Trails Committee
· recording 2 hr 54 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
368 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Here. Here. Since Bill Souser is walking in the door here momentarily, are there any public comments? There he is. We'll consider him here. Comments from the audience. Now is the time to come forward for any item that is not.
5:35 Regularly scheduled on the agenda. Hi. Hi. Laura Beardsley, I'm friends of the Inyo. I just wanted to give you an update on the Nordic grooming program. We are ready. As soon as it snows, we're ready to go. We actually, just this last week, did some trail work and some minor realignment of the trail so that when we do get snow, we won't need as much.
6:03 To groom and hopefully we've aligned it in a way that it'll stay put longer so there's a little less sun affected and a little less melt out. So I know we've all got our fingers crossed but keep on doing that snow dance. The other thing I wanted to just check in on, you know it's the beginning of 2014. Happy New Year everybody.
6:30 And we're getting ready to put together our summer schedule. And I am curious as to when we might be able to submit a proposal for a contract renewal for the trail stewardship programs for the summer 2014. Okay. That's it. Actually, I think that's something that we're going to be at least starting to recognize today. Isn't that right? It's on the massive track. Oh, great.
7:00 Discussions available? Perfect. Thanks. Perfect. Stick around. Okay. Any other public comments? Hi. Good afternoon. My name is John Wentworth. Hi, everybody. Hi, John. So there's a couple things I'm looking forward to you've got in the agenda to speak to, but a couple things to follow up with. There's a whole list of things that we don't need to get into right now. I'm wondering, first, the very interesting discussion about the OSV and...
7:33 The partnered stuff and the sort of complex environmental things that are going on. Has the town or the committee sent any kind of a letter to Mono County as an outreach to start getting a kind of a partnership together to start working on that? At the last meeting, I believe, we were talking about the OSV, kind of the threats to the OSV program coming from this environmental litigation and the need to maybe do a travel management process again or something having to do with all that. And there was some discussion in the committee about
8:04 Reaching out to Monroe County and trying to get kind of a seeing if there's a common cause could be put together to move forward and I'm just wondering if anybody's followed up on that if that's happening. I think I can address it. I reached out to Monroe County to see if they could send somebody to be in this at this meeting. Okay. Unfortunately, they have conflicts but they said that they would be sending a representative to our next month's meeting. Okay, great. Good. Hopefully they'll attend. Good, yeah, just follow up on that. And they'll also be giving follow-ups on whether the trail planning happens.
8:32 Okay, great. And I was also going to reach out on a more informal basis, but I just haven't done that yet. Yeah. I mean, that's something that I know I was talking about at the last meeting. I was just thinking about it because the website stuff we just finished, I mean, a lot of these OSV trails are way, they're beyond the scope of the trail system. They're way out in the county, and I think this is a...
8:50 Really important effort we looked at recently. A couple other things just to check on real quick is the standards manual. I'm just wondering where we're at with moving that standards manual forward. We delivered that to the town well over a year and a half ago, I think. On my way in, I drove by, you know, there's a bollard sitting out there. It's got the old town of Mammoth Lakes logo on it still. I think that moving the standards manual forward and getting it adopted is important for a variety of different reasons.
9:17 One of them, when you talk about the Shady Rest staging area this afternoon, that's part of it, but I'm just wondering what happened to that. It was done at the specific direction of the staff. I heard it was supposed to be here in the fall. I heard it was supposed to be here today. You haven't seen it. It's an important tool for the kind of work you guys are doing. Just hope to see that moving forward. The other thing... I can comment a little bit on that. I know that I did a review of it.
9:41 About three to four months ago, I would say, just pretty much, in other words, of the draft, and, you know, standards manual, that was chapter six, I think you're referring to, it's a very big standards manual, it's public works standards manual, chapter six, you know, when they move the whole thing forward, they'll move it forward, but I don't think that keeps them from using it, but, you know, they're short of staff right now, so that's probably part of it. I just raised a question, I mean, our last understanding was, it was, it did,
10:09 Not need to come forward as part of an update of the entire standards manual. It will come forward just as number 600, and I just, I bring it to your attention. I think it's a useful thing to have. It's there, and they're probably using it, but, you know, again, as I say. I'm just looking at what I'm seeing on the ground. I'm not seeing it being used, and I think, you know, we don't need to get into that, but I think there are several things that are in that manual that are very important to a lot of efforts. It'd be great to have it brought forward, you know, get it adopted so everybody knows we're on the same page with that.
10:38 Finally, we don't have to get into it today, but I'm really anxious and looking forward to seeing your work on the Sherwin stuff. And at the last meeting, there was some representation that there will be an update today on that. I don't see it on the agenda, but whenever you guys are ready, it would be great to see that. That's it. Thank you. John, thank you. Okay, any other public comments? Seeing none. Steve? Okay, in the presentation, I have a couple of things in your packet. You should have color 173.
11:16 So I'm happy to report that this was done over the weekend and this morning I took some time out and put on my, what I refer to as a dumb guy hat, which is sometimes not too hard to do. But getting aside, went to the website, plowed through it as if I were trying to plan a trip for my family or friends and pretty well
11:45 I'd say I'm pretty happy with the progress that we made, the new pages, the photographs, the descriptions, the linkages to activities and other trails that are related. I think it's a great continuation of our website, the excitement that it can lead. When you look at these listings, you'll notice that some of the trails are listed in green.
12:15 That represents that those trails or a portion of those trails are within the wilderness. And then in the next column over, you'll notice post-published steps. Some of them are in a brownish-red color, saying the paint and inventory do not publish. Those are particular trails that both begin and stop within the wilderness and do the forest service policy on wilderness policy.
12:44 We felt it best not to publish those, but we're holding them in the inventory so they will not be destroyed but could be used possibly at a later date. There are other trails that you'll recognize in here that are in green, but those trails start outside the wilderness. So the trailhead may well be in Red's Meadow somewhere down in the monument, and then it leads into the wilderness.
13:08 And John Kazmierski, of course, is here from the Forest Service to help explain further any questions you may have about the wilderness attributes to these trails. As you go further on, you'll notice that there are destination pages. Steve, could you stop right there on the first one? I think we're missing. I see that on yours, there's a blue that we don't have. Yeah, that's inconsequential to you.
13:35 It's just for us to monitor if it's published ready or not. Okay. You're talking about the purple? Blue or? Blue or purple or whatever. The intent of providing information to you, you basically just needed these two major columns and this other stuff to the right was more housekeeping. Does the post-published steps, does this mean that it has been published or it hasn't been published or this is what happens once you do publish it? Yeah, it hasn't.
14:03 All the pages that are going to be posted except for Winter Grooming and Shady Rest, which is a separate contract, all those have been posted. They're there today. So you can go and look at it. And the ones in red that say in inventory, those will not be published at this time. Okay, so post-published means it is published now. Correct. Okay.
14:28 Steve, then I'll ask a question real quick, just because I can. The lines that have the brown retain in inventory and do not publish, so they've been built, but they may never ever get published? Is that accurate? Drafts have been constructed, but not finalized, so they're held in inventory, and depending on the...
14:55 Wilderness Protocol and Procedures from the Forest Service, they may or may not be printed up or published in the future onto the website. Okay. Can I ask why they were done then if they may not be published? So this is a little bit of a learning process for all of us, and I was absent in my detail when the list came to the Forest Service as far as which pages to move forward.
15:23 The contractor, MLTPA, and Steve, and I don't know who else was at a meeting, but reviewed a list of potential pages to put up, and the Forest Service did approve everything that's on this list. Well, when I got back into my role in review of the pages that were prepared for us, several of these, in my review, I realized were with trails that were
15:48 Fell entirely within the wilderness. They weren't trails that were portals to the wilderness. And I think we've been pretty consistent in the last several years in saying MLTS is a system in itself that leads to, you know, in many places, the National Forest Wilderness System. And once we're in the wilderness, the information that we're going to provide the public is going to be much more limited in scope and content.
16:14 And so Sarah Tomsky and Pat McGurvey were working on this, and they're very apologetic, as am I, that we wasted any time and resources because they didn't catch these in advance when that first screening took place. And so there was lost time and money, and we apologize for that. It was really just them not being familiar with the resource. Sarah was fully aware of the...
16:37 You know, our parameters that we have on what information we can provide once we're in the wilderness. Just the fact that she didn't understand the geographic context of some of these trails, that's why they fell through the cracks and we didn't catch them. So I'm very sorry and I think we're on a more firm understanding of what is allowed and what isn't. I thought that we kind of had that understanding in the past, but of course...
17:00 You know, we hadn't come to this situation specifically, so we all learned from it, and I think it's an opportunity to put this in our standard operating procedures, the protocol that manages the website to make sure that this doesn't happen in the future, but I don't really see any likelihood that things will change that will allow us to put this content up in the future, but I ask that we keep them on the shelf.
17:25 In case we think about it differently or perhaps, you know, as technology evolves in other forests, this issue gets taken up elsewhere, perhaps the regional office will change their mind and say, yeah, this is an okay level of information or we can do something with it in the future. So it may not be an entirely lost cause. There's a couple trails that I guess the one that comes to mind is the Mammoth Rim Trail that goes along the Mammoth Crest that I think we said to go ahead with at this point.
17:53 Did we? I can't remember at this point what we've decided to do. It really falls outside the protocol. You really should say no to it. But it's such a heavily used, we should not allow additional information to be on the web on it. But where's it? We're holding on it. We're holding on it. Yeah, I think I wanted to talk to Sarah and John a little bit more about that. My feelings on that is that's one of the more heavily used.
18:14 And probably one of the most beautiful hikes in the area. And perhaps we can provide some higher level of information on that that we wouldn't on other trails that are entirely within the wilderness. Okay. I think, too, from a contract town standpoint, we are very lucky that we have entered into a contract with the contractor to provide 112 pages.
18:43 As you can see here, we're being delivered 173. So there's been a great opportunity here to work with existing data, put things together, and yes, we have this little anomaly, but in no way has it affected the contract financially. So we're actually miles ahead and have a contractor to thank for putting in more pages at no cost to the town.
19:13 I have a question. What does total count mean? I'm just trying to figure out what all of these, you know, your columns mean. Sandy, I think you're picking a... I'd just like to know what it means. It's just a way of accounting for these, and I think if you just take the numbers, the town-approved numbers, and add them up, that's the easiest column to follow. The total count number is...
19:42 It's not alphabetical. Oh, it's just a number of, oh, it doesn't have anything to do with numbers of destinations or experience. Oh, okay, okay. Okay, no, no, that's fine. ATP, which is authorization to proceed, reference number, and then on the trails, for instance, first page, one through.
20:02 25, and then the MLTPA ones were the ones that were extra. Extra, okay, now it makes sense to me. I just, I couldn't figure out what that was. Okay, it was just your, yeah. It's okay, I got it now, got it. If we can, I just want to keep us moving along too, John. I have some questions from the Forest Service before we move on to John, if that's all right with you, sir. Thank you. The ones that are completely in wilderness,
20:29 The decision not to publish those on this is because this is a Mammoth Lakes Trail System website. If I had my own private website, I would be able to put those on there if I had an experience on one of them, would I not? Correct. This website is a partnership between the Town of Mammoth Lakes and the U.S. Forest Service. The information that's being conveyed to the public is information that the Forest Service, if this was entirely our website, that's how we're going to manage the content of this website, and we have policies.
20:59 That regard the information that we provide for the wilderness resources that limit how much information we provide. We want to make the wilderness a little bit more of a discovery type of experience. Of course, yeah, there are guidebooks that go into a level of detail telling you everything you could possibly want to know about every lake and trail and meadow in the two point whatever million acres we got back here.
21:26 For us, our responsibility is to try to make it a little bit more of a self-discovery experience. And we want to make sure people have the information they need to recreate safely, to get the proper permits, and to recreate responsibly. But we don't want to really be holding their hands and telling them what to expect once they cross that wilderness boundary. Okay, thank you. John, did you have a quick question specific to where we've gone so far? Well, yeah, I'd just like to give you an update. This has been a pretty big project.
21:58 We talked this morning. We've got a little handout for you. It might be helpful to give a little bit more background. I'll just take a couple minutes to get you guys up to speed. Okay. Are we considering this part of the presentation still just for agenda sake? That's correct. Okay. Yeah, this is the presentation on the website enhancement contract. So this is some more background information that will help you to understand the contract. So in all of this information, we're going to start working on our measure our performance report for this project. So we'll get you that. That will be...
22:41 Submit it to the town as soon as the contracts have closed out probably this week or so. So just a couple of high-level kinds of points, information that might go to some of the questions you guys have had. The total contracted number of pages was for 190 pages total between amendments two and three. Number of pages finally totaled I think is 173, 177. The contract value was $16,000. I want to thank Mammoth Lakes Tourism for contributing $5,000 to the project.
23:09 And also $5,000 in-kind from MLTPA staff. It's a match of about 62-some odd percent of the contract. There's 44 new trail pages published, 12 new destination pages published, 9 new activity pages published, and then the total experience pages, 54 pages published, 20 pages published, and 27 pages published. This is your, we're still sitting in the...
23:34 The final days of the weeds are what it took to actually build all this stuff. I don't want you guys to have to understand our Excel sheets and how all that stuff worked, but that's where the final throws of all that stuff. So if you go to the website, you'll see all this new stuff. In addition, some things that came out of this that are just helpful to note. I really want to thank the town staff and the Forest Service staff for taking the time
23:58 To review very diligently all of the pages that we submitted to them for review. It's not an easy thing over your Thanksgiving or Christmas holiday to sit down with 190 web pages and logging into various CMSs to do all that stuff, but these guys did a great job, very thorough, and it made it very easy for us to respond to all the changes, all the needs they have to get this stuff right. So I think you guys can feel, the town can feel, the partners can feel, that the information on the site is correct. If you go through there and see anything that might have gotten missed, please let us know and we'll fix it. Brian?
24:27 I'm quite confident that everything's in good shape. This included things like the wilderness address from Red's Meadow. We had some good conversations about that. All the public services have been reviewed and make sure that the status and public service on the site are per the agency direction. What we say is there is actually there. And the incorporation of all the concerns of the town, the forest service on the webpages. I think it's all there. It should all be there. If we've missed anything, again, please let us know and we'll get all that stuff. Some additional things that happened to the site. There's new right now, a new winter map.
24:56 On the trail system website. There are graphic representations for seven OSV staging areas and two motorized, non-motorized staging areas across the system. This is consistent with the look and feel of the existing paper maps. So it's all one product for one branded effort. Everything's in the same thing. There's now opportunities now for winter trails and winter experiences, which can be tied directly to the new winter map. This is all sort of back of the house stuff that we did as part of the contract. The experience.
25:25 This process has been changed per direction from the Forest Service in the town so that now individuals, companies, nonprofits who want to have an experience to share on the website, they will not be getting direct attribution for that. But they're recredited and listed on a page, on one of the administrative pages. I'm hoping we can still continue to develop good experiences for the site, but this is one of the things that the agency has requested, and that's been changed.
