Town Council
· recording 3 hr 17 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
450 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
0:24 Thank you.
0:50 Oh, please do.
1:19 Well, we have 50.
1:20 No, we have just been out.
1:22 25, yeah.
1:22 We have 25.
1:23 We have 25.
1:23 We're actually using our 25th.
1:25 Yeah.
1:25 We're 80.
1:26 Yeah.
1:27 Yeah.
1:28 Yeah.
1:29 Very good.
1:30 Yeah.
1:31 So when that stops, so once this is your current, like I said, yeah.
1:34 Well, I haven't put anything on us.
1:35 I think that we need you.
1:36 Yes, that's right, I know.
1:37 Because I, last year I was there, but I can't put it on this picture.
1:40 I know.
1:41 Well, we're all 50.
1:42 Yeah.
1:43 Well, we should all do it in the description, because we're still .
1:47 No, no, no, no.
1:48 My son is still...
2:14 Because I still, I made him that deal, right? Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah.
2:43 Oh, cut, cut, cut.
3:10 It's the IRS, the IRS, the IRS, the IRS, the IRS.
3:16 We go get a week of training, pre-approval every year.
3:22 That's right.
3:29 This sure helps a lot.
3:33 I do too.
3:38 We do it mostly.
3:39 There was one from Computer Associates that I started using first, and I really liked it. It was a great program. I got one here, and the computer just was bad. It wouldn't download online. I called them. They tried to fix it. They bent me over. I ended up having to buy this other thing at the last minute. This was started in 1984. There was a company. It was about $10,000. There's a company.
4:08 We've got a product called Madison. Do we use that now? They were bought out by another company. They were bought out by another company. Well, in truth, their program is just now getting to the point where this one was. We still use the Tribal House. Tribal House, we've got a state of the city, we've got a state of the city, we've got a state of the city, all of that.
4:37 All I have is students. It's amazing what I have to say. Students just have to bet around.
4:50 Yeah, I didn't want to throw something
5:19 Okay. Here we go.
5:39 I've been called worse, even today.
6:03 Uh-oh. Somebody accused me of having, that I have a reputation of engaging in illegal business activities. Immoral business activities I could see you doing. Illegal business activities. Of course it's easy compared to the criminal charges. Okay, here we go. Who's chair to measure you? Bill, are you? No.
6:32 Vice Chair. Vice Chair. Then you're chairing this. Great. What is their topic? Our topic is the Funding for Measure U Fall Award.
6:46 What we don't have is the knowledge of what is in 74 pages. We couldn't even produce 74 pages.
7:15 Okay. Okay. You've got a summary of his book. And a little bit about the... You have the rankings. You have the various things. So we do know that we do have someone that wants to share something with us. Yes, we have various. But as I said, Bill, I asked him if he's out of the size. Oh. So just tell him right now if he wants to know the audience has to be so sure. Yeah. So if we did...
7:43 It seems to me that the purpose of this is to, even though I don't go back to the audience, is for you in an informal way to make a presentation that you would otherwise make in a formal way, and we will for the benefit of the cameras and the audience tonight, but in an informal way walk through what you want us to know since you are recommending that we adopt that which you've proposed.
8:12 And it'll be an opportunity for us to ask questions, and I hope that it'll be unstructured and informal, and we'll hope to be done in 40 minutes. Yes. 45. 35. Can I get 20? You know, Bill, you take 20.
8:30 I do acknowledge that there are some people in the audience that would like to make some comments, so why don't we do that right up the gate, and then we can... Oh, great. Okay. Are the members of the audience who can speak before we get going? Or... Or later. Or later.
8:57 So actually what I wanted to share with you, I shared with a few members earlier.
9:05 One of the things that the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition is trying to do is maximize marketing dollars. So I just wanted to share with you and add three of the participants in MLAC actually went together and did a co-op ad in the Horizon Magazine, which will be in Alaska Airlines, in the month of March. It's a feature on California events in the summer.
9:29 And in addition to that, they have some editorial that includes Mammoth Lakes in there, and they're also doing a 10,000 print overrun of that that will be placed in tourist locations and airports. And so the cost of this was shared by the three entities that are here. We are already talking about another possibility of sharing advertising and co-op dollars in the June issue. Who's the June issue? It's either the May or the June issue where they're going to be featuring Mammoth Lakes again.
9:57 So I brought copies of this for you to see. Thanks. Anybody else wish to speak for now? All right, good. Joyce, go ahead. How do you want to proceed? Do you want to ask us for our opinions?
10:28 Yeah, go for it. Okay. What's your opinion? As you look at these, as you look at the fingers, you've given a recommendation. Yes. As you look at the recommendations, one of the things that I personally tried to impose on everybody that applied was to not go over last year's allocation. As we've talked about with Council on Measure R and Measure U before, we're trying to
10:51 Wean as much off of it as we can to create that fund for larger CIP projects. So I think that all the people applying, or most of the people applying, did a great job of holding the line and asking for the same or less than they did the year before. And you'll see that our give is far less than the ask in every department. And that left us the $300,000 that you would ask to be set aside to set aside for the capital investment fund.
11:21 It was a, as always, an interesting process, and frankly, I think the committee did a great job. So my recommendation is that you pass it. That didn't take 35 minutes. That's easy. I'll have a couple questions. And another item of note, too, is when the applications were made, there was an estimate that there would be more funding available than...
11:47 was actually available to award. So there was definitely some give and take on coming up with these recommendations and everybody taking a bite to help us meet and stay within our budget. And acknowledging that we were very...
12:03 Reluctant to spend right up to the dollar limit, but preferred leaving some money in the bank. So do you think that there was some negotiation because, you know, there are little reductions here, and so that there was actually some back and forth on where those reductions might have been made with the applicants? Would you say we went back and forth? Well, we went back and forth as committee members. As committee members. We took input from you. Yeah, we scored all of the applicants as we always do.
12:31 And as you heard me say last night, Jo, you were in the meeting last night, the scoring process is, it just really doesn't work because somebody can make a, fill the forms out right to get a higher rating, but we may not feel that that is the best project to move forward. So it sort of ties our hands a little. That being said, there was a lot of discussion amongst us as to how best to keep it down.
13:01 So we did take those filtering numbers and take them into consideration, but they didn't derive, it wasn't like a formula-driven process. We did use our discussion. Yeah, our discussion. We did, but it was numbers up in the 40s. You know, those are pretty clear. There may be more discussion on the small numbers that came out of the ranking. You see the one column of score. And those are just
13:29 Give us a feel for the way we thought it's a mixture of the event itself plus how well a proposal was written. And it's kind of hard to separate that out and we get wrapped up in that too. There are several things such as Pops in the Park was in one of Brian's submittals and that was felt to be supplanting. So you know there were discussions on things like that.
13:57 There may be someone here to discuss wayfinding. We had a three to two vote. We'll be open about it, about whether or not the money for wayfinding was appropriate for Measure U, and obviously we were split. There's a second shoe. I think I noticed Evan back there. You'll see some money here that will do some initial planning with Woodward and Walker, but then there's a second shoe, if that's successful, to do actual construction drawings and all.
14:26 So within a few months, somehow, they'll be looking for another, I think, the number 78,000. So those kinds of things we need to be aware of as we go through this. That's the Performing Arts Center plan. That's the Performing Arts Center plan. This is just the first shoe, but at the same time, there's the involvement of Sierra Coso and what commitments they made, and maybe Evan would want to discuss some of those kinds of things. So, yeah, so, and I would suggest in that 3-2 wayfinding vote in particular, I think what we...
14:56 What we were looking for is bang for the buck and not missing opportunities that are before us more urgently, more currently, whereas wayfinding could be put off and still be built in two, three, five years, and that opportunity doesn't go away. So we didn't want to risk potential opportunities that are right here and right now that could go away.
15:20 In the shorter term for a project that could be built later and wouldn't. We all five recognize that a lot of work's gone into wayfinding. It's a great benefit to the community. You know, if we think we need to do it somehow, the question is how. Can I ask you about that on wayfinding, whether there was a discussion about whether it was a good idea but it was too expensive as proposed? Did you talk about the cost of it? No, we talked more about whether or not the Measure U fund.
15:50 And what it was originally intended for was the funding source for that. And one of the arguments I made, because originally I had it on mine as a fundable, but it would have meant taking some out of the CIP, but since it's a capital project, we could have done that. It does have, you know, momentum going forward. I don't believe it's a Measure U or the original intent to Measure U. I don't think it's a Measure U project. The problem is, do we lose it? Because there is absolutely no other funding source for it.
16:20 So that was... A lot of effort's gone into it. And one of the other points I made, Rick, that's my personal opinion on that one, is that the only source of funds that they were looking for for wayfinding outside of a few private...
16:38 Cooperative deals on specific signs was Measure U funding and I am not convinced that there isn't other funding sources out there so I offered to meet with Faze and get together with him and explore some of the public funding sources I'm aware of and grant sources I'm aware of because I want to be fully convinced there's absolutely no other money available for this other than Measure U because every single Faze had Measure U identified as its funding source.
17:04 One thing that did happen, you can see on your sheet here, it split across two years, and certainly that helped. You may recall several months ago, we also had a Main Street project listed on, a possible measure you, the first thing you saw, and that one was pulled, you know, recognizing the world we're in right now, it was fairly expensive, so it was not added to the list.
17:31 They did split it, and we had requested that, but still, we felt we couldn't get there right now. Now, can I go back, Dr., a comment you made earlier? Okay. Because when you look at the score at home, so anybody looking at this document later is going to see that one that only got a score at 19. Okay. But, so what you're saying is you...
17:53 You guys didn't look just at the score. You also looked at what was going to be accomplished. What's going to be accomplished. On that one, you'll see it says the classic car show they're trying to add on. This is the same weekend as motocross. So we discussed whether or not it really brought more people into town because, you know, this is Old Mammoth Road and people are on Old Mammoth Road then. So it may be not. Motocross is too weekend. Yeah, but it's one of those.
18:23 So it's a benefit. It enlivens that part of town. It's getting started, and we felt that there was merit to it. And they're trying to improve it. I'm sorry I missed it. Which one is that? The second one, Dan. The second one, too. The wine walk. Oh, is that a car show? Oh, okay. I see. Here on Old Mammoth Road. And it is one of those that points out exactly what's wrong with the scoring system. It did not score well.
18:51 But it's bringing animation to a section of town that desperately needs it. The majority of the rest of this all happens in the village, so we're putting a ton of money into keeping the village animated and keeping it going and successful.
19:05 It's important to me that this also extends the season, right? Because it's a before July 4th. It's before July 4th. It's before, yes. Is it the same week as a half marathon that's taking place in the same place? I don't know. I don't know. I don't know that. I don't believe so. I didn't. Because there's the finish lines on Old Man the Throat. Right. But they didn't mention it in their application. And without somebody else bringing that forward, there was no way for me to get there. What's it called? It's probably a way to make it more happen early.
19:34 So I have a question. On the $300,000, is this a threshold that's being set that, or is it not? In other words... No. To me, it's a reserve that would build up over time to do things that need to be done. Right. But as less money comes in, what happens? Or if more money comes in, I mean, I guess I'm trying to say that...
19:59 We need that and a little more. I mean, I would like to set that as a policy as a threshold and also take the fund balance of the 58506 and add it to that. It was a place to start. We picked the 300 number as a place to start. I didn't pick the 300 number. I was sort of told for both R and you that staff and council picked that number. And that's why it was in there. You may not remember that.
20:28 I recall what council meeting you said. So taking the 58-506 and adding it to that, page 13. So if we left it, that's an unallocated amount of money as opposed to specifically earmarking 300 does.
20:58 The fact of the matter is that it's a capital fund. So that doesn't mean that it's going to sit there forever. I'm assuming that if an application came in and it was for a capital project, that we could recommend that council fund it out of the capital fund. So it simply is a portion, and in this case a little over a third.
21:28 That is going specifically to capital projects. A month or more ago, we started a discussion on reserves and all that Manager Holler had put together. And that's an ongoing discussion saying, you know, we need a more controlled way to do these kinds of things. And this is starting that. Maybe it'll have a different name once some of this other stuff proceeds. And maybe under an MLR it'll have a different name.
21:56 But it's a way to start setting aside money to do some of the things that we think we need to do. I will reiterate, I think part of the big push for this is because of the misperception that we are frittering the money away a dime at a time. There's nothing left for capital projects. However, if you look at the true up, we have spent a lot of money on capital projects. We have built a lot of good things. As we all know, events were never apart.
22:25 of Measure U. Yet, with Council's push, they were not. I thought of performing arts. No, no, no. Arts. The reason that, well, I will go back. The reason that arts component was added to the Measure U before it went to the voters was because some folks in town have a whole bunch of money to put into a theater or whatever, and they had no O&M. So we added those people that have been on the Council long enough. We added arts to the Measure U fund.
22:53 And we, I say because I was part of the committee to put that together, specifically because we were going to need the O&M money to manage the arts facilities. Special events was never mentioned, but with Council's push, we decided that this was a good place for special events, and we funded them, and they've been incredibly successful because of it. So I don't see that we're frittering money there. They are what's putting the TOT in our bank at this point because...
23:21 The man upstairs isn't blessing us with the white stuff. It's a lady, Mother Nature. Mother Nature, well, whoever, yeah. Whichever son god you worship. It's a lady. Also, just for the benefit of Michael and Matthew and John, at the next meeting when we are talking about the NLR process, there will be a pie chart that shows how all the money has been spent.
23:46 Because part of that discussion would be about future allocations. So you will see what Bill's talking about. Quick question of the committee members that are here. And trying to be sensitive to Michael's comments as well. I look at this chart and I look at Old Men with Your Own Association. Last year was their first year, is that correct? Yes.
24:14 I think it was pretty successful. So we're dropping them down from 10,000 to 8,000. And then the other one was Village Fest. That has been ongoing. It's been for a number of years, but I think that's a fairly successful event. And the final one, the third one is Sierra Classic Theater from 6,000 requests to 4,500. I'm just thinking if there's any...
24:45 Any sentiment amongst council members or committee members to fund an additional $6,500 and bring those up to the levels where they were last year? Well, there are some reasons not to. Some of the people in their requests last year included money for the tent. It was down at the college, and that wasn't in their requests this year. Okay. So they're comparable in last year? Yeah, I believe they are, yeah.
25:14 Yeah. We did go through all of that in quite a lot of detail to feel fairly comfortable with where the numbers landed relative to firmness. And there was a lot of discussion. Yeah. On my cheat sheet, I had Old Mammoth Road, even though they scored so poorly, I was going to give them the same as last year, and I was going to take the Mammoth Lakes Foundation wine experience back to their last year's numbers. But...
25:41 Somebody's adding something and something's gone away and so we did our give and take and arguing. So you've been through all the details? We've been through, yeah, pretty much, yeah. Paul, since you guys went through that, you thought we had a balance of, the carryover was 54,000 and now we know we've got 58, so there might be 4,000 here.
