Town Council
· recording 1 hr 55 min
Agenda
Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗
Transcript
273 passages · machine transcriptAutomatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗
0:00 Sure. Yes, yes, yes. All right, good evening, everybody. Welcome to the town, welcome to the town of Mammoth Lakes Town Council meeting for Wednesday, March 5, 2019.
1:26 14. Jamie, roll call please. Here. Here. Here. Here. If you would please rise and join our town clerk, Jamie Gray, in the Pledge of Allegiance. Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation, under God, indivisible, with liberty and justice for all.
1:57 All right. Welcome, everybody. This is the public comments section, the established time for any member of the public who wishes to address the council on any matter that does not appear on the agenda. Now it's time to come forward. Andrew Caster. Good evening, Town Council. Mr. Mayor. Andrew Caster with the Man of Track Club. Actually, I should correct myself. The ASICS Man of Track Club. The Man of Track Club secured a sponsorship corporate deal with ASICS America this last week. It was 14...
2:27 14-month process, but we finally got the deal done, so we're excited to bring in fresh faces and have a competitive contract with our peers out there and the rest of the country and training groups, so we're excited for that. So this Sunday is the A6 LA Marathon. Race starts at 7.15 for the women and 7.25 a.m. for the men. My wife, Dina, is going to be down there doing television for KTLA, so I would imagine she's going to be giving
2:54 Man with a plug, because we have actually two athletes racing from our club, Lauren Kleppen and Gabe Proctor, so they'll be racing down there, and I brought in, about two weeks ago, brought in ASICS to do a video shoot with us in the Man with Track Club, and I put together a 90-second spot that's going to be aired live.
3:15 During the marathon on Sunday morning. So it's basically a big 90-second commercial for Mammoth and the Mammoth Track Club. And I like to show that now. If you get up early on Sunday morning, you can watch it again. I encourage that. But I want to try and show you now here. Lights. Lights. We've had over a dozen Olympians on the team in the United States.
4:19 So I encourage the town, encourage town council, everybody in this room to get up early on Sunday morning and watch the marathon KTLA. So enjoy. Thank you. What's the name of the marathon? The LA marathon. LA. Yeah, Los Angeles marathon. Yeah, it's the 29th annual. Yep.
5:39 I'll set this up for the chief. I believe he's next. All right. Hi, Linda. Hi. Good evening, council members. That video is a hard act to follow, but I'm here to talk about the exciting election, so. I think Jamie passed out a copy of my letter that I have addressed to her. I'm just here to provide you with an update on two things. The first is that the Mono County Board of Supervisors has passed a resolution
6:12 Approving your request to consolidate the general municipal election with the June 3rd election. So that's official and it's done. So we will be running that election for you as we have in the past. The second thing is our deadline for completing the canvas, the official canvas. And as you know, the election code allows us 28 days after the election. That deadline is July 1st.
6:38 But as it's been typical that we're able to complete that canvas before the actual deadline, maybe within a week before that actual deadline, I can't say for sure when it will be finished because we never know what problems we might run into. But we've always been able to get it done ahead of time. And as soon as I have that official canvas completed, I will get a copy to Jamie so she can then bring it before you.
7:04 For your approval. So I just wanted to report on those two things and find out if you have any questions. You know, I do have a question for Jamie just for clarification and to be sure. If one or more sitting council members does not file for re-election by tomorrow, I mean by Friday, right, which is the 7th by 5 o'clock.
7:31 That extends the deadline for those who wish to file who are not incumbents or who would not be incumbents until the 12th, which is the following Wednesday at 5 o'clock. And does that apply if only one or all three of us do not? One or more of the incumbents do not file. One or more. Okay. Great. Thank you. I just wanted, for the benefit of the public, to clarify that. Thank you.
8:00 Okay, so if you have no questions, I will give the official paperwork to Jamie, and we'll take June 3rd by store. Great. Thank you, Linda. Joe. Thank you, Mr. Mayor. Joe Perrino here. I just wanted to just hear pretty much just kind of express what's been going on with the Supercross Series, and that's the motorcycle series. They're racing this motorcycle in stadiums.
8:34 Last weekend, they pretty much have, we raced at the Indianapolis, and literally, there was probably over 60,000 fans. That's just fans alone. That's not the teams. So you figure, you know, it's a good, it's definitely good enough to where now it's live on TV. So you can see this live on Fox 1 or Fox 2, which is basically on your, I think on your basic cable stations these days.
9:01 I really encourage everybody to really watch these races because this year is probably one of the most exciting races, years, series because there's so many different new up-and-coming athletes that are really, really stepping it up. Second thing was I noticed on YouTube there's some new sports coming out where they're actually making skate parks for ice skaters. So you've got these guys that are on hockey skates pretty much riding skate parks.
9:30 And doing pretty much everything that the skateboards are doing. So again, it's just one more new sport that's coming out that I feel that's something we can really maybe think about and maybe try to generate, pioneer to maybe draw people here. Again, it's just one more thing that we can put on the list for our extreme sports. Thank you. Thank you, Joe.
9:53 All right, podium's still open for those members of the public who wish to address the council on matters that do not otherwise appear on the agenda. And if there are none, we'll move to councilmember reports and additions. John, can you start with me? Well, thank you, Mr. Mayor. I have no additions, but I have two reports, if I may. The first one is attended the rural county planning team meeting last Tuesday, eight days ago. A couple of items of interest.
10:23 I think on council, Joe Bacon is familiar with Carl Benz, Fish and Wildlife Service, and Carl is retiring in April, and in a month he's going to be done. He's been around for a long time and has done some good work for an agency that sometimes isn't always that way. He's been very common sense attitude. So sorry to see Carl go.
10:53 They gave an update, Carl did, on what's referred to as the bi-state sage-grouse population. Had to field a number of questions. One of them was, and staff is aware of that, aware of this, and that is that there's a number of areas that we're trying to get excluded from consideration of a listing of the sage-grouse as an endangered species.
11:21 Because I would say it's very likely that that's going to happen shortly. The areas that we'd like to have excluded are roughly the airport, Whitmore, the recreation area, the Hot Creek Fish Hatchery and the Hot Creek Ranch and so forth in there.
11:46 Monroe County is asking for the town of Bridgeport to be excluded, which is in the area right now. These seem to be pretty simple common sense requests, and when Fish and Wildlife Service was asked if that was possible, the response was that they really didn't have time right now.
12:16 To process the requests so they didn't know if they were going to be able to do them or not. And of course that drew the ire of those in attendance that, you know, really you're going to shut down the town of Bridgeport for future development because they're in the sage-grouse habitat. I just mention that because that's the level, and we've talked about this subject before, but that's the level of
12:45 I think that the last meeting someone asked what the cost of, well let me back up real quick before I get to a national car table. I went down south last weekend, a week ago, and drove down by myself, and as I was driving down I was reminded of how fortunate we are in the eastern Sierra to have
13:18 The improvements that we have on US 395. We've talked about it before again, how we've been able to leverage funds to get those four-lane divided highways done. But you literally have from Levining to just north of Olancha-Cartego that's four-lane highway. So it's an easy, easy drive. Once you get through Olancha-Cartego, it opens up again into four-lane divided highway.
13:47 to the intersection where 395 comes in to the highway there, or 395 goes east there at that junction. The last major project in Ennio County that is on the horizon would be that section of Olancha-Cartago, and it was stated at the meeting that that is in fact currently a $100 million
14:20 And the construction of that project was scheduled at this time, and that can always change, it's scheduled to begin in 2018. So we're still four years away from the beginning of construction, probably a two-year construction, so it might be as late as 2020 before that's completed. But that's a big project, and it would be nice to have that done.
14:45 Also attended the meeting on Monday of this week at the fire station of the Great Base and Unified Air Pollution Control District. We have a new chairman of that group, and that's Ron Haynes of Alpine County. He's been on the APCD for two years now, and it's his turn to move into the chairmanship. A couple of items of interest are that
15:16 And this is an example, and there's at least a couple of attorneys in the room, and this is not against attorneys, but it is a good example of, at least me. It's a really good example, a case study, if you will, of how attorneys can drive things. People, you know, being on town council, we get complaints that staff runs the town council or the town attorneys.
15:47 So they really scrutinize.
16:17 Everything, every document and everything. And that's what they do. But it has resulted in a number of lawsuits and a number of claims against the Great Basin Air Pollution Control District. And, you know, we go to court, spend money, spend time, energy and so forth, and the judge makes the decision one way or the other. In recent years, the city of Los Angeles has had...
16:45 I believe it's five lawsuits against APCD, and all five of those lawsuits were decided in favor of Great Basin. So we're a big agency, lots of attorneys, spends lots of money, and it doesn't win anything. It's just like part of the program. There's also five claims against Great Basin by LADWP, and
17:14 Four of those five claims were recently dropped by a single judge who made a decision that the claims against APCB were not valid. So what has happened in recent months, just within this last year, is that three members of the Great Basin Board have met with two members of the City of Los Angeles Board.
17:42 And these five members, without attorneys and without staff, have worked through a number of contentious issues and have resolved them to where they're no longer going to court. So I applaud both the City of Los Angeles and the APCD for moving in that direction. Oh, by not going to court and not having a number of
18:12 Attorney's working hours, of course, it saves the taxpayer, not the taxpayer, the ratepayer for water in the city of Los Angeles, arguably millions of dollars. The largest item that was on our agenda, it was a great item, I think, for the Town of Mammoth Lakes. We have, the Town of Mammoth Lakes, because of our cinders, because of a number of cars and exhaust and wood stoves, has been out of compliance with federal.