25:50 A lot of the new photography that happened has now been integrated into the existing pages of the site. So if you go to the home page, the trails page, the destination page, all the new photography that happened has been integrated into that. A lot of work with MLTPA photo library to make all this stuff happen. And then there's a whole slew of technical things that were done as part of this contract that we were just able to get done and bring to fruition. And I think most importantly, John mentioned the protocols for the site. A lot of good learning came out of this process. We've captured all that.
26:20 And that will be moving forward to the partners for their review and approval. So things like the standards, the protocols for the wilderness can be written down and standardized. Everybody knows how those things work. So for future content enhancements and things like that, if you're contracting with us or anybody else, whoever the contractor is, it's going to be written right down there as to what it is they're expected to do. So a lot of really good things came out of this effort. It was a lot of work, a lot of fun. But again, I just want to thank the staffs very much for their time and diligence in order to leading this thing to its success. So thank you very much to both Steve and to
26:50 John. John, I want to thank you too for MLTPA's contribution, both cash as well as all the work that you've done. Sure, thank you very much. On the ones, Steve or John or whoever, that says retained an inventory, is that inventory of MLTPA, the builder, or is... No, it's in the tent. It lives, these pages live in the CMS on the website, so all the...
27:17 All the work was done up until the point of the agency review. So they're 85% of the way there. They live in the CMS. You could publish them tomorrow if you want. You could publish them in five seconds if you wanted to. You know, who knows? The federal wilderness policy may change. I mean, all kinds of different things might change. But we're making sure that the inventory of these pages in the CMS, everybody knows what they are. We're doing the same thing with the photo library. But this is all the town's property, so it's all retained in the town's. That's what we know. Thanks.
27:47 Okay, thank you. Thank you. The other thing I'd suggest is that the committee asked on to make a presentation to the Recreation Commission because this is, again, a measure of our effort and that we've been monitoring this and all of it's part of our master tracker. Okay. I put that out to the committee. If that's appropriate. I think it makes perfect sense, yes. Okay. John, we'll ask you.
28:17 Sure. Yeah. I think I'll just prepare the measure of performance report, which I'll have done by your next meeting, and maybe I can get that to stew in the packet or something like that and just walk them and build whatever, however more or less detail you want to see is entirely up to you guys. We can show pages or just go with us, whatever you'd like. Okay. Thank you. Steve, any further presentation with regard to this component, the website? I have some other presentations, but not in regards to the website. Okay.
28:46 So the other things I have, within your package, you should have two fold-out maps, the CTU, California Trail Users Coalition. It's a third edition, published December 2013. You have PDFs.
29:01 In the email attachments, you can see what I said in greater detail, but I just wanted to let you know that they are available. I've talked with the Welcome Center, and they're looking forward to receiving the next batch for distribution. They currently are distributing 2011 maps. So this is very important to your motorized and non-motorized users for the various trails that are recognized within the National Forum.
29:31 Two things. John, yeah, Mr. Kaz, not that one, this one. Does this represent everything since travel management? So the routes that are out there that still show but were not included in travel management do not show on this map?
29:51 So there are two maps. There's a north half of the forest and south half of the forest. At the scale that this is printed at, it is impossible to show every single road and trail that's part of the system that was authorized per the travel management decision or has been added to the system since the travel management decision. So we have painstakingly gone through and made sure the most heavily traveled, widely used roads are included in both of these maps.
30:21 But for graphic purposes, if you included everything, there would be places you'd just see a big black blob. We had to not include some. And I think it's noted somewhere in this map that that's the fact that, you know, pay attention, there may be some of our rooms out there. But everything that is included on this map is part of the system. There's nothing on this map that's closed, yes. So my next question would be,
30:50 The protocol, and this is just for my own edification, I can ask you afterwards, but Sean wants me to be quick, so I'm being slow. Why aren't we using, as a town and a forest service, something more like a Google mapping system where everything can be there, but as you come down or go out, they disappear and come back depending on the spread? Because it seems to me that, you know, I'd love using that.
31:19 For that reason alone, that roads come and go depending on how far you've zoomed in. Well, we're making some progress there. Okay. But the public still demands a paper, something to hold in their hand. Not everybody owns the technology. Technology doesn't work everywhere in this forest. So paper maps are still very useful and something that we're going to continue to pursue.
31:45 But as far as the technology goes, we are making some progress there. Some of the progress has been made thanks to this MLTS effort. MLTPA has worked with Navtech, I think, is the company? Yeah, I just wanted to say that all of the travel management data from the stuff you gave out after the decision is on the Mammoth Lakes Trail System website. So all the roads, all the trails represented on the website is travel management. So the best way to get to that is to use it. I've used it up.
32:14 In Virginia Lakes, I'm out mountain biking, and I don't know what roads to go on. I can call up and find out what route to take. So it's there. I just wanted to make sure you guys knew that. So through this process, in order to get the Google Map, the base layer, accurate,
32:28 There's two companies that supply that data to Google and to MapQuest and others. And the Forest Service has been working very closely with those companies. But then MLTPA, through this process, has also provided some of that information to those companies. And so they're getting their base data correct now. Five years ago, you looked on Google and you found all these roads that were closed for travel management or roads that never existed. So we've made some improvements there by working directly with those companies.
32:57 Pretty darn good. I haven't gone and Google Earth truce everything, but it's getting a lot better. The other thing is the Forest Service is working on a way to digitally distribute the data so you can download it to your Garmin unit, you can download it to whatever, but there's so many different technologies out there, so many different platforms, and that's not being done at the forest level.
33:23 Press release that just came out, and I can forward it on to the committee if you'd like me to, that it announced the digital release of all the travel management data where you can go and get the most recent maps for each forest, the most recent EMBA, Motor Vehicle Use Map, which is the legal document that says which roads are open, which roads and trails are open for motorized use. So we're making progress, and I think everybody knows where they want to be. There's just a lot of technological hurdles we have to get over.
33:53 In order to get there, and we're getting over some of them. I think that's one of the more useful things that we can offer the public as a coordinating committee. So, yeah, if you haven't afforded that, please do. Yeah, I'll make a note to do that. You know, I'll say this whole thing with using technology to get people to use our trails and roads properly began back in 2002 when I first was in our GIS shop. That was one of the things that I was working on.
34:22 And there was a big concern back then about manipulation of data, and we've actually seen it other places where somebody decides they want to add their own trail, and they're out in the forest, and a law enforcement officer comes upon them and says, why are you on this closed road? Well, it's on my digital map. So we've had to figure out a lot of the legal hurdles, too. And I think we're getting there, and we're getting to the point where the public will have a lot of that technology available to them soon and allow them to recreate that much more safely and responsibly.
34:51 Okay. Is that something that would be appropriate as well to forward to MLT for them to publicize? Yeah, I can send it to John or... Okay. Then I have one more follow-up. Can I talk to the Welcome Center today and they weren't sure when they might be receiving these, granted they're only a month old, but do you know when the print shop will be delivering it to the Welcome Center? I don't know exactly. We try to do this every year.
35:20 Before the OHV use really hits the forest, but that's like right now, because of the weather we're having. So, you know, I'm hopeful that they'll be here by end of April, early May. I don't know for sure, though. We have one more presentation item. This is just a quick follow-up to a project that was funded this year for the seven interpretive signs. If you remember that, the Forest, I'm sorry, the Public Works Department.
35:48 Has responded that a request for proposal is out for the website design. And there are a couple of people that have already indicated interest in that work. And that the deadline to receive the proposals is January 22nd. Ballon Multimedia has modified the panels to put on the trail system logo. And I reviewed those and saw them. So that's ready to go. And then panel production.
36:16 Vendors are starting to deliver price quotes. The panels will be handled by the town of Mammoth Lakes in-house and formal bidding for the actual development will be slated for April with an award in May and then construction probably June of 2014. So Mammoth.
36:41 Lakes Public Works Department is on target. Construction or installation? Installation will start June 14th. Okay. Thank you. In terms of just the interpretive component, so that will be delivered to the town in a format that can then be posted to the web? Absolutely. But the contractor is not going to be accessing the website directly to do the posting themselves, are they?
37:10 I don't know that we've got that totally cleared out yet. Okay. And just, we get too many inputs into the website and it can get a little crazy. Right. Right. That's a good point. We may want to just have it delivered to the town and then with our IT partners come on how to have it. However the technical details work out so we don't introduce something new that we didn't expect. May I make a comment on that?
37:39 Just on the seven interpretive panels that were eight interpretive panels, and I know you guys had some discussion while I was gone, excluding the eighth panel certainly was disappointing to me. It's one of the panels that we worked diligently on. We had a public process that everyone was invited to participate in on the content. We had a review process. I don't want to kick up a lot of dust here, but...
38:06 The Forest Service, you know, this is a partnership with the Mammoth Trail System, and that panel is important in conveying some information that we want the public to be aware of, and the Forest Service has the prerogative, and we haven't decided, John Rogelbrugia hasn't really discussed this with me yet, but we may look at installing that panel ourselves with some other funds, and if we do do that, I will be sure to let you all know, but I wanted to let you know that, you know, we will look into that. It was one of the more important panels that we were dealing with that issue.
38:35 of amphibian decline across the Sierra, and we felt that that panel was something that was very important, one of the most important ones for us to relay the message of the management action that we're taking as a result of that issue. So I know you guys discussed it as a group and you decided that's how you wanted to allocate the funding, but I just wanted to be upfront and let you know that we may be trying to install that panel on our own with some other support in the future. Thanks for supporting the other center.
39:07 So that concludes my presentation, and we're ready to move on to the agenda. Okay. John, thank you for at least sharing that. Consent agenda. Would anyone like to have anything pulled? I move to approve. I'll second. Got a motion to approve from Sandy. Second. Second from Bill Souser. President Philbin. Aye. Aye.
39:35 I'd like the new format with your minutes, Steve, good job. Yeah, and thank you for taking such good notes with Granicus being down last time. Do we have Granicus this time? Yes.
39:57 So we're ready to move on to business matters? Please do. Number three, Steve. So number three is to discuss the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Coordinating Committee's potential extended role and scope of interest regarding providing comments on U.S. Forest Service related projects. And this is project number 112. So if you refer to your master tracker on the track page, it should be a socialist.
40:27 And this is... Let's keep flipping the page. I took out my contact specifically so that I could look at this post. Actually, I think if I go to this one, the SOFA list is easier to read. The particular project that we are talking about is listed on the SOFA list, page 66, number 1, 1, 2. This is the Land and Resource Administration Planning Division in the 1980s.
41:00 So in your packet under identified as 3A is a letter dated December 16, 2013 from the town of Mammoth Lakes to the forest in regards to making comments on the draft assessment. Who's Mrs. Murphy? Who's Mrs. Murphy? Ms. Murphy.
41:25 It looked like there was two different, the salutation was different than the addressee. But that minor detail. The question I actually had was, has the town identified somebody on staff who is principally responsible for reviewing the Forest Service materials and recommending
41:53 I see that this was written by Peter. Is that going to be his role going forward? Or do you know yet? I think you'll see going forward that Peter will be the signatory. However, Sandra Moberly is active community development directors involved as well as Carson. And he's the one that's doing a lot of the research and so forth that helped put together the letter for Peter. So yes, at least three, if not four staff members.
42:22 Have been identified as paying attention to this matter. But to this one matter, I think I would expand on what Bill was asking. I know I've asked a couple different council members and suggested perhaps that one person in the town should be responsible for looking over on a monthly basis the stuff that comes out of the Forest Service and what their intended plans are. And then figuring out what type of project that is and carrying it on to the
42:52 Advisory Body that would then look at it so we don't get it too late to comment because some should go to the Planning Commission, some should come to this body, some should probably go to the Recreation Commission and I don't know how to push or whether we're the right conduit to push the town into appointing somebody for that purpose of looking at all of the Forest Services plans that are going to move forward.
43:19 And getting, taking them for comment. A lot of times the town sees it and at the last minute Peter or somebody else will address it without it ever going through a public process. It's strictly staff addressed. And there's a lot of these things that I get mail on and go over my head on occasion. I think it would behoove the town and the county to have somebody in both departments who says, well this is trail related, we should take this to the
43:49 MLTSCC and inform them what we think it is and get their comments to add into the town's comment pages. I support that. Technically, commenting on this kind of document isn't actually within our assigned scope of services, so unless staff is bringing it to us, we're not really in a position to initiate. Which is what I'm saying. Staff should be bringing it to us and seeking our comments to dovetail with their
44:17 Much better writing ability than I have certainly to address these comments so that it's written in the right format and everything. But I think a lot of times it just falls through the cracks, so to speak. Well, the SOPA list actually, I think that's kind of why the SOPA list is here. It kind of alerts us, but I think your point of, you know, is there a designated staff, I don't know that there is other than Steve to alert us to it. Before I came here, now I'm not finding it.
44:44 Sounds like Sandra. Are there any recommendations, John, on how we can handle this? Well, I'm thinking about it in terms of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. And you have a lot of interaction with the Forest Service through me or whoever ends up attending these meetings. And you have, I think we can discuss an expectation, which I think is very reasonable, that I or the Forest Service keep you informed of any projects related to the trail system.
45:09 And that, you know, whether you all are following the SOPA or not, as part of our partnership, it's reasonable to expect that when I come to these meetings, I can tell you what's going on in terms of what actions the agency may be taking that may affect the management of, development of, or, you know, even close proximity to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System.
45:30 I think we got some comment letters back in the Shady Rest project that expressed some concern about why that project wasn't being considered more as part of the MLTS. And on that project, it got going before the MLTS was really formed and before this group was really formed. And so I think there also are going to continue to be projects where the Forest Service, for whatever reason, feels we need to
45:57 Pursue them independently of our partnership with the town, but they may impact, they may affect, they may have parallels to the MLTS that we need to discuss, and I think we did that with the Shady Project. We took a meeting to discuss that project in great detail. So anyway, I just want to throw out there, it's reasonable for me to be your liaison and talk about projects and try to give you a heads up on things that are going on.
46:23 If you believe the town needs to respond formally or this committee needs to respond formally to our projects, that's entirely your prerogative. I think there's a lot of forest business the town may want to respond to that has nothing to do with this committee or your mandate. So anyway, I may have just stated the obvious to some degree, but I'm here for you guys. And we appreciate that. But when I sit at my computer and I read through the...
46:53 Need for Change Lists and things like that. The way a lot of it's written is not the way stuff I read on a daily basis is written. And while I've read a lot of Forest Service documents and stuff, I still find myself wishing I had the land plan or engineer there who could explain to me what it means. Well, I think what's entirely appropriate is if you are taking the time to read those documents and you have questions about how they relate to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System, ask me.
47:19 If I don't know the answer, I'll tell you, and I'll go try to find it for you in a timely manner. But we should be talking about how the forest plan or any other project's going to impact what we're trying to do together here in this partnership. The rest of it, I don't know how the town wants to deal with the forest service liaison and work down the road. We have lots of meetings staff to staff, town manager to district ranger. There are quarterly.
47:48 Meetings between the Water District, the Forest Service, and the Town of Mammoth Lakes. And so we cover a lot of topics. Actually, there's quarterly and monthly. We've had monthlies as well. We haven't really, with Dan, we haven't really had any of those yet, but we did talk about it when we last met with Dan about trying to get some more regular meetings on track to discuss topics. So that's a lot of town.
