Town Council
· recording 3 hr 0 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
375 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Yes.
0:29 Thank you.
0:58 Thank you.
1:27 Thank you.
1:56 Thank you.
2:26 Thank you.
2:51 Thank you very much.
3:21 I'm afraid we have sort of mixed.
3:50 Metaphors here, if I just throw a question about it, I know this time. So it's my intent to have to go, once we get the introductions done, to do 20 minutes here, 20 minutes here, 30 minutes here. And then 10 minutes of questions. 10 minutes of questions. 10 minutes of questions.
4:14 Or, yeah.
4:21 But you might hear something.
4:50 Thank you.
5:16 Thank you.
5:42 Thank you.
6:10 Okay. So you've got the cards.
6:28 Can I ask our candidates to take their seats, please?
6:53 Geez, we should feel like somebody up here. I don't know. Maybe she got the time wrong. Maybe we should switch signs here so that we don't have to sit next to him. Did you do this? Just so that we can see.
7:22 Okay, ladies and gentlemen, I'd like to get this show going. Welcome to the County Candidates Forum, sponsored by the Mammoth Lakes Chamber of Commerce.
7:48 We've been doing this for a number of years, and this is the second forum we've had for this election. My name is Jack Copeland, and I'll be the moderator tonight. I'd like to go over some of the, they're not really guidelines, they're more like rules. And also the agenda. The purpose of this forum is to provide an opportunity for the public
8:17 To see, to meet our candidates, and to be informed about what the issues are and what each candidate stands for, why they should vote for one candidate or another. It's not a debate. And so I will not be allowing any of the candidates to directly debate one another. And it's also not the British Parliament.
8:42 Where anybody in the audience gets to shout out whatever they want to shout. The questions will come through me to the candidates and I will attempt to answer or ask questions that anyone in the audience is interested in hearing about. Also, we have a telephone line open and that number is 760-934.
9:07 8889, extension 350, and people in the listening audience can call in questions, and or send an email to me at chamberforum at npgtable.com. I am going to be, we're going to start out with each candidate providing a one-minute introduction to them, of themselves to you.
9:40 Then we will go into a period of question and answer. I'll ask two kinds of questions. Group questions in which I start with and ask each candidate the same question so they have an opportunity to differentiate themselves. An individual question. Because we have a bit of a mixed metaphor tonight, unlike two weeks ago when we had the town council forum,
10:06 I'm going to start out after everyone gives their introduction. We're going to stay with the supervisory candidates for 20 minutes. Then we're going to go with the sheriff candidates for 20 minutes. Then we're going to go with the judicial candidates for 30 minutes. I'm assuming that Therese will arrive. She's on her way. And then we will come back through for a follow-up round of questioning.
10:36 And we will finish with three-minute summaries by each candidate. I'm going to make a promise that we are not going to go past 8 o'clock. I don't know how long we'll last, but we're not going past 8 o'clock. Jeff, we appreciate that. What I'd like to do is get this. If there are any questions, there are back rooms straight out the door and down the hallway to the right.
11:06 Candidates will have, my associate, Eric, will be holding up cards so that we can keep track of the time, and I think we should get started. With that, Bill, would you like to introduce yourself, please? Certainly. I'm Bill Sauser. I have been in Mammoth for 52 years. My folks moved up here when I was only six years old. In my adult life, and even going back into my school life some, I've been extremely active in Mammoth.
11:35 Currently, I chair the Towns Tourism and Recreation Commission. I have been on it since it was the Park and Rec Commission for 13 years. I have chaired the Southern Mono Historical Society for the past 10. We run the little Hayden Cabin. I have been active in a lot of other things. I worked with the Forest Service CAT process, their roads designation. I have just been extremely active in a lot of things. Running for this candidate is just a buildup.
12:03 You know, from where I've been. I'm not new to the process. I'm not coming in just because I want to run. I have been supportive of my town for a long time, and this is the next step for me. Thank you, Bill. Larry? Are these microphones working? I believe so. Thank you, Mr. Copeland, and thank you to the Chamber for all the work in arranging tonight's forum. My name is Larry Johnston, and I'm running for District 1 Supervisor.
12:35 This is one of my campaign signs to help viewers know who I am. District 1 is considered by many to be the heart of Mammoth. Although small, it generates almost as much property value as all the rest of the county outside Mammoth combined. As a brief background, I've lived in Mammoth Lakes for over 20 years, working 10 years in private business and 10 years in the public sector. My education includes an associate degree in mathematics, a bachelor degree in planning and management, and a minor study focus in parks and recreation.
13:04 I want to bring this unique combination of background and experience to the task of efficient and frugal government. I've been working hard over the last six months and together with input of numerous voter contacts have developed a comprehensive platform that I believe will lead to a more resilient, sustainable, and self-reliant future. Your consideration of my qualifications and vision for the district and the county would be sincerely appreciated. My website is johnstonforsupervisor.com or just give me a call.
13:32 914-0826. Thank you, Larry. Doug? Hi, my name is Doug Northerton, and I'm a candidate for Mono County Sheriff. I've been a Highway Patrolman for the past 28 years. The past 22 years I've lived in Bridgeport and have served Mono County in that capacity. I also serve as a school board member to continue my volunteer efforts to assist children in this county. And I have...
14:02 A deep commitment to public service and to law enforcement. I feel that I bring a unique set of skills that I can bring to the sheriff's office and to that position to move it forward at a much faster pace than it's been moving forward. And I would appreciate your vote. And I thank you for checking out and Discover the Difference at www.dugforsheriff2010.com. Thank you. Thank you, Doug. Rick?
14:30 Mr. Copeland, thank you for this opportunity and thank you to the Mammoth Lakes Chamber. My name is Rick Scholl. I'm humbled and honored to be here and honored and humbled to be your sheriff. I've been your sheriff for the last three and a half years. I've worked in law enforcement in Mullen County for 23, actually about 25 years now. And I can't think of a finer organization to represent. And I think I've represented the organization extremely well.
14:59 In collaborating with all other agencies within the county and throughout not just Mono County but Inyo County and the state of California representing the Mono County sheriffs as your elected sheriff. I know we've done a terrific job and made some great strides over the last three and a half years. We have an agenda to continue that trend and once again I'm honored to be serving you as your sheriff and please vote for me, Rick Scholl, Mono County Sheriff. Thank you.
15:29 Thank you, Rick. We'll postpone Teresa's introduction until she arrives. Mark? My name is Mark Maggett, and I'm asking for your vote on June 8th. I want to thank the chamber and all of you for attending and those listening in. Public participation and voting is the cornerstone of our democracy. Another foundation of our great nation is a fair, efficient, and independent judicial system. We expect to place our trust in a judge who will treat every person,
15:59 Our next judge needs to be able to make decisions based upon their experience, ability, temperament, and sense of community. I have a deep and abiding respect and commitment for the law and the values of this.
16:27 Thank you, Mark. Randy? Thank you, Jack. Thank all of you for coming. I'm Randy Gephardt. I've been a lawyer for 32 years. I've been practicing in Mammoth County for 22 in private practice as well as doing public defender work. I've represented thousands of clients in civil and criminal matters from the simplest to the most complex.
16:57 I've run a business as a law firm for over two decades and I bring a balance of private practice together with public service which I think is needed in the court. I'm in court two to three times a week on contested matters and my practice is roughly half civil and half criminal which mirrors the work that the Mono County judge will do. I'm the only candidate
17:28 Thank you. Thank you, Randy. Therese, we're glad you made it. Thank you. My name is Therese Hankel.
17:59 I'm running for Mono County Superior Court judge, as you all know. I have, throughout this campaign, not sought out endorsements for my campaign as I truly believe in a fair and an independent judiciary. I would hate to have anyone come before me and wonder if the person that they were litigating against, be it a civil matter, was someone who had supported me for judge. I would hope to give everyone a
18:29 Fair opportunity to be heard. I'm not beholden to anyone and I believe very much in the process. I came from Minnesota where I worked for two different courts, a trial court and an appellate court. I'm the only judicial candidate that has any experience working in the court system. I ask for your vote for judge. Thank you. Thank you, Therese. Now we're going
19:03 We're going to focus some questions on our supervisory candidates. The first question is, where is District 1? What are the boundaries of District 1? And we'll start with Larry. We are sitting in District 1. District 1 is about three square miles. It's about a thousand times smaller than the rest of the county. But it generates...
19:35 And you can find just about anything there. It's got all the
20:04 Grocery stores. It's got all the pharmacies. It's got all the banks. It's got all the lumber yards. You can buy all the drugs and money that you want here. And it has all the schools, trails, the skateboard park, and the high school football field. So it's a really interesting and eclectic place. Thank you, Larry. Bill, do you have anything to add?
20:34 Yeah, I think the lines were probably drawn by a drunk as they wander through Sierra Valley sites up the middle of Joaquin, then over to Lupin and up the middle of Lupin, down Meridian to Old Mammoth and turns hard right. It has got fewer voters than most of the other districts, yet population-wise it is the densest. It is probably the most culturally diverse, not probably, I think it is the most culturally diverse.
21:05 District in the county. There are a lot of people to represent that are not voters and deserve our attention and representation as well. Thank you, Bill. Gentlemen, what are the issues in this campaign? I'd like to start with Bill on this. I think the issues, from my perspective here, is mammoth-centric. The county has done a lot of good things for a lot of other places.
21:41 But I think that there's a lot of partnering and other things that could be done here in Mammoth with the Mammoth tax dollars that perhaps haven't been done. The budget is going to be hugely important with reduced property values and that being the bulk of income for discretionary funding that the supervisors have. I think the budget's going to be very important as well. The issues are...
22:15 Several. When we were out canvassing, one of the issues that came up was at a young man's apartment. We knocked on the door and introduced myself and I asked him, what do you do? And he said, I'm unemployed. And to me, that is probably the number one issue that's facing the district and the county. I have a number of ways and ideas that have been developed over the last few months.
22:44 As to how to solve that particular problem. But I have some things that I'd like to throw out as some of the ideas that have come up during our canvassing. Pursuing frugal and efficient government, returning more resources to District 1 in the Mammoth vicinity, increasing public input to policy and budget decisions, stabilizing and enhancing the tourism base, creating more year-round sustainable jobs.
23:14 Saving taxes through government energy conservation, stimulating the local construction force, and analyzing development projects so they fit within the community that they're in. Thank you, Larry. The state budget is a well-known catastrophe, and you briefly, beginning with Larry, summarize the state of the county's budget this year and give us some
23:50 Projections on what is likely to happen in the next fiscal year. Well, I happen to have a chart that might help here. Ross Perron. The good news is reflected in this chart. And what it shows is that from the year 2000, on my right, year left, to this year, 10 years later, the county and the town have generated
24:23 A 300% increase in assessed values. And the blue area is what was generated in the county, and the red area is what is generated in the town. Currently, 75% of the assessed value is coming from the town in the entire county. The county has wisely pursued a number of issues with this. They've created a $6 million reserve.
24:52 For the first time in the history, I believe, they've created a capital improvement program. They have not laid off anyone except perhaps one state worker. Of the 58 counties in the state, we are 58th best as far as economic consideration. But if you look at this chart carefully, you will see that there's a slight downturn that has occurred in the last year, although it was higher than the year before.
25:20 In 2009 it was slightly lower and projections are that we're going to be about four to seven percent lower this year. So we're going to have to hunker down. We may have to use some of that reserve that we've been saving and we may have to defer some capital or vehicle expenses that we might have otherwise had to do. The state, just a few words on it, is in a heck of a mess.
25:49 And we don't know what's going to happen there yet. So we're in a standby mode. I'd like to see the real figures when they come out as far as what we need to do as far as cuts. And hopefully we'll be able to get through this in good fashion. Thank you, Larry. Bill? As far as the state budget goes and how it affects us, we get an awful lot of our money, over a third, from other government agencies. As the state cuts its budget, we're going to have to look at where that budget cuts and what.
26:19 Funding streams over before, whether that was what department that's a mandated state expense, those went go to, and then try to appropriately cut in those areas. As far as the overall budget, there is going to be a shortfall in property tax revenues and such, and I think we need to look at everything to streamline budget, to streamline spending. This is probably our best opportunity to shrink government, which I think we would all like to see.
26:47 I think we have to look at everything from staffing levels to what we're putting into affordable housing. Any savings we can get, we need to look at capital improvement projects, stimulate growth where we can, stimulate tourism where we can, and try not to dip into reserves if possible. I think this is the new norm. We need to come up with a budget that reflects that. Thank you, Bill.
27:15 Bill, in the local press, you've been very outspoken about your support and advocacy for greater marketing through the county. Can you elaborate on that a little bit, please? Well, I think that tourism is the most important industry we have in Moa County. I think that in the past we have not gone out and told our customer, our potential customer, what it is we have.
27:47 I think we could dedicate a little more and maybe partner with the new DMO here in Mammoth that is being formed to get that word out and to develop recreation programs and trails and infrastructure that will bring people in. I think that the county has been lax in partnering with Forest Service state parks in creating the necessary infrastructure to get the customer here, trails.
