TransparentMammoth

Parks & Recreation Commission · 2013

Parks & Recreation Commission

· recording 2 hr 59 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

399 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 This is a big day. We've got a lot of stuff to cover. Michael will go over a meeting overview here shortly. I want to thank you all for coming again. I think we're getting there. We did, just so you know, go through a lot of old documents. We've seen county documents and color-coded.

0:27 Plans and all kinds of things that you guys spent a lot of time together putting together. So we're going to pull some of that. You'll see it here today. But when we leave today, I think one of the things that we want to get to is some alternatives that we can really begin to know and things we can begin to put together.

0:49 for the council to review. We've met a lot. We've got a lot of information. You'll get a lot more to pay. So we really have sort of a place in mind where we want to get to so that we can keep this process moving and not run it out until June or anything like that. So I'm going to let Michael, oh, for the record, why don't we go around and do introductions just for the public record, Dan. We'll start with you. Dan Hollerner, town manager.

1:16 Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. Oh, sorry, I ran right over you. I know, I know who you are. Rickwood Council. John Urdi, Maniflix Shorten. Joe Bacon Carolson. Dana Stroud, Eastern Sierra Interpretive Association. Colin Fernie, Planning and Economic Development Commission. Betsy Truax, Frank Commissioner. John Armstrong, Full Century in Eastside Village. Terry Settler Park Commission. Okay. Yes?

1:45 I'm sorry in the back, I didn't. Jay, thank you. Sorry about that. Okay, everybody, I'm going to turn it over to Michael. He's going to give you an overview, and we'll be getting into some meat here in just a quick second. So, Michael.

2:11 So I know you all have an agenda in front of me. We're going to throw a whole series of handouts at you at the course of the meeting. So every component of this agenda has a separate handout. If you don't mind, our preference is just to kind of deliver them as we're having that piece of conversation. The agenda, in brief, looks something like this. Carl outlined today's role, what we'd like to get to. We've got a regulation process flow chart, which we'll kind of put in front of here in just a minute.

2:40 and add a little bit of life to it. We've got a rec outcomes framework. It's the beginning of that flow chart I'll explain at the moment. We did take a pretty deep dive into all of the history of how we have thought about slotting or allocating services and core services. In fact, we're going to use the term core services interchangeably with slotting by task and by skill and so on.

3:05 But you think it's really not the purview of this room to get down the skills and so on. I think it's really a function of one of the core services. Plus, Carl and I had the not-so-surprising epiphany after reading all those documents that we do not have a planning problem.

3:22 In fact, you don't have a problem allocating what ought to go where and what to call it. It seems like you've done it several times. And so we feel even more urgency as your support team to help you get past that step. So if anything, it's one of those. There are a couple of options. We've got these two things going together. We've got a subliminary budget.

3:51 Frames that will give us a way of looking at the relative cost of administration over there versus programs and other investments. And we're going to build on the investment piece with a couple of portfolio options. I think you will find that destructive. We're going to need to have a very robust dialogue during that part. We did do some homework. We were asked to do this around measures R&U. I know you guys have actually done this a couple of times.

4:21 2012 of interpretation by your attorney and now we have a 2013 reinterpretation by an attorney. We just ask the questions differently that they'll be charged accordingly. And then we think it's really important to what I would call an eyes wide open dialogue about where by looking at risk analysis from the perspective of not only what the direct risk of a

4:49 Not my strategy of, but what the, what the opportunity cost would be associated with that. These are pretty simple steps. And then at the end of the meeting, I think we want to say, we want to reach the place where we say, what questions have we not addressed? Let's, let's get those clear. That's kind of an agenda setting tool, and to the extent we can resolve any of those questions we do while we're here, so we'll stay as necessary to do that.

5:16 Or when you all get that good year in the head of this look. And then we want to review the outcome and see if, in fact, we're clear, because Carl and I have some work to do in putting, coming back to you on the 6th of January, with a framework that will reflect all of the work you've done in the course of these six meetings. And then identify the next steps. So that's the agenda plan.

5:45 A lot of documents and tools. Corp, could you please distribute that? We're going to look at the common use of this. Any questions on the agenda while this is going around? Yes. Are there copies? Yep. Right here, John. We made extra copies. Let's make sure everyone puts them up here. Is there one? Yeah, we have extras as we go through each. Yeah, looks like. Oops. Actually, there's an extra one here. Sorry.

6:17 Put it back in the gridlock. Put it in the pot. It's like a poker game. Well, I thought it looked like we all got our first card. Paper and pot. By the way, the time frames on the agenda were just a little more time. We have a discussion at whatever length or whatever that's necessary to do that. So on this cover sheet, we're just going to look at the cover sheet now.

6:50 Rec, the structure of this audio piece. There are two pieces to this cover sheet. The first part is kind of the flow of the process as we see it that we've been following. We started out with a very clear vision of where we wanted to get, and that vision is recaptured just below the flow there. One thing we never did very explicitly in the process was declare

7:17 The outcomes, where we moved into dialogue about models and structures and where to allocate tasks and who would do it and what would it cost and what are the skill sets required and what are the legal issues. Those are a lot of details that sort of beg a set of outcomes that are very clear. Those are the means to what end are we pointing this process. I'll go over some suggested outcomes. We have done a very good job of thinking.

7:46 We did it through the gains exercise in the summer. Then we rolled those gains up into a set of strategies for MLR and really for recreation in general. And now we want to build on that. We're going to use that same framework for the slotings here today. So we're going to take all the slotings work, the townies document, color-coded document, all those documents, and kind of summarize them and roll them up into that slotings framework.

8:14 And really the rest of the process is about implementation. It's structure, it's budget, it's how you allocate overhead. What's your relative investment in one thing versus another? What part is capital? What part is programs? And so on. And then how do you measure all of that? And in the spirit of Stephen Covey and beginning with the end of mine, I would like to make sure that we don't have a really deep dialogue on tactics.

8:42 During the meeting, without being very, which are the meetings, without being very clear about what the ends are. Why are you all here to focus on creating a better set of recreation outcomes, even than you already have? The assumption you have good outcomes now. What are those outcomes? So here's a quick download. This is not going to be exhaustive or comprehensive.

9:08 But really a discussion starter for all of you. It's the bottom half of this cover page. It says outcomes. I would summarize it like this. The outcomes, from our perspective, and I want to add one there. Five on here. Total participation. Net economic impact. That's total economic activity. Increased participation by targeted segments. That's your market component. John can help illustrate that for us.

9:39 Satisfaction with the Recreation Experience, and that has both local and visitor dimensions to it. They're quite similar, but very different, particularly when we get to things like loyalty measures, which is much more a visitor measure than a local measure. And then the total increase of recreation products, which we're going to spend a lot of time on, I think, in this meeting here. What are those products?

10:05 To what extent are they capital investments, what extent are they amenities, and so on. And I'm always personally mindful that there are fixed outcomes. There's a new reality that represents the vision you're trying to get to. More people engaged in more recreation activity, both externally, who become loyal, mammoth visitors, take advantage of those assets. More satisfaction.

10:35 and so on, and the total net primary, secondary, and tertiary economic benefits are realized through all the traditional forms, lodging, and you start to get multiplier effects. So that's, that's where they have the effects of the economic side. Sometimes they're a process of outcomes, and they're, they're implementing steps and strategic plans, they're getting particular products done and delivered, get projects built, and so on.

11:03 And one that we've been talking about endlessly, and we didn't include, but I would invite you to write on your sheet is we've given a lot of service to leveraging additional values. You have this core measure R.U. intact investment. It's your investment. It's your angel investment from the community. It's really that. And we've been having a lot of dialogue about multiplying that investment.

11:32 Two times, three times, or portions of that investment from different sources, from sponsorships, from things and so on, through philanthropy, through dedicated direct investment. So net leveraged dollars should be might be a sixth clear outcome. And I've, with Carl here, we've indicated some examples of what those measures might look like at the indicator level.

12:02 But just by way of quick response, what do you think about those outcomes? What do you like? What means explanation? Yes. I like these indicators and numbers because it seems like they would connect to something I saw in the paper. You guys might be able to give you the details better than I can explain them because there were some indexes explaining.

12:33 Recently, that would talk about the health of the town and the community, right, about where this came from, but it was a very interesting article about, it was just, it was economic, it was grades in schools, obesity of students, youth, community indicators. So it seemed like that the recreation world would benefit.

13:02 By having these things tied to those community educators in a very direct and linked way, because then that would get some guts, because I think the guts of this eventually is for the town council to say, recreation is worth 7% of our paid budget. Why? Because of all of these things, because of how it connects to those community educators of health and prosperity and building. Sure. Have you guys done a...

13:32 Community Indicator Project. Yeah, we, well, it'll be coming in front of council soon, but it just came before planning commission at our last meeting. So it's come in front of us a couple of years, and we kind of honed in on a set of, I believe it was 11 community indicators that are split up into different categories. So there's economic, a lot of kind of social health of the community.

14:01 And so, you know, it was tied to obesity rates in adolescents, how many people are on government subsidy programs for school lunches. TOT would obviously be a direct economic indicator. So, yeah, we have, and it's kind of, it should be a year-over-year synopsis of kind of the overall health of the community, but it has a little bit...

14:26 As opposed to just being economically driven and numbers driven. It's a little bit more global and social. We did one in Tahoe about 10 years ago. It was incredibly helpful for several reasons. One, at least we got some benchmarks. But two, it got all these different pieces of the community sort of talking to each other. All of a sudden, the police department was bringing their information over to, you know, the tourism people. And everyone just sort of, we didn't even know how many.

14:52 Percent of our kids were on subsidy lunches. I mean, it was a really kind of an eye-opening deal, and I suspect you'll go through the same. Yeah, and that was another one, you know, prosecuted crimes, just kind of the overall, you know, health. And certainly these could roll up in the quality of life category. Right. You know, so. So not only is that a great suggestion, and I'd be happy to make sure that we frame the funnel.

15:20 concept proposal with that kind of language. I'm going to send you guys a couple of links. We'll maybe do it this evening. There is a set of health indicators that have already been published for the county. You guys remember the Robert Johnson Foundation? It's the Robert Johnson Foundation that actually funded nationwide a county health rankings study. And those county health rankings have been published for all 58 counties in California.

15:48 In fact, we're using them, I live in El Dorado County, so we're using them for El Dorado County, and we've been able to, we spent a thousand bucks, just a thousand bucks, to get the Public Health Institute in California to actually apportion the county health rankings just by the zip codes that are included in our community. The same thing can be done here. In fact, I could set you up with that. So every one of the indicators called what you just named,

16:15 is included in those rankings. And you actually have longitudinal rankings. So they've done the study twice now. So you can actually begin to frame. What you would do is you would say, at the end of all the proposal we have, and a water wreck, you would say, what is the contribution of the recognition as a driver to these outcomes? And how do we point our investments in the direction of those outcomes? How do we get that result? A lot of that's very low levels.

16:44 You know, and I don't know if it falls into any of the other pieces, but being the marketing guy, I always look at awareness, exposure, and recognition for the destination. So, you know, I look at, right now, I look at the elite side, and I look at what we've done with our athletes over the last three years, and beyond that, with the Olympics and et cetera, you know, making sure that people love that they're from here, and that this is,

17:15 John and I were talking on Saturday night about we've got the pro cycling team from Bissell coming in for the entire month of August. So it's making sure that people know that they're here. It's not enough just to have them here. It's to make sure that Team BMC knows that they're here. So it's kind of a, it's the PR side of, it's the PR outcome to make sure that we are seen as the premier destination. So I would actually say that all of that is actually having a measure of your brand.

17:44 We probably should have a brand outcome here, to the extent that that's, these are soft data elements, and so they're hard to collect, and so on, but you get them out of your loyalty, you get them out of satisfaction, and you get them out of your satisfaction, and you actually build your data, you probably have those big functions. Yeah, and this all rolls up to that brand, I mean, that's rubber hitting the road, that's who we are. Okay, so health and brand. Anything else?

18:11 Macro indicators or macro outcomes or associated indicators that you think should be drivers for recreation decisions? Well, there's one, and I'm not sure how to say it, but that we also have to be looking to make sure that we're not ruining our product, that we're somehow sustaining the recreation product, that, you know, we're not overrunning the forest, we haven't got, you know,

18:43 People shoulder to shoulder around Lake Mary trying to fish, those kinds of things. Because there's a point where you get... Stewardship and sustainable growth. Yeah, yeah. But there's a point where you get behind it is, you know, other than opening day, people really don't want to be fishing shoulder to shoulder. Yeah, so it goes to the stewardship of the land. Yeah. This is music to my ears. I've been the lead for three years now for Lake Thomas.

19:14 So it's a pretty wild experience. I love that 22 communities and Truckee. We only consider them once in a while. The Republic of Truckee. The Republic of Truckee. Yes. The Republic of Truckee. Yeah. Like Boulder. Right? So it sits outside of the ground. We're part of the watershed. And we actually have just finished publishing.

19:38 I mean, we'll see. Yeah. Well, and I think that goes back to, so the sustainable growth and the stewardship also goes back to the experience because we, you know, we've talked about the fact that we have times where we need to add thousands and thousands of people and then we have times where we need to maintain where we are and, you know, increase our yield. Yeah. And I think that that's, I think that's a, it's pretty straightforward. I think we all know what it is. I saw it different than increasing the qualities you also still have to maintain. You know, you can't go out, you can't forget what you've already got. Right, yeah.

20:08 Okay. These are great. We should detail this. We tried to develop an efficiency, meaning that the dollars spent, there was a high flint-through rate to the, the athlete of the consumer. So, cost per, or the delivery. Yeah. Yeah. Cost per X. No, that's good. So, I would actually see that these are really good.

20:40 So I think what's so funny about this is that

21:12 We're just having a recreation discussion, yet the indicators are huge. The kinds of outcomes you're wanting to realize are really the other thing that matters and really the other development works. It's land, it's place, it's activity, it's use, it's consumption, it's how you manage that consumption, it's satisfaction with that consumption, and it's all parsed to be locals and external visitors.

21:40 It's not a part of your place-based stewardship is actually future stewards. How do we cultivate people who are not just one-time users and say, oh, we'll be at a great time, but wow, I'm really committed to that place. Well, and that goes back to your loyalty piece and stakeholders. I mean, we want people to think that they're part of this and they, I mean, they are the stewards. They're not just coming up here to village and leave. You hit it in here with that strong element, too.

22:11 Are our best ambassadors for what we have our locals? Are they out there bragging on what we have? Are they talking about the experience they have here by living here? And it's not just resulting in who's coming up to visit, but, you know, it's, yeah, you're inviting your friends and family up here because it's a great place to be. And so it's not just what they enjoy, but it's how they actually serve the ambassadors out.

22:42 Yeah, you don't want to, one of the things we determine while we have a lot, it's one thing we determine at the top of that we have as a challenge is that the most frequent point of contact other than incidental in the markets, in the aisle standing in the checks, the most frequent point of contact is all the various concierge services and lodgings and so on, but the lodging properties are not all systematically trained.