48:15 Business that I'm not going to get into, obviously. But we've got a good thing going here. John, you are our conduit. You are sitting in here on these meetings, so thank you. Anything that you can continue to do as far as bringing heads up, I think for right now, I have heard the same thing from counselors as well, from town counselors as well.
48:36 Yeah, I have many things that I want to discuss and make sure you all are aware of here today, and that's just like every day. I'm going to try to wait until see how many of these things we cover through the agenda items that are listed, because there's a lot of things that we may cover as a result, but then I'll make sure you're aware of anything else that comes out. Well, and I was actually going to make a comment that Steve, when you and I sit down, we're going to probably need to start putting estimated time on the presentations as well, but I know that that's tough to do.
49:06 Because I want to make sure that we get through the rest of the agenda. Is there anything? The next item is, John, did you, in very quick comment? Yeah, I just, as a member of the public, I'd like just to, this is a very important thing that's going on right now. I personally want to extend my thanks to John Kaczmarski for all the work he's done over all these many years on behalf of the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. No one doubts for a second his efforts, efforts of staff to bring this thing together to make it work. That does not preclude
49:34 The responsibility of the town to be effectively engaged in this forest plan revision process. Are you aware of what's happening on January 30th and you are aware of what's happening on January 24th? With the meetings down in Bishop? Yeah. Is the town going to be in attendance? And the question I need to ask the town, again, as a citizen of the town, this is not directed forest service at all, the letter that Peter Bernasconi provided, the letters that we've provided,
49:59 on the assessment stage of the forest plan revision speak specifically to the role of gateway communities in their role with the forest plan revision and the capacity that these communities are bringing to the forest plan to perhaps assist the forest in some way to manage their resources and do the kinds of things that need to get done. These kinds of efforts are consistent with policy coming out of Washington, D.C. This is not coming from outer space. Has the town done an analysis to see if the assessment
50:29 Reflects the MOUs, the kinds of contractual relationships that you guys have worked so hard together to put in place. I'm not seeing them in there. So my question is, what role and what is the town going to be doing to ensure when the need for change question is asked? One meeting January 30th, that's it. Thank you for the question. I would love to see some follow-up, but we're losing opportunities right and left. The town has no standing with the Shady Rest staging on your project because the letters were not filed. Thank you.
51:00 Are you able to answer that with an answer no? I know it's more detailed than that. I've presented to you a December 16th letter from the Town of Mammoth Lakes outlining our recreational contract assessment. Also in your packet under 3B is the notice that there'll be a meeting Thursday, January 30th in Bishop. I encourage all of you to attend. And it's my duty to...
51:31 Asked Peter Bernasconi if he'll be assigning Carson to attend that meeting. I spoke with Carson the other day. He had not yet received that assignment. We have to follow up and find out and encourage that assignment to be made. And then also in your packet under 3C is the need for change.
51:53 Document. So this is a preliminary need for change for the Forestry Division, for Region 5, for the adoption. If you read through it, if you take the time to go through it, you'll see it's fairly conceptual, but it outlines what kinds of things you can expect. So again, comments will be provided from the town on this. And then finally, I think the packet is attachment 3D, which is
52:23 Basically the notice then of the draft assessment report and it gives the website clicks and so forth. So I provide this information to you as a committee and as individuals and with that we can page your level of installment. Well, are we, I don't think we're able to take action on this or? No. It just goes back to exactly what I was saying. So the town has people actively working on this and working on the recreation end.
52:55 As a recreation commissioner, I don't, I know for me personally, no one has come to me and asked me what I think or do I have anything to add to what they're putting in there. Since we are the informational conduit for recreation in Mammoth, I think to daylight it, it should at least come through this committee and that committee. I'm not faulting the force service for not performing this. I'm saying the town needs to, we have people that are going to be responding.
53:22 It seems to me those people should be not making a response for us, but at least getting our input as to what we feel that response should be after they tell us what they think the action is going to potentially have. That's why we hire people to do these things. I know that I was asked, and I did give my input to Peter, and it had to do with the importance of the OSV, the groom program, the motorized program to this town.
53:50 And our support. So he talked to me quite a bit about it and I did give him from my personal perspective, which actually is yours, I believe. I think we share the same. So at least I was asked. And I know my input's in that letter. And we did respond by the date, I guess is the point. We responded. The town responded. So. I suppose there are some options. Mr. Chair.
54:22 A small subcommittee ahead of the 30th date to meet with Peter Vernisconi and staff. And in the meantime, you can do your homework and review the presented materials and then help to formulate a response or at least in the public workshop in the end of January be able to come forward with a set of recommendations or discussion items. Because the issue has been timing.
54:50 Yeah, it's coming. When we're getting the material, we've already set our meetings, and then we're, you know, it's not the fault of really anybody when we're dealing with it. So I think that subcommittee idea is a good idea. I don't know if you want to set a whole new meeting just to talk about this issue. I mean, that's certainly the choice of the chair and the committee to do that if they feel it important at this time. I certainly already hope to attend one of the bishop meetings. But as with you as a business owner,
55:21 I never know until I am in the meeting room that I can be there, so I never know that. And I don't know how they capture the, because I much prefer to verbally go to a meeting and give my responses. Well, sometimes those responses haven't made it into the documents, so I don't know how the Forest Service captures verbal versus written either. I know for them, written is better.
55:46 Well, at every public meeting, they make sure they disclose whether or not your comments will be recorded as official record or if you'll need to submit them in writing beyond the meeting. Well, what is the pleasure of this committee in how to address this? Unfortunately, you're right. Actually, it's not that I don't know. I do know that I will not have any time between now and this meeting and Bishop and myself personally.
56:09 Can I throw a tooth to the agency? This is obviously a huge deal and very important. We've given you an update in the last meeting on the forest plan revision. I'm happy to answer any questions. I think you guys pretty much have the information. But if there are members of the public who are concerned about the direction that the forest plan is taking our relationship with the town in, it's not just the town we want to hear from, but it's those people who share concerns. So I think the members of the public should also feel free.
56:38 To not speak on behalf of the town, but speak on your own interest in how you view the relationship that's forming as a result of the forest plan with the forest service. Feel free to share your thoughts and ideas if you think things are incorrect or need to be addressed. Sorry to display my ignorance here, but the assessment papers were out for comment.
57:08 We're due, what, last week? 6th, 16th, November. I pulled it up here, so I think they've actually updated the page, so yeah, it's come and gone. It was just before Christmas, December 16th. Have those now been incorporated into the assessment documents, and are those available as part of the review for the need for change? I do know. I don't know. I do not think to date, right now, the assessment has been edited in response to those comments.
57:37 Because everybody's been on leave and I know the first meeting was last week. So I can find out for you. I'm just trying to look at timing. But those will be incorporated and any revisions will be out prior to the deadline for responding on the need for change. Again, I apologize. I don't know the answer. I can send you guys an email as a group and let you know what those answers are if you'd like me to. It's just about timing and making sure that when we're
58:06 Addressing the need for change that we've really seen the whole universe of the assessment, not just the first draft. I will ask the questions and send Steve an email and he can distribute something. Is there any further discussion on what we can do for this or is it going to be attend if you can? I don't plan to attend because I've got other engagements. I would say attend, stay in touch with the...
58:43 Stay on top of what's happening through the website. All of the above, if you can. I'm happy to look at my schedule and attend. Yeah, I can tell you for sure I won't be able to attend that. I'm fine. If I look at it, I'm available, I'll go. Okay. Great. I am planning on attending. Okay. My schedule's been bouncing around a bit, so I can't guarantee you, but right now that's the intent. So I'll put it down as consensus. TSEC members plan to attend if they can.
59:14 But at this time, we are not putting together a subcommittee, is what I'm hearing, to review the official comments. It's up to you. Like I said, I think if Bill and I could get there, that's fair representation. Okay. Yeah, okay. Okay, then business item number four, discuss and take action regarding lakes basin early opening slash water closure.
59:48 Great fall closure, project 571. So as you recall from our last meeting, we're going to have to look on our national tracking list, highlighted in yellow, we should find project 571. And this was going to be a meeting with forest service and committee members to discuss restroom workings and also
1:00:11 It could be from any one of the three of us as we all met, although I probably have the latest information since I did some follow-up from. So John Kaczmiewski and Bill Souser and I met and sort of broke down what the issues were and what the nature of the problem, if any, is because
1:00:39 You know, it may not be as significant as has been stated, and also it may turn out that Forest Service has already taken some steps. So we broke it into two components. One was the trash, and one was the restrooms. As we've talked about before, the restrooms in the campgrounds, any of the restrooms that are on the water systems have to close, and they have to really close by mid-October to avoid freeze damage.
1:01:09 And there are three restrooms, one at Mamie, one at Mary, and one at George that are vault toilets that stay open all year. The Forest Service does maintain those up until the gate closure. Tamarack maintains them during the winter. Once Tamarack is done, the Forest Service does do periodic inspections, just replace the toilet paper and make sure that everything's okay.
1:01:36 Beginning this last year, when the campground facilities were closed, Forest Service started putting signs on those, directing people to the open restrooms. But I think pretty much that's as much as we can do with the restrooms. I don't think short of building more vault toilets in some other strategic locations like perhaps, I don't know, Horseshoe and Coldwater, we've kind of done what we can do because the water system is really the limiting factor on those.
1:02:05 And we started talking about the dumpsters. So who handles the, you put the signs up, and if Temrac's not operating, but the Forest Service folks aren't on, who does the toilet paper? According to Mr. Kazmierski, the Forest Service, when they're up there, their staff is doing periodic patrols, and they keep some supplies in the trucks, and they just...
1:02:32 Once or twice a week, make sure that swing by and check the restrooms. In the fall, when there's not enough snow for Tamarack to operate, we'll drive up or, you know, I've had employees walk up and we don't want cars on the roads. That's what I was wondering, yeah. In the spring, we're doing some snowmobile and cross-country ski patrol after Tamarack closes and, you know, I can't even say it happens weekly, but it is needed.
1:02:54 We usually stay on top of it pretty well. It's a lot lighter use during those times. But the most important thing really is the signs directing people to the vault toilets. And those are in place because I've seen them. They're laminated signs that we stick on. We talked a little bit about this in our meetings, whether we're talking dumpsters or restrooms. Laminated signs that you put up with tape.
1:03:17 Don't always last that long. So one of the things we discussed, and I don't know if Bill's going to get to that, but it's potentially some more permanent, you know, ways we can communicate that information that will make sure it's there when people need it. Yeah, I would, you know, talk about that a little bit in our future actions, but yeah, basically, they are, the signs, some have held up, some haven't, so, but at least it's a good first step, and it's better than it was the year before, and I appreciate that.
1:03:48 Efforts of the agency to jump on that without even being asked. As soon as it became clear it was an issue, they got on it. So then dumpsters. So we talked a lot about what the potentials were, what was going on. The campground concessionaire is responsible for managing those dumpsters that are in the campgrounds, paying for them to be emptied. And so they have been securing them at the end of the season.
1:04:17 When the campgrounds close. And we, anyway, long story short, some of them are in very public places. Some people are just piling their trash on the closed locked dumpsters. There was a question about what Mammoth Disposal would or would not be willing to do in terms of servicing. And there was also a question about what the ordinances are with regard to frequency of emptying dumpsters.
1:04:46 CAS thought that perhaps he had understood that if the dumpster was open that it had to be emptied at least weekly. So I did go online, I did review the ordinances. There's nothing in the ordinances for commercial dumpsters that requires that. So unless Mammoth Disposal is considering these to be residential dumpsters, which do require weekly dumping.
1:05:17 Then it can be on an as-needed basis. The other thing is, we talked about, well, what about just leaving all the dumpsters open? Because once the campgrounds are closed, the volume of use up there is so low, you probably can't fill the dumpsters. The agency, for good reason, does not want to burden their permittee with the cost of an additional emptying of the dumpsters. So that might be where we can step in.
1:05:45 I did have a brief discussion with Mammoth Disposal. I need to get bumped up to the next level of responsibility and authority, but it looks like we can set that up. So if we can identify some dumpsters in a few key locations. So I don't think they all need to be left open, the ones deep in the campground, like back in the Lake Mary campground in the woods. You know, that's not going to be an issue. But we can identify a few key ones, leave them open.
1:06:14 And just find a way to pay for having them dumped in the spring before the campground concessionaire starts. We may be able to solve that. That then gets to the final question, which was somehow we need to design some kind of a notice that can go on the locked dumpsters saying, close for the season, here's where you can find new dumps, new dumpsters. So procedurally, I need to finish up with Mammoth Disposal. You and I need to craft a rough...
1:06:43 Outline. We'll need to run that through Dan Holler. If that looks good, we'll either then present it to the Forest Service or whoever else Dan thinks needs to see it first. I think this is going to be minimally expensive. We have not committed that this will come out of our $300,000. That's a discussion to be had. But at least I think we're getting to the point where we're not talking about a lot of money.
1:07:13 Very well reported. Better than I would do. I concur with everything he says. I think that the dumpster issue can be solved with either taking away the, and we talked about that as well, taking away the ones that aren't going to be locked, or putting signs on all the locked ones as to where open dumpsters are. And then I think it would require us to have Mammoth Disposal run one trip up there to dump them prior to campgrounds opening.
1:07:41 I think usually, with the possible exception of George, all the campgrounds open in the same week. No. They're pretty staggered, actually. Well, you've got Pine City and Lake Mary. Coldwater often is the last one to open. Because there's snow at the top. And then George is kind of second to last. But Pine City and Lake Mary will open. Well, Twin Lakes is always the first. And Pine City and Lake Mary and then George and then Coldwater is usually the order.
1:08:09 Regardless, yeah, Mammoth Disposal is up there. We pay them to dump each of those dumpsters on an individual basis prior to that campground opening, and then the concessionaire shows up with a clean dumpster. And we already have the rates for the dumping. Steve got those earlier. I think actually, interestingly, the toughest part may be coming up with some kind of a standardized notice that we can mount on the dumpsters every year.
1:08:37 I don't think even that's going to be terribly complicated, but it's just we have to figure out something that can attach to the dumpster that's robust enough to survive the winter. The only other thing I see coming out of this is the potential need down the road, and we could probably do it through our adopted trails program if we ever get that thing off the ground, is the need to have volunteers who have made a commitment to check these things. So if the Forest Service staff can't get by them, somebody is going and checking them for toys. It's not expensive.
1:09:07 I promise you we can get that stuff donated. Yeah, I think. Yeah, but to create some sort of an adoptive program, which we've talked about many times, we need to do that for many of our trails and trail systems. That would be the final piece. The magnitude, the volume of trash isn't really that great. You go up there and look, and the problem is it doesn't take much trash to look terrible. Well, so if there's two trash bags, you know, and one...
1:09:37 And a couple of diapers thrown around, and the birds have gotten to it. It looks terrible. So a little bit of maintenance and an option for those people will probably more than take care of it. Except for the, you know, and I'm not going to get out of my soapbox about this one today, but except for the idiots who leave their dog bags around. Right. We talked about those too.