28:17 Parks and Rec programs and that sort. Larry? So what was the question again? The question was about marketing, our recreation here in Monon County. I've attended a lot of the tourism meetings, commission meetings, and interviewed the Economic Development Department personnel. And I think we're doing...
28:41 A pretty good job for the budget levels that we've had. This is an example of the brochure that we have that's being sent around to a number of different places. We've also done a good job with fishing enhancement. We're working very diligently on that part of it. It's not that we can't do more, but I think it's real important. I think we've done a great job with fish and photos. But we need to do a lot more, and we need to assure that when a visitor comes here,
29:11 The photos reflect what they expect. And one of the greatest things that we can do is meet their expectations. I give an example of the Mobile Mart. And I think we all know that everybody knows it's one of the best places to eat in the eastern Sierra. But they don't hardly advertise at all. It's a lot of word of mouth. And so when someone comes here as a visitor, they'll go back and tell their friends if the actual...
29:40 A resource is what they like. So we need to work on two ends. We need to expand that a little bit, and we need to make sure that when someone comes here, they get what they've paid for, if you will. There has been quite a bit of talk in the local press about the possibility that the county could take on a greater role supporting the airport, and I think this is a big issue, and Larry, would you like to start on this question?
30:17 This is an opportunity that I think the time has come. As you know, the county sold the airport to the town many years ago, and the town has gone ahead and done, I think, a really great job in getting the Horizon Air and the flights that we've had come to town. We have an opportunity this fall to maintain the air service. The town and the...
30:45 Mountain are working diligently to try to have that happen so there's not a discontinuity in the service. The county has been asked to help and if there was one thing that I think that we would really do well in seeing through and that is I believe the county should step in and give that a hand. It would be about $45,000 in that range and we could put a maximum on it.
31:13 And that $45,000 assumes that the planes would be empty. And we know that they're not going to be. The other part of it is not only would it serve tourism for the fall and the fall colors that happen out in the county as well as around the town, but it would give our local residents another way to leave town without having to drive. So I would support at least some effort by the county to
31:41 Step up to the plate on this one and give that airport a hand. Thank you. Bill? I think that the airport is just one of many issues that the county needs to step up on. I think that air service isn't used just by the people of Mammoth. It helps tourism in June Lake, Crowley Lakes. It gives locals a way to get in and out of town that we didn't have before. On top of the air service, recreation, the town.
32:11 Provides the organized recreation for kids and adults alike from Tom's Place to Levining and there's an opportunity there for the county to partner. We're providing services for county residents. The county could be stepping it up a little. Just a couple of many things that the county needs to be helping support on. Air service is really important as part of the infrastructure from the previous answer that we need to do to get the tourists here to help keep our boat afloat.
32:46 Thank you, Bill. Larry, I just heard from one of our viewers, and apparently that sign is reflecting in a funny way on the television. Reflecting in a good way budget-wise? It's reflecting in a way that makes viewing not so easy. I'll put it in reserve. Thank you. I'm glad you didn't say it was our hits.
33:13 Let the record show that the sheriffs have a sense of humor. I wanted to go back to a point that you both made in your introductions, and that is that the town of Mammoth, and really District 1 in the center of town, the heart of Mammoth, generates an enormous portion of the revenues that eventually make themselves to the county.
33:47 And into the county budget. Do you, my question is, do you feel that an adequate percentage of that money comes back to District 1? I'd like to start with Bill. I think probably not. I think that we put an awful lot into the county coffers and I think more should come back. However, I'm not as naive to think that just because I go to Bridgeport means that we can somehow miraculously find money in the budget to bring back to Mammoth.
34:22 But there are things we could do. Maybe the incremental increase in property taxes as the values start to go back up, we could look at a different split coming back to Mammoth than what is in the regular property tax. We only get 6% back of what we pay in now directly. So I think there are ways, without breaking the counties back and leaving them whole, that in the future we can start to generate those funds with the taxes and bring them back to Mammoth.
34:51 Thank you. Larry?
35:23 District 1 generates about a billion dollars in assessed value. The total is about six billion. So that generates one percent roughly property taxes that go to the county. The county distributes those taxes to the various taxing agencies. The county gets about 30 percent of that one billion assessed value tax that's generated. The town gets about four percent, five percent. But the
35:51 The county also gives back to the water district about 10%. The hospital district gets another percentage. The school districts get another percentage. The fire districts and so on get other percentages. So what's being generated to the town area and services is about 41% of a return. And that's not too bad. I don't think it's as good as it could be, perhaps. But that's the deal that the town and the county made some years ago.
36:19 So what I'm suggesting is that we take on a few more projects in the Mammoth vicinity. One is an example that happened up in Walker, where the county forces, the public works forces, used their equipment and their manpower to help build a ball field. And I think we could do something similar here, say, to help build a track at Whitmore.
36:48 Thank you, Larry. I understand that the sage-grouse may
37:21 May indeed go on to the endangered species list. And I'm not sure, although I love running and it scares the heck out of me when one of them jumps up and flies away, I'm not sure what the significance of that may be to the county. Larry, would you like to address that? Yes, thank you. The sage grouse, the greater sage grouse and the bi-state sage grouse,
37:51 It's a species that's found pretty much throughout the western United States. It eats sage. And it has been declining in numbers throughout the western states. Some of it's been because of development. Other reasons, predation, fires destroy their strutting grounds, which are called leks.
38:20 Listing for our area's sage grouse has been put on a potential list. It's number three in priority at the moment. And it could be listed. The Department of Fish and Game is working hard on this issue. In the county, just recently, we had an issue up in the Fayette's Hot Spring area, which is north of Bridgeport. It was a subdivision that was going on there. It was near one of these lecks, a strutting ground.
38:49 And the Department of Fish and Game is appealing the action of the Planning Commission on that and had appealed it to the board and the board was upheld that. So it's going to be a continuing issue. What I would suggest is first we stop issuing hunting licenses for sage rouse. And that was sort of a joke, actually. And then get out ahead of the game.
39:20 Most of the area that's affected by the sage grouse is areas that are not going to be affected by development, but there are some potential subdivision areas that are out there, and what we need to do is take a look at those areas, work with the Department of Fish and Game and other resource agencies, and maybe find a way to protect those leks and preserve the sage grouse for future generations. Thank you, Larry. Bill, I know this isn't really exactly down your...
39:49 You're in your wheelhouse here, but do you have any comments about the sage grouse? Yeah, you mentioned the track, which is happening out of Whitmore and may be impacted by the sage grouse. More important to me would be the airport. The leks on Convict Creek are far closer to the airport and listing as an endangered species. Well, I'm not sure of all the rules that go along with that, but usually there are numbers of feet that you have to be away and noise issues from the leks, so it is certainly of a great concern.
40:19 Although it is my understanding that originally the efficient game decided not to put it on the list at such high priority and there have been lawsuits trying to get it moved up for whatever reason, managing our natural resources by lawsuit rather than wildlife experts. I'm not sure how to improve the lats or keep them, but certainly we need to look at what can be done to mitigate the effects.
40:49 So that they won't be a detriment to air service, which is so important to us, and moving forward with the track. Although I think we could probably find another area for the track if necessary, but the airport certainly isn't going to be moved. So it is of huge importance. Thank you, Bill. Gentlemen, you can take a break, and I will be moving on to our sheriff's candidates. I'd like to start with a question for both of you to answer.
41:22 What are your qualifications for this job? And we'll start with Doug. Certainly. My qualifications are that obviously I've been in law enforcement for 28 years. I've qualified for an advanced post in the California law enforcement system. I have for the past 27 years been selected as officer in charge, acting sergeant, and
42:04 Acting Area Commander. Since I've been to Bridgeport area, quite a bit of that. We've seen a lot of turnover in our agency as far as our managers go, and I've had to fulfill those roles on numerous occasions. And I think the experience I bring as far as being a previous business owner, managing budgets, and basically being selected by my peers as a leader.
42:34 In the Bridgeport area for the California Association of Highway Patrolmen, which represents us. I've been a defense rep and an area representative for them for the past 14 years. And I feel that all that leads to the leadership portion of the sheriff's job, which is probably one of the most important things that the sheriff needs to bring to that position is, in fact, leadership. Thank you. Rick, same question.
43:04 Qualifications for the job. Actually, I've been your sheriff coroner for the last three years. Prior to that, I've held almost every position in law enforcement, from jailer dispatcher down here at the old substation to training manager to field training officer, deputy coroner, investigator, was the first dare officer in the eastern Sierra to teach in the school system where law enforcement actually was...
43:33 In the school system on a daily basis teaching the kids. As a field training officer, you're accountable to these young new employees, these deputy sheriffs and police officers to help train them, to keep them alive, to keep them safe, and to teach them how to do law enforcement as I would see fit. Part of that is our core value is committed.
44:01 To enhancing the quality of life in each community we serve. And that's one of the things that I don't take lightly. And that was one of the things that I thought about throughout my entire career, not only as a professional person, but as a professional law enforcement officer, is to treat people how I would want to be treated. One of the things that I taught every officer that's ever worked with me, for me, or around me, was try to get a thank you out of the person that...
44:28 That you've just dealt with. Whether it be slamming that steel jail door shut behind them or issuing a citation. And they weren't thanking you for that. They were thanking you for treating them with dignity, with respect and professionalism and explaining to them, taking the extra time to explain to them what's going to happen in the future with them. But my commitment, my goals and things have been reflective of why I'm your current elected sheriff and I'm hoping to serve the county of Mammoth for the next four years. Thank you.
44:58 Thank you, Rick. As much as it seems intuitive to most people, I'd like to know, what are the duties and responsibilities of the sheriff? What is the sheriff actually responsible for? And I'd like to direct that first to Rick. Under 2,600 of the government code, it specifies the issues and things that we are accountable for.
45:26 And number one is to operate a jail. And that's to feed, clothe, and house these inmates. And not only that, but we're responsible for that person. But we also do all civil processes within the county. We do the coroner's duties. Any death that occurs within the county, we're tasked with investigating that.
45:51 It's kind of interesting. The office of the sheriff has been around for 1,100 years, it's been referred to. And it's the oldest office of government that we have in this country. And when I look at the responsibilities, it's unbelievably huge. And it's one of those things where I don't think that lightly. And so jails, civil, coroners, and we're also tasked with investigating.
46:19 Thank you. Doug? Rick pretty much summed it up. Okay. Those are the duties of the sheriff. I think that one of the duties that's been kind of put on a
46:50 The less important track possibly is the law enforcement portion of the job. And I know there's some issues in the county with deputies and other law enforcement agencies not feeling that that part of the role is being fulfilled to its greatest potential. And I think that moving forward with a more defined beach structure, more defined system in place to make sure the deputies are in the field doing their jobs.
47:18 It would be a great enhancement for public safety in Mono County. Thank you. I am a little ignorant of how the Sheriff's Department interfaces with the California Highway Patrol on our highways. They both patrol highways. Can you clarify that for us, please, Dan? Sure. Obviously, the duties of California Highway Patrol is number one priority is traffic safety and management.
47:49 That's been our goal since we were created in 1929. And oddly enough, we actually came out of, as an agency, we actually came out of the sheriff's departments. That when the original, I think, 13 counties in California were doing their, after the advent of the car, and they started taking wrecks, and they started doing
48:15 Speed enforcement and different things on cars when they finally got up to 15 or 20 miles an hour. What happened was that it began to be a county-by-county issue as you travel throughout California that the deputy sheriff in that town decided that he'd put up a 5-mile-an-hour speed limit sign and you'd go through at 10 or 15 and lo and behold you'd get a ticket and it became a revenue-generating thing for the counties.
48:42 So in 1929 the legislature decided that that probably wasn't a good way to go and they created the California Highway Patrol to handle the traffic, take it back out of the bailiwick of the sheriff's departments and create it under one agency so that it was fair to all Californians as they crossed the state. There wasn't an issue with crossing into counties and differing laws so that the laws would be state laws and not necessarily county laws. So the sheriff's department today
49:11 Obviously has patrol powers as well, law enforcement, full law enforcement powers, just like the California Highway Patrol does. And they can stop cars. They can cite the drivers for speed, for mechanical violations, for passing over WLOs or many of the other things. So there is a dual role there for both agencies. We provide backup for each other should there be a call. We back the sheriffs on their calls. The sheriffs back.
49:39 Us on our calls. So it's a mutual aid type that we have agreement that we have between agencies. Thank you. Rick, do you have any? The interaction with the Highway Patrol and the Sheriff's Department. You know, we are the chief law enforcement officers of a county. Excuse me. And so we are relegated to enforce all laws within the county structure.
50:10 Traffic is not a primary function of the Sheriff's Office, and that is a directive I've put out to my troops, and it's one of those things where community-oriented policing is at the core of our value, but we work together with the Howa Patrol on a regular basis. It seems like I have a meeting at least once a week or once every other week with the new commander of the Howa Patrol. We're working on a joint effort to put forth an ATV rally up in the north end of the county.