18:43 Regulations on the amount of particulates that we have in the air. So our staff, the Town of Mammoth Lakes staff, made a request to APCD to have that changed because we've been meeting the standards as we've tested by the steps that we've taken, the street sweepers and our wood stove regulations, things like that. So at the meeting,
19:12 It was requested, it was a public hearing, and it was requested to have the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency redesignate Mammoth Lakes from a non-attainment to an attainment basis based on the monitoring that we've done. It wasn't passed at the public hearing only because the EPA, which regulates the particulates,
19:40 It had a few minor changes that they wanted to take care of. So it's staff recommendation. We've already passed it as a councilman, but staff recommendation from the APCD to approve it. So once we approve it, that will be done. So that's a big step for Mammoth Lakes to go from non-attainment to attainment. And again, not to repeat myself, but I think it shows the...
20:04 Excellent efforts that the town has made, both in wood stove and cinder, cinders to take care of those. That's it. John, thank you. Yes, thank you, Mr. Mayor. I just have one note, and that's that I attended a Mammoth Lakes Tourism meeting yesterday, and they are going to be holding an open house on April 29th at the Edison Theater, so really open to the public. Anybody that has
20:34 Questions, concerns, comments, anything like that about Mammoth Lakes Tourism, TBID, and other things that Mammoth Lakes Tourism is doing, you know, how our money is spent and whatnot. There will be an open house there just so people can gain a better understanding of how the organizations run and where your monies are going. So just wanted to share that. That's all. Thank you. Michael. All right, Tim, to say me, I was going to share the same thing, so that's all.
21:03 A couple of items. First of all, a week ago Friday, I had the opportunity to meet with our lobbyist, Bob, what's his last name? White. White. White. And he got a tour of the airport and a discussion about the issues dealing with the FAA and the terminal expansion. Also took him up to see the main lodge so he'd understand what the land exchange was all about.
21:27 Which is also a federal issue. And finally, I had the opportunity to bring him up to date on the discussion that carried over from the Wednesday night of our last meeting about the Forest Service not having the money to have the capacity to help us with our plans in the recreation area. So he was brought up to speed on all those three items. Then also, while we're speaking of MLR, we have started into the Formation Committee meetings. It's a
21:55 Rigorous schedule, essentially every other week. The next meeting is the 17th, which is a Monday, 3 p.m. here in Suite Z. And then finally, I've had some questions from constituents, and I was wondering if there's consensus on council to invite the Water District General Manager here to talk to us about what they foresee coming in the future, water restrictions, or whatever else that we might be facing. Is there consensus?
22:23 To ask them to make a presentation? I think it's a great idea. Okay. Yeah. All right. Thank you. That's it. Other than MLR, which Mayor Pro Tem Bacon has already spoken of, I attended the monthly housing meeting, Mammoth Lakes Housing. There will be a presentation coming forth on the 19th, our next meeting, with respect to a grant application, an application for free money. So, that's all I have.
22:51 Takes us to reports from commissions and or departments. Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development. Just a note, the council, the zoning code update will be coming before you at the next meeting for a public hearing. So that's exciting to have that almost done. And also the council authorized staff to begin work on
23:23 Floor Area Ratio and Density. And so just a heads up that we are working on that project. We anticipate, we've engaged a consultant. They're doing research on what it means to shift the way we calculate density from rooms or units per acre to a strict floor area ratio calculation. So we're anticipating that in the next few months they'll have some direction for us on what that means, what that means for the overall density of the town, and then we would make decisions at that point on how to move forward.
23:52 So that's all I have. Any questions? No, thank you. No, thank you, Sandra. Stuart Brown, Recreation Manager. Good evening, Mayor, members of Council, staff, and our community. Just a few updates. Bring you up to speed on a few projects and programs that we're working on. The first one, February 23rd, the Mammothites are enclosed for the season. Happy to report that the facility operated without any major issues, thanks to some very timely measure of our funds.
24:25 It was only closed for four days due to weather and finished, we think, approximately about 10% above our revenue projections for the season. So great effort. The facility would now be converted to a roller rink slash kind of entertainment center and will open for the summer season on June 21st. So that's our kind of program with that facility.
24:46 A few new programs that the recreation department is offering is drama classes for both adults and youth up at the community centre. That's every Monday and Wednesday evening. Pick up basketball is now offered at the high school gym on midweek evenings. That's kind of a Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday session. 7.30 to kind of however long everyone wants to pound the boards. It's only $4 a session. And our youth sports funding applications for our youth groups out there close on March 21st.
25:15 The other major program that we're beginning is March 20th, and that's kind of what we're calling our Plan Your Parks program. It's a recommendation, if you remember from our Parks and Recreation Master Plan, and a significant work effort over the last 12 to 18 months of our Recreation Commission to create a specific master plan for the Whitmore Recreation Area, Mammoth Creek Park East and West, the community centre, which has the playground and our tennis courts, as well as the bell-shaped parcel.
25:45 We have two workshops facilitated by Verde Design, who have done previous work with us before. They're coming on March 20th and April 17th. Both those workshops are from 4 to 7 p.m. in the Mammoth Lakes Community Centre, which is located on Forest Trail, corner of Minaret. And yes, we will be serving light snacks and refreshments. So come along.
26:11 We're really seeking broad community input. We really want to hear what the community has to say about their programming priorities for our parks and also to look at our existing parks and how to maximise the opportunities at those facilities. We have some posters available. I've left them at the back of the room. I've put one on the back of the wall. It's on our homepage, front and centre. It's in the Mammoth Times. It's a sheet. We have postcards. We have English and Spanish version as well on our website, mammothrecreation.com. So I really want to encourage everybody to come out
26:40 Have their say and help us plan our parks. Until we go. That's all I have. Any questions? John. Stuart, I'm glad you brought up the ice rink. Just because I've been thinking about it all the time. I drive by it, of course, every day. Every day. But I think the reason I wanted to bring it up is because the ice rink is something that I think is taken for granted by a lot of people, including the council. That's a major facility.
27:10 We'd like more uses. That's fine. But Stuart Brown has accepted the responsibility for keeping that park open and not only with employees to staff it, but to make sure the ice is as good as it can be and the equipment is running. So I just recognize it's a big responsibility. I want you to know that I appreciate your reference on that. It's very appreciated. Thank you. Thank you. Thank you, John. Any other questions?
27:40 All right. Thank you. Any other department heads or commission members who wish to speak? Go, Jamie. Just because I think it bears repeating, the deadline for the nomination for the election of three town council members is on this Friday, March 7th at 5 o'clock. If one or more of the incumbents do not file nomination papers, then the deadline will be extended to next Wednesday, March 12th at 5 o'clock. And also for the public to please note that the town offices are closed to the public on Fridays except for by appointment only.
28:10 So please contact me, Town Clerk, Jamie Gray, if you need to make an appointment. Thank you. Would you mind closing the cover to that? I know, I feel like everybody's back. Jamie, are you going to be there until 5? Yeah. And the town offices are 760-934-8989, and I am at extension 267. 267, thank you. All right.
28:43 That takes us to agenda item number one, which is an introduction. Sandra, I imagine you're going to do that. Thank you. I would like to take this opportunity to introduce our new staff member, Nolan Bobroff. He's a planning technician. He was at Inyo County for a year and a half before this, so we stole him away from Inyo County. We're happy to have him here. He's been in town for five years, managed a couple restaurants before he started working at Inyo County. He has planning degrees.
29:16 And he'll be handling our planning permits for us, building permits, counter questions, and assisting staff with other projects. Welcome, Nolan. Welcome. All right, thank you. That takes us to the consent agenda items 2, 3, and 4. Before we start that, I forgot that I was supposed to mention that if anyone wanted to be on the distribution list for the MLR agenda packets to let Dan Holler know. I'd forgotten that in the council member reports.
29:58 There will be a lot of paper and a lot of meetings. Yes. All right, thank you. That takes it to consent agenda. Items 2, 3, and 4. Any member wish to pull any item? I'd like to pull item 3. Do you have a motion on 2 and 4? Make a motion, Council approve agenda items 2 and 4. Second. Okay, you've been a motion and a second on 2 and 4. January roll call. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes.
30:28 Yes, motion passes 5-0. It takes us to number 3. Matthew. Yeah, I just wanted to bring up an item for discussion on this. I know the Chief's brought it up before, and it sounds as though the department needs a vehicle pretty bad. I'm just wondering what the thoughts are if we get this new vehicle, because we're putting so many miles on it, if we can keep a new vehicle within town, just so we aren't putting, you know, so many thousands of miles on it driving back and forth to...
30:58 Where a lot of folks live outside of Mammoth. I'd like to see us maintain the vehicle for those emergency type uses. The new one? Yes, the new one. We can do that. Our two newest cars, we made a point of making sure they're not assigned anybody to take them all. In fact, we did have somebody doing that. We pushed cars for that specific reason to get the mileage down on our newer cars. What that does is the older cars end up getting running the mileage quicker, but I think that makes no sense.
