TransparentMammoth

Planning & Economic Development Commission · 2014

Planning & Economic Development Commission Special meeting

· recording 1 hr 25 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

174 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:01 Good afternoon. I now call to order the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting for Wednesday, February the 26th. Roll call, please. Here. Here. Here. Here. Here. Would you please stand for the Pledge of Allegiance? I pledge allegiance, United States of America, to the republic, which it stands, on one nation, indivisible, and the liberty team.

1:32 At this time, we'll have public comments. Public comments are for those items that somebody would like to speak on that is not currently on today's agenda. Thank you for the opportunity. My name is Andy Ott. I will not repeat what I have already told you multiple times. You know, if you move the mic up a little bit, I think you'll be more comfortable and we can hear you better. Okay. Thank you very much. I am a little taller than most. Yes. Okay.

2:03 The chart that's displayed, you have a copy of it in front of you, I understand, kind of summarizes where I believe we stand in terms of undergrounding of utilities along the entire length of Main Street from Mountain Boulevard to Minaret. I will not repeat any of that information. It's available for you to peruse. I only have five minutes. Welcome for questions, though. However, I did attend the workshop that took place last week.

2:31 I was very disappointed in one major item, although I support the framework completely. After the meeting, I got together with the consultants, asked them one simple question. Have you ever talked to Southern California Edison? The answer was no, never. I said, gee, you have lampposts and poles along Main Street. Where are you going to get the power from?

3:01 And then they just shrugged. Okay? Very disappointing. The other thing that was disappointing is one of the presenters said, thank you for inviting us to Mammoth. We've never been here before. Wow. Okay, we've got consultants telling us how to do Main Street and they haven't been to Mammoth before? I was shocked at that. But moving on. Okay? Now, I have requested

3:32 to get from SCE a cost estimate to underground the utilities. In my chart, that just means connecting from point A to point B that already are underground. The current plan to move them above poles and removing poles is way too expensive. I'm not going to repeat that. Funding source, I'm requesting you do that. Based on Mammoth staff guidance after the meetings, I contacted SCE again.

4:01 And this time, it was very interesting, very different conversation than I had the last time. They told me very clearly, I will not speak to you. You need to work with the town, not SCE. Very different than beforehand. Very, and frankly, I agree with that. That's why I'm here. We need the town to work with SCE, not me. Although I have a technical background.

4:30 To do that kind of work, I don't have the political smarts to help, and I'm hoping the town or the county does. That's really all I have to say. I am passionate about this project. I love Mammoth. I just can't imagine driving down Main Street after all the new construction, the new retaining walls, and seeing those five ugly poles over there.

5:01 I believe that when sanity prevails, those polls will come down. The question is, shall we take them down now when we have an opportunity? Because the Mammoth View project is ready to go. They're shoveled ready almost. Last I spoke to Hector, he said they're still hoping to get rolling this year, this spring, I should say. So you're looking for quick wins.

5:29 Those are the fancy words that you use, that you're looking for, for the Mammoth, for the Main Street project. Here's one, which I think you can get a quick win with zero cost increase. I'd be happy to answer any questions. There we go. The consultants were here. One of them was new, and he was the one about parking. The others have been here multiple times for extended periods of time, so they're familiar with Main Street.

6:03 And the other thing, and I learned this lesson myself working on the Gateway Project, is it works best when agencies work with agencies. And that's what happened with me and the Forest Service. And they said, no, you work with the town, and, you know, the town will work with the Forest Service with lobbying, advice, whatever, from citizens, because, you know, that is our right and our prerogative. But that is the best advice, to be working with the town, and then the town would work with SCE, whatever can be worked out.

6:31 So that's how it's done, and not for political reasons. It's just it works better that way. You really believe it. You know, as long as citizens are involved, it really does work better that way. They won't work with a private citizen. And I agree with you completely, Elizabeth. I would like to see the town take an active, proactive role in making this happen, perhaps getting involved with Inyo.

6:57 I'm sorry, Mono County, and frankly, the Public Utilities Commission. Okay? Because what I'm requesting, I believe, should be handled by the town, but I don't see that action, and I'm sorry to say that, but I think the town needs to be more aggressive. I do agree that you agree with my idea, but the only way, the squeaky wheel gets to Greece.

7:27 Chair, is it appropriate to ask staff how it would fit in with Main Street? I'm sorry. Can't even comment. No, because it's not. It's just a public comment. Okay, so we can't ask staff any questions. Okay, thank you. Thank you very much, and I appreciate the fact that you sent us all an outline beforehand. Okay, thank you for the opportunity. We hear your passion, so thank you very much. Thank you for the opportunity. I am passionate, and I don't give up easily. Passion is good. We like passion in this town. It's great. There's a lot of it.

8:02 Our first agenda item after public comments is a public hearing. This public hearing is to consider the approval of tentative tract map 13-003 and use permit 2004-09A, the Talus amendment to allow whole ownership for six lots and the combination of lots 10 through 19 into a single parcel, including the findings of the project consistent with the Talus mitigated negative declaration.

8:32 So for our public hearings, we always follow a set protocol. We have a statement presentation. We will have a statement by the applicant, questions from the Planning and Economic Development Commission, call for testimony for those wishing to speak, rebuttal to any of that testimony, and then we'll close the public hearing, and then at that time, the commission will deliberate on the matter and arrive at a decision.

9:01 So at this point, Jen, are you going to do our presentation for us? Yes, thank you, Chair. The Tallis Amendment is a relatively simple amendment. However, it is for a project that has a relatively complicated past. This amendment, as the Chair mentioned, is to change six of the existing fractional homes to whole ownership.

9:23 to facilitate sales and then to create a remainder parcel for the second phase of the TALUS site for future development. The project is consistent with the mitigated negative declaration prepared for TALUS, it's consistent with the general plan, and it's consistent with the Lodestar Master Plan. There are just two items from the staff report to mention here at the hearing. The first is related to housing.

9:48 And as recommended by the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board, we've included a condition that allows a one-year deferral for housing mitigation for Phase I. That Phase I mitigation, which was approved by the Commission, is the deed restriction of a three-bedroom unit in the clubhouse or having that unit occupied by a project employee.

10:11 The Housing Board recommended deferral because they felt that we could achieve a greater housing benefit by deferring this a year and allowing the proposal for Phase 2 of Talus, which will include an affordable housing component, to progress and hopefully have affordable housing for both Phase 1 and Phase 2 of Talus included in that second phase.

10:38 The original mitigation related to the clubhouse unit would be reinstated within one year of the commission's approval unless there is an alternative housing plan approved by the commission before that time. This year deferral will allow the owner to use the clubhouse unit as an amenity for potential buyers or as he sees fit, which will hopefully facilitate the remaining sales of the existing homes.

