Measure U Committee
· recording 3 hr 0 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
260 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 It's, I've done a lot of calculations and all, and I find that opening our blinds, and we have very good blinds, it feels good for the sun coming out. No, it's not on. More heat goes out than the sun's bringing in. I've got blanks trying. I've got nothing still.
0:20 Temperature differential inside and outside. I don't know if it's the web. I don't know if it actually has website connections, you know. Good morning. A few years ago we had to replace them and we got some kind of E window.
0:36 I do too. Sometimes it could be an internet issue. Sometimes we don't get... I don't know, but we do get... I have a meter that actually measures how much in BTUs per square foot per hour, comes in and all, and...
0:52 I can measure that and I can do recalculations. And I've got all the new windows too. Some of my windows are clear stories, like 20 plus feet high. And I had one of the most efficient homes in Mammoth when we bought them. Any efficient homes in Mammoth. It was, we had windows, it was so massive. Where we had these old aluminum frame sliders and all.
1:21 You could see where the extrusions came together. You could see a gap in light about an eighth inch all the way through to the outside. We took some clear stories were coming out. But that's usually sometimes what it is. Like, you'll lie. But I'm not connected, so I don't get access to it. And around the window in places, you do need to have to afford an inch. Yeah, because that's the only way I can actually respond. This house just looked like. So we've done a lot of work on it. Oh.
1:46 It had 69 windows. If the cameras are on, you'll see, it means it's live on TV, but I don't know if it's live on the internet. They were all double-paying. They were double-paying. But the other thing that is required in the title 24 is a solar heat name coefficient. It says you can't let the sun come in. It's for all the areas that have air conditioning. And by covering
2:15 So I think this is the issue. I think it's just the internet connection for some reason. It's great for Palm Springs. Yeah. But, you know, I don't want to care. So I don't want to use this computer that has any setting on it.
2:36 Because we can't even get on, sometimes there's money to get on internet, there's a little more, I don't think it's even the branding is like, I think it's maybe an internet issues. I agree with your statements on the, oh, I absolutely understand. I know, and I should have put a statement in there. I know, and I should have put a statement in there. I know, and I should have put a statement in there. I know, and I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement in there. I should have put a statement
3:05 And I showed him all of those pages with all the color stuff. Nobody takes anything out of these guys.
3:35 What he wants to do isn't there. What he wants to do isn't there. What he wants to do is a consideration.
4:04 I got a call from Sean 15 minutes ago saying, did you know you have a measuring unit? I forgot. I totally forgot. You mean you haven't read every page of this binder? It's a nice short one. Can somebody just take over my wife? Have you called Bill or should I give him a call? We're waiting on Granicus a little bit here, so we'll give it a couple minutes and then...
4:34 We'll start and then see if it catches up. And then also get hold of Bill. I'm sure when you've been through these before it's easier for you to sort through all of this and try to apply the filters, but... You know... Wait...
5:20 That was his voicemail.
6:17 There you go. Try it now. He is here. Morning, Bill. Bill, did you get your apps? I did not. Here you go. I grabbed them for you. Thank you. Mike. How are you, sir? Good to see you. Good, you too. What a weird morning. Yeah.
6:42 My truck was halfway up the hill and it said, I'm not going anywhere. I got a diesel truck. It just froze. I needed an outside to come get me. My truck's sitting next to Crowley right now. Sorry. Euthanizing my dog this afternoon. So it's one of those days. Let me interrupt Tadini if you want to ride back down to your truck. What's that? I'll give you the ride back down. I'll push the triple A. If you need to do it, you can give me a wreck.
7:05 I don't think she really has a grip on her at this point. Okay. Okay. Okay. Okay. All right. Thank you. Only some heels. Have you got through your head yet that you're running for heels? No. No, I don't. Talk to my husband. He's a good candidate. No, no, you're the one.
8:28 Good morning. Let's start the Measure U meeting for Tuesday, December 10th.
8:57 Steve, could you give us a roll call, please? Uh, Chair Perry? Here. Chair West, Chair Spina? Here. Meeting members, Bruce Sousa? Yep. Sandy Hogan? Here. Don Zeller? Here. Good morning. We'd like to start with public comments. Is there anybody who would like to say something this morning? Great. Let's then move along to consent agenda item number one to approve the regular meeting minutes of November 12th. So move to approve. Okay. Sandy Hogan?
9:27 Approved. Do we have a second? A second. All in favor? Aye. Great. And then moving along to discussion item number, first discussion item, to review the 2013 Measure U Fall funding applicant presentations for primary filter requirements and approve the order of applicant presentations. Excuse me.
9:57 So, the application period for the 2013-4 award opened on Monday, November 11, closed on Monday, December 2nd, December 2nd. We have a total of 16 applications for the funding request of $630,545. Today, the task of the committee is to review the all funding applications.
10:23 Essentially for the primary filter requirements. So in the application form, sorry, in the review form, there's primary filter and project filter. The essence with this one I have here for you, the event application form, sorry, the event evaluation form has not gone to council yet, which is this new one. So to conduct the primary filter requirements, we need to still use the current one. Okay.
10:49 Okay. And then the second part of today's meeting is to just review the order of applications as presented by staff in attachment D. So I'll just go through the first step. So really what we need to do here is just run through each application, make sure they do satisfy those five questions. Again, it's not the other questions that we've developed, but the original five questions.
11:11 So is it this one that says 2013, Measure U, follow? Yeah, it's the original project. It's the one evaluation form that we use for the evaluation form. Okay. So I have copies of the commitment, but it's in your packet. Okay, so it's, yes? It's the B, C. They're going to use B for each one of the applications.
11:37 Once they do pass, then we move into December 17th, when we look at the applications themselves. The task there for the committee historically is to commit to a 10-minute evaluation time, which is when the applicant comes forward, does their presentation. That's on the 17th. On the 17th, yeah, it's the next meeting.
12:02 Now looking at that meeting again, you have the option to again look at doing an evaluation on each of those applications. Whether you need a presentation from each and every one of those applications is another matter. It's up to you as a community. You might just want to look at folks that haven't submitted an application in the past or even select ones you want to look at in particular that might have changed. Just giving you the option because there's quite a few.
12:24 So that's on the 7th and 17th. But today you're really just going to get primary filter. And then again, step two is just to confirm the order of presentations and how you want those presentations conducted. So that's kind of step two. So with that, you'll probably turn it back over to the chair. And I'm assuming you're just going to go through to the other questions. Go through those primary filter questions.
12:51 Most of the applicants you can see here today, so if you have any questions on some of those applications, feel free to ask those applicants. They were contacted. Questions come up at this time, and I think it would be quite helpful for the community to engage with them if you have any questions. I know there's some applicants that do want to speak as well. Great. Thank you.
13:20 Yes, Bill, do you have any comments? Yeah, one, on the way we're going to present this on the 17th, I would personally like to ask each applicant to give a brief presentation if they've applied before and we've got their report back from last year, just to make a presentation on the changes in their applications and why the funding is still needed if they had a special event, a successful event the previous year.
13:47 Great. In terms of today, if some of the applicants wish to speak, speaking again personally, not for anyone else on the board up here, I would just as soon hear their spiel they would like to give us up front and then delve into the meat of the matter. And thirdly, since my mouth is open, I think that it...
14:14 Instead of looking at all applications, I think at least the MLEC applications we can move through as a whole and since they're all known quantities and say that they meet the criteria. That's it. Thank you. Bill, are you suggesting that we move one past the other and ask for presentations right now or would you like for
14:41 Yes, two cents. Some of them would like to make comments today regardless. I would just as soon hear those up front and get those done. And then ask the question of everyone here at the end of that whether or not they didn't feel comfortable moving the events forward since we're here just to make sure they meet the primary filter because if they don't, they don't move forward. But I'm comfortable that the event applications meet that primary filter and I would just move them forward as a time saving.
15:11 Instead of dealing with them one at a time. I would agree with that. And I think the folks sitting out there might too. Great. Who would like to come up and talk? One comment though, I would say that probably any brand new application would be worthy of us kind of going over a little more in detail. Because I think you're right, many of them we know. So those make sense. But I would say any new one.
15:43 We might spend a little time on looking at the application itself and going over the filter questions. Well then let's start. Is there anyone from the MLEC joint applications that would like to speak this morning? Good morning, Juliana. Hello. Juliana Olenck, I'm with the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition. And as you'll see, there were five events that actually went through the MLEC filtering process.
16:13 And I appreciate, Bill, your comment that you'd like to move forward with those. I will tell you we used all of the guidelines and we vetted each of those applications.
18:30 Thank you.
19:09 Once you get the construction documents, then you can really go to this, get a tight proposal on the costing of the project. So the kicker is that we're proposing a partnership between the town, the college, and the foundation. The town would have to make a commitment to the operating funding of the project, which I won't throw a number out until we do a business plan.