50:40 But the Highway Patrol serves a very important function in the county with the reduction of traffic accidents and the accident investigation, and we pretty much do everything else with all crimes, coroner cases, civil processes, and things like that. So we do depend on them. We had a burglary that had occurred the other night up in the north end of the county, and we ask CHP for help, which we do on a regular basis. And when we're on the highways and we see them on stops.
51:08 We back them up in situations like that. So it's a very cooperative, collaborative agreement. Thank you. One of the things that's been in the press recently is the issue of 24-hour coverage of the Sheriff's Department. I wonder if you would, we'll start with Rick, if you would address that question. You know, we've looked at that, and actually I was the first
51:36 There were three people assigned to 24-hour coverage for the Sheriff's Department back, I believe it was 1977, and I was one of those first three graveyard shift units, and I've got to tell you, it was boring at times. This county can be awfully quiet after 2 o'clock in the morning, but we've looked at that. I look at the statistical data on a regular basis, and I try to figure out how can we best serve the public and have the coverage that the public would demand.
52:04 But also understanding the budget restrictions and the reductions in budgets and things that we're going to have to deal with. We've met with our Deputy Sheriff's Association. We've talked to the county. We've tried to incentivize residency issues with our deputies, which that has changed over the last couple of years due to governmental legislative changes. But we have an average of...
52:31 I think it's right at about four calls for service on a monthly basis that occur in the county between 2 a.m. and 6 a.m. It's actually 3.8 calls for service. To me, I can't justify the additional personnel to hire to handle those calls for service. And the challenge is we don't know where those calls for service are going to be. We patrol from Chalfont Valley all the way to Topaz, and if we were to have a unit on graveyard shift,
53:00 Where would we put that unit? We might put them in the south end of the county, then invariably the call is going to be in the north end of the county, so we're going to have to call somebody out anyway. So we do have a pretty good record on on-call status. We've been in negotiations now probably over a year of trying to figure out how do we mandate an on-call status within the budget. And there again, once you have that, you have to start paying them if you're going to restrict.
53:26 Thank you. Doug, any comments? Until about six months ago or so, we were basically under the same system as the Sheriff's Department where we were not 24 hours providing coverage. We were on call from anywhere from usually midnight to 5 a.m. or 6 a.m. We had an on call system.
53:56 And I think the difference is between the two agencies is that the Sheriff's Department needs a system, a valid system, that if it's not going to go 24 hours or if it's cost prohibitive to go 24 hours, then you need a valid on-call system. And one of the issues now, obviously, with what the Sheriff was alluding to, was the fact that since there's not the residency restrictions there used to be, that you have deputies living in Inyo County, you have
54:26 Deputies living in the state of Nevada. So it creates an extra burden on those deputies that are left or that have chosen to reside within the county and serve. And so it creates a have and have not situation with those deputies. And I think that serious consideration needs to be given to working toward a very, very
54:53 Fair and balanced on-call system where the deputy knows they're on-call, that they are not going to partake of alcohol, they're not going to be going out to dinner, they're going to be where they're supposed to be available for that call to come and handle the call for service because we never know what that's going to be. This is just not Mayberry anymore. We just can't live with an hour or two-hour or possibly even a three-hour response time to a call.
55:21 It creates a burden on the other agencies that are 24 hours in the county between us and the Mammoth Lakes Police Department. And so something definitely needs to be done about that to work toward a viable solution. Thank you, Doug. I feel like I would be remiss if I didn't ask the sheriff, how's that jail roof doing?
55:47 You know, it was a small leak before we went to have it repaired. It's doing at you. We're in good shape. Well, that really brings me to a serious question, and that is the question of jail overcrowding in California in general. And what are we going to have to do in terms of expanding our jail facilities in Mono County? We'll start with Doug on that. Well, I think the sheriff is going to...
56:17 Tell you that there is a study underway and he's been in a lot of work toward that possibility of building a jail and securing the financing for a jail, a new facility. I believe the studies are about a 78 bed capacity thereabouts to reflect future inmate growth. The cost, you know, 17 million, 19 million, 3, 5, 10 years down the road.
56:46 Twenty, twenty-five, thirty million. I don't think there's a way to truly forecast the true cost of it until it's bid out. You know, it depends on what the economy does. If the economy picks up, contractors get to charge more, I can see the cost skyrocketing millions of dollars just for that. You know, unfortunately now, with contractors as hungry as they are throughout the state and nation, now would be a great time to build a new jail because I think we'd probably get it for three to five million dollars less, possibly.
57:15 But the money is not there. The state obviously with this fiscal crisis is not going to do it. The other question becomes where to build it. Do we build it in South County? Do we build it in North County? Do we build it in the cheapest area possible to build it where we don't have the land cost possibly or where the county has more land and it's away from the populated areas? You know, nobody wants, if you think it on the prison system, nobody wants a prison in their backyard. And no more than you would probably want a jail.
57:44 Sitting in the vacant lot next to McDonald's. So it becomes a real issue. Staffing becomes an issue of where do you staff it from. You know, obviously the population base is in South County, but you have an economic disparity between the two ends of the county. So do you help out the north end of the county by building it there to become an economic stimulus for them? There's just a lot of things that need to go into this. A lot of public input, a lot of community input that needs to be put into this before.
58:13 That kind of decision is made by the Board of Supes or the County Sheriff. Okay, thank you. Rick? It's a challenge. We were faced with overcrowding issues on a regular basis. As of, I think it was January 25th of this year, the legislature changed some good time credits for county inmates and for state inmates, which has actually reduced our jail population. We're at an all-time low since I've been sheriff.
58:42 We've been running around 35 to 38 inmates at any one given day. Now we're at about 25 inmates. So we've got room for growth. But my challenge is, as the sheriff, I have to look to the future and think about what happens not next year, not the year after, but what happens five years down the road, ten years down the road. We have to be prepared for it, as we know.
59:04 Growth takes time, and to plan for it takes time. So one of the first things we had to do to even be possibly in line for this AB 900 funding was to do a jail needs assessment. So I went to the board this last year, got the funding approved to do that. So we had a jail needs assessment completed. It was presented to the board of supervisors last month.
59:28 And it talked about, you know, here's the speculation of how big of a jail capacity we're going to need. Not now, not five years, but, you know, seven, eight years down the road that'll be available for the next 20 years and be capable of housing our inmates. So I know that the timing, it just, it seems like we're rushing it right now, but it takes a long time to go through that process.
59:51 I just had a meeting with a gentleman that was the former secretary of the California Department of Corrections and Rehabilitation, who is now, he knows all the ins and outs of getting that AB 900 funding and how Little Mowen County can compete with the LA counties and the other counties with a much greater need. So we're looking at that, we're trying to get things in place for the future, but I don't think we're going to be building any time in the short, at least during the next four or four and a half years.
1:00:21 Thank you. I'm glad to hear we're not at capacity. I hope that's fortuitous. That's a good thing. I would like to ask, this question came from our audience here. At the Town Council Forum, one of the topics was the kind of researching, looking into the possibility and the efficiency that might happen by contracting for Mammoth Lakes law enforcement with the Mono County Sheriff.
1:00:50 And it wasn't presented by any means as a done deal, but just as a question, is it possible, could it work? Rick, could you take that first? I've got a unique perspective in that I've worked for both agencies, and I've seen it. I was on the Sheriff's Department when the town incorporated, and when they formed their own police department and came over at that time, so I had 10 years with the town.
1:01:18 Multiple years with the county. And, you know, it's one of those things that really that is the, that's going to come from the city or the town council and the citizens of the town of Mammoth Lakes if they want to entertain that. You know, as the chief law enforcement officer of the county, it's not my role to try to come in and say we want to take over and do a contract. There's really no...
1:01:43 I don't see any added benefit to the county sheriff's department to have to do that, to do the additional responsibilities and roles to police the town. But if that's what the wishes are, the citizens of the town of Mammoth Lakes and the town council, then absolutely we'll have to entertain that discussion. Okay, thank you. Doug? I think that, you know, one of the issues with consolidation is to do it for the right reasons.
1:02:13 It's really hard to say who has the right reasons to consolidate. Is money the issue? Do you do it solely for a financial gain or savings? And I don't think that that's the place to start. There's a lot of issues that come with consolidation. There's a matter of the Sheriff's Department having to provide then what the town police provide, which is obviously the traffic portion, the general law enforcement portion.
1:02:44 And what size force would be needed in addition to what the Sheriff Department currently has? Is it going to be bigger than what currently has in the town for the police force? Is it less? Can we do more with less? It's a tough sell here to, for the town, the reason they formed the police department in the first place, have those reasons changed enough to want
1:03:14 To want the Sheriff's Department back in here again. And just a quick thing on the jail roof thing is, I'll ask Rick Wallis here, I'd really like to get my state handcuffs back from helping them move the inmates down to the Indian County. I still don't receive my handcuffs back. He's recycling them, I'm sure. You guys can take a break for a few minutes now. Thank you very much for your time. I'd like to move on to our judicial candidates.
1:03:43 I'd like to start out, and we'll start with Therese. I'd like to, I think that unlike the sheriff and the supervisors, most of us have a pretty good handle intuitively on what the sheriff does and what our supervisors do. But I think that unless we, since we're not attorneys, most of us don't really know what the position of superior court judge is all about. So I'd like to start out with some general questions.
1:04:14 That you can educate us about. So, Therese, what is the job of a superior court judge? Well, the job entails both making decisions in criminal and in civil cases. Criminal cases, of course, when someone is charged with a crime. A civil case can be anything such as family law disputes, real estate matters, contracts, partnership disputes.
1:04:47 Anything that comes before the court that's not a crime. And the job of the judge is to provide a forum where everyone can be heard and air their dispute, whether that's the district attorney charging a criminal defendant with a crime, or whether it's two people who come before the court asking the court to help them come to a decision about a dispute. And the judge in Mono County...
1:05:16 May either render a decision on that dispute, or if it's a trial, then the judge's job is to charge a jury with the law that is applicable to the situation in front of them. Thank you. Mark? In the broadest sense, the judge administers justice. There are two basic types of law, criminal law, where the state has determined that a certain act or conduct
1:05:43 Deserves to be punished by fine or incarceration.
1:05:48 And in that process, there are procedures in place. It's very regulated and set forth. The district attorney generally charges someone with a crime after getting a police report. Then the person is arraigned, which is the first time they come before a court. And at that time, very important rights are told to them. They're told about the right to have an attorney, the right to a speedy trial. And after that, they're generally appointed counsel if they can't afford counsel.
1:06:14 Or they hire an attorney or they represent themselves. And the process starts. And in that process, there's a felony. Then the first thing the judge does is they have something called a preliminary hearing. And that is a determination made, an evidentiary hearing, where the court decides whether or not there's probable cause for that matter to go on to a felony charge and go on to possibly a trial. And then if that matter goes on to trial, then the court
1:06:41 The judge's role is to make sure that all evidentiary motions are ruled correctly. So the evidence that gets in is the appropriate evidence. And then if the jury is charged, then the judge makes sure that the jury process is done accordingly and that the person gets a fair trial with the process being followed. In a civil case,
1:07:01 What the judge does is looks at a complaint. A complaint is filed by one person or another, and then the person who is defending that complaint has a series of processes they can do to try to defend that matter. They can have a demur file that says this complaint is without merit. They can have a motion to strike, and their job on the defense side is to limit what goes before the court. The court makes these decisions along the way. There's going to be evidentiary rulings, and if there's a matter where the facts are not in dispute,
1:07:28 But the law might be, then there's something called a motion for summary judgment. So everyone says, here's the facts, judge, we think the law is this, and the judge decides what that would be. Again, if a resolution cannot be made, it will go on to a trial. In each step of the way, the judge attempts to get the right result and do the right thing and make sure that the process is followed fairly. Thank you. Randy? No, we don't have a chart. Larry, do you have a chart that we can borrow?
1:07:59 You must have one. You've got one that covers everything. I think in the simplest terms, and that's a good question because people really sometimes talk about what a judge does, but unless you have the misfortune of being in front of the judge, either as a criminal defendant, which is significantly misfortunate, especially since there's a lot of room in the jail now,
1:08:29 Or if you're involved in a civil dispute, however defined, and that's broadly defined, whether it's a battle over money, which is one kind of a civil dispute, or you've been injured, and it's called a personal injury case, or you're in a divorce with fighting over property and kids, which is really unfortunate. No matter what type,
1:08:57 of situation you're in. In a simple sense, the judge acts as the referee. And the referee that is making rulings, just like a referee does, between the parties. In a criminal case between the prosecution and the defendant.
1:09:21 And in a civil case between the two parties that are fighting over money or custody or injury or whatever it is. The judge, the reason that a judge needs experience is because the judge needs to know what the law is in acting as a referee in either of these matters. He needs experience in the law and knows how to apply the law that applies whether it's civil or criminal.
1:09:49 And as Mark suggested, matters are decided ultimately on evidence. The judge decides what evidence is going to be considered and evidence is going to result in the resolution of the case one way or the other. So what you need is a judge that knows the rules of evidence, that has a lot of experience with the law.
1:10:17 And that can apply those rules fairly and consistently with a lot of experience. Thank you. There are so many questions that I could ask. And what are the technical qualifications that an attorney must have to run for the position of superior court judge?