11:07 The second item I wanted to mention from the staff report relates to the existing temporary gatehouse and sign. The gatehouse was approved in 2004 as a sales office for TALUS. That approval expired in 2006. The applicant has requested that that sales office be able to remain until all of the units in Phase 1 of TALUS and TALUS Phase 2 are sold.

11:33 Since we haven't received any complaints or concerns about that gatehouse building, the condition that we've included allows for that gatehouse and the related sign to stay in place until all of the units in Phase 1 and 2 are sold or until June 30, 2019, whichever occurs first.

11:55 And with that, staff recommends approval of option one, which is adopting the required findings and approving the Talus amendment as recommended by staff or with modifications. Thank you. Would the applicant like to make a presentation? Good afternoon, commissioners. For the record, Angela Fuse with CFA representing the applicant Talus Homes LLC. As Jen described, this application was initially approved back in 2004 for 19 fractional units.

12:31 Since that time, the market conditions have changed and the property is under new ownership since 2011. We are requesting with this application that three of those units remain as fractional.

12:44 Six of those units be converted to whole rather than fractional and then lots 10 through 19 will be converted into one parcel which will then be developed as part of a second phase of TALUS and that will be before you in the future months. The applicant is here and he and I are both available to answer any questions. Okay. Jen, I'm not quite clear on page six after the

13:15 Condition that's in italics and it says the applicant requested that this housing mitigation be replaced with an existing A-frame, you're referring only to the additional three-bedroom unit for affordable housing, right? You're not referring to the requirement, the original requirement that the housing be in the clubhouse. I'm not clear on that sentence. This housing mitigation, what does that refer to exactly?

13:41 So this housing mitigation there is referring to the housing mitigation required for Phase 1 of Talus, which is the three-bedroom unit in the clubhouse currently. And the off-site one? The off-site one is required with Phase 2 of Talus. So just to kind of be a little bit clear about a little bit of the history there.

14:06 The applicant came in and proposed to swap the mitigation of using the on-site clubhouse unit with rehabilitating that existing A-frame that's on the corner of Joaquin and Meridian. When we went to the housing board to discuss that option, the board was not supportive of rehabbing that A-frame unit. They thought that was the least desirable option just because of the condition that the house is in currently and that it would be ideal to get

14:35 A different, newer unit for housing stock. So this is referring to what the applicant had requested and what the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board reviewed and then ultimately recommended the one-year deferral. Okay, so then the original condition that the clubhouse have the manager's unit, what are our options for changing that? I mean, what are our choices?

15:04 Since that's in the original agreement. Correct. So it's under your discretion as the commission to choose to not concur with the Mammoth Lakes Housing Board and require that that current mitigation remain in place, which would require that unit to be deed restricted or be occupied by a project employee, so it wouldn't be available as an amenity for potential buyers.

15:30 Or the commission could approve an alternative housing plan, which was not recommended by the housing board, which could include the rehab and renovation of that existing A-frame unit. Okay. Okay, thank you. Sure. Staff has done a very good job on explaining the issues. I hate to go back. I can't remember the exact amount of time that it took to get all of this approved in the very first place.

16:08 Just two quick questions for the applicant. First would be, I understand what we got as far as what the housing board recommended, but is it in the desire of the project to rehab that A-frame, or is it preferable for you guys to also?

16:45 Have a deferral and do something newer with the second phase. Yeah. The preference would be to do the one-year deferral, and then when phase two is developed, and like I said, it should be before you in the next couple months, we will incorporate the workforce housing as part of that project. Okay. And actually, you know what? I answered my second question. That's it. Okay. I did also want to, so if, what will happen to the A-frame? So the intent is for the A-frame to stay.

17:14 Not be torn down? Correct. Right. And as, again, as phase two is developed, more options will become available for housing products, and so then we'll have something to bring forward to you. And then my last question is, I just really want to verify that...

17:34 You have read all of the conditions that are attached to the approval and that you're in agreement with all of them. That's correct. We had a meeting with staff who went through all of the conditions and our input was incorporated into them and they were changed and modified accordingly and so we are in agreement with the conditions. Thank you very much. I have some questions of the applicant.

17:57 Yes. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. A couple questions. On page 19 of the staff report, the special planning conditions, who's going to speak to that? Would that be the attorney, I guess? Depends on the question. Thank you. Okay. This would be condition 29, special planning condition 29, the six-foot-high meandering solid cedar fence. When you say solid, has wind been taken into consideration? And also...

18:26 What is the length of the fence that is not – does it go to the property line of the Forest Creek condominiums? Length isn't specified. And then what about snow load in terms of this fence holding out? Fences are the toughest things in the world that have survived a big winter. So if I may, just as background, this was a condition that is a carryover from the original approval, the original TALUS approval. Okay. And this was –

18:56 requested by Forest Creek condominiums to remain in place as a condition. In terms of the ultimate design, I think we were, I think we're happy, well, the applicant can speak to that, but I think the end goal is to make sure that we have a well-designed, attractive fence that isn't, you know, a concern for wildlife. Okay. So this part, these are the original conditions because the original

19:23 Documents are all copied and attached, but then these are the conditions that went with the original agreement. What we've done. I thought they were somewhat revised. Correct. What we've done, because this project has been complicated, we've incorporated any conditions from the previous approvals that are still applicable, so we just have one resolution for the TALUS project, and so these are current conditions with the incorporation of those.

19:52 previous conditions that are still applicable. Okay, then on page 25 of the engineering division conditions, and maybe I'll ask Peter this, condition 38, can you tell me how you define all new utility lines within adjacent to or serving the site shall be placed underground? That seems sort of expansive and a little unclear. Exactly what does that mean? Well, for this project it's pretty easy because all utilities on Meridian Boulevard are

20:22 And this vicinity are underground. So any new utilities for this project would be underground. Okay. I just wasn't quite sure what adjacent to meant. And then I love the little gatehouse. Is that movable? Do you have to tear it down or can you move it? It's like your brand. I like that. Correct. One of the conditions is that the gatehouse can remain until the time of phase one and phase two being sold out or until 2019.

20:48 So at that time, the gatehouse will either have to be removed or come back before you to modify the condition. Okay. I had friends who lived in the A-frame, and I thought, oh, it can't be in that bad shape, and then I remember it was 20 years ago they lived there, so I have to realize how much time has gone by. Okay, those are all my questions of the applicant. Thank you. At this time, we'll open it up for public comments. Does anybody in the public like to speak? Either for or against the public comments.