19:45 500 to 700 people for theater or audience style seating and somewhere in the area of 400 to 500 for a banquet or event on a single floor seating. It would certainly be a multi-use facility. We're envisioning tiered audience seating that is portable.
21:36 So that you can go up in the air maybe seven or eight rows and look down on a stage area and then have a mezzanine level that would have permanent seating for the higher capacities that when not used it's just locked off. And the benefit of doing that in the sprung structure is you don't really create a whole second floor. You already have the envelope and the volume with a
22:06 33 and a half foot ceiling to be able to add a couple hundred extra seats to the facility that would look down on kind of arena style seating. Anyway, I think it's a pretty good opportunity and there's a pretty good chance to make it work. There's just a lot of moving parts that different people have to agree to to make the thing go forward. Any questions? Yes, as I understand,
22:35 I think your request is for $25,000 at this point? It is. But I think what I heard was that within a couple of months you might need another $75,000? If we do the schematics and come back with a business plan and you guys were to approve the business plan, then we'd want to go right to construction drawings. The idea would be if we can move this through the system fast enough that...
23:00 We could potentially have a facility in place by July of 2015. And what's the plan for 2014 then? That would be... I didn't see any mention of a tent. No, there's no tent. Right, right. We're going to bring in some kind of temporary facility that we'll share with Jazz and we'll go back to something that we did the first couple of years. Is that in one of the proposals somewhere? I don't recall seeing it. No, it's not. It's just part of our operating budget.
23:30 Okay. Okay, so there's no specific request for a tent this year. We're not. We're a temporary structure. Yeah. So. Each of the organizations have built that into their budget, though. You know, I don't know. Okay. That was one thing that seemed to be missing, I thought, worked last year. Yeah, I think ourselves and Jazz will share a facility. Okay. And it'll just be a standard Jazz-style tent that we've both used in the past.
24:00 And I believe the other music groups will go back to using the college and maybe the Catholic Church with the idea that we're looking two years down the line to have something more permanent. If I could just, from the MLEC perspective, we've actually had meetings with Evan and we've discussed what the process is. Chamber Music Unbound are all in favor of the sprung structure.
24:35 But everyone realizes that although the tent was a great opportunity last year, we learned that there were some issues that needed to be addressed. Those issues are being addressed with the sprung structure. So for 2014, everyone is going to go figure out the other two events, other than jazz and food and wine. We'll figure out what they're going to do for 2014 in anticipation to be able to use the sprung structure in 2015 and then moving forward from there. And then you're looking at how many years in the sprung structure?
25:05 Is that pretty much going to be the permanent facility? I think it's a stepping stone. We had a very good planning session with the college over the weekend, and they would like to see something, you know, more permanent down the line, but this is a capacity building interim step. You know, you'd like to think that it's a five to ten year facility. They have a shelf life of 30 to 40 years.
25:33 Often the skins have to be replaced after 25 or 30 years. You know, the best example was the two-year Little Eagle facility that's going on 12 years or something now, I think. More than that. More than that. And it wasn't new, I don't believe. And that came from the top of Vail Mountain, it was up there for two years. It was one elk that replaced two elk. Two elk, yep.
25:59 But talking with the sprung people, they've got facilities all over the world that have been up for in excess of 25 years. We've been researching this with the college to determine whether it has to go to DSA and what kind of engineering stamping has to be on it. They just put one up at Pierce College in the San Fernando Valley as a temporary performing arts facility while they're building a new facility.
26:28 building down there, and that was for another community college. But they have about a dozen facilities that are up around the state for either schools or public use in some fashion. I noticed, and I think Sandy tried to get to the point, but the 78,200, would we see that next year at this time, or do you need it earlier? We would need that before next year, and that's why I say this thing's a little complicated. Okay, so that was one question I had.
26:59 And then there's a statement in here, something to the effect, that a board meeting on December 8th, you would put a request in. Yeah, I had to present this to our board also because it really changes a little bit the way the foundation would operate and the use of foundation land. And we got full approval from our board on Sunday.
27:25 Our board went through a pretty extensive workshop on Saturday with the college president and her staff from Ridgecrest to talk about their next five to ten years of programming and the kinds of things they want to bring forward and the educational purposes of this facility. And I would say right now, pending us having to give a presentation to their board in Bakersfield, that they're all very positive about it.
27:55 Willing to move forward with it. Not a commitment yet for transferring or making the dollar commitment, but very supportive of taking that next step and they see the potential use for being adjacent to the college campus so that they can use it for assemblies and for some of their programming. I'm still back on the trying to figure out how to do the $75,000 because you're not, if you would ask for $100,000,
28:28 With perhaps some to be encumbered. It might be a little bit easier, but I'm still kind of struggling with that. You know, through the process, one of the things that I pushed and lost on was the fact that we need a system in place. So when opportunities, we call it oopsertunity with Measure R, so that when opportunities come down the pipe, we cannot afford, or the pipe, we cannot afford to pass on, that we have protocol in place.
28:57 to deal with that without allowing it to be an end run for somebody to make an application outside of all the other people looking for money. I think this just solidifies the fact that on one of our very next agendas, we need to agendize how we're going to deal with mid-year projects that cannot wait. It doesn't happen a lot, but a lot of times you do have, especially on the capital projects,
29:24 You've got price overruns and other things that were not anticipated up front that you have to deal with in that mid-year review. And I think it behooves us somehow to deal with that. So as this arises, I promise you this won't be the only time we see something like this. As this arises, we have the protocol in place so that we can award those monies if it's a worthy cause and project.
29:53 When I went through this, I asked myself whether or not this was part of the 300,000 that we put aside, because certainly the 78 could be. So getting all of that and the reserve discussions we've been having on the other things and how all of these things play together, it needs some thought and consideration. Where this one, in my mind, isn't as much an oops-ertunity, we know about it today. And we're kind of expecting it.
30:21 Except we don't know what it's going to look like. Before I just penciled in, okay, we're going to give you 73 after this, I would want to know what the plans look like. I'd like to see the output of the 25, yes. Right. I would not like to just say we're going to give it to you regardless, but we want to see that application come forward and we want to be able to, even though it will be outside of the scope of the other applications, I want to see what it looks like before I just say, okay, here's the money. Evan's a nice guy. I've known him for a long time.
30:50 And Bill, I completely agree with you. And we have a tentative team in place right now, which is certainly the Sprung Company out of the San Francisco area. And I think I've mentioned they've done three projects in town, Little Eagle, the airport, and the fire station. We're right now working with Cox Construction, who built our apartment building. They built the fire station. They built the post office. And they built the visitor center at Mona Lake.
31:19 They specialize in government and military projects and the president of the company has a second home here and loves the area and he's very supportive of working with us. We've been working with Bruce Woodward of Woodward Architecture who also worked on the sprung structure project at Little Eagle and Larry Walker who is kind of a design vision person is already taking pictures and is going to
31:48 Come up with some schematic or some visual concept designs for it too, which when we come back to you, we'll have something to present. Well, and if I understood you correctly, the 25,000 goes into the planning of this up front now. The final decision really hasn't been made that it will be sprung. It could still be a brick and mortar facility. No, it's brick and mortar would be three to four times
32:17 Likely the cost of it. You know, there's an outside chance you could do a metal building like the search and rescue building down at the water district. But I think even that, when we've looked at it, it still would exceed that amount. And I think with our conversations with the college and what they feel is a value for what their needs are,
32:43 We're probably pushing that 3 million-ish number. Okay. And if any of my fellows up here would like to see it, I do have the book that Evan loaned me with all the different types of sprung structures that have been done, and it's a pretty interesting read to look at what the potentials are. The potential is great. Yeah. They're pretty impressive, and they are all over the place, and many actually serve as performing arts centers, it seems.
33:11 The issues for our lives, there's a lot of them in Colorado in the same kind of weather conditions. They're all over Canada. We know it works. And we'd hope it would be a stepping stone to be able to show that there's demand for the kinds of things that we want to do. You know, the other part of it is if we get down the line 10 years and it's really successful and you need your
33:41 If you're ready to go to the next phase, there's always some value that would come out of this because it would potentially be resold to somebody else or moved to another location. Well, Little Eagle actually demonstrates the fact that they definitely work. Well, you can gussy them up. Oh, yeah. Better than Little Eagle. Better than Little Eagle, yes. Or the airport one. Yes, yes. The mountain loves beautiful detail.
34:12 It's functional. Yeah, and that's why I asked Larry Walker to get involved. He's got a pretty good eye for detail, and he's done some very nice stuff in the community, and he and Bruce work well together. Thank you. Any more questions? Thank you very much. Thank you. Yeah, that helps a lot.
34:56 It's a little unique because it does ask more than, say, what those apply guidelines specify. So it's a good opportunity for the applicant to kind of describe that event. Great. I'm Allison McDonnell-Page, and I'm the director of the board of Sierra Classic Theatre Company that's been around for 15 years, and it's been pretty much a volunteer-based. We do...
