Town Council
· recording 2 hr 32 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
305 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
7:12 But it was a light meeting and nothing to report. Thank you. Thank you. Matthew. I just have a couple items. Not any meetings I had really gone to, but just had some questions. I know we've been getting a lot of discussion out there in the county about the yellow-legged frog, and I'm just wondering if we can find out how serious that's getting to really being a potential impact to us.
7:40 If there's something we need to do to maybe help the county and marketing and whomever else to make sure that we don't become extremely impacted by that. So I was wondering if I could just get some feedback on that. Matthew, and this is for Dan as well. We had a presentation from Mono County, Scott Burns, I think, or Wendy Sugimura put that together, and the gentleman who made the presentation did an excellent job.
8:09 Might check with them to see the contact person. And where was that at? The wildlife or? Yeah, I'm not sure which organization he was with, but it was the Mono County Collaborative Planning meeting. Yeah, I'm just curious how much that significance that's coming to us. And another thing, and I think Councilmember Eastman and I have spoken on this before, and I just wanted to get some clarity.
8:37 We have that tunnel going under 203 connecting Shady Rest Area to the south side of 203, and I'm just wondering, one, if there's any opportunities there to see that opened up to snowmobiling again? And then the third thing is a bit on the same lines. You know, years ago we had Hawk Creek shut down for a number of reasons, and I know that the
9:02 The reasoning behind it was that we were having geysering out there and whatnot. I've been down to the, you know, Hot Creek a number of times and it doesn't seem like it's all that much different. I mean, I know it's always changing down there, but I wanted to see if there's any likelihood of us ever getting that opened up again for the public to go back in and use it as a recreational area. So I wanted to just see if there's, what would it take to do that if it's possible. And that's it. We can follow up on those items. Okay, thank you.
9:33 All right. Thanks. Michael. I just wanted to remind everyone that tomorrow our flights come in starting tomorrow, San Francisco, Orange County, in San Diego, and that the air packs, which are selling pretty good, they will continue to be on sale until December 31st. So there's still some opportunity to buy those air packs that are good all the way until next October. So it's almost a full year, 10 tickets.
10:02 10-1 Wave, $670, San Diego and Los Angeles, San Diego through April and Los Angeles through next October. So those are on sale still available through 800 Mammoth until December 31st. Thank you. Just a couple of items. First, I'd like to thank the staff who volunteered as bell ringers yesterday out there in front of Vaughn's. It's great to see them being involved and visible out there.
10:32 And the other thing is I would recommend to anyone that hasn't seen it yet to get to the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater Christmas show, which is called Every Christmas Tale Ever Told and Then Some. It's great. It's about two and a half hours of pure laughter, which we can all use. Thank you. I've got a couple of items. As promised, and after the last meeting I did,
11:00 As did Matthew Lehman attend the Christmas tree lighting in miserable weather. People actually came out for it. Saw the chief there, saw Dan there, as well as others, and everybody was there at a terrific time, but it didn't seem like the ambient temperature was that bad, but it sure felt bad.
11:18 It was cold. That night, but it was a good way to start holidays. Also, Mayor Potem Bacon and I attended the latest three-hour session of the MLR Steering Committee. Dan Holler was there as well. Extremely substantive.
11:40 Session, a lot of input, varying views of members of the steering committee and members of the public, but we really began to point in the same direction and got into what will ultimately be the meat of the report that's going to be delivered to us, I think, in time for our February 4th meeting. I'm not sure of that. We are going to have another meeting on January 6th at, I believe, 3 o'clock here in Suite Z.
12:08 Members of the public are welcome to attend. At that time, a draft report will be prepared and presented by the facilitators. The Committee of the Nine, as well as members of the public, will have the opportunity to comment on it. And ultimately, that report will, with a recommendation as to what to do, will come to Council. So I'm very pleased with the facilitation of that process and the progress that we've made as well. Rick, I wanted to make a point on that, if I may, and Joe as well.
12:36 Without attending, but from what I've heard, it seems like this is a classic example of where a quality facilitator really benefits the process. Is that correct? Definitely. Couldn't have stated it better or differently. Simply outstanding in the way that they've managed the discussion and really understood what people are saying in order to bring people to the conclusion instead of they
13:03 Thinking that they know what the conclusion or outcome is going to be and then directing us toward it. It's just been a really, really good process. What is their name and where they from? It's Carl Rebottle and Michael Ward. It's called SMG, and I can't remember what that stands for, the Tahoe area. But they've also, we've used them before on several pieces of the recreation plan and on the MLT formation. Good. Thank you.
13:29 And I'd be remiss as well if I didn't mention that out there in the freezing cold, the Stuart Brown as well. And of course he was in the inside experiencing the warmth of the MLR Steering Committee meeting as well. So thanks, Stu, for your participation. All right, it takes us to reports from commissions and or departments. Well, Steve Searles, Wildlife Management.
14:03 This time of year I always try to give the year in review and we have a lot to celebrate about this year. Unfortunately that's postponed. Just a heads up to everybody or people that are watching TV, the Bears are still pretty active and the warm weather and the rain this morning.
14:23 In helping them seal the deal. Most of the bears are in about 20 hours a day and out for four hours in the evening. We still need to advise all of our family, our guests, folks that are coming to town to enjoy the scheme.
14:37 To do the right thing, be bear aware, be bear smart this time of year, even though it's this late in the year, we often forget about the bears once the snow's on the ground. Unfortunately, I have to report that there's still a lot of activity with the bears, and we all should be heads up with that. Also, this time of year, it's predictable that there's an uptick in work with the coyotes and with the raccoons.
15:02 And we'll deal with that as it comes along. But again, 937-BEAR, if anybody needs anything, we'll come right over and help out if we can. Any questions I might answer tonight? Steve, I have seen and heard that uptick in raccoons and coyotes. Why is that? It's the oddest thing.
15:23 This time of year, I used to believe anecdotally that it was connected with the trash, that as the bears, you'd see the coyotes walk behind the bears and take advantage of trash resources. Today, our community does a really, really good job, and so that's the smallest amount of food that they get. The coyotes are extremely stealth.
15:43 They're really well camouflaged. They eat the voles, the mice, small chipmunks, that type of thing. Once the snow covers on the ground, it makes it a lot more difficult. They travel on the roadways more often. Instead of postholing in the snow, it burns up energy. So I think it's a combination of things. But they're not as well camouflaged. We have a lot more sightings. They work the streets more often than in the forest. And a lot of their natural foods are covered by snowfall.
16:11 Year, this time of year when the first snows come, we see a lot more activity with our local coyote populations. We'll continue to work on that and with the coons. Any other questions? Did you get some new boots? Sorry? Did you get some new boots? Thank you for noticing. Yeah, early Christmas present. Thank you, John. Thank you, Stephen. Have a good evening. Thank you. I'd like to start off by thanking our town manager for putting together the slide program on our Shop with a Cop from last Saturday.
16:41 He was one of many town employees that was there helping out. We had a great response from the community this year for funds. We ended up with enough money to sponsor 40 children from Inyo and Mono County. As described before, they were all picked up by a police officer or a deputy and taken to Whiskey Creek for breakfast. We then went at a nice, safe, slow speed, but with red lights and siren up to Kmart.
17:08 Bishop PD did a nice job of shutting down the streets for us. We went in, and a couple of these pictures will have, we took a group photo with the 40 children and their partners, and then they went shopping. And when they finished, they were met by about 30 volunteers that did all the wrapping. And both Sarah and Dan kind of made that happen. If you didn't know it, Sarah is really good at twisting arms.
17:38 And she did a good job of getting a whole bunch of town employees down there. And they all had such a good time, I know they're going to be back. She's working on me on going to yoga, but she hasn't succeeded yet. But, you know, it all works because people come together and it's a great day. And we had, I'm not sure I've got everybody, but besides MLPD and Bishop and Mono and Indio County Sheriff's Departments, we had Indio Probation, Highway Patrol.
18:07 Fish and Wildlife, Law Enforcement, U.S. Forest Service, BLM, the Tribal Police, and I think there were a couple of others that I can't even remember. We actually had two counties from Nevada that heard about it and called and wanted to join us. We said, no, we're going to limit it to Eastern Sierra and California. Next year we plan on doing it again. Second item is we just announced a gun safety lock program. We have teamed up with
18:35 Project Child Safe, which is supported and sponsored by the U.S. Department of Justice and the firearms industry. They provide us locks at no cost and a kit and they are available to the public. It's a very simple cable lock that will secure any type of handgun, most rifles and shotguns. And they're available at the police station, business hours between 8 and 4, Monday through Friday.
19:02 All you have to do is come in, and we're going to limit it to two per person initially, but as supplies, as we get more, and we get as many as we need, we'll make more available. So I would encourage anybody who is concerned about child safety in particular, and that's the primary goal of this, is to reduce the potential for a child getting hold of a firearm that's not secured and having some type of tragedy, and unfortunately that does happen occasionally. Let me give you the kit, pass this around.
19:30 If anybody wants this one, feel free to take it. Thank you, Chief. Finally, I'd like to give a little information on the funeral services tomorrow for retired Division Chief Billy Anderson. They will start at 3 o'clock at St. Joseph's Catholic Church. Parking will be limited. The service will be about an hour. When it's over, there'll be a procession consisting of emergency vehicles only that will go from St. Joseph's to the Fire Station 1 where there'll be a reception.
20:01 The route for information, it will go down Old Mammoth to Meridian, up to Minaret, up Minaret to Main Street, and down Main Street to the fire station. There will be parking and shuttles available for people that are going to attend. We strongly encourage people to take advantage of it. The parking will be at the park and ride facility or the high school. And shuttles will be available to get you from there to the church after the service.
20:27 Back to your car or to the fire station and at the end of the reception back to wherever your car is parked. So we strongly encourage people to use that transportation to get there. Thank you. Thank you, Dan. Pete? Peter Bernasconi, Public Works. Just want to let you guys know and the public know. We did get the RFP out today for the interpretive information that will go along with the MLT, Mammoth Lakes Trail Systems website.
21:02 And reprogram the website to include the information. So that'll be out for about a month, and we hope to get several different qualified consultants to help with that project. Thank you. Sarah? Hi, I just wanted to give a quick update on some HR activities that we've been having. Like Dan mentioned, we had the Shop with the Cop on Saturday. I got a group of town employees that don't normally go to that event to come out, and that was really fun. We had a great time.
21:39 And then on Monday, like Joe mentioned, we did the bell ringing for the Salvation Army. Everybody took a 25-minute period of their day to go out there and ring the bell. I wanted to do it on a weekday because so many employees live in Bishop, and I wanted them to be able to participate. It's great for team-building camaraderie, and then we get to give back to the community, so I think it was a win for all. Roger was my point of contact at the Salvation Army, and he told me he knows a bunch of you.
22:08 And he says next year he wants to have a council challenge against the town employees to see who can raise the most money at bonds. Just putting that out there for next year to think about. And we also have a food drive going on for town employees at the town office. And that's also for the Salvation Army. So lots of fun holiday activities going on and just trying to get the group together for the holidays.
22:35 And on a less fun topic, but equally important, recruiting with regards to the restructuring that we talked about in the last council meeting. Dan and I and Pam has been helping as well, have really hit the ground running with those. And we have already advertised for the planning tech and the office assistant positions. And we think that those will hopefully start in early January. We'll at least have interviews in early January and start mid-January.
23:03 And we're concluding interviews for the Assistant Associate Planner this week, and hopefully we'll have a decision by the end of the week. And with regards to the Public Works Director and the Finance Director, I'm working with Dan to finalize brochures and advertisements, and we really want to hopefully advertise that in early January. So things are moving along in that department, lots of stuff. Thank you. Quick side note on the Salvation Army people that were out there. In Vons, and I walked in one night during that cold spell.
23:34 And there were two people in there. And I mean, it was cold. And they're standing there in the doorway with the door open. And I just felt really sorry for them. One was a girl who works for Dr. Craig Schrager in the office there. And I saw her the next day and gave her some money. I felt so bad for standing out there.
23:59 I did it from the 5 to 6 p.m. shift, and I had the biggest smile on my face. I had a blast. It was cold, but I was having a lot of fun. One of the really nicest moments was one of the children from Shop with a Cop that I wrapped gifts for came by with her family and put some money in the bucket. So it was like full circle. It was really nice. Good. Well, thank you for doing that. Thank you. All right. We're still in reports from commissions and or departments. Thank you, Mayor of Council, Dan Haller.