31:27 Okay. That's all. I like that idea. So do I. Thank you. I gave a motion. Just one other quick question. Dan, I think we went over this before. Where is this being funded out of? The funding comes out of our vehicle replacement fund. Each year we set aside funds to replace vehicles, so this has been built up over time. It's there for that purpose. It doesn't impact the general fund. It doesn't impact our reserve for economic uncertainty.
31:58 It is reserve dollars specifically earmarked and set aside each year for the replacement of vehicles. So the police department allocation has dollars set aside for that purpose for the replacement of vehicles. So there's no impact on the general fund operating side of the budget. And that's something that all other towns and cities and counties do? It's a normal practice. I would say Mammoth is ahead of a lot of them in terms of some of the dollars they're able to set aside into that fund.
32:27 We do a lot for our snow removal equipment. You can't afford to have that go down when we get to another big snow year. But it's a very common practice to set aside funds, restrict it, and hold it for that purpose. Dan, I just wanted to state that when I held this over, and for Chief, too, when I held this over before, it hadn't snowed much. And since that time, we've had between four and six feet of snow on the mountain, which has been able to build up a
32:56 Apparently a five-day-foot base right now, so the concerns that I had have been addressed by Mother Nature. We have the snow to string people here. That last storm was very high. Yes. All right. I'm looking for a motion from a council member to approve number three. Mr. Mayor, I'll make a motion that council approve item number three with the caveat that the new vehicle remain in town limits for...
33:26 For police use. You mean not be used as the one that's taken home at night because it could still take somebody up to Bridgeport. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. Just want to make sure. Okay. Motion and a second for the discussion, if not a couple.
33:45 Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes, motion passes 5-0. It takes us to agenda item number 5, public, this is a public hearing which is entitled to adopt the resolution regarding the 2014-15 Recreation Department fee schedule amendments. I will open the public hearing and call for presentation from staff. Stu? Thank you, ma'am. Thank you, ma'am.
34:13 So the Recreation Department, as per the Municipal Code, Chapter 3.39, conducted an annual review of the town's fees and services charged by the Recreation Department and presented those fees, proposed fees, to the Recreation Commission on February 4, 2014. In your agenda bill, we've provided a summary of the fee amendments. We've broken them down by various programs and facilities.
34:41 The major change really was the impact to our facilities that haven't really seen a change in fees in probably several years, we think probably 10 plus years. So really what we've done here is we've averaged out the CPI index over that period of time and adjusted those fees accordingly by approximately 20%, but in many instances it's only a $2 increase to a lot of our fees and we're just trying to keep them current.
35:08 And the same could be said for the youth camps that we provide as well. You can see they've just gone up by a dollar a day in many instances. Those fees don't really get amended that often. Whitmore Pool, CPI was 1.2%, so it went up by 25 cents. Mammoth Eye Shrink rose by a dollar per session. And again, the pricing strategy there is really just to consider the CPI change over that period of time.
35:38 But also when we did some analysis with those fees, the average adult admission for ice rinks in California was, we looked at about 25 ice rinks, was $8.50. So we're just trying to be comparable to those resorts. So that was the strategy there, so it was kind of taking those into account. No change to the Mammoth Roller Rink. You can see a slight increase to the softball league.
36:05 But again, the major change was just the $2 increase to our facility use fees at our parks. Special event fee was the last one. This one hasn't been changed in several years in looking at it. We had that standard event permit fee of $549. So if someone came in with a new permit for a special event fee, the fee was $549, which really I don't think was very realistic. So we're just...
36:33 Recommend that we replace that with one flat fee of the $190, which is an increase of 20% from the current renewal fee now of $158, which again is consistent with that CPI increase in the last decade. So the Recreation Commission reviewed the amended fee schedule, they passed a motion adopting the fee schedule and they're presenting it to the Town Council for their review and adoption. Questions?
37:02 Stuart, I've got a quick question. Was there any discussion on the ice rink on increasing the fees even more to kind of, you know, raise some more money to get a lid on this thing so we can extend it, you know, the use? I think the strategy that we've tried to do here is just really look at the CPI. I mean, that's what we've really done. And then just to bring it, like I said, as a strategy against other comparable ice rinks in California. So that was kind of our strategy. We tried to keep it really simple.
37:32 And it is a public facility. So again, you know, we have variables that we have to consider for our locals versus residents. We don't have a local resident rate. You know, a lot of facilities do. You know, if you look at community centers, we don't. You know, we eliminated that two years ago, and we just had an advanced purchase with our camps. But for our facilities, it's just one flat fee. We just want everybody to enjoy the experience that we provide. Generally on the fee there, you would have...
38:01 Put in a future capital project in terms of part of that fee cost element. We've looked at the cover on the ice rink as an option to extend the use of it. A shade structure, for example, was about a $250,000 expense, and that would add probably three to four weeks on either side of the season, which would give us additional usage in dollars going into the facility as well. You know, a hard lid would be about a million plus.
38:30 We've actually had that dialogue internally looking how do we fund the potential of a shade structure, expand the winter, also give a better operational element for the summer and the heat. So that's out there being looked at. There's some options that we can pursue, Measure R and some other internal funding sources that we've started to look at. The challenge there, it really isn't.
38:52 Doesn't really drive from these fees because these here would probably cover our lease payment first and those types of issues that we deal with. But about $250,000 or so is what's necessary to extend our current seasons. Okay. Thanks. How's the thing? You know, we have to be real careful about it. I don't know what the price point is. I don't know what they are. People think it's too much because if you take a family of four, for example.
39:22 What seems like a nominal fee for one, but a low fee for one may not be for four. I don't know what the answer is there, because I need to say I haven't done a study, but I'm sensitive to it. Yeah, I'm just trying to figure out how we can get longer use out of it. Well, and you know, it gets better use in the bad snow years, so if we have a good snow year, the uses will drop just because everybody will be doing other sports, so I don't know. Unless you have a lay on it. Well, yeah.
39:52 We'll get there. We'll get there. Yep. Okay. If there are no other questions of staff, I will open the public hearing up for testimony from any member of the public, either in favor of or against the proposal that is on the table, which is to increase the fees, the parks and recreation proposed or fee schedule overall.
40:23 Seeing none, close public hearing, call for counsel deliberation and a vote. Any questions or comments? I'm supportive of the approach. It seems really reasonable to me and probably overdue. I'm supportive. Yeah, I don't really see any reason to buck it. What did he say? Are you not supportive? No, I am. I'm supportive. Hearing no opposition, I'll move we approve option one. Second.
40:56 Okay, there's been a motion and a second to approve option one, which is to approve the resolution that is in our packet to increase the fees as indicated.
41:05 If there isn't any other discussion, roll call, please, Jim.
41:08 Councilmember Eason?
41:08 Yes.
41:09 Councilmember Eason?
41:10 Yes.
41:10 Councilmember Eason?
41:11 Yes.
41:11 Councilmember Eason?
41:12 Yes.
41:12 Councilmember Eason?
41:13 Yes.
41:13 Yes.
41:14 Motion passes 5-0.
41:15 Thank you.
41:16 All right, policy matter, agenda item number six, accept the annual financial statements and audit for fiscal year ending June 30th, 2013.
41:25 You know, I got to about page 49 and I had an email to Dan and he says, Can you summarize this for me in lay terms? And sorry, Cindy, I didn't send the email to you, but it could have been at like 4 o'clock in the morning. I don't know. All right. We'll kind of team tag through it, so. That's great. Thank you. Good evening, Council. The agenda item before you is a request to accept the town's annual financial report. It's a...
41:53 Snapshot, a picture in time as of June 30, 2013, what our financial position was. The report, the statements are presented fairly in all material respects. The importance here is for management and outside agencies. The bond rating companies look at it. Granting agencies look at it. We have a single audit.
42:19 And that kind of gives an overview and a full picture of
42:49 I think it's important as we start to get through these audits, a lot of the purpose of them almost anymore in some of the announcements from the Governmental Accounting Standards Board has been to restructure these more for your bond agencies, financing agencies, and financial institutions. And I think they've actually made them to where they're less understandable from the basic public or policy bodies when they look at them.
43:18 I think there's key elements as they come in and do the audit. And as Cindy mentioned, if you look at the first couple pages from the letter from the accountant on page six and seven, they give an opinion. So we always look at that to make sure that we have a unqualified opinion. There's no issue with that to say this does represent the financial picture of the town.
43:42 The same thing, the Single Audit Act is very important that we have no findings there or that puts you into a different category in terms of what you have to do for future grants. And so you want a clean opinion on your single audit also. You jump to the very last page of the audit. Sorry, Mr. Mayor, if you didn't get that far. But page 75 is kind of a summary of one of the single audits that I would look at to say, do we have any issues that could impact future grants?
44:11 I saw that. I did not know what it meant. Yes, that's...
44:39 I assume it's a good thing to say unqualified and unreported. Exactly. Those are the two words you're looking for. A qualified audit means that they actually have found things in it that would qualify their opinion versus there's nothing to qualify it. It's kind of a backwards language from my perspective as well in trying to lead through this. So that's a good positive element for us. I want to highlight just a couple things. If you look through here, like on page 18,
45:09 of the document. It kind of gives you the overview of our funds. Again, it's a snapshot of funds in time of June 30. We've already brought this to you as part of the mid-year update, and so a lot of the policy decisions you've already made, but rating agencies will look at this. They'll take a look at the general fund and say, okay, walk through me the unassigned fund balance number. What does that mean? And so we'll actually send them a very detailed list of...
