TransparentMammoth

Town Council · 2014

Town Council

· recording 2 hr 16 min

Agenda

Agenda items for this meeting haven't been extracted yet. Read the agenda on the Town's site ↗

Transcript

278 passages · machine transcript

Automatically transcribed from the Town's recording with speech-to-text. Names and numbers can be wrong; the recording is the record. Open the Town's video ↗

0:00 Okay. Okay.

0:29 Call to order. Meeting of the Town Council for Wednesday, April 2, 2014. We'll begin with roll call, please, Jeremy. Councilmember Reeson. Here. Councilmember Layman. Here. Mayor Pro Tem, Bacon. Here. Mayor Wood. All right. John, would you please lead us in the pledge? Please join me. I pledge allegiance to the flag of the United States of America and to the republic for which it stands, one nation,

1:02 Yes, as John just pointed out, we have a 30th anniversary banner on our logo. August is the 30th anniversary of the incorporation of the town. There will be events all summer long, I believe.

1:30 Now is the time for public comment on items that are not onto this evening's agenda. If you have an item, please come forward to the podium. Good evening. Hi, I'm Larry Johnston. I'm current chairman of the Mono County Board of Supervisors. But I'm also on the Treasury Oversight Committee, which is a committee that we just recently established. We just had our first meeting of in many, many years.

2:06 So I would like to invite you to have a future agenda item to discuss your potential participation with the people who are in the investment pool with us. And I have a handout for you that will explain why you might want to take a look at that. Just a little bit of background. When taxes and revenues and fees and so on are collected,

2:49 They tend to come in peaks. And so the money that you, where your revenues more or less come in, you pretty much know what that's going to be from month to month. So the peaks are put into an investment. It's like into a checking account that you have. And in your case, you have most of yours invested in what's called LAIF, L-A-I-F. It stands for Local Agency Investment Fund.

3:20 And a lot of people are in that. And it's very liquid and safe and all that. And you've chosen over the years to maintain that for a number of reasons. And previous councils have done that. We have, as you can see from the hand up that I gave you, the Mona County investment pool, which includes almost all the public agencies in the county,

3:48 We triple or almost quadruple what you're making in interest. We are 11th in the state in return on investment for our investment pool, as you can see from the information. You know, Inyo County, that's about what you're getting because almost all their money is in LAIF, LAIF. So, if you're interested, we'd be happy to

4:20 Sit on the Treasury Oversight Committee with us. We have people from the Water District and schools that are participating with this. And you could make probably never $30,000 to $40,000 more a year just by making this change. And for me it's really a good investment. We have people working on this. In our investment pool right now we have

4:49 In the neighborhood it varies a little bit because of the income that we get from different revenue sources. But we have about $60 million that we manage, actively manage it. And as you can see, we didn't get 11th in the state by not doing that. We're looking at why some of those other counties are doing better. We're going to look into that. We think it's because they're taking on longer-term investments and that's part of our policy that we would do. So I invite you to...

5:18 Take a look at this. Here's the committee information. We'd be happy to share that with you. Leslie Chapman and Rose Glaser would be happy to come and give you more information about it. And then you can discuss it at a regular agenda if you're interested. Question, Larry. It sounds like it's a pretty technical committee. Is it a staff type person who should be on it or a policymaker? The people that are on it, we have...

5:47 Our finance staff people that work with this pretty much daily. Rose Glazier is the main one on that. She's a whiz-get at this. And then we have agency finance people that come and sit on the treasury oversight. And we have one board member, that's me, that's on there. And we have our finance director that's on it as well. We meet quarterly, so it's not a lot of effort.

6:12 I was just going to ask you then about timing, knowing that the majority of council will be changing over shortly. I'm asking the two who won't be here if they'd like to have this brought back for consideration, but I'm wondering if it would be appropriate to wait until we have the new council. Yeah, it's completely up to you. Here's the information for you. If you'd like to set some future agenda, whenever that would be, we'd be fine.

6:41 Every day is $100 that you're missing out on. If you can provide something to staff, then I think you could review it and let us know if it's something that should come back before or after. Yeah, and I don't think we need to agendize it to give staff direction. I think we can just give direction tonight for staff to consider. One of the things, because I don't want anyone to get their hopes up too high,

7:10 One of the uniquenesses about the Town of Mammoth Lakes is that 60, nearly two-thirds of our revenue generated during the year is generated by TOT or bed tax. So it is a fluid up and down. And we do need, as shown this year, we do need access to our reserves. And I understand liquidity is one of the issues. All of lathe is liquid.

7:38 Basically, you can get it any time you want. We have six times that amount in our, we have part of our fund in LAF itself, and we also have another five to ten million in access, ready access as well. So we have five to six times what you have already in liquidity. If you need something that you're going to anticipate as a long term obligation, you can give us 30 days notice and there's different amounts that you can do that. So it's pretty good as well. Pretty good, yeah.

8:09 And almost, like I said, almost all the other agencies in this part of the country are involved with it. Pulling the money together gives us disability. And we have investments in Fannie Mae, Freddie Mac. We have just all kinds of bonds and corporate bonds. They're all required by law to be in these safe categories, which they are. And the interest isn't that much, grant you, but it's triple what you can get with just LAF.

8:37 Maybe quadruple. We're getting, if you see them, we're getting 0.87 and you are getting about 0.27. And if you multiply that amount by how much you have in your LEAF account, it's 30,000, 40,000, depending on the time you have. Thank you, Larry. Thank you. Thanks a lot. Is there anyone else for public comment? Go ahead, you could. Good evening, my name is Rick Voll. I work at Mammoth Disposal and...

9:15 I just wanted to talk tonight because item number 14 is regarding solid waste and some of the direction moving forward and wanted to let you know that we appreciate being a partner with Mammoth Lakes and we have kind of exercised and let staff know that we'd like to continue to provide service in the town and as we work towards more longer term sustainable solutions.

9:37 I really hope we can continue to be a part of that and look at the location as we're identifying those and then the services we need to provide for the next 20, 30 years in town. So here to answer questions during that and I just appreciate you guys kind of attacking this serious scenario we have. So thank you. Thanks, Rick. All right. Now I saw someone else start to get up. Hi. Briefly, my name is Ingrid Braun. I'm running for sheriff of Mono County. I wanted to introduce myself to the town council.

10:13 Even though I've met all three of you before, and Dan. And give a little bit about my background, and I know this is on TV, so I get that out to the people watching TV as well. I have 22 years of law enforcement experience. I retired from Los Angeles PD as a lieutenant. I've supervised hundreds of people, up to 50 people at a time. I live here in town. I have lived here part-time since 1997, full-time since 2010.

10:43 And I am committed to running for office. I believe that the Sheriff's Department is in need of change and that the only way you're going to get change is by electing somebody new and fresh with professional experience into that office and engaging the community and bringing them into being a part of a team of Mono County and our Sheriff's Department. And I just wanted to come out and introduce myself. Great. Well, thank you, Ingrid. Nope. Okay. Any other public comment?

11:14 Okay. Seeing none, we'll move on to councilmember reports, additions to agenda, John. I have none. Oh, okay. I have none. I have a couple. Okay. First to report out on NLR, we had another meeting this past Monday, and we have developed, instead of calling it an elevator speech, we're calling it a chairlift speech, which is an outreach short...

11:39 Set of bullet points for everyone to use in the outreach effort, which was a big part of what will come back to full council on May 21st. We are also working on the board composition. And our next meeting will be next Wednesday, the 9th at 5.30 p.m. here in Suite Z, where Andy Morris will be here and we'll be working through all the legal questions that have been brought up so far.

12:05 The other thing is that I think both of you are aware that on the North Village specific plan, we have an unintended consequence that occurred because of approving that plan several years ago, but the actual development related to it being stalled. And we've come upon a situation on Berner Street where we have some items that aren't

12:30 Currently in existence but not allowed under those changes and so I would like to ask your concurrence that we have staff bring back to us the information and go forward with seeing how we can amend that plan because yes we're ready for reinvestment but we have to have the realities that there are things going on now that are affecting individual businesses not being able to go into those spaces.

12:55 So is there a consensus to bring that back? Yes, and I'd like to add, too, because I know in some cases we have businesses wanting to go into space up there. I'd actually ask if we could expedite it in some fashion just because I want to do what we can to promote business up here as opposed to have obstacles that might hinder it. So to the extent that staff has time, I'd like to do that. Okay. So then, Dan, it would come back to us as just a...

13:25 A scope of work, or just can you just go ahead and start into it? We'll do both. We can start analyzing it. We'll bring back that some information to council as well. Okay. Doesn't it have to go to plan information first? We'll go through that process, but it's probably a five, six month process to amend the plan, so. But we'll take a look at that. We can bring information back to council as well, but we can start some of that work on. Is there anything we can do to, I understand as a business trying to go in, can we offer a special use permit or a

13:56 Short term. I understand we've done that in some other instances in town. We've got to get some options for that. Actually, not open for discussion this evening. Okay. Yeah, we'll look at some ways to move that forward. Maybe some work can be done on their risk side for them. Okay. Thank you. Then we move on to reports from commissions and or departments. Thank you, Sandra Moberly, Community and Economic Development. A couple things for the council.

14:29 The draft housing element update is in the associated initial study and negative declaration are available for public review. The housing element will cover the five-year period of 2014 to 2019, and it includes policies and programs to achieve safe, decent, and affordable housing for existing and future residents. Our 30-day public review on this item ends on April 22nd, and it's available on our website.

14:53 Additionally, the Inn at the Village modified initial study is also available for public review. This is the first step in the environmental review for the project. The 30-day public review period will end on April 24th. And both the housing element and the Village initial study will be discussed at the Planning and Economic Development Commission meeting next Wednesday, April 9th, 2 o'clock here in Suite Z.

15:19 Additionally, the town has kicked off a wood stove replacement program to help fund the changeout of wood stoves. The funding is limited. It's funded by the Clean Air Projects Program, CAP. It's a block grant. Interested property owners are encouraged to contact the retailers in town that the town is working with. That includes Alpine Stove, Angelo Stove, Clean Sweep, High Country Lumber, and Batchelder Enterprise, who does kerosene heating systems.

15:48 The last thing that I have is that the zoning code update is changing the requirements for outdoor sales. Right now, retailers can have three outdoor sales per year. The zoning code update will allow only one. So one of the things that we had discussed with the Planning and Economic Development Commission and some of the council members is having the town sponsor some outdoor sales on some of our weekends, our big weekends.

16:13 So we're moving forward with that and we're going to have outdoor sales this year for Memorial Day weekend, Fourth of July weekend and Labor Day weekend. So we're working on processing the permits right now. We're going to work with Mammoth Lakes Tourism on advertising for that and just letting retailers know that if you want to have an outdoor sale, you can do it one of these three weekends or you can apply for another weekend through a separate permit. So any questions or comments? Thank you. Thank you, Sandra. Evening Council.

16:48 Mayor Bacon, Public Staff, everybody, thanks for coming. The town has a schedule, the eagerly awaited, I know, it's a big date, every year, town clean-up day. There we go. Got some good support. May 17th, so put your calendar, mark your calendar for May 17th, and we're also going to bring back the bag, so we'll have trash bags available. See, there you go. We'll have trash bags available for the community to help us.