23:06 to be effective ambassadors for the visitors. So the visitors should be able to go to the desk and not have to say, hey, I'd like to go to X, where do I find it? The person at the desk would say, welcome to Mammoth, what do you like to do? So in effect, that conversation facilitated to active concierge is kind of an active ambassador process.

23:31 Okay, great. This is double the number of outcomes. Anything we're missing? Anybody? I just got a question. So, for the purpose of these outcomes, are we sort of including arts and culture as a subset of recreation? Yeah, I would say it, but do you think it needs to be called out? It's all they told me it needs to be called out or it would get buried. The recreation would overwhelm arts and culture. I think, yeah, I think so. What would you suggest?

23:59 I mean, I think that we see a lot of this. I think the outcomes would, you know, all fit with arts and culture. I think we may just, you know, maybe want to asterisk, you know, recreation as, you know, including, you know, more than just, you know, people outside. Or maybe looking at, you know, those core strategies from restaurants as, you know. Well, it may be that the user participation, I mean, you segment that actually includes that kind of dedicated. It's a lot of interest. And we get to the capital in a sense that we understand.

24:28 I think when you look at that diversity of product, that's a huge one. Because it's a different type of recreation, but yet it's a fulfillment. We're going to get exercises for local and visitors alike. So we'll just hang on to that. And if, of course, the meeting, if you have a great story on how do you like to express that in your measure of the terms.

24:53 All right. All right. Michael, just for my senior grade, would you put the leveraging up there, too, so that since it wasn't on the phone line? Yeah. So number of hours Xbox use. Right. Community-wide number of Xbox use hours. Yeah. You want to rely on sources that come down the road. That's how you stay in your stewardship.

25:22 Michael, when we talk about loyalty, in your past, have you done any Net Promoter Score stuff with towns? No. I have. Because, I mean, we want to do it from the marketing side, and obviously Net Promoter Score is how likely you are to recommend a destination, but, I mean, can we tie that into here as part of the loyalty piece? Absolutely. I've done this through big nationwide organizations through the customer service. Right. In fact, John, SMG next year is going to launch.

25:50 a net promoter score study for every destination in the state so that people can see what destinations have the top net promoter score. Yep. But how are you getting that info? Because, I mean, we're going to do it locally here. It's something we have to... Oh, no, no. We'll do it on a statewide survey of residents. Oh, okay. We want to get their perspective on what the net promoter score for Mammoth would be versus...

26:16 Big Bear versus Monterey versus whatever. Of course, we'll give you an opportunity to buy into that. Of course you will. It never is. I mean, it's just an indicator, and I think if we do it through lodging, and we have a net promoter score for our lodging in town, and we come out at 84%.

26:42 I'm not sure. Does everybody know Net Promoter? I mean, it's something if we can look at even just how our guests are looking at us, even if we're not comparing it to Big Bear. Right, right, right, right. At least we can know and we can set goals to say, okay, we're at 84 this year, we want to be 87 next year. And what we'll be able to show you is of those who aren't going to your place, what they perceive. Right. Right.

27:12 Mm-hmm. So, yeah, good, good. Okay. Good, now we have the right one. Now let's talk about sliding and, you know, a whole structural aspect of this.

27:29 So we took a pretty deep dive here to all of the, thank you for the thousands of babies. Good thing you have nothing else. Yeah, John, thanks for being the historian. What we did was we went back and looked at all of us, and my desire here is not to go through every single bullet point, but again to show you how we looked at that data and how we can bring that forward into this discussion.

27:56 Exhibit 1, and these are core services as identified in what I think you guys called the townies color-coded document, if that makes historical sense to your recollection. What we did was we looked at what you had assigned to core services for municipal recreation and just put them in, you'll find those in Exhibit 1. I did highlight on the bottom

28:23 A couple of them that I thought these were just notes to me that could be moved over to an MLR, which we talked about last week. But again, these are very familiar. These are what you guys identified in the past. Exhibit 2 are those services that could be moved over to an MLR. And again, this is just my judgment. We could debate each one of these.

28:53 You can begin to see that some of the things that you had originally identified could be assigned over to an MLR. And that's where those are. Exhibit 3, you guys had identified as color-coded, that could go to the appropriate agency. These were what you guys had identified services to be provided when funds were available. So all I did was make a suggestion of where they might best fit.

29:21 And again, we could debate what bullet points was where, but you can begin to see the process. And then finally, there are some things that you identified that could be potentially shared between an MLR and the Municipal Recreation. So what we did was just take what you had, okay, all the work you did in developing the townies document, and just sort of realign them for the moment, okay?

29:48 So hold on because we're going to move the whole thing forward here. On the next page, what we began to look at are all those activities through the proposed structure that we looked at last week. If you remember correctly, we looked at the town council, we had municipal recreation, everybody talked about a dotted line to MLR and then a dotted line to Mammoth Lakes Tourism. What we did

30:15 was we looked at, we went to the strategies, okay, you identified the MLR strategies, and then we simply went back to your recreation plan of January 2010 and pulled the recreation strategy, municipal recreation strategies that you had identified and designed back then and put that in that category. So you could begin to see that there's clearly MLR strategies.

30:40 which we saw along the lines of research and development and investment and municipal recreation strategies which we saw more along the lines of operations and communications. So everything you've seen to this point is your handiwork. We've just sort of rearranged a few boxes for you to maybe look at it in a fresh way. Now, moving forward, what we've done is look at municipal recreation,

31:10 Remember those items you saw in the very beginning? We've attached a strategy to them, okay, which you guys identified, and then we attached a potential measurement to that activity, okay? So if you look at provide diverse indoor-outdoor recreation programs, including delivering classes, yada, yada, yada, we saw that as a programming strategy which you had identified.

31:39 And then there is a measurement to that. Is in fact the town providing high quality recreation programs or new programs being developed annually and so forth? That way there's an activity which you identified that the town should be doing or MLR should be doing. That specific activity is attached to one of the strategies you identified. And then there's a measurement to assess whether it's getting done or not. So we included the loops.

32:08 Those measurements go back to the outcomes that we just went over. So we've created a whole loop for you guys to consider. So those are the municipal recreation. On the next page you'll see Mammoth Lakes, what could be for MLR, same deal. We went back to what we had previously identified as an activity. We tagged it into a strategy, and again, you came up with the strategies.

32:38 And then we looked it into a measurement. Can that be measurement? So now everything on the MLR side has a task, has a strategy, a task and a measurement. And everything on municipal has a task, a strategy, a task and a measurement. So all we did was take all the information that you guys came up with and sort of reclassified it in a way that makes a little more sense moving forward. Thoughts and comments?

33:12 Any questions? Yeah, one, in the first block on municipal recreation, the third bullet about recognizing, nurturing, and investing in the trendsetters and the high-profile athletes, I think the government side of it, just to use, so we're not using all the same words, is to nurture and support, but I think that

33:39 The actual recognizing and working with them isn't any different than the leverage, excuse me, wait a minute, let me find it here, developing the partnerships and things that are on the MLR page. That when you look at, you know, positioning to act on emerging trends and leveraging future sponsorships and things like that, to me, the cultivating the elites goes with that. It just goes on that side.

34:09 And again, like I said, I didn't, we can massage these all day long, and I think at some point you would. Because I think it was on a previous page, it was down there, and I think it's a shared responsibility, but, and if you look at our experience, we have a track because we had a group who came forward, found the leverage funds and things, and brought it to the town, and the town could support it happening. Same thing with trails. So that, I think the town has a support role, but the actual, I don't know.

34:38 Grooming is not, I don't know what word I want, the actual growing of those things falls with this other, the leveraging and the funding. Fair enough. That's pretty good. Natalia? I just want to provide one little bit of clarification on that, the initial document that was used to establish MLR and the Municipal Recreation Strategies, this color-coded document. The yellows indicated it could be either one.

35:05 Right. So it could either be municipal or it could be some type of an entity. There were only a couple that were very specific that the town had to do that nobody else could do. One of those is processing special event permits on the town property. And then the second one was provide administrative oversight of leases, contracts, and permits held by the town with Forest Service, DWP, and any other entities. Those were the two that they had to do and they had to retain.

35:35 Everything else could go either direction. And so where you kind of got it split MLR strategies and municipal recreation strategies, I would just point out that almost everything under municipal recreation strategies and almost everything under MLR strategies could go like this. Yeah, I just made a decision. Okay. I had to move us along. Okay. Well, that's fine. Yeah, no, no. And again, when you get down to the nitty-gritty and you sit down,

36:03 You could say, you know what, better fits over there, better fits over there. The point of the discussion was to capture everything you had done in the past and say there's a bailiwick of work for MLR, there's a bailiwick of work for municipal, there's strategies attached so they're not out there in left field, and there's ways to measure what the heck we're doing. Right, so I'm just advising you don't have to get locked into these two boxes, that there's a lot of this between those two boxes. Point well taken.

36:32 In fact, we're inviting, that's because we're inviting the style of one. This is just a distribution. What do you think about distribution? Help us refine it. How about the general, I mean, we used a concept frame for municipal rec and said it's really about operations, administration, and communication. We looked at MLR as research and development investments.

37:02 That was very consistent with our summer activities, the outlook for summer. But we went back to your 2010 documents and went, wow, you already drew these conclusions then. You were already there. In fact, it was not so much an attempt at this, we were like, okay, how do we...

37:25 How do we mobilize, how do we overcome the inertia that's blocking the process from just saying yes? So are those the right clusters, research and development, investment on the MLR side? Operations, administration, communication on the municipal creation side? I think that there's more, let's see.

37:53 I think MLR could also include some programming and development of programming. Okay, so if that's definition of R&D, then I'm okay with that. R&D, I had a different definition of mine, but if we're talking program... John's working on the track guys, the programming, high altitude stuff, and that's kind of that.

38:22 So that's all under there, Shepard. Okay. And then what about buildings or construction? What is that? And operations and communications, research and development, investment. Are you looking at investment as construction?

38:40 Well, there's one that says new capital projects. I mean, new product development experience includes new capital projects. So if there's a multi-use facility, it's in MLR. Capital tends to fall forward because the town has legal responsibility. Right. Yes. You can have others help program or what it looks like. You can get that, yeah. You know, I think it's helpful, and I want to move us past this. There's a continuum of MLR and municipal, and certain things can flow certain ways.

39:09 Under certain circumstances. I think what we're trying to do in order to move us into the next discussion, which is money, is to just sort of look at what this could look like. Again, not that it's perfect, but here's some rules, strategies, measurements, and so forth at a conceptual level. Thoughts, comments? Yeah, I see a lot of things crossing over, especially when it comes to implementing recreation projects that are in town plans.

39:41 You know, I'm not sure we're going to get them off paper without the MLR. I think there's going to be a lot of flow. That's the second one you ever did. You're saying, you know, we don't want to get stuck on this, but that's the thing I did. I wrote a lot of joint on that stuff that's under municipal. But I think that's part of the challenge, too, that you've been stuck with.

40:07 It's always somebody else's deal. You know, what I hear very frequently is we're waiting for leadership from the council to tell us what to do. Council is looking for input and advice on what to do. Everybody's sort of doing this. And what I've done is, like it or not, they're in a box right now. And if there's a reason to move them, we can move them. But yeah, they could probably flow every which way. But you've got to take a stand somewhere and say,

40:36 You guys are in charge of that. You guys are in charge of that until there's a point where you say it's friction and we need to sit down and maybe move it around. You've got that with all the arrows going back and forth. I mean, there's always going to be that. Absolutely. But there is going to have to be a, you know, Stuart's going to be in charge of doing sure AYSO goes off and the MLR guy's going to be in charge of making sure that the, you know, track is programmed or that we have camps or that we develop.

41:03 This is a ready, fire, aim process. It is not perfection out of the box. You'll switch, swap, flip, flop. You guys do it better. You guys do it better. Let's sit down. As long as you have a dialogue and you sit down and you're solving the problem moving forward, I think things may move around a lot.

41:29 You've got to start. Yeah, and I think that what you're looking at when you're talking about, you know, what MLR is, if you're looking at research development and investment and what those programs would entail, and when you're looking at providing a community activity, that's going to be where this is all separated out. So a program is going to be in both areas, but they're...

41:54 Let me give you this too. If this were me, I could lay out the intellectual argument on paper that each could do the other's job. Okay? Just put it up on the wall, I could make the intellectual argument. Municipal could do this and MLR could do that. Okay? And so, yeah, there's a lot of flux.

42:20 Going back and forth, but we've got to sort of put some feet in the sand. Well, I mean, to get back to your point, though, what we're really trying to do is which entity will do it better. Right. Or they'll take the lead. Yeah, and I think, you know, you did hit the nail on the head with, you know, municipal handle operations and communication because that is the strength of that entity.

42:41 R&D and Investment, and we talk a lot about being entrepreneurial and fast-moving and all those kind of things fall in line with a separate entity that's more entrepreneurial. So, you know, as we're talking about capital improvement projects and kind of those fast-moving market trend.

42:58 Dictated things. Those fall better into R&D and investments with a separate entity. So I agree with where those things are placed. Okay, I want to open it up to the audience comments, questions. Yeah, Pat. Oh, those were more notes for me.

43:23 I'm sorry. When I was going through all of this, believe me, my eyes weren't late. And I was trying to read things on a spreadsheet or a screen. So, yeah, I wouldn't worry too much. I wouldn't worry about that. That was just more of my notes. Yeah, so. I was going to say, I don't have that. Yeah, you've got the one.

43:50 Yeah. I don't see screen. I mean highlights, right?

44:04 Oh, is that what that is? Oh, I thought it was just, no, I thought it was telling us it wasn't grammatically correct. No, incomplete sentence. Fragment. Fragment sentence. I wouldn't worry about it. I don't mean anything other than I may have been looking at it at night and I didn't want to lose my place. It doesn't mean anything of consequence here, but I appreciate your eyesight.

44:30 Well, Mike still has the pen in his hand. On page four where we've got the two things, I think the engage in recreation planning, the second bullet has to be one that's both sides. It doesn't just MLR, it has to be both sides are engaged in recreation planning. How do you know what the future needs are if you didn't ask your people that are doing R&D?

44:57 So I really strongly personally agree with that. This is the point of actually having one set of outcomes. You don't channel your outcomes by delivery process. You have one set of outcomes. But the indicators may be on different levels by different functions. You allocate to functions the tasks that get you the most agility.

45:26 Okay. All right. We are going to move on to something new. We are moving away, and we are getting into some budget stuff. Are there any other adjustments in the allocations?

45:56 I think, you know, we've always operated on the premise of continual improvement. And you have to have a process of continual improvement. That no matter what you end up with at the starting point, there's continuous improvement. I mean, when we formed MLT, the chamber was this thing over here, and it was over there.

46:25 And now continuous improvement, you know, it sort of evolves and you keep going. Okay, what I've done here, and again, this is theoretical in discussion purpose, is just to give you a sense of overhead and what that variable could look like. I confirmed with Stu that the amounts collected, the 1.7 million was for the last fiscal, Stu? His current fiscal year. His current fiscal year. That was the anticipated collections.