45:37 The components of fund balance, be that cash, be it land, other assets, the interfund loans, and so we'll walk through those types of issues with them. Same thing here, you may have people look at Measure R and you and say, hey, it looks like you've got a million dollars sitting in here. And on that one, it'll say restricted. And so you look at that, which means by law, those funds are restricted. They can't be used for general government purposes. And so...
46:04 Those are a snapshot in time. Some of the money is committed. Some of it's, you know, because of the processes we're in and those types of things that'll come through that. So this is kind of a big picture overview from a rating agency. We've actually been working with S&P the last couple of months and they're updating the town's bond rating. So we've been providing them this information. I think it's all, it's a positive story we're telling them. So hopefully that helps our rating. Or I think we're to double B plus or minus, I forget, with this stable outlook.
46:33 The other element, kind of a fiscal year ending snapshot, and this is on pages 18 and 20 again, kind of, it walks through that and the whole financial position of the town and the change, and they'll call up and ask, what was the change in assets or why didn't something go up or down, and when we did a forgiving a couple of the interfund loans between the airport and the town, that actually dropped our dollar amount here, but it really didn't impact our
47:03 Financial Security. And so that was a question we would answer for the rating agencies of why did it look like we had a decline in net position. Our case is actually a good thing in terms of eliminating internal debt. The other piece that I take a look at is on page 40 through 44, and it's our debt structure. That gives you a feel for what is outstanding from the town from a debt obligation that walks through.
47:30 The different certificates of participation we have out there. It walks through other loans that we have incurred. There's some state water resources loans that we've incurred. And then page 42 walks through the settlement and the lawsuit judgment. So we're presenting all of that information in terms of the debt structure of the town. And frankly, Mammoth Lakes has a relatively low amount of debt outside of the lawsuit judgment.
48:00 It's actually been managed very well in terms of the type of debt that's outstanding to the organization. Outside of that one, from a rating agency standpoint, the town actually looks very solid. That one we spent a lot of time. We've built in a payment plan. We have a five-year plan that will end up being a rolling five-year plan to make those payments. And again, that becomes a favorable discussion when you're talking to rating agencies for...
48:27 Future obligations or whatever the town may wish to look at. We've actually been looking at the potential of refunding some of the debt and taking advantage of lower interest rates. That somewhat is tied back to what our rating is, so we're back and forth with that. But it's an ongoing process. You look at that and say if you can save money like refinancing a home, you don't add any term or length or those issues, but you reduce your interest costs. It's a positive element for the town. So those would be the key elements from a staff level walking through and looking at this.
48:55 Other than some of the textual elements in the management analysis and discussion. Those are elements that we take a look. These things are important to us in terms of as we look forward and try to get a handle on some of the numbers and compiles in this format. Then the last area is the supplemental information. If you walk through that, it gives you some good comparisons to budgets and actuals. If you like that level of detail. With that, we're glad to answer any questions.
49:25 Council members may have to add. It's a lot of numbers and stuff, and like I say, I think the way we have to present this to meet rating agency stuff is actually has less impact to our community and policymakers than what audits used to have. But you're after that unqualified opinion, which we do have on the audit. So on pages 41 and 42, I just want to point out how impressed I am with what is really not here, and that is
49:56 We don't have a whole long list of obligations with the exception, of course, of the big one, which is on page 42. And specifically, we've got these tiny little balances left on three loans. One, to finance the water system and the taxi lane extension at the airport. Two, for the workforce housing loans that...
50:24 That's pretty impressive.
50:49 The smallness of the outstanding debt of the town is a real strong asset, frankly, for us in dealing with rating agencies. And of those that I've just named before, three of them are going to be gone within two years, and then the one for the bell parcel will continue on for another, I guess, ten years. Yeah, that's great. Thank you. So hopefully that helps quickly in some overview. I have a question. You know, we did talk a bit before.
51:17 You know about our obligation on the $2 million a year and really it coming out to 5% interest. I mean have we done or should we consider really looking further into perhaps some sort of federal funding or I mean if these banks are able to get lending at 2% or whatever the number is I mean I would think that a municipality that has avoided something like we avoided.
51:45 Might be able to qualify for something, even at 4%, I mean, it's probably going to put us at a 20%, 25% benefit over the long term. And I'd have to believe that there must be a way somewhere out there, some sort of grant funding from the federal government. We're obligated to review at minimum twice a year and actually report to the parties in terms of the ability to refinance the debt or look at a financing option. I haven't seen anything at a federal level.
52:11 I've talked to a financial advisor on some of the issues, and as what is truly a general fund obligation for us to do that at this point, the interest rates are probably about 6%, 6 to 7, just in a general obligation type bond. In terms of looking at some of the other types of potential programs out there, I have not pursued that, but I'd be glad to ask around. I don't imagine it's something they're advertising out there.
52:40 I mean, if there were some sort of disaster relief type funding out there, I would assume that we'd fall into that some category in some way, but I mean, just 1% would make such an enormous difference. In terms of legal lawsuit, those are really tough to justify it for other means. Yeah, no, I understand. It just seems like it could be something, but it might be worth looking. All right, other questions, Jo. Dan, you mentioned that our
53:10 This is reviewed by the bond rating companies. Do we have the opportunity to go back and ask them to improve our rating based on this report? We ask them to, well, jokingly, we always think we should be at least a double A plus, but just under the feds. Yes, we actually visit with them and ask them to update the rating to look at it. There's actually some prohibitions on what you can truly say here, take a look at this.
53:41 We want a higher rating. They have two different arms that do that. That came out of the last real estate process. But they do take a look at that, and we've been upgraded once, and I would anticipate, based on the information that we've given them, we have the potential for one more notch bump, which could take us up to an A-. That would be a really nice place to be, frankly. So we do make that request. We do ask them, do you need any additional information? And we do try to present as much information as we can that
54:11 And I have a second one. Even though this says audit on it, it's not
54:42 Really an audit. It's a review of financial statements, correct? It is an audit. Well, by definition. Okay, but earlier this week, you and I had a conversation about the need for an internal control audit. Can you share that with the rest of the council? Yeah, because what we do with the, you know, there's a number of levels of audits. I mean, there's a national standards that auditors utilize to do this type of audit.
55:10 They're making, they are putting their stamp on it as a certified auditor that it's unqualified payment. The other side of that, you can go down to a lower level and say we want to do an internal controls audit. How do we process things? How do we make sure we have checks and balances in place? Which is, it's a lower, more detailed level audit that definitely can be done. Both internal and external people do that and you can come in.
55:37 We can go down and look at an audit level for a particular departmental area, operational area. I've done areas where we'll do petty cash audits down to that level. But in an operational audit, I think what you're looking at would be a next phase for us to take a look at, especially when we're looking at updating our finance software and our system. How do we take a look at our internal controls and processes that we can re-engineer and change and make us more efficient, more effective?
56:06 And if we have areas that need to be improved to identify those, identify ways to do that that we're able to do financially and walk through that. And that internal control audit would be a more detailed focus and wouldn't be just looking at your financial picture but your processes. And that's definitely a step in the direction we go as we look at updating our financial system too. It would be a good tie-in to do those types of things together as we enhance what we do.
56:37 Other questions? Thank you. I feel a little bad about my brand. A lot of information. Indeed. All right. Jamie, do you need a motion and an approval to accept this? Or what's the formality here? Oh, sorry. You're right. Thank you. Members of the public wish to speak to
57:05 The audit that is before us. Any questions or comments? On page, I think it's seven, Ted Carlton the sheet. Maybe it's six. There's this lawsuit, the lawsuit judgment, in parentheses it has 11.3 million. What is that? Tell me what that is.
57:34 What does that represent? Is that the total expense of like legal time or initial payments or it's under governmental activities, under expenses, page seven, maybe two-thirds down. Is it handwritten seven or the printed? Printed seven, handwritten 11. Oh, yeah. The lawsuit judgment? Yeah, that's an 11-12 number. I believe that was the cost.
58:02 Everything that was put in there. Everything up until that point. No, during 11-12. During that fiscal year. During that fiscal year, that was the amount of money that was expended on the law. So do we then consider the price of the judgment 11.3 plus the 29?
58:23 Realistically. Well, in terms of that total cost of the town, you mean? Yeah. Yeah, you would have the 11-12 number and then whatever was suspended in the year prior or the year after. Okay. Then the second question is, realistically, you know, I appreciated your dissembling, Mr. Manager, Mr. Holler. What is the realistic time frame to attain a bond rating that's actually worthy of looking for a refi? I mean,
58:52 Is it really realistic to look for an A-minus overnight, or are we looking at five years? I mean, in other words, I think Councilmember Lehman brings up an excellent point. When are we going to finally be able to kind of get a better interest rate on this loan? Is it five years? I mean, what's your estimate? From the lawsuit judgment one, that's tough to call because of the amount and the time. You're probably out on a couple years, three to five years, to get a good rating for that type of debt because that's a general obligation type.
59:22 Debt, it's difficult. And looking at some of the other smaller debt refinancings, there's a couple of those you may be able to do actually with a private placement currently and get a better interest rate without the bond rating. There's other, there's some other mechanism to do that. The lawsuit judgment will be a tough nut in terms of a rating for that. How does, how, what type of winner we have and what type of revenues in other words?
