Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2010
Planning & Economic Development Commission
· recording 3 hr 58 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
499 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 It's at 2.05 from this angle of the clock there. And if I could have Commissioner Tammy lead us in the flag. Thank you. Please follow me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all. And if you could call the roll.
0:33 Commissioner Clark, here. Commissioner Duncan, here. Commissioner Tenney, here. Vice Chair Barrett, here. And Chair Dugan, here. At this time we will entertain reports from the commission and is there anything that our fellow commissioners would like to share with the public as well? We'll start with Elizabeth. I have three short things. I'd like to commend Johnny Goetz in the building department. He's taken on the programming for code compliance and
1:01 You know, our outdoor lighting ordinance, which I was instrumental in, along with some other people in getting adopted, was passed eight years ago, and at last, we're having compliance, and it's really gratifying, and Johnny's a great man to do it, so I'd like to commend him for the really good job he's doing. He's a carrot, not a stick. He's just doing a great job. The next item is I had a meeting yesterday with Robert Calvert, who's interested, should the medical marijuana issue pass in opening a dispensary?
1:29 And as I was talking to him, something came to mind, and I'd like to ask our Community Development Director, Mark, we have in the draft ordinance, should this be passed by the voters, we have no more than two, and they have to be so far from school, so far apart, and only in commercial, general, and in industrial zoning. Does the Planning Commission have any discretion in where in that zoning? Yes, you discussed at depth, and Tracy was here reminding him.
1:59 Okay. In addition to the criteria established by the two different ordinances that will proceed, that you also get to apply your own discretionary findings, reasonable findings, as you consider any application. So you'll be able to have discussion about subjects that are not listed in the development standards but pertain to the general plan and the municipal code.
2:24 Okay, thank you for clarifying that. And the third thing is I noticed that the large trees that were planted at Stonegate are dying. We'll probably be dead this summer as soon as it warms up.
2:34 And I wonder when we're doing our code updates to be consistent with the general plan, if we have the right language in there for what kind of trees and how they should be planted and how they should be irrigated, because it's just a shame to see that investment and then we have to start all over again. These are very large trees and they've been hanging on and they're going to go this year. So I'd be very interested in being involved in that. That's all I have. Thank you. Thank you. Tony, do you have anything else? Jay.
3:04 I have one thing. I saw an article that I think has some significance perhaps for our town's triple bottom line, particularly the economic leg of that. The title of this story is Boulder, Colorado, a magnet for high-tech startups. And it says in here that Boulder, that is, quote, usually seen as an enclave of hippies, marijuana dispensaries, and rock climbers, has become a hotbed of capitalism.
3:32 So we may be getting closer to that depending on how the ballot measure goes on June 8th. Who knows? I don't know about the hippie part, but we do have rock climbers here. One of the statements comparing Silicon Valley, where they say you're a small fish in a huge pond if you're an entrepreneur, in Boulder you're a big fish in a small pond, plus there are the mountains.
4:00 And they note that a lot of communities around the country have tried to become the next Silicon Valley, but very few have the mix of money, universities, high-tech talent pool, and appealing lifestyle needed to hatch tech startups. And then one final thing I want to note, they cite the people analyzing this phenomenon in Boulder cite three crucial factors. Talented people in a high quality of life, technological expertise,
4:28 And an open-mindedness about new ways of doing things. I saw a lot of potential parallels to Mammoth here. Obviously, we don't have an academic institution as large or as diverse or well-developed as the University of Colorado at Boulder, but we've got a start on that. And it's just something to think about. We've got all the other factors that they're talking about potentially, and this is something that Mammoth could aspire to as well.
4:58 Thank you for sharing. I saw that article as well. I thought it was quite interesting. Chair. Especially if we could get digital $3.95. That would help. No, I have not. Okay. Thank you. At this time, we'll go to the public comments section. This is the time on the agenda that provides the public an opportunity to address the Planning Commission on matters not otherwise listed on the agenda. If you would like to speak to the Planning Commission at this point, and for the record, we ask that you fill out
5:28 A speaker slip, so we make sure that we have correspondence online as well as what we're seeing here in the audience. So if anyone would like to come forward at this time, please feel free to do so. Not at this time. We will have a public comment section again at the end of the meeting if anyone would like to address something else at that time. Okay.
5:56 Moving on with our agenda, we have a presentation period, and there is none at this time. There is no consent agenda, so I'm moving right to the public hearings. And let me just give you a little bit of the procedure that will follow today, is that I will open the public hearing, and with a statement and presentation by staff, we'll also, I think at this time, since there are so many points to the upcoming hearing, that
6:23 With the presentation, we may have questions from the Planning Commission, item by item, if that works, so we can keep things in context. Then we'll have a presentation by the property owner or the appellate. At this time, it's the property owner only. And then we will go back and hear from the public. I will notify everyone if you want to speak in support or in dissension or just a general comment on this.
6:51 Then we will have rebuttal if there's any needed by the applicant, and then we will have our discussion deliberate the matter and move forward. So the first item in our public hearing is the Snow Creek Development Agreement. This is the request for development agreement for the Snow Creek Master Plan for Snow Creek 8 and Snow Creek 7 projects within the 20-year investing period.
7:13 Its location is at the Snow Creek 7th and 8th Project Sites, approximately 260 acres located in the southeast portion of town. And it is, the zoning is R for resort and resort with open space, stream corridor, overlay and open space as well as open space resort. And it is, the applicant is Snow Creek Hilltop Development Company who is here today.
7:41 And I'll be turning the presentation over to Jen and Mark. Thank you, Chair and members of the Commission, members of the public. The purpose of this item is to allow the Planning Commission and Public Hearing to consider the application for a development agreement and to make recommendations to the Town Council on this subject. Your staff team today is myself, Jen, Ellen Clark, and Joe Pannoni, who is our special legal counsel on this project.
8:10 We work with Joe Pannoni extensively in many forms of development agreements. He has vast experience in disposition development agreements, development agreements, and is a town attorney for a number of different communities. Our applicant team is Mr. Messieurs, Mandy, Chuck, and Chad, and their legal counsel, Sonia Ransom. And these have also been the primary parties with Rob Clark.
8:40 Thank you.
9:10 Policy questions in addition that we think the Planning Commission should be focused upon and then listen to any other policy questions that the Planning Commission has questions with. As we make our presentation, because the subject is kind of complex in some ways and unique to the town, you don't have a lot of development agreements with the five major policy questions that we've posed.
9:39 We'd like to present each question and then rather than going through them all, we'd like to stop with the first question and then if the Planning Commission has any questions about what we've said, we'd like to answer those and then move on to the next one. Mark, can I ask a question? Before we get to the policy questions, can we just ask points of information about the prior part of the staff report? Can you? Yes. Okay.
10:05 So first, development agreements are contracts. They are negotiated between the private party and the town, and they're a discretionary action. So no one is required to enter into a development agreement. These are contracts that are intended to vest certain rules, and in the vesting of rules, that's the principal element of the applicant seeks.
10:30 The town is seeking additional benefits that are not usually or typically secured through the due public process of a master plan or a use permit. Neither an applicant nor a public agency is required to intern to a development agreement, so they are indeed voluntary. The development agreement must be consistent with the general plan. It cannot establish less restrictive requirements than the municipal code.
11:00 Our own municipal code, as well as state law, establishes specific criteria to be able to consider and then adopt a development agreement. Our municipal code has additional language to state statutes, and it specifically requires findings be made. This will be the decision maker, and this is the town council, but the findings need to be approved.
11:24 Are that the agreement is consistent with the goals, policies, general land uses, and programs specified in the general plan for the town. That the agreement and accompanying development plan are compatible with the uses authorized in and the performance and development standards prescribed for the zone classification. And in this case, you are principally vesting, there are other documents, but you're vesting the Snow Creek 8 master plan and the Snow Creek 7 use permit.
11:51 And as a development agreement, we are not trying to reopen the terms and decisions that have already been made. So the master plan, that image on the wall, is a summary of the master plan. It includes very specific criteria about use, density, access, parking requirements, design review standards, and other features. So we're not reopening that. And as you recall, phasing is established in the master plan.
12:21 As well as public access requirements through the site, both access entering and exiting the site. So we're not trying to add new regulations, land use regulations, through this development agreement process. Another finding that you have to make is that the agreement is in conformity with and will promote public convenience, general welfare, and good land use and development practices. And finally, the development agreement shall be shown to be of greater benefit to the community than development under present zone.
12:50 And I'll add an important concept at this point. At the start of this process, the applicant intended to process the master plan concurrently with the development agreement. And it's difficult for some people to separate the fact that in the master plan there are programs, facilities, and conditions that we would not normally associate with the master plan. So many of those were conceived with the development agreement.
13:18 And we'll speak to those later on in this presentation. But a good example is the championship 18-hole golf course. That would not be a normal condition of approval. It is not something that we can establish a nexus or a CEQA fighting to. So in that case, it's included in the master plan, but it's principally a component part of the development agreement when we consider community benefits.
13:44 So it's important to keep in mind that our phasing and sequencing and processing changed throughout this long period of time and many of the concepts that are embedded in the master plan that were intended to be part of this development agreement. The purpose of the proposed Snow Creek Development Agreement is to achieve overall greater community benefits than are typically part of the legislative review process. Development agreement is intended to achieve a couple of important concepts.
14:15 One is to increase the likelihood that the project itself will be built, developed as intended in the long term. As you know, conditions change over time. And when the town approved this master plan, this development agreement establishes a contract to ensure that that master plan will more likely be developed. That allows the...
14:39 Project, the applicant, and the town to withstand various economic changes and other changes that might be promulgated in the town itself. And by its very nature then, it ensures that the facilities that were intended with that master plan, the improvements and services that come with that are achieved. And essentially it provides assurance to the developer regarding the rules, regulations, and policies will be applicable to that future development.
15:08 By way of context, we know that the Intra-West Development Agreement was approved some time ago, and many of the components intended with that project have not come forward yet. The South Hotel has not advanced, the North Hotel has not advanced, nor has the Sierra Star Hotel. And so that just gives you a sense that over time, economic cycles come and go, and the private market is looking for assurance.
15:37 And so both parties desire to...
16:07 Realize the program and facilities that were anticipated by this project. The development increases the likelihood that it will be achieved over the long term. By way of background, we've been at this project in essence since 2006. It started with the Snow Creek 5 use permit and continued through the processing of the Snow Creek 8 master plan. In the processing of that master plan, as we began to negotiate,
16:37 Program, design, facilities, and the components of this development agreement. The Town Council established the Snow Creek Ad Hoc Committee and included Mayor McCarroll and Council Member Bacon and Planning Commissioners Dugan and Tenney. It started with Commissioner Sarri, who was later, that position was filled by Commissioner Dugan. That Ad Hoc Committee met eight times with both staff and the applicant.
17:06 And we discussed thoroughly the program that led to the master plan and the intent of this development agreement. So that was a significant moment that allowed us to be able to negotiate directly with the applicant and proceed with the master plan in this particular project. In that process, a couple of key studies were produced. First, the applicant prepared the CRBE fiscal analysis report, which documented estimated
17:35 Tax revenues and benefits to the town through the master plan and development agreement. And that was peer reviewed by economics research and associates who also provided a comparable analysis of other similar projects so that we had a basis, the ad hoc committee had a basis to determine if this was a fair program and a realistic program in the marketplace. And that ad hoc committee did use that information and did help.
18:04 Move this project to where it is now. In May of 2009, the Town Council accepted the application as is required by the Municipal Code for this development agreement and authorized staff to proceed. They established the negotiating team, which I've already mentioned. And as we continued this processing, I think the applicant started putting pen to paper and looked carefully at the costs associated with development.
18:32 and identified issues associated with housing mitigation requirements and our development impact fee structure. The Town Council established the Community Facilities Funding Committee, which was a broad-based group of people who were called together to help review the development impact fee program and supported by BPS, Economics and Planning Systems, Mr. Malter Kieser.
18:58 They evaluated the facilities in that program and the total communal aggregated costs of our impact fees and they recommended to the Town Council that they be reduced. The Town Council considered their work and has actually adopted by resolution updated fees. That group also started working on revised housing mitigation requirements and referred the matter to Mammoth Lakes Housing who has been studying that matter since. The Town Council
19:28 In November, established interim housing policies which changed the approach to mitigation and essentially went from a kind of total all in housing mitigation program to one that was focused on 10% of the affordable housing population, if you will. That group has been working to try to identify a reconciled
19:56 In lieu of housing mitigation fee, their work has not been completed. So that's a sense of background that has occurred since 2006 on this particular project. The essence of this agreement, this development agreement, is a request for a 20-year vesting term. That vesting would establish specific rules that would be secured and remain the same and not changed for those 20 years.
20:23 In this agreement would be between the town and Snow Creek Investment Company. The vested rules include town ordinances, resolutions, regulations, requirements, and official policies, including the general plan, the municipal code, which includes the zoning code, the Snow Creek Master Plan, and essentially the Snow Creek 7 project. The list of the vested rules is in your development agreement. It is attachment C for exhibit C.
20:51 It would also vest housing in lieu of fees, in a way, vest development impact fees, and it would vest town processing fees and review times. All of that also is spelled out into your project. I won't summarize the master plan. You're familiar with that. So now I'd like to focus on the aspects of, in exchange for those vesting rules, the community benefits provided.
21:22 The first concept is that the project itself provides substantial benefits. The second is the idea of an additional financial contribution. This essentially is a mathematical equation. We refer to it as up to a $10 million amount. It's more appropriate to think of this as an additional cash flow, an additional financial contribution.
21:51 that the town would receive with the issuance of a building permit. So it's associated directly with the processing and construction of a project, and it is dependent on a couple of specific points. One is that it requires those buildings to be built. If those buildings are built, then it would be diminished by how many units or rooms were not processed. Another way that it might be changed is
22:21 That not all of the entitled resort hotel rooms are suites. So one was residential units. The second is if the resort hotel rooms and suites are not constructed. And then finally, it could be changed. Reduced is probably not the right word, but changed is if the affordable housing mitigation financial framework is affected through the implementation of affordable housing.
22:48 An important point in this particular aspect is that the additional financial contribution does not have a COLA, nor do the vested development impact fees. Another important benefit that comes through the adoption of a contract is increasing the likelihood that the project would be built, and we know that the fiscal benefits have a greater
23:16 Probability of accruing to the town, and so we think that that's an important financial consideration. If the project is changed by some act of the town without a development agreement, then the facts and findings made in the development and the approval of the master plan would be changed and you wouldn't have the transient occupancy tax, the sales tax and property tax associated with that, as well as all of the indirect benefits that would accrue to the town through higher visitation.
23:46 The overall master plan includes a series of parks, open spaces, and preserved conservation areas. In total, there is about 8.9 acres of park and open space in excess of what is required through the general plan. That was negotiated through that master plan process, but again, part of the DA that is requested and anticipated through this.
24:12 Preservation of Mammoth Creek Open Space Corridor through a conservation easement. The development of a championship golf course, 18-hole, designed by a top flight architect, as well as the golf practice facility, also designed by a top course, golf course architect. Secondary access for the Snow Creek 5 and Snow Creek 8 project is provided.
24:39 And we note that as an additional benefit because of our traffic studies and the environmental analysis, we were not able to link that to a nexus requirement to the project. The developer in town negotiated this with the fire district, but it is something that is truly over the top from the master plan. Throughout that process and through this development agreement,
25:05 A lot of public sentiment was brought to bear about allowing egress and actually access of backcountry skiers, snowboarders, and snowshoers from the Sherwin Range, and that is included in the master plan and also in this development agreement. The applicant has agreed to programming of public spaces, similar to that done for the North Village area, and that's targeted on the Great Lawn in the Outfitters' Cabin.
25:32 Part implementing the town's economic development strategy, establishment of public access across certain points of the project, which I've covered in some way already, and then if needed, the developer will provide an area for propane tank storage. When the project was first conceived, we had a large area designated to a consolidated propane tank farm associated with the
26:00 Issues of growth in the community and not having suitable sites to put it elsewhere. We have since processed a use permit with the Forest Service and the propane tank is expected to go adjacent to the site, but in the event that that falls through or there's some unforeseen condition, this development agreement allows a contingency site, so it's noted herein.
26:25 One of the important concepts of the development agreement and input that we received from the Council was to make sure that there were appropriate forms of performance to make sure that this was implemented. We all now recognize that we're in a significant recession, a great recession, and unlike many development agreements and dispositioned development agreements, they are framed around an active project that intends to build in a very short time frame.
26:53 And in that type of a document and situation, we would expect to have an aggressive implementation program. X units built within five years. X units built within ten years. Infrastructure with those units provided in the same phases. The concept presented in this development agreement is, one, all phases are complete.
27:15 So when the applicant comes forward with a phase or a sub-phase of that phase, then it includes all of the components, trails, infrastructure, open space, amenities, affordable housing requirements. So it's an all-in phasing approach. We also recognize that in this economic market, we're not able to dictate reasonably to an applicant that you shall build a hotel within three years. We don't know when the hotel will be built.
27:44 We don't know when the market will be built. So we crafted a different approach. One is we're acknowledging that temporary access is already provided across the site in various ways. We've focused on implementation of the conservation easement within two years after the effective date of the DA. We've also attempted to create a performance measure that says
28:14 We're very concerned about the development. We want to see it move forward. And we're especially interested in the development of the resort hotel and the championship golf course. We see that as an especially important financial benefit to the town. And so we've created a disincentive. In the event that there is a marketplace for a hotel and the applicant is not moving forward, then we've created a penalty so that after
28:43 The first 10 years of the project, if progress isn't made, then one day from the vesting term is eliminated for every day of non-implementation. So, although we don't feel that we can reasonably require certain phases by a certain time frame, we're trying to create an incentive to perform on the hotel and then a penalty if it does not occur.
29:08 This development agreement, like any development agreement or any contract, identifies force majeure, which speaks to the fact that there are matters out of any party's control. Earthquakes, volcanoes, economic recession. It's not the town's fault, nor is it the developer's fault. And so it allows resolution for non-performance when it's not one party's particular fault.
29:36 The project includes annual review, which is required, and in this case the town manager will determine annual review and compliance with the terms of agreement. And then finally it includes default and remedies. So if a party is not performing on the requirements of the contract, then we're in default and then there are ways to resolve that. In our staff presentation,
30:04 Jen is most knowledgeable about the master plan, so we'll refer questions to that nature to Jen. Joe is here to answer the legal requirements of the DA. Ellen is here to help with specific housing issues, and then me. We want to make sure that you understand there are two components to this. There are legal requirements, and then there are policy requirements. Policy you have for more flexibility, and on the legal requirements of the DA, we want to be more precise.
30:33 So, that's an overview, and I'd like to go through these policy questions. Do you have any questions before I go there? Does anyone have any questions of Mark at this time before we have the analysis? I have some more. There's others, too. Okay. Excuse me, Elizabeth. Okay. Mark, first, I just want to confirm, everyone knows why a development agreement is good for the developer, but can you...