35:19 We've done the Murder Mystery Fundraiser in the fall where we go to various restaurants around. I'm sure you guys have heard of that. And I know Stu was there this year. And then historically they've done a Shakespeare. And I have been the director of the board for the last four years. And there has been a Shakespeare in the woods, in Sam's Woods, for that four years.
35:43 When I was, I came into town and I got actually hired to be the director of the Shakespeare because the board at that time didn't have any time and then they asked me to be on the board so that's how the history of me but from then on I felt really strongly that we should pay a director and that we should continue the Shakespeare and it should be free.
36:08 I come from New York City. We have that free Shakespeare. And it's free to the public. You'd line up and you can see, you know, Julia Roberts or whoever happens to be in it. And it's for the whole community. So for the first two years, we had a $5 suggested donation. We lost money both times.
36:31 You know, we try to raise money in the fall in order to be able to do a spring show and a summer show and kind of break even and maybe a little bit more for some capital projects. But this year we actually paid for the rights because it was the complete works and we actually made $1,500. Sam Walker I've just met with and he said he would give this space to us again for free. We will do it after Blueza Palooza and they've always been very supportive.
37:00 But he's told us he needs to see it be bigger and better. We usually get about 100 people a night, and he wants to see it 500. He wants to see it a better run organization. Now, last year we had an issue with Flossie. Ken and Flossie usually give us the chairs that are there from Jazz Ublee, but the mountain is going to take the chairs and the mountain is going to take the stage. We have never actually had it on a stage before. We usually just do it right there.
37:30 But in order to have 250 to 500 people there a night, we will have to have a stage. So we would have to rent some kind of stage and we would have to, Brian Knowles has always given us some speakers and he just kind of drops them off and then we sort of figure out how to put them up. But I think we really would need to rent a full on, you know, I mean the sound is huge because basically 100 people by the, you know, it's a flat.
37:59 It's a flat area. They can't really hear or see. And I really think it's possible. This year we want to do Midsummer Night's Dream, which would be, I think, something that we'd get a lot of people. We did do a $10 suggested donation, and we actually made $3,000, so most of the people gave that. Sometimes in the years past, it just depends. It just depends on the people who come.
38:25 You know, how much they give. And then sometimes we get more. Sometimes people are just dropping in 20s. But we really do believe that it should be something for climbers and theatergoers alike and kids and all that that it is like giving back to the community. But I think the application that I know Mike submitted, it was saying $4,000. Well, we've sometimes, I mean, because it's a donation-only event,
38:53 We're afraid to put too much and then, you know, go through our entire budget in that one thing. So, but I think if we really want to get it to 250, 500 people a night, we're going to probably double our marketing, going from 1,000 to 2,000. We're going to have to rent a stage, which is probably at least 1,000. We're going to have to rent the chairs. We're going to, and at that quickly, looking at all, we're going to have to rent sound equipment. We're going to have to, I think, I mean, what Sam Walker's talking about is
39:21 You know, the complete works were so fun, but it was just, we just took some costumes in our costume shop and we just kind of put it together and, you know, I think we want to probably rent some real costumes, which could end up being about $500 or $750. And for us, actually, the rental works better because right now we're spending $2,100 a month on storage space for two costume things. And that's just overhead that is taking away from our productions.
39:51 So anyway, it pretty much quickly gets up to like $10,750 that we would, if we had the support, we would try to do that. Obviously, if we don't have the support, we can't put, we have $20,000 in the bank right now. We can't put half of our budget in there thinking we're never going to get it back. But if we, I keep on thinking of the Latin Festival, the Game Eulers, when I saw the, I went to the first one and then I went to the second one after Measure U,
40:19 And it was like going from a little thing to something that felt like a real event. Shira and I actually have been talking about what my goal for this event is to make it a Shakespeare Festival. Month long. They're almost like a jazz jubilee, various things. And this year, if I can finagle it, what I would really like to do is offer fencing lessons and a fencing thing and a clown workshop for kids.
40:47 Almost like the Latin Festival that there are things going on during the day. And then the performances would be at night. And there are the jugglers and clown people in town that I know would love to do it. And then we, you know, would try to hire people. But that would be a free. Come, you sign up, you do a little thing and you learn how to, you know, kids get involved. I've just closed a youth theater thing that Mammoth Lakes Foundations has sponsored, really, by giving me the space.
41:16 Last year, it was 17 kids. This year, it was 29 kids. It closed at the Edison Sunday. And I can see that growing. And there's really a lot of kids come see the Shakespeare. And this year, if we do midsummer, I could see actually maybe having a kids program as part of the fairies and actually get kids involved with it.
41:40 Ten years down the line, I'd like to see it growing so that we could actually maybe hire some Shakespeare companies from LA or San Francisco to come actually perform. You do various nights. You do one local production. You do one higher production. You have various things going on. You have a fencing thing here. You have a, so that it really feels like, I mean, not a Renaissance Fair because that's something, but a Shakespeare festival that
42:08 My feeling is that a lot of towns like this, like Tahoe, have. And it's a draw, and it's a worldwide draw. Summer Shakespeare, free summer Shakespeare under the stars is something that I think is a global. And the people who have come, we now have about probably half local, half tourists. And they hear about it, and they know about it. And they want to come.
42:36 Because it's something they believe is a good cultural experience. So that's what we are and what we're doing. You know, we are a complete volunteer, so we don't have an executive director, which I think if we're going to grow, we're going to have to build that into our budget because events need somebody who's paid to
43:02 Actually do them. We all have, you know, and the other thing about us is that we're the actors and the hardest people, so it's hard to get things done sometimes, you know, when nobody's actually paid for it. We now pay our directors. That's something I really feel strongly to do. Usually we do a spring show. The Edison isn't available, so what we're actually thinking is of doing another fundraiser, kind of like the murder mystery.
43:32 in restaurants that would then raise money for this event too. So we could use, I think we could use our funds that we have now and maybe funds from that fundraiser to really hire an executive producer of the event because that poor director ends up doing too much. We can't, you know, you have to start now. The other thing is that we would have the time because we're not doing a spring show to start that now.
44:00 To start looking at the, you know, getting that stuff done. Anyway, so anything you guys can get would be really helpful and it would just go towards, you know, really trying to make it a bigger, better event. Thank you. Any questions from the council? I did have, I understand that you have, I was a little confused at first, you have a paid board director but you don't have a paid,
44:28 No. Production director, whatever you call it. No, we have no paid board. We hire a director for each show. Okay. So we pay them $1,000 to direct whatever show they're involved with. And usually that involves...
44:43 Getting the costumes, building the set, getting, um, making sure the marketing happens, but no, the board is not. Okay, that's fine, because I was, at first it sounded like it was, and then it wasn't, and I kept changing a little bit, but okay, that explains it, because I'm not familiar with the productions and things like that, so. And we love a new, a new theater, that would be awesome. I mean, we've done in the past, when I haven't, I think actually Sierra Classic Theater has applied for, um, money from the town, but before I was involved. Um,
45:13 We have done it other times in like different places, but we have found two years that I directed, it rained, but the wind and the outdoor mics, Sam's Wood is the only place. And my feeling for Shakespeare is that you want to be under the stars, and if it rains out, it rains out. We've had a couple times where
45:38 Joyce and Sean have lent us these tents and all of a sudden we pulled them over, we let the actors be in the rain and we put them over the audience. Some people play, some people leave. I remember going to Shakespeare in the park in New York where it was a full-on deluge and finally the director, somebody on the loudspeaker said, actors, please get off the stage and it was lightning and all that stuff and they stopped the show in the mid and my feeling is that that's what it has to be because
46:03 Because I do want, I don't want to, I don't think it should be in a tent. I think it should be out. And if you miss a show, you miss a show. Sometimes the rain actually has been the best shows because they're all impromptu and all of a sudden they, the people who stay really want to see it. Thank you, Allison. I know that I, my family really appreciates what you have done with the Shakespeare.
46:29 In the woods, it's fun for us to go see. I really appreciate that you make it free to include all people in the community as well as visitors who are coming. You can just see the sign as they drive by. I would love to see more marketing. I would love to see it grow as well. I got to see Shakespeare growing up in Tahoe and it's definitely been a part of...
46:56 You know, my education, my cultural and artistic education, and I love that you are, you know, offering that. And I don't know if anyone else had the opportunity to go see Allison's youth theater workshop this weekend. She did a production of Alice at Wonderland. My children were in it, so I got to see it. And it was wonderful, and the kids so enjoy being involved, and I know that there are many...
47:23 Kids in other cities that don't have this opportunity to come and for a minimal cost join in and to see what it's like to act on the stage and to have a director and then finish with a production. But it's really special, so thank you for that. Are there any more questions from members? No, any questions I have, I will wait for the application process because that's what we should be asking. Excellent. Thank you. Mike, please.
47:53 Hi, Mike. I'm Mike Dostro. I'm the secretary for Sierra Classic Theater, and I am the fledgling who put together the application. I apologize for any confusion. I think that Allison gave a more realistic presentation in terms of what we require for a budget in order to make this a more professional program, and I think it certainly is something that we've all enjoyed and can bring something new to the...