24:29 We've been working with our staff on efficiency issues and looking at how do we enhance some different ways of getting work done. And one of those that came up from the staff, kind of went up and through, finalized with our associations as need be, is closing city halls on Fridays. That would start January 3rd. Council's aware we were looking at that. It's a way we're hoping that it'll provide some focus time for a lot of the different reports and things that need to be done. So it'd be closed.
24:57 As far as just somebody walking in, but we will be there working, so we'll be working on a system that allow for people to set appointments. They can still get, you know, we might be answering phones directly, but checking messages and that type of stuff. So we're available, but one of the challenges staff has had, I think, is really to sit down with the workload and say, I need a couple of hours just to focus to get a report done and to have that uninterrupted time that should provide for that. So we're running for probably six months or so.
25:25 See what type of impact we have or what type of feedback we get. I know a lot of agencies have gone to that. They've also gone to 410 work weeks and other things. The proposal isn't to change our work schedules. To have staff there but to be closed to the public on those days and then we're working through the process to make sure people can still pay bills and do those types of things as need be. If they need to come in, leave their TOT payments, for example, so we can collect that. But it's been well received by the employees and I think it'll be a good benefit for getting work done.
25:54 Hopefully a very limited impact on our community. Thank you. All right. Other department heads or commissions to provide reports. Before we leave this, I wanted to just take a second to express publicly my condolences to the family of Danny Dennis, who, as we know, served for quite a long time as our IT director. And I knew him.
26:24 Really well, and every member of his family, and it suffices to say, and those of you who knew him, has been a very, was a very, very tough last year for that young man, and when I say young man, he was only 49 years old, and as was reported in the paper, he passed away on December 6th, we will miss him, we do miss him, and we will continue to miss him.
26:53 All right, with that, we'll move to staff presentation, which is agenda item number one, presentation by Interim Town Manager, Dan Holler, regarding the visit to Whistler. Again, thank you, Mayor and Council, Dan Holler. We've got a little bit of update on Whistler trip from council members once we returned, and our agendas haven't been really heavies here, so we can spend a little bit of time. But I wanted to do a little follow-up with takeaways that I had from there, as well as I know council members have done visits to other peer resorts, and
27:42 First of all, we've gone to those as a visitor, so kind of pulling some of that together here as well. Effective trip, I think, really, that whole idea of being how do we compare to other destination resorts, looking at some best practices items, and for me, kind of an overview coming out with five areas of review that were outlined in the agenda bill, leadership focus, partnerships, housing, promotion, and services and amenities that are there.
28:09 And the fun part of doing the comparison, we tend to kind of, I think at times, kind of downgrade ourselves, but the other hand, I think Mammoth actually compares very well and we're actually doing, I'd say, some things better. But it's also some good practices and things to look at to how do we stay competitive in a very competitive destination market that we have to deal with. And it's exciting to see some of these, some of the shots here, they have a
28:39 Man-made waterway is nice. We have Mammoth Creek. So a lot of the elements I know that Winslow's done, they have a beautiful setting. But if we walk through some of the things, some of it is man-made, where we have the opportunity for natural made, and I think that's a nice distinction we have. Hard to see it here, but they've stolen some of the devil's post pile pieces and created their own little elements through town. So you'll kind of see that in some of the photos and some of the activities there.
29:07 A couple things here just showing out. One is this building here is actually a 50,000 square foot community center or they're a convention center. A couple different floors in it, a couple different major buildings. It's tucked down below a parking and kind of tucked away so it doesn't stand out as a major facility but it is a pretty good sized building. And then also a lot of the parking in the village other than what we had to drive into for the hotel there. But a lot of it is underground.
29:33 So they have some both above and below, and all the underground parking you end up paying where it's part of the hotel you're staying at. Then they have off-site parking as well, which makes it difficult and much more expensive, but it's a very interesting process of how they've dealt with that. The other element they've dealt with, I think, is the whole design side of things, and I think Mammoth has good design codes in place, and the master plan of the work for the planning department work. They also have some buildings, we'll show where design kind of failed them, but...
30:02 One of the key elements in this, and just some of the articulation you see, but one of the main things we highlighted, part of the village area here, was they had to set this up for light to get through here for sunshine for the restaurants on the other side of the walkway. So they do a volume-based calculation, but they also ran some simulations that say that higher parts of the building couldn't block the sun coming into the restaurant side. They don't want to put that. And on the Blackholm side,
30:30 Kind of give you a sense of where they ended up doing that and really kind of ruined one of their retail areas because it's dark and cold, frankly. They deal with snow removal issues. This is in front of a Starbucks out here. They'll make a play pile. And one of the biggest differences is these walkways within the village there are managed by the town. They're actually like the town streets almost. They end up doing the snow removal process and doing that. So I'm not suggesting we get into that business for the village area, but it was interesting that...
30:58 A lot of their elements, they tie into those types of things. And as they've implemented a number of their planning studies and a number of the elements going in there, a lot of that deals with the design, what gets laid out. And as it relates to kind of a focus, they end up with several of these plazas out here that they end up programming and animating throughout the year in partnership with the hotels and the other facilities there, but also
31:26 The municipality itself steps up and really coordinates a lot of those efforts to make sure that there's activities that they're focused heavily on the customer experience and what happens in there in that area. And another photo here shortly, if you kind of remember, there's a little bit of a building on the edge you see here. I'll comment in a minute.
31:46 This was opening day for the ski area we were there. So this is the back side of that building. They're all in line to buy tickets and they had a good opening day on top of the mountain. Bottom of the mountain was barren until it started snowing when we were there. So I think we kind of know that feeling here at the moment. But the animation of the area, the way they partnership on promotion is huge there. So this would be a small level to bring in activities and acts. And then they have major events they work on with...
32:14 For-profit, not-profit elements there as well. Kind of just a differential in their buildings. We figured this would be a great New York deli type style building. Future hotel element. They had this gazebo area out here and they were actually, this was one, they talked about even potentially pulling that out. I don't think it's done as well as they liked. You see some of the rock out here and a little kind of neat building behind it.
32:43 This is the building that's next to that plaza in the back, but it's the entryway to the mountain. It's a great solid blockage of seeing the mountain from being able to walk down the pathway. It's not exactly a lovely building and it's in the wrong place. So it's fun to talk about different places, but here's something they actually did that probably incorrectly to really enhance their visitor experience. Back side of this hotel here, not near as exciting as some of the other buildings.
33:13 In terms of that. So some of their design's great and some of it's not. So something to kind of keep in mind as we go through. But not always something that's done perfectly in other communities as well as maybe what we would like. One of the things they did do a great job in was dealing with the Olympics. They had to have a lot of stuff up and running two years prior. They do pre-events and those types of things. They did a lot of work to make that happen. And once you're that Olympic,
33:40 Town near that forever, so it's kind of like Squaw from 1968, Olympic Village, they still sell it, they do a good job with it. The neat part here is they actually set this whole plaza area up, and the actual metal events were at this side over here, and the stage wasn't, I don't think in place at that point for the metal presentations, they had a different setup for it.
34:04 The cool part here, it's a little hard to see in here, but so they've reconstructed this. The nice part with the Olympics, they also leverage to get all of the electronics underground, so they've got fiber running all over the place, they've got some great connections, they can do the big TV screens where they need to do for their activities. In front of the stage area here is actually, there's a pond area or a concrete area, they actually freeze in the winter for ice skating, and so kind of a multi-use.
34:30 They really cram everybody in here. They can get up to maybe 10,000 people into this probably a little less than two acres. Comfortably, it's less than that, but they can really cram it in there. The nice part of this is you kind of get an idea of what a stage can look like. But the other thing is this is built for the Olympics. It's surrounded by the village area there. First is, I think, the opportunities in Mammoth is we don't have to create something that's completely man-made. We have open areas. We have some natural settings.
34:58 They almost invite themselves to this. So in one sense, I'd say we have some probably better settings, more beautiful settings. But the concept that they have a focal point where they can do venues kind of indoor-outdoor mixed with this stage, but really primarily a summer venue activity. I thought it was cool the way they had the ice skating component there with a little bit of concrete in the front of the stage area. They also can use that for like a dance floor and they can do stuff like that during other events. And so it was kind of an interesting multi-use setting.
35:28 When you look at the village there, it's an area of about 170 total acres or so, and they have the Blackholm side, the center of the village, and they have a creek side. It's almost like they've overdeveloped it. Some of the other areas struggle, and they probably put too many components in there, and so getting everything up to snuff has been a major issue for them in their marketing and branding work and bringing things in. So I think that's going to be an ongoing struggle for some of their areas.
35:57 I will touch on a couple a little further here. Again, that's something for us to be mindful of is how do you maximize what you got but don't go so big that they'll end up in trouble later. So you want things to be successful. This here is their community center and it's about 60 to 65,000 square feet. The white building here, the building on the right is an ice rink, full-blown. Hockey is a little more popular. I think there is it here probably. There's half a dozen people walking around missing teeth.
36:28 No. They're probably not. Anyway, and then next door is a swim center and a weight room and those types of things that went into this. I think this was a phased project too. They didn't do it all at once. But it also met their community needs. And the nice part in the back of it are actually ball fields. And then they have a wonderful trail system, the valley trail system, which runs the whole gamut through the village area and on down through the community into their various nodes and out.
36:58 Fantastic trail system through town, and they've done a good job, I think, connecting it to the residential neighborhoods, too, so it's exercise, it's fun, it's that, it's also a path to work. We did look at some of their transit systems as well, and I think, frankly, Mammoth's transit system is better. They're all large bus stuff and more of a fixed route, and I think we have a little more flexibility with our shuttles and what we do, so that was good to see.
37:25 One of the other areas we looked at heavily was what they did with the Olympic Village where all the athletes were living during the Olympics. And one of the options they had on that is actually they go in and you put all this up and they can actually in some cases end up tearing it down. They said, no, we want to invest in it and keep it. And the majority of it has turned into affordable housing. They've been very creative in how they've had their whole housing program come into play, focused on residents and employees.
37:54 So, to be eligible for affordable housing, you actually have to prove you work in Whistler. It's employee-based, and it's not so much the income-based. U.S. is a little different. We tend to look at dollars tied to income versus the live-work relationship, which I thought was very creative in how they do it. It's, you know, if the cost for the building is, say, $250 a square foot, low number at this point, they just take that time to square footage, and that becomes the purchase price.
38:23 They have a similar formula for rental properties. And so, again, it's not so much income-driven as it is cost-driven for the project. And then you have to prove you're an employee in the area. And if you've worked five of the last six years, you can be a retiree, and then you're eligible for affordable housing also. So it's kind of a unique opportunity that's a little different than what I'd say the U.S. in general has taken on, but definitely most communities I'm familiar with. Dan, do you remember the number, the percentage of the employees?
38:53 Yeah, they have a policy goal. They want 75% of their employees living in the community. During the 12-13 year, I think it was, or 11-12, they had 85% of the employees of Whistler living in Whistler versus either having to commute from the neighboring communities or even from Vancouver up. They did a great job, I think, in being able to provide that type of mix of housing. And then...
39:16 The Black Hole Whistler Group, they provide dorm-style housing, and some of the other employers also end up providing housing on their own, as well as some other conditions of approvals. But to hit that number was great. It was neat to see that they've been able to achieve that level. I think part of that has been that focus on we want our employees to live here, so that's one of the conditions of being eligible for the housing. But to hit that was neat. So these types of facilities, this is the village there where the athletes were living during the Olympics.
39:45 These are affordable units in here. They're hard to see here, but different style of units. The architecture is kind of fun. These are modular units in terms of how they've structured that in there. They have some areas with covered parking, some areas without it, but it's, again, a mix of ownership and rental throughout this. And then they had some other parcels that were pure market rate, aiming toward the entry of the
40:14 Village area, very nice lots and stuff like that with much higher dollar. This building was interesting to me. This here, we actually went in a little bit of it. This here was one of the buildings where the athletes currently come and train. It's like a dorm, hotel. There's a kitchen in there. They pay for the food and stuff. But if you look at kind of what I thought was interesting, the creativity, the architecture. Again, this is a modular building.