31:02 Do I understand correctly that the reason this is good for the community, from what you said, after we've worked so hard on this project in a collaborative way and came up with a really good project with a lot of work by everybody, that that means that this project will be able to go forward and it won't be changed by a subsequent town council? That's the reason that it's a benefit to the community as well as to the developer. That's correct. Did I sum that up sufficiently? It's not just the town council, though.
31:32 If the ways that the town's rules, the municipal code, the zoning code can be changed, those can directly affect a project like this. So you thoroughly evaluated this from the design circulation impacts. But your fiscal and economic development considerations were important to this. So you've determined that the master plan implements the general plan, the triple bottom line, economic, social, and environmental capital.
32:03 To protect this contract and to ensure that all of those benefits, whether it's the open space conservation or increased visitation or affordable housing, all of those move forward, that's what the contract allows and protects. I have a couple questions on each page, 1-6 through 1-8. Shall I just go ahead with all of them?
32:25 Sure. Is that okay? That's fine. On page 16, it talks about the pro rata will be at the time of permit for residential, but at the time of C of O, the pro rata contribution of the additional financial consideration for residential is at the time of permit and it's the time of certificate of occupancy for hotel. Why is that?
32:54 I believe that's done because there would be a single building permit issued for the hotel or phase by phase for the hotel. So rather than requiring that lump sum for the rooms in that phase, it would be by CFO per each room. Thank you. Then further on page 16, it says that the developers quote sole election, the additional financial contribution amount.
33:19 Can either go solely or mainly to residential units and not be applied to the hotel? If the developer sold it, can you just talk about that a little bit? As part of an approach to increase or provide some incentive to accelerate hotel development, the financial contribution now has spread to all units and all rooms, and we felt that it would be a potential benefit for the applicant to be able to shift, transfer those costs to the
33:50 Residential units, and then reduce the direct burden to a hotel. So it's shifting cost from hotel to residential units. So you're achieving the same total contribution, but it provides a little fee relief, if you will, cost relief from the hotel itself. And I think it's a business item. It's the developer's decision.
34:14 Okay. That's why we run it down. Okay. I'll jump ahead to 1-8 because my comments on 7 are for discussion. In the California Code section that was included in our packets, it says one of the requirements of a development agreement is that there be clear phasing and because of the economic conditions, you know, we understand why there's not, but how are we compliant with California Code? There is that general phasing map, I know that, but no dates, of course.
34:44 I don't know that the code actually requires a specific date for phasing. And so we're relying on the master plan, the phasing program of the master plan to establish that. And then your performance requirements are established in the schedule of development and milestones. Okay. And then why are we waiting two years to record the conservation easement? Why isn't that? What is the reason for that?
35:11 And why not do it immediately? We discussed the implementation with the applicant. We could have written it different. I think that you as a commission may add and alter and modify all of this language and recommend it to the town council. You might want to have an earlier start date. And I think this is a good point to frame what might come out of this discussion. So we have developed a document.
35:37 We have partnership with the applicant. We think we've negotiated per the instructions. Town council has given us in closed session. And we've been responsive to the comments provided, questions and comments provided by the council. And so now you as a body review this information and you make your opinions and recommendations. Some of them the applicant may choose to agree with and support. Some of them he may not. And so I think...
36:05 We will carry all of those forward, and ultimately the decision is the council's decision. And so as we wrap this and we complete Planning Commission review, our report will transmit both those agreed to by all parties and those that aren't agreed to. I'll save the rest of my questions for discussion. Thank you. Thank you. Jay. Mark, you talked about the difference between the community benefits that have come out of some of the prior
36:35 stages of this process versus the community benefits, the greater community benefits identified in the development agreement. We just, I think, yesterday afternoon, got the memo on Walter Kieser's ERA analysis, and there was some language in there that left me a little confused about that point, and I wonder if you could touch on that a little bit more. On page four of that ERA memo,
37:03 It states that the Snow Creek Master Plan specifies a range of park and recreation improvements and municipal facilities that are not required by the municipal code or CEQA mitigation or other town policy. These improvements in facilities comprise the greater public benefits secured through the development agreement. But on page 5, the memo notes that some of these features are included with the Master Plan legislative approval, which
37:34 Are they, is he saying that those are not included as new components in the greater community benefits? I found, I'm not sure what's going on there. In Mr. Kieser's review, as identified on page four, he's listed in two groupings, proposed park and recreation improvements.
37:54 And he's reviewing the information that was in the CRBE and the ERA reports, and so he's listing them. Some of them are actually part of the master plan that we reviewed legislatively, and then some of these are what we're separating out and calling the development plan. And the same thing for the municipal facilities. So in his review, he's aggregating them all back up, but in his...
38:20 Closing paragraph to that section, in total, the greater public benefits, including the additional financial contribution, the parkland improvements and municipal facilities, have a combined value of over $24.8 million and above the investments and improvements required above the municipal code or secret. So he's calling out a specific number that he thinks is additional to your master plan review. And then he goes on to say,
38:49 that even if you take some of those out, ultimately, you're receiving, in his opinion, you're able to make a finding that there is significant benefit with just those facilities that you're receiving in his comparative review and experience of other development agreements.
39:14 Okay, thank you. And another way to say that, for example, is if you just list the Great Lawn, the conservation easement, and the championship golf course, for example, you would be able to make a determination practically that that is additional benefit, mindful that the project itself is building its own infrastructure, implementing transit improvements, which we consider part of the master plan agreement. We're not trying to confuse you.
39:41 We're trying to set up the variable scale and the total basket of improvements that come with the development agreement itself. And the financial contribution is indeed significant. Yeah, one more. This relates to the phasing and performance, and particularly I think it relates to the 10-year requirement, the performance measure.
40:07 that you mentioned. In that section of the development agreement, which is Article 2.2.1.C, there's a mention of specific added performance measures. I think maybe what it's saying there is referring to the tenure requirement for the golf course, but it wasn't clear to me that that was the case from that language. So could you clarify for us what is meant by specific added performance measures, where it says measures in the plural?
40:38 What page are you on? Well, I'm on my notes, but I'll find it here in a minute. Give us the numbers. On handwritten, it would be 1-41, your packet. Okay, so the question is, in this contest, we've identified the phasing implementation measures, conservation easement, provision of public access across the site, and then implementing
41:23 By phase and subphase, the full and complete project. So section 2.2.1.C.2 is saying that concept of an incentive and also that it's deducting the negative performance incentive of taking a day off for every day that you haven't condensed. So we're trying to
41:54 Emphasize, please go to the hotel and rock champion, Jen, of course, when the market allows. Thank you. Anything else? No. Go ahead. Mark, I have several questions, some for Joe also. I first want to go back on to Jay's question regarding the community benefits that were over and above, and I just want to be clear, if I can read some off to you, that
42:25 I'm clear on these are over and above what you would find. And I know we've mentioned the additional financial contribution of 8.9 acres of the park area, preservation of the Mammoth Creek open space corridor, the golf course, the practice facility. Now the secondary access for Snow Creek 5 and 8, the emergency roads that would also consider to be over and above. The egress for the backcountry skiers, snowboarders, snowshoers from the Sherwin Range. And that's something that
42:56 Is going to be immediate upon approval. How is that going to be done? Is that through access through a trail? Or what are we looking at for that? At this point in time, we have an agreement. The developer has allowed parties to cross the golf course at certain points in there. And also, I think we intend to see access points throughout the master plan.
43:24 And what we, I'm thinking how we introduce any specifics with the applicant, because this is your point, to ask the staff questions, so we might ask the applicant to speak to this when he makes his presentation as well. Second question is, I noticed there was nothing in the DA that has a requirement that local contractors
43:56 Local business, point of sale is implemented into this DA, and I know that there are DAs in other areas such as Truckee where it has been. Do we have the ability as this body to implement language into the DA regarding that? You do, and as I said, when you have a recommendation, you'll want to know whether the applicant agrees with it or not, and so you know how it fits and how you transmit that to the council, but the answer is yes.
44:27 That's as a recommendation rather than a requirement? Because, I mean, aren't we negotiating also at this point? Right. And the negotiation is a conversation, you know, with the applicant in the room. And, you know, you have the public who no doubt will have comments and requests as well. And so you can make reasonable requirements, and I'm sure the applicant will let you know if they're not practical or they're not feasible and under what conditions they could do those.
44:57 Was there any discussion of geothermal, renewable energy sources, resources used in this project within the DA discussions? No, because we relied on the master plan for that content. Through the Chair, if I may, just to make sure the record is clear, your ability is to make recommendations. You can't establish a requirement. If the developer agrees with something you're recommending, you can go forward.
45:26 But if you want to recommend something, it's only a recommendation to the city council. We received the letter. We've received numerous letters, and this is for Joe. One of them refers that this DA, as I'll quote this letter, profoundly fails to achieve the basic purpose of development agreements and leaves the community holding the bag. In your opinion, can you speak to that, please? Through the chair.
46:01 Development agreement that's before you meets all the legal requirements, both of your code and of the state code. If it didn't, it wouldn't be before you. Regarding phasing, you mentioned that, you know, that we can't really put dates, of course, but we do say no later than two years on the conservation easement. So on the first phase, and it's my understanding, the first phase, and this may go back again to, as you've said earlier on the other things I've asked, but...
46:31 Are we able to put a time limit within so many years on first phase so that the trails are put in, meaning before development begins, or do we have that ability to do that today? You do. And, you know, I think the key acknowledgement in phasing is what's truly practical and feasible. And if it's an unreasonable requirement, it just won't happen no matter what is finally improved.
46:59 The practicality and feasibility has some aspect to do with construction, with construction financing, the sale of units. And then there's also the willingness, which is a different component. And so with the applicant, if you can determine that you think it's reasonably practical to implement, and the applicant is also willing, there you go. So those two things work together. So some of these are discussions with the applicant again.
47:28 And to see what he'll support and what he will support as it goes forward to Council. Access to the trails, to the Great Lawn, what are our guarantees that have continued access? There's no easements. Do we rely on the master plan? I think that the master plan itself has trails that are embedded. Some of them are part of the street system, love system, and some of them are more of a private trail.
47:59 And I don't know that we don't anticipate the Great Lawn being a stand-alone installation or project. It's principally related to the hotel itself. So I don't think we intended to have a trail that linked to a Great Lawn that wasn't there. So I think the key is from the trail's considerations, do you have reasonable access and when does it occur to the site in general? And then final question for you is,
48:26 After being in this year many years, and Jay, Rhonda, Elizabeth, you've dealt with DAs in the past. Were any of the past DAs used as references, formulas for them used in this DA, or are we looking at a whole new direction, say a more positive direction, success that we haven't achieved in other DAs? I think I'll say it this way. We reviewed a number of development agreements.
48:55 Disposition and Development Agreements, which are a different kind of document. We've looked at the town and intra-west agreement. We have reviewed the town and hot creek agreement. And what we chose to do in this case was focus on partnership, complementing and leveraging the investment by the developer and the town, hence the geographic nexus that's pulled out.
49:22 And have been very practical in what you can reasonably require and expect. So we're not trying to receive a swamp and then build a parking structure on it. And we're not trying to have a relationship with cowboys and Indians. For this to work and for this to be a true contract, it has to be feasible, practical, and mutually acceptable. And so we've done what we can to achieve that.
49:52 And we haven't established projects or facilities or requirements that we don't think will actually occur. One more note that just came up. Just to be clear so the public is aware, we're not establishing policy today. We are making recommendations through the DA to the town council where they will establish the policies if they need to be modified.
50:19 Right, but you are making determinations. You're making recommendations of findings. Correct. So do you think that the total package of community benefits is a reasonable exchange for the periods of vesting provided, for example? So you are making recommendations to adequacy. Thank you. Thank you. Sharon, did you have any questions at this time before we move on to the policy questions?
50:48 I guess mine's very simple. Could you give us the calculations from which the $10 million came from? Just a simple formula, how somebody arrived at $10 million as additional financial contribution? I think the developer can share how he developed his recommendation, and I can tell you how we have perceived that total amount with the other costs associated.
51:21 So in addition to the public improvements that are established and vesting the now adopted development impact fees. So the development impact fees are now established and they apply to everybody. So we're assuming that that is the reasonable amount of impact fees appropriate to everybody in the town. Those fees, again, have been reconciled to become the reasonable amount that new development can bear.
51:49 In the process of the Community Facilities Funding Committee, they have reviewed the total scope of those projects, and they've determined, one, what the fee amount should be. They've left the impact fee categories whole, but they've also identified future steps. One of those steps includes looking at all of the facilities and trying to reconcile priorities.
52:16 And it also includes re-scoping and re-evaluating projects so that the concept of some unfunded financial liability is not embedded in the DIFF program. And their concept and recommendation to the Town Council was that we have a true program that is financially feasible and phasible over time. So let's set aside DIFF. Next comes the
52:46 Costs associated with building affordable housing and meeting our requirements. Their project proposal includes 47 units on site, and the cost of that housing is calculated as a formula. So they're assuming a certain amount of disposable income that households can apply to a mortgage, if you will. They're also assuming an average median income.
53:14 And in their formulas, they've taken the highest range, about 200% and 175%. But using that formula, they're able to have a construct of 47 units on-site and then an off-site program intended to be modeled by Enluofi. And then what they've calculated is their bearable cost is 80 units per off-site unit provided. So with that housing construct,
53:42 The DIF, their own internal performance and review, which we have not required because of the previous information provided, they have determined that they can fund or pay an additional amount of financial contribution to the town of $10,000 per unit to a total, if everything's built, of $10 million. And that's just, to us, cash money. And we have not tried to allocate it. It is not dedicated to a use. We do not have CEQA documentation for...
54:11 A host of prospective uses, and we don't wish to enter into the political foray of what those funds should be used for. So we find that totally that package appears to be quite reasonable and beneficial to the town. You could have a different finding. Thank you. Do you have any other questions? No, that's it. Thanks. A follow-up to that, please, Mark. So is it fair to say that the $10 million is a gift to the town?
54:42 and that the town would not have required it as part of this DA agreement if it was not brought forward by the applicant. I wouldn't call it a gift. We would say that it's a significant financial contribution to the town, and it's certainly worthy of evaluating that and the other elements that come with it to the vesting requested. Thank you. Thank you. Are there any other questions of staff at this point?
55:13 Presentation. Then would you like to move on to the policy questions? Yes, I would, just to be thorough. And some of these we've already covered, so I'll be very brief. So the first question is, does the resort, hotel, and championship, 18-hole golf course milestone that we've already talked about provide enough assurance that they'll rebuild? We receive questions from the public and the council.
55:41 What performance measures do we have? And as we've already described, we have essentially milestones, but also the negative incentive of proceeding and taking off day for day after 10 years. So with that, I'll close and see if you have any questions on that one policy question. Does the annual review
56:07 From the developer include hotel market conditions and analysis of hotel market conditions annually. No, it does not. We did not specify the content other than good faith efforts in annual review. You may wish to add criteria or information. That would be a criteria that's important to me. Who initiates the annual review? The applicant would submit or the developer would submit a report to the town manager which would then be reviewed by the town manager and submitted to council with a report.
56:42 Jamie, do you have any questions at this point? I'm sure. Do you have anything else? I'm assuming that when you say one day for each day, I'm sorry, I don't know what it does. And you're not touching it. That if nothing happens, then in five years, it's a day per day. Could you maybe give me an example? Yes, it's 10 years. And so the point is, if we see a market, if we see...
57:20 It's practical and feasible to see a hotelier come forward and develop a project. We've made a statement that says, after 10 years, if we don't see progress by the applicant on developing and proceeding with the hotel and the golf course, then for every day that he doesn't proceed, we take a day off the vesting. And so if we add it up, so if he goes a year without performance,
57:49 The investment period would go from 20 to 19. The next year, from 19 to 18. And so, and the time value of the development agreement is significant. And so we discussed and beat each other up about it, and that was what the applicant was willing to accept in this current marketplace. As well, the town, if the town didn't respond, then we, according to the footnote,
58:17 Then we lose a day as well. Right. And that was our quick pro quo. One of the cost issues is, shall we say, a lackadaisical permit processing program. And so every applicant, whether it's a DA or anywhere, they want to see timely processing. So we've committed that we will be timely or processing. Thank you. Thank you. Move on. No questions.
58:44 Question number two is the affordable housing mitigation financial framework as described in the DA that includes requirements and variables that are less stringent than the current interim housing mitigation policy and if adjusted could result in a major decrease in the amount of the additional financial contribution. Are those framework parameters reasonable and appropriate? The essence of the development agreement is that there's a
59:13 A financial maximum exposure to the applicant. That's one of the aspects of assurance. And so, to be very clear, and this can be somewhat confusing, this development agreement does not establish an affordable housing mitigation plan. It doesn't set up, we shall deliver 20 units or 30 units. It sets up an equation to calculate the maximum financial contribution. And in this case, we're able to determine
59:42 That with an estimated amount of $80,000 per unit for those $47,000 off-site and that resultant amount of money and in combination with the $10,000, we're certainly able to make the finding that it's reasonable that an affordable housing mitigation can be delivered. We also note, and as noted in your response from Mr. Kieser in the letter dated May 24th,
1:00:10 That the housing proposal is reasonable, and as the town's housing program evolves, there may be different ways of mitigating or securing housing than only a new housing construct. So the now housing mitigation plan is modeled after an estimated financial gap or subsidy that is required to provide housing at approximately $209,000 a unit.
1:00:39 We've discussed at great length with the applicant what is feasible and what can be borne in the marketplace. And our applicant and also our financial advisor tells us that a straight out in lieu of fee of $209,000 is not practical or feasible. The developer simply can't afford it. And so then the question to the town in this financial calculus is do we have reasonable means of providing and securing future housing?
1:01:08 Are there other ways to do it? Are there other tools in the toolbox other than just building new? And we know the answer is yes because many communities have different programs and they could range from first-time buyer assistance, rental subsidy, purchase of deed restrictions, so on and so on. So we're not trying to craft the housing mitigation plan that would be implemented. We would expect to receive a housing mitigation plan for review in each phase, as already noted.
1:01:37 Really the financial construct of the DA, the $10 million, the affordable housing, the benefits and implementation. And I don't plan on going through questions A, B, and C. I think we have the report. So Mark, this would be basically giving assurance to the developer of having a number to work with for housing that
1:02:12 And I realize they weren't DAs, but if you go back to the Ritz-Carlton in 8050, they paid very high amounts for housing at the beginning of their project, relying on the fact of the market, what they could sell for. Then they only found out they could not do that. These projects failed. They went back to the lenders. Of course, the environment we were in financially had something to do with it also. So this protects both the town and the developer in those instances.
1:02:41 I think it does. And I can't predict what the best program is for a phase delivered in five years. It might be different from the one that might be delivered in ten years. And so what we're trying, what the applicant is seeking and what we've crafted is the framework, but then an ability to have different forms of implementation as conditions change. Thank you. Elizabeth. Mark, you said you weren't going to discuss A, B, and C, but
1:03:12 I have a question about C. The question, is it appropriate to disperse the on-site deed restricted units throughout the project site in the high density residential product buildings isn't really answered. So I assume we were supposed to discuss that. So make sure you ask us, if you have any questions, ask us on everything. In this particular case, I think it's important to note that high density is somewhat of a misnomer.