48:23 To the community. Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater and Sierra Classic Theater, we cooperate, but the Shakespeare in the Woods and the murder mystery are something that we kind of take pride in being our own thing and something that we've tried to make better each year. Truly, we are in a position where monetary limitations are making it impossible to present a professional-level Shakespeare production.
48:52 And, you know, operating on a $3,000, $4,000 budget, our costumes looked like they were out of the Elizabethan era. You know, we have sound equipment that is picking up all the wind, and wind is certainly an inherent part of an outdoor production. And not having a stage makes it very difficult to visualize, and especially for the little people, to actually see what's going on. And certainly they can benefit from the sage wisdom of the bard.
49:22 So if there's anything else that we can do in terms of the application, I'll rewrite it. I'll do whatever we need to do in order to make this move forward. And I beg your indulgence, and I apologize for the haphazard way that the application was put out, and we'd be happy to redo it in order to facilitate this funding. Thank you. I would make one other comment. Their presentation shows once again that
49:52 We need to find a way to determine what the infrastructure is that's needed for these. We're being asked for a sound system that probably we should already have paid for and owned. We're being asked for a stage that probably we should have already paid for and owned. To have these come out in different individual applications, a way needs to be found to come up with that list.
50:16 And for us to go to staff and say we want to see applications for this, this and this come forward so that then we can offer those things. That's a good point. So that instead of each person asking individually for this stuff, we have what's necessary. The town owns a couple of sound boards themselves. Perhaps with somebody who knew what they were doing and a little phone on the microphones.
50:41 We already have some of what this particular group may need. That's good point. What are our assets? I know we used to need a stage for the outside concerts we used to do. We used to go to Ralph Morissette. He'd put two flatbed trailers together, which were far stronger and larger than what you pay $1,000 to rent. It didn't cost us anything. Who are our partners? How can we identify and do these things without spending the money and with having our own inventory to get it done with? And that's something we haven't tackled.
51:10 We keep waiting for it to come in ad hoc, and I think that both Measure R and Measure U need to get down to that. We actually have a Measure R. I think, you know, we heard Evan talking, but if Evan's talking to Allison, he's proposed an outdoor part of this sprung structure, too. Is that, Evan's still here, is that part of the current planning?
51:35 Will you be working with Allison and that kind of thing to define requirements? Yeah, there's a very small outdoor area built into the back of the sprung structure in the proposal, but Bill hit on a good topic is all of us are renting. We're trying to share stuff now with Jazz, but we're going to rent 500 chairs and 100 tables.
52:02 Stage and sound and lighting and all that stuff and all the events that go on during the season. But when you really look at it, you've got to think about where are you going to store it, who's going to maintain it, who's going to distribute it, check it out and make sure it comes back in. I know just in the small amount of stuff we have, something always comes back broken or it just isn't there when you go to look for it and you don't know what happened to it.
52:31 With the sprung structure right now, and this could be increased, but we've proposed right adjacent to it, kind of in the trees in the back of our parking lot, a 1,200 square foot metal butler building that would be just a storage building with a slab and probably a small heated area for set construction. And, you know, the sprung structure idea is it's a community pavilion.
53:00 We certainly have some programming that goes into it. Brian and Rebecca and the Felici Trio, we're the two organizations that have ongoing year-round stuff, but Sierra Classic Theater and others, I think if we want to be an arts and culture town, it's not just one group, it's going to be a whole bunch of people doing things with a big variety of entertainment and involving the college and the K-12 schools.
53:27 It's going to grow, but you've got to start someplace. I think, Bill, if we put this bigger thing together, then part of what is included in it is the equipment that it takes to operate it, and maybe that could be increased as we go down the line because people have to manage that also. Maybe what you're talking about could be built into, let's just say it's arts, culture, and entertainment and all the stuff that it takes to...
53:57 Produce different events in the community. Anyway, my two cents. But it's town resources. Well, I was going to say, actually, in Measure R, I know that you've taken some big steps there with just the things for the outdoor sporting events purchases there. But, again, they are town resources, and I think Dennis Rottner is the one that's pretty much in charge of them. So that is a good point.
54:23 Well, an event is an event. If you need a PA system, whether you're an athletic event or whether you're an arts event, it's inconsequential. You need the PA system. You need the soundboard. Some of them need a lot more power than others, though. Well, absolutely. But if you don't need as much power, you can use a board that has more. So what I'm hearing is perhaps the Events Coalition, maybe Sierra Classic Theater,
54:47 You know, kind of becomes a part of the events coalition, and perhaps the events coalition should be talking to Dennis Rotner about what they have and see if it fits some of this in the meantime. Yes. Because what I'm hearing is that we may have some of it anyway. I'm going to jump in. I think it's, we've talked about it probably the last year, and I think it's always about the town's role in special events. You know, we did the analysis last year in Phenomeni, and we,
55:14 We received about $5,000 of permit fees and it cost us about $50,000. $50,000 is what I heard? And we got $5,000 revenues. We're underwater. And I think it's that big picture that we don't have the resources. So the rec department. We also don't have the staff. And I think we don't have, you know, the capability right now to really, you know, apply what we're talking about. I think it's a big picture. I think the events coalition, I think I was talking to Mike about
55:43 Can there be coordination with, you know, that venue and the site, I mean, you've got stages on it, how can we kind of better coordinate, you know, those opportunities? So I think everyone's got the resources, how can we kind of make this? And Stu, it's a great point you make that in fees we're only collecting 5,000. However, the events have been incredibly successful.
56:03 In TOT, we're dragging in a whole lot more than $50,000. Thank you. Absolutely. And at some point, the council, not us because that's not our purview, has to look at the success of these and dedicate a larger piece of the general fund budget, not trying to put everything on R&U. I'm politicking now, folks. No. And put that larger piece of general fund budget into the budget.
56:27 This product, because this product is what's putting the money there in the first place. Well, and to piggyback on that, exactly right. And that is Measure A money to me, because that is TOT that's coming in. Measure A is the, let's face it, Mammoth Lakes Tourism. And if it's growing because of the special events, perhaps the funding should at least come to give us some staff and some support there, because that is general fund.
56:53 So those are the kind of things that I think the big picture we need to be looking at. Because when the General Fund Recreation Department is paying $45,000 to put on these events and it's stressed, we've got a problem. Just to answer, sorry, Don, go ahead. Well, I was just going to suggest that perhaps a future proposal, maybe the next time we're sitting up here doing this, there is an application out of STU, out of the event coalition, a collaborative one.
57:23 to start to address some of these things because both the Measure R and Measure U were setting aside money to do things and that's an appropriate use of that. Just to respond to your statement about the MLEC, we have, I think, over the last year or more been discussing that the MLEC is made up of like-minded event producers.
57:50 That's the gist of who support each other. So part of our discussions have been what resources do each of us have. So we're already on, we're already going down that road. And Don's suggestion perhaps the, and we invite anyone who's putting out an event to be part of the events coalition because what we're able to do is support each other.
58:10 We as a group, those of us, the five of us who met and are part of the joint application this year, we met, we all went through our applications, we went through the criterion, we went through everything to make sure that together we worked so that when we came to you, you got applications that met the requirements. So that's one of the advantages. And we certainly, had we known that the Sierra Classic Theater was going to do an event application, we certainly would have welcomed them.
58:38 To come on board. As with the fishing, and I think that was a little oversight perhaps on our part. But there's, in light of the TOT statement that Bill just made, I want to share with you an article that just appeared on December 8th in marketplace.org. The headline is, Arts and Culture Contribute More to U.S. Economy Than Tourism. So I just thought that might be something advantageous for you to think about in the application process. Okay.
59:06 I want to step back to Don's suggestion and comment. I actually think we're starting to, especially with so many moving parts right now and all of the things that are going on, I think we're going to have to just buy our time for a little while when it comes to stop. And that maybe rather than us trying to be, it's almost like we're trying to take on the role of the town manager and figuring out how to manage all of our resources. That's kind of his job right now, but I think we should push back to him and say this is a
59:32 This is important to us as a group and as a potential resource for funding. Think through how it should work. Yeah, so let's, I'd step back from, and especially with so many things just in flux right now with MLR and staff, and let's see how that all shakes out. And we'll keep making it work with chairs, Chris. Perhaps we could agendize this for, because I mean, for one of our, like our next meetings, at least for a topic.
1:00:01 Since we are talking. Well, I think our next couple of meetings are going to be pretty. Pretty busy. Just these. Simulator. Our first open agenda. Yeah. We should start dealing with some of these things, yeah. Yeah, I was just going to say before we move off topic, I think it's much larger than you, it's much larger than us. It is. It is. It's really a town issue, and I think it's a town.