40:41 You wouldn't know that unless they told us frankly in looking at it. They have some large fields next door to it that we were standing on looking back across where they have future plans to do stuff as well on. So they've continued that whole idea of how do we bring athletic teams up and train and utilizing the facilities obviously built for the Olympics gives them a heads up of here come using this truly Olympic style.
41:08 Areas to train on for the future. Most types of areas. This here is over to the Creekside part of Whistler. Kind of some neat development in here and what they've done. But this area I think was originally kind of the primary mountain access and it shifted to the village. This is not doing as well. It's right next to a neighborhood and they have a very difficult time of drawing that neighborhood into the shopping. In part, there's a lot of steps.
41:38 You just got to go upstairs and stuff. And so from a skiing standpoint, people aren't going to walk in their boots to it. It was interesting. It really hasn't worked well. They assumed with a lot of residential next to it, boom, here's your village area, kind of the big side area. Fun little restaurant here and stuff at the bottom of the lifts.
41:59 Rental stuff around it does okay, but that housing seemed to really, wasn't drawn across, and I think it was a lot of just because it was elevated, there's stairs going up, and people, it's just not a comfortable walk, especially in the winter. I'm sure I thought it was interesting, so as you build it right next to residential, doesn't necessarily mean you'll get the residential visitors, you've got to make it a convenient, easy thing to get to still in those areas, so that's kind of a lesson learned to look at that.
42:28 Plus the competition over the other areas. This here is a boutique hotel. About 77 rooms, I believe. It's right next to one of the lakes. The hotel runs down. It's kind of an L shape. At the bottom, it's neat. They have a spa. They have a little train center station there. And this really ties right into the valley trail. There's the back. The back of it goes up to a residential area. People work here. They can walk down to it. It's at the end of a residential street that long term they want to tie into that.
42:57 Mountain Access. But again, people aren't easily just walking up, so they have some challenges in those areas. But very beautiful property in terms of what a boutique hotel begins to look like and feel like in terms of what they can do there. When you go to the Blackholm side, it's really interesting. It's almost like two separate development projects completely. They have this chateau over here. I think it was 600 rooms. It's several thousand square feet of a convention space.
43:27 This was walking up to it. You see the dark shadow on this side versus the sun on this side. When you walk in here, it's dark in there. You go to the right to go up, and you walk through what would be like the stuff in the village there, the right-hand side, there's shopping and stuff. But it's just a funnel, and so people don't stop and shop. They just walk through it. It doesn't have much life to it. It's very stagnant. And it's cold.
43:53 It's standing in the shadows. So if you look at stuff in Mammoth and we look at how do you do phase one, two, three, four stuff, keeping that light coming in, not creating these canyons becomes, experience here would be very important not to look at that. The other interesting thing is you start to see an architectural differential. La Chateau kind of stands on its own. It's more of a Canadian type style building. It's huge. And then they had this other hotel kind of on the other end of it that
44:22 Looks like it should be downtown Sacramento, at least from my perspective of it. It just didn't fit the environment. So I think that's something with our design guidelines and Mammoth and stuff. We can keep that. You have a character. You have a feel. How do you continue that through? Some of the stuff across the street did a little better job of that. Some of the planners actually got a hold of this. And the original plan for that canyon walkway was to continue. And they shut that down and tried to create a little more of a...
44:54 Look and feel for the rest of the community. So this upper part, this north village area, does not do as well as their core village, in part because of just the way it's designed and held. Plus I think again it's just an over building element they came into, which is a challenge. And I think it was right, if John and Madison, I think it was 600 rooms in there that they had, sticks in my head. It was huge, I said they were going. I'm not sure how to fill it up, even in conventions and stuff, just to get all the bodies there.
45:22 Those type of things. Then you have the other rooms and the timeshare rooms and other Reynolds that are in there. Dan, that picture, that photo in the lower right-hand corner, was that the Ritz-Carlton that was built? I don't believe that was the name of it that we were there. It was designed from somebody with an Asian background and stuff and into it. I don't recall that being the Ritz. They do have a Ritz-Carlton there, but I thought it was over by the other village. I'd have to look at the map again for... But it was interesting to me just...
45:52 You look at this other very thoughtful design and you get kind of a different look and feel. To me that would be one of the lessons learned. The other element that came out through all this stuff and talking to them on their promotional side of the house, I mentioned animating things. The other element they were very big on was creating major events. They had to try to get five signature events going. For them working with
46:18 For-profit or non-profits isn't so much the issue, it's a business decision of how successful can the event become. They tend to put more investment on the front end of events versus the back end. In other words, bring it in, make you successful. The gentleman we talked to, I mean, that was his job for the town every day. He gets up and goes out. His job is to make the promotional effort and the event successful. I think he had about a $3 million budget to play with. They have funding out of the province that puts additional...
46:47 Promotional dollars in there. But one of the key elements was how do they keep it animated, how do they do this investment? And they've done a great job in reaching the Pacific Rim, I think, and European markets and those types of things. And talking to the hotel folks, there was a lot of Asian type or Pacific Rim level of people coming in. But it was interesting on the event side, it was really how do you take, and I think they like the for-profit groups because they tend to be more motivated to make successful events because then they do better.
47:17 And those types of things. But making a profit on an event in the community wasn't a bad word for them. A little different perspective sometimes, I think, than what we may take on it. And so that was really a kind of a different perspective just on how they grow those and really focus on those signature events and how to kind of peak those peaks with that element for it. The other piece throughout that, though, we also looked at trash services.
47:44 More comparable or better, frankly, transit I mentioned to do that. Snow plowing, I think we probably get, normal year we get more snow than they do. We probably have that down pat a little better. I'd also hate to be responsible for going inside these village areas and moving snow around. Those types of things would be a little tricky. Those types of areas. The other thing that impressed me was the customer service ethic that was in the community in general. Whether you went into the market, the liquor store, the ski shop.
48:14 The coffee shop, everybody was very engaged, and I thought that was really nice, talking about different things, why are you here, what are you, you know, type of an issue, they were, that customer service you felt wanted, you know, without being overburdened. They did a great job, and I don't recall having any experiences of bad customer service from where we went through that, so there seemed to be a pervasiveness that
48:40 The tourist is our reason for being here, so come and we'll treat you right. It was a great element. I'm not sure how much internal training, external training they do, but it seemed to be pervasive, at least from my perspective, with the interactions that we had through town there. And then I think the overarching issue from this was really setting the vision on the front end that they had to say, we want to create a village set, we want to create this ski town, we want to create these things.
49:06 Same thing as us. They've gone through a lot of planning work and planning documents, and they have the things on the shelf. And then the execution of them has been overall good. And I think the Olympics drove a lot of that. They could make decisions if they had to, or they weren't going to meet the requirements of the Olympic being able to move forward. We went up and visited, but the sledding areas are still there, the bobsled, etc. People can still do some stuff up there and train.
49:32 I think it's the fastest track ever, they were saying, until the upper part is closed. The athlete killed in it, if you remember that. Too much speed there coming down. But in terms of kind of that comparison stuff, I think there's a lot of things Mammoth is on par or even better with. The same thing, though, I think having that leadership vision of where they're going has driven a whole lot of their development, which has been very powerful.
49:57 Making that happen. They have some very strong partners in the community, Whistler Blackcomb, like us, with Mammoth Mountain. And then it was interesting, I think the Olympics drove a lot of them to act on the need, but even prior to that in the village and the vision they had, they kept true to it and pushing it through and working through on that to make it happen. And then a lot of just creativity, I think, in how they did some stuff with the parking elements, those types of things, some of the creativity in buildings. And then with the Olympics, obviously, that
50:27 Taking that whole Olympic Village and converting the majority of that into that affordable housing and ongoing training center, not just having something built be torn down or suffer over time. They've done a great job through some of those areas. So I think that getting things moving forward on a vision and the creativity coming and doing that was a good take-home message for me, at least, in looking at some of those elements. With that, I'll go over the longer I wanted to, but let me pause and I don't, John and Matt, if you guys want to add to it, feel free or I'll
50:56 Answer any questions the council may have. John? I don't, excuse me, I don't have anything to add other than to agree that there were things that they do really, really well in some areas like housing, snow removal and transit we do equally as well. You mentioned earlier in your presentation some of the, that they had some problems and I'm thinking
51:26 I'd like to have some of the problems that Whistler had. I'd like to be that far advanced. Yeah. Yeah, it was a good eye-opener. We had a great host, of course, in Mike Vance, and having him take us around and having him set up appointments with different people in different departments was invaluable. Yeah. Yeah, I just think that I didn't go back to some things we said.
51:55 Earlier, where, you know, they really, what they had down was the visioning. And it was really thinking things through, going through the public process, and then executing after that. It wasn't something where you kept churning it over and over and over and over again. And, you know, I hope that, I'm actually hopeful that this council even can sit down at some point, hopefully in the near future, and even if nothing else, just have a little workshop where we can start to decide.
52:23 What is it we want our town to look like? What are some of the things that are out there in other communities that we could, you know, what do we have available to us to maybe create a rec center for our community or some other thing that's important to us, whether it be a pool or something else along those lines? I know it was interesting going to that rec center to hear, you know, everybody in the community, I think, gets to go there for, you know, 20 or 50 bucks a month.
52:50 And they get to go in there and they have these big warm pools in there and you see kids in there in their section and the adults are over here and the hockey rink and everything else. And it was pretty cool to see that and how well it was done. And, I mean, you think to yourself, wow, just for that amount of money, it'd be nice to have something like that to go to when it's really cold outside. You know, and it's more than just a pool. There's a weight room and all these other different things. And it makes you think, you know, we have a, you know, we have a,
53:17 Athletic Center here already. You don't want to compete with them, but maybe there's private-public partnerships that could take place there or looking at some of the assets that we have in town. And how can we start to, you know, we're sitting on, I don't know how many tens of millions of dollars worth of assets and we're doing absolutely nothing with them. And it seems in some form or another, we have wants here and we have things we have over here. Is there a way to maybe sit down in a room and start talking about what we can do to put some of these ideas together and make it happen?
53:47 Not just to drive things for our visitors, but for ourselves as well and the families that are going to be here and it comes back to the quality of life. So I'm hoping, you know, maybe the next month or two would be fun just to sit down, I think, at some sort of workshop and kind of start picking brains of people that are out there and what they'd like to see. I know there's a lot of community groups have been calling me in the last month saying how they're already doing this on their own. I think people are, you know, morale's been down for four years and it'd be nice to...
54:15 See something happen that's positive and really start getting our community back in a positive mode again. Be nice to do in the next couple of months. Comments? Questions? I do have a couple of comments. It's been probably 10 or so years since I've been there. Some of those photographs are very familiar to me. And what's interesting is that
54:47 That which we saw and learned so many years ago, I think my first trip there was about 14 years ago, are still going on there. What strikes me about Whistler is that they're first pointed in the same direction, everybody seems to be pointed in the same direction. Second, they're constantly thinking about ways that they can improve what they already have.
55:15 And we see them as the gold standard in many ways. They're not resting on that. It's very impressive to see that that is still going on. It doesn't mean that some mistakes are not going to be made. But they seem to have a long-term view, identify what the problems are. And even if they don't appear to be a problem today, they know that it might be a problem or will be a problem later, that they fit into the long-term plans.
55:44 We've made an effort in the past to identify what they've done to promote and encourage this high level of customer service. And in fact, there are formal training programs that employees participate in to do that. We've not gotten there yet, but a great lesson to be learned there. I recall that community center, which is the sports complex,
56:15 is about, if I remember correctly, four miles outside of the village itself. You don't just walk there. And that's instructive for us as well, that we don't actually have to have something within 100 feet, for example, of the village, that if you build something that will serve a need, and you've got the transit to get people there, and that's how people got there, they will use it. I also recall that they built it in three stages, because it's got hockey,
56:44 Indoor aquatics and then of course the other recreation weights and running track and that sort of thing and they did it as they could afford it but they so in that sense it was sort of modular they just kept adding on to the building question that I have for you is is there is the affordable housing deed restricted that is the stuff that was purchased it's interesting to me that if you
57:14 Essentially what they're doing is they're building it and not allowing the developer to make a profit and selling it at cost, basically. Right. Do they restrict once you get it? No, it's deed restricted. Some of them are just deed restricted, and this helps developers, deed restricted just on the occupancy. You can sell it at market, but you can only sell it to somebody who works in town, who's actually an employee. There's also an occupancy.