1:10:43 Mark, will you start that, please? There is only one, and that is that the person has been a lawyer for 10 years. And that's the only qualification. We may have, some of you may have read the book by Malcolm Gladwell called Outliers, which is the concept that if someone does something for 10,000 hours, they become an expert in that.
1:11:03 And anyone who practices law knows that in 10 years you're more likely practicing about 20,000 hours. And we all have more than 20 years of experience. So all of us here are highly qualified and well beyond the minimum bar to be the next Superior Court judge. Thank you. I'm going to vary a little bit from this because I'm going to, and I'll come back to you, Mark, but I think it's important for us, the members of the community,
1:11:31 Thank you. That's a good question.
1:12:05 It's a little difficult, I think, for someone to describe in detail in whatever I have, two minutes, the scope of experience and the breadth of knowledge. Suffice it to say, I'm 57 years old. I'm the old guy here. I've been doing this almost 10 years longer than Teresa and Mark, and they're both.
1:12:31 Highly competent and they're both qualified lawyers. I have significantly more experience in my view and I think it's borne out from any objective evaluation in the practice of law over a period of 32 years. So the experience is essential and going along with experience comes I think what we call judicial temperament.
1:13:01 The calmness, the wisdom, the patience, the ability to listen, the approachability, and the essentially the sense people have that you will be fair and competent and this is a sense I think that you can, I can describe it to you, I can say I'm calm and I can say I'm
1:13:32 And I can say that I have judicial temperament, although I think that my 17-year-old might sometime dispute that. So would my 10-year-old. I think in looking and judging candidates,
1:13:52 For Judge and the experience you can look at objectively. The temperament I think is something that you can only glean and get appreciation for from speaking with people within the community, all over the community who have come to know you, have come to know what you're about, have come to know your personality and your temperament and I would urge everyone when you're checking us out to talk to the people who know us.
1:14:20 Thank you, Randy. Therese? Well, I agree with Randy, what he says about judicial temperament. Ever since I was a young girl, I knew that I wanted to be a judge. When I was about nine years old, my mother remarried, and I was very excited when she did that. I went to school, and I told my teacher in my class that I had a new dad, and that he was such a great guy, he was really interesting.
1:14:52 And he'd climbed Mount Kilimanjaro. My teacher then punished me, sent me to the principal's office, and punished me for telling a lie. She said, I'm sure that Teresa's new dad is really a great guy, but he didn't climb Mount Kilimanjaro. I went home and I told that to my dad, and he said, okay. And the next morning he sent me to school with the summit photos from Mount Kilimanjaro. And he said, Teresa never let anybody...
1:15:21 Judge you without having all of the evidence. And I have lived by that principle since then. I knew right then that that's what I wanted to do. I wanted to make things fair for other people. And that's how I've practiced here in Mono County and in Minnesota. When I went to law school in Minnesota, I worked full time. I was a law review editor. I was a judicial law clerk in both trial court and at the court of appeal in both of those positions.
1:15:50 We worked very, very hard. We had many, many cases come before us. I think at the court of appeal, the 12-judge court that I worked for, they said that that court of appeal was churning out a decision once every 74 minutes. It was an extremely busy situation. I then went and worked for a very large law firm, a 200-lawyer law firm in downtown Minneapolis. I worked for major corporations, Cargill, Honeywell, Department of Defense.
1:16:20 And we had billion-dollar cases. And I thought to myself, gee, justice must be something different than moving piles of money from this person to this person. I then went to the Denver office. Then I came to Mono County. And I started a small practice here. I believe in access to justice. And I believe in providing people with a fair hearing. That's why I'm most qualified. Thank you. Mark?
1:16:48 Thank you. I've been practicing law in Mono County since 1987. I have worked for two local law firms, and I have worked for the county of Mono, providing effective public service as a deputy district attorney, as the child support director, and now in the county counsel's office. That breadth of experience of seeing every type of case in depth is the first reason why I am the most qualified to be the next Superior Court judge. It's not about the
1:17:17 Length of experience. It's about the quality of the experience. It's about each case you look at and do the right thing. I can say by being a deputy district attorney, I took those values representing the people in the state of California to be the highest honor I could have. And in that role, you review a police report, you make the decision as to whether or not a crime should be charged, what that crime should be, what the disposition should be.
1:17:43 And in that role, you are acting as in a quasi-judicial manner. You are acting as a judge. That role shifts when a defense attorney comes in and says, I disagree with you. The facts aren't that way. And if you still believe that that's the right thing, you now switch to being an advocate and you understand the rules of evidence and understand what you need to do to persuade a jury of your peers to reach a conviction and persuade the judge to merit a sentence. After that, I practice family law. I understand the impact of...
1:18:11 Motions and financial difficulties on families going through a divorce in custody cases and I'm aware of those dynamics and would help people work through that process. As Child Support Director, I work with many, many people in determining how to move forward with their lives when one party thinks they're paying too much and the other party thinks they're not getting enough and I was able to reach a resolution in almost all of those cases and did not have to go to court in those cases.
1:18:37 Working for the county has given me a tremendous breadth of experience in personnel law, land use law, child dependency, and in every other respect where the government interfaces with the citizens. I think that my experience and my judicial temperament will make me a very outstanding judge. Thank you, Mark. Since experience is such a big
1:19:02 Player here. I'd like to ask you all some questions about your experience, and we'll start with Therese. Therese, how many jury trials have you litigated to judgment? Boy, I don't know the answer to that. I've litigated several civil and criminal trials. I recently tried a 26 felony count case here. I think I started out here in about 1996, and I immediately, within a couple of months of
1:19:32 Taking the California bar, I opened up a small practice and I had a couple of six felony cases. I think I probably tried about seven or eight criminal trials, felony and misdemeanor. Civil trials, I've probably tried a half dozen. Thank you. Mark? I've had 17 jury trials.
1:20:03 They were criminal cases. I was in the district attorney's office. In that time, I was in the district attorney's office. I tried as many cases as been tried since that time I left. Fortunately, I did not have to try any civil cases because of the tremendous expense in those cases. I was able to resolve those cases prior to going to a jury trial. In my entire practice, Jack, I've tried probably 37 cases.
1:20:37 37 to 40 cases. 11 of those have been jury trials. A couple of the jury trials have been significant over a period of weeks, so complex jury trials, both civil and criminal. And I think it's important to note that in practice, and especially in a private practice, a lot of what is done, evidentiary-wise,
1:21:08 Adversarial wise, similar to what you're doing in court is conducting motions, summary judgment motions that Mark had described, depositions which are just like examining people in court and other contested matters in court. I can tell you that I've done in my significant civil experience
1:21:37 In complex civil cases, I've probably done over 100 depositions and an equal number of contested motions. In criminal cases, not just trials are what you look at in terms of experience. In many criminal cases before you ever get to a trial, in felony cases, you undergo what's called a preliminary hearing.
1:22:06 Which is an evidentiary hearing that can go on for a day or days. And I've been involved in probably a hundred preliminary hearings over the course of my 22 years practicing here in Mono County. So the courtroom experience, and I think we'll all attest to this.
1:22:26 It is broader than just going to trial. Fortunately, most cases don't go to trial, but my experience has been, both in civil cases and criminal cases, vastly greater than just the approximately 37 to 40 trials I've done. Thank you. I'd like to start this... I've lost my spot. Where am I now? You ended with me. Okay, well...
1:22:55 Let's still have a chart. I'd like to ask a question about appellate court experience. And I'd like to know if, and we'll start with Therese, if you have ever brought a case in front of the appellate court. I've brought several cases before the appellate court, both here and in Minnesota. I don't know if you want me to...
1:23:25 Well, I'd love it if you would tell us what that means. I'll tell you what that means. When you appear before the Court of Appeal, you are actually asking the court to review a decision that occurred in the trial court. And that court doesn't have the litigants necessarily before it. It just has...
1:23:51 The record from the trial court, excuse me, and there are oral arguments that are scheduled. You argue before the court and they have just the record from the trial court proceedings and they make a decision based upon that. I've appeared before the California Court of Appeals about six or seven times and I've appealed before the Minnesota Court of Appeals on about a dozen times. Thank you. Mark?
1:24:19 I've done several appeals. Fortunately or unfortunately, it would have been an honor to do so. I never had to go to Sacramento and argue those. The appeals were decided by the written work. What an appeal is, is after an evidentiary hearing or a trial, one of the parties says, hey, something was done wrong here. There was a matter of law that was not applied correctly. The trier of fact, usually a judge, either did not have substantial evidence,
1:24:46 To make the decision or they acted in an arbitrary or capricious manner. So the first thing that's done is set up the stage. There's very formulaic requirements of pleadings that are done. They have to be done on certain colors, with a certain format, with certain spacing. And so it's a very regulated process. So every appellate judge up in Sacramento, we're in the third district, would see basically the same kind of format and the same kind of binding for the appellate and the respondent.
1:25:13 And in that case, you lay them out. You lay out the factors. You lay out what the issue of the case is. You lay out what the main issues are. And then you get into an in-depth, complex analysis of the law and why the law applies to the facts and why, if you're in favor of the decision, you won in the trial court, that the law was, the judge ruled correctly. If you were lost, you're trying to persuade the appellate court that the judge made a mistake. And so you use your arguments. It's a fun and fascinating.
1:25:41 Thank you, Mark. Randy? Typically, the appellate process involves a panel of judges, not just one judge. So, as Mark had described, and I think pretty well, the process of the appeal is if there is some kind of a legal mistake that has been so egregious under the law,
1:26:13 That it merits this panel of judges looking and saying, okay, is that mistake so egregious that we need to send, that it has prejudiced the case and we need to send the case back and do it again? I have, and I don't know if it's fortunate or unfortunate, some of the cases I've been involved on appeals are because I lost.
1:26:40 So I guess those were unfortunate. Some are because I won and I had to defend, but in my years of experience I have argued before various courts of appeal six different times. One case twice out of independence and it is a fascinating area of the law. Typically what happens is
1:27:08 A lawyer that's involved in a case where appeal is going to be taken, if the lawyer I think is wise, will typically get assistance, if not to really take over and completely handle the appeal, but at least get somebody else to come in and help you.
1:27:34 The dangers of a lawyer handling his or her own appeal is that typically the issue on appeal, unfortunately, often involves a mistake that the lawyer, him or herself made. So what you see is that often in appeals you get a lawyer that's going to get somebody else in
1:27:58 Thank you. If I may add one follow-up.
1:28:19 I think we'd all agree. One of the most important things a trial court judge can do is make sure the record is very clean and very clear and that objections are very clear and that evidence is properly marked and admitted and that when someone makes a statement, the court reporter is able to hear it. That's one of the primary functions of a trial judge.
1:28:38 To make sure there is a good record so that if it goes to appeal, the appellate court will have a real good sense of what happened in the trial court. And typically those errors are in admissibility or unadmissibility of evidence. So I agree with Mark. You need a judge that knows the rules of evidence, a lot of experience in dealing with that so you don't end up doing it all over again. Well, you guys sort of took over for me. Out of fairness, Therese, do you want to add anything to this?
1:29:10 I have a question about court administration that I'll come back to, which is sort of some of the tasks you're talking about. Who is the boss? Who does the superior court judge report to? And we'll start with Mark.
1:29:34 Well, as a junior judge, if elected, there would be the presiding judge. In this case, it would be Judge Eller. You have to be a judge, I think it's five years before you can be the presiding judge. Generally, the presiding judge makes the assignments to the other judges. In a larger county, like Los Angeles County, you would be assigned to a juvenile court or a family court or very specialized courts. Here, the sense is it's going to be a pretty good close working relationship to figure out how to properly assign the...
1:30:03 Cases to somebody. So in one sense your boss is the presiding judge. In a real sense though that your boss is the appellate courts.
1:30:13 Because you need to do your job correctly. The one thing a judge does not want to do is be reversed. You will work hard to make sure you make the right decision. You will work hard to make sure there's a clean record and that when you base your decision on the law and the facts, you get it right. So the appellate court could come back and say, you know, you got it wrong and no judge wants to be there. And finally, the real bosses of the judge are the people who elect the judge. And if you don't do a good job, you'll be voted out of office. Thank you. Randy?
1:30:46 I tend to agree with Mark, but I thought that, were you asking, Jack, who's in charge of court administration? No, I'm going to come back to court administration. I think that ultimately the boss, in quotes, is the law. The judge is required and is bound by
1:31:13 Required to follow and is bound by the law. So that's the judge's boss, which is done to the best of the judge's ability based on his experience and knowledge of the law and the letter of the law. But there are many, many situations where the judge has discretion. And as that is defined in the law,
1:31:43 His exact steps or decisions are not clear in the law or the facts. So the judge has discretion, but ultimate discretion to vary from one end of the spectrum to the other as long as it's within the bounds of the law. But ultimately the judge reports to and is bound to follow the law and then as Mark said, if he gets it wrong,
1:32:14 The Court of Appeal will let them know. Thank you, Randy. Therese? Well, I don't disagree with that. I would add that a judge is, of course, accountable to the people, accountable to the judicial counsel, and accountable to the appellate courts to know the law, to research the law, to keep abreast of new developments in the law, both in case law, in legislative law, and...