1:00:24 Strategic investments, strategic perspective, you know, and we've always skirted around the issue. I don't think it's really up to town staff just to submit an application. I think it's really... Yeah, much bigger than that. It really does. I think that was my last one. So there's also... So Kathleen was here, and I know she's probably in time, but she was speaking about an opportunity to submit an additional application due to personal problems, and if you wanted to talk about that at all. I would, yes, thank you. That might be...
1:00:53 Prune at this time. Thank you. I wasn't sure when to. Yeah. Hi, my name is Kathleen Calderon, and I do Mammoth Village Fest, and I'm also involved in the Jazz, Mammoth Jazz Jubilee. And I also last year had submitted a Measure U funding request for the Old Mammoth Events Road. Old Mammoth Road.
1:01:21 Not to rehash all my personal things that I'm going through right now, but a very dear friend of mine has just recently passed away, and I spent a lot of time with the family, and I was unable to compile all the information for the old Mammoth Road events, and I was wondering if by any chance I could be given a few days to submit it to you. If not, I understand because I know there are timelines.
1:01:44 But I just wanted to throw it out to you because they do, they would like to apply for funding and I'm just throwing it out as a thought. Was that part last year of the MLEC joint? Yes, it was. And actually the group, the Old Mammoth Roads, has been at every meeting. We did the prelim with Stu. We've been involved with the MLEC since it's,
1:02:18 Since last year, or actually a few months before, probably about a year and a half. So I would just like to ask if that's possible. Do you have a feel for how long it would take you to get it in? Could you tell me what today is, please? Today's Tuesday. I'm sorry. We lost a very dear firefighter here in town, Billy Anderson. I could probably have it by Friday, if that would be appropriate.
1:02:48 Or you tell me when you want it and I'll just, I'll do it. This would be the performance report and the application, are you saying? Yes, I believe that the performance report actually was turned in last year when we received, prior to receiving the funding for it last year. But yes, I can include that. We met with all, I mean we adhered to all the criteria that we needed to do for last year's
1:03:18 and the funding that you were so generous in giving them.
1:03:21 And they would like to go forward because it was a very successful event along Old Mammoth Road. We had estimated 200 people and we exceeded about 450. It was during motocross weekend, which was kind of a, it was an interesting weekend to have it. And we had a very diverse group of people that attended it. And I don't know, some of you I know were there, but it was a fun event. The animation of Old Mammoth Road was really what we were.
1:03:48 All about. And we had bands and wine tasting and food tasting. And so I'm just asking you if that's possible. Or if you could give me a timeline, I will adhere to it. I realize this is highly unusual, but... Stu, can I ask how this would affect staff? Do we... Um, it doesn't affect staff. I mean, we're primarily the applicants. They kind of do the first meeting. So we just filter and...
1:04:21 Look at it. Yeah, we can work with the applicant on to make sure it fits in the requirements, not the guidelines. So I don't think that's an issue. Well, I think we had consensus that if this is going in MLEC, that we were just going to move all of those forward, making the assumption that they fit the criteria anyway. So I would not have any problem with seeing that extra one added in without any guarantee of funding for it. Right. I understand. Okay. And with the performance report, correct? Yes. Okay. Yeah.
1:04:51 Okay. Stu, can we do consensus on this or do you want a motion? I think you could probably do it all the end if you wanted to for the whole prompt to fill to the first phase. I think that's what you want to maybe look at. Well, except this is an extra. Tell you what, I'll make a motion. I make a motion that we accept the late application from the Old Mammoth Road. Road. Road. Road. I would second it. Aye. Aye.
1:05:24 Thank you very much. I appreciate your consideration. Thank you. Thanks. The only other one you can see there from the Camdenham Lakes is the municipal wayfinding project. So what staff is proposing that we phase that project. So phase one you can see is for requesting $200,000 in this award. And then we request for the committee can encumber those funds to the next award in 2014 for the balance of that award, which is $134,000.
1:05:54 What staff tried to do, you can see with the application, is to fit the funding amount of requests within the funding limits of what's available. We're happy to do that. Again, with these new applications, it's going to really depend on what the committee makes their recommendations for. As you can see, what we've included in the bottom is already...
1:06:21 Staff has taken out the administration costs, which you can see for $32,000, the maintenance of Whitmore tracks, and we've also invested that $33,000 in that capital investment fund. So that's what's going to be taken out in addition to the $33,000. The only other thing I would say is the, if we're looking at attachment D,
1:06:45 The Mammoth Lakes Foundation Repertory Theatre is more of a programming application, so I'd probably move that down into the capital programming application category. You can see staff put together to hopefully facilitate the process to kind of categorise the application. So what I'd recommend is we replace that with the Old Mammoth Road application so they would sit in second right now to become forward with their applicant, and then we'd move the repertory theatre into the capital programming application.
1:07:14 Since we're dealing with the way this is laid out, the recreation special event applications, I don't think Mammoth Rocks fits there.
1:07:43 That I would say is an art and cultural application. They applied under the recreation special event. That's the box they checked. Can't help what box they checked. I hate to chalk them off as recreation when in fact it is arts and culture. It's food and entertainment. They have three boxes to check and they checked that one. I mean, it's recreation entertainment, in other words, the box they checked.
1:08:12 Okay, we can say that for every one of the MLEC applications, that they are entertainment, recreation. It isn't the box they checked. Why don't we ask Mark about that? Because he wrote the application. Yeah. All right, Mark. I think this remains an ongoing dilemma and question with, depending on who's defining an event,
1:08:43 What's contained within the event? Is it recreation? Yes. Is it arts and culture? I argue yes. I seem to have been over the years when representing Mammoth Rocks with regards to where it qualifies on the event's application and this purpose have fallen under quite a bit of scrutiny for
1:09:08 Putting it under the arts and culture because there's those purists of arts and culture that say it's more recreation. So in my efforts to appease all, I've checked the recreation box. But it's also arts and culture in my opinion. And you didn't appease us all. There just goes to show. There you go. And I will tell you why I bring that up. It has become...
1:09:38 I believe that all special events are special events. Most of them are arts and culture. Some of them kamikaze, I suppose, is pure recreation, but I believe they fall in a special event category. We have an argument among us here that we want to split them out so that we can say what money was spent on recreation. If we're going to do that, then I don't want what I believe to be an arts application getting charged up so later we can say, hey, here's how much we spent on recreation and include an event that is...
1:10:06 For all intents and purposes, the same as the other events we're charging up to arts. I don't like breaking it out that way, but that's the way it's being broken out and reported back. So I would just as soon have your application appear under arts because since I personally believe most of the special events have a similarity to yours, that's where it belongs. Just my opinion, regardless what box was checked, I understand your problem in dealing with this because that's the way it's been put out there.
1:10:38 Yeah, that's the challenge is everybody has their own very unique opinion on how each event is categorized. So if it helps facilitate the process, I'm happy to check the arts and culture box for the purposes of this application. I think he noted it. I think it's both. He noted it on the page saying meets the definition of both recreation and performing arts.
1:11:04 You know, I mean, build a matrix that we use is only a rough balancing thing. It's not an allocation. It's something that the steering committee said we should do from time to time to make sure that, you know, one of the three categories isn't being overlooked. But, you know, I mean, yes, I brought it up several times that recreation so far has been over 60%. This is a very small amount. I'm not, I don't think we should worry about it that much.
1:11:33 Or we can always drop the matrix, but the steering committee said we should use it. That's the only reason they bring it up. So we all kind of understand there's some things that are clearly arts and culture. There's some things that are clearly recreational. There are others that are kind of in between, you know, so. Well, you know, I know when I wandered around with my ribs last time and I listened to Pete Watercott.
1:11:59 You know, Fiddling Pete, who is also Sierra Summer Festival, and other things that I guess I would sort of agree with Bill on this one, that on those fine lines. Yeah, it's very fine. It is, but I think food kind of goes under arts and culture too. We'll probably have a kitchen and a sprung structure. Let's see, what was this, food and wine something that's up there? So I would kind of agree with Bill on that one.
1:12:29 You know, at the end of the day, I don't think it's going to make sense. It's not. If it ever got down to Bill's Measure U question, or Measure R question. Yeah, I don't think it's a big deal. I mean, that's what I'm saying. It's just that, you know, I think. I just say, as far as the MLEC is concerned, we actually have more than one box amongst all of us because the food and wine event, we actually checked off under recreation, even though we have an education component. And, yes, we do have arts and culture involved in that.
1:12:59 But the overwhelming, based on the criterion in the forum, really does say recreation. So had Mark been part of the MLEC, had we been able to make the timing work for everyone, you wouldn't even be asking this question. I'm just going to bring that up. It's just a bar. It's not like I'm bringing up the time that we spent, I think, on this summit with us doing the meeting. And they actually spent time categorizing those applications, and the council has already approved it.
1:13:27 If it's a performing arts, visual arts, and a arts-based educational organization, then it's an arts and cultural organization box. If it's a recreational event that's open to the general public, then it's a special event. It's a special event. We've defined it. So really, we're kind of there, and I think that's why it sits in that recreation box. I don't know. Mammoth Rocks is an arts and cultural organization. I don't know if it's a REPS Department 1C3 in regards to performing that. So anyway, I think we've been there. I think we've carried out. Thank you. No, that's not... We're doing it all.