59:51 If we have a normal year or an above normal year revenue generation wise with TOT, I mean, I'm guessing we could generate a couple of million or maybe even more above budget projections and I'm wondering how much that, how, if our RU was 4 million instead of 1.5 or 2 million, does that have any impact? That helps when they look at your stable outlook and they look at the history. One of the challenges we have with the economics of the town is
1:00:20 The ratings will take a look at it. We're heavily dependent on tourism and other nature. So unless you have a long series of great years, it's always one of those, it'd be nice to see more diversification, which would always hold our rating down somewhat. Thank you. Okay, other questions from members of the public? If not, we would like to have a formal motion accepting the audit.
1:00:51 I'll move we approve option one, which is to accept the annual financial report. Second. Okay. There's been a motion and a second. No additional discussion, I see. Well called, please. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 5-0. Thank you, Dan, and also, Cindy, for that. You know, we've been through some pretty hard times.
1:01:20 Those of us who've been on council here, I'm not suggesting that suddenly we're out of the woods by any means. The numbers are what they are, but there's some encouraging things in there. We'll see whether my view changes when we get into the budget discussion. All right. That takes us to number seven. Receive and file a report regarding the police department's statistical crime trends.
1:01:49 Yes, thank you. Good evening. Back in early January, I issued a news release that gave the results of a comparison of 2013 Part 1 crimes to the previous year, and it resulted in a 27% reduction in Part 1 crime last year over the previous year, which is significant. And the town manager asked me to do a more in-depth review going back multiple years.
1:02:18 And to look at more than just crime and prepare a report for you. So you have that in your agenda packet. And what I'm going to do is go through a summarized version of that when I hit some of the highlights. It's a 10-year look at staffing, crime and arrests, traffic collisions, traffic enforcement, and the overall incidents handled by the police department. What I think is most significant right up front is that there's a lot of good news in this data.
1:02:46 We've been getting a little more good news than we have in the last few years, as you just mentioned, and this is another picture that looks good. First, I think it's worth talking about police staffing. You know, we've been up and down, and this chart, and I'm sorry the color isn't better, it shows in blue and red both sworn and civilian staffing. And we had a peak back in 2006 through 2008 when we had a total of 28 employees, 23 sworn officers of all ranks and five civilians.
1:03:19 And then the recession hit, and as a result of that and budget issues the town was facing, the number started to drop every year. And then, of course, last year, as a result of the lawsuit settlement, the police department went from 17 sworn to 10, and we have picked one up. So as of today, we have a total of 14. I thought we caught that. It's 11 sworn, not 12 on the very last column there.
1:03:50 And the town manager pointed that out, and I, yeah, it wasn't fixed. So anyway, we have a total of 11 sworn in 14, which is a pretty substantial reduction over where we were at our peak back several years ago. This next slide shows part one crime. And part one crime, they're all listed there on the right. Those essentially are, those are crimes that were reported to the FBI. They do statistical data collection throughout the country, and they're standardized.
1:04:18 And they would be typically known and considered crimes that have a victim. Part two crimes are the other ones. Those would be narcotics violations, liquor law violations, DUI, being drunk, that type of thing. So what we look at and what's most important is part one crime. And it shows a significant decrease over several years, really starting in 2009. I'm sorry, starting in 2010.
1:04:47 And that's consistent with the nationwide trend over the past 10 years that crime throughout the country has been dropping in most communities. I just read recently that the city of Los Angeles just experienced their 11th consecutive year of crime reductions over the previous year. What I don't have showing here but what is in your report is a comparison of last year to the 10-year average all of these years.
1:05:16 In 2013, our total Part 1 crimes was 40% below the average Part 1 crimes for the last 10 years. So that's a significant and positive trend. Every one of those crimes, those Part 1 crimes, with the exception of robbery, were below the 10-year average. And it's important to note, you know, we don't get a lot of crime, so significant, fairly substantial swings are not unusual. Last year, we had
1:05:45 Five robberies. The average is 3.9. Given our population, five robberies. And robberies are anything from the traditional, somebody comes up and says, you know, give me your money or your life. We don't get many of those. Two, somebody commits a theft of beer in a liquor store and the clerk tries to stop them and the suspect punches out the clerk or struggles with them. That technically is a robbery.
1:06:13 When you see five robberies, it's really very insignificant. Related to crime is arrests. This slide shows the total of arrests, both misdemeanors and felonies. Again, felonies are the blue on the bottom. The red show misdemeanor arrests. It shows a reduction starting in 2009. Part of that would be attributed to the fact less crime will result in less arrests. The other part of it is fewer officers will result in fewer arrests.
1:06:45 Misdemeanor arrests. Felonies, they're not going to make much difference. So fewer officers on the street means fewer officers initiated arrests for crimes like DUI, narcotics violations, and other Part II crimes, but they're not reflected in that other data on crime. So my explanation on the reduction in arrests would be based on fewer officers to initiate activity and less crime. Now let's look at traffic.
1:07:19 We only report, in this report, I've only included three types of traffic collisions. That's those involving a DUI driver, hit and run traffic accidents, and those that have an injury or fatality. The reason we don't do other typical fender bender accidents is there's no legal requirement to complete those traffic collision reports. We do some, many police departments just don't take them under any circumstances. We will, if one of the parties requests one.
1:07:47 And we have people available to do it. So adding those type of traffic collisions in would skew the data because it would not be a true reflection of the what are called property damage only collisions. And again, in all three types of traffic collisions, well, let me talk about fatalities. We've only had one fatality in the last 10 years. That was back in 2010. And if you recall, that was an individual who up in the bluffs ran off the road in a blizzard. He missed a turn.
1:08:16 His truck was discovered a couple of days later. I think part of the reason why is, you know, if you read the paper, Sierra Wave today, or there was a news release put out by the CHP, there was a fatality up on 395 and Lundy Lake Road. That was speed. Someone was driving 100 miles an hour, didn't stop for the stop sign. We don't have streets that result in a lot of high speeds.
1:08:43 So that's why we don't have a lot of injury collisions. Most of our collisions occur when the weather's bad, and it's like bumper cars. Somebody slides in the ice, bounces off of somebody else, relatively minor damage. Again, I think this data is consistent with nationwide trends. DUI in general has been reduced. DUI arrests are way down across the country. I mean, they're like 50% of what they were 15 years ago.
1:09:11 That's because of groups like NAD. When I started driving, and I know some of you started driving, being arrested for DUI was almost a badge of honor. That's not the case anymore. Penalties are really high. It's no longer socially acceptable. So designated driver programs and the like have reduced DUI incidents and DUI crashes. Cars are a lot safer than they used to be.
1:09:36 So people are able to either survive or walk away from a collision without injury that in older model cars would not have been the same situation. The hit and run reduction, which is we have more hit and runs than the other two types of collisions. I'll take it back. We have more hit and run. A number of years ago, the vehicle code was changed.
1:10:05 And studies have shown consistently that people that are unlicensed, either have never had a license or are driving on a suspended or revoked license, have a very high incident of hit-and-run collisions. Or in other words, a high percentage of the hit-and-run accidents that occur, the suspect is somebody who has never been licensed or is driving on a suspended or revoked license. So as a result of that, a number of years ago, the legislature changed the vehicle code and someone who is...
1:10:33 Stopped and driving and is either not licensed or on a suspended and revoked license, their car is impounded for 30 days. It's an additional penalty. And that has had an impact in a lot of areas on reducing hit and runs. We do that some. We don't do a whole lot. We don't have that big of a problem. But that might have had some impact on the substantial reduction on hit and running collisions. Other than that, I can't explain why that would be down so much, other than the fact that total collisions are down.
1:11:04 Traffic enforcement. This is kind of a dramatic slide. We had a big increase in 2008. That was the year that the town, the prior chief, obtained a traffic safety grant. It purchased a vehicle. It added an additional officer who was specifically designated for traffic enforcement. As a result of cuts, a couple years ago, I think, we no longer had a dedicated traffic officer, and the numbers dropped off significantly since then.
1:11:34 What's interesting, I don't have any data, but there's a common belief in law enforcement that there is a, not always, but oftentimes a correlation between traffic enforcement and traffic collisions. An increase in traffic enforcement sometimes, oftentimes, will result in a reduction in traffic collisions. That hasn't been the case here because we've had a reduction in traffic enforcement and crashes are down also. So a bit of an anomaly, but regardless, it's good news that we've had fewer accidents.
1:12:05 This next slide shows total incidents. This comes from our computer-aided dispatching system that's managed by the county. It includes the bottom, the blue data is calls for service. You can see they've been fairly consistent. The numbers, it's dropped off a little bit in the last few years. And the red that's on top of that is total incidents, and that includes officer-initiated activities like traffic stops, foot patrols. It involves other types of...
1:12:34 Data that's entered into the system. So, again, there's a reduction in total incidents, but not calls for service, not a dramatic reduction. And part of that, I'm sure, is due to reduction in staffing and just less activity going on in the town. So, that's, again, good news. So, what's it all mean? If I could explain to you why all this happens, I wouldn't be in this business. I'd be making a lot of money doing consulting for somebody.