1:32:44 And that would be either state law or federal law and to correctly apply the law. And if you're not, if this is not just limited to who we're accountable to, we would also be accountable, at least in an administrative sense, to the clerk of court. That would be Hector Gonzalez here in Mona County. Thank you.
1:33:14 One of you mentioned judicial discretion. I did. Yes, Randy. Let the record show. For good or ill, I don't know if I should have owned up. Because I feel a question coming. A question is coming. And I think this is an appropriate question, but if it's not, correct me. Recently there was a sentence handed down.
1:33:43 By the Superior Court for a repeat sex offender. And that sentence was proved to be quite controversial in local paper and in local coffee shops, etc. And that many people felt that that sentence was too lenient compared to what the repeat nature of the crime. And it was alleged.
1:34:13 That the DA had asked for the maximum, but the judge had changed the sentence and not given the maximum. So my question is, it's kind of a bit deeper question. On one hand, how do you balance when a judge makes, exercises discretion, the will of the people with the letter of the law?
1:34:46 And with your own discretion. So I'd like to start with Teresa on that. Well, any time a judge makes a sentencing decision, the judge has before him or her a whole series of factors. The judge has to look at the arguments of the district attorney, the arguments of defense counsel. The defense counsel would file something that's called a statement in mitigation.
1:35:14 And that expresses from the defense point of view what the sentence should be. There are certain statutory factors that the judge has to look at. Factors in aggravation or factors in mitigation. There are factors such as whether or not the defendant is a recidivist, whether he or she has committed the crime more than one time or has a long criminal record. The court is looking at three basic things. Protection of the public.
1:35:43 The character of the defendant and the gravity of the offense. So the variables there, you can imagine, it could be a very slight offense, but it could be one where you really need to protect the public. It could be that this is a 17-year-old kid who's never been in trouble before and he thought that what he was doing was legal or lawful.
1:36:14 There are all kinds of factors that a judge has to weigh and that's where judicial discretion comes in. There's also a report that is typically done by the probation department and the judge is duty bound to consider the report of probation. And recently there have been new legislation enacted where the judge has more of an opportunity to consider statements from the victim and the victim's family.
1:36:40 There are many, many, many factors to consider in rendering a decision in a sentencing. It's considered misconduct for a judicial candidate or a judge to ever say, I would give more weight to this particular factor than I would to that particular factor, especially at this stage of the game. But it is the judge's responsibility to carefully and considerately
1:37:09 Review all of the factors before rendering a decision. Thank you. Mark? Without knowing all the facts and hearing all the argument, it would be impossible for anybody up here to say how they would rule on a particular matter. So when looking at criminal justice, the four pillars of the criminology system are punishment, deterrence, rehabilitation, and restitution. So you'd look at all those factors. You'd consider the argument of the district attorney.
1:37:36 You'd consider the facts and argument made by the defense attorney. The probation department would do a thorough evaluation and apply the factors that are in the rules of court to see what their recommendation would be. You'd hear from the victim. You would take all that into consideration when rendering a sentence and taking all that public policy in mind when rendering a decision. It's important that the judiciary be independent from the executive branch.
1:38:05 And that includes the district attorney's office. The district attorney makes a reasoned plea, and I was a district attorney for many years, and I would argue the heck out of a case, and I would sometimes be very disappointed when a judge gave a decision that I was not in favor of. I thought it was a miscarriage of justice. I mean, I believed in that with all my heart. Yet I would never, never go to the press, and I would never, ever
1:38:32 Second guess the judge because I have respect for the law and respect for the process and I would move on to the next case. Now if there was an evidentiary ruling that I could appeal and generally as a prosecution you don't get many opportunities to appeal but that is how I look at it. The district attorney has a job to do and they do it very well with passion and commitment but the court has an important job to do. At each level of the criminal defense system there's a safeguard. There's the man in the street.
1:39:00 Highway Patrol, the Sheriff's Department. They make a decision as to what charge should be crimed or someone should be arrested. Then the district attorney is the next gatekeeper. But the next gatekeeper up is the judge. One of the things of judicial temperament in all definitions is courage. And that means standing up to an ill-conceived will of the people who don't have all the facts. Thank you. Randy. I think that in selecting a judge, and that's what we're here about tonight,
1:39:31 That the appointors, the selectors, the population, the voters here have to trust that the candidate is going to exercise discretion in a wise, fair way without prejudging anything, without even referring to or suggesting any reference.
1:40:02 To the case that you have mentioned, Jack, I think it's important that the community have confidence that the judge is going to exercise discretion wisely. And the way the community gets to that is by knowing the candidate, by knowing the people that know the candidate. I think it's important, and I'm going to at risk of
1:40:31 Offending Therese who doesn't believe in endorsements and I know why you said that and I agree that we should not be ever placed in the position of having a... I'd rather you didn't address her. I'd rather just say what you want to say. I'm sorry. I'm sorry. Thank you. The people that know me and know how I would exercise discretion include the District Attorney, George Booth, include...
1:41:01 President of the Mammoth Elementary School, Shanna Bissonnett, President of the Mammoth Middle School Organization, Julie Thompson, Vice President of the MHS Boosters, Leslie Dawson, Judge Denton, three members of the school board, Gloria Vasquez, Dr. Bourne and Betty Kittle, and Judge Denton. And I think...
1:41:25 It is ultimately the voters who have to feel comfortable that the judge is going to exercise discretion in a sound fashion. And I think it's those voters who know the candidates that make that determination. Thank you. Thank you. And I apologize for breaking the ground rules.
1:41:47 I'm overruled. That must mean you guys need a break for a few minutes. We'll take a break from our judicial candidates and we'll come back to our supervisory candidates. Get those juices going and get your brain back in gear. I think an interesting topic came up with our sheriff's candidates that is pertinent to the supervisory candidates and that is
1:42:16 This idea of potentially a jail facility somewhere in the south county. This is not a new idea, but I'd like to know what your thoughts are with regards to that. Bill? One of the things I've said over and over is that the county and town need to find more ways to cooperate. I don't know about joining the two forces. There are reasons.
1:42:45 That the town and the corporation decided to come up with its own police force, but I think a joint facility is something worth looking at. Is it appropriate or not? We won't know until we do the work and look at where it could go and how it could function. But certainly it is one of the things that the town and county could look at. Town needs a new jail facility, there's no question. Look at where they're residing today.
1:43:14 The county needs a south county jail. The study has shown that. There may be cost savings in joining the facilities, not the departments, but creating one facility that can handle both needs. Thank you. And there are probably some job-sharing things that could go along as well with that. Larry? I've spoken with the sheriff about this a little bit, and the jail, as he indicated, is understaffed, if you will.
1:43:45 And I hope that we can keep it that way. And I think there's a number of things that we can do to try to minimize the amount of crime in the area. That's first. I don't think that a total new jail is necessary in the South County. I think it would – you might be able to pay for it some way, generate some funds or get some grants to do it, but the operating costs –
1:44:14 I would agree we might need some form of holding facility and I would think that also we could work together a little bit more with the police and the sheriff in transporting prisoners and so on. So that's my thought on the jail.
1:44:44 Sorry. One other thought. Some of you may have heard of the Sheriff Joe from Maricopa County, Arizona. And I think we should investigate a few more ideas that he's been implementing. And I know there's some issues. This is what I actually spoke to the Sheriff about. I know there's some issues with that. But I think there could be some ways to see our prisoners.
1:45:14 Doing a lot more for the public. Just as an example, we don't need any new specialized equipment to clear sidewalks in Bridgeport. We've got the prisoners. In the snowy seasons, we could take them out there and do that. So I think there's a number of things we could do along those lines if we really wanted to look at it. I'll write that down. And washing cars.
1:45:46 I'd like to ask you directly, you're currently employed by the county? Yes. And if you are elected to the position of supervisor, will you remain employed by the county and be a supervisor? I believe that would be a conflict of interest and I would not. Can you tell us how you would handle that situation? If I were to be elected, I would resign. Not sure when, but before I took office. Okay.
1:46:17 Thank you. Bill, you are a renowned advocate for motorized recreation. Recreation. Motorized recreation. Recreation. And I'd like to know many of the people in District 1 are not so keen on motorized recreation. And how will you represent them as well as
1:46:44 And as effectively as you have been an advocate for motorized access. I think putting me in the corner as a motorized advocate only puts me in a corner I've never been in. If we look at the trail system that the motorized public helped put together, the Orange Diamond Trail System, and the grooming dollars we brought to Mammoth and the Indian National Forest from the state level, I went to the state specifically and fought very hard to get an exemption of the rules that that grooming equipment could not groom.
1:47:13 Non-motorized trails. Hence, today, on the Indian National Forest, we have a Blue Diamond Trail System that is groomed with motorized dollars. I have also been on the Park and Rec Commission for a number of years, part of the process in the Sherwins. I sat on the CAT crew with the Indian National Forest, deciding the fate of a lot of roads. I've helped create the trail system in Mammoth. So, putting me in motorized only...
1:47:41 Isn't fair. What Mammoth needs and what the county needs to be successful is a motorized, non-motorized recreation system so that we can bring outdoor enthusiasts, regardless what their enthusiasm is for, motorized or not, here to fill our beds and buy in our stores and get gas at the gas station and create a sustainable economy.
1:48:09 So it's not about motorized or non-motorized. It's about creating systems on both sides that are world class and work for our needs. And I think I work. Thank you, Bill. And I work very hard towards that end. Remember, it's not the House of Commons. Larry, earlier in the evening you mentioned you had some ideas about employment solutions.
1:48:37 And I wonder if we could go back to that, and you might like to elaborate on that for a moment. Well, I'll show you my last. Wait a minute. I've got some graphs here. I hope that can be seen by most people. What this shows is the trend of building permits issued over the last 18 years in Mono County. And you can see that
1:49:07 It was pretty steady for a number of years until 1985 when the boom years hit. And then it precipitously decreased to almost nothing. It went from 80 building permits in 2005 to last year we had nine building permits issued in the county, four of which were stick built. And what this has done is essentially devastate the construction industry.
1:49:37 Put together a series of potential stimulus ideas because this is drastic times and drastic times call for drastic measures. First of all, I would look at, and I'll find it here in a second, looking at training for construction workers to enable better transition to new green technologies.
1:50:06 Promote construction job opportunities, and this is somewhat controversial, by providing free building permits for all green projects such as solar weatherization, efficient appliances, and so on, windows. I would temporarily suggest that we do something drastic and initiate free building permits for single-family stick-built units that are started within the next year.
1:50:32 I would reduce or eliminate the county's development impact fee, and I have a number of reasons for that. It is different than the town's. I would streamline the development process wherever possible, especially for minor projects. I provide instruction and training for local contractors to be more competitive in the bidding process. And within the law, I increase bidding preferences for locally based contractors. And I would do this now before the industry is decimated.
1:50:59 Thank you. Bill, would you like to take a crack at that question? I think the lull in building isn't just because of the fees. You can't get a loan. I'm not sure that on the county level there's a lot you can do there. I think that the county and the town perhaps rely too much on the building segment and don't build enough the recreation and tourism segment.
1:51:28 I think that if you want to straighten the economy and keep a lot of the ups and downs from happening, you have to concentrate on something that is sustainable, and I think our rec base and our tourist base economy has managed to do that. I will agree, DIF fees should be looked at as a way to bring something back, but regardless of what the town and county fees are, you're not going to see building until someone can go out and get a loan for it, and right now that just isn't going to happen.
1:51:58 Thank you. Bill, I'd like to, in a recent edition of the Mammoth Times, you made a reference to the North County versus South County schism. Can you explain what that is and elaborate on that a little? I can't explain why it is, but my entire life living in Mono County, there has been a
1:52:30 Break between the people of the North County and the people of the South. I mean, I think part of the reason for incorporation in the first place, regardless what reasons we give for today, was because the people of Mammoth wanted to take control of their own destiny because they weren't getting a fair shake from county government at the time. I would love to have the opportunity to sit, and as a supervisor might get that opportunity, to sit with the North County folks and explain to them that really we're all riding in the same boat.
1:52:59 Anything we can do to lift Mammoth lifts the rest of the county. And in fact, if you look at property values and if you look at the last great rise in values, they start with Mammoth. Mammoth is the hub, like it or don't like it, and it works out from there. I'd love to have the opportunity to sit with them and explain we're not trying to take anything from them. We're not trying to take their customers, and we would love to work together.
1:53:27 To put us all in a better, more stable financial position. And I've never understood it. Larry, would you like to address that question? The schism? Between the North County and the South County. Or maybe it's North County, South County, Mammoth. In my professional job right now, I attend almost all the Regional Planning Advisory Committee means from North County to South County.
1:53:57 I think it's more, I don't think it's a schism. I think it's more of just learning about each other a little better and trying to understand that perhaps some communities are different than Mammoth and they need to also learn that Mammoth is different from them. And we can do that in a number of ways and we're working on that through the different supervisorial districts that each go out and represent.