1:03:41 We don't see 10, 8, or even 5-story buildings in this project. And based on our experience, I'll just pass this around. I don't know if you brought yours. The applicant has suggested that the affordable housing be included in each phase, which includes those types of particular units. And so what you see is a three-story type of unit.
1:04:12 And in our review of other projects, we don't think that that's an unreasonable place for housing. You could have a different view. And, you know, Ellen is here principally to talk about housing issues for you. So if you have any questions on A, B, C, D, D, F, please raise them and then we'll go on. Any further questions?
1:04:50 Well, first, I want to follow up. No, go ahead, Sharon. I was just going to follow up on what you said. The size of these high-density residential, what would we have for size? Because one of the big concerns is livability for the affordable housing. And in a smaller unit, that might be appropriate for a week or two, but for...
1:05:20 27, you know, 24-7 it might not be. Jen first. The high-density residential buildings as described in the staff report are up to 45 feet, three-story buildings with understructure parking double loaded. I'm talking about the unit itself in terms of livability.
1:05:45 Okay, the master plan doesn't speak to those specific sizes. So we don't really know whether it would serve for a family to live in. The applicant has discussed there being a range of unit sizes from one to four bedrooms where there being an average two-bedroom unit size. So one would expect those to be commensurate with the other units in those high-density residential buildings, not necessarily larger or smaller, but in a similar range to those.
1:06:14 And as far as livability goes, there's many dimensions to that equation, not just how big or small the unit is, but what sort of storage is provided, how the units are laid out, and how they function, what sort of access you have to amenities and open space, balconies or open space areas outside of the unit itself. So there's a lot of different dimensions beyond just the literal size of the unit.
1:06:41 I guess I would like to see a comparison between a high residential and in the sense, again, that one is going to be much more livable than the other. I think I'd say that as we proceed and the applicant has to provide a true affordable housing implementation plan with each phase, we will review it. We're not going to accept a 70 square foot bedroom. That was a mistake.
1:07:11 Been there, done that, right. And, you know, we have livability criteria that we've jointly developed with Mammoth Lakes Housing. In fact, it was spawned by the Shady Rest-Hidden Creek Crossing project. So you have protection in that, and as the Planning Commission reviews subsequent use permits, you will be seeing that information and acting on it. So it may not all be in one area.
1:07:38 Right. And I don't think it's the applicant's intent nor ours that we've concentrated affordable housing and icky units. The applicant doesn't want to have the icky units. Shall I go ahead? Sure. Go ahead. Okay. The interim affordable housing policy was used or not used? It seems to me it was not utilized in all of these. It is used because the
1:08:08 The essence of the affordable housing policy is a 10% requirement. And the 10% requirement is substantially met. We do have some, there are some issues with numbers and FTE calculations, but then essentially beyond that, then the financial framework comes into play. And again, this is one of the hard parts with the financial equation versus seeing and acting on an implementation plan. It could be that out of the financial framework,
1:08:37 We want to see a program where there are 80 and 100% AMI-related units, but that will change the financial equation. So the maximum amount is established, but we can maneuver within that. It could be that you would like to achieve a program that also works for the developer where you have more 200% AMI units in order to leverage some more lower affordability units.
1:09:04 So we have flexibility to work within that, but what we're not, what the applicant doesn't want to do in order to set a financial cap, we're not trying to specify strict affordability requirements and all the other program requirements that come with affordable housing plan. That's why we're calling it the framework. Well, the developer says the workforce housing will equal X, and our existing policy says Y.
1:09:34 And there's considerable difference, and I'm having difficulty reconciling the two. I think there's no effort to meet the requirement, not no effort, but beyond the 10% inclusionary requirement, the developers proposing, as Mark suggested, a framework of assumptions, really, about what their affordable housing will constitute, and it's not, that was not developed.
1:09:59 Right. Absolutely.
1:10:30 If I may, and if I may through the chair, and the legal construct that that was done under is in your municipal code, the framework that says you can do that if you have findings that are made. The 17.3 steps. I think in a way what this is suggesting is one shoe does not fit all.
1:10:57 And different programs can be presented and reviewed over time. We also, I think most people would agree that there's some finite financial contribution that's on the table. And whether you realize that in cash or amenities or on-site housing, this document provides a balance and some flexibility to maneuver within that. And you can ask the applicant if he would contribute more than $10 million. He is here.
1:11:30 Sharon, did you have any more questions at this point? You'll have an opportunity to ask more. Okay, well, I'm just very concerned that interim housing policy that was passed in, you know, last, what, six months ago? Is not being followed. And if it were, then that would really impact the $10 million. So that's a concern that I have. I think what you're saying, just for me, is...
1:12:01 The literal application of that policy to an affordable housing plan, we are not doing that. We're coming, and I agree that that's not what this has in it. And in order to get to this financial place, we have discussed with the applicant the total amount of funding available. The applicant is, I think, intends to implement the housing program that's described in this master plan, which is the zoning for this site.
1:12:30 We've discussed at length the ability to establish a Belarus district to create additional financing sources. We have discussed at length transfer tax that would create additional fees by sale of units. And ultimately, it just comes down to the bottom line. What is the bottom line? And one of the difficult issues is we can ask for...
1:12:59 A circus and a host of amenities, but that doesn't mean that they're financially practical and feasible. And so with the information that we have with the CRBE and the EPA work and the review by EPS and the partnership that I think we've developed with our applicant and the community has developed through that master plan, we're all working towards a place that is desirable, practical and feasible.
1:13:30 So that's what we presented. Okay, thank you. Elizabeth. More housing questions for Ellen. Ellen, I need some context here. The interim housing ordinance was adopted in November of last year, right? Yes. And when we did the old Mammoth Place approvals, it was with the understanding that they would accept whatever the ultimate housing mitigation requirements were, provided the town made all possible good faith efforts to get it done in one year.
1:14:00 Now, the in-lieu fees are under discussion. Correct. And the in-lieu fees have nothing to do with the in-lieu fees in here? The in-lieu fees, there's two types of in-lieu fee that are established in the interim housing policy. One is just for the projects that can't build on site, small residential projects, for example. And those are set at a certain level. And the $209,000 fee, which is the off-site.
1:14:24 In lieu fee, when you come forward with an alternate housing mitigation plan, is a fee that has been developed by Mammoth Lakes Housing, vetted, reviewed by independent economic consultant and determined to be the actual gap of constructing a new unit. As Mark suggested, there may be other ways to develop, to build, to facilitate people.
1:14:49 Getting into housing in Mammoth Lakes, that may not be as expensive as $209,000 per unit. And one of the tasks of the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board and of the town as we begin to analyze the work towards revising the housing ordinance and the housing fee is to do some additional work to determine what the effectiveness and the cost of all those various strategies are.
1:15:15 At the time that future phases of Snow Creek move forward and come forward with their actual alternate housing mitigation plan, they may be able to take advantage of some of those other strategies that have been developed and fleshed out more through this upcoming process. Okay. All the communications we've had from the Housing Foundation from board members Kirk Stapp and Bill Taylor and from Executive Director Pam Henry have all been about new construction. That's the only new construction, new land. That's the only thing that's been considered. No other.
1:15:42 Option for providing housing, and they're at least half a dozen. The board does have what they call the housing toolbox, which is a range of strategies. We've only heard one. Haven't really been priced or looked at, I think, in a particular financial manner. Okay, thank you. Tony, you had a question? Please. Ellen, 11 of 23, 1-11, under D, last paragraph for the sites.
1:16:11 Municipal Code 17.36.030C, and it talks about the one FTE equals 250 square feet of mitigation housing. The last sentence says, therefore, the proposed FTE calculation would increase the value of the developer's FTE credits and reduce the total amount of their mitigation.
1:16:30 So can you elaborate on that, Mark? I think what it's saying is that the applicant has used a particular calculation method essentially saying that one FTE equals one credit, and by taking a larger amount of credit for those FTEs, obviously, they're reducing their overall cost burden for providing those housing units.
1:16:51 Based on our analysis and the previous way that the town has interpreted the municipal code with regard to the relationship between FTEEs and units, one FTE does not typically equal one unit for the reason that you house more than just employees in a housing unit. And it has nothing to do with livability. This is just a mathematical calculation about the relationship between FTEEs and FTEEs.
1:17:20 Did anybody say the words full-time employee equivalent? Because we throw around these acronyms and it's a whole other language. So in fact the 16.5 FTE units does not equal.
1:17:42 The FTE does not equal the 16.5 units. In our analysis and based on the way that we previously applied the code, that equation would not be there. Now, there may be a reason to accept such an interpretation of the code for the various financial reasons that we've discussed, but that hasn't been the typical way that we've done it in the past. And I'm still having difficulty with the policy that requires them being built on site, and they are not.
1:18:11 Again, the applicant is suggesting that something different needs to occur in order for the project to be financially feasible and for that amount of housing to be provided. Building them all on site is not financially feasible in their calculation. But we did use the policy in putting this together, the DA? We reviewed the policy. We reviewed it. We did not utilize it. We're not trying to apply that policy. Thank you. But it's fair to say that that current policy...
1:18:42 Could be stated as a failure also. I'm sorry, say that again? I'm actually asking Mark. Oh, excuse me. You know, I think the challenge we have, and I'll go back to the work on the impact fee. As Ray Jarvis and I have reviewed 16 different documents to get the array of public facilities that are required to be funded through death.
1:19:03 And we find that there's not extensive policy linkage and analysis in many of those plans. And it's very difficult to determine, you know, is a dog park more important to the community right now than housing or a roadway or a parking structure? Information isn't provided in a way.
1:19:25 So they can be reconciled and true priorities established based on some criteria on economic development or housing. So they're not balanced. We also find that some of the documentation is perhaps faulty and in need of review. The 1994 Parks and Recreation element of the general plan estimates there will be 10,000 permanent residents in the town by the year 2010. There aren't. It's 2010.
1:19:51 Plus or minus 7,000. And we'll find out through the census. And so it's really important for foundational documents to be based on true demand. And that includes employment generation, employment related to jobs, and making sure that we're tailoring all of those facilities, including housing, to what our true demand does. That knowing the size of the pie that needs to be met, arraying the toolbox,
1:20:21 to what we can afford and what we can achieve. All of our advisors agree that a financial gap at $209,000 for affordable housing may not be a feasible fee. A fee may not necessarily equate to gap. And if that's true, then we're going to have to find different paradigms to work with that. Perhaps we are emphasizing other tools in the toolbox.
1:20:51 Or perhaps we look at each case differently and say, for example, those things that are really difficult for the town to achieve, new construction, emphasizing that with new development might be a better strategy. So this, again, is a financial construct that is protecting the applicant to some degree and we think gives the town...
1:21:10 reasonable ways to implement housing, but not exclusively through new construction. Because if it's new construction, it'll be very difficult for you to make a literal finding that off-site is better than on-site because of the essence of the housing gap. So in this, we'll be suggesting to you that you're making a finding that you're consistent with code through the total financial package provided.
1:21:36 And that you can reasonably achieve greater benefits through different approaches. So let me maybe frame this as we're not in discussion and we're in questions. And maybe this would help Sharon too. We have an interim, we had our current policy, we have an interim policy, and it's that, it's an interim policy. Well, we wait to finally adopt a new policy on housing. So what we're doing here is doing the framework for what our recommendations would be to council.
1:22:08 Regarding a new policy. It will influence, yes. Thank you. It's really unfortunate that we can't wait for the housing group to meet and give us some their influence, which would be very helpful. They have been struggling since November, and I'm sure that they'll continue to refine with the town those programs. But they haven't had an opportunity to react that regularly until after their meeting.
1:22:42 Yes. We've had opportunity, but it has not come. You don't hold up a process for waiting for hours. Well, I just think their information would be very helpful. So we're not in comment, we're in questions, so do we have any more questions at this point? Can I move on to number three? This is a policy question, a procedural policy.
1:23:09 Is the revised process for the approval of on-site public art and planning commission described in the DA acceptable? The applicant agrees to install public art consistent with the master plan, which is generally consistent with the municipal code. The municipal code allows an alternative processing process, an alternative compliance with the program, and the applicant has spent tremendous time with the community and the planning commission and staff.
1:23:38 in developing the neighborhood district planning process that led to this master plan. And they believe strongly that it's important to maintain that integrity of placemaking, of landscape, of integrating public art with the project and the public improvements, and that the public art program should be considered with each phase. And so they have suggested that the Planning Commission
1:24:06 Consider and approve the public art associated with each use permit. Simple as that. No questions? Questions? No questions. If the public art fees were applied, what would they do? 8% of construction value. The preference of public art is to have it installed on site. Right. I can't tell you off the top of that. Okay. So there is not a number?
1:24:38 Right, but we haven't calculated it because they're not suggesting that they pay the fee. They want to install it on site. I understand that. Just curious what the fee would be. The next question is, is it reasonable to vest or freeze building permit and application processing fees subject only to the COA? So are fees now a cost of living increase? And that cost of living increase...
1:25:10 Accounts for inflation. InterWest had a coal in it, or has a coal in it. The InterWest DA did not vest these types of fees. Hot Creek? The Hot Creek DA actually vested DIF at zero. Which means it waived DIF. Exactly, so DIF was waived. Any other questions? Have you seen agreements where that cost of living, the impact of that is shared between the developer and the
1:25:51 Municipality? Not in development agreements, but I have seen financial participation in rent, for example, between an agency and a developer. Excuse me? I know our town's fees have been very controversial and have been adjusted several times. Does this, to staff, even seem like it would reasonably cover the cost of processing applications to have only a COLA adjustment?
1:26:23 Or a cost of living adjustment? You know, I think it's a policy decision that could go either way. We hope that our processing fees continually decrease because we've become more and more efficient up to some point in time. On the other hand, if for some reason our fees do increase, then that result would be a general fund impact.
1:26:50 And if it's a general fund impact, you'd be evaluating that in the context of the fiscal benefits generated by the project itself. So we don't have any idea what the general fund, how much it would subsidize the development? We don't know if it would require a subsidy. It's a maybe. And so some documents will invest fees like this and some won't. Being this was a negotiation, would it be fair to say that if the COLA was added in, the $10 million could go away?
1:27:25 I mean, if it's up to, it's a negotiation point. The applicant would probably say that. They've looked at these as all in costs, and that's their position. Any other questions on board? No. You proceed, Mark. Thanks. The last question that we'll review is, is more control of possible assignees than described in the VA desire? The purpose of this is,
1:28:00 As the project proceeds, it is reasonable to expect that the developer could sell portions or could sell all of the project to somebody in the future. And so the question is how much review and involvement should the town have. The town has a good relationship with this developer, but the successors may not be this good. And so the question is how much approval is required.
1:28:30 However, with that being said, this is not intended to be some means to thwart the developer to be progressive. And so the question is, how much control should we have, reasonable review, to make sure that any future owner or developer is qualified, is financially capable, and has some proven track record?
1:28:57 The applicant is very wary about entering into a process where special interest groups or the town council can delay and delay and delay and delay. And that is a very reasonable and legitimate issue. The town, we think that, you know, we want to make sure that we're not getting somebody who won't deliver the project as we're supposed to. Any questions on that? Yes. Mark,
1:29:28 Must have significant experience in the real estate industry and sufficient financial capacity to fulfill the developer's obligations under the DA. I know that the town can't determine to whom the developer transfers rights or sells the property, but that's almost in the eye of the beholder. That's very limited objective analysis of what the successor would be capable of performing.
1:29:58 Don't we need more criteria? That's the issue. That's the issue. Good. That basically is the issue whether you want to have more control than just that. I'm not going to say it's a very limited analysis that we've done because it's very significant that we have to find someone who financially would be capable, but just because, for lack of saying it a different way, just the fact that someone may have a good record of producing things and may be financially capable,
1:30:27 They may not be the type of person who has the same concepts as to wanting to assist a community for the community's benefit, not just for their own pocketbook, and without that kind of ability to control, the town doesn't have that option. So it's purely a policy decision for your recommendation for the town council to make a decision on. I'll save it for discussion.
1:30:56 So that concludes our list of questions. We've provided you with all the information we have on this. I'll close with our recommendation, which is staff recommends that the Planning Commission discuss and make recommendations to the Town Council for all of the policy questions and any other questions that you have and recommend that the Town Council find Development Agreement 09001 consistent with the Municipal Code, Chapter 1748, Snow Creek.
1:31:23 8 EIR and Snow Creek, 7 mitigated negative declaration and approved development agreement 09-001, including the findings in all conditions of approval. Thank you. Thank you, Mark and the staff. At this time also, I would like to open it up to our applicant if you'd like to add additional statements, and I really appreciate the public, your patience with all this. Hopefully it's answering questions as we go, too, that
1:31:56 When it gets time for everyone to speak that we've facilitated in some way. But at this time, let me open the floor up to Chad or Chad Wilson. Thank you, Chairman and fellow Commissioners. I'm Chuck Landy with Snow Creek Investment Company, Snow Creek Hilltop. First of all, I'd like to thank staff and the negotiating committees for their hard work. This agreement does have some pieces that were...
1:32:30 What do you say? Not really fond of, but they're fair, and fair is fair on both sides, and I think they did a great job in negotiating on behalf of the city or the town. You might want to take a couple seconds and address. You got a couple letters. They both say the same thing, and they deal with Mammoth Lakes Housing policies. I think it's a great program. I think what's been portrayed maybe
1:32:59 And the people that wrote them, by the way, are friends of ours. I hope they still are after this hearing. We have a couple times in the past agreed to disagree on items, and that's what life's all about. Not everybody agrees to everything. But perspective, I think, is key. When county council decided to review development impact fees and affordable housing fees, they really said to themselves, how do we stack up to other communities? Is the program proper?
1:33:28 Frankly, put together, is it implemented properly? The community facilities, I know I'm doing that. The CFFC committee first started by saying, is our program proper? DIF is just part of that. How are we covering and paying for our infrastructure, both new and maintenance? And what should we do? They turn to a consultant.
1:33:56 That most people on the committee, including me, have never heard of Walter. Turns out Walter had been involved in many communities. And they asked Walter to look at that program. Talk to us about how it's put together, how it's implemented, how each of the pieces work. And what came out of that was the new proposed program that really looks at DIF based on a nexus analysis. Who should pay for what? How should it be paid for?
1:34:24 What's the town's greatest success of getting all these pieces paid for? And it broke it up into various components. And at the same time to the Affordable Housing Program and asked Mammoth Lakes Housing to bring in a third party and look at that as well, done at about the same time. They did adopt interim ordinance. Just for the record, part of it we endorsed, which was the 10%.
1:34:47 Part of it, for the record, we didn't endorse and attended those board meetings because it didn't make sense. We're involved in other communities with other programs. And the 209,000, quite frankly, economically doesn't work. It doesn't work in other communities where construction costs are less. It doesn't work here. Did we disagree with that gap analysis? No. That wasn't the point. The point was what works. For us, we won't enter into an agreement. That's not fair for both parties.
1:35:17 We won't enter into an agreement to, you know, agree today so we can retrade tomorrow. That's not fair. That's not ethical. I think that's a key element. DAs are beneficial to both parties. Yes, for the developer, it does lock in. What is that? I think it's upstairs on the tent that's going upstairs. For the developer, it does lock in. It's a lock-in process.