1:09:58 Our business matter today is to discuss. Well, it's really just there's an update. There's no action to be taken. That's my next question. Yeah, we will come back to you with a proposal to take to the Forest Service. Yeah. And I think we can adopt this thing by the spring. Okay. Is this something that we should agendize for our February meeting? I mean, do we move that quickly? Let's put it on as the same kind of item we have now. And if it's ready, it'll be ready. And I would say when it comes forward, it's a written, still written proposal.
1:10:27 It's like a little operations plan that's been reviewed by the Forest Service, by Dan Holler, whatever, and then we can just, you know.
1:10:34 Okay. Steve, let's make sure that that's included for February. Can I just add one more thing? I did talk to John Ruegelberger after we met Bill and Bill and had a really good conversation. John and I were both very appreciative that you guys were willing to come and talk to us about a very productive solution to, you know, not our highest priority problem, but something that we've had issue with up in the lake space in the past. It was a very productive discussion. We were very happy that someone came to us with some ideas.
1:11:02 On how to solve it rather than just complaining about the situation without having any real productive steps to assist us. So it's very well appreciated. John was responsive and thought we could figure out something with you guys. One of the things I wanted to bring the committee's attention that John did say that, you know, after thinking about it, I agree. One of the additional things we continue to hear about the dumpsters and the restrooms up in the lake space and more the restrooms than anything is
1:11:30 During the summer when we're really busy that they're not getting the attention that they need, the level of service, the trash cans and the restrooms aren't getting serviced as much as the public believes they should be, or at least as town council and others have expressed, they think there should be a higher level of service. So John was hoping that I could also ask you guys if you have some creative solutions there, the volunteer idea is really good, or throwing resources towards summer level of service, but every summer we get to that point where
1:12:00 You know, our resources are finite. We have to make some very tough decisions on how to spend those resources, not just in the Mammoth area but across the entire forest. And I think we're providing a fairly high level of service given the resources that are available to us. But if there's a wish by the town for us to increase that level of service, we'd appreciate working with you in the same cooperative manner that we're addressing these shoulder season issues.
1:12:26 It might I suggest that we could look at that because we do have this as a standing project item. We have yet to discuss next year's funding, so maybe we could do that. I may want to take the main person. I'd like to maybe take the two items separately because I don't want the fall closure or spring opening to get derailed talking about additional levels of service in the summer. Right, and also I think one of the items I heard you say you wanted to discuss was
1:12:55 Whether or not this was even in our bailiwick. I mean, I kind of think it is, but I understood that somebody, I think you said that you weren't sure that it should come out of our trails budget. There's no assurance that it will. I think we should talk about that. There are reasons why maybe it wouldn't, and there are reasons why maybe it would. So I think we just need to go through that and figure out, one, what else, where it fits in the priority list.
1:13:25 And how it fits with Measure R and the trails end. We don't need to discuss that today. Okay. But I guess I'm just thinking, I mean, I don't see it going to Measure U. No. I don't see it going to the General Fund. I actually do.
1:13:38 There are other partnerships that, you know, the Forest Service is working with the town on Mammoth Tourism is one. And, you know, when you have entities who are trying to bring more and more and more and more people here at a concentrated time, I think it's worth talking to some of our other partners about how they can assist us with some of the problems that they're, you know, in a great positive way that we support contributing to. Mr. Chairman, if I could, I think that you've got a really good plan here.
1:14:07 I think that these guys have a need, the public's got a need. You've got a trails plan that identifies adopter trail programs, adopter identifies trail patrols. Let's get these programs implemented. You would then, the community would have a standing program through which these things get coordinated and things happen.
1:14:26 It's right here in the plan. I would highly suggest you start moving these things forward. Yep. Thank you. Let's keep the, if I may say by consensus, that let's keep going forward with regard to an agenda item for the February meeting with regard to the winter, early opening, late fall closure and agendize for a future meeting that you just brought up and whether that goes before us, Recreation Commission. Thank you for the comment on that item.
1:14:58 Let's move on. Business item number five. Okay, business item number five. There's a couple parts to this. I asked you in your packets to bring forward the December Master Tractor, which does not require magnifying glasses. It does require bifocals, but there's a lot of information on that. The other part of your packet is...
1:15:27 The blended master tracker with all the projects listed in the Transmission Master Plan, all the responses that MLTPA provided as far as work that they've done in the past in regards to projects out of the Transmission Master Plan, and then the current projects that the committee is currently working on funding
1:15:59 And moving forward as well as the projects that have yet to be assigned budgeting or bucketing and also included are the projects in the CIP and the SOPA list. So the purpose of providing you with number five is to show you the spread of the spreadsheet.
1:16:26 I've done my best here to create columns to track all the monies from 2012-13, all the contracts, all the signed contracts, the paid out money, all the monies that we've moved forward, the approved budget from 13-14, same information about contracted paid out amounts, and then in yellow, that yellow stripe then is the
1:16:53 Area that we want to work on for 13-14, I'm sorry, that we want to work on, yeah, for 13-14 projects that we carried over to 14-15 and also the future years and then finally our 14-15 approved funding list. So this is being brought forward now in January so we can start working on it so that when council approves their budgets at the start of the fiscal year,
1:17:23 We will be all lined up and ready to go. So, that's the purpose of number five where I asked you to bring along the Magneton class. And the other thing that I provided was the condensed version. So, in this particular version, a little bit larger font, a little bit easier to read, I compressed all the information from 12 to 13 and you can still see little ribbons of text that are remaining.
1:17:51 But then focus really on the 12-13 funding, the 13-14, and then again what we're going to do in 14-15. And then compress all the information about how much contract is paid out and how much is being paid. So hopefully this is a little bit more user-friendly for you. And then again the request to bring to December 9th was again to be able to show you more clearly and concisely what our funding is.
1:18:20 has been where the assignments of monies have been, and then in pages three and four, the projects that have not even yet received any discussion for funding. So that's the general purpose of the blended master tracking. So when we get into discussions, we might well talk about
1:18:48 How to move some of the projects that we've been doing over the years that have been provided to us by outside contractors. There may be an interest within the committee to explore having town staff take an expanded role to provide services. Those may be in the form of trail maintenance. Those may be in the form of grooming.
1:19:16 Various other types of programs. So something to think about if we want to keep contracting out or if we want to do the work in-house. The other reason for bringing this forward today is to talk about some specific projects and to, again, initiate discussions for next fiscal year prioritization and projects.
1:19:44 I just wanted to specifically say thanks for kicking this off because I didn't want to be where we have been in the past where we're at May and the Town Council's getting ready to adopt a budget and we've got projects in front of us and, you know, we've had to be reactive rather than being forward-looking and thinking about how we want the program structured. So this will be helpful and I'm glad we're getting going on it now.
1:20:08 I'm not even sure this is soon enough, but by the time we can do the whole process. It's earlier than it's been. Do you have a timeline? Has the town set a timeline for the 14-15 budget process? Do you know? Tentatively, yep. Do we know what it is? That's a different question. Well, it's similar to last year's. I think we've been through, as I think the town manager said, very
1:20:39 Many versions of budget processing, so this will be another one. I think the timeline's very consistent. I mean, it's up in front of Council mid-June. I think March, April is when it's coming before Council. So that's probably the schedule we'd probably need to work off. Probably April would be a time we'd probably want to try and send some type of proposed outline right of our funding allocation to... In which case should we be actually targeting March with the idea that we probably won't? Could be.
1:21:07 I think the other thing, too, we have to remember is we will take our recommendations to the Recreation Commission. So we need that step as well. That's why I'm targeting March. Well, you've got three specifics outlined here, or I guess three specific subjects, but even more project numbers. Do we want to try and tackle these today?
1:21:35 Yep. So we are about to discuss and take action regarding these three items. Would we, you know, it's the pleasure of this committee on how to handle this. And actually perhaps maybe one of the first things we want to do is set an agenda for, or maybe actually bring forward those items that are going to be important to this committee. And obviously we've got, you have identified these three items.
1:22:06 That have been important to us beforehand. I think for our work today, I think we can quickly go through these items, and I might make a suggestion, 4-5-A, which is, I represented the email I received from the town attorney in regards to the grant writing fundraising issue, and I think that what I would strongly suggest is that we take the monies
1:22:36 $8,500 that was a carryover, the $5,000 that's still hanging from the fundraising, and then combine that with the $7,500 that we have approved funding for $13,14, and take those monies and combine them all into $441, which is Mammoth Lakes Trail System grants.
1:23:04 And then the definition of possible use as matching funds for the benefit of Mammoth Lakes Trail System infrastructure and programs. In discussion with public works, there are grant opportunities that come forward with them. There were some meetings today, I think that Sandy was even in attendance, where they're starting to reshape some of the grant opportunities. And that I think it's fair to say that the public works department is...
1:23:33 Have their ear very close to the ground on where these opportunities come from. And I think the percentages now for matching are starting to change a little bit. And so if we put these monies into a set-aside to help for matching, I think there'll be much more effective use of that money than if the Trails Committee tried to, with a separate effort, go out and research where grants may or may not be. I think that effort would be redundant. Can you give me the...
1:24:00 Thank you. 441, 442. Just those two. Yeah. Okay. Grants and fundraising. And, you know, we've talked about these over and over and over again, and the attorney has told us over and over and over again he's not comfortable using them for grants or for fundraising. Actually, I really like that proposal because grant matching, yes. Okay. And we always do need those. Any other comments with regard to that?
1:24:25 I'll just mention this kind of feeds into a statement I was going to make about the Sherwin Sharp Projects. I'm going to ask the committee here very soon. I'll just ask you right now. John Riegelberger would like to know what your priorities are in moving forward. What trails would you want to see packaged up in this NEPA process that we want to embark upon to have a decision to build something in 2015?
1:24:54 So I think you should be thinking about if you get the decision to build, what can you afford to build? Where is that money going to come from? Are you going to get it from grants? What kind of match do you need to make that happen? So this is a very timely discussion, and I think you should be thinking about that implementation of the projects that you've asked us to pursue at this point. Any further comment with regard to John's? Well, I would just actually have some questions there, John. Are you talking about the proposed action then?
1:25:24 Yeah, what do you want the proposed action to be? What do you want us to carry forward in analysis? That's a whole other discussion. Yeah, I was going to say, we really need a lot more background information. Yeah, exactly. I'm throwing that out there with you guys need to know what we found and everything else. But in relation to what you're talking about now, I think you should be thinking about the two together. Okay. With regard to 441 and 442, are there any comments, though? Yeah. I think that what we need to do,
1:25:54 Is maybe not call it a grant match because it may come in another form. Maybe it's a match for something the Forest Service has but not enough or something that the town has and not enough at a general fund. So maybe this is just our, as we did with basically UNR, maybe this is our reserve for capital investment. Do we want to spell out any kind of match? We wouldn't have to say grant, I think.
1:26:27 Reserve for Capital Project Match. Reserve for Capital Investment gives us what we need in terms of justification to hold it, and yet it doesn't tie our hands if a need arises for us to move it from one column to another. I know how Terry feels about those. You're going to get in the rec commission. She's going to just shoot that one down. You tell her it's your idea, not mine.
1:26:56 I can fight that one. You know Sean. I do. It leaves us an opening to use it for any building of any trail. Not the planning of any trail, not the administration of any trail, but the building of any trail by calling it a reserve for capital projects. And certainly a grant match, while we are the small amount, is a capital investment. Maybe we could put in there EG grant match.
1:27:26 Something like that. For example, a grant batch. I don't care. We could put for example. Yeah. As long as it doesn't tie us to having to supply the money for something that specifically comes from a grant. Because that's enough money to build a segment all on its own if push comes to shove. Well, I philosophically agree with you. It's just how to present it. Yeah. Well, this has come before us a number of times. I think it is kind of time to put this to bed. Yeah. So, before I go to the podium, just any other...
1:27:59 Just a couple things. This last summer, this committee spent a fair amount of time talking about a mission statement and a vision establishing priorities. It seemed like an interesting exercise. I was wondering when and which that was going to start hitting the road. I would very much like to see, I think a lot of people would like to see, what exactly your priorities are for the implementation of this plan. And I'm hearing some very disturbing thoughts.
1:28:27 Being expressed in terms of the culture of this community, where a very able public works department is just sort of said, well, go ahead and find grants and we'll build and do whatever we can find a grant to match for. I think one of the things in this trail system master plan specifically calls out for an action plan. It specifically says, what are the priorities for the implementation of this plan? And we haven't seen that yet. John asked a critical question.
1:28:54 You guys have committed Measure Our Money to work in partnership with the Forest Service to do very important work. There's no way you're going to be able to afford to pay for all that stuff. What are your priorities? What are the things that you want to do? I want to say also, we just completed a project. I just came here this afternoon to advise you that we leveraged 65% of the Measure Our Funds getting that project done. How are you reaching out to your partners? How are you reaching out to other capacity to bring capacity to these projects?
1:29:21 If you have an adopter trail program in place, if you have a trail patrol program in place, we need bathrooms maintained up in the Forest Service, you could be getting all this stuff for free. I would hate to see you go down the road of saying, let's put dollars aside for the Public Works Department to find whatever grants they can build and build, whatever the hell they come up with, versus a true statement of your priorities and what you want to see built and implemented from this plan to inform all of your partners. So you could be reaching out to volunteers, private capital.
1:29:51 The whole gamut of resources to bring real value to this. I really appreciate John's comment. I think it's critically important that before he gets done with his work and they start saying, what is it that you guys want to build, you've got to have a maintenance program in place, you've got to know how much you can afford to build for that stuff. Thank you. And to answer your question there, John, I never said that I wanted the Public Works Department or Planning Department to be able to use this money how they said it saw fit. That's why it's important for me for it to be a set-aside for capital.
1:30:21 Which is going to have to come through us. And we're going to have to allocate for the projects that we feel are the most important. Not just because there's a grant available. I agree wholeheartedly. We have to stop funding things because there's a specific grant available for something we can't otherwise afford. And yet most of our MUPs have been built that way. And that's important to realize. And these are prioritized in our trail system master plan as near-term MUP projects. Complete all of those.
1:30:50 Moving off. We do have priorities. Okay. I was just going to say, it's similar to what I was saying, but there's always a refinement. The priorities come in different scales. You guys, this committee has taken on the priorities and done some prioritization on several of the projects that have been conceptual, and now you're moving some of those forward. Now it's time to go at a different scale, prioritize the projects within a priority project, the short process. And I would like to see us have on our...
1:31:20 Our agenda is a standing item until we get it done to take a look at the sharps and do a prioritization of where we think the biggest bang for the buck is going to be and what projects we want to see for a second and third. It makes sense. For right now, yeah, we need to move on. So with regard to 441 and 442, I'm hearing... I'm going to make a motion, Chair. I will make a motion that we move that $20,500 into a fund that instead of...
1:31:49 Grants and Grant Research is a capital reserve with the example being given that it could be a potential grant match. I'd second that. Steve, could you please read back that motion? Steve, do a better job of rereading it than I did of writing it in the first place.