17:18 Clean up our town. So we're going to have those available around town, primarily from the town offices, so people can come in and grab their bags, help us clean up. We won't be picking up those bags. We still have the same process of creating those town clean up day stations. If everyone can get their trash to those stations, we'll separate it, take care of it, and working with Mammoth Disposal will do a great job. Peter Roman is actually our staff lead on this project. I'm just assisting with the information.

17:48 We also kicked off our first Plan Your Parks Community Workshop on March 20th. We had just around 60 people, our recreation enthusiasts and stakeholders came along, and they're really helping us master plan four parks in the town of Mammoth Lakes, being the Community Centre Park and Playground Tennis Courts, Mammoth Creek Park East and West, Whitmore Recreation Area, and the Bell Shaped Parcel.

18:15 All those meeting notes and those maps that everyone spent time working on are available on our town website. If they just want to go right from the start on the homepage, there's a little narrative and story on Plan Your Park. So you click there, you'll get to our page. And our second and final community workshop is on April 17th. And the community design group called Verde Design will actually have kind of conceptual drawings and maps and scale of those four parks for the community to weigh in on.

18:44 From that process then, it'll actually go to the Recreation Commission and they'll meet twice with the consultants to further that process and bring it back to Council on July 2nd. So that's that plan. We do have postcards down in the back if people want to still grab those as well. Staff's working on fish stocking. We're working with a new vendor to provide more fish to our lakes basin.

19:11 Probably start, we think, around mid-May and run through summer. We'll actually, if you saw the press release, we pushed out about a week ago through Mammoth Lakes Tourism. We're looking at about 11,000 pounds. Previously, we've stocked about 7,500 to 8,000 pounds in the Lakes Basin. So that'll actually give us more fish and bigger fish, you know, more trophy-sized fish for the summer. So we're excited about that. Fireworks is progressing. So we're permitting and working through all that process as well.

19:40 The District Ranger published a Notice of Decision regarding the Shady Rest OSV, OHV, OHV staging area. It's been a process for about two years. The Ranger selected Proposal 3, which is Alternative 3, which is to design and build an operational vehicle off-highway staging area located off Sawmill Cut-Off Road, which is out at Shady Rest. And then the modified proposal

20:08 Does not include the Ride Back Trail and snowmobile parking. So that was the decision. Information is available on that website. So that was posted. And the Recreation Commission meets on Tuesday, April 8th with the primary task of making a funding recommendation for the Youth Sports Funding Program, which is the annual award to our youth groups. We've got some additional applicants applying for funds, so they've got their work cut out for them. And that will come back to Council at the beginning of May.

20:38 One question for you. Someone who could not attend the Plan Your Parks meeting asked me if some of the older information, like I can remember attending a cafe out at Sherwin's when it was a restaurant about Mammoth Creek Park, how does that older information get added back into this project? The commission's been through that kind of process, so they've kind of dug up a lot of those old plans and gone through those.

21:05 Probably what I'd suggest is to have them contact me and I can at least try and get them that information. I think that's the best bet. And my contact information is on all that material and on the website. You've obviously got my email. Let's do a real quick work on the fish. Yes. I was surprised by that because, of course, we lost our original trophy trout. Yeah, Conway and Inland Ecoculture won't be able to supply that.

21:33 And where did you find the fish? So they're coming from American trout and salmon out of Susanville. So they actually supply all the county's fish as well. They actually started stocking the county's fish last December, you know, in the fall, so they stock early. So they're kind of in a two cycle. So we're able to talk with them. They're very eager. They have some bigger tracks to come down, so they're not going to come down or stock as frequently.

22:03 So we'll try and get them to stock a couple of times a month, but with obviously a greater amount of fish in our lakes. And they'll still be able to stock the Children's Fishing Festival, which is a big part of the town, so they'll still be stocked with about 600 pounds of trout. And they have some trophies as trout as well. They do. Probably not for that event.

22:24 No, no. Little ones are probably good, but yeah. But they have those larger trophy size trout, the three to five pound. Do they have a particular name of the trout? In other words, we've been living with Alper's trout. Is there a new name? I'd have to get that. I think it's just the brown trout. I think it's probably what we're looking at. They are brown. Is it supposed to rainbow? I think so. If they are, that's significant. I'll get that information to you. But like you said, they've been stocked in our area before. Department of Fish and Game have approved, you know, that stocking of that fish. So this time, we're moving forward with that contract.

22:53 And committing, the town funds that program to about $54,000 a year, so it's a considerable investment. Thank you. Feed them frogs. We have, I don't know if you addressed the cost on that. My understanding is going to double, right? Double, triple the cost for stocking per drop. For us? No, no, no, sorry, the fish. Is it going to double the cost of stocking by going to this different?

23:23 We're there. No? No, we'll actually get more fish for the same amount of money. Oh, we will. Yeah. So, and they actually have larger fish. So, you know, running the numbers, probably about a third less, you know, a third of a dollar, you know, 30 cents less per pound. Okay. You know, with this new vendor, so. Okay. I thought I heard something about the cost was going to go up quite a bit. Maybe that's for the trophies, though. Right. Yeah, we'll kind of get that mixed, but there'll be, you know, more trophy size. Okay.

23:53 So, great. That's it. Thank you. Thank you. I'm Mayor Pro Tem Bacon and Councilmembers. Just an update on the Canyon Boulevard project. Constructionals should start in the next couple of weeks, weather permitting. And the initial activity will be potholing and then the drainage work. And then we did receive comments from the FAA, so we'd be working on updating the LLP, the LLP narrative, and the terminal area study. Thank you.

24:30 Any other departments or commissions? Okay. Seeing none, we'll move on to our public presentation. And Chief Watson is going to do the introduction. Thank you. Thank you. Good evening. It's my pleasure to introduce the speaker for our presentation. And that's Lieutenant Ron Cohen from the Highway Patrol. He is the commander of the Bridgeport office, which is the office that covers Mammoth Lakes in the southern part of actually just about all of Mono County.

25:03 Ron has 25 years' experience with the Highway Patrol. He's been assigned to Bridgeport since December of 2012. He spent most of his career in Southern California and Sacramento. He did fly in a helicopter for a while, so out of thermal. I'm not sure if it was an EMT or as a paramedic, but he's almost a local. He grew up in eastern Madera County and started his career working over there.

25:28 I just want to say that I've had the opportunity to work with Highway Patrol people for many years, and they're a professional organization with a lot of really good people, especially in management positions, but Ron has been an absolute delight to work with for us. He's been a great public safety partner here in the county. He has made his resources available to us. He communicates really well. They've offered training opportunities to us in the sheriff's department, and it's just been a real...

25:54 Great relationship between the Bridgeport office and the Bishop office also when we work with them and local law enforcement. So with that it's my pleasure to introduce Lieutenant Ron Cohn who's got a presentation for you on Highway Patrol and what they've been up to. Good evening members of the council, town staff, Ms. Gray. Thank you for the opportunity to speak tonight and giving me just about 15 minutes to just...

26:29 Familiarize those people in the audience that are perhaps not familiar with the Highway Patrol as an organization. And just to kind of recap on some of the things that Chief Watson said, Dan and I work really hard to have a good, strong relationship and be available to each other. And I include Sheriff Obenberger in that to take care of the things that need to be taken care of, especially during busy times.

26:57 I'd like to just tell you a little bit about the organization. I'd like to talk to you a little bit about our 2013 numbers, what we saw in 2013, and then some of the things that I hope to accomplish during 2014. The Bridgeport office has 27 employees assigned to it. It's one of the smaller commands, or one of the smallest, for the Highway Patrol, with some of our commands reaching up over 130, 140 people per work location.

27:26 The CHP was established in 1929, and it was in response to complaints by motorists that the variety of law enforcement agencies that were enforcing traffic regulations all did it differently. So as you were driving your Model A through several of California's 58 counties, you might be stopped for an enforcement action, and the interpretation of the vehicle code might be handled differently depending on where you were stopped.

27:54 So in 1929, the legislature established the Department of California Highway Patrol as a statewide traffic law enforcement agency. We're fortunate to be managed by four commissioners. All four of them have all risen from the rank of officer through our organization. Commissioner Joe Farrow, who was appointed by the governor, started with the Pacific Grove Police Department near Monterey as a police officer, worked there for a few years, came to work for the Highway Patrol, and then rose through the ranks until he was appointed.

28:23 Deputy Commissioner Mona Prieto, the youngest of four children and the only girl, and not wanting to be left out, learned to ride motorcycles at a very young age. And she was our department's first female motorcycle, female motorcycle officer in our central Los Angeles area, which some of you will remember from CHIPS in the center of the interchange down there. She also had risen.

28:50 Through each and every rank. We have two Assistant Commissioners. Assistant Commissioner Field, which is Warren Stanley, who is from Southern California, and Assistant Commissioner Staff John Rodriguez. Commissioner Stanley oversees the eight CHP Field Divisions. We're divided into eight geographic regions. And they are Northern, Golden Gate, Valley, Coastal, Central, Southern, and then our division, which is the best, Inland Division, which spans from Riverside all the way up to Topaz.

29:19 So Bridgeport is the furthest office north in that set of offices. Each division is commanded by a two-star chief. All eight of our two-star chiefs, again, are from within the highway patrol. Each one of them is assisted by either two or three one-star chiefs, and each one of those one-star chiefs oversees three or four commanders. And our two-star division chief for Inland Division is Bill Siegel, and our assistant chief that takes care of all of the eastern Sierras.

29:48 is Todd Sturges. He was the commander at Victorville before he promoted, so he's been in this geographic region for a number of years. I know that when people think about the highway patrol, they think about the flashing lights in their rearview mirror, and that's the first thing that comes to mind. And yes, traffic law enforcement is a big part of what we do. It's an important component of keeping the roadways safe and providing service to the public.

30:14 But we're much more than that. We're an organization of 11,000 people, 7,000 uniformed and the remainder non-uniformed, working at 104 field offices throughout the state. And again, because we were created for the purpose of consistency in law enforcement, we have just volumes and volumes and volumes of policies.

30:38 So that if I have an officer leave Bridgeport that goes to Crescent City and works there a few years and then goes to Winter Haven down outside of Yuma, all that really changes is the geography, the car, the uniform, the policies, the forms, the way we conduct business. That is not supposed to change as employees move throughout the state. We provide services to local government and one of the services that I can speak to locally that's utilized regularly is our air operations program.

31:09 We have 15 helicopters and 15 airplanes throughout the state that are available to other government agencies and victims at absolutely no cost to the entity. It certainly costs money. That's prepaid for when you register your car. And so part of your vehicle registration goes to fund the department and specifically the air operations program, which Mono and Inyo County use on a weekly basis during the summertime. With your permission, I'd like to show just a two-minute video.

31:41 Just the kind of highlights and reminds those people that aren't familiar with the organization about the diversity and the variety of services that we provide. Is it possible to turn down the lights while we play this just a little bit? Yeah, they'll turn them down in the back here. Thank you. The Bridgeport area has personnel assigned to four physical work locations. The Bridgeport office has 10 of the 20 officers.