26:02 I think at this point everybody will be happy if you award the amount that they have asked for because they've probably not plugged that all into their budgets. They've all been informed of the recommendations, yes. And some of them are here tonight to see whether or not you approve those because that's the amount that they're banking on.
26:32 To do the events. Yeah, I mean, I mean, that's my, I mean, my point is, I'm not saying to take away from this, I'm supportive of this, but I'm just saying that I'd like to see the 58 move into the 300s and have a little fun.
26:43 Can I ask how... Is it automatically there? No. No, it's essentially unallocated. What Michael, I think, is saying is allocated to the capital reserve instead of just unallocated. Instead of just... Yeah. That's a reasonable place for it. Well, the way... But remember, that's never happened. There's a process here. So if it stays unallocated...
27:06 We can't just go back in and allocate it. Something has to come in and go through the process. In essence, it gets added to next year's award balance. So the start balance just starts out at $58,000 higher and next year's award. It probably should be because it's going to be lower overall and lower TOT. Exactly right. So if you guys want to continue to...
27:26 Fund the events at the level we're funding them on and you want to continue to put $300,000 aside, that $58,000 pretty much needs to stay in the unallocated portion. If we put it in the CIP, then next year we have to allocate less to the CIP because we're not going to have it. So it's your call. We can go either way. I think Michael's concern is putting it in there so we know it'll go towards that.
27:52 The thought process. Because if you have less come in next year, I mean, that was my point before. I mean, are we going to set a policy that $300 is going to go to the capital improvement fund and everything else will be adjusted lower if there's less money coming in? Or is the $300 getting adjusted down as well? I'd say that's something that we can deliberate on and that it's also going to be the question of
28:14 If you and I are the only council members carrying over, then it might be a different position. It might be a different council. And that's really scary because then the political commitments and everything else go away. And what the people voting for may get... Let's hope not. I'd like to answer what Michael was saying. The $300,000, I would hate to see the council make that a policy, that we have to put that aside.
28:42 Because we have no idea what projects are going to come in. And if we make a policy that it has to go towards this reserve, and then there's a great project, then that ties our hands and we cannot fund that great project. So I look at that not as a set-aside, but as a capital piece of money. So there may be a capital project next year that takes $265,000, and we would only be setting aside the, I screwed myself up, $35,000. I don't do math that fast.
29:12 It's a capital reserve, so I would hate to see it a policy that we're going to put that much money aside every year, because that really ties the hand of this committee or MLR, whoever's looking at it in terms of getting the best bang, recommending to you how to use it to get the best bang for the buck. But it can be a recommendation every year. It can be a recommendation, yeah, just not a policy.
29:37 To change gears, how did the new special events application work for you? Did it help with making your decision? The scoring process is a problem. I think the application I thought worked fine. I think it works, yeah. I know some other communities, they just go off of a business plan. Instead of having all this scoring, if you submit a business plan, just like any other business plan, it doesn't make sense.
30:08 I think, you know, it really comes down to a lot of cases. I mean, if our number one scoring criteria is how much revenue is being brought in the community, I think that should be a pretty high one because that's going to allow others to, you know, more money coming in. Believe me, you get a big fight when you start talking about awarding extra points for the return on investment, the T.O.T. and that sort of thing because of the importance of the arts and the need for.
30:38 And I don't, I guess we could go through that whole process. Well, and I think then, but, so you used the scoring, but you did not use it as the only decision point. And I think that's, that's how, I guess we're still working through this. And that's why I wanted to know how the, how the other things that were added to that application was helpful to me. To me, what the scoring helps is for us to have a discussion. You know, it's sort of a structure for a discussion.
31:09 And it allows us to express where we're coming from, the pros and cons of each of those individual criteria. And if you look at the application itself, Matthew, it's kind of a structured business plan. It's just so we're able to compare apples to apples a little bit better, which was one of the goals of the task force that put it together.
31:34 Let's make it at least in a structure where the committee can prepare apples to apples with all the information you typically get out of a business plan. A year or so ago, Ken sat here before you and said, boy, we generate a lot of paper. And yes, we're trying to reduce that. And you'll notice here the difference. You know, we have some six-page ones, but there are some of these that are 40 or 50 pages. So it sure varies a lot.
32:02 Okay. Then one other question, and it's, I looked at a couple of them, and I noticed, and I thank you now for bringing us this ad, because, you know, when we started this, there was that whole discussion that MLT would be in charge of the cooperative marketing, and I know the first year of the awards, everybody was stripped out of essentially.
32:26 MLT did that. Did you guys again discuss that? Or did you leave marketing budget in some of these so some co-op type things could be done outside of every event over the summer? We never stripped the marketing dollars out. I personally went and we asked John to come to one of our meetings and I think that was before we were in the full committee to talk about it. And his...
32:53 Mr. Herdy, that is. His take was that it's impossible for him to know all the little intricacies for each little thing, so it was best to leave some marketing, because that was my suggestion. Let's take all this money and create this big pot, because certainly MLR knows how to market better than a lot of these. When I talked to John on this kind of item, his response was that he markets Mammoth. He does not market individual events.
33:22 But is he still planning to do those full-page ads that list all of the summer issues? Yes. So we have that as well? At that level, yes. But not at this kind of level. Right. So we have both. Yeah. And from an experienced events person, I wouldn't want MLT to try and market our events because they don't...
33:45 Know what our target audience is. It's a bigger bang for the buck for us to market to the specific audience when John is making sure that everybody that likes coming to Mammoth knows all these things. Correct. Okay. So there was some consideration that that was done. Although somehow in the future I'd like to see a better tie-in there. We have had events whose producers have put
34:11 So I would like to see...
34:35 Along the lines of marketing. Whether it's having each of these people meet with John and his staff and have him look at their plan or something, I would like to see that because we have lost some events. Is there a performance report required of these as well so that we get the feedback? How they did the past year. The other marketing item that was actually Gay Mueller brought it up was a banner, a board.
35:02 You know, something that specific events, you know, bang across Main Street, that's still a hanging thing. They see the sign over here at the school, bright red and all that it is, but something that can say, okay, this weekend, this is what's happening here.
35:20 Get it before people as they're driving down the street. Do you remember the reader board? Yes. Yes. Well, I was going to say, and unfortunately, when the E-Clan Positas put their monument right where a lot of people... Well, we did have one there, and we removed it, because I think someone thought it was tacky or something. I don't remember exactly what the word was. It wasn't going to be spit-tacky. Yeah, it was. It was going to be replaced, as I recall. It was going to be replaced. Yes.
35:50 And we used to have banners over Main Street. Yes. Well, we'll put a couple of questions. Actually, I thought we kept getting a little out if we put in the proper supportive polls. When we see the Main Street plan, we'll see that there is some discussion. We're going to hang it off the gondolas. I've got a couple of questions. One is, you know, ultimately, it's a very subjective process.
36:19 If you're using scoring, which is the structural part of it as either a baseline or a guideline or some platform upon which to have a discussion, how do you think the outcome is influenced by personal biases of the members? You know, I think that there's enough diversity in the members that it takes that bias out of it.
36:48 To a certain extent. You're going to get that with any group of people. Well, that's a good question. I can't answer that. We do debate healthy, though. We haggle. Yeah. I would say there's some diversity in the five folks sitting here, and you work through things, and you all bring something to the discussion. And I think it's the same on major youth. We have different backgrounds.
37:18 We have different interests, but it needs that. As we make up future boards, the importance of somehow maintaining a balance for those of us that worked on this in the first place, how we thought the majority of the funds would be spent is not the way Measure U is going. I think we have five good people on the Measure U committee. Between arts and recreation, I don't think that there's a fair balance.
37:51 I think that the arts side is loaded kind of heavy comparatively. However, I agree with, except for, you know, $1,000 here and $1,000 there, these pretty much match what my recommendations are going to be. Do you think the opposite of Michael's suggestion, which is that the council perhaps as a policy matter set a baseline for capital,
38:21 ...projects, or baseline number. Do you think that there ought to be, out of you, or even R&U, a baseline number for special events? And do you think there ought to be a baseline number for arts and culture that are not special events? Or distinguishable from separate, special events? Personally, I think we have to get to the broader conversation about what should...
38:45 Public money be funding when it comes to special events in arts and culture. Get to that philosophical conversation first and then define how that happens because frankly I think if we had as a council and as a community had that and had that understanding and agreement whether you liked it or not then the hours and hours and hours of community time invested in applications and
39:10 And promoting their events and our haggling over who gets what money would go away. But we haven't agreed as a community philosophically on what we should be funding with public money for special events, non-profits, arts and culture, and for-profit events. So if I ask the question differently, it would probably be the same answer, I imagine, which is should there be a cap on special events funding from you irrespective of whether we...
39:39 To me, not until we know why we're funding what we're funding. I believe there was a lot of discussion on the original major use steering committee, I think we called it, about should we split a third, third, third. And there was hours probably of discussion on how you would do between mobility, arts and culture, you know, recreation.
40:08 And they came down, and I think you can go back to the reports, and it says we shouldn't do that. And maybe in today's world that's a different thing that should be revisited, but I know at least at one time that was discussed at Creighton. And I have a different take on that, okay? I think one of the reasons that we talked about not setting that third, third, third was because the majority...
40:34 The vast majority felt the majority of this money should be going to capital projects. So to go 33, 33, 33 kind of takes capital projects and boots them out of the equation. I think that's the reason. I was hoping this year, only one guy here, that we would set that cap on events or on arts or on recreation or somehow come up with something. The problem came home when I looked at our list here. If you look,
41:03 You will see that the event coalition, what we're calling our arts events, has the Jazz Jubilee and the Wine Walk, but our recreation events has Mammoth Rocks, which is another music-based, so why isn't that in the arts? How do you... That's going to a lot of the concerns that I have. So we haven't answered the question. So if you're going to do a cap, which I believe we almost need to do.
41:30 Because if you don't, everybody looks at it and says here's a $700,000 fund. It's open-ended. Yeah, let's all jump into it. But if there's going to be a special event cap, then you have to take off the arts versus recreation designation. Well, we do that on, as you know, Bill, well, as everybody here knows, we do that on a smaller, much smaller scale with the youth sports activities, the soccer and literally swimming and that sort of thing.
41:58 We set a number, and then we say to those who might qualify, given the criteria that are required, here it is. You figure out, as a commission, how much of that fund you're going to give. This is, theoretically, you could spend $800,000. Or I recommend that we spend $800,000. I see where you're going, and it's a discussion that should happen.
42:28 If you look at page 7 of the agenda bill, essentially what's happening with the funding that's available now is 24% is going to special events, 12% to arts and culture, 2% to recreation programs, 2% to transit, and 55% to capital projects, but those capital projects cover art and culture and recreation and transit. So then you're starting to say, well,
42:54 Are you going to be splitting this way and this way? Right. Yeah. So if you took what's in capital projects and put them back into the special finance arts and culture wreck and transit, you might have slightly different numbers, but that's why I would not favor caps just because then you've got the opportunity to say, well, it's a capital project as opposed to it falls in one of the areas. Right. It just makes it tougher in terms of
43:22 We already look at these special events with their own application separately. Yet we have to keep in mind when we're doing this that it's the whole picture. It is the trolleys. It is the... Yes. So it makes it hard. And we had a little problem going through and figuring out where to plug the numbers... Yeah, where do you plug the numbers in first so that you don't disservice later? Right.
43:53 Essentially, the way that you generated the funds for capital projects was to punt on the municipal wayfinding piece, which totaled $334,000. I think we have some work to do in the future. I'm not disagreeing with your recommendation. I'm also, you know,
44:25 I'm really complimentary of the effort that has to go into this, not just by those who are asking for the money, but by those of you who have to look at these things. But I'm hoping in the future to have something to have it done just a little differently. One last question. Take me down the 2013 Fall Award summary down there.
44:49 Administration, Maintenance, Whitmore Track, and New Capital Investment Fund. So I see the 300. Tell me what the story is on this maintenance on Whitmore Track. It says will be resubmitted in 2014 Fall Award. Stu could probably speak best to that. So that's Whitmore Track was funded from Measure U in the tune of about $450,000 two years ago. So there's an obligation for Measure U to support the maintenance. It's shared with Measure R.
45:16 So this is kind of a one-third allocation of the total amount to maintain that facility. The 19,333 is used essentially from, say, February through to June. So we're only starting to use the money that we received last award now. So what we're saying here is that we don't need that money now. We're OK resubmitting that into next fall award.
45:38 So it's just a timing issue. It's just a timing issue, right. So instead of taking it now. It's not going to be considered. But it's not in this current application. However, in the last workshop for Measure R, where I definitely heard.
45:50 A commitment from Council that they were going to take over the maintenance for all recreation projects having been built by measures R&U. So therefore I will assume that in next year's budget that $19,000 will go away because it would be part of the course budget budget. You're going to stick around with the budget. Well, have you seen the balance of measures we're doing? Well, we're all wishful.
46:20 That's Bill's eternal vigilance. I'm going to keep pushing that. There's no question. And I agree, Rick, because you and I have had the conversation. I'd love to see a half a million from each of these funds made available for capital projects. But with the current things that are so important to get done, and with the lack of general fund dollars, I don't know how to get that done. I think we're lucky if we get a half a million between the two funds.
46:48 One of the things we talked about in our rec commission meeting yesterday, yes, meetings, was the need to do trolleys, and the only fund I could see it coming from would be the Measure U fund, because it's got the component in there, to do trolleys for Whitmore in the summertime. We've got a beautiful track, we've got a great pool there, underutilized because of lack of transportation for a lot of the people that would use them. So we've asked Stu to look at that, and we're going to try to produce an application next year.
47:17 So that we can get people to and from that area and bring its use up to the facts so that it's not as heavily subsidized as it was before. But the only available funds to do that with, we know that the measures that are Measure T that created the transportation fund in the first place, after the 10% reduction for cost savings and everything else, can barely keep up with what we need.
47:42 The problem is to do in town. So where else do we find the transportation? Do I believe it should come out of this fund? No. Are we going to ask for it? Absolutely, because that's what has to be done. We need that to be a successful park down there. That is a big piece of our parks. And I think that, especially for the teenagers and such that want to go and train and go to the pool and everything else, every hour or two-hour bus down to Whitmore is a terribly important thing. So there goes another, what, $20,000?
48:11 Yeah. Or so out of the out of the fund if we can make that happen successfully. The other thing is creative enough that they can probably give you some good ideas. Right. The other thing we talked about last night.
48:27 I'm segwaying. Sorry, guys. I know. I'm trying to keep you focused on the task at hand. Excuse me real quick. Because we're talking about transit down to Whitmore. Right. We've got an ice rink that's right across the street from the schools. Right. We can't get usage there. So I'd do some kind of analysis, some kind of study before you jump into transit down to Whitmore. Just a follow.
48:52 Okay, five minutes. Yeah, so anything else, any questions specifically to... I'm just curious, the 67,000 for the Repertory Theater, what was that? I didn't see it in here. I mean, the real breakdown, I don't think we had it. Did they put the budget in? That's the one for the... Let me look at the application real quick. It just seems like an awful lot of movement, and I'm just curious where it's...