1:32:15 We might want to add that's project 441, 442. Right. Yeah, I don't know. Steve would be better at telling me whether we need a new number for that because we're changing the definition or whether we would maintain the old number.
1:32:44 Okay. The number I don't care about. I have a question. I've got a motion in a second. You've got discussion. Discussion. Discussion. Yeah. Go ahead. So, the question is, are we talking about only for, right now we're talking about for fiscal year 13-14, and that's the pot it's going to go in. It's going to go in the pot for 14-15. No? No.
1:33:09 Talking about 13-14. Okay. I want to make sure that's... 13-14. Because at some point, and this gets to the whole prioritization thing, before we start setting aside, unless we say all we're going to do is reserves, we need to do the other part of prioritization first. Absolutely. And what I was wondering was if these actually needed to go into the... And I'm okay with that for 13-14, by the way. But whether it went into the...
1:33:38 A specific pot only for capital reserve or if it went into our undesignated reserves right now so that we could allocate it to some other projects. I would put it in a pot for capital reserves. And I agree that was my second for capital. And for 1314, not 1415. No, we're just talking about taking what we have right here and combining it. With that clarified? Thank you. Any further discussion? Okay, as the motion was read, all those in favor? Aye. Aye. Opposed?
1:34:08 Motion carries. Good. Thank you. 5B. Yeah, the next item, next item, 5B. This is a continued discussion regarding annual opening events for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System Park at 741. This is also identified in the other on the extended Mammoth Trails Association. In the past, this was in a bucket.
1:34:40 It's data number four designated as future money. So no monies have been set aside in the past. No real discussion as to scope of what this opening event might be. But it has been on our agenda for quite some time. Which page is this on, Steve? Four. Four.
1:35:09 Number 5 of the WSFD fold-out, and it would be on page 5 and 6, top of page. Or on the old Master Tracker 405. Extended Master Tracker. On the tiny fault line. No. Well, it's there as well as on. On the. I'm not seeing it. It's not in yellow on the December Master Tracker, but it's still in here.
1:35:33 Well, he's looking for it. I will make my comments, and that will help us through this. A couple of just comments off the top. It's hard for me to tell when the trails are open and closed, since how I'm hoping that we're doing snow management in the near future, and a lot of these trails are going to be open winter and summer. That being said, I think this is a great marketing opportunity for the town.
1:36:01 To segue from a winter season into a hiking and biking summer season. And I would love to see us not take this on all by ourselves, but have a discussion with Mr. Urdi over in the marketing department on how he thinks this falls and what he can add to it and then working with him make up whatever budget that's going to be. It's a great time to pat ourselves on the back. We did a wonderful job making the trail system, although I didn't sweat over it.
1:36:31 But I think primarily an opening ceremony each year, and I think it's important, is more of a marketing tool than a function of the trail. So I would love to see us enter into a partnership with Mr. Urdi on this and carry it forward from there and work with his group and our group to create this. And I would agree with you on that. In my opinion, I would actually like to see our monies going more towards
1:37:03 Actually taking care of the trails and having MLT actually be doing the promotions on that. Hang on a second. Yeah, I think that both those comments are very good ones. Because you're right, it's an event, it's a marketing tool, whatever.
1:37:21 John, yeah. Steve, I'd like to see it happen, and I don't think he's going to pick the tab up on his own, so we're going to have to participate. Yep. But I think it should be a joint thing, both in the planning and execution of such. Steve, I'm not finding, I still haven't found the number, but what is the dollar amount? There is no dollar amount. Okay. There's always a future discussion item for funding. Okay. It wasn't funded previously.
1:37:48 So that's some of the discussion we have today, is to establish a not-to-exceed number, take that number to Mammoth Lakes Tourism, say, hey, what can we buy for XK $1,000? What would you like to do? How would you like to work it? How can we integrate the website? How can we push this out? How can we buy some banners? I'm getting excited already, and I just have a cup of water.
1:38:12 Maybe have input the ideas for. I refer to the website as the Ferrari in the garage, and I think the Ferrari's out of the garage now, and it's ready to be, you know, taken for a spin and let everybody know it's there. I'd say capitalize on, that's an accomplishment we achieved over the winter, and I'd celebrate that and keep the cost and the time commitment of any celebration to a minimum. That's what we'll need on our end is, you know, we can afford a couple hours to come and join this celebration.
1:38:38 Wear our uniforms and say thank you to everybody for the partnership, which I think we should do. And that could go a long way. Video it, put it on their website, market the heck out of it, and get people up there. And that's MLT's expertise. You're right. I'm reticent about committing money to it. I think John's being pretty vocal in regards to he just needs product.
1:38:59 We have a product. We've spent hundreds of thousands of dollars on this product. So we have a product. We just need to market it. And that's his stated numerous times, get me a product, we'll market it. It gets in that grey line of now we're starting to not only build it, but we're marketing. And I'm just cautious about it, too. And I know it's a Recreation Commission discussion, too, about where do we go with that, because we've talked about it with more track. And I'm like, OK, so...
1:39:24 It's there. Where do I go with Rootmore Track? Do we pull money out of Measure R to start marketing that too, or is that really the role of tourism once we build that product further? So I think it's part of that discussion, so I'm up for a good discussion about it. I don't know that we need to put money into it today, although I could. Either way is not bad. If he won't partner with us and it doesn't become a big marketing thing, we sort of need to do this anyway, because just politically.
1:39:53 We do need to pat the Forest Service on the back, and we do need to pat Steve on the back, and John on the back, for the work they've done in bringing us to this point. If you expect people to continue to do things for you for no money, at some point in time you've got to shake their hand and say thank you for a job well done, and this is an opportunity to do that. So I don't want to lose track of all of that. However, I see it primarily as marketing. I would love to go to him and see what he has to say about it.
1:40:19 I would agree. But I see your concerns with regard to us getting into the marketing business when we really do have a marketing arm of this town. And it's time for them to take it on. I think there are a bunch of things. I think you're right. I think it's part of a bigger discussion. But we have a great example here. We've been saying, hey, let's do it. But let them take the lead. I would agree. Not allocate any money. Just say we might be able to do a little match or something.
1:40:47 Before we can actually take this on specifically. Yes, just on this issue, the original origin of this idea, this is back when we provided the whole projects to this committee back a couple years ago. Our idea at that point was to talk about doing some sort of a race or an event in a lakes basin path to showcase a specific path. Stuart's point is incredibly important. John Urdi is going to tell you, what am I selling?
1:41:12 Well, let's have an event. That was the derivation of that idea that celebrates something specific on the trail system. We had an idea about doing a baby stroller race from the North Village to Horseshoe Lake up the highest altitude, most beautiful mop in the entire country. And you can have a baby or a watermelon, whatever it is you want to do. But to put together an event like that wouldn't cost a lot of money. John Urdi can market that. He's going to have to have something to sell.
1:41:39 Laura's got great ideas about National Public Lands Day. It should be a trail system type of event that you get the public and volunteers involved with that is a product that Urdi can sell and market. Okay, great point. So what do we want to do? I would make up a committee of ourselves and staff to go to John and have that initial conversation to bring back for our next meeting. I'm seeing some nodded heads. I'm happy to do that.
1:42:14 Yeah, that's fine. Yeah, we talk every week anyway. Yeah, it's not like it's a good deal. Yeah, to what John was saying in that, you know, in addition to a race, it sounds actually really fun to watch, but things like National Trails Day is usually the first weekend in June, and that's a great opportunity to get people out and working on the trails, so if you put those things together, you have a really holistic
1:42:42 Full Program that people can get involved in in multiple ways and can really tie people to the trail system itself. And there's no reason why private businesses can't donate a keg of root beer, for instance. My reticence in tying it to a specific day for an event rather than an event itself is that I would view this as the kickoff and the promotional kickoff of telling those in Southern California that they can now come up and hike on our trails.
1:43:11 So I would like a preponderance of our trails to be open on whatever weekend. So it sort of needs to be a floating date and a different type of, you know, it can be the Lakes Basin Trail one year and it can be the new trail that we're building in 15 that goes from Tamarack Street over to the Barrow Pit the next year. But as a marketing tool to get the word out, it's time to put the skis away and bring up the mountain bike and the...
1:43:38 Hiking shoes. And the baby stroller. And the baby stroller. With cup holders. Yeah. So I'm hearing consensus that Stu and Bill Souser are going to get together with John Urdi and perhaps consider an event and bring it back at another meeting. Sounds good to me. Thank you guys for volunteering. Thank you. As long as John bought his lunch, it's okay. That's right. That's right. Okay, 5C, Shady Rest, OE2, OSV.
1:44:06 This has been on our agenda for quite some time. Again, it's a shady rest, off-highway vehicle and over-snowed vehicle staging area project. We invited the Forest Service here to give us a status on the project, with Project 141 on our list. Page what of what? That is, again, on our SOPA tracking list. Last page. Nope, this one. Yep, ML.
1:44:43 So, as you recall, for a while, this project was put on hold. Then it was brought forward. A decision has been made. And that decision should be represented in your pocket under 5C1. Correction, Steve. It's a draft decision. I'm sorry. It's a draft decision at this point. A draft decision notice. Yeah. The decision has not been made. It's a draft decision at this point. Thank you, John. So, again,
1:45:12 Quickly, 5C1 is a notice of the ejection process and that's a two-sided document. 5C2, I put together the title page of the environmental assessment and then made modifications to the alternative pages to indicate then what the description scope of the selected alternative at this time, which is number three, which
1:45:41 Takes out the right back trail. Number three is basically the same as number two, but the right back trail, again, is not part of the draft decision. So at this time, John Kazmierski is here to answer any questions you may have, and I think for the record, the objection period is open to people who have responded before. In my recollection, Sandy Hogan wrote a letter.
1:46:10 And MLTPA is written as well. So if there are any further discussions, we can have them today. So, you know, Steve gave a really good summary there. As I noted, it's a draft decision that's been issued by John Rogelberger upon resolving any objections. If there are any, he will issue his final decision. And so, you know, this was a project that
1:46:41 We received OHV grant money for a planning project. We began the project back in 2010. Is that correct? 2010-11 winter? Yes. Where we held two public meetings over at the Mammoth Ranger Station and kind of identified the values that people have in recreating in that area, the conflicts. We discussed potential sites of a new staging area and how to resolve the
1:47:10 The conflict we have with the access needs for ORMAT and the geothermal wells. So this is a pretty complicated project. It's been going on a long time, as I mentioned earlier, before the MLTS and MLTSCC formed. It is, as we found out in our public involvement process, staging in that area is extremely important to the community and to the OSB users. The current staging area out of Shady Rest.
1:47:37 Isn't really working that well. Users don't like it. It doesn't have the capacity that we're looking for. And so this decision, this draft decision, establishes a new OSV staging area that could also be used for OHV in the summer. So we're not going to take any, you know, action to implement this until after we're out of the decisions that have been made.
1:48:05 And we know that we're moving forward. So there are the OHV grants coming up here soon. And we are going to pursue some talks with town staff because we have, over the years, been discussing the idea of the town building this facility under a special use permit. Whether or not that there's any interest there remaining there is, you know, we have to talk to you guys about.
1:48:28 And it's probably premature to go after a development grant if the decision hasn't already been made. So we're not looking at that quite yet. But perhaps if the decision is to build this as drafted, we can look at using state OHV grants in the future. So the only thing that we may look at this year is looking at asking money from the state to further develop the plans that would be needed to build the infrastructure.
1:48:58 Thanks for that update. Before I shoot through the roof, I want to ask why the trail coming back to the highway and potential parking or tunnel use or whatever was left off. What environmental concern kept that from being in the final plan?
1:49:26 So I didn't draft the decision, but I did read all the comments and I discussed the comments as it related to my recreation report that I filed as an IDT member of this project. So in several of the public comments, it was identified that there was a potential safety issue between having snowmobiles and non-motorized users occupying the same corridor.
1:49:55 In fact, that used to happen when the road was groomed, but it happened on a much larger scale. The trail was the same width as the road, and it's a long, flat stretch, straight stretch, so you can see the visibility is high. The Rideback Trail that we were looking at, we looked at several alternatives. We looked at trying to separate the uses and put the Rideback Trail on one side of the road and the skiers on another side of the road, but the fact is the snow melts out on that southeast-facing.
1:50:23 You know, side of the road. They would never, maybe a week, a year, have a ride back trail that worked. So it wasn't practical from a resource standpoint to build a trail on the other side of the road. They would have to be on the same side. They would have to be a shared trail, shared corridor. And the user conflicts and potential safety issues were just too high. And it also, you know, it's the number of people that that ride back trail.
1:50:52 Would potentially serve the people who want to come back and go to the restaurants or get gas. It's fairly few compared to the non-motorized users who already are enjoying that area. We heard a lot from non-motorized users expressing concern about bringing motorized activity back into an area that has now kind of been used as a non-motorized area.
1:51:15 I don't know for sure. I can't speak for John, but those were public comments that were made that I'm sure influenced his draft decision. If I can jump in before you go on. My concern is that we can get back and forth into discussion on here, and it sounds like there's a draft decision in place, and whether you agree or disagree, I think at this point what's before us as a committee is what we're going to do with regard to proposing a staging area.
1:51:46 Is that correct? I mean, the meat of it? Well, actually, as a committee, since we didn't previously write in any comments, the only people with standing would be at this juncture, MLTPA and Sandy and some other private individuals who have written in. Down the road, there are plenty. As you know, I view this hugely discriminatory, way beyond just
1:52:15 Detrimental, but discriminatory towards motorized recreation. Yes, there are a lot of cross-country skiers using that area now because the motorized public fought like crazy to get grooming for non-motorized done in the Shady Rest Trailhead area. Every time there is a perceived conflict and every study we've done doesn't show a conflict. We boot motorized to the side and I have issues with that both as a businessman who relies on that for some of my income from the people who come to Mammoth.
1:52:45 And anybody who does business in Mammoth should have that interest. Beyond that, the whole reason for moving the staging area out to the Shady Rest ball fields in the first place was Ormat needed to plow those roads. Now that we've moved it out there, we're being told we can't be let back in because we've created a non-motorized area. I said that at the time and was told, Bill, be patient. That's not the way it's going to be. We're going to fix all of this. And every fix comes with a lessening
1:53:15 Capacity for motorized recreation. Who's going to plow it when it's done? Who's going to pay to build the road? The Forest Service has stated they'd like to do this in partnership with the town. What conflicts? On the ground, we haven't seen those conflicts. Yes, we have people writing in talking about conflicts, but in actuality they don't exist. Who builds the whole thing? I certainly would oppose any grant coming from Greensticker to rebuild a trailhead where the original one worked just fine.
1:53:44 If we have to move it because of private business, and that's what we're talking about here, moving it because of private business. The need for plowing is going to exist because of private business. Profit making, large profit making, private business. If ORMAT's the only one using the road, and as I know someone made comments to the Forest Service on, the road doesn't have to be plowed two lanes wide.
1:54:08 If you're only plowing it one lane wide and the recreation of that road makes the total cleared area of trees almost 40 feet, I think 30 some feet, you have more than enough room, even I've been riding that area now for 40 plus years, to create a trail for non-motorized on the east side and create a comeback for motorized on the west side. It does exist.