1:35:49 But most would say that it benefits the city or the town more than the developer because it ensures the likelihood, the greater likelihood of the financeability of a project so that it can come to fruition. This hotel is key to us, quite frankly, from a branding and value perspective. It's key to you from a branding and value perspective in TOT. Let's not put ourselves in a box such that it can't be built. We want to make ourselves...
1:36:18 Financially capable of letting it happen. We want that and we want that. So DAs are important. If it gets too tough, obviously we won't sign a DA. If it's not fair, it's not worth signing a document that you have to come back and retrade. We don't like to do that. I think at this point that's really all I have. It's all about fairness all the way across. You know, when we came to this town and started our first agreement,
1:36:50 Which is the use permit on Snow 36, that would be in Western Iowa. And lo and behold, I guess some people at least like us and like what we've produced, and we intend to continue doing that. So we look forward to sharing. Thank you. Thank you. Does any of the commission have questions for the applicant at this time? Thank you. Chuck, I have a question for you. Please. As you had heard I mentioned earlier about, well first let me frame this, that
1:37:21 Seeing the work that's been going on at Snow Creek over the past few years, I know that you really put effort into having our local contractors working there, electricians, all the trades. But being this is a 20-year agreement, is there a possibility of you looking at terms that we could put in to ensure that our local trades are kept working, point of sale?
1:37:42 Such things as that. Are you familiar with Truckee, with the language that's in their DA? Yes, I am. Next to the mountain and probably the town, we are the largest employer, I think, of local workers. And they're great. Why wouldn't we be dumb enough to? We need to be, if the wording is correct, clearly as we've done, what we've done historically, need to make sure we don't put ourselves in a box. It has to be competitive and all those things. We're sure we're open to it. That's a policy we've always had and certainly will continue to.
1:38:10 And then on your first phase, and I know we discussed this earlier about not being able to put time limits, but I would assume that with the money you have invested, you're not going to sit back and wait for years and years to start. I would hope not, at least. So in your first phase with the trails, is that something that you will put in? And that's a trail connector that goes from the four corners around connecting down to the Sherwins and out to the Sherwins? From Sherwin Ranch? I forget what section it is, but in the...
1:38:39 Master Plan, there is a paragraph that deals with trails. In the phasing it says as we do a phase we'll do the permanent trails associated with that phase. It says in the meantime we will have temporary trails or allow access from Mammoth Creek or from Old Mammoth Road out to the point where the hotel site is and that certainly will be in play and that's continued. Somebody asked a question since I'm babbling here about Sherwin egress.
1:39:08 We did, with Mammoth, with MLTPA, implement that this year. It was successful. It created signage and a path out to Ranch Road. It worked well. No homeowners complained. It worked for us. And I think there is a provision that we document that, which will be obviously forthcoming. And there is an easement that goes from Old Mammoth Road to that access point back by the hotel. That also was part of the...
1:39:37 Master plan. I think it's called the Sherwin Trail. Sherwin Trail. Thank you. Madam Chair, is this then the time to ask questions of the applicant? Yes. Excuse me, I didn't say that right. We're asking questions, but questions about things would he consider for the development agreement? Sounds like he's in a good mood, I take it. Okay, very good. Okay, Chuck. Programming. Would you consider having a clause in there where the town would be able to program a certain percentage of events on the Great Lawn?
1:40:07 You know, we've dealt with that in the master plan. The most, the key element is the Great Lawn is part of the hotel development. Or maybe not the, what was the other venue? There would be events. The Great Lawn is the one point, what is it, 1.6, 1.7 acres down by the hotel. No, I realize that, but that's really the only venue for an outdoor event as it's laid out. We have a mini park in the front, as you recall. Yeah. Which was what? One and a half. So you would not be amenable to the town programming anything adjacent to the hotel.
1:40:37 No, that limits the viability of the hotel itself. That's tough. Okay. But the master plan does provide for the town working through the hotel to create events there and they work together. Okay. So unlike the village where it's only four events per year, you're in the master plan base. I'm sorry to interrupt you, but it allows you to work with the town to program more than just four events.
1:41:02 The time is allowable. Just needs to be workable. You know, you used to work with the hotel and their program. Okay. The language in the DA, I thought was an oversight because it talks only about egress and only for winter recreation users instead of access and hikers in the summer. And what you just said in answer to Tony's question, that access across the property to the access point by the hotel, a temporary trail is something you...
1:41:32 Are amenable to? John Rutworth would know better than I. In other words, it's going to be a long time before you start building. The egress is for egress out of the Sherwin's only, right? Okay, but how about access in the summer? That's in the winter. That's in the winter. Okay. And it's across the golf course. The ranch road. The ranch road. Oh, that egress. Oh, that's a specific egress. That's a specific egress for winter egress. Okay. Separately, there was egress through the Snow Creek Gate property.
1:42:03 Right. Right. And the master plan deals with putting in permanent facilities per phase, which we've agreed to in the master plan and the DA. And then it also provides for temporary access until the permanent is there so long as it doesn't, you know, propose a, what, a life safety or athletic. Yeah, safety hazard. So you're amenable to temporary access as soon as the DA is signed across the Snow Creek Gate property for hikers in the summer to the trails. It's part of the master plan.
1:42:33 And just to amplify, I mean, when she said access, that's two-way as opposed to egress. Okay. Okay, I didn't realize the egress was so specific. It's access to it. Okay. Why do you want to wait on recording the conservation easement? You know, we may record an easement. We may give it to a conservation group. As you probably know, we're in discussions with one now and parents here. Right. We have two ideas. There are two possible recipients.
1:43:04 Maybe it's an easement. Maybe we're just giving them the land. So that's the reason for having a period of time to work all that out. Okay, that makes sense. Okay. I think that's all for you right now. Thank you. Jay, do you have any questions? Yeah. Okay. And, Sharon, do you have questions? I'm not afraid to touch that, so. I do have a question. Your...
1:43:39 Workforce housing would be built to the area middle, medium income of 175 to 200 percent. When our housing group requested 80 to 120 percent, why did you choose the higher? I think philosophically, you know, we're involved in a number of communities, and we've seen, I think our first affordable housing project was in 1986 in the city of Los Angeles, the city of Calisade.
1:44:09 We've seen programs fail. We've seen programs succeed. The last DA we signed was last year. It did have an affordable housing component. So happens that EPS was involved in it, even though I didn't know that. But philosophically, we're catering to part of the affordable housing need on-site, primarily directed at families, philosophically is what we were after, and part off-site.
1:44:37 And that's really how we proposed. Somebody asked me a question, I'll just say it now in case it comes up. In discussions previously with the master plan, we proposed 80 units on-site and 80 units off. It was that same philosophy of 50% of the program on-site and 50% off. Quite frankly, when we did that, I didn't pay attention to the economics of what all it meant. And it was about the time that we...
1:45:06 We're starting in the master plan. And I took out a napkin on an airplane and started playing with Proforma and realized that these numbers didn't work and brought up a whole question about the whole fee schedule itself. And I'm glad that the dip has reduced. I'm looking forward to Mammoth Lakes Housing finishing their process. But that's really the essence of it. Again, you didn't answer my question. You chose the higher percentage.
1:45:36 As opposed to what they requested. And if we change it, then that's going to take away considerable from the contribution. It's all money. You know, one of the things that's frustrating here is a lot of people have their hand out and think a developer can just write a check for a million here and a million there and 10 million here and 10 million there. And at the end of the day, this is a business deal. And in business, you have to be able to make money. Somebody asked us for $10 million.
1:46:04 I said, geez, $10 million is a lot of dough. I broke it down on a per unit basis. Quite frankly, when I first did it in my head, I did it incorrectly, but that's okay. I'm getting older. And I said, all right, you know, that's $10,000 a unit. If all the fees come down, and if everything happens in a balance, you know, we'll do that. I'll do that. It's a lot of money, but I'll do it. And so that's what came forth is this whole framework concept here. If you do $175 to $200,000,
1:46:32 It puts you at one sales price. If you do 80 to 120, it puts you at another and you're going to lose X amount of money, right? Because it costs you more to build than you can sell for. So it's all just dollars. So we just try to be fair and instead of sitting in the back and hiding behind the peas, say, okay, it's all on the table, so how do you want to shuffle the peas? That's how we did it. Chuck, I just thought of something I do want to ask you.
1:47:01 Back to cost of living, and I'm just wondering what your view is of a, what I'm concerned about is the worst possible situation, which is very unlikely, but where you've got some kind of runaway inflation, what your thought is where the party, where this provision would not kick in in a normal situation where you've got 3% a year or 5% or something, but if you have a really, really bad situation over a number of years,
1:47:27 In 20 years, that could amount to a really huge expense that could really clobber the town. Would you be willing to consider some kind of a provision where, over some threshold like that, the parties share that risk? It's one of those keys. Yeah, the honest answer is sure we're open to that. Let's see how the rest of it all falls. Good, thanks. Another question from myself also that came up. Seeing that, what we've seen with some of our housing or workforce housing that...
1:47:56 It failed to sell. Is there any provision? Are you looking at anything to do with that housing if it doesn't sell? And how will that be handled? You know, I will tell you what part of the discussion was. I don't remember what came out in the document. Part of the discussion was, hey guys, you know, if we have this affordable housing we're building on site and there's no market for it, at some point the requirement should go away, shouldn't it?
1:48:23 And in all honesty, I don't remember what came out in the final DA. We did not accept that. Yeah, because I didn't see that in there. In fairness, to build something that doesn't sell and it just sits doesn't benefit anybody. And the discussion in that was we don't want a housing unit designed and built that doesn't sell. And that's one of the things that really emphasized how important it is to craft.
1:48:50 I think what you've seen us do for the last five years is build units that are livable.
1:49:18 And that's critical for the market as well as for the, you know, for the affordable workforce. I like that word better than affordable. Thank you. Well, we've taken care of all of our questions at this point until some more come along. So I am, the public hearing is open, but allowing this time for those, the public that would like to speak. And it's not necessarily a supporter, opposition, or general.
1:49:55 Because you may feel differently on each point. But at this point, I would like to, let's hear for those, anyone that has concerns or questions, I'd like to speak in opposition of Laura's open. Come forward. State your name for the record. My name is Kirk Stapp. And I am a candidate, so I can't separate who I am as citizen and all the different hats that I do wear. I would like to say first to Dlandi that
1:50:33 You know, his natural plan, I sported. I didn't have any problems with it. I also have gone through many of his units, and I think they're beautiful inside, and I live across the way from them, and, you know, I think they're, they're, you know, I really appreciate what, the quality of the units that he's built besides Snow Creek Floor. So I wanted that very clear. The, and this goes to you, Elizabeth, you know, you've spent so much time writing the,
1:51:01 vision statement, and one of the statements or one of the phrases in there is participatory town government. And Tony, you've said that, you know, we've got to push the process forward, but I think it's more important that we have that participatory town government.
1:51:17 May 18th, I got a copy of the DA, so I worked real hard to get through that. May 21, the agenda came out late. I didn't actually get a copy of it until 6-20. And then yesterday, I finally got a copy of the economic analysis. So, you know, to me, this process has met the legal timelines, but it's been absolutely compressed to the minimum legal requirements. And so it's really hard to say that we're a participatory town government.
1:51:47 When, you know, we are compressing this down to where the public, boy, if you weren't really on top of it, guess what? You're not going to be involved in this process. So that's one concern, is the fact that it has gone so fast and been pushed as well as, you know, Mammoth Lake Housing has not had a chance to respond. So if you look at the council's adopted resolution,
1:52:15 On affordable housing, the 10% and everything, this is what it states in there. You know, projects that are required to provide inclusionary housing units on site may propose an alternate housing mitigation plan. Mr. Wardlow can call it what he wants, but that's what it is, and it might be a policy issue that Mr. Landy is proposing that's shaping the policy, but it says subject to Mammoth Lake Housing Board and the Town Council's approval.
1:52:44 So, you know, we have a contract, Mammoth Lake Housing, and the idea is to get some feedback so you guys can make some better decisions in regards to that. Bill Taylor also sent a letter to you guys that you have, I think you have actually quoted, and in that I want to read that given that the basic purpose of a development agreement is to vest
1:53:06 The existing rules and regulations of the town, the fundamental question for the commission is why does the DA not use the policy adopted by the council in November as the foundation for its terms related to housing? So, council adopts this and guess what? The negotiations other than the 10%. Elizabeth, I think you asked a very, or maybe it was Sharon asked a very good question.
1:53:36 The DA is trying to shape public policy and the DA is not the policy that was adopted because the DA has 50% on and 50% off. It talks about a $209,000 fee versus the $80,000 fee. It talks about FTEE. You know, what is the relationship? It's proposing that for each FTEE there's one unit. So there are substantial differences between
1:54:06 What the municipal code says and what the policy says. And so I think that's really important. Also the funding tools, Elizabeth, you know, we've got a toolbox, so the preference is to put it on site. It would be great. But, you know, developers are saying, I don't think I can put it, and, you know, the livability, all the different criteria, and they look at fees as a way of, you know, addressing their housing issues.
1:54:34 We have eight different ways in the toolbox to actually work with the developer, provide land, provide a rehab, different policies, and the board is open to other financial tools.
1:54:54 That out there, such as a Miller Ruth. The Miller Ruth is there. And it's important to recognize that the Miller Ruth is something that developers are not real enthusiastic about because when a buyer comes in, they see that as part of their long-term responsibility. They're going to have to pay off that Miller Ruth. So it slows down sales. So, you know, and if it goes over 2% at different costs, then the developers, you know, and the buyers begin to really question the actual purchasing of that.
1:55:24 This transfer tax that was mentioned by staff, it has never been implemented in the state of California. It would be great. I mean, I'm all for it. I don't have a problem with that to reduce the impact and pass it on to the purchasers out there. But it has been adopted in one community, but it was never implemented. So, you know, some of the tools that are being tossed around...
1:55:48 You know, are not very viable. We've worked very hard looking for economic tools that would be to the benefit of the developer, but also provide the basic, you know, funding mechanism to actually create the housing that is needed. I need to point this out. You know, when council had its study session, one of the things that wasn't pointed out to the council, because they walked through all these different things speculating about
1:56:19 What could or couldn't happen? The DA wasn't in front of them. But the study session didn't ask the question, you know, that the adopted 1109 policy, it was assumed, I would think, by the council that that would be the foundation for working with this. I strongly disagree with some of the caveats or some of the language that is in there that is talking about fees and all of that sort of thing.
1:56:46 And yes, I know it has economic impacts on the financial contribution, but the fact remains that we still got to figure this out. And if it's using a Mellow Roos district or one of the funding tools from the funding, you know, box, the eight different tools, then that needs, you need that information and actually we have been struggling for six months trying to figure out how.
1:57:09 To lower that $209,000. But that was a formula that accepted by the consultant. It's accepted by the development community. These are the criteria. You go through a mathematical formula and that's the number that comes out. And by the way, that was created by Peter Denison from Mammoth Lakes, from Mammoth Mountain Ski Area. So it's not like this came from, you know.
1:57:39 Mammoth Lake Housing, this came from a developer, how to figure it out. And it is a burden, especially in these economic times. The industry standard, you know, I think Sharon, you were asking about this. This economic consultant had looked at the industry standards. What could, if a million dollar piece of property,
1:58:07 What fees could be handled by that and still be viable? So he used this term, industry standard, and that industry standard ranges between 5% and 10%. And so you need that piece of information, and I think Mammoth Lake Housing could provide that by looking at these numbers and the variables there. You know, we've struggled with this, and right now...
1:58:31 Again, I'm not going to say they're absolute, but right now they look like they're about 5%. During recessionary times, that is probably appropriate. But how do you have the flexibility to move it up when the time comes that all of a sudden something is selling for, you know, $1,200 a square foot and you're locking it in for 20 years? So that's a real concern also. It should be a concern for council.
1:58:59 One of the things that the staff is recommending is a thumbs up or down on the entire package. And I think you have the responsibility to do that, worrying the variables. And you also have the opportunity, just as you've done, to try to negotiate with the developer. And I kind of knew what his answers were going to be before you asked the question. I mean, he's worked hard on this DA getting what he considers his needs met.
1:59:27 But you also have the ability to make recommendations on specific, even if the developer disagrees because he is obviously going on and Mark has stated it, you have the ability to do a thumbs up or down on certain things like the COLA, you know, to make a motion and say I believe the COLA should be part of the $10 million. You know, you have the ability to say that the $10 million is not tied to the affordable housing.
1:59:56 You have the ability to say that the $10 million should not just be in the sphere of influence, but let the town council, in its priority, decide where those dollars, so that those dollars might be used someplace else in the community. Maybe the first priority is in the sphere of influence. But the council has more responsibility than just, you know, looking at that area. The developer would love to see those $10 million spent out there.
2:00:26 And they, in the, uh, Snow Creek, um, area, as well as the spheres of influence of Snow Creek. And I don't blame them. It'd be great, because you can pay for the trails and those kinds of different things, which are community benefits. Um, another, and there's a lot of components in here, and I could probably go through about 50 different bullet points with you, but. And since you're at N2. Yeah, I'm going to stop, but.
2:00:55 And I'm probably providing to town council, but things like this, and I'm just going to give you one example. When the village DA was done, $120 was assessed against each piece of property, and that money went to transportation. If you look at the transit issue here, you know, they're going to provide shuttles, they're going to provide some, but there's not something that...
2:01:18 And I would call it an overall community benefit that is funding the transit system. So, you know, we did that with the DA there. There's a lot of things in the DA with InterWest that you might want to go back and review or council should review or just ask. Don't get me wrong, the settlement agreement, obviously the InterWest implementation and holding the accountability didn't occur.
2:01:46 So when you look at the settlement agreement with Interwest, we don't have the bridges over Waterford and all of those things. Thank you for giving me the extra time. Thank you. Madam Chair, are we allowed to ask the commenter questions? No. Why don't we, you know, there will be a lot of things that you'll want to clarify, and I think that we have a lot of paper here so we can take some notes and maybe in our discussion that we would like to do that. Okay, thank you.
2:02:14 Oh, there's a chance to speak at that time. Is there anyone else that would like to speak in opposition? I do want to remind you we are here to negotiate, contrary to what you may have heard. This is not a thumbs up or thumbs down. Oh, I just rescinded my own rule. Continue. My name's Ligosh. When it comes to affordable housing, I don't like the words assumption. I like details. I want to know exactly where the things are going to go.
2:02:42 What lot are you going to? If you're going to put it off the process, where is it going to go? Have you talked to people in the neighborhood? How do they want it to be built? You can't assume because if you do, as time goes on, you can do whatever you want. We want to be involved in the process of exactly where everything is going to go, what it's going to look like. Are the rooms speaking up? Are we rearranging twice? Remove the furniture. Is it going to hit a wall? There should be more on the project. There are so many people that would love to live on the project. I mean, I would.
2:03:12 You know, I would live on a project because I've been places I wish I could have. You need to reach out to the stakeholders of the town. Are they happy with the decision that you guys are doing? Can you look them in the eye and say, this is what we're going to do and it's a done deal? That's what it feels like to me. Affordable housing is a done deal and we have no say so in what's going on.