57:44 And price restriction on buying, owning a unit. And then they have an occupancy and rent restriction as well. And those are, they are deed restricted through that. But it's not an income based. It's a, are you an employee, a retiree eligible? And then the restriction is based on that. So it is deed restricted. But some of them are, were a market rate.
58:06 But it's occupancy based. So if you live there and work there and can afford to pay more, in some cases you could actually get a market rate type home. But if you don't live there, you wouldn't be eligible for it. I see. So did you have a discussion with whoever was showing you that stuff about how that fit in as compared to the private sector? Meaning, was it competitive with the private sector? Was that an issue?
58:35 Private sector was substantially higher for prices. Like if you're paying $400,000 for a market for a affordable unit, it's probably a million for a $750,000 for a true, for a comparable market unit. So different segments and not competitive. What about on the rent side? Because the argument that I've heard time and time again is that if workforce housing is constructed, effectively subsidized by the government, it will bring down rents in the private sector.
59:04 Did not really have the dialogue on the rent structure there. I'd have to go back. I've got a copy of their housing authority plan. I'm not sure if it's addressed in there off the top of my head. But it didn't seem to be an issue in terms of general dialogue that one drives the other one dramatically there in terms of the market demand that was obviously in the community. Rick, I didn't want to leave the wrong impression. The developers did make money.
59:32 And they were able to make money on either selling vacant lots in a certain area at market rates or building market housing and selling them at market rates. Yeah, there's a combination. The Olympic Village is a little different. It had some market rate lots at the opening of it. On project work, it was both. They got additional density and then they would do that and they had market rate, but it was a mix.
59:58 And it's also spread throughout the community, which was nice. I think every place we went to, you would have a little bit of affordable housing. Outside the village, it wasn't concentrated. The last question is not a question, but a comment. And it actually speaks to some of Matthew's comments. As Joe is acutely, maybe painfully aware, we spent some years putting together community priorities in the rec strats process.
1:00:26 That are very clearly identified. But what's important about that, and it's only been two years since we approved the rec strats document, those priorities have been consistent for as long as I've been around. They really haven't changed much. And so this community actually has stated what it wants. And I'm really happy to report that my expectation of the report that is going to come out from the MLR Steering Committee
1:00:53 is that it, meaning MLR, if this council approves the formation of it, is going to essentially shepherd us as a town through that very process that you have described, which is to have a discussion about what we want, what we can afford, when it should be there, what partnerships are available to make things happen that otherwise couldn't.
1:01:21 What opportunities are available to bond the measures R&U funds in order to achieve the things the community says that it wants. And so while I'm thrilled to have a council discussion about it, stay tuned because what you're going to see in February I think will be impressive to you and to us and to the community as well. I've got high hopes for that document as it comes out and then what will follow.
1:01:47 Rick, if I may, I wanted to pick up on what Matthew mentioned earlier as well, and that is, and it's what you and Joe are going through on MLR. I think, I agree with Matthew, I'd like in the next month or two, of course we've got the holidays in front of us, but I'd like to think in the next month or two we could have a community council discussion, and I think Dan is familiar with a gentleman,
1:02:17 Somewhere in the Sierra, certainly someone like Mike Vance from Whistler, I'd like to see us bring in a couple of consultants and have them facilitate a community discussion on an agendized format and start that discussion on what Mammoth needs, what we could look for in the future and stuff like that, if there's support.
1:02:45 Maybe it's just a springboard for, you know, just gathering information on what MLR's done or doing. Well, in fact, it's funny that you say that because one of the comments that the consultants made this last week is we don't have a problem planning. We've got everything planned and what this process is to get us to actually implementing it. Right. And the presentation that Dan made at Monday's meeting gave us options where
1:03:11 Literally, okay, if these are the top three priorities as they were established in rec tracks, here's how you could have them in place in five years. Or less. Or less. It's a much different approach. It's more proactive and entrepreneurial. So I agree we should have the discussion, but I think you want to wait and see this report first. And of course, first meeting in February, and of course,
1:03:39 The MLR meetings are on the Granicus system, so you can go and listen to them and see the discussion as it's come to this point. Yeah, I can't overstate that. There's been a lot of work and really significant progress made in areas that you guys are talking about. It's just that we are the council members that are on it.
1:04:01 I don't want to get ahead of it, but it's going to be very substantive as it is presented, and I think it will be a springboard for that discussion. Whether it's walking and chewing gum at the same time or not, but I'd like to think we could almost do two or at least have this other one set up immediately afterwards. I'm more focused on, and I mentioned this before, and it was the reason that I wanted to go on this particular peer resort tour.
1:04:31 And I'll back up a little bit. Our competitors, they do resort tours. And our new council or whatever it is, our new staff, I think that after the election this summer that it would benefit the community and the council and the town staff to do a resort tour because when we talked to department heads, whether it was transportation or marketing,
1:05:03 They go to other resorts on a routine basis to see what other resorts are doing, and they base the decisions on the information that they get. They don't do maybe ten resorts, but they might do two, three, or four, or five just to keep up to date because, as Matthew said, they're always looking forward. They're not resting on their laurels. They're looking forward to try to figure out the new latest and greatest.
1:05:30 But the other thing what I was going to mention is we've talked about that we want to be development ready. I mean, that's the phrase that people have used. I think that I haven't met the gentleman that Dan is talking about, but I have met the other gentleman, of course, from Whistler. These individuals are involved in the process, and they can tell us as a council, as a community,
1:06:01 You want to be development ready in today's market. This is what you need to focus on, you know, whatever it may be. I don't know. But I think that that would be a very relevant discussion to have. Thanks, John. Okay. Can we agendize maybe at our next meeting to see if there's council support for doing something like that? We can't decide tonight. This is not a decision.
1:06:34 I'm trying to remember if the zoning code amendment is coming to us in February as well. I'm trying to... There's too many dates out there. But I think that that's a time probably... I think February will be the month of... Where are we going? That's fine. Yeah. Because with only one meeting in January, it's probably going to be a big meeting. Already is. Thank you, Jo. And you have a cold, don't you? Yes, I do. I'm sorry.
1:07:05 All right. Dan Holler, thank you. Any comments from the public on this? Obviously, we're not taking any specific action. I appreciate the report. I wholeheartedly endorse these tours. I'm just so glad you guys did them. They really fell off of the council's radar some five, six, seven, eight years ago. We were focused on other things. There were other things to do, but they're very important.
1:07:34 All right. If not, that takes us to consent agenda items two through seven. Any council member wish to pull any item? I'd like to pull number four, please. Number four. Now I'm going to have to abstain from four and recuse myself since I live right next door. So. Okay. So first, before we get to four, with respect to two, three, five, six, and seven, is there a motion? Make a motion, council approve.
1:08:04 Consent of agenda items 2, 3, 5, 6, and 7. Second. Okay. We have a motion and a second. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. It takes us to number 4, which is authorized the consulting agreement with RBF Consulting for Preparation of the California Environment Quality Act CEQA review for the Inn at the Village project.
1:08:35 Hi, thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers. This item is simply to have the Council authorize the town to enter into a consulting agreement for the environmental review for the IN project. It will be a subsequent environmental impact report. We anticipate it taking about seven months. The contract itself is for a little over $124,000. That includes contingency and I think
1:09:02 Oh, and the applicant will be paying for that contract in its entirety as well as all of staff's time to manage the consultant and process the permit. Questions? I had a couple of questions. A couple of them you just answered, but so is this a supplemental? Is it, or I mean, is it already, does it go into the guideline of the whole North Village plan already or not?
1:09:33 For the environmental impact report, we will be working off of the North Village EIR, which was done in 99 and has had a few supplements to it. So we won't be reiterating or redoing information that has been analyzed before that hasn't changed with this project, but we will be looking at any impacts that are increased or more severe than that certified EIR. Okay. My other question was as far as the pay that
1:10:03 Doesn't go forward or whatever it may be that we're not stuck paying that town. I mean, it's going to be paid almost like a retainer type of structure with the developers. Is that what I understand? Correct. The consultant wouldn't be authorized to do any work until the town has full payment from the applicant for that work. Okay. And then lastly, from what I understand is that part of the parking requirement was an agreement with the hillside project that caused the way.
1:10:32 That's not moving forward at this time. So how does that impact this with parking? Is there enough parking for what's now without that? Or how does that get worked through? Right now, based on the information that's been provided, is that the numbers work, that there is adequate parking. Parking will be evaluated in the EIR, so we will be looking at – there's a variety of parking agreements with this project, so it is a bit complicated.
1:11:00 There's agreements with the mountain, fireside, so there's a lot of different aspects. The commercial two means has parking in there as well. So we'll be looking at that in detail. We have a transportation consultant who peer reviews all the analysis that's provided by the applicant. So they'll be looking at the proposed parking as well as a valet plan is proposed to make sure that the parking is adequate. So they'll be looking at that in detail. Okay, thank you. Sharon, if I can ask you,
1:11:30 This EIR or supplemental is required because of the amendments that have been requested by the developer that would fall outside of what's currently in the North Village specific plan, right? That's exactly. Height and density primarily. Right. Well, why is the EIR, I guess, what I understand is,
1:11:54 If those things haven't been, you know, conditionally approved, why is the EIR done in advance of the formal application and does that come before Council or is that only a Planning Commission decision? Both the EIR and the project will come before Council and we can't approve a project until the Environmental Impact Report is certified so we have to do the Environmental Impact Report.
1:12:19 And have it certified before we take any action on the project. So theoretically, the work, the $124,000 could be spent, but that doesn't guarantee that that which is being requested is going to be approved either by Planning Commission or by Council. Correct. Thanks. And that was my concern that I wanted to make sure that Town was going to be able to look for the report for it. Thank you. Other questions from Council? No.
1:12:46 How about members of the public who wish to provide a comment? If not, I'll entertain a motion on number four. I'll move approval of option one. Second. Okay, with a motion and a second.
1:13:06 No, he had to recuse himself. Oh, sorry. Yes. You know, he's at Fireside, so he had to recuse himself. Understood. All right, with one council member appropriately absent, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 4-0 with one recusal under for extension. All right, it takes us to agenda item
1:13:34 Number 8. This is a public hearing that is entitled Adopt an Ordinance Amending Town of Mammoth Lakes Municipal Code Title 18, Chapter 18.02. This relates to the Mammoth Lakes Airport Rules and Regulations. I'm told by staff that I'm told by the public hearing and I therefore do so and that the matter at the request of staff is going to be continued to, is it the next meeting, Jamie? Yes, Jamie.
1:14:04 January 15th. 15th. And however, since there may be members of the public here who wish to speak on the agenda item, we want to provide the opportunity for the public to do so, notwithstanding that there's not a report and there will be another opportunity to speak. If not, we'll continue the public hearing and that takes us then to agenda item number nine.
1:14:33 I was missing you, Matthew. I didn't know where you went. Sorry, I got to leave again, so I recuse myself on nine. With respect to number nine, it's entitled, Awards a Contract for the Lower Canyon Boulevard Rehabilitation Project. Yeah, but isn't it of a public nature? Well, that's kind of what I thought, but I'm hearing no, so. All right. All right, Peter, you're going to give the presentation? I am. Go ahead, thank you. This project, as Council may recall,
1:15:03 We'll reconstruct Forest Trail in Canyon Boulevard from Forest Trail down to Hillside Boulevard. And it'll install, construct a sidewalk on the north side. There'll be some street lights at the interceptions. The other main feature of the project, it will complete the drainage facilities from where they currently come out of the ground, or out of the pipe at Forest Trail, run along the gutter, and then go back in.
1:15:33 Down near Viewpoint Road. So staff, there is a modification on the recommendation. We've got one additional item to add to the recommendation. And staff recommends that we waive the minor, the council waives the minor irregularities that were noticed in the bid and find that the contractor did not, did meet the disadvantaged business program that he proposed in this contract.
1:16:04 In addition, staffs recommending awarding the contract to the lowest response bidder with those findings, which was piece construction for 3.53765979 cents to construct a project. This is a reduced award because the bid was above our budget and we've adjusted the award to fit it within the budget. Again, the
1:16:31 Staff would recommend that Council approve the plan specifications and those are and have been available in the Public Works Department. And authorized Public Works Director to modify the project scope and keep the project within the approved budget and we'll review options during our 2014 CIP discussions to see if we can find additional funds to complete the entire project. And then authorized Public Works Director to execute the contract to accept the project when it's completed.