34:42 Two of the three sergeants, two clerical employees, an automotive technician, a maintenance worker, and an office assistant. We have three officers that work from our Walker-Coleville resident post. We have two officers assigned to June Lake Le Mining resident post. And we have five officers and one sergeant assigned to Mammoth Lakes resident post. And the resident post officers typically we don't see at the office except every couple of days for paperwork exchange, if even that often.

35:11 Resident Post Officers are assigned take-home vehicles and equipment, and we have an expectation that we can call them out at all hours of the day and night to assist with things that are going on. And again, they represent about half of our field staff. Bridgeport's a unique office in that half of our entire field staff is assigned to Resident Post. So typically when you see a TV show, you see a briefing at the beginning of a work shift, and there's a sergeant or lieutenant doing it, and there's people sitting there.

35:41 We have a room, but we don't ever have anybody sitting there because they're all coming from their homes. We currently have 18 officers assigned to road patrol. They're responsible for 395, several estate routes, county roads, and miles of dirt roads on a 24-hour-a-day basis. Two of our officers work inside. They provide office security, coordinate training, control evidence, provide public information, conduct testing of sensitive equipment, review collision reports.

36:12 And other duties allow the office to remain open and operate. Two of the commands, three sergeants are generally on duty each day. The three of them share the on-call responsibilities 24 hours a day, seven days a week, which can be interesting when more than one of them is gone on vacation or for training. Our automotive technician skillfully and meticulously maintains our fleet of vehicles. Our maintenance worker keeps the oldest CHP facility.

36:41 That the Highway Patrol currently operates open and running on a day-to-day basis. And our office, most areas have multiple clerical employees and each one of them would have two or three tasks. Our office assistant, Diane Richardson, she does it all. Because since our office services supervisor retired at the end of December, it's left me with one person around the office. So she is the jack of all trades and master of many. We're a little lean on staffing. We're supposed to have 20 officers.

37:12 We've been down two for the entire time that I've been here and since before I arrived. Unfortunately, right after Thanksgiving, one of our officers' two-year-old son developed leukemia, had to be in his continuing to be treated at Loma Linda Children's Hospital, and I've loaned him to the San Bernardino office indefinitely as long as his son's treatment is occurring. So that puts us down three, which is 15%.

37:42 The Bridgeport area has changed over the past 10 years. In the past, officers needed 15 years to come to Bridgeport or Mammoth Lakes, 15 years of working as an officer. There's virtually no chance of getting here as a new officer, let alone coming directly from the academy. But changes in the economy and the communities have changed the way many businesses and governments operate, and the highway patrol is included in that. Prior to my arrival, a request was made to Commissioner Farrell allowing for people to live out of state.

38:11 in bordering communities within Nevada. Ultimately, that was approved, and that kind of changed the personality of the office, previously having all of the officers living in Mono County, and now having only about half living here, and that being the resident post officers and the rest living in the Gardnerville-Mindon area. We have approximately 13 departmental locations where the commissioner allows people to live outside of California.

38:39 Of our 18 officers, 7 transferred to Bridgeport after having worked with other CHP commands, and 11 of them were assigned here directly from the academy after completing 27 weeks of training in West Sacramento. Receiving new officers is a good thing from my perspective, especially having spent as much time in Southern California. It brings a certain amount of energy to a command when you're getting new people. It raises questions that perhaps haven't been raised in a long time.

39:08 Our employees are better educated now than ever before. Twelve of our eighteen officers and two of our other employees have college degrees. Many of our staff came from previous careers with one of our newest officers having left this position as a college dean in order to join the highway patrol. Four other officers are certified as drug recognition experts or DREs by the International Association of Chiefs of Police. One of these officers is an instructor for that same program.

39:37 Four of the officers, these four officers provide invaluable service and we're faced with making a determination about an impaired driver that's impaired from a substance other than alcohol. Our DREs not only evaluate drivers stopped by other CHP officers but are available to any law enforcement agency that requests this type of specialized assistance. None of our local agencies have the ability to handle a significant incident single-handedly and I'm pleased to have a great working relationship with your chief of police.

40:08 Sheriff Obenberger, Supervising State Park Ranger for Bodie, Josh Heitzman, Lieutenant Bill Daley, Fish and Wildlife Supervisor, District Attorney Tim Kendall, and the U.S. Marine Corps Mountain Warfare Training Center, Police Chief Frank Atkins. Both in emergencies and in day-to-day operations, these people are my public safety partners. They're the people that I call upon. One of my goals has been to increase information provided to the public regarding CHP programs and day-to-day operations.

40:36 During 2012, before I arrived, the command put out approximately 11 press releases. In 2013, that number quadrupled as we authored 46 press releases. With the assistance of our local media, these press releases not only inform the public of incidents that have occurred, they allow the CHP to provide and emphasize our safety messages in the hopes of encouraging safe driving. I'd like to talk just lastly about Bridgeport's report card.

41:05 My report card is a commander. First, let me say that I'm not a huge numbers person. I don't base command decisions on one, two, or even three months of statistics. And I'd like to explain where we ended up for 2013 and where I'd like to see us go for 2014. The good news is that in 2013, total accidents were down by 7.8%, both in that one year and in the three-year average from 2010 to 2012.

41:35 And as I talk more about the three-year average, I'm talking about that three-year period between 10 and 12. Our challenge to address in 2014 is that during 2013, driving under the influence collisions rose 63.6% in that single year and 125% for the three-year average. Our responsibility is to aggressively seek out impaired drivers before they're involved in a collision. To do this, we have to stop vehicles for violations.

42:06 Or driving that's suggestive of impairment. During 2013, DUI arrests were down 25.3% from the previous year and 17.6% from the three-year average of overall enforcement. Overall enforcement contacts, which include citations of verbal warnings, was down 20.6% between 12 and 13 and 24.7 for the three-year average. So those numbers should tell us that there are impaired drivers out there. They're crashing.

42:35 Because they're up 63.6%. But they're finding us. We want to find them. So with enforcement contacts down 20 plus percent, I'm asking my people to really increase the number of cars that they're stopping. And when I came here, I was just interested to hear from a lot of people that there was perception that we were stopping a lot of people. Well, I can tell you that in the...

43:01 15 months I've been here, we're not stopping more people, we're not stopping enough, and we're stopping fewer than we've stopped in previous years, and we're missing out on the opportunity to stop someone from being involved in a DUI crash, which potentially sends them to prison, and instead provide them with a misdemeanor DUI arrest, which gets them a big fat fine and a license suspension. Addressing increasing DUI collisions cannot be a single-pronged approach.

43:29 Making more enforcement contacts increases the opportunity for us to locate impaired drivers, but we must continue with press releases about drivers with high blood alcohol levels, public education programs, interaction with the courts and our public safety partners. I'm in the process of making adjustments to the work schedules in order to have twice as many officers on the road in Monod County in the evening hours, and CHP officers will be increasing the number of enforcement contacts that they make.

43:56 Of course, this entire time that officers and sergeants are patrolling, they look for opportunities to assist disabled motorists and provide information to both residents and visitors. I'd be glad to briefly answer any of your questions. I'm sure I've used up most of my 15 minutes. Who determines your staffing levels? My regional office in San Bernardino, which is my division headquarters, and Sacramento.

44:25 And it's all based, everything is fed by the number of cadets that are graduated. So if we start a 27-week academy class with 120 cadets, there's no way to know how many we're going to graduate because they fail out up until the last two or three weeks before graduation. So, for example, if I was slated to receive two cadets to come here to Bridgeport or Mammoth Lakes and one of them failed out,

44:53 Two weeks before graduation, I don't get another one because they've already been given their assignments and they have focused on finding a place to live in wherever it is that they were sent. Dan mentioned that I was from Oakhurst and I ended up in Woodland Hills. That's just the way it ended up. So it doesn't appear to be a factor of finances, it appears to be more of a factor of how many cadets graduate? Yeah, it just comes down to how many, because that's what drives the transfers.

45:24 They would transfer the number of officers. They wouldn't let officers here that are waiting to return home to where they're from transfer until they knew they had a cadet coming to backfill them. And then there's that little window, that couple-week window where we hope that cadet doesn't fail out, but they do, and so sometimes you could be left. And again, Bridgeport's a small command. I have 20 officers, so every missing officer is 5% of my staff. I'm down 15.

45:52 If I was going to get two and only got one, now I'm down 20. So the magnitude of losing the one officer to allow him to spend time with his family is that that reduces the number of officers, in this case in Mammoth? Yeah, exactly, and that plays a part. That was the slot that would be an additional evening officer that I can't fill because I have him on loan to San Bernardino.

46:21 Because his child has a life-threatening disease. Okay. Final question, and that is a curiosity question as it relates to Highway 120 West from the binding of the title of the pass road. Does that have any impact on your two officers that are assigned to that region in the summer months? That roadway requires a lot of patrol, and the reason it requires a lot of patrol is because there's a lot of rocks that end up in the roadway.

46:49 One of those rocks was played a part in a fatal collision two years ago in which a girl returning from the Electric Daisy Festival trying to get through Yosemite to stay with family over in Groveland struck a rock and then attempted to park her vehicle after she lost the oil pan and the coolant and the car seized up and wouldn't move. Unfortunately, she wasn't familiar with the parking brake.

47:17 And exited her car while it was still in gear, not in park, and without the parking brake on, and the vehicle rolling backwards drug her over the side. So it does affect your two officers in that region? Well, we, and the Mammoth people also cover that. We are pretty diligent about making sure that we're up there several times a day because of the amount of traffic that's coming out of Yosemite. And it's just a, I mean, it's a high altitude mountain roadway, and normally snow's melting into July.

47:47 And that's moving rocks, and that means they're coming down on the road. Caltrans is another one of our partners. They have equipment staged there that they leave there so they can respond up in a small pickup and then get the larger piece of equipment to go get the rocks out of the road. That's more expeditious than leaving Levining with a big truck. Thank you. You know, I had one question.

48:11 Command Post is in Bridgeport currently. I'm wondering, with so much traffic coming from Southern California to Mammoth and with such a high population base here in Mammoth, would there be any benefit to moving that command post to Mammoth Lakes? The bigger question is, do you want to move, you have two offices on the Eastern Sierras, so you've got all the way from the Inyo-Mono County line, or I'm sorry, the Inyo-Kern County line, Pearsonville.

48:41 All the way to Topaz, you have two offices. Do you want them within 35 miles of each other? And if you're going to put them within 35 miles of each other, then the people that build the offices, which are not the highway patrols, the Department of General Services, they're going to ask the question, do you really need two? Could you get by with one? From my perspective, the danger of having one CHP office, could it be done? Could you just have one CHP office on the east side of the Sierra? Sure, it could be done.

49:10 The problem is what happens when some event impacts that office? An earthquake, a broken water line, a chemical spill out in front, and that's the problem with both the CHP offices. They're right on 395. So what if we had something where we had to physically close down the office? Fire. So now you have no office for the amount of time that it takes you to have temporary office space installed or rented. So there's a certain...