1:13:57 Thank you, Stu. Is there anyone else that would like to speak on behalf? Back to something that Stu said about, you said perhaps the Repertory Theater should be moved or? Yes, it's not typically an event. They're requesting programming funds for that facility.
1:14:22 That's why I would probably recommend just putting them in that capital slash programming application. Oh, programming applications. Oh, I see. Okay. In other words, that's item number two. Because that's the year-round support of the repertoire. So item number two would move down to capital and programming? Right. Okay. And what was – there was another movement I missed. Thank you for asking. Oh, man, for an answer would probably slide into the NLAC. Okay. Okay. I see. Okay. I'm not through. Okay. We don't know the amount yet from –
1:14:57 Old Mammoth Road events, though. That'll come in? Yes. Okay. There's also a request from individual advocates to put time against each of the presentations. I know what we typically do is provide up to 10 minutes, but then it's really up to the committee for those questions. They might have more questions or less questions, so it's sometimes difficult to put a particular time against each of those applications. So, I mean, you can tell me what you'd like me to do, but that's why we typically don't.
1:15:29 I'd say let's encourage them to keep it shorter whenever possible.
1:15:59 We will have plenty of time between now and then to go over all the applications and come up with some pretty pointed questions, hopefully. More than overnight. Yeah, and, you know, I mean, sometimes too much information isn't helpful. Yeah, I personally would love to see a presentation from everyone, not having been on the committee last year. I'd love to see something. Obviously, short and sweet would be wonderful. Yeah.
1:16:30 So, Stu, are we trying to make a decision here on whether or not we want everyone to make a presentation? It's up to us to keep. I think the question is whether if an applicant has provided the performance report in the previous event, if they had any questions like Bill was saying that might be relevant. I don't know if you need a full-blown presentation from that group to really ask what's different, what's changed.
1:17:00 If we ask them, as I said, what are the changes? I would like to see each applicant at the podium for a moment, even if they have hopefully nothing to say new, so that we could ask each one of them individually. So we have the opportunity. Questions, yeah. So my encouragement would be make them as short as possible because you're a known entity, but I would like the opportunity to question each one of them separately at the podium. That would be my, I don't think I'm going to quantify and say you have 10 minutes.
1:17:28 I would like them to each spend three minutes or two minutes. But I do want each of them to make a presentation if it is just to stand up there and say, what are your questions? And last year, I remember the MLEC, remember they just kind of lined up and bam, bam, bam, bam, and I thought that was very effective. So you can repeat that act for me. And then... There's a press in the room, MLEC went bam, bam. They just lined up and came up and it was great.
1:17:56 And then, I don't know if I'm jumping ahead, but we would be approving the order as well that we have outlined. So I suppose we've done it by consensus, but I would make a motion that we put MLEC applications up first and that for today's purpose we accept all of those as meeting criteria.
1:18:30 And then move on and look at each one of the events from 7 through 15 quickly to make sure they all meet the criteria. That's my motion on how we carry through today. Yeah, as amended. Yes. Yeah. I would second. Aye. So Bill, would you like to ask? So then, yeah, what I would do now probably is start with number 7 in our book and go through the
1:19:12 primary filter, which is attachment B, one through five, and make sure that it, of course, now I have to find number seven. You know, again, since this is pretty much a known one. Well, let's just ask the question real quick. So, Draya, if you just want to start with number seven and ask us the question, number one, yes or no, number two, yes or no,
1:19:49 The first time you go through it, you may want to read those questions for those in the audience who don't know what one, two, three, four, or five is. But after that, we should just be able to ask on each application whether it's yes or no. My question here was do we actually need to go to that detail when you have four known things right here again? And we know that they passed the primary filters last year. So, you know, I'm thinking if there was something new in there.
1:20:16 But all of these we know passed the filter last year. Sorry. I know you're saying number seven, but could you... Yes, I'm going over. Absolutely. Number seven is the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation's Kamikaze Bike Games. All right, so let's start asking this question. So number seven...
1:20:45 Do you want to go through every one of them? Is my question. Sandy, if you think you want to pass those, I would just make a motion that we pass 7 through 10 through. That's what I would do. Without, then I would ask you to make that motion. Okay. I'll move that we accept 7 through 10. As they are all Mammoth Rocks, Fly Fishers, and the Mono Council for the Arts, we have performance reports for all of them. They're all known.
1:21:12 Commodities, so I would say I would move that we accept 7 through 10 as we did 1 through 6. And for the sake of the public here, Sandy, could you please read 7 through 10? Yeah, Mammoth Kamikaze Bike Games, and that's the Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation, Mammoth Rocks, A Taste to the Sierra, Southwest Council, Federation of Fly Fishers, the Fly Fishing Fair, and the Mono Council for the Arts, the Kids Fishing Festival. All of these were events last year.
1:21:40 They all went through the filter last year, so I'm just saying, you know, rather than reading off the questions, and I think it's more efficient, maybe just go ahead and say, go for it. And seeing how I was wrong, those would actually fall under the event evaluation form. Yeah. That we don't have approved yet. That we're not using yet. That we're not using yet. It's not approved by the council, so we have to use what we had before.
1:22:06 From my standpoint, for today's event, that's what if it passes those filters, that's how it can go off. So whether it's been approved or not, would you then amend your motion to include 11? Yes, I would. Is there a classic theater, right? They what? This is their first time applying. No, I know, but it's an event. That's been going on for many years. And we could just move it forward without having to ask ourselves those six.
1:22:42 Questions? With the amendment to add that, I would second the motion. A clarification for me. This is a totally new application, so the rationale that they've been here before, so let's move it forward. It's not a totally new event. They've been going on for years. Well, I know it has, but this is a new application, correct? Which is the first time they are applying. Yes.
1:23:07 That's correct. So we just want to be careful to pass it. Since it hasn't gone through a filter before, I scratched my head over. And we will once again amend. Could we remove that and look at it? If Sandy will amend her motion, I will amend my second. So we have the amended motion to include items 7, 8, 9,
1:23:35 And 10, the Mammoth Kamikaze Bike Games, Mammoth Rocks, A Taste of the Sierra, Fly Fishing Fair, and the Kids Fishing Festival. A motion to approve the primary filter. Do we have a first? Do we have a second? Yes, I second. The bill seconded it. Thank you. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Aye. All right. Thank you, Stu. So next, then, we will address item number 11, the Sierra Classic Theater, Summer Shakespeare in the Woods.
1:24:06 Ms. Chair, Madam Chair, however you want to be, Drea. I would suggest, even though it has not been approved by Council, that we use the primary filter from the draft event evaluation form for number 11. So item, attachment C. Attachment C. Attachment C. I will then go ahead and read through the primary filter, and we can decide yes or no.
1:24:33 Is the event funding application for operational expenditures only? Where is this one in here? With a better budget, I can tell you, but it's a thin one, kind of nice, back towards the rear. Yeah, that would be C, I think, isn't it? So it's $2,000 operations, $2,000.
1:25:00 So it's all operated. It sounds like it's all operated. It is. It's okay. They don't get money from the town. Okay, so it's yes. Well, you know, we've argued that point as well. Supplant doesn't necessarily mean the town. Oh, that's true. Supplant just means that we're taking the place of other available funding. So, but in this case, I would say no, yeah. Well, it does not supplant, so it's actually.
1:25:38 Yes. So it's a yes. So we can all have a yes. Just for the sake of the public here who may not have these forms. So number one is the event funding application for operational expenditures only. Yes. Yes. Number two, the event funding application does not supplant existing funds. Yes. Yes. Number three, the event aligns with the Measure U priorities.
1:26:08 Yes. Number four, the applicant complied with the stated funding guidelines. Yes. Well, that's a different, yeah, that's kind of open. It's quite, because they're asking actually for about 100%.
1:26:26 But it is a free event open to the public, so it's a very... Well, they're not really asking for 100%. Well, you know, they'd say that someplace in the application, but I know you're right, the figures don't exactly match. Right. It's just because they didn't know how the thing operated, and this is their first application. Yep. It's not their first event, but it's their first application. Right. They have not adequately listed all expenses. They have listed...
1:26:54 I will try to clean that up. Right. And there are a lot of other good models to look at. Volunteer time is significant. It's extremely significant. But it's not in here. It's not real dollars either, but yeah. We put in at least 100 hours of these copies. I know that's what I put it. So I think, committee, could we ask
1:27:25 The Sierra Classic Theater Company to possibly amend their application. Clean it up a little bit. Clean it up specifically for the stated funding guidelines. And Stu, would we want to have that by Friday or detailed? I don't know that we can get it exactly with that one. I know and I'm thinking about the Children's Fishing Festival also. Yes, comparable. We have, it's very comparable. You know, it's an event that's open to everybody.