1:17:00 This is one of the Townsville's priorities. It's a road maintenance project primarily. It is a capital project, but it's a capital maintenance project. It'll be a new facility when we're done. This project was conceived prior to the 2006 State Transportation Improvement Program. We selected a consultant in 2008 to design the project. Plans were completed over the course of several years.
1:17:32 Sometimes the state didn't have money, but in the course of it, we increased the budget by $600,000, and the budget, the construction funds were allocated, or awarded by the CTC for this fiscal year. We began advertising the project on November 15th. Bids were open December 11th. Staff evaluated the bids. The low bid was from Speeds Construction at $3.89,208.60.
1:18:03 There was, this includes a, some irregularities which reduced their project bid that was shown on their bid form by $2,179.21. The scope that we're currently recommending be not awarded is we're going to reconstruct, fully reconstruct the road between Hillside and Lake Mary when we've got quite a bit of pavement failures.
1:18:33 And then we were going to reconstruct the section of Hillside Boulevard up to the west end to widen that street to allow parallel parking. And long term, if there's a parking garage there, it provides that space for certainly. That's a project, Peter, that could easily be added at a later date, isn't it? It could be. The part we'd like to put back into the project is fund an overlay through the village.
1:19:05 With fiber or a petrol mat to eliminate the cracks and reconstruct that street because it's one of the worst sections of road in that area. Gets heavy use. Yeah. Yeah. With that, Council has any additional questions? Sorry. Go ahead. From Forest Trail up to Canyon is not part of this, correct?
1:19:34 Correct. A number of years ago, I think in 2006, we reconstructed that section of the road, put in a storm drain, and constructed the sidewalk on the north side of the road. Presently that sidewalk stops at Mammoth Slopes Drive. Yeah, at Forest Drive. Yeah, and then Mammoth Slopes. The right-of-way above Mammoth Slopes isn't really wide enough to fit a sidewalk in. There's some site agreements for snow storage that were implemented when...
1:20:05 That right away was condemned. And so it's really not, yeah, there's just not enough space here with the parking that's required for Mammoth Quest. Thank you. Yeah. So, Peter, now that we're essentially pulling back the full work and just overlay for the section, which I think we all agree is probably the most noticeably degraded section, then would we do that? Is the overlay in here?
1:20:37 Or do we have to find that out of our regular road rehab funds? Yeah, I think what we're suggesting is that we look at when we're finalizing the 2014 CIP, 14-15 CIP, that we see if there's a couple hundred thousand dollars within that road rehab budget to allocate to this project. Okay, so we'd be using our own funds, not the state funds. The other design feature just...
1:21:07 Just to point out is that essentially we're doing two things with the road. We're going to narrow it slightly. Right now there's eight foot shoulders. There'll be six foot shoulders. And we're going to shift the center line two feet to the south. What that does is reduce the impact to the properties on the north side to an impact of two feet from the current curb location and really minimizes the impact of the driveways. There is a few homes that will have an impact.
1:21:36 Those homes have had were approved with the requirement that they don't park in their driveways. And so with this project they really won't be able to fit at all in those driveways. And I think two locations. And so will notice of that go out to those homeowners? Yeah, we've been in contact with all the property owners. We've sent them several letters. I've met with most of them in the field to show them exactly where the improvements will be.
1:22:08 Peter, on page two, I handwritten two of the agenda bill that we received tonight, I see that there is the, under options analysis, there is a recommendation of these four bullet points, and I heard you say that, but can you restate the two additions? I heard one, which is to, I believe, way of minor, did irregularities, and what was the other one?
1:22:36 To include in a motion? To find the contractor, the little bid contractor has met the disadvantaged business enterprise requirements of the contract. Do any member of the public wish to speak on this matter, this agenda item? If not, I would make a motion that the four bullet pointed options that are set forth under options analysis on page two
1:23:12 Which is to award the contract to the lowest bidder of space construction with that minor reduction as indicated as a result of the bid irregularity. To approve the plans and specifications, to authorize the Public Works Directive to modify the project scope to keep the project within the approved budget, and review options to increase the project budget with the 2014 CIP,
1:23:44 Authorized Public Works Director to action the contract, accept the project, and also to waive the minor bid irregularities that were contained in the low bidder's bid, and also to find the low bid contractor has met the disadvantaged business enterprise requirement of the project. Second. I was going to say, let you do all that. Okay.
1:24:13 I think we all understand what it is that we're voting on, because I just read it. Are there any other questions, any other comments? If not, roll call. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 4-0. Thank you. Thanks, Peter. I'm glad to see that project get underway. That's tangible stuff that people need and want. The best part is that it comes...
1:24:42 From 100% funded by the state of California. Yes. It does. And, you know, most of the homeowners are very happy to see a sidewalk. Once they realize that it wasn't going to take out their whole front yard. Yeah. And once they realize that it was only lighting at the intersections. Correct. Yeah. All right. It takes us to... Can we get Matthew back? Oh, yeah. That's... He's disappeared. He's Matthew. We lose his pants.
1:25:05 All right, while we're fetching him. Thanks, Pat. We will go to policy, agenda item number 10, policy matter entitled Review of the Town Solid Waste Program and Opportunities to Increase Recycling and Diversion. And we are at staff report. Peter, are you going to deliver that? Yep, council members. Recycling is a state mandated requirement by AB 341, as we discussed at the
1:25:35 A meeting a month ago. And so I'll just kind of review a little bit of the history that the town's been going through over the last many years of this project. That review was done on October 16, 2013 meeting. As discussed at that meeting, AB 341 that took effect in 2012 requires that
1:26:04 Many businesses, commercial businesses and multi-unit complexes recycle their waste. The town is responsible on a local level to enforce and facilitate an implementation of 340. Back in September 7th of 2005, council meeting, direction was given to staff to evaluate several policy issues and options regarding the town's waste program.
1:26:37 This was in response to, and a request actually from Mammoth Disposal and also to look at the franchise agreement at that time. There were several members of the public, John Eastman, Skip Harvey was a big proponent of the recycling effort and Cal Recycle still remembers Skip and many of the things that they had with him and the commitments that the town made at that time. They remind me of that.
1:27:11 In addition, Ted Colleton of the Sheep was on the committee, Mary Canada, who no longer lives in town, Lisa Isaacs, at the time she worked at the mountain, Greg Jennison, Greg Jennison from the Contractor Association. The final committee report dated March 23rd is attached and, but most of the items within that that were service related actually have been implemented by Mammoth Disposal.
1:27:47 Direction was given to staff at that time to work on updating the exclusive franchise agreement. There's a letter from the town to Mammoth Disposal Waste Connections related to several deal points. I didn't include the franchise agreement because it's like 90 pages. But the deal points basically have been incorporated into the current franchise agreement. And if anybody wants to review that, we have that in the office.
1:28:23 And that amendment was effective January 1st, 2010. It currently does have a five-year extension option for Waste Connections, and that would end December 31st, 2019. Mono County commissioned a report for Solid Waste Report prepared by HDR, which was completed in November 30th, 2010. I don't know that it was actually ever accepted by the county, but...
1:28:58 In the report, it was really a technical report that really looked at just the numbers, many options within the area to handle solid waste long term. Generally, really in the end, the analysis was the closer you can have a sorting, recycling type facility to the source, the cheaper it would be. The town currently has actually, the report says 70, we're nearly 80% of the solid waste in town.
1:29:31 So those costs, if you're able to complete that sorting closer to the source, it makes it certainly cheaper from it. Transportation costs themselves are quite expensive. The other part that it really didn't talk about is, and as we all realize, is that the cost of labor for a private company generally is quite a bit cheaper than the cost of labor for an entity or an agency. One of the main reasons is because of benefits. The other thing about a larger scale
1:30:08 Sorting facility, recycling facility. It really provides more opportunity to recycle materials. And I'll get into some of the recommendations that CalRecycle gave us recently. One item that wasn't included in the report, because it really wasn't looking at the overall environment, it was really just looking at technically at the details and really the cost detail.
1:30:36 It really didn't look at, there's a circular 150 slash 5233B that the FAA puts out, which really prohibits generally any waste facilities that might encourage wildlife within a five mile radius of the airport. During the last several months, staff has met with many of the community partners, the water district,
1:31:09 Mono County, Forest Service. We intend to have another meeting with the Forest Service soon. And Waste Connections to understand their needs and look at possible opportunities to collaborate. Recently, we've been in detail discussions with Waste Connections. They provided information about the handling costs and the capacities. And so we'll be using that information to look at
1:31:44 Long term, what are the town's waste needs? So at build out, we know what the waste is now, it's between 30 and 40 tons a day. In the shoulder seasons, it's much less than that. Long term, 20 year build out scenario, what is our waste stream and do we have enough capacity with whatever we're doing to meet that need? So the recent discussions with CalRecycle and they'll be here again in January to do another audit.
1:32:17 And review our recycling, recycling that we're doing and reviewing what we're dumping out at the landfill. But they really want us to fully implement the green building code and construction and demolition recycling. And we have a new building official come on board next month and we can help with that implementation process. They also wanted us to implement an ordinance for
1:33:04 Commercial recycling. And really it's just kind of restating state law. But since we're the local enforcing agency, that was one of their suggestions that we do to continue to be within the best efforts program instead of the compliance program. And then from a public outreach and education standpoint, they want us to implement additional recycling program for special events.
1:33:34 One of the things they heard from, they don't just meet with staff, they essentially walk through the community, they meet with business owners, people on the street, they go out to the landfill, they look at what's coming out of the trucks, they don't, you know, they really do an investigation when they're here for the number of days. So one of the things they heard from the public was the town really doesn't have any recycling at special events. And that's not necessarily true, we do have some recycling going on, but from that perception,
1:34:05 They thought, well, you need more enforcement, more guidelines for events to include recycling, at least promote it more so that people understand that we're not just throwing away everything at events. We are doing some recycling there. So those are our three highlights. The CD gives us the big volume numbers. The commercial recycling, it's required by the state and they want to see it implemented more. One of the things they saw was that
1:34:36 The trash coming out of the trucks four or five years ago was the same as the trash coming out of the trucks this summer. So from that standpoint, not quite making what they're trying to do. So that's what their main things are and they'll be, like I said, they'll be again here in January and they'll have a final report later on, probably February or April. The other
1:35:11 The other thing that the town will need to be working on over the long term, you know, we need to have a 15, 20 year, state requires a 15, we really need to have a 20 year plan for where our solid waste goes. And so over the next few years really the town needs to work to understand where that waste will go, waste stream will go once Benton Crossing closes. The HGL report really looked at two options, which are the
1:35:42 Which is the Lockwood, Nevada site, or the Indio County. And so both of these options were discussed and long term one of them will need to meet the needs of the town and the county. So with that, I think Mono County, Jim Letty's here, he'd like to speak a little bit. We also have Pat Fenton with Waste Connections. If they've got questions, council has questions and information on the agenda report.
1:36:13 Let's start with questions from Council of Peter. Peter, on number three in the options where we're talking about the Municipal Code revisions that you just spoke to, it says at the end that this would be over the next several months. Our special events start in June. Will we be able to have the ordinance in place in time? It's an outdoor special events. Okay. Yeah, we can do that. Okay. Other questions?
1:36:45 You know, I have some questions probably afterwards. We try to work with them on the long-term solution cooperatively, so they do have some background information, I think, on the landfill, etc. And actually, I'm just warming up for Tony. But I did want to thank Dan and Peter for helping us have an opportunity to present some background.
1:37:14 From the county, I want to thank Tony for, he's going to do a PowerPoint presentation on the history, this ongoing dialogue, you know, in the spirit of trying to continue partnership, find opportunities to ensure that both jurisdictions' goals are addressed, whether it comes to diversion or the long-term issues surrounding the landfill. So, without further ado, I want to turn it over to Tony Gablino and also thank him for, you know, prior to my getting here, he's been having to carry a lot of the water on this and, um,
1:37:43 And I want to thank Dan for, we've had about six conversations, five of which have been about solid waste, and really appreciate the time that you've put into this, and Peter, thank you also for your work on this. So with no further ado, Mr. Dublino. Mr. Mayor, members of the council, thanks again for allowing me to speak to you a little bit about these topics. I'm going to just try and keep this brief. There's just a few slides, but with animation and what have you, you know, sometimes they can run a little bit long, but
1:38:11 I'll try to keep it as brief as possible. Just wanted to talk a little bit about the history here and set the stage to kind of explain, you know, some of the county's perspective once again on where we're at, how we found ourselves here, and where we are trying to go. You know, essentially it's about a 50-year partnership. I mean, Benton Crossing Landfill as a public dump site, as they were called prior to them being permitted in the 70s, was essentially where a lot of mammoth's waste was going back kind of before regulation.