21:22 For this public hearing is now closed. Commission, do you want to start? I don't have a ton to add. So I'm supportive of the additional conditions. I'm supportive of the project. And if it's something that, you know, the applicant is comfortable with and staff is comfortable with, I agree with the recommendation, the MLH board, to kind of deal with the affordable housing.

22:03 Fortune of it in phase two, which I believe will be coming before us pretty shortly, so I don't have a ton to add. Mr. Harvey? Thanks, a good idea. Why did we ever have the manager's unit be in the clubhouse? How did that happen? That was a long time ago, and there are many projects over the dam, but I don't know why we, I shouldn't be saying this in public, should I? But I just read that and thought, gee.

22:43 Rob, is anything happening with the ski pro on site as far as occupancy of the A-frame? Is anything moving forward with occupancy of the A-frame right now? Yeah, well, get back to your question. The A-frame is livable. It's not a bad condition, but it's not as a good condition for affordable housing, as funny as that sounds. So for me to convert it to make it be affordable housing is going to cost me about $100,000.

23:16 That little A-frame? Yeah, it can make it compliant for the installation, for the energy efficient, for everything else, but no, the actual A-frame is occupable. I mean, I redid it, and it's, you know, actually, somebody's going to potentially be living in it itself, but to comply with the affordable housing requirements, it's not applicable, so it's kind of funny, but somebody is going to be living in it. And with the housing that you're

23:44 You're asking for, that's new construction, but it's going to be on site, so your manager would be on site. Is that what you're saying? Or you're not sure yet? Not sure yet. No, then that's fine. You don't need to commit at all. It's just, you know, curiosity. Do you have any additional questions to give? Well, I think we certainly meet the CEQA findings, the municipal code findings, and the subdivision findings, and I personally support approving this. So do I have a motion?

24:20 I'll move that we adopt the required CEQA findings, adopt the required Municipal Code findings, adopt the required Subdivision Map Act findings, and we approve tentative tract map 13-003 and use permit 2004-09A use permit 13-006 with conditions as recommended by staff

24:49 Or with modifications. None I've heard. Second. Or third. All right. Roll call, please. Commissioner Harvey? Aye. Commissioner Tenney? Yes. Vice Chair Herney? Yes. Chair Brown? Yes. Thank you very much. The next matter on our agenda is a business matter.

25:20 This is referring to the Mammoth Brewing Company tasting room use at 18 Lake Mary Road. And staff, Sandra? Thank you. The item before you today is a request from staff for a Planning Commission interpretation. We received a request from Mammoth Brewing Company to move their tasting room from their Burner Street site into the vacant Whiskey Creek restaurant portion of the building at...

25:47 18, Lake Mary Road. Tasting rooms are not listed as a use in the North Village specific plan, so the Planning Commission has the opportunity or has the ability to make a determination that the use is similar to and no more detrimental than another listed use in the North Village specific plan. On page, I guess, 115 of the packet, staff provided the Planning Commission with some other uses listed within the North Village specific plan.

26:17 That the Commission could use to say they are similar to no more detrimental than. The three uses that we looked and found were restaurants. Restaurants are currently a permitted use within the Mammoth Crossing Zone of the North Village Pacific Plan. Retail within an existing building is permitted. However, a use permit is required for any stand-alone retail developments. And liquor stores, those would require an administrative permit.

26:45 Staff also provided the commission with background on the zoning code update. The zoning code update does list tasting rooms, and tasting rooms are proposed to be a permitted use in all commercial zones as part of the zoning code update. So staff is requesting that the planning commission discuss this item and provide us with direction as to how to process this request for Mammoth Brewing Company. And I'm available for any questions that you have on this. Are there any questions at this time for the commission?

27:16 What's the best time to address this letter from the Fireside Board of Governors? No. Okay. Well, maybe I have questions for the applicant, then, if we're going to do that. Before we have the applicant come forward, and also we'll open it for public comment, I just really want to clarify that we are not talking today about the brewing operation.

27:44 Okay. All right. Did the applicant like to come forward?

28:10 Commissioners, thank you for taking the time to review our situation. Joyce Turner with Mammoth Brewing Company. I also have here with me today Sean Turner, my partner, and Andrew Drake, our tasting room manager. We, just for a little bit of background, we are currently located in 94 Burner Street with our tasting room operation. We are currently doing only tastings and retail sales of our

28:40 Our beer products as well as shirts, hats and those kinds of things. We have lost our lease at that location and have successfully negotiated to stay there until the end of March. However, we cannot operate in that location beyond...

28:54 The end of March, beyond March 31st, so we do need to relocate that tasting room, and as you know, we do have a signed lease for the Whiskey Creek Restaurant location. Our initial intent, and we also have a Type 23 ABC license, which exists currently at Burner Street, and we are currently in the process of expanding it to the entire building at Whiskey Creek. That license does allow us to do

29:20 Pint sales. It's a very unique license, actually. It's really wonderful for craft breweries to have this type of license. It allows us to do retail sales. It also allows us to sell pints. So at some point in time, we are considering opening our tastings beyond just tastings and creating a very limited venue for selling pints and doing light food. But that's yet to be determined.

29:46 Based on how things proceed. This has all come about fairly quickly for us. The opportunity to take over such a large space has come about fairly quickly. So we need to take our time and figure out how we're going to make this happen. It kind of rearranges our business plan a little bit. But we do intend to create a really wonderful destination location. I don't know if you've been to the tasting room lately, but Andrew is reporting that Saturday night...

30:13 It was so popular that he had to turn away about 30 people from that location. It's just become a wonderful destination, really feel-good place to come and experience a piece of Mammoth. Tasting rooms have, I don't know if you know much about the craft beer scene and where tasting rooms have gone.

30:33 They have just exploded in the state over the course of the past five, ten years. My dear partner here had the vision for this and was a bit ahead of the curve. And our tasting room has been a model for others around the state. So we're very proud of what we have. We think it's a strong community asset. From my background, I think we're right in line with what that use should be in that kind of space.

31:03 And I think it'll be a wonderful improvement in atmosphere, in feel, in community, and a strong attraction for the community. So we, in the interest of maintaining the continuity of our tasting room, in the interest of believing that what we're asking for is very consistent with the intended uses, it's just that when the specific plan was developed,

31:29 Tasting room if they weren't on our radar screen. And knowing that those are coming, we strongly ask that you consider this as just a straight-up building permit for any improvements we do at that location. And Andrew and Sean are here as well to answer any questions you have about our operations. Does anybody have any questions at this time? Are there any members in the public that wish to speak? All right. So for the record, Sandra, we received a couple of letters, correct?

32:06 We received one letter from Tracy Spencer, fireside owner, with an attachment of a letter that was submitted in September. Okay, and that's been submitted and distributed, right? And it's part of the record. Okay. All right. Commission.