1:27:53 In fact, they probably don't follow the guidelines either, but it's... I agree. We're not looking for something perfect here, but we are just looking for a little bit of a cleanup, and if we could possibly get that by Friday turned into stew. Mike, would that work? And I would be comfortable with getting an answer on four and five.
1:28:20 By the 17th when we, so that I have it in front of me when I'm looking and asking questions. Performance report wouldn't be applicable. Performance report wouldn't be applicable. No, because they haven't done it. That's what I mean. In terms of money they've received before, but they've done the event several times. And as part of their budget, I would love to see they make money on one event and they use it for this event, which doesn't show here. And I would like to see
1:28:47 How that all ferrets out and what the monies are, how many people they've had in the past and what they've done, you know, the event has been going on. So they could put together a paragraph and a half if they wished on the success of the event in the past and how they have funded it in the past. If I might just, as a member of the Measure U events task force that put together the application, the revised application,
1:29:14 The criterion that we talked about was that first year events would not be funded, but that we would recommend that a first year event put together a performance report so that when they come in the second year to request funds, they have a performance report from the previous year that meets all the various criterion that we put together in the application process.
1:29:34 You know, like, who's the event producer? All those pieces of information to help us guide the second year event application. So, since this is a multi-year event, I would think that, you know, having been on that task force, Joyce, that we would expect there would be some kind of performance report, whether it may not have to do with the one that's required now, but certainly there should be the ability to... There is information in that application that...
1:30:00 It's kind of, it does give the background and the history. Yeah, it does. Yeah, so it's like a performance. But it's just, we're saying it's a little bit more difficult because it's not a first year event. It's a first year application. And it's, you know, definitely, to me, those are those little things that I think we can work with. And it's there. So if Mike can just kind of clean up the figures. On Bill's point about the other things that the group does, do we require that of other events?
1:30:29 Do we require, and I see Brian's gone now, but that he covers all his winter events that are also paid, and... Yeah, I don't think it's... They're mentioned. They're reviewed a little bit about the organization's entire budget. Yeah. Well, the budget for the event needs to cover what other incomes are being used and where they're coming from. I don't want to see the total cost of the organization, but...
1:30:57 It's in the application. For Mammoth Food and Wine, I had to put my... Yeah, yeah, yeah, but it's different. It's different. We're talking... It's an event. The event and the organization that produced the event was required to put in an annual budget. Right. Yeah. I'm just saying, well, we were required to do it for our... But you didn't have to put in the entire Mammoth Lakes Foundation budget. Yes, I did. Oh, you did.
1:31:21 Yeah, hers is there. Okay. Yeah, it is there. So you'd like an operating budget expenses and what we've contributed in the past to this event and what we yield. Right. As close as you can kind of do that, Mike, right, because what's really helpful for us this year, I think, has been the people who've shown their actual...
1:31:44 Their projected budget a lot of times for last year and their actual for this. There's a history there. The history. And since we just couldn't see your history. I mean, it's implied in your write-up. Absolutely. And of course this year, because we're trying to make this a much more professional production, the budget has increased exponentially. Exactly. And the treasurer.
1:32:05 And accountants for Sierra Classic Theater is on her way to Sweden right now. So trying to do this by Friday is an issue, you say? I will do the best. Yeah. But I'm pretty sure she's at LA. I actually wait for a plane right now. Yeah. We're not asking for perfection. Yeah. Okay. The Mammoth Lakes Foundation has been doing it a long time, Juliana. Yes. You guys are perfection. We know that. Yeah.
1:32:31 But, okay, even when you look at what the task force went through, what we require is if it's a non-profit, then the non-profit has to present its budget. And non-profit organizations are required by law to have their budgets made public. So that's part of whether an organization is a non-profit or a commercial entity. And that was part of the requirements that we did ask of each organization to apply for funding.
1:32:58 You know, for all of those in the MLEC and outside the MLEC and everyone who else is applying, we're all doing our full budgets. And I would just ask that the committee keep the standards and nothing because I'm sure they have the information. But it's just if you're going to be consistent, you're going to be consistent. Otherwise, you know, why did I go through what I went through and what did they go through and everyone else go through the process? Equity demands that we do that and that's what we will do. Thank you.
1:33:27 You bet. And just a quick question, do we request this by Friday or would Tuesday be all right? I'm fine with Tuesday. They've got people missing and everything else as long as I have it when it comes time to ask questions so that I can ask questions based on the budget. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yeah, get it to Stu a little bit sooner so he can make copies for us. Yes. Yeah, you know. We have a Monday. A few days lead time. Yeah. Monday.
1:33:56 Monday. I appreciate that. Morning, so you can make copies. You can always hand in at least settle copies. I will do that. Yeah, that would be the easiest for you. And Stu, yeah. All right, thank you, Mike. With that, then, it looks like we, let's move along. For number five, the applicant provided a detailed performance report, if applicable.
1:34:22 We will see more details by the time we meet on the 17th. And number six, primary filter, will the event be conducted if Measure U funds are not awarded? That says yes. Has been. Thank you. Yeah, it has been. On a shoestring, yes. All right, then. Let's move along to the capital programming applications number 12.
1:34:54 The Mammoth Lakes Foundation Performing Arts Center Planning Grant for $25,000. I appreciate your time. My truck broke down this morning. I had to go deal with it. My diesel truck froze up. So I appreciate your time, and I will certainly get that to you ASAP. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, Mike. Thanks for having me this morning for answering our questions. It's just an extra sheet past the one you're at. Thank you.
1:35:42 I like what Don's done with his. I need to go home and color coordinate mine. We have all of those red sheets, but it's still. Yeah, it was passed a few of them, yeah. It's really not color coordinated, but at least I get to them. I'm missing something. So now we're on Evans, correct? Excellent, yes. So we will then go to number B. Is that correct?
1:36:11 To the 2013 Measure U Fall Award Project Filter and Checklist. I have a question. Yes. If we already moved the repertory theater down there, number two, probably we need to deal with them as well because we would not have moved them forward with the event. So if we start with number two and then go to number 12, we will not mess up and leave one out. Thank you.
1:36:40 And which form do we use for it? This would be the, if it's a capital programming, then it would be the B application. That's right. Okay. All right, so applicant. It's programming, yes. Number two, Mammoth Lakes Foundation for the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater. We will be now moving that to the capital programming applications and going through the checklist for the number one primary filter.
1:37:09 Is the project program for planning, construction, and operation, maintenance, programming, and administration of facilities, equipment, and projects for mobility, recreation, or arts and culture? Yes. Yes. Number two, the project program does not supplant existing funds used for the purposes identified above. Yes, it does not. I know it. As an English major, it's like...
1:37:36 Number three, does the project program meet the goals established by the town? Yes. Number four, is the project program identified in the town's adopted plans? Yes. Number five, did the applicant provide a detailed project program conceptual plan and economic analysis? Yes. I believe so. I know that we've seen a yes. There's a business plan in here. I know we've seen a yeah.
1:38:19 All right, then, with that, do we need a motion? No, consensus, I believe, works, does it not, Stu? Yeah. It passed the filter. Okay, so we'll just move through everyone and then do a motion. Okay. So then, number 12, Mammoth Lakes Foundation for the Performing Arts Center Planning Grant for $25,000. I'm going to try and make this quick. I believe it passes primary filter. I would agree. I would agree. Excellent.
1:39:00 Then number 13, Town of Mammoth Lakes, the Mammoth Roller Rink Operations for $20,000. Once again, I'm going to stick my head out and say it passes primary filter. I would agree. Excellent. Number 14, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, special event trolley funding for $20,000. I have a question on this one.
1:39:25 Yes, I believe it crashes primary filters. Yep. My question is why did we reduce it from 24 down to 20? Because we did it. It was still running a balance in that previous fund bill. Right. Yeah, I think that when we set this up, my request was that we do it at enough so that we don't have to change that figure. If they don't spend it, it just goes back into the pot. My preference would be just to keep it at 24 in case something happens and we need...
1:39:52 More event trolleys for one reason or another. They were well below budget, I think. Yeah. I think quite a bit. So I think the 20 figured was sufficient. Okay. Again, I will say it passes all primary filtering. Yep. Agreed. Excellent. Number 15, Town of Mammoth Lakes, Municipal Wayfinding for Phase 1, the 2013 award for $200,000, and then Municipal Wayfinding for Phase 2, the 2014 award.
1:40:23 Projected for $134,250. You know, I know we awarded funds last year, but Stu, where's the funding come from this before? I'm curious on the supplanting question. This was, I can give the background on that for mobility. This project was funded, the first phases, was funded totally through grants, all the planning, the merchant.
1:40:53 Design group that, and it went over a couple of years, but the first actual funding for construction was last year with us. Okay. So there was no supplanting issue in, it's one of these huge long projects that's been totally grant funded. Okay, so all of the design work that's happened between last year and now has all been grant funding as well? That was, no, between last year and this year, no, that was part of, that was the cleanup of the design work.