1:13:04 There's a lot of theories on what impacts crime. Certainly activities by police department has an impact on it. The economy can have an impact on crime. In a city like ours that is a tourism-based, visitors will have an impact. But what's important is even though staffing is down, crime is also down, arrests are down, traffic collisions are down, traffic enforcement is down, overall incidents are down.
1:13:34 And what's most important is we're safer than we were 10 years ago. I can't explain, I can't show that staff reductions have had any impact on crime. I'm pleasantly surprised that that's not the case. I don't think that means that we shouldn't be concerned about whether or not we should look at what our staffing is. Police officers do a lot more than just investigate crime. We have obviously had to reduce the number of contacts with...
1:14:04 Such as bar checks, foot beats in the village. In other parts of town we're not able to do that because we don't have as many officers. But, you know, I mentioned in the staff report maybe part of it is maybe our population and our visitors are maturing over what they were years ago and they're less likely to get involved in aggressive behavior. I don't know. I also said maybe some of it's just good luck. The fact is,
1:14:32 It's good news for the town. I think it's good news for tourism. I hope John Urdi picks up on this and takes advantage of what I see as a positive trend in the town of Mammoth Lakes. Chief, in answer to your question, and I'm sure you realize it as well, but I think one of the reasons that we're getting by with good law enforcement is that we've had three punk...
1:14:57 Winters, and I mean, you saw it last weekend with your report last weekend, the number of fights up in the village. Busy weekend. It's a busy weekend. So that the last three years we haven't, month after month, had those kind of visitors, those kind of numbers. And the visitors in the winter are different than the visitors in the summer. Right. So I think that that has, in my mind, as big an impact as anything. So if we have a normal winter again, not if we do, but when we do, and have the normal numbers,
1:15:27 And the number of storms and the problems related with the storms themselves, I think we're going to have issues. I think you're right, the impact on the weather and visitors. You know, last year was a really good year for tourism, but a lot of it was based in the summer. And you're right, the people that come in the summer tend to camp more. The people that come in the winter have no choice but to stay in a condominium or in a hotel.
1:15:55 They're here to ski or snowboard, and then they want to go out and have a good time at night, so there's more alcohol-related problems in the winter than there are in the summer. So we, yeah, I think that could very well be part of the explanation. Other questions? Okay, I'm not asking for anything to be done, just wanted to give a presentation and recommend that it be received and filed. As it will be. Thank you, Chief. Thanks, Chief. Any member of the public wish to either provide comment or ask questions? Joe.
1:16:37 Joe Perino again. You know, I don't know if I really believe some of that stuff he says. No disrespect Mr. Watson. But I'll tell you right now, Old Mammoth Road is definitely a problem from pretty much Snow Creek on. And why it is, Mr. Watson and I have talked about this, it goes from 40 to 25. And a lot of people don't shut down to 25.
1:17:06 So then you get in by Snow Creek and pretty much where the Aspen Village is. These guys are still going 40, 50 miles an hour. You've got little kids. You've got dogs running free. It's a disaster. It really is. I live in that area. And I definitely observe a lot of this stuff. I always have my dog on a leash just because of those reasons. I thought maybe since we've got so many extra cop cars.
1:17:37 Since there's, you know, pretty much down on the, down on our staff. Is it possible that maybe we can put a dummy car at the fire station? Because that's what it is, that blind corner right there. You wouldn't even believe how many dogs have been hit along that section. In fact, that's where Mingus got hit. Mingus was a beautiful husky, probably about 170 pounds, and this guy just slaughtered it. And again, you know, you've got a lot of kids in Aspen Village there.
1:18:06 A lot of you are Hispanic. I walk through that area a lot. I see kids running around, you know, again, unsupervised, and I feel it's a danger zone. And Mr. Watson lives in that area. He lives off Redford. And so, again, I ask for that because I see that. I even see Mr. Eastman's, I don't know what he is, is he a brother-in-law or son-in-law, whatever he is. Even he speeds through there. And I gave him an indication last week, slow down. Yeah, and he skid in the middle of the road, got out of his truck.
1:18:36 He was ready to approach me. And all I was just telling him was to slow down. So it's a problem. It's a real problem. And it's been a problem for a long time. And we've tried to address it. And it just doesn't seem to be really a priority. But I feel it'd be nice just to put a dummy car there. You don't have to have an officer in it. You've got plenty of extra cars, plenty of SUVs. Just park them right there at the fire station. And I think that would really slow the traffic down. Any questions? Questions of Joe.
1:19:10 Thank you. Thank you, Jim. All right. Anybody else wish to speak? If not, we've received and accepted the report, filed the report, and again, I appreciate the effort that you have put in putting this report together, and also, you know, it is remarkable that with a 40 or 50 percent reduction at one point,
1:19:46 Thank you. I will pass that on. What we have is working hard. You know, they're focused. I'm really pleased with the, you know, the overall performance of the officers with the department. So we've gotten through a tough period and, you know, we're coming out of it. All right. Thank you. I have one question for the chief. I'm just curious.
1:20:16 Statistically, when the economy's bad, or as bad as it's probably been, crime's usually higher, isn't it? I mean, in downtime, recessionary, depression. People who know a lot more about this than I do would say that's the case. You know, I know, this is anecdotally, but my observations and my officers, since I've been here, my officers say it's consistent, is there's some interesting trends. We have police activity, and crime reports don't reflect.
1:20:44 Police activity. We do a lot of things that don't result in an arrest and don't result in a crime report, but result in us breaking up a fight where nobody's injured, dealing with a drunk individual who we get them a ride home. That doesn't show up. I think what happens is when the snow conditions aren't good and the mountain has furloughed people or laid people off, or at the beginning of the season, one of the interesting dynamics I've noticed
1:21:13 Is October, early November, when people are starting to come into town, the seasonal employees, but they're not working yet. A lot of them are young. Some of them, it's the first time they've been away from home. So they're here and they have a lot of free time. And so, you know, Taco Tuesdays and $2 PBRs, they take advantage of that. And we're real busy. And then when the Mountain starts hiring and all the other businesses in town that hire seasonal employees, when they get ramped up,
1:21:42 Those people don't have the time. There's much free time to go out and create problems. So the police activity here is different than most towns because we're a resort town. Thanks, Chief. Thank you. All right. It takes us to agenda item number eight, which is entitled Consider Option for Adjusting Town Tobacco and Smoking Regulations to Include E-Cigarettes.
1:22:13 Yes, Mr. Mayor. I saw something on the news today in Los Angeles about an ordinance or a bill that was passed by the City Council there banning e-cigarettes in parks and other public places or public buildings. Dan. Yes, Mr. Mayor, this item is coming for you in part by request from the County Health Department in looking at e-cigarettes and the elements just in town. It is a growing trend, as I mentioned, L.A. just going through that.
1:22:40 One of the attachments to the staff report highlights a number of cities throughout the state that are taking different actions related to the use of e-cigarettes and looking at how to regulate them as we do similar to other smoking activities. It's really a policy matter for the town whether or not we want to incorporate e-cigarettes into the definition of smoking or enhance the tobacco type thing to include e-cigarettes.
1:23:05 Some of the challenges agencies have run into is there's a push to say, well, we need these cigarettes as a means to quit smoking, which is good. And you have the other side going. As people, one, begin utilizing them more because they can, it actually leads to smoking, so there's a debate going on that way. The other side of it is a confusion that happens. If you're sitting there smoking one and other people see it, they, oh, smoking's fine, they tend to light up. You have those types of confusion issues that go on with that.
1:23:33 I think there's an overall concern, too, is as they get accepted, there's data coming out, are they really non-hazardous for your health, etc. But the other piece on that is this whole issue of a lot of work going in to reduce smoking, reducing the health impacts, and I think there's studies starting to come out that this tends to actually probably push that the other direction. It has an impact versus a positive impact on some of the studies aren't.
1:24:00 Thank you. Thank you.
1:24:24 Staff really didn't have a strong recommendation one way or the other. It's a growing trend, I think, of communities to begin to regulate e-cigarettes for a variety of reasons. From just seeing what's going on with that, it's probably not a bad thing to take a hard look at doing. I know Nancy can address this and provide additional information regarding some of the health focuses and the things that are going on there.
1:24:50 Really bringing this forward if the council wants to. It's pretty easy to assign the town attorney to do a couple of ordinance updates, amendments to actually bring it forward from that perspective. And really the question is how much outreach and other information you want to have on that. But at a minimum I would come back to you for a few different readings from an orbit standpoint there. So it's doable. A lot of agencies have gone to it. Some more restrictive than others. And we could definitely incorporate it into a current.
1:25:19 Restrictions the town has on smoking. With that, glad to answer any potential questions and some information from the community that you brought forward as well. Questions from counsel, Dan first. Nancy? My name is Nancy Mahan. I'm a public health nurse and spent much of my career working in cancer nursing and in general medicine at UCLA.
1:25:50 And I feel very passionate about tobacco control. I've seen a lot of people drown and suffocate because of tobacco. And so that's why I do what I do.
1:26:01 I just wanted to talk briefly. You have a lot of information about the health consequences and all, but what I wanted to assure you is that there's good community support for tobacco control, and I just want to go back historically for people who haven't been here for the last 23 years and remind them where tobacco control has gone in Mono County. In 1993, there was a marble race course up on Mammoth Mountain.