2:03:32 Affordable housing needs to have more money so they can build better, proper places for the people to live here. Right now, the places in Sierra Valley sites are much too small. The kids play in the parking lots. Yesterday, they were all over the street in the parking lots. There is absolutely no place for the kids to play. It's a black-topping building. It is very discouraged and sad. It's sad. How can you again perform when you don't know where everything is going to go? It needs to be in detail.
2:04:04 The DIF fees, they need to pay the DIF fees. I know, like Kurt was saying, it needs to go to the sphere of influence, but Sierra Valley Sites, one, we have been screwed there so many times. We don't have the drainage system fixed. I'm not talking about Sierra Valley Sites, two, I'm talking about one. And it seems like you want to, the town wants to put everything onto us to fix it. It's our problem now, your problem is our problem. Sierra Valley Sites, the people that work there are very important, and we want to be heard.
2:04:34 And the bottom line, it seems like it's all about money in this town. What about the people of our town? We're hard workers here, and respect us, please, and think about us. Thanks. Is there anyone else that would like to speak in opposition or concern? Raise questions regarding the Snow Creek 8 project. Ted. Mr. Carlson. I'm sorry I've been too busy with the election to follow this very closely in regards to the DA, which was printed, but...
2:05:06 This 20-year agreement and the gain-a-day, lose-a-day stuff, I'm a little bit confused by that because who, is it a town decision as to who determines what an unavoidable delay is or market conditions or is that a joint decision? How does that work? That would be a joint decision.
2:05:35 There was a, we had discussed earlier, and I'm sorry, I don't know if you were in a room, there was a schedule, this came up, a discussion of who's responsible for making that determination. I can't imagine that Mr. Landy would just say, oh yeah, by the way, it's also on me and you can take my days away. Oh, he said he didn't like it, but he agreed to it. But that, it's just not going to happen if it's a mutual decision. That's as silly as, I mean, it's a nice policy if you want to feel good about it, but
2:06:04 It's ridiculous. If I may, through the chair, in worst case scenario, that's what I'm going to describe now. Worst case scenario, if there was some disagreement that between the town and the developer that the developer didn't think they should be deducted, but the town thought they should, the town's in total control because the town's the one that issues permits. If the town decides that there wasn't sufficient evidence and they hold the permit,
2:06:33 The option of the developer is going to have to go to court to force the town to issue the permit. That doesn't mean that there isn't a possibility of an expense to the town because the town may be wrong in its analysis and the developer may win and be able to recoup attorney's fees, but ultimately, because we're talking about permit issuance, the town is in control. We are historically good in court, I may. So the next question I would have is, okay, say for example,
2:07:04 In year 12, you know, the light dawns. We say, okay, now is the time, you know, that the clock is ticking. And then say by about year 14, oh, shoot, we're in a recession again. Does the clock stop ticking? And then we have like a, is there resets associated with this? I mean, I can't imagine like a 10-year period where it's all going to be rosy and sunny, right? So how does the clock work? And who times it?
2:07:35 It's 20 years. It's not 20 years plus if something happens. It's 20 years. But it's 10 years until we even start discussing it, right? Until it becomes an issue. If I may. The 10-year issue is the lose-a-day process doesn't start until the first 10 years are done. Correct. So the maximum amount of time that Mr. Landy could lose is 5 years, correct? 10 years.
2:08:08 For the additional 10 years. For the additional 10, because it fails in the first 10. That's a day. Oh, I thought the clock started ticking at 10. Five. Five, so I was correct. That's what we heard. I like that. All right. Thank you for your questions. It says 10 in the packet. So, which obviously it needs clarity. Lee. I don't appreciate something you said when I walked away. You said,
2:08:38 for anything to pertain to the Snow Creek Gate. You know that Sierra Valley sites and Old Mammoth Road, whatever project comes forward, we are always affected by this. Any project that comes forward, because that's the only place to put affordable housing. That's the way I took it. Maybe I misinterpreted it. You did. But every project has access in one way. I'm sorry if there was an issue there. And when you were talking about affordable housing, that was it. But when it started to stray,
2:09:05 From issues regarding this, that would be better held for another time. But the development impact fees need to go other areas in the town. That's what you were talking about. Once the sphere of influence is taken care of, it needs to go to other areas. That's not where you were going. Excuse me, for the record, I just want to clarify. Sure. The project pays development impact fees, and they're not restricted. They just go to the town. And so there's no geographical limit to DIV.
2:09:31 To the extent that they pay stormwater management fees, they go into that system that the town would build. So DIF is paid, and as the project progresses, and they're deployed as the town would deploy DIF funds. The only thing that has the geographic nexus associated with it is the additional financial contribution, just the additional cash that the developer would provide and how it would be used.
2:09:59 Is to be determined. So it could be for a host of issues. But for the record, DIF is whole and funded through this project and not distributed. Does that help? Yeah, but I still do for, like, people in this town have forgotten. Thank you, Lee. That's so noted. Anyone else? John? John, are you speaking in opposition? No, I wasn't sure. I wanted to ask you where are you at in terms of soliciting comment.
2:10:30 How about if we go ahead and let you speak? We're moving on to the next level, but everybody that wants a chance to speak. Okay, so as a general proposition, I'm speaking on behalf of MLTPA as a general proposition in supporting of this proposal with several caveats. Exactly. The reason why we would support something like this is because we put a lot of work on behalf of MLTPA and with the applicant into the master plan.
2:11:00 And I think the questions you had about Trails, Tony, we're confident that the language that's in the master plan is solid. It represents an enormous amount of work. And to the public understand, this is work the MLTPA does in our advocacy roles. There's no compensation that goes in this. These are literally many, many hours of voluntary effort going into this to make this happen. So we believe that the Trails component in this master plan is solid. I am no expert on development agreements.
2:11:29 What I understand about development agreements is that this is a voluntary contractual relationship between the town and the applicant. This does not have to happen. It's a voluntary situation. It needs to be consistent with the general plan. It needs to be consistent with current regulations in place that the town has on its books. And that in the end, this development agreement needs to provide a greater community benefit than the existing, the current master plan. That's my understanding of it.
2:11:56 That is your role to assess and figure that out. It's the council's role to figure that out and make that decision. And I trust that when all is said and done, you will go to your constituents and the people in this community and say yes, if it goes that direction. This development agreement provides greater community benefits and here's why. And that's a decision that you will recommend to the council. The council will make as well. But that is your burden. And that's, I think, where we sit with that.
2:12:26 We wrote a letter, and if you have any, I don't want to need to go back and review that, but if you have any questions about it, I can answer those questions. I think there were four essential points that had to do with, my copy's at my seat, but, you know, there has been this discussion with the housing situation. It doesn't sound like it's resolved. Staff is certainly represented. It's not resolved yet. The trails and MLTPA are not coming to this process with our hands up. I think we've been very effective.
2:12:53 Advocating for our mission and bringing things forward absent any kind of financial consideration. This is about the mission of our organization, the benefit to the community, the benefit to the applicant, the benefit to this place and everything else. We would be very concerned that a development agreement, once it's agreed to, that parties are generally satisfied with it, provides a greater community benefit. If there's some process to figure out where money gets allocated, that happens after that. But we certainly, our interest is in community harmony.
2:13:23 And all the people and our colleagues that we work with in this community feel that this is the community's benefit, that elements of the community aren't being maybe inadvertently pitted against each other. So we're certainly holding back to see the determination that you guys make, that this thing is the community benefit, that you and the council can see a way forward for the allocation of these funds, and there's a process for how those funds will get allocated. But we'll sit back and see how all that goes. And I'm very interested in your deliberations.
2:13:51 I would make one comment, though, about this gentleman, Mr. Kieser. Mr. Kieser, as far as I'm concerned, I don't know, he's starting to kind of smell like a hired gun, like an expert witness. The guy's got enormous technical skills, and I appreciate that, but every time his name comes forward, it's coming forward on behalf of something that doesn't quite smell right, just from a technical perspective. In the CFFC thing, I believe it was his recommendation that measure our money could be used out of the box without
2:14:21 A recognition of the process that Measure Art is involved with. Measure U was cited as a possible funding source. Measure U hasn't even passed yet. And now, in this situation, again, this is just a technical note, but there's some conflation and confusion about, say, the Sherman's egress thing, which is part of the master plan. That's not an additional community benefit. That's in the master plan. We've been working well this winter to make that work effectively. But there's a lot of fuzzy logic and fuzzy reasoning and fuzzy factual stuff that comes out of Mr. Kieser.
2:14:50 And I would just caution. I hope that public money isn't being used to pay for these studies. I'm assuming this is work that Chuck's paying for and bringing forward as part of the process. But general fund money in these tough times is not being used in a consultant. It doesn't seem to have any, you know, real, hard, factual, credible connection to this community and what goes on in this place. That's just kind of a point of order coming from somewhere else. John, could you give an example of his fuzziness? Well, just in this letter that came out yesterday.
2:15:17 This, this, the greater public benefits. There's, it's not clear if you read this, you might think that all the work that we did with the applicant for trails and egress and all that kind of stuff that's in the master plan should somehow be considered as a greater, as a greater public benefit. Well, I think everybody would agree it's in the master plan, it's where it should be and we think good work and that's where it exists, but should not be considered and assessed and evaluated as a greater community benefit, which kind of clouds the discussion about a development agreement.
2:15:47 So I just, it's important to make sure that, and if we have to, every time Mr. Kiesner's work comes forward, we have to put time into going through it, analyzing it, bring it to your attention so you know that, well, this isn't quite right over here, maybe that's not quite right over there. I just think that's something for you to consider. And if he comes back with future work that maybe really needs to be looked at and make sure the T's are crossed and the I's dotted, because this is the second time on some significant issues that, you know, maybe the work isn't as accurate as it should be. And that's a technical note, but I'll just bring that up.
2:16:17 Do you have any questions about the letters? Anything I can guess, Jake? Not about the letter, John, but you said that MLTPA is happy with the provisions regarding trails in the master plan. Yes. We had a discussion, I think brought up by something Tony asked a little earlier, I'm not sure if you were in the room, regarding the access egress issue with respect to the trails and specifically with respect to
2:16:43 A provision that talks about egress, wintertime egress from the Sherwins. Right. Through the Snow Creek property. And I gather you say you're happy with the provisions. You don't have any issue with that needing to be two-way access. Access into the Sherwins from there, access during non-wintertimes. I will defer to the languages in the master plan, which I believe says egress. I think it does. I think that's how it's written.
2:17:10 You know, I think that, you know, Chuck and I spoke a little bit about this. I'm not here to open up the master plan. I think that was a very complicated, difficult process, but the things that are in the master plan or what's in the master plan. Okay, but let me make sure you understand. I'm not asking, the issue isn't whether we open up the master plan. The development agreement, let's say the master plan says that and that if someone has a concern that
2:17:34 There's a need for access into the Sherwin's or that there's a need for access or egress in a time other than winter. That has the potential for being a greater community benefit. That's something over and above the master plan. So the issue is, is that needed? Yeah, I can't. There's nothing that, in terms of the greater
2:17:57 Efficacy of this process. There's nothing that I can come forward to you now that say there's some little piece that's missing out of the master plan that you should try to bring in as part of the development agreement to try to fix something that's not in the master plan. And I think that there was so many of these things are interrelated. There is, unlike a lot of the components of the master plan, there is a phasing component for the trails. I know when a use permit is sought for the next nine holes, the golf course, the applicant is required to provide a trails plan for the whole system, having to do the winter stuff.
2:18:27 So we're confident that there are phasing and benchmark mechanisms within the master plan to address a lot of those issues. And thanks to that opportunity, I don't have anything other than the award-winning Shore and Area Recreation Plan, which is, you know, that's a whole separate tract, but that's moving forward, and there's an enormous amount of opportunities that we could realize with all this stuff. But again, I would defer to your judgment that council's greater community benefit, it's consistent with regulations.
2:18:56 Lines up with the general plan, and you can go to the community and say, this is the community's larger community benefit, and for these reasons, and you can make the sell. John, are you saying, excuse me, John, are you saying that a temporary trail from Minaret at Old Mammoth Road to the future access point, the access point by the future hotel, you know, immediately, in order to have access to the Sherwins, even though the trail system is not fully developed yet, that wouldn't be considered a community benefit?
2:19:26 I would... A temporary, initial temporary trail. Sure. I think if you guys are interested in finding additional community benefits that may have something to do with trails issues, I would suggest that perhaps you direct the applicant and maybe MLTPA to sit down and see if there are things, starting with the master plan, with all the various pieces that all connect together, to say, look, we'd like to bring some additional community benefit out of the already...
2:19:53 agreed to consensus that's in the things in the master plan. I would hate to start pulling things out of the sky and just saying, well, there's one thing here, if you just kind of do this, and maybe we just kind of do this thing over here, that threatens to kind of upset a certain kind of an apple cart that's in place, but if it's a direction from the Planning Commission, I'm sure that Chuck and I can sit down and find some pieces that maybe could advance things a little bit further forward, but again, I would defer to your direction on that. Mark Blatt. If that makes sense. I mean, there is integrity to how it's put together right now. I'd hate to start.
2:20:23 Pulling needles out of places and risk the thing falling down on itself. While John's still up here, his number four in this letter regarding the special account that he's talking about for the money, could you address that issue, especially for the public? Tony, what page are you on? It's a second page. So page three, I guess it would be. Number four suggests that there should be a special account for funds that flow from the...
2:20:54 Construction of the project that are the additional cash flow. Of course we would do that. We will set that up. It doesn't just flow blindly into the general fund. We would establish a separate account so we know where it is and track it. The 10 million is what we're speaking of. But then the council still has the ability to have it be discretionary. Well, it's town money. The town council is the board of directors for the town. They adopt the budget.
2:21:27 They establish the priorities. Among the reasons we have not tried to apply or allocate the use of the funds is for some of these items we don't have CEQA completed. And so if you're making a discretionary decision to allocate the funds to something, you have had to have done CEQA. And we have not done CEQA on many of these. You can also imagine the political sensitivities.
2:21:55 When people perceive there is some cash flow, many people will have an interest, and we're simply not at that point. So an oversight committee? So a recommendation of an oversight committee, as we've done for Measure R and other school board standards, is that something that's out of the question? You could recommend that to the town council. So we could? Separately, yes. If I could, if this is an opportune motion, a couple of statements have been made. One is that
2:22:25 Regarding transit and transportation funds, the master plan has... Do you need me to... Can I sit down? I'll be right here. I just want to make sure that was answered for you. I'm sorry. And so, John, I do have one thing to ask. So, as it stands today, this is the scope of the concerns that we have? Yes. Okay, so this is... Because we'd like to know what it is we need to mitigate. These are our thoughts. Thank you. If you have any questions, please, I'll be... Thank you very much.
2:22:53 Continue. As you recall, in the master plan, standard condition of approval assesses a transit fee to transient units, so there is a cash flow associated with transportation. The master plan also has a host of conditions that relate to transit and traffic and transportation. Next, with Mr. Kieser, it's...
2:23:16 It's always difficult when somebody challenges the professionalism or integrity of one of your consultants. And the reason we rely on Mr. Keeser, as we have with Kaiser Marston and ERA, is that they're qualified professionals. In this particular letter, people ultimately, as was the case with Old Mammoth Place, went to parse to the penny what is technically some greater benefit than what could have been required by code. It is far more of an art than it is a science.
2:23:44 And in this case, in Mr. Kieser's review, if he was not qualified, we would not hire him. In this review, he's reviewing the CRBE work. And he's paraphrasing what you see here to give you a scope and order of magnitude, which is different from what we've specifically identified in the development agreement and the staff report as those exclusive benefits. So you're getting...
2:24:12 A review of previous documents and an opinion from him as to his experience with other development agreements. So if he was erroneous, errors and omissions, wrong, we wouldn't hire him. So I just want to state that. And then, if I could just respond, if, if, no, I'm not impugning Mr. Kieser's CV, but if mistakes come forward and there are concerns, it would be a lot easier if staff could just acknowledge
2:24:41 Made a mistake. That's not right. No problem. We can move on. I'm not impugning the guy's integrity and his professional ability, but these things have significant impacts to this community. I don't know where the guy lives. I don't know where he works. I'm sure he knows what he's doing. But, you know, when the rubber hits the road in the community, I would just, we'll bring these things forward and just advise you guys, things aren't quite right here. Mark? Did you have anything else, Ted? Okay. Ted, you can speak.
2:25:16 Per usual, John's got me thinking. So now you're supporting the project? I don't know what I'm doing, Tony. I'm just here to give Chuck a hard time. I'm looking at these attachments, and what I find interesting, we have an analysis of North Star at Tahoe and Ritz-Carlton Highlands and Hyatt Residence Club and Gray's Cross and all these places.
2:25:47 Do you think if we did all this work to do these analyses that we could just do a housing analysis for all these projects as well? I feel like it's an incredible omission and it would have really assuaged a lot of doubt. And then from just a nitpicky perspective, on page 143, why are we making comparisons with Inyo County AMI as opposed to Mono? I believe that was just a
2:26:19 Error. That's an error-rata sheet for the DA. What about all the analyses? Why don't we do how? So I'll speak to context. As the ad hoc committee was working on the master plan itself and the DA at that time, the committee had a number of questions. And in working with the applicant, we had to figure out what was the best way to answer these questions.
2:26:54 And at that time, the recession was well underway. And so that committee agreed to use the CRBE fiscal analysis and then hire economics research associates to review that and provide information. The ad hoc committee looked at the questions that became the scope of work for ERA, and that group
2:27:20 Jointly developed that work program that resulted in this analysis. Also at that time, it was always the intent of the applicant, more or less, to have about 50% of the required housing on site and about 50% met through and in the work field. And that program has carried forth. And so although we did not, this has not been a comparative housing analysis of other communities, that's a different subject.
2:27:50 In fact, in part, that's what Mammoth Lakes Housing in the town is going to have to figure out, what those housing requirements are. So it was not a question framed in form by the ad hoc committee, nor do we usually, when we look at affordable housing programs or implementation programs, continually run a comparative analysis of what other communities are doing for one particular item. I think the town is going to certainly have to struggle with housing and what the numbers are.
2:28:20 But, you know, this was the analysis that was conducted, you know, based on the direction of the council and commission group and with the acceptance of the applicant. The issue I have with that is that in these analyses you're now analyzing what price points are, you're talking about retail space, you're talking about benefits and golf courses and all that stuff, and then the elephant in the room, because it's uncomfortable, we don't tackle.
2:28:50 That's a serious omission. Thank you. Please. Thank you. I'm Karen Farrell Ingram, Executive Director of the Eastern Sierra Land Trust, and I appreciate the opportunity to provide some input to the development agreement and maybe change the subject to something a little less contentious, which is the conservation easement subject. We're very pleased that the Snow Creek Development Agreement includes the permanent preservation of the Mammoth Creek Open Space Corridor.
2:29:24 The Eastern Sierra Land Trust has been a supporter of this concept since our inception in 2001 when we first started talking with Linda Dempsey about this idea of permanently preserving and ensuring the future of the meadow and creek area back then. So we would like to offer several suggestions for fine-tuning the language in the development agreement so that the goals of the conservation effort can be met more effectively.