49:40 And that being said, I don't know that, I mean, I'm not opposed, and DGS advertised in the Mammoth area, out by Mammoth Airport, four state property to build our next office. But I'm just not sure if I'm sitting in the commissioner's chair and I'm looking at a map and I'm looking at the cost to operate a CHP office, whether I need two within 35 miles over a

50:08 250-mile stretch. Right. Yeah, no, I agree with the two offices. I'm just thinking, you know, even though we're 35 miles apart, we're really a world apart as far as the grade, the snow we get, all the problems we have here are very different from what they probably experienced there. But it just seems like there's so much traffic coming in and out of here. And with all the agencies, it just seems like there could be proximity would be a nice way to perhaps consider.

50:36 Interagency cooperation. And again, that decision has made way above me. When they asked me where they should look for property, I suggested Mammoth, Bridgeport, and Colville Walker. I think those are the three centers that should be looked at. And there's not a lot of infrastructure in between to support a CHP office. And again, I have about five or six years to go, and I don't have any expectation that I'll be cutting the ribbon.

51:06 At the door of the new office. Bridgeport's been on the replacement plan for over 15 years. And just about the time we're within a stone's throw of building a new office or pulling the trigger on buying some property, some other office at some other location that's fairly aged slides into their septic tank in the back parking lot or something like that, and then we get put on the back burner. Got it. All right. Well, thank you. Thank you. Thank you very much for your time. Thank you, Ron.

51:37 We will move on to the consent agenda. Yes, Madam Pro Tem. I would like to request an item 5 related to the council compensation be moved out to a future agenda. We'll look at which one works best for bringing it back. All right. Are there any items to be pulled? Yes, I'd like to go ahead and pull a consent agenda item number 4, please. 4? Okay. Matthew, anything? No.

52:06 Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I'll move that the council adopt consent agenda items 3, 6, 7, 8, 9, and 10. I'll second. I have a motion and a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilman Reeson? Yes. Councilman Delaney? Yes. Mayor Pro Tem. Yes. Motion passes 3-0. John? Yes, I pulled number 4, which for the audience is to waive the reading and adopt by title only the ordinance.

52:35 Amending Title 17 of the Town of Amanda Flake's Municipal Code relating to zoning. I had a request during the daytime to pull that to allow for public comment. Okay. And is there someone likely to speak? Tom? Good evening, Council. I requested that Item 4 be pulled as a result of some...

53:04 Discussions that have transpired over the course of the zoning code update and in particular as it relates to some of the district plans that have occurred, in particular the commercial zoning districts and basically the downtown Old Mammoth and the mixed lodging and retail slash residential. It's not, there's two issues. One is parking, shared parking in particular, and there's a lot of concerns that

53:33 The fire district has, as far as how shared parking is going to work, I think we'll have a great example when the bowling alley gets into full swing and we have an occupancy in that building of over 500 people and a parking lot for 37 cars. So we'll see how that plays out and that'll be something that is a concern of ours, especially if we start migrating that now to other parts of the community and especially the downtown area.

54:02 But the main reason I came or asked John to bring this up for discussion is primarily the downtown district and the building height of 55 feet on the south side, so as you're driving up Main Street on the left-hand side of Main Street, the 55-foot height and the discussion about moving buildings closer to Main Street as part of the concept for the downtown area.

54:31 The concern is that there has never really been a shading study that has been done to indicate what that kind of size structure and the relationship of the sun, especially in the wintertime, what that's going to do to the road surface of Main Street. We have had numerous traffic accidents, Old Mammoth Road and Main Street, Sierra Park Road and Main Street, where

54:59 Just the trees that are in that area provide enough shading and the speed with which people come down Main Street, especially coming downhill, not so much going up Main Street, where people slide into each other. Most of it's been traffic accidents associated with non-injury, but some have been injury-related. And if we now duplicate that all the way up Main Street such that the shading of those taller buildings creates an ice.

55:25 An icy situation on Main Street as the grades increase as you go at Main Street, we believe that there's a concern. We applaud the idea of trying to get our general plan and the zoning code such that we get quote unquote building ready, but one thing we really need to look at is the relationship of the height of those buildings in relationship to how

55:52 The sun exposure is going to deal with the shading of Main Street. Okay. Sandra, let me say it this way. I know there was a little bit of shading work done within the downtown working group documents. Have you had a chance to review that? And the shading document that I saw, the only shading document I saw was done on June 21st. Ah. Okay. Sandra, do you have any comments?

56:23 So the CEQA analysis for the zoning code update is based on the 2007 general plan EIR. So the 2007 general plan EIR analyzed building heights and allows building heights of up to 55 feet. So the CEQA that we're doing now is saying that the zoning code update is consistent with the certified EIR that was certified in 2007 that analyzed that and allows 55 foot building heights.

56:50 So that in the CEQA analysis, if something were to come up, could it mean that the building height might be reduced or the set might be increased or something like that to deal with these shading issues? Are you talking about the future, when future projects come forward? I mean, we would look at design review for these future projects. A lot of, depending on what's proposed.

57:14 If it's a new hotel, new hotels would be permitted, but we would still be doing design review, looking at the way the building sits on the site, looking at different impacts like that. Depending on what's proposed, CEQA analysis may be done or it may be exempt. We'd have to go through that, but we would certainly want to deal with any hazard issues through that, and the fire department is part of our development review committee, so they review all of those new projects as well and provide comments on that as part of that process.

57:40 So to recap what you said, and I don't want to put words in your mouth, that each individual project, as it comes before the town, even though the height limit is a maximum of 55 feet, it would be reviewed, and would it be reviewed in enough detail where you could be able to tell the wintertime shading of that building? If there's an issue with shading, we can request a shade and shadow study, so we can look at that, yes. Okay, there's a heads up, I think.

58:07 What Tom is saying that pretty much anything 55 feet close enough to the roadway would create a shading problem. Right. And I guess the suggestion I have, you're going to go through the FAR analysis. Right. Immediately, it's going to take a period of time, but maybe make that shading analysis at just a generic 55 foot high building scattered along, because we also are saying 55 feet as you get to the upper end of Main Street between basically

58:35 Mono Street and the Whiskey Creek intersection where the road is even steeper. We're suggesting a 55-foot height limit up there. It just seems like if we're going to encourage people to come to town, especially in that location, we want to have some information to have provided them with a generic block building, whatever you want to call it, however the design ends up looking, and what the shading impacts are going to be, and then make a decision on what's acceptable and what's not acceptable.

59:04 Especially at intersections. But we're going to have an opportunity to do that as each project comes forward, is that correct? And also within the, can there be more modeling done within the CEQA review to also deal with this issue? For the FAR? Yes. We can ask the consultant to do that as part of their CEQA? Because I understand what you're saying, Tom, and I want to give you an opportunity to do.

59:35 Get that information in. I mean, we know it's all bad right here on Meridian because the shade right there. I can't imagine, but I also know that there were certain, it's my understanding that the buildings are actually a little bit farther away from the road than they are from the frontage road right now. Right, and that's what I was going to say. If we're moving the buildings closer, but we're getting rid of that road, your shading is actually going to be

1:00:00 Yeah, because they're sidewalks and parking and bike lanes and things, but I understand. Now, so I have another question is that would it impact the timelines if we tabled this to the next meeting so there'd be an opportunity for staff to work with the fire department? Yeah, I think what you're looking at from May is the current zoning code is dealt with under the previous EI officer. There's no secret issues and those types of good things.

1:00:29 I think what I'm hearing from the Far Department through Tom and the Council's comments is to really look at it as we look at that next issue related to the Fourier ratio and the density issues and to analyze under that CEQA process which is probably more appropriate as well as on a project-by-project basis going forward. But I think from a broader scale standpoint, it probably goes better with that next phase. Otherwise, you're kind of mixing apples and oranges, I think, with the zoning code.

1:00:57 As is and as a current EIR versus putting it into that next set of studies where it probably is more appropriately looked at. Is that, will that work? No, that would work. That would certainly work. Okay. Thank you. Thank you. Appreciate it. Do you want to make a motion, John? Yes, I go ahead and move that the council adopts a consent agenda item number four. I'll second. We have a motion and a second. Roll call.

1:01:23 Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 3-0. And we will now move on to our policy matters. And we have a presentation from Susie Baines with Wild Iris. Good evening. Susie Baines with Wild Iris. I'm here this evening to ask the council to...

1:01:52 Provide a proclamation proclaiming April as Sexual Assault Awareness Month and as Child Abuse Prevention Month. I've been up here many times before and they always fall in the same month so I'm just going to do one presentation for both and make it easy for all of us. I wanted to give you some statistics, a little bit of history and let you know some of the events that we're doing around town to bring awareness to these issues.

1:02:19 So according to national statistics, one in three women and one in 33 men will be sexually assaulted in their lifetime. From January 1, 2013 through December 31, 2013, Wild Iris served 84 victims of sexual assault, and we provided services that range from peer counseling, legal and medical advocacy, to providing emergency food, clothing, and shelter. And also nationally, a report of child abuse is made every 10 seconds.

1:02:49 And more than four children die every day as a result of child abuse. And again, in the calendar year 2013, Wild Iris assisted 35 children under the age of 18 for issues connected to child abuse. Of those 35, 14 were victims of sexual assault. And I thought this was interesting. It's something I just learned today that according to UNICEF, in 2010, there was more money spent on preserving native birds in the United States

1:03:19 Then there was money spent on preventing child abuse. To commemorate both months, Wild Iris has planned several events to honor the victims and survivors of sexual assault and child abuse. Once again, we're going to be hosting the Clothesline Project. That is a display that offers a voice to those that are affected by sexual assault, by child abuse, by any type of violence, really.

1:03:47 It's a really great and powerful exhibit. T-shirts are strung out on a clothesline. Those T-shirts are designed by survivors of violence, both children and adults alike, and they're a reminder to the community that sexual assault and child abuse do happen here. The project also helps those survivors in their healing process and gives them a way to tell their story and to let them know that they're not alone.

1:04:13 That project will be on display for the public to view on Saturday, April 26th from 9 to 3 p.m. at Minaret Mall right downstairs and on Wednesday, April 30th for the entire day at Mammoth High School. I also wanted to remind council and the public that April 23rd is Denim Day and I usually stand up here and say wear jeans but it occurred to me that I don't really know if everybody knows why that's important.

1:04:42 A little bit of history. Denim Day was originally triggered by a 1998 ruling in an Italian Supreme Court case where a rape conviction was overturned because the judges felt that the victim was wearing tight jeans and therefore she must have helped her rapist remove those jeans, thereby implying consent. So the following day the women in the Italian Parliament came to work wearing jeans in solidarity with this victim.

1:05:10 And so this is why we ask that our community show solidarity as well and to raise awareness and stand with survivors of sexual assault by wearing denim on April 23rd. And as usual, we'll be contacting different agencies and businesses around town to take pictures and ask that you join us in bringing awareness to this issue. And this month and throughout the year, as a reminder, we do have a youth violence prevention program that visits all of the schools.