49:25 I guess I'm looking at this.
49:52 This doesn't actually break down anyway, is it? Well, not in a bar, you're absolutely right. It's in there. Do you remember how you, it's in order in front, so that one will be back 10 or less. I'll put the coffee.
50:19 It's here. I'll stay. Juliana's dropping stuff here.
50:42 Yeah. Just give them the, yeah. It includes the business plan and all of the detail. I'm just curious. There you go. I think I have some more detail. That one is really a year-round.
51:04 The question was? The list of programs.
51:22 What are you looking for? Are you looking for the... Page 10 of the application is sort of the activities. If you go to page 10 of that application, Matthew, it has a list of all the... Page 10 of that application... This one? Yeah. It'll actually list all the productions. Yeah, so you're almost there. All right. Well, he's looking at that. Do you have anything else?
51:50 Deb, do you want to talk to us about or to support the recommendation? I don't think so specifically. I feel pretty comfortable with where we got to and found that it was more balanced this year than last. I just have one thing. Yeah. I would echo what we said earlier and thank you for all the hard work that you've done. Members of the public wish to speak on.
52:16 I think one of the things I represent the Mammoth Lakes Events Coalition as well as individual applicant through the Mammoth Food and Wine Experience and I think one of the things to keep in mind is
52:42 When we look at the money coming in from Measure U, it's the utility tax, we look at what comes in from TBID, we look at what comes in from TOT. If you look at the results over the last two summers, what the events that take place in Mammoth have brought to the town, it's bringing in the money that is then being turned around to support those events so that those events can grow and bring more people to Mammoth Lake. So I think it's important to keep that support there. Thank you. Ellen.
53:12 Thank you. Evan Russell. I just want to comment a little bit about some of the discussion that's taken place here. I was, and John is gone, but we were on the original Measure U campaign committee, and we helped draft some of the language that is in Measure U. And certainly, you know, our input, and I'm not hiding anything here, is that we had Bill Taylor build a
53:42 Feasibility Study Draft Business Plan for us in 2010. Joe sat in with that group for about a year working on stuff. We were pretty sure we knew where we could get most of the capital outlay money through the Measure C bond, but we couldn't figure out how to fund the facility. And when Bill and I researched a number of places, and we looked at about 30 different resorts, and, you know, and Rick, you sat in on one of the meetings with the Levitt Pavilion people.
54:12 That they came up and pitched us on doing something here. And we went back through some of their stuff and their operating budgets somewhere between 30 and 40 percent comes from government sources. Mostly local but state and federal grants and applications are part of that. So we tried to model this thing and scope it or craft it into Measure U.
54:39 So that Measure U was broad enough, if we got a capital facility, that we were able to maintain it and grow it in the future. And that was one of the emphasis, I think, on our bringing arts and culture into Measure U originally. And if you remember those on the council, we were kind of the last ones in the door. We brought up the arts and culture stuff. Measure U passed by about 12 votes, give or take, two-thirds.
55:10 Passage. So if about five people would have voted the other way, Measure U would not have passed. And after spending probably 15 or 20 nights on the telephones talking to voters and trying to convince them, I can tell you if the arts and culture component hadn't have been there, you never would have had Measure U as part of this. And you guys talked a little bit about what happens when the next council comes in. And Matt, I know you were running for
55:39 Office while Measure U was being campaigned for. You know, through that whole process, we never once told people that this was for economic stimulus. It was never to create TOT. It was something that was going to replace what we did. You know, the first utility users tax bill, Shady Rest Park and Mammoth Creek Parks.
56:01 We knew going down the line that we also had to find ways to operate those things into the future. And that's why we asked for a broad base of the measure used stuff. So with the proposal that we're bringing forward now for schematic designs for the Sprung Structure Performing Arts Center, actually it's an event center as well as performing arts if we do this thing right.
56:32 That was something we thought the college would build. And the college, you know, kept sitting on the fence and a lot of stuff changed at the state with how they could spend or where their emphasis was to be on spending education money. And if any of you read the grand jury report, you have a pretty good understanding as to why they would not spend Measure C money on the big picture facility, which we thought was going to be about 15 or 20 million.
57:02 That said, we went back to them and said if we scaled this down and there's an educational component and we go back to look at what we originally asked to do is to make this a community use facility also and you didn't have to be responsible for the operations of it, would you consider it? And that's where we are today is the business manager has said we'll consider something in the $3 to $4 million area.
57:31 There will be an educational component to it that we'll want set aside. And they did this with the library. So $3.5 million of the Measure C money went into the library. The library wouldn't have been built if that Measure C money hadn't have gone into it. The college has some space set aside there. They get accreditation because the library is in place. So it works. They have an operating agreement between
58:01 The College and the Mono County Office of Education. So what we're trying to do with the seed money to do the schematic design is that will give us enough background to take the estimates we've done on this facility and be able to take those to an architect and refine both a capital budget and an operating budget, which will lead into a business plan.
58:29 That's got a governance plan in it. It's got a marketing plan. And it has to have a content plan. And that's one of the reasons that we took Shira and the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater under our wing at the foundation is because we knew we couldn't build a facility unless there was going to be year-round content that went with it. And it doesn't just have to come from the Repertory Theater. You know, the Chamber Music Unbound people are world-class.
58:59 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.
59:29 To go to construction design. But before we get to that point, we're going to have to create an agreement between the college and the town and probably the Mammoth Lakes Foundation because we've got assets and the systems in place to do that. But it could be somebody else that we'll all have to be on the same page with or we'll never get the money coming out of the college program. But there's some excellent models.
59:57 The program Rich did with the college for the county. They've sent me that information. We're going to follow that kind of format. And then there's a really good governance model between City of San Luis Obispo, Cal Poly San Luis, and the Center for Performing Arts there, which is a 50C3 nonprofit. And I think all this goes to, I think what I've heard, Rick, I've heard you say,
1:00:26 You know, we need to leverage this money. We need to bring it in, focus on some capital projects, but don't forget, once you get the capital project built, if you haven't done a good operating plan, we don't want, and I use the ice rink as my example because we had a bunch of passionate people come to the town council when Tracy Fuller was the town manager, and we all thought,
1:00:56 Hey, we're going to do this, and I was one of those people. You know, if we get it, it's going to be an enhancement for the community, and people will just come and use it. It doesn't happen that way. I think Matt said if we don't have a good business plan and we know how it's going to operate and we know what we're going to do, it just won't happen. So that's my two cents. I think we have a good opportunity to take this project, and if this project can work, then there's others coming up that I think if they all follow,
1:01:26 A business plan model, and it's not a great emotional decision. I think we as a community can add a lot more to enhance it. And when we do things for the people that live here, and I think Carl Roboto in one of his opening comments, one of those first sessions, he said if the locals like it, the visitors will like it. And that tends to follow.
1:01:52 We're going to generate more business for the community just by virtue of having things that cause more people to come here. And when Bill Tabler and I were looking at other resorts, and I guess I'd use the term mature resorts that have been around for a while where they have multiple populations coming at the same time to do different things, I think we're headed in that direction.
1:02:18 But, you know, the day will come, it's not just a Sam's Woodside or a Performing Arts Center. There will be four or five pods of things going on that will appeal to different ages, different demographics, different kinds of people. And that's what we saw when we looked at some of the older resorts that we compared to. And I just hope you take all that into consideration and good luck. I think, you know, the group's done a good job analyzing this stuff and I think you guys have been very supportive of it.
1:02:46 Thank you. Sorry it's over 6. Thank you, Evan. All right. We'll adjourn to the regular meeting to be held at 6.10. Oh, thank you. Welcome.
1:03:50 There's a lot of filler in it, too. I don't have any chapstick for you, John.
1:09:32 Thank you, sir. To a session. Every other meeting I'm borrowing a pen from her. That's why she has plenty. Good evening and welcome to the Town of Mammoth Lakes regular meeting for Wednesday, February 5, 2014. Jamie, roll call please. Here. Here. Here, if you could please rise and join Mayor Pro Tem Bacon in the Pledge of Allegiance. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the Republic for
1:11:44 All right, welcome. This is the public comments portion of our meeting. This is the time for any member of the public who wishes to address the council on any matter that does not otherwise appear on the agenda tonight to do so. Anybody want to come forward? If so, state your name. Mr. Mayor, Town Council, Andrew Castor with the Mailman Track Club. And two and a half weeks ago we went to the...
1:12:22 Chevron Houston Marathon and it was the U.S. Championships for the half marathon and we had great success and tonight I wanted to introduce three of the athletes that ran very, very well in those championships. To my right, Lauren Kleppen, she was a surprise second place finisher at the U.S. Championships. She generated a lot of buzz in the running community. Been answering, I've been answering and she's been answering a lot of
1:12:51 A lot of reporters, interviews, and questions, so we got a lot of great press just off of that one performance. To her right is Gabe Proctor, just 23 years old. He placed 10th at the championships and ran a wonderfully fast time. He's looking to run, actually both Lauren and Gabe are looking to run in the A6 LA Marathon on March 9th, and we're very excited about their prospects there. And to Gabe's right is Josfat Boyt, who's a returning Mammoth Track Club athlete.
1:13:20 He basically ran Meb, ran him to about 10 mile mark before Meb started to pull away just a little bit, but JB let him know his presence, and JB actually set a really fast personal best in the half marathon championship. So the dry weather we had for the last few months really paid dividends for us because we were able to train at 7,000 feet on the trails and at the track and down there at the airport. So it worked out really well for us, both Lauren and JB, or Josaphat.
1:13:49 We'll be selected for the World Half Marathon Championships to represent the United States and Copenhagen, Denmark at the end of March. So we have 20% of the U.S. team going to those World Championships. So these three athletes made their mark in the U.S. Our first race right off the bat, 2014, we really nailed it. And we're looking to do some more damage in the future. So these are my athletes.
1:14:18 Great. Congratulations. Meb, if you will, can you tell us how, or Meb, Andrew, can you tell us how Meb did? Meb won the race. He did win. Yeah, he did. He looked superb. He's racing the Boston Marathon. He's feeling good. Yeah. Good. Yeah, he's doing well. We had a great conversation after the race, and he was encouraging to all the newcomers up here. So did I understand they're going to do the LA Marathon and these World Championships in the same month?
1:14:48 Correct. Wow. Just Lauren is. Yeah, just Lauren. JB's going to look at possibly running the Boston Marathon. We're looking at one or two other marathons, but we haven't decided yet. Wow. Great. A lot of good buzz out there. Yeah, it was really good. Yeah, for sure. A lot of good buzz about you as well, Andrew, and Dina, of course, has been in the buzz for a decade or more, but we're going to be able to say one day that we knew him when.
1:15:18 Congratulations. Well done. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. That's pretty good. Hello, Juliana Olenka with the Mammoth Lakes Foundation. I'm actually here on behalf of Shira Dubrovna, the Artistic Director of Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theater, to let you all know that the next production at the Edison Theater, The 39 Steps, opens a week from tomorrow, February 13th, runs for three weekends, and Shira would be here, but she's in rehearsal right now. So I wanted to share that information. We look forward to all of you coming to see the show.
1:15:52 It's a takeoff of an Alfred Hitchcock movie, The 39 Steps, and it is full of humor and lots of references to Hitchcock movies, and come to the show. You'll have a great time. Thank you very much. Thank you, Juliana. Okay, party's still open. Public comment. Lee. Good evening. My name is Lee Gosch. I'm here this evening to let people know that on Friday, if you're around, around 4 o'clock to watch TV and watch Katie Couric.
1:16:28 Christina Bloom is going to be on it. Christina ran for Miss California, and she was nominated for Miss Congeniality. Christina was born in Bishop, California, and she's legally blind. At one time, she had a guide dog from San Rafael, and right now, she's in New York, and Katie Couric is going to interview her. And I think it's on from 3 to 4 on the Southern Lane Station up here. But it would be interesting to watch it, because Christina's only 22 years old.
1:16:56 And the doors open for her for many opportunities. She's a very fine lady. I think a lot of people up here know who Christina is. I would love to get her to come to talk to you guys, but she works at the Chamber of Commerce in Bishop on Wednesday, so it would be really hard for her to get here. Rick, at any time if she came, because she gets off at quarter after five, and so she'd be too late to speak later if I make arrangements with you? Well, we don't, well, sure. I'll be happy to accommodate her, certainly.
1:17:25 Thank you. So remember Friday, Katie Couric. Thanks. Lee, real quick, was she also a horsewoman in Bishop at all or not? I don't know. You don't know? Okay. Oh, she was Miss Bishop too in 2012. I remember that. Thank you. Thanks. All right. Thank you. The podium is still open. Public comment. Any member of the public who wishes to speak?
1:17:48 If not, and seeing none, we'll move to Councilmember Reports and additions to the agenda. John, can we start with you? Yes, I have none, Mr. Mayor. I don't have anything either, Mr. Mayor. Michael. None as well. Joe. Just one. I'm looking forward next meeting to our discussion about Mammoth Lakes Recreation, and towards that end, I attended the Recreation Commission meeting yesterday, and I'm to remind Bill that he's going to speak to something in a few minutes here.
1:18:18 Really excited to be able to share that whole process with you at the next meeting. Thank you. A couple of things. I attended the monthly Mammoth Lakes Housing Board of Directors meeting along with the town manager on Monday of this week. And I just wanted to indicate to the council that there will be a recommendation of the housing board to the planning
1:18:47 Commission when it considers a tentative track map amendment that's to be presented by the current owner of the TALUS project to handle and manage its workforce housing mitigation requirement. And I don't know that that's something that ever comes up to the council unless the map is not approved or somebody appeals it or something.
1:19:15 Essentially, what we're trying to do there is to assist the new owner of a project that, as we know, has historically failed, at least as compared to its initial concept, to assist that person in getting that project sold and
1:19:39 Abiding by the workforce housing mitigation requirement that exists in the current map. So that's going to be coming forward to the Planning Commission. Also echo what Mayor Pro Tem Bacon has said. We look forward to the presentation on MLR. Seven months now going on eight months of meetings. And we intend to spend the time to...
1:20:03 Let the public know what it is that we've been doing and to explain a very comprehensive recommendation coming forward for MLR and for allocation of measures R and U funds. Last but not least for the benefit of the public, we have an election coming up on June 3rd. Three members of the town council for a full term of four years. Nomination period opens on Monday, February 10, and closes on Friday, March 7.
1:20:33 If none of the three incumbents, and there are three, file papers for re-election, then that period on March 7th, and correct me if I'm wrong, Jamie, is extended to March 12th for members of the public who wish to pull papers. So election season is here. It's about to begin for the town of Mammoth Lakes. That's all I have. Okay. Takes us to agenda item.