46:55 I began to look at overhead. If overhead were 10%, that would be roughly $177,000. If overhead were 12%, a little bit over $200,000. If overhead were 15%, you'd be looking at $265,000. We could run the numbers out, but I thought it would be good to focus on that. If you look at Exhibit 2, what I began to look at is a beginning of an allocation. Now, if we had 10% overhead,

47:24 And what I did there was create a range of funds, capital funds allocation from 40% to 80%, what that would begin to look like. It's also important to note the highlighted bullet point number two, that when we talk about leverage, the outside money the organization raises, we want to at least equal the overhead costs so the whole thing is revenue neutral.

47:54 Okay, so that we're not taking S, we're borrowing S funds, but it would be a revenue neutral deal. I've done the same scenarios on the following page, projecting overhead at 12%, and again, that range of capital projects between 40 and 80%, you can see what's available. Okay, and what's included in capital projects, we could have a huge, that could be bond money, that could be

48:21 Money going to maintenance. That could be, you know, a variety of capital project investment. I'm wondering what's an overhead. It's wages, but is it rent? Is it copier leases? That would be the whole enchilada. Is it? Yeah. Is that realistic based on your experience? I don't know. If we're talking about everything? Everything. Pencils included?

48:49 So if you're looking at 20%, you're looking at over 300,000 in overhead. I mean, again, we can run the numbers out. If you're looking at what? If you're looking at 20%. Oh, 20%. Yeah, yeah, yeah. Overhead. Right, right, right. And again, we can run the numbers out, but again, it sets up a dynamic where you want to get to, eventually get to capital leverage that's going to equal the overhead so that you're revenue neutral. Okay? And again,

49:15 I'm just laying out some concepts here. I was just saying we're just looking at some options because we still don't know what it is. Of course we don't know what that overhead percentage is. Right. But again, you have to be wary of overhead. You know, is it a 30% overhead? You know, is it because there's a point where you begin to say, well, yeah, where's the, you know, where does it make sense? Is it 40% overhead? I mean, I can run these numbers and detail them in greater.

49:46 Greater detail. But again, you begin to see what this looks like. If you had 15% overhead and you invested 80% into capital projects, you'd be putting $1.2 million into stuff, capital projects. Put $300,000 into other stuff. If you did it at 10% overhead and you were investing 40%

50:15 In capital projects, you'd have $637,000. There's a wide range here. And what we're trying to point out is there's somewhere that this has to fall and you have to take account for the overhead charges and that has to be a leverage goal so that we get to revenue neutral at some point. Comments, questions? We have overhead now.

50:41 Yes. No, no, I'm not saying overhead's a bad thing. I'm just saying it's overhead, that's all. But this is a separate, if this goes separate entity, then you've got to build that from the ground up with where are they going to live. You know, what have been all the, you know, FF&E, I mean, you're going to need desks, you're going to need computers, you're going to need, I mean, there's a lot of that that's set up. And maybe it's just a lot of it's year one, but rent keeps going. Yes. Wages, benefits.

51:05 Yeah, and I'm not saying overhead's a bad thing. It just is part of the equation. I'm just trying to illustrate, we're just trying to illustrate what those numbers begin to look like. Do we know what this would be with the town's overhead percentage? So this is taking, this is a new entity? Yeah. So is there a comparison that says if we were to... We did not, but typically town overhead is... What percentage is that? I think for...

51:33 Comparison, you know, you asked the question, we have overhead. Well, town overhead's going to be twice a minus. What is that? And so I think for comparison, or at least...

51:44 Information? Yeah, we didn't have that available. I think that's part of the project. I understand that, but I'm just saying, I think that there's a lot of perception out there that, you know, your overhead may be greater than the town's overhead, but nobody knows that. So I'm just saying, is there a comparison that we should be looking at or considering? Meaning they're the same allocation for cost, municipal or MLR, you know, MLT in the case.

52:14 The question becomes, what is the fully loaded cost? Yes. Well, that, yeah, and that's the real question. That is the real question that we don't know. It's just benefits. Alone. Totally different. And I think that's a, I think that somewhere we need to have that comparison. I think in general, most of what I've seen in NGOs,

52:37 They run a far lower fully loaded cost structure than a municipality. In fact, it's not even close a lot of times. But if that's a given, and I think it is, there are two questions. One is that people don't want duplication of overhead. Right. And that's a criticism, it's a foul idea. And two,

52:59 You made the statement that you need to leverage funds in order to effectively neutralize that overhead or that additional dollars need to come in to cover that overhead. At least that's the way that I interpreted it. But that's, you know, if all of this is inside the municipal government, wouldn't be the same? You could make the very same argument. Absolutely, and it would be higher.

53:26 My only point was to erase that objection of saying you're taking money that could be done inside. Well, if one of the goals is to go out and leverage dollars and bring some in, then that overhead cost becomes neutral, revenue neutral, and it isn't, in fact, taking away from municipal recreation funds. It, in fact, is a leverage of the whole deal. It's one of the reasons to do it.

53:53 As a matter of fact. So I'll go ahead. Just for my sense of clarity, though, does this group feel like that's a reasonable assumption that this entity is going to be revenue neutral? I mean, is MLT revenue neutral?

54:06 It's close. It's close. Will you guys make an ancillary income from all of your various... Right. I don't have them in front of me here. I think you can get there. I think you can get there. Okay, so I just want to know if that's a reasonable assumption. When you look at the recreation support foundations and programs that are going on out there, there's a lot of sponsorship stuff. The right person could probably leverage those dollars. I mean, it's not going to happen tomorrow, but over time, I actually think you have a pretty...

54:35 Pretty good opportunity. Those were the two things that jumped out at me as number one. Is 10, 12, 15 percent, is that a reasonable expectation? Maybe we're hearing no. The second question is, is it being revenue neutral? Is that a reasonable expectation? And I think I'm hearing yes. Over time, I think it is, sure. I do. So that would be your expectation of how you get there. Right. That's on your director to figure that out. Right, right, right. Okay, so what we did,

55:04 This goes back to the philosophy of the whole thing. I just have one comment and that's that we will, I think you guys know this, but we will need to take in those now so that existing maintenance obligations for the things already built with our new money. Yeah, that would fall into the capital and program line items, you know, that are already committed, so yes.

55:33 Yes. And can I clarify that the gray area, the available funds, well, let me go back. Capital funds percentage that's been discussed, that's just a random, you took 40, 50, 60 percent. Yes. You just took random numbers. So then is it presumed that what's left is the available funds, is that?

55:55 Or could that be covering everything from, is there programming built into that? Oh yeah, you could spend that whatever. Functions, operations, activities, and all that. Yeah, that would be however you want to spend. So that's okay. Everything going in capital. Yeah, everything going in capital. That align with. And again, the point was not to. That align with Measure R and U. Yeah. The point was not to give you the end budget. Right, right, right. But to give you a look at how this thing could begin to look like. Sure, sure.

56:20 I think part of the direction you're asking for from the group then is a sense for how much money or a percentage we want to allocate towards capital. Well, we're going to get to that in one second. Okay. So comments in the back.

56:36 Todd, do you have your hand up?

57:01 Yeah. Sure. Sure. Sure.

57:23 Well, I just think if you looked at an employee on a salary and benefits basis, you're going to be lower on the NGO side.

57:50 Well, we were thinking about, we were thinking of putting it in John's building for free. We'll do cheap rather. If you take on the license, you get that. Sure.

58:18 We have plenty of space. We have plenty of space. We have plenty of space. You can share space or equipment. Sure. Conference rooms. How often do we borrow a realtor?

58:47 Explain what you mean by that.

59:08 The town's overhead continues. Because if you sub it out and it goes away, it goes away. You very easily could sub it out. No, you're creating a new duplicative? No, no, no. No, I do not accept that, Sandy. No, I won't say the word duplicative. I'll say you're creating a new organization that has to pay its own lights, its own utilities, its own cost in the water.

59:38 Yeah, that's for the right reaction. Sure. That's all I'm saying. What I was really trying to say there, if I understood it correctly, is that you would reallocate the total town costs between the town's actual usage and the MLR usage if you use joint facilities. That's just an assumption.

59:55 But there's really no difference than when we split tourism and Rec. Rec maintained its staff and its budget and moved back into the town. A new entity was formed, a new budget was set aside. I paid the building off. I picked up the copier leases. So, I mean, we had the outside. We basically went private and had to go out on our own and get our own phone bills and do all the other pieces and set up the overhead.

1:00:24 But Stuart, I mean, it's almost the same thing that happened four years ago when MLT split off and Recreation went back to town. Now we're talking about municipal splitting off, staying with the town, and MLR becoming the same sort of entity that MLT is. And whether that means that they live in our building or they live in the town building or whatever it is, you know, there could be economies. But even if they live in my building, I am going to have a, they're going to have rent.

1:00:50 So, well, we're getting caught up on fixed costs that are going one way or the other, right? What we're really talking about here is a benefits package, and that's the only difference. Right, right. Well, it's like, like, we provide the building for MLT. What? We provide the building for MLT, for sure. And, like, housing is bought. So there's other cost elements in how you subsidize your cost, share costs. Sure, but your savings is going to come.

1:01:17 From a different set of benefits. From a different set of benefits. At the same time, we have a creative process for MLR and MLP. Betsy, Teri, various folks, we give our time and get paid nothing. Tomorrow morning at 8.30, we're going to listen to proposals. And at some point in time, I expect that MLR will have a process to do those things.

1:01:46 I don't think those folks are going to do it for you. Well, but you're also not accounting fully for steward's costs. Oh, but it's in the 4%. It is there, yes. No, no, no, no. I would imagine, Don, that steward's costs far exceed 4%. Okay? When you look at the time and you look at the process, so you have, you've been getting,

1:02:11 The community's been getting subsidized on staff time at the 4% level. All along. At some level, but again, there are some folks that spend a lot of time outside. Sure. They're volunteers. Sure. Maybe, maybe not. They may be volunteers, too. We'll see.

1:02:35 What we've done here is we've really looked at

1:03:04 Two philosophies of the organization. And what we're calling these is MLR and MLR-like. Okay? Portfolio one envisions capital investment at 60%. Okay? And again, we can change these percentages. That's MLR-like. No, that's MLR. MLR-like is most of this money allocated to capital expense.

1:03:34 Okay? And you'd have an organization that had a much lighter set of functions because most of that money is going into capital as opposed to some of these other things. Okay? This is a philosophical point of how you move forward. Okay? And you can rely, you can look back on and say, how do we spend the money? This group has done a great job of identifying issues.

1:04:01 RecStrats did a great job of identifying issues, you know, but really this will be the strategic discussion the council needs to have is do we look at a structure and investment that has significant amounts of capital tied up in capital investment or a moderate range of capital investment plus, plus, plus these other things. Okay, so you're really getting to a point now.

1:04:30 of how this thing shakes out. Well, and I hate to say it, but I'm channeling Bill Sauser at the moment. Won't you end up going to a larger and larger program and maintenance and things like that as you're building these things? Yes. So even if you started out on portfolio two light side, you're going to eventually back, you're going to have to, you're going to be moving closer and closer to one as you go along.

1:04:55 When we're successful. When we're successful, yes. So what I'd like to do, we met with Dan the other day, and he had a pretty interesting take, and I want to give him a chance to present his idea of being another newcomer and outsider. He hasn't gotten totally immersed in the mammoth aura.

1:05:16 Yeah, but we're trying. But we had a very thoughtful discussion. Brainwashing. But we had a very thoughtful discussion that we felt should be presented to this group to look at a philosophical, which way do we go? Because which way we, or which way the council can go? So I'm going to let him take it from here and go ahead.

1:05:40 And that discussion kind of came with an MLR heavy light type discussion and a lot of the other dialogue that's going on. Again, as Carl said earlier too, as he was working through BRAVE's documents, I've been trying to do that just to get myself immersed in stuff. So whether it's the general plan, the extract, the sale plan, the rec plan, plans that haven't been adopted yet, the gateway plan, the farming arts, et cetera, as well through the dialogue and discussion.

1:06:07 One of the questions I had over MLR and the whole issue of looking at RNU is how much of that is program dollars out to do, you know, recreation activity and how much of that is really building facilities that facilitate activity coming into that. And then trying to look at it and say if it's more of a capital intensive versus non-capital intensive, what does that allow us to do in looking at

1:06:32 Assuming the budget number that Carl had there, assuming that's flat for the next five years, I didn't build any growth into it, could you go out and actually borrow some of the neighborhood of 12 to 13 million dollars? That's kind of depending on municipal rates, a 20-year deal, etc. And I think the answer to that is probably yes. So if you look at that 12 to 13 million in capital investment, that's a huge number. And the idea that you have growth in your dollars, that would then...

1:07:00 Pretty much go back into your maintenance and back into your set-aside and those types of issues over time on that. If you're able to do that, do you turn around and really the choice starts to become is where do you put that heavy investment? And then looking through RecStrat and the other documents, you start to look at that and say how do you deliver the performing arts component, an area in the community that is very heavy from the events side but doesn't really have a housing element.

1:07:30 Doesn't belong somewhere yet. Looking at the stuff, talking about partnering with the college. How much of that do you really need to invest there versus leveraging their dollars and really you're looking at a couple hundred thousand a year going into operations. So call that capital support. A couple hundred thousand going there. Assuming the college builds the facility for the most part and it's tied to their educational elements and those types of things. You've got about a 10 to 12 thousand square foot facility.

1:07:59 Probably a relatively low dollar investment, maybe half a million to 750,000 from our new side of it to make that come together. The discussion on a rec center, some type of a facility here, multi-phase most likely, but a phase one where you could do 15 to 17,000 square feet. You can program that differently. Location, a whole other debate. Where does that fall out at? You could end up funding that somewhere in that $7 million.

1:08:27 Plus or minus $7.5 million range for a facility. Again, you're probably rolling $200,000 a year from an operational standpoint just to help. The same issue there, you turn around and look at an outdoor venue. What do we have for an outdoor event center? Whether that's the existing property being utilized for that, do you acquire that to secure it, do you look at investing in other property? Again,

1:08:53 Depending how you leverage your dollars, maybe about 5 million investment whether you're buying land or if you're going into current property and town owns and re-putting in the infrastructure and developing those elements that can fall into that, you end up working through that. Once you do that, it ties up somewhere in the neighborhood of 1.1, 1.2 million just in capital debt payment. So you're just taking that off the top.

1:09:19 If you put another $400,000 in operations, it eats that up. Assuming that you continue the investment in our outdoor recreation, the trail side of the house, look at that. You have $1.5 million. We've made the commitment to run through. Does that drop off to a lower level at $100,000 to $150,000 a year going forward from a trail component? Stay in there. I have a much lower overhead as a project manager, so to speak, going into something $130,000 to $150,000 a year.

1:09:48 With the Townley providing the support services, be that for the copy of the phones and those types of things. The MLR board becomes the implementation of Citizens' Oversight, that whole element of how do you program and how do you make this effective, how do you raise, how do you leverage dollars, almost hitting all of the strategy elements we've talked about before, that that community-based organization probably does better than the city organization in that perspective do that.