1:54:36 Because you don't have to make the road 24 feet wide. You're only going to plow 12 feet wide. And all of this has been separated from the whole ORMAT process. And they are the cause for all of it. They should be paying this mitigation for it to be there. So I have so many huge issues with this project. And it has been driven and driven hard forward. And I understand the political implications. The phone calls from Washington, we're going to move ORMAT forward.
1:55:06 There's where the liability is. There's where the conflict is. There's where the decreased recreation for all users in that area is going to be. Why have we separated these and why are we not taking them on appropriately? We could reopen the old trailhead and have more parking than we have out at Shady Rest. We could have a ride back to that trailhead without having to do the $40,000 a year plowing cost to go out there. And if you look at the study that was done,
1:55:37 Survey that was done in, I can't remember when it was done, 10 years ago or so, over 90% of the cross-country skiing public is extremely happy with the product out there. I know as a businessman you'd agree with me that if I can get over 90% huge approval rating, that probably there is no conflict worth me spending a lot of money on. So as a user, I'm viewing this as a total detriment to motorized in an effort to just move us further out of town.
1:56:06 Using our own dollars to make that push. And the irony of that is not lost on me either. I'd like to make a comment because I did comment on this. I think there's a bigger picture than OSV. And frankly, it's the separation of users at that park. For us to actually have an OHV staging area, which do we have any really constructed ones?
1:56:36 On this forest even? I mean on the Arrowhead where I was district- In formal parking areas where we had- In formal parking areas. I came from the- I was district ranger on the Arrowhead. We had model OHV staging areas. And this design meets that and it gets them out of Shady Rest Park. Go to Shady Rest Park on a Sunday, a Saturday morning or a Sunday.
1:56:57 In the summer and watch the little kids running around and the big trucks coming in with their big trailers coming in and their ATVs and they can't turn around. It's an inadequate OHV staging area. We have an opportunity, at least I see, to separate the users, get them away from Shady Rest Park, which should be non-motorized, create a really well-designed, that would be the next step to get green sticker funds to design, right, an OHV, OSV staging area, which makes a lot of sense.
1:57:27 I commented at the Rec Commission, I don't see the, you know, I, actually I put forward, I was in favor of having the Ride Back Trail as modified. And I tried to think about this a little bit. As I said, I don't think this precludes having a Ride Back Trail in the future. But at this point, you know, to me, to have a good winter staging area and a good summer staging area and get it away from little kids.
1:57:55 That's key. So the big trucks can turn around. So that, you know, I mean, those are important things. And we just don't have, well, right now, and the old one was better than Shady Rest, I agree. The old one was not great. I know that from my days there. But, you know, we just didn't have the proposal. So that's where I'm coming from. We've got comments from two committee members. Any other comments at this time? Yeah, I think from the municipal recreation side, you know, I think the user issue is key.
1:58:25 I understand where Bill's coming from, I see where Sandy's coming from, I know it's always been a concern from John Regalbrugger about mixed use, I know we talk about special events out there too and so forth, but it is such a municipal rich, you know, environment for our community. So I also see the frustration, I think, with OMAT and with, you know, trying to weave all this together. But anyway, I'm...
1:58:49 I'm happy with the decision. I think there's a few little things to work out, but from the municipal point of view and from the town, we'd just like to see that segregation. How you can get everyone back and forth, that's probably the issue, but really, now it's really about how do we kind of make it happen and move it forward. Do you have any suggestions that you want to add with your comments on that as far as how to move it forward? No, I'm happy with the...
1:59:14 With the outcome, what stands, I just don't know where we're going to be able to do anything until the decision becomes final. We need to wait for the decision and I will make a couple comments on the ORMAT side of things because they do carry some responsibility in this and they are, if their other project moves forward, they're going to have some mitigations that they're responsible for and that includes widening and improving the road to access their wells. That's a huge project that costs a lot more money than building the staging area.
1:59:42 They also continually pay into a fund to the town to do the plowing bill that you mentioned costs so much of you guys. They're covering those costs already, and they will continue to cover those costs of plowing out to that area. So just to set the record straight, ORMAT already is taking responsibility for those things that through
2:00:02 Very formal processes we've determined they are responsible for. And there are lines where you draw, you can't connect them directly to 100% of this mitigation. There were problems with the new Shady Rest where it originally was. It wasn't meeting all of our needs. And we had talked, we had internal discussions about redoing that staging area somewhere else to meet the needs of the OSV user.
2:00:24 Before ORMAT was ever even in the picture, we were talking about redeveloping the OSV staging area, addressing some of the OHV use in the area, and so you can't hang ORMAT up for that 100%. It's not 100% their responsibility. We were already talking about doing something different. Their need drove us to think about it perhaps sooner than we were planning. Anyway, they are taking some responsibility, but they're mitigating some of their impact.
2:00:53 Since we can't do this, and I'll get a comment from the public in just a minute, but I'm getting the impression that, you know, we've had the chance to weigh in those who want to, and I feel like we just need to move on from this because we're not going to be able to take any action on this as it is. John, can you hold on to your comments then? No, I'd like to be able to comment. A couple things. MLTPA saw standing. Again, it's an invitation. We can have a get-together to get some of these comments gathered and led with the Forest Service.
2:01:24 Fred Zunio, I think, commented also. The Sierra Club did. There's a number of other groups that have standing that I think it makes sense to get together and have a conversation about this. The second thing is I'd just like to ask – I don't know if you want to – you don't have to respond to this, but our comments really had to do with what is the relationship of that node to the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. In reading the draft decision, I didn't –
2:01:44 It didn't even mention it. Yeah, so that's really unrelated. The decision to construct or not construct a facility isn't related to how we manage it in the future. That decision can be made administratively. Okay. So it can be part of the MLTS. It can be funded with MLTS money. We haven't figured that out yet. Okay. We're trying to figure out how to provide a better experience for the motorized user.
2:02:09 And mitigate some of the concerns we have with the conflicts between motorized, non-motorized users and the geothermal access issues. Okay, fine. Just because I, when there are other motorized staging areas out there that are coming forward, it wasn't clear whether they're part of the ML test or not. I mean, that's our primary concern is that if this goes back to bringing the standards manual forward so that these guys say, you know what, we are going to move forward with this, we got a grant.
2:02:34 The standards are in place for the kiosks, as mentioned in the draft decision, that that's going to tie and be part of one system. So I think that's important to keep on. There's nothing that precludes it from becoming part of the MLTS or acknowledges such in the future. Perfect. Great. Thank you. I share Bill Souser's concerns about ORMIT. And I think that when you start talking about your Winter Summit, it's really not clear what exactly is going on out there. And I think when we get to that item, I'd recommend...
2:02:59 Maybe talking about that a little bit. But again, I just wanted to extend an invitation. I hope to hear from some members of the committee to get together and maybe put some comments together that can keep this thing moving forward. Thank you. Thank you. I would think they would be individual comments rather than... Probably would be. Yes, they would have to be. On this matter, let's move on because we're not taking any action at this time. So, Steve, are we going back to... So we covered these three items and I think that the discussion then was there anything at this time...
2:03:29 That we want to bring forward from the SOPA list, or at least go into more detail at this time, or if we want to agendize it, or at least put together a calendar timeline for it. Is that accurate? Did you jump to number seven? No, no. No, we're still on five. Oh, I see. Sean's discussion is...
2:03:51 Whether or not we want to keep talking about budget items in the future or we want to move on. So I think my intent today was to just present this information. You'd ask me to blend all the information from past project lists or past approved budgets, combine them with the information provided by MLTPA, combine it with the information and recommendations from the trail system management plan. So that's been delivered at number five.
2:04:17 I've opened up the door with the vertical columns about discussion for moving projects forward for the budget. I also brought forward the idea that in those budgeting things in the future, there may be items that are currently provided by outside contractors that we want to develop and have town staff take on those responsibilities. So I'm just putting that out there.
2:04:42 The hour's getting a little late, so if you want to continue on with the agenda, I'll give you a call. Okay. And then you're at 8.30 tomorrow, right? Yeah. Okay. 8.30? Yeah. Sorry, Bill. Can I comment on this quickly before the chair? I think the other discussion part of this
2:05:12 Bigger picture is maybe some guidance and direction from the committee in regards to the methodology of how we want to really attack the budget. I mean, do we want to just pick off and piecemeal it? Do we want to kind of realign it to the priorities and strategies that we've adopted and accepted? I mean, how do we really want to go about, if we've got this timeline of two months, what's the best way to be most effective and efficient with our time?
2:05:37 And attacking this student. You verbalizing my question perfectly. Okay, great. Good. Because that's, I feel like what we have done in the past has been, you know, kind of piecemeal. Right. So I would actually like to take a more organized considering, as Bill Souser pointed out, that we're starting this earlier than usual, but as Bill Taylor pointed out, maybe it could have been done earlier. But it is where it is, so let's actually try and take this a little bit more strategically than we have previously. So.
2:06:06 Having posed that question, have you got any suggestions? I haven't thought about it in a lot of depth, but I think you need to align it with our trials program. We need to align it with our priorities that we've established. I think we've got to go through, maybe really just go through in one session what we have here and just consider what we want to at least discuss for either future funding or reallocation or whatever it is.
2:06:33 And I think the big picture is really looking at, you know, what is out there. You know, what do we need to bring to the table. So it's probably, I think it's like two or three meetings, really. One, to kind of go over this, two to consider new projects, and three to kind of weave them together. But always kind of, you know, bringing them back to, you know, what we're trying to achieve in a third year or five year plan, right? So understanding. And I think overall is really trying to pick out one or two things, you know, that we can really get done, right?
2:07:03 We're moving forward with Sharp. I mean, that seems to be like our priority. We've got some other ones that are underlying, but I really think we want to, if we want to really get some runs on the board, let's go after one or two big projects and, you know, get them done. My feeling is, and I thought it was well verbalized by the public earlier, about making sure that we're aligning with our priorities and exactly it was, you know, what are our priorities. So, having posed that,
2:07:31 You know, again, I'll ask, I'm not sure what the best way to really start in on this, if we're to have it done, or at least be formalizing recommendations within the next two months. Well, to a certain extent, we have existing ongoing projects, what we call, ironically, bucket four, which are actually the things that are annual, and I would start with those.
2:08:01 I would too. And review those and say, okay, are they still appropriate? Are they being funded at the appropriate levels? And again, using our adopted priorities and the trail system master plan as the guidance for making those determinations. And then we've got projects like the SHARP that we need to deal with because we're going into the second year of a three-year program.
2:08:31 So seeing how, what information we have from year one and getting a timeline from Forest Service so we can start to effectively plan year two and year three's work program, make sure that again, we're aligned with our priorities, we're spending the appropriate amount of money and where that's going to lead to. Because as John pointed out, we're going to get to a point where we have to start picking projects.
2:09:03 Millions of dollars worth of projects in that scope. And so which ones do we want to focus on and where are we going to start looking for money to build them? And then, I mean, those are things we're already engaged in. So dealing with those first and then, as Stu said, then we can go on to what's next. These are some big projects. If we can manage these large projects effectively, we'll be successful.
2:09:32 See, I wouldn't forget the ongoing, like the Summer of Stewardship, the Lakes Basin Stewards, those are the kind of, yeah, those are programming rather than projects. Right. I'm sorry. Yeah, yeah, you know, I mean, that's what I didn't hear. Okay. Yeah, but I feel. When I was saying projects, I was thinking anything, we're funding whether it's actually a physical project or. Right, right. And the oversnow grooming, whether it happens this year or not, we know we want it.
2:09:56 If it would just snow, we'd have it. So I would say those are the kind of things that's, again, that's an ongoing program to me. Whoever does it, whatever, but we want to set aside money and say this is a priority for us. You know, those are ones, the website, we know. I mean, yeah, I think we can go through, but I would agree. I think we ought to jump right in with the things that are ongoing and we can just make a list and say, yeah, yeah. And we've got a bunch of things that we've said are annual and we've got a number of...
2:10:26 Projects that we're into that we need to make sure we're seeing through to completion. Our governance? I mean, Steve actually gave a huge list at that last commission meeting. I mean, it was just, you know, ones that... Yeah, would it be productive to, just to keep this moving along, so this meeting here is kind of more of a policy review or overview as opposed to really the discussion that maybe formulated a little subcommittee?
2:10:53 To kind of work on start to, once the committee is firmed up on what it really wants to accomplish by, you know, what time, get a subcommittee working together and actually, you know, do this work, bring it forward to our committee, and we can kind of go over it, firm it, and then just move on. So we kind of, you know, we keep on track, because I just think this meeting here is just too burdensome to really get it done. Would you like to, are you proposing that that subcommittee meet before our next? Yep. Okay. So I think with the direction from this committee, we can get that subcommittee and start working on it.
2:11:23 Okay. And with some of them like the Sharp, you know, I think the Forest Service is going to have to lead us through what they want for the proposed ones. I don't know that we need to actually add any additional money at this point in time because we actually have committed three years' worth of money, which may, depending if everything goes smoothly, and we probably need to deal more with the trails that we would like to see constructed, soft surface, the trails that might be MUPS that we can, you know, stick public works on to...
2:11:53 Think about applying for grants and whatever, and then we can kind of fine-tune your grant matches sometimes in those ways also. So we may need some conceptual discussion in between before assigning money to things like that. Okay. Who would like to volunteer for that subcommittee? I guess, Stu, do you want to be on it? I was hoping Bill and Sandy would be on it. I can certainly assist. I'm curious to see when Steve's time is. We need to be conscious of the Brown Act issues. It could only be two. Yeah.
2:12:26 And then I was seeing if it was relevant to have the Forest Service representative at that same meeting, kind of move it along, and then what Steve's availability is to assist with staff. John, correct me if I'm wrong, but obviously because you're the conduit to the Forest Service, I think it would be very helpful to have you involved in that. Yeah, no, I'm happy to be a part of it. If you don't want to be volunteering. No, no, it's okay. I think it's just kind of a given that I need to be a part of it and invite it in where needed. I may not need to be a part of the whole thing.
2:12:56 Certainly, wherever you need me, let me know. I just wanted to throw out, this is again kind of piecing together my delivery of information on the SHARP after a conversation I had with John Regalbrugge, but it seems fairly important to mention it now. One of the things he said, and I've repeated in these meetings over and over, is what's really important for him on SHARP is that we have a comprehensive understanding of if the town is going to propose to bundle X, Y, and Z project together.
2:13:24 If two of them are soft surface trails, or even if they're muffs, part of that proposal needs to be a maintenance plan. Maintenance, maintenance, maintenance. You guys are talking about what money do we need to allocate towards that project. Well, maybe you don't need to allocate that money now, but be cognizant of the fact that we're going to respond and say none of this is moving forward unless we have an agreement on how to fund the maintenance of these new trails and the existing system. The summer of stewardship,
2:13:53 Great model. I think what we've explained is that it's bringing, you know, the Forest Service values, the fact that you're engaging the public in it. And you're getting some good work done on the trails, work that's needed. But it's not the high level of maintenance that we need to do on the entire trail system. And there is an opportunity, I think, to meet those maintenance needs.