1:21:03 Nope. It takes us to reports from commissions and or departments. Sandra. Thank you. Quickly, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development Department. I just wanted to report that the zoning code update public hearing is next Wednesday, February 12th at 2 o'clock for the planning commission. So that will be the first public hearing for this item. And then the following Wednesday, February 19th at 5 o'clock, the town council is having a joint meeting with the planning and economic department.
1:21:33 Economic Development Commission to discuss the Main Street Plan and the final Main Street Plan will also be on the Council's agenda that night as well. Thank you. Thank you. Stu? Orville? Orville. He can explain what I tell you. Joe asked me to speak to this last night because we just had a meeting on Measure U and how those monies would best be spent. Last night's Recreation Commission meeting,
1:22:06 While we were talking about the Measure R Award and talking about the timeline for the Spring Award, it was decided by the commission to do away with the Spring Award for next year and instead create a path so that emergency situations for underfunded projects and projects that timely could not fit in to bring them forward outside of a regular application process. So this should free up a lot of staff time.
1:22:34 And hopefully create a smoother and create less of an end run for those who want to apply outside of the main bunch. So I think that will be big and exciting and I want to bring that forward to you. But Bill, you said next year. You really mean this spring. This year, yeah. This year. The spring cycle of next year. I'm in December still. Wait for me to catch up. The spring cycle will have started actually in March.
1:23:03 With our meetings. So the staff time and stuff that would have gone into that will now instead go into creating plans so that if something we award comes in woefully short and we need to add to it, or if, you know, Bon Jovi decides he wants to come to Mammoth and we need to spring money up real quick, we'll have a process to do that. But that's pretty much what we decided. I thought that was pretty big. Thank you. Thank you, Bill. Stu, can you explain that?
1:23:34 No. If you wish. Actually, what they've done is they're scheduling a joint workshop with the Measure U Committee as well. So I believe that is March 4th at 1 o'clock. We're trying to get both those committees together to look at how that kind of opportunity process could be laid out, structured, and presented to Council. We'll be back.
1:23:58 On other items, Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager, have three items. First one's regarding the Mammoth Ice Rink. Coming into February, sun's higher in the sky, the ice is not as good as what it would like it to be, so we open later in the day just to keep the integrity of ice and the quality of the experience for our guests at a prime. So what we've done is we've changed our hours at the Mammoth Ice Rink.
1:24:26 And this was beginning Monday, February 3rd. We're going to open from 4 to 6 p.m. And this is seven days a week. We'll open from 4 to 6 p.m. And folks can skate for the midweek rate of only 5.25 at that time. And then again from 6.30 to 9 p.m. Obviously the evening sessions and the later sessions are just better for the ice and the experience. So that's the change there. And then that is through February 23rd. That's still our scheduled closing date for the ring. So until we can...
1:24:54 Look at some type of shade structure or keeping the sun off the ice. That's what we have. And then just pertaining to that, we hosted the inaugural Winter Youth Hockey Classic on Saturday evening and we had over 40 local youth players come along, which is hugely popular, really well received. So we've made the decision to still schedule on Monday and Wednesday nights from 5.15 to 7 o'clock and Saturdays from 9 to 11 a.m.
1:25:22 The use of the rink for those hockey players. So we did kind of move them around and we got a lot of calls and so we've moved it back. So there we go. So our youth can still come out and enjoy the experience at the same time that they've been doing all season. All these changes are on the homepage of the website if you want to jump on and have a look and also on mammothiserink.com. Two additional items. Our indoor colored soccer program is full. We have eight teams.
1:25:49 They're going to start their league play this Sunday evening at the high school. So we have from 6 to 9 p.m., so we have games scheduled every hour. We have teams up from Bishop and around the area competing against each other, so it's a fun event if you want to come along and watch. And then we're also kicking off our first and second grade basketball program, which is actually free for our community members. So it's a great program. It's kind of an instructional basketball program that our staff put on. You can sign up online, and once again, that's free. So there we go.
1:26:19 Any questions from? Questions? Thank you, Stu. Thank you. Welcome, Stu. Here. Mayor, Councilman, just an update on the RTIP, Jerry from LaFrancoise and I did go down to the CTC meeting yesterday, presented the RTIP to the CTC board commission, and essentially they didn't have any major questions about our RTIP. That includes our part of the Alanchuk-Artego MOU project.
1:26:52 It includes a couple of sidewalk projects on Main Street, Minaret, and the county had a rehab section and then a match for a federal grant that they've got. So, but there is ITIP money that's part of the Allegiant Cartago project. It sounds like there is going to be a political struggle within the Caltrans recommendations, which include that funding for that project. And so there may be in the next month some
1:27:23 Letter writing campaign to kind of help position the, maintain that funding, that ITIP money. As you may recall, and you probably don't recall, we had a funding opportunity a number of years ago, maybe eight years ago, for that same project. The ITIP money was recommended, and then it ended up being shifted down to San Diego. So San Diego's looking to increase their funding, and it's about the same amount that the
1:27:49 That we're looking for for the ITEM money, about $46 million. So it was a good meeting. Like I said, no questions. Sometimes they do have questions for us, but they were happy with ours. We weren't spending all of our money, and we were supporting the Caltrans network. Peter, can you share the dollar amounts of some of the programs that you're talking about for Mammoth Lakes? For Mammoth Lakes, we have a $2.1 million sidewalk section and street light project from
1:28:17 Mountain Boulevard to Minaret Road. And then the same type of project, sidewalk, streetlights, for Minaret Road up to 8050. Those are our two primary projects for the new 2014 STIB. And then we're also contributing to the MLU project down south. Currently, in our current budget, we have the Canyon Boulevard rehab project, which we'll start this summer.
1:28:46 That's a $3.6 million project. And then we've got the, what do we call the Mammoth Park, Mammoth Creek Park Minaret Connector Path, which is, we're doing the design right now environmental. So it's a good deal. That's about a $2 million project too. So this is, yeah, good funding. It's flexible that we can do with projects that are less competitive and we don't necessarily have the performance numbers.
1:29:18 That we may need for some of the other competitive grants. So the projects that the council decides is of high importance and the state doesn't necessarily question the specific projects. They're supposed to either approve entire list of projects and not cherry pick, so to speak, of projects here and there. In the past, essentially the town of Mammoth Lakes did have the first pedestrian project in the Stip, which was Lake Mary Dyke Path.
1:29:48 And that did create some controversy at the state level. And we had to defend our tip aggressively. But in the end, that was interesting. In the end, the board overrode their staff's recommendation and approved it. So that was great. Can you be a little more specific on the Alantia-Cartago section? What phase is that project in? So this, they're currently doing,
1:30:17 Design work, right away acquisition. Essentially it's a $120 million project. Mono County shares is 10% of that for the construction phase, which is scheduled to start in 2017, is almost $10 million. So the project should be completed in probably 2018, early 19. Can you tell us, you may or may not be able to, but can you tell us,
1:30:49 What benefit in the past, in the past, I don't know how many years it's been, five or ten years, the benefit was that a number of municipalities and counties went in together to fund these projects and they got money from the state of California and federal funds as well because they liked those MOU projects. Is that still as beneficial today as it was five or ten years ago?
1:31:19 Yeah, so essentially the MOU projects created a collaboration between the counties and other transportation agencies so that we could tap into the IATIP money, and that's the interregional transportation pot of money. So in 99, the Mono County actually had the first MOU project.
1:31:42 And so that kind of set the standard and the template for use throughout the state. And there's many counties now have a summer MOUs between their agencies. And basically the home county, whichever that county is, like in this case it's Inyo County, they pay 40% of the cost of the project. And then the other counties that are participating pay 10. And so we're paying 10. And then there's the ITIP money pays 40% of the project. So without the ITIP money,
1:32:11 None of the counties would be able to complete a project of that mega tube. Great. Thank you. Peter, can I also ask you, is the Waterford connector going to be completed or started and perhaps completed this summer as well? Yeah, that would be completed this summer as well. Those are the bridges out in the meadow over Mammoth Creek, over Mammoth Creek. Correct. So that corridor will now have an access point year-round. And those will be a 14-foot wide.
1:32:40 Section, so emergency vehicle and emergency situation that could be used for access. Thank you. Okay. Other commission reports or department reports? If not, we'll move to agenda item number two, which is introduction of new assistant planner, Ruth Traxler. Thank you. It's my pleasure to introduce you to Ruth Traxler, our new assistant planner.
1:33:11 She moved here from Prescott, Arizona, where she worked for the city as a community planner for about three and a half years. She's been involved in current planning issues, updates to zoning codes, as well as airport and economic development planning. She has a bachelor's degree from Western Washington University in demography and Spanish and a master's degree in planning from Northern Arizona University. So, welcome, Ruth. Welcome. Thank you. Welcome.
1:33:52 All right. Great. Thank you. And that takes us to the consent agenda items 3 through 6. Any council member wish to pull any agenda item? Nope. Mr. Mayor, make a motion to council approve consent agenda items 3, 4, 5, and 6. A second. Okay. If there's a motion and a second, roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
1:34:20 Yes, motion passes 5-0. It takes us to number 7, which is a public hearing to consider potential community development block grant applications. I'll open the public hearing and hear from staff first. Jen. Thank you, Mayor, Councilmembers. Jen Doherty, Associate Planner. The purpose of this public hearing is to provide an opportunity for council input and public input on our applications for this year's CDBG.
1:34:50 Notice of Funding Availability. Every year, the State Department of Housing and Community Development issues this NOFA opportunity, and to be eligible for current funding, projects must meet a national objective. That must be either benefiting low or moderate income persons or preventing or eliminating slums or blight. Eligible projects include both housing and economic development programs and activities.
1:35:19 That includes items such as homeowners, first-time homebuyer assistance, rehab, acquisition of land for housing, public improvement for improvements for lower income neighborhoods or affordable housing projects, and economic development studies and programs. The town can apply for up to three applications. The maximum reward is up to $2 million, not including economic over-the-counter activities.
1:35:46 Certain limits are applied for each type of activity for the threshold that we can apply for. For instance, planning and technical assistance, like for an economic development plan, is limited to $100,000. The applications under the CDBG grant are due on April 11th. The awards will be announced in July or August. We will be coming back to the council once we prepare these applications, so you will be looking at this again.
1:36:13 On the economic development side, we are planning on applying for an economic development plan. That would provide us with the framework we would need to apply for other grants, such as for business assistance and business expansion type loans. We have here today Jennifer Halfordy, Executive Director of Mammoth Lakes Housing, to speak on behalf of the housing projects that we're looking to apply for.
1:36:38 As well as representatives from both IMACA and Head Start who would like to speak to potential projects as well. Quick question, are the grants, outright grants or loans? They are grants. And it's a competitive process? It is competitive. We are ranked on the housing side and there's a ranking system that the state has established that we'll be subject to. And do the grants require matching funds?
1:37:08 The planning and technical assistance grants do. They require a 5% match, so if we were awarded the $100,000, it would be a max of $5,000. But none of the other ones do? None of the other ones, yeah. Thank you. Thanks. Jennifer. Good evening, Council.
1:37:31 Jennifer Halperny, Mammoth Lakes Housing. Mammoth Lakes Housing's Board met, as Rick mentioned earlier, on Monday, and we discussed the various opportunities within this grant for housing. And back in October, Mammoth Lakes Housing Board did a strategic planning session where we discussed about what some of our goals were for the coming two years. And one of them was to
1:37:59 And so we're looking at...
1:38:26 Doing a housing combo application where we do home buyer assistance and rehab for either owners or investors, owner-investors. The combo program is appealing because you can use the money for either or. Since the rehab program would be new in the community, we're not exactly sure how popular it would be, and so that way we could definitely use the funding with home buyer's assistance if need be.
1:38:55 Since that's proven to be very popular, you may be aware the town was just awarded a home fund, home funds of $700,000 for home buyer assistance, but those have been, like I said, very popular with the interest rates being low and it seems like the housing market stabilizing has helped as well. So those are our intentions. Questions? Thank you. Real quick, the
1:39:25 And I asked Peter the same question. We are looked favorably on by the state of California in their grant funding, typically because of the program that we have. Is this another situation where our likelihood of getting this grant would be good, or do you know?
1:39:47 Well, we are ranked and rated, as Jen said, against all the other applicants. So that's an unknown as to who would apply and how they would rank and rate. In our office, we did a preliminary run-through of the figures based on the NOFA.
1:40:05 And it looks favorable, but again, you don't know until you're weighted against the other applicants. This is the third year that the Community Development Block Grant has offered this form of NOFA. It's called the SuperNOFA, where everybody applies at once under one NOFA. And you must have spent, each jurisdiction in order to be eligible has to have spent 50% of all their previous awards.
1:40:31 Considering we're in the third year, there's a high probability there's a lot of jurisdictions that haven't spent their 50% and therefore they're not eligible. So I'm thinking there's going to be less people eligible this year than next year. So I'm hopeful. Okay. Thank you. Good evening.
1:40:56 Mayor and Councilmembers, my name is Larry Emerson. I work for AMACA. AMACA owns and operates the Glass Mountain Apartments located at 25 Mountain Boulevard. It's a 26-unit affordable housing complex for very low and extremely low income residents. And we've owned and operated this apartment complex since the late 1990s. We purchased it with a home loan through the
1:41:24 Through the town of Mammoth Lakes. And as some of you may know, it's the old International Inn that was converted into low-income apartments. And because it's an older building, the infrastructure is decaying. And so we would respectfully request, through the block grant program this year, $400,000 to do rehab for that apartment complex. We're looking at focusing on some major infrastructure issues, electrical work.
1:41:54 Plumbing work. The parking lot needs to be repaired and regraded so that it doesn't drain towards the apartments. And then if we have money, we'd also like to convert one of the units to accessibility to provide for handicapped. So that would be part of the grant application or one of the projects that we're going to be going after? It would be if...
1:42:17 If the money goes far enough. I've done a preliminary budget, and we need to refine the numbers, but we're hoping to apply for all of those things. Jennifer, you can help me on this. It was only Monday that we had that meeting, and it seems like an eternity. This is really going to be a joint application, isn't it, of AMACA as well as the town is going to share in...
1:42:41 The, or jointly present an application and share in the funds by a cooperative arrangement among the two of you, between the two of you. Right, I mean, ultimately the town is the applicant, and then the way this grant, we did this exact application actually last year for the town, and the way it was structured last year is that Mammoth Lakes Housing,
1:43:08 was designed to be a subrecipient of their portion that, you know, they were going to administer. And then IMACA was a subrecipient under the portion they were administering.
1:43:20 From the town. And then the town receives the PTA portion and administer that themselves. Okay. Good. Thank you. So it's not a separate application. It's a blended application. It is. I mean, there's multiple, as you can see, there's multiple activities you can apply for. Each one has their own sub-application within the major. That's why they call it a supernova because you have all these things coming in under one notice of funding availability.
1:43:47 What is the total amount of the grant? The maximum amount you're eligible for is 2 million. And so, but under the housing portion, the maximum amount is 1 million under housing activities. And so, I'm Maka's activity falls under housing and Mammoth Lakes housing activity that we're proposing falls under housing as well. So we would collectively be capped at 1 million.