1:10:17 Do you end up in that case be it much more facility driven, especially in the short term if you're borrowing dollars and debt to have that stuff happen? But what it looked like to me looking at it, and again, depending how you go through the RecStrat thing, you end up with a performing arts center in the neighborhood of that 10 to 12,000 square foot. You end up with a rec center, I'll say a phase one rec center, 15 to 17,000 square foot, ultimately getting out probably to

1:10:45 25 to 30 to get everything in if people want. Maybe it's two different facilities if one's more swimming focused or water focused versus indoor activity focused. And you end up with an outdoor event center. What do you do for that? You know outdoor events are successful. How do we secure a piece of property to continue that to happen or invest in property to make that happen? And those elements start to come together and it seems to me what you don't do in that is then just a lot of programming outside of it.

1:11:15 There's a lot of elements out there. I mean, you can continue to throw dollars at those things, but from a strategic investment, do you really look at the capital intensity? And then operationally begin to say, how do you grow that? How do you have people coming in to help pay for it? Frankly, you look at the ice rink operations. That should be a town obligation. We should figure out how we take that on. We've got some challenges there financially, but we can get there. Track and pool, ultimately, some of the same issues there. There may be some investments that come.

1:11:42 It's dollars growing, you should invest back in there, but some of those things are rebuilt, challenges the economics of the town's budget, but if the other stuff is successful, you know, we're looking at next year or so, seven million bucks in promotional dollars, potentially, hopefully that creates a brand and a promise that we actually deliver on them. I think all these elements start to fit into that, and I think each of these elements starts to tie into both that visitor experience and delivering on that when you come up to Mammoth.

1:12:11 What do you enjoy? There's the outdoor activities, be that winter or summer, depending on what you're doing. There's inside activities to do. There's outdoor event activities going on. And hopefully they start to bridge their peaks. No more room space, hopefully. And then how do you begin to shove that out into the shoulder seasons? And what's that, now the MLR, that R&D element? What do you do in those months when it's really hard to track people? Are you indoor or outdoor? Well, it depends on the weather.

1:12:40 There's a whole element that starts to feed into that that works together for leverage activity. And again, what it does then is your overhead gets reduced down pretty dramatically because really you're paying debt service and the overhead really is right back to the facilities you've created versus staff and operations and all of those types of things. And to some degree if the town's already doing that, does it continue a piece of that? Depending on how you want to put the structure together that happens to that.

1:13:08 But kind of MLR light in one sense because most of these dollars over the next number of years is really capital intensive and then really how do you program it financially. Or you can really reduce down your capital and spend dollars in other areas and how do you want to go out and do things of that nature. But it seemed like those were core elements that tended to naturally flow up out of most of the documents at least that I've been able to dive in and look at. For me at least.

1:13:37 Kind of crystallize that. Those are the types of things that seem to keep coming to the top of being done. It's a matter of pulling the trivia and saying, well, how do we achieve A, B, or C? And you can argue which one's the priority. From my perspective, done right, you could do a decent rec center, decent performing arts center, decent outdoor venue. Frankly, you could hit all three of those. But in the next five years, you could have all of them up and running, pending probably the CEQA analysis.

1:14:03 Going through. But it seemed very doable, at least from a very big picture, big brush issue. And still even those dollars to really focus on that outdoor recreation, what do you do, you know, as it relates to the trail system, to the snowmobile, to the cross-country skiing, to the motorcycles, to hiking in the wilderness, you know, all the elements that fit into that. And I think it builds off and offers something that we don't have today in town.

1:14:30 Some of the research done on people visiting areas. They'll spend about 60% of their time doing other things than what they came there to do. So how do you fill in the rest of that time? And I'd say my wife and I would travel. That tends to happen. You go to go ski somewhere. You ski a couple days. Then you go, well, what else is there to do? Summertime, you go down. Where do we play on the beach? Well, after your sunburned, what else did we go do? So I'm going to start to follow that. Thank you.

1:14:59 So, Dan, just to clarify a couple things to make sure I have the notes right. So, in a sense, this is one way of expressing the 80% portfolio. Right. You wouldn't have started to move that direction. It's capital intensive. It's MLR light. The MLR functions on the website board. The admin causing, did you say $200? I had it down about $150,000 for admin, give or take. Depending on how much of that you leave in the town versus

1:15:27 Put in another organization or anything. But my assumption there is you leave a lot of the town because you're paying debt. The organization function of MLR would be leveraged activities. What's your thinking on the leverage of dollars and resources to go back to fund? I have 200,000 going into the Rec Center, 200,000 going to performing arts just straight into those facilities for operation, et cetera, and how that gets matched or not. And then the programming is a whole other element that comes in.

1:15:57 And that depends how much is local driven versus fee driven in terms of what you put into facilities. Did you have a dollar amount for the outdoor? I didn't write one. The outdoor event center really becomes the question. I looked at one issue and say if you bought land, you've got $5 million going in to buy dirt if you want to do that. Well, you have an infrastructure that goes into it too. It depends how wide open you keep it. What we do today, we don't have any infrastructure. But definitely you would put some into that. I was looking at probably about a half a million to a million over time for infrastructure.

1:16:26 Depending how much you want to have, how much you want to keep quaint and rusty. I mean, you bring 5,000, 7,000 people and you're not going to build a restroom building big enough to handle that. Frankly, you want to pour the toilets in and out. But do you have passive recreation in there otherwise? You know, winter type activity. Again, depending where you end up going with that. There's some options that probably have less costs. There's some that have more costs. Try to stay away from thou shalt buy and or put X.

1:16:57 But I think the leverage is there. You could actually end up with those three elements doing well in the community and give it a five-year window to make it happen. Well, yeah, and I totally understand that. In fact, Dan and I talked about it this morning. But essentially what you do is in five years you buy three venues, but then you have 15 more years to pay for them off. So where's the incentive? How do you get leverage to keep going to whatever's next on the list? Right.

1:17:27 Or are you stuck in a holding pattern? How do you work it so that those three are up and running but you still somehow have additional revenue coming in? The additional revenue comes in from the $7 million that he's going to spend. Well, hopefully, hopefully. But I think that needs to be folded into it so that people understand that you don't just then hit another wall because you don't have funding. How do you get the leveraged or how do you get the revenues coming back from them?

1:17:54 Right. To increase it. Yeah, and all of those have a potential to generate all of those. I mean, that's one of the things that we never considered on any of these is, I mean, the current outdoor venue, town gets no revenues off of that. Indirectly. Indirectly, I mean, it's the indirect. I'm looking at, you know, some direct. If you actually own the facility, you turn around and say, yeah, it's at $1,000. Yeah, yeah, here's your rent cost per night, yes. Yeah.

1:18:20 Yeah, you should have drawn dollars off all of them to some degree in terms of how they operate. I had a question about the Performing Arts Center and the Mammoth Lakes Foundation and the college bond. So are you tapping into that for the construction? Yeah, looking at what they put on the table at least initially, there's a deficit issue to deal with that. They've got about three million, give or take, that I think would be committed to that. As long as you meet the other element, there needs to be an educational element. I think the college, what happens there.

1:18:49 They need subsidy for operations. The college isn't going to stand up and fund it all. And I think from a partnership, you put some dollars into it on the front end, whether that's for parking, whether that's for infrastructure, whether that's for one of those issues. Like I said, I'd kick in a half million, $750,000 in some north house ballpark. I think you could do that. There's dollars out there. Leverage that. Obviously, I had to take a conversation with the college. You go, hey, we're serious. Are you now? And same with Mammoth Lakes Foundation.

1:19:18 We're very serious about moving this forward. Next step. We leverage that against the Edison Theater, so now you've got kind of an arts complex there. It's more of an indoor type facility there, but you'd be focused on that as an option. You know, that... We keep going around the room and come back to this. So, and some of the questions come to mind down the road. How do you not become...

1:19:46 Services poor while you become capital intensive. And they also, part of that question is, I see these numbers with Measure R and Measure U income numbers, but what are the numbers that we're spending on municipal recreation now and where do you think that will go, both in sort of absolute numbers or percentage of the town's budget? Kind of play with the rec side of the town budget piece, but I think some of those elements that are out there that we're currently throwing R and U at.

1:20:16 I think that's something the town needs to look at, how do you absorb those costs. Some of the smaller stuff that's going on, it's $20,000 a year for running the ice rink. Frankly, that should be a town obligation, not an R&U obligation. Right now, things are really tight, so we've done that as a matter of need. How do we transition out of that? I think that should be a priority for the town to look at. In terms of the facility addition, it's also generated into additional programming and additional services provided, I think, just in terms of what they offer.

1:20:46 I think the other challenge becomes is how do you continue some level of investment into, I'll call it passive recreation, hiking, biking, picnicking, outdoor recreation stuff that you're doing. I think you need a dollar amount every year going into that element, whether it's, you know, supporting information or whether it's actually supporting trail construction. You know, those elements that come into play that. And I'd say that that's somewhere in that 100,000 or a little better.

1:21:16 Until you actually do debt financing, that number's a little squishy in terms of you know what your interest rates are and the markets and those types of things. I assume 20 years at 6.5%. Can you do better than that? Depends on when you do debt. I've seen it as low as 4.5% and high as 7.5%. Depends on the minutes of the markets. But I think what Carl was getting at, the question is does UNR become more capital-intensive and venue-driven or is it more soft costs out there?

1:21:48 Information, Programming, other elements that are different from venue-driven events. It seemed like a lot of the documents tended to point toward venue events. I might be missing the boat there completely, so that's fine. But it seemed to kind of pyramid up to that discussion. That answers the question in 10 years' time when you look back and say, do you have a performing event center servicing?

1:22:16 30,000 people a year. Do you have a rec center that has 80% of your school age population involved in after school activities? Do you have those types of elements? And I've made the assumption that R and U, the revenue doesn't grow. I've held that flat, which is probably unrealistic, but it's a good conservative approach. Anything that starts to grow above that, where do you invest that back into the other programming?

1:22:41 It's an option. It would have to be addressed. Anything that measure our new buildings, it has to be maintained, it has to be placed. And then the other concern that I have is I see that we're looking at the capital in this, but how do we make these facilities successful? I mean, you've got to program these facilities. And then we also have an element of trails that is a huge part of this as well that is not addressed, like you said, how you invest in our outdoor.

1:23:11 So, you know, I guess, just because you build a facility, I mean, we have a trap. And it's, you know, John's taking over right now the programming of that. That shouldn't be our marketing director's purview to have to do. That would be, if you're going to build these facilities, we have to make them successful. How do you make them successful? Just because you have a building doesn't mean that it's going to be, it could just be a huge money pit.

1:23:36 I agree 100% with that. I mean, if this was the concept in terms of the capital. I don't see the best taking that into consideration within this. I think it fits in there, but yes, you're right. They have to be successful. It fits, but dollars aren't fair. This is actually another dialogue that I think put all this in front of me for the purpose of having exactly this conversation. So I think we want to get all of your reactions, public reactions on this. In a sense, this is a...

1:24:05 The capital intensive approach, it's consistent with the MLR line, portfolio option, those are just meant to be provocative for the purpose of determining where you want to place your bets. One of the reasons we put the outcomes up front is those outcomes, your intended outcomes should be drivers for where you place those bets. Who are you trying to attract? For what purposes? What's the short-term, mid-term, and long-term investment?

1:24:34 How do you avoid building assets that have long-term deferred maintenance costs and do not add to the economic evaluation? I want to just get a thought in that Terry brought up. In South Shore, we have an ice skating facility that costs $6.7 million to build competition ice. So the town ran it, and it was losing about $100,000 a year.

1:25:03 The negative. The private sector did it out. Big ordeal, big angst, big struggle, big, you know, profit's a bad word, yada, yada, yada. The guy who took it over, a very, very smart guy, he has closed the $100,000 negative operating expense and now is paying the city $25,000 a year on top of that. He's in charge of maintenance. What he did was he flipped the whole business model.

1:25:31 He said, you know, he got away from charging every kid five bucks to come in and skate, kids skate free. He now has changed the business model to be more driven by groups, more driven by whatever. Now he's sitting around and he goes, you know, the gym at the rec center sits open. I got a friend who used to play for the Warriors, and we're going to have some basketball kids. And we have a brand new track like you have.

1:25:59 Didn't cost what you guys spent, but we have a brand new beautiful track that, and he's got a track guy, now they're, you know, so on and so forth, and so, so, so the facility is part of it, you're right, and then what's the plan to activate and use the assets and make money from the asset, I think is a very key question that involves both the community and the city, but it can be done, it is being done. It's done all over the country. I guess what I'm looking at is I didn't see that.

1:26:28 As an option within this, I saw that we're putting stuff on the ground, but there was really no discussion as to exactly what you were just talking about. And that's probably that link with MLR, if you've got a private group, how do you help really program that, how do you turn those, this isn't unique to Mammoth to see that stuff happen, and you can have great examples and poor examples, both municipal and non-profit, both. There are many big ground options between these 60-80 approaches here, too. You could look at

1:26:58 It will be an asset while engaged in very amenity-intensive program development and building out that business model that might be worth a three-year run. So that you're not sinking your whole investment in one strategy. I think that's where we are. But we just frankly... Two big pictures and we can... I had a conversation this morning talking about the fact that

1:27:27 You know, there's a chicken and egg situation here where I think that the more that we can expand on programs, the more likely it is that we're going to be able to build these facilities. You know, John and I have talked about race camps and cycling camps. We've talked about running camps. We've talked about bringing in tournaments. We've talked about, you know, what are the things that we can do so that we do show up as a high altitude training center, and then all of a sudden we catch the eye of Gatorade to build a, you know, sports fitness center, things like that. And I think there's a lot of that that once we show the programming.

1:27:57 Because one of the things that floored me when I moved here was that we were so successful with all the high schools and colleges that come up here for running, training, and all the elite athletes, and, you know, we didn't have a facility, really. I mean, we had the forest, which is great. But again, I think that once you start to formalize those things, then all of a sudden, you know, the success allows us to build these facilities. And then when we're talking about trying to bring in...

1:28:21 You know, the pro cycling team from Bissell, if we've got this high altitude facility, they're probably going to rent a house here for the entire summer and train here. And then they're going to tell other teams, and I mean, that team is here because we had one rider three years ago, John, that came up and rode before the Tour of California, and he went back and brought his entire team. So it's experiential, and it's not, I think the baby steps are...

1:28:46 Let's get somebody in here to formalize those programs. You know, I want 52 weeks of running camps that I can promote. There's no reason why we shouldn't have them. We need the person to run that. And if it's a subculture of MLR, you know, I've got a woman in Wyoming that would be more than happy to program this place 52 weeks a year. She's an elite runner. She's got, you know, a thousand people in her database that would be here in a heartbeat. So I think those are the programmatic, very low-cost, no-cost, some-cost items.

1:29:12 That can get us to, okay, now that we've got this huge following, we've got these programs in place, we need this facility, and now all of a sudden we've got the eye of Nike or of Gatorade or of Power Bar or whoever, competitor group, you know, that we can go after and say, look at all these great things that we've got in place, we want to build this facility, we need 23 million bucks, we want you to be the title. So at the risk of paraphrasing too much, just to give a short name, what we've been talking about is capital intensive investment.