1:05:40 Preschool through college to teach about healthy relationships, bullying, healthy boundaries, bystander intervention. So that's something that we do year long to help prevent child abuse and to bring awareness to the kids as well. We encourage all individuals and organizations to play a role in making the town of Mammoth Lakes a better place for children and families by ensuring that our community members have the knowledge, the skills, and the resources

1:06:09 That they need to care for themselves and their children and that we help promote our community's social and emotional well-being and prevent child abuse and sexual assault within our families and within our community. So thank you. Stand there for just a minute. Happy to field any questions. First of all, other questions? Okay. Then could I get a motion to approve the two proclamations? I'll make a motion that we approve both proclamations. Okay.

1:06:39 A roll call vote, please, Jamie. Councilmember Eason? Yes. Councilmember Lehman? Yes. Yes. Motion passes 3-0, and we have both proclamations. I'd like to thank you for the work you do, and I would say to the public that if you have not seen this person-line project, it is moving. It's a wonderful thing. Take the time to walk by the two locations and see it. I appreciate it. Thank you all. Thank you.

1:07:20 All right. Our next item is a TOT appeal hearing. We will begin with a presentation from staff. Joe, if I may, just real quick. During the last presentation, I couldn't help but notice looking around at the members of the audience, and it's a sign of the times, but exactly 50% of the audience had their heads down looking at their iPhones, and so just interesting that...

1:07:50 Something like that wouldn't happen five years ago. In two years, it'll probably be 80% of the audience. Just interesting. Oops. Okay. Good evening, Council. I'm Cindy Myrold, the Finance Manager. Before you is an appeal hearing on TOT taxes, penalties, and interest for the address located at 49 Garmish Place. Our appellant is John Hopp.

1:08:21 How this procedure works is I will be giving my presentation of the case and then Mr. Hopp will be able to provide any new evidence or rebuttal to the evidence that I'm presenting before you and then we'll have a chance to appeal and public comment can happen if necessary. So I'm going to start. Oh, and your role in this is to act in a judicial.

1:08:50 So staff is recommending that you uphold the notice of determination in the amount of $50,593.91.

1:09:16 As well as additional interest that is accrued since the time of the notice of determination of $3,687.73 for a total of $54,281.64. I'm going to walk in your attachments. You have Town Council agenda dated April 18th of 2012. In that agenda, we spelled out the process of our TOT collection and enforcement efforts.

1:09:45 I have a TOT case summary on this particular case in attachment two. Attachment three is the property owner's rental records. Attachment four is the property owner's appeal to the notice of determination. And attachment five is an email sting from February that the appellant has answered as he still has current advertisements for the property and nightly rental rates. I'm going to walk you through.

1:10:17 Part of attachment number one, which is the case summary that is just an overview of what is in this very thick document of information. So we opened this case in September of 2011. We sent our first warning letter in February 15th of 2012. There was no response. We sent a citation on March 6th for $100.

1:10:46 Tracy Meyer, one of the owners of the property, called acknowledging receipt of the citation. Mr. Hopp called and stated he had some transient rentals and would change his ads to modify monthly rentals only. On April 13th, we sent a citation invoice. There was no response. On August 5th of 2012, we sent another sting email, which was answered at nightly rental rates of $1,050 per night and cleaning fee of $250. On August 24th,

1:11:17 We sent a second citation with an invoice for $200 plus the previous citation for $100. The citation for answering the email for a nightly rate, the fine was $100 for the first violation. March 6 was $200 for the second violation. On August 24th, we prepared an assessment for a total of $80,791.

1:11:39 The T.O.T. was for $50,011, penalties $13,893, interest $16,636, and enforcement charges of $250. We did not receive a response from that. We filed an intent to file a judgment on the property on September 24th. There still was no response. On November 13th, we got an email response from Mr. Hopp disputing the amount assessed.

1:12:08 He filed a, he requested a hearing before the tax collector on December 3rd. Notice of the hearing was sent scheduling appeal for January 28th, 2013. The hearing was held on January 28th and the owners were given two weeks to provide documentation. Telephone and email correspondence occurred with Mr. Hopps, left several messages. We finally received documentation on May.

1:12:37 In the end of May 2013. Based on the documentation provided that's all included in your packet, I prepared a notice of determination on July 23rd with taxes totaling $27,316, penalties of $8,194, interest $14,832, and enforcement charges of $250. We did not receive a response. On October 7th, we filed, we

1:13:09 Sent letters for an intent to file a judgment. No response until December 10th. Email received from Mr. Hopp asking for options since he did not reply to the NOD in a timely fashion. What happened after that, Shereen? So I'm missing the communication. There must have been some communication that occurred between then. It's not in here. There was no appeal. So it had gone to a judgment.

1:13:50 We had a telephone correspondence between the town and Mr. Hoffman and Ms. Meyer. We prepared the judgment certificate. Mr. Hoff responded asking that the NOD be adjusted. I spoke with them and responded that he either must pay the full amount or he could appeal to town council. On February 26th, we received the appeal to town council for the notice of determination.

1:14:15 Additional interest charges have been assessed at $3,687.73 and we are currently we have ongoing enforcement for this property from the end of the notice of determination or end of the period that was assessed which was August of 2012.

1:14:36 He had provided documentation in his tax return that also included time beyond that. So our intention is to go back and assess from August 2012 to current based on numerous complaints and activity continuing for the rental of this property. I want to kind of point out that we have received a letter from one of the correspondents from Mr. Hopp is disputing how we calculated the taxes.

1:15:06 Basically saying that the tax amount shown on his tax returns in the documentation provided should include the tax, but there's no documentation. All of his lease agreements do not spell out that he has collected tax of any sort from his renters. So his dispute in writing to us was he felt that we should have calculated the tax due differently where it included the TOT.

1:15:35 With that, and that would reduce his amount owed. But since he does not spell that out in any of his lease agreements, I prepared the notice of determination as the amount charged as rent, because the tax is not broken out separately. For clarification on that, are you saying that the rent collected, the towns calculated it as rent, not rent and tax? Correct.

1:16:04 We calculated it as rent because he did not in any of his documentation, the code requires that the tax be broken out separately from the rent. Rent is what it costs the renter to stay in the unit and tax is on top of that. Okay. All right. And that's required by code? Yes. And really kind of near the back of your packet is the tax returns that

1:16:35 Mr. Hoff provided and we compared his tax returns. We had bank statements and we were able to cross-check his information from the information that he provided and the notice of determination was based on his records. And then the very end of the packet is his

1:16:56 He is showing evidence showing that he is still advertising the property and still has nightly rentals listed and that he had recently answered another sting email that the property is still being rented. Okay. So it looks like in the order we get the statement from the property order and then we ask questions of either staff. Yes. That's correct. So then, Mr. Hopp, do you have anything? I guess we're...

1:17:32 This appeal stems on a multiple set of levels. I think the first and most sort of crucial one is the questioning of the legitimacy of the transient occupancy tax legally. The ordinance states that it should be in a zoning area to which the occupancy tax, where it is valid, when it was sort of the intention of setting it up.

1:17:58 For the lodging owners, they put this tax on one area, I think it was R2, and it was never applied to the other areas. In fact, in the minutes, in various meetings in 1985 and 1991, they actually, residents opposed the tax because they thought it would sort of promote illegal rentals. In essence, I'm saying that the tax that is being levied on me is illegal because I'm not a transient occupancy facility based on the description.

1:18:27 In the ordinance. So you can't collect transient occupancy tax if you don't have a transient occupancy tax facility. And you could play with that regardless of, you know, you may be familiar with the ordinance, but it ends in lodging, sleeping lodging or similar, and then it has to be in conformance with the town's zoning laws, which I'm not. So in essence, if you knew,

1:18:59 The word similar, I think you could read it one of two ways, but either way it's ambiguous. And in an ambiguous sort of situation, I think that the benefit usually goes to the people that didn't draft it, which in this case would be me. So that's my first sort of the biggest, and I only discovered that after, in my opinion, being, you know, I offered up early on, I thought my tax returns were a reasonable assessment.

1:19:30 Of where I was, I've told the truth, I've not done anything sort of shady or under the table, I think, you know, I have a question for the city, I mean, for the tax collectors, really, it's like, how do they know even the websites are legitimate? Because I've got illegitimate websites that steal my ad and put it on, and I use Craigslist, I have a police report that I had to file, people are advertising my property for 500 bucks a night or whatever, so I took the nightlies off and they're off my listings.

1:19:59 Any listings that are not nightly, they're not mine. So I wonder, like, what evidence, I mean, do they research that or not? Because I only have one listing and it doesn't have one. But essentially, I think it's an illegal tax in this particular case. I think the intent of it is not what it is now. Okay, anything else to add at this point? For now, no. Okay. Who wants to start?

1:20:34 I don't know, do we need to go to the public, or do you want to just... Well, no, it's supposed to be questions next and then call for public comment. Okay. Question, I guess first I'd have a staff. With regard, I think I read in here that Mr. Hoff had come back and you determined based on information he provided that the tax due went from roughly $80,000 to $50,000, is that correct? Yes. Based on his information? Based on his information. Okay. And then...

1:21:07 You're saying the property's still being rented? Yes. And we have recently, he recently responded to a sting that, and with a nightly rate of... He said it's like a thousand something, I think. Yeah. Okay. That's all I guess I have of staff. In response to Mr. Hoppe, you're saying the legality of it, that they can't collect a tax. I'd argue, I mean,

1:21:42 I know our town attorney and staff have gone to exhaustion to look at every angle of this, and they've been pretty firm to us that they can collect a tax, and the tax is legitimate. As far as it not being a legitimate, your website, I mean, you do have something on there, your marketing, though, right? Yeah, but not for nightly rentals.

1:22:07 Okay. And are you saying you don't have anything on there at all for nightly rentals? I mean, you're saying people are pirating your site? Yep. Okay. And like I said, I have a, I can, you know, show you a police report before, and I've taken one of them to pass. They don't apparently do much about it because it's not pirating. Okay. But if somebody pirates your site and they rented your property out, you'd rent it to them, right?

1:22:33 I mean, you're... Somebody did what? I'm sorry. If they're pirating your site and they rented your property out, if they're saying it's available on a nightly basis, you'd rent it. No. You wouldn't. But you've been renting it. Yes. Okay. All right. I don't have any other questions. Thank you. John. Mr. Hoff, what do you attribute your, in most cases, your lack of responsiveness to solicitations from the town?

1:23:03 I've got four children. I'm very busy. I've been doing a business in Ecuador where I've been leading town a lot. And there are some personal issues as well mixed into that that are who's collecting the mail type of issues. But in general, I tried to respond. And I did come forth and have a meeting with the town tax collector in person.

1:23:28 And brought my tax returns and really wanted to attend to. And I did pay income tax on any income that I had. So, you know, I was slow, but I was getting slow turtle, but I did get to the race. I mean, I'm taking care of it. What do you attribute to the continuation of renting on a single family neighborhood? It didn't seem to me that the intent.

1:23:55 I didn't understand the intent of the law, and I didn't feel that it was applicable. And I never did charge tax before because I didn't know. Prior it was more the oops factor of not understanding that we weren't to do transient rentals. But even though you didn't charge the tax, you were still renting illegally? Correct, yes. Yeah, I did not know. I don't think it was even disclosed to me on my...