1:44:15 And so since it is a grant, not a loan, I mean, is there any loopholes or fine detail or anything in there that the town ultimately, as you just said, the town is the applicant, the town would be liable for any of this or not? Right. Because it's not a loan?
1:44:32 The only time the town would be liable to repay the funds is if they were misappropriated because there are all those national objectives. And so if funds were used and they didn't meet the national objective, then they could be recalled. But ultimately the town is responsible to make sure that the programs are, their sub-recipients are acting in accordance with the agreements. Okay, thanks. It's a similar...
1:45:01 Relationship that we've had historically, Mammoth Lakes Housing, and I believe Amaka has to put the town on these kinds of grounds. Thanks. So I'm also with Amaka, Cindy Dorisco, Director of Child Development and Family Services. So
1:45:32 Our Head Start Preschool, which is a combination of state preschool and Head Start, the center is currently located on the elementary school property, and we may be having to relocate to the old library building. And there's already Infant Toddler Center there, First Steps, I believe it's called. And so if we moved over to the new location,
1:46:01 There would be rehabilitation requirements so that we can have the center be up to licensing requirements. So a kitchen would need to be installed and bathrooms for the children. So that would be our part. And this would also be part of that blended application? That would come out, I think, of public facility sections of the various areas within the CDBG grant program. Do you have an estimate of what that cost is going to be?
1:46:33 I want to say 200,000 probably. All right, good. Questions? All right. If none, this is the time for members of the public who wish to provide comment either in favor of the proposal, which is for the town to proceed with the application or against that proposal or to provide neutral comment.
1:47:08 I have a question. I know there's a list of where the grants can go. What is the list? I know it's not very long because it's not just for affordable housing. Jen, can you answer that? There's quite a long list that's described in the NOFA, but all projects to be eligible under this grant have to meet a national objective, which would be benefiting low or moderate income persons or eliminating slums or blight. So really the overall objective is for
1:47:42 Thank you. Lee, does that answer your question? I've talked to quite a few people about this, and a lot of us feel that we have enough affordable housing in this town right now at this time. Who knows what the future has in hold? The affordable housing just got $700,000 as Ino County and Mono County.
1:48:06 We would like to see some of the money go towards infrastructure. Our town needs to be cleaned up. It's not the cleanest town in the world. If you want to have our guests come to visit and be happy to come here, you know, it has to be cleaned up a bit and our drains need to be fixed. I mean, there's a lot of stuff. When it comes to affordable housing, Sierra Valley sites, I mean, I know, Rick, you don't like me talking about this, but it needs help. You know, and I believe in Chief Watson when he talks about the broken window theory.
1:48:36 You know, I'd like people to lead by an example. And if you go buy one affordable housing right now, there's a shopping cart in the storm drains. I mean, things need to change with affordable housing. You can't just keep getting money and handing it out because people are going to take it. You know, they need to be – they have to – we all have to work for things. Things aren't given to you. And I don't think affordable housing needs to have any more money at this time. They need to –
1:49:03 Start thinking about the town a little more. I mean, our whole town cannot be affordable housing someday. And I've said before, I will fight this until I see it distributed through the whole town. And it's all basically in two different areas and that's it. And it's affecting the people that have lived there since the county days. So I would really like to see more of the money go towards infrastructure in this town so that we can go forward. Lee, thank you. Other members of the public who wish to speak on this item?
1:49:34 If not, I'll close the public hearing and call for council deliberation. Comments from any member of the council before someone makes a motion, or is there a motion? I just got a couple comments. I guess I'm looking for some clarification on the understanding of the town ultimately being responsible, even though it's a grant, not a loan. Maybe you can help me again.
1:50:03 Because, because. Yeah, Michael, yeah, I think I know what you're after there. The CBG grants, like other federal grants or state grants, if you use it inappropriately, they can ask for the money back. I don't think we've ever been in that boat, frankly. The application goes in. It's a pure grant coming back to the town. The process generally comes back in. It's a grant to the recipients.
1:50:29 For either the remodel work, you can't put it into a loan program, so it becomes a revolving loan program as well. In that case, we're not liable for those loans. The property runs on or they're secured with property. If there's a foreclosure or something, it ends up being a grant versus a loan because usually you're not in a position to get your money back. But there's no really, I'd say there's no risk to the town of having to pay back $600,000 in housing money to the state.
1:50:58 If you did that, frankly, you'd probably ask myself or other folks to leave the town as well because we misappropriated grant money. So there's a pretty solid protection in that. That's kind of a go-to-jail, don't-collect-200 type issue. So I don't think the town is at risk from the grant standpoint. It's a very competitive process. You come up with good projects. There's a lot of oversight by the state, the CDBG.
1:51:22 Program itself looks at those things. You have different records and things you've got to keep and report to. So I think there's a pretty solid accounting program and those types of issues. And as a pure grant, again, the town's not really on that hook, only if you were to do a misappropriation type of an issue. And then the program, the way it works into it, even if it goes into a loan pool type program, there's usually nothing from the town that comes back and backs up or guarantees any of those loans out there.
1:51:50 I think that's the concern if I'm hearing you correctly. Thank you. Other comments? I have some. Go ahead. I think that we've been down this road before. And, you know, we had grant money, loan monies, whatever, before that were allocated for housing in the past. And I believe there's still $288,000 that was sat in MLH.
1:52:20 There's $396,000 that sat in MLH. And because this entity didn't have the money to pay for these funds or loans or whatever you want to call them, the town ended up picking up the tab. And we're still paying for it. And part of the reasons the town can't do a lot of other things, including, I don't know, maybe fixing some of our other departments that need help, we have to pick up this bill.
1:52:49 I think a friend of mine put it pretty well. He says, in effect, this entity is bankrupt. And we're looking at going and creating more affordable housing at a time when we've already spent the last decade or whatever it is building this affordable housing that, you know, I know we've sold ourselves on the idea that we need it because there's a line out the door for it. Well, there's going to be a line out the door forever as long as there's a handout of some sort.
1:53:18 I think we need to start getting ourselves off the housing crack, quite honestly. It's, you know, and start letting the economy take its toll and move forward in that fashion, quit relying on government. We can't afford it. And I don't, you know, there's some good things, I think, in this grant. I mean, if I knew it was really going to economic development, if it was going to get rid of the blight in our community, those are things we desperately need in this town. We definitely do need those things.
1:53:48 But for me, if it's associated with creating more housing, Lee, I appreciate your comments. That's true. We have too much. If we let this entity go, it will continually build affordable housing. We'll end up being a town of affordable housing. I just don't want to see that anymore. I think some comments were made earlier about how affordable housing is working with some of the developers and assisting them in their housing programs.
1:54:18 Quite honestly, housing is putting a burden on the construction community. There are houses, when the developer goes out and builds a house right now, about $1,000 of that, some of the fees have to go to pay for housing right off the bat. The TALUS project, I believe the developer there is going to, they're going to try to rehab an existing home over there. And it's going to cost an exorbitant amount of money. If you want to assist them, get out of the way.
1:54:46 Quite honestly. Let's stop requiring all of this housing for everybody. I think we have enough housing and let's let some of the private folks be successful. Again, I like the positive components of this. I think if we were able to split it apart and look at how we could help out our planning department and finance there, or if we could work with the economic development, I'd be all for this. I think it's a wonderful grant. But I think...
1:55:15 If we could take a piece of this and get the housing component of it and pay our old bills, I'd be in favor of it. But I imagine that there won't be an application for that. The town's on the hook for it. We got stuck with that bill. And I say let them pay that back before we take on any more grants. Yes. I'm going to disagree with you, Matthew, because, yes, there were some other issues with loans. This is a grant.
1:55:44 What I heard staff saying to us is they want to apply to get an economic development strategy, which we know we need, that they want to do homeowner assistance programs so that our families can get into homes in existing units and that it's based on rehab. I did not hear anything about building new units in this grant application. So that's why I'm going to support it. Whether this agenda item says anything about building new units or not, I wanted to address that.
1:56:17 Mammoth Lakes is a resort community in the High Sierra and we are isolated to a large degree. Many resorts throughout the United States, not resorts, are isolated as well. The lesson learned, and you can point your finger at Aspen and Vail, the lesson learned by those two areas and some others, not all, but some others,
1:56:46 They were down
1:57:17 Down Canyon. Mammoth Lakes was facing a similar situation, I don't know how many years ago it was, let's say 10 years ago, where we didn't have enough housing and we identified the need for employee housing. Otherwise we were going to have our employees, some living in town of course, but many of them living in outlying communities and as far away as Bishop. We identified the problem, realized it would be a problem,
1:57:47 Part of that problem is not only that you wouldn't be providing housing for the employees in the community where they're working, but part of it is you would have more and more vehicles, whether it's cars or transportation or buses or whatever, coming in the community and going back and forth. And we wanted to become a community where we could walk around it on foot.
1:58:10 Instead of people getting into their cars, that's why we got our transportation system, and that's why we wanted our employees in the community. So I don't want to go backwards. I support Mammoth Lakes Housing and support what they're doing, and I would point also to Mono County and the City of Bishop who has taken advantage of Mammoth Lake Housing in the past years because they see the benefit in it. So I'm strongly supportive.
1:58:38 of Mammoth Lakes Housing, what they're doing, what they've done, and I think it's something that this community, because we are a resort community, and because we're isolated, we need to provide the housing for our employees as best we can within our community. It's part of being a mature resort community. Thank you. You and I, Matthew, have a fundamental philosophical disagreement, and what I have heard
1:59:11 is a philosophical statement that you have been able to make because of a simple grant application. A grant is a grant. I specifically asked whether any of these funds would be required to be repaid, and the answer is no. It's not a loan, it's a grant. I respectfully disagree with you that Mammoth Lakes Housing is bankrupt. The fact of the matter is that if you were to look at the financial statement, which I looked at Monday night, the audit came back,
1:59:41 You would find that Mammoth Lakes Housing has substantial assets with extraordinarily little debt. And that is because the voters 12 years ago in 2002 passed a measure and directed the council to devote 1% of TOT toward workforce housing. The fact that there might not be a crisis now because we don't have 600 construction workers taking all of the housing.
2:00:11 The fact that we don't have a crisis now because we have no snow and people have left the community doesn't mean that we won't have a crisis in the future. What we have in this community is a hollowed out middle class based upon the trouble since 2008 economically, based upon three years of drought, and the housing crisis has actually gotten worse. There are a whole lot of folks in this community who make eight bucks an hour.
2:00:40 Well, that's $320 a week if you can get 40 hours during the seasons in which there is work. Multiply that by a year, double it for two. Then go into the housing, single pane windows, electric heat, $1,200 for two bedrooms, $2,000 for three bedrooms, and tell me why it is that people are doubled up and tripled up.
2:01:11 Whole families living in one room? You think it doesn't happen in this town? Go speak to the Hispanic community. Get out there and speak to them. Get an interpreter. They'll speak to you in Spanish, maybe. I think you have a different view. Every resort that we've ever gone to has addressed affordable workforce housing. The state of California considers it a priority. This town has voted. This community has voted to allocate funds. Why would we not spend them?
2:01:43 Why would we not leverage them? Mammoth Lakes Housing is in the business of leveraging, and they've leveraged millions and tens of millions of dollars into housing. What I heard tonight is one of the most successful programs that we've seen in the town of Mammoth Lakes is to provide people with homebuyer assistance. Why wouldn't you? Why wouldn't you go after money that is available? It's going to go to some other community if we turn it down. That's extraordinary to me that we would not.
2:02:13 Take advantage of that which is available to get two and three families living in substandard housing units that are not rehabbed by the private sector. Why wouldn't we not want as a social policy that we can actually influence to get those folks into decent housing so that the employers will benefit, so that higher wages wouldn't necessarily have to be paid.
2:02:44 So that people would come to work every day. So that people wouldn't be sick because they're living in too close quarters. The social impacts of overcrowding in a community in which... I got your newsletter the other day. I know what the median family house is. I know what the median price is of a condominium. I know what the average is. You've stated it. Show me who can afford that stuff. Not very many people in Mammoth Lakes. That's our crisis.
2:03:15 Wait a minute, I'm not finished. We can't afford it. What is it that we cannot afford about receiving money from the federal government? I don't know what that is. We need to stop giving people a handout because they'll take it? Is that really what this town is about? If no one can live here, the folks that you need to run your business, and then everybody else up here who has a business,
2:03:50 Needs to operate a business and earn a profit so that we can make a living and a good one probably all of us up here can't be made. It won't happen. This is simply one component. I have great fear as this council changes that the collective eye will be taken off the ball. I will address that fear as I think that it is appropriate and remind people of the good.
2:04:22 That has happened as a result of the generosity of these voters. Interestingly enough, it's not a single dollar out of anybody's pocket who's sitting in this room because it comes from the visitors. It's the visitors who subsidize housing, and that's a subsidy like many others at the federal level, at the state level, and the local level is worthy of continuing. It's no different to me than the subsidy of marketing.
2:04:52 We spend marketing money that benefits businesses who employ people in order to bring more people here so that we can all prosper in an isolated, difficult, seasonal economy. I don't see housing as any different. I don't see housing as any different from transit. And I won't see housing as any different from recreation as it comes forward. I'm supportive of the bill.
2:05:22 We're going to go to the public in a second unless other council members have other comments. Just another quick question on the 2 million. The economic development side, there's a 3 million availability. Is that correct? In a separate application? For economic development over-the-counter activities, there's a higher limit. That's for activities like business assistance and expansion loans. I don't think the town is...
2:05:51 Ready yet to implement one of those programs without an economic development plan in place first. Okay. Did you say you wanted us to speak before the public? If you'd like to, sure. I just want to have a couple of follow-up comments. Regarding other communities, I think the problem is we're trying to put the cart before the horse. If you go to Aspen or Vail, as you've referenced, the homes there are far more expensive. You don't drive up their main street and see blight.
2:06:24 Okay, those people are living down canyon because they can't afford it. There are properties that people can afford in this community. And the problem with affordable housing has been that they're catering only to the lower end of the economic spectrum. That's all we've catered to. When workforce housing was planned, it was supposed to also cater to middle management, upper management, and other people.
2:06:56 And we haven't really been doing that. I mean, I'm reading even in this document, we're going to continue going after the same economic spectrum. Mono County, you referenced, got rid of their affordable housing program. They found out it wasn't working. So they got rid of it. It was putting a burden on development. And some of the first houses that have been built in the last couple of years in communities are being built in the county because it was more of an incentive. It wasn't a detriment.
2:07:26 We have one of the lowest
2:07:57 Inventory of homes and condos right now. So there are people that can afford it. They are affording it. The challenge isn't that people can afford it. They can't get a loan right now. And I understand that this program will help certain people get those loans. It's great. I think if there were certain pieces like that we could take advantage of, it's wonderful. But my fear is maybe it's a trust factor that I see that we're just going to continue going down this path.
