summer motorized is subjected to a travel management plan. If you took snowmobiling and created the same type of system that you do in the summer and the winter, it would kill the sport. And that's what this is aimed at, at killing the sport. This isn't aimed at, sorry, I'm going to go off tilt here. This isn't aimed at fixing anything environmentally that's going on.
2:26:48 This is aimed at killing a motorized recreation. That's its sole purpose, its sole focus, and that's what they're trying to do. If you kill the grooming, and believe me, the people who are filing these lawsuits, I know some of them don't care, you also kill the grooming for the non-motorized out at Glass Creek. The non-motorized in Shady Rest that gets knocked down first by the groomer, because it's a motorized state groomer that would go away. This doesn't touch just snowmobilers. This affects every forest user.
2:27:18 And if your goal is to eliminate as many people as you can from the forest, this is a great plan and a great way to go about using our laws that were there initially set up to give us healthy forests to eliminate users and user groups. I wish there was something personally I could do about it. I wish I had the money to put into the lawsuits, but I don't. The poor government is under the gun, and a lot of times instead of litigating these because of the cost, they are settling.
2:27:47 Out of court at less than desirable solutions, I think, for everybody. That's just my opinion. I can't speak for those sitting in the chair, and even if they could, they're not allowed to say it anyway. And that's really what's going on here. This is an attempt to eliminate snowmobiling. The Groom Trail System was set up here specifically almost as a tourist-based system so that when people come here, they can find their way around and they can get into it.
2:28:17 Those of us who have lived and snowmobiled here for years really don't use it all that often because we're off-trail riders. That's what we do. And that's what's the most fun, taking some of you out on some of these rides. And having to adhere to a travel management plan similar to that for summer motorized would kill it. This is obviously a big impact to Tamarack too, right, John? I mean, their grooming and their Nordic programs? I mean, is that right? Because of what they do up there?
2:28:47 How many is it? Not necessarily. I'm trying to think the best way to explain things without getting too complicated. It really, the lawsuit that we had hit us in California, those 11 national forests of which we were one, and then we were outside of the settlement agreement. What that was really about was
2:29:19 Whether we had a sufficient NEPA analysis and decision, so meaning we're consistent with all the applicable laws to support the grooming that we did with the state off-highway motor vehicle commission funds, and a lot of the arguments with respect to the environmental effects were that motorized use has some effects and we hadn't properly analyzed those, and some were the effects of the groomers. Some was the effects of
2:29:48 The motorized vehicle use. The Tamarack situation is a little bit different in that they do grooming for non-motorized use, so the scope and scale of the motorized use is smaller. It's also a more confined area, so perhaps a little simpler. We haven't yet been challenged by either by lawsuits for
2:30:12 Grooming at Alpine ski areas or grooming at Nordic ski areas for those purposes. That said, I think to tie in with something that Bill said, we have had, and Bill was instrumental in making this work, the grooming that we started years ago at Shady Rest and the grooming that we do at the Deadman Summit area of City and Dome for non-motorized use.
2:30:42 That's done with the state's groomer that we use under agreement and with their funding. And the idea there was that people acknowledged there are these conflicts between motorized recreation and non-motorized recreation. And my understanding was that it was proposed to the state to allow us to do some grooming specifically for non-motorized.
2:31:08 So that non-motorized users didn't have to use, if they wanted to use, because we weren't doing other grooming for non-motorized, if they wanted to use groom trails, they had a place where they could go that they didn't have to share with motorized users in the interest of reducing that conflict, thereby helping the overall program to be successful. Because the interesting thing is, we get money that
2:31:32 Doesn't come from green stickers primarily. It comes from gasoline taxes that everybody pays. But under state law, they go for these motorized uses that the Off-Highway Motor Vehicle Commission funds. It's just like when someone builds a subdivision next to an Air Force base, which I've seen that where I used to live too. The Air Force base was there for a long time. We got the funding to Groom 4 Motorized.
2:32:00 Once we had the Groom Trail, people wanted to use it. Some of them were upset that they had to share it with the motorized users that it was done for the first place, just like the people who bought the inexpensive houses that just happened to be next to March Airfield. Once they lived there for a few years, they realized they really didn't like the noise from March Airfield, and so they start taking legal action. So if we lost our state funding for that other program, or if we lost the ability to do that program,
2:32:30 For the motorized, we wouldn't have, we don't have other funds to support the high cost of grooming for non-motorized, and, you know, Tamarack charges fees to be able to support what they do. Bill is certainly entitled to his opinion. I'll take a moment to slightly disagree with Bill, as I'm sure I can do respectfully. I'm not sure whether, I don't know what the motivations of the people filing the lawsuits are deep down. Bill may be.
2:32:59 Correct. I believe certainly there are user conflicts and folks have questions about the balance of where there is motorized and where there is non-motorized and how easily accessible they are. There's certainly no doubt that the organizations that filed those lawsuits aim to at least restrict the motorized use because they would like to have more of the available land area strictly non-motorized.
2:33:29 But in our experience, I'm not sure we've seen anything that makes it clear that they want it completely eliminated. But Bill may very well be right. But I think there are opportunities. Every year that we continue to try to do the old program that we've always done and we never had a NEPA decision, even though there's a federal action, we enter into a contract with the state and we take their money and we go out and do things on the ground. So that's the tide to NEPA.
2:33:57 Can't demonstrate that we're compliant with all laws and regulations, then we're vulnerable to challenges. And so there is a chance that if we were to embark in a public process and a NEPA analysis and culminate in a decision that was motorized travel analysis and or
2:34:18 A grooming system in open areas. It may or may not look exactly like a summer road system because the situation is different. There could be some open areas, open riding areas. There might be designated trails. There's lots of ways it could go. The advantage of doing a decision like that and taking it through the NEPA process is that you'd have some certainty that that system would remain.
2:34:43 Solid into the future and would be less vulnerable to various challenges. And it would certainly give us, you know, some opportunity to continue to pursue contracts with the state, et cetera, because we had some certainty about what our system was going to look like. No question, as Bill stated, there's a lot of controversy and there's a wide range of opinions about things and, you know, I'm sure it'd be real fun to work on. But the bottom line is I'm not sure we can,
2:35:13 Avoid biting off that chunk of work for that much longer into the future without some real risk to disrupting some of the programs that we've become accustomed to. Fair enough. It's a tough one. It's going to be a bad audience. At the same time, we'll be interested to keep abreast of that to see where MLT, LCC, or even the Recreation Commission can participate. Good to know. Thank you for your briefing.
2:35:47 Thank you. All right. Any further? No, I think that concludes my list. All right. Thank you. This time? It concludes my list. I know you'll be the first to make a motion. I'll make a motion that we adjourn. I'll second it. All right. There we go. As far as discussion, Steve, on the adjournment, it says December 9, 2013 from 1.30 to 4.30. That should be 1.30 to 3.30. Just to keep it short.
2:36:14 Well, remember, it was two hours. Yes. Theoretically. So we're not done early, we're actually done late. We're done late. Sorry about that. Under the presentations. No, it was. Thank you. It was good, and we very much appreciate it. Under the presentations, Steve, put an estimated time for the presentations, too, and that way will help us. That's a good idea. I think we're always going to run over, but I just want to. Yeah.
2:36:43 Are you pessimistic? Are you pessimistic?