32:23 Questions, thoughts? Yes, I have some questions. This letter is just to be the first of many, you know, paraphrases of it, I'm sure, because of your neighbor. I'm a little troubled that last October we were supposed to meet to discuss the design review committee and Sandra and you meet to discuss what you were going to do with the tanks outside with a retaining wall. The tanks are, you know, clean and in good order and they have the insignia and all that sort of stuff. There's no interpretive stuff. Nothing's been done to make it less industrial and more

32:52 Interpretive, you know, for our visitors, and that was last October, we were supposed to meet on that, because you were, of course, really busy with the summer and, you know, big season. So, this is another request, and it'll be one of many, and we'll have to deal with all the issues that the attorneys for fireside raised, but I wondered what the status of that is, and what the, maybe the delay has been on doing something with the tanks, you know, the things we discussed on site. Yeah, and I apologize, Elizabeth, that follows in my court.

33:22 You're right. It has been a busy summer. We've had quite a few things on our plate and just trying to keep ahead of the curve on keeping business in order. Sandra and I are working on that. We are in the process of completing the operational agreement. My commitment is that we will complete everything that we were required to do in October for the administrative permit on the interpretive signs, on the fencing, on all of that.

33:48 here in the very, very near future, in the next month, I hope. I don't recall that we saw an actual plan. Did we see an actual plan? We discussed conceptually, but... Yeah. And again, that ball is in my court. I've been the one that's been behind on getting that completed. Because I think design review would be part of that, just how it all pulls together. Yep.

34:07 So we did, and we did put a fence up because we needed to get something up to protect that. Oh, sure. Recognizing that, recognizing that we'd have to come back with, to you for the aesthetic portion of it. Because especially considering wanting to have a tasting room in Whiskey Creek, I mean, that would be even more important. It's at the, you know, exactly. Exactly. So I'm glad to know that the ball is being picked up. Yeah, yes. And I apologize again, it is in my court. Okay.

34:33 Do you have any other questions? So all we're talking about is the tasting room. Yes. We're not talking about future restaurant, bottling, nothing, nothing else. But that's going to be coming, I take it? And we'll address all these issues that are raised by the neighbors? Is that coming? A future restaurant would be a permitted use. So if Mammoth Rain Company wanted to open a restaurant, that's already a permitted use. These items that were cited in the September letter, staff is working with those through the operational agreement with the fireside board. So we're working on that with them.

35:04 Oh, well, that's helpful. Thank you. Okay, I'm set. Okay. Commissioner Harvey? All right. A couple of things. First of all, I think it's a wonderful opportunity for the town of Mammoth to have this tasting room in such a prominent spot in Mammoth. More than most of you, I was around when Whiskey Creek was built.

35:35 And that was just such a landmark. And for many, many, many years, that's where you met. We always talked over the last number of years of building a clock tower on Main Street and having a sense of identity for people when they arrive in town and they want to meet and this is where you would go. Well, Whiskey Creek satisfied that for the town of Mammoth for a long, long time.

36:03 So we have the combination now of an incredibly successful microbrewery in our own backyard here, homegrown, and this incredible landmark that millions of people from Southern California identify with. It just, the administrative permit that was issued was the right thing, in my opinion.

36:32 And it will remain my opinion. So all the good things that come with this certainly outweigh what has been expressed by some neighbors as major issues. I think a major issue is going to come when the three corners there start getting developed and 80-50 starts getting developed.

37:03 There are more issues down the road in that respect. The physical location gives us something in this town that I think is a huge, huge plus, and that is not only is the tasting room now within direct walking distance of the village. You don't have to tramp over a

37:34 Unlit parking lot area and stumble and bumble and hurt yourself and possibly try to drive over there and then God forbid drive back after a few samples. It's just everything about it is the right idea and we need to embrace these things and move them forward instead of trying to find reasons to hold them back.

38:02 Now, having said that, I believe very strongly in the good neighbor aspect. These people do have property ownership that are writing the letters and complaining. I understand that there has been some communication and I would recommend more communication to see if, in fact, things can be resolved.

38:31 But I don't believe that that in and of itself is any reason to hold up the administrative permit that's been issued, I understand, on this and from moving forward in that respect. So I will be in favor of option one. Well, I think, you know, first of all, I would like to commend you guys as a business for what you've been able to build.

39:10 Remarkable the job you've been able to do with the current tasting room, because quite frankly it's not a very attractive location or exterior, but you come inside and it's jamming. You guys have done a fantastic job with building that space out, and I have a tremendous amount of faith that you will do the same with this new location. Kind of similar to what Commissioner Harvey had said, that is definitely a marquee spot in Mammoth.

39:39 It's a prime location and I personally can't think of a better case scenario for a business to come into that space. So I'm very supportive of that. I do understand some of the concerns of the fireside neighbors. I know from speaking to you both personally as well as corroborated by staff that you guys are making efforts to be good neighbors and I appreciate that.

40:04 But I don't think that's really what we're charged with dealing with here today. And I think what we're looking at today is very simple, that we're asked to determine if a tasting room is similar to and no more detrimental than a restaurant in that permitted use space. And for me, that's a simple yes. You know, should you choose to expand the operations, have a restaurant, brew pub on site, I think that would be fantastic.

40:33 That will also be permitted. But I don't see in any way, shape, or form that a tasting room could be more detrimental to that area than what currently exists there. So I'm excited about your kind of new opportunity there. And for me, it's very black and white for my determination today. So again, I would support option one. I concur with everything that my fellow commissioners have said.

41:03 I'll just make a side note that it highlights what we previously talked about is that someday we have to take on the project of once again amending the North Village specific plan so that it has the same standards as our now Main Street. So I don't have anything else to add. Does anybody else have any questions or thoughts? Yes. I think this is a great idea and I'm so happy that we're not going to have an empty storefront.

41:29 You know, a monster empty storefront in Mammoth. And I agree with Dave about what a landmark this is. And I would urge you strongly to petition the town, the post office, whoever you have to petition, to change the address to number one, Lake Mary Road, instead of 18. It should be number one, Lake Mary Road. Very good. Yeah. So, Pam, do we need an app? This is a consent item, business matter item? Consent? It's a recommendation. It's a recommendation.

42:00 Do you need a roll call? Let's do a roll call. All right. So then we'll need a motion. I'll move that we go with option one and not require the applicant to submit for any land use permits. Building permits would be required for any tenant improvements. Okay, I'll second that motion. Roll call, please. Aye. Commissioner Henry? Yes.