2:08:25 I understand the state of California has made it a priority. Well, the state of California is probably the most indebted state in the nation. It's because of programs where they think that we have money. We don't. To think that this money is just being placed on the backs of the TOT and our visitors, one, that doesn't excite me, and two, it isn't coming just from our visitors. It's also coming out of your tax dollars.
2:08:53 When we get money from state and federal government, that's not free money, folks. That's tax money. That's your money. So philosophically, yes, we have different opinions. And I've said it before, and I'm going to stick to my guns on it. I can count votes. But I think it's just important for the public to hear the other side of the story, of the other sales pitch, if you will. So that's all I have.
2:09:24 In reply, Phyllis' differing philosophies notwithstanding, how about some facts? Mono County didn't get rid of their affordable housing ordinance. They suspended it, and it goes back into effect on January 1, 2015. You were fortunate enough in your county development project to fall within the period in which no housing was required, and you don't have to provide any.
2:09:55 If you have real property interests in the town of Mammoth Lakes, in which you rent to lower-end individuals, there are some on this council that do, you're in direct competition with, you think, with Mammoth Lakes Housing. I would assert that Mammoth Lakes Housing isn't in competition with anybody. Mammoth Lakes Housing is in the business of improving the quality of lives of those people who live and work here and support all of us sitting on this dais.
2:10:24 Now, with that, I'd like to ask any member of the public who wishes to speak to do so who hasn't. Excuse me, this is, sorry, I closed the public hearing. Members of the public have spoken. Okay. Well, we had the two from IMACA, but we didn't ask the general public. Oh, we didn't. Oh, we did? Okay.
2:10:49 All right. And I was thinking that I hadn't, but we had, and that we received some testimony from Degas. Okay. All right. So we're at the point, as we have been, for the Town Council to deliberate the matter and arrive at a decision, and I would ask a council member for a motion. Mr. Chair, I will, sorry, move that we approve option one. Second.
2:11:16 Okay, there's been a motion and a second. We've got one final opportunity for debate and discussion or comments. Actually, council members, if I may, option one asks you to provide council direction regarding the application, so it might be appropriate to have a motion be more specific about what that direction might be. If I may, and correct me if I'm wrong, on page four, handwritten.
2:11:37 It says option one would allow the town and Mammoth Lakes Housing to proceed with developing a CDBG application packet. Is that the direction you're looking for? If that's part of the motion, I think that would provide some direction to staff. Is that okay, Jo? Yes. Yes. I'll amend my motion. I'll amend my second. All right. Thank you, Andy. I see it. The reason is that... There's two option ones. Yeah. It's really the effect of option one, which causes a little bit of confusion. I get it.
2:12:04 But before we vote, if it needs clarification, my intention was that we were accepting the proposals that had been brought forward to us this evening as potentials for those applications after attending this other meeting next week. Yeah, and that would include the Mammoth Lakes Housing IMACA project as well as the town's economic development grant application. Correct, that they be considered by staff and be brought back to us.
2:12:33 That was inferred. I don't know if we have to state them specifically. As well as looking into the application for the Head Start relocation and re... Yes, of considering it, yeah. Okay. Other comments or questions? We have an amended motion and an amended second. If none, roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. No. No.
2:13:02 Mayor Pro Tempick?
2:13:03 Yes.
2:13:04 Mayor Pro Tempick?
2:13:05 Yes.
2:13:06 Mayor Pro Tempick?
2:13:07 Yes.
2:13:08 Motion passes 3-2.
2:13:09 Thank you.
2:13:10 That takes us to policy.
2:13:11 Our first policy matter, which is agenda item number 8, approve the 2013 Measure U Fall funding
2:13:14 recommendations approved by the Measure U Application Committee.
2:13:18 Stuart.
2:13:19 Thank you, Mayor.
2:13:21 I will try and be brief, based on your workshop, but as you know, this is a very lengthy and complex award
2:13:28 With many volunteer hours by our committee members and applicants, so I'll do the best I can. The application period for the 2013 Measure You Fall Award opened on November 11th and closed on December 2nd, 2013. A total of 16 applications were received by the town for a total funding request of just over 500,000.
2:13:52 These funding applications can be viewed on the Town's website right on the homepage under Measure U and they're also listed on page 2 and 3 of the Agenda Bill. Priorities for the effective use of Measure U funds are reviewed annually by the Measure U Application Committee which were adopted by Town Council on November 6, 2013. These priorities in no particular order as follows, economic stimulus and sustainability, high impact, ready to go,
2:14:21 Slash implementation, leverage, and the last one is if the applications have to exist in current plans or studies. On Tuesday, December 17th, the committee conducted the first required applicant presentations, and after additional public comment, on January 7th, 2014, completed the new event evaluation form that was completed this summer by the Special Event Task Force, and also existing project filter and checklists
2:14:49 For the capital and programming applications. The applicant scores from those evaluation forms are identified on page 5 of the agenda bill. On January 14th, the Measure U Application Committee unanimously approved the 2013 Measure U 4 Award funding recommendations in the amount of $591,105. For the benefit of the public, if you don't have a copy of the agenda bill,
2:15:17 I'll just quickly specify if you wish the funding recommendations made by the committee for each of the applications. The Mammoth Food and Wine Experience event was $24,000. The Old Mammoth Road Wine Walk and Classic Car Show was $8,000. Mammoth Lakes Jazz Jubilee $24,995. Mammoth Lakes Music Festival $12,000. Village Fest and the New Chordad Festival was $12,000. Sierra Summer Festival $6,000. The second annual Mammoth Kamikaze Bike Games.
2:15:47 $30,000. Mammoth Rocks Tasted the Sierra, $12,000. The California Federation of Fly Fishers Fly Fishing Fair was $6,000. The, I think, 26th Annual Kids Fishing Festival, $2,500. And that event is also supported by the town in regards to about $6,500 of fish stocking as well. So that event, that amount there was just for marketing. The Summer Shakespeare in the Woods,
2:16:17 By CEO Classic Theatre is $4,500, the Mammoth Lakes Repertory Theatre, $67,000 for annual programming, the Performing Arts Centre Planning was $25,000, Mammoth Rollerink Operations for one year of operations, which is a co-joint application with the Measure R was $10,000, and special event trolley funding was $12,000. Also included... Stuart, you made one misstatement when you were reading all these tiny numbers out.
2:16:47 On the fly fishing fair, you said 6,000, but it's 9,000. 9,000, sorry, right? Okay. Thank you. Well done. It's all these tiny numbers. Yeah, yeah, yeah. So also included in the recommendation by the committee is the town administration 4% allocation. That's taken out annually. That was $32,110.
2:17:10 That amount, or that budget is actually actual incurred costs by the town. It's not just a fund that's set aside. So we bill directly of actual time to that fund. And this year a capital reserve fund of $300,000 was set aside as well. Just quickly, the town, due to the timing of the fund, removed the request for the Whitmore Track Maintenance Fund. They also withdrew the Main Street application.
2:17:37 And finally, you'll see that last application there, which is number 16. The committee chose not to at this time recommend funding for the municipal wayfinding project. Attached to the agenda bill is also the completed evaluation forms, which shows the scores and some comments by the committee. And we also included the executive summary from each of the applicants. With that, we have the chair of the measure application committee in the audience. We also have a member of the committee.
2:18:07 If you need to ask any questions to the committee members in addition to the workshop we had today at 5. So with that staff recommends Town Council adopt option number 1. Stu, thank you. Questions? Mr. Mayor? Stuart, I'd like to first of all commend you for putting together this comprehensive and yet easy to read agenda bill. I mean, this is pretty basic stuff, but you did it to where it was easy to follow, and thank you.
2:18:38 And also to commend you for your efforts in guiding the Measure U Application Committee towards this conclusion this evening. So good job by everyone. Thank you. Good town effort. Thank you. Other questions of staff? Stuart, just on the fall award fund balance, just clarification, this is $58,506, correct? That's correct. Yep.
2:19:11 I realize from the benefit of the public that we don't have a lot of questions, and the reason for that is that we spent nearly an hour on this. In fact, maybe even a little more than an hour on this from 5 to about 6.05. And so we don't want to suggest to you that we haven't deliberated or that we haven't been thinking about this. We actually had a really good informal but nonetheless productive session from 5 to 6.
2:19:37 In which we really took this apart, and I thought that was really an excellent dialogue. I want to indicate that I'm supportive of the recommendation as it is. I certainly have respect for the five-member committee and its individual members. I continue to have some concern about the process.
2:20:06 Politics and bias is getting in the way sometimes, but I really do commend those who spent the time to walk through these 16 applications as well as staff. So if there are no other comments, I'll take comments from the public if any member of the public wishes to speak to this item. Seeing none. I have just a couple additional comments. As do I. As I stated in the workshop,
2:20:34 I'd like to see the $300,000 in the capital investment fund increase by rolling the $58,506 balance into that. I also stated that I'd like to set a policy as the $300,000 is a threshold. We discussed that regardless of what's coming in. My main concern is that
2:20:59 If we're taking the $300,000 as an example and go out and try to bond that, I mean, do we need to, you know, have that committed or is it something that every year can come back to council once we go to bond that amount of money? So I guess that's a question I'm asking.
2:21:21 If you actually issue debt on it, it's committed revenue, then that would have first call on this revenue above anything else if you actually issue debt and it's in that first position. So you'd be required to make those debt payments. But also if you made it a policy of putting the $300,000 each year towards it and thought that that would help you in a loan application, I would submit that future councils could change that policy at any time and it wouldn't be there.
2:21:49 Yeah, if it became pledged to a loan, then honestly, that is a multi-year commitment, which the council can make, but failing at being pledged to a loan, it is something the council can revisit every year, even if the council adopts a statement that it intends to keep making that $300,000 grant every year. Okay. That's a great thought, but I'm just not sure if it's a practical matter.
2:22:15 Yes, I have a couple of comments. First, I am supportive of the recommendations from the committee, and I thanked them earlier. I will again thank them for the hours. I will also thank everyone who applied, because it is a process that you work through, but we heard a lot about the deliberation and why the amounts were worked there. They were. I'm supportive of that. I am not supportive of taking that 58,000, which is the potential...
2:22:42 Unallocated balance right now and putting it into the capital reserve for two reasons. The reality is that utility users tax, even though we all paid a heck of a lot for our utilities in November and December, with the slowing economy we'll be losing people so we cannot guarantee that we'd have even the same base amount of money next year.
2:23:03 The second thing is, as Bill Sauser said earlier, and Stuart backed up, that they're talking about still having a way, which we used to call the oopsertunity, that I don't want to put, I want to have some money out there if one of these projects going forward has a critical need in the next few months. I want to have a little bit of a...
2:23:28 Balance there that's unallocated or that would be combined with next year's funds when the Measure U amounts are awarded. So I would not support – I am totally supportive, Michael, of having as much money going to capital as we can, but I think we have to be practical and have a little bit saved back in case there's some issues that come up that would roll into next year.
2:23:51 My thought being if things turn around or if there's more money or there's fewer applications, that then it could be part of what is committed to capital reserve next year. But ultimately, wouldn't it come back to us if it was needed anyways? I mean, if we roll it in, wouldn't it come back to council? I think what you heard Bill talk about, and I did attend the recreation commission yesterday, so I have the benefit of hearing their discussion, is they're looking about a way to...
2:24:18 Deal with those situations without having to run a full two and a half month application process. And so that's why I would be willing to leave some out there for consideration of how it might be used in that process. Because if we put it in the reserves, then there's the process of having to take it out. And so I was trying to streamline or save staff time in the next few months. But we split the difference. Well, I'll get input from other people here too.
2:24:48 You know, I don't think 300 is enough. I don't think you do either. But I think that actually establishing a policy could have in its own sort of perverse way a negative effect because it will be thought that we only have to put 300 in.
2:25:14 I was saying there's a threshold. No, I understand, and that's what the policy would be, but I know how these things work, sort of psychologically, and I would submit that we can adopt a policy, but I agree with John that the policy simply gets changed by a council that might have a different priority, and so as a practical matter, as a...
2:25:41 Nothing more than a statement, which can be made as part of the record. You know, I don't really feel strongly about this $58,000, but Joe, I like your argument, which is, one, we know there will be lower revenues next year. If this winter is saved, there will still be lower revenues next year, because after all, it's a percentage.
2:26:03 of a utility tax and all of a sudden we're now at February 1st and before you know it's going to be March and the sun is higher and the utility is going to be lower. So I'm a little worried about that. The third thing is I don't want to get ahead of the MLR process and I know that it's sometimes hard to think about MLR and Measure U but you're going to see on the 19th
2:26:31 That as that comes together for presentation for the Council, my expectation, this Council may not buy into what I would like to do, but my expectation is that there's going to be a revamp of this process. And it's going to relate in part to whether this Council determines or decides to, in effect, reallocate Measure U monies. One of the things that I've
2:26:59 I had some concern about, and I've expressed it, is that sometimes I worry that the politics of the moment get in the way of the specific awards. And we always know, I mean, government is in the business of handing out money. We collect it, and then we spend it, and we spend it for the benefit of the community. And in this instance, we've got a hundred and...
2:27:23 Some odd thousand dollars for events, and we've got a total of other things, a total as indicated in the agenda bill of several hundred thousand dollars. My expectation is that the process is going to change a little bit, and so I'm okay with what we've done, and I certainly commend.
2:27:43 The committee, but I think it's going to look a little different. I hope it's going to look a little different in the future. And as a result, I would leave the 58 where it is, but that doesn't mean that it's not ultimately going to be used for capital projects. I think there's a strong sentiment everywhere that stuff should be built. But it competes against, as we know, the requests by individuals to help them launch events or to sustain events that have previously been launched in order to bring visitors here.
2:28:13 Both of them are legitimate and the balance has to be struck. What I hope ultimately the council is going to do is on a high level basis in the future and as a policy matter give broad directive to how these funds ought to be spent and kind of stay out of the details.
2:28:32 We got into the details, John. I know you had some specific things. Why don't we add some money here and there? And I was sort of cringing. I understand. And that's what we do. I was throwing the bait out. That's what we do. And now I'm hearing, you know, here's 58,000. Maybe we split the difference. I don't really want to do that. And I don't think in the future that we necessarily will do that. I think what we know from this council right now, because the committee came back and said, we heard you.
2:29:02 Is that we want to begin to build money from R and U to put toward something that is big, tangible, you can feel it, and something that we will be proud of, whether it's acquisition of land or building a facility or whatever it might be. And so I would just leave them as it is, make the statement with respect to our support for at least $300,000 a year in...
2:29:30 Reserves for capital investment in the future and just let that $58,000 sit where it is. If it doesn't, if it's not needed for something, if somebody doesn't come up with some emergency thing, then perhaps ultimately it's going to go into that. So those are my thoughts in response to your comments. I was just, you know, I don't think I've gone too far different. I was actually thinking of a percentage.
2:29:57 Make it all more confusing, but I think you're right. Well, maybe not in the future, though, Matthew. I mean, that may be. Right. And I think I agree with you, Michael, in that I would like to see the capital certainly higher. I just don't know if, you know, with MLR coming on, if that's going to change everything or not as well. I'm in favor of it, but I just think if we change it and make a policy, it could be unchanged just based on all the...