2:14:12 Whether it's through, you know, I talked to John Ruggelberger about what does he want from the town. Does he want them to send the Forest Service money for a trail crew? And he said no, not necessarily. He, you know, he's very open to working with another organization, and Mono County has been working very closely with friends of the Inyo to provide friends some money for the maintenance activities in the June Lake area to demonstrate that Mono County can contribute to the maintenance efforts.
2:14:42 Of the trails in the area in anticipation that we may work with them on developing more trails in the area. And so I think that's another thing for the committee to consider is on top of summer stewardship, doing something in addition to provide a higher level of expertise and an additional amount of maintenance on an annual basis, even before we talk about SHARP, start thinking about that now, about how we can do some harder.
2:15:10 More robust maintenance projects and then how that would translate into the future maintenance of the trail system when we build new trails. Thank you. Can I? Yep. Sorry. I have a couple things. One I want to just tag on to what John was saying. You know, part of the Summer of Stewardship Program with Friends of Inyo has been the Lakes Basin Stewards, which are, we have had someone out every summer for the last, I want to say, five or six summers.
2:15:41 Who is walking the trail, doing trail maintenance on the trails in the lakes basin, providing visitor information, visitor contacts, and we would like to continue that program, and we can certainly work with you and with the committee to talk about if that is something that could be, we could do even more maintenance through that program. My question to all of you, I think, is,
2:16:10 You know, it sounds like you're setting up a timeline and a plan. Would it be helpful for you if we were to provide you with our vision proposal or renewal? I mean, I think our contract was initially established as a renewable for three years. Would it be helpful for you to have that in advance of the next meeting so that you can incorporate that into your discussions?
2:16:37 Absolutely. Yes, absolutely. Yes, absolutely. Yes, let's leave it at that. Because I think for us, as we've mentioned before, you know, it's really, it's helpful for us to have as much leave time as possible so that we can get projects planned and get things going both from the trail steward side where we're out doing trail work, planning the interpretive programs, and working with...
2:17:06 MLTPA, and the Forest Service, and the trails days as well. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Hi. So just a couple things. I look forward to working with the summer stewardship program getting those things figured out. To be clear, what John's alluding to in Morrow County is a little bit different in terms of what you guys can deal with because you're dealing with Measure R. And Measure R has specific language in there about the town's role in these trails. So if...
2:17:30 When you're developing that maintenance program, you need to talk about special use permits, liability, and all those other kinds of things. It's not quite as simple. What John's saying is entirely appropriate, and part of the reason why we've been taking part in the summer stewardship program all along is to one day be able to deliver a maintenance program for the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. You know, there's a lot of jurisdictional things that have got to get figured out, but that's something that's part of it. The other thing I want to caution to our dear friends, friends at Inyo with Lakes Basin Steward,
2:17:56 Paul's made mention that this is the implementation of the quote trail patrol. And while I appreciate the fact that it's kind of sort of similar, it goes back to the need for this committee to establish an adopted trail program and a formal trail patrol as mentioned and described in the trail system master plan. Let's get real about this. Let's get these programs figured out and moving forward. So every summer we go into things, we can be leveraging
2:18:22 Volunteers on behalf not just of the Forest Service trails, the public lands, but the mops, the stuff that are things that are in here in town, the bathrooms, these other kinds of issues. We really need these programs. And I'd hate to see the trail patrol be implemented by default just because no formal plan came forward. People just started doing things. We really need to get these things done and get the programs formalized and set up properly. So thank you. Thank you. Let's leave it at that just because we need to move on. But I think that Bill Taylor just asked an important question to me.
2:18:50 Which is, you know, is this subcommittee going to be just working on, how do you say it, the process or actually strategizing priorities? Yeah, because where it started was laying out the program, getting things lined out so that we could have a structure for the whole committee to review. Not getting ahead of it, not getting into the details of trail maintenance and what that's going to take. And that's why I think
2:19:19 Had getting the proposal from Friends of Inyo for our next meeting. That's great. It's probably not important to have that for the subcommittee meeting where all we're trying to do is say, here's what we're going to do first, here's what we're going to do second, here's what we're going to do third. Okay. It tells us that I think we could make some suggestions because we have, you know, we have obviously ongoing stuff and, you know, exactly in ones that may or may not fit in the vision that they submit.
2:19:43 So, Sandy and Bill Taylor, can we ask you to take it on as subcommittee? When Stu said Bill, I wasn't sure which one he was talking about. He was looking at you. Okay, I'm happy to do that. Thank you. And John Casimir, they would very much appreciate it. So you guys will schedule time to meet before our next meeting and bring forward strategy and suggestions for process. Steve, what's your schedule look like? We'll just have to coordinate.
2:20:11 You won't be back. I'm sorry. I won't be back in town until... Can we get you by Skype? I'll let you guys work on this separately. Can we let you work on this separately? Yeah, let's do it after. Because we really need to move on. Because I think we can meet and lay out some stuff. Sure. Mr. Chairman, if I could, I've looked over Steve's comments in terms of the representation of the MLTPA projects.
2:20:39 With all due respect, if I could get with Steve a little bit, we're going to talk about tomorrow, some of the things I think aren't maybe quite accurate, and so when you guys are making decisions about the status of various projects, if I could, if you and I could just maybe go through some of those things, and maybe I could provide you some language so that when you guys are making decisions, you're starting with the good existing conditions. We're not making decisions, though. We're just coming up with a... But it sounds like they'll work independent. And you don't need our permission to do that. I just want to do... All right, let's move on. One thing I'm thinking that...
2:21:08 In order to get ahead of this, maybe what we do with, or maybe this is something to talk about with our future agenda items, but maybe what we might want to think about is having this as the number one item on the agenda and taking up most of the medium time. So we can really get ahead of it. That would be good. That would be good. This is our priority. Steve, you and I will make sure that with the agenda we do that next time. Number six. Number six, yeah. Discuss and take action regarding
2:21:35 Directing staff to create a conceptual outline and list of potential discussion items for a Winter Recreation Summit process. And that could include scheduling, funding, users, questions, issues, etc. and include Project 552, the Winter Grooming, Shady Rest Trailhead, which now may be modified to the Sherwin Road Borrow Pit via the tunnel on SR203.
2:22:02 So the discussion here was that because there are many issues in regards to the use of our trail system in the winter and that the trail system master plan was able to facilitate a summer summit for its creation and deferred a winter recreation summit that now maybe is the appropriate time to start planning for a winter recreation summit and bring forward the players.
2:22:32 To Bill Souser's concern, talking about these impacts, what's the situation with the staging area now, if it's decided to be moved out, what are the recreational impacts, what are the mitigations that we might bring forward, how can we work together to create an integrated winter system use for our entire trail system. This could even include grooming recommendations, it could include recommendations ultimately.
2:23:01 And just to be clear, our action that we're working on today is really just starting the process, not trying to go into any kind of detail with discussions on specifically what we're trying to accomplish, but just
2:23:26 Setting up a basic outline, correct? Last time we had this as a matter of discussion, but there was no actionable items that came out of it. So what this does is, again, the action is to direct staff to create the process in an outline, and then we can come back and start moving forward with the next items out of that outline. You have a question? Would this be limited to the urbanized, urban limits?
2:23:56 It might, I'm just trying to think about the impacts on the Forest Service results. If we open up too big of a picture, it could be. Well, I was thinking, though, in terms of this summit and the issues that have come up that we've talked about, those were actually mostly outside of the urban growth boundary. Except I just heard, we're talking about, and there was potential for grooming of the special use paths and things like that, which would be.
2:24:23 To me, that might be okay. I guess I kind of would hate to open up the issue of the motorized traffic off. I mean, that's the kind of thing. I don't know if John might want to comment on that. He's got to have the partners because if, in fact, you know, it's off the table, then we shouldn't throw it out there for discussion. That's what I was asking. What do you think, John? Well, I don't think we're going to tell you it's off the table, but I think it's more about managing expectations.
2:24:52 No matter what you're talking about, if it's taking place on the National Forest, we're hoping that nobody goes into and participates in a Winter Summit thinking that it's a decision-making body or that recommendations will be implemented. I don't know. I would be very cautious in how you characterize it. I'd characterize it as a women.
2:25:13 Winter Summit brainstorming session or something because that's what it is when it comes to national forest lands. You can't be telling the public we're going to do anything that comes out of it. We're not comfortable with that. And right now it's just not our highest priority. Our ability to participate in it is going to be, if it's this year or even next winter, it's going to be very limited. And so I'm not...
2:25:39 I'm not hearing that you guys know entirely why you want to have this, except for it's somewhere in a document somewhere that said we were going to do it and where it's deferred. I don't know how important it really is. The OSV issues are going to be addressed in a planning process here very soon, and we're going to go through our formal process to work through those. And then the rest of the non-motorized use in the area, whether it's on MUPS or...
2:26:04 Or a lot of those MUPs are on the National Forest. I think we can have a dialogue here about, you know, what's most important. And maybe it's not a full-on summit. Maybe it's something on a, you know, a simpler level where, you know, some, this committee develops a set of winner recommendations that's in a short document that's released to the public and there can be comment. I don't know. I'm just, I get really hesitant to enter into these big collaborative processes when
2:26:32 When the outcome is a little uncertain. I think Sharp was really good. I think we managed the expectations well in that, and it went well, but you've still got people after we told them, hey, nothing's definitely coming out of this. You've still got people knocking on the door. When are you going to build that trail we agreed to build? And we've got to be very careful of that. I think the more you enter into these collaborative processes with kind of no real end in sight,
2:26:59 You're going to get people worn down and tired of participating. And we've got to be cognizant of the fact that everybody, you know, doesn't, you know, you guys don't get paid to do this. People's time is limited and their energy to participate in this is limited. So I don't know. I don't see it as the most important thing to do, but that's my perspective. My worry, what I was referring to actually in trying to limit it, I heard a potential from Steve to how to limit it and to kind of keep our heads down a little bit.
2:27:28 I worry about this opening up the broader issue when people say, well, I want to keep riding my snowmobile out of my backyard because that's the kind of thing that may, we don't need to draw a lot of attention to that if the Forest Service is trying to work with the town and with some of the other folks so that we keep the program that we have, which is the grooming. So that's why I was looking at, well, maybe we're talking about which trails do we groom for Nordic on our special use.
2:27:58 You know, one's within the town. Or, yeah, they go out along National Forest, but they're on special use permits, so that might be something we could address without jumping out into the undroomed area. Well, I think it gets back, you know, somewhat to what John said, and that is the why. And it has to be driven by more than just the fact that the trail system master plan says we will do it. Right. Because we decide when. We need to look at
2:28:27 I hate a solution in search of problems. We've talked about it before. We've identified some issues that might be appropriate for the summit. It might be worth going back and looking at the minutes. If, in fact, they're all tied up with OSV, maybe this isn't the right format. But if there are other issues and questions that we should be talking about, then we can identify both a conceptual scope and a geographic scope that's appropriate to the questions.
2:28:57 I'm just thinking, Chair, is there a way to link the previous discussion with this discussion? I mean, I'd be really interested to get the community input and engagement on our investment to our trail system. I mean, that seems to be, you know, we sit here, we do it, you know, we have good representation from our partners, but, you know, what opportunities the public really come forward with and how we want to kind of invest or what we think, I mean...
2:29:22 So I'd be curious more about that, and it becomes a little bit more specific. Again, you have to manage your expectation of what's really the expectation of the public when you're presenting whatever plan you have, and I know there's going to be issues there, but maybe this is something, I don't know, I'm not sure we actually have a winter. I mean, I don't know. It seems like it's a planning for next year. I don't know if there's any hot items that we need to really address right now. Stuart, did I understand that you're saying really just throw out there public?
2:29:49 What do you want us, town, to focus on as far as winter recreation? Do we need more sledding hills? Do we need more cross-country skiing? Is that just kind of a more general tell us what you'd like to see us work on? That has some type of framework to what we can actually deliver on maybe here, and I think that might be a good general way to do it. But not problem solving, not going in and saying what's, you know, it would be totally appropriate for a motorized user to say I'd like to be able to find a place.
2:30:16 I can snowmobile into town and, you know, go to a restaurant. Well, that's a comment that can be woven into a report, but it's not really getting to a decision in any way, shape, or shape. Right, I think it's a good opportunity for the public. And I think, I mean, you did one the other day with transit. You do two meetings a year with transit. You know, I think it works really well. I mean, we've got our trials committee. I think John's probably going to talk about that. You know, so we have user groups out there. So what opportunity do they have to kind of connect with us in regards to...
2:30:44 What they'd like to see, maybe. I mean, I don't know. Do you have any suggestions? I'm thinking of some, but maybe we can grab John's comments and we'll come back. Maybe a little history might be of help.
2:31:02 The Winter Summit process was brought forward by the then Recreation Director, Dan Stroud, to specifically look at issues related to the staging area and the tunnel and all that stuff of 203. It was thought by the consultants and by the tenant at the time and the Forest Service that it was too potentially contentious to deal with in the context of the trail system master plan itself, but that that could be maybe a breakout to take care of that.
2:31:29 Since the plan, since that effort back in 2007, 2008, 2009, things have happened. The Forest Service is moving forward with this staging area out there. I mean, you guys now are well aware of what level of standing the town has with it. Unless, you know, something crazy happens, I would imagine that that proposal, that decision, draft form, is probably going to go forward. And that's going to take several of the questions off of the table that that summit was designed to address. Perhaps if the summit had convened two or three years ago,
2:31:59 Maybe something might have happened, but to John's point about expectations, that ship has kind of left port. I think also the issues about the Rideback Trail going from the Sherwins area over to Shady Rest, that was discussed as part of the SHARP process. There's probably some documentation about that. It wasn't brought forward because I think it was felt as sort of outside of the scope and may not have been realistic, but that question, there's some documentation of that. So if those are the two critical issues, I think maybe the train's kind of left the station.
2:32:26 I would refer you again back to the Trail System Master Plan. It wasn't that long ago. It was 2000, I guess, 2007. There's a significant amount of work through the Camp Winter process, a lot of agency involvement that really documented existing conditions and needs. There's a lot of agency input. So unless you've got something to get into John's question, like, well, what do you want to summon people's time to do and what expectation are you going to match to that, I would just, I'd be interested to hear what ideas you have, but I'm not really hearing anything that compelling at this point.
2:32:57 I'll add one other note. There is some sensitivity you guys should be aware of. You know, when you get outside of the urban growth boundary, there are a few parties, I'll just leave it at that, that have expressed concern to us that Mammoth is trying to influence the whole county or, you know, the whole geographic area. And I take a lot of that with a grain of salt. But I think you just, I'll just mention the fact that
2:33:23 When you start, if you start laying out plans for, you know, the winter trail system beyond the immediate town of Mammoth area, you are going to hear some rumblings of people saying what's going on. You're getting into Mono County area now. You're getting outside of your kind of jurisdiction, if you will. But I think we've talked about that with what is the MLTS and, you know, what are the boundaries. And I think the Forest Service, we're very comfortable with how we've agreed to, you know,
2:33:50 Define the boundaries of the MLTS, and certainly it includes some stuff outside the urban growth boundary where people who stay in the Glass Creek campground are coming to Mammoth for dinner. But all those conversations need to give consideration to the other people in the area who may also have interests. I think at this point we need an actual suggestion on how to move forward. I heard Stu say, or somebody say, maybe we don't need to move forward right now.