2:29:52 First, we suggest that the area to be preserved be described in more detail. It is our understanding that the preservation is to include the approximately 15 acres on the north side of Old Mammoth Road that encompass the meadow and the creek and the upland area along the road. And right now, it's just described as the Mammoth Creek Open Space Corridor, so I'm not sure that those are really the two same areas.
2:30:18 Another area to better define is the mechanism for preservation, and Chuck alluded to this earlier. We've had several conversations with him and his representatives regarding the potential of a full fee title donation of the 15 or so acres to Eastern Sierra Land Trust, and I know he's considering other organizations, but we believe that there could be multiple benefits to the town and to Snow Creek.
2:30:43 If the land were owned by an organization that could properly steward the land while providing interpretive resources to users. So we recommend that both options, the conservation easement or the fee title donation of the land be identified as acceptable in the donation agreement. And again, we're very supportive of the permanent preservation of this land. There's a number of issues that still need to be worked out between the landowner and whoever the entity is who
2:31:13 provides that permanent preservation, including what exact desired uses are there for that land, the source of funding to oversee the conservation easement or the land management and other details. And we're very happy to assist in this effort any way we can. Thank you. Thank you. Any questions? Yes, Karen.
2:31:38 Who would you, did you recommend someone to be the steward of the land or are you saying you would facilitate or I've misunderstood. If the Eastern Sierra Land Trust becomes the entity that Chuck decides he wants to donate the land to, we would be interested in, we would steward the land as part of that obligation. And we do that on our other properties and our other easements.
2:32:06 Thank you. Thank you. Any other questions? Mark, you got the clarifications of definition that she was asking about also? Yes. You got it. Okay. Thank you. Anyone else would like to address the commission? Go for it. Well, good afternoon. My name is Pam Hennerty. I am the Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing. I want to take just a second and sort of describe where we are in the process that you guys are talking about based on the in-loo fees so that you have an understanding.
2:32:43 We had a subcommittee that included Ellen, Clark, myself, and then two board members, Jim Smith and Bill Taylor, who were asked to consider an interim housing policy based on the economic conditions and reconsidering Chapter 1736 of the Municipal Code. We met and came up with an interim policy of 10% of on-site housing, which Chuck has graciously endorsed.
2:33:10 Actually, a little bit on the low side for what we see in other communities in California, 10%, it's 10 to 20%, and we're comfortable, we did that analysis based on population, the number of people who live in town within certain income categories. We also looked at that time at the housing gap, because if you're doing an inclusionary policy, you're asking somebody to build units on site. We had just completed the Aspen Village project, so we know
2:33:39 How much subsidy went into each unit. We did that analysis, and essentially, in order to build an inclusionary unit at those income levels, which are 80 to 120 percent of the area median income at that time, it cost $209,000 of subsidy for unit. We know that that's not the only way to provide housing. We're not providing housing in only that way at Maniflex Housing. You know, we started out just providing housing by building new.
2:34:08 In 2006, we started a down payment assistance program. Since that time, we've done 55 down payment assistance loans. We have a program in Mono County in the City of Bishop. We recognize that that's a huge tool that we need to use. We also have started acquiring and rehabilitating existing units. We've done it through alternative housing mitigation proposals for developers. Mammoth Lakes Housing is doing it now on our own through state and federal grants.
2:34:37 But we didn't know how to go forward with that fee. We started talking with Walter Kieser and EPS as he's going through the CFFC process, and we wanted to evaluate that fee, but we didn't want it to be an arbitrary fee. We know that this is a big deal and it matters a lot to developers, and I think the timing of where we are in our process and where Chuck is in his process is unfortunate because we're not in the same place at the same time.
2:35:04 Walter, Kieser, and Mammoth Lakes Housing and the town have said, we don't have enough information to figure that out. What percentage of housing would be new development? What percentage of housing we want to provide should be provided through these other methods? I can tell you that this morning, in preparation for this meeting, I did an arbitrary calculation of if we said use those three tools that we're currently using, we did a third of each. So we said we're going to build a third new.
2:35:32 A third of our housing will be provided through down payment assistance and a third of our housing through acquisition rehab. I took our $209, which we know it costs to build a new unit. I took our average down payment assistance loan for the 55 loans that we've done in the last four years, which coincidentally enough is $80,000. And I did what it's costing us on a per unit basis to do acquisition rehab, which was close to $90,000, and did an average. We did a third each.
2:36:01 The fee came to $120,000 per unit. Still not where Chuck thinks it should be and not in line with what Chuck's proposal was. And that hasn't been vetted. I mean, I did that this morning. But that's the kind of analysis we're wanting to do with the background of what the community needs are going to be, what community housing types are out there, and how we can go forward and meet the needs of the community's housing targets.
2:36:29 So that's where we are in the process. There's a budget policy decision before council to hire a consultant to help us go through that process and set that fee in such a way that it works and that we are considering all of those financial options. And once the council approves that, hopefully they will in their budget, we'll go forward. But we don't have that information now, but we do need to deal with the proposal before us.
2:36:58 This is part of forming good policy. When 1736 was adopted, we thought it was the right policy at the time. I wasn't around then, but the decision makers thought it was. We review, we revise, and we adjust based on where we are. Mammoth Lakes Housing, I wrote a letter to you on behalf of Mammoth Lakes Housing outlining concerns related to the terms that are outlined in the DA. I think that there is
2:37:29 Willingness on the part of Snow Creek to sit down and talk with me and roll our sleeves up and arm wrestle and see if we can't meet some consensus on the concerns I brought up in those letters. You know, when I think about 20 years time frame and locking in some of these conditions, you know, five years ago we were in a very different place on housing. I hate to think about where I'm going to be in 20 years. I might have grandchildren by then.
2:37:58 I know 20 years ago, I was sitting in Mrs. Tenney Shue's 7th grade science class, never thought I'd be before you, you know, so it's a long time and we need to be careful and these terms will be held accountable to those terms. I'm not asking to change the mathematical equation, I'm a math geek and I love mathematical equations and I think that we can work within the math equation in order to get
2:38:27 So, you know, for Old Mammoth Place,
2:38:57 You were here back in that white room quite a bit during the meeting. Yes. So if we were to make a recommendation similar to what we did on Mammoth Place, what is the timeline for you? Would you be ready with the analysis and be able to hit council with a conclusion or is it going to take you months, weeks, years? Well, I don't think, we will not be able to have the analysis done on this topic as I, you know, with the
2:39:28 The percentage is for the June 16th meeting. We've talked with Walter a lot. We've been going over this for six months. Maybe we can look at it this way and get there. But every time we came to the conclusion that it was arbitrary and that it wasn't necessarily going to meet the needs and it wasn't enough information for us to come forward and say, yes, this should be our policy.
2:39:55 I think that between now and June 16th, we could come to terms with Chuck on what is outlined in this DA, but to have the analysis done to update the code and the policy the way that it should be wouldn't be done in time for June 16th. Is that it? No, that's right. And thank you for also stating that you're speaking for Mammoth Lakes Housing. It gets away with some confusion that we have here.
2:40:27 Pam, I'm really, really perplexed about the relationship between the town and Mammoth Lakes Housing. I remember back when Steve Julian was a general town manager and council was meeting. I thought I was going to talk to Kirk about this, but he's gone. And Ted phrases the issue about the elephant in the room. And town council was meeting at the community center and real estate prices were going up and development was coming to town and people were getting really nervous and wringing their hands. We've got to do something about workforce housing. Nobody can afford to live here.
2:40:56 And it was always, we can't find an executive director, we can't find a director. And that went on and on. That was sort of almost a delaying tactic. It was really strange. And then they found a director, the Housing Foundation was formed, and everything was fine. And I thought, I was under the impression the Housing Foundation and the town were working together. And yet, lately, it appears to me it's being adversarial, which I think is not the right direction to go.
2:41:24 And why were all the proposals that were sent to us only for new construction? You know, Bill's letter yesterday, Kirk's email, what, three days ago, and your letter that was in our packet, it was all about new construction and nothing else. And I know you've been talking about these fees for six months, but why, how do you guys operate? Is the town involved, I think Rob Clark's on the board, so there is involvement between the town and the housing foundation, but
2:41:54 I'm just wondering, how do we get to this point? Well, so Mammoth Lakes Housing has a contract for services with the town. Okay. So we have an annual contract with the town where we provide input and on this kind of… Excuse me, Pam, would you pull that mic down just a little? Thank you. Sure, thank you. So we have a contract for services with the town and we provide housing-related input on…
2:42:22 Housing mitigation projects and implementation of the housing element, all kinds of good stuff. Rob Clark is on the board of directors. We are subject to the Brown Act because of the way we were formed. We have the town manager sits on our board, so if Rob were to ever leave, it would become whoever is the town manager. We also have a city council, town council member on the board. Who would be? It's Mayor McCarroll at the moment. Oh, okay, I didn't even realize that.
2:42:52 We do work with the town, Ellen especially at the town, and she's the housing geek, I'm the housing geek, so we work closely on issues. The reason that the fee that's been brought before you has to do with on-site is because of the fact that historically we've looked at housing as being provided with the preferences for it to be provided on-site.
2:43:22 So if a developer wants to provide it off-site, they have to provide a greater housing benefit, and historically that's been seen as having to pay, if it's a fee related, that then they have to pay the equivalent of providing that unit, so that Mammoth Lakes Housing or some other organization could then provide that unit. And that's been historically the way it's been seen.
2:43:51 That thinking has been shifting, and I think some are more willing to accept that thinking than others. And that's one of the things that we're working on in the process of revising the housing mitigation ordinance and the work we've been working with Walter Kieser and the town on in the last six months and hearing from the development community that that's too much. And so how do we work within that confine?
2:44:22 Still provide a greater housing benefit. It's such a difficult topic because we like to think about housing. Mammoth Lakes Housing staff likes to think about housing in units. How many units are we going to provide? How many households are we going to provide homes for? But it's easier to talk about it in a currency format because it can be compared to loss. And so it's always just been looked at as that's the cost to provide a unit.
2:44:49 In theory, Chuck would have to spend on each housing unit if he were building them on site. So if he's not going to build them on site, that's what he should have to pay. Again, that goes back to my point earlier is that we implement something, we test it out, we review it, we revise it, we make it better, we learn from what we're doing. And I think that's what we're trying to do.
2:45:16 And the process we're going through in updating the ordinance, updating the fee to include other housing options. So I'm correct in assuming you could probably get more housing for the buck using the other tools with the in lieu fees than you can depending on new construction, which is so expensive? It depends on the economic times, you know? And when we did a, one developer did a, bought an existing unit and deed restricted and sold it as an alternative housing plan.
2:45:46 Several years ago. $400,000 went into that unit. I'm not sure that was such a great deal either. We've learned a lot from that. Mammoth Lakes Housing has had an executive director for seven years. We're learning. And I think that we're getting some things better. I think we're learning new programs. Every year we're getting more tools in our tool belt to be able to provide housing.
2:46:12 So sometimes yes and sometimes no. I think it all depends on the economic climate and what's out there and what's available. Thank you. That really helps. Any other questions with Pam? Yeah. I'm kind of thinking about this and how do we resolve this, and maybe this is too obvious to be stated, but the most desirable solution for us would be for you to suggest a change, a revision, in addition to the
2:46:41 Development Agreement that would satisfy Mammoth Lakes Housing's concern and those changes would be acceptable to the developer. The second most desirable would be changes that maybe didn't satisfy either of you but would be something we could recommend to council that would at least help the situation. And I'm not sure, that's pretty nefarious.
2:47:08 I didn't say that. Okay. I think, Jay, to that response, I believe that Chuck and I can come to terms and that Mammoth Lakes Housing can come forward and say, yes, we're in support of this development agreement. I know that seems like a little far-fetched considering some other comments out there, but I believe that in the best interest of housing, we can tweak this DA and
2:47:37 and come to terms. He's expressed the willingness to sit down and have that discussion, and so I would ask that we be given the opportunity to arm wrestle a little bit. Are you prepared to do that now while we go on with the rest of the meeting? In other words, like we did on Old Mammoth Place. Yeah, like we did on Old Mammoth Place. Both of you going off into the room and coming up with some language for us.
2:48:05 Not the one you have to worry about. I think what I heard her say, which is acceptable to us, is that we can work this out within the framework, which is really what we've proposed. There is a framework of all these keys, and we can work on that aspect of it within the framework, which allows you then to send this on. By the time it gets to the town council in a couple weeks, we will have reached resolution.
2:48:32 I think that's what she said. And we are prepared to do that if that is what she said. That is what I said. That was a little too easy. Did you get that, John? Uh-huh. June 16th? I believe so. I think, I do. I think so. I think that I'm an ambitious woman, and I didn't sleep very well last night, and I think I've come up with some brilliant ideas that Chuck cannot say no to.
2:49:07 On that note, I do believe in you, and I think you can do it, and I trust in you to do it. Thanks, sir. Absolutely, that's great. Not to hide in the draw, Annie. Thank you, Pam. Who would have thought that, Ted? Anyone else like to speak from the public at this point? Okay, then I will close the public hearing and the public comments portion of it so we can move along.
2:49:41 to if there's anything left to delivery and start a discussion for the Commission. So to open this up into points of discussion, I'm going to start with Sharon, if you have some things that you'd like to share and points of discussion before we hear a motion. Yes, I would like to see that the ASC should be subject to COLA.
2:50:15 Quite simply. I don't know if that's somewhere you want to start, but it's something I'd like to put on the table for discussion. Anything else that you want to bring up? Go ahead. We're not going to discuss these as we... We may find that we have some mutual concerns. Okay. Obviously, I'm concerned about the town of Mammoth Lakes' money.
2:50:46 Heard a great deal about what's feasible for the developer. My concern is what's feasible for the town of Mammoth Lakes. And we are at the bottom of an economic ladder, and if we rest everything at the bottom, I have concerns about where we'll be in 10 years. As far as the benefits, do you want me to go through my list? Sure. Okay. My benefits...
2:51:15 I think we have counted Mammoth Creek open space twice. I'm on page 17, where it talks about the 8.9 acres of park open space, and then at the next bullet point says preservation of Mammoth Creek Park. It seems to me it's been used twice there. Corridor. Well, does that go then with what Karen was talking about? It's different.
2:51:46 Yeah, they're different things as far as the, I read them as the conservation easement was different than just the part of the open space. Oh, well down below in the footnote it's quite clear. Just to clarify, if I may, the reason that the Mammoth Creek open space corridor was separated out is because it would be providing that easement within two years of execution. So that in of itself is a benefit.
2:52:13 In addition to the fact that it is also counted towards the 8.9 acreage. So because it's coming sooner? Correct. But the 15.6 acres of the open space corridor was used in that overall calculation, but it's not specific to the 8.9. It was an overall calculation. So it is looking at two different things, but it is contained in both in a way. But it is cumulative. I mean, it is combined.
2:52:47 Based on the 8.9 calculation, but the easement is a separate idea. Okay. And of course to, I don't know that the entire 18 golf course is just a community benefit. I mean, it has to be certainly part of your reason for building. So I don't think we can count that as a total community, and nor the next thing, the golf practice facility.
2:53:23 Secondary access is for the, I believe it's the emergency vehicle, is not a public access, so I don't see how it's considered a benefit, lest, of course, you're talking about the people who would be marooned without it in the hotel, and of course it's a benefit to them. I think we already have the trails at that country.
2:53:55 Skiers, and that's bullet point number eight. And if someone asks about the program, so I don't see that that's a benefit, we already have it. The programming of the public space, I think you asked about Rhonda, and of course that will be done by the hotel, so I don't know that that's necessarily a benefit. And the last bullet point, again, I think is already part of the master plan. So those are...
2:54:23 Just my concerns about the benefits, and of course I tend to agree that some of these things that we got today, the Walter Kieser point, I think, was he available or did he have the interim housing policy when he put this together? Yes. Well, it doesn't seem to have been included and I...
2:54:54 was curious. The items that he talked about, I think, and gave financial benefit for, I would disagree with. So I think I've pointed that out. Those are my concerns. Oh, I guess there was one more. With the housing, it gets back again. The DA says that these will not be able to be
2:55:21 Leased or rented by anyone, and I think that is, again, not in, that is in conflict with the Mammoth Lake Housing Policy. That was the final one. Could you clarify that because... Tell us what page and where you're... I think that this says that these units cannot be, or were you saying that it can't be used for transient? No, that they couldn't rent, that they have to be owner-occupied. Sure.
2:55:52 I believe this is the same point that Mammoth Lakes Housing raised in their letters, that their own covenants tend to have less restrictive language, which allow, for example, someone to sublease a room if they lose their job and need to help to pay their rent or mortgage. So there's more latitude in there, and I think Pam's concerned that was too restrictive. Right, and that's what they would be discussing over this time. Oh, that would be part of it? Yeah. Okay. Obviously. Yeah. Okay. Okay. Thank you. I just want to go.
2:56:21 Understand? Because I read it to be something completely different, too. But not at that. The units would be restricted from being transient. Transient. Transient. Do you have anything else at this time, Shane? No, I'm fine. Elizabeth? I, too, favor a COLA on the cost of living adjustment on the additional financial contribution and also a cost of living adjustment on the permit fees.
2:56:51 I would like to see stronger language on the requirements for transfer of development rights. I would like to see an annual update on the status of the hotel market, an assessment of the hotel market along with just the annual sort of review that would be submitted. I'm very concerned, as I made clear when I was asking Pam those questions, about the housing situation because new construction is so prohibitably expensive.
2:57:20 And if we required all new construction, which is what the thrust of all the communications we had from Mammoth Lakes Housing for our packet, I mean, the developer couldn't possibly do it, and what it would cost would come out of that $10 million of additional financial contribution, and we need that for lots of things in this town. The trails, you know, the trails development, which is adjacent to the property, needs it.
2:57:47 Stream corridor, open space stream corridor needs it. Mobility, you know, just with more people, that money can be very well spent on other things. So, and not only that, it's just so expensive. I mean, we don't need all that new construction. I think even though there was one project that turned out to, you know, have huge cost overruns, I think you can get a lot more bang for the buck using other tools in the toolbox. Let's see.
2:58:17 I very much favor the language that Karen Farrell Ingram asked for from Eastern Sierra Land Trust. I think having a fee title donation is acceptable, and I'm really gratified to hear that one of my questions, gee, why are you delaying on the conservation easement? It was for such a wonderful reason, so that's great. I was very happy about that. As far as golf not being a community benefit or the programming not being a community benefit, it is because it brings TOT.
2:58:44 The hotel is a community benefit because of what it's going to, you know, bring to the community in the way of additional revenues. And it's not just TOT, it's what our general plan is all about. I mean, our whole physical development concept and the general plan, Appendix C. This is where we said as a community, after many years of debating and discussion, this is what we want to do and this plan fits and that's why we worked so hard to get best possible outcome for the master plan.
2:59:14 So unless I think of something else when others are talking, that's what I have. Through the chair, may I ask for a point of clarification from Commissioner Tenney? You mentioned a COLA. You said, as I said, there's three pots. There's the additional financial contribution of $10 million, there's processing fees, and then there's the DIF fees. Were you saying the COLA should be applied to all three or to...? I didn't even think about the DIF.