2:30:26 Different things that are happening here in the next couple of months. One other comment is I think, you know, if we're already estimating lower numbers, I mean, what's going to happen to that 300, you know, next year? I don't think we're going to hit that 300. So, you know, that's another argument why I'd like to see that 58,000 moved. If that number comes down,
2:30:56 And obviously that's balanced because everything's already allocated, which I'm fully in support of what's allocated. But, you know, I mean, the reality of it is the number is going to come down and money's not going to come down. Depends on the priority of those council, don't you think? I mean, the priority of the next council may be, you know what, we've spent too much money last year on events and didn't produce the results or the performance reports didn't bear out that it was productively spent. Gee, we're not going to put...
2:31:23 You know, $150,000 into events, we're going to put $100,000 in, put another $50,000 into reserves. Any council can make that, give that direction. Right. As in, if we move to $58,000, it's a needed application, council can say, okay. So, I mean, to me, I think it makes sense to move it. Jo, you have a comment? Yeah, I was just trying to formulate it as, you know,
2:31:52 It's kind of interesting. We're all talking about less money next year, and I think it's likely. But one of the things is that you're inferring that everybody who's applied this year is going to apply next year, and one of the things that was discussed in the committee and was part of the new special events application form is it's a declining amount of revenue over the years. So that...
2:32:15 Yeah, there might be less money from my understanding in the workshop. The committee worked really hard to try and make sure that everybody got as much as possible within the same overall allocation, which I think is really important. And that's why I still think we need a little bit of flexibility.
2:32:33 I'd love to see a heck of a lot more going through it, but I also don't want, and it's hard for everybody else to understand it, we're kind of saying, so wait until the next meeting when we actually talk about the structure that's proposed for MLR that can add certain amount of flexibility and might go to higher percentages allocated to capital projects and things like that. So it's kind of like at this point, I...
2:32:58 We'd like to see us just stay with the recommendations, hold that little bit in reserve, understanding that next year the existing committee or whomever it is will work through some of those same issues again with some other potential perspectives that we haven't been able to present to you yet. Well, look, I mean, I think we're all sitting up here saying that we want to see that fund grow. Right.
2:33:26 So I think there's no harm, no foul for us to move the money and let it sit there. And if something comes forward our way, then we address it at the time. But, I mean, I guess, I just don't understand what the negative is to not move it. Because everything else, everything is allocated and no one's coming back to request any further. No, that's not necessary.
2:33:54 That's not true. Just because there wouldn't be another allocation of you money before we get to summer doesn't mean that there might not be something that comes up. That's why they were talking about having a simpler process rather than two and a half months of committee and staff time to work through that. How about, Mr. Mayor, if I approve that we do one motion that is to approve option 1A and B,
2:34:23 And then we can further deliberate C. Whatever the pleasure of counsel is. If somebody's got a motion, make it. Okay. If there's a second, we'll discuss it. I would like to split it so that we can have it because I don't want to have to deal with it as all one package necessarily. So I would move that we approve option one A and B, which approves the recommendations and appropriates the money that needs to be done within the two fiscal years for the benefit of the audience.
2:34:56 There's a motion. I'd second that. A and B. All right. Any other comment? I just, my position is that we had the majority of the Measure U Application Committee present for an hour in our workshop, and I would defer to their unanimous of the three members appeal to
2:35:23 To approve this as proposed, option number one, A, B, and C, and also to not move the 58,506 over. Okay. Then I'll withdraw my original motion. I just didn't want to get into position. If C was changed to include the 58,000, I didn't want to vote against the recommendations. So do you want to do a new motion? I'll rescind mine. Okay.
2:35:53 Do we have to rescind the second as well or do we have to vote on it? Well, if the maker of the second is willing to withdraw the second. So then go for it, John. Make it easy. Mr. Mayor, I would move that the council approve option number one including items A, B, and C. Second. Okay. So procedurally, we are now looking at the option one as stated.
2:36:24 And is there, and there is a second, is there further discussion on the motion that's proposed? I don't think I'm persuading anybody, so. Is it worth restating that that does leave the $58,000 in change out of the reserve at this point, just to make sure our community understands? The resolution that you would be approving calls out just $300,000 into the reserve, so. Okay.
2:36:53 Hard choices. So I'm not hearing anybody else who wishes to speak. Roll call, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you. Takes us to the next policy matter, which is, oh, this would be fun, fiscal year 13-14 budget review and the bad word amendment.
2:37:22 Cindy, you're going to take this, or Dan, will we... Oh, here you are. We're going to tag today. Okay. Okay. Okay, I'll start off. The last time I was before you, I was giving you really good news of $1.3 million to put into your REU because we had a really great year last year in T.O.T. I can't predict the snow. So what's before you tonight is...
2:38:06 A recommendation to amend revenues to accept the $500,000 that we have in excess in revenues over what was budgeted in the first half of the fiscal year, and a recommendation to reduce the revenues, general fund revenues by a million dollars for the second half of the year for a net effect of basically $500,000 in needing to find expenditure.
2:38:35 Reductions in the current fiscal year. The first five months of the year had a really strong growth, and most of that was in TOT. That is our strongest revenue. And up through, we didn't know November's numbers until late in December, and it still was coming in strong, but the snow didn't happen. We saw reservations declining.
2:39:09 And we're trying to respond to that at this time. It's not just TOT. Our franchise fees are affected, our sales tax is affected, and our property tax is affected. Property tax is kind of a different issue, but property tax is more related to some appeals that are out there, and the county is withholding money to see the outcome of what those appeals are going to be.
2:39:39 So we're looking at anywhere from a $450,000 to $900,000 revenue loss in the current fiscal year. So with that, I'm going to pass it on to Dan to discuss the details. Can I ask Cindy a couple questions real quick? Sure. Cindy, you've mentioned that we added $1.3 million to the RU. Last fiscal year.
2:40:05 As well as put $400,000 aside for community development and $100,000 aside for a finance system. Okay, but my main point is that we, in last fiscal year, which was a 12-month time frame, we added $1.3 million to our REU because that was a revenue surplus above expenditures. That is correct. Okay. And in addition to that, in the next five months after that 12-month time frame,
2:40:35 We generated an additional half million dollars of revenues above expenditures. That is correct. Okay. So in roughly a year and a half, we had about 1.8 million in excess revenues above expenditures. And what we're asking you to do today is to look at our current economic situation and make adjustments to the budget to be able to handle what is really happening economically due to a low snow year.
2:41:05 Right, thank you. We didn't want to come at the end of the fiscal year and say last year we ended up with a bunch of money, this year we don't have a bunch, so going the other direction. So yeah, we're just doing it early so we can hopefully be realistic in how we handle our budget. And we've looked at a diversified approach to address what we believe to be the shortfall. Again, someone's going to depend on ultimately how the winter plays out and of course the strength of the summer.
2:41:29 Wanted to give a little more detail to the chart that's in the staff report and kind of walk through the detail of the recommendations. Basically, we are looking at a gross loss of about a million dollars in revenue. As Cindy mentioned, the first five months out of the year we're going strong so we weren't too worried and then we get hit.
2:41:50 We're looking at half a million dollars that came in in those first five months of adding that into the budget, recognizing it now as revenue, and we'll amend the budget to incorporate that. And then the other two pieces of revenue that we have that look to be over and above current budget, one is in the snow removal side and the reimbursement we get based on last year's activities. That should be up about $150,000 over the budget.
2:42:16 And also due to the payment process the state of California has on the police COPS grants. Last year's COPS grants came in about $40,000 less. We get $100,000 every year appropriated to us. Depending on their cash flow, we don't always get that payment in the same fiscal year that they say they will. So we were $40,000 short last year. It looks like it's all going to come in this year plus the $100,000 for this year. Hopefully they're all in time with their payments. So that would give us...
2:42:42 In a revenue element, about $690,000 of additional revenue coming into the town, offsetting part of that million dollar loss. So we're doing a net element to do that. To meet the other elements, we're looking at about $310,000 then to address. In looking at doing that, the overall budget reductions operationally, we're asking the departments to go back in and tighten their belts, looking at a minimum of $75,000 in there.
2:43:09 We've identified probably about 50 to 60 of that already. So we're meeting with departments and walking through and reducing things through that budget process. We met today with the town attorney who's coughed up a little bit as well. So thank you, Andy. And then we had a number of vacancies. We brought a reorganizational plan to the council here a month and a half or so ago. And so we will have some savings, personnel savings, the fact that we just haven't.
2:43:39 Hired positions that were authorized at the beginning of the year and carrying that through, we believe, about $100,000 in that range. And then also we'd set aside some additional contingency dollars and again, when things were better, that's nice to have for unknowns, but we'd be looking at reducing that by $50,000 as well. That would take us down about, taking $225,000 out of the budget in terms of reductions. To offset the remaining element for the
2:44:07 Initial million dollars, we'd be about 85,000 short. We had looked at our other unrestricted various revenues, looked at our housing revenue as one area. We have some unrestricted revenues there. And I'll come back and touch on that again in a moment. The other thing we're asking for is an additional 300,000 use of that reserve for economic uncertainty, that REU. Mainly because we don't know how the rest of the winter is going to play out in the summer. And if we can make amendments now and be ready.
2:44:35 We'd rather be able to make those adjustments versus going back in a very short time frame and trying to come back and reduce the budget. That would give us a little bit of a cushion, if you will, going into these next few months, depending how the winter plays out, to be able to make sure that we address the needs of the town. The other goal we've made with the staff is try not to reduce our service levels. We're relatively thin staffed as it is, as council is aware, and try and retain those service levels. So we really haven't gone in and looking at reducing.
2:45:04 Bodies or staff counts at this point, just given where we're at. In terms of the use of reserves, this is kind of a last resort at this point, just in terms of looking at that. One of the options if you want to in terms of we can just put the 385,000 number all in the REU and that's our last point of use. So if we can tighten our budget a little tighter or we have additional savings, it would reduce the impact there. I know there's some discussion, we've internally even looked at it, do we move the housing reserve out or not.
2:45:34 Recommendation in looking through this again is maybe to just go after the REU at this point. That housing reserve would be remained whole and frankly we're probably looking at it in our next budget year and offsetting some of the loan payments we'll have to make next year. So still getting used but using for housing purposes at that point. So if that follows through that will give us, you know, that adjustment of about $610,000 and again $300,000 is in there as a cushion.
2:46:02 Not being able to project out the next couple of months. I think January and February, January in particular, I think is going to be a pretty good hit. A couple hundred thousand minimum, probably maybe up to 300,000. So it's just been a soft month due to the lack of snow. So with one modification to the recommendation, maybe just in terms of using REU versus the housing reserve, would allow us to work through and make the budget adjustment, budget reductions across the board, having all the departments and participating in that.
2:46:31 Would allow us to do that. Initially when we came putting this report together, we were looking at a mid-year review budget that actually looked very good. You had been up about $600,000 in revenue. A little lack of snow. A little too much blue sky I think was the problem. Really kind of turned things around for us in terms of what we need to be looking at. So the staff recommendation would be able to implement the budget amendments and reductions accordingly. Across the departments that will come in.
2:47:01 A variety of different accounts. Given that, we weren't able to put a formal, here's a resolution with every line item noted, but getting the authority to go to make those amendments so we do have a balanced budget coming out of the end of the fiscal year. And that would still rely most likely on some level of reserves. That number would depend on, again, how strong our revenues perform. I can answer any questions or send to me also.
2:47:26 So I just want to make sure I understand the wording when you say authorize the use of the REU if necessary. What you're really saying is authorize use of the REU up to an amount. Yeah, if you want to do that up to 385 would be the recommendation. And if we need it, great. If we need more than that, we'll come back and ask. And for the benefit of my other council members up here is I support the idea of leaving the housing reserves alone. We have...
2:47:50 Hammered Housing. Over the last few years, I would say up to $385,000 in the REU as an up to. Dan, do you see any other, you were just commenting on possible other savings. Can you elaborate a little bit? I think there's pieces out there as we're working through this mid-year budget review and looking at next year's budget. Some of those numbers are just soft. I can't really say it's going to be an additional $5,000 or $25,000.
2:48:23 Some of that's going to depend on some of the departmental work that's being done. I think there's some small pieces out there that we can end up pulling together, but it's hard right now to say, to put a hard number to it. So I was cautious on that, not wanting to overpromise we can cut the budget and then not be able to do it. So. Yeah, I mean, I thought we were kind of, you know, on a path to building the REU. And we're not, you know, we're not very far into already having to go into it.
2:48:53 That's called no snow. At least we have it. At least we have it. I mean, if there are some further savings somewhere to find, I would like to do that. And what I would do is I've cut other savings first before using reserves, so that's why that kind of, not to exceed amount or up to amount, and if we can reduce the budget elsewhere and not impact our service levels or put a burden on the public.
2:49:22 We'll do that. I did want to touch base on a couple of the other partners we have in this that are impacted. MLT, they get to 2.5%. They've already made some budget adjustments to reflect loss of TOT. The other one we're working with is on the transit side. Again, that 1% of revenue that comes in the transit that allows them to be able to function. This will impact their dollars going there. We've been working with them on looking at some options.
2:49:52 They have done some service reductions already just through operationally. There's about a $21,000 savings. We have about another $12,000. They had set aside money to replace bus signs and work on bus shelters that generally get damaged in the snowfall. That hasn't happened. So one positive thing, the lack of snow, we're not tearing things up. So there's some savings there that we can build into that for about...
2:50:21 Excuse me. The, uh, about $21,000 in savings. They have about a $60,000 potential, $70,000 loss on the TOT side. The one element of reduction in service that we've looked at that would, uh, is potentially doable would be after President's Day weekend. We would look at reducing the night trolley, uh, from a 20-minute frequency to a 40 basically, and from two trolleys to one. That would take that operating time, uh,
2:50:51 For the evening down accordingly. It's a low usage standpoint. As we're getting people used to transit, it's really hard to reduce it and then bring it back, so that's always a concern. That would save about $23,000 in total, so that would get their full savings. The other option is at the end of last year, again, as we ended well, we were able to set aside about $113,000 there in reserves for vehicle replacement and work on the building.
2:51:20 We could take the first 21 and 12, so we'd end up about $36,000 in savings, and we could fund the rest of the operational stuff out of that, again, that reserve element. And it's just, the evening one we could reduce back, and I don't think it'd have a huge impact on services, but we wanted to bring that up for discussion here, and then we've been continuing to work with ESTA on that ability. It would reduce that evening service in the trolleys from one.
2:51:50 Trolley did. Two trolleys down to one trolley. So you still have a service that would be a 40-minute headway instead of a 20-minute headway. And that would be Sunday through Thursday only. What time was that? 5.40 to 10 p.m. Would it be spring only or the whole year? That would just be through the rest of this fiscal year. Well, we don't have anybody here to write. It would be the rest of this year and then...