1:41:21 In other words, the initial consultant left side planning type of thing, that was all grant funded. Yeah, and that's what, so between last year and now there's been hours spent on this work. It was the final, we did. In other words, it was. You did.
1:41:37 Measure U paid for that? Measure U did. Okay. It was the final, actually, engineering design type of work. And then the construction of the first, actually the first monument, which is supposed to go out in front of Footloose, which I hoped it happened this year, but it's happening in the spring. Yeah. Yeah, so that'll be, and then this is the rest of the signs. So are we approving, my, my, I'm a little confused about the 2014 award portion of this.
1:42:05 Oh, that'll come forward. It'll come forward then. So nothing now is a commitment. This is just the filter. Just an application. The filter. Just the filter. Yeah. And is there a consensus that it passes the primary filter? Oh, yeah. Yes. Yes. All right. Then do we have a motion to accept capital programming applications? Item number two, Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater. Twelve, Performing Arts.
1:42:36 Senator Planning Grant, 13, Mammoth Roller Rink Operations, 14, Special Event Trolley Funding, and 15, Municipal Wayfinding Phase I, 2013 Award. Do we have a motion to accept these? I would move to accept them. Thank you. Do we have a second? Second. All in favor? Aye. Aye. Excellent. So with that then we have...
1:43:08 Reviewed the 2013 Measure U Fall Funding Applicant Presentations for Primary Filter Requirements, and now for number two, to approve the proposed order of applicant presentations as presented in attachment D.
1:43:36 And what I've done here is just kept the Mammoth Food and Wine as the first one and then replaced the Repertory Theatre with the Old Mammoth Road event application. Excellent. Three would be Jason Gugli, four would be Mammoth Lakes Music Festival, five would be Village Fest, six would be Sierra Summer Festival. And then you have the recreation event applications. First would be Kamikaze Bike Gang, second would be Mammoth Rocks, third would be Fly Fishing Fair, and fourth would be the Kids Fishing Festival.
1:44:07 You still have the Sierra Classic Theater as the non-MLEC arts and culture application. And then the order down here on the last capital program, the application to performing arts and planning grant. No, no, no. Repertory. MLRT. I was actually going to just keep them first and put the repertory theater below them. Okay. You can go either way. It's up to you. I can't want to go to the repertory theater as the first one then. Then the performing arts and planning grant, roll-room operations, trolley funding and municipal.
1:44:40 I will make a motion to approve that order. Do you have a second? I'll second. All in favor? Aye. Thank you. So are there any other comments or questions or future agenda items from the committee? Future agenda items, I'm not sure how we deal with that. It's not on the agenda, so I don't know that we can actually deal with it.
1:45:08 One of the things, an actual amount of money that we would be giving to events specifically, we've talked about limiting that. We haven't talked about what we're going to limit that to, and I would love to see that on the agenda for the 17th. I don't know how we deal with that, though, because that's the day we're listening to. Well, I thought we'd gotten to specifically, we weren't limiting anything in particular because
1:45:36 Because we hadn't come to any kind of policy decision on that and we didn't want to. Well, we also have that policy document that Dan put together. We're supposed to address it on a separate. I thought we're supposed to address that and I hoped that this would sort of be a trial of that thing. So how all of this fits together isn't clear.
1:46:03 It's Greek to me, but that thing won't be done by the 17th. I have no problem just going forward as we have gone forward, knowing that I have certain amounts in my mind that I want to do it. Oh, yes. Well, I would agree, and I think if we have that date for January 7th, I think, which may or may not be needed.
1:46:22 And perhaps we can have a... Maybe that becomes... Because some of this will have formed up by then a bit. Because it's going to be a big policy decision for us. Well, and I think discussion is good. You know, the more we can discuss it and kind of kick it around is good. And at the same time, what I heard too was this whole special event support type of thing where, you know, the revenue coming in was $5,000 and yet the support, there's another $45,000 that went out.
1:46:48 So I think that's a separate discussion I'd like to see agendized too. Stu, is there a plan for reviewing that policy document or continuing that discussion we had in here?
1:47:06 And after the January... Yeah, we won't be doing that before then, so... But, you know, sometimes it's worthwhile having it... Yeah.
1:47:34 I think it's too wrapped into the policy conversation. All right. So we'll move back to a later date. So the 7th in February, March. I think the 7th is good for the discussion on the categories of funding and your amounts because I think it's perfect. I think special events, if we can push that to February, I think that would be okay because it's more aligned with that policy discussion. Right. Yeah. So I think that would go more together. We have two meetings scheduled in January. The 7th and the 14th. Right. Yeah.
1:48:02 And the 7th you see being full? I thought the 7th was going to be the... If necessary, right. If necessary, right. If necessary, presentations. If you want to agenda that meeting, that's great. Typically what we'll do is have those follow-up questions to the applicants, and they're going to come back. But we can make that decision on our next meeting on the 17th. Yes. Okay. Yes. See how the presentations go, and we need that extra meeting. Or perhaps just for some of that. Yeah. What not? Excellent. Okay, so we'll decide then. Right.
1:48:33 And then Stu, I'm sorry, I jumped ahead. Is there a few of a manager's report or anything? Excellent. Then with that, we have a motion to adjourn today's meeting to the 2013 Measure U Fall Funding Application Presentations on Tuesday, December 17th at 8.30 in Sweet C. Did you ask any of the committee members if they had a report? I'm sorry. Committee member? They may not, but I... Thank you, thank you. I jumped ahead. I thought it sort of...
1:49:01 Added that in earlier. But committee members, do you have any reports? It's cold. That's my report. Just one comment. I did attend the MLR meeting, and there's only an action and a no action alternative, nothing else. And the proposed option that the facilitators brought forward was to put Measure U, Measure R,
1:49:31 Trails and special events under the MLR. So this is just an update for you to keep. If you want to find out about the notes, anything like that, PowerPoint, go on the rec department's website, go to the very last thing, which is the MLR process, and then you've got a whole bunch of documents, including notes and PowerPoints, and there's also a feedback sheet now that's available electronically that wasn't before. So if you have any feedback you want to...
1:50:00 Make you can. For the public. For the public and for members of the committee. Are the notes from the last session online yet? No, they won't. Or presentation. They put them on at the last minute, yeah. All right, well, Sandy, thank you for that. And with that, do we have a... I'd like to go ahead. Thank you. Do we have a second to adjourn? I'll second. All in favor? Aye. Thank you. See you next week. Okay. Do it.
1:50:28 Next week? What is next week? It's next week. It is next week. It's next week. It's next week. Have we lost that week? We lost that week. I got a Christmas shop. We're there. Where did my week go? Fabulous show opening on Thursday. Oh. This meeting's over. This meeting's over. Okay. Good. Thank you for telling me. Bye-bye. Thank you, Sarah.
1:51:03 I'll be there. Oh, my. Go back to your one bill. Did that say in that packet, one of all of them? Yeah. Okay, I delivered. I thought it was two for some reason. I dropped it off to her because she just got back in town yesterday. Well, she'll probably notice if it says that on the agenda. Yeah. Okay.
1:51:35 You don't know if there's other documents on the NLR. I also have a recommendation. Sister, I assume we will get like a new, an updated month. Perfect. Thank you. Thank you for that. Thank you for helping move this along. Perhaps part of our turnover.
1:51:59 That's where we are today. I did sit yesterday afternoon.
1:52:16 Perhaps there is a third line of the chart. Perhaps there is a cultural by the name of C3, which is sort of what he's been thinking about. But the evolution of what he would deal with that, because he's certainly interested in the art thing under the foundation. But sorting out this.
1:52:46 Thank you. Thank you.
1:53:15 So anyway, but I didn't get a response necessarily. Oh, I said, I thought
1:53:44 Thank you.
1:54:10 So we'll see.
1:54:11 So we'll see.
1:54:12 No, see.
1:54:13 The 16.
1:54:14 Yeah, because that's exactly right.
1:54:17 These are things that are in the line of the line of the line.
1:54:19 Can you just come in line?
1:54:20 And I mean, I mean, that's basically somebody we don't need to say.
1:54:25 Because let's face it right now, the 16.
1:54:28 We don't even know.
1:54:29 The constraints are that they haven't even read the ordinance.
1:54:31 They haven't read anything.
1:54:32 I mean, what's true or speak, though?
1:54:34 The jury has a discussion.
1:54:36 It was live on the whole of the other words.
1:54:39 Thank you.
1:54:39 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:56:21 Thank you.
1:56:52 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
1:57:09 Thank you.
1:57:36 I said that to the manager, I said, look, you've got these rooms, they're great to know, they're like, each room should find people for them, and then 20 feet away, but they spend the time, and either need to do it for a day.
1:57:55 Believe me, if I'm spending 100% by something for a day, I'm going to be doing this in the way.
1:58:03 It's exactly right.
1:58:04 Thank you.
1:58:06 Thank you for your help and helping.
1:58:36 Thank you.