42:34 Vice Chair, Farney? Yes. Fair amount? Yes. Thank you. Thank you, staff. Good. All right. We'll now move on to our next business item, which is consider recommending approval of the draft general bikeway plan. Thank you. Everyone out of here. Commissioners, Hazel Pays, Associate Civil Engineer, Town of Mammoth Lakes, presenting both the updated bicycle and pedestrian master plans for your review.

43:12 Staff is requesting that this commission recommend approval of the two plans to the Town Council. These plans before you support the general plan vision of feet-first transportation and serve to help prioritize infrastructure improvements. The two plans are based on the accepted draft mobility element and serve to provide another more detailed layer of goals, objectives, and policies for both bicycle and pedestrian mobility. Staff made the draft plans available earlier this month for public comment.

43:41 And we are currently collecting comments from the public and our jurisdictional partners. We are well aware of the grammatical and spelling formatting errors that are in the plan that was submitted, but we felt it was important to push this out, and I'll get to that in a second. All these corrections and all of the input will be incorporated in the final draft that does go to Town Council. These plans are really important and a necessary tool to secure grant funding.

44:10 And staff has been made aware that a grant call is coming in early March. So it's important that we get through this process so we are frankly ahead of the curve when it comes time to apply for grant money. And so with that being said, available for questions if you have any comments, concerns. We would like to start. Okay.

44:37 I had a meeting with Hayes about these two plans because I had a couple suggestions to make which I want to mention to you, but first I want to tell you how the meeting went because every suggestion I had, he said, oh yeah, I'm applying for a grant for that. He's just hustling money right and left and it was really exciting when you think we're just stuck and we're not going anywhere. He said, oh yeah, I'm applying for a grant for that, so that was a good thing. I had a couple comments on the plan. I know

45:03 Let's see, we're having public comment, but this won't come back to us, will it? After the 30-day public comment, will this come back to us? Okay, so this is our opportunity to say this. Under the needs assessment, I thought it was important to put something in there about visitors on vacation who are clueless. Clueless in the sense...

45:22 Clueless in the sense of… Would you like us to phrase it that way or… No, but in the sense that they're on vacation, they forget that other people are on the road. They forget that if they cross the road, you know, a truck might be coming, that kind of stuff. And I thought we should have awareness, whether it's signage, I don't mean clueless visitor, you know, cross here, I don't mean that kind of signage, but something about acknowledging that visitors, because they're happy and on vacation and they sort of forget that we have rules for the streets and…

45:50 And walkways and all the rest of it. Then my other comment to him was I felt that Old Mammoth was underserved for one length of Old Mammoth Road that didn't have any sidewalk indicated on the map, which would go from Waterford to Sherwin Street. And that's a large segment of workforce housing through there. And it's a very narrow stretch of Old Mammoth Road on the curve. Edelweiss Lodge is at Waterford. And then Sherwin Street, you know where Sherwin Street is. Do you think there should be sidewalk that goes up to Sherwin Street?

46:20 I suggested that there should be a way to walk safely along the street, and it would only be on one side, but I did feel that because there's so much workforce housing there that we really needed some way for people to get to the bus stops because it's narrow and people are coming downhill around a blind curve. I just thought there ought to be a place for safe pedestrians. So those are my two issues, general issues with this, and he's just pushing this forward, you know, as fast as he can so they haven't even done the spell check yet, but all that will get worked out.

46:49 And just to touch on your old Mammoth, I think we would leave that as a pedestrian corridor and identify it as either a mop or a sidewalk so that we can follow both types of grant funding opportunities. Oh, that's good. We don't tie ourself to one or the other. Instead of closing off any options. If that, it kind of meets your intent of just providing pedestrian connectivity in that area. For the people to be able to walk to the bus stop or whatever on the roadway, it's very narrow. Chair Hardy? Okay.

47:20 So is it Hayes that's actually writing for the grants? Public Works staff. We all work together. Okay, so there's no one individual that's doing the grant writing. We all work together. Okay. Depends if they get the grant or not. I'll have to put you on the spot here. Okay, Measure R and Measure U. They were called out as methods of funding.

47:50 In both of these, the bicycle and the pedestrian, has the potential MLR group addressed this issue as to being a potential funding source in their eyes? I think it's kind of premature.

48:25 I understand that to an extent, but has the conversation surfaced? I mean, it's one thing to put it in the book, but has it in fact been broached? I would say that we've been applying, we've been using Measure U and Measure R money for funding grants to date, and from the staff's perspective, we would expect that that's a good use of those funds to leverage a small amount of local dollars towards a large amount of grant funds.

48:56 The grant funds we apply for with Measure R and Measure U are to complement the grants. It's just a match. So we actually haven't funded any entire projects with those sources to date. Okay. We just leverage it. So you'd be using those for the leverage on the grant that you're going for? My hope is that we could continue to do that. Yeah. But I don't believe the discussion has gotten that far yet.

49:21 Okay. Town manager might be able to find a little more insight, but essentially I think it's early in the process of the formation and the rules and guidelines really haven't been figured out or understood at this point. I think that's a fair statement that it is early in the stage, but to answer your question directly, no, that conversation has not been broached. Okay. I would suggest that it be broached sooner than later.

49:49 For obvious reasons. Because all the 100, you know, the 100% grant projects are really, there really aren't any more of those. They're always going to require a local match. Right, exactly. Or in some cases 10% and they do 90. Are there any of those deals anymore? 10 and 20. And then 20. And then 11.67, depending on the color of the money. I think, you know, that is a very important consideration to look at.

50:29 How the potential formation of MLR can impact some of that stuff. But as a general statement, I think that's one of the major shortcomings of our town is pedestrian connectivity and bike routes. And it's obviously a very popular mode of transit for people here. So anything that we can do to continue to further that.

50:59 I'm very supportive of. So I don't have much to add, but I do think that as Dave called out, that's an important conversation to have because presumably there will be some changes to the landscape of R&U. But I don't have any other comments there exactly. I know we spoke a little bit about kind of safety concerns and signage and those kind of things, and I think as a general comment, there's always

51:29 Going to kind of be that battle between bikes, pedestrians, vehicles. I just don't think there's a very good understanding in the general public of who has right of way and how those kind of deferments work and policies of whether a bike is a vehicle or a pedestrian and all that kind of stuff. So I think, I guess, probably the best we can do is just education and signage, but I think that's probably always going to be an issue.

51:58 I don't really have much to add other than that. And we're talking about both drafts, I assume, at the same time, right? Correct. So can you give us an update on how we're doing with our safe routes to school? Sure. As you're aware, we've been very, very successful in both the state and federal programs. We have a number of projects that we've completed. We have one on the books for the summer. Actually, two on the books for the summer. Take that back.