1:24:25 On my real estate board. In fact, we have an appraisal where it is not said at all that that's just disclosed. And what do you attribute the continuation of renting on a nightly basis? I was under this understanding that it's an illegal, like, it's not allowed to have that restriction. Even though many other communities, towns, cities have the same ordinance?

1:24:57 I'm not aware of what other towns and communities have. I'm not all that savvy in sort of the real estate world. Thank you. Question of staff. The sting emails were responded to that there was a nightly rental rate? Yes, if you turn to the very... And what are the dates on those? If you turn to the very back of your packet, we... Where's your date on here? Well, I got it. I can turn to it. I just know which one it is. Which page? Yeah. Can you tell us a...

1:25:26 You have 255 pages. I don't know. I know. It's almost at the very tail end, like one, if you've one, two, three pages up from the back of the packet. Okay. April 4th through 13th, is that the one you're talking about? Yes. Okay, so that's April of this year? Mm-hmm. So you were, okay. Mm-hmm. Okay. Any public comment on this?

1:26:01 I did see one person move. I didn't know if that made you wanted to make a comment or not. Could you please come forward to the podium? Mr. Hopp. Mr. Hopp. Let's gentlemen speak. Sorry, I came in a little late, so I'm not sure where you've gone with this so far. I just want to make a general comment. I'm sorry, could you state your name, please? Oh, I'm sorry, Greg Eckert. On any of the, whether single family, multifamily, any of the TOT rentals at all,

1:26:31 I'd like to make a proposal that there be some sort of a town bid. And what this bid would do, if you pick a number, whether it's two or five, with qualified people, it'd be up to you guys to figure out what qualified people means. But you put out a bid for basically a bounty hunter. And if you do that, the town would get a license fee from this bounty hunter.

1:27:01 And it would be their job to go out and document these cases. They would, on their own dime, actually rent a property, get cash back and forth, document that this rental took place, and then turn it into the town. At that point, the town staff doesn't have to do the work. There's not money coming out of the town coffers to enforce this. And it's a case brought in with a bow tie around it.

1:27:33 That is documented that these people did what they did. And the town hasn't spent any money on it. There's no staff time. And a bounty hunter who's going to get paid by pick a number, whether it's 25, 50 percent of whatever the buying and collected is, that bounty hunter is going to be way more motivated than even the best town staff person. If you had the ideal employee that's working for wages, they're not going to be as motivated.

1:28:02 As a private enterprise person whose entire compensation is to document these cases. So if the bounty hunter comes with this bow tie wrap thing, the town gets the majority of the money that they're entitled to. There's no cost to the town at all. And the town actually gets money for the bounty hunter license. Now you've got a motivated person, way more than a wage earner, and it's all bow tied and ready to go. So anyway, just something to consider. Thank you.

1:28:32 And just for your information, it was previously considered and our staff have collected over $700,000 in assessments and late payments and penalties, etc. Am I right with the dollar amount? Yes. Actually, I have, before we go into deliberation, I have one more clarification from the town manager. Sitting as only three members with a quorum, it would take a 3-0 vote for this.

1:29:00 On whatever motion is made, am I correct? The appropriate would be 3-0. It's not a resolution over an ordinance. I believe two of you could use that. Two? Okay. I just wanted to clarify that. So, deliberation? You know, my only thoughts are, we've seen a few cases come before us on this, and I think the thing that's really important to stress, I think any time you're running a business, you're collecting money,

1:29:32 We rely so heavily on

1:30:02 People staying in our community. And it's very important that when somebody comes to our community, the guest experience has to be good. It has to be professional. Because if it's not, they don't come back. And, you know, our town's been set up in such a fashion that there are areas that the zoning does allow for rentals at the current time. It's places where there's access to trolley systems, there's access to...

1:30:30 Retail, commercial amenities and whatnot. And I think until this gets resolved, we have to be, it's important that we stick with the law. You know, our police, our snow removal, all of these things rely on these taxes that are collected. And for me, you know, what's been presented here today, I just feel that, I think it's pretty clear to me that this is a case of

1:30:58 You know, just an illegal rental, and I understand that ignorance may come up in a lot of situations where you don't know about things, but I think it's a person's obligation to find those things out, and it's not the rest of the tax community's job to pick up the tab for, you know, there's some pretty significant numbers here.

1:31:22 And, you know, for me, I'm going to, personally, I feel like I'm going to side with what staff's presented. Any comments, John? Just that I'm also not sympathetic to the naive argument of the property owner this evening, and that based upon the mounds of evidence presented in our packet this evening, leaves me no other choice than to support the staff's recommendation.

1:31:51 And I agree with all those comments made, so I won't repeat them. I'll just call for a motion. Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I'll move that the Council approve option number one, which is to uphold the tax collector's notice of determination during July 23rd. Excuse me. Yes, I put that correctly. July 23rd, 2013. And direct staff to take all actions necessary to finalize the appeal requiring the property owner to pay.

1:32:19 $50,593.91 TOT penalties, interest and enforcement charges, as well as interest charges on the tax accrued from July 23, 2013 through April 2, 2014 of $3,687.73 for a total collection due of $54,281.64. Mayor Pro Tem, I will second the motion. Thank you.

1:32:49 We have a motion and a second. Roll call, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. The motion passes 3-0. And we move on to an agenda item number 13, presentation of preliminary fiscal year 2014-15, budget information. Thank you, Madam America. I wanted to bring some information is we're preparing for the 2014-15 budget year, really kind of highlighting where we're at.

1:33:21 Some of the direction we provide the staff and what we're looking at on some of the key revenue projections and if there's any comments from Council in terms of we prepare a preliminary budget that we plan to bring for you second meeting in May with hopefully a final budget adoption in the first meeting in June. The basic direction has been to look at our rollover budget. By that basically trying to keep our O&M costs in total at the same level as it was in the current year.

1:33:46 And then also looking at the same staffing structure. We're not adding additional positions over current year of budget. Even doing so, we will still have some bump up and increases from natural contractual increases that we're trying to absorb, or staffing issues where you have a built-in process for merit increases. We will have some increases from such things as our retirement system purge or the medical.

1:34:10 Increases that for half the year that come into play. So there are some impacts we'll have financially on it. But as we begin, the budget is heavily driven really by our revenue and the primary debate comes into the general fund and where we're at there. So the primary push is on this. The current year you're aware of, we've definitely seen a decline in our revenues due to the low snow year. We've come in, ended last year strong. So that was real positive for us, about 2.6 million.

1:34:38 Reserve for economic uncertainty. You previously authorized using up to about 385,000 of that, which would take us down to about a 2.2 or so economic reserve, which is still better than we were a year before. The goal is still to try to maintain that maximum use of reserves as currently allocated. The brief current analysis of the current year, we could be as much as a half a million in a shortfall.

1:35:04 We do have some one-time adjustments we're working through. If that happens, it would still bring us back down to that 385 give or take number. So we're not ready to recommend any adjustments to that yet. We'll be working through that and obviously trying to figure out what the March number would be, et cetera. When you look at that, December, January, February, and March, that is basically 56% of the TOT collected in those four months.

1:35:31 TOT is 60% of the general funds. So you start to look at the numbers there are substantial in terms of what happens to these winter months. I'm sure painfully aware or gainfully aware depending on the year. So in looking at that, one of our issues was trying to look at what do we utilize going into next year's budget for TOT. If we just take the current year, we'd actually be below our current year budget. If you take a multi-year average,

1:35:59 You're substantially below the current year budget. So try to take a blended approach, basically looking at the last four years and the last couple of summers. You've seen record growth in the summers, and so we're making some assumptions that we will continue to see an equalization in the summer. It may not grow much, but it wouldn't decline. And then try to take a look at more of an, hard to call it average, but try to average out some of the winter months in a more of a blended rate.

1:36:27 Doing that, we end up with a rough estimate of about $11.6 million in the TOT projection for the following year. I think that feels relatively conservative. One of the unknowns will be the impact of the TBID and additional marketing and other activities going on. That could move that number again. And then, of course, the other question, what will the snow be next year or so?

1:36:51 Unknown there. So we've taken a fairly conservative approach to it. There may be a little bit more room in there as we come to the budget. That'll be a question as we move forward. The question this evening is, I guess, overall in some of the revenues, is the council comfortable with looking at those numbers as a preliminary basis for putting a budget together? Property tax, we believe we will see a decline. We're seeing that countywide. We'll see it here in Mammoth.

1:37:14 A couple other pieces of the property taxes, there's a number of factors to that, at least a decline in a couple other areas. Sales tax, same impact really from the TOT side, just depends on that tourism visit impact. We're looking at that pretty much being flat going into next year. Part of that deals with, we should see a little bump in the part of the sales tax we keep, and there's a piece of it, 0.25 of it.

1:37:43 Goes back to the current year. So it's a bifurcated fee on sales tax. I'm going to work and tell if you want on that. But bottom line is we think it should be a flat number going forward. The other one we'll see a hit I think is in franchise fees. It's a rather larger chunk. And that's partly to do with some one-time money we received in the Marigas sale or purchase of a heritage and some issues in that. So we're looking at some factors there.

1:38:08 And again, this year that's down, you've got a warmer year, people aren't using as much utility, so we have an impact from that. And you look at those, just those four revenues in there, that really is about almost, you know, what is it, 85 or better percent of our revenue streams in general fund in those couple of categories, dominated obviously by TOT.

1:38:32 We will see some modifications in our other revenues. We have some grants this year that we'll be doing up next year, so we're looking through that. Overall, actual total revenues are projected to drop slightly because of that grant activity in the general fund. So that would really put us on a pretty flat budget, which I think will be extremely tight. We'll be doing some work to make that balance as we go forward. That would drive the general fund.

1:39:00 I've also provided a quick list without a lot of the dollars in it to kind of our capital program. It's been relatively robust the last few years. That's in large part due to some happens in staff being very aggressive in grants, being very creative in how we use our local transportation funds, and some work in all the areas in the airport funds that come in each year. One area in there I know, one of the projects has a $50,000 general fund match that we'll be looking at.

1:39:30 Currently not funded. It's been identified as a match, but we'll need to figure out the funding for that to match up to that grant. As we look at the current year where we're at from the goals that the council set walking into this year, I would say all but two of those goals have been addressed at some level. The two that have not, which were tied to financial issues, was trying to put more funding back into the street maintenance budget and looking at additional police officers within the budget.

1:39:59 Obviously, we haven't seen an increase in revenue this year, so we have not achieved those two goals. I have asked staff to take a look at a partial year of a police officer to see what that number would look like for next year, whether or not that would actually be recommended would be still a way to be seen. Looking at nine months, we may back that off to a half year to see what that looks like. And the same thing, if there's any additional funding that we could put back to the road maintenance budget, we'd be looking for that as well before our priorities must be reset by the council.

1:40:28 With that, I'm really looking for any other comments or if there's a comfort level in terms of these rough revenue, preliminary revenue projections, will we be finding them as we go forward? There may be some changes to them, but again, that makes up the majority of the revenue for the general fund, which provide the basis then for us as we go forward with completion of the expenditure side of the budget. With that, I can answer any questions or any comments. Yes, Dan, on the revenue projections,

1:40:58 Through what month are we secure in knowing what we've generated in TOT? Through February. Through February. Yeah, because that's due, the February is due the 20th of the following months, so as of March 20th, everything for February was due, so we have a pretty good number for February at this point. There'll be some stuff that gets paid late, often a little bit. But when will we know what our March and April numbers are? Again, they're a month after, 20 days after the...