1:38:38 In 1988, after a permit of the landfill, the solid waste parcel fees were adopted, funded landfill operations at $30 per residential equivalent. Some of you may have been around at that time and remember just not having to pay anything. You would just show up and dump your garbage into a pit, and that was the end of it, and that $30 essentially covered it. That went up to $60 in 1993 as a result of increasing costs and regulatory issues such as closure costs.
1:39:07 That the state implemented at that time. Until 2000 approximately, Benton Crossing was operated by a contractor. It was Mammoth's Landfill. There was some minor input from unincorporated communities, but all the other communities essentially in Mona County had their own landfills. So really Benton Crossing was essentially Mammoth's Landfill. 2000, the county assumed operation at Benton Crossing. We financed equipment and we financed infrastructure through bonds that went through 2023.
1:39:35 In 2004, DWP, not exactly sure the precise history of that, but for one reason or another, they decided that when those bonds were done in 2023, they wanted us to close the landfill operations of Benton Crossing entirely, and they've held that position since. In 2005, Benton Crossing became the regional landfill for all Mono County. We essentially shut down all the other landfills and started, at least from municipal solid waste, started bringing all the waste from Mono County to
1:40:05 Benton Crossing. As it turns out, Bridgeport, Walker go out of the county already towards Lockwood, Nevada, ultimately, but everything else goes to Benton Crossing, meaning the Tri-Valley, Paradise, Twell Meadows, Crowley, all of that, and Pumice, Lee Vining, Mona Basin area. Nonetheless, Mammoth still represents 80% of the waste at Benton Crossing. In 2000,
1:40:29 Waste volumes and related funding plummeted as a result of the recession. We've all kind of heard this story. That kind of is what put this program into the financial pickle that it endured for the last several years. In 2009 to 2012, gate fees increased from $44 to $74 per ton. During that time, that's when HDR, that HDR report that Peter referenced, that's when that was commissioned.
1:40:55 In order to determine kind of future disposal options and cost. You know, the writing was on the wall at that point with those tipping fees that this really was not going to be the most economic feasible option for us moving forward. So the county and the town, I think, both are interested in investigating it. And that's the HDR report, and I looked into that. 2013, today, essentially, the fund is balanced for the first time in six years. It actually is not six years. It's closer to...
1:41:22 Five years, four to five years, so I kind of overstated that a little bit. But, you know, this history and this partnership, I think, is why, you know, you will find in some of the documents that are part of this agenda packet, like the 2006 committee recommendation, as well as the deal points letter from Waste Connections in 2009, that both reference the fact that the town should continue to utilize Bend Crossing Landfill as its disposal site.
1:41:47 If you look at both the 2006 committee recommendation and the deal points letter, you'll find that statement in plain English. So I think essentially that history is why that is the case. What's going on at Benton Crossing Landfill? This I think is kind of important to explain for those of you who haven't been out to the site and don't know exactly what's going on out there.
1:42:09 Obviously, we landfill municipal solid waste. That gray area is our waste disposal footprint, historic. We are not landfilling waste in the entire place, but that's essentially where we buried municipal solid waste in the past. We accept C&D for diversion and landfill activities as well. A site of approximately two acres. This area is essentially where we believe that we could help the town achieve its diversion requirements relating to C&D.
1:42:39 By, you know, doing some diversion activities with heavy equipment and crushing aggregate materials I kind of discussed at the last council meeting. Another thing that's really critical to consider is that we dry and reuse sludge for Mammoth Community Water District. And, you know, I just think it's really important as this conversation goes forward and there's talk about the future of disposal that, you know, it's important to consider the, you know, 30,000 foot view of what the
1:43:06 You know, what the entire waste needs of the community are, which includes sludge. It's not just about garbage or recycling or construction and demolition waste. You know, the Water District at this point has determined this is the least expensive option for them to process their waste. And so, you know, that operation benefits the town, I think, in a pretty significant fashion at this time.
1:43:29 Collect, store, and process wood waste and organics. You can see basically about four acres. They're all in piles, but we do quite a bit of diversion in wood waste and organics at the site. These various activities, household hazardous waste, waste tires, televisions, e-waste, appliances, metal, all happens in the site of approximately three acres. We also collect and recycle auto bodies, boats, trailers, mobile homes, kinds of things like that.
1:43:54 About an acre we used for that. Total on the site, about 12 acres actively being used for these various activities. Another thing I wanted to just describe is, you know, parcel fees. You know, a lot of people in town and people throughout the county are going to ask, you know, what does my parcel fee really give me? What does this do for me? And ultimately, you know, one thing is that it gives you the right to utilize the landfill for discounted disposal of items such as furniture, appliances, tires, electronics, and televisions.
1:44:22 I just want to clarify, you know, when I say discounted, I'm not saying that, you know, there's a, if they're dropped off at Mammoth Disposal, you have to pay a little bit more for these particular items. And, of course, they have to then take the materials and drive them out to the landfill for disposal or to do what they're going to do with them. So it's understandable charge for convenience. But if you don't need the convenience and you want to take things out there and save yourself some money, you have those options. Similar to the transfer stations in the outlying part of the county, which now pay $20 more per ton.
1:44:52 To dispose of their waste than Benton Crossing landfill charges. You get free household hazardous waste disposal at either Mammoth disposal or at the landfill. The county effectively manages and pays for that program. You also get support for local programs, wood waivers, town cleanup, support for the cast off, location for cost effective processing of MCWD sludge, which I mentioned.
1:45:19 C&D diversion activities, location close to the town where all-town garbage can be landfilled in an environmentally appropriate manner, and also a location where large volumes of waste that exceed the transfer station limits can be disposed, including items such as cars and trailers. And ultimately, you're contributing to the funding required for the closure of the site and post-closure monitoring and maintenance.
1:45:45 As far as future partnership options, you know, something else that got mentioned as far as what CalRecycle was requesting of the town, you know, of course, we're interested in providing C&D diversion activities if the town wants us to do that. Also, I thought I would mention events. Peter mentioned events. We applied for a grant and actually got a letter of support from Johnny when he was here that would...
1:46:10 Fund the purchase of basically an event recycling kit that is meant to be loaned out to events in all parts of the region, actually. We also had support from Ennio County on that grant. So I think if it is funded, we're going to know in January or February, that might be an opportunity to partnership, at least to provide your event managers with the infrastructure necessary to implement a recycling program.
1:46:36 First thing on there, long-term parcel fee agreement through post-closure period of benton crossing landfill. As we mentioned before, we're interested in maintaining funding so we can close this site accordingly. We think there's opportunities to look to the solid waste parcel fee to modify it and provide stable funding for state-mandated diversion infrastructure and programs. You know, one of the problems that a lot of waste managers have gone through in the last five years is watching their funding dry up.
1:47:04 Amidst this drop in revenues related to the drop in waste and tonnage. And so there's this real push right now to try and stabilize those fees wherever possible. And of course the parcel fees are one of the most stable sources of revenue that you can get. Use revenues from the parcel fee and gate fees to plan and develop a regional recycling center and long haul transfer station to replacement and crossing landfill. And this is just something that has been talked about. It's something that the HDR report contemplated, although it didn't really get into recycling, it did contemplate.
1:47:34 Regional Long Haul Transfer Station. And, you know, that's something that the parcel fees we believe could be used for in the future. So, that's basically all I have. Questions? Questions? Thank you, Tony. Tony, real quick, thank you, first of all. What, isn't the Benton Crossing landfill set to close within 10 years by LADWP? Um,
1:48:05 Yeah, they've said that they want the landfill to close in 2023. We've initiated discussions with them at this point to inquire, you know, what about these non-disposal activities, meaning C&D diversion, for example, stockpiling, wood waste, grinding wood waste, you know, different types of recycling activities, HHW, all of these things. We've initiated discussions with them, but at this point, you know, we have not come to any kind of agreement, but it would be in our interest to
1:48:33 To secure a long-term lease for those kinds of activities, if available, so we could continue to provide them at the site, even post-closure, you know, post-closure of the actual disposal operations. Okay. What is the distance of the Benton Landfill to the airport in mileage? I'm not exactly sure, but I'm pretty sure it's less than five miles. And I'm not sure you're asking that because of this FAA circular? Yeah.
1:49:02 You know, it's interesting. Some of the comments that are being made about that, it's a little unclear to me, honestly, because I read it, and clearly landfill operations are prohibited within five miles of the airport, but there's a pretty lengthy description of types of operations related to disposal or waste processing that are actually allowed, permitted.
1:49:23 You know, transfer stations, different types of processing facilities, so long as they meet certain criteria, you know, as they need to be fully enclosed, things like that. Because the reason of having... As a wildlife attractant, as an attractant to birds primarily, I think is the reason. So yeah, does Benton Crossing fall within the five mile radius, I believe it does, but existing landfills are exempted from those requirements anyways. Okay.
1:49:51 Speaking of the birds, we just had the recent listing of the sage-grouse and the intent is to not have the birds in a landfill area because then they would prey on the sage-grouse allegedly. Has the county had communication with anyone on that at this point?
1:50:20 Well, yeah, I mean, we have, I've participated in some meetings, you know, about the sage grouse, discussed the issue with fish and wildlife representatives. You know, we have some mitigations in place at Bent Crossing Landfill right now that were part of the original approvals that did analyze and contemplate sage grouse and potential impacts to sage grouse. You know, it's safe to say that, you know, if we could, anything that we could do to somehow eliminate those impacts, we would be interested in, in,
1:50:49 Pursuing them. Unfortunately, there's not a whole lot in the toolbox, you know, to solve these problems at this time. What are they telling you at this point? Anything? As far as what? As far as the use of that particular location? Well, the continued use beyond 2023 or between now and now. Just as it relates to the recent listing of the sage-grouse? My understanding and my conversations with fish and wildlife is that there's nothing...
1:51:17 Nothing is going to happen with continued operations. If we were to want to seek an expansion of the landfill or an extension somehow of our permitted activities, then I think at that point we would have to face off with Fish and Wildlife and go through consultations and things like that. But yeah, they haven't said that they're going to come in and try and shut it down or anything to that effect, no. Okay. The reason I ask that is at this Mono Collaborative Planning
1:51:47 Team meeting. I got a different response from Fish and Wildlife and they said that that was the single largest concern of theirs as it related to sage grouse in the area and Joe, you would know this, sage grouse have leks and it's not like they go from point A to point S and move their lek, their historic areas and
1:52:16 They mentioned that as being their number one concern was the location of the landfill as it related to the lex that they've identified for the sage grouse. So I appreciate your response, but from someone else I got it from Fish and Wildlife Service I got a different opinion on it. And were they suggesting that
1:52:40 They were going to move to try and close the landfill? They just said that that was their single largest concern for the impact. I agree and recognize that they have stated that the landfill is the primary threat as far as they see it to the Long Valley, South Mono Population Management Unit. I understand that. So I'm pointing that out because it seems reasonable that if they want to address
1:53:11 The problems that they have been sued on as it relates to the sage grouse, they would want to show good faith effort in addressing what would be their number one concern. They don't have a plan today, but I'm just saying that because it's reasonable to think at some point they would put pressure on that. Yeah, and I think that we certainly are willing to work with Fish and Wildlife to implement any kind of mitigations that
1:53:41 That they want to try out and try and put in place out there. And just to confirm on a different item, it's fair to say that Mono County today already ships roughly 20% of their solid waste out of state? 20% of the total unincorporated Mono County waste. Yes. It might be a little closer to 30% actually. Okay. Yeah. Yeah, and just, you know, for the,
1:54:19 For the record on that, the Mono County waste that gets shipped out of the state, the operators that do that do have to pay the county an exported waste fee, which is equivalent to our tipping fees, so there is not, so we can maintain some kind of equitability and funding for the program, you know, for the entire program. Great. So it's not done just at a total cost savings to the people up in the north part of the county. Great. Thank you. You're welcome. Thank you.