2:59:42 Because the DA already applies it to the processing fees. Okay, I wasn't sure. I saw that language, but I wasn't. The DA applies it to processing fees. Okay, I would need discussion with the commission about whether or not to apply it to the DIF. I didn't want to put an idea in your head. I was just asking for clarification. I've been sitting here for three and a quarter hours and then to the additional financial contribution.
3:00:12 But I would like to discuss with you about whether it should also be applied to the diff, putting a cola. I would like to hear what you have to say. And Elizabeth, I want to clarify, my comment about the golf course and the, is not that it, the entire thing cannot be counted as a benefit. I didn't think. It is, you know, it's about half and half, half for the developer and half for the community. Okay. So maybe. Yeah, that makes, that makes sense. Right. And your comment about the.
3:00:40 Money, the $10 million, it has to be used according to the current DA within the sphere. I was talking about housing. If brand new construction, you know, this $209,000 gap, if brand new construction is required for all of the housing mitigation, I mean, the developer can't afford that. It's just like saying, why aren't we getting the $10 million up front? Well, you know, you just don't go down to the parking lot and get it out of the trunk of the car. It's not there. It's cash flow. That's what it is.
3:01:10 And it's the same thing with the housing. You can't afford that. So where is that money going to come from? Well, it probably will come out of the additional financial contribution. And I would be very saddened if that were the case because we need it for so many other things. For many other things. And the reason that having the nexus with that, what's the geographic thing called? What's the word? What was the word for the geographic thing for the nexus? Yeah, the geographic.
3:01:39 Area of Nexus. Geographic area of Nexus is we want this project to succeed. I mean, we want it just to be hugely successful and bring people to Mammoth to support our economy and, you know, enjoy what we have here. And so that's the reason for having it be the geographic Nexus, and that makes all kinds of sense to me, rather than having it be put in the town budget, you know, for...
3:02:02 for other things, other places. We want this project to succeed and want to do everything we can to make sure it's good for the developer, but especially that it's good for us. First, with respect to greater community benefits, Sharon and Elizabeth both alluded to similar kinds of concerns. The list of, the best list, I think, is in Exhibit B to the DA of the greater community benefits. And a lot of those
3:02:34 Could use some amplification so that parties on both sides understand what's expected there. I'm on page 1-75. Yeah, right. Yeah. The best example I have seen of that so far was Ms. Farrell-Ingram's discussion of the preservation of Mammoth Creek open space corridor. And she's kind of an expert in that area and came up with some things that I had no idea were issues.
3:03:02 That's the kind of thing I would like to see thought about with most of those other greater community benefits. And maybe with that as an example, what would be the best way for us to do this is to suggest to staff that they explore that with people who have the right knowledge of some good ways to flesh out each of those or consider fleshing out each of those and where it's appropriate to suggest some additional criteria. And, you know, I like just a few of them.
3:03:32 These may be ridiculous, but for example, with the 8.9 acres of park area, maybe there needs to be a specification about when that's available to the public, other criteria like that. The public spaces, somebody talked earlier about programming. I think that's something that could be helpful there is to have a little bit of definition of what programming will be provided. You mean by the hotel? Well,
3:04:00 By the hotel, by other parties, you know, there's a lot of room for structuring that. Just something so that both parties understand, make sure their expectations are not skewed. Right, I think that's a good point. Okay, and then the required annual review, Elizabeth, you mentioned that you would like the developer in the annual review to include market and financial report.
3:04:28 Regarding hotel development. Yeah, that's a specific, more generally what I would say is that it would really help, again, for both the parties to understand what the expectations are to have some kinds of objective criteria like that expected other than just it's got to be in good faith. And one of those objective criteria is like you mentioned, the hotel market report. So, again, if staff could look at that and come up with some ideas for things that back up that.
3:04:58 that are indicia of good faith in that annual report. There's quite a bit of good faith phraseology. I'm sorry, say again. There's quite a bit of good faith phraseology and I wish there was more specifics. Yeah. Good faith is fine if you have some specifics to back it up. Same kind of a comment with respect to the schedule.
3:05:23 Part of the development agreement, article 2.2.1, dealing with phasing and performance. We have the 10-year requirement. Again, could staff look at that over the 20-year period? Are there some other objective indicators that could be used there to help both parties understand what's expected? The 10-year one's good, but I'd like to see more of that. And then my final is cost of living that we've already discussed.
3:05:55 All of us mentioned that, I think, so far. And as you saw from my question to Chuck, I'm not, I don't think it's a good idea to transfer that whole risk to the developer. I think there should be some shared pain there, or potential pain, I guess it's not actual pain. If we can work out a way for us to, for both parties to share in the extreme downside situation, which hopefully won't happen.
3:06:22 But to mitigate that among both parties. Share the risk on the fees? Share the risk on the fees? I'd say, well, we should look at it for both. Okay. For both DIF and the additional financial contribution. Okay. That's the end of my comments. Thank you. Well, I guess I bring a different perspective to this. I don't agree that a call should be added. I think that the...
3:06:53 The agreement of the $10 million goes over and above that. I look at this development agreement as being new territory. I look at this commission as having the ability to be mavericks in new territory of development agreements. This town has a history of failed development agreements. And let me just kind of briefly go through those. We started with the original Snow Creek development agreements that were never completed.
3:07:27 Tom Dempsey did great things for this town. Even without the development agreements, if it wasn't for Dempsey, we wouldn't have the bell-shaped parcel, we wouldn't have properties for the school, we wouldn't have propane in this town. It wasn't part of the DA though. Then we come across to the Hot Creek issue in 1997, so I'm taking you back 13 years now. Town Council, actually Kirkstapp was part of that agreement. It failed. We're now sitting in a $30 million lawsuit. You then have the IntraWest.
3:08:01 DA agreement, or DA. Again, I think I don't need to go through it. It's failed again. No parking, no success of the village, trade-offs of infrastructure for Canyon Boulevard. We got a piece of property that we can't build a parking structure on. It failed. You have the development agreement with Mammoth Mountain Starwood for the North Hotel, the South Hotel, their other properties. We didn't encumber them as much as we could have, but it still failed also. It went back to the bank.
3:08:38 My concern is you now have the new territory of a new DA that's not defined by the failed DAs of the past. Frankly, the folks that have spoke out against this are responsible for those DAs. They're responsible for the failures of them. And I can't see why we are taking comments that are made from folks that negotiated failed agreements and implementing them into a DA.
3:09:11 That takes us into the future. Thus, I don't support the COLA. I support the DA as it is. I believe that the benefits that are there far outweigh any other benefits greater and above in any DA this town has ever entered into. And that's why you don't support the COLA? Yes. Okay. And I don't support it because of the $10 million. You know, I think if we send this to negotiation, as you're suggesting, the staff for more analysis,
3:09:43 that there's going to be trade-offs. So if you're willing to allow that 10 million to go down, which it will, this is a negotiation. If you're willing to let other things go out of this development agreement that makes it a more solid agreement, it gives it the ability to be a success, then that's your choice. I believe that staff, the consultants, the applicant, going back to the original group that Roy Sari was on,
3:10:17 Worked diligently to come to where we are today. I'm very pleased that John Wentworth with MLTPA have taken the position they have. We have seen how cooperation works to come to a good product that could be successful. I think that what has been brought up by my fellow commissioners are really things that don't play that much into the success, meaning that it could be detrimental to the success if they're changed.
3:10:49 If there's, you know, a majority to have staff work on this, then I would ask that we bring this back no later than next Tuesday. And I don't know if staff could do that, but I think the importance of not letting this linger far outweighs just letting it stand out there in the wind. Again, it's a negotiation. You don't do that. You don't, you know, you don't have 10 million sitting in your lap.
3:11:19 And then walk away from it. That just concerns me. I think a lot of the policies that are coming forward that are going to council, especially housing, and I'm very pleased that Pam was able to get up and speak more for Mammoth Lakes Housing than what we were hearing from other parties. The importance of having a good relationship of Mammoth Lakes Housing in our town is so important for our future.
3:11:49 And it saddens me that there's been some fractures there. And not calling folks out, I know that Pam has done an excellent job. It's a board that she's dealing with. So I think for us to encumber the developer and start making changes that we're suggesting is not going to give us the best product possible. I'm willing, if the applicant's willing, to go to Tuesday if staff can come back with answers.
3:12:22 But I just feel that we're messing with the buyer here. I cannot tell you after living in this town for 24 years of having the failed agreements by past councils, by past planning commissions, and Jay, Elizabeth, Rhonda, I mean, you've been on this commission for quite some time. You've lived in this community, all of you, many years. And Sharon, I realize you're new, but there's so much history going back as to...
3:12:49 Why? We keep repeating the same thing over and over again. And that's failed agreements. So I really believe this, as I said, is new territory. It's maverick. It puts us in a position for our future. It puts us in a position for a successful future. So I would be happy to listen to more, but I really think that we need to keep that in mind about this is a negotiation and be very careful about what we're requesting.
3:13:20 and what the return is and what we're going to get up. Well stated. Thank you. I won't belabor the points that have been brought forward, but just a couple things I wanted to bring up. I agree with fellow commissioners on just more clearly defining the transfer and the development rights. I think that came forward and I think that's language that would be easy.
3:13:49 to work with. I'm very pleased to see the Eastern Sierra Land Trust that that's actually a work in progress and understanding that within two years you're expecting this to be resolved, which is very encouraging and there's options. That's rare that there's options as well. I'm going back and forth regarding COLA applying to
3:14:16 The AFC, because looking at this, this is a 10 million is above and beyond. I will go with fellow commissioners, but I have a tendency to say that the way that this is applied, it is that I wouldn't necessarily support it. I don't want to hold up the process for this, but I think that it's not subject to COLA adjustment there for this 10 million.
3:14:45 I agree with Commissioner Barrett. A couple of things that I do want to bring in, and there's been a lot of question about the validity of certain studies and, you know, errors. And I, this is a particular area, and what are community benefits? This is my area of expertise in the last 20 years, whether it's been through training or
3:15:12 Trial of Fire, so I don't actually have the same issues here because I have vetted these myself. And in sales strategic plans, whether it's for hotel marketing or what is developing for events, these things I find to be in line. And just a further clarity is when we're listing these particular community benefits,
3:15:39 That keep coming up a lot. Is this truly a benefit? Is it a benefit for the developer? What do we get out of it? It's realizing that these have, when they're done right, as we believe that we're seeing ahead, they have a synergistic effect. It's more than one and one. These things actually equal three. And a championship golf, and I'll use this as an example because if we want to go further, I'm happy to go there.
3:16:06 A championship 18-hole golf course designed by a top architect when combined with another 18-hole golf course in town allows you to market yourself as a golf destination. We cannot market ourselves right now as a golf destination because we simply do not meet the criteria of having enough golf to play within a certain radius that allows us to attract those customers.
3:16:32 Now, if you have two, you can attract those customers that end up spending an excessive amount of money within the community, not just at this. Golf courses lose money if they are not put together with the other entities and it's not all in one place. It is throughout the community. So those are working with ways that how
3:16:59 This adds not only a benefit to the developer, but it has an enhanced benefit to the community. The other is the programming of public spaces, and we discussed the public spaces as in the Great Lawn. You definitely want to work with the community to make sure that we're not having conflicting events within, you know, with in the same, appealing to the same market at the same time. But it is particularly an area which
3:17:28 Also, I know from experience, they can lose a lot of money. They're a great gift to town, everything from the spectacular night of lights 20 years ago to what it is now. They're a great gift, but the ones putting them on are not necessarily making the money. The community does. And that's how you have to relate those two. And looking very closely at programming, are these things going to benefit?
3:17:56 The community as well as the one putting them on. Oftentimes in the case with motocross, it is benefiting the community a lot more because Mammoth Mountain Ski Area does not produce it any longer for this very reason. But it was able to come together with this cooperative relationship. So these things, if you're not in the business every day living and dying by these particular things, it's hard to understand that relationship. But they are there. They are community benefits.
3:18:24 They benefit everyone, whether they benefit some more than others. It depends on how successful these events are. And we can talk to Ken and Flossie about that as well if we want to know. And then the last point is, Sharon, you brought up a good point about the egress, which we already have. And we discuss this a lot in the master plan along with the access and the secondary roads. We have those.
3:18:54 Because no, he has granted that. That is not something that was, you know, it has come there because people have used it. It's allowed to be used and it is a benefit to allow that because there's other areas that we do not have the access that we did before once it got developed and to recognize that we're going to continue with that. That is something that we need to make sure shows up as a benefit at that time because we're still mitigating other issues where we no longer have access.
3:19:23 So those are the type of things that the analysis is not deep enough. We do need to go in and explain these particular issues there. And looking at this being a long-term agreement with, I'm very encouraged to see that you can get in the room and fight it out and come up with something because there was no other solution for housing. It was not going to please anyone.
3:19:50 The fact that we're willing to go back and do that is quite encouraging to me. That's what I have. At this point, is there any further discussion, anything else that we want to do before we entertain a motion, discuss that, decide what our next steps are? Well, I'd just like to add to your community benefit discussion you just had that, you know, folks, I mean, the community benefits that are being put forward that are described within our document, the greater community benefits.
3:20:21 Are far more than any you will find in any other development agreement. Go to Joe. Have you seen this much added into a DA in your history of working with DAs? I mean, it's a pretty incredible amount. I mean, when you look at, in my opinion, the development and what a normal DA would have, the golf course alone, with maybe a few other items, probably is what you would see. If you focus on particular things, you're probably right.
3:20:49 For this community, it's something that is very unusual to be gained. However, if you look at it from a complete package financial approach, it's in the range, it's really, it's in the range, and it's very reasonable compared to other development agreements. But just the size of our communities, yeah. Yeah, and I just, you know, I mean, the 10 million on top of that, it's, you know, it's kind of an unheard of thing.
3:21:19 In my opinion. And I just, again, want to go back to the COLA, Elizabeth. Attaching a COLA to the 10 million, we're going to have to give something up. It's just part of a negotiation. And I just, I don't want to see us give anything up. I want us to keep the 10 million. I want to keep the community benefits that are being brought forward. And I want us to show that we are on new territory and we're moving forward in our town. And we're going to have a successful development agreement for once.
3:21:48 Your argument is very compelling. Mark, when I suggested we have a COLA on the additional financial contribution, I was thinking of it since it is a cash flow over a 20-year period and it goes unit by unit. You know, it's almost like a surcharge or something on each unit. What kind of impact would that have? I mean, I know what things cost back in the 70s as compared to now, but 20 years out,
3:22:18 Any way of, you know, Jay talks about rampant inflation and, you know, some economists talk about that. Right now we have none. I think there are a lot of little questions in there. One question. So with inflation generally, the future value, the present value of the future value of that money will be less. That's true, isn't it? And we could run an analysis of that. It's relatively straightforward.
3:22:50 But I don't necessarily think that's your key issue. I think that in terms of a partnership agreement, everybody's expectation is the developer performs. You want him to. And we're all subject to the marketplace. And to the extent that the market is slow because of economic recovery, so be that.
3:23:18 When you're placing a COLA on the cost of inflationary protection, you're betting against the developer, if you will, or the marketplace. And so I think you have to balance it with the financial penalty that it will pose on the developer and your desire to see it move forward and expecting to proceed.
3:23:42 So, and what we do know is that some development agreements provide colex protection and some don't. It really is a policy choice. But we can tell you that, yes, inflation may erode the values. It's more likely that it will erode the value than it is unlikely. And so that would apply for both the financial contribution and debt. So that same concept applies to both.
3:24:10 Nobody on the commission addressed a COLA on the diff. Anybody have a concern about that? Well, I'll just go back to both, and I'm moving towards dropping that for a different reason than anything anybody has expressed. It's because it's a very slight possibility of being a very huge problem. So it's a risk that the town will assume, but it's not likely to happen.
3:24:40 From that point of view and, you know, not having consensus, I think I'd just be in favor of dropping it. I've been persuaded as well, so I would do so. And I'd like to just point also, I apologize, she's not here now, but Eastern Sierra Land Trust, I'm also in favor of that language. I thought I had said it earlier, but just to be clear. And then also, what does the Commission feel about making a recommendation that we have an oversight committee on the use of the $10 million?
3:25:10 Can we do that? You always, Joe, you lead forward like you have an opinion. If I may, to the chair. Help us out here. My initial reaction to that is this development agreement is really to be a document between the developer and the town. It would be unusual for the town to place some process in the development agreement that the town has to follow. I mean, the town has the ability to...
3:25:39 Follow whatever they want to follow. We can, can we craft a recommendation that fits that, though? I mean, it doesn't have to go into the development. It's part of our recommendation. It's not something that's incorporated in the agreement itself. Could that be part of, as we've done in the past? Yes, you can do that. Sure. Is there a consensus for that? Mm-hmm. I think it's good. And then also on the language. Sharon, you had a comment.
3:26:09 I was just going to say I guess I'm the only one who wants $10 million in 10 years, and it won't be there if we have heavy inflation. And DIF also, not subject to COLA, makes me very, very uneasy for the town of Mammoth Lakes. So I've not been convinced yet, as you others have, so I just want to put that out there. And go ahead. Thank you.
3:26:36 As for the language that I proposed that comes from, I think it's North Star, regarding the construction that we discussed earlier, is that something that there's consensus that I requested that there be language in the DA that specifies local contractors, local sales, point of sale. I think that one that's got a strong likelihood that...
3:27:03 The parties can agree on, so. Which I said, okay. Yeah. I just want to make sure there's consensus for that also, so we have that in there, Jen. Correct, right, but that's something you would be able to work out with staff. And do I'm hearing consensus to the resolution of the housing issues by the community development, Mammoth Lakes Housing and the developer, would we would like to see what you come up with? Do we have to see it before it goes to council?
3:27:37 Consensus. So that consensus that was stated was live within the financial framework but develop other programs that would fit within that framework. Yes. Which may or may not be part of the development agreement and it becomes a future affordable housing implementation program. Oh, okay. Understanding it that way. And that's your understanding also, Pam. That's two thumbs up. Okay. I think something I just said, it would be, excuse me for interrupting, it would be our hope that what we could do is...
3:28:07 Is you do make a recommendation today, but part of the recommendation is that we work with Pam as we said we would, we work with staff as we said we would to refine this language as it goes to town council. Exactly. So by the 16th you would have something remarked. Exactly. So this will not come back to us, we won't have an additional meeting. The language that we ask for, like stronger language here or whatever, will go directly to council. That's your option. Because we've indicated our...
3:28:35 Preferences, intent, et cetera. We've been clear? So may we ask if the Chair and another member of the Commission receives the language before it goes, just to be clear that it's, you know, not it wouldn't be a vote, but of course it would just be the review. So a two-member planning commission committee to confirm the statements that will be forwarded. I can see a major.
3:29:01 Mm-hmm. You can see it by email. If you can see it by email because Elizabeth served with me on the master plan. That would be good. That's a great idea of the ad hoc committee. That's great. Yeah, that would be very good. If I could see it by email. I'm noting your consensus. We all nodded. Okay, good. Bobbing heads. Bobbing heads at this time. We've become bobbleheads after three and three-quarters hours in this chair. So, John.