1:29:41 And I think that answers Terry's question of do you build something without knowing how you're going to program it? Because when you build it, you've got the programs in place, and they just now have a new facility.

1:30:11 I want to keep going around, but John's had his hand up for a really long, long time, so I want to just invite him back in. My hand was up briefly, and I'll try to be brief. But between Terry's comments and the town manager's comments and John Urdi's comments, I'm assuming that the purpose of this effort is to convene a board of directors who is responsible, as Carl said earlier on, is not a committee. There's an organization that is accountable for what happens.

1:30:38 That board of directors establishes those priorities that lie somewhere between a full capital program maybe to the other end of that. And what you guys are talking about is seeding that board to make those decisions and recommendations and using these public funds to advance and move this stuff forward. Am I correct? I would say you're correct and let me add this proviso. In fact, it's everything you just described plus this group is looking to provide some guidance to the town council.

1:31:08 As to whether and how to execute on that. And what's the appropriate portfolio mix out of the gate, year two, year three, and so on. So it's very detailed proposal. And just one final point is that this board of directors is going to be creative enough and informed enough to understand that we live in facility. Right. You know, we and that we're not...

1:31:37 You know, we're not a suburb of Salt Lake City or something. We have unique assets, which has been part of this process in the beginning. And again, that's part of the charge, back to Joe's question, of making sure we have a sustainable facility. We have good relationships with the public land management agencies and all the rest of it. But that may be a huge part of what this board is responsible for. I would call that a place-based recommendations. I need to ask you a question on something you just said, Michael.

1:32:04 I don't think that we should sit here and suggest a certain percentage. That's for the board and their executive director if we form it to decide. I think we can give the options just saying you could have different amounts, but we haven't got the background. So I just wanted to go to, you know.

1:32:23 I don't think we should spend time arguing over whether it's 40 or 50 or 60 or 70 or 80 percent. But I think we owe the counsel. We need to tell them there's ranges and here's your results. Right, exactly. We owe the counsel. If you want to do MLR, there's a couple ways to look at MLR. Correct. So that they can make an informed decision philosophically and listen to their voters and whatnot. What we're just trying to get to today is when you talk about MLR, there's a couple ways you can go.

1:32:53 And to have this discussion. You know, John makes a really good point. I could make another counterpoint that says, you know, having an indoor facility in a community like this, not a bad idea because it allows indoor programming and shoulder seasons and whatever it is. But again, I think it's not either or. I think it's a balance of things. It's not, but we're just showing you the outer extremes to get to something that we can give and put in front of a council.

1:33:22 and say, hey, the idea is viable, here's what it could look like, here's how a budget could look like, here's how it could be spent. Ultimately, it's a council's decision. Carl and I are talking about this offline back here with you. We always write the same question, and that is to give the council more than one path into success and outline true success for each path. Then it comes down to

1:33:51 How do you see the market? What do you value? What are the relative risk issues? All kinds of decisions. So yes, we're not doing the math on this. Okay, because I think that council, especially the ones who haven't been sitting here and listening to this, would say, we don't know which way to go. And that's one of the problems we've had so far is what I see this last presentation tells us is

1:34:20 Things are more possible than we had imagined previously, and I think that that's just the way to put it across, but to say that should this get formed, that it's their responsibility to come back with a recommendation on if we do three at once, or if we phase them, or those kinds of things. That's not something that council's got the expertise to weigh in on. We have personal ideas, but...

1:34:49 I think that the point that Joe just made is a key one in that I don't know that it is counsel to tell an MLR board you're going to build these three things and then you're going to become a debt service board over the next 20 years to get this paid off. I keep going back to the gains that we talked about earlier and the fact that we were looking for

1:35:19 A product, an outdoor recreation product that was going to help drive some visitation, that was going to help lead to connecting our visitors to that outdoor experience. And I'm wrestling with this capital-intensive pursuit of Measure R and U because it seems to be walking away from all the gains that we talked about earlier in relation to our outdoor recreation product and what it was that was driving us here.

1:35:49 I'm trying to be as open-minded as possible, but I'm not ready to say to an MLR board, gosh, you're smart and you're great and you're going to provide us great leadership, but all you're going to do is be debt oversight for the next 20 years. And I don't know that that's what this MLR organization, at least in my mind, was intended to be formed for. I think of so many of these other, you call them incremental or baby step efforts, that

1:36:18 Three and a half years ago, we handed over a plan and slotting and who should do what, and three and a half years later, nothing has really materialized out of it. The intent with an MLR board and this organization was to say, go do this and own this and deliver this and be accountable for it and be responsible for it. I'm not ready to say to an MLR board, you're only going to be capital.

1:36:43 Just yet. Because I think there's more to this destination and to our living here than three facilities. I'm thinking about in an instance, today is December 16th.

1:36:56 There are comments due to the Inyo National Forest on their forest plan revision process. A 25-year opportunity. The next plan is going to come 25 years from now. I'm not certain that I've seen the council or the commission or anybody else within the town weigh in on what should go into that forest plan revision process. In my mind, MLR would have taken the lead on that and would have delivered it. So that's an example.

1:37:21 Pure and simple. I'm not sure that I'm ready to go capital intensive yet. Let me throw a counter just for the point of discussion. Ten years from now, you'll have gone through $17 million plus. If you don't have anything capital built, how's that look to the taxpayer?

1:37:38 I didn't say no capital. I said I'm not a fan of capital intensive with the sake of sacrificing an outdoor recreation product development and enhancement and ownership and leadership, etc. And my other question is, we're sitting with a town entity that still has a $2 million a year price tag, I think.

1:37:59 For the next how many years to pay off the debt? The 22nd year? 21 years. So I'm not sure, you know, again, I'm not sure how that plays into the discussion, but I think it's something that we should be at least aware of, that what the town is going to be able to do is going to be somewhat constrained because of that right off the top of you $2 million going over there. So I'm just, I'm not ready to give it all to capital.

1:38:29 And if there's a hybrid somewhere in there, if there's a mix somewhere, or you give it to MLR and you let them determine based on what they're hearing, what their trends are, what's driving it, what the Gatorade folks are saying, this is what we need.

1:38:49 You walked into our trap. It's fine. You walked into our trap. I think it's really important to hear from all of you on this. So while you're thinking about what you want to say on this, Sandy, go for it. Yeah, first of all, I want to thank Dan for providing a really great analysis of what you could be because it is a sliding scale.

1:39:19 But, you know, you can talk all you want about this and that, whatever. But we just found out, and I think I'm going to say it, we can do more. We can do both. I'm on measure for you. Betsy's on measure arc. Pat's on measure arc. Dan gave us a blueprint of how to have what we've been talking about for a long time. And those are facilities, capital facilities. Now, maybe it takes us a little longer. He projected on a flat basis, which I thought was terrific.

1:39:44 Because, and he also covered, I believe I heard the 300,000 portrayals, I think I heard in that list. He covered the whole 300,000 stock. And I have to say, facilities that we've been talking about, he's not his brother to have these. Now, if you go to the demand model first, you're catering, not to our community, you're catering to the TOT again. But we have heard over and over again, if we have great facilities here,

1:40:13 Our visitors are going to come back and use it, but it provides for our community, too. I mean, so it's a slight scale. It can be a combination of the two, but I want to thank you for this. This is a true analysis. It says we can have it. We're talking about how we can actually measure you and measure our commitment to me and measure R. Both have been taking the steps towards capital. We both measure you set up a capital reserve because we said...

1:40:38 We don't want the appearance of the public that we're frittering money, even though the special events are not frittering. They create TO2 and they're TOT and they're great things. But we said we want to start a capital reserve. I've heard the same thing from the measure article. So we're all thinking the same thing. We want facilities. And those are going to have operations. And if there's growth, as Dan pointed out, if there's any growth, that can go into operations.

1:41:06 So thank you for the comment. Let me just put that back to the group here and reframe just a little bit. I think this is your challenge. Is it built and they will come? This is the 20th century model. Or is it 21st century grand?

1:41:37 Is there balance? What's the synergy between these two approaches? This is actually, I'll put that in the center of the table. And I just want to clarify, I want these buildings tomorrow. But when I talk about the demand model, even if we do talk about this being capital driven, we're going to have to amass the money over.

1:41:55 Three to five years before we're going to have enough to do. I'm thinking if you did get, by the time you build something, it's two, three years by the time you do something. Right. So what I'm saying is in the meantime, we need to develop that demand through setting up the programs that we don't currently have, whether it's cycling camps or running camps or high altitude training facilities, because that's going to create that demand so that when we do have a facility, it's not that we've built a facility that's empty. So that's...

1:42:22 Oh, sorry. Well, and to that point, which I think is really important, and I think, you know, at a big level, that's really critical. But I also think we need to remember, too, that in RecStrats, the community already asked for this stuff. You know, the local community already is, you know, is clamoring for these things. And I agree, we don't want to end up in the situation we have with the track, where we've got this amazing track, and now we're like, oh, my God, we've got to program it and make sure people are out there and using it and know they can be on it. But I think that's just important to keep in mind, is that the community has already...

1:42:50 You know, said, you know, these are some of the things we would like to see happen with our money. And, you know, frankly, the potential I see with, you know, with the MLR is a hybrid. It's, you know, instead of, you know, having to deal with all this debt service right off the top, you know, you've got an MLR to go out and talk to Gatorade, you know, talk to Ormat about building, you know, a geothermal pool, that kind of thing. So, you know, the other thing, too, is these things don't have to be sequential. They can be simultaneous.

1:43:20 You could sit there and say part of our short-term goal is we want to do a performing arts thing with the college. They got money to go. Their conversation is real. We think we ought to do it. It doesn't foreclose doing these other things that you're talking about. And I think you can do things simultaneously, not sequentially when it comes down to doing this. Let me just comment on demand versus capital.

1:43:47 I've seen it work and fail in both occasions. I've seen where in South Shore, we've been working on the demand model for years, never worked. Despite how much money we poured into marketing and all the rest of that, it didn't work. When we built a new downtown, it worked. I mean, I've seen it both ways. I've seen people spend money. I have friends, I'm doing a project in the Tri-Valley area right now. You know, they built things and...

1:44:16 Is it sort of translating? You know, and so forth. And so it works both ways. I think you need to look at it, you know, as a potential mix. You know, our goal is to draw you in two diametrically different positions to get on purpose to get somewhere. And to justify, to rationalize an approach that we can recommend to the council to say, you know what, here's what we think. You want an MLR?

1:44:44 Here's the best thinking on what it could be, what it could do, you know, what a budget could theoretically look like, and here's the outcomes we think you should expect and demand of whatever that is. So I think, again, we purposely wanted to put you in a corner, but I think what I see everyone coming to is something in the middle. It's a reasonable hybrid. That makes sense.

1:45:13 There needs to be something in the middle. And I agree wholeheartedly with Dana. That's kind of what I was trying to get to. You can't use all of these funds for a debt service because we are going to lose what we're trying to gain with going with this MLR process. But can this process motivate to get something going on the capital side?

1:45:37 Absolutely. And I think that's, and I think that has to be, absolutely. That is the expectation. I guess my conclusion, Joe, would be to disagree with you a little bit in that I think you said that it's not our position to come from the steering committee or task force and face

1:46:03 Talk about any of it on our board and say, I don't tell them what to do. If we take that approach, I think we've just done another fabulous study that's... I meant not to tell them what percentage went well. Oh, percentage, I agree. Yeah, I just meant what percentage went, you know. I think out of this, we kind of be passive when this outcomes for this group, I think we have to be passionate. Oh, definitely.

1:46:28 We have to make a huge splash when this report lands on the table of council and on the table of the community. And I think it needs to be, my position and the balance of where we are is to say, to be the best helpwinder and creation community for the country by pursuing an aggressive capital campaign while maintaining and developing

1:46:55 Programming and Services. We do that by finding world-class coaches. And even though we have some world-class athletes in town, and we have some world-class coaches, we haven't put them before. Todd Hensley, an example at the point, when he wants to retire from being a school teacher, Stuart and I was Todd Hensley, and he just runs programs for middle school-aged kids, 60-year-old week, 40-year-old, huge, great.

1:47:23 But I think that pushing and making that splash. And I agree. Let me ask one thing, and maybe you guys have done this. Have you guys done a market study on the feasibility of this elite, this training approach? I mean, what can that really drive, John, and Rubites? We haven't. I mean, what it really has done for us right now, again, it goes back to awareness and recognition. You know, when you talk to people that come here, they know that Meb has lived here, that Ryan's lived here, that Dana lives here, that this is a place for...

1:47:53 Training. We haven't done that sort of study. There may have been one done for the track. I don't know. Yeah, I would think at least. And, you know, I think that there's some information on that, but that's another place where we need to capture more data to know.

1:48:13 Who's here, why they're here, how long they've been coming here, how many people are they bringing to the track? You know, one of the things that I think was anecdotal was that with the track now, you'd get the cross-country teams, but then you'd also get the short-distance and sprinters and hurdlers and things, and I'm not sure whether that's happened or not. So, I mean, we've talked about it at our board level that that's one thing that we don't know who's here. I mean, we don't know, and you see Santa Barbara running around, and you see Irvine, and whoever's wearing their shirts, you know who they are. But there's very little...

1:48:41 Tracking of who's here, and we've talked about doing, we did have a high altitude training focused steering committee, and we were talking about, you know, how do we do an incentive that says, hey coaches, get us all your information and we'll enter you to win a trip for you and 20 kids to come here and train for a week and do all these things with Josh Cox and Mep and Dina. But we have to get a lot of those, we have to get a lot of that data. And again, I think that's where MLR really comes in handy.

1:49:07 Is that that's, because to me that's making the sausage and I don't need to know how to make the sausage, I just need the sausage. Yeah, no, no, and I agree, I'm busy. I don't want to know what's in it. Right, right, right. And again, I see that as a, Rick, you've got to speak up here. It's deliberate. No, no, no. It's all coming back to us. No, no, no. Comments? Well, you know, I just think that there's never going to be enough money to do everything that we want to do.

1:49:37 And I think that we have suffered from, you know, analysis by committee without decisions being made by the board, in this case the council. So we have an ice rink that's now, I'm going to give you this anecdotal story. I was the chair of the Parks and Recreation Commission and in May of 1998, which was one month before I was elected,

1:50:05 The Council, we went to the Council and they gave us $230,000 to buy an ice rink. Greg Seamus and I were the proponents. We had no idea how we were going to operate it, how it was going to be programmed, how we would pay for that programming, what the deficit would be. We just thought it was a good idea. And if we got one, then the Lakers, not the Lakers, but the Kings of the Ducks of summer would come up.

1:50:34 God, we thought of the same thing. And you know, in some measure, we might look back on the track and say the same thing. Well, how is it that we're going to carry out that which we say could be done? I don't believe that the government can do that as well as an entity that has the passion, the focus, the commitment, the expertise, the experience. And so...

1:51:00 That's what's fueled my interest in moving this forward in the way that we have. But what this committee has to do is provide us, that's Joe and me, with the argument points to persuade a council to effectively give up control over something that hasn't worked. And I'm not suggesting that we've misspent the money over these last four or five, three or four years.