1:54:25 Thank you. I find it personally a little perplexing that District 1 is essentially entirely in the town of Mammoth Lakes.
1:54:56 So there would appear to be a jurisdictional issue between the town of Mammoth Lakes and how it influences the population of District 1 and the county and how the county influences the population of District 1. And I would really like to know what can the District 1 supervisor do to improve the quality of life for people in District 1. I'd like to start with Bill.
1:55:29 I think it's as simple as partnering with the town, finding a way to help. You know, the county has built beautiful community centers in a lot of the other communities in the county. Mammoth, who puts in the majority of the property tax dollars, doesn't have such a beautiful community center. There are a lot of ways that the county can partner with the town to build facilities and infrastructure.
1:55:58 That are going to directly relate to the people of District 1. It's not hard. It's communication and representing your district hard at the county level. Thank you. Larry? The county is, it overlaps a lot here in town. And I think the, just in my canvassing and talking to people, again, one of the main considerations is how do we stabilize our tourism base.
1:56:29 And how do we diversify our job base? I've got a number of ideas that we might do that. Certainly cooperating with the tourism departments in each jurisdiction. Continuing county's fish stocking efforts, that has a spin-off to the jobs in the town. We need to look at creating better geotour.
1:56:57 Tourism-based employment opportunities, and we're doing that with the National Geographic and Sierra Business Council efforts. We need to rethink some of our transportation projects to include more unique visitor experiences. I would like to see a revisit of the Tioga Pass Heritage Road. Right now, the county, through the Local Transportation Commission,
1:57:26 Which the county and the town both sit on. Has sent a lot of money south, and you've seen the fruits of that effort in the four-lanning of 395, especially south of Bishop. We have an agreement that one day we will get money back. And I believe that one of the things we can do is capitalize on the Yosemite National Park east side entrance and create something that's similar to the going to the Sun Highway in Glacier National Park, which is a tremendous...
1:57:54 Summertime attraction. I'd like to see us, again, assist with operation improvements related to Yosemite Airport. Securing more shoulder season employment opportunities, and I have in mind there creating a training-based destination for the shoulder seasons. When I look at going to something training-wise, I look at going to someplace really nice.
1:58:19 To go and take training courses and we could do something very similar to that here. Thank you. You guys can take a breather now. I'd like to move back to the sheriff candidates. I guess that's not exactly accurate. One of you is the sheriff. Thank you. You are both running for the office. I'd like to clarify some statements that are at least attributed to you both in the local press.
1:58:50 And so I'd like to start with Rick, and I'd like you to clarify for us what you mean by community policing. What is that? You know, it's the core value of successful law enforcement. It's the community and law enforcement working together to solve problems. We've got basically 11 different communities within the county, and each one's unique, and each one has their own set of, let's say, community standards.
1:59:19 And unless you work in those communities on a regular basis, you may not understand what that community standard is. And it's really to get out of your cars, to get into the schools, to get into the businesses, to actually talk to the people to help solve the problems that they see as what issues they're confronted with. You know, we're pretty lucky in our amount of crime in the county, and part one crimes have been reduced by a significant...
1:59:48 Thank you. Doug, you've been quoted in the paper as saying
2:00:17 Right, you believe that right is right and wrong is wrong. Can you elaborate on that for us? Absolutely. You know, over the years there's, and I'm talking over the past 22 years I've been here certainly, and my guess is it went on long before that because it happens in every community, is you have issues of favoritism shown by law enforcement toward certain people in the communities.
2:00:45 There's always allegations of cover-ups and other things that go on and that's just typical of any time you have interaction with law enforcement and the people in the communities. And I think that the bottom line is that when you break the law, there's a process to be followed, regardless of who you are, that sends you into the possible jurisdiction of the judges. And I don't think that a sheriff
2:01:14 A sheriff deputy, a highway patrolman, a highway patrol sergeant, a highway patrol lieutenant should make a decision that's political in nature as opposed to following the law. That nobody should be exempt from the law. I think that it breeds distrust. It breeds not having the faith in your law enforcement agencies that they're going to do the right thing. And it isn't always our decision to
2:01:44 There should not always be our decision. We are allowed a lot of discretion in what we do, you know, between verbal warnings, between arrests, but it depends on what that crime is for, you know, and infractions we have ultimate discretion. Misdemeanors, the discretionary powers go down tremendously. Felonies, there is absolutely no discretion. And I think that over the years there's been allegations made against probably every department in Mono County of
2:02:12 Of that type of behavior going on, and I would make sure that it doesn't happen while I was sheriff. Okay. To the sheriff's department. Thank you. Along this same line of conversation, Rick, you also have mentioned that officers must use common sense. That's what this job is all about. We're working with human beings. Human beings make mistakes, and we have to be, I think, utilize our own common sense on how we deal with the situations.
2:02:44 And, you know, I'm really proud of the men and women of this sheriff's department. They have come, you know, through the trenches, so to speak, and every time that we get attacked, whether it's in the letters to the editor or whatever, you know, we come out on top. And, you know, it is. It's common sense. That's what this job is all about. It's dealing with people. I mean, we've got all these things to be able to accomplish the job, but none of those things work without people.
2:03:11 Thank you. It's common sense.
2:03:39 Doug, you also meant, well, I don't know if you did or not, but you were quoted as saying something to the effect that you advocate traffic stops as an enforcement tool. Can you advocate or can you explain that to us? Absolutely. If you think about our society today, it's a very mobile society. I mean, who in Mono County doesn't have a car for the most part?
2:04:09 The criminal element that comes to Mammoth to sell its drugs, to transport its drugs here to other parts of the county come by vehicle. It only makes sense to me that you be allowed the freedom to stop vehicles for lawful violations of the law and pursue any evidentiary stuff that comes up or any indicators that come up of drug trafficking, of being an unlicensed or suspended driver.
2:04:36 To the mechanical violations, to the moving violations. And it shouldn't matter whether you're in a black and white car or a solid white car. It just shouldn't matter. I think there's a perception, and I've heard this numerous times throughout the communities, that, and it disturbs me, and I'll tell you why, that the audience out here can attest to this probably, is that when they look in their review mirror and they haven't been paying any attention for a little while and they see a black and white behind them, my guess is, is that
2:05:05 Their heart rate jumps up a little bit. Yeah, I think I can confirm that for you. Absolutely. And what I'm hearing is that, and I'm hearing it from the deputies, I'm hearing it from citizens in the community, that they're just not, they just don't have that heart rate jump when they see the white vehicle behind them of the Sheriff's Department. And that should not be. That there's always, it's always good the way you deter crime.
2:05:34 To a certain extent is by the presence of the police. The presence of law enforcement deters crime. And that should be all crime. The deputies absolutely have, just like every law enforcement officer, absolute discretion. When they stop that vehicle for the traffic violation, they have the ability to issue the verbal warning, to provide education. We have a lot of tourists up here. We have a lot of people that don't understand the rules of the road.
2:06:03 Providing that education component could save a life down the road. And it doesn't matter if you're driving the black and white or the solid white. Thank you. Doug, I have to ask you a difficult question. This comes from our audience here. We are all pretty familiar with the difficulties the Eastern Sierra School District is having. And you are on that board.
2:06:35 I'd like you to explain to us why we should vote for you given the difficulties that that board has experienced with their budget. Absolutely. That's a very valid question. And, you know, it's one of the issues that I've had to face over this campaign, and time means everything, right? So if they hadn't been in the issue, it wouldn't be an issue. And I think the difference…
2:07:03 The reason why people should vote for me and have confidence in me, I think, is the leadership I provided as a minority member of the board regarding the decisions that have been made that I think are core, go to my core beliefs that you have to do the right thing for people. And I've spent my entire career doing the right thing. And I absolutely disagree with the management of the district and their
2:07:33 Their process for dealing with the budget crisis. We are absolute extreme opposites of how that should be dealt with. And my goal, and every parent in here should understand this, that administrators do not teach kids. There is not a single person in the district office that teaches kids. That teachers teach kids. Teachers in the classroom, aides in the classroom, are the best.
2:08:03 Value that we have to educate children. That is their job. And the further, my contention is, is you keep the cuts the furthest away from the classroom. And we have a serious disagreement on the Eastern Sierra Board about where those cuts are to be made. My goal is to keep it away from the classroom. And if people don't want to vote for me because I want to keep teachers in the classroom, then I really don't want their vote.
2:08:30 That I want them to know that they can have the confidence in me to do the right thing as sheriff. I'm running for sheriff. I'm not running for school board. I've got two years off of my term. And if I become sheriff, I'll probably have to resign from that as a conflict of interest of holding two public offices. But I absolutely have the character, the moral character, the moral fiber to choose the right and fight for my beliefs. And you should want that out of your sheriff, that he is going to fight for what is right, regardless of...
2:08:59 This political race or any other political race, I feel very strongly about that. Thank you for the question. Rick, how many total employees does the Sheriff's Department have? We're right at 60 right now. And what is the annual budget of the Sheriff's Department? Approximately $10.2 million. And where are you in that budget as of this fiscal year? We're under budget. We have...
2:09:29 Basically seven different budgets within the sheriff's office and we monitor it weekly. I meet with my financial person and we're audited by the county finance department also on a regular basis and we review that. We just came up at mid-year budget review to make sure that we're not overextending our budget in any way, shape, or form. You know, this last year...
2:09:55 Well, when I started, we were down about 40% in our patrol force and our corrections staff. And since I took over office, we increased it to full staffing. Not only that, we actually increased the department by three new positions without expending any additional general fund dollars. So we were able to do that through grants and things. And, yeah, we're right on target. And hopefully with the last three years, we've come in just at or below our allocated budget.
2:10:25 Doug, you mentioned earlier in your introduction that you have been a previous business owner and that you have managed budgets in that capacity. Can you give us a little more detail on that? Have you managed people? Have you managed a large group of people and a large budget? I guess you could say that as a sole proprietorship,
2:10:57 I managed myself and my wife. I didn't do a very good job managing my wife. You just got yourself off the hook on that. But, you know, I think the management part of it is, how do I want to say this? To a certain extent, the management part of the sheriff's job is, if you think about the structure of the sheriff's department, he has an undersheriff. He has two lieutenants.
2:11:31 That comprise a management staff. And the sheriff relies heavily on that staff of managers that he has under him. What the sheriff provides or should provide is leadership. And I've spent my entire career formulating my leadership skills and improving them and moving them to a point where I believe they would be a great benefit to the sheriff's department. Managerial-wise, yes, I think that
2:11:59 As far as employees go, obviously as you're one of five board members on the school and you manage the superintendent. That is your role. The problem is you have to do it with five other people. The obvious advantage to being sheriff is that the buck stops with you, period. You are the elected official. You are the boss. And that every decision, good or bad, your employees make, it's your problem. You should accept responsibility for that.
2:12:30 I'm willing to do that. I'm willing to not assign blame, but take blame. And I've done that in every job I've had, that if it's my screw-up or my people screw-up that I'm responsible for, and I'm responsible for the 21 officers in my office as their representative, and from time to time, believe it or not, I have trouble when they screw-up, and I have to help them out of that mess and see them through it and manage the damage.
2:12:59 Et cetera, just like the sheriff does for his people. I thought I'd, Rick, you, no doubt you know that there's been some controversy over the last couple of years between how, in the town of Mammoth Lakes, between, and the local police department about how we handle our wildlife issues here. We, we all like, we love the bears.
2:13:27 We like to think we can live with them in our society and that we can peacefully coexist. And what role does the Sheriff's Department play in the wildlife problems on the bigger arena of the county? We get calls for service just like they do in the town of Mammoth Lakes with bears from the Tri-Valley area up to Walker-Coleville.
2:13:54 We respond. We basically do the same kind of aversion techniques that has been utilized in the town of Mammoth Lakes for many, many years. I personally, when the town, when it became a big controversial issue of what was going on with the town, I made it a point to contact the wildlife, let's say, experts for the Yellowstone National Park to try to ask them, what works? What's working for you guys? I mean, Yellowstone...
2:14:24 It entertains millions of visitors every year. They have not, you know, just the typical bears that are around here, but they got the grizzlies that eat people. And I said, so I need to know, what do we need to do as a county? I've dealt with the Fish and Game, worked with them, and discussed, you know, we've had a training program. We've also developed a policy in how to deal with the bears, with basically euthanasia as being the last resort. I mean, we don't want to do that.
2:14:49 But it boils down to, as I talked with the people in Yellowstone, it's education. It's taking the food source away from the bears and it's educating the public. I know Bear With Us has been trying to do that. Steve Searle's been doing that for many years. And that is the bottom line. The aversion, as I said, they can tranquilize a bear, put it down, put it in a net, haul it 300 miles away via helicopter, and that bear will be in the same location within a week. Because the aversion techniques...
2:15:18 And things according to the, you know, Yellowstone National Park don't work on a long-term basis. So it's taking away the food source and educating the public to do that. So that's what we've been trying to do. Thank you. Doug, who does the sheriff answer to? The sheriff answers obviously every four years to the voters. He has to work closely with the board of supervisors to, they provide the budget, they approve a lot of the budget.