3:29:28 Sorry. If I may, just for the record, are we reopening the public hearing? No. No. Thank you. You didn't realize how casual we are. We're pretty casual, but our attorney is getting troubled.
3:29:48 Has been closed at this point. And so we're in debate. We're about to have a motion. Is there anything that you would be contributing to it at this point? I would just ask a question that you don't have to engage if you don't want to. In our letter, we laid out some ideas about benchmarking for funding. Should you guys come to consensus? Should the council agree to go forward with a development agreement?
3:30:18 And I would ask the commission, is there any, is there going to be any suggestion from the commission as to should the development agreement be recommended the way it is, go in front of council, the disposition of the funds, the $10 million being recommended, is there any recommendation from this commission as to how the community can expect to engage with that process? You can say yes or no, it's a question as to how that works. Are you okay with us? Oh no.
3:30:43 Sure choice. So, I mean, I think our language, John, that we covered about making a recommendation separate from the DA to the council was covering that. Okay, yeah, I wasn't clear. Yeah, it's just, we can't put the language in the DA, but we can make a side recommendation or recommendations to the council of things we would like to see addressed. Yeah, I'm just thinking in terms of the process. Yeah. Right. No, I mean, there's generally blocks are defeated.
3:31:09 Intentionally, no one's talking about how to get into that. Right. But if this goes forward, it'd be nice for the community to have some expectation of how. I think that's more of a council issue as well. Okay, it is. So what we will carry forward is we will acknowledge that there will be a separate account and a counting of the money. Okay, good. Separately an oversight committee. And then essentially, this is going to be a town. How does the town council.
3:31:32 Consider, evaluate projects, and make recommendations, and how does the public become more involved in that? So it's not an arm wrestle between Pam and John with Ted. It's a cage. I'll sell tickets. Okay. That's how I understood it. That we would have one as well. Okay. So...
3:31:55 I think that we've covered all the major issues at this point, unless someone has anything else for discussion. If not, I would entertain a motion at this time. I move that we recommend to Town Council that they find the development agreement consistent, 09-001, consistent with the Town Municipal Code, Chapter 17.48, Snow Creek 8 EIR.
3:32:24 The Snow Creek 8, Snow Creek Master Plan Update 2007, and the Environmental Impact Report, and Snow Creek 7, mitigated negative declaration and improved the development agreement 09001 with the conditions of approval as modified by the Planning Commission. I'll second that. Any further question or discussion? I just like to say it's been a great process. Sorry.
3:32:58 Well, it's just been a great process, and I think this is, you know, something that we need to look forward to in the future of having the different agencies, applicants, TETS comments, everything coming together and working as a community for the better good. So I've enjoyed this process, and I just thank my fellow commissioners for all the work they've put into it, especially our ad hoc group that has put quite a bit of time. I just want to remember that Lloyd was part of that too. Absolutely. Thank you. Okay.
3:33:25 We'll call for the vote. Let's do a roll call vote on this. Yes. Commissioner Clark? No, and I think I stated my reason. I'm very concerned about the feasibility for the town of Mammoth Lakes if we do not have a cost of living attached to the financial contribution as well as diff. Commissioner Duncan? Yes. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Barrett? Yes. And Chair Dugan?
3:33:55 Yes. Thank you. There was one point that resonates through this, is that this whole process is an effort to have a successful project and make things succeed. So if we keep working towards that, we trust that all of the things that bring together these teams, that we can make this work. And so I want to thank you for your patience and time. We do have one other item on the agenda.
3:34:25 for anyone that can handle it. Thank you very much. Thank you. Thank you. At this point. You may wish to take a brief break. Yeah, let's take a break. I'm afraid to fall over. It's the Clearwater Pacific Plan Amendment, and it's an application to request the amendment.
3:34:52 to the plan implementing conditions of approval related to the SEVIS policy and fee waivers. As many as you may know, I now have to recuse myself from this item here, so I'm going to turn the gavel over to Vice Chair Barrett. Thank you.
3:35:23 Okay, so as Chair Dugan had stated, this is the specific plan amendment. Number one, we have an amendment to the Clearwater Specific Plan CSP to implement conditions of approval of the Old Mammoth Place project relating to the CBIS policy and fee waivers for the portions of the project that qualify as incentive, density, or community benefit. And number two, grant by ordinance fee waivers for the portions of the Old Mammoth Place project.
3:35:50 That qualify as incentive, density, or community benefit. For the benefit of the public, this is a carryover from our last action. Call it maybe a cleanup. It's a housekeeping issue. And with that, I will turn this over to Mark, and I will open the public hearing. Thank you. As stated, this is really an implementation measure, a housekeeping item.
3:36:16 I'll introduce the item. Your staff presentation will be provided by Mr. Kevin Ennis. This, as you recall, during the discussion of the Old Man Meta Place use permit, we discussed and the Planning Commission established conditions of approval in order that the implementation of the community benefits incentive zoning policy could be reconciled and result in an amendment to various municipal code sections.
3:36:44 And this item is that analysis and recommendations to achieve that implementation measure. The reason Mr. Ennis is here is that the application was filed by the applicant and we informed the applicant that we didn't have sufficient staff resources, we're working on other things such as a development agreement. And so in order for them to proceed, they asked if they could
3:37:12 Hire contract planning services. Contract planning services are a typical way of outsourcing. And in this case, there are not significant policy issues. The Old Mammoth Place Use Permit was considered. And so we felt comfortable relying on Mr. Ennis, who is our special legal counsel, to actually craft this implementation language. So with that, I'll turn it over to Mr. Ennis.
3:37:40 Thank you, Mr. Wardlaw and Vice Chairman, members of the Commission and audience. As Mr. Wardlaw indicated, this is to implement conditions of approval that you already imposed on the Old Mammoth Place project and specifically conditions 3 and 102 as cited in the staff report require the town within a year from the approval of the project to
3:38:08 Reconcile the provisions of the SEVIS policy with town code provisions. So we have been analyzing that issue since the project was approved on April 21st by the town council on appeal. And we looked at various options for accomplishing this reconciliation. Of course, the one option was to do a generally applicable town code amendment.
3:38:37 that would provide for the fee waiver language in the town code for each of the different categories of fees and that this would be applicable to all development projects that met the SEVIS policy and were approved under that policy. It was thought that that could take some time and careful thought analysis to word a waiver provision that would be generally applicable. So we looked at some other options, one of which was a development agreement.
3:39:06 which is indicated in the report we felt was not the most appropriate mechanism. Lastly, there were two other options, a specific plan amendment to the Clearwater specific plan and then an ordinance to grant the specific fee waiver provisions for this specific project only. This application constitutes and is both of those latter two proposals, meaning a specific plan amendment and
3:39:33 recommendation of an ordinance to grant the specific fee waiver for this project only by ordinance. So let me walk through the contents of DZA10-002. The first component is to add clarifying text to the Clearwater Specific Plan. And in boiling it down to its basic, it does four things. First of all, it clarifies what was the community benefit that was granted for this project.
3:40:04 So we've specified that in textual amendments to the specific plan. Secondly, we make clear in several places in the specific plan that approved incentive density and community benefits are exempt from the payment of development impact fees, public art fees, and program requirements, and workforce housing ordinance requirements. We also make clear in textual amendments that the base density
3:40:34 Or any square footage that doesn't qualify as community benefit is still subject to applicable development impact fee, public art fee, program requirements for workforce housing. And lastly, we carry out textual language of conditions 3 and 102 relating to what is the fee to be calculated, what fees in place at various times are we going to impose on this particular development.
3:41:01 So those are the four textual elements of the amendment to the specific plan. The other part of this, DZA 1002, is recommending to the Town Council that by ordinance they grant specific waivers to the three different ordinance provisions for the incentive density and community benefits portion of this project. I want to mention that for purposes of CEQA,
3:41:33 We have reviewed the EIR that was certified for the Clearwater Specific Plan on January 7, 2009. We looked at the conformance review document. It was prepared in connection with the Old Mammoth Place project, and we find that the project is consistent with the project as analyzed in that document, meaning this particular amendment is not changing.
3:41:57 The physical nature of that project or changing its implementation measures or mitigation measures. The options before you are, number one, to recommend that the town council determine that the project is consistent with those environmental documents and approve district zoning amendment 10-002 with or without additional modifications or option two, recommend that the town council deny
3:42:24 District Zoning Amendment 10-002. Staff is recommending that the commission choose option one. Attached to the staff report is the resolution which would embody your recommendation to the town council. It includes background findings as to how we get to this point, has sequel findings. It contains the recommendation that staff is suggesting. And then as exhibits, and specifically exhibit A3,
3:42:53 Is the actual textural amendments proposed to the Clearwater-specific plan that would make this fee waiver clear? So with that, that concludes my presentation, and I'm happy and available to answer any questions you may have. Great, thank you. All right, so we'll take questions that are specific to these two items. Sharon, would you like to go first, please? Are we going to have a chance to ask the... This is questions just... Mark, is this...
3:43:24 Project ready to, is it building imminent? No, this is the implementation of the municipal code changes. So there's no urgency to, for this to be passed in terms of building, use of coming forward, a building permit? No. Thank you. Is that all your questions? That's it. Elizabeth, do you have any questions for staff?
3:43:52 No, I think this is a housekeeping matter that should be tidied up. Okay. I think it's very clear. No questions. I feel the same way. So with that, this is a public hearing. We'll go to the applicant. Any presentation you may have? Mark Kearney. Thank you. Good evening, Chair Barrett and Commissioners. My name is Mark Kearney. I'm here on behalf of Metric Manigal, seeing the applicants, Jim and Nancy Demetriatus.
3:44:19 Basically, we really don't have much to add substantively. Really what we're trying to do is document the business deal that both parties had and our expectations leading up to the Planning Commission meeting. I just want to thank Mark Wardlaw and his staff for allowing us to go forward with this procedure on this timeline and compliment Mark and his particular special counsel, Mr. Ennis.
3:44:46 A very elegant solution in solving the problem that we were faced with by the approval of the project. So that's really all we have to say. We think they've done a great job, and we thank them for their help, and we ask you for your recommendation of approval. Thank you, Mark. This is a public hearing, so at this time we'll ask anyone that wishes to oppose the project to come to the podium, state your name. Anyone wishing to speak in favor? General testimony?
3:45:16 All right, with that, I'll close the public hearing and we'll go into discussion or a motion. Elizabeth? To ask for all this mitigation on top of something that's already a community benefit sort of reminds me of, you know, double dipping with pensions or something. It just is over the top. So I'm in favor of this option, option one. Sharon?
3:45:43 Obviously, I considered the SEVIS policy quite controversial when we had the hearing. Since then, of course, there's been an appeal. The town council made the comments after following the appeal that the SEVIS policy needs to be changed, and I'm quoting, needs work.
3:46:04 Do need to address the policy, continue to get clarity. I had hoped that we would meet with town council. We, I thought, had a year to get the policy and our codes in order. That has not happened. So I feel very uncomfortable trying to second guess where the town council is coming from, and I cannot support it. Okay.
3:46:36 I think it's very clear. I don't think any of what Commissioner Clark is saying is relevant to this issue. I think it's clear and we should go ahead. I don't see this as about the seed is policy. This is different. I agree. This is a totally different issue. It's basically housekeeping, so it does go to town council. If it's housekeeping, we had a whole year. So I don't see it as housekeeping.
3:47:05 So as I was saying, if I may finish, I don't see this as the end of something that's the beginning of the process, and thus I'm very supportive. All right, any further discussion? All right, there's a motion. I'll give it a try. I move that the Planning Commission choose option one to adopt the resolution that's set out in our packet that...
3:47:32 Recommends the Town Council determine that the project is consistent with the Clearwater Specific Plan Environmental Impact Report pursuant to the California Environmental Quality Act guidelines and approve District Zoning Amendment 10-002. I second. Right, there's a motion and a second. Is there any further discussion? If not, Anita can we have a roll upon this, please. Yes. I beg your pardon, who was a second? I'm still on this machine. I second it. Thank you very much.
3:48:06 Okay. It's all on the screen. Commissioner Clark. It's high tech. Commissioner Clark. I think I stated my reason for saying no. Commissioner Banken. Yes. Commissioner Tenney. Yes. And Vice Chair Banken. Yes. Motion passes 3-1. Thank you for this. Mark Carney, thank you. Thank you very much. If we could have Rhonda back in. Oh, Rhonda.
3:48:38 Rhonda promised me six. I don't think we're going to make it. We did finish. We finished this by six. No. No, we got the housing elements. No, we finished this by six. That was what we said. No, no. No, we finished this item by six. No, that's not what I heard. Oh, that's what Rhonda and I said. Oh, I didn't hear what you said. We got the housing element. I was supposed to drive to Reno tonight. That's not going to happen. Housing element is time-sensitive. It has to be addressed tonight. We're back. Item three matters with the draft housing element.
3:49:28 Update on the study session, and Ellen, you're on, finally. Thank you. Chair Dugan, I'll try and keep this short and sweet. I think I overheard you saying this is a somewhat time-sensitive matter, just as you are probably where we're trying to bring the housing element, get the housing element adopted by the end of June and bring this, we have a public hearing scheduled with you on June 9th and with the town council on June 23rd.
3:49:59 And so this meeting is really an opportunity just to update you on some revisions that have been made to the housing element in response to comments from the Department of Housing and Community Development so that you're familiar with those, see if you have any additional questions or questions on the previously circulated draft of the housing element so that we are as prepared as possible for that hearing on the 9th and can bring back any changes to you to expedite that process to the extent possible.
3:50:28 I won't go into a lot of detail. I think it's laid out quite clearly in your staff report what the changes were. We did circulate the draft housing element to HCD in February. They have 60 days to provide their comments and, of course, took the full 60 days to give those comments to us. And in the interim, we worked to develop a CEQA document, a draft.
3:50:53 Negative declaration, initial study, negative declaration for the project, which has also been circulated for review. The changes that were made were relatively minor. HTD has submitted 10 or 20 page comment letters to some jurisdictions on the housing elements. We were lucky to get away with a three page comment letter with fairly minor comments.
3:51:16 Principally directed at the housing sites analysis, which HED has become increasingly concerned with over recent years. And then also some more minor changes with regard to programs for special needs housing, including supportive and transitional housing, as well as housing for extremely low-income residents, who are those who are earning under 30% of the area median income.
3:51:41 In response to those changes, we, I would say, tightened up some of our site's analysis, provided some more realistic and conservative estimates for development of units on the Snow Creek site and also on Shady Rest, and also added a program to be somewhat more proactive in working with the owner and developer of the Shady Rest site to update the master plan and potentially to include provisions that would streamline future development approvals when that master plan comes forward.
3:52:10 And then secondarily, with regard to the special needs housing, we did add in a few more programs that will ensure our municipal code is entirely consistent with state law and that we do call out those special needs groups in our housing programs and direct programs to help to facilitate things like group housing, transitional housing, and that sort of thing in the community.
3:52:35 Those are really the extent of the changes, fairly minor. The remainder of the draft remains as you previously reviewed it. I won't go into a lot of detail on the CEQA document except to say that it's fairly straightforward. It recognizes that this is a program-level document, a policy document that does not in and of itself create new development. It simply puts programs in place that encourage housing development of various sorts that revises our
3:53:05 Codes to be consistent with state law requirements and to remove regulatory barriers to housing where we found them to exist. And for those reasons, we found that a negative declaration finding that the housing would have no significant impact on the environment was appropriate, and we wrote the document to that end. That comment period ends on June 1st, so we'll expect to have any comments prior to your June 9th hearing, and you'll be able to...
3:53:34 to see those at that time. So with that, do you have any questions? Is Sacramento weighted toward new construction? Not particularly. They understand that many communities are built out, that it's hard to build new units, and so they really look for a very broad range of programs to facilitate and provide.
3:53:56 New housing. So I would say not. They recognize that in California where you have a lot of mature communities that building new housing is not always an option for many places. Good. Yeah, I'd just like to add in, and I think, Ellen, you'll remember this from our meeting that Jay and I attended, Pam and some of the housing board, and a comment was made about how the numbers were derived and where they came from, and it kind of disappointed me. So the only thing that I
3:54:26 would really like to have assurances of is that we can back up all the numbers that were in here. The numbers for the? Just on the element, the housing album, how we came about coming across with the numbers that we would look at for the analysis. I'm referring to the comment that we pull them out of the sky. How we determine what our housing allocation is and what our housing plan is.
3:54:57 That was just kind of disturbing to hear that that day. Well, maybe I didn't speak as clearly as I should have done. I mean, the state sort of gives us our allocation, and it's based on demographic information that, you know, looks at projection of our past and future housing trends. So it's not a made-up number, but it's...
3:55:19 You know, may or may not die the gap. I mean, what our local housing need may be based on our own determination. And I forget, did they give that to us based on the community or the county? It's a county-wide allocation which they divide between the unincorporated county and the town. Exactly. And it's about 50-50 between the town and the county. Okay. That gives a context, I think, that it may not be completely applicable if all of your concentration is in one portion of the county. That's what I took it to be. Okay.
3:55:48 Any other questions? That was useful. Thank you. I thought the changes proposed by the state and the way Ellen made the changes to implement those is very clear. I had one minor kind of a technical issue that I sent to Ellen and she made that correction so I have no problem with it. Thank you. Yeah, you've done a great job on this too. Thank you. I look forward to
3:56:18 Defining all the creative tools in our arsenal these days. I guess the quiver gets fuller, huh? Is that how we look at it? So no longer a tool above, it's not an arsenal. It would have come in handy with some of these discussions recently, wouldn't it? Do we have anything for the director's report that we haven't possibly been covered? One thing we've discovered, when the... Money? No, how'd we actually...
3:56:48 When the town council established the ordinance that would be placed on the ballot, somehow and inadvertently, that has been incorporated into our online code, so that's a mistake and we're correcting it. And you know, people look at our code, it's some kind of clerical area. The ordinance is on the web? We have a municipal code service.
3:57:09 And so somehow it was transmitted to them and they stuck it in there. So now it's being removed. It's coming out. Honestly, I thought we had it there because some folks asked me and I thought it was there so they could review it. So when we went to vote, what it was. Heart before the horse. I thought we were doing a good thing there. And then you have, I'll send you information on when you were joint meeting with the council scheduled to discuss.
3:57:34 Yes. And height and all that other stuff. So that's pending in June. We don't have a date yet. I do, I just don't remember when it is. It might be a three separate meetings. I believe it's the 23rd of June, but I'll send you an email. It's not the regular council meeting. The 23rd. Special meeting on the 23rd. Okay. Okay.
3:57:57 Yes, that's the special meeting with the council that we're talking about. And what time of day do you have that special meeting? Five. Five. Five. For the reference, it's five. I'm sorry. Sorry. So at this point, we will be adjourning to our... Do you need to ask for public comment for a second? Just as a technicality. Oh, we have public comment. Do you need public comment? No. Thank you. At this, we'll close the public comment.
3:58:25 And we will adjourn to our regularly scheduled meeting of June 9th. Thank you.