1:51:30 I'd like to find balance, but I don't think that the council can find that balance for a number of reasons. If we could have, we would have. RecStrats is now an old document. How old is it? Three years old? And the process of getting to that document took another couple of years. So I don't know whether it ought to be capital versus demand. It ought to be both, and there's not enough money to do both. That's a perfect world.

1:51:57 But I'm convinced what I have to be able to do is make a public argument that persuades three other council members, because I'm looking for five votes on this. Actually, four, because Jo hasn't told me how she's going to vote. That is going to actually justify relinquishing control over something that people in public office don't really want to do.

1:52:24 I think we can do all these things. Everything that, with great respect for Dan, everything that he said has been thought of before. He just put it out there. And he says, well, here's the plan. I'd put $100,000 here, I'll put $200,000 here, I'll put $1.2 million here, and this is what we're going to get. I don't know whether that's going to be or not, but one thing I know is that if you have the right board and you've got the confidence, the council's got the confidence to...

1:52:51 Put together a structure that will allow for the right board, then you'll get those folks that are interested and then can make recommendations, which leads me to my final thought, and this was kind of my initial thought, and that is, you know, are we looking to have a board tell council what to do, or are we looking for the council to tell the board what to do? That's dotted line versus solid line. And, you know, in my own head, my thought is that we've got these overarching...

1:53:21 ideas and principles that have not come out of nothing or thin air. They've been developed over time. We've been through the processes and there's been public input in those and we keep coming back to the same things over and over again. That gives people who are looking to the next election, looking for votes and looking to satisfy constituents.

1:53:43 the confidence that they can give a directive, a general, broad directive to an organization that then can carry that out, but the specifics ought to be left in the organization. Let me do this just to push you in the final direction. Are we going to get a break at any point? No, we're going to power through. What you have in front of you is a risk analysis. This is the risk of doing nothing.

1:54:17 No strategic investment. There's marginal change. So that speaks to the need of doing some capital. Missed window of opportunity. If you've frozen this analysis position where you've been, the world moves by. And I can tell you right now the biggest word of the South Shore of Lake Tahoe is recreation. The things John's talking about, they're already...

1:54:47 The only difference is you've got money and they don't. And they'll maybe figure out a way to get the money. I don't know. Reduce confidence in leadership. We don't come out with an MLR with some sort of balanced approach. It creates next generation stability issues in terms of, hey, what happened? What did we miss? What have you? And then finally, a failure to execute some of those strategies on RecStrats.

1:55:17 Continues to handcuff municipal recreation. Time they've got to spend tied up in R and U and all of that, the rest of that stuff. So there's a lot of reasons to move forward. What I'm hearing, and Michael, maybe you can summarize, is there's a big key interest in moving forward with a balanced approach between capital and demand drive, okay, in this structure that we talked about that is a dotted line to the town council, okay.

1:55:47 Yeah, I want to ask, I have a question I might ask from the general department group, without pre-empting the dialogue council, which we'll see later, but I'd still like to give to everybody else, because I think some of you are, you're leaning in one direction without being asked to put on this, it should be fully vetted.

1:56:15 Sure. Yeah, yeah. Ultimately, I think I agree with a lot of what's been saying, but I feel like I'd be remiss if I didn't at least to play devil's advocate represent the other side of the spectrum because I think there's a lot of validity to the fact that obviously programming and capital projects have to work in conjunction, but when we look at Mammoth and what we're most defunct on, it is capital facilities. So when we talk about

1:56:44 Looking at RecStrats, and we talk about being the best Alpine recreation destination. In a lot of those documents, there's things about indoor-outdoor, there's things about year-round, and I think we're missing a huge piece of that, and a lot of that is tied to lack of facilities. So I just want to maybe just to be heard and to represent the other side of the spectrum respectfully. I think there is some merit to if you build it, they will come.

1:57:12 You know, I think a lot of the programming currently is a little bit hamstrung by a lack of facilities. So, I mean, I've talked to a lot of people that are like, I've got, you know, five different events or programs that I'd like to bring to town right now, but I don't have a facility to put them in. And so, you know, I guess if we're trying to pick sides.

1:57:33 I'd lay a little bit more on the capital intensive side, but to me, that's fine at 60%. I'm not necessarily making an argument for whether that's 60%, 70%, 80%, because if you look at the way the numbers break down, I mean, we're talking 12 to 13 million over five years. We're looking at an annual difference of $400,000 in the capital improvement investment portion of it. So I think...

1:57:58 It is very important to be cognizant of the fact that we can't put all of our money into capital improvements and then have no programming and no maintenance money. But I definitely, you know, really see the value and the need in some of these facilities and how that kind of broadens our offerings here. Because I think that's something that we're majorly deficient on right now. And in certain respects, sometimes we have the facility and we don't have the programming. In other areas, we might have the programming and not the facility.

1:58:27 We're kind of missing both in a lot of areas too. So we could have added to the risk analysis of risk of underutilized assets. The bottom, the back end to the last chapter of the story, Carl's telling me what's the ice rink, it's not just that they flip the business model and refocus how they view the market and fund it and so on, they look at the empty buildings.

1:58:50 And to give like a targeted example that keeps coming back in my head through this process is when I think of the two most

1:59:20 Widely known and recognized event venues, because we're talking about an event venue in the country. That would be Red Rocks outside of Denver and the Gorge. Both of those facilities do a really good job of kind of utilizing the indoor-outdoor. I mean, as John said, we are an amazing facility.

1:59:37 And I think that's what's been so cool about Sam's Wood Site up to this point. It's like you feel like you're going to a festival or a concert just in the middle of the woods, right? And so that's a unique experience that can only happen here as opposed to where I grew up in Columbus, Ohio, where it's like you pick a suburb and you put something up and people go because you get big venues there, right? So I think with some sort of capital improvements to a facility like that,

2:00:04 That has to be a piece of it, but you can have a kind of low-cost capital improvement. You don't have to build a 50,000 square foot concert venue. You can put some capital improvement into that facility, and then it's kind of an indoor-outdoor, really cool venue. So it's not like Denver was known as a worldwide mecca for outdoor music prior to Red Rocks. It became that because they have this world.

2:00:31 Renowned Facility. So I think, I just want to just kind of represent that kind of devil's advocate side of the things that I think we've been talking about a lot of these facilities for a very long time here. It's very well vetted that the community wants them. And it was really cool to see that laid out, Dan, to just like we can actually do this in five years or whether it takes seven years or eight years. And I would be less concerned with it taking eight years as opposed to five if we do them right.

2:01:01 Because we have a lot of facilities here that really aren't up to snuff, and that's part of what impacts the programming, you know. So not to call out like specific facilities, but we all know that they exist.

2:01:23 I just want to add, you know, Rick talks about 1998 going out and buying an ice rink. Colin talks about, you know, how many times this community has talked about its desire and or need for a rec center or an aquatic center or a

2:01:41 Public, a performing arts facility or an event venue. And I keep coming back to, well, why don't we have these? We passed R back in 2008. That was five and a half years ago. It was passed. We passed you in 2010. That was three and a half years ago. We are no further towards...

2:01:59 Securing those or obtaining those or building those or approving those or identifying those than we were in 2005 when I landed here in 1998 when you were Chair of the Rec Commission. And I keep struggling with why is it that we haven't gotten off the dime on this? What is our hesitation? Where does this live?

2:02:16 When I come back to the fact that it hasn't lived with any entity that is willing to take a risk and go out and do it. And so if we're talking about an MLR, and if we're talking about creating this entity that is going to potentially take on that debt service, etc.,

2:02:35 I'm okay with sending it with some debt service if we're going to get it done. If that's going to be the entity to own it, to deliver it, to champion it, to bring it forward to the community in a way that gets it done once and for all. In 2005, a bunch of people went on a peer resort tour. In 2006, some more people went on a peer resort tour. And everybody came back very excited. We need this, this, this, and that, and that, and that, and that.

2:02:59 Put it in all the plans and put it in everything. Nothing has ever come out of any of those. And I am just sitting here, I'm scratching my head. Why? Why haven't we done it? Why hasn't it gotten off the dime? And I'm ready to say, I would support an MLR who is going to take on that ownership and is going to take on that champion to deliver it.

2:03:23 to program it, to take care of the facilities that we have now and enhance that programming opportunity. We know these facilities sit empty, but let's give it some life and let it go do it because we've sat here, I've sat here for eight and a half years and we haven't gotten as far as I would hope we could have gotten. If we're going to give it this entity, send it to MLR and let it deliver it, let it take on some debt, let it go leverage, let it go pursue it.

2:03:52 Because nothing else has worked that I'm aware of or that I'm familiar with. We have a lot of plans that are sitting on a lot of tables and a lot of desks and a lot of bookshelves that we haven't been able to really, really get in and implement. And I just keep seeing, is MLR the path for it? And it's, I don't know, I'm just asking that question and posing, that's why we're here. But it's very frustrating to hear that

2:04:21 We've all said it. It's living in all the plans, but we haven't gotten a point to deliver it just yet. Sorry. I just wanted to make a really brief comment following up on what Colin said in terms of the risk analysis, and I think Dana makes great points, too, in terms of, you know, why don't we have this stuff. And I think there are some explanations, but I think it's time we got this stuff.

2:04:42 I think something else we can add to the risk analysis, and maybe it falls under the first one, is that we are also at risk of pouring a lot of money into inadequate facilities. And I am going to call out one of them, and that's, you know, we have a community center that needs a new group. You know, it's not meeting the community needs. Our programming is limited. You know, we can't, you know, have a good gymnastics. I mean, we have a gymnastics program, but it's limited by the ceiling height. I mean, it's just, it's not adequate for the community needs.

2:05:10 You know, at the rate we're going, we could, you know, we take, we really have a risk of putting a lot of money in the facilities that aren't, aren't what we need. Yes, agreed, you could misspend your investments. Right. On a number of levels, you could have an inadequate facility, poorly accounted for long-term deferred maintenance costs, and you could have an inadequate program, so an underutilized asset. All of those are really some of the risks. But,

2:05:39 You guys remember the very first meeting that we did together in this room back on July 19th, I think? We did the strengths of the gaps, and when we summarized all the gaps and pulled back in the notes to you, if you remember, I can visualize this, the very top of the gaps column was a single statement, I don't remember who said it in the room, but you all said yes, it was fear of moving forward. I'm paraphrasing. It was fear of doing something.

2:06:09 couple Rick's and Dan's comments together and reframe it as a question for all of you and for the public. You said, is it a council deciding or is it telling an MLR, some entity, how to proceed or is this advisory function guiding the council and making the decision?

2:06:35 And I thought you were suggesting guide the council, so that's the way I wrote it. Is that accurate? I hope I have been clear that I'm trying to call it outsourcing. I'd like to give them the responsibility that Dana would like it to take on. It's got to be that way. I mean, John does an annual report to the council and says, this is what we're doing. You like it?

2:07:00 And if we don't, we stop the funding. I mean, ultimately, we've got the power of the money. And that's the only power that I want. I mean, I want to leave it to the experts because I recognize that the five of whoever's sitting up there are not. So, in a sense, if I could paraphrase in short words, you're saying, well-informed and get or go. Right? Well-informed and get or go. And Joe's point...

2:07:26 You know that you can get it done because you're not relying on people who are not expert in guiding the decision process. Does that remove all risk? Absolutely. What Dan has done is illustrate one scenario in which you could get it done at a reasonable profile cost in time and you could begin to get to outcomes. John's making the point.

2:07:56 That you could market the potential and help facilitate sponsorship acquisition, MLR, can both guide, leverage both demand and capital. In a sense, leveraging demand helps grow the capital base because you'd like to spend more than the local resident's tax base on getting this done. You know, you'd like to double or triple or quite equal.

2:08:26 And, you know, when I made that comment back at the beginning that I thought that one bullet was in the wrong place, that is exactly what I think we're all talking about.

2:08:43 Is, you know, the bullet about the recognizing, the nurturing, etc. When the track is coming forward, and forget everybody who thinks it's Rick's track, I was as much interested in making it happen. I'm trying to tell everybody it's I had nothing to do with it. When they were first doing their Measure R applications, I would ask the question, who's programming it? Well, it got out there. Who's programming it? Guess what? The entrepreneurial spirit is now doing the programming. And that's exactly what I see MLR giving us.

2:09:12 Yes, so your point was that's that third bulletin. Yeah, and I know, two and a half hours later, you know, I think that that's how I would sum up what we've just gotten to is we know that we have some percentage, and that's why I said I don't want to have the council sit in there and try and, you know, seat of our pants to say, well, I don't know, I like 70 better than 60. You know, I say, give it to them and use that spirit and have them come back.

2:09:41 With a recommendation, you know, hey, I can get you all three, but we want to still hold a little bit back for operations, you know, whatever it is, let them come back with a recommendation. That is their job. That's what an executive director and the passionate board members would do. So let me tell you all the react to this. I thought I saw your hand. Yeah, just a quick finger. I came in late, I probably missed it, but I'm glad Carl put this fourth point on the risk analysis. I think that's a really important point.

2:10:10 Because with the introduction of an organisation to kind of take on this role, Municipal Act is actually free to perform what it's supposed to be doing, right? And we are so under-resourced, we're over-exploited, we're still trying to process and get all this stuff done, but we're not able to actually do our jobs. And I think the programming is key, and that's really what we do. And we've worked with John, and we've worked with... That's right. Yeah.

2:10:36 Track Club and work with our clubs. We program with the school. We do the AOSO. I mean, we've got great partnership opportunities, I think is what we're trying to say. So I don't think the programming is one bucket of fish. It sits in one bucket. I think you've been talking about a rec center. I mean, you're going to have, you know, multiple, you know, partners, you know, really trying to program and make it successful. I just kind of like the way it's going in regards to the municipal can actually do its municipal function, its full function.

2:11:02 of programming its facilities, and I like, Paul Sauser, the idea of actually getting some more funds to actually fix our facilities the way we actually use them more efficiently. So, anyway. I'm scared of just continuing to paraphrase what I was saying. I think what you're suggesting is there's this kind of beautiful possible outcome, which is that MNLR Valley creates new valuation in terms of guiding counsel and guiding investments in the direction of outcomes and leveraging future sponsorships.

2:11:30 But maybe it actually contributes to enhanced valuation of municipalities. I just want to see a win-win. That's what we need. So I kind of like the way it's going. You know, I think that we're all saying the same thing. You know, we're kind of going at it. The words are a little bit different, but we're saying the same thing. And the opportunity that we have on the table right here with MLR is...

2:12:00 Huge. And so if we let that fear drive us, then we aren't going to be any further than we are right now. I just don't see that there's any type of risk in moving forward. Because if it doesn't work, what do you go back to where we are right now? There is an old adage that says it.

2:12:21 Nothing like a little debt to focus here. Makes me go to work every day. I just want to throw one quick thing in again just to kind of clarify on the capital and demand. I don't think any of us wouldn't think that we should build these facilities tomorrow, and I think from your standpoint, you know, I think that the facilities that we're talking about, I think they're givens. I don't think there's any, I think the risk for those facilities of a multi-use facility or a performing arts center, I think the risk is very minimal.