52:26 Both a state and a federal project. We'll be constructing a sidewalk on the north side of Meridian from Old Mammoth Road to Tallis and some other ADA improvements between the school and Old Mammoth Road. We'll also put the Meridian on a road diet. We'll implement the first phase of that, so we'll be narrowing from five lanes to three lanes. The other project is state-funded. It's going to be a path between the elementary and middle school.

52:55 We are coordinating with their efforts to, while they work to reconstruct their parking lot, so we're putting our heads together to come up with a really nice rational product for the students and the parents to utilize those facilities. Along with that, we're going to be installing two new pedestrian activated crosswalks, one to replace the old defunct one at Roberto's on Old Mammoth Road. The second one will be at Sierra Park and Meridian to help facilitate high school students.

53:23 Well, that's a great one. Off and cross there. So those are the two projects we have currently programmed for construction right now. And the next, like I said, the next round of funding is coming up in a little less than a month. And we'll be going after additional Safe Routes money through that process. And out of all the proposed projects, do you have a favorite one? Or is there one at the top of your list? I have lots of favorites. They're all fun and exciting.

53:50 Can I comment on my favorite? Yes. None of this will work without wayfinding. We need our wayfinding signage. My goodness, that's where all the accidents happen. Like I haven't mentioned it before. No, and I think it is appropriate that it's in both drafts. Yes. All right. So we'll do a roll call. I guess we'll have to do two separate ones. Pam? Okay. Okay. Do you want a motion? Yes, please.

54:27 I move that we approve option one, find that the general bikeway plan is consistent with the general plan and recommend that town council adopt by resolution the general bikeway plan as proposed or with minor modifications. And then the other one. Well, I can just substitute the pedestrian master plan. It's the same thing. Okay. So find that the pedestrian master plan is consistent with the general plan and recommend that town council adopt by resolution the pedestrian master plan as proposed. Thank you.

54:58 Roll call, please. Hi. Yes. Yes. Yes. And thank you very much for your hard work and good luck with your grant writing. Thank you. Okay. At this point, we'll move on to our consent agenda. Anybody have any comments about our minutes from February 12th? No. Okay. So the consent agenda is approved? Aye. Aye. We'll now move on to commissioner reports.

55:52 The design committee? I think, correct me if I'm wrong, but we've met once since our last meeting. We did have a sign approval for the Mammoth Tavern. And was there anything else with that? There was a house at the Bluffs. Oh, right. It was a design review. Yeah, you know, I mean, not a ton to report. We did approve the current sign at the tavern.

56:25 Pending a little bit of a readjustment. It's kind of hanging a little bit below the edge there, so we requested that they adjust that up a little bit, which they were fine with, and you can maybe speak a little bit more on the housing. Just one more thing about the sign. That worked out very well because these people were misinformed.

56:51 By the person who produced the sign, they had a beautiful sign designed, it was absolutely beautiful, and it ended up that they didn't have a sign permit, the master sign plan had expired, and the sign was oversized. But it was, we decided that, you know, they went ahead and applied for a sign permit, and what was our final thing, what happened to Jen about the master sign plan? I'm trying to remember what the decision, do you remember, Colin, what we decided to do about the master sign plan?

57:19 I don't recall. I know that the sign… Because every 10 years, those are supposed to be updated. They really haven't kept up with it because they haven't been able to. The 2011 sign ordinance does not require master sign plans to be renewed anymore. Right. That's what it was. Okay. And then where it was hung, it was just a matter of rehanging it because now it looks sort of droopy drawers. You know, it's hanging down below the edge of the building. But it was a really good outcome. And it sort of reminded me of a property I visited recently in Tahoe where the…

57:48 Planning Commission there said that you can build this new development but you can only build it within the confines of the existing foundations and an old motel was torn down and what that resulted in is you have a beautiful facility but you had to go outdoors to get to the steam room or the sauna in your bathroom and slippers and walk across the parking lot through the cinders and I thought that's an example of just not being realistic.

58:15 And that's why I thought the Mammoth Tavern sign was an example of, oh yeah, we can work through this. We worked it out and they applied for the permit and they were very happy to change the position and even though it's a little bit big, it's okay. It just worked out. And I just thought of that example because I was the one patting through the parking lot in my bathroom with slippers. You know, I think the bottom line is the intent is to encourage, you know,

58:41 Good design work and good signage. Oh, exactly. And it is a good sign. Very good. So the fact that they went to the trouble and the effort to put together that level of the sign I want to encourage. And truthfully, that master sign plan is extremely outdated. It doesn't even allow for signage for a second-story restaurant. And this was not malicious, what they did by not applying for a permit. They were just misinformed. And I think that's it.

59:10 For us? In the design, the house at the Bluffs, it was a contemporary home, and we made a couple suggestions. There was one contemporary home up there that the previous design review committee I know was okay with the design of the home, but then when they painted it black, we realized, oh, we need to review these colors a little more closely, so. But, yeah, we made some good suggestions on that, too.

59:33 Jen is very efficient at getting these design review agendas, you know, just clusters things and very efficient. That's appreciated, Sandra. Economic development, Commissioner Harvey, that would be you. I've got a couple of things. Thank you for making it snow. Number one, my wife and I attended the TED Talks last night and they were absolutely fabulous. Elizabeth?

1:00:06 Thank you. Did that not turn out to be a great idea? It was phenomenal. The talks that were given were a combination of talks that were extremely exciting. There were other talks that were educationally rewarding and even other talks that were

1:00:37 Very heartfelt and educational, specifically the Hantavirus talk. It was the history of a person here in the Eastern Sierras that went through the illness. Pretty good stuff, to say the least. It's a great program. I encourage you to continue to...

1:01:08 Bring things like that forward whenever you see them. I've had a lot of emails this morning. Great job. Thank you. Great job. Okay, another thing I wanted to talk about a little bit is a program that the county is pushing and I believe needs to have town support as much as possible, both from

1:01:36 our town staff and from the residents of Mammoth. California, as you may or may not know, has a zero net energy program that they hope to have accomplished by 2020.

1:01:58 And the only way they're going to get this accomplished is by individual residences and commercial businesses participating. The biggest obstacle to participate in any of these programs is always financing. It's always the cost. There's been a program around for a number of years. Unfortunately, it was put on hold in many areas.

1:02:26 Especially areas that had Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac type lending. That's just about resolved now. And California is officially in the PACE program. Mono County is leading the charge to create our own PACE program. PACE is Property Assessment Clean Energy.

1:02:57 Property Assessed Clean Energy. It allows for a 100% in most cases funding. The funding is backed by real estate and it's handled through a collection mechanism very similar to real estate taxes. It's a loan that runs with the property so it's not

1:03:28 It's not burdening any individual. And it has been very, very successful throughout the Midwest. On March 18th, the county board will have a meeting here in Mammoth. There will be a presentation by county staffers to the board. This is headed by Gerald Frank of the county.