2:52:14 Kicking off some of our trolley service, we'd actually probably start the weekend of June 28th for the July weekend, so a little bit of cross-fiscal year stuff there. And we could push that. If we had ridership, we could push that, start data that out a little bit to get the savings we need in our reduction of hours in services there. We're getting pretty deep into the minutia. Cindy, we, I went over this earlier, we've already,
2:52:49 Officially added 1.3 million in the last fiscal year to our REU. Yes. And what is our REU number roughly? Is it 2.5, 2.8? 2.6. 2.6? Okay. So we have an REU today of 2.6 million. If we'd have taken that 500,000 that we had the first five months of this year, it would have been an REU of 3 million.
2:53:19 Where we would have put that money, just like we, that's why we put the 1.3 million in there. So we've got roughly a 2.5 million REU, and you're projecting a 1 million shortfall in this fiscal year at this point. And overall close to anywhere from $450,000 to $900,000, but what we're asking for right now is pretty much a $500,000 adjustment, excepting $500,000.
2:53:46 Okay, so what I'm saying is go high and do the $900,000. If you did the $900,000, which is on the upper end, we'd still have $1.7 million in our RU. That's just clarification. But a point I wanted to make is if you go back on the snow charts, and yes, we had a decent winter last year as far as occupancy.
2:54:14 But we had a decent winter only because we had a good snowfall in November and excellent snowfall in December. And then it essentially didn't snow much in January, February, March, and April. So we limped financially, we limped through last winter. And still, still in last year we had 1.3 million in excess revenues. Big summer there. Big summer, yeah.
2:54:43 We missed a lot of TOT in the winter last year. The other thing is REU stands for Reserve for Economic Uncertainty. REUs are money is put into the REUs for something that is exactly like what's happening to us right now. This event...
2:55:08 That we're experiencing in the last year, the amount of snowfall is an event that happens once every 30 or 40 years. Maybe 150. I don't know what the number is, but it doesn't happen every five years typically. So it's a rare event. We don't know what's going to happen next year. The same thing could happen next year. We don't know that.
2:55:31 But statistically, it's unlikely that it will happen two years in a row, as extreme as it is right now. So my point is that I'm supportive, and Joe mentioned it earlier, of doing the things that staff is proposing to make cutbacks. But I'm supportive of taking whatever the number is, whether it's $300,000 or $900,000.
2:56:01 For this to get us through this year out of our RU because that's what it's intended for. The other thing is I wanted to remind us is that Dan talks about the summer and when I think of the summer I think of June, July, August and maybe part of September. Well the reality is in this year's budget summer is June because we have a new budget so we're going to miss out.
2:56:28 Revenue-wise, on our biggest two months of the summer, which are July and August. So it's reasonable to think that if we get through this current budget year with a budget shortfall and having to take out of the REU $300,000 or $900,000, whatever that number is or in between, we're going to start off the next year.
2:56:53 In pretty good shape as far as we get revenues for July and August. So it's not a major thing, but I just wanted to point that out. I wanted to make a statement, and that is that I take our current drought and the financial consequences that that current drought is having on our town budget very seriously. So I am supportive of the proposal in front of us tonight.
2:57:29 With the one exception of, and I agree with Joe, of the use of reserves and making that use of reserve, the $385,000 completely out of RU. I know what I wanted to say. Two things. Chief Watson is here, and I'm glad you stayed, Chief, because I wanted to give you, you know, some good words. Chief Watson, pretty much on your own, I know you had help from other people.
2:57:58 But we've reduced the police force in the community because of bad economic times and the airport lawsuit, the financial consequences of that. We've reduced our police staffing, and I don't know the exact numbers, but roughly from 22 sworn officers down to 12. Huge reduction in the police force. Dan Watson is the chief of police. He wants police officers, you know, for the community.
2:58:29 And what he did without complaining is he went out and he developed a program for reserve officers in Mammoth Lakes. And those reserve officers cost us less money, and yet they're able to maybe not go out by themselves, but those six individuals can go out with another fully sworn officer and be the backup, be the second person. So I just wanted to congratulate you, Dan, for
2:59:00 The work you've done on that and for signing up two new reserve officers in recent days. So thank you. The second thing I wanted to say was directed to the town employees. And I don't know what the number of the years are, but let's say it's been roughly the last seven years because of circumstances, because of the recession, because of drought years, because of the airport lawsuit for a variety of reasons.
2:59:31 We've had to reduce, as I pointed out with the police department, we've had to reduce our town staffing by about 40% roughly. Major reductions in staffing. I'm not willing, as one council member, to propose any additional staffing reductions or program reductions. I don't think we need to. I think, again, I go back to the REU. This is what the REU is intended for.
3:00:01 So I don't want to stop the momentum or break the momentum that we currently have with our staff and with the programs that we're trying to do for the community. I want to maintain our staffing and level of service at the same level that we have today. Thank you. Actually, Rick, I have one more question with Dan. Dan, in your presentation, you mentioned a resolution.
3:00:25 And there's no resolution attached to it? Normally the budget would bring a formalized resolution. Because we don't know all the account numbers where we're cutting stuff, we did not do that. So the request is just to give us authority to make those adjustments. We can bring something back. Okay, so that if we just say the number of balancing measures, you would know that if it's the consensus, it's not the housing reserve, and we'd still see a resolution at the next meeting? We could bring something back accordingly. It's not required.
3:00:55 That's why I was asking, when you mentioned a resolution, I thought, well, are we supposed to approve one? Normally we would demand it by resolution, but there's nothing that requires us to do that. I don't want to get into minutia either, but I just have a couple of questions. Isn't the last year's budget, I mean, the current year's budget, didn't it contemplate a compensation package for the town manager which was substantially in excess of what we're currently paying?
3:01:25 And where's that savings? In that personnel vacancies deferred higher than $100,000 in there. There's several pieces that fall into that. Yeah, well, the other two pieces, as I recall, are we were going to hire a finance director. It hasn't happened yet. And a public works director. It hasn't happened yet. Both of those, of course, are senior management, comparatively highly paid individuals. I would think that we'd have more than $100,000 savings.
3:01:53 Just from those three. And again, I don't want you to take them apart, but it just occurs to me that... Actually, Rick, when we did the other adjustment for the year-end, we spent the money Dan's not getting for the IT and some of the other stuff. Right. We already recognized that reduction. Part of the year, too. Yeah, right. So this is for, like, the finance director and the public works person and even the building official that didn't get here in July, they got here later.
3:02:20 Yeah, I suspect that number will be higher. That's one of the things I say. The savings will be higher. It's one of our analysis things that we have on the table. We could clearly identify at least $100,000 in savings. Okay, yeah. Great, thanks. Just a couple of other comments. I got a call a week ago today, actually, from a reporter and a producer at CBS News who
3:02:48 Indicated they want to come up and do a piece on the impact of the drought on Mammoth Lakes. Andrew, you're going to be available. And I thought to myself, well, you know, the reporters report bad news. And so that happened to be the day before the anticipated storm had dumped.
3:03:16 12 to 15 inches of snow on the town. And I said to them, and I was mindful of the fact that, you know, they'll take this, you know, negativism and Hessemism and roll it, absolutely. And I said, you know, I said, I'm in a pretty good mood today. I said, we haven't had much snow, but I'm in a pretty good mood today because everybody that I talk to who goes up on the hill says they're having a great time on the snow. And by the way, we've got the storm coming tomorrow on Thursday, so why don't you call me on Friday?
3:03:45 They didn't call that. We got the storm. Optimism and the expression of optimism is important. What you've done is you've been realistic and pragmatic and I think relatively conservative without suggesting that we have fallen off a cliff. It's really easy for us to look around town and in my instance speak with the many business clients that I have who are frightened.
3:04:14 But people are doing exactly what the town is doing. They're pulling in and they're getting rid of excess spending, obviously continuing to hope for the best. So I think it's... I'm supportive of the adjustments that you make. I like Joe's suggestion in particular because of the multi-year cannibalization of housing and put that at the bottom of the list. The last thing I want to say, John, you reminded me of it.
3:04:43 You and I were fortunate enough to attend the Town Appreciation Luncheon about two weeks ago, about two weeks or so ago, maybe three, and I was asked to say a few words along with a number of others, and so I was standing, it was right here, and I was standing right here, looking out over, what, 60 people probably that day? The room was completely full, and Tummies had catered it, and it was just really great, and I looked around and thought, my God.
3:05:12 I don't recognize 50% of the people. We went through an attrition that was so extraordinary that it's just hard to imagine that we have survived, really. But what we've done, to the credit of this council, is we've issued a directive to go and rebuild that organization in order to deliver the services that we're required to deliver and to continue to do the things that town government does.
3:05:41 I'm not hearing that you're going to cut employees. I'm glad to hear that and I'm happy to see all the new faces and in particular those who have decided to come here even though they know that this is a town that has gone through a really severe fiscal crisis. So good for you. Those are my thoughts. Other comments? Comments from the public. If not, the
3:06:16 Mr. Mayor, I would move that the council adopt option number one as stated, which is authorize the town manager and the finance director to amend the town's fiscal year 2013-14 budget to recognize the increase in TOT revenue.
3:06:41 Of $500,000 for actual revenue received through November of 2013 reporting period, reduce the general fund revenues projected for the remainder of the fiscal year by $1 million due to poor snow conditions and to address the anticipated overall shortfall with the number of balancing measures. Second. If we include that, the authorization to use up to $385,000 in the REU? Yes.
3:07:11 Right? Yes. So amended. And nothing from the housing reserves. Nothing what? No housing. Nothing from the housing reserves. Correct. That's when we're vacant spot. Yeah. All right. So that's an amended motion. Is there an amended second? Yes. All right. If no other discussion, I'm not seeing anybody who wants to speak locally. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. That's great. Thank you, Council.
3:07:42 The next item and the last item, I think, on the agenda is consider options for recruitment of a town manager. Sarah, you're going to take the lead on this. I'll follow you, I guess. All right. Good evening, council members. So this agenda item is basically just revisiting the conversation we had on January 15th meeting, talking about the recruitment.
3:08:12 of a permanent town manager. So it's basically just the exact same agenda, Phil. So I'd kind of like to take the lead on this, if the council will let me. For the benefit of the public, this is on because we have an interim town manager, and that town manager, who's seated over here at the staff table, came on after the departure of our previous town manager.
3:08:42 One of the things that we heard as counsel from the public is that the selection process for a permanent town manager should be transparent. And one way to have transparency is to start with hiring a consultant. We had a discussion, I think, two meetings ago and last meeting about
3:09:10 Retaining a consultant in each instance, the majority of the council is not supportive of doing that. The reason that this comes back is that I think that it's a good opportunity to segue into having a different discussion, which should be public and should be transparent, and that is to consider this council hiring the interim town manager as the permanent town manager.
3:09:37 And toward that end, with the Council's blessing, I've had some discussion with our Town Attorney as well as the Town Manager about what might be appropriate, acceptable terms of a contract that would be offered. And the suggestion that I have to Council tonight
3:10:04 is that it authorized me or some other member of the council, it didn't have to be me, to get together with the town manager and the town attorney and craft an agreement that could be brought back for council discussion and public discussion at the next meeting on February 19th. And if the council so desires to approve a contract with Dan Holler,
3:10:30 As opposed to going out and conducting our own town manager recruitment or hiring a consultant to initiate that process as well. I do understand from a town attorney that there is a provision of the Brown Act. I'm not sure how new it is, but I have a sense that it's really new. Very new. Like a month old that compels us to have a discussion about the terms of a town manager contract in public.
3:10:57 And I think that's a great idea. And Dan Holler thinks that's a great idea. But I think as a foundational matter, we probably ought to have put some structure together so that we can frame that discussion and then have the opportunity for council input and for public input. What I don't want to do is suggest that I know what the terms are or should be. But I have a pretty good idea from our discussions from...
3:11:25 in closed session over the last six months about what is on individual council members' minds as to what should or shouldn't be included in the contract, and it could certainly provide the basis for a discussion. So that's why I kind of want to take the lead and put it out there, and I'm looking for council comment on that proposal. So I mean, will we make a motion off the options?
3:11:54 More of a discussion. No, it would be a totally different option. But if no one else wants to speak, I do want to speak because I was the one who was most concerned about doing an open and transparent process. And my real reason behind that was that
3:12:17 I wanted us to be in a position where we could have a contract that benefits the community as well as the individual entering into the contract, specifically in some of the areas about something that gives us stability but does not tie us into egregious severance pay and things like that that we have had to deal with in the past.
3:12:42 So I am willing to say that yes, I think there are some real values to going with an offer. I don't know if you want to get into specific areas, but I would definitely say a reasonable length of time so that there is some stability, but also not having a huge severance payout at any point in between there.
3:13:13 And something that reflects salary and other issues that are commensurate with the size of a town that we have at this point. Listen, I appreciate that. And in particular, point number three, we've had a lot of discussion over the last six months about that I actually see an opportunity in setting a compensation package for the town manager to effectively
3:13:46 Almost in a de facto way, revamp the compensation structure for the non-union management personnel, some of whom we haven't hired yet. And I think this council has a great opportunity to do a number of things that Michael has been asking to do for the last couple of years.
3:14:12 I get what you're saying without being specific because I don't feel like I should be specific. Yet I think that this is a process that will involve. And by the way, there's nothing that says that we have to approve something on the 19th. There's nothing that says that we can't, that the things that need to be resolved must be resolved by the 19th. But I think that I'd like to be the benefit of the community, particularly because it's an election year.
3:14:37 It's certainly the benefit of Dan Holler to move forward on that to see whether that's, that we can reach agreement on at least, well, more than conceptual agreement, but agreement on basic terms. Are there other things that council members wish to have a view expressed on publicly that...
3:14:58 Well, I think Dan's helped in some ways as well with helping outline some of that structure, whether it be for himself or for some of these other management. I think when it came before us, we agreed on it that time, and I think that's a good foundation for discussion and starting points of some of the salaries. I agree with Joe 100% on the severance. I think that's been...
3:15:27 Mammoth Lakes downfall over the decades has just been, you know, decisions with how we structure our severance packages, so. Oh, and I would also add that I am very glad to suggest that Rick is the person to do the negotiations. I think I have a pretty good idea of where everybody sits on a whole bunch of specific issues and we'll see how well I do.
3:15:59 Andy, do we just give direction? Yeah. That's enough. So we'll come back in the 19th and have a discussion. Do we need to authorize Rick to be our negotiator or anything like that? I think you have. I don't think a motion is required. All right. Okay. John, that's okay with you? Absolutely. Okay. Well, I'll take that direction and we'll get to that and bring something back on the 19th and we'll have public discussion at that time.
3:16:29 Is there any public comment tonight? Any member of the public wish to speak on this issue? Seeing none, we'll move into closed session and then we'll adjourn to our next regularly scheduled meeting, which is to be held on Wednesday, February 19th at 6 o'clock here in the council chambers. Thanks, everybody. Good night. Okay. Okay.