1:41:26 Due date for payment. So our March won't be known until April 20th, a couple days after when everything gets in and gets in. But you can mail it on the 20th until we get it two days later. So April, we're going to start budget discussions when? May? Yeah. So we will have our April numbers and we may have some of the May, a good chunk of the May numbers for that budget hearing on the 21st of May as well. And of course the reason that I mentioned that is

1:41:55 March and April are our last two large revenue generation notes for TNT in this year's budget. Okay. But you're comfortable we'll have a good sense as to what those numbers are? Yes. And not only impact what we're ending this year at, but I'm not really using this four year as a total base for projecting in the next year. I think you've got a balancing map looking more at the blending the last two years.

1:42:20 Well, since this is the least amount of snow we've had since 37 years or whatever it's been. Long time. We're hoping next year has nothing, looks nothing like this year. Much whiter. Do we have a percent difference of budget, the budget numbers you're talking about versus last year? I don't, I don't, off the top of my head, if last year, if you look at the highest year a year ago, when we ended with 11.7 million in T.O.T.,

1:42:51 We'd be looking at 11-6 in the budget going forward. Current year projecting in that about a million, one million, two million, so it would be a 10-4 or so. And you're suggesting keeping that or you're suggesting the 11-6 moving on? I'm suggesting 11-6. Yeah. So that's below the peak year and less than 200,000 above the current year budget. Okay. Thank you.

1:43:19 All right. Are there any questions from the public? So we will hear more on May 21st. Correct. Yeah, I don't need any formal action tonight unless there's something in here. Again, staff's been working hard on it. It's my first year looking at it, so I want the council to feel comfortable in terms of the key numbers we're bringing in on the revenue side. So there's no other comments. That's great. Okay. Then we'll move on to number 14, solid waste update.

1:43:59 Mayor Pro Tem and Council will kick this off and Peter will be joining me on the discussion. He's handing out a color copy of the map that's in your packet. There's a couple extra copies for part of the discussion. As the Council is aware, the last several months we've been looking at solid waste issues related to changes in state law and requirements placed on the town. And then also going forward in terms of the last couple of discussions was to try to take a look at long-term solutions for waste management issues within

1:44:29 The town and also looking at it not just in the town of Mammoth Lakes but really regionally as we have a number of different partners related to trash handling and the waste management overall that we've been working with. We've had meetings with the Forest Service, with Mono County, Inyo County, the Water District and then obviously Mammoth Disposal working through this. Mammoth Disposal has

1:44:56 Submitted a request to extend or exercise their option to extend the franchise for five years. That's been received and accepted by the city here in the town. So we will continue to work with managed disposal in terms of the options that we're looking at. The water district definitely has an interest in it because of sludge disposal as well as some of the potential locations for a future transfer site potentially adjacent to their properties.

1:45:22 Motto County, obviously, is a partner in this as it relates to the Benton Crossing landfill, which will close 2023, if not earlier. Also, looking at their long-term needs for the same issue of collecting waste and transferring it ultimately to a disposal site. Currently, the disposal sites, from a long-term perspective, most likely Inyo County, if not Lockwood, Nevada Waste Management Facility there.

1:45:49 A number of different partners are trying to take a long-term regional approach to this. We know that the town generates about 70 to 80 percent or so of the waste going into the Denton landfill. And so definitely we have a major interest in dealing with the long-term issue of the facility. And the long-term nature of that facility needs to be handling.

1:46:12 You know, that transfer of waste needs to handle our recycling efforts that over time are going to be enhanced. We need to be able to handle storage, trucks, the whole operation, the waste management side. And so we've been looking at options for that from a land standpoint. At the current location, the potential to expand that from two to three acres is an option that's still on the table. We've also begun to look at other options and discussions with the Forest Service, the viable options, narrowing it down to...

1:46:40 Four other options in addition to the current site. One of those kind of being off the map you were handed, item five, which is out near the proposed geothermal plant expansion. Probably less of an interest from a town perspective when it's outside the town boundaries for dealing with it. But secondly, as we still will rely on residential drop-off and buy-back, one of the concerns was either the location being too far to town becomes a disincentive. I'm sorry, several of us are...

1:47:10 Or lazy, I guess, in driving an extra few miles to take care of our trash. Secondly, it would be just in terms of the back and forth, just in terms of the overall waste management activity going on in the community for those areas. So I'll walk through the map in a moment on that. The other issues that we're looking to that would be

1:47:34 Looking at something that we can plan out within 20 to 30 years to the future, and that's the other issue for the sides. I think technology and waste management is changing in solid waste issues and those types of areas. There's been discussion in the community, say, for example, regarding a biomass facility. Do we have a place where we can help collect the material and process it to some degree for those types of things? So a number of different elements out there that are unknown today, but we want to have a site that can accommodate.

1:48:03 Yes, I know it's currently. With that, I don't know, Pete, if you want to walk through a couple of these sites and then also we'll talk about some of the next steps that we need to do regardless if we deal with other elements under the state requirements. Looking at your map, site one is what we call a snow pit area. And essentially we have an existing access road that would require some upgrades, but at least it's constructed and

1:48:32 It's easy access for all the community to do self-hauling as well as the commercial delivery of waste. This would require a small transition addition that would serve both the U.S. Forest Service boneyard area. They would likely want that fenced if there was a facility near there. And then there's a couple of options for the actual shape of that site. One of the benefits is close to town, short, easy access.

1:49:01 It's a flat site, most of which has been previous disturbed. Site two was one that was identified by the Forest Service. They thought it would be visually you wouldn't see it from the highway. It does look like it's kind of problematic to get access to it without going through the water district's property and would probably be the most expensive for an access point of view to

1:49:28 Coordinate a turn lane and crossing 203 divided road there. Site 3 is on the west side of the water district. It also is a relatively flat site where it's located. It has a short access road to Meridian. It would be directly across from the Commerce Drive location. It would require a slight relocation of the bike path.

1:49:55 Like path in this area actually is rather steep so a relocation would be helpful long term to flatten that grade and make it easier for kids to navigate. Site 4 is the current site and the shape includes the additional acre that's been discussed over the several years. And then again site 5 is really, we get significant complaints today regarding the location of the

1:50:26 The drop-off center and the buyback center that's too far out of town. It really, it's in town. It's pretty convenient for people that are using it. But that would just exaggerate that, those comments that we've received from the public today. So is there any questions or further comments regarding any of those sites? Thank you for doing the work and we'll be anxious to see what's reality and what's fantasy. Add two elements to that, one being,

1:50:59 We also want to have a discussion with Inyo County. One of the options there was actually looking at a, you know, a clean material sorting facility, actually at the Inyo landfill, long term, to help not just us, but potentially for a broader regional issue and make the offsetting some future costs. Plus, it's cheaper to build there than here because of snow loading and those factors. But offset that against some haul cost issues. So that's what the analysis pieces will be doing. We've...

1:51:28 Next up for the sites would be actually to make a formal request to the Forest Service to do an additional review and analysis on their sites that we need to walk through for that process on a formalized level. We'd be looking at those either under a youth permit or a Townside Act acquisition, so a couple different options for acquiring property that we'd need to look at. And then lastly, we wanted to just kind of a reminder issue back. Council's seen some of this before.

1:51:55 In terms of some of the updates that we do with recycling and cow recycle, they've been out doing some additional work. We expect something probably toward the end of the fiscal year, June, July, reporting that. We will be still working through bringing an item forward related to implementing the green building codes that deals with our construction and demolition debris, mostly. One of our challenges with that, of course, is we get the material, we get it separated out, we clean it up. The question is, what do we do with it?

1:52:21 Having a disposal process, recycling process lined up for that. We're also looking at the state law, again, implementing enhanced recycling with the commercial areas in kind of Indian project. That is a requirement of state law for the enforcement agency under state law, so we end up doing that. When Peter reported a couple of meetings ago, we have a grant working with the conservation fund.

1:52:45 Yes, sir, conservation. To actually put more recycling containers out, we can get the positive element. And then the other piece they asked us to look at was some enhanced recycling elements at the very special events that are in town. So looking at how to enhance some of those components there as well.

1:53:06 Then the last thing I would add is we've actually had some good discussions with Mono County regarding some options and actually getting into some dialogue regarding some potential cooperative areas in looking at longer-term funding elements for whichever option gets pursued, either working with the parcel fee or the current tipping rates, et cetera. So those options are currently under discussion now between the county and we'll be bringing that back as part of a broader package.

1:53:34 Proponent for consideration and hopefully that it is. Glad to answer. Any other questions the council may have? No. Okay. I have one, Dan, and that's so, so there's essentially six potential sites because the Inyo County is still an option that will be evaluated further. Correct. Inyo County would mean just for really the MERT location, the separation facility, we would still need a transfer station here close to town for people to come in.

1:54:02 Drop-off waste in that element. So it would be a bifurcated location at that point. Okay. And then we still have the funding issues to discuss with the county. Correct. So what is your best guesstimate at the next time we would have an update, not on the paces that we know we have to change the ordinances because the law changed, but what's your estimate on the next time you'd be back to us with an update?

1:54:29 The earnings would be probably in June and depending on some of the negotiations that may get pushed into July. Okay. So. All right. Before we go this far, I'd like to ask if there's any questions or comments from the public. All right. Good evening, Council, staff, Mayor Pro Tempekin. This is Martin Kleinbart, resident and a contractor. I'd like to renew my concerns over a couple items. And it's not about...

1:55:05 The Murph or location per se of it, it's about where our biggest bang for the buck is. My personal observation, and I've spoken to Mr. Eastman about it in the past, is condominium complex. They generally just have the one dumpster and everything goes into it. It doesn't matter, there's no separation.

1:55:35 Personally don't understand why those locations are still taking such a long time to get implementation. Then there is, there was mentioned, Town Manager Holler about the Green Code. One of the items in the Green Code is they're calling for, when that goes into force, a substantial amount of reuse of materials. And

1:56:02 If everything goes into MRF and then goes out of town, there's no reuse here. And I think that's a waste to truck it out of town. I think we need to find a way of certain materials that can be reused. You know, if we were to go take a visit down to the dump, you would see all kinds of construction debris that ranges from wood and drywall and insulation and things of that. I mean, wood should not be going to the...

1:56:31 I know there's something I was forgetting because there was three items I was thinking of. Oh,

1:57:01 As far as the MRF goes, I mean, it's currently touted as for construction and demolition, but what do we do about all that other stuff that's generated by our tourists and, you know, the bottles of cans, tin cans, all those things that should be separated, yet the condo complexes, I mean, that's very substantial. I don't know what the weight, the tonnage of stuff going to the dump compared to

1:57:31 I know that the personal waste has got to be much more consistent than the construction. But then again, I don't have those numbers. And my concerns for the MRF was it would be generally used for construction and demolition and not really for separation. And I understand people have said that the separation issue of regular trash

1:58:01 It could be problematic, but we've only heard one side of that, and I'd like to hear some more. Martin, real quick, I would submit that other communities have already moved, and most of them over a long period of time previously have moved in the direction that you're talking about as far as the separation, and I think it's just a matter of the town having an ordinance forcing the condominium projects.