1:04:02 For those of you that want to learn more about this, that's an excellent opportunity to learn. The county is extremely serious about this project. They have waived, or their proposal is to waive fees that have to do with folks doing solar and geothermal on their residences and also commercial buildings.

1:04:33 It's a wonderful opportunity here for us to be known for the green aspect of building. As Commissioner Tenney remembers, this is a program that we wanted to push forward very hard with many years ago with the Heiss Air Energy Foundation and ran into the obstacles as I

1:05:08 Described earlier, but now it looks like it's back on track and it should be a wonderful thing not only for the county but also for the town. It's my understanding that the county will come forward with a request for the town to create a resolution to participate in the program and I hope

1:05:33 Everyone will educate themselves more on the program and give that support to council when needed to make that happen. Okay. Is that both a residential and commercial program? Yes, it is. And then if the loan is secured by the property, do you have to have equity in your property? Yes. You do have to have some equity in your property, typically 20%. And do you happen to know what the...

1:06:05 Is there a generic set of terms for the loan? Like length, interest rate? That will be put together by what's called a company that goes by the acronym of HERO, and they are facilitators for municipalities and utility districts who operate these kinds of programs, and they can be accessed on the internet.

1:06:37 Learn all about the conditions that they impose. There's a lot of good information on the internet about PACE. U.S. Department of Energy basically initiated the program a number of years ago, and that's very accessible on the web. Okay? Very welcome. One other thing, and this is a very important thing in our community here.

1:07:10 About a month ago I sat in on a court case that involves something called or referred to as green mail. Green mail is the practice of different entities. In this case it was a labor union entity. A suit was filed.

1:07:42 challenging the acceptance of the EIR by the county on ORMAT's proposal to go forward and create new plants and develop their business. The screen mail has been going on in a number of cases now for the last two years. As you can imagine, that costs a lot of money.

1:08:14 We want to bring more diversity to our town so that winters like we're going through now don't crush businesses and these are the kinds of obstacles that businesses are running into. It's appalling to me because it's so blatant.

1:08:44 I guess blackmail is about the best way I can put it, but the individuals throughout the country have referred to it as greenmail, and that's basically where one entity uses an EIR and a CEQA process to delay and postpone businesses from going forward.

1:09:15 And it's something I think that we should all be aware of. And sometimes I guess you just call a spade a spade. But it's not going to go away until there's public outcry about these types of practices. Anyway, I just received the court decision.

1:09:43 Thankfully, in this case, the judge has seen through the green mill process and awarded in favor of ORMAT. So hopefully that will go forward. Chances always are that that can be appealed, but we'll see. But I urge you all to get involved in these kinds of things.

1:10:15 because it's we either stand strong and stand together with these things or they will eventually take down the kinds of industries that we want here in our community and it can happen to anybody that has to go through the CEQA and EIR process. Don't these green male people make a business of filing these suits? It wasn't...

1:10:44 Personal necessarily in this suit, was it? No. No. Nothing personal, it's just they're using a very good tool, the CEQA EIR process, to their advantage, and it was never intended to be used that way. Anyway, that's my reports. If you want a copy of the judge's decision, I'd be more than happy to share that.

1:11:14 That's good news. Chair Brown, may I make one economic development comment in Rhonda's absence? Thank you. Thank you, Commissioner Harvey, for telling everybody how successful last night was. I'm so gratified at how this casual idea last October just mushroomed into this incredibly successful three-evening series.

1:11:35 It was good for business because, you know, a dead Tuesday night in town, there's a local restaurant that has a lot of business. The second evening we had, February 11th, we had a lot of technical glitches and they ended up putting in a whole new sound system to make a new mic, to make sure we didn't have these glitches again because they realized what they essentially have there is a little mini conference center with remote rooms but, you know, they can participate in the conference and it was so successful.

1:12:03 So successful and so many people have asked me to give talks on various topics that we're going to do it again in September and October. It's going to be Eastside Know-How, the sequel. So that's going to be great. And, you know, shoulder season, September and October probably are two most beautiful months. And I think this should be heavily advertised, marketed, you know.

1:12:25 So it was very successful. It was wonderful last night. All the speakers have been great, but last night you could hear them perfectly, so that was good. Terrific. Yeah, that was very good. Thank you. Main Street. I have a question on Main Street. Where do we stand after that workshop? I'm just really, I need to be brought up to date. So the council accepted the Main Street plan, so that's done. Okay.

1:12:50 So the next step, and kind of the quick wins, one of the quick wins was parking and snow management feasibility studies, and that's the process we're starting now. So Commissioner Tenney, you sent an email kind of talking about a little confusing how Noray was kind of mixing the existing project with the future. So it was a little confusing. Yeah, it was confused. So that's where we are. The Main Street project is accepted, and now we're kind of going to start working on those quick wins.

1:13:20 You know, one of them is, like I said, the snow management and parking feasibility. Other ones are sidewalks. We're applying for grants, as Haislip mentioned during his presentation. So we're looking to start moving forward with some of these quick wins, and hopefully we can make some changes on Main Street slowly but surely. We didn't have – Council had a very busy agenda, so they wanted to cut the workshop from two hours to one. We had no time to talk to them at all because of the presentation, and I really hope that we can –

1:13:49 Have joint meetings with council, in fact, Dan is still here, joint meetings with council more often because just to stay in touch, you know, and so we all are on the same page and can communicate with each other and it's a good way to do it. So I hope they can be regularly scheduled. Thank you. That's all I have to say about Main Street is where are we? Yeah, I think we need to do a little reformatting. You know, we had a zoning code committee.

1:14:16 As we all know, the zoning code as it currently stands is going to go before Council next week. Unfortunately, I'll be traveling next week, so perhaps Commissioner Harvey, you can go to that meeting just in case Council has any need. So, but we kind of have a combination between the Main Street and the zoning code. It's like another sequel, to use Elizabeth's word. So I don't know, do we even need a committee for this, do you think?

1:14:43 Because, you know, we are working on the shared parking. We do have to do our general plan amendment CEQA work. So do you think maybe we should just combine that with one? I think it would be good. We can add an item to your next meeting to allow you to reformat these committees and eliminate committees if necessary. So, yeah, we can do that at the next meeting. Perfect. And then, Commissioner Tenney, did you want to say anything about way? Wayfinding is ready to go to bid.

1:15:12 The engineering's done. Everything is done. We've got this great plan that we adopted and worked so closely with Merge to do, and it's just a matter of finding the money to do it because, you know, town project, prevailing wage, it's expensive, but we also want signs that are going to last. You know, you're not just going to put up some junk, but I'm so anxious for that to happen because not overnight, but over the month or whatever it takes to put them all up, it's going to change the character of our town. It'll just be incredible.