2:34:22 My sense is right now, short of going back to the minutes and seeing if there was something else, most of the issues I recall were all related to OSV. And that being the case, I don't want to create issues just so we can have a summit. So my sense is absent depressing need. Can I throw up one other idea?
2:34:51 I'm happy to provide an update on where we're at with OSV, NEPA and everything, but as we get into that process, this committee may identify taking that Winter Summit idea and doing something that would complement the agency process. Once we get into the NEPA and the left side planning, left side is kind of before we release a proposed action, you guys may say, hey, let's have a community conversation about what we want to tell the Forest Service.
2:35:18 We want to see in the OSB system. That may be the right time to have your winter summit and focus on some OSB issues. That way you're not really defining a new process. You're saying this is just a part of the process that the agency is moving forward. As a matter of fact, that might be the good time to affirm that the community may affirm that we're kind of happy with the grooming that we have and the off.
2:35:45 It's hard to say. You never know what you're going to hear. You never know. You never know. Am I hearing by consensus then that we're going to table this? Yeah, I think so. Okay. Thank you. Good. All right. Let's move on to number seven, new projects. Okay. Yeah. New projects. For new projects, I've got a couple of things here. One is some information received from the Forest Service in your packet, probably three pages or so.
2:36:13 of the National Technology and Development Project Proposal. And so there's a brief outline in the cover letter dated December 20th. Then there is a sponsorship, contract, and proposal due dates. And then finally a blank official form for the project proposal. Has Murphy brought this forward?
2:36:40 Thought that there might be some interest and inability for the committee and the Forest Service to work together on this. So I'll turn it over to John for further explanation. This is an annual grant opportunity through the Forest Service Technology Development Center.
2:37:00 I brought it to your attention because this is one example of a place where we could go after federal funding to support some of the innovative things we're doing in the Mammoth Lakes Trail System. It doesn't have to be this year. It could be next year. But if you all, I would urge you to, just as we talked about the grants that the town in Peter Bernersconia are looking at, how does it meet your other priorities? If there is a project where you can see
2:37:24 This grant process fitting into the priorities that we're working on, then maybe it's ripe to think about doing something in the next couple weeks. But if not, we can think about it for next year. Since I've been in the agency, this grant opportunity comes out every year. And I was thinking of things like the QR code system, enhancing, getting money to do something innovative with QR codes or web-based information or enhancing the website.
2:37:54 I don't know. The ideas are kind of endless, but it's based on technology. I mean, these grants have been used to design the sweet-smelling toilets, the vault toilets. That was a technology grant awarded to a forest. They developed the toilets. So, you know, toilets to creek crossings. They bring in technology to prevent erosion. But they also are actually focused on kind of this, you know, the real technology that we think of, you know.
2:38:21 Gadgets and things like that. So there's lots of, there's ample opportunity. It's just a, it's something for us to think about. So to be clear, you guys are the grantees. Yes. So this would be something that you would, the district would actually apply for and get funds to.
2:38:43 Right, but we could also do something, we have the challenge cost share agreements and we could do a supplemental challenge cost share agreement where if you guys have, I think you have to avoid, I'm sorry, let's see here, to avoid federal contracting rules, the cooperator must provide more than 50% of the cost. So if we were looking at something where the Forest Service would get the money and we were sending it somewhere else to do the work,
2:39:11 And to stay out of the federal contracting rules, then the town or MLTSCC would have to come up with more than 50% of the cost. If we're not worried about that, and we wanted to go through federal contracting, well, then we can just apply to the grant, get the money, and either, you know, probably not do it in-house because we wouldn't have the skills, but contract it out and get something done.
2:39:35 Can counters, trail counters be part of that technology? No, it's not. It's usually something that's going to, it's usually kind of cutting edge, something new. It's a technology development center, so they want a project that's a challenge to them, that's unique, and it's, so just purchasing stuff or helping us further what we're trying to do doesn't really meet it. It's something new and innovative.
2:39:58 Do we need to, so we actually need to come forward with those ideas. Yeah, I just wanted to let you know, as I've told the committee in the past, anytime I see a funding opportunity that might fit into the MLTS, I'm going to bring it forward. And so this is one that you can count on every year. It's been, at least since I've been here. And it looks like the proposal due dates go from anywhere from February 7th through May 2nd. Yeah, I thought that I saw. Depending on the category. Yeah, yeah, I thought that I saw the kind of technology one was.
2:40:27 Okay, this is good to know. John, did you have a comment? Yes, just in our current scope of work managing the website, we have an allocation to, I think, respond to this. I would love to get direction from whoever I get direction from to sit down with CAS.
2:40:45 Look at what the opportunities might look like. I think the MLTS website platform is a perfect example for this. I can't think of a partnership between a municipality and a forest anywhere in the country that's delivering this level of sophistication of technology. I think it's a golden opportunity. And I know that with our current contract, we've got some resources to submit the website to peer organizations for review and things like that. I think this fits.
2:41:10 So I think it's an opportunity. I just would like some direction from somebody to do something. John, what would you think about that? Is that something that you feel would fit? Yeah, I mean, whatever John and I were to sit down and discuss and come up with, I know I'm pretty certain we'd need to bring it back to the committee and get your input and decision. So, yeah, I'd be happy to talk to John about the possibilities. It sounded like you had some ideas. You mentioned the QR codes. Yeah, it's just what popped in mind.
2:41:38 There could be that or there could be other things. I'm open. I'm looking at anything. Well, I do like this, you know, opportunity, and I think that this does fit in with our priorities, especially with us trying to become a world class. I don't know what was the exact language, but essentially this is something that fits into that. I'm looking for, I'm not sure where that would fall into on this category. You know, our next meeting, the Watershed, Soil, and Air,
2:42:09 You know, the proposal date is going to be after our next meeting. So I'm not sure if... Sorry to interrupt, but I think we've got resources within our current contract to certainly meet with John and come up with an idea. We could certainly submit that idea to, if it's before your next meeting, either to staff or to members of the committee.
2:42:32 Individually or something. April 4th's date, actually. April 4th is recreation. Recreation, yeah. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, this time. Yeah, I knew it was in the middle. I couldn't remember where. April 4th. Sorry. Well, yeah, I think it would be great to have you two meet. Thank you. Okay, sounds good. Steve? Okay, so the consensus is that John Kastnersky, the Forest Service, and John Wimper with MLTPA will meet and discuss.
2:43:02 Potential opportunities for this grant program. And obviously anyone in this committee or the public, please, if you have any ideas, forward them via email. Steve. To Steve. That's what I meant to say. Thank you. And then under new projects and also a future agenda item was the bike rack program. So in your package there should be some information there about the past history of the bike rack program.
2:43:29 So the first page is a brief synopsis from the MLTPA's performance report on that item, the deliverables and the cost and leverage dollars. Then the second item is the actual report on outreach efforts and feedback on Mammoth M bike rack in November 14, 2011.
2:44:01 The conclusions in there were that additional work could be done with that particular design, and I think there's also an opportunity for a different design. So I brought this forward because it had been requested in the past and thought might be an item we might want to add to the master tractor as a new project. So pretty much completes our business items for today.
2:44:31 And my suggestion is that our agenda for the next week just focus on tracking and budget. Yeah, I did have a question. I didn't know if we'd come up earlier or not. The new huge budget and tracking. Is this set in concrete at this point? I know that I was one of the ones that suggested that we put in all of the trails parts, and it's just like.
2:45:01 It's not much of a good tool anymore. It's very confusing. Does this one work for you? That's the one I'm looking at. No. It's still, yes, that is the one I'm looking at. Yeah, and it's still, I guess the master tracker to me is one that is really a useful tool. And this one all of a sudden is just, again, I apologize for being the one to make that suggestion in the first place.
2:45:31 But it's really wordy, and it's really unwieldy, and it's really like, hmm, I'd volunteer to work on a subcommittee with you one of these days to see if we can't massage it to make it a little more. In other words, I guess what I'm saying is... Yeah, if you have any suggestions, I think you should bring them forward, but let's... I don't know if I necessarily want to create an agenda item at this time. I think your point was well taken, though, that our next meeting, the agenda item, item, singular...
2:46:02 Should be working on that SOPA list. And I mean, it's no hurry. I mean, I guess what my suggestion is just kind of continue using our master tracker. Let's use it since we're already there. We're already talking about the agenda for our next meeting. So may I ask, will the subcommittee, Bill and Sandy, when you meet and we meet,
2:46:22 Will you ultimately come up with a set of recommendations for SHARP that says here? No, we're not going to get that. How do we get there? I don't know. That's what we're going to talk about. That's what we'll talk about, how to get there. Yeah, because we need to, I'm not quite sure how to get there either. I mean, we've set aside the money. We've got our three-year challenge cost share agreement. But how to select the...
2:46:47 The proposed action, I don't have a clue how John wants to go about that, how you want to go about that. You must have some sort of a decision sequence. We have lots of ideas and priorities and the resource surveys. In terms of you must have some kind of a decision sequence. You've collected some data. What are your sort of filtering steps? And that's what we can talk about. We don't have to talk about it. Yeah, I think we would need to do that because, yeah, it's not clear in my mind, you know, kind of.
2:47:15 Frankly, what I had envisioned was that the proposed action would be to carry forth with most of the stuff in SHARP as a proposed action, and then over time, what you do is you start, as a MUP comes up that we can put in for a grant, wow, as something else comes up that we can do with our, you know, with that SOS day, do it. So that's kind of, you were thinking the same thing, okay, and so I wasn't really quite sure.
2:47:40 When, you know, John Minchin proposed action, went, oh, you know, is he just focusing on a couple of trails? Because I think it's the opportunity to say... Now, if what I thought I heard you say was that information may have come up through the resource surveys that may have complicated one or more of the segments, in which case, maybe we ought to have a community discussion about it. But I really thought, as saying that, that basically the action was on the whole thing, and then we would be...
2:48:10 Picking off the pieces based on our priorities and planning. Well, yeah, I mean, I have been describing it to you guys as long as I can remember that we would bundle the projects into different NEPA projects. And one of the, I think we talked about very specifically, you know, John's got some concerns about anything going up to the bluffs because of, you know, when the MLTS Technical Committee, sorry.
2:48:39 TC looked at that. A lot of people raised concerns. And so we said, why would we want to kick off a project there? Why would we want to include that in our first round? Because there's just going to be a lot of competition. When you brought that forward, we heard from the runners that, in fact, that was a high-priority trail for them because that created the loop that eliminated bottlenecks on the Mammoth Rock Trail. So I think it needs to be...
2:49:08 It needs to be a bigger discussion. If we're going to start doing that kind of bundling, then we probably need to invite the public back in to listen and weigh in on that because we could have easily made a shoot-from-the-hip decision without having heard from the runners. It would have been the wrong one. Okay, that makes sense. Now you bring that back up. I think we just all need to discuss about our discussion. Like you said, let's have a discussion and we'll figure out how to get there.
2:49:38 We've got time. And I'll just fill you in on the rest of the conversation if you guys, if you're okay with me doing that. So, you know, the money that you gave us essentially supports two six-month periods, and that's how I originally viewed it as a planner doing this planning work, kind of moving it forward into six-month increments. But I've been talking to John about it as well. That might not make sense for a number of reasons. Maybe we need to look at taking that money and hiring one person for a year to just crank through.
2:50:07 All the NEPA we possibly can, including the Sarbanes projects and the Sharp projects. So I think that the timing of that would be, you know, probably June or July through June or July of next year. Maybe we can bump that up a little bit earlier. I'm not entirely sure. But what we're talking about is a term position where we'd bring in a planner or we'd bring in somebody to take some of my workload and let me do the work.
2:50:30 One or the other. So we're still trying to figure all that out. We're trying to juggle all the other forest priorities. There have been a couple projects that have surprised us that we have to pay attention to. One is the Lake Mary Dam. Just so you all know, you'll be hearing about that eventually. It's been determined to be a structure that needs to be replaced. And it's a big project and it's an immediate need that we have to respond to. We're hoping for some specific allocations that will help.
2:50:56 With the actual construction, but the planning falls entirely on the forest shoulders and we're being told, get it done. So that's a project that I've got to do that kind of messes with our timelines and then all this OSV stuff is certainly something we weren't completely expecting and it's another level of work. What I've been optimistic about is that both John and Ed have been supportive of making sure we follow through with our commitments that we've made and they want to see trails projects moving forward, but we need to have a discussion about
2:51:25 What's the scope, the extent, and then, you know, what will it ultimately cost? Because basically what you're saying is we, yeah, okay, I think I have it. I did have one question on Sarbanes projects. With Jessica gone, how would you handle the Lake Mary Loop part? Is there? Well, so, I don't know, I'm meeting with Hayes to discuss some of that here soon, and I did talk to John Regalbrugge, pardon me, about the Sarbanes projects.
2:51:55 And for Lake Mary, you know, there's a lot of controversy about one-way in Lake Mary, of course. And so what he asked me to pursue, and this is all hot off the press, if you will, but we're going to try to do some left-side discussions, maybe some community discussions about...
2:52:15 The problems that we're having up there. Take off where labs stopped and pick up from where labs stopped and kind of carry the conversation forward to see if there are other ideas out there. But when we did the resource surveys, we did surveys way up the hill behind the cabin. We looked at the whole area so that we wouldn't leave out any possibilities as far as putting a trail back there.
2:52:43 Or whatever. But we have to have some conversations about those other ideas. And I think a lot of people in the past have thought about one way in Lake Mary as the whole thing. And that's not what we're really talking about. Jessica worked and she left some really good documents for us that show the idea of one way in between somewhere around the Lake Mary Marina to that vault toilet, which is a very short, probably less than a quarter mile section that could potentially be a one way with roundabouts.
2:53:12 That would really improve, you know, from her analysis, would really improve traffic flow and provide the opportunity to have a trail there adjacent to the road and improve some parking along the area. But, of course, it does complicate matters for some of the people that are caught in between the lodge and the rec residence and stuff. So we've got to have kind of a conversation about it, left-side planning, discuss the options and see what people's preferences are. There were 27 options in our original meeting.
2:53:41 Meetings that were in years ago. Yeah. After we adjourn, I'll make a comment. I don't think so. You're right. I'm good. Yeah. Before I entertain a motion, I just want to say to John Wentworth and Laura, thank you very much for being here. Your comments and questions from the public, and I really do appreciate those very much. I appreciate you representing essentially the public with your comment.
2:54:12 So, at this time, I'll make a motion that we adjourn. I'll second. And I've got a second. Any further discussion? All those in favor? Aye. Aye. Thank you very much for your time. Good job. Thank you, Steve. Hey, we made it by 4.30. Yes. Good. Yes. Good.