1:54:48 Other questions? If not. Other members? I'd like to speak. Good evening. I'm the mayor of the council. I'm just actually here to answer any questions you have on it. I think most of you know me, Pat Fenton. I was the former manager of Mammoth Disposal in Bishop Place. Some of you didn't know that. And my replacement, Greg Felsen from...
1:55:23 But I'm sure there's still questions. I've talked to many of you. You've visited with me. I've given you briefings on what we suggest as the exclusive franchise holder in this town. I realize it's difficult for the county. You know, some of this stuff between the birds and the FAA thing. But, you know, this is a safety and health issue, this whole waste thing. So when I come to you and tell you this stuff, it's not we're trying to make things difficult for the county because we're not.
1:55:53 But you need a 15-year plan for your solid waste. You don't have one. In 2023, you've got less than 10 years. We were trying to sit you up with one for a long term, even though it's out of county. To me, it's the best thing possible for the town of Mammoth Lakes, 25 to 30-year deal where you would have a much lower tipping fee and it would be like a CPI-type program.
1:56:21 Also building the MERV because the diversion thing hasn't gotten better. You heard the briefings, HDR. We're not getting any better. We're still the same way we were five years ago. So do you have any questions? Councilman Eastman, did you have something? I did. You mentioned that the town of Mammoth Lakes needs a 15-year plan for our disposal. Does that come from CalRecycle? No, that comes from your town senior engineer.
1:56:52 Can you clarify? It's a state requirement that the city municipalities agencies need to have at least a 15-year plan. Okay. The town manager was suggesting we should have a 20-year horizon. Okay. But in our options, you're suggesting 20? Correct. There's been some discussion earlier, not this evening, but previously, with the use of the term MRF.
1:57:21 Is that what we're really looking at, or is that the proper description? You know, there's different names, but I think, you know, a town recycle center, maybe, you know, materials recovery facility got a lot of people worked up that it could refer to different things. We're trying to recycle, and at the same time, we get to solve the solid waste problem. I mean, the town of Mammoth, we need to have a plan, in my opinion, 20 years minimum. Where are we going to be sending our trash?
1:57:49 Do you really want to be addressing this in a couple of years? We have the opportunity now to send it to a location where we could get what I consider a very reasonable tip fee because there's a need for them. If not, do you want to be sitting at a table five years from now trying to negotiate a fee that could be doubled because supply and demand just got turned upside down? I mean, that's a real deal because you only really have two opportunities.
1:58:18 Inyo and Lockwood. Unless something could be worked out with Mono. But my job is to get for the town of Mammoth Lakes a cheaper tip fee. And we would be able to negotiate that for a long-term agreement. 25 to 30 years. Peter and Dan, correct me if I'm wrong, but I think all we're looking tonight is to take the next step.
1:58:42 By the questions I'm asking, I'm afraid I'm getting into a little more detail than is necessary this evening, and I apologize for that. There are more curiosity questions. But one thing I want to point out, too, a couple of council members have seen, is the current facility we have is in bad shape. It was in 2009, back in the last contract. You know, it's in dire straight of repairs, and we're actually bailing the cardboard.
1:59:09 Up in Sam Walker's garage site that we're going to lose in six years. And the bailer is just about out of gas, if you want to put it that way. So that's a real problem, because if we can't use that bailer, and that site's going to go away, Sam's going to have it, or he wants some huge amount of money, we can't use that as a MRF, so we're actually taking, with a big yellow loader, we're taking that stuff up the street and bailing it in the garage with drivers who just get off driving all day.
1:59:39 So that's a situation we're in. I don't think we want to stay in that situation until 2019. It's a safety issue to me, big time. Thank you. Joe, did you have another question of staff? Yes, I did of staff after Pat's done. Any other questions of Pat first? Okay, thank you. Peter, in option number one, essentially we'd be moving forward to evaluate sites.
2:00:09 And I noticed that you said including improvements in impacts to disposal rates, but then I – but what other things – I mean, I'm presuming land ownership might be an option. Obviously environmental impacts are an option. So when it comes back to us, will you have – will it be laid out like a matrix of what you considered in evaluating each of the sites? Correct. So it'll look at the size of land, you know, the acreage you might need to do –
2:00:36 Recycling, currently we've got an operation that works and that's working. But long term we want to make sure that whatever the facility is that we build or the ratepayers are paying for will accommodate a 20 year plan so that in 10 years we don't need expansion. So from that, basically I'll use the build out model and we have to build parcels in town. We've got pretty much a fixed land base to
2:01:04 Understand the capacity we need, the area we need, and bring that back to Council with some options. Okay, and then in number six, when you're talking about other stakeholders, it sounds like from what John has said and what Tony mentioned is that Fish and Wildlife will be one of the other stakeholders. Correct. I'll add that to the list. Lisa, comment? Thank you. Good evening. I'm going to apologize ahead of time.
2:01:41 Just come back in from out of town for this meeting, and I'm not going to sneeze on the microphone, but I hope nobody goes after me, or you have some disinfectant if you do. However, this was too important to not attend in person. I'm Lisa Isaacs. I am one of the people with maybe the dubious distinctions of being mentioned at least twice in your agenda packet items.
2:02:09 As far as my involvement with the town solid waste planning and source reduction, I have been on the town county solid waste task force since 2000, but prior to that I was involved in many recycling efforts and development efforts before coming to Mammoth, including setting up recycling programs for Atlanta Olympics. What I wanted to do briefly, as briefly as possible, excuse me,
2:02:37 And I'm going to first thank you for listening ahead of time. But as briefly as possible, I wanted to run through Peter Bernasconi's packet of information, and you've done a wonderful job with compiling something that just got handed to you. I understand this isn't your field of expertise or past experience. First, Pat, the...
2:03:03 Prior Manager for Waste Connections, Mr. Fenton, just mentioned safety issues. And I just wanted to ask you if any of you are paying attention to the current news stories as far as the recycling facility that was burning last night, probably as it still is today in the industrial area of Redwood City, creating quite a bit of air quality hazard for the citizens of Redwood City.
2:03:33 Two weeks, a week and a half ago, there was, for a couple days in a row, a running news story about another recycling facility, Recology, burning by Candlestick Park in the Bay Area, also presenting quite some significant air quality hazards, as well as Highway 101 had some visibility hazards as far as driving along Highway 101. And within the last year, the current facility that's on fire
2:04:03 Earned within the last year as well. So I just wanted to bring that up as far as safety issues of recycling facilities. They don't, they're not foolproof. These things come with some very inherent hazards. I'm going to take you straight into your agenda packet and I would just like to point out, I'm going to follow for
2:04:26 Just for organization's sake so you can follow me easy. I'm going to run through the packet and just briefly point out on different pages my questions. Could you, would you mind, I have to grab a water because my, I have to cough. Will you excuse me for one minute if you want to mind? I'm just going to, thank you, Chief. Okay, I'll start with on page one.
2:04:50 I'm going to go to the third bullet point down. Develop programs to maximize recycling, require effective and efficient recycling programs. What I wanted to point out here was in the world of source reduction, recycling, reuse, diversion, you don't start with recycling. You always start with reduce and reuse. That is the manner in which you approach these diversion programs. And I haven't seen anywhere in this packet, well,
2:05:30 Possibly I missed it in some of the addendums, but I haven't seen anywhere in the packet reduce or reuse, even in your educational outreach discussions. Those are big areas right there. That's your low-hanging fruit before you get into recycling, which takes a lot of energy. My next question on the background regarding your October 16, 2013 meeting, staff provided council information. I am very concerned while this town has
2:05:59 Some very qualified staff and some extremely hardworking staff. I know you don't have anyone on staff right now that has a background or experience, knowledge or education in the source reduction field, recycling, reduction, reuse. So whenever I hear, but I believe the town manager may have a bit of experience coming in here, and I don't understand the full extent of your experience yet, but I've heard that secondhand. But I do want to point that out. Whenever I see staff in this agenda packet,
2:06:29 I'm concerned that staff is coming at this, especially when we're looking at historical staff because nobody's been in place for quite a few years that had this background. So I'm very concerned that this is coming from a lack of knowledge. I'm going to go down to the town has been working on increasing solid waste diversion for many years, beginning at the September 7, 2005 meeting. I have stood before this council, two of which are still here, starting in 98 or 99 on this matter. So this goes way back.
2:07:01 And talking about this has been going on for a long time. The final committee report, bottom of page 2, dated March 3rd, is attached for information. I'm really concerned about most of the information that's attached is all old information, previous, prior to AB, the most recent, AB 341, thank you, starting in 2011, implemented in 2012. All of this...
2:07:29 Most of this information, other than the town attorney's review and recommendations, everything happened before AB 341, so I've got to discount it because it doesn't take that into account. My next point, going on to page two, waste connections, the primary deal points in this letter to waste connections, dated March 27, 2009, note that
2:07:55 It was amended effective January 1, 2010, expires December 31, 2014. The letter that was attached is actually expires June 30, 2014. It wasn't – these dates didn't – did not align. So I had a question if that was what you referred to available at the town offices and you just chose not to attach that that correlated – those dates correlated with the –
2:08:24 Am I allowed to ask questions specific so I have an understanding since I'm involved in this? Well, I think one of the things I think is important, there are two things I want to state. Thank you. You've been at it for ten minutes, we have a five minute limit, and I don't want to cut you off. You've got some expertise in this area, your input is valuable, but I understand what the agenda bill is, which is to begin a process. The other thing that occurs to me in your critique of the agenda bill is that this is background information.
2:08:52 And, you know, it's history, it's historical, and it's presented for our review, but that's the context within which it is presented. So I'm certainly, you know, I could take any agenda bill apart, or all of them, if I wanted to. And to the extent that it's going to be helpful and productive as we go forward, and specifically as it relates to what is being proposed in Option 1, the six sub-points,
2:09:20 I'm certainly willing to hear it, but we put in place a rule of five minutes for a reason. I don't want to cut you off. You've got expertise. But I want to have you be mindful of the fact that this isn't the night, in my view, to critique or to criticize the town staff report publicly unless it's going to have some productive impact or...
2:09:46 I'm sorry. My understanding was that Council goes forward with making decisions on all of your actions following the agenda packet items. There are a lot of things that are missing from the agenda, so in my critique, I'm not meaning to critique it. I mean to provide more information that may not be there to allow you to provide the bigger picture in your...
2:10:14 Decision, such as the FFA Circular, there have been at least two facilities built adjacent to airports. Understood, but understand my point, which is, and because it's going to be a point where I exercise the discretion that I have to stop you, what's before us today, unless this council thinks otherwise,
2:10:41 is a request that we approve a process that is going to go forward to examine literally all of the things that I'm sure are important to you and relevant, including, for example, the location of the landfill to the airport, the FAA circular, the implications of that, the requirements that we are going to have to comply with. I don't know all those things, but as I read this thing, as I read the
2:11:10 The thing in preparation for this meeting, this is simply a motion, if you will, for us to go forward. And certainly there's going to be an opportunity, I hope and expect, for you to have specific involvement in that which ultimately is presented to us. But I don't see the decision tonight to be anything other than that which, other than authorizing moving forward to...
2:11:35 Bring us something that we can then make a decision. Will you be voting on any of these options tonight? We're going to vote on what's presented to us, yes. So anything I might have to say to fill in the rest of the picture?
2:11:49 Does it have relevance to your decision-making process? Well, I don't know, Lisa, but frankly, it's not particularly helpful to me to have you suggest that what's wrong with the agenda bill is that there's a date that should have been June 30th instead of December 31st. I'm trying to move this thing forward. And as I look at the six items, this is simply in each instance a suggestion that we authorize this town in
2:12:17 That our staff and in whatever way they deem appropriate, certainly because they've got expertise well beyond mine, to move forward with an analysis of the various things that are set forth in the six points. Will you allow me to go straight to your option analysis? Certainly. Okay. I'm going to go straight there. And I do want to point out that in each analysis or option,
2:12:44 The direct staff, direct staff, direct staff, and all first of the six, all six. Again, I want to point out that I really would hope that the town relies on staff with very in-depth experience and knowledge in this field when you're directing staff. And I know you don't have a code compliance officer in place yet. I know you don't have a recycling coordinator in place.