1:15:40 So I'm very anxious for that to happen. But Hayes was telling me he has a lot of trouble finding any kind of money for construction, which is really a problem. We always find money for planning, but when it goes in the binder on the shelf and we never see it on the ground, I just get hopelessly discouraged. And particularly for a wayfinding project, you know, the money that's coming forward really is for safety projects, pedestrian access projects, multimodal type projects, but just a wayfinding type project is a tough one to find funding for.

1:16:09 Is there any way to take that map of accidents and show all the places where people tried to turn left because they didn't know where they were going and find a nexus? Can't you be creative, Peter? And the signs that are actually within a project boundary, we can incorporate those as kind of incidental work as far as the project goes. But the timeline one is, to do that all at once is really the problem. Yeah. Oh, I hope we can find the money. It'll just...

1:16:37 It'll make us look like a real resort community that's, you know, friendly to visitors, other than just going in a shop and you're friendly to visitors, you know, when you enter town, you're friendly. So I know we have some big agenda items, but maybe when it calms down on our future meetings, but maybe we can have this as an agenda item, possible source funding for wayfinding, so at least we have it outlined. Oh, that'd be great. Three or four different possible ways that we can go back and recommend.

1:17:06 In a formal way to council. Okay. All right. But you, but I know you have your work program with your A priorities so you can finish those first. But I really would like to see us finish a program. Absolutely. All right. Such a good one. Are there any other commission reports? Then let's move on to the director report. Thank you. So just two quick items. As you recall, we, the zoning code update will limit the number of outdoor sales to only one sale.

1:17:37 Thank you. Thank you.

1:18:06 That's positive. And another item is at your next meeting, Pat Hayes from the Water District was going to give a presentation. He was here over the summer talking about water conservation. And so I just wanted to see if the commission, maybe not during this meeting, but after the meeting, could send me any topics that you'd like to hear him cover. He's prepared to, you know, talk about water conservation. He'll probably talk about

1:18:30 Thank you. Thank you.

1:18:59 We'll be meeting with the property owners on Old Mammoth in the next few weeks to talk about things that we're going to need to change. Essentially, we have to cut our water way back. And talk about options. We don't really have a lot of money to invest in relandscaping the street, but essentially most of the grass is going to probably go away and then convert some areas to a flower pot type thing, other areas to a hardscape type product.

1:19:28 Hard scape like pavers? Well, pavers, yeah, pavers are rather expensive, but something, you know, maybe it turns up being a concrete, different cover, embossed concrete or something. And then on Main Street, kind of the same thing, it's a little bit, you know, bigger area, so it's going to cost more, but we have the same kind of problem where we've got asphalt on both sides of the Moe Strip that creates a lot of evapotranspiration that is way above our Mawa, a lot of the amount of water to use.

1:19:58 So we'll be having a different discussion with different people along Main Street to talk about ideas of where we can eliminate grass and maybe have community gardens that help manage the flower areas or something like that on Main Street. We used to have that a number of years ago. I remember that. Some of the volunteers kind of went away, so the program went away. We planted grass, and here we are. We need to go back to less water, more.

1:20:27 Plants are drought tolerant. Is this the time to start our complete street with a bulldozer? Yeah. We're ready to go on Main Street. And then if the commission wasn't aware, we do have a couple projects that should be, funding should be approved next month. It takes a few years to get these kind of projects going, so 2018. But we do have the project in front of Mammoth View, so basically from Mountain Boulevard up to Minaret, a sidewalk on the north side.

1:20:56 That's funded, reconstructing those retaining walls, and includes street lights through that zone. And then the piece along 8050 to Fireside, Whiskey Creek, building a sidewalk along that section as well. That would be a great addition. So we can go back to water for a second. I was just in Montecito, and Montecito has a tremendous water problem because a lot of their wells are going dry. Wow.

1:21:21 You know, some of those people are doing some very interesting things. I don't even want to use the term artificial turf because it hardly explains. I mean, it looks so real. You have to, like, go touch it to see if it's not real. And I think it's pretty costly still, but, I mean, I think it's something that future, go forward, we should, like, at least put on the plate of considering. And the other thing that they're doing is some very interesting things with rock gardens. So we might just consider.

1:21:52 Some of those things in our future. All right, is there anything else? Along with that discussion, we did talk, you know, our commission just was interested in having a partnership in installing the artificial turf down Trails End Park near the new playground facility. And so the water district is looking at maybe a one-time grant program that would facilitate basically half of that cost. Pat's going to be taking that back to his board.

1:22:24 Seeing how that works. Doesn't it get awfully hot with the sun in the summer? They can be. This particular product is more of a playground grass, and so the rubber, the cushion part is actually underground. It doesn't have to have the rubber balls within the turf itself, so you don't also get the rubber balls all over your clothes or something if you're sitting on the grass, so it's a little bit different. It's definitely a little bit more expensive.

1:22:52 It should be a good product if we're able to install that. Is there any way along Old Mammoth Road or even on Main Street? Probably not. I'm thinking of shop owners in European cities. They're responsible for the sidewalk in front of their shop. I mean, that's what they do. They sweep it off, wash it down with a mop bucket, whatever, and just then the whole street's clean. Do you think there's any way to get people to participate in the extent of the sidewalk or whatever right in front of their business?

1:23:20 And I think that'll be part of the discussion, you know, trying to meet with at least all the ones that want to meet with us to talk about what can we do in front of your area. You know, we have got six blocks. They all could be a little bit different. It'd be nice if there was some repetition of some continuity in the type of landscape. But essentially we can try something, see if it works, and over the next few years maybe implement the program. We certainly don't have a half a million dollars to invest.

1:23:47 Yeah. And redoing the whole thing at once. But, you know, Hartstock last year, he bought all of those little baskets at the height. You can't really tell that they're all synthetic, but they look fairly nice and they're lightweight. They're not a safety issue. We were thinking we'd convert the, you know, we've got an irrigation system, so it could be converted to a bubbler type system and water pots so that somebody doesn't have to go out there and hand water everything. The hanging pot.

1:24:17 Not the hanging pots. No, the ones that stay on the ground, some linear type, like what they have in Bishop, but maybe something a little bit less expensive. Yeah. So those could be watered easily. The shop owners, though, would need to sew out and trim the flowers. To have flowers that look nice, it takes a little bit of effort. Oh, sure. Yeah. All right. Does anybody else have any other comments? Just once again, and just because Jen's come back, I really want to thank Jen and Sandra.

1:24:49 Thank you. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you.