2:12:47 So I don't think that anybody here would say that that's risky. If we were to try and build a velodrome, sure, that's probably not in our best interest. We'll just get the road trip. It's all left turns. I don't know. But again, when we're looking at those things, sure, we can go out and take Measure R tomorrow and buy all the Mega Millions tickets we want, but realistically, whether we can figure out a way to build those all.

2:13:13 Simultaneously, or whether it's programming, it's building up to those things, or whether we know that with NEPA and CEQA and all those other things that you have to do, that we are looking at five years. That's where I think the demand needs to be formalized, because we have demand right now. We have demand for an indoor facility, we have demand for a pool, we have a demand for all these different pieces, but we need to program that demand and formalize that demand. The problem is we haven't formalized it.

2:13:42 I don't know, hundreds of schools that come up here? We haven't formalized it. We need to formalize that process so we know exactly who's coming in, we know exactly where they're going. We've talked about building a runner's village in August so that they can go and have concerts and barbecues every night and have Adidas sponsored one night and ASIC sponsored another night and be able to use that as a tracking mechanism. But the formalization of the programs, whether we're building something in three years or five years or eight years or ten years,

2:14:07 Those programs have to be more formalized. We have the demand, we just have to formalize it. And it starts now, though, too, because as you're formalizing it, and that momentum starts to build in five, six, seven years when the facility's in place.

2:14:20 You've got it. You flip the light switch. And they're there. It's not a will they come. They're already there. They're clamoring for it. You're selling it to them. That's a great point. I appreciate that addition because my initial problem with the demand model is that we already drive a tremendous amount of visitors through here. Yeah, it's not a question of waiting. It's a question of we're going to have, there's going to be time to build. I mean, look at how long the bowling alley's been taken to build. I mean, it's not going to be an immediate thing where tomorrow we're going to put all this money out there and we're going to bond it and we're going to have this building in six months. Right. You know, we need to make

2:14:49 Make sure that we've got that demand formalized. Again, the demand is there. It's got to be formalized so that when we open this, you flip the switch, and boom, it's full. And I was just going to, one quick add, is my concern with what Dan had said, and because my immediate reaction is that we're not going to move on with an MLR. We're just going to start stockpiling money just to go to facilities, and that isn't going to...

2:15:14 Be successful for anybody. If we're looking at going this direction where you're working towards that goal in, you know, five years or more, and we're building MLR and the base before that, then, you know, that's great. The other thing, too, is I think you guys need to challenge yourself.

2:15:32 You should have something built in three years. That's five years. Well, again, it goes back to the... Yeah, you guys got a challenge. So just to catch this last comment, so the thing about getting your data is not just about satisfying pens up local demands, but it's that the market will pass you by. I think this is one of the things you make.

2:16:01 Moments here is that we really want to be able to scale demand within whatever resources we need to put together. So, I'm going to go to Donald Johnson. A couple thoughts. I wanted to thank Dan, too, because it sounds as if he read a proposal that will hear at 8.30 in the morning for a 12,000 square foot facility that has no debt service that is online in two years. Is that a rec center?

2:16:30 No. That's all he is proposing. The foundation's putting up four acres of land. We invest $25,000 or $30,000 for some initial planning that convinces Cerakoso that they put up $3 million. And then he'll be back to us in about four or five months once Cerakoso says yes. And he needs to do the detailed architectural drawing, but he's planning on having a facility somewhere after that.

2:17:00 Sounds like Sarah Coso has a proposal for a bond. No, no, they've already got a proposal. They already have the bond. In a couple of years, if you go back a little bit, there's a million dollars that's been sitting there. Thirteen years ago. Thirteen years ago. You know, that's all it takes to do in the days. You know, we worry about net service and all, but there are other options.

2:17:29 The key takeaway from the comments is that one guy with MLR maybe came past the hurdle of not moving. Yeah. 8.30 in the morning, we will hear a proposal that we can see whether or not we had set the council with steps without MLR. Yeah. I think it's MLR. No, no.

2:17:56 That's what it's saying. Yeah, I just think the conversation's been excellent. And I think the full range of things that need to be discussed, have been discussed, you guys keep coming back to the ceiling points. I think it's very refreshing and it's encouraged to be here. I think from that question about we've had all these things, we've wanted to build them, we never got them done, in the current status quo configurations, they haven't got them done. And over the last couple of years, I've looked at the track folks.

2:18:25 I would do the trail system folks that were able through energy, entrepreneurship, micro-examples of organizations acting outside were able to bring things forward and get some things done. And imagine if you institutionalized that kind of energy, that kind of spirit, as Teri is saying, I think we're all saying the same thing. The benefit of the community for all this, I think you guys are exactly what I'm trying. Literally every organization that I've worked through and worked across about 15 sectors that

2:18:53 Wants to increase its agility in the current and future marketplace, creates an R&D function, and they get it out of the main building. When you move that R&D function someplace, it will not be federal by process, it will actually focus on the outcomes.

2:19:19 I think it's lack of focus. And that's where I think that maybe an MOR could be, is that there's more focus in two things, to getting things done. I think that's what John was saying. Ender Castor made a presentation for the commission for the MOR.

2:19:45 Funds, and he knows exactly what's going on. And that kind of concerns me. He doesn't. He doesn't. He doesn't. He has an idea. He knows. He knows some pieces. Well, you know what? He might differ. We've had the discussion. We've had the discussion. But, I mean, that kind of concerns me that there might be, I mean, he's a key force, you're a key force in the community, but there's a lack of communication, and that's what kind of...

2:20:12 Something that I think needs to be looked at to make sure that there's not a lack of communication between organizations. I think there's a lack of communication in general not there, though. Back to like a panacea that this MLR is going to be, you know, it's going to be the godsend to everything. I think you have to be careful about that because...

2:20:35 Coming together with a board, it's going to be a board of interested people, just like commissions are interested people, town council are interested people, but they're not necessarily professionals. Maybe there's one professional and the rest are interested parties. So that doesn't necessarily mean that they're any better than a town manager and his team who have expertise and proven history and a certain extent. We have to be careful about that as well.

2:21:03 I'm wondering about the amount of time that was mentioned earlier about being cost neutral. How long would it take for an MLR to be in that kind of position? And then what if it isn't? And that's maybe something when you get to the nuts and bolts of things, but then what are your questions? Let me just, I'm getting my notes here. I'm seeing the contours of MLR come forward.

2:21:34 We agree it's a separate organization. We agree it's a dotted line relationship to the town council. They'd be responsible on an annual basis, so on and so forth. You guys, what I heard today was there's a hybrid approach to the investment portfolio. Capital needs to be considered, capital investment, as well as programmatical demand building sites to that. We also agree and believe that this approach will begin to free up municipal.

2:22:04 Time for them to invest in certain things and whatnot. We also agree that this approach will create the focus that you guys are looking for to get or done, whatever that means and whatever that project. I think Pat had a great point of manage expectations because you've got to manage everybody's expectations and say, look, realistically, we can get this project.

2:22:32 May be right on the way here. We'll see. But I think it's key to manage the expectations of the community. Am I getting a sense of that's what MLR is beginning to look like? Something we can now put together for you guys to look at the next meeting and send to the council after that? So people seem to be more comfortable with MLR Portfolio 1 versus Cal 2. I think it's...

2:22:59 Over time, it's going to morph between the two. We have to start somewhere. It's our job to bring the council something that says, in general, here's directionally, strategically. It takes care of some strategic investments for the community. It creates the entrepreneurial action sort of things you're looking for from the community also. But most importantly, it becomes a vehicle to move things forward.

2:23:29 And I think that's what I hear a lot of. You guys have been just stuck at MLR. That is the expectation you should have, is to get projects going, get cooperative relationships going, connect the dotted lines. You know, there's a lot of dots, but you've got to create the connection between them and make them all happen. This is the contours of what I'm seeing MLR is. We see it with a board of directors.

2:23:59 And, you know, we can give you a recommendation or a council recommendation on how to at least get a transition board or this board can be the transition board however you want. But we're going to lay out the glide path to getting there. And, you know, you'll have a draft on the 6th. Am I missing any big picture items here? I'm sorry. Oh, January 6th next meeting. Thank you. Okay. Which 6th? I mean, are we missing any big picture items here?

2:24:28 Because our next is to take this, wrap it all up, and create a glide path to get in there.

2:24:55 Yes. Yes. And it's not trend responding. No. It's being proactive. Yes. Yes.

2:25:21 Question, did we have, have we properly named, described outlines, framed the risks, framed the value, the purpose, got, asked and answered the right questions, focused the purpose of them no longer? Did we talk about what the structure is outside of this board of directors at all? Did you explain the question? Yeah. To talk about it now? Well, I think from a characteristic standpoint, what I heard,

2:25:52 And again, this is very loose, is, you know, you don't want a huge body count in this thing. You know, very, very low in terms of employees. Might even be a director and an assistant with a board of directors to guide it. And the board can decide at that point beyond that. I think that might.

2:26:12 Paul's talking about the board itself. No, no, that's exactly what I'm talking about, is I would view it as an executive director that is an expert in this field, an assistant to help with administrative tasks, and a board of volunteers that steers. Because I see that those people are going to go out to these other organizations, whether it be that are MLT or community.

2:26:35 And they're going to be their partner. So it's the person who's orchestrating it. I think that gets you off the dime. And then at that point, you'll have a board that can say, okay, here's what we need. They'll go through their own strategic planning exercise, figure out, you know, here's what we need, where we're going. And to do that, we need a part-time thing over here. Or we need a full-time thing over there. And they can run the organization. But to get it off and give it for them.

2:27:04 I think that would be sort of a lean approach which I would support. And there's one piece in that structure that's a question that we have to give to, we, meaning council, has to give to them is the question, now that you've kind of made yourself to no longer this amorphous cloud, we left out there still that question about what other commissions and things are there and how do they interact? Because that's still a piece because

2:27:34 That's, yeah, did they go away, did they do what, because that's a piece, we don't, this town doesn't survive without the volunteers on commissions, committees, etc., things like that. So I think it's a question to leave out there, and the structure is, so what capacity, you know, what's the interface with either existing groups or with community groups, you know.

2:27:57 Oh, there's no tourism board. Yeah, you know, you've got Mammoth Rails sitting out there. There's no tourism commission. Yeah. There is no tourism commission. Right, right. But it's, I don't want us to forget that that's a structured question that still we have to pass along to that group. Right. I think going through a strategic planning exercise, you would identify the macro environment of what that organization touches. Right. And that will give you the list of. Yeah. Yeah.

2:28:22 Those relationships or at least begin to define those relationships. Because in one of the previous ones we got kind of stuck on that. We didn't know whatever. Well, of course, we don't know. That's something for that formation board to figure out and bring back. Okay. And would you expect that formation board, that's what I wanted to talk about, would you expect to have a detailed proposal to the council included in this as to... I think we should provide you with some options for...

2:28:52 For that. I mean, we talked about each council person appointing somebody, you know, to get this thing off the ground, and then, you know, I think that's a great place just to start. But at a certain point in time, it kicks over, and that board needs to decide how it wants to stock its board, i.e., we want to have representation from here, there, and so forth. But to give it some form and function, that might be the easiest place to go.

2:29:20 And I'm going to totally disagree with that because you can have three members of council who haven't had any idea and they might pick the absolute worst person as opposed to maybe trying to get volunteers. The politics play, we've got to flesh that out. I think it's a discussion. Well, ultimately, you know, you can look at it two ways. You could say, well, this will be a board.

2:29:48 But ultimately the council's call, I mean. Right. Well, and what I'm looking at is that what we have here, to me, is the impetus for the formation because everybody's already got however many months it's been since July worth of background. Why would you start over with whoever somebody might pick?

2:30:09 And that's fine. I mean, that's another option is you guys can just... Because we often don't agree at all. I mean, it's funny that there's sometimes to try and get the council to agree on... I mean, let me just throw it out there. Should this be the board? No. No. You know? But could it be the formation board? Right. No, no, no, formation board. Between a formation board and then a transition board and then a permanent board. Because to the point that was made, and not to add boards and boards, but...

2:30:39 You've got a group of people that can get in and actually kind of put the nuts and bolts together for the organization that says, here is maybe what your bylaws are going to be, here's the function of the organization. And that group could also be the ones who are vetting out who the potential transition permanent board members are. To your point that maybe the council members aren't the ones to make the appointments, but maybe there's this...

2:31:04 Formation body that is doing that legwork to come back with. I would also offer up, though, that your transition slash permanent board should also be involved in conversations about the bylaws because in the end, if they're the ones that are going to be delivering and acting on those bylaws, then they're going to want to have maybe some say in what those bylaws are, so maybe there's some carryover from your formation board to your transition board.

2:31:33 But I think your formation board is the one to get in there and do the nuts and bolts, like we did with MLT. They were in there, the drafted bylaws that submitted everything to the state, that drafted up MOUs, I mean, all kinds of the groundwork, legwork. And then you set your transition board. This is who is going to start off as your board with your terms. So what I'm hearing you say, then, is the count will be receptive to a proposal that said the formation board should be this board.

2:32:02 Well, I think it's necessary. But we have to make sure that the Council has the confidence in this group to be able, just as I said before, to in effect relinquish its own authority and power. And that includes not going through the usual process of nominating or appointing individuals, but instead...

2:32:32 Having the confidence to follow a committee's recommendation, which is why it's so important that this be so measured and thorough and thoughtful. So let me ask you this. Michael and I go away when this report's done. Who's going to actually do this? I don't know that yet. Well, that's something to start thinking about. We hand in a report to the council. We go away.

2:33:02 Who's going to do the grind it out, talk to the lawyer, check that off, set the bank account up, check that off, do this, check that off, sort of stuff. So think about that. But, okay, I hear what you're saying on the transition board. I think we should go a step further to present to council about what the board is like. And we talked a lot about the agility and the willingness and attitude of an entrepreneurial frame of mind.

2:33:32 But I think our general definition, we should extend that definition from the early days of this group. To say that we want more to pros. When I hear the word representation and representative, I say yes, versus talent, I'd rather see talent. So I would see pros, coaches, CEOs, hedge fund managers, some people from out of town, some people from in town. And I'd see some people, and maybe there's some people that...

2:34:00 We can't even think of right now. Well, it's that sort of quality, professional, we're in sports marketing, we're in sports management, we're in sports promotion, and that sort of thing, and we've got people from schools, and we've got a couple of weak-hit foundations in town, Mammoth Mountain Community Foundation being one, and Mammoth Lakes Foundation being another. There may be Draven, but there's one there. Then you've got it.

2:34:25 I just wanted to offer up one more thing to that, though. This is a working board, too. This board is going to have to be doing a significant amount of work, so the type of work that they're going to be doing kind of speaks to maybe who they are also. I just want to add that, too, because we're talking about a very lean staff, so this board initially for the first five, six years is going to be doing a lot of...

2:34:49 That heavy lifting in some regards to get stuff off the ground. But that board would be rich in context, rich in resource, so that you could go to a gallery in LA and say, hey Paul, I need contact with these celebrities, with these foundations, and with these sports teams, and things like that, and you've got it the next day. I'm thinking... The USC team has a sport of trustees that are full of powerful business people from the whole country.