1:58:30 Individual people in restaurants and commercial and so forth to do that separation that you're talking about. Yeah, and that's what we discussed about, so maybe agendize getting that ordinance going. Well, and Ashley Martin, I think that that is already here that they're going to be back to us in June or July on those items. I am supportive of that. Thank you. If I may, a couple issues on that, one with the condo stuff, part of that is out there with the Sierra, with the conservation.

1:59:00 Do that source separation. Right now everything is source separated so you have canned bottles and papers. Most agencies have gone to clean recyclables co-mingled and then you use the MRF to separate those between the various products. The same facility that sorts that would sort C and D as well because you're looking at a clean process. You're not looking at sorting your traditional trash.

1:59:25 It's a co-mingled separation versus a right now we have to separate our can, our glass, our plastics, our paper separately. So there are some options to do exactly what I mentioned there. Working with the condo complex is really is that separation component versus just putting another dumpster that could do co-mingled recycled. Right now we have no way of breaking that out unless you have a lot of hand sorting going on the ground or something. The irony is that most of our, where's Martin?

1:59:55 Most of our visitors are from large cities, and they're already doing it. And I think when they come here, yes, they're on vacation, but I think they've been conditioned for such a period of time that they want to do the recycling, the separation that we're talking about. Right now, we just don't offer that to them. We're not able to facilitate them, so that would be the goal to get them there. The larger site element was to look at distillation like a good process.

2:00:24 And you can't end up holding other material out or reading some of those type of elements, which would be a nice element to add to our recycling capabilities. And I'm also presuming that some of Martin's questions about capacity are part of the analysis that you'll be working on, because that will make the difference in the size of the site. So we will have that kind of information later. Yes. Okay. Joe. Joe Perino.

2:00:53 My question is, has there been any kind of research at all what other countries and other states are doing? Again, I'm all for the whole separation thing. And after the trash is separated, has there been any kind of, again, any kind of research, any kind of view around the world? Because, you know, you've got other places with a lot more bigger continents and definitely having these issues.

2:01:20 Have they came up with, the technology these days, have they came up with a burning process where you can actually burn the trash and use it as alternative energy? Yes, we've looked at, there's a number of different technologies out there that can transform trash into other energy sources. Some of those are currently in process to be looked at in California. Some of the transformation processes here are not allowed. Just a direct burn for like energy, electricity generation.

2:01:54 They're not permitting any new plants of that nature. There are other technologies out there that are being utilized. I've looked at different aspects in Canada primarily. I haven't looked at other countries outside of that. But a lot of that is that recycling and reuse of material for plastics into additional plastics or other uses. There are processes that convert trash into material that can be utilized for non-structural building materials, for example.

2:02:22 Again, you need a market for that. You need adequate trash for that. You need the ability to actually permit those types of elements. And some of that in California is still difficult. So does California, it's an issue of an environmental thing? It's not so much an environmental side in terms of it's more of a policy issue of the new technology. It just isn't there yet for them to say that's a good use for recyclable material or use of trash. Because then again, I mean, could it as a possible way you can...

2:02:51 Use that trash and almost make modules out of it of some kind for housing. Since everybody's kind of now gone to the hay barrel houses, the hay bales. You know, I've seen a lot of stuff in magazines, technology magazines where people are building houses out of trash, out of waste. And they're actually pretty, well, economical and they're actually pretty efficient. So just another option. Thank you.

2:03:20 Dan, I've had the advantage of hearing one of the presentations about the biomass project. I wonder, is there a way to do a quick overview at an upcoming council meeting so that our community can also hear a little bit about where that is going? Maybe we could ask someone from the task force? I'm not suggesting the 45-minute version that we got at the...

2:03:51 Town County Liaison meeting. But just an overview so that people know what's being considered. Okay. Any other public comments? Hello, Councilmembers. Rick Voll again, Mammoth Disposal. First, I want to invite anybody in the audience or here, if you have not been to the transfer station that currently exists, please come and visit. Great opportunity to see where we're at today and what we're talking about in the future because I think...

2:04:22 The strong point that's being made is that we need to have the right location and then also the right equipment. The equipment is key and some of the equipment that we've been specking out and we've been looking at across the country can process six to ten tons of debris per hour, which is both single stream recyclables, the plastic, paper, cardboard, tin, aluminum, as well as C&D, which can be metal, wood, drywall, all the other great stuff.

2:04:51 Martin had mentioned, you know, we need to start assessing. So I think we have a huge opportunity. I'm glad we're talking about it. The staff's doing a great job coordinating and just talking about it. And then as we get into outreach, I think it's going to be important to talk about the sustainability that we are planning for 20 years, not five years, 20 or 30. And I think a lot of research has been done, so I think we'll come up with a great solution for the town of Mammoth Lakes. Thank you. Yeah.

2:05:19 Like I said, come over and visit any time. Thanks. Any other? Hi, Tim Flynn, resident. So where the transfer station is now is one of the considerations as well. Okay, that's all I... Okay, so that's still in a MRF facility is still planned for there, so to speak? Correct. Okay. Okay. Okay.

2:06:01 One thing I would bring up is that this is kind of a preliminary analysis. Once we move into and get direction, instead of funding source, essentially they want to start a CEQA process and that would probably look at multiple locations and select a site based on the analysis system as part of CEQA. So this is really initial and then we'll refine it so we're not studying 50 sites but maybe two sites. But we might have like a

2:06:30 Top three or something like that that would go through CEQA. Okay. All right. Any other comments from staff? I think we've got some good options. Essentially, I'm looking at the options here. Essentially, you're looking for us, do you say, to continue to work? Bottom line, yeah, we're continuing down the process. If council's comfortable with the direction we're moving in, just to confirm that direction that we're going in.

2:07:02 Okay. Then based on that, do you need a motion or do you just? Or consensus. Just consensus to keep moving forward? Yes. And I know for the two of you, the sooner the better. I know every time somebody says July, I see these two a little bit quick. Okay. Thank you for that.

2:07:31 Update. We will now move on to appointment of three applicants to the Building Advisory Committee Board of Appeals. We did interview five applicants earlier today for the benefit of the community that was not here, and at this point we will, we have three positions to fill. So, John, I'll start with you. Thank you. Thank you, because

2:08:02 Council's in a situation tonight on this appointing members to the appeals board that we're not generally in, and we're not generally in it because a lot of times we have to solicit people to apply for positions like these. They're not glamorous at all, and when they do work, it's difficult work. What's interesting, it's a seven-member, I believe a seven-member board, and three of those positions are up.

2:08:32 And generally the best we can hope for is to get the three people that are on the board to reapply so that we have enough people on the board. Tonight and the applications for this is very different because we have the three applicants that applied, but we have two additional applicants. And I would argue that the two additional new applicants are both completely and totally qualified to be on this board.

2:09:02 So it's kind of be careful what you wish for. So we had five people apply for three positions, and all five of them are totally qualified and would be excellent members of the board. When we did the interviews, I rated, we had four questions, and I rated the response to each of the four questions between one and ten.

2:09:32 All of the people that I rated were very close in the rating. One of them, and since you're here, Bruce, I'll mention it. On my rating, Bruce got a perfect score. He's an ideal person to have on this board. He's an architect. He's the second of two architects.

2:09:56 But what my thinking is, is we have a very

2:10:32 Very good working Board of Appeals currently. And staff feels that the board is working excellent together. The members of the board feel that they're working well together. And it's kind of one of those situations, if it's not broken, then I make an effort to fix it. You can make arguments that we need, and they're good arguments that we need.

2:11:01 To interject, you know, some new people on this board, and that's a valid argument. But what swayed me is, in the interviews, the other two current board members also rated the highest along with Bruce. Not a perfect score, but rated high. So my top three, my long-winded, and I apologize, my top three candidates would be Al Pasciuti, Willis Woodward, and Richard Quidd.

2:11:34 Okay. Well, it's kind of hard to argue what John's saying. There are five great candidates. I would agree that the three existing candidates, the ones that are already on the board, all presented very, very well and all brought something great to the table.

2:12:00 One thing I do think a little bit differently than John, and that is that I look at the next wave of people coming forward, you know, are going to be some of the folks that may be sitting on this board for the next, you know, 8, 10, 20 years, whatever that number may be, and probably a lot like our board, we switch everything out at once, it's kind of a shock to the system, so I'll just cut right to the chase. I really appreciate

2:12:29 Bruce Woodward, I agree with you 100%. In fact, he's an architect, and he not only didn't answer the questions, but he had a lot of other information to offer. Al Pershutti, I think, same thing. He just had a lot of experience, a lot of advice. It was good. I also like, though, you know, I'm going to go a little different than John here and say that I like what Tim Flynn had to say.

2:12:57 Rotation of leadership. I also appreciate the fact that we have somebody new coming in and wanting to be there passionately to not only act on the civic duty that, you know, desire that he has, but you know, also kind of prep the board for the next wave. So those are my three. So Tim Flynn, Al Pershutti, and Bruce Woodward.

2:13:25 You know, John is right. It's great to have more candidates than you have positions, but that also makes it difficult because you have to make a choice. I think that all the candidates are quite capable of the job. I agree with both of you on Bruce Woodward and Al Prasciutti, and I think that my third vote goes to Richard Goode because we also then get the...

2:13:47 perspective that he has of being one of the fire department commissioners as being very important. So my three votes would be for Bruce, Al, and Richard. So does that, that gives us, so, so Bruce gets three votes, Al gets three votes, and Richard gets two, and Tim gets one. And I would recommend, I would ask those who tried and weren't successful this time to consider it again in how many years?

2:14:19 Two years when the other positions on the board come up. It's so important that our community stay involved and be involved. It's the only way we operate in a small community like this. So those of you that weren't successful this time, I would suggest that you try again in the two years. Joe, if I may, and I stated it earlier, and I hope that the people got the message, but the two people that were not selected on the board this evening,

2:14:49 Both of them, again, very, very well qualified. They're two individuals who do a great job on this board, and they're also two individuals who stated in the interview that they wanted to be involved in the community. And they didn't state it just in the interview, but they're two people who are present tonight and are present often in meetings, and also two members that are...

2:15:14 The leaders of the Contractors Association were leaders in that organization. So they're very active. They're very qualified. It's just that the competition was tremendous on this. Thank you. Okay.

2:15:30 That being said, we will adjourn to the next regular meeting. I think we need a motion. Oh, I'm sorry. That would be helpful to actually have a vote. Okay. Okay, John, make a motion. Sorry. Madam Mayor Pro Tem, I would move that the council appoint to the Building Advisory Committee, Board of Appeals, three candidates, Richard Goode, Alan Prosciutti, and Bruce Woodward.

2:15:56 Okay. A second. All right. We have a motion, a second. Roll call vote, please, Jamie. Yes. Yes. Yes. Yes. Motion passes 3-0. And now we will adjourn to April 16th. Here we go. Got my gentleman.