2:15:48 For him. So he answers in some ways to them or at least confers with them on a regular basis to ensure that they're assured that the taxpayer's money is being spent properly. And the bottom line is your answer to the people. That phone, I've no doubt, rings a lot. Thank you. You guys can breathe easy now. I just had one comment on Sheriff Joe.
2:16:16 Yes. Ever since I've been in office, believe me, I get the weekly emails about here's what Sheriff Joe has done. We actually do an awful lot of those things. Our inmates, especially when we're at full staffing, when we have enough people, not only our jailers, but we have enough inmates to go out. They're on work programs almost every day in the county. We clean the cemeteries. We've already been elicited to clean the Jazz Jubilee sites.
2:16:45 And we do that. We have the inmates do that. They do clean the sidewalks in Bridgeport. Through jail funding money, we bought a brand new Honda snowblower two years ago so they could clean the sidewalks in Bridgeport. So we do a lot of those things, but we don't do a lot of the things that would keep the county council's office in business. Doug, in fairness, do you want to add anything? You know, I think that I grew up in San Diego County in San Diego Sheriff's Department.
2:17:14 has utilized a kind of like the state has with their camp facilities where they actually have camps where inmates go, trustees go, that are lesser risk and are utilized in that same regard. And it's a good way to house inmates and a much cheaper way to house inmates than building a jail. And there might be some possible funding for that that could be explored to maybe create a camp type.
2:17:44 Not the kind of camp, you know, that you send your kids to. But definitely a work camp. The CDC has a camp right down the road that's in combination with the California Department of Forestry. Those are all felons. A lot of the issues for the county jail are misdemeanants and could be utilized, I think, in that type of setting at a much lower cost.
2:18:11 That could do even more for the county and pay back some of that debt they owe society. So that's kind of what I think. Thank you. Gentlemen, you can take a breather. Our judicial candidates need to perk up. Yeah, here we go. Wake up. So I'd like, starting with Therese, how do you think the Mono County Grand Jury works today and is it functioning well?
2:18:45 I haven't yet read the grand jury report from this year. I think the grand jury functions very well. I think that it's an important part of our process, and I wouldn't change a thing. Mark? I think the grand jury is working very well. I've had the good fortune of advising the grand jury for the last several years. The first decision relative to the grand jury that a judge makes is getting good grand jurors. And fortunately, the judges have...
2:19:16 had excellent appointments to grand jurors who have been diligent, dedicated, interested in taking on various county departments and digging deep to understand what issues are. We have issues throughout the state. There's going to be a mid-year report coming out soon because of an issue of importance. And then they do a report. They make sure the report is
2:19:40 Gives good, solid recommendations. That's their primary job is to investigate something, investigate a complaint, then make a recommendation for the county to adopt or a city or a district to adopt. And they make those very thoughtfully and carefully. And I think the quality of the grand jury is reflective upon the very good citizens who are appointed to that function. Thank you. Randy? I think the grand jury process is important and vital. I agree that the...
2:20:10 And I have heard and become aware of frustration.
2:20:40 On the part of some of the good citizens that have worked on the grand jury, that their efforts are simply done and then not acted upon. So to that extent, I think that a role can be taken by the judge, the next judge, to ensure that that frustration, that sense that the work is done and then shelved can be addressed.
2:21:11 Someone earlier mentioned that the Mammoth and the county, Mono County, it's a small county, it's a small community. And the legal community is even smaller. And all of you have been here for a considerable amount of time and a big part of your career.
2:21:37 And no doubt you have established long-standing personal and professional relationships with other attorneys, including the district attorney, including the existing incumbent judge. And how do we, the people of Mono County, know that these relationships are not going to get in the way of judicial process in Mono County? I'd like to start with Mark. Well, first,
2:22:08 I'll start off with my time as a district attorney. And in that role, I worked with the defense lawyers and became friends with them. And not once did that friendship interfere with me doing my job. As county counsel, I work with lawyers and I work with county departments. And not once you can ask them, do I do anything but do the right thing?
2:22:32 Friendship is friendship and a professional responsibility and ethics and assuming the duty of every office I've taken, including the office of the court, would be the most important thing to do. And I'm able to separate that. In addition, I've been the president of the Mona County Bar Association for two or more terms, and I work well with all the lawyers in the town.
2:22:54 And throughout the county. I had an experience when I was a young lawyer going down to San Bernardino doing a trial, a court trial, and I was hometown. And I'll never forget that experience. I know what it's like to be treated unfairly and without respect. And I knew that because we went into chambers afterwards and the other lawyer was a friend of the family of that judge and he didn't tell me that. So I would treat everybody with respect.
2:23:24 Lawyer who provides any type of economic benefit of $150 or more, that judge has to disclose to the other parties that this lawyer has made a donation to me. If it's $1,500 or more, there has to be disqualification. So I take that very seriously, and from playing sports, we know that we can work hard, play hard, and then when the game is over, we can resume our friendship. But while I'd be wearing those robes, there'd be nothing but looking at the facts and the law.
2:23:53 Thank you, Mark. Randy? The small county aspect of the legal community here I think is a positive. I think that many of us have heard stories about practicing law in big counties where everything is impersonal, where there's a sense that
2:24:23 The work is being done simply to generate fees or to bill the client. There is real animosity within the legal community. I've practiced in Los Angeles. I know what that's about. I think that the small county aspect of the Mona County legal community is a positive because it allows
2:24:52 The lawyers and their clients and working with the judges to treat each other with respect and as human beings. And I don't see the small county aspect and the relationships that I think are beneficial in this community which foster resolution of cases, which tend to foster resolution of cases on behalf of the clients.
2:25:19 In a way that can be done quickly and more cheaply. And with the help of the judges and the participation of the judges and the respect that the judges have for the community, I think it's positive. Thank you. Therese? When I was mentored by my judges at both the trial court and the appellate court level back east, one of their predominant concerns were being too buddy-buddy.
2:25:51 With other members of the judiciary, with county employees, with even other practitioners. That's something that I've taken seriously for my entire career. When I said that I don't take endorsements, it is because in this small, small community, I find that it at least shows the appearance of impropriety to have people endorse you as a judge who will then come before you.
2:26:21 Perhaps with another litigant. I think that one of the most important things for a judge is to have an independence from other lawyers, from other judges. I have never been a county employee. I have never been a town employee. I have never had a lot of social interaction with either of the judges. Deliberately, I know all of the attorneys in town.
2:26:50 But I've never, with the exception of Liebersbach, Mullen, Carney, and Reed, when I first came to this town, have I ever worked for another lawyer? I take it as a very, very important aspect of being a judge that you are not beholden to anyone. Thank you. I told you that the court administration question would come back. So I wonder if...
2:27:24 Randy, if you could spend a minute or two here and just explain what some of the other duties, what's meant by court administration, what are some of the other duties and responsibilities of a judge other than simply presiding over the court? Well, obviously you said other, and that's the main one. In my view, the judge is responsible for what happens in the court. Now, and that's without limitation.
2:27:57 In my view. But having stated that, there is a division, an important mandated division of responsibility that delegates to the court administrator who is a state court employee to
2:28:23 Manage such things as staffing levels and scheduling and to essentially supervise the clerks and we're fortunate enough to have Hector Gonzalez, a good court administrator and he's doing a good job but ultimately the buck stops with the judge and I think that it is the judges who
2:28:51 Agree upon the court administrator, agree to hire the court administrator, he functions.
2:29:00 To some degree independently of the judges, but I think ultimately is responsible to the judges in the county. And I think that the buck stops with the judges. I think that there are good reasons why the judges should not become involved in scheduling and personnel matters. There are reasons that apply to issues of, for example, immunity to the judge. The judge doesn't want to be involved in allegations of
2:29:30 Employee discrimination or those kinds of things. So employee management issues are, I think, rightfully delegated to the court administrator, but ultimately the judge is the one that makes sure that the court is functioning. Thank you. Mark, I noticed that over by the community church there is a construction project underway, and I understand that to be a courthouse.
2:29:59 Where's that money coming from? That money was allocated many years ago, I'm not sure, to the administrative office of the courts. There's been a longstanding process to refurbish and update courts throughout the state of California. Mono County was fortunate enough to have that money allocated many years ago, and fortunately even despite the downturn in the budget, the legislature has been able to restrain from taking those court funds to
2:30:26 From those court building funds. So that process is going forward. The money's been allocated. The architecture's been done and it's breaking ground. I think Friday is the ceremony for that. Thank you. I understand that any state agency or special state agency, I believe, that builds a construction project is required to put that project out to bid and get at least three competitive bids and is further required to accept the lowest
2:30:56 Credible bid. Do you know, and this would be for Therese, if there are any local contractors and local people who will be employed in the construction of this courthouse? I would hope that there would be many, many local people employed to construct this courthouse. I don't have any personal knowledge as to the bidding process, nor do I know specifically who has been chosen.
2:31:27 to construct the courthouse, but I would think that in this economy, with the recession hitting us so hard that I would hope that there were local folks who were helping to construct the courthouse. And I would like to just briefly respond to the administration question that you asked. Okay, please. Because I would like to see the next judge work with the court administrator to do such things as
2:31:58 To make forms available online to the citizens of Mono County, Judicial Council forms. And I would also like to see a bit more of a law library that's accessible to the citizens of Mono County. Right now we have just an abysmal library. We have one computer that is designated the law computer in our library. And unless you happen to know how to access Westlaw,
2:32:26 You may not have any help at all in researching your legal case. There's a set of codes. Where's the Whitkins? Where are any of the law books? I think there are some NOLO books in the law library. I think that that's pathetic, and I think that Mona Connie deserves to do better by its citizens. Thank you, Therese. Randy, I can see you are itching to make comments. You know, I am shocked and disappointed, and I have spoken.
2:32:55 with Greg Jenison and other contractors in this town who have advised and are similarly shocked and amazed that the general contract and the general contractor are from out of state and to date, amazingly as it may seem, there appear that there are no local contractors that intend to be or are intended to be involved in the construction of our new courthouse.
2:33:23 That could change, and I hope that it does, but from what I understand to date, the general is from out of state, and the subs do not include any local contractors. And I think that, I find that disturbing. Would you, just as a point of follow-up, would you, is that, I mean, from a
2:33:51 From a governance point of view, is that a legislative question or a judicial question? It's a procedure that the judge and apparently the court administration have no control over. It's a process, as I understand it, that takes place at the state level, beyond the court administrative level.
2:34:20 It's a contract that's awarded at the state level and administered at the state level without any requirements that local subcontractors have the benefit of that contract. Thank you. Mark, did you want to add anything? Well, sure. I'll add something to both. As court administration, I'll be quick. The rule of the court is first...
2:34:44 As the judge to set the example for the employees, the clerks and the people doing data entry have a very difficult job. And so getting to work on time, putting in a full day's work, doing your job, training people, and making their job a sense of accomplishment and that what they're doing is the first thing you would do. You'd set a tone and culture.
2:35:05 Every agency, every department, every office has a culture and the judge as a leader would be the first person to set that culture and treat those people with respect and be an example. In addition, the court needs to look at efficiencies.
2:35:18 In dispute resolution, improving our mediation capacities, improving the way we work with juvenile cases. So there's a lot of things that aren't just solving a case before you, but setting up processes and procedures, review hearings in juvenile cases, education, and always treating the process as moving forward and improving. It's a dynamic process, and that would be a very important rule, sort of behind the scenes, how to efficiently administrate the court. The people wouldn't see that to give the most seamless results possible.
2:35:48 And calendaring issues and working all those things out, going to Bridgeport when needed and as often as needed to make sure that the folks up in the north part of the county are well treated and considered. In terms of the state issue, this is something that local courts and people in private business are going to need to get used to. The state does what the state does.
2:36:07 And the state doesn't care that much for what happens out anywhere else. And they have the funding sources and the contract sources and the procedures. And as much as supervisors try to get things to happen, as much as sheriff's association tries to get things to happen, as much as local judges complain and write letters, the state's going to do what the state's going to do. And that's just a fact of life working in that type of office. Thank you, Mark. I believe the state has an election coming up on June.
2:36:35 Well, now I'd like to move into our summaries. Each candidate is going to give us a three-minute summary of their position and review their stance on things and close with remarks about why we should vote for them. And we'll start with Bill Sauser. Well, I think that I've stumbled a bit tonight. I don't know the county issues perhaps as well as others.
2:37:07 But that just gives me a fresh set of eyes to look at them. Talk to anyone I have worked with in the Parks Department, Tourism, State, and ask them how I perform my job. If elected, I promise you all I will bring to this the same passion, commitment that I have brought to the Tourism and Recreation Commission.
2:37:37 And all the other activities that I've been involved in from historical society on down. I think I have shown through all the projects I've been involved with, including the last wilderness bill, I worked very hard on that to reach a compromise so it would not adversely affect recreation and accomplish that, that I can bring different views together and reach consensus if elected.
2:38:07 The supervisor job will be my highest priority after family, of course, and will get my top attention. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Larry? I'd like to show you some more graphs, but I don't have any more. Again, thank you very much, Mr. Copeland and members of the chamber for staging this forum.