1:26:27 And that was then discontinued in the interest of the health and the healthy environment for families at the mountain. In 1993, the Yodler became the first smoke-free bar in Mammoth Lakes. Three years before the California Department of Education required that
1:26:47 Schools that accepted their money for tobacco control be free three years before they required that all schools in Mono County were tobacco free. By December of 1995, 17 of the 24 bars were voluntarily smoke free in Mammoth Lakes. The California state law for smoke free bars went into effect three years later in 1998.
1:27:15 And at that time, two months before that law went into effect, 22 of 24 bars were already smoke-free in Mammoth Lakes, and there were the most smoke-free bars of any city in the entire nation. Mammoth Hospital's campus went smoke-free in 2000. The Mammoth Parks went 100% tobacco-free in 2001.
1:27:41 And that was before the state law made playgrounds smoke-free in 2003. County buildings went smoke-free in 2002, which was several years before they required government buildings to be smoke-free. A 2005 scientific study that was done in all of Mono County in conjunction with Prop 63 needs assessment demonstrated that, and this was before cell phones,
1:28:09 We're so popular, demonstrated that only 9.3% of households in Mammoth Lakes stated that there was a smoker in their household. In 2009, we did a face-to-face survey with 77 home managers of condo units representing over 4,800 units in Mammoth. We found that only a third of condos
1:28:34 were smoke-free at that time, had smoke-free buildings at that time. However, in 2013, when we went back, and we have done only half that many, 38 managers interviewed, 75% of those persons interviewed stated that their condos were 100% smoke-free. Right now, the community college is trying to create a smoke-free campus.
1:29:01 UC system has already gone smoke-free, but locally, because they're managed out of Bakersfield, they're still working on that. When the LA Council declared, did the same thing that we're asking the Mammoth Council to do, they actually passed it 14 to 0. I just think that that's an important note.
1:29:27 Issue of e-cigarettes has already created conflict in town. Mammoth Mountain Ski Area has reported that people are using e-cigarettes in areas where smoking is not allowed and creating an enforcement nightmare for them. The Cerro Coso Student Housing have had students come in and start arguing with the staff because of it saying that they're not really smoking and creating a problem there.
1:29:56 The owner of the restaurant in Bridgeport, the Bridgeport Inn, has stated that he also has had problems with people coming in and having problems with the conflict of enforcement. And Rick Johnson cannot be here today. However, he's on his way to Sacramento. However, he did ask me to read this letter to you. Dear Town Council, you have been given the opportunity and the responsibility by virtue of your elected position.
1:30:26 To protect the lives of our residents and visitors. Fifty years ago, the Surgeon General at that time issued the first report on smoking and health. Since that time, it has become obvious that health and financial burdens caused by tobacco use are far greater than previously recognized. In addition, although the use of non-tobacco vapor products have been touted as a safer product than tobacco-containing products, it is now accepted
1:30:52 They are in fact a gateway product for many into the world of nicotine addiction, eventual tobacco use, and a slow expense of death. It only makes sense for the town of Mammoth Lakes to do all that it can to safeguard the lives of all who visit, work, and reside in our town. This includes the proposal to extend the Mammoth Comprehensive Tobacco Control Ordinance to include these new products. We hope that you will do what is right for the people of Mammoth Lakes.
1:31:20 And in closing, I just want to say that the definition of public health, which is what my department and Rick are mandated to do, states that are not definition, but it says public health is what we as a society do collectively to assure the conditions in which people can be healthy.
1:31:42 As far as the health effects and everything, according to Stan Glantz, the cardiologist from UC San Francisco, 80% of people that use e-cigarettes also are dual users in that they don't just use them for cessation, but they flip back and forth between using regular cigarettes and using electronic cigarettes.
1:32:09 Is that the schools, all the schools in Mono County, all the districts have made e-cigarettes, put the equivalent of having drug paraphernalia on campus and there have been several incidents where students have brought them on campus and several, in fact even an incident where they started smoking in the classroom. So that's all I have to say. Does anybody have any questions or comments? Questions? It's kind of a fad. Oh yeah.
1:32:37 Do you remember cigars were like massively popular in the late 90s and everything? Yeah, so it's a fad definitely. But the major, you know, the major e-cigarette brands have been bought up by the major tobacco companies and they're using the exact same kinds of propaganda to try to influence people to use their product. That's somebody we can trust. Yeah.
1:33:06 Nancy, thank you. So what are the designated areas? Well, there aren't yet. What's before us is direct to, as I understand it, to direct staff to...
1:33:22 Look into it further and bring something back to us if we think it should. Yeah, essentially. Treat it like a cigarette. Treat it like a tobacco cigarette. Which are what areas? Multifamily.
1:33:50 It would be a really simple, really quick change to the ordinance if that's the direction you'd like to go. Yeah. I think there's a pretty good list on page 8 of the areas that we have already. Mr. Mayor, I'd move that the council adopt option number 1. Second that.
1:34:16 Well, we're supposed to give direction with that option. Right, to give direction to come back to us with the changes. Yeah. I'll mention this has been an agenda item at housing as well. Some period of time we're working through that as it relates to housing that we would manage our own.
1:34:44 So in other words, you might have regulations that go beyond what the town ordinance is. Well, I don't want to say that, but I mean, obviously, we're property managers, and so there's an opportunity, just like the condominium manager, to restrict smoking, and that may very well include e-cigarettes. I certainly support it. Is there a problem with the secondhand vapor that's coming out of it? Is there an issue where...
1:35:14 People breathing it in? Yeah, if you could, please. I'm just curious because if it starts with an e-cigarette, then where does it go? Well, the right now, as you know, it took many years for the Surgeon General's report to come out. In terms of the vapor, it's the chemicals that are the solvent are propylene glycol and glycerin.
1:35:40 And so even though the tobacco industry claims that it's water vapor coming out, it's not actually water vapor, it's something else, and it also contains a lot of chemicals. And most of the e-cigarettes right now, they're not regulated by the FDA. So the research has found that even though they declare that there's specific amounts of nicotine in each, you know, what they claim,
1:36:07 Those, in fact, vary quite a bit. The other thing about e-cigarettes in places like the mountain or elsewhere or schools or the college or whatever is that you can, they're kind of like an asthma inhaler in that you can put whatever you want in it. And so the research on exactly what comes out or how bad it's for you really has not formulated because really this is a very new trend.
1:36:32 But it is a multi-billion dollar industry. It has doubled in the last two years. So at this moment, it does appear that it will continue. What's the argument about that makes you want to quit smoking? I don't get that. Can you speak to that? Because it's just a different...
1:36:55 Nicotine delivery device. So it has less chemicals than tobacco smoke. So it is a harm reduction product. Right. But the option is, you know, if you're going to use the e-cigarette, that's better than a cigarette. Smoking nothing or using nothing is better than both. Do you get the buzz off it? I suppose one could if you put something else in it or if you get the buzz off of nicotine, which does happen.
1:37:25 Okay.
1:37:28 Alright.
1:37:29 There has been a motion.
1:37:31 Is there a second to that motion?
1:37:32 Yeah, I second.
1:37:32 Thank you.
1:37:33 Other comment from the members of the public who are here or questions?
1:37:39 And seeing nobody else on council who wishes to speak, roll call, please.
1:37:44 Councilman Rayston?
1:37:44 Council Member Landon?
1:37:45 Council Member LeMondon?
1:37:46 Council Member LeMondon?
1:37:47 Council Member LeMondon?
1:37:47 Council Member LeMondon?
1:37:47 Council Member LeMondon?
1:37:48 Yes.
1:37:48 Council Member LeMondon?
1:37:48 Yes.
1:37:49 Yes.
1:37:49 Motion passes 5-0.
1:37:52 That will come back to us.
1:37:53 Good.
1:37:54 It takes us to agenda item number nine, consider options for adjusting town council salaries. Yes, Mr. Mayor, I'm a member for council, put this report together based on comments we've received, some from council members and others who have been interested in running for town council asking about the pay for council, and we say it's generally a volunteer type position for the hours that get put into it.
1:38:19 We walked through, and Andy can touch on some of the detailed processes by law that governs the salary structure for the town of Mammoth Lakes as a general law city. Current salary set back in 85, I think it was, of $300 a month. You also do have a benefit component. Council members can participate in the town's insurance program. That's on average at about $17,000 a year. It's a different benefit piece. It's optional.
1:38:48 And depending on what the structure is for the families. But the actual structure for salaries is relatively limited. It's set by the size of the city under state law, common for general law cities throughout the state. Mammoth has followed the practice of many that set that initial, and a lot of them have left it there over time. Others have gone ahead with the allowed increases that speaks to by state law. So it's bringing it forward. It's really, I think at this point, it's...
1:39:17 If I'm looking at it from a budgetary aspect or a financial aspect, you're not talking a lot of dollars. Ultimately, it's more of a policy question. The challenge for any time a council looks at changing their pay, I don't think there's any good time. But you must, it cannot be effective until after the next election, so now's a good time to talk about it. You have elections coming up. If you do it after that, then you're two years out. So basically,
1:39:43 Sitting councils can't give themselves a pay raise. They have to wait at least one election is the thought process there. So if Annie can walk through some of the different elements of what you can look at in terms of that, and then again, we're looking at this council of direction. Do you wish to see something come forward or not on this matter? Andy? As Dan said, I mean, you do have some options that are laid out in staff report. The easiest one is that you can, by ordinance, simply increase your pay from $300 up to, I think it's $735 a month.