2:13:12 I know that other people have picked this up, added it to their already existing workplace. So I have to say that of the first six. I'm looking at number three, though. And the town attorney's done a wonderful job in analyzing AB 341. And regarding this effort, we'll include public involvement through the Planning and Economic Development Commission. Again, public, they don't have anyone on that commission that has any in-depth experience.
2:13:41 Maybe you don't think that waste reduction is deserving of someone other than the project proponent who stands to financially benefit from this. You don't think that we need to bring more expertise into this discussion. I want to suggest an option three. Option two is interesting too. Out of your six, the first six, three is...
2:14:05 I understand Paul Rudder also suggested the public involvement through, but he said an actual public group, not the Planning and Economic Development Commission. I want to suggest an option three, hire or contract with experienced staff or consultants to provide objective guidance. Objective, I'd like to really stress objective.
2:14:31 And not someone who stands to financially benefit from you following their guidance. And number four for consideration is work with the county to conduct, to go back to a feasibility analysis for regional solid waste diversion in which you get a lot of input from experienced knowledgeable people in this field other than
2:15:00 Other than the historic, we have a lot of balls and there's so many variables that affect this. And Tony's future partnership options, that to me went straight to a feasibility analysis, but that's just my view. Is that on number four? I'm sorry to interrupt. That was my number four option suggested. And my last thought was I heard in the Whistler presentation
2:15:28 That you did mention you saw a lot of trash, and I expect you saw a lot of waste diversion, because I've been to Whistler and studied their waste diversion programs a few times. I was sorry we didn't hear about that in that presentation, but your direct quote was, Whistler was constantly thinking about ways to improve what they already have, and I really hope we move toward that direction, and I also heard good faith efforts tonight.
2:15:56 There's a lot of things we can do for CalRecycle that go a long way in good faith efforts other than building a multi-million dollar facility for the contractors. There's a lot of things we could do such as hiring a recycling coordinator or having a code compliance officer in place or really emphasizing commercial recycling. I drove through all four gas stations tonight, not a single one.
2:16:25 Has a recycling program that touches the actual customer, yet CalRecycle has verbiage and has even given out grants in that field. So I'll just conclude there because there's a lot more I could go into, but I know you don't want me to. Well, I want you to, within the appropriate forum, and I appreciate that which you bring to the table. Can I, any direct questions I could answer? Questions of these? And I have to.
2:16:56 I wonder if I had said I would be here ahead of time if I would have had been able to give a presentation if I had followed the proper process, such as Tony's presentation? Well, presentations are at the pleasure of the council and staff, and so I'm not prepared to answer that tonight. Okay. It didn't happen in that manner, but my expectation is that you're going to remain very closely, intimately involved in this process.
2:17:25 Your view and input is going to be as important as far as more than others. And I'm always available for my conversation, given that my conversation only or my experience only comes from my view and my experience. But I have had a lot of years in this field, so I'm always available for any offline conversations, as I've had with all of you. Thank you very much. Thanks, Lisa.
2:17:55 All right. Other members of the public who wish to speak? Mayor and council members, again, my name's Rick Voll, Mammoth Disposal, the new manager, recently moved here from Coyac. I'm new to the community here. I'm sorry. What's your last name again? Voll, V-A-H-L. Thank you. And I think after reading this report,
2:18:18 Peter did a great job. I mean, for a new guy stepping into this community to understand the history that is involved as well, I appreciate what Tony had provided from the Mono County perspective. Helps me get some of that background and knowledge. And the community I had come from, we understood that transportation costs really caused a lot of hurdles in the way we performed our waste and recycling programs.
2:18:46 And so in Kodiak Island, where an hour flight to Anchorage or a 10 hour ferry to Homer, which was considered our mainland, we had lots of obstacles and hurdles. CalRecycle, what they're trying to do is encourage us to do three things. And I think it's outlined in here, develop quality programs, require programs of the community, and then provide the resources so that follow through. Because when we live in a small town, we need to look at sustainability.
2:19:15 And, sure, recycling. Lisa mentioned reduce and reuse. I think those can be just as complicated. And we do have thrift shops that provide those naturally in our community. And I've seen them at transfer stations where there are drop sites. And the public can come and go. Those can be more complicated because they're not manned. And a lot of stuff is just garbage.
2:19:38 So I think we're looking at a lot of improvements for Mammoth here short-term and long-term. So when we start to plan here for the short-term solution and working with Sierra Conservation on opportunities, we also look at the big picture. Because if we're talking about a multi-million dollar facility, how does that roll into the small step-by-steps we're looking at today? And how does that impact our multi-family homes, condominiums, our construction projects?
2:20:07 And also our large events and venues. So how can we reach that public in a reasonable manner, be sustainable long term, 15, 20, and hopefully until my child's grown. So we're talking even further than that. I appreciate your time, and I look forward to working with the town. Thank you, and welcome to the banana belt. Other members of the public or the audience wish to speak.
2:20:38 If not, let's see if we have some council discussion first. Any comments? I have some comments and questions, and some I've gotten from the public contractors. I think if we decide to move forward with evaluating sites and a program, just some questions I'd like to try to get answers to if we can. I think we've churned a lot of them before. You know, we talk about
2:21:08 If we have a site in town or wherever it may be, one, I like to start getting a grasp of what a franchise agreement looks like. You know, we talk about how we're going to save money here or there. I have no idea what that agreement would look like or how much money the town would get back or have to cough up or whatever. So I'd like to see a little bit of an income versus cost analysis on having some of these programs in place.
2:21:37 Consideration people have brought up about competition. We've historically had just one group providing these services, and typically when you have one entity, it doesn't usually fare well for the community unless we have a very tight franchise agreement and something that's agreeable. And speaking with some of the contractors, I know a concern was if we do have, let's say, a MRF in town,
2:22:05 If our fees end up going up, some of the contractors have told me they don't care, they're going to take it to Bishop anyway because it's just going to be cheaper to go down there. So it all comes down to the bottom line. So I'm curious to know what it looks like if we go that direction. How will that compare to a cost of maybe driving it elsewhere so we don't end up building a facility that doesn't really get used to its full potential? Let's see.
2:22:36 And I know there's been discussion too about this being strictly for construction materials, but there's a fear out there that it'll grow beyond construction materials and start turning into a trash facility. And I'm wondering what sort of contract or guarantee we have that it will be that, or if it does change, what's the plan? And then some of these other discussions, when we started off a couple of years ago talking about it, I think there was...
2:23:04 We know what that's all about.
2:23:30 And then I think Lisa brought it up. You know, as we analyze sites, as it says here in item number one, I am just interested to look at the cost analysis of some of the sites in cooperation with the county of whether it's, you know, whether it's here in town or somewhere else, what are the pros and cons of it so we really understand it. Those are just some of my concerns with things I'd like to see at the very least analyze if we go through the
2:23:56 If we end up deciding with option one, if we could include some of those items, I'd appreciate it. That's all. Thank you, Matthew. Comments or questions or discussion? For myself, I mean, we've had a few of these conversations already, and I mean, I've heard things Matthew's mentioned, and I think, as Rick mentioned, I think,
2:24:23 A lot of those issues will be addressed in this, right? Because what we're going over tonight is exactly that. I mean, we're not going to decide on anything tonight. We're really deciding on, you know, to go through the evaluate and evaluate and go through all these points. I think a couple of the points that Lisa did make, I would like to see however worded or whatever you want to say added to this as part of it because I think a few of her
2:24:52 Points are very valid, and I'm just not sure how we go about, you know, putting that in the option one. But from what I understand is that it's a lengthy process for us to go through all this before we're going to come to any conclusion and decision. I'm thinking that certain things would run parallel, like the ordinance changes that we know are already in effect. Those are one piece, yes, at the same time you start studying and looking at all the aspects.
2:25:21 Doing a complete analysis and evaluating sites, that's a longer process, but I'm presuming they run parallel. Just to follow up on what Rick said is that, you know, I've been pushing us to move forward on this because I don't think we're ready for reinvestment and ready for development unless we've got our solid waste problems figured out. And that's going to hit us sooner rather than later. I think that each of these is just
2:25:47 Next steps, telling staffs, you know, these are all the areas we think have to be considered. So from my perspective, I would say I think we've got enough information here. I wouldn't want to start wordsmithing the staff thing because in each area it's like complete an analysis or work with or so on and so forth. So to me, it's got enough for us to say, yes, we want to go in this area and let's go. Let's start working on this instead of just passing along as we have for, well, at least the five years I've been on council.
2:26:21 Well, I think what Michael's getting at is, you know, I think kind of what I was seeing too is if we do the analysis, could we include certain items in the analysis? Yeah, no, and I think there's many, there's probably a huge list of items that have to be considered. Right. But I don't think it's necessary to list them all here. Right. No, I agree with that. John? I'm prepared to move forward and give staff direction. I'm going to make just a couple of comments.
2:26:51 The five questions, Matthew, that you asked are appropriate, and I'm sure that the minutes will reflect that they've been asked and ought to be considered. Michael, the stuff that you mentioned, including the points that you consider valid that Lisa has made that need to be considered. The question that I have of staff, and I think this option does that. I mean, it's just a move forward option.
2:27:18 I don't see it as restrictive at all. The question I have though is this, and Lisa raised the point. My takeaway from her comments is that the staff and commission is inexperienced in this specific area. And so what I gather her concern is, at least as I hear it, is that an analysis is either going to not be complete.
2:27:41 Or is not going to be thorough enough or is not going to understand really what it is that they're analyzing if there's no expertise and experience. And I'd like you to address that. And then the other is I saw a request for a feasibility analysis. That suggests to me a study that is going to be conducted by a consultant. I also see a direct request to number three for a consultant. Where do consultants fit into this, if at all?
2:28:09 And it's really a sub-part of the first question, and that is, in the event that we don't have the requisite experience and expertise, do we need to engage consultants? And would a report come back suggesting that we do that and that we fund it? Or how would you envision that piece of it? Well, let's start with the municipal code. So town attorney has substantial experience in formulating these types of municipal code changes.
2:28:40 When we do municipal code updates, typically we go through the planning commission because they need to make findings and then it comes to the council for adoption. So, you know, previously there has been some discussions about some of these code changes. I did see Johnny's notes regarding those in the discussions they had that the people that were in the subcommittee really weren't interested in having code compliance related to municipal code.
2:29:10 I think that the town attorney can certainly provide the expertise for the language needed to make and keep CalRecycle happy and not have the town become a police force of recycle Gestapo. For what it's worth, I've been handling all the solid waste related legal issues for 30 cities for 8 years.
2:29:36 So that's pretty good. I can write some more. That's pretty good. Could you also clarify, we have a code compliance officer, right? He just started. Yeah. The effective, we're working on this. We've had a temp and then we're going to have the permanent one shortly. It'll be in this month, the first part of January, we'll have a mark full time. The other, I think, related to the staff support there,
2:30:03 As Lisa mentioned, I've worked on a number of these different projects as well and some of the code updates that Andy's referencing. It's not new territory, if you will, for California cities in general. There's a lot of information out there. I think if we come back to a point where we need that expert help, I've got no problem coming and asking you to approve that or to go to bring somebody in where we need them. As we start to walk through it, I think that those areas where that may be necessary will pop up.
2:30:31 Site evaluation, that may or may not require that. I couldn't tell you that tonight. You go through the siting process, it's pretty straightforward. There are different firms out there that do a lot of this type of work if need be. But I think the current staff level, we can get through the direction here. And if we do have a problem area, an area where we really need that outside expertise, we would be glad to bring that forward and say, here, we need help. I think we have a lot of, between the different resources we have access to, including the county.
2:31:02 Staff, our staff, our city attorney staff, you've got a pretty good, I think, overview group that can really get you, I think, where you need to be, and if we need particular skill sets, then we would go get those. Thank you for that explanation. The other thing, you know, the project actually hasn't been defined yet so that we can do CEQA, so once we've actually defined that, then that's when CEQA would be completed.
2:31:33 We would likely hire a consultant to assist with the CEQA evaluation. All right. Other discussion for council member? Questions? Staff? John, you suggested you're ready to move forward with a direction. Do you want to make a motion? I would be happy to, Mr. Mayor. I would move that the council adopt and move forward with option number one as presented. Second. Okay. There's been a motion and a second. No.
2:32:06 Further discussion, we'll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes. 5-0. That takes us to the end of our agenda tonight, and we will adjourn to the next regular meeting to be held on Wednesday, January 15, 2014, at 6 o'clock. Yes.