2:38:34 Also thank you to all who have participated, either present here in the audience or home via the media. And thank you to my friends and supporters. I would also like to recognize and congratulate retiring District 1 Supervisor Tom Farnetti, who is in the audience today, for his nearly four terms, four terms in 16 years of service to the county and its citizens. Yogi Berra is quoted as saying, the future ain't what it used to be. And ain't it the truth?
2:39:09 We are deep in the midst of uncertain times and face many yet unknown economic challenges. Tonight, I have laid out a number of my platform issues along with several suggestions on how we might better prepare for the future. I believe that if we act prudently and decisively, we can become more resilient. We can stabilize our tourism base. We can diversify the local economy and create sustainable, environmentally sensible jobs. We can create better communities that embrace inevitable change.
2:39:38 While still preserving our sense of place. Mono County Government and all government agencies must become more in touch with the needs of the citizenry, not just holed up in independent silos. Governments must look outside themselves for solutions to ever-present problems. After all, we are all the same taxpayers. Some people and candidates have suggested that the biggest problem facing Mono County is decreasing revenues from decreased state subventions, decreasing taxes, and so on.
2:40:09 And these issues are important. Service levels are important. The real issue which faces the average wage earner, the small business owner, the construction contractor, the normal citizen, and the communities that they create and engender. You and I are the government, and we must tend to ourselves better. I've lived here with my family for over 20 years.
2:40:39 Like many, I treasure the eastern Sierra and all that it offers. I've had the pleasure to help create the town's trail system, the main street promenade, the June Lake streetscape, and other public improvements. But my most rewarding experience has been my involvement in community service. It is a natural and big part of my life, and it's where my passion lies. I want to be supervisor because I care about Mono County, and particularly District 1, the very heart of this region. Supervisors make as many as a thousand decisions a year.
2:41:10 I will bring a diversified background and an ability to make logical judgments at every occasion. I have the skill to understand complex regulations, the willingness to weigh all sides of an issue, the capacity to focus on practical solutions, a frugal budget approach, the desire to ask the hard questions, and a creative vision to look beyond the norm. And there is no one that will work harder, and I will be a full-time supervisor.
2:41:36 This is a very special place, and if elected, I would do my best to help make it even better. Become part of the solution. Please vote on Tuesday, June the 8th. And thank you so much for your attention. Thank you, Larry. Doug? Again, I would also like to thank the chamber and yourself for moderating tonight. You've got to ask some pretty tough questions and did a nice job of it. Thank you. Thank you very much. And to the audience as well, both here and throughout the town of Mammoth on the media system you have. My platform.
2:42:07 I want to bring effective leadership into the position of Monaco County Sheriff. I will ensure the Monaco County Sheriff's Department becomes proactive in its law enforcement role. I will be a leader in a completely new style of effective, consistent, community-oriented policing. As I said, this is not Mayberry anymore. We need to move past that. I will be restructuring the current patrol patterns and beat assignments in order to reduce response times, increase crime prevention, and provide greater public safety and service.
2:42:33 I will be instituting a new and more effective staff evaluation process at all levels which will increase productivity, service, professionalism, and morale of all employees. I will ensure that the budgets to which I am entrusted is properly managed with the constant diligence in saving the taxpayers of the county, state, and federal systems the most money possible. During these difficult economic times, it is smarter than ever to share training between agencies whenever possible to minimize the cost of taxpayer dollars. There's a lot that can be done between the...
2:43:02 Law enforcement agencies and the other agencies that are in Mono County that can help law enforcement through social services, through wild arrows, through the local fire departments, et cetera, that can improve our performance to the citizens of this county and the visitors alike. I will ensure that the Sheriff's Department mission is to continue to serve and protect at the highest levels of service possible. And I will continue to work positively with all county, state, and federal agencies.
2:43:31 And build on positive relationships with the Mona County Board of Supervisors. The biggest duty we have as citizens of this great country is to get out and vote and to encourage our neighbors to get out and vote. That nothing changes until the ballot is cast at the ballot box. And we need to move forward. I believe that I'm the sheriff candidate that can move it forward. And I would appreciate your vote on June 8. And please encourage your neighbors to vote as well.
2:44:04 Obviously the ballots, we say June 8th, but realistically the FCT ballots are out as of yesterday, so people are already voting today. And so the sooner the word gets out that there are differences between me and Rick, and let the people decide. You know, you need to discover the difference. There is a difference, and we both have media or ways to transfer our information to the public, the voting public.
2:44:33 Mine is through my website, which is www.dubforsheriff2010.com. I'm on Facebook as well. As you can imagine, we Twitter and we blog as well. So we've truly come into the new century here in a big way, even way over four years ago. So I'd appreciate your vote. Thank you for taking the time. And thank you again. Thank you, Doug. Nick? Hi, Mr. Copeland. Thank you. Thank you to the chamber. Thank you to the public and the media.
2:45:03 I know we've increased our relationship with the media over the three and a half years I've been sheriff, but one of the things that is a core value of mine is never being satisfied with the status quo. We're always looking for ways to improve our delivery of service to the public. Although that being said, never being satisfied with the status quo, my wife of 35 years is back there, so I guess that's status quo. We've had a wonderful relationship and that will continue hopefully for at least another 35 years.
2:45:33 But one of the things when I talk about status quo is we're always evaluating are we doing the job that the public expects? I came out with a citizen survey form a little over two years ago to find out you, the public, that we work for, are we doing the job that you expect? The return on those citizen surveys has been overwhelmingly positive from the time they first call the dispatcher to the time the deputy leaves the scene, whether it be a
2:46:00 A civil matter, a criminal matter, or a coroner's issue, or a lost hiker. The overwhelming response has been positive. I've always been one to look at myself and evaluate myself. Am I doing the best that I can do? Am I leading by example? And I take this very seriously. I'm always looking at leadership training. I have obtained the highest level of peace officer standards and training certificate that's issued by legislative
2:46:30 Act, the Post or Peace Officer Standards and Training came into being in 1959. They've issued 115 executive certificates since that time. I was the proud recipient or earned that right to carry that certificate this last year that was presented to me at the Board of Supervisors meeting. Always evaluating our service, continually increasing training for all of our officers. We talked about, you know, car stops on the highway.
2:46:57 We have deputies at what we call desert snow training that we've done over the years where they go down and work with drug interdiction teams to find out, you know, how do we not profile people based on race, color, origin and things like that, but how do we profile criminal behavior? And so we're always increasing our training for all of our employees. We've reduced our crime through community-oriented policing, getting out of our cars, talking to the neighbors, finding out.
2:47:26 You know, what's going on in your community, doing Forest Service Patrol checks, things like that. One of the things that I know that's the number one economic engine for this county is tourism. I don't take that lightly. Every single job in Mono County depends on that. And I want to exemplify that. Chief McAfee is the first chief of police of Mammoth Lakes, said we're ambassadors for the town of Mammoth Lakes, but we're also law enforcement officers. That's also my same philosophy. Community-oriented policing.
2:47:54 Let's do what's right for the community. Use common sense out there. And don't take yourself too serious and do the right thing. Thank you. Please vote. Thank you, Rick. I believe that I have the experience, the judicial temperament, and the dedication to public service and access to justice to make a good judge. As far as my experience goes, I've not only been a public defender, appointed public defender,
2:48:23 For over 15 years. But I've also been appointed as minors counsel in difficult family law cases, in juvenile delinquency cases and dependency cases. I've litigated hundreds of family law cases, custody, visitation, property division. I've handled easement issues, evictions, unlawful detainers, trademarks. I've done just about every single thing that a judge can do.
2:48:53 And I've done it for many, many years. I've litigated for over 23 years. With respect to my judicial temperament, Socrates said there were four important qualities of a judge. To listen respectfully, to answer wisely, to consider soberly, and to decide impartially. I believe that I have those qualities. In my practice here in Mono County, when I first came here, it was a very economically depressed time.
2:49:23 I think that I showed that I would facilitate public service and access to justice because I have performed thousands of hours of pro bono legal services for this community. I've also, in my practice, I bartered for services. I've done everything from accepting dozens and dozens of cords of wood. I've had my house cleaned. I've had my car painted. I've had massage...
2:49:51 I've had massages. I've had climbing lessons. I've had skiing lessons. I even went to Africa with a mountaineer and I climbed Mount Kilimanjaro myself. And I did that because, not as charity, but because I'm a member of this community and I wanted to help out people who maybe couldn't afford legal services. I don't think that legal services should be only for the wealthy.
2:50:22 If I was elected judge, I would also try to decrease the cost of litigation by helping to implement programs to reduce the cost of litigation like they have in Inyo County, by helping to implement a community-based arbitration program, and by increasing the services of the family law facilitator, which down in Inyo County is called the Self-Help Center, and they do a lot more than just assist people in filing for dissolutions.
2:50:52 I think that it's really important to provide everyone with a fair and full opportunity to be heard. I would want a judge to treat me the same way I want to be treated when I go into court. I want that judge to listen to me. I want that judge not to be hostile toward me, but to make the forum easy for me to tell the judge my side of the story. I'm proud to be a member of this community.
2:51:23 And I'd be honored to be your judge. Thank you. Thank you, Therese. Mark? Thank you for hosting this. Thank you for attending and listening in. All of us in government, I think we've all heard a consistent message, both from the people up here and in town council, it's time for government to step up and ask more from ourselves. That's what I would do as a judge. I have a tremendous amount of experience, both in criminal and civil matters, in infrastructure matters. I see the big picture. I have a good working relationship with the sheriff's department.
2:51:54 The District Attorney's Office, the Police Department, and every aspect and avenue of government. My experience is not only at the big picture and the administrative level, but also working with people, working with hundreds of people, people who are in desperate need of child support or in desperate dire straits to have to pay that extra dollar for their children. Representing children in child dependency cases, understanding the burdens that families go through in custody cases, and understanding the impact of domestic violence and public safety.
2:52:24 And taking every single person who comes before the court seriously, understanding the court's jurisdiction, what the court can and can't do to help people get through their lives. Each person who comes before a judge is not there because they want to be there. They are detoured from their true mission and goal in life, and the role of the court is to help them get through that with courtesy, with patience, with respect, and with a reasoned application of the law. That is something that I can do. I know that Teresa earlier said that she does not
2:52:54 And so, with all due respect to Teresa's position, which I understand,
2:53:23 And with all due respect to those people who would know that if they came before me, they wouldn't expect any special privilege or treatment because that's who I am and that's why they're supporting me. I want to thank you all. This is an important matter for you to decide who the next judge will be. I have nothing but great respect for both Therese and Randy. They're friends of mine. I think that we would all be very capable. But I think that my unique experience, perspective, demeanor, and judicial temperament is the right person for this job.
2:53:55 Thank you. Thank you, Mark. Randy? Thank you for moderating. Thank you all for coming. I think Tom Cage has to worry about his job because you've done such a good job here tonight. I'm not a politician. I've been a lawyer for 32 years and running as I'm doing here does not come naturally to me. I could not do this and would not do this without
2:54:31 The terrific support of my wife, Claudia, who's sitting there, who's also a very fine lawyer in her own right, and with the support and understanding of both my sons, Jack and Joe, who have pretty much not seen me for the last few weeks. And without, I couldn't do this without the support of scores of people in this community.
2:55:00 That know me, that know what I'm about, that know that the way I have lived my life, not necessarily just in court, but including in court and outside of court is a testament to my judicial temperament and to my qualities that I would bring to the bench. It's about experience as well as
2:55:37 And I've been both.
2:56:06 A prosecutor and a defense lawyer. My experience I've discussed in some detail here tonight and I think it's important to note that some of my biggest supporters include George Booth at the DA's office and all the lawyers in his office. Now I've never worked for George or the DA's office. I've worked against them for 22 years, opposing them in hundreds of cases and having said that,
2:56:36 They know what I'm about. They know what I'm like as a lawyer and a person. And in addition to the supporters that you can find listed on my website, I think it's important to note that George Booth and his lawyers in the DA's office are really important examples of people that know me and know what I'm about.
2:57:02 It's an important election. I wouldn't be doing this. I wouldn't be going through this or putting my family through the, you know, this is not easy for us if I didn't think it was extremely important. So it is important. Thank you all for coming and vote on the 8th and choose wisely. Thank you. Thank you, Randy.
2:57:30 We've come to the end of our time. I have a few items of housekeeping I need to take care of. I'd like to introduce Eric Wasserman and have him stand up. Eric is the President of the Chamber of Commerce. I'd also like Maggie Thompson to stand up. Maggie, please stand up. Maggie's a board member at the Chamber. And both Maggie and Eric have worked many, many hours through this season to put on these forms.
2:58:01 I think we'd be remiss if we didn't acknowledge our appreciation to the town of Mammoth Lakes for allowing us to use this facility, which certainly works better than Little Eagle, which is where we had the last one. And I want to, I really want to take a moment for all of us to give a round of applause to all of our candidates who have given us this round. You know there are battles being fought around the world as we speak.
2:58:41 Thank you all for your time.