1:40:13 Representing 29 years of 5% increases that haven't been adopted until now. You can't make it an automatic escalator going forward. State law says that you have to adopt a new ordinance every time you wanted to increase it. That's the quick and easy way to do it, although it's limited to that 735 amount. A more complicated way of doing it would be to ask the voters to approve any kind of ballot measure, either taking away the cap entirely or setting it at some higher one.
1:40:39 And then the third option that's theoretically possible but that I wouldn't recommend would be to convert to the status of being a charter town to escape the council member pay cap. Being a charter town is something that has a lot of ramifications. You would have to be very, very carefully thought through and it would be a little bit like swatting a fly with a battleship to go that route for this reason. John, you want to speak right now? Yeah, it's getting real close to bedtime.
1:41:09 When I read this, I'm sorry, when I read this, I wrote down, I can't even imagine. So I'm not interested in spending any more time personally discussing this and I'm not supportive. So John, how much was that $300 a month worth back in 85 when you were first on council? I don't know and I don't care. It's not an issue. I'm very supportive of it.
1:41:39 Very, very much so. And there's a number of reasons why. It's not for any council member to make money or to profit off of it. I think, if anything else, what it does is it prevents a council member that's spending a lot of time, commissions, committees, otherwise, from losing money. There's a lot of people out there, I think, that may be swayed by running or not running a certain demographic.
1:42:07 I'd like to see it perhaps encourage some younger people to run.
1:42:39 I don't think it's a lot to ask, but I do think it's something that will help out the spectrum of people that may run for council in the future. Yeah, I kind of agree with Matthew, too. I mean, you're not talking about a lot of money with the fact that Joe's point was pretty good. I mean, there hasn't been an increase since 1985. The dollars from $85 to today and still $700.
1:43:10 It's not very much money, but I agree that I think it offsets a little bit of expense in time.
1:43:21 Is it 27 cents an hour, you say? Well, I joke about that often, that we feel like we work for 27 cents an hour, so maybe this will bring it up to 52. But, you know, it is a thankless job, and even a little bit, excuse me, I'm losing my voice, even a little bit does show that there is some concern and consideration for the fact that this is a job. We're running a corporation at essentially very little salary.
1:43:49 And I think that will affect who has or who might apply for the positions in the future. So I agree totally with what Matthew said. So my view is that this is a $30,000 budget increase. It's $26,400 plus Social Security and Medicare, which is the employer's share. And I don't want to consider a $30,000 budget increase until we have a budget discussion tonight, especially this year.
1:44:26 Good evening, Mayor, Town Council, Martin Kleinberg. I have concerns about this agenda raise, not because of a raise for work well done. My biggest concern is the jump from giving potentially a well-deserved raise, I'm not saying that the full gamut of the $700.
1:44:56 But the leap from, well, if that doesn't work, maybe we should try going to a charter township. And that to me is apples and oranges. I mean, I can go on and on with a litany of things of where it doesn't correlate. And I don't think it should have been brought up. I don't know where it's coming from. It's not the first time. But the ramifications for doing such a thing and our budget constraints.
1:45:25 Thank you.
1:45:55 I think there's something, and I just don't see to add up every year at 5%, because each year isn't even a guaranteed 5%, it's up to the 5%, so I think that there should be something, but everyone gets to participate in the health plan, and that's been worthy of a lot of dollars for people. I know it's very expensive even.
1:46:24 Even under our current California CARES. So I would support some type of thing, but I think as Mayor Wood said, I think there needs to be a budget discussion prior to such a raise. Thank you. Thank you.
1:46:47 Yes. Could I ask, Andy, timing-wise, if we held off discussing it until we were in the budget, does that mean it would most likely not be in effect until after the June 2014 election? So did that mean it couldn't be effective until June 2016? That's correct. Because of the ordinance adoption cycle, you'd have to have both readings plus 30 days occurring prior to the election.
1:47:19 Joe Prino again, candidate for town council. You know, you guys are kind of giving yourselves a raise, and everybody's kind of wondering where their next meal's coming from. I know that you definitely spend a lot of time. Believe me, I'm looking through that pack, and it's going, wow, what a job that you guys have definitely to do, especially that whole deal with the lawsuit. I mean, you know, reading some of the stuff that Matt went through. It's definitely very time-consuming. But the main thing is this.
1:47:48 You're probably going to tick off a lot of the community right now because, again, over 14 million people are wondering where their next meal is coming from. That's true Americans that have birth certificates, driver's license, and true social security numbers. So I think you want to maybe think about that before you kind of walk out of the streets and, you know, you might get a little of that deal. If I was elected, what I would like to do is actually not really in the service business, but I would like to try to get the businesses to bring up
1:48:17 The hourly wage. Because, you know, this $8, $9 an hour, you can't make it. And there's not, right now, there's not enough jobs to go around to have two jobs. Most of the, most of your, most of your businesses are hiring the kids. Most of them are hiring Hispanics because they can get away with the lower wage. But a lot of people moved and sacrificed a lot of stuff and moved here.
1:48:45 For pretty much the quality of life. And realize, oh no, I can't make it. Now they're trapped. Unless they have rich parents or grandparents or some kind of trust fund to pull them through, you're going to see a lot of people out in the street. You're going to see more people. I mean, I don't know if anybody saw the sheet. That was great that Ted printed that, that the Mono County paramedics had their own food bank in front of the store. I mean, that was just impressive. That was during my dangers.
1:49:15 Thank you very much for that, Jeff. And again, I really think you need to really think twice about this whole deal. Again, I would like to see if I got elected, I would sure try to push. Because poverty right now, even at $13 an hour, you're still at poverty in this town. I mean, look at the prices of bonds, look at the prices of most of your gas. And then again, prices in your retail stores, you're kind of pushing your customers away.
1:49:41 Is what's happening because now they can go online and get that same product for a lot less. And by that, the one who hurts are the businesses. Plus with the T-bid, plus with the double tax up at the village. I don't need the village just because of the resort tax and now a T-bid. And again, I think it's just, you know, it's not fair. So again, if I was elected, that's something I would really try to push because I know a lot of people moved here for the quality of life. But when you're working three jobs, you can't enjoy it. Any questions?
1:50:12 Thank you, Joe. Thank you. Other members of the public? Well, what's the pleasure of counsel? You've got another one. Oh, sorry. It's probably blasphemous for me to say, but you have a rare opportunity where you have a lot of incumbents not running for re-election, where you can actually do this where it's not necessarily political, but you've done the job and you know how much time it takes. So, on some level, if you have not increased this thing in 29 years,
1:50:45 You should do something. Mr. Mayor, before we make a motion, I'd like to say, to just reaffirm what I said earlier, I think that something like this sends the wrong message. It sends a wrong message to the town staff who we've asked almost unheard of financial sacrifice in recent years. Rick, you and I and Joe as well know more so than others.
1:51:21 We've basically reduced our town staffing and not given raises and cut things for our town staff and for the council to sit up here. I don't care if it's been 100 years. We incorporated it under certain guidelines and certain rules and certain restrictions, if you will, and I wouldn't come close to passing it just for the message that it would send to the town staff. I also agree with Joe at some level that
1:51:48 It would send the wrong message to the people in the community because, as Joe stated correctly, I don't know what the numbers are, Joe, but I don't know if it's 50-50 or if it's 80-20, but there's a tremendous population in this community of workers that things aren't going well.
1:52:12 And they're not going well because they are low-paying jobs. They're not going well because we've had three years of below normal precipitation and bad economic times and the national recession and all these things. So I just think the timing is horrible on this. Thank you. I just think it's a distinction without any meaningful difference. You don't run for council for the money. You never did, you never will.
1:52:41 I agree with Rick, it's not about the money. I agree too. I don't think it is. I don't think anybody's going to get rich up here doing it. That's not the point. I think the point is for another generation to come up here and not lose money coming on here because it does take a lot of time. So I think that's...
1:53:10 I think we've all accepted that. I understand that. I understand. Okay, but I think that there's another demographic of people out there that maybe can't afford it like the five people up here may. Yet they might want to step up here and have the opportunity to have their voice heard in some fashion or other or even take a leadership role. Matthew, there might be, but when I was on council, I had a newborn child. While I was on council, I had two children. Just before I got on council, I didn't have a job. I didn't have a place to live.
1:53:40 This is the type of job where you make a decision other than, in my mind, other than the financial. All right, well. It'll be interesting when we have the presentation because it looks like we have three votes to move it forward. There is an agenda item. If there's no other comments, does anybody wish to make a motion? I'll make a motion.
1:54:11 And that's to move forward with an increase to council salary to $735 per month. Effective as soon as legally possible. I'll second that. Okay, we've been a motion and a second. Any further comment from council members? If not, roll call please, Jamie. Council members? No. Council member Layman? Yes. Council member Layman? Yes. Council member Layman? Yes. Mayor Pro Tempo? Yes. Mayor Pro Tempo? Yes. Mayor Pro Tempo? No. Motion passes three to two.
1:54:43 All right, that concludes the public portion of our meeting. We're going to go into closed session for a brief item, and then we'll adjourn to the next regularly scheduled meeting, which is to be held on March 19th at 6 o'clock here in the council chambers. Good night.