2:35:14 I'm thinking of a seven-member board. Seven members, get it done.

2:35:35 Boom, boom, boom. And then you might have advisory. You can have all the advisory committees and boards you want. Which is where you get those money. Well, we'll fall on used to. But this is a working board, though. I can't figure out. Yeah, this isn't just because you're, you know, because we're not asking anybody to pay to be on it yet. Someday, maybe, they're going to pay to be on it.

2:36:00 Not yet, but I think we have to understand that these folks are going to be hitting the ground doing it. I got it. I heard what you said.

2:36:29 We will do that. We will do that.

2:36:58 We went through the responsibilities the last two or three meetings. We'll bring that information forward in the next document.

2:37:27 Yeah. Keep going. Keep doing them. Keep doing them. Yeah. I think ultimately what we talked about was organizations have contractual responsibilities to get things done where committees don't. And again, nothing against committees. Some committees get lots of things done. Others don't.

2:37:57 And I think from a financial management standpoint, you want to have this, you know, this organization would be contracted to, you know, get the trails investment done. And they can figure out how they want to do it and what needs to be done next. But within that, here's the budget, here's what we want to do with trails. And, you know, if we need a committee, right, let's have a committee. If we don't, we need something else, we can do that.

2:38:26 But I think, yeah, I think that's part of it is getting that out of municipal and being able to also leverage and find partners for those trails where applicable, you know, applicable. So I think let us come back and then you guys can have a look at the document and we'll revise accordingly. But I do see R&U will be spent at a allocated at a strategic level.

2:38:54 You know, X amount of dollars are going to be peeled off and go to capital projects. I don't think you need, you know, maybe there's a smaller amount that need to get allocated. If you decide you're going to have a special event fund or whatever, you can decide you can have a committee to do that. But the big strategic level investment will be done at a board level. And that frees up staff to not have to, you know, deal with that process.

2:39:23 Carl, your submission was really nice. You left out one thing, which I think is critical, accountability. That was everything that was talked about since you finished saying that comes back to accountability of the board, accountability for the program, accountability for the dollar, accountability to get all this done. That's one of the big things that have been missing these last eight years, a lot of great ideas. No one can hold anybody accountable for things not getting done. I think that's one of the big benefits of having contractual agencies.

2:39:53 is accountability. And as Rick said earlier, we don't like what's going on, we pull the funding or change the funding or re-vote. You're always three votes away from whatever. So it keeps everyone on their toes. But yeah, accountability, I think, is a key feature in the MLR approach that, again, I don't want to diss what's been going on.

2:40:17 But, you know, sometimes a gun to your head focuses you a little bit at getting things done in a timely and urgent urgency. Urgency is the good word. That's the word nowadays, is urgency. And I think MLR, with the right relationship with the town, can be pretty darn urgent and effective in getting things done. It'll be different, but I think it'll be good. Urgent plus focus.

2:40:46 I have two questions. On number one, who came up with those projects running along? And then number two, I think we missed something you mentioned about how to argue how legal that is. Oh, we have that document here. So why were trails and farm you drawn out of a hat? They weren't drawn out of a hat. They weren't drawn out of a hat.

2:41:15 I don't remember the group discussing that. I remember it being presented and nobody... Well, actually, we didn't present it. You actually created it. The Gaines profile we created on this fight where we didn't create it. You guys created it. All of you. This did it. This process. When we did the Gaines... Do you think that they had a say in that? Or was it presented? Yeah.

2:41:42 Oh, I don't think there's been anything presented. Yeah, I think we presented it. You know, as part of the gains of what we were looking at, what would stay with CORE, what would move on with MLR,

2:42:11 And what would those opportunities be? And so, you know, those were in all the gains, and then we spoke specifically about, you know, the R and U at the last meeting, and how those could possibly move over to an MLR, and, you know, what exactly the duties might be of each one. And I think it was a matter of clarifying what was poor municipal recreation and what would stay there, and we focused on...

2:42:38 with the Municipal Recreation Department and what would move over as kind of more of a visitor driving and global resort focused kind of recreation. And then that would free up the Rec Commission to be much more focused on the municipal recreation side and being an asset to those efforts. So yeah, this will be laid out in the option one, option two, option three, plus four, all of that.

2:43:08 And then as to the legal ramifications, yeah, we contact the town's legal counsel, and we had three specific questions for him, which he kindly took.

2:43:36 So the first question we asked the town council was can measure R and U funds flow directly into the new organization? And his opinion was no they could not. However, we asked them could the town council allocate measure R and U funds and that is doable. So the funds wouldn't flow directly into the organization. The town would still retain control but they would

2:44:05 They could allocate R&U funds to the new organization on an annual basis and that's their means of control of those funds. Yeah, pretty similar. Can measure R&U funds go to salary and benefits as long as they are being used to implement the desired outcomes of R&U? Basically, yes. And his advice to us was, you know,

2:44:32 You need to be thoughtful that administrative costs don't go crazy. That's why we built in the component to try and find capital outside funds that would try and make this thing revenue neutral so as to alleviate that. But by law, some of those funds could go to overhead. The board may say, decide as a policy, hey, we want to try and get all our funds. We want to be revenue neutral completely. Or the board may say, hey,

2:45:02 You know, we want to go at a 50% level, and we think that, does that meet the criteria of the law? And, you know, the town council can advise. So in terms of all of that, it's pretty clear that the funds could flow ultimately into the organization with a few political, with a few, you know, legal votes or whatever by the council. So I hope that sheds some light on it.

2:45:33 I have a question under question two. In the last sentence and the answer, the language of Measure R prohibits the town from giving funds to MLR to manage facilities, programs, trails, or parks. We're talking about facilities, programs, trails, or parks. Manage.

2:45:59 So if there is a contract with specific scope and deliverables, then the council is still managing it and they're just implementing it? Is that... To the extent that you build assets... Yeah. ...on the sales internal... Okay. ...and operation managed by... By the talent? By the talent? Yeah. So if we build a rec center... If we build a rec center...

2:46:24 There's the expectation that the town will manage that rec center. Or sub it out. Well, that's what I'm asking this question. It's a balancing act of legal stuff, right. We've had some conversations of what does that look like, and there's a couple different ways for that to go. But for the town just to hand it off, the answer is no. You've got to have some type of relationship and control over it from a town perspective that may seem to tend to be managed. I think the attorney went... It's not as clean as... ...additional notes to us saying the measures were not...

2:46:54 Well, I was just going to say, so under Dan's example of an entrepreneur renting it, that's still possible, it's just how the contract is. Yeah, I mean, you really have to structure in a way that meets it.

2:47:17 Okay. You can get there, but you better take the goods. So if Measure U money comes to the, to MLR, and MLR is working with Mammoth Lakes Foundation to build the facility, the new performing arts facility, MLR can take that Measure U money that they've received and contract with the foundation to manage the facility?

2:47:45 And you will be different than ours, though. There's two different pieces there. Oh, that's right. Okay. Yeah, so it depends. Yeah, there's a slight nuance there. So there will have to be more work done on that in terms of what we look at. I think there's a way to get there, but it'll be, it'll take some thought process. I think it's stuck in focus, too. I don't want to see MLR get bombed in the operating facilities when it takes away from the focus of actually trying to program expand. But I don't think they should be handcuffed either, though. They're the entity to maybe deliver it and also to...

2:48:14 Managing and program and function and operate it. The managing of it and program and it creates some challenges in the legal structure currently. So that'll... So for contract? Well, I think it's beyond just a contract too, but yes, there's some ways to make it work, I think, but it's going to take more time. For me, I was just saying this is critical, whether it's legal or not. You can go down the path that's legal. So for me, what would be helpful is...

2:48:42 This is the list of things that are MLR, is to give this to the town attorney, not three questions, and say yes or no. Measure R. That's fine, we can do that. I don't think it'll be that clean is the challenge there, because there are certain ways you can structure it to make it work, and there's other ways that you structure it's going to be in direct violation. I think we need some of that guidance. Well, we certainly do during the transition board period. Yeah, absolutely. I think we can get there with it, but it's going to be a little creative.

2:49:11 His general response was, if I can paraphrase, was have the measures when written anticipated this delineation of these functions? It would have been written differently. Can you expand a bit on, you know, because we had talked at last meeting about, you know, whether Rec Commission goes away at some point or whether it stays. I mean, this says in the language here.

2:49:37 This allocation is made after considering the Recreation Commission's annual recommendation. Yeah, I think, Colin, that's a good point because I came up to it too. I think what has to happen is the town council, I think in the language, can say it was Rec Commission or another entity. They just need to vote to move it to another entity.

2:50:02 Expenditure plan. Yeah, yeah. So the town council is ready to change. If that has to be changed to accommodate what...

2:50:10 Then that's part of what comes. But it does also have the language of saying the recognition or another advisory board. No, Measure U has that. Measure R doesn't have that. But this language is in the expenditure plan, which the ordinance says the town council can change at any time. Or not at any time, with a majority vote. So that's the nuance. So to your point, if

2:50:40 The Council says, well, this isn't the Recreation Commission's purview anymore, this is going to be MLR, then the Council is going to have to change the expenditure plan to add the language that says some other entity. So there's some stuff like that that can happen based on the structure that comes out. Measure U doesn't have to do that because it says it. It doesn't seem like there's any big, big red flags here, according to Andrew. Did he get this? No.

2:51:09 I'm happy to send it to them though. Okay. Any residual questions that we have not entirely think of today captured, asked and answered, asked and pardoned for a later discussion, we would like to see the rest in 4.6.

2:51:39 So just so I'm clear, the meaning of the six will essentially be to review that proposal, see if we have any recommended changes, and then that's what will go to the council. So that's essentially a one-item agenda.

2:51:54 Okay. Is it possible to get that in advance of the meeting at all? No. I'm going to happen. What we're prepared to do is go over it, and then you guys can take some time, and then we can have another meeting. But to me, the sixth is pretty important, and I know. You just don't have the time. And I understand that. Then could we?

2:52:15 Could you get it to us in advance of the meeting to at least be able to come in prepared to ask questions and or provide comments or at least prepare ourselves for that kind of conversation instead of an off-the-cuff react to what's placed in front of us. I'm just because I which gives me 24 hours to review it. I'm just saying

2:52:38 The sixth sounds like there's going to be some significant decision and or direction given. And I'm just looking for preparation. Yeah, there's another meeting after that. So we built in two meetings for review. I also don't think there would be any surprises. It's a summation of what we've talked about.

2:53:03 Correct. Yeah. But there are... Yes. Yes. Correct. Correct. Correct. We need, with this holiday, we need concentration for every hour I can get. What holiday? What Carol and I try to think about is give you back your own stuff. Just organize. We take big lists and we affinity sort them and go.

2:53:31 They weren't in categories. Here's five categories. What do you think? Let's call them strategies. They weren't. There was a dotted line or a solid line. What do you think? We're just trying to come back to you with options. We give you our own questions and your own answers back. We try not to invent stuff in the white space. If this is coming to us on the 6th, then we're going to have it again on the 27th report. Yeah. Yeah.

2:53:59 Is there a target for when it's going to the Council? First weekend, first Tuesday, Wednesday in February? Yeah, first weekend. So the 27th is the last week of January, and then the following week is when it's going to the Council. So the Monday, the 27th, and then by that Friday, the agenda for the following week comes out, right? So what's being drafted in the agenda bill that's going to the Council is being drafted where and reviewed where and...

2:54:29 Approved where in a what I would call a five-day period. Well, the agenda will just say it's going to be on the agenda. But the materials, but are the recommendations within the staff report that's going to the council, that has to be, that needs to be out in advance by at least Friday. I'm just asking the time, you know, in anticipation of what the public is going to see when the agenda is posted on that Friday.

2:54:59 After our meeting on Monday, there's a posted date on Monday, or on Friday, and then there's a council meeting on Wednesday. What is the public going to see on Friday that they're going to see in front of the council on Wednesday? That would depend. That would depend what the report that comes out. Okay, I'm just saying, do we have time built into this thing to accommodate all that? Yeah.

2:55:21 I would think it would be. I would think it could be. Yeah, as we got that meeting on the 27th, wouldn't that be the final hash out? And if you don't come up with the final document at that point, then you have to push back and cancel the sentence. Hopefully by no later than the end of February. Oh, absolutely. Yeah. Right. But I still think we can...

2:55:47 Push for the first meeting, because if we've got the whole next meeting, another four hours to get down on the, work out the nitty gritty of the proposal, then I think there would be time to see the final information on the 27th. I think what Dale's trying to get to is who's writing the agenda bill. Is the agenda bill, what we're going to see on the 27th, basically, is that going to be the agenda bill? Well, it won't be agenda bill if they're writing, but that'll be the...

2:56:15 Meet of, the agenda bill, actually, I think will be fairly short. It's going to be the attachment where all the meat is. Yeah, so I think that's the question. Yeah, so that's what I'm trying to do. You'll have an agenda bill, but it's not going to be. All the recommendations, there are no staff recommendations. Dan, can I, there are no staff recommendations. These are committee recommendations that are going to be in that report right there. Yeah, the staff recommendation will be, you know, deal with the committee recommendations or pun.

2:56:42 I mean, it's kind of the standard, but I mean, really the recommendations are going to be what's coming. I'd make the staff recommendation is it can be a recommendation. It's not a separate dialogue. Well, not only that. I think it's critical as a matter of transparency that this not be staff-driven. It isn't staff-driven and the community should not think that it's staff-driven. There's a whole lot of effort that's gone in by all of these people who aren't members of the staff to make this, to get to where we will ultimately.

2:57:11 Great work again. The one place I think where you're going to have to pay some attention to is the scope of work of MLR. I think it's specifically because there's a nexus between the two measures and their legal language. It sounds like there may be some work

2:57:38 Done the measure, or at least the expenditure plan, that may be an interpretation of you. And I think when you get right down to what exactly MLR is going to be doing, I don't think that this committee is going to figure it out, but I think you want to make sure that in your transformation, the transition board or whatever, that that board really gets into it to make sure that if you do make some adjustments to the language for the measures, it's going to line up with what the board anticipates. It's a countable responsibility to speak.

2:58:06 And a lot of work back in 2010, thanks for going through all those documents, you probably can see that most of the work in that work went into that final slotting exercise. So there's a lot of work that went into that. These are sort of nice ideas, but I think we've got a board now that's going to be accountable to it. We want to make sure that they understand the legal footing and understand how the dollars are tied to the legal footing and they've got a good sense of what this sort of work is going to be about. Any additional comments?

2:58:40 Ready? So we're clear on the 6th. We're coming back with the draft work you proposed. The anticipation is to refine that, come to the agreements, and the piece that we reveal on the 27th is for the council ready. Going forward. And we've made it by 6 o'clock. Thank you. Thank you. Thanks, everybody.

2:59:07 Last thing, Carl, the Yankees are still terrible even though you've got the building. I knew that was coming, I just didn't know where it was going to come from. Hey, you know, he's got glass legs, he'll be out for like 40, 50, 60 games this year. Yeah, you loved him three weeks ago. Yeah, he'll be out there. Now you're crapping. Now you're crapping.